View
216
Download
1
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
EngagingPhysiciansinLeadingQualityImprovement
Carol Peden, MB ChB, MD, MPH Felipe Osorno, MSCEP Kaveh Houshmand Azad, MSCIE
Keck Medicine of USC University of Southern California Los Angeles
Disclosures CarolPedenisashareholderinFidelityHealthandaFellowandFacultyofIHI.Wehavenootherrelevantfinancialrela;onshipswiththeproductsorservicesdescribed,reviewed,evaluatedorcomparedinthispresenta;on.
2
CarolPeden,MBChB,MD,MPHFelipeOsorno,MSCEPKavehHoushmandAzad,MSCIE
3
OBJECTIVESOFTHISSESSION
1-Tounderstandhowtodevelopastrategyandframeworktocreateaprogramforphysiciansinleadershipandqualityimprovement2-Tounderstandhowtoimplementaframeworktoenablephysicianstoleadqualityandperformanceimprovementprojects3–Tolearnfromsuccessstoriesfromourphysicianqualityandimprovementprogram,aswellaslessonslearned
4
KeckMedicineofUSC
3Hospitals
619Beds
60+Clinics
4,000+Employees
1300FacultyandScien;sts
9000ClinicalTrials
900Residents
$1.6BNetRevenue
Bornin2009
5 Source:UHC,Q32016–Q22017
2.96KeckMedicalCenterofUSCCMI
2.78CityofHope
2.46MoffiQCancerCenter
2.50ClevelandClinic
2.53Univ.ofMarylandMedicalCenter
2.43StanfordHealth
2.27UCLAHealth(RonaldReagan)
2.34MayoClinic
2.11UCSFMedicalCenter
1.92JohnsHopkinsMedicine
Weseesomeofthe
sickestpa]entsinthena]on
2.72SylvesterCancerCenter
CMI=CaseMixIndex
Innovation at Keck
6
CharlesHeidelberger,firstassociatedirectorforbasicresearchatUSCNorrisComprehensiveCancerCenterandof5-Fluorouracil,themostwidelyusedcancerchemotherapydrug
FirstFDA-ApprovedHigh-IntensityFocusedUltrasoundSurgicalAbla]onforKidney&
ProstateCancer
FirstImplantableAr]ficialRe]natoRestoreVisionfromRe]ni]sPigmetosa
FirsttoTreatUncontrolledEpilepsywithFDA-ApprovedResponsiveNeuros]mula]onSystem
FirsttoOfferBronchialThermoplastyOutpa]entTreatmentforSevereAsthma
FirsttoEstablishRela]onshipofCancerandEpigene]cDNAMethyla]on
Keck’s Revenue Growth – An Academic Start Up • Revenuehastripledin6years–reached1.6Bin2017• 30%growthinthelast2fiscalyears
7
$460M$550M
$620M
$790M
$1.15B
$1.31B
$1.5B
$0
$200
$400
$600
$800
$1,000
$1,200
$1,400
$1,600
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Los Angeles Health Care • SignificantMedi-cal(37%ofLACountyand33%ofCA)andMedicarepa;entpopula;on
• LosAngelesisoneoftheleastconsolidatedhealthsystemsintheUS• Markeddemographicdiversity
8
Health Spending Per Capita Per State 2014 (most recent data)
9
Source:KaiserFamilyFoundaOonhPps://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/health-spending-percapita
From a For-Profit Hospital to an Academic Medical Center in a changing healthcare world
• Challenges!
• Culture
• Developingdatainfrastructure
• LiQleimprovementinfrastructure
• Rapidgrowthanddevelopingsystems
10
Who we are? • CarolPeden,Physician–anesthesiologistandintensivist30yearsfront-lineclinicalexperience,IHIFellowandFaculty,experienceofdesigningandleadingQIprojectsandcurriculaaroundtheworld.
• FelipeOsorno,MITChemicalEngineer,6yearsinconsul;ngatMcKinsey,LeanandSixSigmaTrained,experienceandpassionincrea;ngsystemstoempowerfrontlinestafftoimprovevalue.
