Life cycle based assessment for agricultural productsAn Austrian best practice

9/1/2013 1

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Life cycle based assessment for agricultural products

An Austrian best practice

 Martin Wildenberg, Tanja Altaparmakova, Kewin Comploi, Dominik Frieling, Anna Geiger

9/1/2013 2

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

Structure of the talkIntroduction & BackgroundThe GLOBAL 2000 Approach- The Process- Infrastructure- ResultsSuccess factors & lessons learned

9/1/2013 3

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

Austrian Environmental NGO (www.global2000.at)

Part of the Friends of the Earth Network

• Political campaigns and activism

• Education and Awareness

• Solution oriented cooperations

9/1/2013 4

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

Measuring impacts: Inputs and outputs of society:

OutputsSocietySocial

MetabolismInputs

9/1/2013 5

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

We suggested a label that:

- Focuses on conventional food & farming

- Focuses on whole production chain

- Can make the environmental impact of a product visible

- Can make the resource rucksacks of a product visible

- Rests on measurable indicators -> you can only manage what you know

- Induces a process with the participants to increase the sustainability of their products step by step

- Creates a Win – Win situation for producers – retailer – customer and environment

9/1/2013 6

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

The GLOBAL 2000 adaptive labeling approach for sustainable agricultural products

Aim: • set incentives for farmers, distributors and retailers to adopt a

more sustainable production mode • inform consumers about environmental impacts of their

choices.

9/1/2013 7

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Use case: Pro Planet – Austria fruit vegetable and eggs

The Label:

In Germany & Austria- Identify & resolve social and ecological hot-spots

in the production chain

In Austria:

For fruits, vegetables and eggs:

Cooperation between Caritas, REWE International AG & GLOBAL 2000

9/1/2013 8

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

The building blocks of the programG

ood

Agr

icul

tura

l P

ract

ice

Glo

bal G

ap

Soc

ial P

ract

ice

GR

AS

P &

SA

800

0C

arita

s

Co

nsu

me

r S

afe

tyP

estic

ide

Mon

itorin

g P

RP

Ecological SustainabilityIndicator setRules and regulationsStakeholder process

9/1/2013 9

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

The focus of our indicator system

Ressource use

Impacts on environment

9/1/2013 10

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Farm based indicatorsN-balance P-balanceHumus-balancePesticide use Energy intensity

Calculated by INL using the model REPRO (Hülsbergen et al 2003)

9/1/2013 11

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Per service unit indicators (MIPS):Carbon-footprint Biotic Material InputA-biotic Material InputWater inputArea used

Field to shelf(Schmidt-Bleek 1998, Ritthof 2002, GHG Protocol)

9/1/2013 12

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Field records (machine use etc.)Pesticide useYieldsIn case of fruit rotation the

data should cover at least three years

Data on other inputs (energy & materials) collection via standardized form

Calculated by using factors from the EcoInvent Database

Data needed:

9/1/2013 14

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

For a product-group zero-tolerance thresholds were defined. If crossed the product cannot be labeled.

9/1/2013 15

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Benchmarking Water:Increasing product water efficiency in Spain or how to set incentives to use more and more water…

9/1/2013 16

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Benchmarking Water:Include water availability in watershed based on :

more absolute water use in the Watershed = lower benchmark

9/1/2013 17

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

The Soft side of Labeling:

InvolvementKnowledge exchangeEducation

= Participation & Change

9/1/2013 18

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Stakeholder Process

BenchmarkingRegulations

Hotspots

Participants:• Producer• Distributor• Producer-organization• Quality Management• Experts• GLOBAL 2000• Caritas

9/1/2013 19

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Different communication to:

- Producer- Retailer- Consumer

9/1/2013 20

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Results

After starting with the labeling of Austrian open-land strawberries in June 2010…

• Over 550 farms & suppliers have submitted data in 2013• 30 product groups have been screened from which • 25 products labeled. • 50+ stakeholder workshops have been conducted

9/1/2013 21

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

biotischer in

put kg /

kg

abiotisch

input k

g / kg

Fläc

he m² /

kg

Wass

er m³ /

kg

CO2e eq. Kg /

kg0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

Tomato Greenhouse AUT (Gas-heating)Tomato Greenhouse AUT (comunity heating)Cocktail Tomato ESP (tunnel)Tomato ESP (tunnel)Tomato AUT (tunnel)

Comparing production systems

9/1/2013 22

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

CO2 eq. per kg sweet maize and level od origin. In average soil carbon losscontributes to 16% of total CO2 emissions from field to shelf.

Identifying Hotspots

9/1/2013 23

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Paprik

a FT

Tom

atoe

s (p

. t.)

Rad

ish

Lettu

ceC

hine

se C

abba

ge

Cab

bage

Iceb

erg

Lettu

ceStra

wbe

rryH

orse

radi

sh

Potat

oeG

rape

s IT

A

Oni

on

Apple

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

1 2 2

45 5 5 5

7

9

15 15

16

Pesticide use index

Pro-Planet product

Comparing products:

9/1/2013 24

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Comparing producers:

0,0

5,0

10,0

15,0

20,0

25,0

30,0

35,0

40,0

Pflanzenschutz-Index

Häufigkeit und Menge von Pestizid-Anwendungen 2011

Pflanzenschutzindex Pro Planet-ÄpfelIhr Betrieb (Mittelw ert aller Schläge)OptimumgrenzeToleranzgrenze

Pfla

nze

ns

ch

utz

-In

de

x

Variation in Pesticide Index in 138 apple producers

9/1/2013 25

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Changes achieved:- In crop rotation patterns- Feed composition (eggs)- Packaging- Transport packaging- New product line for “ugly” vegetables- Pesticide use

9/1/2013 26

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Lessons Learned

9/1/2013 27

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Ten Success factors1. Largely relying on data that is available and recorded anyway

2. Indicators point at hotspots

3. Indicators cover resource use, direct impacts on environment & health

4. Improvements can be quantified & communicated in understandable units

5. Indicators are relevant for producers to improve efficiency

6. Life cycle approach – transparency and responsibility over production chain

7. Third party assessments

8. Stakeholder involvement

9. Cooperation with important stakeholders: supermarket-chain, GlobalG.A.P. and farm management software

10. Constant evaluation, adaptation and further development

9/1/2013 28

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Obstacles and ProblemsSome important topics currently still too complicated to be

considered via indicators e.g. biodiversity, erosion.

Our current model for agricultural indicators restricted to central European soils and climate

The set of indicators is considered too complicated to communicate

Many sustainability problems are systemic. The cause are in the way food is commercialized.

9/1/2013 29

Sustainability

Assessment , Solutions and Applied Research

27/08/2013 LCM 2013 Göteburg martin.wildenberg@global2000.at

Thank You!

Contact:Dr Martin Wildenberg

T: +43-699-14200046

martin.wildenberg@global2000.at