FLAWS IN BLACK HOLE THEORY AND GENERAL RELATIVITY

XXIXth International Workshop on High Energy Physics, Protvino, Russia, 26-28 June 2013

S. J. Crothers – Flaws in Black Hole Theory and General Relativity 1

FLAWS IN BLACK HOLE THEORY AND GENERAL RELATIVITY

Stephen J. Crothers Queensland, Australia

(Alpha Institute of Advanced Study) [email protected]

15 April 2013 _____________________________________________________________________

ABSTRACT

! "

# $

#

# #

% "

" "

#

"

& #

" % !

"

"

"

" " "

'()*+,-.)(/,)-'()*+,-.)(/,)-'()*+,-.)(/,)-'()*+,-.)(/,)-

0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1

(

( ( " 234

5 !" # $6

0 274"

% &$' ( # $) # * + ,- . / ( *. - . . 0 ..1 ++,.2

# - $ !

0 1

All alleged black hole solutions pertain to a universe that is spatially infinite, is eternal, contains only one mass, is not expanding, and is asymptotically flat or asymptotically curved. But the alleged big bang cosmology pertains to a universe that is spatially finite (one case) or spatially infinite (two different cases), is of finite age, contains radiation and many masses including multiple black holes (some of which are primordial), is expanding, and is not asymptotically anything. Thus the black hole and the big bang contradict one another – they are mutually exclusive. The black hole is almost universally claimed to be predicted by General Relativity. It is surprisingly easy to prove that this is not true. Similarly it is very often claimed that Newton’s theory of gravitation also predicts the black hole, but this too is very easily proven to be erroneous. Despite numerous claims for discovery of black holes in their millions, nobody has ever actually found one. In addition it is not very difficult to prove that General Relativity violates the usual conservation of energy and momentum, with only a little use of mathematics. The simple proofs also demonstrate that all ‘singularity theorems’ related to General Relativity are invalid. Fundamentally there are contradictions contained in the very physical principles of General Relativity, combined with invalid mathematics, which render the theory untenable. It is the object of this paper to provide the proofs without the complicated mathematics usually associated with the subject.



& # $

) )8294"

% . 2

" " :3333 4444

# - $!

" 3333 ; 4444 #

0 "

" < "

"

" " " +"

# - $ !

# " " %

" #

! #"

" 2= > ? @ A4 !

% "

" " " " "

" "

% #"

B

# # $ "

0 1 # 0

1

" % "

" " <

" 0

274 %" "

"

%0. #

r +5m " . .

0m6 7,77M*..$.#-

. r + 5m 82

,# 2C4

59 . . . . .6

( 1823D4

5:.;. .

5 # .6

( 2334

50" " #< $ #. 1 $#.# 25".. :. :. . < . * E6

59 # . :. * - . ".*- = ) . . < . ) :.

22

2 821

21616 MMM πππ =

≥

2M

M ≥

:# .

( ) 22 293.02/11 McM =− 6

( F 2374

5" . # ( > . . 5

( " 1 2394

%1 . # ( ( .2



,# 0 23=4

51 # . *. - 6

0 274

51 .r? 5m* .-6

,#

"

" " %

" " 1

"

G1#8$

G1#8 $ HG

$E

"

#

" %

1 "

"

# # $

0 1

5. 6 #

#

% # $ ( #

G$ I#

"

" 0

## # " #

" I#

" #

" "

"

., .. ., .. ., .. ., .. " %" %" %" %

! #

" ( - $

!

" % "

,# "

H E

H# E

" " "

H" # " E

% "

" &#

"

" "

. "

B

"

# "

# " "

"

!

G $ #

HE

" "

" "

"

1 - $

! "

"

. "

#

"

.,.,.,., ## $ ## $ ## $ ## $

" "

. "

< I G

8 $ ,$ "

23? 3@4

2221

22 21

21 Ω−

−−

−=−

drdrrm

dtrm

ds

( )2222 sin ϕθθ ddd +=Ω

r≤0 H3E

#m" "

"

" 1#8$23A4"

,$ "

( 0 274 ,$"

% ( 2

% H3Ec # $

G !

