THE NEW ROI - FRTR · The New ROI The New ROI - Outcome . Trajectory . Certainty . Source Treatment...

J Q i PE PG

THE NEW ROI Return on Investigation from Smart Characterization Methods

Joe Quinnan, PE, PG Nick Welty, CPG, PG

December 2, 2015 FRTR General Meeting

Site Characterization for Effective Remediation

Agenda • Health and SafetyHealth and Safety

Moment• R tReturn on

Investigation• Exit Ramp Strategies• Smart

CharacterizationCharacterization• Flux-Based CSMs

Health and SafetyInnovationInnovation

o The ROI f Smart The ROI of Smart CharacterizationCharacterization

30 November 2015 5

Full slurrywall

Smart characterization

Focused pumping

90% of relative flux in Return on Investigation Return on Investigation10% of cross-section

Client avoided di $5Mspending > $5M

on slurry wall

LNAPL recovery (> 25 acres)

LNAPL removal not required

Return on Investigation Return on Investigation

Client avoided spending $$4 - $$5M on active LNAPL recovery

Unknown plume extent

1-mile long, 10PPM VOC plume

R t I ti Return on Investiti gation

No active No active remediation required

E it R St t i

Return onReturn on InvestigationApproach ValueApproach Val

proposition

Exit Ramp Strategies

The New ROI

Align remedy with business strategy Exit Ramp Strategiesstrategy

Outcome certainty

LFlux-Based Least cost Smart Characterization

Flux Based Conceptual Site

The New ROI CurrentCurrent Trajectory

Total $$

Year 30 projected cost

savings

ROI pay back period

Year 30

Opptimized OpEx

Total $$ CapEx for Smart Characterization

Time © Arcadis 2015 30 November 2015 11

TheThe New ROI New ROI Current Current

Opptimized OpEx

Best CapEx for source

treatment or Outcome alternate tealterna

Total $$ strategy

Trajectory

Year 30 projected cost savings

ROI pay back periodperiod

Year 30 © Arcadis 2015 Time 30 November 2015 12

E it R St t i

Exit Ramp Strategiesstrategy

Outcome certainty

Return onReturn on InvestigationApproachApproach

The New ROI

Align remedy with business strategy

Background PW

Diffuse VOC plume PW

PW Characterized with S d monitoring wells

20 years of P&T

Clay 30 November 2015

The Problem

PWPW MassMass Removal

PW Time

Total Total $$ $$

Clay Time

30 November 2015

CurrentCurrent The New ROI The New ROI

Total $$

Trajectory

Smart characterization • Find mass that moves

Focus remedy Focus remedy Balanced approach:

• Align remedy withb i bj business objectiti ves

• Achieve return oninvestigationinvestigation

Current Trajectory

The New ROI The New ROI Current

Optimized OpEx

• Potential to reduce duration• Use Exit Ramps to ensure business solution

Flatten OpEx trajectory • Optimize P&T performance

Flatten OpEx trajectory

t Ca to e su e O

CurrentCurrent The New ROI The New ROI Trajectory

CapEx for source treatment

Total $$

period

OptimizedpOpEx

Best Outcome

• Optimize remedy performance• Align with business objectives• Limit CappEx to ensure ROI• Select alternative strategy or

management based on paybackperiod

E it R St t i

The New ROI

Outcome certainty

Exit Rampp 1 – Can P&T be optimized?

$50K investment

Goal: • Optimize P&T

• Reduce OpEx

increase mass removal

• Reduce duration &increase mass removal

30 November 2015 20

Exit Ramp 1 Result: Flux transect Result: Flux transect

• Plume is concentratedPlume is concentrated • Pumping can be

optimized• Change cost and

performance curve

Why is plume concentrated?

30 November 2015 21

E it R St t i

The New ROI

Outcome certainty

L Ne Generation Flux-Based Least cost Next Generation Smart

Characterization

HPTStratigraphic Flux HPTg p Relative permeability

Find the flux 0.1 1.0 10 100

Fine Sand

Coarse Sand

> 90% of flow is in

Interbedded d l

coarse sand zone

sand & silt

Stratigraphic Fluxg p HPT Relative permeability

Find the flux 0.1 1.0 10 100

Fine Sand

Coarse Sand

>90% of flux is in

Interbedded d l

coarse sand zone

sand & silt

PW? PW

Exit Ramp 2 -OpEx Optimization

• Consider ROI paybackon CapEx

• Verify plume geometry

30 November 2015 25

2630 November 2015

FFocus pumpiing on flfl ux… © Arcadis 2015

2730 November 2015

Optimize O EOpEx, enhance massmass recovery with lesswith less flow

CurrentThe New ROI – Flux- CurrentThe New ROI Flux Based CSM

OptimizedOptimized OpEx

• Optimize P&T performance•• Flatten OpEx trajectory

Trajectory

Flatten OpEx trajectory • Potential to reduce duration

Outcome Certaintyy?

