View
223
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 1/85
CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT
(CPA/ COPRA)
&DENTISTRY
PRESENTED BY:
Dr. Nilesh Arjun Torwane
2nd Year Post Graduate Student,
Department of Public Health Dentistry,
People’s Dental Academy,
Bhopal.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 2/85
INTRODUCTION
• The relationship between doctor and patient is based onconfidence.
• Lucky doctors of the past were treated like God and peo
revered and respected them.
• Today, we witness a fast pace of commercialization and
globalization on all spheres of life and the medical profe
no exception to these phenomena.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 3/85
• The practice of medicine in India has undergone considchange during the last five decades effecting delivery of
both positive and negative directions.
• As a result, it was increasingly felt that medical treatme
also be made answerable; therefore, doctors were covevarious laws.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 4/85
• In India, the Consumer Protection Act (CPA) of 1986 was en
enforced from 10th June 1987 for better protection of the inteconsumer grievances.
• This is done through quasi-judicial mechanisms set up at dis
and national levels.
• It was on 13th November 1995 that the honorable supreme
India delivered judgment on application of consumer protect
1986 to the medical/dental profession, hospitals, dispensari
homes and other related services by the now famous ruling
VS VP Shanta case.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 5/85
• This act empowers the patient to file lawsuits (in case operceived negligence) in consumer courts.
• After the consumer protection act came into effect, a nu
patients have filed cases against dental and medical pro
and have proved that they were negligent in service del
• The law is not made to punish all health professionals th
injury to patients; it is concerned only with negligent act
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 6/85
• This presentation provides general information to a regarding various dental negligent acts and legal pro
available in India.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 7/85
Negligence:
• Failure to use the degree of care considered reasonable
the circumstances, resulting in unintentional injury is ne
• For an act to be considered negligent, the following asp
be present:
1. Dentist owed a certain standard of care2. Dentist did not maintain that standard
3. There was an injury resulting from the lack of care
4. There should be a connection (proximity) between the
act and the resultant injury
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 8/85
• Dental negligence can cause the dentist to face litigatioservice has been paid for.
• However, the onus is on the patient to prove not only th
victim of negligent service but also has suffered damage
process.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 9/85
A few dental negligent acts
1. Any doctor can take up an emergency. A patient cannot be refutreatment on the ground that it is a medico legal case and there
seen in a government or approved hospital. Failure to attend an
is negligence.
2. It is dentist‟s responsibility to prevent cross infection between pa
Endangering the health or lives of other patients (even without iinvite criminal negligence (Sec 336 IPC).
3. All the patients have a right to information about the procedure
outcomes. Failure to explain may be considered a negligent act
however, not be necessary in emergency.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 10/85
4. Another cause of negligence usually involves-general dentists attempt to treat beyond their level of com
and failure to refer cases to the appropriate specialists.
For example: in periodontal cases when there is any ques
the degree of difficulty or outcome, case should be referre
periodontist to avoid legal pitfalls.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 11/85
5. Lack of informed consent is a cause of malpractice actiwithout it, battery (unlawful touching) can be alleged.
In practical terms, this means physically or emotionally ha
patient.
If there is a procedure, which has complications or undesi
consequences, which a prudent patient does not anticipat
necessary to get an informed consent.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 12/85
In the consent,• There must be understanding of problem, that is, a diag
• The proposed treatment and any alternative treatments
fully explained.
• No warranties or guarantees can be given.
• Authorization must allow for a change in plan if an un pr
circumstance arises.
• Discussion of all sequel and side effects of proposed/ cu
treatment plan must be given.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 13/85
6. Failure to give advice clearly results in complication. Degive clear instructions regarding diet and postoperative ca
7. If prescriptions are not clear and if they do not have pro
instructions, dentist is deemed to have a been negligent.
