Upload
independent
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ORIGINAL ARTIGLESAnn Agric Environ Med 1997, 41 26Y269
BORRELIA BURGDORFERT SENSU LATO IN TIJE IXODES RICINAS TICKS IN
SOUTHERNPOLAND
Branislav Pet'kor, Krzysztof Siuda2, Michal Stanko3,,Gabriela Tresov6l, Grzegorz Karbowiaka,Jana Fridov6'
l lnstitute of Parasitology, Slovak Academy of Sciences, KoSice, Slovakia2Department
of Biology and Parasitology, Silesian Medical Academy, Katowice, Poland3lnstitute of Zoology, Slovak Academy of Sciences, Ko5ice, Slovakia
aW. Stefafrski Institute of Parasitology, Polish Academy of Sciences, Warsaw, Poland
'' Pet'ko B, Siuda K, Stanko M, Tresov6 G, Karbowiak G, Fridov6 J: Borrelia burgdorferi
sensu lato in the lxodes ricinus ticks in southern Poland. Ann Agric Environ Med 1997,4 . 2 6 3 - 2 6 9 .
Abstract: In May 1996,164 pooled and single samples containing 913 larvae, nymphsand adults of lxodes ricinus from urban, suburban and wooded biotopes of southern '.
' Poland were examined for the presence of Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato. Ticks werecollected by draggin g a flag over the vegetation and B. burgdorferi was detected inpooled tick samples by darkfield microscopy or isolated by cultivation in BSK-IImedium. Minimum infection rates of nymphs, males and females in the area were 8.2,
'
9.8 and l0.3Vo, respectively. Infection of adult I. ricinus ticks on l0localities fluctuatedfrom 4.0 to 15.0o/o and over IOTo of adult ticks in forests and in some urban andsuburban parks of the city Katowice were infected. Five Borrelia strains were isolatedfrom the adult L ricinus ticks. Relative density of ticks ranged from 20-65 ticks per onecollecting hour and from 3.3- 10.8 ticks per 100 m2. respectively. Frequent occurrence ofticks was also observed in urban parks and residential districts of the city Katowice. Theresults refer to the risk of human and animal infections bv borreliae in the areas of bigcities in southern Poland.
Address for correspondence: Pet'ko Branislav, MVD., Ph.D., Institute of Parasitology,Slovak Academy of Sciences, Hlinkova 3,040 01 Ko5ice, Slovakia.E-mail: petko@ saske.sk
Key words: Bonelia burgdorferi. Lyme borreliosis, ticks, Ixodes ricinus, WestCarpathians, Upper Silesia, Malopolska Region, Poland.
INTRODUCTION Eurasia, L pacificzs Cooley et Kohls and /. scapularis Sayin North America [1, 7, 23]. Infected ticks frequently
Since its discovery in 1981, Borrelia burgdorfei sensu occur in peripheral md central town parks in the
lato [ 3], etiological agent of Lyme boneliosis (LB), has teritories oflarge cities in Central Europe. Therefore, we
been the subject of many epidemiological and were interesied in the occunence md overinfestation of
epizootiological studies. This polysystemic disease of ticks by the agent ofthis dangerous zoonosis in the area of
humms and animals has been recently regmded as the southemPolandwithhighconcentrationof lagecities.
most common human tick-borne disease in the Holarctic. Little is known about the prevalence of Botelia
In natural foci, LB is transmitted primarily by blood- spirochetes in ticks in Poland. The most complete data
sucking arthropods, especially by ticks of the genus was reported from the northeast provinces by the Institute
Ixodes: I. ricinus (L) in Europe, L persulcatus Schulze in of Maritime and Tropical Medicine in Gdynia | 6, 24,25,
Received: 14February 1997Accepted: 24 Apnl1997
=AAEM
II| 264 Pet'ko B. Siuda K. Stanko M. Tresovd G. Karbowiak G. Fridov6 J
Figure 1. The locations of tick collection in South Poland: A) In
Katowice and vicinity, B) In the northwest region of Tarn6w province.
