g!/' POCC~Li1CK~lI1 ~HCT~TYTP~Cl1 CTPATEn-1l1ECKVlX VlCCJ1EAOBAH~Li1

HAHAHYHE- -BEIIIHDI BDIHbl:PDI:I:IR I MIP

MOCKBa 2014

rrpaB~-

eT~JI CO-

JIbBOBa.

OMOl.I\b

rrpaB~-

rrOJIO-

I'afipnaae HaTaJIHQHa, npenOAaBaTelIb yHwBeponeTa "Canaenua", Ha}"lHbIJ1

COTpYAHHK HCClIeAOBaTelIbCKOrO QeHTpa CEMAS (li1TaIIWR).

POCCIUI B Cl1CTEME ME)I(,[];YHAPO~HbIXOTHOIllEHl1M HAKAHYHE

IIEPBOM Ml1POBOM BOMHbI

1914 r. CTaJI rrepelIoMHbIM rO~OM B ~CTOpJ1J1 acero M~pa ~ HbIHe,

rro rrpolliecTB~~ CTOJIeT~R, npononxcaer OKa3bIBaTb BJI~RH~e Ha COCTO-

RH~e OTHOllieH~M Me)f(~y pa3lIWIHbIM~ rocy~apcTBaMliL EClI~ rOBOpJ1Tb

06 OCHOBHbIX reerax, xoropsre xapaKTepJ130BalIJ1 Me)f(~apO~Hyro no-

lI~T~Ky rrOClIe~HJ1X 20 JIeT, TO BJI~RH~e BTOpOM M~pOBOM BOMHbI B 3Ha-

tIHTeJIbHOM CTerreHJ1 COllilIO Ha HeT. (C pR~OM J1CKlIlO'feHJ1M, CBR3aHHbIX

B TOM 'f~CJIe c YTpaTOM CBO~X rr03~~J1M eBporreMCK11M~ CTpaHaM11 11ne-

p;aBH11M B03Bpal.I\eH~eM K pyccKo-aMep11KaHcKoMy rrpOT~BOCTORH111O

B pane per110HOB - Esporre, DJI11)f(HeM BOCTOKe, Ha rrOCTCOBeTCKOM rrpo-

CTpaHCTBe.) B TO BpeMR KaK Kp113~C pa3JIWIHbIX COCTaBlIRIOl.I\11X rrOJI11-

T11'feCKOMC~CTeMbI, C03p;aHHOM B 1919 r. 'fT06bI BOCCTaHOB~Tb M11pOBOM

()PR~OK, napyurennsrà BoeHHbIM KOH<PlI~KTOM, OKa3bIBaeT 60JIblliOe

BlI11RH11e~ Ha cospestenayto rvroòansnyro nomrrnxy.

TIpoBalI 11~e11 B~lIbCOHa o perylI11poBaH1111 Me)f(p;yHapo~HOM no-

lI~T~K~ 'fepe3 ~HcrreK~110HHble areHTCTBa, uensro KOTOpbIX RBlIRIOTCR

C03~aH~e 61Iarorrp~RTHbIX yClIOB~M ~lIR Me)f(rocy~apCTBeHHoro COTpy~-

eCTBa 11xenonyiuenae B03H11KHOBeH11R arpeCC~BHOM BOMHbI, conpo-

O)f(~alICR rrOII~T~'IeCK~M pacnanosr IOrOClIaB1111 11B03H~KHOBeH~eM

ara HeCTa6~lIbHOCT11 Ha Banxanax, HOBbIM~ scnsnuxasrn H~110Ha-

CT~'IeCK11X HaCTpoeH~M 11 CTpeM11TelIbHOM scxanauaeà HaC11lI11R Ha

l1)f(HeM BOCTOKe, COCTaBlIReT TOlIbKO 'IaCTb rrpOT~BOpe'f11BOrO aacnen-

a Bepcanscxoro M11pa. B CBR3~ C 3T11M 11CClIe~OBaH11e BorrpOCOB, CBR-

HblX ~ TIepBoM M~pOBOM BOMHOI1, Ba)f(HO ae TOlIbKO ~lIR rr03HaH11R

pl1~, HO ~ npexcne acero ~lIR rrOH11MaH11R rexynreà gl1HaM11K11 Me)f(-

TBeHHbIX oraourenaà.

Hy)f(HO YKa3aTb, Bo-rrepBblx, '!TO coxpaHeH11e nonotiaoro ~tP<peK--sa MaclliTa60B 11 rny6J1HbI rrOlI11T11'IeCK11X 113MeHeH11I1, nponao-

Me)f(AY 1914 11 1918 rr. (oTKa3 AMep~K~ OT 11301IR~110H113Ma,

36r. HamallUt{Ua

OKTR6pbCKOJlpeBOllIOl.\MR) M npO~Oll)KeHHbIX B pa3BMTMeBOMHbIC 1919 r.

(BepcallbCKMM, TpMaHOHCKMM M CeBpCKMM MMpHble ~OrOBOpbI, C03~a-

HMe JIMm Hal.\MM), MMeeT B CBOeMOCHOBe "KOHCTMTYMPYIOll.\)'IO"npM-po~y TIepBOM MMpOBOM BOMHbI. 3TO nOHRTMe OTHOCMTBOMHY, KOTOpaH

npMHMMaeT B TO)Ke BpeMH XapaKTep "Bceo6ll\eM BOMHbI" (generaI war),

nocxorrsxv OXBaTbIBaeT ace "nomoca" CMCTeMbIMe)K~YHapo~HbIX OTHO-

weHMM B OC06bIM MCTopU'IecKMM MOMeHT, BbI3blBaH nepepacnpe~elleHMeBllaCTM, TaIOKe M K "MCXO~HOMBOMHe" (source war), B xozte KOTOpOMnpo-

MCXO~MTnepeYCTpOMCTBO Me)K~YHapO~HOM nOllMTM'feCKOM CMCTeMbI,

OCHOBaHHoe ae Ha rrpe~weCTBYIOll\MX Tpa~Ml.\MHX Me)K~YHapO~Horonpasa, a Ha TOllbKO 'fTO 3aKpenMBwMXCR TeH~eHl.\MHXl.