• KavehHoushmandAzad,MScIndustrialEngineering,10yearsofexperienceinhealthcareperformanceimprovement
11
Getting Physicians Engaged in Improvement
• Whythisprogramforusnow?• GrowthandInfrastructure• Valueinhealthcare• Transforma;onalchange• Theissuesallhealthcareorganiza;onsarefacing
12
We are all facing similar challenges
13
End-to-End
BundlesV VALUE
Changesinreimbursement
models
Risingsupplyandlaborcosts
Wasteininternalprocesses
Varia]onamongproviders
Needforchange
Burnout
WestetalLancet2016;388:2272-81SalyersetalJournalofGeneralInternalMedicine201614
Strategies to reduce physician burnout
15
hPps://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/mayo-clinic-reversing-physician-burnout-using-nine-strategies-to-promote-well-being/
• Acknowledgingandassessingtheproblem• Recognizingthebehaviorsofleadersthatcanincreaseordecreaseburnout
• Usingasystemsapproachtodeveloptargetedinterven;onstoimproveefficiencyandreduceclericalwork
• Cul;va;ngcommunityatwork• Usingrewardsandincen;vesstrategically• Assessingwhethertheorganiza;onsac;onsarealignedwiththestatedvaluesandmission
• Implemen;ngorganiza;onalprac;cesandpoliciesthatpromoteflexibilityandwork-lifebalance
• Providingresourcestohelpindividualspromoteself-care
• Suppor;ngorganiza;onalscience(Studythefactorsinyourownins;tu;onthatcontributetotheproblem,andinvestinsolu;ons.)
15
Achieving The Quadruple Aim
16
ImprovedPa]entOutcomes
LowerCostofCare
ImprovedPa]entExperience
ImprovedCareGiverExperience
Why not a multidisciplinary team approach? • Culture• Nomedicalschooltraining(todate)inQIatUSC
• Time• LiQleestablishedinfrastructure• Needtorapidlydevelopacohortofleaderswhocouldthenworkwiththeirteams
17
18
CultureofImprovement
DataAvailabilityandTransparency
BuildingCapabili]es
System-WideImprovement
Specialty-LevelImprovement
EngagedPhysicians
Our System-Wide Strategy
19
hPp://www.ihi.org/resources/Pages/HowtoImprove/default.aspx
ModelforimprovementdevelopedbyAssociatesinProcessImprovement
• Approachfromboth“Lean”and“ModelforImprovement”• Usingbackgroundresearchandtheteam’sexperience
Designing the program
LeanThinking
20
hPps://www.rcoa.ac.uk/system/files/CSQ-ARB-2012_0.pdf
hPps://paOentsikkerhed.dk/content/uploads/2016/02/psskatalog_uk_www.pdf
hPps://www.rcplondon.ac.uk/projects/learning-make-difference-ltmd
Experience and Learning
The “Secret Sauce”
AmericanJournalofMedicalQuality2017.
• “Earlyengagementofaphysicianleader–whocanlisten,engage,andleadothercolleagues–tobeanearlyadopter”
• “Theymustbeequippedwiththetrainingandtoolstoleadothers,requirededicatedprotected;me,andtheautonomytocoordinateandimplementchanges”
• “Theengagedphysicianleaderrequirestrainingingovernance,leadershipandmedicaleconomics…andmentorship”
EPOCH Aim and Theory
22
EPOCHTrial:EnhancedPeri-Opera;veCareforHigh-riskPa;ents£1.5M/90Hospitals
Front-line clinical staff will be enabled
to achieve improvements in care for patients
undergoing Emergency Surgery
which will lead to improved outcomes
Evidencebased
interven;ons
Measurement&datafeedback
Mo;va;onandfocus
Communityofprac;ce
QIskillstraining
MDTapproach
Ethnography and physician engagement “Becausehistoricallyweassurgeonswouldfinishanemergencyandouenleavetheopera;ngtheatretowritetheopera;onnotes,andthenouentheconsultantwouldleave,andtheregistrarmightcomebacktoseewhatisgoingon,butouenyouwould…findoutthenextmorningwherethepa;enthadgone.Whereasthisnow,gevngusintomoreofacultureof:‘Isthispa;enthighrisk?Shouldtheygotointensivecare?Whatisourplanofmanagement?Doweextubate?’Thosekindofthingsareconversa;onsIthinkweshouldhave’.”(SurgicalFellowHospital2)
23 EPOCHTrialSociologyofHealthandIllness2017;39:1314-1329
How to make change happen
24
What does engagement really mean to physicians? 1. Respectformycompetencyandskills2. Feelingthatmyopinionsarevalued3. Goodrela;onshipswithmymedicalcolleagues4. Goodwork/lifebalance5. Avoiceinhowmy;meisstructuredandused6. Faircompensa;on7. Goodrela;onshipswithnon-clinicalstaff8. Abroadersenseofmeaninginmywork9. Avoiceinclinicalopera;onsandprocesses10. Opportuni;estoexpandmyskillsandlearnnewskills
25
From:IncreasingPhysicianEngagement:startwithwhat’simportanttophysicians.RobertStarkThejournalofmedicalpracOcemanagement2014;30:171-5
How was our program developed?
