View
233
Download
3
Category
Tags:
Preview:
Citation preview
Employee Stock Ownership Plans
ESOP Services, Inc.
Copyright 2008
ESOP Services, Inc.
2
OverviewESOP Uses for Your ClientsThe MechanicsThe AdvantagesCreating an ESOPCandidate Checklist
ESOPs
3
Overview
11,000 ESOPs in U.S. (10% of private sector)
3,500 majority owned by the ESOP
2,000 are 100% owned by the ESOP
Found in all industries with more than 25% in manufacturing
71% of ESOP’s are in companies with fewer than 250 employees
At least 75% of ESOP’s are or were leveraged, i.e. they used borrowed funds to acquire stock bought by the ESOP
As small as a few dozen employees and as large as 40,000
(Source: The ESOP Association)
4
What is an ESOP?
An ESOP is a Tax Qualified, Defined Contribution, Employee Benefit Plan (ERISA)
• Invests primarily in the stock of the sponsoring company
• “Qualified” in that sponsoring company and selling shareholder receive various tax benefits
• Technique of corporate finance
• May use debt to purchase employer securities
5
What is an ESOP? (continued)
An Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) is a very flexible financial and equity incentive instrument that uses corporate tax-deductible or tax-free dollars to achieve a variety of individual and corporate objectives, including shareholder liquidity, perpetuation, raising working capital, and charitable giving
5
6
Answers the question, “What are my alternatives for business perpetuation and creating liquidity?”
Sale to Third Party Merger Sale to Management Corporate Stock Redemption Initial Public Offering Gift or Other Transfer to Heirs Wind-Up Business and Liquidate Leveraged Recapitalization Sale to Employee Stock Ownership Trust (potentially tax
deferred with “tax-free” dollars)
Creates liquidity, in part or whole, enabling the business owner(s) to diversify their portfolios
Why ESOPs ?
6
7
ESOP Uses for Your Clients
Provide a market (at fair-market value as determined by an independent appraiser) for partial or complete sale by existing shareholders with “tax-free” rollover treatment if ESOP ownership in a C Corporation is 30% or greater (IRC 1042)
Borrow from a bank, the sponsoring company, or sellers to purchase a block of stock
Make corporate tax-deductible contributions, including loan principal and interest payments via the ESOP (25% of Payroll + C Corporation Interest)
Gain a corporate tax deduction for C Corporation dividends passed through the ESOP to employees, or used to repay ESOP debt (excluded from 25% limit)
7
8
Income attributable to S Corporation stock owned by an ESOP is not subject to federal income tax
Raise working capital (Dilutive)
Charitable giving
Going private
401(k)/ESOP combination plans
ESOP Uses for Your Clients (continued)
8
9
The Mechanics
Non-Leveraged
andLeveraged
10
Non – Leveraged
(1) Company sets up an ESOP Trust
(2) Company makes annual tax-deductible contributions in cash or stock to the ESOP
(3) Cash is used to buy stock from current shareholders
(4) Shares are allocated to the accounts of eligible employees within the ESOP based on salary
(4) ESOP holds stock for employees and annually notifies them of how much they own and how much the stock is worth
(4) Employees receive stock or cash after they retire or leave the company, a vesting schedule applies
Employees
ESOP (1) ESOP (1)
CompanyShareholders
23
4
11
Leveraged ESOPs
The ESOP receives a loan and uses the proceeds to purchase stock from current shareholdersThese shares are held in trust and are released
into employee accounts at a rate corresponding to debt amortization
Lender
Leveraged ESOP
(1) Lender lends to company(2) Company lends to ESOP(3) ESOP buys stock from existing shareholders(4) Company makes annual tax-deductible contributions to ESOP. (5) The ESOP then in turn repays lender(6) Employees receive stock or cash when they retire or leave (vesting applies)
Cash
12
Cash
Contri
butio
n
4
Note
1Cash
Stock
3
Shareholders
ESOP
Company
Annua
l Pay
men
t5
Note
2
6Stock or Cash
UP-FRONT FLOWS
FUTURE FLOWS
13
ESOP Lenders
Owner/Selling Shareholder Take back a note in exchange for shares Taxed on principal upon receipt at capital gains and interest as ordinary income (if
installment sale treatment is elected) Advantage: Entitled to higher interest rate; subordinated to bonding company and bank Disadvantage: 1042 Tax Free Roll over requires proceeds to be reinvested within 12
months Bank
Loan is to the company which makes “mirror” loan to ESOP Typically 7 years Assessment of company credit Advantage: Selling shareholder ends up with cash up front Disadvantage: Lenders look to collateralize short fall with proceeds, Bank will not
subordinate to bonding company The Company
Cash rich company can make loan to the ESOP Advantage; Company repays itself with market rate of interest
14
Perpetuation Planning C CorporationIRC 1042 “Tax-Free” Rollover
Seller can elect to defer gain on C Corporation shares sold to ESOP by reinvesting all or any portion of the sale proceeds in Qualified Replacement Property (“QRP”)QRP is stock or debt instruments of a domestic
operating corporationQRP must be acquired within 12-months of the
ESOP sale (or 3 months before)After the sale, ESOP must own at least 30% of
company
15
* QRP must be evaluated by an experienced investment advisor to ensure compliance guidelines are met.
