Upload
tran-thang
View
1.206
Download
8
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
INTEGRATED BUSINESS
EXPERIENCE 2-
CASE STUDY ANALYSIS
TRAN TRUNG HIEU - MBA29152271
NGUYEN HY MINH HOANG ndash MBA 29152195
NGUYEN MINH HOANG ndash MBA29152299
WARM UP
Rules
Same as Chiec non ky dieu Gameshow
You will have 04 Hints to guess
Point to be counted for correct answer at Hints
Hint 1 5 points
Hint 2 4 points
Hint 3 3 points
Hint 4 2 points
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 1 30 Total
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 2
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 3
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 4
1159
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
B U S I N E S S1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
S T R A T E G Y1 2 3 4
G A M E
Sample Question
Question 1
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
WARM UP
Rules
Same as Chiec non ky dieu Gameshow
You will have 04 Hints to guess
Point to be counted for correct answer at Hints
Hint 1 5 points
Hint 2 4 points
Hint 3 3 points
Hint 4 2 points
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 1 30 Total
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 2
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 3
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 4
1159
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
B U S I N E S S1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
S T R A T E G Y1 2 3 4
G A M E
Sample Question
Question 1
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Rules
Same as Chiec non ky dieu Gameshow
You will have 04 Hints to guess
Point to be counted for correct answer at Hints
Hint 1 5 points
Hint 2 4 points
Hint 3 3 points
Hint 4 2 points
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 1 30 Total
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 2
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 3
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 4
1159
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
B U S I N E S S1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
S T R A T E G Y1 2 3 4
G A M E
Sample Question
Question 1
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 1 30 Total
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 2
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 3
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 4
1159
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
B U S I N E S S1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
S T R A T E G Y1 2 3 4
G A M E
Sample Question
Question 1
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 2
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 3
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 4
1159
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
B U S I N E S S1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
S T R A T E G Y1 2 3 4
G A M E
Sample Question
Question 1
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 3
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 4
1159
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
B U S I N E S S1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
S T R A T E G Y1 2 3 4
G A M E
Sample Question
Question 1
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Sample Question1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1 2 3 4
Hint 4
1159
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
B U S I N E S S1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
S T R A T E G Y1 2 3 4
G A M E
Sample Question
Question 1
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
B U S I N E S S1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
S T R A T E G Y1 2 3 4
G A M E
Sample Question
Question 1
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Question 1
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Hint 2
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Hint 3
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Hint 4 Start with letter ldquoRrdquo
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Question 1
1 2 3 4 5 6
R E T A I L
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 1
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 2
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 3
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Hint 4
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Question 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
M U L T I N A T I O N A L
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 2
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Question 3
Hint 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Question 3
Hint 4
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Question 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
M E M B E R S H I P
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
1Retail
2Multinational
3Membership
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Savings Too Big To Get Home
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco Today
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco Facts - 2nd largest global retailer (National Retail Federation 2015)
- 18th largest in Fortune 500 (Costco 2015)
- $71 billion market cap (Costco 2016)
- 698 locations worldwide (568 in North America) (Costco 2016)
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco Stores
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Costco dominated Canada wholesale club industry with a 72 share of value sales and 60 of the total number of outlets (Euromonitor 2016)
