Designing Effective Reading Activities Jennifer Bixby Joe McVeigh

Designing Effective Reading Activities

Jennifer Bixby Joe McVeigh

Selecting appropriate reading materials

Intensive and extensive reading

Vocabulary Development

• Using a dictionary• Recognizing word forms• Identifying affixes and roots• Understanding collocations• Guessing meaning from

context

Checking on the vocabulary level

Use a vocabulary profiler such as this one at the English Centre at the University of Hong Kong

http://ec.hku.hk/vocabulary/profile.htm

Vocabulary Profiler Results

Frequency Percentage

1 - 1000 words 703 92.1%

1001 - 2000 words 42 5.5%

AWL words 5 0.6%

Off-list words 13 1.7%

Vocabulary Profiler Results• 1 - 1000: a about accept addition after agree agreement

allow also always an and are as at bad be because bills both broke brothers build business businesses but buy by car cared carried change child children college color could couldn counting course day describe didn difficult dollars done each easy enjoy enjoyed enough escape even every everything expected fact families family. . .

• 1001 - 2000: afford arguments baby clothes customer customers ducks during dusting exactly fun hated holidays hungry ice lesson lessons lot lots lucky nice parents proud rabbits restaurant salary shelves shop sweeping worried

• AWL: adult appreciate communicate eventually jobs • Off-list: budget chutney dusty feeding london menu

pakistan shy talents teenager untrained woodworking yelling

General guidelines and principles for activities

Teaching vs. testing

Teaching vs. testing

Bottom up processing

• Starting from sounds and letters to make meaning

• Identifying words and structures

• Focus on vocabulary, grammar, organization

Top down processing

• Comprehension resides in the reader

• Reader uses background knowledge and makes predictions

• Teacher focus is on meaning-generating activities (Anderson 2008)

Top down or bottom up?

1. Schema building to activate background knowledge

2. Pre-teaching new vocabulary words

3. Help students comprehend discourse structures

4. Underline a grammar structure or verb tense

5. Skip over vocabulary words you don’t know

6. Write the number of a paragraph where you find the answer

Comprehension vs. strategy development

Strategies

• Skim for ideas; scan for specific info

• Find the main idea

• Locate topic sentences

• Adjust reading rate relative to purpose

• Read and interpret tables, charts, maps…

• Make inferences about content

• Differentiate between fact and opinion

What’s on the menu?

Activity and Response Types

• Completing a table• Sorting or grouping • Finding information in

a reading• Answering questions• Writing a reflection

• Multiple choice• Fill in the blank• True-False• Matching• Sequencing• Completing a graphic

organizer

What makes an effective activity?

• Motivating and engaging – sack race

Pump slide

Pre-reading activities

• Schema building• Previewing• Predicting• Skimming• Identifying genre• Learning key

vocabulary

Schema building

This reading is about the invention of the telephone. What do you know about the topic? List anything you know about the invention of the telephone. What do you want to know about the invention of the telephone? Write questions. After you read, you will fill in the chart with what you learned.

• What I know…• My questions:• I learned…

Previewing

Preview the reading. Answer these questions.

1. How many paragraphs are in the reading? How long will it take you to read?

2. How many sections are there? What are the titles?

3. Look at the photographs and read the captions. What new word is explained?

Predicting

The author of the next reading has a negative opinion about reality TV shows. What issues do you think the author will discuss in the reading?

Identifying genre

Look at the magazine article. How is the format different from the newspaper article on page 17? What other kinds of differences are there?

Learning key vocabulary

Read the sentence. Choose the best definition for the bold word.

1. Company signs come in a variety of colors.

a. different kinds b. small choicec. unusual order

Activities while reading

• Keeping questions in mind• Taking notes• Filling in a graphic organizer• Monitoring comprehension• Developing fluency

Keeping questions in mind

As you read, keep these questions in mind.