KaK B ~pyrMX nonoénux cnysaax (TpM~l.\aTMlleTHHR BOMHa, Hano-lleOHOBCKMeBOMHbI), nocne OKOH'IaHMR TIepBOM MMpOBOMBOMHbI Me)K-

~YHapO~HaR CMCTeMa,xasanocs, 6bIlla MaKCI1MallbHO B03MO)KHO yrropa-

noxeaa M npaseneaa K llOrM'feCKOMY KOHl.\Y, o 'feM CBM~eTellbCTBOBallO

nOllHOCTbIO ~OMI1HMpyroll\ee nOllO)KeHl1e CTpaH-no6e~I1TellbHI1l.\, a ccpop-

MMpOBaHHaR CMCTeMa,B CBOIOo-repens, 6bIlla npaasaaa 06eCne'fMBaTb

MCKllIO'IMTellbHO I1X MHTepeCbI. MbI ne ~Oll)KHbI TaK)Ke 3a6bIBaTb, 'ITO

nOClle~CTBMR "rnaBHbIX BOMH" (major wars) TO)Ke OKa3bIBaIOT BllMRHMe

Ha nOllMTM'IeCKOe nepeYCTpOMCTBOBTHHYTbIX B HMX rocy~apcTB, M npe-

)K~e acero CTpaH, nOTepneBUIMX B HMX rropaxenae. TI03TOMY BerrnxaaBOMHane TOllbKO rronoaorna KOHel.\ Me)K~YHapO~HoM CMCTeMe, CcpOPMM-

pOBaBweMCR nocne Bencxoro KOHrpecca, HO TaK)Ke M rropO~Mlla HOByro

Me)K~YHapO~HYIO CMCTeMY, yCTaHoBMB HOBbIM - nYCTb l1 ~OCTaTO'IHO CO-MHMTellbHbIM - MMpOBOMnopR~OK2.

XOTR ace eBponeMCKMe ~ep)KaBbI MrpallM Ba)KH)'IO pons B pa3BH3bI-BaHMM KOHcpllMKTa l1 n03)Ke CMllbHO nocrpanan« OT ero rrOClle~CTBMM,

pons POCCI1M6bIlla pewaIOll\eM M B onpe~elleHMI1 aanpaszremo, pa3BI1-

TMR Me)K~YHapO~HbIX OTHoweHMM, l1 B npl1HHTMM peweHMH O Ha'Ialle

BOMHbI, M B rrepnyro osepens M3-3a .Pl'oM30We~WI1X B HeM Kap~MHallb-

HbIX nOlll1TM'IeCKMX M3MeHeHMM - B yTBep)K~eHI1I1 pH~a Ba)KHeMwMX

npMHl.\l1nOB nosoro MMpOBoro nopsnxa. MHTepeCHO n03TOMY paCCMO-

rperi, cxeMY B3aMMOCBH3MPOCCMMCKOMI1Mnepl111_ a TaK)Ke COBeTCKoro

COI03a, KOTOpbIM crarr eé npeeMHMKOM, XOTH M B a6comOTHO MHOMcpop-

Me rocy~apcTBeHHoro M nOllMTM'IeCKOro pe)KMMa, - l1 TIepBOM MMpOBOM

l Bonanate L. Storia internazionale. Le relazioni tra gli Stati dal 1521 al 2009. Milano;Torino: Bruno Mondadori, 2010. P. 15-29.2 Wight M. Power Politics. London : Continuum, 2004. P. 100.

37P01CC!lJl B cucmesse MeJICayHapOaHbtX omHoz.ueHUlt HaKaHyHe BOltHbt

BOMHbI. TaKMM 06pa30M, MbI nOnbITaeMCR BbI~elll1Tb TpM rtpofinerasr,

B03HI1KWl1e sa ~eCRTl1lleTl1H ~O tra-rana BOMHbI l1 OKa3aBWl1e BllVlHHVle Ha

rexeuae MMpOBOMI1CTOpMl1,a TaK)Ke nonpoéyex BbI~Bl1HYTb Ha nepasnr

nnaa TpM HaM60llee Ba)KHbIX nOClle~CTBI1H OKTH6pbCKOM peBOllIOl.\MI1 -

c TO'IKM 3peHV1HcpOpMl1pOBaHMHnoaoro Ml1pOBOrO nopH~Ka.

Ilepnaa npofineaa - nepBoe pernemle. TIapl1)KCKMM Ml1pHbIM ~O-

rOBOp, KOTOpbIM 3aBepWl1n Kpsnacxyio BOMHy 1853-1856' rr., aurno-pyc-

cxoe cornaurenae 1888 r., 03Ha'IaBWee KOHel.\"òonsuroà nrpsr" B CpenaeàA3MM, M, HaKOHel.\, nopazcenae B PYCCKO-HnOHCKOMBOMIle 1904-1905 rr.,

xoropoe nsnrynano CaHKT-TIeTep6ypr cocpe~OTO'IVlTbCH Ha ansrepaa-

TMBHbIX Bapl1aHTaX nOl1CKa asixona K "TennbIM MOpHM". B xone peanM-

3al.\l1M3TOM nOnl1TMKI1 oco6oe crparernsecxoe 3Ha'leHVle npnoéperanaBanKaHbI3. Ilnanaposanae POCCVleMp,eMCTBVlMB 3TOM HanpaBneHMVI Ha-

sano pa3BMBaTbCH y)Ke B 70-x rr. XIX B., o 'IeM caanerenscrsytor nocne-

nosarensuas nonnepzcxa Cep6Ml1 VI aoopyacénnoe astcrynnenae B 3a-

I.l.\MTycnaBHHCKVlX naponos Banxaa npOTl1B OCMaHCKoro npaBneHVlH BO

BpeMH BOMHbI 1877-1878 rr." Onnaxo B naxane XIX B. 3aU\VlTa pyCCKMX

• Hal.\VlOHanbHbIX MHTepeCOB Ha Banxanax npnoripena euré éorn.uiee 3Ha-

'feHVle, nocxonsxy VlMeHHO3TOT perl10H npep,CTaBnHn C060M ep,VlHCTBeH-

HbIM B03MO)KHbIM KOpVlp,Opp,nH ssrxona K MOpIOs.Bropaa npotineaa - BTopoe perneHMe. Bcrynnemre Ha npeCTon rep-

MaHCKoro Kalbepa BMnbrellbMa II, ero KOHcpnVlKTc peMXCKaHl.\JJepOMOT-

TO cpOHEVlCMapKOM 11OTKa3 OT B0306HOBneHMH c POCCMeMCornaureanaO nepecrpaxosxe npVlBenM K KopeHHOM nepeouenxe CMCTeMbI COI030B,

Ha'KOTopOM 6a3MpOBaJJaCbEBponeMCKaH CVlCTeMaBO 2-M nOnOBl1He XIX B.

