Upload
uii
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
i
“ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS PARK”
AN APPROACH TO URBAN RIVER REVITALIZATION AND WATER QUALITY
IMPROVEMENT FOR RIVERBANK SLUM SETTLEMENT IN PAMUATAN RIVER
OUTFALL
FOCUSING ON SUSTAINABLE LANDSCAPE OF WASTEWATER TREATMENT USING CONSTRUCTED
WETLAND AND APPLIED ENVIRONMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY OF CHANGING BEHAVIOUR TOWARDS
ENVIRONMENTAL AWARENESS IN URBAN PARK DESIGN
BY
BARITOADI BULDAN RAYAGANDA RITO
4057332
Date of Birth : 14th of May, 1979
MASTER THESIS
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements
for the degree of Master of Landscape Architecture
Anhalt University of Applied Sciences
Bernburg, Germany
Submitted on : 26th of August, 2014
1st Advisor : Prof Nicole Uhrig
2nd Advisor : Prof Einar Kretzler
ii
"Eat and drink from the provision of Allaah, And do not
commit abuse on the earth, spreading corruption." Qur'an, 2:60
iii
ABSTRACT
In developing country like Indonesia, the large number of population mostly impacts on the problem
related to settlement. Parallel with poverty, this situation caused lack of ability of posessing adequate
shelter in propriate places. In most cities in Indonesia, riverbanks is one among places which taken by this
informal settlers.
In Sampit, Central Kalimantan, Indonesia, Mentaya river is one of vital subject to people livelihood as a
source of many activity related to water needs. Nowadays as the city grows its infrastructure most to the
land, Riverbank settlement is remains and leads to many problems. For settlers, they live in unhealthy
condition. Specially in Pamuatan river as the outfall to Mentaya River, it also affects the overall city
drainage system. Urban riverfront has lost its potencies to be a decent public space for the city.
Throughout several integrated urban Plans and studies called RTRW / Rencana Tata ruang dan Wilayah
(Spatial Plan) of Kotawaringin Timur Regency, SPPIP / Studi Pembangunan Permukiman dan Infrastruktur
Perkotaan ( Settlement & Urban Infrastructure Development Study ), RIPJM / Rencana Investasi Jangka
Menengah (Medium-term Investment Plan) and RPKPP or Rencana Pembangunan Kawasan Permukiman
Prioritas ( Priotity Settlement Area Development Plan ) , the local municipality had determined the area
for habitation improvement and planned to massively relocate the dwellers area in the riverbanks of
Mentaya and Pamuatan River. However, as mentioned in these reports, this action will has its challanges,
such as greater cost and social impact.
This thesis is proposing another approach of urban riverfront revitalization and improve the settlement in
the outfall parts of the priority area of the Pamuatan river, by the solution of adaptive or renewal without
massive relocation. The main goals are to focusing on overcome hygienic problem related to the
wastewater management using natural treatment system and the social problem of the need of open
space.
Constructed wetland as natural waste water treatment solution brings benefits in the eye of sustainablity,
ecology and aesthetic. The importance of cleansing and re-using river water is made possible by
implementing this method. The wetland also serve as new home for many habitat. Moreover, Landscape
architect gain opportunity to integrates the engineering-sound application of water treatment into
sophisticated garden and park design of constructed wetland.
As the Unhealthy lifestyle is becoming the part of people habit in the area and in general, of the city,
another goal of the design ideas is how to create a public space which psychologically affects people to
iv
promotes and educates them towards the awareness of health and hygiene behaviour inspiring by
environmental psychology principles on behavior change. This idea will implemented on the unused site
of PT.INHUTANI III nearby the settlement, which both will becoming visually and functionally integrated.
As once it was a place for a historical timber factory of Dutch collonial, high consideration of the remaining
structures are taken. Along with the issues of future development of the site, this revitalization ideas will
enhance the site values towards more economic, social, cultural and ecolgical potentials.
Key words : Urban Riverfront Revitalization, Riverbank Settlement, Wastewater Management,
Sustainable landscape, Constructed Wetland, Awareness of Health and Hygiene Behaviour, Public Space,
Environmental Psychology, Behaviour Change
v
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Ultimately, the writing will not be complete without a kind assistance, rigorous reviews, inspiring
discussions and motivational supports from my 1st supervisor, Prof. Nicole Uhrig. She also sparks my
interest in landscape urbanism as well as brings the historical topic comes to life and understanable
thorough her classes. I would also thank to my 2nd supervisor, prof. Einar Kretzler for his kind support
throughout this process.
