87
" "# $%%&'()* +'*, -&./0&)1 23) 4*0 5*&6&#178 93(': ;(8'<.* +=8'*%> # $%&'(&&%)* )+ ,-. #/. )+ 01%2%*34 5.&6)*&%7%4%,8 +&)&: ?(,*) " #$%%&'()($*+ %,-.$((&# $+ /)'($)0 1,01$00.&+( *1 (2& #&3'&& *1 (2& 4)52&0*' *1 6)7% 89*+*,'%: )( (2& ;+$<&'%$(= *1 >()3* 9',)7.1 :;";

Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! "!

!

!

!

"#!$%%&'()*!+'*,!-&./0&)1!23)!4*0!5*&6&#178!93(':!

;(8'<.*!+=8'*%>!!

!

!#!$%&'(&&%)*!)+!,-.!#/.!)+!01%2%*34!5.&6)*&%7%4%,8!

!!!!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

+&)&:!?(,*)!

!

!

"!#$%%&'()($*+!%,-.$((&#!$+!/)'($)0!1,01$00.&+(!*1!(2&!#&3'&&!*1!(2&!4)52&0*'!*1!6)7%!

89*+*,'%:!)(!(2&!;+$<&'%$(=!*1!>()3*!

!9',)7.1!:;";!

!

Page 2: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! %!

"./#306*1@*%*#'8!

!!!

?!7*,0#!0$@&!(*!(2)+@!(2&!1*00*7$+3!/&*/0&A!!!!!

<.)++=!>)1!8)(1!63,%.*'.!3*?!/(%?3*'.!!

@8!$(*.?%*!+1%.*?&!3*?!+43,23,.&=!+)1!344!,-.!/))?!,%2.&!!

A-.!9++%'.!01.B=!+)1!&)2.!4%/-,!1.4%.+!!C!

!@(2D!$3?D!3*?!E3*.=!>)1!344!8)(1!4)F.!3*?!&(66)1,!,-1)(/-)(,!!

28!G*%F.1&%,8!?38&

Page 3: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! %%!

AB4CD4C+!

!

$4CEBFGAC$B4HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHIJ!

AK"LCDE!B4DM!-&./@)3(#1 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIN!

JIJ!!"#!<#')31(.'<3#!'3!':*!O&@*!32!.)<%<#&6!)*8,3#8<P<6<'=Q IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII N!

JIR!!;(8'<.*!&#1!S*62&)*!",,)3&.:*8IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII T!

JIN!!4*0!5*&6&#178!93(':!;(8'<.*!U*@<86&'<V*!+*''<#@ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII W!

AK"LCDE!CSBM!C:*!"%*#1%*#'8 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJX!

RIJ!!A:&#@*8!23)!':*!8*)<3(8!.:<61!322*#1*)IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJX!

RIR!!93(':!B22*#1*)8!<#!':*!"1(6'!A3()' IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJT!

RIN!!Y(<1<#@!L)<#.<,6*8IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJW!

RIX!!Y*#*)&6!E*Z3)@&#<8&'<3#IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJW!

RIT!!A3#')&Z2630!*V<1*#' IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJ[!

RI\!!C:*!E33'8!32!':*!"%*#1%*#'8 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIJ[!

RIW!!C:*!L36<'<.<8*1!4&'()*!32!93(':!;(8'<.* IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR]!

RI^!!"!L)<#.<,6*1!",,)3&.: IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIRT!

AK"LCDE!CKEDDM!"#!DV<1*#'<&6!",,)3&.: IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR^!

NIJ!!C:*!+*)<3(8!A:<61!B22*#1*)78!U<%<'*1!A(6,&P<6<'=IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR^!

NIR!!C:*!&,,)3,)<&'*#*88!32!':*!93(':!;(8'<.*!8=8'*%!23)!)*1(.<#@!)*Z322*#1<#@ IIIIIIIIIIINX!

NIN!!$#'*)#&'<3#&6!K(%&#!E<@:'8!$#8')(%*#'8 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIX]!

NIX! !A3#.6(8<3#IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIX\!

AK"LCDE!_BGEM!C:*!S&=!_3)0&)1 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIX^!

XI!J!!"!_()':*)!D`'*#8<3#!32!':*!93(':!A3()'78!;()<81<.'<3# IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIX^!

XIR!!C)&#82*)!32!_&%<6=!A3()'78!A&)*!&#1!L)3'*.'<3#!B)1*)8!'3!':*!93(':!A3()'IIIIIIIIIIIIIITR!

XIN!!-)<#@<#@!+.<*#'<2<.!DV<1*#.*!<#'3!+*#'*#.<#@!a!"!b(&6<'&'<V*6=!1<22*)*#'!&,,)3&.: IIIT\!

AB4AUG+$B4 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII\J!

-$-U$BYE"LK9IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII\R!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 4: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! H!

$4CEBFGAC$B4!!

!IA-.8J! +1.K(.*,48! L*)B! ,-.! ?%++.1.*'.! 7.,B..*! 1%/-,! 3*?! B1)*/! 3*?! 31.!

')26.,.*,! ,)! &,3*?! ,1%34M!N.'3(&.!)+! ,-.%1! %263%12.*,&D!-)B.F.1D!78!?.+%*%,%)*!

,-.8!-3F.!?%2%*%&-.?! '363'%,%.&! ,)!(*?.1&,3*?!3*?!61)'.&&!2%&,3L.&! 3*?! 4.31*!

+1)2! .O6.1%.*'.D! ,)! .*/3/.! %*! 4)/%'34! 1.3&)*%*/D! ,)! ')*,1)4! %26(4&.&D! 3*?! ,)!

(*?.1&,3*?! ,-.! 1.3',%)*&! )+! ),-.1&MMMM! A-.%1! ?.+%'%.*'%.&! ?)! *),! B3113*,! 3*!

.O.26,%)*! +1)2! '1%2%*34! &3*',%)*&D! 7(,! ,-.8! ?)! ?%2%*%&-! ,-.%1! 6.1&)*34!

'(4637%4%,8M!

!!!!!!!"(@$+%!<B!C$'3$+$)D!PHQ!GMRM!H;SD!H"TD!"::!RM0,M!::S:D!::P;!U:;;:V!

!

W*! ,-%&! 636.1! W! B%44! ')*&%?.1! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! %*! X.B! Y.343*?Z&! 8)(,-!

[(&,%'.!&8&,.2!+)'(&%*/!61%231%48!)*!,-.!\&.1%)(&!8)(,-!)++.*?.1Z"M!5.'.*,!32.*?2.*,&:!

,)! X.B! Y.343*?Z&! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 4./%&43,%)*! ]! ,-.! 0-%4?1.*! ^)(*/! _.1&)*&! 3*?! ,-.%1!

>32%4%.&! #',! "`T`D! ,-.! 61.F34.*'.! )+! &.1%)(&! 8)(,-! '1%2.! %*! X.B! Y.343*?! 3*?! ,-.!

6)4%,%'%&.?!*3,(1.!)+!,-.!?.73,.!&(11)(*?%*/!%,!23L.&!,-%&!3!61.&&%*/!%&&(.M!0-%4?1.*!B-)!

')22%,! &.1%)(&! )++.*'.&! 6)&.! 3! 6.'(4%31! '-344.*/.! ,)! .F.18! '1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2M!

0-%4?1.*! 238! ')22%,! a3?(4,b! '1%2.&! 7(,! ,-.%1! %223,(1%,8! 3*?! 43'L! )+! (*?.1&,3*?%*/!

2.3*!,-3,!,-.8!'3**),!7.!?.34,!B%,-!3&!a&2344!3?(4,&bMH!

!

A-%&!13%&.&!61)74.2&!+)1!,-.!'1%2%*34!43BM!c(.&,%)*&!31%&.!3&!,)!B-.,-.1!3!'-%4?!)++.*?.1!

%*! ,-.&.! '%1'(2&,3*'.&! &-)(4?! 7.! ')*&%?.1.?! 1.&6)*&%74.! +)1! ,-.%1! 3',%)*&M! X),%)*&! )+!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! '3*! ')*+4%',!B%,-! ')*'.1*&! +)1! 61),.',%)*! )+! ,-.! 6(74%'D! 3*?! ,-.! *..?! ,)!

1.?('.!&('-!)++.*?%*/!M!

!

^)(,-! E(&,%'.! 1.+)12D! 34)*/&%?.! /.*.134! [(&,%'.! 1.+)12D! B3&! 3! '.*,134! 643*L! )+! ,-.!

X3,%)*34!_31,8Z&!:;;T!.4.',%)*!'3263%/*M! ! W*! E)-*!d.8Z&!61.!.4.',%)*!'3263%/*!]! %,!B3&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"!>)1!,-.!6(16)&.&!)+!,-%&!636.1!,-.!\R.1%)(&!^)(,-!9++.*?.1Z!e!,-)&.!)++.*?.1&!3/.?!":!f!"g!,-3,!')22%,!)++.*'.&!B-%'-!71%*/!B%,-!,-.2!3!23O%2(2!6.*34,8!)+!3,!4.3&,!";!8.31&M!A-%&!?.+%*%,%)*!%*'4(?.&!3!B%?.!13*/.!)+!)++.*'.&D!+1)2!3&&3(4,!B%,-!%*,.*,!,)!1)7!U&!:HQD!01%2.&!#',VD!B)(*?%*/!B%,-!%*,.*,!,)!'3(&.!/1%.F)(&!7)?%48!-312!U&!"TTU"VV!7(1/4318!U&!:H"V!3*?!1)77.18!U&!:HSV!.,'!.,'VD!!#4,-)(/-!,-%&!238!&..2!1.&,1%',%F.!%,!B%44!344)B!2.!,)!L..6!%*!2%*?!,-.!&32.!h)++.*?.1h!B-.*!?%&'(&&%*/!,-.!'-3*/.!%*!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!3*?!),-.1!?%&'(&&%)*&!B%,-!1./31?!,)!)++.*?.1&!7.+)1.!8)(,-!')(1,!3*?!,13*&+.1!)+!61%*'%64.&!%*!,-.!#?(4,!')(1,&M!:!A-.!0-%4?1.*D!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!U^)(,-!0)(1,!E(1%&?%',%)*!3*?!91?.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!#',!:;";M!U\A-.!#2.*?2.*,ZV!H!$%&'(&&.?!+(1,-.1!%*!0-36,.1!,-1..!

Page 5: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! S!

23?.!'4.31!,-3,!%+!.4.',.?D!X3,%)*34!B)(4?!/.,!a,)(/-b!)*!8)(,-!)++.*?.1&MS!9*!@31'-!Q!

:;";!,-.!X3,%)*34!<)F.1*2.*,!63&&.?!A-.!0-%4?1.*D!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!

U^)(,-!0)(1,!E(1%&?%',%)*!3*?!91?.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!#',!:;";!UA-.!#2.*?2.*,VM!A-%&!*.B!

4./%&43,%)*! '32.! %*,)! +)1'.! )*! "&,! 9',)7.1! )+! ,-%&! 8.31M! #&! %,&! *32.! &(//.&,&D! ,-.!

#2.*?2.*,!#',!+)'(&.&!)*!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,M!W,!*),!)*48!%*,1)?('.&!*.B!6)B.1&D!)1?.1&!

3*?! %*'1.3&.?! [(1%&?%',%)*D! %,! 34&)! 1.61.&.*,&! 3! &%/*%+%'3*,! &-%+,! %*! ,-.! (*?.148%*/!

,-.)1.,%'34!61%*'%64.&!)+!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2M!A-.!61)6)&34!,)!%*'4(?.!&)2.!":!3*?!

"H!8.31!)4?&!B%,-%*! ,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,D!347.%,! %,!)*!3!F.18! 4%2%,.?!73&%&D!-3&!7..*!&3%?! ,)!

1.61.&.*,!a,-.!2)&,!+(*?32.*,34!'-3*/.!,)!X.B!Y.343*?Z&!61.&.*,!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!

&%*'.!%,&!%*'.6,%)*!%*!"`T`bMP!

!

A-%&!636.1!B%44!61)F%?.!,-.!73&%&! +)1!3*! %*+)12.?!3*?!61%*'%64.?!'1%,%K(.!)+!,-.!'(11.*,!

32.*?2.*,! ,)! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M! 5.'.*,! %*,.1*3,%)*34D! &'%.*,%+%'! 3*?!

7.-3F%)(134! .F%?.*'.! B%44! 7.! &(2231%&.?! 3*?! 4%*L.?! ,)! ,-.! ?%&'(&&%)*! )+! ,-.!

32.*?2.*,M! W,!B%44!&(//.&,!-)B!,-.!&8&,.2!'3*!B)1L!,)B31?&!2%,%/3,%*/!,-.!3++.',&!)+!

,-%&! 4./%&43,%)*D! &(//.&,%*/! ,-3,! 78! %*'1.3&%*/! ,-.! [(1%&?%',%)*! ,)! %*'4(?.! "g! 8.31! )4?&D!

61)F%?%*/!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!B%,-!,-.!6)B.1&!)+!,-.!>32%48!0)(1,!3*?!-3F%*/!3!K(34%,3,%F.48!

?%++.1.*,!3661)3'-! ,)B31?&!8)(,-!3,! &.*,.*'%*/!B%44! 61)F%?.! +)1! ,3*/%74.! 1.?(',%)*&! %*!

)++.*?%*/!3*?!B%44!61),.',!,-.!1%/-,&!)+!,-.&.!F(4*.1374.!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&M!!

!

9F.1344D!W!3%2!,)!23L.!3!613',%'34!')*,1%7(,%)*!,)!&'-)431&-%6!%*!,-%&!31.3D!.*')(13/%*/!3!

1.3&)*.?!3*?!,13*&631.*,!3661)3'-!,)!,-.!2('-!6)4%,%'%&.?!%&&(.!)+!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!%*!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!1.342M!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!S!d.8D!E)-*=!R,3,.!)+!,-.!X3,%)*!R6..'-D!:`!E3*(318!:;;T!-,,6=iiBBBM*j-.134?M')M*ji*ji*.B&i31,%'4.M'+2k'l%?e"C)7[.',%?e";ST`S:S!!P!A-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!)+!X.B!Y.343*?!aR(72%&&%)*!,)!R)'%34!R.1F%'.&!R.4.',!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!0-%4?1.*D!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!U^)(,-!0)(1,!E(1%&?%',%)*!3*?!91?.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!N%44bM!

Page 6: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! H!

AK"LCDE!B4D!

-&./@)3(#1!!

!

R.,,%*/!3*!3/.!+)1!,-.!3'K(%&%,%)*!)+!'.1,3%*!1%/-,&!)1! %*?..?D!,-.!4)&&!)+!'.1,3%*!

61),.',%)*&D! %&!3!')264.O!23,,.1M!#!,-)1)(/-!(*?.1&,3*?%*/!)+!,-.!(*?.148%*/!,-.)1%.&!

)+! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 3*?! ,-.! *),%)*! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! %&! 1.K(%1.?! %+! 3*! %*+)12.?!

')*&%?.13,%)*!)+!,-.!'1%2%*34!3/.!)+!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! %&!,)!7.!(*?.1,3L.*M!W*!,-%&!'-36,.1!W!

B%44!61)F%?.!3!71%.+!%*,1)?(',%)*!,)!,-.!')*'.6,!)+!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M!W!B%44!

,-.*! 4))L! ,)! %?.*,%+8! ,-.!(*?.148%*/! ,-.)1%.&!)+! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.!3,!6438! %*!X.B!Y.343*?Z&!

'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!&8&,.2M!!

!

JIJ!! "#!<#')31(.'<3#!'3!':*!O&@*!32!.)<%<#&6!)*8,3#8<P<6<'=Q!

!

A-.!\3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8Z!%&!,-.!a3/.!3,!B-%'-!3!6.1&)*!7.')2.&!&(7[.',!,)!,-.!

+(44! 6.*34,%.&! 61)F%?.?! 78! ,-.! '1%2%*34! 43BbMQ! 0-%4?1.*! 7.4)B! ,-.! 2%*%2(2! 3/.! )+!

'1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! 31.! ')*&%?.1.?! ,)! 7.! #*0$! $+5)/)DDg! ,-3,! %&! a%*'36374.! )+!

')22%,,%*/! 3*! .F%4! 3',b! 3*?! 3&! 3! 1.&(4,! '3**),! 7.! -.4?! 4./3448! 1.&6)*&%74.! +)1! ,-.%1!

7.-3F%)(1MT!

!

A-.1.!31.!3,!4.3&,!,B)!B38&!)+!')*'.6,(34%j%*/!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M`!A-.!+%1&,!1.+.1&!,)!

'1%2%*34! '363'%,8D! '1%2%*34! %*,.*,%)*! )1! 2.*&! 1.3m! ,-.! 3/.! 3,! B-%'-! ,-.! '-%4?! %&!

')*&%?.1.?! &(++%'%.*,48! ')26.,.*,! ,)! ?%&,%*/(%&-! \1%/-,Z! +1)2! \B1)*/ZM! W*! ,-%&! 1.&6.',D!

&.,,%*/! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! %264%.&! ,-3,! '-%4?1.*! (*?.1! ,-3,! 3/.! 31.!

61.&(2.?!,)!7.!(*374.!,)!+(448!3661.'%3,.!,-.!1.34!*3,(1.!)+!,-.!\)++.*'.Z!3*?D!3&!&('-D!

31.! *),! 4%374.! ,)! '1%2%*34! 61)&.'(,%)*M! 0)*F.1&.48D! '-%4?1.*! 37)F.! ,-.! 3/.! 31.! +(448!

\1.&6)*&%7%4%&.?Z!3*?!&(7[.',!,)!,-.!61)F%&%)*&!)+!,-.!&(7&,3*,%F.!'1%2%*34!43B!%*!61.'%&.48!

,-.!&32.!B38!3&!3?(4,&D!34,-)(/-!&.*,.*'%*/!)6,%)*&!238!?%++.1M";!A-.!,-1.&-)4?!-.1.!%&!

%*.O,1%'3748! 4%*L.?!B%,-! ,-.!*),%)*!)+! ,-.! 4%2%,.?! 3'')(*,37%4%,8! )+! '-%4?1.*! 3*?! 8)(*/!

6.1&)*&m!1.+4.',.?!78!,-.%1!6-8&%'34D!%*,.44.',(34D!3*?!&)'%34!%223,(1%,8!%*!')2631%&)*!,)!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Q!N!<)4?&)*!a0)(*,.1743&,=!$%++%'(4,!,)!G*?.1&,3*?!)1!$.+.*?=!#!5.3&)*.?!03&.!+)1!53%&%*/!,-.!#/.!)+!01%2%*34!5.&6)*&%7%4%,8b!U:;;`V!STUPV!A-.!n)B31?!E)(1*34!)+!01%2%*34!E(&,%'.!3,!P"S!g!A-.!?)',1%*.!)+!?)4%!%*'363O!B-%'-!61.&(2.&!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!31.!'1%2%*3448!%*'36374.!%&!3!(&.+(4!2.3*&!)+!61)F%?%*/!&)2.!+4.O%7%4%,8!,)!32.4%)13,.!,-.!6),.*,%34!-31&-*.&&!)+!3!2%*%2(2!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!4%37%4%,8M!A-.!61.&(26,%)*!344)B&!,-.!0)(1,!,)!')*&%?.1!,-.!%*?%F%?(34!'-%4?Z&!'363'%,8!%*!,-.!?%++%'(4,!a%*!7.,B..*!8.31&bM!U_1%*'%634!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(?/.D!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,VM!!T!#!5382)*?!E*,+3!>11&+#&'%!)+#!(2&!6)7!UA384)1!C!>13*'%&D!n)7)L.*D!:;";V!3,!SH!!`!N!<)4?&)*D!37)F.!*!QD!3,!P"P!";!#!5382)*?D!37)F.!*!T!3,!SH!!

Page 7: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! S!

3?(4,&M""! A-%&! %&! 1.')/*%&.?! %*! 43B!78! ,-.!61%*'%64.!)+! \'1%2%*34! '363'%,8ZM":!#'')1?%*/48D!

,-.! &.,,%*/!)+!3*!3/.!)+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! %&! 3! +)1234! 1.')/*%,%)*! ,-3,! '-%4?1.*!?)!

*),! 6)&&.&&! ,-.! &32.! 2.*,34! '363'%,8! 3&! 3?(4,&! ,)! (*?.1&,3*?! ,-.! .O,.*,! )+! ,-.!

'1%2%*34%,8! )+! ,-.%1! 3',%)*&D! 3*?! ,-.%1! %264%'3,%)*&! 3&! 3?(4,&M! W+! 3?)4.&'.*,&! -3F.! 4.&&!

?.F.4)6.?!?.'%&%)*f23L%*/!'3637%4%,%.&D! ,-.*!,-.!13,%)*34.!+)1!3! [(F.*%4.! [(&,%'.!&8&,.2!

,-3,!-)4?&!3?)4.&'.*,&!,)!3?(4,f4%L.!&,3*?31?&!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!3*?!'(4637%4%,8!%&!

'-344.*/.?M"H!

!

#!&.')*?!B38!)+!%*,.161.,%*/!3*?!36648%*/!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!%&!4.&&!')*'.1*.?!B%,-!

'1%2%*34! '363'%,8! %*! %,&.4+! 3*?! 2)1.! %*,.1.&,.?! %*! ,-.! 61%*'%64.! )+! %22(*%,8! +1)2!

61)&.'(,%)*M!W*!),-.1!B)1?&!B-.,-.1!)1!*),!,-.!'-%4?!%&!?..2.?!,)!-3F.!\'363'%,8Z!%&!*),!

,-.!61%2318!K(.&,%)*M!53,-.1D! ,-.!3661)61%3,.*.&&!)1!),-.1B%&.!)+! ,-.! +)1234! '1%2%*34!

[(&,%'.!366313,(&!3&!3!2.3*&!)+!3??1.&&%*/!'-%4?1.*Z&!,13*&/1.&&%)*&! %&!,-.!L.8!6)%*,!3,!

%&&(.M! A-.! +(*?32.*,34! &(72%&&%)*! 3?F3*'.?! -.1.! %&! ,-3,! '1%2%*34%&%*/! '-%4?1.*! %&!

61)74.23,%'! +)1! 1.3&)*&! ,-3,! .O,.*?! +31! 7.8)*?! 317%,1318! ')*&,1(',%)*&! )+! '1%2%*34!

'363'%,8M! A-%&!636.1!B%44!7.! 4))L%*/!3,! ,-.!3/.!)+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! +1)2!7),-! ,-.!

%?.3!)+!'1%2%*34!'363'%,8!3*?!,-.!3661)61%3,.*.&&!)+!,-.!'1%2%*34!31.*3!+)1!?.34%*/!B%,-!

,-.!%&&(.!)+!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?%*/M!

!

G*?)(7,.?48! 3*8! &('-! 4./34! ,-1.&-)4?! B-%'-! 371(6,48! ?..2&! 3! '-%?! \'1%2%*3448!

1.&6)*&%74.Z! (6)*! ,-.! ?3B*%*/! )+! 3! 7%1,-?38! %&! %*-.1.*,48! 31,%+%'%34! 3*?! 317%,1318M!

#'')1?%*/48D!,-.!')*'.6,!)+!3*!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!%&!3!*.'.&&318!4./34!+%',%)*M!

X)!'-%4?!&(??.*48!3,,3%*&!,-.!1.K(%&%,.!.2),%)*34D!2.*,34!3*?!%*,.44.',(34!23,(1%,8!(6)*!

-%&!')2%*/!)+!3/.!3&!?%',3,.?!78! 43BM!^.,! ,-.! %26)&%,%)*!)+!3*!3/.! ,-1.&-)4?! ,)!?.+%*.!

'1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8D! 3*?! +)123448! 1.')/*%&.! ,-.! %*'363'%,8! )+! '-%4?1.*! B-)! 31.! ,))!

8)(*/!,)!')261.-.*?!,-.!%264%'3,%)*&!)+!,-.%1!3',%)*&D!%&!3*!37&)4(,.!*.'.&&%,8!%*!)1?.1!

,)!-3F.!3!+(*',%)*%*/!&8&,.2!)+!3'')(*,37%4%,8M!!!

!

9F.1!,-.!8.31&!,-.!317%,1318!4%*.!)+!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!%*!X.B!Y.343*?!-3&!

7..*! 23*%6(43,.?! ,)! 1.?.+%*.! ,-.! 61)74.2! )+! 8)(,-! )++.*?%*/D! ,)! 3'')22)?3,.!

'-3*/%*/!3,,%,(?.&!,)!8)(,-!43B71.3L.1&!3*?!2)F.?!,)B31?&!B-%'-!3661)3'-!&-)(4?!7.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!""!N!<)4?&)*!37)F.!*!Q!3,!P"P!":!B-%'-!%&!,-.!a3/.!3,!B-%'-!3!'-%4?!%&!?..2.?!'36374.!)+!')22%,,%*/!3!'1%2.!3*?D!,-(&D!7.')2.&!'1%2%*3448!1.&6)*&%74.bM!!"H!0311%.!R!>1%.?!3*?!$%'L)*!X!5.66(''%!a01%2%*34!$.'%&%)*!@3L%*/=!A-.!$.F.4)62.*,!)+!#?)4.&'.*,!E(?/2.*,D!01%2%*34!5.&6)*&%7%4%,8D!3*?!0(4637%4%,8b!U:;;"V!:P!o3B!3*?!n(23*!N.-3F%)1!3,!"!

Page 8: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! P!

6(1&(.?M"S!A-.!61)74.2!%&!,-3,!)*'.!,-%&!4%*.!%&!.&,374%&-.?!%,!%&!.3&8!,)!)F.14))L!,-.!+3',!

,-3,!%,!%&!317%,1318"P!3*?!,-.1.+)1.!'-3*/%*/!%,!7.')2.&!?%++%'(4,M!!

!

JIR!! ;(8'<.*!&#1!S*62&)*!",,)3&.:*8!

!

#*!.O32%*3,%)*!)+!,-.!,-.)1%.&!(*?.148%*/!&8&,.2&!)+![(F.*%4.![(&,%'.!%&!%*F34(374.!,)!3*8!

&('-!?%&'(&&%)*!)+!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M!W*?..?D!3*!3*348&%&!)+!,-.!&)f'344.?!

\2)?.4&! )+! [(F.*%4.! [(&,%'.Z! '3*! 7.! &..*! 3&! %*,./134! ,)! (*?.1&,3*?%*/!B-8! 3! 631,%'(431!

,-1.&-)4?!+)1!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!-3&!7..*!'-)&.*!78!3!R,3,.!)F.1!3!8)(*/.1!)1!)4?.1!

3/.M!@)1.)F.1D! 78!(&%*/! ,-.&.!2)?.4&! 3&!731)2.,.1&! %*!)1?.1! ,)! 3&&.&&! ,-.!2.3&(1.&!

(&.?!78!&,3,.&!%*!,-.!,3'L4%*/!)+!8)(,-!'1%2.D!%,!%&!6)&&%74.!,)!/3%*!3*!3''(13,.!%261.&&%)*!

)+! ,-.! 61.'%&.! %263',! )+! &('-! 61)F%&%)*&! (6)*! '-%4?1.*! %*! 1.43,%)*! ,)! ,-.! &.,! 3/.! )+!

'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M!A-.!,B)!+)1.2)&,!3661)3'-.&!,)!)++.*?%*/!78!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!

6.)64.! %*!2)?.1*! '1%2%*)4)/8! 31.! L*)B*!78! ,-.! &-)1,-3*?!?.&'1%6,%)*&! )+! ,-.! [(&,%'.!

3*?!B.4+31.!2)?.4&M"Q!

!

A-.!B.4+31.!3661)3'-!%&!3!'31.!73&.?!3661)3'-!f!%,!')*'.*,13,.&!)*!+3',)1&!B-%'-!4.3?!3!

8)(*/! 6.1&)*! ,)! ')22%,! '1%2.D! 3*?! 23%*48! +)'(&.&! )*! ,-.! )++.*?.1Z&! *..?&M! W,! %&!

+)(*?.?! )*! ,-.! 6)&%,%F%&,! 6-%4)&)6-8! )+! '1%2%*)4)/8D! B-%'-! 3&&(2.&! ,-3,! 8)(*/!

)++.*?.1&!')22%,!)++.*'.&!3&!3! 1.&(4,!)+! +3',)1&!7.8)*?!,-.%1!')*,1)4M"g!_1)6)*.*,&!)+!

,-%&!F%.B!3?F)'3,.!3!F31%.,8!)+!,-.136.(,%'!3661)3'-.&!%*!)1?.1!,)!-.46!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!!

')6.!2)1.!.++.',%F.48!B%,-!,-.%1!6.1&)*34!61)74.2&M"T!A-.!B.4+31.!2)?.4!/%F.&!61%)1%,8!

,)! ,-.!61),.',%)*!3*?! 1.-37%4%,3,%)*!)+! [(F.*%4.!)++.*?.1&D!B-%4.! ! F.-.2.*,48! &-(**%*/!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"S!A-.!*),%)*!)+!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!+%1&,!.*,.1.?!X.B!Y.343*?Z&!&,3,(,.!7))L&!F%3!&::!)+!A-.!01%2%*34!0)?.!#',!"T`H!]!%*!4%*.!B%,-!p*/4%&-!613',%'.!3,!,-.!,%2.!]!%,!61)F%?.?!,-3,!*)!6.1&)*!(*?.1!,-.!3/.!)+!g!')(4?!7.!')*F%',.?!)+!3*!)++.*'.M!A-%&!61)F%&%)*!B3&!1.6.3,.?!%*!&S"!)+!,-.!01%2.&!#',!"`;TD!3*?!%,!B3&!*),!(*,%4!"`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m!%*!E363*!%,!%&!"SD!%*!5(&&%3D!%,!%&!"QD!+)1!_)1,(/34!"TD!%*!,-.!Gd!%,!%&!";D!3*?!+)1!2)&,!)++.*'.&!3*?!R'),43*?Z&!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!%&!)*48!TM!!"Q!E)8!q(*?.1&%,j!3*?!0-1%&,%*.!#4?.1!F).$0=!G*+1&'&+5$+3!)+#!H,<&+$0&!H,%($5&A!I2&!J)=!F*'7)'#!*'!K$%/0)5&#!>/($.$%.L!U#(&,134%3*!W*&,%,(,.!)+!01%2%*)4)/8D!03*7.113D!"``SV!"g!X%'-)43&!0!N343!H,<&+$0&!H,%($5&!M=%(&.%A!"+!?+(&'+)($*+)0!G*./)'$%*+!*1!N'*-0&.%!)+#!M*0,($*+%!UA-)26&)*!p?('3,%)*34!_(74%&-%*/D!A)1)*,)D!:;;:V!3,!Q!"T!!o8*'-D!X.&&3!aA-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!^)(*/!_.1&)*!%*!,-.!X.B!Y.343*?!^)(,-!E(&,%'.!>32%48!<1)(6!0)*+.1.*'.b!U_n$!A-.&%&D!G*%F.1&%,8!)+!9,3/)D!:;;TV!3,!"P!