(COI03rpéx "KOHcepBaTVlBHbIX" MMnepaTOpOB - POCCVlVI,ABCTpO- Benrp VI11

I 11fepMaHVll1). B 1879 r. Me)Kp,y fepMaHCKOM M ABCTpo-BeHrepCKOM VlM-

nepl15IMM 6bIlI nonrnrcan ,D,BoMcraeHHbIM COI03 (KOTOpbIM B 1882 r. no-

cne npncoenanenxs K HeMy MTanVll1 cran TpoMcTBeHHbIM), 'lTO BbIHy-

p;l1no POCCl1IOnaxar» nOVlCKB03MO)KHOCTl13aKllIO'leHMH HOBbIX CO!030B6•

PaBHOBeCl1eCMn 6bIllO BOCCTaHOBneHOMe)K~y 1891 VI 1894 rr. c 3aKnIO-

'feHMeM cppaHKo-pyccKoro COI03a, no KOTOpOMy CTOpOHbI o6H3anVlcb

3 Schroeder P. W. The 19th-Century lnternational System: Changes in the Structure 1/World Politics. 1986. VoI. 39, No l. P. 4-6.4 Biagin! A. F. Storia della Turchia contemporanea. Milano: Bompiani, 2005. P. 8-16.S Bull H., Watson A. L'espansione della società internazionale. L'europa e il mondo dalefine del Medio Evo ai tempi nostri. Milano: [aca Book, 1994. P. 65-78.6 Kissinger H. L'arte della diplomazia. Milano: Sperling&Kupfer, 1996. P. 52-97

1

I

38r. Hamanu~ua

OKa3bIBaTb nOMOlQb npyr l1.ABCTpo-BeHrpMIiI Ha PocculO

pyryB

J1ClIY'Iae Hanal1.eHM5I fepMaHMM MlIM

T " MlIM TalIMM M fepM rh

eneps CMJIbI l1.Byx UeHTpalIbHbIX ensc 6 aHMM Ha 'VpaHQMIO.

COlO30M Me)Kl1.Y l1.ByM5I rOCYl1.a

pCTB l1. p aa bllIM BHOBb ypaBHOBeweHbI

M BOCTOKa. Ilocne »ce C03TT

aH aMM, xoropsre OKpy)KalIM MX c 3anal1.aM MH HOBoro aHrno-ri-.pa

B 1907 r. 6lIarOl1.apH nOl1.nMcaHMIO oros ,,'t' HKo-pyccKoro COlO3a

AHTaHTe (1904 r) u anr l1. opa o Cepl1.e'IHOM corrracrra" -• " .r lIO-pyCCKOMy co

Hble OTHoweHMH Me)l(TTV JIo rnaweHMIO 1907 r. HanpH)KeH-MI Hl1.0HOM M DapM)K Adi

JIOHl1.0HOM M CaHKT-DeTep6yproM B C e _ eM B rppaxe M Me)K!l.Y

lIOM npeononeau TaK)Ke KaK U ..p l1.HeM A3MM M KMTae 6bIlIM B ue-, Yl cepbe3Hble Ml1.eOJIO

CMH Me)Kl1.Y 3TMMM CTpaHaMu7 B .. rM'IeCKMe paaaorna-Yl. ce 3TO npMBelIO K CO

1030B, xoropsre sa 30 ner TTO'" 3l1.aHMIO CMCTeMbI co-M "Toro Ka3alIMCb 6bI np

HaQMOHalIbHo-nOlIMTM'IeCKue OCTO HeB03MO)l(HbIMM8.Yl MHTepeCbI POCCM B

6bllIa BbIH~l1.eHa nOCTOHHHO K M Ha anxaaax, rne OHaOHcplIMKTOBaTb c AB B -

lIHlIMCb l1.lIH neè Ba)l(Hee nanpn .. CTpO- eHrpMeM, HB-.n)KeHHbIX OTHoweH - B 6

CMcTeMa COlO30B B nasane XX MM C elIMKO pMTaHMeM.

K npaKTM'IeCKM OTKpbITOMY KO:~:::Be:aB:=H~T- DeTep6ypr He TOlIbKO

My npOTMBOCT05IHMIO c BeplIMHoM9 BTY

OM, HO TaK)Ke M K CKpbITO-

CH Me)Kl1.)'HapOl1.Ha5I CMCTeMa B . nepasre rons: XX B. ClIO)KMBwaH-blpOl1.MlIaCb B cue ri-.

Me)K!l.Y l1.BYM5I COlO3aMM 06"LeTT Hy l1.lIH KOH't'pOHTaQMM, D MMHHBWMMM Bemmr

LIepe3 HeCKOlIbKO JIeT OHU npaur M,....,Me MMpOBble nepxaasr.Yl "lIM K TOMy 'ITO

06H3aTelIbCTB M cB060TTa TTe" _ ,ypOBeHb MX B3aMMHbIXM M "CTBMM He MOT'VT TT

HeCOBMeCTMMOCTM MX nau - r : ziarree coxpaHHTbCH M3-3a•..•MOHalIbHbIX MHTepeco

nOlIMTMKOM npOTMBHMKOBIO• B c 3KcnaHCMOHMCTCKOM

Tpersa npo6neMa - TpeThe penrenae BKOTOpbIM nOClIel1.0BalI aa y6MMC . xone MlOlIbCKoro KpM3Mca,

B CapaeBe (28 MIOHH 1914 ) TpBOM ~PQrepQora <PpaHQa <Pepl1.MHaHl1.ar., OCCMMCKa5I MMnep

3aHMMaBWa5I BbI)KMl1.aTelIbHYIO MH, nepBOHa'IaJIbHO

BO MMH Ml1.eM naHClIaBM3M I.!93MQMIO, peWMJIa nOl1.l1.ep)KaTb - KaKa, TaK M l1.lI5I Toro 'IT06 6

ABcTpo-BeHrpMeJ.1 BalIKaHIl ,bI M3 eacars 3aHHTMH, - peweHMe Cep6cKoro KopolIeBCTBa He

7 Michon G. The Franco-Russian Al!' N8 Wa/t S. M. The Origins of Alliance~a~t~e. ~w York: MacMillan, 1929. P. 54.9 Snyder G. H. The Securit Dilem '. aca , London : Cornell Univ.Press, 1987N2 4. P. 463-465. Y ma In Alllance Politics Il World Politics. 1984. VoI 36lO A/b t' .L . ,I1 er In! . Le origini della guerra del 1914 (voI I) .

