View
221
Download
0
Category
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
Hidrológia 1 BME jegyzet.
Citation preview
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ KLGUROyJLD WiUJ\D IHORV]WiVD IHODGDWD
$ KLGUROyJLD iOWDOiQRV pUWHOHPEHQ D Yt]]HO IRJODONR]y WXGRPiQ\RN
|VV]HVVpJH
6]&NHEE pUWHOHPEHQ D KLGUROyJLD D] D WXGRPiQ\ DPHO\ D YL]HN I|OGL
HOIRUGXOiViYDO pV HORV]OiViYDO IHOWiUiViYDO pV Q\LOYiQWDUWiViYDO
YDODPLQW D Yt] WHUPpV]HWEHQ W|UWpQ N|UIRUJiViQDN YL]VJiODWiYDO
IRJODONR]LN
$ KLGUROyJLD IHORV]WiVD DV]HULQW W|UWpQLN KRJ\ D )|OG PHO\ UpV]
WHUOHWHLQHN Yt]YLV]RQ\DLW NXWDWMD
$ KLGURPHWHRUROyJLD D OpJN|UEHQ OpY Yt]W|PHJHN iOODSRWiW pV
IRUJDOPiW D V]iUD]I|OGL KLGUROyJLD D NRQWLQHQVHN pV NLVHEE V]iUD]I|OGL
WHUOHWHN Yt]YLV]RQ\DLW PtJ D] RFHDQROyJLD D WHQJHUHNHW pV D]
yFHiQRNDW YL]VJiOMD
$ KLGUROyJLD KiURP I UpV]WHUOHWH WHKiW D KLGURPHWHRUROyJLD D
V]iUD]I|OGL KLGUROyJLD pV D] RFHDQROyJLD
$ KLGUROyJLDL V]ROJiODW IHODGDWD KRJ\ D Yt]JD]GiONRGiV WHUYH]pVL pV
]HPLUiQ\tWiVL SUREOpPiLQDN PHJROGiViKR] KLGUROyJLDL LQIRUPiFLyNDW
V]ROJiOWDVVRQ (EEHQ D WHYpNHQ\VpJL N|UEHQ D KLGUROyJLDL V]ROJiODWRN
IHODGDWDL D] DOiEELDN V]HULQW FVRSRUWRVtWKDWyN
$ KLGUROyJLDL pV]OHOKiOy]DWRN OpWHVtWpVH pV IHQQWDUWiVD
$] DODSDGDWRN J\&MWpVH IHOGROJR]iVD pV N|]UHDGiVD
$ Yt]NpV]OHWHN V]iPEDYpWHOH pV NH]HOpVH
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
+LGUROyJLDL HOUHMHO]pVHN NpV]tWpVH pV WHUMHV]WpVH
(OHP] pV WHUYH]pVL WDQXOPiQ\RN NpV]tWpVH
+LGUROyJLDL NXWDWiV pV IHMOHV]WpV
$ Yt] WHUPpV]HWHV N|UIRUJiVD pV D N|UIRO\DPDW HOHPHL
$ Yt] HJ\ UpV]H D WHUPpV]HWEHQ iOODQGy N|UIRUJiVEDQ YDQ .|UIRUJiVD
IRO\DPiQ iOWDOiEDQ OpJQHP& KDOPD]iOODSRWEDQ SiUD IRUPiMiEDQ
PHJWDOiOKDWy D OpJWpUEHQ IRO\pNRQ\ pV V]LOiUG KDOPD]iOODSRWEDQ SHGLJ
D I|OG IHOV]tQpQ YDJ\ D IHOV]tQ DODWW
$ IHOKNEO D OpJQHP& KDOPD]iOODSRW~ SiUD FVDSDGpN IRUPiMiEDQ D
)|OG IHOV]tQpUH pV D IHOV]tQL YL]HNEH KXOO $ I|OGUH KXOORWW FVDSDGpN D
WDODMED V]LYiURJ HOSiURORJ YDJ\ OHIRO\LN $ OHIRO\y Yt] HUHFVNpNEO
SDWDNNi PDMG IRO\yYi YpJO IRO\DPPi LV HJ\HVOKHW $ WDODMED
V]LYiUJRWW Yt] KRVV]DEE U|YLGHEE YiQGRUOiV XWiQ YDJ\ D IHOV]tQUH NHUO
LVPpW YDJ\ D PpO\ UpWHJHN YL]HLW J\DUDStWMD $ OHIRO\y Yt] pV D] ~MUD
IHOV]tQUH NHUO Yt] IRO\DPDWRVDQ SiURORJ tJ\ Q|YHOL D OHYHJ
SiUDWDUWDOPiW DKRO LVPpW IHOKN NHOHWNH]QHN DPLNEO D FVDSDGpN ~MEyO
D WDODMUD KXOO (NNRU D Yt] N|UIRUJiVD ~MUD NH]GGLN iEUD
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
iEUD
$ Yt] WHUPpV]HWHV N|UIRUJiVD
$ SiUROJiV pV D OHYHJ QHGYHVVpJWDUWDOPD
$ OHYHJEHQ PLQGLJ WDOiOKDWy OpJQHP& KDOPD]iOODSRW~ Yt] YDJ\LV SiUD
$ Yt] SiUROJiVVDO MXW D OHYHJEH 3iURORJ D V]DEDG Yt]IHOOHW pV D WDODM
QHGYHVVpJH LV $ Q|YpQ\HN pOHWP&N|GpVN VRUiQ XJ\DQFVDN
QHGYHVVpJHW SiURORJWDWQDN $ SiUROJiV PpUWpNpW V]iPRV WpQ\H]
EHIRO\iVROMD H]HN N|]O D OHJIRQWRVDEE D KPpUVpNOHW D OHYHJ
SLOODQDWQ\L SiUDWDUWDOPD pV D OHYHJ iUDPOiVD $ SiUROJiV PpUWpNH
PDJDVDEE KPpUVpNOHW pV DODFVRQ\DEE SiUDWDUWDORP HVHWpQ QDJ\REE
/pJPR]JiV VRUiQ D SiUROJy Yt]IHOOHW IHOHWWL OpJW|PHJHN IRO\DPDWRVDQ
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
FVHUpOGQHN DPL D SiUROJiV Q|YHOpVpKH] YH]HW $ SiUROJiV N|]YHWOHQ
PpUpVH PpJ QHP PHJROGRWW GH W|EE HOIRJDGKDWy HUHGPpQ\W DGy
N|]YHWHWW PyGV]HUW DONDOPD]QDN D KLGURPHWHRUROyJLDL PpUiOORPiVRNRQ
6]DEDG Yt]IHOOHWHN SiUROJiVDLUD DG MHOOHP] pUWpNHW D SiUROJiV
PpU NiG $ SiUROJiVPpU NiGQDN VRNIpOH WtSXVD KDV]QiODWRV YDQQDN
N|]|WWN V]|JOHWHV pV N|U DODSUDM]~DN HJ\HVHN WHOMHVHQ D WDODM IHOHWW
KHO\H]NHGQHN HO PiVRN WHOMHVHQ EHOH YDQQDN VOO\HV]WYH ~J\ KRJ\ D
NiGEDQ OpY Yt] HJ\ V]LQWEHQ YDQ D WDODM IHOV]tQpYHO $ 0HWHRUROyJLDL
9LOiJV]HUYH]HW :02 V]DEYiQ\RVtWiVUD MDYDVROWD D] $PHULNDL (J\HVOW
OODPRNEDQ KDV]QiOW $ WtSXV~ PpUNiGDW DPHO\QHN IHOOHWH P
PpO\VpJH FP pV D WDODM IHOV]tQpQ YDQ HOKHO\H]YH pV D YROW
6]RYMHWXQLyEDQ ).EDQ KDV]QiODWRV **, WtSXV~ P
IHOOHW& FP PpO\ WDODMED VOO\HV]WHWW NiGDW LV $ QDSL SiUROJiV
pUWpNpW D] HJ\PiV XWiQL QDSRNRQ OHROYDVRWW NiGYt]V]LQWHN
NO|QEVpJHNpQW D] LGN|]EHQ HVHWOHJ KXOORWW FVDSDGpN ILJ\HOHPEH
YpWHOpYHO V]iPtWMiN pV PPEHQ DGMiN PHJ
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
iEUD
$ WDODM SiUROJiViQDN PpUpVH OL]LPpWHUUHO
$ WDODM SiUROJiViQDN PpUpVpUH OL]LPpWHUW KDV]QiOQDN iEUD
$ OL]LPpWHU RO\DQ WDUWiO\ DPLEHQ D Yt]V]LQW I|Op D] HUHGHWL
WDODMV]HUNH]HWQHN PHJIHOHO iOODSRW~ WDODMW|PE|W KHO\H]QHN pV tJ\ D
WDUWiO\EyO D Yt] FVDN D WDODMUpWHJHQ NHUHV]WO WXG SiURORJQL $
Yt]YHV]WHVpJ DGMD D WDODMSiUROJiV PpUWpNpW $ Yt]YHV]WHVpJ
OHJHJ\V]HU&EEHQ V~O\PpUpVVHO iOODStWKDWy PHJ
$ OHYHJ SiUDWDUWDOPD SRQWRVDQ PHJKDWiUR]KDWy pUWpN 7|EEIpOH
PpUWpNHJ\VpJEHQ LV NLIHMH]KHW
$EV]RO~W SiUDWDUWDORP DGRWW KPpUVpNOHWHQ P
OHYHJEHQ OpY
Yt]SiUD PHQQ\LVpJH JUDPPEDQ PHJDGYD JP
7HOtWHWWVpJL SiUDWDUWDORP D] D PD[LPiOLV SiUDPHQQ\LVpJ DPL DGRWW
KPpUVpNOHWHQ P
OHYHJEHQ HOIRUGXOKDW $ WHOtWHWWVpJL SiUDWDUWDORP
QiO DGRWW KPpUVpNOHWHQ D OHYHJ WRYiEEL SiUDW|PHJHW QHP NpSHV
PiU IHOYHQQL $ KPpUVpNOHW Q|YHNHGpVpYHO DUiQ\RVDQ Q D WHOtWHWWVpJL
SiUDWDUWDORP LV H]pUW SO D
R
& KPpUVpNOHW& WHOtWHWW OHYHJ
R
&
KPpUVpNOHW HVHWpQ PiU QHP WHOtWHWW tJ\ WRYiEEL SiUDPHQQ\LVpJHW LV
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
NpSHV IHOYHQQL &VDSDGpNNpS]GpVNRU D OHYHJ W~OWHOtWHWWp YiOLN
iOWDOiEDQ
5HODWtY SiUDWDUWDORP D] DEV]RO~W SiUDWDUWDORP pV D KPpUVpNOHWKH]
WDUWR]y WHOtWHWWVpJL SiUDWDUWDORP KiQ\DGRVD +D D KiQ\DGRVW V]i]]DO
V]RUR]]XN D UHODWtY SiUDWDUWDOPDW V]i]DOpNEDQ NDSMXN $ UHODWtY
SiUDWDUWDORP KD D] DEV]RO~W SiUDWDUWDORP HJ\HQO D WHOtWHWWVpJL
SiUDWDUWDORPPDO (] D] iOODSRW QHP FVDN ~J\ N|YHWNH]KHW EH KRJ\ Q
D] DEV]RO~W SiUDWDUWDORP KDQHP ~J\ LV KRJ\ D OHYHJEHQ OpY
SiUDPHQQ\LVpJ YiOWR]DWODQ GH D KPpUVpNOHWFV|NNHQpV PLDWW FV|NNHQ
D WHOtWHWWVpJL SiUDWDUWDORP
$ KDUPDWSRQW D] D KPpUVpNOHW DPHO\EHQ D OHYHJ QHGYHVVpJH HOpUL
D WHOtWHWWVpJL iOODSRWRW +D D KDUPDWSRQW DOi FV|NNHQ D KPpUVpNOHW
PHJLQGXO D SiUDNLFVDSyGiV KDUPDW YDJ\ HV IRUPiMiEDQ
$ OHYHJ SiUDWDUWDOPiW V]iUD]QHGYHV KPpUSiUUDO SV]LFKUR
PpWHU PpULN $ NpW KLJDQ\RV KPpU N|]O D] HJ\LN HJ\ N|]|QVpJHV
OpJKPpUVpNOHWPpU H]HQ ROYDVKDWy OH D] ~Q V]iUD] KPpUVpNOHW $
PiVLN KPpU KLJDQ\JRPEMiW iOODQGyDQ QHGYHVHQ WDUWRWW PXV]OLQEXURN
ERUtWMD H]HQ ROYDVViN OH D] ~Q QHGYHV KPpUVpNOHWHW $ QHGYHV
KPpUVpNOHW D SiUROJiV RNR]WD KYHV]WHVpJ PLDWW PLQGLJ DODFVRQ\DEE
D V]iUD]QiO pV D NpW KPpUVpNOHW HJ\WWHV pUWpNpEO
P&V]HUWtSXVRQNpQW HO]HWHVHQ PHJiOODStWRWW KLWHOHVtWpVL DGDWRN DODSMiQ
PHJ OHKHW iOODStWDQL D OHYHJ SLOODQDWQ\L SiUDWDUWDOPiW
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ FVDSDGpN NHOHWNH]pVH PpUpVH
$ FVDSDGpN KLGUROyJLDL V]HPSRQWEyO D OHJIRQWRVDEE LGMiUiVL HOHP $
Yt] WHUPpV]HWHV N|UIRUJiViEDQ D FVDSDGpNKXOOiV D OHJLVPHUWHEE
PR]]DQDW
$ FVDSDGpN KDOPD]iOODSRWD V]HULQW OHKHW
V]LOiUG FVDSDGpN Ky
MpJ
]~]PDUD
GpU
IRO\pNRQ\ FVDSDGpN HV
KDUPDW
$ IHOV]tQUH MXWiV PyGMD V]HULQW PHJNO|QE|]WHWQN
PDNURFVDSDGpNRW DPL D OpJWpUEHQ NLFVDSyGLN pV KRVV]DEE
U|YLGHEE V]DEDGHVpV XWiQ pUL HO D WDODMIHOV]tQW HV Ky MpJHV
PLNURFVDSDGpNRW DPL N|]YHWOHQO D WDODM IHOV]tQpQ FVDSyGLN NL
KDUPDW GpU
$ FVDSDGpN NHOHWNH]pVH OiWV]yODJ HJ\V]HU& IL]LNDL WpQ\H]N KDWiViUD
LQGXO PHJ D WHUPpV]HW D]RQEDQ D FVDSDGpNNpS]GpVQHN LJHQ VRN
NO|QE|] PyGMiW WHUHPWL PHJ $ FVDSDGpNNpS]GpV IHOWpWHOH KRJ\ D
OHYHJ SiUDWDUWDOPD HOpUMH D WHOtWHWWVpJL SiUDWDUWDOPDW $ PHOHJ
OHYHJ QDJ\REE PHQQ\LVpJ& SiUiW WXG HOUDNWiUR]QL D KLGHJ OHYHJ
NHYHVHEEHW $ PHOHJHEE OpJW|PHJ IHOV]iOO D KLGHJHEE OpJW|PHJHN
N|]p NHUO YDJ\ D KLGHJ OpJW|PHJ HUHV]NHGLN OH D PHOHJHEE
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
OpJW|PHJHN N|]p pV iOWDOiQRV OHK&OpVW RNR] tJ\ D KPpUVpNOHW D
KDUPDWSRQWLJ VOO\HG D UHODWtY SiUDWDUWDORP SHGLJ D WHOtWHWWVpJLJ YDJ\
iWPHQHWLOHJ D]RQ W~O LV Q|YHNV]LN $ FVDSDGpNNpS]GpV HOWW D
OHYHJEHQ OpY SiUD IHOKYp V&U&V|GLN $ NLFVDSyGiVKR] D]RQEDQ
WHOtWHWWVpJ HVHWpQ LV HVNpS] DHURVRORN V]NVpJHVHN DPHO\HNHQ D
SiUDNLFVDSyGiV PHJLQGXOKDW (]HN PLNURPpWHU VXJDU~ UpV]HFVNpN
YDJ\ HVHWOHJ D WHOtWHWW IHOKEH PHVWHUVpJHVHQ MXWWDWRWW FVHSSNpS]
HOHPHN
$ FVDSDGpN NLYiOiViW Q\iURQ D OpJN|UL HOHNWURPRVViJ LV HOVHJtWL (]HN
NLVOpVHNRU QHYH]]N D ]iSRUFVDSDGpNRW ]LYDWDUQDN
$ V]LOiUG FVDSDGpNNpS]GpVKH] HUV OHK&OpV V]NVpJHV *\DNUDQ
HOIRUGXO KRJ\ D] HUV OHK&OpV N|YHWNH]WpEHQ V]LOiUG FVDSDGpN
NpS]GLN GH D MpJ YDJ\ D Ky KXOOiV N|]EHQ PHOHJHEE OHYHJQ KDODG
NHUHV]WO pV D I|OGUH pUpV HOWW HOROYDG
$ FVDSDGpN PDJDVViJiW D FVDSDGpNPpU P&V]HUHNNHO PpULN
$ FVDSDGpNPpU P&V]HUHN NpW I FVRSRUWED VRUROKDWyN
1HP UHJLV]WUiOy FVDSDGpNPpUN
$] RPEURPpWHU HJ\ IJJOHJHV IDO~ IpP KHQJHU DPLW P PDJDV
ViJEDQ KHO\H]QHN HO D WHUHSV]LQW IHOHWW pV D FVDSDGpN IHOIRJiViUD
V]ROJiO $ Yt] D KHQJHU DOVy UpV]pEHQ J\&MWSDODFNEDQ WiUROyGLN
DPLW HJ\ NDOLEUiOW PpUSiOFiYDO YDJ\ HJ\ PpUKHQJHUUHO PpUQHN OH
QDSRQWD iOWDOiEDQ HJ\V]HU $ FVDSDGpN PDJDVViJiW PLOOLPpWHUEHQ NHOO
PHJDGQL $ FVDSDGpNJ\&MWNHW WiYROL ODNDWODQ KHO\HNHQ KRVV]DEE
LGV]DN DODWW KXOORWW FVDSDGpN |VV]PHQQ\LVpJpQHN pV]OHOpVpUH
KDV]QiOMiN (]HNQHN D J\&MWWDUWiO\ UpV]H HOpJ QDJ\ DKKR] KRJ\ DNiU
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
HJ\ HJpV] pYV]DN FVDSDGpNPHQQ\LVpJpW LV WiUROQL WXGMD $ SiUROJiV
FV|NNHQWpVH pUGHNpEHQ NHYpV RODMDW YDJ\ PiV SiUROJiVFV|NNHQW
DQ\DJRW LV OHKHW D WDUWiO\ED W|OWHQL
&VDSDGpNtUy P&V]HUHN
(OQ\N KRJ\ D OHKXOOiV SLOODQDWiWyO IRO\DPDWRVDQ U|J]tWLN D FVDSDGpN
PHQQ\LVpJHW
)EE WtSXVDL
6~O\PpUpVHQ DODSXOy FVDSDGpNtUyN
$ P&V]HU IRO\DPDWRVDQ IHOMHJ\]L D J\&MWWDUWiO\ pV D EHQQH |VV]HJ\&OW
FVDSDGpN HJ\WWHV V~O\iW 0LQGHQ IDMWD FVDSDGpNRW WHKiW D KXOOiV
SLOODQDWiEDQ U|J]tW ( P&V]HUWtSXVQDN iOWDOiEDQ QLQFV |QUtW DXWRPD
WLNiMD HJ\ HPHOUHQGV]HU VHJtWVpJpYHO D]RQEDQ HOpUKHW KRJ\ D]
tUyWROO EiUPHQQ\LV]HU YLVV]DWpUMHQ D] pV]OHOV]DODJ WHWHMpUO D] DOMiUD
V]yV FVDSDGpNtUyN iEUD
$] HJ\V]HU& RPEURPpWHUW NLHJpV]tWLN ~V]yYDO UDM]ROy EHUHQGH]pVVHO
pV yUDP&YHO HJ\EHpStWHWW IRUJyKHQJHUUHO $] pV]OHOODSRW QDSRQWD
