View
224
Download
1
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
2007 SUSBIZ India 1
CSR- Indian Perspectives
2007 SUSBIZ India 2
CSR in India
• CSR approaches and strategies are based on – the ethical beliefs of the founding fathers, – business areas in which the companies operate,– the socio-economic environment, – opportunities emerging over long periods of their existence. – visibility(Global)– perception of customer oversight
• Tied up with philanthropy and community development.
• Community influence and paternalism among traders-turned-entrepreneurs.
• Foundations within companies that follow the Gandhian ideology of “giving back to society”.
2007 SUSBIZ India 3
Companies & CSR
• Three kinds of Indian companies when it comes to corporate
responsibility:
– big Indian multinational corporations that have proper corporate
responsibility mechanisms in place;
– large national companies that appreciate the value of corporate
responsibility but have no inherent structures to show for it; and
– the many small and medium-sized enterprises that are doing only
piecemeal work at best.
2007 SUSBIZ India 4
What is CSR
• Maximize company’s overall impact on the society and stakeholders.
• More than a collection of discrete practices or occasional gestures, or initiatives motivated by marketing, public relations or other business benefits.
• approaches and attitudes differ largely due – to social and economic systems
– legal and regulatory frameworks,
– cultural practices,
– local societal and public needs and expectations.
• CSR: In a developed country: •governance, •Business ethics, •human rights and • Environment
In a developing country( India): •Focus on nation building
•Socio-economic development•Rural development•Employment
•Education•Health care
•Community support
2007 SUSBIZ India 5
Definition
• The Prince of Wales International Business Leaders Forum defines CSR on basis of four issues:
– corporate governance to include reputation, transparency, accountability, and anti corruption;
– safety and environment which comprises product/service safety, worker health and safety, local environment quality ;
– access/development that includes initiatives in education, health-HIV/AIDS, digital divide, enterprise development, and;
– Human Rights that includes labour standards, security and indigenous people.
2007 SUSBIZ India 6
CSR philosophies India
R Edward Freeman
Companies respond to theneeds of stakeholders – customers,
employees, communities, etc. Stakeholder
Milton Friedman
Corporate responsibilities limited to private owners (shareholders) Liberal
Jawaharlal Nehru State ownership & legal requirements
determine corporate responsibilities Statist
M K Gandhi Voluntary commitment bycompanies to public welfare Ethical
Champions Focus Model
2007 SUSBIZ India 7
Profit Focus
Philanthropy
Community Affairs
Corporate community
investment
Sustainable businessIntegrated into
Business functions Goals, strategy
Strategic partnerships Initiated by company
Strategic givingLinked to business
interests
Passive donations To charities when
requested
Focus is on Shareholder profit
CSR Paradigm in India
Corporate social
responsibility [102]/33%
Corporate responsibility [80]/26%
Corporate citizenship [19]/6 %
It doesn't matter,
it's all the same thing [57]/18%
2007 SUSBIZ India 8
Front runners in India
• Birlas & Tatas- Led by philosophies of nation building & trusteeship
• Hero Honda, Hindustan Unilever, ITC, MarutiUdyog etc- Fuse local business standards with the Partner/Parent company’s thrust
• BHEL, ONGC, NTPC- Public sector-true to the reasons of being set up
• IT, IT ES, Pharma, Life science etc- emerging companies/sector- Spread the positive spill over of their growth and success.