Sagan S. D. 1914 Revìsìted. AlI' Off " MIlano: Casa ed. F.lli Bocca 1942. ies, rense and r t bili ' .1986. VoI. Il, No 2. P. 163. ns a 1 ity Il International Security.

Pace wc B cucmeMe MeJ/CayHapoaHbtX amHaz,ueHuu naxanyne BaUHbl 39

npMHI1MaTb yClIOBMH ylIbTI1MaTyMa BeHbI, a 3aTeM M 06'bHBI1Tb 'IaCTM'l-

HyIO M06MlIl13aQMIO npOTI1B ABCTpo-BeHrpI1M12. B pe3ylIbTaTe 6blJIO sa-nyuteno l1.eMCTBl1e MexaHM3Ma Me)Kl1.)'HapOl1.HbIX COI030B

13, npasemnee

B CMlIy MCnOlII-IeHMH eBponeMCKMMI1 CTpaHaMM 06H3aTelIbCTB, B3HTbIX

Ha ceéa B 3aKlIlO'leHHbIX B npensoenasrà nepnon norosopax, K aa-rarry06lQeeBpOneMcKoM Bm1HbII4• B 3TOM OTHOWeHI1M éonsuroe 3Ha'IeHl1e

HMelOT DapM)KcKa5I BOeHHa5I KOHBeHQMM (2 MaR 1915 r.) M JIOHAoHcKMe

comaureana (26 anpelIR 1915 r.), B KOTOpbIX <PpaHQMR, J1TalIMR, POCCMR

M BelIl1K06pMTaHMR 06'bRBliIlIliI o CBoeM COI03e, OTKa3e OT 3aKlIlO'leHIiIR

cenaparnoro MliIpa, a raioxe o HaMepeHMRX corrracosars CBOIiI soeaasreyCMlIliIR (nasce npM TOM, 'lTO emororo OnepaTI1BHOrO nlIaHliIpOBaHMR

TaK HMKorAa l1.0CTliIrHYTO ae 6b1lI0) 15.BbI60p POCCMIiI liI ABCTpo-BeHrpMM,

CAelIaBWI1X crasxy Ha 3CKalIaQliIIO KOHcplIMKTa nocne y6MMcTBa 3PQrep-

nora, BbI3BalI uernryro peaKQMIO, ycanennyro CTpaXOM Aep)KaB nepeA

"a6aHAOHOM" CBOMX COI03HIiIKOB. LIpe3BbI'IaIllHaH )KeCTKOCTb CIiICTeMbI CO-

1030B, CTaBwaR peayns'raroa MHorOlIeTHeM 3CKalIaQl1IiI HanpR)KeHHOCTIiI

liI CTpeMlIeHl1eM CTpaH 06eCne'II1Tb C06CTBeHHyIO 6e30naCHOCTb M CBR3aB-

WaR OCHOBHble esponeàcxae nepacassr (POCCIiIR / <PpaHQMR - ABCTpO-

BeHrpMR / I'epvaaaa - <PpaHQIiIR / BelIIiIK06pIiITaHMR), OCTaBliIlIa xpaà-

ne MalIO B03MO)KHOcTei1 AlIR MaHeBpa (lIliIWb 11TalIliIliI Yl1.alIOCb n03)Ke

nepeMeTHYTbCR 1iI3 onnoro 6lIOKa B npyroà): BeJI.YlQMe esponeàcxae ro-

CYAapCTBa, naxce nepnoaaxansno HenocpeACTBeHHO ne 3aTpOHYTble Ha-

naneiorera, npliIHRlIliI peweHliIe BMewaTbCR B BOi1HY 113onacennn, 'lTO ne-

CTa6MlIM3aQMR cliITyaQI1IiI, B03HliIKwaR M3-3a IiIX OTKa3a cnenosars nono-)KeHMRM COI03a, 3aKOH'IIiITCR nopaaceaaesr COlO3HliIKOB 1iI,KaK cnencraae,

ocna6neHliIeM Ii1X n0311QIi1i116 (HY)KHO nOA'IepKHYTb, OAHaKO, 'lTO Me)KrO-

CYAapCTBeHHble OTHoweHMR B resenae nexoroporo BpeMeHIiI RBHO WlIli1

K nasany BOi1HbI, oc06eHHO Me)KAY <PpaHQl1ei11iI fepMaHli1ei1)17.

12Trachtenberg M. The Meaning of Mobilization in 1914 Il lnternational Security.1990-1991. VoI. 15, No3. P. 125-126. .13 Waltz K. N. Teoria della politica internazionale. Bologna: Il Mulino, 1987. P. 297-351.14 Cesa M. Alleati ma rivali. Teoria delle alleanze e politica estera settecentesca. Bologna:Il Mulino, 2007. P. 48-53.15 Biagini A. F. In Russia tra guerra e rivoluzione. La missione militare italiana 1915-1918.Roma: Nuova Cultura, 2010. P. 9.16 Cesa M. Alleati ma rivali. Teoria delle alleanze e politica estera settecentesca. Bologna:Il Mulino, 2007. P. 104-113.17 Snyder G. H. Op. cit. P. 463-465.

