View
224
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
University of Groningen
Water vapour loss measurements on human skin.Valk, Petrus Gerardus Maria van der
IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite fromit. Please check the document version below.
Document VersionPublisher's PDF, also known as Version of record
Publication date:1984
Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database
Citation for published version (APA):Valk, P. G. M. V. D. (1984). Water vapour loss measurements on human skin. [S.n.].
CopyrightOther than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of theauthor(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons).
Take-down policyIf you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediatelyand investigate your claim.
Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons thenumber of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum.
Download date: 04-06-2019
WATER VAPOUR LOSS MEASUREMENTS ON HUMAN S K I N
WATERDAMPVERL I E SMET I NGEN VAN DE HU I D
STELLI NGEN
Bij produkten bes temd voor h u i dapp l i kati e d i ent het effekt van deze
produkten op de hui dbarri ere bestudeerd te worden ( d i t proefschr ift ) .
I I
Het i rr i terend vermogen van rei n i g i ngsmi ddel en op de hu i d wordt voor
een bel angri j k gedeel te bepaal d door het effekt van deze mi dde l en op
de barri erefun kti e van de huid ( d i t proefschr i ft ) .
I I I
Het gebru i k van de predi katen baby zeep en med i ci nal e zeep d i ent
vermeden te worden , daar gesugg ereerd wordt dat respekti evel i j k
baby zeep mi l der i s en dat med i ci na l e zeep hui dafwi j k i ngen voorkomt
of geneest . Sei de i s i n a l gemene z i n n i e t j u i s t ( d i t proefschri ft ) .
I V
Het verwijderen v a n de vern i x caseosa b i j d e pasgeborene met water en
zeep d i ent vermeden te worden .
v De eendimens i ona l e i ndel i ng van i ndrogend tot hydrerend zoa l s veel a l
toegepas t b i j h e t beschri j ven v a n h e t veh i cu l um gaat voorb i j a a n de
compl exe i n teract ie tu ssen de bestanddel en van het veh i cu l um en de
hoorn l aa g .
V I
Acetosal ( asp i ri neR) kan een dodel i j k geneesmi ddel z i j n voor pat i enten
met urt i car i a ( ga l bu l ten ) .
V I I
Voor de behandel i ng van scab i es met gammexaan 1% kan met een
appl i kati eduur van 6 uur worden vol staan ( J . Am . Acad . Dermatol . 9 :
546-550, 1983 ) .
V I I I
Het gebrui k van komb i nati epreparaten i n de dermatol ogi e d i ent beperkt
te worden tot s l echts enkel e i nd i katies .
I X
Epidemio l ogi sche gegevens omtrent het v66rkomen van hu idz i ekten di enen
mede de i nhoud van het onderw i j s te bepal en .
X
' Genet i c counsel i ng ' d i en t een bel angr i j k onderdeel van de dermato l og i e
te worden ( Dermato l og i ca 167 : 197-203 , 1983 ) .
X I
B i j d e i nterpretat i e van de bepa l i ng van het speci fi ek I g E d i en t d e
gevoel i ghei d van het shoc korgaan betrokken te worden (Am . Rev . Respi r .
D i s . 120 : 1053- 1058 , 1979 ) .
X I I
Met behul p van reg i onal e transcutane oximetri e kan een betrouwbare
i ndruk worden verkregen omtrent de oxygena ti e van de hu id ter pl aatse
en de onderl i ggende weefsel s ( D i abetes 33: 527-531 , 1984 ) .
X I I I
Marathonl opers zi j n , mi ts goed voorbereid , geen dood l opers .
Stel l i ngen behorende b i j het proefschri ft
' Water vapour l oss measurements on human sk i n ' .
P i eter G . M . van der Va l k , Groni ngen 18 december 1984 .
R I J KSUN I VERS ITE IT TE GRON INGEN
WATER VAPOUR LOSS MEASUREMENTS ON HUMAN SK IN
WATERDAMPV ERL I ESMET INGEN VAN DE HU I D
PROEFSCHR IFT
ter verkri j g i ng van het doctoraat i n de Geneesku nde
aan de R i j ksu n i vers i te i t te Groni ngen
op gezag van de Rector Magn i f i cus dr . E. Bl eum i n k
i n het openbaar te verded igen op d i nsdag
18 december 1 984 des nam iddags te 4 uur
door
Petrus Gerardus Mar i a van der Val k
geboren te Haa r l em
Promotor : Prof . Dr . E . Bl eum i n k
Referent : Dr . J . P . Nater
{ Thes i s , State Un i vers i ty of Gron i ngen , the Netherl ands , 1984 )
Aan m i j n vader
Th i s study was carri ed out i n the Occu pat i onal Dermatol ogy U n i t ( Head : dr . J . P . Nater ) o f the Department o f Dermatol ogy (D i rector: prof . d r . A . H . Kl okke ) , Un i vers i ty Hos p ita l , State Uni vers i ty of Groni ngen , the Netherl and s . I t was made pos s i b l e by grants from the Jan Korne l i s de Cock S t i c ht i ng and the Research Fund , Department of Derma tol ogy .
Stati s t i ca l man i pu l at i ons were performed on the Cyber 1 70/760 computer of the State Un i vers i ty Groni ngen , the Netherl and s , u s i ng MSUED I T , WESP and SPSS program packages .
3
Determi nat i on of water va pour l oss throug h s k i n by the Servo Med
Evaporimeter .
4
Contents
I ntroducti on .
Chapter 1 : The barri er funct i on of the s k i n aga i nst d i ffus i onal 8 wa ter l os s .
Barr i er funct i on of the s k i n and i ts rel a t i on wi th 28 i rr i tant and a l lerg i c contact dermati ti s .
Water vapour loss as i nd i cator for barri er funct i on 36 impa i rmen t .
Personal and envi ronmental vari ables i nfluenc i ng s k i n 40
wa ter vapour l os s .
Methods o f measuri ng the evapora ti ve water l os s of 46
huma n s k i n .
Cha pter 2 : S k i n i rri tancy of surfactants a s assessed by water 68 vapour loss meas urements .
Chapter 3: The vu l nerabili ty of the sk i n to surfactants i n
d i fferent groups o f eczema pati ents and control s
as determi ned by water vapour l oss .
81
Chapter 4 : The i nfluence of repeated s k i n exposure to surface 9 1
acti ve agents on water barri er a n d morpholog i c
pa rameters .
Chapter 5: Eczematous ( i rr i tant and a l l ergi c ) reacti ons of the 104
s k i n and barri er fu ncti on as determi ned by water
va pour l os s .
Chapter 6 : The i nfluence of l ow concentrati ons of i rr i tants on 121 sk i n barr i er function as determi ned by water vapour
l os s .
Chapter 7 : S k i n i rr i tancy of commerc i ally ava i l abl e soap and 1 29
detergent bars as measured by water vapour los s .
Cha pter 8: Summary and conc l us i on s .
Samenvatt i ng en conclu s i es .
Acknowledgement .
5
142
157
I ntroduction
I n severa l epidem i o l og i ca l stud i es on s k i n d i seases , eczema was found
to be the most important d i agnos t i c ca tegory .
Eczema can be c l as s i f i ed i nto ma ny types . These c l a s s i f i cati ons are
based on combi nat i ons of morphol og i ca l , eti ol og i ca l and consti tuti onal
features . In contact derma titi s externa l factors are ass umed to p l ay
a domi nant rol e i n the etio l ogy and can be c l a ss i fi ed as fol l ows :
- Acute tox i c contact derma t i t i s
- I rri tant contact dermati ti s
- Al l erg i c contact dermati ti s
- Phototoxi c contact dermati t i s
- Photoa l l erg i c contact dermat it i s .
Al l erg i c contact dermati t i s i s based on an immunol og i ca l phenomenon i n
wh i c h the s k i n reacts hypererg i ca l ly to a substance after prev i ous con
tact wi th that substance .
I rr i tant contact dermati ti s i s a term used to descri be a non- immunol o
gi ca l i nfl ammat ion of the sk i n , whi ch i s due to the i nfl uence of one
or more externa l factors .
The data ava i l ab l e at date i nd i cate that i n the major i ty of the cases
of contact dermati t i s i rr i tant factors p l ay a promi nent rol e .
I rri tant contact dermati t i s may show a n acute , subacute or chron i c
course . I n the chron i c type , the eczema i s mostly not caused by one
i rri tant factor but is cons i dered to be the resu l t of many damag i ng
factors . These factors may be of chemi ca l , phys i ca l or b i o l ogi cal ori g i n .
I rri tant factors may i mpai r the s k i n barr i er wi thout c l i n i ca l ( vi s i b l e )
effects upon the ski n . These effects o n the s k i n barrier have been shown
to be cumu l a t i v e .
I t i s hypothes i zed that s k i n barri er i mpai rment may pl ay a cruci a l rol e
i n the devel opment of chron i c i rr i tant contact dermat i ti s .
Among other methods , s k i n wa ter vapour l oss measurements have been used
to eva l uate s k i n barr i er funct i on i mpa i rmen t . Wi th thi s method the i n
crease i n s k i n wa ter vapour l os s i s cons i dered as an i nd i cati on of s k i n
barr i er defi c i ency .
The method of s k i n wa ter vapour l oss measurements may be appl i ed i n the
6
fo l l owing ways :
- For the assessment of the effect of i rri tants upon s k i n barri er func
t ion . Th i s is espec i a l ly rel evant for surface acti ve agents wh i ch are
known to have a profou nd effect upon the s k i n barr i er , wh i ch to a
grea t extent may para l l e l the s k i n i rri tancy of these substances .
Cumu l ati ve effects of repeated exposure upon the s k i n barr i er and the
course of barr i er repa i r in t ime can be eva l ua ted .
- After s tandardi zed exposure of the s k i n to one or more i rri tant fac
tors, i n ter i nd i v i dua l d i fferences in i mpa i rment of the barri er func
t ion may be as sessed . I f barr i er functi on is i ndeed dec i s i ve in the
deve l opment of chron i c i rri tant contact dermat i ti s , these d i fferences
may pl ay a cruci a l rol e i n i nteri nd i v i dua l d i fferences i n suscepti b i
l i ty t o i rr i tants and consequent ly i n suscepti b i l i ty to deve l o p
chron i c i rr i tant contact dermati ti s .
- The course of s k i n d i seases wi th concomi tant d i s turbances of barri er
functi on can be mon i tored by s k i n water va pour l os s measurements .
I n the seri es of s tudi es , presented i n thi s thes i s , an attempt was made
to contri bute to the f i r st two a ppl i cati ons .
7
CHAPTER 1
THE BARRIER FUNCTION OF THE SKIN AGAINST DIFFUSIONAL WATER LOSS
8
The barr i er functi on of the s k i n aga i nst d i ffu s i onal water l oss
Tota l water l oss
Di ffus i onal water l os s
cutaneou s l oss o f water ( vapour and dropl ets )
v i a pas s i ve d i ffu s i on through the epi derm i s
and by sweat g l and act i v i ty ;
water l os s through the s k i n by d i ffu s i on ,
emphas i z i ng the pas s i ve nature of th i s
process;
Transepi derma l water l os s water l os s through the s k i n by d i ffus i on ,
emphas i z i ng the l ocati on of the barr i er ( a
more prec i se but not frequently used term
wou l d be transcornea l water l os s ) .
An important func t i on of the s k i n i s i ts barr ier nature wh i ch protects
the body aga i nst the entry of fore i gn matters a nd prevents the l os s of
essent i a l substances l i ke water . Th i s protect i v e fu nct i on has been known
for centu r i es . Unti l the twent i eth century , the s k i n was genera l l y
regarded as bei ng impermeab l e to a l l substances , except perhaps for
vol ati l e substances and gases (1 , 2 ) . Ma i n ly through work done by
Schwenkenbecher at the turn of the century , the fa l l acy of the compl ete
impermeab i l i ty of the s k i n was gradua l l y d i spel l ed ( 1 , 3 ) .
H i s exper iments revea l ed that the s k i n i s permeabl e to substances wh i c h
are sol ub l e i n l i p i ds and to those i n t he gaseous state , b ut i s
pract i ca l l y impermeab l e to water and e l ectro l ytes . S i n ce that t ime , the
barri er fu nct i on of the s k i n has not been cons i dered to be absol ute ,
a l though i t can norma l l y be rel i ed on to protect agai nst mu l t i pl e
env i ronmenta l s tresses ( 4 ) .
The anatomi ca l bas i s of the barr i er agai nst cuta neous d i ffus i onal water
l oss
The preci se l ocat ion of the s k i n l ayer const i tuti ng the mai n barri er has
been a prob l em for many years . Based on t,i s experi ments , Rei n concl uded
i n 1924 that an el ectri cal dou b l e l ayer s i tuated between the stratum
corneum and the Ma l pi gh i an l ayer i s respons i b l e for the l ow permeabi l i ty
9
of the s k i n to i ons ( 5 ) . Others i dent i f i ed the stratum l u ci dum as the
ma i n barri er ( 6 ) .
The stratum l uc i dum , however , was not a l ways present i n the i nvesti gated
s k i n ( 2 ) . Th i s l ayer was detected w ith certa i nty only i n the s k i n of the
pa l ms of the hands and sol es of the feet . For th i s reason , Rothman i n
1932 proposed that the trans i t i onal l ayers between corni f i ed and noncor
ni f i ed epi dermi s shoul d be rega rded as the s i tes of impermeabi l i ty for
el ectrol ytes and water , wi thout spec i fying the h i sto log i ca l nature of
the trans i t i onal l ayers ( 2 ) .
As early as 1944 , Wi nsor and Burch p i npoi nted the stratum corneum as the
barri er aga i nst d i ffu s i onal water l oss ( 7 ) . This conc l u s i on was hard l y
accepted a t that t ime . Rothman ( 1 954 ) draw attenti on t o the great avi
d i ty w ith wh i ch the human horny l ayer takes up water from ei ther s i de ( 8 ) .
The horny l ayer was cons i dered as a porous membrane through wh i ch i ons
and l arge mol ecul es move rapi d l y . Th i s theory arose from the c l i n i ca l
p i cture o f many s k i n d i seases . The cus tomary h i stol og i ca l techni que of
prepar i ng and vi ewi ng the s k i n i n transverse secti on a l so contri buted
to th i s fau l ty i dea ( 1 ) . Ma l i ( 1 955 ) cons i d ered the stratum corneum as
a porous structure on ly s l i ght ly imped i ng the passage of water mo l ecul es
and concl uded that the l ayer wh i ch determi nes the barr i er for water i s
the barri er zone between the l i v i ng cel l s o f the stratum spi nosum and
the dead corn i f i ed stratum corneum ( 9 ) .
The adhes i ve stri pp i ng technique u s i ng cel l ophane tape to remove th i n
l ayers of stratum corneum offered a way to l ocate the barri er zone more
prec i sely ( 1 , 10 , 1 1 ) .
Us i ng th i s method , Bl ank ( 1952 ) concl uded that the stra tum corneum i s
the rate l i mi t i n g barri er for transepi dermal water l oss ( 12 ) . I n a
seri es of i nvesti gati ons , he made i t c l ear that repeated stri ppi ng i n
creased water di ffu s i on very l i ttl e unti l the base of the stra tum corneum
was reached . Al though he was aware of the defi c i ences of the stri ppi ng
method , he came to the concl us i on that not the enti re corn i fi ed epi the
l i um but a very th i n l ayer near the base of the stratum corneum formed
the maj or barr i er aga i ns t d i ffu s i ona l water l oss ( 13 ) .
Th i s l ayer , the stratum corneum conj unctum o r Szaka l l l ayer ( 14 ) , was
thought to be the rea l barr i er of the s k i n aga i nst water l os s for many
10
years . Monash and B l a n k ( 1 958 ) , al so us i ng the s tri ppi ng tech n i que wi th
cel l ophane adhes i ve tape , found that the water barri er cons i sted of the
i nner two-t h i rds of the s tratum corneum ( 1 5 ) . In 1 965 , B l a n k recons i dered
h i s resu l ts and came to the conc l u s i on that h i s data cou l d equa l l y we l l
be i nterpreted as implyi ng that the bu l k of the horny l ayer was u n i form ly
impermeab l e ( 1 , 4 ) . The concept of a un i form horny l ayer as the ma i n sk i n
barri er has been confi rmed by stud i es on the l ocation of substa nces
wi th i n the t i ssue some t ime after appl i cati on . The l a rgest amount has
a l ways been fou nd i n the outer l ayers and to decrease proporti onate ly
towards t he base ( 1 ) .
E l ectron mi croscopy has revea l ed the structure of the stratum corneum to
be a compact mu l t i l ayered ti ssue i n wh i ch the cel l s are i nterd i g i tated
and the i nterce l l u l ar spaces are fi l l ed . The el ectron mi crogra phs suggest
that a l l strata of the horny l ayer are equa l ly effect i ve , perhaps w i th
the excepti on of the one adj acent to the granu l ar l ayer , which may be
s l i ght ly more permeab l e because it is not yet fu l l y corn i f i ed , and the
outermost l ayers whi ch may be break i ng up and bei ng s hed ( 4 ) .
Al though not genera l l y accepted , t h i s v i ew has been acknowl edged by many
authors ( 1 4 , 1 6 -2 1 ) . The horny l ayer however i s not the s o l e obstac l e to
i nward passage . The skin can be cons i dered as a sys tem of mu l ti pl e com
pa rtments , a l l wi th the i r rate l im it i ng propert i es . I n heal thy s k i n ,
the stratum corneum i s deci s i ve for the tota l permeabi l i ty ( 17 , 22 ) .
For some substances , especi a l ly i f the horny l ayer i s defi c i ent , other
barri ers may pl ay a part ( 23 , 24 ) . Thi s has no impl i cati ons for the
i nvest i gati on of water l os s , because the horny l ayer prov i des the only
barri er for thi s .
The water l oss from stri pped s k i n ( horny l ayer removed ) i s about the same
as the water vapou r l oss at a water surface ( 1 3 , 25 ) .
11
Tab l e 1 . Rates of water vapour l oss from the surface of the forea rms as
reported by d i fferent i nvest igators .
Authors Method Cutaneous water vapour l os s ( g;m2h )
Gasse l t & V i erhout venti l ated chamber (dr i ed a i r ) ( 1963 ) ( 2 6 ) not standardi zed
Ohara & Ono ( 1963 ) ( 2 7 )
Spru i t & Ma l ten ( 1965 ) ( 2 5 )
Th i e l e & Senden ( 1966 ) ( 2 8 )
Ba ker & Kl i gman ( 1967 ) ( 2 2 )
Shah i du l l ah e t a l . ( 1 967 ) ( 2 9 )
Johnson & Shuster ( 1 969 ) ( 30 )
S ha h i du l l ah et a l . ( 1 969 ) ( 3 1 )
Lamke & Wed i n ( 197 1 ) ( 3 2 )
Lamke et a l . ( 197 6 ) ( 33 )
d e Jongh ( 1981 ) ( 3 4 )
u nventi l ated chamber neutral therma l cond i t i ons
venti l ated chamber ( d r i ed N2 ) not standard i zed
venti l a ted chamber (dr i ed N ) d i fferent envi ronmental con3 i t i ons
venti l ated chamber ( dri ed a i r ) ant icho l i nerg i c suppres s ion
unventi l a ted chamber not sta ndard i zed
venti l ated chamber ( d r i ed N2 ) anti chol i nerg i c suppress i on
venti l a ted chamber (dr i ed N2 ) a nti chol i nergi c suppres s i on
venti l ated chamber (moi s tened a i r ) neutral amb i ent cond i ti o ns
gradi ent estimat i on not s tandard i zed
venti l ated chamber ( dr i ed gas ) not s ta ndard i zed
12
4 , 8 - 9 , 0 ( ra nge )
12 , 7 (mea n )
8 , 8 � 3 , 7 (mea n and S . E . )
1 , 8 - 15 ( ra nge )
3 , 1 � 0 , 6 (mean a nd S . E . )
0 ,84 - 4 ,65 ( range )
3 , 5 � 0 , 4 (mean a nd S . E . )
1 , 9 - 6 , 4 ( ra nge )
1 2 , 3 � 1 , 4 (mea n and S . E . ) "
3 - 11 ( range )
+ 4 , 6 - 1 , 5 (mean and S . E . )
The bi ochem i cal bas i s of the s k i n barri er aga i nst cutaneous d i ffus i onal
water l oss
Probabl y , a l l major bi ochem i cal cons ti tu ents of the horny l ayer con
tri bute to the i ntegri ty of the s k i n barr i er aga i nst transepi derma l
water l oss ( 3 5 ) . The rel at i ve importance of l i p i ds , prote i ns and carbo
hydrates i n l i m i t i ng water l os s by evaporati on has , however , been debated
( 3 5 , 36 ) . The importance of kerat i n , i ntracel l u l ar and i ntercel l u l ar
l i p i ds and water sol u b l e substances has been emp ha s i zed ( 9 ,36-41 ) . I t
has a l so been postu l ated that not the absol ute quant i t i es o f horny l ayer
components but the compl ex i nterrel ati ons h i p between them i s i mportant
for the s k i n barr i er capac i ty ( 42 ) .
Primari l y prote i n , the ma i n component of the horny l ayer ( Tabl e 2 ) , was
cons idered as bei ng ch i efly i nvol ved i n l i m i t i ng evaporative water l os s ,
espec i a l l y the t i ght network of kerati n f ibres ( 38 , 40 ) . However , kerat i
nolyt i c agents were found to have n o or onl y s l i ght effects o n the water
barri er of the s k i n ( 43 , 44 ) . If the barri er was mos tly prov ided by the
kerat i n mo i ety , one wou l d expect a d i rect correl at ion between the th i ck
ness of the horny l ayer and transepi dermal water l os s ( 41 ) . However , the
thi ckness of the horny l ayer and d i ffu s i onal water l os s correl ate poorly
( 45 ) . The t h i c kness and water d i ffu s i veness seem to compl ement each other
l ead i ng to rather constant permeabi l i ty ( Tab l e 3 ) . These reg i onal d i ffe
rences i n permeabi l i ty cannot be expl a i ned on the bas i s of d i fferences
i n the chemi cal nature of the kerat i n mol ecu l e1 ( 40 ) . Al though there i s
ev i dence that the structural protei ns of the cytopl asm and the cel l
envel ope p l ay a part i n the barri er funct i on . The rol e i n l i m it i ng
transepi derma l water l os s i s rel at i vely sma l l ( 36 ) .
The centra l rol e of l i p i d s i n regu l at i ng transepi derma l water l oss has
been demons trated by many i nvesti gators ( 13 , 3 6 , 3 9 , 41 -44 ,46 ,47 ) . The
greatest i ncrease in d i ffus i ve water l os s was found after treat i ng the
1 . Reg i onal var i at i on in horny l ayer l i pi ds i s more l i kely to be respons i b l e for d i fferences in permeab i l i ty ( Tab l e 4, p . 20 ) .
1 3
Tab l e 2 . Consti tuents of human dry corn i f i ed epithel i um . _[ro� Mato l tsy
& Bal samo (1955) ( 93) .
So l ub l e epi derma l kerati n :t 10 %
D i a lyzab l e substances !" 10 %
Epi derma l kerati n :t 65 %
L i p ids 7 -9 C{ ,,
Res i stant cel l membranes :!; 5 %
Tab l e 3 . Regi onal var i at i on i n water permeabi l i ty
p l ei n & B l a n k ( 1 9 7 1 � (45).
S k i n reg i on Js c5 om
Abdomen 0 . 34 15 . 0 6 . 0
Vol ar forearm 0 . 3 1 1 6 . 0 5 . 9
Back 0 . 29 10 . 5 3 . 5
Forehead 0 . 85 13 . 0 12 . 9
Scrotum 1 . 70 5 . 0 7 . 4
Back of hand 0 . 56 49 . 0 32 . 3
Pa lm 1 . 14 400 535 . 0
P l antar so l e 3 . 90 600 930 . 0
Js steady state f l ux of water (mg cm- 2hr- 1 )
o th i c kness of the horny l ayer (em x 10-4 )
D = d i ffus i on constant ( cm2sec- 1 x 10- 1 0 ) m
14
at 30°C . From Scheu------
s k i n w i th del i p i d i z i ng sol vents . Other exper imenters cou l d not confi rm
the importa nce of l i p i d extract i on for barr i er function ( 38 ) . Th i s
d i screpancy may be exp l a i ned by the fact that b r i ef immers i on i n or
appl i cat i on of l i p i d sol vents only removes superfi c i a l l i p i d s , proba b ly
un i mporta nt for barr i er funct ion ( 38 ) . Moreover , l i p i ds compl exed w i th
prote in s and carbohydrates and protected by a hydroph i l i c zone prevent i ng
the so l vents from reach i ng the l i p i d s are not sol u b l e i n very nonpo l a r
sol vents ( 39 ) . These compl ex l i p i ds c a n be extracted more effecti vely by
a combi nat ion of pol ar and nonpo l a r sol vents ( 45 ) . I t i s a l so sugges ted
that water extract i on after del i p i d i zati on removes pol ar substances i m
portant for barr i e r funct i on i f unprotected by l i p i d s { 1 3 ) .
Not a l l horny l ayer l i pi ds are equa l ly i mportant for barr i er capaci ty
( 3 5 ) . Recent s tud i es i nd i cate that essenti a l fatty ac id s may be part i cu
l a r ly i nvol ved i n the i nteg r i ty of the water barri er of the s k i n ( v i de
i nfra ) .
The rol e of stratum corneum hydrat ion i s a l so emphas i zed ( 2 1 , 3 7 , 38 , 48-
50 ) . The water b i nd i ng capac i ty of the corneocyte i s attri buted to
fi brou s protei n and water sol u b l e substances wi t h i n the cel l i n add i t i on
to the osmoti c funct ion of the cel l membrane ( 2 1 , 38 , 48 , 49 ) . I t i s sugges
ted that bou nd water mol ecu l es form a barr i er aga i n st d i ffus i ng free wa
ter mol ecu l es ( 49 ) .
I f the horny l ayer cel l s have a defi c i ent water b i nd i ng capa c i ty , e . g . ,
due to damage to the cel l membranes , th i s may l ead to both hydrat i on and
i ncreased d i ffus i ve water l os s ( 2 1 , 3 7 ,48 , 49 ) . The barr i er funct ion i s
a l so i mpai red i n the case of exces s i ve hydrat i on ( 48 , 49 ) . 'Pores' may be
opened by t h i s exces s i ve hydrat i on through wh i c h d i ffus i on of water may
be faci l i tated ( 49 ) .
The essenti a l fatty a c i d component of horny l ayer l i p i ds
Both the l i p i d wei g ht percentage and the compos i t i on of the l i p i d s of
the horny l ayer a re importa nt for the barri er funct ion of the s k i n
( 46 , 51 , 52 ) . Topograp h i c var i a t i on i n permeabi l i ty can b e l argely
expl a i ned by quant i ta t i ve d i fferences i n l i p i d content ( 46 ) .
Recentl y , part i cu l ar a ttent ion has been devoted to es senti a l fatty ac i d
1 5
components of the stratum corneum l i p i d s . I t has been demonstrated that ,
i n essent i a l fatty aci d defi c i ent rats and humans , qual i tat ive di ffe
rences i n l i p i d compos i t i on i n compar i son w i th norma l s can a l so be found .
The def i c i ency i s refl ected i n abnorma l fatty ac id moi et i es i n epi derma l
phospho l i p i d s wh i ch correl ate with ma rked barr i er funct i on impai rment
wi th respect to wa ter ( 52-56 ) .
Top i ca l appl i cati on of sunfl ower seed o i l (whi ch i s ri ch i n l i no l ei c
aci d } proved to l ower the rate of transepi derma l water l oss i n these
essent i a l fatty ac id defi c i ent rats and huma ns ( 39 , 53 ) . It has been
shown that sunfl ower seed oi l rapi d l y restores the h i gh rates of trans
epi dermal water l oss of sk in treated w ith a so l u ti on of sod i um l aurate
( 54 ) . Th i s water retardent property of sunfl ower seed oi l proved to be
the res u l t of its h i g h content of l i no l ei c ac i d . Al though other
cutaneous ly appl i ed fatty aci d tr ig lyceri des are a l so metabo l i zed and
i ncorperated i nto the comp l ex l i p i ds of the s ki n , only l i no l e i c- and
y- l i no l e n i c ac id restore the barri er functi on ( 55 ) . It is concl uded
that d i fferent fatty ac ids may have vary i ng roles i n the epidermis ,
l i nol ei c ac id bei ng parti cu l ar ly i nvol ved i n the i nteg r i ty of the water
barri er ( 3 5 , 56 ) .
However , i t has been demonstrated that the water retardent property of
l i no l e i c acid is not compound spec i fi c , s i nce several syntheti c , d i enoi c ,
transconfi gurated fatty aci ds can substi tute for l i neol ate ( 57 ) . The
questi on of wh i ch stratum corneum l i pi d s refl ect the abnorma l i ty of
barri er functi on rema i ns to be answered ( 52 ) .
L i nol e i c ac id compri ses only a mi nor fracti on of horny l ayer fatty ac id
moi et i es ( 58 ) a nd l i p i ds conta i n i ng esteri fi ed l i no l e i c a c i d may p l ay
a rol e ( 52 ) .
Modern v i ew of subce l l u l ar horny l ayer orga n i zati on : a two-compartment
mode l
Di fferent model s have been proposed t o expl a i n t h e subce l l u l ar organ i za
t i on of the horny l ayer and thus of the s k i n water barri er (46 , 52 , 59 ) .
Ear l i er model s were based on c i rc u l a r protein cyl i nders coa ted with
l i p i d mol ecu l es ( Fi g . I ) ( 59 ) . The horny l ayer was cons i dered as a
16
Fig . I .
Intracel l u l ar keration in the stratum corneum . From Scheupl ein and B l ank ( 4 5 ) .
•
Fig . I I . Col umnar pattern of the ( huma n ) horny l ayer . From Mackenzie ( 63 ) .
17
Fi g . I I I .
stratum corneum 1�.·.;.::; �:·{:::.·.: � � -· ··· · .: � •t."• .::·· �· • . :� .:.:· \ ... . �· .. . : '.. ..... ·: .. :
components
CORNEOCYTES
IC LAMELLAR L I P I D
brick wall
components
BRI CKS
MORTAR
Current concept of the stratum corneum as a two-compartment system , in
wh ich cel l s can be ana l ogized to bri cks , and i ntercel l u l ar l amel l ae to
mortar . From El i a s et a l . ( 52) .
18
homogeneous sheet of fi bri l s i nters persed w ith a shel l of amph i pati c
l i p i d ( 59 ) . Th i s kerat i n - phosphol i p i d compl ex i ns i de the corneocyte
was presumed to be the major pathway for penetrati on . The i ntercel l u l a r
spaces were d i sm i ssed because o f thei r sma l l volume ( 45 ) . Recent h i sto
chemi ca l stud i es s how a stratum corneum cel l devo i d of l i p i d and l arge
i ntercel l u l ar spaces f i l l ed mos tly wi th nonpo l a r l i p i ds ( 58-60 ) .
Di rect evi dence has a l so become ava i l abl e that epi cutaneous ly appl i ed
subs tances permeate v i a the i ntercel l u l ar s paces ( 6 1 ) .
I n the stratum granu l osum , the i nterce l l u l a r vol ume i s gross ly d i stended
as a resu l t of accumu l ated l amel l ar body contents ( 59 ) . These l amel l ar
bod i es , a l so ca l l ed membrane-coati ng g ranu l es , Odland bod i es , cementa
somes or kerati nosomes ( 52 ) , are sma l l bod i es wi th a l ame l l ar s tructure
l ocated in the cel l s of the m i depi dermi s ( 62 ) . In the h i gher epi derm i s ,
they mi grate to the per i phery of the cel l and a re extruded i nto the
i ntercel l u l ar s pace . I n i t i a l l y , much of the substru cture i s reta i ned
after expu l s i on . I n the s tratum granul osum , the l amel l a e rema i n
segregated i nto foca l accumu l at ions of rel ati ve ly pol ar d i scs and matr i x
( 59 ) . I n the horny l ayer , th i s l amel l ar materi a l i s transformed i nto
broad mu l ti l am i n ated i nterce l l u l ar sheets of l i pi ds corre l at i ng w i th a
stri k i ng s h i ft from pol ar l i p i d s ( p hos phol i p i ds ) to nonpol ar l i p i ds
( tr i g lycer i des , free s terol s , free fatty ac i ds , sterol esters ) ( 5 1 , 5 2 ,
58-60 ) ( Ta b l e 4 ) .
These f i nd i ngs are expres sed i n the hypothes i s depi cti ng the s tra tum
corneum as a two- compa rtment system of l i pi d depl eted cel l s surrounded
by l i p i d enri ched cel l u l ar doma i ns ( 52 ) , mos t ly organi zed i n a col umnar
pattern , accordi ng to Mackenz i e ( 1983 ) ( 63 ) ( F i g. I I , I I I ) . I n the
desquamat i ng s tage of kerati n i sat i on , these d i fferences between the
corneocyte and i ntercel l u l ar s pace probab ly d i s a ppear , whi l e corneum
l i pi ds i n the su perf i c i a l s tratum were found to be u n i formly d i stri buted
throughout and between the cel l s ( 64 ) .
The rel at i ve importance of the cel l u l a r and i ntercel l u l a r pathways for
l i pi d sol ubl e and water sol ubl e substances i s u nknown, a l though the
i ntercel l u l a r doma i n is mos t important for the water barr i er capa c i ty of
the horny l ayer ( 52 , 58-60 ) .
19
Tabl e 4 . Reg i onal var iat i on and strati f i cation of human stra tum corneum l i p i d s . lro� E l i a s et a l . (52 ) .
Outer Whol e stratum corneum Stratum Strata
stratum Abdomen P l antar granu l osum basa l e/ s p i nosum
corneum
L i p i d WT { '; ) 6 . 5 : 0 . 5 2 . 0 : . 6 ND ND
Fract ion
Pol ar l i p i d s 2 . 3: 0 . 5 4 . 9 : 1 . 6 4 . 5 : 0 . 4 25 . 3 : 2 . 6 44 . 5 ± 3 . 4
Chol esterol s u l fa te 3.4 : 0 . 5 1 . 5 ± 0 . 2 3 . 4 ± 1 . 2 5 . 2 ± 1 . 4 2 . 6 ± 1 . 0
Neutra l l i p i d s 68 . 4: 2 . 1 77 . 7 ± 5 . 6 63 . 9 : 3 . 6 60 . 9 ± 9 . 1 50 . 0 ± 4 . 5
Free s terol s 1 8 . 4 ± 2 . 1 14 . 0 ± 1 . 1 2 3 . 1 ± 9 . 0 10 . 5 ± 1 . 6 12 . 1 ± 1 . 0 0
Free fatty ac id s 1 5 . 6 ± 3 . 0 19 . 3 ± 3 . 7 N
20 . 0 ± 12 . 3 9 . 2 ± 1 . 5 7 . 0 ± 2 . 1
Tr i g l ycer i des 1 1 . 2 ± 1 . 5 2 5 . 2 : 4 . 6 8 . 5 ± 2 . 2 24 . 7 ± 4 . 0 12 . 4 ± 2 . 9
Nonpol ar Nls 19 . 4 ± 2 . 6 1 6 . 3 ± 6 . 5 1 2 . 3 ± 1 . 2 14 . 3 ± 1 . 1 16.7 ± 0 . 7
Sterol /wax esters 6 . 4 : 1 . 4 6 . 4 ± 1 . 4 6 . 7 ± 1 . 0
Squa l ene 3 . 8 ± 1 . 6 4 . 6 ± 1 . 0 5 . 9 ± 0 . 9
n-Al kanes 2.1 ± 0 . 7 3 . 3 ± 0 . 8 4 . 1 ± 0 . 3
Sphyngol i p i d s 26 . 6 2 . 3 1 8 . 1 2 . 8 30 . 1 ± 6 . 3 1 1 . 7 ± 2 . 7 7 . 3: 1 . 0
G lycol i p i d-! 2 . 7 1 . 4 2 . 9 3 . 2 2 . 0
G l ycol i p i d - 2 2 . 7 0 . 5 1 . 1 1 . 4 1 . 5
Ceram i des 7 .l 1 2 . 4 19 . 6 4 . 1 1 . 7
Ceram i des/Nls 7 .l 3 . 8 6 . 2 2 . 9 2 . 1
The phys i o l ogical bas i s of cutaneous water l oss
Tota l wa ter l oss from the skin has been trad i t i ona l l y d i v i ded i nto a
v i s i b l e l oss of water by sweat g l and act i v i ty a nd macros cop i c i nv i s i b l e
water l oss from " pers p i rat io i nsens i b i l i s " ( 8 , 6 5 ) . Th i s nomencl ature has
the shortcom i ng that it does not i nd i cate the ori g i n of the water l os s of
the s k i n . Moreover , qu i te l a rge quanti t i es of water l osses from , e . g . ,
the palms of the hand , may be i nv i sibl e ( 7 , 8 , 66 ) .
I n fact , the ma i n sources of cutaneous water l os s are the sweat g l ands
and the conti nuous fl ow of water through the epi dermi s , the l a tter cal l ed
by Rothman ( 1954 ) transepi derma l water l os s ( 8 ) . Mi nor sources of water
l os s may be desorpt i on of the horny l ayer cel l s ( after bei ng hydrated ,
e . g . , by sweat ) and dehydrat ion of cel l u l ar protopl asm during kerat i n i
zation (8 , 2 2 , 67 ) . Water l os s through sebum may be negl ected , as th i s
l oss i s very sma l l and on ly about 1 m l per day ( 68 ) . Water l oss v i a the
pi l osebaceous uni t may be i mportant , a l though i t s surface area i s very
sma l l i n compari son wi th the unbroken stratum corneum ; the l arger shunt
d i ffus i veness of water is more than compensated for by the muc h sma l l er
effecti ve area of the shunt pathway ( 1 , 16 , 69 , 70 ) .
On the bas i s of these facts , many i nvesti gators attri bute total water
l oss from the s k i n to a fl ow through the stratum corneum ( transep i dermal
water l os s ) and a f l ow through the sweat g l and a s vapour or as dropl ets
( 7 , 8 , 66 , 67 ) . Transepi dermal water l oss is descri bed i n terms of d i ffu s i on
through the "membrane- l i ke " s tructure of the horny l ayer and i ts appen
dages , i nc l ud i ng the sweat g l and epi thel i um ( 66 ) .
The sweat g l and i s con s i dered as a functi onal un i t neura l ly acti vated
by acety l chol i ne ( 66 , 6 7 ) .