The thesis is made possible from unlimited access to all necessary resources provided by authorities of
Kotawaringin Timur Regency. I would like to thank Mrs. Siti Rudiyanti and Mr. M. Wijaya Putra from
Regional Planning Agency, Mr. Danang Kurniawan from Department of Public Work , Mrs Umi from
Department of Hygiene, Urban Landscapping and Housing and Mr. H. Moedjiono from Department of
Trade, for their kind support.
I owe a great debt for generous sharing from all professor in MLA Anhalt during my study. Special
mentioned to Prof Joachim Möller as our studio supervisor, who always endrosed us to worked in very
inspiring ways and be a motivational tutor for the students all the time. Also, I would like to thank Prof
Wolfram Kircher for his kind attention, and enlightment about landscape planting, which is something
that competely new world for my inadequate comprehension.
This study will not be realized without great support from many institutions. I have my greatest gratitude
and thankfull for being an awardee of Directorate of the General Higher Educational (DGHE) of Indonesia.
Many thanks are also addressed to Mrs. Citra, who dedicated her effort taken care the process. I also be
very thankful for continous support from Islamic University of Indonesia and all the dearest colleagues in
the Architecture Department. I owe a valuable, an inspiring insight from DR.Ing. Ilya Fadjar Maharika, who
keen to endorsed me in any occasion. Among the most valuable support, this study will not be possible
without the generous genuine of PT.Surya Unggul Nusa’s companion founders, M. Ikhwan and Kukuh
Santiko Wijaya, who sincerely let me pursuing master degree. I owe them an unpayable kindness to fully
support me, also for their hard time during my absence. I would also thank to Wisnu Bayuaji who triggered
my desired of pursuing a master degree and always be my mate of discussion about living in Germany.
Living in Germany will not be cheerful and meaningful without energetic support of my Colleagues. Million
of thanks for my moslem brothers, Adeeb Kanaan and Hushaam Ali Abbasi, who stood beside me all the
time. I also feel grateful to have enjoyable yet challanging collaboration with my both studios collegues,
Karzan Jalal, Daeyong Kim, Michael Olasoji Ajayi, Ye Zhang and Sevinc Zehra Kahrahman. This works taught
vi
me of working in diversity and intercultural environment, something that surely brings the new dimension
to my perspectives.
I owe a truly endless support of careness from my own and extended family which has brought me to
pursuing study in Germany come true. My Parents and sisters who always support and cheers me , and
my parents in laws with their kindness of taken care my little family.
Finally, This acomplishment is dedicated to my Wife, Faridah, and My Children, Mutia Aqilatul Hanifah,
M. Haidar Taqillah, and Khansa Kiyasati Hanifah,who truly compliance my leave and endeavour during my
absence. I owe them an unreplacable time of years without a husband and a father.
