CBGP - SourceForgec-bgp.sourceforge.net/downloads/cbgp-1.pdfOutcome of BGP decision process does not...

Interdomain routing with BGP4Interdomain routing with BGP4

CBGPA new approach to BGP simulation

http://cbgp.info.ucl.ac.be/(1/2)

Bruno Quoitin(bqu@info.ucl.ac.be)

Université Catholique de LouvainComputer Science and Engineering Dept.

Day 1Day 1

Introduction & Internals

AgendaAgenda

IntroductionHow does it work ? Internals

topology representationsimulator's principleBGP details

How do we use it ? Scriptingsetting up the topologysetting up BGP routerspolicies

Hands on...

MotivationsMotivations

Main interests: Traffic Engineeringstudy effects of manipulating BGP attributesinvestigate changes in BGP protocol

RequirementsPolicy Routing (no protocol dynamics)Large timescale aspects (10ths of minutes,hours)Scalability & efficiency: topologies with same order of magnitude as Internet

MotivationsMotivations

Why a new simulator ?

Traditional simulators do not scaleJavasim/SSFNetPacketlevel simulationGranularity is too high

HistoryHistory

Development started in December 2002under the ATRIUM project and now continued under the TOTEM project.

First version (1.0.0)simplified BGP decision process (localpref, aspath, tiebreak)ASlevel: one router per AS

HistoryHistory

Latest version (1.1.17)complete decision processroute reflectorsversatile filtersintradomain routingvarious MED behaviourscommandline

Announced version (1.1.18)integration within TOTEM toolboxsupport for XML topologies

New approachNew approach

Assumptions:BGP sessions rely on TCPOutcome of BGP decision process does not rely on time

Consequences:Transmission lines never fail => simulator only preserves BGP messages ordering on each transmission lineDeterministic BGP decision process

How does it work ?How does it work ?

Conceptual view

scheduler[queue of events]

script / CLI

start/stop

setup, read update

readtopology DB

[nodes, links, ...]

Router configs DB[peerings, ...]

routers states DB[RIBs, sessions...]

Internals (1)Internals (1)

Topology databaseTopology represented as a graph

node = router, identified by a single IP addressedge = physical link

Graph implementationradixtree contains all nodes: O(1)adjacencies maintained in sorted heaps: O(n)

Edge attributesdelay (informal)metric (for intradomain routing)

Current limitation:single link between nodes

Example: topological view

10.0.0.1

10.0.0.2

10.0.0.3

10.0.0.4

physical link

iBGP session

Example: content of topology database

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.2 10.0.0.3 10.0.0.4

adjacencies(sorted heap)10.0.0.2, 1010.0.0.3, 5

... ... ...

network (radix-tree)

Routers configs databaseList of BGP neighbors (sorted heap)Per peer input/output filters

Routers states databaseRouting table (radixtrees)

STATIC routesIGP routes (computed)BGP routes (filled by BGP decision process)

BGP sessionsAdjRIBs, LocRIBs (radixtrees)

Example: routers configs/states databases

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.2 10.0.0.3 10.0.0.4

BGP neighbors: (sorted heap) 10.0.0.2 [filters, Adj-RIB-in, Adj-RIB-out] 10.0.0.3 [...] 10.0.0.4 [...]

network

Loc-RIB (radix-tree)

Routing table (radix-tree)

.........

SchedulerSingle linear global queueHolds messages (with src, dst and nexthop)Sequential processing of messages by a single threadMessages are propagated hopbyhop until they reach their final destination

Simulator's FIFO queue

PUSHnew msg POP msg

UPDATE [192.168.0/24]src=10.0.0.1dst=10.0.0.2next-hop=10.0.0.2

UPDATE [192.168.1/24]src=10.0.0.3dst=10.0.0.4next-hop=10.0.0.4

FIFO queue

Deliver msg tonext-hop router

source routersend msg

Structure of a router (simplified)

dst=local?

BGP peer ?

Forwarding:? route

DecisionProcess

nodrop

Output filter

Input filter

Loc-RIB

poppedmsg

pushmsg

Adj-RIB-in

Adj-RIB-out

Decision process (simplified)

0). ignores routes with unreachable nexthop1). prefer routes with highest LOCALPREF2). prefer routes with shortest ASPATH...i). prefer eBGP routes over iBGP routes...j). prefer routes with nearest IGP nexthop...n). prefer routes with smallest IP address

Per peer filterssequence of rules (predicates, actions)predicates: match prefix, communityactions: localpref, communities, aspath prepending, ...

Input filter:(predicates, actions)(predicates, actions)...

