View
214
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!"#$%&'((
"#$%&'!
()*+,!-.//)00,12!345)6!)./7,*8!
916*5)!:,;;2!
<<%!'=5651!
>5112;!?)@421!!
#$AA"#$:"!
'.0)115!?)74@)1!
!
!
B72;!*5;5)*+7!=);!;.CC,*/56!DE!)!F*)1/!G*,@!(2+*,;,G/H!#,*C,*)/2,1I!
FROM WORKPLACE TO ANYPLACE ASS ESSI NG THE OPP ORTUNI TI ES
TO REDU CE GREE NHOUSE GAS EM I S SI ONS WI TH VI RTUAL ME ETI N GS AND TELECOM M UTI NG
(!
!
! !
!
! J
!
"#$%&'$!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!)!
*+$',-./$!0,11!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!3!
45-#67,'-.65!((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!88!
8! 9&':;#6,57!((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!8<!
KIK! B545=,*L21F!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!KJ!
KIKIK! B545=,*L21F!M!>)/)!)N)24)D242/E!)16!6)/)O+,445+/2,1!2;;.5;!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!KJ!
KIKIP! B545=,*L21F!M!?515/*)/2,1!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!KQ!
KIKIR! B545=,*L21F!M!"S2;/21F!D)**25*;!)16!F*,=/7!C,/51/2)4!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!KT!
KIP! U2*/.)4!@55/21F;!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!KV!
KIPIK! U2*/.)4!@55/21F;!M!>)/)!)N)24)D242/E!)16!6)/)O+,445+/2,1!2;;.5;!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!KV!
KIPIP! U2*/.)4!@55/21F;!M!"S2;/21F!42/5*)/.*5!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!PW!
KIPIR! U2*/.)4!@55/21F;!M!"S2;/21F!D)**25*;!)16!F*,=/7!C,/51/2)4!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!PP!
KIR! $./4,,L!M!B545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!PJ!
KIJ! ?)/7;!,G!XYX!2@C)+/!G,*!/545=,*L21F!)16!/545+,1G5*51+21F!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!PJ!
<! =,-,#$!>6#?70!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!<3!
PIK! #)*D,1!=,*46!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!PZ!
PIP! ?,42+E!=,*46!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!PZ!
PIR! B5+7!=,*46!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!PT!
PIJ! '@)*/!=,*46IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!PT!
@! A,&5-.-&-./$!&5&?20.0!B!C$-D676?6;2!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!@E!
RIK! [5E!);;.@C/2,1;!M!9CC*,)+7!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!RK!
F! A,&5-.-&-./$!&5&?20.0!B!G.1,?&-.65!#$0,?-0!&57!7.0',00.65!((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!@)!
JIK! B545=,*L21F!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!RQ!
)! "6?.'.$0!&57!0-#&-$;.$0!((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!)F!
3! HII$57.+!8!B!H00,1I-.65!-&J?$0!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!)K!
\IK! B545=,*L21F!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!QZ!
\IP! U2*/.)4!@55/21F;!IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII!\\!
K! HII$57.+!<L!G,11!7&-&!%6#!*M!'6,5-#.$0!((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!KE!
N! HII$57.+!@L!M5$1I?62$7!I$6I?$!.5-$#$0-$7!.5!-$?$>6#:.5;!((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!KF!
O! 9.J?.6;#&ID.'!#$%$#$5'$0!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!K)!
!
! Q
Preface 944!/,,!,G/51!/75!62;+.;;2,1!)D,./!*56.+/2,1!,G!F*5517,.;5!F);5;!2;!+).F7/!21!)1!,46!62+7,/,@E!=75*5!
21+*5);56!].)42/E!,G!42G5!2;!C*5;51/56!);!2G!2/!2;!21!+,1G42+/!=2/7!/75!1556!/,!@,N5!)=)E!G*,@!)!65C51651+E!
,1!G,;;24!G.54I!B,6)E!15=!)16!211,N)/2N5!;,4./2,1;!5S2;/!/7)/!+)1!D,/7!C*,N265!)!D5//5*!].)42/E!,G!42G5!)16!
+,1/*2D./5!/,!6*)@)/2+)44E!*56.+56!5@2;;2,1;I!B75;5!;,4./2,1;!)*5!C)*/2+.4)*4E!2@C,*/)1/!D./!)4;,!
+7)4451F21F!=751!)CC*,)+721F!/75!+42@)/5!+7)4451F5!G*,@!)!F4,D)4!C5*;C5+/2N5^!D5+).;5!/75!1556!/,!754C!
D2442,1;!,G!C5,C45!@,N5!].2+L4E!,./!,G!C,N5*/E!)16!/75!1556!/,!C*,N265!;,4./2,1;!/7)/!+)1!754C!C5,C45!21!
/75!65N54,C56!=,*46!/,!*56.+5!/752*!5+,4,F2+)4!G,,/C*21/!@.;/!D5!;.CC,*/56!)/!/75!;)@5!/2@5I!
!
B=,!,G!/75!@,;/!21/5*5;/21F!)16!211,N)/2N5!+42@)/5!;,4./2,1;!/7)/!+)1!+,1/*2D./5!/,!)!72F75*!].)42/E!,G!42G5!
)16!65+*5);56!5+,4,F2+)4!G,,/C*21/!)*5!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16!/545+,@@./21FI!_)/54E!/75;5!;,4./2,1;!7)N5!
D5F.1!/,!D5!.;56!,1!)!=265*!;+)45^!D./!/75!C,/51/2)4!2;!51,*@,.;!)16!7);!1,/!E5/!D551!*5+,F12056^!);!
/72;!*5C,*/!;7,=;I!`1+*5);21F!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16!/545+,@@./21F!/,6)E!+,.46^!=2/7,./!)1E!6*)@)/2+!
@5);.*5;^!754C!/,!;)N5!@,*5!/7)1!R!D2442,1!/,1;!,G!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!21!)!G5=!65+)65;a!/72;!2;!5].2N)451/!/,!
)CC*,S2@)/54E!7)4G!,G!/75!+.**51/!b'!#$P!5@2;;2,1;I!B75!L5E!/,!/)C!21/,!/75!*5)4!C,/51/2)4!425;!21!
+,44)D,*)/2,1!D5/=551!F,N5*1@51/;!)16!D.;215;;^!);!=544!);!+,44)D,*)/2,1!D5/=551!$"#>!)16!5@5*F21F!
5+,1,@25;!;.+7!);!#721)!)16!`162)I!Y,C5G.44E!/72;!*5C,*/!+)1!754C!21;C2*5!+,1+*5/5!)+/2,1;^!);!/75*5!2;!1,!
*5);,1!/,!=)2/!D5G,*5!=5!5@D)*L!,1!)1!211,N)/2N5!4,=O+)*D,1!65N54,C@51/!C)/7!M!)!C)/7!/7)/!5@D*)+5;!
211,N)/2,1^!5].2/E^!)16!45)65*;72CI!B72;!*5C,*/!;7,=;!/7)/!=5!+)1!6,!2/!2G!=5!=)1/!/,I!A,=!2;!/75!/2@5!G,*!
)+/2,1I!
!
>5112;!?)@421^!X4,D)4!?,42+E!96N2;,*^!<<%!'=5651!
()*+7!PWWV!
!
! \
Executive summary
B72;!*5C,*/!G,+.;5;!,1!/75!,CC,*/.12/25;!/,!*56.+5!/75!F*5517,.;5!F);!3XYX8!5@2;;2,1;!21!=,*LO*54)/56!
+,1/5S/;^! /7)1L;! /,! /75! 65C4,E@51/! ,G! `B! ;,4./2,1;! /7)/! 51)D45! ,15! ,*! @,*5! 2162N26.)4;! /,! =,*L! ,*!
+,44)D,*)/5! *5@,/54EI! `1! C)*/2+.4)*! /75! *5C,*/! )1)4E05;! /75! C,/51/2)4! );;,+2)/56! =2/7! /545=,*L21F! )16!
N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!/,!*56.+5!+)*D,1!5@2;;2,1;!G*,@!6)24E!+,@@./21F!DE!+)*!)16!D.;215;;!)2*!/*)N54^!)16!/75!
+,162/2,1;! .165*! =72+7! ;.+7! C,/51/2)4! +,.46! D5! *5)42056I! B75! F,)4! ,G! /75! *5C,*/! 2;! /,! F)21! )1!
.165*;/)1621F!,G!/75!;+)45!,G!/75!,CC,*/.12/25;!)N)24)D45!=7245!2651/2GE21F!/75!L5E!6*2N5*;!/7)/!@)E!51)D45!
,*!72165*!/75!G.44!)+725N5@51/!,G!;.+7!,CC,*/.12/25;I!-E!)1)4E021F!62GG5*51/!/*)c5+/,*25;!,G!C,;;2D45!G./.*5!
65N54,C@51/;^! /72;! *5C,*/! C*,N265;! 21;2F7/! 21/,! )! G./.*5! 21! =72+7! @)S2@.@! XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;!
+,.46!D5!)+725N56I!
B75!C*5@2;5! G,*! /75!)1)4E;2;! 2;! /7)/! `B! 2;!D5;/!;551!);!)! +)/)4E;/! /7)/! +)1!52/75*!D5!.;56! 21!=)E;! /7)/!
*56.+5! ,.*! 51N2*,1@51/)4! G,,/C*21/! ,*! +)1! D5! 65C4,E56! =2/721! ;E;/5@;! /7)/! .4/2@)/54E! *5;.4/! 21! )1!
21+*5);56!51N2*,1@51/)4!G,,/C*21/I!-5+).;5!/75!C,42+E!)16!5+,1,@2+!51N2*,1@51/!21!=72+7!`B!/5+71,4,FE!
2;!65C4,E56! 4)*F54E!65/5*@215;! 2/;!15/! 2@C)+/!,1!XYX!5@2;;2,1;^! /72;! *5C,*/!,./4215;! G,.*! ;+51)*2,;! G,*!
C,;;2D45! G./.*5! 65N54,C@51/;^! +7)*)+/5*2056! DE! 62GG5*51/! *,45;! )16! )//2/.65;! 21! C,42+E! @)L5*;! )16! `B!
216.;/*E!3;55!/)D45!D54,=8I!
B75!G2*;/!C)*/!,G!/75!*5C,*/!C*,N265;!)!D)+LF*,.16(,1!+.**51/!/*516;!21!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!
21!L5E!*5F2,1;!)*,.16!/75!=,*46I!B72;!2;!G,44,=56!DE!/75!65;+*2C/2,1!,G!G,.*!C,/51/2)4!dG./.*5!=,*46;e!/7)/!
=,.46! *5;.4/! 21!62GG5*51/!,./+,@5;! G,*!F4,D)4!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!B75! G21)4!C)*/!,G! /75!*5C,*/!62;+.;;5;! /75!
C,42+25;! )16! ;/*)/5F25;! /7)/! +)1! D5! 65C4,E56! c,21/4E^! DE! C,42+E! @)L5*;! )16! `B! C*,N265*;! )16! .;5*;^! /,!
G,;/5*!/75!)6,C/2,1!,G!;,4./2,1;!;.+7!);!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16!/,!@)S2@205!/752*!D515G2/;!
21!/5*@;!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;I!
!
! )*(+,-"'#&.(/0$12+%&(
!
`B!216.;/*E!)16!.;5*;!6,!1,/!)66*5;;!515*FE!)16!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!2;;.5;!;C5+2G2+)44E(
`B!216.;/*E!)16!.;5*;!)FF*5;;2N54E!C.*;.5!)16!,GG5*!+42@)/5!G*25164E!
;,4./2,1;(
3%4+5.(
-%61+,(
"GG5+/2N5!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!C,42+E^!21+4.621F!;.CC,*/!G,*!4,=O+)*D,1!`B!;,4./2,1;!
3%4+5.(7%&4-(((
861&#(7%&4-((
<5)L!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!C,42+E^!2F1,*21F!/75!*,45!,G!4,=O+)*D,1!`B!
91&/%,(7%&4-((
(
*05$(7%&4-((
(
*1/40(:;(<20&2+07(%=(="#"&0(7%&4-'(
'/*)/5F2+!+7,2+5;!,G!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)16!51/5*C*2;5;!=244!65/5*@215!=72+7!G./.*5!=,*46!=5!=244! 42N5!21I!B75!
62GG5*51/! G./.*5!=,*46;! )1)4E056! 21! /75! *5C,*/! 6,! 1,/! *5C*5;51/! G,*5+);/;! ,G! G./.*5! 65N54,C@51/a! /75E!
*5C*5;51/!21;/5)6!)!C,*/G,42,!,G!,C/2,1;!)N)24)D45!/,!/75!F4,D)4!+,@@.12/EI!!
%,*! 5)+7! ,G! /75! C,;;2D45! /*)c5+/,*25;^! /75! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;! );;,+2)/56! =2/7! D.;215;;! )2*! /*)N54! )16! +)*!
+,@@./21F!)*5!5;/2@)/56!].)1/2/)/2N54E!/,!+,1/*);/!)16!+,@C)*5!62GG5*51/!G./.*5!=,*46;^!)16!/,!)1)4E05!
/75!*56.+/2,1!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!/7)/!@)E!D5!51)D456!DE!`B!/7*,.F7!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16!/545+,@@./21FI!!
<20&2+07(%=(
>="#"&0(7%&4-'?(
!
! Z
b/242021F! 62GG5*51/! C*,c5+/2,1;! ,G! G./.*5! =,*46;^! /75! *5C,*/! )1)4E05;! 1,/! ,14E! /75! 62*5+/! 5GG5+/! ,G! /75;5!
/5+71,4,F25;! D./!)4;,!62GG5*51/! /EC5;!,G! 2162*5+/!5GG5+/;! G*,@! /75!.C/)L5!,G! /75;5! /5+71,4,F25;! /7)/! +)1!
*5;.4/!21!D,/7!65+*5);56!)16!21+*5);56!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!B75;5!+)1!D5!+7)*)+/5*2056!21!/=,!=)E;f!
• _,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+L^!2G!)!;,4./2,1!/7)/!62*5+/4E!45)6;!/,!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!)4;,!F515*)/5;!
+7)1F5;!21!D57)N2,*^!5+,1,@2+!)+/2N2/25;^!C*,+5;;5;^!,*!;,+25/)4!,*F)120)/2,1;!/7)/!21!/.*1!45)6!/,!
)662/2,1)4!XYX!*56.+/2,1;I!
! Y2F7O+)*D,1!G556D)+L^! 2G!)!;,4./2,1!/7)/!62*5+/4E!45)6;!/,!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!)4;,! 45)6;!/,!
+7)1F5;!21!D57)N2,*^!5+,1,@2+!)+/2N2/25;^!C*,+5;;5;^!,*!;,+25/)4!,*F)120)/2,1;!/7)/!21!/.*1!45)6!/,!
)662/2,1)4!XYX! 5@2;;2,1;^!=72+7!@)E! 15F)/5^! 21! G.44! ,*! C)*/2)44E^! /75!XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;!
212/2)44Eg62*5+/4E!)+725N56I!
!
@0.(=+,-+,A'(
• B75! )1)4E;2;! 72F742F7/;! /7)/! /75! N,4.@5! ,G! XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! C,/51/2)44E! 6542N5*56! DE!
/545=,*L21F! 2;! 4)*F5*! /7)1! /75! N,4.@5! C,/51/2)44E! 6542N5*56! DE! N2*/.)4! @55/21F;! 3;55! F*)C7;!
D54,=8I! B545=,*L21F! 2;! 1,/! /75! ;)@5! );! d7,@5! =,*Lea! 21+*5);21F4E! C5,C45! =,*L! 21! N)*2,.;!
4,+)/2,1;!,./;265!/75!=,*LC4)+5I!
• ()S2@.@!D515G2/;!+)1!D5!)+725N56!21!)!;@)*/!=,*46!=75*5!D,/7!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)16!C*2N)/5O;5+/,*!
+,@C)125;! C*,6.+5! )16! .;5! `B! K8! =,*L! /,F5/75*! /,! 45N5*)F5! /545=,*L21F! )16! N2*/.)4! @55/21F!
;,4./2,1;! );! /,,4;! /,! 6542N5*! XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! =7245! P8! 2@C45@51/21F! ;/*)/5F25;! /7)/!
*56.+5! /75! *2;L;! ,G! 15F)/2N5! *5D,.16! 5GG5+/;! )16! 21+*5);5! /75! ,CC,*/.12/25;! /,! )+725N5! N2*/.)4!
+E+45;! ,G! 4,=O+)*D,1! G556D)+L! 3;55! /)D45! P^! D54,=8I! %,*! 5S)@C45^! /72;! @2F7/! ,++.*! =75*5! /75!
F)21;! G*,@! 21+*5);56! .;5! ,G! 4,=O+)*D,1! `B! ;,4./2,1;! /*2FF5*! G.*/75*! )+/2,1;! /7)/! *56.+5! XYX!
5@2;;2,1;I! 3`1+*5);56! .;5! ,G! /545=,*L21F! +)1^! G,*! 5S)@C45^! 21+*5);5! +,115+/2N2/E! )16! @)L5! 2/!
5);25*! G,*! C5,C45! /,! 7)N5! )! ;@)*/! 7,.;5! ,*! /,! D.E! 4,+)4! F,,6;! ,14215! 21;/5)6! ,G! 6*2N21F! /,! )!
;.C5*@)*L5/!/,!D.E!F,,6;!=2/7!)!72F7!+)*D,1!G,,/C*21/8I!!
• B75! 62GG5*51+5! 21! 5@2;;2,1! ;)N21F;! D5/=551! /75! +)*D,1!=,*46! 34,=5;/! ;)N21F;! ,N5*)448! )16! /75!
;@)*/!=,*46!372F75;/!;)N21F;!,N5*)448!2;!;2F12G2+)1/!M!5IFI^!G,*!/545=,*L21F!)D,./!K!D2442,1!/,1;!,G!
#$P!5@2;;2,1;!62GG5*51/2)/5!/75!/=,!;+51)*2,;!21!E5)*!PWRW!3)CC*,S2@)/54E!5].2N)451/!/,!/75!/,/)4!
+.**51/! #$P! 5@2;;2,1;! G*,@! b[! )16! `/)4E! +,@D21568! )16! )4@,;/! RIQ! D2442,1! /,1;! 21! E5)*! PWQW!
3)4@,;/! );! @.+7! );! /75! "bh;! /,/)4! #$P! 5@2;;2,1;! ,*! @,*5! /7)1! 7)4G! ,G! /75! b'h;! +.**51/! #$P!
5@2;;2,1;8I!!
• B75!,/75*!/7*55!G./.*5!=,*46;!6,!1,/!6542N5*!+)*D,1!*56.+/2,1;!);!;2F12G2+)1/!);!/7,;5!,GG5*56!DE!
/75!;@)*/!=,*46!D5+).;5!K8!/75E!);;.@5!)!4,=5*!.C/)L5!,G!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!,*!P8!
/75!F)21;!G*,@!21+*5);56!.;5!,G!4,=O+)*D,1!`B!;,4./2,1;!)*5!,GG;5/!DE!,/75*!)+/2,1;!/7)/!.4/2@)/54E!
21+*5);5! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;! 32I5I^! 15F)/2N5! *5D,.16! 5GG5+/;8I! %,*! 5S)@C45^! /75! 21+*5);56! .;5! ,G!
/545=,*L21F! +)1! *5;.4/! 21! C5,C45! D.E21F! D2FF5*! +)*;! )16! 6*2N21F!@,*5!,*! 5N51! 4,1F5*! 62;/)1+5;!
/7)1!/75E!626!=751!/75E!=5*5!+,@@./21F!/,!/75!,GG2+5^!,*!21!/75@!)CC4E21F!;)N21F;!G*,@!*56.+56!
+,@@./21F!/,!72F7O+)*D,1!F,,6;!)16!;5*N2+5;!;.+7!);!N)+)/2,1;!/7)/!*5].2*5!4,1F!G42F7/;I!!
• `1;/5)6!,G!4,,L21F!)/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!);!;,@5/721F!15F)/2N5^!2/!2;!2@C,*/)1/!/,!*5+,F1205!/7)/!21!
/75! *2F7/! C,42+E! 51N2*,1@51/^! *5D,.16! 5GG5+/;! +)1! 754C! *56.+5! /75! 5@2;;2,1;! 5N51! G.*/75*^! )!
;2/.)/2,1! L1,=1! );! 4,=O+)*D,1! G556D)+LI! U2*/.,.;! +E+45;! ,G! 4,=O+)*D,1! G556D)+L! +)1! ,14E! D5!
)+725N56!=751!C,42+E!@)L5*;^!`B!.;5*;^!)16!/75!`B!216.;/*E!=,*L!/,F5/75*!/,!65C4,E!)CC*,C*2)/5!
C,42+E!@5);.*5;!)16!;/*)/5F25;I!
!
! T
• <75*5);!$"#>!+,.1/*25;!@)E!6542N5*!/75!@)c,*2/E!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!21!/75!;7,*/!/5*@^!
65N54,C21F! )16! 5@5*F21F! +,.1/*25;! +)1! C*,N265! )! F*,=21F! ;7)*5! ,G! G./.*5! *56.+/2,1;! )16!=244^!
G*,@!)D,./!E5)*!PWRW^!6542N5*!/75!@)c,*2/E!,G!15=!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;I!B545=,*L21F!)4,15!+,.46!
)+725N5!,N5*!KIR!D2442,1!/,1;!,G!*56.+/2,1;!21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!D5/=551!PWRW!)16!PWQW!3JPK!
(/#$P!21!#721)!)4,158!+,@C)*56!/,!TZ\!(/#$P!21!$"#>!+,.1/*25;!G,*!/75!;)@5!/2@5!C5*2,6I!
• 9!=5D+)@O5].2CC56!4)C/,C!)16!@,D245!)16!=2*545;;!+,115+/2N2/E^!);!=544!);!5GG5+/2N5!)16!;5+.*5!
;,G/=)*5^!)*5!/75!L5E!/5+712+)4!*5].2*5@51/;!G,*!/545=,*L21FI!B75;5!;,4./2,1;!)4*5)6E!5S2;/^!)16!
/75!;,,15*!)!D*,)6!65C4,E@51/!+)1!/)L5!C4)+5!/75!G);/5*!;2F12G2+)1/!*56.+/2,1;!+)1!D5!)+725N56I!9!
+*2/2+)4!G)+/,*!/,!;.CC,*/!D*,)6!65C4,E@51/!2;!,*F)120)/2,1)4!D.EO21!G,*!/545=,*L21FI!
• >5;C2/5! /75! *5D,.16! 5GG5+/;^! /75! C*5N)451/! +,1;51;.;! 21! /75! 42/5*)/.*5! 2;! /7)/! ,N5*)44!
/545+,@@./21F! *56.+5;! /75! 62;/)1+5! /*)N5456! )16! /75! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;! /7)/! *5;.4/! G*,@!
/*)1;C,*/)/2,1I!(
!
!
!
!B&1C$(:D(9<E(06+''+%,'(=&%6(5%66"#+,A(1,-(/"'+,0''(1+&(#&1204(+,(C&%F05#+%,'(%=(="#"&0(7%&4-';(
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
'$""
'%""
'&""
#""" #""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$%
&'"()*#$% +,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/34*56"*'0*7',6*8'19-/34*
:,;(<"*(/=*>6?'2/=*+006<".
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
$""
$("
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
@-1<1(0"*#$% +,-..-'/.*A2.-/6..*&1(B6)4*56"*'0*C-1"2()*
!66"-/3.D*:,;(<"4*#'116<"6=*0'1*>6?'2/=*+006<".*!"#$%
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
!
! V
3%4+5+0'(1,-('#&1#0A+0'(!
B75*5!)*5!;5N5*)4!1,O*5F*5/!;,4./2,1;!/7)/!+)1!D5!2@C45@51/56!21!)!*54)/2N54E!;7,*/!/2@5!G*)@5^!;.+7!);!
45N5*)F21F!,G!C*,+.*5@51/!C*)+/2+5;!)16!62;;5@21)/21F!D5;/OC*)+/2+5!+);5;I!!
(,;/!,G! /75;5!)+/2N2/25;!)*5!@,;/!5GG5+/2N54E!.165*/)L51!=2/7! /75!)+/2N5!C)*/2+2C)/2,1!,G!D,/7! /75!C.D42+!
)16!C*2N)/5!;5+/,*^!);!72F742F7/56!DE!/75!/)D45!D54,=f!
!
( 3"/4+5('05#%&( )*(+,-"'#&.( G01-+,A()*(H'0&'(
I*&0,-'0##0&'J(
"1;.*5!D*,)6D)16!21G*);/*.+/.*5!
:5F.4)/,*E!G*)@5=,*L!)16!21+51/2N5;i!
>2*5+/!21N5;/@51/iii! !
-.246!L1,=456F5!)16!+)C)+2/E!,1!`B!.;5!/,!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!
d#,*5!D.;215;;e!,G!/75!C.D42+!;5+/,*iii!
(,;/!L1,=456F5)D45!,1!/5+71,4,FE!)16!2/;!.;5;iii!
>2*5+/!5SC5*251+5!)16!C*)+/2+)4!21;2F7/iii!
:5@,N5!*5F.4)/,*E!D)**25*;!!
9;;5;;!)16!*5N2;5!*5F.4)/2,1iii!
`651/2GE!D)**25*;!)16!C*,C,;5!;,4./2,1;ii!
`651/2GE!D)**25*;!)16!C*,C,;5!;,4./2,1;ii!
_5N5*)F5!C*,+.*5@51/!/,!;.CC,*/!XYX!*56.+/2,1;!=2/7!4,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+L!
iii! ii! ii!
9*/2+.4)/5!@5/7,6,4,F25;!G,*!6)/)!+,445+/2,1!)16!)1)4E;2;!!
%,*!62;;5@21)/2,1!)16!;/)16)*620)/2,1i!
<,*L!=2/7!+.;/,@5*;!)16!G)+242/)/5iii!
>2*5+/!)CC42+)/2,1!)16!;/)16)*6!65N54,C@51/iii!
'E;/5@)/2+)44E!);;5;;!/75!XYX!2@C)+/!,G!`B!;,4./2,1;!321+4.621F!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;8!
%,*!@)+*,O45N54!)1)4E;5;iii!
'E;/5@)/2+)44E!);;5;;!/75!2@C)+/!,G!C*,6.+/;!)16!;5*N2+5;iii!
X)21!62*5+/!5SC5*251+5!)16!C*)+/2+)4!21;2F7/iii!
'5/!.C!6)/)!+,445+/2,1!;E;/5@;!
()+*,!45N54!)16!/,!+*5)/5!;/)16)*6;iii!
"@D56!6)/)!+,445+/2,1!)16!+,@@.12+)/2,1!+)C)D242/25;!21!`Biii!
`@C45@51/!+,@C)1EO!)16!;.CC4EO+7)21O=265!;E;/5@;iii!
>2;;5@21)/5!D5;/!C*)+/2+5;! #,.1/*E!45N54iii! <2/7!+.;/,@5*;!)16!C,42+E!@)L5*;iii!
<2/7!C55*;^!;.CC425*;^!)16!C,42+E!@)L5*;iii!
`1/*,6.+5!C,42+25;!/7)/!+7)1154!*5;,.*+5;!/,=)*6;!+*5)/21F!4,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+L!
9;;5;;!)16!65N54,C!)CC*,C*2)/5!C,42+25;iii!
?*,N265!)6N2+5!)16!5SC4,*5!;,4./2,1;ii!
?*,N265!)6N2+5!)16!5SC4,*5!;,4./2,1;ii!
B5+71,4,FE!65N54,C@51/!)16!/)24,*21F!/,!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!
?*,N265!;.CC,*/!)16!L1,=456F5iii!
>5N54,C!/5+71,4,F25;iii!
Y54C!)*/2+.4)/5!*5].2*5@51/;iii!
#)C)+2/E!D.24621F!)16!62;;5@21)/2,1!21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!
'.CC,*/!=2/7!/,,4;!!)16!G.1621F!21;/*.@51/;iii!
<,*L!=2/7!4,+)4!)16!;.CC425*;!)16!+.;/,@5*;iii!
<,*L!=2/7!4,+)4!;.CC425*;!)16!+.;/,@5*;iii!
!i!_2@2/56!*,45! !!ii!(562.@!2@C,*/)1/!*,45! iii!`@C,*/)1/!*,45!
!*1/40(ED(3%4+5+0'(1,-('#&1#0A+0'(#%(&0-"50(BKB(06+''+%,'(7+#$()*(1,-((A0,0&1#0(4%7L51&/%,(=00-/15M(+,(&041#+%,(#%(-+==0&0,#('#1M0$%4-0&'(
I*$0(,%#0'(+,(015$(5%4"6,(C&%2+-0(1('$%&#(0NC41,1#+%,(%=(#$0(&%40(%=(-+==0&0,#('#1M0$%4-0&';J(;(
(
-E! c,21/4E! =,*L21F! /,=)*6;! /75! 2@C45@51/)/2,1! ,G! /75;5! ;/*)/5F25;^! C,42+E! @)L5*;! )16! C*2N)/5O;5+/,*!
+,@C)125;!@)E!51)D45!`B!)CC42+)/2,1;^!;.+7!);!/75!,15;!;.CC,*/21F!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;^!/,!
F)21!)!D*,)65*!)++5C/)1+5!)16!.;5!21!;,+25/EI!B75E!=,.46!6542N5*!F*5)/5*!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!=7245!
42D5*)/21F! *5;,.*+5;! )16! C*,N2621F! @,654;! /7)/! +)1! 754C! *56.+5! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;! @,*5! D*,)64E^! /7.;!
G,;/5*21F! 4,=O+)*D,1! G556D)+LI! `G! /72;! C,/51/2)4! 2;! G.44E! /)CC56^! /75! XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! +)1! D5!
6*)@)/2+I!!
!
! KW
B,!244.;/*)/5!/75!62GG5*51/!,C/2,1;^!<<%!7);!65N54,C56!)!=5D!/,,4!/7)/!@)L5;!2/!2;!C,;;2D45!/,!5SC4,*5!/75!
C,;;2D45!,./+,@5;IK!
!
@0.(&05%660,-1#+%,'(
O >5N54,C!*2F,*,.;^!/*)1;C)*51/!@5/7,6,4,F25;!/,!5N)4.)/5!/75!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!)+725N56!=2/7!
`B!;,4./2,1;!)16!62;+4,;5!.;5!)16!C,/51/2)4!;)N21F;!21G,*@)/2,1I!
O `B!+,@C)125;!@.;/!/75@;54N5;!.;5!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16!;.CC,*/!/545=,*L21F!M!)!@.;/!/,!D5!)D45!
/,!65@,1;/*)/5!/7)/!`B!+,@C)125;!D5425N5!21!/752*!,=1!;,4./2,1;I!!
O "1;.*5!2@C*,N56!21G*);/*.+/.*5!D,/7!G,*!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16!/545=,*L21F!M!+2/25;!;7,.46!21+4.65!
/545=,*L21F!21!/752*!/*)1;C,*/!;/*)/5F25;!)16!51;.*5!/7)/!+,115+/2N2/E!2;!C,;;2D45!G*,@!)44!*545N)1/!
C4)+5;I!!
O _,=O+)*D,1! `B! ;,4./2,1;! @.;/! D5! 21+4.656! 21! +42@)/5! +7)1F5! ;/*)/5F25;! )16! ;C5+2G2+)44E! 21!
/*)1;C,*/!)16!21G*);/*.+/.*5!C,42+E!C*,+5;;5;I!
O 9*/2+.4)/5! )16! 21/*,6.+5! C,42+25;! /7)/! 542@21)/5! 15F)/2N5! *5D,.16! 5GG5+/;! )16! C*,@,/5! N2*/.,.;!
+E+45;! ,G! 4,=O+)*D,1! G556D)+L! M! 5IFI^! =751! *5;,.*+5;! 3/2@5! ,*! @,15E8! )*5! 42D5*)/56^!
)./,@)/2+)44E! C*,N265! 21+51/2N5;! G,*! /7,;5! *5;,.*+5;! /,! D5! 21N5;/56! 21! =)E;! /7)/! 45)6! /,!
*56.+/2,1;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!)16!;.CC,*/!G.*/75*!*56.+/2,1;I!!
O 9;;5;;! 5S2;/21F! ;.D;2625;! G,*! 72F7O+)*D,1! ;5*N2+5;! 35IFI^! ;.D;2625;! G,*! +)*!,=15*;72C^! 21+*5);56!
/)S)/2,1! ,1! *,,@;! =75*5! /545=,*L21F! +)1! /)L5! C4)+5^! )16! /)SOG21)1+56! 21N5;/@51/;! 21!
21G*);/*.+/.*5!/7)/!51+,.*)F5!21+*5);56!.;5!,G!+)*;!)16!C4)15;8!)16!65N54,C!;E;/5@;!/7)/!)44,=!
G,*!)!/5+71,4,FEO15./*)4!+,@C5/2/2,1!/,!C*,N265!;2@24)*!;5*N2+5;I!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!1 '55!===IC)16)I,*Fg2+/!G,*!)!421L!/,!/75!/,,4I
!
! KK
Introduction
B72;! *5C,*/! G,+.;5;! ,1! /=,! )CC42+)/2,1;! ,G! `Bf! /545=,*L21F! )16! N2*/.)4! @55/21F;I! B75E! @)E! 45)6! /,! )!
*56.+/2,1!21!/75!65@)16!G,*!+,@@./5O!)16!D.;215;;O*54)/56!/*)N54!)16!/75!);;,+2)/56!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!
! !"#"$%&'()*+, 2;!65G2156!);!C5*G,*@21F!=,*L^!52/75*! G,*!)1!,./;265!5@C4,E5*!,*!/7*,.F7!;54GO
5@C4,E@51/^!)/!7,@5!,*!G*,@!)1E!*5@,/5! 4,+)/2,1!35IFI^!)=)E!G*,@!/75!,GG2+5!,*!)1E!,/75*!
d/*)62/2,1)4e!=,*LC4)+58I!
! -(&./0#, 1"".()*2+, )4;,! L1,=1! );, ."#"3%)4"&")3()*^! )*5! 65G2156! );! =,*LO*54)/56! @55/21F;!
21N,4N21F! /=,! ,*! @,*5! F5,F*)C72+)44E! ;5C)*)/56! 4,+)/2,1;! )16! 51)D456! DE! /75! .;5! ,G!
/545+,@@.12+)/2,1! )CC42+)/2,1;^! 21! =72+7! +,@@.12+)/2,1! @)E! D5! 5S+4.;2N54E! ).62,!
30/5(%3%)4"&")3()*8^! ).62,! )16! N265,! 36(5"%3%)4"&")3()*8^! ,*! 51)D456! DE! /75! =5D! 3$"7,
3%)4"&")3()*8IP!
b/242021F! 62GG5*51/! C*,c5+/2,1;! ,G! G./.*5! =,*46;^! /72;! *5C,*/! )1)4E05;! 1,/! ,14E! /75! 62*5+/! 5GG5+/! ,G! /75;5!
)CC42+)/2,1;!D./!)4;,!62GG5*51/!/EC5;!,G!2162*5+/!5GG5+/;!G*,@!/752*!.C/)L5!/7)/!+)1!*5;.4/!21!D,/7!21+*5);56!
)16!*56.+56!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!'.+7!6E1)@2+;!)*5!75*5!65G2156!);!!
! 4,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+L^!2G!)!;,4./2,1!/7)/!62*5+/4E!45)6;!/,!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!)4;,!F515*)/5;!
+7)1F5;!21!D57)N2,*^!5+,1,@2+!)+/2N2/25;^!C*,+5;;5;^!,*!;,+25/)4!,*F)120)/2,1;!/7)/!21!/.*1!45)6!/,!
)662/2,1)4!XYX!*56.+/2,1;^!)16!
! 72F7O+)*D,1!G556D)+L^! 2G!)!;,4./2,1! /7)/!62*5+/4E! 45)6;! /,!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!)4;,! 45)6;! /,!
+7)1F5;!21!D57)N2,*^!5+,1,@2+!)+/2N2/25;^!C*,+5;;5;^!,*!;,+25/)4!,*F)120)/2,1;!/7)/!21!/.*1!45)6!/,!
)662/2,1)4!XYX! 5@2;;2,1;^!=72+7!@)E! 15F)/5^! 21! G.44! ,*! C)*/2)44E^! /75!XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;!
212/2)44Eg62*5+/4E!)+725N56I!
B75! 21;2F7/!F)2156!=2/7!/72;!)1)4E;2;!+)1!7,C5G.44E!754C!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)16!+,@C)125;!)*/2+.4)/5!C,42+25;!
)16!;/*)/5F25;!/7)/!@)S2@205!/75!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!)+725N56!=2/7!`BI!
B75!*5C,*/!2;!,*F)12056!21!/75!G,44,=21F!;5+/2,1;f!
'5+/2,1! P! C*,N265;!/15MA&%",-( ,1! /75! `B! ;,4./2,1;! /7)/! )*5! /75! G,+.;! ,G! /72;! *5C,*/! DE! 65G2121F! /75!
;.Dc5+/!,G!/75!)1)4E;2;a!244.;/*)/21F!6*2N5*;^!.;5;^!)16!/*516;a!)16!62;+.;;21F!/75!+,1+5C/.)4!421L!D5/=551!
/75;5!`B!;,4./2,1;!)16!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!
B75!)CC*,)+7!,G!/72;!*5C,*/!2;!/,!);;5;;!/75!C,;;2D45!2@C)+/!,G!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!,1!XYX!
5@2;;2,1;! .165*! 62GG5*51/! /*)c5+/,*25;! ,G! G./.*5! 65N54,C@51/;I! '5+/2,1! R! =244! /75*5G,*5! C*,N265! )!
-0'5&+C#+%,(%=( #$0(C%''+/40( ="#"&0'O!,*!G./.*5!=,*46;^!/7)/!)*5!)1)4E056!)16!62;+.;;56!21!/72;!*5C,*/I!
B75E!6,!1,/!*5C*5;51/!G,*5+);/;!,G!G./.*5!65N54,C@51/!D./!)*5!].)42/)/2N5!*5C*5;51/)/2,1;I!!