YDJ\ KHWHQWH D IRUJyKHQJHUUH HUVtWLN $] ~V]yQDN D Yt]V]LQWHPHONHGpV
RNR]WD IJJOHJHV PR]JiViW D] ~V]yWROO D] HJ\HQOHWHVHQ PR]Jy
V]DODJUD UDM]ROMD FVDSDGpNKXOOiV LGHMpQ
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
iEUD
V]yV FVDSDGpNtUy
$ FVDSDGpN PDJDVViJiQ NtYO LVPHUQL NHOO D FVDSDGpN LQWHQ]LWiViW
LV $ FVDSDGpNLQWHQ]LWiVW D] LGHJ\VpJ DODWW OHHVHWW FVDSDGpNPHQQ\L
VpJ DGMD 0pUWpNHJ\VpJH PPPLQ YDJ\ PPK $] iWODJRV FVDSDGpN
LQWHQ]LWiVW PHJNDSMXN KD D FVDSDGpN PDJDVViJiW HORV]WMXN D
FVDSDGpN LGWDUWDPiYDO $ YDOyViJEDQ D FVDSDGpNLQWHQ]LWiV QHP
HJ\HQOHWHV KDQHP YiOWR]y $ FVDSDGpNtUy P&V]HU pV]OHO ODSMiQDN
DGDWDL DODSMiQ D]RQEDQ D FVDSDGpN LQWHQ]LWiViW D QHNQN
V]NVpJHVEiUPHO\ LGSRQWEDQ XWyODJ NL WXGMXN V]iPtWDQL
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ FVDSDGpN pV]OHOpVH UDGDUUDO
$ UDGDU DONDOPDV D FVDSDGpNRV WHUOHWHN KHO\pQHN pV KHO\YiOWR]WD
WiViQDN pV]OHOpVpUH VW EL]RQ\RV UDGDUNpV]OpNHN D FVDSDGpN
LQWHQ]LWiViW LV PpULN $ UDGDU PpUpV KLEiMD QDJ\REE PLQW D]
tUyP&V]HUp GH SHUFHQNpQWL WHUOHWL DGDWRW NpSHV V]ROJiOWDWQL
0&KROGDV pV]OHOpVHN
1DJ\ WHUOHW& LGMiUiVL iOODSRWRN IHOWiUiViUD DONDOPD]KDWyN $
P&KROGDV pV]OHOpVHNEO D] HJ\KyQDSRV YDJ\ DQQiO KRVV]DEE
LGV]DNRN DODWW KXOORWW FVDSDGpNPHQQ\LVpJHN HOIRJDGKDWy SRQWRVViJJDO
PHJEHFVOKHWN
$ EHV]LYiUJiV
$ Yt] WHUPpV]HWHV N|UIRUJiViW YL]VJiOYD PHJiOODStWRWWXN KRJ\ D WDODMUD
KXOORWW FVDSDGpN HJ\ UpV]H OHIRO\LN PiVLN UpV]H EHV]LYiURJ D WDODMED
$ WDODM PLQVpJH D Yt] EHIRJDGiVD V]HPSRQWMiEyO W|EEIpOH OHKHW
$ Yt]]iUy WDODM ILQRPV]HPFVpM& QDJ\ DJ\DJ pV LV]DSWDUWDORPPDO (] D
WDODM V]iUD] iOODSRWEDQ UHSHGH]LN pV D UHSHGpVHNHW D OHKXOORWW
FVDSDGpN NLW|OWL LOOHWYH D IHOV]tQN|]HOL WDODMKp]DJRNDW PHJW|OWL D
FVDSDGpNYt] $ QHGYHVVpJ KDWiViUD D Yt]]HO WHOtWG YpNRQ\ IHOV]tQL
UpWHJ PHJGX]]DG pV QHP NpSHV WRYiEEL J\RUV Yt]IHOYpWHOUH (] D
WDODMWtSXV WHKiW FVDN LJHQ ODVV~
NLV LQWHQ]LWiV~
FVDSDGpN
EHIRJDGiViUD DONDOPDV
$ IpOLJ Yt]]iUy WDODMRN
D NLVHEE LV]DS pV DJ\DJWDUWDOP~ KRPRN YDJ\
KRPRNOLV]W WDODMRN
NHGYH]EE Yt]JD]GiONRGiV~DN $ FVDSDGpNEyO
KRVV]DEE LGQ NHUHV]WO QDJ\REE PHQQ\LVpJHW WXGQDN EHIRJDGQL
$ Yt]iWHUHV]W WDODMRN W~OQ\RPy UpV]EHQ KRPRN pV NDYLFV
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
DODSDQ\DJ~DN (]HN QDJ\PHQQ\LVpJ& Yt] J\RUV HOQ\HOpVpUH NpSHVHN
$ WDODM Kp]DJRVViJD pV Yt]WDUWDOPD WHUPpV]HWV]HU&OHJ EHIRO\iVROMD D
OHIRO\y Yt]PHQQ\LVpJ NLDODNXOiViW 7|P|UHEE WDODMEDQ NHYHVHEE Yt]
WiUROyGKDW $ WDODM D Yt] EHIRJDGiViUD NpSWHOHQ DNNRU LV KD WHOtWHWW
YDJ\LV KD Kp]DJDL PiU Yt]]HO YDQQDN WHOYH $ EHV]LYiUJiV DWWyO LV IJJ
KRJ\ D YL]HW EHIRJDGy WDODMUpWHJ PLO\HQ YDVWDJ +D D Yt]WDUWy UpWHJ
YpNRQ\ pV DODWWD Yt]]iUy UpWHJ KHO\H]NHGLN HO DNNRU D EHV]LYiUJiV FVDN
D Kp]DJRN WHOtWGpVpLJ WDUW 7RYiEEi ERQ\ROtWMD D EHV]LYiUJiV
YL]VJiODWiW KRJ\ D V]iUD] IHOOHW W|EE YL]HW NpSHV EHIRJDGQL D
FVDSDGpNEyO PLQW D] iWQHGYHVHGHWW YDJ\LV D EHV]LYiUJiV LGEHQ
YiOWR]y LQWHQ]LWiV~ =iSRU MHOOHJ& QDJ\ LQWHQ]LWiV~ FVDSDGpN HVHWpQ D
EHV]LYiUJiV PiU SHUF DODWW LV D NH]GHWL pUWpNUO D PLQLPiOLVUD
FV|NNHQKHW +RVV]~LGHM& NLV LQWHQ]LWiV~ FVDSDGpN HVHWpQ D
EHV]LYiUJiVL NDSDFLWiVW PiV WpQ\H]N LV OpQ\HJHVHQ EHIRO\iVROMiN
(]HN N|]O OHJIRQWRVDEE D WDODMP&YHOpV PyGMD pV PpO\VpJH -HOHQWV
KDWiV~ D Q|YpQ\WDNDUy IDMWiMD pV D WDODMIHOOHW W|P|UVpJH LV
9iURVL WHUOHWHQ D Yt]]iUy EXUNRODW~ IHOOHW QHP YHV] UpV]W D
EHV]LYiUJiVEDQ pV H] LJHQ MHOHQWVHQ PHJQ|YHOL D OHKXOORWW FVDSDGpN
N|]YHWOHQO OHIRO\y KiQ\DGiW $ PRGHUQ YiURVUpV]HN EDQ
Yt]]iUy IHOOHWHW NpSH]QHN D FVDSDGpN ~WMiEDQ pV HQQHN Yt]Ki]WDUWiVL
KDWiViW IHOWpWOHQO ILJ\HOHPEH NHOO YHQQL
$ OHIRO\iV
$ FVDSDGpNQDN D] D UpV]H DPHO\LN QHP V]LYiURJ EH D WDODMED D WHUHS
OHMWpVpQHN LUiQ\iEDQ D WDODM IHOV]tQpQ NH]G OHIRO\QL $ OHIRO\y Yt] HOV]|U
D EDUi]GiNEDQ J\&OLN |VV]H PDMG D WHUHS WHUPpV]HWHV NLDODNXOiV~
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
NLVHEE PpO\YRQXODWRNEDQ D YiSiNEDQ HJ\HVO $ YiSD D WHUPpV]HW
DONRWWD HOV Yt]OHYH]HW WHUHSDODNXODW $ YiSiN YH]HWLN D YL]HW D
Y|OJ\HNEH D WHUPpV]HW YDJ\ D] HPEHU iOWDO NLDODNtWRWW iUNRNED
FVDWRUQiNED SDWDNRNED IRO\yNED
$ OHIRO\y Yt] PHGUpQ D] iUNRQ FVDWRUQiQ IRO\yQ YDODPLO\HQ YL]VJiODW
pUGHNpEHQ D V]NVpJ V]HULQWL KHO\HQ NLYiODV]WXQN HJ\
NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\W $ Yt]YH]HW PHGHU PLQGHQ NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\pKH]
PHJKDWiUR]KDWy D KR]]iWDUWR]y Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW $ Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW
D] D WHUOHW DKRQQDQ D FVDSDGpNEyO OHIRO\y Yt] D YL]VJiOW V]HOYpQ\KH]
|VV]HJ\OHNH]LN
9t]YiODV]Wy YRQDOQDN QHYH]]N D Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW KDWiUiW 7DJROW
GRPERU]DW~ WHUOHWHQ D Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW KDWiUiW D Yt]YiODV]Wy YRQDODW D
GRPERN KHJ\HN JHULQFYRQDODL KDWiUR]]iN PHJ 6tN YLGpNHQ D] HPEHU
DONRWWD PHVWHUVpJHV Yt]YiODV]Wy YRQDODNDW WDOiOKDWXQN OHJJ\DNUDEEDQ
(]HN W|EEQ\LUH iUYpGHOPL JiWDN ~W YDJ\ YDV~WL W|OWpVHN $ Yt]J\&MW
WHUOHW QDJ\ViJiW NP
YDJ\ KD PpUWpNHJ\VpJEHQ NHOO PHJDGQL
gVV]HJ\OHNH]pVQHN QHYH]]N D Yt]J\&MW WHUOHWUO OHIRO\y Yt]
IRNR]DWRV KDOPR]yGiViW gVV]HJ\OHNH]pVL LG W D] D] LGWDUWDP
DPHO\ DODWW D Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW OHJWiYRODEEL SRQWMiEyO LV D YL]VJiOW
V]HOYpQ\EH MXW D OHIRO\y Yt] $] |VV]HJ\OHNH]pV NH]GHWL LGV]DNiEDQ D
WHUHSHQ PDMG D PHGHUEH MXWYD D Yt]IRO\iV PHGUpEHQ PR]RJYD MXW HO D
YL]VJiOW V]HOYpQ\LJ D Yt] (V]HULQW D] |VV]HJ\OHNH]pVL LG LV NpW
UpV]EO WHYGLN |VV]H YDJ\LV D WHUHSHQ W|UWpQ OHIRO\iV LGHMpEO pV D
PHGHUEHQ W|UWpQ OHIRO\iV LGHMpEO
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
$] |VV]HJ\OHNH]pVL LG W EHFVOKHW D] DOiEEL NpSOHWWHO
W/
$ , =
DKRO
/
D OHJKRVV]DEE OHIRO\iVL ~W KRVV]D NP
$
D Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW NLWHUMHGpVH NP
,
D OHJKRVV]DEE OHIRO\iVL ~W OHMWpVH
9t]KR]DPQDN WpUIRJDWiUDPQDN QHYH]]N D YL]VJiOW NHUHV]W
V]HOYpQ\KH] LGHJ\VpJHQNpQW pUNH] pV D]RQ iWIRO\y Yt]PHQQ\LVpJHW
$ Yt]KR]DPRW 4YDO MHO|OMN
/HJJ\DNUDEEDQ KDV]QiOW PpUWpNHJ\VpJHL P
V OV P
V OV
+D D YL]VJiOW NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\EHQ iWIRO\y Yt]KR]DPRW HORV]WMXN D
V]HOYpQ\KH] WDUWR]y Yt]J\&MWWHUOHW QDJ\ViJiYDO DNNRU PHJNDSMXN D
IDMODJRV Yt]KR]DPRW
$ IDMODJRV Yt]KR]DP PHJPXWDWMD KRJ\ HJ\VpJQ\L WHUOHW& Yt]J\&MWUO
P
UO KDUyO NP
UO LGHJ\VpJ DODWW V SHUF yUD
PHQQ\L Yt] O P
IRO\LN OH $ IDMODJRV Yt]KR]DPRW TYDO MHO|OMN
/HJJ\DNUDEEDQ KDV]QiOW PpUWpNHJ\VpJHL
P
V NP
O
V KD
O
V P
,VPHUHWHV KRJ\ D Yt]J\&MWWHUOHWUH KXOORWW FVDSDGpNQDN FVDN HJ\
UpV]H IRJ OHIRO\QL D YL]VJiOW V]HOYpQ\LJ PLYHO D PiVLN UpV]H EHV]LYiURJ
D WDODMED
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ OHIRO\iVL KiQ\DG PHJPXWDWMD KRJ\ D OHKXOORWW FVDSDGpN KiQ\
V]i]DOpND IRO\LN OH .LV]iPtWiVD ~J\ W|UWpQLN KRJ\ D OHIRO\W FVDSDGpN
PDJDVViJRW HORV]WMXN D] |VV]HV FVDSDGpNPDJDVViJJDO pV V]RUR]]XN
V]i]]DO J\ D OHIRO\iVL KiQ\DGRW V]i]DOpNEDQ NDSMXN PHJ $ OHIRO\iVL
KiQ\DG D OHIRO\W FVDSDGpNW|PHJ WpUIRJDW P
EHQ pV D OHKXOORWW |VV]HV
FVDSDGpNW|PHJ KiQ\DGRVDNpQW LV PHJKDWiUR]KDWy
/HIRO\iVL KiQ\DG L mmC mm
( )( ) 100
$ OHIRO\y Yt]KR]DPRN PHJKDWiUR]iVD D KLGUROyJLDL V]iPtWiVRN V~O\SRQWL
IHODGDWiW NpSH]L (]HNQHN D V]iPtWiVRNQDN W|EE PyGV]HUpW LV
NLGROJR]WiN pV DONDOPD]]iN D] HJ\V]HU& OHIRO\iV EHFVOpVWO NH]GYH D
ERQ\ROXOW PDWHPDWLNDL PRGHOOH]pVL HOMiUiVRNLJ $ PpUWpNDGy FVDSDGpN
Yt]KR]DP V]iPtWiViKR] LJHQ J\DNUDQ D UDFLRQiOLV V]iPtWiVL
PyGV]HUW DONDOPD]]iN
0pUWpNDGy Yt]KR]DPQDN ( )Qm D Yt]JD]GiONRGiVL OpWHVtWPpQ\HNPpUHWH]pVHNRU DODSXO YHWW Yt]KR]DPRW QHYH]]N &VDSDGpNFVDWRUQiN
PpUWpNDGy KLGUDXOLNDL LJpQ\EHYpWHOpQHN D YL]VJiOW Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW
|VV]HJ\OHNH]pVL LGHMpKH] WDUWR]y YDODPLO\HQ S iWODJRV LVPpWOGpVL
LGK|] D WHOHSOpV QDJ\ViJiWyO IJJHQ YDJ\ pYHQNpQW
iWODJRVDQ HJ\V]HU HOIRUGXOy UHQGHOW PRGHOOFVDSDGpNEyO NHOHWNH]
OHIRO\iV WHW] Yt]KR]DPiW pUWMN $ YDOyViJRV FVDSDGpN YiOWR]y
LQWHQ]LWiV~ PtJ D PRGHOOFVDSDGpN iOODQGy LQWHQ]LWiViQDN pUWpNH
JUDILNRQUyO V] PHOOpNOHW +D]DL PRGHOOFVDSDGpN QRPRJUDPRN YDJ\
WiEOi]DWEyO OHROYDVKDWy LOO D ]iSRUFVDSDGpNW|UYpQ\ DODSMiQ V]iPtWKDWy
LV
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
5DFLRQiOLV V]iPtWiVL PyGV]HU HVHWpQ D N|]HOtW IHOWpWHOH]pVHN
YDODPHO\ FVDSDGpN RNR]WD OHIRO\iV Yt]KR]DPD DNNRU PD[LPiOLV
DPLNRU D PpUWpNDGy FVDSDGpN LGWDUWDPD D] |VV]HJ\OHNH]pVL
LGYHO HJ\HQO
D OHIRO\y Yt]KR]DP pV D] D]W NLYiOWy FVDSDGpNLQWHQ]LWiV N|]|WW
OLQHiULV D NDSFVRODW
D OHIRO\iVL WpQ\H] PLQGHQ LGWDUWDP~ pV EiUPLO\HQ J\DNRULViJ~
FVDSDGpN HVHWpEHQ YiOWR]DWODQ
$ UDFLRQiOLV V]iPtWiV DODS|VV]HIJJpVH
Qp ip A= DKRO
D Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW OHIRO\iVL WpQ\H]MH
ip D S iWODJRV J\DNRULViJ~ W |VV]HJ\OHNH]pVL LGHM&
FVDSDGpN LQWHQ]LWiVD
PRGHOOFVDSDGpN LQWHQ]LWiV
l sha/
$
Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW NLWHUMHGpVH KD
$ OHIRO\iVL WpQ\H] ( ) D PRGHOOFVDSDGpNEyO NHOHWNH] iUKXOOiPWHW] KR]DPiQDN DUiQ\D D] D]W RNR]y PRGHOOFVDSDGpN LGEHQ iOODQGy
LQWHQ]LWiViKR]
$ OHIRO\iVL WpQ\H] EHFVOpVH D N|YHWNH] WDSDV]WDODWL HPSLULNXV
|VV]HIJJpV DONDOPDV
5 ,
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
DKRO
5
D Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW Yt]]iUy IHOOHWKiQ\DGD
,
D Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW iWODJRV OHMWpVH
$ V]iPtWiV PHQHWH
D] $ pV D] / pUWpNHLQHN PHJKDWiUR]iVD
D PpUWpNDGy FVDSDGpN LVPpWOGpVL LGHMpQHN NLYiODV]WiVD
D] |VV]HJ\OHNH]pVL LG W NLV]iPtWiVD D PpUWpNDGy FVDSDGpN
LQWHQ]LWiViQDN V]iPtWiVD
D OHIRO\iVL WpQ\H] V]iPtWiVD
D FVDSDGpNEyO OHIRO\y Yt]KR]DP ( )Qp V]iPtWiVD
$ Yt]NpV]OHW pV YiOWR]iVD $ Yt]Ki]WDUWiVL HJ\HQOHW
$ I|OG IHOV]tQpQ IRO\y YDJ\ iOOy YL]HW IHOV]tQL Yt]QHN D WDODMV]HPFVpN
N|]|WW LOOHWYH D WDODM Kp]DJDLEDQ YDODPLQW D N]HWHN UHSHGpVHLEHQ