Output filter:(predicates, actions)(predicates, actions)...

Decisionprocess

Adj-RIB-in Adj-RIB-out

Loc-RIB

Input filter:(predicates, actions)(predicates, actions)...

Adj-RIB-in Adj-RIB-out

Output filter:(predicates, actions)(predicates, actions)...

Peer 1

Peer 2

Peer 1

Peer 2

Filtering one route

filter(ROUTE)foreach (rule R=(predicate, actions))

if (R.predicate matches ROUTE)for (i= 0; i < size(R.actions); i++)

if (R.action[i] == ACCEPT)return ACCEPT;

elsif (R.action[i] == DENY) {return DENY;

elseapply(R.action[i], ROUTE);

return ACCEPT;

Example: running simulation

4.1AS1

FIFO queue

<empty>

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, local

Example: running simulation FIFO queue

192.168/16[AS1]src=1.1dst=2.1

192.168/16[AS1]src=1.1dst=3.1

AS41.1

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS1]

192.168/16[AS1]

AS41.1

192.168/16[AS2 AS1]src=2.1dst=3.1

AS41.1

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS1]

192.168/16[AS1]

AS41.1

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS1]

192.168/16[AS2 AS1]src=3.1dst=4.1

AS41.1

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS1]

192.168/16[AS2 AS1}

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, AS2 AS1

AS41.1

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS1]

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS2 AS1]

192.168/16[AS4 AS2 AS1]src=4.1dst=3.1

AS41.1

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS1]

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS2 AS1]

AS41.1

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS1]

192.168/16[AS3 AS1}

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS2 AS1]

AS41.1

Loc-RIB:192.168/16, [AS1]

192.168/16[AS4 AS2 AS1}

<empty>

Scripting (1)Scripting (1)

How do we setup a CBGP simulation ?through scriptingfile / interactiveCISCOlike syntax

A few main steps:create nodes and linksconfigure static routesconfigure IGPsetup BGP routers (peerings, filters, etc)run simulation...

CISCOlike syntaxsequence of keywords and parameters

cbgp> net add node 10.0.0.1cbgp> bgp add router 1 10.0.0.1cbgp> bgp router 10.0.0.1cbgp-router> add network 192.168/16cbgp-router> add peer 1 10.0.0.2cbgp-router> peer 10.0.0.2 upcbgp-router> exitcbgp> bgp router 10.0.0.1 show rib 192.168/16

Console

Classes of commandsnet ...

commands related to topology and IP routingbgp ...

commands related to BGPsim ...

commands related to the simulatormiscelaneous additional commands

Network commands (1)Network commands (1)

net add node IPaddr

net add link IPaddr1 IPaddr2 Delay

net link IPaddr1 IPaddr2 igpweight Weight

net node IPaddr route add Prefix Nh Metric

net node IPaddr spfprefix Prefix

net node IPaddr show rt Prefix

net node IPaddr1 recordroute IPaddr2

and more...

net add node 10.0.0.1net add node 10.0.0.2net add link 10.0.0.1 10.0.0.2 10

Example

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.210

Routing table: Routing table:

Console

net add node 10.0.0.1net add node 10.0.0.2net add link 10.0.0.1 10.0.0.2 10net node 10.0.0.1 spf-prefix 10/8net node 10.0.0.2 spf-prefix 10/8

Example

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.210

Routing table:10.0.0.2 IGP

Console

net add node 10.0.0.1net add node 10.0.0.2net add node 20.0.0.1net add link 10.0.0.1 10.0.0.2 10net add link 10.0.0.2 20.0.0.1 5net node 10.0.0.1 spf-prefix 10/8net node 10.0.0.2 spf-prefix 10/8net node 10.0.0.2 route add 20.0.0.1/32 20.0.0.1 5net node 20.0.0.1 route add 10.0.0.2/32 10.0.0.2 5

Console

Example

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.210

Routing table:10.0.0.2/32 IGP

Routing table:10.0.0.1/32 IGP20.0.0.1/32 STATIC

Domain 1

Domain 220.0.0.1

Routing table:10.0.0.2/32 STATIC

net options igp-inter onnet add node 10.0.0.1net add node 10.0.0.2net add node 20.0.0.1net add link 10.0.0.1 10.0.0.2 10net add link 10.0.0.2 20.0.0.1 5net node 10.0.0.1 spf-prefix 10/8net node 10.0.0.2 spf-prefix 10/8

