View
216
Download
1
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
Page 1 of 15
An interview with Roger Tamraz -- A Man of History
By Anees Dayoub, Editor
Page 2 of 15
Arabian Business Magazine, Dubai, U.A.E.
Issue 08/2017
For more than two decades, particularly the years between 1965 and 1989 of the
last century, Roger Tamraz was one of the most prominent figures in the Lebanese
and Middle Eastern economic arenas.
This was particularly true after the collapse of Lebanon's Intra Bank and his
assumption of the management of its successor Intra Investment Company, which
Tamraz created and then ran as chief executive, a position he was assigned to by
former Lebanese president Amin Gemayel.
A controversial personality, Roger Tamraz for decades occupied the headlines of the
Lebanese, Middle Eastern and even American television and print news starting in
the 1960s. He receded from view more recently, however, and has avoided the
political and economic turbulence of Lebanon, concentrating instead on his private
oil and banking investments, especially his large oil company Tamoil, which operates
throughout Western Europe and the Arab countries.
Page 3 of 15
Mr. Tamraz , who appeared full of energy like a person coming back from the
depths of history, was interviewed by “Arabian Business” at its offices in Dubai.
Despite the many hypothetical news stories proclaiming his supposed legal problems
in more than one place in this world, the fact is that Tamraz is not involved in any
such problems anywhere, and travels with complete freedom in all of the world's
countries as he cares for his investments.
Tamraz, a Lebanese citizen, was born in Cairo in 1940, where he studied at a
renowned private school in the Egyptian capital. He then completed his studies at
the American University in Cairo (AUC) and later at Cambridge University in
England, where he received his certification. He later continued his studies at the
European Institute for Management Sciences (INSEAD) in France. He is fluent in
the three main languages of the Middle East: Arabic, English and French.
In 1966 he obtained his Masters of Business Administration Degree (MBA) from
Harvard Business School in Boston, and it was there where he got to know many of
the people who were later to play major roles in the governments and companies of
Europe and other parts of the world.
His first distinguished role was in 1960 when he worked as a key executive and later
as Chairman, Kidder Peabody Middle East, with the investment company “Kidder,
Peabody” in Wall Street. He was assigned the task of forming and leading a task
force to refloat the large Lebanese Intra Bank, which had run into liquidity problems
and had closed in late 1966. The Bank had been established in 1951 by Yousef
Page 4 of 15
Beidas, a Palestinian businessman who had later acquired the Lebanese nationality.
Intra Bank had established itself as the leading bank in Lebanon and the Middle
East, but poor management had eventually caused an acute liquidity shortage its
default.
As the Middle East representative of Kidder, Peabody Tamraz laid out a reflotation
plan under which the creditors received shares in the newly formed Intra Investment
Company as compensation for their lost deposits. The Lebanese, Kuwaiti, and Qatari
governments (which had lost the most money) were the lead investors in this
company, and Kidder Peabody, in the form of Mr. Tamraz, undertook a key
consultative role for the board of directors until 1973.
At that time, Tamraz left Intra Bank for larger business opportunities, and pursued
investment and banking activities in the Middle East, benefiting from his strong
relationships in both Arab and western countries. One of his most successful
undertakings in this stage was his 1973 creation and early management of SUMED,
a two hundred mile long oil pipeline between the Egyptian city of Suez and the
Mediterranean Sea that was built to bypass the Suez Canal, which had been closed
since the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. Another major Tamraz project at that time was the
building of the world's largest Methanol production plant in the Saudi city of Jubail.
In 1976 Tamraz moved to the United States where he bought a billion-dollar bank in
Detroit, Michigan. He managed and expanded the bank’s activities until 1983 when
Page 5 of 15
he sold his shares to finance the establishment of Tamoil Refining Company in
western Europe. At the same time, Tamraz bought a large hotel group that owned
three of the most prestigious hotels in Paris. In 1988, he announced his candidacy
for the presidency of the Lebanese Republic on the basis of a” Marshall Plan”
approach to rescue Lebanon, but the elections did not take place in that year and
Tamraz instead left Lebanon and invested abroad.
