View
246
Download
0
Category
Preview:
DESCRIPTION
Use Case 2: CDS Guidance Service Transactions - Standards per Transaction #TransactionServiceOrganizer/ContainerItem Payloads Reference Information Model 1 CDS Request (patient data and potentially context) Decision Support Service (DSS) Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton) CDS Knowledge Artifact Implementation Guide (HeD UC1 IG) Consolidated CDA Virtual Medical Record (vMR) Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton) Virtual Medical Record (vMR) Consolidated CDA (hL7 Clinical Statements) HL7 Version 3 Standard: Order Set Publication, Release 1 Federal Health Information Model (FHIM) HL7 v2.x HL7 v3 2 CDS Response (guidance and/or other response elements) Decision Support Service (DSS) Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton) CDS Knowledge Artifact Implementation Guide (HeD UC1 IG) HL7 Version 3 Standard: Order Set Publication, Release 1 Consolidated CDA Virtual Medical Record (vMR) Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton) Virtual Medical Record (vMR) Consolidated CDA (HL7 Clinical Statements) HL7 Version 3 Standard: Order Set Publication, Release 1 Federal Health Information Model (FHIM) HL7 v2.x HL7 v3
Citation preview
Use Case 2 – CDS Guidance Service Transactions
CDS Guidance Requestor
2. CDS Response(Clinical Data, Supporting Evidence, Supporting
Reference, Actions, Attribute-Value List, Response Metadata & Exceptions)
CDS Guidance Supplier
1. CDS Request (Clinical Data & Context)
INSERT SELECTED STANDARDS HERE
INSERT SELECTED STANDARDS HERE
Transport and Security
Transactional Layers
2
Transport and SecurityResponse Service: e.g., DSS Response ElementResponse Items Organizer/Container: e.g., HeD Action Groups Element
Response Item Payload: e.g., VMR Proposal
Request Service: e.g., DSS Request ElementRequest Items Organizer/Container: e.g: VMR or CCDA
Request Item Payload: e.g., VMR Clinical Statement
Use Case 2: CDS Guidance Service Transactions - Standards per Transaction
# Transaction Service Organizer/Container Item PayloadsReference
Information Model
1CDS Request (patient data
and potentially context)
• Decision Support Service (DSS)
• Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton)
• CDS Knowledge Artifact Implementation Guide (HeD UC1 IG)
• Consolidated CDA• Virtual Medical Record
(vMR)
• Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton)
• Virtual Medical Record (vMR)• Consolidated CDA (hL7 Clinical
Statements)• HL7 Version 3 Standard: Order Set
Publication, Release 1
• Federal Health Information Model (FHIM)
• HL7 v2.x• HL7 v3
2 CDS Response (guidance
and/or other response elements)
• Decision Support Service (DSS)
• Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton)
• CDS Knowledge Artifact Implementation Guide (HeD UC1 IG)
• HL7 Version 3 Standard: Order Set Publication, Release 1
• Consolidated CDA• Virtual Medical Record
(vMR)
• Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton)
• Virtual Medical Record (vMR)• Consolidated CDA (HL7 Clinical
Statements)• HL7 Version 3 Standard: Order Set
Publication, Release 1
• Federal Health Information Model (FHIM)
• HL7 v2.x • HL7 v3
Use Case 2: CDS Guidance Service Transactions - Standards per Transaction
# Transaction Transport Authentication/Authorization Encryption Vocab & Code Set
1CDS Request (patient data
and potentially context)
• SOAP• REST
• SAML • TLS • LOINC• SNOMED CT• CVX• Manufacturers of Vaccines (MVX)• OID• RxNorm• ICD-9-CM and ICD-10-CM• HCPCS• C80 - Clinical Document and
Message Terminology Component • NQF Value Sets
• ICD-10-PCS• UCUM• CPT• C154• NDC• FDA Route Administration• HL7 Vocabulary• Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV)
2 CDS Response (guidance
and/or other response elements)
• SOAP • REST
• SAML • TLS • LOINC• SNOMED CT• CVX• Manufacturers of Vaccines (MVX)• OID• RxNorm• ICD-9-CM and ICD-10-CM• HCPCS• C80 - Clinical Document and
Message Terminology Component • NQF Value Sets
• ICD-10-PCS• UCUM• CPT• C154• NDC• FDA Route Administration• HL7 Vocabulary• Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV)
CDS Guidance Request Transaction: Service Standards RationaleStandard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
Decision Support Service (DSS)HITSC Rating:*M: 78.69A: 88.6SI: 33.33T: 72.71
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits: Response Metadata;
(N) Does not Fit:
Yes • One significant gap is DSS will tie to SOAP. There is significant industry movement towards REST.
