Upload
lin-zhangde
View
33
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ACG Nebraska 2015
Team 1Daniela Morales, Sergio Gutierrez, Edgar
Lopez, Zhangde Lin
Index• Objective• Recommendation• Qualitative Analysis
– SWOT Analysis– Porter’s Five Forces Analysis
• Quantitative Analysis– MediaCo– ApparelCo– FashionCo– MediaCo + ApparelCo– MediaCo + ApparelCo + FashionCo
• Alternative options• Conclusion• Appendix
Objective
• Use qualitative and quantitative analysis to advise ParentCo on whether to:– Sell ApparelCo– Acquire FashionCo– Keep the status quo– Pursue other options
Recommendation
ParentCo should sell a majority stake of ApparelCo.
Qualitative Analysis
SWOT Analysis
Strengths Weaknesses
Opportunities Threats
Internal
External
Positive Negative
StrengthsMediaCo• Quality consumer product reviews• Long, established company• Strong positioning
ApparelCo• High quality and fashionable apparel• Good reputation • Young target audience• Revenue growth in line with comparable companies• William Masterson• Less likely to be impacted by economic downturns
FashionCo• Ample distribution channels• Affordable products
Strengths
StrengthsMediaCo• Non-diversified revenue stream• Low profits in Production portion
ApparelCo• Few synergies with MediaCo• Lower profit margins• Limited distribution channels• Vulnerable to changes in weather during seasons
FashionCo• Lack of owners interest in industry• Untrendy products
Weaknesses
StrengthsMediaCo• Capturing new market segment• Strengthening brands • Divesting ApparelCo
ApparelCo• Faster future growth than MediaCo • Economies of scale• Advertising through MediaCo channels
FashionCo• Increase sales percentage in brick and mortar stores• Potential sale of company
Opportunities
StrengthsMediaCo• Low industry future expected growth
ApparelCo• Possible divesture from ParentCo • Possible request for a seat in the board of directors
from activist hedge funds • Agency problem
FashionCo• Lack of customer interest • Economic downturn can impact demand
Threats
Qualitative Analysis
Porter’s Five Forces
• Competitors are big• Low long-term growth
rates• Low product
differentiation
• Abundance of substitute products
• Low switching costs• High buyer propensity to
substitute
• Men, women, and children
• High price sensitivity• High customer
acquisition price
• Low switching costs• Economies of scale• Low product
differentiation
• Economies of scale• High branding costs• High capital
requirements
Buyer Power
Threats of Substitution
Supplier Power
Threat of New Entrants
Fashion Industry
Rivalry
HIGH
HIGH
LOW
LOW
HIGH
• Wide and diverse competitors
• Long, established competitors
• Medium exit barriers
• Abundance of substitute media
• High quality substitute media
• High customer loyalty• Low price sensitivity• Medium switching costs
(print)• Recurring purchases
• Scattered suppliers • Low cost of inputs• Low switching costs
• Economies of scale• Medium capital
requirements• Expected to have low
growth• Internet as point of entry
Buyer Power
Threats of Substitution
Supplier Power
Threat of New Entrants
MediaIndustry
Rivalry
MEDIUM-LOW
HIGH
LOW
MEDIUM-LOW
MEDIUM
Quantitative Analysis
Valuations
2014A Sales
2014A EBITDA