%,*! 5)+7! ,G! /75! C,;;2D45! /*)c5+/,*25;! /75( BKB( 06+''+%,'! );;,+2)/56! =2/7! D.;215;;! )2*! /*)N54! )16! +)*!
+,@@./21F!7)N5!D551!0'#+61#0-(P"1,#+#1#+204.!/,!+,1/*);/!)16!+,@C)*5!`BO51)D456!*56.+/2,1;!21!/75!
62GG5*51/! G./.*5! =,*46;^! /7*,.F7! N2*/.)4! @55/21F;! )16! /545+,@@./21FI! B75! *5;.4/;! ,G! /72;! )1)4E;2;! )*5!
C*5;51/56!21!;5+/2,1;!J!)16!QI!'5+/2,1!J!65;+*2D5;!/75!@5/7,6,4,FE!.;56!/,!@,654!XYX!5@2;;2,1;^!=7245!
;5+/2,1!Q!62;+.;;5;!/75!*5;.4/;!,G!/75!;2@.4)/2,1;!.165*/)L51I!!
B75!)1)4E;2;!72F742F7/;!/75!L5E!*,45!/7)/!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)16!/75!`B!216.;/*E!+)1!C4)E!21!*5)42021F!)!G./.*5!
/7)/!G.44E!45N5*)F5;!`B!/,!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!G*,@!D.;215;;!/*)N54!)16!+)*!+,@@./21FI!B75*5G,*5!2/!=244!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!P!9@,1F!/75!,/75*!`#B!)CC42+)/2,1;!1,/!62;+.;;56!21!/72;!*5C,*/^!,15!,G!/75!@,;/!21/5*5;/21F!)16!C,C.4)*!2;!L1,=1!);!$"7302.()*,32I5I^!dD*,)6+);/21Fe!,N5*!/75!`1/5*15/8^,=72+7!*5G5*;!/,!)!1,1O21/5*)+/2N5^!d,15O/,O@)1Ee!3);!,CC,;56!/,!d,15O/,O,15e8!G,*@!,G!+,@@.12+)/2,1I!<5D+);/21F!2;!.;56!5S/51;2N54E!21!/75!+,@@5*+2)4!;5+/,*!G,*!21N5;/,*!*54)/2,1;!C*5;51/)/2,1;!)16!5O45)*121F^!)16!G,*!*54)/56!+,@@.12+)/2,1;!)+/2N2/25;I!
!
! KP
D5! +*2/2+)4! /,! 2@C45@51/! C%4+5+0'( 1,-( '#&1#0A+0'! /7)/! @)S2@205! /75! 5GG5+/2N515;;g5GG2+251+E! ,G! `B!
;,4./2,1;!321!/5*@;!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;8!)16!/752*!65C4,E@51/I!'.+7!+,@C45@51/)*E!C,42+25;!)16!
;/*)/5F25;!)*5!62;+.;;56!21!;5+/2,1!\I!
B75!6,+.@51/!+,1+4.65;!M!21!;5+/2,1!Z!M!=2/7!)!'"661&.!,G!/75!@)21!*5;.4/;!*5)+756^!/752*!;2F12G2+)1+5^!
)16!/75!2@C42+)/2,1;!G,*!G./.*5!)+/2N2/25;I!
9!1.@D5*!,G!1CC0,-+50'!)*5!21+4.656!=2/7!)662/2,1)4!D)+LF*,.16!21G,*@)/2,1!)16!)1)4E/2+)4!65/)24;I!
!
1 Background `1G,*@)/2,1!)16!+,@@.12+)/2,1!/5+71,4,F25;!3`Bg`#B8!C*,N265!)!D*,)6!*)1F5!,G!;,4./2,1;!/,!D,/7!C.D42+!
)16!C*2N)/5!,*F)120)/2,1;!)16!D.;215;;5;^!C)*/2+.4)*4E!21!/75!;5*N2+5!216.;/*EI!'551!G*,@!)!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!
C5*;C5+/2N5^!/75;5!;,4./2,1;!)*5!21/5*5;/21F^!);!/75E!+)1!*56.+5!/75!1556!/,!/*)N54!G,*!=,*LO*54)/56!
C.*C,;5;^!/7.;!51)D421F!)!*56.+/2,1!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!G*,@!/*)1;C,*/)/2,1I!(,*5,N5*^!/75;5!;,4./2,1;!+)1!
C,/51/2)44E!;.CC,*/!G.*/75*!*56.+/2,1;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!21!,/75*!C)*/;!,G!;,+25/E!2G!+,@C45@51/)*E!
@5);.*5;!)*5!C./!21!C4)+5^!2I5I^!/75E!+,.46!D5!21;/*.@51/)4!21!)+725N21F!#%$830&7%),4""5703'9R,
!
`1! )662/2,1! /,! /752*! C,/51/2)4! +,1/*2D./2,1! /,! XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;^! D,/7! /545=,*L21F! )16!
/545+,1G5*51+21F! )*5! 21+*5);21F4E! C5*+52N56! DE! +,@C)125;! );! C*,6.+/2N2/E! )16! 5GG2+251+E! 517)1+5*;^! );!
/75E!;7,=!D515G2/;!1,/!,14E!21!/5*@;!,G!+,;/!*56.+/2,1!)16!51N2*,1@51/)4!C5*G,*@)1+5!D./!)4;,!21!/5*@;!
,G! 21+*5);56!5+,1,@2+! C5*G,*@)1+5!)16! ;,+2)4! D515G2/;I! %,*! 5S)@C45^! ./242021F! )! 65/)2456!].5;/2,11)2*5!
=2/7! 2/;! 5@C4,E55;^! 9BjB! 5;/)D42;756! /7)/! /75! 2@C45@51/)/2,1! ,G! /545+,@@./21F! C*)+/2+5;! =2/721! 2/;!
+,@C)1E! =);! );;,+2)/56! =2/7! )1! 21+*5);5! 21! C*,6.+/2N2/E! )16! c,D! ;)/2;G)+/2,1! )@,1F! /545+,@@./5*;I!
(,*5,N5*^!9BjB!5;/2@)/56!/7)/!/545+,@@./5*;!;)N56!)D,./!QIK!@2442,1!F)44,1;!,G!F);,4215!35].2N)451/!/,!
)D,./!JJ^WWW!@5/*2+!/,1;!,G!)N,2656!N572+45!5@2;;2,1;8IJ!
!
?*,6.+/2N2/E!2@C*,N5@51/;!=5*5!)4;,!2651/2G256!);!L5E!D515G2/;!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;^!);!72F742F7/56!21!/75!
F*)C7! D54,=! G*,@! )1! 5)*4E! ;/.6E! ,1! N265,+,1G5*51+21FI! '2@24)*! D515G2/;! =5*5! *5C,*/56! DE! :,E! )16!
%242;/*).4/! 3KVVT8^! =7,^! D);56! ,1! )! ;.*N5E! +,16.+/56! )@,1F! D.;215;;! /*)N545*;^! +,1+4.656! /7)/!
/545+,1G5*51+21F!+)1!)++545*)/5!65+2;2,1!@)L21F!DE!*)C264E!421L21F!L5E!C4)E5*;I!%21)44E^!Y,CL21;,1!5/!)4I!
3PWWR8^! 21!/752*!;.*N5E!,G!-B!5@C4,E55;^!G,.16!/7)/!TP!C5*+51/!G54/!/7)/!/545+,1G5*51+21F!7)6!2@C*,N56!
/752*!=,*L!C5*G,*@)1+5^!21+4.621F!JJ!C5*+51/!=7,!G54/!/72;!2@C*,N5@51/!=);!+,1;265*)D45I!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!R!#,1N5*;54E^!2G!;.**,.1621F!+,162/2,1;!)*5!.1G)N,*)D45^!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!212/2)44E!)+725N56!DE!/545=,*L21F!,*!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!@)E!D5!+,.1/5*D)4)1+56!DE!;5+,16)*E!5GG5+/;!/7)/!456!/,!72F75*!XYX!5@2;;2,1;^!)!;2/.)/2,1!/7)/!@)E!5N51!45)6!/,!15/!21+*5);5;!21!+)*D,1!5@2;;2,1;I!B75;5!;2/.)/2,1;!@)E!D5!65G2156!);!72F7O+)*D,1!G556D)+LI!_,=O!)16!72F7O+)*D,1!G556D)+L!=244!D5!G.*/75*!62;+.;;56!21!;5+/2,1!KIJ!)16!21!/75!+7)C/5*;!D54,=I!4 9BjB^!PWWPa!9BjB^!KVVZI
!
! KR
!
!(
B&1C$(ED(Q==05#'(%=(2+-0%5%,=0&0,5+,A(%,(600#+,A';(
!
`1! )!@,*5! *5+51/! ;/.6E^!>51;/)642! 3PWWJ8! /*256! /,! 2651/2GE! )16! *)1L! /75!@)21! G)+/,*;! /7)/! 45)6! +5*/)21!
D.;215;;5;!/,!+7,,;5!N265,+,1G5*51+21F!,N5*!C7E;2+)4!/*)N54!3;55!F*)C7!D54,=8I!9++,*621F!/,!/75!;.*N5E!
+,16.+/56! DE! >51;/)642! 3PWWJ8^! N265,+,1G5*51+21F! )44,=;! G,*! ;.D;/)1/2)4! *56.+/2,1! ,G! /*)N54! +,;/;! )16!
,GG5*;!/75!D515G2/!,G!*54)/56!/2@5!;)N21F;I!9/!/75!;)@5!/2@5^!/7*,.F7!N265,+,1G5*51+21F^!@,*5!G*5].51/!
@55/21F;! =2/7! @,*5! C)*/2+2C)1/;! M! =7,! ,/75*=2;5! =,.46! 1,/! 7)N5! /*)N5456! M! +)1! /)L5! C4)+5! )/! )!
+,1;265*)D4E!4,=5*!+,;/I!B72;!@5)1;!/7)/!@,*5!C5,C45!=2/7!62GG5*51/!D)+LF*,.16;!)16!C5*;C5+/2N5;!+)1!D5!
D*,.F7/! /,! /75! dN2*/.)4! /)D45^e! 51*2+721F! /75! 62;+.;;2,1! )16! 45)621F^! 5N51/.)44E^! /,! )! @,*5! 21G,*@56!
65+2;2,1I!(,*5,N5*^!;,@5!;/.625;!35IFI^!>.)*/5!)16!'1E65*^!PWWK8!7)N5!;7,=1!/7)/!C)*/2+2C)1/;!21!N2*/.)4!
@55/21F;!/516!/,!D5!N5*E!+,1+51/*)/56!)16!G,+.;56^!517)1+21F!/75!5GG5+/2N515;;!,G!/75!65+2;2,1O@)L21F!
C*,+5;;^!21!4215!=2/7!/75!G21621F;!,G!/75!;/.6E!DE!:,E!)16!%242;/*).4/!3KVVT8I!91,/75*!2@C,*/)1/!G5)/.*5!,G!
N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!425;!21!/75!G)+/!/7)/!/75E!+)1!D5!*5+,*656^!F2N21F!C)*/2+2C)1/;!/75!C,;;2D242/E!/,!;.@@)*205!
)16!)1)4E05!/75!62;+.;;2,1!)G/5*=)*6;I!`1/5*5;/21F4E!>51;/)642h;!;.*N5E!)4;,!72F742F7/;!/7)/!51N2*,1@51/)4!
+,1;265*)/2,1;!+.**51/4E!6,!1,/!*)1L!72F7!);!)!6*2N5*!G,*!/75!)6,C/2,1!,G!N265,+,1G5*51+21F!;,4./2,1;I!
91
81
50
48
42
31
19
14
0 20 40 60 80 100
Save the environment
Internal training/upgrading
Improve contact with clients/suppliers Reduce travel fatigue
Increase efficienc y of decision making Improve internal contact
Reduce travel costs Time
savings
!B&1C$(R;(S01'%,'(=%&(1-%C#+,A(2+-0%5%,=0&0,5+,A;(8%"&50D(T0,'#1-4+(IEUUVJ;(
!
!
! KJ
B75! 1.@D5*! ,G! D.;215;;5;! =72+7! .;5! /75;5! )CC42+)/2,1;! 52/75*! *5F.4)*4E! ,*! ,++);2,1)44E! 7);! F*,=1!
;2F12G2+)1/4E! 21! /75! 4);/! G5=! E5)*;I! `1! )662/2,1^! /75! G*5].51+E!=2/7!=72+7! /75;5! )CC42+)/2,1;! 7)N5! D551!
.;56!7);! 21/51;2G256!);!=544I!B75!;5+/2,1;!/7)/!G,44,=!=244!62;+.;;!*5+51/!/*516;!)16!6E1)@2+;! 21! G.*/75*!
65/)24I!
!
1.1 Teleworking
1.1.1 Teleworking – Data availability and data-collection issues
>)/)! ,1! /75! C515/*)/2,1! ,G! `#B! )CC42+)/2,1;! 21! /75!=,*LC4)+5! )16! ,1! /752*! 2@C)+/! ,1! +,@@./21F! )*5!
*54)/2N54E!;+)*+5I!!
:5F.4)*! ;/)/2;/2+)4! 6)/)! ,1! /545=,*L21F! )*5! 1,/! +.**51/4E! +,445+/56^! ,/75*! /7)1! 21! )! G5=! +,.1/*25;I!
$++);2,1)4! ;)@C45! ;.*N5E;! )16! 5;/2@)/5;!)*5! )N)24)D45! G,*! ;,@5! +,.1/*25;^! /EC2+)44E! 21!A,*/7! 9@5*2+)^!
".*,C5^!,*!k)C)1I!>)/)!)*5!C)*/2+.4)*4E!;+)*+5!G,*!65N54,C21F!)16!5@5*F21F!+,.1/*25;^!=75*5!/EC2+)44E!1,!
6)/)! 2;! )N)24)D45I! %,*! ;,@5! +,.1/*25;^! 7,=5N5*^! ;.+7! );! /75! b'! )16!@5@D5*;! ,G! /75! "b^! 6)/)! ,1! /75!
;7)*5!,G!/545=,*L21F!DE!;5+/,*!)16g,*!,++.C)/2,1!)*5!)N)24)D45I!!
"S2;/21F! ;/)/2;/2+)4! ;.*N5E;^! 7,=5N5*^! ,G/51!C*,6.+5!*5;.4/;! /7)/!)*5!1,/! +,@C)*)D45! 6.5! /,! /75! 4)+L!,G!
;/)16)*6! 65G212/2,1;I! ',@5! ;.*N5E;^! G,*! 5S)@C45^! G,+.;! ,1! /545=,*L5*;! );! )! =7,45^! =7245! ,/75*;!
62GG5*51/2)/5! ,*! *5;/*2+/! /752*! G,+.;! /,! /545=,*L5*;! /7)/! =,*L! G*,@! 7,@5! 37,@5! =,*L5*;8^! ./24205! `#B!
/5+71,4,F25;! 21! /752*!=,*L^!,*!@.;/!./24205! `#B! /5+71,4,F25;!/,!=,*L!3B#! /545=,*L5*;8I!B75! G2F.*5!D54,=!
C*,N265;!)!F*)C72+)4!*5C*5;51/)/2,1!,G!N)*2,.;!/EC5;!,G!/545=,*L5*;!/7)/!+)1!D5!2651/2G256!)16!/7)/!@)E!D5!
/75!G,+.;!,G!;/)/2;/2+)4!;.*N5E;I!
!
! !(
W+A"&0(:D(T+==0&0,#(#.C0'(%=(#0407%&M0&';(
X%#0D(*$0(&041#+20('+Y0(%=(#$0(5+&540'(-%0'(,%#(&0=405#(#$0(&041#+20('+Y0(%=(-+==0&0,#(A&%"C';(
!
91!)662/2,1)4!42@2/)/2,1!,G!5S2;/21F!6)/)!,1!/545=,*L21F!2;!/7)/!].5;/2,11)2*5!65;2F1;!,G/51!G)24!/,!+)C/.*5!
2@C,*/)1/! 21G,*@)/2,1^! ;.+7! );! /75! 1.@D5*! ,G! 6)E;! /545=,*L56! 5)+7! @,1/7! ,*! =55L! DE! *5;C,1651/;!
G)4421F!.165*!/75!+)/5F,*E!,G!/545=,*L5*;I!!
Workers (employed or self employed)
ICT EnabledWorkers
Out of home Teleworkers
Home-basedteleworkers
TC Tele-workers
ICT enabled
teleworkers
Teleworkers
!
! KQ
>5;C2/5! 62GG5*51+5;! 21! 65G212/2,1;^! @5/7,6,4,F25;^! )16! 5;/2@)/2,1;! =5! +)1^! 7,=5N5*^! 6*)=! ;,@5!
C*542@21)*E!+,1+4.;2,1;^!=72+7!)*5!62;+.;;56!D54,=I!
1.1.2 Teleworking – Penetration
B75!*)/5!,G!C515/*)/2,1!,G!/545=,*L21F!)16!/545+,1G5*51+21F!21/,!/75!=,*L21F!51N2*,1@51/!2;!1,/!.12G,*@!
)+*,;;!+,.1/*25;^!6.5!/,!62GG5*51/!5+,1,@2+^!/5+71,4,F2+)4^!)16!C,42+E!+,1/5S/;I!9++,*621F!/,!<,*46)/<,*L!
3PWWT8^! 21!PWWQ!/75*5!=5*5! 21!/75!b'!)*,.16!P\IK!@2442,1! /545=,*L5*;!365G2156!);!/7,;5!/545=,*L21F!)/!
45);/! ,1+5! )!@,1/78^! +,**5;C,1621F! /,! KZIQ! C5*+51/!,G! /75! /,/)4!=,*LG,*+5I!9@,1F! /75;5^! K\IP!@2442,1!
=5*5! +4);;2G256! );! d+,1/*)+/! /545=,*L5*;^e! =7245! KPIJ!@2442,1!=5*5! d5@C4,E55! /545=,*L5*;IeQ!$./! ,G! /75!
/,/)4!P\IK!@2442,1!b'!/545=,*L5*;!21!PWWQ^!PPIP!@2442,1!=,*L5*;!=5*5!/545=,*L21F!)/!45);/!,1+5!C5*!=55L^!
=2/7!KPIP!@2442,1!/545=,*L21F!)4@,;/!5N5*E!6)E!3G.44!/2@58I!`1!/75!"b^!)++,*621F!/,!/75!".*,C5)1!<,*L21F!
#,162/2,1;!$D;5*N)/,*E!3PWWZ8^!/75!C5*+51/)F5!,G!/545=,*L5*;!3/545=,*L21F!)/! 45);/!,1+5!)!@,1/78!=);!
)*,.16! T!C5*+51/! ,G! /75! /,/)4!=,*LG,*+5^!=7245!,14E! P!C5*+51/! /545=,*L!5N5*E!6)E! 3G.44! /2@58^!=2/7! /75!
72F75;/!C*,C,*/2,1! ,G! /545=,*L21F! 21! /75!'+)1621)N2)1! +,.1/*25;!)16! /75!A5/75*4)16;!)16! /75! 4,=5;/! 21!
;,./75*1!".*,C5)1!+,.1/*25;I!%21)44E^!X)*/15*!3PWWQ8!*5C,*/;!/7)/!21!k)C)1!/545=,*L5*;!)++,.1/56!G,*!\I\!
C5*+51/!,G!/75!=,*LG,*+5!21!PWWWI!!
!
B75!.;5!,G!/545=,*L21F!65C516;!,1!/75!,++.C)/2,1!45N54!,G!5@C4,E55;I!`1!@,;/!+);5;^!)44!54;5!D521F!5].)4^!
/,C!@)1)F5*;^! ;512,*! ,GG2+2)4;^! )16! C*,G5;;2,1)4;^!);! =544! );! C5,C45! 21! ;L24456O/*)65! ,++.C)/2,1;^! )44! ,G!
=7,@!7)N5!)!72F75*!65F*55!,G!+,1/*,4!,N5*!/752*!)+/2N2/25;!+,@C)*56!/,!/75!)N5*)F5!5@C4,E55^!/516!/,!
.;5! /75;5! )CC42+)/2,1;!@,*5! ,G/51I! %,*! /75! "bOPZ^! G,*! 5S)@C45^! )@,1F! C*,G5;;2,1)4^! @)1)F5*2)4^! )16!
/5+712+)4!,++.C)/2,1;^!/72;!;7)*5!2;!=544!)D,N5!KW!C5*+51/!3;55!F*)C7!D54,=8I!
!
!(
B&1C$(VD(*0407%&M+,A(/.('05#%&(+,(#$0(QHO('%"&50D(Q"&%C01,(Z%&M+,A(9%,-+#+%,'(</'0&21#%&.(IEUU[J;(
!
9;! 72F742F7/56! DE! /75! F*)C7! )D,N5^! /75! 2@C45@51/)/2,1! ,G! /545=,*L21F! 2;! 1,/! .12G,*@! )+*,;;! ;5+/,*;I!
BEC2+)44E^! /75! 72F75;/! 2@C45@51/)/2,1! ,++.*;! 21! /75! @,;/! L1,=456F5O21/51;2N5! 216.;/*25;! =2/721! /75!
;5*N2+5!;5+/,*!,G!5+,1,@2+)44E!)16!/5+71,4,F2+)44E!)6N)1+56!+,.1/*25;I!',@5!/*)62/2,1)4!;5+/,*;^!7,=5N5*^!
@)E! 7)N5! 72F7! )6,C/2,1! *)/5;I! B72;! 2;! /75! +);5! 21! /75! +,1;/*.+/2,1! ;5+/,*! 21! /75! "bOPZ^! )16! )4;,! ,G!
)F*2+.4/.*5!)16!G2;721F!21!+,.1/*25;!;.+7!);!/75!b[!3;55!F*)C7!D54,=8I!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!5 <,*46)/<,*L!3PWWZ8!65G2156!)!d+,1/*)+/!/545=,*L5*e!);!d)!;54GO5@C4,E56!2162N26.)4!=7,!=,*L;!*5@,/54E!)/!45);/!,15!6)E!C5*!@,1/7!6.*21F!1,*@)4!D.;215;;!7,.*;e!)16!)1!d5@C4,E55!/545=,*L5*e!);!d)!*5F.4)*!5@C4,E55!3G.44!,*!C)*/!/2@58!=7,!=,*L;!*5@,/54E!)/!45);/!,15!6)E!C5*!@,1/7!6.*21F!1,*@)4!D.;215;;!7,.*;Ie
!
! K\
!B&1C$(\D(*0407%&M+,A(/.('05#%&(+,(#$0(H@O('%"&50D(X1#+%,14(8#1#+'#+5'(=%&(H@(IEUU\J;(
!
9;! ;7,=1! 21! /75! F*)C7! D54,=^!=7245! ;,@5! /545=,*L5*;!=,*L! G*,@!7,@5! 37,@5!=,*L5*;8^! )! ;2F12G2+)1/!
C*,C,*/2,1^!5;C5+2)44E!)@,1F!;L24456!/*)65;^!=,*L!G*,@!,/75*!4,+)/2,1;!D5;265;!/752*!7,@5;I!!
!
!B&1C$(]D(*0407%&M+,A(=&%6($%60(1,-(=&%6(-+==0&0,#(C4150'(+,(#$0(H@O('%"&50D((
X1#+%,14(8#1#+'#+5'(H@(IEUU\J;(
!
:5F)*621F! /75! *5@,/5! 4,+)/2,1;! G*,@!=72+7! /545=,*L21F!@)E! D5! +)**256! ,./^! 6)/)! G,*! /75!b'! ;.FF5;/;!
/7)/^! )4/7,.F7! /75! 7,@5! 2;! ;/244! /75! @,;/! +,@@,1! 4,+)/2,1! G,*! /545=,*L5*;! /,! +,16.+/! /752*! =,*L^! )!
F*,=21F! 1.@D5*! ,G! /75@! =,*L! G*,@! N)*2,.;! ,/75*! 4,+)/2,1;I! `1! C)*/2+.4)*^! )++,*621F! /,! )! ;.*N5E!
+,16.+/56!DE!<,*46)/<,*L!3PWWZ8^!PJI\!@2442,1!C5,C45!+,16.+/56!=,*L!G*,@!)!+.;/,@5*!,*!+4251/h;!C4)+5!
,G!D.;215;;! 21!/75!@,1/7!C*5+5621F!/75!;.*N5E^!PWIP!@2442,1!+,16.+/56!=,*L!G*,@!)!+)Gl!,*!*5;/).*)1/^!
KZIT!@2442,1!626!;,! G*,@!)!7,/54!,*!@,/54^!)16!KKIQ!@2442,1!=,*L56!G*,@!)!C)*L!,*!)1!,./6,,*! 4,+)/2,1I!
%21)44E^!)!+,1;265*)D45!1.@D5*!,G!C5,C45!+,16.+/56!=,*L!.;21F!)!/545C7,15!)16g,*!)!?#!=7245!/*)N5421F!
3PJ!@2442,1!21!/75!+)*a!KWI\!@2442,1!,1!)1!)2*C4)15^!/*)21^!,*!;.D=)Ea!)16!VIK!@2442,1!21!)1!)2*C,*/^!/*)21!
65C,/^!,*!;.D=)E!C4)/G,*@8I!!
b[!6)/)!)4;,! ;7,=!,/75*! 21/5*5;/21F! /*516;I!-5/=551!PWWW!)16!PWWQ^! G,*! 21;/)1+5^! /75! ;7)*5! ,G!7,@5!
=,*L5*;!.;21F!)!/545C7,15!)16!+,@C./5*!/,!+)**E!,./!/752*!=,*L!3`BO51)D456!/545=,*L5*;8!21+*5);56!].2/5!
;2F12G2+)1/4E!3.C!/,!ZZ!C5*+51/8^!)16^!)@,1F!/75@^!/75!C*,C,*/2,1!=7,!+,.46!1,/!=,*L!G*,@!7,@5!=2/7,./!
!
! KZ
.;21F!D,/7!)!/545C7,15!)16!+,@C./5*!3;,O+)4456!dB#!/545=,*L5*;e8!21+*5);56!);!=544!3*5)+721F!TZ!C5*+51/!
21!PWWQ8\!!
>2GG5*51+5;! 21! D57)N2,*! D5/=551! 62GG5*51/! F*,.C;! ,G! /545=,*L5*;! @)E! 7)N5! ;2F12G2+)1/! 2@C42+)/2,1;! 21!
/5*@;!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!)+725N56!N2)! /545=,*L21F!35IFI^!D5+).;5!,G!62GG5*51/! /545=,*L21F!)16!
/*)N5421F!;+756.45;!,G!62GG5*51/!F*,.C;8I!#.**51/4E^!7,=5N5*^!/75!21G,*@)/2,1!)N)24)D45!)D,./!/75!D57)N2,*!
,G! 62GG5*51/! F*,.C;^!)16! 21! C)*/2+.4)*!)D,./! C5,C45!=,*L21F!,./;265! /752*!7,@5;^! 2;! 21;.GG2+251/! /,! 6*)=!
G2*@!+,1+4.;2,1;I!>5;C2/5!/75;5! 42@2/)/2,1;^!)!1.@D5*!,G!;/.625;^! /EC2+)44E!+);5O;/.6EOD);56!,*! G,+.;21F!
,1!2162N26.)4!+,.1/*25;^!7)N5!)//5@C/56!/,!5;/2@)/5!/75!2@C)+/!,G!/545=,*L21F!,1!/*)1;C,*/)/2,1!)16!XYX!
5@2;;2,1;!3;55!/)D45!D54,=8I!
!
%,+.;21F!,1!/75!b'!@)*L5/!);!)!=7,45^!/75!#,1;.@5*!"45+/*,12+;!9;;,+2)/2,1!5;/2@)/56!/7)/!)D,./!RIV!@2442,1!9@5*2+)1;! +.**51/4E! /545+,@@./5!)16! /7)/! /545+,@@./5*;! ;)N5!D5/=551!KZ!)16! PR! LF!,G!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!)!6)EI!B7.;! /75!#"9!5;/2@)/5;!/7)/!+.**51/4E!b'!/545+,@@./5*;!)N,26!5@2//21F!D5/=551!KW!)16!KJ!@2442,1!/,1;!,G!#$P!C5*!)11.@I!
_,,L21F! )/! 5S2;/21F! )16! C,/51/2)4! )6,C/2,1! ,G! /545+,@@./21F^! /75! 9@5*2+)1! #,1;.@5*;! `1;/2/./5!51N2;2,1;!/7)/!)1!)662/2,1)4!KW!C5*+51/!,G!/75!b'!=,*LG,*+5!+,.46!D5F21!/545+,@@./21F!,N5*!)!KWOE5)*!C5*2,6I!#,1;265*21F!,14E!D515G2/;!65*2N21F!G*,@!/75!*56.+/2,1!,G!+)*!+,@@./21F^!/75!9#`!5;/2@)/5;!/7)/!;.+7!+7)1F5!=,.46!)44,=!/75!b'!5+,1,@E!/,!;)N5!)D,./!mV\IQ!D2442,1!5)+7!E5)*^!*56.+21F!F);,4215!.;5!DE!K\I\!D2442,1!42/5*;!)16!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!DE!RTIQ!@2442,1!/,1;I
Z!
`1!/75!b[^!)!C24,/!;.*N5E!.165*/)L51!DE!-B!2162+)/56!/7)/^!,1!)N5*)F5^!7,@5O=,*L5*;!542@21)/56!R^KJV!@245;!3)D,./!Q^WWW!L@8!,G!7,@5O/,O,GG2+5!/*)N54^!@,;/!,G!=72+7!=,.46!7)N5!D551!DE!+)*!*)/75*!/7)1!DE!C.D42+!/*)1;C,*/I!:5;C,1651/;!=5*5!)4;,!);L56!2G!/75E!7)6!21+*5);56!452;.*5!c,.*15E;f!,14E!;5N51!,./!,G!/75!JR!7,@5!=,*L5*;! 21/5*N25=56!;)26! /75E!7)6^!)16!/75! 21+*5);56!@245)F5!=);! 4,=! 21! *54)/2,1!/,! /75!;)N21F;!G*,@!7,@5O,GG2+5!/*)N54IT!
`1! ;2@.4)/21F! /75! 2@C)+/!,1! /*)GG2+!+,1F5;/2,1^!A":9!"+,1,@2+!#,1;.4/21Fh;! d+,1;5*N)/2N5!);;.@C/2,1e!,1! +)*! +,@@./21F! 2;! /7)/! +,@C)*56! /,! )! D.;215;;O);O.;.)4! ;+51)*2,^! 7,@5!=,*L5*;! =244! 51)D45! )! KW!C5*+51/! *56.+/2,1! 21! /*)GG2+! 21! PWWQ! )16! KQ! C5*+51/! 21! PWKW^! =2/7! )! 1,/2+5)D45! 2@C)+/! ,1! /*)GG2+!+,1F5;/2,1VI!
>2;+.;;21F! C,/51/2)4! )FF*5F)/5! ;)N21F;! )/! ".*,C5)1! 45N54^! )16! +2/21F! )! ;/.6E! DE! /75! ".*,C5)1!B545+,@@.12+)/2,1;!A5/=,*L!$C5*)/,*;!9;;,+2)/2,1!3"BA$8!)16!/75!<,*46!<24642G5!%.16^!/75!9@5*2+)1!"45+/*,12+;!9;;,+2)/2,1!39598!1,/5;!/7)/!2G!c.;/!KW!C5*+51/!,G!/75!"b!5@C4,E55;!D5+)@5!G45S2O=,*L5*;!PP!@2442,1!/,1;!,G!#$P!@2F7/!D5!;)N56!)11.)44EKWI!
*1/40(R;((8"661&.(%=('#"-+0'(0'#+61#+,A(#0407%&M+,A(+6C15#(%,(BKB(06+''+%,'(
B7.;^!D,/7!b'!)16!".*,C5)1!;/.625;!C,21/!,./!/7)/!/545=,*L21F!+)1!C,/51/2)44E!51)D45!@2442,1;!,G!/,1;!21!
/*)N54O*54)/56!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;I!!
'5N5*)4!)./7,*;^!7,=5N5*^!C,21/56!)/!)!1.@D5*!,G!2162*5+/^!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!/7)/!@)E!*56.+5!/75!C,;2/2N5!
2@C)+/! ,G! /545+,@@./21F! ,1! /*)GG2+! 45N54;! )16! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;I! `1! C)*/2+.4)*! C,/51/2)4! /*)GG2+! 3)16! XYX!
5@2;;2,1;8!21+*5);5;!7)N5!D551!);;,+2)/56!=2/7f!
• 4)/51/!65@)16!G*,@!C5,C45!=7,!65+265!/,!/*)N54!);!+,1F5;/2,1^!/7)1L;!/,!/545+,@@./21F^!65+*5);5;f!
• 452;.*5! /*)N54! G*,@! /545+,@@./5*;! /7)/! /)L5! )6N)1/)F5! ,G! /75! +,@@./21F! /2@5! ;)N56!/7)1L;!/,!/545+,@@./21Fa!)16!
• 21+*5);56!.*D)1!;C*)=4^!G)+242/)/56!DE!/75!62@212;756!1556!/,!42N5!21!C*,S2@2/E!/,!,GG2+5;I!!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!6 A)/2,1)4!'/)/2;/2+;!b[^!PWWQ 7 k,;5C7!%.7*!)16!'/5C751!?,+2);LI!!d-*,)6D)16!;5*N2+5;f!5+,1,@2+!)16!51N2*,1@51/)4!D515G2/;^e!B75!9@5*2+)1!
#,1;.@5*!`1;/2/./5^!$+/,D5*^!PWWZI!T!(,/,*;!)16!(,65@;!:5N2;2/56f!B75!:,45!,G!B5+71,4,FE!21!:56.+21F!B*)N54!>5@)16;!)16!B*)GG2+!#,1F5;/2,1I!!k,71!>,6F;,1^!k,1)/7)1!?)+5E!)16!(2+7)54!-5FFI!!A":9^!_,16,1^!()E!PWWWI!V!$CI+2/I!KW!959!PWWZ!M!k,71!9I!d'L2Ce!_)2/15*^![)*51!"7*7)*6O()*/2150!96N)1+56!"45+/*,12+;!)16!`1G,*@)/2,1!B5+71,4,F25;f!B75!`11,N)/2,1O_56!#42@)/5!#7)1F5!',4./2,1I
!
! KT
>5;C2/5! /75! *5+,F12/2,1! ,G! /75;5! 6E1)@2+;^! /75! C*5N)451/! +,1;51;.;! 21! /75! 42/5*)/.*5! 2;! /7)/^! ,N5*)44^!
/545+,@@./21F! *56.+5;! /75!62;/)1+5! /*)N5456!)16! /75!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!65*2N21F! G*,@! /*)1;C,*/)/2,1I!B75!
65D)/5!,1!/75!;205!)16!L216!,G!*5D,.16!2@C)+/!*5@)21;!,C51I!`/!2;!+45)*^!7,=5N5*^!/7)/!/75!;205!)16!L216!
,G! C,;;2D45! *5D,.16! 5GG5+/;! 65C516! ,1! /75! +.4/.*)4^! 5+,1,@2+^! )16! C,42+E! G*)@5=,*L! 21! =72+7!
/545+,@@./21F!2;!65C4,E56^!5IFI^!21!)1!51N2*,1@51/!21!=72+7!4)+L!,G!.*D)1!C4)1121F!6,5;!1,/!51+,.*)F5!
@2S56O.;5!42N21F^!/545+,@@./21F!@)E!45)6!/,!21+*5);21F!;C*)=4!)16!)662/2,1)4!452;.*5O!)16!+7,*5O*54)/56!
/*)N54I!%4)1L21F!C,42+25;!)16!@5);.*5;!+)1!/75*5G,*5!@)S2@205!/75!2@C)+/!,G!/545+,@@./21F!)16!@212@205!
/75!15F)/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!)16!;.CC,*/!4,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+LI!!
!
1.1.3 Teleworking – Existing barriers and growth potential
<75*5);!+.**51/!)6,C/2,1!,G!/545=,*L21F!2;!/EC2+)44E!42@2/56!/,!)!;@)44!C5*+51/)F5!,G!=,*L5*;^!2/!)CC5)*;!
/7)/!)!D*,)65*!1.@D5*!,G!=,*L5*;!)*5!C,/51/2)44E!21/5*5;/56!21!/72;!)CC42+)/2,1I!9!72F7!45N54!,G!21/5*5;/!2;!
C*5;51/!D,/7!)@,1F!/7,;5!)4*5)6E!5@C4,E56!3;55!/)D45!D54,=8!)16!)@,1F!/7,;5!+.**51/4E!.15@C4,E56!
3;55!)CC5162S!R8I!B72;! 45N54!,G! 21/5*5;/!;7,.46!D5!+,1;265*56!72F7^!*54)/2N5!/,!/75!G)+/!/7)/!;.CC,*/!)16!
+,@@5*+2)4!C.;7!G,*! /545=,*L21F!)*5!1,/!72F7!)16!G5=!*,45!@,654;!/7)/!;.++5;;G.44E!7)N5! 2@C45@51/56!
/545=,*L21F!;,4./2,1;!)*5!=544!L1,=1I!!
!
!(
*1/40(VD(Q6C4%.0-(C0%C40(+,#0&0'#0-(+,(#0407%&M+,AO('%"&50D(B1&0+'(IEUUEJ;(
!
B75!;5/!,G!C,/51/2)4!/545=,*L5*;!@)E!D5!5N51!4)*F5*!2G!,15!+,1;265*;!/75!G.1+/2,1)4!)+/2N2/25;!,G!62GG5*51/!
=,*L5*;!)16!/752*!)+/.)4!+,115+/2,1!/,!)!C7E;2+)4!;C)+5I!
B75!+,@@2;;2,1!,G!/75!".*,C5)1!#,@@.12/25;^!G,*!5S)@C45^!7);!5;/2@)/56!/7)/!*,.F74E!QW!C5*+51/!,G!)44!
5@C4,E@51/! 2;! 1,/! D,.16! /,! )! ;C5+2G2+! F5,F*)C72+)4! 4,+)/2,1I! `1! /75! b'^! /75! 1.@D5*! ,G! ;,O+)4456!