Duration of P&T Or opportunity for optimized remedyremedy depends on source

source

Calibrating ROI Expectations • Remedy decisions dependent on more than least total cost

•• Align the remedy to meet expectations that match yourAlign the remedy to meet expectations that match yourbusiness needs in short- and long-term

Opptimized OpEx

Best CapEx for Outcome source

Total $$ treatment

• Select payback period to determine ifsource characterization & remedyaligns with business objective

• What ROI is required to optimize remedy?

Source Treatment – Exit Ramp

Flux-Based Source E lEvaluattiion • Mass

distributionrelative totransport andstorage zonesdictatetechnologies,endppoint, andcost

Is Smart source characterization worth the effort? Is Smart source characterization worth the effort? © Arcadis 2015 30 November 2015 32

Flux-based source evaluation – Transport zone

Coarse Sand >90% of flux in

Interbedded d l

coarse sand zone

Limited mass in difficult to treat sand & silt

Size is key

difficult to treat storage zone

Size is key cost factor

The New ROI - Outcome CurrentCurrent CertaintyCertainty Trajectory

Opptimized OpEx

Best CapEx for Outcome source treatmentTotal $$

• Evaluate payback period for CapEx ofSmart Characterization and sourceSmart Characterization and sourcetreatment

• Business decision to proceed

• Benefit of source evaluation

Flux-based source evaluation – storage zone source storage zone source

Coarse Sand

Interbedded d lsand & silt

Treatment approach is key approach is key cost factor

>90% of flux in coarse sand zone

Significant mass inmass in difficult to treat storage zone

Current The New ROI The New ROI - Outcome Trajectory Outcome Trajectory

Certainty Source

Treatment Optimized

OpExOpExCapEx for

source treatment • Benefit of source characterization

• C EX f t tCapEX of source treatmenttTotal $$ exceeds reasonable payback

• Optimize P&T performance• Fl tt O E t jFlatten OpEx trajecttory• Potential to reduce duration

For new sites, do it right the first time: SMART SMART

CONVENTIONAL CHARACTERIZATION V SS.

Investiggation • Years of effort• Dozens of reports & work

Remediation • Long-term, ineffective

remedy• Poor outcome certainty

Investigation • Weeks of effort using real-time

methods• ONE report & work plan

Remediation • Focused, cost-effective remedy• Outcome certainty with

t it t t h b iopportunity to match businessobjectives

30 November 2015 37

E it R St t i

Value proposition

The New ROI

Outcome certainty

Questions?Questions?

ArcadisArcadis Improving quality of life

ContactsContacts Joe Quinnan, PE (Wisconsin), PG Global Director Site Investigations/Emerging Contaminants Lead 24 years of experience, 15 with Arcadis Brighton, Michigan JQuinnan@Arcadis.com 810.225.1943

Nick Welty, PG, CPG Principal Geologist, Next-Generation Site Characterization Lead 10 years with Arcadis Brighton, Michigan NW l @A di NWelty@Arcadis.com 810.225.1958

THE NEW ROI - FRTR · The New ROI The New ROI - Outcome . Trajectory . Certainty . Source Treatment...

Documents

New Building Commissioning and ROI - bcxa.org · Kenny Reed, CEM, LEED AP, CxAP Commissioning Project Manager, Associate M.E. GROUP New Building Commissioning and ROI

New Source SPLASH

Frugalnomics Requires New ROI-Focused Sales & Marketing Approach

ROI in Social Media - New Life Event

Open Source Value: Beyond ROI

Maximizing Return On Identity (ROI) in a Brave New World

NEW SOURCE CONSTRUCTION PERMIT and SOURCE SPECIFIC

New Open Source

Nielsen Cracks the Code on ROI - RAB.com | Radio ...A breakthrough collaboration between Nielsen and various partners creating the first single- source ROI tool for radio

The real value of open source: ROI and beyond

New Energy Source

New ROI framework

New research supports Return On Investment (ROI) for

How To Improve The ROI Of Your New Product Launch

The True Cost of Open Source Software: Uncovering Hidden Costs and Maximizing ROI

Source Factors NEW

Open Source Return on Investment: Achieving the Financial … · 2012-11-03 · Open Source Return On Investment Whitepaper December 2006 The Value of Open Source By selecting high-ROI

Hugues Capet Vers 940-996. Source : Roi de France (987-996)

South Dakota Board of Regents - sdbor.edu...Lifetime Earnings Bonus 23 Source: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey (PUMS), 2013 ROI 7 to 1 ROI 12 to 1 ROI 10 to 1 ROI 17 to

BlackBerry ROI - Forrester's New Findings on Total Economic Impact