Upload
philippe-vandenbroeck
View
1.347
Download
2
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Intro to a seminar on 'working with wicked problems' - www.shiftn.com
Citation preview
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 1
Working with Wicked Problems
Philippe Vandenbroeck, shiftN February 2011 www.shiftn.com
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 2
Picture: Calabi‐Ya Manifold Courtesy Berkeley Center for Cosmological Physics
WICKED PROBLEMS A special class of problems ?
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 3
Our current predicament
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 4
Enter the Anthropocene
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 5
'Hockey sGck curves' abound
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 6
Planetary Predicament
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 7
Copyright: UNFCCC, 2010
Global Governance
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 8
Picture: The Intenet
ConnecGvity
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 9
But what does this mean? It's up to us to make sense of it ...
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 10
CriGcal uncertainGes
A trap is a trap only for creatures which cannot solve the problem that it sets. Man‐traps are dangerous only in relaEon to the limitaEons on what men can see and value and do. The nature of the trap is a funcGon of the nature of the trapped.
Sir Geoffrey Vickers (1892‐1984)
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 11
Reconfiguring the appreciaGve basis for our existence
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 12
Picture: The Intenet
RevoluGon
Return
Mindlessness
What happens beyond the 'stable state' ...
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 13
Picture: The Intenet
Engineering our way out
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 14
Nevertheless we have made progress
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 15
Cuban Missile Crisis, 1961 Kennedy AssassinaEon, 1963 Vietnam War, 1964‐1973
Moon landing, 1969 Student revolt, 1968 US urban riots, 1964 onwards Earth Day, 1970
The sixties
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 16
Kahn & Wiener 1968
Schon 1972
Meadows 1972
Toffler 1970
Ackoff 1973
Vickers 1972
De Jouvenel 1964
The late 1960s and early 1970s: a period of ferment
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 17
CriGcal uncertainGes Planning problems are inherently wicked: ill‐defined and reliant on poliEcal judgment. They are never
solved. At best they are re‐solved, over and over again.
Horst Ri]el and Marvin Webber, 1973
What decision‐makers deal with are messes, not problems. A mess is a set of
external condiEons that produces dissaEsfacEon.
Russ Ackoff, 1974
The policy process is 'a swampy lowland' where soluEons are confusing messes
incapable of technical soluEons
Don Schön, 1979
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 18
Wicked problems: • Unclear causaliEes. • Numerous intervenEon points. • Data are scarce, dispersed and low quality. • Uncertainty regarding costs and benefits of intervenEons. • MulEple stakeholders with different, oeen incompaEble worldviews. • FormulaEon is subject to conEnuous reframing and renegoEaEon. • OpEmal soluEons to wicked problems do not exist. • There may be path dependency associated to intervenEon strategies.
Super‐wicked problems: • The scope is planetary and the potenEal downside is very large. • Those most responsible have least interest to do something. • The longer one waits to do something about it, the more wicked it gets.
Wicked problems
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 19
Based on Cynefin Model CogniGve Edge
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 20
CriGcal uncertainGes
System Dynamics Jay Forrester (1968)
Morphological Analysis Fritz Zwicky (1967, 1969)
Delphi Analysis RAND Corpora7on (1959, 1964)
Scenario Planning Bertrand de Jouvenel, Herman Kahn (1965, 1964)
Viable Systems Model Stafford Beer (1972)
Methodological innovaGons in the 1960s and 70s
Making uncertainty amenable to decision‐making
Gebng a hold on feedback structures
Codifying the laws underpinning viability of organisaGons
The coming of age of modern systems thinking
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 21
1998
1992
1989
The nineties
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 22
Twin Towers, 2001 Dot com crash, 2001 US occupaEon of Iraq, 2003‐2009
Hurricane Katrina, 2005 Financial crisis, 2008 ‐ Afghanistan, 2005 ‐ Social media revoluEon, 2001 ‐
The noughties
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 23
CriGcal uncertainGes
Soc Systems Methodology Peter Checkland (1984)
Systemic Governance Ralf‐Eckhard Türke (2008)
AdapGve Management C.S. (Buzz) Holling (1978)
TransiGon Management Jan Rotmans (1998)
Design Thinking Bruce Mau (2000)
Methodological innovaGons from 1980s onwards
Intervening as learning
AnGcipaGng non‐linear dynamics (Gpping points, regime change)
'Steering' large‐scale socio‐technical systems toward sustainability
Modifying objects so that they can modify the world
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 24
Pointers to relevant approaches
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 25
LUMAS‐model ‐
Learning for a User by a Methodologically‐informed Approach to a SituaGon
Courtey: P. Checkland and J. Poulter (2004)
Soc Systems Methodology
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 26
SSM
• A pragmaEc approach to collaboraEvely improve (our understanding of) fuzzy problemaEcal situaEons.