vii
TABLE OF CONTENT
ABSTRACT ........................................................................................................................................... iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT .......................................................................................................................... v
TABLE OF CONTENT ........................................................................................................................... vii
CHAPTER I. Study background .............................................................................................................. 1
I.1 Introduction ......................................................................................................................................... 1
I.2. Hypothesis and objectives .................................................................................................................. 4
I.2.1. Content, questions and/or hypotheses ....................................................................................... 4
I.2.2. Objectives ..................................................................................................................................... 6
I.3. Methodology ....................................................................................................................................... 6
I.4. Limitation ............................................................................................................................................ 7
I.5. Further research ................................................................................................................................. 8
CHAPTER II. City Context and its Development ..................................................................................... 9
II.1. Location .............................................................................................................................................. 9
II.1.1. Kalimantan Island & Central Kalimantan province of Indonesia ................................................ 9
II.1.2. Sampit City and Kotawaringin Timur regency in Central Kalimantan province ........................ 12
II.2. History of Kotawaringin Timur and Sampit ...................................................................................... 13
II.2.1. Original tribe ............................................................................................................................. 13
II.2.2. Historical city development ...................................................................................................... 14
II.3. Population ........................................................................................................................................ 14
II.4. Climate & temperature .................................................................................................................... 15
II.5. Geological features .......................................................................................................................... 18
II.5.1. Topography ............................................................................................................................... 18
II.5.2. Soil ............................................................................................................................................. 18
II.5.3. River profiles ............................................................................................................................. 18
II.6. Economy ........................................................................................................................................... 20
viii
II.6.1. GRDP Per capita ....................................................................................................................... 20
II.6.2. GRDP According to Business Fields ........................................................................................... 21
II.7. Tourism ............................................................................................................................................ 21
II.7.1. Natural tourism objects ............................................................................................................ 21
II.7.2. Cultural tourism objects ............................................................................................................ 23
II.7.2.1. Traditional ritual and ceremonies ...................................................................................... 23
II.7.2.2. Dances ................................................................................................................................ 25
II.8. City structure and Its development ................................................................................................. 26
II.8.1. City infrastructures, authority bodies and public facilities ....................................................... 26
II.8.1.1. Transportation ................................................................................................................... 26
II.8.1.2. Economic facilities.............................................................................................................. 28
II.8.1.2. Govermental agencies ....................................................................................................... 29
II.8.1.3. Socio cultural facilities ....................................................................................................... 30
II.8.2. The urban structure transformation phases ............................................................................. 34
II.8.2.1. Period of (1826-1897) ........................................................................................................ 35
II.8.2.2. Period of (1826-1897) – Period of (1898-1945) ................................................................. 36
II.8.2.3. Period of (1898-1945) – Period of (1946-1968) ................................................................. 37
II.8.2.4. Period of (1946-1968) – Period of (1969-1990) ................................................................. 38
II.8.2.5. Period of (1969-1990)- Period of (1991-2008) .................................................................. 39
II.8.2.6. Period of (1991-2008) – recent (2014) .............................................................................. 40
II.9. Conclusion of CHAPTER II ................................................................................................................. 41
CHAPTER III. Regional and Urban planning for Settlement Infrastructure Development .................... 42
III.1 General overview of linkages between Studies .............................................................................. 42
III.2. Resume of Planning and Studies ..................................................................................................... 44
III.2.1. Resume of RTRW/ Rencana Tata Ruang dan Wilayah Kabupaten (Regency Spatial & land use
plan) of Kotawaringin Timur regency, year of 2012-2032 .................................................................. 44
III.2.1.1. Spatial Plan of Kotawaringin Timur regency ..................................................................... 44
III.2.1.2. Spatial structure plan ........................................................................................................ 46
III.2.1.3. Regency’s strategic region ................................................................................................ 48
III.2.1.4. Policies and development programs ................................................................................ 49
ix
III.2.2. Resume of SPPIP / Strategi Pembangunan Permukiman dan Infrastruktur Perkotaan
(Development Strategy of housing and urban infrastructures) .......................................................... 50
III.2.2.1. Aims and policies of SPPIP ................................................................................................ 50
III.2.2.2. Strategies and programs of the housing and urban infrastructure based on SPPIP ........ 52
III.2.3. Resume of RPIJM / Rencana Pembangunan Investasi Jangka Menengah (Medium–term
Investment Development Plan) .......................................................................................................... 53
III.2.4. Resume of RPKPP / Rencana Pengembangan Kawasan Permukiman Prioritas ( Settlement
priority sector development plan) ...................................................................................................... 54
