QUIETING THE ECHOES - a case study for creatives

!"#$%&'&'("%')"*+%*,&'("*+'-./#%'*0"1+$"*$2%#&32-

!"#$%#&'(%)$(*+),$-!"4%-2"5#.)0"&'",+6"4+%*,&'("7/23%#2)"%"4$2%#&32"8$+12--&+'%/9-"8$+).*#&3&#0

:,&-"*%-2"-#.)0"6%-"6$&##2'"#+"&//.-#$%#2"#,2"3%/.2"+1"*+%*,&'("1+$"*$2%#&32"C$+12--&+'%/-@

?<2?;9*

*6*20(1/377*=>*

59<=5!<*

P#9-"6$&##2'"6&#,"#,2"?2/&21"#,%#"232$0"*,%//2'(2"&-"%"+'*2G&'G%G/&12#&>2"-&#.%#&+'"#,%#"-&>&/%$/0"$2A.&$2-".'&A.2"-+/.#&+'-"%')"%CC$+%*,2-@""

D,&/2"#,&-"C%$#&*./%$"*%-2"-#.)0"6%-"'+#")2-&('2)"#+"?2"C$2-*$&C#&32;"&#"2')-"6&#,"%"-&>C/2"1$%>26+$<"+1"A.2-#&+'-"1+$"#,2"$2%)2$"#+"*+'-&)2$;"&1"#,&-"*,%//2'(2"122/-"1%>&/&%$@

43:7*(,@(1;=4*=49Q!4RSTUVWOB""4/&2'#"-&#.%#&+'

OP54UK7TXB"""V')2$-#%')&'("#,2"*,%//2'(2

OP!SWU5P5B"""D,%#9-"#,2".')2$/0&'("*%.-2Y

5UZV:PUWB"""D,%#")&)"62"C$+C+-2Y

[77OQ!4RB"""4/&2'#9-"C2$-C2*#&32

5VFF!TXB"""D,%#"%$2"#,2"<20"#%<2%6%0-Y

T7!O7T"!88ZP4!:PUWB"""\+6"#+"%CC/0"%-"$2%)2$Y

D$&##2'"%')")2-&('2)"?0"Q$&%'":%>7)&#2)"6&#,"/+32"?0"(++)"1$&2')-

]%>2-;"%")2-&('"2H2*.#&32"#.$'2)"2'#$2C$2'2.$;"6%-"1$.-#$%#2)"#,%#",&-"'26"?.-&'2--"6%-'9#">+3&'("1+$6%$)@""\2"#.$'2)"#+"*+%*,&'("#+"%))$2--"#,&-"*,%//2'(2@

:31A>2;<=8

F(G0*4HFI4*00G0J4.'4-04K0))4D'*>.>'@0J4.'4)0(J4L>*4*.(M.?D;"6&#,"^_"02%$-"+1"-+/&)"2HC2$&2'*2"&'",&-"&').-#$0;"6,&*,"&'*/.)2)"/2%)&'(",&-"1+$>2$"*+>C%'0E-"4,&'%"2HC%'-&+'"#2%>@

!1#2$"$2%/&`&'("*+$C+$%#2"C+/&#&*-"6%-"'+#"1+$",&>;",2")2*&)2)"#+"C.$-.2",&-"/+'(G,2/)")$2%>"+1"-#%$#&'(",&-"+6'"1&$>@""X2#;"%1#2$"%"C2$&+)"+1"#&>2;",&-"?.-&'2--"6%-'9#">+3&'("1+$6%$)"%-",2"<'26"&#"*+./)@

\2"($26">+$2"%')">+$2"1$.-#$%#2)"%#",&-"-#%('%#&+'@""D,0"6%-"#,&-",%CC2'&'(Y

$%+"77$9"%6"

"!=63+$8%

"N5":$"%6"

5:89:";;

!"#$%#&'(%)$(*+),$-

8591;6*20Q21+$2",2%$&'("%?+.#"*+%*,&'(;"]"1+*.-2)"+'"-+/.#&+'-"#,%#"#%$(2#2)",&-"/%*<"+1"C$+($2--@""X2#;"6%-"#,&-",&-"#$.2"*,%//2'(2"+$">2$2/0"%"-0>C#+>"+1"

-+>2#,&'(")22C2$Y

204L(J4.M>0J40O0MP.L>@&4()M0(JPQ"1$+>"C$+).*#&3&#0"-+1#6%$2;"#+"*,%'(&'(",&-"+11&*2"2'3&$+'>2'#;"%')"232'"*+'-&)2$2)"*+'#%*#&'("%",2%),.'#2$;"a.-#"&'"*%-2",2"*+./)'9#"(2#"#,2"?.-&'2--"(+&'(@

Z&<2">%'0"C2+C/2;"]"%/-+"#.$'2)"#+",&-"C22$-"1+$"%)3&*2"6,+"-.((2-#2)",2"'+#"#+",%32"%"C%$#'2$"#+"-#$2%>/&'2",&-"-#%$#.C@"Z%#2$"62")&-*+32$2)"#,&-"%)3&*2"#.$'2)"+.#"#+"?2"62//G&'#2'#&+'2)"?.#"#,2"./#&>%#2/0"6$+'("1+$"]@