Console

Example

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.210

Routing table:10.0.0.2/32 IGP20.0.0.1/32 IGP

Routing table:10.0.0.1/32 IGP20.0.0.1/32 IGP

Domain 1

Domain 220.0.0.1

BGP commands (1)BGP commands (1)

bgp add router ASnum IPaddr

bgp router IPaddr add network Network

bgp router IPaddr1 add peer ASnum IPaddr2

bgp router IPaddr1 peer IPaddr2 up

bgp router IPaddr1 peer IPaddr2 nexthopself

bgp router IPaddr1 show rib IPaddr2|Prefix/*

bgp router IPaddr1 show ribin Peer|* IPaddr2|Prefix|*

bgp router IPaddr recordroute Prefix

bgp router IPaddr1 peer IPaddr2nexthopselfrrclientvirtualrecv Message

bgp add router 1 10.0.0.1bgp router 10.0.0.1

add peer 1 10.0.0.2peer 10.0.0.2 up

bgp add router 1 10.0.0.2bgp router 10.0.0.2

add peer 1 10.0.0.1peer 10.0.0.1 up

sim run

Example (iBGP)

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.210

ConsoleAS1 AS1

iBGP sessionAS 1

Example (eBGP)

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.210

Routing table:10.0.0.1/32 IGP20.0.0.1/32 STATIC20.0.0/24 BGP

AS 220.0.0.1

Routing table:10.0.0.2/32 STATIC20.0.0/24 BGP

bgp router 10.0.0.2add network 10.0.0/24add peer 2 20.0.0.1peer 20.0.0.1 up

sim run

Console

! missing route !(20.0.0/24)

Nexthopself

bgp router 10.0.0.2add network 10.0.0/24add peer 2 20.0.0.1peer 20.0.0.1 next-hop-selfpeer 20.0.0.1 up

sim run

Console

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.210

Routing table:10.0.0.2/32 IGP20.0.0/24 BGP

Routing table:10.0.0.1/32 IGP20.0.0.1/32 STATIC20.0.0/24 BGP

AS 220.0.0.1

Routing table:10.0.0.2/32 STATIC20.0.0/24 BGP

Use peer 20.0.0.1 next-hop-self

without Nexthopself

sim run

Console

10.0.0.1 10.0.0.210

Routing table:10.0.0.2/32 IGP20.0.0.1/32 IGP20.0.0/24 BGP

Routing table:10.0.0.1/32 IGP20.0.0.1/32 IGP20.0.0/24 BGP

20.0.0.1

Routing table:10.0.0.2/32 IGP10.0.0/24 BGP

Use net options igp-inter on

Miscellaneous commandsMiscellaneous commands

sim run

include Scriptexample: include /workspace/scripts/toto.cli

print Messageexample: print “Hello World\n”

# This is a comment

Policies (1)Policies (1)

bgp router IPaddr1 peer IPaddr2 filter [in|out]addruleinsertrule Indexremoverule Index

where a rule is composed ofmatch logical combination of predicatesactions comma separated list of actions

Supported match predicatesany

match all routescommunity is Community

match routes that contain given community(specified as X or X:Y)

prefix is Prefixmatch routes for exact given prefix

prefix in Prefixmatch routes contained in given prefix

Not yet implementedregular expressions on ASPathless specific prefixes

Supported actionsaccept

accept the routedeny

deny the routeaspath prepend Amount

prepend the route's aspath Amount timescommunity add Community

add the given community to the routecommunity strip Community

remove all the route's communities

Supported actions (cont')localpref Pref

change the route's localprefmetric Med|internal

change the route's multiexitdiscriminator(absolute value or based on IGP)

redcommunity add prepend Amount Targetadd a redistribution community that requestsprepending Amount times towards Target

redcommunity add ignore Targetadd a redistribution community that requestsignoring Target

ExamplePrefer routes received from neighbor 2.0.0.1

bgp router 1.0.0.1add peer 2 2.0.0.1peer 2.0.0.1

filter inadd-rule

match anyaction “local-pref 120”

ExampleDeny routes towards martian prefix 192.168/16

bgp router 1.0.0.1add peer 2 2.0.0.1peer 2.0.0.1

filter outadd-rule

match “prefix is 192.168/16”action deny

CBGP results (1)CBGP results (1)

Different meansdisplaying routing table of one routerdisplaying AdjRIBin and LocRIB of one BGP routertraceing route from one router to anothertraceing ASpath from one router to a prefixrecording BGP messages exchanged during the simulation