• DSS has 2 levels, one is model of the service which is implementation agnostic. Could support standard with implementation based on REST, but it would have to be developed.
• DSS is designed to be able to support patient data, unlike Infobutton.
• Has broader scope than Infobutton
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton)
HITSC Rating*M: 90.08A: 92.11SI: 47.62T: 82.07
(Y) Fits: Context; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource
(P) Partially Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response
(N) Does not Fit: Clinical; Actions; Attribute Value List; Response Meta Data
No
• Can send some patient data, but not designed to support rich patient data payload like DSS
CDS Guidance Response Transaction: Service Standards RationaleStandard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
Decision Support Service (DSS)HITSC Rating:*M: 78.69A: 88.6SI: 33.33T: 72.71
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits: Response Metadata;
(N) Does not Fit:
Yes • One significant gap is DSS will tie to SOAP. There is significant industry movement towards REST.
• DSS has 2 levels, one is model of the service which is implementation agnostic. Could support standard with implementation based on REST, but it would have to be developed.
• DSS is designed to be able to support patient data, unlike Infobutton.
• Has broader scope than Infobutton
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton)
HITSC Rating:*M: 90.08A: 92.11SI: 47.62T: 82.07
(Y) Fits: Context; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource
(P) Partially Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response
(N) Does not Fit: Clinical; Actions; Attribute Value List; Response Meta Data
No
• Can send some patient data, but no designed to support rich patient data payload like DSS
CDS Guidance Request Transaction: Organizer/Container RationaleStandard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
CDS Knowledge Artifact Implementation Guide (HeD UC1 IG)HITSC Rating:*M: 61.39A: 86.84SI: 35.71T: 64.62
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Clinical; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions; Attribute Value List;
(P) Partially Fits: Context; Response Metadata
(N) Does not Fit: Exceptions
No • UC1 is not designed to carry patient data
• If CCDA is chosen, would probably have to use related HL7 Clinical statements for the Item Payload bucket.
• If vMR is chosen, would probably have to use the vMR Clinical Statements for the Item Payload bucket
• External options may exist for transforming CCDA request into a vMR component
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
Consolidated CDAHITSC Rating:*M: 53.59A: 80.70SI: 33.33T: 58.48
(Y) Fits: Clinical;
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit: Context, Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions; Attribute Value List; Response Metadata; Exceptions
Yes • Can transform CCDA request into a vMR component from the execution system
• Not everything from CCDA goes easily into vMR, but vMR is designed to easily accept CCDA components
CDS Guidance Request Transaction: Organizer/Container Rationale (continued…)Standard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
Virtual Medical Record (vMR)HITSC Rating:*M: 78.06A: 81.58SI: 33.33T: 70.08
(Y) Fits: Clinical; Attribute Value List
(P) Partially Fits: CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Context; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions;
(N) Does not Fit: Response Metadata; Exceptions
Yes • Lighter weight than the other options• Developed specifically for clinical decision
support computability• Intended to be used for this initiative, and
has recently been enhanced in this respect
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
CDS Guidance Response Transaction: Organizer/Container RationaleStandard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
CDS Knowledge Artifact Implementation Guide (HeD UC1 IG)HITSC Rating:*M: 61.39A: 86.84SI: 35.71T: 64.62
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Clinical; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions; Attribute Value List;
(P) Partially Fits: Context; Response Metadata
(N) Does not Fit: Exceptions
Yes • Fits Clinical; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions data requirements
• Attribute value list is not supported in UC1 schema, however the schema does allow extensions using XSD
• Would use subset of HeD UC1 schema that may require further modifications
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
Consolidated CDAHITSC Rating:*M: 53.59A: 80.70SI: 33.33T: 58.48
(Y) Fits: Clinical;
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit: Context, Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions; Attribute Value List; Response Metadata; Exceptions
No • There is a profile in IHE that uses DSS and returns IHE as an output. But hasn’t been finalized within IHE
• Lacks the ability to group and organize things the way that UC1 does
CDS Guidance Response Transaction: Organizer/Container Rationale (continued…)
StandardSummary of
Findings from UCR Crosswalk
Keep? Rationale
Virtual Medical Record (vMR)HITSC Rating:*M: 78.06A: 81.58SI: 33.33T: 70.08
(Y) Fits: Clinical; Attribute Value List
(P) Partially Fits: CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Context; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions;
(N) Does not Fit: Response Metadata; Exceptions
No • Does fit this situation, however CDS Knowledge artifact may be the better option
• UC1 action would need to be modified to represent payload for UC2 regarding vMR