Tamraz settled in the former Soviet Republic of Turkmenistan as of 1991 and
established extremely strong relations with its president, and with the presidents of
neighboring countries. He implemented a number of projects in the financial, oil and
construction fields. Additionally, he built strong relations with the neighboring Soviet
Republics of Azerbaijan and Georgia.
At the start of our interview, I asked Mr. Tamraz:
You worked in politics and you were a presidential candidate in Lebanon in
1988; what do you have to say about that period?
Regretfully, this mistake was the biggest mistake I had made in my life…. I was still
young then, and I thought we would soon reach a peace agreement with the enemy
at the time. I had played an earlier role in the peace settlement between Anwar
Sadat and Israel, and later between Jordan and Israel. At that time I said: Let’s
Page 6 of 15
establish a similar peace arrangement between Lebanon and Israel and thus end the
Middle East Crisis. If the Lebanese citizen wants to eat bread, he’s got to have a
good economy and you will not have one if you have an enemy on your borders. I
always told my friends, it is better to have a bad peace than to have a good war, but
my mistake was that all of them did not want peace -- many wanted war. I used to
ask them, how many wars do you want? And which one is next?
Nobody estimates your fortune and neither do you; why?
It is simply that this issue has no significance at all for me. How will people benefit
and what will be my personal benefit from such information? I like doing impossible
tasks such as the pipeline I told you about; the project came into existence because
the partners wanted it to pass through the Ukraine and this did not happen, so we
had to find an alternative, which was a pipeline that passes through Russia and
Kazakhstan. For me, this constitutes an intellectual wealth and contribution that I
want people to remember me for.
Are you thinking of writing your biography after all this eventful history?
Different versions are now being written by three different persons: A lady in New
York, a Swiss journalist and the famous professor Dr. Kamal Deeb who will publish it
in Al Nahar Newspaper, since I do not have the time for writing it. Dr. Deeb wants to
write about my story with Intra Bank. He has started it with Yousef Beidas and wants
to conclude it with me. Yousef was not my friend but he knew my father and I only
met him once when I was still a young university student. As you know, I refloated
the bank he owned, Intra Bank, after he escaped abroad when the bank went
bankrupt. Dr. Deeb has already written about Intra Bank and how Beidas came from
Palestine and established himself in Lebanon until the troubles of 1966, at which
point the financial world became afraid of him and forced his resignation and exile.
The bank suffered for a whole year until I came to the scene and rescued it. At that
time, I was 27 years old.
How were your beginnings in the business, the finance and the banking
world?
Page 7 of 15
I inherited that from my father, Edward Tamraz, who went to Egypt in 1937, just
before the Second World War. There he met my mother, Margaret Dayoub, and
opened a shop for selling automotive spare parts. That time witnessed the arrival of
General Bernard Montgomery with his British army to confront the army of the
German General Erwin Rommel (The Desert Fox), at the Alamein Desert in
Egypt.The British brought large numbers of cars and trucks that used to break down
over and over because of the desert dust. At that beginning of the war, my father had
a large stock of spare parts, which he used to supply the British army with whatever
they needed throughout the war years 1940 till 1945. Montgomery thanked my
father earnestly for that and asked him once: "What can we do to repay you, Mr.
Tamraz? How can we serve your interests, Mr. Tamraz?” My father did not speak
good English, but he nevertheless he asked Montgomery to do only one thing: send
me to the English School of Cairo. I was only five years old at that time.
Montgomery initially told my father then that these schools were only open for the
sons of the British officers and not for Arabs, at which point my father replied, "Then
do nothing, thank you." Yet, Montgomery came back to my father after one hour and
informed him that I would be allowed to enter the English school and added that my
Page 8 of 15
blond hair and features were not Arab but rather extremely English. That, he said,
would help a lot.
