14
Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives? Marie-Renée B-Lajoie, MDCM CORE Group Meeting- October 14th 2011 What is you organization’s experience? A short survey proposition. Remuneration and Incentives for Community Health Workers

Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

 

Citation preview

Page 1: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives?

Marie-Renée B-Lajoie, MDCM CORE Group Meeting- October 14th 2011

What is you organization’s experience? A short survey proposition.

Remuneration and Incentives for Community Health Workers

Page 2: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Plan

• Video• Introduction• Discussion• Survey

McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Page 3: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Video

• http://youtu.be/u6XAPnuFjJc

McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Page 4: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

What motivates us?

Mechanical skills

Performance =

Cognitive skills

Performance ≠

McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Page 5: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

What motivates us?

Once money is off the table:

Autonomy MasteryPurpose

+McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Page 6: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Community Health Workers

Some algorithmic work

But much more than

And other motivators …

McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Page 7: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Motivators

Purpose

StatusSupervision

Justice

…McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Page 8: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Background

Page 9: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Background

Page 10: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

CHWs: Incentives & Disincentives

Relationship with community = IMPORTANTMIX intrinsic & extrinsicCHWs need to be recognized as volunteersNeed to understand: WHY are CHWs dropping

out?More research on financing schemes &

retention/attrition are needed

McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Bhattacharyya et al. CHWs: Incentives & Disincentives

Page 11: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Our survey

Document current practices in CHW programs – Monetary & non-monetary incentives– Relation to attrition

•Based on the population of iNGOs affiliated with the CORE group•NOT representative of ALL CHWs programs•BUT sample of program experiences

McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Page 12: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Discussion points • In your programs, what monetary incentives have

contributed to the success/good performance ? • What monetary incentives have proven

problematic or disincentivized CHW performance?

• What are the most important ethical and practical issues at play in your experience with deciding on CHW incentives and compensation?

• Are their national guidelines to help guide this process where you work? How has this been helpful or problematic?

McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Page 13: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Survey

Paper copy

OR

https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/CHW-Survey

McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie

Page 14: Payday, Ponchos, or a Plethora of Incentives_Lajoie_10.14.11

Conclusion

• Complex subject• Promote research • Exchange experiences

Thank you ! Merci [email protected]

McGill Humanitarian Studies Initiative - Lajoie