Page 9: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! Q!

,-.! (&.! )+! -31&-48! 6(*%,%F.! '(&,)?%34! 2.3&(1.&! 3&! 3! 2.3*&! )+! ?.34%*/! B%,-! '-%4?!

)++.*?.1&M! W*?..?D! 3&! ,-.! G*%,.?! X3,%)*&! 0)*F.*,%)*! )*! ,-.! 5%/-,&! )+! ,-.! 0-%4?!

UGX0590V!?%',3,.&D"`! !R,3,.&!2(&,! ,3L.! %*,)!3'')(*,!a,-.!?.&%137%4%,8!)+!61)2),%*/! ,-.!

'-%4?Z&!1.%*,./13,%)*!3*?!,-.!'-%4?!3&&(2%*/!3!')*&,1(',%F.!1)4.!%*!&)'%.,8Mb:;!q-.1.!,-.!

+)'(&!%&!)*!,-.!'-%4?Z&!B.4+31.D!,-.!4%*.&!7.,B..*![(&,%'.!3*?!'-%4?!61),.',%)*!31.!.3&%48!

74(11.?!3*?!,-.1.!%&!)*48!4%2%,.?!1.')/*%,%)*!)+!3!'-%4?Z&!4./34!1%/-,&M:"!

!

A-.!B.4+31.!2)?.4! +3'.&!.*)12)(&! '1%,%'%&2M!966)*.*,&! 31/(.! ,-3,! 3! 13*/.!)+! 37(&.&!

31.!')*'.34.?!(*?.1!,-.!/(%&.!)+!,-.!,.12!\B.4+31.ZM!>%1&,!)+!344D!'1%,%'&!?%&3661)F.!)+!,-.!

4%2%,.?! 1.&)(1'.! 1.')/*%,%)*! )+! ?(.! 61)'.&&! 3*?! ,-.! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*Z&! 4./34! 1%/-,&M::!

R.')*?D!,-.!71)3?!?%&'1.,%)*!.O.1'%&.?!78!,-.!3(,-)1%,%.&!238!4.3?!,)!?%&631%,%.&!,-1)(/-!

&(7[.',%F.D! 3*?! 6)&&%748! ?%&'1%2%*3,)18D! ?.'%&%)*f23L%*/! 3*?! '3*! -3F.! 3! *.,fB%?.*%*/!

.++.',M:H!

!

A-.!B.4+31.!3*?!,-.![(&,%'.!2)?.4!31.!)+,.*!?.&'1%7.?!3&!a,B)!6)431%,%.&!)*!3!,-.)1.,%'34!

')*,%*((2! )+! 6)&&%74.! 2)?.4&! )+! 1./%2.&! )+! [(F.*%4.! [(&,%'.MZ:S! W*?..?D! ,-.! [(&,%'.!

3661)3'-!B3&!6.**.?!3&!3!1.&6)*&.!,)!'1%,%'&!)+!,-.!\B.4+31.Z!3661)3'-M!#&!3!1.&(4,!23*8!

)+!%,&!61%*'%64.&!31.!,-.!.O3',!)66)&%,.!)+!,-)&.!(*?.148%*/!,-.!B.4+31.!3661)3'-M:P!A-.!

[(&,%'.!2)?.4D! !+)44)B&!,-.!*),%)*!,-3,!,-.!6(*%&-2.*,!/%F.*!)(,!+)1!3!'1%2.!&-)(4?!7.!

61)6)1,%)*3,.! ,)! ,-.! '1%2.! ')22%,,.?! 3*?! -3&! 1.,1%7(,%)*! 3&! %,&! 61%2318! /)34M:Q! W,! %&!

73&.?! (6)*! ,-.! 3&&(26,%)*! )+! 3*! .K(34! 7343*'.! 7.,B..*! ,-.! 1%/-,&! )+! &)'%.,8! ,)!

61),.',%)*! +1)2! '1%2%*34! 7.-3F%)(1D! 3*?! ,-.! 1%/-,&! )+! ,-.! %*?%F%?(34! '-31/.?! ,)! +3%1!

,1.3,2.*,!(*?.1!,-.!43BM:g!W,!+)'(&.&!(6)*!?(.!61)'.&&!3*?!,-.!\[(&,!?.&.1,&Z!61%*'%64.!]!

.&&.*,%3448! ,-.! 3&&%/*2.*,! )+! 6(*%&-2.*,! ,-3,! %&! 61)6)1,%)*3,.! ,)! ,-.! '1%2.M!!

_(*%&-2.*,!(*?.1!,-.![(&,%'.!2)?.4!%&!,-(&!&..*!3&!?.&.1F.?D!3*?!%&!*),!?.,.12%*.?!78!

,-.!)++.*?.1Z&!*..?&D!3&!(*?.1!,-.!B.4+31.!2)?.4M!W*&,.3?D!6(*%&-2.*,!%&!61.&'1%7.?!%*!

)1?.1! ,)! 1.+4.',! ,-.! 23/*%,(?.! )1! &.F.1%,8! )+! ,-.! '1%2.&! ')22%,,.?M! A-%&! ,-.)18! )+!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`!;+$(&#!O)($*+%!G*+<&+($*+!*+!(2&!P$32(%!*1!(2&!G2$0#!U)6.*.?!+)1!&%/*3,(1.!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!3?)6,.?!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!.*,.1.?!%*,)!+)1'.!:!R.6,.27.1!"``;VM!UA-.!\GX0590ZV!A-.!GX0590!%&!?%&'(&&.?!%*!2)1.!?.6,-!3,!0-36,.1!HMH!!:;!A-.!GX0590!#1,%'4.!S;U"V!:"!XD!N343D!37)F.!*!"gD!3,!P!::%7%?D!3,!Q!:H!<371%.44.!@[email protected]!3*?!#44%&)*!@)11%&!F).$0=Q!C$5($.%Q!)+#!G,0(,'&A!E*,(2!H,%($5&!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#!UR)'%34!_)4%'8!#/.*'8!3*?!W*&,%,(,.!)+!01%2%*)4)/8D!r%',)1%3!G*%F.1&%,8!)+!q.44%*/,)*D!q.44%*/,)*D!"``HV!3,!"QP!:S!XD!N343D!37)F.!*"gD!3,!Q!:P!<[email protected]!3*?!#!@)11%&D!37)F.!*!:HD!3,!"Qg!:Q!XD!N343D!37)F.!*"gD!3,!g!:g!#!5382)*?D!37)F.!*T!D3,!SH!!

Page 10: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! g!

61)6)1,%)*34%,8! U')**.',%*/! ,-.! '1%2.! 3*?! ,-.! /(%4,8! 2%*?! ,)! ,-.! &.F.1%,8! )+! ,-.!

6(*%&-2.*,V!-)B.F.1D!'3*!7.!-%/-48!61)74.23,%'!B-.*!3664%.?!,)!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&D!B-.*!

,-.!'-%4?! %&! ,))!8)(*/!,)! +(448!3661.'%3,.!,-.!&.1%)(&*.&&!)+! ,-.%1!3',%)*&!3*?!,-.! 4./34!

%264%'3,%)*&!,-3,!*.'.&&31%48!+)44)BM!

!

#'-%.F%*/!,-.!3661)61%3,.!7343*'.!7.,B..*!a[(&,%'.b!3*?!aB.4+31.b!%&!)*.!)+D!%+!*),!,-.!

2)&,! %*,13',374.! %&&(.! +3'%*/! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.M:T! A-.1.! %&! 3! B.34,-! )+! 1.&.31'-! 23,.1%34!

B-%'-!&(//.&,&!,-3,!%,!%&!*),!)*48!(*[(&,D!7(,!(*1.34%&,%'D!,)!?.*8!,-3,!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!31.!

,-.!61)?(',!)+!,-.%1!(671%*/%*/!3*?!.*F%1)*2.*,!3*?!71%*/!B%,-!,-.2!(*1.&)4F.?!'31.!

3*?! 61),.',%)*! %&&(.&! B-%'-! 31.! 3,! ,-.! 1)),! )+! ,-.%1! )++.*?%*/M! ^.,! 3,! ,-.! &32.! ,%2.!

,-.&.! )++.*?.1&! 31.! 1.K(%1.?! ,)! 7.! -.4?! 3'')(*,374.! 3*?! +3'.! &3*',%)*&! +)1! )++.*?%*/!

B-%'-!%&!,-.!1.&(4,D!3,!4.3&,!%*!631,D!)+!3*!.4.2.*,!)+!6.1&)*34!'-)%'.M:`!

!

A-.1.! %&! 4%,,4.! ?)(7,! ,-3,! ,-.! B.4+31.! 3*?! [(&,%'.! 2)?.4! ')*&,1(',&! 31.! 631,%'(43148!

%26)1,3*,! %*! (*?.1&,3*?%*/! ,-.! -%&,)1%'34! ?.73,.! )F.1! ,-.! 3661)61%3,.! +)12! )+! 8)(,-!

[(&,%'.! &8&,.2M! W*!613',%'.!*)!8)(,-! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2! +%,&!6.1+.',48! %*,)!.%,-.1!)+! ,-.! ,B)!

2)?.4&M!q-%4.!,-.8!238!7.!'43&&%+%.?!3'')1?%*/!,)!,-.!2)?.4&D!3',(34!&8&,.2&!31.!73&.?!

)*! 3! ')27%*3,%)*! )+! 6-%4)&)6-%'34! 13,%)*34.&D! 3*?! *(2.1)(&! )F.1436&! 7.,B..*! ,-)&.!

'-313',.1%&,%'&! ?.+%*.?M! #??%,%)*3448D! 6)4%,%'34D! 4)/%&,%'34! 3*?! 3?2%*%&,13,%F.! ')*'.1*&!

%*,1(?.! (6)*! ,-.! ,-.)18! ,)! 2)?%+8! ,-.! 3664%'3,%)*! )+! 3*8! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 2)?.4M! A-.!

0-%4?1.*D! ^)(*/! _.1&)*&! 3*?! A-.%1! >32%4%.&! #',! "`T`D! X.B! Y.343*?Z&! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.!

4./%&43,%)*D! %&! 431/.48! 3*! .O3264.! )+! 3! \[(&,%'.Z! 3661)3'-! 3&! %,! &..L&! ,)! &.6313,.! [(&,%'.!

3*?!B.4+31.!61)'.&&.&MH;! R.',%)*!"MH!B%44! .O32%*.!X.B!Y.343*?Z&! '(11.*,! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.!

4./%&43,%F.! &.,,%*/! 3*?! ?%&'(&&! B-.1.! %,&! (*?.148%*/! 61%*'%64.&! 3*?! 6(16)&.&! +%,! %*!

3'')1?3*'.!B%,-!,-.&.!2)?.4&M!

!

JIN!! 4*0!5*&6&#178!93(':!;(8'<.*!U*@<86&'<V*!+*''<#@!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:T!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,!a:;";D!3!7%/!8.31!+)1!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!]!A(1*%*/!:"!3*?!/.,,%*/!,-.!2)&,!)(,!)+!,-.!#',b!UA1%.**%34!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(?/.&!0)*+.1.*'.!:;";D!q3%6(*3!o)?/.D!#('L43*?V!:`!%7%?!!H;!q%,-!,-.!%*,1)?(',%)*!)+!,-.!*.B!#',D!$))43*!31/(.&!,-3,!X.B!Y.343*?!-3&!&-%+,.?!,)B31?&!,-.![(&,%'.!2)?.4!aB%,-)(,!.2713'%*/!&)2.!)+!,-.!2)?.4&!2)1.!?)',1%*3%1.!3&6.',&Mb!E(&,%'.!@'p41.3!3/1..&!B%,-!,-%&!,-.&%&D!7(,!,3L.&!%,!)*.!&,.6!+(1,-.1D!78!61)6)(*?%*/!,-3,!aB.!-3F.!'1.3,.?!3!*.B!'1.3,(1.!34,)/.,-.1s!3!2)?.4!)+!1.&6)*&%74.!1.')*'%4%3,%)*Mb!R..!$))43*D!@%L.!E*,(2!H,%($5&A!6&3$%0)($*+!)+#!N')5($5&!!%*!N)1B*D!N!E!3*?!@'p41.3!>!q!@!Up?&MV!E*,(2!G*,'(!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!"!K*#&0!*1!H,%($5&!U5.6)1,!*)!HSD!o./34!5.&.31'-!>)(*?3,%)*D!q.44%*/,)*D!"``HV!3,!"P!!

Page 11: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! T!

A.12&! &('-! 3&! \B)14?! 1.*)B*.?ZH"! 3*?! \*.B! 6313?%/2ZH:! 31.! +1.K(.*,48! (&.?! %*!

')**.',%)*! B%,-! ,-.! '(11.*,! X.B! Y.343*?! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2! 3*?! %,&! 61%2318!

4./%&43,%)*!]!,-.!0^_>!#',M!G*,%4!,-%&!8.31Z&!#2.*?2.*,!,-%&!4./%&43,%)*!3*?!,-.!&(7&,3*'.!

)+! ,-.! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 61)F%&%)*&! -3?! 1.23%*.?! (*'-3*/.?! &%*'.! %,&! .*3',2.*,! %*! "`T`M!

A-.!-%&,)18!)+!8)(,-![(&,%'.!%*!3!/.*.134!&.*&.DHH!3*?!%*!3!&6.'%+%'!X.B!Y.343*?!')*,.O,D!%&!

B.44!1.-.31&.?MHS!_1%)1!,)!,-.!'1.3,%)*!)+!,-.!0^_>!#',DHP!X.B!Y.343*?!+)44)B.?!3!B.4+31.!

73&.?!3661)3'-!,-1)(/-!,-.!0-%4?1.*!3*?!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!#',!"`gSM!A-%&!#',!?.34,!B%,-!

'31.!3*?!)++.*?%*/!'3&.&!%*!3!&%2%431!B.4+31.!73&.?!23**.1D!B-.1.!,-.!61%2318!+)'(&!%*!

7),-!'3&.&!B3&!)*!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*MHQ!W*!,-.!"``;&!B%,-!,-.!3?F.*,!)+!,-.!0^_>!#',D!

X.B!Y.343*?!8)(,-! [(&,%'.!613',%'.!7./3*!6(1&(%*/!3! [(&,%'.! !73&.?!3661)3'-!3*?! ,B)!

.*,%1.48!&.6313,.![(1%&?%',%)*&!B.1.!7)1*=!,-.!>32%48!0)(1,!3*?!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,D!23L%*/!

3!&,1%',!?.4%*.3,%)*!7.,B..*!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.! %*!*..?!)+!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!

3*?!,-)&.!)++.*?%*/MHg!

!

A-.! "`T`! 4./%&43,%)*!B3&! (*61.'.?.*,.?! %*! ,-.! p*/4%&-! &6.3L%*/!B)14?DHT! %*! ,-.! &.*&.!

,-3,! %,! B3&! ?.&%/*.?! ,)! ?.F.4)6! ')22(*%,8! 34,.1*3,%F.&! ,)! %*&,%,(,%)*&! %*! )1?.1! ,)!

1.&6)*?!2)1.!.++.',%F.48!,)!,-.!*..?&!)+!F%',%2&D!,)!61)F%?.!7.,,.1!&(66)1,!+)1!+32%4%.&!

3*?!,-.%1!'-%4?1.*D!,)!1.&6)*?!,)!?.23*?&!+1)2!@3)1%!+)1!3*!%*'1.3&.?!%*F)4F.2.*,!%*!

?.'%&%)*&!37)(,!,-.%1!'-%4?1.*D!3*?!,)!1.?('.!,-.!*(27.1!)+!2%*)1!)++.*?.1&!366.31%*/!

7.+)1.! ,-.!')(1,MH`!p26)B.1%*/! +32%4%.&! ,)!?.34!B%,-!)++.*?%*/!78! ,-.%1!8)(*/!6.)64.D!

631,%'(43148! ,-1)(/-! ,-.! (&.! )+! ,-.! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! +32%48! /1)(6! ')*+.1.*'.! B3&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!H"!E(?/.!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,!a^)(,-!E(&,%'.!>32%48!<1)(6!0)*+.1.*'.&=!#!c(%'L!\X%6!3*?!A('LZ!)1!A13*&643*,!R(1/.18!]!q-3,!B)(4?!,-.!$)',)1!)1?.1!%*!:;;Qb!U636.1!61.&.*,.?!3,!,-.!W*,.1*3,%)*34!0)*+.1.*'.!)*!,-.!>32%48!<1)(6!0)*+.1.*'.!f!!0)2%*/!n)2.D!A.!n)L%*/3!@3%D!q.44%*/,)*D!X.B!Y.343*?!:gf:`!X)F.27.1!:;;QVM!H:!#44%&)*!@)11%&!3*?!<371%[email protected]!aE(F.*%4.!E(&,%'.!%*!X.B!Y.343*?=!#!X.B!_313?%/2b!U"``HV!:Q!#(&,134%3*!3*?!X.B!Y.343*?!E)(1*34!)+!01%2%*)4)/8!3,!T"!!HH!R..!/.*.13448!E)-*!@(*'%.D!<)1?)*!n(/-.&!3*?!p(/.*.!@'o)(/-4%*!U.?&MVD!E*,(2!H,%($5&A!G'$($5)0!P&)#$+3%!Uo)*?)*=!R3/.D!:;;:VD!n3118!n.*?1%'LD!\n%&,)1%.&!)+!^)(,-!01%2.!3*?!E(&,%'.Z!%*!N3118!<)4?&)*!3*?!E)-*!@(*%'.!U.?&MVD!!E*,(2!G'$.&!)+#!H,%($5&!Uo)*?)*=!R3/.!_(74%'3,%)*&D!:;;QVM!!HS!E)-*!#!R.82)(1D!S&)0$+3!7$(2!>11&+#&'%!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!I2&!M=%(&.!$+!T<*0,($*+!U#('L43*?=!o./34!5.&.31'-!>)(*?3,%)*D!"`gQVD!#44%&)*!@)11%&D!3*?!q311.*!^)(*/D!H,<&+$0&!H,%($5&!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!N*0$5=!)+#!N')5($5&!!Uq.44%*/,)*=!W*&,%,(,.!)+!01%2%*)4)/8D!r%',)1%3!G*%F.1&%,8!)+!q.44%*/,)*D!"`TgV!p2%48!q3,,D!!"!9$%(*'=!*1!E*,(2!H,%($5&!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#!U$.631,2.*,!)+!0)(1,&D!5.&.31'-!_36.1D!:;;HV!3F3%4374.!3,!BBBM[(&,%'.M/)F,M*ji8)(,-i-%&,)18!!HP!&6.'%+%'3448!%*!,-.!"`g;&!3*?!T;&!HQ!p2%48!q3,,!"!9$%(*'=!*1!E*,(2!H,%($5&!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#!U$.631,2.*,!)+!0)(1,&D!5.&.31'-!_36.1D!:;;HVM!Hg!A-.1.!%&!3!'4.31f'(,!6-8&%'34!?.231'3,%)*!B%,-%*!,-.!&,3,(,.!%,&.4+!7.,B..*!031.!3*?!_1),.',%)*!%&&(.&!%*!_31,!WW!3*?!^)(,-!E(&,%'.!%&&(.&!%*!_31,!Wr!HT!<[email protected]!3*?!#!@)11%&D!37)F.!*!:HD!3,!"QP!H`!%7%?!

Page 12: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! `!

&,1.&&.?MS;#! -.3F8! .26-3&%&! B3&! 34&)! 643'.?! )*! 61)'.?(134! 1%/-,&D! 61)6)1,%)*3,.!

1.&6)*&.&D! /13?(3,.?! &3*',%)*&D! 3*?! ,-.! ,%2.48! %*,.1F.*,%)*! )+! _)4%'.! ?%F.1&%)*318!

613',%'.&!,)!+)'(&!,-.!8)(*/!6.1&)*!3*?!,-.%1!+32%48!)*!,-.%1!)++.*?%*/M!!

!

A-.! 0^_>! #',! /3F.! 3! 4./%&43,%F.! 73&.! ,)! 3! \')261.-.*&%F.! &.,! )+! /.*.134! 61%*'%64.&DZ!

B-%'-!B.1.!,)!/(%?.!,-.!.O.1'%&.!)+!6)B.1&!%*!1.43,%)*!,)!8)(*/!6.)64.!U&!SV!3*?!2)1.!

631,%'(43148!,-.!)6.13,%)*!)+!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!61)F%&%)*&!)+!,-.!0^_>!#',!U&!:;TVMS"!!A-%&!

#',!B3&!(*%K(.!3,!,-.!,%2.!%*!')?%+8%*/!,-.!61%*'%64.&!)*!B-%'-!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!

B3&!73&.?MS:!R.',%)*!SU+V!)+!,-.!0^_>!#',!&.,&!)(,!61%*'%64.&!+)1!?.34%*/!B%,-!'-%4?1.*!3*?!

8)(*/! 6.)64.! B-)! ')22%,! )++.*'.&M! A-.! +%1&,! '43(&.! 23%*,3%*&! ,-3,! &('-! '-%4?1.*! )1!

8)(*/!6.)64.!2(&,!7.!-.4?!3'')(*,374.!3*?!.*')(13/.?!,)!3''.6,!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8MSH!A-.!

&.')*?! '43(&.! &,3,.&! ,-3,! ,-.%1! *..?&! 2(&,! 7.! 3'L*)B4.?/.?! &)! ,-3,! ,-.8! '3*! 7.!

.*')(13/.?!,)!?.F.4)6!%*!a1.&6)*&%74.D!7.*.+%'%34D!3*?!&)'%3448!3''.6,374.!B38&bMSS!A-%&!

%&!3!'4.31!.O3264.!)+!3*!3,,.26,! ,)!')27%*.!7),-! ,-.!B.4+31.!3*?! [(&,%'.!3661)3'-.&M!

_1%*'%634! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! E(?/.! N.'1)+,! 1.+.1&! ,)! ,-.&.! ,B%*! )7[.',%F.&! 3&! 3??1.&&%*/! ,-.!

\*..?Z!3*?!,-.!\?..?ZMSP!

!

_1%)1!,)!,-.!#2.*?2.*,D!344!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!(*?.1!"S!8.31&!)+!3/.!U.O'.6,!B-.*!+3'%*/!

2(1?.1! )1! 23*&43(/-,.1! '-31/.&VSQ! B.1.! ?.34,! B%,-! )*! ,-.! 73&%&! ,-3,! '31.! 3*?!

61),.',%)*!%&&(.&!31.!,-.!61%2318!'3(&.!)+!,-.%1!)++.*?%*/M!A-.8!B.1.!,-(&!?.34,!B%,-!%*!

,-.!>32%48!0)(1,!3*?!')(4?!*),!7.!'-31/.?!%*!3*8!'1%2%*34!')(1,MSg!A-.!01%2.&!#',!"`Q"!

.&,374%&-.?!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!3/.?!(*?.1!"S!-3F.!3!?%2%*%&-.?!'363'%,8!%*!1.&6.',!)+!'1%2%*34!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!S;!A-.!+32%48!/1)(6!')*+.1.*'.!B-%'-!.*374.?!F%',%2&!!3*?!)++.*?.1&!,)!2..,!,)/.,-.1!B%,-!,-.!2.27.1&!)+!,-.!.*+)1'.2.*,!3/.*'8D!3*?!,-.!+32%48!%*!)1?.1!,)!?.'%?.!)*!3*!3661)61%3,.!6.*34,8M!A-.!+32%48!/1)(6!')*+.1.*'.!.*374.&!,-.!%*F)4F.2.*,!)+!,-.!+32%48D!,-.!8)(*/!6.1&)*D!3*?!,-.!F%',%2!%*!?.'%&%)*f23L%*/!3,!3!F.*(.!3*?!(&%*/!3!61)'.?(1.!)+!,-.%1!)B*!'-)%'.!3*?!%*!3'')1?3*'.!B%,-!,-.%1!'(4,(1.M!!S"<[email protected]!r!d%*/%m!E!5)7.1,&)*m!#!@)11%&m!0!0(**%*/-32D!"52$&<$+3!T11&5($<&!>,(5*.&%!$+!E*,(2!H,%($5&!>%*34!5.6)1,!UWRNX=!;fSgTf:P"S:fSD!q.44%*/,)*!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,D!:;;SV!3,!g!S:!#4,-)(/-!&,3,.2.*,&!)+!61%*'%64.&!*)B!366.31!%*!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!4./%&43,%)*!)+!),-.1![(1%&?%',%)*&M!R..!+)1!.O3264.!&`Q!)+!,-.!0-%4?1.*&!#',!:;;"!UW1.43*?VD!&H!)+!,-.!^)(,-!01%2%*34!E(&,%'.!#',!:;;:!U03*3?3VD!&H!)+!,-.!^)(*/!9++.*?.1&!#',!"``H!UR)(,-!#(&,134%3VD!&H!)+!,-.!^)(*/!9++.*?.1&!#',!"``g!UX.B!R)(,-!q34.&VM!!W*!3??%,%)*D!&,3,.2.*,&!)+!61%*'%64.&!31.!*)B!%*'1.3&%*/48!')22)*!%*!),-.1!,86.&!)+!X.B!Y.343*?!4./%&43,%)*!SH!.O3264.!)+!,-.!E(&,%'.!#661)3'-M!!SS!.O3264.!)+!,-.!q.4+31.!#661)3'-!SP!_1%*'%634!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(?/.!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,D!\^)(,-!E(&,%'.!]!A-.!X.B!Y.343*?!pO6.1%.*'.!_3&,!o.&&)*&!3*?!>(,(1.!0-344.*/.&ZM!_36.1!61.&.*,.?!3,!#(&,134%3*!W*&,%,(,.!)+!01%2%*)4)/8i!XRq!$.631,2.*,!)+!E(F.*%4.!E(&,%'.!0)*+.1.*'.=!H,<&+$0&!H,%($5&A!F'*.!6&%%*+%!*1!(2&!N)%(!(*!)!P*)#!1*'!(2&!F,(,'&Q!R8?*.8D!"f:!$.'.27.1!:;;HD!";M!!SQ!_1)&.'(,%)*&!)+!'-%4?1.*!3/.?!";!)1!2)1.!3*?!8)(*/!6.1&)*&!+)1!2(1?.1!3*?!23*&43(/-,.1!31.!-.31?!%*!,-.!n%/-!0)(1,!3+,.1!3!61.4%2%*318!-.31%*/!%*!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,M!!Sg!G*?.1!031.!3*?!_1),.',%)*!61)F%&%)*&!)+!,-.!0^_>!#',!"`T`!]!_31,!WW!

Page 13: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! ";!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8D!B%,-! &!:"!)+! ,-.!01%2.&!#',!"`Q"!61)F%?%*/! ,-3,! '-%4?1.*!3/.?!(*?.1!";!

'3**),!7.!-.4?!'1%2%*3448!1.&6)*&%74.!3*?!,-(&!'1%2%*34!61)&.'(,%)*!'3**),!7.!71)(/-,!

3/3%*&,!,-.2M!0-%4?1.*!(*?.1!"S!')(4?!)*48!7.!'-31/.?!B%,-!@(1?.1!3*?!@3*&43(/-,.1M!!

!

R.',%)*!::U"V!)+!,-.!01%2.&!#',!"`Q"!34&)!&,3,.&!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!3/.?!+1)2!";!,)!"H!'3**),!

7.!-.4?!'1%2%*3448!1.&6)*&%74.!(*4.&&!%,!%&!61)F.?!,-3,!,-.!'-%4?!L*.B!B-3,!,-.8!?%?!B3&!

B1)*/! )1! ')*,1318! ,)! 43BM! A-%&! %&! ')264.2.*,.?! 78! ,-.! ')22)*! 43B! ?)',1%*.! )+!#*0$!

$+5)/)D!B-%'-!B3&!34&)!1.,3%*.?!%*!X.B!Y.343*?M!W,!3664%.&!,)!'-%4?1.*!3/.?!";!f"S!3*?!

)6.13,.&!3&!3!1.7(,,374.!61.&(26,%)*M!#!'-%4?! %&!61.&(2.?!*),!,)!L*)B!,-.!?%++.1.*'.!

7.,B..*!1%/-,!3*?!B1)*/!3*?!,)!7.!/.*.13448!%*'36374.!)+!')22%,,%*/!3!'1%2.!7.'3(&.!

)+!43'L!)+!(*?.1&,3*?%*/M!A-(&!%*!)1?.1!,)!23%*,3%*!3!2(1?.1!)1!23*&43(/-,.1!')*F%',%)*!

)+!3!'-%4?!7.,B..*!3/.&!";!3*?!(*?.1!"S!,-.!61)&.'(,%)*!-3?!,)!&-)B!*),!)*48!,-3,!,-.!

'-%4?!')22%,,.?!,-.!'1%2.!B%,-!,-.!1.K(%&%,.!2.*&!1.3!f!!7(,!,-3,!,-.!'-%4?!3661.'%3,.?!

,-3,!B-3,! -.!B3&! ?)%*/!B3&! &.1%)(&48!B1)*/! U%M.M! 61)F.! ,-.! '-%4?Z&! /(%4,8! L*)B4.?/.VM!

#*8! 61.&(26,%)*&! 3&! ,)! ,-.! *3,(1.! )+! ,-.! )++.*'.! %,&.4+! B%44! *),! &(++%'.! ,)! 61)F.!

L*)B4.?/.MST!

!

#!?%&,%*',!&.,!)+!61%*'%64.&!)1!\&%/*6)&,&Z!,)!/(%?.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!31.!61)F%?.?!%*!&!:;T!)+!

,-.! 0^_>! #',MS`DP;! R.',%)*! :;TU7V! )+! ,-.! 0^_>! #',! &.,&! )(,! ,-.! 61%*'%64.! ,-3,! '1%2%*34!

61)'..?%*/&!&-)(4?!*),!7.!%*&,%,(,.?!B%,-!,-.!&)4.!6(16)&.!)+!3?F3*'%*/!,-.!B.4+31.!)+!