" #c G

# % %

H3E"

2221

22

222 2

12

1 Ω−

−−

−=−

drdrrc

Gmdt

rcGm

cds

r≤0 H7E

# d2 % H3E

# " g00 g11%" % H7E

1

211200

21

21

−

−−=

−=rc

Gmg

rcGm

g H9E



# r = 2Gm/c2

G $ # r = 0

G $ F r =2Gm/c2

H23C4E

( ) ( ) ∞−=−=−

−==−=01

111

011 1100 gg H=E

G $

27 3=4

! 2/2 cGmr =

0 274 %

H3E

% r + 5m 2

,# % H=E 8

g11& 8

" "

8 " 8

8 -

1 g11 2/2 cGmr =

% H7E

r

rJD# " % H9E

−

−=

−=

02

1

10

21 1100 Gm

gGm

g H>E

8

# g00 g11

% H7E

"

8 r

I" G1#8$

,# 2C4

5 !. @ 7ABC 7AD, . . . 6

. % H>E

" 3K J027D4# % H=E

H>E

,# I0 1 "

23=4

%

8

2

2cGm

r = H?E

1 c

rGm

c2= H@E

" " # $

% "

% "

c 2334

5E> . . . 9 . 6

(

( ( " 2734

5 9 . # . "' . . M R

RGM

vesc

2=

G '9. *. ) - . *. R- vesc. 1 # . . RBH . vesc

c:

2

2cGM

RBH =

%" ! * - # #!: !: . / * -/ 2

( ,# 2C4

% . . . ..9. . . . . . .. . . $ " " ./ 2

- L 2774



59/. <# .6

. "

2334

5 . < ..6

,# 2C4

%" !. @ . . " ./ . " .. 2

F 2794

5.. . 39FE4 6

-! H?E H@E #

#&

# $ ! H?E

"

B I) #

# <

< 2= > ? 7=4

B I)" #

2

2cGm

r <

" B I

) (

,# -27>4

%E( 2

" , ( "

27?4

5.$ . .. . < . ! /*-$ . . 6

.%7=3 G $ B

F 27D4 B I)

G.)(/ ,)-1$

1 7=7

)$ G# G ) $

" + #

" '

" 1

. M# (

G+7=3$# :

% ; *7AHH- *7DAC 7AHA- ' . .2

2334

% . E 7DAI E . 0 MR/ v Nv7 O GM/R&

v7P 7GM/R> E R P

7GMKc7 JRs*- c .. 8

5 RsE#.. 2

.

" Rs 5 E6

# %

,$

c

!

" +" "

" !c

G $ "

c

"

" "

*

" "

8

<

#G$2=4

,# I0 G $

,# I0 1 " 23=4



####IIII % % % %

( % H@E "

" " $ :

" .

- $!

"

# $%

" " %

I # $%

,$

H7E " #

5. 6 5$6

# "

% H7E " " "

I" " "

- $ ! 8

" " 2> ? @4

B B B B IIII) ) ) )

B I)

& " B I

)

& !

# &

&

8 &

# B I

)

2=4& B I)

#

B I)

" #

" " "

" H "

" " E

# " & B I

) 9I" -

=I" I-

" & B I)

" #"

"

B I)

R = 0 " " " " - $!

5 . * -627@4

5 . .. .227A4

59./ . . . * ..

ikg - .627C4

5" . $. .$ Tab . " 629D4

5) . . 62934

Q - R! :

.JI%

# B "

% - :

µνµνµν κ TgRR −=−21

HAE

# D 3 7 9

# #

-% HAE # "

" - #

µνµνµν gRRG21−=

! HAE"

µνµν κ TG −= HCE

I" " " T

" - $

- "

" H E

" -

" " " R

R g " H "

E( - T= 0 R = 0

% HCE

0=µνR H3DE

( -

! H3DE"

" " - 2974

! " ! H3DE50 9 ) 6



-

" "

" " !

T = 0 1 "

" " - $ !

I" " " 8

"

" R = 0

5 6

23C4 5#2274

,$ R = 0

,$" H3E - 29943

5) . $<*7,A-

T" #7J#5*7,A-

222

22

11 φdr

rA

drdt

rA

ds −

−−

−= ”

# A = M/4. ,$" H3E

H7E B B 29D4r = 2m,

5( " / . .