261. Ticks of the species I. ricinus and Dermacentorreticulatu.r were examined. Most of positive results were
obtained from L ricinus; the spirochetes Borrelia sp. havebeen observed recently also in D. reticulatus (Wegner,
personal information).
Moreover, Siriski et al. [20] published the results of astudy on the Borrelia burgdorferi infectton of ticks inUrwitalt in Masuria Region and several places in thesoutheast Poland (including Katowice and Szczyghce near
Krak6w). Tylewska - Wierzbanowska et al. l22lexamined ticks collected from vegetation, humans andanimals in different provinces all over Poland. L ricinus
and D. reticulatus mostly and occasionalll' ,Argas re.fle.ruswere examined in the above cited works. Positive resultswere obtained only for I. ricinus.
The occurrence of Borrelia burgdorferi in ticks in theclosely neighbouring area of the Carpathians in Slovakia
was studied by Kmety et al. [3], Prokopd6kor'6 er ql.
[19], Petko et aI. [15] and in the bordering area of the
West Carpathians in Moravia by Hubiilek er ul. 19. l0l
and Chmela [4].This paper presents the studies on the occurrence of
Lyme borreliosis agent in ticks in the areas of large citiesin southern Poland over the vear 1996.
J
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Studied area and collection of ticks. The density oftick populations and their overinfestation with LB agent,spirocheta Borrelia burgdorferi sensu lato. u'as studied inten localities of southern Poland in May 1996 (Fi-e. l).Ticks were collected by dragging a light woolen flag(60 x 90 cm) over the plant and bush ve-eetation. Thecollections were carried out primarily in the urban andsuburban biotopes of the city Katowice (Fig. 2). in theplaces most frequently visited by people, e.g. in parks,sporting areas and peripheral villa districts. Some tickswere collected in wooded areas at places with lowintensity of anthropogenic damaging (Chobot, Wal Ruda -
Fig. 3). The area dragged with one flag in one hourmeasured approximately 600 m' in pastures and forestswith shrubs, 800 m- in meadows and parks. Tickscollected from the particular localities were placed in test
tubes with a few blades of grass and preserved at 4oCuntil investigation. The relative density of active ticks wasexpressed as the number of ticks collected with one flagper one hour, as well as a number of ticks per 100 m-(Tab. 1).
Y
tF
Table 1. Material of lxodes ricinus ticks collected in southern Poland in Mav 1996.
Locality Date No. of ticks Time Areadragged" draggedb
RD.No./ hour
males females nymphs total
1
2aJ
4
)6
7
8
9
1 0
May 24
May 24
May 29
May 30
May 30
May 30
May 30
May 25
May 25
May 25
45
7T
37
52
3 1
32
30
1 3
35
39
5 5
5 6
36
47
39
4 I
43
7
30
52
3
5
52d
20
5
27
10
r03
r32
t25
l l 9
75
100
83
20
65
9 l
3
3
3
3aJ
2.25
2.25
I
I
2
2400
1800
I 800
34
.t-1
40
-r0
l5
-lJ
39
20
65
16
2m
l-r00
I _150
l 350
600
600
1200
Total
uhours, bm2
913 23.50 l59m -r0.3
Borrelia burgdorferi in the ticks in southern Poland
Table 2. Borrelia species in lxodes ricinus ticks collected in southern Poland.
Stage Pool samples Single samples
No. of Infection
rate (Vo)"
No. of Infection
rate (Vc)pools positive pools positive
0
16.7
28.3
t2 .5
l 0
6 l
46 13
4 0 5
0
8.2
10.3
9.8
5 1
110 22
360 72
345 69
0
9 (40.97o)
37 (5l.4%o)
34 (49.37o)
Larvae (n = 6)
N y m p h s ( n = 1 1 6 )
Females (n = 406)
Males (n = 385)
u calculated minimum infection rate.
