Христианская газета Разумный замысел № 18

!!"#!$%& !%'(")*+%!,! -./0+%1 $0)21#1National Geographic 31 2008 ,. 21 -1++4!')&' !''1#%&-15677 #&8! 271297):

'1#*81. ; 213-12&&, -.27+722!4 21 !"#!$%0$0)21#1, +97#12 1%872' 21 !/)797#722!4 +#!-7,1 &4722!: «<)0,&7 =59&: )1+%).'1 '1>21 2712:97)'1#*87-». ?'! +#!-! «9)0,&7» !@72* 9!#,! #7:$1#! - !+2!-7 !"67/)&2('!,! 4272&(, %!'!)!7+7,!92( /!'7)/7#! %)1A.

B1 /)!'($72&& "!#77 -7%1 +@&'1#!+* (A!'(+7,!92( 0$7 '1% +@&'15' -+7 472*C7 #597>), @'!271297)'1#*8. ".#& +0'0#.4&, $7+'!%&4& & ,#0:/.4& +067+'-14&, %!'!).A +! -)747274 -.'7+:2&#& "!#77 A09.7, "!#77 042.7 +!-)74722.7

#59&, -'!),C&7+( - &A /)!+')12+'-!. D'! &3 21+27 -&97# &##5+')18&>, &3!")1$156&A /!%).'.AC7)+'*5, A)5%156&A !A!'2&%!-, ,!2(56&A+( 31414!2'!4 - E/!A0 #792&%!-!,! /7)&!91?

F A!'( $0)21# National Geographic - !@7)79:2!> )13 &2&8&&)!-1# 9&+%0++&5 ! 271297)'1#*:81A, !2& -.")1#& /#!A!7 -)74(, @'!". 213-1'*&A «9)0,&4&». D!4472'1)&&, +97#122.7 - G)!:'!%!#1A 218&!21#*2!> 1%1974&& 210% HIJ(GBJB), /! +0'&, )13)0C&#& /!+#792&7 1),0472:'. - /!#*30 '!,!, @'!". 213.-1'* &A «9)0,&4&»1.G)& E'!4, 9#( +'1'*& ".#! -.")12! !@72* /!9A!:9(677 213-12&7: «K1397#(( «21+» & «&A»: /!-7:972&7 271297)'1#*87- & +!-)74722.A #597>».

; /!(+272&(A GE' I&/412 (12')!/!#!,, C'1'G72+&#*-12&() /&C7':

«; 21+'!(677 -)74( &477'+( 2!-1( &2L!):418&( !" 191/'18&(A 271297)'1#*87- + M&")1#:'1)1 — !+')!-1, ,97 )1277 ".# !"21)0$72 @7)7/-3)!+#!,! 271297)'1#*81 & L)1,472'. @7)7/1271297)'1#*+%!,! )7"72%1. D1% +!!"617'+( --./0+%7 GBJB, 9122.7, /!#[email protected] - )730#*'1'7&++#79!-12&( /767) ;12,1)9 & M!)AE4, /!9'-7:)$915', @'! 271297)'1#*8. !"#$%&'$()%! "$(*+,-,../, "%$0./, "+,1"2() 1%3 "45,"2($*().!3. 6%3 -.$7!8 49,./8 :2$ "2)%$ #$%.$;.,$0!1)..$"2&<».1

!"#$#%&'()' (* +,"*()-' 3

"791-2! 4!> 9)0, /!%131# 427 0@7"2&%+-!7,! +.21 /! 7+'7+'-!3212&5. N20@&'+( - ,!+091)+'-722!> +)7927>

C%!#7 - D-&2+#7297, J-+')1#&(. O1% -!', 87#.>)1397# E'!,! 0@7"2&%1 /!+-(672 E-!#58&&. G)&!321%!4#72&& + 2&4 0 472( -+%&/7#1 %)!-*.

H7,!92( 0 97'7> 3147@1'7#*2.7 0@7"2&%& —8-7'2.7, ()%&7, &2'7)7+2.7, - A!)!C74 /7)7/:#7'7, 2! )1397# !" E-!#58&& #+$#!2). %$0&<,!92!"!%!+'*5, L121'&@2!+'*5 & 9!,41'&34!4.

B0, @'! $7, - 2&A /&C0' '!, @'! 31/#12&)!-12!,!+091)+'-722!> !"67!")13!-1'7#*2!> /)!,:)144!>. ?'!' 0@7"2&%, 213-122.> «; 872')7 210:%1, 4», ".# +/78&1#*2! 21/&+12 9#( &30@72&( "&:!#!,&& - 4:5 %#1++1A C%!#. - +!+79274 C'1'7 B!:-.> P$2.> QE#*+. ; )1397#7 !" E-!#58&& 97'(4/)!+'.4 & /!2('2.4 (3.%!4 )1++%13.-15', @'!!2& E-!#58&!2&)!-1#& «!' "1%'7)&& 9! @7#!-7:%1». ?'1 &2L!)418&( /!9%)7/#721 &3!")1$72&(:4&, %!'!).7 +&#*2! -#&(5' 91$7 21 '7A 97'7>, %!:'!).7 27 0475' @&'1'*. D)!47 '!,!, %1)'&2%& !":A!9(' -!/)!+. '7A 97'7>, %!'!).7 0475' @&'1'*.

B1 !92!> &3 '1%&A %1)'&2!% &3!")1$72 ,!#.>@7#!-7% )(9!4 + +&4/1'&@2!> !"73*(2!>. G!+:#12&7 0@72&%14: -. 27 ".#& +!'-!)72. /! !")1:30 R!$*740, 1 E-!#58&!2&)!-1#&, -. — -+7,!#&C* $&-!'2.7.

S67 21 !92!> %1)'&2%7 &3!")1$721 #7+'2&81:,!#.7 /)&41'., /)7-)16156&7+( &3 +,!)"#72:2.A !"73*(2 - #597>. ?'! ')19&8&!22!7 &3!")1:

$72&7 0%)1C1#! !"#!$%0 %2&,& <$!21'121 ;7##+1«F%!2. E-!#58&&», /!+-(6722!> %#1++&@7+%&4«9!%131'7#*+'-14» E-!#58&&. G!9!"2!7 &3!")1:$72&7 + /!#2.4 /)1-!4 4!$2! 213-1'* )1+&+:'+%&4 (E'!' -!/)!+ ( )1++4!')7# - 9)0,!> +'1'*7).

T27 &2'7)7+2!, @&'1# #& %'!:2&"09* &3 +!+:'1-&'7#7> E'!,! )1397#1 !" E-!#58&& %2&,0;7##+1? FA )1397# /!#2!+'*5 /)!/&'12 0+'1:)7-C&4& «&%!214&», %!'!).7 ;7##+ !%!2@1'7#*:2! 9&+%)79&'&)!-1#. B70$7#& !2& 04.C#722!/)!&,2!)&)!-1#& 7,! 210@205 %)&'&%0? ;!#207'#& &A '!' L1%', @'! !2& «%!)4('» 97'7> #!$2!>&2L!)418&7>?

D!,91 ( /)!+41')&-1# )1397#, ( !")1'&#-2&412&7 21 '!, @'! - 274 +!97)$&'+( 42!,! 0+:'1)7-C7> &2L!)418&& & [email protected] !C&"!%. T!$:2! 21/&+1'* 87#05 %2&,0, !/)!-7),1( E'0 7)0290.U!)!C!, @'! 21 +14!4 97#7 '1%&7 %2&,& 0$7 21:/&+12. (H4., 21/)&47): «N/)!-7),1( E-!#5:8&5», @. 1:2). V /)&-790 #&C* 27%!'!)05 &2L!):418&5, /)79+'1-#72205 - E'!4 )1397#7.

=&<+>! 6)+(!.). ;*5)%& 27 /!9'-7)$915'E-!#58&5 - '!4 +4.+#7, - %!'!)!4 !21 /)79+:'1-#721 - 0@7"2&%7 — E-!#58&( «!' "1%'7)&& %@7#!-7%0».

N2& (-#(5'+( /)&47)!4 7+'7+'-722!,! !':"!)1, %!'!).> /)& E'!4 27 !")1307' 2&%1%!> 2!:-!> ,727'&@7+%!> &2L!)418&&, 27!"A!9&4!>9#( '!,!, @'!". )1"!'1#1 E-!#58&(.

=?@AB CDE?=?FFEGAD@

!"#$#%&'()' (* +,"*()-' 2

#!' 0$7 27+%!#*%! #7' )!412 <E21 R)10:21 «D!9 91 ;&2@&» 312&417' -7)A255+')!@%0 - +/&+%7 4&)!-.A "7+'+7##7:

)!- (/)!912! !%!#! 40 4#2 E%374/#()!- 21 44(3.%1A), 1 2791-2! /! %2&,7 ".# +2(' L&#*4,'1%$7 +'1-C&> +0/7)/!/0#()2.41. <#( 27+#&C%!4 -904@&-!,! @&'1'7#( — E'! -+7,!#&C* 21C047-C&> 97'7%'&- ! '!4, %1% 3#!:97>+%& 0"&'.> +4!')&'7#* =0-)1 0+/7# !+'1:-&'* /7)79 +47)'*5 31C&L)!-12205 31/&+%0,1 %#5@& % C&L)0 +%).'. - )1"!'1A =7!21)9!91 ;&2@&, -%#5@1( «T!20 =&30». ?'& %#5@& 27/!4!,0' 21>'& 0"&>80, 2! + &A /!4!6*5 4!$2!

-.(+2&'*, ,97 21A!9&'+( H-('!> M)11#*. N921:%! - E'!> &+'!)&& H-('!> M)11#* — 27 @1C1, &3%!'!)!> U)&+'!+ /&# -! -)74( O1>2!> ;7@7)&,1 … $726&21, T1)&( T1,91#&21 — /! 0'-7)$:972&5 R)1021, $721 F&+0+1, %!'!)1( /!+#7 S,!)1+/('&( "7$1#1 -! W)128&5, ,97 )!9&#1 !'B7,! 9!@* (,#1-1 60). (O1%&4 !")13!4, #!2! T1:)&& T1,91#&2. 91#! $&32* /!'!4+'-0 F&+0:+1.). <!%131'7#*+'-1 '!40, %1% ,!-!)&'+( - )!:4127, «+!+'!(' &3 '.+(@ +')12&8 '7%+'1 … - @7:'.)7A !,)!42.A '($7#.A +0290%1A» (,#1-1 60).

R)102 /&C7': «G!&+%& @1C& M)11#( 21 +14!497#7 27 @'! &2!7, %1% +')74#72&7 /)7%#!2&'* %!:

#72& /7)79 /)1A!4 T1)&& T1,91#&2.. ?'! +-!7:,! )!91 /1#!42&@7+'-! + 87#*5 /!4!#&'*+( !':-7)$722!>, 0')1@722!40 +-(6722!40 $72+%!4021@1#0» (,#1-1 60).

BH"$%<2./; (/-/",% ; +14!4 21@1#7 %2&,& R)102 /&C7': «; E'!4

)!4127 -+7 97>+'-056&7 #&81, 47+'1 & +!".'&(#&"! -.4.C#72., #&"! 27 +!!'-7'+'-05'97>+'-&'7#*2!+'&». B7+4!')( 21 E'!, 91#77 -)!4127 !2 /.'17'+( /!+'1-&'* /!9 +!4272&7 "!:$7+'-722!+'* U)&+'1 & 9!+'!-7)2!+'* R&"#&&.

!"#$#%&'()' (* +,"*()-' 8

$"% &'(&$)*+, -$./ "*0%1 )(,21

«3$) )* #%"4%»: #5)613* &$) #%)$1 &'*#)5

3$"(7 1%8* $ "(*")(',*-/7*9?!"# "$%%$&'&( )*&%+'$*&( ,&,-%$ ( ./& %&(0)*0.

1909 ,.

2007 ,.

=?@AB CDE?=?FFEGAD@

?IEBF I?JD@ DKD LKBAGMB ?IGFNOA?

L+!-,9).!,: E'1 /)!"#741 1%'01#*21 & 9#( Q%)1&2., '1% %1% "!#*C&2+'-! !C&"!%, !"412!- &0+'1)7-C7> &2L!)418&&, !/&+122.A - E'!> +'1'*7, /)&+0'+'-05' & - 0%)1&2+%&A 0@7"2&%1A.<#( !321%!4#72&( + /!#2.4 +/&+%!4 !C&"!% & !"412!- - 0%)1&2+%&A C%!#*2.A 0@7"2&%1A+4!')&'7 21 +1>'7 http://nt:creaz.org.ua/data/zvern2:fulltext:spysok:nedol.htm

K13042.> X14.+7# | www.origins.org.ua

0,3 0!+)P) — /!/0:#()2.> +&4-!# E-!:#58&&, 2! !2 27

&477' 2&%1%&A &+%!/174.A /!9':-7)$972&> & 2& !92!,! 0"79&:'7#*2!,! 47A12&341 (H4. 21www.origins.org.ua: «I7( $&)1:L1: 767 !9&2 +&4-!# E-!#58&&'7)/&' 27091@0»).

G"2,"2(,../; $2H$+. N2&97' 21/7)7)73 E-!#58&&. S+:'7+'-722.> !'"!) #&C* !'"&)1:7' & 091#(7' ,727'&@7+%05 &2:L!)418&5, %!'!)1( 0$7 /)&+0':+'-07' (H4. 21www.origins.org.ua: «T0'2.7 -!:9.: -2!+( (+2!+'* - -!/)!+ ! 7+:'7+'-722!4 !'"!)7»).

I,+,'$(/, #31,.!Q/. <1:$7 7+#& E%+/7)&472'. + 2&4& &".#& 0+/7C2.4&, !2& /!%131#&#&C* 7+'7+'-722.> !'"!), 1 E'!— 27 E-!#58&(. <1$7 +14& E-!:#58&!2&+'. /)&3215' E'!'L1%' (H4. 21 www.origins.org.ua:«G)!61>'7, "7)73!-.7 /(972&:8.»).

=!1$$H+)'$().!,. N/('*:'1%&, -&9!!")13!-12&7 27 (-#(:7'+( E-!#58&7> — 2!-.> "&!:#!,&@7+%&> -&9 !")1307'+( "73%1%!>:#&"! 2!-!> ,727'&@7+%!>&2L!)418&&. ;&9!!")13!-12&727 /)7-)1'&' «"1%'7)&5 - @7#!:-7%1». W1%'&@7+%& ".+')!7 -&:9!!")13!-12&7 A!)!C! !"Y(+:2(7'+( - )14%1A 4!97#& %)718&:!2&341, 2! E-!#58&!2&+'.09&-#72. '74, 21+%!#*%! ".+':)! E'! /)!&+A!9&'.

R$.(,+7,.2.)3 :($%<Q!3.B13-12&7, /)&904122!7 9#( !"Y:(+272&( 27!$&9122.A & 27-7)!('2! +A!92.A/)&321%!- 0 $&-!'2.A, 27 +-(3122.A "#&$1>C&4)!9+'-!4. F2!,91 77 213.-15' «,!4!/#1+'&@7+:%!> E-!#58&7>». O1%&7 +A!92.7 A1)1%'7)&+'&%&(-#(5'+( 4!62.4 +-&97'7#*+'-!4 - /!#*30 +!':

-!)72&( (H4. 21 www.origins.org.ua: «T!,#! #&+)79277 0A! 4#7%!/&'156&A $&-!'2.A E-!#58&:!2&)!-1'* 9-1$9.?»).

S>"#,+!-,.2 C!%%,+)*T+,3. D1% 27 +'.9:2!! ;! -)74( E'!,! E%+/7)&472'1 &+/!#*3!-1#&27 '0 1'4!+L7)0, ".#& /!#0@72. 27 '7 A&4&@7+:%&7 /)!90%'., & 27 ".#! !")13!-12! 2&@7,!, @'!A!'( ". !'91#722! 21/!4&21#! $&32*. B&%!40 27:&3-7+'2!, %1%&4 !")13!4 $&32* 4!,#1 -!32&%20'*- A!97 21'0)1#&+'&@7+%&A /)!87++!-, 2! 0@72&:%14 !" E'!4 27 ,!-!)(' (H4. 21 www.origins.org.ua:«G!@740 &++#79!-12&7 T&##7)1:Q)7( !/)!-7):,17' 1"&!,7273»).

L,+,8$1./, P$+-/.B7 +067+'-07' 2&%1%&A/7)7A!92.A L!)4, 21 !+2!-7 %!'!).A 4!$2! ".#!". /!+')!&'* 27!/)!-7)$&4!7 9!%131'7#*+'-! —7+'* #&C* 27%!'!).7 +!42&'7#*2.7 21A!9%&.

E31/ !">$#),-/8 %$U)1,;. G!3!)! H&4-!#,!' %!'!)!,! 0$7 91-2! !'%131#&+* +14& [email protected]:E-!#58&!2&+'. (H4. 21 www.origins.org.ua: «=!C1:9&2.> 2!2+72+»).

6($3>$1/U)5!, +/H/. S67 !921 0+'1)7-:C1( &97(, !' %!'!)!> [email protected] !'%131#&+* (H4. 21www.origins.org.ua: «=7'!/&+* !%14727#!+'7>9)7-2&A '7')1/!9: +-&97'7#*+'-! !+2!-2!,!E-!#58&!22!,! /7)7A!91?»).

B+8,$#2,+!>". S67 !9&2 0+'1)7-C&> /)&:47), %!'!).> E-!#58&!2&+'. 0$7 /7)7+'1#&)1++41')&-1'*. S,! 91'&)!-12&7 27/)1-&#*2!791$7 /! /!9+@7'14 +14&A E-!#58&!2&+'!-, & +7:,!92( 1)A7!/'7)&%+ +@&'17'+( /!#2!+'*5 L02%:8&!21#*2!>, #7'1567> /'&87>1.

V+)(.!2,%&.)3 ).)2$-!3.F2!,91 E-!#58&:!2&+'. 31(-#(5', @'! +A!92!7 +')!72&7 !),12&3:4!- /!9'-7)$917' +067+'-!-12&7 !"67,! /)79:%1, 2! &2!,91 !2& '1% 27 90415'. O1%!7 4272&7,"730+#!-2!, +0"Y7%'&-2!7, & 42!,&7 !+!"722!+'&E4")&!21#*2!,! )13-&'&( !/)!-7),15' '1%!7 31:(-#72&7. HA!9+'-1 - +')!72&& — E'! A!)!C77+-&97'7#*+'-! - /!#*30 !"67,! 9&31>27)1 (H4.21 www.origins.org.ua: «V-#(7'+( #& ,!4!#!,&(+-&97'7#*+'-!4 E-!#58&!22!,! 21'0)1#&341?»).

S-H+!$.)%&.$, +)'(!2!,. G!3!) & 767)13 /!3!)! ?'0 &975 0$7 91-2! 27 &+/!#*305'%1% 9!%131'7#*+'-! E-!#58&&. K&+02%& M7%%7#(— (-21( #!$*. (H4. 21 14> +')12&87: «N"412)1+%).' 312!-!»)

W,$7+)P!9,">$, +)"#+,1,%,.!, +)"2,*.!; ! 0!($2./8. K1++0$972&7 /! %)0,0. ?-!#5:8&( 9!/0+%17'+( 9#( !"Y(+272&( "&!,7!,)1L&&,%!'!)1(, - +-!5 !@7)79*, &+/!#*307'+(, @'!".9!%131'* E-!#58&5. <#( E-!#58&!2&+'1 -+7-!%)0, 7+'* 9!%131'7#*+'-!4 E-!#58&&, 2! +0:67+'-05' & 9)0,&7 !"Y(+272&(.

64#%!>)Q!3 7,.). S+#& -. +97#17'7 9-7 %!:/&& 9!%0472'1, @&+#! 321%!- - -1C74 9!%0472'727 09-!&'+(. D!/&)!-12&7 27 /)!&3-!9&' 2!-!>,727'&@7+%!> &2L!)418&& — !2! /)!+'! -!+/:)!&3-!9&' '!, @'! 0$7 7+'*. D1%&4 !")13!4

-/7)-.7 -!32&%#1 &2L!)418&(? (H4. 21www.origins.org.ua: «B!-.7 L02%8&& /!(-#(5'+(- )730#*'1'7 90/#&%18&& ,721?»).

S($%<Q!3 9,%$(,>). <!%131'7#*+'-1 21!+2!-7 ,!4&2&9 4!$2! )1397#&'* 21 &+%!/17:4.7 @7#!-7%1 & &+%!/174.7 !"73*(2. X1(-#72&(! /7)7A!92.A L!)41A — E'! -+7,! #&C* +0"Y7%:'&-2.7 &2'7)/)7'18&&, +97#122.7 21 !+2!-741#!@&+#722.A & +!42&'7#*2.A 21A!9!%.

K<"!. Z7#!-7@7+%&7 ,#131, )0%& & 2!,&, /)&:)&+!-122.7 % !"73*(27, 97#15' E'! +067+'-!/!A!$&4 21 /!#0@7#!-7%1:/!#0!"73*(20. B! -97>+'-&'7#*2!+'& =5+& ".#1 !".%2!-722!>!"73*(2!>, ! @74 +-&97'7#*+'-07' & 77 213-12&7— 1-+')1#!/&'7% («5$21( !"73*(21») (H4. 21www.origins.org.ua: «?-!#58&!2&+'. "!#*C7 27#5"(' =5+&»).

W$-$ W)H!%!". M)091 &+%!/174.A @7#!-7%1 &!"73*(2., %!'!)1( '7/7)* /)&32121 2797>+'-&:'7#*2.4 '1%+!2!4. ; 0@7"2&%7 91$7 +!97)$&'+(&3!")1$72&7 E'!,! -.4.C#722!,! +067+'-1(H4. 21 www.origins.org.ua: «M!4! M1"&#&+ +#73 ++747>2!,! 97)7-1»).

W$-$ S+,>24".B7' 2& !92!,! +-&97'7#*+'-1,0%13.-1567,! 21 '!, @'! E'! 27 @7#!-7@7+%&> -&9(H4. 21 www.origins.org.ua: «;!>2. @7)7/!-»).

A,).1,+2)%,Q. K12*C7 7,! &3!")1$1#& --&97 /)&4&'&-2!,! /767)2!,! @7#!-7%1, 2! '7:/7)* +@&'17'+(, @'! 271297)'1#78 — /!#2!872:2.> @7#!-7%. H4. 21 3> +')12&87 «D!278 4&L1 !271297)'1#*81A?»)

R+$-).&$.,Q. B7 3-7)* + 90"&2%!>, 1 /!#:2!8722.> @7#!-7%.

K1++4!')72&7 '74. E-!#58&& - 0@7"2&%7 —/)!+'! /!3!)! ?-!#58&( /)79+'1-#(7'+( 210:%!>, 2! -7+* )1397# ! 27> — 210@2! !C&"!@2.>(+ '!@%& 3)72&( !+2!-2.A /)79+'1-#722.A - 274+-&97'7#*+'-) & 0+'1)7-C&>. ?'!' )1397# !"E-!#58&& /)!/&'12 #!$*5, !92!"!%!+'*5, 27:!+-79!4#722!+'*5 & !"412!4. N2 %)&'&%07'

+!'-!)72&7 & !"&$17' '7A, %'! /)&97)$&-17'+(9)0,!> '!@%& 3)72&(.

?'! /)&47) 1-+')1#&>+%!,! 0@7"2&%1, .$1)..)3 #+$H%,-) !-,,2 -!+$(/, -)"U2)H/.

H!3917'+( -/7@1'#72&7, @'! 0@7"2&%& — E'!-+7,! #&C* @1+'* !,)!42!> +')1'7,&& /! /!9:-7)$72&5 87230)7 9!+'0/2!> &2L!)418&&, 121:#!,&@2! '!40, %1% /!%1312! - L&#*47 «F3,212:2.7». ;+7 9122.7 /)79+'1-#(5'+( - +-7'7 4&)+:%!,!, 1'7&+'&@7+%!,!, 41'7)&1#&+'&@7+%!,! &,0412&+'&@7+%!,! 4&)!-!33)72&(.

G)!+41')&-1( E'!' 0@7"2&%, ( -+/!42&# ')1:,&@7+%!7 31(-#72&7 <1))7##1 H%!''1, 9!@* %!'!:)!,!, K7>@7#, ".#1 31+')7#721 20 1/)7#( 1999 ,.;47+'7 + 9)0,&4& 12 97'*4& !21 ".#1 0"&'1 9-0:4( +'0972'14& - +)7927> C%!#7 D!#!4"&21,HIJ. N9&2 &3 +')7#(-C&A +'0972'!- ".# !97' -L0'"!#%0 + 219/&+*5 «S+'7+'-722.> !'"!)».

<1))7## +%131#: «S+#& 21C&A 97'7> 0@1', @'!!2& -!32&%#& &3 %0+%1 ,)(3&, E-!#58&!2&)!-1#&&3 2&3C7> L!)4. $&32&, 1 /!+#7 +47)'& 27' "0:9067,!, '!, 7+'7+'-722!, -+7 E'! L!)4&)07' &A4&)!-!33)72&7… ; 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'& $&32* 9#(2&A 27 &477' '!,! +4.+#1, %!'!).> &475' 97'&,-7)056&7 - '!, @'! !2& +!'-!)72. /! !")130R!$*740, & @'! /!4&4! E'!> $&32& 0 2&A 7+'*$&32* - "090674».

L$+) 49,H./- ')(,1,.!3- #+,>+)2!2&49!2& .)U!8 1,2,; %0!. N921%! -#1+'&, L&:212+&)056&7 E'0 /!3!)205, )13)0C15605 &97:!#!,&@7+%05 !")1"!'%0, #0@C7 21>40' "!#*C7/!#&87>+%&A, /!+')!(' 2!-.7 '5)*4. & --790'"!#77 +0)!-.7 31%!2., @'!". +/)1-&'*+( + 7727,1'&-2.4& /!+#79+'-&(4&. ?'! /)!+'! ,#0/!.

M)" T?RGEwww.creation.com

V"/%>!:;7##& K., B7-&## D., K!"7)'+!2 G., K&%1)9 M., W&##&/+ M.,<$7LL)& W., ?##&+ <. ; 872')7 210%1, 4. — T7#*"0)2:Pearson Educational Australia, 2005. — H. 222:261. ; 0@7":2&%7 40 +')12&8 &3 300 /!+-(672. E-!#58&&.

=?@AB CDE?=?FFEGAD@

$"% &'(&$)*+, -$./ "*0%1 )(,21!1.2'$*, '-,$1*-''#3 &)$2*-"$, %&4'&3 $'5&6"-7$.3, 8029.*:$('#"$ ,6.;,&%&4.'$<"$ $ … %&4+=?

!"#$%&' ()#*& +,*&%-"&#$ ./#%01+". 2*#($+ 34+*#5.$+/%-) 60%07 8+65%-($+'$9 $+/10, .1&:-"&' %& $+, /$+ 0(1+3&#*-# 34+($+ +$(.$($".;$.

F2'7)7+2! '!, %1% E-!#58&!2&+'. /)&9041:#& +/!+!" +!A)12('* +-!5 ,&/!'730 "73 9!%131:'7#*+'- - -&97 /7)7A!92.A L!)4, +%).-1( /)!:"7#. & +!391-1( &##53&5 )71#*2!+'& 41%)!E:-!#58&&. D1% !2& E'! 97#15'? H /!4!6*5 —%#19!,)144 (+A74. ,7271#!,&@7+%&A +-(37>).

D7-&2 G19&12, %0)1'!) T037( /1#7!2'!#!:,&& D1#&L!)2&>+%!,! Q2&-7)+&'7'1 - R7)%#&,974!2+')&)07' E'!' +/!+!" - +'1'*7 «<6./=#%0#>"+6;?0+%%+@+ +,4&:+"&%0'», ,97 !2 &3!")13&#«/)!&+A!$972&7 @7'-7)!2!,&A $&-!'2.A».

G19&12 ,!-!)&': «G)&47)2! 385:360 4#2#7' 21319, - A!97 E-!#58&& 0 /[email protected],&4756&A 4(+&+'.7 /#1-2&%&, /!(-&#&+* @7:'.)7 2!,&, 1 +! -)747274 & +/!+!"2!+'* A!:9&'* /! 374#7. H'19&& E'!,! /7)7A!91 31/&+1:2. - &+%!/174.A, & 27%!'!).7 &3 2&A /)79+:'1-#72. 397+*».

N921%!, %#19!,)1441 27 0+'121-#&-17'%1%!>:#&"! ,7271#!,&@7+%!> +-(3& !' /)79%1% /!'!4%0 — !21 (",7$ %!U& +)'-,5),2 $+*7).!'-/ - +!!'-7'+'-&& +! +A!9+'-14& 47$:90 2&4&. ; E'!> 9&1,)1447 /!%1312. - !/)7:97#722!4 /!)(9%7 97-('* )132.A $&-!'2.A.X147'*'7, @'! E'& $&-!'2.7 +!79&272. 9)0, +9)0,!4 @7)2!> $&)2!> #&2&7>, - )730#*'1'7@7,! "$'1),2"3 (#,9)2%,.!,, @'! E'& ,)0//.$&-!'2.A E-!#58&!2&)!-1#& !' !"67,!/)79%1. B1 +A747 &3 #&2&>, 21/!4&21567>%0+', /!%1312! -!+74* !"6&A /)79%!-, !"!3:[email protected] 47+'14& /7)7+7@72&( #&2&>.

F'1%, 9!%13.-17' #& E'1 +A741 &+'&22!+'*E-!#58&&, %1% 31(-#(7' G19&12? <1-1>'7 )1+:+4!')&4 "(!1,2,%&"2(). ;&9&4 #& 4. +-&97:'7#*+'-1 $&-!'2.A, /!%13122.A - %!287 %1$:9!> #&2&& +A74.? <1. T. -&9&4 42!$7+'-!/)&47)!- #0@7/7).A & 9-!(%!9.C16&A ).", 1

'1%$7 @7'-7)!2!,&A $&-!'2.A. D)!47 '!,!, 4.-&9&4 &+%!/174.7 '1%'11#&%& ()!9 &+%!/17:4.A #!/1+'7/7).A )."). O1% @'! +-&97'7#*+'-1+067+'-05' & +)"#$%$0,./ $.! .) >$.9!>)8%!.!; >%)1$7+)--/ !%! (,2(,; >4"2).

;&9&4 #& 4. +-&97'7#*+'-1 !"6&A /)79:%!-, %!'!).7 !"!321@72. /7)[email protected]& #&:2&(4& %#19!,)144.? B1/)&47), /)79+'1-#(:7' #& +A741 +-&97'7#*+'-1 !"67,! /)79%1, /!:#!$&-C7,! 21@1#! +!-)74722.4 @7'-7)!2!:,&4 & &+%!/174.4 '0#7)/7'!214, %1% /!%13.:-15' /7)7+7@72&( &A #&2&>? B7', E'!,! 4. 27-&9&4. J %1% 21 +@7' 47+' /7)7+7@72&( 9)0,&A#&2&>? B7', -!!"67 2& !92!,!.

O1% @'! -+( %#19!,)1441 G19&121 — E'! 27"!#77 @74 )1++'12!-%1 $&-.A & &+%!/174.A$&-!'2.A - !/)797#722!> /!+#79!-1'7#*2!+:'& - +!!'-7'+'-&& + )13#&@2.4& A1)1%'7)&+:

'&%14&. G! 7,! 4272&5, +A741 9!%13.-17', @'!E-!#58&( — E'! L1%'. A$ $. (,+!% ( :2$ ,5,1$ 2$7$, >)> "$"2)(!% "($< "8,-4.

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

D1% +%131# - +-!7> %2&,7 «A+(6&%0# + 50:%0»%)718&!2&+' ;!#'7) K741>2, %#19!,)144. +!3:915' &##53&5 L&#!,72&& ()!9!+#!-2!,! 97)7:-1), A!'( - 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'& !21 !'+0'+'-07'.

!"#$%&'#((): *++,!-./0)1 23%2%4//,$,0.5 67,0.!%/ / 8#4"69$,0.,

/%- :%'%;#50%/%2-<

!#0$72&7 «K13042.> X14.+7#» +')74&'+(/)!+#1-#('* & /!@&'1'* R!,1:O-!)81, 1 '1%$70'-7)$91'* &+'&20 ! '!4, @'! R&"#&( !/&+.:

-17' /!9#&2205 &+'!)&5 /)!&+A!$972&( 4&)1 &@7#!-7%1. Z1+'*5 E'!> &+'!)&& (-#(7'+( /#!A1(2!-!+'* ! 21)0C72&& J914!4 R!$*7,! /!-7#72&(.R02' @7#!-7%1 /)!'&- +-!7,! O-!)81 /)&27+ - 4&)+47)'*, +')1912&( & )13#0%0 + R!,!4: «F"! -!3473:9&7 31 ,)7A — +47)'*» (K&4#(214 6:23). ?'& )7:30#*'1'. &3-7+'2. %1$9!40. H 4!472'1 31@1'&( -+7/!'!4%& J9141 /!)1$72. ,)7A!4 (G+1#!4 50:7) &+!/)&@1+'2. 27/!+#0C12&5 J9141 (,)7A0). =59&0$7 27 4!,0' 21A!9&'*+( - /)&+0'+'-&& H-('!,! R!:,1, !")7@72. 21 )13#0%0 + B&4, /)7".-1( /!9 -7@:2.4 R!$*&4 !+0$972&74 & ,27-!4 31 ,)7A&. R&":#&( ,!-!)&', @'! «-+7 +!,)7C&#& & #&C72. +#1-.R!$&7>» (K&4#(214 3:23), & @'! -+7 «/!9-7),20'+(21%1312&5, -7@2!> /!,&"7#&, !' #&81 M!+/!91 & !'+#1-. 4!,067+'-1 S,!» (2 W7++1#!2&%&>814 1:9).

B! 7+'* & A!)!C1( 2!-!+'*: R!, 27 !+'1#+("730@1+'2.4 % 21C7> "797. «F"! '1% -!3#5"&#R!, 4&), @'! !'91# H.21 H-!7,! S9&2!)!92!,!,91". -+(%&> -7)056&> - B7,!, 27 /!,&", 2! &47#$&32* -7@205» (F!1221 3:16).

M!+/!9* F&+0+ U)&+'!+, H!391'7#* 4&)1, "0:90@& R73,)7C2.4, -3(# 21 H7"( ,27- R!$&> & -&:20 31 ,)7A& -+7,! @7#!-7@7+'-1, /!27+( &A /!+#7:9+'-&( — +47)'* & )13#0%0 + R!,!4. N2 047) 21%)7+'7 31 ,)7A&, 2! 21 ')7'&> 972* -!+%)7+, /!"7:9&- +47)'*. F '7/7)* %1$9.>, %'! &+%)7227 -7)&'- B7,! %1% - +-!7,! #&@2!,! M!+/!91 & H/1+&'7#(,)1+%1&-17'+( - +-!&A ,)7A1A & /!#1,17'+( - +/1:+72&& 27 21 +7"(, 27 21 +-!& 97#1, 1 21 U)&+'1 &S,! "#1,!91'*, 4!$7' -7)20'*+( % R!,0 & /)7".:-1'* - -7@2!4 !"672&& +! +-!&4 O-!)8!4. «;7)0:56&> - B7,! 27 +09&'+(, 1 27-7)056&> 0$7 !+0$:972, /!'!40 @'! 27 0-7)!-1# -! &4( S9&2!)!92!:,! H.21 R!$&(» (F!1221 3:18).

«F+'&22! &+'&22! ,!-!)5 -14: -7)056&> -T72( &477' $&32* -7@205» (F!1221 6:47)

<&-72 21C H/1+&'7#* & @097+2! +/1+72&7 -!U)&+'7, 21C74 H!391'7#7!

2

K13042.> X14.+7# | www.origins.org.ua 3

:!#*C&2+'-! 12')!/!#!,!- 0$7 !'27+#&271297)'1#*87- % ,)0//7 #597>. O1%,?)&% O)&2%10+ +@&'17', @'! 271297)'1#*:

8. & +!-)74722.7 #59& +%)76&-1#&+*. R!#*:C&2+'-! +!-)74722.A [email protected] +@&'15' 271297):'1#*87- A!)!C&4& !A!'2&%14&, #!-%&4&, 9)0$7:#5"2.4&, 1)'&+'&@2.4& & 0+/7C2.4& -! -+7A!'2!C72&(A #59*4&, 1 27 /!#09&%&4& +067+'-1:4&, &4756&4& «-7+*41 !'91#722!7 !'2!C72&7»% +!-)74722.4 #59(4. Q$7 91-2! &3-7+'2!, @'!!"Y74 &A @7)7/2!> %!)!"%& - +)79274 ".# "!#*:C7, @74 !"Y74 21C7,! @7)7/1. F -+7 $7 42!,&712')!/!#!,& 9! +&A /!) 27 4!,0' !'%131'*+( !'4272&(, @'! !2& ".#&, 20, A!)!C!, 4!$7' ".'*, &27 ,#0/.4&, 2! 27 '1%&4& 0409)722.4&, %1% +!-:)74722.7 #59&, - !'2!C72&& +!8&1#*2!,! /!:-7972&(, '-!)@7+'-1 & $&32722.A +')1'7,&>.

I&/412 /!+'1-&#1 /!9 +!4272&7 /!+#792&>1),0472' - /!#*30 %#1++&L&%18&& 271297)'1#*87-%1% «9)0,&A». <122.7, /!#[email protected] - A!97 &++#79!:-12&( M&")1#'1)+%&A /767), /!%13.-15', @'! !2&!"#191#& -+74& +%$0./-! 8)+)>2,+!"2!>)-!#$(,1,.!3, /)&+06&4&, %1% +@&'1#!+*, '!#*%!+!-)74722.4 #59(4:(1) C&)!%!7 &+/!#*3!-12&7 3747#*2.A )7+0):

+!-;(2) #!-#( ).". & !A!'1;(3) &+/!#*3!-12&7 47#%!41+C'1"2.A )7+0)+!-;(4) /#12&)!-122!7 &+/!#*3!-12&7 )7+0)+!- -

31-&+&4!+'& !' -)7472& ,!91.O1%!7 !'%).'&7 ".#! -+')7@72! 9!+'1'!@2!

E4!8&!21#*2!. «O!, @'! $&32722.7 +')1'7,&&,+-!>+'-722.7 +!-)74722.4 #59(4, !'47@1#&+*+)79& '1%&A 1)A1&@2.A #597>, %1% 271297)'1#*8.,91$7 «28 000 #7' 21319», — !'47'&#1 I&/412, —«/)!+'! 09&-&'7#*2!». Z'! E'! !321@17'?

X)>2!9,">!, :2$ $'.)9),2, 92$ ).2+$#$*%$7! (", (+,-3 $U!H)%!"& $2.$"!2,%&.$ .)*U!8 "$H+)2&,(. ?'! )13)0C17' '!@%0 3)72&(,+!,#1+2! %!'!)!> 271297)'1#*8. ".#& 27091@:2&%14& /! +)1-272&5 + "!#77 +!-)74722.4& &)13-&'.4& Homo sapiens. N")1'&'7 -2&412&7 21/!+#792&> -!/)!+ 12')!/!#!,1:

«; 21+'!(677 -)74( /1#7!12')!/!#!,& "#$*+32 $ 2$-, $2%!9)<2"3 %! >)>!,*%!H$ :%,*-,.2/ -)2,+!)%&.$; >4%&24+/ ( #$(,1,.!!"$(+,-,../8 ! 1+,(.!8 %<1,;. ; @1+'2!+'&,T1%")&)'& & R)0%+ +'1-(' /!9 +!4272&7 ,&/!'7:30, +!,#1+2! %!'!)!> :40 000 #7' 21319 - S-)!/7/)!&3!C7# )73%&> «/7)7-!)!' - )13-&'&& @7#!:-7%1», !"0+#!-&-C&> /!(-#72&7 +!-)74722.A#597> & )13-&'&7 +!-)74722!,! /!-7972&(. ;M&")1#'1)7 ?28 000 #7' 21319 271297)'1#*8. &+!-)74722.7 #59&, !@7-&92!, &47#& /!A!$&7&#& !9&21%!-.7 «+!-)74722.7» 47'!9. -797:2&( A!3(>+'-1... G"%! «.)"» ("$(+,-,../8 %<*1,;) $21,%3%$ $2 «.!8» (.,).1,+2)%&Q,() .,#$(,1,.!,, 2$ 92$ 0, 2$71)?».

D)!47 '!,!, !21 +/)1C&-17': 7+#& 271297):'1#*8. & +!-)74722.7 #59& $&#& /! +!+79+'-0 -M&")1#'1)7, &47( !92& & '7 $7 47'!9. -7972&( A!:3(>+'-1, /!@740 '!,91 !2& -.47)#&? ; 31%#5@7:

2&&, I&4/12 ,!-!)&': «V>$+,, (",7$, -/ .!>$7*1) 27 /!#0@&4 !'-7'. 21 E'& -!/)!+.».