21G,*@)/2,1!=,*L5*;^!=72+7!)++,.1/! G,*!)*,.16!7)4G!,G! /75! /,/)4!=,*LG,*+5! 3=2/7!/72;! G2F.*5!5SC5+/56! /,!
F*,=!.C!/,!ZW!C5*+51/8^!7);!D551!.;56!);!)1!2162+)/,*!,G!/75!C,/51/2)4!F*,=/7!,G!/545=,*L21FI!Y,=5N5*^!
1,/!)44!21G,*@)/2,1!=,*L5*;!+,1;265*!/75@;54N5;!C,/51/2)4!/545=,*L5*;I!9++,*621F!/,!)!1.@D5*!,G!;.*N5E;!
/7)/!7)N5!D551!+,16.+/56^!D5/=551!PW!)16!TP!C5*+51/!,G!21G,*@)/2,1!=,*L5*;!52/75*!D5425N5!/75E!+)11,/!
/545=,*L! ,*! )*5! 1,/! =24421F! /,! 6,! ;,! .165*! +.**51/! +2*+.@;/)1+5;I! `G! /75! *5;.4/;! ,G! /=,! 5@C2*2+)4! b'!
!
! KV
;.*N5E;!DE!(,L7/)*2)1^!=72+7!;.FF5;/!/7)/!21G,*@)/2,1!=,*L5*;!=7,!)*5!.1)D45!,*!.1=24421F!/,!/545=,*L!
*5C*5;51/!JW!C5*+51/!,G!/75!/,/)4^!)*5!/)L51!);!*5C*5;51/)/2N5^!/72;! 2@C425;!/7)/!+.**51/4E!RW!C5*+51/!,G!
/75! 4)D,*! G,*+5!+,.46!)16!=,.46! 42L5! /,! /545=,*L!3\W!C5*+51/!,./!,G!QW!C5*+51/!,G! /75! /,/)4! 4)D,*! G,*+58!
39*1G)4L!KVVV8I!`/!@.;/!D5!1,/56^!7,=5N5*^!/7)/!/75!D*,)6!*)1F5!,G!*5;C,1;5;!C*,N2656!/,!/75;5!;.*N5E;!
@)E! ;2F1)4! 4)+L! ,G! +4)*2/E! )@,1F! *5;C,1651/;! )D,./! /75! 2@C42+)/2,1;^! D515G2/;^! )16! 6*)=D)+L;! ,G!
/545=,*L21FI!!
!
'.**,.1621F!+,162/2,1;!C4)E!)!L5E! *,45! 21!65/5*@2121F!D,/7! /75!C,/51/2)4! G,*! /545=,*L21F!)16! 2/;!)+/.)4!
./2420)/2,1I!B,6)E^!65;C2/5!/75!72F7!45N54!,G!21/5*5;/!G,*!/545=,*L21F!5SC*5;;56!DE!@,;/!5@C4,E55;^!);!=544!
);!DE!)!F*,=21F!1.@D5*!,G!5@C4,E5*;^!/75!;7)*5!,G!/545=,*L5*;! 2;!;/244! *54)/2N54E! 4,=! 21!@,;/!+,.1/*25;I!
B72;! 2;! 6.5! /,! )! +,@D21)/2,1! ,G! G)+/,*;^! 21+4.621F! /5+71,4,F2+)4! )16! 5+,1,@2+! D)**25*;^! 45F)4! )16!
)6@212;/*)/2N5!D)**25*;!3;.+7!);!4)+L!,G!C5*@2;;2,1!/,!/545=,*L!G*,@!/75!+,@C)1E!,*!4)+L!,G!)CC*,N)4!G*,@!
/75!;.C5*2,*8^!)16!/75!C5*+52N56!1556!G,*!C7E;2+)4!C*5;51+5!)16!G)+5O/,OG)+5!21/5*)+/2,1!21!)!1.@D5*!,G!
c,D;I!B75!*5;.4/;!,G!)!;.*N5E!+,16.+/56!21!/75!"bOKQ!,1!/75!*5);,1;!G,*!1,/!/545=,*L21F!)*5!*5C,*/56!21!
/75!/)D45!D54,=I!
!(
*1/40(\D(S01'%,'(#%(#0407%&M(%&(,%#(#%(#0407%&MO('%"&50D(B1&0+'(IEUUEJ;(
!
>5;C2/5! 5S2;/21F! D)**25*;! 2/! 2;! /,! D5! 5SC5+/56! /7)/^! =2/7! /75! +,1/21.)/2,1! ,G! 5S2;/21F! /*516;^! )! 4)*F5*!
C*,C,*/2,1!,G!C5,C45!=244!D5!)D45!,*!=24421F!/,!/545=,*L!21!/75!G./.*5^!6.5!/,!;5N5*)4!6*2N5*;^!);!62;+.;;56!
21!;5+/2,1!KIR!D54,=I!B75!;C556!,G!65N54,C@51/^!7,=5N5*^!)16! /75! 2@C)+/! /7)/!;.+7!65N54,C@51/!@)E!
7)N5! ,1! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;! =244! N)*E! ;2F12G2+)1/4E^! 65C51621F! ,1! /75! D57)N2,*! ,G! L5E! C4)E5*;! ;.+7! );! `B!
C*,6.+5*;!)16!.;5*;!)16!C,42+E!@)L5*;I!B75;5!);C5+/;!=244!D5!62;+.;;56!21!@,*5!65/)24!21!;5+/2,1;!P!)16!R!
D54,=I!
!
1.2 Virtual meetings
1.2.1 Virtual meetings – Data availability and data-collection issues
B75! D)+LF*,.16! *5;5)*+7!.165*/)L51! G,*! /72;! C*,c5+/! 72F742F7/56! /7)/! +.**51/4E! /75*5! 2;! 1,! ;E;/5@)/2+!
5GG,*/!/,!+,445+/!;/)/2;/2+)4!6)/)!)D,./!/75!)6,C/2,1!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;I!'/)/2;/2+)4!6)/)!5S)@2121F!N2*/.)4!
@55/21F;! 2;! /75*5G,*5! 5N51! ;+)*+5*! /7)1! G,*! /545=,*L21FI! B72;! 2;! ;.*C*2;21F^! F2N51! 7,=! @.+7! N2*/.)4!
@55/21F!/5+71,4,F25;!)*5!C*,@,/56!DE!@)1E!`B!+,@C)125;!);!2@C,*/)1/!D.;215;;!;,4./2,1;I!
!
! PW
9! 1.@D5*! ,G! ;/.625;^! D);56! ,1! +);5! ;/.625;^! 7)N5! )1)4E056! N)*2,.;! /75@5;! );;,+2)/56! =2/7! N2*/.)4!
@55/21F;!;.+7!);!.;5*!D57)N2,*a!/5+71,4,FE!C5*G,*@)1+5a!,*^!);! 21!/75!;/.625;! /7)/!=244!D5!72F742F7/56!
D54,=^! 2@C)+/! ,1! /*)N54! D57)N2,*! )16! #$P! 5@2;;2,1;I! B75;5! ,++);2,1)4! ;.*N5E;! )16! ;/.625;! N)*E!
;2F12G2+)1/4E!21!/5*@;!,G!F,)4;^!;+,C5^!)16!)CC*,)+7I!9;!/75;5!;/.625;!)*5!D);56!,1!)15+6,/)4!5N2651+5^!
/75E!G)24!/,!C*,N265!*2F,*,.;!;/)/2;/2+)4!6)/)!,1!/75!)6,C/2,1!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!21!/75!=,*LC4)+5!)16!,1!
/75!);;,+2)/56!2@C)+/!,1!D.;215;;!/*)N54!)/!)1!)FF*5F)/56!45N54^!=75/75*!DE!+,.1/*E!,*!5N51!DE!216.;/*2)4!
;5+/,*I!
!
1.2.2 Virtual meetings – Existing literature
'21+5!/75!21/*,6.+/2,1!,G!/75!/545C7,15!)16^!4)/5* !̂,G!/75!?2+/.*5C7,15!DE!-544!_)D;!)/!/75!<,*46!"SC,!21!
KV\J^!)!1.@D5*!,G!;/.625;!7)N5!;C5+.4)/56!/7)/!/545+,1G5*51+21F!=,.46!4,=5*!,*!5N51!*5C4)+5!/75!1556!
G,*!D.;215;;!/*)N54I!%,*!5S)@C45^!)!45//5*!/,!/75!562/,*;!,G!/75,!(1"2!6)/56!()E!KW^!KTZV^!,C215;!/7)/!/75!
21N51/2,1!,G!/75!/545C7,15!:3%/#5,&";#03",.<",&0;(5,=%/&)">()*,$<(3<,$"0&("5,.<",7/2()"2210),%4,.%50>9?!
n.2/5!;2@24)*4E^!21!KV\V^![c544;/*,@!=*,/5^!:@>,ABCD,$",$(##,)%,#%)*"&,)""5,.%,2;")5,.(1",(),403"8.%8403",
1"".()*29, !<0)'2, .%, 3%1;/."&, ."&1()0#2, 0)5, ;(3./&", ."#";<%)>+,$",$(##, 7", 07#", .%,1""., "#"3.&%)(30##>,
4&%1,%/&,%44(3",3<0(&2?,39*1G)4L^!PWWP8I!
$N5*! /75! 4);/! +,.C45! ,G! 65+)65;^! /75! 21/*,6.+/2,1! ,G! C5*;,1)4! +,@C./5*;! )16! ,G! /75! `1/5*15/! 21! /75!
=,*LC4)+5^!+,@D2156!=2/7!/75!@,*5!*5+51/!;C*5)6!,G!D*,)6D)16^!7);!;C.**56!)!*515=56!21/5*5;/!)@,1F!
*5;5)*+75*;^! =7,! 7)N5! G,+.;56! /752*! )//51/2,1! ,1! ;C5+2G2+! /EC5;! ,G! /545+,1G5*51+21F! ;.+7! );!
N265,+,1G5*51+21F! )16^!@,*5! *5+51/4E^!=5D! +,1G5*51+21FI! 9! ;)@C45! ,G! ;/.625;! 2;! C*,N2656! 21! /75! /)D45!
D54,=I!
!
!
! PK
8%"&50( W+,-+,A(
-B!/*2)4!KVTRMKVT\!3-5112;,1!KVVT8!
"2F7/EO;5N51!C5*+51/!,G!*5;C,1651/;!G54/!/7)/!/545+,1G5*51+21F!*56.+56!/752*!1556!/,!/*)N54I!!
'#9X!@55/21F!3(,L7/)*2)1!KVTT8!
• B,/)4!N572+45!@245;!21+*5);56!DE!PV!C5*+51/!DE!*5C4)+21F!)!*5F2,1)4!@55/21F!G,*!)!/545+,1G5*51+5^!);!;7,*/5*!62;/)1+5;!/,!/545+,1G5*51+5!G)+242/25;!=5*5!,./=52F756!DE!21+*5);56!)//516)1+5I!!
• B*)N54!21!C5)LO7,.*^!+,1F5;/56!+,162/2,1;!=);!*5C4)+56!DE!/*)N54!21!,GGOC5)L^!45;;!+,1F5;/56!+,162/2,1;I!
• 9!/,/)4!,G!KIT!C5*+51/!,G!)44!D.;215;;!/*)N54!@)E!+.**51/4E!D5!;.D;/2/./56!DE!/545+,1G5*51+21FI!
#)1)62)1!5@C4,E55;!3:565L,C!KVVJ8!
B=51/EOG2N5!C5*+51/!,G!*5;C,1651/;!@)65!G5=5*!D.;215;;!/*2C;!6.5!/,!+,@@.12+)/2,1!/5+71,4,F25;!21!KVVP^!)16!PT!C5*+51/!626!;,!21!KVVJI!
Cook and Haver (1994) • It was argued that a 25 percent replacement of business travel by air was going to take place in the US by 2010.
#)1)62)1!D.;215;;!/*)N545*;!3:,E!)16!%242;/*).4/!KVVT8!
• 9!/,/)4!,G!PJIP!C5*+51/!;)26!/75E!=5*5!/*)N5421F!45;;!,G/51!);!)!*5;.4/!,G!+,@C)1E!C,42+E!/,!21+*5);5!./2420)/2,1!,G!/545+,1G5*51+21FI!
• $G!/7,;5!C)*/2+2C)/21F!21!)/!45);/!,15!N265,+,1G5*51+5!21!/75!C*5N2,.;!E5)*^!.;5*;!;/)/56!/7)/!N265,+,1G5*51+21F!7)6!D551!)!;.D;/2/./5!G,*!)1!)2*!/*2C!21!JQ!C5*+51/!,G!/75!+);5;I!
• 9;!@.+7!);!KIT!C5*+51/!,G!)44!D.;215;;!/*)N54!@)E!+.**51/4E!D5!;.D;/2/./56!DE!/545+,1G5*51+21FI!
"C;,1!B545+51/*5!3'.;/)21`B!.16)/56^!-2DDE!PWWW8!
9!/545+51/5*!=2/7!52F7/!65;L;!=);!5;/2@)/56!/,!;)N5!RW^WWW!N572+45!@245;!C5*!)11.@!3R^ZQW!@245;!C5*!65;L8I!
B5/*)C)L!39*1G)4L!PWWP8! -.;215;;!/*)N54!+,.46!D5!*56.+56!DE!KW!C5*+51/!6.5!/,!N265,+,1G5*51+21FI!
B542)!39*1G)4L!PWWP8!! -5/=551!KVVZ!)16!PWWW^!D.;215;;!/*)N54!DE!)2*!=);!*56.+56!DE!,N5*!)!/72*6^!C)*/4E!6.5!/,!@,*5!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!3C)*/2+.4)*4E!).62,+,1G5*51+21F8I!
'.*N5E!,G!G,.*!'=562;7!+,@C)125;!39*1G)4L!PWWP8!
• %,*/EOG2N5!/,!\K!C5*+51/!*5;C,1651/;!;)26!N265,+,1G5*51+21F!7)6!*56.+56!/752*!,=1!/*)N54I!
• %2G/551!/,!PQ!C5*+51/!;)26!2/!7)6!*56.+56!,/75*!C5,C45h;!/*)N54I!• '5N51/551!/,!PW!C5*+51/!;)26!2/!7)6!,14E!7)6!)!@21,*!5GG5+/I!• $15!/,!R!C5*+51/!;)26!2/!7)6!21+*5);56!/752*!/*)N54I!
Y,CL21;,1!5/!)4!PWWR! • '5N51/EO,15!C5*+51/!,G!*5;C,1651/;!;)26!/752*!4);/!+,1G5*51+5!+)44!7)6!*5C4)+56!)!@55/21F!3=2/7!QP!C5*+51/!,G!*5;C,1651/;!;/)/21F!/7)/!/72;!=);!d65G212/2N54E!/75!+);5e8^!=7245!Q!C5*+51/!;/)/56!/7)/!2/!7)6!F515*)/56!)!@55/21FI!
• 9!7)4G!@2442,1!+)*gN)1!/*2C;!)16!QKMQV!@2442,1!@245;!,G!/*)N54!;)N56!G,*!KWT^WWW!C5,C45!3)CC*,S2@)/54E!G2N5!/*2C;!)16!JQWMQQW!@245;!C5*!C5*;,1!C5*!E5)*8I!
• %,*/EO;2S!C5*+51/!)N,2656!/*2C;!/7)/!=,.46!7)N5!/)L51!C4)+5!6.*21F!C5)L!C5*2,6;I!
• B51!/,!KK!C5*+51/!;)=!)!*56.+/2,1!21!D.;215;;!@245)F5I!();,1!<2442)@;!3PWWJ8! U265,!@55/21F!5].2C@51/!7);!)44,=56!/*)N54!+,;/;!/,!6*,C!DE!)!/72*6I!Y?!PWWT! #);5!;/.6E!,G!Y)4,!/545C*5;51+5!;,4./2,1!)CC4256!/,!)!Y?!/5)@!*5;C,1;2D45!
G,*!/*)1;G5**21F!@)1.G)+/.*21F!*5;C,1;2D242/E!G,*!)1!Y?!C*,6.+/!G*,@!$*5F,1!/,!'21F)C,*5f!• +./!)1!5;/2@)/56!JJ!21/5*1)/2,1)4!5@C4,E55!/*2C;!G*,@!/75!C*,c5+/!)16!!• C*5N51/56!)D,./!KJQ!@5/*2+!/,1;!,G!+)*D,1!5@2;;2,1;!G*,@!D521F!
*545);56!21/,!/75!51N2*,1@51/I!(
*1/40(]L!G'&?$!&57!.1I&'-!6%!-$?$'65%$#$5'.5;P!'%"&50(#)2*1;!'O('4,@)1!_O(A5=;,1!#O(91)D45!kO(@+&M/&+-0(!(^(B%%-7+,(3(IEUUVJ(_861�&(9$%+50'(`(9$1,A+,A(#$0(Z1.(Z0(*&1204(!
!
9;!=2/7!/545=,*L21F^!/75!5;/2@)/56!D515G2/;!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!@)E!N)*E!65C51621F!,1!/75!);;.@C/2,1;!
@)65! ,1! /75! C,/51/2)4! *5D,.16! 5GG5+/;! F515*)/56I! BEC2+)44E^! @,*5! C*.651/! 5;/2@)/5;! 72F742F7/! /7)/!
D5;265;!;.D;/2/./2,1^!/=,!,/75*!C,;;2D45!5GG5+/;!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!,1!/*)N54!+)1!D5!2651/2G256f!
! '.CC45@51/)/2,1f! U2*/.)4! +,@@.12+)/2,1! ;.CC45@51/;! C7E;2+)4! /*)N54^! =72+7! +,1/21.5;! /,!
/)L5!C4)+5I!
! X515*)/2,1f! U2*/.)4! +,@@.12+)/2,1! 45)6;! /,! @,*5! 1.@5*,.;! )16! *5@,/5! +,1/)+/;! )16!
D.;215;;5;^!;/2@.4)/21F!)16!F515*)/21F!@,*5!65@)16!G,*!/*)N54I!
!
! PP
!
%,*! 21;/)1+5^! )++,*621F! /,! ;,@5! )./7,*;^! ;.+7! );! >51;/)642! 3PWWJ8^! N265,+,1G5*51+21F! @)E! +).;5! )!
d/*)N54! ;72G/21F^e! G*,@! 21/5*1)4! +,@C)1E! @55/21F;! )16! *,./215! +,1/)+/;! /,! 5S/5*1)4^! D.;215;;O
65N54,C@51/O*54)/56!@55/21F;I!`1!,/75*!=,*6;^!/*)N54!+,;/;!)16!/2@5!;)N56!G,*!21/5*1)4!@55/21F;!/7)1L;!
/,! /75! .;5! ,G! /545O! )16! N265,+,1G5*51+21F! @)E! G*55! /2@5! )16! *5;,.*+5;! G,*! @,*5! ;/*)/5F2+! 5S/5*1)4!
@55/21F;I!94/7,.F7!/72;!@)E!7)N5!C,;2/2N5!5GG5+/;!21!/5*@;!,G!D.;215;;!65N54,C@51/^!2/!@)E!15./*)4205!,*!
5N51!*5N5*;5!/75!*56.+/2,1!21!C7E;2+)4!/*)N54!/,!)//516!21/5*1)4!@55/21F;I!$/75*!/*)N54OF515*)/2,1!5GG5+/;!
=5*5! G,.16! DE! (,L7/)*2)1! 3PWWR8^! )++,*621F! /,! =7,@! N265,+,1G5*51+5OD);56! @55/21F;! ,G! /75! ',./7!
#)42G,*12)!9;;,+2)/2,1!,G!X,N5*1@51/!*5;.4/56!21!F*5)/5*!,N5*)44!@245;!/*)N5456^!);!/75!)N5*)F5!1.@D5*!,G!
)//51655;^!=7,!7)6!/,!/*)N54! 21!,*65*!/,!c,21!/75!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)/!/752*! 4,+)4!7.D;^!*,;5I!%21)44E !̂=2/7!
2@C*,N56!`B!)CC42+)/2,1;!;.+7!);!/545O!)16!N265,+,1G5*51+21F^!/75!F5,F*)C72+!;+,C5!,G!D.;215;;5;!@)E!
5SC)16^!51)D421F!+,@C)125;! /,!5;/)D42;7!,GG2+5;!)16!,C5*)/2,1;! 21! *5@,/5! 4,+)/2,1;!D);56!,1!*5;,.*+5O
5GG2+251+E! +,1;265*)/2,1;I! 944! 54;5! D521F! 5].)4^! /72;! =,.46! F515*)/5! 15=! 65@)16! G,*! 21/5*)+/2,1^! D,/7!
N2*/.)4! 3/7*,.F7! /545+,1G5*51+21F8! )16! C7E;2+)4^! +*5)/21F! /75! 1556! G,*! )662/2,1)4! /*)N54I! `1! )! ;.*N5E!
+,16.+/56!DE!-)*+4)E+)*6!-.;215;;!)16!%./.*5!%,.16)/2,1!3PWWZ8!)@,1F!b[!D.;215;;5;^!KR!C5*+51/!,G!
/7,;5!=7,! *5;C,1656!;)26! /7)/! /75E!=5*5! /*)N5421F!@,*5! /7)1! 21! /75!C*5N2,.;!E5)*^!)16! 2162+)/56! /7)/!
/72;!=);!6.5!/,!/75!F*,=21F!1556!G,*!G)+5O/,OG)+5!@55/21F;I!9;!+,1+4.656!DE!-)*+4)E+)*6!-.;215;;!)16!
%./.*5! %,.16)/2,1! 3PWWZ8^! d-.;215;;! )+*,;;! 21/5*1)/2,1)4! D,*65*;! 21+.*;! 2;;.5;! ;.+7! );! +.4/.*)4! ,*!
4)1F.)F5! D)**25*;! )16! 21+,@C)/2D45! /2@5! 0,15;^! )44! ,G! =72+7! )*5! D5//5*! ,N5*+,@5! =2/7! G)+5O/,OG)+5!
+,1/)+/Ie! %21)44E^! 9*1G)4L! 3PWWP8^! 72F742F7/56! /7)/! )! +5*/)21! 1.@D5*! ,G! @55/21F;! /7)/! =5*5! 7546! N2)!
/545+,1G5*51+5!=,.46!1,/!7)N5!7)CC5156!,/75*=2;5!)16g,*!G5=5*!C5,C45!=,.46!7)N5!/*)N5456!/,!)//516!2/I!
9++,*621F!/,!)!;.*N5E!75!+,16.+/56^!)4@,;/!,15OG2G/7!,G!*5;C,1651/;!7)6!C)*/2+2C)/56!21!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!
/75E! =,.46! 1,/! ,/75*=2;5! 7)N5! /*)N5456! /,I! `/! 2;! *5);,1)D45! /,! );;.@5^! /75*5G,*5^! /7)/! /75! +.4/.*)4^!
5+,1,@2+^!)16!C,42+E!G*)@5=,*L!21!=72+7!;.+7!@55/21F;!/)L5!C4)+5!=244! 42L54E!)GG5+/!/75!.4/2@)/5!2@C)+/!
,1!XYX!5@2;;2,1;^!=7245!/5+71,4,F2+)4!G)+/,*;!=244!)GG5+/!.;)F5!*)/5;!)16!C)//5*1;I!
1.2.3 Virtual meetings – Existing barriers and growth potential
BEC2+)4!+7)4451F5;!G,*!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!65*2N5!G*,@!/75!42@2/)/2,1;!/7)/!)!=,*L!21/5*)+/2,1!@562)/56!DE!)1!
`B! 65N2+5! @)E! D*21F! /,! @55/21F! C)*/2+2C)1/;I! B72;! 2;! @,*5! 5N2651/! =2/7! ).62,+,1G5*51+5;^! =751! /75!
+,@@.12+)/2,1!2;!+,1;/*)2156!/,!N5*D)4O,14E^!D./!2/!2;!)4;,!C*5;51/!21!@,*5!;,C72;/2+)/56!;,4./2,1;^!;.+7!
);!N265,+,1G5*51+21F!,*!=5D!+,1G5*51+21F^!=751!N2;.)4!21/5*)+/2,1!2;!)4;,!C*5;51/!)16!@,*5!/,,4;!51)D45!
*2+75*!21/5*)+/2,1;I!")*425*!;/.625;!72F742F7/56!;,@5!,G!/75;5!D)**25*;^!);!;7,=1!21!/75!F*)C7!D54,=I!
!
! PR
(
B&1C$([;(3&%/406'(7+#$(2+-0%5%,=0&0,5+,A(+,(=%"&(870-+'$(%&A1,+Y1#+%,';(!-1C#0-(=&%6(!&,=14M(I:aaaJ;(
!B5+71,4,F2+)4! 65N54,C@51/! +,1/21.5;! /,! 2@C*,N5! G.1+/2,1)42/25;! )16! 51)D45! *2+75*! `BO@562)/56!
21/5*)+/2,1;I! 9! 1.@D5*! ,G! D)**25*;^! 7,=5N5*^! )*5! 1,/! +,@C45/54E! ,N5*+,@5! E5/I! %,*! 5S)@C45^! /75!
G,44,=21Ff!
! >5;C2/5!/75!;2F12G2+)1/!5SC)1;2,1!)16!517)1+5@51/!,G!`B!21G*);/*.+/.*5;!,N5*!/75!C);/!G5=!E5)*;^!
21! 5@5*F21F! 5+,1,@25;! )16! 65N54,C21F! +,.1/*25;! ;.+7! 21G*);/*.+/.*5;! )*5! ;/244! 21)65].)/5I!
?*,D45@;!@)E!G,44,=!21!/5*@;!,G!4)+L!,G!D)16=26/7^!+,115+/2,1!*542)D242/E^!;5+.*2/E^!,*!4,;;!,G!6)/)I!
`1!/75!+);5!,G!@.4/21)/2,1)4!+,@C)125;!)16!,*F)120)/2,1;!=2/7!,C5*)/2,1;!21!/75;5!+,.1/*25;^!/72;!
+)1!*5C*5;51/!)!@)c,*!,D;/)+45!/,!/75!.;5!,G!`B!)CC42+)/2,1;!G,*!21/5*1)4!@55/21F;^!=72+7!)++,.1/!
G,*!)!4)*F5!;7)*5!,G!/*)N54!21!/75;5!/EC5;!,G!51/2/25;I!!
! B75*5!)*5!C*,D45@;!,G!)++5;;2D242/E^!D,/7! 21!/5*@;!,G!+,;/;!)16!L1,=O7,=I!B72;! 2;!/75!+);5!=2/7!
N265,+,1G5*51+21FI!>5;C2/5!/75!;.D;/)1/2)4!65+*5);5!21!/75!+,;/;!,G!N265,+,1G5*51+21F!5].2C@51/!
)16!;5*N2+5;^!/72;!/5+71,4,FE!;/244! *5].2*5;^! 21!,*65*!/,!)+725N5!N5*E!72F7!C5*G,*@)1+5^!)1! 212/2)4!
21N5;/@51/!/7)/!@)1E!;@)44!)16!@562.@!D.;215;;5;!+)11,/!)GG,*6I!B72;!);C5+/^!+,.C456!=2/7!/75!
4)+L! ,G! )65].)/5! /5+71,4,F2+)4! L1,=O7,=! /7)/! )GG5+/;! @)1E! ;@)44! )16! @562.@! 51/5*C*2;5;!
3'(";8^!7);!42@2/56!/75!65N54,C@51/!,G!/72;!/5+71,4,FE!,1!)!4)*F5!;+)45I!!
! #.4/.*)4^! ,*F)120)/2,1)4^!)16! C;E+7,4,F2+)4! D)**25*;!@)E!)4;,! 42@2/! )6,C/2,1^! );! +7)1F5;! 21! d/75!
=)E!D.;215;;!2;!6,15e!@)E!D5!;551!);!.1155656^!21)CC*,C*2)/5^!,*!+,;/4EI!
91!2@C,*/)1/!);C5+/!/7)/!=244!21G4.51+5!/75!4,1FO/5*@!62;;5@21)/2,1!)16!./2420)/2,1!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!2;!
/75! 65F*55! /,! =72+7! /75E! =244! 3D5! C5*+52N56! /,8! 4)+L! /75! 7.@)1g;,+2)4! 21/5*)+/2,1! 155656! /,! C5*G,*@!
;C5+2G2+! =,*LO*54)/56! /);L;I! 9++,*621F! /,! 9*1G)4L! 3PWWP8^! G,*! 5S)@C45^! D.;215;;! /*)N54! +)1! 7)N5! /7*55!
@)21!C.*C,;5;f!!
! ?*,N265! )++5;;! /,! +.;/,@5*;^! ;.CC425*;^! C)*/15*;^! )16! +,445)F.5;^! ,*! /,! C*,6.+/;^! 21;/*.@51/;^!
5/+I!
! &2546!N)4.5;f!*5N51.5^!21G,*@)/2,1^!L1,=456F5^!;L244;^!+,44)D,*)/2,1^!5/+I!
! ?*,N265!21/)1F2D45!N)4.5;f!/*.;/^!+,1G2651+5^!21/5*5;/^!C45);.*5^!F*)/2/.65^!5/+I!!
`BO51)D456! N2*/.)4! @55/21F;! @)E! )4*5)6E! C5*G,*@! ;,@5! ,G! /75;5! G.1+/2,1;! *54)/2N54E! =544I! $/75*;^!
7,=5N5*^!C*5;51/!D2FF5*!+7)4451F5;^!5;C5+2)44E!/7,;5!/7)/!*5].2*5!)!72F7!6,;5!,G!d;,+2)4!C*5;51+5^e!;.+7!
);! L2+L,GG! )16! L2+LO,./! @55/21F;^! =72+7! /EC2+)44E! C*,N265! 21/)1F2D45! N)4.5;! ;.+7! );! /*.;/^! +,1G2651+5^!
21/5*5;/^!5/+I!!
!
! PJ
1.3 Outlook – Teleworking and virtual meetings
B75!F*,=21F!C515/*)/2,1!,G!D,/7!/545=,*L21F!)16!/545+,1G5*51+21F! 21! /75!=,*LC4)+5!7);!D551!C*,@C/56!
DE!)!1.@D5*!,G!G)+/,*;^!=72+7!=244!42L54E!+,1/21.5!21!/75!+,@21F!E5)*;!)16!65+)65;I!%,*!5S)@C45^!+,1;265*!
/75!G,44,=21Ff!!
! B75!*542)D242/E!)16!)GG,*6)D242/E!,G!`B!)CC42+)/2,1;!;.+7!);!/545=,*L21F!)16!/545+,1G5*51+21F!7)N5!
2@C*,N56! +,1;265*)D4E! 21! /75! C);/! G5=! E5)*;^! +,.C456!=2/7! 5N5*O2@C*,N21F! G.1+/2,1)42/25;I! B72;!
/5+71,4,F2+)4!C*,F*5;;!2;!5SC5+/56!/,!+,1/21.5!21!/75!G./.*5^!)44,=21F!@,*5!*542)D45^!72F7O].)42/E^!
)16!21/5*)+/2N5!+,@@.12+)/2,1;!)16!5S+7)1F5;!)@,1F!.;5*;I!!
! '/*.+/.*)4! +7)1F5;! 21! /75! 5+,1,@E! 3;.+7! );! )! F*,=21F! C*,C,*/2,1! ,G! ;5*N2+5O;5+/,*! )16!
L1,=456F5! =,*L5*;! ,N5*! /75! /,/)4! =,*LG,*+58! +)1! D*,)651! /75! C,,4! ,G! =,*L5*;! /7)/! +)1! .;5!
/545=,*L21F! ,*! N2*/.)4! @55/21F;I! '2F12G2+)1/! F*,=/7! 2;! 42L54E! 21! 5@5*F21F! 5+,1,@25;! )16!
65N54,C21F! +,.1/*25;^!=75*5! /75! ;5*N2+5! ;5+/,*! +.**51/4E! *5C*5;51/;!)! ;@)445*!C*,C,*/2,1! ,G! /75!
5+,1,@E!);!+,@C)*56!/,!65N54,C56!+,.1/*25;I!B75;5!)*5);!=244! 42L54E!F*,=!;2F12G2+)1/4E!,N5*!/75!
15S/!G5=!65+)65;I!
! B5+71,4,F2+)4! 2@C*,N5@51/;! @)E! )4;,! 51)D45! D5//5*! @)1O@)+7215! )16! @)+7215O@)+7215!
21/5*)+/2,1^! =72+7! @)E! )44,=! /75! 65C4,E@51/! ,G! `B! ;,4./2,1;! 21! )! D*,)65*! ;5/! ,G! ;5+/,*;^! )4;,!
51)D421F!)!F*5)/5*!;5/!,G!C*,G5;;2,1;!)16!C5,C45!/,!./24205!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16!/545=,*L21FI!!
! B*)1;C,*/)/2,1!)16!515*FE!+,;/;!7)N5!;551!)1!.C=)*6!/*516!)16!;.+7!+,;/;!)*5!42L54E!/,!G.*/75*!
21+*5);5!21!/75!G./.*5^!5;C5+2)44E!2G!/75!/*.5!+,;/;!,G!G,;;24!G.54!5@2;;2,1;!321+4.621F!5S/5*1)42/25;8!
)*5!+7)*F56!/,!/75!/*)1;C,*/)/2,1!;5+/,*I!
! '5N5*)4! +,@C)125;! )*,.16! /75! =,*46! 7)N5! +,@@2//56! /,! XYXO5@2;;2,1O*56.+/2,1! ;/*)/5F25;^!
C)*/4E!21!*5;C,1;5!/,!/75!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!@2/2F)/2,1!/)*F5/;!)6,C/56!DE!)!1.@D5*!,G!F,N5*1@51/;^!
C)*/2+.4)*4E!.165*!/75![E,/,!?*,/,+,4I!
b16,.D/564E!)!F*,=21F!.;5!,G!/545=,*L21F!)16!/545+,1G5*51+21F!=244!7)N5!)1!2@C)+/!,1!/*)1;C,*/)/2,1!)16!
);;,+2)/56!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!B75!15/!2@C)+/!)+725N56^!7,=5N5*^!@)E!N)*E!;2F12G2+)1/4E^!);!;5N5*)4!G)+/,*;!
21G4.51+5!D,/7!62*5+/!)16!2162*5+/!3*5D,.168!5@2;;2,1;^!);!244.;/*)/56!21!/75!G,44,=21F!;5+/2,1I!
!
1.4 Paths of GHG impact for teleworking and teleconferencing
-E!42@2/21F!/75!1556!/,!/*)N54!G,*!=,*L!,*!@55/21F;!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!+)1!C,/51/2)44E!
C*,N265!)!C,;2/2N5!+,1/*2D./2,1!21!/75!5GG,*/!/,!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!B75;5!`B!;,4./2,1;^!7,=5N5*^!+)1!
2@C)+/!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!/7*,.F7!@.4/2C45!+7)1154;^!D,/7!62*5+/4E!)16!2162*5+/4EI!%*,@!/75!C,21/!,G!N25=!,G!
+42@)/5!+7)1F5^!;,@5!;,4./2,1;!@)E!45)6!/,!G.*/75*!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!3+*5)/21F!N2*/.,.;!+E+45;!,G!XYX!
5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;8!=7245!,/75*;!@)E!45)6!/,!21+*5);56!5@2;;2,1;!3+*5)/21F!15F)/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!
/7)/!+)1!15F)/5!21!=7,45!,*!21!C)*/!/75!212/2)4!*56.+/2,1;!)+725N568I!B75!/)D45!D54,=!C*,N265;!)1!
244.;/*)/2,1!,G!/75;5!6E1)@2+;I!',4./2,1;!/7)/!45)6!/,!*56.+/2,1;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!)*5!=*2//51!21!F*551a!
/7,;5!/7)/!45)6!/,!21+*5);5;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!)*5!=*2//51!21!D4)+LI!!
!
! PQ
!
8%4"#+%,'(G01-+,A(#%(S0-"5#+%,'(
+,(BKB(Q6+''+%,'(
8%4"#+%,'(G01-+,A(#%(),5&01'0'(
+,(BKB(Q6+''+%,'(
:56.+56!+,@@./21F!,*!=,*LO*54)/56!/*)N54!*56.+5;!#$P!5@2;;2,1;I!
!
B75!.;5!,G!`B!5].2C@51/!/,!;.CC,*/!=,*L!)16!21/5*)+/2,1!G*,@!7,@5!.;5;!545+/*2+2/E^!=72+7!C*,6.+5;!#$P!5@2;;2,1;I!
!
_5;;!,*!@,*5!5GG2+251/!.;5!,G!`B!5].2C@51/!21!)1!,GG2+5!@)E!*56.+5!545+/*2+2/E!.;5!)16!*54)/56!#$P!5@2;;2,1;I!
!
B545=,*L5*;!@)E!+,1;.@5!@,*5!515*FE!)/!7,@5!G,*!75)/21F!)16!42F7/21FI!
!
"@C4,E55;!@)E!+,1;.@5!45;;!515*FE!)/!=,*L!G,*!75)/21F!)16!42F7/21FI!
!
?5,C45!=7,!)N,26!+,@@./21F!,*!D.;215;;!/*)N54;!@)E!7)N5!)662/2,1)4!/2@5!)N)24)D45^!=72+7!@)E!45)6!/,!)662/2,1)4!/*)N54!G,*!C5*;,1)4!+7,*5;!,*!452;.*5^!=72+7!21+*5);5;!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!!
!
9N,2621F!/*2C;!*56.+5;!+,;/;^!=72+7!C*,N265;!)662/2,1)4!21+,@5!,*!C*,G2/;^!=72+7!21!/.*1!45)6!/,!+,1;.@C/2,1!,*!21N5;/@51/!21!C*,6.+/;!)16!;5*N2+5;!/7)/!)4;,!F515*)/5!)!*56.+/2,1!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!3B72;!=,.46!D5!/75!+);5!2G!+.4/.*5^!5+,1,@2+;^!)16!C,42+25;!+7)1154!5SC5162/.*5;!/,=)*6;!4,=O+)*D,1!42G5;/E45;!)16!+,1;.@C/2,1;I8!!
!