8. Failure of dentist to advice a crown for root canal filled t
significant loss of tooth substance can result in fracture of
Dentist will be held liable. Similarly, making defective dent
negligent act.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 14/85
9. Accidental ingestion of crowns, dental instrument, teethalso be considered as negligence.
10. Patient was given local anesthesia without test dose a
developed anaphylaxis and died. Dentist will be held liable
11. Under Public Liability Insurance act, a dentist can be h
for harm caused to the public by inadvertent exposure of h
substances like mercury, arsenic or even radiations.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 15/85
Some Non-negligent acts
1. Not obtaining a consent form in an emergency is not neglig
2. patient‟s dissatisfaction with the progress of treatment can
called negligence.
3. Not getting desired relief is not negligence.
4. Charging, what the patient thinks is exorbitant is not neglig
5. When patient does not follow advice of the doctor and doe
satisfactory results, dentist cannot be held negligent.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 16/85
6. Not accepting the patients is not negligence.
7. Not attending on patients outside clinic timing is not neg
8. Collecting fees is not negligence.
9. Referring patients is not negligence.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 17/85
How dentist is liable for negligenc
Dentists are liable under four heads:1. Tortious liability
2. Contractual liability
3. Criminal liability
4. Statutory liability
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 18/85
1. Tortious Liability:a. Primary liability
b. Vicarious liability
a. Primary tortious liability:
- when dentist is directly liable for an act of negligence in
or hospital.
- Most dental negligence come under this category.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 19/85
b. Vicarious liability:- Dentist who is employed by a hospital or institution is of
primarily responsible for negligence.
- They may be said to have vicarious liability through the
- The hospital has the liability for the negligence of an em
- However, if the patient is admitted by a dentist in his pe
capacity, then the dentist will be personally liable.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 20/85
2. Contractual liability:- In a doctor- patient relationship, an implied contract is est
when a dentist accepts a patient for treatment.
- A breach of any aspect of this implied contract, where the
under duty to, treat with care as well as continue to treat aterminate until patient is cured or patient discontinuous tre
may be considered a contractual liability.
- However in most instances if there is no written contract,
liability will essentially lie within the realm of tortious liabili
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 21/85
3. Criminal liability:
- This liability normally lies with an identifiable individual or grou
individuals.
- However, recent trends indicate that hospitals also may be he
vicariously liable just as in civil liabilities.
- Criminal liability is penal and involves punishment in the form o
imprisonment or fine or both.
- Criminal negligence is considered to be a crime against societ
just the aggrieved party.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 22/85
The important offences inviting criminal liability with r
negligence are:
1. Section 304 A (IPC):
- A rash or negligent act resulting in death.
E.g. death on the dental chair.
2. Section 336 (IPC): An act endangering the life of a pers
there is no injury).e.g.- extracting a tooth for a patient with valvular heart dis
without antibiotic prophylaxis against endocarditis (even if
not develop endocarditis)
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 23/85
3. Section 337 (IPC): a rash or negligent act causing simpe.g. pain and swelling after extraction due to negligent ext
4. Section 338 (IPC): a rash or negligent act resulting in g
injury.
e.g. fracture of jaw during extraction due to excessive or imforce.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 24/85
A few terminologies
1. Cognizable offence: An offence where a police officer can, base
investigation, arrest a person without a judicial warrant.
2. Non-cognizable: An offence, where an arrest can only be made
warrant.
3. Bailable: The arresting officer can give a bail. Bail is a matter of has to be given unless the officer apprehends that the accused
abscond or tamper with evidence.
4. Non-bailable: Bail can be secured only from a judge. Heinous an
crimes fall in this category, e.g. If there is a significant risk that th
may commit further crime, abscond or tamper with evidence.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 25/85
5. Compoundable: A crime in which a compromise betweesuspected offender and the victim or his representatives c
worked out is said to be compoundable.
6. Non-compoundable: If the crime is against society and
serious nature, no compromise can be made between theand the victim. These cases are said to be non compound
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 26/85
• Sec C304A is cognizable, bailable and non compoundable.
- It can be punished with imprisonment of either description fo
two years or fine or both.
• Sec 337 and 338 are cognizable, bailable and compoundab
- Sec 337 may attract an imprisonment up to three months anto Rs 250 or both.
- Sec 338 can involve imprisonment up to two years and a fin
1000 or both.
