Valsalva retinopathy in the third trimester of pregnancy · troisième trimestre de sa grossesse,...

VOL 75 | NO 4 2013C A N A D I A N J O U R N A L O F O P T O M E T R Y | R E V U E C A N A D I E N N E D ’ O P T O M É T R I E 47

!

MD, a 24-year old female of African descent in her third trimester of pregnancy, presented upon referral from her family physician with an 18-hour history of dark !oating spot in her left eye. Her history was signi"cant for violent vomiting immediately preceding the onset of visual symptoms. General and ocular health history was otherwise unremarkable. Clinical examination showed central vitreous hemorrhaging in the absence of any other ophthalmic anomaly, consistent with a diagnosis of Valsalva retinopathy. Over the subsequent several months, which included the uncomplicated birth of her healthy child, the hemorrhaging resolved without sequelae.

Keywords: Valsalva maneuver, Valsalva retinopathy, hyaloidotomy, Terson’s syndrome, Purtscher retinopathy

MD, femme de 24 ans de descendance africaine qui en est au troisième trimestre de sa grossesse, se présente recommandée par son médecin de famille en se plaignant d’avoir un point !ottant noir depuis 18 heures dans l’œil gauche. Comme antécédents importants, elle a vomi violemment juste avant l’apparition des symptômes visuels. Ses antécédents relatifs à la santé générale et oculovisuelle ne présentent autrement rien de remarquable. L’examen clinique révèle une hémorragie au centre du vitré et aucune autre anomalie ophtalmique, ce qui concorde avec un diagnostic de rétinopathie de Valsalva. Au cours des mois qui suivent, qui ont inclus la naissance sans complication de son enfant en bonne santé, l’hémorragie s’est résorbée sans laisser de séquelles.

Mots clés : Manœuvre de Valsalva, rétinopathie de Valsalva, hyaloïdotomie, syndrome de Terson, rétinopathie de Purtscher

CLINICAL STUDY

Valsalva retinopathy in the third trimester of pregnancy

BY DEREK MACDONALD, OD, FAAO

Case Details

!"#$%$&'()*%+$,-.$/*0%-*$,/ $1/+23%4$.*53*46#$7+*5*46*.$

87,4$8+9*46$+*/*++%-$/+,0$:*+$/%02-)$7:)5232%4$;26:$%4$<=(:,8+$

24$:*+$-*/6$*)*$4,6$%33,07%42*.$>)$7%24$,+$7:,6,752%?$1$@%98*$,332726%-$:*%.%3:*$;%5$+*7,+6*.?$A:*+*$;%5$4,$:256,+)$,/ $6+%80%?$B*+$9*4*+%-$:*%-6:$;%5$9,,.#$%4.$4,$5)56*023$0*.23%62,45$;*+*$>*249$6%C*4?$B,;*@*+#$!"$;%5$24$:*+$6:2+.$$6+20*56*+$,/ $7+*94%43)#$%4.$+*7,+6*.$%4$*725,.*$,/ $@2,-*46$@,026249$200*.2%6*-)$7+*3*.249$$6:*$,45*6$,/ $5)076,05?D46*+249$84%2.*.$@258%-$%38262*5$

;*+*$EFG?HI$24$6:*$+29:6#$EFG?H($24$6:*$-*/6?$J38-%+$0,62-26)$;%5$/8--?$$$

(

24$>,6:$+29:6$%4.$-*/6?$K872-$+*%3(62,45$;*+*$4,+0%-$;26:$4,$%//*+*46$.*/*36?$146*+2,+$5*90*46$*@%-8%(62,4$;%5$84+*0%+C%>-*L$6:*+*$;%5$4,$4*,@%538-%+2M%62,4?$N46+%,38-%+$7+*558+*5$;*+*$<&$%4.$<O#$+29:6$%4.$-*/6$+*57*362@*-)#$%6$<PQPP$%?0?"2-%6*.$+*624%-$*R%024%62,4$,/ $

6:*$7,-*$%4.$7*+27:*+)$S85249$$

0)$56%4.%+.$7+,6,3,-$,/ $P?HT$6+,723%02.*$/,--,;*.$>)$EP$5*3,4.5$,/ $9*46-*$*)*-2.$3-,58+*U$;%5$84+*(0%+C%>-*$24$6:*$+29:6$*)*$S!"#$%&'(U?$N4$6:*$-*/6#$%$7+*.,024%46-)$24/*+2,+(3*46+%-$@26+*,85$:*0,++:%9*$SVBU$;26:$5*@*+%-$587*+2,+$W56+*%0*+5X$;%5$4,6*.$S!"#$%&')U?$A:*+*$;%5$4,$,>@2,85$4*,@%538-%+$7+,3*55#$,+$0%38-%+$,+$7*+27:*+%-$+*624%-$%4,0%-)?

ABSTRACT | RÉSUMÉ

Figure 1*'+&,-.+/'012.&%"1%'01-&3'%"#+.'&/&Figure 2 *'4,-2,-5,'%&."610,.+/3'-&7.'&/&

C A N A D I A N J O U R N A L O F O P T O M E T R Y | R E V U E C A N A D I E N N E D ’ O P T O M É T R I EVOL 75 | NO 4 201348

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

4,6*.$%$50%--*+$0,+*$7*+27:*+%-$57,6$24$6:*$-*/6$*)*$4,6$%33,07%(42*.$>)$7%24$,+$7:,6,752%?$[4%2.*.$%38262*5$;*+*$EFE$24$6:*$+29:6#$EFE($24$6:*$-*/6?$\,4/+,46%62,4$@258%-$

%//*+*46$.*/*36?"2-%6*.$+*624%-$*R%024%62,4$

6:*$VB#$;26:$5,0*$W9+*)249X$,/ $6:*$+*0%24249$>-,,.$S!"#$%&'8U?$A:*$0%38-%$%4.$7*+27:*+%-$+*624%$+*0%24*.$84+*0%+C%>-*?15$6:*$7%62*46$;%5$%77+,%3:249$