* *Eligible issuer must have:• more than 50% of its assets used in the active conduct of a trade or business• no more than 25% of its gross income from passive sources
Eligible** Not Eligible
Common Stock
Convertible Bonds
Corporate Fixed Rate Bonds
Corporate “Floating Rate Notes”
Municipal Bonds
US Government Bonds
Mutual Funds
Foreign Securities
REITs
Bank CDs
Qualified Replacement PropertyGeneral Guidelines*
16
Perpetuation Planning C CorporationIRC 1042 “Tax-Free” Rollover (continued)
Seller must have owned stock for at least three years prior to sale: Seller cannot have acquired the stock in a
compensatory stock option plan or any other section 83 transaction, nor from a qualified retirement plan
Seller, certain related individuals, and greater-than-25% owners generally cannot participate in ESOP allocations
10% excise tax applies if ESOP disposes of stock within three years, except for normal benefit distribution
Above rules do not apply, if seller does not elect the “tax-free” rollover
17
Tax Status Conversion
C to S or S to C IRC 1042 “tax-free” rollover as C Corporation
transaction, then convert to S Corporation S Corporation convert to C for “tax-free”
Rollover – five-year wait to convert to S 100% shareholder approval for S Corporation
election
18
Comparison of After-Tax Proceeds
90%
8%
50%
40%
100% 100%
100%
75%
50%
25%
0%
IPO Recap Stock Swap ESOP
Percent available to invest in diversified portfolio
Percent remaining in company stock
19
Assume: $500,000 pretax income
10% growth rate
40% effective tax rate
1 2 3 4 5Pretax Income 500,000 550,000 605,000 665,500 732,050
Tax Savings 200,000 220,000 242,000 266,200 292,820
Total Tax Savings $1,221,020 = more than 2x’s current income!
100% ESOP – Five-Year Value of Tax-Free Operations By Electing S Corporation Status
(The ESOP can own less than 100%, with a proportional reduction in tax-free income.)
20
“Outside” Equity incentives for ESOP S Corporations Attacked!
House Ways and Means Committee Proposes Cutback in outside equity incentives (Stock options, Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs), Warrants, Phantom Stock, etc.)
Legislation introduced 10/25/07 by Chair of the House Ways and Means Committee, Charles Rangel [D-NY], has as a so-called loophole closer, a provision that impacts an S ESOP corporation’s granting equity incentives to employees by assessing additional taxes that could exceed 100%.
Existing Structures to be grandfathered.
21
Advantages for the Company
Substantial tax savings (40% to 100%) Corporate perpetuation Cash flow increased Pre-tax dollars repay debt S Corporation stock owned by an ESOP is not subject to
federal tax (California and most states mirror) Tax-deductible C Corporation dividends Justifies accumulated retained earnings
22
Advantages for Stockholders
Creates liquidity at fair market value (as determined by an independent appraiser)
Control maintained (if desired)
“Tax-Free” rollover treatment available to sellers in closely-held C Corporation (IRC 1042)
Establishes value and provides liquidity for estate planning
Selling shareholders excluded from ESOP participation can be “made whole” by the corporation (deferred compensation)
Additional equity incentives still available (stock option, bonus, purchase, phantom stock, etc.)
23
Advantages for Employees
Employees share directly in equity growth of company
ESOP employer contributions tend to be larger than profit sharing contributions
Proven motivator and builds unity and team spirit Retains key employees (25 years of studies) Accounts accumulate tax-free and are tax-favored
at distribution Employees can realize dividend income Buy/sell agreements ensure future employee
ownership through the ESOP
24
Creating an ESOP
Preliminary Analysis Preliminary Assessment Questionnaire
Phase I Preliminary Valuation
Feasibility Study (“Decision Package”)
25
Creating an ESOP (continued)
Phase II ~ Implementation Plan design
Financing
Employee communication
Repurchase obligation planning/funding
Independent transaction valuation
Phase III ~ Ongoing Administration
Annual valuation
Communications
26
Yes/No___/___1. The entity is a corporation taxed in the normal
manner. Please check type of corporation."C" Corp. ___ "S" Corp. ___ Professional Corp. ___
___/___2. The company is closely held, or if publicly traded has a significant concentration of ownership
___/___3. The company has payroll adequate to support an ESOP (Minimum $500,000)
___/___4. The company has a strong pretax, pre-distribution/bonus earnings and cash flow over the previous few years ($1,000,000 +)
Is an ESOP Right for You?ESOP Candidate Checklist
26
27
Yes No___/___5. The company expects to have strong pretax, pre-
distribution/bonus earnings over the next few years ($1,000,000+)
___/___6. The company has paid substantial federal income taxes during the past few years
___/___7. At least some stockholders are motivated to sell some stock; e.g., planning for retirement, liquidating an estate, entering a new business venture, children not involved in business, etc.
Is an ESOP Right for You?ESOP Candidate Checklist (Continued)
27
28
Yes No___/___8. If one or more principal executives will be departing
in connection with the sale, there is strong management available to take their place(s)
___/___9. The company customarily makes payments to a 401(k) or profit sharing or other employee benefit plan that could in the future be made to an ESOP
___/___10. The owners are psychologically willing to share ownership with their employees, assuming an attractive transaction can be arranged
Is an ESOP Right for You?ESOP Candidate Checklist (Continued)
28
29
ESOP Services, Inc.www.esopservices.com
Founded in 1984, ESOP Services, Inc. responds to the needs of business owners to understand and analyze the ESOP’s impact on the company, shareholders, and employees, focusing on the financial aspects of cash flow, tax savings, shareholder liquidity, and employee benefits. We specialize in all aspects of Employee Stock Ownership Plans for both private and public companies throughout the United States and internationally. Our unique approach emphasizes the financial aspects of ESOPs, while coordinating the many diverse elements necessary to successfully establish an ESOP.
P.O. Box 420563 251 Albevanna LaneSan Diego, CA 92142 Scottsville, VA 24590 Phone: 858.292.4819 Phone: 434.286.3130Fax: 858.565.0764 Fax: 434.286.3815paige@esopservices.com esop@esopservices.com
Recommended