Localities:1. Mikol6w near Katowice, in the "Barbara" coal mine
area, meadow with mixed shrubs and trees.2. Katowice, Ligota, oak-hornbeam forest and surrounding
pastures with shrubs and dewberry.3. Katowice, Kokociniec, forest and pastures with shrubs
near railway.4. Katowice, Wojew6dzki Park Kultury i Wypoczynku
Gen. J. ZiEtka, park in surroundings of tennis-court.5. Katowice, Park Tadeusza KoSciuszki, old park with
local occurrence of shrubs.6. Katowice, Ochojec, forest near railway and
residential district.l. Katowice, Murcki, forest in surroundings of sports
afea.8. Chobot (Krak6w province), Niepolomicka Forest,
old oak-hornbeam forest.9. BorzEcin (Tarn6w province), pastures with mixed
shrubs and trees.10.Wal Ruda (Tarn6w province), pastures and
meadows near forest with predominance of oaks andpines.
Investigation of ticks. Nymphs, males and femaleswere investigated in pools of 5 specimens each. Moreover,some specimens were examined individually. Ticks wereexamined for the presence of Borrelia spp. by dark fieldmicroscopy, according to Wilske et al. I27l and bycultivation according to Preac-Mursic et al. tl8l andTresov6 et al. [211. The samples were examined with aNikon microscope at 400 x magnification. Minimum infectionrate of pools was calculated according to Kahl et aI. f.l2l.
A total of 164 pooled samples containing 820specimens of L ricinus were examined for the presence ofBorrelia burgdorferi sensu lato. Another 93 ticks wereinvestigated individually (Tab. 2).
RESIILTS
In 1996,913 larvae, nymphs and adult ticks I. ricinuswere collected during a 23.5-hour vegetation flagging insouthern Poland. Their relative density in l0 examinedlocalities ranged between 20-65 ticks per one flag in onehour, or 2.8-12.3 ticks per 100 mt, ,espectively (Tab. l).Higher relative densities were observed on pastures in a
Table 3. Examination of pooled samples of lxodes ricinus adults for Borrelia species in the localities of southern Poland.
Locality No. of pools u Positive pools b Infection rate (Vof Isolatedd
Borrelia strainsMales Males Females Males
I
2
3
4
)6
7
8
9
1 0
9
t 2
7
8
6
6
6
2
7
6
1 7 . 8
1 0
2.9
5
13.3
0
1 0
0
t 7 . l
1 3 . 3
t2 .7
1 5 . 5
14.3
2 .9
l t .4
12.5
5
0
6.9
l 0
l 1 P153
y2t0
Pl75
Pt37.Pl42
266 petko B. siuda K, Stanko M. Tresovd G. Karbowiak G, Fridov6 J
+ +
i . lr tuclrl' 4!
ii i', t iI t l, l !
I
L,-"-1
::=J
-ililtr:lr[]!<trT*
r : n Q :l r v r d
iMYQ])itft
1 l r
;\lk/ f tr \
i.qgI r > 4 l
\
o-I3BI
effir--
i- t
o
+'-, ,4 \-.j / Li.iR
Borrelia burgdorferi in the ticks in southern Poland
t % ,
#j*"=** ./ PrzybYsla'1ic"\
" 1 ' " ) ' x
"4:.-. Ma-nfnf31ic'e,:+b -<l f.*,
(1@4
olor... /-lifal-Rudai
f ) (
Figure 3. Tick collection localities in the northwest region of Tarn6w province: 8) Chobot. 9) Borzqcin, l0) Wat Ruda.
\Jadowr ik i i
Mokre
1. t
$:-\I
? /- .-1 *'\i
.-,t -€ s* , ra -4 , ,
' r
$\ffif, - "a'il'\,, iF"le ( r . l \ t " p
wooded area (loc. 9 and 10). Relatively high densitieswere also recorded in some urban and suburban parks andresidential districts in the city Katowice (loc. 2,3, 4,6 and j).