9N,2621F!/*2C;!*56.+5;!+,;/;^!=72+7!C*,N265;!)662/2,1)4!21+,@5!,*!C*,G2/;^!=72+7!21!/.*1!45)6!/,!+,1;.@C/2,1!,*!21N5;/@51/!21!F,,6;!,*!;5*N2+5;!=2/7!4)*F5!+)*D,1!G,,/C*21/;I!3B72;!=,.46!D5!/75!+);5!2G!+.4/.*5^!5+,1,@2+;^!)16!C,42+25;!51+,.*)F5!5SC5162/.*5;!/7)/!45)6!/,!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I8!!
!
#,@C)125;!=75*5!)!;2F12G2+)1/!1.@D5*!,G!5@C4,E55;!=,*L!G*,@!7,@5!@)E!D5!)D45!/,!*56.+5!/752*!,GG2+5!;C)+5!)16!/75!);;,+2)/56!545+/*2+2/E!)16!75)/!.;5I!!
!
<,*L5*;!=7,!=,*L!)/!7,@5!@)E!=)1/!D2FF5*!7,@5;!/,!)++,@@,6)/5!/75!7,@5!,GG2+5^!=72+7!@)E!21+*5);5!515*FE!.;5I!
!
?5,C45!=7,!7)N5!/75!,CC,*/.12/E!/,!/545=,*L!@)E!D5!21+42156!/,!@,N5!G.*/75*!)=)E!G*,@!/752*!,GG2+5;^!/7.;!,N5*!/2@5!7)N21F!)1!21+51/2N5!/,!)4@,;/!15N5*!/*)N54!/,!/75!,GG2+5^!=72+7!65+*5);5;!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!!
I!!
?5,C45!=7,!7)N5!/75!,CC,*/.12/E!/,!/545=,*L!@)E!D5!21+42156!/,!@,N5!G.*/75*!)=)E!G*,@!/752*!,GG2+5;^!/7.;!/*)N5421F!4,1F5*!=751!F,21F!/,!/75!,GG2+5;^!=72+7!21+*5);5;!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!!
!
B75!)D242/E!/,!=,*L!=2/7!C5,C45!21!N2*/.)4!;C)+5;!@)E!5S/516!)!15/=,*L!,G!*54)/2,1;72C;!/,!C4)+5;!/7)/!)*5!G.*/75*!)16!G.*/75*!)=)EI!B72;!@)E!45)6!/,!3);!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!D5+,@5!;,!+,@@,1!/7)/!2/!2;!2@C,;;2D45!/,!@55/!5N5*E,158!)!65+*5);5!21!/75!.*F5!/,!C7E;2+)44E!@55/I!!
!
B75!)D242/E!/,!=,*L!=2/7!C5,C45!21!N2*/.)4!;C)+5;!@)E!5S/516!)!15/=,*L!,G!*54)/2,1;72C;!/,!C4)+5;!/7)/!)*5!G.*/75*!)16!G.*/75*!)=)EI!B72;!@)E!45)6!/,!!21OC5*;,1!/*2C;!21!)*5);!/7)/!=,.46!1,/!,/75*=2;5!D5!)!/*)N54!65;/21)/2,1^!/7.;!21+*5);21F!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!!
!
?5,C45!=7,!)N,26!+,@@./21F!,*!D.;215;;!/*)N54;!@)E!F5/!*26!,G!/75!+)*!)16g,*!+7)1F5!/752*!42G5;/E45^!=72+7!@)E!45)6!/,!*56.+56!/*)N54!G,*!C5*;,1)4!+7,*5;!,*!452;.*5^!=72+7!65+*5);5;!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!
!
!
<,*L21F!G*,@!7,@5!@)E!45)6!/,!;/*,1F5*!*,,/;!21!)1!)*5)!)16!=2/721!)!+,@@.12/E^!=72+7!@)E!45)6!/,!45;;!/*)N5421F!)16!@,*5!4,+)4!+,1;.@C/2,1!)16!45;;!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!362*5+/!C,;2/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/8I!
!
!
`G!/545+,@@./21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)*5!5SC42+2/4E!);;,+2)/56!=2/7!51N2*,1@51/)4!D515G2/;^!C5,C45!@)E!/*)1;G5*!;.+7!N)4.5;!G*,@!/75!=,*L!51N2*,1@51/!/,!,/75*!51N2*,1@51/;^!=72+7!=244!65+*5);5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!!
!
!
(*1/40([D(*0407%&M+,A(1,-(2+&#"14(600#+,A'O(-+&05#(1,-(+,-+&05#(+6C15#(%,(BKB(06+''+%,';(
!"#$%&'"(
%)*%(+()(,
-%. '/
#00+(+'$#1
".%')"2.%
34#$5.
+$
*)+10+$5%
34#$5.+$
2+(+.%
34#$5. +$6
7#1).% 86
*.4#7+')"%9'".6
+$0+".2(
9'".60+".2(
!
! P\
%,*!@,;/!,G! /75!N)*2)D45;!)16! *54)/2,1;72C;!@51/2,156!)D,N5^! /75!6)/)! +.**51/4E!)N)24)D45! 2;!5S/*5@54E!
;+)*+5I! b165*;/)1621F! )16! ].)1/2GE21F! /75! 5S2;/21F! )16! C,;;2D45! 2@C)+/! ,G! /545=,*L21F! )16! N2*/.)4!
@55/21F;!,1!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!/75*5G,*5!21N,4N5;!;2F12G2+)1/!+7)4451F5;I!!
`/! @.;/! )4;,! D5! ;)26^! 7,=5N5*^! /7)/! /)*F5/56! C,42+25;! )16! ;/*)/5F25;! +)1! F*5)/4E! )GG5+/! @,;/! ,G! /75!
N)*2)D45;! )16! *54)/2,1;72C;! @51/2,156! )D,N5I! B,! )! ;2F12G2+)1/! 5S/51/^! /75*5G,*5^! =751! +,1;265*21F! /75!
,CC,*/.12/25;!G,*!*56.+/2,1;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!/7*,.F7!/545+,@@./21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;^!,15!+)1!);L!
/75!].5;/2,1^!d<7)/!+,162/2,1;!+)1!D5!+*5)/56!/,!@)S2@205!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;^!)16!=7)/!;7,.46!D5!
6,15!/,!)N,26!*2;L;!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!21+*5);5oe!!
B72;!].5;/2,1!.165*425;!/72;!*5C,*/I!B75!;5+/2,1;!D54,=!)6,C/!)1!)CC*,)+7!/,!21N5;/2F)/5!C,;;2D45!G./.*5!
/*)c5+/,*25;^! 62;+.;;! L5E! 6*2N5*;! )16! ;51;2/2N2/25;^! )16! 2651/2GE! C,42+25;! )16! ;/*)/5F25;! /7)/! +)1! 754C!
@)S2@205!/75!+42@)/5!D515G2/;!,G!/75!4,=O+)*D,1!`B!;,4./2,1;!.165*!21N5;/2F)/2,1I!
!
2 Future worlds
9;! 72F742F7/56! 21! ;5+/2,1! P^! /75*5! )*5! 1.@5*,.;! N)*2)D45;! /7)/! @)E! )GG5+/! /75! 2@C45@51/)/2,1! ,G! `B!
;,4./2,1;! G,*! *5@,/5!+,44)D,*)/2,1!)16! *5@,/5!=,*L21F^!)16! /75*5!)*5!@.4/2C45! +7)1154;! /7*,.F7!=72+7!
;.+7!/5+71,4,F25;!+)1!)GG5+/!XYX!5@2;;2,1;^!D,/7!62*5+/4E!)16!2162*5+/4E^!=2/7!N)*2,.;!65F*55!,G! 2@C)+/!
C5*! +7)1154I! B7.;! ;5N5*)4! C,;;2D45! G./.*5;! +)1! D5! 2@)F2156^! 21! =72+7! /75! 21/5*C4)E! ,G! /75;5! N)*2)D45;!
45)6;!/,!6*)@)/2+)44E!62GG5*51/!*5;.4/;I!
B7*55!L5E!C4)E5*;!)CC5)*!/,!7)N5!)!;2F12G2+)1/!65F*55!,G!21G4.51+5!,1!@,;/!,G!/75!*545N)1/!N)*2)D45;f!/75!
`B! 216.;/*E^! +.;/,@5*;! /7)/! )6,C/! `B! C*,6.+/;! /,! *56.+5! /*)N54! 3`B! .;5*;8^! )16! C,42+E!@)L5*;I! B75! `B!
216.;/*E! 7);! )! F*5)/! 65F*55! ,G! 21G4.51+5! ,1! 7,=! `B! /5+71,4,F25;! )*5! 65N54,C56^!@)*L5/56^! )16! .;56I!
%)+/,*;! +,1/*,4456! DE! /75! `B! 216.;/*E! 21+4.65! 65+2;2,1;! ;.+7! );! =751! 15=! C*,6.+/;! )*5! 65N54,C56^!
=75/75*!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!D515G2/;!)*5!C)*/!,G!/75!C*,6.+/h;!*5].2*5@51/;!)16!+,1N5E56!/,!.;5*;^!=75/75*!
/,! 51+,.*)F5! ;E;/5@! 2@C45@51/)/2,1! /,! 21+4.65! )1! 5GG,*/! /,! *56.+5! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;^! )16! =75/75*! /,!
51+,.*)F5!F,N5*1@51/)4!C,42+E!65N54,C@51/!*5F)*621F!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!)16!21G*);/*.+/.*5!65N54,C@51/I!!
`B! .;5*;! +)1! G,*@.4)/5! ;/*)/5F25;!)16! 65@)16;!,1! D,/7! /75! `B! 216.;/*E!)16! C,42+E!@)L5*;I! B75E!@)E!
65C4,E! `B! /,! +,1;+2,.;4E! *56.+5! /752*! XYX! G,,/C*21/! ,*! @)E! D5! .1)=)*5! ,G! /72;! C,/51/2)4! 3,*!
.1=24421Fg.1)D45!/,!)+/8!)16!;,!.;5!`B!21!=)E;!/7)/!G.*/75*!21+*5);5!/752*!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!!
?,42+E!@)L5*;!+)1!)*/2+.4)/5!C,42+25;! /7)/!)GG5+/! /75!)6,C/2,1!,G!`B!)16!/75! 2@C)+/!`B!+)1!7)N5!,1!XYX!
5@2;;2,1;! /7*,.F7!62GG5*51/! +7)1154;I!%,*! 21;/)1+5^!C,42+E!@)L5*;! +)1! 2@C45@51/!C,42+25;! /7)/!C*,@,/5!
/75! .;5! ,G! `B^! G)N,*! `B! ;,4./2,1;!=2/7! /75! 72F75;/! 51N2*,1@51/)4! D515G2/^! )6,C/! )! ;5*N2+5! C5*;C5+/2N5^!
)44,=!`B!;,4./2,1;!/,!D5!+,@C)*56!=2/7!/*)62/2,1)4!=)E;!,G!C*,N2621F!/75!;5*N2+5!;.+7!);!G4E21F!,*!6*2N21F!
DE! +)*^! *56.+5! ,*! 21+*5);5! /75! )D242/E! ,G! =,*L5*;! /,! =,*L! *5@,/54E^! C*,@,/5! )! ;.;/)21)D45! ,*!
.1;.;/)21)D45!.;5!,G!)662/2,1)4! *5;,.*+5;!3/2@5!,*!@,15E8! /7)/!)*5!@)65!)N)24)D45!DE!5GG2+251+E!F)21;^!
5/+I!
#,1;265*21F!62GG5*51/!D57)N2,*;!G*,@!/75;5!L5E!C4)E5*;^!/72;!*5C,*/!244.;/*)/5;!)16!)1)4E05;!G,.*!C,;;2D45!
G./.*5;f!!
! A,! ,15! /)L5;! /75! 45)6! )16! ;,+25/E! 65N54,C;! ,1! )! D.;215;;O);O.;.)4! C)//5*1! p+)*D,1!
=,*46qI!
! B75!C,42+E! 6,@)21!6542N5*;!5GG5+/2N5! +42@)/5!+7)1F5!C,42+25;^!D./! `B! ;.CC425*;!)16!.;5*;!
)*5!1,/!C*,)+/2N5!)/!)66*5;;21F!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!C*,D45@;I!B72;!=,.46!D5!)!;+51)*2,!=2/7!
!
! PZ
)@D2/2,.;! /)*F5/;! +,@C)*56! /,! /,6)E^! *5;.4/21F! 21! ;2F12G2+)1/^! D./! ;/244! 21+*5@51/)4^!
2@C*,N5@51/;!pC,42+E!=,*46qI!
! B75!`B!216.;/*E!)16!`B!.;5*;!;7,=!)!+,@@2/@51/!/,!2@C45@51/!4,=O+)*D,1!`B!;,4./2,1;^!
=7245!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)*5!215GG5+/2N5!)/!/)*F5/21F!+42@)/5!+7)1F5I!B72;!;+51)*2,!2;! 21!@)1E!
=)E;! )1! 5S/*5@5! ;+51)*2,! /7)/! 2;! @5)1/! /,! 244.;/*)/5! =7)/! 7)CC51;! 2G! 1,! ,N5*)44!
G*)@5=,*L!5S2;/;!p/5+7!=,*46qI!
! [5E!C4)E5*;! 21! /75! `B! 216.;/*E^! `B!.;5*;^!)16!C,42+E!@)L5*;! +,@5! /,F5/75*!)16!;.CC,*/!
/75! .;5! ,G! 4,=O+)*D,1! `B! ;,4./2,1;! )16! /75! +*5)/2,1! ,G! )! G*)@5=,*L! /7)/! ;.CC,*/! 4,=O
+)*D,1!G556D)+L!/7)/!+,1/*2D./5;!/,!)++545*)/56!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!p;@)*/!=,*46qI!
B75!G,.*!C,;;2D45!G./.*5;!)*5!;.@@)*2056!21!/75!/)D45!D54,=I!
!
(! )*(+,-"'#&.(/0$12+%&(
(
! `B!216.;/*E!)16!.;5*;!6,!1,/!)66*5;;!515*FE!)16!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!2;;.5;!;C5+2G2+)44E(
`B!216.;/*E!)16!.;5*;!)FF*5;;2N54E!C.*;.5!)16!,GG5*!+42@)/5OG*25164E!;,4./2,1;(
3%4+5.(
-%61+,(
"GG5+/2N5!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!C,42+E^!21+4.621F!;.CC,*/!G,*!4,=O+)*D,1!`B!;,4./2,1;!
3%4+5.(7%&4-((
(
861&#(7%&4-(
(
<5)L!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!C,42+E^!2F1,*21F!/75!*,45!,G!4,=O+)*D,1!`B!
91&/%,(7%&4-((
(
*05$(7%&4-((
(
*1/40(b;((")+7!,G!/75;5!C,;;2D45!G./.*5;!2;!65;+*2D56!21!@,*5!65/)24!D54,=I!
2.1 Carbon world
9!+)*D,1!=,*46!*5C*5;51/;!)!=,*46!21!=72+7!D,/7!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)16!216.;/*E!)*5!1,/!=24421F!,*!)D45!/,!
5GG5+/2N54E!)66*5;;!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!2;;.5;I!`1!/72;!=,*46^!C);/!/*516;^!D57)N2,*;^!)16!65N54,C@51/!@,654;!
)*5!@)21/)2156I!-.;215;;5;!*5].2*5!5@C4,E55;!/,!@,;/4E!=,*L!21!+51/*)42056!,GG2+5;!,*!G)+/,*25;I!%)+5O/,O
G)+5!@55/21F;!*5@)21!/75!C*5N)451/!=)E!/,!21/5*)+/I!_)D,*!*54)/2,1;!G,+.;!,1!C*,+5;;!+,1/*,4!3);!,CC,;56!
/,!,./+,@58I!$=15*;72C!,G!C*2N)/5!N572+45;!2;!)!;/)/.;!;E@D,4!21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!)16!65N54,C56!
+,.1/*25;!)42L5^!)16!2;!)!15+5;;2/E!21!@)1E!+,.1/*25;!/7)/!6,!1,/!,GG5*!)4/5*1)/2N5;!/,!C*2N)/5!N572+45!
/*)1;C,*/)/2,1I!-E!)16!4)*F5!/75!515*FE!;E;/5@;!.;56!21!;,+25/E!321+4.621F!/*)1;C,*/)/2,18!)*5!G,;;24OG.54O
D);56!)16!;7,=!)!42@2/56!21+*5);5!21!5GG2+251+E!,N5*!/2@5I!`B!/5+71,4,F25;!3D);56!,1!21+*5@51/)4!
2@C*,N5@51/;!,G!+.**51/!M!PWWT!M!/5+71,4,F25;8!;.CC,*/!)!;/5)6E!F*,=/7!21!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!
@55/21F;^!D./!/75*5!2;!1,!;C5+2G2+!G,+.;!,1!)+725N21F!*56.+/2,1;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!=2/7!;.+7!)CC42+)/2,1;I!
2.2 Policy world
?,42+E!@)L5*;!6*2N5!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!)+/2,1!21!/75!C,42+E!=,*46^!=7245!/75!`B!216.;/*E!)16!/75!C*2N)/5!;5+/,*!
G,+.;! ,1!@55/21F! *5F.4)/,*E! *5].2*5@51/;I! #42@)/5! +7)1F5! C,42+E! /)*F5/;! /*)62/2,1)4! )+/2N2/25;! ;.+7! );!
515*FE! C*,6.+/2,1! )16! 515*FE! 5GG2+251+E! 21! D.24621F;! )16! 21! 515*FEO21/51;2N5! 216.;/*25;I! $N5*)44!
5+,1,@25;! )16! ;,+25/25;! D5+,@5! 45;;! 65C51651/! ,1! G,;;24! G.54;! )16! *56.+5! /752*! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;I! B75!
C,42+25;!21!C4)+5^!7,=5N5*^!)*5!1,/!5GG5+/2N5!)/!45N5*)F21F!`B!/,!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!'/2@.42!/,!)6,C/!`B!
;,4./2,1;!/7)/!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!)*5!2162*5+/!,*!G55D45I!!
!
! PT
2.3 Tech world
B75!/5+7!=,*46!2;!)!@2**,*!2@)F5!,G!/75!C,42+E!=,*46I!`1!/72;!=,*46^!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)*5!.1)D45!/,!G216!/75!
+,1;51;.;!155656!/,!;5*2,.;4E!/)+L45!+42@)/5!+7)1F5I!B75!`B!216.;/*E^!,1!/75!,/75*!7)16^!65N54,C;!)16!
62*5+/;!/5+71,4,FE!/,=)*6;!*56.+21F!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!<751!`B!2;!/75!+,*5!+,@C,151/!,G!)!;5*N2+5!35IFI^!
/545=,*L21F!,*!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;8^!62*5+/!*56.+/2,1;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!)*5!)+725N56I!<751!`B!2;!65C4,E56!
);!)!;.D+,@C,151/!,G!)!=265*!;E;/5@!35IFI^!21!515*FE!,*!/*)1;C,*/)/2,1!;E;/5@;8^!`BO51)D456!
2@C*,N5@51/;!)*5!F515*)44E!./242056!/,!21+*5);5!C5*G,*@)1+5!=2/7,./!65+*5);21F!515*FE!+,1;.@C/2,1!)16!
5@2;;2,1;I!`1!D,/7!+);5;^!)662/2,1)4!*5;,.*+5;!3/2@5!)16!@,15E8!@)65!)N)24)D45!DE!/75!5GG2+251+E!F)21;!
65*2N21F!G*,@!`B!.;5!)*5!;C51/!21!F,,6;^!;5*N2+5;^!)16!)+/2N2/25;!/7)/!45)6!/,!G.*/75*!XYX!5@2;;2,1;^!/7.;!
F515*)/21F!15F)/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;I!`1!/72;!=,*46!̀ B!2$(12,0*0()2.,.<",3/&&").!);!/75!5GG2+251+E!F)21;!
)16!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!C,/51/2)44E!51)D456!DE!`B!)*5!+,.1/5*D)4)1+56!DE!)!F515*)4!;,+2,5+,1,@2+!
;5//21F!/7)/!2;!1,/!+,16.+2N5!/,!655C5*!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;I!!
2.4 Smart world
`1!/75!;@)*/!=,*46^!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)16!/75!`B!216.;/*E!+,1N5*F5!,1!/75!F,)4!,G!*56.+21F!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!
"GG5+/2N5!+,44)D,*)/2,1!/)L5;!C4)+5!)16!`B!2;!)!+*2/2+)4!+,@C,151/!21!/75!C,*/G,42,!,G!;,4./2,1;!65N2;56!DE!
;,+25/25;!/,!542@21)/5!/75!5GG5+/;!,G!+42@)/5!+7)1F5I!
!
B,F5/75*^! C,42+E! @)L5*;! )16! /75! `B! 216.;/*E! ;55L! /,! )+/2N)/5! N2*/.,.;! +E+45;! ,G! 4,=O+)*D,1! G556D)+L^!
=72+7! C*,@,/5! )16! 45N5*)F5! 211,N)/2,1! 21! =72+7! `B! 2;! )! L5E! 51)D45*I! ! 9;! 4,=O+)*D,1! G556D)+L! 4,,C;!
.1G,46^! /*)1;G,*@)/2N5! +7)1F5;! +)1! /)L5! C4)+5! )/! )44! 45N54;! ,G! ;,+25/E^! 45)621F! /,! *56.+/2,1;! 21! XYX!
5@2;;2,1;!)+*,;;!)!D*,)6!*)1F5!,G!)+/2N2/25;I!U2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16! /545+,@@./21F!)*5! /=,!,G! /75!@)1E!
;,4./2,1;!/7)/!51)D45!6*)@)/2+!*56.+/2,1;!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!
!
!
!
! PV
G%7L51&/%,(=00-/15M(`(c1M+,A(#&1,'=%&61#+20(06+''+%,(&0-"5#+%,'(1(&014+#.::((
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`B! /5+71,4,F25;^! /,F5/75*! =2/7! ,/75*!)6N)1+56^!1,1/EC2+)4!515*FE!;,4./2,1;^!;.+7!);!21/5F*)/56!;,4)*g_">gD)//5*E!;,4./2,1;^!@)E!C4)E!)!L5E!*,45! 21! )+725N21F! ;.+7! /*)1;G,*@)/2N5! +7)1F5;I! U2;2,1! )16! ;@)*/! ;/*)/5F25;! G*,@! F,N5*1@51/;! )16!C*2N)/5O;5+/,*!+,@C)125;! 45N5*)F21F!`B!/5+71,4,F25;!+)1!51)D45!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1!C)/7;!/7)/! 45)6!/,!/*)1;G,*@)/2,1;^! =72+7! 21! /.*1! C*,6.+5! G.*/75*! XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;^! /7.;! F515*)/21F! N2*/.,.;!+E+45;!,G!4,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+LI!91!5S)@C45!2;!C*,N2656!D54,=I!
?.D42+! )./7,*2/25;! )6,C/! 5OF,N5*1@51/! ;,4./2,1;! )+*,;;! /75! D,)*6^! +,.C456! =2/7! )! /*)1;G,*@)/2,1! ,G!/752*!D)+L!,GG2+5;^!=72+7!21N,4N5;!)!F515*)42056!.;5!,G!*5@,/5!=,*L21F!;,4./2,1;I!_)=;!/7)/!72165*!/75!)6,C/2,1!,G! *5@,/5!=,*L21F! ;,4./2,1;!)*5!)@51656^!=7245! 21+51/2N5;!)*5!C*,N2656! /,! +,@C)125;! /7)/!*56.+5! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;! =2/7! )! ;@)*/! .;5! ,G! `B! 3)4,1F! =2/7! ,/75*^! @,*5! /*)62/2,1)4^! ;/*)/5F25;8I!-*,)6D)16! )++5;;! 2;! F515*)42056! )16! +,@@.12+)/2,1! )16! +)C)+2/EOD.24621F! +)@C)2F1;! )*5! *,4456! ,./!/7*,.F7,./!;,+25/E!/,!21+*5);5!/75!)++5C/)1+5!)16!)6,C/2,1!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16!/545+,@@./21FI!
91!21+*5);5!21!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)16!/545+,@@./21F^!+,.C456!=2/7!/)*F5/56!+,@@.12+)/2,1!)16!21+51/2N5!;+75@5;^!45)6;!/,!)1!21+*5);21F!65@)16!G,*!;@)*/!D.24621F;!)16!)!D*,)65*!.;5!,G!`B!/,!,D/)21!C*,6.+/;!,*!;5*N2+5;!35O+,@@5*+5^!5OF,N5*1@51/^!5O75)4/7^!5/+I8I!!
B75!F*,=21F!65@)16!G,*!5O+,@@5*+5!)16!5O;5*N2+5;!51)D45;!@,*5!+,@C)125;!/,!)6,C/!/545+,@@./21F!;,4./2,1;! G,*! /752*!5@C4,E55;!)16!@)L5! /752*!,GG2+5;!N2*/.)4!);! /75! 212/2)4!65@)16!F515*)/5;!)!D5//5*!21G*);/*.+/.*5! G,*! )662/2,1)4! ;5*N2+5;I! `1! /.*1^! =2/7! @,*5! C5,C45! =,*L21F! G*,@! 7,@5! )16! .;21F! /75!`1/5*15/! /,! D.E! C*,6.+/;! )16! ;5*N2+5;^! /*)1;C,*/)/2,1! C)//5*1;! +7)1F5! =7245! /75! 1556! G,*! C*2N)/5!,=15*;72C!,G!)!N572+45!65+*5);5;I!?.D42+!)./7,*2/25;!G)N,*!/75;5!/*516;!/7*,.F7!.*D)1!C4)1121F^!+*5)/21F!@,*5!@2S56O.;5!+,@@.12/25;!3`B!/,,4;!51)D45!C.D42+!)./7,*2/25;!/,!.165*/)L5!;@)*/!.*D)1!C4)1121F8I!9662/2,1)4! C,42+25;! )*5! )6,C/56! /,! *56.+5! .115+5;;)*E! /*)N54! )16! /,! C*,@,/5! C.D42+! /*)1;C,*/! 35IFI^!*5)4O/2@5!C*2+21F!G,*!+)*!C,44./2,1^!51)D456!DE!`B8I!!
9;!@2S56O.;5!+,@@.12/25;!21+*5);5!21!1.@D5*^!)=)*515;;!)16!L1,=456F5!)4;,!21+*5);5;!21!/75!=265*!;,+25/EI! ?,42+E! @)L5*;! C*,@,/5! /75;5! /*516;! =2/7! +,@@.12+)/2,1! +)@C)2F1;I! 9;! )! *5;.4/^! C5,C45!65@)16!@,*5!C,42+25;! /7)/! 45N5*)F5!/5+71,4,FE! /,! 21+*5);5!].)42/E!,G! 42G5!)16!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;^!)16!51/2*5!+2/25;!)16!+,.1/*25;!D5+,@5!d;@)*/5*Ie!!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!11 B75!4,=O+)*D,1!)16!72F7O+)*D,1!G556D)+L!2;!65N54,C56!G.*/75*!21!/75!<<%!*5C,*/!dB75!G2*;/!F4,D)4!;/*)/5FE!G,*!#$P!*56.+/2,1;!=2/7!`Bf!9!D2442,1!/,1;!,G!#$P!*56.+/2,1;!)16!D5E,16!/7*,.F7!/*)1;G,*@)/2N5!+7)1F5^e!)N)24)D45!)/!===IC)16)I,*Fg2+/I
!
! RW
3 Quantitative analysis – Methodology
B72;! *5C,*/! 21+4.65;! )! ].)1/2/)/2N5! )1)4E;2;! DE! F5,F*)C72+! *5F2,1;! /,!5;/2@)/5! /75!XYX!5@2;;2,1;! /7)/!
@)E! /)L5!C4)+5! 21! /75!62GG5*51/!=,*46;!65;+*2D56!)D,N5^!)16! G,+.;5;! ,1! /75!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!);;,+2)/56!
=2/7!D.;215;;!)2*!/*)N54!)16!+)*OD);56!+,@@./21FIKP!!!
B75!].)1/2G2+)/2,1!)CC*,)+7!2;!244.;/*)/56!DE!/75!G2F.*5!D54,=I!!
!
!
!
W+A"&0(E;(d"1,#+#1#+20(1,14.'+'(%=(BKB(06+''+%,'!
-)+LF*,.16! 6)/)! =5*5! +,445+/56! ,1! ;,+2,5+,1,@2+! 2162+)/,*;! 35IFI^! C,C.4)/2,1^! 21+,@5! )16!
,++.C)/2,1! DE! ;5+/,*8^! *,)6! /*)1;C,*/! 3+)*! ,=15*;72C! *)/5;^! )N5*)F5! L24,@5/5*;! /*)N5456^!
)N5*)F5!G.54!5GG2+251+E^!+,@@./21F!6)/)^!5/+I8^!)16!)2*!/*)1;C,*/!3/,/)4!L24,@5/5*;!,G!)2*!/*)N54^!
D.;215;;!/*)N54!);!)!C5*+51/)F5!,G!/75!/,/)4^!)N5*)F5!G.54!+,1;.@C/2,1;!C5*!L24,@5/5*!/*)N5456^!
5/+I8I!!
%,*! /72;! D)+LF*,.16! 6)/)^! ,GG2+2)4! ;/)/2;/2+;! =5*5! .;56! G*,@! N)*2,.;! ;,.*+5;! C.D42;756! DE!
21/5*1)/2,1)4! ,*F)120)/2,1;! ;.+7! );! /75! $*F)120)/2,1! G,*! "+,1,@2+! #,,C5*)/2,1! )16!
>5N54,C@51/! 3$"#>8^! /75! `1/5*1)/2,1)4! "15*FE! 9F51+E! 3`"98^! )16! /75! b12/56! A)/2,1;I! %,*!
+,.1/*EO45N54!6)/)^!,GG2+2)4!1)/2,1)4!;/)/2;/2+;!=5*5!.;56!);!=544I!%.*/75*!65/)24;!,1!/75!;C5+2G2+!
;,.*+5;!.;56! G,*!5)+7!;5/!,G!6)/)!)*5!C*,N2656!21!/75!)115S!/,!/72;!*5C,*/^!);!=544!);! 21! /75!
D2D42,F*)C7EI!!!
B75! D)+LF*,.16! 6)/)! 21G,*@56! /75! ;2@.4)/2,1! @,6.45;^! =72+7! C*,c5+/56! ;,+2,5+,1,@2+!
)+/2N2/25;!)16!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!G,*!/75!G,.*!=,*46;!.165*! 21N5;/2F)/2,1I!`1!,*65*!/,!C5*G,*@!/75!
;2@.4)/2,1;^! L5E! );;.@C/2,1;! =5*5! 65N2;56! G,*! 5)+7! ,G! /75! G,.*! ;+51)*2,;! @,65456I! '.+7!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!
KP!B75!G,+.;!,G!/75!)1)4E;2;!=);!,1!D.;215;;!)2*!/*)N54^!);!2;!2/!2;!,15!,G!/75!G);/5;/OF*,=21F!;,.*+5;!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!$/75*!C,;;2D45!5GG5+/;^!;.+7!);!+7)1F5;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!65*2N21F!G*,@!D.;215;;!/*)N54!.165*/)L51!DE!+)*!,*!/*)21!32I5I^!1,/!D.;215;;!)2*!/*)N548^!=5*5!1,/!].)1/2G256I!B75!)1)4E;2;!.165*/)L51!21!;5+/2,1!Q!=244!/75*5G,*5!C*,N265!)1!.165*5;/2@)/5!,G!/75!C,/51/2)4!2@C)+/!,G!`#B!,1!D.;215;;!/*)N54!);!)!=7,45I!!
Simulation modules
Country n
Country …
Country A
Control panel
Key assumptions virtual meetings
Key assumptions telecommuting
Virtual meeting
Country n
Country …
Country A
Telecommuting
Background data modules
Country n
Country …
Country A
Socio-economic data
Country n
Country …
Country A
Socio-economic data
Country n
Country …
Country A
Road transportation
data
Country n
Country …
Country A
Road transportation
data
Country n
Country …
Country A
Air transportation data
Country n
Country …
Country A
Air transportation data
Output Sheet(s)
!
! RK
);;.@C/2,1;^!)16!/752*!*)/2,1)45^!)*5!65;+*2D56!21!@,*5!65/)24!21!;5+/2,1!RIK!3D54,=8!)16!21!/75!
)CC5162SI!!
3.1 Key assumptions – Approach
B75!/)D45!D54,=!;.@@)*205;!/75!@)21!N)*2)D45;!.;56!21!/75!;2@.4)/2,1!@,654!)16!244.;/*)/5;!/75!)CC*,)+7!
G,44,=56!21!;545+/21F!/75!L5E!@,654!);;.@C/2,1;I!B75!/)D45!C*,N265;!)!65;+*2C/2,1!,G!/75!@)21!
);;.@C/2,1;!./242056!21!/75!@,654I!(,*5!65/)2456!21G,*@)/2,1!,1!/75!1.@5*2+)4!N)4.5;!./242056!21!/75!
;2@.4)/2,1!2;!C*,N2656!21!/75!)CC5162SI!
(
9%66"#+,A!
( 91&/%,(7%&4-( 3%4+5.(7%&4-( *05$(7%&4-( 861&#(7%&4-(
#)*!,=15*;72C!*)/5!C*2,*!/,!/545=,*L21F!
-);56!,1!C);/!/*516;!)16!X>?!F*,=/7!C*,c5+/2,1;!
_,=5*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!!
')@5!);!21!+)*D,1!=,*46!
_,=5*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46!
r!7,@5!=,*L5*;! %./.*5!F*,=/7!D);56!,1!72;/,*2+!C515/*)/2,1!)16!C5*+52N56!4,1FO!/5*@!C515/*)/2,1!C,/51/2)4!21!)!+)*D,1!=,*46!
()*F21)44E!72F75*!/7)1!21!+)*D,1!=,*46!
Y2F75*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46!!
Y2F75*!/7)1!/5+7!=,*46!
"15*FE!5GG2+251+E!21!N572+45;!
-);56!,1!C);/!/*516;!! Y2F75*!5GG2+251+E!F)21;!/7)1!21!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!5GG2+251+E!F)21;!);!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!5GG2+251+E!F)21;!);!C,42+E!=,*46!
9662/2,1)4!545+/*2+2/E!.;56!DE!/75!`B!;,4./2,1;!/7)/!51)D45!`B!
%,44,=21F!72;/,*2+!65N54,C@51/!
_,=5*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
_,=5*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46!
')@5!);!/5+7!=,*46!
"45+/*2+2/E!F*26!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!!
X*26!5@2;;2,1!6)/)!=2/7!;,@5!65+*5);5!,N5*!/2@5!
_,=5*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!);!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!);!C,42+E!=,*46!3+,.46!D5!4,=5*8!
9662/2,1)4!/*)N54!G,*!452;.*5!)16!+7,*5;!362*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/8!
-);56!,1!72;/,*2+)4!6)/)!)16!+,1;/)1/!,N5*!/2@5!
_,=5*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!);!+)*D,1!=,*46!
_,=5*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46!
A.@D5*!,G!7,@5!=,*L5*;!F2N21F!.C!/752*!N572+45!
s5*,! '42F7/!*56.+/2,1! s5*,!! Y2F75*!/7)1!21!C,42+E!=,*46!)16!F*,=21F!,N5*!/2@5!
`162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/KR!
9662/2,1)4!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!65*2N21F!G*,@!)662/2,1)4!62;C,;)D45!21+,@5!,*!C*,G2/;a!65+*5);21F!,N5*!/2@5!);!G,*!C);/!/*516;!
_,=5*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!);!+)*D,1!=,*46!
_,=5*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46^!)16!);!N2*/.,.;!+E+45;!,G!4,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+L!*5;.4/!21!G.*/75*!XYX!*56.+/2,1;!
(
*1/40(aD(8"661&.(1''"6C#+%,'O(5%66"#+,A;(!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!13 B75!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!);;,+2)/56!=2/7!/75!5SC5162/.*5!,G!/75!)662/2,1)4!5+,1,@2+!*5;,.*+5;!@)65!)N)24)D45!DE!/545=,*L21F!=5*5!.;56!);!)!+,@D2156!2162+)/,*!G,*!;5N5*)4!2162*5+/!5GG5+/;^!;.+7!);!C.*+7);5;!,G!F,,6;!,*!;5*N2+5;^!7,@5!2@C*,N5@51/;g21N5;/@51/;g@,N5;^!)16!+7)1F5;!21!42G5;/E45;!)16!N)4.5;I!9;!62;+.;;56!21!;5+/2,1!KIJ^!5)+7!,G!/75;5!)+/2N2/25;!@)E!D5!);;,+2)/56!=2/7!21+*5);56!,*!65+*5);56!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I
!
! RP
%,*!;,@5!,G!/75!L5E!);;.@C/2,1;!./242056!21!/75!@,654^!)16!G,*!;545+/56!+,.1/*25;!3b'9^!"b^!#721)8^!/75!1.@5*2+)4!N)4.5;!G,*!E5)*!PWRW!)*5!*5C,*/56!21!/75!/)D45;!D54,=I!!
*1/40(:UD(H8!(9%66"#+,AeEURU(
( K+'#%&+514(
EUU\(
91&/%,(
7%&4-(
3%4+5.(
7%&4-(
*05$(
7%&4-(
861&#(
7%&4-(
B545=,*L5*;!);!r!,G!+)*!+,@@./5*;! KZr! RWr! RRr! JKr! J\r!
B545+,@@./21F!6)E;!C5*!=55L! PIZW! PITJ! PIVP! RIPJ! RIQW!
9N5*)F5!*56.+/2,1!21!L@!/*)N5456!DE!/545=,*L5*;!
P^Q\\! P^\JR! P^JZQ! R^WKV! P^V\Q!
9N5*)F5!G.54!5+,1,@E!G,*!+)*;!3_gKWW!L@8!3+)4+.4)/568!
KKI\! KKIK! KWIR! KKIK! KWIR!
"45+/*2+2/E!.;56!DE!/545=,*L21F!65N2+5;!C5*!7,.*!,G!/545=,*L21F!3L<78!
WIWQ! WIWQ! WIWJ! WIWP! WIWP!
X*26!5@2;;2,1!G)+/,*!3LF#$PgL<78! WIQP! WIQP! WIRR! WIQP! WIRR!