UHJHLEHQ MiUDWDLEDQ OpY YL]HW IHOV]tQ DODWWL Yt]QHN QHYH]]N
$ Yt]NpV]OHWHW D IHOV]tQL pV D IHOV]tQ DODWWL YL]HN HJ\WW DONRWMiN $ Yt]
NpV]OHWHW D FVDSDGpN WiSOiOMD pV D SiUROJiV FV|NNHQWL (J\ Yt]J\&MW
WHUOHWHQ PHJKDWiUR]KDWy D IHOV]tQL pV D IHOV]tQ DODWWL YL]HN PHQQ\LVpJH
HJ\ DGRWW LGSRQWEDQ (] D PHQQ\LVpJ MHOHQWL D WHUOHW Yt]NpV]OHWpW (J\
EL]RQ\RV LGV]DN SO HJ\ pY HOWHOWH XWiQ ~MEyO PHJiOODStWYD D
Yt]NpV]OHWHW PHJNDSMXN KRJ\ D] HOP~OW LGV]DNEDQ PLO\HQ PyGRQ
YiOWR]RWW QWW YDJ\ FV|NNHQW D Yt]NpV]OHW +D D YL]VJiOW LGV]DN DODWW
SRQWRVDQ PHJPpUWN D NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVW RNR]y NpW WHUPpV]HWL
WpQ\H]W D FVDSDGpNRW pV D SiUROJiVW DNNRU V]LQWpQ LVPHUQL IRJMXN D
Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iVW
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
$ Yt]NpV]OHWYiOWR]iV YL]VJiODWiQDN DODSMD D Yt]Ki]WDUWiVL HJ\HQOHW
)HOtUKDWMXN KRJ\ D WHUOHWUH OHKXOORWW pYL FVDSDGpNPHQQ\LVpJJHO PL
W|UWpQLN OHIRO\KDW EHV]LYiURJKDW pV SiURORJKDW H] D Yt]PHQQ\LVpJ
& 3 / % 6
&
FVDSDGpN
3
SiUROJiV
/
OHIRO\iV
%
EHV]LYiUJiV
6
WiUR]yGiV
9DJ\LV D FVDSDGpNPHQQ\LVpJHW FV|NNHQWL D SiUROJiV D PDUDGpN Yt]
SHGLJ OHIRO\LN H] IRJMD D IHOV]tQL Yt]NpV]OHWHW DONRWQL LOOHWYH EHV]LYiURJ
pV HEEO OHV]QHN D IHOV]tQ DODWWL YL]HN $] LO\HQ IRUPiEDQ IHOtUW
Yt]Ki]WDUWiVL HJ\HQOHW MREE ROGDOiQ WHKiW D Yt]NpV]OHW V]HUHSHO
&VDSDGpNRV pYEHQ W|EE FVDSDGpN KXOOLN PLQW DPHQQ\L HOSiURORJ
HNNRU pY YpJpQ D Yt]NpV]OHW Q|YHNHGpVpW iOODStWKDWMXN PHJ
& ! 3
$V]iO\RV D] pY KD D FVDSDGpN NHYHVHEE D SiUROJiVQiO HNNRU D
WiUR]RWW Yt] 6 IRJ\
& 3
,O\HQ pYEHQ D FVDSDGpNPHQQ\LVpJ QHP NpSHV SyWROQL D IHOV]tQL pV D
IHOV]tQ DODWWL YL]HNEO W|UWpQ SiUROJiVW pV pY YpJpQ tJ\ D Yt]NpV]OHW
FV|NNHQpVpW NHOO PHJiOODStWDQXQN $ Yt]IRUJDORP YL]VJiODWiKR]
FpOV]HU& PHJKDWiUR]QL D Yt]IRUJDORPQDN D]W D] iWODJRV UpV]pW DPHO\LN
UpV]W YHV] D KLGUROyJLDL N|UIRO\DPDWEDQ pV IRO\DPDWRVDQ PHJ~MXO
SyWOyGLN $ Yt]IRUJDORPQDN H]W D UpV]pW GLQDPLNXV Yt]NpV]OHWQHN
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
QHYH]]N $ IHOV]tQL Yt]IRUJDORPQDN PR]JiVEDQ OHY UpV]pW D IHOV]tQ
DODWWL YL]HNEO HQQHN D KiQ\DGQDN FVDN XWiQSyWOyGy W|UHGpNpW
VRUROKDWMXN D GLQDPLNXV Yt]NpV]OHWKH]
6WDWLNXV Yt]NpV]OHW HJ\ Yt]J\&MW WHUOHW IHOV]tQL iOOyYL]HLQHN WHOMHV pV
IHOV]tQ DODWWL YL]HLQHN V]LQWH WHOMHV W|PHJpW MHOHQWL +DV]QRVtWiV
V]HPSRQWMiEyO QHP D WHUOHWHQ UDNWiUR]yGRWW Yt] PHQQ\LVpJH D G|QW
VWDWLNXV NpV]OHW KDQHP D PHJ~MXOy SyWOyGy Yt]NpV]OHW GLQDPLNXV
NpV]OHW
$ )|OG WHOMHV Yt]NpV]OHWpW NHWW PLOOLiUG NP
UH EHFVOKHWMN DPHO\ D
)|OG WpUIRJDWiQDN iW WHV]L NL $ WHOMHV Yt]NpV]OHW NE D YLOiJ
WHQJHUHNEHQ D NpPLDLODJ N|W|WW iOODSRWEDQ D N]HWHNEHQ PtJ
D V]iUD]I|OGL WHUOHWHNHQ pV D OpJWpUEHQ WDOiOKDWy
$ )|OG yFHiQMDLQDN Yt]IHOOHWH PLOOLy NP
D V]iUD]I|OGHN
WHUOHWH PLOOLy NP
(V]HULQW D )|OG IHOOHWpQHN W|EE PLQW
NpWKDUPDGD Yt]]HO ERUtWRWW $ V]iUD]I|OGHN IHOOHWpEO PLOOLy NP
OHIRO\iVWDODQ
$ WHOMHV Yt]NpV]OHW D pGHVYt] D]RQEDQ HQQHN PLQWHJ\ D VDUNL
MpJWDNDUyEDQ D I|OGNpUHJ PpO\HEE UpWHJHLEHQ YDODPLQW D OpJN|UEHQ
WDOiOKDWy $ IHQQPDUDGy PiU YLV]RQ\ODJ N|]YHWOHQ NDSFVRODWEDQ
YDQ D] pOYLOiJJDO D] iOOy pV IRO\yYL]HN WDODMQHGYHVVpJ IHOV]tQ DODWWL
YL]HN D]RQEDQ D] HPEHUL IHOKDV]QiOiV V]HPSRQWMiEyO MHOHQOHJ
V]iPtWiVED YHKHW GLQDPLNXV Yt]NpV]OHW FVXSiQ NP
pY ,O\
PyGRQ WHKiW D WHOMHV I|OGL pGHVYt]L NpV]OHWQHN HG UpV]pW NpSH]L
D] pYHQWH iWODJRVDQ IHOKDV]QiOKDWy Yt]PHQQ\LVpJ $PHQQ\LEHQ D]
HPOtWHWW NpV]OHWHW |VV]HYHWMN D )|OG ODNRVViJiQDN YiUKDWy V]iPiYDO
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
pV HJ\ iWODJRV Yt]LJpQQ\HO V]iPROXQN PHJiOODStWKDWy KRJ\ D]
H]UHGIRUGXOy YpJpLJ D] HPEHULVpJ FVXSiQ HJ\KDWRG UpV]pW IRJMD
LJpQ\EH YHQQL HQQHN D Yt]NpV]OHWQHN
$ KD]DL DGDWRN D PHOOpNOHWEHQ WDOiOKDWyN
V] PHOOpNOHW 0DJ\DURUV]iJ iWODJRV pYHV Yt]IRUJDOPD
V] PHOOpNOHW 0DJ\DURUV]iJ iWODJRV pYHV Yt]IRUJDOPD NO|Q|V
WHNLQWHWWHO D Yt]KDV]QRVtWiVUD
7HKiW QHP D PHQQ\LVpJL NpUGpV D I SUREOpPD KDQHP D] KRJ\ D Yt]
QHP D PHJIHOHO KHO\HQ QHP D PHJIHOHO LGSRQWEDQ pV WDOiQ DPL D
OHJIRQWRVDEE QHP D PHJIHOHO PLQVpJEHQ iOO UHQGHONH]pVQNUH
7RYiEEi NRUOiWR]y N|UOPpQ\ D] LV KRJ\ D MHOHQOHJL iWODJRV WHFKQLNDL
V]tQYRQDO PHOOHWW FVXSiQ NP
UH WHKHW D] D] pYL GLQDPLNXV
Yt]NpV]OHW DPHO\HW D] HPEHULVpJ pYHQWH JD]GDViJLODJ PpJ NLIL]HWHQG
PyGRQ KDV]QRVtWDQL WXG
$ IHOV]tQ DODWWL YL]HN
$ FVDSDGpNYt] HJ\ UpV]H D I|OG IHOV]tQH DOi V]LYiURJ 2WW YDJ\ D
OHJIHOV V]HPFVpV N]HWEHQ KHO\H]NHGLN HO YDJ\ PpO\HEE Yt]WDUWy
UpWHJHNEH V]LYiURJ WRYiEE $ OHJIHOV V]HPFVpV UpWHJEHQ HOKHO\H]NHG
YL]HW WDODMYt]QHN D WRYiEEL V]HPFVpV UpWHJHNEHQ OHYW UpWHJYt]QHN
QHYH]]N $ UpWHJHN OHKHWQHN Yt]DGyN DPL DODWW D]W pUWMN KRJ\
DONDOPDVDN D Yt] NLWHUPHOpVpUH ,GH iOWDOiEDQ D GXUYD V]HPFVpV
DQ\DJ~ UpWHJHN WDUWR]QDN /HKHWQHN WRYiEEi QHP Yt]DGyN YDJ\
Yt]]iUyN DPHO\HN DQ\DJD V]LOiUG UHSHGpVPHQWHV N]HW YDJ\ LJHQ
DSUy NRKp]LyV WXODMGRQViJ~ V]HPV]HUNH]HW& WDODMIDMWD DJ\DJ LV]DS
%iQ\DQHGYHVVpJQHN QHYH]]N D N]HWHN KDVDGpNDLEDQ pV UHSHGp
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
VHLEHQ HOKHO\H]NHG YL]HW +D D KDVDGpN RO\DQ PpUHW& KRJ\ EHQQN
JUDYLWiFLyV iUDPOiV DODNXOKDW NL DNNRU D EHQQN OpY Yt] D KDVDGpNYt]
$ PpV]N pV GRORPLW DQ\DJ~ N]HWHNEHQ D Yt] YHJ\L ROGiVD
N|YHWNH]WpEHQ D KDVDGpNRN MiUDWRNNi UHJHNNp EDUODQJRNNi
|EO|V|GKHW .DUV]WYt]QHN QHYH]]N D] H]HNHW D MiUDWRNDW NLW|OW YL]HW
$ WDODMYt]
$ IHOV]tQ DODWW D] HOV Yt]]iUy UpWHJ I|O|WWL Yt]WDUWy UpWHJEHQ WDOiOKDWy
.|]YHWOHQ NDSFVRODWEDQ YDQ D FVDSDGpNYt]]HO pV N|]YHWOHQO pULQWNH]LN
D OHYHJYHO LV $ OHJDOXO HOKHO\H]NHG WDODMYt] D] HOV Yt]]iUy UpWHJ
IHOHWW D WDODM Kp]DJDLW WHOMHVHQ NLW|OWL (QQHN V]LQWMH QHP iOODQGy PLYHO D
SiUROJiV pV D FVDSDGpNPHQQ\LVpJ HUVHQ EHIRO\iVROMD D WDODMYt]
PHQQ\LVpJHW (EEO D PpO\VpJEO YHWW WDODMW NpWIi]LV~ WDODMQDN
QHYH]]N PHUW FVDN WDODMV]HPFVpNHW pV D Kp]DJRNDW WHOMHVHQ NLW|OW
YL]HW WDOiOXQN D PLQWiEDQ $ WDODMYt]V]LQW IHOHWW D WDODMKp]DJRNEDQ PiU
OHYHJW LV WDOiOXQN D Yt] PHOOHWW $] LO\HQ WDODMW KiURPIi]LV~ WDODMQDN
QHYH]]N PLYHO D EHOOH YHWW PLQWD WDODMW YL]HW pV OHYHJW LV WDUWDOPD]
$ Yt] HEEHQ D WDODMUpWHJEHQ D WDODM LJHQ YpNRQ\ Kp]DJDLQ KDMV]iO
FV|YHLQ NDSLOOiULV MiUDWDLQ HPHONHGLN IHO D WDODMYt]V]LQWWO H]pUW H]W D
WDODMUpV]W NDSLOOiULV ]yQiQDN QHYH]]N $ OHJIHOV WDODMUpWHJEHQ PiU
FVDN SiUD IRUPiMiEDQ WDOiOKDWXQN YL]HW pV H]W D UpWHJHW WDODM
OHYHJ
WDUWDOP~ |YQHN QHYH]]N iEUD $ WDODMYt] HOVVRUEDQ FVDSDGpNYt]
EO D EHV]LYiUJiV VRUiQ SyWOyGLN GH IRO\yN N|]HOpEHQ
KD D PHGHU
DQ\DJ iWHUHV]W
LGV]DNRVDQ D IRO\yYt] LV WiSOiOMD $] LO\HQ YL]HW DPL
HUHGHWpW WHNLQWYH IHOV]tQL Yt] YROW FVDN D PHGHUDQ\DJRQ NLV]LYiURJYD
NHUOW D IHOV]tQ DOi D WDODMYt]KH] SDUWLV]&UpV& Yt]QHN QHYH]]N
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
$ WDODMYt]V]tQ iOWDOiEDQ QHP Yt]V]LQWHV KDQHP N|YHWL D IHOV]tQL
WHUHSDODNXODWRW 'RPEYLGpNHQ WHKiW D WDODMYt] MHOHQWV OHMWpV& D OHMWpV
LUiQ\D D Y|OJ\ IHOp PXWDW pV D WDODMYt] LV HEEHQ D] LUiQ\EDQ PR]RJ
$ WDODMYt] NLV PpO\VpJH PLDWW DNQiV YDJ\ I~UW N~WWDO N|QQ\HQ I|OWiUKDWy
pV NLWHUPHOKHW 0LYHO IHOOUO QHP YpGL Yt]]iUy UpWHJ N|QQ\HQ HOV]HQ\
Q\H]GKHW pV LYyYt] FpOMiUD FVDN WLV]WtWiVVDO KDV]QiOKDWy +D D
WDODMYt]V]LQW D IHOV]tQ N|]HOpEH HPHONHGLN DNNRU DNDGiO\R]]D
D PH]JD]GDViJL WHUPHOpVW H]pUW OHFVDSROiVVDO NHOO D NtYiQW
WDODMYt]V]LQWHW V]DEiO\R]QL
iEUD
)HOV]tQ DODWWL YL]HN
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ UpWHJYt]
$ WDODM NO|QE|] DQ\DJ~ UpWHJHNEO iOO $ UpWHJHN UHQGNtYO
YiOWR]DWRVDQ Yt]V]LQWHVHQ YDJ\ IHUGpQ HVHWOHJ OHQFVHV]HU&HQ
HONO|QOYH pV EHpNHOGYH KHO\H]NHGQHN HO D] OHSHGpVN pV D
JHROyJLDL PR]JiVRN N|YHWNH]WpEHQ $] HOV Yt]]iUy UpWHJ DODWW D NpW
Yt]]iUy UpWHJ N|]|WWL Yt]DGy UpWHJEHQ VRN KHO\HQ HJ\PiV DODWW W|EE
V]LQWEHQ HOKHO\H]NHG YL]HW QHYH]]N UpWHJYt]QHN $ WDODMYL]HW WDUWy
UpWHJHW N|YHWHQ W|EE H]HU PpWHU PpO\VpJLJ PHJWDOiOKDWy $ UpWHJYt]
D OHJW|EE HVHWEHQ WHOMHVHQ NLW|OWL D Yt]WDUWy N]HW Kp]DJDLW H]pUW D
WDODMYt]WO HOWpUHQ D UpWHJYt] I|O|WW QLQFV NDSLOOiULV ]yQD
$UWp]L Yt]QHN QHYH]]N D NpW Yt]]iUy UpWHJ N|]|WWL Yt]WDUWy UpWHJEHQ
HOKHO\H]NHG pV Q\RPiV DODWW iOOy UpWHJYL]HW +D D I~UiVVDO IHOWiUMXN D]
DUWp]L YL]HW WDUWDOPD]y UpWHJHNHW DNNRU D Q\RPiV N|YHWNH]WpEHQ D Yt] D
IHOV]tQ I|Op HPHONHGKHW
3R]LWtY DUWp]L N~WQDN QHYH]]N D]RNDW D] DUWp]L YL]HW NLWHUPHO
NXWDNDW DPHO\HNEO V]LYDWW\~]iV QpONO FVDN D UpWHJQ\RPiV KDWiViUD
NHUO D IHOV]tQUH D Yt] +D D I~UiVVDO IHOWiUW UpWHJYt]UH KDWy Q\RPiV QHP
HOpJ QDJ\ DNNRU D Yt] XJ\DQ D] HUHGHWL Yt]WDUWy UpWHJ I|Op HPHONHGLN
GH QHP pUL HO D IHOV]tQW KDQHP D WHUHSV]LQW DODWW PDUDG (]pUW D YL]HW
V]XEDUWp]L Yt]QHN QHYH]]N $ V]XEDUWp]L YL]HW IHOWiUy NXWDN D QHJDWtY
DUWp]L NXWDN $ UpWHJYt]UH KDWy Q\RPiVW D IHG N]HWHN V~O\D
UpWHJQ\RPiV D UpWHJHNEHQ OpY Ji]RN IHOKDMWy HUHMH YDJ\ D
PHGHQFpNQpO D Yt]WDUWy PDJDVDEE UpV]HLEHQ WiUROyGy Yt] KLGURV]WDWLNDL
Q\RPiVD NHOWL $ UpWHJYL]HN N|]YHWOHQO D OHYHJYHO QLQFVHQHN
NDSFVRODWEDQ H]pUW KPpUVpNOHWN QHP D IHOV]tQL KPpUVpNOHWWO
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
KDQHP D Yt]WDUWy N]HWHN KPpUVpNOHWpWO IJJ $ )|OG EHOVHMH IHOp
KDODGYD QDJ\REE PpO\VpJHNEHQ PHOHJHEE YL]HW WDOiOXQN $
JHRWHUPLNXV JUDGLHQV PHJPXWDWMD KRJ\ OHIHOp KDODGYD D )|OG
KPpUVpNOHWH KiQ\ PpWHUHQNpQW HPHONHGLN
R
&NDO eUWpNH P
N|]|WW YiOWR]KDW iWODJRV N|]pSpUWpNH P +D]iQNEDQ D] $OI|OG GpOL
UpV]pQ D JHRWHUPLNXV JUDGLHQV P N|]|WWL ,WW D KpYt] K
KDV]QRVtWiVD LJHQ JD]GDViJRV +pYt]QHN QHYH]]N D
&QiO
PHOHJHEE YL]HW
$ NDUV]WYt]
$ KDVDGpNYL]HN NO|QOHJHV IDMWiMD D PpV]N pV GRORPLW DODSDQ\DJ~
N]HWHN KDVDGpNDLEDQ WDOiOKDWy NDUV]WYt] $ KDVDGpNYL]HN N|]O
FVXSiQ D NDUV]WYt]EO WHUPHOKHW NL pV KDV]QRVtWKDWy V]iPRWWHY
IHOV]tQ DODWWL Yt] $ PpV]N pV D GRORPLW N]HWEO iOOy KHJ\VpJHNEHQ D
Yt] ROGy KDWiVD N|YHWNH]WpEHQ KDWDOPDV MiUDWRN EDUODQJUHQGV]HUHN LV
NLDODNXOQDN (]HNQHN D MiUDWRNQDN HJ\ UpV]pEHQ SDWDNRN pV WDYDN
YDQQDN $ MiUDWRNDW N|]HO IJJOHJHV KDVDGpNRN N|WLN |VV]H D