Moving spirochetes, morphologically resemblingbacteria from Borrelia cultures, were observed in 49.3%oof male and 5l.4Vo of female I. ricinus pools. The lowervalues for nymphs (40.9vo) were statistically insignificant(t = 0.690 and t = 0.866, respectively). Minimum infection
1 6
1 4
, r =f
10 = 'c
38 = '
+o
6 g- of
4 do
2 80
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0
Locality
I Relative density f Minimum infection rate
Figure 4. Relative density and minimum infection rate of lxodes ricinusadults with Borrelia species in southern poland.
ru
rate of I. ricinus nymphs, males and females was balanced(8.2-10.37o) in the entire studied area. Individuallyinvestigated ticks showed the proportion of infectedfemales to be more than twice as high as for males. Singlesamples of larvae and nymphs were not evaluated becauseof a too smal l set (Tab. 2).
Borreliae were found in ticks from 9 localities (Tab. 3).The absence of infected ticks on locality 8 is probably dueto the small number of examined specimens. Minimuminfection rate of I. ricinus adult ticks at studied localitiesfluctuated from 4.0-r5.ovo without correlation withrelative density of ticks (Fig. 4). A relative highinfestation was observed in some suburban meadows andforests of the cities Katowice and Mikol6w (loc. 1,2), aswell as in the urban park (loc. 5), which was higher thanthat in wooded rural areas (loc. 9 and l0).
Minimum infection rate of males and females at studiedlocalities showed differences. At localities 2, 3 and 6,females were infected more frequently, at other localitiesit was males. Five strains of Borrelia spp. were isolatedfrom tick pooled samples at localities I, 4, 5 and 9. Thestrain marked as Pl42 comes from males. the others fromfemales (Tab. 3). Immunochemical investigations of theisolated strains are published in other paper l2l).
DISCUSSION
Relatively high densities of ticks were found in May1996 in the central and peripheral parks of the city ofKatowice. Finding of ticks in central parks of large cities
'.J4rfl
\=.
60
50
40
30
20
1 0
0
L
f
o\o)o
qU'-:<o
v
=aCo
E^ l gI EJ &
I
268
(parks, gardens etc.) is a common phenomenon in the
Central European region l2l.In the urban parks of Prague,
Cerny and Daniel [5] ascertained 23.5-139.5 nymphs and
adults per flag in one hour of collecting, with variable
density during a year and also between different years. In
a suburban park of the city Ko5ice, from 9-212 nymphs
and adults of L ricinus (flaglhour) were collected at 8
localit ies t151.The occurrence of ticks in towns is connected with
establishing new parks in original forest areas or with
building new residential districts on the peripheries of
towns close to forests. Persistence of ticks is determined
by their possibility to accomplish their life cycle, which
depends on the presence of suitable hosts for all
developmental stages. The presence of hosts is important
for adult ticks. In Central Europe these hosts are represented
mainly by squirrels (Sciurus vulgaris), both species of
hedgehog s (Erinaceus europaeus and E. concolor) and
local stray dogs and cats. A sporadical occuffence of ticks
in isolated parks can be attributed to the transmission by
birds.The occurrence of ticks has a mosaic-like character and
their infection with borreliae at different places of an area
with the presence of LB is highly variable, depending on
the place and time of investigation t281. Cases with
seasonal alteration were observed in local populations of
t icks [9, 13, 15].Long-term observations under Central European conditions
showed an impressive local fluctuation in the infestation
of t icks in the individual years of study: 6.5-11.47o [10],19-22.0%o [16]; 0.9-18.67o lI l l ; 2.l4l.7Vo | 151. These
variations in tick infestation are most likely reflecting the
periodical occurrence of borreliae in ticks, which was
pointed out in Slovakia by Kmety et al. t131. In the
Carpathian region of Slovakia this appears as a 4-5 year
cycle, with the last minimum recorded in 1994 and
maximum in 1992-1993 t151. In comparing the values of
the LB prevalence at different places of this area, the
phase of epizootiological cycle should also be considered.
The high variability of Borrelia infection in ticks at
individual developmental stages is probably associated
with the periodicity of LB. Adult ticks become generally
more frequently infected than nymphs, females more
frequently than males. Kahl et al. ll2l reported a
minimum 2.57o infection rate of nymphs, 5.3Vo of males
and I0.27o of females from the territory of Berlin in 1986.