5+",&-"*,%//2'(2"-#&//"C2$-&-#2)")2-C&#2"#,2-2"$2>2)&2-;"6,&*,")&)"'+#"%))$2--"#,2"1.')%>2'#%/"">&')-2#-"#,%#"6%-"#,2"*%.-2"+1"#,2-2"$2-./#-@

:+"1&')"%'"2112*#&32"%')"/%-#&'("-+/.#&+';"+.$"*+%*,&'("-2--&+'-"-2%$*,2)"1+$"#,2"b$++#"*%.-2c"+1"]9-"1$.-#$%#&+'@

R$%!;"+4!:$C"4:";=7+;

623%9"4,8=:4R$%!;"+4+84623%9"4,8=:4:";=7+;4+%*,&'(",2/C-"0+."#+"2HC/+$2"#,&-"*,%&'"+1"232'#-;"-+"0+.".')2$-#%')"0+.$".'*+'-*&+.-">+#&3%#&+'-;"?2/&21-;"%')"+#,2$">&')-2#-"#,%#")2#2$>&'2"%*#&+'-"%')"#,2$21+$2"$2-./#-@

R$%!;"+

:";=7+;

36+$8%;

-.?*+'-*&+.-

)2-&('"62?-&#2

:";=7+;

36+$8%;

R$%!;"+;D,%#"&-"#,2"1+.')%#&+'"+1",&-"#,+.(,#-Y""

D2")&-*+32$2)"I")&-#&'*#"&)2'#&#&2-"#,%#"]".-2)"&'",&-"6+$<@

D,0"6%-",2")+&'("-+">%'0")&112$2'#"#,&'(-Y""

D2"2H%>&'2)",&-"?2,%3&+$-"%')"#,2">+#&3%#&+'-"?2,&')"#,2>"#+"$232%/",&-">&')-2#-@

!$94!""5":4#8:4+2"4:88+463=;"!-"62"*+'#&'.2)"+.$"*+%*,&'(;"]"$232%/2)"#,%#",2",%)"2A.%/"2HC2$&2'*2"&'"2%*,"+1"#,2"I">%a+$"%(2'*0"$+/2-B"#,2"*$2%#&32"/2%);"#,2"#2*,'&*%/"/2%);"%')"#,2"-%/2-"/2%)@""

:,&-"#.$'2)"+.#"#+"?2"%'"&>C+$#%'#"$232/%#&+'@

D,%#"6%-"*%.-&'(",&-"/%*<"+1"C$+($2--Y""

D2"6%'#2)"#+"(+"?20+')"#,2"-.C2$1&*&%/"*,%//2'(2"%')")&(")22C2$"#+".')2$-#%')"]9-"6,+/2"-&#.%#&+'@

O>*>.4/)>0@.*

6$&#2"C$+C+-%/-

?.&/)"'26"$2/%#&+'-,&C-J0*>&@4@0K4&M(DL>/*

6$&#2"*+C0

&'-C&$2"#2%>

)2#2$>&'2"-#$%#2(0

/++<"1+$"C%$#'2$-

2)&#"*+C0%##2')"232'#-

>%<2"C&#*,

/2%$'"-+1#6%$2

*$2%#2"*+'*2C#-

)$%1#"C&#*,

*0.4O>*>'@4

736<48#45:89:";;

6:"3+$C" ;37";47"3! +"6247"3!

/++<"1+$"+CC+$#.'&#&2-

!"#$%#&'(%)$(*+),$-

;?D0MS>/>())PT4L>*40UD0M>0@/04G>&L.4-04*00@4(*4(4D'*>.>O0V4"

82$,%C-;"#,&-"6+./)"%//+6",&>"#+"/++<"%#"?.-&'2--",+/&-#&*%//0;">+$2"-#$%#2(&*%//0@""[.$#,2$>+$2;"#,&-"6%-"*+./)"?2"23&)2'*2"-.CC+$#&'("#,2"%)3&*2",2%$)"?21+$2B",2")&)'9#"'22)"#+",&$2"%-">%'0"C2+C/2"+$"1&')"%"C%$#'2$"?2*%.-2"+1"#,&-")&32$-2"-<&//"-2#-@

\+6232$;"%-"62"*+'#&'.2)"#+")&(")22C2$;"]"$232%/2)"%'"&>C+$#%'#"C%##2$'@""\2"6+./)"#,&'<"1$+>")&112$2'#"C+&'#-"+1"3&26-;"2%*,"/2%)&'(",&>"#+")&112$2'#"*+'*/.-&+'-@":,&-"$2C2%#2)"6&#,+.#"2')"%')"%-",&-">&')"1&//2)"6&#,"A.2-#&+'-;",2"?2*%>2"*+'1.-2);"C$+($2--"-/+62);"%')"1$.-#$%#&+'"1/%$2)@""]9-"-#$2'(#,"6%-"%*#.%//0"*%.-&'(",&-"*,%//2'(2d