IHOV]tQQHO DPHO\HNHW Yt]Q\HONQHN QHYH]QN $ Yt]Q\HON J\&MWLN
|VV]H D IHOV]tQUH KXOORWW FVDSDGpNRW pV YH]HWLN D MiUDWRNED $KRO D
NDUV]WMiUDWEDQ OpY Yt] D IHOV]tQUH NHUO iOODQGy YL]& YDJ\ LGV]DNRV
NDUV]WIRUUiV NHOHWNH]LN $ NDUV]WIRUUiV YL]pW HOQ\HO SDWDN HVHWOHJ ~MUD
KDVDGpNED NHUO pV D KHJ\VpJ EHOVHMpEHQ IRO\LN WRYiEE $ SDWDNRNQDN
H]W D IRUPiMiW E~YySDWDNRNQDN QHYH]]N $ NDUV]WRV N]HWW|PHJEHQ
LV NLDODNXO RO\DQ YiOWR]y Yt]V]LQW DPHO\ DODWW PiU PLQGHQ MiUDW UHJ
EDUODQJ WHOMHVHQ WHOtWHWW Yt]]HO (QQHN D Yt]V]LQWQHN PLQGHQNRUL
PDJDVViJiW QHYH]]N NDUV]WYt]V]LQWQHN
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ NDUV]WRV N]HWW|PHJQHN NpW I HOIRUGXOiVL IRUPiMD LVPHUW 1\tOW
NDUV]W D] D PpV]N YDJ\ GRORPLWW|PHJ DPHO\ D OpJWpUUHO
N|]YHWOHQO pULQWNH]LN )HGHWW NDUV]WUyO EHV]pOQN KD D NDUV]WRV
UpWHJUH D IHOV]tQHQ YDODPLO\HQ Yt]]iUy UpWHJ WHOHSOW $ NDUV]WYt]V]LQW
HOKHO\H]NHGpVpW WHNLQWYH PHJNO|QE|]WHWQN VHNpO\ pV PpO\ NDUV]WRW
$ VHNpO\ NDUV]W Yt]WiUROy NpSHVVpJH NLVHEE D Yt] YLV]RQ\ODJ U|YLG ~WRQ
D IHOV]tQUH OpS pV D FVDSDGpNYLV]RQ\RN HJ\EHQ D IRUUiVRN KR]DPiW
EHIRO\iVROMiN $ PpO\ NDUV]W Yt]WiUROy NpSHVVpJH QDJ\ D
FVDSDGpNYLV]RQ\RN NHYpVEp EHIRO\iVROMiN pV QDJ\ NLWHUMHGpV&
|VV]HIJJ Yt]V]LQWMH Yt]WNUH YDQ $ NDUV]WYt] J\DNUDQ ]DYDUMD D
EiQ\iV]DWRW (PLDWW D NDUV]WYt] V]LQWMpW IRO\DPDWRV V]LYDWW\~]iVVDO
OHV]iOOtWMiN $] tJ\ NLWHUPHOW EiQ\DYL]HW IRUGtWMiN D WHOHSOpVHN pV
]HPHN Yt]HOOiWiViUD SyWROYD D NLV]iUDGW NDUV]WIRUUiVRN YL]pW
$ NDUV]WYt] KPpUVpNOHWH QHP N|YHWL D UpWHJYL]HN HJ\HQOHWHV
PHOHJHGpVpQHN W|UYpQ\HLW (OIRUGXO KRJ\ QDJ\REE PpO\VpJEHQ LV
DUiQ\ODJ KLGHJ NDUV]WYL]HW WDOiOXQN
$ IRUUiVRN
)RUUiVUyO EHV]pOQN KD D IHOV]tQ DODWWL Yt] EiUPHO\LN HOIRUGXOiVL
IRUPiMD WHUPpV]HWHV ~WRQ D WHUHSV]LQWUH EXNNDQ $ IRUUiVRN YL]pW D
IHOV]tQL YL]HN N|]|WW V]RNWiN V]iPRQWDUWDQL IJJHWOHQO DWWyO KRJ\
YL]pQHN PLQVpJH D IHOV]tQ DODWWL Yt] VDMiWRVViJDLW YLVHOL $ IRUUiVRN
WHUPpV]HWEHQ PHJMHOHQ NO|QE|] IRUPiL LJHQ YiOWR]DWRVDN $
I|OGNpUHJ WHUPpV]HWHV HOUHQGH]GpVH VHKRO VHP LVPpWOL |QPDJiW
H]pUW NpW WHOMHVHQ HJ\IRUPD IRUUiV QLQFV D WHUPpV]HWEHQ $ IRUUiVRN
YL]pQHN KDV]QRVtWiVDNRU JRQGRV KLGURJHROyJLDL IHOWiUy PXQNiYDO PHJ
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
NHOO iOODStWDQL D IRUUiV WHUPpV]HWpW PHUW NHOO WiMpNR]yGiV QpONO D
IRUUiV Yt]DGy NpSHVVpJpW D] HPEHUL EHDYDWNR]iV FV|NNHQWKHWL VW PHJ
LV V]QWHWKHWL $ IRUUiVRN YL]pQHN KDV]QRVtWiVD IJJ D IRUUiV
Yt]KR]DPiWyO PLQVpJpWO pV D Yt]KR]DP LQJDGR]iViWyO $ IRUUiVRN
Yt]KR]DPD XJ\DQLV D] pY NO|QE|] LGV]DNDLEDQ YiOWR]y $]
LQJDGR]iV PpUWpNH HOVVRUEDQ DWWyO IJJ KRJ\ D IRUUiV YL]pW
IHOV]tQN|]HOL YDJ\ PpO\HEEHQ HOKHO\H]NHG UpWHJHN YL]H SyWROMD $
IHOV]tQN|]HOL UpWHJHN YL]pEO WiSOiONR]y IRUUiV LQJDGR]iVD V]pOVVpJHV
$ PpO\HEE UpWHJHN NLHJ\HQOtWHWWHEE Yt]KR]DP~ IRUUiVRNDW WiSOiOQDN
$ IRUUiVRN YL]pW WHUPpV]HWHV IHOW|UpVN IRUPiMiEDQ QHP OHKHW
KDV]QRVtWDQL $ IRUUiVW IRUUiVIRJODOiVVDO WHVV]N DONDOPDVVi D Yt]
KDV]QRVtWiViUD $ IRUUiVIRJODOiV RO\DQ Yt]pStWpVL P&WiUJ\ OpWHVtWpVH
DPHO\ OHKHWYp WHV]L D IRUUiV YL]pQHN |VV]HJ\&MWpVpW pV HOV]iOOtWiViW
]iUW YH]HWpNEHQ YDODPLQW PHJyYMD D IRUUiV YL]pW D] HOV]HQQ\H]GpVWO
$ IRUUiVIRJODOiV OpWHVtWpVH VRUiQ J\HOQL NHOO DUUD KRJ\ QH ]DYDUMXN
PHJ D WHUPpV]HWHV Yt]DGy MiUDWRNDW QHKRJ\ H]iOWDO D IRUUiV Yt]DGy
NpSHVVpJH FV|NNHQMHQ
$ IHOV]tQL YL]HN KLGUROyJLiMD
)HOV]tQL Yt]QHN QHYH]]N D )|OG IHOV]tQpQ OpY PLQGHQ iOOyYt] Wy
PRFViU WHQJHU pV Yt]IRO\iV pU FVHUPHO\ SDWDN IRO\y IRO\DP YL]pW
$ IHOV]tQL Yt] INpQW N|]YHWOHQO D FVDSDGpN OHIRO\y UpV]pEO V]iUPD]LN
GH NHOHWNH]KHW D I|OGEO IHOW|U IRUUiVRNEyO LV
$ Yt]IRO\iVRN NLDODNXOiVD
$PLNRU D FVDSDGpN OHKXOO D I|OGUH pV HOLQGXO D WHUHS HVpVYRQDOiQ
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
NH]GHWEHQ D WHUHS IHOV]tQpQ IRO\LN D Yt] N|]YHWOHQO PHUW QHP WXGRWW
PpJ PHGUHW DODNtWDQL PDJiQDN +D |VV]HJ\OHNV]LN QpKiQ\ EDUi]GiEyO
HJ\ HUHFVNH QDJ\REE OHMWpV& WHUHSHQ RO\DQ VHEHVVpJ DODNXOKDW NL
KRJ\ D Yt] HOUDJDGMD D WDODM V]HPFVpLW $ PHJLQGXOy WDODMOHVRGUiV
N|YHWNH]PpQ\H D KRUGDOpNNpS]GpV pV D Yt]PRViV NLDODNXOiVD $
Yt]PRViV D KHJ\ pV GRPEYLGpNHQ D OHIRO\y Yt] HQHUJLiMD iOWDO
NLDODNtWRWW EHYiJyGiV DPLEHQ D OHIRO\y Yt] D Y|OJ\EHQ OpY SDWDNPHGHU
IHOp IRO\WDWMD ~WMiW +D D QDJ\ OHMWpV& GRPEROGDODNRQ D Yt]PRViVRNRQ
NHUHV]WOIRO\y Yt] HQ\KH OHMWpV& WHUOHWHW pU HO VHEHVVpJH OHFV|NNHQ pV
OHUDNMD D PDJiYDO KR]RWW KRUGDOpNRW J\ DODNXO NL D Yt]PRViVRN
KRUGDOpNN~SMD
9t]PRViV WRURNQDN QHYH]]N D Yt]PRViV KRUGDOpNWHUPHO pV
KRUGDOpNOHUDNy V]DNDV]DL N|]|WW iWPHQHWL UpV]W 7HKiW DPtJ D Yt] HOMXW
D Y|OJ\EHQ OpY SDWDNPHGHULJ D WHUHSHQ LOOHWYH KHJ\ pV
GRPEYLGpNHQ Yt]PRViVRV V]DNDV]RQ KDODG iW iEUD
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
iEUD
9t]PRViV
$ SDWDN PHGUpEHQ |VV]HJ\OHNH] Yt] D PHGHU DQ\DJiYDO V]HPEHQ
W|EEIpOH PyGRQ YLVHONHGKHW DWWyO IJJHQ KRJ\ PLO\HQ VHEHVVpJJHO
IRO\LN D PHGHUEHQ LOOHWYH D PHGHU PLO\HQ DQ\DJ~
+RUGDOpNWHUPHO V]DNDV]RQ D QDJ\ HQHUJLiM~ Yt] PHJERQWMD D PHGHU
DQ\DJRW PpO\tWL V]pOHVtWL D PHGUHW pV D] HOUDJDGRWW PHGHUDQ\DJRW
KRUGDOpN IRUPiMiEDQ HOV]iOOtWMD
(J\HQV~O\EDQ OpY V]DNDV]RQ D Yt] HQHUJLiMD FVDN DUUD HOHJHQG
KRJ\ D PiU PDJiYDO KR]RWW KRUGDOpNRW WRYiEE V]iOOtWVD GH ~MDEE
KRUGDOpNWHUPHOpVUH H]HQ D V]DNDV]RQ PiU QHP NpSHV
)HOW|OW PHGHUV]DNDV]RQ D Yt] PiU D IHOVEE V]DNDV]RNUyO KR]RWW
KRUGDOpNRW VHP NpSHV WRYiEE V]iOOtWDQL KDQHP OHUDNMD pV tJ\ HONH]GL
IHOW|OWHQL D PHGHU HJ\HV UpV]HLW $ IRO\yYt] D KRUGDOpNRW NpW PyGRQ
WXGMD WRYiEE V]iOOtWDQL *|UJHWYH V]iOOtWMD D PHGHU IHQHNpQ KD D
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
KRUGDOpNDQ\DJ RO\DQ QDJ\ V]HPFVpNEO iOO KRJ\ D Yt] HQHUJLiMD QHP
NpSHV D]W IHOHPHOQL GH D KHO\pUO PiU HO WXGMD PR]GtWDQL $ Yt]
PXQNDYpJ] NpSHVVpJpQHN HJ\ UpV]pW DUUD IRUGtWMD KRJ\ D KRUGDOpNRW
PR]JiV N|]EHQ IHODSUy]]D J\ D] HOLQGXOW J|UJHWHJEO PLQG NLVHEE
iWPpUM& NDYLFV pV D V~UOyGiV YDODPLQW D] WGpVHN N|YHWNH]WpEHQ
OHNHUHNtWHWW V]HPFVpM& KRPRN OHV] $ KRPRN LV WRYiEE NRSLN pV
LV]DSV]HPFVpYp FVLV]ROyGLN (]pUW D Yt]IRO\iV PHQWpQ OHIHOp KDODGYD D
KRUGDOpN iOWDOiEDQ HJ\UH DSUyEE V]HP&Yp YiOLN $ ILQRP KRUGDOpN
V]HPFVpNHW D Yt] IHOUDJDGMD pV OHEHJWHWYH V]iOOtWMD
$ KRUGDOpNPR]JDWy NpSHVVpJ HJ\HJ\ IRO\yV]DNDV]RQ VHP iOODQGy
UDGy Yt] VRNNDO QDJ\REE PHQQ\LVpJ& KRUGDOpNRW PR]JDW PHJ PLQW D]
DSDGy Yt] (QQHN N|YHWNH]WpEHQ D KRUGDOpN LGV]DNRVDQ OHUDNyGLN
PDMG NpVEE IRO\WDWMD ~WMiW $ NLVHEE Yt]IRO\iVRN SDWDNRN KRUGDOpN
WHYpNHQ\VpJH NHYpVEp MHOHQWV GH J\DNUDQ HOIRUGXO KRJ\ HJ\HJ\
iUYt] D IHOLVPHUKHWHWOHQVpJLJ PHJYiOWR]WDWMD D PHGUHW KHO\HQNpQW D
PHGHU SDUWMDLQDN NLPRViViYDO PiV V]DNDV]RNRQ D PHGHU IHOW|OWpVpYHO
0HVWHUVpJHV I|OGPHGU& FVDWRUQiNQiO DUUD NHOO W|UHNHGQL KRJ\ D
QDJ\Yt] QH RNR]]RQ NiURV PHGHUNLPRViVW YDJ\ PHGHUHOIDMXOiVW D
NLVYt] SHGLJ QH UDNMD OH D KRUGDOpNiW ( NpW N|YHWHOPpQ\W ~J\ WHOMHVtWLN
KRJ\ D NO|QE|] PHGHUDQ\DJRNUD WiEOi]DWRNEDQ DOVy pV IHOV KDWiU
VHEHVVpJHNHW tUQDN HO pV KD D] HONpV]OW FVDWRUQiEDQ D
WpQ\OHJHVHQ NLDODNXOy VHEHVVpJ D] HOtUW KDWiUVHEHVVpJHN N|]|WW
PDUDG OHJIHOMHEE LGV]DNRVDQ IRJ IHOOpSQL NiURV KRUGDOpNMHOHQVpJ GH D
Yt]IRO\iV iOWDOiEDQ |QV]DEiO\R]y PHGHUNpQW YLVHONHGLN
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
$ Yt]IRO\iVRN DODNWDQD
$ OHIRO\iVNRU D Yt] D] HO] IHMH]HWEHQ LVPHUWHWHWW PyGRQ D Y|OJ\HN
IHOp IRO\LN $ Y|OJ\ PpO\YRQXODWiQ D Yt]QHN YDJ\ PHVWHUVpJHVHQ
NpV]tWQN PHGUHW YDJ\ D Yt] |QPDJiQDN YiM XWDW 0HGHUQHN QHYH]]N
D]W D WHUPpV]HWHV YDJ\ PHVWHUVpJHV EHPDUyGiVW PpO\HGpVW DPHO\EHQ
D Yt] IRO\LN
.LVYt]L PHGHU D PHGHUQHN D] D UpV]H DPHO\HW D IRO\yYt] NLV
Yt]iOOiVNRU LV PHJW|OW .|]HSHV Yt]iOOiVQiO PpJ D PHGHUEHQ IRO\LN D Yt]
PDMG D Yt] WRYiEEL HPHONHGpVHNRU HOpUL D SDUWpOHNHW $] iUYL]HN HJ\HV
PpO\HQ EHiJ\D]RWW
Yt]IRO\iVRNRQ D SDUWpOHN N|]|WWL PHGHUEHQ LV OH
WXGQDN IRO\QL PiV HVHWEHQ D] iUYt] D SDUWpO PDJDVViJiW PHJKDODGMD
pV NLOpS D] iUWpUUH $] iUWHUHW KDWiUROKDWMD WHUPpV]HWHV WHUHSDODNXODW
NpQW PDJDVSDUW +D D] iUWpU HJ\ UpV]pW YpGHQL DNDUMXN D] HO|QWpVWO
DNNRU iUYpGHOPL W|OWpVW NHOO pStWHQQN $] iUYpGHOPL W|OWpV D] iUWHUHW
KXOOiPWpUUH pV PHQWHWW iUWpUUH RV]WMD iEUD
iEUD
0HGHU NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\
)HOW|OWG IRO\yV]DNDV]RNRQ D PHGHU D N|UQ\H] WHUHSV]LQWKH]
YLV]RQ\tWYD IRNR]DWRVDQ HPHONHGLN J\ HOiOOKDW KRJ\ D PHGHUEHQ
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
IRO\y NLVYt] V]LQWMH LV PDJDVDEE PLQW D N|UQ\H] WHUHSV]LQW (NNRU
IJJPHGHUUO EHV]pOQN )JJPHGHU HVHWpQ PiU D NLV pV D
N|]HSHV YL]HN LV iUYt]YHV]pO\W MHOHQWHQHN D PpO\HEEHQ IHNY
N|UQ\H]HWUH $] LO\HQ PHGUHW IHOWpWOHQO V]DEiO\R]QL V]NVpJHV
$ PHGHU SDUWYRQDO DODWWL Up]V&MH D Yt]IRO\iV WHUPpV]HWH pV D
PHGHUDQ\DJ PLQVpJH V]HULQW DODNXO NL OOpNRQ\ iOODQGy PHGHUUp]V&
DNNRU iOOKDW HO KD D Yt]IRO\iV KRUGDOpNV]iOOtWiV V]HPSRQWMiEyO
Q\XJDORPEDQ YDQ WHKiW VHP KRUGDOpNWHUPHOpV VHP KRUGDOpNOHUDNyGiV
QLQFV
$ PHGHU KHO\V]tQUDM]L YL]VJiODWiEyO PHJiOODStWKDWMXN KRJ\ D
WHUPpV]HWHV PHGHU NDQ\DUXODWRN VRUR]DWiEyO iOO $ PHGHU NDQ\DUXODWD
LEDQ D Yt]IRO\iV N|]HSH IHOO WHNLQWYH KRPRU~ pV GRPERU~ SDUWRW NO|Q
E|]WHWQN PHJ
$ KRPRU~ SDUW PHUHGHNHEE Up]V&MpW D Yt] V]DJJDWMD pV DOiPRVVD
H]pUW J\DNUDQ V]DNDGy SDUWQDN LV QHYH]LN $ KRPRU~ ROGDORQ
PpUKHWMN D OHJQDJ\REE Yt]PpO\VpJHNHW LV D V]HOYpQ\EHQ $ GRPERU~
SDUW OHMWpVH H]]HO V]HPEHQ HQ\KH D Yt] H]HQ D] ROGDORQ UDNMD OH D
KRUGDOpNiW iEUD $ NDQ\DURN N|]|WW U|YLG iWPHQHWL V]DNDV]RN
DODNXOQDN NL H]HNHQ D KHO\HNHQ UHQGV]HULQW NLVHEE PpO\VpJ& D PHGHU
(]HNHW D KHO\HNHW Ji]OyNQDN QHYH]]N
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
iEUD
0HGHU KHO\V]tQUDM]
$ PHGHU D NDQ\DURN WHWSRQWMiQ D KRPRU~ SDUW N|]HOpEHQ D
OHJQDJ\REE PpO\VpJ& $ PpO\VpJ D Ji]OyLJ IRNR]DWRVDQ FV|NNHQ PDMG
D N|YHWNH] NDQ\DU WHWSRQWMiLJ LVPpW Q +D WHKiW D PHGHU OHJPpO\HEE
SRQWMDLW KRVV]LUiQ\EDQ |VV]HN|WMN D]W WDSDV]WDOMXN KRJ\ D IHQpNYRQDO
QHP SiUKR]DPRV D Yt] IHOV]tQpQHN HJ\HQOHWHV OHMWpV& YRQDOiYDO KDQHP