>2*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!321+*5);5!21!L@!/*)N5456!);!r!,G!L@!;)N56!=2/7!/545=,*L21F8!!
PQr! PQr! KQr! PQr! Qr!
r!/545=,*L5*;!F2N21F!.C!/752*!N572+45! Wr! KIKr! PIPr! KIKr! PRIRr!
`162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!M!LF!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!C5*!m!;)N56!DE!/545=,*L5*;!3)16!;C51/!,1!F,,6;!,*!;5*N2+5;8!
WI\J! WIQ\! WIRJ! WIQ\! W!
!!!
*1/40(::D(QH(9%66"#+,AeEURU(
( K+'#%&+514(EUU\(
91&/%,(7%&4-(
3%4+5.(7%&4-(
*05$(7%&4-(
861&#(7%&4-(
B545=,*L5*;!);!r!,G!+)*!+,@@./5*;! Tr! PQr! PVr! RZr! JPr!
B545+,@@./21F!6)E;!C5*!=55L! KIWW! KIZP! PIWW! PIPP! PIVQ!
9N5*)F5!*56.+/2,1!21!L@!/*)N5456!DE!/545=,*L5*;!
ZQW! K^PJJ! K^RKJ! K^\WR! K^VRV!
9N5*)F5!G.54!5+,1,@E!G,*!+)*;!9N5*)F5!+)*;!,1!*,)6!G.54!5+,1,@E!3_gKWW!L@8!3+)4+.4)/568!
ZIT! ZIW! \IQ! ZIW! \IQ!
"45+/*2+2/E!.;56!DE!/545=,*L21F!65N2+5;!C5*!7,.*!,G!/545=,*L21F!3L<78!
WIWQ! WIWQ! WIWJ! WIWP! WIWP!
X*26!5@2;;2,1!G)+/,*!3LF#$PgL<78! WIRQ! WIRQ! WIKT! WIRQ! WIKT!
>2*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!321+*5);5!21!L@!/*)N5456!);!r!,G!L@!;)N56!=2/7!/545=,*L21F8!!
PQr! PQr! KQr! PQr! Qr!
r!/545=,*L5*;!F2N21F!.C!/752*!N572+45! Wr! KIKr! PIPr! KIKr! PRIRr!
`162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!M!LF!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!C5*!m!;)N56!DE!/545=,*L5*;!3)16!;C51/!,1!F,,6;!,*!;5*N2+5;8!
WIRV! WIRJ! WIPW! WIRJ! 3WIK8!
!
!
! RR
(
*1/40(:ED(9$+,1(9%66"#+,AeEURU(
( K+'#%&+514(
EUU\(
91&/%,(
7%&4-(
3%4+5.(
7%&4-(
*05$(
7%&4-(
861&#(
7%&4-(
B545=,*L5*;!);!r!,G!+)*!+,@@./5*;! Jr! KQr! KTr! PJr! RPr!
B545+,@@./21F!6)E;!C5*!=55L! KIWW! KIZP! KIZQ! KIVJ! PIQW!
9N5*)F5!*56.+/2,1!21!L@!/*)N5456!DE!/545=,*L5*;!
VWW! K^JQJ! K^RJQ! K^VQQ! K^VPK!
9N5*)F5!G.54!5+,1,@E!G,*!+)*;!9N5*)F5!+)*;!,1!*,)6!G.54!5+,1,@E!3_gKWW!L@8!3+)4+.4)/568!
KKIJ! KWIK! VIK! KWIK! VIK!
"45+/*2+2/E!.;56!DE!/545=,*L21F!65N2+5;!C5*!7,.*!,G!/545=,*L21F!3L<78!
WIWQ! WIWQ! WIWJ! WIWP! WIWP!
X*26!5@2;;2,1!G)+/,*!3LF#$PgL<78! WIZV! WIZV! WI\P! WIZV! WI\P!
>2*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!321+*5);5!21!L@!/*)N5456!);!r!,G!L@!;)N56!=2/7!/545=,*L21F8!!
PQr! PQr! KQr! PQr! Qr!
r!/545=,*L5*;!F2N21F!.C!/752*!N572+45! Wr! KIKr! PIPr! KIKr! QKIZr!
`162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!M!LF!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!C5*!m!;)N56!DE!/545=,*L5*;!3)16!;C51/!,1!F,,6;!,*!;5*N2+5;8!
WIVW! WIZQ! WIQR! WIZQ! WIP!
!!!
*1/40(:RD(f"'+,0''L&041#0-(!+&(*&1204(
( 91&/%,(7%&4-( 3%4+5.(7%&4-( *05$(7%&4-( 861&#(7%&4-(
[@!/*)N5456!C*2,*!/,!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!
?*,c5+/2,1;!G*,@!;5N5*)4!;,.*+5;!
_,=5*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
Y2F75*!/7)1!21!+)*D,1!=,*46!
_,=5*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46!
r!*56.+/2,1!21!L@!/*)N5456!6.5!/,!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!
-);56!,1!72;/,*2+)4!6)/)!)16!)!;4,=!F*,=/7!!
()*F21)44E!72F75*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
Y2F75*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46!
Y2F75*!/7)1!/5+7!=,*46!
"15*FE!5GG2+251+E!21!)2*C4)15;!
-);54215!,1!C);/!/*516;!
Y2F75*!5GG2+251+E!F)21;!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!5GG2+251+E!F)21;!);!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!5GG2+251+E!F)21;!);!C,42+E!=,*46!
9662/2,1)4!545+/*2+2/E!.;56!DE!/75!`B!;,4./2,1;!/7)/!51)D45!`B!
%,44,=21F!+.**51/!/*516;!
_,=5*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
_,=5*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46!
')@5!,*!4,=5*!/7)1!21!C,42+E!=,*46!
"45+/*2+2/E!F*26!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!!
X*26!5@2;;2,1!6)/)!=2/7!;,@5!65+*5);5!,N5*!/2@5!
_,=5*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!);!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!);!C,42+E!=,*46!3+,.46!D5!4,=5*8!
>2*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!
-);56!,1!72;/,*2+)4!6)/)!)16!+,1;/)1/!,N5*!/2@5!
_,=5*!/7)1!21!+)*D,1!=,*46!!
Y2F75*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!372F7O+)*D,1!G556D)+L8!
_,=5*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46!
`162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!
-);56!,1!/75!XYX!21/51;2/E!,G!/75!5+,1,@Ea!65+*5);21F!,N5*!/2@5^!);!G,*!C);/!/*516!
_,=5*!/7)1!+)*D,1!=,*46!
')@5!);!+)*D,1!=,*46!
_,=5*!/7)1!C,42+E!=,*46^!=2/7!G.*/75*!*56.+/2,1;!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!,N5*!/2@5!);!N2*/.,.;!+E+45;!,G!4,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+L!)*5!)+725N56!!
!%,*!;,@5!,G!/75!L5E!);;.@C/2,1;!./242056!21!/75!@,654^!)16!G,*!;545+/56!+,.1/*25;!3b'9^!"b^!#721)8^!/75!1.@5*2+)4!N)4.5;!G,*!E5)*!PWRW!)*5!*5C,*/56!21!/75!/)D45;!D54,=I!
!
!
! RJ
*1/40(:VD(H8!(g+&#"14(c00#+,A'eEURU((
( K+'#%&+514(
EUU\(
91&/%,(
7%&4-(
3%4+5.(
7%&4-(
*05$(
7%&4-(
861&#(
7%&4-(
-.;215;;!/*)N54!)N,2656!/7)1L;!/,!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!3r8!!
Tr! PZr! RWr! QWr! \\r!
9662/2,1)4!545+/*2+2/E!.;56!C5*!7,.*!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F!3L<78!
PIJR! PIJR! KIVJ! WITQ! WIJV!
X*26!5@2;;2,1!G)+/,*!3LF#$PgL<78! WIQP! WIQP! WIRR! WIQP! WIRR!
A5F)/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!);!r!,G!L@!212/2)44E!;)N56!DE!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!
PQr! PQr! KWr! PQr! !
`162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!M!LF!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!C5*!m!;)N56!DE!/545=,*L5*;!3)16!;C51/!,1!F,,6;!,*!;5*N2+5;8!
WI\J! WIQ\! WIRJ! WIQ\! W!
!
*1/40(:\D(QH(g+&#"14(c00#+,A'eEURU((
( K+'#%&+514(EUU\(
91&/%,(7%&4-(
3%4+5.(7%&4-(
*05$(7%&4-(
861&#(7%&4-(
-.;215;;!/*)N54!)N,2656!/7)1L;!/,!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!3r8!!
Qr! PPr! PVr! JJr! \Jr!
9662/2,1)4!545+/*2+2/E!.;56!C5*!7,.*!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F!3L<78!
PIJR! PIJR! KIVJ! WITQ! WIJV!
X*26!5@2;;2,1!G)+/,*!3LF#$PgL<78! WIRQ! WIRQ! WIKT! WIRQ! WIKT!
A5F)/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!);!r!,G!L@!212/2)44E!;)N56!DE!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!
PQr! PQr! KWr! PQr! Qr!
`162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!M!LF!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!C5*!m!;)N56!DE!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!3)16!;C51/!,1!F,,6;!,*!;5*N2+5;8!
WIRV! WIRJ! WIPW! WIRJ! 3WIK8!
!!!
*1/40(:]D(9$+,1(g+&#"14(c00#+,A'eEURU((
( K+'#%&+514(
EUU\(
91&/%,(
7%&4-(
3%4+5.(
7%&4-(
*05$(
7%&4-(
861&#(
7%&4-(
-.;215;;!/*)N54!)N,2656!/7)1L;!/,!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!3r8!!
Kr! KZr! KVr! PJr! RZr!
9662/2,1)4!545+/*2+2/E!.;56!C5*!7,.*!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F!3L<78!
PIJR! PIJR! KIVJ! WITQ! WIJV!
X*26!5@2;;2,1!G)+/,*!3LF#$PgL<78! WIZV! WIZV! WI\P! WIZV! WI\P!
A5F)/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!);!r!,G!L@!212/2)44E!;)N56!DE!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!
PQr! PQr! KWr! PQr! Qr!
`162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!M!LF!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!C5*!m!;)N56!DE!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!3)16!;C51/!,1!F,,6;!,*!;5*N2+5;8!
WIVW! WIZQ! WIQR! WIZQ! WIP!
!
B75!].)1/2G2+)/2,1!@,654!51/)24;!;5N5*)4!/)D45;!=2/7!21C./!6)/)!)16!);;.@C/2,1;!G,*!5)+7!F5,F*)C72+!)*5)!
)1)4E056!)16!G,*!/75!/2@5!C5*2,6!.1/24!PWQWI![5E!);;.@C/2,1;!/)D45;!)*5!*5C,*/56!)16!62;+.;;56!21!/75!
)CC5162SI!
!
!
! RQ
4 Quantitative analysis – Simulation results and discussion
B75! )CC*,)+7! 65;+*2D56! )D,N5! 51)D456! /75! ;2@.4)/2,1! ,G! N)*2,.;! C)/7;! ,G! 65N54,C@51/! =2/7!
+,**5;C,1621F!+)4+.4)/2,1;!,G!/75!C,;;2D45!2@C)+/!,1!#$P!5@2;;2,1;I!!
%,*!5)+7!,G!/75!=,*46;^!/75!;2@.4)/2,1;!.165*/)L51!C*,c5+/!;5N5*)4!5@2;;2,1!C)/7;^!21+4.621F!
! !dD);54215e! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;! /7)/! =,.46! ,++.*^! 21! 62GG5*51/! =,*46;^! 21! /75! )D;51+5! ,G! )1E!
/545=,*L21F!,*!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;a!
! XYX!5@2;;2,1;!15/!,G!/75!62*5+/! 2@C)+/!,G!/545=,*L21F!,*!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!32I5I^!,14E!)++,.1/21F!
G,*! /75! *56.+/2,1! 21! +,@@./21F! /*)N54^! =2/7,./! +,1;265*21F! )1E! *5D,.16! 5GG5+/^! C,;2/2N5! ,*!
15F)/2N58^!=2/7!)16!=2/7,./!)!+,**5+/2,1!G,*!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!);;,+2)/56!=2/7!/75!545+/*2+2/E!.;56!DE!
`B!65N2+5;a!)16!
! XYX! 5@2;;2,1;! 15/! ,G! /75! 2@C)+/! ,G! /545=,*L21F! ,*! N2*/.)4! @55/21F;! )16! ,G! *545N)1/! *5D,.16!
5GG5+/;!65*2N21F!G*,@!/75!)N)24)D242/E!,G!)662/2,1)4!/2@5!,*!21+,@5I!!
B7.;! /75! )1)4E;2;! )44,=;! G,*! +,@C)*2;,1;! D5/=551! 62GG5*51/! =,*46;! 35IFI^! /,! +,1/*);/! +,@@./21F!
5@2;;2,1;!21!/=,!62GG5*51/!=,*46;8!)16!=2/721!2162N26.)4!=,*46;!35IFI^!/,!)2*O/*)N54!5@2;;2,1;!15/!,G!62*5+/!
N2*/.)4O@55/21F!2@C)+/!=2/7!)2*O/*)N54!5@2;;2,1;!/7)/!)*5!)4;,!+,**5+/56!G,*!62GG5*51/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;8I!
[5E!G21621F;!)*5!*5C,*/56!)16!62;+.;;56!D54,=I!
!
4.1 Teleworking
%,*!/545=,*L21F^!/75!)1)4E;2;!G,+.;56!,1!@,65421F!/75!C,;;2D45!*56.+/2,1;!21!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!65*2N21F!G*,@!
/75! /545=,*L5*;h! *56.+56! .;5! ,G! C*2N)/54E! ,=156! +)*;! G,*! +,@@./21F! C.*C,;5;I! ?,;;2D45! C,;2/2N5! )16!
15F)/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!)*5!)4;,!+,1;265*56!21!/75!)1)4E;2;^!21!/5*@;!,G!)662/2,1)4!L24,@5/5*;!/*)N5456!G,*!
+7,*5;!,*!452;.*5!)16!G*,@!21+*5);21Fg65+*5);21F!5@2;;2,1;!65*2N21F!G*,@!/75!.;5!,G!62;C,;)D45!21+,@5!,*!
C*,G2/;!@)65!)N)24)D45!DE!/*)1;C,*/)/2,1!;)N21F;I!?,;;2D45!*56.+/2,1;!21!/75!5@2;;2,1;!F515*)/56!DE!C.D42+!
/*)1;C,*/)/2,1^!,1!/75!,/75*!7)16^!)*5!1,/!+,1;265*56!21!/75!)1)4E;2;^!.165*!/75!+,1;5*N)/2N5!);;.@C/2,1!
/7)/! /75! 1.@D5*! ,G! C.D42+! /*)1;C,*/)/2,1! N572+45;^!=72+7! )*5! .;56! /,! /*)1;C,*/! +,@@./5*;^! =,.46! 1,/!
65+*5);5!5N51!2G!)!;2F12G2+)1/!C*,C,*/2,1!,G!=,*L5*;!=,*L56!G*,@!;,@5=75*5!,/75*!/7)1!/75!,GG2+5I!!
!
#,@@./21F!2;!+.**51/4E!5;/2@)/56!/,!*5C*5;51/!D5/=551!PZ!)16!QW!C5*+51/!,G!,N5*)44!L24,@5/5*;!/*)N5456^!
)16! 5@2;;2,1;!C*,6.+56^! DE! C*2N)/54E! ,=156! +)*;^! 65C51621F! ,1! /75! *5F2,1IKJ!BEC2+)44E! D5/=551! R^WWW!
)16!Q^WWW!L24,@5/5*;!C5*!)11.@!C5*!N572+45!)*5!6.5!/,!+,@@./21F^!45)621F!/,!,N5*)44!5@2;;2,1;!)/!F4,D)4!
;+)45!,G!)D,./!TWW!(/#$P!3PWWQ!6)/)8^!);!+,@C)*56!/,!)!/,/)4!G*,@!C*2N)/54E!,=156!+)*;!,G!)D,./!P^\WW!
(/#$PI!#.**51/!C*,c5+/2,1;!G,*! 21+*5);5;!21!+)*!,=15*;72C!=,.46!45)6!/,!)!;2F12G2+)1/!F*,=/7!21!62;/)1+5!
/*)N5456^! )16! );;,+2)/56! 5@2;;2,1;^! 5;C5+2)44E! 21! *)C264E! F*,=21F! )16! 65N54,C21F! +,.1/*25;I! B72;! 2;!
72F742F7/56!21!/75!F*)C7;!D54,=^!244.;/*)/21F!/75!C*,c5+/2,1;!,G!/75!+)*D,1!=,*46I!!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!14 >5/)2456!6)/)!,1!+,@@./21F!D57)N2,*!)*5!1,/!*5)624E!)N)24)D45!G,*!@)1E!+,.1/*25;^!5;C5+2)44E!45;;!65N54,C56!,15;I!<5)4/725*!*5F2,1;!=2/7!72F75*!62;C,;)D45!21+,@5;^!;7,*/5*!=,*L21F!=55L;^!)16!D5//5*!C.D42+!/*)1;C,*/)/2,1!;E;/5@;!/EC2+)44E!;7,=!)!72F75*!C*,C,*/2,1!,G!452;.*5!/*)N54I
!
! R\
! !
! !!
B&1C$(bD(@+4%60#0&'(%=(51&(5%66"#+,A(1,-(9<E(06+''+%,'(51&/%,(7%&4-O(EUU\(1,-(EU\U;(
"
'""
#""
)""
$""
(""
%""
;""
&""
<""
'"""
=8>
?=#;
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!+H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
A*E,
+."-,("6=*9,*#(1*#',,2"-/3*
F%GGHI
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
=8>
?=#;
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!+H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
!&*#$%
+."-,("6=*#$% +,-..-'/.*01',*#(1*
#',,2"-/3*F%GGJI
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
'$""
'%""
=8>
?=#;
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!+H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
A*E,
+."-,("6=*9,*#(1*#',,2"-/3*
#(1?'/*8'1)=*F%GHGI
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
$""
=8>
?=#;
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!+H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
K1'L6<"6=*#$%*+,-..-'/.*01',*#(1*
#',,2"-/34*#(1?'/*8'1)=*%GHG
!
! RZ
#,@C)*21F!C*,c5+/2,1;!G,*!+,@@./21FO*54)/56!+)*!5@2;;2,1;!G,*!/75!G,.*!=,*46;!;.FF5;/;!/7)/^!=,*46=265^!
21!/75!)D;51+5!,G!/545=,*L21F^!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!=,.46!+,1/21.5!/,!F*,=!,1!)!*54)/2N54E!;/5)6E!4215)*!/*516!
21!/75!+)*D,1!)16!/5+7!=,*46;^!)16!)/!)!4,=5*!*)/5!21!/75!C,42+E!)16!;@)*/!=,*46;!3;55!F*)C7;!D54,=8I!`G!
/75!15/!2@C)+/!,G!7,@5!=,*L21F!2;!)6656^!)44!C*,c5+/2,1;!*5;.4/!21!)!*56.+/2,1!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;^!=72+7!2;!
42@2/56! 21! +)*D,1!=,*46^!@,65*)/5! 21!D,/7! /75!C,42+E!)16!/5+7!=,*46;^!)16!@,*5!6*)@)/2+! 21! /75!;@)*/!
=,*46I! 'C5+2G2+)44E^! /75! 2@C)+/! ,G! 7,@5! =,*L21F! ,1! +,@@./21F! 5@2;;2,1;! G*,@! +)*;! =,.46! *5;.4/! 21! )!
*56.+/2,1!21!/75!F*,=/7!/*516!21!)!+)*D,1!)16!/5+7!=,*46^!=,.46!)+725N5!)!;/)D2420)/2,1!,G!5@2;;2,1;!21!)!
C,42+E!=,*46^!)16!=,.46!,14E!6542N5*!)1!,N5*)44! *56.+/2,1! 21!5@2;;2,1;! 21!)!;@)*/!=,*46I!<751!*5D,.16!
5GG5+/;! )*5! )++,.1/56! G,*! 21! D,/7! /75! +)*D,1! )16! /5+7! =,*46;^! /75! 212/2)4! *56.+/2,1;! 21! /*)1;C,*/)/2,1!
5@2;;2,1;! )*5! C)*/2)44E! +,.1/5*D)4)1+56! DE! )662/2,1)4! 5@2;;2,1;! 65*2N21F! G*,@! 545+/*2+2/E! .;5! 3@212@)4!
2@C)+/8^! 21+*5);21F! /*)N54! G*,@! 452;.*5! )16! +7,*5; !̂ )16! )662/2,1)4! XYXOF515*)/21F! 5SC5162/.*5;I! B72;!
2162+)/5;! /7)/! 21! /75! )D;51+5! ,1! )FF*5;;2N5! C,42+E !̂ +.**51/! /*516;! ,G! 5@2;;2,1! F*,=/7! =,.46! 1,/! D5!
5GG5+/2N54E!@2/2F)/56I! B72;! )4;,! 72F742F7/;! /7)/! 5N51! 2G! /75! `B! 216.;/*E! G,+.;5;! ,1! 65N2;21F! ;,4./2,1;! /,!
*56.+5! #$P! 5@2;;2,1;! 3/5+7! =,*468^! /75! ,N5*)44! ,./+,@5! =,.46! 1,/! D5! )! 15/! *56.+/2,1! 21! +,@@./21F!
5@2;;2,1;!2G!/75!D*,)65*!;,+2,5+,1,@2+!51N2*,1@51/!21!=72+7!/75!`B!216.;/*E!,C5*)/5;!G)24;!;.D;/)1/2)44E!
)/!/75!/);L!,G!/)+L421F!F4,D)4!=)*@21FI!
!
!
!
!
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
'$""
'%""
'&""
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$
%
M)'?()*#$% +,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/3*K1-'1*
"'*7',6*8'19-/3
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
'$""
'%""
'&""
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$
%
&'"()*#$% +,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/3*56"*'0*7',6*8'19-/3*
:,;(<"*'/*&1(00-<*FK1-'1*@/N*>6?'2/=*+006<"I
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
!
! RT
(
!
!(
B&1C$(aD(9<E(=&%6(5%66"#+,A(1,-(&0/%",-(0==05#'(+,(-+==0&0,#(7%&4-';((
!
9! +4,;5*! 4,,L! )/! /75! #$P! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! /7)/! /545=,*L21F! +)1! F515*)/5! =2/721! 62GG5*51/! =,*46;^!
7,=5N5*^! *5N5)4;! /7)/! 7,@5! =,*L21F! +)1! C*,N265! )! 4)*F5*! +,1/*2D./2,1! 21! /5*@;! ,G! XYX! 5@2;;2,1!
*56.+/2,1;! 21!D,/7!;@)*/!)16!/5+7!=,*46;^!);!+,@C)*56! /,!/75!+)*D,1!)16!C,42+E!=,*46;I!B72;! 2162+)/5;!
/7)/!=75*5);!21!)!C,42+E!=,*46!)!4)*F5*!;7)*5!,G!/75!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!)+725N56!+,.46!D5!)//*2D./56!/,!
C,42+25;! 3=72+7! 45)6! /,!)1! 21+*5);56!.;5!,G! `B!;,4./2,1;!D./!)4;,! *56.+5! /752*!XYX! 2@C)+/8^!=751!;.+7!
C,42+25;!)*5!4)+L21F^!/75!)+/2N5!51F)F5@51/!,G!/75!`B!216.;/*E!+)1!C4)E!)!;2F12G2+)1/!*,45I!B72;!7,46;!/*.5!2G!
*5D,.16! 5GG5+/;! )*5! /)L51! 21/,! )++,.1/I! <751! +,1;265*21F! D,/7! 62*5+/! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! )16! 62*5+/!
*5D,.16! 5GG5+/;^! )D,./! KVZ!(/#$P!=,.46! D5! ;)N56! 21! PWRW!DE! )! C*,)+/2N5! `B! 216.;/*E^! +,@C)*56! /,!)!
;)N21F;!,G!KKZ!(/#$P!=2/7,./!;.+7!51F)F5@51/I!"N51!2G!;/*21F51/!2162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!)*5!;2@.4)/56^!
/75!/5+7!=,*46!=,.46!,./C5*G,*@!/75!+)*D,1!=,*46!DE!,N5*!JK!(/#$P!DE!PWRW^!6542N5*21F!/,/)4!5@2;;2,1!
*56.+/2,1;!,G!)D,./!VR!(/#$P^!)16!DE!,N5*!KQP!(/#$P!DE!PWQW^!6542N5*21F! /,/)4!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!,G!
)D,./! PT\! (/#$PI! B75! F*5)/5;/! 2@C)+/! 21! /5*@;! ,G! XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! 51)D456! DE! /545=,*L21F^!
7,=5N5*^!=,.46!D5!)+725N56! 21!)!;@)*/!=,*46^!=75*5!/,/)4!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!,G!JQQ!(/#$P!)16!KQZQ!
(/#$P!=,.46!D5!)+725N56!21!PWRW!)16!PWQW^!*5;C5+/2N54EI!`1!;@)*/!=,*46^!2162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!=,.46!
C*,6.+5!)1!21+*5);5!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!21!PWRW!3,G!)D,./!RT!(/#$P8!)16!)!65+*5);5!3,G!)D,./!KVK!(/#$P8!
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
'$""
'%""
'&""
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$
%
&'"()*#$% +,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/34*56"*'0*
7',6OP'19-/3*:,;(<"*(/=*:/<)2=-/3*+,-..-'/.*Q1',*
+)6<"1-<-"N*R.6*(/=*S-16<"*>6?'2/=*+006<"
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
'$""
'%""
'&""
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$
%
&'"()*#$% +,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/34*56"*'0*7',6OP'19-/3*
:,;(<"*(/=*>6?'2/=*+006<".
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
!
! RV
21! PWQWI! B72;! 2;! 6.5! /,! /75! G)+/! /7)/! ,N5*! /75! PWRWMPWQW! C5*2,6^! )! F*,=21F! 1.@D5*! ,G! *5F2,1;! )*5!
);;.@56!/,!65C4,E!C,42+25;!)16!;/*)/5F25;!/7)/!+)1!5GG5+/2N54E!+7)1154!/75!)662/2,1)4!5+,1,@2+!*5;,.*+5;!
F515*)/56! DE! /75! *56.+/2,1! 21! /*)1;C,*/)/2,1! +,;/;! 51)D456! DE! /545=,*L21F! 21/,! )+/2N2/25;! /7)/! 45)6! /,!
G.*/75*!*56.+/2,1;!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!
!
!
!
!(
B&1C$(:UD(9<E(06+''+%,(&0-"5#+%,'(=&%6(#0407%&M+,A(+,(-+==0&0,#(7%&4-';(
!
9!D*5)L6,=1!DE!*5F2,1!;7,=;!/7)/!=2/721!5)+7!=,*46!/545=,*L21F!F515*)/5;!/75!F*5)/5;/!*56.+/2,1;!21!
5@2;;2,1;!21!$"#>!+,.1/*25;^!*5F)*645;;!,G!/75!G./.*5!=,*46!;2@.4)/56!21!/75!C*,c5+/2,1I!B72;!*5G45+/;!D,/7!
/75!72F75*!1.@D5*;!,G!L1,=456F5!=,*L5*;!21!$"#>!+,.1/*25;!)16!/75!F*5)/5*!C515/*)/2,1!,G!C*2N)/54E!
,=156!N572+45;I!$N5*!/2@5^!7,=5N5*^!/75!C,/51/2)4!2@C)+/!,G!/545=,*L21F!D5+,@5;!;2F12G2+)1/!21!
65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!);!=544^!);!;7,=1!DE!/75!PWQW!C*,c5+/2,1;!*5C,*/56!D54,=I!
!
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
'$""
'%""
#""" #""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
#$% +,-..-'/*>6=2<"-'/.*S61-B-/3*01',*&6)6P'19-/34*-/*
S-00616/"*8'1)=.*K1-'1*"'*>6?'2/=*+006<".
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
'$""
'%""
'&""
#""" #""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$
%
#$% +,-..-'/*>6=2<"-'/.*S61-B-/3*01',*&6)6P'19-/34*-/*
S-00616/"*8'1)=.*:/<)2=-/3*>6?'2/=*+006<".
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
!
! JW
(
!
!
!
!
"
#"
$"
%"
&"
'""
'#"
'$"
'%"
'&"
=8> ?=!#; @+A+/ *72/+ I/J2+
!"#$
%
#$% +,-..-'/.*T(B6=*?N*&6)6P'19-/34*K1-'1*"'*>6?'2/=*+006<".*
F%GUGI
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
"
#"
$"
%"
&"
'""
'#"
'$"
'%"
'&"
=8> ?=!#; @+A+/ *72/+ I/J2+
!"#$
%
#$% +,-..-'/.*T(B6=*?N*&6)6P'19-/34*:/<)2=-/3*>6?'2/=*
+006<".*F%GUGI
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
$""
=8> ?=!#; @+A+/ *72/+ I/J2+
!"#$%
#$% +,-..-'/.*T(B6=*?N*&6)6P'19-/34*K1-'1*"'*>6?'2/=*+006<".*
F%GHGI
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
!
! JK
!
!(
B&1C$(::D(9<E(06+''+%,(&0-"5#+%,'(0,1/40-(/.(#0407%&M+,A(+,(-+==0&0,#(&0A+%,';(
!
"N51!+,1;265*21F!C,/51/2)4!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;^!/545=,*L21F!45)6;!/,!*56.+/2,1;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1!21!)44!=,*46;I!
Y,=5N5*^!21!C*,c5+/2,1;!;.+7!);!G,*!/75!+)*D,1!=,*46^!=72+7!);;.@5;!4,=5*!5GG2+251+E!21!`B!5].2C@51/^!
/75!15/!2@C)+/!,1!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!=244!D5!;2F12G2+)1/4E!*56.+56^!);!72F75*!*)/5;!,G!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!);;,+2)/56!
=2/7!545+/*2+2/E!C*,6.+/2,1!)16!F*5)/5*!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!65*2N21F!G*,@!/75!)662/2,1)4!*5;,.*+5;!3/2@5!)16!
@,15E8!@)65!)N)24)D45!DE!/545=,*L21F!1556!/,!D5!/)L51!21/,!+,1;265*)/2,1I!B75!F*)C7;!D54,=!C*,N265!
G.*/75*!65/)24!,1!/75!2@C)+/!/7)/!N)*2,.;!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!+)1!7)N5!,1!/75!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!F515*)/56!
DE!/545=,*L21FI!
!
!
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
$""
$("
=8> ?=!#; @+A+/ *72/+ I/J2+
!"#$
%
#$% +,-..-'/.*T(B6=*?N*&6)6P'19-/34*:/<)2=-/3*>6?'2/=*
+006<".*F%GHGI
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
&""
&("
<""
<("
'"""
0,6N:616O.,P2/Q I/31GJ2/Q!
:616O.,P2/Q!
29A+3:!./!
3.99G:2/Q
I/31GJ2/Q!
6163:,232:4!GH6J!
-4!:616O.,P2/Q!
J6R236H
I/31GJ2/Q!J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
I/31GJ2/Q!
2/J2,63:!,6-.G/J!
6MM63:
K')-<N*8'1)=*M7M*+,-..-'/.*Q1',*#',,2"-/3
V6(1*%GUG
!
!
!
!
&""
&("
<""
<("
'"""
'"("
''""
!"#$%
<""<("'"""'"("''""''("'#""'#("
0,6N:616O.,P2/Q
!"#$%
'"""
''""
'#""
')""
'$""
'(""
'%""
';""
'&""
0,6N:616O.,P2/Q
!"#$
%
&6<W*8'1)=*M7M*+,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/3
!
:616O.,P2/Q I/31GJ2/Q!
:616O.,P2/Q!
29A+3:!./!
3.99G:2/Q
I/31GJ2/Q!
6163:,232:4!GH6J!
-4!:616O.,P2/Q!
J6R236H
I/31GJ2/Q!J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
I/31GJ2/Q!
2/J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
:616O.,P2/Q I/31GJ2/Q!
:616O.,P2/Q!
29A+3:!./!
3.99G:2/Q
I/31GJ2/Q!
6163:,232:4!GH6J!
-4!:616O.,P2/Q!
J6R236H
I/31GJ2/Q!J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
I/31GJ2/Q!
2/J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
&6<W*8'1)=*M7M*+,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/3
V6(1*%GHG
!
!
!
!
! JR
(
!
!(
B&1C$(:ED(9<E(06+''+%,'(7+#$(#0407%&M+,A(1,-(21&+%"'(&0/%",-(0==05#'(7%&4-7+-0(EURU(1,-(EU\U;(
!
9!+,@C)*2;,1!,G!15/!5@2;;2,1;!,N5*!/2@5!21!/75!;@)*/!)16!+)*D,1!=,*46;!72F742F7/;!7,=!/75!+,@D2156!
)+/2,1!,G!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)16!`B!216.;/*E!45)6;!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!/,!C5)L!D5/=551!PWKW!)16!PWKQ!21!
65N54,C56!+,.1/*25;!=7245!6*)@)/2+)44E!;4,=21F!6,=1!/75!C*,c5+/56!F*,=/7!21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;^!=75*5!
)!C5)L!21!5@2;;2,1;!2;!*5)+756!)*,.16!PWRW^!G,44,=56!DE!)!65+4215!21!15/!5@2;;2,1;I!
!
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
0,6N:616O.,P2/Q I/31GJ2/Q!
:616O.,P2/Q!
29A+3:!./!
3.99G:2/Q
I/31GJ2/Q!
6163:,232:4!GH6J!
-4!:616O.,P2/Q!
J6R236H
I/31GJ2/Q!J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
I/31GJ2/Q!
2/J2,63:!,6-.G/J!
6MM63:
!"#$%
T,(1"*8'1)=*M7M*+,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/3
V6(1*%GUG
"
#""
$""
%""
&""
'"""
'#""
0,6N:616O.,P2/Q I/31GJ2/Q!
:616O.,P2/Q!
29A+3:!./!
3.99G:2/Q
I/31GJ2/Q!
6163:,232:4!GH6J!
-4!:616O.,P2/Q!
J6R236H
I/31GJ2/Q!J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
I/31GJ2/Q!
2/J2,63:!,6-.G/J!
6MM63:
!"#$
%
T,(1"*8'1)=*M7M*+,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/3
V6(1*%GHG
!
! JJ
!
(B&1C$(:R;(EUU\`EU\U(9<E(06+''+%,(=&%6(5%66"#+,AO(0405#&+5+#.("'0O(1,-(&0/%",-(0==05#'(+,(1(51&/%,(7%&4-;(
(
((
B&1C$(:VD(EUU\`EU\U(9<E(06+''+%,'(=&%6(5%66"#+,AO(0405#&+5+#.("'0O(1,-(&0/%",-(0==05#'(+,(1('61&#(7%&4-;(
!
#,@C)*21F!/75!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!,G!)!+)*D,1!=,*46!C*5O/545+,@@./21F!/,!/7,;5!,G!)!;@)*/!=,*46^!21+4.621F!
/75! 2@C)+/! ,G! /545=,*L21F^! C*,N265;! )! @5);.*5! ,G! /75! ,N5*)44! 2@C)+/! /7)/! )+/2N5! )16! 5GG5+/2N5! C,42+E!
@)L5*;!)16!)1!51F)F56!`B!216.;/*E!+)1!)+725N5!=2/7!/5+71,4,FE!3;55!F*)C7!D54,=8I!
!
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$%
#@>A$5*8$>XS
#$% +,-..-'/.01',*#',,2"-/34*+)6<"1-<-"N*R.64*(/=*>6?'2/=*+006<". =8>
?=
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!>H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$%
T!@>&*8$>XS
#$%*+,-..-'/.*01',*#',,2"-/34*+)6<"1-<-"N*R.64*(/=*>6?'2/=*+006<".
=8>
?=
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!>H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
!
! JQ
!(
B&1C$(:\D(9%6/+,0-(+6C15#(%=(0==05#+20(C%4+5.(61M0&'O()*(+,-"'#&.O(1,-(#05$,%4%A.;(
!
B75!F*)C7!72F742F7/;!/7)/!,N5*)44!)4@,;/!RIQ!D2442,1!/,1;!,G!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!+)1!D5!;)N56!21!PWQWI!<75*5);!
/75! 4)*F5;/! +,1/*2D./2,1! /,! ;.+7! ;)N21F;!=244! +,@5!G*,@!$"#>! +,.1/*25;^!,N5*! /2@5! ;2F12G2+)1/!5@2;;2,1!
*56.+/2,1;!)*5!)4;,!F515*)/56!21!65N54,C21F!)16!5@5*F21F!+,.1/*25;I!B72;!6E1)@2+!2;!5N51!@,*5!5N2651/!
=751! 4,,L21F!)/! /75!15=!;)N21F;! 32I5I^! 21+*5);5;!,G!#$P!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!+,@C)*56! /,! /75!C*5N2,.;!
C5*2,68!F515*)/56!21!)1E!F2N51!C5*2,6!3;55!D54,=8I!!
!
!(
B&1C$(:]D(X07(9<E(06+''+%,(&0-"5#+%,'(/.(5%",#&.(%20&(#+60e5%6/+,0-(+6C15#(%=(0==05#+20(C%4+5.(61M0&'O()*(+,-"'#&.O(1,-(#05$,%4%A.;(
!
9;!72F742F7/56!)D,N5^!=7245!15=!;)N21F;!C5)L!21!$"#>!+,.1/*25;!D5/=551!PWPQ!)16!PWRQ^!65N54,C21F!)16!
5@5*F21F!+,.1/*25;! G*,@!9;2)!)16!_)/21!9@5*2+)!C*,N265!)!F*,=21F!C*,C,*/2,1!,G!/75!)662/2,1)4!;)N21F;!