,-.! '-%4?D! )1! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*D! )1! ,-.%1! +32%48M! A-%&! %&! &,1.*/,-.*.?! ,-1)(/-! &! :TS!B-%'-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!ST!G!<!SNN!I"``PJ!n)(&.!)+!o)1?&!S`!@%L.!$))43*D!\A-.!X.B!^)(,-!E(&,%'.!f!o./%&43,%)*!3*?!_13',%'.Z!%*!NE!N1)B*!3*?!>q@!@'p41.3!U.?&MVD!I2&!E*,(2!G*,'(!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!"!K*#&0!*1!H,%($5&!U#('L43*?!o./34!>)(*?3,%)*D!"``HVD!:PM!!P;A-.!&6.'%+%'!61%*'%64.&!/(%?%*/!8)(,-![(&,%'.!61)F%?.!,-3,=!

! 01%2%*34!_1)'..?%*/&!&-)(4?!*),!7.!')22.*'.?!B%,-!,-.!&)4.!6(16)&.!)+!61)F%?%*/!B.4+31.!3&&%&,3*'.!,)!,-.!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*!)1!,-.%1!+32%48!U&:;TU7V!0^_>!#',VD!

! #*8!&3*',%)*&!%26)&.?!)*!'-%4?1.*!)1!8)(*/!6.)64.!&-)(4?!&..L!,)!61)2),.!,-.%1!?.F.4)62.*,!B%,-%*!,-.%1!+32%4%.&!3*?!,3L.!,-.!4.3&,!1.&,1%',%F.!+)12!3661)61%3,.!%*!,-.!'%1'(2&,3*'.&!U&:;TU+VU%V!3*?!U%%VVD!0^_>!#',VD!

! #*8!2.3&(1.&!?.34%*/!B%,-!)++.*?%*/!&-)(4?!&..L!,)!&,1.*/,-.*!,-.!+32%48!3*?!,)!+)&,.1!,-.!37%4%,8!)+!+32%4%.&!,)!?.34!B%,-!)++.*?%*/!78!,-.%1!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.!U&:;TU'VU%V!3*?!U%%VD!0^_>!#',VD!!

! 0-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.!&-)(4?!7.!?%F.1,.?!+1)2!,-.!+)1234!'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!(*4.&&!%,!%&!%*!,-.!6(74%'!%*,.1.&,!*),!,)!U&:;TU3V!0^_>!#',VD!

! @.3&(1.&!%26)&.?!&-)(4?!-3F.!?(.!1./31?!,)!,-.!%*,.1.&,&!)+!F%',%2&!)+!)++.*'.&!U&:;TU/V!0^_>!#',VD!!

! #/.!%&!,)!7.!3!2%,%/3,%*/!+3',)1!%*!?.'%?%*/!B-.,-.1!&3*',%)*&!&-)(4?!7.!%26)&.?!3*?!B-3,!,-)&.!&3*',%)*&!&-)(4?!7.!U&:;TU.VU%V!0^_>!#',VD!

! G*4.&&!6(74%'!&3+.,8!%&!3,!%&&(.D!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.!B-)!')22%,!)++.*'.&!&-)(4?!7.!L.6,!%*!,-.!')22(*%,8!U&:;TU?V!0^_>!#',VD!

! A-.!F(4*.137%4%,8!)+!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.!.*,%,4.&!,-.2!,)!&6.'%34!61),.',%)*!?(1%*/!,-.!%*F.&,%/3,%)*!)+!)++.*'.&!U&:;TU-V!0^_>!#',V!

Page 14: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! ""!

61.F.*,&!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!+1)2!)1?.1%*/!&(6.1F%&%)*D!')22(*%,8!B)1LD!&(6.1F%&%)*!B%,-!

1.&%?.*'.D! &(6.1F%&%)*!B%,-! 3',%F%,8D! )1! ,13*&+.1! ,)! ,-.!$%&,1%',! 0)(1,! +)1! &.*,.*'%*/!)*!

,-.!&)4.!/1)(*?&!,-3,!,-.!8)(*/!6.1&)*!%&!%*!*..?!)+!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*M!!

!

>(1,-.12)1.D!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!%&!.*,%1.48!&.6313,.!+1)2!,-.!>32%48!0)(1,!3*?!&)!'31.!3*?!

61),.',%)*! %&&(.&! 31.! *),! ,)! 7.! 6(1&(.?! %*! ,-.! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! +)1(2MP"! #&[email protected]! 3*?!

@)11%&! 31/(.! asM! A-.! X.B! Y.343*?! &8&,.2! 3,,.26,&! ,)! 2)F.! &)2.! B38! ,)B31?&! 3!

[(&,%'.!3661)3'-!B%,-)(,!373*?)*%*/!,-.!?.&%1.!,)!3'-%.F.!6)&%,%F.!)(,')2.&!+)1!8)(*/!

B-)!)++.*?MbP:!#+,.1!"S!8.31&!)+!3/.D!3!8)(,-!)++.*?.1!')(4?!7.!71)(/-,!%*,)!,-.!^)(,-!

0)(1,Z&! [(1%&?%',%)*M! N(,D! .F.*! ,-.*D! ,-.1.!B3&! 3! 61)'.&&!B-.1.78! '31.! 3*?!61),.',%)*!

%&&(.&!238!7.!1.+.11.?!,)!3!031.!3*?!_1),.',%)*!>32%48!<1)(6!0)*+.1.*'.!0)f)1?%*3,)1!

3,!,-.!?%1.',%)*!)+!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(?/.!UB%,-!,-.!)6,%)*!,-.*!)+!+(1,-.1!1.+.1134!,)!,-.!

>32%48!0)(1,VM!q-.*!,-3,!-366.*&D!,-.!'1%2%*34!'-31/.&!'3*!7.!3?[)(1*.?D!3*?!,-.*!,-.!

)++.*?.1!?%&'-31/.?!37&)4(,.48M!q-.*!8)(*/!6.)64.!31.!?%&'-31/.?!%*!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,D!

,-.! ,B%*! .26-3&%&! %&! )*! 3'')(*,37%4%,8! 3*?! 3??1.&&%*/! ,-.! (*?.148%*/! '3(&.&! )+!

)++.*?%*/D!7(,!,-.1.!1.23%*&!3!&,1)*/!.26-3&%&!3/3%*&,!B.4+31%&%*/!,-.!1.&6)*&.MPH!

!

A-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! 61)'.&&! %&! ,-(&! 1.&.1F.?! +)1! 3! 2%*)1%,8! )+! 8)(*/! )++.*?.1&MPS! W,&!

.&,374%&-2.*,! (*?.14%*.&! ,-.! %26)1,3*'.! )+! ,-.! 61%*'%64.! ,-3,! ,-.! )++.*?%*/! )+! 8)(*/!

6.)64.! &-)(4?! 7.! 61.2%&.?! )*! '1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! *),! B.4+31.! 61%*'%64.&MPP! ! #! [(&,%'.!

)1%.*,3,.?!3661)3'-! %&!34&)!&..*!3&!*.'.&&318!+)1!)4?.1!8)(,-!)++.*?.1&!B-)!31.!2)1.!

'(46374.! ,-3*! ,-.%1! '-%4?! ')(*,.1631,&M!^)(*/!6.)64.!31.!374.! ,)!7.! ,13*&+.11.?! ,)! ,-.!

3?(4,! '1%2%*34! ')(1,&! 3,! ,-.! 3/.! )+! "PM! R('-! ,13*&+.1! %&! 6)&&%74.! %*! ,B)! '%1'(2&,3*'.&M!

>%1&,48!B-.*! ,-.!)++.*'.! ')22%,,.?! %&!6(1.48! %*?%',374.!3*?! ,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!?).&!*),!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!P"!A-.!0^_>!#',!"`T`!&!:;TU7V!!P:!<[email protected]!3*?!#!@)11%&D!37)F.!*!:HD!3,!:M!!PH!E(?/.!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,!_1%*'%634!a0-%4?1.*!3*?!^)(*/!_.)64.!%*!0)*+4%',!B%,-!,-.!o3B=!#&L%*/!,-.!n31?!c(.&,%)*&b!UtrWW!q)14?!0)*/1.&&!)+!,-.!W*,.1*3,%)*34!#&&)'%3,%)*!)+!^)(,-!3*?!>32%48!E(?/.&!3*?!@3/%&,13,.&D!N.4+3&,D!W1.43*?D!H"!#(/(&,!:;;QVM!PS!A-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!?.34&!)*48!B%,-!,-.!2)&,!&.1%)(&!)++.*'.&!3*?!)++.*?.1&D!7(,!,-.1.!-3&!7..*!3'L*)B4.?/.2.*,!+1)2!,-.!_1%*'%634!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(?/.!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,!,-3,!X.B!Y.343*?!*)B!-3&!3!6.1&%&,.*,!(*?.1'43&&D!,-1..!/.*.13,%)*&!4)*/!+1)2!B-%'-!23*8!)+!,-.&.!)++.*?.1&!31.!?13B*M!n.*'.!%,!%&!3!2%O.?!73/!)+!1.&(4,&!+)1!X.B!Y.343*?!&)'%.,8=!)*!,-.!)*.!-3*?D!61)/1.&&%F.!4./%&43,%)*!,)!L..6!'-%4?1.*!)(,!)+!,-.!')(1,!3*?!,-.!6.*34!&8&,.2!3*?!,)B31?&!?%F.1&%)*318!+)12&!)+!&.*,.*'%*/!4%L.!')22(*%,8!&.1F%'.D!7(,!)*!,-.!),-.1!-3*?D!&2344!7(,!6.1&%&,.*,!')-)1,&!)+!8)(,-!B-)!31.!)*!63,-B38&!,)B31?&!&.1%)(&!'1%2%*34%,8M!A-.1.!%&!3!&%/*%+%'3*,!.,-*%'!')26)*.*,!,)!,-%&!63,,.1*D!B%,-!@3)1%!)F.1f1.61.&.*,.?!%*!,-.!*./3,%F.!&,3,%&,%'&M!A-.!@3)1%!8)(,-!3661.-.*&%)*!13,.!%&!2)1.!,-3*!,-1..!,%2.&!,-3,!)+!_3'%+%'!)1!XY!p(1)6.3*!^)(,-!U0-%4?!^)(,-!3*?!>32%48!9++.*?%*/!R,3,%&,%'&!%*!X.B!Y.343*?!:;";!3,!S:VM!!!!PP!A-3,!%&D!)*!*),%)*&!)+!3'')(*,37%4%,8!3*?!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!+)1!3',%)*&D!?(.!61)'.&&D!4./34!1.61.&.*,3,%)*D!1.K(%1%*/![(?/.&!,)!/%F.!1.3&)*&!+)1!'.1,3%*!?.'%&%)*&D!3*?!%26)&%*/!&3*',%)*&!B-%'-!31.!61)6)1,%)*3,.!,)!,-.!/13F%,8!)+!,-.!)++.*'.!

Page 15: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! ":!

7.4%.F.! %,! -3&! ,-.! 1.K(%&%,.! ,))4&! ,)!?.34!B%,-! ,-.!)++.*?%*/D!)1! 34,.1*3,%F.48!B-.*! ,-.!

)++.*'.! %&! 6(*%&-374.!78! %261%&)*2.*,! +)1! 3! ,.12!.O'..?%*/!H!2)*,-&! 3*?! ,-.! 8)(*/!

6.1&)*!.4.',&!,1%34!78![(18!(*?.1!&!QQ!)+!,-.!R(22318!_1)'..?%*/&!#',M!

!

X.B!Y.343*?Z&!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!B3&!34&)!,-.!+%1&,!4./%&43,.?!.O3264.PQ!!)+!3!2)F.!%*!

,-.!?%1.',%)*!)+!3!1.&,)13,%F.![(&,%'.!3661)3'-!,)B31?&!)++.*?%*/!f!3*?!,-(&!3B38!+1)2!

,-.! ,13?%,%)*34! [(&,%'.! 3*?! B.4+31.! 1.&6)*&.&MPg! ! W,! +)'(&.&! )*! 1.63%1%*/! -312D!

1.%*,./13,%*/!)++.*?.1&D!3*?!1.&,)1%*/!,-.!7343*'.!B%,-%*!,-.!')22(*%,8!3++.',.?!78!,-.!

)++.*'.M! N),-! +32%48! /1)(6! ')*+.1.*'.&! 3*?! 1.&,)13,%F.! [(&,%'.! /%F.! 3! &38! %*! -)B! ,-.!

)++.*'.! &-)(4?! 7.! 1.&)4F.?! ,)! ,-)&.! 2)&,! 3++.',.?! 78! %,! ]! F%',%2&D! )++.*?.1&D! ! ,-.%1!

+32%4%.&D! 3*?! B%?.1! B-u*3(! f! B%,-! ,-.!2)?.4! )+! ?.'%&%)*f23L%*/! 3?F)'3,.?! ,)! 7.! 78!

/1)(6! ')*&.*&(&M! p26-3&%&! %&! 6(,! )*! ,-.! *..?! ,)! 3??1.&&! ,-.! )++.*?%*/! 3*?! %,&!

')*&.K(.*'.&! %*! 2.3*%*/+(4! B38&MPT! A-.! L.8! .4.2.*,! )+! ,-%&! 61)/1.&&%F.! 1.&,)13,%F.!

613',%'.! %&! ,-3,! ,-.! )++.*?.1! %&! *),!231/%*34%&.?! 7(,! 3''.6,.?! 3&! 3! L.8! ')*,1%7(,)1! ,)!

?.'%&%)*f23L%*/M! A-.1.+)1.! %*! X.B! Y.343*?! +32%48! /1)(6! ')*+.1.*'.&! 31.! *),! &%2648!

(&.?! %*! ,1%F%34! '3&.&! 7(,! 34&)! &.1%)(&! )++.*?%*/! %*F)4F%*/! 7(1/4318D! 31&)*D! 136.! 3*?!

)++.*'.&!)+!3!&%2%431!*3,(1.M!!

!

X.B! Y.343*?Z&! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2! 366.31&! 6-%4)&)6-%'3448! &)(*?M! W*?..?! %,! %&!

+1.K(.*,48!')*&%?.1.?!B)14?!4.3?%*/MP`!W,!'3*!7.!&..*!,-3,!,-.!"`T`!4./%&43,%)*!B3&!73&.?!

(6)*!,-.!*..?!,)!%*')16)13,.!,-.![(&,%'.!2)?.4!B-%4&,!3'L*)B4.?/%*/!,-3,!)*!&)2.!4.F.4!

3!?%++.1.*,%3,%)*!-3?!,)!7.!23?.!7.,B..*!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*! %&&(.&!3*?!,-)&.!B-.1.!

,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!3*?!,-.!'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!B.1.!,-.!3661)61%3,.!+)1(2!+)1!?.34%*/!

B%,-!,-.!8)(*/!6.1&)*Z&!,13*&/1.&&%)*&D!3*?!,-(&!3*!317%,1318!4%*.!B3&!?13B*!3,!,-.!3/.!

)+!"SM!W*!613',%'.D!%,!+3'.&!61)74.2&!)+!3?.K(3,.!1.&)(1'%*/!3*?!?%++%'(4,%.&!%*!3?.K(3,.48!

2..,%*/!7),-!,-.!3'')(*,37%4%,8!3*?!B.4+31.!*..?&!)+!'-%4?!3*?!8)(,-!)++.*?.1&MQ;mQ"!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PQ!q%,-%*!3!')(*,18!,-3,!)6.13,.&!(*?.1!,-.!q.&,2%*&,.1!&8&,.2!Pg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email protected]!3*?!#44%&)*!@)11%&!a^)(,-!E(&,%'.!%*!X.B!Y.343*?=!5.&,)13,%F.!E(&,%'.!%*!_13',%'.kb!U:;;QV!Q:!A-.!E)(1*34!)+!R)'%34!W&&(.&!3,!:"!P`!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,D!37)F.!*!PH!Q;!%7%?!!R('-!%*3?.K(3'%.&!%*'4(?.=!%*3?.K(3,.!<)F.1*2.*,!+(*?%*/D!%*3?.K(3,.!344)'3,%)*!)+!1.&)(1'.&!B%,-%*!?.631,2.*,&D!6))1!,13%*%*/!)+!&)'%34!B)1L.1&D!3*?!6))1!,13*&+.1!)+!%*+)123,%)*!7.,B..*!3/.*'%.&m!E(?/.!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,D!_1%*'%634!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(?/.!a^)(,-!E(&,%'.!%*!X.B!Y.343*?=!>(,(1.!

Page 16: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! "H!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!0-344.*/.&b!U636.1!61.&.*,.?!3,!,-.!X.B!Y.343*?!^)(,-!E(&,%'.!0)*+.1.*'.D!X.B!Y.343*?!^)(,-!E(&,%'.!0)*+.1.*'.=!aX.F.1!A))!p3148D!X.F.1!A))!o3,.b!q.44%*/,)*D!"g!]]"`!@38!:;;SV!3,!g!Q"!A-%&!%&!?%&'(&&.?!+(1,-.1!%*!0-36,.1!HMH!

Page 17: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! "S!

AK"LCDE!CSB!

C:*!"%*#1%*#'8!

!

9*!@31'-! Q! :;";! ,-.! X3,%)*34! <)F.1*2.*,! 63&&.?! A-.! 0-%4?1.*D! ^)(*/! _.1&)*&! 3*?!

A-.%1! >32%4%.&! U^)(,-! 0)(1,! E(1%&?%',%)*! 3*?! 91?.1&V! #2.*?2.*,! #',! :;";! U\A-.!

#2.*?2.*,ZVM! A-%&! *.B! 4./%&43,%)*! '32.! %*,)! +)1'.! )*! ,-.! "&,! 9',)7.1! :;";M! #&! ! %,&!

*32.!&(//.&,&D!,-.!#2.*?2.*,!+)'(&.&!)*!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,M!W,!*),!)*48!%*,1)?('.?!*.B!

6)B.1&D!)1?.1&D!3*?!.O,.*?.?!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(1%&?%',%)*m!%,!31/(3748!34&)!1.61.&.*,.?!

3! &%/*%+%'3*,! &-%+,! %*! ,-.! (*?.148%*/! ,-.)1.,%'34! 61%*'%64.&! )+! ,-.! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2!

?%&'(&&.?! 37)F.M! A-%&! '-36,.1! B%44! .O643%*! ,-.! #2.*?2.*,&! 3*?! B%44! .*?.3F)(1! ,)!

(*?.1&,3*?!,-.!2),%F3,%)*!7.-%*?!&('-!3!+(*?32.*,34!'-3*/.M!!

!

RIJ!! A:&#@*8!23)!':*!8*)<3(8!.:<61!322*#1*)!

!

A-.!2)&,! +31f1.3'-%*/!'-3*/.! ,-3,! ,-.!#2.*?2.*,!61)F%?.?!B3&! ,)! ,-.!'-%4?!)++.*?.1!

61)F%&%)*&!)+!,-.!61%*'%634!#',M!G*?.1!,-.!#2.*?2.*,!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!

1.23%*&!3,!";!8.31&!3*?!'-%4?1.*!238!&,%44!7.!61)&.'(,.?!+)1!-)2%'%?.D!7(,!'-%4?1.*!3/.?!

":!3*?!"H!8.31&!31.!*)B!61)&.'(,374.!%*!,B)!+(1,-.1!'%1'(2&,3*'.&MQ:!A-.!+%1&,!%&!B-.1.!

,-.! '-%4?! %&! 344./.?! ,)! -3F.! ')22%,,.?! 3*! )++.*'.! B%,-! 3! 23O%2(2! 6.*34,8! %*'4(?%*/!

%261%&)*2.*,!+)1!4%+.!)1!+)1!3,!4.3&,!"S!8.31&MQH!A-.!&.')*?!%&!B-.1.!,-.!'-%4?!%&!344./.?!,)!

-3F.!')22%,,.?!3*!)++.*'.!B-.1.!,-.!23O%2(2!6.*34,8!%&!)1!%*'4(?.&!3,!4.3&,!";!8.31&v!

%261%&)*2.*,! 7(,! 4.&&! ,-3*! "S! 8.31&v! %261%&)*2.*,! 3*?! ,-.! '-%4?! %&! 3! 61.F%)(&!

)++.*?.1MQS!A-.&.!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!1.,3%*!,-.!61),.',%)*&!)+!#*0$!$+5)/)DM!

!

A-.!61)F%&%)*!344)B%*/!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?!'-%4?1.*!,)!7.!61)&.'(,.?!+)1!'.1,3%*!&.1%)(&!

)1! 6.1&%&,.*,! )++.*?%*/! %&! 3! ')*&%?.1374.! ,-.)1.,%'34! &-%+,M! A-.! 1.&,1%',%)*&! )*!

61)&.'(,%)*!)+!(*?.1!"S!8.31!)4?&!-3&!7..*! %*!643'.! &%*'.! ,-.!"`gS!#',!3*?!&%*'.! ,-%&!

,%2.D!,-.!,-.)1.,%'34!73&%&!)+!,-.!,1.3,2.*,!)+!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!-3&!7..*!,-.!61.&(26,%)*!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!\R

!!&"S!E(1%&?%',%)*!)+!^)(,-!0)(1,!UR..!#66.*?%O!#V!QH!A-%&!?.+%*%,%)*!%*'4(?.&!3!B%?.!13*/.!)+!)++.*'.&D!+1)2!3&&3(4,!B%,-!%*,.*,!,)!1)7!U&!:HQD!01%2.&!#',VD!B)(*?%*/!B%,-!%*,.*,!,)!'3(&.!/1%.F)(&!7)?%48!-312!U&!"TTU"VVD!,)!,-.!4.&&.1!L*)B*!)++.*'.&!)+!?.34%*/!%*!&43F.&!U&!`TV!3*?!6%13'8!U&!`:VM!!!QS!#/3%*D!,-%&!')F.1&!3!13*/.!)+!)++.*'.&!%*'4(?%*/!7(1/4318!U&!:H"!)+!,-.!01%2.&!#',V!3*?!1)77.18!U&!:HSVM!h_1.F%)(&!)++.*?.1h!%&!?.+%*.?!%*!&!SU:V!)+!,-.!32.*?%*/!#',!3&!7.%*/!3!'-%4?!B-)!-3&!7..*!?.'431.?!%*!*..?!)+!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!78!,-.!>32%48!0)(1,!%*!1.43,%)*!,)!3*!)++.*'.!3,,13',%*/!3!23O%2(2!6.*34,8!)+!3,!4.3&,!";!8.31&D!)1!')*F%',.?!78!,-.!n%/-!0)(1,!)+!2(1?.1!)1!23*&43(/-,.1!)1!3*!)++.*'.!B%,-!3!23O%2(2!6.*34,8!)+!4%+.!)1!3,!4.3&,!"S!8.31&v!%261%&)*2.*,D!)1!61)F.?!7.+)1.!3!^)(,-!0)(1,!,)!-3F.!')22%,,.?!3*!)++.*'.!B%,-!3!23O%2(2!6.*34,8!)+!4%+.!)1!3,!4.3&,!"S!8.31&M!

Page 18: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! "P!

,-3,!)++.*?%*/!&,.2&!+1)2!?%++%'(4,%.&! %*!,-.!-)2.! 4%+.!)+! ,-.!'-%4?D!3*?!,-(&!&-)(4?!7.!

1.&)4F.?! ,-1)(/-! 34,.1*3,%F.! 3',%)*! )1! ,-.! '31.! 3*?! 61),.',%)*! 61)'.&&MQP! A-.! &,31,%*/!

6)%*,!-3&!7..*!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!B-)!)++.*?!?)!&)D!%*!,-.!+%1&,!%*&,3*'.D!7.'3(&.!)+!&.1%)(&!

%*3?.K(3'%.&! %*! ,-.%1! (671%*/%*/M! q-%4.! 3,! ,-3,! 3/.! ,-.1.! %&! '.1,3%*48! 3*! .4.2.*,! )+!

?.4%7.13,.!3*?!6.1&)*34!'-)%'.! %*F)4F.?D! ,-.!6-%4)&)6-8!61%)1! ,)! ,-.!32.*?2.*,&!B3&!

,-3,!(*4.&&!,-.1.!31.!&%/*%+%'3*,! %*,.1F.*,%)*&! %*,)!,-.!'-%4?Z&! +32%48!&8&,.2!,-.*!,-.1.!

B%44!7.!4%,,4.!'-3*'.!)+!,(1*%*/!3!'-%4?!3B38!+1)2!'1%2.MQQ!A-%&!%&!')*&%?.1.?!.&6.'%3448!&)!

+)1! F.18! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?.1&MQg! A-.! 6-%4)&)6-8! -3&! 7..*! ,-3,! &%2648! -)4?%*/! &('-!

'-%4?! )++.*?.1&! ,)! 3'')(*,! 3*?! (&%*/! 3! 6(*%,%F.i! 1.-37%4%,3,%F.! 6313?%/2! B%,-%*! ,-.!

^)(,-!0)(1,!%&!(*4%L.48!,)!61)?('.!.*?(1%*/!'-3*/.MQT!

!

RIR!! 93(':!B22*#1*)8!<#!':*!"1(6'!A3()'!

!

A-.!3/.!3,!B-%'-!3!8)(*/!6.1&)*!238!7.!,13*&+.11.?!,)!,-.!$%&,1%',!0)(1,![(1%&?%',%)*!+)1!

,1%34! 3*?! &.*,.*'.! -3&! 7..*! 1.?('.?! +1)2! "P! ,)! "S! 8.31&! f!23L%*/! &('-! "S! 8.31! )4?&!

4%374.!,)!&.*,.*'.&!)+! %261%&)*2.*,MQ`!N8!.4.',%*/!,1%34!78! [(18!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&!'3*!

34&)!.*,.1!,-.!3?(4,!'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!&8&,.2M!9*!,13*&+.1!,)!,-.!3?(4,!')(1,&!,-.!61%*'%64.&!

)+!,-.!0^_>!#',!'.3&.!,)!36648!3*?!,-.!61%*'%64.&!)+!,-.!R.*,.*'%*/!#',!:;;:!L%'L!%*M!A-%&!

7.'32.!'4.31! %*!E(48!)+! ,-%&!8.31!B-.*! %*!N*,72)'&!<!PUV!,-.! !0)(1,!)+!#66.34!23?.!3!

[(?/2.*,! )*! ,-.! 3664%'3,%)*! )+! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 61%*'%64.&! %*! ,-.! $%&,1%',! 0)(1,! 3*?! n%/-!

0)(1,Mg"! A-.! 366.34! -.1.! B3&! )*! 3! K(.&,%)*! )+! 43B! +1)2! ,-.! n%/-! 0)(1,! 3/3%*&,! 3!

&.*,.*'.!)+! ,B)!3*?!3!-34+!8.31&! %261%&)*2.*,!)+!3*!)++.*?.1! ,13*&+.11.?!,)! ,-.!n%/-!

0)(1,!+)1!3!')*F%',%)*!)+!3//13F3,.?!1)77.18Mg:!A-.!#66.34!3&L.?!,-.!K(.&,%)*=!B-.*!3!

8)(*/! 6.1&)*! %&! &.*,.*'.?! %*! ,-.! $%&,1%',! 0)(1,! )1! ,-.! n%/-! 0)(1,D! -3F%*/! 7..*!

,13*&+.11.?! +)1! &.*,.*'.! 78! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,D! 2(&,! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 61%*'%64.&! (*?.1! ,-.!

0^_>!#',!"`T`!3&!B.44!3&!,-)&.!%*!,-.!R.*,.*'%*/!#',!:;;:!7.!,3L.*!%*,)!3'')(*,!78!,-.!

&.*,.*'%*/![(?/.k!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!QP!q%,-!,-.!*),%'.374.!.O'.6,%)*!)+!-)2%'%?.!QQ!<[email protected]!3*?!E!5)7.1,&)*!U"``PV!G2$0#!>11&+#&'%A!"!'&/*'(!(*!(2&!K$+$%(&'%!*1!H,%($5&Q!N*0$5&!)+#!M*5$)0!J&01)'&B!q.44%*/,)*=!9++%'.!)+!,-.!0)22%&&%)*.1!+)1!0-%4?1.*m!5!N)&-%.1!U"``QV!G2$0#!>11&+#&'%!K)+,)0M!#!613',%'34!/(%?.!,)!&(''.&&+(4!%*,.1F.*,%)*!B%,-!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&M!!Qg!%7%?!QT!A-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!)+!X.B!Y.343*?!aR(72%&&%)*!,)!R)'%34!R.1F%'.&!R.4.',!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!0-%4?1.*D!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!U^)(,-!0)(1,!E(1%&?%',%)*!3*?!91?.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!N%44bM!Q`!A-.!0-%4?1.*D!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!U^)(,-!0)(1,!E(1%&?%',%)*!3*?!91?.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!#',!:;";!UaA-.!0^_>!#2.*?2.*,!#',!:;";V!X.B!&!:THU)V!!g;!N*,72)'&!<!P!I:;";J!XY0#!:QT!g"!A-%&!E(?/2.*,!B3&!/%F.*!)*!,-.!:*?!)+!E(48!:;";!3+,.1!,-.!#2.*?2.*,!-3?!7..*!63&&.?M!!g:!N*,72)'&!<!PD!"Q!#61%4!:;";D!n%/-!0)(1,D!q3*/3*(%D!05W!:;";fSTHf""D!E(&,%'.!@%44.1!

Page 19: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! "Q!

!

A-.!0)(1,!-.4?!,-3,!%,!%&!,-.!R.*,.*'%*/!#',!61)F%&%)*&!3*?!61%*'%64.&!B-%'-!36648!,)!,-.!

&.*,.*'%*/! )+! 3! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*! B-)! -3&! 7..*! ')*F%',.?! 3*?! ,13*&+.11.?! +)1! &.*,.*'.M!

q-%4.!3!8)(*/!6.1&)*v&!F(4*.137%4%,8D! %26(4&%F.*.&&!3*?!43'L!)+!23,(1%,8!B%44!34B38&!7.!

1.4.F3*,D!3*?!&)2.,%2.&!?.'%&%F.! ,)! ,-.%1! &.*,.*'%*/! %*!3*!3?(4,!')(1,D! ,-.!R.*,.*'%*/!

#',! :;;:! 3*348&%&! B)(4?! 7.! 1.*?.1.?! %*')-.1.*,! %+! %,&! 6(16)&.&D! 61%*'%64.&! 3*?!

3//13F3,%*/! 3*?! 2%,%/3,%*/! +3',)1&! ?%?! *),! .++.',%F.48! ?%&643'.! ,-.! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.!

&.*,.*'%*/! 61%*'%64.&! %*! &:;T! 0^_>! #',M! W*! &-)1,D! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 61%*'%64.&! 31.! *)B! *),!