N'-7'. /!#0@&'* 27 '1% 0$ & +#!$2!. ?'! E-!:#58&!2&+'. 31%).-15' #59(4 ,#131 & 97#15'27(+2.4 !@7-&92!7 9#( '7A, %'! !'%13.-17'+(-&97'*. ?'! 27 09&-#(7' %)718&!:2&+'!-. N2& @0-+'-05' +7"( !/:)1-9122.4&.

;+( &+'!)&( !" E-!#58&& @7#!:-7%1 — 27 "!#77 @74 -.904%1. <#(21@1#1 /!9041>'7 -!' ! @74: '7:/7)*, %!,91 4. 32174, @'! 271297):'1#*8. ".#& '1%&4& $7 )13042.4&,%1% & +!-)74722.7 #59&, E-!#58&:!2&+'. A!'(', @'!". 4. /!-7)&#& -'!, @'! E'& #59& $&#& +)79& %)0/:2.A 4#7%!/&'156&A $&-!'2.A & !A!'&#&+* 21 2&A21 /)!'($72&& 100 000 #7' (@'! - 97+('* )13 "!#*:C7 31/&+122!> @7#!-7@7+%!> &+'!)&&), 31 -+7 E'!-)74( %# %&./060(9 #:80$9 "#4)+* %& 6+=&80, -.:)16&-1'* )1+'72&( &#& +')!&'* ,!)!91. B70$7#&E'! 31+#0$&-17' A!'* %1/#& 9!-7)&(?

<1$7 /!(-&-C&4+( 30 000 #7' 21319 «+!-)7:4722.4 #59(4», @'!". 210@&'*+( -+740 E'!40,/!')7"!-1#!+* 22 000 #7'. B70$7#& E'! '!, @'!4. 32174 ! 21C74 #5"!321'7#*2!4 & &3!")7'1:'7#*2!4 -&97? H!,#1+2! 91)-&2&+'+%!40 +8721:)&5 ! 9)7-27> L12'1+'&@7+%!> X74#7, %1%1(:'!091@21( 40'18&( 9!#$21 ".#1 /)&-7+'& % -!3:2&%2!-72&5 1"+')1%'2!,! (3.%1, 1)A&'7%'0). &+7#*+%!,! A!3(>+'-1, !921%! 1)A7!#!,&( /!%1:

3.-17', @'! E'& +/!+!"2!+'& /)&+0'+'-!-1#& ++14!,! 21@1#1. D'! 4!$7' /)!9!#$1'* -7)&'*E'&4 E-!#58&!22.4 +%13%14?

O!#*%! /!9041>'7 ! '!4, +%!#*%! -)791 ".#!2127+72! 4&L!4 ! 271297)'1#*81A. B1 /)!'($72&&

"!#77 +'!#7'&( 97'(4 - C%!#1A-"&-1#& - ,!#!-., @'! 271297)'1#*:8. ".#& +-!7,! )!91 9!&+'!)&@7+:%&4& +067+'-14&, '! 7+'*, 27 +!-:+74 #59*4& — /)!90%'!4 E-!#5:8&&, %!'!).A -.'7+2&#& '1%&7 /)7:-!+A!92.7 +!-)74722.7 #59&, %1%7-)!/7>8.. ?'! ".#1 /#!A1( 210%1,&47561( '1>2.> 314.+7# — -.:91'* E-!#58&!2205 )7#&,&5 31@&+'05 210%0. J '7/7)*, /!+#7 -+7>

E'!> /)!/1,129., !2& +/)1C&-15': «S+#& «21+» &«&A» )1397#(#! 27 /!-7972&7, '! @'! $7 '!,91?». N':-7' !@7-&972: A)" .!9,7$ ., +)'1,%3%$!

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— &2&%'! 2&@7,! 27 3147'&'… ;/)!@74, 2&%'! 2&@7:,! 27 3147'&' 91$7 7+#& -. 7,! & 27 /!")77'7.

H#7907' !'47'&'*, @'! E'! -!-+7 27 %&.1& 21/:)1-&#1 %0#*'0)0 /! E'!40 #!$2!40 /0'&. ?'! +97:#1#& 91)-&2&+'. — 2731%!22! -!)-1-C&7+( -%0#*'0)0 41'7)&1#&+'., &4756&7 /+&A!#!,&@7+:%05 /!')7"2!+'* (#!8!()2& %<H$, "(!1,2,%&*"2($ ( "($< "8,-4 +)'(!2!3 $2 -$%,>4% 1$ %<*1,; + /!4!6*5 "7++4.+#722.A, 270/)1-#(74.A &"7+/!#732.A 7+'7+'-722.A /)!87++!- E-!#58&&.; 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'& !2& )13)0C15' 210%0.

X 1 / ! 4 2 & ' 7E'!' L1%': 91)-&:2&+'. !C&"1#&+*21 +@7' 271297):'1#*87- "!#77 150#7' (!), 2)> 0, >)>$.! $U!H)%!"& !$2.$"!2,%&.$#+$!"8$01,.!30!'.!, %,2$#!"!$>)-,.,%$"2,; !7,.,2!9,">$7$>$1). D1%!7 %)0/:2!7 !'%).'&7 27+'1#! 9#( 2&A /!#:2!> 27!$&912:

2!+'*5? D!9 <BD, +#!$2!7 +')!72&7 %#7'%&, 31:%!2. T7297#(, D74")&>+%&> -3).-, $&-.7 &+%!:/174.7, /!-+747+'21( «%!2-7),72'21( E-!#5:8&(» — E'! #&C* 27%!'!).7 /)&47).. H97#1#& #&!2& A!'* !9&2 /)!,2!3, %!'!).> -/!+#79+'-&& 27".# !/)!-7),20'? B1/)&47), 4!#7%0#()21( L&:#!,72&(, #7,%!+'* «+14!+"!)%&» 4!#7%0# - %#7'%0,27!,)12&@7221( 21+#79+'-7221( &3472@&-!+'*,E-!#58&( #!C19&, $&32* 21 T1)+7, & 42!,!7 9)0:,!7… ;+7 E'! ".#! !/)!-7),20'!! V41&H) :($*%<Q!$.!"2) — #$"2$3..$ 41!(%32&"3 P)>*2)-, >$2$+/, ., (#!"/()<2"3 ( ,7$ "8,-4.

G7)7+'1274 213.-1'* 21C&A 9)7-2&A, 91-2!047)C&A /)79%!-, 271297)'1#*814&! N2& ".#&/)!+'! #59*4&! N+'12!-&4 E'0 )1+&+'+%05 )&'!:)&%0 «4.» /)!'&- «2&A» — !2& ".#& 21C&4&")1'*(4&! ?'!' !%!2@1'7#*2.> %)1A 4&L1 ! 2712:97)'1#*+%!4 @7#!-7%7 9!#$72 &2&8&&)!-1'*/)!87++ /)!'&- 7,! #$&-.A +!391'7#7>.

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

?'! )13)0C&#! -7)0 42!,&A #597>. ;+7 E'!".#1 #!$*, #!$*, #!$*! =59&, %!'!).7 #5"(' 21:0%0, 21-7)2(%1 9!#$2. +7>@1+ !@72* )1++7):9&'*+(. B1/)1-*'7 E'!' /)1-792.> ,27- -%!2+')0%'&-2!7 )0+#!! B1-79&'7 /!)(9!% - T&:2&+'7)+'-7 N")13!-12&(!

www.crev.info

V"/%>!:1. I&/412 G. K1397#(( «21+» & «&A»: /!-7972&7 271297):

'1#*87- & +!-)74722.A #597> // G)!'!%!#. 218&!21#*:2!> 1%1974&& 210%, HIJ, !/0"#&%!-12! 22 +72'(")( 2008,., doi:10.1073/pnas.0807931105.


3$"(7 1%8* $ "(*")(',*-/7*9?!"# "$%%$&'&( )*&%+'$*&( ,&,-%$ ( ./& %&(0)*0.

>.6.8:-'."'-?#(-:+ '-)$@;6.('$@, ;-('&

0".6)$@ ,6.;*&(,'.-';.6:-%+7-"$!A'$ 2#%$ ,6&8:&

%=;+"$!

B-''#., ,&%01.''#.( @&;. $88%.;&(-'$<C$26-%:-68*$@

,.D.6, ,&*-?#(-=:,1:& &'$ &2%-;-%$(8."$ 8%&4'#"$

@-6-*:.6$8:$*-"$,&(.;.'$<,

,6$80D$"$, *-*81$:-%&8+, :&%+*&8&(6.".''#" %=;<"

B1 /)!'($72&& "!#77 +'!#7'&( #$&-.7 &##5+')18&& ELL7%'&-2! &+/!#*3!-1#&+* 9#( /!9).-1 A)&+'&12+%!> -7). & 9#( 0"7$972&( #597>- &A /)!&+A!$972&& !' $&-!'2.A. H)1-2&'7 /!+#792&7 )7%!2+')0%8&& 271297)'1#*87- + &3!")1$72&(4&, %!'!).7 E-!#58&!2&+'. &+/!#*3!-1:#& - +-!7> /)!/1,1297 100 & 40 #7' 21319. D'! "097' !'-7@1'* 31 E'!' !"412?

B7 /!3-!#&4 &4 #,1'*, @'! &4722! '1% & )1"!'17' 210%1. N '!4, @'! 271297)'1#*8. ".#& /!#2!8722.4& #59*4&, [email protected]:%)718&!2&+'.31(-#(#& 767 - 19:4 -7%7. ?'! ".# "!#732722.>, 1"+!#5'2! 2720$2.> /0'* 9#&2!> - 150 #7'. ?-!#58&!2&+'14 "!#*C7 27#*3( 9!-7)('*. Q4.4&##&!2!- C%!#*2&%!- /!/1#& - E'0 #!-0C%0. ?'! )13)0C&#! -7)0 42!,&A #597>. ;+7 E'! ".#1 #!$*, #!$*, #!$*!

C#8&"%'' 4#1+%($4.1?0' %#&%8#4$&69?&.D:"#($%&' 066;($4&?0' %#&%8#4$&69?&, 3+8@+$+"6#%%&' ).8+5%01+* E4&%$0=#1+* F.31+7 "1909 @+8. %& +(%+"# «4&,+$-» G4&%?.:(1+@+ 3&6#+%$+6+@&H>"+6;?0+%0($& I&4(#60%& J.6'.

C#&%8#4$&69(107 4#,#%+1. K8%& 0: 3+(6#8%0)4#1+%($4.1?07 (2001 @+8), http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/neanderthals/prod_03.html

D66;($4&?0' 50:%0 %#&%8#4$&69?#", +3.,601+"&%%&' " 1960H) @+8&). D:+,4&5#%0#4&%%#@+ /#6+"#1& @+6-* %# 0*##$ 3+8 (+,+; +(%+"&%07 0 3+6%+($9; +(%+"&%+ %& "#4# ">"+6;?0; /#6+"#1& +$ +,#:9'%-. L+4+=+ 0:"#($%+, /$+ %#&%8#4$&69?- %+(060 +8#58..

-#! %4(#0)/#". =,"), 3%!%",0.5...

K13042.> X14.+7# | www.origins.org.ua4

$L&8&1#*2!7 31(-#72&7: J)A7!)1/'!) —/!997#%1 & 7,! '7/7)* 4!$2! 213-1'*G&#'9102+%!> /'&87>!

O!@2! '1% $7, %1% & 321472&'.> G&#'9102+%&>@7#!-7%, !"21)0$722.> 21 '7))&'!)&& J2,#&& &+!+'!(-C&> &3 &+%!/174.A !+'12%!- 9-0A )132.A+067+'-, )13)7%#14&)!-122!7 «!'+0'+'-056773-72!» 47$90 9&2!31-)14& & /'&814& — J)A7!:)1/'!) — '7/7)* !L&8&1#*2! +@&'17'+( «%!4"&21:8&7>, /! 472*C7> 47)7, 9-0A )132.A $&-!'2.A».

National Geographic — $0)21#, %!'!).> 21&"!:#77 1%'&-2! 312&41#+( )1+%)0'%!> & )7%#14&)!-1:2&74 E'!,! /!9!3)&'7#*2!,! «!'+0'+'-0567,! 3-7:21», '7/7)*, /!+#7 '!,!, %1% E'!' !")1378, «)13"&-1:56&> - /0A & /)1A %)718&!2&+'!-», H/% #+!'.).0)%>$; #$11,%>$; (!" E'!4 4. )1++%13.-1#& )1:

277 21 E'!4 -7":+1>'7), /!:-&9&4!40, +/1+17' +-!5)7/0'18&5. ?'!40 &+%!/174!40 $0)21# /!+-('&#"!#*C05 +'1'*5 — 21+'!#*%! ,)!4%05 & "731/7##(:8&!2205, @'! 91$7 27%!'!).7 E-!#58&!2&+'. !':27+#&+* % 27> "!#77 @74 +%7/'&@7+%&! \0)21#National Geographic 31C7# 21+'!#*%! 91#7%! - +-!74')&04L1#*2!4 -!+A&672&&, @'! /!47+'&# 21 +-!&A+')12&81A &##5+')18&5 /7)21'!,! 97'72.C1 M0H4&%%+:&"4& N#1(&!N%131-C&+* - '1%!4 ,#0/!4 /!#!:$72&&, B18&!21#*2!7 ,7!,)1L&@7+%!7 !"67+'-!(HIJ) !L&8&1#*2! !"21)!9!-1#! 9122.7 ,)0//[email protected], /!9'-7)9&-C&A, @'! '1% 213.-174.> J)A7!:)1/'!) — -!-+7 27 +-(305677 3-72!, 1 +!+'1-2!7&+%!/174!7. N921%! 31 /!+#792&> ,!9 &391'7#&$0)21#1 '1% & 27 &3-&2&#&+* 31 +-!& #!$2.7 )&+02:%& & 31(-#72&(, %!'!).7 ((,%! ( ')H%401,.!,

-!%%!$./ %<1,;. R!#77 '!,!, !2& )1347+'&#& 21+-!74 +1>'7 +#7905677 97)3%!7 «!/)1-912&7»:

«B731-&+&4! !' +97#122!,! 21 E'!> 2797#731%#5@72&(, "!#*C&2+'-! [email protected] %1%!7:'! -)7:4( ".#& 0-7)72., @'! /'&8. /)!&3!C#& !' 27:"!#*C&A 9&2!31-)!-, /&'156&A+( 4(+!4. FA '7:!)&( !+2!-.-17'+( 21 !,)!42!4 %!#&@7+'-7 &+:%!/174.A +-&97'7#*+'-, !"21)0$722.A - )13:#&@2.A 47+'1A /! -+740 4&)0».

; 31(-#72&& 2& +#!-1 27 +%1312! !" E-!#58&!:2&+'1A, 0%131-C&A 21 L1'1#*2.7 279!+'1'%& '7!)&&«!' 9&2!31-)1 % /'&87», % @&+#0 %!'!).A !'2!+&'+(,/! %)1>27> 47)7, !9&2 0@72.> &3 ,)0//., 2791-2!!/0"#&%!-1-C7> 9122.7 +-!&A &++#79!-12&>!

6$>2$+ R)+% =DKBA6www.creationontheweb.com

#0,!#*2!> C1A'7 L!)418&& H7))79$!2,)1+/!#!$722!> - D!#04"&&, ".# !"21)0:$72 3!#!'!> /)&&+% &+%!/174.A. ?'!'

!+!"722.> '1>2&% +!A)12&# +-&97'7#*+'-1 -)7:472& &+'!)&& X74#& 9! M#!"1#*2!,! G!'!/1, %!,:91 ')!/&@7+%&> %#&41' +&#*2! !'#&@1#+( !' +!-:)74722!,! — !2 ".# "!#77 '7/#.4 & -#1$2.4.B7+4!')( 21 '!, @'! %#&41' ".# 9)0,&4, - 274 +0:67+'-!-1#& '7 $7 )1+'72&(, @'! & +7,!92(.

«F+%!/174.7 )1+'72&( 915' 214 )71#*2!7/)79+'1-#72&7 ! +14.A 9)7-2&A ')!/&@7+%&A#7+1A ]72')1#*2!> & P$2!> J47)&%&», — ,!-!:)&'+( - +!!"672&& 9#( /7@1'& 02&-7)+&'7'1C'1'1 W#!)&91. ?-!#58&!2&+'. 91'&)05' E'&&+%!/174.7 58 4&##&!214& #7'.

H!,#1+2! $7 R&"#&&, E'& /!)!9. (%1% &0,!#*) ".#& %1'1+')!L&@7+%& !'#!$72. -! -)7:4( M#!"1#*2!,! G!'!/1. <#( /)7-)1672&( - !%1:4727#!+'& & @'!". &3"7$1'* )13#!$72&(, )1+'7:2&( 9!#$2. ".#& ".'* 31A!)!272. ".+')!. N":)1'&'7 -2&412&7 21 &A !'#&@205 +!A)122!+'*(K&+. 1 & 2). O1% @'! +14 L1%' /)&+0'+'-&( !%147:27#!+'7> )1+'72&> - /!)!91A 0%13.-17' 21 &A%1'1+')!L&@7+%!7 & ".+')!7 !")13!-12&7.

B1>9722.7 &+%!/174.7 /!9'-7)$915', @'!9)7-2&7 ')!/&@7+%&7 #7+1 «+!+'!(#& &3 '7A $7 +7:47>+'- )1+'72&>, %!'!).7 /)!&3)1+'15' - +!-)7:4722.A -#1$2.A 9$02,#(A, -%#5@1( "!"!-.7, /1#*:4!-.7, 1-!%19! & "1212» (K&+.1). B! @'! 767 "!#7709&-&'7#*2!, /)79/!#!$&'7#*2! 9)7-2&7 &+%!/17:4.7 #&+'*(, 27%!'!).7 &3 %!'!).A /)7%)1+2! +!A:)12&#&+*, 4!$2! ".#! !/)797#&'* «-/#!'* 9! )!:91»1. G!4&4! )1+'72&>, !%14727#.7 !+'12%& $&:-!'2.A '1%$7 /!%13.-15', @'! !2& /)1%'&@7+%& .,$2%!9)%!"& $2 "($!8 "$(+,-,../8 +$1"2(,..!*>$(. B1/)&47), - E'!> $7 L!)418&& &++#79!-1'7:#& !"21)0$&#& !%14727#.7 !+'12%& !,)!42!>347&, %!'!)05 !2& 213-1#& «O&'12!"!1». ; +!!"67:2&& 9#( /7@1'& 02&-7)+&'7'1 C'1'1 W#!)&91 !9&2&3 &++#79!-1'7#7> !'47'&#, @'! «/!9!"2! 3477 O&:'12!"!1, %!'!)1(, 27+!42722!, (-#(7'+( )!9+'-72:2&87> +!-)74722.A /&'!2!- & 121%!29, - 9)7-274#7+0 H7-7)2!> D!#04"&& /)!&3)1+'1#& +747>+'-1)1+'72&>, /!A!$&7 21 '7, @'! 4. +7:,!92( 21"#59174 - E'!> E%!#!,&:@7+%!> +&+'747»1.

B& !92! &3 /!9!"2.A 21"#5:972&> 27 +'1#! !'%)!-72&74 9#('7A, %'! -7)&' - !+!"722!7 +!'-!:)72&7 )1+'72&> & $&-!'2.A. J -!'- '!, @'! E'&4 &+%!/174.4 58 4#2#7', %!40:'! 4!$7' & ')092! /!-7:)&'*. S+#& 97>+'-&'7#*2! /)!C#!+'!#*%! 42!,! -)7472&, /!@740$7 + !/&+122.4& )1+'72&(4& &$&-!'2.4& 27 /)!&3!C#! 2&%1:%&A E-!#58&!22.A &347272&>?

;79* +!,#1+2! E-!#58&&, 21:3742!7 %!/.'2!7 $&-!'2!7 /)7-)1:'&#1+* - %&'1 47277 @74 31 /!#!-&:20 E'!,! /7)&!91 -)7472&. N@7-&92!, @'! &+%!/17:4.7 +-&97'7#*+'-1 /!9'-7)$15' R&"#7>+%!7 H!':-!)72&7. N9&2 &3 )1+/)!+')12722.A 1),0472'!-,&+/!#*3074.A E-!#58&!2&+'14& 9#( 316&'. +-!:7> '7!)&& - +-7'7 !'+0'+'-&( &+'&22.A 9!%131:

'7#*+'-, 31%#5@17'+( - '!4, @'! !/)797#722.7 -&:9. )1+'72&> & $&-!'2.A 27 E-!#58&!2&)!-1#&-+#79+'-&7 27&34722!+'& -/#!'* 9! +7,!92(C27,!92( 0+#!-&>, - %!'!).A !2& +067+'-!-1#&. J, /!4272&5 E-!#58&!2&+'!-, "73 &347272&> - !%)0$1:567> +)797 27 4!$7' ".'* & 91-#72&( +! +'!)!2.

7+'7+'-722!,! !'"!)1, %!'!).>9-&$7' /)!87++!4 E-!#58&&.

B! - L!)418&& H7))79$!2«"!"!-.7, /1#*4!-.7, 1-!%19! &"1212 — -+7 !2& +!A)12&#& +-!7E%!#!,&@7+%!7 /)7!"#1912&7,27+4!')( 21 +067+'-722.7 &347:272&( - %#&41'7 & ,7!#!,&@7+%!>+')0%'0)7 P$2!> J47)&%&»1.

O1% @'! - 9122!4 +#0@17 ".#!9!+'1'!@2! -)7472& 9#( '!,!, @'!".+!+'!(#1+* E-!#58&(, 1 '1%$7 /)!&:3!C#! 9!+'1'!@2! «%)0/2.A &347:272&>» - E'!> !"#1+'&, %!'!).7 4!,:#& ". +/)!-!8&)!-1'* 91-#72&7 +!+'!)!2. 7+'7+'-722!,! !'"!)1. ?'!9!#$2! ".#! ". +'1'* &971#*2.4

%!2')!#*2.4 /)&47)!4 9#( %)0/2!41+C'1"2!>E-!#58&&. B! +067+'-!-12&7 121#!,&@2!> L#!). &L102. '!,91 & +7,!92( /!%13.-17', @'! .!>)>$;:($%<Q!! ., #+$!"8$1!%$ ($$H5,. D)!47 '!,!,E'& 09&-&'7#*2.7 +A!9+'-1 +!,#1+05'+( + "!#77 4!:

#!9.4 -!3)1+'!4 &+%!/174.A. B1"#59174.7 L1%:'. #0@C7 !"Y(+2(5'+( '1%: )1+'72&( & $&-!'2.7".#& +!'-!)72. !'2!+&'7#*2! 2791-2! %1% !'97#*:2.7 +!'-!)722.7 -&9., 1 /!3$7 ".#& /!,)7"72. -!-)74( M#!"1#*2!,! G!'!/1 -! 92& B!(.

V"/%>!:1. D121/! R. F+%!/174.7 )1+'72&( 915' 214 /7)-!7 )71#*:

2!7 /)79+'1-#72&7 ! +14.A 9)7-2&A ')!/&@7+%&A #7+1A]72')1#*2!> & P$2!> J47)&%&. H!!"672&7 9#( /7@1'&02&-7)+&'7'1 C'1'1 W#!)&91 !' 15 !%'(")( 2009 ,.

T=KGRBMGKNAYG JD=YG DVR?LBGCYG

E0D.8:(&(-'$.-'-%&/$1'&3 5%&6#$ 5-0'# :&/;- $

8./&;'< ,&*-?#(-.:,1:& '$*-*&3F(&%=7$$ '.

,6&$8@&;$%& (&&2D..A1.($;'&, 1:&$8*&,-."#.

8($;.:.%+8:(-,&;:(.64-=:G$2%.38*&.E&:(&6.'$.

!"#.2 A+4+8& (+8#450$ +1&*#%#6+($9 4&($#%0' Lauraceae, +$%+('B#@+(' 1 (#*#7($". O&"4+"-#. P4&"%#%0#( 50".B0* (#@+8%' "08+* 3+1&:-"&#$, /$+, 1&1 0 " (6./&# ( $-('/&*0 84.@0) 50"+$%-) 0 4&($#%07, %01&1+7>"+6;?00 %# 34+0()+806+ :& 34#83+6+@&#*-# 58 *0660+%+" 6#$ ("4#*', :& 1+$+4+#, (+@6&(%+ >"+6;?00, %&H:#*%+# 1+3-$%+# 50"+$%+#, "#4%."=0(9 " *+4#, 34#"4&$06+(9 " 10$+" 0 8#69G0%+"!) K/#"08%+, /$+ >"+6;H?0' — >$+ (1&:1& 86' ":4+(6-), %# 0*#;B&' ( 4#&69%+($9; %0/#@+ +,B#@+. K1&*#%#6+($0 $4+30/#(10) 4&(H$#%07 ,-60 +,%&4.5#%- " .@+69%+7 =&)$# G+4*&?00 P#44#85+%, 4&(3+6+5#%%+7 " F+6.*,00.

P+$4.8%01 .%0"#4(0$#$& E6+408- %& 4&(1+31&) "F+6.*,00.

E+$+@4

&G0

' 0 34

&"& %& %## 34#8

+($&"6#%- <%0

"#4(0

$#$+*E

6+40

8-

(http://new

s.ufl.edu/2009/10/15/neotrop

ical) 0 I

.H:##*

Q($#($"+:%&%0

' E6+4

08

- (http

://ww

w.flm

nh.ufl.edu)

"%3*3$; <#$-+7%% ,'$&%4(!3%9 '*!,("%; =* «58 1%--%$"$# -(,»

H&(#3 :-3'$* $8*&,-."#@ I &*'& ( ;&,&:&,'#3 "$6 J;-"- $ H&<

?AD LEGL?6BZM K?JN AB[DC 6GMOC

NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC 3*&%,6-%'6(,… $,4*!,%!

!"#. 1. D(1+3&#*-# 4&($#%0' 8&;$ %&* 4#&69%+# 34#8($&"6#%0# + 84#"%0) $4+30/#(10) 6#(&): +%0 (+($+'60 0: $#) 5# (#*#7($" 4&($#%07, 1+$+4-# 34+0:4&($&;$ " (+"4#H*#%%-) "6&5%-) 85.%@6'), "16;/&' ,+,+"-#, 3&69*+"-#, &"+1&8+ 0 ,&%&% — %01&1+7 >"+6;?00, %# (*+$4' %& 34#83+6&@&#*-# *0660+%- 3+1+6#%07. R"+6;?0+%0($- )+$'$ :&($&"0$9 %&( 3+"#40$9 " $+, /$+ 3+1& 3&69*- +($&"&60(9 8+ (#@+ 8%' 3&69*&*0, ,&%&%- H ,&%&%&*0, &"+1&8+ H &"&1&8+ 0 $.8. H +%0, 1&1 0 $-('/0 84.@0)4&($#%07 0 50"+$%-), %# 0:*#%060(9!H :& >$+ "4#*' " *04# *&6#%910# *6#1+30$&;B0# 34#"4&$060(9 " 69"+", 504&G+", (6+%+" 0 1#%@.4., %&:#*%-# 1+3-$%-# 4&:*#4+* ((+,&1. "#4%.60(9 " *+4#, 0:,&"060(9 +$ :&8%0) %+@ 0 34#"4&$060(9 " 10$+" 0 8#69G0%+", %&(#1+*+'8%-# ":6#$#60 " "+:8.) 0 «0:+,4#60» >)+6+1&?0; (6#$./0# *-=0), &+,#:9'%- 34#"4&$060(9 " 6;8#7, %&./0"=0(9 3+ )+8. @+"+40$9, ($4+0$9, 40(+"&$9 0 3#$9. K/#"08%+, /$+ >"+6;?0' +$ &*#,- 1 /#6+"#1. (.B#($".#$ $+691+ " @+6+"# . "#4.B0)" %## 0 %# 0*##$ %0/#@+ +,B#@+ ( 4#&69%-* J+590* *04+*, @8# (+$"+4#%%-# 4&($#%0' 0 50"+$%-# "+(34+0:"+8'$(' «3+ 4+8. ("+#*.», 1&1 0 (1&:&6 S+(3+89 " P"+#* P6+"#.K1&*#%#6+($0 P#44#85+% 08#%$0G0?04+"&%- 8+ (#*#7($"& 0 0%+@8& 8+ 4+8&. (A) L"+7%-#; (B) P$#%+)6#%& (CJ81); (C 0 D) %#.($&%+"6#%%-# ?"#$10; (E) 36+8 J+,+"-); (F)14-6&$1& J+,+"-); (G) T4#1+"-#, "+:*+5%+ 4+8 C03&; (h) D*,04#?"#$%-#; (I–K) 60($9' 0 60($+/10 J+,+"-); (h) O0($+1 I&69"+?"#$%-) ( 34+8#6&%%-*0 %&(#1+*-*08-4+/1&*0; (M) O&"4+"-# (CJ22); (n) 14.3%-7 36&% M, %& 1+$+4+* 3+1&:&%- 36&($0%+/%-# (*+6'%-# 5#6#:- (1 **); (o) I&69"+"-# (CJ26); (P) I+6+/&7%-# (CJ24); (Q) O0($+1P&3+$+"-) (+ (U#8#%%-* 14&#* 0 34+8#6&%%-*0 %&(#1+*-*0 8-4+/1&*0.

E+$+@4

&G0

' 0 34

&"& %& %## 34#8

+($&"6#%- <%0

"#4(0

$#$+* E

6+40

8-

(http://new

s.ufl.edu/2009/10/15/neotrop

ical) 0 I

.:##* Q

($#($"+:%&%0' E

6+40

8-

(http://w

ww

.flmnh.ufl.ed

u)

J

B C D E F

G H I J K

L

M

N O

P Q


1. S($%<Q!3? 6B ! AGM; 4&)7 $&-!> /)&)!9. 4. 4!$74 21"#5:

91'*, %1% /)!&+A!9(' -&9!&347272&(, 40'18&& &7+'7+'-722.> !'"!). ?-!#58&!2&+'. 213.-15'E'! «E-!#58&7>», @7,!, /! &A 4272&5, 9!+'1'!@:2! 9#( 31(-#72&> ! 9!%13122!+'& E-!#58&&.

T. 21"#59174, %1% !%)0$1561( +)791 -#&:(7' 21 -.$&-12&7 )13#&@2.A $&-!'2.A. R!#77'!,!, - )730#*'1'7 E'&A /)!87++!- /!(-#(5'+(2!-.7 -&9.. ;+7 E'& (-#72&( — 21"#59174.7 &210@2! 31L&%+&)!-122.7. F %)718&!2&+'. +!,:#1+2. + 2&4&. B1 +14!4 97#7 E'& &347272&(/)!&+A!9(' !@72* ".+')!. ;&9!!")13!-12&7 4!:

$7' /)!&3!>'& - '7@72&7 -+7,! 27+%!#*%&A /!%!:#72&>1. ?1.)>$, 27+4!')( 21 E'!, +!"1%& !+'1:5'+( +!"1%14&, $1". — $1"14&, 1 #!C19& — #!:C19*4&. K.". 27 /)7-)1615'+( - $1", 1 (67)&:8. 27 +'12!-('+( /'&814&.

;+7, @'! 4. 21"#59174 +7,!92(, /!#2!+'*5+!,#1+07'+( + "&"#7>+%&4 !/&+12&74 2791-27,!+!'-!)72&(. ; +14!4 21@1#7 R!, +!391# )132.7-&9. $&-!'2.A, !"#19156&A +/!+!"2!+'*5 191/:'&)!-1'*+( % )13#&@2.4 0+#!-&(4 !%)0$1567>+)79.. D)718&!2&+'. /)79/!@&'15' 213.-1'* E'&-&9!&347272&( -20')& -&91 27 «E-!#58&7>» (&91$7 27 «4&%)!E-!#58&7>»2), 1 «191/'18&7>».

; 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'&, 27 &477' 321@72&(, %1:%!7 +#!-! 4. 0/!')7"#(74, -1$2! 321'*, @'! 4./!9 2&4 /!9)13047-174. D)718&!2&+'. &+/!#*:305' +#!-! «E-!#58&(» 9#( @7,!:'! +!-7)C722!!'#&@1567,!+( !' '!,!, @'! 4. -&9&4 397+*.

2. S($%<Q!3? AGMT. 21+#.C12. ! '!4, @'! !92!%#7'[email protected] $&:

-!'2.7 21 /)!'($72&& 4&##&!2!- #7' &3472(#&+*/!9 -!397>+'-&74 40'18&> & 7+'7+'-722!,! !'"!:)1, /)7-)1'&-C&+* - )7/'&#&>,/'&8 & 4#7%!/&'156&A $&-!'2.A.

F4722! E'! %)718&!2&+'. 21:3.-15' «E-!#58&7>» & !'#&@15'E'! /!2('&7 !' /!2('&( «191/'1:8&&». ?-!#58&!2&+'. '1%$7 213.:-15' E'! «E-!#58&7>», 2! E'! $7+#!-! !2& &+/!#*305' & 9#( /!2(:'&( «191/'18&(». F4722! /!E'!40E'!' -!/)!+ '1% 31/0'12.

S($%<Q!$.!"2/ #+!-,.3<2$1.$ ! 2$ 0, "%$($ 1%3 "$(,+*U,..$ +)'./8 #$.32!; (E'! '1%213.-1741( E%-&-!%18&( — &+/!#*3!-12&79-0+4.+#722.A 0'-7)$972&>), /!E'!40 -. 274!$7'7 '!@2! 321'*, ! @74 !2& ,!-!)('.

S+#& 9#( !")13!-12&( 2!-!> ,727'&@7+%!>

&2L!)418&&, 27!"A!9&4!> 9#( -+7A E'&A 09&-&:'7#*2.A &347272&> 0 $&-!'2.A, 20$2. 27"!#*:C&7 +#0@1>2.7 40'18&&, '! 9#( 4&##&!2!- '1%&A,727'&@7+%&A !C&"!% 9!#$2. ".#& /)!>'& 4&#:#&!2. /!%!#72&>. F4722! /!E'!40 9#( !/)1-91:2&( +-!7> &97& E-!#58&!2&+'14 20$2. 4&##&:

1)9. #7'.?1.)>$ 2)>!, !'-,.,.!3

.!>$71) ., .)H%<1)%!"& (#+!+$1,. F3472@&-!+'* & 7+'7:+'-722.> !'"!) 27 /)!&3-!9('2!-!> ,727'&@7+%!> &2L!)41:8&&, 1 #&C* /)7!" )1305' &#&091#(5' 0$7 +067+'-05605 &2:L!)418&5. T0'18&& '1%$7 27 !":)1305' 2!-!> ,727'&@7+%!> &2:L!)418&&, 1 02&@'!$15' @1+'*0$7 +067+'-0567> &2L!)418&&.

R!#77 '!,!, &+%!/174.7 27/!9'-7)$915' E-!#58&!2205 &975, /!+%!#*%0"7+@&+#722.7 /7)7A!92.7 L!)4., %!'!).79!#$2. ".#& ". +067+'-!-1'*, /)!+'! !'+0'+'-0:5'. D!287/8&( E-!#58&& !' 4!#7%0#. 9! @7#!-7:

%1 — E'! -+7,! #&C* ,&/!'7'&@7+%1( L&#!+!L&(,27 /!9'-7)$97221( 2& !92&4 [email protected] 21"#597:2&74. ?'1 E-!#58&!221( '7!)&( &+/!#*307'+(9#( !/)1-912&( 0'-7)$972&(, +!,#1+2! %!'!)!404&) $&-!> /)&)!9. 4!$2! !"Y(+2&'* "73 R!,1.F, %!27@2! $7, E'1 %!287/8&( /)!'&-!)7@&' "&":#7>+%!40 0@72&5. N21 4!$7' -.,#(97'* 210@2!>,2!, %1% 4. -&9&4, !21 '1%!-!> 27 (-#(7'+(.

Q/!')7"#72&7 '1%!,! 9-0+4.+#722!,! (3.%1 —E'! +-!7,! )!91 E-!#58&!22.> ')5%. ?-!#58&!:2&+'. &+/!#*305' 191/'18&5, %!'!)05 4!$2! 21":#591'* - 4&)7 /)&)!9., 9#( /!9'-7)$972&( E-!#5:8&&, @'! - 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'& (-#(7'+( +!-7)C722!9)0,&4 /)!87++!4. ;+7 E'! +)!92& /)&740 «3141:2&'* & /!9472&'*», @1+'! &+/!#*3074!40 4!C722&:%14&. N921%! E-!#58&!2&+'14 -+7 +A!9&' + )0%,/!+%!#*%0 #59& 27 /!2&415', @'! 9#( +!-7)C722!)132.A /!2('&> !2& &+/!#*305' !92! & '! $7 +#!-!.

I,+,7!2,"&!; +#79056&> )13, %!,91 -14 %'!)'! +%1$7', @'!

E-!#58&( — E'! 21"#59174.> - /)&)!97 210@2.>L1%', /!/)!+&'7 -1C7,! +!"7+792&%1 0'!@2&'*,@'! !2 /!9)13047-17' /!9 E'&4 /!2('&74. H%!)77-+7,!, !2 21@27' ,!-!)&'* -14 !" 191/'18&&, 2!31A!@7', @'!". -. /!-7)&#& - 9!%13122!+'* E-!:#58&&. B7 /!/19&'7+* - #!-0C%0! <-0+4.+#722.>(3.% -797' % 9-0+4.+#722!40 4.C#72&5.

Q-7)72, @'! -14 27 A!'7#!+* ". 97#1'* 27/:)1-&#*2.7 -.-!9. !'2!+&'7#*2! 2197$2!+'&R&"#&& - -!/)!+7 /)!&+A!$972&(, /!'!40 @'!@0-+'-07'7 +7"( /!>4122.4& 21 /)&74 «3141:2&'* & /!9472&'*».


V"/%>!:1. D7'@/0# <., ;&#129 D. R.+')!7 !")13!-12&7 -&9!- 09&-)

#(7' // Creation. — 2001; 23 (2):13)15,<www.creation.com/speedy>. ;7)20'*+( % '7%+'0.

2. G!2('&7 «4&%)!E-!#58&(» --!9&' - 31"#0$972&7, '1% %1%&347272&( /)!&+A!9(' - 27-7)2!4 21/)1-#72&&.


=!!#!,&( — 09&-&'7#*2.> /)7947'. V &30:@1# 77 - 02&-7)+&'7'7, "090@& 0$7 -3)!+:#.4 +'0972'!4. D1$905 2797#5 4. /!+7:

61#& 9-7 #7%8&& & #1"!)1'!)&5, ,97 &30@1#&)132.7 -&9. $&-!'2.A.

N921$9. '74!> 21C7> #7%8&& ".#& 42!,!%:#7'[email protected] $&-!'2.7, '1%&7 %1% %!)1##., 47903.& @7)-&. G)7/!91-1'7#* !"Y(+2&#1 /7)7/!#272:2!> 109&'!)&&, %1% -/7)-.7 42!,!%#7'[email protected]$&-!'2.7 E-!#58&!2&)!-1#& &3 '1%&A !92!%#7:'[email protected] +067+'-, %1% 147"1.

N92!%#7'!@2!7 $&-!'2!7 — E'!27 /)!+'! +%!/#72&7 /)!'!/#134..?'! !@72* +#!$2.> !),12&34, +/!:+!"2.> -./!#2('* )132.7 L02%8&&+ 87#*5 -.$&-12&( & )1342!$72&(— & -+7 E'! !2 97#17', (-#((+* !9:2!> 2731-&+&4!> $&-!> %#7'%!>1.

T2!,!%#7'!@2!7 $&-!'2!7,&+A!9( &3 7,! 213-12&(, +!+'!&'&3 )132!,! '&/1 %#7'!%, %!'!).7-./!#2(5' )13#&@2.7 L02%8&&.

; !'#&@&7 !' !92!%#7'[email protected]$&-!'2.A, !'97#*2.7 %#7'%& -42!,!%#7'!@2!4 !),12&347 27 4!:,0' -.$&-1'* +14!+'!('7#*2!.G"%! $1.) >%,2>)$21,%3,2"3 $2 $+7).!'-), $.) #$7!H),2.

<#( '!,! @'!". !),12&34 -.$&-1#, 9!#$2./)&+0'+'-!-1'* -+7 '&/. %#7'!%. N2& 9!#$2. 21A!:9&'*+( 21 +-!&A 47+'1A & )1"!'1'* +!,#1+!-122!.

S+#& %1%&7:'! %#7'%& /7)7+'15' L02%8&!2&)!-1'*(21/)&47), %#7'%& %)!-&), !),12&34 /!,&"17'.