:*+$.8*$.%6*#$/8+6:*+$/,--,;(87$;%5$53:*.8-*.$/,+$6:+**$0,46:5#$%4.$%4$87.%6*$;%5$/,+;%+.*.$6,$6:*$/%02-)$7:)5232%4?],8+$0,46:5$/,--,;249$6:*$

,45*6$,/ $:*+$5)076,05#$!"$

24$6:*$-*/6$*)*?$Z,$*R%3*+>%62,4$,/ $:*+$5)076,05$:%.$,338++*.$.8+249$6:*$843,07-23%6*.$@%924%-$>2+6:$,/ $:*+$:*%-6:)$3:2-.$^$;**C5$*%+-2*+?$[4%2.*.$%38262*5$+*0%24*.$EFE$24$6:*$+29:6#$EFE($24$6:*$-*/6?$

(

+*0%24*.$4,+0%-$;26:$4,$%//*+*46$.*/*36?"2-%6*.$+*624%-$*R%024%62,4$

+*@*%-*.$*55*462%--)$3,07-*6*$+*5,(-862,4$,/ $6:*$VB$24$6:*$-*/6$*)*$S!"#$%&'9U?$A:*$0%38-%$%4.$7*+27:(*+%-$+*624%$+*0%24*.$84+*0%+C%>-*?$14$87.%6*$;%5$/,+;%+.*.$6,$6:*$/%02-)$7:)5232%4?A:2+6**4$0,46:5$/,--,;249$,45*6$

,/ $:*+$5)076,05#$!"$4,6*.$4,$

*26:*+$*)*#$>86$5-29:6$4*%+$56+%24$%4.$,33%52,4%-$:*%.%3:*?$_*56(3,++*36*.$%38262*5$;*+*$EFE$24$>,6:$+29:6$%4.$-*/6$SJ?"?$I<?&H(P?&H`<=PL$J?a?$I<?PP(P?&H`<=PU?$_24,38-%+$

4*%+$*R,7:,+2%?$!,62-26)$;%5$/8--?$(

+*0%24*.$4,+0%-$;26:$4,$%//*+*46$.*/*36?$146*+2,+$5*90*46$*R%024%(62,4$;%5$84+*0%+C%>-*?$N46+%,38-%+$7+*558+*5$;*+*$<<$%4.$<O#$+29:6$%4.$-*/6$+*57*362@*-)#$%6$'Q'P$7?0?"2-%6*.$+*624%-$*R%024%62,4$

+*@*%-*.$4,$%4,0%-2*5$,/ $6:*$$7,-*$,+$7*+27:*+)$,/ $6:*$+29:6$*)*$S!"#$%&':U?$A:*$-*/6$7,-*$%4.$7*+27:(*+%-$+*624%$;*+*$84+*0%+C%>-*#$;:2-*$6:*$24/*+2,+$@26+*,85$5:,;*.$6+%3*$:%M249$3,45256*46$;26:$+*5,+>*.$VB$S!"#$%&';U?1448%-$3,07+*:*452@*$*R%024%(

62,45$;*+*$+*3,00*4.*.?

Figure 3'*'.<1'<&&=2'012.>0%&2&6.,."163'4,-2,-5,'%&."610,.+/3'-&7.'&/&

Figure 4'*'71$%'?16.+2'012.>0%&2&6.,."163'4,-2,-5,'%&."610,.+/3'-&7.'&/&

Figure 6'*'(8'?16.+2'012.>0%&2&6.,."163'4,-2,-5,'%&."610,.+/3'-&7.'&/&Figure 5'*'+&,-.+/'012.&%"1%'01-&3'%"#+.'&/&

VOL 75 | NO 4 2013C A N A D I A N J O U R N A L O F O P T O M E T R Y | R E V U E C A N A D I E N N E D ’ O P T O M É T R I E 49

DiscussionA:*$V%-5%-@%$0%4*8@*+#$4%0*.$

24@*5629%6*.$26$24$6:*$<G6:$3*468+)#$25$

%9%2456$%$3-,5*.$9-,6625$3%85249$%$

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b807(

%0,49$%$:,56$,/ $246*+*56249$%4.$.2@*+5*$3%85*5?H(<^

B*0,++:%9*5$3%4$>*$842-%6*+%-$,+$>2-%6*+%-#$5249-*$,+$08-627-*#$,/ $@%+)249$5:%7*#$%4.$24$%$480>*+$,/ $,38-%+$56+8368+*5#$243-8.249$6:*$7*+2,38-%+$5C24#$58>3,4b84362@%-$%4.$587+%3:,+,2.%-$57%3*5#$%4.$7*+2/,@*%-$+*624%?&P(&&$A:*$7+*325*$-,3%62,4$,/ $%$+*624%-$:*0,++:%9*$S58>(246*+4%-$-2026249$0*0>+%4*$SNc!U$@*+585$58>:)%-,2.U$3%4$>*$

,7:6:%-0,53,7)#$%-6:,89:$58>(Nc!$:*0,++:%9*5$6*4.$6,$>*$0,+*$200,>2-*?$N4$6:*$7+*5*43*$,/ $%$7,56*+2,+$@26+*,85$.*6%3:0*46$SKV"U#$6:*$24262%-$:*0,++:%9*$6)72(3%--)$,33872*5$6:*$58>(Nc!$57%3*#$92@*4$6:%6$6:*+*$25$4,$%66%3:*.$

>-,,.?$B*0,++:%9249$24262%--)$,3387)249$6:*$58>(Nc!$57%3*$0%)$7%55$6:+,89:$Nc!$>+*%3:*5$246,$6:*$58>:)%-,2.$57%3*#$%4.$58>(5*d8*46-)$6:+,89:$6:*$7,56*+2,+$:)%-,2.$/%3*$6,$24@,-@*$6:*$@26+*,85$265*-/?&O(&H