2015E Sales
2015E EBITDA
2014A Sales
2014A EBITDA
2015E Sales
2015E EBITDA
Perp. Method
Multiple Method
$0 $100 $200 $300 $400 $500 $600 $700 $800 $900 $1,000
$265.7
$195.0
$262.1
$178.6
$393.0
$309.6
$387.6
$283.5
$224.2
$167.2
$819.4
$573.4
$808.2
$525.2
$650.4
$533.3
$641.5
$488.5
$333.1
$418.2
Implied Total Enterprise Value ($ in millions)
Relevant Mulitple(a)Precedent Trans-
actions
3.0x-8.9x
0.5x-1.5x
0.5x-1.5x
3.0x-8.9x
Multiple Method:3.0x-8.9x exit multiple8.8-10.8% discount
rate
Perp. Method:-0.89-1.1% growth rate8.8-10.8% discount rateDCF Analysis
4.8x-8.3x
4.8x-8.3x
0.7x-1.2x
0.7x-1.2x
Trading Compa-rables
A graphical summary of the
various valuation
methodologies that our team
has reviewed is presented here
and can help triangulate towards a
potential value
Source: ACG Cup 2015
MediaCo Illustrative Preliminary Valuation Analysis - Summary
MediaCoFinancial Data ($mm)
2014A 2015E
Sales $535.12 $527.80
EBITDA $64.14 $58.74
2014A Sales
2014A EBITDA
2015E Sales
2015E EBITDA
2014A Sales
2014A EBITDA
2015E Sales
2015E EBITDA
Perp. Method
Multiple Method
$0 $100 $200 $300 $400 $500 $600
$113.6
$106.4
$122.4
$114.2
$237.3
$160.9
$255.8
$172.8
$101.0
$89.4
$336.6
$270.0
$362.8
$290.0
$294.7
$239.4
$317.7
$257.0
$294.7
$224.9
Implied Total Enterprise Value ($ in millions)
Relevant Mulitple(a)Precedent
Transactions
5.2x-13.2x
0.4x-1.3x
0.4x-1.3x
5.2x-13.2x
Multiple Method:5.2x-7.2x exit multiple11.0-13.0% discount
rate
Perp. Method:7.03%-9% growth
rate11.0-13.0% discount
rate
DCF Analy-sis
7.8x-11.7x
7.8x-11.7x
0.9x-1.1x
0.9x-1.1x
Trading Com-parables
A graphical summary of the
various valuation
methodologies that our team
has reviewed is presented here
and can help triangulate towards a
potential value
Source: ACG Cup 2015
ApparelCo Illustrative Preliminary Valuation Analysis - Summary
ApparelFinancial Data ($mm)
2014A 2015E
Sales $258.10 $278.20
EBITDA $20.53 $22.05
2014A Sales
2014A EBITDA
2015E Sales
2015E EBITDA
2014A Sales
2014A EBITDA
2015E Sales
2015E EBITDA
Perp. Method
Multiple Method
$0 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 $300 $350 $400 $450 $500
$85.6
$79.7
$91.7
$93.5
$178.8
$120.5
$191.7
$141.5
$99.1
$76.7
$253.6
$202.2
$271.8
$237.4
$222.1
$179.3
$238.0
$210.4
$231.3
$181.2
Implied Total Enterprise Value ($ in millions)
Relevant Mulitple(a)Precedent Trans-
actions
5.2x-13.2x
0.4x-1.3x
0.4x-1.3x
5.2x-13.2x
Multiple Method:5.2x-13.2x exit multi-
ple11.0-13.0% discount
rate
Perp. Method:6.28-8.3% growth rate11.0-13.0% discount
rate
DCF Analy-sis
7.8x-11.7x
7.8x-11.7x
0.9x-1.1x
0.9x-1.1x
Trading Compa-rables
A graphical summary of the
various valuation
methodologies that our team
has reviewed is presented here
and can help triangulate towards a
potential value
Source: ACG Cup 2015
FashionCo Illustrative Preliminary Valuation Analysis - Summary
FashionCoFinancial Data ($mm)
2014A 2015E
Sales $194.46 $208.46
EBITDA $15.38 $18.05
ParentCo Consolidation Financial StatementsSummary
($ in millions) Fiscal Year Ended December,
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
Actual Actual Actual Actual Projected Projected Projected
Revenue 364.1$ 391.6$ 420.6$ 452.6$ 486.7$ 525.8$ 565.5$
% Growth 7.5% 7.4% 7.6% 7.5% 8.0% 7.5%