; +-(3& + E'&4 -!32&%17' -1$2.> -!/)!+: 7+:#& -+7 $&-.7 !),12&34. E-!#58&!2&)!-1#& - )7:30#*'1'7 -!397>+'-&( /)&)!92.A /)!87++!- + /!:4!6*5 27"!#*C&A +#0@1>2.A C1,!-, $2>41) ('3*%$"& #,+($, P4.>Q!$.!+4<5,, -.$7$>%,2$9*.$, 0!($2.$,? G!42&'7, @'! +!,#1+2! E-!#5:8&&, 9! '!,!, %1% /!(-&#&+* 42!,!%#7'[email protected] $&:-!'2.7, 21 X74#7 +067+'-!-1#& '!#*%! !92!%#7:'[email protected] !),12&34..

; 109&'!)&& ".#! !%!#! 300+'0972'!-, & -+7 !2& ".#& 312('.%!2+/7%'&)!-12&74 &2L!)418&&,%1% "09'! !' E'!,! 31-&+7#& &A$&32&.

F'1%, 9#( '!,! @'!". &3 !92!%:#7'!@2!,! !),12&341 !")13!-1#:+( 42!,!%#7'!@2.> !),12&34, !':97#*2.7 %#7'%& 9!#$2. +!")1'*+(-47+'7. B! E'!,! 279!+'1'!@2! —$.! 1$%0./ H/%! "2)2& 1!PP,*+,.Q!+$()../-!, '.7. /)&!")7+:'& +/!+!"2!+'* /7)7+')1&-1'*+(+ -./!#272&( !92!> L02%8&&, %1%

21/)&47), /7)7-1)&-12&7 /&6&, 21 -./!#272&79)0,&A L02%8&>. ?'! !321@17', @'! !2& 9!#$2.".#& /7)7+'1'* -.$&-1'* +14& /! +7"7 & .)9)2&')(!",2& !' 9)0,&A %#7'!%, L02%8&!2&)!-12&7%!'!).A !2& !"7+/7@&#&.

S+#& ". E'& &347272&( ".#& % #0@C740, 9)0:,&7 %#7'%& /7)7+')!&#&+* ". 9#( -./!#272&(9!/!#2&'7#*2.A L02%8&>, & E'& &347272&( /)!:&3!C#& ". +8%+"4#*#%%+. F -+7 E'& %#7'%& +!7:9&2&#&+* ". -47+'7 - !920 79&205 +')0%'0)0,@'!". !),12&34 4!, -.$&-1'*, 91$7 27+4!')(21 '!, @'! 7,! !'97#*2.7 %#7'%& 27 +4!,#& ". -.:$&-1'* /! !'97#*2!+'&.

D!,91 90417C* ! '7A E'1/1A,%!'!).7 !),12&34. 9!#$2. ".#&/)!>'&, & 27!"A!9&4!4 9#( E'!,!-)7472&, 21@&217C* -!+A&61'*:+( & 09&-#('*+(. D1% -+7 E'! 4!,:#! /)!&3!>'& +#0@1>2!? B&%'! 27+/!+!"72 !"Y(+2&'*. A,2 .! $1.$7$ #$18$13*5,7$ #$1+$H.$7$ $#!").!3 2$7$, >)> -$7%$$H+)'$()2&"3 #,+($, -.$7$>%,2$9.$, 0!*($2.$,. B! %1% '!#*%! 4. 21@&2174 +#7/! -7:)&'* - '!, @'! E-!#58&( &+'&221, /)7-)1672&7!92!%#7'!@2!,! !),12&341 - 42!,!%#7'!@2.>+'12!-&'+( «)71#*2!+'*5».

V !"21)0$&#, @'! )1++41')&-1( )132.7 1+:/7%'. E-!#58&&, /)7/!91-1'7#& & 0@7"2&%& 9!:-!#*2! /!9)!"2! !/&+.-15' -+7 E'& /)!"#74..<0415, @'! 21 +'0972'!- E'! !%131#! !"73!)0:$&-15677 -#&(2&7. Q 2&A +#!$&#!+* -/7@1'#7:2&7, @'! [email protected] )13)7C&#& E'0 /)!"#740, '1% %1%!2& 97'1#*2! 77 !/&+1#&.

G!E'!40 +'0972'. 91$7 & /)79+'1-&'* +7"727 4!,0', @'! - E-!#58&& 4!$2! +!427-1'*+(. B!L1%'&@7+%&, 2& /)7/!91-1'7#&, 2& 0@7"2&%& 27915' 09!-#7'-!)&'7#*2.A !'-7'!- 21 -+7 E'&/)!"#742.7 -!/)!+..

F4722! E'! & /)!&3!C#! - '! 0')!. G!+#7 '!:,! %1% /)7/!91-1'7#* )1++%131#1 214 !"! -+7AE'1/1A )13-&'&( & 0/!4(20#1 ! 27%!'!).A /)!":#741A, !21 /!%131#1 214 +#1>9, 21 %!'!)!4 ".#!/)79+'1-#72! -7)!('2!7 &3!")1$72&7 /7)-!,!42!,!%#7'!@2!,! $&-!'2!,!. N2! ".#!: 1) 41:#72*%&4, 2) 4!)+%&4, 3) C1)!!")132.4 & /!:#.4. H'0972'. '!)!/#&-! 31/&+.-1#& - %!2+:/7%'. 0+#.C12205 &2L!)418&5. T2!,!%#7'!@:2!7 $&-!'2!7 &47#! 4) !9&2 $,0'&%2, 27 &47#! 5)2& )'1, 6) 2& %&C7@2&%1. <1, 91, 91!

F4722! - E'!' 4!472' ( /!92(# )0%0 & +%131#:«G)!+'&'7…». H'0972'., %1% /)1-&#!, 27 31915'-!/)!+!- 21 '1%&A "!#*C&A & -1$2.A +!")12&(A.

«<1», — !'-7'&#1 /)7/!91-1'7#*, /!+4!')7-21 472(. «G)!+'&'7, 2! 427 /)!+'! &2'7)7+2!, %1:%&7 +067+'-05' 9!%131'7#*+'-1 '!,!, @'! E'! $&:-!'2!7, %!'!)!7 -. !/&+.-17'7, -.,#(97#! &4722!'1%? R.#& #& !"21)0$72. %1%&7:#&"! !")138. -!%7127 &#& &+%!/174.7 !+'12%& E'&A $&-!'2.A?».N21 319041#1+* & 0")1#1 &3!")1$72&7 + E%)121.

«B0, 27', — +%131#1 !21. — B7 ".#! !"21)0:$72! 2&%1%&A &+%!/174.A. ?'! ,&/!'7'&@7+%&>/)&47). B1-7)2!7, $&-!'2!7, %!'!)!7 +067+':-!-1#!, -.,#(97#! &4722! '1%».

X1'74 /)7/!91-1'7#* -.-7#1 21 E%)12 &3!":)1$72&7 +#790567,! +#1>91, /!+4!')7#1 21 27:,! & +%131#1: «B0, E'! '!$7 ,&/!'7'&@7+%!7 &3!":)1$72&7».

B1 E%)127 ".#1 &3!")1$721 %#1++&@7+%1(+A741 '1% 213.-174!,! E-!#58&!22!,! 97)7-1,%!'!)!7 21@&217'+( + !92!> %#7'%& & )13)1+'1:

7'+( - )13#&@2.7 -&9. $&-.A !):,12&34!-, %!'!).7 4. -&9&4 +7:,!92(.

D!,91 /)7/!91-1'7#* 0"&)1#1+ E%)121 E'! &3!")1$72&7, !21+%131#1: «;&9&'7 #&, '!' L1%', @'!E'& &3!")1$72&( ,&/!'7'&@7+%&7,

-!-+7 27 !321@17', @'! E-!#58&( 27 &+'&221. T.-&9&4 E-!#58&5 - /)!87++7 -7397 & /!+'!(22!.?-!#58&( — E'! /)!+'! /)!87++ /)!&+A!$97:2&(, %!'!).> +!/)!-!$917'+( &347272&(4&…».

X1(-&- E'!, !21 0,#0"&#1+* -! 42!,&7 9)0,&7-!/)!+.. N21 +47C1#1 +-!& /!2('&( E-!#58&& +9)0,&4& -!/)!+14& — E'!' /)&74 213.-17'+(«31412&'* & /!9472&'*».3R!#*C&2+'-! +'0972'!-2&@7,! 27 3147'&#&, 1 ( 0$7 !9&2 )13 21)0C&# 77/#12., /!E'!40 !21 /)!9!#$1#1 ,!-!)&'*.

V @1+'! +/)1C&-15 +7"(, @'! ". +#0@&#!+*,7+#& ". ( 27 3191# E'!' -!/)!+. H'0972'. '1%$731/&+.-1#& ". '!, @'! +#.C1', 2! !2& '1% & 27 03:21#& ". ! '!4, @'! E'!,! $&-!'2!,! 27 +067+'-!:-1#!, @'! E'! ".#1 -+7,! #&C* ,&/!'7'&@7+%1(4!97#*, /!+')!7221( "73! -+(%&A 9!%131'7#*+'-.

«F"! 27-&9&4!7 S,!, -7@21( +&#1 S,! & R!:$7+'-!, !' +!3912&( 4&)1 @)73 )1++41')&-12&7'-!)72&> -&9&4., '1% @'! !2& "73!'-7'2.» (K&4:#(214 1:20).


L+!-,9).!3:1. H14 /)!87++ )1342!$72&( — E'! 0$7 @09!. 2. O.7. !9&2 $,0'&%, /#7'7-&92.> /!-!)!'2.> 9-&,1'7#*,

"#1,!91)( %!'!)!40 !),12&34 /7)747617'+(. H4.: <7-!0H. Q9&-&'7#*21( "1%'7)&( + 4!'!)@&%!4 // Creation. —2004; 27 (1):24:25, <creation.com/flagellum>; H1)L1'& <.<&31>2 $&-.A !),12&34!- (4!'!)@&%&),<creation.com/motor>.

3. ;!%7) T. B7 /!/191>'7+* 21 09!@%0 '7A, %'! 31412&-17' &!"412.-17' // Creation. — 2007; 29 (4):38:39.

K-:.",6.,&;-(-:.%+(#(.%- '- F*6-'$?&26-4.'$.

8%.;0=D./& 8%-3;-,,&8"&:6.%- '- './&$ 8*-?-%-: «H0, F:&

:-*4./$,&:.:$1.8*&.$?&26-4.'$.»

L 1-8:& 8,6-)$(-=8.2<, 1:& 2#

8%01$%&8+, .8%$ 2# <'. ?-;-% F:&: (&,6&8

N0(.: M0*

C9;

1+*,

A;'-*&F(&%=7$&'$8:-" (8.

8@&;$: 8 60*,,&8*&%+*0 %=;$ '.,&'$"-=:, 1:& ;%<8&(.6).''& 6-?'#@

,&'<:$3 &'$$8,&%+?0=: &;'& $

:& 4. 8%&(&

"*!,$2>%( ,'+3% ! ?%&$,(,%4(!3%1% .%#$,"51%

"( &$&*)%,(!/ # -$#6036!B(08"#8%.''#3 <?#* (.;.: * ;(08"#8%.''&"0 "#)%.'$=


3!,91 ( +'!(# - !@7)79& &3 +!'2& #597>,@'!". /!/1+'* -20')* &3-7+'2!,! =!2:9!2+%!,! 4037( 7+'7+'-722!> &+'!)&& +

87#*5 /!+7'&'* 2!-05 91)-&2!-+%05 -.+'1-%0(- E'!4 ,!90 J2,#&( /)139207' 200:#7'&7 +! 92()!$972&( Z1)#*31 <1)-&21), ( +/)1C&-1# +7"(,"097' #& E'! 27%!> /!/.'%!> 0/)1-#('* 4!&4+!3212&74? L$"%, 2$7$, >)> 3 #+$U,% #$ (",;(/"2)(>,, 3 .!942& ., "$-.,()%"3 ( :2$-!

?'1 -.+'1-%1 21/!#2&#1 427 !9&2 &3 '7A+')122.A 210@2!:L12'1+'&@7+%&A L&#*4!-, - %!:'!)!4 #59& -.+')1&-1#&+* - !@7)79*, @'!". /!:/1+'* - +/78&1#*205 41C&20, ,97 &3 2&A 97#1#&)!"!'!-; :2! %<1! ., -$742 40, 14-)2& ")-! ')",H3 & !2&, - %!287 %!28!-, +'12!-('+( /!A!$&4&21 '7A #597>, %!'!).7 /)!4.-15' &4 4!3,&.

; !/)797#722!4 +4.+#7 ( !"21)0$&#, @'!E'1 91)-&2!-+%1( -.+'1-%1 /)79+'1-#(7' +!"!>!@72* 042.> +/!+!" %!2')!#( +!3212&( @7#!-7:%1, %!'!)1(, /! +0'&, +!+'!&' &3: 1. G)79+'1-#72&( #!$2.A 1),0472'!-, %!'!).7

#$%.$"2&< !">)0)<2 '!, -! @'! -7)(' 9!-7:)(56&7 R&"#&& A)&+'&127.

2. Q%13.-12&( 21 '!, %1% 27/)1-. A)&+'&127,-7)( - '!, -! @'! !2& /)79/!#!$&'7#*2! -7:)(' (2! -! @'! !2& &321@1#*2! 27 -7)('!).

3. Q"7$972&( /!+7'&'7#7> - '!4, @'! <1)-&2!:-+%1( E-!#58&( &+'&221 & @'! 7+#& %'!:'!-7)&' - /)!'&-!/!#!$2!7, '! !2 ,#0/78 (&,27+!42722!, ,#0/! 9!-7)('* R&"#&&).

W1%'&@7+%& '1%!> -&9 %!2')!#( +!3212&( 0$7C&)!%! &+/!#*307'+( - 4&)7 - !"67!")13!-1'7#*:2!> +&+'747, HTF & [email protected] 4037(A (% +!$1#72&591$7 -! 42!,&A U)&+'&12+%&A C%!#1A & %!##79$1A).

F+/!#*30( /)&47) + E'!> -.+'1-%!> - =!29!2+%!440377, 91-1>'7 )1++4!')&4, %1% !),12&31'!).-.+'1-%& &+/!#*305' 47'!9 %!2')!#( +!3212&(: 1. B1 +'7297 -.+'1-%& /!+7'&'7#& @&'15' +#790:5677: «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».

B7-7)2!! ?'! #!$2!7 /)79+'1-#72&7 L1%'!-.=59&, %!'!).7 3215' R&"#&5 & 9!-7)(5' 7>, -7:)(', @'! 4&) - 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'& &3472&#+( &3:31+!".'&>, !/&+122.A - %2&,7 R.'&7 (-'!)$72&7,)7A1 - 4&), B!7- G!'!/ & +!".'&7 0 ;1-&#!2+%!>"1C2&). O7, %'! -7)(' R!$*740 H#!-0, 3215', @'!/1)1 %1$9!,! «)!91» (1 27%!'!).A $&-!'2.A ".#!& /! +74*) 213742.A $&-!'2.A ".#& 21 "!)'0 B!:7-!,! D!-@7,1. ;+7 )13#&@2.7 -&9. $&-!'2.A (-/)797#1A !92!,! +!'-!)722!,! )!91 4!$7' ".'*9! '.+(@& -&9!-), $&-06&A +7,!92( 21 +0C7, (-#(:5'+( /!'!4%14& '7A «)!9!-», %!'!).7 +!C#& +D!-@7,1. <1, $&-!'2.7 &3472&#&+* — %1% &3472&:#1+* +&#*2! & 374#( + '7A /!), %1% +!,)7C&# J914.

D+'1'&, 9! '!,! %1% /!(-&#+( <1)-&2, #59&)13-!9&#& )132.7 /!)!9. +!"1%,%!'!-, ,!#0"7> & '.9. <1$7 - E'!>91)-&2!-+%!> -.+'1-%7 ,!-!)&':+(, @'! «!2 [<1)-&2] 321#, @'! #5:9& @1+'! )13-!9&#& $&-!'2.A +/)79/!@'&'7#*2.4& /)&321%14&,& @'! +! -)747274 '1%!7 )13-797:2&7 /!)!9 0-7#&@&#! 41#72*%&7!'#&@&(... H!"1%& !+'1-1#&+* +!:"1%14&, 2! %)!C7@21( 97%!)1'&-:21( +!"1@%1 & "!#*C1( '!61( "!)31( +!-+74 27".#& /!A!$& 9)0, 21 9)0,1». T27 /)!+'! &2'7:)7+2!, +%!#*%! /!+7'&'7#7> 3147'&#& E'! !,:)!42!7 27+!!'-7'+'-&7.

D!27@2!, -+7 3215', @'! $&-!'2.7 472(5'+(.=!$2.> 1),0472' -.+'1-%&, @'! -7)056&7 - R&":#&5 #59& 90415', @'! $&-!'2.7 27 4!,0' 472('*:+( - /)797#1A -&91, 21/)1-#72 21 '!, @'!". 4!$2!".#! #7,%! !/)!-7),20'* 9!+'!-7)2!+'* R&"#&&. 2. <1#77, %!,91 /!+7'&'7#& 4037( 21@&215' 21:A!9&'*+( /!9 -#&(2&74 4.+#& ! '!4, @'! -7)05:6&7 - R&"#&5 #59& 27 /)&2&415' '!,!, @'! -7:6& 472(5'+(, !),12&31'!). -.+'1-%& 31(-#(5':«N'%).'&( ,7!#!,&& 0$7 /!9'-7)9&#& #!$2!+'*

&97& ! '!4, @'! -+7 -&9. /)!&3!C#& 21 374#7 -!92! -)74( 27+%!#*%! '.+(@ #7' 21319. N%147:27#!+'& (+2! /!%13.-15', @'! - /)!C#.A -7%1A4&) ".# 21+7#72 9)0,&4& -&914&, %!'!).7 +7:,!92( "!#*C7 27 +067+'-05'…»

F'1%, 9!-7)(56&7 G&+12&5 A)&+'&127/)79/!#!$&'7#*2! 27 -7)(' - '!, @'! $&-!'2.7472(5'+(, 2! <1)-&2 -.(+2&#, @'! !2& '1%& 47:

2(5'+(, 9!%131- #!$2!+'* R&":#&&. ?'& &347272&( ".#& 7,! 9!:%131'7#*+'-!4 E-!#58&& (21/)&:47), '!,!, @'! !"73*(2!/!9!"2.7+067+'-1 /)7-)1'&#&+* - #597>).?'1 -.+'1-%1 &+/!#*307'+( - #!2:9!2+%!4 40377 9#( '!,!, @'!"./!+7'&'7#& 9041#&, @'! &4 20$2!!'-7),20'* "&"#7>+%!7 !/&+12&7/)!&+A!$972&( & 27 -7)&'* - 4!:

#!905 374#5. 3. F, 21%!278, /!+#792&> E'1/ 0"7$972&( /!+7'&:'7#7> 27 9!-7)('* R&"#&& @7)73 %!2')!#* +!321:2&(. G!+7'&'7#7> +%#!2(5' /!-7)&'* - 9!/!#2&:'7#*2.> #!$2.> 1),0472': %)718&!2&+'. 27 /)&:2&415' '!,!, @'! 4!,0' !")13!-.-1'*+( 2!-.7 -&:9.. B! -79* 4. - E'! -7)&4! T. 42!$7+'-! )13 31:(-#(#& ! '!4, @'! 2!-.7 -&9. !")1305'+(, 1 7+'7+':-722.> !'"!) 97>+'-&'7#*2! /)!&+A!9&' (%1% 4./!%13.-174 - 2!-!> -.+'1-%7 - C4',, "$2($+,*.!3). K132&81 - '!4, @'! 4. 31(-#(74 +#7905677:-&9!!")13!-12&7 27 4!$7' /)&-!9&'* % <1)-&2!:-+%!> E-!#58&& — &97& ! '!4, @'! !9&2 +!-7)C72:2! !'97#*2.> '&/ !),12&341 (27 -&9) &3472(7'+( -

+!-7)C722! 9)0,!> ('.7., 21/)&47), )7/'&#&& +'1:2!-('+( /'&814&). =!29!2+%1( -.+'1-%1 31(-#(7':«<1)-&2!-+%1( '7!)&( E-!#58&& /0'74 7+'7+':-722!,! !'"!)1 —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».

G7@1#*2!, 27 /)1-91 #&?R&"#&( /)790/)7$917' 21+ ! '1%&A #59(A,

%!'!).7 A!'(' %!2')!#&)!-1'* 21C7 +!3212&7,'1%&A, %1% 4. -&9&4 21 E'!> 91)-&2!-+%!> -.+:'1-%7: !2& «/!91-#(5' &+'&20 27/)1-9!>» (K&4:#(214 1:18).

T!> -!/)!+ '1%!>: 21+%!#*%! «0/)1-#(56&7+7,!92( +!3212&74» /!-#&(#& 21 -1+ & 21 -1C0+74*5, & 27 '!#*%! - -!/)!+1A %)718&!2&341 &E-!#58&&? G!9041>'7 !" E'!4. J 31'74 0"79&:'7+*, @'! 0 -1+ 7+'* /)1-&#*2.7 !'-7'., %!'!).7/!4!,0' 316&'&'* -1C0 U)&+'&12+%05 -7)0!

R,. \SCwww.answersingenesis.org


3$",'$-/ !$="*"%2

M-*:$1.8*$ :-*&3($; *&':6&%<

8&?'-'$< 04. )$6&*&$8,&%+?0.:8< ( "$6. (&2D.&26-?&(-:.%+'&3

8$8:."., ENO $'-01'#@ "0?.<@

I.:#7 #($#($"+:%&%0' (O+%8+%), credit H DAVID ILIFF

ww

w.w

ikipedia.org

127 -+/!42&#+( E'!' +'&A, %!,91 ( @&:'1# !'-7' !92!,! 1'7&+'1 21 4!& )1+:+0$972&(, %!'!).7 ( 21/&+1# - +-!74

"#!,7. K7@* C#1 !" 1'7&+'1A, /!4272&5 %!'!).A A)&+'&127 +!:-7)C15' «21+&#&7 219 97'*4&»,!"0@1( &A A)&+'&12+'-0 & %)718&:!2&340. B1 E'!' +@7' 4!$2! 42!:,!7 +%131'*, 2!, /)7$97 -+7,!, ( A!:@0 !'47'&'*, @'! E'!' @7#!-7% 27'!#*%! 27/)1-&#*2! !/&+.-17' &&+%1$17' +0'* A)&+'&12+'-1, 2! &+%).-17' &+'&2205 /)1-90 ! '!4,@740, /! 4272&5 E'!,! @7#!-7%1,+#7907' 0@&'* 97'7>.

T1'7)&1#&+'. 0@1' 97'7> '!:40, @'! !2& — -+7,! #&C* %!4!%,)(3&, %!'!).> +! -)747274/)7-)1'&#+( - @7#!-7%1 — $&-!':2.7, & %!,91 !2& 04&)15', 21+'0:/17' %!278 1"+!#5'2! -+740, '1% @'! - $&32& 27'&+'&22!,! +4.+#1 & 87#&. B7' 2&%1%!> 2197$9.— -+7 "732197$2! & "7++4.+#722!. N2& A!'(',@'!". 97'& 321#& '!#*%! !" 1'7&+'&@7+%!> E-!:#58&& & -7)&#& - '!, @'! !2& — $&-!'2.7. G!E'!:40 27' 2&@7,! 09&-&'7#*2!,! - '!4, @'! (", H$%&*U, ! H$%&U, %<1,; 0!(42 ( "$$2(,2"2(!! ":2$; P!%$"$P!,;. D '!40 $7 &4722! E'& 1'7&+:'. #7,1#&3!-1#& 1"!)'., @'!". 4!$2! ".#! 0"&:-1'* 4&##&!2. 97'7> - 41'7)&2+%!> 0')!"7!

;!' E'! & 7+'* +14!7 21+'!(677 21+&#&7 21997'*4&, %!'!)!7 +!-7)C17'+( +)79& #597> /!-+740 4&)0.

U)&+'&127 0@1' 97'7>, @'! $&32* — 02&%1#*21,& R!, #5"&' 21+ "7+%!27@2!> #5"!-*5 '1% +&#*2!,@'!, 27+4!')( 21 21C7 -!++'12&7 /)!'&- B7,! (4.+!,)7C&#& - J9147), /)&,!-!)&-C77 21+ % !'97:#72&5 !' H-('!,! R!,1, 21C O-!)78 -!C7# - &+'!:)&5 )19& &+%0/#72&( 21C7,! ,)7A1 & +/1+72&( 21+!' '!,!, @'! 4. +14& + +!"!> +97#1#&! F E'!' 91)+/1+72&( RSX;NXTSX<B^[: 4. 2&@7,! 27 4!:

$74 +97#1'*, @'!". 31+#0$&'* 7,!, 1 /)!+'! +-!:"!92! /!#0@174! («F"! "#1,!91'&5 -. +/1+72.@7)73 -7)0, & +&7 27 !' -1+, R!$&> 91)», SL7+(214

2:8). <1, $&32* &477' +4.+# & 87#*!T. — 27 /)!+'! $&-!'2.7, 4. +!':-!)72. /! !")130 & /!9!"&5 R!,1!

F %1%!,! $7 «/)7%)1+2!,!,-9!A2!-#(567,!» /!+#12&( 4.«#&C174 97'7>», %!,91 27 0@&4 &A'!40, @'! !2& /)!+'! $&-!'2.7,E-!#58&!2&)!-1-C&7 &3 %!4%1/7)-!".'2!> ,)(3&?

N921$9. 9!%'!)1 K&@1)91 <!:0%&231 (1'7&+'1 & "!,!2721-&+':2&%1) +/)!+&#& 21 +1>'7 Beliefnet:

«Z'! -. 4!$7'7 +%131'* ! '!4!'@1(2&&, %!'!)!7 &+/.'.-15' 27:%!'!).7 #59&, )134.C#(( ! 7+'7:+'-722!4 !'"!)7 & +#0@1>2.A 40:'18&(A? H141 &97( E-!#58&& & 7+:

'7+'-722!,! !'"!)1 31+'1-#(7' 27%!'!).A #597>@0-+'-!-1'* "7++4.+#722!+'* $&32& !'97#*2!,!@7#!-7%1, 91 & $&32& -!!"67».

B1 @'! !2 !'-7'&#: «S+#& E'! /)1-91, @'! 27%!:'!).7 #59& 4!,0' @0-+'-!-1'* !'@1(2&7, '! 9!#:$72 +%131'*, E'! '($7#!. B! -+7 $7 /)1-91 !+'17':+( /)1-9!>. ;+7#7221( 27 9!#$21 214 +!@0-+'-!:-1'* & 0'7C1'* 21+; !21 '1%$7 27 !"(3121 97#1'*$&32* %1$9!,! @7#!-7%1 /)&('2!>. S+#& E'! /)1-:91, '! E'! /)1-91, & 214 #0@C7 +4&)&'*+( + E'&4».

D1%!7 «/)7%)1+2!7» /!+#12&7 9#( 4&)1!\&32* "7++4.+#7221 & "732197$21! H E'&4/)!+'! 219! +4&)&'*+(! D1% -14 2)1-&'+( '1%!7/)7%)1+2!7, 42!,!321@&'7#*2!7 & -9!A2!-#(5:677 /!+#12&7 9#( 97'7>?

N'-7@1( 21 -!/)!+ ! «$&32& /!+#7 +47)'&» &+14!> +47)'&, <!0%&23 +%131#: «B7 9041>'7, @'!-. /!/197'7 - )1>... ;. /)!+'! +,2&7'7 - 374#7».

D1%!7 /)7%)1+2!7 & -9!A2!-#(5677 /!+#12&79#( @&'1'7#7>: «;. /)!+'! +,2&7'7 - 374#7!». D!:27@2!, 7+#& +7)*732! -!+/)&2&41'* +#!-1 <!0%&2:31 & -%#19.-1'* &A - 04. 97'7> — - $&32& 27' 2&%1:%!,! +4.+#1 & 87#&, /!+#7 +47)'& -+7 31%12@&-17':+(, & @7#!-7%0 27 912! 321'*, @'! !2 %!,91:'! -!!":67 +067+'-!-1# 21 X74#7 — '! %1%!> $7 +4.+# -$&32&? G!@740 ". 27 /!%!2@&'* + E'&4 +7>@1+? F

E'!' @7#!-7% (%1% & 9)0,&7 /!9!"2.7 740) !+47#&:-17'+( !"-&2('* A)&+'&12 - «21+&#&& 219 97'*4&»?!

<1-1>'7 31919&4 -!/)!+ 1'7&+'0, 21/&+1-:C740 27#7/.> !'-7' 21 4!& %!4472'1)&& - "#!:,7: 7+#& $&32* — E'! -+7,! #&C* A&4&@7+%&7 )7:1%8&&, 1 #59& — $&-!'2.7, '! /!@740 +@&'17'+(«27/)1-&#*2.4», 7+#& %'!:'! 97#17' '!, @'! 740,- %!287 %!28!-, A!@7'+(?

=59(4 27!"A!9&4! !/!42&'*+( & /!2('*, @'!-)2,+!)%!"2/ ')8()2!%! "!"2,-4 7$"41)+*"2(,..$7$ $H+)'$().!3 & 0@1' 87#.7 /!%!#72&(97'7> 1'7&+'&@7+%!>, 21'0)1#&+'&@7+%!> "73"!$:2!> )7#&,&&. ?'! & 7+'* +141( -.+C1( L!)41 21+&:#&( 219 97'*4&: -!+/&'.-1'* 42!,&7 /!%!#72&( 97:'7>, -%#19.-1( &4 - 04. #!$* ! '!4, @'! R!,1:O-!):81 27 +067+'-07' & @'! !2& — /)!+'! $&-!'2.7 -E'!4 41'7)&1#&+'&@7+%!4, 47A12&+'&@7+%!4, E-!:#58&!22!4 4&)7. S+#& +#79!-1'* '1%&4 )1++0$97:2&(4, '! - $&32& 97>+'-&'7#*2! 27' +4.+#1 & 87#&.

D1% ,!-!)&'+( - %2&,7 H097>: «; '7 92& 27".#! 81)( 0 F3)1&#(; %1$9.> 97#1# '!, @'! 740%131#!+* +/)1-79#&-.4» (H097> 17:6).

R,. \SC

3,$ "* !*1$1 )(-( !$#('0*(, «"*!%-%( "*) )(,/1%»?«C&6. :.", *&:&6#. ... :+"0 ,&1$:-=: 8(.:&", $ 8(.: — :+"&3» (O8-$< 5:20)

P:& $ .8:+ 8-"-<(#8)-< 5&6"-

'-8$%$< '-; ;.:+"$:(&8,$:#(-:+ "'&/$.,&*&%.'$< ;.:.3,

(*%-;#(-< $" ( 0"#%&4+ & :&", 1:&G&/-IQ(&67- '.

80D.8:(0.: $ 1:&&'$ — ,6&8:&

4$(&:'#. ( F:&""-:.6$-%$8:$1.8*&",F(&%=7$&''&" "$6.


!1),72' R)7> &3 1-+')1#&>+%!,! 02&-7):+&'7'1 T1%%-1)& !"21)0$&#, @'! !'#!:$72&( (2'1)(, 31#7,156&7 - 0,#7 D1:

4722!0,!#*2!,! /7)&!91 «~320 4&##&!2!- #7'21319», 4!,#& !")13!-1'*+( &3 +!%1 )1+'72&>,+067+'-!-1-C&A, /! 4272&5 E-!#58&!2&+'!-,767 9! Q(,245!8 +)"2,.!;1. N2 !'47'&#, @'!27%!'!).7 A&4&@7+%&7 -767+'-1, -A!9(6&7 -+!+'1- (2'1)(, +!!'-7'+'-05' -767+'-14, %!'!:

).7, %1% &3-7+'2!, +!97)$1'+( - 8-7'06&A )1+:'72&(A. O1%&7 !%14727#.7 @1+'& 8-7'06&A )1+:'72&>, %1% #&+'*(, %!)2& & +'7"#&, !".@2!, 27!"21)0$&-15'+( - E'&A ,#0"!%! 31#7,156&A

+#!(A /!)!9, & -!3)1+' '1%&A )1+'72&> 0$7 91-:2! &+@&+#(5' «/)&47)2! 125 4&##&!214& #7'»2.

B7+4!')( 21 '!, @'! (2'1)* +!97)$&' A&4&:

@7+%&7 /)&321%& 8-7'06&A )1+'72&>, /! 4272&5R)7(, E'! !'%).'&7 -!-+7 27 !321@17', @'! 91'0/!(-#72&( E'&A )1+'72&> 27!"A!9&4! /7)7+:4!')7'*. B1!"!)!', !2 +@&'17',@'! E'& (2'1)2.7 !'#!$72&(«0%13.-15' 21 '!, @'! 1+/7%'."&!#!,&& 8-7'06&A )1+'72&> 21:@1#& L!)4&)!-1'*+( 2142!,!)12*C7, @74 125 4&##&!2!- #7'21319»2.

N921%! E'! /)79/!#!$72&7!+2!-.-17'+( 27 21 9122.A, /!:#[email protected] - )730#*'1'7 &++#79!:-12&( (2'1)(, 1 21 E-!#58&!2:2!4 4&)!-!33)72&&. S+#& /!+:4!')7'* 21 /!#[email protected] - )730#*:'1'7 21"#5972&> 9122.7 !"Y7%'&-2!, +'12!-&':+( +!-7)C722! (+2!, @'! 3.2)+& $H+)'$()%"3!' ")-/8 .)"2$35!8 Q(,245!8 +)"2,.!;. H1:41 &97( ! /)!+'7>C&A 8-7'06&A )1+'72&(A, +0:67+'-!-12&7 %!'!).A 27 ".#! /!9'-7)$972! 2&!%14727#.4&, 2& ".'056&4& L!)414& — E'!

767 !921 &+'!)&(, -.9041221( 9#( /!9,!2%&9122.A /!9 E-!#58&!22!7 4&)!-!33)72&7.

F2'7)7+2!, @'! 37)21 /.#*8., %!'!).7 (-#(:5'+( /)!90%'!4 &+%#5@&'7#*2! 8-7'06&A )1+'7:2&>, ".#& !"21)0$72. - +#1281A U1%1'1>, (-#(:56&A+( @1+'*5 +14.A 2&$2&A (<!%74")&>+%&A)/!)!9 M)129 D12*!21. B7+4!')( 21 '!, @'! /)7:9122.7 /+7-9!'7!)&& !" E-!#58&& 8-7'06&A)1+'72&> [email protected] /.'1#&+* -.91'* E'& 37)21 31«31,)(32(56&7 -767+'-1», /!-'!)2!7 &++#79!:-12&7 /)79+'1-&#! 121#!,&@2.7 )730#*'1'.: -2&$2&A /!)!91A ".#& !"21)0$72. 37)21 /.#*:8.3.

S+#& (2'1)* R)7( !")13!-1#+( &3 +!%1 8-7:'06&A )1+'72&>, %1% & /!9'-7)$917'+( 9122.4&,1 - +#1281A U1%1'1> 97>+'-&'7#*2! -.(-#721/.#*81, '! #$>+/2$",-3../, +)"2,.!3 "45,*"2($()%! " ")-$7$ .)9)%) -!+), %1% & !/&+12!

- R.'&&:«F +%131# R!,: 91 /)!&3:

)1+'&' 374#( 37#72*, ')1-0,+75605 +74( 97)7-! /#!9!:-&'!7, /)&2!+(677 /! )!90+-!740 /#!9, - %!'!)!4 +74(7,! 21 374#7. F +'1#! '1%. F/)!&3-7#1 374#( 37#72*, ')1:-0, +75605 +74( /! )!90 77, &97)7-!, /)&2!+(677 /#!9, -%!'!)!4 +74( 7,! /! )!90 7,!.F 0-&97# R!,, @'! E'! A!)!C!.F ".# -7@7), & ".#! 0')!:

972* ')7'&>.» (R.'&7 1:11:13)B1#&@&7 %)0/2.A L)1,472'!- /!%).'!+7:

4(22.A )1+'72&> - -7)A2&A +#!(A /!)!9 27 (-#(:7'+( /)&321%!4 E-!#58&!22!,! -)7472& &A /!:(-#72&(. N2!, +%!)77, 0%13.-17' #&"! 21 -)74(&A !'#!$72&( - )13#&@2.A 0+#!-&(A -27C27>

+)79. -! -)74( G!'!/1, 9#&-C7,!+( !9&2 ,!9,#&"! 21 /!+#79+'-&( +&#*2!,! 21-!9272&(, #&"!21 +!@7'12&7 E'&A L1%'!)!-.

I+);). M?CBV, *&@0($4 %&.1*www.icr.org

V"/%>!:1. R)7> G.H., J297)+72 K.R. F972'&L&%18&( (2'1)( %1472:

2!0,!#*2!,! /7)&!91 (320 4&##&!2!- #7' 21319) %#1++1 Ic// Science. — 2009; 326 (5949):132.

2. B7!$&91221( 21A!9%1 (2'1)( /7)7/&+.-17' &+'!)&5 "!:'12&%&. H!!"672&7 9#( /7@1'& 02&-7)+&'7'1 T1%%-1)& 2!%'(")( 2009 ,.

3. U!0 M.W. & 9). F++#79!-12&( %)718&!22!,! 210@2!,! !":67+'-1 9!%74")&>+%!> /.#*8., @1+'* III: 121#&3 /.#*8.,!"21)0$722!> - +#1287 U1%1'1>, & 9)0,&7 /!)!9. M)129D12*!21 // G7)&!9&@7+%!7 &3912&7 D)718&!22!,! 210@2!:,! !"67+'-1. — 1988; 24 (4):173.

)'(#"%; 2",*'/ &$),#('.)*(, :%:-%+: 7#(,6+>%('*!,("%2 !6>(!,#$#*-% ! !*1$?$ "*4*-* 1%'*

GVKD ?AD TC?KRATM, M? RBCAD =?F?LDZM

http://mq.edu.au/new

sroom/control.php?page=story&

item=3933

M-*:#,-%.&':&%&/$$,&;:(.64;-=:, 1:&,&*6#:&8."<''#.6-8:.'$<80D.8:(&(-%$ 88-"&/& '-1-%- "$6-,*-* $ &,$8-'& (G$2%$$.

?#1-2!7 - 0%)1&2+%!4 !")13!-12&& — 7,!90A!-21( +!+'1-#(561(, 4&)!-!33)72:@7+%1( !+2!-1. F4722! 397+* %!)2& -+7A

/)!"#74 !")13!-1'7#*2!> !')1+:#& - Q%)1&27, & !/)797#(561( &32&A — 4&)!-!33)72@7+%1(.H4.+# 4&)!-!33)72@7+%!> /)!":#74. /)!+' & !@7-&972: D!2+'&:'08&7> Q%)1&2. ,1)12'&)07'+(,@'! «%1$9.> &477' /)1-! 21 +-!:"!90 -."!)1 4&)!-!33)72&(...»(+'. 35), 1 0%)1&2+%1( +&+'741 ,!:+091)+'-722!,! !")13!-12&( +7:,!92( /)1%'&@7+%& /!#2!+'*5+!A)12&#1 & 31%)7/&#1 - /)1-!:-.A 2!)41A 41'7)&1#&+'&@7+%!7,1'7&+'&@7+%!7 4&)!-!33)72&7,7,! 87#&, 8722!+'&, /)&28&/. &/!9A!9.. Q%)1&2+%!7 !")13!-1:2&7 -!/)7%& D!2+'&'08&& /!3-!#&#! +7"7 2731:%!22! 021+#79!-1'* !+2!-0 /)79.9067> +!-7'+:%!> +&+'74., 77 ,!+091)+'-722!7 4&)!-!33)7:2&7, 021+#79!-1- !"(31'7#*2!,! 9#( «/!%#!27:2&(» -+7A 0@16&A+( &9!#1 /!9 213-12&74 «-!&2:+'-056&> 41'7)&1#&34». O7/7)* /! /!2('2.4/)&@&214 - +&+'747 !")13!-12&( +'1#! 472*C7-!&2+'-722!+'& & "731/7##(8&!22!+'&, 2! +06:2!+'* 27 &3472&#1+*.

O1%!7 4&)!-!33)72@7+%!7 +!+'!(2&7 21C7,!!")13!-12&( &477' %1% !"Y7%'&-2.7, '1% & +0"Y:7%'&-2.7 /)&@&2.. G)7$97 -+7,!, —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— /)&'!4 - H,')%&2,+.)2!(.$- /!)(9%7— - /)!,)1441A -+7A 0@7"2.A /)7947'!-, 0'-7:)$9174.A TNB.