128413;47"3!$%94+2"413,W!-"%"32$-%#&/2"*$2%#&32"C$+12--&+'%/;"]"6%-"%?/2"#+"#,&'<"%?+.#",&-"?.-&'2--"1$+>">./#&C/2"C2$-C2*#&32-@""

D%-"#,&-"%"-#$2'(#,"+$"62%<'2--Y

6:"3+$C"Eb6,%#")+"62"6%'#Yc

;37";47"3!Eb6,%#")+2-"#,2"*/&2'#"6%'#Yc

+"6247"3!Eb,+6")+"P">%<2"&#Yc

"bV'#&/"0+."!"#$%&'$%()*+),*-+(,%*+),*-+(,;"&#"6&//")&$2*#"0+.$"/&12"%')"0+."6&//"*%//"&#"

1%#2@c""

4@S@"].'(

6:"3+$C"

;37";47"3!

+"6247"3!

853>=;959

+L>*4K(*4L>*4M''.4/(?*0E4#,&-"#%'(/2"+1"#,+.(,#-"#,%#"$2-./#2)"&'",&-"-2'-2"+1"*+'1.-&+'"%?+.#"6,&*,"6%-"#,2"$&(,#"C+&'#"+1"3&26"#+"1+//+6@""!(($2(%#2)"1+$"232$0")2*&-&+'"232$0")%0;"#,&-"6%-"6,%#"6%-"?2,&')",&-"*+>C%'09-"-#%('%#&+'@

D,%#9-"#,2"C+#2'#&%/",%$>Y""Q2-&)2-">%<&'("/&##/2"C$+($2--;"&>%(&'2"&1"]",%)"a.-#"-#.??+$'/0"=C+62$2)"#,$+.(,="6&#,"%//"#,$22"&)2'#&#&2-@""\&-"#2%>"6+./)"?2""a.-#"%-"*+'1.-2)"%?+.#"#,2"C$&+$&#&2-"%-",2"6%-@""P'"#.$';"#,2"A.%/&#0"+1"6+$<")2/&32$2)"#+"#,2"*/&2'#-"/&<2/0"6+./)"-.112$"%-"%"$2-./#"%-"62//@

D&#,+.#"%"*/2%$"&)2'#",2"6+./)"/%*<"#,2"*+'-&-#2'#"*/&2'#"-%#&-1%*#&+'"&-"*$&#&*%/"#+"(2'2$%#&'("#,2"$2C2%#"-%/2-"#,%#"%//"?.-&'2--2-"'22)"#+"?2"-.-#%&'%?/2@

]"6%-".'%6%$2"+1",&-"C$&>%$0"&)2'#&#0"%')"6,%#"&#"-,+./)"?2@""\2")2-*$&?2)"#,2"$2-./#&'("#,+.(,#"C%##2$'"%-"#,2"b2*,+"*,%>?2$-"+1"#,2">&')@c"

123+4$;4$!"%+$+,W

!'"&)2'#&#0"&-",+6"0+."3&26"0+.$-2/1"%')"#,2"?2,%3&+$-"#,%#"(+"%/+'("6&#,"&#@"":,&-"%112*#-".-"-.?*+'-*&+.-/0;"%')"#0C&*%//0"#,2""&')&3&).%/"&-'9#"%6%$2"+1"#,2&$"&)2'#&#0@

[+$"2H%>C/2;"0+.">%0"&)2'#&10"0+.$-2/1"%#",+>2"%-"%"b1%#,2$;c"6,&*,"0+.">%0"%--+*&%#2"6&#,"?2&'("#,2"C$&>%$0"?$2%)6&''2$"1+$"#,2"1%>&/0@"":,2$21+$2;"0+.">&(,#"3&26"0+.$"*%$22$"%-"2H#$2>2/0"&>C+$#%'#"#+"?2&'("%">2>?2$"+1"#,2"1%>&/0@""

8$+?/2>-"%$&-2"6,2'"#,2$29-"%"(%C"+$"%">&-%/&('>2'#"?2#622'"$2%/"2HC2*#%#&+'-;"%')"-2/1GC2$*2C#&+'@

+2"4"6284623RB":;"G"#,+.(,#-"2')/2--/0"?+.'*2)"%$+.')"&'"]9-",2%)"6&#,+.#"%'0"*+'*/.-&+'@

!"#$%#&'(%)$(*+),$-

9;7<45;=:,2"-+/.#&+'"6%-"#+"1&$-#;"C&'C+&'#",&-"C$&>%$0"&)2'#&#0"%')"-2*+')/0;"%)3&-2",&>"+'"-#$%#2(&2-"#,%#"%//+6",&>"6+./)"?2-#"/232$%(2"&#"#+">+32",&-"*+>C%'0"1+$6%$)@