1.K(%1.?!,)!7.!,3L.*!%*,)!3'')(*,!B-.*!&.*,.*'%*/!3!8)(*/!6.1&)*!%*!,-.!3?(4,!')(1,M!

!

A-.!0)(1,!)+!#66.34!-.4?!,-3,D!(*?.1!,-.!R.*,.*'%*/!#',D!3!0)(1,!2(&,!B.%/-!,-.!8)(*/!

6.1&)*v&!3/.!3*?!,-.!1.3&)*&!B-8!-.!)1!&-.!)++.*?.?!3&!2%,%/3,%*/!+3',)1&!3/3%*&,!,-.!

&.1%)(&*.&&!)+!-%&!)1!-.1!)++.*?%*/!3*?!61)&6.',&!)+!1.-37%4%,3,%)*M!A-%&!&.*,.*'%*/!34&)!

-3?! ,)! 3'')1?! B%,-! ,-.! G*%,.?! X3,%)*&! 0)*F.*,%)*&! )*! ,-.! 5%/-,! )+! ,-.! 0-%4?! B-.1.!

')*&%&,.*,!B%,-!,-.!R.*,.*'%*/!#',MgH!

!

A-%&!?.'%&%)*!34&)!1.%*+)1'.?!,-.!0)(1,!)+!#66.34v&!')22%,2.*,!,)!8)(*/!+%1&,!)++.*?.1&!

B-)D!78! %264%'3,%)*D!-3F.!/))?! '-3*'.&!)+! 1.-37%4%,3,%)*M! W*! +3',D! ,-.!0)(1,! ')*+%12.?!

,-3,D!?.&6%,.!,31%++!'3&.&!&('-!3&!P!<!K)@*!I:;;TJ!$05!g;!Un0V!7.%*/!%*?%&6.*&374.D!,-.!

.++.',!,-3,!3/.!'3*!-3F.!)*!,-.!4.*/,-!)+!3!&.*,.*'.!%&!h(*')*&,13%*.?!78!3*8!*)123,%F.!

6.1'.*,3/.hM! A-%&! )6.*&! ,-.!B38! +)1! ')27%*.?! ?%&')(*,&! +)1! 8)(,-! 3*?! /(%4,8! 64.3! ,)!

.O'..?! P;w! )+! 3*! 3?(4,! &,31,%*/! 6)%*,M! W*! ,-%&! '3&.! ,-.! 0)(1,! )+! #66.34! (6-.4?! ,-.!

?.'%&%)*!)+!@%44.1!E!%*!,-.!n%/-!0)(1,D!3*?!,-.!366.34!3/3%*&,!,-.!&.*,.*'.!)+!,B)!3*?!3!

-34+!8.31&!B3&!?%&2%&&.?M!!!

!

$.&6%,.! ,-.! +3',! ,-3,! ,-.! 0)(1,! )+! #66.34! &.,! *)! 4%2%,! )*! ,-.!23O%2(2!?%&')(*,! ,-3,!

')(4?! 7.! /%F.*! +)1! 8)(,-! 3&! 3!2%,%/3,%*/! +3',)1D! ,-.! 6)&&%7%4%,8! &,%44! 31%&.&! )+! '-%4?! 3*?!

8)(,-! )++.*?.1&! 7.%*/! &.*,.*'.?! ,)! &(7&,3*,%34! &.*,.*'.! )+! %261%&)*2.*,! ?(.! ,)!

4.*/,-8!&,31,%*/!6)%*,&!7.%*/!&.,!78!/(%?.4%*.![(?/2.*,&MgS!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!gH!A-%&!%&!?%&'(&&.?!+(1,-.1!%*!0-36,.1!,-1..!3,!HM:M!!A-.!GX0590!61)F%?.&!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!(*?.1!"T=!

• R-)(4?!-3F.!,-.%1!7.&,!%*,.1.&,&!,1.3,.?!3&!3!61%2318!')*&%?.13,%)*m!• @(&,!7.!,1.3,.?!%*!3!B38!,-3,!61)2),.&!,-.%1!&.*&.!)+!?%/*%,8!3*?!B)1,-m!• @(&,!-3F.!,-.%1!1.&6.',!+)1!,-.!-(23*!1%/-,&!3*?!+(*?32.*,34!+1..?)2&!)+!),-.1&!

1.%*+)1'.?m!3*?!• @(&,!7.!/%F.*!3!&.*,.*'.!B-%'-!,3L.&!%*,)!3'')(*,!,-.%1!3/.!3*?!?.&%137%4%,8!)+!61)2),%*/!

,-.%1!1.%*,./13,%)*!3*?!3&&(2%*/!3!')*&,1(',%F.!1)4.!%*!&)'%.,8M!gS!A-%&!%&!?%&'(&&.?!+(1,-.1!%*!0-36,.1!SMH!!

Page 20: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! "g!

!

RIN!! Y(<1<#@!L)<#.<,6*8!

!

#&!2.*,%)*.?!37)F.D!,-.!/(%?%*/!61%*'%64.&!')*,3%*.?! %*!&!:;T!)+!,-.!"`T`!#',!31.!,-.!

73'L7)*.!)+!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2M!AB)!'-3*/.&!,)!&!:;T!31.!')*,3%*.?!%*!&!Q!)+!,-.!

#2.*?2.*,MgP!>%1&,D!,-.!&,3,(&!)+!,-.!F%',%2!%&!&,1.*/,-.*.?M!q-%4.!(*?.1!,-.!61%*'%634!

#',!2.3&(1.&!2(&,!,3L.!?(.!1./31?!)+!F%',%2&v!%*,.1.&,&D!*)B!h61)6.1!1./31?h!-3&!,)!7.!

/%F.*! ,)! ,-.! %*,.1.&,&! 3*?!B%&-.&!)+! ,-.! F%',%2&! 3*?! ,-.! h%263',!)+! ,-.!)++.*?%*/h!)*!

,-.2M!R.')*?D!3*8!2.3&(1.&!2(&,!*)B!3??1.&&!,-.!'3(&.&!)+!)++.*?%*/M!A-%&!%&!.F%?.*,!

%*! ,-.!*3,(1.!)+!*.B!)1?.1&!3F3%4374.! ,)!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,=! ,-.&.!31.!?.&%/*.?!,)!,3'L4.!

,-.!K(34%,8!)+!631.*,%*/!3*?!,-.!.O,.*,!)+!&(7&,3*'.!37(&.!61)74.2&M!!

!

A-1..!*.B!)1?.1&!1.+4.',!,-%&!'-3*/.!%*!,-.%1!(*?.148%*/!61%*'%64.&!,)!3??1.&&!,-.!'3(&.&!

)+!)++.*?%*/M!W,!%*,1)?('.&!,-1)(/-!&!H;!631.*,%*/!.?('3,%)*!)1?.1&DgQ!!?1(/!3*?!34')-)4!

1.-37%4%,3,%)*! 61)/1322.!)1?.1&! 3*?!2.*,)1%*/! )1?.1&! U)+! (6! ,)! ":!2)*,-&VMgg! A-.&.!

*.B!61%*'%64.&!&-)B!3*!3??%,%)*34! ,-.)1.,%'34!&-%+,! %*!,-.!#',M!#*! %**)F3,%F.!+.3,(1.!)+!

,-.!61%*'%634!#',!B3&!,-.!61%2318!1)4.!/%F.*!,)!,-.!+32%48!%*!?.'%&%)*f23L%*/D!3&!%,!,))L!

,-.!1.F)4(,%)*318!&,.6!)+!631,%3448!,13*&+.11%*/!6)B.1!+1)2!,-.!&,3,.!,)!+32%4%.&D!F%',%2&!

3*?!')22(*%,%.&!,-1)(/-!%,&!>32%48!<1)(6!0)*+.1.*'.MgT!W,!%&!31/(374.!,-3,!+)44)B%*/!%,&!

#2.*?2.*,! ,-.! #',! -3&! 2)F.?! '4)&.1! ,)! ,-.! [(&,%'.! 2)?.4! )+! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! ,-1)(/-!

.26-3&%&%*/! ,-.! F%',%2Z&! 1%/-,&! 3*?! ,-3,! ,-.! 4)'(&! )+! 6)B.1! -3&! /13F%,3,.?! &4%/-,48!

,)B31?&! ,-.! &,3,.! 78! 1.2)F%*/! ,-.! .4.2.*,! )+! &.4+f?%1.',%)*!61.F%)(&48! 61.&.*,! %*! ,-.!

#',Mg`!

!

RIX!! Y*#*)&6!E*Z3)@&#<8&'<3#!

!

A-.!#2.*?2.*,!34&)!61)F%?.?!+)1!3!/.*.134!1.f)1/3*%&3,%)*!)+!&!:TH!)+!,-.!61%*'%634!#',!

U?.34%*/!B%,-!^)(,-!0)(1,!)1?.1&VD!'1.3,%*/!3!-%.131'-8!)+!)1?.1&!+1)2!<1)(6!"!U?%&'-31/.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!gP!R.',%)*!Q!A-.!0^_>!#2.*?2.*,!#',!:;";D!R..!#66.*?%O!#!!gQ!A-.&.!61)/1322.&!31.!36631.*,48!2)?.44.?!)*!61)/1322.&!%*!p*/43*?!3*?!q34.&M!!W+!,-.!631.*,!+3%4&!,)!')264.,.!,-.!1.K(%1.2.*,&!)+!,-.!)1?.1D!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(?/.!%&!.26)B.1.?!,)!)1?.1!,-3,!3!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!+32%48!/1)(6!')*+.1.*'.!7.!')*F.*.?!%*!1.&6.',!)+!.F.18!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*!%*!,-.!+32%48M!W+!,-.!8)(*/!6.1&)*!%&!3!631.*,!)1!&))*f,)f7.!631.*,D!-.!)1!&-.!'3*!7.!1.K(%1.?!,)!3,,.*?!3!631.*,%*/!.?('3,%)*!61)/1322.D!3*?!71.3'-!B%44!7.!?.34,!B%,-!3&!%&!,-.!71.3'-!)+!3*8!),-.1!)1?.1M!gg!A-.!0^_>!#2.*?2.*,!#',!:;";D!&!H;!]!R..!#66.*?%O!#!!gT!E(?/.!@'p41.3!aX.B!Y.343*?!^)(,-!0)(1,=!#!@)?.4!+)1!$.F.4)62.*,!%*!),-.1!0)(1,&k!b!UX3,%)*34!0)*+.1.*'.!)+!$%&,1%',!0)(1,!E(?/.&D!5),)1(3D!X.B!Y.343*?D!#61%4V!g`!X.&&3!o8*'-M!a0-3*/.&!,)!^)(,-!E(&,%'.b!U:;";V!SU@38!V!X.B!Y.343*?!o3B!E)(1*34!3,!"H;!

Page 21: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! "T!

)1! 3?2)*%&-2.*,V! ,)!<1)(6!g! U,13*&+.1! ,)! ,-.!$%&,1%',!0)(1,! +)1! ,1%34!)1! &.*,.*'.VM! A-.!

63132.,.1&!)+! ,-.! ,)6f.*?!^)(,-!0)(1,!)1?.1! U&(6.1F%&%)*!B%,-! 1.&%?.*'.V!31.!'-3*/.?!

,)!3!2%*%2(2!)+!,-1..!2)*,-&!3*?!3!23O%2(2!)+!&%O!2)*,-&!U&!HQVMT;!

!

#! 1.')/*%&.?! 43'(*3! %*! ,-.! 61%*'%634! #',! B3&! ,-.! 61)'.?(1.! B-.*! 3! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*!

71.3'-.?! ,-.! ,.12&! )+! 3*! )1?.1MT"! A-.! 32.*?%*/! 4./%&43,%)*! 61)F%?.&! +)1! 3! /13?(3,.?!

&8&,.2! )+! 1.&6)*&.&! ,)! 71.3'-.&! )+! )1?.1&MT:! W+! 3! '-%4?! )1! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*! -3&! +3%4.?! ,)!

')2648!B%,-!3!')(1,!)1?.1DTH!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!%&!.26)B.1.?!,)!23L.!3*),-.1!)1?.1D!)1!f!%+!

,-.! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*! %&! 341.3?8! &(7[.',! ,)! [(?%'%34! 2)*%,)1%*/! ?(.! ,)! 3! 61.F%)(&! 71.3'-! f!

23L.!3*!%*,.*&%F.!&(6.1F%&%)*!)1?.1MTS!!>(1,-.12)1.!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!%&!*)B!.26)B.1.?!

(*?.1! ,-.! 32.*?.?! &H""! ,)! 23L.! 3! &(6.1F%&%)*! B%,-! 1.&%?.*'.! )1?.1! &(7[.',! ,)! ,-.!

')*?%,%)*! ,-3,! ,-.! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*! (*?.1,3L.&! 3*8! &6.'%+%.?! 61)/1322.! )1! 3',%F%,8M! A-.!

<)F.1*2.*,! 61)6)&.?! ,)! ?.F.4)6! 3*?! %264.2.*,! -%/-48! &6.'%34%j.?! 1.&%?.*,%34!

61)/1322.&!,-3,!%*F)4F.!7(,!31.!*),!4%2%,.?!,)D!2%4%,318!&,84.!?%&'%64%*.M!5.+.1.*'.!,)!,-.!

%*,1)?(',%)*!)+!,-.&.!2%4%,318f&,84.!3',%F%,8!'326!61)/1322.&!%&!23?.!%*!,-.!5./(43,)18!

W263',!R,3,.2.*,! %*'4(?.?! %*!,-.!.O643*3,)18!*),.!,)!,-.!N%44MTP!n)B.F.1! %,! %&!(&.+(4! ,)!

*),.! ,-3,! ,-.! N%44! ?).&! *),! 61)6)&.! 3! &6.'%+%'! 2%4%,318f&,84.! 3',%F%,8! '326! 61)/1322.!

)1?.1MTQDTg!!!

!

!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!T;!R.',%)*!HQ!0^_>!#2.*?2.*,!#',!:;";!R..!#66.*?%O!#!!T"!!>)1!.O3264.D!'(11.*,48!,-.!+32%48!/1)(6!')*+.1.*'.!-3&!3!B%?.!?%&'1.,%)*!%*!%,&!1.')22.*?3,%)*&D!7(,!(*?.1!,-.!32.*?%*/!#',!%,!B%44!7.!&,3,(,)1%48!1.K(%1.?!,)!')*&%?.1!1.')22.*?%*/!?1(/!3*?!34')-)4!1.-37%4%,3,%)*!)1?.1&D!2.*,)1%*/!)1?.1&!3*?!631.*,%*/!)1?.1&M!T:!R.',%)*!:`!0^_>!#2.*?2.*,!#',!:;";!R..!#66.*?%O!#!TH!A-%&!%*'4(?.&!631.*,%*/!.?('3,%)*!)1?.1&D!2.*,)1%*/!61)/1322.D!34')-)4!)1!?1(/!1.-37%4%,3,%)*!61)/1322.D!&(6.1F%&%)*D!')22(*%,8!B)1L!)1!%*,.*&%F.!&(6.1F%&%)*!)1?.1!TS!A-%&!238!%*'4(?.!'(1+.BD!6)&&%748!B%,-!.4.',1)*%'!2)*%,)1%*/!TP!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!"!F'&%2!M()'(!1*'!E*,+3!>11&+#&'%A!P&3,0)(*'=!?./)5(!M()(&.&+(!UpO.'(,%F.!R(22318D!:;;`V!3,!:`!TQ!A-.&.!'326&!B.1.!,3//.?!%*!,-.!2.?%3!3&!h7)),!'326&h!3*?!B.1.!3!61)2%*.*,!631,!)+!,-.!X3,%)*34!.4.',%)*!'3263%/*!%*!:;;TM!!Tg!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!G2$0#'&+Q!E*,+3!N&'%*+%Q!)+#!I2&$'!F).$0$&%!8E*,(2!G*,'(!H,'$%#$5($*+!)+#!>'#&'%:!".&+#.&+(!4$00!W!S&/)'(.&+()0!P&/*'(!U9',)7.1!:;;`V!3,!P"D!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!G2$0#'&+Q!E*,+3!N&'%*+%!)+#!I2&$'!F).$0$&%!8E*,(2!G*,'(!H,'$%$#$5$($*+!)+#!>'#&'%:!".&+#.&+(!4$00!W!?+$($)0!4'$&1$+3!(*!(2&!M*5$)0!M&'<$5&%!G*..$((&&!U#61%4!:;;`VD!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!a>1.&-!R,31,!_3'L3/.!+)1!^)(*/!9++.*?.1&b!U61.&&!1.4.3&.D!:Q!#(/(&,!:;;`!VM!A-.!>1.&-!R,31,!_3'L3/.!6(,!3&%?.!xPMH!2%44%)*!+)1!,-.&.!'326&D!?.&'1%7%*/!&('-!'326&!3&!a643'.&!%*!3128f,86.!+3'%4%,%.&!,31/.,%*/!2)1.!&.1%)(&!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&M!G6!,)!,-1..!2)*,-&!1.&%?.*,%34!,13%*%*/!+)44)B.?!78!(6!,)!`2)*,-&!%*,.*&%F.!&(66)1,Mb!&Q!X.B!&.',%)*!H""!&(7&,%,(,.?!]A-.!0^_>!#',!"`T`!]!R..!#66.*?%O!#!

Page 22: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! "`!

RIT!! A3#')&Z2630!*V<1*#'!

!

>%*3448D! B-%4.! X.B! Y.343*?! -3&! 7..*! 3! B)14?! 4.3?.1! %*! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 6)4%'8! &%*'.! ,-.!

%*'.6,%)*!)+!,-.!(*%K(.!3*?!6%)*..1%*/!"`T`!#',D!,-.!')*,13f+4)BZ!)+!8)(,-![(&,%'.!6)4%'8!

%&!*)B!.F%?.*,MTT!A-.!32.*?2.*,!7.31&!2)1.!,-3*!3!63&&%*/!1.&.2743*'.!,)!p*/43*?v&!

X.B! o37)(1! 1.+)12&! )+! ,-.! .3148! "``;&D! 631,%'(43148! %*! ,-.! 4)B.1%*/! )+! ,-.! 3/.! )+!

61)&.'(,%)*D!,-.!?.F.4)62.*,!)+!*.B!+)12&!)+!')*,1)4!&('-!3&!%*,.*&%F.!&(6.1F%&%)*!3*?!

'(1+.B&! 3*?! %*! 2)F.&! ,)! 23L.! 631.*,&! 3'')(*,374.! +)1! )++.*'.&! ')22%,,.?! 78! ,-.%1!

'-%4?1.*MT`!

!

q-3,!2(&,!7.!3&L.?!%&!%*!4%/-,!)+!&('-!3!+(*?32.*,34!'-3*/.D!B-.,-.1!,-.1.!B3&!/))?!

1.3&)*!,)!373*?)*!,-.!6-%4)&)6-%'34!+132.B)1L!+)1!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!61.&.*,!&%*'.!

,-.!#',Z&!%*'.6,%)*!%*!"`T`k!

!

RI\!! C:*!E33'8!32!':*!"%*#1%*#'8!

!

A-.! 4./%&43,%)*! %&! ')*'.1*.?!B%,-! ,-.! &2344! -31?f')1.! /1)(6! )+! P! f! "Pw! )+! )++.*?.1&`;!

&)2.,%2.&!'344.?!a.3148!)*&.,!)++.*?.1&Mb`"!A-.&.!)++.*?.1&!6)&.!3!/1.3,.1!'-344.*/.!,)!

,-.! &8&,.2! 7.'3(&.! %,! %&! 2)1.! ?%++%'(4,! ,)! &,..1! ,-.2! 3B38! +1)2! 3! 4%+.! )+! '1%2.M! X)!

&8&,.2! %*! ,-.! B)14?! -3&! -3?! /1.3,! &(''.&&! B%,-! ,-.&.! ?%++%'(4,! 8)(,-M`:! A-.%1!

'-313',.1%&,%'&! 63%*,! 3! F.18! /4))28! 6%',(1.M`H! A-.8! 31.! ,86%+%.?! 78! 73'L/1)(*?&! )+!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!TT!X.&&3D!o8*'-D!37)F.!*!g`D!3,!"H;!T`!$3F%?D!R2%,-!aX.B!o37)(1!3*?!^)(,-!E(&,%'.!b!U:;;HV!"g!0-%4?1.*!C!R)'%.,8!::Q!f!:HP!`;!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!"!F'&%2!M()'(!1*'!E*,+3!>11&+#&'%A!P&3,0)(*'=!?./)5(!M()(&.&+(!UpO.'(,%F.!R(22318D!:;;`VM!`"!A.11%.!p!@)++%,!a#?)4.&'.*'.f4%2%,.?!3*?!4%+.f')(1&.f6.1&%&,.*,!3*,%&)'%34!7.-3F%)1=!#!?.F.4)62.*,34!,3O)*)28!b!U"``HV!";;USV!_&8'-)4)/%'34!5.F%.B!QgS!f!g;"M!`:!E(?/.!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,!a#4,.1*3,%F.!#661)3'-.&!,)!R.*,.*'%*/!b!U0@E#!A1%.**%34!0)*+.1.*'.D!A)1)*,)D!03*3?3D!":!R.6,.27.1!:;;QVM!`HE(?/.!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,D!37)F.!*!!PH!ao))L%*/!3,!,-.!-31?')1.!)++.*?.1&!B-)!')22%,!&.1%)(&!3*?!2(4,%64.!)++.*'.&!B.!'3*!)7&.1F.!,-.!+)44)B%*/!'-313',.1%&,%'&!!

! THw!31.!234.D!-)B.F.1!,-.!*(27.1!)+!8)(*/!B)2.*!B-)!)++.*?D!.&6.'%3448!F%)4.*,48!&..2&!,)!7.!%*'1.3&%*/!

! @3*8D!.&,%23,.?!(6!,)!g;fT;w!-3F.!3!?1(/!3*?i!)1!34')-)4!61)74.2D!3*?!31.!&%/*%+%'3*,!*(27.1!31.!?1(/!?.6.*?.*,i!3??%',.?M!!

! @)&,D!.&,%23,.?!(6!,)!g;w!31.!*),!.*/3/.?!B%,-!&'-))4!]!2)&,!31.!*),!.F.*!.*1)44.?!3,!3!&.')*?318!&'-))4M!X)*f.*1)42.*,D!13,-.1!,-3*!,1(3*'8!%&!,-.!61)74.2M!!]!SPw!-3F.!7..*!.O'4(?.?i!.O6.44.?!+1)2!&'-))4M!!

! @)&,!.O6.1%.*'.!+32%48!?8&+(*',%)*!3*?!?%&3?F3*,3/.m!3*?!2)&,!43'L!6)&%,%F.!234.!1)4.!2)?.4&M!!

Page 23: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! :;!

6)F.1,8D! 37(&.D! ?1(/! 3*?! 34')-)4! 61)74.2&D! 2.*,34! -.34,-! %&&(.&D! .?('3,%)*34!

?%&.*/3/.2.*,! 3*?! 2)&,! 31.! 341.3?8! L*)B*! ,)! ,-.! 0-%4?D! ^)(,-! 3*?! >32%48! R.1F%'.&!

U0^>RVM`S!!

!

A-.! *(27.1! )+! ":! 3*?! "H! 8.31! )4?&! B-)! 31.! ')*&%?.1.?! &.1%)(&! 8)(*/! )++.*?.1&! 78!

')22%,,%*/!,-.!,-1.&-)4?!)++.*'.&D!-)B.F.1D!31.!F.18!4)BM`P!A-.!N%44Z&!1./(43,)18!%263',!

&,3,.2.*,!&,3,.&!,-3,!_)4%'.!3661.-.*&%)*!&,3,%&,%'&!%*?%'3,.!,-3,!31)(*?!T;!":!]!"H!8.31!

)4?&! 31.! 3661.-.*?.?! %*! 1.&6.',! )+! ,-.&.! )++.*'.&! 8.3148M`Q! A-.&.! +%/(1.&! ?)! *),!

?%&3//1./3,.! ,-)&.! 3661.-.*&%)*&! B-.1.! ,-.! )++.*'.! B3&! 3?2%,,.?! )1! 61)F.?M! <%F.*!

,-3,! _)4%'.! 3661.-.*&%)*&! 3'1)&&! 3/.! /1)(6&! ,),34! )F.1! :;;D;;;D! ,-.&.! '-%4?1.*!

')*&,%,(,.!3!,%*8!&./2.*,!)+!,-.!,),34!6)6(43,%)*!3661.-.*?.?!78!6)4%'.M`g!!W*!3??%,%)*D!

,-.1.! ?).&! *),! 366.31! ,)! 7.! 3*8! .F%?.*'.! ,-3,! 6)%*,&! ,)! 3! &%/*%+%'3*,! 1%&.! %*! '1%2%*34!

)++.*?%*/!78!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&M`T!A-.!K(.&,%)*!,-(&!*..?&!,)!7.!3&L.?m!B-3,!B3&!,-.!

%26.,(&!7.-%*?!,-%&!#2.*?2.*,k!!

!

RIW!! C:*!L36<'<.<8*1!4&'()*!32!93(':!;(8'<.*!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! @3*8!-3F.!&)2.!+)12!)+!6&8'-)4)/%'34!?%&)1?.1D!.&6.'%3448!')*?(',!?%&)1?.1D!3*?!?%&6438!

4%,,4.!1.2)1&.D!4.,!34)*.!3*8!F%',%2!.263,-8M!R)2.!B%44!34&)!-3F.!3!&6.'%+%'!4.31*%*/!?%&37%4%,8D!./M!$8&4.O%3D!34,-)(/-!1.&.31'-!%&!1.K(%1.?!,)!.&,374%&-!,-.!.O,.*,!)+!,-%&!61)74.2M!!

! #,!4.3&,!P;w!31.!@3)1%!3*?!%*!&)2.!^)(,-!0)(1,&m!%*!31.3&!)+!-%/-!@3)1%!6)6(43,%)*!,-.!@3)1%!366.313*'.!13,.!%&!`;wM!

! @3*8!-3F.!3!-%&,)18!)+!37(&.!3*?!*./4.',D!3*?!61.F%)(&!%*F)4F.2.*,!B%,-!0-%4?D!^)(,-!3*?!>32%48!R.1F%'.&M!!

! ":w!31.!4%F%*/!B%,-!7),-!631.*,&D!:Tw!B%,-!)*.D!3*?!,-.!23[)1%,8!B%,-!*)*.b!`S!<[email protected]!#??1.&&%*/!,-.!03(&.&!)+!9++.*?%*/=!q-3,!%&!,-.!pF%?.*'.k!UW*&,%,(,.!)+!_)4%'8!R,(?%.&D!r%',)1%3!G*%F.1&%,8D!q.44%*/,)*D!:;;`V!3,!Q:!`P!pF%?.*'.!)*!,-.!*3,(1.!)+!'%1'(2&,3*'.&!)+!'-%4?1.*!B-)!7.')2.!%*F)4F.?!%*!3*8,-%*/!),-.1!,-3*!2%*)1!)++.*?%*/!3,!,-.!3/.&!)+!":!3*?!"H!8.31&!&-)B!,-3,!,-.8!31.!1.43,%F.48!+.B!%*!*(27.1M!W*!9',)7.1!"``P!B-.*!&%2%431!61)6)&34!B3&[email protected]!')*?(',.?!3!&,(?8!,)!.&,374%&-!-)B!23*8!'-%4?1.*!%*!,-.!61.F%)(&!8.31!2.,!'1%,.1%3!,)!%*?%'3,.!,-3,!,-.8!B.1.!)+!&.1%)(&!')*'.1*!,)!,-.!6)4%'.!3&!%*?%'3,.?!78!7.%*/!1.+.11.?!+)1!3*!><0!)1!-3F%*/!3!?.'4313,%)*!+%4.?!%*!1.43,%)*!,)!)++.*?%*/D!')22%,,.?!2)1.!,-3*!)*.!)++.*'.!.O'4(?%*/!2%*)1!23,,.1&!)1!')22%,,.?!3!&.1%)(&!)++.*'.!&('-!3&!3,,.26,.?!2(1?.1D!L%?*366%*/D!3//13F3,.?!1)77.18D!/1%.F)(&!)1!&.1%)(&!3&&3(4,D!23[)1!31&)*!)1!&.O(34!F%)43,%)*M!#!,),34!)1!";`!'-%4?1.*!B.1.!%?.*,%+%.?!7(,!)*48!""!)+!,-.&.!-3?!')22%,,.?!)++.*'.&!,-3,!B.1.!'3,./)1%j.?!3&!23O%2(2!&.1%)(&*.&&!7(,!*)*.!)+!,-.&.!1.&(4,.?!%*!&.1%)(&!)1!6.123*.*,!-312!,)!3*),-.1!6.1&)*M!R%*'.!,-3,!,%2.!,-.1.!-3&!7..*!*)!.F%?.*'.!,-3,!,-.!*(27.1!)+!'-%4?1.*!')2%*/!,)!,-.!3,,.*,%)*!,)!,-.!6)4%'.!B-)!B)(4?!+%,!,-.!&32.!'3,./)1%.&!-3&!%*'1.3&.?!3*?!,-.!)F.1344!*(27.1!)+!'-%4?1.*!')2%*/!,)!3,,.*,%)*!-3&!1.23%*.?!&,374.!)1!?.'4%*.?!%*!,-3,!,%2.M!!`Q!@%*%&,18!)+!E(&,%'.!G2$0#!)+#!E*,(2!>11&+#$+3!M()($%($5%!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!XYYZ!W!ZVV[!U@%*%&,18!)+!E(&,%'.D!#61%4!:;";VM!!`g!@%*%&,18!)+!E(&,%'.!G2$0#!)+#!E*,(2!>11&+#$+3!M()($%($5%!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!XYYZ!W!ZVV[!U@%*%&,18!)+!E(&,%'.D!#61%4!:;";VM!6313!HM:!]!,),34!:;;Q!6)4%'.!3661.-.*&%)*&!:;HDSTSM!!`T!W7%?!]!9F.1!,-.!"``P!,)!:;;T!6.1%)?!F%)4.*'.!3661.-.*&%)*!13,.&!%*'1.3&.?!+)1!8)(,-!3*?!3?(4,&D!B-%4.!,-.!'-%4?1.*Z&!13,.!1.23%*.?!1.43,%F.48!&,374.!=!S;!F%)4.*,!)++.*'.&!%*!:;;g!3*?!H`!%*!:;;TM!!

Page 24: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! :"!

W,! %&! '4.31! ,-3,! 6(74%'! 3,,%,(?.&! 37)(,! 8)(,-! '1%2.! 6438! 3! &%/*%+%'3*,! 1)4.! %*! +3&-%)*%*/!