%492,9+%7:)$SNV]1U$;2--$5:,;$

6:*$:*0,++:%9*?$J7623%-$3,:*+*43*$6,0,9+%7:)$SJ\AU$%--,;5$0,+*$7+*325*$-,3%-2M%62,4$,/ $246+%,38-%+$:*0,++:%9249#$%4.$:%5$+*@*%-*.$6:*$7,6*462%-$/,+$7+*+*624%-$0*0>+%4*$SKe!U$/,+0%62,4?$Ke!$%+*$:256,(-,923%--)$5202-%+$6,$6:*$9-2%-$62558*$,/ $*72+*624%-$0*0>+%4*5$SDe!U#$>86$3,46%24$>-,,.$.*9+%.%62,4$7+,.8365$%4.$%+*$4,6$%.:*+*46$6,$6:*$84.*+-)(249$+*624%-$58+/%3*?&E

a)076,05$.*7*4.$87,4$>,6:$6:*$5*@*+26)$%4.$-,3%62,4$,/ $6:*$:*0(,++:%9249?$f:*4$6:*$@258%-$%R25$25$

207%2+*.?&G$Y2@*4$6:%6$50%--$*R6+%/,(@*%-$:*0,++:%9*5$0%)$>*$02420%--)$5)076,0%623#$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$25$-2C*-)$84.*+(+*7,+6*.?$],+684%6*-)#$0,56$3%5*5$+*5,-@*$57,46%4*,85-)$,@*+$5*@*+%-$;**C5$6,$0,46:5$,/ $,>5*+@%(62,4#$;26:$@252,4$,/6*4$207+,@249$6,$4,+0%-$,+$4*%+$4,+0%-#$%5$;%5$6:*$3%5*$;26:$7%62*46$!"?K*+0%4*46$@258%-$207%2+0*46$

0%)$+*58-6$/+,0$0%38-%+$7290*4(

Ke!$/,+0%62,4#$,+$6,R23$+*624%-$.%0%9*$5*3,4.%+)$6,$7+,-,49*.$*R7,58+*$6,$>-,,.#$:*0,9-,>24#$%4.F,+$2+,4#$24$243+*%5249$,+.*+$,/ $6,R2326)?&=#&^$c%+9*$58>(Nc!$,+$58>:)%-,2.$:*0,++:%9*5$4,6$+*5,-@249$57,46%4*,85-)$0%)$>*$*@%38%6*.$246,$6:*$@26+*,85$57%3*$>)$7*+/,+0249$%$7,56*+2,+$@26+*,85$:)%-,2.,6,0)$85249$6:*$Z.Qg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c!$;+24C-249#$%4.$De!$/,+0%62,4?OE$N6$25#$:,;*@*+#$-*55$24@%52@*$6:%4$@26+*36,0)#$%4.$9+*%6-)$+*.83*5$6:*$+25C$,/ $7,6*462%--)$.*@%56%6249$24/*3(62,85$3,07-23%62,45?$a8>5*d8*46-)$,+$%-6*+4%62@*-)#$@26+*36,0)$0%)$562--$>*$4*3*55%+)$24$3%5*5$,/ $5*@*+*$,+$5-,;-)$+*5,-@249$@26+*,85$:*0,+(+:%9*$SVBU?$],--,;249$@26+*36,0)#$+*52.8%-$58>(Nc!$:*0,++:%9*$0%)$>*$+*-*%5*.$6:+,89:$Nc!$7**-#$,+$-%5*+$0*0>+%4,6,0)?OG$a8>5*d8*46$:256,-,923%-$*@%-8%62,4$:%5$5:,;4$*R325*.$Nc!$6,$>*$3,4@,-86*.$%4.$%4,0%-,85#$3,46%24249$%6)723%-$3*-(-8-%+$%4.$>-,,.$.*9+%.%62,4$3,07,(

W7+,-2/*+%62@*$@26+*,+*624,7%6:)(-2C*X$

C A N A D I A N J O U R N A L O F O P T O M E T R Y | R E V U E C A N A D I E N N E D ’ O P T O M É T R I EVOL 75 | NO 4 201350

.%0%9*$0%)$>*$+*57,452>-*$/,+$5,0*$3%5*5$,/ $7,,+$7,56(*@*46$@252,4#$5877,+6249$*%+-2*+$%4.$0,+*$%99+*552@*$246*+@*462,4?

%5$%$7+*.257,5249$/%36,+$24$6:*$.*@*-,70*46$,/ $V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%(6:)?O=#O^$K+*94%43)(24.83*.$:,+(0,4%-#$20084,-,923#$0*6%>,-23#$%4.$:*0%6,-,923$3:%49*5$243-8.249$6:+,0>,3)6,7*42%$3%4$243+*%5*$6:*$-2C*-2:,,.$,/ $>,6:$V%-5%-@%$0%4*8@*+$%4.$+*624,7%6:)?$\,4562(7%62,4$%4.$4%85*%#$C4,;4$6+299*+5$,/ $V%-5%-@%$0%4*8@*+#$/+*d8*46-)$%33,07%4)$7+*94%43)?$D-*@%62,4$,/ $246+%(%>.,024%-$7+*558+*$5*3,4.%+)$

(3%46-)$243+*%5*$W>%5*-24*X$246+%@*4,85$7+*558+*#$*R%3*+>%6249$%4)$/8+6:*+$243+*%5*$,338++249$.8+249$-%>,+$%4.$.*-2@*+)?$A:*+*$%+*#$:,;*@*+#$4,$+*7,+65$.*6%2-249$+*38++*46$V%-(5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$/,--,;249$@%924%-$.*-2@*+)#$0%C249$%..262,4%-$%33,0(0,.%62,4$844*3*55%+)?$e*624%-$:*0,++:%9249$:%5$>**4$+*7,+6*.$24$%55,32%62,4$;26:$>,6:$*72.8+%-$%4*56:*52%#$6)723%--)$+*d82+*.$/,+$*-*362@*$\%*5%+*%4$5*362,4#$%4.$9*4*+%-$%4*56:*52%?$_,6:$6+299*+$%4$243+*%5*$24$@*4,85$7+*558+*#$%4.$6:*$-%66*+$0%)$24.83*$V%-5%-@%$0%4*8@*+$.8+249$*R68>%62,4?'P