HOQ\~Oy PpO\HGpVHN VRUR]DWiEyO iOO $ PHGHUEHQ IRO\y Yt] VHEHVVpJH D
PHGHU V]pOHVVpJpEHQ pV PpO\VpJpEHQ YiOWR]y $ V]pOHNHQ pV D IHQpN
N|]YHWOHQ N|]HOpEHQ NLVHEE D VHEHVVpJ $ OHJQDJ\REE VHEHVVpJ&
SRQWRNDW |VV]HN|W YRQDO D VRGRUYRQDO $ VRGRUYRQDO QHP HVLN HJ\EH
D PHGHU WHQJHO\YRQDOiYDO PHUW D NDQ\DURNEDQ D KRPRU~ SDUW LUiQ\iED
WROyGLN HO (EEO N|YHWNH]LN KRJ\ D VRGRUYRQDO pV WHQJHO\YRQDO
W|EEV]|U LV PHWV]L HJ\PiVW +D D PHGHU pV D SDUWRN V]DEiO\RVDN pV
QLQFVHQHN D Yt]IRO\iVW JiWOy DNDGiO\RN D IHQpNHQ YDJ\ D SDUWRNRQ
DNNRU D Yt] D PHGHUEHQ HJ\HQOHWHVHQ WXG IRO\QL $KRO DNDGiO\RN
YDQQDN RWW |UYpQ\HN YDJ\ IRUJyN NHOHWNH]QHN DPHO\HN
PHGHUHOIDMXOiVW LV RNR]KDWQDN
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ PHVWHUVpJHV PHGUHNHW W|EEQ\LUH HJ\HQHV pV tYHV V]DNDV]RN
VRUR]DWiEyO DODNtWMiN NL (]HNQHN D PHGUHNQHN D] iOODQGyViJiW
PHGHUEXUNRODWRNNDO YDJ\ SDUWYpG P&YHNNHO LV OHKHW EL]WRVtWDQL
$ PHVWHUVpJHV PHGUHN NLDODNtWiViQDN IEE V]HPSRQWMDL D
N|YHWNH]N
$ PHGHU D PpUWpNDGy QDJ\Yt]KR]DPRW NiUWpWHO QpONO WXGMD OHYH]HWQL
/HJ\HQ HOHJHQG GH QH W~O QDJ\ OHMWpVH D PHGHUQHN
$ PHGHU DODNMD OHJ\HQ WDUWyVDQ iOODQGy
$ PHGHU iEUi]ROiVD KiURP PyGRQ W|UWpQLN 7pUNpS IRUPiMiEDQ
KHO\V]tQUDM]RQ iEUi]ROMXN D PHGHU Yt]V]LQWHV PpUHWHLW HOKHO\H]NHGpVpW
$ PpUHWDUiQ\RNWyO IJJHQ NpWIDMWD KHO\V]tQUDM]RW NO|QE|]WHWQN PHJ
$] iWWHNLQW KHO\V]tQUDM] YDJ\
PpUHWDUiQ\~ $] |WYHQ PpWHUQpO V]pOHVHEE PHGUHNHW NHWWV
YRQDOODO HQQpO NHVNHQ\HEE PHGUHNHW SHGLJ HJ\ YRQDOODO iEUi]ROMXN $
UpV]OHWHV KHO\V]tQUDM] PpUHWDUiQ\~
6]HOYpQ\H]pV P&WiUJ\DN pV P&WiUJ\NLPXWDWiV LV V]HUHSHO D UpV]OHWHV
KHO\V]tQUDM]RQ $ V]HOYpQ\H]pV SRQWMD D PHGHU WRUNRODWiQiO YDQ
$ NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\ D Yt]IRO\iV NLYiODV]WRWW V]HOYpQ\pEHQ D
VRGRUYRQDOUD PHUOHJHV PHWV]HW $ NLV Yt]IRO\iVRN SDWDNRN
NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\HLW WRU]tWiV QpONO D QDJ\ Yt]IRO\iVRN V]HOYpQ\HLW SHGLJ
PpUHWWRU]tWiVVDO iEUi]ROMiN $ WRU]tWiV D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\ D IJJOHJHV
PpUHWDUiQ\ pV D Yt]V]LQWHV PpUHWDUiQ\ D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\
iEUi]ROiVDNRU QHP HJ\H]LN PHJ $ WRU]tWiV KD D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\
PDJDVViJL PpUHWDUiQ\D SO D Yt]V]LQWHV WiYROViJRN PpUHWDUiQ\D
SHGLJ
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
+RVV]V]HOYpQ\QHN QHYH]]N D Yt]IRO\iV VRGRUYRQDOiEDQ NpS]HWW
KRVV]LUiQ\~ PHWV]HWHW $ KRVV]V]HOYpQ\W D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\HN DGDWDL
DODSMiQ V]HUNHV]WLN PHJ pV PLQGLJ WRU]tWiVVDO iEUi]ROMiN iEUD
iEUD
+RVV]V]HOYpQ\
OOyYL]HN KLGUROyJLiMD
OOyYt]QHN QHYH]]N D WpUV]tQ PpO\HGpVHLW NLW|OW iOODQGy MHOOHJ&
IHOV]tQL YL]HNHW DPHO\EHQ D Yt]PR]JiVRN LUiQ\D INpQW D
V]pOYLV]RQ\RNKR] LJD]RGLN .HOHWNH]pVNHW WHNLQWYH PHJNO|QE|]WHWQN
WHUPpV]HWHV iOOyYL]HNHW pV PHVWHUVpJHV iOOyYL]HNHW
$ WHUPpV]HWHV iOOyYL]HN IDMWiL pV MHOOHP]LN
0RFViUQDN QHYH]]N D OHIRO\iVWDODQ WHUHSPpO\HGpVHNEHQ |VV]H
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
J\OHNH] VHNpO\ PpO\VpJ& iOOyYL]HW $ PRFVDUDN IOHJ YDODPHO\
Yt]IRO\iV J\DNRUL NL|QWpVHL IRO\WiQ YDJ\ D WDODMYt] QDJ\PpUWpN&
IHOHPHONHGpVpQHN HUHGPpQ\HNpQW NHOHWNH]QHN RO\DQ HVHWEHQ DPLNRU
D WHUHS DODWW QHP QDJ\ PpO\VpJEHQ Yt]]iUy UpWHJ KHO\H]NHGLN HO
1|YpQ\]HWH iOWDOiEDQ LJHQ V&U& YL]H KDV]QRVtWiVUD NHYpVVp DONDOPDV
$] HOSXV]WXOW PRFViUL Q|YpQ\HN OHUDNyGiViEyO NHOHWNH]LN D W]HJ
$ WDYDN OHIRO\iVWDODQ WHUHSKXOOiPRNEDQ NLDODNXOy iOOyYL]HN $ WDYDN
HUHGHWH W|EEIpOH OHKHW J\ )|OGQN|Q W|EE KHO\HQ PDUDGWDN YLVV]D
VyVYL]& WDYDN D JHROyJLDL P~OW WHQJHUpQHN YLVV]DK~]yGiVD XWiQ ,JHQ
J\DNRULDN D YXONiQL NUiWHUHNEHQ YDJ\ D YXONiQL NLW|UpVHN iOWDO HO]iUW
PHGUHNEHQ NLDODNXOW WDYDN 9L]N V]iUPD]KDW IRO\yNEyO SDWDNRNEyO
IRUUiVRNEyO pV D IHOHPHONHG WDODMYt]EO (J\ UpV]N YL]pW PHJFVDSROMiN
D EHOON NLLQGXOy YDJ\ UDMWXN iWIRO\y IHOV]tQL Yt]IRO\iVRN PiV UpV]N
OHIRO\iVWDODQ 6yWDUWDOPXN YiOWR]y QHGYHV pJKDMODW~ WHUOHWHNHQ
iOWDOiEDQ pGHVYL]&HN V]iUD] pJKDMODW~ WHUOHWHNHQ VyVDN $ WDYDN
I|OGWDQLODJ U|YLG pOHW&HN iOWDOiEDQ IHOW|OWGQHN $ )|OG WHUPpV]HWHV
WDYDLQDN V]iPD LJHQ QDJ\ pV H]HN N|]|WW VRN Wy YDQ DPHO\QHN WHUOHWH
D] NP
W LV PHJKDODGMD
$ WHQJHUHN pV yFHiQRN VyVYL]& iOOyYL]HN 9L]NHW D )|OG IRO\yL
WiSOiOMiN IHOOHWN SHGLJ SiUROJiV ~WMiQ SyWROMD D OpJN|U QHGYHVVpJpW $
V]iUD]I|OGHN N|]p pNHOG|WW WHQJHUHNHW EHOWHQJHUHNQHN QHYH]]N
FHiQRN D I|OGUpV]HN N|]|WW HOWHUO KDWDOPDV YLOiJWHQJHUHN $ WHQJHU
NO|QOHJHV PR]JiVD D] DSiO\ pV D GDJiO\ 2ND D +ROG pV D 1DS
YRQ]iVD $ 1DS pV D +ROG HJ\WWiOOiVDNRU D NpW pJLWHVW YRQ]iVD
HJ\LUiQ\ED HVLN HNNRU pUL HO D GDJiO\ D PD[LPXPiW
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
$ PHVWHUVpJHV iOOyYL]HN
$ PHVWHUVpJHV iOOyYL]HN OHKHWQHN D IRO\yV]DEiO\R]iV VRUiQ iWPHWV]HWW
NDQ\DURNEyO NLDODNXOW D IRO\yNWyO HO]iUW KROWiJDN PHVWHUVpJHVHQ
NLDODNtWRWW VtNYLGpNL pV KHJ\L YDJ\ GRPEYLGpNL KDODVWDYDN YDODPLQW D
NO|QE|] Yt]JD]GiONRGiVL FpO~ WiUR]yN $ EiQ\DWDYDN DQ\DJQ\HU
J|GU|N DPHO\HNHW WDODMYt] iUDV]WRWW HO +LGUROyJLDL V]HPSRQWEyO D
WiUR]yN PXWDWMiN D OHJQDJ\REE KDVRQOyViJRW D WHUPpV]HWHV
iOOyYL]HNKH] HOVVRUEDQ D WDYDNKR]
9t]WiUR]iV DODWW D OHIRO\y Yt] HJ\ UpV]pQHN YDJ\ WHOMHV PHQQ\LVpJpQHN
YLVV]DWDUWiViW pUWMN $ WiUR]RWW YL]HW YDJ\ DQQDN HJ\ UpV]pW NpVOHOWHWYH
OHERFViWMiN YDJ\ KDV]QRVtWMiN SO |QW|]pVUH Yt]HOOiWiVUD .LV
WHUHSHVpV& YLGpNHNHQ UHQGV]HULQW D Yt]IRO\iVRN PHGUpEHQ GX]]DV]Wy
P&YHN IHOHWWL V]DNDV]RQ YDJ\ W|OWpVHNNHO N|UO YHWW VtNYLGpNL
WiUR]yNEDQ WDUWDOpNROMiN D YL]HW +HJ\ pV GRPEYLGpNL WHUOHWHNHQ
Y|OJ\]iUyJiWDNNDO OpWHVtWHQHN WiUR]yNDW $ Yt] WiUR]iVD D Yt]]HO YDOy
JD]GiONRGiV HJ\LN LJHQ IRQWRV WHYpNHQ\VpJH
$ WiUR]iV FpOMD OHKHW D WHUPpV]HWHV Yt]MiUiV pV Yt]LJpQ\HN |VV]H
KDQJROiVD D] iUYL]HN pV EHOYt] WHOMHV YDJ\ UpV]OHJHV YLVV]DWDUWiVD
HVHWOHJ D Yt]KR]DPRN OHERFViWiViQDN V]DEiO\R]iVD D] HQHUJLDLJpQ\
V]HULQW $ WiUR]y D WHUPpV]HWHV Yt]MiUiV V]DEiO\R]iViQ NtYO
HJ\LGHM&OHJ HOOiWKDWMD Yt]]HO D N|UQ\H] WHUOHWHNHW NRQFHQWUiOW HVpVW
OpWUHKR]YD Yt]HUP& NLpStWpVpW WHV]L OHKHWYp D QDJ\YL]HN KR]DPiQDN
FV|NNHQWpVpYHO SHGLJ D Yt]NiU HOOHQL YpGHOPHW V]ROJiOMD
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ WiUR]yN OpWHVtWpVpQpO ILJ\HOHPEH YHHQG WpQ\H]N
$ Yt]IRO\iV DGRWWViJDL
D Yt]IRO\iV YL]VJiOW V]HOYpQ\pEHQ pYHQNpQW OHIRO\y Yt]PHQQ\LVpJ
D Yt]PHQQ\LVpJ OHIRO\iViQDN LGEHQL HORV]OiVD
D OHIRO\y Yt] PLQVpJH
$ WiUR]y OpWHVtWpVpUH NLMHO|OW WHUOHW DGRWWViJDL
D WiUR]RWW Yt] iOWDO HOERUtWRWW WHUOHW pUWpNH
D GRPERU]DWL pV WDODMYLV]RQ\RN
D JHROyJLDL YLV]RQ\RN
+D D KLGUROyJLDL pV D WHUOHWL DGRWWViJRN HJ\DUiQW PHJIHOHOHN FVDN
DNNRU OpWHVtWKHW WiUR]y
$ YpV]WiUR]yN YpGHOPL FpO~ WiUR]yWHUHN DPHO\HNQHN HOHPL
PH]JD]GDViJL KDV]QRVtWiVD OHKHWVpJHV GH HO|QWpVUH NLMHO|OW WpU
DKRYD D] iUYt] FV~FVKR]DPiW WHUHOLN KD WHOHSOpVW YHV]pO\H]WHW D
OHYRQXOy iUYt]
9t]UDM]L DGDWRN PpUpVH pV IHOGROJR]iVD
9t]PpUpVWDQQDN KLGURPHWULD QHYH]]N D YL]HN MHOOHP] PHQQ\LVp
JHLQHN PpUpVpYHO IRJODONR]y WXGRPiQ\W $ KLGURPHWULD N|UpEH WDUWR]QDN
D Yt]iOOiV Yt]VHEHVVpJ Yt]KR]DPPpUpVHN PHOOHWW D YL]HW V]iOOtWy
PHGHU QDJ\ViJiUD DODNMiUD D Yt] iOWDO V]iOOtWRWW KRUGDOpN
PHQQ\LVpJpUH pV PLQVpJpUH YRQDWNR]y PpUpVHN LV $ KLGURPHWULDL
DGDWRN |VV]HJ\&MWpVpYHO UHQGV]HUH]pVpYHO IHOGROJR]iViYDO pV
N|]]pWpWHOpYHO D Yt]UDM] KLGURJUiILD IRJODONR]LN
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
9t]iOOiV PpUpV
$ Yt]iOOiV PpUpVpUH D Yt]PpUFH V]ROJiO $ Yt]PpUFH WHOHStWpVHNRU PHJ
NHOO KDWiUR]QL D Yt]PpUFH QXOOD SRQWMiQDN DEV]RO~W WHQJHUV]LQW
IHOHWWL PDJDVViJiW /HKHWOHJ ~J\ YiODV]WMiN PHJ D SRQW KHO\pW
KRJ\ D Yt]IRO\iVRQ DGGLJ WDSDV]WDOW OHJNLVHEE Yt]iOOiVQiO DODFVRQ\DEE
V]LQWUH NHUOM|Q $ MyO WHOHStWHWW Yt]PpUFpQ D OHJNLVHEE Yt]iOOiVW LV SR]LWtY
V]iPPDO WXGMXN HNNRU PHJDGQL
$ Yt]iOOiV D Yt]IRO\iV YDJ\ iOOyYt] Yt]V]LQWMpQHN PDJDVViJD D
Yt]PpUFH V]HOYpQ\pEHQ D Yt]PpUFH SRQWMiWyO PpUYH
$ Yt]iOOiVW QH WpYHVV]N |VV]H D Yt]PpO\VpJJHO
$ Yt]PpO\VpJ D Yt]V]LQW pV D PHGHUIHQpN N|]|WWL WiYROViJ FP DPL D
NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\ NO|QE|] KHO\HLQ D]RQRV LGSRQWEDQ LV PiV pV PiV
PtJ D Yt]iOOiV D V]HOYpQ\ PLQGHQ KHO\pQ D]RQRV LGEHQ HJ\ pUWpN $
Yt]PpUFH WHOHStWpVH XWiQ D PpUFpW PHJERO\JDWQL iWKHO\H]QL QHP
V]DEDG PHUW D] ~M KHO\HQ PpUW Yt]iOOiVpUWpNHN SUREOpPiW RNR]QDN D
UpJL DGDWVRUKR] YDOy LOOHV]WpVNRU
$ QHP UHJLV]WUiOy Yt]PpUFpN IDMWiL
/DSYt]PpUFpN
$ ODSYt]PpUFH FPHV EHRV]WiVRNNDO HOOiWRWW iOWDOiEDQ ]RPiQFR]RWW
NLYLWHOEHQ |QW|WWYDVEyO NpV]OW OHPH] $ Yt]PpUFH EHRV]WiViW GP
PH]NUH FVRSRUWRVtWMiN $] HJ\HV GP pUWpNHN V]iPMHJ\HL D GP
PH]EHQ WDOiOKDWyN $ FHQWLPpWHUHQNpQWL IHNHWHIHKpU EHRV]WiV SHGLJ
GHFLPpWHUHQNpQW ROGDOW YiOW iEUD
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
iEUD
/DSYt]PpUFH
(]HNHW D ODSYt]PpUFpNHW IJJOHJHV SDUWIDODNUD KtGSLOOpUHNUH YDJ\
NO|Q HUUH D FpOUD D Yt]EH WHOHStWHWW YDVEHWRQ DFpO YDJ\ IDF|O|SUH
HUVtWLN $] LO\HQ PyGRQ IJJOHJHVHQ WHOHStWHWW ODSYt]PpUFpNHW iOOy
Yt]PpUFpQHN LV QHYH]LN
(OIRUGXOKDW KRJ\ D Yt]PpUFHV]HOYpQ\EHQ D Yt]IRO\iVQDN D N|]pSYt]L
PHGHU PHOOHWW V]pOHV KXOOiPWHUH LV YDQ $] LO\HQ PpUFHV]HOYpQ\EHQ W|EE
Yt]PpUFH WDJRW LV HOKHO\H]QHN NO|Q HJ\HWHJ\HW D NLV pV N|]pSYL]HN
QHN YDODPLQW QDJ\YL]HNQHN $] LO\HQ PyGRQ D PpUFHV]HOYpQ\ W|EE
KHO\pUH LV WHOHStWHWW Yt]PpUFpW RV]WRWW Yt]PpUFpQHN QHYH]]N $]
RV]WRWW Yt]PpUFH YDODPHQQ\L WDJMiQDN SRQWMiW D]RQRV PDJDVViJEDQ
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
NHOO HOKHO\H]QL $] iOOy Yt]PpUFpN WDUWyV]HUNH]HWH ]DYDUKDWMD D Yt] pV
KRUGDOpNPR]JiVW H]pUW J\DNUDQ FpOV]HU&EE D Up]V&VHQ NLNpS]HWW
SDUWUD PHJIHOHO DOpStWPpQ\UH U|J]tWHQL D Yt]PpUFHODSRW $ Up]V&EHQ
HOKHO\H]HWW ODS Yt]PpUFpNHW IHNY Yt]PpUFpQHN QHYH]]N $ IHNY
Yt]PpUFpQ QHP FP KRVV]~ViJ~ HJ\ EHRV]WiV KDQHP D
Up]V&KDMOiVWyO IJJHQ YiOWR]y GH PLQGLJ DNNRUD KRJ\ FP
Yt]iOOiVYiOWR]iVW PXWDVVRQ (PLDWW D ODSRV Up]V&Q HOKHO\H]HWW ODSRNRQ