8)(,-! [(&,%'.!6)4%'8M``! W*!3*!3/.!B-.1.! ,-.!6(74%'! 1.3',%)*! ,)B31?&!8)(,-!F%)4.*'.!-3&!

1.3'-.?!*.B!61)6)1,%)*&D";;!3*?!%&!.*'36&(43,.?!78!6-13&.&!&('-!3&!\j.1)!,)4.13*'.ZD";"!

/)F.1*2.*,&!-3F.!1.3',.?!78!4./%&43,%*/!%*'1.3&%*/48!6(*%,%F.!2.3&(1.&!+)1!,-.!,3'L4%*/!

)+!8)(,-!'1%2.M!!W*!X.B!Y.343*?!\/.,,%*/!,)(/-Z!)*!'1%2.!-3&!7.')2.!3!23*,13!3?)6,.?!

78!23*8!6)4%,%'34! 631,%.&! 3*?! %&! *),! 3&&)'%3,.?!B%,-! 4.+,f! )1! 1%/-,fB%*/D!23%*&,1.32!)1!

2%*)1! 631,%.&M";:! #&! %*! ),-.1! [(1%&?%',%)*&D! 6)4%,%'%3*&! +1)2! 3'1)&&! ,-.! &6.',1(2! -3F.!

&)(/-,!6)4%,%'34!'36%,34!+1)2!3?)6,%*/!3!,)(/-!)*!'1%2.!&,3*'.M";H!

!

0(11.*,!&)'%.,34!')*'.1*!%*.F%,3748!34&)!1.+4.',&!,-.!32)(*,!3*?!,86.!)+!2.?%3!')F.13/.!

f! 631,%'(43148! ,-3,! /%F.*! ,)! ,-.!2)&,! F%)4.*,! 3*?!?%&,1.&&%*/! '1%2.&M";S! 0)22.*,%*/!)*!

,-.! %*+4(.*'.!)+!,-.!2.?%3D!,-.!NN0!-3&!1.'.*,48!1.6)1,.?!,-3,! %*!,-.!G*%,.?!d%*/?)2D!

'1%2.!&,3,%&,%'&!-3F.!/)*.!?)B*!.F.*!,-)(/-!,B)!,-%1?&!)+!6.)64.!%*!p*/43*?!3*?!q34.&!

7.4%.F.!'1%2.!%&!/)%*/!(6M";P!X.B!Y.343*?!?3,3!')44.',.?![(&,!7.+)1.!,-.!94826%'&!)*!,-.!

,.4.F%&%)*!*.B&!&-)B.?!,-3,!)*!3F.13/.!37)(,!:;w!)+!,-.!23%*!,.4.F%&%)*!*.B&!&,)1%.&!

B.1.! 37)(,! '1%2.! 3*?! 37)(,! -34+! B.1.! &,)1%.&! ,-3,! ?.34,! B%,-! .%,-.1! '1%2.! )1!

?%&3&,.1&M";Q!!

!

E.1.28!5)&.!)+!@.?%3!q3,'-!1.'.*,48!61.&.*,.?!?3,3!')2631%*/!,-.!.26-3&%&!)*!'1%2.!

3*?!F%)4.*,!?.3,-&! %*! &.4.',.?! 4.3?!*.B&636.1&!31)(*?! ,-.!B)14?m!X.B!Y.343*?! '32.!

,-%1?!%*!,-.!*(27.1!)+!&('-!&,)1%.&M";g! W,! %&!*),!)*48!,-.!32)(*,D!-)B.F.1D!7(,!34&)!,-.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!``!o!R,.%*7.1/!3*?!#!_%K(.1)!a@3*%6(43,%*/!_(74%'!96%*%)*!#7)(,!A18%*/!E(F.*%4.&!3&!#?(4,&=!#*!pO6.1%2.*,34!R,(?8b!U:;";V!01%2.!3*?!$.4%*K(.*'8!3,!STg!";;!A-%&!%&!*),!,)!%2648!,-3,!%*&,3*'.&!)+!1.')1?.?!'1%2.!32)*/&,!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!-3F.!%*'1.3&.?D!)*48!,-3,!6(74%'!1.3',%)*!')*'.1*%*/!8)(,-!'1%2.!-3&!1.3'-.?!*.B!61)6)1,%)*&!";"!X.B!Y.343*?!X3,%)*34!_31,8D!E(&,%'.!_)4%'8!U:;";V!y-,,6=iiBBBM*3,%)*34M)1/M*ji_)4%'8#1.3&M3&6OkReSHzM!!";:!@%'-3.4!5)B.!a_)4%'%*/!3*?!\'13'L%*/!?)B*!)*!'1%2.Z=!,)(/-!K(.&,%)*&!3*?!,)(/-!3*&B.1&b!UW_R!>)1(2!#??1.&&%*/!,-.!03(&.&!)+!9++.*?%*/D!q.44%*/,)*D!X.B!Y.343*?D!>.71(318!:;;`VM!";H!o.+,!/)F.1*2.*,&D!7./%**%*/!B%,-!04%*,)*!3*?!N43%1!631,%'(43148D!-3F.!1.&-36.?!,-.!6)4%,%'&!)+!43B!3*?!)1?.1!,)!&('-!,-3,!,)(/-!)*!'1%2.!%&!3!*)*f*./),%374.!')26)*.*,!)+!,-.!,-%1?!B38!+)1!'.*,1.!4.+,!631,%.&D!3&!B.44!3&!')*,%*(%*/!3&!3!2)1.!+32%4%31!')26)*.*,!)+!')*&.1F3,%F.!6)4%,%'&M!>)1!.O3264.!N1%,%&-!o37)(1!%*,1)?('.?!&)2.!"SDH;;!*.B!)++.*'.&!&%*'.!,3L%*/!)++%'.!%*!"``g!3*?!,-.!*.B!/)F.1*2.*,!')*,%*(.&!,)!?)!&)M!A-.!0)*&.1F3,%F.!<)F.1*2.*,!%*!03*3?3!-3&!34&)!,3L.*!3',%)*!,)!/.,!,)(/-!)*!'1%2%*34&M!";[email protected]!$1!<371%.44.!a0-3*/%*/!01%2.!53,.&!"``T!f!:;;gb!UW_R!>)1(2!#??1.&&%*/!,-.!'3(&.&!)+!)++.*?%*/D!q.44%*/,)*D!>.71(318!:;;`VM!";P!p3&,)*D!@!U:;;TV!G'$.&A!6$&%!)+#!M()($%($5%B!-,,6=iiBBBM77'M')M(Li74)/&i,-.1.6)1,.1&i231L.3&,)*i:;;Ti;gi'1%2.&l4%.&l3*?l&,3,%&,%'&M-,24!!";Q!<[email protected]!37)F.!*!";S!";g!E!5)&.!#??1.&&%*/!,-.!03(&.&!)+!9++.*?%*/=!q-3,!%&!,-.!pF%?.*'.k!UW*&,%,(,.!)+!_)4%'8!R,(?%.&D!r%',)1%3!G*%F.1&%,8D!q.44%*/,)*D!:;;`V!3,!"g`!

Page 25: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! ::!

,86.! )+! ')F.13/.! ,-3,! %&! 3! 61)74.2M";T! A-.! &.*&3,%)*34D! 631,%&3*! 3*?! ?1323,%'! 2.?%3!

1.6)1,%*/! )+! '.1,3%*! %*'%?.*,&! ')*'.1*%*/! '-%4?1.*D! -3&! 34&)! 61)F%?.?! 2('-! )+! ,-.!

%26.,(&!7.-%*?!,-.&.!'(4,(134!3*?!6)4%'8!&-%+,&M!A-.1.! %&!3!?%&'.1*%74.! %1)*8!-.1.!B-.*!

,-.! GX! 0)*F.*,%)*! &(//.&,&! ,-3,! ,-.! 61%2.! +(*',%)*! )+! ,-.! 2.?%3! &-)(4?! 7.! a,)!

?%&&.2%*3,.! %*+)123,%)*! 3*?! 23,.1%34! )+! &)'%34! 3*?! '(4,(134! 7.*.+%,! ,)! ,-.! '-%4?! sMM!

.&6.'%3448! I23,.1%34&J! 3%2.?! 3,! ,-.! 61)2),%)*! )+! -%&! )1! -.1! &)'%34D! &6%1%,(34! 3*?!2)134!

B.44!7.%*/bM";`!N(,! %,! %&!?%++%'(4,! ,)!1.3?!-.3?4%*.&!B-%'-!?.&'1%7.!'-%4?1.*!3&!a^)7&b"";D!

a7378f+3'.?! 136%&,b"""D! a(*.O64)?.?!-(23*! ,%2.!7)27&bD"":! aX.B!Y.343*?Z&!^)(*/.&,f

.F.1! d%44.1bD""H! )1! a,-(//%&-! 4)&.1&b""S! 3*?! ')*'4(?.! ,-3,! ,-.&.! 31.! a7.*.+%'%34! ,)! ,-.!

'-%4?bM""P!!A-.!)(,')2.!%&!,)!?%&,)1,!&)'%.,8Z&!6.1'.6,%)*!)+!8)(,-!'1%2.D!(*B3113*,.?48!

%*'1.3&.! +.31+(4*.&&! 37)(,! 6.1&)*34! &3+.,8! 3*?! (*?.12%*.! 6(74%'! ')*+%?.*'.! %*! ,-)&.!

B-)!31.!1.&6)*?%*/!,)!%,M""Q!

!

^)(,-! E(&,%'.! 1.+)12D! 34)*/&%?.! /.*.134! [(&,%'.! 1.+)12D! B3&! 3! '.*,134! 643*L! )+! ,-.!

X3,%)*34!_31,8Z&!:;;T!.4.',%)*!'3263%/*M""g! ! W*!E)-*!d.8Z&!61.!.4.',%)*!'3263%/*!%,!B3&!

23?.! '4.31! ,-3,! %+! .4.',.?D! X3,%)*34! B)(4?! /.,! a,)(/-b! )*! 8)(,-! )++.*?.1&D""T! 3*?! %,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!";T!XD!N343D!37)F.!*!"gD!3,!"S!!";`!#1,%'4.!"g!;+$(&#!O)($*+%!G*+<&+($*+!*+!(2&!P$32(%!*1!(2&!G2$0#!U)6.*.?!+)1!&%/*3,(1.!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!3?)6,.?!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!.*,.1.?!%*,)!+)1'.!:!R.6,.27.1!"``;VM!"";!R%*.3?!9Z0)**)1!a>3%1!A3L.&!>%1.!>1)2!$1(*L!^)7&b!K)+)7)(,!M()+#)'#!UX.B!Y.343*?D!::!$.'.27.1!:;;TV!3,!-,,6=iiBBBM&,(++M')M*ji?)2%*%)*f6)&,i*3,%)*34igg"T;QM!!JJJ

!p?%,)1!&,(++M')M*j!a0)3'-.?!A..*3/.!536%&,!,)!7.!>1..?b!I2&!S*.$+$*+!N*%(!Uq.44%*/,)*D!X.B!Y.343*?D!:H!#61%4!:;;`V!3,!y-,,6=iiBBBM&,(++M')M*ji*3,%)*34i'1%2.i:HPQ"`Pi0)3'-.?f,..*3/.f136%&,f,)f7.f+1..?zM!JJR

!E)-*!d.8=!R,3,.!)+!,-.!X3,%)*!R6..'-D!:`!E3*(318!:;;T!-,,6=iiBBBM*j-.134?M')M*ji*ji*.B&i31,%'4.M'+2k'l%?e"C)7[.',%?e";ST`S:SD!!n)*)(1374.!R%2)*!_)B.1!a$1%F.1&!)+!01%2.!@%*%&,.1%34!@..,%*/!96.*%*/!#??1.&&b!Uq.44%*/,)*D!;H!#61%4!:;;`VM!""H!^)(*/.&,!L%44.1v&!7%?!,)!7.!+1..!-,,6=iiBBBM&,(++M')M*ji*3,%)*34i'1%2.iS;g:HHHi^)(*/.&,fL%44.1&f7%?f,)f7.f+1..!JJX

!R%*.3?!N)('-.1!/1)(6!)*4%*.!.?%,)1!a_3,'-.&!W?.*,%+8!A-(//%&-!o)&.1&b!I2&!S*.$+$*+!N*%(!Uq.44%*/,)*D!X.B!Y.343*?D!H;!R.6,.27.1!:;;TV!3,!y-,,6=iiBBBM&,(++M')M*ji?)2%*%)*f6)&,i)6%*%)*i.?%,)1%34&iQP:PTSzM!""P!#1,%'4.!"g!;+$(&#!O)($*+%!G*+<&+($*+!*+!(2&!P$32(%!*1!(2&!G2$0#!U)6.*.?!+)1!&%/*3,(1.!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!3?)6,.?!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!.*,.1.?!%*,)!+)1'.!:!R.6,.27.1!"``;VM!""Q!R'),,D!pMD!C!oM!R,.%*7.1/M!:;;TM!5.,-%*L%*/!E(F.*%4.!E(&,%'.M!03271%?/.D!@#=!n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j.!)*!,-.&.!+.31&!,)!B%*!.4.',%)*&!)1!1.,3%*!6)6(431%,8M!""gX.B!Y.343*?!X3,%)*34!_31,8D!E(&,%'.!_)4%'8!U:;";V!y-,,6=iiBBBM*3,%)*34M)1/M*j!i_)4%'8#1.3&M3&6OkReSHzM!!""T!E)-*!d.8!:`!E3*(318!:;;TM!:;;T=!#!>1.&-!R,31,!+)1!X.B!Y.343*?D!#!R,3,.!)+!X3,%)*!R6..'-!!

Page 26: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! :H!

2)F.?! &B%+,48! ,)! %*,1)?('.! 4./%&43,%)*! ,)! -)*)(1! %,&! ')22%,2.*,M""`! ! A-.!@%*%&,.1! )+!

R)'%34! $.F.4)62.*,! 3*?! p264)82.*,D! _3(43! N.**.,,! .O61.&&.?! ,-3,! aX.B! Y.343*?.1&!

-3F.!7..*!366344.?!,-3,!&)2.!)+!)(1!2)&,!&.1%)(&!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!31.!3&!8)(*/!3&!":!)1!

"HMb":;! X3,%)*34! 31/(.?! ,-3,! ,-.! a>32%48! 0)(1,! &%2648! ?).&! *),! -3F.! ,-.! ,))4&! 3*?!

&)4(,%)*&! ,)! ?.34! B%,-! ,-.&.! .O,1.2.48! ')264.O! '3&.&Mb":"D"::! ! A-.! )7[.',%F.! )+! ,-.!

1.+)12&!B3&! ,-(&!3%2.?! ,)!a1.?('.! 1.f)++.*?%*/!78! I,-.&.J! &.1%)(&!3*?! 1.'%?%F%&,! '-%4?!

3*?! 8)(,-! )++.*?.1&! 3*?! ,-.1.78! %261)F.! ')22(*%,8! &3+.,8Mb":H! W,!B3&! 31/(.?! %*! ,-.!

1./(43,)18!%263',!&,3,.2.*,!,-3,!,-.!#2.*?2.*,D!%*'4(?%*/!,-.!4)B.1%*/!)+!,-.!3/.!)+!

'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!a+%,&!B%,-%*!,-.!.O%&,%*/!8)(,-![(&,%'.!+132.B)1L!%*!,-3,!%,!+)'(&.&!

)*! -)4?%*/! '-%4?1.*! 3*?! 8)(*/! 6.)64.! 3'')(*,374.! 3*?! 3'L*)B4.?/%*/! ,-.%1!

?.F.4)62.*,!*..?&Mb":S!

!

R(66)1,! B3&! /%F.*! ,)! ,-.! 4)B.1%*/! )+! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! 78! ,-.! X.B!

Y.343*?! _)4%'.! #(,-)1%,8! B-)! 23?.! 1.+.1.*'.! ,)! '(11.*,! '31.! 3*?! 61),.',%)*!

61)'..?%*/&! 3&! ')264.OD! 4.*/,-8! 3*?! (*4%L.48! ,)! ?.4%F.1! 3*! .++.',%F.! 1.&6)*&.! ,)!

)++.*?%*/!U+1)2!.%,-.1!3!F%',%2!&3,%&+3',%)*!6)%*,!)+!F%.B!)1!%*!3??1.&&%*/!,-.!)++.*?.1Z&!!

7.-3F%)(1VM!#&!3! 1.&(4,D! ,-.!6)4%'.! 1.&6)*&.! %&!2)1.! 4%L.48! ,)!.11! ,)B31?&! ,-.! %*+)1234=!

B31*%*/! ,-.! )++.*?.1! 3*?! ?.4%F.1%*/! ,-.2! -)2.D! .F.*! %*! 1.43,%F.48! &.1%)(&!

'%1'(2&,3*'.&M":P!

!

$.&6%,.! ,-%&! &(66)1,! -)B.F.1D! ,-.! 23[)1%,8! )+! &(72%&&%)*&D! %*'4(?%*/! ,-)&.! +1)2! ,-.!

^)(,-! 0)(1,D! o3B! 0)22%,,..D! 0-%4?1.*Z&! 0)22%&&%)*.1D! 6&8'-)4)/%&,&! 3*?! ,-)&.! ,-3,!

-3F.! .O,.*&%F.! .O6.1%.*'.! %*! ,-.! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 31.*3! f! +.4,! ,-.1.! B3&! *)! '3&.! +)1!

4)B.1%*/! ,-.! 3/.! 31/(%*/! ,-3,! ,-.1.! %&! 3! B.34,-! )+! '1.?%74.! %*,.1*3,%)*34! 3*?! 4)'34!

1.&.31'-!B-%'-!&-)B&!,-3,!71%*/%*/!8)(*/.1!)++.*?.1&!%*,)!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!B%44!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!""`!A-%&!4./%&43,%)*!B3&!%*,1)?('.?!3&!3!N%44!,)!_314%32.*,!)*!,-.!"Ti;:i;`!78!,-.!n)*)(1374.!_3(43!N.**.,,!4.&&!,-3*!";;!?38&!3+,.1!X3,%)*34!'32.!7.'32.!,-.!<)F.1*2.*,!)+!X.B!Y.343*?M!!":;!n3*&31?!U";!>.7!:;";V!QQ;!XY_$!TgggM!!":"!%7%?!"::!0-36,.1!H!31/(.&!,-3,!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!34&)!?).&!*),!-3F.!,-.!,))4&!,)!?.34!B%,-!,-.&.!)++.*?.1&M!!":H!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!"!F'&%2!M()'(!1*'!E*,+3!>11&+#&'%A!P&3,0)(*'=!?./)5(!M()(&.&+(!UpO.'(,%F.!R(22318D!:;;`V!3,!:!":S!%7%?!":P!X.B!Y.343*?!_)4%'.!#&&)'%3,%)*!aR(72%&&%)*!,)!R)'%34!R.1F%'.&!R.4.',!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!0-%4?1.*D!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!U^)(,-!0)(1,!E(1%&?%',%)*!3*?!91?.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!N%44bM!aA-%&!4.3?&!,)!,-.!+1.K(.*,48!1.6)1,.?!3&&.1,%)*!,-3,!6)4%'.!\'3*Z,!,)('-ZD!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&D!3*?!-3F.!,)!B3%,!(*,%4!,-.8Z1.!"S!7.+)1.!,-.8!'3*!?)!3*8,-%*/M!q-%4.!*),!&,1%',48!,1(.D!,-.1.!%&!.*)(/-!&(7&,3*'.!,)!,-.!7.4%.+!3*?!%,!%&!1.6.3,.?!&)!)+,.*!,-3,!%,!%&D!%*!I,-.%1J!F%.BD!4%L.48!,)!7.!')*,1%7(,%*/!,)!,-.!36631.*,48!%*'1.3&%*/!713j.**.&&!)+!'-%4?!3*?!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&Mb!

Page 27: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! :S!

*),! 1.?('.! )++.*?%*/M":Q! >(1,-.12)1.! ,-.8! ?%?! *),! +..4! ,-3,! &('-! 32.*?2.*,&! +%,,.?!

B%,-!,-.!/.*.134!61%*'%634&!7.-%*?!,-.!0^_>!#',M":g!!

!

A-)&.!)7[.',%*/!,)!,-.!'-3*/.&!31/(.?!,-3,!,-%&!36631.*,!\,)(/-*.&&Z!)+!')*,.26)1318!

6)4%,%'34!6)4%'8!]!*),! [(&,!3&&)'%3,.?!B%,-! ,-.!X3,%)*34!_31,8!]!3',(3448!.F3?.&!&)2.!)+!

,-.!2)&,! %26)1,3*,! K(.&,%)*&! 3*?! '-344.*/.&! %*! 1.&6)*?%*/! ,)! '1%2.! %*! ')*,.26)1318!

&)'%.,8M":T! #&! 3! ')*&.K(.*'.D! ,-.1.! -3&! 7..*! 3*! 37&.*'.! )+! 13,%)*34! ?.'%&%)*f23L%*/!

73&.?!)*!3*8!'1%,%'34!.O32%*3,%)*!)+!,-.!%&&(.&!3*?!,-.!.F%?.*'.!3F3%4374.M":`!

!

A-%&! %&! '4.31! ,-.! #2.*?2.*,! 3&! 3,! *)! 6)%*,! %*! ,-.! 4./%&43,%F.! 61)'.&&! )1! &(66)1,%*/!

?)'(2.*,3,%)*!%&!3*8!1.+.1.*'.!23?.!,)!.F%?.*'.D!1.F%.B&D!3*?!2.,3f3*348&%&!37)(,!,-.!

4%L.48! .++.',%F.*.&&! )+! 4)B.1%*/! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! *)1! ,-.! 4%L.48!

')*&.K(.*'.&! )1! ')&,&M! A-.! )*48! ')22.*,! ,-3,! 7.31&! )*! ,-.! [(&,%+%'3,%)*! )+! ,-.&.!

32.*?2.*,&! B3&! 61)F%?.?! %*! ,-.! 5./(43,)18! W263',! 5.6)1,! B-%'-! *),.&! UB%,-)(,!

1.+.1.*'.V! ,-3,! 3! 61.F%)(&! 1.F%.B! )+! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! +)(*?! ,-3,! ,-.! 4.*/,-! )+! ,-.!

'(11.*,!)1?.1&!?).&!*),!61)F%?.!3! '1.?%74.! 1.&6)*&.! ,)! ,-.!7.-3F%)(1!)+!2)&,! &.1%)(&!

)++.*?.1&D! %,! 61)F%?.&! *)! ?%&'(&&%)*! 3&! ,)! ,-.! ?.'1.3&.! %*! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M"H;! ! A-.! &32.! 1.6)1,D! -)B.F.1D! 34&)! *),.&! ,-3,! ,-.&.! 61)F%&%)*&! .O6)&.!

X.B!Y.343*?!,)!6)&&%74.!'1%,%'%&2!78!,-.!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!

0-%4?M"H"!A-.! 43'L!)+!.F%?.*'.!)*!,-.! [(&,%+%'3,%)*!3*?!.++.',%F.*.&&!)+!,-%&!#2.*?2.*,!

')(64.?!B%,-!6),.*,%34! %*,.1*3,%)*34!'1%,%'%&2&!'4.3148!'344&!&)2.!)+! ,-.&.!32.*?2.*,&!

%*,)!K(.&,%)*M"H:!A-%&!?%&&.1,3,%)*!&..L&!,)!'-344.*/.!,-.!.F%?.*,%34!73&%&!+)1!,-.!4)B.1%*/!

)+! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! B-.*! ,-.! 23[)1%,8! )+! 1.&.31'-! %*?%'3,.&! ,-3,!

34,.1*3,%F.!&,13,./%.&!31.!2)1.!.++.',%F.!%*!?.34%*/!B%,-!,-%&!631,%'(431!3/.!/1)(6M"HH!

!

W,!2(&,!7.!*),.?!,-3,!3!1.F%.B!)+!344!)+!,-.!4./%&43,%F.!32.*?2.*,&!%&!)(,&%?.!,-.!&')6.!

)+!,-%&!636.1D!*.F.1,-.4.&&!,-.8!B%44!7.!?%&'(&&.?!B-.1.!3661)61%3,.!%*!1./31?&!,)!,-.%1!

3++.',!)*!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,Z&!*.B![(1%&?%',%)*M!#!'(1&)18!F%.B!)+!,-.!#2.*?2.*,&!.O-%7%,&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!":Q!HP!&(72%,,.1&!23?.!')22.*,!)*!,-.!N%44Z&!61)6)&34!,)!'-3*/.!,-.![(1%&?%',%)*!)+!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!,)!%*'4(?.!":f!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&M!9+!,-)&.!Q!&(66)1,.?!%,D!:!61.?)2%*3,.48!&(66)1,.?!%,!3*?!::!'4.3148!)66)&.?!%,M!":g!W7%?M!!!!":T!@!5)B.D!37)F.!*!";:!D!3,!"TP!":`!@D!R2%,-D!37)F.!*!";gD!3,!:P;!!"H;!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!a>1.&-!R,31,!_3'L3/.!+)1!^)(*/!9++.*?.1&b!U61.&&!1.4.3&.D!:Q!#(/(&,!:;;`!VM!"H"!A-%&!%&!?%&'(&&.?!+(1,-.1!%*!0-36,.1!HMH!"H:!A-%&!%&!?%&'(&&.?!+(1,-.1!%*!0-36,.1!H!!"HH!A-%&!%&!?%&'(&&.?!+(1,-.1!%*!0-36,.1!H!

Page 28: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! :P!

&(7&,3*,%34! &(66)1,! +)1! ,-.! 4.*/,-.*%*/! )+! 3*?! %*'1.3&.! %*! ,-.! )1?.1&! 3F3%4374.! ,)! ,-.!

^)(,-! 0)(1,D! 631,%'(43148! 78! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! [(?/.&! B-)! &3B! ,-.2! 3&! *.'.&&318! ,)!

61)F%?.! +)1! ,3*/%74.! %*,.1F.*,%)*&! %*! &.1%)(&! )++.*?.1Z&! 4%F.&M"HS! A-.! 32.*?2.*,! ,-3,!

1.'.%F.?! ,-.!2)&,!*./3,%F.! 1.&6)*&.!B3&! ,-.!*.B!&H""!B-%'-! 1.43,.&! ,)!3! &(6.1F%&%)*!

B%,-!1.&%?.*'.!)1?.1!B-%'-!')(4?!6.1,3%*!,)!3!a2%4%,318f&,84.!3',%F%,8!'326bM"HP!A-.!%&&(.!

B3&! ,-.! 2)&,! ')22.*,.?! )*! )F.1344! 3*?! 2)&,! &(72%,,.1&! B.1.! (*%,.?! %*! ,-.%1!

)66)&%,%)*!,)!,-.!61)6)&34M"HQ!

!

RI^!! "!L)<#.<,6*1!",,)3&.:!

!

X.B!Y.343*?D! 4%L.!,-.!1.&,!)+! ,-.!B)14?D!*..?&!,)!(*?.1&,3*?!,-.!(*?.148%*/!'3(&.&!)+!

)++.*?%*/!3*?!,-.!.++.',%F.*.&&!)+!?%++.1.*,!&,13,./%.&!%+!%,!3%2&!,)!6(,!%*!643'.!&,13,./%.&!

,-3,! B%44! 4)B.1! ,-.! 1%&L! )+! )++.*?%*/D! 3*?! B%44! 3F)%?! 3',(3448! .&'343,%*/! ,-.! )++.*?%*/!

13,.&M"HgA-.1.! %&! *)B! 3! 431/.! 6))4! )+! 1.&.31'-! %*! ,-.! 31.3! )+! 4)B.1%*/! ,-.! 1%&L! )+!

)++.*?%*/M!A-%&!-)B.F.1D!366.31&!,)!-3F.!7..*!F3&,48!)(,63'.?!78!3!6)4%,%'34!3*?!6(74%'!

%*,.1.&,! %*! &.1%)(&! )++.*?%*/! 78! 8)(*/! 6.)64.! 3*?! '-%4?1.*M! 9*.! )+! ,-.! ,.26,3,%)*&D!

.&6.'%3448!B-.*!?.34%*/!B%,-!,-.!Pw!)+!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!B-)!31.!&.1%)(&!1.'%?%F%&,&D!%&!,)!

2)F.!,))!136%?48!+1)2!3!,1.3,2.*,!+)'(&D!,)B31?&!?.,.11.*'.D!')*,1)4D!')264%3*'.!3*?!

%*'363'%,3,%)*M!A-.!)1%/%*34!F%&%)*!)+!,-.!0^_>!#',!61)F%?.?!,-3,!2%*%2%&%*/!%*F)4F.2.*,!

%*! ,-.! +)1234! '1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! -3&! 7..*! 61)F.*! ,)! 61)?('.! 7.,,.1! )(,')2.&D! 3*?!

&.')*?48D! ,-3,! %*! 2)&,! '3&.&! +32%4%.&! 31.! 7.&,! 643'.?! ,)! -)4?! ,-.%1! 8)(*/! 6.)64.!

3'')(*,374.!3*?!,)!23L.!,-.!.*?(1%*/!'-3*/.&!%*!3!8)(*/!6.1&)*Z&!4%+.!,-3,!B%44!&.'(1.!

7.,,.1!4%+.f')(1&.!)(,')2.&M"HT!!A-%&!)1%/%*34!F%&%)*!-3&!'4.3148!7..*!74%*?&%?.?!+)1!,-.!":!

3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&!*)B!.*,.1%*/!,-.!'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!&8&,.2M!o)1?!>34')*.1!&,3,.?!,-3,="H`!

!

3*! .++.',%F.! 6.*34! 6)4%'8! %&! )*.! %*! B-%'-! ,-.! 6(74%'! -3&! ')*+%?.*'.! B-.1.!

')22(*%,%.&!'3*!&..!,-3,![(&,%'.!%&!7.%*/!?)*.M!N(,!%,!%&!2('-!2)1.!,-3*!,-3,M!

A-.8! 2(&,! &..! ,-3,! ,-.! &8&,.2! ?.4%F.1&! 1.34! 1.?(',%)*&! %*! 1.f)++.*?%*/! 3*?!