N46+%,38-%+$:*0,++:%9249$24$

24$<=E<#$,4-)$*-*@*4$)*%+5$%/6*+$6:*$246+,.8362,4$,/ $6:*$,7:6:%-(0,53,7*#$%4.$:%5$58>5*d8*46-)$>**4$+*7,+6*.$24$87$6,$'PT$,/ $@%924%-#$>86$,4-)$%$50%--$/+%362,4$,/ $\%*5%+*%4$.*-2@*+2*5?'<#'&$A+%80%$.8+249$%4.$/,--,;249$.*-2@*+)$25$%4$207,+6%46$3,452.*+%62,4Q$26$:%5$>**4$%+98*.$6:%6$24/%465$%+*$84%>-*$6,$

5*-/(9*4*+%6*$6:*$243+*%5*$24$246+%(6:,+%323$7+*558+*$+*d82+*.$6,$6+299*+$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)?'O$\,45*d8*46-)$%4.$84/,+684%6*-)#$%>852@*$:*%.$6+%80%$S1BA#$W5:%C*4$>%>)$5)4(.+,0*XU$0856$>*$243-8.*.$24$6:*$.2//*+*462%-$.2%94,525$/,+$24/%465$%4.$),849$3:2-.+*4$7+*5*46249$;26:$246+%,38-%+$:*0,++:%9249#$7%+6238(-%+-)$;:*4$:*0,++:%9249$25$>2-%6*+%-$%4.$24@,-@*5$08-627-*$+*624%-$-%)*+5$6:+,89:$6:*$*462+*6)$,/ $6:*$/84.85#$5899*56249$+*7*6262@*$%33*-*+%62,4F.*3*-*+%62,4$24b8+)?''

f:2-*$"8%4*$,+2924%--)$7,5(68-%6*.$6:%6$/%8-6)$+*624%-$3%72--%+(2*5$;*+*$+*57,452>-*$/,+$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)#$6:*$7+*@%-*43*$,/ $6:25$3,4.262,4$24$:*%-6:)$),849$%.8-65$;,8-.$5899*56$,6:*+;25*?'H$N4$/%36#$6:*$.*>%6*$%5$6,$;:*6:*+$+8768+*.$3%72--%+2*5$%+*$%>4,+0%-$,+$:*%-6:)$:%5$-%+9*-)$>**4$+*5,-@*.$24$/%@,+$,/ $6:*$-%66*+#$;26:$0,56$%+98249$6:%6#$

,338+5$24$6:*$%>5*43*$,/ $3,438+(+*46$,38-%+$,+$5)56*023$.25*%5*?$B,;*@*+#$26$3%4$>*$*R%3*+>%6*.$>)$+*624%-$@%538-%+$%4,0%-2*5#$5)56*023$0*.23%62,45#$:*0,++:%923$/*@*+5#$%4.$>-,,.$.)53+%52%5?'E('=$\,%98(-%>2-26)$25$%$7%+6238-%+-)$207,+6%46$3,452.*+%62,4Q$7*+624*46$6,$6:25$3%5*#$5,0*$0%246%24$6:%6$%4)$7%62*46$,/ $1/+23%4$.*53*46$;:,$7+*5*465$;26:$246+%,38-%+$>-**.249$:%5$523C-*(3*--$.25*%5*$8462-$7+,@*4$,6:*+;25*?$a)56*023$:)7*+6*452,4#$+*624%-$@*24$,33-852,4#$%4.$.2%>*6*5#$7%+6238-%+-)$7+,-2/*+%62@*$.25*%5*#$%+*$207,+6%46$3,452.*+%62,45$24$6:*$.2//*+*462%-$.2%94,525?$a*@*+*$%4*02%#$-*8C*02%#$%4.$3:+,423$%-3,:,-250$:%@*$%-5,$>**4$207-23%6*.$%5$+25C$/%36,+5$$/,+$246+%,38-%+$:*0,++:%9*?$$

K%+6238-%+$3%+*$0856$>*$6%C*4$6,$3,4(52.*+$7,6*462%--)$-2/*(6:+*%6*4249$.2%9(4,5*5#$243-8.249$A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*$%4.$K8+653:*+$+*624,7%6:)?'^(H<