Cost of Goods Sold 298.9$ 319.5$ 342.3$ 368.0$ 396.7$ 428.3$ 461.4$
Gross Profit 65.3$ 72.1$ 78.3$ 84.6$ 90.0$ 97.5$ 104.1$
Gross Margin 17.9% 18.4% 18.6% 18.7% 18.5% 18.5% 18.4%
Selling, General & Administrative 29.3$ 35.9$ 42.8$ 48.7$ 48.1$ 51.0$ 53.9$
Depreciation & Amortization 5.3$ 5.2$ 5.7$ 4.2$ 6.3$ 6.6$ 6.6$
Other Operating Expenses 2.3$ 1.6$ -$ -$ -$ -$ -$
Operating Income (EBIT) 28.4$ 29.3$ 29.8$ 31.7$ 35.6$ 39.9$ 43.6$
Operating Margin 7.8% 7.5% 7.1% 7.0% 7.3% 7.6% 7.7%
Interest Expense, net 4.5$ 8.3$ 6.6$ 2.8$ 2.2$ 2.4$ 2.5$
EBT 23.9$ 21.1$ 23.2$ 28.9$ 33.4$ 37.5$ 41.1$
Taxes (1) 9.6$ 8.4$ 9.3$ 11.6$ 13.3 15.0 16.4
Net Income Available to Common 14.4$ 12.6$ 13.9$ 17.3$ 20.0$ 22.5$ 24.6$
3.94% 3.23% 3.31% 3.83% 4.11% 4.28% 4.36%
Add: Taxes 9.6$ 8.4$ 9.3$ 11.6$ 13.3$ 15.0$ 16.4$
Add: Interest expense 4.5$ 8.3$ 6.6$ 2.8$ 2.2$ 2.4$ 2.5$
Plus: Depreciation & Amortization 5.3$ 5.2$ 5.7$ 4.2$ 6.3$ 6.6$ 6.6$
Adjusted EBITDA 33.7$ 34.6$ 35.5$ 35.9$ 41.8$ 46.5$ 50.1$
EBITDA Margin 9.3% 8.8% 8.4% 7.9% 8.6% 8.8% 8.9%
Capital Expenditures 5.1$ 6.2$ 4.9$ 6.1$ 6.9$ 9.2$ 10.2$
Our team has reviewed the historical and
projected financials as provided for
each entity and has
combined them to
create ParentCo
Source: ACG Cup 2015
2015E Sales
2015E EBITDA (No Synergies)
2015E EBITDA (With Synergies)
2015E Sales
2015E EBITDA (No Synergies)
2015E EBITDA (With Synergies)
Perp. Method
Multiple Method
$0 $100 $200 $300 $400 $500 $600 $700 $800
$199.1
$186.0
$216.8
$416.1
$281.5
$328.0
$216.0
$174.4
$590.2
$472.2
$550.3
$516.8
$418.6
$487.8
$557.0
$424.2
Implied Total Enterprise Value ($ in millions)
Relevant Mulitple(a)Precedent Trans-
actions
5.2x-13.2x
5.2x-13.2x
0.4x-1.3x
Multiple Method:5.2x-13.2x exit multiple11.0-13.0% discount
rate
Perp. Method:6.7-8.7% growth rate11.0-13.0% discount
rate
DCF Analysis
7.8x-11.7x
0.9x-1.1x
Trading Compa-rables
Relevant Mulitple(a)Precedent Trans-
actions
DCF Analysis
7.8x-11.7x
Trading Compa-rables
A graphical summary of the
various valuation
methodologies that our team
has reviewed is presented here
and can help triangulate towards a
potential value
Source: ACG Cup 2015
ApparelCo&FashionCo Illustrative Preliminary Valuation Analysis - Summary
Apparel+FashionFinancial Data ($mm)
2014A 2016E
Sales $452.56 $486.66
EBITDA $35.91 $41.85
NewCo Consolidation Financial StatementsSummary NewCo=MediaCo+ApparelCo+FashionCo
Our team has reviewed the historical and
projected financials as provided for
each entity and has
combined them to
create NewCo
Source: ACG Cup 2015
NewCo - Income Statement
($ in millions) Fiscal Year Ended December,
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
Actual Actual Actual Actual Projected Projected Projected
Revenue 886.4$ 932.1$ 972.4$ 987.7$ 1,014.5$ 1,048.1$ 1,088.4$
% Growth 5.2% 4.3% 1.6% 2.7% 3.3% 3.8%
Cost of Goods Sold 605.0$ 632.6$ 670.8$ 684.0$ 709.9$ 739.5$ 767.5$
Gross Profit 281.5$ 299.5$ 301.6$ 303.7$ 304.5$ 308.6$ 320.9$
Gross Margin 31.8% 32.1% 31.0% 30.8% 30.0% 29.4% 29.5%
Selling, General & Administrative 183.7$ 197.1$ 196.1$ 202.0$ 203.9$ 206.1$ 208.7$
Depreciation & Amortization 20.1 20.6 20.6 20.8 22.2 22.6 20.8
Other Operating Expenses 2.3 1.6 - - - - -