"
'""
#""
)""
$""
(""
%""
;""
&""
<""
'"""
#""" #""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$
%
#',?-/6=*:,;(<"*F#$% +,-..-'/*>6=2<"-'/.I*'0*+006<"-B6*K')-<N*!(961.4*
:#&*:/=2."1N4*(/=*&6<W/')'3N
=8>
?=!#;
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!>H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
"
#"
$"
%"
&"
'""
'#"
'$"
'%"
'&"
#""(N#"'" #"'"N#"'( #"'(N#"#" #"#"N#"#( #"#(N#")" #")"N#")( #")(N#"$" #"$"N#"$( #"$(N#"("
!"#$%
Y56PY*#$% +,-..-'/*>6=2<"-'/.*@<W-6B6=*B-(*&6)6P'19-/3Z*#',?-/6=*
:,;(<"*'0*K')-<N*!(961.4*:#&*:/=2."1N4*(/=*&6<W/')'3N
=8>
?=!#;
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!>H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
!
! J\
)+725N56^!6542N5*21F!/75!@)c,*2/E!,G!15=!;)N21F;!;/)*/21F!G*,@!)D,./!PWRWI!B72;!21;2F7/!+)1!C*,N265!.;5G.4!
F.26)1+5!/,!D,/7!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)16!/75!`B!216.;/*E!21!/5*@;!,G!G,+.;!G,*!)+/2,1!)16!/2@21FI!
!
`/!@.;/!D5!C,21/56!,./!/7)/!.1+5*/)21/E!);;,+2)/56!=2/7!/75!)1)4E;2;!.165*/)L51!@.;/!D5!+,1;265*56!72F7^!
);!*545N)1/!6)/)!2;!+.**51/4E!@2;;21F!21!)!1.@D5*!,G!)*5);I!>5;C2/5!/72;!42@2/)/2,1^!7,=5N5*^!/75!)1)4E;2;!
72F742F7/;! /7)/! +,@D2156! )+/2,1;! ,G! C,42+E! @)L5*;! )16! /75! `B! 216.;/*E! +)1! 6542N5*! *5;.4/;! /7)/! )*5!
6*)@)/2+)44E! ;.C5*2,*! 21! /5*@;! ,G! XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! )+725N56I! B75! )1)4E;2;! )4;,! ;7,=;! /7)/!
=75*5);! $"#>! +,.1/*25;! =244! 42L54E! 6542N5*! /75! @)c,*2/E! ,G! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! 21! /75! ;7,*/! /5*@^!
65N54,C21F!)16!5@5*F21F!+,.1/*25;!=244!C4)E!)!C*5C,165*)1/!*,45!,N5*!/2@5I!!
!
g+&#"14(600#+,A'(
B,!].)1/2GE!/75!C,;;2D45!XYX!D515G2/;!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;^!/75!)1)4E;2;!G,+.;56!,1!D.;215;;!)2*!/*)N54̂ !);!
/72;!)+/2N2/E!+)1!@,;/!+45)*4E!D5!/)*F5/56!G,*!;.D;/2/./2,1!DE!N2*/.)4O@55/21F!;,4./2,1;^!)16!D5+).;5!)2*!
/*)N54!2;!)!F*,=21F!;,.*+5!,G!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!)16!/7.;!)!/,C2+!,G!+,1+5*1!21!/75!+42@)/5!C,42+E!65D)/5!3;55!
D54,=I!!
!
!
"
(""
'"""
'(""
#"""
#(""
)"""
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")"
K(..6/361*E,*A2.-/6..*@-1*&1(B6)*FA*E,I
>M,23+
L+:2/!>96,23+
K2JJ16!?+H:
I/J2+
F:76,!>H2+
*72/+
F:76,!?G,.A6
E8=
8B!>=!CD!*>
@+A+/
?=
=8>
!
! JZ
!(
B&1C$(:[D(f"'+,0''(1+&(#&1204O(M+4%60#0&'(#&12040-O(1,-(1''%5+1#0-(9<E((06+''+%,';((
!
9;!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!+)1!)4;,!;.D;/2/./5!;7,*/5*!/*2C;!/7)/!=,.46!1,/!,++.*!N2)!)2*C4)15^!/75!C*,c5+/2,1;!
62;+.;;56!D54,=!+)1!D5!+,1;265*56!+,1;5*N)/2N5I!9;!=2/7!/545+,@@./21F^!21!)662/2,1!/,!62*5+/!5@2;;2,1!
*56.+/2,1!F515*)/56!DE!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;^!C,;;2D45!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!)*5!)4;,!+,1;265*56!21!/75!)1)4E;2;I!B75!
F*)C7;!D54,=!72F742F7/56!/75!/,/)4!#$P!5@2;;2,1;!C*,c5+/56!G,*!D.;215;;!/*)N54!21!/75!62GG5*51/!=,*46;!
)1)4E056I!
!
((
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
$""
$("
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")"
#$% +,-..-'/.*01',*A2.-/6..*@-1*&1(B6)4*K16OB-1"2()*!66"-/3.
>M,23+
L+:2/!>96,23+
K2JJ16!?+H:
I/J2+
F:76,!>H2+
*72/+
F:76,!?G,.A6
E8=
8B!>=!CD!*>
@+A+/
?=
=8>
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
$""
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
@-1<1(0"*#$% +,-..-'/.*A2.-/6..*&1(B6)*456"*'0*C-1"2()*
!66"-/3.D*S-16<"*:,;(<"4*!"#$%
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
!
! JT
((
B&1C$(:bD(9<E(06+''+%,'(=&%6(1+&5&1=#(/"'+,0''(#&1204(+,(-+==0&0,#(7%&4-';(
!
`1!D,/7!)!+)*D,1!)16!)!/5+7!=,*46^!D.;215;;!)2*O/*)N54!5@2;;2,1;!=,.46!+,1/21.5!/,!F*,=!65;C2/5!/75!
@2/2F)/21F!2@C)+/!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;I!`1!/75!C,42+E!)16!;@)*/!=,*46;^!7,=5N5*^!5@2;;2,1;!G*,@!D.;215;;!
/*)N54!=,.46!D5!*56.+56I!`1!)!/5+7!=,*46^!21!/75!)D;51+5!,G!C,42+E!45)65*;72C^!/75!`B!216.;/*E!+,.46!C4)E!)!
;2F12G2+)1/!*,45^!);!)!72F75*!)6,C/2,1!,G!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!36*2N51!DE!/75!`B!216.;/*E8!+,.C456!=2/7!)!
*54)/2N54E!215GG2+251/!/*)1;C,*/!;5+/,*!3+).;56!DE!4)+L!,G!;/*,1F!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!C,42+E8!=,.46!45)6!/,!
;2F12G2+)1/!F*,;;!*56.+/2,1;!21!5@2;;2,1;!3;55!F*)C7;!D54,=^!45G/8I!b1G,*/.1)/54E^!4)+L!,G!;/*,1F!+42@)/5!
+7)1F5!C,42+25;!=,.46!)4;,!@5)1!/75!C*5;51+5!,G!;2F12G2+)1/!15F)/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;^!=72+7!=,.46!
+,.1/5*D)4)1+5!)!;2F12G2+)1/!C*,C,*/2,1!,G!/75!62*5+/!F)21;!)+725N56!=2/7!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!3F*)C7;!D54,=8I!!
!
!
!
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
$""
$("
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
@-1<1(0"*#$% +,-..-'/.*A2.-/6..*&1(B6)4*56"*'0*C-1"2()*
!66"-/3.D*:,;(<"4*#'116<"6=*0'1*>6?'2/=*+006<".*!"#$%
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$
%
#$% +,-..-'/*>6=2<"-'/.*S61-B-/3*01',*C-1"2()*!66"-/3.*-/*
S-00616/"*8'1)=.*K1-'1*"'*>6?'2/=*+006<".
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
!
! JV
!(
B&1C$(:aD(9<E(06+''+%,(&0-"5#+%,'(=&%6(2+&#"14(600#+,A'(7+#$+,(-+==0&0,#(7%&4-';(
!
B75!F*)C7;!D54,=!C*,N265!G.*/75*!65/)24!,1!/75!2@C)+/!/7)/!N)*2,.;!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!+)1!7)N5!,1!/75!
5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!F515*)/56!DE!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;I!
!
"
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$
%
#$% +,-..-'/*>6=2<"-'/.*S61-B-/3*01',*C-1"2()*!66"-/3.*-/*
S-00616/".*8'1)=.*:/<)2=-/3*>6?'2/=*+006<".
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
!
! QW
!
!
!
#("
#;"
#<"
)'"
))"
)("
);"
)<"
$'"
$)"
0,6!R2,:G+1!
966:2/QH
I/31GJ2/Q!R2,:G+1!
966:2/QH
I/31GJ2/Q!
6163:,232:4!GH6
I/31GJ2/Q!J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
I/31GJ2/Q!2/J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
!"#$%
M7M*+,-..-'/.*A2.-/6..*&1(B6)4*#(1?'/*8'1)=
V6(1*%GUG
'("
';"
'<"
#'"
#)"
#("
#;"
#<"
)'"
))"
0,6!R2,:G+1!
966:2/QH
I/31GJ2/Q!R2,:G+1!
966:2/QH
I/31GJ2/Q!
6163:,232:4!GH6
I/31GJ2/Q!J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
I/31GJ2/Q!2/J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
!"#$%
M7M*+,-..-'/.*A2.-/6..*&1(B6)4*K')-<N*8'1)=
V6(1*%GUG
!
! QK
!
!
!
!(
B&1C$(EUD(g+&#"14(600#+,A'h(+6C15#O(+,54"-+,A(-+==0&0,#(&0/%",-(0==05#'(+,(-+==0&0,#(7%&4-'O(EURU;(
!
>5;C2/5!)2*!/*)N54h;!G);/5*!F*,=/7!21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;^!/75!C*,c5+/2,1;!2162+)/5!/7)/!)!4)*F5*!;7)*5!,G!
#$P!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!@)E!D5!)+725N56!21!65N54,C56!+,.1/*25;I!9;!=2/7!/545+,@@./21F^!/72;!+)1!D5!
5SC4)2156!DE!)!F*5)/5*!1.@D5*!,G!D.;215;;!/*)N545*;!)16!DE!)1!5+,1,@2+!;C5+2)420)/2,1!21!;5+/,*;!/7)/!)*5!
@,*5!;.2/)D45!G,*!)1!)6,C/2,1!,G!N2*/.)4O@55/21F!;,4./2,1;!3)/!45);/!21!/75!;7,*/!)16!@562.@!/5*@8!21!
$"#>!5+,1,@25;I!9;!=2/7!/545+,@@./21F^!,N5*!/2@5!)!;2F12G2+)1/!N,4.@5!,G!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!=244!
D5+,@5!C,;;2D45!21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!3;55!F*)C7;!D54,=8I!
!
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
$""
$("
0,6!R2,:G+1!
966:2/QH
I/31GJ2/Q!R2,:G+1!
966:2/QH
I/31GJ2/Q!
6163:,232:4!GH6
I/31GJ2/Q!J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
I/31GJ2/Q!2/J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
!"#$%
M7M*+,-..-'/.*A2.-/6..*&1(B6)4*&6<W*8'1)=
V6(1*%GUG
("
'""
'("
#""
#("
)""
)("
0,6!R2,:G+1!
966:2/QH
I/31GJ2/Q!R2,:G+1!
966:2/QH
I/31GJ2/Q!
6163:,232:4!GH6
I/31GJ2/Q!J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
I/31GJ2/Q!2/J2,63:!
,6-.G/J!6MM63:
!"#$%
M7M*+,-..-'/.*A2.-/6..*&1(B6)4*T,(1"*8'1)=
V6(1*%GUG
!
! QP
((
((
B&1C$(E:D(9<E(06+''+%,(&0-"5#+%,'(0,1/40-(/.(2+&#"14(600#+,A'(/.(&0A+%,;(
!
9;!72F742F7/56!DE!/75!/=,!F*)C7;!D54,=^!)!;@)*/!=,*46!=,.46!212/2)44E!F515*)/5!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!DE!
*56.+21F!/75!5@2;;2,1;!);;,+2)/56!=2/7!D.;215;;!/*)N54!21!$"#>!+,.1/*25;^!D./!+,1/21.5!/,!;7,=!F*,=/7!21!
65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;I!%*,@!)D,./!PWPW!/,!PWPQ^!5@2;;2,1;!65*2N21F!G*,@!D.;215;;!/*)N54!=,.46!/751!
65+*5);5!21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!);!=544^!21+4.621F!#721)I!
!
"
(
'"
'(
#"
#(
)"
)(
$"
=8> ?= @+A+/ *72/+ I/J2+
#$% +,-..-'/*>6=2<"-'/.*+/(?)6=*?N*C-1"2()*!66"-/3.*
:/<)2=-/3*>6?'2/=*+006<".*%GUG*!"#$%
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
"
(
'"
'(
#"
#(
)"
)(
$"
$(
=8> ?= @+A+/ *72/+ I/J2+
#$% +,-..-'/*>6=2<"-'/.*+/(?)6=*?N*C-1"2()*!66"-/3.4*
:/<)2=-/3*>6?'2/=*+006<".4*%GHG*!"#$%
*+,-./
0.1234
5637
89+,:
!
! QR
!(
B&1C$(EED(9<E(06+''+%,'(%20&(#+60(=&%6(/"'+,0''(#&1204O(,0#(%=(2+&#"14(600#+,A'((1,-(&0/%",-(0==05#'O(51&/%,(7%&4-;(
!
!(
B&1C$(ERD(9<E(06+''+%,'(%20&(#+60(=&%6(/"'+,0''(#&1204O(,0#(%=(2+&#"14(600#+,A'((1,-(&0/%",-(0==05#'O('61&#(7%&4-;(
!
9;!72F742F7/56!21!;5+/2,1!KIP!)D,N5^!;/)/2;/2+)4!6)/)!,1!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!2;!1,/!+,445+/56^!=7245!5S2;/21F!
+);5!;/.6E!)1)4E;5;!)*5!D);56!,1!)!N)*25/E!,G!)CC*,)+75;^!@5/7,6,4,F25;^!)16!6)/)!;5/;^!)16!/EC2+)44E!
G,+.;!,1!2162N26.)4!+,@C)125;I!B75!.1+5*/)21/25;!);;,+2)/56!=2/7!/75!5;/2@)/5;!C*,N2656!)D,N5!)*5!
/75*5G,*5!72F7I!B75!;2@.4)/2,1;^!7,=5N5*^!C*,N265!.;5G.4!2162+)/2,1;!,1!/75!;205!,G!/75!5@2;;2,1!
*56.+/2,1;!/7)/!+,.46!C,/51/2)44E!D5!)+725N56I!B75E!)4;,!C*,N265!21;2F7/!,1!/75!15F)/2N5!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!
/7)/!+)1!C,/51/2)44E!,++.*!21!/75!)D;51+5!,G!5GG5+/2N5!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!C,42+25;I!?.D42+!C,42+25;!)16!
;/*)/5F25;!=244!/75*5G,*5!D5!/75!G,+.;!,G!,.*!15S/!;5+/2,1I!
"
'"
#"
)"
$"
("
%"
;"
&"
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$
%
#@>A$5*8$>XS
#$% +,-..-'/.*01',*A2.-/6..*&1(B6)4*56"*'0*C-1"2()*!66"-/3.*(/=*>6?'2/=*
+006<".
=8>
?=
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!>H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
"
'"
#"
)"
$"
("
%"
#""( #"'" #"'( #"#" #"#( #")" #")( #"$" #"$( #"("
!"#$%
T!@>&*8$>XS
#$% +,-..-'/.*01',*A2.-/6..*&1(B6)4*56"*'0*C-1"2()*!66"-/3.*(/=*>6?'2/=*
+006<".=8>
?=
@+A+/
8B!>=!CD!*>
E8=
F:76,!?G,.A6
*72/+
F:76,!>H2+
I/J2+
K2JJ16!?+H:
L+:2/!>96,23+
>M,23+
!
! QJ
5 Policies and strategies
B75! )1)4E;2;! .165*/)L51! )D,N5! 244.;/*)/5;! 7,=! 62GG5*51/! D57)N2,*;! G*,@! C*2N)/5O;5+/,*! +,@C)125;!
;.CC4E21F! )16!.;21F! `B^! );!=544! );! G*,@!C,42+E!@)L5*;^! +)1! 45)6! /,! 6*)@)/2+)44E! 62GG5*51/! ,./+,@5;! 21!
/5*@;!,G!/75!C,/51/2)4!2@C)+/!,G!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!,1!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!
B75! ,CC,*/.12/25;! /,! *56.+5! XYX! *56.+/2,1;! ,GG5*56! DE! /545=,*L21F! )16! N2*/.)4! @55/21F;! =244! 1,/! D5!
7)*N5;/56!)./,@)/2+)44E^!);^!DE! 2@C*,N21F!5GG2+251+E!)16!C*,6.+/2N2/E^! /75;5!;,4./2,1;!)4;,!6542N5*!@,*5!
G*55! /2@5! /,! =,*L5*;^! 72F75*! C*,G2/;! /,! +,@C)125;^! )16! 72F75*! 62;C,;)D45! 21+,@5I! B75! .;5! ,G! /75;5!
)662/2,1)4!*5;,.*+5;!+)1!45)6!/,!72F75*!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!/7)/!15F)/5!212/2)4!F)21;I!B75!;205!,G!/72;!*5D,.16!
5GG5+/!=244!65C516!,1!/5+71,4,F2+)4!)16!5+,1,@2+!65N54,C@51/!)16!,1!/75!D*,)65*!;/*)/5F25;!)16!C,42+25;!
/7)/!;,+25/25;!)16!D.;215;;5;!=244!C.*;.5I!!
B75! C*,c5+/2,1;! 244.;/*)/56! 21! ;5+/2,1! J! 72F742F7/! /75! 2@C,*/)1+5! ,G! )! +,@D2156! 5GG,*/! G*,@! D,/7! /75!
C*2N)/5!)16!/75!C.D42+!;5+/,*;I!'.+7!+,@D2156!5GG,*/!+)1!C4)E!)!L5E!*,45! 21!542@21)/21F!5S2;/21F!D)**25*;!
G,*! /75! 2@C45@51/)/2,1!,G! /545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4O@55/21F!;,4./2,1;^! 21! *56.+21F! /75!15F)/2N5! G556D)+L!
/7)/! @)E! ,++.*! =751! )662/2,1)4! *5;,.*+5;! )*5! @)65! )N)24)D45! DE! ;.+7! ;,4./2,1;^! )16! 21! )+/2N)/21F!
N2*/.,.;!+E+45;!/7)/!45N5*)F5!/75;5!`B!;,4./2,1;!/,!G.*/75*!65+*5);5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!3;55!D,S!D54,=8I!!
!
!5#+21#+,A(2+&#"%"'(5.540'(
U2*/.,.;! +E+45;! +)1! D5! )+/2N)/56! =751! /75! 2@C45@51/)/2,1g.;5! ,G! )1! `B! ;,4./2,1! /7)/! *56.+5;! XYX!
5@2;;2,1;!
! @)L5;!2/!5);25*!G,*!@,*5!,G!/75!;)@5!;,4./2,1!/,!D5!65C4,E56a!
! 45)6;! /,! )! 72F75*! .;5! ,G! +,@C45@51/)*E! `B! ;,4./2,1;! /7)/! )4;,! )+725N5! XYX! 5@2;;2,1!
*56.+/2,1;a!!
! 45)6;!/,!)!D*,)65*!)6,C/2,1!,G!,*F)120)/2,1)4!;/*.+/.*5;!)16!C*,+5;;5;!/7)/!*5].2*5!G5=5*!
XYX!5@2;;2,1;a!)16!!
! G,;/5*;!)!+.4/.*5!)16!D57)N2,*;!/7)/!6*2N5!;,+25/E!/,=)*6;!4,=5*!XYX!5@2;;2,1;I!
!
#.**51/4E! /75*5! 2;!)! 42@2/56!.165*;/)1621F! ,1! 7,=!C*2N)/5O;5+/,*! +,@C)125;!)16! C.D42+! )./7,*2/25;! +)1!
=,*L!/,F5/75*!/,!G.44E!)+725N5!/75;5!F,)4;^!);!/75*5!2;! 21;.GG2+251/!21;2F7/!,1!/75!N)*2,.;!G556D)+L!4,,C;!
/7)/! /545=,*L21F! )16! N2*/.)4! @55/21F;! +)1! F515*)/5I! >5;C2/5! /75;5! 42@2/)/2,1;^! )! 1.@D5*! ,G! 1,O*5F*5/!
;/*)/5F25;!)CC5)*!/,!D5!C*5;51/I!B75E!21+4.65!/75!G,44,=21Ff!
• >5C4,E! /75! D*,)6D)16! 21G*);/*.+/.*5! 155656! /,! 51)D45! `B! )CC42+)/2,1;! /7)/! *56.+5!XYX! 5@2;;2,1;^!
/7.;!,GG5*21F!)1!)4/5*1)/2N5!/,!21G*);/*.+/.*5;!/7)/^!DE!/752*!1)/.*5^!45)6!/,!)662/2,1)4!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!
3/72;!@,N5!1,/!,14E!C*,@,/5;!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!D./!)4;,!;.CC,*/;!,/75*!`B!;,4./2,1;!
/7)/!+)1!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;8!!
• "SC42+2/4E! 421L! /75! )6,C/2,1! ,G! /545=,*L21F! )16! N2*/.)4! @55/21F;! =2/7! /75! 1556! /,! *56.+5! XYX!
5@2;;2,1;^! 21+*5);21F! )=)*515;;! ,1! /75! XYX! ,CC,*/.12/25;! )16! *2;L;! );;,+2)/56! =2/7! /75;5! /=,!
;,4./2,1;!)16!D.24621F!+)C)+2/E!)@,1F;/!C,42+E!@)L5*;^!D.;215;;!5S5+./2N5;^!)16!5@C4,E55;^!);!=544!
);!=2/721!;,+25/E!
• `651/2GE!)16!*5@,N5!*5F.4)/,*E!D)**25*;!/7)/!72165*!/75!65C4,E@51/!,G!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!
@55/21F;^!5IFI^!1)/2,1)4!*5F.4)/2,1;!,*!+,445+/2N5!D)*F)21;!/7)/!65@)16!C7E;2+)4!C*5;51+5!21!)!
=,*LC4)+5^!);!=544!);!*5].2*5@51/;!/,!21/5*)+/!=2/7!C.D42+!,GG2+2)4;!,*!+.;/,@5*!*5C*5;51/)/2N5;!21!
C5*;,1!)16!,1!C)C5*^!5N51!=751!;.+7!21/5*)+/2,1!+,.46!5);24E!/)L5!C4)+5!*5@,/54E!=2/7!`B!
!
• b;5!C.D42+!C*,+.*5@51/!)16!C.D42+!;5*N2+5;!21!F515*)4!/,!;C.*!/75!)6,C/2,1!,G!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!
@55/21F;^!=2/7!)!G,+.;!,1!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!!
• 9*/2+.4)/5!@5/7,6,4,F25;! /,! +,445+/! *545N)1/! 6)/)! )16! );;5;;! /75! 2@C)+/! ,G! /545=,*L21F! )16! N2*/.)4!
@55/21F;!)/!/75!45N54!,G!2162N26.)4!2@C45@51/)/2,1;!M!/72;!@)E!*5].2*5!3`B8!;E;/5@;!/,!+,@@.12+)/5!
*545N)1/! 21G,*@)/2,1!D5/=551!62GG5*51/!+,@C)125;^!,*!D5/=551!+,@C)125;!)16!5@C4,E55;^!)16!@)E!
)4;,!21+4.65!)CC*,)+75;!/,!/*)+L!2162*5+/!2@C)+/!/7*,.F7,./!/75!5+,1,@E!
• 'E;/5@)/2+)44E!5N)4.)/5!/75! 2@C)+/!,G!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4O@55/21F!65C4,E@51/;!/,!);;5;;!62*5+/!
5GG5+/;!)16!2Gg=7)/!N2*/.,.;!+E+45;!=5*5!)+/2N)/56^!2Gg=7)/!15F)/2N5!,./+,@5;!,++.**56^!)16!=7)/!15/!
2@C)+/!,1!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!=);!)+725N56!
• '5/! .C! )CC*,C*2)/5! 6)/)O+,445+/2,1! ;E;/5@;! /7)/! )*5! )D45! /,! *5F.4)*4E! F)/75*! /75! ;/)/2;/2+)4! 6)/)!
155656!/,!);;5;;!)16!@,12/,*!C*,F*5;;!21!/72;!G2546^!)/!)1!)FF*5F)/56!45N54!
• #,445+/!)16!62;;5@21)/5!21G,*@)/2,1!)D,./!D5;/!C*)+/2+5;!,1!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;^!.;21F!
5S)@C45;!,G!,*F)120)/2,1;!/7)/!)*5!;.++5;;G.4!)/!@212@2021F!62*5+/!XYX!5@2;;2,1!=7245!)+/2N)/21F!
C,;2/2N5!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!+E+45;!!
• `1/*,6.+5!D*,)6!C,42+25;!/7)/^!=751!*5;,.*+5;!3/2@5!,*!@,15E8!)*5!42D5*)/56!DE!/545=,*L21F!,*!N2*/.)4!
@55/21F;^!)./,@)/2+)44E!C*,N265!21+51/2N5;!G,*!/75!.;5!;.+7!*5;,.*+5;!21!=)E;!/7)/!45)6!/,!)662/2,1)4!
*56.+/2,1;!21!XYX!5@2;;2,1!M!G,*!5S)@C45^!)!=72/5O+5*/2G2+)/5!,*!,GG;5/!;E;/5@!/7)/!C*,N265;!*5=)*6;!
2G!/75!5+,1,@2+!;)N21F;!F515*)/56!DE!/545=,*L21F!,*!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!)*5!65C4,E56!21!212/2)/2N5;!/7)/!
G.*/75*!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!3;.+7!);!)!*515=)D45!515*FE!21N5;/@51/8!!
• %.16!/5+71,4,FE!65N54,C@51/!212/2)/2N5;!/,!2@C*,N5!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4O@55/21F!;,4./2,1;!)16!/,!
/)24,*!/75@!/,!/75!1556;!,G!+,.1/*25;!,*!;5+/,*;!/7)/!+)1!)6,C/!;.+7!;,4./2,1;!21!)1!5)*4E!C7);5!,G!
65N54,C@51/^!/7.;!)+725N21F!)!4,=OXYXO5@2;;2,1!C)/7I!()1E!,CC,*/.12/25;!)*5!42L54E!/,!D5!C*5;51/!21!
65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!=2/7!72F7!F*,=/7!
• `@C45@51/!+)C)+2/EOD.24621F!)16!/5+71,4,FEO/*)1;G5*!C,42+25;!65;2F156!/,!D515G2/!65N54,C21F!
+,.1/*25;!,*!;5+/,*;!/7)/!)*5!4)+L21F!21!+*2/2+)4!L1,=456F5!)16!5SC5*/2;5^!D./!/7)/!7)N5!/75!C,/51/2)4!/,!
)6,C/!/545=,*L21F!)16!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;!/,!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!)16!)+/2N)/5!4,=O+)*D,1!+E+45;!!
(,;/!,G! /75;5!)+/2N2/25;!)*5!@,;/!5GG5+/2N54E!.165*/)L51!=2/7! /75!)+/2N5!C)*/2+2C)/2,1!,G!D,/7!/75!C.D42+!
)16!C*2N)/5!;5+/,*^!);!72F742F7/56!DE!/75!/)D45!D54,=f!
!
( 3"/4+5('05#%&( )*(+,-"'#&.( G01-+,A("'0&'(I#&0,-'0##0&'J(
"1;.*5!D*,)6D)16!21G*);/*.+/.*5!
"!!
3*5F.4)/,*E!G*)@5=,*L!)16!21+51/2N5;8!
"""!
362*5+/!21N5;/@51/8!
!
-.246!L1,=456F5!)16!+)C)+2/E!,1!`B!.;5!/,!*56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!
"""!
3d+,*5!D.;215;;e!,G!/75!C.D42+!;5+/,*8!
"""!!3@,;/!L1,=456F5)D45!,1!/5+71,4,FE!)16!2/;!.;5;8!
"""!
362*5+/!5SC5*251+5!)16!C*)+/2+)4!21;2F7/8!
:5@,N5!*5F.4)/,*E!D)**25*;!!
"""!
3);;5;;!)16!*5N2;5!*5F.4)/2,18!
""!
32651/2GE!D)**25*;!)16!C*,C,;5!;,4./2,1;8!
""!
32651/2GE!D)**25*;!)16!C*,C,;5!;,4./2,1;8!
_5N5*)F5!C*,+.*5@51/!/,!;.CC,*/!XYX!*56.+/2,1;!=2/7!4,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+L!
"""! ! ""!
9*/2+.4)/5!@5/7,6,4,F25;!G,*!6)/)!+,445+/2,1!)16!
"!
3G,*!62;;5@21)/2,1!)16!
"""!
3=,*L!=2/7!+.;/,@5*;!
"""!
362*5+/!)CC42+)/2,1!)16!
!
! Q\
)1)4E;2;!! ;/)16)*620)/2,18! )16!G)+242/)/58! ;/)16)*6!65N54,C@51/8!
'E;/5@)/2+)44E!);;5;;!/75!XYX!2@C)+/!,G!`B!;,4./2,1;!321+4.621F!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;8!
"""!
3G,*!@)+*,O45N54!)1)4E;5;8!
"""!
3;E;/5@)/2+)44E!);;5;;!/75!2@C)+/!,G!C*,6.+/;!
)16!;5*N2+5;8!
"""!
3F)21!62*5+/!5SC5*251+5!)16!C*)+/2+)4!21;2F7/8!
'5/!.C!6)/)O+,445+/2,1!;E;/5@;!
"""!
3@)+*,!45N54!)16!/,!+*5)/5!;/)16)*6;8!
"""!
35@D56!6)/)!+,445+/2,1!)16!+,@@.12+)/2,1!+)C)D242/25;!21!`B8!
"""!
32@C45@51/!+,@C)1EO!)16!;.CC4EO+7)21O=265!
;E;/5@;8!
>2;;5@21)/5!D5;/!C*)+/2+5;!
"""!
3+,.1/*E!45N548!
"""!
3=2/7!+.;/,@5*;!)16!C,42+E!@)L5*;8!
"""!
3=2/7!C55*;^!;.CC425*;^!)16!C,42+E!@)L5*;8!
`1/*,6.+5!C,42+25;!/7)/!+7)1154!*5;,.*+5;!/,=)*6;!+*5)/21F!4,=O+)*D,1!G556D)+L!
"""!
!3);;5;;!)16!65N54,C!)CC*,C*2)/5!C,42+25;8!
""!
3C*,N265!)6N2+5!)16!5SC4,*5!;,4./2,1;8!
""!
3C*,N265!)6N2+5!)16!5SC4,*5!;,4./2,1;8!
B5+71,4,FE!65N54,C@51/!)16!/)24,*21F!/,!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!
"""!
3C*,N265!;.CC,*/!)16!L1,=456F58!
"""!
365N54,C!/5+71,4,F25;8!
"""!
3754C!)*/2+.4)/5!*5].2*5@51/;8!
#)C)+2/E!D.24621F!)16!62;;5@21)/2,1!21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;!
"""!
3;.CC,*/!=2/7!/,,4;!)16!G.1621F!21;/*.@51/;8!
"""!
3=,*L!=2/7!4,+)4!;.CC425*;!)16!+.;/,@5*;8!
"""!
3=,*L!=2/7!4,+)4!;.CC425*;!)16!+.;/,@5*;8!
*1/40(:[D(3%4+5+0'(1,-('#&1#0A+0'(#%(&0-"50(BKB(06+''+%,'(7+#$()*(1,-(A0,0&1#0(4%7L51&/%,(=00-/15M(+,(&041#+%,(#%(-+==0&0,#('#1M0$%4-0&';(@0.D(""""""""""""(i(+6C%,#(&%40j(""""""""(i(60-+"6(+6C%,#(&%40j(""""(i(4+6+#0-(&%40;(*$0(,%#0'(+,(/&15M0#'(C&%2+-0(1(
'$%&#(0NC41,1#+%,(%=(#$0(&%40(%=(-+==0&0,#('#1M0$%4-0&';((
-E!c,21/4E!=,*L21F!)/!/75!2@C45@51/)/2,1!,G!/75;5!;/*)/5F25;^!C,42+E!@)L5*;!)16!C*2N)/5O;5+/,*!+,@C)125;!
@)E! 51)D45! `B! )CC42+)/2,1;^! ;.+7! );! /75! ,15;! ;.CC,*/21F! /545=,*L21F! )16! N2*/.)4!@55/21F;^! /,! F)21! )!
D*,)65*! )++5C/)1+5! 21! ;,+25/EI! B75E! =,.46! 6542N5*! F*5)/5*! XYX! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! =7245! 42D5*)/21F!
*5;,.*+5;!)16!C*,N2621F!@,654;!/7)/!+)1!754C! *56.+5!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!@,*5!D*,)64E^!/7.;!G,;/5*21F! 4,=O
+)*D,1!G556D)+L!4,,C;I!`G!/72;!C,/51/2)4!2;!G.44E!)+725N56^!/75!*5;.4/;!21!/5*@;!,G!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;!
+)1!D5!6*)@)/2+^!);!72F742F7/56!21!;5+/2,1!QI!!
!
! !
!
! QZ
6 Appendix 1 – Assumption tables ',@5!,G!/75!);;.@C/2,1;!./242056!21!D.24621F!/75!C*,c5+/2,1;!G,*!/75!62GG5*51/!=,*46;!)*5!244.;/*)/56!D54,=I!
!
6.1 Teleworking
(
• GTg(51&(%7,0&'$+C(&1#0(IC0&(:OUUU(C%C"41#+%,J(C&0L(1,-(C%'#L#0407%&M+,A(
• #)*D,1!=,*46f!%,*!72;/,*2+)4!6)/)!G,*!PWWW!)16!PWWQ!);!=544!);!G./.*5!C*,c5+/2,1;!,1!
+)*! ,=15*;72C! *)/5;! G,*! /75! *5F2,1;! +,1;265*56! 21! /75! ;/.6E^! G2F.*5;! G*,@! /75!
`1/5*1)/2,1)4! "15*FE!9F51+E! 3`"98! )16! /75!<,*46! -.;215;;!#,.1+24! ,1!'.;/)21)D45!
>5N54,C@51/! 3<-#'>8!=5*5! .;56I! #)*! ,=15*;72C! G2F.*5;! C,;/O/545+,@@./21F! )*5!
+,**5+/56!DE!/75!/545=,*L5*;!/7)/!F2N5!.C!/752*!+)*;I!B75!C*,C,*/2,1!,G!/545=,*L5*;!
/7)/!F2N5!.C! /752*! N572+45;! 2;!);;.@56! /,!D5! ;@)44! 21! /75! +)*D,1!)16! /5+7!=,*46;^!
)16!72F75*!21!/75!C,42+E!)16!;@)*/!=,*46;I!
!
!
!
!
• ?,42+E!=,*46f! `1! /72;!=,*46^! 2/!=);! );;.@56! /7)/^! 6.5!@)214E! /,! /75! )6,C/2,1! )16!
2@C45@51/)/2,1! ,G! )@D2/2,.;! )16! 5GG5+/2N5! XYXO5@2;;2,1O*56.+/2,1! C,42+25;! )16!
/)*F5/;! 21! /75! /*)1;C,*/)/2,1! ;5+/,*! );!=544! );! 21!,/75*! ;5+/,*;^! /75! F*,=/7! 21! +)*!
,=15*;72C!*)/5;!=244!65+*5);5!,N5*!/2@5^!);!+,@C)*56!/,!/75!+)*D,1!=,*46^! 21!D,/7!
65N54,C56!+,.1/*25;!)16!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;I!`1!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;^!;.+7!65+4215!
=,.46!@)214E!/)L5!C4)+5!21!/75!;5+,16!7)4G!,G!/75!/,/)4!/2@5!C5*2,6!+,1;265*56^!=7245!
21! /75! G2*;/! 7)4G^! +)*! ,=15*;72C! *)/5;! )*5! 5SC5+/56! /,! 21+*5);5! 6.5! /,! F*,=21F!
)N5*)F5!21+,@5;I!!
!
LDV Car ownership rate (per 1000 population) pre telecommuting
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 618 626 636 644 651 659 667 674 682 690 698
EU 27 463 463 501 520 537 553 569 585 601 618 635
Japan 395 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404
SK AU NZ CA 360 380 399 418 437 456 476 495 514 533 552
FSU 100 108 133 168 212 258 310 340 373 408 447
Other Europe 201 218 235 304 345 391 440 466 493 522 551
China 13 17 26 37 50 66 86 111 142 181 231
Other Asia 21 25 29 33 37 46 56 68 82 98 117
India 10 14 17 21 26 30 40 51 66 83 105
Middle East 42 45 47 51 57 63 68 74 79 85 91
Latin America 78 87 101 118 136 157 181 209 240 276 317
Africa 20 23 27 31 34 38 42 46 50 54 58
Car ownership rate post telecommuting (per 1000 inhabitants)2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
USA 618 626 636 643 650 657 664 671 678 685 692
EU 27 463 463 501 520 536 552 567 583 599 615 631
Japan 395 395 396 397 397 398 399 399 400 400 401
SK AU NZ CA 360 380 399 418 437 456 474 493 511 530 548
FSU 100 108 133 168 211 258 309 339 372 407 445
Other Europe 201 218 235 304 345 391 440 465 492 519 549
China 13 17 26 37 50 66 86 110 142 181 230
Other Asia 21 25 29 33 37 46 56 68 82 98 116
India 10 14 17 21 26 30 39 51 65 83 104
Middle East 42 45 47 51 57 63 68 73 79 85 91
Latin America 78 87 101 118 136 157 181 208 240 275 315
Africa 20 23 27 31 34 38 42 46 50 54 58
!
! QT
!
!
• B5+7!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46^!/75!;)@5!G2F.*5;!21+4.656!21!/75!+)*D,1!=,*46!=5*5!.;56^!
);! 2/! =);! );;.@56! /7)/! /75! `B! 216.;/*E! =244! 1,/! 7)N5! )! 62*5+/! 2@C)+/! ,1! +)*!
,=15*;72C! *)/5;! )*,.16! /75!=,*46I! _,=5*! ,=15*;72C! *)/5;! )*5^! 7,=5N5*^! ,D/)2156!
=751!/75!N572+45;!/7)/!=244!D5!F2N51!.C!DE!/545+,@@./5*;!)*5!)4;,!+,1;265*56I!