QDJ\REE HJ\ EHRV]WiV PLQW D PHUHGHN Up]V&UH WHOHStWHWW Yt]PpUFpNHQ
$ QHP UHJLV]WUiOy Yt]PpUFpN PiVLN PHJROGiVL PyGMD KRJ\ D
Yt]IRO\iV IHOHWW YDODPLO\HQ V]HUNH]HWHQ HOKHO\H]HWW KX]DOUD HJ\ V~O\W
IJJHV]WHQHN IHO $ KX]DOW NLVPpUHW& NiEHOGREUD FVDYDUMiN pV D
NiEHOGRE IRUGXODWDLQDN V]iPiYDO PpULN D] LVPHUW PDJDVViJ~ V]LQW pV
D Yt]IHOV]tQ N|]|WWL PDJDVViJNO|QEVpJHW $QQDN MHO]pVpUH KRJ\ D
KX]DO YpJpQ OyJy V~O\ YL]HW pUW HOHNWURPRV MHO]OiPSiW YDJ\
KDQJMHO]pVW EHUUHJW DONDOPD]QDN
$ V~OO\DO HOOiWRWW KX]DO KHO\HWW HJ\ EHRV]WiVVDO HOOiWRWW SiOFD YDJ\
V]DODJ LV DONDOPD]KDWy D Yt]IHOV]tQLJ WHUMHG IJJOHJHV WiYROViJ
PpUpVpUH
5HJLV]WUiOy UDM]ROy Yt]PpUFH
$ UDM]ROy P&V]HUW D PpUpVL V]HOYpQ\EHQ D SDUWRQ OpY DNQiUD pStWHWW
P&V]HUKi]EDQ KHO\H]LN HO $] DNQiW D Yt]IRO\iVVDO HJ\ N|]HO Yt]V]LQWHV
FV N|WL |VV]H DPL EL]WRVtWMD KRJ\ D] DNQiEDQ D Yt]iOOiV D PpUHQG Yt]
V]LQWMpYHO D]RQRV OHJ\HQ $ Yt]iOOiV YiOWR]iVW ~V]y pU]pNHOL DPLQHN D
PR]JiViW HOOHQV~OO\DO HOOiWRWW KX]DO YDJ\ SHUIRUiOW V]DODJ WRYiEEtWMD
iEUD $ QDJ\ Yt]V]LQWLQJDGR]iVRNDW IRJDVNHUpNiWWpWHOHNNHO
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
DUiQ\EDQ D EHiOOtWiVWyO IJJHQ D P&V]HU NLFVLQ\tWL tJ\
D] tUyV]HUNH]HW D] iWWpWHOHNQHN PHJIHOHO KRVV]~ViJ~ MHOHW UDM]RO D]
pV]OHOODSUD 3O iWWpWHOQpO HJ\ P Yt]V]LQWHPHONHGpVW RNR]y
iUKXOOiP NpSH D] pV]OHOODSRQ FP OHV] $] pV]OHOODSRW HJ\
yUDV]HUNH]HWWHO IRUJDWRWW KHQJHU SDOiVWMiUD V]HUHOMN $] yUDV]HUNH]HWWO
IJJHQ D] pV]OHOODSRW QDSRQWD YDJ\ KHWHQWH NHOO FVHUpOQL $
FVHUpOHQG V]DODJUD IHO NHOO tUQL D Yt]PpU iOORPiV QHYpW D GiWXPRW pV
D V]DODJFVHUH LGSRQWMiEDQ pV]OHOW Yt]iOOiVW
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
iEUD
5HJLV]WUiOy UDM]ROy Yt]PpUFH
$ UDM]ROyP&V]HU P&N|GpVpW DNDGiO\R]]D KD D P&V]HUDNQiW D
Yt]IRO\iVVDO |VV]HN|W FV IHOLV]DSROyGLN $] |VV]HN|W FVV]NVpJ
V]HULQWL LV]DSPHQWHVtWpVpUO IRO\DPDWRVDQ JRQGRVNRGQL NHOO $]
LVPHUWHWHWW P&V]HUWtSXVRQ NtYO PiV UDM]ROy Yt]PpUFHV]HUNH]HWHW LV
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
NpV]tWHQHN $ IRJDVNHUpNiWWpWHO KHO\HWW FVLJDVRURV PHJROGiVW LV
DONDOPD]QDN $] LVPHUWHWHWW P&V]HUWtSXVRQ NtYO PiV UDM]ROy Yt]PpUFH
V]HUNH]HWHW LV NpV]tWHQHN $ IRJDVNHUpN iWWpWHO KHO\HWW FVLJDVRURV
PHJROGiVW LV DONDOPD]QDN .pV]O RO\DQ P&V]HU LV DPHO\QpO D]
yUDV]HUNH]HW QHP RO\DQ QDJ\ KHQJHUW KDMW PHJ DPLQHN D SDOiVWMiYDO
PHJHJ\H] QDJ\ViJ~ D] pV]OHOODS KDQHP FVXSiQ HJ\ SDStUV]DODJRW
WHNHU IHO DPLQHN D KRVV]D DNNRUD KRJ\ HJ\ KyQDSQiO LV QDJ\REE OHKHW
D V]DODJFVHUpOpVL LG
$ Yt]V]LQW YiOWR]iV PHFKDQLNXV pU]pNHOpVpQ NtYO D UDM]ROy Yt]PpUFpNHW
HOHNWURPRV UHQGV]HU LV P&N|GWHWKHWL
$ Yt]iOOiVpV]OHOpVHN J\DNRULViJD
$ Yt]iOOiV IHOMHJ\]pVpQHN J\DNRULViJiW D Yt]IRO\iV YDJ\ Wy Yt]MiUiVD
WRYiEEi D] DGDWJ\&MWpV FpOMD V]DEMD PHJ +D J\DNRUODWLODJ IRO\WRQRV
Yt]iOOiVpV]OHOpVUH YDQ V]NVpJ D QDSL NpWV]HUL OHROYDViV iUYL]HN LGHMpQ
WRYiEE V&UtWYH D OHJW|EE Yt]IRO\iV HVHWpEHQ HOpJVpJHV 2O\DQ
KHO\HNHQ DKRO D Yt]iOOiV KLUWHOHQ LQJDGR]LN UDM]ROy Yt]PpUFH IHOiOOtWiVD
DMiQODWRV $] iUYt]HOUHMHO] UHQGV]HU DNNRU DODSXOKDW QHPUHJLV]WUiOy
Yt]PpUFpNHQ KD YDQ RO\DQ V]HPpO\ DNL NHOO J\DNRULViJJDO OHROYDVVD
pV MHOHQWL D Yt]iOOiVRNDW 7DYDN pV WiUR]yN HVHWpEHQ D WiUR]RWW
Yt]PHQQ\LVpJ PHJYiOWR]iViQDN V]iPtWiViKR] iWODJEDQ HOHJHQG KD
Yt]iOOiVDLNDW QDSRQWD HJ\V]HU pV]OHOLN $] HOHNWURQLNXV DGDWU|J]tWpV
QHP FVDN D Yt]PpUFH KHO\pQ ROGKDWy PHJ KDQHP PHJIHOHO
MHOWRYiEEtWy VHJtWVpJpYHO NiEHOHQ YDJ\ UiGLyQ QDJ\REE WiYROViJUD LV
iWYLKHW $ WiYMHO] EHUHQGH]pVHN D Yt]V]LQW YiOWR]iViW pU]pNHOLN PDMG
D] pU]pNHOW LQIRUPiFLyW HOHNWURPRV MHOOp DODNtWMiN pV H]W D MHOHW
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
WRYiEEtWMiN D N|]SRQWL NLMHO] pV IHOGROJR]y EHUHQGH]pVEH $ IHOGROJR]y
EHUHQGH]pV D] pU]pNHO HOHNWURPRV MHOHW YDODPLO\HQ YL]XiOLVDQ
pU]pNHOKHW MHOOp SpOGiXO NLMHO]HWW V]iPPi YDJ\ HJ\ PXWDWy
PR]JiViYi DODNtWMD iW .RUV]HU& UHQGV]HUHNQpO D N|]SRQWED EHpUNH]
DGDWRW QHP FVDN IHOMHJ\]LN D P&V]HUHN KDQHP D N|]SRQW V]iPtWyJpSH
D MHOHN IRUPiMiEDQ EHpUNH] LQIRUPiFLyNDW IHOGROJR]]D pV pUWpNHOL LV
$XWRPDWL]iOW UHQGV]HUHNQpO D V]iPtWyJpS QHP FVDN IHOGROJR] pV
pUWpNHO KDQHP WiYYH]pUOpVVHO P&N|GWHWL LV D Yt]V]LQWV]DEiO\R]y
P&YHNHW SO ]VLOLSHNHW $] DXWRPDWL]iOW UHQGV]HUHN NLpStWpVpQHN RWW
YDQ MHOHQWVpJH DKRO D KHYHV Yt]MiUiV SLOODQDWQ\L KHO\]HWpKH]
DONDOPD]NRGy ERQ\ROXOW pV |VV]HWHWW WHYpNHQ\VpJHW LJpQ\O
]HPHOWHWpVUH YDQ V]NVpJ ,O\HQHN SpOGiXO D QDJ\ QHP]HWJD]GDViJL
pUWpNHW MHOHQW W|EE HJ\VpJEO iOOy WiUR]yUHQGV]HUHN
9t]KR]DPPpUpVL PyGRN
$ Yt]KR]DP D YL]VJiOW NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\EHQ LGHJ\VpJ DODWW iWIRO\y
Yt]PHQQ\LVpJ
-HOH 4
0pUWpNHJ\VpJH
P
V
O
V
.|]YHWHWW Yt]KR]DPPpUpVL PyGRN N|]p WDUWR]QDN D]RN D PyGV]HUHN
DKRO D Yt]KR]DPRW D
4 Y
N
$
|VV]HIJJpVVHO V]iPtWMXN D N|]pSVHEHVVpJ Y
N
pV D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\
WHUOHWpQHN $ PHJKDWiUR]iVD XWiQ
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
.|]YHWOHQ Yt]KR]DPPpUpVL PyGRN N|]p D]RN D PyGV]HUHN WDUWR]QDN
DKRO D Yt]KR]DP PHJKDWiUR]iViKR] QHP V]NVpJHV D V]HOYpQ\WHUOHW
pV D V]HOYpQ\N|]pSVHEHVVpJ NO|QNO|Q W|UWpQ PpUpVH
.|]YHWOHQ Yt]KR]DPPpUpVL PyGRN LVPHUWHWpVH
$ N|E|]pV D Yt]KR]DP OHJHJ\V]HU&EE PpUpVpQHN PyGMD 1pKiQ\ OV
QDJ\ViJ~ Yt]KR]DP PpUpVpUH DONDOPDV DPHQQ\LEHQ D PpUHQG Yt]
HJ\ Yt]VXJiUED |VV]HIRJKDWy .|E|]pV VRUiQ PpUQL NHOO HJ\
PpUHGpQ\EH IRO\y Yt] PHQQ\LVpJpW 9 pV PpUQL NHOO D EH|POpV
LGWDUWDPiW W $ Yt]KR]DPRW PHJNDSMXN KD D PpUHGpQ\EH IRO\W Yt]
PHQQ\LVpJpW HORV]WMXN D] HGpQ\EH |POpV LGWDUWDPiYDO
Q Vt
= OV
$ PpUpV VRUiQ J\HOQL NHOO DUUD KRJ\ D J\&MWHGpQ\W HJ\HWOHQ
PR]GXODWWDO KHO\H]]N HO D Yt]VXJiU DOi LOOHWYH YHJ\N HO RQQDQ pV
H]]HO HJ\LGEHQ LQGtWVXN LOOHWYH iOOtWVXN PHJ D] LGPpUpVUH KDV]QiOW
VWRSSHUyUiW $ J\&MWHGpQ\EHQ OpY YL]HW NDOLEUiOW PpUHGpQQ\HO
SRQWRVDQ OH NHOO PpUQL 2O\DQ QDJ\ViJ~ J\&MWHGpQ\W DONDOPD]]XQN
KRJ\ D PpUpV OHJDOiEE PiVRGSHUFLJ WDUWVRQ PHUW HQQpO U|YLGHEE
LG HVHWpQ D] LGPpUpVQN YDOyV]tQ&OHJ QHP OHV] NHOO SRQWRVViJ~
$ N|E|]pVW OHJDOiEE KiURPV]RU PHJ NHOO LVPpWHOQL +D D PpUpVL
HUHGPpQ\HN N|]|WWL HOWpUpV QiO NLVHEE ~J\ D PpUpVHN iWODJD DGMD D
NHUHVHWW Yt]KR]DPRW QiO QDJ\REE HOWpUpVHN HVHWpQ D PpUpV VRUiQ
KLEiW N|YHWWQN HO H]pUW D PpUpVHNHW PHJ NHOO LVPpWHOQL
$ N|E|]pV HOVVRUEDQ NXWDN pV IRUUiVRN Yt]KR]DPiQDN PpUpVpUH
DONDOPDV
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
9t]KR]DPPpUpV NLIRO\yQ\tOiVVDO HOOiWRWW PpUHGpQQ\HO
'DQDLGiV PpUpV
$ PpUHGpQ\ DOMiQ LVPHUW PpUHW& HVHWOHJ YiOWR]WDWKDWy NHUHV]W
PHWV]HW& NLIRO\yQ\tOiVRQ NHUHV]WO D] HGpQ\EH EHIRO\y Yt] IRO\DPDWRVDQ
NL LV WXG IRO\QL $GGLJ IRJ HPHONHGQL D Yt]V]LQW D] HGpQ\EHQ DPtJ D]
HGpQ\EO NLIRO\y Yt]KR]DP NLVHEE PLQW D] HGpQ\EH EHIRO\y Yt]KR]DP
+D D NpW Yt]KR]DP HJ\HQO DNNRU D] HGpQ\EHQ iOODQGyVXO D Yt]V]LQW pV
H]W D] HGpQ\ EHOV IDOiQ OpY PpUFpQ OH WXGMXN ROYDVQL $ Yt]KR]DPRW D
Q A g h= 2|VV]HIJJpVVHO V]iPtWKDWMXN NL
$ D NLIRO\yQ\tOiV NHUHV]WPHWV]HWpQHN WHUOHWH
K D PpUHGpQ\EHQ iOODQGyVXOW Yt]V]LQW PDJDVViJD
J D QHKp]VpJL J\RUVXOiV J PV
D Yt]KR]DPWpQ\H] DPL D NLIRO\yQ\tOiV NLDODNtWiViWyO IJJ GHHJ\QpO PLQGLJ NLVHEE V]iP $ PpUHGpQ\ KLWHOHVtWpVHNRU NHOO D pUWpNpW PHJKDWiUR]QL
+tJXOiVRV Yt]KR]DPPpUpV DONDOPD]iVD RO\DQ HVHWHNEHQ MDYDVROW
DPLNRU VHNpO\ D Yt]PpO\VpJ HVHWOHJ LJHQ QDJ\ D VHEHVVpJ YDJ\ SHGLJ
D UHQGNtYO HUV WXUEXOHQFLD PLDWW D KDJ\RPiQ\RV Yt]KR]DPPpUpVL
PyGV]HUHN QHP KDV]QiOKDWyN $ PpUpV HOYH D] KRJ\ YDODPLO\HQ LVPHUW
F
NRQFHQWUiFLyM~ Yt]EHQ KtJXOy ROGDWEyO HJ\HQOHWHVHQ T KR]DP~
ROGDWVXJDUDW HQJHGQHN D PHJPpUHQG Yt]IRO\iV DGDJROiVL
V]HOYpQ\pEH (J\ OHQWHEE IHNY RO\DQ V]HOYpQ\EHQ NHOO Yt]PLQWiW YHQQL
H]XWiQ DKRO D EHHQJHGHWW ROGDW PiU W|NpOHWHVHQ HONHYHUHGHWW
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ PLQWD F
NRQFHQWUiFLyMiQDN PHJKDWiUR]iVD XWiQ D Yt]KR]DP
NLV]iPtWKDWy D IHOtUW DQ\DJPpUOHJ VHJtWVpJpYHO
q c Q c = 1 2 HEEO D Yt]KR]DP
Q q cc
=
1
2
9t]KR]DPPpUpV PpUP&WiUJ\DNNDO
$ Yt]KR]DPPpU P&WiUJ\DN D PpUEXNyN pV D PpUFVDWRUQiN .LVHEE
Yt]KR]DPRN PpUpVpUH DONDOPDVDN D KRUGR]KDWy NLYLWHO& EHUHQGH]pVHN
$ QDJ\REE Yt]KR]DPRN PpUpVpUH FVDWRUQiNQiO SDWDNRNQiO IL[
NLpStWpV& PpUP&WiUJ\DNDW DONDOPD]QDN
0pUEXNyN RO\DQ EXNyN DPHO\HN Yt]KR]DPPpUpVUH DONDOPDVDN
%XNyNQDN QHYH]]N D V]DEDG IHOV]tQ& Yt]IRO\iV PHGUpEH NHUHV]WEH
EHpStWHWW RO\DQ V]LOiUG IDODW YDJ\ V]HUNH]HWHW DPHO\EHQ D Yt] FVDN
iWEXNiVVDO D EXNy NRURQiMiQ WXG iWMXWQL $ PpUEXNy NRURQiMD pOHV
V]pO& OHJ\HQ KRJ\ D] iWEXNy Yt]VXJiU QH WDSDGMRQ D EXNy DOYt]L
ROGDOiKR] pV V]DEDG iWEXNiV~ OHJ\HQ DPL D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\ D]
DOYt]V]LQW D EXNypOWO DQQ\LYDO DODFVRQ\DEEDQ KHO\H]NHGLN HO KRJ\ QHP
EHIRO\iVROMD D] iWEXNiVW
iEUD
.O|QE|] V]HOYpQ\& PpUEXNyN
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
$ iEUiQ NO|QE|] V]HOYpQ\& PpUEXNyN OiWKDWyN D %D]LQ E
3RQFHOHW F &LSROHWWL G 7KRPVRQIpOH EXNy
$ EXNyQ iWEXNy Yt]KR]DPRW EXNyNpSOHWWHO V]iPtWMXN NL $
EXNyNpSOHWEHQ D] iWEXNiV V]pOHVVpJH E D] iWEXNy Yt]VXJiU
PDJDVViJD K pV D Yt]KR]DPWpQ\H] V]HUHSHO $] iWEXNiVV]pOHVVpJH D PpUP&WiUJ\ PpUHWpEO DGyGyDQ LVPHUW D] iWEXNiV
PDJDVViJiQDN PpUpVH V]NVpJHV FVDN DPLW D IHOYt]L ROGDOUD WHOHStWHWW
Yt]PpUFpYHO WXGXQN PHJPpUQL
$ Yt]KR]DPWpQ\H]W D P&WiUJ\ KLWHOHVtWpVHNRU NHOO PHJKDWiUR]QLhJ\HOQL NHOO DUUD KRJ\ D NO|QE|] EXNyWtSXVRNKR] PiV pV PiV
EXNyNpSOHW WDUWR]LN
$ %D]LQ EXNy NpSOHWH
Q b g h= 0 666 2 3, $ 7KRPVRQ EXNy NpSOHWH
Q tg g h= 0 5332
2 5,
DKRO
D 7KRPVRQ EXNy Q\tOiVV]|JH
J
QHKp]VpJL J\RUVXOiV J PV
N|]HOtW pUWpNH J PV
0pUFVDWRUQiN
0&N|GpVN DODSHOYH D PpUFVDWRUQiN OHV]&NtWHWW V]HOYpQ\pEHQ URKDQy
Yt]PR]JiV DODNXO NL tJ\ D IHOYt]V]LQW IJJHWOHQ OHV] D] DOYt]WO $
PpUV]&NOHWHQ iWIRO\y Yt]KR]DP FVDN D NULWLNXV PpO\VpJ IJJYpQ\H
WRYiEEi D NULWLNXV PpO\VpJ pV D IHOV Yt]iOOiV N|]|WW NDSFVRODW YDQ
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
(OHJHQG WHKiW D IHOV Yt]iOOiV pV]OHOpVH D Yt]KR]DP PHJKDWiUR]i