Operating Income (EBIT) 75.4$ 80.2$ 84.9$ 81.0$ 78.4$ 79.9$ 91.4$
Operating Margin 8.5% 8.6% 8.7% 8.2% 7.7% 7.6% 8.4%
Interest Expense, net 7.6 10.4 8.1 4.4 4.0 4.2 4.2
Other (Income) / Expenses 0.5$ (1.6)$ 1.5$ 3.2$ 2.4$ (2.8)$ 1.7$
EBT 68.3$ 68.2$ 78.3$ 79.8$ 76.8$ 73.0$ 88.8$
Taxes (1) 27.3 27.3 31.3 31.9 30.7 29.2 35.5
Net Income Available to Common 41.0$ 40.9$ 47.0$ 47.9$ 46.1$ 43.8$ 53.3$
4.62% 4.39% 4.83% 4.85% 4.54% 4.18% 4.90%
Add: Taxes 27.3$ 27.3$ 31.3$ 31.9$ 30.7$ 29.2$ 35.5$
Add: Interest expense 7.6 10.4 8.1 4.4 4.0 4.2 4.2
Add: Other (Income) / Expenses 0.5 (1.6) 1.5 3.2 2.4 (2.8) 1.7
Plus: Depreciation & Amortization 20.1 20.6 20.6 20.8 22.2 22.6 20.8
Adjusted EBITDA 96.5$ 97.5$ 108.5$ 108.2$ 105.5$ 96.9$ 115.5$
EBITDA Margin 10.9% 10.5% 11.2% 11.0% 10.4% 9.2% 10.6%
Capital Expenditures 20.1 21.6 19.8 22.9 23.2 25.5 25.9
• Status Quo• Sell ApparelCo• Sell Majority Stake of ApparelCo• Buy FashionCo• Buy Minority Stake of FashionCo• Status Quo + Liquidity for ShareHolder• Status Quo + Debt for Investment
Alternatives Options
Conclusion
• ParentCo should not make an offer for FashionCo• ParentCo should sell a majority stake of ApparelCo
– Based on our aforementioned analysis there is a valuation range applicable to ApparelCo
– We feel comfortable based on our analysis ,to ballpark an estimate around $150mm for ApparelCo
• Additional strategies ParentCo could pursue to enhance the value for ParentCo Shareholder include:
– Issuing additional senior debt– Issuing subordinated debt– Issuing equity
Rationale for Conclusion:Gross Margin Analysis
2014 2015 2016 20170.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
0.4
0.45
Gross Profit Margin
MediaCo
MediaCo+ApparelCo
MediaCo+ApparelCo+FashionCo
FashionCo
ApparelCo
2014 2015 2016 2017
MediaCo 40.95% 40.65% 40.42% 41.46%
MediaCo+ApparelCo 33.78% 32.95% 32.25% 32.56%MediaCo+ApparelCo+Fashi
onCo 30.75% 30.02% 29.44% 29.48%
FashionCo 18.40% 18.70% 19.10% 18.60%
ApparelCo 18.91% 18.33% 18.12% 18.25%
6.0%
7.0%
8.0%
9.0%
10.0%
11.0%
12.0%
13.0%EBITDA
MediaCo
MediaCo+ApparelCo
MediaCo+ApparelCo+FashionCo
FashionCo
ApparelCo
Rationale for Conclusion:EBITDA Margin Analysis
2014 2015 2016 2017
MediaCo 11.99% 11.13% 10.72% 11.86%
MediaCo+ApparelCo 10.67% 10.02% 9.67% 10.52%
MediaCo+ApparelCo+FashionCo 10.96% 10.40% 9.25% 10.62%
FashionCo 7.91% 8.66% 9.34% 8.74%
ApparelCo 7.96% 7.93% 7.86% 8.36%
Rationale for Conclusion:EBIT Margin Analysis
2014 2015 2016 2017
MediaCo 8.89% 8.10% 7.66% 9.14%
MediaCo+ApparelCo 8.27% 7.63% 7.21% 8.45%
MediaCo+ApparelCo+FashionCo
8.20% 7.72% 7.62% 8.39%
FashionCo 7.02% 7.26% 8.31% 7.38%
ApparelCo 6.99% 6.73% 6.45% 7.34%
2014 2015 2016 20176.0%
6.5%
7.0%
7.5%
8.0%
8.5%
9.0%
9.5%EBIT
MediaCo
MediaCo+ApparelCo
MediaCo+ApparelCo+FashionCo
FashionCo
ApparelCo
Rationale for Conclusion:Net Income Margin Analysis
2014 2015 2016 20170.03
0.035
0.04
0.045
0.05
0.055
Net Income Margin
MediaCo
MediaCo+ApparelCo
MediaCo+ApparelCo+FashionCo
FashionCo
ApparelCo
2014 2015 2016 2017
MediaCo 4.79% 4.39% 4.71% 5.09%
MediaCo+ApparelCo 4.51% 4.17% 4.30% 4.73%
MediaCo+ApparelCo+FashionCo 4.85% 4.54% 4.18% 4.90%
FashionCo 3.70% 4.09% 4.71% 4.15%
ApparelCo 3.93% 3.76% 3.59% 4.15%
Thank you!!