Transepi dermal water l oss
Transepi derma l water l oss can be cons i dered as a fl ow by d i ffu s i on
through the s tratum corneum structure , based purely on phys i cochemi cal
l aws ( 35 , 7 1 , 7 2 ) . It has been suggested that water i s acti vely transported
i nto the s k i n ( 1 , 69 , 73 ) . Acti ve transport of water , however , seems very
un l i ke l y . The water barr i er functi on i s essenti a l l y the same i n v i vo and
2 1
i n v i tro and i s mai ntai ned l ong after the s k i n i s removed from the body
( 73 , 7 4 ) . The stratum corneum , mai nly res ponsib l e for the d i ffu s i onal
res i s tance , cons i sts of h i g h l y d i fferent i a ted but metabol i ca l ly i nacti ve
ti ssue ( 3 5 , 7 2 ) . The physi cochem i ca l l aws of pa s s i ve d i ffu s i on are l argely
obeyed ( 1 , 3 5 , 69-72 ) .
Pa s s i ve d i ffu s i on can be descri bed by F i c k ' s l aw:
J s amou nt of water per u n i t area and t ime
transported throu gh the stra tum corneum
Kp permeabi l i ty constant
6Cx d i fference i n concentrat ion on both
s i tes of the stratum corneum
Th i s equation can be ex panded i n ( 6 9, 7 5 ) :
part i t i on coeff i c i ent ; i n the case of
water , the sol ub i l i ty coeff i c i ent
d i ffu s i on coeff i c i ent
th i ckness of the stratum corneum
The proport iona l i ty of vapour l os s to vapou r pressure i s wel l establ i shed .
Thus , F i ck ' s l aw can a l so be wr i tten a s ( 7 5 , 7 6 ) :
6R.H. = d i ffere nce i n rel ati ve hum i d i ty on
both s i des of the stratum corneum .
The rel at i ve humi d i ty on the i nner
face of the stratum corneum can be
con s i dered as 100 ( 22 ) .
This equat i on means that , i f the horny l ayer behaves l i ke an i deal mem
brane , the trans fer of water i s dependent u pon amb i ent humi d i ty and the
t h i ckness a nd membrane qual i t i es ( i nteg r i ty ) of the horny l ayer ( 1 2 ) .
F i c k ' s l aw proved appl i cabl e a s far a s proport i onal ity w ith the th i ckness
of the horny l ayer is concerned ( 4 , 1 6 , 22 ) . The proportional ity with the
d i fference i n re l at i ve hum i d i ty , however , does not perfectly fit the l aw
of F i c k . The l os s of d i ffu s i ve water decreases when the ambi ent humi d i ty
i ncreases , but not to an extent that wou l d be expected on the bas i s of
F i c k ' s l aw ( d i fference i n re l at i ve hum id i ty decreases i f amb i ent hum i d i ty
i ncreases ) ( 77 ) . The i ncrease i n permeabil i ty for water at h i g h environ
mental humi dity can be explained by a bsorption of water . The higher water
content of the horny l ayer a l ters the permeabi l i ty constant of the s k i n ,
22
Tab l e 5 . Permeab i l i ty of water through monol ayers , fi lms , cel l u l ar
membranes and i ntegument . From_2�heu p l e i n & B l a n k ( 1 971" ) (45) .
Mono l ayers
Thi ckness , Permeab i l i ty em . Constant
em/ sec .
C l ean wa ter i nterface 3 x 10- 8
Long-cha i n a l i phat i c a l cohol 2 x 10- 7
monol ayer at a i r-wa ter
5 X 1 02
( 1- 2 ) X 1 0- 1
i nterface
Phosphol i p i d b i l ayer
( tetra decane l ec i th i n )
F i lms
Stagnant water l ayer
My l a r
Tef lon
Saran
Ce l l u l ar membranes
Human erythrocytes
Human l eucocytes
F i brob l a sts i n t i s sue
Arbac i a eggs
I ntegument
Frog s k i n
cu l ture
Human stratum corneum
Human derm i s
- 7 - 4 6 . 1 X 10 3 . 3 X 10
2 . 0 X 10- 3 1 X 1 0-2
2 . 0 X 10-3 1 . 5 X 10- 7
2 . 0 X 10-3 3 . 1 X 10-8
2 . 0 X 10-3
2 . 0 X 10-8
5 . 0 X 10- 7 1 . 3 X 10-2
1 X 10-6 2 . 8 X 10-3
1 X 10-6 6 . 2 X 10- 3
( 2- 8 ) X 10-4
7 X 10 - 5
2 X 10- 3 2 . 5 X 1 0- 7
4 X 10- 1 5 X 1 0-6
23
D i ffu s i on Constant cm2/ sec .
1 . 5 X 10- 5
( 2- 4 ) X 1 0-8
2 . 5 X 10- 5
3 . 0 X 10- 10
6 . 2 X 10- 1 1
4 . 0 X 10- 1 1
6 . 5 X 10-9
2 . 8 X 10-9
6 . 2 X 10-9
5 X 10- 1 0
2 X 10-6
resul ting in facil itation of water pas sage ( 77 ) . I t shou l d be noted that
skin diffusion constants may vary from one s kin region to another ( Ta bl e
3 ) { 6 ) . The diffu sion constants are a l so a refl ection of constitutiona l
and environmental factors ( 78 , 79 ) .
Sweat g l and activity
Human sweat g l ands are described as merocrine and are usual ly divided
into apocrine and eccrine sweat g l ands ( 80 ) . This division has been
criticized because apocrine secretion is not substantiated in human
beings ( 80-82 ) . It has been shown that during apocrine sweating the
apices of the secretory cel l s are not s hed , but sma l l portions of apica l
cytopl asm are pinched off ( 82 ) . I t is proposed to use the description
epitrichia l for apocrine swea t g l and s , since they norma l ly devel op from
the externa l root sheath of the hair fol l ic l e , and atrichia l for eccrine
sweat g l ands , because they have no re l a tion with the hair fol l ic l e .
Atrichia l ( eccrine ) sweat g l ands devel op from the superficia l epidermis
and remain independent from the hair fo l l ic l e ( 80 , 83 ) .
The epithrichia l ( a pocrine ) sweat g l ands are common ly found in the
axil l a , the perianal region and the areo l a of the breasts , a l though
ectopic g l ands may be found e l s ewhere on the body surface ( 80 ) . It may
be concl uded that epitrichial sweat g l ands , except for the axi l l ary
region , have a l imited physiol ogical funct i on ( 84 ) . Because of these
facts , the contribution of the epitrichia l sweat g l and to skin water l os s
c a n b e neg l ected .
The atrichia l (eccrine) sweat gl and in man
The sweat g l and activity in man is quite variabl e and is regu l ated by
central sudo-motor activity , l ocal conditions and hormona l factors ( 85 ) .
Both differences in sweat g l and density and activity of the individual
sweat g l and a re responsib l e for regional differences in sweat g l and
production ( Tab l e 6) ( 8 , 80 , 85 ) . Variations in sweating due to sex , race
and age have a l so been reported ( 8 , 85 ) . Racial differences in sweat
g l and density have been observed . These differences probab ly refl ect
24
Tabl e 6. D i s tr i but i on of eccr i ne g l ands i n man (per square i nch of
surface area ) . From Rothma n (1�54) (8) .
Pa l ms
Sol es
Dorsa of hands
Forehead
Chest and abdomen
Forearm
f l exor as pect
2 . 736
2 . 685
1 . 490
1 . 2 58
1 . 136
1 . 123
extensor aspect 1 . 093
Dorsa of feet
T h i g h and l eg
med i a l as pect
l ateral as pect
Cheek
Nape of neck
Back and buttocks
25
0 . 924
0 . 576
0 . 554
0 . 548
0 . 41 7
0 . 41 7
an adaptat i on phenomenon to hot c l imates rather than bei ng ba sed on
genet i c d i fferences { 8 , 85 ) .
The onset of swea t i ng i n response to heat becomes more del ayed wi th age
i n ma l es , wherea s i n fema l es the del ay t ime i s grea te�in adu l t l i fe
{85 ) .
The funct ion of the atr i c h i a] sweat g l and i s dependent on an i ntact
sympatheti c nerve supp ly . Denerva t i on l eads i n i t i a l ly to a fast
functi onal arrest wi thout h i sto l og i ca l changes ( 86 ) . Central acti vati on
occurs by therma l , menta l and gustatory s t i mul i from hypotha l am i c and
cort i ca l centres ( 8 , 80 , 85 ) . The efferent pathways i nvol ve nerve fi bres
synaps i ng i n the medu l l a , l a teral horn of the sp i na l cord and sympathet i c
gangl i a . The postgang l i on i c nerve fi bres a re phys i o l og i ca l ly and
anatomi cal ly sympathet i c , but pharmacol og i ca l ly parasympatheti c ( 85 ) .
The nerve end i ngs wh i ch exc i te the atr i c h i a] sweat g l ands l i berate
acetyl chol i ne , i n contras t to a l l other pos tgang l i on i c sympathet i c
fi bres ( 87 ) . Adrena l i n a l so has some effect o n the sweat g l ands , a l though
i ts phys i o l og i ca l rol e rema i ns uncl ear { 88 ) .
Recentl y , a l oose network of catechol ami ne conta i n i ng nerves a round sweat
g l and of monkey paws , whi ch may a l so be present i n man , has been demon
s trated ( 89 ) . Therma l swea t i ng is control ed by thermoregu l atory centres
i n the hypothal amus wh i ch are acti vated by changes in the temperature
of perfu s i ng b l ood. Afferent st imu l i from the s k i n and cort i ca l impu l ses
may a l ter the acti v i ty of these centres ( 85 ) .
Therma l sweati ng occurs most ly on the s k i n of the face and trunk , but
a l so occurs on the who l e body , i ncl udi ng the palms of the hands and sol es
of the feet ( 80 ) .
The centres control l i ng menta l and gus tatory swea t i ng are not fu l l y known .
There are , however , centres wi th i n the frontal reg i on of the bra i n wh i ch
st imu l ate swea t i ng , espec i a l ly of the pa l ms and sol es , but a l so i n the
axi l l a e , on the forehead or profuse , under i ntel l ectual or emoti onal
i nfl uences . Gusta tory swea t i ng occu rs phys i o l og i ca l l y in many persons
on the l i ps , forehead and nose after eat i ng hot , sp i cy foods ( 8 , 80) .
26
I n h i b i t i on of atri chi a l (eccr i ne) sweati ng
To study transepi derma l water l oss and thus the barri er fu nction of the
horny l ayer , the very vari abl e sweat g l and acti v i ty has to be restr i cted
as much as poss i b l e ( 67 ) . Abol i t i on of sweati ng i s attempted by use of
anti chol i nerg i c compounds such as atrop i ne , pol d i ne methosu l phate and the
scopo l amine ester of hexopyrron i um brom ide ( 8 , 22 , 3 1 ,34 ,67 , 68 ) .
I ndeed , cutaneous evaporati on can be l owered by anti chol i nerg i c drugs
( 90 ) . It is stated that neura l ly contro l l ed swea t i n g i s comp l ete ly
i nh i b i ted by atropi ne ( 88 ) . The questi on , however , i s whether a sweat
gl and sti l l produces water vapour i f i t i s not s t imul a ted . Th i el e et a l .
( 1 981 ) dep i cts the sweat g l and as be i ng equ i va l ent to a "heat p i pe" ( 9 1 ) .
I t i s assumed to function i n thermoregu l at i o n . Water i s secreted by the
fundus of the g l and and evaporates near the base of the duct . The bu l k
of th i s vapour wi l l recondense near the outl et of the g l and and wi l l
return v i a cap i l l ary acti on or by osmos i s . I n th i s way , the sweat g l and
contr i butes cons i derab ly to the thermal regu l a ti on of the body wi th
mi n ima l l os s of water , anal ogous to a "heat pi pe " ( 9 1 ) . (A " heat pi pe"
i s used i n engi neeri ng to transfer heat at h i gh effi c i ency . ) I t i s doubtful whether th i s hydrodynami c f l ow v i a the sweat g l ands can
be b l ocked by top i ca l a ppl i cat i on of anti chol i nerg i c drugs . Spru i t ( 197 1 )
d i d not succeed i n compl etely b l ock i ng th i s s k i n temperature dependent
fl ow by atropi ne i ontophores i s ( 92 ) . Baker & Kl i gman { 1967 ) con s i der
anhydros i s by l oca l a pp l i cati on of ant i chol i nerg i c compounds to be
poss i b l e and obl i gatory i f transepi dermal water l oss i s to be accurate ly
measured . Scopol am i n i zat ion , however , i s not necessary for the greater
part of the trunk and for the l i mbs i f the amb i ent temperature i s 20°C
or l es s ( 22 ) .
27
BARRIER FUNCTION OF THE S KIN AND ITS RELATION WITH IRRITANT
AND ALLERGIC CONTACT DERMATITIS
28
Barri er funct i on of the s k i n and i ts rel at i on wi th i rri tant and a l l erg i c
contact dermati t i s
Horny l ayer forma t i on
By conti nuous cel l prol i ferati on i n the basal l ayer , m i grati on of the
cel l s to the outer l ayers of the s k i n and desquamati on of horny l ayer
cel l s , the s k i n i s prov i ded wi th a constant epi derma l renewa l wh i ch i s
essen t i a l for epi derma l ma i ntenance ( 94 ) .
Through a rate of cel l prol i ferat ion appropri a te to repl ace desquama t i ng
s tratum corneum and a constant exfol i at i ng l evel , the th i c kness of the
ep iderma l l ayers rema i ns cons tant ( 95 ) . Dur i ng the proces s of mi gra t i on
{wh i c h requ i res 52 to 7 5 days ) , i mportant changes occur i n both the
cel lul ar and extracel l u l ar compartments ( 96 ) . The basal cel l , a wel l
hydrated cyl i ndri ca l ce l l , trans forms i nto a rel a t i ve ly dry (wa ter
content of the horny l ayer cel l , 10-20% of the d ry wei ght ) and f l a ttened
polygonal cel l wi th a w idth of� 1 �m and a l ength of� 40 �m ( 3 5 , 97 ) .
The nuc l ei of the v i abl e cel l s of the l ower l ayers of the epi dermi s
d i s i ntegrate i n the outer l ayers of the stratum granul osum ( 98 ) . A dead ,
h i g h ly s tructured , l ayer of� 1 5 cel l l ayers and a w idth of ± 1 5 �m
for mos t of the body regi on s i s formed ( 95 } .
Dur i ng horny l ayer format i on , vert i ca l epi derma l col umns , wh i ch for the
great part of the i r width contact on ly the cel l s immed i ately above and
bel ow are formed . In the horny l ayer , the cel l s of adj acent col umns
overl ap l atera l l y , each cel l i nterd i g i tati n g wi th i ts nei ghbours . Th i s
ordered col umnar arrangement i s parti cu l ar ly pronounced i n the body
reg i on s havi ng a th i n epi derm i s ( 9 4 , 9 9 , 100} . U l t i ma tel y , the cel l s of
the outer l es s dense ly packed l ayers are shed i n d i fferent s i zed
c l u s ters ( 95 ) .
The extracel l u l ar compa rtment a l so undergoes profound a l tera t i ons . I n
the stratum granul os um , the extracel l u l a r vol ume con s i derab ly i ncreases
because of the l amel l ar contents of the membrane-coati ng granu l es ( 59 ) .
These l amel l ar body contents are remodel ed i n to broad sheets of mu l ti
l ami nated l i pi ds ( 52 , 59 , 10 1 ) . B i ochem ica l changes i n the extracel l u l ar
l i pi ds ( ca tabol i sm and de novo synthes i s } are con s i dered to be important
for barr i er funct ion and contro l l ed desquamat i on { 51 , 52 , 10 1 ) .
29
I t may be conc l uded that the s tratum corneum i s a very compl ex product
of a renewi ng epi derm i s .
Horny l ayer protecti ve capaci ty and s k i n barr i er functi on impa i rment
The i nteg r i ty of the horny l ayer funct i ons i s determi ned by:
1 ) The d i rect i nflu ence of env i ronmenta l factors of chemi cal , phys i ca l
or b i o l og i ca l ori g i n on the horny l ayer , wh i ch may temporar i l y or more
permanently i nterfere w i t h i ts functi on ( 1 5 , 1 9 , 7 8 , 7g , 1 02- 105 ) .
I t i s poss i b l e that i nterference of a penetrant wi th the comp l ex i n ter
rel ati onsh i p of horny l ayer components resu l ts i n temporary barri er func
t i on d i sturbances . These phys i cochem i ca l c hanges may be revers i b l e i n a
few hours { 1 9 , 103-105 ) . Envi ronmental factors may a l so cause more struc
tu ral damage to the horny l ayer wh i ch may resu l t in more permanent l os s
of barri er functi on ( 7 8 , 79 ) . T h e dead horny l ayer i s not abl e to restore
th i s funct i on and must be repl aced by a new l ayer of epi derma l cel l s be
fore compl ete protect ive capaci ty i s rega i ned ( epi derma l renewa l ) . If the
damage i s l im i ted to the stratum corneum t h i s proces s wi l l take a few
days ( 19 ) .
An externa l factor ( e . g . the effect of a degrea s i ng agent ) impa i r i ng bar
rier funct i on wi l l a l so decrease the capac i ty of the s k i n to l im i t the
l oss of water throug h the ep idermi s ( 2 5 , 106-108 ) .
I f the horny l ayer i s severel y damaged , a para keratot i c l ayer i s formed
wh i ch restores the barri er functi on for water very qu i ck ly ( 2-3 days ) .
Th i s l ayer i s mechan i ca l l y i nsuff i c i en t . Normal kerat i n i zat ion after the
format i on of the temporary barri er total regenerati on of the barr i er wi l l
requ i re about two weeks ( 1 9 , 25 , 106 , 109 , 1 10) .
Experimental exper i ences wi th l es s severe i nj u r i es to the s k i n demonstra
ted that the restorati on of the barri er funct ion aga i nst water fol l ows a n
exponenti al course i n t i me . I f, however , a nother external factors impa i rs
the barr i er funct ion for water before the s k i n barri er i s comp l ete ly re
covered, the effects prove to be cumu l at ive ( 7 8 ) ( F i g . IV) .
T h i s impl i es that the s k i n barri er may be i mpai red by var i ou s external
factors to such an extent that the s k i n i s not ab l e to prov i de for a hor
ny l ayer of suffi c i ent barr i er capac i ty ( 7 8 , 79 ) . Th i s may resu l t i n per
manent barri er funct i on impai rment and permeat i on of substances wi l l be
30
log
barrier
Impairment Clinical disease
1" 2"
' '
' '
3' 4"
' ---
' '
' '
' '
' '
' '
'
days
Fig I V . Cumu l at i ve barr i er funct ion i Mpa i rment due t o d i fferent i n
fl uences u l t imately l ead i ng to c l i n i ca l d i sease . Freely
adapted from Ma l ten ( 1981 ) ( 7 8 ) .
3 1
enhanced . Subcornea l l ayers of the epi dermi s and derma l structures
may be affected and fau l ty horny l ayer formati on may ensue . In th i s way,
a c i rcu l u s v i t i osus ma i nta i n i ng or aggravat i ng the barr i er funct i on
d i s turbances, may appear { 78, 97 );
2 ) the functi on of the v i ab l e su bcorneal l ayers of the epidermi s and the
derma l cel l s and structures ( 1 9, 7 8, 79 ) .
The horny l ayer i s the f i na l product of ep iderma l renewa l . The i ntegri ty
of the horny l ayer funct i ons i s therefore determi ned by both the deeper
l ayers of the epidermi s and the subepiderma l structures . The epi derm i s,
hav i ng no i ntri n s i c vascu l ar supply, i s dependent on the derm i s for nu
tri t i ve and other essent ia l substances . Growth and di fferent iat i on of
epidermal cel l s is a l so partl y regu l ated by the contact of the epi dermi s
w i th subepi derma l structures ( 1 1 1 - 1 13 ) . I nterposed between the body and
the envi ronment, the capac i ty of the epidermi s to form an eff i c i ent bar
r i er i s a l so i nf l u enced by externa l factors . For exampl e, after penetra
ti on, a su bstance may damage the v i abl e cel l s of the epi dermis or may
e l i c i t i nfl ammatory responses resu l t i ng i n fau l ty horny l ayer format i on
( 19, 109 ) .
Derma l pathol ogy, e . g . , i nsuff i c i ent neural or vascu l ar supply, (ma i n l y )
epidermal pathol ogy, e . g . , d i sorders o f kerati n i zati on l i ke psori asi s or
i chthyos i form dermatoses, ( endogeneou s ) eczematou s processes and unfa
vourab l e externa l factors may i nf l uence the epi dermal cel l s and horny
l ayer format i on ( 31, 109, 1 14- 1 1 6 ) .
Most ly, however, the epidermi s, prov i ded wi th a wel l -devel oped enzymat i c
system, can cope wi th changes i n both the externa l and i nternal envi ron
ments . There i s a bal ance between the demands whi ch are made on the s k i n
and i ts repa i r and thus protecti ve capac i ty ( 1 1 3 ) . The s k i n i s ab l e to
adapt to i ncreased envi ronmental stresses { 109, 1 1 0 ) . The capaci ty of the
sk i n to react to i ncreased envi ronmental demands by adaptati on and rege
nerati on vari es i nter- and i ntrai nd i v i dua l l y and i s determi ned by i nter
nal ( cons t i tut iona l ) factors ( age, s k i n type, sk i n reg i on, med i cati on,
neura l and vascu l ar i ntegri ty, s k i n temperature, i nterna l d i sease, fat i
gue, etc . ) and externa l factors ( chem i ca l s, i nfrared i rrad i ati on, mecha
n i ca l forces, rel at i ve hum i d i ty, mi crobes, etc . ) ( 1 9, 7 8, 79 ) .
32
Horny l ayer barr i er funct i on impa i rment and contact dermati t i s
Barr i er funct i on impa i rments may p l ay a rol e i n the eti ol ogy of both
i rri tant and a l l erg i c contact dermati ti s ( 79 ) .
The term i rr i tant contact dermati t i s i s u sed to descr i be a l oca l i zed ,
superf i c i a l , exudative nonimmunol og i ca l i nf l amma t i on of the s k i n wh i ch
i s due to the d i rect i nfl uence of one or more externa l factors ( 78 ) .
Most ly , after repeated contact wi th d i fferent potenti a l i rri tants , the
eczematous reacti on devel ops ( 7 8 ) .
The exact pathogenes i s of i rri tant contact dermat i t i s , however , i s
un known , a l though i t seems l i ke ly that the same mechan i sm a s i n the
pri mary i rri tant react i on of the s k i n wh i c h can be observed after patch
tes t i ng a tox i c substance i s i nvol ved ( 1 1 7 , 1 1 8 ) .
The centra l rol e of permeabi l i ty shou l d be poi nted out : wi thout permea
t i on , no tox i c effects can be observed ( 79 ) . Therefore , i t i s very
l i kely that i ncreased permeation of ( toxi c ) subs tances contri bute to the
devel opment of i rri tant contact dermati ti s ( 79 ) . Al l erg i c contact derma
t i t i s i s the term u sed to describe an infl ammatory process of the s kin
based on immunol og i cal mechan i sms . The mechan i sm of del ayed-type hyper
sens i t i v i ty i s most important i n the devel opment of a l l erg i c contact
derma t i tis . A compl ete descri pti on of t h i s mechani sm i s not wi th i n the
scope of th i s chapter . In s hort : The process of hypersens i t i v i ty deve
l ops in two phases . F i rs t , the sens i ti zati on process takes p l ace , i n
wh i ch immunocompetent anti gen- i nexperi enced T lymphocytes become commit
ted by an enconter wi th a conj ugate of l ow mol ecul ar wei ght ( the hapten )
and an autol ogous prote i n .
I n th i s phase , Langerhans cel l s may p l ay a rol e . These cel l s have been
i mp l i cated as antigen-presenti ng and target cel l s i n contact a l l erg i c
( cel l -med i ated ) reacti ons . I n the fol l owi ng el i c i t i ng phas e , a
second contact of the a l l ergen w ith the s k i n may l ead to recogni t i on by
effector T lymphocytes (wh i ch have devel oped as the memory T l ymphocytes
from the comm itted l ymphocytes ) . The effector cel l s wi l l produce lympho
k i nes wh i ch i nduce i nfl ammatory reacti ons and subsequentl y the devel op
ment of a l l erg i c contact dermati t i s ( 1 1 9 , 120 ) .
For a l l ergic contact dermatitis , it a l so app lies that it cannot devel op
wi thout permeati on of a l l ergens through the horny l ayer . Both the conduc-
33
t i v e and the el i c i t i ng phase can occur on l y i f an a l l ergen permeates the
horny l ayer ( 7 9 , 12 1 ) .
Kl i gman ( 1966 ) found a strong enhanc i ng effect on sens i t i za t i on i f the
s k i n was pretreated wi th substances wh i ch impa i r the barr ier functi on of
the s k i n , espec i a l l y if the substance a l so evo ked an i nf l ammatory re
sponse . The i nfl ammat i on was con s i dered to del ay restorat i on of the
barri er i ntegri ty ( 1 22 ) .
Lanti nga et a l . ( 1983 ) demonstrated that pati ents wi th eczematou s pro
cesses of l onger durati on have more pos i t i ve a l l erg i c patch test reac
t i ons ( equal exposure i n both groups i s l i ke ly ) than those wi th an
eczema of s horter dura t i on ( 123 ) .
I t may be concl uded that i rr i tant factors may cause barr i er functi on
i mpa i rment and i rr i tant contact dermati t i s , wh i ch may l ead secondari ly
to sens i t i za t i on and a l l erg i c contact derma t i t i s ( "two phases eczema " ) ( 79 ) .
Summar i z i ng , i t can be stated that the i ntegri ty of barr i er functi on i s
essent i a l for the preven t i on of both a l l erg i c and i rr i tant contact der
mat i t i s ( Fi g . V ) .
34
I rr i tant or Allergic
Contact Dermati tis
Noxae
! Permea b i l i t y
'-------------:;.. Integrity of the Horny Layer
t Const i tuti o n
F i g . V . The i nteract i on between contact dermat i t i s and horny l ayer
permeab i l i ty . Freely adapted from Ummenhofer ( 1981 ) ( 79 ) .
35
��ATER VAPOUR LOSS AS INDICATOR FOR BARR IER FUNCTION !MPAIRI,1£NT
36
Water vapour l os s as i nd i cator for barr i er func t i on i mpai rment
Much work has been done to eval uate the barri er funti on of arti fi c i a l l y
damaged o r d i seased sk i n ( 14 , 29- 3 1 , 1 02-1 08 , 1 1 0 ) .
Among other phys i ca l methods ( carbon d i ox i de mea surements , s k i n i mpeda nce
measurements ) , water vapour l os s methods have been used to s tudy the
barr i er properti es of the s k i n ( 34 , 102 , 1 03 ) .
The method of water vapour l os s meas urements has been used for eva l uat i on
of s k i n barr i er function becaus e :
1 ) the horny l ayer barr i er i s deci s i ve for the penetrat i on o f most chem i
cal s i nc l ud i ng water ( 1 , 18 , 69 ) ;
2 ) the horny l ayer behaves l i ke a pass i ve d i ffus i on med i um , obeyi ng
Fi ck ' s l aw to a certa i n extent ( 1 , 18 , 69 ) .
Thi s i mpl i es that penetrat ion of substances i s proporti onal to the di ffe
rence i n concentra t i on across the s tratum corneum , i ndependent of the
di recti on of the ski n grad i ent ( i . e . , the fl ux of potenti a l l y damagi ng
agents from the envi ronment through the horny l ayer i s essenti a l ly the
same pass i ve mechan i sm as the l os s of water from the body through the
epi dermi s ) ( 1 , 18 , 69 ) .
F i c k ' s l aw , however , assumes that the s tratum corneum i s a homogeneous
d i ffus i on barri er ; t h i s is not stri ctly true because ( 1 ) :
1 ) the appendages ( ha i r fol l i c l es , sweat g l ands ) i nterrupt the horny
l ayer ( 1 ) ;
2 ) the u nbroken stratum corneum cons i sts of an i ntra- and an i ntercel l u
l ar compartment of d i fferent compos i ti on ( 52 ) . Even the i ntracel l u l ar
compartment cons i st i ng of fi l aments and a n amorphous i nterfi l amentous
matr i x i s not homogeneous .
Consequentl y , each subs tance wi l l have i ts own pattern of d i ffus i on a l ong
the d i fferent pathways ( i ntra- and i ntercel l u l a r , appendages ) accordi ng
to i ts phys i ca l properties (mo l ecu l ar wei ght , e l ectri ca l c harg e , hydro
ph i l i c of hydrophobi c characteri s t i c s ) ( 1 , 49 , 6 1 ) .
Damage to the s k i n wi l l not equa l ly affect a l l s tructures whi ch are
i mportant for barri e r funct i on ( 1 0 5 ) . Penetrati on of chemi cal s wi l l
therefore not be equa l l y i nfl uenced for a l l subs tances . For exampl e ,
i f the i ntercel l u l ar compartment i s seri ous l y damaged by surface acti ve
37
agents , the i ntracel l u l ar compartment may be rel ati vely i ntac t .
Hence , s k i n water vapour l os s measurements c a n b e cons i dered as g i v i ng
some i nformat i on on the barr i er funct ion of the horny l ayer , espec i a l ly
for substances hav i ng phys i cochem i ca l properti es resembl i ng those of
water .
38
E v a p o r a t i o n
T h e r m i s t o r
C y l i n d r i c a l c a p s u l e
F i g . V I . Arrangement o f sensors i n the probe o f the Servo Med Evapor i
meter . From N i l sson ( 1 977 ) ( 140 ) .
39
PERSONAL AND ENV I RONMENTAL VAR IABLES I NFLUENCING SK IN WATER
VAPOUR LOSS
40
Personal and envi ronmental vari abl es i nfl uenc i ng s k i n water vapour l os s
S k i n water vapour l oss varies cons i derab ly wi t h i n a subject a n d between
subj ects ( 34 , 107 ) . D i fferences i n s k i n water vapour l os s as caused by
horny l ayer ( functi on ) i mpai rment are mas ked by the i nfl uence of un
des i rab l e i nterven i ng vari abl es . Therefore , attempts have been made to
reduce the i nfl uence by keepi ng i nterven i ng var i abl es constant or by
correct i ng sk i n water vapour l oss for the i nfl uence of the i nterven i ng
va r i a b l es ( 34 ) .
I n th i s study , s k i n water vapour l os s measurements were done under neu
tral envi ronmental cond i t i ons . Before the actua l determi nati on s , a wa i
t i ng peri od was a l l owed i n order to reduce the effect of d i fferences
i n eccr i ne sweati ng and s k i n temperature (most i mportant i nterven i ng
var i a b l es ) .
The i nfl uence of i nterven i ng vari a b l es , howeve r , cannot be excl uded
compl etel y . On the one hand , the des i gn of the s tudy prevented compl ete
control of envi romental vari abl es ; on the other hand, restr i ct i on of a l l
i nterveni ng persona l vari abl es i s pract i ca l l y i mposs i b l e ( 34 } . The most
important vari abl es wi l l be d i scussed ( be l ow ) .
S k i n temperature
I n the absence of sweat g l and acti v i ty , s k i n wa ter vapour l oss vari es
wi th the s k i n temperature ( 2 2, 3 2 , 43 , 92 , 1 24- 1 2 7 ) . The rel at i on s h i p be
tween transep iderma l water l os s and s k i n temperature proved to be ex
ponent i onal and d i fferent formu l as have been deri ved for converti ng
transepi derma l water l os s a t a random s k i n temperature to a s tandard
reference temperature ( 1 2 5 , 1 26 ) .
The purpose of th i s conversi on i s to permi t a more accurate compari son
of transepi derma l water l os s data between and w i th i n subj ects ( 126 ) .
Under neu tra l env i ronmental cond i t i on s , the s k i n temperature di ffe
rences are sma l l and a ny i nfl uence cannot be eas i l y detected { 107 ) .
Moreover , s k i n temperature i s dependent on i n ternal and externa l con
d i ti ons and there is no u sefu l def i n i t i on for in v i vo measurements
( 12 5 , 1 28 ) .
41
For the conversion , i t i s obl i gatory to i n h i b i t swea t g l and acti v i ty ,
since this acti v i ty i s i nfl uenced by both central sudomotor impu l ses
and focal s k i n temperature . This focal infl uence of s k i n temperature
may be d i rect (without neural i nvol vemen t ) and by neural refl exes and
wi l l therefore a l ter the exponentia l rel a tionship between trans epiderma l
water l oss and s k i n temperature ( 1 29 ) .
A d i urna l var i ation which has been described for transepi derma l water
l oss is probab ly a refl ecti on of a diurnal variati on i n s kin tempera
ture ( 130 ) .
A l inear rel ations h i p between water l os s and s k i n temperature if swea t
g l and activ i ty i s not inhibi ted has been descri bed ( 92 ) . The sweat g l and
acti v i ty i s considered as a part of a periphera l regu l atory system and
the water l oss as being dependent on s k i n temperature ( 92 ) .
Eccrine sweat g l and acti v i ty
S k i n water vapour l os s partly cons i sts of water vapour originat i ng from
the swea t g l ands even under neutra l environmental circumstances ( 66 , 67 ) .
I f , however , the barr i er capac i ty of the s k i n i s studied by means of
water vapour l oss mea surements , swea t g l and acti vity has to be restr i c
ted as much as poss i b l e ( 22 ) .
I n th i s study , it was not practi ca b l e to i nh i b i t the ( neura l ) impul ses
to the swea t g l ands by use of anti chol i nerg i c compounds . Thus , i n sp i te
of the precaut i ons ( v i de supra ) , s k i n water vapour l oss may be partly
due to therma l but probab ly more important to emotional sweating . Th i s
may b e a source o f i nfra- and i ntersubject variat i on i n the measurement
resu l ts ( 1 07 ) .
Sources of sys tema t i c fau l ts by errors as a resu l t of eccri ne sweat i ng
may be :
1 ) The measurements were performed on the vol ar s i de of the forearm .
Al though sweating is not excessive in this reg i on ( 8 ) , differences i n
sweat g l and dens i ty and activity may vary from the el bow to the wri s t .
Th i e l e & Mal ten ( 1 972 ) have described a rel a t i on between the water l os s
of t h e forearm a n d i t s circumference ( 92 ) . The product of water l os s
and circumference i s considered a s a rel a tively constant val ue within
42
and between i nd i v i dua l s i f no s k i n pathol ogy i s present .
On ly at the wr i s t may th i s product be s l i ght ly h i gher . To demons trate
th i s rel a ti on correcti on for s k i n temperature shou l d be made . The i n
fl uence of ci rcumference , wi thout correct i on for d i fferences i n tempe
ra ture , cou l d not be confi rmed wi th the water vapour l oss measurements
a t the forearm , u s i ng the Servo Med Evaporimeter ( grad i ent estimati on )
( 107 ) .
2 ) Abnormal sweat g l and res ponses i n pat i ents wi th acti ve a top i c derma
ti ti s after st imu l ati on wi th acetyl chol i ne are found ( 13 1 ) . Therefore ,
pati ents w i t h atop i c dermati ti s may have i ncreased sweat g l and act i v i ty
i n case of neura l acti vati on . F i na l l y , i t s hou l d be noted that theore
t i ca l ly i ncrea sed water vapour l oss after expos ure of the s k i n to i rr i
tants may b e due to functi onal damage to the sweat g l ands , l eadi ng to
i ncreased or decrea sed sweat g l and acti v i ty ( 92 ) .
I nj ury to the sweat g l and epi thel i um may l ead to i ncreased d i ffus i onal
water l oss v ia th i s shunt pathway . D i ffus i onal wa ter l oss v ia shunt
pa thways , however , may be cons i dered as part of transepiderma l water
l oss ( 66 ) .
Rel at i ve humi d i ty of the amb i ent a i r
A re l � ti on between the rel ati ve humi di ty o f the amb i ent a i r and d i ffu
s i ona l water l os s through the s k i n has been men t i oned in both i n v i tro
( 43 , 50 ) and i n v i vo s tud i es ( 30 , 132 , 133 ) , a l though th i s rel at i on i s not
a l ways eas i ly demonstrated in v i vo ( 3 2 , 13 3 , 1 34 ) . If the horny l ayer ( the
mai n barrier aga i n s t d i ffu s i on a l water l oss ) behaves l ike an i deal mem
brane wi th permeabi l i ty properti es i ndependent of chang i ng amb i ent hu
m i d i ty , water l os s can be expected to obey Fi ck ' s l aw ( 50 , 7 7 ) . I ndeed ,
some authors have menti oned a l i near rel at i ons h i p between rel at i ve hu
m i d i ty of the envi ronmental a i r and transepi derma l water l os s ( 7 1 , 135 ) .
I n rea l i ty , however , the horny l ayer does not behave l i ke an i dea l mem
brane .
1 ) The horny l ayer absorbs and desorbs water from subcornea l l ayers and
from the envi ronment ( 50 , 77 ) . The permeabi l i ty for water proved to be
dependent on the water content of the horny layer ( 50 , 77 , 1 34 , 136 ) .
43
Th i s phenomenon i nterferes wi th the l i near rel ati ons h i p as pred i c ted
by F i ck ' s l aw ; the actual wa ter l os s after adaption of the s k i n to
the l ower or h i gher envi ronmental humi d i ty bei ng , respect i vel y , l ower
and h i gher than wou l d be expected ( 77 ) .
Gri ce et a l . ( 1 972 ) found an i ncrease i n transepi derma l water l oss i n
go i ng from l ow humid i ty to 30 - 50\ and than a decrea se i f the hum i
d i ty i ncreased sti l l more . By 73 - 7 7 � , the transepi dermal water l oss
had decreased to abou t the i n i t i a l rate ( 1 33 ) .
2 ) The water content of the horny l ayer i s dependent not on ly on the en
v i ronmental humi d i ty but a l so on the way i n wh i ch thi s humi d i ty has
been reached . The water i sotherm from l ow to h i g h humi d i ty i s not
equal to the desorption i sotherm from h i gh to l ow humi d i ty . Thus ,
the water content of the horny l ayer at a fi xed humi d i ty wi l l vary
between the two val ues ( 7 7 ) .
3 ) The gradi ent of rel a t i ve h um id i ty throug h the membrane cannot be d i
rect ly establ i s hed , a l though the subcornea l l ayers can probab ly be
cons i dered as ful l y hydrated ( R . H . 100% ) ( 22 , 1 24 ) .
I n th i s s tudy , the rel at i ve hum i d i ty of the ambi ent a i r probab ly d i d not
s i gn i fi cant ly i nfl uence the s k i n water vapour l oss measurements ( 107 ) .
The i nfl uence of a i r movement on eva pora t ion i s probab ly due to con
stantly l ower i ng the rel at i ve humi d i ty , wh i ch faci l i tates evaporati on
( 124 ) .