FX*4DM0S0MM0J4D'>@.4'S4O>0K4.?M@0J4'?.4.'4-04.L04/M0(.>O0V44\2">%)2"#,&-"$2%/&`%#&+'"1$+>"*+%*,&'("2H2$*&-2-"#,%#"%//+62)",&>"#+"$21/2*#"+'",&-"$+/2G>+)2/-;"#,2"C2+C/2"&'",&-"&').-#$0"#,%#",2"%)>&$2);"6,&*,",&'#2)"%#",&-"C$212$$2'*2"%')"%/-+"(%32",&>"*+'1&)2'*2"+'*2",2"$2%/&`2)"+#,2$-",%)"/2)"#,2&$"?.-&'2--"&'"-&>&/%$"6%0-@

:,2"'2H#"-#2C"6%-"#+"-.((2-#">2#,+)-"#+"1+-#2$"%')"-#$2'(#,2'"#,&-">&')-2#"?+#,"&'"#,2"/+'("%')"-,+$#"#2$>@

:,2"/+'(G#2$>"-+/.#&+'-">2%'#"%"*,%'(2"+1">&')-2#;"&'*/.)&'("%">2'#%/"3&-.%/&`%#&+'"2H2$*&-2"#,%#"%//+62)",&>"#+"*+'-*&+.-/0"=-#2C"&'#+="#,%#"$+/2@"":,&-"#2*,'&A.2"6&#,"C$%*#&*2;"-.CC+$#2)"?0"+#,2$"-&>C/2"$2>&')2$-"+32$"#&>2;"6+./)"(&32",&>"*+'1&)2'*2"#+"1.//0"&>>2$-2",&>-2/1"&'"#,2"$+/2"+1"#,2"*$2%#&32@

R'*.4>GG0J>(.0)PT4L04S'?@J4(@4>GD'M.(@.4*L'M.Y.0MG4*')?.>'@B"#+"-2%$*,"1+$"%"?.-&'2--"C%$#'2$@"":,$+.(,"*+%*,&'(;",2"$2%/&`2)"#,%#"#,2"%)3&*2"(&32'"?0",&-"C22$-">&(,#"%*#.%//0"$.'"*+'#$%$0"#+",&-"'%#.$%/"C2$-+'%/"6,&*,"6%-"#+",%32"-+>2+'2"#+"#%/<"#+"6,2'">%<&'("%")2*&-&+'@

U'*2"%"-.&#%?/2"C%$#'2$"6%-"1+.');",&-"C$212$$2)"&)2'#&#0"6+./)"?2"1.$#,2$"-#$2'(#,2'2);"%-"+#,2$"C+&'#-"+1"3&26"6+./)"?2">2'#%//0"b+.#-+.$*2)c"-+",2"*+./)"1+*.-"+'")$&3&'("#,2"?.-&'2--"1+$6%$)"1$+>"%"-&'(/2"C+&'#"+1"3&26@

:,2"<20"#+",&-".'?/+*<&'(",&-"C$+($2--"6%-")&-*+32$&'(",&-"C$&>%$0"&)2'#&#0"%')"#,2'"*$2%#&'("*.-#+>&`2)"-+/.#&+'-"%$+.')"#,%#@

6:"3+$C"

;37";47"3!

+"6247"3!

12$624$!"%+$+,4$;4B";+W

\&-#+$0",%-"-,+6'"?.-&'2--2-"#,$&32"6,2'"#,2"/2%)2$",%-"%"*/2%$"&)2'#"6,%#232$"#,%#">&(,#"?2@""P'"1%*#;"&#"*+./)"232'"%'0"+1"#,2"#,$22"C+&'#-"+1"3&26"#,%#"]",%)@

[+$"2H%>C/2;"5#232"]+?-"1%>+.-/0"/2)"!CC/2"6&#,"*$2%#&32")2-&(';"6,&/2"F&*,%2/"O2//"/2)"%-"%"-%/2-"%')")&-#$&?.#&+'">%-#2$;"%')"PQF",%-"/+'("/232$%(2)"&#-"#2*,'&*%/"-#$2'(#,-@

!-"/+'("%-"?.-&'2--"/2%)2$-"^N"*+'1&)2'#/0"$2*+('&`2"#,2&$"C$&>%$0"&)2'#&#0"%')"eN"%/&('"#,2&$"#2%>"#+"*+>C/&>2'#"&#;"*+>C%'&2-"*%'"-.**22)"6&#,"%"3%$&2#0"+1"&)2'#&#&2-@