]2+56$+*7,+6*.$24$<^PP#$A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*$25$3:%+%36*+2M*.$>)$6:*$7+*5(*43*$,/ $58>:)%-,2.$%4.F,+$@26+*,85$:*0,++:%9*$5*3,4.%+)$6,$246+%3+%42%-$58>%+%3:4,2.$:*0,++:%9*$Sa1BU?H&$A:25$3,4.262,4$25$/,84.$0,+*$/+*(d8*46-)$24$;,0*4#$3,45256*46$;26:$6:*$9*4.*+$.2//*+*43*$24$7+*@%-*43*$,/ $%4*8+)50%-$a1B?$N46+%,38-%+$:*0,+(+:%9249$25$>2-%6*+%-$24$%77+,R20%6*-)$HPT$,/$3%5*5#$>86$,/6*4$%5)00*6+23?$f:2-*$246+%3+%42%-$:*0,++:%9*$265*-/ $3%4$>*$-2/*$6:+*%6*4249#$6:*$7+*5*43*$,/ $3,438++*46$VB#$/,84.$24$87$6,$'PT$,/$3%5*5$>86$-2C*-)$84.*+(.2%94,5*.#$25$%55,32%6*.$;26:$%$'?=`$243+*%5*.$0,+6%-26)$+25C$%4.$0,+*$98%+.*.$,863,0*$5:,8-.$6:*$7%62*46$58+@2@*?$N6$;%5$,+2924%--)$:)7,6:*52M*.$6:%6$6:*$246+%,38-%+$>-,,.$;%5$58>(%+%3:4,2.$>-,,.$6+%450266*.$6:+,89:$6:*$,7623$4*+@*$5:*%6:?$B,;*@*+#$26$25$4,;$>*-2*@*.$6:%6$VB$+*58-65$/+,0$@*4,85$56%525$%4.$58>5*d8*46$246+%,38-%+$@*55*-$+8768+*$3%85*.$>)$%386*-)$*-*@%6*.$246+%3+%42%-$7+*5(58+*$SN\KU?HO$J38-%+$3,07-23%62,45$0%)$243-8.*$0%38-%+$:,-*$%4.$+*624%-$.*6%3:0*46#$%-6:,89:$6:*$7+,94,(525$/,+$@258%-$+*3,@*+)$24$58+@2@249$7%62*465$25$58+7+25249-)$9,,.?H'$K%62*465$;26:$A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*$/+*d8*46-)$3,07-%24$,/ $W6:84.*+3-%7$:*%.%3:*X$%4.$58>5*d8*46-)$7+*5*46$6,$6:*$*0*+(9*43)$+,,0$3,0%6,5*$5*3,4.%+)$6,$.+%0%623%--)$*-*@%6*.$N\K?HH$K8+653:*+$+*624,7%6:)#$24262%--)$

.*53+2>*.$24$<^<P#$25$%4$,33-852@*$023+,@%538-,7%6:)$S6+%80%623$+*624%-$%492,7%6:)U$3:%+%36*+2M*.$>)$3,66,4$;,,-$57,65#$08-627-*$+*624%-$:*0,+(

VOL 75 | NO 4 2013C A N A D I A N J O U R N A L O F O P T O M E T R Y | R E V U E C A N A D I E N N E D ’ O P T O M É T R I E 51

HE$A:*$-%66*+#$7,-)9,4%-$%+*%5$,/ $244*+(-%)*+$+*624%-$;:26*4249$6:,89:6$6,$>*$3%72--%+)$>*.$24/%+365$>*6;**4$%+6*(+2,-*5$%4.$@*48-*5$58++,84.*.$>)$%4$%.b%3*46$3-*%+$M,4*#$%+*$7%6:,94,(0,423$>86$4,6$842@*+5%-?HG$e*624%-$-*52,45$%+*$-,3%-2M*.$6,$6:*$7,56*+2,+$7,-*$/,--,;249$3,07+*552@*$24b8(+2*5$6,$6:*$6+84C$%4.F,+$-,49$>,4*$/+%368+*$,+$3+85:#$%4.$%+*$>2-%6*+%-$24$87$6,$EPT$,/ $3%5*5?H=$WK8+653:*+(-2C*X$S4,4(6+%80%623U$+*624,7%6:)$:%5$>**4$+*7,+6*.$5*3,4.%+)$6,$%386*$7%43+*%62625#$,+6:,7*.23$58+9*+)#$+*4%-$/%2-8+*#$%4.$3:2-.>2+6:?H^#EP$N4$%--$*62,-,92*5#$6:*$7%6:,9*4*525$25$/*-6$6,$

3-,65#$%4.F,+$%042,623$0%6*+2%-5#$,+$3,07-*0*46(0*.2%6*.$-*8C,3)6*$%99+*9%62,4?$A:*$7*+27%72--%+)$3%72--%+)$4*6;,+C$:%5$+*-%62@*-)$/*;$%+6*+2,-%+$/**.5#$0%C249$26$842d8*-)$5853*762>-*$6,$*0>,-23$,>56+8362,4?$K+*5*46249$@258%-$%3826)$0%)$>*$EFEP$,+$-*55$;26:$3*46+%-$53,6,0%L$@258%-$5)076,05$%+*$.*-%)*.$87$6,$'=$:,8+5$7,56(2--4*55$,+$(6+%80%?E<$a7,46%4*,85$@258%-$+*3,@*+)$6,$6:*$-*@*-$,/ $EF<&$,+$>*66*+$,338+5$;26:24$;**C5$6,$5*@*+%-$0,46:5$24$6:*$0%b,+26)$,/ $3%5*5#$%-6:,89:$.+%0%623%--)$+*.83*.$7+*5*46249$%3826)$.8*$6,$24@,-@*0*46$,/ $6:*$0%38-%+$%+6*+2,-%+$4*6;,+C$25$%$7,,+$7+,94,5623$24.23%6,+?$A:*+*$25$4,$7+,@*4$6+*%60*46Q$6:*$85*$,/ $5)56*023$56*+,2.%-$%4.$4,4(56*+,2.%-$

(%>-)$*//*362@*$24$207+,@249$8-620%6*$@258%-$+*3,@*+)?E&

]+,0$%$>2,0*3:%423%-$7*+57*3(62@*#$6:*$3%85%62@*$/,+3*$24$K8+653:*+$+*624,7%6:)$25$3*46+2/89%-$S%46*+2,+F7,56*+2,+U#$;:*+*%5$6:%6$24$V%-5%-@%$

+*624,7%6:)$25$3*46+27*6%-$S587*+2,+F24/*+2,+U?EO$15$583:#$3,438++*46$K8+653:*+$%4.$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%(6:)$25$+%+*#$%-6:,89:$7,552>-*$24$2456%43*5$,/ $5*@*+*$3:*56$6+%80%?$N4$4*26:*+$3,4.262,4$25$.2+*36$,38-%+$6+%80%$%4$*62,-,923$/%36,+?