SPO
NSO
RS
HIP
DES
IGN
HealthSystemLeadership
ValueImprovementOffice(“LeanTeam”)+CenterforHealthSystemInnova;on
DepartmentChairs
ValueImprovementOffice(“LeanTeam”)+CenterforHealthSystemInnova;on
SELE
CTI
ON
DEL
IVER
Y
Why it was designed this way? • Tohelpcliniciansunderstandthecomponentsofvalue• Toequipthemwithimprovementsciencetools• Toprovideleadershipdevelopment• Toeducateonchangemanagementconcepts• Toprovidebasicsonorganiza;onalstrategyandgoals• Todemonstratehowtouseandinves;gateins;tu;onaldatae.g.Vizient• Tohelpfosterresearchandpublica;oninqualityimprovement• Tosupportselec;onanddevelopmentofaprojectonwhichtoapplytheseskills
27
Program Structure
28
Day
1Day
2
Day
3Day
4
§ QualityandLeanIntroduc]on
§ SystemThinking§ A3andPDSA§ ProjectSelec]on
§ ValueStreamMap§ RunCharts§ RootCauseAnalysis
§ ChangeManagement§ Innova]on§ StakeholderAnalysis§ Leadership
§ Publica]on§ Benchmarking§ Sustainability
AdultLearningprinciplesIncludinggameandsimula;ons
1:1coachingsessions
DataSupport
Introduction to the program
29
Oct16
Nov16
Dec16
Jan17
Feb17
Mar17
Apr17
May17
Jun17
• Selec;ngandscopingpoten;alprojects
• Selec;ngandcalcula;ngprojectmetric(s)
QIPIday2QIPIday3
• Formingprojectteams• Mappingprocesses• RootCauseAnalysis
• Developingcountermeasures• Implemen;ngcountermeasuresCommunica;ngtheprojectwithotherstakeholders
• Re-measuringprojectmetrics• Makingnecessaryadjustments• Finalizingthepresenta;on
QIPIday1
Jul17
Aug17
Sep17
Oct17
Nov17
QIPIday4
Ongoingcoachinganddatasupport
CohortSelec]on
Sharingtheresultandlearnings
Educating and Inspiring our Staff - QIPI
30
Crea;ngacollabora;veandposi;veoff-siteexperienceFastpacedlearningandapplica;onoftoolsInvitedguestspeakerstoenrichthelearningexperienceOpportuni;esforpublica;ons
Crea;ngacollabora;veandposi;veoff-siteexperience
Fastpacedlearningandapplica;onoftools
Opportuni;esforpublica;ons
Invitedguestspeakerstoenrichthelearningexperience
Summary of successful projects
31
Dr.BrigneyDeClerckImprovingEMRU;liza;on/efficiency
indermatologyclinics
Dr.ArmandDorianAppropriate“Pa;entStatus”
Determina;onat;meofAdmission
Dr.JayHudginsImprove%oftransfusedcasesvs.
typeandscreenorders
Dr.BenjaminEmanuelImprovedoor;metoCT/MRI;mefor
strokepa;ents
Dr.JehniS.RobinsonImprovepa;entcycle;meinFamily
Medicineclinic
Dr.NaomiSchechterImprovingpa;enttransferstoNorris
Radia;onOncology
Dr.MichaelJohnsImprovePa;entthroughputin
OHNSclink
32
Recognitions and presentations
Other QI physician engagement projects at KMUSC • CareDeliveryRedesignAmul;disciplinaryapproachleadbyhealthcareadministratorswithengagedphysicians,andsupportedbytheValueImprovementOffice• SurgicalQualityImprovementOfficersAphysicianledprogram,fundedbytheDepartmentofSurgerywithnominatedsurgicalandanesthesiologyleads,supportedtoworkontheirownimprovementprogramswithfinancialcompensa;on.QIMentoringanddataanaly;cssupportprovided.
