Constructive Manslaughter

Constructive Manslaughter

By Maryam Kamkar

Vickers 1957

MR of Murder Includes ‘Intention to Cause GBH’Only if No Intention? Then Consider Involuntary Manslaughter

Constructive Manslaughter

Defined in:

Larkin1944

DPP v Newbury Must have intention for The Act Not for The Death …………………………

Lowe 1973

Must be Positive Act Not Omission !

Franklin 1883

Must Be A Criminal Act Civil Wrong

Not Sufficient!

Lamb 1967 Prov

e Both Actus Reus & Mens ReaOf “D”’s Act !!!

8

LarkinMust be Dangerous likely to Injure Another Person …

9

Church 1966Objectively

Dangerous Act Such that its’ Risk of Some harm

Albeit not a Serious harm

is inevitably recognised By any sober and Reasonable Man!

EdmundDavis

WatsonThe “Risk of harm” that became obvious to D

DawsonThe knowledge D had

or ought to Have…

Dawson The unlawful dangerous Act Must have Caused the Death …

11

Causation Rules Factual & legal Causation

Applies As Normal, White…

Transferred MaliceR v Latimer1886 Where MR of the

crime directed at one person is transferred to the unintended Victim of the crime

Pembilton1969

Only if AR is the Same as MRIt Can be Transferred..

Mitchell

Unlawful Act Need Not Be aimed Directly at the Victim!

15

R v Goodfellow 1986

Unlawful Act Need Not Be aimed Directly at the Victim!

Ball 1989 Mistaken

Belief Is Not

Acceptable

17

Dias2002

Dalby 1982

Cato 1976

No Break In the Chain ……..Guilty of Manslaughter…..

S 23 of MDA 1971More than minimum Cause of Death

Kennedy 2007Fully

Informed Adult Acting Freely AndVoluntarily … Overruled Roger & Finlay

Using more visual Clues for teaching Law Students

June 2015

By Maryam Kamkar

20