1. What were three steps in the design process?

2. What was the most difficult problem for the architects?

Underlining

As you read, use a pencil and lightly underline important information. Only underline two points in each paragraph. Don’t underline complete sentences.

Filling in a graphic organizer

As you read, fill in the T-chart.

Advantages of online classes

Disadvantages of online classes

Monitoring comprehension

As you finish reading each section, answer the question.

Section 1: Who conducts the survey for the most livable city?

Section 2: Which city was the most livable city in 2009? Why?

Section 3: What three factors make it a great city to live in?

Reading fluency

• Timed readings

• Word recognition exercises

• Capacity building

Post-reading activities

• Comprehension• Critical analysis and

evaluation• Summarizing or

paraphrasing• Task-based output• Reflection and

integrated activities Photo:

Comprehension

Answer these questions. Re-read the story if you need to.

1. Why was the narrator afraid of the old man?

2. What indications are there that the narrator is mad?

Critical analysis and evaluation

In which lines of the reading does the author give factual information?

In which lines does the author give her opinion.

How do you know?

Summarizing or paraphrasing

Write a paragraph in which you summarize the reading.

Write one sentence for each paragraph.

Be sure to use your own words. Do not quote directly from the text.

Task-based output

Go back to the section describing how to make a paper airplane.

Take a piece of paper and follow the instructions.

Show your airplane to your classmates.

Did everyone’s come out the same way?

Reflection and integrated activities

Do you agree with the author that technology is bad for human relationships?

Write a paragraph giving your opinion. Use quotations from the text to help focus your argument.

Putting it all together

Putting it all togetherDirections:

1. Read the text at the end of the handout.

2. With a partner or in a small group, select two activities for either the pre-, during, or post- reading portion of the lesson.

3. What activities would you choose? How would you design each activity? What would the students need to do to complete these tasks? How long would each task take to complete?

Photo CreditsAll photos from flickr used under a Creative Commons Attribution

license

Snowy street “striatic”Shopper in aisle “Elsie esq”Rabbit reading email Toms BaugisAmazed child with book Pierre VignauShelf of books Alan LevineSoccer girls “Randy, son of Robert”B& W book and feet “striatic”Punk girl reading “txd”Vocabulary list “Autumn Bliss”Blueprints Todd EhlersTest “sergis blog”Dinosaur classroom “worldislandinfo.com”Bottom up Judith GreenTop down Marya “emdot”

Photo creditsAll photos from flickr used under a Creative Commons Attribution license

Disintegrating sign Peter MorganStrategy Joe McVeighAisles of choices Lyza DangerClear water swimmers Lali MasrieraPole vaulter “latvian”Sack race Ian ChalmersGears “Ralphbijkers”Yellow chain Jurek DurczakPump “Tinyfroglet”Framed house Stephen BrotschulHand with highlighter Steph McGlenchyB & W classroom Chuck Phillips, U. of Arizona CESLPuzzle “Antoanetta”Question mark Ethan LoftonBlue bear Jeff TurnerFlower and sky Joanne Quirante-Escober

Materials Writers Interest Section

• Come to the open meeting 5-7pm CC 602

• Visit the booth in the exhibit area

• Check your program book on p. 214 for more sessions

• Join the MWIS e-list through TESOL

Come to our other presentations

• Pathways to Successful Co-authoringFriday, 7-7:45 AM CC 503

Daphne Mackey & Jennifer Bixby

• The World of Freelance ESL EditingSaturday, 5-5:45 CC 506

Dorothy Zemach & Jennifer Bixby

• Exploring College SlangFriday, 11-11:45 CC 504

Joe McVeigh & Ann Wintergerst

• Current Trends in ESL/EFL PublishingSaturday, 3-4:45 CC 304

Joe McVeigh, Louisa Hellegers, PietroAlongi, Sherrise Roehr, Laura Pearson

Thank you

Download the PowerPoint slides

www.joemcveigh.org/resources