40 r.Hamanuuua

B xozte B03HMKllieJ1: "l\enHOJ1: peaxuna" cpena CTpaH-l.meHOB npo-

TMB060pCTByro~MX 6rrOKOB B 'rexemre aenena nocne MCTel.JeHMR CpOKOB

aBCTpMJ1:CKOrO ylIbTMMaT}'Ma ",lIMlIeMMa 6e30naCHOCTM" BOBlIeKJIa B KOH-

CPlIMKT POCCl1J1:CKyro, Fepsraacxyro, ABCTpO- Benrepcxyro M EpMTaHCKyIO

MMnepMM, a rarose <DpaHl\MIO. Cxryauarr, CBR3al-IHaR c 3a~MTOJ1: Hal\MO-

narrsusrx MHTepeCOB KOHKpeTHOJ1: CTpaHbl (B ,lIaHHOM clIyqae Cep6MM),

BbllIMlIaCb B OTKpbITOe CTOlIKHOBeHMe MHTepeCOB ,lIByx BelIMKMX ,lIep-

)f(aB (ABCTpo-BeHrpMM M POCCMM), cnposouxposasmee MX COI03HMKOB.

J1MeHHo n03TOMy <DpaHl\MR M BelIMK06pMTaHMR ,lIO castoro KOHl\a non-nepaorsana POCCMIO (6e30naCHOCTb KOTOpOJ1: MeHbllie npyrnx sasucenaOT Me)f(rocy,llapCTBeHHblX cornanremrà Me)f(,lIy l.JlIeHaMM AHTaHTbl), M3-

òeraa KaKMX-lIM60 cornauremoi c fepMaHMeJ1:. Bbl3BaB caxryro xpyrmo-

MaClliTa6Hyro BOJ1:HY,xaxyio TOlIbKO MCTOpMR snana ,lIO aroro BpeMeHMI8•

IIeperrOMHbIM MOMeHT. TPM rona BOJ1:HblHa BOCTOl.JHOM cppoHTe 060-

CTpMlIM rrOlIMTMl.JeCKMe, 3KOHOMMl.JeCKMe M couxansirsre rrpOTMBOpel.JMR

B POCCMM. He COBceM RCHO (l.JaCTMl.JHO M3-3a CMlIbHOJ1: rrOlIMTM311pOBaH-

HOCTM TpaKTOBKM MCTOpMl.JeCKMX C06blTMJ1: aroro nepaona), HaCKOlIbKO

,lIeJ1:CTBMTelIbHO TR)f(elIOJ1: 6bllIa BHYTpMrrOlIl1TMl.JeCKaR cirryauxa B CTpa-

ne, no KpaJ1:HeJ1:Mepe B nepasre naa rona BOJ1:Hbl, eClIM MCXOAMTb M3 Toro,

KaK 3TO CTalIM TpaKTOBaTb COBeTCKMe MCTOpMKM nocne peBOlIIOl\MM.

B 3TOJ1: CMTyal\MM ,lIOCTaTOl.IHO MHTepeCHblM RBlIReTCR pRA nOlIO)f(eHMJ1:

MX OTl.JeTOB, OTnpaBlIeHHbIX B KOHl\e 1915 r. nOlIKOBHMKOM 3AyapAoM

Ponono, BoeHHbIM ar'ranre MTalIbRHCKoro Bepxosnoro KOMaH,lIOBaHMR

B POCCMM. OTHocMTelIbHo TeH,lIeHl\MM pa3BMTMR noennsrx onepanxànOlIKOBHMK OTMeTMlI: "EClIM npoTMBHMK OCTaHOBMT CBOM nacryrrarerrs-

nsre ,lIeJ1:CTBMR [Ha PyCCKOM cppOHTe] M3-3a Toro, l.JTO COI03HMKl1 opra-

HM3yroT AaBlIeHMe Ha ApyrOM TeaTpe BoeHHbIX AeJ1:CTBl1J1:,R ne CTalI 6bl

yrnepxnan, l.JTO xepea ABa MecJRla pyccxas apMMR, CMlIbHaR M nOlIHaR

CMlI, HeMeAlIeHHO B0306HOBMT 3HeprMl.JHOe nacryrrnenxe, HO OHa 6YAeT

B COCTORHMM nOAroTOBMTbCR K HeMy M 6bITb AeJ1:CTBMTelIbHO rOTOBa

CKOBaTb ana-nrrensnoe KOlIMl.JeCTBO BOJ1:CK npoTMBHMKa. Ho eClIM no-

3BOlIMTb npoTMBHMKy npOAOlI)f(MTb AeJ1:cTBoBaTb B TOM »ce xartpaanenaaM ycneunro ynepacnaars pyCCKyro apMMIO B rexyutesr KpMTMl.JeCKOM

nOlIO)f(eHMM, ne nanaa di: B03MO)f(HOCTb npMJ1:TM B ceés, TO 3TO. sxyne

c BHYTpMnOlIMTMl.JeCKOJ1: caryauneà, MO)f(eT npasecra K nOCrre,llCTBMRM,

18 Snyder G. H. Op. cit. P. 474-475.

e ue~òyHapoÒHblX OmHOUIeHUU HaKaHyHe BOUHblPoccwr B cucmeM m ~

41

t 6 a3YlTb"19 MeHbllie 6eCnOKOJ1:-

KOTopble Mbl ne MO)f(eM C;~::Rac:eB BT~O!.06bl pYl~OBaTb xaprauy B po-

CTBa, XOTR ormone ae CKa '06 3KOHOMl1l.JeCKOJ1: CYlTy-.-.., P OlIO npORBlIReT, rosopa

30BblX TOHax, Cl. on O" CTOpOHbl nena, TO MYlHM-. "OTHOCMTelIbHO cpYlHaHCOB •• 6

al\Ml1 B crpane: 6 aIOT aoasre cornauienaa, l.JTO blcrnst cpl1HaHCOB COI03Hl1KOB pa3pa aTbl~ tT

TOxacaerca npono-

-r _ M pyCCKOM BalIIOTbI. "l.1136e)f(aTb pe3KOM AeBalIbBal\M nop ra nllieHYll\bI, 60RTbCR

MTblBaR lIYlKBYl,llal\YlIO 3KCBOlIbCTBYlR, TO, yq .. 6 no yCTpOJ1:CTBy MYllIlI110HOB

C eCTByeT cepsesaaa rtpo lIeMaHel.Jero. yin 6 Te" 3aHRTblX npOTYlBHYlKOM,

- yl1pyroTCR 113O nac ",lIIOAel1, xoropsre 3BaK aJ1:0HaX l1Mnepl1l1; OHl1 6eccnop-11nnryr y6e)f(Ylru;e B l\eHTpalIbHblX P _ 6 "20 B 1916 r.