The British school curriculum was very distinguished and I learned a lot from it. After
the English School I continued my university studies at the AUC and later at
Cambridge and Harvard Universities, where I met my colleague who became my
business partner too. We graduated in 1965, and at that time the Americans wanted
to enter the Arab Region. I wrote in my graduation dissertation that it was not logical
for oil prices to remain at the price level of one dollar per barrel. The oil companies
differed with me then and in 1973 the price went up to 12 dollars per barrel. as I had
predicted. Since that time I became a specialist in the oil and banking sector.
I always say that we, as Arabs, have huge oil reserves under the ground and that
when these are extracted; the reserves do not go away, but simply turn into a
second kind of reserves -- bank deposits. Now our bank deposits are shrinking.
There are hundreds of billions of Arab money deposits in the banks, particularly from
oil revenues, and each year the Arab oil producing countries lose tens of billions due
to current drops in oil prices. This means that these cash reserves might well dry up
within few years.
This is why I say that we need to sit with the Russians and the Iranians within the
coming five years and reach a new Sikes Picot agreement, but this one will be
concerned with oil.
Page 9 of 15
Since we are talking about oil, what is your perception on current oil prices?
Recently, I gave a lecture in China regarding this subject, followed by a very
interesting discussion. Everybody was saying that the prices of oil were low.
Economically speaking, I think they were right, however I say that oil is the only
commodity that should be considered as a weapon. I witnessed the year 1973 when
oil was used as such, and its prices went up from one dollar per barrel to 12 dollars
within a period of 5 months. Four people initiated this step: Mohamed Reza Pahlavi,
the Shah of Iran, Anwar Sadat, the Egyptian president, King Faisal bin Abdul-Aziz al
Saud, the King of Saudi Arabia, and Sheikh Kamal Adham, the head of the Saudi
Intelligence Services.
Page 10 of 15
I met Kamal Adham while he was still a student studying at Victoria College in Egypt.
He was my friend, and when he was appointed to his Intelligence position, I was still
a young man and helped him in his negotiations. We could not raise the price of oil
until the war broke out between Egypt and Syria on one side and Israel on the other.
Anwar Sadat was not able to enter the war without raising oil prices because he was
afraid that the Israelis would strike him hard in such a war. He had asked King Faisal
before whether Saudi Arabia would use its oil as a weapon in case Egypt entered a
war. King Faisal agreed, on the condition that Sadat would kick the Soviets out of
Egypt before declaring the war, and ally his country with the Americans, which Sadat
did.
Another important issue was the support that Sadat received from the Shah of Iran.
But why was this support so important? The reason was because if Saudi Arabia
would use oil as a weapon in 1973, the Americans would stand against Saudi Arabia
and Sadat, but the Americans would not be able to stand against the Shah of Iran
because of the strong relationships between the Shah and the President Richard
Nixon’s administration. During the Watergate scandal, Nixon asked the Shah to help
him in calming down the angry voices that were spreading widely throughout the
United States regarding this scandal. The Shah was the only one to give money to
Richard Nixon from outside the U.S. This is why when the Shah announced that he
would raise the oil prices, he received little objection from Nixon, while William (Bill)
Simon, the former minister of finance then in the United States and George Shultz
the minister of foreign affairs, together with Henry Kissinger stood against the price
rise. They wanted oil to stay at one dollar a barrel, but the Shah was in agreement
with us, and with Anwar Sadat, and also with Ashraf Marwan (an Egyptian business
man who was the husband of Mona, the daughter of the former Egyptian president
Gamal Abdul Nasser) to raise the oil prices.
Nowadays, I see the same situation, except that now we will not raise the oil prices
from one dollar to $12, but from $50 to $80 per barrel. How will that happen$ I say if
we put three people in a room and ask them to agree on distributing $3 trillion
equally among them, i.e.: each will receive $1 trillion over a period of 10 years, then
this will be similar to signing an agreement between Iran, Saudi Arabia and Russia to
raise oil prices from $50 to $80 per barrel, and gas prices from $6 to $9 or $10
Page 11 of 15
dollars per million BTU something that will be to the interest of the three countries
and their people.