Tempera ture of the amb i ent a i r
The temperature o f the ambi ent a i r i nfl uences s k i n temperature both d i
rectl y and i nd i rectl y ( by central thermoregu l atory effects ) ( 2 2 , 32 , 1 24 ,
1 28 ) . The temperature of amb i ent a i r wi l l a l so have effects on body tem
perature . Therefore , sweat g l and acti v i ty wi l l be i nfl uenced by d i ffe
rences i n temperature ( thermal swea t i ng ) a nd must be cons i dered as an
i mportant var iab l e ( 85 ) .
I f a i r tempera ture i s bel ow 20° C and s k i n temperature bel ow 3 3°C , h ow
ever , thermal sweat g l and acti v i ty i s un l i ke l y , prov ided that the s k i n
i s not exposed t o forced convecti on and n o exces s i v e body heat i s pro
duced ( bodi l y excerc i se ) ( 22 , 1 37 ) .
44
I naccurac i es and d i sturbances due to the measuri ng dev i ce
The methods emp l oyed to mea sure s k i n water vapour l os s wi l l more or l ess
a l ter the m i crocl i ma te at the s i te of measuremen t and wi l l therefore
d i s turb the mi croc l imate onl y modera te l y , because of the l i m i ted s i ze
of the measuri ng probe and the absence of a chamber .
The i naccuracy of the measur ing dev i ce ( s ervo Med Evaporimeter ) i s usu
a l l y i ns i gn i fi cant in compari son wi th factors wh i ch i nfl uence the d i ffu
s i on zone ( boundary l ayer ) around the body such as a i r movement or fac
tors wh i ch i nfl uence the sensor el ements and , consequentl y , the gra
d i ent estima t i on such as , e . g . , d i rect l i gh t or heat sources { 138 ) .
Factors i nfl uenci ng horny l ayer barri er properti es
The propert ies of the horny l ayer are determi ned by const i tut i ona l and
envi ronmental factors ( 19 , 34 , 78 ) . If cons ti tuti onal factors are stud i ed
(wh i c h are on ly part ly hered i tary and cannot be cons i dered as f i xed du
ri ng the l i fet ime ( 78 ) ) , d i fferences in s k i n water vapour l oss based on
nonstandard i zed envi ronmental factors are i n terven i ng var i a b l e s ( 34 ) .
Therefore , s k i n water vapour l os s measurements i n unexposed s k i n or s k i n
exposed to a s tandard i zed st imu l us g i ve on ly an i mpres s i on of the ( con
st i tut i ona l l y determ i ned ) vu l nerab i l i ty of an i nd i v i dua l if random i n
j ur i es to the s k i n are avoi ded . Al so , reg i onal d i fferences i n s k i n pro
perti es may be of i mportance ( 22 , 124 ) . The vo l a r s i de of the forearm
was used for the exposures and s k i n water vapour l os s measurements i n
th i s s tudy , s i nce t h i s s k i n s i te i s not norma l l y exces s i ve ly exposed to
envi ronmental s t imu l i .
Vascu l ar changes , deep s k i n and body temperature
The i nf l uence of vasoconstr i ct ion and vasod i l atat i on has been suggested
{ 127 ) , but i s probab ly not of importance ( 22 , 124) . Consequent ly deep
s k i n and body temperature wi l l probably have no d i rect i nf l uence on
transep i derma l water l os s .
45
r·lETHODS OF MEASURING THE EVAPORATIVE WATER LOSS OF HUMAN SKIN
46
Methods of measuri ng the evaporati ve water l os s of human s k i n
The f i rst attempts to eva l uate the wa ter l os s from human s k i n were made
i n the 1 7th and 1 8th centuri es and were whol e body grav i metr i c stud i es
( 1 39- 14 0) . The water l oss of the s k i n was estimated by determi n i ng the
wei ght r �ducti on of a person on a wei g h i ng sca l e . After Lavo i s i er and
Segu i n i n 1 7 90 poi nted out the importance of pu l monary l osses of water
and carbon d i ox i d e , correct i on for these l osses was made ( 65 ) .
I n th i s century , i nv est i gati ons wi th improved and more sensi t i ve vers i ons
of these gravimetr i c methods were made to study total cutaneou s water
l oss under phys i o l og i ca l and patho l og i ca l cond i t i ons { 65 , 7 1 , 1 32 , 1 4 1 - 143 ) .
I nves ti gat ion of l im i ted areas of s k i n , however , i s not pos s i b l e i n
th i s way and , to perm i t stud i es of cutaneous water l os s from l i m i ted
areas , new methods have been devel oped . These techni ques are often i n
tended to assess swea t g l and act i v i ty , e . g . , i n phys i o l og i ca l and psycho
l og i ca l stud i es . However , they l ack the accuracy to reg i s ter sma l l d i ffe
rences i n i nsens i b l e water l os s through the epi derm i s ( 144 , 145 ) .
I f we restr i ct our su rvey to method s s u i tabl e for accurate measurement
of water vapour l oss , these i nvol ve the use of : a ) a vent i l ated chamber ;
b ) an unvent i l ated chamber ; or c ) grad i ent estimati on ( 140 ) .
I ) Methods based o n unventi l ated chambers
In the methods based on an unvent i l ated chamber , the water l oss of the
s k i n i s determi ned grav imetr i ca l l y . A chamber wi th i ts open end to the
s k i n surface is fastened to the s ki n . A hygroscopi c mater ia l (most ly
saturated so l ut i ons of s a l t s s uch as NaCl , L i C l , MgC l 2 and NaBr ) p l aced
i ns i de the chamber takes u p the water l ost by the s k i n . The change i n
we i ght o f the hygroscopi c mater i a l i s a measure for the water l os s of
the s k i n per u n i t t ime and s k i n surface { 1 5 , 29 ) .
Al ternat i vel y , the water vapour l os s can be est imated by a hum i d i ty
sensi ng e l ement p l a ced i ns i de the chamber . The sens i ng el ement
reg i sters the rel at ive hum id i ty and the rate of change i n the hum i d i ty
corres pond s to the rate of water vapou r l os s ( 27 , 146 - 148 ) .
I I) Methods based on vent i l ated chambers
In methods based on a vent i l ated chamber , a carr i er gas wi th a known
water content and at a known gas fl ow i s passed through a chamber p l aced
47
with i t s open end on the s k i n . The water l oss of the tested s k i n area i s
proporti ona l to the gas f l ow and the i ncrease i n the water vapour l oss
of the water vapour pres sure of the carr i er gas . I n formu l a format :
water vapour l oss � ( Pout -- P i n ) x f l ow .
The water vapour l oss can thus b e ca l cu l ated ( 140 ) .
The water content of the carr i er gas can be anal yzed grav imetr i ca l l y or
el ectrohygrometri ca l l y . Other methods l es s frequently used are based on
determi nat i on of changes i n therma l conducti v i ty , i nfrared absorpt i on or
temperature d i fferences caused by evaporat i on .
Grav imetri c estimati on of the water content i s done by wei gh i ng the
amount of water removed from the carr i er gas by an absorbent materi a l or
by col l ecti ng the water in a freez i ng m i xture ( 68 , 1 4g- 1 51 ) .
E l ectrohygrometr i ca l ana l ys i s makes use of an absorbent materi a l ( P2o5 )
that takes up the water vapou r of the carr i er gas . The water i s then
sp l i t by exposu re to an e l ectr i c potent i a l d i fference . The e l ectr ic
current resu l t i ng from th i s el ectro lys i s i s a measure for the water l oss
( 26 , 106 , 1 2 5 ) .
Other electrohygrometr i c methods make use of sens i n g e l ements w i th
hygroscop i c fi l ms of whi ch the el ectri ca l conducti v i ty i s i n proporti on
w ith the humi d i ty of the gas passed over i t ( 2 2 , 1 52- 1 54 ) .
The method of thermal conducti v i ty i s based upon the d i fferent therma l
conducti v i ty of gases . The therma l conduct i v i ty cel l detects the d i ffe
rences in therma l conducti v i ty i f the water content of a gas changes
( 145 , 1 55 , 1 56 ) .
I nfrared gas ana lys i s used as the operati ng pri nc i pl e the absorpti on of
i nfrared radi at i on by water vapour ( 30 , 1 57 ) .
The venti l ated chamber method u s i ng temperature d i fferences to detect
the water vapour pressure i s based upon the phys i ca l l aw that evapora
t i on i s proporti ona l to the rel ati ve humi d i ty of the ambi ent gas .
Because evaporat i on wi thdraws energy , temperature d i fferences are a
measure for the water content of the carr i er gas ( 1 58 ) .
I I I Determi nat i on of water vapour l os s through s k i n by grad i ent estima
t i on
Grad i ent estimation i s based on a method devel oped by N i l s son an Oberg
( 1 59 ) .
48
Th i s method depends upon determ i n i ng the vapour pressure g rad i ent i n the
l ayer adjacent to the s k i n . Th i s g radi ent can be con s i dered as propor
ti ona l to the exchange of water vapour from the s k i n .
The evapora t ion from a fl at and exten s i ve surface can b e treated a s a
f l ux normal to the s k i n wh i ch i s the resu l tant component of random
movement of mol ecu l es . Th i s f l ux through a s tat i onary water permeab l e
l ayer can be expres sed a s :
water exchange
D the mo l ecu l ar d i ffus i on
coeff i c i ent of water vapour
in a i r .
p the vapour pres sure .
x = the d i s tance to the s k i n
surface .
The quant i ty of water evaporated per u n i t t i me and s k i n area can thus
be cal cu l ated accord i ng to :
D llp llx
t t i me .
A area of surface .
m wei ght of the transported
water .
T h i s re l at i on i s va l i d wi t h i n a boundary l ayer ( d i ffu s i on zone ) wh i ch
surrou nds the human body . The depth of th i s stati onary l ayer depends on
the envi ronmental c i rcumstances , but , under neutra l cond i t i ons , t h i s
l ayer wi l l have a depth o f 7 mm t o 1 0 mm ( 1 40 , 1 60 , 1 6 1 ) .
The evaporimeter as desi gned by N i l sson ( 1977 ) , a pa i r of transducers
p l aced in a probe , measu res the rel ati ve humi di ty at two di fferent
d i stances from the surface ; another pa i r reg i sters the temperature and ,
from these s i gnal s , the pressure gradi ent i s computed ( F i g V I , p 39 ) ( 140 ) .
Compari son of the three methods for measurement of evaporat i on
Al l methods for measurement of water evaporat i on more or l es s suffer from
the d i sadvantage that they i nterfere wi th the mi crocl i mate near the
surface of the s k i n . Because th i s i nterference is d i fferent for the
methods appl i ed , resu l ts cannot be compared with any degree of accuracy .
Moreover , t h i s i nterference ma kes i t d i ff i cu l t t o estimate the "true
49
water l os s '' i n the absence of the i nterfer i ng chamber or probe on the
s k i n ( 29 , 1 40 ) .
Unvent i l ated chambers have t he d i sadvantage that the rel at ive hum i d i ty
and temperature i n the chamber cannot be kept constant , a l though some
i nvest i gators deal w i th t h i s probl ems i ngen ious ly ( 27 , 148 ) .
I f a grav imet r i c method i s u sed , the hyg roscopi c mater i a l wi l l a l so take
up the water va pou r a l ready present in the chamber ; therefore , a bl ank
determi nat i on has to be carr i ed out ( 1 62 ) .
Another probl em concern i ng t he grav imetr i c unventi l ated method i s the
impos s i b i l i ty of ma ki ng trans i ent record i ng s ( 1 40 ) .
The vent i l ated chamber methods make use of forced convect ion by pass i ng
the carri er gas throug h the chamber ; cons equent ly , extrapol at ion to a
zero f l ow or more accuratel y to a fl ow correspond i ng wi th the f l ow
immed i ately above the body su rface of a person under neutral ambi ent
c i rcumstances i s requ i red { 3 0 , 1 54 , 1 55 ) . However , the gas f l ow can s t i l l
i nf l u ence the hydrat i on and temperatu re of the s k i n ( 1 44 , 1 54 ) .
To obta i n comparab l e resu l ts corres pond i ng wi th the " true water vapour
l oss " , amb i ent a i r shou l d be u sed ; howev er , the u s e of a i r makes great
demands on the sens i t i v i ty of the mea su rement ( 140 ) . In fact , most
met hod s make use of dr i ed n i trogen or oxygen at d i fferent gas f l ows .
When u s i ng a vent i l ated chamber , the measurement i s often quan l i ta t i ve
and ta kes much t ime because of the dead s pace i n t he c i rcu l at i ng system .
Mechan i cal i nf l uence of the chamber can cause a change i n s k i n vapour
l os s . The chamber must be pressed on to the s k i n to avo i d m i x i ng of
amb i ent a i r w i th the gas in the system or to avo i d l ea kage of carri er
gas ( 3 1 , 92 ) .
The method of grad i ent est imat i on i s wi thout many of the d i sadvantages
of the c hamber methods and , becau se of i t s s impl i c i ty , it i s easy to
hand l e in da i l y pract i ce ( 1 63 ) . The i nterference of the measu r i ng probe
w i th the m i crocl imate of the s k i n i s l im i ted to s i tuati ons w i th rap i d
evaporat ion .
The mechan i cal i nfl uence of the probe on the s k i n i s smal l .
The resi stance to d i ffus i on of water vapour i n the cyl i ndri cal probe
may be greater than the boundary l ayer surround i ng the s k i n i n cases of
rap i d evaporat i on . In these s i tuat i ons , g radi ent est i mati on underva l ues
50
the actual evaporati on . A correct i on for th i s phenomenon can be made
( 16 1 , 164 ) .
The theoreti cal sens i t i v i ty defi ned as the grad i ent of the s i gnal output
of the measuri ng i ns trument and the water exchange of the method of
grad i ent est imati on i s super i or to the sens i t i v i ty of the chamber
methods ( 1 65 ) . The actual accuracy of the grad i en t est imati on methods i s
d i scus sed i n the next sect i on .
Servo Med evapori meter(138 )
The Servo Med evapori meter used i n th i s s tudy i s an i nstrument for
quant i ta t i ve determi nation of evaporati ve water l os s . Its opera t i ng
pri nci p l e i s based on the method of gradi ent es t i mati on as devel oped
by N i l sson and Oberg ( 140 ) .
The actual i nstrument cons i sts of a detac habl e hand- hel d probe attached
by a cabl e to a portabl e control un i t .
The sensor arrangement of the probe i s p l aced i n a tefl on caps u l e wh i ch
i s shaped as an open cyl i nder and measures 1 5 . 5 mm i n l ength and 1 2 . 5 mm
i n wi dth .
By p l a c i ng th i s cyl i nder upon the s k i n , a sma l l area i s separated and
protected from d i s turb i n g draughts . At two po i n ts a l ong an a x i s
perpend i cu l ar t o the measuri ng s urface , both humi d i ty transducers
and thermi stors are s i tuated i n the cyl i nder . The s i gna l s of the
transducers for rel ati ve humi d i ty and those of the thermi s tors are
used to compute the part i a l pressure of the water vapour and the
temperature at two d i s tances 4 mm apart from the measuri ng surface .
The pa rt ia l pressure grad i ent and evaporat i on rate can thus be cal cu
l a ted .
The el ectron i c control and d i s p l ay u n i t offers the fol l owi ng measuri ng
poss i b i l i t i es and ranges . If only the "WE" swi tch i s pres sed , the
range for water eva porat i on or water uptake from or to surfaces i s
0 - 300 g/m2h . When a l s o pres s i ng the swi tch " Range " , the d i s p l ay
covers the 0 - 1 00 . 0 range . Moi s ture measurements by both pai rs of
transducers can be done by pres s i ng the swi tches RH or P for rel at i ve
humi d i ty or parti a l water vapour pres su re , respec t i ve l y . Rel a t i ve
51
humi d i ty can be determi ned wi th i n the range of 0 - 100, and part i a l
wa ter vapour press ure wi th i n the range o f 0 - 6 . 65 KPa ( 0 - 5 0 mm Hg ) .
Mea surement pri nc i p l es and accurac i es of the Servo Med evaporimeter(138)_
The d i s turba nce , defi ned as the d i fference between the water evaporation
duri ng the meas urement and what the evaporat i on wou l d have been wi thout
appl i cat i on of the mea suri ng dev i ce , is norma l l y many t i mes grea ter than
the i naccuracy of the eva porimeter .
Th i s means that a l l effects such as draughts , d i rect l i ght , etc . ,
d i s turb i ng the mi crocl imate and thus the boundary l ayer of the s k i n
shou l d be mi n imi zed . For accura te measurements , care must be taken to
do a correct ca l i brati on . Cal i brati ons at a 3-month i n terva l i s usua l ly
sat i s fac tory . Before the actua l measurement , a 15 m i n warm up t i me for
the i nstrument i s advi sabl e .
When the warm u p t ime has el apsed , the i n s trument h a s to b e zeroed wi th
the " offset" potenti ometer . To el i minate edge effects cau s i ng a d i s tur
bance of the " s tat i onary" boundary l ayer , the probe shou l d be p l aced on
as l arge a s k i n surface as poss i b l e .
After p l a c i ng the probe properly on the s k i n , the response t i me for
measurement of evaporati ve water l oss i s very short . However , for very
stati onary va l ues , a m i n ima l t ime dura t i o n of three mi nutes i s requi red
( 1 66 ) . Fi l ter buttons ( 10 and 20 s ) can be used separately a nd s i mul taneou sly
to avo i d fa st fl uc tua ti ons in the d i s p l ayed va l ues . The ul t imate va l ue
of the eva pora t i ve wa ter l os s , however , i s atta i ned more s l owly by the
use of the f i l ters .
The actual accuraci es depend on the t ime that the sensor un i t i s a l l owed
to reach the amb i ent temperature . Tha t i s 1-1hy i t i s neces sary to avo i d
heat transfer t o the probe by suns h i ne , t h e hand or otherwi s e . Even so ,
i f moi sture cond i t i ons change abrupt l y , i t wi l l take some t i me before
a d i ffu s i on equ i l i br i um i n the measur i ng probe i s atta i ned .
After ca l i bra ti on and at l east 5 mi n appl i cat ion of the probe , the
typ i ca l accuraci es are (wi thi n the temperature range of 18 - 3 5° C ) :
52
Water transport ;
Rel ati ve hum id i ty ;
Part i a l pressure ;
+ + 2 1 5% - 2 g/m h . : 2%-un i ts wi th i n the range 0-65% ,
+ 3%-uni ts wi th i n 65-80� .
! 6% wi th i n 20- 100% rel at i ve hum i d i ty .
53
References
1 ) Scheup l e i n , R . J . Percutaneous absorpt i on after twenty-five years :
or o l d w ine i n new wi nes ki ns . J . I nves t . Derm . 6 7 : 31 -38 ( 1 976 ) .
2 ) Rothman , S . Percutaneous absorpt i on . I n : Phys i ol ogy and B i ochemi stry
of the Sk i n , pp 27-29 ( 1 954 ) The Un i vers i ty of Ch i cago Press ,
Ch i cago .
3 ) Schwen kenbecher , A . Das Absorpt ions vermogen der Hau t . Arch . Anat . u .
P hys i o l . 1 2 1 - 165 ( 1 904 ) .
4 ) B l a n k , I . H . Cutaneous barr i e rs . J . I nves t . Derm . 45 : 249-256 ( 1965 ) .
5 ) Rei n , H . Exper imental el ectroendosmot i c stud i es on l i v i ng huma n
s k i n . Z . B i ol . 81 : 125- 140 ( 1 924 ) .
6 ) Mackee , G . M . , Su l zberger , M . B . , Herrma nn , F . , Baer , R . L . H i sto l og i c
stud i es o n percutaneous penetrat i on w i t h spec i a l reference to the
effects of veh i c l es . J . I nves t . Derm . 6 : 43-6 1 ( 194 5 ) .
7 ) Wi nsor , T . , Burch , G . E . Di fferen t i a l ro l es of l ayers of human ep i
gastri c s k i n on di ffu s i on of water . Arch . I ntern . Med . 7 4 : 428-444
( 1 944 ) 0
8 ) Rothman , S . I nsens i b l e water l oss . I n : Phys io l ogy and Bi ochem i stry
of the S k i n , pp 1 53-200 and pp 233-243 ( 1 954 ) The Un i vers i ty of
Ch i cago Pres s , Ch i cago .
9 ) Mal i , J . W . H . The transport of water through the human epi dermi s .
J . I nvest . Derm . 27 : 451 -469 ( 1956 ) .
1 0 ) Wol f , J . D i e i nnere Struktur der Zel l es des Stratum Desquamans der
mensch l i chen Epi dermi s . Z . Mi k ros k . Ana t . Fors ch 46 : 1 70-202 ( 1939 ) .
1 1 ) P i nkus , H . Exami nati on of the epi derm i s by the str i p method of
remov i ng horny l ayers . J . Inves t . Derm . 1 6 : 383-386 ( 19 5 1 ) .
1 2 ) B l a n k , I . H . Factors w '• i�h i nfl uence the water content of the stra tum
corneu� . J . I nvest . Derm . 18 : 433-440 ( 1952 ) .
1 3 ) Bl a n k , I . H . Further observa ti ons on factors wh i c h i nfl uence the
water content of the stratum corneum . J . I nvest . Derm . 2 1 : 259-269
( 1 953 ) .
1 4 } Spru i t , D . The measurement and the regenerat i on of the water vapour
l os s of human s k i n . pp 58-59 ( 1969 ) Thes i s ( N i jmegen ) Offsetdrukker i j
mi nOpri nt , N i jmegen .
54
1 5 ) Monas h , S . , B l an k , H . Locat i on and re-formation of the epi thel i a l
ba rri er t o water va por . Arch . Derm . 7 8 : 7 10-7 13 ( 1958 ) .
1 6 ) B l a n k , I . H . , Scheupl e i n , R . J . Transport i nto and wi th i n the sk i n .
B r . J . Derm . 81 , suppl ement 4 : 4- 10 ( 1969 ) .
1 7 ) Schaefer , H . , Zesch , A . and Stuttgen , G . S k i n permeabi l i ty . I n :
Handbuch der Haut und Geschl echtskrankhei ten . Norma l e und Pathol og i
sche Phys i ol og i e der Haut I I I , J . Jadassohn , p p 575-577 ( 1981 )
Spri nger Verl ag , Berl i n .
1 8 ) Dugard , P . H . S k i n permeabi l i ty theory i n rel ati on to measu rements
of percutaneou s absorption in tox i col ogy . I n : Dermatotox i col ogy and
Pharmacol ogy , pp 525-550 ( 1 977 ) Edi tors : F . H . Marzu l l i and H . I .
Ma i bach , Hem i s phere Publ i s h i ng Corpora t i on , Wash i ng ton .
1 9 ) Mal ten , K . E . Dermato l og i sche tox i c i te i tsmeti ng . Lecture del i vered
at the sympos i um ' arbe ids- en bedri j fsgeneeskunde ' ( 1980 ) E i ndhoven .
20 ) W inke lmann , R . K . The rel a t i onshi p of the structure of the epi dermi s
to percutaneou s absorpti on . Br . J . Derm . 81 : suppl ement 4 , 1 1 - 2 1
( 1969 ) .
2 1 ) Kl aschka , F . Veranderungen der Hornsch icht bei Feucht i g kei tss chwan
kungen i n v i vo . Fette , Sei fen und Anstri chmi ttel 84 : 204-207 ( 1 982 ) .
2 2 ) Baker , H . , Kl i gman , A . M . Measurement of transepiderma l water l os s by
el ectri cal hygrometry . Arc h . Derm . 96 : 441-452 ( 1967 ) .
2 3 ) Menczel , E . , Ma i bach , H . I . I n v i tro human percutaneous penetrat i on
of benzyl a l cohol and testosterone : epi dermal -dermal retenti on . J .
I nves t . Derm . 54 : 386-394 ( 1970 ) .
2 4 ) Fel dman , R . J . , Ma i bach , H . I . Penetrati on of hydrocort i s one through
normal s k i n . Arch Derm . 9 1 : 661-666 ( 1965 ) .
2 5 ) Sprui t , D . , Mal ten , K . E . Epi dermal water- barri er formati on after
stri ppi ng of norma l s k i n . J . I nves t . Derm . 4 5 : 6 - 14 ( 1965 ) .
26 ) Van Gassel t , H . R . M . , V i erhout , R . R . Reg i stra t i on of the i nsens i b l e
pers p i ra t i on o f sma l l quanti t i es o f sweat . Dermato l og i ca 1 2 7 :
255-259 ( 1963 ) .
27 ) Ohara , 0 . , Ono , T . Reg i ona l rel ati onsh i p of water vapour pressure of
human body surface . J . Appl . P hys i ol . 18 ( 5) : 10 19- 1022 ( 1963 ) .
28 ) Thi el e , F . A . J . , van Senden , K . G . Rel a t i onsh i p between s k i n tempera
ture and the i nsen s i b l e persp i ra t i on of the human s k i n . J . I nvest . Derm .
55
4 7 ( 4 ) : 307 -3 1 2 ( 1 966 ) .
29 ) Shah i du l l ah , M . , Raffl e , E . J . , Fra i n-Bel l , W . I nsens i b l e water l oss
in dermati ti s . Br . J . Derm . 79 : 589-597 ( 1 967 ) .
3 0 ) Johnson , C . , Shuste r , S . The measu rement of transepi dermal water
l oss . Br . J . Derm . 81 ( suppl . 4 ) : 40- 45 ( 1 969 ) .
3 1 ) Shah i du l l ah , M . , Raffl e , E . J . , R immer , A . R . , Fra i n-Bel l , W . Trans
epi dermal water l oss in pati ents wi th dermati ti s . Br . J . Derm . 81:
722-730 ( 1969 ) .
32 ) Lamke , L . O . , Wedi n , B . Water evaporati on from norma l s k i n under
d i fferent envi ronmental cond i t i ons . Acta Derm . Vener . 5 1 : 1 1 1- 1 1 9
( 1 97 1 ) .
33 ) Lamke , L . O . , N i l sson , G . E . , Rei thner , H . L . I nsens i b l e perspi rat i on
from the s k i n under norma l envi ronmental condi ti ons . Quotat i on i n :
Measurement of water exchange through s ki n . N i l s son , G . E . , Med . &
B io l . Eng . & Comput . 1 5 : 209- 2 18 ( 1977 ) .
3 4 ) de Jongh , G . J . Poros i ty of human s k i n i n vi vo assessed v i a water l oss ,
carbon d i ox i de l oss and el ectri cal i mpedance for heal thy vol unteers ,
atop i c and psori ati c pa t i ents . Ed i tor : J . W . H . Mal i . Curr . Prob l .
Derm . , vol . 9 : 83- 101 ( Karger , Basel ) ( 1981 ) .
3 5 ) Baker , H . The s k i n as a barri er . I n : Textbook of Dermatol ogy , pp
289-298 ( 1979 ) Edi tors : A. Rook , D . S . Wi l k i nson , F . J . G . Ebl i ng .
Bl ackwe l l Sc ient i f i c Publ i cati ons part I , Oxford .
36 ) Matol tsy , A . G . , Downes , A . M . , Sweeney , T . M . Stud i es of the epi dermal
water l oss water barr ier , part I I . I nvesti gati on of the chemi ca l
nature of the water barri er . J . I nvest . Derm . 50 : 19-26 ( 1968 ) .
37 ) V i ckers , C . F . H . Kerati n and wate r . Br . J . Derm . 80 : 469-471 ( 1968 ) .
38 ) Smeen k , G . De i nv l oed van detergenti a op de hui d . Thes i s J .
Noorduyn en Zoon N . V . Gori nchem pp 4 1 -45 ( 1968 ) .
39 ) Gri ce , K . A . Transepi derma l water l oss . I n : The Physi ol ogy and Patho
phys i o l ogy of the Ski n , Vol . 6 , pp 2 134-2 142 ( 1 980 ) Ed i tor : A .
Jarret . Academi c Press , London .
40 ) Tregear , R . T . The structures wh i c h l i m i t the penetrabi l i ty of the
sk i n . J . Soc . Cosmet . Chern . 1 3 : 145- 1 5 1 ( 1962 ) .
4 1 ) Ja rret , A . The permeab i l i ty barri er . I n : The Phys i o l ogy and Patho
phys i o l ogy of the Ski n , vol . 6 , pp 2 1 1 1 - 2 1 14 ( 1980 ) Ed i tor : A .
56
Ja rret . Academ i c Press , London .
42 ) Sweeney , T . M . , Down i ng , D . T . The rol e of l i p i ds i n the epi derma l
barr i er to water . J . I nvest . Derm . 5 5 : 1 3 5 - 1 39 { 1970 ) .
43 ) Berenson , G . S . , Burch , G . E . Stud i es of d i ffus i on of water through
dead human s k i n : The effect of d i fferent envi ronmental s tates and
of chemi cal al tera t i ons of the epi derm i s . Amer . J . Trop . Med . 3 1 :
842-853 ( 1 951 ) .
44 ) Onken , H . D . , Moyer , C . A . The water barri er i n human epi dermi s . Arch .
Derm . 87 : 584- 590 ( 1 963 ) .
45 ) Scheu pl ei n , R . J . , B l ank , I . H . Permeab i l i ty of the s k i n . P hys i o l .
Rev . 5 1 : 702-747 ( 19 7 1 ) .
46 ) E l i as , P . M . , Cooper , E . R . , Korc , A . , Brown , B . E . Percutaneous
transport i n rel at i on to stratum corneum s tructure and l i p i d compo
s i t i on . J . I nvest . Derm . 7 6 : 297-301 { 1 981 ) .
47 ) Tregea r , R . T . The permeabi l i ty of mamma l i an s k i n to i ons . J . I nves t .
Derm . 46 : 16-23 ( 1966 ) .
48 ) Baker , H . Factors i nfl uenc i ng barri er i ntegr i ty . I n : Textbook of
Derma to l ogy , pp 294-295 { 1 979 ) Edi tors : A . Roo k , D . S . W i l k i nson ,
F . J . G . Eb l i ng . B l ackwe l l Sc ient i fi c Pub l i cati ons Oxford part I ,
Oxford .
49 ) Scheupl ei n , R . J . Mechan i sm of percutaneous adsorpti on I . Routes of
penetrat i on and the i nfl uence of sol ub i l i ty . J . I nves t . Derm . 45 :
3 34-345 ( 1 965 ) .
50 ) Spru i t , D . , Mal ten , K . E . Humi d i ty of the a i r and water vapour l oss
of the s k i n . The chang i ng permea bi l i ty . Derma tol ogi ca 138 : 418-426
( 1969 ) .
51 ) Smi th , W . P . , Chr i s tensen , M . S . , Nacht , S . , Gans , E . H . Effect of
l i p i ds on the aggregat i on and permeab i l i ty of human s tra tum corneum .
J . I nves t . Derm . 7 8 : 7 - 1 1 { 1982 ) .
52 ) E l i as , P . M . , Grayson , S . , Lampe , M . A . , W i l l i ams , M . L . , Brown , B . E .
The i ntercorneocyte space . I n : Stratum Corneum , pp 53-67 { 1983 )
Ed i tor : R . Marks . G . P l ewi g Spri nger Verl ag , Berl i n .
53 ) Prottey , C . , Hartop , P . J . , Press , M . Correcti on of the cutaneous
man i festa t i on of essent i a l fatty ac i d defi c i ency i n man by appl i ca
t i on of sunfl ower seed oi l to the s k i n . J . I nves t . Derm . 64 :
57
228-234 { 197 5 ) .
54 ) Prottey , C . , Hartop , P . J . , B l ack , J . G . , McCormack , J . I . The repa i r
o f i mpai red ep i dermal barri er funct i on i n rats by the cutaneous
appl i cat ion of l i no l e i c ac i d . Br. J . Derm . 94: 13-21 ( 1976 ) .
5 5 ) Hartop , P . J . , Prottey , C . Changes i n transepi derma l water l oss and
the compos i t i on of epi derma l l ec i th i n after appl i cati ons of pure
fatty acid tri g lyceri des to the s k i n of essenti a l fa tty aci d
def i c i ent rats . Br . J . Oerm . 95 : 255- 264 { 1976 ) .
56 ) Prottey , C . I nvesti ga t ion of functi on s of essenti a l fatty ac ids i n
the ski n . Br . J . Derm . 97: 29-38 { 1977 ) .
57 ) Houtsmu l l er , U . M . T . , v . d . Bec k , A . Effects of top i cal appl i ca-
t i on of fatty ac ids . I n : Prog . L i p i d Res . pp 2 19-224 ( 1981 )
Ed i tor : R . T . Ho lman . Perganon Press .
58 ) E l i as , P . M . , Brown , B . E . , Fri tsch , P . , Goerke , J . , Gray , G . M . ,
Wh i te , R . J . Loca l i zati on and compos i t i on of l i p ids i n neonatal mouse
stratum granul osum and stratum corneum . J . I nves t . Derm . 73 :
339- 348 ( 19 79 ) .
5 9 ) E l i as , P . M . , Goerke , J . , Fri end , D . S . Mamma l i an epi derma l barr i er
l ayer l i pi d s : compos i t i on and i nfl uence on structure . J . I nves t .
Derm . 69 : 535- 546 ( 1977 ) .
60 ) Gr�yson , S . , E l i a s , P . M . I so l ati on and l i p i d b i ochem ica l characteri za
t i on of stratum corneum membrane comp l exes : Impl i cati ons for the
cutaneous permea bi l i ty barr ier . J . Inves t . Derm . 78: 128- 135 ( 1982 ) .
6 1 ) Nemani c , M . K . , E l i as , P . M . I n s i tu prec i p i tat ion i n novel cyto
chem i ca l techni que for v i sual i zati on of permeabi l i ty pathways i n
mamma l i an stra tum corneum . J . H i stochem . Cytochem . 28 : 573-578
( 1 980 ) . 62 ) Jarret , A . Norma l ep iderma l kerat i n i zat i on . I n : The Phys i o l ogy and
Pathophys io l ogy of the Sk i n , Vol . 1 , p . 198 ( 1 973 ) Ed i tor : A. Jarret . Academ i c Press , London .
63 ) Mackenz i e , I . C . The cel l u l ar archi tecture of the stratum corneum . I � : Stratum Corneum , pp 146- 152 { 1 983 ) Edi tors : R . Marks , G . P l ewi g , Spri nger Verl ag , Berl i n .
64 ) Yard l ey , H . J . I so l ati on and l i p i d compos i t i on of fracti ons from the superf i c i a l stra tum corneum of the p i g . I n : Stratum Corneum , pp 73-78
58
( 1983 ) Edi tors � R . Marks ,G . P l ewi g , Spri nger Verl ag , Berl i n .
6 5 ) Bened i c t , F . G . , Root , H . F . I nsens i b l e pers p i rati on : i ts rel at i on to
human phys i o l ogy and pathophy s i o l ogy . Arch . I n t . Med . 38 : 1 -35
( 1926 ) .
66 ) Thi el e , F . A . J . The water l os s by s k i n . I n : Handbuch der Haut und
Geschl echtskrankhei ten , pp 5-8 ( 1981 ) Ed i to r : J . Jadas sohn . Norma l e
u nd Pathol og i sche Phys i o l og i e der Haut I I . Spri nger Verl ag , Berl i n .
67 ) Gri ce , K . A . Mea surement of transepi derma l water l os s . I n : Phys i o l ogy
and Pathophys i o l ogy of the S k i n V I , pp 2 1 16- 2 1 18 ( 1980 ) . Ed i tor : A .
Jarret . Academ i c Pres s , London .
68 ) Bettl ey , F . R . , Gri ce , K . A . , A method for measuri ng the transep i derma l
water l oss and a means of i nacti vati ng sweat g l and s . Br . J . Derm . 77 :
627-638 ( 1965 ) .
69 ) I d son , B . Percutaneous absorpti on . J . Pharm . Sci . 64 : 901-924 ( 1975 ) .
70 ) Scheupl ei n , R . J . S k i n permeati on . I n : P hys i o l ogy and Pa thophysi ol ogy
of the S k i n V , pp 1693- 1730 ( 1 976 ) Ed i to r : A . Jarret . Academ i c Pres s ,
London .
7 1 ) Brebner , D . F . , Kers l ake , D . M . Waddel l , J . L . The d i ffu s i on of water
vapour through human s k i n . J . P hys i ol . 132 : 2 25-231 ( 1956 ) .
7 2 ) Tregear , R . T . Mol ecul ar movement . I n : Phys i ca l Functi ons of S ki n ,
Vol . 5 , p p 46-48 ( 1 966 ) . Academ i c Press , London .
7 3 ) Burch , G . E . , Wi nsor , T . Rate of i nsens i b l e persp i rat i on l ocal l y
through l i v i ng and dead human s k i n . Arch . I n t . Med . 74 : 437-444
( 1946 ) .
7 4 ) Ga l ey , W . R . , Lons dal e , H . K . , Nach t , S . The i n v i tro permeabi l i ty of
s k i n and buccal mucosa to sel ected drugs and tri tated water .
J . I nves t . Derm . 67 : 7 13 - 7 1 7 ( 1976 ) .
7 5 ) Spru i t , D . The measurement and the regenerati on of the water vapor
l oss of human s k i n , pp 9-20 ( 1969 ) Thes i s Offset mi nOpri n t , N i jmegen .
7 6 ) Tregea r , R . T . Mol ecu l ar movement . I n : P hys i ca l Funct i ons of the
S k i n , Vol . 5, pp 6- 1 1 ( 1966 ) Academ i c Pres s , London .
7 7 ) Spru i t , D . The measurement and the . regeneration of the water vapor
l oss of human s k i n , pp 77-93 ( 1969 ) Thes i s Offset mi nOpri n t ,
N i jmegen .
7 8 ) Ma l ten , K . E . Thoughts on i rri tant contact dermat i ti s . Contact Derma-
59
t i t i s 7 : 238-247 ( 1981 ) .
7 9 ) Ummenhofer , B . Hornsch i chtphys i o l og i s che Grund l agen der Praventi on
und Rehabi l i tat ion von Berufsekzemen . Derma tosen 29 : 102- 106 ( 1 981 ) .
80 ) Eb l i ng , F . J . G . D i sorders of Sweat G l ands . I n : Textbook of Dermato
l ogy , pp. 1675- 1680 ( 1979 ) Edi tors : A. Rook , D . S . Wi l k i nson , F . J . G .
Eb l i ng . B l ackwel l Sc ient ifi c Pub l i cat i ons , Oxford .
81 ) Jenki nson , D . M . Comparat i ve phys i o l ogy of sweat i ng . Br . J . Derm . 88 :
397- 406 ( 1 973 ) .
8 2 ) Bel l , M . The u l tras tru cture of human axi l l ary apocri ne g l ands after
epi nephr i ne i nj ect ion . J . I nves t . Derm . 63 : 147 - 1 59 ( 1974 ) .
83 ) Cag e , G . W . Eccri ne and apocri ne secretory g l ands . I n : Dermatol ogy
i n general med i c i ne ( 197 1 ) Edi tors : T . B . Fi tzpatr i c k , K . A . Arndt ,
W . H . C l ark , A . Z . E i sen , E . J . van Scott , J . H . Vaughan . McGraw-Hi l l
Book Company , New Yor k .