2007 SUSBIZ India 9
Some examples
First Indian company to publish a sustainability
report in line with Global Reporting Initiative guidelines
Tata Iron and Steel Disclosure
Reduced flushing WCs is estimated to save
2 billion litres of water
Hindustan SanitarywareWater conservation
Energy conservation measures are saving
the company 1150 million rupees per annum
Reliance Energy conservation
All BHEL units are certified to the
ISO14 001 environmental management system
BHEL Environmental
management
Pioneering evaluation of human capital using
an education index for its employees
Infosys Human capital
First company in India to be certified to
the SA8000 social accountability standard for its Chirala facility
ITC Labour standards
One of the few organizations to have a
policy for the grant of patrenity leave
NTPC Gender equality
One of first corporates to launch an
HIV/AIDS programme
Larsen and ToubroHealth
Dedicating 0.75% of net profit to community
development initiatives
Indian Oil Corporation Corporate giving
Asian CSR Award for its Integrated Rural Poverty Alleviation
Programme
HindalcoCommunity development
Action Company Issue
2007 SUSBIZ India 10
Examples…
• Boosting profits Gujarat Ambuja, one of the country’s leading cement manufacturers, reports that ‘our efforts to achieve world standards in environment protection have had the happy outcome of substantially improving efficiency and profitability’.
• Cutting costs Reliance Industries’ energy conservation measures have saved the company1150 million rupees per annum.
• Increasing revenues HLL’s Project Shakti creates income-generating opportunities for theunder-privileged rural women, while giving the company an enhanced access to hitherto unexplored rural areas.
• Strengthening brand value In February 2004, Infosys was among seven international companies to be chosen in the first annual list of ‘Top Brands with a Conscience’.
• Enhancing reputation The Oil and Natural Gas Corporation has found that its communitydevelopment programme has ‘generated tremendous goodwill and earned the company thereputation of being a company that cares’.
• Improving morale Tata Steel believes that helping the community also provides a new perspective to its employees, thereby strengthening employee morale.
2007 SUSBIZ India 11
The Drivers
• Ethically aware consumer groups, NGO’s.
• Moving beyond compliance.
• Right to Information Act.
• "last mile connectivity" to reach the benefits to
the deserving people. Public- Private
partnership.
2007 SUSBIZ India 12
2007 SUSBIZ India 13
2007 SUSBIZ India 14
2007 SUSBIZ India 15
Why CSR?
• Because of visibility• Feel good factor( retention of talent)• Business partner requirements• Voluntary • Pressure from stakeholders• Need to maintain good relationship with external entities• Founders attitudes• Pressure from investors, lenders and insurers• Threat of regulatory action or emerging legislation• Risk to company brand or reputation (and hence shareholder value)
as a result of consumer pressure or NGO campaigns• Desire to enhance or sustain competitiveness• Barriers to competition
2007 SUSBIZ India 16
CSR Focus by Whom?
2007 SUSBIZ India 17
Expectation….
• CSR begin at home- do the right thing towards internal stakeholders- esp employees.
• Comply with all legal requirements
• Look at – rigorously focusing on priorities,
– treating CSR as an investment and monitor ROI
– reporting performance in an open and transparent
• real CSR leadership is not just putting one’s own house in order, but advocating the right conditions to reward responsible practice.
2007 SUSBIZ India 18
Way forward
• Indian companies need to stop looking at local communities through the prism of charity and see them
as allies in the development process.
• CSR is critical in the context of enlightened self-interest
for survival in the ever-growing fierce corporate
competitive battle, for
– protecting reputations,
– defending attacks,
– improving bottom line and
– building business competitive edge.
2007 SUSBIZ India 19
Barriers
• Absence of clear linkage between CSR and financial success
• Low voluntary adoption of CSR- Leads to ‘green washing’
• Lack of mechanisms to measure, monitor evaluate and report impacts
• Two myths
– Smaller companies think it the responsibility of the bigger onesand
– It is mainly a philanthropic exercise
• High ‘overheads’ of implementing and sustaining CSR efforts.
• No universally accepted frameworks.
2007 SUSBIZ India 20
The CSR business case
• What is good for the community, the environment and the workforce is also good for the financial performance of the company
• Companies cannot be seen to exist in islands of prosperity in ‘sea of poverty’
• Go beyond compliance
• Hard commercial factor directly linked to profits and brand value.
• Manage risk( supply chain, business partners)
• Increasingly becoming a non-tariff trade barrier.