!
!
!
LDV Car ownership rate (per 1000 population) pre telecommuting
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 618 626 636 641 645 649 653 657 662 666 670
EU 27 463 463 499 515 529 542 555 567 580 593 607
Japan 395 395 394 393 392 391 390 389 388 387 386
SK AU NZ CA 360 380 397 414 431 447 464 480 496 512 527
FSU 100 108 133 168 211 255 305 333 364 396 432
Other Europe 201 218 235 304 344 387 434 457 481 506 532
China 13 17 26 37 50 65 84 108 138 176 223
Other Asia 21 25 29 33 37 46 55 67 80 95 113
India 10 14 17 21 25 30 39 50 64 81 101
Middle East 42 45 47 51 57 62 67 72 77 83 88
Latin America 78 87 101 118 135 155 179 205 234 268 306
Africa 20 23 27 31 34 38 41 45 49 52 56
Car ownership rate post telecommuting (per 1000 inhabitants)2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
USA 618 626 635 639 643 646 649 651 654 656 658
EU 27 463 463 499 514 527 540 551 562 574 585 596
Japan 395 395 394 392 391 389 387 385 383 381 379
SK AU NZ CA 360 380 397 413 430 445 461 476 490 504 518
FSU 100 108 133 168 210 255 304 331 361 392 426
Other Europe 201 218 235 304 343 386 432 454 477 501 526
China 13 17 26 37 50 65 84 108 137 174 220
Other Asia 21 25 29 33 37 45 55 67 80 94 112
India 10 14 17 21 25 30 39 50 64 80 100
Middle East 42 45 47 51 56 62 67 72 77 82 87
Latin America 78 87 101 117 135 155 178 204 233 265 302
Africa 20 23 27 31 34 38 41 45 48 52 56
LDV Car ownership rate (per 1000 population) pre telecommuting
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 618 626 636 644 651 659 667 674 682 690 698
EU 27 463 463 501 520 537 553 569 585 601 618 635
Japan 395 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404
SK AU NZ CA 360 380 399 418 437 456 476 495 514 533 552
FSU 100 108 133 168 212 258 310 340 373 408 447
Other Europe 201 218 235 304 345 391 440 466 493 522 551
China 13 17 26 37 50 66 86 111 142 181 231
Other Asia 21 25 29 33 37 46 56 68 82 98 117
India 10 14 17 21 26 30 40 51 66 83 105
Middle East 42 45 47 51 57 63 68 74 79 85 91
Latin America 78 87 101 118 136 157 181 209 240 276 317
Africa 20 23 27 31 34 38 42 46 50 54 58
Car ownership rate post telecommuting (per 1000 inhabitants)2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
USA 618 626 635 643 650 657 664 670 677 683 689
EU 27 463 463 501 519 536 551 567 582 597 612 627
Japan 395 395 396 397 397 398 398 399 399 399 399
SK AU NZ CA 360 380 399 418 437 455 474 492 510 528 545
FSU 100 108 133 168 211 258 309 339 371 406 444
Other Europe 201 218 235 304 345 390 439 464 491 518 547
China 13 17 26 37 50 66 85 110 141 180 229
Other Asia 21 25 29 33 37 46 56 68 82 98 116
India 10 14 17 21 26 30 39 51 65 83 104
Middle East 42 45 47 51 57 63 68 73 79 85 91
Latin America 78 87 101 117 136 157 181 208 239 274 314
Africa 20 23 27 31 34 38 42 46 50 54 58
!
! QV
• '@)*/!=,*46f!B75!G2F.*5;!21+4.656!21!/72;!=,*46!=5*5!D);56!,1!/7,;5!21+4.656!21!/75!
C,42+E! =,*46^! G,*! /75! *5);,1;! 62;+.;;56! )D,N5I! `1! )! ;@)*/! =,*46! /75! 2@C)+/! ,G!
/545=,*L21F!,1!+.*D21F!+)*!,=15*;72C!2;!/75!F*5)/5;/I!
!
!
!
!
• GTg(120&1A0(#&1204(C0&(20$+540(I20$+540(M+4%60#0&'(C0&(.01&J((
• #)*D,1!=,*46f!9;!G,*!_>U!+)*!,=15*;72C!*)/5;^!G2F.*5;!G,*!)N5*)F5!/*)N54!C5*!N572+45!
=5*5!/)L51!G*,@!/75!`1/5*1)/2,1)4!"15*FE!9F51+E!)16!/75!<,*46!-.;215;;!#,.1+24!,1!
'.;/)21)D45!>5N54,C@51/I!
• B5+7!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46^!/75!;)@5!G2F.*5;!21+4.656!21!/75!dF*)E!=,*46e!=5*5!.;56^!
);!2/!=);!);;.@56!/7)/!/75!`B!216.;/*E!=244!1,/!7)N5!)1!2@C)+/!,1!)N5*)F5!/*)N54!C5*!
N572+45!,/75*!/7)1!/7)/!);;,+2)/56!=2/7!/75!*56.+/2,1!21!/*)N54!6.5!/,!/545+,@@./21F!
)16!/545+,1G5*51+21FI!
!
!
!
• ?,42+E!=,*46f! `1! /72;!=,*46! 2/! 2;! );;.@56! /7)/^!6.5! /,! /75! ;)@5! *5);,1;!62;+.;;56!
)D,N5!G,*!+)*!,=15*;72C!*)/5;^!/75!)N5*)F5!/*)N54!C5*!N572+45!=244!/516!/,!65+*5);5!
,N5*! /2@5^!D,/7! 21!65N54,C56!)16! 21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;! 321!)! 4)/5*!C7);5! G,*! /75!
4)//5*8I!!
LDV Car ownership rate (per 1000 population) pre telecommuting
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 618 626 636 641 645 649 653 657 662 666 670
EU 27 463 463 499 515 529 542 555 567 580 593 607
Japan 395 395 394 393 392 391 390 389 388 387 386
SK AU NZ CA 360 380 397 414 431 447 464 480 496 512 527
FSU 100 108 133 168 211 255 305 333 364 396 432
Other Europe 201 218 235 304 344 387 434 457 481 506 532
China 13 17 26 37 50 65 84 108 138 176 223
Other Asia 21 25 29 33 37 46 55 67 80 95 113
India 10 14 17 21 25 30 39 50 64 81 101
Middle East 42 45 47 51 57 62 67 72 77 83 88
Latin America 78 87 101 118 135 155 179 205 234 268 306
Africa 20 23 27 31 34 38 41 45 49 52 56
Car ownership rate post telecommuting (per 1000 inhabitants)2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
USA 618 626 634 631 625 609 583 546 499 459 435
EU 27 463 463 498 509 515 513 500 477 442 412 394
Japan 395 395 393 388 381 369 350 325 294 268 251
SK AU NZ CA 360 380 397 410 420 424 419 404 379 356 343
FSU 100 108 133 167 207 245 282 292 296 302 313
Other Europe 201 218 235 302 337 372 401 401 392 385 386
China 13 17 26 37 48 61 74 87 102 120 143
Other Asia 21 25 29 33 36 43 48 54 59 65 73
India 10 14 17 21 25 28 34 40 47 55 65
Middle East 42 45 47 51 55 58 59 58 57 56 57
Latin America 78 87 101 116 131 145 156 165 173 183 196
Africa 20 23 27 30 33 35 36 36 36 36 36
LDV average travel per vehicle (vehicle km per year) - IEA/WBCSD numbers
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 17,600 17,600 17,600 17,600 17,600 17,600 17,600 17,600 17,600 17,600 17,600
EU 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500
Japan 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000
SK AU NZ CA 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,500
FSU 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000
Other Europe 11,000 11,000 11,000 11,000 11,000 11,000 11,000 11,000 11,000 11,000 11,000
China 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000
Other Asia 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000
India 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000
Middle East 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000 13,000
Latin America 12,000 12,000 12,000 12,000 12,000 12,000 12,000 12,000 12,000 12,000 12,000
Africa 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000
!
! \W
• '@)*/!=,*46f!B75!G2F.*5;!21+4.656!21!/72;!=,*46!=5*5!D);56!,1!/7,;5!21+4.656!21!/75!
C,42+E!=,*46^!G,*!/75!*5);,1;!62;+.;;56!)D,N5I!
!
!
!
!
• *0407%&M+,A(+6C4060,#1#+%,(1'(1(C0&50,#1A0(%=(#%#14(5%66"#0&'(
• #)*D,1! =,*46f! Y2;/,*2+)4! 6)/)! ,1! /75! C515/*)/2,1! ,G! /545=,*L21F! 21! /75! 62GG5*51/!
*5F2,1;!+,1;265*56!21!/75!;/.6E!=5*5!/)L51!G*,@!/75!G,44,=21F!;,.*+5;f!<,*46)/<,*L!
3PWWZ8^! X)*/15*! 3PWWQ8^! b[! $GG2+5! G,*! A)/2,1)4! '/)/2;/2+;! 3PWWQ8^! )16! X)*52;! 3PWWP8I!
:5F)*621F!G./.*5!C*,c5+/2,1;^!F*,=/7!*)/5;!+,1;2;/51/!=2/7!/7,;5!*5F2;/5*56!21!/75!*5+51/!C);/!
=5*5!.;56I!!
!
!
!
• ?,42+E!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46^!2/!2;!);;.@56!/7)/!/75!2@C45@51/)/2,1!,G!)@D2/2,.;!)16!
5GG5+/2N5! XYXO5@2;;2,1O*56.+/2,1! C,42+25;! )16! /)*F5/;^! C)*/2+.4)*4E! 21! /75!
/*)1;C,*/)/2,1!;5+/,*^!=244!2162*5+/4E!45)6!/,!)!*)/5!,G!2@C45@51/)/2,1!,G!/545=,*L21F!
/7)/!2;!@)*F21)44E!G);/5*!/7)1!21!)!+)*D,1!=,*46I!!
!
!
!
• B5+7!=,*46f! `1! /72;!=,*46^! 2/!=);!);;.@56! /7)/! )FF*5;;2N5!)16! 5GG5+/2N5! :j>!)16!
@)*L5/21F!;/*)/5F25;!DE!/75!`B!216.;/*E!/)*F5/56!/,!/545=,*L21FO*54)/56!/5+71,4,F25;!
LDV average travel per vehicle (vehicle km per year) - Pretelecommuting
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 17,600 17,600 17,600 17,424 17,072 16,544 16,016 15,488 14,960 14,432 14,080
EU 27 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,375 12,125 11,750 11,375 11,000 10,625 10,250 10,000
Japan 10,000 10,000 10,000 9,900 9,700 9,400 9,100 8,800 8,500 8,200 8,000
SK AU NZ CA 12,500 12,500 12,500 12,375 12,125 11,750 11,375 11,000 10,625 10,250 10,000
FSU 13,000 13,000 13,000 12,870 12,610 12,220 11,830 11,440 11,050 10,660 10,400
Other Europe 11,000 11,000 11,000 10,890 10,670 10,340 10,010 9,680 9,350 9,020 8,800
China 10,000 10,000 10,000 9,900 9,700 9,400 9,100 8,800 8,500 8,200 8,000
Other Asia 10,000 10,000 10,000 9,900 9,700 9,400 9,100 8,800 8,500 8,200 8,000
India 8,000 8,000 8,000 7,920 7,760 7,520 7,280 7,040 6,800 6,560 6,400
Middle East 13,000 13,000 13,000 12,870 12,610 12,220 11,830 11,440 11,050 10,660 10,400
Latin America 12,000 12,000 12,000 11,880 11,640 11,280 10,920 10,560 10,200 9,840 9,600
Africa 10,000 10,000 10,000 9,900 9,700 9,400 9,100 8,800 8,500 8,200 8,000
Telecommuting take up - as % of number of commuters
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 11.0% 17.0% 19.6% 22.2% 24.8% 27.4% 30.0% 32.5% 35.0% 37.5% 40.0%
EU 5.5% 8.0% 11.4% 14.8% 18.2% 21.6% 25.0% 27.5% 30.0% 32.5% 35.0%
Japan 6.5% 12.0% 14.6% 17.2% 19.8% 22.4% 25.0% 28.8% 32.5% 36.3% 40.0%
SK AU NZ CA 6.5% 6.5% 10.2% 13.9% 17.6% 21.3% 25.0% 27.5% 30.0% 32.5% 35.0%
FSU 2.7% 4.0% 6.2% 8.4% 10.6% 12.8% 15.0% 17.5% 20.0% 22.5% 25.0%
Other Europe 2.7% 4.0% 6.2% 8.4% 10.6% 12.8% 15.0% 17.5% 20.0% 22.5% 25.0%
China 2.7% 4.0% 6.2% 8.4% 10.6% 12.8% 15.0% 17.5% 20.0% 22.5% 25.0%
Other Asia 2.7% 4.0% 6.2% 8.4% 10.6% 12.8% 15.0% 17.5% 20.0% 22.5% 25.0%
India 2.7% 4.0% 6.2% 8.4% 10.6% 12.8% 15.0% 17.5% 20.0% 22.5% 25.0%
Middle East 2.7% 4.0% 6.2% 8.4% 10.6% 12.8% 15.0% 17.5% 20.0% 22.5% 25.0%
Latin America 2.7% 4.0% 6.2% 8.4% 10.6% 12.8% 15.0% 17.5% 20.0% 22.5% 25.0%
Africa 2.7% 4.0% 6.2% 8.4% 10.6% 12.8% 15.0% 17.5% 20.0% 22.5% 25.0%
Telecommuting take up - as % of number of commuters
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
USA 11% 17% 20% 23% 26% 29% 33% 36% 39% 42% 45%
EU 5% 8% 12% 16% 20% 24% 29% 33% 37% 41% 45%
Japan 7% 12% 16% 19% 23% 27% 30% 34% 38% 41% 45%
SK AU NZ CA 7% 7% 11% 15% 19% 24% 28% 32% 36% 41% 45%
FSU 3% 4% 7% 10% 13% 16% 18% 21% 24% 27% 30%
Other Europe 3% 4% 7% 10% 13% 16% 18% 21% 24% 27% 30%
China 3% 4% 7% 10% 13% 16% 18% 21% 24% 27% 30%
Other Asia 3% 4% 7% 10% 13% 16% 18% 21% 24% 27% 30%
India 3% 4% 7% 10% 13% 16% 18% 21% 24% 27% 30%
Middle East 3% 4% 7% 10% 13% 16% 18% 21% 24% 27% 30%
Latin America 3% 4% 7% 10% 13% 16% 18% 21% 24% 27% 30%
Africa 3% 4% 7% 10% 13% 16% 18% 21% 24% 27% 30%
!
! \K
)16!;5*N2+5;!=244! 45)6! /,!)! F*5)/5*! )16! G);/5*! )6,C/2,1! ,G! /545=,*L21F!DE!51)D421F!
D5//5*! )16! 655C5*! N2*/.)4! 21/5*)+/2,1;! )@,1F! 5@C4,E55;! 3);! =544! );! D5/=551! /75!
4)//5*!)16!5@C4,E5*;8^!/7.;!D*,)65121F!/75!/EC5!,G!;5+/,*;!)16!C*,G5;;2,1;!21!=72+7!
/545=,*L!+)1!D5!+,16.+/56I!!
!
!
!
• '@)*/!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46^!2/!2;!);;.@56!/7)/!21!)662/2,1!/,!/75!)FF*5;;2N5!:j>!)16!
@)*L5/21F! ;/*)/5F25;! DE! /75! `B! 216.;/*E^! C,42+E! @)L5*;! =,.46! )4;,! )*/2+.4)/5!
)@D2/2,.;! XYXO5@2;;2,1O*56.+/2,1! C,42+25;! /7)/! 45N5*)F5! `BI! B72;! 45)6;! /,! /75!
72F75;/! )6,C/2,1! ,G! /545=,*L21F^! =72+7! =244! D5! C*5G5**56! /,! C7E;2+)4! /*)N54! 3G,*!
+,@@./21F!C.*C,;5;8!DE!)!+,1;265*)D45!)16!F*,=21F!1.@D5*!,G!C5,C45!=,*46=265I!!
!
!
Telecommuting take up - as % of number of commuters
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 11% 17% 22% 27% 31% 36% 41% 46% 50% 55% 60%
EU 5% 8% 14% 20% 25% 31% 37% 43% 48% 54% 60%
Japan 7% 12% 17% 23% 28% 33% 39% 44% 49% 55% 60%
SK AU NZ CA 7% 7% 12% 18% 24% 30% 36% 42% 48% 54% 60%
FSU 3% 4% 8% 12% 16% 20% 24% 28% 32% 36% 40%
Other Europe 3% 4% 8% 12% 16% 20% 24% 28% 32% 36% 40%
China 3% 4% 8% 12% 16% 20% 24% 28% 32% 36% 40%
Other Asia 3% 4% 8% 12% 16% 20% 24% 28% 32% 36% 40%
India 3% 4% 8% 12% 16% 20% 24% 28% 32% 36% 40%
Middle East 3% 4% 8% 12% 16% 20% 24% 28% 32% 36% 40%
Latin America 3% 4% 8% 12% 16% 20% 24% 28% 32% 36% 40%
Africa 3% 4% 8% 12% 16% 20% 24% 28% 32% 36% 40%
Telecommuting take up - as % of number of commuters
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 11% 17% 23% 29% 35% 41% 46% 52% 58% 64% 70%
EU 5% 8% 15% 22% 29% 36% 42% 49% 56% 63% 70%
Japan 7% 12% 18% 25% 31% 38% 44% 51% 57% 64% 70%
SK AU NZ CA 7% 7% 14% 21% 28% 35% 42% 49% 56% 63% 70%
FSU 3% 4% 10% 15% 21% 27% 32% 38% 44% 49% 55%
Other Europe 3% 4% 10% 15% 21% 27% 32% 38% 44% 49% 55%
China 3% 4% 10% 15% 21% 27% 32% 38% 44% 49% 55%
Other Asia 3% 4% 10% 15% 21% 27% 32% 38% 44% 49% 55%
India 3% 4% 10% 15% 21% 27% 32% 38% 44% 49% 55%
Middle East 3% 4% 10% 15% 21% 27% 32% 38% 44% 49% 55%
Latin America 3% 4% 10% 15% 21% 27% 32% 38% 44% 49% 55%
Africa 3% 4% 10% 15% 21% 27% 32% 38% 44% 49% 55%
!
! \P
• !20&1A0(#0407%&M+,A(-1.'(C0&(700M(
• #)*D,1! =,*46f! %2F.*5;! ,1! /75! )N5*)F5! /545=,*L21F! 6)E;! C5*! =55L! 21! /75! N)*2,.;!
*5F2,1;!)16!+,.1/*25;! 21+4.656! 21! /72;! ;/.6E!=5*5! /)L51! G*,@!3,*!+)4+.4)/56!D);56!
,18! /75! G,44,=21F! ;,.*+5;f! <,*46)/<,*L! 3PWWZ8^! X)*/15*! 3PWWQ8^! b[! $GG2+5! G,*!
A)/2,1)4! '/)/2;/2+;! 3PWWQ8^! )16! X)*52;! 3PWWP8I! :5F)*621F! G./.*5! C*,c5+/2,1;^! )! F*,=/7! *)/5!
;2@24)*!/,!/7)/!@5);.*56!21!/75!C);/!G5=!E5)*;!G,*!/75!1.@D5*!,G!6)E;!/545=,*L56!C5*!=55L!
3DE!/545=,*L5*;8!=);!)CC4256I!!
!
!
!
• ?,42+E!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46^!2/!2;!);;.@56!/7)/!/75!2@C45@51/)/2,1!,G!)@D2/2,.;!)16!
5GG5+/2N5! XYXO5@2;;2,1O*56.+/2,1! C,42+25;! )16! /)*F5/;^! C)*/2+.4)*4E! 21! /75!
/*)1;C,*/)/2,1!;5+/,*^!=244!2162*5+/4E!45)6!/,!)!@,*5!G*5].51/!.;5!,G!/545=,*L21F!3DE!
+.**51/!/545=,*L5*;8I!!
!
!
!
• B5+7! =,*46f! `1! /72;! =,*46^! 2/! 2;! );;.@56! /7)/! )FF*5;;2N5! )16! 5GG5+/2N5! :j>! )16!
@)*L5/21F!;/*)/5F25;!DE!/75!`B!216.;/*E!/)*F5/56!/,!/545=,*L21FO*54)/56!/5+71,4,F25;!
)16! ;5*N2+5;! =244! 21+*5);5! /75! G*5].51+E! ,G! /545=,*L21F! DE! 51)D421F! D5//5*! )16!
655C5*! N2*/.)4! 21/5*)+/2,1;! )@,1F! 5@C4,E55;! 3);! =544! );! D5/=551! /75! 4)//5*! )16!
5@C4,E5*;8^! /7.;! D*,)65121F! /75! /EC5! ,G! )+/2N2/25;! /7)/! @)E! D5! +)**256! ,./! G*,@!
*5@,/5!4,+)/2,1;!N2)!/545=,*L21FI!!
Average telecommuting days per week
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 2.50 2.70 2.73 2.76 2.78 2.81 2.84 2.87 2.89 2.92 2.95
EU 0.90 1.00 1.14 1.29 1.43 1.58 1.72 1.87 2.01 2.16 2.30
Japan 1.80 2.20 2.24 2.29 2.33 2.38 2.42 2.47 2.51 2.56 2.60
SK AU NZ CA 0.90 1.00 1.17 1.33 1.50 1.67 1.83 2.00 2.17 2.33 2.50
FSU 0.90 1.00 1.14 1.29 1.43 1.58 1.72 1.87 2.01 2.16 2.30
Other Europe 0.90 1.00 1.14 1.29 1.43 1.58 1.72 1.87 2.01 2.16 2.30
China 0.90 1.00 1.14 1.29 1.43 1.58 1.72 1.87 2.01 2.16 2.30
Other Asia 0.90 1.00 1.14 1.29 1.43 1.58 1.72 1.87 2.01 2.16 2.30
India 0.90 1.00 1.14 1.29 1.43 1.58 1.72 1.87 2.01 2.16 2.30
Middle East 0.90 1.00 1.14 1.29 1.43 1.58 1.72 1.87 2.01 2.16 2.30
Latin America 0.90 1.00 1.14 1.29 1.43 1.58 1.72 1.87 2.01 2.16 2.30
Africa 0.90 1.00 1.14 1.29 1.43 1.58 1.72 1.87 2.01 2.16 2.30
Average telecommuting days per week 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.5
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
USA 2.50 2.70 2.74 2.79 2.83 2.88 2.92 2.97 3.01 3.06 3.10
EU 0.90 1.00 1.20 1.40 1.60 1.80 2.00 2.20 2.40 2.60 2.80
Japan 1.80 2.20 2.27 2.33 2.40 2.47 2.53 2.60 2.67 2.73 2.80
SK AU NZ CA 1.00 1.00 1.19 1.38 1.57 1.76 1.94 2.13 2.32 2.51 2.70
FSU 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.30 1.45 1.60 1.75 1.90 2.05 2.20 2.35
Other Europe 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.30 1.45 1.60 1.75 1.90 2.05 2.20 2.35
China 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.30 1.45 1.60 1.75 1.90 2.05 2.20 2.35
Other Asia 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.30 1.45 1.60 1.75 1.90 2.05 2.20 2.35
India 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.30 1.45 1.60 1.75 1.90 2.05 2.20 2.35
Middle East 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.30 1.45 1.60 1.75 1.90 2.05 2.20 2.35
Latin America 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.30 1.45 1.60 1.75 1.90 2.05 2.20 2.35
Africa 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.30 1.45 1.60 1.75 1.90 2.05 2.20 2.35
!
! \R
!
!
• '@)*/! =,*46f! `1! /72;! =,*46^! 2/! 2;! );;.@56! /7)/! /75! +,@D2156! 5GG5+/! ,G! )@D2/2,.;!
XYXO5@2;;2,1O*56.+/2,1! C,42+25;! )16! )FF*5;;2N5! :j>! )16!@)*L5/21F! ;/*)/5F25;! DE!
/75! `B! 216.;/*E! =244! 45)6! /,! /75! 72F75;/! .;5gG*5].51+E! ,G! /545=,*L21F^! =72+7! =244!
*5C4)+5!C7E;2+)4!/*)N54!DE!+,@@./5*;!21!)!+,1;265*)D45!)16!F*,=21F!1.@D5*!,G!6)E;I!
!
!
!
!
• T+&05#(&0/%",-(0==05#(I-&+20,(/.(1--+#+%,14(#+60(121+41/+4+#.JO(+,5&01'0-(
M+4%60#0&'(#&12040-(/.(#0405%66"#0&'(=%&(5$%&0'(%&(40+'"&0(
(
• #)*D,1!=,*46f!9;;.@C/2,1;!,1!/72;!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!)*5!D);56!,1!/75!*5N25=!,G!,N5*!RW!
;/.625;! .165*/)L51!DE! '/5N51! ',**544! b[":#! 3PWWZ8I! `1! )! +)*D,1!=,*46! /72;! *5D,.16!
5GG5+/!2;!);;.@56!/,!*5@)21!+,1;/)1/!,N5*!/2@5I!
!
!
!
• ?,42+E!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46^!2/!2;!);;.@56!/7)/!/75!2@C45@51/)/2,1!,G!)@D2/2,.;!)16!
5GG5+/2N5! XYXO5@2;;2,1O*56.+/2,1! C,42+25;! )16! /)*F5/;^! C)*/2+.4)*4E! 21! /75!
/*)1;C,*/)/2,1! ;5+/,*^! =244! 2162*5+/4E! 45)6! /,! G5=5*! L24,@5/5*;! /*)N5456! DE!
/545+,@@./5*;!G,*!452;.*5!)16!+7,*5;I!
Average telecommuting days per week 0% 2% 5% 8% 11% 14% 16% 18% 20%
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 2.50 2.70 2.74 2.84 2.98 3.11 3.24 3.38 3.49 3.61 3.72
EU 0.90 1.00 1.20 1.43 1.68 1.94 2.22 2.51 2.78 3.07 3.36
Japan 1.80 2.20 2.27 2.38 2.52 2.66 2.81 2.96 3.09 3.23 3.36
SK AU NZ CA 1.00 1.00 1.19 1.41 1.65 1.90 2.16 2.43 2.69 2.96 3.24
FSU 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.33 1.52 1.73 1.94 2.17 2.38 2.60 2.82
Other Europe 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.33 1.52 1.73 1.94 2.17 2.38 2.60 2.82
China 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.33 1.52 1.73 1.94 2.17 2.38 2.60 2.82
Other Asia 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.33 1.52 1.73 1.94 2.17 2.38 2.60 2.82
India 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.33 1.52 1.73 1.94 2.17 2.38 2.60 2.82
Middle East 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.33 1.52 1.73 1.94 2.17 2.38 2.60 2.82
Latin America 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.33 1.52 1.73 1.94 2.17 2.38 2.60 2.82
Africa 0.90 1.00 1.15 1.33 1.52 1.73 1.94 2.17 2.38 2.60 2.82
Average telecommuting days per week
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 2.50 2.70 2.86 3.02 3.18 3.34 3.50 3.68 3.85 4.03 4.20
EU 0.90 1.00 1.39 1.78 2.17 2.56 2.95 3.26 3.58 3.89 4.20
Japan 1.80 2.20 2.42 2.64 2.86 3.08 3.30 3.53 3.75 3.98 4.20
SK AU NZ CA 1.00 1.00 1.38 1.77 2.15 2.54 2.92 3.07 3.21 3.36 3.50
FSU 0.90 1.00 1.30 1.60 1.90 2.20 2.50 2.75 3.00 3.25 3.50
Other Europe 0.90 1.00 1.30 1.60 1.90 2.20 2.50 2.75 3.00 3.25 3.50
China 0.90 1.00 1.30 1.60 1.90 2.20 2.50 2.75 3.00 3.25 3.50
Other Asia 0.90 1.00 1.30 1.60 1.90 2.20 2.50 2.75 3.00 3.25 3.50
India 0.90 1.00 1.30 1.60 1.90 2.20 2.50 2.75 3.00 3.25 3.50
Middle East 0.90 1.00 1.30 1.60 1.90 2.20 2.50 2.75 3.00 3.25 3.50
Latin America 0.90 1.00 1.30 1.60 1.90 2.20 2.50 2.75 3.00 3.25 3.50
Africa 0.90 1.00 1.30 1.60 1.90 2.20 2.50 2.75 3.00 3.25 3.50
Direct rebound effect - increased km travelled by telecommuters working from home as % of km saved by telecommuting
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
EU 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
Japan 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
SK AU NZ CA 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
FSU 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
Other Europe 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
China 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
Other Asia 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
India 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
Middle East 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
Latin America 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
Africa 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%
!
! \J
!
!
!
• B5+7!=,*46f!')@5!);!21!+)*D,1!=,*46I!!
!
• '@)*/!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46^!2/!2;!);;.@56!/7)/!/75!2@C45@51/)/2,1!,G!`B!;,4./2,1;!21!
)!G*)@5=,*L!/7)/!C.*;.5;!XYX!5@2;;2,1!*56.+/2,1;^!+,@D2156!=2/7!)@D2/2,.;!XYXO
5@2;;2,1O*56.+/2,1!C,42+25;^!=244!45)6!/,!/75!15./*)420)/2,1!,G!/72;!*5D,.16!5GG5+/I!
!
!
!
!
• ),-+&05#(&0/%",-(0==05#(I-&+20,(/.(+,5%60(121+41/+4+#.JO(+6C15#(%,(BKB(%=(
6%,0.('120-(/.(#0405%66"#+,A(
(
B75!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!);;,+2)/56!=2/7!/75!5SC5162/.*5;!,G!/75!5+,1,@2+!;)N21F;!@)65!)N)24)D45!
DE! /545=,*L21F! =);! .;56! );! )! C*,SE! G,*! ;5N5*)4! 2162*5+/! 5GG5+/;! /7)/! @)E! *5;.4/! G*,@!
/545=,*L21F!3)16!62;+.;;56!21!;5+/2,1!KIJ8I!!
!
• #)*D,1!=,*46f!')N21F;!G*,@!/545+,@@./21F!35IFI^!65*2N21F! G*,@!G5=5*! G.54!C.*+7);5;8!
)*5!);;.@56!/,!D5!;C51/!21!F,,6;!,*!;5*N2+5;!/7)/!F515*)/5!5@2;;2,1;!C*,C,*/2,1)/5!/,!
/75!XYX! 21/51;2/E! 3XYX!5@2;;2,1;gX>?8! ,G! 2162N26.)4! *5F2,1;I!"@2;;2,1;!C5*!X>?!)*5!
);;.@56!/,!65+4215!;/5)624E!,N5*!/2@5I!
Direct rebound effect - increased km travelled by telecommuters working from home as % of km saved by telecommuting
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050
USA 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
EU 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
Japan 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
SK AU NZ CA 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
FSU 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
Other Europe 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
China 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
Other Asia 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
India 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
Middle East 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
Latin America 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
Africa 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15%
Direct rebound effect - increased km travelled by telecommuters working from home as % of km saved by telecommuting
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
EU 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Japan 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
SK AU NZ CA 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
FSU 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Other Europe 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
China 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Other Asia 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
India 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Middle East 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Latin America 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Africa 25% 25% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 0% 0% 0%
!
! \Q
!
!
• ?,42+E!=,*46f!9;! 21!)!+)*D,1!=,*46^! 2/! 2;!);;.@56!/7)/!;)N21F;!G*,@!/545+,@@./21F!
)*5! ;C51/! ,1!F,,6;! ,*! ;5*N2+5;! /7)/! F515*)/5! 5@2;;2,1;! 21! C*,C,*/2,1! /,! /75!XYX!
21/51;2/E!3XYX!5@2;;2,1;gX>?8!,G!2162N26.)4!*5F2,1;I!`1!)!C,42+E!=,*46^!7,=5N5*^!2/!2;!
);;.@56!/7)/!5GG5+/2N5!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!C,42+25;!=244!45)6!/,!)1!,N5*)44!65+*5);5!21!/75!
+)*D,1!21/51;2/E!,G!*5F2,1)4!5+,1,@25;I!
!
!
!
• B5+7!=,*46f!')@5!);!21!+)*D,1!=,*46I!!
!
• '@)*/!=,*46f! `1! /72;! =,*46^! 2/! 2;! );;.@56! /7)/! /75! `B! 216.;/*E! )16! C,42+E!@)L5*;!
)*/2+.4)/5!C,42+25;!)16!;/*)/5F25;!/7)/!51)D45!/75!+*5)/2,1!,G!N2*/.,.;!+E+45;!21!=72+7!
/75! )662/2,1)4! *5;,.*+5;! F515*)/56! DE! 212/2)4! 5@2;;2,1! *56.+/2,1;! )*5! 65C4,E56! 21!
=)E;!/7)/!)+725N5!G.*/75*!*56.+/2,1;!21!5@2;;2,1;I!
!
!
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 0.64 0.64 0.64 0.62 0.60 0.58 0.56 0.54 0.52 0.50 0.48
EU 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.37 0.36 0.35 0.34 0.33 0.32 0.31 0.30
Japan 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.37 0.36 0.35 0.34 0.33 0.32 0.31 0.30
SK AU NZ CA 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.37 0.36 0.35 0.34 0.33 0.32 0.31 0.30
FSU 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.37 0.36 0.35 0.34 0.33 0.32 0.31 0.30
Other Europe 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.37 0.36 0.35 0.34 0.33 0.32 0.31 0.30
China 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.85 0.80 0.75 0.70 0.65 0.60 0.55
Other Asia 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.88 0.86 0.84 0.82 0.80
India 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.85 0.80 0.75 0.70 0.65 0.60 0.55
Middle East 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.90 0.88 0.86 0.84 0.82 0.80
Latin America 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.58 0.56 0.54 0.52 0.50
Africa 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.60 0.58 0.56 0.54 0.52 0.50
simple average 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59
Indirect rebound effect - kg CO2 emissions associated to each US $ saved by telecommuters (and spent in other goods and services
causing CO2 emissions)
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 0.64 0.64 0.62 0.57 0.49 0.41 0.34 0.27 0.21 0.15 0.10
EU 0.39 0.39 0.37 0.34 0.30 0.25 0.20 0.17 0.13 0.09 0.06
Japan 0.39 0.39 0.37 0.34 0.30 0.25 0.20 0.17 0.13 0.09 0.06
SK AU NZ CA 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.35 0.31 0.27 0.24 0.20 0.17 0.14 0.11
FSU 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.35 0.31 0.27 0.24 0.20 0.17 0.14 0.11
Other Europe 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.35 0.31 0.27 0.24 0.20 0.17 0.14 0.11
China 0.90 0.90 0.89 0.85 0.73 0.62 0.53 0.43 0.35 0.28 0.21
Other Asia 0.90 0.90 0.89 0.85 0.77 0.70 0.62 0.53 0.45 0.38 0.30
India 0.90 0.90 0.89 0.85 0.73 0.62 0.53 0.43 0.35 0.28 0.21
Middle East 0.90 0.90 0.89 0.85 0.77 0.70 0.62 0.53 0.45 0.38 0.30
Latin America 0.60 0.60 0.59 0.56 0.52 0.47 0.41 0.35 0.29 0.24 0.19
Africa 0.60 0.60 0.59 0.56 0.52 0.47 0.41 0.35 0.29 0.24 0.19
simple average 0.59 0.59 0.58 0.55 0.50 0.46 0.41 0.36 0.32 0.27 0.22
Indirect rebound effect - kg CO2 emissions associated to each US $ saved by telecommuters (and spent in other goods and services
causing CO2 emissions)
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 0.64 0.64 0.62 0.30 0.20 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
EU 0.39 0.39 0.37 0.20 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
Japan 0.39 0.39 0.37 0.30 0.20 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
SK AU NZ CA 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.30 0.20 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
FSU 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.35 0.31 0.20 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
Other Europe 0.39 0.39 0.38 0.35 0.31 0.20 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
China 0.90 0.90 0.89 0.85 0.60 0.40 0.20 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
Other Asia 0.90 0.90 0.89 0.85 0.60 0.40 0.20 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
India 0.90 0.90 0.89 0.85 0.60 0.40 0.20 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
Middle East 0.90 0.90 0.89 0.85 0.60 0.30 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
Latin America 0.60 0.60 0.59 0.56 0.30 0.20 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
Africa 0.60 0.60 0.59 0.56 0.30 0.20 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
simple average 0.59 0.59 0.58 0.55 0.30 0.20 0.10 - (0.10) (0.10) (0.10)
Indirect rebound effect - kg CO2 emissions associated to each US $ saved by telecommuters (and spent in other goods and services
causing CO2 emissions)
!
! \\
6.2 Virtual meetings
(
• *%#14(/"'+,0''(#&1204O(C1''0,A0&LM+4%60#0&'((
A,! ;/)/2;/2+)4! 6)/)! =5*5! G,.16! ,1! D.;215;;! /*)N54! C);;51F5*OL24,@5/5*;I! B72;! 6)/)! =);!
/75*5G,*5! 5;/2@)/56! .;21F! /,/)4! C);;51F5*OL24,@5/5*! 6)/)! )16! )1! "+,GE;! );;.@C/2,1! ,1! /75!
C5*+51/)F5!,G!D.;215;;!)2*!/*)N54!*54)/2N5!/,!/,/)4!)2*!/*)N54I!Y2;/,*2+)4!6)/)!)16!C*,c5+/2,1;!,1!
/,/)4!C);;51F5*OL24,@5/5*;!,G!/*)N54!=5*5!/)L51!G*,@!3,*!+)4+.4)/56!D);56!,18!G2F.*5;!G*,@!/75!
`1/5*1)/2,1)4! #2N24! 9N2)/2,1! $*F)120)/2,1! 3`#9$8! )16^! G,*! ".*,C5)1! +,.1/*25;^! G*,@! /75!
".*,C5)1!"1N2*,1@51/!9F51+E!3""98I!B75;5!6)/)!)16!C*,c5+/2,1;!=5*5!.;56!G,*!)44!=,*46;I!!
!
!
!
!
