Boards and Fundraising - afpwestchester.org€¦ · Boards and Fundraising October 13, 2016 1 ....

Boards and Fundraising

October 13, 2016 1

Agenda

I.Mo,va,ngboardinvolvementinfundraisingII.TheroleoftheBoardinfundraising

III.TheWorkIV.Fundraisingdynamics

October 13, 2016 2

I.Mo,va,on

•  Thefrequentlyaskedques,onis:Whywon’tmyboarddomoreaboutfundraising?

•  Posingtheprobleminthiswaycouldleadtotheiden,fica,onofac,vi,esthatcouldaddressspecificbarrierswhichwewillreviewlater,suchas:– Makingthecase– Trainingandroleplayexperience– Datamanagementsupport– Materials,etc. October 13, 2016 3

Therealques,on•  Thefirstques,onhoweverisnotwhytheydon’tfundraise,butrather:Whywouldanybodyeverwanttofundraise?

•  Theanswerthisques,onisfoundinac,velyengagingtheboardinitsfiduciaryandleadershiproles,especiallyinassuringthattheorganiza,onisadap,ngtochangesthatsurroundit.

•  Rubberstampsdon’tfundraise!

October 13, 2016 4

Thevalueproposi,onFirstly,wemustrecognizethatboardserviceisa

counterintui,veproposi,on1.ALend4ormoreboardmee,ngs.(Generallyinthe

eveningwhenyoumightratherberelaxing.)Themee,ngsmayormaynotbeinteres,ng

1.  WorkonacommiLeethatmayalsobemee,ngintheeveningorbyconferencecallwhenyouareworking

2.  Payfortheprivilege3.  Asabonus,yougettoaskyourfriendsforcontribu,ons

October 13, 2016 5

Therewardsthatmo,vateboardservice

1.Personalconcernfortheachievementofthemission;forthechangethattheorganiza,oncanmakeintheworld

2.Beingpartofaneffec,veandsuppor,vegroup

3.Havingapersonalimpactonabilityoftheorganiza,ontomakethatchange

October 13, 2016 6

1.Missionconnec,on1.Bringthemissionintoboardmee,ngsEveryboardagendashouldincludeanitemrela,ngtothemission,e.g.a

staffpresenta,onaboutexci,ngresults,aclientspeakingabouttheimpactontheirlife,aspeakerfromarelatedfield,etc.

2.BringboardmemberstothemissionBoardmembersshouldbeexpectedandenabledtovisitprogramsandto

speakwithstaffandclients3.ConnectboardmemberswithstakeholdersEverymee,ngwithastakeholder(funder,government,partneragency,

communitymee,ng,etc.)isanopportunitytoenableboardmemberstolearnaboutstakeholderinterests.(ThisalsosendsaveryvaluablemessagetothestakeholderaboutboardInvolvement.)

4.Lookforvolunteeropportuni,es

March 17, 2016 7

2.Beingpartofagoodgroup

January31,2013 October 13, 2016 8

A basic fact of human nature is that we spend our lives seeking to be part of good groups and that we perform at our best when we are part of such groups.

Coxswains call that took the American women from second to first in the Olympics: “You are the USA women’s eight!”

Think about a group that you valued.

•  How would you describe it?

• What were its qualities

StructuresThatMakeaBoardaGoodGroup

Crea,ngaculturethatencouragesthefullengagementofallmembersinvolves:• Agreednormsandexpecta,ons• Clearworkassignments• RespectforcommiLeework• Communica,onandtransparency• Opportuni,estoknoweachotherpersonallyandtodeveloppersonaltrust*

*PatrickLencioni.TheFiveDysfuncBonsofaTeam

Oct 13, 2016 9

Boardmee,ngs

•  Theagendafocusesondiscussion,decisionsandac,onplanning

•  Mee,ngsarenotusedtopresentinforma,onthatisnotneededfordecisionmaking

•  Boardmee,ngshouldengageboardmemberswithissuesofstrategicimportance

•  Thereisanopportunityforcollegiality•  Everymee,ngincludesamissionconnec,on•  Everymee,ngincludesanExecu,veSession

Oct 13, 2016 10

Expecta,ons

•  Highteamperformancedependsuponhavingsharedexpecta,onsandnorms.

•  Individualperformancedependsonbeingabletotrustthatotherswillperformaswell.

