IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE ......that Mr. Zinke had an in-person meeting with...

Preview:

Citation preview

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

____________________________________ STATE OF CONNECTICUT AND ) MASHANTUCKET PEQUOT TRIBE, ) ) Plaintiffs, ) ) v. ) Civil Action No. 1:17-cv-02564-RC ) RYAN ZINKE, in his official capacity as ) Secretary of the Interior, and the U.S. ) Department of the Interior, ) ) Defendants, ) ) and ) ) MGM RESORTS GLOBAL ) DEVELOPMENT, LLC, ) ) Defendant/Intervenor. ) ____________________________________)

PLAINTIFFS’ NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT

Plaintiffs the Mashantucket Pequot Tribe (Tribe) and the State of Connecticut submit this

Notice of Supplemental Authority in support of their pending motion for leave to file an

amended complaint (Dkt. 60) to inform the Court of recent developments supporting the factual

allegations in the proposed amended complaint. Specifically, the Plaintiffs submit news articles

from The Washington Post and political news website Politico detailing an ongoing Department

of Justice (DOJ) investigation into whether former Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke – who

recently resigned from office under a cloud of scandal related his personal conduct – violated the

law by lying to his own agency’s inspector general investigators regarding his involvement in the

dispute that is the subject of this litigation.1

1 The articles in question are attached hereto as Exhibits 1, 2 and 3 and are accessible as follows. Washington Post article here: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/justice-dept-investigating-whether-zinke-lied-to-inspector-general/2019/01/03/6c9dea06-0eac-11e9-

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66 Filed 01/24/19 Page 1 of 4

2

These articles and the DOJ investigation that they detail are of particular relevance to the

plaintiffs’ proposed Amended Complaint. Count II of the Amended Complaint alleges, inter alia,

that the Department of the Interior’s decision to not approve amendments to the Tribe’s gaming

procedures with the State of Connecticut was motivated in whole or in part by improper and

undue political influences, pressures, and considerations directed at key decision-makers such as

then-Secretary Zinke. Dkt. 60-2 ¶ 70. The revelation that Secretary Zinke is under DOJ

investigation for lying to his own agency’s investigators regarding his “involvement in reviewing

a proposed casino project by Native American tribes in Connecticut,” as the Washington Post

reported, at the very least provides strong circumstantial evidence of exactly the sort of improper

dealings alleged in the Amended Complaint. See also Politico (“[T]he casino matter now appears

to be the primary subject of DOJ’s interest.”). And as the Washington Post further reported, the

DOJ would not be investigating this matter unless federal prosecutors had determined that the

former Secretary’s account of his actions “was suspect and warranted further scrutiny.”

The attached articles also confirm that then-Secretary Zinke was in Las Vegas, Nevada,

on July 30, 2017. This reporting lends further support to the Amended Complaint’s allegation

that Mr. Zinke had an in-person meeting with Senator Dean Heller (R-NV) in Las Vegas on that

date. See Dkt. 60-2 ¶ 43.

Finally, the Washington Post article provide further support that “Interior officials —

including career staff and even some Trump appointees — had been poised to approve the

agreement last summer, according to interviews with current and former employees and

documents released under the Freedom of Information Act.” This reporting lends further support

84fc-d58c33d6c8c7_story.html?utm_term=.787823f14f03. Politico article here: https://www.politico.com/story/2019/01/03/ryan-zinke-ethics-problems-lying-congress-raul-grijalva-1059149. Hartford Courant article here: http://www.courant.com/politics/hc-pol-zinke-lied-connecticut-casino-20190103-skp4cjauxnbkdpd5bovu4uk4n4-story.html. (last accessed Jan. 24, 2019).

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66 Filed 01/24/19 Page 2 of 4

3

to the Amended Complaint’s averment that the Department intended to approve the amendments

until a last-second change in course by Zinke. See Dkt. 60-2 ¶¶ 35-40, 50.

For the foregoing reasons, the attached articles support the allegations in the Plaintiffs’

Amended Complaint and underscore the need for further proceedings to allow the Plaintiffs to

prove the claims set forth therein.

Dated January 24, 2019. Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Keith M. Harper Keith M. Harper, Bar No. 451956 KHarper@kilpatricktownsend.com

Catherine F. Munson, Bar No. 985717 cmunson@kilpatricktownsend.com KILPATRICK TOWNSEND & STOCKTON LLP 607 14th Street, N.W., Suite 900 Washington, D.C. 20005 Telephone: (202) 508-5800

Counsel for the Mashantucket Pequot Tribe

/s/ Mark. F. Kohler Mark F. Kohler Assistant Attorney General Mark.Kohler@ct.gov Michael K. Skold Assistant Attorney General Michael.Skold@ct.gov Connecticut Office of the Attorney General 55 Elm Street, P.O. Box 120 Hartford, CT 06141-0120 Telephone: (860) 808-5020 Attorneys for Plaintiff The State of Connecticut

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66 Filed 01/24/19 Page 3 of 4

4

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on January 24, 2019, I electronically filed the foregoing Notice of

Supplemental Authority with the Clerk of the Court using the CM/ECF system, which will send

notification of such filing to all counsel of record.

/s/ Keith M. Harper Keith M. Harper, Bar No. 451956 KHarper@kilpatricktownsend.com

KILPATRICK TOWNSEND & STOCKTON LLP 607 14th Street, N.W., Suite 900 Washington, D.C. 20005 Telephone: (202) 508-5800

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66 Filed 01/24/19 Page 4 of 4

��������� ���� �������� ��������� ���� �� ������������� ���!��� ���"��������# �$���� ������������#�%�&���'�� ����(���

��������������� ���������� ����#$�� �#%����� ���)��� ��%$���% ���� �� �%�������%* ��%# �$%��% �������%����#����������+�,��$��,%���%- ���

./0�123/456785�9837:;<=>?;@�ABCDE=<FGHIJKLM�NMOJP�KQRMIJKSTJKQS�UVMJVMW�XKQYM�ZKM[�J\�KQIOMLJ\W�SMQMWTZ]�_277�2a8783b�cd83/�e2f30�cdgh407�i4ha0j45�25kl432�m045d25g2j�nopq�rstuvwq�xqyz{u|q}u~t�ys��vw�v}uq�{vu��tqwuv�}�vt�q�z|v}v}���pqupq{�}q�����qyz{uq���}uq{v�{��qw{quz{����z}�v}�q��vq��u��pvt�z�q}w�~t�v}tyqwu�{��q}q{z��v}�qtuv�zu�{t��zww�{�v}��u��up{qq�yq�y�q��z|v�vz{��vup�upq�|zuuq{��zy�uq}uvz��w{v|v}z���v��zuv�}�upzu���s���q�zwq{�zuq��v}�q~t��q�z����qt��v}�q���p���q�u�upq�o{s|y�z�|v}vtu{zuv�}��q�}qt�z����zt��zwv}��u���v}tyqwu�{��q}q{z��v}�sv{vqt�uvq��u��pvt�{qz�qtuzuq��qz�v}�t�v}�pvt�p�|q�tuzuq������}uz}z�z}��pvt�v}����q|q}u�v}�{q�vq�v}��z�y{�y�tq��wztv}��y{��qwu�����zuv�q�|q{vwz}�u{v�qt�v}���}}qwuvwsu���}�upq�w�s{tq����upzu���{���v}tyqwu�{��q}q{z��v}�qtuv�zu�{t�wz|q�u���q�vq�q��v}�qpz���vq��u��upq|��z}��upq��{q�q{{q��upq�|zuuq{�u��upq�rstuvwq�xqyz{u|q}u�u��w�}tv�q{��pqupq{�z}���z�t��q{q�v��zuq���upq�yq�y�q��z|v�vz{��vup�upq�|zuuq{�tzv��opq��qyz{u|q}u~t�ys��vw�v}uq�{vu��tqwuv�}�pzt�tv}wq��qq}�q�y��{v}��upq�wztq��upq�yq�y�q��z|v�vz{��vup�upq�|zuuq{tzv���tyqz�v}���}�upq�w�}�vuv�}����z}�}�|vu��u���vtwstt�z}��}��v}��v}�qtuv�zuv�}��opq�q�uq}u����vut���{��vt�s}w�qz{�up�s�p�upq�v}tyqwu�{��q}q{z��pz���sqtuv�}q���vu}qttqt�v}�z}�zyyz{q}u�zuuq|yu�u��tw{suv}v�q��v}�q~t�zww�s}u���}q���upq�yq�y�q�tzv����ty��qt|z}���{��v}�q�tzv���v}�q����s}uz{v���yz{uvwvyzuq��v}�u���v}tyqwu�{��q}q{z��v}uq{�vq�t�z��su�upq��}}qwuvwsu�u{v�z��|zuuq{�z}���u��upq��qtu����pvt��}���q��q�z}t�q{q��z����sqtuv�}t�u{sup�s������opq�ty��qt|z}tzv���v}�q�pz��}�u��qq}�w�}uzwuq�����upq�rstuvwq�xqyz{u|q}u�z}��upzu��vtw��ts{qt�z��su�upq�|zuuq{��v��zuq�v}tyqwu�{��q}q{z��z}��rstuvwq�xqyz{u|q}u�y{�u�w��t��}��q�}qt�z����v}�q��{�uq�z��z{q�q����quuq{�u��tuz���z}��y�tuq��z�pz}��{vuuq}�}�uq��}�o�vuuq{���su�}qvupq{�|z�q|q}uv�}����upq�qupvwt�z��q�zuv�}t�upzu�y{�|yuq��pvt��qyz{us{q���pq}����zt�z������w�su�����zt�uzs�pu�u���qz�q�upq�wz|ytvuq��quuq{�upz}�����s}��vu���pq��{�uq�u���}uq{v�{~t�������q|y���qqt�����z|�w�}�v�q}u�upzu���q{�upq��ztu����qz{t���q�pz�q���}q�upzu�u��qupq{���{��s{�ys��vw��z}�t�z}��upqxqyz{u|q}u����upq��}uq{v�{����rstuvwq�xqyz{u|q}u�ty��qt|z}��qw�v}q��u��w�||q}u�opq�rstuvwq�xqyz{u|q}u~t�v}uq{qtu�v}�upq�|zuuq{�vt�tv�}v�vwz}u��tv�}z�v}��y{�tqwsu�{t��q�u��v}�q~t�zww�s}u��zttstyqwu�z}���z{{z}uq���s{upq{�tw{suv}���xqyz{u|q}u����vwvz�t�pz�q�}�u��qu��qwv�q���up�s�p���pqupq{�pq�tp�s����zwqwpz{�qt��yq�y�q��z|v�vz{��vup�upq�|zuuq{�tzv��

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-1 Filed 01/24/19 Page 1 of 4

��������� ���� �������� ��������� ���� �� ������������� ���!��� ���"��������# �$���� ������������#�%�&���'�� ����(���

��������������� ���������� ����#$�� �#%����� ���)��� ��%$���% ���� �� �%�������%* ��%# �$%��% �������%����#����������+�,��$��,%���%- ���

./0�12340�56�47839:�67;<0�<=7=0409=<�179�>0�?36631@;=�=5�A25B0�>017@<0�3=�20C@320<�39B0<=3:7=52<�=5�</5D�7�A02<59E895D39:;F�79?�D3;;6@;;FG�;30?H�27=/02�=/79�<34A;F�43<<=7=0?�7�671=I�J3980K<�20<3:97=359H�=55H�15@;?�4780�/34�7�;0<<7AA07;39:�=72:0=�652�A25<01@=52<IL0B027;�652402�.2@4A�7?B3<02<�/7B0�A;07?0?�:@3;=F�=5�;F39:�=5�39B0<=3:7=52<�52�=5�M59:20<<H�391;@?39:�/3<�632<=97=3597;�<01@23=F�7?B3<02H�N31/70;�O;F99H�/3<�652402�A02<597;�;7DF02�N31/70;�M5/09�79?�7�652402�174A73:97?B3<02H�P052:0�Q7A7?5A5@;5<IJ3980H�D/5�<@>43==0?�/3<�20<3:97=359�;7<=�459=/H�/7?�6710?�39=09<0�A20<<@20�=5�<=0A�?5D9�>017@<0�56�=/0�A25>0<39=5�/3<�159?@1=H�=/5@:/�Q20<3?09=�.2@4A�/7?�<5@20?�59�/34�652�5=/02�207<59<H�=55H�71152?39:�=5�590�56�=/0A05A;0�6743;372�D3=/�=/0�47==02I�R9�A72=31@;72H�=/3<�A02<59�<73?H�.2@4A�D7<�@A<0=�J3980�D5@;?�95=�1/7;;09:0�L09IS59�.0<=02�TUVN59=IW�39�;7<=�F072K<�0;01=359�79?�5B02�/5D�J3980�/79?;0?�=/0�7?4393<=27=359K<�A;79�=5�0XA79?566</520�?23;;39:IY7<=�S79@72FH�J3980�6;0D�=5�O;523?7�79?H�D3=/5@=�159<@;=39:�=/0�Z/3=0�[5@<0H�7995@910?�39�7�90D<�1596020910D3=/�=/09VP5BI�\318�L15==�T\VO;7IW�=/7=�R9=02352�D5@;?�0X04A=�=/0�<=7=0�6254�566</520�?23;;39:I�./0�45B0�273<0?0=/31<�C@0<=359<H�7;59:�D3=/�79�5@=12F�6254�5=/02�:5B02952<�D/5<0�157<=7;�<=7=0<�D020�76601=0?�>F�=/0�A;79IR=�D7<�95=�1;072�A2013<0;F�D/7=�J3980�3<�=/5@:/=�=5�/7B0�;30?�7>5@=H�>@=�=D5�56�=/0�A05A;0�6743;372�D3=/�=/0�47==02<73?�3=�D7<�95=�7>5@=�7�;79?�?07;�J3980�<=2@18�D3=/�=/0�1/732479�56�53;�<02B310<�:379=�[7;;3>@2=59�39�/3<�/540=5D956�Z/3=063</H�N59=I�R9=02352K<�39<A01=52�:09027;�/7<�>009�A25>39:�=/7=�7<�7�A5<<3>;0�1596;31=�56�39=020<=I./0�39<A01=52�:09027;�/7<�7;<5�>009�0XA;5239:�J3980K<�39B5;B0409=�39�7�?3<A@=0�5B02�7�>3?�6254�=D5�]7=3B04023179�=23>0<�=5�5A027=0�7�17<395�39�_7<=�Z39?<52H�M599I./0�60@?�5B02�=/0�N7</79=@180=�Q0C@5=�79?�N5/0:79�=23>0<K�C@0<=�=5�539=;F�5A027=0�7�:74>;39:�6713;3=F�/7<<A7280?�39=09<0�;5>>F39:H�<3910�=/0�5@=1540�76601=<�=/0�6;5D�56�/@9?20?<�56�43;;359<�39�799@7;�:7439:�20B09@0I./0�=23>0<�7;;0:0�J3980�<@11@4>0?�=5�A5;3=317;�A20<<@20�39�95=�:279=39:�=/032�7AA;317=359I./0�=D5�=23>0<�<5@:/=�60?027;�7AA25B7;�=5�2@9�=/0�154402137;�17<395�566�20<02B7=359�;79?�7<�A72=�56�79�7:200409=D3=/�M59901=31@=�5663137;<H�D/31/�20C@320?�79�7409?0?�7:200409=�=5�09<@20�=/0�90D�5A027=359�D5@;?�A25B3?0ab�A02109=�56�3=<�<;5=�471/390�20B09@0�=5�=/0�<=7=0INPN�\0<52=<�R9=0297=3597;�5>01=0?�>017@<0�=/0�17<395�D5@;?�154A0=0�D3=/�3=<�:7439:�154A;0X�ca�43;0<�7D7F�39LA239:630;?H�N7<<IH�79?�15@;?�05A72?3d0�3=<�1/7910<�56�5A0939:�7�17<395�39�M59901=31@=IR9=02352�5663137;<�e�391;@?39:�172002�<=766�79?�0B09�<540�.2@4A�7AA539=00<�e�/7?�>009�A53<0?�=5�7AA25B0�=/07:200409=�;7<=�<@4402H�71152?39:�=5�39=02B30D<�D3=/�1@2209=�79?�652402�04A;5F00<�79?�?51@409=<�20;07<0?@9?02�=/0�O200?54�56�R965247=359�1=I�Q5;3=315�632<=�20A52=0?�172002�<=766K<�<@AA52=�652�=/0�=23>0<K�A0=3=359If;=347=0;FH�=/5@:/H�=/0�?0A72=409=�206@<0?�=5�<3:9�566�59�=/0�N7</79=@180=�Q0C@5=K<�A25A5<7;H�<A72839:�7�;7D<@3=6254�=/0�=23>0�79?�=/0�<=7=0�56�M59901=31@=I

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-1 Filed 01/24/19 Page 2 of 4

��������� ���� �������� ��������� ���� �� ������������� ���!��� ���"��������# �$���� ������������#�%�&���'�� ����(���

��������������� ���������� ����#$�� �#%����� ���)��� ��%$���% ���� �� �%�������%* ��%# �$%��% �������%����#����������+�,��$��,%���%- +��

./�0123145167�8909�:;<36;=3�>?@A1�B?@CD2E�FC/3616G<�@;<4;<<1@�3E1�36;51H<�;/;3;GD�=DG;49�IE1�JCE1AG/�36;51K;3E@61K�L6C4�3E1�D;3;AG3;C/�GL316�./316;C6�G=M/CKD1@A1@�3E1�NGD;@;3O�CL�;3<�AG4;/A�GA61141/3�;/�>?/19P?3�3E1�36;51�Q�KE;=E�KG<�/1G6DO�K;21@�C?3�LC?6�=1/3?6;1<�GAC�5O�3E1�R/AD;<E�Q�EG<�=C/3;/?1@�3C�261<<�;3<�=G<19�.3<C?AE3�3C�G41/@�;3<�=DG;4�;/�S=3C5167�G6A?;/A�;/�=C?63�@C=?41/3<�3EG3�./316;C6�<3GLL�EG@�T2612G61@�@6GL3�G226CNGDD13316<U�C/�S=39�V7�WXYZ7�5?3�3E1/�;/LC641@�3E1�36;51<�G�K11M�DG316�;3�KC?D@�3GM1�/C�G=3;C/�C/�3E1�213;3;C/7<3O4;1;/A�3E1�26C[1=39�IE1�36;51�=EG6A1@�3EG3�T3E1�:12G6341/3�?D3;4G31DO�5?=MD1@�?/@16�?/@?1�2CD;3;=GD�261<<?61UL6C4�3KC�B12?5D;=G/�414516<�CL�FC/A61<<�L6C4�\1NG@G7�01/9�:1G/�]1DD16�G/@�B129�JG6M�4C@1;9]1DD167�KEC�EG<�<;/=1�D1L3�3E1�01/G317�EGN;/A�DC<3�E;<�611D1=3;C/�5;@�DG<3�O1G67�=C?D@�/C3�51�61G=E1@�LC6�=C441/394C@1;�<G;@�;/�G/�S=3C516�WXYZ�;/316N;1K�K;3E�/1K<2G216�=CD?4/;<3�:GN;@�FCDD;/<�3EG3�E1�3CD@�./316;C6�CLL;=;GD<�3CT@C�3E1;6�[C5U�G/@�KG<�4161DO�G=3;/A�C/�51EGDL�CL�G�D;=1/<1@�AG4;/A�C216G3C6�;/�\1NG@G9IE1�=C?63�L;D;/A�GDD1A1<�T01/G3C6�]1DD16�@;61=3DO�261<<?61@�01=613G6O�_;/M1�3C�@C�KEG3�KG<�/1=1<<G6O�3C�<3C2�3E1I6;51<H�[C;/3�N1/3?61�=G<;/C�26C[1=3�@?6;/A�G�26;NG31�@;//16�G3�G�<31GMEC?<1�;/�G<�a1AG<7�C/�C6�G5C?3�>?DO�bX7WXYZ9U�_;/M1H<�CLL;=;GD�=GD1/@G6�<ECK<�E1�KG<�;/�G<�a1AG<�3EG3�@GO7�51LC61�=G3=E;/A�G�DG31c/;AE3�LD;AE3�5G=M�3CdG<E;/A3C/7�5?3�;3�@C1<�/C3�D;<3�E;<�G=3;N;3;1<�3E1619d;3E�_;/M1�AC/17�01/9�B;=EG6@�PD?41/3EGD�e:cFC//9f�;<�36O;/A�3C�A13�E;<�<?==1<<C6�3C�G226CN1�=EG/A1<�3C�3E136;5GDc<3G31�=C42G=37�<C�3E1�RG<3�d;/@<C6�=G<;/C�=G/�26C=11@9�FC//1=3;=?3�<3G31�DGK4GM16<�G61�GD<C�=C/<;@16;/A/1K�D1A;<DG3;C/�3EG3�KC?D@�1D;4;/G31�3E1�61g?;6141/3�3EG3�3E1�36;51<�61=1;N1�G226CNGD�L6C4�./316;C6�51LC61�4CN;/AGE1G@�K;3E�3E1�=G<;/C9hijj�kilmjmnopqrss�truvsvwxy�zv{|}w�s~|���ws�z|��|ur}s�|�s��v}��~|��rw~���sv���vws�w��rs�v�r��w|z�}�sy�s|r����|�~rw�u}|{�v�w�y��v}x|�zv{|}����s~|��|�|}r��zv�}s~v�w|������|�r��}�r�r����vzr���r��|��v}z|�|�s�����}��z|��|v}�|�w��v��sy�r����v�s~|}��qr}y�r����v��v����mn���i�n�p�vw~��r�w|y��w�r��~�s|��v�w|�}|uv}s|}��v}��~|��rw~���sv���vws���|��v��|��s~|�uru|}������� ���|�u}|{�v�w�y�zv{|}|��s~|��~�s|�v�w|��v}��v��s�zv¡�r���¢|��£v}x���sy��r���r���¢|���|}w|y��v{���~}�w��~}�ws�|��v}�s~|��r����s}||s��v�}�r����v��v����¤¥¦�j�§¦¥l�¦©����|s�ª��u|}����w��~|��rw~���sv���vws�w�w|��v}��rs�v�r��r��r�}w�zv}}|wuv��|�s¡�zv{|}����~v��s~|��|��r�����ws}rs�v���ws}r�w�v}�����r�}r��|�v��«����uv��z�|w�r���s~|��|�|}r���v{|}��|�s��sw|�����~|��w�s~|�r�s~v}�v��s�v�¬vvxw�­�v�|�v��w~r}xw�r��r�vs~|}�v���v��}|ww¡��vs�sv�¬|�zv���w|����s~�|rz~�vs~|}�­�r���~rw��v}x|���v}��~|��vws�w��z|��®®���v��v���°¦ni�±�¦©²�wr�³|���zv{|}w��|�|}r��r�|�z�|w�r���s~|��r�r�|�|�s�v���v{|}��|�s����s~|��}��u�r����ws}rs�v����s��~|��rw~���sv���vws¡�w~|~rw��}�ss|��r¬v�s�s~|��|�|}r���v}x�v}z|�wsrs|�uv��s�zw�r����v{|}��|�s�������ruv��w¡�r������³�z~�v����vzr���v{|}��|�s����r�}�r���v��sy¡�µr��r���s~|�}|�|{|�vu�|�s�v���rw~���sv��r����sw��|��~¬v}~vv�w���v��v���

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-1 Filed 01/24/19 Page 3 of 4

��������� ���� �������� ��������� ���� �� ������������� ���!��� ���"��������# �$���� ������������#�%�&���'�� ����(���

��������������� ���������� ����#$�� �#%����� ���)��� ��%$���% ���� �� �%�������%* ��%# �$%��% �������%����#����������+�,��$��,%���%- ���

./0�12/0345678�9::;7�<4=>?�23�@47?63A=23�43B�=?:�<205BCDEF�G�HIJKL�MIE�NOP�QGRSJT�HS�KLUV�IMMSEWXYZ[\]�[�_ aYbZYc�RUdJ�UJ

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-1 Filed 01/24/19 Page 4 of 4

��������� ���� ����������������������������������������������������� ��������������� ! "�

#��$�%��&&&'$�����'�������������������(������)������#���$��*���������������������+������ ����,���� ���

- ./

012�34562�72849:;<�=2>?@�A=�91;:B2�4C�4D2:622A=B�<12�E=<2:A4:�72F;:<82=<�6;@6�12�6<A??�>;=<6�C4:82:�G29:2<;:@H@;=�IA=J2�<4�;FF2;:�C4:�K526<A4=A=B�;L45<�1A6�2<1A96�F:4L?286M�N26FA<2�1A6�2OA<�C:48�<12�0:58F�;N8A=A6<:;<A4=P

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-2 Filed 01/24/19 Page 1 of 4

��������� ���� ����������������������������������������������������� ��������������� ! "�

#��$�%��&&&'$�����'�������������������(������)������#���$��*���������������������+������ ����,���� ���

-./0123�4567�4389�:./;39<3=�>?1�@11A�1<5.�B?C.DE3F�3D�G?3/.H32�1I�@?5�J3@C.39�45D1C.G5D�K1HH/@@55=�@19ELMNOBOKM�/2�3�P./5I�/2@5.</5>�@?3@�?5�6932D�@1�D55A�Q/2A5RD�@5D@/H12F�S3@�D1H5�61/2@S�@?/D�F53.7�T5�E/E�21@593P1.3@57:./;39<3RD�G1HH52@D�G1H5�3H/E�.561.@D�@?3@�@?5�UCD@/G5�V563.@H52@�/D�5W3H/2/2X�3995X3@/12D�@?3@�Q/2A5=�>?195I@�?/D�61D@�Y5E25DE3F=�9/5E�@1�/2<5D@/X3@1.D�>/@?�O2@5./1.RD�/2D65G@1.�X525.39RD�1II/G57�B?5�Y3D?/2X@12�L1D@.561.@5E�12�@?3@�6.1P5=�G/@/2X�@?.55�D1C.G5D�I3H/9/3.�>/@?�@?5�H1<57Q/2A5�.5D/X25E�3I@5.�95DD�@?32�@>1�F53.D�/2�L.5D/E52@�V1239E�B.CH6ZD�K3P/25@=�52E/2X�3�@C.PC952@�@52C.5�H3.A5EPF�2CH5.1CD�/2<5D@/X3@/12D�/2@1�?/D�G12ECG@�/2�1II/G57�B?5�H1D@�D5./1CD�6.1P5D�>5.5�93C2G?5E�I1991>/2XLMNOBOKMZD�.561.@/2X�12�?/D�/2<19<5H52@�/2�3�932E�E539�>/@?�@?5�G?3/.H32�1I�T399/PC.@12=�3D�>599�3D�O2@5./1.ZDC2CDC39�E5G/D/12�@1�P91GA�3�@./P39�G3D/21�/2�K1225G@/GC@�I1991>/2X�91PPF/2X�PF�3�./<39�G3D/21�165.3@1.7O2<5D@/X3@1.D�/2@5.</5>5E�Q/2A5�@>/G5�3P1C@�@?5�G3D/21�H3@@5.�32E�2CH5.1CD�@/H5D�/2�@?5�G1C.D5�1I�/@D�1@?5./2<5D@/X3@/12D=�@?5�I1.H5.�D5G.5@3.F�@19E�LMNOBOKM�</3�@5W@�H5DD3X5�B?C.DE3F=�PC@�?5�D3/E�VMU�?3D�21@G12@3G@5E�?/H7�T5�D3/E�?5�S32D>5.5E�@.C@?IC99F�@1�399�H3@@5.D=S�@1�@?5�P5D@�1I�?/D�A21>95EX5=�32E�D3/E�?5�?3D�E12521@?/2X�>.12X7[Y?3@�/D�>.12X�/D�>3D@/2X�\]D�1I�@?1CD32ED�1I�@3W�63F5.�E1993.D�12�I39D5�3995X3@/12D�32E�953A�I.1H�3212FH1CD_D1C.G5D=�Q/2A5�>.1@57:./;39<3�32E�Q/2A5�?3<5�@.3E5E�P3.PD�.5653@5E9F�1<5.�@?5�93D@�@>1�F53.D�a�H1D@�E.3H3@/G399F�/2�V5G5HP5.=�>?52Q/2A5�3GGCD5E�:./;39<3�1I�SE.C2A52S�P5?3</1.7O@�>3D�C2G953.�>?3@�Q/2A5�>3D�DCD65G@5E�1I�9F/2X�3P1C@=�PC@�@?5�G3D/21�H3@@5.�21>�36653.D�@1�P5�@?5�6./H3.FDCP;5G@�1I�VMURD�/2@5.5D@7�O@�>3D�21@�@?5�932E�E539�>/@?�@?5�T399/PC.@12�G?3/.H32=�3GG1.E/2X�@1�@?5�L1D@7O2@5./1.ZD�O:�P5X32�/2<5D@/X3@/2X�@?5�G3D/21�E539�93D@�D6./2X=�3I@5.�K1225G@/GC@�93>H3A5.D�3DA5E�I1.�3�6.1P5�/2@1>?5@?5.�@?5�E5G/D/12�>3D�/H6.165.9F�/2I9C52G5E�PF�91PPF/2X�I.1H�b:b�45D1.@D�O2@5.23@/1239=�>?/G?�?3D�D/2G516525E�3�./<39�G3D/21�\c�H/95D�I.1H�>?5.5�@?5�@?5�b3D?32@CGA5@�L5dC1@�32E�b1?5X32�@./P5D�?3E�?165E�@1�PC/9E@?5/.D7L19/@/G39�3661/2@55D�3@�O2@5./1.�H3E5�@?5�E5G/D/12�@1�P91GA�@?5�6.1;5G@�3@�@?5�\\@?�?1C.=�1<5..C9/2X�@?5.5G1HH52E3@/12D�1I�G3.55.�1II/G/39D�/2�@?5�E563.@H52@RD�MII/G5�1I�O2E/32�:3H/2X=�LMNOBOKM�.561.@5E�93D@�F53.7B?5�H1<5�.5D@5E�12�3�23..1>�/2@5.6.5@3@/12�1I�@?5�O2E/32�:3H/2X�45XC93@1.F�-G@�@?3@�@?5�@./P5D�D3F�3H1C2@5E�@1

e

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-2 Filed 01/24/19 Page 2 of 4

��������� ���� ����������������������������������������������������� ��������������� ! "�

#��$�%��&&&'$�����'�������������������(������)������#���$��*���������������������+������ ����,���� (��

-.�/0123142�135/6/7-5�8-932�63�53::;/<6<�-.=�>49-=-�5-?0-@42<�?A3�A-=�-=937-64=�832�B-<�C4D-<E:-<4=�FGFH<13</6/3.IJ/.@4�=/<1K64=�6A4�62/:4<L�73.64.6/3.M�?2/6/.D�63�NOBPQPRO�6A-6�A/<�13</6/3.�?-<�6A-6�6A4�.-6/3.<�S-24�<39424/D.-.=�TOP�<A3K5=�.36�6-@4�-�13</6/3.M�4/6A42�=/2476�32�/015/4=M�1426-/./.D�63�P.=/-.�-76/9/6/4<�3.�.3.�62K<6�5-.=<36A42�6A-.�-<�3:5/D-64=�:;�5-?�32�624-6;ISU�84=42-5�VK=D4�A-<�=/<0/<<4=�-�5-?<K/6�7A-554.D/.D�P.642/32H<�=47/</3.M�:K6�6A4�F-<A-.6K7@46�-24�-664016/.D�63249/94�6A4�7-<4�:-<4=�3.�-==/6/3.-5�-554D-6/3.<�38�/0123142�135/6/7-5�/.85K4.74I

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-2 Filed 01/24/19 Page 3 of 4

��������� ���� ����������������������������������������������������� ��������������� ! "�

#��$�%��&&&'$�����'�������������������(������)������#���$��*���������������������+������ ����,���� ���

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-2 Filed 01/24/19 Page 4 of 4

��������� ���� �������� ������������������ ������������������� ���������� ��!���"� ������ ��#�$�������%� �� �

���&'�����(�� �� �(����&���������#&��#)� ��#���#�� ����� �#��� �#�������*#�&��+� , ��&-��� � �� �#����(���� ���

./0121345678�9:;68<9=><9:=�?@6<@6A�BCAD6A�E:<6A9CAF6GA6<>AH�I9:J6�K967�>LCM<�N>8<�O9:78CA�G>89:CPQ�RS22�TS./24UV�W�X/4Y�ZS[4\V��] _�014S�\1abcdefghijg�kjdi�l mcg�nop�qnrs t �u �vwxyz{|}~z�z�|

�������������������������������������������������������������������� ��¡���¢���¢�����£���� m���¤��¥��p�¦����������������������¢���������¥��¦�����¢������§�© i§��e���¦��¥�c��§¥������§�����¢����¥��������¦�������������¥��¦���ª��¢©« 2/.134 �����������������¬­® �°±¬�²³ µ 0/¶�1a

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-3 Filed 01/24/19 Page 1 of 9

��������� ���� �������� ������������������ ������������������� ���������� ��!���"� ������ ��#�$�������%� �� �

���&'�����(�� �� �(����&���������#&��#)� ��#���#�� ����� �#��� �#�������*#�&��+� , ��&-��� � �� �#����(���� ���

./0�1234560�7089:4;0<4=3�82>?56�5<40@:54A�30645B<�53�0C9;5<5<@�D/04/0:�<0D?A�E089:40E�F<40:5B:�G06:049:A�HA9<�I5<J0�?50E�4B�/53�9@0<6A=35<38064B:�@0<0:9?�5<K0345@94B:3L�MN56/90?�H0A<B?E3�O�PQRSPTPOHPUVWXY�Z[\]_Y�Yabc]dYe]f\�a[gh_�e]Yic]j�\Y_]ke�\�Ylbdeei�mXY]XYc�eYmhj�nYabc]Yn�oe]YckcpY_cY]bcj�qjbe�resY�hYn�]k�X\�biYe_jf\�e\aY_]kc�iYeYcbh�etY\]ib]kc\�_ke_Yceei�b�ackak\Yn_b\ek�e�ub\]�v en\kcw�b__kcnei�]k�]XcYY�aYkahY�xbdhbc�m]X�]XY�db]]YcyresYw�mXk�hYx]�]XY�Wc[da�bnde\]cb]ke�vYneY\nbjw�mb\�xb_ei�]mk�e\aY_]kc�iYeYcbhez[cY\�]Yn�]k�X\�cYbh�Y\]b]Y�nYbhei\�e�X\�XkdY�\]b]Y�kx�{ke]beb�ben�X\�etkhtYdYe]�ecYtYmei�b�ackak\Yn�_kddYc_bh�_b\ek�ack|Y_]�]Xb]�mk[hn�gY�c[e�gj�]XY�{b\Xbe][_sY]�}Yz[k]ben�{kXYibe�]cgY\y�oe�]XY�_k[c\Y�kx�]Xb]�mkcsw�e\aY_]kc�iYeYcbh�etY\]ib]kc\�_bdY�]k�gYhYtYresY�Xbn�hYn�]k�]XYdw�ben�]XYj�cYxYccYn�]XY�db]]Yc�]k�]XY�Z[\]_Y�Yabc]dYe]�]k�_ke\nYcmXY]XYc�bej�hbm\�mYcY�tkhb]Ynw�]XY�aYkahY�xbdhbc�m]X�]XY�db]]Yc�\bny

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-3 Filed 01/24/19 Page 2 of 9

��������� ���� �������� ������������������ ������������������� ���������� ��!���"� ������ ��#�$�������%� �� �

���&'�����(�� �� �(����&���������#&��#)� ��#���#�� ����� �#��� �#�������*#�&��+� , ��&-��� � �� �#����(���� *��

./0�1234560�789:0�5;49�<5;=0>3�?@5;A�8078030;43�B�7940;45B?�685C5;B?�D59?B459;E./0�F07B84C0;4>3�72:?56�5;40A854@�306459;�/B3�:00;�0G7?985;A�4/0�6B30H�4/0�7097?0�IBC5?5B8�J54/4/0�CB4408�3B5FE�./0�0G40;4�9I�543�J98=�53�2;6?0B8H�4/92A/�4/0�5;3706498�A0;08B?�/BF�K203459;0FJ54;03303�5;�B;�B77B80;4�B440C74�49�368245;5L0�<5;=0>3�B6692;4H�9;0�9I�4/0�7097?0�3B5FEM�379=03CB;�I98�<5;=0�3B5F�<5;=0�D9?2;4B85?@�7B845657B40F�5;�4J9�5;3706498�A0;08B?�5;408D50J3B:924�4/0�N9;;0645624�485:B?�CB4408�B;F�O49�4/0�:034�9I�/53�=;9J?0FA0�B;3J080F�B??�K203459;34824/I2??@EP�./0�379=03CB;�3B5F�<5;=0�/BF�;94�:00;�69;4B640F�:@�4/0�Q234560�R07B84C0;4�B;F4/B4�F536?932803�B:924�4/0�CB4408�D59?B40F�5;3706498�A0;08B?�B;F�Q234560�R07B84C0;4�7894969?3ES;�T0F;03FB@H�<5;=0�J8940�B�UVWXYXZZ�ZX[[XW�[\�][VUU�B;F�79340F�B�/B;FJ85440;�;940�9;.J54408�:24�;054/08�CBF0�C0;459;�9I�4/0�04/563�B??0AB459;3�4/B4�789C740F�/53�F07B84280EOT/0;��JB3�B�_9@�6924H��JB3�4B2A/4�49�?0BD0�4/0�6BC73540�:04408�4/B;��I92;F�54HP�/0�J8940;408598>3�abHbbb�0C7?9@003E�O�BC�69;I5F0;4�4/B4�9D08�4/0�?B34�c�@0B83H�J0�/BD0�F9;0�4/B449A04/08�I98�928�72:?56�?B;F3�B;F�4/0�R07B84C0;4�9I�4/0�;408598EPM�Q234560�R07B84C0;4�379=03CB;�F06?5;0F�49�69CC0;4E

defghijkglgmi

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-3 Filed 01/24/19 Page 3 of 9

��������� ���� �������� ������������������ ������������������� ���������� ��!���"� ������ ��#�$�������%� �� �

���&'�����(�� �� �(����&���������#&��#)� ��#���#�� ����� �#��� �#�������*#�&��+� , ��&-��� � �� �#����(���� ���

. ./012�3456789�:;<=01>67;�4??<09�7�?>7>0=01>�;7>0�@6<8?97AB�CD0E�41FG8=7>4G1�>67>�FG8=08H1>084G8�/0580>78A�I41J0�=7A�67K0�;409�>G�41K0?>4L7>G8?�M�7�F09087;�584=0�M�4?�?084G<?�719?4L14F4571>N�G.0141L�7�10E�.67?0�41�6G;941L�I41J0�755G<1>7O;0�FG8�64?�4=.8G.08�5G19<5>2�@60.8G?05<>G8?�41�>60�P0.78>=01>�GF�Q<?>450R?�S<O;45�H1>0L84>A�/05>4G1�O841L�584=417;�5678L0?7L741?>�;7EO807J41L�GFF4547;?�719�5G19<5>�>847;?�719�G>608�.8G500941L?�M�1GE�7�94?>415>;A.G??4O;0�G<>5G=0�FG8�I41J02�@60�807?G1�H�57;;09�FG8�>60�H1?.05>G8�T01087;R?�41K0?>4L7>4G1N�E6456;09�>G�>64?�41U<48AN�E7?�I41J0R?�.G??4O;0�5G1F;45>?�GF�41>080?>N�4=.8G.08�F7KG84>4?=N�719�G>608.G>01>47;�=4?5G19<5>�V�E6456�5G<;9�L4K0�84?0�>G�5678L0?�GF�.08W<8A�719�F87<9N�7=G1L�G>608?2X@60�Q<?>450�P0.78>=01>R?�41>080?>�41�>60�=7>>08�4?�?4L14F4571>N�?4L17;41L�.8G?05<>G8?�F0;>�I41J0R?755G<1>�E7?�?<?.05>�719�E78871>09�F<8>608�?58<>41A2�P0.78>=01>�GFF4547;?�67K0�1G>�A0>�9054909N>6G<L6N�E60>608�60�?6G<;9�F750�5678L0?N�.0G.;0�F7=4;478�E4>6�>60�=7>>08�?7492@60�584=0�GF�=7J41L�F7;?0�?>7>0=01>?�571�O0�94FF45<;>�>G�.8GK0�O057<?0�4>�80U<480?�41K0?>4L7>G8?>G�?6GE�7�.08?G1�CJ1GE41L;A�719�E4;;F<;;AX�;409N�87>608�>671�?4=.;A�=4??>7>09�7�F75>2�I41J0R?80?4L17>4G1N�>GGN�5G<;9�=7J0�64=�7�;0??�7..07;41L�>78L0>�FG8�.8G?05<>G8?2/0K087;�FG8=08�@8<=.�79K4?08?�67K0�.;07909�L<4;>A�>G�;A41L�>G�41K0?>4L7>G8?�G8�>G�YG1L80??N415;<941L�64?�F48?>�17>4G17;�?05<84>A�79K4?08N�Z45670;�[;A11N�64?�FG8=08�.08?G17;�;7EA08�Z45670;YG601�719�7�FG8=08�57=.74L1�79K4?08N�T0G8L0�S7.79G.G<;G?2\] _abc_d_ea