<1, 0%)1&2+%&7 %)718&!2&+'. -.+'0/15' 31/!#2!7 & /!+#79!-1'7#*2!7 -279)72&7 /)&28&:/1 210@2!+'& - 0%)1&2+%!4 !")13!-12&&. B!, %1%

,!-!)&'+(, 219! !'97#('* /)1-792!7 !' ,)7C2!:,! — «!'97#('* 210%0 %1% )18&!21#*205 /!321-1:'7#*205 97('7#*2!+'* !' '1% 213.-174!,! '210@:

2!,! 4&)!-!33)72&(', %!'!)!7 21:0%!> 21 +14!4 97#7 27 (-#(7'+(,2! &+/!#*307' 210%0, 1 '1%$7 !/&:)17'+( 21 27%!'!).7 L&#!+!L+:%&7 +&+'74.; +14.> ()%&> /)&:47) — 41'7)&1#&34». ?'! 8&'1'1&3 -.+'0/#72&( G)73&972'1 K!+:+&>+%!> J%1974&& 210% P.H. N+&:/!-1 - 41)'7 1998 ,., %!'!).> +97:#1# -.-!9, @'! 210@2!7 4&)!-!3:3)72&7, /)7'729!-1-C77 21 02&:-7)+1#*2!+'* & 314720 )7#&,&&,27 +!+'!(#!+*.

N921%!, 9#( @&2!-2&%!- TNB& /!9@&2722.A 740 J%974&> &F2+'&'0'!- — - !'#&@&7 !' )!+:

+&>+%!> 210@2!> -7)A0C%& — «210@2!7 4&)!-!3:3)72&7» /)!9!#$17' !+'1-1'*+( &9!#!4, %!'!:)!40 !2& !"(3.-15' /)&2!+&'* - $7)'-0 +!:-7+'*, 2)1-+'-722!7 39!)!-*7 & "090677 +!'72'.+(@ 0@72&%!-. ; E'!> +-(3& 4!$2! /)!8&'&)!:-1'* & 21C7,! &3-7+'2!,! 0@72!,!:L&#!+!L1,9!%'!)1 L&#!+!L+%&A 210%,+'.2.+. F2+'&'0'1 L&#!+!:L&& BJB Q%)1&2. H. G)!#7:7-1: «; C%!#7 <...> ')09 !"0:@72&( & ')09 4.C#72&(/)7-)1'&#&+* - /)!/1,12904&)!-!33)72&(. <...> N"0:@72&7 -./!#2(7' %-13&)7#&:,&!3205 4&++&5. <...> ?'!/)&41' &97& 219 97>+'-&:'7#*2!+'*5» («W_#!+!L+*%1904%1», 2009 / 1).

B1C& /)7'723&& 19)7+0:5'+( 27 !'97#*2.4 /7)+!:214, 1 T&2&+'7)+'-0 %1%,#1-2!40 !),120 - +&+'747&+/!#2&'7#*2!> -#1+'&,/)&3-122!40 )13)1"1'.-1'*,!+091)+'-722.7 +'1291)'.!")13!-12&(, 0+'121-#&-1'*+'1291)'. 3212&> /! %1$9!:40 /)7947'0 & -!!"67 -.)1:"1'.-1'* ,!+091)+'-72205!")13!-1'7#*205 /!#&'&%0.

Q$7 /!+#7 /)&2('&(D!2+'&'08&& Q%)1&2. - 1996,. -.)!+#! 2!-!7 /!%!#72&7C%!#*2&%!-, 1 &A ! 1)%&U,$H49)<2 %0!, /)&'!4 %!2:9!-!>, 150:#7'27> -.97)$:

%&. F 27 /)!+'! !"0@15', 1 21+&#*+'-722! & "7:31#*'7)21'&-2! 21-(3.-15' E'0 #!$*. D!2+'&'0:8&( Q%)1&2. — 21 +'!)!27 %)718&!2&+'!-, & '1:%1(, + /!3-!#72&( +%131'*, «!")13!-1'7#*21( /!:#&'&%1» /)!9!#$1'*+( 27 4!$7'!

;.+C&7 @&2!-2&%& TNB & /!9-#1+'2.A 740J%1974&> & F2+'&'0'!- 0/!)2! 27 $7#15' /!:-7)20'* !")13!-1'7#*2.> /)!87++ - )0+#! )7:1#*2!> $&32& (1 )71#*2!+'* '1%!-1, @'! +!,#1+2!+!8!/)!+1 2009 ,., "!#77 67% 0%)1&287- +@&'1:5' +7"( A)&+'&1214&, [1]) & 2!)4 D!2+'&'08&&.

]7#.> )(9 !"67+'-722.A !),12&318&>, -'!4 @&+#7 [email protected], — 1 +)79& 2&A F2+'&'0'/)!"#74 /)!&+A!$972&( & )13-&'&( ;+7#722!>& $&32& + -7+2. 2005 ,., — 27!92!%)1'2! /)79:#1,1#& 21C740 T&2&+'7)+'-0 )13#&@2.7 -1)&:12'. & +/!+!". +!')092&@7+'-1, /)79#1,1#& 2!:-.7 0@7"2.7 %0)+., 0@7"2&%&, +!-47+'2.7 &2&:8&1'&-. - 21/)1-#72&& 0+')1272&( 21)0C72&>%!2+'&'08&!22!,! /)&28&/1 +-!"!9. 4&)!-!3:3)72&(. ;79* 97#! 0 21+ -+7A !"677 — +'!)!22&:%& -+7A 4&)!-!33)72&> /7)7$&-15' 31 +-!&A 97:'7> & -20%!-; /)&28&/. )1-72+'-1 & +/)1-79#&:-!+'& 9!#$2. ".'* +!"#5972.. B! )71%8&( TNB/!@'& .!>)>)3. G)1-91, 4&2&+') !")13!-12&(

F-12 ;1%1)@0% !'%#&%20#+( 21 /!+#79277 /)&,:#1C72&7 !" 0@1+'&& -! ;+70%)1&2+%!> /0"#&@:2!> 9&+%0++&& «T&)!-!33)72@7+%&> -."!) & "0:90677 210%& & !")13!-12&( - XXI -7%7», +!+'!(-:C7>+( - 417 2009 ,!91 - D&7-7, & /)79#!$&#+-!&4 /!9@&2722.4 /)&2('* - 27> 0@1+'&7 [2].N921%! 2& @&2!-2&%&, 2& 1%1974&%& TNB (270@&'7#(!) !' !")13!-12&( 27 !'%#&%20#&+* 21/)&,#1C72&7 +-!7,! 21@1#*2&%1.

G!E'!40 767 )13 /!9@7)%&-174: 97#! 27 -/7)+!21#&(A, 1 - +&+'747. F !'-7' 21 -!/)!+«Z'! 97#1'*?» -/!#27 !@7-&972: 4>+)!.">)3 .)*49.)3 ! $H+)'$()2,%&.)3 $H5,"2(,..$"2&1$%0.) #$-$9& 2,- 9!.$(.!>)- C?A T>+)!*./ ! ,7$ "2+4>24+, >$2$+/, 8$232 "$7%)"$*()2& $H+)'$()2,%&.4< "P,+4 " R$."2!24Q!*,; T>+)!./. J &21@7, 4. — +-!7,! )!91 27!(3.:@7+%!7, &9!#!/!%#!22&@7+%!7 ,!+091)+'-!, - %!:'!)!4 «210@2!40 4&)!-!33)72&5» - $7)'-0 /)&:2!+('+( 90C& 4!#!9.A ,)1$912.

F&%8. ;408. %&.1 E$"2!"%)( ?WDER?

V"/%>!: [1] — +4. http://polityka.in.ua/info/212.htm [2] — +4. http://nt:creaz.org.ua/lyst:MON.jpg


!4. ,&8%.,6$'<:$<R&'8:$:07$$!*6-$'# ( 1996 /.(#6&8%& '&(&.,&*&%.'$.)*&%+'$*&(, - $@ $;-%+). &201-=:%4$, ,6$:&"*&';&(&3, 150I%.:'.3 (#;.64*$.

«"*64"5; %)$-» # 63'*%"!3$1 $:'*=$#*"%%,3$,$'$16 &'%"$!2,!2 # .(',#6 )(,%

http://creationwiki.org/ru


#9!-7)C72&7 %! -+740, !2 767 & /7)7'!#%!:-.-17' A)&+'&12+'-!: 21/)&47), -20C17'@&'1'7#5, @'! F&+0+ A!'7#, @'!". T1)&(

T1,91#&21 /!+#7 S,! +47)'& -!3,#1-&#1 ]7)%!-*.R)102 #!-%! /.'17'+( /)&91'* E'&4 0'-7)$97:

2&(4 9!+'!-7)2!+'*, -%#19.-1( &A - 0+'1 9-0A /7):+!21$7>:[email protected] — «/)!L7++!)1 &%!2!,)1L&& &&+'!)&& )7#&,&& /! &472& K!"7)' =E2,9!2» & «".-:C7,! @#721 D!)!#7-+%!,! &+'!)&@7+%!,! !"67+':-1» +E)1 =*5 O&"&2,1. N921%! E'& «[email protected]» — /#!9/&+1'7#*+%!,! -.4.+#1! ; %!287 ,#1-. «W1%'.»R)102 +14!2197(22! 31(-#(7': «; %2&,7 /)79+'1-:#72. '[email protected] !/&+12&( /)!&3-7972&> &+%0++'-1,1)A&'7%'0)., 9!%0472'!- & '1>2.A )&'01#!-».A$ !:2$ 42(,+01,.!, — "$(,+U,..,;U)3 (/14->)!

«L",(1$!"2$+!9,">)39,#48) ( >4H,»2

G! +#!-14 /)!L7++!)1 T1>%#1 Q&#%&2+13, +&+'!)&@7+%!> & "&"#7>+%!> '!@7% 3)72&( %2&,1<E21 R)1021 «&3!"&#07' /!)13&'7#*2.4& 27'!@:2!+'(4&»4. B1/)&47):• R)102 0'-7)$917', "09'! 9)7-2&7 N#&4/&>+:

%&7 &,). ".#& /!+-(672. -!#C7"+'-0 ;727:

). (,#1-1 6). B1 +14!4 $7 97#7, &A /)!-!9&:#& - @7+'* X7-+1 — -7)A!-2!,! ,)7@7+%!,!"!$7+'-1, 1 ;727)1 — -!!"67, "!,&2( )&4+:%1(, 1 27 ,)7@7+%1(.

• H-&'%& T7)'-!,! T!)( ".#& 21>972. - 1947,. (1 27 «- /('&97+('.7 ,!9.», %1% +%1312! -,#1-7 55) & 2&%1% 27 4!,0' -%#5@1'* «S-12,7:#&(» (,#1-1 55), /!+%!#*%0 /!(-&#&+* )12*:C7, @74 B!-.> X1-7'.

• G)&!)1' H&!21 (%!'!).> R)102 213.-17' A)1:2&'7#74 «'1>2.» U)&+'1) -!-+7 27 ".# !+2!:-12 - F7)0+1#&47 - 1099 ,. L)12803+%&4 %!)!:#74 M!9L)01 97 R0>!2!4 (,#1-1 37). N2 ".#«&3!")7'72» & 31)7,&+')&)!-12 (- +!!'-7':+'-&& + L)12803+%&4 31%!2!4) 7 41( 1956 ,.9-04( L)1280314& — !+0$9722.4 4!C722&:%!4 G*7)!4 G#12'1)!4 & J29)E R!2!4!45. O1:%&4 !")13!4, "!#*C1( @1+'* +5$7'2!> #&2&&,%1+1567>+( =7!21)9!, !+2!-121 21 L1#*+&:L&%18&&, @'! 27!/)!-7)$&4! 9!%1312!.

• R)102 !/&+.-17' H-('05 H-('.A %1% /!9374:2!7 /!47672&7 /!9 U)14!4 ]1)( H!#!4!21(,#1-1 104). ?'! 27 '1%. H-('1( H-('.A — 27:"!#*C1( %!421'1 -20')& A)141, - %!'!)!> /7):-!+-(6722&% /)&2!+&# $7)'-. (3 ]1)+'- 7:50).

• R)102 0'-7)$917', @'! I7%&21 ".#1 «)1-2.4F7,!-7 /! +&#7 "!$7+'-!4 $72+%!,! )!91,$&-06&4 - A)147» (,#1-1 74). ?'! 27 '1%. ;9)7-277-)7>+%!4 (3.%7 +#!-! «I7%&21» !3:21@17' 3)&4!7 /)!(-#72&7 +#1-. R!$*7>.

• H!,#1+2! R)1020, 9)7-277-)7>+%!7 +-(672:2!7 F4( R!,1, Jehovah (F7,!-1), — +!79&27:2&7 40$+%!,! 21@1#1 Jah & $72+%!,! Havah —'1% (%!". 3-0@1#! &4( «S-1» 21 (3.%7, /)79:C7+'-!-1-C74 9)7-277-)7>+%!40. ?'! 27'1%. F7,!-1 — E'! ')12+%)&/8&( 9)7-277-:)7>+%!,! YHWH (VA-7) — &472&, %!'!)!7 N2!'%).# T!&+75 (F+A!9 3:14:15)6.?'!' +/&+!% !C&"!% & L1#*+&L&%18&> 4!$2!

/)!9!#$1'* "7+%!27@2!, 2! 9!+'1'!@2! & E'!> '!:#&%&, @'!". -+7 +'1#! /!2('2!7. G!A-1#*2!, @'!;7+'4&2+'7)+%!7 1""1'+'-! 31/)7'&#! +2&41'* 21+-!7> '7))&'!)&& L&#*4 /! )!4120 «D!9 91 ;&2:@&» &3:31 «91#7%&A !' &+'&2. )7#&,&!32.A & &+'!:)&@7+%&A -.+%13.-12&>» & «L1%'&@7+%&A !C&"!%»- %2&,7 R)1021. D +!$1#72&5, )0%!-!9+'-! H!"!)1=&2%!#*21 )13)7C&#! +Y74%& - A)147 31 «/!$7)':-!-122.7» 100 000 L02'!- +'7)#&2,!-8.

A)#)1>! I+)4.) .) 8+!"2!)."2($; ,#1-7 55 R)102 -%#19.-17' - 0+'1 O&"&2,1 '1:

%&7 +#!-1: «R&"#&( — E'! '-!)72&7 @7#!-7%1… ;!-:+7 27 R!,1… 1 31'74 !21 /)!C#1 "7+@&+#722!7 %!:#&@7+'-! /7)7-!9!-, 9!/!#272&> & /7)797#!%. <#(-%#5@72&( - B!-.> X1-7' )1++41')&-1#&+* +-.C7-!+*4&97+('& S-12,7#&>… R&"#&(, %1%!> 4. 77 '7:/7)* 32174, ".#1 +!+'1-#721 &3 )13#&@2.A &+'!@:2&%!- (3.@2&%!4, )&4+%&4 &4/7)1'!)!4 D!2+'12:'&2!4 ;7#&%&4… NL&8&1#*2! /)!-!3,#1+&- F&+0:+1 H.2!4 R!$*&4, D!2+'12'&2 '74 +14.4 /)7-)1:'&# S,! - "!$7+'-!… @*( -#1+'* -7@21 & 273."#741».

?'! /)!'&-!)7@&' 4272&5 1-'!)&'7'2.A &+:+#79!-1'7#7> R&"#&& & &+'!)&%!-:1. O7%+' R&"#&& 27 &3472&#+(. H!-)74722.7

&3912&( !+2!-12. 21 41%+&41#*2! '[email protected]/7)7-!91A 9)7-277-)7>+%&A & ,)7@7+%&A 41:20+%)&/'!-.

2. B&@7,! /!A!$7,! 21 -!+74*97+(' 9)0,&A«7-12,7#&>» !"21)0$72! 27 ".#!9.

3. F4/7)1'!) D!2+'12'&2 (274:337 2. E.) 27 -.:"&)1# S-12,7#&( !' T1'L7(, T1)%1, =0%& &F!1221 & 27 +!+'1-#(# %12!2&@7+%05 R&"#&5- 325 ,. Q$7 -! II -7%7 2. E. (!%. 130:202) F)&:27>, 0@72&% G!#&%1)/1, ".-:C7,!, - +-!5 !@7)79*, 0@72&:%!4 1/!+'!#1 F!1221, ,!-!)&#!" E'&A @7'.)7A S-12,7#&(A%1% ! «@7'.)7A +'!#/1A»10, %!:'!).7 «- 27)1397#*2!+'& +-!:7> (-#(5' +!"!> ,#1-2!7 +-&:97'7#*+'-! !" F&+0+7»11.

4. D!2+'12'&2 27 !"!$7+'-#(#F&+0+1, - 325 ,. !L&8&1#*2!/)!-!3,#1+&- S,! +.2!4R!$*&4. Q$7 - I:II --. A)&+'&:12 K&41, %!'!).7 27 !')7%1:#&+* !' -7). - "!$7+'-72:2!+'* U)&+'1, /)!-!3,#1C72:205 - R&"#&&, +$&,1#& 21%!+')1A &#& %&91#& 21 +Y7972&7 #*-1412.

I/% %! D!"4" 0,.)2?B7 +067+'-07' 91$7 +14!,! !'91#722!,! 21:

47%1 21 &+'!)&@7+%&7 +-&97'7#*+'-1 ! '!4, @'!F&+0+ (%!". ".# $721' 21 T1)&& T1,91#&27.B&,97 - R&"#&& 2&@7,! /!9!"2!,! 27 +%1312!.J/!+'!# G1-7#, /)!-!3,#1C1( /)1-! «&47'*+/0'2&87> $720» (1 D!). 9:5), ,!-!)&', @'! 0 /)!:@&A 1/!+'!#!-, ")1'*7- M!+/!91 & 0 D&L1 [G7')1]".#& $72., 2! !" F&+0+7 !2 E'!,! 27 ,!-!)&'.

B1 %)7+'7 F&+0+ /)!+&' F!1221 /!31"!'&'*:+( ! S,! 41'7)& (F!1221 19), !921%! 27 -.%13.:-17' 31"!'. ! T1)&& T1,91#&27 — H-!7> 0$7:/!@'&:-9!-7, 7+#& -7)&'* R)1020.

; «S-12,7#&(A» !' W&#&//1 & T1)&& T1,91#&2.,21 %!'!).7 ++.#17'+( R)102, 27 +%1312!, @'! T1)&(T1,91#&21 ".#1 $72!> F&+0+1. M#1-2!7 «9!%131:'7#*+'-!» R)1021 — E'! 8&'1'1 &3 S-12,7#&( !' W&:#&//1: «J +/0'2&81 H/1+&'7#( — T1)&( T1,91#&21».R)102 /&C7': «=5"!> +/78&1#&+' /! 1)147>+%!40+%1$7' -14, @'! +#!-! «+/0'2&81» - '7 92& "0%-1#*2!!321@1#! «+0/)0,1» (,#1-1 58). ?'! 27/)1-91! S-12,7:#&7 !' W&#&//1 ".#! 21/&+12! 27 21 1)147>+%!4, 121 ,)7@7+%!4 (3.%7, & /7)7-7972! 21 %!/'+%&>, '.7.7,&/7'+%&>, 1 27 1)147>+%&>13. M)7@7+%!7 +#!-!kowovoc (koinonos), ! %!'!)!4 &97' )7@*, !321@17'«9)0,, +!)1'2&%»; - B!-!4 X1-7'7 !2! 2& )130 27-+')7@17'+( - 321@72&& «+0/)0,» 14. B1 +14!4 97#7,27-7+'1 U)&+'!-1 — E'! S,! ]7)%!-*15.

L$14-),U&, $U!H>!!M)0".7 &+'!)&@7+%&7 !C&"%& — 27 )79%!+'*

9#( 2&3%!/)!"2!> L12'1+'&%&. X1@74 $7 097:#('* '1% 42!,! -2&412&( '!40, %1% 27#7/! &+%1:$17' 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'* <E2 R)102? B1 '! 7+'*27+%!#*%! /)&@&2:1. «D!9 91 ;&2@&» — 27 /)!+'! L12'1+'&%1. ?'!

27!(3.@7+%1( -7)+&( &+'!)&&. G)&%).-1(+*'-!)@7+%&4 -!!")1$72&74, /)&+06&4 A09!:$7+'-722!> /)!37, R)102 97)3%! +'1-&' /!9+!4272&7 "!$7+'-722!+'* U)&+'1. J 27%!'!:).7 #7,%!-7)2.7 @&'1'7#&, «/)!,#!'&-» E'&&34.C#72&(, 21@&215' )1397#('* -3,#(9.-.4.C#722.A /7)+!21$7> R)1021 & +!427:

-1'*+( - '7A &+'&21A !" F&+0+7, %!'!).7 !2&-+7,91 &+/!-79!-1#&16.

2. «S7 [%2&,&] &+'&221( 87#* — /!9!)-1'*… -7:)0 - '!, @'! /!9#&221( 7-12,7#*+%1( -7+'*,+!A)127221( 9#( 21+ - R&"#&&, — E'! 02&:%1#*2!7 +#!-! H14!,! R!,1 — +#!-!, "73 %!:'!)!,! 214 27 !")7+'& +/1+72&(»17.

3. R)102 /)!+#1-#(7' «"!,&25» ('.7. +7%+01#*205)1+/06722!+'*), - @1+'2!+'&, 7,&/7'+%05 "!:,&25 /#!9!)!9&( F+&90 (,#1-1 26). H-!> G)&!:)1' H&!21 (%!'!).>, +09( /! -+740, 9!#$72 31:6&61'* «&+'&20» A)&+'&12+'-1) R)102 213.-1:7' «/)&-7)$72814& (3.@7+%!,! %0#*'1 "!,&2&»(,#1-1 23). D2&,1 /)!/1,129&)07' "7+/!)(9!@:2.7 /!#!-.7 +-(3&. B1/)&47), R)102 /&C7':«…+!-!%0/#72&7 ".#! '74 1%'!4, @7)73 %!'!:).> 40$@&21 & $726&21 /!3215' R!,1».

4. G)79+'1-*'7 +7"7, @'! - 27%!74 )!4127 1-'!)0+'14& 0@72!,! &#& 0-1$174!,! &+'!)&%1 0'-7:)$91# "., @'! U!#!%!+' — E'! 4&L &#& @'!T1)'&2 =5'7) D&2,:4#19C&> 21+&#!-1# "7#.A97-0C7%. O1%05 %2&,0 27479#722! !"Y(-&#& ".12'&+74&'+%!> &#& )1+&+'+%!> & 31/)7'&#& ".,27+4!')( 21 '!, @'! E'! /#!9 A09!$7+'-722!,!-.4.+#1. J '74 -)747274 A)&+'!L!"&5 <E21R)1021 +-7'+%&7 HTF '!#*%! /)&-7'+'-05'.

H'1'*( - New York Times ,#1+&': «F97( '1>2!,!31,!-!)1, 21 %!'!)!> 3&$97'+( «D!9 91 ;&2@&», -!42!,!4 ".#1 /)&904121 767 1-'!)14& "7+'+7#:#7)1 1980:A ,,. «H-('1( %)!-*, H-('!> M)11#*». [B1+14!4 97#7, 1-'!). «H-('!> %)!-&, H-('!,! M)1:1#(» 91$7 /!91#& 21 R)1021 - +09 31 /#1,&1', 2!/)!&,)1#& 97#!. — G)&4. )79.] ?'1 %2&,1 ".#1!+2!-121 21 /1/%7 + 9!%0472'14&, !"21)0$722!>- B18&!21#*2!> "&"#&!'7%7 W)128&&, 2! +7,!92(0$7 -.(+272!, @'! E'! ".#1 4&+'&L&%18&(».

?/&#!, )!4121, %!,91 =E2,9!2 /)&%#!2(7' %!#7:2& /7)79 /)1A!4 T1)&& T1,91#&2., — +14.> /!9:A!9(6&> 4!472' 9#( R)1021, @'!". /)79Y(-&'*«9!%131'7#*+'-1» — 42&4.7 97+('%& '.+(@ +')12&8&2L!)418&& &3 @7'.)7A !,)!42.A +0290%!-. B1 +1:

4!4 $7 97#7, R)102 27 /)&-!9&' 2&!92!> +')12&8. 9!%131'7#*+'-. ;.:4.C#722.> «+%#7/» '1% & !+'17'+(31%).'.4. B& !92!,! 9!%131'7#*:+'-1 7)7+& R)1021 27 +067+'-07'.

G!A!$7, @7#!-7% ,!'!- /!-7)&'*- #5"05 L1#*+&L&%18&5 &+'!)&&,7+#& E'! /!4!$7' 740 &3"7$1'*!"(31'7#*+'-, %!'!).7 -#7@7' 31 +!:"!> -7)1 - &+'&20 !" F&+0+7 U)&+'7.; E'!4 «D!9 91 ;&2@&» !@72* +A!$ +'7!)&7> E-!#58&& !' 4&%)!"1 % @7:#!-7%0. S+#& ". A!'* @'!:'! &3 E'!,!".#! /)1-9!>, E'! !321@1#! "., @'!R&"#&( #$7', #59(4 27 20$72 H/1:+&'7#* & F+%0/&'7#* ,)7A!-, 1 &97(

H092!,! 92( "73!+2!-1'7#*21.R)102 +!321'7#*2! /!9472&# /!9#&2205 &+:

'!)&5 !@7-&92!> 4&+'&L&%18&7>, @'!, "730+:#!-2!, A!)!C! 9#( 7,! %!C7#*%1, 2! !@72* !/1+:2! 9#( "7++47)'2.A 90C 42!,&A @&'1'7#7>.

E)"",% WEDWwww.creation.com

V"/%>! ! #+!-,9).!31. ;/7)-.7 )!412 ".# !/0"#&%!-12 - '-7)9!4 /7)7/#7'7 &3:

91'7#*+'-!4 Doubleday, New York, 2003. J-'!). E'!>+'1'*& /!#*3!-1#&+* &3912&74 - 4(,%!4 /7)7/#7'7 &391:'7#*+'-1 Corgi Books, Transworld Publishers, London, 2004.

2. ;.+%13.-12&7 &+'!)&%1 K!21#*91 U&,,&2+1 &3 +'1'*&«F3Y(2. - «D!97 91 ;&2@&, 23 97%1")( 2004.

3. G)7/!91-1'7#* B!-!,! X1-7'1, 97%12 L1%0#*'7'1 - +74&:21)&& R&!#1 (O1#"!'+%1( C%!#1 "!,!+#!-&().

4. Wilkins M. What should every Christian know about The Da VinciCode? // <www.irr.org/da:vinci:code.html>, 19 !%'(")( 2005 ,.

5. Bock D.L. Breaking the Da Vinci Code. — Tennessee: NelsonBooks, 2004. — K. 185:186.

6. YHWH /)!&+A!9&' !' 9)7-277-)7>+%!,! ,#1,!#1 hayah —«".'*», 21/)&47): «V 7+4* +06&>» (F+A!9 3:14). J Havah(&#& Chavah) — E'! &4( «S-1» 21 9)7-277-)7>+%!4, 1 27 21(3.%7, /)79C7+'-!-1-C74 740. N2! /)!&+A!9&' !' 7-)7>+:%!,! +#!-1 chay, @'! !321@17' «$&32*; $&-!>» (R.'&7 3:20).

7. G!9)!"2.> )13"!) + ++.#%14& 21 9)0,&7 %)&'&@7+%&7+'1'*& +4.: Holding J. Not InDavincible: A review and critiqueof The DaVinci Code, at www.tektonics.org/davincicrude.htm,3 !%'(")( 2005 ,.

8. Tapper J., Runnette B. Religious groups wary of @lsquo;Da VinciCode@rsquo; movie, abcnews.go.com/Nightline/WNT/story?id=1051906&page=l, 21 +72'(")( 2005 ,.

9. <.G. U!#9&2, /&C7': «<1$7 7+#& & +067+'-!-1#! + /!#+!'2&/+7-9!E/&,)1L&@7+%&A 7-12,7#&>, ! "!#*C&2+'-7 &3 2&A &3:-7+'2! '!#*%! /! 213-12&(4, 0/!4(20'.4 - !'97#*2.A -.+:%13.-12&(A 1-'!)!- E/!A& )1227> 87)%-&». H4. ++.#%0 7.

10. F)&27> «G)!'&- 7)7+7>»: 3.11.8. ;!34!$2!, F)&27> 8&'&:)!-1# 767 "!#77 )122&7 &+'!@2&%&. H4.: Skeat T.C.Irenaeus and the Four:Gospel Canon. — Novumestamentum,1992; 34:194:199, <www.mindspring.com/~scarlson/hypo:typoseis/2004_02_15_arch.html>, 8 2!(")( 2005 ,.

11. H4. ++.#%0 5, +'). 114. 12. Grigg R. Who really is the God of Genesis? // Creation. —

2005; 27 (3):37:39. 13. Schenke H.:M. New Testament Apocrypha, cited in Gospel of Philip.

— Vol. 1, K. 182:183 , <www.earlychristianwritings.com/gospel:philip.html> 20 !%'(")( 2005 ,.

14. B1/).: T1'L7( 23:30; =0%& 5:10; 2 D!)&2L(214 1:7; 8:23;S-)7(4 2:14, 10:33; 1 G7')1 4:13, 5:1 & '.9.

15. 2 D!)&2L(214 11:2; D SL7+(214 5:22:32; N'%)!-72&7 19:7. 16. O1%, !9&2 4!#!9!> @7#!-7% 21/&+1# 214: «H '7A /!) [%1% (

/)!@7# %2&,0 R)1021] ( !')7%+( !' A)&+'&12+%!> -7)., &'7/7)* ( 1'7&+'». B1C /!9)!"2.> !'-7' +4. 21 www.cre:ationontheweb.com/vinci, 9 2!(")( 2005 ,.

17. Garlow J.L., Jones P. Cracking Da Vinci@rsquo;s Code. —Colorado: Cook Communications Ministries, 2004. — K. 151.

M);.)3 (,9,+3B13-12&7 )!4121 R)1021 +-(312! + %1)'&2!>

«O1>21( -7@7)(», 21/&+122!> =7!21)9! 91 ;&2@& -1495:1497 ,,. B1 27> &3!")1$72. F&+0+ & 9-7219:81'* 1/!+'!#!- - '!' 4!472', %!,91 U)&+'!+ +%1:31#: «N9&2 &3 -1+ /)791+' T72(» (T1'L7( 26:21).

F+%0++'-!-79. +@&'15', @'! L&,0)1 +/)1-1 !'F&+0+1 — E'! 4!#!9!> & "73"!)!9.> 1/!+'!# F!:122, %1%&4 7,! &3!")1$1#& 21 /!#!'21A '!,! /7)&:!91. N921%!, +!,#1+2! E%+')1-1,12'2!40 '!#%!-1:2&5 R)1021, E'! — T1)&( T1,91#&21. G!@740? G!:'!40 @'! -47+'7 + L&,0)!> U)&+'1 E'1 L&,0)1 !":)1307' "0%-0 «V» — 9)7-2&> +&4-!# $72+%!,! 21@1:#1 (7+#&, %!27@2!, -7)&'* R)1020), 1 L&,0). G7')1& F09. (+/)1-1 !' F!1221) +!3915' "0%-0 «M» —T1)&(. D)!47 '!,!, R)102 /&C7', @'! 0 "73"!)!9!>L&,0). -&972 «27%&> 2147% 21 ,)09*» (,#1-1 58).?2(,2 .) :24 "$P!"2!>4 "$"2$!2 !' 2+,8 9)"2,;:1. <1$7 7+#& /)79/!#!$72&7 R)1021 -7)2!, '!

!2! !')1$17' '!#*%! '-!)@7+%05 -!#*2!+'* =7:!21)9!, 2! 2&%1% 27 &+'!)&@7+%&> L1%'.

2. F+'!)&% K!21#*9 U&,,&2+ /&C7': «<1$7 7+#&@*7:'! @7)7+@0) "!,1'!7 -!!")1$72&7 +4!$7'21>'& '1%!> «2147%» - +%#19%1A /#161 F!1221,'! + 9)0,!> +'!)!2., 27 /!%).'!> /#16!4,,)09* 9!#$21 ".'* -&921 2142!,! #0@C7. B!E'1 @1+'* ,)09& F!1221 1"+!#5'2! /#!+%1(.<!#$2. #& 4., &+A!9( &3 E'!,!, +@&'1'*, @'! 0T1,91#&2. ".#1 '!#*%! !921 ,)09*?»1

3. S+#& E'1 L&,0)1 — T1)&( T1,91#&21, '! ,97 $7F!122? N2 '!@2! ".# '14 (!" E'!4 +-&97'7#*+'-0:5' T1'L7> 26:20, T1)% 14:17, 20; =0%1 22:8, & 2&!9&2 &3 2&A 27 0/!4&217' T1)&5 T1,91#&20), 1 31+'!#!4 — '!#*%! 9-721981'* L&,0) 1/!+'!#!-!

V"/%>):1. Higgins R. @lsquo; Cracks in the Da Vinci Code@rsquo;

www.irr.org/da:vinci:code.html, 23 97%1")( 2004 ,.

R).$.!9,">!, >.!7! A$($7$ F)(,2)

D12!2&@7+%&7 %2&,& B!-!,! X1-7'1 — E'! %2&:,&, /)&32122.7 A)&+'&12+%!> ]7)%!-*5 H-(:6722.4 G&+12&74. Z'! $7 27!"A!9&4!, @'!:". %2&,0 /)&321#& %12!2&@7+%!>?1. N21 9!#$21 ".'* 21/&+121 1/!+'!#!4 &#&"#&3%&4 9)0,!4 1/!+'!#!-, '1%&4 %1% T1)%&#& =0%1.

2. N21 9!#$21 )1++%13.-1'* /)1-90 ! R!,7.3. H!97)$12&7 %2&,& 9!#$2! +-&97'7#*+'-!:-1'* ! 77 "!,!-9!A2!-722!+'&.

4. N21 9!#$21 ".'* /)&32121 R!$*&4& #59*4&.G)&3212&7 %2&, B!-!,! X1-7'1 21@1#!+* - I

-. 2. E. J/!+'!# G1-7# (1 O&4!L75 5:18) 213.:-1# S-12,7#&7 !' =0%& 10:7 H-(6722.4 G&+1:2&74. J/!+'!# G7') 213.-1# H-(6722.4 G&:+12&74 /!+#12&( 1/!+'!#1 G1-#1 (2 G7')13:15:17). Z7'.)7 "&"#7>+%&A S-12,7#&( «/)!@:2! 0'-7)9&#&+* - %1@7+'-7 !+2!-!/!#1,156&A'7%+'!- A)&+'&12+%!> 87)%-& % %!280 -'!)!,!-7%1, 7+#& 27 )12*C7»1. G7)-.7 +/&+%& %12!2&:@7+%&A %2&, B!-!,! X1-7'1 ".#& /)&3212. 21F//!2+%!4 +!"!)7 393 ,. & D1)L1,72+%!4 +!:"!)7 397 ,., '! 7+'*, ,!)139! /!3$7 +47)'&D!2+'12'&21 - 337 ,. ;1$2! /!42&'*, @'! -21@1:#7 %12!2 ".# 0'-7)$972 R!,!4 & '!#*%! /!'!4— #59*4&. W.W. R)5+, &++#79!-1'7#* B!-!,!X1-7'1, /&C7': «B7-7)2! +@&'1'*, @'! %2&,&B!-!,! X1-7'1 +'1#& !+2!-!/!#1,156&4& 9#(87)%-&, /!'!40 @'! ".#& L!)41#*2! -%#[email protected] +/&+!% %12!2&@7+%&A %2&,. B1/)!'&-, ]7):%!-* -%#5@&#1 &A - +/&+!% %12!2&@7+%&A, /!'!:40 @'! 0$7 +@&'1#1 &A -9!A2!-#722.4&...» 2.

J/!%)&L&@7+%&7 7-12,7#&( T1)&&, G7')1& W&#&//13, 21 %!'!).7 ++.#17'+( R)102, 27!'-7@1#& E'!40 !+2!-2!40 %)&'7)&5 & 27 ".#&/)&2('. ]7)%!-*54:5; '1%&4 !")13!4, 27 ".#!+4.+#1 &A /7)7/&+.-1'*. B1 +14!4 97#7, &97&R)1021 27 !'#&@15'+( !)&,&21#*2!+'*5. N2&42!,! #7' ".#& /!/0#()2. - %)0,1A !%%0#*'&+:'!- & +'!)!22&%!- %0#*'1 «B*5 ?>9$», 1 %!)2(:4& 0A!9(' - 9)7-255 7)7+* ,2!+'&8&3416.

V"/%>! ! #+!-,9).!3:1. Bock D.L. Breaking the Da Vinci Code. — Tennessee:

Nelson Books, 2004. — K. 153. 2. Bruce F.F. The New Testament Documents: Ate they reliable?

— Leister, England: InterVarsity Press, 1960. — K. 27. 3. «[email protected] 91'&)05' S-12,7#&7 !' W&#&//1 III -. 2. E. —

/)&47)2! 200 #7' +/0+'( /!+#7 3742!> $&32& F&+0+1.O1%&4 !")13!4, @'!". 21/&+1'* 7,!, 1/!+'!#, 213-12:2.> - D2&,7 <7(2&> W&#&//!4, 9!#$72 ".# /)!$&'*%1% 4&2&404 310 #7'!». G!9)!"2.> )13"!) + ++.#%1:4& 21 9)0,&7 %)&'&@7+%&7 +'1'*& +4.: Holding J. NotInDavincible: A review and critique of The DaVinci Code, atwww.tektonics.org/davincicrude.htm, 3 !%'(")( 2005 ,.

4. G)&47): «; )15 )1+'0' 9-1 97)7-1. N92! /!)!$917' $&:-!'2.A, 9)0,!7 — #597>. J914 7# !' 97)7-1, )!$91-C7,!$&-!'2.A, /!E'!40 !2 +'1# $&-!'2.4 & /)!&3-7# 21 +-7'$&-!'2.A. H '7A /!) /!'!4%& J9141 /!%#!2(5'+( $&-!':2.4». R&"#&!'7%1 B1,:U14419&, «S-12,7#&7 !' W&#&/:/1», /7)7-!9 21 12,#. Q&3#& J>372"7),1 (Wesley Isenberg).www.gnosis.org/naghamm/gop.html, 23 1-,0+'1 2005 ,.

5. «H141( 09&-&'7#*21( '741, !"61( 9#( -+7A /('&97:+('& 9-0A '7%+'!-, 21>9722.A -! -)74( )1+%!/!% -B1,:U14419&, — E'! !')&812&7 H!'-!)72&(, !/&:+122!,! - %2&,7 R.'&(». Gartow J.L., Jones P. CrackingDa Vinci@rsquo;s Code. — Colorado: CookCommunications Ministries, 2004. — K. 166.

6. M2!+'&%& (! ,)7@7+%!,! gnosis — «3212&7») 0'-7)$91#&,@'! !"#1915' '1>2.4 !%%0#*'2.4 3212&74. B1/)&47),!2& +@&'1#&, @'! /#!'* & 41'7)&( /!)!@2., 1 321@&',F&+0+ 27 4!, ".'* R!,!4 -! /#!'&. M#1-2!> 90A!-2!>/)!"#74!> !2& +@&'1#& 27 ,)7A, 1 27-7$7+'-!. F+'!@:2&%!4 $7 +/1+72&( 9#( 2&A ".#! 3212&7, 1 27 /)!67:2&7 "#1,!91'*5 @7)73 -7)0. K1+8-7' E'!,! '7@72&( /)&:C7#+( 21 II -. 2. E. H')0%'0)&)!-122!7 )13-&'&7 A)&+'&:12+%!> 9!%')&2. (21/)&47), +&4-!#!- -7).) ".#! -!42!,!4 -.3-12! "!)*"!> 87)%-& + ,2!+'&8&34!4.

>&@&4., 1.%&(.*/&:&( ,&(.6$:+ (

%=20=5-%+8$5$*-7$=$8:&6$$, .8%$ F:&,&"&4.: ."0$?2.4-:+

&2<?-:.%+8:(,*&:&6#. (%.1.: ?-8&2&3 (.6- ( $8:$'0&2 O$808. S6$8:..

=?@AB CDE?=?FFEGAD@

«3$) )* #%"4%»: #5)613* &$) #%)$1 &'*#)5


3!27@2! $7, +)79& A)&+'&12 ".#& [email protected],312&41-C&7+( A!)!C7> 210%!>, 2! E'!".#! 9! <1)-&21. O1%? B7', 27 '1%! T.

)1++%1$74 -14 &+'!)&5 ! /!+-(6722!4 91)-&:2&+'7, %!'!).> /)&C7# % %)718&!2&340, 1 31'74& % A)&+'&12+'-0.