•  Explicitexpecta,onsandaregularprocesstoassessperformancewillalsoenabletheboardtobasemembershipdecisionsonperformanceratherthanpersonali,es

Oct 13, 2016 11

Expecta,ons•  Ican’tdomyjobifIdon’tknowwhatitis,andIwon’tdoitifI’mnotconfidentthatmyteammatesaredoingtheirsaswell

•  Coach’sadviceinTheBoysintheBoat:“Youwillbeyourbestwhenyoulearntotrustyourteammates”

•  Trustrequires,ataminimum,knowingoneanother•  Alsohelpfulwouldbesomeopportunityforpersonalhonesty,e.g.WhatIammostproudof,WhatIcouldhavedonebeLer

Oct 13, 2016 12

Boardmemberjobdescrip,on

•  Boardmee,ngaLendanceandprepara,on•  Policies(conflicts,confiden,ality,supportfordecisions)•  CommiLeepar,cipa,onandleadership•  Programvisits•  RespecbuldiscussionandrespectforcommiLee

recommenda,ons•  Rela,onshipwithstaff•  Personalcontribu,onsandfundraisingengagement

Oct 13, 2016 13

CollegialityTotheextentthatboardmembersknowoneanotherpersonally:

•  Theyaremorelikelytowanttocometoboardmee,ngsand

•  Maketheirbesteffortssothattheydonotdisappointtheirfriends

•  Engageinmutuallyrespecbuldiscussion•  Trustoneanother

Oct 13, 2016 14

TheChair:ChiefMoBvator

Hasthebigpicture.Clearabouttheworkthattheboardneedstoaccomplish

Engagesandsupportseachboardmemberandprovidesperformancefeedback

MaintainsaprocesstomanageandsupportthecommiLeework

Hasasuppor,vepartnershipwiththeExecu,veDirectorwhocanalsoprovidethechairwithfeedbackontheirperformance

October 13, 2016 15

3.Personalimpact

•  Developingpersonalresponsibilityfortheorganiza,onrequiresthattheboardbegivenresponsibility

•  Theboardmustbeanac,vepartnerinthedecisionsimportantforsustainabilityandmissionimpact

•  Theboardmustbefullyinformed:thegood,thebadandtheugly

Oct 13, 2016 16

Achievingmissiongoals

•  Theboardmustbeengagedintheprocessofsecnggoalsfortheorganiza,onandfortheboard

•  Iftheyarenot,wecannotexpecttheircommitmentto,andengagementit,theachievementofthosegoals

•  Rubberstampsdon’tfundraise!

October 13, 2016 17

PersonalrewardsVolunteerworkmaybemo,vatedbyadesireto“giveback”,butitismaintainedbytherewardsthatvolunteersobtain

•  Usingtheirabili,estomeetnewchallenges•  Usingtheirskillsinnewways•  Developingleadershipskills•  Havinganimpact•  Themoreweaskofvolunteers,thehappiertheyare.Itcommunicatesthattheyareimportant,neededandregardedascapable.

Oct 13, 2016 18

II.TheImportanceofBoardInvolvementinfundraising80%oftherevenueofthenonprofitsectorcomesfromindividualcontribu,ons

TheBoardmustdemonstrateitscommitmentBoardmemberswhocontributeandraisemoneyaremoreengagedwiththeorganiza,on

Boardmemberscanspeaktopeersaboutthepersonalmeaningtheorganiza,onhasforthem

19 October 13, 2016

III.TheWorK

•  Makingthecase•  Developingexpecta,ons•  Crea,ngthestructure

October 13, 2016 20

MakingtheCase

•  Theimportanceofindividualgiving$358billionincharitablegiksin201472%fromindividuals15%founda,ons8%bequests5%corpora,ons

October 13, 2016 21

Makingthecase

EstablishingtheneedtoyourboardDifferentcases1.FillingtheGap.Thedifferencebetweenthebudgetedcostsofeachprogramandanes,mateoftherealcosts.

•  Enhancement.Theprojectedcostofsomeshorttermprogramgrowthorenhancement

•  Vision:Thecostofachievingastrategicgoal

October 13, 2016 22

MakingthecaseTheregularfinancialreportshouldalsoenabletheboardto

understandhowprogramsarefinanced•  Whatthedirectcostsofeachprogram?•  Whataretheindirectcosts(infrastructure,marke,ng,

development,etc.)?•  Whatisthegapbetweentotalprogramcostanddirect

programsupport(grants,contracts,etc.)?•  Howisthatgapmadeup?•  Howhaverevenuesandexpenseschangedover,me?