84 ) Kl i gman , A . M . , Shehade k , N . Pub i c apocri ne g l ands and odor . Arch .
Derm . 89 : 46 1-462 ( 1964 ) .
8 5 ) Morimoto , T . T he eccr i ne and apocri ne g l ands and thei r funct i on . I n :
P hys i o l ogy and Pathophys i o l ogy of the Ski n V , pp 1623- 1663 ( 1 978 )
Ed i tor : A . Jarret . Academ i c Pres s , London .
86 ) S i l ver , A . , Montagna , W . , Versac i , A . The effect of denervat i on on
sweat g l ands after epi nephri ne i nj ect i on . J . I nves t . Derm . 42 :
307-324 ( 1964 ) .
87 ) Da l e , H . H . , Fel dberg , W . The chemica l transm i s s i on of secretory
i mpu l ses to the sweat g l ands of the cat . J . Phys i o l . 82 : 1 2 1 - 128
( 1964 ) .
88 ) Sato , K . The phys i ol ogy , pharmacol ogy and b i ochemi stry of the eccri ne
sweat g l ands . Rev . P hys i ol . B i ochem . Pharmaca l . 7 9 : 5 1 - 1 3 1 ( 1977 ) .
89 ) Uno , H . , Montagna , W . Cathechol ami ne-conta i n i ng nerve termi na l s of
the eccr i ne sweat g l ands of Macaques . Cel l . Ti s s . Res . 158 : 1 - 13 ( 1975 ) .
90 ) Kuno , Y . Human Perspi rat ion , p p 347-353 ( 1956 ) Ed i tor : R . F . P i tts ,
C . C . Thomas . Spri ngfi el d , I l l i no i s .
9 1 ) Th i e l e , F . A . J . , Reay , D . A . , Ma l i , J . W . H . Poss i b l e contri buti on to
heat trans fer through the human s k i n by the eccr i ne ( atri ch i a l )
sweat g l and . I n : Handbuch der Haut und Gescnl echtskrankhei ten ; ( 1981 )
Norma l e und Pathol og i sche Phys i ol og i e der Haut I I I ; Ed i tor : J .
60
Jadassohn , Spri nger Verl ag , Berl i n .
92 ) Thi el e , F . A . J . , Ma l ten , K . E . I nsens i b l e water l os s . Transacti ons
St . John ' s Hos p i ta l . Soc . 58 : 199- 2 1 7 ( 1972 ) .
93 ) Matol tsy , A . B . , Bal samo , C . A . A study of the compounds of the
corn i fi ed epithel i um of human s k i n . J . Bi ophys i c . and Bi ochem .
Cyto l . 1 : 339-361 ( 1 955 ) .
94 ) Chr i s tophers , E . , Laurence , E . B . Ki net i cs a nd structura l organ i s a
t i on of the epi dermi s . I n : Curr . Probl . Derma tol . , Vol 6, pp
87- 104 ( 1976 ) Ed i tor : J . W . H . Ma l i . Karger , Base l .
9 5 ) Kl i gman , A . M . , The b i o l ogy of the stratum corneum . I n : The epi der
mis pp 387-433 ( 1 964 ) Edi tors : W . Montagna , W . C . Lobi tz .
Academi c Press , New York .
96 ) Ha l pri n , K . P . Epi derma l ' turnover t ime ' - a re-exami nati on . Br .
J . Derm . 86 : 14- 1 9 ( 1972 ) .
97 ) Bl an k , I . H . T he s k i n as an organ of protecti on agai n st the
external envi ronment . I n : Dermatol ogy in general med i c i ne , pp
102- 106 ( 19 79 ) Ed i tors : T . B . F i tzpatri ck , A . Z . E i sen , K. Wol ff ,
J . M . Freedberg , K . F . Austen . McGraw- H i l l Book Company , New Yor k .
98 ) Odl ang , G . F . , H i stol ogy a n d f i ne s tructure o f the epi dermi s . I n :
The s ki n , pp 28-46 ( 1 97 1 ) Edi tors : E . B . Helwi g , F . K . Mostofi .
The Wi l l i ams & Wi l ki ns Company , Ba l ti more .
99 ) Eb l i ng , F . J . G . , Rook , A . D i s orders of kerati ni zat ion . I n : Textbook
of Dermatol ogy , p . 1 259 ( 1979 ) Edi tors : A. Rook , D . S . Wi l ki nson ,
F . J . G . Ebl i ng . Bl ackwel l Sci enti f i c Pub l i cati ons , Oxford . 100 ) Menton , D . N . , E i sen , A . Z . Structure and organ i zat ion of mammal i an
stratum corneum . J . U l trastruct . Res . 3 5 : 247 - 264 ( 197 1 ) .
101 ) Yard l ey , H . J . , Summerl y , R . L i p i d compos i ti on and metabo l i sm i n
normal and d i seased epi dermi s . Pharma c . Ther . 1 3 : 357- 383 ( 1981 )
102 ) Th i el e , F . A . J . , Mal ten , K . E . Eva l uat ion of s k i n damage I . Br . J .
Derm . 89 : 373-382 ( 1973 ) .
103 ) Mal ten , K . E . , Th i e l e , F . A . J . Eva l uat ion of s k i n damage I I . Br . J .
Derm . 89 : 565- 569 ( 197 3 ) .
1 04 ) Sweeney , T . M . , Downes , A . M . , Matol tsy , A . G . The effect of DMSO on
the epi dermal water barr i e r . J . I nves t . Dermato l . 46 : 300-302
( 1966 ) .
6 1
105 ) Scheupl e i n , R . , Ros s , L . Effects of surfactants and sol vents on the
permeabi l i ty of the epi dermi s . J . Soc . Cosmet . Chern . 21 :
853-873 ( 1 970 ) .
106 ) Spru i t , D . , Mal ten , K . E . The regenerat ion rate of the water va pour
l oss of heav i ly damaged s ki n . Dermatol og i ca 1 3 2 : 1 1 5- 123 ( 1 966 ) .
107 ) Val k , P . G . M . van der , Nater , J . P . , B l eumi n k , E . S k i n i rri tancy of
surfactants as assessed by water vapour l oss measurements . J .
I nvest . Derm . 82 : 291-293 ( 1 984 ) .
108 ) Val k , P . G . M . van der , Cr i j ns , M . C . , Nater , J . P . , B l eum i n k , E . S k i n
i rri tancy o f commerc i a l ly ava i l ab l e soap and detergent bars a s
measured by water vapour l os s . Dermatosen 3 : 87-90 ( 1 984 ) .
109 ) Montagna , W . , Hu , F . , G i a cometti , L . Genera l morpho l ogy . I n : U l tra
structure of norma l and abnormal s k i n , pp 1-20 ( 1 967 ) Ed i tor : A . S .
Zel i ckson . Lea & Febi ger , P h i l adel ph i a .
1 10 } Mal ten , K . E . , Spru i t , D . , Boemaars , H . G . M . , Kei zer , M . J . M . Horny
l ayer i nju ry by sol vents . Berufsdermatosen 1 6 : 135- 147 ( 1 968) .
1 1 1 ) S ims , R . T . The epidermi s . I n : An i ntroducti on to the b i o l ogy of the
s k i n , pp 6 1 - 7 5 ( 1970 ) Edi tors : R . H . Champ i on , T . G i l l man , A . J . Rook ,
R . T . S i ms . Bl ackwe l l S c i en t i f i c Publ i cati ons , Oxford .
1 1 2 ) G i l l man , T . Derma-epi dermal i nterpl ay wi th spec i a l reference to the
heal i ng of cutaneous i nj ur ies and to carci nogenes i s . I n : An i ntro
duction to the b i ol ogy of the s ki n , pp 3 18-341 ( 1970 ) Edi tors :
R . H . Champi on , T . G i l l man , A . J . Rook , R . T . S ims . B l ackwe l l
Sc i ent i f i c Publ i cati ons , Oxford .
1 1 3 ) Jarret , A . The epi dermi s and i ts re l ati ons wi th the dermi s . I n :
The Phys i o l ogy and Pathophys i ol ogy o f the S ki n , Vol I , p p 3-42
( 1 97 3 ) Ed i tor : A . Jarret . Academ i c P ress , London .
1 14 ) Fros t , P . , Wei nstei n , G . D . , Bothwel l , J . W . , Wi l nauer , R . I ch thyos i
form Dermatoses I I I . Stud i es of transepiderma l water l os s . Arch .
Derm . 98 : 230-233 ( 1 968 ) .
1 1 5 ) Gri ce , K . , Satta r , H . , Baker , H . The cutaneous barr i er to sa l ts and
water in psori a s i s and in normal s k i n . Br . J . Derm . 88 : 459-462
( 1 973 ) .
1 16 ) P i n kus , H . Eczematou s ti ssue react ions . I n : A gu ide to dermato-
62
h i stopathol ogy , pp 95- 1 06 ( 1969 ) Ed i tor : A . H . Mehregan . Mered i th
Corporati on , New Yor k .
1 1 7 ) Kl i gma n , A . M . Cutaneous tox i col ogy ; a n overv i ew from the unders i d e .
I n : Curr . Probl . Dermatol . , V o l I , p p 1 - 25 ( 1978 ) Edi tor : J . W . H .
Ma l i . Karger , Basel .
1 18 ) Kl i gman , A . M . , Wood i ng , W . M . A method for the measurement and eva
l uat i on of i rri tants on human s ki n . J . I nves t . Derm . 49 : 78-94
( 1967 ) .
1 19 ) Na ter , J . P . , Groot , A . C . de . Local s i de effects of top i ca l drugs .
I n : Unwanted effects of cosmeti cs and drugs used i n derma tol ogy ,
pp 1 - 28 ( 1983 ) Excerpta Med i ca , Amsterdam , Oxford .
120 ) Berman , B . , France , D . S . , G i org i o , B . A . , Mar t i nel l i , P . , Hars , A .
Modu l at i on o f express i on o f epi derma l Langerhans cel l properti es
fol l owi ng i n s i tu exposure to g l ucocorti cos tero ids . J . I nvest . Derm .
80 : 168- 1 7 1 ( 1983 ) .
1 2 1 ) Baer , R . L . , G i g l i , I . Al l erg i c eczematous contact dermat i ti s . I n :
Dermatol ogy i n genera l med i c i ne , pp 5 12-519 ( 1979 ) Edi tors : T . B .
Fi tzpatri ck , A . Z . E i sen , K . Wol ff , J . M . Freedberg , K . F . Aus ten .
McGraw- Hi l l Book Company , New Yor k .
122 ) Kl i gman , A . M . T h e i denti fi cat i on o f contact a l l ergens by human
assay I I Factors i nfl uenc i ng the i nduction a nd measurement of
a l l erg i c contact dermati t i s . J . I nvest . Derm . 47 : 375- 392 ( 1966 ) .
123 ) Lanti nga , H . , Nater , J . P . , Coenraads , P . J . Preval ence , i nc i dence ,
and course on the hands and forearms i n a samp l e of the general
popu l ati on . Contact Dermati t i s 10 : 135- 139 ( 1984 ) .
1 24 ) Gri ce , K . A . Transepi derma l water l os s . I n : The Phys i o l ogy and
Pathophys i o l ogy of the Ski n , vol 6 , pp 212 .1 - 2 1 27 ( 1980 ) Edi tor :
A . Jarret . Academ i c Press , London .
1 25 ) Gri ce , K . A . , Satta r , H . , Sharra t , M . , Baker , H . S k i n temperature
and transepiderma l water l os s . J . I nves t . Derm . 57 : 108- 1 10 ( 197 1 ) .
1 2 6 ) Math i a s , C . G . T . , Wi l son , D . M . , Mai bach , H . I . Transepi derma l water
l os s as a funct i on of s k i n temperature . J . I nvest . Derm . 7 7 : 219-
220 ( 1981 ) .
1 27 ) Th i el e , F . A . J . , Senden , K . G . van . Rel a t i ons h i p between s k i n tempe
rature and the i nsens i b l e pers p i ra t i on of human s ki n . J . I nves t .
63
1 28 ) Rothman , S . The ro l e of the s k i n i n thermoregu l at i on : Factors i nf l u
enc i ng s k i n surface temperature . I n : Phys i o l ogy and Bi ochem i s try of
the Sk i n , pp 258-260 ( 1 954 ) The Uni vers i ty of Ch i cago Press , Chi ca
g o .
129 ) Rothman , S . Nonnervous eccr i ne swea t i ng . Nervous sweati n g . I n : Phy
s i o l ogy and Bi ochem i s try of the Sk i n , pp 1 6 1 - 162 , 168- 1 78 ( 1 954 )
The Uni vers i ty of Ch i cago Press , C h i cago .
130 ) S ha h i du l l ah , M . , Raffl e , E . J . , Frai n-Bel l , W . , R immer , A . R . Di u rna l
var iat i on i n transepi derma l water l oss . Br . J . Derm . 81 : 866-867
( 1969 ) .
1 3 1 ) Warndorff , J . A . De reacti es van de zweetkl i eren op st imu l ati e met
acetyl -chol i ne . Een onderzoek b i j a topi sche en ni et-atopi sche derma
tol og i s che pati enten en b i j gezonde proefpersonen . I n : Conti nue
reg i s trat i e van zweetsecreti e , pp 20-60 ( 1 972 ) Brakkens tei n , N i jme
gen .
132 ) Zol l ner , G . , Thauer , R . , Kaufma n , W . Der i nsens i b l e Gewi chtsverl ust
a l s Funkt i on der Umwel tbed i ngungen . Pfl Ugers Arc h i v 260 : 26 1-273
( 1 955 ) .
1 33 ) Gri ce , K . A . , Satta r , H . , Bake r , H . Effect of ambi ent humi d i ty on
transepi derma l water l os s . J . I nvest . Derm . 58: 343- 346 ( 1 972 ) .
1 34 ) Hal e , F . C . , Westl and , R . A . , Tayl o r , C . L . Barometri c and vapor pres
sure i nf l uences on i nsens i b l e wei ght l os s . J . Appl . Phys i o l . 1 2 : 20-
28 ( 1 958 ) .
135 ) Hammarl und , K . , N i l sson , G . E . , Oberg , P . A . , Sed i n , G . Transepiderma l
water l oss i n newborn i nfants I . Rel ati on to ambi ent humi d i ty and
s i te of measurement and estimati on of tota l transep i derma l water
l os s . Thes i s I I I pp 1-32 ( 1 977 ) Zata Tryc keri erna , L i n kopi ng .
1 36 ) Bett l ey , F . R . , Gri ce , K . A . The i nfl uence of amb i ent humi d i ty on
transepi derma l water l os s . Br . J . Derm . 79 : 575- 581 ( 1 967 ) .
1 3 7 ) Z i j l stra , W . G . , Brunst i ng , J . R . , Ten Hoar , F . , Mook , G . A . , R i s pens ,
P . Energ i ewi s sel i ng , voed i ng , temperatuurregel i ng . I n : Fys i o l og i e
van het i nterne m i l i eu , p p 260-269 ( 1973 ) V a n Gorcum & Camp . B . V . ,
Assen .
1 38 ) Operati on manua l . Evapor i meter Ep1 , October 1 97 7 . Operati on manual
Servo Med AB , Sweden .
64
139 ) Spru i t , D . The mea surement and the regenera t i on of the water l os s
o f human s k i n . D i ssertat i o n , offsetdru kkerij mi nOpr i nt , N i jmegen ,
2 1 -27 ( 1 969 ) .
1 40 ) N i l sson , G . E . Mea su rement of water exchange through s k i n . Med . B i o l .
Eng . & Comput . 1 5 : 209- 218 ( 1977 ) .
1 4 1 ) Tay l or , C . L . , Buettner , K . I nfl uence of evaporat ive forces u pon
s k i n temperature depend ency of human pers pi rat i on . J . Appl . P hys i o l .
6 : 1 1 3 - 1 23 ( 1 953 ) .
142 ) Wegg , P . , Garl i nton , L . N . , Schwarz , M . J . I nsens i b l e we i ght l os s at
h i g h s k i n temperatures . J . Appl . Phys i o l . 1 1 : 4 1 -44 ( 1 957 ) .
1 43 ) Zoon , J . J . , Mal i , J . W . H . The i nfl uence of erythroderma on the body .
Arch . Derm . 7 5 : 573-578 ( 1 957 ) .
1 44 ) Heerd , E . , Ohara , K . E i n gerit zure u nunterbrochenen Mes sung der
Persp i rat io i nsens i b i l i s k l ei ner Hautfl ichen . Pfl ugers Arch i v .
27 2 : 23 7-246 ( 1961 ) .
145 ) Adams , T . , Funkhou ser , G . E . , Kenda l l , W . W . Measurement of evapora
t i ve water l os s by a therma l conduct i v i ty cel l . J . Appl . P hys i o l .
1 8 : 1 291 - 1 293 ( 1963 ) .
1 46 ) Wi l son , J . S . , Moncr i e f , J . A . Vapor pressure of norma l and burned
s k i n . Ann . Surg . 1 6 2 : 130-134 ( 1965 ) .
147 ) Rosenberg , E . A . , B l a n k , H . , Resn i k , S . Swea t i ng and water l os s
through the s k i n . J . A . M . A . 1 7 9 : 809-81 1 ( 1962 ) .
148 ) Th i el e , F . A . J . , Schutter , K . A new mi cro method for measu ri ng the
water-ba l a nce of the human s k i n . Sa l t crysta l method . J . I nv . Derm .
3 9 : 95- 1 1 1 ( 1962 ) .
1 49 ) Fal l o n , R . H . , Moyer , C . A . Rates of i nsens i b l e pers p i rati o n through
norma l , bu rned , tape str i pped , and ep iderma l ly denuded l i v i ng human
s k i n . Ann . Surg . 1 58 : 9 1 5-923 ( 1963 ) .
1 50 ) Burch , G . E . , Sodeman , W . A . Reg i onal rel ati ons h i ps of rate of water
l os s i n norma l adu l ts i n a subtropica l c l imate . Am . J . P hys i o l .
1 38 : 603-609 ( 1943 ) .
1 5 1 ) Neumann , C . , Cohn , A . E . , Burch , G . E . A quant i ta t i ve method for the
measurement of the rate of water l os s from sma l l areas , wi th resu l ts
for f i nger t i p , toe t i p and postero - superi or porti on of the p i nna
of normal rest i ng adu l ts . Ame r . J . P hys i o l . 1 3 2 : 748-756 ( 1 941 ) .
65
1 5 2 ) Bu l l ard , R . W . Conti nuous record i ng of swea t i ng rate by res i s tance
hygrometry . J . Appl . Phys i o l . 17 : 7 3 5-737 ( 1 962 ) .
153 ) Rovens ky , J . , Sax l , 0 . D i fferences i n the dynam i cs of sweat se
cret i on in atopi c ch i l dren . J . I nv . Derm . 43 : 1 7 1 - 176 ( 1 964 ) .
1 54 ) Lamke , L . An i nstrument for estimati ng eva pora t i on from sma l l s k i n
surfaces . Scand . J . P l as t . Reconstr . Surg . 4 : 1 - 7 ( 1 970 ) .
1 5 5 ) Cohen , S . An i nvest i g ati on and fract i onal asses sment of the eva
porat i ve water l os s through norma l s k i n and burn eschars u s i ng a
mi crohyg rometer . P l as t . and Reconstr . Surg . 37 : 475- 486 ( 1 966 ) .
1 56 ) Spru i t , D . Measu rement of the water vapour l oss from human s k i n by
a therma l conduct i v i ty ce l l . J . Appl . Phsyi o l . 23 : 994-997 ( 1967 ) .
1 57 ) Al bert , R . E . , Pa l mes , E . D . Evaporat ive rate patterns from sma l l s k i n
areas a s measured by a n i nfrared gas ana lyzer . J . Appl . Phys i ol .
4 : 208- 2 1 4 ( 1 95 1 ) .
1 58 ) P i r l et , K . E i ne Methode zur Hautwass erabgabe i n k l e i nen Hautarea l en .
Arch . ges . Phys i o l . Pfl Uger ' s 273 : 182- 180 { 1 961 ) .
159 ) N i l s son , G . E . , Oberg , P . A . A new method for measu rement of trans
epi derma l water l os s . 3rd . Nord i c Meeti ng on Med i ca l & B i o l og i ca l
Eng i neer i ng , Tampere , 53 : 53 . 1- 53 . 3 ( 1975 ) . 1 60 ) N i l sson , G . E . On the measurement of evaporat ive water l os s , thes i s ,
Zata Trycker i erna , L i n kopi ng , 9-42 ( 1977 ) .
1 6 1 ) Whel don , A . E . , Montei t h , J . L . Performance of a s k i n evaporimeter .
Med . & B i o l . Eng . & Compu t . 1 8 : 201 - 205 ( 1 980 ) .
1 6 2 ) Hatt i ng h , J . , Luc k , C . P . A sens i ti ve , d i rect method for het measure
ment of water l os s from body su rfaces . S . Afr . J . Med . Sci . 38 :
3 1 - 3 5 ( 1973 ) .
163 ) Carnes , R . W . , So l l ec i to , W . A . , Sa l i s bury , R . E . Evaporat i ve water
l oss from hea l ed burn wou nd s . Journa l of Burncare and Rehab i l i ta
t i on , val . 2 No 5 : 239-245 ( 1 981 ) .
164 ) Scott , R . D . , O l i ver , G . J . A . , Dugard , P . H . , S i ng h , H . J . A compari son
of techni ques for the measurement of transepi dermal water l os s .
Arc h . Dermato l . Res . 274 : 57-64 ( 1 982 ) .
165 ) N i l sson , G . E . A theoret i ca l compar i son of the measurement sen s i t i v i
ty of d i fferent methods for measurement of evaporati on ( 1976 ) .
Publ i cat i on L i n kopi ng Un i vers i ty , Department of med i ca l engi neeri ng ,
66
Sweden .
1 66 ) Lamke , L . O . , N i l s son , G . E . , Rei thner , H . L . I nsens i b l e pers p i rat i on
from the s k i n u nder standardi zed envi ronmental cond i t i ons , thes i s ,
G . E . N i l s son , ( 1 977 ) Zata Trycker i erna , L i n kopi ng .
67
CHAPTER 2
SK IN I RR ITANCY OF SURFACTANTS AS ASSESSED BY WATER VAPO UR LOSS
MEASURE�iENTS
Journnl of I nvest igat ive Dermatol ogy
82 : 291-293 ( 1 984 )
68
Authors :
P . G . M . van der Val k
J . P . Nater
E. B l eumi nk
Summary
A method to assess the i rr i tancy of c hemi cal s on human s k i n that i s based
on measu rement s of s k i n (water ) vapor l oss ( SVL ) i s presented . The SVL
measurements were performed with the Servo Med Evapori meter in a group of
27 hPul thy vol unteers . Four surfactants , d i st i l l ed water . and NaCl 0 . 9%
i n d i sti l l ed water were assayed . For the exposures a chamber techni que
was used . Sod i um l auryl s u l fate and cocobet a i ne most marked ly i nfl uenced
the l oss of water through the s ki n . Pol ysorbate-60 and sodi um l aurate had
l ess effect on SVL . The mean d i fference between the test substances were
fou nd stat i st i ca l ly s i gn i f i cant , except for the mean d i fference between
sod i um l aurate and pol ysorbate-60 ( p > 0 . 1 ) and between polys orbate-60
and di sti l l ed water ( p > 0 . 05 ) . The reacti ons of the tested subj ects to the surfactants suggest that each i nd i v i dua l has h i s own pattern of sus
cepti b i l i ty to these substances . The mean va l ues of the SVL measurements
were compared w ith the macroscopi ca l l y percept i b l e morpho l og i c changes of
the exposed test s i tes . The resu l ts of the v i sua l scori ng system corres
ponded w ith the resu l t s of the SVL measu rements . The correl at i on coeffi
c i ent between the mean val ues of both methods was found to b e h i gh ( r =
0 . 98 ) .
I ntroducti on
The i nfl uence of surfactants on the s k i n can be s tud i ed in d i fferent ways .
I n exposure tests , by g i v i ng a test panel a cert a i n product for a l ength
of t ime , i nterven i ng var iab l es hamper i n terpretat i on of the resu l t s ( 1 , 2 ) .
A more rel i abl e techn i que for eva l uati ng s k i n i rr i tancy of c l eansers i s
the soap chamber tes t , ut i l i z i ng a v i sual scori ng system ( 1 ) . Al though
macroscop i cal ly percept i b l e changes of the s k i n observed w i th thi s method
more or l ess corres pond w ith the c l i n i ca l p i cture of eczema , the method
i s not very obj ect i ve and i s prone to i nterobserver b i a s ( 3 , 4 ) . Moreover ,
unphys i o l og i cal ly h igh concentrati ons of soaps or detergents have to be
used to produce d i scern i b l e reacti ons of the s k i n ( 5 ) . Another method for
eva l uati ng the: i nfl uer 1ce of chem i c a l substances i s a ssessment of d i stur
bances in uarri er capaci ty of the s k i n ( 6 , 7 ) . Techn i ques to eva l uate the
69
barri er capaci ty are measu rements of s k i n i mpedance and water vapor l oss
( 6 ) . The l atter techn i que i s i ncreas i ng ly u sed to study the s k i n tox i c i
ty o f chemi cal substances , a l though there i s st i l l some controversy about
th i s method ( 2 , 5-9 ) .
We want to present a s k i n vapor l oss ( SVL ) method wi th wh i ch the effect
of exposure on the s k i n to mi l d i rr i tants can be measured .
Materi a l s and methods
For the exposu re , the l arge F i nn chamber wa s uti l i zed - an a l umi n i um cup
wi th a d i ameter of 12 mm ( Ep i tes t , Hel s i n ki , F i n l and ) ( 10 ) . F i ve pi eces
of absorbi ng paper ( Whatman ) were fi tted i nto each chamber wh i ch subse
quently received 100 �L of a 2 g/ 100 ml i n d i sti l l ed water by mea ns of an
Oxford pi pette ( Oxford Lancer , Brunswi ck Company , St . Loui s , Mi ssouri ) .
The chambers were appl i ed pa i rwi se to the vol ar s i de of the forearm by a
sma l l pi ece of non i rri tat i ng Leukos i l k tape ( Bei ersdorf , Hamburg , Germa
ny ) . Fi xati on was assured by the use of Mol l e l ast el asti c gauze bandages
( Lohmann , Neuwi ed , Germany ) .
A panel of 27 heal thy vol unteers wi thout s k i n ai l ments ( 8 women and 19
men , rang i ng in age from 21-32 years ) were tes ted dur i ng the month of De
cember. The s k i n wa s exposed to the tes t substances duri ng a peri od of
24 h . An off- peri od of 1 h before the actual SVL mea surements was empl oy
ed to reduce the effects of macerat ion and desorpt i on after the arti f i c i
a l hydrati on , wh i ch m ight i nfl uence the resu l ts ( 1 1 ) .
Prior to the SVL measu rements the test s i tes were graded for erythema ,
scal i ng , and f i s suri ng accord i ng to a method descri bed by Frosch and Kl i g
ma n ( 1 ) . Erythema : 1+ , s l ight redness , spotty of d i ffus e ; 2+ , moderate
rednes s ; 3+ , i ntense rednes s ; 4+ , f i ery red wi th edema . Scal i ng : 1+ , f i ne
cracks ; 2+ , s i ng l e or mu l t i p l e broader f i s sures ; 3+ , wide cracks wi th he
morrhage or exudat ion .
After the 1- hour off- peri od a prel imi nary t i me of 1 5 m i n was kept before
the actual measurements were i n i t i ated i n order to reduce effects of ther
mi c and emot i ona l sweat i ng ( 1 1 ) .
The quant i tat ive measurements of evaporat i ve water l os s were carr i ed out
u s i ng the Servo Med Evaporimeter ( Servo Med , Stockho l m , Val l i ngby , Sweden ) .
70
Thi s i nstrument uses the method of g rad i ent estimati on des cri bed i n deta i l
by N i l sson ( 12 ) . The operat i ng pr i nc i p l e of t h i s method i s based on ca l
cu l at i on of the vapor pressure g rad i ent i n the l ayer adj acent to the s k i n .
The pres sure gradi ent i s w i t h i n a stati onary l ayer of a i r surround i ng the
human body proporti onal to the exchange of water vapor from the s k i n sur
face . The actual i nstrument compr i s es a hand- hel d probe attached to a por
tab l e d i s p l ay uni t . Duri ng the SVL measurements a hol der was used for the
probe to prevent warmi ng up and to make some maneuveri ng poss i b l e . After
app l yi ng the probe perpend i cu l ar to the s k i n surface , stabi l i zation of
the d i s p l ayed val ues was awa i ted . The m idpo i nt va l ue of a 1 5-s . SVL reg i s
trat i on was ta ken as a typ i ca l score for the tes ted s k i n s i te . Measu re
ments were carri ed out on exposed and on 6 unexposed adj acent s k i n s i tes .
The measu rements of SVL were performed i n a tempera tu re-control l ed room
( 22° C ) wi th a rel a ti ve hum i d i ty of 28 . 7 ± 5 . 0% . Duri ng the measurements
s k i n temperature was reg i s tered by means of a Yel l ow Spri ngs thermi stor
prox ima l to the tested s k i n area ( Yel l ow Springs I n strument , Yel l ow
Springs ) .
The fol l owi ng 6 substances
sod i um l aury l s u l fate
sod i um l aura te
pol ysorbate-50
cocobeta i ne
di sti l l ed water
NaCl 0 . 9�
were tes ted on both the
a n i on i c surfactant
ani oni c surfactant
noni on i c surfactant
amphoteri c surfactant
control
control
r i g ht and l eft arms :
( pH 7 . 3 )
( pH 9 , 2 )
( pH 3 . 8 ) ( pH 5 . 2 )
( pH 5 . 6 )
( pH 6 . 7 )
These surfactants were sel ected because of the d i fferences i n chemi ca l
properti es and on the bas i s of frequency of use in commerc i a l l y avai l ab l e
products .
Stat i sti ca l Methods
The observed frequency d i s tr i but i ons of SVL data of the d i fferent test
s i tes were stud i ed for c l ear dev i ances from norma l i ty (Gau s s i an d i stri bu
t i on ) by means of Kol mogorov- Smi rnov one-samp l e tes t .
I n compar ing the d i fferent test substances the mean SVL va l ues were eva l u
ated for s i gn i f i cant d i fferences u s i ng a t-tes t for pai red data (a=0 . 05 ) .
71
The var i a ti on of the SVL val ues was ana lyzed by est imati ng one person ' s
SO ( cr = IMSr ; MSr = res i dua l mean sum of squares ) and that between per
sons ' SD ( cra = /(MSa - MSr ) / 2 ; MSa = i ntersubj ect mean sum of squares ) .
The morphol og i c changes of the s k i n after exposure of the test subs tances
were eval uated by cal cu l ati ng an " overa l l score " for each i nd i v i dua l test
s i te from the scores for erythema , fi ssuri ng , and sca l i ng as graded by
Frosch and Kl i gman ( 1 ) . Di fferences between the test substances as asses
sed by th is v i sual scor i ng system were tes ted by means of the Wi l coxon
s i gned rank sum test for pai red data u s i ng the mean of the overa l l scores
( a = 0 . 05 ) .
The test substances were ranked accord i ng to the mean SVL as wel l as the
mean overal l score of the morpho l og i c changes of the sk i n . Pearson ' s pro
duct-moment correl at i on between the mean scores of both methods was ca l
cu l ated .
Resu l ts
I n Tab l e I the SVL val ues of exposed and u nexposed s k i n s i tes are summa
r i zed . The surfactants as wel l as d i st i l l ed water and NaCl 0 . 9% l ed to
an i ncrease of SVL as compared wi th unexpos ed sk i n . Sod i um l auryl su l fate
and cocobeta i ne most marked l y i nf l uenced the l oss of water through the
s k i n whereas pol ysorbate-60 and sod i um l au rate proved to have l ess effect
on evaporati ve wa ter l oss of the s ki n . Consp i cuous is the d i fference be
tween d i sti l l ed water and NaCl 0 . 9t .
Ana lys i s of the SVL frequency d i stri but i ons ( Kol mogorov- Smi rnov one- sam
p l e tes t ) d i d not show s i gn i f i cant d i fferences between the observed cumu
l at i ve frequency di stri buti ons of SVL data and the corres pond i ng ( theore
t i ca l ) cumu l at i ve frequency d i stri but i on of normal ly d i stri buted data .
I n v i ew of these data di fferences between the tes t substances , they were
tested by means of a t-test for pai red data . Al l the mean d i fferences be
tween the test substances were s i gn i f i cant , except for the mean d i fferen
ce between sod i um l aurate and pol ysorbate-50 ( p > 0 . 1 ) and the mean d i f
ference between pol ysorbate-50 and d i sti l l ed water ( p > 0 . 05 ) .
7 2
Tabl e I . Mean s k i n vapor l ossa after a 24-h exposure .
Mean { g/m2h ) SD
1 . SVL after sod i um l auryl su l fate 1 5 . 5 4 . 0
2 . SVL after sod i um l aurate 10 . G 2 . 5
3 . SVL after pol ysorbate-GO 9 . 8 2 . 5
4 . SVL after cocobeta i ne 1 2 . G 2 . 3
5 . SVL after d i st i l l ed water 9 . 2 2 . 1
G . SVL after NaCl 0 . 9.1> 7 . 7 1 . 9
7 . SVL control b G . 2 1 . 3
a Twenty- seven subj ects ; 2 measurements i n 1 subj ect . b Twenty- seven subjects ; G measurements i n subj ect .
Tabl e I I . S i n g l e person s ' and between eersonsa s tandard dev i at i on of
the SVL val ues .
S i n g l e persons ' S D Between person s ' SD
1 . Sod i um l auryl su l fate 2 . 9 3 . 4
2 . Sodi um l aurate 2 . 2 2 . 0
3 . Pol ysorbate-GO 2 . 2 2 . 0
4 . Cocobeta i ne 1 . 8 2 . 0
5 . Di sti l l ed water 2 . 0 l . G
G . NaCl 0 . 91 1 . 5 l . G
a Twenty- seven subj ects ; 2 test s i tes i n 1 subj ect .
73
Di s pers i on of the SVL va l ues
Tab l e I I g i ves a survey of a s i ng l e person ' s SO and the SD between per
sons for each test substances . Both sources of var iat i on proved to be im
portant .
I nfl uence of personal and env i ronmental var i ab l es
The i nfl uence of rel evant var iab l es u pon va l ues of unexposed s ki n was
stud i ed . Amb i ent hum i d i ty d i d not i nfl uence SVL i n the obs erved rang e .
The i nfl uence of a i r temperature cou l d not be stud i ed because t h e tem
perature was a l most constant . Personal ( conti nuous ) var i a b l e l i ke age ,
s k i n temperatu re , and arm c i rcumference at t he test s i te d i d not have a
s i gn i f i cant i nfl uence . Th i s a l so appl i ed for d i screte vari abl e such as
sex , s k i n type , and h i s tory of atopy in th i s grou p .
Compari son o f the S V L method w i t h a v i sua l scor i ng sys tem
I n tabl e I I I the macroscop i ca l ly v i sual changes of the s k i n after expo
sure to the test su bstances are l i sted . The ar ithmet i c mean of the over
a l l scores was taken as a measure for the i rri tancy of the test substan
ces . I t is noteworthy that a s i ng l e 24-h exposure of a 2 g/ 1 00 ml so l u
t i on i n d i s t i l l ed water d i d not provoke severe reactions ( 3+ and 4+ ) as
observed by Frosch and Kl i gman ( 1 ) . The d i fferences between the mean
overa l l s cores were tested for s i gn i fi cance ( Wi l coxon ' s s i gned rank sum
test for pai red data ) . Al l mean d i fferences between the tes t substances
were s i gn i f i cant , except for the di fference between sod i um l aurate and
pol ysorbate-60 , sod i um l aurate and d i st i l l ed water (p > 0 . 1 ) , and be
tween polys orbate-60 and d i s t i l l ed water ( p > 0 . 05 ) .
The mean react i on of the tes ted s k i n s i tes to the chemi ca l s as measured
by the SVL method was compared w i th the mean overa l l s cores . ( F i gs 1 , 2 ) .
The rank order of i rri tancy of the tested substances was equal for both
methods . Correl at i on between the mean scores of both methods was r =
0 . 98 .
Di s cus s i on
The resu l ts of the i nves t i gat ion poi nt out that the descri bed method of
74
Tab l e I I I . Mean scores of the morphol ogi c changes a after a 24-h exposure .
Erythema Sca l i ng F i s s ur i n g " Overa l l
s core"
1 . Sod i um l auryl s u l fate 0 . 926 0 . 093 0 . 167 1 . 833
2 . Sod i um l aurate 0 . 296 0 . 056 0 . 167 0 . 537
3 . Pol ysorbate-60 0 . 352 0 . 000 0 . 074 0 . 462
4 . Cocobeta i ne 0 . 574 0 . 03 7 0 . 204 1 . 093
5 . D i st i l l ed water 0 . 296 0 . 000 0 . 01 9 0 . 333
6 . NaCl 0 . 9% 0 . 1 48 0 . 000 0 . 000 0 . 1 48
a T1�enty- seven s ubjects ; 2 test s i tes i n 1 subj ect .
7 5
SVL measurements to assess the i rri tancy of surfactants i s equ i va l ent to
a v i sua l scori ng system ( soap chamber tes t ) , wi th the advantage that pa
rametri c analys i s can be used to eva l uate sma l l d i fferences i n i rr i tancy
of the surfactants . Wi th th i s method i t i s pos s i b l e to test surfactants
i n wea k concentrati ons , resemb l i ng da i ly l i fe c i rcums tances .
Al though c l ear d i fferences among the ( genera l ) i rr i tancy of the test sub
s tances cou l d be noted , con s i derabl e vari a t i on of the SVL val ues was a l so
observed (Tab l e I I ) . Th i s may be expl a i ned i n part by i naccurac i es of the
SVL method (. s i ng l e persons ' var i a t i on of the SVL val ues after exposu re
of the same surfactant ) . Howeve r , d i vergent patterns of SVL val ues cou l d
be observed , probably a l s o contri bu t i ng to the total vari at ion of the re
su l ts , wh i ch suggest i n ter- and i ntrasubj ect d i fferences in suscept i b i l i
ty .
Di fferent damag i ng effects have been descri bed l i ke degrea s i ng of the
s k i n , denaturat ion of kera ti n , wi thdrawa l of the " natural moi ster i ng fac
tors , " and destabi l i zati on of l ysosomes ( 13 - 18 ) . These effects d i rect ly
or i nd i rectl y ( e . g . , by i nf l ammatory proce sses ) i nfl uence the barr i er
funct i on of the s k i n . Surfactants have d i fferent phys i cochem i ca l proper
t i e s . Consequent ly each surfactant wi l l penetra te and affect the s k i n to
a certa i n extent a l ong s pec i f i c pathways wi th s peci f i c i nteracti ve and
cumu l ati ve effects , res u l t i ng i n d i sturbances of the barr i er funct i on .