;. 27 4!$7'7 0'-7)$91'*, @'! -7)1 =54+9721".#1 )730#*'1'!4 '!>%0#*'0)2!> +)79., - %!'!:)!> !2 -.)!+, %1% 27%!'!:).7 ,!-!)(' !" [email protected] XVI+'. R!#77 '!,!, !2 ".# 1%:'&-2.4 @#72!4 12'&%)71:8&!22!,! 9-&$72&( -'!:)!> /!#!-&2. UU -. <!%:'!) K&@1)9 <. =54+972".# /!#2!+'*5 /!,)0$72- 91)-&2!-+%05 L&#!+!:L&5 & 27&47# 2&$7#12&(,

2& /)&@&2 9041'* ! A)&+'&12+'-7.S,! -7)!> ".#1 210%1: L1%'. &'!#*%! L1%'.. F -!', 21A!9(+* 21-7)C&27 +-!7> /)!L7++&!21#*2!>%1)*7)., !2 21C7# - +7"7 +47#!+'*& @7+'2!+'* /)!-7)&'* &+'&22!+'*L1%'!-, /)&2(- 27#7,%!7 )7C72&7+#79!-1'* 31 2&4&, %091 ". !2& 7,!27 /)&-7#&, 27+4!')( 21 -+7, @7407,! 0@&#&, & @740 !2 +14 0@&# 9)0,&A. V 2,8 #$+ ,7$0!'.& #$%.$"2&< !'-,.!%)"&: &3 91)-&2&+'1 !2/)7-)1'&#+( - %)718&!2&+'1, 1 &3 1'7&+'1 — -A)&+'&12&21.

<!%'!) K&@1)9 <. =54+972 ".# /)!L7++!)!4/1)13&'!#!,&& & %#7'!@2!> "&!#!,&& 02&-7)+&'7'1,!)!91 O0#7>2. N2 31-79!-1# !'97#72&74 41,&+':)1'0). & !/0"#&%!-1# +!'2& [email protected] +'1'7>. O)&9:81'* 7,! +'0972'!- -/!+#79+'-&& /!#0@&#& 9!%'!:)+%05 +'7/72*. F47( !,)!42.> '7!)7'&@7+%&> &#1"!)1'!)2.> !/.' - !"#1+'& "&!#!,&@7+%&A 210%,-%#5@1( &++#79!-12&( + /!4!6*5 E#7%')!22!>4&%)!+%!/&&, $. #$%49!% (/"$>$, -,014.)+$1*.$, #+!'.).!, ') (>%)1 ( #)+)'!2$%$7!<. B1/)!'($72&& -+7> +-!7> %1)*7). !2 27/!%!#7"&4!-7)&# - '!, @'! 91)-&2!-+%1( E-!#58&( — E'! /)&3:2122.> 210@2.> /)&28&/ & &+%)722! -.+47&-1#A)&+'&12+%&7 0"7$972&(. N921$9. !2 0+#.C1#,@'! - C'1'7 =0&3&121 /)&2(' 31%!2, +!,#1+2! %!'!:)!40 - C%!#1A -.97#&#& /!)!-20 -)7472& 9#( &30:@72&( %)718&!2&341 & E-!#58&&. ?'1 2!-!+'* 7,!/)!+'! /!)13&#1. «D1% ,#0/! & 27/)1-&#*2!!», — 90:41# !2. ;!3406722.> /)!L7++!) )13)13&#+( /7:)79 +-!&4& +'0972'14& ()!+'2!> '&)19!> /)!'&-%)718&!2&341, &+/!#*30( /)& E'!4 -+7 +-!7 %)1+:2!)7@&7 - /!997)$%0 91)-&2&341. N2 27 321#, @'! -'!' 972* - %#1++7 /)&+0'+'-!-1# «!/1+2.> /)!'&-:2&%». B7', E'! ".# 27 %)1+2!)7@&-.> !)1'!), ,!'!:-.> +!+'(31'*+( + 2&4 - !+')!04&& — E'! ".#! ".+#&C%!4 /)!+'! 9#( =54+9721. B1 E'!' )13 E'! ".:#1 /)&('21(, -7$#&-1(, 4!#!91( +'0972'%1.

?'1 97-0C%1 /!9!C#1 % 2740 /!+#7 #7%8&& &,)!4%! -!+%#&%20#1: «N'#&@21( #7%8&(, 9!%'!)=54+972! H%1$&'7, 4. 4!$74 -+')7'&'*+( + -14&#&@2! — 0 472( 7+'* 27+%!#*%! -!/)!+!- !'2!+&:'7#*2! '!,!, @'! -. +%131#&. V /)!+'! A!@0 -! -+74)13!")1'*+(». <!%'!) =54+972, /!#*6722.> '1:%!> 31&2'7)7+!-122!+'*5 +'0972'%&, +!,#1+&#+(21 -+')7@0 - +-!74 )1"!@74 %1"&27'7.

; 21321@722!7 -)74( 97-0C%1 /)&C#1, /!":#1,!91)&#1 7,! 31 -.97#722!7 -)74( & 21@1#13191-1'* +-!& -!/)!+.. N21 27 +/!)&#1 + '74,@'! +%131# 9!%'!) 21 #7%8&& /! /!-!90 E-!#58&&,2! 21@1#1 3191-1'* -!/)!+., 21 %!'!).7 !21 A!:'7#1 /!#0@&'* !'-7'.: «D1% -!32&%#1 $&32*?..K13-7 <BD 27 +#&C%!4 +#!$21(, @'!". !")13!:-1'*+( +#0@1>2!?.. G!@740 47$90 !+2!-2.4&,)0//14& - #7'!/&+& !%14727#!+'7> +067+'-05''1%&7 !,)!42.7 /)!47$0'%&?.. D1%&7 7+'* /7)7:A!92.7 3-72*( 47$90 !"73*(2!> & @7#!-7%!4?»…H'0972'%1 97>+'-!-1#1 "73 !+0$972&( &#& /)!:-!%18&& — !21 /)!+'! A!'7#1 /!#0@&'* !'-7'..

=54+972, 1"+!#5'2! 27 +406722.> /!9!":2.4& -!/)!+14&, 91-1# 7> !"[email protected] E-!#58&!2:2.7 !"Y(+272&(. B! @'!:'! - E'!> "7+797 -.3-1#!0 27,! @0-+'-! 27#!-%!+'&. N2 ,!'!- ".# % "!)*"7,1 27 % +/!%!>2.4 /)(4.4 -!/)!+14. D!,91 =54+:972 +#.C1# +-!> ,!#!+, 0-7)722! 91-1-C&> +'0:972'%7 '&/&@2.7 E-!#58&!22.7 !'-7'., !2 /!90:41# /)! +7"(: «;+7 E'! 27 &477' 2&%1%!,! +4.+#1.O!, @'! ( 3215 ! "&!#!,&&, /)!'&-!)7@&' '!40, @'!( ,!-!)5». D!,91 -)74( -+')7@& /!9!C#! % %!280,97-0C%1 -3(#1 +-!& %2&,&, 0#."20#1+* & +%131#1:«H/1+&"!, 9!%'!) =54+972!», — & 0C#1. ;27C27K&@1)9 =54+972 ".# +/!%!72, 2! -20')& ".#/)!+'! !/0+'!C72. ?. '.)%, 92$ (", ">)')..$,!- "241,.2>, — .,#+)(!%&.$!

<!%'!) =54+972 !"#191# 9!+'1'!@2!> @7+':2!+'*5, @'!". /!+4!')7'* - #&8! +-!&4 +!427:2&(4. N2 /)!-7# +!"+'-722!7 &++#79!-12&7,@'!". /)!-7)&'* 1),0472'. - /!#*30 E-!#58&&! "$ (+,-,.,- $H.)+40!%, 92$ !8 #+$"2$ .,2.

N+2!-.-1(+* +0,0"! 21 [email protected] L1%'1A, !2 /)&:2(# )7C72&7, @'! 9!#$72 !'-7),20'* 91)-&2&34& +'1'* %)718&!2&+'!4. B! '1% $7 %1% 0')! +47:2(7' 2!@*, /)&C7# +#79056&> -!/)!+: «J %'! $7'1%!> O-!)78?». ;+%!)7 /!+#7 E'!,!, +#0@1>2!&#& 27', +7+')1 /)&,#1+&#1 7,! - ]7)%!-*. G!>'&- ]7)%!-* — E'! ".#! '1% 27 /!A!$7 21 ".-C7,!27/!%!#7"&4!,! & +14!0-7)722!,! E-!#58&!:2&+'1! S67 2791-2! !2 & 321'* 2&@7,! 27 A!'7# !)7#&,&&. B! '7/7)* !2 ,!'!- ".# /7)7+4!')7'*&+'&22!+'* O-!)81 & +-&97'7#*+'-1 R&"#&&.

S,! 1'7&+'&@7+%1( L&#!+!L&( 27 91-1#1 740+&#, @'!". +/)1-&'*+( + @0-+'-!4 -&2. & /#!A&4&/)&-.@%14& - #&@2!> $&32&. O7/7)* !2 +'1# +-!"!:972 & 0+#.C1# R#1,05 ;7+'* ! R!,7, /!+#1-C7,!H-!7,! H.21 /!27+'& 21%1312&7 31 21C& ,)7A& &/)79#!$&-C7,! #59(4 /)!672&7 & -7@205 $&32*.

B7-7)!('21( "!)*"1 /)!&+A!9&#1 - +7)987 9!%:'!)1 =54+9721, %!,91 !2 +#0C1#/)!/!-79*. D!,91 +#0$72&7 /!9A!9&:#! % %!280, /1+'!) !")1'&#+( % /)&+0:'+'-056&4 & /)&,#1+&# -.>'& -/7:)79 '7A, %'! A!'7# /0"#&@2! /)&2('*F&+0+1 - +-!7 +7)987. <!%'!) =54+:972 '1% !/&+1# -7#&@1>C77 +4('7:2&7, !A-1'&-C77 7,! - '!' 4!472':«T!( /#!'* /)!'&-&#/+* -.A!9&'*,2! ( -9)0, /!2(#, @'! &90 -/7)79 /!21/)1-#72&5 % 1#'1)5. F '14 ( 21:C7# R!,1! ; '!' 4!472' ( -!&+'&20

/!321# S,! & /)&2(# M!+/!91 F&+0+1 U)&+'1 %1% 4!7:,! M!+/!91 & H/1+&'7#(». ;!3#7 %)7+'1 7+'* 47+'!91$7 9#( «-+732156&A» [email protected], 7+#& !2& ,!'!-.+4&)&'*+( & /)7%#!2&'*+( /7)79 H!391'7#74, 21 %!:'!)!,! & 0%13.-15' -+7 [email protected] +-&97'7#*+'-1.

<!%'!) =54+972 21+#1$91#+( +-!7> 2!-!> -7:)!>, 2! /!2(#, @'! !2 9!#$72 ".# 31/#1'&'* 31 E'!.G!+#7 '1%!,! 1%'&-2!,! !")1672&( % U)&+'0 & %)7:18&!2&340 7,! -.,21#& &3 L1%0#*'7'1 7+'7+'-!321:2&(. F2+'&'0' %)718&!222.A &++#79!-12&> /)79:#!$&# 740 -!3,#1-&'* %1L79)0 "&!#!,&&, %!'!)!>!2 )0%!-!9&# + 1990 /! 1996 ,,. <!%'!) M72)& T!):)&+ +%131# ! 274: «G7)79 214& ():%!7 +-&97'7#*+'-! !")1672&( @7:#!-7%1 -+7,! 27+%!#*%! #7' 21319 &'!,!, %1%05 -1$205 )!#* - E'!4 +.,:)1#1 !921 &3 7,! +'0972'!%, 21+'!>:@&-! 3191-1-C1( /)!2&81'7#*2.7-!/)!+.. N2 /!#2!+'*5 0"79&#+( -27+!+'!('7#*2!+'& +-!&A 0"7$97:2&> & /!2(#, @'! 79&2+'-7221( )1:30421( 1#*'7)21'&-1 — /!-7)&'* -H!391'7#(».

<&% =54+972 ".# /)&,#1C7221 %1L79)0 7+'7+'-!3212&( «T1+:'7)+ D!##79$1» 9#( 0+'12!-#72&(&347)&'7#*2!,! !"!)09!-12&(9#( !"0@72&( +'0972'!-. S,! $&32* 21/!#2(#1)19!+'*, 1 7,! #7%8&& +'1#& $&-.4&. G-4 .+)*(!%$"& 1,-$."2+!+$()2& 1!');. ( >%,2>)8,>$2$+/, ., -$7%! ($'.!>.42& ( +,'4%&2)2,1)+(!.$(">!8 #+$Q,""$(. <&+%0'&)0( + E-!:#58&!2&+'14&, !2 321# &A «+#1".7 47+'1», /!'!:40 @'! /!".-1# 21 &A 47+'7. S,! +'0972'. /!9!+'!&2+'-0 !872&#& +'&#* 7,! !"0@72&(, -+5,#0"&20 & C&)!'0 7,! 3212&> & !/.', %!'!).4 !2679)! 97#&#+( 21 #7%8&(A & - #1"!)1'!)&&.

K&@1)9 =54+972 +-&97'7#*+'-!-1# - /)!,)14:47 +#0$72&( «D!)1# K&9$», !+2!-122!,! 9!%'!)!4<. <$7>4+!4 D72279&. ; /)!,)1447 !2 /!9)!"2!

)1++%131# ! '!4 927, %!,91 % 2740 - %1"&27' /)&C:#1 +'0972'%1, -!/)!+. %!'!)!> 31+'1-&#& 7,! /7:)7+4!')7'* +-!& -3,#(9.. ; (2-1)7 1996 ,. !2 91#&2'7)-*5 R&"#7>+%!:210@2!> J++!8&18&& - !'-7'21 %2&,0 1'7&+'1 K&@1)91 <!0%&231 «H#7/!> @1+!-:6&%». ; +-!7> )7@& «B7 '1%!> 0$ & +#7/!> E'!' @1:+!-6&%» !2 /)79+'1-&# 27+%!#*%! /!9)!"2.A !/&:

+12&> !),12!-, %!'!).7 27 4!,#&!")13!-1'*+( -+#79+'-&7 91)-&2!:-+%!,! 7+'7+'-722!,! !'"!)1. D!,:91 21+'1#! -)74( -!/)!+!- & !'-7:'!-, !2 )1++%131# ! '!4, %1% R!,+/1+ 7,! !' /)7$27> $&32&, - %!'!:)!> !2 ".# +14!2197(22.4 E-!#5:8&!2&+'!4. D +!$1#72&5, 9#&'7#*:2!7 3#!0/!')7"#72&7 1#%!,!#74 &2&%!'&2!4 - 7,! «/)!C#!>» $&32&+%131#!+* 21 7,! 39!)!-*7, & !2047) +#&C%!4 )12! — - -!3)1+'759 #7' - 1997 ,. S,! +'0972'. !@72*+%0@15' /! 2740.

; +72'(")7 2001 ,. M!+091):+'-7221( +#0$"1 )19&!-7612&( HIJ ')12+#&)!:-1#1 -!+*4&@1+!-!> 8&%#, - %!'!)!4 E-!#58&5!/&+.-1#& %1% L1%' & 872')1#*205 '740 "&!#!:,&&. ; E'!4 8&%#7 -+7 ".#! /)7/!927+72! '1%,@'! 91)-&2&340 /)!'&-!+'!(' '!#*%! #59&, %!'!:).7 &90' -+#79 31 )7#&,&7>. S+#& ". 9!%'!) K&:@1)9 =54+972 9! +&A /!) ".# $&-, !2 ". -+'1# &+/)!+&# 0 +!391'7#7> 8&%#1: «H%1$&'7, 4. 4!:$74 -+')7'&'*+( + -14& #&@2! — 0 472( 7+'* 27+:%!#*%! -!/)!+!- !'2!+&'7#*2! '!,!, @'! -. +%1:31#&. V /)!+'! A!@0 -! -+74 )13!")1'*+(». ?'!".#1 ". !@72* &2'7)7+21( "7+791. <!%'!) =54+:972, 27+!42722!, 321# "., ,97 &A +#1"!7 47+'!.

T]GAY@ A?CGEB

'%4*') -+1!)(" (/&;# 4$?'$ 1938I1997 //.)

A' ,6&(.%8&28:(.''&.

$88%.;&(-'$., 1:&2#,6&(.6$:+

-6/0".':# ( ,&%+?0F(&%=7$$ $ 8&

(6.".'." &2'-604$%,1:& $@ ,6&8:& '.:

T&?%. *6.8:- .8:+".8:& ;-4. ;%<«(8.?'-=D$@»01.'#@, .8%$ &'$

/&:&(# 8"$6$:+8< $,6.*%&'$:+8< ,.6.;E&?;-:.%.", '-*&:&6&/& $

0*-?#(-=: (8.'-01'#.

8($;.:.%+8:(-

76$% 4%9<,&% 8#()2"# / !",-!,«E%-(%= Q.2<, ,&:&"0 1:& < ;$('& 08:6&.'. B$('# ;.%- Q(&$, $ ;0)- "&< (,&%'. &8&?'-.: F:&» (>8 138:14).

© 2010 Encyclopedia B

ritannica, Inc. ww

w.britannica.com


2/1+'!), 1 '1%$7 @#72 %!4129., %!'!)1(/)!/!-7907' & 27+7' "#1,05 -7+'* 210#&81A ,!)!91 J97#1&91 - P$2!>

J-+')1#&&. G!@'& %1$905 /('2&80, -7@7)!4, 4./)!-!3,#1C174 S-12,7#&7 21 0,#0 C042!> 0#&:8.. D1$9.> @#72 21C7> %!4129. /!#2!+'*5/!+-(672 E'!40 97#0.

N921%! %!,91 ( /!92&415 +)79& A)&+'&12-!/)!+ ! +'1)!4!92!4 0#&@2!4 /)!/!-79!-1:2&&, '! %1$9.> )71,&)07' /!:)132!40. B7%!:'!).7 /!#2!+'*5 /!997)$&-15' /!9A!9 «+47:#!,!» /)!/!-79!-12&( 21 0#&87 & /)!-!3,#1:C72&7 R!$*7,! H#!-1, 9)0,&7 $7 A)&+'&127-.)1$15' +-!7 27+!,#1+&7. N2& ,!-!)(', @'!E'!' 47'!9 +#&C%!4 «0+'1)7#» & 27 ELL7%'&:-72, -7)!('2!, /!#1,1(, @'! 7+#& #59& 27 /)&:2&415' +/1+72&7 - /('2&80&/&#& 27 A!9(' - 87)%!-* /!-!+%)7+72*(4, '! /!9!"2.>/!9A!9 27#*3( 213-1'* )730#*:'1'&-2.4. B7+4!')( 21 '!, @'!+067+'-07' 42!$7+'-! +/!+!:"!- «+97#1'*+( -+74 9#( -+7A»(1 D!)&2L(214 9:22), /)!/!-7:9!-12&7 21 0#&87 &477' !/)7:97#722.7 /)7&4067+'-1, /!+:%!#*%0 917' /)7%)1+205 -!3:4!$2!+'* +#0C1'* & !"61'*+( + #59*4&. D09&-#72&5 27%!'!).A #597> - 87)%-&, 9041:56&A, @'! 27A)&+'&127 27 #5"(' ,!-!)&'* 21«)7#&,&!32.7 '74.», 42!,&7 /)!A!$&7 21 +1:4!4 97#7 94("2(4<2 ",H3 )H"$%<2.$ .$+*-)%&.$, %!,91 &A +/)1C&-15' ! R!,7, R&"#&&,)7#&,&& & 9)0,&A -761A.

E,)%&.)3 4%!Q)T!#!97$* /!+'!(22! !"+0$917' '740 E-!:

#58&&. B7+4!')( 21 '!, @'! E'! 27 79&2+'-7221(-!32&%1561( - 4!#!97$2.A %)0,1A '741, !21 !":+0$917'+( @167 -+7,!, & 4!#!9.4 #59(4 2)1:-&'+( ,!-!)&'* !" E'!4. G!@740? G)!+'! /!'!40,@'! E'! '!, @740 !2& ".#& 210@72., & '!, -! @'!!2& -7)('. ;!34!$2! '1%$7, @'! E'! +14.>«09!"2.>» +/!+!" 9#( «4!#!9.A» ,)7C2&%!-!+!32122! !'-7),1'* R!,1, '74 +14.4 !/)1-9.:-1( +-!> !")13 $&32&.

N921$9. 0 472( +!+'!(#+( )13,!-!) + !92&49-1981'&#7'2&4 /1)274. N2 ,!)9! 31(-&# 427,@'! (-#(7'+( @#72!4 )!%:,)0//. & -!!"67 27 -7:)&' - R!,1. N2 +@&'1#, @'! R!, 27 &,)17' - 7,!$&32& -1$2!> )!#&. O!,91 ( +/)!+&# 7,!, -7)&'#& !2 - E-!#58&5. N2 !'-7'&# «91», /!+4!')7-21 472( '1%, +#!-2! ( 3191# 740 %1%!>:'! %1-7)3:2.> -!/)!+. D!,91 ( 1),0472'&)!-12! )1++%131#740 !" !'+0'+'-&& "7++/!)2.A +-&97'7#*+'-E-!#58&&, !2 ".# C!%&)!-12!

H /!9!"2!> )71%8&7> ( - +-!7> $&32& -+')7:@1#+( 42!,! )13. = H$%&U!."2(, "($,- "$(+,*-,..)3 -$%$1,0& #+$"2$ #+$7%)2/(),2 :($*%<Q!$..4< %$0&. T!> !/.' /!%13.-17', @'!)13,!-!). ! G1+A1#*2!4 /!+#12&& 4!,0' 3-0@1'*/)&-#7%1'7#*2!, 2! 27 &47'* "!#*C!,! 321@72&(9#( #597>, $&-06&A - %0#*'0)7, /)!/&'122!> ,0:412&34!4.

N921$9., %!,91 4. + %!4129!> 31%!2@&#&)1"!'0, ( C7# /! 0#&87 - +'!)!2047')!. T!7 -2&412&7 /)&-#7%#&9-!7 4!#!9.A #597> (&3 &A )13,!:-!)1 ( /!2(#, @'! !2& +'0972'.02&-7)+&'7'1). N92!40 &3 2&A (-)0@&# ")!C5)0 & -7$#&-! 21@1#3191-1'* -!/)!+.. N2& !"1 +@&'1:#&, @'! -7)1 - R!,1 (-#(7'+( #&@:2!> &977> @7#!-7%1, & N2 27 &47:7' !'2!C72&( % )71#*2!> $&32&.O1%!7 4272&7 (-#(7'+( 27/!+)79:

+'-722.4 )730#*'1'!4 E-!#58&!22!,! 4&)!-!:33)72&(, +!,#1+2! %!'!)!40 27 +067+'-07' .!*>)>$7$ 148$(.$7$ -!+) — '! 7+'*, E'! /)!+'!«/#!9 -!!")1$72&(».

R73 +!4272&(, E'& 4!#!9.7 #59& ".#& 1":+!#5'2! 0"7$972., @'! E-!#58&( !"Y(+2(7'/)!&+A!$972&7 -+7,! $&-!,!. N2& /!/1#&+* 21

09!@%0 !"4121 ! '!4, @'! #7'!/&+* !%14727#!+:'7> +!97)$&' !,)!42!7 %!#&@7+'-! +-&97:'7#*+'- E-!#58&&. V /)&-7# &427%!'!).7 [email protected] 9122.7, ! %!:'!).A +!!"617'+( - $0)21#7«H!'-!)72&7» & 21 F2'7)27':+1>:'7 47$9021)!92!,! %)718&!22!:,! +#0$72&(. H'0972'!- 31&2'7:)7+!-1#1 E'1 &2L!)418&(, &-+%!)7 4. 0$7 !"+0$91#& )13:#&@2.7 -!/)!+. — !' 1"+!#5':2!> &+'&2. 9! 1#*'7)21'&-2!,!!")131 $&32&.

M97 7+'* -7)1 - E-!#58&5, '1427' 2&%1%!,! #!,&@7+%!,! !+2!-1:2&( 9#( 1"+!#5'2!> &+'&2.. V ,!:-!)5 «#!,&@7+%!,!», /!'!40 @'!27%!'!).7 #59& 27 )1397#(5'0@72&( !" E-!#58&& & -7). - R!,1. O1%1( '!@%13)72&( /!/0#()21 +)79& '7A @#72!- '7#1 U)&+'!:-1, %!'!).7 /.'15'+( 097)$&-1'* +#1".> "1:#12+ 47$90 R!,!4, R&"#&7> & E-!#58&7>. G!:

9!"21( +&+'741 -3,#(9!- 213.-17'+( «'7&+'&:@7+%!> E-!#58&7>», @'! (-#(7'+( 1"+!#5'2! 27:#!,&@2.4.

=2$+$"2,#,../; ($#+$":«A4, 1), >$.,9.$!»F -+7:'1%& ( !@72* @1+'! +#.C0 !' ")1'*7- -

87)%-&, @'! -!/)!+ +!'-!)72&(/E-!#58&& 27 (-:#(7'+( +'!#* -1$2.4 & 321@&4.4, & @'! E'! '!#*:%! «!'/0,&-17' #597> & 0-!9&' !' A)&+'&12+'-1».A$ 9%,./ -$,; >$-).1/, >)> ! 3, ., "$7%)"./" :2!-. N/&)1(+* 21 +!"+'-722.> !/.', 4. 0':

-7)$9174 !")1'2!7. B7%!'!).7 /)!A!$&7 27'!#*%! !+'121-#&-15'+( /!,!-!)&'* + 214&, 2!

91$7, !'#!$&- -+7 +-!& /#12. 21-7@7), !+'15'+(, @'!". /!!":61'*+( /!9!#*C7.

O1%, 27+4!')( 21 /!')1@72:2.7 3+6$+4& /&(& & 9-1 /)!/0:6722.A 1-'!"0+1, +'0972'. &302&-7)+&'7'1, ! %!'!).A ( )1+:+%13.-1# -.C7, /!"#1,!91)&#&472( 31 &2'7)7+205 "7+790. G!:9!"2.7 +#!-1 "#1,!91)2!+'& 4.@1+'! +#.C&4 - /('2&@2.7 -7@7:)1 21 0#&87. T!#!9.4 #59(42)1-&'+(, %!,91 &A +#0C15', !2&#5"(' -.+%13.-1'*+( ! «-1$2.A$&32722.A -!/)!+1A» & !"+0$:91'* &A + 9)0,&4& #59*4&. F472:

2! /!E'!40 +'0972'. !+'121-#&-15'+( & )13,!:-1)&-15' + 214& 21 '74., %!'!).7, /! 4272&5"!#*C&2+'-1 @#72!- 87)%-&, +@&'15'+( «27-1$2.4&» 9#( +/1+72&(. D!,91 4!#!9.7 #59&/!#0@15' !'-7'. 21 &2'7)7+056&7 &A «-1$2.7-!/)!+.», !2& 21@&215' 31904.-1'*+( ! 4&)!:-!33)72&& & #!,&%7 A)&+'&12+%!> -7).. H)130, -'!' $7 -7@7), !2& 4!,0' & 27 /!-7)&'* - S-12,7:#&7, 2! %!,91 A)&+'&127 21@&215' )13)0C1'*1'7&+'&@7+%&7 '-7)9.2& (2 D!)&2L(214 10:5),/)!(-#(( /)& E'!4 9!")!'0 & 0-1$72&7 (1 G7')13:15), !2&, 27+!42722!, +75' +74721 &+'&2. -041A 4!#!9.A #597>!

R+,)Q!$../; ,().7,%!'- — E'! /)7%)1+:2.> &2+')0472', &971#*2! +!,#1+056&>+( +7-12,7#*+%&4 /!+#12&74. T1'7)&1#., %!'!).7( &+/!#*305, 4!$2! 21>'& - $0)21#7 «P+$"+4#H%0#» & 21 F2'7)27':+1>'7 47$9021)!92!,! %)7:18&!22!,! +#0$72&(. ;#1972&7 27!"A!9&4!>&2L!)418&7> & +/!+!"2!+'* !'-7'&'* 21 !+:2!-2.7 -!/)!+. — E'! 4!621( +')1'7,&( 9#(7-12,7#&318&& +!-)74722!> 4!#!97$&. G)&:@&2!> 27!")1672&( #597> % R!,0, (-#(7'+( /!:/.'%1 0"79&'* &A «/)!+'! -7)&'* - F&+0+1», 27+@&'1(+* + /)79/!#1,174.4& 9!%131'7#*+'-1:4& E-!#58&&. V $7 27 $90, @'! 4!#!9!> 04 "0:97' /.'1'*+( 91'* #!,&@7+%!7 !"Y(+272&7 /)!:'&-!)7@&5.

?-!#58&!22!7 4.C#72&7, %!'!).4 "0%:-1#*2! /)!/&'12! +!-)74722!7 !"67+'-!, +0:67+'-722! 0+#!$2(7' 7-12,7#&318&!2205 )1:"!'0. I7+'*97+(' #7' 21319 /)!/!-792&%0 210#&87 27 20$2! ".#! "!)!'*+( + /)7/('+'-&(:4&, %!'!).7 -+'15' 21 /0'& % S-12,7#&5 +7,!9:2(. ?'! & E-!#58&!22.> /!9A!9 % &++#79!-1:2&5 !">$#),-/8, -,2$1 1)2!+$().!3 #$ 47*%,+$14, #+$!"8$01,.!, .)+$1$(, 1!.$')(*+/ & !"Y(+272&7 &A +067+'-!-12&( 4&##&!2.#7' 21319.

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«;. -7)&'7 - &+'!)&5 /)! J9141 & S-0?».<722& !@72* A!'7# 0321'* "!#*C7.

G!+#7 '!,!, %1% ( !'-7'&# 21 7,! -!/)!+, !23191# +#79056&>: «Z'! -. 90417'7 ! )132.A #5:9(A?» (!2 &47# - -&90 /)!&+A!$972&7 )132.A 21:)!9!-). ;27C27 /1)72* /.'1#+( +!A)12('* +/!:%!>+'-&7, 2! ".#! -&92!, @'! 2!-1( &2L!)418&(+&#*2! /!-#&(#1 21 27,!. V /!@0-+'-!-1#, %1%7,! !A-1'&#! @0-+'-! )19!+'& & -!#272&( !' '!:,!, @'! !2 '7/7)* +2!-1 4!, -7)&'* - R!,1. N2+%131#: «;. 91#& !"Y(+272&(, %!'!).7 /!4!,0'427 !'")!+&'* -+7 +!4272&(».

V 91# <722& $0)21# «P+$"+4#%0#» & /!+!-7:'!-1# /!+#7 /)!@'72&( 91'* 7,! +-!7> +7+')7,/!'!40 @'!, /! +#!-14 <722&, «!21 "!#*C7 27A)&+'&12%1, 1 1'7&+'%1». D 4!740 09&-#72&5, !2!"2(# 472(, 1 /!'!4 /!C7# 21 !+'12!-%0.

D!27@2!, 21 0#&87 &#& 21 )1"!'7 27%!'!).74!& +#0C1'7#& 4!,0' @0-+'-!-1'* +7"( 27%!4:L!)'2! &3:31 '!,!, @'! ( )1++%13.-15, 2! 7+#&-. %1% -7)056&> - S-12,7#&7 @7#!-7% ,!'!-. !':-7'&'* 21 &A -!/)!+., -14 "097' #7,%! +/)1-&'*:+( + #5".4& -!3)1$72&(4& +! +'!)!2. '7A #5:97>, %!'!).4 -. +-&97'7#*+'-07'7.

J %!,91 -. 0-&9&'7, %1%!7 /!#!$&'7#*2!7-#&(2&7 !%13.-15' -1C& !'-7'. 21 #597>, /!>:47'7 — E'! +'!(677 97#!. R!, "#1,!

E)"",% T?KKGVwww.creation.com

?MFY=Y ]DMBMGKG@

6-%4"5; &'$&$#()"%3 ?$#$'%,, 4,$ !$,#$'("%(«2#-2(,!2 $4("/ #*."51 #$&'$!$1»

>&6- U.6*($ ,.6.8:-:+ $/'&6$6&(-:+ (&,6&8#, '- *&:&6#. %=;$ @&:<: ,&%01$:+ &:(.:#

N&%&;#. %=;$%=2<:, *&/;- $@8%0)-=:, $ %=2<:6-8804;-:+ &«(-4'#@4$?'.''#@(&,6&8-@»

T%-;.'$.'.&2@&;$"&3$'5&6"-7$.3 $8,&8&2'&8:+&:(.:$:+ '-&8'&('#. (&,6&8#— "&D'-<8:6-:./$< ;%<2%-/&(.8:$<8&(6.".''#""&%&;#" %=;<"

REGB^D?AA?G IKBW?=GVMDG AB LEBRMDRG


«47)7/ +!42&'7#*2!,! @7#!-7@7+%!,!/)79%1, ! %!'!)!4 -/7)-.7 31(-&# K&:@1)9 =&%& - 1972 ,., ".# /#!A!> )7%!2:

+')0%8&7>», — 31(-&# /1#7!12')!/!#!, O&4!'&R)!47>9$ &3 02&-7)+&'7'1 B*5:[!)%1, +/78&1:#&3&)056&>+( 21 @7)7/2!:#&87-!> "&!#!,&&.

G! 4272&5 0@72!,!, -! -)74( +!"&)12&( %!+:'7> 9#( +-!7,! «Z7)7/1 1470» =&%& &+/!#*3!-1#27+'1291)'2.7 /)&28&/., - )730#*'1'7 @7,! #&8!/)&!")7#! "!#77 )!-2.> @7#!-7@7+%&> -&9. T2!:,&7 [email protected], 0321- !" !'%).'&& =&%&, ".#& /!')(:+72. '74, @'! E'! @7#!-7%!/!9!":2!7 #&8! 91'&)!-1#!+* 3 4&##&!:214& #7'. (?'!' -!3)1+' /!39277".# /7)7+4!')72 & &347272 211,9 4#2 #7'. ;/!+#79+'-&& @7)7/0".#! 912! 213-12&7 Homorudolfensis, & 7,! +'1#& +@&'1'*/)(4.4 /)79%!4 Homo sapiens.)

K0%!-!9+'-0(+* /)1-&#14&,+!,#1+2! %!'!).4 ,#131, 0C& &)!' 4#7%!/&'156&A 9!#$2. ".'*27/!+)79+'-722! +-(312. 9)0, +9)0,!4, 9!%'!) R)!47>9$ +97#1#+!"+'-72205 )7%!2+')0%8&5 &!"21)0$&#, @'! @7)7/ =&%& «"!#*:C7 /!A!$ 21 !"73*(2&> @7)7/».

; )7%!2+')0%8&&, +97#122!> + /!4!6*5%!4/*5'7)2!> /)!,)144., )1347) 4!3,1 !%1:31#+( 472*C7 /!#!-&2. )1347)1 4!3,1 +!-)7:4722!,! @7#!-7%1. G! 4272&5 R)!47>9$1, +%!):)7%'&)!-122.> @7)7/ &477' «41!(!2,%&.$ -)*%,.&>!; -$'7 & !'@7'#&-! -.+'0/15605 @7:#5+'* — ).)2$-!9,">!, $"$H,..$"2!, "($;*"2(,../, $H,'&3.)- +747>+'-1 -.+C&A /)&:

41'!-, %!'!).7 $&#& "!#77 ')7A 4&##&!2!- #7'21319».

R)!47>9$ ,!-!)&', @'! /7)-!21@1#*21( )7%!:2+')0%8&( +')!&#1+* &+%#5@&'7#*2! 21 ')+).,,"P$+-!+$()..$- /)79+'1-#72&& ! '!4, %1%-.,#(97#& 1+,(.!, %<1! — 4272&7, %!'!)!7,%1% 0$7 +7,!92( &3-7+'2!, +!-7)C722! 27-7)2!7.; )730#*'1'7 ".# /!#0@72 @7)7/, %!'!).> !"#1:91# 27%!'!).4& !"6&4& A1)1%'7)2.4& !+!"72:2!+'(4&, %!'!).7 +-!>+'-722. +!-)74722.4 #5:9(4, -%#5@1( $2.$"!2,%&.$ #%$">$, %!Q$ !

H$%&U4< 9,+,#.4< >$+$H>4.G! 7,! +#!-14, !2 & 7,! %!412:

91 &+/!#*3!-1#& 9#( )7%!2+')0%:8&& "&!#!,&@7+%&7 /)&28&/., %!:'!).7 27 ".#& 767 &3-7+'2., %!,:91 ".# !"21)0$72 @7)7/, +!,#1+2!%!'!).4 ,#131, 0C& & )!' 4#7%!:/&'156&A 9!#$2. 21A!9&'*+( -'!@2!4 -31&42!4 )1+/!#!$72&&/! !'2!C72&5 9)0, % 9)0,0.

B1/)&47), ,!-!)&' R)!47>9$,-!3*4&'7 #5"!7 4#7%!/&'15677$&-!'2!7 & 21)&+0>'7 -!!")1$17:405 #&2&5 !' %)1>27,! "!#*C!,!%!)722!,! 30"1 - 7,! @7#5+'& %0C2!40 !'-7)+'&5 & % 872')0 ,#13:

2!> -/19&2.. Q,!# E'!> #&2&& 9!#$72 +!+'1-:#('* /)&47)2! 45 ,)190+!-.

«; /7)-!21@1#*2!> )7%!2+')0%8&& @7)7/1«KNM:ER 1470», E'!' 0,!# +!+'1-#(# /)&47)2! 60— 75 ,)190+!-», — ,!-!)&' R)!47>9$. N2 '1%$7!'47@17', @'!: «O1%!> 0,!# +!-7)C722! 27+!-47+:'&4 + $&32*5. Z7#5+'* )1+/!#1,1#1+* ". 21+'!#*:%! ,#0"!%! - @7)7/7, @'! - 274 27 !+'1#!+* ". 47+:

'1 9#( 9.A1'7#*2!,! /0'& &#&/&67-!91. Z7#!-7% + '1%&4 @7:)7/!4 /)!+'! 27 4!, ". 9.C1'*&#& 7+'*».

<!%'!) R)!47>9$ !+09&#&3-7+'2!,! /1#7!12')!/!#!,1,+@&'1(, @'! «9!%'!) =&%& +!3:91# .,$H_,>2!(.4< +,>$.*"2+4>Q!<, !+2!-.-1(+* .)%$0./8 #+,1('32/8 #+,1#$*%$0,.!38 ! '!4, %1% 9!#$72-.,#(97'* 9)7-2&> @7#!-7%,@'! /)!'&-!)7@&' !+2!-2.4/)&28&/14 L!)4&)!-12&( @7:)7/2!:#&87-.A %!+'7>... ;!+:+!391221( 4!97#* 9!%'!)1 =&:%& 27 4!,#1 ". +067+'-!-1'* -)71#*2!> $&32&».

D1% ,!-!)&'+( - +'1'*7,/!9!"2!7 #!$2!7 '!#%!-12&7@7)7/1 ".#! «)1+/)!+')1272!-/#!'* 9! +7,!92(C27,! 92(».

www.crev.info EurekAlert.

<! %1%&A /!) E'! "097'/)!9!#$1'*+( - +!42&'7#*2!>/)1%'&%7 /1#7!12')!/!#!,&&?H%!#*%! 21 +7,!92( 767 21>:97'+( /)&47)!-, !+2!-122.A21 #&@2!4 /)790"7$972&&?G)1-91 ! «Z7)7/7 1470» ".#1)1+%).'1 #&C* 25 #7' +/0+'(/!+#7 E'!,! «!'%).'&(». G!4:2&'7 !" E'!4, %!,91 [email protected] !/('* "090' 97#1'*,)!4%&7 31(-#72&( !" !@7)792!4 !'+0'+'-05:

674 3-727. H!-)74722.7 97'& +4!,0' 0321'* !'!4, @'! E'! /!997#%1, 27 )12*C7 2034 ,!91.