Can you tell us about your investments in the Emirates?
We have no investments in the Emirates but we meet occasionally with our agents
from Saudi Arabia, Iran or Russia and we work in the oil and gas sectors. Our offices
were in Beirut before, then we moved to the United States and later we decided to
settle in Dubai where business men come from India, China, Iran and elsewhere to
strike their deals in a free atmosphere ideal for work and cooperation.
Don’t you have any business in the Gulf? We know you have a long experience
in hotels, aviation and banking businesses?
Yes, all those businesses are still going on, and we keep them all separate inside
companies that we call ”Single Purpose Vehicles” or SPVs. For instance, we worked
in Egypt with the “ Bank of America” and we established a bank there. During the
tenure of President Anwar Sadat, we invested in agriculture, where we bought 4,000
dunums (four million square meters) of land on the desert road between Cairo and
Alexandria, and we reclaimed it. We wanted to compete with the Israelis on selling
fruits and vegetables to Europe during winter months. We faced enormous problems
and problems in Egypt, however, especially regarding freedom to export. For
instance, we had to secure 27 separate signatures in order to be able to export
tomatoes through the airport, but by the time we could reach the final signature,
spoilage was so heavy that the crops could not be accepted in Europe and the
shipments were repeatedly lost.
Regarding oil and gas investments, do you buy gas or oil or do you just work
as dealers or mediators?
We do not produce oil and gas directly. We work only as mediators and transporters.
Some years ago, we used to have oil investments in the Caspian Sea. We went
there during the tenure of former president Mikhail Gorbachev, and invested in
onshore and offshore oil fields. We came to know the area very well and we brought
buyers and partners from India and China. We have made an agreement with the
Russians and others to build a gas pipeline from the Caspian Sea through Iran and
then to the Arabian Sea. In Turkey, we established a gas pipeline and we did the
Page 12 of 15
same in Egypt. As for the pipeline we agreed upon with the Russians, it passes
offshore to international waters where it is transformed into liquefied natural gas
(LNG). The pipeline itself first crosses Russian territory and then passes through
Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan until it reaches its designated transit area in Iran. This
project is now being completed and the gas is exported to all the countries located
along the pipeline route through our executive partners and China Power Company,
which is affiliated with the Chinese government.
This information gives people the right to name you one of the oil barons of
the world, isn’t that right?
I don’t know, really. Each of us is just doing his job.
How do you view your life journey in the past period, and do you regret
anything?
Of course everybody regrets something in his life. But life is not always an ascending
march. One will face ups and downs because his life journey does not follow a linear
line at all. I see that life starts with tears, because we humans are born with a cry in
our mouths but never a smile.
At the beginning you face difficulties. You strive and struggle here and there until you
discover that life is a mixture of successes and disappointments, and if you do not
learn how to tackle these disappointments, you will be a loser. We have to teach our
Page 13 of 15
children ethical values instead of giving them a Ferrari at the age of 18. I should refer
back to the British way where a child goes to Eton Boarding School (the most
famous British school in the past) when Winston Churchill wrote in his letters to his
parents that he used to cry in order to get the attention he needs. We all know what
a great man Winston Churchill ended up to be. We have to teach our children
discipline in addition to the following five things in this world: intelligence, creativity,
cool nerves needed for good behavior, a sense of appreciation for beautiful things
and lastly an ethical compass. If they get to have all this, they will turn up to be
distinguished and successful people.
How do you see the work with the governments? Did it change? Do you feel
relaxed working with them?