%261)F.2.*,&! %*! ,-.! B38! B.! 61),.',! ,-.2! +1)2! ?3*/.1)(&! )++.*?.1&M! A-.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"HS!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!G2$0#'&+Q!E*,+3!N&'%*+%Q!)+#!I2&$'!F).$0$&%!8E*,(2!G*,'(!H,'$%#$5($*+!)+#!>'#&'%:!".&+#.&+(!4$00!W!S&/)'(.&+()0!P&/*'(!U9',)7.1!:;;`V!3,!S;!"HP!%7%?!!"HQ!A-.!1.3&)*!2)&,!')*&%&,.*,48!'%,.?!+)1!,-%&!)66)&%,%)*!B3&!%*,.1*3,%)*34!1.&.31'-!%*,)!a7)),!'326&b!3*?!X.B!Y.343*?!1.&.31'-!%*,)!,-.!U1.6.34.?V!&.*,.*'.!)+!')11.',%F.!,13%*%*/D!6)%*,%*/!,)!,-.!+3',!,-3,!&('-!'326&!2%/-,!3',(3448!%*'1.3&.!13,.&!)+!1.f)++.*?%*/M!!"Hg!E(?/.!031)48*!n.*B))?D!37)F.!*!`SD!3,!""Q!"HT!%7%?D!3,!HS!"H`!o)1?!>34')*.1D!,-.*!R.'1.,318!+)1!R,3,.!+)1!E(&,%'.D!G*%,.?!d%*/?)2D!:;;g!

Page 29: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! :Q!

6(74%'! *..?&! ')*+%?.*'.! ,-3,! ,-.8! 31.! 7.%*/! L.6,! &3+.! +1)2! -312D! B-%4.!

)++.*?.1&! 31.! *),! )*48! 7.%*/! .++.',%F.48! 1.-37%4%,3,.?D! 3*?! ,-.%1! )++.*?%*/!

7.-3F%)(1!3??1.&&.?M!

!

W,!%&!')*,.*?.?!,-3,!3*8!*.B!3661)3'-.&!,)!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&-)(4?!7.=!.++.',%F.!%*!1.?('%*/!

1.)++.*?%*/D! 73&.?! )*! &)(*?! .F%?.*'.D! 1.61.&.*,! F34(.! +)1! 2)*.8! 3*?! 7.! )6.*! ,)!

&8&,.23,%'!.F34(3,%)*M!_)4%'8!,-3,!?%1.',48!')*,13?%',&!,-.!23[)1%,8!)+!3F3%4374.!1.&.31'-!

%*!,-.!31.3!)1!%&!73&.?!)*!B.3L!)1!+43B.?!.F%?.*'.!?).&!*),!6(1&(.!&('-!/)34&M"S;!!!

!

A-.!*.O,!'-36,.1! 4))L&!3,!3F3%4374.!1.&.31'-m!3&L%*/!B-3,!.F%?.*'.! %&!1.4.F3*,!,)!23L.!

,-.!?.'%&%)*!)+!B-.1.!,)!?13B!,-%&!317%,1318!4%*.!)+!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M!W,!%&!

3'L*)B4.?/.?! ,-3,! ,-.! %26)1,3*'.! )+! 1.?('%*/! 8)(,-! )++.*?%*/! 78! ,-.! 2)&,! &.1%)(&!

8)(*/! )++.*?.1&! %&! 6.1,%*.*,! 7.'3(&.! )+! ,-.! ?%&61)6)1,%)*3,.! 32)(*,! )+! '1%2.! ,-.8!

')22%,M! n)B.F.1D! ,-.! 4.F.4! )+! 1.'%?%F%&2! 3*?! ?./1..! )+! &.1%)(&*.&&! )+! ,-.! )++.*?%*/!

?).&!*),!,3L.!3B38!,-.!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!)+!/)F.1*2.*,!,)!?.34!B%,-!8)(,-!)++.*?%*/!%*!,-.!

2)&,!.++.',%F.!B38&M!!

!

A-.! 6)%*,!B3&!23?.! ?(1%*/! ,-.! 4./%&43,%F.! 61)'.&&! ,-3,! aW*,.1*3,%)*34! 1.&.31'-! &-)B&!

,-3,!.F.*!&2344!1.?(',%)*&!%*!)++.*?%*/!78!&.1%)(&!3*?!6.1&%&,.*,!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!-3F.!

&%/*%+%'3*,!')&,!3*?!&)'%34!7.*.+%,&Mb"S"!W,!B3&!34&)!3'L*)B4.?/.?!,-3,!,-.!23%*!1%&L!B%,-!

,-.!1.+)12&D!/%F.*!,-3,! ,-.8!31.!3%2.?!3,!3!?%++%'(4,!/1)(6!,)!,(1*!31)(*?D! %&! ,-3,!,-.8!

B%44! *),! 1.?('.! 1.f)++.*?%*/! +)1! ,-%&! /1)(6! 3&! ,-.! '3(&.&! )+! 1.'%?%F%&2! 31.!

')264.OM"S:N),-! ,-.&.! 6)%*,&! 3'L*)B4.?/.?! 78! ,-.! F.18! 4./%&43,)1&! B-)! 63&&.?! ,-%&!

#2.*?2.*,! &-)B! [(&,! -)B! '1('%34! %,! %&! ,-3,! B.! +%/(1.! )(,! -)B! ,)! 23L.! ,3*/%74.!

1.?(',%)*&!%*!,-%&!31.3!F%3!.F%?.*'.!3*?!*),![(&,!,-.!B-%2&!)+!6)4%,%'&M!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"S;!d.118!N3L.1!K,0($W"3&+5=!N,-0$5!N'*(&5($*+!"'')+3&.&+(%!)+#!E*,(2!H,%($5&!UA-.!_)4%'8!_1.&&D!N1%&,)4D!:;;`V!3,!P!"S"!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!"!F'&%2!M()'(!1*'!E*,+3!>11&+#&'%A!P&3,0)(*'=!?./)5(!M()(&.&+(!UpO.'(,%F.!R(22318D!:;;`V!3,!H!"S:!%7%?!

Page 30: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! :T!

AK"LCDE!CKEDD!!

"#!DV<1*#'<&6!",,)3&.:!

!

#&!2.*,%)*.?! %*! '-36,.1! )*.! ,-.1.! 31.! 3,! 4.3&,! ,B)!B38&! )+! ')*'.6,(34%&%*/! '1%2%*34!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M"SH!A-.!+%1&,!K(.&,%)*&!3,!B-%'-!3/.!3!'-%4?!3,,3%*&!,-.!'363'%,8!,)!+3'.!,-.!

'1%2%*34!43BD!%*!),-.1!B)1?&!%,!K(.&,%)*&!3,!B-%'-!3/.!,-.!'-%4?!%&!374.!,)!+(448!3661.'%3,.!

,-.! 1.34! *3,(1.! )+! ,-.! \)++.*'.Z! ,-.8! ')22%,,.?M! A-.! &.')*?! K(.&,%)*&! ,-.!

3661)61%3,.*.&&! )+! ,-.! '1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! 366313,(&! 3&! 3!2.3*&! )+! 3??1.&&%*/! '-%4?1.*Z&!

,13*&/1.&&%)*&M! A-%&! '-36,.1! 4))L&! 3,! 7),-! ,-.&.! ')*'.6,%)*&! 3&L%*/! +%1&,48=! B-3,!

*.(1)&'%.*'.!'3*! ,.44!(&!37)(,! ,-.!'(4637%4%,8!)+!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&Z! '1%2%*34!3',%)*&M!

R.')*?48! ,-.! '-36,.1! K(.&,%)*&! B-3,! 3F3%4374.! 1.&.31'-! ,.44&! (&! 37)(,! ,-.! (&.! )+! ,-.!

8)(,-! [(&,%'.! 366313,(&! 3&! 3! ,))4! +)1! 1.?('%*/! 1.f)++.*?%*/D! 3*?!-.*'.!B-3,! ?).&! ,-%&!

%2648! 37)(,! ,-.! 3/.! 3,! B-%'-! ,)! &.,! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M! ! >%*3448! %,! 3&L&!B-3,! X.B!

Y.343*?Z&! %*,.1*3,%)*34! -(23*! 1%/-,&! ')22%,2.*,&! %*?%'3,.! ,-3,! ,-.! 3/.! )+!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!&-)(4?!7.M!!!

!

A-%&!'-36,.1!%&!61.2%&.?!)*!,-.!%?.3!,-3,!,-.1.!%&!3264.!1.&.31'-!3F3%4374.!,)!/(%?.!3*!

.F%?.*'.!73&.?!3661)3'-!,)!8)(,-![(&,%'.M!A-%&!B%?.!31138!)+!.F%?.*'.!B%44!7.!1.F%.B.?!

3*?!(&.?!,)!')*+%12!,-3,!,-.1.!B3&!*)!61%*'%64.?!'3&.!+)1! 4)B.1%*/!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M! ! A-.!2)&,! &34%.*,! 1.3&)*&! 7.%*/! ,-3,! ,-.!#2.*?2.*,! +3%4&! ,)! 1.')/*%&.!

,-.! 4%2%,.?!?.F.4)62.*,34! %223,(1%,8!)+!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&m! %&!(*4%L.48!,)!1.?('.!,-.!

13,.! )+! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?%*/m! 3*?! +(1,-.12)1.! %,! +3%4&! ,)! 1.&6.',! ,-.! 1%/-,&! )+! &('-!

'-%4?1.*M!!

!

NIJ!! C:*!+*)<3(8!A:<61!B22*#1*)78!U<%<'*1!A(6,&P<6<'=!!

!

W*,.1.&,!%*!3?)4.&'.*,&Z!1.43,%F.!23,(1%,8!%*!')2631%&)*!,)!3?(4,&D!B-.,-.1!6.1,3%*%*/!,)!

?.73,.&! 37)(,! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8D! -)B! ,-.! GR! &-)(4?! ,1.3,! 8)(*/!

%*?%F%?(34&! 3,! <(3*,3*32)! N38D"SS! )1! ),-.1! 23,,.1&! &('-! 3&! B-.,-.1! ,-.! ?1%F%*/! 3/.!

)(/-,!,)!7.!13%&.?D"SP!-3&!7..*!/1.3,48!&,%2(43,.?!?(1%*/!,-.!63&,!?.'3?.!78!,-.!136%?!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"SH!R..!'-36,.1!"M"!!"SS!o3(1.*'.!R,.%*7.1/!B3&!3&L.?!,)!.F34(3,.!,-.!7.-3F%)(1!)+!3!<(3*,3*32)!N38!?.,3%*..D!9231!d-3?12!(&%*/!?.F.4)62.*,34!&'%.*'.M!!"SP!!o3*?!A13*&6)1,!U5)3?!R3+.,8!3*?!9,-.1!@3,,.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!N%44!f!_314%32.*,=!S`!N%44!*)=!:"Hf"!!

Page 31: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! :`!

.O63*&%)*! )+! L*)B4.?/.! 37)(,! 3?)4.&'.*,! 713%*! ?.F.4)62.*,M"SQ! #&! 3! ')*&.K(.*'.!

.O64%'%,! 1.+.1.*'.! ,)! ,-.! *.(1)&'%.*'.! )+! 3?)4.&'.*'.! %&! &4)B48! '1..6%*/! %*,)! 6)4%'8!

?%&'(&&%)*&!3&!B.44!3&!4./34!?.'%&%)*!23L%*/M"Sg!q-3,!'3*!,-%&!*.(1)&'%.*'.!,.44!(&!37)(,!

&.,,%*/!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8k!

!

#&!&.,!)(,!%*!'-36,.1!)*.!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!*..?&!,)!7.!&.,!3,!3*!3/.!,-3,!

3661)61%3,.48!1.+4.',&!,-.!?%2%*%&-.?!'(4637%4%,8!)+!,-.!'-%4?!)++.*?.1M!W*!3',(34!+3',D!,-.!

&)4.!73&%&!)+!)(1!&.6313,.!&8&,.2!)+![(&,%'.!+)1!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.!%&!,-.!61%*'%64.!

,-3,!B.!&-)(4?!*),!.O6.',!-(23*&!B-)&.!713%*&!31.!*),!8.,!23,(1.!3*?!+(448!?.F.4)6.?!

,)! 7.! +(448! '36374.D! *)1! ,-.! 1.'%6%.*,! )+! 3?(4,! 1.&6)*&.&M"ST! W,! %&! B.44! ?)'(2.*,.?! %*!

?.F.4)62.*,34!&'%.*'.!4%,.13,(1.!,-3,!,-.!713%*!%&!*),!+(448!?.F.4)6.?!(*,%4!,-.!.3148!:;&!

3*?!23*8!&'%.*,%&,&!7.4%.F.!,-3,!+(44!')/*%,%F.!23,(1%,8!%&!*),!3'-%.F.?!(*,%4!3,!4.3&,!3/.!

:P! 8.31&M"S`! A-.! X.B! Y.343*?! 0)(1,! )+! #66.34! -3&! 3'L*)B4.?/.?! ,-%&! ?.F.4)62.*,34!

%223,(1%,8!&,3,%*/!,-3,!a%,!%&!B%?.48!3''.6,.?!,-3,!3?)4.&'.*,&!?)!*),!6)&&.&&!.%,-.1!,-.!

&32.! ?.F.4)62.*,34! 4.F.4! )+! ')/*%,%F.! )1! 6&8'-)4)/%'34! 23,(1%,8! 3&! 3?(4,&Mb"P;! A-%&!

&,3,.2.*,! .O-%7%,&! ,-.! %*,./134! ')**.',%)*! 7.,B..*! ,-.! ?.F.4)62.*,34! %223,(1%,8! )+!

8)(,-!3*?!,-.%1!4.F.4!)+!'(4637%4%,8M!$.F.4)62.*,34!*.(1)&'%.*'.!.F%?.*'.&!,-.!.O,1.2.!

%223,(1%,8! )+! ":! 3*?! "H! 8.31! )4?&! 713%*! ?.F.4)62.*,! %*! ')2631%&)*! ,)! )4?.1!

3?)4.&'.*,&!3*?!3?(4,&M!!p*,18!%*,)!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!31.*3!238!7.!.*,%1.48!%*3661)61%3,.!

+)1! 8)(*/! )++.*?.1&! 3&! 3! ')*&.K(.*'.! )+! ,-%&! ?.F.4)62.*,34! %223,(1%,8M! 5./1.,,3748!

?.&6%,.!,-%&!1.&.31'-!7.%*/!)+!?%1.',!1.4.F3*'.!,)!3*8!2.3&(1.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!

&('-!.F%?.*'.!B3&!*),!+)44)B.?!78!,-.!<)F.1*2.*,!B-.*!63&&%*/!,-%&!#2.*?2.*,M!!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"SQ!o!R,.%*7.1/!aR-)(4?!,-.!R'%.*'.!)+!#?)4.&'.*,!N13%*!$.F.4)62.*,!W*+)12!_(74%'!_)4%'8kb!U:;;`V!A-.!#2.1%'3*!_&8'-)4)/%&,!IgH`J!3,!gS"!!"Sg!%7%?!"ST!A-%&!-3&!7..*!,-.!6-%4)&)6-8!)+!,-.!#',!(6!,)!*)B!U&..!0-36,.1!:V!"S`!E!<%.??!3*?!),-.1&!aN13%*!?.F.4)62.*,!?(1%*/!'-%4?-))?!3*?!3?)4.&'.*'.=!3!4)*/%,(?%*34!@5W!&,(?8b!U"```V!:!X3,(1.!X.(1)&'%.*'.!";!3,!TQ"M!!"P;!P!<!M0)#&!\!>'%!I:;;PJ!:!XYo5!P:QD!6!PHHD!6313!SH!!

a!#?)4.&'.*,&!-3F.!?%++%'(4,8!1./(43,%*/!,-.%1!2))?&D!%26(4&.&!3*?!7.-3F%)(1&!UR6.31D!:;;"VM!W22.?%3,.!3*?!')*'1.,.!1.B31?&D!34)*/!B%,-!,-.!1.B31?!)+!6..1!3661)F34D!B.%/-!2)1.!-.3F%48!%*!,-.%1!?.'%&%)*&!3*?!-.*'.!,-.8!31.!4.&&!4%L.48!,-3*!3?(4,&!,)!,-%*L!,-1)(/-!,-.!')*&.K(.*'.&!)+!,-.%1!3',%)*&M!#?)4.&'.*,&Z!?.'%&%)*f23L%*/!'363'%,%.&!31.!%223,(1.!3*?!,-.%1!3(,)*)28!')*&,13%*.?M!A-.%1!37%4%,8!,)!23L.!/))?!?.'%&%)*&!%&!2%,%/3,.?!78!&,1.&&+(4D!(*&,1(',(1.?!&.,,%*/&!3*?!%*+4(.*'.!)+!),-.1&M!A-.8!31.!2)1.!F(4*.1374.!,-3*!3?(4,&!,)!,-.!%*+4(.*'.!)+!').1'%F.!'%1'(2&,3*'.&!&('-!3&!61)F)'3,%)*D!?(1.&&!3*?!,-1.3,!3*?!31.!2)1.!4%L.48!,)!23L.!1%&L%.1!?.'%&%)*&!B-.*!%*!/1)(6&M!#?)4.&'.*,&Z!?.&%1.!+)1!6..1!3661)F34D!3*?!+.31!)+!1.[.',%)*D!3++.',&!,-.%1!'-)%'.&!.F.*!B%,-)(,!'4.31!').1'%)*!U@)++%,D!"``HVM!#4&)D!7.'3(&.!3?)4.&'.*,&!31.!2)1.!%26(4&%F.!,-3*!3?(4,&D!%,!238!,3L.!4.&&!)+!3!,-1.3,!,)!61)F)L.!3*!3//1.&&%F.!1.&6)*&.!+1)2!3*!3?)4.&'.*,Mb!!

Page 32: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! H;!

$13B%*/! 3/.! 7)(*?31%.&! )*! ,-.! 73&%&! )+! ?.F.4)62.*,34! 1.&.31'-! '3**),! 7.! ?)*.!

&.*&%748!B%,-)(,!3!'31.+(4!3*?!*(3*'.?!')*&%?.13,%)*!)+!,-.!631,%'(431!?.23*?&!643'.?!

)*!,-.!%*?%F%?(34!+)1!a3?(4,f4%L.b!23,(1%,8!%*!?%++.1.*,!?)23%*&!)+!+(*',%)*%*/M"P"!W*!),-.1!

B)1?&D!,-.!*),%)*!,-3,!3!&%*/4.! 4%*.!'3*!7.!?13B*!7.,B..*!3?)4.&'.*'.!3*?!3?(4,-))?!

+)1! ?%++.1.*,! 6(16)&.&! (*?.1! ,-.! 43B! %&! 3,! )??&! B%,-! ?.F.4)62.*,34! &'%.*'.M! W*&,.3?!

B-.*!(&%*/!&('-!.F%?.*'.D!,-.!+)'(&!*..?&!,)!7.!)*!,-.!631,%'(431!+(*',%)*&!)+!,-.!713%*!

,-3,! 31.! 1.4.F3*,! ,)! ,-.! 6)4%'8! %*! K(.&,%)*! ]! -.1.! ,-3,! 7.%*/! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M! 9*! 23*8! )+! ,-.! ')/*%,%F.! '3637%4%,%.&! 1.4.F3*,! ,)! 23L%*/! 3*! %*+)12.?!

'-)%'.!37)(,!B-.,-.1!,)!-3F.!3*!37)1,%)*!+)1!.O3264.D!3?)4.&'.*,&!?)!*),!4))L!344!,-3,!

?%++.1.*,!+1)2!3?(4,&M"P:!n)B.F.1!)*!23*8!)+!,-.!6&8'-)&)'%34!'363'%,%.&!1.4.F3*,!(*?.1!

,-.! 43B! +)1! [(?/%*/! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8D! 3?)4.&'.*,&! 43/! ')*&%?.13748! 7.-%*?!

3?(4,&M"PHD"PS!A-.!3661)3'-!,)!&('-!6)4%'8!?.'%&%)*&!&-)(4?!*.'.&&31%48!7.!K(%,.!?%++.1.*,D!

3*?! ,-(&! /.*.134%&3,%)*&! 3&! ,)!B-.*! 3! '-%4?! 1.3'-.&!23,(1%,8! '3**),! 7.!23?.M! W*! ,-.!

X)F.27.1!:;;`!.?%,%)*!)+!,-.!#2.1%'3*!_&8'-)4)/%&,D!_1)+.&&)1!R,.%*7.1/!')*,%*(.?!-%&!

2%&&%)*! ,)!')**.',!3?)4.&'.*,!713%*!?.F.4)62.*,! ,)!6(74%'!6)4%'8! 1./31?%*/! ,..*3/.1&!

&,3,%*/="PP!

!

W,! %&! .*,%1.48!6)&&%74.! +)1! 3?)4.&'.*,&! ,)!7.! ,))! %223,(1.! ,)! +3'.! ,-.!?.3,-!

6.*34,8D! 7(,! 23,(1.! .*)(/-! ,)! 23L.! 3(,)*)2)(&! 37)1,%)*! ?.'%&%)*&D!

7.'3(&.! ,-.! '%1'(2&,3*'.&! (*?.1!B-%'-! %*?%F%?(34&!23L.!2.?%'34! ?.'%&%)*&!

3*?!')22%,!'1%2.&!31.!F.18!?%++.1.*,D!3*?!23L.!?%++.1.*,!&)1,&!)+!?.23*?&!

)*!%*?%F%?(34&Z!37%4%,%.&M!

!

!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"P"!o!R,.%*7.1/!3*?!),-.1&!a#1.!#?)4.&'.*,&!o.&&!@3,(1.!A-3*!#?(4,&k!@%*)1&v!#''.&&!,)!#7)1,%)*D!,-.!E(F.*%4.!$.3,-!_.*34,8D!3*?!,-.!#44./.?!#_#!h>4%6f>4)6bb!U:;;`V!QSUgV!A-.!#2.1%'3*!_&8'-)4)/%&,!3,!PTH!!"P:!W7%?D!3,!P`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o!R,.%*7.1/!3*?!),-.1&!a5.')*'%4%*/!,-.!0)264.O%,8!)+!n(23*!$.F.4)62.*,!B%,-!,-.!5.34%,8!)+!o./34!_)4%'8=!5.648!,)!>%&'-.1D!R,.%*D!3*?!n.%LL%*.*b!U:;;`V!QSUgV!A-.!#2.1%'3*!_&8'-)4)/%&,!IQ;"J!3,!Q`S!"PS!W,!%&!%*,.1.&,%*/!,)!*),.!,-3,!,-.!4./34!3/.!+)1!37)1,%)*!%&!&.,!-%/-.1!,-3*!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!B-.*!,-.!+(*',%)*&!1.K(%1.?!,)!23L.!%*+)12.?!?.'%&%)*&!&('-!3&!37)1,%)*&D!?.F.4)6!.314%.1!,-3*!,-)&.!(&.?!%*!'1%2.M!!!"PP!o!R,.%*7.1/D!37)F.!*!"P"!!

Page 33: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! H"!

C:*!P)&<#!&#1!.3%%<88<3#!32!.)<%*!

!

W*! )1?.1! ,)! 6(1&(.! 3*! .F%?.*,%34! 3661)3'-! B-.*! ?.,.12%*%*/! ,-.! '(4637%4%,8! )+! 8)(,-!

)++.*?.1&!,-.!631,&!)+!,-.!713%*!B-%'-!31.!1.4.F3*,!,)!,-.!?.'%&%)*!,)!')22%,!'1%2.!2(&,!

7.!%?.*,%+%.?!3*?!&,(?%.?M!!q1%,%*/!+)1!,-.!23[)1%,8!)+!,-.!G*%,.?!R,3,.&!R(61.2.!0)(1,!

%*!P*/&'!<!M$..*+%"PQ!B-%4&,!?%&'(&&%*/!,-.!3664%'3,%)*!)+!'36%,34!6(*%&-2.*,!,)!3!8)(,-!

?.+.*?3*,D! E(&,%'.! #*,-)*8! d.**.?8! ?1.B! 3,,.*,%)*! ,)! ,-1..! &6.'%+%'! 3&6.',&! )+!

3?)4.&'.*,&Z!%223,(1%,8!,-3,!?%2%*%&-.?!,-.%1!'1%2%*34!'(4637%4%,8=!,-.%1!(*?.1?.F.4)6.?!

&.*&.! )+! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! U3*?! ?%++%'(4,8! ')*,1)44%*/! ,-.%1! %26(4&.&VD! ,-.%1! -.%/-,.*.?!

F(4*.137%4%,8! ,)! 6..1! 61.&&(1.D! 3*?! ,-.! (*+)12.?! *3,(1.! )+! ,-.%1! '-313',.1&M"Pg! #44! )+!

,-.&.!'3*!7.!,13'.?!73'L!,)!'-3*/.&!%*!,-.!+(*',%)*!3*?!&,1(',(1.!)+!,-.!713%*M!"PT!"P`!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"PQ!P*/&'!<!M$..*+%!U:;;PV!PSH!GRM!!"Pg!#&!E(&,%'.!d.**.?8!B1),.=!a>%1&,!3&!3*8!631.*,!L*)B&!3*?!3&!,-.!&'%.*,%+%'!3*?!&)'%)4)/%'34!&,(?%.&!1.&6)*?.*,!3*?!-%&!32%'%!'%,.!,-.*!,)!')*+)12D!aI3J!43'L!)+!23,(1%,8!3*?!3*!(*?.1?.F.4)6.?!&.*&.!)+!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!31.!+)(*?!%*!8)(,-!2)1.!)+,.*!,-3*!%*!3?(4,&!3*?!31.!2)1.!(*?.1&,3*?374.!32)*/!,-.!8)(*/M!A-.&.!K(34%,%.&!)+,.*!1.&(4,!%*!%26.,()(&!3*?!%44f')*&%?.1.?!3',%)*&!3*?!?.'%&%)*&Mb!s!A-.!&.')*?!31.3!)+!?%++.1.*'.!%&!,-3,![(F.*%4.&!31.!2)1.!F(4*.1374.!)1!&(&'.6,%74.!,)!*./3,%F.!%*+4(.*'.&!3*?!)(,&%?.!61.&&(1.&D!%*'4(?%*/!6..1!61.&&(1.s!A-.!,-%1?!71)3?!?%++.1.*'.!%&!,-3,!,-.!'-313',.1!)+!3![(F.*%4.!%&!*),!3&!B.44!+)12.?!3&!,-3,!)+!3*!3?(4,M!A-.!6.1&)*34%,8!,13%,&!)+![(F.*%4.&!31.!2)1.!,13*&%,)18D!4.&&!+%O.?s!,-.&.!?%++.1.*'.&!1.*?.1!&(&6.',!3*8!')*'4(&%)*!,-3,!3![(F.*%4.!+344&!32)*/!,-.!B)1&.!)++.*?.1&M!U5)6.1!F!R%22)*&D!:;;PD!66!"P!]!"QVM!!"PT!o!R,.%*7.1/D!37)F.!*"SgD!3,!gS"M!A-.1.!31.!+%F.!&6.'%+%'!3*?!*),.B)1,-8!3*3,)2%'34!'-3*/.&!,-3,!)''(1!%*!3?)4.&'.*,!713%*&M!

! #!?.'1.3&.!%*!/1.8!23,,.1!%*!61.+1)*,34!1./%)*&D!4%L.48!?(.!,)!&8*36,%'!61(*%*/M!!! 0-3*/.&!%*!,-.!')*'.*,13,%)*!)+!?)632%*.!1.'.6,)1&D!.&6.'%3448!?(1%*/!6(7.1,8D!B-%'-!238!

'3(&.!6),.*,%3448!1.B31?%*/!&,%2(4%!,)!7.!.O6.1%.*'.?!3&!.F.*!2)1.!1.B31?%*/D!.F.*!%*!&%,(3,%)*&!B-.1.!1.B31?&!3*?!')&,&!31.!61.&.*,M!

! #*!%*'1.3&.!%*!')**.',%)*&!7.,B..*!')1,%'34!3*?!&(7f')1,%'34!1./%)*&!)+!,-.!713%*D!B-%'-!%&!.&6.'%3448!%26)1,3*,!+)1!.2),%)*!1./(43,%)*M!!

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

! >(1,-.12)1.!3!&%/*%+%'3*,!+.3,(1.!)+!3?)4.&'.*,!?.F.4)62.*,!%&!,-.!*.(,134!%*,./13,%)*!)+!,-.!4.+,!3*?!1%/-,!-.2%&6-.1.&!)+!,-.!713%*M!A-%&!%*,./13,%)*!+3'%4%,3,.&!,-.!?.F.4)62.*,!)+!,-.!'363'%,8!,)!(*?.1&,3*?!,-.!')*&.K(.*'.&!)+!7.-3F%)(1D!')*,1)4!%26(4&.&!3*?!(*?.1,3L.!1.3&)*.?D!4)/%'34!3*?!13,%)*34!?.'%&%)*&M"PT!

"P`!W*!3??%,%)*!+(*',%)*34!&,(?%.&!%*?%'3,.!,-3,!3?)4.&'.*'.!%&!34&)!3!,%2.!)+!%26)1,3*,!'-3*/.!%*!63,,.1*&!)+!713%*!3',%F%,8M!!

! N13%*!&8&,.2&!%*F)4F.?!%*!&.4+f1./(43,%)*!31.!&,%44!?.F.4)6%*/!?(1%*/!,-%&!6.1%)?M!! #?)4.&'.*,&!31.!631,%'(43148!&.*&%,%F.!,)!1.B31?&M!! #?)4.&'.*,&!?)!*),!61)'.&&!.2),%)*34!%*+)123,%)*!3&!B.44!3&!3?(4,&D!%M.M!,-.8!31.!?.+%'%.*,!%*!

,-.!&8*'-1)*%&3,%)*!)+!')/*%,%)*!3*?!3++.',=!o!R,.%*7.1/D!37)F.!*!"SgD!3,!g:SM!!

Page 34: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! H:!

9F.1344! ,-.&.!?.F.4)62.*,&! %*!,-.!713%*!61)F%?.!,-3,!,-.!8)(*/.1!3*!)++.*?.1!,-.! 4.&&!

4%L.48! ,-.8! 31.! 374.! ,)! 23L.! 1.3&)*.?! ?.'%&%)*&! 3*?! ')*,1)4! ,-.%1! %26(4&.&! 3*?!

.2),%)*&M! A-(&! %*! &%,(3,%)*&! ,-3,! .4%'%,! %26(4&%F%,8D! ,-3,! 31.! ,86%'3448! '-313',.1%j.?! 78!

-%/-!4.F.4&!)+!.2),%)*34!31)(&34!)1!&)'%34!').1'%)*D!)1!,-3,!?)!*),!.*')(13/.!)1!6.12%,!

')*&(4,3,%)*!B%,-! 3*! .O6.1,!B-)! %&!2)1.! L*)B4.?/.374.! )1! .O6.1%.*'.?D! 3?)4.&'.*,&Z!