2

2cGM

rs = 6

,$ 23C4

5" " . 6

0 274 ,$

5 . #2

,# " "

I" " "

8 R = 0

#" #G$ G$ G$$

"

I" " "

8- $" "

1 - $! H3DCE,$" H3E

&

# G$R = 0

"

" 1 R = 0 "

,$ H7E "

,

+" - %"

" #

" #5 6 5. 6

! HCE

" " #

" # 5 6

5 6 "

" " "

T = 0,

0 1

.,.,.,.,

- 2994 0

-! # 1 "

"

# (

-

5E&) & 1 $& &! & <&/ . &> . K . . .. & K . & K $ . & & K < . . # $$ " . .0. .



* &- . *&-5# . 6

+ 27@4

0 -! :

51 ; " .*.- . . 6

( 027A4

51

.

# /

# . .

"

F 2794

5 ! $ 6

( 2934

5@ @ @ @ ;9 .

.

# ( '

(.

# 6( ( ( " 234

5' . .

*. . -

# #

.6

0 -! 1 " " "

" 0 -! 1 " " " " " . R = 0 " " " " R = 0 " 1 ,$ R = 0 ." ,$ # " 0 -! 1 " " #

r ,$ ,$ ,$ ,$

! r ,$" H7E 565 6 5 5$6 56 56 5 6 5 6 5 6 5 . 2 5 ..

; r6

r J 7mJ 7GMKc7 G

$G. 23C4rJ

7m56

%" r+ 5m. 2

0 274r #

5 r r + t + Lr76

H 0 r G GE

,#

# r

" r ,$" ! " " 2> ? 9?4 " " 8" " " I"

%9

..



.

.229=4

%( .

(229>4

I" ,$" H7E%" # " " ! "

r ,$" " "

" % "

" ! r ,$" 29 > ? 9>4

( )222221

22 sin

21 ϕθθ ddrdr

rcGm

ds ++

−=−

H33E

++ " Q +" 2> ? 9?4

( )22222 sin ϕθθ ddrds += H37E

" " " K 7 +#"

gR

K 1212= H39E

#R1212 " " + / g " "

% H37E g = g11g22

=gg H" % H37E

E # g = r2, g J r2sin2 .

K ##

λνρσµγµνρσ .RgR =

1221

11222

121

1

1221

212. kk

kk

xxR ΓΓ−ΓΓ+

∂Γ∂−

∂Γ∂=

j

iiiji

iij x

g

∂

∂=Γ=Γ

ln21

( )jix

g

g ijj

ii

ijj ≠

∂∂

−=Γ2

1H3=E

ijkΓ i, j, k = 1, 2;

x1 = , x2 = . ( % H39E H3=E

% H37E

2 " -" S $B -% "

2

1r

K = H3>E

Kr

1= H3?E

# " r ! " " ,$ " ,$ " " "

G $ r

1 r ,$" 5 6

,$ Rp

,$ 2> ? 3>4

drrc

GmR p

21

2

21

−

−=

- "

( )

−++−=α

ααα rrrrR p ln H3>E

2

2cGm=α

% 2> ? 3>4

( )

−++−=

αα

αα ccccp

RRRRR ln

( ) nnnoc rrR

1

α+−=

ℜ∈r +ℜ∈n r ro H3?E

# n ro " ( " % H3?E " ! R = 0 "

" " " n =1, ro = , r > ro $" 29@4n = 3, ro = 0, r > ro 1#8$" 23A4

n =1, ro = 0, r > ro . $ 29A4



" ,$ " H7E " " 29A4 " " "

r " # $% : #I # - I+ /I18 " " ( I G $ ,$" " # " " " " " ''''(((()* +. .( )* +. .( )* +. .( )* +. .( 1B ) * 1B ) * 1B ) * 1B ) *

. " " " " " " 29>4"

%" . # oo

po(

2%: . .

.

2

1 " " " " " % " +" # - $ ! # " " % " # " " # " " " &- 2974 " 5 2B " " " " # " & 0 1 " ## $" 29>4 %"

%1

oo po,

/ . ..