It is important for the dentist to be aware of these liabilities.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 27/85
4. Statutory liability• A dentist is liable if there is any infringement of statutes
• They then become accountable to a statutory body.
• The liability depends on the kind of infringement and the
provisions in the statute to deal with it.
• Dentists may also be liable to other statutory bodies suc
Pollution Control Board.
Wh i li bl ?
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 28/85
Who is liable?
• Dentists with independent practice rendering only free s
• Private hospitals charging all.
• All hospitals having free as well as paying patients; they
to both.
• Doctors/hospitals paid by an insurance firm for treatmen
client or an employer for the treatment of an employee.
Wh i t li bl ?
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 29/85
Who is not liable?
• Dentists in hospitals which do not charge of their patien
• Hospitals offering free services to all patients.
• Dentists providing emergency care in the interest of pat
LEGAL PROCESS
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 30/85
LEGAL PROCESS
• Dental negligence falls under section 2 (0) of the ConsuProtection Act (CPA) because Indian Dentist Act (IDA) h
provision to:
- Entertain any complaint from the patient
- Take action against dentist in case of negligence
- Award compensation
In India, the CPA 1986 envisages 3-tier grievance redress
mechanisms.
CONSUMER COURTS
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 31/85
CONSUMER COURTS
1. District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum (DCDRF
- Established by state Govt. for each district
- Headed by President and two members
- Presently 569 district forum (DF) are functioning
Jurisdiction:
- Where compensation claimed not exceeding Rs. 20 lak
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 32/85
2. State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (SCD
- Established by State Govt.
- Headed by president and two members
- Presently 32 State Commissions are functioning in coun
Jurisdiction:
compensation claimed exceeds Rs.20 lakhs up to Rs. 1 C
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 33/85
3. National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NC
- Established by Central Govt., located in New Delhi
- Headed by president and five members
Jurisdiction:
- Entertain complaints where compensation claimed for valgoods or services exceeds rupees One Crore.
- It has the power of review.
• Within 30 days from the date of decision, appeal can be fi
higher commission.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 34/85
Salient features of Consumer Cou
• Quasi-judicial: one sitting or retired district judge and 2 lay
• It has powers of civil court.
• Speedy justice avoids cumbersome procedures.
• Accepts experts opinions as affidavits.
• No court fees (changed with effect from 15/3/2003)
• No appeal fees (changed with effect from 15/3/2003)
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 35/85
• Court shall forward complaint to opposite party within 2
• Opposite party replies within time given by court.
• Decision within 3 months (Act no 62 of 2002)
• Appeal in 30 days to higher court.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 36/85
When the doctor is sued?
• If a patient threatens the doctor with a suit.
• If the doctor receives a letter from an attorney represen
patient threatening suit.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 37/85
Who can Sue the doctor under CP
1. Patient himself
2. Registered consumer organizations
3. State or Central Govt.
4. The legal representative
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 38/85
Against whom can complaint be fil
• All medical practitioners (medical, dental, others)
• All private or trust hospitals, NH, polyclinics
• Govt. hospitals and doctors
• Laboratories, x-ray clinic
• The nurses and paramedical staff
• Medical stores, pharmaceutical companies
• Quacks
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 39/85
Time limit to file a complaint
• It is two years from the date of injury.
• If the patient is aware of certain facts regarding treatme
time starts from the point.
• The time starts from the date of injury and not from the disability certificate.
• However, if the injury is continuous then time starts from
of last treatment given.
Most frequent allegations against d
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 40/85
Most frequent allegations against d
professionals
• Slipping instruments
• Broken needles
• Root left in the socket without the knowledge of patient
• Flying fragments entering the respiratory passages
• Injury in fitting or ill fitting plates and dentures
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 41/85
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 42/85
Other Common causes for filing com
• Doctor too busy to talk
• Criticism of doctor by other doctor (bad professional ethics)
• Pressure from others
• To prevent happenings to others
• To relieve guilt by blaming the doctor
• For vengeance or money.
What should a dentist do in the event
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 43/85
medical mishap?