III.2.4.1. Area delineation ................................................................................................................ 54
III.2.4.2. Main concepts of the area development plan .................................................................. 56
III.2.4.3. The problem solving based on typology of physical characters ....................................... 57
III.2.4.4. Assesment criterias for priority 1 sub - area determination ............................................ 61
II.2.4.5. Criterias, Indicators and parameters for development ..................................................... 63
III.2.4.6. Deatiled plan on the selected sub-priority area 1 ............................................................ 64
III.3. Conclusions of CHAPTER III ............................................................................................................. 71
CHAPTER IV. Urban riverfront in developed and developing countries, a comparison ........................ 72
IV.1. Urban waterfront, an overview ...................................................................................................... 72
IV.2. Urban Waterfront in developed country ........................................................................................ 72
IV.2.1. Common principles on urban waterfront design .................................................................... 72
IV.2.2. Design implementation on urban waterfront design .............................................................. 74
IV.3. Urban riverfront as riverbank slum settlement in developing countries, the case of Indonesia ... 81
IV.3.1. The global phenomenon of riverbank slum settlement in developing countries ................... 81
IV.3.2. Typical problem of riverbank slum settlement in Indonesia, the case of Jakarta, Yogyakarta
and Banjarmasin ................................................................................................................................. 84
IV.3.3. The thesis case: The riverbank settlement and its typical problems in Sampit, Central
Kalimantan .......................................................................................................................................... 92
IV.3.4. Goverment related Policies and programmes for slum settlement improvement ................. 99
IV.3.5. Best practices : participatory waterfront design in sungai Jinah Banjarmasin, decreasing
vulnerability with self-reliant urban design for riverfront housing in Banjarmasin, Indonesia ........ 100
x
IV.3.5.1. Background ..................................................................................................................... 100
IV.3.5.2. Design concept ............................................................................................................... 103
IV.3.5.3. Participatory process and realization of partial design .................................................. 106
IV.3.5.4. Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 110
IV.4. Conclusions of CHAPTER IV ........................................................................................................... 110
CHAPTER V. Constructed wetland as sustainable wastewater treatment solution ............................ 112
V.1 The importance of sustainable water cycling ................................................................................. 112
V.1.1. Background ............................................................................................................................. 112
V.1.2. The picture of water hazard in Indonesia ............................................................................... 112
V.2. Sustainability in landscape architecture ........................................................................................ 116
V.2.1. Sustainable development concept ......................................................................................... 116
V.2.2. Sustainability in landscape design ......................................................................................... 116
V.3. Constructed wetland as a sustainable water cleaning method..................................................... 117
V.3.1. Overview ................................................................................................................................. 117
V.3.2. History of constructed wetland .............................................................................................. 119
V.3.3. The principles of constructed wetland design ........................................................................ 119
V.3.3.1. Definition and basic concept ........................................................................................... 119
V.3.3.2. Constructed wetland System ........................................................................................... 120
V.3.3.3. Typical planting types ...................................................................................................... 126
V.3.3.4. Implementation ............................................................................................................... 128
V.3.3.5. Pros and Cons of constructed wetland as water cleansing method ............................... 140
V.3.4. Best practices Case I : Shanghai Houtan park: landscape as a living system .......................... 142
V.3.4.1. Background ...................................................................................................................... 142
V.3.4.2. General concept ............................................................................................................... 144
V.3.4.3. Sustainable water cleaning method using constructed wetland .................................... 145
V.3.4.4. Sustainable design approach of recycling material ......................................................... 148
V.3.4.5. Green education and Aesthetic Concept ......................................................................... 150
V.3.4.6. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 154
xi
V.3.5. Best Practice Case II : Kallang River-Bishan Park .................................................................... 154
V.3.5.1. Background ...................................................................................................................... 154
V.3.5.2. General Concept .............................................................................................................. 155
V.3.5.3. Sustainable water cleansing method ............................................................................... 157
V.3.5.4. Park and Public Spaces .................................................................................................... 161
V.3.5.5. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 162
V.4 Conclusion of CHAPTER V ............................................................................................................... 162
CHAPTER VI. Applied Environmental psychology and environmental awareness education in urban
park ................................................................................................................................................. 163
VI.1. Overview: Pro Environmental behaviour problems in the developing country, the case of
Indonesia ............................................................................................................................................... 163
VI.2. Environmental psychology ............................................................................................................ 165
VI.2.1. Overview ................................................................................................................................ 165
VI.2.2. How environmental psychology change the world ............................................................... 166
VI.2.3. Old vs recent paradigm on changing behaviour .................................................................... 167
VI.2.3.1. Basic principles ............................................................................................................... 168
VI.2.3.2. Three basic interventions ............................................................................................... 169
VI.2.3.3. Approaches to The basic interventions .......................................................................... 170
VI.3. Landscape perception and its languages towards emotional impact .......................................... 172
VI.3.1. Overview ................................................................................................................................ 172