nOCTORHHOYl 03a Ol.JeHHOCTYl .

~~~;~~::C:H:~:O~~::l1°'::Cb B03MO)f(HOCTb onl1caTb OCHOBHble MOMeH-

Tbl pyccxoà BHYTpeHHeJ1: nOlIl1Tl1K~~HOCTb l.JTO noasre C06bITl1R MorYTXOTR OH ne l1CKlIIOl.JalI B03M, 11 Ha

"Hue raioxe Ha nOlIl1Tl1l.JeCKl1e 11 06ru;eCTBeHHble xpyraOKa3aTb BIIYln •• - (npeaoie Bce-

1916 r BHYTP"nolIlTll.JeCKll Kp113Ji1CHacelIeHl1e, BbI3BaB B· nero HeT KaKJilX-1I1160ro B ropoAax), BOeHHblJ1: arrauie Cl.Jl1TalI. l.JTO y u oéuiecrae".

, - l.JT06bl O)f(YlAaTb rrry60KJilx 113MeHeHJiIJiI B

nOATBep)f(AeHl1l1. 1917 r B03HMKlIJiI 6lIaronpl1RTHble yClIOBl1R AlIR KO-

HeCMOTpR Ha 3TO, B . H KaKOM clIyqae ne 3aTparl1BaR A"a-

peIÌHoro 113MeHeHl1R pe)f(l1Ma. u 11 B KTO KaK 3Pl1K X06c6aYM,onOIIO)f(HblJil Te311C Tex, ,

MeTpalIbHo npOTJilB XX B 6YAeT nOIIHOCTbIO 3aBJiI-

YTBep)f(AalI, l.JTO nOlIl1:~:~;~Rc~:~::RAl1Ha~JilKJiI, JilM npOYl3BeAeHHOJ1:

cers OT l1CTOpYll1 COB _ B u 0"Hbl)22 HV)J(HO rrOAQepKHYTb.eAcTBl1l1 elIJilKOYl B •• • J •• -

(a norosry - OT rrOCII BJilKaMJiI 11 OKTR6pbCKaR peBolIIOl\l1R CTalIl1

l.JTO saxsar BlIaCTYl 60lIblue eiuatouree BlIl1RHJile Ha cpOpMl1-

nqBopoTHblM MOMeHTOM~ OKa3aBlll11M p OJ1:CTBaMl1pa nocne OKOHl.JaHl1R

POBaHl1e Me)f(AyHapoAHOl1 Cl1CTeMbl yCTp,l., 23

soeaaoro KOH't'lIl1KTa . n npeACTaBJilTelIRMJiI COBeTCKOJ1:POC-

ITep8btU pe3y~bmam. OAn_JilCaHl1eB EpeCT-DJilTOBCKe (MapT 1918 r.),Cl1l1 KpaJ1:He TR)f(elIblX yClIOBJill1 Ml1pa

. . L issione militare italiana 1915-1918.19 B' .' A F In Russia tra guerra e nvoluZlOne. a mwgml ..P.29.20lbid. P. 30. .... R . (Pietrogrado 15-28 gennaio 1916 -21lRopolo E Note sulla sìtuazrone interna m ussia 8

. ) /I SME-AUS. MMIR. B. 9 .Rapporto al Comando Supremo '. Bur 1997. P. 71-106.22Hobsbawm E. f. Il secolo breve 1914-1991. Milano. •Trino' Einaudi. 1974.23 Carr E. H. 1917: Illusioni e realtà della rìvoluzione russa. o .

r42 r. Hamanuuua

OTcyrcTBJ.1e npencrassrreneà POCCl1l1 Ha Ilapl1)f(CKOJ.1 xoarpepeauaaIi'l iraxano rrpOTl1BOCTORHl1R "KpaCHbIX" 11 "òerrux" - BCe 3TO OKa3bIBaeT

60JIbllIOe Blll1RHli'le Ha 113MeHeHl1e Me)f(A)'HapOAHOJ.1 csrryauxa 11 MeHReT

ormoorrerrsasre qepTbI rrOllIOCOB HOBOJ.1Ml1pOBOJ.1Cl1CTeMbI, B03Hl1KllIeJ.1

Ha 06llOMKax Belll1KOJ.1 BOJ.1-HbI.HOBbIJ.1 Me)f(A)'HapOAHbIJ.1 rropRAOK nove-crxn COBeTCKl1J.1COI03 B rrO~l1HeHHOe nonozceaae OTHOCl1TellbHO BeAY-

~J.1X Ml1pOBbIX Aep)f(aB, 11 OH rrOTepRll pRA rr0311~11J.1,paHee 3aHl1MaeMbIX

POCCl1J.1CK0J.111Mrrepl1eJ.1. (3TOT nepaon rrpOAlll1llCR, rro KpaJ.1HeJ.1 Mepe,

AO 1934 r., xorna COBeTCKl1J.1 COI03 6bIlI norrytnea B JIl1ry Hal.\11J.124.)

Bmopoù pesynsmam. Ilomrrn-recxaa Cl1Tyal.\l1R B BOCTOqHOJ.1 EBPO-

rre Ha Teppl1Topl1RX, paHee BXOAl1BllIli'lXB COCTaB fepMaHCKOJ.1, ABCTpO-

BeHrepCK0J.111 POCCl1J.1CKO:i1Ii'lMrrepl1J.1, crana OAHIi'lM113 ocnoaononara-

ronnrx 3lleMeHTOB Me)f(AyHapoAHoro rropRAKa, coanasaeraoro nepsca-BaMIi'l-rr06eAl1TellbHl1l.\aM1125• Ilormepacxa, OKa3bIBaeMaR 3Tl1MIi'l Aep-

)f(aBaMl1, rrpe)f(Ae acero Benaxoépnraaaeà Ii'l <DpaHl.\li'le:i1, B C03AaHl1l1

l1JIl1 B03pO)f(AeHl1l1 MHOrOQl1ClleHHOJ.1 rpyrrrrbI rOCYAapCTB aroro perl1-

OHa (<Dl1HllRHAIi'lR, 3CTOHl1R, JIaTBl1R, JIl1TBa, Ilonsura, Hexocnoaatoia,Benrpxa 11 IOrOCJIaBl1R) 6bIlIa BbI3BaHa l.\ellbIM pRAOM "reononarrore-