- In the US Costco outperformed both Samrsquos Club and BJrsquos Wholesale club over the 2009 ndash 2014 period (Euromonitor 2015)
- In 2014 Costco accounted for 52 of the total US market share (Euromonitor 2015)
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Overall Competitive Landscape
- Competition is based among the following factors price merchandise quality and selection location and customer service (MarketLine 2015)
- Highly competitive industry whereas Costco will have to compete against
(1) other players in wholesale club industry
(2) other forms of retailing businesses such as retail discounters (Walmart and Dollar General) supermarkets general merchandise chains specialty chains gasoline station and Internet retailers (Arthur 2012)
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
COSTCOrsquoS MISSION amp BUSINESS MODEL
A company mission statement describes its present business scope and purpose (ldquowhere we are what we do and why we are hererdquo)
According to Costcorsquos its mission statement is (ldquoto continually provide our members with quality goods and services at the lowest possible pricerdquo)
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
BUSINESS MODEL
Overview
The plan implemented by a company to generate revenue and make a profit from operations
The model includes the components and functions of the business as well as the revenues it generates and the
expenses it incurs
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL High sale volume and rapid inventory turnover
Offering fee-paying members attractively low prices on a limited selection of nationally branded and selected private- label products in a wide range of merchandise categories
Allowing it to sell and receive cash for inventory before it had to pay many merchandise vendors even when vendor payments were made in time to take advantage of early payment discount
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
COSTCOrsquoS BUSINESS MODEL A unique aspect of Costcorsquos business model
Limits marketing advertising and promotional activities to new warehouse openings
Occasional direct mail marketing to prospective new members and regular direct marketing programs (such as The Costco Connection a magazine we publish for our members and coupon mailershellip)
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Costco has developed a reputation as a socially responsible company by its actions and not by its marketing
Costco does not have a public relations department or staff
Costco relies primarily on word-of-mouth from its members to spread its brand messages
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
MARKETING AND ADVERTISING
Using direct marketing to existing customers to promote merchandize
The executive membership program offers additional benefits on member services
Its low prices and reputation for making shopping at Costco something of a treasure-hunt made it unnecessary to engage in extensive advertising or sales campaigns
These practices result in lower marketing expenses as compared to typical retailers
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
APPEALING BUSINESS MODEL
Their mission is to provide quality goods and services at the lowest possible price
Satisfying buyer needs and requirements at a price they will consider a good value
The greater the value delivered and the lower the price to get the value the more appealing a companyrsquos value proposition and product offering
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco Strategy 1 Pricing
2 Product Selection
3 Treasure Hunt Merchandising
4 Low Cost Emphasis
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Chief Elements of Costco Strategy
Ultra-low prices Keep the customers going to the shop by wowing them with low prices Low markup on brand-name merchandise at 14 (compared to 20 ndash 50 markups at other discounters and many supermarkets Jim Sinegal - CEO of Costco said ldquoWe understand that our members do not come to us because the window displays or the Santa Claus or the piano player They come and shop with us because we offer great valuesrdquo
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Product Selection
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Product Selection
The selection within each product category was restricted in some cases to a single offering
Costco stocked only a 325 ndash count bottle of Advil ndash a size that many shoppers might find too large for their needs
Costco had opened ancillary departments within the next to most Costco warehouses see the table on the next slidehellip
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costcorsquo s Strategy - Treasure Hunt Merchandising
Dozens of featured specials came and went very quickly sometimes in several days or a week ndash like Italian ndash made Hathaway shirts priced at $2999 and $800 leather sectional sofas
The strategy was to entice the shoppers and bargain ndash hunting shoppers would go to Costco more frequently than for periodic ldquostock uprdquo trips
The shoppers quickly learned that they need to buy treasure ndash hunt specials that interested them because these items would very likely not available on their next shopping trip
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costcorsquo s StrategyLow cost emphasis
Costco eliminate all the frills and costs historically associated with conventional retailers including salespeople fancy buildings delivery billing and accounts receivable