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-3 Filed 01/24/19 Page 4 of 9

��������� ���� �������� ������������������ ������������������� ���������� ��!���"� ������ ��#�$�������%� �� �

���&'�����(�� �� �(����&���������#&��#)� ��#���#�� ����� �#��� �#�������*#�&��+� , ��&-��� � �� �#����(���� -��

./�01//23453647�482�926:�1;2<�482�=>?8>/463@24�A2B614�>/:�=182C>/�4<5D2?E�B62?4�41�F15/4GH1I2<>42�>�C>JDG5/C�9>35G54H�8>?�?I><@2:�5/42/?2�G1DDH5/C7�?5/32�482�16431J2�>99234?�482�9G1K�1986/:<2:?�19�J5GG51/?�19�:1GG><?�5/�>//6>G�C>J5/C�<2;2/62L�M82�4<5D2?�>GG2C2�N5/@2�?6336JD2:�41I1G5453>G�I<2??6<2�5/�/14�C<>/45/C�4825<�>IIG53>451/LM82�4K1�4<5D2?�?16C84�92:2<>G�>II<1;>G�41�<6/�482�31JJ2<35>G�3>?5/1�199�<2?2<;>451/�G>/:�>?�I><419�>/�>C<22J2/4�K548�01//2345364�199535>G?7�K8538�<2B65<2:�>/�>J2/:2:�>C<22J2/4�41�2/?6<2482�/2K�1I2<>451/�K16G:�I<1;5:2�OP�I2<32/4�19�54?�?G14�J>385/2�<2;2/62�41�482�?4>42L=Q=�R2?1<4?�./42</>451/>G�1DF2342:�D23>6?2�482�3>?5/1�K16G:�31JI242�K548�54?�C>J5/C31JIG2S�TO�J5G2?�>K>H�5/�UI<5/C952G:7�=>??L7�>/:�316G:�F21I><:5V2�54?�38>/32?�19�1I2/5/C�>3>?5/1�5/�01//2345364L./42<51<�199535>G?�W�5/3G6:5/C�3><22<�?4>99�>/:�2;2/�?1J2�M<6JI�>II15/422?�W�8>:�D22/�I15?2:41�>II<1;2�482�>C<22J2/4�G>?4�?6JJ2<7�>331<:5/C�41�5/42<;52K?�K548�36<<2/4�>/:�91<J2<2JIG1H22?�>/:�:136J2/4?�<2G2>?2:�6/:2<�482�X<22:1J�19�./91<J>451/�Y34L�A1G54531�95<?4<2I1<42:�3><22<�?4>99E?�?6II1<4�91<�482�4<5D2?E�I245451/L�ZG45J>42GH7�4816C87�482�:2I><4J2/4<296?2:�41�?5C/�199�1/�482�=>?8>/463@24�A2B614E?�I<1I1?>G7�?I><@5/C�>�G>K?654�9<1J�482�4<5D2>/:�482�?4>42�19�01//2345364L./�U2I42JD2<7�ZLUL�[5?4<534�\6:C2�R6:1GI8�01/4<2<>?�:5?J5??2:�482�4<5D2E?�5/545>G�3G>5JL�M82=182C>/�4<5D2�K548:<2K�9<1J�482�G545C>451/�>942<�./42<51<�>3@/1KG2:C2:�482�;>G5:54H�19�54?C>J5/C�>C<22J2/4�5/�\6/2L]64�482�4<5D2�W�K8538�K>?�/2><GH�K5I2:�164�916<�32/46<52?�>C1�DH�482�/CG5?8�W�8>?�31/45/62:

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-3 Filed 01/24/19 Page 5 of 9

��������� ���� �������� ������������������ ������������������� ���������� ��!���"� ������ ��#�$�������%� �� �

���&'�����(�� �� �(����&���������#&��#)� ��#���#�� ����� �#��� �#�������*#�&��+� , ��&-��� � �� �#����(���� .��

/ 0 1 / 123�04566�726�8965:�;2�63<1=2�23�9>5?@�726�8A97>�7?�B823C54D�941<7?1�7?�83<42�@38<>5?26�2=92;?254734�629EE�=9@�F0450945@�@49E2�90043G9A�A522546H�3?�B82:�ID�JKLMD�C<2�2=5?�7?E34>5@�2=5�247C569�N55O�A9254�72�N3<A@�29O5�?3�98273?�3?�2=5�0527273?D�62/>757?1�2=5�043P582:�Q=5�247C5�8=9415@2=92�F2=5�R50942>5?2�<A27>925A/�C<8OA5@�<?@54�<?@<5�03A72789A�04566<45H�E43>�2N3�S50<CA789?>5>C546�3E�T3?14566�E43>�U5G9@9D�V5?:�R59?�W5AA54�9?@�S50:�X94O�Y>3@57:W5AA54D�N=3�=96�67?85�A5E2�2=5�V5?925D�=9G7?1�A362�=76�455A58273?�C7@�A962�/594D�83<A@�?32�C54598=5@�E34�83>>5?2:�Y>3@57�697@�7?�9?�B823C54�JKLM�7?254G75N�N72=�?5N609054�83A<>?762R9G7@�T3AA7?6�2=92�=5�23A@�;?254734�3EE7879A6�23�F@3�2=574�P3CH�9?@�N96�>545A/�9827?1�3?�C5=9AE�3E�9A785?65@�19>7?1�30549234�7?�U5G9@9:Q=5�83<42�E7A7?1�9AA5156�FV5?9234�W5AA54�@74582A/�04566<45@�V5845294/�Z7?O5�23�@3�N=92�N96?5856694/�23�6230�2=5�Q47C56[�P37?2�G5?2<45�8967?3�043P582�@<47?1�9�047G925�@7??54�92�9�6259O=3<657?�\96�]5196D�3?�34�9C3<2�<A/�_KD�JKLM:H�Z7?O5[6�3EE7879A�89A5?@94�6=3N6�=5�N96�7?�\96�]51962=92�@9/D�C5E345�8928=7?1�9�A925?71=2�EA71=2�C98O�23�a96=7?123?D�C<2�72�@356�?32�A762�=76�9827G727562=545:a72=�Z7?O5�13?5D�V5?:�S78=94@�bA<>5?2=9A�cRT3??:d�76�24/7?1�23�152�=76�6<8856634�23�90043G58=9?156�23�2=5�247C9A62925�83>0982D�63�2=5�e962�a7?@634�8967?3�89?�043855@:�T3??58278<2�62925A9N>9O546�945�9A63�83?67@547?1�?5N�A5176A9273?�2=92�N3<A@�5A7>7?925�2=5�45f<745>5?2�2=92�2=5247C56�45857G5�90043G9A�E43>�;?254734�C5E345�>3G7?1�9=59@�N72=�2=5�8967?3:ghihjklmnopqrpstuvwxylmnopqrpstuz{|�}~{�lmnopqrpstu��y��y~���h�y~�~l���~���y����lwk���yx���~�wx����h�hx��lwk�~�jy��y{��{h�y���~x�w��y{�{y�~h�y{��wk�{y��{wj~j�l���y{�~lhx��~����~�wx�����h���yxhk���{h�i�gh����h����~�����wk{�zw���h�i�������~����zw���h����y{l�z~l�z{|�}~{�lmnopqrpstu��g~l���wk{��~����i���w{�vy��

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-3 Filed 01/24/19 Page 6 of 9

��������� ���� �������� ������������������ ������������������� ���������� ��!���"� ������ ��#�$�������%� �� �

���&'�����(�� �� �(����&���������#&��#)� ��#���#�� ����� �#��� �#�������*#�&��+� , ��&-��� � �� �#����(���� .��

/-0��� �1��2�%3 4���5���6�������&� ����7� � 89:;<=>?@AB<C�DC@EC9�FB9=?;�FEB=�FGEBH?CH�IJ�DC;9B9@;�KC;?L�MIMI

KL;?NE;9�O9;�8P;B?;?ACQRSTUVTWXYZG9�[C9�ZG?CH�\>9B]�AH�[_C9B�GAPL=�<==�ZA�ZG9?B�AH�aAA=Bb�cEB;]QRSTUVTWXY\C9BH]�d?LL�FBPCeG9B�ALEB�fPA;9@QRSTUVTWXYgE?@9B�O9BNEC9C;9QRSTUVTWXYh�?HC@�<C=�]Ni;AN@�ZGE;�jAPB�AH�D@�DC�OE?CFEL?kABC?E�<iiBA>9@�8A�FA@;�ALEB�OBAHBEN�?C�EC�lA@9;?HNE�m99i@�i9AiL9�@?L9C;b�n9;o@�eGECH9�;GE;beAPBEC;beANeAPBEC;beANaABN9B�FACEB=�p?HG�eGAAL�ZBEem�FAEeGq�r9@;�pEB;kAB=�;P=9C;�Z9EeG9B�\C;9B@�8A;�sP?L;]OL9E3��������%� ���$������������ � ����������� ���������������� ��������� �����, ���������� ��&������� ��t#����#���� � ��� �������&��������� ���� �����&���� �� �����������&&���� ������u���v����� �� &������%� ���"� ������� � �(s9CA�<PB?9NNE�r9?HG@�DC�[C�KFACC�\:i9e;E;?AC@q�c9HEC�rELm9B�<C=�FABBPi;?ACw%� �������x� ��3 �������������������������&������33%�4����y��2����� �������� ������ ����������������z���������������(ZAi=P@;�kAB�89e;EBQRSTUVTWXYDC>9@;?CH�[P;LAAmQRSTUVTWXYr9�ZB?9=�ZG9�cE;;B9@@�\>9B]AC9�D@�{E>?CH�<|AP;bcEC�rGA�FELL9=�[r�MIqIII�pE@�PBiB?@?CH�89_�OB9=?e;?ACp9B9o@�rG]�sP]@�<B9�[|@9@@9=�r?;G�ZG?@�KC=9B_9EB}

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-3 Filed 01/24/19 Page 7 of 9

��������� ���� �������� ������������������ ������������������� ���������� ��!���"� ������ ��#�$�������%� �� �

���&'�����(�� �� �(����&���������#&��#)� ��#���#�� ����� �#��� �#�������*#�&��+� , ��&-��� � �� �#����(���� .��

/0123145/6167389:9;�<;=>�?@:ABCA�DEF;;�G:HG�I;JG�KL;:AMANJ�9CO:@B�@PAAMAN�QC@�R:HC@�CQ�S:@9QC@BTUVWX�YD45/61673?MLL�9@:EZ;@V�[I;@;�BC�Z;H�MGGP;G�G9:AB�MA�9I;�\CAA;E9MEP9�L;NMGL:9P@;]VUU�YD45/61673\CAA;E9MEP9JG�_>8>�G;A:9C@G�9C�@PR=V�<;C=;A�NCa;@AR;A9�:AB�9I;A�O;JLL�9:LZbYc�def�dUTg45/61673h;G=M9;�;L;E9MCA�LCGG;Gf�G9:9;�Fij�EI:M@R:A�N;9G�kTel�m=;@QC@R:AE;�nCAPGobYc�def�dUTg45/61673pMa;�@;:GCAG�GCR;�MA�\CAA;E9MEP9�:@;�G:HMAN�KACJ�9C�L;N:L�R:@MqP:A:bYc�def�dUTg

rst�uttvwx�yz{t|�}�~��v�utw�������������

������������ �������������������������

� ¡¢£�¤�¢¥¢¦�

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-3 Filed 01/24/19 Page 8 of 9

��������� ���� �������� ������������������ ������������������� ���������� ��!���"� ������ ��#�$�������%� �� �

���&'�����(�� �� �(����&���������#&��#)� ��#���#�� ����� �#��� �#�������*#�&��+� , ��&-��� � �� �#����(���� ���

./012345�67895:;<=>?::32@5.�;3AB:CDEFDE452�FD@9E5G

HI�JDGA37@:G�F5@D32G�K5:�L@E.�/M�>N5.�O@3PQ55:�:N5�RF�<C4.SG�@5P�TUV�WDEED3@�CD2A2CM:X32052�Y6�Z5.:3@�QC@@D@9�[D45G�\D:N�]DG�ZC2:@52�D@�>NDG�K329537G�QC@GD3@?25�37�L452�_I��[33BD@9�X32�[345�D@�FC@�a3G5�bcdef�gh�ijk�jgkflmnolpplkncgqnrkdql�ijk�gfodsdplturrlnn vwxyyz{|}y~wx�|�x���}v���x����y�|��y�����|��z�| �����������}y�������y�|y��|�z|�y~�z�x���~�wz��� � � � v����z�������������x�����}�v���x��

� ¡¢��£�¢¤¢¥�

Case 1:17-cv-02564-RC Document 66-3 Filed 01/24/19 Page 9 of 9

Recommended