37$9%R"%+"G"?0")&-*+32$&'(",&-"'%#.$%/"&)2'#"]"#,2'"*+./)"C$&+$&#&`2"#,2"%*#&3&#&2-"#,%#">+32)",&>"1+$6%$)"#,2">+-#@

FX*4DM0S0MM0J4D'>@.4'S4O>0K4.?M@0J4'?.4.'4-04.L04/M0(.>O0V44\2">%)2"#,&-"$2%/&`%#&+'"1$+>"*+%*,&'("2H2$*&-2-"#,%#"%//+62)",&>"#+"$21/2*#"+'",&-"$+/2G>+)2/-;"#,2"C2+C/2"&'",&-"&').-#$0"#,%#",2"%)>&$2);"6,&*,",&'#2)"%#",&-"C$212$$2'*2"%')"%/-+"(%32",&>"*+'1&)2'*2"+'*2",2"$2%/&`2)"+#,2$-",%)"/2)"#,2&$"?.-&'2--"&'"-&>&/%$"6%0-@

:,2"'2H#"-#2C"6%-"#+"-.((2-#">2#,+)-"#+"1+-#2$"%')"-#$2'(#,2'"#,&-">&')-2#"?+#,"&'"#,2"/+'("%')"-,+$#"#2$>@

:,2"/+'(G#2$>"-+/.#&+'-">2%'#"%"*,%'(2"+1">&')-2#;"&'*/.)&'("%">2'#%/"3&-.%/&`%#&+'"2H2$*&-2"#,%#"%//+62)",&>"#+"*+'-*&+.-/0"=-#2C"&'#+="#,%#"$+/2@"":,&-"#2*,'&A.2"6&#,"C$%*#&*2;"-.CC+$#2)"?0"+#,2$"-&>C/2"$2>&')2$-"+32$"#&>2;"6+./)"(&32",&>"*+'1&)2'*2"#+"1.//0"&>>2$-2",&>-2/1"&'"#,2"$+/2"+1"#,2"*$2%#&32@

R'*.4>GG0J>(.0)PT4L04S'?@J4(@4>GD'M.(@.4*L'M.Y.0MG4*')?.>'@B"#+"-2%$*,"1+$"%"?.-&'2--"C%$#'2$@"":,$+.(,"*+%*,&'(;",2"$2%/&`2)"#,%#"#,2"%)3&*2"(&32'"?0",&-"C22$-">&(,#"%*#.%//0"$.'"*+'#$%$0"#+",&-"'%#.$%/"C2$-+'%/"6,&*,"6%-"#+",%32"-+>2+'2"#+"#%/<"#+"6,2'">%<&'("%")2*&-&+'@

U'*2"%"-.&#%?/2"C%$#'2$"6%-"1+.');",&-"C$212$$2)"&)2'#&#0"6+./)"?2"1.$#,2$"-#$2'(#,2'2);"%-"+#,2$"C+&'#-"+1"3&26"6+./)"?2">2'#%//0"b+.#-+.$*2)c"-+",2"*+./)"1+*.-"+'")$&3&'("#,2"?.-&'2--"1+$6%$)"1$+>"%"-&'(/2"C+&'#"+1"3&26@

:,2"<20"#+",&-".'?/+*<&'(",&-"C$+($2--"6%-")&-*+32$&'(",&-"C$&>%$0"&)2'#&#0"%')"#,2'"*$2%#&'("*.-#+>&`2)"-+/.#&+'-"%$+.')"#,%#@

37$9%"!4.'4;=66""!U'*2"]")&-*+32$2)",&-"C$&>%$0"&)2'#&#0"6%-"#,2"*$2%#&32;"C$&+$&#&2-"?2*%>2"*/2%$;"%')",2"6%-"%?/2"#+"%*,&232"#,2"$2-./#-",&-"?.-&'2--"'22)2)@ )2-&('-"62?-&#2

3&-&#-"*/&2'#-

6$&#2-"C$+C+-%/-

?.&/)-"'26"$2/%#&+'-,&C-

)2-&('-"'26"($%C,&*-

6$&#2-"*+C0

&'-C&$2-"#2%>

)2#2$>&'2-"-#$%#2(0

/++<-"1+$"C%$#'2$-

2)&#-"*+C0

%##2')-"232'#-

>%<2-"C&#*,

/2%$'-"-+1#6%$2

*$2%#2-"*+'*2C#-

)$%1#-"C&#*,

-2#-"3&-&+'"

68R57"+";5:8F"6+

6:"3+$C"

;37";47"3!

+"6247"3!

/++<-"1+$"+CC+$#.'&#&2-

67"3:7,;"+;C$;$8%

;"77;C$;$8%4+867$"%+

!"#$%#&'(%)$(*+),$-

B**8:31A4,2*<&'("&'"f">+'#,-"/%#2$;"62"-%6",&-"-#%$#.C"6%-"-.**2--1.//0"($+6&'("%')"]"6%-"6+$<&'("+'"%"'.>?2$"+1"*$2%#&32"C$+a2*#-"1+$",&-"*/&2'#-@

F4G(J04*'G04*)>&L.4.K0(Z*4(.4K'MZ4.'4S'*.0M4L>*4/M0(.>O04>J0@.>.PV""[+$"2H%>C/2;",2"62'#"?%*<"#+"C2'"%')"C%C2$"#+")$%1#"&)2%-">+$2"A.&*</0"%')"1$22/0@""\2"%/-+"a+&'2)"%"($+.C"+1"*$2%#&32"2'#$2C$2'2.$-"#+",2%$">./#&C/2"C+&'#-"+1"3&26;")&-*.--"*,%//2'(2-;"%')"-,%$2"&)2%-@