Total passenger-km of travel (bil)
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 885 1,040 1,219 1,376 1,545 1,724 1,949 2,149 2,357 2,576 2,803
EU 980 1,188 1,400 1,610 1,771 1,985 2,125 2,259 2,390 2,569 2,695
Japan 253 280 356 403 433 483 520 557 594 644 681
SK AU NZ CA 240 284 346 398 443 499 553 605 659 723 782
FSU 63 78 94 118 147 177 210 253 304 366 441
Other Europe 52 70 95 127 170 205 248 292 339 388 438
China 141 197 266 422 721 1,027 1,481 1,922 2,363 2,801 3,239
Other Asia 197 248 316 398 493 604 734 895 1,087 1,316 1,591
India 50 66 89 118 152 193 244 304 378 469 583
Middle East 102 121 144 172 209 251 295 340 390 444 502
Latin America 281 337 430 546 690 869 1,095 1,368 1,706 2,125 2,643
Africa 77 98 126 161 204 256 319 392 478 580 698
business travel as % of total passenger-km travel
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 18% 17% 17% 17% 16% 16% 16% 16% 15% 15% 15%
EU 32% 32% 30% 28% 27% 25% 23% 22% 20% 18% 17%
Japan 26% 26% 25% 24% 23% 22% 20% 19% 18% 17% 16%
SK AU NZ CA 26% 26% 25% 24% 23% 22% 20% 19% 18% 17% 16%
FSU 40% 40% 38% 37% 35% 33% 32% 30% 28% 27% 25%
Other Europe 40% 40% 38% 37% 35% 33% 32% 30% 28% 27% 25%
China 57% 50% 47% 45% 43% 41% 39% 37% 34% 32% 30%
Other Asia 57% 50% 47% 45% 43% 41% 39% 37% 34% 32% 30%
India 57% 50% 47% 45% 43% 41% 39% 37% 34% 32% 30%
Middle East 57% 50% 47% 45% 43% 41% 39% 37% 34% 32% 30%
Latin America 57% 50% 47% 45% 43% 41% 39% 37% 34% 32% 30%
Africa 57% 50% 47% 45% 43% 41% 39% 37% 34% 32% 30%
!
! \Z
• f"'+,0''(#&1204(12%+-0-(7+#$(2+&#"14(600#+,A'(1'(1(C0&50,#1A0(%=(#%#14(
• #)*D,1!=,*46f!%2F.*5;!,1!/75!)6,C/2,1!,G!/545+,1G5*51+21F!=5*5!D);56!,1!)15+6,/)4!
5N2651+5!)16!,++);2,1)4!;.*N5E;! 21+4.656! 21!)!1.@D5*!,G!;/.625;^! 21+4.621F!-)*+4)E!
+)*6!-.;215;;!)16!%./.*5!%,.16)/2,1!3PWWZ8^!9*1G)4L!3PWWP8^!)16!:,E!)16!%242;/*).4/!3KVVT8I!!
!
!
!
• ?,42+E!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46^! 2/! 2;!);;.@56!/7)/! /75!)6,C/2,1!)16! 2@C45@51/)/2,1!,G!
)@D2/2,.;! )16! 5GG5+/2N5! XYXO5@2;;2,1O*56.+/2,1! C,42+25;! M! 5;C5+2)44E! 21! /75!
/*)1;C,*/)/2,1!;5+/,*!3;.+7!);!/75!C*,C,;56!+)C!,1!XYX!5@2;;2,1;!G*,@!)N2)/2,1!21!
/75!"b8!=244!2162*5+/4E!45)6!/,!)!72F75*!)6,C/2,1!,G!/545+,1G5*51+21F!/7)1!21!)!+)*D,1!
=,*46I!
!
!
!
• B5+7! =,*46f! `1! /72;! =,*46^! 2/! 2;! );;.@56! /7)/! )FF*5;;2N5! )16! 5GG5+/2N5! :j>! )16!
@)*L5/21F! ;/*)/5F25;! DE! /75! `B! 216.;/*E! /)*F5/56! /,! /545+,1G5*51+21FO*54)/56!
/5+71,4,F25;!)16!;5*N2+5;! 3C)*/2+.4)*4E! N265,+,1G5*51+21F8!=244! 45)6! /,! )! ;2F12G2+)1/!
)16! F*,=21F! .;5! ,G! /545+,1G5*51+21F! DE! 51)D421F! @,*5! *542)D45^! 21/5*)+/2N5^! )16!
@5)121FG.4!+,@@.12+)/2,1;!D5/=551!C5,C45!N2)!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;I!B72;!=,.46!45)6!/,!
)1! 21+*5);5! 21! /75! 1.@D5*! )16! /75! /EC5! ,G! @55/21F;! /7)/! +,.46! D5! 7546! N2)!
/545+,1G5*51+21FI!
!
!
business travel avoided with virtual meetings % of total 0.5 0.7 1 1.2 1.25 1 1 0.95 1
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 4% 8% 9% 12% 16% 21% 27% 30% 33% 34% 35%
EU 3% 5% 6% 9% 13% 17% 22% 25% 28% 29% 30%
Japan 3% 6% 7% 10% 13% 18% 22% 25% 28% 29% 30%
SK AU NZ CA 3% 6% 7% 10% 13% 18% 22% 25% 28% 29% 30%
FSU 1% 1% 3% 6% 9% 13% 17% 20% 22% 24% 25%
Other Europe 1% 1% 3% 5% 8% 12% 17% 20% 23% 24% 25%
China 1% 1% 3% 5% 8% 12% 17% 20% 23% 24% 25%
Other Asia 1% 1% 3% 5% 8% 12% 17% 20% 23% 24% 25%
India 1% 1% 3% 5% 8% 12% 17% 20% 23% 24% 25%
Middle East 1% 1% 3% 5% 8% 12% 17% 20% 23% 24% 25%
Latin America 1% 1% 3% 5% 8% 12% 17% 20% 23% 24% 25%
Africa 1% 1% 3% 5% 8% 12% 17% 20% 23% 24% 25%
business travel avoided with virtual meetings % of total
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 4% 8% 9% 13% 18% 24% 30% 34% 37% 39% 40%
EU 3% 5% 7% 11% 16% 22% 29% 33% 37% 38% 40%
Japan 3% 6% 8% 12% 17% 23% 29% 33% 37% 39% 40%
SK AU NZ CA 3% 6% 7% 11% 15% 20% 26% 29% 32% 34% 35%
FSU 1% 1% 2% 4% 7% 12% 19% 23% 26% 28% 30%
Other Europe 1% 1% 2% 4% 7% 12% 19% 23% 26% 28% 30%
China 1% 1% 2% 4% 7% 12% 19% 23% 26% 28% 30%
Other Asia 1% 1% 2% 4% 7% 12% 19% 23% 26% 28% 30%
India 1% 1% 2% 4% 7% 12% 19% 23% 26% 28% 30%
Middle East 1% 1% 2% 4% 7% 12% 19% 23% 26% 28% 30%
Latin America 1% 1% 2% 4% 7% 12% 19% 23% 26% 28% 30%
Africa 1% 1% 2% 4% 7% 12% 19% 23% 26% 28% 30%
business travel avoided with virtual meetings % of total
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 4% 8% 11% 20% 31% 44% 50% 55% 57% 60% 60%
EU 3% 5% 8% 17% 27% 39% 44% 49% 52% 54% 55%
Japan 3% 6% 10% 19% 30% 43% 49% 54% 57% 60% 60%
SK AU NZ CA 3% 6% 9% 18% 28% 40% 45% 49% 52% 55% 55%
FSU 1% 1% 3% 5% 9% 16% 24% 29% 34% 38% 40%
Other Europe 1% 1% 3% 5% 9% 16% 24% 29% 34% 38% 40%
China 1% 1% 3% 5% 9% 16% 24% 29% 34% 38% 40%
Other Asia 1% 1% 3% 5% 9% 16% 24% 29% 34% 38% 40%
India 1% 1% 3% 5% 9% 16% 24% 29% 34% 38% 40%
Middle East 1% 1% 3% 5% 9% 16% 24% 29% 34% 38% 40%
Latin America 1% 1% 3% 5% 9% 16% 24% 29% 34% 38% 40%
Africa 1% 1% 3% 5% 9% 16% 24% 29% 34% 38% 40%
!
! \T
• '@)*/!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46^!2/!2;!);;.@56!/7)/!/75!+,@D2156!5GG5+/;!,G!/75!;.CC,*/2N5!
C,42+E!51N2*,1@51/!62;+.;;56!21!/75!C,42+E!=,*46!)16!,G!/75!C*,)+/2N5!)16!5GG5+/2N5!
`B! 216.;/*E! 21! /75! /5+7! =,*46! =244! 45)6! /,! )! =265;C*5)6! )16! F*,=21F! .;5! ,G!
/545+,1G5*51+21F!);!)1!)4/5*1)/2N5!/,!C7E;2+)4!/*)N54I!!
!
!
(
• !--+#+%,14(0405#&+5+#.("'0-(C0&($%"&(%=(2+&#"14(600#+,A(IMZ$J(
• #)*D,1! =,*46f! `1! /72;! =,*46! 2/! 2;! );;.@56! /7)/! )N5*)F5! 545+/*2+2/E! .;5! =,.46! D5!
5].2N)451/! /,! /75! 545+/*2+2/E! .;56! DE! )! 72F7O516! ;,4./2,1^! ;,! /75! Y?! Y)4,!
/545C*5;51+5!;,4./2,1!=);!/)L51!);!D51+7@)*L!3;55!Y?^!PWWT8I!
!
!
!
• ?,42+E!=,*46f!"GG5+/2N5!+42@)/5!+7)1F5!C,42+E!2;!);;.@56!/,!6*2N5!)!*56.+/2,1!21!/75!
)N5*)F5!545+/*2+2/E!.;56!DE!N2*/.)4O@55/21F!;,4./2,1;I!
!
!
!
business travel avoided with virtual meetings % of total
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 4% 8% 14% 25% 39% 53% 66% 78% 83% 88% 90%
EU 3% 5% 12% 23% 37% 52% 64% 77% 82% 87% 90%
Japan 3% 6% 12% 24% 38% 52% 65% 78% 83% 87% 90%
SK AU NZ CA 3% 6% 12% 24% 38% 52% 65% 78% 83% 87% 90%
FSU 1% 1% 4% 8% 15% 26% 37% 46% 53% 60% 65%
Other Europe 1% 1% 4% 8% 15% 26% 37% 46% 53% 60% 65%
China 1% 1% 4% 8% 15% 26% 37% 46% 53% 60% 65%
Other Asia 1% 1% 4% 8% 15% 26% 37% 46% 53% 60% 65%
India 1% 1% 4% 8% 15% 26% 37% 46% 53% 60% 65%
Middle East 1% 1% 4% 8% 15% 26% 37% 46% 53% 60% 65%
Latin America 1% 1% 4% 8% 15% 26% 37% 46% 53% 60% 65%
Africa 1% 1% 4% 8% 15% 26% 37% 46% 53% 60% 65%
Additional electricity used per hour of virtual meeting (kWh)
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
EU 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
Japan 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
SK AU NZ CA 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
FSU 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
Other Europe 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
China 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
Other Asia 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
India 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
Middle East 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
Latin America 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
Africa 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.43
Additional electricity used per hour of virtual meeting (kWh) -5.0% -10.0% -15.0% -20.0% -25.0% -30.0% -35.0% -40.0%
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
EU 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
Japan 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
SK AU NZ CA 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
FSU 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
Other Europe 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
China 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
Other Asia 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
India 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
Middle East 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
Latin America 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
Africa 2.43 2.43 2.43 2.31 2.19 2.07 1.94 1.82 1.70 1.58 1.46
!
! \V
• B5+7! =,*46f! `1! /72;! =,*46! 2/! 2;! );;.@56! /7)/! /75! `B! 216.;/*E! )+725N5;! ;2F12G2+)1/!
2@C*,N5@51/;!21!/5*@;!,G!545+/*2+2/E!155656!/,!6542N5*!N2*/.)4O@55/21F!;,4./2,1;I!
!
!
!
• '@)*/!=,*46f!`1!/72;!=,*46!)1!5N51!G);/5*! 21+*5);5!21!515*FE!5GG2+251+E!2;!)+725N56!
G,*! N2*/.)4O@55/21F! /5+71,4,F25;! /7)1L;! /,! /75! +,@D2156! 5GG,*/! ,G! /75! `B! 216.;/*E^!
C,42+E!@)L5*;^!)16!516!.;5*;I!
!
!
(
• T+&05#(1,-(+,-+&05#(&0/%",-(0==05#'(
%,*!N2*/.)4!@55/21F;^!/75!);;.@C/2,1;!@)65!G,*!62*5+/!)16!2162*5+/!*5D,.16!5GG5+/;!=5*5!21!4215!
=2/7!/75!);;.@C/2,1;!@)65!G,*!/545=,*L21FI!!
!
Additional electricity used per hour of virtual meeting (kWh)
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
EU 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
Japan 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
SK AU NZ CA 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
FSU 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
Other Europe 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
China 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
Other Asia 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
India 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
Middle East 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
Latin America 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
Africa 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.46 1.09 0.85 0.68 0.58 0.51 0.49
Additional electricity used per hour of virtual meeting (kWh)
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050USA 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
EU 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
Japan 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
SK AU NZ CA 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
FSU 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
Other Europe 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
China 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
Other Asia 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
India 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
Middle East 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
Latin America 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
Africa 2.43 2.43 2.43 1.94 1.22 0.73 0.49 0.34 0.24 0.17 0.12
!
! ZW
7 Appendix 2: Summary data for EU countries (
*0407%&M+,A(`(9<E(06+''+%,'(=%&(5%66"#+,A(C&0L#0407%&M+,A(
(
! !
! !
!
CO2 emissions Pre-teleworking
Carbon world
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions Pre-teleworking
Policy world
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
20
05
20
10
20
15
20
20
20
25
20
30
20
35
20
40
20
45
20
50
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions Pre-teleworking
Tech world
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MrC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions Pre-teleworking
Smart World
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
20
05
20
10
20
15
20
20
20
25
20
30
20
35
20
40
20
45
20
50
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
!
! ZK
*0407%&M+,A(`(9<E(06+''+%,'(=%&(5%66"#+,A(7+#$(#0407%&M+,AO(+,54"-+,A(&0/%",-(0==05#'(
(
! !
! !
Commuting CO2 emissions including impact
of teleworking and rebound effects
Carbon World
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
Rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions from commuting net of
teleworking and rebound effects
Policy world
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
20
05
20
10
20
15
20
20
20
25
20
30
20
35
20
40
20
45
20
50
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
Rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions from commuting considering
impact of teleworking and rebound effects
Tech World
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
Rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions from commuting considering
teleworking and rebound effects
Smart world
-
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
Rest of EU 27
!
! ZP
g+&#"14(600#+,A'(`(/"'+,0''(1+&L#&1204(06+''+%,'O(C&0`2+&#"14(600#+,A'(
(
( (
( (
!
CO2 emissions from business air travel
pre-virtual meetings
Carbon World
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
2000
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions business travel
pre-virtual meetings
Policy World
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
2000
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions for business air travel
pre-virtual meetings
Tech World
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
2000
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
Business travel CO2 emissions
pre virtual meetings
Smart World
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MrC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
!
! ZR
g+&#"14(600#+,A'(`(/"'+,0''(1+&L#&1204(06+''+%,'(7+#$(2+&#"14(600#+,A'O(5%,'+-0&+,A(06+''+%,'(
-0&+2+,A(=&%6(0405#&+5+#.("'0(1,-(&0/%",-(0==05#'(
(
( (
( (
(
! !
CO2 emissions business air travel net of virtual
meetings and rebound effects
Carbon world
-
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
2000
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions business air travel net of
virtual meetings and rebound effects
Policy world
-
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions business air travel net of
virtual meetings and rebound effects
Tech World
-
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
CO2 emissions business air travel net of
virtual meetings and rebound effects
Smart world
-
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
2005
2010
2015
2020
2025
2030
2035
2040
2045
2050
MtC
O2
France
Germany
Italy
Netherlands
Spain
UK
Rest of EU 15
rest of EU 27
!
! ZJ
8 Appendix 3: Unemployed people interested in teleworking !
!*1/40(:D(H,06C4%.0-(C0%C40(+,#0&0'#0-(+,(#0407%&M+,AO('%"&50D(B1&0+'(IEUUEJ;(
!
!
! !
!
! ZQ
9 Bibliographic references !!
959^!PWWZI!k,71!9I!t'L2Ch!_)2/15*!)16![)*51!"7*7)*6O()*/2150I!96N)1+56!"45+/*,12+;!)16!`1G,*@)/2,1!B5+71,4,F25;f!B75!`11,N)/2,1O_56!#42@)/5!#7)1F5!',4./2,1I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I)5)15/I,*Fg)5)+,.1+24;g959".*,C5u"15*FEu"GG2+251+Eu:5C,*/uKZ'5CWZIC6GI!!
945S!"N)1;!)16!>)N26!'/5N51^!PWWZI!#42@)/5!+7)1F5f!/75!;/)/5!,G!/75!65D)/5^!#51/*5!,1!`1/5*1)/2,1)4!#,,C5*)/2,1^!B75!_,16,1!9++,*6!#$PI!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I4,16,1O)++,*6I+,I.LgG21)4u*5C,*/g*5C,*/;gC6GgDKIC6GI!!
9BjB^!PWWPI!:,D5*/!9/LE1;!5/!)4I!(5);.*5@51/!,G!51N2*,1@51/)4!2@C)+/!,G!/545=,*L!)6,C/2,1!)@26;/!+7)1F5!21!+,@C45S!,*F)120)/2,1;f!9BjB!;.*N5E!@5/7,6,4,FE!)16!*5;.4/;!21!*5;,.*+5;^!+,1;5*N)/2,1^!)16!*5+E+421FI!R\!3PWWP8!P\ZMPTQI!
9*1G)4L^!?I!PWWPI!-(&./0#,E%7(#(.>,0)5,F%##/.(%),F&"6").(%)G,!<","1"&*()*,&%#",%4,HI!8702"5,3%11/)(30.(%),(),%&*0)(20.(%)2,0)5,(.2,(1;03.,%),.&06"#9,```""f!_.16^!_.16!b12N5*;2/EI!
9*1G)4L^!?I^!KVVVI!H)4%&10.(%),."3<)%#%*>,(),;%##/.(%),;&"6").(%)G,!"#"3%)4"&")3()*,0)5,."#"$%&',/2"5,02,.%%#2,(),.<",&"5/3.(%),%4,$%&'8&"#0."5,.&06"#I!```""f!_.16^!_.16!b12N5*;2/EI!
9.;/*)42)1!:5;2651/2)4!-.24621F!'5+/,*!X*5517,.;5!X);!"@2;;2,1;!KVVWMPWKW!7//Cfgg===IF*5517,.;5IF,NI).gD.24621F;gC.D42+)/2,1;g*5;2651/2)4I7/@4I!!
-)*+4)E+)*6!-.;215;;!)16!%./.*5!%,.16)/2,1I!PWW\I!!<",@0&3#0>30&5,@/2()"22,!&06"#,J/&6">,KLLDMKLLNI!!
-2*/45;^!9I-I^!)16!:I<I!k,71^!KVTJI!'/.6E!,G!/75!C5*G,*@)1+5!,G!)1!515*FE!@)1)F5@51/!;E;/5@I!-'":B^!_,16,1I!
-,;/,1!#,1;.4/21F!X*,.C!3KVVV8!?)C5*!)16!/75!"45+/*,12+!(562)I!!
-*)165@.574^! (IkI^! )16! (IkI! -*)6G,*6^! KVVVf! $C/2@)4! ;.C5*N2;,*E! +,1/*,4! ,G! +,,421F! C4)1/;! =2/7,./!;/,*)F5I!%21)4!:5C,*/!,1!9'Y:9"!:5;5)*+7!?*,c5+/!TPR.
-*)165@.574^!(IkI^!)16!kI"I!-*).1^!KVVVf!B75! 2@C)+/!,G!65@)16O+,1/*,4456!)16!5+,1,@205*!N51/24)/2,1!;/*)/5F25;!,1!515*FE!.;5!21!D.24621F;I!OJPQOR,!&0)203.(%)2^!KWQ3P8^!CCI!RVOQWI(
-Bg%,*.@!G,*!/75!%./.*5I!`#B!);!)!@,65!,G!/*)1;C,*/f!9!*5N25=!,G!/75!.;5!,G!21G,*@)/2,1!)16!+,@@.12+)/2,1!/5+71,4,FE!/,!)+725N5!/*)1;C,*/!C,42+E!F,)4;I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===ID/C4+I+,@g',+25/E)1651N2*,1@51/g:5C,*/;g`#B);)@,65,G/*)1;C,*/G21)4IC6GI!!
#)42G,*12)!"15*FE!#,@@2;;2,1^!PWWRI!d>5N54,C@51/!,G!)!:5)4OB2@5!(,12/,*21Fg>E1)@2+!:)/21F!'E;/5@!G,*!$N5*75)6!_215;^e!DE!">(!`1/5*1)/2,1)4^!`1+I!
#);;)*^![I!3PWWR8!k.C2/5*!@)*L5/!G,*5+);/!*5C,*/f!:5/)24!/7*,.F7!PWWZI!>)*251!#f!k.C2/5*!>2*5+/I!!
#"'`^!`BB^!("^!:9(-v__^!PWWQI!'/.6E!,1!"15*FE!`1G*);/*.+/.*5!#,;/;!)16!`1N5;/@51/;!D5/=551!KVV\!)16!PWKR!3(562.@OB5*@8!)16!%.*/75*!/,!PWPR!3_,1FOB5*@8!,1!/75!B*)1;O".*,C5)1!"15*FE!A5/=,*L!)16!`/;!#,115+/2,1!/,!A52F7D,.*21F!:5F2,1;I!B"AO"15*FEO`1N5;/I!
#,@C./5*!;2@.4)/2,1!/5+71,4,FE!2@C45@51/56!21!'7510751!.*D)1!C4)1121F!)16!65;2F1!3#7215;58I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===IT\N*I+,@g+);5g+2/EC4)1121FgPWWJKKgJQPJI7/@4I!!
#,,L^!9I^!?I!Y)N5*^!KVVJI!d(55/21F!G)+5O/,OG)+5f!N265,+,1G5*51+21FIe!O(&#()",@/2()"22!KW3KK8I!!
>51;/)642^!kI(I^!PWWJI!d`@C)+/;!,G!N265,+,1G5*51+21F!,1!D.;215;;!/*)N54f!/75!A,*=5F2)1!5SC5*251+5Ie!S%/&)0#,%4,O(&,!&0)2;%&.,E0)0*"1").!KWf!RZKMRZ\I!
>,6F;,1^!k,71^!?)+5E^!k,1)/7)1^!!-5FF^!(2+7)54!3PWWW8!($B$:'!9A>!($>"('!:"U`'`B">f!B75!:,45!,G!B5+71,4,FE!21!:56.+21F!B*)N54!>5@)16;!)16!B*)GG2+!#,1F5;/2,1^!A":9^!_,16,1I!!>.)*/5^!>I_I^!AIBI!'1E65*^!PWWKI!E02."&()*,-(&./0#,!"012I!k,;;5EO-);;^!`1+If!')1!%*)1+2;+,I!
"?9g_-A_^!PWWWI!k,71!9I!d'L2Ce!_)2/15*!5/!)4I!:5O5;/2@)/21F!/75!911.)4!"15*FE!$./4,,L!PWWW!%,*5+);/!b;21F!bC6)/56!9;;.@C/2,1;!)D,./!/75!`1/5*15/!"+,1,@EI!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg516.;5I4D4IF,Ng`1G,gJ\JKTO)D;/*)+/I7/@4I!
d"O'/)/;^e!bI'I!#51;.;!-.*5).^!()E!PQ^!PWWZI!9N)24)D45!)/f!7//Cfgg===I+51;.;IF,Ng5,;g===gPWWQgPWWQ*5C,*/G21)4IC6GI!
"BA$g<<%I!>5112;!?)@421^![)/)421!'0,@,4)1E2I!')N21F!/75!?4)15/!)/!/75!'C556!,G!_2F7/I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg);;5/;IC)16)I,*Fg6,=14,)6;g*,)6u@)Cu;C556u,Gu42F7/u==Gu5/1,IC6GI!!
!
! Z\
".*,C5)1!<,*L21F!#,162/2,1;!$D;5*N)/,*E^!PWWZI!T%/&.<,R/&%;"0),U%&'()*,I%)5(.(%)2,J/&6">,VKLLCW9,9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I5.*,G,.16I5.*,C)I5.g6,+;g5=+,gJ"<#'g5GW\VTg+7)C/5*QIC6GI!
%.7*^!k,;5C7!?I!k*I^!'/5C751!-I!?,+2);L^!$+/,D5*!RK^!PWWZI!-*,)6D)16!'5*N2+5;f!"+,1,@2+!)16!"1N2*,1@51/)4!-515G2/;I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I21/5*15/211,N)/2,1I,*Fg?,*/)4;gWg>,+.@51/;g%21)4uX*551u-515G2/;IC6GI!
X)*52;^![I^!PWWPI!!<",H).")2(.>,%4,!"#"$%&',(),KLLK,(),.<",RX+,J$(.Y"�)5+,0)5,.<",XJO9,9N)24)D45!)/,7//Cfgg===I5@C2*2+)ID20gC.D42L)/2,151g6,+.@51/;gX)*52;uB545=,*LO21/51;2/EuPWWPIC6GI!
X)*/15*^!PWWQI!!"#"$%&'()*G,!<",Z/(".,Q"6%#/.(%),VKLLD,X;50."W9,9N)24)D45!)/,7//Cfgg===I7,@5P,GG2+5I+,@gC6Gg/545=,*L21F/75].25/*5N,4./2,1IC6GI,
X).021O(w445*^!>I^!PWWPI!'.;/)21)D45!)*+72/5+/.*5!)16!.*D)12;@I!-2*L7x.;5*^!-);54^!PQQ!CCI!
Y)*N5E^!>I^!PWW\I!9!7)16D,,L!,1!4,=O515*FE!D.24621F;!)16!62;/*2+/!515*FE!;E;/5@;f!%.16)@51/)4;^!/5+712].5;^!)16!5S)@C45;I!k)@5;!)16!k)@5;^!_,16,1I!
Y52;L)151^!5/!)4I^!!PWWKI!>5@)/5*2)42;)/2,1f!B75!C,/51/2)4!G,*!`#B!)16!;5*N2+5;I!B75!%2112;7!"1N2*,1@51/!QRRI!B75!%2112;7!(212;/*E!,G!"1N2*,1@51/!321!%2112;78I!!
Y2F7O:,)6! '/*)/5F25;f! B75! ?,/51/2)4! ,G! `1G,*@)/2,1! B5+71,4,FE! 9CC42+)/2,1;! /,! "1)D45! "+,1,@EO<265!"15*FEO"GG2+251+E!X)21;I!:5C,*/!/,!/75!9#"""!G,*!/75!9#"""O959!".*,C5!?*,c5+/^!9.F.;/!KZ^!PWWZI!
Y,CL21;,1^! ?I^! k)@5;! ?I^! )16! ()*.E)@)! BI^! PWWRI! I%)4"&")3()*, 0., @!G, Q"2/#.2, %4, 0, 2/&6">, %), (.2,"3%)%1(3+,")6(&%)1").0#+,0)5,2%3(0#,(1;03.2I!:5C,*/!DE!'.;/)21`B^!b[!#"">^!?5/5*D,*,.F7I!
Y?^!PWWTI!Y?!#.;/,@5*!#);5!'/.6Ef!Y?!;,4./2,1!;5/;!15=!;/)16)*6!G,*!N2*/.)4!@55/21F^!*56.+21F!/75!1556!G,*!/*)N54!=7245!G)+242/)/21F!=,*46=265!+,44)D,*)/2,1I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg7PWRRWI===PI7CI+,@g51/5*C*2;5g6,=14,)6;g"1N2*,u#;'/6Eb'uQuK\u_:IC6GI!
YEN)*2151^!kI^!KVVKI!#,;/!D515G2/!);;5;;@51/!@5/7,6;!G,*!-"('I!`1/5*1)/2,1)4!"15*FE!9F51+E!9115S!K\^!-.24621F!)16!"15*FE!()1)F5@51/!'E;/5@;f!b;5*!X.26)1+5I!9`U#^!#,N51/*E^!b[I!
`"9^!PWW\)I!"15*FE!B5+71,4,FE!?5*;C5+/2N5;!PWW\f!'+51)*2,;!)16!;/*)/5F25;!/,!PWQWI!`1/5*1)/2,1)4!"15*FE!9F51+E^!?)*2;I!
`"9^!PWW\DI!<,*46!"15*FE!$./4,,L!PWW\^!`1/5*1)/2,1)4!"15*FE!9F51+E^!?)*2;I!
`@C*,N21F!"15*FE!?5*G,*@)1+5!21!#)1)6)I!:5C,*/!/,!?)*42)@51/!.165*!/75!"15*FE!"GG2+251+E!9+/I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I,55I1*+)1IF+I+)g+,*C,*)/5g;/)/2;/2+;g15.6g6C)g6)/)u5g?)*42)@51/WPuWRg?)*42)@51/WPuWRIC6G!!
`Bb!B545+,@@.12+)/2,1!>5N54,C@51/!'5+/,*!`#B!)CC42+)/2,1;!)16!+ED5*;5+.*2/E!62N2;2,1!?,42+25;!)16!'/*)/5F25;!>5N54,C@51/!`#B;!G,*!"O"1N2*,1@51/!KT!9C*24!PWWT!>:9%BI!
`B9#I!`B9#!C,;2/2,1!C)C5*^!k)1.)*E!\^!PWWRI!B75!2;;.5f!`11,N)/2,1^!21G,*@)/2,1!/5+71,4,FE^!)16!+42@)/5!+7)1F5I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I2/)+I+)g9*+72N5g"O#,@@5*+5gWRk)1\B75`;;.5`11,N)/2,1`1G,*@)/2,1B5+71,4,FE)16#42@)/5#7)1F5I7/@.!
k5421;L2!_I!<I^!X*)5654!BI"I^!_).62;5!:I!9I^!(+#)44!>I!<I^!)16!?)/54!#I![I!AI^!d`16.;/*2)4!"+,4,FEf!#,1+5C/;!)16!9CC*,)+75;^e!F&%39,[0.#9,O3059,J3(9,XJO!TV3R8fZVROZVZ!3KVVP8I!9N)24)D45!,1!7//Cfgg===IC1);I,*Fg+F2g*5C*21/gTVgRgZVRI!!
[*)C@525*^!YI^!)16!"I!>*y;;45*!356;I8^!PWWKI!#"?Y"b'f!_2N21F!+,@G,*/!=2/7,./!75)/21FI!'C*21F5*OU5*4)F^!U2511)^!KRV!CCI!
B5N5*@,*5^! XIkI^! PWWWI! -.24621F! 515*FE! @)1)F5@51/! ;E;/5@;a! )CC42+)/2,1! /,! 4,=O515*FE! YU9#! )16!1)/.*)4!N51/24)/2,1!+,1/*,4I!'5+,16!562/2,1I!"j%A!'C,1^!B)E4,*!j!%*)1+2;!X*,.C^!_,16,1I!
?5*;;,1^!5/!)4I^!PWWWI!%./.*5!#$P!;)N21F;!G*,@!,1O4215!;7,CC21F!c5,C)*62;56!DE!D)6!C4)1121FI!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I;+)1)@5*2+)I15/g===gG/Cg"O"GG_,F2;/2+;'=5651IC6GI!!
?*2+5^!_I^!'I!65!4)!:.5!6.!#)1^!kI!'21/,1^!"I!<,**544^!AI!s7,.^!kI!')/7)E5^!)16!(I!_5N215^!PWW\I!'5+/,*)4!/*516;! 21! F4,D)4! 515*FE! .;5! )16! F*5517,.;5! F);! 5@2;;2,1;I! _-A_OQ\KJJ^! _)=*51+5! -5*L545E! A)/2,1)4!_)D,*)/,*E^!-5*L545E^!#9I!
:)4C7!X)E^!5/!)4I^!PWWQI!(,654421F!C)*)62F@!G,*!/75!51N2*,1@51/)4!2@C)+/;!,G!/75!62F2/)4!5+,1,@EI!k,.*1)4!,G!,*F)120)/2,1)4!)16!545+/*,12+!+,@@5*+5!3PWWQ8!\KMTPI!
:2+7)*6!'/)*L5E!)16![5N21!9165*;,1I!>,@5;/2+!/*)6)D45!].,/);f!9!C,42+E!21;/*.@51/!G,*!*56.+21F!F*5517,.;5!F);!5@2;;2,1;!G*,@!515*FE!.;5I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I/E16)44I)+I.Lg*5;5)*+7g/75@5PgG21)4u*5C,*/;g/RuPPIC6GI!
!
! ZZ
:,@@^!KVVVI!B75!`1/5*15/!"+,1,@E!)16!X4,D)4!<)*@21Ff!9!'+51)*2,!,G!/75!`@C)+/!,G!"O+,@@5*+5!,1!"15*FE!)16!/75!"1N2*,1@51/I!B75!#51/5*!G,*!"15*FE!)16!#42@)/5!',4./2,1;^!9!62N2;2,1!,G!B75!X4,D)4!"1N2*,1@51/!)16!B5+71,4,FE!%,.16)/2,1I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===ICPC)E;I+,@g*5GgWJgWRZTJI7/@I!!!
:,@@^!PWWKI!B75!`1/5*15/!"+,1,@E!)16!X4,D)4!<)*@21Ff!9!'+51)*2,!,G!/75!`@C)+/!,G!"O+,@@5*+5!,1!"15*FE!)16!/75!"1N2*,1@51/I!#51/5*!G,*!"15*FE!)16!#42@)/5!',4./2,1;!3#"#'8!
:,@@^!k,;5C7^!PWWPI!B75!21/5*15/!)16!/75!15=!515*FE!5+,1,@Ef!:5;,.*+5;^!+,1;5*N)/2,1^!)16!*5+E+421F!R\!3PWWP8!KVZMPKWI!!
:,/7^![I<I^!%I!X,46;/521^!)16!kI![4521@)1^!PWWPI!"15*FE!+,1;.@C/2,1!DE!,GG2+5!)16!/545+,@@.12+)/2,1;!5].2C@51/!21!+,@@5*+2)4!D.24621F;I!U,4.@5!Kf!"15*FE!#,1;.@C/2,1!-);54215^!9*/7.*!>I!_2//45^!`1+I^!#)@D*26F5!3(98^!PWK!CCI!7//Cfgg===I55*5I515*FEIF,NgD.24621F;g!21G,g6,+.@51/;gC6G;g,GG2+5u/545+,@ON,4KuG21)4IC6G!
:,E^!kI^!%242)/*).4/^!?I!KVVTI!dB75!2@C)+/!,G!15=!D.;215;;!C*)+/2+5;!)16!21G,*@)/2,1!/5+71,4,F25;!,1!D.;215;;!)2*O/*)N54!65@)16Ie!S%/&)0#,%4,O(&,!&0)2;%&.,E0)0*"1").!Jf!ZZOT\I!!
'+,//!()//75=;!5/!)4I^!PWWP!"15*FE!2@C42+)/2,1;!,G!,14215!D,,L!*5/)2421F!21!/75!b'!)16!k)C)1I!"1N2*,1@51/)4!`@C)+/!9;;5;;@51/!:5N25=^!JVROQWZI!
'22L)N2*/)!5/!)4I^!PWWR!"GG5+/;!,G!"O#,@@5*+5!,1!X*5517,.;5!X);!"@2;;2,1;f!9!#);5!'/.6E!,G!X*,+5*E!Y,@5!>542N5*E!21!%214)16I!
',**544!'/5N5I!b[":#^!PWWZI!B75!*5D,.16!5GG5+/!L5E!2;;.5;^!@)21!G21621F;I!?*5;51/56!$+/,D5*!RK^!PWWZ^!)/!/75!"15*FE!`1;/2/./5^!_,16,1I!
'C5*421F^!>I^!)16!>I!')4,1^!PWWPI!B*)1;C,*/)/2,1!21!65N54,C21F!+,.1/*25;f!91!,N5*N25=!,G!F*5517,.;5!F);!*56.+/2,1!;/*)/5F25;I!?5=!#51/5*!,1!X4,D)4!#42@)/5!#7)1F5^!9*421F/,1^!JW!CCI!
B)L)7);72![)0.5^!PWWTI!:5D,.16!5GG5+/;!,G!N265,+,1G5*51+5!21!62GG5*51/!+,.1/*25;I!ABB!"15*FE!)16!"1N2*,1@51/!'E;/5@;!_)D,*)/,*25;^!ABB!#,*C,*)/2,1I!
B54;/*)^!PWWZI![)*4!()44,1!5/!)4I!B,=)*6;!)!72F7OD)16=26/7^!4,=O+)*D,1!G./.*5I!9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I/54;/*)I+,@I).g)D,.//54;/*)g+;*g6,+;g+42@)/5uG.44u*5C,*/IC6GIC6GI!!
b[!$GG2+5!G,*!A)/2,1)4!'/)/2;/2+;^!PWWQI!\07%/&,E0&'".,!&")52!KKR3KW8f!JWQOJR\I!9N)24)D45!)/!
7//Cfgg===I;/)/2;/2+;IF,NI.Lg6,=14,)6;g/75@5u4)D,.*g_(Bu$+/WQIC6GI!
<,*46)/<,*LI!PWWZI!!"#"$%&',!&")5#()"2,4%&,KLLN9,9N)24)D45!)/!7//Cfgg===I=,*L21FG*,@)1E=75*5I,*Fg15=;gB*5164215;uPWW\IC6GI!,
&.6L51^!k,54^!!PWWZI!9;;5;;21F!/75!?,/51/2)4!,G!`1G,*@)/2,1!B5+71,4,FE!9CC42+)/2,1;!/,!"1)D45!"+,1,@E!<7245!"15*FE!"GG2+251+E!X)21;^!Y2F7!:,)6!'/*)/5F25;I!9!*5C,*/!G,*!/75!9@5*2+)1!#,.1+24!G,*!)1!"15*FEO"GG2+251/!"+,1,@E^!<);721F/,1^!>#I!
!
!
!
Recommended