2. 0 1 ! " " " "

+" " " 0 -! 1 " , " " #'''''()* +-1-$1+-)-Q ( 1'()* +-1-$1+-)-Q ( 1'()* +-1-$1+-)-Q ( 1'()* +-1-$1+-)-Q ( 1

- $! HCE # " % "

µν

µν κTG −= H3@E

! H3@E - 2974

" I" " "

( )σ

µσµ Tt + H3AE

#σµt

σµT I

" " " ( - 2974 "

5.( . 6

% H3AE " + " " " % I" " " " 8. - $ % I" " " !" ! - 2974 I" " " %

H3CE

- % H3AE H - x

( )0=

∂+∂

σ

σµ

σµ

x

Tt



x # " # # " " E- 2974! H3CE

% .

. 2

%( .

. 2

( 23C4

%" #

. . .

;*- .

. *- .

* - .

. . .

*-

*-".#

. .

2

#- $ ! H3CE 5T

.

2 - $ " " " " ! " " " - $ I" " " % H3AE % H3CE " " ,2=D4

+ # " " " g#- $I 2=D4

H7DE

# g " " µ

νδ

/ I" #

µνδ J 3# J 0#

" I "

abcΓ "

" " gab

g/ x

abcΓ L "

" " H# E " H # E F ! L " " " # " I"

" νν xgg sbsb ∂∂= /, "

" " # # " +" g " " " " "

# " " % :G $ ! 7& I" % D # - $ " % H7DE H73E

# tt =µ

µ # µµδ J 3; 3; 3

; 3J = D 3 7 9 " " H " " E 0" % H73E2=D4

1 % H73E

t

1 L " " " g " " "

t " " " " " "

" tI . " " I )I 2=34

∂∂−=− sb

sb ggL

Ltg νµ

µν

µν δ ,

,21

νν xg

gsb

sb

∂∂≡,

( ) αβ γ κ γ κακ βγ γκαβ= − Γ Γ − Γ Γ

∂∂−

∂∂+

∂∂=Γ d

bcc

bdbdcada

bc xg

xg

xg

g21

∂∂−=− sb

sbg

gL

Ltg µµ

µµ ,

,

421

LggL sbsb

2,,

=

∂∂

µµ

gL

t−

=



3CDD " " #U1- $ " " " " " " " - $ % H3AE I" " " % H3CE I" " " " " " R = 0 " " " " - $ ! " # " 2> ? 3D =D4

H77E

% # " <% HAE HCE H3DE

0=+ µνµν

κT

G H79E

"

0=+ µνµν

κT

G

#% H3AE#

( )µ

νµ

ν Tt + = H7=E " #% H77E% H7=E

0=+ µν

µν

κT

G ( )µ

νµ

ν Tt + = H7>E

# % H77E " - $! % I" " " - $ " % H7>E κµ

νG "

2=D4 µνt

% H77E H7>E - $ #8

" κµνG µ

νT "

# 0=µνT 0=µ

νG

0 = 0 # I" " " 8 " " H E - $" ! R = 0 # T = 0 # R = 0 " " " " H- # %E 2=D4&

- $ ! " " " #%" "

( IG.$" - $ ! # 29>4

µνµνµν κ TgG −=Λ+ H7?E

#g I" " " - $ " G. % H7?E" 29>4" %( .

. $ .

.$ T g .”

#% H77E ! "

% # :

( )0=+

Λ+µν

µνµν

κT

gG H7@E

# (G + g)/ # "

(G + g)/ T " # ! % H77E " % H7>E 1 " " ''()* +1 )(-1''()* +1 )(-1''()* +1 )(-1''()* +1 )(-1

+" ,# # " # " " " #

, $ " I"

r J 0 ,# ,$ " # 8

r 8B r ,$" +" " " % " (" # " " ( " " " I" <( 0 2=74

%>

5m .

0=+ uv

uv T

Gκ



. .

. 2

2934 %9 .

9 .

.

. "

2

0 274

%9 r $ * rMH-. r+ 02

%$..

r+ 5mr+ 02

" " B " % D = M/V "

0M=∞

8

. 1"

r J 0& H " E ( " " "

IV" I" / /I#" I " " " " " "

" 1" " # " # " " ( " < &" " ( I8" # I8" #I

(" # $ % # # "

" % " ( ,# 2=94

%9 . . .

2

( B F 27D4 %>

.$.;K.