They locate warehouses on high ndash traffic routes in or near upscale suburbs that were easily accessible by small businesses and residents with above ndash average incomes it avoided prime real estate sites in order to contain land costs
Warehouse building material Metal pre-engineered design concrete floors and minimal interior deacutecor
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
COSTCOrsquoS WAREHOUSE
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costcorsquo s Strategy Growth Strategy
Costco had opened between 14 and 34 new locations annually (most in the US) In the fiscal year 2011 Costco spent $13 billion to open 20 new locations two newly relocated warehouses and several distribution depots In the fiscal year 2012 4 new warehouses in the US and 2 new warehouses in Japan (first 4 months of fiscal year 2012) and planned to open an additional 12 new warehouses on September 2012
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Grade the CEO
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Game Name Right Names
By whom you are inspired
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=12
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Source httpwwwcnbccom20090424Portfolios-Best-American-CEOs-of-All-Timehtmlslide=14
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
If youve got to work for the rest of your life youd better do something youll enjoyrdquo
httpwwwexploringmarketscom201402costco-founder-james-sinegal-might-havehtml
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
INTELLIGENCE
HONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENT
DRIVENCOURAGEOUS
What can you see
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
What can you seeINTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
INTELLIGENCEHONESTCREATIVE
CONFIDENTDRIVENCOURAGEOUS
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
bull Strategic vision indicates the paths that company takes in developing and strengthening its
business as preparing for long-term future
bull Key consideration in Deciding Companyrsquos Future Direction External vs Internal
bull What is your Slogan
bull Strategic vision vs Mission Statement
bull Strategic vision sets companyrsquos future direction ldquowhere are we goingrdquo
bull Mission statement describes the present ldquowho we are what we do and why we are hererdquo
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
bull WHAT - ldquoObjectives are an organizationrsquos performance
targetrdquo
bull WHO - ldquoObjectives reflects managerial commitment to
deliver results and outcomes
bull WHY
bull Helps organization to be focus on what should be
completed to deliver expected overall outcomes
bull Considered as Benchmark to track company
performance
bull Motivates all members to deliver best possible results
bull WHERE amp WHEN HOW
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Setting Objectives Task 2
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
First introduced by Kaplan and Norton 1992 Havard Business
Review
bull Tracking Financial result while monitoring progress in
building the capabilities for future growth
bull To integrate Long-term strategy with Short-term financial
goals
bull Not as replacement of Financial measures but
complement
bull Four main processes
1 Translating the vision
2 Communicating and linking
3 Business planning
4 Feedback and learning
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
httpswwwyoutubecomwatchv=biyGxEix5Zs
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 9
Back up
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Task 3
CORPORATE
STRATEGY
BUSINESS
STRATEGY
FUNCTIONAL
STRATEGY
OPERATIONAL
STRATEGY
CEO and Other Senior Executives
General Managers
Functional Heads
Sub-Functional Heads
Two-way InfluenceTop down vs Bottom Up
Reproduced Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 14
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 4 ndash Page 2
Back up
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Source Textbook - Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches ndash Arthur A Thompson The University of Alabama ndash Chapter 2 ndash Page 13
Resources preparation Human resources Physical Resources Financial Resources
Internal process policies and supporting systems
Rewards and Recognition Employee Engagement
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Task 1
Developing Strategic vision mission and core value
Setting Objectives
Crafting Strategy to achieve objectives and vision
Implementing and Executing
Task 2
Task 3
Task 4
Overall Grade A-
Task 5
Monitoring developments evaluating performance and initiating corrective actions
Costcorsquos case
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco Obey the law
Take care of Members
Take care of Employees
Respect Suppliers
Reward shareholders
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Jim Sinegalrsquos core values for Costco - ABCD Adhering to a strict code of ethics taking care of our employees and members respecting our
suppliers rewarding our shareholders
Bringing the highest quality goods and services to market at the lowest possible prices
Complying to Law seeking to be responsible corporate citizens and environmental stewards
Delivering excellent customer services
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Porterrsquos Five Forces Analysis
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Porterrsquo Five Forces
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
High Rivalry among Existing Competitors
