Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
,iUNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT.
.. -.
iSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK-
t i,-
'
1
___________________________________x ;
|1
, GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP., !:i et al. , i'
.
|:
Plaintiffs, PLAINTIFFS' FIRST I
-
!
-against- : REQUEST ?OR COCTMINTS I;
:THE BA3 COCK & WILCOX CO.,
80 Civ. 1683 (2.0.)-
and J. RAY MCDERMOTT & CO., INC. : g
Defendants. :____
______________________________xI
S I.R S :.
-
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that plaintiffs, by their !
undersigned attorneys, hereby request that defendants pro-,i4
|'duce and permit plaintiffs 'attorneys to inscect and con.v.+ -
t
each of the following documents pursuant to Rule 34, Federal-
; Rules of Civil Procedure, within thirtv <
(30) davs after. (.,
- -
date of service of this notice, ,
Iat the offices of Kaye,
'Scholer, Fiernan, Hays & Eandler', 425 Park Avenue, New York,N. Y. 10022.
~
DEFINITIONS-
A. The terms "you" or "your" means the defen-pfants, their parents, subsidiaries, =erged or acquiredi
;i. predecessors., affiliates, lpresent and for=er directors, jjefficers, agents, employees and all other persens ac-ing f,1
jor purperting to act on their behalfi .
: 3. The term "perscn" neans, unless c herwiseI
I '
-fspecified,anynaturalperson,.
!
ij fir =, cerpcration, assccia- '
|picn, group or organization. i
4 '
1 !.: .io
8307020214 800515 I.PDR ADOCK 0500028 iO g 13 QMf. Fvh k L
,- _C.The term " document" means cach criginal &
.
'' '
' copy, regardless of origin or location.
, of any written or* *
recorded material,,
including computer stored and ccmputer; retrievable info =mation.
.I .
I D.', ; - The tern " generically * means relating or
. .
applicable to a group or class of plants,,
,
equipmen: c:
| cystems, or not restricted only to a particular nuclear,
,
:!
j plant..?
'
l E.The term "TMI-1"means the Three Mile2; Island Unit No.1
,
t - 3.
*
F.i
The term "TMI-2" means the Three Mile.
la
Island Unit No. 2a
7
f INSTRUCTIONSj A.
Produce all responsive documents createdI
{ prior to the date of service of this request.3.
Produce all documents in a form which'
t
jaccurately reflects their condit' ion as maintained by you inthe nor=al course of business, including but not limited:
|to:
li That all associated file labels, file'
headings and file folders be produced together withthe
responsive-documents from each file and that each file b,
1
e
identified as to its owner or custodian..
2)That all pages now stapled or otherwise
if
astened together be produced stapled or fastened together: ~
.
i: .
That all documents of which a legible ('I 3)'
reproduction cannot be furnished be produced in their[originalfc=n.!
'
.
6
:.l.
u-
- , - - w - - m _ogu-
respect to any document, state with respect to each such-'
.
document- -
thn date thereof, the author, the recipients,-
.'; the subject, the privilege claimed and a descriptien of the- -
document sufficient to:-demonstrate the acclicability o#.
l!' the privilege claimed..
,
i'
D. Defendants shall preserve in their criginal'a form all documents and files which are or ma'y be respensiveP
to all or any part of this request. i;
.i REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION.
i *
1. Each document relating or referring to any , 8,
.
1, transient, incident; accident or event at TMI-2 which-l 3
or to the centinuation;|commenced on or about March 28, 1979,.
:l. causes or effects thereof.:' 2. Each document relating or referring to -
:I
any equipment or system c,onsidered for or actually in I,
fTMI-2, including without limitation any actual or con-'
:':
l sidered' analysis, design, research, development, test,.e
1 or modification of or defect in any such equipment or>
) system..,
-
t .I -
| :| 3. Each document relating or referring to' if
| 4 : operation of TMI-2 or any equipment or system in TMI 2; 3. (including actual, anticipated, simulated or calculated!
'4operation).
a.ij 4.
-
Each document relating or referring to any ;i
; actual or considered technical specification, limit and ,
..
precaution, operating procedure, energency procedure,
'. abncrual procedure, surveillance procedure, other procedure.
or alar = response. pertaining to TM:-2. '.
,
.
sgaE~Eocumsnt relating or referring to anyT. -: ao
'
.. :.
gj actualf or considered training program for any TMI-2_
} operator or the training of any person for the operation' '
,of TMI-2, including without limitation classroo= ins ruction,design and use of a control rhom simulator, and any
.
Lwritten or recorded training or instruction materials.
6. Each. document relating or referring to,
4.