Q&A
Appendix
1. MediaCo Discount Cash Flow2. ApparelCo Discount Cash Flow3. FashionCo Discount Cash Flow4. ApparelCo+FashionCo Discount Cash Flow5. Comparable Companies Multiples Analysis6. MediaCo Comparable Transaction Analysis7. ApparelCo & FashionCo Comparable Transaction Analysis
1. MediaCo Preliminary Discounted Cash Flow Analysis
2015E 2016E 2017ENet Sales $208.5 $224.0 $240.1
% growth 7.5% 7.2%PF EBITDA 58.7 56.0 62.0
% margin 28.2% 25.0% 25.8%Depreciation & Amortization 16.0 16.0 14.2PF EBIT 42.8 40.0 47.8
% margin 20.5% 17.9% 19.9%Taxes @ 40% 17.1 16.0 19.1Unlevered Net Income $25.7 $24.0 $28.7
+ Depreciation & Amortization 16.0 16.0 14.2 - Capital expenditures 16.3 16.3 15.8 - Changes in working capital 12.4 0.5 (0.0) Unlevered free cash flow $13.0 $23.2 $27.2
Perpetuity MethodGrowth Rate
$267 -0.89% 0.1% 1.1%7.8% $302.8 $338.1 $384.1
Discount 8.8% $271.0 $298.5 $333.1Rate 9.8% $245.3 $267.2 $294.2
10.8% $224.2 $242.1 $263.611.8% $206.6 $221.4 $238.9
Multiples MethodExit Multiple
$287 3.0x 6.0x 8.9x7.8% $183.8 $309.6 $435.4
Discount 8.8% $178.0 $298.1 $418.2Rate 9.8% $172.4 $287.2 $401.9
10.8% $167.2 $276.8 $386.511.8% $162.2 $267.1 $371.9
2. ApparelCo Preliminary Discounted Cash Flow Analysis
2015E 2016E 2017ENet Sales $278.2 $301.8 $325.4
% growth 8.5% 7.8%PF EBITDA 22.1 23.7 27.2
% margin 7.9% 7.9% 8.4%Depreciation & Amortization 3.3 4.3 3.3PF EBIT 18.7 19.5 23.9
% margin 6.7% 6.4% 7.3%Taxes @ 40% 7.5 7.8 9.6Unlevered Net Income $11.2 $11.7 $14.3
+ Depreciation & Amortization 3.3 4.3 3.3 - Capital expenditures 4.9 6.3 5.9 - Changes in working capital 5.9 4.6 4.6 Unlevered free cash flow $3.8 $4.9 $7.1
Perpetuity MethodGrowth Rate
$150 7.0% 8.0% 9.0%10.0% $203.0 $299.7 $586.2
Discount 11.0% $152.0 $199.7 $294.7Rate 12.0% $121.4 $149.5 $196.4
13.0% $101.0 $119.5 $147.214.0% $86.5 $99.5 $117.7
Multiples MethodExit Multiple
$154 5.2x 9.2x 13.2x10.0% $100.4 $167.6 $234.7
Discount 11.0% $96.5 $160.7 $224.9Rate 12.0% $92.9 $154.3 $215.6
13.0% $89.4 $148.1 $206.814.0% $86.1 $142.3 $198.5
3. FashionCo Preliminary Discounted Cash Flow Analysis
2015E 2016E 2017ENet Sales $208.5 $224.0 $240.1
% growth 7.5% 7.2%PF EBITDA 18.1 20.9 21.0
% margin 8.7% 9.3% 8.7%Depreciation & Amortization 2.9 2.3 3.3PF EBIT 15.1 18.6 17.7
% margin 7.3% 8.3% 7.4%Taxes @ 40% 6.1 7.4 7.1Unlevered Net Income $9.1 $11.2 $10.6
+ Depreciation & Amortization 2.9 2.3 3.3 - Capital expenditures 2.1 2.9 4.3 - Changes in working capital 4.7 2.1 2.1 Unlevered free cash flow $5.3 $8.6 $7.5
Perpetuity MethodGrowth Rate
$137 6.28% 7.3% 8.3%10.0% $176.0 $235.1 $361.1