• Systems models are used as heurisEc devices, developed from an explicitly declared worldview, not as 'pictures of reality'.
• The purpose of SSM is not to reach consensus, but to agree on a temporary 'accomodaEon', as a fleeEng consolidaEon point in a learning process. SSM = Learning for AcEon.
• SSM has been deployed in very varied circumstances (governance, informaEon mgt, hermeneuEcs).
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 27
Generic Governance
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 28
Generic Governance
• An approach to facilitate the design and conEnuous re‐design of social structures in complex governance semngs, where decision‐making power is devolved and dispersed and subject to different worldviews (e.g. ciEes, regions).
• Generic governance integrates insights from several systems and futures thinking tradiEons.
• It is a meta‐methodology to improve the adapEve capacity of an organizaEon: "It facilitates the creaEon of condiEons for sustainable governance, which in consequence aids addressing wicked problems – or even dissolving them."
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 29
AdapGve Management
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 30
AdapEve Management
• Ecologists developed an iteraEve approach to govern complex human‐environmental systems. The methodology mixes rigorous scienEfic monitoring and characterisaEon of uncertainty with ongoing sense‐making, negoEaEon and insEtuEon building.
• AdapEve management wants to contribute to 'resilience': adapEve capacity in the face of disturbances.
• Inspired by insights from complexity science it tries to understand how systems may be subjected to catastrophic regime shies.
• Panarchy: adapEve cycles are nested in a hierarchy across Eme and space (mulE‐level perspecEve).
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 31
TransiGon Management
BackcasEng
MulE‐level perspecEve
Fast and slow
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 32
• A meta‐methodology that emerged from Dutch innovaEon policy, inspired by technology studies, evoluEonary economics and complexity science.
• Focus on radical changes in large‐scale socio‐technical systems (energy, mobility, agriculture, health care) towards sustainability.
• TransiEon 'Management' = an oxymoron. Change comes about as result of interacEons between different systemic levels.
• Connects short term experiments with a long‐term vision in a conEnuous learning dynamic: goal‐oriented incrementalism.
TransiEon Management
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 33
Future Scenarios
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 34
Future scenarios
• Scenarios have been conceived as an instrument to explicity integrate future uncertainty into decision‐making.
• The methodology is extensively used, in a wide variety of semngs, from narrow decision‐oriented contexts to encompassing mulEstakeholder processes.
• The approach conEnues to evolve. In this seminar we will explore the use of scenarios as a way of acEon learning, in conjuncEon with other tools, as an apempt to reframe our basic assumpEons about global environmental problems: RIMA scenarios.
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 35
Design thinking
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 36
Design thinking
• Designers have expanded their reach beyond products and services, to include larger and more wicked dysfuncEonaliEes.
• Design plays on the performaEve character of our physical and insEtuEonal environment. Design is fundamentally acEon‐oriented, pragmaEc, voluntarist, utopian.
• The designer as reflecEve pracEEoner relies on meEculous, layered descripEon ('conversaEon avec une situaEon', cfr Paola Vigano), reframing of the problem situaEon and visualizaEon of alternaEve possibiliEes.
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 37
Working with wicked problems
From 'tools' to 'approaches' to ...
• develop systemic insight • make explicit normaEve choices • pragmaEcally embrace acEon and experiment, hence provisionality and open‐endedness
• support an ongoing dynamic of learning and sense‐making
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 38
"There is no quesEon of theory versus pracEce
but rather of intelligent pracEce versus
uninformed, stupid pracEce."
John Dewey 1859-1952
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 39
Shiftn, ©2010 www.shiftn.com 40