C& 40(.%1# ""#4). 3+1&:&%& 3#4"+%&/&69%&' 4#1+%($4.1?0', (8#6&%H%&' N0/&48+* O010 0 84.@0*0 ./#%-*0 " 1970H-) @+8&) 3+8 %&:"&%0H#* KNMHER 1470.2%0:.: (8#6&%%&' ( 3+*+B9; 1+*39;$#4& 4#1+%($4.1?0' M0*+$0 J4+H*#785&, %& 1+$+4+7 3+1&:&% $+$ 5# (&*-7 /#4#3 ( :&*#$%+ "-($.3&;B#7"3#4#8 /#6;($9;. V#6#%-# 0 14&(%-# 60%00 +,+:%&/&;$ 4&(3+6+5#%0#@6&:, .=#7 0 4$&, 1+$+4-# 8+65%- %&)+80$9(' " $+/%+* ":&0*%+* 4&(3+H6+5#%00 3+ +$%+=#%0; 84.@ 1 84.@. . "(#) *6#1+30$&;B0). T"$+4 0 34&H"&: M0*+$0 J4+*#785, http://www.nyu.edu/dental/index.php2 %+"+7 4#1+%($4.1?00, (8#6&%%+7 ( 3+*+B9; 1+*39;$#4%+7 34+@H4&**-, 4&:*#4 /#4#3& +1&:&6(' *#%9=# 3+6+"0%- 4&:*#4& *+:@&(+"4#*#%%+@+ /#6+"#1& 0 0*##$ +$/#$60"+ "-($.3&;B.; /#6;($9 —&%&$+*0/#(10# +(+,#%%+($0, ("+7($"#%%-# +,#:9'%&* (#*#7($"&"-(=0) 340*&$+".

%=#(!,"5; *",'$&$-$? -%3% 1*"%&6-%'$#*- $:(=/2"/%1«4('(&$1 1470», 4,$:5 &'%)*,/ (16 4(-$#(4(!3%; #%)

&!+#7 /0"#&%18&& 21C7> +'1'*& !" 1'7:&347 (creation.com/atheism) 214 21/&:+1# ".-C&> 1'7&+' & )1++%131#, %1% !2

/)&C7# % U)&+'0. B&$7 4. /)&#1,174 E#7%')!2:2!7 /&+*4!, /!#0@722!7 - '! $7 -)74(, - %!'!)!4)1++%13.-17'+( ! 4!#!9!4 @7#!-7%7, %!'!).>, %+!$1#72&5, /!%!2@&# $&32* +14!0"&>+'-!4.

«Q-1$174!7 T7$9021)!92!7%)718&!22!7 +#0$72&7, ( 27 4!,0-.)13&'* +#!-14& 4!5 "#1,!:91)2!+'*. V +'1# A)&+'&12&2!4')& ,!91 21319 /!+#7 '!,!, %1%-+#79+'-&7 4!&A 1'7&+'&@7+%&A-3,#(9!-, 9!#,! "!)!#+( + 4.+:#(4& ! +14!0"&>+'-7.

;1C7 +#0$72&7 97>+'-&'7#*:2! +/1+#! 427 $&32*.

V -.)!+ - 27-7)0567> +74*7& + 97'+'-1 ".# !%)0$72 1'7&+'&:@7+%!> /)!/1,129!>, %!'!)05+#.C1# - C%!#7 & +)79+'-1A41++!-!> &2L!)418&&. B7 09&-&'7#*2!, @'! --!3)1+'7 12 #7' ( +'1# 1'7&+'!4.

G! 47)7 '!,!, %1% C#& ,!9., ( &+%)7227 /.:'1#+( /!2('* 4&) -!%)0, +7"( & !921$9. !'%).#U$>!+4<54< !"2!.4, %!'!)05 !' 472( +%).-1:#& '1% $7, %1% & !' 9)0,&A #597>.

F4722! /!E'!40 ( /&C0 E'! /&+*4!, '1% %1%91$7 - -1C&A 3147@1'7#*2.A +'1'*(A !" 1'7&347-. 27 )1+%).-17'7 9! %!281 41+C'1". '!> "739:2., %!'!)!> 9!+'&,15' 1'7&+'.,!"412.-1( -+7A, & /)7$97 -+7,!+14&A +7"(.

J'7&+'. @1+'! 31(-#(5', @'!!2& 4!,0' $&'* +@1+'#&-!>, 21:/!#2722!> $&32*5. F, '74 27 47:277, E'! #!$*, !"412, %!'!).>+'1# /)!%#('&74 9#( 4&##&!2!-@7#!-7@7+%&A 90C, --79( &A -31"#0$972&7.

;. 42!,!7 !"+0$917'7 - +-!:&A +'1'*(A, 2!, % +!$1#72&5, 27 0+')12&#& +14%!)72* /)!"#74. — 1'7&34 )13)0C17' -!34!$:2!+'* +14!&972'&@2!+'&, -."!)1, 1 '1%$7 !"Y:

7%'&-2!,! & +0"Y7%'&-2!,! +4.+#1.J'7&34 27!'-)1'&4! -797' % 21'0)1#&340, 1

'!', - +-!5 !@7)79*, — % ,19%!> '1>27, %!'!)057,! /!+#79!-1'7#& /.'15'+( +%).-1'*, — > 1,*2,+-!.!'-4.

6,2,+-!.!'- .,!'H,0,., 7+#& @7#!-7%(-#(7'+( 21'0)1#&+'!4 & -7)&' - '!, @'! -+7 +0:

677 41'7)&1#*2! & /)!&3!C#! -)730#*'1'7 &+%#5@&'7#*2! /)&:)!92.A /)!87++!-.

?'! !321@17', @'! @7#!-7@7+:%&> )1304 — 21C7 +14!7 "!#*C!7+!%)!-&67 — +-!9&'+( #&C* % 41:'7)&1#*2!40, %!'!)!7 !+2!-.-1:7'+( 21 L&3&@7+%&A 31%!21A, 1&4722!: 21C& 4.+#&, @0-+'-1 &97>+'-&( (-#(5'+( #&C* +,'4%&*2)2$- +,)>Q!; 8!-!9,">!8 (,*5,"2( - 4!3,0.

B! #&C* 27%!'!).7 #59& /!2&:415': 2)>$; ('7%31 +)'+4U),2

(", 2$, 92$ 1,%),2 .)" %<1&-!.S+#& 21C& 4.+:#&, @0-+'-1 & 97>+'-&( — /)!+'! )730#*'1' A&4&:@7+%&A )71%8&> - 4!3,0, '! E'& )71%8&& (-#(5'+(-+7,! #&C* /!"[email protected] /)!90%'!4 /)79.906&A )7:1%8&>, !")13056&A 27/)7).-205 87/*, %!'!)1(-797' % +14!40 21@1#0 21C7> ;+7#722!>.

F '!,91 E'! !321@17', @'! ". 4. 27 97#1#&,4. 97#174 E'! /!'!40, @'! 4. 9!#$2. E'! 97:#1'*. T. 27 4!$74 97#1'* @7,!:#&"!, /!4&4!

'!,!, @'! 4. 97#174, '1% %1% E'!/)!+'! 27-!34!$2!.

;+7 /)!&3-!9&4.7 97>+'-&((-#(5'+( )730#*'1'!4 /)79.90:6&A 97>+'-&> - 27/)7).-2!> 87:/&. T. 2&@74 27 !'#&@174+( !'30"*7- %!#7+1 - @1+!-!4 47A12&3:47 &#& /191567,! 9!4&2!.

B7' 2&%1%!> )132&8. 47$90!"Y('&(4& #5"(67,! 40$1 & $7+:'!%!+'*5 0$1+2!,! 21+&#*2&%1,

47$90 97>+'-&(4& -)1@1, +/1+1567,! $&32&#597>, & +7)&>2.4 0"&>87>, %!'!).> #5"&'0"&-1'* &A, 47$90 97>+'-&(4& -7#&%&A #&97)!-

& "7397>+'-&74 #72&-.A "7397#*2&%!-. ; )14:%1A 1'7&341 -+7 E'& 97>+'-&( 2&@74 27 !'#&@1:5'+(.

N"Y7%'&-2!,! +4.+#1 27 +067+'-07', 1 +0"Y:7%'&-2.> +4.+# 27/!+#79!-1'7#72! B70$7#&97>+'-&( )!"!'1, %!'!).> 31/!#2(7' +'7%#(2:2.7 %!#"., &475' %1%!>:#&"! +4.+#, -1$2!+'*&#& 321@&4!+'*? D!27@2! $7, 27'! N2 /)!+'! 97:#17' '!, @'! 9!#$72 97#1'*! N2 27 4!$7' 97#1'*2&@7,! 9)0,!,!!

Z'! 4!$7' &47'* - -&90 1'7&+', %!,91 ,!-!:)&', @'! !2 97>+'-&'7#*2! +067+'-07' %1% #&@:2!+'*? T1'7)&1#, &3 %!'!)!,! +!+'!&' 21C7 '7:#!, /!-'!)2! /7)7)1"1'.-17'+( & 31472(7'+(

%1$9.7 +74* #7', & 21C7 +!3212&7 !+'121-#&-1:7'+(, %1$7'+(, %1$9.> )13, %!,91 4. &974 +/1'*.O1% - %1%!4 $7 +4.+#7 '1 41++1 41'7)&&, @'!/)!+./17'+( 0')!4, 7+'* '!> $7 #&@2!+'*, %!'!:)1( /!C#1 +/1'* -7@7)!4?

J"+!#5'2! !@7-&92!, @'! 1'7&34 @)73-.@1>:2! !/1+72 & 0$1+72! D +!$1#72&5, "!#*C&2+'-!1'7&+'!- 27 3215' !"! -+74 E'!4! V 90415, 7+#&". !2& 97>+'-&'7#*2! /!2&41#& /!+#79+'-&('!,!, -! @'! !2& -7)(', !2& /7)7+4!')7#& ".+-!& -3,#(9..

V 3215, @'! +97#1# &4722! '1%.G0+'* R!, "#1,!+#!-&' -1+».

60)"2!. V., PWT

*,(%!,, !,$2>%; "* ?'*"% !*1$6:%;!,#*, $:'*,%-!2 3 9'%!,6V=D6GMGKNVM=?

J:.$?" 6-?60)-.:(&?"&4'&8:+

8-"&$;.':$1'&8:$,(#2&6-, - :-*4.&29.*:$('&/& $8029.*:$('&/&

8"#8%-

>& ".6. :&/&, *-*)%$ /&;#, < $8*6.''.,#:-%8< ,&'<:+"$6 (&*60/ 8.2< $&;'-4;# &:*6#%)&*$60=D0=

$8:$'0, *&:&60= &:".'< 8*6#(-%$ :-*4., *-* $ &: ;60/$@

%=;.3.

C*&66.*:$6&(-''#31.6., $"..:

«0;$($:.%+'&"-%.'+*$3 "&?/ $

&:1.:%$(&(#8:0,-=D0=1.%=8:+ —

-'-:&"$1.8*$.&8&2.''&8:$,8(&38:(.''#.&2.?+<'-".

M+)7!9,">!; +,'4%&2)2G)&47)2! - '! $7 -)74(, %!,91 4. /!#0@&:

#& -.C7&3#!$722!7 /&+*4!, % 214 /)&C#!767 !92! ')!,1'7#*2!7 /&+*4! !' $726&2.,/!/)!+&-C7> 27 213.-1'* 77 &472&. ; /&+*47,!-!)&#!+* ! 2791-274 )71#*2!4 /)!&+C7+':-&&: 16:#7'2&> 52!C1, + %!'!).4 !21 ".#1321%!41 & %!'!)!,! !21 213-1#1 O!4, 27 0/!:4&21( 7,! 21+'!(67,! &472&, /!%!2@&# $&32*+14!0"&>+'-!4. ?'1 $726&21 21/&+1#1 (9#(/)!(+272&( '!,!, @'! +#0@&#!+*):

«O!4 04.C#722! C1,20# 21 /)!73$05@1+'* /!9 %!#7+1 ,)03!-&%1. B7 42!,&7 321#&!" E'!4. B7319!#,! 9! E'!,! !2 21/&+1# /&+*:4! ! '!4, @'! @0-+'-!-1#. T27 27&3-7+'2. -+7/!9)!"2!+'&. V 27 A!'7#1 )1++/)1C&-1'* 7,!4140; !21 ".#1 '1% +#1"1 - '!' 4!472'. N921:%! 427 &3-7+'2!, @'! !2 /&+1# ! "7++4.+#72:2!+'& $&32&: «; @74 +4.+# $&32&? K13-7$&32* 27 9!#$21 ".'* @74:'! "!#*C&4, @74/)!+'! "!)*"1, +!/7)2&@7+'-! & 972*,&?».O!4 27 ".# A)&+'&12&2!4 &, %!27@2! $7, -!+:/&'.-1#+( - /!#2!4 E-!#58&!22!4 !%)0$7:2&& — %1% 9!41, '1% & - C%!#7».

?'& /&+*41 21/!42&#& 427 -+7 '7 +'1'*&47$9021)!92!,! %)718&!22!,! +#0$72&(, %!:'!).7 ( @&'1#, & '7 )13,!-!)., %!'!).7 +#.:C1# !" E-!#58&&. V /!2(#, %1%!7 -#&(2&7 E'!!%13.-17' 21 $&32& 42!,&A 4!#!9.A #597>.

R73 1"+!#5'2!> &+'&2. S-12,7#&(, /7)-!21:@1#*2! /)7%)1+2!,! 4&)1, )13)0C722!,! ,)7:A!4, 2! !$&91567,! -!3)!$972&( @7)73 U)&+:'1, -+7 /)7-)1617'+( - «+/#!C205 "!#*, /!+#7%!'!)!> +#7907' +47)'*». O1% @'! 7+#& -1+ /7:)7/!#2(7' @0-+'-! "732197$2!+'& & !'@1(2&(,& 7+#& -. -7)&'7, @'! @7#!-7% — E'! 27 "!#77@74 %!4!% &#1 - /)090, +14!0"&>+'-! 4!$7'/!%131'*+( 21&"!#77 )13042.4 -.A!9!4.

R)1% )!9&'7#7> O!41 )13)0C&#+(. N2 $&#+! +-!&4 !'8!4, 91#7%! !' 41'7)&.

?'! 31+'1-&#! 472( 319041'*+( ! 4&++&&%)718&!22!,! 47$9021)!92!,! +#0$72&(. S+:#& E'!' 4&) +!'-!)72 R!,!4, '! N2, +!391- 21+,#5"&' & 31"!'&'+( ! %1$9!4 &3 21+ '1% +&#*2!,@'! 31/#1'&# 31 E'! 0$1+205 8720. B1C& ,)7A&4!,0' ".'* /)!672., & 4. 4!$74 -!3#!$&'*-+7 +-!& 31"!'. 21 B7,!, %1% N2 & ,!-!)&'. N9:21%! 7+#& 4. $&-74 - 21'0)1#&+'&@7+%!4, E-!:#58&!2&)!-1-C74 4&)7, ,97 -+7 /!$&)15'9)0, 9)0,1, '!,91 - @74 +4.+# $&32&?

V 90415, E'!' 4!#!9!> @7#!-7% /)&C7# %31%#5@72&5, @'! +47)'* "!#77 /)&-#7%1'7#*:21, @74 /0+'!7 "73"!$2!7 +067+'-!-12&7 -4&)7, ,97 81)&' /)1-&#!: %'! 27 0+/7#, '!'!/!391#.

B! '7/7)* +#&C%!4 /!392! ,!-!)&'* + 2&4! #5"(6&A, /)!6156&A & 31"!'#&-.A )0%1AF&+0+1!»


$/)797#72&7 /)!/1,129.: =5"1( /!/.':%1 /!-#&('* 21 97>+'-&( &#& 2147)72&(#597>, 27 31+'1-#(( &A /)& E'!4 9041'*.

I$%&U)3 %$0&N/)797#72&7: J"+!#5'21( #!$*, )1++%131221( +21/0+%2!> 0-7)722!+'*5 & ")1-19!>.G!/0#()21( L)131: B7%!'!).A #597> 4!$2! !":412.-1'* /!+'!(22!...L+!-,+/:•;.+'0/#72&( M&'#7)1 & H'1#&21.•«Q"7>'7 +7"( - +-(6722!> -!>27, 31A-1'&- ++!"!> %1% 4!$2! "!#*C7 27-&22.A #597> -'!),!-!4 872')7, & -. /!#0@&'7 72 97-+'-72:2&8. 9#( -7@2!,! "#1$72+'-1».

•N"412 /! E#7%')!22!> /!@'7: 1L7)1 - B&,7)&&.•=72&2 213-1# +-!5 /1)'&5 «"!#*C7-&+'+%!>»

(!' +#!-1 «"!#*C&2+'-!»), %!,91 - 97>+'-&:'7#*2!+'& &A ".#! 472*C7.

•«<73&2L!)4&)056&7» %14/12&& DMR.•T1#72*%&> )7"72!%: «T141, R&##& 091)&# 47:2( - %0#1% +-!&4 $&-!'!4!».

•U&4&%:E-!#58&!2&+': «T&##&1)9. #7' 21319!%712. ".#& '7/#.4& & 31/!#2722.4& +')!&:'7#*2.4& "#!%14& $&32&».

•G1#7!12')!/!#!,: «G)&47)2! C7+'* 4&##&!:2!- #7' 21319 21C& /)79%& 4&,)&)!-1#& &3JL)&%& (& '.9., & './.)... G)&47)2! 30 000 #7'21319 271297)'1#*8. ".#& +!-+74 27 /!A!$&21 +!-)74722.A #597>, /)&9041-C&A &+%0+:+'-!, 210@&-C&A+( /!#*3!-1'*+( !,274 & &3,!:'1-#&-1'* !)09&( ')091, & -+7 "#1,!91)( +-!7>"!#77 -.+!%!> )13042!+'&...».

•«H)79& [email protected] 27' 2&%1%&A /)!'&-!)7@&> !'2!:+&'7#*2! E-!#58&&».

•G&#'9102+%&> @7#!-7%, 27")1++%&> @7#!-7%. •«R&!,727'&@7+%&> 31%!2» M7%%7#( & +L1")&%!:-122.7 )&+02%& E4")&!2!-.

•G!997#%1 1)A7!)1/'!)1.•<!"$12+%&>: «; "&!#!,&& -+7 &477' +4.+#'!#*%! - +-7'7 E-!#58&&».

;'!)!> /!+'0#1' O14"1: =7,%! /!2('21(, #7,%!-!+/)&2&41741( #!$* "!#77 ELL7%'&-21, @74+#!$21( & 27/!2('21( /)1-91.G)&'@& H!#!4!21: «T09)!+'* )13042!,! — 321:2&7 /0'& +-!7,!, ,#0/!+'* $7 "73)1++092.A —31"#0$972&7» (G)&'@& 14:8).

L$%4#+)(1)N/)797#72&7: Z1+'&@2! /)1-91, @1+'&@2! —#!$*; (9, /!%).'.> +1A1)!4. Z1+'! /!#0/)1-91"!#77 ELL7%'&-21, @74 "!#*C1( #!$*.G!/0#()21( L)131: G)1-91, '!#*%! /)1-91 & 2&:@7,!, %)!47 /)1-9..L+!-,+/:•G!#&''7A2!#!,&&.•;.)-1221( &3 %!2'7%+'1 8&'1'1. •O7#7-&3&!22.7 )791%8&!22.7 ')5%&: /!+#7&2'7)-*5 -+'1-#(5'+( +!-+74 27 '7 -!/)!+.,%!'!).7 3191-1#&+* ,!+'5.

•X16&'2&% 1"!)'!-: «\726&21 -/)1-7 +141)1+/!)($1'*+( +-!&4 +!"+'-722.4 '7#!4» (2!77 )7"72!% '!$7 &477' +-!7 +!"+'-722!7 '7#!,4!3,, +7)987, '&/ %)!-&, /!# & ,72., %!'!).721/!#!-&20 !2 /!#0@&# !' !'81).

•H47C&-12&7 /!2('&> «4&%)!E-!#58&(» (774!$2! 21"#591'*) & «41%)!E-!#58&(» (77 27:-!34!$2! 21"#591'*).

•N"21)0$722.7 &+%!/174.7 !+'12%& #!C197>:21 +14!4 97#7 27%!'!).7 &+%!/174.7 31#7,1:#& - 27/)1-&#*2!4 /!)(9%7 & $&#& 21 )132.A%!2'&272'1A.

•Q+'!>@&-.7 % 12'&"&!'&%14 "1%'7)&&: !921%!/)& E'!4 "1%'7)&& '7)(5' &2L!)418&5 &L02%8&5.

G)&'@& H!#!4!21: «M#0/.> -7)&' -+(%!40 +#!-0,"#1,!)13042.> $7 -2&41'7#72 % /0'(4 +-!&4»(G)&'@& 14:15).

L$(2$+,.!,N/)797#72&7: G!-'!)72&7 @7,!:#&"! +2!-1 &+2!-1, /!%1 +#!-1 /)!@2! 27 31L&%+&)05'+( -047 +#0C1'7#(.G!/0#()21( L)131: <! "7+%!27@2!+'&, 9! !'-)1:672&(.L+!-,+/: •«=&C277 /!-'!)72&7» - 4!#&'-7 (T1'L7( 6:7).•=!302,& (!")1'&'7 -2&412&7, %1% )7%#14!91:'7#& /.'15'+( /!-'!)('* +-!> #!302, ')&$9. -'7@72&7 30 +7%029). «T. 97#174 -+7 E'! 9#(-1+» («T1%9!21#*9+»); «H'12*'7 @1+'*5 /!%!:#72&( G7/+&» («G7/+&:D!#1»); «D1% /&C7'+(«!"#7,@72&7?» («K!#7>9+»); «N'#&@2.> 9! /!+:#7927> %1/#&» («T1%+-7## A10+»).

•T!92.7 +#!-7@%& & L)13. '&/1 «R!, /)!"7#!-»&#& «;.$&-17' +&#*27>C&>».

•«;7#&%1 J)'74&91 SL7++%1(!» — %)&@1#1 21/)!'($72&& 9-0A @1+!- '!#/1 - !'-7' 21 /)!/!:-79* G1-#1 !" F&+0+7 (<7(2&( 19:34).

•T12')1: «?-!#58&( — 210%1, %)718&!2&34 —)7#&,&(»

X1%!2 H!097)1: G!-'!)72&7 27 !"7+/7@&-17'9!+'!-7)2!+'&.X1%!2 Q&#%&: U!)!C&> #!302, 4!$7' /)&!+'12!:-&'* 121#&3 21 9!").A /('*97+(' #7'.

6,%); >)> (",N/)797#72&7: G)&3.- «;+7 97#15' E'!! G)&+!7:9&2(>+(, 1 '! "097' /!392!».G!/0#()21( L)131: <7+('* '.+(@ L)12803!- 274!,0' !C&"1'*+( !92!-)74722!.L+!-,+/: •O;:)7%#141 ! '!4, %1% 4!92.7 4!#!9.7 #59&/*5' ,13&)!-12205 -!90, /!9)13047-17', @'!'1% 97#15' -+7.

•<1-#72&7 +! +'!)!2. +-7)+'2&%!-.•G!#&'&@7+%1( )7%#141, /)79+'1-#(561( 321:472&'.A #597> & !),12&318&&, /!997)$&-15:6&A %129&91'1.

•;&#*(4 G1''72, <1)'4!0' (1930): «H141 E-!:#58&( 0$7 91-2! -.C#1 31 )14%& [email protected] 97:"1'!-. B7' '1%!,! 9)0,!,! /)7947'1, /! /!-!90%!'!)!,! [email protected] ".#& ". 21+'!#*%! 79&2!,:#1+2.4&. ?-!#58&( — E'! !921 "!#*C1( &+'&:21, %!'!)1( 214 &3-7+'21 21-7)2(%1».

I%!"2)2,%&.$, $H$H5,.!,N/)797#72&7: N"6&7 0/)!672&(, +%).-156&7-!3)1$72&( &#& /)!"#74..G!/0#()2.7 L)13.: <*(-!# %)!7'+( - 47#[email protected]+!-,+/:•=5"!-* 31+'1-#(7' 4&) -)161'*+(.•R!#*C&2+'-! /!#&'&@7+%&A )7@7> & #!302,!-.•G!#&'&%, /)79#1,156&> +067+'-722!7 0-7#&:@72&7 21#!,!-: «T. 9!#$2. +/1+'& 97'7>» &#&«T. 9!#$2. !"7+/7@&'* 21C7 "090677».

•T1+C'1"2.7 +8721)&& E-!#58&& !' R!#*C!,!-3).-1 9! @7#!-7%1, %1%, 21/)&47), - L&#*41A«2001: D!+4&@7+%1( N9&++7(» &#& «=59& F%+».

•«;+7 )7#&,&& — )132.7 9!)!,& - !92! & '! $747+'!».

•«[email protected] 4!,0' )1+A!9&'*+( -! 4272&(A /! /!:-!90 47A12&34!- E-!#58&&, 2! !2& -+7 +!,#1+:2. + '74, @'! E-!#58&( — E'! L1%'».

•D1)# H1,12, «D!+4!+»: «?'! #&C* @1+'* '!,!,@'! +97#1#& 1'!4. -!9!)!91 31 /('21981'*4&##&1)9!- #7' %!+4&@7+%!> E-!#58&&».

=,">!, "%$()N/)797#72&7: F+/!#*3!-12&7 E4!8&!21#*2!21+.6722.A +#!- — %1% 27,1'&-2.A, '1% & /!3&:'&-2.A (E-L74&34), @'!". -#&('* 21 )71%8&5+#0C1'7#7>.G!/0#()21( L)131: G!#&'&@7+%& %!))7%'2.>.L+!-,+/ (#$'!2!(./,):•T&++&( R!$7+'-722.> +-7' (%0#*' U1)& D)&C2.).•X16&'2&% +-!"!92!,! -."!)1 (+'!)!22&%1"!)'!-).

•H-!"!921( #5"!-* ()1"+'-! /!A!'& "73 0@7'1/!+#79+'-&>).

•K132!+'!)!2277 !")13!-12&7 (/)79+'1-#72&7,!4!+7%+01#&341 %1% 2!)4.).

L+!-,+/ (.,7)2!(./,):•B1-7C&-12&7 ()#.%!-: E%+')74&+', )19&%1#,E%+872')&@2.>, +041+C79C&>, %1%!>:'! @)73:47)2! A)&+'&12+%&> !)'!9!%+, L0291472'1:#&+', !"+%0)12', )71%8&!27), L121'&%. B1%#7&:-12&7 /!#&'&@7+%&A ()#.%!-: 9727$2.7 47C:%&, %137221( %!)40C%1, +/78&1#*2.7 /)!872:'., !A!'1 21 -79*4, 41%%1)'&34, /!9#78.

•D)718&!2&34 — +A741 L0291472'1#&+'!- 9#(/)!9-&$72&( +-!&A )7#&,&!32.A 2147)72&> &/)!4.-12&( 4!3,!- 21C&4 97'(4.

•«K13042.> 314.+7#» — !@72* A&').> %)718&!:2&34.

•M!)18&! U!%7'' B*5412 (1932): «B7' 2& !92!>%!2%0)&)0567> ,&/!'73., 31 &+%#5@72&74+'1)!4!92!> & /!#2!+'*5 !/)!-7),20'!> &97&!" !+!"!4 +!'-!)72&&, %!'!)!> +7,!92( /)&:97)$&-15'+( '!#*%! 27-7$7+'-722.7, 27 9!:/0+%156&7 -!3)1$72&> & /)79-3('.7 #59&».

B""$Q!)Q!3 N/)797#72&7: J++!8&&)!-12&7 /)!9-&,174!>-14& '74. + @74:'!, @'! 2)1-&'+( #59(4. F#&,21!"!)!', + 87#*5 %)&'&%& & !+0$972&( 1++!8&:&)!-12&7 + @74:'!, @'! #59(4 27 2)1-&'+(.L+!-,+/ (#$'!2!(./,):•G)&-#7@72&7 321472&'!+'7> - O;:)7%#140.•W!'!)1"!'.: %129&91', 97)$16&> 21 )0%1A )7:"72%1.

•; )7%#142!> %14/12&& 9$&2+!- &+/!#*3!-1:#1+* 403.%1 - +'&#7 9$12,# & ,!#!+, 21/!4&21:56&> ).@12&7 '&,)1, ,!-!)(6&> /!%0/1'7#(4:$&-!'2.4: «?'! 9$02,#&, & -. 9!#$2. ".'*/)&,!92.4& 9#( -.$&-12&(... <$&2+. !'H7)9$&! ;1#72'&2& — -.$&-17' +&#*27>C&>.S+'7+'-722.> !'"!)».

G)&47). (27,1'&-2.7):•T!> !//!272' /!A!$ 21 M&'#7)1.•;+7, %'! 27 +!,#1+2. + %!#&@7+'-!4 E4&,)12:'!- - +')127, — )1+&+'..

•;%#5@72&7 %)718&!2&341 - +/&+!% '1%&A /+7-:9!210%, %1% 1+')!#!,&(, +/&)&'&34 & E%+')1:+72+!)2!7 -!+/)&('&7: «...')7"!-1'* 0@&'7#7>!"0@1'* 21C&A 97'7> %)718&!2&340 '1% $7 27:!/)1-9122!, %1% & ')7"!-1'*, @'!". !2& 0@&#&&A 1+')!#!,&&, 1#A&4&& & L)72!#!,&&...» (R)1CH.M. Q@&'7#* 7+'7+'-!3212&(. — 1981; 4:33).

=.4U,.!,N/)797#72&7: F+/!#*3!-12&7 /!9+!321'7#*2.AA&')!+'7> + 87#*5 /)&-#7@72&(, !'-#7@72&( &#&--7972&( - 31"#0$972&7.G!/0#()21( L)131: G)!+'1%& )!$915'+( %1$9054&20'0.

L+!-,+/:•M&/2!'&34. T79&04.. Z1)!97&. T1++!-1( &+:'7)&(.

•G!9+!321'7#*21( )7%#141. V3.% '7#1. T03.:%1#*2!7 +!/)!-!$972&7.

•G!#&'&@7+%&7 /#1%1'. & )7%#142.7 6&'., +!:97)$16&7 '!#*%! &4( %129&91'1, @'!". #59&31/!42&#& 7,! & /)& ,!#!+!-12&& - %1"&2%7+4!,#& +!)&72'&)!-1'*+(.

•X1,!#!-%&: «G)1-91 #&, @'! %)718&!2&34 04&:)17' 479#722!> +47)'*5?», %!,91 - 97>+'-&:'7#*2!+'& !2, 21!"!)!', -!3)!$917'+(.

A)7.,2).!, "2+)8) ! .,.)(!"2!N/)797#72&7: ;.3.-12&7 +')1A1 &#& -)1$97":2!+'& /! !'2!C72&5 % !/)797#722.4 #59(4. L+!-,+/:•G)7+#79!-12&7 M&'#7)!4 &0977- 9! &A &+')7":#72&(.

•W1)&+7&, ,!-!)(6&7 G&#1'0, @'! F&+0+ /)79+:'1-#(7' 0,)!30 9#( )&4+%!,! /)1-1 (%!'!)!7!2& +14& 2721-&97#&).

•H')1A ! «+%).'.A 2147)72&(A» !//!272'1. O7!:)&& +%).'!,! 04.+#1.

•M7,7#*(2+%1( '1%'&%1: +!391'* %)&3&+, 31'74)13$7@* )7-!#58&5, @'!". -.>'& &3 %)&3&+1(2! #7@72&7 !%13.-17'+( 2142!,! A0$7, @74 31:"!#7-12&7).

•«G!3-!#&'* %)718&!2&+'14 ,!-!)&'* ! +-!&A-3,#(91A 21 0)!%1A 7+'7+'-!3212&( — '! $7 +1:4!7, @'! /!3-!#&'* '74, %'! !')&817' 41++!-!702&@'!$72&7 7-)77- L1C&+'14&, ,!-!)&'* !+-!&A -3,#(91A 21 0)!%1A &+'!)&&».

=/"-,!().!,N/)797#72&7: G!/.'%1 -.3-1'* 27/)&(32* % @7:#!-7%0 &#& &977 /0'74 21-7C&-12&( ()#.%!-,+1)%1341 &#& C0'!%.G!/0#()21( L)131: Q -+7A +-!& +')122!+'&.L+!-,+/:•H1'&)1. D!4&%+. & %1)&%1'0).. H1)%1+'&@7+:%&7 & 54!)&+'&@7+%&7 "1##19..

•; +)7927-7%!-*7 &+/12+%&7 &2%-&3&'!). 21:97-1#& 21 «7)7'&%!-» (@1+'! "#1,!@7+'&-.AA)1").A 40@72&%!-) 90)18%&7 %!#/1%& &#& %!+:'54., 21 %!'!).A ".# &3!")1$72 !,!2* 191, &/)!-!9&#& &A @7)73 ,#04(605+( '!#/0.

•N"3.-12&7 %)718&!2&+'!- +'1)!4!92.4&, 9&:%&4& (<!0%&23) & /767)2.4& #59*4&.

•G!+#7 +097"2!,! /)!87++1 219 H%!/+!4 ".#1-./06721 %1)&%1'0)1, 21 %!'!)!> Q&#*(4 <$72:2&2,+ R)1>12 &3!")1$72 - -&97 !"73*(2. + 219:/&+*5: «N2 !')&817' +-!7 /)!&+A!$972&7».

www.crev.info

&'%(15 &'$&*?*")5 R-* $@ 6-8,&?'-:+ $ '. ,&,-8:+8< '- 0;&1*0

ww

w.evidentcreation.com

=?@AB CDE?=?FFEGAD@


$921$9. 427 /!3-!2&#1 4!( 9!@* & +%1:31#1: «G1/1, '. 27 /!-7)&C*, 2! L&#*4«T!( "!#*C1( ,)7@7+%1( +-19*"1» 31':

)1,&-17' '740 E-!#58&&!».«O. C0'&C*!», — !'-7'&# (. X1'74 !21 /!9:

)!"2! )1++%131#1 427, @'! !21 &47#1 - -&90.D!,91 ( /!-7+&# '7#7L!2205 ')0"%0, ( ".# /)!+:'! /!)1$72: ,!9., %!'!).7 4. + $72!> /!')1'&:#& 21 !"0@72&7 21C&A 97'7> %)&'&@2!40 4.C#7:2&5, !%0/&#&+* +/!#21.

;+7 21@1#!+* + 4!7,! #5"&4!,! 97'+%!,!L&#*41 «C#"#4+'$%-7 *0($#4 O0*3#$». N921$:9. ( /)&!")7# -&97!%1++7'0 + E'&4 L&#*4!4 & +09!-!#*+'-&74 +7# /!+4!')7'* 7,! -47+'7 +!+-!&4& 9-04( 97'*4& (%!'!).4 '!,91 ".#! 15 &16 #7') & $72!>. T. !%020#&+* - %#1++&%0 %&2!1964 ,!91… B! 27 /)!C#! & 97+('& 4&20', %1% (".# 31+'&,20' -)1+/#!A. T!> ,7)!> M72)& =&4:/7' - &+/!#272&& <!21 B!''+1 ,!-!)&# + E%)121+-!740 9)0,0: «N+!3217C* #& '., @'! 21C&4&/)79%14& ".#& ).".?».

«;!' E'! 91! N+'12!-&'7 %1++7'0, 97'%&, 21420$2! /!,!-!)&'*». G!+#7 '!,! %1% 4. !"+09&#&E'!' E/&3!9, 4. +2!-1 -%#5@&#& %1++7'0. B!-+%!)7 21+ 31+'1-&#1 /!)134.+#&'* 767 !921+8721. B1 E'!' )13 4&+'7) =&4/7', 97)$1 - )0%1A%2&,0 /!9 213-12&74 «O#+40' +,4&$%+7 >"+6;H?00», 4!#&#+(, /)!&32!+( +#79056&7 +#!-1:

«D1% ". 427 A!'7#!+* ".'* )."!>». B7!$&9122!27&3-7+'2.> "!, !'-7'&# 21 7,! 4!#&'-0. T&+'7)=&4/7' /).,20# - -!90 & + 2&4 21@1# /)!&+A!:9&'* !")1'2.> E-!#58&!22.> /)!87++: !' @7#!:-7%1 — 9! 14L&"&&, !' 14L&"&& — 9! )."..

L+!(%,>)2,%&.$"2& "+,1"2(-)""$($; !.P$+-)Q!!H)79+'-1 41++!-!> &2L!)418&& +! -+7A

+'!)!2 1'1%05' "&"#7>+%&7 +'1291)'. 4!)1#&.G*(2+'-!, 3#!0/!')7"#72&7 21)%!'&%14&, /!):2!,)1L&(, "#09, /)7#5"!97(2&7 & /!C#.7 +#!:-1 +'1#& !"67/)&2('.4& & 91$7 &971#&3&)!:-122.4&. ;+7 E'& /)!(-#72&( —+-&97'7#*+'-! -!++'12&( @7#!-7:%1 /)!'&- R!,1. G&+12&7 0@&' )!:9&'7#7>:A)&+'&12 «-!+/&'.-1'*&A (97'7>) - 0@72&& & 21+'1-#72&&M!+/!9274» (SL7+(214 6:4). N9:21%! + %1$9.4 9274 E'! 97#1'*-+7 ')09277 & ')09277. O1% %1% $7A)&+'&12+%&4 )!9&'7#(4 0@&'*+-!&A 97'7>, @'!". !2& +4!,#& 0+:'!('* - "!)*"7 /)!'&- /1,0"2.A4&)+%&A &+%0C72&>?

<#( 21@1#1 !"+0$91>'7 E'&-1$2.7 -!/)!+. +! +-!&4& 97'*:4&. M!-!)&'7 + 2&4& & /!%13.-1>:'7, @'! ,#1+&' !" E'!4 R&"#&(.B1@2&'7 +! +'&A1 SL7+(214 4:17.S+#& -1C7 /)!C#!7 21/!#272!#&@2.4& !C&"%14&, )1++%1$&'7!" E'!4 +-!&4 97'(4 '1%, @'!". !2& /!2(#& -1+.G!%1$&'7 &4, %1% R!$*( "#1,!91'* & 4&#!+'*+/1+#& -1+, — /0+'* -1C& 97'& 0@1'+( 21 -1C&A27091@1A & !C&"%1A. Q+7)92! 0@&'7 +-!&A 97'7>,/!'!40 @'! 7+#& E'!,! 27 "097'7 97#1'* -., >2$*.!H41& !%! 92$*.!H41& $H3')2,%&.$ "1,%),2:2$ ') ()".

V +2!-1 21$1# 21 /1030 21 -&97!41,2&'!L!:27, & 4. 767 )13 !"+09&#& L&#*4, %!'!).> +4!':)7#&. T27 +'1#! &2'7)7+2!, /!@740 ( 27 0#!-&#

E'&A +#!-, %!,91 )7"72%!4 +4!')7# +-!> #5:"&4.> L&#*4. V )!+, A!9&# - +)79255 C%!:#0 & /!+761# #&"7)1#*205 87)%!-*. ;+7 E'!-)74( 472( 0@&#&, @'! E-!#58&5 & R&"#&54!$2! !"Y79&2&'*, /!E'!40 /!+'7/722! (/7)7+'1# -!!"67 )134.C#('* 219 E'&4.

G!-!)!'2.> 4!472' - 4!7> $&32& 21+:'0/&#, %!,91 ( !")1'&#+( & +'1# A)&+'&12&:2!4. G!+#7 '!,!, %1% - %!287 1980:A ,,. ( /)!:@7# %2&,0 «=!$*: ?-!#58&(», ( !+!321#, @'!4!,0 9!-7)('* R&"#&& %1% &+'&22!40 R!$*7:40 H#!-0, 21@&21( + +14!,! /7)-!,! +'&A1.

H'1- A)&+'&12&2!4, /!#2!+'*5 9!-7)(5:6&4 R!,0, 0 472( /!(-&#1+*2!-1( /)&!")7'7221( @0-+'-&:'7#*2!+'* (+-!7!")132.> «)1:91)»), /!4!,1561( !/)797:#('* -76& & /!2('&( E'!,! 4&:)1, %!'!).7 /!9).-15' &+'&20R!$*7,! H#!-1. G)!C#! -)7:4(, ( /)!@&'1# 42!,! A!)!C7>#&'7)1'0). !'2!+&'7#*2!"&"#7>+%!,! H!'-!)72&( & -+7"!#*C7 & "!#*C7 !+!321-1#,%1% E-!#58&!22.7 &97& &+:/!#*305'+( 9#( /!9).-1 1-'!:)&'7'1 R!$*7,! H#!-1. S2!!1,! (>%)1/()<2"3 ( >4%&*24+4 $9,.& 8!2+/-! "#$"$*H)-!. V 21A!9&# E-!#58&!2:205 #!$* '14, ,97 & 27 /!9!3:)7-1#: 2,%,(!1,.!,, .$($"*

2!, 4#)>$(>! " ,1$;, !7+4U>!, P!%&-/,-4%&2P!%&-/ ! +,>%)-).

G!+#7 '!,!, %1% 4. + $72!> +'1#& )!9&:'7#(4&, 214 A!'7#!+* 210@&'* 21C&A 97'7>9041'* %)&'&@2!, /!E'!40 4. /)1%'&%!-1:#&+* -! -)74( /)!+4!')!- )132.A L&#*4!-.; %1$9!4 L&#*47 4. +#.C1#& 27"&"#7>+:%&7 L)13., 1 31'74 +)130 $7 &#& /!+#7 !%!2:@12&( /)!+4!')1 !"+0$91#& +-(3122.7 +2&4& /)!"#74..