Discount 11.0% $139.5 $173.2 $231.3Rate 12.0% $115.7 $137.4 $170.5
13.0% $99.1 $114.0 $135.314.0% $86.8 $97.7 $112.4
Multiples MethodExit Multiple
$127 5.2x 9.2x 13.2x10.0% $85.2 $137.0 $188.8
Discount 11.0% $82.2 $131.7 $181.2Rate 12.0% $79.4 $126.7 $174.1
13.0% $76.7 $122.0 $167.314.0% $74.1 $117.5 $160.8
4. ApparelCo+FashionCo Preliminary Discounted Cash Flow Analysis
2015E 2016E 2017ENet Sales $208.5 $224.0 $240.1
% growth 7.5% 7.2%PF EBITDA 41.8 46.5 50.1
% margin 20.1% 20.7% 20.9%Depreciation & Amortization 6.3 6.6 6.6PF EBIT 35.6 39.9 43.6
% margin 17.1% 17.8% 18.1%Taxes @ 40% 14.2 16.0 17.4Unlevered Net Income $21.4 $23.9 $26.1
+ Depreciation & Amortization 6.3 6.6 6.6 - Capital expenditures 6.9 9.2 10.2 - Changes in working capital 10.6 6.7 6.8 Unlevered free cash flow $10.1 $14.6 $15.8
Perpetuity MethodGrowth Rate
$309 6.66% 7.7% 8.7%10.0% $406.0 $566.5 $957.0
Discount 11.0% $313.6 $399.5 $557.0Rate 12.0% $255.7 $308.7 $393.1
13.0% $216.0 $251.9 $304.014.0% $187.3 $213.0 $248.2
Multiples MethodExit Multiple
$294 5.2x 9.2x 13.2x10.0% $194.6 $318.4 $442.2
Discount 11.0% $187.5 $305.8 $424.2Rate 12.0% $180.8 $293.9 $407.0
13.0% $174.4 $282.6 $390.814.0% $168.3 $271.9 $375.4
5. Comparable Companies Multiples Analysis
Comparable Company Multiples
(figures in millions except per share amount)
Shares LTM LTM LTM LTM Sales EBITDACompany Ticker Stock Price Outstanding Debt Cash Sales EBITDA EBIT Earnings Market Cap Multiple Multiple
Gannett Co., Inc. GCI $31.50 225.6 $4,112.6 $1,374.5 $5,675.2 $1,254.7 $1,023.9 $476.9 $7,107.88 1.3x 5.7x
Lee Enterprises, Incorporated LEE 3.73 53.7 815.0 17.8 657.1 160.2 112.9 (85.1) 200.36 0.3x 1.3x
The McClatchy Company MNI 3.56 86.7 1,560.3 225.1 1,215.2 248.9 144.6 83.9 308.82 0.3x 1.2x
The New York Times Company NYT 12.84 150.3 669.4 414.6 1,587.7 232.1 152.8 64.1 1,929.87 1.2x 8.3x
Time Inc. TIME 22.59 109.0 1,376.0 325.0 3,352.0 510.0 352.0 8.0 2,461.63 0.7x 4.8x
Shares LTM LTM LTM LTM Sales EBITDACompany Ticker Stock Price Outstanding Debt Cash Sales EBITDA EBIT Earnings Market Cap Multiple Multiple
Ever-Glory International Group, Inc. EVK $6.19 14.8 $55.4 $25.0 $422.3 $27.0 $20.8 $12.8 $91.55 0.2x 3.4x
G-III Apparel Group, Ltd. GIII 79.35 22.4 71.2 21.5 1,931.7 152.4 135.9 80.2 1,776.25 0.9x 11.7x
Oxford Industries Inc. OXM 61.25 16.5 108.5 6.4 951.8 121.9 85.3 45.9 1,008.73 1.1x 8.3x
Perry Ellis International Inc. PERY 20.45 15.7 172.5 49.2 899.0 34.7 21.3 (25.1) 321.62 0.4x 9.3x
PVH Corp. PVH 114.35 82.4 3,907.4 461.1 8,250.7 1,202.2 948.9 321.0 9,421.64 1.1x 7.8x