It depends on the kind of government official you are dealing with. I strongly believe
that the government official can instantly affect and influence the working team. I met
the former American president Bill Clinton. He is an unusual man who always seems
in a hurry and interferes in everything. He usually gives you 10 minutes to explain all
what you want, but as a graduate of Georgetown and Yale Universities, he likes
arguments. Again, it all depends on the government official or leader you are talking
to. Here in the Emirates, if you sit with His Excellency Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid
Al Maktoum, the Vice President of the Emirates and Ruler of Dubai, you will find that
he possesses three extraordinary traits.
First he is a military man who studied at Sandhurst, the renowned military college,
and he was the UAE Minister of Defense. This indicates that he is a very well
organized man. He is also a poet, meaning that he loves and appreciates beautiful
things. I went to him once with a paper regarding extending a gas pipeline to Jebel
Ali. At the end of the meeting, he asked me if I didn’t mind giving him this paper. I
answered: “with pleasure Your Excellency, but I have prepared this paper in a hurry
and it is not very well organized”. He said: “No problem with that”.
I mentioned this story about His Excellency to indicate how much he likes simplicity,
a trait that is well attached to his personality, and is generated from his love of
poetry. He is also a man who loves horses and any sport related to them. This
indicates that he is a man of adventures and initiatives with cool nerves that allow
him to act the best in everything.
Page 14 of 15
The Crown prince of the Emirates: His Excellency Sheikh Mohamed Bin Zayed Al
Nahyan is a man endowed with a great mentality. He is very modest and very
welcoming and he believes in intelligence, which is something very important. The
late Jordanian King Hussein Bin Talal (God bless his soul) used to hold the same
traits. He was so modest to an extent that he made you feel when you meet him that
you were the king and not him. Those modest leaders deserve appreciation, love
and admiration from all the people of the world and not only from their people. My
answer to your question is that it all depends on the leader himself and the space he
grants to you.
What do you advise young pioneers after all this experience?
I say to young men and women, to my children and to myself: “We have to keep
learning throughout all our life. Reading is the best blessing. We should not even
think that we might ever stop reading."
We do not see your name on the Rich People Lists, although you are one of
the biggest Arab business men?
No…. I don’t like this. I am more influenced by the British way. I had members from
the British Royal Family studying with me at Cambridge University where I used to
see students wearing shoes or jackets with holes in them. Look at Boris Johnson
and his poems. The worst thing for the British was to hear you talking about your
Rolex Watch that costs $200,000, or your expensive car. I do not want people to
respect me because I am wearing a Rolex or because of my car or my style of
clothes. I want them to respect me for my way of talking, or behaving. You might
consider this some kind of intellectual arrogance, but no. I want people to remember
my words and deeds, not my clothes and belongings.
Back to writing your memoirs! Will they write your memoirs according to their
point of view or will they sit with you to hear the details?
No…….Everyone writes his own point of view. The lady is writing it with Egypt in the
background and with the perspective of the fifties and the forties of the last century
during the reign of King Farouk, when Syrians and Lebanese used to come there to
study and later reached the American territories. My grandfather started in Turkey
Page 15 of 15
then he became a ruler at Sidon. My father went to Egypt for opportunities, while I
went to the United States.
The Swiss journalist studies the history of Tamoil Refinery near Geneva, which
controlled 20% of the Swiss market. He did not highlight this side before because
they wanted to close it after I sold it to the Libyans. It is considered the last refinery in
Switzerland and of great importance in national defense issues, especially
independence of jet and diesel fuel. He searched me on Google and called to tell
me that he wants to write about my life because he considers it a story worth writing.
I told him that I do not have time for that but he went on. On his side, Dr. Deeb
wanted also to write about my life from a Lebanese perspective.
At the end, Mr. Tamraz can never be spared from the hundreds of accusations
claiming he has been dealing with the Intelligence Services of several countries for a
long time. He seems resigned to that, saying "It comes with the territory".
This aspect of his life, however, was not on our agenda for the interview, in
accordance with his expressed desire to confine our discussion only to business
matters.
Arabian Business / Issue 08/2017
Recommended