Percentage of ticks infected by spirochetes of Borrelia
spp. examined in Poland varied. In Olsztyn province it has
ranged from 2.9-35.77o (average II.57o) 1251, in Urwitalt
in Masuria region 3.5Vo and in examined localities in
southeast Poland from l3-58.3Vo (in Szczyghce near
Krak6w l9.2%o) t201. Among I. ricinus specimens from
different parts of Poland tested by Tylewska-Wierzbanowska
et al. t22) only 0.75Vo of ticks were infected by B.
burgdorferi. In southern Germany, Wilske et al. l27lfound an average l%o infection in larvae, l07o in nymphs
and 207o in adult ticks, with no difference observed
between the infection rate in males and females. Nymphs
are less frequently infected than adult ticks 120,25,261. as
was observed at several localities in 1992 t8. l5l. A
variation in the prevalence of infected adults is generally
preceded by the change in the infection rate of nymphs in
the previous year. In both mentioned cases, an increased
prevalence of infected adults occurred during the next
year or the next two years. These differences may reflect
the presence of Boruelia donors (animals at the stage of
bacteraemia) and of naturally immunized hosts of I-
ricinus, which may cause either the increase in the
occurrence of borreliae [11] or their loss in ticks tl4l.The proportion between the prevalence of boneliae in
nymphs and adults and the absolute prevalence values in
May 1996 may serve as a basis for estimating the phase of
epizootiological cycle and for prognosing the epidemiological
situation for LB in the region. A significant local
variability of infected tick prevalence on a relatively small
territory points out the wide spectrum of ecological
factors influencins the occurrence of borreliae in nature.
CONCLUSION
The preliminary results indicate the hazard of human
infection elicited by the agent of Lyme borreliosis - a
grave natural focal zoonosis in the urban and suburban
verdure of large cities in southern Poland, which should
not be underestimated. Relatively high prevalence of
infected ticks and the balanced proportion of nymph and
adults infestation with borreliae in southern Poland
suggests the culmination of cycle and its possible
persistence in the year 1997.
Acknowledgement
This work was supported in part by grants No.2/577196 and2t2006196 from the Science Grant Agency of the Ministry ofEducation of the Slovak Republic and Slovak Academy ofSciences, and Grant NN - 4-012196 from the Silesian MedicalAcademy. The authors are grateful to Dr. Jin Panc6k fortechnical assistance.
REFERENCES
in the tick lxodesMikrobiol Intntunol
Borrelia burgdorferi in the ticks in southern Poland 269
' j ' '
t , '
I 'r
7. Filippova NA: Taxonomic aspects of the Lyme disease agenttransmision . P arazit o l o gy a 1990, 24, 251 -267 ([n Russian).
8. Hub6lek Z,Halouzka J, Juiicov6 Z: A simple method oftransmissionrisk assessment in enzootic foci of Lyme borreliosis. Eur J Epidemiol1 9 9 6 . 1 2 . 3 3 r - 3 3 3 .
9. Hub6lek Z, Halouzka J, Juiicovh Z, Svobodov6 S: Seasonaldistribution of borreliae in lxodes ricinus ticks. Zbl Bakt 1994- 280. 423-431.
10. Hub6lek Z, Korenberg EI, Juiicov6 Z, Kovalevski JV, HalouzkaJ, Shcherbakov SV: Prevalence of borreliae in lxodes ricinus ticks fromSouthern Moravia, Czechoslov akia. F olia P arasitol 1990, 37, 359-362.
ll. Humair PF, Turrian N, Aeschlimann A, Gern L: Borreliaburgdorferi in a focus of Lyme borreliosis: epizootiologic contributionof small mammals. Folia Parasitol 1993,40,65-70.
12. Kahl O, Schmidt K, Schcinberg A, Laukamm-Josten U, Kni.illeW, Bienzle U: Prevalence of Borrelia burgdorferi in Ixodes ricinus ticksin Berlin (West). Zbl Bakt HyS A 1989,270,434-440.