ConclusionV%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$0%)$>*$7+*3272(6%6*.$>)$%$480>*+$,/ $@*+)$.2@*+5*$3%85*5#$243-8.249$7+*94%43)?$],+68(4%6*-)#$57,46%4*,85$+*5,-862,4$;26:$+*3,@*+)$,/ $4,+0%-$,+$4*%+$4,+0%-$@252,4$25$6:*$+8-*$24$6:*$0%b,+26)$,/ $3%5*5?$[4*d82@,3%-$*@2.*43*$,/ $%46*3*.*46$V%-5%-@%$0%4*8@*+$25$:*-7/8-$24$*56%>-25:249$6:*$.2%9(4,525?$N4$265$%>5*43*#$.2//*+*462%-$.2%94,525$25$3+2623%-#$7%+6238-%+-)$24$-29:6$,/ $6:*$7,6*462%--)$.*@%56%6249$3,45*d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d8*$*62,-,9)$%4.$5*-/(-2026249$3,8+5*#$/,--,;(87$25$6)723%--)$6:+,89:$+*98-%+$3,07+*(:*452@*$*)*$*R%024%62,45?

References<?$ 1-(!8b%242$1a#$!,46%4%$\\?$V%-5%-@%$

+*624,7%6:)$24$7+*94%43)Q$%$3%5*$+*7,+6?$@1$%6,-'17 'A&B"C,-'D,2&'E&01%.2$&PP=L&Q<P<(O?

&?$ \:,2$a#$*6$%-?$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$%55,32%6*.$D,6'@'

F0+.+,-?1-$&PPEL'<Q'^<(O?

O?$ 1:0%.1>%.2$!Z#$*6$%-?$K+*0%38-%+$:*0,++:%9*$24$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)Q$%$568.)$,/ $&<$3%5*5?$G%,6",6'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PP^L&<SOUQ<<(<E?

'?$ V%4$e*45$D?$A+%80%623$,38-%+$:%*0,++:%9*$+*-%6*.$6,$>849**$b807249?$H%'@'F0+.+,-?1-$<^^'LG=S<&UQ^'=?

H?$ B%55%4$!#$A%b8425%:$N?$V%-5%-@%$:%*0,++:%923$+*624,7%6:)$%/6*+$785:(875?$I,6C&.$&P<<LOGGQHP'?

E?$ a8*C*$B?$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$24.83*.$>)$@29,+,85$429:63-8>$.%43249?$A@J$&PP^L<^PSEUQOOO?

G?$ !,5*-)$N]#$K2--249$h_?$N46+%,38-%+$:%*0,++:%9*$%5$%$3,07-23%62,4$,/ $74*80,*43*7:%-,9+%7:)?$@'K&$%1-'K&$%12$%#'L2/C+",.%/$<^GELO^QOGH(O=P?

=?$ \%--*4.*+$"#$*6$%-?$V%-5%-@%$:%*0,++:%923$+*624,7%6:)$24$%$7+*94%46$;,0%4?$M/&$<^^HL^Q=P=(^?

^?$ a:%+0%$a?$J7:6:%7+,>-*0$i$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)?$D,6,B",6'!,?"-/'L+/2"C",6$<^^=L''Q&E'O#&EH<(&?

<P?$A%>%6%>%**$a1#$*6$%-?$K8+653:*+$+*624,7%6:)$%55,32%6*.$;26:$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$%/6*+$%332.*46?$G%,6",6'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PP^L&<S<UQGP(G&?

<<?$\%0*+,4$he#$*6$%-?$V26+*,85$:%*0,++:%9*$/,--,;249$3%+.2,78-0,4%+)$+*585326%62,4?$M/&$&PPEL&PQ<O<G(<^?

<&?$ h20$hg#$*6$%-?$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$%55,32%6*.$;26:$%4$,+%6,+23%-$3,46*56?$j,+*%4$h$F0+.+,-?1-$&PP^L&OQO<=(&P?

<O?$ N,%442.25$1a#$*6$%-?$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$%55,32%6*.$;26:$+2.249$%$0,6,+3)3-*?$M/&$&PP'L<=QO&^(O<?

<'?$c**$Ag#$\:%49$fB?$1$3%5*$,/ $V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$%55,32%6*.$;26:$56+%24249$%6$56,,-?$N&$6#?,6'O6"5'@'A&B$&PPEL&OS&UQ&&G(O<?

<H?$\:%4$h?$J7:6:%-023$3,07-23%62,45$%/6*+$>849**$b807249?$H%'@'F0+.+,-?1-$<^^'LG=Q&O^?

<E?$]+2>*+9$Ae#$*6$%-?$a8..*4$@258%-$-,55$%55,32%6*.$;26:$5*R8%-$%362@26)?$1+3:$F0+.+,-?1-$<^^HL<<OSEUQGO=('&?

<G?$e,>*+65$"j#$!%3j%)$j1?$!23+,:*0,++:%923$0%38-,7%6:)$%55,32%6*.$;26:$%*+,>23$*R*+325*?$@'J?'F0.1?'J221C$<^=GLH=SHUQ'<H(=?

<=?$Y*,+92,8$A?$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$%55,32%6*.$;26:$>-,;249$>%--,,45?$M/&$<^^^L<OSHUQE=E(G?

C A N A D I A N J O U R N A L O F O P T O M E T R Y | R E V U E C A N A D I E N N E D ’ O P T O M É T R I EVOL 75 | NO 4 201352

<^?$ \:%4.+%$K#$*6$%-?$V%-5%-@%$%4.$K8+653:*+X5$+*624,7%6:)$;26:$,7623$4*8+,7%6:)$24$3,07+*552@*$6:,+%323$24b8+)?$M/&$&PPHL<^Q^<'(H?

&P?$aC,+24$c#$j*26:$h]?$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)Q$*R%07-*5$,/ $3-%5523$%4.$5*3,4.%+)$,338++*43*5?$D-"6'E&7 'F0.1?$&PP=L<^S&UQOE('P?