• Cost of not considering social, environmental issues could be crippling
2007 SUSBIZ India 21
Linkages
Risk reductionEngage in a dialogue with employees, suppliers , local
community, NGO's, Politicians and other business partners
Stake holder engagement
Business growthBuilding strong linkages with the local
community and employment of locals
Poverty reduction
Increased labour
productivity
Reduced costs
Provision of training, health, and education benefits for
workers; a clean and safe working environment; fair wages
Effective Human resource
management
Cost savingseco-efficiency measures using less energy and materials, lower
pollution costs and fines, reorganizing production processes,
material flows and supplier relationships
Environmental improvements,
Business BenefitActivitiesCSR dimension
2007 SUSBIZ India 22
Linkages
Sustainability Resource efficiency Environmental
Welfare Reputation Social
Employee well-being Worker productivity Human
Per Capita income growth Profitability Economic
External objectives E.g.Internal objectives E.g.) Capital stocks
2007 SUSBIZ India 23
CSR & Standards
• Broadly relate to ‘outcome’ i.e. Product and ‘process’• Types
1. Quality (for example, appearance, cleanliness, taste, and facilities)
2. Safety (for example, pesticide or artificial hormone residue, microbial presence, and use of safety features in hotels)
3. Authenticity ( for example, guarantee of geographic origin or use of traditional process)
4. ‘Goodness’ of the production process (for example, worker health and safety, environmental contamination, resource conservation, or ethical trade)
2007 SUSBIZ India 24
Some global standards on CSR
• AccountAbility 1000• Business in the Community Corporate Responsibility Index• Business in the Environment's Index• Caux Principles for Business• Coalition for Environmentally Responsible Economies - Principles• Dow Jones Sustainability Group Index• Ethical Trading Institute• FTSE 4 Good Index Series • Global Reporting Initiative • Global Sullivan Principles • Global e-Sustainability Initiative • International Chamber of Commerce Guidelines• London Benchmarking Group• MHC International• Principles for Global Corporate Responsibility• Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development Guidelines for Multinationals• Social Accountability 8000• World Business Council for Sustainable Development
2007 SUSBIZ India 25
Comparison of standards
Origin Sector coverage Example
Industry
initiatives
Shoes, Toys,
Textiles, Retail Buyers COC's
Business
associations Multiple
WRAP, Kenya
Flower Council code
BGMEA code
Third party initiatives Multiple
FTA, Organic
labelling, fair trade
Independent/
Multi stakeholder All/Voluntary
ISO, SA 8000, GRI
AA 1000
Joing Govt-Business Industry Specific
ETI, OECD
Guidelines
ILO Principles,m
UN
Global compact
2007 SUSBIZ India 26
Salient point about standards
• All standards/models focus
– On ensuring basic human rights
– Protecting children, women and ensuring fair
treatment to all stakeholders
– Some have requirements on disclosure and
transparency
– Require stakeholder involvement
– Require adherence to local law at a minimum.
2007 SUSBIZ India 27
The Indian challenge
• Three generations of challenges
– ‘first generation’: conflicts between companies
and communities over the control of natural resources is widespread
– ‘second generation’: relating to hazards of industrial activity affecting Air, Water, Land and humans
– ‘third generation’: issues related to products and services,
Public expectation: In addition to providing good quality products at reasonable prices , companies should strive to make their operations environmentally sound, adhere to high labour standards, reduce human rights abuses and mitigate poverty.
2007 SUSBIZ India 28
Leader Speak
• “Corporate Social Responsibility is more than philanthropy and must not mean 'giving and receiving'.
An effective CSR initiative must engage the less
privileged on a partnership basis. "CSR means sustainable development of the community by being
partners in their progress." The industry's focus should be about becoming efficient, competitive but also
inclusive.”
Mr Venu Srinivasan, Chairman - CII National Summit on CSR 2007, and Managing Director, Sundaram Clayton Limited said that New Delhi 14 June, 2007
Recommended