13. Kmety E, RehSdek J, Vyrostekov6 V, Koci6novd E, Gurydovd D:Infestation of ticks with Borrelia burgdorferi and Francisella tularensisin Slovakia. Bratisl Lek Listy 1990,91,251-266.
14. Matuschka FR, Spielman A: Loss of Lyme disease spirochetesfrom lxodes ricinus ticks feeding on european blackbirds. Exp Parasitolt 9 9 2 , 7 4 , 1 5 1 - 1 - 5 8 .
15. Pet'ko B, Stefandikov6 A, Tresov6 G, Peterkovd J, Skardov6 I,Prokopd6kov6 H, eiskikovii L: I.rodes ricinus tick as a source of Lymeborreliosis infection of human and dogs. Slov Vet Cas 1996,21,313-319(In Slovak).
16. Pokorny P: Borrelia sp. in ticks (Ixodes ricinus') on the territoryof the capital of Prague. Cs Epidem 1990,39, 32-38.
17. Pokorn'j P, Zahr{dkovii S: Incidence of borrrelias in the tickIxodes ricinus in the town of Brno. Cs Epidem 1990, 39, 166-170.
18. Preac-Mursic V, Wilske B, Schierz G: European Borreliaburgdorferi isolated from humans and ticks culture conditions andantibiotic susceptibility. Zbl Bakt Hyg A 1996, 263,ll2-118.
19. Prokopd6kov6 H, Peterkov6 J, Petko B: Examination of tick forBorrelia sp. in Ko5ice and surroundings. Preliminary results. Cs Epidem1992, 41, 236-239 (In Slovak).
20. Silrski E, Karbowiak G, Siuda K, Buczek A, Jongejan F: Borreliaburgdorferi infection of ticks in some regions of Poland. Pr:eg Epid1994, 48, 461 -465 (In Polish).
2l. Tresov6 G, Pet'ko B, Stanko M, Fridov6 J. Koziikovii D. MateickaF: Borrelia burgdorferi in lxodes ricinus ticks from Southern Poland.Folia Parasitol 1997 (in press).
22. Tylewska-Wierzbanowska S, Kruszewska D, Chmielewski T,Zabicka J: Ticks as a reservoir of Co.riella burnetii and Borreliaburgdorferi in Poland. PrTeg Epid 1996.50.245-25l (ln Polish).
23. Wegner Z, Stahczak J: The role of ticks in the epidemiology ofLyme borreliosis. Przeg Epid 1995.49,246-250 (In Polish).
24. Wegner Z, Stahczak J, Racewicz M. Kruminis-Lozowska W.Kubica-Biernat B: The first report on occurrence of Borrelia spirochetesin ticks (lxodidae) in selected regions of Poland. lnz Abstracts ofCommunications of the ITth Congress of the Polish ParasitologicalSocien', Gdynia, Poland, September 15-17, 1994,67.
25. Wegner Z, Stafrczak J, Racewicz M, Kruminis-tr-ozowska W.Kubica-Biernat B: Occurrence of Borrelia spirochaetes in ticks (Acari,
Ixodidae) collected in the forest areas in Olsztyn province (North CentralPoland). Bull Inst Mar Trop Med Gdvnia 1993/1994. Ul45.5l-59.
26. Wegner Z. Stahczak J. Racewicz M, Kruminis-tr-ozowska W,Kubica-Biernat B: Occurrence of Borrelia spirochaetes in lxodes ricinusticks in Bialystok province. lnz Lynte Borreliosis and Other Tick-tran smitte d Di sease s. Abstrac t of Inte rnational Stmpos ium, Bialou' ie:a,Poland, April2S-29, 1995, 13.
27. Wilske B. Steinhuber R. Bergmeister H, Fingerle V, Schierz G.Preac-Mursic V. Vanek E. Lorbeer B: Lyme borreliose in Siiddeutschland.Deutsch Med Wschr 1987.ll2. 1730-1736.
28. Tnman P, Daniel M: Mosaic pattern of Borrelia infection in acontinuous tick population. P roce eding s of I nte ntati onal Confe re tlc e onZoonoses, Pieit'anv, Slovak Republic, October 5-7, 1993.26-27.