• When something untoward happens following a diagnostic o
therapeutic procedure, or when a patient or relative makes athe dentist must take appropriate steps, some of which may
1. Complete the patient‟s record and recheck the written note
2. Be frank enough and inform clearly of the mishap.
- Show that you were genuinely concerned about the unfortumishap.
- Answer all the queries of patient / relative and do not mind t
repeated questioning, harsh attitude and at times even abus
language.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 44/85
- Keep in mind the mental state of the close relatives / friends.
- Be compassionate, try to remain on the scene as long as possibl
engage less excited attendants into discussion on the mishap an
try to bring into focus the circumstances under which the mishap
- Doctors who are open-minded and communicative are much lesscomplained against as patients / attendants are extremely forgivi
made by a friendly and concerned medical attendant.
- A high proportion of complaints are precipitated or escalated into
by a progressive breakdown of the doctor-patient communication
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 45/85
3. After these initial responses, the dentist should contact
other doctor / protection organization to seek advice.
- The Dental Associations can form groups / cells to advis
assist in such situations.
Wh t d ti t h ld t d ?
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 46/85
What a dentist should not do?
• Don‟t get upset
• Tell your patient that you are insured
• Agree to offer a settlement without consultation from your in
company.
• Alter your patient‟s records.
• Agree to or offer a specialist fees without consulting your ins
company
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 47/85
• Give your original treatment records to the patient or anyone exc
if required. Preserve the photocopy in your record.
• Discuss about the patient‟s treatment with anyone, except the ins
company.
• Admit fault or guilt to anyone.
• Contact any other practitioner about the case.
• Agree to treat the patient plaintiff during the pendency of the case
Guidelines to be adopted to avoid ne
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 48/85
p
litigations
• Maintaining proper clinical records, documents.
• Prescriptions given by the doctors should stick to the ac
norms of the medical practice.
• Whenever certificates are issued, duplicates should be any future reference.
• Avoid any comments in front of the patient regarding the
management adopted by your colleagues in a given situ
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 49/85
• Before any invasive/ costly investigational or therapeutic
procedure, informed consent of the patient or the neare
should be obtained.
• Obtaining professional indemnity.
• Continuous updating of recent developments.
CPA & Patients
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 50/85
CPA & Patients
• Advantage:
- Costly and time consuming litigation is avoided by going
consumer courts.
- These courts ensure a cheap and fairly quick remedy.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 51/85
• Disadvantages:
- The doctors will practice “ defensive medicine”, i.e. morthan may normally be required- this will make medicina
more expensive.
- Insurance premium for doctors and hospitals will shoot
will be passed on to the patient in terms of higher medic
- Patient- doctor relationship based on mutual trust and c
will gradually disappear and a completely formal, contra
antagonist relationship might replace it
CPA & Doctors
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 52/85
CPA & Doctors
• Disadvantages:
- The doctor prescribes medicine or treatment on the bas
personal judgment formed “ at the time of examination”.
situation might change shortly thereafter. It is difficult fo
people to judge all the cases.
- Any unwillingness or negligence on the part of the patie
negate the efficacy of medicines or treatment prescribed
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 53/85
- As there are no court fees, many frivolous and vexatiou
may be filed against doctors. This may affect his practicreputation even if the case is eventually dismissed, the
complainant loses nothing.
- Danger of professional blackmailer: trying to tarnish thename of doctors or squeeze money out of them even w
are not to be blamed.
How can we protect ourselves?
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 54/85
How can we protect ourselves?
• Indemnify yourself against litigation: insurance policy.
• Pressure your professional association to start professional
linked social security scheme (PPLS).
• adopt safe practices& left nobility out of the argument.
• Accepted that the medical profession is a business, but with
difference.
• Highlighted technical complexity and humanitarian benefits
CONCLUSION
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 55/85
CONCLUSION
• Doctors should be clear while taking the cases, they mu
whether to undertake the case, they must decide what tto give, and they must take care in the administration of
treatment.
• A breach of any of these duties gives the patient a right
negligence.