ViKR] $] DOiEEL NpSOHWWHO WXGMXN D PpUFVDWRUQiQ iWIRO\y Yt]KR]DPRW
NLV]iPtWDQL
Q b g h= 2 3
DKRO
E D PpUFVDWRUQD V]pOHVVpJH D V]&NOHWEHQ
K D IHOV]tQL Yt]PpO\VpJ
D Yt]KR]DPWpQ\H]
$ PpUFVDWRUQiN DONDOPD]iVD NLV OHMWpV& Yt]IRO\iVRNRQ HOQ\|VHEE
PLQW D PpUEXNyN DONDOPD]iVD PHUW VRNNDO NLVHEE D PpUpVKH]
V]NVpJHV Yt]OpSFV tJ\ D] HOQ\WHOHQ YLVV]DGX]]DV]Wy KDWiV U|YLG
V]DNDV]RQ MHOHQWNH]LN pV D OHMWpVYHV]WHVpJ NLFVL $ OHJJ\DNUDEEDQ
DONDOPD]RWW PpUFVDWRUQD D 9HQWXUL FVDWRUQD pV D 3DUVKDOO FVDWRUQD
$ OHJNRUV]HU&EE Yt]KR]DPPpU EHUHQGH]pVHN DPHO\HNHW
Q\tOWIHOV]tQ& Yt]IRO\iVRNQiO pV FVDWRUQiNQiO LV OHKHW DONDOPD]QL D]
LQGXNFLyV pV D] XOWUDKDQJRV Yt]KR]DPPpUN
$] LQGXNFLyV Yt]KR]DPPpUNQpO D )DUDGD\IpOH W|UYpQ\W DONDOPD]WiN
D EHUHQGH]pV PHJDONRWyL 0iJQHVHV WpUEHQ iUDPOy IRO\DGpN HVHWpEHQ
KD D Yt] YH]HWNpSHVVpJH HJ\ KDWiUpUWpN I|O|WW YDQ D NHOHWNH]
HOHNWURPRV IHV]OWVpJ HOHNWUyGRN VHJtWVpJpYHO PpUKHW pV HEEO D
Yt]VHEHVVpJ LOOHWYH D Yt]KR]DP V]iPtWKDWy
$] XOWUDKDQJRV Yt]KR]DPPpU PpUpVL HOYH D] XOWUDKDQJ WHUMHGpVL
VHEHVVpJpQHN D] iUDPOy IRO\DGpNN|]HJEHQ W|UWpQ YiOWR]iViQ DODSXO
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
.|]YHWHWW Yt]KR]DPPpUpVL PyGRN
$V]HULQW FVRSRUWRVtWKDWyN KRJ\ D V]HOYpQ\ N|]pSVHEHVVpJHW Y
N
PLO\HQ PyGRQ KDWiUR]]XN PHJ
6HEHVVpJPpUpV ~V]yYDO
(]W D PyGV]HUW DNNRU DONDOPD]]XN DPLNRU
DNiU D QHP PHJIHOHO
VHEHVVpJHN YDJ\ PpO\VpJHN DNiU D OHEHJWHWHWW KRUGDOpN PLDWW
QLQFV OHKHWVpJQN VHEHVVpJPpU P&V]HUW KDV]QiOQL YDJ\ KD QDJ\RQ
U|YLG LG DODWW NHOO D Yt]KR]DPRW PHJKDWiUR]QL
$ NLYiODV]WRWW ~V]y OHKHW IHOV]tQL ~V]y YDJ\ ERW ~V]y $ IHOV]tQL ~V]y
Yt]EH PHUOpVL PpO\VpJH NLVHEE D Yt]PpO\VpJ HJ\QHJ\HGpQpO $ IHOV]tQL
~V]yN DONDOPD]iViW V]HOHV LGEHQ NHUOQL NHOO $ ERW~V]yN Yt] DODWWL
UpV]pQHN PpUHWH QDJ\REE PLQW D Yt]PpO\VpJ HJ\QHJ\HGH $ ERW
~V]yQDN QHP V]DEDG D PHGHUIHQpNKH] pUQLH
$ PpUpV YpJUHKDMWiVD VRUiQ NL NHOO MHO|OQL HJ\ W|EEpNHYpVEp D]RQRV
NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\& OHKHWOHJ HJ\HQHV PpUV]DNDV]W pV PHJ NHOO PpUQL D
KRVV]iW $ V]DNDV]RQ iWKDODGy ~V]y iWKDODGiVL LGHMpW W|EE
~V]WDWiV iWODJiEyO NHOO PHJKDWiUR]QL $] ~V]yW D NLMHO|OW V]DNDV] IHOHWW
NHOO D Yt]EH HQJHGQL KRJ\ IHOYHKHVVH D Yt]PR]JiV VHEHVVpJpW PLNRUUD
D NLMHO|OW V]HOYpQ\KH] pU pV HONH]GGLN D] LGPpUpV $ VHEHVVpJHW
PHJNDSMXN KD D PpUV]DNDV] KRVV]iW HORV]WMXN D] ~W PHJWpWHOpKH]
V]NVpJHV LGYHO +D IHOV]tQL ~V]yYDO PpUWQN DNNRU D NDSRWW
HUHGPpQ\ D IHOV]tQL VHEHVVpJ DPL QDJ\REE PLQW D NHUHVHWW
N|]pSVHEHVVpJ $ N|]pSVHEHVVpJ N|]HOtW pUWpNH D IHOV]tQL VHEHVVpJ
KiURPQHJ\HGH $] ~V]yYDO W|UWpQ VHEHVVpJPpUpV D SRQWDWODQViJD
PLDWW LQNiEE FVDN D Yt]KR]DP EHFVOpVpUH DONDOPDV PyGV]HU
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
6HEHVVpJPpUpV VHEHVVpJPpU P&V]HUUHO
(J\ DGRWW SRQWEDQ D Yt] VHEHVVpJpW iOWDOiEDQ ~J\ KDWiUR]]iN PHJ
KRJ\ PHJV]iPROMiN D VHEHVVpJPpU P&V]HU WHQJHO\pQHN IRUGXODWDLW
HJ\ U|YLG PpUW LGWDUWDP DODWW $ VHEHVVpJPpU P&V]HUW D] iUDPOy
Yt]EH YDJ\ U~GRQ YDJ\ KX]DORQ ERFViWMiN OH
$ VHEHVVpJPpU P&V]HUHNQHN NpW WtSXVD LVPHUHWHV
$] HJ\LN HVHWEHQ IJJOHJHV WHQJHO\& NDQDODV WtSXV~ IRUJyUpV]W D
PiVLN HVHWEHQ Yt]V]LQWHV WHQJHO\& YLWRUOiW DONDOPD]QDN 0LQGNpW WtSXV
HVHWpEHQ HJ\ NLEH NDSFVROy pULQWNH] DGMD D IRUJyUpV] IRUGXODWDLW MHO]
LPSXO]XVRNDW $ OHJJ\DNRULEE PHJROGiV HVHWpQ D P&V]HU
IRUGXODWRQNpQW FVHQJHWpVVHO MHOH] $] LGPpUpVW D P&V]HU NtYiQW
PpO\VpJEH W|UWpQW OHHUHV]WpVH XWiQ FVHQJHWpVQpO NH]GMN pV OHJDOiEE
PiVRGSHUF HOWHOWH XWiQ FVHQJHWpVQpO IHMH]]N EH $ FVHQJHWpVHN
V]iPiW K~VV]DO V]RUR]YD NDSMXN D VHEHVVpJPpU P&V]HU YLWRUOiMiQDN
IRUGXODWV]iPiW $ IRUGXODWV]iPRW HORV]WYD D PpUpV LGHMpYHO PHJNDSMXN
D] HJ\VpJQ\L LGUH HV IRUGXODWV]iPRW IRUGXODWPiVRGSHUF YDJ\
IRUGXODWSHUF PpUWpNHJ\VpJEHQ 0LQpO QDJ\REE D Yt] VHEHVVpJH DQQiO
QDJ\REE HJ\VpJQ\L LGUH HV IRUGXODWRW NHOO NDSQXQN 0LQGHQ
P&V]HUKH] WDUWR]LN HJ\ KLWHOHVtWpVL J|UEH JUDILNRQ DPLUO D
IRUGXODWSHUFKH] WDUWR]y VHEHVVpJHW PV PpUWpNHJ\VpJEHQ OH WXGMXN
ROYDVQL $ OHJNRUV]HU&EE P&V]HUHN EHpStWHWW LGPpUYHO pV GLJLWiOLV
NLMHO]YHO UHQGHONH]QHN DPLUO N|]YHWOHQO D PpUpVL SRQWEDQ OpY
HJ\VpJQ\L IRUGXODWV]iP HVHWOHJ VHEHVVpJ ROYDVKDWy OH 0LYHO D
NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\EHQ D Yt] VHEHVVpJH NO|QE|] KHO\HNHQ PiV pV PiV
H]pUW D VHEHVVpJHW W|EE KHO\HQ LV PHJ NHOO PpUQL $ NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\W
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
IJJpO\HNUH RV]WMiN pV PLQGHQ IJJpO\ N|]pSYRQDOiEDQ HJ\PiV DODWW
W|EE SRQWEDQ LV PpULN D VHEHVVpJHW $ IJJpO\HN NLRV]WiVD pV D
IJJpO\EHQ D PpUpVL SRQWRN V]iPD D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\ PpUHWHLWO pV D
PHJNtYiQW PpUpVL SRQWRVViJWyO IJJ $ V]HOYpQ\ Yt]KR]DPiW FpOV]HU&
~J\ PHJKDWiUR]QL KRJ\ IJJpO\HQNpQW IJJpO\ N|]pSVHEHVVpJHW
V]iPtWXQN pV D] tJ\ NDSRWW IJJpO\ Yt]KR]DPRNDW |VV]HJH]YH NDSMXN D
V]HOYpQ\ Yt]KR]DPiW
$] DOiEELDNEDQ LVPHUWHWMN D 0HWHRUROyJLDL 9LOiJV]HUYH]HW :02
DMiQOiViW D NO|QE|] iUDPOiVL YLV]RQ\RN N|]|WW W|UWpQ Yt]KR]DP
PpUpVQpO D PpUpVL SRQWRN IJJpO\EHQ W|UWpQ NLRV]WiViUD pV D IJJpO\
N|]pSVHEHVVpJ PHJKDWiUR]iViUD
(J\SRQWRV PyGV]HU $NNRU DONDOPD]]XN KD D Yt]PpO\VpJ PQpO
NLVHEE $ VHEHVVpJHW D PpO\VpJQHN D IHOV]tQWO V]iPtWRWW
V]RURViEDQ PpUMN pV H]W WHNLQWMN D IJJpO\ N|]pSVHEHVVpJpQHN
.pWSRQWRV PyGV]HU PQpO QDJ\REE Yt]PpO\VpJ pV V]DEiO\RV
VHEHVVpJ HORV]OiV HVHWpQ DONDOPD]]XN $ VHEHVVpJHW D Yt]PpO\VpJ
V]HUHVpEHQ pV V]RURViEDQ PpUMN $ NpW pUWpN iWODJD D IJJpO\
N|]pSVHEHVVpJH
+iURPSRQWRV PyGV]HU 1|YpQ\]HWWHO EHQWW PHGUHN HVHWpEHQ NHOO
DONDOPD]QL $ VHEHVVpJHW D PpO\VpJQHN D Yt]IHOV]tQWO V]iPtWRWW
V]|U|VpEHQ V]|U|VpEHQ pV V]RURViEDQ PpUMN ( KiURP
pUWpN V]iPWDQL iWODJiW WHNLQWMN D IJJpO\ N|]pSVHEHVVpJpQHN
gWSRQWRV PyGV]HU $NNRU DONDOPD]]XN DPLNRU D VHEHVVpJ IJJ
OHJHV HORV]OiVD QDJ\RQ V]HV]pO\HV $ VHEHVVpJHW N|]YHWOHQO D
Yt]IHOV]tQ DODWW Y
V
N|]YHWOHQO D PHGHUIHQpN I|O|WW Y YDODPLQW D
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
Yt]PpO\VpJQHN D IHOV]tQWO V]iPtWRWW V]HUHVpEHQ V]RURViEDQ
pV V]RURViEDQ PpUMN $ IJJpO\ N|]pSVHEHVVpJHW Y
N
D] DOiEEL
NpSOHWWHO V]iPtWMXN
Y Y Y Y Y YN V
= + + + +
$ PpUV]HOYpQ\ NLYiODV]WiVD
$ VHEHVVpJPpU V]iUQQ\DO W|UWpQ Yt]KR]DPPpUpVW FVyQDNUyO
NiEHOUO KtGUyO HVHWOHJ Yt]EHQ Ji]ROYD YpJH]]N
$ OHJSRQWRVDEE Yt]KR]DPPpUpVL HUHGPpQ\HNHW D N|YHWNH] WXODMGRQ
ViJRNNDO UHQGHONH] Yt]IRO\iVV]HOYpQ\HNEHQ NDSMXN
D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\ PHUOHJHV D IRO\iVLUiQ\UD
D SRQWEHOL VHEHVVpJHN PHJKDODGMiN D PV pUWpNHW
D PHGHU DODNMD V]DEiO\RV pV iOODQGy
D Yt]PpO\VpJ PHJKDODGMD D PW
D Yt] N|]pSYt]L PHGHUEHQ IRO\LN YDJ\LV QHP OpS W~O D SDUWpOHNHQ
QLQFVHQHN Yt]LQ|YpQ\HN
OWDOiEDQ QHP OHKHW RO\DQ V]HOYpQ\W WDOiOQL DPHO\ YDODPHQQ\L IHOVRUROW
N|YHWHOPpQ\W NLHOpJtWHQp $ OHJW|EE V]HOYpQ\EHQ PpJLV NLHOpJtWHQ
SRQWRV Yt]KR]DPPpUpV YpJH]KHW KD PHJIHOHO V]iP~ SRQWEDQ
PpUQN
0HGHUIHOYpWHOL PyGRN 9t]PpO\VpJ PpUpV
$ PHGHUIHOYpWHO RO\DQ I|OGPpUpVL IHODGDW DKRO D JHRGp]LDL PpUpVL
HOMiUiVRN PHOOHWW D Yt]PpO\VpJ PpUpVW LV PHJ NHOO ROGDQL$ PHGUHW D
KHO\V]tQUDM]RN PHOOHWW PLQW LVPHUHWHV NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\HNHQ pV KRVV]
V]HOYpQ\HNHQ iEUi]ROMXN $ NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\HN V]iUD] UpV]pW JHRGp]LDL
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
HV]N|]|NNHO V]LQWH]pVVHO PpULN PtJ D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\HN QHGYHV
UpV]pQHN IHOYpWHOpUH Yt]PpO\VpJ PpUpVW DONDOPD]QDN
9t]PpO\VpJPpUpVL PyGRN
$ Yt]PpO\VpJ D Yt]IHOV]tQ pV D PHGHU IJJOHJHV WiYROViJD $]
DONDOPD]RWW PpUpVL PyGV]HU D PpO\VpJWO IJJ
6]RQGi]iVVDO KDWiUR]]XN PHJ D Yt]PpO\VpJHW P PpO\VpJLJ KD D
VHEHVVpJ QHP W~O QDJ\ $ V]RQGDU~G GHFLPpWHU EHRV]WiV~ PpUU~G
DPL NpV]OKHW IiEyO YDJ\ N|QQ\&IpPEO $ IpP V]RQGDUXGDN W|EE
GDUDEEyO iOOQDN pV D NtYiQW KRVV]~ViJ~UD V]HUHOKHWN |VV]H ,V]DSRV
PHGHUIHQpN HVHWpQ D V]RQGDU~G DOVy YpJpUH LV]DSWiUFViW NHOO
IHOV]HUHOQL KRJ\ PpUpV N|]EHQ D U~G QH WXGMRQ D PHGHUDQ\DJED
EHV]~UyGQL $ V]RQGDU~GGDO YDOy PpO\VpJPpUpVW OHJJ\DNUDEEDQ DUUD
DONDOPDV Yt]LMiUP&EO YpJ]LN $PLNRU D V]RQGDU~GGDO D PpO\VpJPpUpV
PiU QHP OHKHWVpJHV D Yt]PpO\VpJHW PpUFVyQDNUD V]HUHOW FV|UOYHO
GUyWN|WpOHQ OHHUHV]WHWW V~OO\DO NHOO PpUQL $ PpO\VpJHW D FV|UOUO
OHWHNHUHG N|WpOHQ OpY MHO]pVHNEO YDJ\ D FV|UO GREMiQDN
IRUGXODWDLEyO OHKHW PHJiOODStWDQL hJ\HOQL NHOO DUUD KRJ\ PHJIHOHO
PpUHW& V~O\W DONDOPD]]XQN PHUW NLV V~O\ HVHWpQ D Yt] iUDPOiVD D V~O\W
pV D N|WHOHW D Yt]IRO\iV LUiQ\iED HOK~]]D pV tJ\ D IHUGH N|WpOHQ
QDJ\REE PpO\VpJHW pV]OHOQN +D D Yt]IRO\iV VHEHVVpJH PV DNNRU
NJ PV VHEHVVpJLJ NJ PV VHEHVVpJ HVHWpQ SHGLJ NJ
OHJ\HQ D V~O\ DPLW KDV]QiOXQN
$] XOWUDKDQJRV PpO\VpJPpU HFKRORW D OHJNRUV]HU&EE PpO\VpJPpU
HV]N|] $ P&V]HU XOWUDKDQJRW ERFViW NL pV D PHGHUIHQpNUO V]iUPD]y
YLVV]KDQJ YLVV]DWpUpVL LGHMpEO V]iPtWYD N|]YHWOHQO D Yt]PpO\VpJHW
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
PXWDWMD $ MHODGyW pV D] pV]OHOIHMHW D Yt] V]LQWMpUH NHOO OHHQJHGQL D
NLMHO] P&V]HUW SHGLJ D PpUFVyQDNEDQ HOKHO\H]QL $] XOWUDKDQJRV
PpO\VpJPpU N|]YHWOHQO UDM]ROy P&V]HUKH] LV NDSFVROKDWy $KKR]
KRJ\ D PpUW SRQWRNDW NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\EHQ iEUi]ROQL WXGMXN QHP FVDN D
PpO\VpJHW KDQHP D PpO\VpJ KHO\pW LV LVPHUQL NHOO D V]HOYpQ\EHQ $]
iEUi]RODQGy SRQW NpW NRRUGLQiWiMD D PpO\VpJ pV D] DODSYRQDOWyO PpUW
PHUOHJHV WiYROViJ $ PpO\VpJPpUpV KHO\pW ~J\ KDWiUR]]iN PHJ
KRJ\ D V]HOYpQ\EHQ NHUHV]WEHQ NLIHV]tWHQHN HJ\ N|WHOHW pV H]HQ D
V]HOYpQ\N|WpOHQ KDWiUR]]iN PHJ D PpO\VpJPpUpV KHO\pW $ IHOPpUW
NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\W PLOOLPpWHUSDStURQ iEUi]ROMiN PDMG DPHQQ\LEHQ
V]NVpJHV PHJKDWiUR]]iN D WHUOHWpW
$ V]DEiO\RV NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\ WHUOHWpW SO WUDSp]V]HOYpQ\& FVDWRUQD
NpSOHWWHO V]iPtWMXN NL
$ V]DEiO\WDODQ DODN~ NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\ WHUOHWpQHN PHJKDWiUR]iViUD