&<?$h%>%-)(B%>2>$Bg#$*6$%-?$a87+%3:,+,2.%-$:%*0,++:%9*$%/6*+$V%-5%-@%$24$%$0),723$*)*$;26:$32+38-%+$>83C-*?$J2",6'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PPOLHSOUQ<<(<&?

&&?$c*2>,;26M$B!?$A:*$+*.$*)*?$K'M6#-'@'A&B$&PPPLO'OSHUQO'H(H<?

&O?$A%6-2724%+$a#$*6$%-?$J7623%-$3,:*+*43*$6,0,9+%7:)$/*%68+*5$,/ $58>(246*+4%-$-2026249$0*0>+%4*$:*0,++:%9*$%4.$7+*+*624%-$0*0>+%4*$24$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)?$D,6'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PPGL'&Q<&^(OP?

+*624,7%6:)?$e*@2*;$,/ $J76,0*6+)$J4-24*$i$OO+.$1448%-$"2%94,5623$A*3:4,-,9)$e*7,+6$&P<P?$:667QFF;;;?+*@,76,0?3,0F3,46248249k*.83%62,4F6%>@2*;6*56F-*55,42.F<PE^&<F$

&H?$Y2>+%4$aj#$*6$%-?$\:%49*5$24$6:*$+*624%-$246*+4%-$-2026249$0*0>+%4*$%55,32%6*.$;26:$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)?$H%'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PPGL^<QGP<(&?

&E?$"8+8C%4$1B#$*6$%-?$c,49(6*+0$+*58-65$,/ $Z.Qg1Y$-%5*+$6+*%60*46$/,+$7+*0%38-%+$58>:)%-,2.$:%*0,++:%9*$,;249$6,$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)?$M/&$&PP=L&&Q&<'(=?

&G?$\:%70%4("%@2*5$1#$c%M%+*@23$1?$V%-5%-@%$0%38-,7%6:)?$D-"6'MP0'F0.1?$&PP&L=HS<UQ'&(H?

&=?$B%M*0$B1#$a:%M-)$A1?$D@%-8%62,4$,/ $78-5*.$Z.Qg1Y$-%5*+$7,56*+2,+$:)%-,2.,6,0)$%5$%4$*0*+9*43)$6+*%60*46$/,+$>-24.249$7+*0%38-%+$58>:)%-,2.$:*0,++:%9*?$J7*4$133*55$D0*+9*43)$!*.2324*$&P<<LOQOO(G?

&^?$!%:*5:$Y#$*6$%-?$Z"$g%9$:)%-,2.,6,0)$/,+$7+*0%38-%+$:%*0,++:%9*$24$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)?$Q&%,-,'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PPELlVNNNS'ULOP<(O?

OP?$]*-277*$D#$*6$%-?$K+*+*624%-$:*0,++:%9*?$D2456*24$&PP'L&S'UQO<'(H?

O<?$f23C+*0%5249:*$aa#$*6$%-?$V%-5%-@%$:%*0,++:%923$+*624,7%6:)$24$%$7+*94%46$;,0%4Q$207-23%62,45$/,+$.*-2@*+)?$JC.,'F0+.+,-?1-'RC,6B$&PPOL=<Q'&P(&?

O&?$Z2-2$1:0%.%>%.2$!#$*6$%-?$Z.Qg1Y$0*0>+%4,6,0)$24$.2%>*623$7+*0%38-%+$:*0,++:%9*?$H"6,'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PP=L<OSOUQOOE(O'P?

OO?$Y%>*-$VK?$Z.Qg1Y$-%5*+$7:,6,.25+8762,4$,/ $:*0,++:%923$.*6%3:0*46$,/ $6:*$246*+4%-$-2026249$0*0>+%4*?$J?'@'F0+.+,-?1-$<^=^L<PGS<UQOO(G?

O'?$]%+@%+.24$!#$*6$%-?$Z*,.)0280Qg1Y$-%5*+$6+*%60*46$/,+$7+*0%38-%+$:*0,++:%9*?$J%C+'G%,6",6'A&B$&PPHL=S<UQ=(<O?

OH?$[-92>$!f#$*6$%-?$c,49(6*+0$+*58-65$%/6*+$.+%24%9*$,/ $7+*0%38-%+$58>:)%-,2.$:*0,++:%9*$246,$6:*$@26+*,85$;26:$78-5*.$Z.Qg1Y$-%5*+?$J%C+'F0+.+,-?1-'<^^=L<<EQ<'EH(^?

OE?$m,8$!#$*6$%-?$K*+5256*46$845*%-*.$246*+4%-$-2026249$0*0>+%4*$%/6*+$Z.Qg1Y$-%5*+$6+*%60*46$/,+$@%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)?$HAD'F0+.+,-?1-1#/$&P<OL<OQ<H?

OG?$"*$!%*)*+$j#$*6$%-?$a8>(244*+$-2026249$0*0>+%4*$:%*0,++:%9*Q$3%85*5$%4.$6+*%60*46$;26:$@26+*36,0)?$H%'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PPGL^<Q=E^(G&?

O=?$D-("*/+%;)$B#$*6$%-?$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$24$7+*94%43)?$a:,8-.$;*$6+*%6n$@'E'R1C'A&B'R+'E&0$&P<<L&Q'H(G?

O^?$"*%4*$ha#$m2%C%5$Z?$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$24$7+*94%43)?$M/&'<^^GL<<Q<OG(=?

'P?$_,-.*+$K!#$Z,+6,4$!c?$e*624%-$:*0,++:%9*$/,--,;249$%4*56:*52%?$J6&2.+&2"1-1#/$<^='LE<QH^H(G?

'<?$a*M*4$]?$e*624%-$:%*0,++:%9*5$24$4*;>,+4$24/%465?$H%'@'F0+.+,-?1-$<^GPLHHQ&'=(HO?