CKl1X" C006pa)f(eHl1J.1. Bo-nepasrx, CTpeMlleHl1e "CrJIaAl1Tb" HeMel.\Kyro

onacnocrs, pa3AP061i'lB Ha QaCTIi'l Aacrpo-Bearepcxyro l1Mrrepl110 Ii'l l1C-

rrOJIb30BaB 3Tl1 Teppli'lTOpl1li'l AJIR C03AaHl1R 6ycpepHbIX rOCYAapCTB, QTO

AOJI)f(HO 6 bIlI O rrpeAOTBpaTl1Tb rnotisre nonsrrxa HeMel.\K0J.13KCrraHCl1li'l Ha

BOCTOK11IOr. BO-BTOpbIX, nossre rOCYAapCTBa BOCTOQHOJ.1Esponsr nonac-

HbI 6bIlIl1 ncnonsaosaraca KaK "caHl1TapHbIJ.1 KOPAOH" rrpOTl1B B03MO)f(-

noro 3KcrropTa 60llbllIeBl1CTCK0J.1 penomouna, a Ha 3TOM rrepBOM arane

aa nonoényio "rrepraaneirrnyro peBOllIOl.\l1IO" BbICTyrrallli'l MHOrli'le srras-

rensasre rnnta 113asrcmero COBeTCKoro PyKOBOACTBa26• HaKOHel.\, c03Aa-

Hli'le 3Tl1X He3aBl1Cl1MbIX rOCYAapCTB COOTBeTCTBOBallO CTpaTerl1QeCKIi'lM

rroTpe6HOCTRM Belll1K06pli'lTaHIi'l11 11<DpaHl.\l1l1. 110 MHeHIi'lIO C3pa ~)f(OHa

X31IcpOPAa Maxronmepa, l1X l.\ellbIO_6bIlIO rrpeAOTBpaTIi'lTb B03MO)f(HOe

COTpYAHIi'lQeCTBOMe)f(AY I'epsranaeà 11POCCl1eJ.1, KOTopble B TeCHOM CO-

I03e - ecmr ne B rrOlIHOM 06'beAl1HeHl1li'l - yCTaHoBl1lIl1 6bI KOHTpOlIb HaA

EBpa311:i1cKIi'lM KOHTl1HeHTOM, ypaBHOBeCl1B TeM caMbIM 6pl1TaHCKOe

24 Ferguson N. XX secolo l'età della violenza. Una nuova interpretazione del Novecento.Milano: Mondadori, 2008. P. 158-173.25 NolteE. La guerra civile europea 1917-1945. Nazionalsocialismo e bolscevismo.Milano: Bur, 2008. P. 47-69.26 Ferguson N. Op. cit. P. 173-198.

43

27 (Il a3HbIM rrpli'l'lYlHaM Y)f(e B 1919 r. 6bIlIOt-'[OpcKoe rrpeBocxOfl,CTBO. O P ynaTb rrpOTYlB

6 v-r C castoro Ha'lalla BbICTHCliO, 'lTO 06a rocYfl,apCTBa Yfl,,· Y13CXO)f(eCTYIY1HTe-aosoro MYlpOBOrO rropRfl,Ka, B CBR3Y1 C QeM, Y1CXOfl,H 28 )

6 11J.1COI03 Ka3allCR snonne B03MO)f(HbIM .pecos, Y1X Y~ 6erry "pealll1cTa" CTalll1Ha,Tpemuù pe3yJlbmam. HeCMOTpR Ha rro M uT o "rrepMaHeHTHOl1B pe3YllbTaTe KOTOpOJ.1CTOpOHHYlKIi'lTe311caCOBPeOT~~~~0COI03 rrpOAOll)\(all

" 11l1Cb B MeHbllIl1HCTBe,~::~;~~::a~~:~M"POBbIM" A:~;;:;::c:%;~:::'~;:c::;::::K 3KcrropTY peBO~IOl.\Y1611,11 rr03T HeCMOTpR Ha rrparMaTYl3M CTalll1Ha

Ofl,HOl1 CTa 1i'l1lbHOCTIi'l.Me)\(fl,YH

3a

Op XX B nocne OTHOCYlTellbHOJ.1 CTa6Y1111i'l3al.\1111BHyrpl1rrO-

20-x 11 -x rr. ., u Bl1H nou CCCP BHOBb aKTl1B11311pOBall CBOl1 neacr

JIl1TYlQeCKOl1Cl1Tyal.\l1l1 CTBax Ilorr06HaR CYlTy-B B fl,pyrl1X rocyfl,ap . M

IlOfl,fl,ep)\(Ke peBOllIOl.\110Hepo fepMaHl1l1 HaTTl1CTOB11yCTaHOBJIe-pl1XOfl,OM K BllaCTl1 B '-\

al.\Y1Ruapany c rr H EBporrbI cpaUI11CTCKl1Xpe)\(Y1MOB (3TOT npouecc Ha-HYleM B pRfl,e crpa RrrOHl1Y1 Ha A3Y1aTCKOM KOHTYlHeH-QaJICH c 1922 r.), a raiose 3KcrraHCl1R HOJ.1rrOJIYlTYlKe- XOTR

nonoénaa 3KCIlopTy peBOJlIOl.\l1Y1B Me)\(fl,)'Hapofl, _Te, M llYlTYlQeCKYlMrrpYlQIilHaM,

no a6COJIIOTHO pa31111'IHbIM Kr.;:~;~I:H:J.1~OrrpYlPOfl,bl MYlpOBOJ.1Cl1CTe-

raiose rr!l1~:llp::J.1 C~:;::: BOJ.1Hbl. C 3TYlM rrOHRTYleM P3~MOHfl, ApOH

Mb! noc IO CR HallYl'lYleM xacrea, opraH1130-CBR3bIBall CYlCTeMy, xapaKTep113y uryro e HaxOfl,HTCH BO B3a-

::::: :;O~~B~pee~~~l1r:~b~::;Iil:llIU:~OoeBp~M~;pT::':e:~B Me::;~:::":a~~

..h ~eJ.1 cpYHKl.\lilelil nna cp ••KllaccYlcp~l.\Y1PYIO 06H0J.1 MOfl,eJlYl MYlpOBOrO yCTpo:i1cTBa HuYlBellYlpy-nopsnxa . Ilpa non eHHeJ.1 Iil BHellIHeYl rrOllYlTYI-