522>&'(/0"+/)G1%-,&+'2)"%')"/+6G#2*,;"#,2"&>C+$#%'#"#,&'("6%-"#,%#"#,2-2"-.((2-#&+'-"62$2"#%&/+$2)"#+"]9-"C2$-+'%/"*,%//2'(2"%')"%//+62)",&>"*+'#&'.2"#+"($+6@

#:8R4F3R";EP"$2%//0"%CC$2*&%#2)"#,2"*+%*,&'(@""D,%#"$2%//0">%)2"#,2"?&((2-#")&112$2'*2"6%-"-&>C/0".')2$-#%')&'("6,%#">0"*,%//2'(2"6%-"L>2'#%/"2*,+2-N@""P9>"-.$2"+'2"+1"#,2"$2%-+'-"P"-#+CC2)"($+6&'("?20+')"%"*2$#%&'"C+&'#"6%-"#++">.*,"2*,+;"'+"#$%*#&+'@"

!/-+;"6,%#"-#.*<"+.#"6%-"#,2"&>>2)&%#2/0"%*#&+'%?/2"-+/.#&+'-"-.((2-#2)"/&<2",%3&'(">+$2"C22$")&-*.--&+'-"%')"#,&'<&'("6&#,"&'<@""

U.$"-2--&+'-"(%32">0"1+2"%"'%>2"%')"#++/-"#+">%<2"C2%*2@"":,%'<"0+.dc

[8?M4*0**>'@*4&(O04GP4S'04(4@(G0T4(@J4.'')*4.'4G(Z04D0(/0V\

"C":,462377"%9"4$;4=%$]="4#+">%<2"($2%#"*,%'(2;"C2$-+'%/&`2"2%*,"-+/.#&+'-"1+$"2%*,".'&A.2"*,%//2'(2@

R$%!;"+

:";=7+;

36+$8%;

5":;8%37$^"!4;87=+$8%

9<CC320

63;"4B36<9:8=%!E]%>2-;"%"#%/2'#2)")2-&('"C$+12--&+'%/;"-#$.((/2)"#+"/%.'*,",&-"'26"?.-&'2--"%')")&)'9#"<'+6"6,0@

!$;68C":,E4\&-"*%$22$"-C%''2)"I")&-#&'*#"$+/2-;"#,2"*$2%#&32;"#,2"-%/2-"/2%)"%')"#2*,'&*%/"/2%)@""W+6"%-"#,2"1&$>9-"1+.')2$;",2"-#$.((/2)"#+"a.((/2"#,2-2"$+/2-"&'",&-",2%)@"":,&-"/2)"#+"*+'1.-&+'"%')"&'"#.$';",&-"/%*<"+1"C$+).*#&3&#0@

!$39%8;$;E4\2"6%-".'%6%$2"+1",&-"C$&>%$0"&)2'#"#,2"C+&'#"+1"3&26"#,%#"6%-",&-">+-#"'%#.$%/"-#$2'(#,@""

;87=+$8%E"Q0"-.((2-#&'("-+/.#&+'-"#,%#"%//+62)"]"#+"1+*.-"%')"1+-#2$",&-"'%#.$%/"*$2%#&32"&)2'#"C$&+$&#&2-"?2*%>2"+?3&+.-"#+",&>"%')",&-"-#%$#.C"6%-"%?/2"#+"2/23%#2"&#-"C2$1+$>%'*2@

<",4+3<"313,;G"Q.-&'2--"/2%)2$-">.-#"?2"*/2%$"%?+.#"#,2&$"&)2'#&#0"#+"%)3+*%#2"%")21&'&#&32")&$2*#&+'"%')"$%//0"#,2"#2%>"?2,&')"%"*$0-#%/"*/2%$"3&-&+'@

G"[+$"*,%'(2"#+"?2"C2$>%'2'#;"62">.-#"2H%>&'2"#,2".')2$/0&'(">&')-2#-;"%')"?.&/)"*.-#+>&`2)"-+/.#&+'-"%$+.')"#,%#"-C2*&1&*"-&#.%#&+'@

:,&-"*%-2"-#.)0"C$+3&)2)"%'"2H%>C/2"+1",+6"*+%*,&'(">%0"?2".-21./"1+$"*$2%#&32"C$+12--&+'%/-"#+".'*+32$">2'#%/"+?-#%*/2-"%')"$2*2&32"(.&)%'*2"#+"%*,&232"#,2&$")2-&$2)"$2-./#-@"

bX+.$"3&-&+'-"6&//"?2*+>2"*/2%$"+'/0"6,2'"0+."*%'"/++<"&'#+"0+.$"+6'",2%$#@"

D,+"/++<-"+.#-&)2;")$2%>-g"6,+"/++<-"&'-&)2;"%6%<2-@c"