• May need a model agnostic response
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
HL7 Version 3 Standard: Order Set Publication, Release 1HITSC Rating:*M: 46.20A: 75.44SI: 33.33T: 53.31
(Y) Fits: Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Response Metadata
(P) Partially Fits: Clinical; Context; Actions
(N) Does not Fit: Attribute Value List; Exceptions
No • Some vendors may want to support this as an option, however CDS Knowledge Artifact is the better option
• Adoption of this standard is low, so there is not a driving reason to extend support to it
CDS Guidance Request Transaction: Item Payloads Rationale Standard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton)HITSC RatingM: 90.08A: 92.11SI: 47.62T: 82.07
(Y) Fits: Context; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource
(P) Partially Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response
(N) Does not Fit: Clinical; Actions; Attribute Value List; Response Meta Data
No
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
Virtual Medical Record (vMR)HITSC Rating:*M: 78.06A: 81.58SI: 33.33T: 70.08
(Y) Fits: Clinical; Attribute Value List
(P) Partially Fits: CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Context; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions;
(N) Does not Fit: Response Metadata; Exceptions
Yes
CDS Guidance Request Transaction: Item Payloads Rationale (Continued…)Standard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
Consolidated CDAHITSC Rating:*M: 53.59A: 80.70SI: 33.33T: 58.48
(Y) Fits: Clinical;
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit: Context, Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions; Attribute Value List; Response Metadata; Exceptions
Yes
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
HL7 Version 3 Standard: Order Set Publication, Release 1HITSC Rating:*M: 46.20A: 75.44SI: 33.33T: 53.31
(Y) Fits: Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Response Metadata
(P) Partially Fits: Clinical; Context; Actions
(N) Does not Fit: Attribute Value List; Exceptions
No
CDS Guidance Response Transaction: Item Payloads Rationale Standard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
Context Aware Retrieval Application (Infobutton)
HITSC Rating:*M: 90.08A: 92.11SI: 47.62T: 82.07
(Y) Fits: Context; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource
(P) Partially Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response
(N) Does not Fit: Clinical; Actions; Attribute Value List; Response Meta Data
No
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
Virtual Medical Record (vMR)HITSC Rating:*M: 78.06A: 81.58SI: 33.33T: 70.08
(Y) Fits: Clinical; Attribute Value List
(P) Partially Fits: CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Context; Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions;
(N) Does not Fit: Response Metadata; Exceptions
Yes
CDS Guidance Response Transaction: Item Payloads Rationale (Continued…)Standard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
Consolidated CDA
HITSC Rating:*M: 53.59A: 80.70SI: 33.33T: 58.48
(Y) Fits: Clinical;
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit: Context, Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Actions; Attribute Value List; Response Metadata; Exceptions
Yes
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
HL7 Version 3 Standard: Order Set Publication, Release 1HITSC Rating:*M: 46.20A: 75.44SI: 33.33T: 53.31
(Y) Fits: Supporting Evidence; Supporting Resource; Response Metadata
(P) Partially Fits: Clinical; Context; Actions
(N) Does not Fit: Attribute Value List; Exceptions
Yes
CDS Guidance Request Transaction: Transport RationaleStandard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
SOAP
HITSC Rating:*M: 100.00A: 100.00SI: 100.00T: 100.00
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit:
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
RESTHITSC Rating:*M: 100.00A: 100.00SI: 42.86T: 88.30
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit:
CDS Guidance Response Transaction: Transport RationaleStandard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
SOAP
HITSC Rating:*M: 100.00A: 100.00SI: 100.00T: 100.00
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit:
* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
RESTHITSC Rating:M: 100.00A: 100.00SI: 42.86T: 88.30
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit:
CDS Guidance Request Transaction: Authentication/Authorization RationaleStandard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
SAMLHITSC Rating:*M: 100.00A: 100.00SI: 100.00T: 100.00
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit:* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
CDS Guidance Response Transaction: Authentication/Authorization RationaleStandard
Summary of Findings from UCR
CrosswalkKeep? Rationale
SAMLHITSC Rating:*M: 100.00A: 100.00SI: 100.00T: 100.00
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit:* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
CDS Guidance Request Transaction: Encryption
StandardSummary of
Findings from UCR Crosswalk
Keep? Rationale
TLSHITSC Rating:*M: 100.00A: 100.00SI: 42.86T: 88.30
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit:* M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
CDS Guidance Response Transaction: Encryption
StandardSummary of
Findings from UCR Crosswalk
Keep? Rationale
TLSHITSC Rating:*M: 100.00A: 100.00SI: 42.86T: 88.30
(Y) Fits: (Sender) CDS Request; (Receiver) CDS Request; (Sender) CDS Response; (Receiver) CDS Response; Exceptions
(P) Partially Fits:
(N) Does not Fit: * M: Maturity A: Adoptability SI: S&I Specific T: Total
Recommended