View
220
Download
1
Category
Tags:
Preview:
Citation preview
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
1
STANDARDS PRIORITY TASK FORCE
NESCCJK August, ANS/Chair
ANSIWashington DCMarch 28, 2013
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
2
NESCC Charter
Discussions with NIST Scope of work Requests sent Jan-Feb Most responses
“We’re good” We use ANSI protocols; we’re always current Lists of nuclear standards used
Other
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
3
SDO Contacts
SDO Points of Contact Email Dist listACI (American Concrete Institute) Doug Sordyl Douglas.sordyl@concrete.org nACI (American Concrete Institute) Matthew Senecal Matthew.senecal@concrete.org nAISC (American Institute of Steel Construction) Charlie Carter carter@aisc.org nANS (American Nuclear Society) Jim August jkaugust@msn.com yASCE (American Society of Civil Engineers) John Stevenson jstevenson4@earthlink.net nASME Kevin Ennis ennisk@asme.org nASTM Intl. Joe Koury jkoury@astm.org yAWS (American Welding Society) Annette Alonso aalonso@aws.org nAWS (American Welding Society) Andrew Davis adavis@aws.org nIEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) James Gleason Gleason@ge.comIEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers)IEEE NPEC Jack Carter nISO (International Standards Organization) No contact yet identified nMSS (Manufacturing Standardization Society) David Thompson dthompson@mss-hq.org yNFPA (National Fire Protection Association) Paul May pmay@nfpa.org yNFPA (National Fire Protection Association) Meghan Housewright mhousewright@nfpa.org yNFPA (National Fire Protection Association) Greg Cade gcade@nfpa.org yOther email contacts
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
4
ANS Standards Priority
Standard/Title Priority
ANS 2.8 - Determining Design Basis Flooding 1
ANS 3.8.3 - Radiological Emergency Response Plans 2
ANS 57.3 - Design Requirements for New Fuel Storage 3
ANS 2.30 - Surface Faulting at Nuclear Facilities 4
ANS 57.10 -Design for Consolidation of LWR Spent Fuel 5
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
5
ANS Standards NESCC
Basis Discussion Original Idea (pre March 13, 2011:
Fukushima) New Construction Materials and Hardware Few Nuclear Processes
like Coding SSC for new plants Today
Support operating plants NEI support/Current vision Long-term disarray for processes support
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
6
Concerns
Are we getting new plant issues? Do we have the right priorities? Do we know what SDOs see or want? Do we know what will benefit new plants? Can we support new nuclear initiatives
like SMRs? Are we supporting new Gen3+ LWRs? Why aren’t nuclear utilities at the NESCC? Does NEI represent them adequately?
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
7
Do we have an effective plan to answer the question (ATQ)?
What do we need? Current thinking is that we lack the
information to ATQ Standards Database Effort was to help
organize that information We are dealing with around 1400
Standards and 500 Reg Guides, minimally That’s only starters
20 NRC document categories/Other Standard-like documents
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
8
NRC GoalGive us ‘Top 5’ to endorse
Endorsed, we will reference them in our Reg Guides
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
9
Everyone (NESCC)
Get priorities for work Understand how those fit, overall Especially between SMRs and
Gen3+LWRs Get focused to accomplish NESCC goals Improve use of nuclear standards
Existing New
Use nuclear standards to raise safety, simplify work, lower costs
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
10
Standards Database (DB)
Regulatory Guides versus Standards Keep track of needed work Allow cross-referencing and use of
existing standards Currently in paused mode Idea was to create a web-enabled
database accessible to all to cross references Regulatory Documents and Standards they referenced
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
11
Counts of Standard References in DCD/COL Submittals
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
12
Standard Reference Totals in DCD/COL Submittals
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
13
Request to Populate
400 Reg Guides
1400 Standards
This is a big table!!!!3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
14
Oh, by the way…Please provide this, too… ;)-
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
15
Conclusions
Rather complex Lots of information Needs to be done well, to be useful now… …and carry Nuclear Standards into the
future.
Basically, calls for a database approach
3/28/2013
NESCC Standards Meeting ANSI Washington, DC
163/28/2013
Recommended