Routing table of one node

cbgp> net node 1.0.0.1 show rt *4.0.0.0/8 4.0.0.1 0 BGP4.0.0.1/32 4.0.0.1 5 STATIC5.0.0.0/8 5.0.0.2 0 BGP5.0.0.2/32 5.0.0.2 5 STATIC

cbgp> net node 1.0.0.1 show rt 5/85.0.0.0/8 5.0.0.2 0 BGP

cbgp> net node 1.0.0.1 show rt 5.0.0.25.0.0.2/32 5.0.0.2 5 STATIC

LocRIB of one router

cbgp> bgp router 1.0.0.1 show rib *i> 1.0.0.0/8 1.0.0.1 0 0 null i*> 4.0.0.0/8 4.0.0.1 0 4294967295 4 i*> 5.0.0.0/8 5.0.0.2 0 4294967295 5 i

cbgp> bgp router 1.0.0.1 show rib 5/8*> 5.0.0.0/8 5.0.0.2 0 4294967295 5 i

cbgp> bgp router 1.0.0.1 show rib 5.0.0.2*> 5.0.0.0/8 5.0.0.2 0 4294967295 5 i

AdjRIBin of one router

cbgp> bgp router 1.0.0.1 show rib-in 4.0.0.1 ** 2.0.0.0/8 4.0.0.1 0 4294967295 4 2 i*> 4.0.0.0/8 4.0.0.1 0 4294967295 4 i* 6.0.0.0/8 4.0.0.1 0 4294967295 4 2 6 i

Traceing route

cbgp> net node 1.0.0.1 record-route 5.0.0.21.0.0.1 5.0.0.2 SUCCESS 1.0.0.1 5.0.0.2

cbgp> net node 1.0.0.1 record-route 6.0.0.21.0.0.1 6.0.0.2 SUCCESS 1.0.0.1 2.0.0.1 6.0.0.1 6.0.0.2

Traceing ASpath

cbgp> bgp router 1.0.0.1 record-route 5/81.0.0.1 5.0.0.0/8 SUCCESS 1 5

cbgp> bgp router 1.0.0.1 record-route 6/81.0.0.1 6.0.0.0/8 SUCCESS 1 2 6

Recording BGP messagesuse “bgp options msgmonitor File”

...6.0.0.2|BGP4|114.00|W|6.0.0.1|6|5.0.0.0/85.0.0.2|BGP4|127.00|A|5.0.0.1|5|6.0.0.0/8|3 6|IGP|5.0.0.1|0||1.0.0.1|BGP4|147.00|A|5.0.0.2|5|6.0.0.0/8|5 3 6|IGP|5.0.0.2|0||5.0.0.1|BGP4|147.00|W|5.0.0.2|5|6.0.0.0/8...

Routereflectors (1)Routereflectors (1)

GoalDecrease number of iBGP sessionsDecrease information known by BGP routersAffect routing choices

How to setup RRs ?Only change sessions with RRclients

Example

client client

bgp router 1.0.0.1add peer 1 1.0.0.2add peer 1 1.0.0.3peer 1.0.0.2 rr-clientpeer 1.0.0.3 rr-clientpeer 1.0.0.2 uppeer 1.0.0.3 up

Console

Only change sessions with RR-clients

1.0.0.1

1.0.0.31.0.0.2

Multiple RRs

client client

bgp router 1.0.0.1add peer 1 1.0.0.2add peer 1 1.0.0.3add peer 1 1.0.0.4peer 1.0.0.2 rr-clientpeer 1.0.0.3 rr-clientpeer 1.0.0.2 uppeer 1.0.0.3 uppeer 1.0.0.4 up

Console

1.0.0.1

1.0.0.31.0.0.2

1.0.0.4

Fullmesh of iBGP sessions between RRsDefault clusterID based on IP address (change with set clusterid)

Hands on... (1)Hands on... (1)

Installationdownload from http://cbgp.info.ucl.ac.be/

libgds 1.1.5cbgp 1.1.17

tar xvzf libgds1.1.5.tar.gzcd libgds1.1.5./configure; make; sudo make installcd ..tar xvzf cbgp1.1.17.tar.gzcd cbgp1.1.17./configure; make

Hands on... (2)Hands on... (2)

ExercisesEx1: Write a CBGP script that models basetopo1 (next slide)

Ex2: Based on the topo of Ex1, show the inbound and outbound paths passing on each access link of AS6

Ex3: Try to balance the inbound/outbound paths on each access link of AS6 using localpref and aspath prepending

basetopo1basetopo1

CBGP - SourceForgec-bgp.sourceforge.net/downloads/cbgp-1.pdfOutcome of BGP decision process does not...