33
34
Recipe for Care Delivery Redesign Steps:1. AlignonBurningPlaxorm
2. Iden;fyKeyOpportuni;es3. GaugeReadiness&BuildCoreTeams
4. EngageinCri;calReview
5. CreateEnvironmentforChange
6. FacilitateCross-Collabora;on7. Sustain,Share,&Expand
KeyIngredients:q PhysicianChampionsq Mid-LevelProvidersq AlliedHealth
Professionalsq AncillaryServicesq Administra;veSupportq Execu;veEngagementq DataTransparencyq SharedVisionfor
Success
35
1.AlignonBurningPlaiorm
2.Iden;fyKeyOpportuni;es
6.FacilitateCross-Collabora;on
7.Sustain,Share,&Expand
3.GaugeReadiness&BuildCoreTeams
4.EngageinCri;calReview
5.CreateEnvironmentforChange
Steps
KeyIngredientsatWorkAssessCurrentStateandBenchmarkEngageClinicalLeadersinthe“Why?”CreateASharedVision
Q+S+A $
OurSharedChallenge:
36
1.AlignonBurningPlaxorm
2.Iden]fyKeyOpportuni]es
6.FacilitateCross-Collabora;on
7.Sustain,Share,&Expand
3.GaugeReadiness&BuildCoreTeams
4.EngageinCri;calReview
5.CreateEnvironmentforChange
Steps
KeyIngredientsatWorkUseDatatoDiscoverGapsIden;fyExis;ngImprovementsinProgressSelectFocusCohort
37
1.AlignonBurningPlaxorm
2.Iden;fyKeyOpportuni;es
6.FacilitateCross-Collabora;on
7.Sustain,Share,&Expand
3.GaugeReadiness&BuildCoreTeams
4.EngageinCri;calReview
5.CreateEnvironmentforChange
Steps
KeyIngredientsatWorkAssessReadinessforChangeIden;fyChampionsinKeyAreasAskWhoElseShouldBeInvolved
38
1.AlignonBurningPlaxorm
2.Iden;fyKeyOpportuni;es
6.FacilitateCross-Collabora;on
7.Sustain,Share,&Expand
3.GaugeReadiness&BuildCoreTeams
4.EngageinCri]calReview
5.CreateEnvironmentforChange
Steps
KeyIngredientsatWorkCombineClinicalandFinancialDataCri;callyReviewEveryDay,EveryCareDecisionIden;fyProcessFailuresAcrossDisciplines
39
1.AlignonBurningPlaxorm
2.Iden;fyKeyOpportuni;es
6.FacilitateCross-Collabora;on
7.Sustain,Share,&Expand
3.GaugeReadiness&BuildCoreTeams
4.EngageinCri;calReview
5.CreateEnvironmentforChange
Steps
KeyIngredientsatWorkAssembleImpactedStakeholdersCreateSafeSpacetoShareEncourageDifficultDiscussions
40
1.AlignonBurningPlaxorm
2.Iden;fyKeyOpportuni;es
6.FacilitateCross-Collabora]on
7.Sustain,Share,&Expand
3.GaugeReadiness&BuildCoreTeams
4.EngageinCri;calReview
5.CreateEnvironmentforChange
Steps
KeyIngredientsatWorkShareFindingsfromCri;calReviewsIden;fyCross-Func;onalTeamsLaunchShort-andLong-termImprovements
41
1.AlignonBurningPlaxorm
2.Iden;fyKeyOpportuni;es
6.FacilitateCross-Collabora;on
7.Sustain,Share,&Expand
3.GaugeReadiness&BuildCoreTeams
4.EngageinCri;calReview
5.CreateEnvironmentforChange
Steps
KeyIngredientsatWorkMonitorandSharePerformanceLearnfromSuccessesandFailuresCreateOrganiza;onalAwareness
42
1.AlignonBurningPlaxorm
2.Iden;fyKeyOpportuni;es
6.FacilitateCross-Collabora;on
7.Sustain,Share,&Expand
3.GaugeReadiness&BuildCoreTeams
4.EngageinCri;calReview
5.CreateEnvironmentforChange
Steps
KeyIngredientsatWorkShareFindingsfromCri;calReviewsIden;fyCross-Func;onalTeamsLaunchShort-andLong-termImprovements
Department of Surgery Quality Officers Program • SupportedandfundedbyChairofSurgery• Financialincen;ve• SignificantdataandQIsupport• Onemee;ngamonthofgroup• SomeQItraining• Focusondevelopmentofleaders• Financialcalcula;onstojus;fyROI• Celebra;onofsuccess
43
DOS Quality Officers Desired Outcome
44
Forumtosharequalitydata&ini]a]ves
Engage,mentor,&trainofficersonquality&
performanceimprovement
Leadandimplementquality&performanceimprovement
projectwithinthedivisionandscaletootherdivisions
1 2 3
Performance Improvement Process
45
IDENTIFICATIONOFPROJECT
Regulations
QualityOutcomes
CostOperationalInefficiencies
Research
INVESTIGATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION AUDIT/MODIFY/ITERATE REPORT
QualityOutcomes
CostOperationalInefficiencies
Research
Value=QualityCost
ProcessforPerform
anceIm