OHJJ\DNUDEEDQ D ViYRNUD ERQWiV PyGV]HUpW DONDOPD]]iN $ NHUHV]W
V]HOYpQ\W HJ\HQO V]pOHVVpJ& D ViYRNUD ERQWMiN $ ViYRN
N|]pSYRQDOiQDN V |VV]HJpW V]RUR]]iN D ViYV]pOHVVpJJHO pV
PHJNDSMiN D V]HOYpQ\ WHUOHWpW $
$ V
V
V
V
Q
D
$ PpUHWDUiQ\UD J\HOQL NHOO PHUW D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\HNHW J\DNUDQ
WRU]tWYD iEUi]ROMiN iEUD
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
iEUD
6]DEiO\WDODQ DODN~ NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\ WHUOHWpQHN PHJKDWiUR]iVD
+RUGDOpNPpUpV
$ Yt]IRO\iV D KRUGDOpNRW OHEHJWHWYH YDJ\ D PHGHUIHQpNHQ J|UJHWYH
V]iOOtWMD
$ OHEHJWHWHWW KRUGDOpN PpUpVH D] HJ\V]HU&EE IHODGDW $ OHEHJWHWHWW
KRUGDOpNPpUpVKH] D V]HOYpQ\ W|EE SRQWMiEDQ Yt]PLQWiW YHV]QHN
$ PLQWDYHY QHKH]pNNHO HOOiWRWW GXJyYDO OH]iUW SDODFN DPLQHN D
EHOVHMpEHQ SDUDIDJ|PE WDOiOKDWy $ PLQWDYHY SDODFNRW U~GUD YDJ\
N|WpOUH IJJHV]WYH D QHKH]pN VHJtWVpJpYHO D NtYiQW PLQWDYpWHOL KHO\UH
VOO\HV]WLN PDMG D OH]iUy GXJyW D UiV]HUHOW ]VLQHJJHO NLK~]]XN
D PLQWDYHY SDODFNEyO $ EHiUDPOy Yt] D SDUDIDJ|PE|W D SDODFN
PHJWHOpVHNRU EHO&OUO D SDODFN Q\tOiViKR] RGDV]RUtWMD tJ\ NLHPHOpV
N|]EHQ D IHOVEE Yt]UpWHJEO VHP KRUGDOpN VHP Yt] QHP NpSHV D
PLQWiKR] NHYHUHGQL $ V]HOYpQ\ NO|QE|] SRQWMDLEDQ J\&MW|WW
Yt]PLQWiNDW |VV]H|QWLN pV HQQHN D] |VV]H|QW|WW PLQWiQDN D
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
V]LOiUGDQ\DJWDUWDOPiW KDWiUR]]iN PHJ ~J\ KRJ\ OHStWpV XWiQ D
KRUGDOpNUyO D YL]HW OHV]tYMiN PDMG D QHGYHV KRUGDOpNRW NLV]iUtWMiN pV
OHPpULN $ OHEHJWHWHWW KRUGDOpN PHQQ\LVpJpW JP
PpUWpNHJ\VpJEHQ
DGMiN PHJ
$ J|UJHWHWW KRUGDOpN PpUpVH QHKp] IHODGDW $ J|UJHWHWW KRUGDOpN
PR]JiV VHEHVVpJH QHKH]HQ PpUKHW PLYHO D KRUGDOpN D PHGHU
IHQpNHQ EDUi]GiN KRPRNSDGRN DODNMiEDQ PR]RJ 1HKp] RO\DQ
NpV]OpNHW V]HUNHV]WHQL DPHO\ VLPiQ IHNV]LN D PHGHUIHQpNHQ DQpONO
KRJ\ D] iUDPOiVL YLV]RQ\RNDW YDJ\ D KRUGDOpN PR]JiViW QH ]DYDUQi
$] DONDOPD]RWW
J|UJHWHWW PLQWD YpWHOpUH DONDOPDV
KRUGDOpNIRJyN
KiURP I FVRSRUWED VRUROKDWyN NRViUV]HU& VHUSHQ\ DODN~ YDODPLQW
Q\RPiVNO|QEVpJ HOYpQ P&N|G KRUGDOpNIRJyN
$ NRViU WtSXV~ KRUGDOpNIRJy iOWDOiEDQ KiOyV DQ\DJEyO NpV]O Q\tOiVD
D IHOYL]L ROGDORQ YDQ $ Yt]KRUGDOpN NHYHUpN iWKDODG UDMWD $ KiOy
iWHQJHGL D YL]HW pV D OHEHJWHWHWW KRUGDOpNRW GH YLVV]DWDUWMD D J|UJHWHWW
DQ\DJRW
$ VHUSHQ\ WtSXV~ KRUGDOpNIRJyN NHUHV]WPHWV]HWNHW WHNLQWYH pN
DODN~DN J\ KHO\H]LN HO NHW KRJ\ D] pN pOH D] iUDPOiVVDO V]HPEHQ
iOOMRQ PHUW tJ\ D OHJNLVHEE D KRUGDOpNPR]JiVW ]DYDUy KDWiVXN
$ VHUSHQ\EHQ D PR]Jy DQ\DJ IHOIRJiViUD DONDOPDV WHUHON WDOiOKDWyN
$ Q\RPiVNO|QEVpJ HOYpQ P&N|G KRUGDOpNIRJyW ~J\ DODNtWMiN NL
KRJ\ D NLMiUDWQiO KLUWHOHQ Q\RPiVFV|NNHQpV iOOMRQ HO DPHO\ DONDOPDV
D PLQWDYHY RNR]WD HQHUJLDYHV]WHVpJHN OHJ\]pVpUH J\ EL]WRVtWKDWy
KRJ\ D EHOpSpVL VHEHVVpJ HJ\HQO OHJ\HQ D Yt]iUDPOiV VHEHVVpJpYHO
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
$ PLQWDYpWHO PyGMD
(J\HJ\ NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\EHQ iOWDOiEDQ PpUpVL SRQWQDN NHOO OHQQLH
$ KRUGDOpNIRJyW DGGLJ NHOO D PHGHUIHQpNHQ WDUWDQL DPtJ KDUPDGiLJ
PHJWHOLN KRUGDOpNNDO $ PpUpVHNHW NO|QE|] Yt]KR]DPRN LGHMpQ PHJ
NHOO LVPpWHOQL KRJ\ |VV]HIJJpVHNHW WDOiOMXQN D Yt]KR]DP pV D
J|UJHWHWW KRUGDOpNV]iOOtWiV N|]|WW $ KRUGDOpNIRJyEDQ |VV]HJ\&MW|WW
DQ\DJRW NLV]iUtWMiN pV PHJPpULN D V~O\iW +D D V]iUD] V~O\W RV]WMiN D
PpUpV LGWDUWDPiYDO pV D KRUGDOpNIRJy V]pOHVVpJpYHO D] DGRWW PpUpVL
SRQWUD YRQDWNR]y KRUGDOpNKR]DPRW NDSMiN (]HNHW D] pUWpNHNHW
YDODPHQQ\L PLQWDYpWHOL SRQW I|Op IHOUDNYD RO\DQ J|UEpW NDSXQN
DPHO\EO OHROYDVKDWy D WHOMHV NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\ KRUGDOpNKR]DPD
$ KRUGDOpNPR]JiV IRO\DPDWRV ILJ\HOpVpUH QDJ\ OHMWpV& IRO\yV]DNDV]RQ
KRUGDOpN]|UHM ILJ\HO EHUHQGH]pVHNHW LV OHKHW DONDOPD]QL $ KRUGD
OpN]|UHM Q|YHNV]LN KD D V]iOOtWRWW KRUGDOpN PHQQ\LVpJH Q $ KRU
GDOpNYiQGRUOiV N|YHWpVpUH DONDOPDV D UDGLRDNWtY L]RWySSDO MHO|OW
KRUGDOpNV]HPFVpN ~WMiQDN ILJ\HOpVpUH
$ KLGUROyJLDL DGDWRN IHOGROJR]iVD +LGURJUiILD
9t]iOOiVDGDWRN IHOGROJR]iVD
$ Yt]iOOiVDGDWRNDW RO\DQ JUDILNRQRNRQ GROJR]]iN IHO DPHO\HN Yt]V]LQWHV
WHQJHO\pQ D] LGW QDSEDQ D IJJOHJHV WHQJHO\pQ D Yt]iOOiVW FPEHQ
WQWHWLN IHO (] D IHOGROJR]iV DGMD D QDSL Yt]iOOiVRN iEUiMiW YDJ\ PiV
QpYHQ D Yt]iOOiV LGVRUW $ Yt]iOOiV LGVRUEyO PHJiOODStWKDWy KRJ\
PLNRU YROW iUDGy LOOHWYH DSDGy Yt]iOOiV 7HW]pVQHN QHYH]]N D] iUDGy
LGV]DNRN OHJQDJ\REE Yt]iOOiViW Y|OJ\HOpVQHN D] DSDGy LGV]DNRN
OHJNLVHEE Yt]iOOiVDLW
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ KDYL N|]pSYt]iOOiVW PHJNDSMXN KD D KyQDS PLQGHQ QDSMiQ pV]OHOW
Yt]iOOiVRNDW |VV]HDGMXN pV HORV]WMXN D KyQDS QDSMDLQDN V]iPiYDO
8J\DQtJ\ iOODStWMXN PHJ D] pY YDODPHQQ\L Yt]iOOiVpUWpNpEO D] pYL
N|]pSYt]iOOiVW $ KRVV]DEE LGV]DNRW IHOGROJR]y Yt]iOOiVVRU DGDWDLEyO
D MHOOHP] Yt]iOOiVRNDW NLHPHOMN pV H]HN YL]VJiODWiYDO N|YHWNH]WHWQN
D Yt]PpUFH V]HOYpQ\EHQ pV]OHOKHW Yt]iOOiVUD
$ OHJNLVHEE Yt] /.9 D PpUFpQ D] pV]OHOpV NH]GHWpWO HOIRUGXOW
OHJNLVHEE Yt]iOOiV $] pUWpNH PHOOHWW IHO NHOO WQWHWQL D] pV]OHOpV GiWXPiW
LV
$ NLVYt] .9 HJ\ YL]VJiOW LGV]DNRQ EHOO iOWDOiEDQ pY pV]OHOW
OHJNLVHEE Yt]iOOiV +D HJ\ Yt]PpUFpQ pY yWD W|UWpQLN Yt]iOOiV
pV]OHOpV DNNRU HQQHN D] DGDWVRUQDN pYHV LGV]DNRNDW YL]VJiOYD
GE NLVYL]H OHV] $ N|]HSHV NLVYt] ..9 KRVV]DEE LGV]DN NLVYL]HLQHN
V]iPWDQL N|]pSpUWpNH
$ N|]pSYt] .g9 D] pV]OHOpV NH]GHWpWO PpUW |VV]HV Yt]iOOiVDGDW
V]iPWDQL N|]pSpUWpNH
$] HO]HN V]HULQW pUWHOPH]KHW D OHJQDJ\REE Yt] /19 D QDJ\Yt]
19 pV D N|]HSHV QDJ\Yt] .19 IRJDOPD
9t]MiWpNQDN QHYH]]N D OHJQDJ\REE Yt] pV D OHJNLVHEE Yt]
NO|QEVpJpW +D HJ\ Yt]IRO\iV HJ\PiVW N|YHW Yt]PpUFH V]HOYpQ\HLQHN
Yt]MiWpNiW YL]VJiOMXN D]W WDSDV]WDOMXN KRJ\ D PHGHUYLV]RQ\RN NO|QE
VpJH PLDWW D Yt]PpUFH V]HOYpQ\HNEHQ PiVPiV Yt]MiWpN DODNXO NL H]pUW
D Yt]PpUFpNHQ OHROYDVRWW pUWpNHN N|]YHWOHQO QHP KDVRQOtWKDWyN |VV]H
$] |VV]HKDVRQOtWiV FVDN ~J\ W|UWpQKHW KRJ\ PLQGHQ Yt]iOOiVDGDW PHOOp
NLV]iPtWMXN D Yt]IRNRW DPL PiU |VV]HKDVRQOtWKDWy PXWDWy
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
$ Yt]IRN KLGURJUiG pUWpNpW ~J\ NDSMXN PHJ KRJ\ D QDSL Yt]iOOiVEyO
NLYRQMXN D PpUFpQ PpUW OHJNLVHEE Yt]iOOiVW pV RV]WMXN D Yt]MiWpNNDO +D
D NDSRWW HUHGPpQ\W V]RUR]]XN V]i]]DO D] HUHGPpQ\W EDQ NDSMXN
6]iPtWVXN NL D Yt]IRNRW KD D PDL Yt]iOOiV FP D Yt]PpUFpQ HGGLJ
PpUW OHJNLVHEE Yt]iOOiV FP D OHJQDJ\REE Yt]iOOiV FP
9t]IRN
1DSLYt]iOOiV /HJNLVHEEYt]iOOiV
/HJQDJ\REEYt]iOOiV /HJNLVHEEYt]iOOiV
Vzfok(%) =
328 51845 51
100
9t]IRN
9t]KR]DPDGDWRN IHOGROJR]iVD
$ Yt]IRO\iVRN OHJMHOOHP]EE DGDWD D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\EHQ HJ\VpJQ\L LG
DODWW iWIRO\y Yt]PHQQ\LVpJ D Yt]KR]DP $ Yt]KR]DP PpUpVH PLQW
LVPHUHWHV PXQND pV LGLJpQ\HV IHODGDW 0LYHO QHP PpUKHWQN PLQGHQ
QDS Yt]KR]DPRW H]pUW D PLQGHQQDSRV Yt]iOOiVpV]OHOpV DGDWDLEyO NHOO
N|YHWNH]WHWQL D YL]VJiOW V]HOYpQ\EHQ D Yt]KR]DP YiOWR]iVUD $ Yt]iOOiV
pV D Yt]KR]DP NDSFVRODWiW NO|QE|] Yt]iOOiVRNQiO YpJ]HWW Yt]KR]DP
PpUpVHN HUHGPpQ\HLEO V]HUNHV]WHWW Yt]KR]DPJ|UEpYHO iOODStWMXN
PHJ $ Yt]KR]DPJ|UEH WHKiW D Yt]iOOiVYt]KR]DP NDSFVRODW
IJJYpQ\J|UEpMH $ Yt]KR]DPJ|UEpW ~J\ V]HUNHV]WLN KRJ\ D Yt]KR]DP
PpUpVHNRU PHJiOODStWRWW Yt]iOOiVYt]KR]DP pUWpNSiURNDW RO\DQ
JUDILNRQRQ iEUi]ROMiN DPLQHN D Yt]V]LQWHV WHQJHO\pQ D Yt]KR]DP
IJJOHJHV WHQJHO\pQ SHGLJ D Yt]iOOiV V]HUHSHO D iEUD +D D
Yt]KR]DPJ|UEpW NO|QE|] LGV]DNRNEDQ PpUW NHOO V]iP~ DGDWEyO
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
V]HUNHV]WMN PHJILJ\HOKHWMN KRJ\ XJ\DQDEEDQ D NHUHV]WV]HOYpQ\EHQ
XJ\DQD]RQ Yt]iOOiVQiO NO|QE|] D Yt]IRO\iV Yt]KR]DPD $]W
WDSDV]WDOMXN KRJ\ iUDGy LGV]DNEDQ XJ\DQDQQiO D Yt]iOOiVQiO QDJ\REE
D Yt]KR]DP PLQW DSDGy LGV]DNEDQ (QQHN D] D PDJ\DUi]DWD KRJ\
iUDGiVNRU PHJQ D Yt]IHOV]tQ OHMWpVH H]pUW QDJ\REE OHV] D] iUDGy Yt]
VHEHVVpJH DPLQHN N|YHWNH]WpEHQ XJ\DQRO\DQ Yt]iOOiVQiO LV W|EE
YL]HW NpSHV V]iOOtWDQL D Yt]IRO\iV $SDGy LGV]DNEDQ D MHOHQVpJ IRUGtWYD
MiWV]yGLN OH +D iUDGy LOOHWYH DSDGy LGV]DNRNEDQ PpUW Yt]KR]DPRNEyO
V]HUNHV]WQN Yt]KR]DPJ|UEpW DNNRU D Yt]iOOiVYt]KR]DP NDSFVRODWRW
HJ\ ~J\QHYH]HWW iUYt]L KXURNJ|UEH IRJMD PHJDGQL E iEUD
D iEUD
9t]KR]DPJ|UEH
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
E iEUD
+XURNJ|UEH
$ IHQWLHN PLDWW D Yt]KR]DPJ|UEpW PLQGLJ D WHW]pVKH] YDJ\ D
Y|OJ\HOpVKH]
DSDGiV pV iUDGiV N|]|WW
NLDODNXOy Yt]iOOiVKR] WDUWR]y
Yt]KR]DP DGDWRN DODSMiQ NHOO V]HUNHV]WHQL
$ PpUFHNDSFVRODWL YRQDO
*\DNUDQ V]NVpJHV KRJ\ NpW V]RPV]pGRV HVHWOHJ QDJ\REE WiYROViJ
EDQ OpY Yt]PpUFH DGDWDLQDN |VV]HIJJpVHLW PHJiOODStWVXN $ IHODGDWRW
~J\ WXGMXN PHJROGDQL KRJ\ HJ\ GLDJUDPP IJJOHJHV WHQJHO\pUH
IHOUDNMXN D] HJ\LN Yt]PpUFpQ Yt]V]LQWHV WHQJHO\pUH SHGLJ D PiVLN
Yt]PpUFpQ XJ\DQD]RQ iUKXOOiPEyO pV]OHOW Yt]iOOiVDGDWRNDW J\ EL]WRVt
KDWy KRJ\ XJ\DQD]RQ iUKXOOiPEyO pV]OHOW |VV]HWDUWR]y SRQWSiURNDW
iEUi]ROMXQN KRJ\ PLQGLJ FVDN D] iUKXOOiP WHW] LOOHWYH D] DSDGiV Y|O
J\HO Yt]iOOiV pUWpNSiUMDLW iEUi]ROMXN $ PpUFHNDSFVRODWL YRQDO V]DEi
O\RV PHGHUV]HOYpQ\QpO HJ\HQHV V]DEiO\WDODQ V]HOYpQ\QpO J|UEH YRQDO
+,'52/*,$, $/$3,60(5(7(.
$ Yt]UDM]L DGDWRN N|]]pWpWHOH
$ QDSL Yt]UDM]L DGDWRN N|]]pWpWHOpQHN OHJHJ\V]HU&EE PyGMD D] KRJ\ D
KLGUROyJLDL V]ROJiODW iOWDO |VV]HiOOtWRWW QDSL Yt]UDM]L MHOHQWpVW D UiGLyEDQ
PLQGHQ QDS XJ\DQDEEDQ D] LGSRQWEDQ N|]OLN $ QDSL Yt]UDM]L MHOHQWpV
DGDWDLW D Yt]pStW D PH]JD]GDViJL Yt]JD]GiONRGiVVDO SO |QW|]pV
IRJODONR]y V]DNHPEHUHN YDODPLQW KDMy]KDWy YL]HN HVHWpQ D KDMy]iVL
V]DNHPEHUHN LV MyO WXGMiN KDV]QRVtWDQL $] DGDWRN U|YLG LGQ EHOO
W|UWpQ N|]]pWpWHOpQHN PiVLN J\DNRUL PyGMD D QDSL Yt]MiUiVL WpUNpS
DPLW D KLGUROyJLDL V]ROJiODW D] HOIL]HWNQHN QDSRQWD PHJNOG $ WpUNpS
D Yt]iOOiV DGDWRN PHOOHWW KLGURPHWHRUROyJLDL DGDWRNDW LV WDUWDOPD] SO
Yt]KPpUVpNOHW FVDSDGpN $ KLGUROyJLDL V]ROJiODW pYHQNpQW NLDGKDW
9t]UDM]L eYN|Q\YHW DPHO\EHQ N|]OL D WiUJ\pY Yt]UDM]L DGDWDLW D]
RUV]iJRV Yt]PpUFH V]HOYpQ\HNEHQ .|]OL WRYiEEi D FVDSDGpN D
SiUROJiV IRQWRVDEE DGDWDLW pV D WDODMYt]MiUiVL DGDWRNDW
+,'52/*,$ e6 +,'5$8/,.$
Recommended