?'& )7,0#()2.7 +747>2.7 /)!+4!').-9!A2!-&#& 472( 21 +!3912&7 /)7372'18&>,%!'!).7 +7,!92( ( /)!-!$0 - 87)%-(A & 4!:#!97$2.A ,)0//1A. V 31915 +-!&4 +#0C1'7:#(4 -!/)!+: «; 21+'!(677 -)74( - HIJ 21+:@&'.-17'+( 400 000 87)%-7> & 6000 %&2!'7:1')!-, 974!2+')&)056&A /7)-.4 E%)12!4;@'!, /! -1C740 4272&5, !%13.-17' 21 21C&A+!,)1$912 "!#*C77 -#&(2&7?».

D +!$1#72&5, !'-7' -+7,91 !9&2 & '!'$7: «D!27@2! $7, %&2!'71').». ]7#* M!##&:-091 — 27 '!#*%! )13-#7%1'* & /!#0@1'* /)&:".#*. G&+1'7#&, %&2!)7$&++7). & 9)0,&70@1+'2&%& &290+')&& )13-#7@72&> A!'(',@'!". &A 3)&'7#& /!-7)&#& - '!, -! @'! !2&-7)(' +14&. J !9&2 &3 +/!+!"!- /)&91'* &A4&)!-!33)72&5 /)&('2.> -&9 — +97#1'*L&#*4. -7+7#.4& & /)&-#7%1'7#*2.4&.

U)&+'&127 9!#$2. ".'* 21+'!)!$7 &321'* !"! -+7A ,!##&-09+%&A 47'!91A & /)&:741A. T. 9!#$2. &+/!#*3!-1'* R&"#&5 %1%)19&!#!%18&!2205 +&+'740, /!4!,15605214 27 /!991-1'*+( #$& E'!,! 4&)1. F+'&2:2.7 A)&+'&127 9!#$2. )13#&@1'*, !"21)0:$&-1'* & !"#&@1'* 27/)1-90. O!#*%! '1% 4.+4!$74 @740:'! 210@&'* 21C&A 97'7>. R)+% RGEID

<,$ #!(?$ -%0/ '*=#-(4("%(... %-% "(,?S($%<Q!3 — $.) (,'1,!

G)&47). 0/!4&212&> !" E-!#58&& 21>'& !@72* #7,%!.Z1+'! !2& 79-1 0#!-&4., 2!, -+7 $7, /!%13.-15', 21+:%!#*%! C&)!%! )1+/)!+')12722!> & !"67/)&2('!>+'12!-&'+( #!$*, 31#!$7221( - !+2!-7 &97& E-!#5:8&&. T. 9!#$2. 047'* )1+/!321-1'* E'0 #!$* & 210:@&'* E'!40 +-!&A 97'7>. B&$7 /)&-7972. 27+%!#*%!/)&47)!-:• ; !92!> &3 +7)&> 40#*'L&#*41 «R1,+ R12&» /!9213-12&74 «N@72* +47C2!> %)!#&%» ?#47) W199,!2&'+( 31 R1,+ R122&, %!,91 '!' -9)0, !"21)0$&-1:7' /#72%0 — 9!%0472'1#*2.> L&#*4 «CromagnumScope Color by Neanderthal Color» — & +4!')&' 7,!.; E'!4 9!%0472'1#*2!4 L&#*47 ?#47) W199+'!02!A!'&'+( 21 +1"#730"!,! %)!#&%1. ;! -)74( /)!+:4!')1 L&#*41 R1,+ C0'#&-! ,!-!)&': «G!+4!')&'721 E'!,! /7)-!".'2!,! %!+!30"!,!. B70$7#& E'!!9&2 &3 4!&A /)79%!-?».

• ; 40#*'L&#*47 «W12'13&(» T&%%& T10+ )1++%1:3.-17' &+'!)&5 !" E-!#58&& !' !92!%#7'!@2!,!!),12&341 9! @7#!-7%1.

• ; 40#*'L&#*47 «; /!&+%1A B74!», %!,91 T1)#&2(/1/1 B74!) & <!)& /)!"&)15'+( +%-!3* 42!$7:+'-! 47903, <!)& ,!-!)&' T1)#&20: «X1-(3.-1>,+'1)&%. O. 27 4!$7C* &9'& /)!'&- E-!#58&&. V".#1 +!39121 9#( +%!)!+'&».

• ; L&#*47 «T!( "!#*C1( ,)7@7+%1( +-19*"1» E-!:#58&( 0/!4&217'+( - E/&3!97, %!,91 $72&A O0#./.'17'+( +%131'* 77 !'80 21 ,)7@7+%!4 (3.%7:«G!39)1-#(5 + G1+A!>». G1/0 27 -/7@1'#&#! 7,!/)!&32!C72&7, /!E'!40 !2 +%131# $72&A0 21 ,)7:@7+%!4 (3.%7 (/!(-#(5'+( '&'). 21 12,#&>+%!4(3.%7): «D!,91 4!> 21)!9 /&+1# L&#!+!L+%&7')1%'1'., '-!> 21)!9 767 /).,1# /! 97)7-*(4».

• ; 40#*'L&#*47 /!9 213-12&74 «M0"%1 R!" — %-19)1':2.7 C'12.» !/&+.-17'+( E-!#58&( - 4!)+%&A ,#0"&:21A. H#790561( 8&'1'1 -3('1 &3 +7)&& /!9 213-12&:74 «JA!»: «B19 /7)-!".'2.4 4!)74 -!+A!9&' +!#287.F4722! 397+* 4&##&!2. #7' 21319 21@1#1+* $&32*,97#1( +-!& /7)-.7 27")7$2.7 C1,& &3 '*4., !'%).:-1( +-!& '!#*%! @'! +L!)4&)!-122.7 ,#131 & ,#(9( 21!+#7/&'7#*2.> +-7' )13042!+'&».

• ?-!#58&!22.> +4.+# !"21)0$&-17'+( 91$7 - '1:%!4 40#*'&/#&%18&!22!4 L&#*47 9#( 9!C%!#*:2&%!-, %1% «R!":+')!&'7#*». ; !92!> &3 +7)&> /!9213-12&74 «H'7,!31-) H%0/1» R!" %!/17' (40 &21A!9&' %!+'*. N2 ,!-!)&', @'! E'!, 9!#$2! ".'*,%!+'* 9&2!31-)1. =!L'& 21/0,121, 2! R!" 0+/!%1:&-17' 77 +#!-14&: «B7 "7+/!%!>+(, =!L'&, 9&2!:31-). $&#& 4&##&!2. #7' 21319».

• ; L&#*47 «G&'7) G72», - /7+72%7 «G!@740 %)1+2!%!:$&7 +'1#& %)1+2.4&?», /!7'+(: «<1-1>'7 -7)274+(21 4&##&!2. #7' 21319 % +14!40 /7)-!40 &297>+%!:40 /)&280».

• ; )7%#147, %!447)@7+%&A )19&!— & '7#7/7)791:@1A, %!'!).7 )7%#14&)05' -+7 — !' +')1A!-%& 1-:'!4!"&#7> 9! -.+!%!+%!)!+'2!,! F2'7)27'1 —-7397 +!97)$1'+( 2147%& 21 E-!#58&5. F3-7+':21( ')12+/!)'21( %!)/!)18&( FedEx, )!#&% %!'!:)!> ')12+#&)!-1#+( -! -)74( 41'@1 «H0/7) R!0#:2005», /!%131#1 /7)-!".'2!,! /767)2!,! @7#!:-7%1, /)&-(31-C7,! /1%7' % #1/7 /'7)!91%'&#(,-+%!)7 +Y79722!,! M04&%%+:&"4+* N#1(+*. ?'!-!-+7 27 %!447)@7+%&> 54!), 1 79-1 0#!-&4!7E-!#58&!22!7 /!+#12&7, 0%)7/#(5677 &975 E-!:#58&& !' 4!#7%0#. 9! @7#!-7%1, 1 27 &+'&20 H!':-!)72&(, ! %!'!)!> ,!-!)&'+( - R.'&&.

P:$ $;.$(*%-;#(-=:8< (*0%+:060 &1.'+

@$:6#"$ 8,&8&2-"$.L '-@&;$%

F(&%=7$&''0= %&4+:-", /;. $ '.,&;&?6.(-%::.%.($;.'$.,

'&(&8:$, 0,-*&(*$ 8.;&3, $/60)*$,

5$%+"#,"0%+:5$%+"# $

6.*%-"-.

B=M?EDMGM I?JNGW? VK?=B

«F9&'7 /! -+740 4&)0 & /)!/!-790>'7 S-12:,7#&7 -+740 '-!)72*5». T1)%1 16:15

T()0),-/, 9!2)2,%! 7)',2/ «E)'4-./;')-/",%»! F47( "!#*C!7 $7#12&7 )1++%131'*9)0,&4 ! -7#&@&& & 409)!+'& 21C7,! H!391'7#(,4. !),12&3!-1#& D#0" «H!'-!)72&7», %!'!).>21@1# +-!> ')09 - /,'. ;!#!91)+%:;!#.2+%&> 1441)'1 2009 ,!91 - ]7)%-& «D!-@7, +/1+72&(».

?'!' D#0" ".# +!3912 + 87#*5 /)79+'1-#7:2&( +-&97'7#*+'-, %!'!).7 /!9'-7)$915' R&":#7>+%!7 H!'-!)72&7 & +067+'-!-12&7 K13042!:,! X14.+#1 - /)&)!97.

B1C7> 4!#!9`$2!> %!4129!> 0$7 /)!-797:2! /)&"#&3&'7#*2! 25 -+')7@ D#0"1, 21 %!'!).A/!92&41#&+* '1%&7 -!/)!+. %1%:• G)1-90 #& ,!-!)&' '7!)&( E-!#58&&?• \&#& #& 9&2!31-). - !92! -)74( + #59*4&?• R.# #& 21 374#7 /!'!/?• H%!#*%! #7' 21C7> /#127'7 X74#(? F 42!,!

9)0,&A.26.07.2009 ; /,'. ;!#:;!#.2+%7 214& ".#1

!),12&3!-121 -.+'1-%1 D#0"1 «H!'-!)72&7», %!:'!)1( (-#(#1 +!"!> +-!7!")132.> !'@7' /! /!:-!90 21C&A &++#79!-12&>. T. /)79+'1-&#& ')&+'7291 /! '1%&4 '7414: «;!3)1+' X74#&», «J)A7:!#!,&( & R&"#&(» & «<&2!31-). & R&"#&(». S2$;(/"2)(>$; 1%3 -.$7!8 H/%) $2>+/2) !"2!.).B7%!'!).7 &3 /)&+0'+'-056&A 21 27> ".#&09&-#72. '74, @'! 21C7> 374#7 -+7,! /)&"#&3&:'7#*2! C7+'* '.+(@ #7', 1 27 4&##&!2., %1% !"

E'!4 !2& +#.C1#& -+5 +-!5 $&32*. F#& '!, @'!-+( 374#( ".#1 /!%).'1 -!9!5, 1 27 &3472(#1+*21 /)!'($72&& 4&##&!2!- #7' #7'. R!#77 -+7,!09&-#(7' '!, @'! - 21C7 -)74( 767 42!,! #597>-7)(' - '!, @'! /)79%!4 @7#!-7%1 ".#1 !"73*(21.B7%!'!).7 &3 2&A 27 3215', @'! @7#!-7%1 +!391#R!,:O-!)78, 1 9)0,&7 27 A!'(' & +#.C1'* 2&@7,!9)0,!,! %)!47 E-!#58&&. G!E'!40 - 9122.> 4!:472' 4. -79`4 /!9,!'!-%0 /)!-7972&( +7)&&'1%&A -.+'1-!% - C%!#1A 21C7,! )7,&!21.

08.08.2009 B1 "137 21C7,! D#0"1 ".#1 !):,12&3!-121 C%!#1 «H!'-!)72&7». N21 -%#5@1#147+(@2.> %0)+ 312('&>. ; C%!#7 ".#& 3197>:+'-!-12. 4!#!9.7 #59&, /)!(-&-C&7 $7#12&7,#0"$7 &30@1'* &+'!)&5 -!32&%2!-72&( '7!)&&E-!#58&& & -+7 "!#*C7 0321-1'* -7#&@&7 O-!):81. ;+7 0@72&%& C%!#. 97#&#&+* 47$90 +!"!>

&2'7)7+2.4& L1%'14& 27+!+'!('7#*2!+'& E-!:#58&& & 9!%131'7#*+'-14& +067+'-!-12&( R!,1.X1%!2@&#1+* 0@7"1 - C%!#7 «H!'-!)72&7»29.08.2009. ;+7 0@72&%& ".#& - -!+'!),7 !' '!,!,21+%!#*%! 4!,067+'-72 & /)7%)1+72 21C O-!)78&. G! !%!2@12&& 312('&> -+74 0@1+'2&%14 C%!#.".#& -)0@72. +7)'&L&%1'..

X1 -+5 21C0 )1"!'0 - /7)-05 !@7)79* 4."#1,!91)2. M!+/!90, D!'!).> 21 /)!'($72&&-+7,! E'!,! -)7472& 91-1# 214 +&#. &9'& -/7:)79, /!4!,1# 0+'!('* /7)79 &+/.'12&(4& & -+7:#(# $7#12&7 ')09&'*+( 21 S,! 2&-7. T. '1%$7"#1,!91)2. 21C7> ]7)%-&, %!'!)1( /!997)$&:-17' 21+ & 4!#&'-722!, & 41'7)&1#*2!. T. )1:9., @'! '7/7)* 7+'* '1%1( /)7%)1+21( -!34!$:2!+'* +-&97'7#*+'-!-1'* #59(4 ! O-!)87.

S+#& '7"(, 9!)!,!> 9)0,, 31&2'7)7+!-1#! E'!+-&97'7#*+'-! & '. $7#17C* 21@1'* D#0" «H!'-!:)72&7» 0 +7"( - 87)%-& &#& /)&+!79&2&'*+( % 21:C740 9-&$72&5, '. +4!$7'7 21>'& 21+ /! 19)7+0:

X0$+*04(1&' +,6&($93@$. 2+6+8&4(1H2+6-%(107,.6. W#"/#%1&, 78!#41+"9 «F+"/#@ P3&(#%0'»

O1%$7, "!#77 /!9)!"205 &2L!)418&5 ! 21+,21C& 41'7)&1#. & 2!-!+'& +#0$72&( '. +4!:$7C* 21>'& 21 21C74 &2'7)27':+1>'7:http://wks.nsknet.ru

T. $7#174 ;14 "#1,!+#!-72&>, 9)03*(, &

/!"!#*C7 0321-1'* ! 21C74 ;7#&@7+'-722!4O-!)87.

A)2)%!3 ! ?>").) 6BAZR

!#%)(,(-/!,#$ 64*!,"%3$# 3-6:* «!$,#$'("%(»REGB^D?AA?G IKBW?=GVMDG AB LEBRMDRG


:!#*C&2+'-! #597> #&"! +#.C1#&, #&"!0@&#&, @'! -! -)74( +-!7,! -20')&0')!":2!,! )13-&'&( @7#!-7@7+%&> E4")&!2

/)!A!9&' (&#& /!-'!)(7') '1%&7 )13#&@2.7 E-!:#58&!22.7 +'19&&, %1% +'19&( $1"), %1% 0 ).",+'19&( A-!+'1, %1% 0 !"73*(2, & '. 9.

?'0 &975 27 '!#*%! -%#19.-1#& - 04. 87#.A/!%!#72&> +'0972'!- "&!#!,&@7+%&A & 479&8&2+:%&A L1%0#*'7'!- %1% 27!+/!)&4.> L1%', 2! & 21/)!'($72&& 42!,&A #7' &+/!#*3!-1#& 9#( 0"79&:'7#*2!,! $#+)(1).!3 )H$+2$(. H'!)!22&%& 1"!):'!- 31(-#(#&, @'! 27)!$9722.> )7"72!%, %!'!)!,!0"&-15', -+7 )1-2! 21A!9&'+( 21 +'19&& ).". &#&!"73*(2., 1 321@&', !2 767 27 +'1# @7#!-7%!4.

H %!281 1860:A ,,. E'0 &975, 213.-17405«E4")&!21#*2!> )7%1/&'0#(8&7>» &#& «E4")&!:21#*2.4 /!-'!)72&74», 1%'&-2! /)!/1,129&)!:-1# ?)2+' M7%%7#*, @'! +/!+!"+'-!-1#! )1+/)!:+')1272&5 E-!#58&!22!> '7!)&& <1)-&21 - M7):412&&. F E'! /)&'!4, @'! M7%%7#* 27 &47# 2&%1:%&A /!9'-7)$972&> +-!7> &97&1.

VP)H+!>$()../, 1)../,B7 &47( 9!+'1'[email protected] 9!%131'7#*+'-, M7%%7#*

319041# +L1")&%!-1'* 9122.7. N"4122.4 /0:'74 !2 &3472&# +97#122.7 9)0,&4& [email protected]& )&:+02%& E4")&!2!- @7#!-7%1 & +!"1%&, @'!". 0+&:#&'* +A!9+'-1 47$90 2&4& & +%).'* !'#&@&(. T.0$7 +!!"61#& !" E'!4 -!/&5674 !"4127 - 27:91-274 -./0+%7 $0)21#1 H!'-!)72&7.2

H'!)!22&%& M7%%7#( - M7)412&& (- @1+'2!+'&,/)!L7++!) 121'!4&& =7>/8&,+%!,! 02&-7)+&'7'1;&#*,7#*4 U&+ - 1874 ,.), 0321- !" E'!4 !"4127,/!')7"!-1#& !' 27,! !"Y(+272&>. ; !'-7' $7 0+#.:C1#& /)&3212&7, - %!'!)!4 M7%%7#* !"-&2&# - 27:'!@2!4 +!+'1-#72&& )&+02%1 A09!$2&%1, 27 +!321-:C&+* - '!4, @'! E'&4 A09!$2&%!4 (-#(7'+( !2 +14!2

X1 /!+#792&7 70 #7' 21&"!#77 !+-79!4#72:2.7 E-!#58&!2&+'. /!2(#&: '7!)&( E4")&!:21#*2!,! /!-'!)72&( — #!$21(.3

O74 27 47277, 1$ "!8 #$+ ($ -.$7!8 49,H*.!>)8 &975 E4")&!21#*2!,! /!-'!)72&( /)79+:'1-#(5' %1% /!9'-7)$972&7 '7!)&& E-!#58&&.B1+'!>@&-! !'+'1&-15' E'0 #!$* +!+'1-&'7#&E28&%#!/79&> & '1%&7 E-!#58&!22.7 /!/0#()&:31'!)., %1% D1)# H1,12.4

S2$ ,5, ., (",!D!,91 E-!#58&!2&+'. ,!-!)(', @'! '7!)&(

E4")&!21#*2!,! /!-'!)72&( #!$21(, !2&, %1%/)1-&#!, 27 /)&3215' '!,!, @'! +)1-272&7 E4")&:!2!- 1"+!#5'2! 27 /!9'-7)$917' +067+'-!-12&(!"67,! /)79%1. ; 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'&, «316&61(»E-!#58&5, !2& 31@1+'05 ,!-!)(' ! /)79/!#1,17:4.A +A!9+'-1A 47$90 E4")&!214& 21 &A )122&A+'19&(A )13-&'&( (&97(, 213.-17:41( «E4")&!21#*2!> ,!4!#!,&:7>»). O1%!7 /)79/!#!$72&7 !+2!:-.-17'+( #&C* 21 '!> &977, @'! /!:9!"2.7 +A!9+'-1 (-#(5'+( «!"67:&3-7+'2.4 L1%'!4»5.

B1 /)!'($72&& 9!#,&A #7'E'!, '1% 213.-174!7, +A!9+'-!E4")&!2!- !+2!-.-1#!+* (!+!3:2122! &#& 27!+!32122!) 21 +7)&&&3 24 )&+02%!- M7%%7#(, %!'!).7!2 -/7)-.7 /)79+'1-&# 0@72!404&)0 - 1866 ,. - +-!7> )1"!'7 GeneralleMorphologie der Organismen, 1 31'74 /!-'!)2! -1874 ,. - "!#77 /!/0#()2!> )1"!'7 Anthropogenie(+4. 2&$7). ; E'!> +7)&& )&+02%!- ".#& &3!")1:$72. E4")&!2. )."., +1#14129)., @7)7/1A&,8./#72%1, %!)!-., %)!#&%1 & @7#!-7%1 21 ')7A+'19&(A +-!7,! )13-&'&(, %!'!).7 21 )122&A+'19&(A &47#& 321@&'7#*2!7 +A!9+'-!.

H 4!472'1 /!(-#72&( E'&A )&+02%!- [email protected]+'1#& +@&'1'*, @'! !2& /)&"#&3&#&+* % /!3212&5&+'&2. !" E4")&!21#*2!4 )13-&'&& /!3-!2!@:2.A $&-!'2.A. ?'1 &97( 21+'!#*%! 0%!)72&#1+*- &A 041A, @'! E'& )&+02%& 9! +&A /!) &3!")1$1:5' - 0@7"2&%1A & /!/0#()2.A )1"!'1A, /!+-(:6722.A E-!#58&&.6, 7

; 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'& 2&%'! 27 +@7# 20$2.4/)!-7)&'* /)1-&#*2!+'* E'&A )&+02%!-— -/#!'*9! +7,!92(C27,! 92(. N%131#!+*, @'! $H-). W,>*>,%3 !-,,2 H$%,, -)"U2)H./, #$"%,1"2(!3,@74 4!$2! ".#! +7"7 /)79+'1-&'*. N2 27 '!#*%!!%131# -#&(2&7 21 &975 !" E4")&!21#*2!4 /!-:'!)72&&, 2! & --7# -+7A - 31"#0$972&7 !'2!+&:'7#*2! +A!9+'- 47$90 E4")&!214& — %1% !%131:#!+*, &A 2142!,! 472*C7, @74 +@&'1#& [email protected].

D'49,.!, !+)">+/2!,$H-).)

T1>%# K&@1)9+!2,/)7/!91-1'7#* & E4":)&!#!, &3 479&8&2+:%!> C%!#. "!#*2&8.H-('!,! M7!),&( -=!29!27, ,!-!)&' !"E'!4 9!/!#2&'7#*2!4!"4127 - +'1'*7 $0):21#1 Anatomy andEmbryology8, %!'!)1(2791-2! ".#1 !/0"#&:%!-121 - $0)21#1AScience9 & NewScientist.10

D1% ,!-!)&' +14K&@1)9+!2, !2 -+7,91@0-+'-!-1#, @'! + )&:+02%14& M7%%7#( @'!:'! 27 '1%, «/!'!40 @'!!2& /)!+'! 27 +!!'-7:'+'-!-1#& 7,! [K&@1:

)9+!21] /!2&412&5 +%!)!+'&, + %!'!)!> 0 ).",)7/'&#&>, /'&8 & 4#7%!/&'156&A $&-!'2.A )13:-&-15'+( &A !'#&@&'7#*2.7 !+!"722!+'&»8. N227 +4!, !"21)0$&'* 2&%1%&A 9122.A, 0%13.-15:6&A 21 '!, @'! %'!:#&"! L1%'&@7+%& +)1-2&-1#E4")&!2. )132.A -&9!-, '. 7. «2&%'! 27 /)79+:'1-#(# %1%&A:#&"! +)1-2&'7#*2.A 9122.A - /!9:97)$%0 E'!> &97&»8.

; +-(3& + E'&4 K&@1)9+!2 +!")1# 47$9021:)!9205 %!41290 9#( &30@72&( &L&%+18&& «-27C27,! -&91 E4")&:!2!- )13#&@2.A -&9!- /!3-!2!@:2.A $&-!'2.A 21 '!> +'19&&, 21%!'!)!> $&-!'2.7 &3!")1$72. 21)&+02%1A M7%%7#(»8.

D!41291 +!")1#1 E4")&!2.39 )13#&@2.A $&-!'2.A, -%#5@1(E4")&!2. +04@1'.A &3 J-+')1:#&&, 9)7-7+2.A #(,0C7% &3 G0E):'!:K&%!, 347> &3 W)128&& & 1##&:,1'!)1 &3 J2,#&&. ?.! $H.)+40!*

%!, 92$ :-H+!$./ +)'%!9./8 (!1$( "45,"2*(,..$ $2%!9)<2"3. ; 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'&, E4":)&!2. !%131#&+* 21+'!#*%! 27/!A!$&4& 21 '7,%!'!).7 &3!")13&# M7%%7#* (+A!92.7 47$90 +!:"!> E4")&!2. @7#!-7%1, %)!#&%1, +1#14129).,)."., %0)&8. & '. 9.), @'! [email protected] /)&C#& % !9:2!321@2!40 -.-!90: +!"4.>! W,>>,%3 ($$H5,., -$7%! H/2& "$"2)(%,./ .) $".$(, +,)%&*

./8 :-H+!$.$(.B&,7#* U!%+ -3(# 0 K&@1)9+!21 &2'7)-*5 9#(

&3912&( The Times (=!29!2)11. ;+'1'*7, - %!'!)!> M7%%7#* 213-12«E4")&!21#*2.4 #$78!4», U!%+8&'&)07' K&@1)9+!21:

«?'! !9&2 &3 +14.A A09C&A/)&47)!- 210@2!,! !"4121. Q$1+:2! !"21)0$&'*, @'! &3-7+'2.> 0@7:2.> 04.C#722! --7# -+7A - 31":#0$972&7. V -!340672 E'&4… M7%:%7#* /)!+'! -3(# @7#!-7@7+%&>E4")&!2 & /7)7)&+!-1# 7,!, +!3:91- -&9&4!+'* '!,!, @'! E4")&!2.+1#14129)., +-&2*& & -+7A 9)0,&A$&-!'2.A -.,#(9(' !9&21%!-! 21!92!> +'19&& )13-&'&(. B1 +14!497#7 !2& +!-+74 27 /!A!$&… S,!E4")&!2. — /!997#%&».11

M7%%7#* 27 '!#*%! &3472&# )&+02%& /0'74 9!:"1-#72&(, 0/0672&( & &347272&( 121'!4&:@7+%&A !+!"722!+'7>, 2!, /! +#!-14 K&@1:)9+!21 & 7,! %!4129.:

«N2 '1%$7 &3472&# )1347)., @'!". /)7:0-7#&@&'* +A!9+'-1 +)79& )132.A -&9!-,91$7 27+4!')( 21 '!, @'! )1347). 27%!'!:).A E4")&!2!- !'#&@1#&+* 9)0, !' 9)0,1 -97+('* )13. D)!47 '!,!, M7%%7#* +97#1# +0:67+'-056&7 !'#&@&( 27(+2.4&, - "!#*C&:2+'-7 +#0@17- /)!+'! 27 213.-1( -&9. $&:-!'2.A, +#!-2! !9&2 /)79+'1-&'7#* - '!@:2!+'& +!!'-7'+'-!-1# -+7> ,)0//7 $&-!':2.A»9.

; 1874 ,. /)!L7++!) U&+ /)!-!3,#1+&#)&+02%& ?)2+'1 M7%%7#( #!$2.4& & -%#5:@&# &A - /)&3212&7, (%!". +97#122!7 M7%:%7#74, 2! %1% 0'-7)$917' K&@1)9+!2:

«G)&3212&7 M7%%7#( 2&@7,! 27 +'!&#!,/!+%!#*%0 -/!+#79+'-&& 7,! )&+02%& ".#&&+/!#*3!-12. - 1901 ,. - %2&,7 «<1)-&2 &/!+#7 <1)-&21» & C&)!%! )1+'&)1$&)!-1:2. - 12,#!([email protected] '7%+'1A /! "&!#!,&&»9, 12.

H'120' #& "&"#&!'7%1)&, &391'7#& & /)!:91-8. E-!#58&!22!> #&'7)1'0). &3.41'*&3 !")1672&(, /7)7/&+.-1'* 0@7"2&%& &/)&321-1'* '!' L1%', @'! &97( !" E4")&!:

21#*2.A +A!9+'-1A, /!9'-7)$9156&A E-!#58&5,+')!&'+( 21 210@2!4 !"4127?

E)"",% WEDWWwww.creation.com

V"/%>! ! #+!-,9).!3:1. D1$0677+( +A!9+'-! )13#&@2.A E4")&!2!- /)&-#7%#! -2&:

412&7 3!!#!,!- 767 9! M7%%7#(, -%#5@1( <.W. T7%7#((1781:1883), M.U. K1'%7 (1793:1860) & ?'*721 K.A. H7))7+1(1786:1868), %!'!).> -.-7# '7!)&5, +!,#1+2! %!'!)!> E4":)&!2. -.+C&A $&-!'2.A /)!A!9(' +'19&&, /!A!$&7 21 +'1:9&& 2&3C&A $&-!'2.A, 1 '1%$7 K. -!2 R1E)1 (1792:1876), %!:'!).> ".# %)718&!2&+'!4 & 1%'&-2! /)!'&-!+'!(# %1% E'!>

'!@%7 3)72&(, '1% & 91)-&2&340 - 87#!4(Encyclopaedia Britannica, 1992; 1:789).F4722! M7%%7#* /!/0#()&3!-1# E'0 &975, &+:/!#*30( '1%05 314.+#!-1'05 L)130, %1% «!2:'!,7273 /!-'!)(7' L&#!,7273» ('.7. -20')&0':)!"2!7 )13-&'&7 @7#!-7@7+%!,! E4")&!21(-#(7'+( /!-'!)72&74 C1,!- - /)79/!#1,17:4!4 E-!#58&!22!4 /!(-#72&& @7#!-7%1 &3/)&4&'&-2!,! +067+'-1). 2. M)&,, K. «?)2+' M7%%7#*: /)!/!-792&%E-!#58&& & 1/!+'!# #$&» // Creation. —1996; 18 (2):33:36. ;7)20'*+( % '7%+'0.3. B1/)&47), E-!#58&!2&+' H'&-72 <. M!0#9+%131#: «F '7!)&( E4")&!21#*2!,! /!-'!)7:2&(, & «#7+'2&@2.> /!9A!9» % %#1++&L&%1:8&&, %!'!)05 !2 /!997)$&-17', 21 +7,!92((-#(5'+( &#& 9!#$2. (-#('*+( 27ELL7%'&-:2.4&». H4.: H&29)!4 9!%'!)1 <1021 //Natural History. — 1980; 89:144. ;3('! &3 )1:"!'. T!))&+ M. <#&221( -!>21 /)!'&- R!,1.— T&@&,12: F391'7#*+'-! Baker Book House,

1989. — H. 139. 4. B1/)&47), World Book Encylopedia, 1994; 6:409:410; Collier's Encyclopedia, 1994; 2:138; H1,12 D. <)1:%!2. ?9741. — =!29!2: F391'7#*+'-! Book ClubAssociates, 1977. — H. 57:58.5. D)718&!2&+'. ,!914& ,!-!)&#& ! '!4, @'! +A!9+'-!27 (-#(7'+( /!9'-7)$972&74 +067+'-!-12&( !"67,!/)79%1, 1 4!$7' -!32&%1'* -+#79+'-&7 !"67,! 9&31>:21, !"6&A /0'7> '7A2&@7+%!> /)!90%'&-2!+'& & '.9.H4.: HA!9+'-! <BD @7#!-7%1 & C&4/1237 — 9!%13.:-17' #& !2! !"677 /)!&+A!$972&7? 6. B1/)&47), M&#"7)' H. R&!#!,&( )13-&'&(. 5:7 &3:912&7. — T1++1@0+7'+: F391'7#*+'-! SinauerAssociates, 1997. — H. 254, 900, ,97 M&#"7)' !C&"1:7'+(, /)&/&+.-1( 1-'!)+'-! )&+02%!- «K!4127+0,1901 ,!9». J '1%$7 <$!2+!2 <.R. Biology. — H72':=0:&+: F391'7#*+'-! Mosby — Year Book, 1992. — H. 396. 7. B1/)&47), U!,#129 T., <!"+!2 R. - )1"!'7 D1%L02%8&!2&)07' $&32*. — =!29!2: F391'7#*+'-!Ebury Press, 1995. — H. 174 /)79+'1-#(5' )&+02%&M7%%7#( - /!#2!4 8-7'7 — 2& "!#*C7, 2& 472*C7! 8. K&@1)9+!2 T. & 9). Anatomy and Embryology. —1997; 196 (2):91:106. 9. G722&+& ?. ?4")&!2. M7%%7#(: +2!-1 )1+%).'!"412 // Science. — 5 +72'(")( 1997; 277(5331):1435. 10. ?4")&!22.> !"412 /)!9!#$17' $&'* // NewScientist. — 6 September 1997; 155 (2098):23. 11. U!%+ B. The Times (=!29!2). — 11 1-,0+'1 1997.— H. 14. 12. D)718&!2&+'. -+7,91 321#& !" !"4127 M7%%7#(,A!'( & 27 -+7,91 /!9!3)7-1#& ! 41+C'1"1A E'!,!

!"4121. H4.: OE>#!) F. ; 041A @7#!-7@7+%&A. — O!)!2'!:F391'7#*+'-! TFE Publishing, 1986. — H. 185, 275.

!"#. 2 $%&'(") &*+: S#11#6#"(10# 0:+,4&5#%0' %#(1+6910) 4&:60/%-) >*,40+%+", 1+$+4-# 3+1&:-"&;$ %#"#H4+'$%+# ()+8($"+ %& 4&%%#7 «)"+($+"+7 3+/10» ($&800.,"-(") &*+: E+$+@4&G00, (8#6&%%-# N0/&48(+%+*, %& 1+$+4-) 3+1&:&%+, 1&1 %& (&*+* 8#6# "-@6'8'$ >*,40+H%- %& $+7 5# ($&800 4&:"0$0'. (P6#"& %&34&"+: 4-,& Salmo salar, (&6&*&%84& Cryptobranchus allegheniensis, /#H4#3&)& Emys orbicularis, 1.40?& Gallus gallus, 14+601 Oryctolagus cuniculus, /#6+"#1 Homo sapiens.) I%+@0# (+"4#H*#%%-# >"+6;?0+%0($- ,+69=# %# :&'"6';$, /$+ «/#6+"#/#(107 >*,40+% " ("+#* 4&:"0$00 3+"$+4'#$ ":4+(6-#($&800 >$0) 34#83+6&@&#*-) >"+6;?0+%%-) 34#81+"», %+, "(# 5#, ((-6&;$(' %& 40(.%10 S#11#6' ("#4)%07 4'8) 0@+"+4'$, /$+ «+% 3+"$+4'#$ >*,40+%&69%-# ($&800». K8%&1+ .5# 0:"#($%+, /$+ $&1+# (+*%0$#69%+# 3+8$"#458#H%0# >"+6;?00 ($4+0$(' %& G&69=0"-) 40(.%1&).

R$--,.2)+!! 9!2)2,%,;:.-/( M., T"($4&60', 7 +1$',4' 2009 @.H/1+&"! 31 E'0 +'1'*5. Q@7"2&% /! "&!#!,&&4!7> 11:#7'27> 9!@7)& (+)792(( C%!#1 -B!-!4 P$2!4 QE#*+7), 21/&+122!4 - 2006 ,.,9! +&A /!) +!97)$&' )&+02%& M7%%7#(. Q9&-&:'7#*2!: E'!40 !"4120 "!#77 100 #7', 1 !2 9!+&A /!) /)7/!92!+&'+( %1% L1%'.

!/( T., PWT, 18 +1$',4' 2009 @.V /)7/!91-1# - C%!#7 21 /)!'($72&& "!#7735 #7'. ;! -+7A 0@7"2&%1A, &39122.A ,#1-2.4&&391'7#*+'-14&, %!'!).7 ( %!,91:#&"! -&97#,+!97)$1#&+* M7%%7#7-+%&7 )&+02%& E4")&!:2!-, 1 +14& 0@7"2&%& !".@2! /)79+'1-#(#&E'& )&+02%&, %1% 9!%131'7#*+'-! E-!#58&&.T2!,&7 9)0,&7 «9!%131'7#*+'-1» E-!#58&&'1%$7 0$7 91-2! !/)!-7),20'.: 21/)&47),E%+/7)&472' T&##7)1, %#5-. 3("#&%!- & '. 9.

!"#. 1 D:"#($%&' (0 3+:+4%&') S#11#6#"(1&' (#40' 0: 24 40(.%1+", 1+$+4&' 0:+,4&5&H#$ "+(#*9 4&:60/%-) >*,40+%+" %& $4#) ($&80') "%.$40.$4+,%+@+ 4&:"0$0', +3.,60H1+"&%%&' S#11#6#* " S#4*&%00 " 4&,+$# Anthropogenie (1874).

© S

pringerHVerlag Gm

bH &

Co., Tiergartenstrasse, 69121 S#78#69,#4@, S#4*

&%0'.

K13#&@2.7 E4")&!2. 21 )13#&@2.A +'19&(A, L!:'!,)1L&& T1>%#1 K&@1)9+!21. N")1'&'7 -2&412&721 '!, %1% !2& !'#&@15'+( !9&2 !' 9)0,!,! & !' /!9:97#*2.A )&+02%!- M7%%7#(N-,&

F.40?&

P"0%9'

Y#6+"#1

$:1*" '*!3'5, =*"$#$B-('& $?(.8:'&, 1:& &;$' $? 8-"#@ 6+<'#@ ,6&,-/-';$8:&( F(&%=7$$ ,&;;.%-% '.8*&%+*& 6$80'*&(…

O :&%+*& :.,.6+ 8:-%$ $?(.8:'# "-8):-2# F:&/& (&,$=D./& &2"-'-.


N0(.%10 S#11#6'

2 8#7($"0$#69%+($0

Q." '. ".'.., ;& 8$@,&6 (& "'&/[email protected]'$*-@ $;.=F"26$&'-%+'&/&,&(:&6.'$<

,6.;8:-(%<=: *-*,&;:(.64;.'$.:.&6$$ F(&%=7$$.

T &:(.: 4.08%#)-%$

,6$?'-'$., (*&:&6&" C.**.%+

&2($'$% ( '.:&1'&"8&8:-(%.'$$

6$80'*- @0;&4'$*-,'. 8&?'-()$8+ (:&", 1:& F:$"@0;&4'$*&"

<(%<.:8< &' 8-"!

P8#6&%%-# N0/&48(+%+* G+$+@4&G00 >*,40+%+" %&«)"+($&$+7» ($&800 0) 4&:"0$0' (" +8%+* 0 $+* 5# 4&:H*#4#) 8#*+%($404.;$ +@4+*%-# +$60/0' *#58. >*,H40+%&*0 4&:60/%-) "08+" 50"+$%-).


"1%12027 -.A!91 21 E%)12. L&#*41«Z7'-7)'.> '&/» 214, %1% @#7214 47$:9021)!92!,! %)718&!22!,! +#0$72&( -

HIJ, ".# )13)7C72 7,! +/78&1#*2.> /)79-1)&:'7#*2.> /)!+4!'). V !9&2 &3 2742!,&A A)&+'&:12, )13!"#1@156&A (-#72&( B=N, %!#&@7+'-!%!'!).A - /!+#79277 -)74( 270%#!22! )1+'7'.

I41&2, .)7$2$(,; HIJ -!%)0, «Z7'-7)'!,! '&/1» 0$7 !),12&3!:

-1#& "!#*C05 C04&A0 & 1%'&-205 )7%#140. K7%#14:2!7 !")1672&7 % 3)&'7#(4 ".#! +!-7)C722! !/)7:97#722.4: «T. /)79+'1-#(74 9!%0472'1#*2059)140, !+2!-12205 21 )71#*2.A +!".'&(A, 97'1#*:2!4 &++#79!-12&& )71#*2.A /)!&+C7+'-&> & )7:1#*2!4 1)A&-2!4 41'7)&1#7, @'!". /!%131'*, @'!&2!/#127'(27 & - +14!4 97#7 /!A&61#& #597>».

N921%! /!+#7 /)!+4!')1 L&#*41 :2$ ')3(*%,.!, ., #$12(,+1!%$"&. S+#& @'! & ".#! +!:-7)C722! !/)797#722.4, '1% E'! )7%#1421(#!$*, /!+%!#*%0 2&%1%!,! «)71#*2!,!» !'+2('!,!41'7)&1#1 ! /!A&672&& #597> %1%&4&:'! +067:+'-14& - L&#*47 /)79+'1-#72! 27 ".#!.