October 13, 2016 23

Expecta,ons•  Afixed“giveorget”canbecomeaceilinginsteadofafloor

•  Everyboardmembermustgiveandgettothebestoftheirabilityincludinga“personallysignificant”gik

•  A“personallysignificant”gikisonethatyouwouldhavetothinkaboutbeforemaking

•  Asthisprocessdevelops,youmightwanttohavemembersoftheResourceDevelopmentcommiLeemakethe“ask”ofeachboardmember.(It’sgoodtrainingforallinvolved.)

•  Everyonecan,andmust,“ask”forsomethingOctober 13, 2016 24

IV.Fundraisingdynamics

• WhyDoPeopleGive?• Wherehaveyoucontributedinthepast?• Whatpromptedthegik?

25 October 13, 2016

Resistance

Whyarewereluctanttoask?•  Fearofrejec,on•  Fearofdamagingarela,onship•  Reciprocity

October 13, 2016 26

Enrollment

Therealworkofboardistobuildrela,onshipsthatcanleadtomajorgiks

•  Whataretheexperiencesthatconnectboardmemberswiththemissionoftheorganiza,on?

•  Whatexperiencesweresignificantinconnec,ngdonors?

•  Whatcantheorganiza,onandtheboarddotocreatemoreopportuni,esfortheseconnec,ons?

•  Enrollmentdiminishesthelikelihoodoftheexpecta,onofareciprocalgik

October 13, 2016 27

Aradicalproposi,on

•  Boardmembersshouldusetheir,meandenergyoncul,va,onofpoten,allysignificantdonorsratherthanonbroadbasedasks

•  Eachboardmembershouldfocusonfourcul,va,onsayear

•  Cul,va,onshouldbeasignificant,ifnotthemain,focusofevents

October 13, 2016 28

Overcomingresistance•  Themosteffec,vewaytoovercomethisfearistofindout

howfriendsreacttothemissionanditsimpactwhenyouarenotaskingformoney.

•  Developthehabitofintroducingtheorganiza,oninordinaryconversa,on

•  Learnhowtointroduceitbyaskingabouttheotherpersonsinterests.Thisistheessenceofsales:Donotintroduceaproductun,lyouhaveIden,fiedaneed.

•  Ac,vi,esthatstrengthenyourpersonalconnec,ontothemissionwillenablethis;learningabouttheorganiza,on,knowingthecaseforsupportandhavinggreatstoriestotell.

October 13, 2016 29

BoardPrac,ces•  Includinganitemonfundraisingateveryboardmee,ng•  Repor,ngonprogramvisitexperiences•  Crea,ngindividualcul,va,onandaskingplans•  Boardmemberssolici,ngcontribu,onsfromtheirpeers•  Crea,ngacul,va,ondatamanagementsystem•  Crea,ngaResourcedevelopmentCommiLeetomanagethe

boardengagement•  Providetrainingwithopportuni,estoprac,ce

October 13, 2016 30

Prac,ce

Helpfulac,vi,esthatarealsowarm-ups•  Iden,fyingprospects•  ALendingandinvi,nggueststoevents•  Targetednetworkingatevents•  SigningleLers•  Hostaparty•  Makethankyoucalls•  Recruitboardmembers•  Joinstaffonasolicita,onmee,ng

October 13, 2016 31

Training

Whattrainingmightbehelpful?•  DevelopmentCommiLeeleadershipandstructure•  Specialeventsplanning•  Useofemailandsocialmedia•  Secngupmee,ngs•  Havingamee,ng•  Introducingtheorganiza,onbyaskingques,ons•  Theartoftheask

October 13, 2016 32

Michael Davidson

Michael Davidson is a consultant specializing in nonprofit board development, management support, strategic planning, leadership transition, and executive coaching for nonprofit managers. He has over 20 years experience in nonprofit board and managerial leadership and has provided board training and retreat facilitation for more than 100 nonprofit organizations. He is the former Chair of Governance Matters, lead consultant for the BoardServe NYC program of the United Way of New York City and a member of the selection committee for the New York Community Trust Nonprofit Management Excellence Awards.

He has been a Peace Corps Volunteer, an Assistant Professor of Anthropology,

an Assistant District Attorney and an attorney in private practice. He holds a BS in mathematics from New York State University College on Long Island, a JD from Columbia Law School and an M. Ph. In Anthropology from Yale University.

   michael@boardcoach.com www.boardcoach.com (646) 418 9619

October 13, 2016 33