4@S@"].'(

!"#$%#&'(%)$(*+),$-

3??751345;=732$0"*,%//2'(2"&-".'&A.2g"XUVT"*,%//2'(2"&-".'&A.2@"":,2-2"-22>&'(/0"-&>C/2"A.2-#&+'-"%$2"%"(++)"-#%$#&'(GC+&'#"#+"$21/2*#"+'"0+.$"C%$#&*./%$"-&#.%#&+'@

#8:4B";+4:";=7+;T4+3<"4+2"4+$R"4+84+2$%<41$+245"%43%!4535":V

L^N"D,%#"$+/2")+"0+."&)2%//0")2-&$2"#+"C/%0"&'"0+.$"?.-&'2--Y""D,0Y

LeN"D,%#"&-"-#+CC&'("0+."1$+>"C/%0&'("#,%#"$+/2"'+6Y""D,0Y

LIN"O+"0+."-&'*2$2/0"6%'#"#+"#$%'-1+$>"0+.$-2/1"&'#+"#,%#"$+/2Y""D,0Y

LhN"D,%#"6&//"0+.")+"?0"#,2"2')"+1"#+)%0"#+">%<2"->%//"M"-&('&1&*%'#"*,%'(2Y

F+$2"-C%*2"1+$"0+.$"($2%#"&)2%-"+'"#,2"/%-#"C%(2@""[+$"122)?%*<"+$"#+")&-*.--"6&#,"%"Z2#9-"F%<2"ST7!:d"*+%*,;"2>%&/"0+.$"%'-62$-"#+"?$&%'i/2#->%<2($2%#@*+>@

:,20"%$2"#,2"+'2-"*$2%#&'("+.$"1.#.$2;"#%*</&'("=1+$"#,2"1&$-#"#&>2"232$="*,%//2'(2-"%')"%&>&'("#+"%*,&232"?&("$2-./#-@

:,20"%//"%/-+"-,%$2)"#,&-".'&A.2"*,%//2'(2B""#,2")+.?#;"12%$"%')"?/.$$2)"#,&'<&'("#,%#"+1#2'"%**+>C%'&2-"#%<&'("+'"'26"*,%//2'(2-"%')"

)+&'("#,&'(-"#,%#",%32"'232$"?22'")+'2"?21+$2@

D2".')2$-#%')"#,&-"?2*%.-2"62E32"(+'2"#,$+.(,"&#"+.$-2/32-"%')",%32"1&(.$2)"%"6%0"#+",2/C"

*$2%#&32"/2%)2$-"+32$*+>2"#,+-2"+?-#%*/2-"%')"%*,&232"%(%&'@

./0(12*3456*(7*38*29

3:;<4(1;31/5=>

!"#$%"&'()*

$!"%+$#,'-*.(/)0*

123+434+,5$637468362$%945:86";;4$;47$<"

+3<"436+$8%

=%!":;+3%!*>.?(.>'@

;=558:+4A4#""!B36<

!"C"785(/.>'@4D)(@

4+%*,&'("&-"-&>C/0"%"*+'32$-%#&+'")2-&('2)"#+",2/C"*/&2'#-"%*,&232"($2%#2$"(+%/-@F%'0"*/&2'#-"6%'#"*+%*,&'("?2*%.-2"#,20"122/"1$.-#$%#2)"%?+.#"#,2&$"*,%//2'(2-;"*+'1.-2)"%?+.#"#,2"?2-#"*+.$-2"+1"%*#&+';"+$",%32"%"-2$&+.-"-2'-2"+1".'2%-2"%?+.#"#,2&$"1.#.$2@

:,$+.(,"%"-2$&2-"+1"-#$%#2(&*"*+'32$-%#&+'-;"#,2"*+%*,"(.&)2-"#,2"*/&2'#"#+"&//.>&'%#2"?/&')G-C+#-;"2HC%')"C+--&?&/&#&2-"%')"*$2%#2"%*#&+'"C/%'-"#+"%*,&232"#,2&$")2-&$2)"(+%/-@"

:,2"*+%*,&'("-2--&+'-"C$+3&)2"#,2"*/&2'#"%"-%12"-C%*2"6&#,"I$)"C%$#0"C2$-C2*#&32"#+"6+$<"#,$+.(,"#,2&$"*,%//2'(2-;".')2$-#%')"#,2&$"122/&'(-"%')")&-*+32$"'26"-+/.#&+'-@

B"%"#$+;48#468362$%9J"&'*$2%-2)"C2$1+$>%'*2

J"*$2%#&32"*+'1&)2'*2

J"I$)"C%$#0"C2$-C2*#&32

J"2>+#&+'%/"-.CC+$#

J",&(,2$"-2/1G%6%$2'2--

J"C2%*2"+1">&')

+2";"46:"3+$C";4$%67=!"EG"4+$C+$%#2"K&-&+'%$&2-"%')"K2#2$%'-G"F%$<2#&'("%')"!)32$#&-&'("7H2*.#&32-G"7'#$2C$2'2.$-"L-2$&%/;"-+/+"M"'26?&2-NG"!$#&-#-;"D$&#2$-;"O2-&('2$-G"8$+).*#"P''+3%#&+'"F%'%(2$-