- Fierce competition both from dominant players in wholesale club industry and other forms of retailing businesses (Euromonitor 2015)
- Minimal switching cost involved (Cal State LA nd)
- No notable differentiation between the merchandise offerings of players in the market (Cal State LA nd)
- Competitors compete on pricing and accessibility through frequent new storesrsquo openings (Arthur 2012)
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
High Threat of Substitute Products
- Various types of retailers are available that can be easily accessible such as online retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Products are not differentiated and can be easily purchased at other locations (Cal State LA nd)
- Minimal switching cost especially for members without membership (Cal State LA nd)
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Low Supplier Bargaining Power
- No single supplier who accounts for a large proportion of merchandise that the wholesale club stocks (Cal State LA nd)
- Wholesale clubs are big-volume purchasers
- Dominant firms like Costco and Samrsquos Club possess strong bargaining power due to their reputation in the market
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Moderate Buyer Bargaining Power
- Many customers are individuals who buy in small quantities
- Minimal switching cost involved whereas customers can easily switch to other alternative forms of retailers without facing any substantial disadvantages (Cal State LA nd)
- Undifferentiated productsrsquo (Cal State LA nd)
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Low Threats of New Entrants High entry barriers that are derived from
- Formidable competitors with firm positions in the market that enjoy the benefits of economies of scale that are not easily accessible by new players (Cal State LA nd)
- Effective competition requires sizeable capital (Cal State LA nd)
- Current playersrsquo popularity remain a major obstacle for newcomers to build up trust and customer relationship (MarketLine20 15)
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Financial Performance
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco 2011 2010 2009 2008Net sales 87048 76255 69889 70977 Membership fees 1867 1691 1533 1506 Total Cost 86476 75869 69645 70514 Operating Income 2439 2077 1777 1969
Findings
2011-Strong revenue growth at 141 and a 174
increase in operational profit ndash Flow through
algorithm
2015 ndash Moderate revenue growth at 32
However Operating profit grow at 126 to
maintain the flow through
Membership is the main contributors to Profit
ultra-low pricing mark-up rate
60151
88915
112640 116199
1626
2439
3624
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Operating Income USD Mil Net Income USD Mil
Free Cash Flow USD Mil Revenue USD Mil
Net Revenue (Secondary axis)
COGS NR 877 SGampANR 96
COGS NR 870 SGampA NR 100
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Source 2015 Costco Annual Report
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Growth rate 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015Revenue Year over Year 706 1255 -146 913 1407 115 607 712 3163-Year Average 1021 1104 589 657 705 1155 105 82 5445-Year Average 1069 1124 822 805 813 901 773 954 831Operating Income Year over Year -105 224 -974 1688 1743 1312 1066 547 12553-Year Average 51 1012 301 889 74 1579 137 97 9525-Year Average 729 1123 51 71 845 1139 917 1262 1178Net Income Year over Year -185 1847 -1534 1998 122 1689 1931 093 1553-Year Average 706 646 -052 637 446 1632 161 1207 11635-Year Average 912 1221 424 415 579 956 971 1364 1278EPS Year over Year 304 2194 -1453 1822 1301 1788 1902 043 15483-Year Average 861 985 241 72 452 1635 1661 1211 11355-Year Average 987 1356 595 602 749 1042 988 1349 1296
Back up
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Profitability Market Performance Efficiency
Return on Equity ROE Net Income Earnings per share EPS Net Profit - Minority Interest Asset Turn-over Net RevenueTotal Equity Number of share Total Asset
Return on Asset ROA Net Income Cashflow per share CFPS CFO - Preference dividens Days in Inventories DII InventoriesTotal Asset Number of share COGS
Gross Profit Margin Gross profit Dividen per share DPS Dividens paid Days of Sales Outstanding
DSO AR
Net Revenue Number of share Net Revenue
Profit Margin EBIT Dividen payout ratio Profit distributed as dividens Cash Collecting Cycle DPO
Net Revenue Total Profit
Cashflow to Sales CFO Price Earning ratio PER Current market price Cash Collecting Cycle CCC
Net Revenue EPS
Liquidity Capital Structure
Current ratio Debt ratio LiabilitiesAsset
Quick Asset ratio Debt to Equity LiabilitiesEquity
Cashflow ratio Equity ratio EquityAsset
Cash from Operating ProfitCurrent Liabilities
x 365 days
x 365 days
Current Asset - InventoriesCurrent Liabilities
Current AssetCurrent Liabilities
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
188
161 160
127116 120
108
140
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
ROE
6167
6055 55
49
62
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009
ROA130
126 126
124
126
128 127
124
2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Gross Profit margin
Profitability Ratios
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Liquidity Ratios and Capital Structure
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Is there any link among these ratios
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Profit Margin
Asset Turn-over
Debt ratio
Gross Profit Margin Expense RatioCurrent Asset
Turn-over
DII DSO DPO
CCC Cash Collecting Cycle
ROA Leverage
ROE
Entities Financial Health