$any equipment or system in.TMI-1, or to its operation,.
!.
Isi
-| where the type of equipment or system was incorporatec in !13 :.
.!TMI-2 or is similar in intended function.to a system or equipi:
.!I
lment in TMI-2.l,
.; 7 Each document relating or referring to:I
] any technical specification, lisit and precaution,.i
)operatingprocedure,emergency procedure, abnormal precedurep41 -
!~! surveillance procedure, other procedure, or alarm response |
.
ie -
I' pertaining to TMI-1, where the same was adapted to or ,
!,.
.
,iactuallv used for TMI.-2. !.
4' ..
8. Each document contained in any file '
; relating generically to any equipment or system of a type ;
in TMI-2 or simild in intended function to any syste= or ii
,I
j equipment in TMI-2.t
--j 9. Each document contained in any file which
s
t
.!relatesgenericallytotechnicalspecifications,:I
il limits *
land precautions, operating procedures,--
emergency procedures,tI'
abnormal procedures, surveillance procedures, o theri!
!
procedures or alarm responses, which includes any fer ii
.ITMI-2 or any which are similar in intended function to those,
d e r M.1g "- 2 ..$
-- ..
.. i
, .
.
relates generically to the training of reactor cperators-. .
- for any equipment or system of a type in 2".iI-2 or similar.
-' in ~ intended function to any system or equipment in TX -2.;-
. i,j 11. Each document relating c referring to
'
i .
j any actual or considered change in design, manufacture, t:'.
,
il
" construction or supply of any part of any nuclear plant,J system or equipment af ter January 1,1975.a
i 12. Eacn document relating c: referring toi any actual or considered change in any technicali
] specification, limit and precaution, operating procedure,-
;emergency procedure,. abnormal procedure, surveillance
! procedure, other procedure or alarm response af ter January li-
3I4 1975.
.
13.j Each document relating or referring to1
j any actual or considered change in any~ training program_
:; for reactor operators af ter August, 1977. I+.
a .
14. Each document relating or referring to j'
any actual, simulated or theoretical transient, accident Li
!
or other-than-normal operating event in any nuclear plant;
| .
!' involving in any way'- -
.I.
| (a) Small break loss of coolant,:i
! !! (b) High pressure injection.of coolant,1 '-,
'(c) Pilot operated relief valve,i 4
*
i (d) Water level in the pressurizer,I '
i
-
,
!. 4 (e) Pressure, temperature or quantity !
!
E I
Ij of water c presence of steam !,
! .,
I :e.in the reactor coolant system, '',
(f) Quanuity of water in a steam *
generator or drying out of a'
'
.
steam generator, '
r
|
-. . . - , . . ,. - - .
.
flow,- *.. . .
- : (h) Reactor scram.or shutdown, ,! ',4 b
'-
,$ (i) Adequacy of operator respense or training,
,
'
~.
ti.(j) Adec.uacy of any crocedure, s.ystem descrie.- '; . .
:Ij tion or limi t and precaution,,
i!
j (k) Set point for reactor scram or any other.,
3
] set point, such as for equipment activa-'.t:!
y! - tion, equipment deactivation or alar =,. or -
.i!|. (1)1
Adequacy of or the absence of any inswumen .:,
1i tion,. or any computei or information display.,
., . . ". r ;. .. -
j 1S. Each document relating or re' ferring to any.
iIjincident, transient, accident c: other-than-normal operating'
.! ~ ,i .
.!t q'|eventatDavis-BesseinoraboutSeptemberandOctober :
" 1977 or to any actual oz;, considered change resulting there-1n -
;i f r o m i n a n y p r o c e d u r e , training or equipment.il ;
.
| 16. Each document referring or relating t: any !
pilot operated relief ' valve or associated instrumentation,
i*
of the type or similar in intended function to that usedf
| at TMI-2, including but not limited to (a) any defect in or
failure of such valve or assocated instrumentation or (b),.
the adequacy of inst: '. mentation to.. monitor the positien ..
of the valve.l
*
17. Each document relating or referring t:.
any actual or considered equipment or instrumentation to. 1I limenitor the water level or presence of steam voids in a ,
'-- d.
reactor vessel or a reactor ecolant system. .
..
18.-
Each document relating or referring :=.
'.
any actual or considered criterion, specification c re-
. quirement for control room design, lay-out, instr'hentation!
infor=ation display for TMI-2.c:
. .- - - - . -- - - - - - _ _ - - .. -- - . - - = - -
w -
'
; or received from any Congrossional cocmittee or sub-- .
!
! cot:mittee, ccanission, body, tnsk force, individual c:, >
::
jgroup (within or outside your companies) studying or cen-~!