VI.3.2. Theories on landscape perception ........................................................................................ 173
VI.3.2.1. The biophilia hypothesis ................................................................................................. 173
VI.3.2.2. Information processing theory ....................................................................................... 174
VI.3.3. Landscape “making space” Design tools vs “positive” and “negative” perceptions ............. 176
VI.3.3.1. Enclosure ........................................................................................................................ 176
IV.3.3.2. Dynamics orientation ...................................................................................................... 180
IV.3.3.3. Light and shadow as design tools to provoke emotion .................................................. 184
VI.4. Urban park as a facility to promote environmental awareness .................................................. 189
VI.4.1. Overview ................................................................................................................................ 189
VI.4.2. Urban park as social and educational facilities...................................................................... 190
xii
VI.4.3. Urban park as an arts showcase of environmental message ................................................ 192
VI.4.4. Best practices case I : Educational recycling park .................................................................. 198
VI.4.4.1. Background ..................................................................................................................... 198
VI.4.4.2. General concept .............................................................................................................. 198
VI.4.4.3. Recycling education concept .......................................................................................... 200
VI.3.4.4. Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 204
VI.4.5. Best practices case II : Eco Green Park at Jatim Park............................................................. 205
VI.4.5.1. Background ..................................................................................................................... 205
VI.4.5.2. Concept ........................................................................................................................... 205
VI.4.5.3. Environmental awareness learning concept .................................................................. 207
VI.4.5.3. Conclusion ....................................................................................................................... 208
VI.4. Conclusion of CHAPTER VI ............................................................................................................ 209
CHAPTER VII. Existing Profiles and Analysis ...................................................................................... 210
VII.1. Existing ......................................................................................................................................... 210
VII.1.1 General profiles ..................................................................................................................... 211
VII.1.1.1 Views ............................................................................................................................... 211
VII.1.1.2. Surroundings and urban context ................................................................................... 214
VII.1.1.3. Waterflow direction and level ....................................................................................... 216
VII.1.2. Riverbank settlement area ................................................................................................... 216
VII.1.2.1. Description of the area .................................................................................................. 216
VII.1.2.2. Typical setting and layout .............................................................................................. 217
VII.1.2.3. Accessibility .................................................................................................................... 219
VII.1.3. Unused PT. INHUTANI III Site area ........................................................................................ 220
VII.1.3.1. Description of the area .................................................................................................. 220
VII.1.3.2. Site boundaries and features ......................................................................................... 221
VII.1.3.3. Topography .................................................................................................................... 222
VII.1.3.4. Vegetation ..................................................................................................................... 223
VII.1.3.5. Accessibility .................................................................................................................... 224
VII.2. Analysis ........................................................................................................................................ 225
VII.2.1. Site Analysis .......................................................................................................................... 225
xiii
VII.2.1.1. Area Accessibility ........................................................................................................... 225
VII.2.1.2. Views .............................................................................................................................. 226
VII.2.1.3. River Water and pollutant from settlements flow ........................................................ 227
VII.2.2. Functional analysis ................................................................................................................ 228
VII.3. Conclusion of CHAPTER VII .......................................................................................................... 229
CHAPTER VIII. Concept development and masterplan design illustrations ........................................ 230
VIII.1. Design concept ........................................................................................................................... 230
VIII.1.1. Constructed wetland design concept and implementation ................................................ 230
VIII.1.1.1. Riverbank settlement needs ......................................................................................... 231
VIII.1.1.2. Neighborhood and surrounding needs ......................................................................... 235
VIII.1.2. Approach to urban park design ........................................................................................... 241
VIII.1.2.1. Behaviour changing and environmental education concept ........................................ 241
VIII.1.2.2. Social and cultural activities concept ........................................................................... 255
VIII.2. Integration of the both approaches and design illustrations ..................................................... 259
VIII.2.1. Masterplan ........................................................................................................................... 260
VIII.2.2.Accessibility .......................................................................................................................... 261
VIII.2.3. Zonation ............................................................................................................................... 261
VIII.2.4. Aerial views .......................................................................................................................... 263
VIII.2.5. Instructional area illustrations ............................................................................................. 265
VIII.2.6. Motivational area illustrations ............................................................................................ 266
VIII.2.7. Supportive and self management area illustrations ............................................................ 268
VIII.2.8. Cultural and social area illustrations ................................................................................... 270
VIII.2.9. Settlements area illustrations .............................................................................................. 273
VIII.3. Conclusions of CHAPTER VIII ....................................................................................................... 274
Bibliography, List of figures, List of Tables