# .

* -

2

,# " 5 6W

( " # # " " " " " % " & # ,#

'''' )1 )1 )1 )1

# $ # # - $ # " # " " " # - $ # " (" - $ # #

-% # # ! " 2==4

,# I0 1 " 23=4 " 2=>4-( -( -( -(

" :

37B 3C?AS7>" 7DDA

-+---1-+---1-+---1-+---1

234 ( ( " B 8 ( - 0)) . )( H7DD3E :KK###K#K" " KK XY 7DXY 7D XY 7D(XY 7D XY 7D( "



2740 5 : 6 ! '9= @ ZH7DD7E

294) ) )8 -

+ ( IF B ( H3C>3E

2=4B ' )R5

6 > CA 7@7 H3C@AE

###<" " KB '2>4 1Z 51#8 " #6 H7DDAE F @ B B CI39 7DDC ' 0 B 7DDC:+ [ :KK%KK33D9DD>32?4 1Z5., .. :" 6 HB 7D3DE :KK%KK33D9DD=@32@4 1Z 5 S( 6 N 0!@

'" 37 = ' 3 HZ 7D37E :KK%KK37D@DD3A72A4 1Z 50G.,$. 16 N 0!@ '" 37 = ' 3 HZ 7D37E :KK%KK37D?DDAD72C4,# 1F - + #B " 0 ., ( H7DD7E23D418 .+ ( " 0 / H3CCDE

2334 1 5

" 6

> C7 3?A H3C@7E2374F 1 " :0 ( Z F \1 #* H3C@7E2394 " Z 1 , 5 6 @!'3? H3C9CE23=4,# 1F 0 5 " 6 @!E 99993=3=3=3= >7CI>=A H3C@DE23>4 1Z 5 1 - $'" + " 6 @.@ '3 ?AI@9 H7DD>E###I " K %]K7DD>K00ID3IDC0+23?4(" )15.,:),$-6 FN@?@?@?@?@:C3C

H3CACE :KK :I!KD3D7D>>23@4( 1 5, G1#8$1 6H7DD3E :KK%KKKD93D3D=23A41#8 / 5 " - $6 .@91 @) & 3AC H3C3?E

###<" " K#8

23C4 0(B

0 ) " 01

0 0 0 Z H3CC?E27D4B F /1 F Z( F ,+" " #* H3C@DE

2734 (

( " B 8 ( - 0))

. )( H7DD3E:KK###K#K" " KK XY 7DXY 7D XY 7D(XY 7D XY 7D( " 2774 - , 0 ) H7DD3E2794 -+ F Z( -% .,I ( F ) " H E H7DDDE27=4 1Z 5(.,.6 @.@ '7 >=I>@ H7DD?E###I " K %]K7DD?K00ID>I3D0+27>4 ,# 1 F - + )

1 1 1I" " 0 " H3C@9E

27?4" , ( " , B - " 0 " / H3CC@E27@4+ Z Z ( 1 I' #* H3CC>E27A40 F 0 #* 3CA3 27C4F , 1" B 0 #* 3C>729D4B B " (1I &B #I, #* 7DD?2934 .F (( B ( ( IIF 0 " 3CC?2974- (+ 9@ =C H3C3?E 0 H( " " E 0 #* H3C>7E2994- (B 1 0 B \) H3C?@E

29=4-" ' , " B 0

B # H3CADE



29>4" " " " 0 #* H3CA@E29?4)I( 0 #* H3C@@E 29@4Z5 - $

" 6 '91 9 3C3C3C3C 3C@ H3C3@E

###<" " K29A4. B 5 - $ 6 N@! 79 =9 3C79

###<" " K 29C4 1Z 5 - $ +6 @.@ '9 @I37 H7DD?E###I " K %]K7DD?K00ID?ID70+2=D4)I 5B S ( -% B - $6 !!(" ) 7?:9A3H3C3@E :KK%KKKCCD?DD=2=34I )I 6B __ - 6 ) 9 .>= 3?7 H3CDDE :KK" KK3>@CC@2=74 Z 0 " I " '# 7 - 1 II' H3CC3E2=94,# 1F (.," "

.. ., #0) ) H3CAAE

2==4, Z. ,# 1F , 5(-% " 6 H9D

B 7D37E :37D>9AD@72I42=>4 1Z 5 ,# I0 1 G" $ ( #" 6 HA( 7D39E :KK%KK39D=DD9@

Documents

FLAWS IN BLACK HOLE THEORY AND GENERAL RELATIVITY