::c; :P::r::~;:~:~~~:a::::~~':7 ~7ca~T rropRfl,OK, OCHOBaHHbIJ.1 Ha

KOHcpllYlKTe Iil HerrpeOfl,Olll1MbIX rrepBOrrpYl:::a~~llIilTYlQeCKYlX pe)\(l1MOBy cnoaue pa3HopOfl,HOCTl1 npnnuan HbIX

PHOJ.1 oc06eHHOCTbIO CYlCTeMbI Me)\(fl,)'Hapofl, u

HBllRllOCb xapaKTe nasany IlepBOJ.1 MYlpOBOYlOTHOllIeHYlJ.1 B rOfl,bI, rrpefl,llieCTByro~Y1e

. /I The Geographic Journal. 1904.27 Mackinder H. J. The Geographical Pivot of H1StOry

VoI.XXIIl,N24.P.421-444. f B' . g the Revisionist State Back In /I28 Schwe/ler R. L. Bandwagoning for Pro u. nngm

. 1994 V I 19 NQl P.72-107.International Secunty. . o'. '. M.'l . Edizioni di Comunità, 1970. P. 130.29 Aron R. Pace e guerra fra le naziorn. 1ano.

Iz

44r. HamallU/,jua

3031 ~a;r Eb' H. The Twenty Years' Crisis. New York: Palgrave 2001

o om o A. La disunità del mondo D '1 l ,.2010. P. 195-206. . opo I seco o globale. Milano: Feltrinelli Editore,32N l .o te E. Op. cit, P. 219-346.

,ll;ymaH BaTaKOBJ1'J, AwpeKTop l1HcTwTyTa 6anKaHwcTwKW Cepécxoù axane-MJ1WHayK J.1J.1CKyCCTB (Cepéan).

CEPBMH HAKAHYHE IIEPBOl/J: MMPOBOl/J: BOl/J:HbI:BHEIJ1HME M BHYTPEHHME BbI30BbI

Ilpasneaae Ilerpa I Kapareopraeaa-ra (1903-1914 rr., epopMallbHo -

AO 1921 r.) nOMHRT KaK 301I0TOl1: BeK Y11IY1Ilepaxnony 3py Cep6Y1Y1 61Ia-

rOAapR yCKopeHHoMy nonaraxecxoay, Ha~Y10HallbHOMY 11KylIbTypHOMy

nom.ésry, KOTOpbIH BMeCTe C TeM COnpOBO)!(,IlalICR pOCTOM 3KOHOMWle-

CKOH caMOCTORTellbHOCTI1. Mexcrry TeM KlIro'IOM K ycnexy Cep61111 6bIlIa

rrpl1BlIeKaTelIbHOCTb eé ,IleMOKpaTI1'IeCKOrO ncrenuaana. OKOllO 70 %M~CKoro HaCelleHI1R I1MenO npaBO ronoca, B TO BpeMR KaK B ABCTpO-

BeHrpY1Y1, a ocoéenao B eé rorocnasancxax perY10HaX (XopBaTI1R -

CllaBOHI1R, AalIMa~I1R, CllOBeHI1R, BOeBO,IlI1Ha) 3Tl1M rrpaBoM B naxane

XX B. pacnollarallo MeHee 20 % HaCelIeHI1R. B npOTY1BOnOlIO)!(HOCTb

Cep61111 B EOCHI1I1 Y1I'epuerosnae, CTpaHe CB060,IlHblX KpecTbRH, KOTO-

pble KaK nenyrarsr B HapO,IlHOH CKyn~I1He cyBepeHHo rrpI1HY1ManY1 pe-

IIIeHI1R 06 yrrpaBlleHl111 rOcy,IlapCTBOM, Cep6CKY1e KpeCTbRHe scé euré 6bI-

lll1 B cTaryce epeO,IlalIbHOH 3aBl1Cl1MOCTl1 (KaK KMembL - KpeCTbRHe, 3a-

BI1CI1Mble OT MycylIbMaHCKI1X òeroa). KOlIOHl1alIbHOe ynpaanenae nya-

lll1CTWleCKOH MOHapXl111 B EOCHI1I1 l1 I'epueroaxae ocnapxaano y 60c-

HI1HCKY1X cepfios, OTHOCI1TelIbHOro 601Ibllll1HCTBa HaCeneHY1R B OKKyrrY1-

pOBaHHbIX npOBY1H~Y1RX, Y1X OCHOBHble 'IenOBe'IeCKY1e npaBa: OT Y1MeHY1

R3bIKa Y1 caMOHa3BaHY1JI (Y1MeHY1 napona) ,Il0 npaBa Ha nl1CbMeHHOCTb

11pelIY1rY103Hble lllKOllbI, c noraoursro KOTOpbIX saurauranacs naunonans-

HaR Y1,I1eHTY1'IHOCTb. B CTapOH Cep6Y1Y1 Y1MaKe,IlOHY1Y1, rne 31I0,IleRHY1R

all6aHCKY1X MRTe)!(HY1KOB Ha,II Cep6aMY1-XpI1CTY1aHaMY1 npl1HRllY1 ,IlpaMa-

TY1'IeCKY1e MaclllTa6bI, ,Ila)!(e Enponeàcxaa Y1HTepBeH~Y1R B TaK Ha3bIBa-

eMblX "MaKe,IlOHCKY1X Bl1lIaHetax" B Eaponeùcxoji Typ~1111 ne Morna

BCTaTb Ha nYTY1 Y pacr~ero xaoca Y1npononacaroureàca ,IlY1CKpY1MY1Ha-

~Y1Y1HeMycylIbMaHcKoro HaCelleHY1R B YMY1paro~eH OCMaHCKOH Y1Mne-

pYlY1I.

I 1jop/je8un /1,. Cptiaja 101Banxau Ha nO'-leTKy XX aexa (1903-1908) // Iyrocnoaeucxa Ha-ponn rtpen Ilpaa CBeTCKI1paT: Iloceéna 1013Aal-baCAHY. Kie. CDXVI : Onerserse npyurr-BeHIo1XHayKa. Beorpan, 1967. K~b.61. C. 207-230.