Interest Coverage
httpwwwinvestopediacomvideoplaydupont-analysis
DuPont Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
2009 2010 2011 2011Costco -15 91 141 125Sams Club 82 -04 35 129BJ 112 16 68 -71
201055-8114
200910701133
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Net Revenue - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
7248 7142 7795
8892
4434 4798 4781 4946
901 1003 1019 1088
2008 2009 2010 2011
Operating Profit - Bil US$Costco Sams Club BJ
Costco ndash Samrsquos Club - BJ
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco Wholesale Competition
Costco has not only wholesale competitors but also retailers
Two main wholesale competitors are Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
What make they are different competitors
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Position High-traffic routes in or near upscale suburb
Near Wal-Mart Near Costco or Samrsquos Club (within 10 miles)
Items 3600 4000 7000
Treasure - hunt Treasure - hunt items are upscale
Treasure - hunt items are less upscale but cheaper than Costcorsquos
Price Lowest price Low price Low price
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Added service (pharmacy optic gasoline)
Beside BJ also has some special services such as vacation and travel package garden and storage sheds patio and sun rooms
Social Media Website Facebook Twitter
Blogs which be operated by customers to share their experience
Website Facebook Twitter
Website Facebook Twitter
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club Customer Care Service(Returns Refunds amp Exchange Policy)
Payment method approve
Store quality
90 days from the purchase date to return your order for a full refund
All of payment cards which include both Bill Me Later and American Express be approved in Costco
Many customers feel Costco is much cleaner than BJrsquos and prefer to shop at Costco for bulk items
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
American Express Card not be approved
Clear
Electronic device (90 days) other goods (30 days)
One of the payment methods that is not accepted at BJs Wholesale Club at this time is Bill Me Later
Less Clean
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Website Security amp Safety Transfer Money
Delivery method
Use security and safety transfer money by third party ndashMcAfee
Only tires can be shipped to Costco stores for collections and not any others
The rates vary with service required using UPS for its delivery services ensures smooth and timely delivery of products ordered
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
Depend on size and weight of good they will choose shipment method by themselves
Use security and safety transfer money by themselves
BJrsquos Wholesale Club cannot ship packages to PO Boxes
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos Wholesale Club
Membership bull Business members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $55 (include a supplemental card) bull Executive members fee of $100 Save 2 on purchases save on various service offered by Costco and third-party company such as insurance loan real estate and mortgage servicebull Accept goods returns
bullBusiness members fee of $35 (include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $40 (include a supplemental card) bull Premium members fee of $100 (including health care insurance personal and financial service recreational vehicle program) Cash back 2
bullBusiness members fee of $50(include a supplemental card) bull Individual members fee of $50 (include a supplemental card) bullRebate 2bullAccept goods returns
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Competitive Advantages
Costcorsquos wholesale is better than Samrsquos Club amp BJrsquos Wholesale
1 Low Price2 Good customer service3 Good Customer care4 Effective Social network
Costco have winning strategy to focus on customer need (Lowest price) and try to satisfy them (customer care amp service)
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Costcorsquos Prices
Costco Prices are Lowest
(they always try to make try to make price is lower than their rivals)
1 Focusing on customer need (Business strategy)
(Buy quality product with the best price to save money)
2 Try to improve customer care amp service better than other rival ndash payment delivery methodshellip)
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Compensation Policies
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Overview - In 2015 Costco employs about 205000 employees (88000 are part-time employees and 117000 full-time employees) (Statista 2015)
-Ranked as second best employer in the US (Clare 2015)
-The companyrsquos turnover rate is kept at 5 for employees who have worked at Costco for more than a year (Aaron 2014)
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Overview- Craig Jelinek ndash the CEO of Costco believes that a more rewarding workplace will eventually lower employee turnover rate boost their productivity and on-job performance (Aaron 2014)
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Compensation Practices Comparison
Costco Samrsquos Club BJrsquos
Pay rate Average of $20hour (Aaron 2014) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd) $9 ndash 13hour (PayScale nd)
Health-based benefits
Medical Dental Mental health and substance abuse Pharmacy Vision and hearing aid coverage Personal wellness tools care network behavioral health (Costco 2016)
Consumer-directed health plans Vision Dental Counseling services Illness protection (Walmart Careers 2016)