Furthermore , i t i s pos s i b l e that const i tuti onal d i fferences i n s k i n type
cause a s pec i f i c i nd i v i dua l suscept i b i l i ty to the effects of a substance ,
resu l t i ng i n i nter- and i ntras ubject d i fferences i n SVL after exposure .
The pattern of wi dely d i vergent morpho l og i c changes as observed i n the
soap chamber test support th i s hypothes i s .
76
16-l t
14l m, . n 12J S . V . L v a l ues 10
8�
6� �
t
f f f
' +
II I I I .-----J 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
surf a c t a n t s and c o n t r ols
m e a n 'o v e r a l l s c o r e s'
2
f
! t t
� � 2 3 4 5 6 7
surfactants a n d controls
F i g . 1 . S k i n i rr i tancy of the tes ted substances as asses sed by S . V . L . measurements
and by a ' v i s ua l s cor i ng sys tem ' (mean s cores ! S . E . M . ) .
1 . sod i um l aury l s u l fate 2 . sod i um l aurate 3 . polysorbate-60
4 . cocobeta i ne 5 . d i s t i l l ed water 6 . NaCl 0 . 9% 7 . control .
,..... ,..._
16
14
MEAN 12 S V_L VALUES
10
8
I 0, 4
I 0, 8
I 1.2
MEAN 'OVERALL SCORES'
I 1.6
I 2, 0
F i q . I I . Scattergram of the tes ted subs tances ; regres s i on of the
mean S . V . L . wi th the mean ' overal l s core ' of the morpho-
1 og i c changes .
78
References
1 ) Fros c h , P . J . , Kl i gman , A . M . The soap chamber tes t . J . Am . Acad . Der
matol . 1 : 35-41 ( 1979 ) .
2 ) Ketel , W . G . van , Bruynzeel , D . P . , Bezemer , P . D . , Stamhu i s , I . H . Tox i
c i ty o f hand c l eansers . Dermato l og i ca 168 : 94-99 ( 1 984 ) .
3 ) Wah l berg , J . E . Assessment of s k i n i rr i tancy : measurement of s k i n fol d
th i c knes s . Contact Dermat i t i s 9 : 2 1-26 ( 1 983 ) .
4 ) Shel l ow , W . V . R . , Rapa port , M . J . Compari son tes t i ng of soap i rri tancy
u s i ng a l umi n i um chamber and standard patch methods . Contact Derma
t i t i s 7 : 7 7-79 ( 1 981 )
5 ) Has s i ng , J . H . , Nater , J . P . , B l eumi n k , E . I rr i tancy of l ow concentra
t i ons of soap and synthet i c detergents as meas ured by s k i n vapour
l os s . Dermatol og i ca 164 : 3 1 4-32 1 ( 1982 ) .
6 ) T h i e l e , F . A . J . , Ma l ten , K . E . Some measuri ng methods for the eva l ua
t i on of orthoerg i c contact dermat i t i s . Arch . Be l g . Dermato l . 28 : 23-
46 ( 1973 ) .
7 ) Mal ten , K . E . , Arend , J . den . Topi ca l tox i c i ty of var i ou s concentra
t i on s of DMSO recorded w i th impedance measurements and water vapour
l os s measurements . Contact Dermati ti s 4: 80-92 ( 1978 ) .
8 ) Mal ten , K . E . , Spru i t , D . , Boemaars , H . G . M . , Kei zer , M . J . M . de . Horny
l ayer i nj u ry by so l vents . Berufsdermatosen 16 : 1 35- 147 ( 1978 ) .
9 ) Va l k , P . G . M . van der , Nater , J . P . , B l eumi n k , E . S k i n vapour l os s as a
method for measur i ng the i nfl uence of soaps and detergents on human
s k i n . Derm . Beruf . Umwel t 2 : 58-60 ( 1983 ) .
10 ) P i r i l a , V . Chamber test versus patch test for epi cutaneou s tes t i ng .
Contact Dermati ti s 1 : 48- 52 ( 197 5 ) .
1 1 ) Ba ke r , H . , Kl i gman , A . M . Measurement of transepi dermal water l os s by
el ectri ca l hygrometry . Arc h . Dermatol . 96 : 441-452 ( 1967 ) .
1 2 ) N i l s s on , G . E . Measurement of water exchange through the s k i n . Med .
B i o l . Eng . Comput . 1 5 : 209- 218 ( 1977 ) .
1 3 ) Harrol d , S . P . Denaturat i on of epi derma l kerat i n by surface act i ve
agents . J . I nves t . Dermatol . 3 2 : 581- 588 ( 1959 ) .
1 4 ) Imokawa , G . , M i s h ima , Y . Cumu l at i ve effects of surfactants on cuta
neous horny l ayers : Lysosome l ab i l i z i ng act i o n . Contact Dermati t i s 5 :
7 9
1 51- 162 ( 1979 ) .
1 5 ) K i r k , J . F . Effect of hand was h i ng on s k i n l i p i d remova l . Acta Derm .
Venereol . ( Suppl . ) ( Stockh . ) 57 : 24-68 ( 1966 ) .
1 6 ) Mal a szk iewi cz , J . Untersuchungen Uber d i e Wi rkung von Ten s i den auf
d i e mensch l i che Haut mi t e i ner Mi kromethode . Arch . Kl i n . Exp . Der
mato l . 237 : 652-661 ( 1970 ) .
1 7 ) Smeen k , G . The i nfl uence of detergents on the s k i n . Arch . Kl i n . Exp .
Dermato l . 235 : 180- 19 1 ( 1 969 ) .
1 8 . Scott , E . J . van , Lyon , L . 8 . A chem ica l measure of the effect of soap
and detergents on the s k i n . J . I nves t . Dermatol . 2 1 : 199-203 ( 1 963 ) .
80
CHAPTER 3
THE VULNERAB I L ITY OF THE SK IN TO SURFACTANTS IN D I FFERENT GROUPS
OF ECZEMA PAT I ENTS AND CONTROLS AS DETERMINED BY WATER VAPOUR LOSS
Accepted for pub l i cati on i n
C l i n i ca l & Experi mental Dermatol ogy
81
Authors :
P . G . M . van der Va l k
J . P . Nater
E . B l eumi n k
Summary
Hea l thy unaffected s k i n of the vol ar s i d e of the forearm of eczema pa
t i ents and control s was exposed duri ng a peri od · of 48 hou rs to 100 � 1 of
a 2 g/v% sol ut ion of 8 surfactants and d i sti l l ed water by means of the
l arge F i nn chamber method .
The effect of th i s ' s tandardi zed s k i n i ns u l t ' was eval uated by means of
s k i n water vapour l os s measurements u s i ng the Servo Med Evaporimeter .
Cl ear d i fferences i n react i ons caus ed by the d i fferent surfactants were
observed .
The subgroup of pati ents wi th atopi c derma t i t i s reacted more severe ly
than d id the subgroup of heal thy control s to the syntheti c detergents .
The a l kal i ne soaps were tol erated rel ati ve ly wel l i n th i s grou p .
N o s i gn i fi cant di fferences i n react i on upon exposure to the surfactants
as determi ned by water vapour l os s measurements were noted between the
subgroup of pati ents wi th i rri tant contact dermati ti s and the subgrou p
of heal thy contro l s .
I ntroducti on
If the s k i n is exposed to a proper concen trati on of a surfactan t , func
ti onal d i s turbances of the s k i n , wh i ch can be assessed by i nterrel ated
parameters such as s k i n impedance , water l os s and carbon d i ox i de rel ease
of the s ki n , occur (Thi el e & Mal ten , 197 3 ; Ma l ten & Thi el e , 1 973a ,
von Ki s s , 1 981 ; v . d . Va l k , 1 984a ) . A l s o tox i c effects can be revea l ed by
means of i n v i vo and i n v i tro methods ( Fros ch , 1982 ; Smeenk , 1969 ) .
Under l aboratory cond i ti ons , th i s react i on represents to a certa i n ex
tent the s ame mechan i sm as i nvol ved i n i rri tant contact dermati t i s
( Kooyman & Snyder , 1 942 ; Frosch & Kl i gman , 197 9 ) .
I n the past , many aut�ors had a l ready poi nted to a pos s i bl e associ ati on
between the use of soaps and detergents and the devel opment of i rri tant
contact dermati ti s ( Pol ano , 1 968 ; Bettl ey , 197 2 ; Ma l ten , 1981 ) .
I n the s tudy reported here , unaffected s k i n of pati ents wi th various
dermato l og i ca l d i seases and of hea l thy subj ects was exposed to s tan
dardi zed sol ut ions of d i fferent surfactants i n order to assess the vu l -
82
nerabi l i ty of the s k i n to these subs tances .
The react ion to the surfactants was eval uated by mean s of s k i n water
vapour l os s mea surements u s i ng the Servo Med Evaporimeter ( N i l s son , 1977 ;
v . d . Va l k et a l . , 1 984a ) .
An attempt has been made to rel ate the observed i ncrease of water vapour
l os s after exposure to the surfactants to c l i n i ca l characteri st i c s of
the tested subj ects .
Mater i a l s and methods
The s k i n was exposed to the tes t substances by u t i l i z i ng F i n n chambers of
a d i ameter of 12 mm ( P i r i l a , 1 97 5 ) . Each chamber conta i ned absorb i ng pa
per wh i ch was s aturated wi th 100 � l of a 2 g/v% so l ut i on .
Four stri ps each cons i s t i ng of three F i nn chambers para l l e l to each other
were appl i ed to the vo l ar s i de of the forearm from proxi ma l l y to d i
stal l y . Each tri pl et of chambers con s i sted o f two chambers conta i n i ng a
surfactant and one chamber wi th d i s t i l l ed water . The s k i n was expos ed
duri ng a peri od of 48 hours to the fol l owi ng 8 s u rfactants :
sod i um l au rate a n i on i c pH 9 . 2
sod i um stearate an i on i c pH 10 . 4
s od i um l au ryl su l fate an ion i c pH 7 . 3
pota s s i um soap� a n i on i c pH 10 . 0
cocobetai ne amphoteri c pH 5 . 2
ceteareth- 12 non i on i c pH 6 . 4
cocami dopropy l beta i ne amphoter i c pH 6 . 0
pol ysorbate-60 non i on i c pH 3 . 8
� ) Pota s s i um s a l t of coconut and r i c i nu s o i l .
Water vapour l os s of the 1 2 exposed s k i n s i tes { 8 surfactants and four
contro l s wi th d i st i l l ed water ) and of four unexposed s k i n s i tes adjacent
to the four stri ps was determi ned . The measurements were performed twi ce :
after the 48 hours exposure and 24 hours l ater . Before t he actu a l mea
surements , there was a wa i t i ng peri od of 15 mi nutes in order to reduce
effects of sweati ng ( Ba ker & Kl i gman , 1 967 ) .
Duri ng the t ime of measurement ( ± 30 m i nutes ) , the rel a t i ve humi d i ty and
83
tempera ture of the ambi ent a i r were con s i dered as constan t .
For t h e quanti tat i ve determi nations o f eva porati ve water l oss , the Servo
Med Evaporimeter was used ( N i l sson , 1977 ; v . d . Va l k et a l . , 1 984a ) .
Test panel
A grou p of 103 subj ects ( 47 fema l es and 56 ma l es rangi ng in age from 19
to 7 2 years ) was tes ted in the l a st f i ve months of 1982 and the f i rst
two months of 1983 .
The panel cons i s ted of the fol l owi ng two groups :
number of subj ects mean age S . D .
1 ) Eczema pat i ents 69 35 . 3 1 3 . 9
2 ) Control s 34 39 . 8 1 3 . 8
The group of eczema pati ents con s i s ted of 5 subgroups :
number of subj ects mean age S . D .
1 ) Al l erg i c contact dermati t i s 14 37 . 2 1 5 . 9
2 ) I rri tant contact dermati t i s 1 7 30 . 7 1 3 . 1
3 ) Atop i c dermati ti s 10 28 . 1 7 . 1
4 ) Dys hi droti c dermati ti s 2 1 36 . 0 1 1 . 4
5 ) Uncl a s s i f i ed eczema 7 52 . 9 1 3 . 1
The c l a s s i fi cati on i nto eczema subgroups was based on h i story , cl i n i ca l
pi cture , i ntracutaneous tes ti ng and patch testi ng . The cri teri a of Fre
gert ( 1981 ) and Nater & de Groot ( 1982 ) were used for thi s c l a s s i fi ca
tion . Seven subj ects cou l d not be c l a s s i f i ed i nto one of the maj or ec
zema categor i es . Al l pati ents wi th eczema were tested i n a qui escent
pha se of the d i seas e .
The group o f control s cons i s ted o f two su bgroups :
1 ) Hea l thy contro l s
2 ) Pati ent cont ro l s
number of s ubj ects
19
1 5
mean age
33 . 5
47 . 8
S . D .
1 1 . 2
12 . 8
The subgroup of heal thy subj ects were ei ther med i ca l s tudents o r emp l oy
ees of the hos pi tal . The subgroup of pati ent control s con s i s ted of a
84
mi scel l aneous group hav i ng noneczema tous dermatoses ( u l cus cruri s , urt i
cari a , psor i a s i s , etc . ) . Di sti ncti on between these two control subgroups
wa s made in order to exc l ude a pos s i b l e i nfl uence of noneczematous de�
matoses of the s k i n e l sewhere on the test resu l ts .
A l l subj ects wi th a dermatol og i ca l d i sease ( eczematous and noneczematous )
were recru i ted from the pati ents v i s i t i ng the outpati ent department of
the c l i n i c for d i agnosti c purposes . The s k i n of a l l tes ted subj ects used
for the exposures and measu rement procedure was { c l i n i ca l l y ) unaffected .
I n most subj ects , the surfactants el i c i ted no v i s i b l e reacti ons or on l y
a s l i ght soap effect ( chappi ng ) . I n some subjects , t h e surfactants ,
wh i ch a l so caused a cons i derab l e i ncrease i n s k i n water vapour l os s ,
caused d i fferent grades of erythema .
Stati s t i ca l methods
The nu l l hypothes i s of no d i fference i n res pons e of the d i fferent groups
of s u bj ects to the surfactants was tested by u s i ng an a pproxi mate F-test
of mu l t i vari ate analys i s of vari ance ( Hu l l & N i e , 1981 ) .
To study d i fferences between the groups , t-tests for unpai red data were
performed . D i fferences between the surfactants i n i nfl uenc i ng s k i n water
vapour l oss were tes ted by u s i ng pai red t-tests .
As the fi rst step of the analys i s , poss i b l e i nfl uences of ambi ent humi
d i ty (mean 3 8 . 4� ! 8 . 7 ) and ambi ent temperature (mean 22 . 9°C ± 1 . 5 ) ,
age of the tes ted subj ects , month of tes t i ng , l ocat i on of the test s i tes
on the arm and sex of the tested subjects were assessed . No i nfl uence of
these var iab l es , except for the sex of the tested subjects , was detected
( a = O . D5 ) .
The mean wa ter vapour l os s of unexposed s k i n wa s 6 . 9 g/m2h ± 2 . 4 for 2 + ma l es and 6 . 2 g/m h - 2 . 4 for fema l es . For exposed s ki n , the d i fferences
i n reacti on between ma l es and fema l es were randomly negati ve or pos i ti v e .
These di fferences were not i nvol ved i n the ana l ys i s ( the subgroups were
not domi nated by one of the sexes ) .
85
Resu l t s
The mean evaporative water l oss of the s k i n s i tes exposed to surfactants
and d i sti l l ed water and the mean val ue for the unexposed control s i tes
are l i sted i n Tabl e I for the entire test panel .
The mu l t i var i ate ana lys i s of variance performed on the water l oss data
i nd i cated d i fferences i n reaction to the tested substances among the
di fferent groups ( p < 0 . 05 ) .
To study the d i fferences between the subgrou ps of eczema pati ents and
the subgroup of heal thy contro l s , the mean water vapour l oss va l ues for
corres pond i ng test s i tes were compared . On ly i n the subgroup of pati ents
wi th atop i c dermati t i s were s i g n i fi cant d i fferences observed for the
synthet i c detergent s . Between the three test s i tes expos ed to a l ka l i ne
soaps , the d i fferences proved to be non- s i g n i f i cant i n t h i s group ( Tabl e
I ) .
A s i g n i f i cant d i fference between the group of pati ents wi th atop i c der
mat i t i s and the heal thy i nd i v i dua l s w ith respect to the control measure
ments can be seen { d i s ti l l ed water and unexposed sk i n ) .
D i scu ss i on
The subgroup of pat i ents wi th atopi c dermati t i s reacted more severe ly
than d id the group of heal thy contro l s , espec i a l ly to the synthet i c de
tergents . The a l ka l i ne soa ps were tol erated rel a ti vely wel l i n the sub
group of atopi c dermati ti s . These fi ndi ngs confi rm the resu l ts of Has
s i ng et a l . ( 1982 ) , Fros ch ( 1 982 ) , Dyer & Hassapi s ( 1983 ) and van Ketel
et a l . ( 1 984 ) . These authors menti on the good tol erance of a l ka l i ne
soaps , especi a l l y for subj ects with a dry s k i n ( Frosch , 1 982 ) .
I t i s noteworthy that the water vapour l os s of unexposed s k i n i n the
subgroup of pati ents wi th atop i c dermati ti s was a l so s i g n i fi cant ly
h i g her ( p < 0 . 01 ) .
Al though macroscopi ca l ly no l es i ons may be v i s i b l e at the test s i te , i t
must b e empha s i zed that atop i c dermat i t i s i s often a genera l i zed s k i n
d i sease i n wh i ch a l so i n apparently norma l s k i n subcl i n i ca l a l terati ons
of the barr i er capaci ty may ex i st (de Jong h , 1981 ) .
86
A more severe react i on on the exposure to the surfactants as determ i ned
by water vapour l os s mea surements i n the s ubgroup of i rr i tant contact
dermati t i s as a who l e was not seen , a l though i t has been s tated that
genet i c factors may pl ay a rol e ( Kl i gman & Wood i ng , 1967 ) .
Th i s may be exp l a i ned as fol l ows :
1 ) I n th i s study , on ly one exposure of the s k i n to the tes t sub stance
was emp l oyed . After a cumu l at i ve i nsu l t to the s k i n by the same sur
factant by means of a seri es of exposures , a pred i s pos i t i on for chro
n i c i rr i tant contact dermati t i s may become man i fest .
2 ) W i th i n the et io l ogy of eczema a l l ergi c , i rr i tant and const i tuti onal
factors may p l ay a rol e . The rel at ive importance of these factors i n
each person i s often d i ffi cu l t to eva l uate . The present d i agnost i c
cr i ter i a may be too i naccurate to demonstrate ( smal l ) d i fferences i n
react i on on a cons t i tu t i onal bas i s between s ubj ects w i th and wi thout
a pred i s pos i t i on for chron i c i rr i tant contact dermati t i s .
3 ) The i nf luence of a cons t i tut i onal pred i s pos i t i on may be i ns i g n i fi cant
in compari son wi th the rel evant externa l i nfl uences ; the effects of
the l atter may overr i de cons t i tu t i ona l factors ( Ma l ten & Th i e l e ,
1973b ) .
4 ) The rol e of barr i er funct i on i mpa i rment i n the devel opment of i rr i
tant contact dermati ti s may be overemphas i zed ; consequentl y , d i ffe
rences i n s u s cepti b i l i ty to barri er functi on d i sturbances may not
run para l l e l to d i fferences i n vu l nerabi l i ty to devel op chron i c i rr i
tant contact dermati ti s ( v . d . Val k et a l . , 1 984b ) .
87
TABL E I MEAN SK IN WATER VAPOUR LOSS VALUES (g/m2 h ) FOR ALL TESTED SUBJECTS , H EALTHY CONTROLS AND PATI ENTS
WITH ATOP I C DERMATIT I S AND I RR ITANT CONTACT DERMAT I T I S AFTER EXPOSURE TO THE SURFACTANTS
SURFACTANT ALL SUBJECTS H EALTHY CONTROLS I RR ITANT CONT . DERM . ATO P I C DERM .
( n = 103 ) ( n = 19 ) ( n = 1 7 ) ( n = 1 0 ) ± S . D . :!: S . D . :t S . D . + :!: S . D . s i gn . mean mean mean s i gn . mean
sod i um l aurate 9 . 5 : 3 . 2 9 . 5 : 3 . 3 10 . 5 : 3 . 6 0 . 442 1 1 . 3 +
2 . 8 0 . 1 71 -
sod i um stearate 10 . 4 : 6 . 1 9 . 5 : 3 . 6 9 . 7 : 2 . 7 0 . 940 1 1 . 6 + 4 . 0 0 . 197
sod i um l auryl su l fate 1 9 . 6 : 7 . 8 17 . 7 : 5 . 4 20 . 5 : 0 . 1 0 . 273 25 . 2 : 10 . 8 0 . 020
pota s s i um soap 1 1 . 1 : 3 . 7 10 . 6 : 3 . 7 1 1 . 8 : 4 . 4 0 . 394 1 1 . 8 + 2 . 9 0 . 377
cocobeta i ne 14 . 2 : 6 . 8 1 3 . 2 : 4 . 7 1 3 . 9 : 4 . 1 0 . 624 20 . 5 : 10 . 1 0 . 013 : 5 . 0 : 2 . 7 : 2 . 7 + 00
ceteareth - 1 2 1 0 . 4 9 . 0 10 . 5 0 . 1 1 2 16 . 2 9 . 8 0 . 007 00
cocami dopropyl beta i ne 1 0 . 8 : 4 . 5 10 . 0 : 2 . 8 10 . 6 : 4 . 4 0 . 640 1 7 . 0 + 7 . 4 0 . 001 -
pol ysorbate-60 9 . 0 : 4 . 0 8 . 4 ± 2 . 4 8 . 3 ± 1 . 9 0 . 853 14 . 6 + 9 . 7 0 . 016
d i st i l l ed wa ter 9 . 8 : 3 . 3 8 . 5 ± 2 . 5 9 . 8 : 2 . 4 0 . 1 3 5 14 . 1 :!: 6 . 1 0 . 002
contro l s++ 6 . 6 : 1 . 8 6 . 5 : 1 . 5 6 . 4 : 1 . 6 0 . 82 2 8 . 7 +
2 . 0 0 . 004 -
+ ) t-tests between the mean va l ues of correspond i ng test s i te s of pati ents w i th i rr i tant contact dermati t i s
and atopi c derma ti t i s and hea l thy control s o n the bas i s of pool ed vari ance .
++ ) the mean water vapour l os s of unexposed control s i tes .
References
1 ) Baker , H . , Kl i gman , A . M . Measu rement of tran sepiderma l water l oss by
el ectri cal hygrometry . Archi ves of Dermatol ogy 96 : 441-452 ( 1967 ) .
2 ) Bett l ey , F . R . The i rri tant effect of deterge nts . Transact i ons of the
St . John ' s Hos p i ta l of Dermatol og i ca l Soci ety 58 : 65-74 ( 197 2 ) .
3 ) Dyer , D . W . , Hassap i s , T . Compari son of detergent based versus soap
based l i qu i d soaps . Soap/Cosmeti cs/ Chem i ca l s peci a l i t i es 59 : 36-40
( 1 983 ) .
4 ) Fregert , S . Manua l of contact dermati ti s . Mu nksgaard , Copenhagen ,
pp 9- 10 ( 1981 ) .
5 ) Frosch , P . J . , Kl i gman , A . M . The soap chamber tes t . Journa l of the
Ameri can Academy of Dermatol ogy 1 : 35-41 ( 1979 ) .
6 ) Frosch , P . J . Pri nci p l es of Cosmeti cs for the Dermatol ogi s t . Fros t , P .
( ed . ) St . Horwi tz , Mosby , St . Loui s , pp 5 - 1 2 ( 1982 ) .
7 ) G i g l i , I . , Baer , K . L . Dermatol ogy i n Genera l Med i c i n e . McGraw-Hi l l
Book Company , New York , pp 520- 528 ( 1979 ) .
8 ) Has s i ng , J . H . , Nater , J . P . , B l eum i n k , E . The i rri tancy of l ow concen
trati ons of soap and synthet i c detergents as measured by s k i n vapour
l os s . Dermatol og i ca 164 : 314-321 ( 1982 ) .
9 ) Hu l l , H . , N i e , N . H . Stati st i ca l Pac kage for the Soc i a l Sci ences .
Update 7-9 . McGraw-Hi l l Book Company , New Yor k , pp 1-79 ( 1981 ) .
1 0 ) De J ongh , G . J . Poros i ty of human s k i n i n v i vo assessed v i a H2o l oss ,
co2 l os s and e l ectr i ca l i mpedance of hea l thy vol unteers , atop i c and
psori ati c pati en ts . Curr . Probl . Derm . Karger , Basel 9 : 83-101 ( 1981 ) .
1 1 ) Van Ketel , W . G . , Bruynzee l , A . P . , Bezemer , P . O . , Stamhu i s , J . H .
Tox i c i ty of handcl eaners 168 : 94-99 ( 1984 )
1 2 ) Von Ki ss , G . Prufung von durch Was chmi ttel bed i ngten Hautschad i gun
gen . Dermatosen i n Beruf und Umwe l t 29 : 1 5 - 18 ( 1981 ) .
1 3 ) Kl i gman , A . M . , Wood i ng , W . M . A method for the measu remen t and eva l u
at ion of i rr i tants on human s k i n . Journa l of I nves t i gat ive Dermato l o
g y 49 : 78-94 ( 1 967 ) .
1 4 ) Kooyman , D . J . , Snyder , F . H . Tests for mi l dness of soa p . Archi ves of
Dermatol ogy & Syphi l o l ogy 46 : 846-855 ( 1942 ) .
1 5 ) Mal ten , K . E . , T h i el e , F . A . J . Eva l uat ion of s k i n damage . I I Water
89
l os s and carbon d i ox i de re l ease measurements rel ated to s k i n res i s
tance measurements . Bri ti s h Journ a l o f Dermatol ogy 89 : 565- 569
( 1 973a ) .
1 6 ) Mal ten , K . E . , Th ie l e , F . A . J . Some theoret i ca l a spects of ' orthoerg i c '
( = i rri tant ) dermati ti s . Arch i ves Be l ges de Dermatol ogi e et de Syphi
l i graph i e 28 : 9-22 ( 1973b ) .
17 ) Ma l ten , K . E . Thoughts on i rri tant contact derma t i ti s . Contact Derma
t i t i s 7 : 238-247 ( 1981 ) .
18 ) Nater , J . P . , de Groot , A . C . Unwanted effects of cosmeti cs and drugs
used in dermatol ogy . Excerpta Med i ca , Amsterdam , Oxford , pp 1 -28
( 1983 ) .
1 9 ) N i l sson , G . E . Measurement of water exchange through s ki n . Med i c a l &
B i o l og i ca l Eng i neeri ng & Comput i ng 1 5 : 209-218 ( 1977 ) .
20 ) Pol ano , M . K . The i nteraction of detergents and the human s k i n . Jour
na l of the Soci ety of Cosmeti c Chemi sts 19 : 3-20 ( 1968 ) .
2 1 ) P i r i l a , V . Chamber test versus patch test for epi cutaneous tes t i ng .
Contact Derma t i t i s 1 : 48- 52 ( 1975 ) .
2 2 ) Smeen k , G . The i nfl uence of detergents on the sk i n . Archi v fUr k l i
n i sche und experi mentel l e Dermatol ogi e 235 : 180- 191 ( 1969 ) .
2 3 ) Th ie l e , F . A . J . , Ma l ten , K . E . Eva l uati on of s k i n damage . I . S k i n re
s i stance measurements wi th a l ternati ng current ( i mpedance meas ure
ments ) . Bri t i sh Journa l of Dermatol ogy 89 : 373-382 ( 1 973 ) .
24 ) Van der Va l k , P . G . M . , Nater , J . P . , B l eumi n k , E . S k i n i rri tancy of
surfactants as asses sed by water vapour l os s measurements . Journal
of I nvesti gati ve Dermatol ogy 82 : 291-293 ( 1984a ) .
25 ) Van der Val k , P . G . M . , Nater , J . P . , B l eumi n k , E . The i nfl uence of
repeated s k i n exposures to surface acti ve agents on water barr i er
and morpho l og i c parameters . Submi tted for publ i cat ion : Journa l of
Dermatol og i ca l Research ( 1 984b ) .
26 ) Ummenhofer , B . Hornschi chtphys i o l og i sche Grundl agen der Praventi on
und Rehab i l i tati on von Berufsekzemen . Dermatosen i n Beruf und Umwe l t
29 : 102-106 ( 1 981 ) .
90
CHAPTER 4
THE I NFLUENCE OF REPEATED S KI N EXPOSURES TO SURFACE ACT I VE
AGENTS ON WATER BARRI ER AND MORPHOLOG I C PARAMETERS
Submi tted for publ i cat ion i n
Journal of Dermato l og i cal Research
91
Authors :
P . G . M . van der Va l k
J . P . Nater
E . B l eum i n k
Summa ry
Surface act ive agents may i mpa i r the barr i er of the horny l ayer and may
a l so have a tox i c effect on the vi ab l e l ayers of the epi dermi s and der
mi s .
These effects of surfactants may contri bute to the devel opment of i rr i
tant contact dermati ti s , especi a l l y i f the s k i n i s frequentl y exposed .
Data on repeated exposure of the s k i n to s u rfactants , however , a re scarce.
In th i s s tudy , the effect of repeated exposure to l ow concentrat i ons of
surfactants on the barrier fu nction of the s k i n for water a nd on the
c l i n i ca l appearance of the s k i n ( soap effect ) was eva l uated .
For th i s purpose , the s k i n of the forearms of a panel of 20 heal thy med i
cal students was exposed three t i mes to fou r pure surfactants ( 0 . 5 w/ v% )
and to four propri etary products ( 1 w/ v% ) a t the same test s i te for
peri ods of 24 hours .
The effects of the test substances proved to be cumu l ati v e , except for
sod i um l aurate and pol ysorbate-60 , wh i ch had hard l y any effec t .
The general pa ttern of water barri er funct ion a nd macroscop i ca l l y v i s i b l e
changes corresponded , a l though d i fferences were observed .
Repeated expos ure to l ow concentrati ons of s urfactants may l ead to cumu
l a t i ve impa i rment of the barri er functi on of the horny l ayer and conse
quently to i ncreased permeat ion of substances . Th i s i ncreased permeati on
may be an important factor i n the devel opment of i rri tant contact derma
t i t i s , a l though other factors may a l so pl ay a ro l e .
I ntroducti on
Surface acti ve agents are known to l ead to impa i rment of the barr i er ca
paci ty of the s tratum corneum and a l so to d amage to the vi ab l e l ayers of
the epi dermi s and dermi s ( 1 , 4 , 1 8 ) .
Under l abora tory condi t i ons , i t has been shown that a s i ng l e exposure of
the s k i n to l ow concentrati ons of a surfactant as present i n c l eans i ng
mater i a l s may l ead to changes i n barr i er funct i on ( 2 , 6 , 19 ) .
A l though as a ru l e no marked i nf l ammatory reacti ons are observed after a
s i ng l e app l i cat i on of l ow concentrati ons of a surfactant , macroscopi ca l l y
92
vi s i b l e effects ( erythema , sca l i ng ) have been found to occu r ; a c l ear
associ ati on wa s found between macroscopi ca l l y v i s i b l e effects and s k i n
water vapou r l os s changes ( 20 ) .
At present , data on the effect of repeated or cont i nuous exposure to l ow
concentrat i ons of surfactants are s carce , j us t as those on the summa
t i on effect a nd pos s i b l e i rrevers i bl e changes whi ch may occur after
repeated exposure to surfactants ( 5 , 7 ) .
To eva l uate the rol e of surfactants i n the deve l opment of chroni c i rr i
tant contact derma t i ti s , control l ed stud i es on t h e accumu l at i on effects
of repeated exposure to surfactants may be of i mportance .
The a im of t h i s study was to i nvest i gate the effect of repeated exposures
to surfactants on water barr i er funct i on and on the c l i n i c a l appearance
of the s k i n . For th i s purpose , the s k i n of the forearms of a panel of
heal thy vo l unteers was exposed three t imes to four propri etary c l ea ns i ng
products a nd four surfactants duri ng peri ods of 24 hours .
The barr i er functi o n of the s k i n was eva l uated by means of s k i n water va
pour l os s measurements ( 12 , 20 ) . The morphol og i c changes of the s k i n were
graded accord i ng to a " v i sua l scori ng system" ( 4 ) .
Mater i a l s and methods
The s k i n of the vol ar s i de of the forearms was u sed for the exposures to
the test substances . Each substance was appl i ed to the s ame s k i n s i te
three t imes for per i od s of 24 hours ( on Monday , Tuesday a nd Wednesday of
the f irst week of the i nvest i gat ions ; see schedu l e ) .
The s k i n of both arms was exposed to the fol l owi ng propri etary products
a nd surfactants :
R ight arm : Left arm:
Type of
Brand name pH Chemi ca l name surfactant pH
Zwi t s a l baby soap 10 . 6 Cocobetai ne amphoter i c 5 . 2
Su l foderm soap 5 . 9 Sod i um l aurate a n i on i c 9 . 3
Neutrogena soap 9 . 8 Sod i um l auryl s u l fate a n i o n i c 7 . 3
Lactacyd soap 3 . 8 Polysorbate-60 non i on i c 3 . 8
93
For the exposures , a l um i n ium chambers ( La rge F i n n Chambers , Epi test Ltd .
Oy Hel s i nk i , F i n l and ) wi th a d i ameter of 12 mm were used . Each chamber
was fi tted wi th 5 pi eces of absorbi ng paper ( Whatman ) wh i ch were satura
ted with 100 � l of the test substance . The propri etary products were
tested i n a 1 w/v% sol uti on and the surfactants i n a 0 . 5 w/v� s o l u t i on .
Unexposed occl uded ( by an empty chambe r ) s k i n served a s a control area .
The effect of the test substances on the s k i n was eva l uated after each
24 hour exposure ( on Tuesday , Wednesday and Thursday of the fi rst week
of the i nvest i ga t i o n ) and subsequently on Fri day of the same week and on
Monday to Thursday of the second week ( see schedu l e ) .
The durat ion of th i s study had to be l im i ted to th i s peri od for pract ica l
reascns .
Fi rst week Second week 3: --i :E: --i "Ti (./') (./') 3: --i :E: --i 0 <: ro ::::r ""'l Qj <: 0 <: ro ::::r ::> ro a. <: �. <+ ::> ::> ro a. <: a. Ul ::> -s a. <: a. a. Ul ::> -s Qj a. ro VI Qj -s Qj Qj a. ro VI
'< Qj VI a. '< a. '< '< Qj VI a. '< a. Qj Qj '< a. Qj
Qj '< '< Qj '< '< '<
" " " " " I " " " I A I I : I : I I I I I
Schedu l e of the app l i cat i on a nd eva l ua t i on of the test subs tances .
- - --> appl i cat i o n , --> eva l uat i o n .
The tests were performed i n a panel o f hea l thy med i ca l s tudents wi thout
s k i n cond i t i ons ( 1 1 women and 9 men rang i ng in age from 19 to 34 years ) .
The s k i n water vapour l oss of the exposed s k i n s i tes and control s i tes
was measured by means of an Evapori meter ( Servo Med , Stockho lm , Va l l i ng
by , Sweden ) . The pri nc i p l e of th i s i nstrument is based on the cal cul at ion
of the vapour pressure gradi ent adj acent to the s k i n surface . I n the
steady state , the vapour pressure grad i ent i s proporti on a l to the amount
of water evaporated per uni t t ime and s k i n s u rface wi t h i n a boundary
l ayer surround i ng the s k i n . The actual gradi ent and thereby the evapora
t i on rate i s ca l cul ated from the s i gn a l s of two pa i rs each of a humi d i ty
transducer a nd a thermi stor l ocated at two d i fferent d i stances i n a
measuri ng probe . The d i ameter of the measured s k i n corresponds w ith that
of the exposed s k i n area ( 12 mm ) ( 12 ) .
94
Dur i ng the measurement , the room temperature was kept a l most constant at
20oc . Rel at i v e humi d i ty vari ed from 2 1-36% ( 28 . g � 5 . 2% ) .
The macroscop i ca l l y v i s i bl e changes i n the s k i n after the exposures were
b l i nd ly eval uated by an i ndependent i nvesti gator u s i ng the " v i su a l sco
r i ng sys tem" as descri bed by Frosch & Kl i gman ( 1 979 ) ( 4 ) :
Erythema : 1+ s l i g ht rednes s , spotty or d i ffuse
2+ moderate , un i form redness
3+ i ntense redness
4+ fi ery red wi th erythema
Scal i ng : 1+ f i ne
2+ moderate
3+ severe w ith l arge fl a kes
F i ssures : 1+ f i ne cracks
2+ s i ng l e or mul t i p l e broader f i s sures
3+ wide cra c ks wi th hemorrhage or exudat i on .
Stat i st i ca l methods
The d i fference i n s k i n wa ter vapour l oss between the exposed and the con
trol s i tes as wel l as the di fference in s k i n water vapour l os s after one
and after three exposures ( both i ndependent data ) was tested for s i g n i f i
cance us i ng a t- test for pai red observati ons ( 1 1 ) .
Resu l ts
The effects of the test substances on the s k i n are presented by graphs of
s k i n wa ter vapou r l os s and morpho l og i c changes i n the sk i n versus the
t ime course ( Fi g I a nd Fig I I ) . The overa l l mean s core of the test panel
duri ng 8 measurement sess i ons for the unexposed s k i n ( i ndi cated i n the
graphs ) was 2 . 8 g/m2h � 1 . 3 . For a l l the test substances , except for so
d i um l aurate , water vapour l os s cumu l at i ve ly i ncreased on repeated ex
posure ( s i g n i fi cance of the i ncrease in water vapour l os s after one and
three exposures , p < 0 . 01 ) .
95
For sod i um l aurate , thi s i ncrease was l ess pronounced ( p < 0 . 2 ) . After
the exposures repa i r of barr i er functi on for water was observed for the
s k i n exposed to the test subs ta nces ( s i gn i fi cance of the decrea se in wa
ter vapour l oss after the ex pos ures and the l as t measu rement ses s i on for
the d i fferent test substa nces , 0 . 07 < p < 0 . 001 ) . Thi s repa i r , however ,
was not compl ete at the l ast day of the i nvesti gation ( s i gn i fi cance of
the d i fference between the test substances and the control measu rement ,
0 . 02 < p < 0 . 001 ) .