!"#$%#&'(%)$(*+),$-

Q$&%'"/2%)-"#2%>-"#+"ST7!:"?0"*$2%#&'("'26"C+--&?&/&#&2-d

!-"%"*$2%#&3&#0"#$%&'2$"%')"*+%*,;",2"ZUK75"&''+3%#&+'"M"2'#$2C$2'2.$-,&C@":,2"+'/0"#,&'("?2##2$"&-"$2%//0"#%<&'("!4:PUW"#+"*+'32$#"*$2%#&32"-C%$<-"&'#+"C+62$1./"1/%>2-@

U$&(&'%//0"1$+>"W26"X+$<;"Q$&%'">+32)"#+"5,%'(,%&"&'"e__j"#+")$&32"#,2"1%'#%-#&*"*,%'(2"#,%#"&-",%CC2'&'("&'"4,&'%"M"#,2"6+$/)@""\2"-22-"%"'2%$"1.#.$2"6,2$2"($2%#"PWWUK!:PUW"*+'#&'+.-/0"*+>2-"1$+>"4,&'%;"%')">%<2-"#,2"6+$/)"232'"?2##2$d

D%'#"#+")&-*.--"ST7!:Y""?$&%'i/2#->%<2($2%#@*+>

C**4(7*4!9(C3A*(>2*34"

B:$3%4+3R*$2%#&3&#0"*%#%/0-#

%$=47"$-+*&%/"*,%'(2>%<2$

[$+>"5,%'(,%&"(22<"#+"(/+?%/"*,%'(2>%<2$;"W&."Z2&"*/2%$/0"-22-"?+#,"#,2"W77O"1+$"*+>C%'&2-"&'"4,&'%"%')"#,2"O75PT7"1$+>"&#-"C2+C/2"1+$"-+*&%/"&''+3%#&+'@

:,2"+'/0"6%0"#+"-.**22)"&'#+"#,2"1.#.$2"&-"#+")2-&('"+$(%'&`%#&+'-"6&#,"\7!T:"#,%#"-&'*2$2/0"1+*.-"+'"#,2"I8-B"C/%'2#;"C2+C/2;"%')"C$+1&#-@

:+">%<2"#,%#",%CC2';",2"?2/&232-"62">.-#")232/+C"#,2"'2H#"(2'2$%#&+'"+1"/2%)2$-"&'"4,&'%g"C2+C/2"6,+"*%'"#,&'<"*$2%#&32/0;"/2%)"C%--&+'%#2/0"%')"%*,&232"(/+?%//0@

O+"0+.",%32",2%$#Y""'&.@/2&i/2#->%<2($2%#@*+>

70.X*4R(Z049M0(._4>*4(4/M0(.>O>.P4/'@*?).(@/P4S'M4&M'K>@&4.0(G*T40GD'K0M>@&4.0(G*4.'4)0(J4.LM'?&L4&M0(.4>@@'O(.>'@_

D2"&>%(&'2"%"'2%$"1.#.$2"6,2$2"#,2"6+$/)"?2'21&#-;"2HC2*#-"%')"$2-C2*#-"#,2"bST7!:c"#,%#"*+>2-"1$+>"4,&'%@""bS$2%#c"&-"6,%#"62"*%//"#,2"&)2%-"#,%#">+32"#,2"6+$/);"C$+).*#-"#,%#"*,%'(2"/&32-;""%')"-2$3&*2-"#,%#")2/&(,#"#,2"*.-#+>2$@

!-"#2*,'+/+(0"*+'#&'.2-"#+")&-$.C#"&').-#$&2-"&'#+"#,2"1.#.$2;"232$0+'2">.-#",%32"#,2"-<&//-"#+"*+'*2C#.%/&`2"%')"2H2*.#2"($2%#d

123+41"4!8

&''+3%#&+'"*+'-./#&'(

2'#$2C$2'2.$-,&C"*+%*,&'(

&'-C&$%#&+'%/"-C22*,2-

1%*&/&#%#&'("?$%&'-#+$>-

*$2%#&32G#,&'<&'("#$%&'&'(

666@/2#-">%<2"($2%#@*+>

!"#$%#&'(%)$(*+),$-

=;4*9

666@/2#-">%<2"($2%#@*+>

b[&(,#&'("1+$"&)2'#&#0"&-"-+>2#,&'("#,%#"&-"32$0">.*,"&'">0"/&12@c

F+3&2"O&$2*#+$;"!'("Z22"

!"#$#%&$'&(#&)$*+$,*-)$.&/(0!"#$%&'($)%($&*+,(-.,*-$1(*2$2%*$,*-$3)&

3(4$,*-$1(*2$2%3#$,*-$23(#56$

73*$89-

Business

QUIETING THE ECHOES - a case study for creatives