I c'erning the accident or event'that began at TMI-2 on ord
'
about Ma:ch 28, 1979, or any aspect thereof.-
,
''
., 21. A copy of each organization chart and
,
directory of management employees prepared afte: 1965.;
,1 22. Each document relating or referring.
,to the involvement, oversight, review or participatienlj by J. Ray McDermott & Co. in the business of The Babcock &:
i Wilcox Co. '
34
23. Each document relating or referring tethe merger of the J. Ray McDermott & Co. or any subsidia:y-:
.'i.
i thereof and The Babecek & Wilcox Co. or the acquisitic: of9
..*
:'. The Babcock & Wilcox Co by J. Ray McDermott & Co. or any |: i
lsubsidiary thereof. !.p .
{.
-! Dated: New York, New Yorki May 15, 1980 KAYE, SCHOLER, FIERMAN, EYi5 &
.
EANDLER'
. . -p--.
.
| 425 Park Avenuei New York, New York 10022
I (212) '759-8400||1
BERLACK, ISRAELS & LI3E?.YJ2*L- 26 Broadway| New York, New York 10004
(212) 248-6900
l ATTORNEYS FOR PLAIN"IFFSiIt-e
i!
-
!
TO: 5! In .
;'' AVIS, POLK & WARDWELL I,
.. Attorneys for Defendants !
h1 Chase Manhattan Plaza !,
L ~jNew York, New York 10005 i: |
_ .. _ - . .- - . - -= - , _-
_,
il. .
9
21 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT'.ISOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NI*4 YORK. .
..!
II__________ _______ ___ ______ ______x:i
2 GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP. , :! et al.,., Index No. 80 Civ. 1683. .
h, (R.O.)Plaintiffs, :
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE- against - :
|RAYMCDERMOTT&CO.,'
THE BABCOCK & WILCOX CO., and J. :"
INC.;
6
i- Defendants.i:
|i
l _______________________________________x
0 STATE OF NEW YORK )1
| : ss.:jCOUNTY OF NEW YORK )!.
flt
'
DONNA BROWN, being duly sworn, deposes and says.'
)that she is employed by the law firm of Kaye, Scholer,n -
),Fierman, Hays.& Handler, is over the age of eighteen yearsil'
;a' and not a party to this action.||!' on May 15, 1980 deponent served a true copy of the't
| Plaintiff's First Request for Documents annexed hereto, by.i
$ depositing the same, enclosed in a sealed postpaid envelope,2..
;; in the U. S . ?ostal Service at 425 Park Avenue, New York,::
;j New York, addressed to the following:nU: Davis, Polk & Wardwelli; 1 Chase Manhattan Plaza'!
New York, New York 1000g-
D*ALk '* 1%j Donna Brown.!~
Sworn to before me this,"?'# day.of May, 1980'
..3, ,, ,
. . ' f'.*: t . .-s.. i : G. 3. ' g. ,
,. .
Notary Pubiic m.e-, [$:. -,..,, nEII . I ii w Ye'i-
i q - n. ::..n: :- -
ce..t .; + *..* % := =r '
% , u ns.,o .wr:4 4, b. .s,
, ...
e
.
. , . , , --,---v +-'
. _ -
_
'
-against-*- t.
CEE BA3 COCK & WILCOX CO.,' ' *
and J. RAY MCDERMOTT & CO., INC.
Defendants.
PLAINTIFFS' FIRST REQUEST FOR DOCUMENTS
-.
KAYE, SCHOLER, HERMAN, HAYS & HANDLER
Anorneys for
OHise ani Pan QHiss Adduss, Taleplwns-
425 Park AvenueNEW YORK. N;Y.100::2
(2i2) Plaza 9-5400
TO Davis, Folk & Wardwell'
1 Cha'se Manhattan PlazaNew York,' New York 10005
Anorcem for Defendants
.
.
9
.B
- i .
- _
t_
OOCKiT5'j[.:,?O.
! 1 OATE- ~ *
b . . $, _-LaT W _
_.
C!GM'#O J
1_._.== .
$) -.;
I1
cuEtMi'f2D i--- -.y
O ~U $ O"'i"*'I h
L 6/r.'/ G'] -4// ;f. / /1*i f';.f2:La&-.*
,1
-T..._ vf. 4 j- *~
,
,*
Ogav.
m
O
.
O
4
+ v - .,.~,--....-.m_. . . - - .re- ,-u_.. . ,m--. --.-_m_ - - - _. _ , _ - _ . - , , , , , - - . . , - - - , - - - - -, - - - , . - - . - - . ,