• As mentioned earlier, the medical profession has come
pressure due to globalization and liberalization; therefor
the time to think well and to set our priorities right, both
individually and collectively
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 56/85
• Doctors practicing ethically and honestly should not hav
reason for fear.
• Law whether civil, criminal or consumer law, can only se
limits of acceptable conduct i.e. minimum standards of
professional care and skill, leaving the question of idealprofession itself.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 57/85
L l l bilit i D t l P ti
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 58/85
Legal vulnerability in Dental Practice
CRIMINAL CIVIL
TORT CONTRACT Unintentional Intentional
Negligence (Professional negligence,
malpractice)
Assault Misrepresentation Defamation Breach
& (deceit) (libel & slander)Battery
TORTS
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 59/85
TORTS
• A tort is a civil wrong or injury, independent of a contrac
results from a breach of a duty.
• It may be intentional or unintentional.
• An unintentional tort is one in which harm was not intenthe case of negligence).
• Intentional torts contain the element of intended harm.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 60/85
• The intentional torts of major concern to the dent
include:
- Trespass to the person(assault and battery)
- Defamation
- Breach of confidentiality &- Misrepresentation (deceit)
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 61/85
Trespass to the person (Assault & Battery):
• It means a threat to harm (assault) and unauthorized to
(battery)
• Traditionally lack of consent was treated as assault & ba
• But recent decisions classify lack of informed consent a
negligence.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 62/85
• This change resulted because, courts recognized that, e
most unusual cases, doctors do not intend to harm theireven though the touching was not authorized by the pat
• If consent is present but faulty, the rules of malpractice w
• If there is total absence of consent, the case will be trea
assault & battery.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 63/85
• But there are some cases have occurred in dentistry, w
of consent was not associated.
E.g. the use of force or unnecessary physical restraints in
treatment of uncooperative children has led to allegations
assault & battery and civil trespass to the person.
• For that, avoid the use of physical force or unnecessary
in the treatment of children.
- If you feel that such measures are necessary, discuss th
with the parents and have them present in the operatory.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 64/85
Misrepresentation (deceit)
• Patient must be kept informed of their treatment status.
• If information is withheld that places a patient‟s health in
or deprives the patient of the legal right to bring suit aga
practitioner, a legal action in deceit or fraudulent conceamay result.
• The problems in dentistry most frequently associated w
and fraudulent concealment include
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 65/85
- The failure to inform the patient when an instrument bre
a root canal,
- when a root is fractured & tip remains inside the jaw and
- when the dentist is aware that the success of the treatmcompromised because of lack of cooperation by the pat
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 66/85
• In such matters, a note on the patient‟s record of the ev
the fact that the patient was informed should be made; the patient should be asked to initial or sign the entry.
• To avoid the allegation of misrepresentation, never lie to
about their treatment, and keep them informed about th
status while in your care.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 67/85
Defamation
• The intentional tort of defamation is not of major concerdentistry because most dentists are aware of the proble
consequences.
• To avoid the defamation related legal processes: keep y
opinions about your patients to yourself unless they are to their successful treatment.
• Expressions about the mental health of the patient are p
risky
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 68/85
Breach of confidentiality
• It was not known as a tort under English Common Law, product of recent case laws.
• The information obtained from the patient in the course o
diagnosis or treatment must remain confidential.
• Unless the patient waives confidentiality, a breach may l
suit.
Patient ma ai e confidentialit b their actions or ord
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 69/85
• When patient visits a specialist on your request, you are
to inform that practitioner of the health status of the pati
• To avoid the legal issues related to break of confidentia
- Never reveal any information about a patient to anyone
first obtaining permission from the patient (preferably in
Patient’s records
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 70/85
• The patient‟s dental record is a legal document.
• It serves many purposes in the judicial process.
• It contains information about the patient‟s complaint, healt
basis for diagnosis, it reports all treatment rendered, the p
reaction to treatment & the results of the treatment.
• Treating a patient without maintaining accurate records re
serious departure from an acceptable level of care (define
t )
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 71/85
• The outcome of many suits against dentists are decided
content and quality of patient records.