?.'%&%)*!23L%*/D!3,!4.3&,!(*,%4!,-.8!-3F.!,(1*.?!"TD!%&!4%L.48!,)!7.!4.&&!23,(1.!,-3*!,-3,!

)+!3?(4,&M!A-%&!&.,!)+!'%1'(2&,3*'.&! 4%L.48!'-313',.1%&.&!,-.!')22%&&%)*!)+!2)&,!'1%2.&!

6.16.,13,.?! 78! 3?)4.&'.*,&! UB-%'-! 31.! (&(3448! ')22%,,.?! %*! /1)(6&! 3*?! 31.! &.4?)2!

61.2.?%,3,.?MV"Q;! A-.&.! '%1'(2&,3*'.&! 238! 34&)! 7.! ,86%'34! )+! ),-.1! &%,(3,%)*&! B-.1.!

3?)4.&'.*,&! 31.! .2),%)*3448! 31)(&.?=! %*! /1)(6&D! 37&.*,! 3?(4,! &(6.1F%&%)*D! 3*?! +3'%*/!

'-)%'.&!B%,-! 36631.*,! %22.?%3,.! 1.B31?&! 3*?! +.B! )7F%)(&! )1! %22.?%3,.! ')&,&! ]! ,-.!

F.18! ')*?%,%)*&! ,-3,! 31.! 4%L.48! ,)! (*?.12%*.! 3?)4.&'.*,&Z! ?.'%&%)*f23L%*/!

')26.,.*'.M"Q"!

!

A-%&!?.F.4)62.*,34! %223,(1%,8! %&! +(1,-.1! ')26)(*?.?!78! &)2.!)+! ,-.!?.F.4)62.*,34!

+.3,(1.&!)+! ":! 3*?!"H! 8.31!)4?&! 3*?! ,-.!(*%K(.! '-313',.1%&,%'&! )+! ,-.&.! &.1%)(&! 8)(*/!

)++.*?.1&M!@3*8!)+!,-.!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!,-3,!B%44!366.31!7.+)1.!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!

31.!4%L.48!,)!-3F.!3*!%*,.44.',(34!?%&37%4%,8D!4.31*%*/!?%++%'(4,%.&!)1!6))1!3'-%.F.2.*,!?(.!

,)! &6.'%+%'! +3',)1&! &('-! 3&! >).,34! #4')-)4! R8*?1)2.! )1! +32%48i! 4%+.! '%1'(2&,3*'.&! 3*?!

,-.1.+)1.!238!7.!'-1)*)4)/%'3448!3/.?!":!)1!"H!8.31&D!7(,!2.*,3448!2('-!8)(*/.1!,-3*!

,-%&M"Q:! A.*?.*'8! ,)B31?&! %26(4&%F%,8! %&! 34&)! ')26)(*?.?! +)1! 8)(*/!6.)64.!B-)!-3F.!

.O6.1%.*'.?! ,13(23M"QH! _.1&%&,.*,! ,13(23! &('-! 3&! 37(&.! 3*?! *./4.',! '3(&.&! 3! 8)(*/!

6.1&)*Z&!713%*!,)!3?36,!%*!)1?.1!,)!.*&(1.!&(1F%F34M!A-%&!)+,.*!1.&(4,&!%*!-86.1!F%/%43*'.D!

.4.F3,.?!-.31,!13,.D!3*?!.4.F3,.?! 4.F.4&!)+!&,1.&&f1.43,.?!-)12)*.&! %*!3!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!

6.1&)*M"QS#&!'-36,.1!,B)!.O643%*.?!,-.!4%L.4%-))?!)+!,-.!&.1%)(&!8)(*/!)++.*?.1!7.%*/!3!

61)?(',!)+!37(&.!3*?!*./4.',!%&!.O,1.2.48!-%/-!3*?!3&!3!1.&(4,D! %,! %&!.O6.',.?!,-3,!&('-!

'-%4?1.*! 31.! .F.*! 2)1.! ?.F.4)62.*,3448! %223,(1.D! 3*?! -.*'.! 31.! %*-.1.*,48! 4.&&!

'(46374.!+)1!,-.%1!'1%2%*34!3',%)*&M!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"Q;!$!>311%*/,)*!U:;;HV!a$.F.4)62.*,34!3*?!4%+.f')(1&.!'1%2%*)4)/8=!d.8!,-.)1.,%'34!3*?!.26%1%'34!%&&(.&b!S"!01%2%*)4)/8!3,!::"D!!>!Y%21%*/!".&'$5)+!E*,(2!C$*0&+5&!U9O+)1?!G*%F.1&%,8!_1.&&D!X.B!^)1LD!"``TVD!3,!::"M!"Q"!o!R,.%*7.1/!a5%&L!A3L%*/!%*!#?)4.&'.*'.=!X.B!_.1&6.',%F.&!>1)2!N13%*!3*?!N.-3F%)134!R'%.*'.b!U:;;gV!"QU:V!0(11.*,!$%1.',%)*&!%*!_&8'-)4)/%'34!R'%.*'.!IPPJM!"Q:!o%*?3!#M!<)B!*),.&!%*!-.1!&(72%&&%)*!,)!,-.!R.4.',!0)22%,,..!,-3,!a3!1.'.*,!%*+)1234!?%&'(&&%)*!B%,-!,-.!&,3++!3,!d)1)B3%!@3*33L%!U^)(,-!E(&,%'.!X)1,-V!&(//.&,.?!,-3,!23*8!)+!,-.!8)(*/!6.)64.!%*!,-.%1!'31.!3/.?!"S!f"g!8.31&!31.!2.*,3448!+(*',%)*%*/!3,!61%2318!&'-))4!3/.!U%M.My";!8.31&!)4?VM!!"QH!_.118D!N!U"``gV!a%*'(73,.?!%*!,.11)1=!X.(1)?.F.4)62.*,34!+3',)1&!%*!,-.!'8'4.!)+!F%)4.*'.bD!%*!E$!9&)+&L8D!!G2$0#'&+!$+!)!<$*0&+(!%*5$&(=!U66M!":S!]!"S`V!X.B!^)1L=!A-.!<(%44+)1?!_1.&&!3,!"H"M!!!"QS!W7%?M!

Page 35: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! HH!

!

+.<*#.*78!)36*!<#!6*@<86&'<V*!1*.<8<3#8!

!

q-.,-.1!3*?!-)B!,-.&.!+%*?%*/&!&-)(4?!%*+)12!?.'%&%)*&!37)(,!3?)4.&'.*,&Z!,1.3,2.*,!

(*?.1! ,-.! 43B! ?.6.*?&! )*! ,-.! &6.'%+%'! 4./34! %&&(.U&V! (*?.1! ')*&%?.13,%)*M! A)! F31%)(&!

?./1..&D!&('-!?.'%&%)*&!1.48!)*!F34(.![(?/2.*,&!U.M/M!37)(,!B-3,!3&6.',&!)+!23,(1%,8!31.!

1.4.F3*,!,)!3!631,%'(431!?.'%&%)*!)1!37)(,!B-3,!%&!23,(1.!a.*)(/-b!,)!B3113*,!3(,)*)28!

3*?i! )1! '(4637%4%,8VD! B-%'-! &'%.*'.! 34)*.! '3**),! ?%',3,.M! X.F.1,-.4.&&D! ,-.! 4./34!

,1.3,2.*,!)+!3?)4.&'.*,&!&-)(4?!3,!,-.!F.18!4.3&,!7.!%*+)12.?!78!,-.!2)&,!3''(13,.!3*?!

,%2.48!&'%.*,%+%'!.F%?.*'.!)*!,-.!*3,(1.!3*?!')(1&.!)+!6&8'-)4)/%'34!?.F.4)62.*,M"QP!

!

$.F.4)62.*,34! 6&8'-)4)/%&,&! 3*?! *.(1)&'%.*,%&,&! B%,-! .O6.1,%&.! %*! 3?)4.&'.*'.! 31.!

+1.K(.*,48! '344.?! )*! ,)! 61)F%?.! /(%?3*'.! 37)(,! ,-.! 3661)61%3,.! ,1.3,2.*,! )+! 8)(*/!

6.)64.!(*?.1!,-.!43B!3*?!37)(,!,-.!61)6.1!643'.2.*,!)+!4./34!3/.!7)(*?31%.&!7.,B..*!

,-)&.!B-)!&-)(4?!7.!,1.3,.?!3&!3?(4,&!3*?!,-)&.!B-)!&-)(4?!*),M"QQ!

!

A-.! 43B! %*! X.B! Y.343*?! -3&! ?.F.4)6.?! )F.1! ,-.! 8.31&! ,)! 1.+4.',! 7),-! ,-.! &'%.*,%+%'!

.F%?.*'.!31)(*?!,-.!'1%2%*34!'(4637%4%,8!)+!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64."Qg!3*?!,)!3??1.&&!

,-.! 1)),! '3(&.&! )+! ,-.%1! )++.*?%*/D! ,-1)(/-! 61)'.&&.&! ?.&%/*.?! ,)! 61)F%?.! /1.3,.1!

61.F.*,3,%F.! 2.3&(1.&"QTD! &(66)1,"Q`! 3*?! %*! 23*8! 1.&6.',&! 3'')(*,37%4%,8"g;M!

>(1,-.12)1.! ,-.1.! %&! *)B! a%*')*,1)F.1,%74.! .F%?.*'.! )+! &%/*%+%'3*,! '-3*/.&! %*! 713%*!

&,1(',(1.! 3*?! +(*',%)*! ?(1%*/! 3?)4.&'.*'.M! #4,-)(/-!2)&,! )+! ,-%&! B)1L! -3&! 366.31.?!

[(&,! %*! ,-.! 43&,! ";! 8.31&D! ,-.1.! %&! 341.3?8! &,1)*/! ')*&.*&(&! 32)*/! ?.F.4)62.*,34!

*.(1)&'%.*,%&,&! 37)(,! ,-.! *3,(1.! )+! ,-%&! '-3*/.Mb"g"!X.B!?%&')F.1%.&! 61)F%?.! &'%.*,%+%'!

')*+%123,%)*! ,-3,! ,-.! ,..*! 8.31&! 31.! 3! ,%2.! )+! &%/*%+%'3*,! ,13*&%,%)*M! R('-! .F%?.*'.!

?.2)*&,13,.&! ,-3,! 3?)4.&'.*,&! -3F.! &%/*%+%'3*,! *.(1)4)/%'34! ?.+%'%.*'%.&! ,-3,! 1.&(4,! %*!

&,31L! 4%2%,3,%)*&! )+! [(?/2.*,M! 5.&.31'-! &(//.&,&! ,-3,! B-.*! ')26)(*?.?! B%,-! 1%&L!

+3',)1&!)+!,-.&.!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!U*./4.',D!37(&.D!6)F.1,8D!.,'MVD!,-.&.!4%2%,3,%)*&!

'3*!&.,!,-.!6&8'-)4)/%'34!&,3/.!+)1!F%)4.*'.!3*?!)++.*?%*/!7.-3F%)(1M!A-.&.!?%&')F.1%.&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"QP!o!R,.%*7.1/D!37)F.!*"SgD!3,!!P`:!f!q-.*!%,!')2.&!,)!,-.!1)4.!)+!?.F.4)62.*,34!&'%.*'.!%*!%*+4(.*'%*/!6)4%'8!?.73,.D!_1)+.&&)1!R,.%*7.1/!%&!3?323*,!,-3,!,-.!&'%.*'.!)+!713%*!?.F.4)62.*,!&-)(4?!a%*+)12b!*),!?%',3,.!6)4%'8M"QP!!"QQ!o!R,.%*7.1/D!37)F.!*"P"!3,!P`:!"Qg!01%2.&!#',!"`Q"D!&::D!0^_>!#',!"`T`!&:;TU.V!3*?!U-V!"QT!0^_>!#',!&:;TU3VDU'VU%%V!3*?!U+VU%V!!"Q`!0^_>!#',!&:;TU'VU%V!3*?!U%%V!!"g;!0^_>!#',!&:;TU/V!"g"!o!R,.%*7.1/D!37)F.!*"SgD!3,!PH"M!

Page 36: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! HS!

&(66)1,! ,-.!3&&.1,%)*! ,-3,! 3?)4.&'.*,&! 31.! 4.&&!2)13448! '(46374.! +)1! ,-.%1! 3',%)*&! ,-3*!

')26.,.*,! 3?(4,&! 3*?! 31.! 2)1.! '36374.! )+! '-3*/.! 3*?! 1.-37%4%,3,%)*M! W,! +)44)B&! ,-3,!

4)B.1%*/! ,-.!3/.!)+! '1%2%*34!61)&.'(,%)*D!.F.*! ,3L%*/! %*,)!3'')(*,! ,-.! ,-1.&-)4?&!3*?!

61)F%&)&!')*,3%*.?!%*!,-.!N%44D!%&!3!1.,1)/13?.!3*?!?.F)4(,%)*318!2.3&(1.D!,-.!.&&.*'.!)+!

B-%'-! 1(*&! ')*,1318! ,)! &'%.*,%+%'! ?.F.4)62.*,&M! #4,-)(/-! 4./34! 4%*.&! B%44! 7.! ?13B*!

B-.,-.1!&'%.*,%&,&!B.%/-!%*!)1!*),D!%,!%&!&(72%,,.?!,-3,!(&%*/!&'%.*'.!,)!%*+)12!,-.!43B!]!

.F.*!%*!,-.!+)12!)+!.?('3,.?!/(.&&.&!]!%&!7.,,.1!,-3*!(&%*/!*)!&'%.*'.!3,!344M"g:!

!

NIR!! C:*! &,,)3,)<&'*#*88! 32! ':*! 93(':! ;(8'<.*! 8=8'*%! 23)! )*1(.<#@! )*Z

322*#1<#@!

!

#*),-.1!B38!,)!.F34(3,.!3,!B-%'-!3/.!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!&-)(4?!7.!&.,!%&!,)!?.'%?.!3,!

B-%'-! 3/.! ,-.! '1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! 366313,(&! 7.')2.&! 3! (&.+(4! 2.3*&! )+! 3??1.&&%*/!

'-%4?1.*Z&! ,13*&/1.&&%)*&M! 9*.! )+! ,-.! )7[.',%F.&! )+! 4)B.1%*/! ,-.! '1%2%*34! 3/.! )+!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!+)1!&.1%)(&!)++.*?.1&!B3&!,)!1.?('.!1.)++.*?%*/!3*?!3',!3&!3!?.,.11.*,!+)1!

,-%&!3/.!/1)(6M"gH!pF%?.*'.!-)B.F.1!.O-%7%,&!,-3,!71%*/%*/!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&!%*,)!,-.!

8)(,-! [(&,%'.!31.*3!B%44! *),! 1.?('.!)++.*?%*/! +)1! +)(1! &34%.*,! 1.3&)*&M! >%1&,48D! 1.&.31'-!

-3&!&-)B*!,-3,!?.,.11.*'.!%&!(*4%L.48!,)!B)1L!+)1!&('-!8)(*/!3?)4.&'.*,&m!&.')*?48D!,-.!

61)74.2!)+!?.F%3*,!')*,3/%)*! U*./3,%F.!6..1! %*+4(.*'.V!31%&.&!B-.*!'-%4?1.*!.*,.1! ,-.!

&8&,.2m! ,-%1?48! 3&! 3! 1.&(4,! )+! &,%/23,%j3,%)*! 3*?! ,-.! \437.4%*/Z! 61)'.&&D! 1.f)++.*?%*/! %&!

2)1.! 4%L.48!,)! %*'1.3&.m!3*?!+)(1,-48D! ,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!238!*),!-3F.!,-.!37%4%,8! ,)!?.34!

B%,-!,-.!1)),!'3(&.&!)+!,-.!'-%4?Z&!)++.*?%*/M!!

!

F*'*))*#.*!!

!

W,! B)(4?! 7.! ?%++%'(4,! ,)! &(&,3%*! ,-.! 61)6)&%,%)*! ,-3,! ,-.! .O%&,.*'.! 3*?! (&.! )+! ,-.!

23'-%*.18! )+! '1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! ?).&! *),! 61.F.*,! &)2.! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*&! +1)2! ')22%,,%*/!

'.1,3%*!,86.&!)+!'1%2.M!n)B.F.1D!,-.!B38!,-3,!,-.!43B!3'-%.F.&!,-%&!)7[.',%F.!%&!)6.*!,)!

?)(7,M!q-.*!3!&.1%)(&!8)(*/!)++.*?.1!%&!'3(/-,!(6!%*!,-.!'1%2%*34!61)'.&&!23*8!+3',)1&!

)6.13,.D! 3*?! ,-.! ,3&L! )+! %?.*,%+8%*/! ,-.%1! ?.,.11.*,! %263',! %&! *),! .3&8M! A-.! &-)'L! )+!

3661.-.*&%)*D! &(7&.K(.*,! ?.34%*/&! B%,-! ,-.! 6)4%'.D! ,-.! .O6.1%.*'.! )+! ,1%34! 3*?!

')*F%',%)*D! ,-.! 1.3',%)*&! )+! ),-.1&! 3*?! ,-.! .273113&&2.*,D! B-%'-! ,-.&.! '3(&.! ,-.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"g:!o!R,.%*7.1/!3*?!),-.1&!a5.')*'%4%*/!,-.!0)264.O%,8!)+!n(23*!$.F.4)62.*,!B%,-!,-.!5.34%,8!)+!o./34!_)4%'8=!5.648!,)!>%&'-.1D!R,.%*D!3*?!n.%LL%*.*b!U:;;`V!QSUgV!A-.!#2.1%'3*!_&8'-)4)/%&,!3,!Q;"M!!"gH!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!"!F'&%2!M()'(!1*'!E*,+3!>11&+#&'%A!P&3,0)(*'=!?./)5(!M()(&.&+(!UpO.'(,%F.!R(22318D!:;;`VM!

Page 37: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! HP!

8)(*/!)++.*?.1D!238!)1!238!*),!')2.!%*,)!6438M!n)B!2('-!.3'-!)+!,-.&.!+3',)1&!3++.',&!

3*?! ?.,.12%*.&! ,-.! &(7&.K(.*,! 7.-3F%)(1! )+! 3! 8)(*/! )++.*?.1! %&! (*L*)B*m! -)B! ,-%&!

')27%*3,%)*!)+!,-1.3,.*.?!')*&.K(.*'.&!3++.',&!,-.!')*?(',!)+!3!\B)(4?f7.f)++.*?.1Z!%&!

3*!.F.*!2)1.!?%++%'(4,!K(.&,%)*M"gS!#4,-)(/-! ,-.! &-)'L!)+! 3! +)1234!61)'.&&!3,! 3*!.3148!

3/.! 2%/-,! 7.! .O6.',.?! ,)! ?.,.1! '-%4?1.*! +1)2! 1.f)++.*?%*/D! 1.&.31'-! &-)B&! ,-3,! ,-.!

23[)1%,8! )+! 8)(,-! B-)! 31.! %*'4%*.?! ,)! ')22%,! '1%2.&D! .&6.'%3448! &.1%)(&! 3*?! 1.6.3,!

)++.*?.1&D! 43'L! ,-.! [(?/2.*,D! +)1.&%/-,D! 3*?! &.4+f')*,1)4! ,)!7.! %*! 3*8!B38!?.,.11.?!78!

,-.! 61)&6.',! )+! 4)*/.1! &.*,.*'.&D! )1! &.*,.*'.&! 3,! 344M"gP@)&,! &,(?%.&! -3F.! +3%4.?! ,)!

(*')F.1!3*8!1.?(',%)*&!%*!8)(,-!'1%2.!13,.&!,-3,!'3*!7.!4%*L.?!,)!43B&!&(7[.',%*/!8)(*/!

6.)64.!B-)!)++.*?!,)!'1%2%*34!61)&.'(,%)*M"gQ!

!

@)1.!&6.'%+%'3448!,-.1.!%&!*)!.F%?.*'.!,)!%*?%'3,.!,-3,!'1%2%*34!61)&.'(,%)*!)+!":!3*?!"H!

8.31! )4?&! B-)! )++.*?! %&! 3*! .++.',%F.! B38! ,)! ?.,.1! '1%2.! /.*.13448! )1! 1.?('.! ,-.!

4%L.4%-))?!,-3,!3!'-%4?!B)(4?!7.!4.&&!4%L.48!,)!')22%,!+(1,-.1!)++.*'.&!3&!3!1.&(4,!)+!,-.&.!

2.3&(1.&M"gg!W*!3',(34!+3',!&)2.!1.&.31'-!&-)B&!,-3,!8)(*/!6.)64.!B-)!7.4%.F.!,-.8!B%44!

7.! '3(/-,! 3*?! 6(*%&-.?! &.F.1.48! 3',(3448! ')22%,! 2)1.! '1%2.M"gT! pF%?.*'.! +1)2! ,-.!

G*%,.?!R,3,.&!)+!#2.1%'3!&-)B&!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!B-)!)++.*?D!')22%,!2)1.!F%)4.*,!'1%2.&!

3&!3! 1.&(4,!)+! ,-.%1!.O6.1%.*'.! %*! ,-.!'1%2%*34! [(&,%'.!&8&,.2D!B-%4.! ,-.8!31.!34&)!2)1.!

4%L.48! ,)! ')22%,! 2)1.! &.1%)(&! *.B! )++.*'.&! ,-3*! ,-.%1! ')(*,.1631,&D! 3*?! 3,! 3! +3&,.1!

13,.D"g`! ')*,%*(%*/! %*,)! 3?(4,-))?M"T;! >(1,-.12)1.! &,(?%.&! %*! ,-.! G*%,.?! R,3,.&! -3F.!

&-)B*! ,-3,! ,-.! *./3,%F.! .++.',&! )*! '-%4?1.*! .*,.1%*/! ,-.! '1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2! 31.!

2)1.! 4%L.48! +)1! ,-)&.! B-)! ')2.! +1)2! %26)F.1%&-.?! 73'L/1)(*?&! )1! ,-)&.! B-)! 31.!

743'LM"T"!A-%&!,-1)B&!?)(7,!)*!,-.!&(//.&,%)*!,-3,!+)1234!61)&.'(,%)*!,-1)(/-!,-.!8)(,-!

[(&,%'.!&8&,.2!%&!,-.!2)&,!.++.',%F.!B38!)+!-)4?%*/!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!3'')(*,374.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"gS!o!R,.%*7.1/!3*?!#!_%K(.1)!a@3*%6(43,%*/!_(74%'!96%*%)*!#7)(,!A18%*/!E(F.*%4.&!3&!#?(4,&=!#*!pO6.1%2.*,34!R,(?8b!U:;";V!01%2.!3*?!$.4%*K(.*'8!ISTgJD!3,!ST!!"gP!XD!N343D!37)F.!*!"gD!3,!"P!"gQ!<1%++%*D!_M!U:;;TV!S$11&'&+(!1'*.!)#,0(%A!"+!;/#)(&#!"+)0=%$%!*1!H,<&+$0&!I')+%1&'!)+#!40&+#&#!M&+(&+5$+3!6)7!7$(2!P&5*..&+#)($*+%!1*'!P&1*'.B!!X3,%)*34!0.*,1.!+)1!E(F.*%4.!E(&,%'.M!!"gg!0-%4?1.*v&!0)22%&&%)*.1!aR(72%&&%)*!,)!R)'%34!R.1F%'.&!R.4.',!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!0-%4?1.*D!^)(*/!

_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!U^)(,-!0)(1,!E(1%&?%',%)*!3*?!91?.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!N%44!bM!!"gT!@'o31.*D!d!a^)(,-!9++.*?%*/!A.32&=!q-3,!q)1L&!,)!5.?('.!9++.*?%*/!78!^)(*/!_.)64.b3,!S!"g`!p!d))8M!U:;;TV!!G2)00&+3$+3!G*,'%&A!"!P&<$&7!*1!(2&!F$'%(!I7*!E&)'%!*1!S',3!I')+%1&'!P&1*'.!$+!?00$+*$%B!!W44%*)%&!E(F.*%4.!E(&,%'.!W*%,%3,%F.M!"T;!E)*!<(**31!N.1*7.1/!3*?!d1)-*!$!@31F%*!ao37.4%*/D!o%+.!0-3*'.&D!3*?!#?(4,!01%2.=!A-.!$%1.',!3*?!W*?%1.',!p++.',&!)+!9++%'%34!W*,.1F.*,%)*!%*!#?)4.&'.*'.!)*!01%2.!%*!p3148!#?(4,-))?b!U:;;HV!01%2%*)4)/8!":Tg!f!"H"TM!#,!"`!!"T"!%7%?D!N.1*7.1/D!<(**31!3*?!d1)-*!')*'4(?.!,-3,!')*,3',!B%,-!,-.!+)1234![(F.*%4.![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!-3&!7..*!&-)B*!,)!-3F.!3!1.3&)*374.!4%L.4%-))?!)+!%*'1.3&%*/!,-.!4.F.4!)+!'1%2%*34!3',%F%,8!%*!.3148!3?)4.&'.*'.M!R,(?%.&!+)(*?!,-3,!,-.!.++.',!)+!6)4%'.!%*,.1F.*,%)*!)*!'1%2.!%&!&,1)*/.1!32)*/!234.&!B-)!-3F.!%26)F.1%&-.?!+32%48!73'L/1)(*?&M!!

Page 38: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! HQ!

+)1!,-.%1!'1%2.&D!B-.*!,-.!23[)1%,8!)+!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!B-)!B%44!7.!&(7[.',.?!,)!

,-.!&8&,.2!31.!4%L.48!,)!7.!@3)1%!3*?!')2.!+1)2!%26)F.1%&-.?!73'L/1)(*?&M"T:!!

!

F*V<&#'!A3#'&@<3#!!

!

W*F)4F.2.*,!%*!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!238!34&)!'3118!,-.!1%&L!)+!%*'1.3&%*/!1.'%?%F%&2!

?(.!,)!.O6)&(1.!,)!2)1.!?.,1%2.*,34!7.-3F%)(1&!,-1)(/-!3&&)'%3,%)*!B%,-!),-.1!8)(*/!

)++.*?.1&D! B-.,-.1! ,-1)(/-! 61)/1322.&D! 1.&%?.*'.&! )1! ')(1,! 366.313*'.&M"TH! A-.!

23[)1%,8!)+!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&!31.!-%/-48!&(&'.6,%74.!,)!6..1!%*+4(.*'.D"TS!3*?!71%*/%*/!

,-.2! (*?.1! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! [(1%&?%',%)*! .O6)&.&! ,-.2! ,)! +(1,-.1! 3*,%f&)'%34! 6..1!

%*+4(.*'.&! 3*?! %*'1.3&.&! ,-.! )66)1,(*%,8! +)1! 6..1! %*+4(.*'.&! ,)! )6.13,.M! 0)*,3',!B%,-!

3*,%&)'%34!6..1&!%&!)*.!)+!,-.!7%//.&,!1%&L!+3',)1&!%*!'-%4?1.*!?.F.4)6%*/!3*?!23%*,3%*%*/!

')*?(',! 61)74.2&! U)+!B-%'-! 3! 431/.! 61)6)1,%)*! )+! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?.1&! 31.! 4%L.48! ,)!

-3F.VM"TPD"TQ!

!

5.'.*,! 1.&.31'-! )*! 1.&%?.*,%34! 3*?! /1)(6! %*,.1F.*,%)*&! +)1! 8)(,-! )++.*?.1&! -3&!

%*?%'3,.?!,-.! 431/.!?./1..!)+! %*+4(.*'.!3!/1)(6!)+!a4%L.f2%*?.?b!6..1&!-3&!)*!3!8)(*/!

6.1&)*M"Tg! d*)B*! 3&! a$.F%3*,! 0)*,3/%)*b! )1! aX./3,%F.! _..1! W*+4(.*'.&Db"TT! &('-!

%*+4(.*'.&! 1.%*+)1'.! ,-.!23%*,.*3*'.! )+! 3*,%f&)'%34! 7.4%.+&! 3*?! 3,,%,(?.&! ,-3,! &(66)1,!

+(1,-.1!)++.*?%*/M!A-.&.!')*'.6,&!)1%/%*3,.?!+1)2!)(,')2.!&,(?%.&!B-%'-!&-)B.?!,-3,!

&)2.! 1.&%?.*,%34! 3*?! /1)(6! ,86.! 61)/1322.&! +)1! 8)(*/! )++.*?.1&! 3',(3448! %*'1.3&.?!

)++.*?%*/!13,.&!13,-.1!,-3*!1.?('.?!,-.2M"T`!!

!

q-.*!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?!)++.*?.1&!366.31!7.+)1.! ,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!3! &(6.1F%&%)*!B%,-!

1.&%?.*'.!)1?.1!'3*!7.!23?.D!1.&(4,%*/!%*!,-.%1!7.%*/!?.,3%*.?!+)1!(6!,)!&%O!2)*,-&!%*!3!

0-%4?D! ^)(,-! 3*?! >32%48! 1.&%?.*'.M!q-%4.! &('-! 1.&%?.*'.&! 31.! 4.&&! 3(&,.1.! ,-3*! 3?(4,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"T:!:;;T!+%/(1.&!&-)B!,-3,!@3)1%!3661.-.*&%)*!13,.&!31.!2)1.!,-3*!P!,%2.&!,-3,!)+!_3'%+%'!)1!XY!p(1)6.3*M!@%*%&,18!)+!E(&,%'.!G2$0#!)+#!E*,(2!>11&+#$+3!M()($%($5%!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!XYYZ!W!ZVV[!U@%*%&,18!)+!E(&,%'.D!#61%4!:;";VM!!!"TH!E)-*!N13%,-B3%,.D!\q-3,!%&!,)!7.!?)*.!37)(,!01%2%*34!E(&,%'.Z!%*!NE!N1)B*!3*?!>q@!@'p41.3!U.?&&VD!I2&!E*,(2!G*,'(!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!"!O&7!K*#&0!*1!H,%($5&!U#('L43*?=!o./34!5.&.31'-!>)(*?3,%)*D!"``HV!3,!HHM!!"TS!o!R,.%*7.1/D!37)F.!*"P"D!3,!!"TP!W3*!o327%.D!37)F.!*`S!D!3,!QS!"TQ!R..!'-36,.1!:!+)1!+(1,-.1!?%&'(&&%)*!)+!,-.!'-313',.1%&,%'&!)+!,-.!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1M!!"Tgd.**.,-! #! $)?/.D! A-)23&! E! $%&-%)*! 3*?! o3*?&+)1?D! 3*?! E.**%+.1! p! S&<$)+(! N&&'! ?+10,&+5&%! $+!?+(&'<&+($*+! )+#! N,-0$5! N*0$5=! 1*'! E*,(2! U#! _(74%'3,%)*! )+! ,-.! R)'%.,8! +)1! 5.&.31'-! %*! 0-%4?!$.F.4)62.*,D!:;;QV!3,!!"TT!%7%?!"T`!%7%?!