provement
(1yearTim
efram
e)
1 month 2-4 months 2 months 3-6 months 1 month
Using measurement and local data…to inform and drive improvement
• ProcessandOutcomedata• Crea;ngabuzz,acampaign,energy–thewishtobepartofsomething
• Ini;alQItraining,followup,regularreviewandsharingwithstakeholders
• BasictraininginQItechniques,dataandsupport
46
Sample Project: Increasing Efficiency & Decreasing Length of Stay
in Vascular Surgery • Hypothesis• Projectiden;fiedbysurgeons,engagedAQendingandDivisionChief• Increasingiden;fica;onandearlymanagementofavoidabledelayswilldecreaselengthofstay–focusonpa;entswithO/Era;o>1day
• OverlappingprojectbetweenSurgicalQualityOfficersandCareRedesign• Results
47
Current Process
48
Proposed New Process for Workflow
49
Surgical Quality Officers; Reflection -what we will do differently in the next
iteration • InvolveAnesthesiology• Compensa;onlinkedtoaQendance• Projectsmoreclearlylinkedtoorganiza;onalgoals• Moreformal;meinQItraining• Lessofa‘research”approachtodata,lessretrospec;veanalysis–moreuseofsamplingandruncharts
• GreaterinvolvementofhospitalQIdepartment• Morecelebra;onandpromo;onofsuccess50
We’ve shared our experience …. What does some of the research say….
51
• Askdoctorstolead–mantrais“physician-led,data-driven,evidencebased”• Askdoctorswhattheywanttoworkon• Makeiteasyfordoctorstoleadandtopar;cipate• Recogni;onfordoctorswholead• Supportformedicalstaffleaderswithcourage• Opportuni;estolearnandgrowGosfeldAG,ReinertsenJL(2010).AchievingClinicalIntegra;onwithHighlyEngagedPhysicians.Unpublishedmanuscriptin“MedicalEngagementtooimportanttobelektochance”ClarkJ.TheKing’sFund2012
52
hPp://www.kingsfund.org.uk/sites/files/kf/medical-engagement-nhs-john-clark-leadership-review2012-paper.pdfhhPps://www.kingsfund.org.uk/sites/default/files/field/field_publicaOon_file/medical-engagement-a-journey-not-
an-event-jul14_0.pdf
Lessons from McLeod Hospital’s Transformation
53
Consider Behavioral Economics
AnnInternMed2016;164:114-119
• Improvingqualityispartofdoctorsprofessionaliden;ty-tappingintothiscanbeapowerfulmo;vatorforchange
• Clinicianledqualityimprovementcanleadtogreaterstandardiza;on,moreequitablecare,greaterqualitycontrol,improvedpa;entsa;sfac;onandbeQerpa;entoutcomes
• QImustbealignedwithresourcealloca;on,supportedbyprofessionaltraining,commissioningandregula;onandintegratedintoservicemanagement
• QItobesustainablemustbeintegratedwithorganiza;onaldirec;onandresources
54
www.health.org.uk
How do you get clinicians involved in quality improvement?
1. Consideryourorganiza;onstrackrecord–emphasizewhythisprogramwillsucceed–howisitdifferent?
2. Givedoctors;meandresourcestoac;velyengage3. Explana;onsofthepurposeoftheprogramshouldbe
phrasedtoreflectpriori;esandconcernsofclinicians4. Evidenceofefficacy–localevidencewillhelp5. Externalexper;sewherepossibletoaddcredibility6. Localprogramchampions(credibilitywithother
clinicians)7. Managementinvolvement–inaposi;ontosupport
clinicians
55
MedicalEngagementinorganisaOonwidesafetyandqualityimprovementprogrammes.
ParandetalQualSafHealthCare2010;19:e44
Seven Themes for Medical Engagement
Harness Passion • Whatistheirpassion,whatistheirclinicaldesire?• Isittobethebestgastroenterologistever–howcanyouhelpthemgetthere?• Tohavethelowestmortalityforsepsis–howcanyourQIworkgetthemthere?• AskhowcanIhelpyou..bethebestdoctor…havethebestteam..savethemostpa;ents?
56
In Summary • Wehavedesignedandledanumberofprogramswhichengageanddevelopphysiciansinimprovementleadership
• Wewillmodifythenextroundoftheseprogramsbasedonourexperienceandfeedback
• Wehaveseentangibleimprovements,ROIandjoyinworkincreaseforphysiciansandtheirteams
57
58
THEKECKEFFECT
ENGAGEDPHYSICIANSIMPROVINGTHEQUALITYOFOURCARE
THANKYOU!
Recommended