Documents

UNIVERSIDAD POLITÉCNICA DE MADRID ESCUELA ...oa.upm.es/48105/1/NURIA_FERNANDEZ_BAUTISTA_ABAD.pdfDr. Lourdes Fernández Calvino (CBGP, INIA) for her help in the nalysis of the involvement

Kementerian Perdagangan Dalam Negeri dan Hal Ehwal …belanjawan2021.treasury.gov.my/pdf/perbelanjaan/2021/BP.25.pdfOutcome 2 : Pengguna yang bijak. Petunjuk Prestasi Utama 2019 (Sebenar)

CBGP Thématiques de recherche : Caractérisation de la biodiversité. Biologie des bio-agresseurs et de leurs antagonistes. Origine, évolution et conséquences

1-14nrb.org.np/ecorev/pdffiles/vol6_art1.pdfoutcome of disequilibrium in money market and such BP disequilibrium is self-correcting unless it is sustained by policy actions. Third,

C-BGP User’s Guide (version 1.1.20)c-bgp.sourceforge.net/downloads/cbgp-doc.pdf · C-BGP is an efﬁcient BGP decision process simulator. C-BGP can be used to experiment with modiﬁed

Multi-area intra-domain routing - C-BGPc-bgp.sourceforge.net/downloads/siasi-cbgp-ospf-2005.pdf · Multi-area intra-domain routing ... group and the friends of the mailing list scattered

Home | CCPB | UCI Social Sciences...CB?D@I @EBJ JKBKJ E kBS NKCIS B kK HKI?KCDE@?B0 ?>ZK U @?PTB?D TE @??KMBIJ JBE?E VK@? B CBGP B?KK@E >ElCB>?P^ LBS @?EE) uME @EEALKBI UCBCB@D EZBCKP^

CBGP S3-Forum Novel Gene Technologies: Evolution and ......CENTRO DE BIOTECNOLOGÍA Y GENÓMICA DE PLANTAS UPM-INIA (CBGP) Parque Científico y Tecnológico de la UPM. Campus de Montegancedo,

OUTCOME BASED EDUCATION SYSTEM - AMET …M).pdfOUTCOME BASED EDUCATION SYSTEM DEPARTMENT OF ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONICS ENGINEERING AMET VISION MISSION To sustain our identity as a

CBGP S3-Forum DÍA DE LA MUJER Y LA NIÑA EN LA CIENCIA …

Outcome journal - pubs.iclarm.netpubs.iclarm.net/resource_centre/CSISA-BD Aquaculture Outcome Journal 2015.pdfOutcome journal Contributions of aquaculture to improving income and quality

315-2012: Effect Modification, Confounding,Hazard Ratio ...support.sas.com/resources/papers/proceedings12/315-2012.pdfoutcome in this study. This algorithm for e ect modi cation has

Biologie des populations urbaines de rongeurs invasifs à ...vminfotron-dev.mpl.ird.fr:8080/cbgp-gas/archives/20171012-Rongeurs/Brouat.pdfBiologie des populations urbaines de rongeurs

Catholic University of Louvain Computer Science …c-bgp.sourceforge.net/downloads/gculpin-thesis.pdfcomponents, their interactions (e.g. high-level policy routing, low-level IP forwarding),

FORECASTING ELECTIONS: DO PREDICTION MARKETS …granthaalayah.com/Articles/Vol5Iss5/03_IJRG17_A05_287.pdfoutcome of the event (more often than not a given election). While the weight

West Nile Viruslapublichealth.org/acd/docs/West Nile/WNV_UCLA_JULY 2.pdfOUTCOME OF WEST NILE VIRUS INFECTION AMONG HOSPITALIZED PATIENTS fAt discharge (NY and NJ, 2000) 9More than

Diversity and Genetic Structure of Sitophilus Spp. … · 2015-01-25 · BIOPASS Laboratory UMR 022 IRD‐CBGP University Cheikh Anta DIOP Dakar, Senegal kiiraa10@hotmail.fr ... UMR

Optical IP Switching - SourceForgec-bgp.sourceforge.net › downloads › ruffini-phd-thesis.pdf · emphasizes the e cacy of Optical IP Switching in redirecting IP tra c to dynamically

De collecte sur le terrain à la CBGPvminfotron-dev.mpl.ird.fr:8080/cbgp-gas/archives/... · Permis de capture, détention, transport Autorisation de recherches dans le pays : niveau

Resurgence of Al-Qaeda in South Asia Post-US Drawdowncf.orfonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/OccasionalPaper_66.pdfoutcome: al-Qaeda is far from decimated and several of its affiliates,