'&?$_%80$h"#$_8-7266$\h?$e*624%-$%4.$3,4b84362@%-$:%*0,++:%9*$24$6:*$4*;>,+4?$J%C+"5&2'17 'S"2&,2&'"6'D+"-B+11B$<^GPL'HQO''(^?

'O?$B*++$a#$*6$%-?$",*5$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$,338+$24$24/%465n$14$24262%-$24@*5629%62,4$24$24/%465$;26:$@,026249$3%85*.$>)$7)-,+23$56*4,525?$L&B",.%"C2$&PP'L<<OQ<EH=(E<?

''?$c*@24$1V?$e*624%-$:*0,++:%9*5Q$%.@%43*5$24$84.*+56%4.249?$L&B",.%'D-"6'K'J?$&PP^LHEQOOO(''?

'H?$"8%4*$A"?$V%-5%-@%$:*0,++:%923$+*624,7%6:)?$T%,62'J?'F0+'R1C$<^G&LGPQ&^=(O<O?

'E?$.*$\+*33:2,$Y#$*6$%-?$V%-5%-@%$+*624,7%6:)$%55,32%6*.$;26:$%$3,49*426%-$+*624%-$0%3+,@*55*-?$J%C+'F0+.+,-?1-$&PPPL<<=S<UQ<'E(G?

'G?$j,4,6*)(1:8-8$]?$V%-5%-@%$@26+*,85$:%*0,++:%9*$%4.$+*624,7%6:)$24$523C-*$3*--$:%*0,9-,>24$\$.25*%5*?$I,6C&.'<^^GLO'^Q<GG'?

'=?$":%50%4%$e?$_2-%6*+%-$7+*0%38-%+$58>:)%-,2.$:*0,++:%9*$24$"*498*$/*@*+?$@1$%6,-'17 'F0+.+,-?"C',6B'4"2"16'E&2&,%C+$&P<<LES<UQEO(H?

'^?$!*.*-*$eh#$*6$%-?$A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*$24$58>%+%3:4,2.$:*0,++:%9*$%4.$5*@*+*$>+%24$24b8+)$%33,07%42*.$>)$%386*-)$+%25*.$246+%3+%42%-$7+*558+*?$@'K&$%12$%#$<^^=L==Q=H<('?

HP?$!3\%++,4$!J#$*6$%-?$1$5)56*0%623$+*@2*;$,/ $A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*Q$/+*d8*43)$%4.$7+,94,525$%/6*+$58>%+%3:4,2.$:%*0,++:%9*?$@'K&$%1-'K&$%12$%#'L2/C+",.%/$&PP'LGHQ'^<(O?

H<?$Y2>+%4$aj?$[42-%6*+%-$@26+*,85$:%*0,++:%9*$5*3,4.%+)$6,$3%8.%-$*72.8+%-$24b*362,4Q$%$@%+2%46$,/ $A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*?$H%'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PP&L=EQOHO('?

H&?$B%55%4$1#$*6$%-?$A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*?$K&$%1C%".'D,%&$&P<<L<HQHH'(=?

HO?$K%d8*66*$]#$*6$%-?$A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*?$D,6'@'K&$%1-'RC"$&P<&LOGQ=E<(&?

H'?$j,$]#$j4,R$"c?$A:*$,38-%+$7%6:,-,9)$,/ $A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*?$F0+.+,-?1-1#/$&P<PL<<GQ<'&O(^?

HH?$e*5423C$ah#$e%>2456*24$11?$A*+5,4X5$5)4.+,0*$24$58>%+%3:4,2.$:%*0,++:%9*?$$@'K&$%1-'K&$%12$%#'L2/C+",.%/$&PPELGGQ&=G?

HE?$\%7-*4$a!#$!%.+*7*+-%$a1?$K8+653:*+X5$+*624,7%6:)Q$%$3%5*$+*7,+6$%4.$+*@2*;?$J?'@'M?&%#'A&B$&PP=L&EQ=OE?*<(=OE?*&?

HG?$_83C-*)$a1#$h%0*5$_?$K8+653:*+X5$+*624,7%6:)?$L12.#%,B'A&B'@$<^^ELG&Q'P^(<&?

H=?$19+%;%-$1#$!3j2>>,4$!?$K8+653:*+X5$+*624,7%6:)Q$*72.*02,-,9)#$3-2423%-$/*%68+*5$%4.$,863,0*?$H%'@'F0+.+,-?1-$&PPGL^<Q<'HE(^?

H^?$19+%;%-$1#$!3j2>>24$!1?$K8+653:*+X5$%4.$K8+653:*+(-2C*$+*624,7%6:2*5Q$%$+*@2*;?$R$%5'F0+.+,-?1-'&PPELH<Q<&^(OE?

EP?$D++*+%$!B#$*6$%-?$K+*94%43)(%55,32%6*.$+*624%-$.25*%5*5$%4.$6:*2+$0%4%9*0*46?$R$%5'F0+.+,-?1-'&P<OLH=Q<&G('&?

E<?$!298*-$1N!#$*6$%-?$a)56*0%623$+*@2*;$,/ $K8+653:*+X5$%4.$K8+653:*+(-2C*$+*624,7%6:2*5?$M/&$&P<OL&GQ<(<OL.,2Q<P?<PO=F*)*?&P<&?&&&?

E&?$Z,+(!%542;%62$a#$*6$%-?$K8+653:*+(-2C*$+*624,7%6:)$/,--,;249$@%-5%-@%$0%4*8@*+Q$3%5*$+*7,+6?$@1$%6,-'17 'A&B"C,-'D,2&'E&01%.2$&P<<LHQOO=?

EO?$A%07,)%$\#$*6$%-?$J38-%+$0%42/*56%62,45$,/ $V%-5%-@%$0%4*8@*+?$D-"6'E&7 'F0.1?$&P<&L&OQ<&(^?

SILVE

RTHANK YOU | MERCI