• For the doctor, the record is the only documentation in/a
course of treatment.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 72/85
• In cases which the doctor and patient disagree on what
and there is no written documentation of the event, the how much weight will be given to the oral statements m
determined in court by who makes the most creditable w
• This can become a risky situation for the doctor.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 73/85
• In summary:
- Failure to keep accurate records may constitute negligesome jurisdictions, a violation of a law.
- It markedly increases the risk of losing a malpractice su
Record keeping rules
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 74/85
1. Entries should be legible, written in black ink or ballpoi
2. In offices where more than one person is making entrie
should be signed or initialed.
3. Entries that are in error should not be blocked out so thcannot be read. Instead, a single line should be drawn
the entry, and a note made above it stating “error in en
correction below.”
The correction should be dated.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 75/85
4. Entries should be uniformly spaced on the form. There
no unusual or irregular blank spaces.
5. There should be no blank spaces in the answers to hea
questions. If the question is inappropriate, draw a single li
the question, or record “not applicable” (NA) in the box.
If response is normal, write „within normal limits‟ (WNL).
6. Record all cancellations, late arrivals and changes in
appointments.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 76/85
7. Document consents, including all risks and alternative t
presented to the patients. Also include remarks made by t
8. Document all conversations held with other health pract
relating to the care of the patient.
9. All patient records should be retained forever.
10. If the practice is discontinued, local law should be chec
determine the requirements on how, where, and in what fo
d t t i d
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 77/85
11. Never surrender the original record to anyone, except
of a court or to your own attorney.
12. Never tamper with a record once there is some indicat
legal action is contemplated by the patient.
What not to put on treatment reco
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 78/85
• Financial information should not be kept on the treatme
Use separate financial form.
• Do not record subjective evaluations, such as your opin
the patient‟s mental health, on the treatment record unle
are qualified and licensed to make such evaluation. Rec
observations on a separate sheet marked “confidential-
notes”.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 79/85
• Do not record any correspondence with your profession
insurance company, your attorney representing a patientreatment record.
• Record all such notes and any conversations with the a
separate sheet marked “Confidential- personal notes”.
Implied warranties (duties) owed bydoctor
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 80/85
doctor
• To the doctor-patient relationship there are some additio
that are implied.
• They are enforceable although not written or stated.
• Some of the identified duties are as follows:
1. Use reasonable care in the provision of services as me
against acceptable standards set by other practitionerssimilar training in similar community.
2. Be properly licensed and registered.
3. Employ competent personnel and provide for their pro
i i
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 81/85
4. Maintain a level of knowledge about current advances i
profession.5. Use methods that are acceptable to at least a respecta
minority of similar practitioners in the community.
6. Do not use experimental procedures.
7. Do not abandon the patient.
8. Ensure that care available in emergency situations.
9. Charge a reasonable fee.
10. Complete the care in timely manner.
11. Keep the records clear.
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 82/85
12. Maintain confidentiality of information.
13. Comply with all laws regulating the practice of dentistr And
14. Practice in a manner consistent with the code of ethics
profession.
Implied duties owed by the patie
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 83/85
• In accepting care the patient warrants the following.
1. Home care instructions will be followed.2. Appointments will be kept.
3. Bills for services will be paid in a reasonable time.
4. That the patient will cooperate in the care.
5. That the patient will notify the dentist of a change in hestatus.
• If the patient breaches any of these duties, notes to that
should be made in the patient‟s record.
References
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 84/85
1. K. Singh et al. Awareness of Consumer Protection Act among Doctors
City, India. Journal of Dentistry, Tehran University of Medical Sciences
Iran; Vol. 7, No.1, 2010.
2. Ranjan Dhawan. Legal aspect in dentistry. Jr indn soc periodont. Vol
2010.
3. Consumer Protection Act & Medical Practitioners – J V N Jaiswal.
4. S.S.Hiremath.Textbook of preventive and community dentistry. Elsev
Publications, 2nd edition, 2009,page nos. 277-283.
5. Anthony W. Jong. Community dental health. Mosbey publications, 3rd
7/27/2019 CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT.pptx
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/consumer-protection-actpptx 85/85
THANK YOU
Recommended