Medical Dental Employee assistance program (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Financial-based benefits
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Money management information employee self-service (Costco 2016)
401(k) retirement plan Stock purchase plan Discount cards when buying at Walmart and Samrsquos club (Walmart Careers 2016)
401(k) retirement plan (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
Other benefits Reimbursement account Various forms of insurance(Costco 2016)
Various forms of insurance (Walmart Careers 2016)
Flexible spending account Various forms of insurance (BJrsquos Careers 2016)
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
COSTCO VS SAMrsquoS CLUB VS BJrsquoS
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES- Well-perceived private label brand (Kirkland
Signature) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Available gasoline and other additional services encourage more frequent shopping (MartketLine 2015)
- Higher market coverage (9 markets) compared to Samrsquos Club (only 4) (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low cost operating model (MarketLine 2015)
- Healthy financial position (Euromonitor 2015)
- Dependence on North America markets (MarketLine 2015)
- Limited product choice (only 3700 products) (MartketLine 2015)
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
SWOT AnalysisOPPORTUNITIES THREATS- International expansion enable Costco to access to a
large customer base(Euromonitor 2015)
- Multichannel retailing enables Costco to widen its reach (Euromonitor 2015)
- Face fierce competition from various types of retailers (Euromonitor 2015)
- Catered to middle-high income class but faces challenges in US as such class proportion continues to decrease (Euromonitor 2015)
- Low customersrsquo loyalty
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Recommendations Recommendation 1 Focus in developing internet retailing and multi-channel strategies
- Capitalize on its strong financial position to invest in creating new retailing channels
- Allow to minimize threats posed by other retailing channels
- Stronger online presence enables Costco to reach a wider customer base
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Recommendations Recommendation 2 Global expansions into untapped markets
- Reduce Costcorsquos dependence on North America market
- Partnerships with other Internet retailers can allow Costco to enter untapped markets without physical presence
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Revision
1 The process of crafting and executing a companyrsquos strategy consists ofA Developing a Strategic missionB Setting ObjectivesC Monitoring and corrective action to short-term fix issuesD All are correct
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Revision2 To improve Cash Collection Cycle the company should
A Extend DSO Shorter DPOB Extend DSO Extend DPOC Shorter DSO Shorter DPOD Shorter DSO Extend DPO
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Revision
3 Four main process in developing Balanced Scorecard
A Translating the vision Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
B Translating the vision Business planning Communicating and linkingF eedback and learning
C Develop mission Business planning Communicating and linking Feedback and learning
D Develop mission Communicating and linking Business planning Feedback and learning
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
Revision4 Which statement is TRUE
A A company achieves competitive advantage when an attractive number of Buyers are drawn to purchase its products or services rather than those of competitors
B A company achieves sustainable advantage when the basis for buyer references for its product offering relative to the offerings of its rivals is durable despite competitorsrsquo efforts to nullify or overcome the appeal of its product offering
C Both are TRUED Both are FALSE
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
References Euromonitor International 2015 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Euromonitor International 2016 Costco Wholesale Canada Ltd in Retailing (Canada) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
MarketLine 2015 Costco Wholesale Corporation Retrieved January 24 2016 from httpwwwmarketlinecom
Statista 2015 Number of Costco employees worldwide from 2011 ndash 2015 (in 1000s) Statista ndash The Statistics Portal Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Aaron T (2014 October 23) Why Costco Pays Its Retail Employees $20 An Hour Business Insider Retrieved from httpwwwbusinessinsidercomcostco-pays-retail-employees-20-an-hour-2014-10
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13
References Cal State LA nd Sample Case Study Costco Retrieved January 23 2016 from httpwebcalstatelaedufacultyklaiCourse497Costcopdf
Clare C (2015 March 25) Americarsquos Best Employers 2015 Forbes Retrieved from httpwwwforbescomsitesclareoconnor20150325americas-best-employers- 20152351e9e76ceb
Costco 2016 Costco Wholesale Corp in Retailing (World) Retrieved January 25 2016 from httpwwweuromonitorcom
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwstatistacomstatistics284430costco-number-of-employees-worldwide-2011-2013
Payscale nd Average Hourly Rate for Sams Club Employees PayScale Retrieved from httpwwwpayscalecomresearchUSEmployer=BJs_Wholesale_ClubHourly_Rate
Arthur A T Strategy Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches The University of Alabama Chapter 2 Page 13