The modest v i s i bl e a l terati ons after one exposure i ncreased after the
second and th i rd exposures , a l though the propri etary produc t , Neutrogena
and the surfactants , polysorbate-60 and sod i um l aurate el i c i ted hard l y
any v i s i b l e effects . Erythema , as caused by t h e tes t substances , de
creased i n the course of t ime . I n the cas e of the more severe a l tera
tions erythema was s ti l l present on the l ast day of the i nvesti gati on .
The s l ow decrease i n the v i s i b l e changes was partly due to the more pro
nounced chappi ng ( s l i ght fi ssuri ng ) and scal i ng i n some subj ects after a
few days after the l ast exposure . The general pattern of water barri er
functi on d i sturbances and the pattern of the macroscopi ca l l y v i s i b l e
changes i n the cou rse of t ime corres ponded .
D i scu s s i on
The data presented i n th i s communi cati on c l earl y s how that repeated ap
pl i ca t i on of l ow concentrati ons of surface active substances may l ead to
a marked impa i rment of the stratum corneum barri er ca paci ty for water
vapour l os s . The effects of the tox i c pri nci p l es appear to be cumu l a t i ve
wi th regard to water vapou r l oss . Genera l l y , th i s barr i er functi o n im
pai rment para l l el ed the deve l o pment of v i s i b l e impa i rment of the s k i n .
Cumu l at ive barri er funct ion impa i rment has been i ncrimi nated for i ts rol e
i n the devel opment of chroni c i rri tant contact dermat i ti s . The resu l ts of
th i s study su pport th i s v i ew , a l though the data must be i nterpreted with
some care . I t has been shown that conti nuous exposu re even to s trong i r
ri tant stimu l i wi l l as a ru l e l ead to epiderma l hyperp l a s i a and , a l though
an i ncreased permeation through th i s th i c kened s k i n has been demons trated
( 10 , 13 ) , an i ncrease of water l oss cou l d not be demons trated by us ( 17 ) .
96
Thu s , i t seems pl au s i b l e that the epi derm i s repeated l y exposed to i rr i
tant st imul i may adapt structura l l y a nd perhaps metabol i ca l l y ( 10 , 13 ) .
Externa l i nj u ri ous effects may impa i r the barr i er fu nction of the s tra
tum corneum a nd may i nterfere wi th norma l homeo s tas i s of the epi derm i s
a n d dermi s ( 9 , 1 3 , 16 , 18 ) . These effects are most ly revers i b l e and on ly
i n except i onal cases wi l l changes l ead to a d i m i n i shed repa i r ca pac i ty
wh i ch may u l timately l ead to a chron i ca l l y d i seased s k i n occur ( 9 , 16 ) .
S k i n barri er impa i rment by repeated exposures to i rri tant stimul i l i ke ,
e . g . , c l eans i ng mater i a l s { the da i l y wear and tear of the s k i n ) i s proba
bly an important factor i n the devel opmen t of chron i c i rr i tant contact
derma t i ti s . It seems j ust i f iab l e , however , to a ssume that other factors
may be i nvol ved i n the pathogenes i s { 13 ) .
Faul ty i nfl ammatory control mecha ni sms , d i s turbance of homeostas i s i n
the v i ab l e l ayers of the epi derm i s a nd derm i s and accumu l ati on of i rr i
tant subs tances o r ( endogeneou s ) ant i gens i n repeatedl y exposed s k i n
s i tes may a l so b e cons i dered as causa t i v e o r contri buti ve factors i n
the devel opment of i rrevers i b l e changes i n the s k i n u l t imatel y l eadi ng
to chron i c i rr i tant conta ct derma t i t i s ( 3 , 8 , 9 , 14 , 1 5 , 21 ) .
97
w
9
8
7
6
5 � � � 4
� � 3 0 � � > 2 c � � 1
Fi g . I A .
2 3 5 6 days
7 8 9 1 0 1 1
Mean water vapour l os s ( 20 subj ects ) of the sk i n after repeated
exposures to the propri etary products versus t ime ( g/m2h ) .
e--e Lactacyd soap 7 . 5 g/m2h ! 3 . gt
l--A Su l foderm soap 7 . 4 gjm2h ! 2 . 9
0--0 Neutrogena 4 . 0 g/m2h ! 2 . 1
&--� Zwi tsa l babysoap 7 . 0 g;m2h ! 3 . 9
* + Mean water vapour l oss - S . D . after three exposures
98
10
9
8
7
6
5 "' "' 0 I, .... � 3 0 c.. "' > c 2 :;;: "'
F i g . I B .
..--:----
2 3 I, 5 6 days
7 8 9 10 11
Mean water vapour l os s ( 20 subj ects ) of the s k i n after repeated
s k i n exposures to the s k i n su rface active su bstances versus t ime
{ g/m2h ) .
.___. pol ysorbate-50 2 3 . 3 g/m h ± 1 . 3* !-! sod i um l au rate 4. 6 g/m2h ± 1 . 7
()--{) sodi um l aury l su l fate 8 . 9 g/m2h ± 4 . 3 6--6. cocobetai ne 7 . 4 g/m2h + 2 . 5
* Mean water vapour l os s ± S . D . after three exposures
99
"' Cll 0'1
2.5
2,0
� 1 ,5 .r;; u
u
·g. 1 .0 0 .r;; 0.
� 0.5
Fi g . I I A .
d a y s
Mean scores of morph o l og i c changes ( 20 subj ects ) in the s k i n
after repeated exposures t o the propri etary products .
.-e Lactacyd
!-! Sul foderm
o--o Neutrogena
�--� Zwi tsal babysoap
100
"' CIJ Ol
2 .5
2 .0
:;; 1 .5 .r. u
u
� 1 .0 0
.r. a. ..
� 0.5
F i g . l i B .
2 3 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 days
Mean scores of morphol og i c changes ( 20 subj ects ) i n the s k i n
after reneated exposures t o surface acti ve substances versus
t i me .
e--e polysorbate-60
!--! sod i um l aurate
o--o sod i um l auryl su l fate
�� cocobeta i ne
101
References
1 ) Bett l ey , F . R . Some effects of soap on the s ki n . B r . Med . J . 1 :
35-41 ( 1 960 ) .
2 ) Bettl ey , F . R . The i rri tant effects of detergents . Trans . St . J ohn ' s
Hos pi ta l Oermatol . Soc . 58 : 65-74 ( 1 972 ) .
3 ) Bonta , I . L . Endogeneous modul ators of the i nfl amma tory response .
I n : I nfl amma t i on , pp 523-567 ( 1 978 ) Edi tors : Vane & Ferre i ra .
Spri nger-Verl ag , Berl i n .
4 ) Fro sch , P . J . , Kl i gman , A . M . The soap chamber tes t . J . Am . Acad .
Oermatol . 1 : 35-41 ( 1979 ) .
5 ) Frosch , P . J . I rri tancy of soaps a nd detergent bars . I n : Pri nc i p l es
of cosmetics for the dermato l og i s t , pp 5 - 1 2 ( 1982 ) Edi tors : Frosch
& Horwi tz . Mosby , St. Loui s .
6 ) Hass i ng , J . H . , Nater , J . P . , B l eumi n k , E . The i rri tancy of l ow con
centrati ons of soap and synthet ic detergents as measured by s k i n
wa ter l oss . Oermato l og i ca 1 6 4 : 314-321 ( 1 982 ) .
7 ) Von Ki s s , G . ( 1 981 ) Prufung von durch Waschmi ttel bed i ngten Haut
schad i gunge n . Derm . Beruf Umwel t 29: 1 5 - 1 8 ( 198 1 ) .
8 ) Ma l k i n son , F . O . , Fergu5o n , E . H . Percutaneous absorpti on of hyd ro
corti sone-4-c 14 i n two human subjects . J . I nves t . Derm . 2 5 : 281-
283 ( 1 955 ) .
9 ) Mal ten , K . E . Thoughts on i rri tant contact dermati ti s . Contact Derma
ti t i s 7 : 238-247 ( 1981 ) .
10 ) McOs ker , D . E . , Beck , L . W . Characteri sti cs of accomoda ted ( hardened }
s k i n . J . I nves t . Dermato l . 48 : 372-383 ( 1967 ) .
1 1 ) N i e , N . H . , Had l a i Hul l , C . , Jenk i ns , J . G . , Stei nbrenner , K . , Bent ,
D . H . Stati sti ca l Package of the Soci a l Sci ences , pp 249-275 ( 1981 )
McGraw- Hi l l Book Company , New York .
1 2 } N i l sson , G . E . Measu rements of water exchange through s k i n . Med . &
B i o l . Eng . & Comput . 1 5 : 209-2 15 ( 1 977 ) .
1 3 ) Prottey , C . The mol ec u l a r bas i s of sk i n i rri tat i o n . I n : Cosmeti c
Sci ence , Vol 1 , pp 2 75- 349 ( 1978) Ed i to r : Breuer . Academi c Press ,
London .
1 4 ) Schaefer , H . , Zesch , A . , Stuttgen , G . Sk i n permeab1 l i ty : Keservo 1 r
102
function of the horny l ayer . I n : Handbuch der Haut- und Geschl echts
krankhe i ten . Norma l e und Patho l og i sche Phys i o l ogy der Haut , pp
601-604 ( 1981 ) Ed i tor : Jadassohn . Spri nger-Verl ag , Berl i n .
1 5 ) Turk , J . L . , Wi l l oughby , D . A . Immuno l ogi ca l and para immunol ogi cal
as pects of i nfl ammati on . I n : I nfl amma t i on , pp 523- 567 ( 1978 ) Ed i
tors : Vane & Ferrei ra . Spri nger-Ver l ag , Berl i n .
1 6 ) Ummenhofe r , B . Hornsch i chtphys i o l og i sche Gru nd l agen der Pravention
und Rehabi l i ta t i on von Berufsekzemen . Derm . Beruf Umwel t 29 : 102-
106 ( 1981 ) .
1 7 ) Unpub l i shed data .
1 8 ) Van der Val k , P . G . M . , Kru i s -de Vri es , M . H . , Nater , J . P . , B l eumi nk ,
E . , de Jong , M . C . J . M . Eczematous ( i rri tant a nd a l l ergi c ) reacti ons
of the s k i n and barri er functi on a s determi ned by water vapour l os s .
Accepted for publ i cat ion : C l i n . & Exp . Derm .
1 9 ) Van der Val k , P . G . M . , C r i jns , M . C . , Nate r , J . P . , Bl eumi nk , E .
Sk i n i rr i tancy of commerc i a l l y avai l ab l e soap a nd detergent bars as
measured by water vapour l os s . Derm . Beruf Umwel t 3 : 87-90 ( 1984 ) .
20 ) Van der Va l k , P . G . M . , Nater , J . P . , B l eumi nk , E . S k i n i rri tancy of
surfactants as as sessed by water vapour l oss measurements . J . I nvest .
Dermato l . 82 : 291-293 ( 1984 ) .
2 1 ) V i ckers , C . F . H . Exi s tence of reservo i r i n the s tratum corneum . Arch .
Dermato l . 88 : 20-23 ( 1963 ) .
103
CHAPTER 5
ECZEMATOUS ( I RRITANT AND ALLERG I C ) REACT IONS OF THE SKIN AND
BARR I ER FUNCT ION AS DETERMI NED BY WATER VAPOUR LOSS
Accepted for publ i cati on i n
Authors :
P . G . M . van der Va l k
M . H . Kru i s-de Vri es
J . P . Nater
E . B l eum i n k
M . C . J . M . de Jong
C l i n i ca l and Experimental Dermatol ogy
1 04
Summary .
The a im o f th i s study was t o compare t h e i nfl uence of i rri tant a n d a l l er
g i c react i ons on the barr i er fu nction of the s k i n and to correlate d i s
turbances o f barr i er funct i on wi th macroscop i ca l l y v i s i bl e changes .
For th i s purpose , the s k i n of the vol ar s i de of the forearm was exposed
to n i ckel su l fate {5% ) , sod i um l aury l s u l fate ( 5% ) , d i methyl su l fox i de
{50• ) and phenol su l fate (5% ) duri ng a peri od of 48 hours . D i s ti l l ed
water served as contro l .
The exposures were made i n a test panel of 23 fema l e subj ects cons i st i ng
of a grou p of 14 pati ents w i th pos i ti v e s k i n react i ons to n i ckel su l fate
and 9 contro l s i n whom no ev idence of s k i n d i sease was found .
Both s k i n water vapour l oss measu rements and a '' v i sua l scori ng system"
{ based on erythema , f i s su r i ng and scal i ng ) were used to assess the effects
of the substances on the s k i n . The test s i tes ex posed to n i c kel s u l fate
were a l s o read for a l l erg i c react i ons .
Al l test substances caused an i ncrease i n s k i n water vapour l os s i n com
pari son with d i s ti l l ed water i n both groups . The i ncrease was found to be
stat i sti ca l l y s i g n i f i cant for n i c kel s u l fate , sod i um l auryl su l fate and
d imethyl s u l fox i de {a = 0 . 05 ) . Erythema was cons i stent l y el i c i ted by the test substances , parti cu l arly
by sod i um l auryl su l fate . In add i t i on , d i methyl su l fox i de reg u l ar ly
caused f i ne cracks ( chappi ng ) .
The corre l at i on between erythema and the i ncrease i n water vapour l os s
after exposure o f the s k i n t o an i rri tant var i ed cons i derably from sub
stance to substance and was poor for n i ckel su l fate {5% ) and phenol ( 5% ) and negati v e for d i methyl s u l fox i de (50% ) . A s i g n i fi cant correl at ion was
found for sodi um l auryl s u l fate ( 5% ) . Th i s impl i es that a l i near re
l at ions h i p between barrier funct ion d i sturbance and damage to the v i ab l e
cel l s o f deeper l ayers o f the s k i n may not b e as sumed beforehand .
Water vapour l os s measurements i n s k i n exposed to n i c ke l s u l fate revea l ed
that severe a l l erg i c s k i n reacti ons ( 3+ and 4+ reacti ons ) may l ead to an
i ncrease i n water v apour l os s i n compari son wi th d i sti l l ed water .
Al l erg i c s k i n react i on may a l so i nf l uence adj acent i rri tant react i on s :
The i rr i tant effect of sod i um l auryl su l fate was i nf l uenced by a pos i t i ve
105
patch test reacti on to n i ckel s u l fate .
I ntroduc t i on .
Substances wh i ch are desti ned to contact the s k i n must be eva l uated for
unwanted effect s . Var i ou s methods have been devel oped for th i s safety
eva l uat i on . Mos t of these ut i l i ze parameters for asses s i ng i nfl ammatory
react i ons ei ther quanti tat i ve ly by measu ri ng , for examp l e , s k i n fo l d
t h i ckness ( oedema ) ( Wah l berg , 1983 ) and cutaneous bl ood f l ow ( Laser
Doppl er fl owmetry ) ( N i l sson , Otto & Wah l berg , 1982 ) or sem i quant i tat i ve
ly by , for examp l e , " v i su a l scor i ng " of erythema , scal i ng and f i ssuri ng
( B ettl ey , 1964 ; Kl i gman & Wood i ng , 1967 ; Frosch & Kl i gman , 1979a ; Da h l &
Tranci k , 1977 ) .
Most m i l d i rri tants encountered i n da i l y l i fe do not provoke v i s i b l e
changes i n the s k i n (Ma l ten , 1981 ) . These i rr i tants , however , may have
a subcl i n i ca l effect wh i ch may be cumu l at i v e and wh i ch may in the l ong
run l ead to the devel opment of chron i c i rr i tant contact dermat i t i s .
Because of th i s , methods for assess i ng subc l i n i ca l effects of i rr i tants
have been devel oped ( Smeen k , 1968 ; Bj ornberg , 1968; Mal ten & den Arend ,
1978 ; von Ki s s , 1979 ; He i s e , von Mattheus & Brust , 1983 ) .
Among such techn i ques , s k i n water vapour l oss measu rements proved to be
usefu l in assess i ng the i nfl uence of substa nces on the barr i er funct i on
i ntegri ty (Mal ten & T h i e l e , 1973a , 1973b ) . These measurements are based
on the assumpt i on that the i ncrease i n water vapour l os s para l l e l s the
extent of barri er funct i on d i sturbances (de Jongh , 1981 ) .
The a im of the study reported here was to assess the i nfl uence of i rr i
tant and a l l erg i c react i ons o n t h e barri er funct i on to a macroscop i ca l l y
v i s i b l e chang e .
T h e i nvest i g at i on was performed o n a test panel cons i st i ng o f a group of
14 fema l es wi t h pos i t i v e patch test reacti ons to n i ckel s u l fate and a
grou p of 9 fema l e subj ects without a ny known a l l ergy .
106
Mater i a l s and method s .
Unaffected s k i n of the vol ar s i d e o f t h e forearm was exposed to the
fol l owi ng su bstances :
1 ) n i ckel su l fate-7H20 5 g/v% i n d i s t i l 1 ed water , pH 5 . 4 .
2 ) sod i um l auryl s u l fate , 5 g/v% in d i s t i 1 1 ed water , pH 7 . 3 .
3 ) d imethyl su l fox i de 50 g/v% i n d i st i l l ed water , pH 7 . 1 .
4 ) phenol 5 g/v% i n d i st i l l ed water , pH 6 . 2
5 ) d i s t i l l ed water pH 6 . 5 .
The test substances were appl i ed to the sk i n for a peri od of 48 hours .
One- hundred mi crol i ters of the tes t substances were pi petted ( Capi
l etto r , C l i n i con AB , Stockho lm , Sweden ) i nto an a l um i n i um chamber of
12 mm d i ameter ( Large F i nn chamber , Epi test Ltd . Oy , Hel s i nki , F i n l a nd )
wh i ch conta i ned f i ve pi eces of a bsorb i ng paper ( Whatma n ) . The chambers
were sea l ed to the s k i n by means of adhes i v e tape ( Scanpor tape , Norges
p l aster A/ S , Os l o , Norway ; F i xomu l l stretch , Bei ersdorf AG , Hamburg ,
Germany ) . After the 48 hours exposure , the morphol og i ca l changes of the
test s i tes were graded a s fol l ows ( Frosch & Kl i gman , 1 97 9b ) :
erythema :
sca l i ng :
f i s sur i ng :
1+ s l i ght rednes s , s potty or d i ffu s e .
2 + moderate rednes s .
3+ i ntense red ness .
4+ fi ery red wi th oedema .
1+ f i n e .
2 + moderate .
3+ severe wi th l arge fl a kes .
1+ f i ne cracks .
2+ s i ng l e or mu l t i p l e broader f i s �ures .
3+ wi de cracks wi th hemorrhage or exudat ion .
The test s i tes on the arm were a l so read for a l l erg i c react i ons accord i ng
to standards devel oped for patch tes t i ng a nd graded a s fol l ows ( Nater ,
197 4 ) :
107
0 no reacti on .
1+ erythema wi thout i nf i l trat ion .
2+ erythema wi th papu l es / i nfi l trat i on .
3+ erythema wi th ves i c l es .
4+ conf l uent ves i c l es .
Ski n water vapour l os s measurements on the tes ted s k i n s i tes were per
formed after a wa i t i ng peri od of 15 mi nutes . The measurements were done
u nder neutra l envi ronmental c i rcumsta nces ( room temperature , 2 1 . 1 °C
± 1 . 1 ; re l at i ve humi d i ty , 38 . 1 k ± 9 . 0 ) .
The mea surements were made by means of an Evaporimeter ( Servo Med , Stock
hol m , Va l l i ng by , Sweden ) accord i ng to methods descri bed i n deta i l earl i er
( N i l sson , 1977 ; van der Va l k , Na ter & Bl eum i nk, 1984 ) . The opera t i ng
pri nc i pl e of th i s i nstrument i s based on ca l cu l ati on of a water vapour
pres sure grad i ent perpend i cu l ar to the sk i n .
The exposures and measurements were performed i n two groups :
1 ) a grou p of 14 femal e pati ents (mean age , 27 . 9 � 1 0 . 2 ; range , 19-52 y . )
w ith a h i story of derma t i t i s ; a l l were i n a qu i et phase of the derma
t i t i s . These pati ents were sel ected on the ba s i s of pri or pos i t i v e
patch t e s t resu l ts t o n i c kel su l fate and thei r react i on to n i c ke l
su l fate as appl i ed duri ng the i nvest igat i o n ;
2 ) a grou p o f 9 fema l e control s (mean age , 10 . 3 ; range , 19-52 y . ) wi thout
any known s k i n d i sease or a l l ergy .
Stat i st i ca l methods :
The d i fferences between the test chem i ca l s as regards the i r effects on
the barri er funct i on of the s k i n (mean s k i n vapour l oss scores ) were
tested for s i g n i f i cance as compared wi th d i st i l l ed water u s i ng a t -test
for pai red data . To study the associ at1 on between the morphol og i ca l
changes o f the s k i n and the s k i n water vapour l os s va l ues , rank order
corre l at i on coeffi c i ents were cal cu l ated ( Kenda l l ' s tau ) . Th i s stat i s t i
c a l method was sel ected because o f the l arge number o f t i ed ranks i n
the " v i sua l scor i ng " vari abl es ( N i e et a l . , 1981 ) .
108
Res u l ts .
The mean val ues for the s k i n water vapour l oss from the expos ed s k i n
s i tes are presented i n Tabl e I . Marked ly i ncreased va l ues were observed
for a l l test substances as compared wi th d i st i l l ed water . The di ffe
rences were found to be stat i st i ca l ly s i g n i fi cant ( t-test for pai red
data ) for n i c kel su l fate ( 5% ) , sod i um l aury l s u l fate ( 5% ) and d i methyl
su l fox i de ( 50% ) {Tab l e I I ) . The observed d i fferences in reacti on between
the a l l erg i c i nd i v idua l s and control s were found to be s i gn i f i cant for
sod i um l auryl s u l fate.
The ari thmet i c means of the scores for erythema , f i s suri ng and scal i ng as
graded accord i ng to the " v i su a l scori ng system" are l i sted i n Tabl e I I I .
Erythema , espec i a l l y after exposure to sod i um l au ry l s u l fate , was con
s i stently obs erved . D imethyl su l fox i de regu l ar l y el i c i ted fi ne cracks
( chappi ng ) . The assoc i at i on between erythema a nd water vapour l os s from
exposed s k i n was determi ned ( Kendal l ' s tau correl at i on coeffi c i ent ) .
A s i gn if i cant correl ati on was found for sod i um l au ryl s u l fate ( 5% ) .
Corre l a t i on was poor for n i ckel s u l fate ( 5% ) and phenol ( 5% ) and nega
t i ve for di methyl s u l fox i de ( 50% ) . Sca l i ng and f i ssuri ng were too un
common to just i fy ca l cu l at i on of correl at i on coeffi c i ents w ith s k i n
vapour l os s {Tabl e I I I and I V ) .
Grou ps w ith the same grade of a l l erg i c or nona l l erg i c reacti on to n i c kel
s u l fate were formed and the mean water vapour l os s of these groups was
cal cu l ated i n order to assess the i nfl uence of an a l l erg i c reacti on on
the barr ier funct i on of the s k i n . The res u l ts are presented i n Tabl e V
( see a l so F i g . 1A ) .
To eva l uate the i nfl uence of a n a l l erg i c reacti o n to n i ckel s u l fate on
the i rr i tancy of the other substances , the assoc i at i on between the a l l er
g i c reacti ons to n i c kel s u l fate and the grades of eryth ema of the test
s i tes exposed to the d i fferent test substances was i nvestigated ( Tab l e
V I ) .
The i rr i tancy of sod i um l a uryl su l fate was i nf l uenced by a pos i t i ve patch
test reacti on to n i ckel s u l fate ( Kenda l l ' s tau correl ati on coeffi c i ent ,
0 . 42 ; p < 0 . 01 ) .
109
Di scuss i on .
Assoc i at i on between the erythematous effect of the test substances and
s k i n water vapour l os s .
I n t h i s study , sod i um l auryl su l fate was the on ly test substance for
wh i ch pos i t i ve s i gn i f i cant corre l ation between the degree of erythema
and the i ncrease of s k i n water vapour l os s was found (Tabl e I I ) . The
5 g/v% so lut ion of th i s potent i rr i tant ( Bj ornberg , 1 96B ) a s u sed i n
th i s study cau sed v i s i b l e ( i nfl ammatory ) react i ons i n most subj ects .
Sod i um l auryl su l fate l i ke other an ion ic surfactants a l so has a pro
nounced effect on the barr i er fu ncti on of the s tra tum corneum ( van der
Val k et a l . , 1 984 ; Scheu p l e i n & Ros s , 1970 ) . The h i g h correl ati on
between erythema and water va pour l oss suggests that the extent of
cytotox i c damage to the v i ab l e cel l s of the epi dermi s and derm i s
paral l el s barr i er fu nct i on impa i rment for water . For phenol ( 5% ) and
d imethyl su l fox i de ( 50% ) , no pos i t i ve corre l at i on between the l os s of
water vapour and erythema was observed .
Dimethyl s u l fox i de i nfl uences the barr i er funct i on wi thout much structu
ral damage ( Sweeney , Downes & Matol tsy , 1966 ) . It causes only extract i on
of some l i p ids , wh i ch may prevent compl ete restorat i on of barri er func
t i on ( Scheup l e i n & Ros s , 1970 ) . ( Chappi ng was regu l ar ly obs erved i n
t h i s study after s k i n exposu re to d imethyl s u l fox i de ( 50% ) ) . The l ow
nons i gn i f i cant i ncrease i n water vapour l os s after exposure of the
s k i n to phenol ( 5% ) may be i nfl uenced by the effect of phenol on the
sweat g l and pores ( Dobson & Lobi tz , 1 957 ; Mal ten et a l . , 196B ) . Both
substances a l so have a cytotox i c effect on the v i ab l e cel l s of the epi
dermi s (Mal ten et a l . , 1 968; Baker & Kl i gman , 1967 ) .
I n th i s study , no pos i t i ve ( s i gn i f i cant ) correl at i on between water va pou r
l os s and v i s i b l e ( i nf l ammatory ) react i ons was observed for the s k i n ex
posed to phenol ( 5% ) and d imethyl s u l fox i d e ( 50% ) , suggesti ng that for
these substances an i ncrease of water vapou r l os s does not para l l el the
extent of cytotox i c damage to the v i abl e cel l s of the epi derm i s and der
mi s .
Th i s impl i es that a l i near rel at i on between barr i er functi on i mpai rment
and damage to the v i abl e cel l s of deeper l ayers of the s k i n may not be
110
TABLE I . Mean s k i n water vapour l os s from the s k i n exposed to the test substances
and d i st i l l ed water .
Persons with a l l erg i c Control grou p
react i ons to n i ckel s u l fate
n = 14 n = 9
mean (g/m2h )±so mean ( g/m2h ) ±so
S . V . L . 3 ) after n i c kel su l fate 6 . 8 ± 4 . 4 5 . 6 ± 3 . 6
S . V . L . after sod i um l aury1 su l fate 33 . 9 ± 2 1 . 7 1 3 . 7 ± 9 . 2
S . V . L . after d i methyl su l fox i de 8 . 9 ± 3 . 2 9 . 9 ± 3 . 6
s . v . L . after phenol 7 . 1 ± 7 . 3 4 . 1 ± 2 . 5
s . v . L . after d i s ti l l ed water 4 . 0 ± 1 . 3 3 . 6 ± 1 . 5
S i g n . 1 )
n . s . 2 )
p < 0 . 01
n . s .
n . s .
n . s .
1 ) S i g n i f i cance o f the d i fference between the group o f persons wi th a l l erg i c reacti ons t o n i c kel su l fate
and the control group ( a = 0 . 01 ) .
2 ) n . s . = not s i g n i f i cant .
3 ) S . V . L . = Sk in ( Water ) Vapour Loss .
....... ...... .--<
TABLE I I . S i gn i fi cance of the d i fferences between the mean i ncrease
in S . V . L . after exposure of the s k i n to the test substances as
compared with d i st i l l ed water ( control ) ( pa i red t-tests , t > 2 . 07 ;
p < 5% ) .
1 . ni ckel s u l fate
2 . sod i um l auryl su l fate
3 . d imethyl su l fox i de
4 . phenol
+) not s i g n i f i cant .
t-va l ue
2 . 95
5 . 29
8 . 62
1 . 60
s i g n i f i cance
p < 0 . 05
p < 0 . 05
p < 0 . 05
+ n . s .
TABLE I I I . Morphol ogi cal changes i n the s k i n (mean scores of
23 subj ects ) after a 48- hour exposure to the test substances .
erythema scal i ng fi ssuri ng
n i c kel su l fate 0 . 9 0 . 0 0 . 0
sodi um l auryl su l fate 1 . 8 0 . 1 0 . 2
d imethyl su l fox ide 0 . 7 0 . 0 0 . 4
phenol 0 . 2 0 . 0 0 . 0
d i s t i 1 1 ed water 0 . 0 0 . 0 0 . 0
1 1 2
TABLE IV . Assoc i a t ion between S . V . L . and erythema ( a s graded
accord i ng to a v i sual scor i ng system ) i n s k i n exposed to the
test substances .
Corre l a t i on Coeff i c i ent1 ) S i g n . 2 )
n i ckel s u l fate
sod i um l auryl s u l fate
d imethyl s u l fox i de
phenol
0 . 1 0
0 . 65
-0 . 36
0 . 23
1 ) Kenda l l ' s tau correl at i on coeff i c i ent .
2 ) Level of s i gn i f i cance a = 0 . 01 .
n . s .
p < 0 . 01
n . s .
n . s .
TABLE V . Mean water vapour l os s from the s k i n after a 48-hour exposure
to n i ckel s u l fate for the group wi thout an a l l erg i c reaction and those
wi th d i fferent grades of react i o n .
mean ( g/m2h ) ± SD
negat ive ( 9 subjects ) 5 . 6 ± 3 . 6
1+ react i on ( 2 subj ects ) 5 . 2 + 0 . 8
2+ react i on ( 5 subj ects ) 4 . 7 ± 1 . 2
3+ react i on ( 3 subj ects ) 7 . 6 ± 4 . 4
4+ react i on ( 4 subj ects ) 9 . 6 + 7 . 1 -
1 1 3
TABLE V I . Assoc i at ion between the grades of erythema of
adj acent s k i n exposed to a test su bstance and the grades
of a l l erg i c react i on to n i ckel su l fate .
n i c kel su l fate
sod i um l auryl s u l fate
d imethyl s u l fox i de
phenol
Correl ation coeff i c i ent 1 )
0 . 78
0 . 42
0 . 26
0 . 3 2
S i g n . 2 )
p < 0 . 01
p < 0 . 01
n . s .
n . s .
1 ) Kenda l l ' s tau correl ati on coeff i c i ent between erythema and
the a l l erg i c reacti ons to n i ckel su l fate .
2 ) Level of s i gn i f i cance a = 0 . 01 .
1 1 4
assumed beforehand and i s probabl y doubtfu l for many s ubstances .
Assoc i at i on between a l l ergi c patch test resu l ts for n i ckel su l fate and
s k i n water vapour l os s .
S k i n water vapour l oss was sometimes cons i derabl y i ncreased after expo
sure to ni cke l su l fate , espec i a l ly if strong a l l erg i c reacti ons were
present ( Tabl e V ) .
However , not a l l a l l erg i c reacti ons l ead to d i sturbances of the horny
l ayer barr i er for water . Apparently , the horny l ayer was not (yet )
affect ed by the eczematous process or the funct i onal nature was reta i ned
or restored by adaptat ion or regenerati on , e . g . , by an i ncreased m i toti c
rate.
The i nfl uence of " s p i l l -over" react i ons and s k i n water vapou r l oss .
The erythematou s react ion of the s k i n to sod i um l auryl su l fate was
stronger i f pos i t i ve patch test react i ons to n i c ke l su l fate were
present on an adj acent area , i nd i cati ng a " sp i l l -over phenomenon" , i . e . ,
enhancement of an i rri tant react ion by an adj acent a l l erg i c reaction
( Bruynzeel et a l . , 1983 ) . { I t shou l d be noted that theoret i cal l y the
stat i sti ca l assoc i a t i on can a l so be expl a i ned by enhancement of a l l erg i c
react i ons by an adj acent i rri tant react i on ) .
T h i s i nd i cates that adj acent a l l erg i c react i on may i nf l uence the i rr i tant
response , wh i ch may secondari l y l ead to i ncreased s k i n water vapour l os s .
I t may b e concl uded that :
a ) A substance ( and i ts veh i cl e ) may have a primary { d i rect ) effect on
the horny l ayer by i nteract i on w ith horny l ayer components , resu l t i ng
i n i ncreased s k i n water vapour l os s .
b ) After permeation , a substance may el i c i t secondary ( a l l erg i c and
i rr i tant ) i nf l ammatory react i ons , wh i ch may a l so have del ayed effects
on the barri er functi on of water .
c ) D i rect damage to the horny l ayer may correspond w ith the extent of
the macroscop i ca l i nfl ammatory reacti ons of the s k i n , but th i s i s
not necessar i l y the case .
T h e s k i n water vapour l os s measu rements and t h e v i s i b l e changes i n the
1 1 5
s k i n are probab ly only partl y i nterdepend ent . The assoc i at i on between
the two parameters var i es from substance to substance . The concentrat ion
of the test substances wi l l probab ly a l so i nfl uence the assoc i at i o n . A
l ow concentrat ion of a su bstance may have an effect on the barr i er
funct i on for water wi thout el i c i t i ng v i s i b l e changes , whereas a h i gher
concentrat i on wi l l a l so cause macroscopi ca l changes in the s k i n .
I n the f i rst s i tuati o n , no s i g n i f i cant correl at i on wi l l be fou nd , i n
contrast w ith the second . The t ime of eva l uat ion wi l l a l so b e of impor
tance , subs i d i ng of the erythema and restorat i on of the barr i er funct i on
hav i ng the i r own courses i n t ime .
I t may b e neces sary therefore t o assess the i rr i tancy o f a substance by
eva l uat i on of the s k i n barr i er funct ion as wel l as of the v i s i b l e i n
fl ammatory response of the exposed s k i n . The eva l uati on shou l d be done
not on ly once , but by repeated measu rements ( time ser i es ) .
1 1 6
13
12
1 1
10
9
8
7
6
s � UJ (/) I. +I
_, 3 > (/) c 2 til Cll E
F i g . A .
f ±
0 1 +
I
2+ 3+ f. + patch test react ions
Mean s k i n vapour l os s (t S . E . M . } of the d i fferent patch test
reactions ( d i fferent grades o f a l l erg i c reacti ons ) to
n i ckel s u l fate .
1 1 7
References :
1 . Ba ker , H . & Kl i gman , A . M . ( 1 967 ) Measurement of transepi derma l
water l oss by el ectr i ca l hygrometry . Archi ves of Dermatol ogy , 96 ,
441 -452 .
2 . Bett l ey , F . R . ( 1 964 ) Non spec i f i c i rri tant reacti on i n eczematous
subj ects . Bri t i s h Journal of Dermato l ogy , 76 , 1 1 6 - 12 1 .
3 . Bett l ey , F . R . ( 1 97 2 ) The i rr i tant effects of detergents . Trans
acti ons of the St. John ' s Hos p ita l Dermatol og i ca l Soc i ety , 58 , 65-74 .
4 . Bj Hrnberg , A . ( 1 968 ) Sk in reacti ons to pri mary i rri tants in pat i ents
with handeczema . Thes i s Oscar I sacsons Tryc ker i A . B . , GHtenborg .
5 . Bruynzeel , D . P . , N i eboer , C . , Boersma , D . M . , Scheper , P . J . & van Ke
tel , W . G . ( 1 983 ) Al l erg i c react i ons , " s pi l l over " react i ons and T
cel l subsets . Arch i ves of Dermatol og i c a l Research , 27 5 , 80- 85 .
6 . Da h l , M . V . & Tranci k , R . J . ( 1 977 ) Sod i um l auryl sul fate i rri tant patch
tests . Degree of i nf l ammat i on at vari ous t i mes . Contact Dermat i t i s ,
3 ' 263-266.
7 . Dobson , R . L . & Lobi tz , W . C . ( 1 957 ) Some h i stochem i ca l observati ons on
the human eccr i ne swea t g l ands . Archi ves of Dermatol ogy , 7 5 , 653-666 .
8 . Fros ch , P . J . & Kl i gman , A . M . ( 1 97 9a ) The Du hri ng Chamber . An i m
proved techni que for epi cutaneous tes t i ng of i rri tant and a l l erg i c
react i ons . Contact Dermat i ti s , 5 , 73-81 .
9 . Frosch , P . J . & Kl i gman , A . M . ( 1 979b ) The soap chamber tes t . A new
method for asses s i ng the i rr itancy of soaps . Journa l of the Ameri can
Academy of Dermatol ogy , 1 , 35-41 .
1 0 . Hei s e , H . , Von Mattheu s , A . & Bru s t , B . ( 1 983 ) Irri tati onsprUfungen
in der Dermato l og i e , i hre Bedeutungen u nd Au ssage . Dermatol og i sche
Monatsschri ft , 169 , 63 1-637 .
1 1 . De Jong h , G . J . ( 1981 ) Poros i ty of human s k i n i n v i vo assessed i n
water l os s , carbon d i ox i de and el ectr i ca l impedance for heal thy
vol unteers , atop i c and psor i a t i c pat i ents . I n : Current Probl ems i n
Dermatol ogy : some fundamental approaches i n s k i n research ( Ed . by
J . W . H . Ma l i ) , Vol . 9 , 83- 10 1 . S . Karger , Basel .
1 2 . Von K i s s , G . ( 1 97 9 ) Mes sung der el ektri schen Impedanz zur Best immung
von durch Laugen bed i ngten Hautschadi gungen . Dermatol og i sche Monats -
1 18
schri ft , 1 6 5 , 526- 530 .
1 3 . Kl i gman , A . M . & Wood i ng , W . M . ( 1 967 ) A method for the measurement and
eva l uat i on of i rr i tants on human s k i n . Journal of I nvest igat i ve
Dermatol ogy , 49 , 78-94 .
1 4 . Mal ten , K . E . , Spru i t , D . , Boemaars , H . G . M . & de Kei zer , M . J . M .
( 1 968 ) Horny l ayer i nj ury by sol vents . Berufsdermatosen , 1 6 , 135- 147 .
1 5 . Mal ten , K . E . & Thi e l e , F . A . J . { 1973a ) Eva l ua t i on of s k i n damage I I .
Water l os s and carbon d i ox i de l oss rel ease measurements rel ated to
s k i n res i stance measu rements . Bri t i sh Jou rna l of Dermatol ogy , 89 ,
565- 569 .
1 6 . Ma l ten , K . E . & T h i e l e , F . A . J . { 1973 b ) Some measuri ng method s for the
eva l uat i on of orthoerg i c contactdermati t i s . Archi ves Bel ges de Derma
tol og i e et de Syph i l i graph i e , 28 , 23-46 .