V.F. Corporation VFC 67.68 431.1 2,083.5 496.5 11,993.4 2,047.8 1,775.2 1,293.1 29,176.92 2.4x 14.2x
6. MediaCo Comparable Transaction Analysis
Comparable Company Analysis - Comparable Transactions
($ in millions)
Announced Target EV / EV / EBITDATransaction Date Enterprise Value Revenue EBITDA Revenue EBITDA Margin
Transaction 1 2014 $972 NA 11.7x NA $83 NA
Transaction 2 2014 690 NA NA NA NA NA
Transaction 3 2014 511 1.5x 8.9x $334 58 17.2%
Transaction 4 2014 350 NA NA NA NA NA
Transaction 5 2014 25 0.2x 6.9x 139 4 2.6%
Transaction 6 2014 6 0.5x 3.5x 13 2 14.2%
Transaction 7 2013 105 0.8x 8.9x 140 12 8.4%
Transaction 8 2013 76 1.9x NA 41 NA NA
Transaction 9 2013 82 0.5x 3.0x 162 27 16.7%
Transaction 10 2013 252 1.1x NA 239 NA NA
Transaction 11 2013 3 0.3x NA 12 NA NA
Transaction 12 2013 829 2.1x 8.0x 386 103 26.7%
Transaction 13 2013 201 NA NA NA NA NA
Transaction 14 2013 355 2.1x 11.3x 171 31 18.4%
Transaction 15 2013 108 NA 17.0x NA 6 NA
Transaction 16 2013 214 2.7x NA 80 NA NA
Transaction 17 2012 13 0.3x 8.7x 42 1 3.5%
Transaction 18 2012 86 1.0x 5.2x 85 16 19.5%
Transaction 19 2012 15 0.4x 8.6x 41 2 4.3%
Min $3 0.2x 3.0xMax 972 2.7x 17.0xMedian 108 0.9x 8.6xMean 258 1.1x 8.5x
7. ApparelCo & FashionCo Comparable Transaction Analysis
Comparable Company Analysis - Comparable Transactions
($ in millions)
Announced Target EV / EV / EBITDATransaction Date Enterprise Value Revenue EBITDA Revenue EBITDA Margin
Transaction 1 2014 $359 0.6x NA $633 NA NA
Transaction 2 2014 189 NA 13.0x NA $15 NA
Transaction 3 2013 2,201 0.6x 9.8x 3,848 226 5.9%
Transaction 4 2013 1,486 1.4x 11.1x 1,031 134 13.0%
Transaction 5 2013 615 2.2x 9.6x 285 64 22.5%
Transaction 6 2013 253 1.3x 13.2x 194 19 9.9%
Transaction 7 2013 2,274 0.9x 8.0x 2,503 285 11.4%
Transaction 8 2013 567 1.0x 13.1x 562 43 7.7%
Transaction 9 2013 143 1.9x 13.5x 74 11 14.3%
Transaction 10 2013 1,000 1.1x 9.8x 921 102 11.0%
Transaction 11 2013 628 1.3x 7.2x 481 87 18.1%
Transaction 12 2013 18 0.4x 9.8x 46 2 4.0%
Transaction 13 2013 548 0.7x 8.7x 742 63 8.5%
Transaction 14 2012 2,847 1.2x 9.9x 2,406 288 12.0%
Transaction 15 2012 88 0.4x 5.2x 200 17 8.5%
Transaction 16 2012 852 0.4x 10.2x 1,969 84 4.3%
Transaction 17 2012 1,809 0.5x 8.4x 3,505 216 6.2%
Transaction 18 2012 246 0.5x 10.6x 478 23 4.9%
Transaction 19 2012 553 4.4x 10.9x 125 51 40.5%
Transaction 20 2012 58 0.4x 5.5x 139 11 7.6%
Transaction 21 2011 60 0.6x 10.6x 103 6 5.5%
Transaction 22 2011 60 0.6x 10.6x 103 6 5.5%
Transaction 23 2011 357 0.3x NA 1,144 NA NA
Min $18 0.3x 5.2xMax 2,847 4.4x 13.5xMedian 548 0.7x 9.9xMean 748 1.0x 9.9x