V2+)U.$, >!.$G7)79 /!%13!4 L&#*41 (/!392! 2!@*5, /)1%:

'&@7+%& - /0+'!4 %&2!31#7) 81)&#1 $0'%1( 1'4!+:L7)1. N21 +'1#1 767 "!#77 3#!-767>, %!,91 1%':)&+1 T&##1 [!-!-&@ 31(-&#1 + E%)121, @'! !21 &,:)17' /+&A!#!,1 &3 «)71#*2!> $&32&» — 9!%'!)1?""&,7># ?4&#& O1>#7), 1 - L&#*47 &+/!#*3!-1:2. L)1,472'. )71#*2! !'+2('.A &2'7)-*5 +#59*4&, 1 '1%$7 +!")122.7 /!#&8&7> -&97!41:'7)&1#. +!".'&>, /)!&3!C79C&A - 27"!#*C!4,!)!9%7 B!4, C'1' J#(+%1. V-21( 87#* '1%&A /)(:4.A 31(-#72&> — 31+'1-&'* 3)&'7#7> /!-7)&'* -'!, -! @'! -7)(' +14& +!391'7#& L&#*41.

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— [!-!-&@ &#& O1>#7), E'! !321@17', @'!21 E%)127 ".#1 &#& [!-!-&@, &#& O1>#7); 7+#&$7 !"1 — 321@&', E%)12 ".# )1397#72: - !92!>7,! @1+'& /!%13.-1#& (%!". /!9#&22.7 41'7)&:

1#. + O1>#7) (&#& 31/&+122.7 75 +!".'&(), 1 -9)0,!> — 1%')&+0 ([!-!-&@), %!'!)1( 77 &,)17'.

K7,)7++&( O1>#7)/[!-!-&@ — E'! /!/.'%1 !$&:-&'* - /14('& ,7)!&2& 2!@* +47)'&77 40$1, /! 77 4272&5, /!,&"C7,!!' )0% 0"&>8.. N921%! -! -)74( /!:9!"2!,! ,&/2!'&@7+%!,! +712+1 !212&%1% 27 4!$7' 0-&97'* #&8! 0"&>:8.. H47)'* 40$1 2127+#1 27&3#7:@&405 90C7-205 )120 27 '!#*%! 7>,2! & 77 97'(4 — +.20:/!9)!+'%0 &4#19C7> 9!@7)&. ;/!+#79+'-&&[!-!-&@ -7)20#1+* % +-!7> 479&8&:2+%!> /)1%'&%7 - ,!)!9%7 B!4, & 4.-&9&4, %1% O1>#7)/[!-!-&@ "7+790:7' + 27+%!#*%&4& /18&72'14&, +')1:9156&4& !' !92!,! & '!,! $7 «2!@:2!,! 0$1+1». G)!+20-C&+*, !2& 274!,0' -+/!42&'*, @'! $7 21 +14!4 97#7 /)!&+A!9&:#! + 2&4&, 31 &+%#5@72&74 '!,!, @'! -+7 !2& /!42('!9&2 !")13 — "7#05 +!-0 -!3#7 !%21. O1>#7)/[!-!:-&@ --!9&' !92!,! &3 /18&72'!- - +!+'!(2&7 ,&/2!:31, & '!' /7)72!+&'+( - +!".'&(, %!'!).7 + 2&4/)!&3!C#&, /7)7$&-1( 0$1+2!7 &+/.'12&7 — 21+:'!#*%! +')1C2!7, @'!, /)!+20-C&+*, !2 27 A!@7')1++%13.-1'* /!9)!"2!+'& 91$7 +-!740 /+&A!'7:)1/7-'0. ; '!' $7 -7@7) E'!' /18&72' 0"&-17' +-!5$720 & 97'7> (E'! /!%13.-15' -!+/)!&3-79722.797>+'-&( & (%!". )71#*2.7 !'+2('.7 /!#&8&7> 41:'7)&1#., @'! +!3917' -!#205677 )71#&+'&@7+%!7!60672&7), '1% %1% !2 27 A!@7', @'!". !2& /7)7$&:#& '!' 0$1+, %!'!).> !2 &+/.'1# +14.

W!#.$' ., 3(%3,2"3.)1,0./- "(!1,2,%&"2($-; +-!7> %2&,7 «;'!)$72&7 &2!/#127'(2:

+-(3* 47$90 B=N & E-!#58&7>» ( ,!-!)5 ! '!4,@'! ,&/2!'&@7+%05 )7,)7++&5, %1% /)1-&#!, &+:/!#*305' &++#79!-1'7#& B=N, /! 4272&5 %!'!:).A /!9+!3212&7 4!$7' -.27+'& 21 /!-7)A2!+'*+!".'&(, %!'!).7 @7#!-7% 27 4!$7' /!42&'*,21A!9(+* - +!3212&&.

N921%! A!)!C! &3-7+'2!, @'! '1%&7 47'!9.4!,0' )1+%).'* '1>2. /)!C#.A +!".'&>. B! !+:2!-21( /)!"#741 31%#5@17'+( - '!4, @'! /+&A!:'7)1/7-', /)&472(( ,&/2!3, 27 4!$7' 321'* 21:-7)2(%1, 97>+'-&'7#*2! #& 7,! /18&72' -+/!4&:217' )71#*2.7 +!".'&(, -79* 21 +7,!92( A!)!C!&3-7+'2!, @'! @7#!-7@7+%&> )1304 & -!!")1$7:2&7 4!,0' +!391-1'* %$0./, ($"#$-!.).!3.

D!27@2! $7, 21&#0@C&4& 321'!%14& - E'!4+4.+#7 (-#(5'+( 97'& — /! +-!7> /)&)!97"!#*C&7 L12'137)., 2! /+&A!#!,&@7+%&7 ')1-:4. '1%$7 4!,0' +')!&'* 9!/!#2&'7#*2.7 -.90:4122.7 +8721)&&, - %!'!).7 %'!:'! 4!$7' /!-7:)&'*, %1% - )71#*2.7 &+'!)&&. Q "!#*C&2+'-1#597> -+/#.-12&7 - /14('& /!9!"2.A +!".'&>/)&-!9&' % 27%!740 +14!0+&#72&5 & +14!!"41:20. F+'!)&& &3 /)!C#!,! 9!/!#2(5'+( & /7)791:5'+( &3 0+' - 0+'1 21+'!#*%! @1+'!, @'! !2& 4!,0'+'1'* «/)1-9!>» - @*7>:'! $&32&. S67 !921/)!"#741 31%#5@17'+( - '!4, @'! +14& /+&A!'7:)1/7-'., /)&472(56&7 ,&/2!3, !+!32122! &#&27!+!32122! @7)73 )13#&@2.7 2147%& +!3915' -047 /18&72'1 -!!")1$174.> +8721)&> &#& +!:".'&7. D1% '!#*%! '1%!> 2147% 0%!)72&#+( — -!:!")1$72&7 & )1304 +97#15' -+7 !+'1#*2!7.

; )730#*'1'7 /)!9!#$&'7#*2!> ,&/2!'&@7+%!>)7,)7++&& !"&'1'7#7> B!41 -.(+2(7'+(, @'! !2&-7)(', @'! #$"+,1! .$9! !8 #$",5)%! .,',-./,"45,"2(), /)!-!9&-C&7 219 2&4& 27#7/.7 E%+/7:

)&472'.. F4722! -! -)74( E'!,! 4!2'1$1 & )7%!:2+')0%8&& !'+2('!,! 41'7)&1#1 4. -&9&4, %1% '7:#1 #597> /)&2&415' &+%)&-#722.7 L!)4., & !2&

/)!2&3.-1567 %)&@1'. V -&97# 27+%!#*%! )7,)7++&>

/)79/!#1,174.A $7)'- /!A&67:2&(, & !2& 97>+'-&'7#*2! &+/.'.:-15' -.3-12205 E'!> /)!8790)!>')1-41'&318&5. F -+7 /!'!40, @'!!2& /7)7$&-15' +!".'&7, %!'!)!7,/! &A 4272&5, + 2&4& /)!&3!C#!— /!A&672&7 &2!/#127'(214&. B!9! +&A /!) (, &++#790( E'! (-#7:2&7, 2& )130 27 -&97# & 27 @&'1# !'!4, @'!". /18&72'. &#& $7)'-.,21A!9(+* - +!+'!(2&& )7,)7++&&,/!92&41#&+* ". - -!390A &#& @'!:". &A '7#1 &3472(#& +-!5 L!)40, 1

%!+'& #!41#&+*, %1% E'! &3!")1$72! - L&#*47. F A!'( 314.+7# +!391'7#7> L&#*41 +!+'!(# -

'!4, @'!". 31+'1-&'* 21+ /!-7)&'* - /!A&672&(!"&'1'7#7> B!41 &2!/#127'(214&, +#0@1&, /)!:&+A!9(6&7 + /18&72'14& - E'!4 L&#*47 -! -)74('1% 213.-174!> )7,)7++&&, "(!1,2,%&"2(4<2 $#+$2!($#$%$0.$-. <7#! - '!4, @'! +! 42!,&4&#59*4& /! -+740 4&)0 & - +14!4 97#7 /)!&+A!:9(' +')122.7 +#0@1&, 2! !2& 2&%1% 27 +-(312. +/!A&672&74 +067+'-14& + 9)0,&A /#127' &#&E%+')147)2!> ;+7#722!>. D!,91 #59& !/&+.-15'/!9)!"2!+'& '!,!, @'! + 2&4& /)!&+A!9&#!, & 91:$7 '!, @'! /!%1312! - E'!4 L&#*47, +!-7)C722!(+2!, @'! +,9& !1,2 $ 148$(./8 #,+,0!().!38.

?'! 97>+'-&'7#*2! '1% -.,#(:9&' — 21/1972&( +!-7)C&#& 27:-&9&4.7 +067+'-1. O1% 213.-17:4.> !'+2('.> 41'7)&1# )7,)7+:+&& $7)'- /!A&672&( !@72* 21/!:4&217' 1,-$.!9,">4< $1,+0!*-$"2& & +&'018&5, !/&+.-17405- T1)%1 9:17:26, ,97 F&+0+ &+87#&# 4!#!9!,!52!C0, !97)$&4!,! 3#.4 90A!4. N" &3,212&&3#!,! 90A1 - R&"#&& +%1312!: «F, -+%)&%20- &+&#*2! +!')(+C& 7,!, -.C7#; & !2 +97#1#+(, %1%47)'-.>, '1% @'! 42!,&7 ,!-!)&#&, @'! !2 047)».

A!9,7$ .$($7$ #$1 "$%.Q,-(G>>%,"!)"2 1:9)G!%13122.7 - E'!4 L&#*47 /)&47). (A!'( & 27

21+'!(6&7) /! +-!7> +')0%'0)7 !@72* /!A!$& 21/)79/!#!$&'7#*2! «)71#*2.7» /!A&672&( &2!/:#127'(214&, & E'& «)71#*2.7» $545,.!3 #$1$H*./ .)"2$35!- 148$(./- #,+,0!().!3-. B1/:)&47), E'!' L&#*4 /)79/!#1,17', @'! #597>97>+'-&'7#*2! /!A&61#& &2!/#127'(27, %!'!).7-A!9&#& - &A +/1#*2& @7)73 +'72. &#& /!'!#!%, &@'! $7)'-. /!A&672&( /!%&91#& +-!& 9!41 '1%&4$7 !")13!4. N921%! '1%&7 97>+'-&( /)!'&-!)7@1'31%!214 L&3&%&. D)!47 '!,!, !@7-&92!, @'! /!9-7:

),C&7+( E%+/7)&472'14 #59& 9!#$2. ".#& &47'*"!#732722.7 )12., @7)73 %!'!).7 &2!/#127'2.7+067+'-1 --!9&#& - 2&A 3!29., !921%! - L&#*47!2& 27 &475' .!>)>!8 #+!'.)>$( '!,!, @'! + 2&4&/)!-!9&#&+* '1%&7 /)!8790).. ;47+'! '!,! @'!".)1+%).'* E'!' 27)71#*2.> '!2%&> !"412, %!'!).>-%#19.-17'+( - 04. #597> + 87#*5 +!3912&( «)7:1#*2!+'&», 1-'!). L&#*41, 1 -47+'7 + 2&4& &"!#*C&2+'-! &++#79!-1'7#7> B=N - 4&)7 +@&'1:5', @'! &2!/#127'(27 «9!#$2.» !"#191'* 27&3-7:+'2.4& 0+!-7)C72+'-!-122.4& '7A2!#!,&(4& &#&+&#14&, /!+%!#*%0 /! E-!#58&!22.4 47)%14 E'&+067+'-1 +'1)C7 & 04277 #597>.

F97( ! +067+'-!-12&& -.+!%!)13-&'!> -27:3742!> L!)4. $&32& !+2!-.-17'+( 21 '7!)&&E-!#58&&, /!'!40 @'! 7+#& $&32* E-!#58&!2&:)!-1#1 21 X74#7, !21 9!#$21 ".#1 E-!#58&!2&:)!-1'* ,97:'! 767 — -!34!$2!, 31 4&##&!2. #7'9! /!(-#72&( @7#!-7@7+'-1. J 321@&', &4722! /!:

E'!40 &2!/#127'(27 !"#1915' '1%&4& /)!,)7+:+&-2.4& '7A2!#!,&(4&, -!+/)&2&4156&4&+(%1% «-!#C7"+'-!». R&"#&( @7'%! ,!-!)&' ! '!4,@'! 27-7)056&7 #59& 27 +/!+!"2. )13#&@1'* 90:

A!-2.7 -76&. J/!+'!# G1-7# /&:+1#: «<0C7-2.> @7#!-7% 27 /)&:2&417' '!,!, @'! !' <0A1 R!$&(,/!'!40 @'! !2 /!@&'17' E'! "730:4&74; & 27 4!$7' )13047'*, /!'!:40 @'! ! +74 219!"2! +09&'* 90:A!-2!» (1 D!)&2L(214 2:14).

S2$ ($#+$" -!+$($''+,.!3;+7 E'! 767 )13 /!%13.-17' 214, %1% 0"7$97:

2&7 @7#!-7%1 ! /)!&+A!$972&& -#&(7' 21 '!, %1:%&4 !")13!4 !2 &2'7)/)7'&)07' «-+7 9122.7»: !'&+%!/174.A - 374#7 9! 91#7%&A 3-739 & 91$7+')122.A !%%0#*'2.A !60672&>, &+/.'.-174.A#59*4& - +-!&A +/1#*2(A. W&#*4 «Z7'-7)'.>'&/» '1%$7 )73%! %)&'&%07' A)&+'&12+%05 -7)0.T. -&9&4, %1% [!-!-&@ 4!#&'+( -47+'7 + 97'*4&31 +'!#!4, 1 /!39277, %!,91 !21 /.'17'+( /!2('*/)&@&20 0$1+2.A +!".'&>, /)!&3!C79C&A - 77$&32&, +/)1C&-17' R!,1: «G!@740?». N21 03217',@'! 77 40$ '1%$7 /.'1#+( )1+%).'* '1>20 B!41.

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— +14!/)!-!3,#1:C722!,! +/78&1#&+'1 /! E'&4 '1"#&@%14, 31(-#(:567,!, @'! '-!)8. @7#!-7%1 — &2!/#127'(27, &3:-7+'2.7 - E'&A C047)+%&A '7%+'1A %1% T%%.%&10, 1- R&"#&& — %1% J21%&4. (R!#77 97'1#*2! E'!' -!/:)!+ )1++4!')72 - +'1'*7 «;'!)$72&7 &2!/#127'(2:+-(3* 47$90 B=N & E-!#58&7>»).

V?M=?EGADG, S=?KZ^DO D AK?

$:1*" $ &$9%>("%% %"$&-*"(,2"*1% A2?&6 5$%+"- «V.:(.6:#3 :$,»

A8'&('-< ,6&2%."-?-*%=1-.:8< ( :&",1:& ,8$@&:.6-,.(:,,6$".'<< /$,'&?, '.

"&4.: ?'-:+'-(.6'<*-,

;.38:($:.%+'& %$./& ,-7$.':(8,&"$'-.:

6.-%+'#. 8&2#:$<

P:& ;.38:($:.%+'&:-* (#/%<;$: —

'-,-;.'$< 8&(.6)$%$'.($;$"#. 80D.8:(-.

2 G069*# 3+($+'%%+ 0(3+69:.#$(' +,4&: ,#6+7 (+"-.

T1$40(& I066& Z+"+"0/ 0(3+6%'#$ 4+69 8+1$+4&R,,0@#76 R*060 M&76#4.

:7331%!2&7, 21)%!412&(, +14!0"&>+'-1,%!))0/8&( & -!)!-+'-! 21 -+7A 0)!-2(A!"67+'-1, )13-)1', 1#%!,!#&34, )13-!:

9., +&)!'+'-!, 2&67'1, "7+%0#*'0)*7, 3#!"1....-+7 E'! )71#&( 0%)1&2+%!,! +!8&041.

T2!,&7 /!#1,15', @'! !+2!-2!> /)&@&2!>21C7> %1'1+')!L&@7+%!> +!8&1#*2!> +&'018&&7+'* ')092!7 L&212+!-!7 /!#!$72&7 #597>. B!( 0"7$972, @'! E'! +%!)77 +#79+'-&7, 1 27 +14%!)72*. S+#& $7 4. /!+4!')&4 21 '!, @740 0@1'87#.7 /!%!#72&( #597>, 4. %!7:@'! /!>474.

; C%!#1A & ;QX1A 21 /)!'($72&& /!+#792&A')7A /!%!#72&> /)7/!915' E-!#58&5, %!'!)1(0@&', @'! -+` -! -+7#722!> !")13!-1#!+* - )730#*:'1'7 +#0@1>2.A /)&)!92.A /)!87++!- (1 27 ".#!+!'-!)72! $&-.4 R!,!4 '1% & '!,91, %1% ,!-!)&'R&"#&(). Q@7"2&%& /7+')(' /!9!"2.4& L)1314&:«Z7#!-7% — E'! $&-!'2!7, %!'!)!7 &477' '!,! $7!"67,! /)79%1, @'! & 374#(2.7 @7)-&».

<1-1>'7 /!904174 !" E'!4: 7+#& 97'(4 +)1227,! -!3)1+'1 ,!-!)(', @'! !2& — E-!#58&!:

2&)!-1-C&7 $&-!'2.7 & -%#19.-15' E'0 &975 -&A ,!#!-. 9! 16:25 #7', %1%, /! -1C740 4272&5,!2& "090' +7"( -7+'&? S+#& 0@&'* )7"72%1 '!40,@'! !2 — -+7,! #&C* "7++4.+#722.> @7)-(%, %!:'!).> !")13!-1#+( +#0@1>2! 21 /)!'($72&&4&##&!2!- #7', $. "$$2(,2"2(,..$ H41,2 0!2&! #$"24#)2& >)> 9,+(3>, #+,.,H+,7)3 I$0&,;#+)(1$;, (,+$; ! G7$ ')#$(,13-!.

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— 27'.R&"#&( ,!-!)&', @'! %1$9.> @7#!-7% /!+'0/1#

'1%, %1% ".#! /)1-&#*2! - 7,! ,#131A... &@'! 31 E'&4 /!+#79!-1#!??? \)$"! J'7/7)* -3,#(2&'7 21 !"67+'-! - Q%)1&:27! V A!@0 +%131'* +#7905677: 7+#&0@&'* 97'7> '!40, @'! !2& — -+7,! #&C*$&-!'2.7, %!'!).7 !")13!-1#&+* 21/)!'($72&& 4&##&!2!- #7' - )730#*'1:'7 +#0@1>2.A 40'18&> ... $.! ! H4142#$"24#)2& >)> 0!($2./,.

X9)1-.> )1++09!% /!9+%13.-17',@'! 7+#& 4. "0974 0@&'* #597> '!40,@'! 4&) +!'-!)72 R!,!4 & @'! #59& 27/)!&3!C#& !' $&-!'2.A, 2! ".#& +!3:912. M!+/!9!4 /! S,! !")130, & @'! +0:67+'-05' 4!)1#*2.7 &+'&2., %!'!).>/)&C#& !' H-('!,!, H/)1-79#&-!,!O-!)81, %!'!).> +09&' @7#!-7%1... '!21C& 97'& & -3)!+#.7 RQ<QO /!+'0:/1'* - !"67+'-7 /!:9)0,!40!

?-!#58&( — 27 '!#*%! ,#0/1( &97(,2! & !/1+21(.

BRMTBKNA?VMN V?M=?EGADO VGW?6AO

&$4(16 6 63'*%"!3$?$$:>(!,#* !,$-/3$ &'$:-(1?

K13042.> X14.+7# | www.origins.org.ua16 M137'1 31+2!-121 29 #&+'!/191 2006 )!%0. X1)7a+')!-121 - T_2_+'7)+'-_ 5+'&8_b Q%)1b2&.H-_9!8'-! H7)_( D; c13786–2760GK -_9 17.03.2008 )!%0. =!8$1!2& U`"2& +)'`( .) +`>. A)>%)1: 25 000 /)&4_)2&%_-.6)2) (!8$14 a 18: 30 ,)092( 2009 ).^` _

F)".$(.!>: D0)!-+*%&> <4&')! J21'!#_>!-&@W$%$(.!; +,1)>2$+: D0)!-+*%&> <4&')! J21'!#_>!-&@B1+,") +,1)>Q`b: Q%)1b21, 4. K_-27, -0#. d. D!2!-1#*8( 7, %-. 184=!1)(.!>: HG< M1-)&#5% H7),_> N#7%+_>!-&@B1+,") 1+4>)+.`: 4 D&b- -0# J29)5672%! 6

8&#*4. & HTF (-#(5'+( 4!62.4 !)0:$&74. T2!,&7 #59& 91$7 27 !+!321:5', @'! /)& /)!+4!')7 /!9!"2!> «&2:

L!)418&&» !2& L1%'&@7+%& /!3-!#(5' '!40, %!:,! !2& +#0C15', )1++%13.-1'* 7,! &+'!)&5 & 91:$7 7,! -7)+&5 /)1-9.. ; )730#*'1'7 !2& +%#!2:2. -7)&'* '!40, +#.C1'.

L+)(1) $ P!%&-,K13!"#1@1( E'0 «/)1-9&-05» 9!%0472'1#*205

&+'!)&5, ( )&+%05 /!#0@&'* 3#!"2.7 /&+*41 !'42!,&A /!%#!22&%!- B=N /! -+740 4&)0, /!E'!40/)!+'! /)&-790 27+%!#*%! 9!+'!-7)2.A L1%'!-:• G)79/!#1,174.A /!A&672&> #597> &2!/:

#127'(214& - B!47 21 J#(+%7 27 ".#!.

X97+* 97>+'-&'7#*2! &+@73#! 42!,! #597>,!921%!, +!,#1+2! )730#*'1'14 )1++#79!-1:2&( WRK, E'! 91$7 27 97#! )0% +7)&>2!,!0"&>8., 1 +#79+'-&7 '%$4#$2+,H%,.!3-.$7!-! 0!2,%3-! :2$7$ 7$+$1>) )%>$*7$%,-, 1 '1%$7 /!+#79+'-&( !@72* A!#!9:2.A 3&4. ;. 4!$7'7 /)!@7+'* !L&8&1#*2!7+!!"672&7 /! E'!40 /!-!90 - TheAnchorage Daily News.

• <!%'!) ?""&,7># O1>#7) — -.4.C#722.>/7)+!21$. B7' 2&%1%&A /&+*4722.A 9122.A,/!9'-7)$9156&A 77 /)7".-12&7 - ,!)!97B!4 21 J#(+%7.

• H!391'7#& L&#*41 27 /)79+'1-&#& 2&%1%&A9!%131'7#*+'- - /!9'-7)$972&7 +-!&A 31(-:

#72&> ! )71#*2!+'& +!".'&>, !'+2('.A 41'7:)&1#!- & '.9.

• ;#1+'& B!41 31(-#(5', @'! 2&%1%&A /!9!":2.A /)!&+C7+'-&>, !/&+122.A - L&#*47, -&A ,!)!97 27 /)!&+A!9&#!.

• ; L&#*47 +%1312!, @'! &4721 97>+'-056&A#&8 ".#& &347272. (-%#5@1( &4( !L&87)1/!#&8&&) 9#( &A $7 "73!/1+2!+'&, 1 - %!287L&#*41 +!!"617'+(, @'! E'& #59& !'%131#&+*91-1'* &2'7)-*5 &#& 0@1+'-!-1'* - L&#*47.?'! !@72* 09!"2!, /!'!40 @'! '1%&4 !")13!42&%'! 27 4!$7' /)!-7)&'* )71#*2!+'* /)79:/!#1,174.A +!".'&> &#& &2'7)-*5.

• ; F2'7)27'7 -2731/2! /!(-&#&+* '1% 213.:-174.7 &2L!)418&!22.7 -7":+1>'., /!9':-7)$9156&7 /!9#&22!+'* /)79/!+.#!% &97>+'-056&A #&8 L&#*41, !+!"722! #&@2!+:'& ?""&,7># O1>#7). ;+%!)7".#! 0+'12!-#72!, @'! 42!,&7&3 E'&A +1>'!- ".#& +!3912.31 +@&'122.7 2797#& — 2731:9!#,! 9! +'&A12&( )7%#142!:,! "041 -!%)0, L&#*41.

• ; !/&+12&(A /!A&672&>&2!/#127'(214& 27' 2&%1%!,!!")131 "7#!> +!-.. F3!")1:$72&7 +!-., -7)!('2!, ".#!/!31&4+'-!-12! &3 +%129&21:-+%!,! 4&L1, - %!'!)!4 /!(:-&-C1(+( 2&!'%091 "7#1(/'&81 /)!%#&217' +74*5 & !$&-#(7' 47)':-.A.

• ;7+* L&#*4 %1$7'+( !92&4 +/#!C2.4 -.:4.+#!4, A!'* & &3!")1$722.4 + /!3&8&& #7:,729 ! /!A&672&(A. T7'!9 0'-7)$972&(, @'!)71#*2! !'+2('.7 41'7)&1#. &2'7)-*5 (@0'*#& 27 /)[email protected] 9#( +747>2!,! /)!+:4!')1) (-#(5'+( /!9#&22.4&, !@72* /!A!$ 21'1%'&%0, &+/!#*307405 - '1%&A L&#*41A, %1%«;79*41 &3 R#7)» & «<!%0472'1#*2.7 41'7:)&1#. ! -+%).'&& &2!/#127'2!,! +067+'-1».

D0#*4&218&7> L&#*41 (-#(7'+( !'%).'&7,@'! +141 O1>#7)/[!-!-&@ — $7)'-1 /!A&672&(.;! -)74( !92!,! &3 E%+/7)&472'!- 77 9!@* '1%$7/!A&615' &2!/#127'(27, & !21 2&%!,91 27 -!3-:)1617'+(. ;! -)74( )7,)7++&& + 87#*5 -!++'1:2!-#72&( +!".'&( !21 /7)7$&-17' 0$1+2!7 /!:A&672&7, %!'!)!7 /)!#&-17' +-7' 21 -+7 /)!&+:A!9(677. B! )7,)7++&( /)&@&2(7' L&3&@7+%&> &E4!8&!21#*2.> -)79 O1>#7)/[!-!-&@, %!'!)1(-/!+#79+'-&& )1++%13.-17', @'! 77 40$ 27 ".#0"&', 1 /!%!2@&# $&32* +14!0"&>+'-!4 — -7)!:('2!, &3:31 /7)7$&'!,! /!9!"2!,! /!A&672&(.

N@7-&92!, @'! O1>#7)/[!-!-&@ -+7,91 321#1

!" E'!4, 2! 27 A!'7#1 - E'! -7)&'*, '1% %1% + E'&4!@72* ')092! & "!#*2! $&'*. B14 ,!-!)(', @'! !2190C7-2!"!#*21(, 1 321@&', 3)&'7#* +!427-17'+(- '!4, @'! /)!&3!C79C77 + 27> ".#! )71#*:2!+'*5. ; L&21#*2.A +8721A 4. -&9&4 O1>#7)/)&%!-122!> % &2-1#&92!> %!#(+%7, & 0 277 "7)7'&2'7)-*5 )71#*2.> 1-'!) +8721)&( L&#*41 &9&)7%'!) Z7/472+%!,! 02&-7)+&'7'1 ()71#*2.>02&-7)+&'7', 2! 7,! +!')092&%& !')&815', @'!%!,91:#&"! ")1#& E'& &2'7)-*5 & 321#& O1>#7)).

F -+7:'1%& &3!")1$72&7 &3)12722!> O1>#7)!%13.-17' 90C7)139&)15677 97>+'-&7. B7+4!':)( 21 '!, @'! !/&+12&7 4!$7' ".'* -.4.C#722.4,)71#*2!+'* 21+'!#*%! +7)*732! &3)12722.A #5:97> !@7-&921 '!#*%! '74, %'! +-(312 + &++#79!-1:2&74 /!A&672&>. ; 97>+'-&'7#*2!+'& /7)79 214&)71#*2!7 +-&97'7#*+'-! &3472&-C&A+( & )13"&:'.A $&327> — )730#*'1' 97>+'-&( 3#.A #597>, &+:

/!#*3056&A '1%05 !"412205 & )13)0C&'7#*205/)1%'&%0, %!'!)1( ,27-&' R!,1 & !'-!)1@&-17' !'B7,! '7A, %!,! N2 #5"&'. D +!$1#72&5, +-7'+%&7&++#79!-1'7#& 31".-15' !" E'!4 L1%'7. G!+#79:2(( +8721 + O1>#7) /!#2!+'*5 &A )13!"#1@17'. F2:'7)-*57) +/)1C&-17': «;. ,!-!)&#&, @'! !2&[&2!/#127'(27] 213.-15' +7"( R!,!4». O1>#7) !':-7@17': «B7', !2& /)&'-!)(5'+(, @'! !2& R!,».

I$%&U$; $H-).=597> 27 /!A&61#& &2!/#127'(27. A,2 .!>)*

>!8 (.,',-./8 +)", :($%<Q!$.!+$()(U!8 .)1+47!8 #%).,2)8. R!, 27 +!'-!)&# /!9!"2.A )1+21 9)0,&A /#127'1A. N921%! +! 42!,&4& #59*4&)71#*2! /)!&+A!9(' 0$1+2.7 +#0@1&, -&2!-2&%1:4& %!'!).A (-#(5'+( !"412@&-.7 /19C&7 12,7#.& 974!2.. ?'& +067+'-1 +!3915' 31/0'12205 C1:

)190, %!'!)1( /!997)$&-17' '7!:)&5 E-!#58&&, /!9).-15605 31:%!22!7 47+'! R!,1 %1% ]1)( ;+7:#722!>. N60672&( 4!,0' ".'* )7:1#*2.4&, 1 -!' C1)191 27'. D1% !':47'&#& 27%!'!).7 &3-7+'2.7A)&+'&12+%&7 %!4472'1'!).:«…%1% 4!$2! -7)&'* - '!, @'! "0%:-1#*2! '.+(@& &2!/#127'(2 /)7!:9!#7#& 4&##&!2. &#& 4&##&1)9.+-7'!-.A #7' /)!+'! 9#( '!,!, @'!:". 210@&'* #597> L&#!+!L&& B!:-!,! -7%1, !'-7),1'* A)&+'&12+'-!

& /!997)$&-1'* !%%0#*'&34... X1@74 &4 /!+'!(2:2! -)1'* 214 ! '!4, @'!, %1% 214 &3-7+'2!, (-#(7':+( /)1-9!>, & /!@740 !2& 04.C#722! !"412.-1:5' #597>, + %!'!).4& -A!9(' - %!2'1%'?»1.

;+7 '!, @'! -. 397+* @&'17'7, /)!/&'12! "!#*5,%!'!)05 &+/.'.-15' E'& #59&. T2!,&7 &3 2&A 2&:%!,91 27 ".#& - ]7)%-&, 2&%!,91 27 @&'1#& R&"#&& &27 3215' F&+0+1 U)&+'1 %1% +-!7,! H/1+&'7#(. G!+0'&, E'&A #597> #7,%! !"4120'*, & '1%&7 L&#*4.,%1% «Z7'-7)'.> '&/»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

T., +!')092&%& 47$9021)!92!,! %)718&!2:2!,! +#0$72&(, 219774+(, @'! ]7)%!-* /!>47'!@7-&9205 &+'&20: -!/)!+ ! /)!&+A!$972&& (-:#(7'+( ,#1-2.4 -!/)!+!4 /)1%'&@7+%& - %1$9!41+/7%'7 +&+'74. -7)!-12&(. T272&7 @7#!-7%1 !'!4, !'%091 !2 /)&C7# - E'!' 4&), - %!287 %!2:8!-, -#&(7' & 21 7,! 4272&7 ! +4.+#7 $&32&, 27:31-&+&4! !' '!,!, 7+'* #& +#790561( $&32* /!+:#7 E'!>, 1 '1%$7 (-#(7'+( #& X74#( 79&2+'-72:2!> 31+7#722!> /#127'!> -! ;+7#722!>. R&"#&(+!97)$&' !'-7'. 21 -+7 E'& -!/)!+..

«F /!3217'7 &+'&20, & &+'&21 +97#17' -1++-!"!92.4&» (F!1221 8:32).

W)+! [email protected]

V"/%>):1. J2%7)"7), <., ;7#9!2 <. W1%'. !" B=N & 9)0,&7 +-7)AY:

7+'7+'-722.7 (-#72&(. — P9$&2, N)7,!2: F391'7#*+'-!Harvest House Publishers, 1992. — H. 8. ;7)20'*+( % '7%+'0.

V?M=?EGADG, S=?KZ^DO D AK?

%&/&6+ %& 15 ($4.

$:1*" $ &$9%>("%% %"$&-*"(,2"*1%A2?&6 5$%+"- «V.:(.6:#3 :$,»

O':.6(+=.6: «T#/&(&6$%$, 1:& &'$[$'&,%-'.:<'.]'-?#(-=: 8.2<G&/&"». Q-3%.6&:(.1-.:: «H.:,

&'$ ,6$:(&6<=:8<,1:& &'$ G&/»

R$--,.2)+!! 9!2)2,%,;:I&4=&6 P., PWT

V ".-C&> +'0972', &30@1-C&> E-!#58&!2:205 "&!#!,&5. V +14 «/7)7$&# %!2'1%' + &2!/:#127'(214& & ".# /!A&672» 9! '!,!, %1% )!9&#:+( +-.C7 @7)73 -7)0 - F&+0+1 U)&+'1 & !+-!"!:9&#+( !' 3#.A 90A!-, ! @74 -. 4!$7'7 /)!@&'1'*- 4!74 +-&97'7#*+'-7 21 alienresistance.com.

V /!@'& 31%!2@&# )1"!'0 219 %2&,!>, /!+-(:6722!> E'!> '747, & (, %!27@2! $7, 21"#5915 31'74, @'! /)!&+A!9&' - 4&)7. H-($&'7+* +! 42!>,7+#& -! -)74( /)!-7972&( /0"#&@2.A 9&+%0+:+&> -14 "097' 20$21 4!( /!4!6* — ( + 09!-!#*:+'-&74 /!!"615+* %1% + '74&, %'! -7)&' - /!A&:672&(, '1% & + '74&, %'! - E'! 27 -7)&'.

N&(( 2., T"($4&60'V /)!+4!')7# /1)0 +1>'!-, %!'!).7 /!9:

97)$&-15' &975 !" B=N, & 9!#$72 +%131'*, @'!-7)1 - +067+'-!-12&7 -273742.A L!)4 $&32&27-7)!('2! +&#*21. V +4!')7# 31/&+* /)7++:%!2L7)728&& + 9!%'!)!4 H'&-72!4 M)&)!4,%!'!).> - 2001 ,. /)&3.-1# /)1-&'7#*+'-! HIJ!+'12!-&'* /)!,)1440 %!+4&@7+%!,! !)0$&(,/!'!40 @'! &2!/#127'(27 /)&A!9(' + 4&)!4! QE'!,! @7#!-7%1 27 ".#! 2&%1%&A 9!%131'7#*+'-'!,!, @'! &2!/#127'(27 /)&#7'1#& 21 X74#5,

2!, '74 27 47277, !2 (& 87#1( ,)0//1 9)0,&A+/&%7)!-) ".# -7+*41 0"79&'7#72. B1 9)0,!4+1>'7 ( /)!@&'1#, @'! 4. 27 &4774 '1%&A 9!%1:31'7#*+'-, /!+%!#*%0 /)1-&'7#*+'-! +%).-17'&A !' 21+ (20 219! $7!). ;7)1 - E-!#58&5 97#1:7' +067+'-!-12&7 - +!+7927> ,1#1%'&%7 37#7:2.A @7#!-7@%!- !@72* /)1-9!/!9!"2.4. V +!:"&)1#+( +%131'* «37#72.A @7#!-7@%!- + T1):+1», 2! '7/7)*, %!,91 214 &3-7+'2!, @'! $&32&21 T1)+7 27', !2& 9!#$2. $&'* !' 21+ 21 )1+:+'!(2&& -+7,! #&C* 100 000 +-7'!-.A #7'…

N,)!42!7 %!#&@7+'-! #597> -7)(' - +0:67+'-!-12&7 &2!/#127'(2, /!'!40 @'! E'! &3:"1-#(7' &A !' /!')7"2!+'& - R!,7 %1% O-!)87.S+#& -. -7)&'7 - E-!#58&5, -1+ 2&@7,! 27+'!&' !"4120'* 767 "!#*C7. T!$7' ".'*, '!!,)!42!7 !"!#*672&7, ! %!'!)!4 ,!-!)&'+( -2 W7++1#!2&%&>814 2:3, %1+17'+( &4722! 97:('7#*2!+'& &2!/#127'(2. D2&,1 M1)& «;'!)$7:2&7 &2!/#127'(2» 0"79&'7#*2! )1++%13.-17'! '!4, @'! +067+'-!-12&7 &2!/#127'(2 (-#(:7'+( )730#*'1'!4 97>+'-&( 974!2&@7+%&A+&#. ?>, 7+#& '7/7)* K&@1)9 <!0%&23 +%1$7',@'! 21 /#127'7 X!)% $&-0' &2!/#127'(27, '!!"!#*672&7 — E'! L12'1+'&@7+%&> !"412.D1% +%!)! E'!' !"412 +'127' ,!+/!9+'-0567>210%!>? N@72* +%!)!.

/0.(#0.,: C 50/#'5 2010 &%$# &#8,-#«'#86(0)1 8#()2,"»

'#23'%2-'#05,-25 4,23"#-0%! A)U) Q,%& — /)!+#1-#('* O-!)81 & 0'-7)$91'* R!$*5 &+'&20 ! H!'-!)72&& & F+%0/#72&&,@'!". %1% 4!$2! "!#*C7 #597> /)&2(#& S-12,7#&7 & /)!-7#& -7@2!+'* + R!,!4.

R$.2)>2.)3 !.P$+-)Q!3 1%3 ')>)') 7)',2:'7#. 096:747:89:63 &#& 067:364:08:58. e:mail: [email protected]

W)',2) «E)'4-./; F)-/",%» "45,"2(4,2 !">%<9!2,%&.$ .) #$0,+2($().!3. B1 /!9).- 1-'!)&'7'1 R!$*7,! H#!-1 & 21 /)!/1,1290 #$& !" E-!#58&&, 0-!9(67> 4&##&!2.#597> !' R!,1, - 4&)7 ')1'('+( +!'2& 4&##&!2!- 9!##1)!-. B7+4!')( 21 '!, @'! +7,!92(, %1%2&%!,91 )1277, 21%!/#72! !,)!42!7 %!#&@7+'-! +-&97'7#*+'-, /!9'-7)$9156&A R&"#&5 &!/)!-7),156&A E-!#58&5 !' 4!#7%0#. % @7#!-7%0, - C%!#1A /)!9!#$15' !"412.-1'*0@72&%!-. D1% $7 +#!$2! /!+#7 E'!,! 9!+'0@1'*+( % 2&4 + S-12,7#&74!

T. /)&3.-174 -1+ -+'1'* - /)!#!4 31 R!$*5 /)1-90 & +/1+72&7 90C & /!997)$1'* +#0$72&7«K13042.> X14.+7#» 4!#&'-722! & L&212+!-!.

R)01$, ()U, #$0,+2($().!, 4(,%!9!2 >$%!9,"2($.)#,9)2)../8 7)',2.

E,>(!'!2/ 1%3 #$0,+2($().!;:PA[ S&"406;1 P#4@\7 K6#1(\7+"0/ N&).]26000053109932, F+8 ^[NAK<: 2827808796, IEK: 321842, E\6\' «N+:4&).%1+"07 ?#%$4» A40"&$,&%1. 340:%&/#%%' 36&$#5.: :& @&:#$. «N&:.*%-7 V&*-(#6»