17 . Mal ten , K . E . & den Arend , J . ( 19 78 ) Top i ca l tox i c i ty of vari ou s con
centrati ons of DMSO recorded w ith impedance measurements and water
vapour l oss measurements . Contact Derma t i t i s , 4 , 80- 92 .
1 8 . Ma l ten , K . E . ( 1981 ) Thoughts on i rr i tant contact dermat i ti s . Contact
Dermati t i s , 7 , 238-247 .
1 9 . Nater , J . P . { 1974 ) Techn i ek en moei l ij kheden van de l apj esproef .
I n : Contacteczeem , 23-27 . Stafl eu , Lei den .
20 . N i e , N . H . , Had l a i Hu l l , C . , Jenki ns , J . G . , S chei nbrenner , K . & Bent ,
D . H . { 1981 ) Stat i sti ca l package for the soc i a l s c i ences , 289- 290 .
McGraw-H i l l Book Company , New Yor k .
2 1 . N i l sson , G . E . ( 1 97 7 ) Measu rements o f water exchange through s k i n .
Med i ca l and B i o l og i ca l Eng i neer i ng and Comput i ng , 1 5 , 209- 2 1 5 .
2 2 . N i l s son , G . E . , Otto , U . & Wahl berg , J . E . { 1982 ) Assessment o f s k i n
i rr i tancy i n man by Laser Doppl er F l owmetry . Contact Derma t i t i s , 8 ,
401 -406 .
23 . Scheu p l e i n , R . & Ros s , L . ( 1970 ) Effects of surfactants and sol vents
on the permeabi l i ty of epi derm i s . Journal of the Soci ety of Cosmet i c
Chem i sts , 2 1 , 853-87 3 .
24 . Smeen k , G . { 1 968 ) De i nv l oed van deterg ent i a op de hu i d . Thes i s J .
Noorduyn en Zoon N . V . , Gori chem .
2 5 . Sweeney , T . M . , Downes , A . M . & f-latol t sy , A . G . ( 1 966 ) The effect of
DMSO on the epiderma l water barr i er . Journal of I nvesti gat ive
1 19
Dermato l ogy , 46 , 300- 302 .
26 . Van der Val k , P . G . M . , Cri j ns , M . C . , Na ter , J . P . & B l eum i n k , E .
( 1 984 ) S k i n i rri tancy of commerc i a l ly ava i l abl e soaps and detergent
bars as measured by water vapour l oss . Dermatosen in Beruf und
Umwel t , 3 , 87-90 .
28 . Wah l berg , J . E . ( 1 983 ) Assessment of s k i n i rr i tancy : mea surement of
s k i n fol d thi cknes s . Contact Dermat i t i s , 9 , 2 1-26 .
120
CHAPTER 6
THE I NFLUENCE OF LOW CONCENTRAT IONS OF IRRITANTS ON SK IN BARR I ER
FUNCT I ON AS DETERMI NED BY WATER VAPOUR LOSS
Accepted for pu b l i cat i on i n
Dermatosen i n Beruf und Umwe l t
1 2 1
Au thors :
P . G . M . v an der Va l k
J . P . Nater
E. B l eum i nk
Summary .
The effect of some i rr i tants on the barr i er funct i on of the s k i n was
assessed by means of wa ter va pou r l oss measu rements .
One-hundred mi crol i ters of the test substa nce i n d i s ti l l ed water were
appl i ed to the s k i n for a peri od of 48 hours , u s i ng l arge Fi nn chambers .
The exposures were done i n a test panel of 42 subj ects .
Sod i um l auryl su l fate ( 2% ) , cocobeta i ne ( 2% ) , crotona l dehyde ( 0 . 7 5v ) wi th
sod i um l auryl su l fate ( 0 . 5% ) and d i methyl s u l fox i de ( 50� ) mar ked l y
i nfl uenced water va pou r l os s .
Sod i um hydroxi de ( 1 % ) had l es s effect o n water vapou r l oss , a l though
the i ncrease wa s s i gn i f i cant (p < 0 . 05 ) . Phenol ( 5% ) and benza l koni um
ch l or i de ( 0 . 2% } d i d not s i g n i f i cantly i nfl uence the l os s of water
through the s k i n .
It i s concl uded that subc l i n i ca l effects of chem i ca l s o n the barr i er
funct i on may be of i mportance i n the devel opment of i rr i tant contact
dermat i t i s , but that th i s capac i ty i s probab ly not the only factor wh i ch
determi nes the potent i a l of a substance to contri bute to the devel opment
of i rr i tant contact dermat i t i s . A chem i ca l wh i ch has l i tt l e or no effect
on the funct i on of the horny l ayer may have a tox i c effect on the v i abl e
cel l s of deeper l ayers of the sk i n .
Th i s tox i c effect may a l so be a n important subc l i n i ca l factor i n the de
vel opment of i rri tant contact dermat it i s .
I ntroducti on .
Whereas exposures o f the s k i n to strong i rr i tant factors l ead t o d i rect
and acute s k i n react i ons i n wh i ch a cause a nd effect rel at ionsh i p can be
establ i s hed w ith some certa i nty , thi s rel at i ons h i p i s as a ru l e l es s
evi dent i n chron i c i rr i tant derma ti t i s .
Preva i l i ng theory states that chron i c i rri tant contact dermati ti s may be
attr i butab l e to the cumu l at i ve effect of subc l i n i ca l doses of i rri tant
factors wh i ch i n themse l ves are not capab l e of produci ng c l i n i ca l effects
( 1 -3 ) .
I t i s hel d that barr i er funct i on impai rment of the stratum corneum p l ays
122
a rol e i n the devel opment of i rri tant s k i n reacti ons ( 3 , 4 ) .
The defi ci ent barri e r of the s k i n may l ead to i ncreased permeat ion of
chem ica l substances and th i s may faci l i tate tox i c effects upon the
v i ab l e cel l s of the epi derm i s and derm i s ( 4 , 5 ) .
I n strong i rri tant react i ons , the barr i er fu ncti on of the stratum cor
neum wi l l be i mpai red by either the d i rect effect of the chem i ca l upon
the horny l ayer or i nd i rect l y by a severe tox i c ( eczematou s ) reaction
of the skin ( 5 ) .
The a im of t h i s study was to as sess the d i rect effect of some chem i ca l s
upon barr i er funct ion o f the s k i n . An attempt was made to expose the
s k i n to a concentrat i on whi ch may el i c i t subc l i n i ca l effects upon the
horny l ayer w ithout cau s i ng a severe tox i c react ion .
The barri er funct i on of the s k i n was eva l uated by means of s k i n water
vapou r l os s measurements ( 5- 7 ) .
Mater i a l s and method s .
The exposures were done i n a test panel of 4 2 subj ects (mean age 3 9 ±
1 7 . 5 y ; rang e , 16-83 yea rs ) . The panel cons i sted of pati ents w ith
mi scel l aneou s s k i n d i seases ( l oca l i zed eczema , u l cu s cruri s , psori a s i s ,
etc . ) v i s i t i ng the outpati ent department for a l l erg i c patch tes t i ng . The
fol l owi ng test su bstances were appl i ed on c l i n i ca l l y unaffected s k i n
o f the vol ar s i de o f t h e forearm { g/v% i n d i st i l l ed water ) :
sod i um l auryl su l fate ( 2g/v%) pH 7 . 3
cocobetai ne ( 2 g/v% ) pH 5 . 2
croton a l dehyde ( 0 . 7 5 g/v% ) wi th sod i um l auryl pH 4 . 8
su l fate ( 0 . 5 g/v% )
d imethyl s u l foxi de ( 50 g/v% ) pH 7 . 1
phenol ( 5 g/v% ) pH 6 . 2
sod i um hydrox i de { 1 g/v% ) pH 1 2 . 7
benza l kon i um ch l or ide ( 0 . 2 g/v% ) pH 6 . 6
d i s ti l l ed water pH 6 . 5
The substances were tested (on the bas i s of a prel im i nary study ) i n these
concentrati ons in order to el i c i t s l i ght macroscopi cal l y v i s i b l e changes
123
i n the s k i n , i . e . , on ly s l i ght or moderate erythema , s l i ght scal i ng or
fi ssu r i ng ( 1+ or 2+ reacti ons as descri bed by Frosch & Kl i gman ( 1 97 9 ) )
( 8 ) .
I n these concentrati ons , subc l i n i cal effects on the barri er funct i on
can be expected . The exposures were done for a per i od of 48 hours by
means of a chamber method ( F i nn c hamber , Epi test Ltd . Oy , Hel s i nki ,
F i n l and ) . The a l um i n i um cups wi th a d i ameter of 12 mm , and fi tted wi th
5 pi eces of absorb ing pa per ( Whatma n ) were saturated wi th 1 00 � 1 of the
test substance .
At 24 hours after the exposu res , s k i n water vapour l oss was measured by
means of the Servo Med Evaporimeter ( Servo Med , Stockho l m , Val l i ng by ,
Sweden ) accord i ng to methods descri bed i n deta i l el sewhere ( 6 , 7 ) .
Th i s i ns trument i ncl udes a measuri ng probe wh i ch reg i sters vapour l os s
o f a s k i n area correspond i ng w ith t h e s i ze o f t h e exposed s k i n .
S k i n water vapour l oss was determi ned after a res t i ng per i od of at l east
1 5 mi nutes . The measurements were done under neutral envi ronmenta l c i r
cums tances ( 21 . 0°C . � 1 . 9 ; rel ati ve hum id i ty , 42 . 1� ! 9 . 6 ; s k i n tempe
rature , 3 1 . 5°C � 1 . 2 ) .
Stati st ica l method s .
S k i n water vapour l oss from the exposed s k i n was compared wi th that of
unexposed s k i n . The d i fferences were tes ted for s i g n i f i cance by u s i ng a
t-test for pai red observati ons ( 9 ) .
Res u l t s .
Water vapour l oss from the s k i n s i tes ex posed t o the test substances and
from unexposed s k i n i s g i ven i n Tab l e I . The surface act i ve agents
( sod i um l auryl su l fate ( 2% ) , cocobeta i ne ( 2% ) and sod i um l auryl su l fate
in combi nat ion wi th crotona l dehyde ( 0 . 7 5%) ) , except for benza l kon ium
ch l or ide ( 0 . 2% ) ( ta ke note of d i fferent concentrati on ) , cons i derab ly
i ncreased water vapour l oss i n compari son w ith unexposed s k i n . D imethyl
s u l foxi d e ( 50%} and sod i um hydrox i d e ( 1% } a l so i ncreased s k i n water
vapour l os s . Phenol ( 5% ) d i d not negat ive ly i nfl uence the barri er func-
124
t i on for water ( i n the appl i ed concentrati on ) . The d i fferences between
s k i n exposed to the test substances and unexposed s k i n were s i g n i f i cant ,
except for phenol ( 5% ) and benzal kon i um ch lor ide ( 0 . 2% ) ( a = 0 . 05 ) .
D i scuss i on .
I n th i s study , an attempt was made to expose the s k i n t o chem i ca l s i n a
concentration el i c i t i ng subcl i n i cal effects on the barr i er funct i on
wi thout the devel opment of man i fest tox i c react i ons , a l though i t shou l d
be noted that accurate assessment o f such a concentrati on i s d i ff i c u l t
becau se o f the occurrence o f l arge i ntra- and i nter i nd i v i dual d i fferen
ces i n reacti on to i rr i tants { 10 ) .
A pre l i m i nary study revea l ed that h i g her concentrati ons than those used
i n th i s study cause severe tox i c react i ons i n s ome i nd i v i dua l s . For
exampl e , benza l kon i um ch l or ide proved to have a greater i rr i tant poten
t i a l i n compari son w ith the other tested su rfactants and had to be
tested i n a l ower concentrati on .
The subcl i n i ca l effect on barri er funct i on a s d etermi ned by s k i n water
vapour l os s var i ed among the test substances . Benza l koni um chl oride
( 0 . 2% } and phenol ( 5% ) , a l though cau s i ng i rr i tant effects i n h i g her
concentrat i ons , hard ly i nfl uenced the barr i e r functi on of the s k i n ( as
determ i ned by water vapour l os s ) .
Apparentl y , some i rr i tants act by exert ing a subcl i n i ca l effect on the
barri er fu ncti on , whi l e others fa i l to do so .
Therefore , eva l uat i on of the subcl i n i ca l effects of chem i ca l s upon
barri er functi on may be u sefu l only i nsofar as stratum corneum i ntegri ty
i s important to prevent the permeati on of chem i ca l s and consequently
to prevent the devel opment of i rr i tant or a l l erg i c contact derma t i t i s
( 3 , 4 ) .
I t must be cons i dered that subcl i n i ca l effects other than i mpai rment of
barr i er funct i on may pl ay a rol e i n the devel opment of chron i c i rr i tant
contact dermati t i s ( 1 1 ) . After penetrat i on of a substance through the
horny l ayer wi thout primari l y i mpa i r i ng the horny l ayer funct i ons ,
damage to the v i ab l e cel l s of the epidermi s a nd dermi s may occur and thi s
may l ead to the devel opment of i rr i tant contact dermati t i s ( 5 ) .
1 25
Thus , subcorneal l ayers may be subcl i n i ca l l y damaged , whi l e at the same
time no measura b l e effects on the barrier functi on of the s k i n can be
noted .
126
TABLE I . Mean vapour l ass 2 + {g/m - S . D . ) from ex posed and unexposed s k i n
S . D . s i g n . +
mean
sod i um l auryl su l fate 6 . 4 3 . 6 p < 0 . 05
cocobeta i ne 5 . 1 2 . 7 p < 0 . 05
crotona l dehyde w i th sod i um l auryl su l fate 5 . 1 5 . 9 p < 0 . 05
d imethyl su l fox ide 5 . 3 4 . 3 p < 0 . 05
phenol 2 . 7 0 . 9 ++ n . s .
sod i um hydroxi d e 3 . 6 2 . 0 p < 0 . 05
benza l kon i um chl oride 3 . 0 1 . 4 n . s .
d i st i l l ed wa ter 2 . 5 1 . 1 n . s .
control 2 . 5 1 . 0
+ ) S i g n i f i cance of the di fference between the expos ed s k i n s i te and
the unexposed s k i n (a = 0 . 05 ) .
++ ) n . s . = not s i gn i f i cant .
127
References
1 . Mal ten , K . E . , Thi el e , F . A . J . Some theoreti cal as pects of ' ortho
erg i c ' ( = i rri tant ) dermati t i s . Arch . Bel g . Derm . 28 : 9-22 ( 197 2 ) .
2 . Hagerma n , G . Uber das traumi terati ves ( tox i sche ) Ekzem . Dermato l o
g i ca 1 1 5 : 525-529 ( 1 957 ) .
3 . Mal ten , K . E . Thoughts on i rri tant contact dermat i t i s . Contact Derma
t i t i s 7 : 238-247 ( 1 981 ) .
4 . Ummenhofer , B . Hornsch i chtphys i ol og i sche Grund l agen der Pravent i on
und Reha bi l i tati on von Berufsekzemen . Dermatosen 29 : 1 02- 106 ( 1981 ) .
5 . Va l k , P . G . M . van der , Kru i s -de Vr ies , M . H . , Nater , J . P . , Bl eumi n k ,
E . , Jong , M . C . J . M . d e . Eczematous ( i rr i tant and a l l erg i c ) react i ons
of the s k i n and barri er function as determi ned by water vapour l oss
Accepted for pub l i cati on . C l i n . & Exp . Derm .
6 . N i l s son , G . E . Measu rement of water exchange through the s k i n . Med .
& B i o l . Eng . & Comput . 1 5 : 209- 2 1 5 ( 1 977 ) .
7 . Va l k , P . G . M . van der , Nater , J . P . , B l eumi n k , E . S k i n i rri tancy of
su rfactants as assessed by water vapou r l os s measurements . J . I nvest .
Dermatol . 82 : 291-293 ( 1 984 ) .
8 . Frosch , P . J . , Kl i gma n , A . M . The soap chamber tes t . J . Am . Acad .
Derma tol . 1 : 35-41 ( 1979 ) .
9 . N i e , H . N . , Had l a i Hu l l , C . , J enki ns , J . G . , Stei nbrenner , K . , Bent ,
D . H . Stati s t i ca l package for the soci a l sc i ences . McGraw-Hi l l Book
Company , New York pp 267-274 ( 1 97 5 ) .
1 0 . Bj ornberg , A . S k i n react i ons to primary i rri tants i n pat i ents wi th
hand eczema . Thes i s , Oscar I sacsons Tryckeri AB , Goteborg , Sweden
pp 1 38- 142 ( 1 968 ) .
1 1 . Prottey , C . The mol ecu lar bas i s of s k i n i rr itat ion . Cosmet i c Sci ence
vol I . Academ i c Press , London pp 275-349 ( 1 978 ) .
128
CHAPTER 7
SK IN I RRITANCY OF COMMERC IALLY AVAI LABLE SOAP AND DETERGENT
BARS AS MEASURED BY WATER VAPOUR LOSS
Dermatosen i n Beruf und Umwel t
3 : 87-90 { 1 984 )
129
Authors :
P . G . M . van der Val k
M . C . C r i j ns
J . P . Nater
E. B l eumi nk
Summary
The i rri tancy on human s k i n of 13 toi l et soaps was asses sed by means of
water vapour l oss measurements . The tests were performed on heal thy s k i n
o f the vol ar s i de of t h e forearm i n a panel o f 3 3 subjects . The exposu
res were done u s i ng the F i nn chamber method . S k i n water vapour l oss was
measured by means of an ' evaporimeter ' . Al l soaps - tested i n 2 g/v% so
l ut i ons - were found to l ead to a stat i st i ca l l y s i gn i fi cant i ncrease of
water vapour l oss as compared to the control s i tes . Syntheti c detergents
based on a l kyl su l fates , part i cu l arly Lactacyd , genera l l y had a rel at i
vely greater effect o n s k i n vapour l oss a s compared wi th the other pro
ducts . On the whol e the d i fferences between the products were sma l l . I t
appears that every person probab ly has h i s own pattern of suscept i b i l i ty
to wash-acti ve agents .
I ntroduct i on
Soaps and detergents u sed for c l eans i ng t he s k i n may damage the s k i n ei
ther by i nfl uenci ng i t s barri er funct i on or by cau s i ng tox i c reacti ons i n
the epi derm i s o r dermi s ( 1-4 ) . A faci l i tated permeation of substances may
enhance sens i t i zat ion to a l l ergens present i n the c l eans i ng materi a l or
to other a l l ergens i n the envi ronment ( 5-7 ) . I rr i tant effects may i n the
l ong run contri bute to the deve l opment of i rri tant contact dermat i t i s .
The importance of l ow concentrati ons of surfactants i n cau s i n g and sus
tai ni ng i rr i tant contact dermati t i s is st i l l i n d i scuss i on . Soaps and
synthet i c detergents commonly cause only s l i ght i rri tati on when tested on
the s k i n i n concentrati ons comparabl e to soa p d i l uti ons used for was h i ng
( 8 , 9 ) . I t i s , however , l i kely that the i rri tant effects of soaps and de
tergents are cumu l ati ve in the course of time ( 5 , 8 ) . Moreover a certa i n
percentage of i nd i v i du a l s comp l a i ns about dryness and i tch i ng of the s k i n
after u s i ng c l eansi ng products { 10 ) . Therefore i t i s mandatory t o advi se
subj ects with adverse react ions to certa i n soaps or detergents other pro
ducts wh i ch are better tol erated , i . e . products that do not conta i n com
ponents that may g i ve ri se to a l l erg i c reacti ons and a l s o have as l i tt l e
i rri tant effects o n the s k i n a s poss i b l e ( 7 , 8 , 1 0- 14 ) .
130
I n order to i nvesti gate the i rri tant effects of soaps and detergents the
d i fferent components have been stud i es ( 1 5 - 1 7 ) . However , the i rri tant ef
fect of c l eans ing products cannot be estimated re l i ab ly on the bas i s of
data obta i ned from the i ngred i ents a l one ( 18 ) . The total product must a l
s o b e tes ted to assess i ts i rri tancy .
I n t h i s study an attempt was made to test l ow concentrati ons of a number
of soap and detergent bars commerc i a l l y ava i l ab l e i n the Netherl ands for
the i r i rr i tancy to human sk i n .
The effect of the products o n the s k i n was asses sed by water vapour l oss
measurements ( 1 3 , 14 , 1 9 ) .
Materi a l s and methods
Thi rteen brand- name products were eva l uated dur i ng the months Apri l and
May on a panel of 33 hea l thy subj ects , rang i ng i n age from 18 to 52 years .
The exposures were performed u s i ng a c hamber method ( Large Fi nn chamber ,
Epi test Ltd . , Oy Hel s i nk i , F i n l a nd ) . Each F i nn chamber w ith a d i ameter of
12 mm conta i ned 5 c i rcu l a r p i eces of absorbent paper { Whatmann ) . By means
of a mi cropi pette {Ass i sten t , Karl Hecht , Sondheim/ Rhon , FR Germany ) th i s
p i eces of absorbent paper were saturated wi th 100 � 1 of a test substance .
I n total 16 F i nn chambers on Scanpor ( Norgesp l aster A/S Os l o , Norway ) we
re used . Th i rteen were fi l l ed wi th 2 g/v% of the soap or detergent i n d i s
ti l l ed water. Th ree were used as control s . The chambers were appl i ed to
the vol ar s i de of the forearm . The brand names of the tested products and
add i t i ona l i nformati on are l i sted in Tab l e 1 . F i xomu l l stretch (Bei ers
dorf , Hamburg, FR Germany ) and No 1 1 e 1 ast bandage ( Lohmann , Neuwi ed , FR
Germany ) were used for f i x i ng the chambers to the s ki n . After an exposure
of 24 hours and an off- peri od of one hour to reduce effects of macerat i on
and desorpti on ( 20 ) the actual measurements were done .
S k i n water vapour l os s measurements were performed by means of the Servo
Med evaporimeter { Servo Med , Stockhol m , Val l i ng by , Sweden ) . Th i s i nstru
ment compri ses a probe attached to a portabl e d i s p l ay un i t . The probe i s
appl i ed perpendi cu l ar to the s k i n . I n the probe two pai rs of both a humi
j i ty transducer and a thermi stor are s i tuated at d i fferent l evel s . From the
s i gna l s of the sensors the s k i n water va pour l oss per unit t i me and sur-
1 3 1
Ta b l e 1 . I n forma t i on about the tes ted produ cts .
Brand name
Aveenoderm
C i da l
Johnson ' s baby soap
Lactacyd
Lux
Neutrogena
Pa lmo l i ve
Seba med
Sebopona
Sporex
Sul foderm
Un i cura
Zwi tsa l baby soap
Compo s i t i on accord i ng pH
to manufacturer*
Synthet i c detergent 5 . 43 conta i n s sodi um l auryl ester su l fonate
Sod i um soap of tal l ow- and 10 . 6 1 coconut o i l
Sod i um soap of tal l ow- and 1 0 . 65 coco nut o i l
Synthet i c detergent conta i n s 3 . 84 ammon i um a l kyl s u l fate
Sod i um soap of tal l ow- and 9 . 68 coconut o i l
Sod i um soap of coconut o i l 9 . 7 5
Sodi um soap of tal l ow- and 10 . 59 coconut o i l
Synthet i c detergent 5 . 50 conta i n s a l kyl s u l fates
Syntheti c detergent 6 . 68 conta i ns a l kyl s u l fates
Pure sod i um soap of coconut o i l 10 . 63
Synthet i c detergent conta i n s 5 . 88 sod i um s u l fsucci nate
Sodi um soap of tal l ow- and 10 . 60 coconut oi l
Sod i um soap of tal l ow- and 10 . 60 coconut o i l
* Only ma i n components are ment i oned .
1 32
face can be ca l cu l ated . A fu l l descri pt i on of t h i s i nstrument i s g i ven by
N i l s son ( 2 1 ) . Reg i stration and measur i ng techn ique were performed accor
d i ng to methods descri bed e l sewhere ( 1 9 ) . Measu rements were performed un
der neutral amb i ent c i rcums tances ( room temperature var i ed from 20 to 22° C ; the mean rel a t ive h umi d i ty was 36 . 4 � 5 . 4 ) .
Stat i s t i c analys i s
A two-way ana l ys i s of vari ance was done to test the contri but i o n o f the
products ta k i ng i nto accou nt the i ntersubj ect vari abi l i ty ( 22 ) . To test the actual d i fferences for s i g n i f i cance a pai red t-test was used .
The assumpt i on of a Gauss i an frequency d i str ibut i on proved to be l eg i t i
mate ( 19 ) . To avoid a cumu l at i ve type 1 error proba bi l i ty the Newman
Keu l s mul t i p l e compari son test procedure was used ( 22 , 23 ) . Th i s conser
vati ve procedure prov i des a l evel of s i gn i f i cance for the ent i re col l ec
t i on of tests , implyi ng that the probab i l i ty of obta i n i ng spurious s i g n i
fi cant resu l ts does not exceed th i s l evel .
Res u l ts
I n Tab l e 2 the rank order of the tes ted products i s l i sted accord i ng to
the effects on water vapour l os s of the s k i n . Al l products caused a s i g
n i f i cant i ncrease of water vapour l oss as compared to the control s ( p <
0 . 05 ) . The ana lys i s of var i ance performed on the data showed a s i gn i f i
cant contr i but i on o f the products i n cau s i ng the vari ati on . Th i s i nd i ca
tes that , though d i fferences between products were most ly sma l l , the mean
water vapour l os s va l ues of the exposed s k i n s i tes do not on ly d i ffer by
chance { Tab l e 3 ) .
The actual d i fferences were tested by means of pa i red t-tests { Tabl e 4 ) .
By means of the Newman-Keu l s mu l t i p l e compari son procedure an attempt
was made to order the products i nto groups wi th more or l ess the same ef
fect on water vapour l os s . Th i s procedure showed a l a rge i ntermed i ate
group of ma i n ly a l ka l i ne soaps wi thout s i g n i f i cant d i fferences . Lactacyd
caused a s i gn i fi cant i ncrease i n water vapour l oss w i th regard to other
products . Sebopona di ffered s i gn i f i cantly from Aveenoderm to C i da l . Seba-
1 33
Tab l e 2 . Rank order of sk i n vapour l os s va l ues of the d i fferent test
substances .
Mean ( g/m2 . h . ) S . D .
1 . Empty F inn chamber 6 . 573 1 . 972
2 . Sod i um chl oride 0 . 9% 6 . 7 1 8 2 . 057
3 . Di st i l l ed water 7 . 388 1 . 9 1 7
4 . Aveenoderm 8 . 333 3 . 276
5 . Zwi tsa l baby soap 8 . 79 1 2 . 4 1 1
6 . Neutrogena 8 . 900 2 . 7 1 0
7 . Sporex 8 . 945 2 . 590
8 . Pa lmol i ve 8 . 99 1 2 . 286
9 . Su l foderm 9 . 030 2 . 6 1 1
10 . Uni cura 9 . 1 7 3 2 . 63 5
1 1 . Lux 9 . 281 2 . 445
1 2 . C i da l 9 . 239 2 . 986
1 3 . Johnson ' s baby soap 9 . 809 3 . 1 7 5
1 4 . Seba med 9 . 909 3 . 049
1 5 . Sebopona 10 . 464 3 . 542
16 . Lactacyd 1 1 . 236 2 . 972
1 34
Tabl e 3 . Analys i s of vari ance , water vapour l os s va l ues by soap and
subj ect .
Soap
Source of
var i at i on
Subj ect
Res i dual
Tota l
Sum of squares
241 . 165
2420 . 73 1
947 . 089
3608. 985
135
OF
1 2
3 2
3 84
428
F
8 . 1
30 . 7
S i gn . F
p < 0 . 001
p < 0 . 001
Tab l e 4 . T-val ues ; pa i red t-tests between SVL-va l ues of the di fferent test substances�) .
1 . Aveenoderm 0
2 . C i da l - 3 . 00 0
3 . J ohnson - 4 . 00 - 1 . 67 0
4 . Lactacyd -6 . 3 1 - 5 . 1 9 -3 . 45 0
5 . Lux - 2 . 33 0 . 06 1 . 47 5 . 16 0
6 . Neutrogena - 1 . 81 1 . 2 1 2 . 94 5 . 70 1 . 19 0
7 . Pa lmo l i ve - 1 . 56 0 . 69 2 . 23 4 . 92 0 . 63 -0 . 3 1 0
8 . Seba med - 3 . 49 - 1 . 65 -0 . 2 1 2 . 80 - 1 . 54 - 2 . 52 - 2 . 38 0
9 . Sebopona - 4 . 34 - 2 . 50 - 1 . 25 1 . 52 - 2 . 53 -3 . 59 - 3 . 10 - 2 . 1 7 0 "' M
10 . Sporex - 1 . 49 0 . 7 7 2 . 1 6 5 . 92 0 . 84 -0 . 16 0 . 14 3 . 10 3 . 93 0
1 1 . S u l foderm - 1 . 67 0 . 52 1 . 7 2 4 . 95 0 . 55 -0 . 36 -0 . 10 2 . 24 2 . 96 -0 . 34 0
1 2 . Un i cu ra - 2 . 22 0 . 19 1 . 53 5 . 36 0 . 13 -0 . 84 -0 . 50 2 . 1 6 3 . 41 -0 . 7 2 -0 . 44 0
1 3 . Zwi tsal - 1 . 1 7 1 . 1 4 2 . 3 5 6 . 04 1 . 37 0 . 33 0 . 53 2 . 90 4 . 00 0 . 47 0 . 7 1 1 . 95 0
1 ) 2 ) 3 ) 4 ) 5 ) 6 ) 7 ) 8 ) 9 ) 1 0 ) 1 1 ) 1 2 ) 13 )
� ) t > 2 . 042 , p < 0 . 05 .
med and Johnson ' s Baby Soa p d i ffered s i gn i fi cant ly from Aveenoderm � ) .
Di s cu s s i on
I n the app l i ed 2 g/v � so l u t i on a l l tested products were found to l ead to
a s i ng i f i cant i ncrease of water vapour l os s in compar i son to the contro l
s i tes ( p < 0 . 05 ) . Th i s i ncreas e of water vapour l os s poi nts to a l terati
ons of s k i n permeabi l i ty .
I n compari son t o a l ka l i ne soaps syntheti c detergent bars based o n a l kyl
s u l fates , espec i a l ly Lactacyd , appear to exert a s l i ght ly s tronger effect
on the s k i n . Lactacyd a l so conta i ns , apart from ammon i um a l kyl s u l fate ,
l acti c ac i d . Th i s su bstance probab ly has ant i - bacteri a l propert i es , but
a l so may affect the protei ns of the horny l ayer ( 24 ) . So l act i c ac i d may
contri bute to the i ncrease of s k i n water vapour l os s , a s observed i n t h i s
study . The a l ka l i ne s oaps were not found t o i nf l uence water l os s t o a
greater extent than the synthet i c products (wi t h excepti on of Aveenoderm ) .
Thu s the often c l a imed advantages of products wi t h a neutra l or ac i d pH
in compar i son to a l ka l i ne soaps wi th respect to the i r i nj uri ng effect of
the s k i n ( 2 5 ) cou l d not be proven .
Under neutra l c i rcumstances the pH of the s k i n var i es from 5 . 2 to 6 . 0 and
is kept wi th i n these l i m i t s by the " funct i ona l buffer capa c i ty of the
s k i n " , rna i n ly a 1 actate-b i carbonate buffer system ( 26 ) . The importance of
stri ct mai ntenance of the ac i d pH , the " a c i d ma nt l e of the s k i n " ( 2 7 )
seems to b e overemphas i s ed , a s on ly very a l ka l i ne ( buffered ) substances
i nj ure the s k i n structura l l y ( 28 ) . Present ly some i nvest i gators even ad
vocate the use of a l ka l i ne soaps ( 29 , 30 ) .
Especi a l l y sod i um s oaps of l ong cha i n fatty ac i ds are adv i sed , because
fatty acids of a l ower mo l ecu l a r wei ght more frequently y i e l d i rr i tant
react i ons ( 1 6 , 3 1 ) . E spec i a l l y for subj ects with a " v u l nerabl e s k i n " the
use of these a l ka l i ne soaps shou l d m i n i mi ze the r i s k of adverse react i
ons ( 30 ) . The i rri tancy of synthet i c detergents cannot be genera l i zed
however , s i nce products based on i sethi onates seem to have a rel at i vel y
good s k i n compat i b i l i ty ( 10 ) .
� ) Tabu l ati on ava i l ab l e from the authors .
137
Genera l l y we only observed sma l l d i fferences between commerc i a l toi l et
soaps , even between chemi cal ly unre l ated surfactants . I t i s noteworthy
that i n the avai l ab l e l i terature cl ear d i fferences have only been obser
ved i n stud i es ma k i ng use of repeated exposu res of h i gh concentra t i ons of
the products ( 10- 12 ) . For the popu l ati on as a who l e i t genera l l y may hol d
true that some cl eans i ng products are better tol erated than others , but
in the i nd i v i dua l case t h i s i s not neces sari ly tru e . It i s not poss i b l e
t o pred i ct the i ntens i ty of the s k i n react i on o f a n i nd i v i dual t o an i rri
tant ( 32-34 ) . Th i s i s al so pl aus i b l e for su rface acti ve agents ( 1 9 , 32 ) .
Thi s impl i es that every subject may have i t s own pattern of suscept i b i l i
ty to soaps and detergents . D i fferences i n " s k i n type" probab ly determ i ne
wh i ch products are wel l tol era ted . For examp l e persons w i t h a severe se
borrhoea may tol erate a strong l y degrea s i ng produ ct , wh i ch on the other
hand may cause s i de effects i n peop l e wi th a dry and more sens i t i ve s k i n
( 3 5 , 36 ) .
1 38
References
1 ) Bettl ey , F . R . , Donaghue , F . The i rri tant effect of soap upon the nor
ma l s k i n . Br . J . Dermatol . 7 2 : 67-76 ( 1 960 ) .
2 ) Bett l ey , F . R . The i nf l u ence of soap on the permeab i l i ty of the epi
dermi s . Br . J . Dermato l . 73 : 448-454 ( 1961 ) .
3 ) Bett l ey , F . R . The i rr i tant effect of detergents . Transacti ons St .
John ' s Hos p i ta l Dermatol . Soc . 58 : 65-74 ( 19 72 ) .
4 ) Val er , M . D i e verg l e i chende Untersuchung der Rei zw i r kung von Wasch
mi ttel n auf d ie menschl i che Haut . Berufsdermatosen 1 7 : 83-99 ( 1969 ) .
5 ) Mal ten , K . E . Thoughts on i rri tant contact dermat it i s . Contact Derma
t i t i s 7 : 238-247 ( 1 981 ) .
6 ) Ummenhofer , B . Hornsch i chtphys i o l og i sche Grundl agen der Pravent i on
und Rehabi l i tat i on von Berufsekzemen . Dermatosen 28 : 102- 106 ( 1981 ) .
7 ) Ummenhofe r , B . Prakt i s che berufsdermatol og i sche As pekte der Hautre i
ni gung . Zent . B l . Haut-Gesch l . Krankh . 147 : 379-449 ( 1982 ) .
8 ) Ki s s , G . von . PrUfung von durch Waschmi ttel bedi ngten Hautsch�d i gung
en . Dermatosen 29 : 1 5- 1 8 ( 1981 ) .
9 ) Jansen , L . H . , Young , E . Mag eczemateus veranderde hu i d gewassen wor
den? Ned . T . Geneesk . 1 06 : 7 10-7 1 5 ( 1962 ) .
1 0 ) Frosch , P . J . I rri tancy of soaps and detergent bars . I n : Pr i nc i p l es of
Cosmeti cs for the Derma tol og i st , pp 5- 12 ( 1 982 ) Edi tors : Frost and
Horwi tz . Mosby St . Loui s .
1 1 ) Frosch , P . J . , Kl i gman , A . M . The soap chamber test . J . Am . Acad . Der
matol . 1 : 35- 4 1 ( 1979 ) .
1 2 ) Ketel , W . G . van , Bruynzee l , D . P . , Bezemer , P . O . , Stamhu i s , I . H . Toxi
c i ty of handc l eaners . Dermatol oqi ca 168 : 94-99 ( 1984 ) .
1 3 ) Has s i ng , J . H . , Nater , J . P . , B l eum i n k , E . I rr i tancy of l ow concentra
t i ons of soap and syntheti c detergents as measured by s k i n vapour
l os s . Derma to l og i ca 1 64 : 3 14-321 ( 1 982 ) .
1 4 ) Val k , P . G . M . van der , Nater , J . P . , B l eum i n k , E . S k i n vapour l os s as a
method for measuri ng the i nfl uence of soaps and detergents on human
s k i n . Dermatosen 3 1 : 58-60 ( 1983 ) .
1 5 ) B l ank , I . H . Acti on of soap on s k i n . Arc h . Derm . & Syph . 39 : 8 1 1 -824
( 1939 ) .
139
1 6 ) Tronn i e r , H . Uber d i e Abhang i g kei t dermato l og i scher E i genschaften
waschakti ver Tens i de von deren Kettenl ange . ParfUm . u . Kosmet . 58 :
60-65 ( 1977 ) .
1 7 ) Smeen k , G . De i nv l oed van detergent ia op de hui d . Thes i s , J . Noor
duyn en zoon N . V . , Gori chem ( 1968 ) .
1 8 ) Gol demberg , R . L . , Safri n , L . R�duct i on of topi cal i rr i tat i on . J . Soc .
Cosmet . Chern . 28 : 667-679 ( 1977 ) .
1 9 ) Val k , P . G . M . van der , Nater , J . P . , Bl eu� i n k , E . S k i n i rri tancy of
surfactants as assessed by water vapor l oss measurements . J . I nvest .
Derma to l . 82 : 291 -293 ( 1 984 ) .
2 0 ) Baker , H . , Kl i gman , A . M . Measurements of transep i derma l water l os s
by el ectr ica l hygrometry . Arc h . Derm . 9 6 : 441-452 ( 1 967 ) .
2 1 ) N i l s son , G . E . Measurements of water exchange through sk i n . Med . B i o l .
Eng . & Comput . 1 5 : 209-2 18 ( 1 977 ) .
22 ) Arm i tage , P . Stat i s t i ca l methods i n med i ca l research , 7 : 189-2 1 6 .
B l ackwel l Sci ent if i c Publ i cati ons , Oxford , U . K . ( 19 7 1 ) .
23 ) Mi l l er , R . G . S imu l taneous stat i s t i cal i nfP.rence , 6 : 82-90 . McGraw
H i l l Boo k Company , New York , U . S . A . ( 1966 ) .
24 ) Th i el e , F . A . J . The s k i n d i s i nfectant propert i es of l act i c ac i d . I n :
Handbuch der Haut- und Gesch l echts krankhei ten , Vol . 1 /4B , pp 257-258
( 1981 ) Normal e und Patho l og i sche Phys i ol og i e der Haut I I I . Ed i tor :
J . Jadassohn . Spri nger-Verl ag , Berl i n .
2 5 ) Bettl ey , F . R . , Donaghue , E . The i rri tant effect of soap upon the nor
ma l s k i n . Br . J . Dermatol . 72 : 67-76 ( 1 980 ) .
26 ) Kl aschka , F . Arbei tsphys i o l og i e der Hornsch i cht i n GrundzUgen . I n :
Handbuch der Haut- und Ges chl echts kran khei ten , Vol . 1 /4A , p p 184- 185
( 1 979 ) Norma l e und Patho l og i sche Phys i ol og i e der Haut I I . Edi tor : J .
J adassohn . Spri nger-Ver l a g , Berl i n .
27 ) Schade , H . , March i oni n i , A . P hys i ka l i s ch - chemi sche Untersuchungen
an mensch l i cher Hau t . Kl i n . Wsch r . 1 : 1 - 1 4 ( 1928 ) .
28 ) Tronn i er , H . D i e potent i ometri sche T i trat i on a l s Methode zur Best im
mung der Al kal i empf i nd l i ch ke i t der Haut . Berufsdermatosen 1 4 : 296-
308 ( 1966 ) .
2 9 ) Mal ten , K . E . Tens i de ( Nederl ands ) = Ten s i de ( Du i ts ) = Surfactants
( Engel s ) z i j n bel angri j ke componenten i n de cosmet i ca . N i euwsbr ief
1 40
Conta ctdermatol ogi e 4 : 47-53 ( 197 3 ) .
30 ) Mal ten , K . E . De zeep waarmee wij ons wassen . N i euwsbrief Contactder
matol og i e 5 : 66- 7 1 ( 1980 ) .
3 1 ) B l ank , J . H . Act i on of soap on s k i n . Arch . Derm . Syph . 39 : 8 1 1 -824
( 1 939 ) .
32 ) Bj ornberg , A . S k i n reactions to primary i rr i tants i n pati ents wi th
handeczema . Thes i s , Oscar I sacsons Tryckeri AB Goterborg , Sweden
{ 1963 ) .
33 ) Czerwi n s ka- D i hm , I . , Rudzk i , E . S k i n reacti ons to pr imary i rri tants .
Contact Dermat i t i s 7 : 3 1 5 -3 19 ( 1981 ) .
34 ) Coenraads , P . J . , B l eumi nk , E . , Nate r , J . P . Suscept i b i l i ty to prima ry
i rr i tants . Contact Dermati t i s 1 : 377-381 ( 19 75 ) .
3 5 ) Schne i der , W . Experi mentel l e Untersuchungen zur Frage der Rei n i gung ,
Pfl ege und externe Therap i e der Haut . Derm . Wschr . 1 52 : 505- 5 14
( 1965 ) .
36 ) Schne i der , W . , Tron n i e r , H . , Wagner , H . Rei n i gung und Pfl ege der Haut
im Beruf unter besonderen BerUck s i chti gung der experimentel l en u nd
prakt i s chen PrUfverfahren . I n : Dermatol ogi e und Venereol ogi e , Vol I / 2 ,
pp 1 043- 1070 ( 1962 ) Ed i tors : H . A . Gottron , W . Schonfel d . Georg Th i eme
Verl ag , Stuttgart .
141
CHAPTER 8
SUMMARY AND CONCLUS I ONS
SAMENVATTI NG EN CONCLUS I ES
1 42
Summary and conc l u s i ons .
I n t h i s thes i s , the resu l ts of a seri es of i nvestigat i ons i nto the
barri er funct ion of human s k i n are pres ented . I n these i nves t i gat i ons ,
the barr i er functi on was asses sed by water vapour l os s measu rements of
the s k i n u s i ng a method based on grad i ent e st ima t i on .
I n the fi rst chapter , a theoreti cal essay i s prov i ded based on a rev i ew
of the l i terature on the l ocal i za t i on , b i ochemi ca l compos i t i on and phy
s i cal properti es of the s k i n barri er wi th spec i a l reference to the wa
ter barri e r .
T h e importance o f an u n impa i red barr i er for prevent ion o f damage to the
v i ab l e l ayers of the s k i n and the pos s i b l e rol e of barr i er function de
f i c i ency in the devel opment of chroni c i rr i tant contact dermat i t i s i s
d i scus sed . On the bas i s of the l i terature , i t i s concl uded that wi thout
penetrat i on through the horny l ayer i n deeper l ayers of the s k i n poten
t i a l i rr i tant factors wi l l not g i ve r i s e to tox i c effects i n the s k i n .
The appl i cati on of the method of water vapour l os s meas urements to
a s sess barr ier impa i rment i s worked out and a s urvey of the most con
found i ng vari abl es i s g i ven . The d i fferent methods of measurement of
water vapour l os s a re d i s cussed and compared wi th the method of g rad i ent
estimat i on . Measurement pri nci p l es and the accuracy of t he method of
gradi ent estimation are d i scussed .
I n Chapter 2 , t he method for asses s i ng the i nfl uence of substances on
the s k i n barri er for water u sed i n the seri es of i nvesti gati ons presen
ted i n more detai l . The chamber techni que a s u sed to expose the s k i n to
the test substances and the method of measurement are e l aborated . I n
the s tudy presented i n Chapter 2 , the fol l ow i ng s u rface act i ve compounds
and contro l s were tested ( a l l i n d i s t i l l ed water ) :
sod i um l auryl s u l fate ani on i c s urfactant ( pH 7 . 3 )
sod i um l aurate a n i on i c s urfactant ( pH 9 . 2 )
pol ysorbate-60 non i o n i c s urfactant ( pH 3 . 8 )
cocobeta i ne amphoteri c s urfactant ( pH 5 . 2 )
d i st i l l ed water control ( pH 5 . 6 )
NaCl 0 . 9% control ( pH 6 . 7 )
143
Al l tes ted substances as assayed on the vol ar s i de of the forearm i n a
panel of heal thy vol unteers caused a s i gn i f i cant mean i ncrea se i n water
vapour l oss as compared wi th that of unexposed s k i n . D i s t i l l ed water
i nfl uenced the water barr i er of the s k i n to a greater extent than d i d
D . 9% NaCl i n d i s ti l l ed water .
Di vergent i ntra- en i nters ubject patterns of water vapour l oss data
were observed sugges t i ng each i nd i v i dual a s havi ng h i s own patterns of
suscepti b i l i ty to barr i er functi on d i s turbance .
The mean scores for the water vapour l oss measurements were compared
wi th those cal cul ated from the resu l ts of a ' v i sual scori ng system ' :
Erythema 1 + , s l i ght redness , s potty or d i ffuse ; 2+ , moderate redness ;
3+ , i ntense redness ; 4+ , fi ery red wi th edema .
Sca l i ng 1+ , fi ne ; 2+ , moderate ; 3+ , severe wi th l arge fl akes .
F i s sur i ng : 1+ , f i ne cracks ; 2+ , s i ng l e or mu l t i p l e broader fi ssures ;
3+ , wide cracks wi th hemorrhage or exudati on .
The systems proved to be h i gh ly correl ated for the substances tes ted ,
i mp ly i ng that the i rr i tancy of surfactants i s greatly dependent on the i r
effects o n the (water ) s k i n barr i e r .
T h e a im o f the study d i scussed i n Chapter 3 was the assessment by s k i n
water va pour l os s measurements o f s k i n barri er impa i rment caused by
surface acti ve compounds i n d i fferent eczema categori es and control
groups . For th i s purpose , unaffected s k i n of the vol ar s i de of the
forearm was exposed to the fol l owi ng substances ( a l l in a 2 g/v% i n
d i sti l l ed water ) :
sod i um 1 aura te a n i on i c ( pH = 9 . 2 )
sodi um stearate a n i on i c ( pH = 10 . 4 )
sodi um l auryl s u l fate a n i on i c ( pH 7 . 3 )
potas s i um soap II an ion i c ( pH 10 . 0 )
cocobetai ne amphoteri c ( pH 5 . 2 )
ceteareth-12 non i on i c ( pH 6 . 4 )
cocami dopropyl beta i ne amphoteri c ( pH 6 . 0 )
pol ysorbate-GO non i on i c ( pH 3 . 8 )
II ) Potass i um sa l t of coconut- and r i c i nu s o i l .
The group of pati ents wi th eczema as a who l e reacted more severely to
144
the test substances . T h i s was ch i ef ly the resu l t of reacti ons of the
subgroup of pati ents wi th atopi c dermati ti s . The atop i c pati ents reacted
more severel y to the test substances , espec i a l l y to the syntheti c deter
gents ( arti fi c i a l ly bui l t up surface acti ve compounds out of coa l or mi
neral oi l ) . The a l ka l i ne soaps ( carboxyl ates of an ima l or veg eta b l e
oi l s ) were tol erated rel ati ve ly wel l i n t h i s g roup , confi rm ing t h e re
su l ts of other stud ies . In the subgroup of pati ents wi th i rr i tant con
tact dermati ti s , i t was not poss i b l e to demon strate a more severe reac
t i on as determi ned by s k i n water vapour l oss in compar i son wi th the
control groups , sugges t i ng a l i mi ted rol e of a c onsti tuti onal vul nera
b i l i ty to barr ier functi on d i s turbances in t h i s grou p .
I n Chapter 4 , a study compari ng t h e effects o n t h e barr i er functi on of
the s k i n of a poss i b l e a l l ergen ( n i ckel su l fate ) i n a concentrati on not
norma l l y g i ven r i se to a v i s i b l e i rri tant reacti on and th ree test sub
s tances wi th moderate ( v i s i b l e ) tox i c effects in the concentrati ons em
p l oyed i s presented . The fol l owi ng test substances ( a l l in d i st i l l ed
water ) were appl i ed to the vo l ar s i de of the forearm :
n i ckel su l fate 5 g/v% { p H 5 . 4 )
sod i um l au ryl su l fate 5 g/v% ( pH 7 . 3 )
d i methyl su l fox i de 50 g/v% ( pH 7 . 1 )
phenol 5 g/v% ( pH 6 . 2 )
Ba rri er funct i on d i sturbances a s as sessed by water vapour l os s were a l s o
rel a ted to macroscopi cal l y v i s i b l e changes ( ' v i sual scoring system ' ) .
The test s i tes exposed to n i c ke l su l fate were a l so read for a l l erg i c
react i ons accord i ng to a current method . The i nf l uence of the d i fferent
grades of a l l erg i c reacti ons on water vapour l os s was i nvesti gated . The
exposures were done in a g roup of persons wi th a h i s tory of pos i t i ve
a l l erg i c patch test reacti ons to n i c ke l su l fate and a group of persons
wi thout any s k i n d i sease or known a l l ergy . Genera l l y , a l l test sub
s tances caused an i ncrease in s k i n water vapour l os s in compari son wi th
a control ( d i s ti l l ed wate r ) . The correl a t i on between the s treng th of the
erythematous reacti on and the i n crease of water vapour l oss of the expo
s ed s k i n s i tes vari ed cons i derab ly among the app l i ed substances . Al l er
g i c react i ons , es peci a l l y the strong reacti ons , were shown to be abl e to
145
effect the water barr i er of the s k i n .
I t was concl uded that a substance may damage the horny l ayer i n severa l
ways : 1 ) d i rect l y by i ts phys i cochem i ca l properties ( i nteract i on wi th
horny l ayer components ) ;
2 ) i nd i rectl y , after permeation through the horny l ayer , by i ts
effect ( tox i c and/or a l l erg i c ) on the deeper v i ab l e l ayers of
the s k i n . Th i s may secondari ly resu l t i n a def i c i ent horny
l ayer format ion .
Both d i rect and i nd i rect effects may d i s tu rb the barr i er functi on on the
s k i n . It i s a l so concl uded that the extent of the horny l ayer barr i er
funct ion d i sturbance as caused by a substance may run para l l e l to the
extent of the v i s i b l e i nfl ammatory reacti ons of the deeper l ayers of the
s k i n .
Thi s , h owever , i s not a l ways the case , espec i a l l y not i f the effects are
eva l ua ted on ly once , because barr i er i mpai rment and repa i r of the horny
l ayer wi l l fo l l ow another t ime course than the v i s i b l e i nfl ammatory re
act i on of deeper l ayers of the s k i n .
The resu l ts of a l ong i tud i nal i nvesti gati on of the effect of repeated
s k i n exposures to surface acti ve compounds on the water barr i er are pre
sented i n Chapter 5 and compared wi th macro scop i ca l ly v i s i b l e changes
( ' v i sual scori ng system ' ) . The fol l owi ng propri etary products were tes ted
i n a 1 g/v% i n d i sti l l ed water on the vol ar s i de of the r i ght arm :
Zwi tsal baby soap ( pH 10 . 6 )
Su l foderm soap ( pH 5 . 9 )
Neutrogena soap ( pH = 9 . 8 )
Lactacyd soap ( pH 3 . 8 )
On the vol ar s i de of the l eft arm were tes ted i n a 0 . 5 g/v% i n d i sti l l ed
water the fol l owi ng surfactants :
cocobetai ne ( pH 5 . 2 )
sod i um l aurate ( pH 9 . 3 )
sod i um l au ryl su l fate ( pH 7 . 3 ) pol ysorbate-60 ( pH 3 . 8 )
The effects of l ow concentrat ions of surface acti ve compounds ( i n a test
panel of hea l thy subjects ) proved to be cumu l ati ve and there was a
146
correspondence between the general pattern of water vapour l os s and the
macroscopi ca l ly occurri ng v i s i bl e changes . I t has conc l uded that re
pea ted s k i n exposures to l ow concentrat i ons of surfactants may l ead to
i ncreased permeati on and may consequentl y faci l i tate the devel opment of
chron i c i rr i tant contact dermati ti s . Other factors such as faul ty i n
fl ammatory control mechani sms , d i s turbance of homeostas i s of the v i a b l e
l ayers o f the epi derm i s and derm i s and accumul a t i on o f ( endogeneous )
anti gens and i rr i tants i n repeatedl y exposed s k i n s i tes may a l s o p l ay a
rol e i n caus i ng or mai nta i ni ng chron i c i rr i tant contact dermati ti s .
I n Chapter 6 , the method of s k i n water vapour l oss measurements i s u sed
to assess the subc l i n i ca l effects of l ow concentrati ons of substances
known as s trong i rr i tant i n h i g her concentrati ons . The fol l owi ng sub
stances were appl i ed to c l i n i ca l l y unaffected s k i n of the vol a r s i de of
the forearm ( g/v% in d i s ti l l ed water ) :
sod i um l au ryl sul fate 2 g/v%
cocobeta i ne 2 g/v%
croton a l dehyde 0 . 75 g/v% and sod i um l au ryl su l fate
0 . 5 g/v%
d imethyl s u l fox i de 50 g/v%
phenol 5 g/v%
sod i um hydroxi de 1 g/v%
benzal koni um c h l or ide 0 . 2 g/v%
d i st i l l ed water
( pH 7 . 3 )
( pH 5 . 2 )
( pH 4 . 8 )
( pH 7 . 1 )
( pH 6 . 2 )
( pH 12 . 7 )
( pH 6 . 6 )
( pH 6 . 5 )
These test so l ut ions e l i c i ted only s l i ght macroscopi cal l y v i s i b l e re
acti ons of the s ki n . The surface act i ve compounds ( sod i um l au ryl su l fate ,
cocobetai n e and the combi nati on of croton a l dehyde wi th sod i um l au ryl
su l fate ) , except for benza l kon i um chl ori de , i nc reased water vapour l os s
s i gn i fi cantly i n compari son wi th unexposed s ki n . D imethyl su l fox i de at
50% and 1 % sod i um hydrox i de a l so i ncreased sk in water vapour l os s s i gn i
f i cant ly . Phenol at 5% d i d not i nfl uence the barr i er functi on of the
s k i n for water .
I t was concl uded that i rr i tant substances i n l ow concentrat i on may have
a subcl i n i cal effect on s k i n barr i er functi on , a l though not a l l i rr i tant
substances produce th is effect .
147
I n the study of Chapter 7 , the effects of 13 propri etary soap and syn -
theti c detergen t bars on the water barri er funct i on of the s k i n was eva-
l uated . The fol l ow i ng products were tes ted on the vol a r s i de of the
forearm i n a panel of heal thy subjects :
Aveenoderm ( pH 5 . 4 ) Pa lmol i ve ( pH 10 . 6 )
C i da l ( pH 10 . 6 ) Sebamed ( pH 5 . 5 )
Johnson ' s babysoap ( pH 1 0 . 7 ) Sebapona ( pH 6 . 7 )
Lactacyd ( pH 3 . 8 ) Sporex ( pH 1 0 . 6 )
Lux ( pH 9 . 7 ) Su l foderm ( pH 5 . 9 )
Neutrogena ( pH 9 . 8 ) U n i cura ( pH 10 . 6 )
Zwi tsa l babysoap ( pH 10 . 6 )
Al l of the propri etary products were found to l ead to a s tati st i cal ly
s i gn i fi cant i ncrease i n wa ter vapour l os s a s compared wi th d i s t i l l ed wa
ter . Synthet i c detergent bars based on al kyl s u l fates had a rel a ti vely
greater effect on the s k i n ba rri er than d i d the other products . On the
whol e , however , the mean d i fferences between the products were smal l .
I t i s concl uded that d i fferences i n ' s k i n type ' probably a l so determ i ne
wh i ch products are wel l tol era ted .
The con s i derab l e var i a t i on i n wa ter vapour l os s data as observed i n the
stud i es d i scus sed in th i s t hes i s may hamper a - correct i n terpretat i on .
Partly th i s vari at ion can be expl a i ned by the i nfl uence of i n terven i ng
vari abl es l i ke , e . g . , sweati ng .
The i nfl uence of these vari abl es ( random vari ati on i s l i ke l y ) cou l d be
restri cted by compa r i ng mean s cores .
A s i ng l e person ' s i mpa i rment of s k i n barri e r functi on however , cou l d not
be assessed rel i abl y . Da ta about the suscept i bi l i ty of the i nd i v i dual
to barr i er functi on d i s turbances can probably on l y be obtai ned by keepi ng
the i nfl uence of ( random ) var i a t i on i n more narrow l i mi ts .
1 48
Samenvatt i ng en conc l u s i e s .
I n d i t proefschri ft z i j n d e resul taten gebund e l d van een aantal onder
zoeken naar de barri erefuncti e van mensel i j ke h u i d tegen schade l i j ke
i nv l oeden u i t de omgev i nq .
I n deze studi es werd de barri erefunct i e van de mensel i j ke hu i d onder
zocht met behu l p van waterdampverl i esmet i ngen . De met i ngen werden ver
ri cht vol gens een methode gebaseerd op het meten van de rel ati eve
vocht i ghe id op twee afstanden van de hu i d .
I n het eerste hoofd stuk wordt een theoreti sche verhandel i ng gegeven
over de l oka l i sati e , b i ochemi sche samenstel l i ng en fys i sche ei genschap
pen van de hu i dbarri ere . Deze verhandel i ng , toegesp i tst op de h u i d
barri ere voor waterdampverl i es , i s gebaseerd op l i teratuuronderzoek .
Het bel ang van een onbeschad i gde h u i dbarri ere voor de preventi e van be
schadi g i ng van d i epere l agen van de hu i d en de mogel i j ke rol van stoor
n i ssen van de barri erefuncti e b i j het ontstaan van het orthoerg i sch con
tact eczeem worden bes proken .
Op bas i s van l i tera tuuronderzoek wordt geconc l udeerd dat zonder pe�etra
t i e door de hoornl aag i n de d i epere l agen van de hui d potenti ee l bescha
d i gende fa ktoren geen aan l e i d i ng geven tot tox i sche effekten in de hu i d .
De toepass i ng van de waterdampverl i esmeti ngen a l s methode om beschad i
g i ng van d e h u i dbarri ere o p te sporen wordt u i tgewerkt en een overz i cl tt
van de var i a bel en , d i e de meti n g kunnen beinv l oeden , wordt gegeven .
Tevens worden de versch i l l ende methoden om het waterdampverl i es te me
ten bes proken en vergel eken met de i n deze s tud i e toegepaste method i ek .
De meetpr i nc i pes en de nauwkeur i ghe i d van het i n deze s tud i e gebru i kte
i ns trument worden besproken .
I n hoofdstuk 2 wordt de methode besproken om met behu l p van waterdamp
verl i esmeti ngen van de hu i d de i nv l oed van chem i sche s toffen op de h u i d
barri ere t e meten .
De kamertechn i e k , zoa l s i n de s tud i es van d i t proefschri ft gebru i kt om
de hu i d aan de chem i sche s toffen b l oat te s tel l en , en de meetprocedure
worden u i tgewerkt .
I n de s tud i e van d i t hoofdstuk werden de vol gende wasakti eve s toffen en
149
control e v l oei stoffen getest ( i n gedest i l l eerd water ) :
natri uml auryl su l faat an i onogene wasakti eve stof ( pH 7 . 3 )
natri uml auraat an i onogene wa sakti eve stof ( pH 9 . 2 )
pol ysorbaat-60 n i et- i onogene wasakti eve stof ( pH 3 . 8 )
cocobeta i ne amfotere wa sakti eve stof ( pH 5 . 2 )
gedes ti l l eerd water contro l e ( pH 5 . 6 )
NaCl 0 . 9% control e ( pH 6 . 7 )
Al l e s toffen werden getes t op de vol a i re z ijde van de onderarm . I n een
groep van gezonde vri jwi l l i gers veroorzaakten a l l e versch i l l ende v l oe i
s toffen een s i gn i fi cante toename i n waterdampverl i es i n vergel i j k i ng met
n i et geexponeerde hu i d .
Gedest i l l eerd water veroorzaakte een gemi dde l d grotere toename i n water
dampverl i es dan een opl os s i ng met 0 . 9% NaCl .
Zowel sprei d i ng tussen de getes te stoffen a l s tussen de proefpersonen
werd waargenomen . Het sterk wi ssel ende patroon in waterdampverl i es w i j s t
erop d a t i eder i nd i v i du een ei gen gevoel i ghe idspatroon voor stoorn i ssen
van de barri erefuncti e heeft .
De gemi ddel de scores van de waterdampverl i esmeti ngen werden vergel eken
met de scores berekend van de resu l taten van een sys teem ter eva l uat ie
van de z i chtbare afwi j k i ngen ( ' v i sual scor i n g system ' ) :
Erytheem 1+ , l i chte roodhei d , pl aatsel i j k of d i ffuus ; 2+ , mat i ge
roodhei d ; 3+, i ntense roodhei d ; 4+ , fel l e roodhe i d met
oedeem.
Sch i l feri ng : 1+ , l i chte schi l fer ing ; 2+ , matige schi l feri ng ; 3+ , ern
st i ge sch i l feri ng .
Barstj es 1+ , fi j ne barstjes ; 2+ , een of meerdere d i epere barstjes ;
3+ , w i jdere barstj es met b l oed i ngen of exsudaat .
De twee systemen ter eva l uat i e van het effect van d e geteste v l oe i stof-
fen hadden een hoge correl ati e , hetgeen erop du idt dat de schadel i j ke
werk i n g op de hui d van wasakti eve stoffen voor een groat gedee l te wordt
bepaal d door het effekt van deze stoffen op de hui dbarri ere .
Het doel van de stud i e , bes pro ken i n hoofdstuk 3 , was het meten van de
h u i dbeschad i g i ng met behu l p van waterdampverl i esmetingen door wasakti eve
stoffen i n verschi l l ende eczeemcategori een en control egroepen . H i ervoor
1 50
werd onaangedane h u i d van de vol a i re z i jde van de onderarm b l ootgestel d
a an de vol gende chemi sche stoffen ( 2 g/v% i n gedesti l l eerd water ) :
natri uml auraat an i onogeen ( pH 9 . 2 )
natri umstearaat an i onogeen ( pH 10 . 4 )
natri uml auryl s u l faat ani onogeen ( pH 7 . 3 )
ka l i umzeep* ani onogeen ( pH 10 . 0 )
cocobeta i ne amfoteer ( pH = 5 . 2 )
ceteareth- 12 n i et i onogeen ( pH 6 . 4 )
cocami dopropyl beta i ne amfoteer ( pH 6 . 0 )
pol ysorbaat-60 n i et i onogeen ( pH 3 . 8 )
* ) kal i umzout van cocos - e n wondero l i e .
De groep pati enten met eczeem reageerden i n z i j n geheel s terker op de
testv l oe i s toffen . D i t werd hoofdzakel i j k veroorzaakt door de resu l taten
van de subg roep met const i tut i oneel eczeem . Deze pati enten reageerden
heft i ger op de geteste v l oei s toffen , met name op de syntheti s che deter
genti a ( kunstmati g berei de wasakt i eve s toffen u i t s teenkool of mi nera l e
o l i e ) . D e a l kal i sche zepen ( ca rboxy l aten van d i erl i j ke o f p l antaard i ge
oorsprong ) werden rel ati ef goed verdragen i n deze g roep , hetgeen de
resu l taten van andere stud i es bevesti gen .
I n de subgroep van pati enten met orthoergi sch contact eczeem kon een
hefti ger reacti e ( gemeten met waterdampverl i es ) n i et worden vastgeste ld
i n vergel i j k i ng met de contro l egroepen . Deze bev i nd i ngen s uggereren een
beperkte rol van een consti tutione l e kwetsbaarh e i d voor barri erefuncti e
stoorni ssen in deze g roep pati enten .
I n hoofdstuk 4 wordt een s tud i e besproken , waar i n de effecten van een
a l l ergeen ( n i kkel s u l faat ) i n een concentrati e , d i e normal i ter geen
z i chtbare beschadi g i ng van de hu i d veroorzaakt en dri e chemi sche s tof
fen , d i e in de toegepaste concentrat i e mat i ge ( z i chtbare ) toxi sche
effecten veroorzaken , werden verge l e ken wat betreft de effecten op de
barri erefuncti e van de hui d . De vol gende testvl oei s toffen werden op de
huid van de vol a i re z i jde van de onderarm ( i n gedesti l l eerd water ) ge
pl akt :
1 5 1
n i kkel su l faat 5 g/v% ( pH 5 . 4 )
natr i um lauryl su l faat 5 g/v% ( pH 7 . 3 )
d i methyl su l fox i de 50 g/v% ( pH 7 . 1 )
phenol 5 g/v% ( pH 6 . 2 )
De barri erefuncti es toorn i s sen ( gemeten met waterdampverl i esmethode ) wer-
den oak gerel ateerd aan de macroscopi sch z i chtba re afwi j k i ngen van de
hu i d ( vol gens het ' v i s ual scori ng system ' ) . De hu i d geexponeerd aan
n i k ke l s u l faat werd oak afgel ezen voor a l l ergi sche reacti es vol gens een
gang bare method i e k . De i nv l oed van de ( versch i l l ende ) grader i ngen van
de a l l erg i sche reacti es op het waterdampverl i es werd onderzoch t .
De b l ootstel l i ng a a n de testvl oei stoffen werd verri cht i n een groep pa
t i enten met pos i t i eve l apj es proeven voor n i kkel su l faat en een groep per
sonen zonder hui dzi ekte of ( bekende ) a l l erg i e .
I n het a l gemeen veroorzaakten a l l e testvl oe i stoffen een toename i n wa
terdampverl i es i n vergel i j k i ng met de contro l e ( gedesti l l eerd water ) .
De correl ati e tussen de ernst van het erytheem en de toename van het
waterdampverl i es van de aan de chem i sche s toffen b l ootgestel de hui d va
ri eerde aanz i en l i j k voor de verschi l l ende s toffen .
Al l erg i sche react i es , met name de heft i ge react i es , hadden i n een aantal
geva l l en een aanz i en l i j k effect op het waterdampverl i es van de hu i d .
Er werd geconc l udeerd dat een chemi sche stof de hoorn l aag kan beschad i
gen op versch i l l ende mani eren :
1 ) Di rekt door z i j n fys i cochemi sche ei genschappen ( i nteract i e met hoorn
l aag bestanddel en ) .
2 ) I nd i rekt , na permeat i e van de hoornl aag , door z i j n· effecten ( toxi sch
en/of a l l erg i sch ) op de d i epere l agen van de hu i d . D i t kan secunda i r
tot een def i c i ente hoorn l aagforma t i e l e i den .
Bei de effecten kunnen aan l e i d i ng geven tot verstori ng van de barri ere
functi e van de hui d .
Er werd eveneens geconc l udeerd dat de omvang van d e stoorn i s van de
barri erefuncti e van de hoorn l aag , veroorzaakt door chemi sche stoffen ,
overeen kan komen met de omvang van de z i chtbare ontsteki ngsreact i es
van de d i epere l agen van de hu i d . D i t i s echter n i et a l t i j d het ge
va l , met name n i et i ndi en de effecten eenma l i g worden geeval ueerd ,
1 52
omdat beschad i g i ng en herstel van de hoorn l aag en de di epere l agen van
de hui d een ei gen verl oop in de t i j d kunnen hebben .
I n hoofdstuk 5 worden de resu l taten van een l ongi tudi naal onderzoek naar
het effect van herhaa l de b l ootstel l i ng van de hu i d aan wasakti eve stof
fen op de barri ere voor waterdampverl i es besproken en vergel eken met de
macroscopi sch z i c htbare veranderi ngen ( ' v i sua l scori ng system ' ) .
De vol gende merkprodukten werden getest i n 1 g/v% i n gedesti l l eerd water
op de vol a i re z i j de van de rechterarm :
Zwi tsal babyzeep ( pH
Su l foderm zeep ( pH
Neutrogena zeep ( pH
Lactacyd zeep ( pH
10 . 6 )
5 . 9 )
9 . 8 )
3 . 8 )
Op de vol a i re z i jde van de l i nkera rm werden was akti eve chemi cal i en ge
test in 0 . 5 g/v% in gedes ti l l eerd wa ter :
cocobeta i ne ( pH 5 . 2 )
natri uml auraat
natr i um lauryl s u l faat
pol ysorbaa t-60
( pH
( pH
( pH
9 . 3 )
7 . 3 )
3 . 8 )
De effecten van d e toegepaste l age concentrati es was akti eve stof bl eken
in de groep van geexponeerde vri jwi l l i gers een cumu l a t i ef effect te
hebben op de hu idbarri ere . In het a l gemeen kwam het pa troon van het
waterdampverl i es overeen met het optreden van de macroscopi sch z i cht
bare afwi j k i ngen . Er werd geconcl udeerd dat herhaa l de b l ootstel l i ng aan
l age concentrati e wasakti eve stof kan l ei den tot toename van de door
gankel i j kh e i d en a l s gevol g daarvan het ontstaan van orthoerg i sch eczeem
kan bevorderen .
Andere factoren echter , zoa l s de onvol doende beteugel i ng van het ont
stekingsproces , verstori ng van de homeostas i s i n de d i epere l agen van
de epi dermi s en derm i s en de accumu l at i e van ( endogene ) anti genen en
i rri tanti a in herhaa l del i j k b l ootgeste l de hu i d kunnen ook een rol
s pe l en in het veroorza ken en onderhouden van het orthoerg i sch contact
eczeem .
I n hoofdstuk 6 werd de methode van de waterdampverl i esmeti ngen toegepast
1 53
om het subkl i n i sche effect van l age concentrati es van chemi sche stoffen ,
i n hogere concentrati es s terk i rri terend voor de hu i d , te eva l ueren .
De vol gende chemi sche s toffen werden op n i e t-aangedane hu id van de vo
l a i re z i jde van de onderarmen i n een groep van dermatol ogi sche pati enten
getes t ( g/v% in gedesti l l eerd water ) :
natri uml aury l su l faat 2 g/v%
cocobetai ne 2 g/v%
crotonal dehyde 0 . 7 5 g/v% en natri uml aury l s u l faat
0 . 5 g/v%
d imethyl s u l fox i de 50 g/v%
phenol 5 g/v%
natri umhydroxi de 1 g/v%
benza l kon i umch l ori de 0 . 2 g/v%
gedes ti l l eerd water
( pH =
( pH =
( pH
( pH
( pH :: ( pH
( pH =
( pH =
7 . 3 )
5 . 2 )
4 . 8 )
7 . 1 )
6 . 2 )
1 2 . 7 )
6 . 6 )
6 . 5 )
De testopl oss i ngen veroorzaa kten a l l een l i c hte macroscopi sch z i chtbare
afwi j ki ngen van de hu i d . De wasakti eve s toffen ( natri uml auryl su l faat ,
cocobeta i n e en de comb i nati e van crotona l dehyde met natri uml aury l su l
faat ) , beha l ve benza l kon i umch l ori de , veroorzaakten een s i gn i fi cante toe
name i n vergel i j k i ng met n i et b l ootges tel de hui d . OMSO en NaOH veroor
zaa kten eveneens een s i g n i fi cante toename van het waterdampverl i es .
Phenol 5% beinvl oedde de barri erefuncti e van de hu id voor het water
dampverl i es n i et .
Er werd geconc l udeerd dat de i rri tanti a i n l age concentrati es een
subk l i n i sc h effect kunnen hebben op de barri erefuncti e van de hu i d ,
hoewel n i et a l l e i rr i tantia dat effect vertonen .
I n hoofdstuk 7 werd het effect van 13 commerci ee l verkr i jgbare s tu kjes
zeep op de waterbarri ere van de huid bestudeerd . De vol gende produ kten
werden getest i n een groep gezonde vri jwi l l i gers op de vol a i re z i j de
van de onderarm :
Aveenoderm ( pH 5 . 4 ) Neutrogena ( pH = 9 . 8 )
C i da l ( pH 10 . 6 ) Pa l mo l i ve ( pH = 10 . 6 )
Johnson ' s babyzeep ( pH 1 0 . 7 ) Sebamed ( pH = 5 . 5 )
Lactacyd ( pH :: 3 . 8 ) Sebapona ( pH = 6 . 7 )
Lux ( pH 9 . 7 ) S porex ( pH = 10 . 6 )
1 54
Sul foderm
Uni cura
( pH 5 . 6 )
( pH 10 . 6 )
Zwi tsa l babyzeep { pH 10 . 6 )
Al l e produ kten veroorzaa kten een s i gn i fi cante toename van het waterdamp
verl i es i n vergel i j k i ng met gedes ti l l eerd water . Synthet i s che zepen ,
gebaseerd op a l ky l su l faten , hadden een rel a t i ef groter effect op de
hu i dbarri �re dan de andere produkten . In het g eheel wa ren de gemi dde l de
verschi l l en echter ger i ng en mees ta l n i et-s i g n i fi cant . Er werd gecon c l u
deerd dat versch i l l en i n ' hu i dtype ' waarsch i j n l i j k eveneens bepal en wel k
produkt het best door de hu id wordt verdragen .
De aan z i en l i j ke spre i d i n g zoa l s waargenomen i n de resul taten van de wa
terdampverl i esmeti ngen i n de bes proken s tudi es bemoe i l i j ken een j u i s te
i nterpretat i e . Voor een gedeel te kan deze spre i d i ng worden verkl aard
door de i nv l oed van s torende factoren zoa l s b . v . zweten .
De i nv l oed van deze storende vari a bel en (wi l l ekeuri ge sprei d i ng i s aan
n emel i j k ) kon worden beperkt door gemi ddel de scores te vergel i j ken .
De beschad i g i ng van de hu idba rri �re b i j een i nd i v i du kon echter n i et be
trouwbaa r worden bepaa l d . Gegevens over i nd i v i duel e gevoel i ghei d voor
beschad i g i ng van de hu i dbarri ere kunnen waarsch i j n l i j k a l l een worden ver
kregen i nd i en de i nv l oed van de (wi l l ekeuri ge ) spre i d i ng meer wordt be
perkt .
155
EXTERNAL. (EJIMRON�ENTAL)
Sll�UU
ALTDtED HOWEOSTASIS ! ('SKIN F'ATIOUE')
l ���UNE RESPONSE
l HORNY LAYER BMRIER
� FUNCTlON OISRIRBANCE
l T AUERGIC (CHRONIC OR ACUTE)
CYTOTOXIC EFTECTS CONTACT OERWAnns
UPON THE VIABLE AO.t.PTATlON AND
LAYERS OF' THE SKIN fE- � IRRITANT (CHRONIC OR ACliTE) ftEGENEPtAT10N
! i CONTACT 0£RMAnns
CONST1RIT10NAL. F'ACTORS
INfl....I.MMAlORY
t.fEDIA.TOitS
I AC11VAnDN Of" lOCAU.Y
PERSISTENT INfl....I.MWATORY crus
ACTlVAOON OF' INfl....I.MMATORY
Crus AND/OR HUMORAL F'ACTORS
Hypothet i ca l d i agram of the pathogenes i s of horny l ayer impai rment
and the rol e of barrier functi on d i sturbance i n the et i o l ogy of
i rri tant and a l l erg i c contact dermat i t i s .
1 56
Dankwoord/Acknowl edgement
Voor de hu l p , d i e i k heb verkregen bij het tot stand brengen van d i t
proefschri ft ben i k d e vol gende personen b i j zonder dankbaar :
- Dr . J . P . Nater , d i e het m i j mogel i j k maakte en m i j stimul eerde om het
onderzoek te verr i chten en onder wi ens d i rekte begel e id i ng de u i t
voer i ng en het op schri ft stel l en p l aatsvond .
- Prof . D r . E . B l eumi n k , d i e m i j waardevol l e opmerki ngen verschafte om
trent opzet , u i tvoer i ng en het op schr ift stel l en van d i t proefs chri ft .
- Prof . Dr . A . H . Kl okke , i n wi ens k l i n i e k het onderzoek pl aats kon v i n
den .
Dr . P . J . Coenraads , d i e m i j i nwijdde op het gebi ed van de s tat i s t i ek
en computerprogrammatuur en met wi e i k zeer vruchtbare d i scuss i es had
omtrent opzet en u i tvoer i ng van het onderzoek .
- Mevr . A . Datema , d i e met veel i nzet het typewerk verzorgde .
- Dhr . A . J . Kl oosterhu i s , d i e het tekenwerk verzorgde en dhr . D . C . D i j k ,
d i e de foto ' s vervaard i gde .
- Mev r . T . Woes t , d i e hu l p verl eende b i j het onderzoek en
Dr. M . C . J . M . de Jong , d i e theoreti sche ondersteu n i ng verl eende .
- De col l egae Drs . M . C . Cri j ns , Drs . M . H . Kru i s -de Vri es en
dhr . B. Boorsma , d i e ass i s teerden b i j het onderzoek .
- Drs . V . F i d l er , d i e waardevol l e advi ezen verstrekte met betrekki ng tot
de toegepaste s tati s t i e k .
- Dr . A . C . Ford , P h D , who rev i ewed the engl i s h .
- Al l e proefpersonen , d i e z i ch beschi kbaar s te l den voor het onderzoek .
- Col l ega Drs . H . Lanti nga , met wi e i k pretti g h e b samengewerkt .
- Joke en Thi j s .
1 5 7
Recommended