Page 39: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! Hg!

61%&)*&D!,-.8!%*F)4F.!4)&&!)+!4%7.1,8D!&.6313,%)*!+1)2!+1%.*?&!3*?!+32%48D!3*?!2%O%*/!B%,-!

"S!,)!"Q!8.31!)4?&M!A-.1.!%&!3!')*&%?.1374.!32)(*,!)+!1.&.31'-!B-%'-!&-)B&!,-3,!643'%*/!

8)(*/!'-%4?1.*!%*!%*&,%,(,%)*&!%&!?323/%*/!,)!,-.%1!*)1234!?.F.4)62.*,!3*?!631,%'(43148!

?(.! ,)! 2%O%*/! B%,-! ),-.1! 8)(,-! )++.*?.1&D! %,! %&! 4%L.48! ,)! %*'1.3&.! ,-.! 1%&L! )+! +(1,-.1!

)++.*?%*/M"`;! R(7&.K(.*,48D! %,! %&! *.'.&&318! ,-3,! &('-! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?.1&! &-)(4?! 7.!

L.6,!)(,!)+!&('-!1.&%?.*'.&!B-.1.F.1!6)&&%74.M!!

!

q%,-!,-.!%*'1.3&.?![(1%&?%',%)*!)+!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!,-.1.!%&!34&)!,-.!4%2%,.?!6)&&%7%4%,8!)+!

":D! "H! 3*?! "S! 8.31! )4?&! *)B! 366.31%*/! 7.+)1.! ,-.! #?(4,! 0)(1,&! 3*?! 7.%*/! /%F.*!

&.*,.*'.&!)+!%261%&)*2.*,M!A-%&!,))!136%?48!%*'1.3&.&!,-.!'-3*'.!)+!7.%*/!23*%6(43,.?!

78!,-.!*./3,%F.! %*+4(.*'.&!)+!)4?.1!3*?!-31?.*.?!'1%2%*34&M!A-.!1%&L&!)+!2)F%*/!8)(*/!

6.)64.!+1)2!8)(,-!,)!3?(4,![(1%&?%',%)*!%&!B.44!?)'(2.*,.?!%*!4%,.13,(1.D!B%,-!%*'1.3&.?!

1.'%?%F%&2! 13,.&! 36631.*,M"`"! ! W261%&)*2.*,! %&! 3! 631,%'(43148! 6))1! 1.&6)*&.! ,)! 8)(,-!

'1%2.! 7.'3(&.! )+! 3! *(27.1! )+! *./3,%F.! 6&8'-)4)/%'34! 3*?! 7.-3F%)(134! ')*&.K(.*'.&!

B-%'-!)''(1!%*!8)(*/!6.)64.!B-)!31.!%261%&)*.?!3&!3?(4,&D!3*?!B%,-!3?(4,!)++.*?.1&M!W*!

631,%'(431D! ?(.! ,)! ,-.%1! F(4*.137%4%,8D! 231/%*34%&.?! 8)(,-! 4.31*! ,)! +%,! %*! ,)! ,-.! 61%&)*!

'(4,(1.! 3*?! ')*,%*(.! ,)! (&.! ,-3,! '(4,(1.Z&! *)12&! (6)*! 1.4.3&.M"`:! R,.34%*/! 3*),-.1!

6.1&)*Z&!&-).&D!F%)4.*'.!)1![)%*%*/!3!/3*/!31.!*)1234!7.-3F%)(1&!+1)2!,-.!F%.B6)%*,!)+!3!

a'(&,)?8!'(4,(1.b!B-%'-!61%j.&!6)B.1D!&,3,(&!3*?!%*?%++.1.*'.!,)!,-.!61.?%'32.*,!)+!,-.!

),-.1! 6.1&)*M"`H! r.1734D! 6-8&%'34D! &.O(34! 3*?! .2),%)*34! 37(&.! %&! 631,%'(43148! 4%L.48! +)1!

,-)&.! %*'31'.13,.?! +)1! ,-.! +%1&,! ,%2.D! ,-)&.! ,-3,! 31.! &2344D! +1)2! 3! 2%??4.! '43&&!

73'L/1)(*?D!)1!43'L!a&,1..,B%&.b!L*)B4.?/.M"`S!>(1,-.1D![(F.*%4.&!%*!3?(4,!61%&)*&!31.!3,!

/1.3,.1!1%&L!)+!&(%'%?.M"`P!

!

C:*!c6&P*6<#@!,)3.*887!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`;!R'),43*?MD!01%2%*34!E(&,%'.!R)'%34!q)1L!$.F.4)62.*,!0.*,.1!+)1D!N(%&,D!@3(1..*!3*?!q-%,.D!N%44!?+(&'+)($*+)0!T<$#&+5&!)-*,(!#&5$%$*+!.)@$+3!)+#!%&'<$5&%!1*'!52$0#'&+!)+#!=*,+3!/&*/0&!$+<*0<&#!$+!*11&+#$+3B!U:;;SVM!"`"!N%&-)6D!$M@M!:;;;M!E(F.*%4.!)++.*?.1&!%*!,-.!3?(4,!'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!&8&,.2M!G'$.&!)+#!H,%($5&!!:g=!T"!]!"Qg!"`:!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,D!_1%*'%634!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(?/.!)+!X.B!Y.343*?!a0-%4?1.*!3*?!^)(*/!_.)64.!%*!0)*+4%',!B%,-!,-.!o3B=!#&L%*/!,-.!n31?!c(.&,%)*&b!UtrWW!q)14?!0)*/1.&&!)+!,-.!W*,.1*3,%)*34!#&&)'%3,%)*!)+!^)(,-!3*?!>32%48!E(?/.&!3*?!@3/%&,13,.&D!N.4+3&,D!W1.43*?D!H"!#(/(&,!:;;QVM!!!3*8!.F%?.*'.!)+!,-%&!),-.1!,-3*!1.)++.*?%*/kkk!]!3*8!.F%?.*'.!)+!,-%&!),-.1!,-3*!1.f)++.*?%*/k!!*PH!"`H!%7%?!"`S!%7%?!"`P!%7%?!

Page 40: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! HT!

pF%?.*'.! 34&)! &-)B&! ,-3,! *),! )*48! ?).&! 2%O%*/! B%,-! ),-.1! ?.4%*K(.*,&! ,-1)(/-! ,-.!

&8&,.2! %*'1.3&.! ,-.! '-3*'.!)+! 1.f)++.*?%*/D! ')*+%12%*/! 3! '1%2%*34! %?.*,%,8! .3148! %*! 4%+.!

34&)! 1%&L&! 3,,13',%*/! ,-.&.! F.18! 8)(*/! '-%4?1.*! ,)! 3*! 3*,%f&)'%34! .,-)&! 3*?!.*,1.*'-%*/!

7.-3F%)(1! ,-3,!B%44! 4.3?! ,)! +(1,-.1! )++.*?%*/! 3&! 3?(4,&M"`Q! R,(?%.&! -3F.! +)(*?! ,-3,! ,-.!

2.1.!61)'.&&%*/!)+!3!8)(*/!6.1&)*! %*! ,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,! &8&,.2&!-3&!3?F.1&.!.++.',&!)*!

&(7&.K(.*,! '1%2%*34! )++.*?%*/! U')*,1)44%*/! +)1! 61%)1! )++.*?%*/VM! A-%&! &(//.&,&! ,-.!

%*+4(.*'.! )+! F%1,(34! 3&&)'%3,%)*! B%,-! ?.F%3*,! 6..1&! ,-1)(/-! 437.4%*/! )+! 8)(,-! 3&! 3!

2.27.1!)+!3!?.F%3*,!'3,./)18M"`g!_1%*'%634!32)*/!,-.!*./3,%F.!.++.',&!)+!%*F)4F.2.*,!%*!

,-.! +)1234! [(&,%'.! 31.*3! %&! ,-.! .++.',! )+! &,%/23,%&%*/! ,-.! '-%4?! )1! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*! 78!

437.4%*/!-%2!)1! -.1! 3&! 3! '1%2%*34M"`T! A-.! &,%/23,%&3,%)*!)+! '1%2%*34%,8! %&! -%/-48! 4%L.48! ,)!

\-(1,! 3*?! -31?.*Z! ,-.&.! F.18! 8)(*/! )++.*?.1&D! 34%.*3,.! ,-.2! +1)2! ,-.%1! +32%48! 3*?!

')22(*%,8D! 3*?! -3F.! 3! ?.,1%2.*,34! .++.',! )*! ,-.%1! 2),%F3,%)*! ,)! 3F)%?! +(1,-.1!

'1%2%*34%,8M"``! A-%&! )''(1&! ,)! 3!2)1.! .O,1.2.! .O,.*,! ?(.! ,)! ,-.! &.*&3,%)*34%&2! )+! ,-.!

2.?%3D! B-)! 1.3',! &)! F.-.2.*,48! ,)! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?%*/D! ?(.! %*! 631,! ,)! ,-.!

&-)'L%*/*.&&! )+! &('-! 8)(*/! '-%4?1.*! %*F)4F.?! %*! &('-! '344)(&! 3*?! F%)4.*,! '1%2.&M:;;!

_(74%'%,8!)+! ,-.!*32.&!)+!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&! %*-%7%,&! ,-.%1!1.-37%4%,3,%)*!78!3&&%&,%*/! %*!,-.!

\437.44%*/Z! 61)'.&&! )+! ,-.! '-%4?M:;"! R('-! 437.44%*/!23L.&! 1.%*,./13,%)*! 73'L! %*,)! &)'%.,8!

2)1.!?%++%'(4,! +)1! ,-.!'-%4?M!A-.! %*,.1*3,%)*34!)(,'18!)F.1! ,-.! 1.4.3&.!)+! ,-.! ,B)!7)8&Z!

*32.&! %*! ,-.!N(4/.1! ,1%34D!)1! ,-.!'3&.!)+!N3%4.8! E(*%)1!d(131%L%!31.! ,.&,%2)*8! ,)! &('-!3!

61)'.&&M!!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"`Q!o327)(1*D!N317313!U.?V!E*,+3!)+#!"55*,+()-0&L!M2*,0#!OR!0*7&'!(2&!)3&!*1!5'$.$+)0!/'*%&5,($*+L!!UR(22318!_)&%,%)*!_36.1D!GXW0p>!XYD!9',)7.1!:;;TVM!"`g!E)-*&)*D!oM!@MD!R%2)*&D!oMD!C!0)*/.1D!5M!$M!U:;;SVM!01%2%*34![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!%*F)4F.2.*,!3*?!')*,%*(%,8!)+!8)(,-!'1%2.=!#!4)*/%,(?%*34!3*348&%&M!E*,(2!\!M*5$&(=B!"`T!#44%&)*!@)11%&!3*?!n.*18!<%44.1D!!;+#&'%()+#$+3!H,<&+$0&!H,%($5&!Ud.*,=!01))2!n.42D!"`TgVD!"HTM!#44%&)*!@)11%&!3*?!q311.*!^)(*/D!H,<&+$0&!H,%($5&!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!N*0$5=!)+#!N')5($5&!Uq.44%*/,)*=!W*&,%,(,.!)+!01%2%*)4)/8D!"`TgV!3,!Q:M!"``!o327%.D!WM!U:;;QV!I2&!O&3)($<&!?./)5(%!*+!H,<&+$0&!>11&+#&'%!?+5)'5&')(&#!$+!"#,0(!N'$%*+%Q!!K(),.?!%*!N.'1)+,D!#MDA-)26&)*D!5M=!!M=./*%$,.!G2$0#!)+#!E*,(2!>11&+#&'%B!J2)(!7*'@%BQ!::!#(/(&,!:;;QD!q.44%*/,)*M!$)B*4)3?374.!+1)2!-,,6=ii[(&,%'.M)1/M*ji8)(,-i2.?%3i&6..'-.&i'-%4?f8)(,-f)++.*?.1&fB-3,fB)1L&f3(/(&,f:;;QM6?+M!!:;;!o!R,.%*7.1/!3*?!#!_%K(.1)!a@3*%6(43,%*/!_(74%'!96%*%)*!#7)(,!A18%*/!E(F.*%4.&!3&!#?(4,&=!#*!pO6.1%2.*,34!R,(?8b!U:;";V!01%2.!3*?!$.4%*K(.*'8!ISTgJM!!#!61)2%*.*,!X.B!Y.343*?!.O3264.!)+!,-%&!%&!,-3,!)+!N3%4.8!E(*)%1!d(131%L%!B-)!B3&!,-1)B*!%*,)!,-.!&6),4%/-,!3+,.1!,-.!@%'-3.4!0-)8!2(1?.1D!3*?!-3&!7..*!+4)(,.?!3&!,-%&!')(*,18Z&!a8)(*/.&,!L%44.1b!.F.1!&%*'.M!A-.!*32.&!)+!,-.!)4?.1!8)(,-&!]!%*!631,%'(431!,-)&.!B.1.!+)(*?!/(%4,8!)+!2(1?.1!1.'.%F.?!*)!B-.1.!*.31!,-.!&32.!32)(*,!)+!!6(74%'%,8M!!:;"!A-.!437.4%*/!,-.)1%&,&!73&%'3448!61)6)(*?!,-3,!%+!,-.!'-%4?!%&!&,%/23,%j.?!78!,-.!'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!61)'.&&D!3*?!-%&!+32%48D!+1%.*?&!3*?!,-.!2.?%3!437.4!-%2!3&!\?.4%*K(.*,ZD!,-.*!,-.!'-%4?!%&!4%L.48!,)!3''.6,!3*?!1.+4.',!,-%&!437.4!%*!-%&!7.-3F%)(1M!!

Page 41: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! H`!

93(':! A3()'! 6&./8! ':*! #*.*88&)=! &%%(#<'<3#! '3! 1*&6! 0<':! .&)*! &#1! ,)3'*.'<3#!

<88(*8!!

!

_.1-36&!,-.!2)&,!&34%.*,!1.3&)*!*),!,)!71%*/!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&!%*,)!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!%&!

,-.! %*37%4%,8!)+! ,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,! ,)!?.34!B%,-!,-.!1)),&!)+! ,-.!)++.*?%*/!)+! ,-.&.!8)(*/!

'-%4?1.*M! @)&,! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?.1&D! %*! )*.! B38! )1! 3*),-.1D! 71%*/! B%,-! ,-.2! 63&,!

3*?i)1!61.&.*,!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!?.+%'%,&M:;:!#,,.26,&!,)!1.?('.!,-.!)++.*?%*/!)+!&('-!

'-%4?1.*! 31.! 7.&,! ?)*.! %*! ,-.! ')22(*%,8D! 3*?! 7.,,.1! &,%44! %*! ,-.! ')*,.O,! )+! ,-.!

.*F%1)*2.*,!B-%'-! 61)73748! ')*,1%7(,.?! ,)! ,-.! )++.*?%*/! 3*?! ,)!B-%'-! ,-.! '-%4?!B%44!

-3F.!,)!1.,(1*M:;H!R('-!3*!3,,.26,!%&!4%L.48!,)!1.?('.!,-.!'-%4?Z&!'-3*'.!)+!1.f)++.*?%*/!

13,-.1! ,-3*!&,%/23,%&%*/! ,-.!'-%4?!3*?!643'%*/! ,-.2!32)*/&,!),-.1&!B-)!B%44! 1.%*+)1'.!

,-.%1! '1%2%*34! 7.-3F%)(1M! N8! 71%*/%*/! &('-! '-%4?1.*! %*,)! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! %,! 13%&.&! ,-.!

61)+)(*?! 1%&L! )+! '1%2%*34%&%*/! B-3,! %&! .&&.*,%3448! 3! B.4+31.! %&&(.M:;S! #??1.&&%*/! &('-!

%&&(.&! %*! ,-.! '1%2%*34! ')(1,&D! .&6.'%3448! ,)! ,-.! .O,.*,! *.'.&&318! ,)! +(448! 1.&)4F.! ,-.2D!

1(*&!,-.!1%&L!)+!aB.4+31%&%*/b!3*?!61)4)*/%*/!,-.![(&,%'.!1.&6)*&.!3*?!')261)2%&%*/!,-.!

61%*'%64.!)+!61)6)1,%)*34%,8!)+!1.&6)*&.M:;P!

!

A-.1.! %&! 1.34! ')*'.1*! 78! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! E(?/.&! ,-3,! ,-.! 0)(1,! B%44! 7.! 3&&(2%*/! ,-.!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! +)1! ,-.! B)1&,! '-%4?! )++.*?.1&D! aB-)! 78! ?.+%*%,%)*! B%44! -3F.! ,-.! 2)&,!

&.1%)(&!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!%&&(.&D!7(,!,-3,!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!B%44!*),!-3F.!,-.!*.'.&&318!

&,3,(,)18!a322(*%,%)*b!,)!?.34!B%,-!,-.!%*.F%,374.!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!')*'.1*&Mb:;Q!A)!

7.!/%F.*!,-.![(1%&?%',%)*!,)!?.34!B%,-!,-.&.!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!%&!)*.!,-%*/D!7(,!,)!7.!/%F.*!

,-.!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!,)!?.34!B%,-!,-.2!B%,-)(,!,-.!6)B.1&!,)!3??1.&&!B-3,!31.!4%L.48!,)!7.!

,-.! 1)),! '3(&.&! )+! ,-.%1! )++.*?%*/! U'31.! 3*?! 61),.',%)*V! %&! K(%,.! 3*),-.1M! A-.!

#2.*?2.*,! %*! %,&! +%*34%,8! 61)F%?.?! ,-3,! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! [(?/.&! B.1.! 374.! ,)! ?%F.1,!

'-%4?1.*!,)!,-.!>32%48!0)(1,Z&! [(1%&?%',%)*! %+! ,-.8!')*&%?.1! ,-3,! %,! %&!3661)61%3,.! +)1! ,-.!

'-%4?!,)!7.!?.34,!B%,-!(*?.1!%,&!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!61)F%&%)*&M!$.&6%,.!,-%&D!%,!%&!31/(374.!

,-3,!%,!B)(4?!7.!7.,,.1!+)1!,-.!#',!%,&.4+!,)!61.&'1%7.!43B&!B-%'-!31.!3661)61%3,.!,)!,-.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:;:!#&!2.*,%)*.?!%*!'-36,.1!,B)!!:;H!R.*?%*/!)(,!3*!R9R!]!^)(,-!E(&,%'.!*..?&!,-.!0)22(*%,8D!E(?/.!N.'1)+,D!q)1L%*/!A)/.,-.1!0)*+.1.*'.D!X)F.27.1!:;;gf!:;S!#&!2.*,%)*.?!%*!'-36,.1!,B)D!61.F%)(&48!%*!344!'3&.&!)+!'-%4?!)++.*?%*/D!,-.!23,,.1!-3?!,)!7.!?.34,!B%,-!78!B38!)+!3!>32%48!<1)(6!0)*+.1.*'.!3*?!%+!*.'.&&318!3*!3664%'3,%)*!')(4?!7.!23?.!,)!,-.!>32%48!0)(1,!,-3,!,-.!8)(*/!6.1&)*&!B3&!%*!*..?!)+!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*M!A-%&!1.+4.',.?!,-.!6-%4)&)6-%'34!3&&(26,%)*!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!B-)!)++.*?!2(&,!7.!F%.B.?!%*!,-.!')*,.O,!)+!,-.%1!+32%48M!!:;P!A-%&!)6,%)*!%&!?%&'(&&.?!%*!0-36,.1!SM:M!!:;Q!!A-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!)+!X.B!Y.343*?!aR(72%&&%)*!,)!R)'%34!R.1F%'.&!R.4.',!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!0-%4?1.*D!

^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!U^)(,-!0)(1,!E(1%&?%',%)*!3*?!91?.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!N%44bM!!

Page 42: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! S;!

3/.&! 3*?! &,3/.&! )+! '-%4?1.*D! 13,-.1! ,-3*! 1.48%*/! )*! ,-.! ?%&'1.,%)*318! 6)B.1&! )+! ,-.!

[(?/.&!,)!.*&(1.!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!31.!,1.3,.?!3661)61%3,.48M:;g!!

!

A3#.6(8<3#!

!

A-.!6)%*,!,)!7.!23?.!-.1.!%&!,-3,!71%*/%*/!&.1%)(&!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!%*,)!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!

31.*3!%&!(*4%L.48!,)!B)1L!%*!,-.!&.*&.!)+!1.?('%*/!1.)++.*?%*/!3*?!238!%*!+3',!23L.!,-.!

&%,(3,%)*!B)1&.M!o./%&43,)1&!3*?!6)4%'8!23L.1&!*..?!,)!L*)B!2('-!2)1.!37)(,!.++.',%F.!

6)4%'8!'-)%'.&!+)1!1.?('%*/!&.1%)(&!)++.*?%*/!78!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&!7.+)1.!,-3,!/)34!'3*!

7.!(&.?!3&!3!&(7&,3*,%F.!1.3&)*!,)!4)B.1!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8M!W,!%&!31/(374.!

,-3,!(*,%4!.F%?.*'.! %&!61)F%?.?!,-3,!71%*/%*/!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&! %*,)!,-.!8)(,-! [(&,%'.!

&8&,.2! B%44! 3',(3448! +(4+%44! ,3*/%74.! 6)4%'8! /)34&D! %,! 2%/-,! 7.! 7.&,! ,)! 3?)6,D! 3&! 3!

61.4%2%*318! &)4(,%)*D! ,-.! F%.B! ,-3,D! %*! ?.F%&%*/! &,13,./%.&! +)1! ?.34%*/! B%,-! 8)(*/!

)++.*?.1&!]!631,%'(43148!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!]!B.!&-)(4?!*),!&3'1%+%'.!),-.1!)7[.',%F.&!&('-!3&!

(6-)4?%*/!,-.!1%/-,&!)+!,-.!'-%4?!%*!,-.!6(1&(%,!)+!,-.!6)6(4%&,!3%2M!!

!

NIN!! $#'*)#&'<3#&6!K(%&#!E<@:'8!$#8')(%*#'8!!

!

A-.! 37)F.! &(2231%.&! )+! ?.F.4)62.*,34! .F%?.*'.! 3*?! 713%*! &'%.*'.! -3F.! .&,374%&-.?!

,-3,!4)B.1%*/!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!,)!":!%&!(*4%L.48!,)!1.?('.!,-.!13,.!)+!1.f

)++.*?%*/!%*!,-%&!&.4.',.?!/1)(6!)+!'-%4?1.*D!3*?!*.%,-.1!?).&!%,!3?.K(3,.48!1.+4.',!,-.%1!

'363'%,8! ,)! ')261.-.*?! ,-.%1! 3',%)*&M! A-.! ,-%1?! .4.2.*,! )+! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! ,-3,! *..?&! ,)! 7.! 3*348&.?! %&! ,-.! 1%/-,&! )+! ,-.&.! '-%4?1.*! 1.')/*%j.?!

,-1)(/-! 43BM! A-.! '(11.*,! _1%*'%634! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! E(?/.! #*?1.B! N.'1)+,! -3&! '-344.*/.?!

X.B!Y.343*?!&)'%.,8!&,3,%*/!,-3,=:;T!

!

13,-.1! ,-3*! &(''(27! ,)! &%264%&,%'! 6(74%'! 61.&&(1.! ,)! a/.,! ,)(/-bD! '-%4?! 3*?!

8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2&!2(&,!,3L.!3&!,-.%1!+)(*?3,%)*!,-.!61%*'%64.&!,-3,!(6-)4?!

,-.!1%/-,&!)+!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.M!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:;g!1.+.1!,)!'-36,.1!SM:M!!:;T!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,D!37)F.!*PH!

Page 43: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! S"!

W*,.1*3,%)*34!)74%/3,%)*&!-3F.!34&)!'-344.*/.?![(1%&?%',%)*&!,)!7.!2)1.!,13*&631.*,!3*?!

.F%?.*'.! 4.?! %*! ,-.%1! 3661)3'-! ,)! '-%4?1.*! 3*?! 8)(*/! 6.)64.! 3*?! ,)! ?.2)*&,13,.!

.++.',%F.*.&&!%*!,-.%1!613',%'.&M:;`!

!

#4,-)(/-! ,-.1.! %&! *)! '3,./)1%'34! %*,.1*3,%)*34! &,3*?31?! 1./31?%*/! ,-.! 3/.! 3,! B-%'-!

'1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! '3*! 1.3&)*3748! 7.! %26(,.?! ,)! 3! '-%4?D:";! L.8! %*,.1*3,%)*34!

')*F.*,%)*&! )*! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! ')*,3%*! 3! *(27.1! )+! 61%*'%64.&! ,-3,! 31.! F%,34! +)1! 3!

2.3&(1.?!3*?!?%&63&&%)*3,.!1.&6)*&.!,)!'-%4?!)++.*?%*/M:""!A-1..!&6.'%+%'!%*,.1*3,%)*34!

%*&,1(2.*,&! 31.! 1.4.F3*,! ,)! X.B! Y.343*?Z&! ,1.3,2.*,! )+! 8)(,-! )++.*?.1&=! A-.! G*%,.?!

X3,%)*&!0)*F.*,%)*&!)*! ,-.!5%/-,&!)+! ,-.!0-%4?! U\GX0590ZVD:":! A-.!R,3*?31?!@%*%2(2!

5(4.&! +)1! ,-.! #?2%*%&,13,%)*! )+! E(F.*%4.! E(&,%'.! U\,-.! N.%[%*/! 5(4.&ZVD:"H! 3*?! ,-.!

W*,.1*3,%)*34!0)F.*3*,!)*!0%F%4!3*?!_)4%,%'34!5%/-,&!UW00_5V:"SM!!

!

>)1,8f,B)!8.31&! 3/)!X.B!Y.343*?! 13,%+%.?! ,-.! W00_5!3*?! ,-.1.78!(*?.1,))L! ,)!.*&(1.!

,-3,! ,-.! 1%/-,&! 3*?! +1..?)2&! ')*,3%*.?! %*! ,-.! ')F.*3*,! B.1.! 1.')/*%&.?! 78!

/)F.1*2.*,M!@)&,!)+!,-.!1%/-,&!%*!,-.!W00_5!B.1.!.27)?%.?!%*!,-.!X.B!Y.343*?!N%44!)+!

5%/-,&!#',!"``;!UXYN95#VM:"P!!q-%4&,!,-.!XYN95#!?).&!*),!61)F%?.!3*8!&6.'%34!1%/-,&!+)1!

8)(*/!)++.*?.1&D!%,!?).&!&,3,.!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!31.!,)!7.!\?.34,!B%,-!%*!3!23**.1!,-3,!,3L.&!

3'')(*,!)+!,-.%1!3/.ZD!B-%'-! %264%.&!,-3,!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!&-)(4?!7.!,1.3,.?!?%++.1.*,48!

3*?!2)1.!4.*%.*,48!,-3*!3?(4,&M:"Q!

!

W*! 3'')1?3*'.! B%,-! &! g! )+! ,-.! XYN95#! ,-.! :;";! #2.*?2.*,! N%44! B3&! 1.F%.B.?! +)1!

')*&%&,.*'8! B%,-! ,-.! XYN95#M:"g! A-.! #,,)1*.8! <.*.134! 1.6)1,.?! ,)! _314%32.*,! ,-3,!

B-%4.!%&&(.&!(*?.1!&&!""D!"gD!::!3*?!:PU"V!)+!,-.!XYN95#!31)&.D!%*!1.&6.',!)+!,-.!N%44D!%,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:;`!N(%&,D!@3(1..*!3*?!q-%,.D!N%44!?+(&'+)($*+)0!T<$#&+5&!)-*,(!#&5$%$*+!.)@$+3!)+#!%&'<$5&%!1*'!52$0#'&+!)+#!=*,+3!/&*/0&!$+<*0<&#!$+!*11&+#$+3!U01%2%*34!E(&,%'.!R)'%34!q)1L!$.F.4)62.*,!0.*,.1!+)1!R'),43*?D!:;;SV!3,!HM!:";!N!<)4?&)*D!37)F.!*!QD!3,!T!:""!#*?1.B!N.'1)+,D!37)F.!*!PH!:":!;+$(&#!O)($*+%!G*+<&+($*+!*+!(2&!P$32(%!*1!(2&!G2$0#!U)6.*.?!+)1!&%/*3,(1.!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!3?)6,.?!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!.*,.1.?!%*,)!+)1'.!:!R.6,.27.1!"``;VM!:"H!;+$(&#!O)($*+%!M()+#)'#!K$+$.,.!P,0&%!1*'!"#.$+$%(')($*+!*1!H,<&+$0&!H,%($5&D!<#!5.&!S;iHHD!GX!$)'!#iS;iPHD!#**.OD!S;!GMXM!<#95!R(66MX)MPH!U"`TPV!3,!:;gM!!:"S!W*,.1*3,%)*34!0)F.*3*,!)*!0%F%4!3*?!_)4%,%'34!5%/-,&!U#?)6,.?!3*?!)6.*.?!+)1!&%/*3,(1.D!13,%+%'3,%)*!3*?!3''.&&%)*!78!<#!5.&!::;;#!UttWV!)+!"Q,-!$.'.27.1!"`QQD!.*,18!%*,)!+)1'.!:H1?!@31'-!"`gQ!%*!3'')1?3*'.!B%,-!31,M!S`V!:"P!<[email protected]!37)F.!*`SD!3,!`H!!:"Q!%7%?!!:"g!03&.8D!r%',)1%3!"#<$5&!(*!(2&!"((*'+&=W]&+&')0!*+!(2&!G*+%$%(&+5=!7$(2!(2&!O&7!R&)0)+#!4$00!*1!P$32(%!"5(!XYYV!*1!(2&!G2$0#'&+!E*,+3!N&'%*+%!\!I2&$'!F).$0$&%!8E*,(2!G*,'(%!H,'$%#$5($*+!\!>'#&'%:!".&+#.&+(!4$00!U01)B*!o3BD!P!>.71(318!:;;`V!!

Page 44: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! S:!

')*'4(?.?!,-3,!,-.&.!%&&(.&!/3F.!1%&.!,)!*)!%*')*&%&,.*'8M:"T!!A-.!1.F%.B!*),.?!,-3,!,-.!

4)B.1%*/! )+! ,-.! 3/.! )+! 61)&.'(,%)*! +)1! '.1,3%*! )++.*'.&! (*?.1! ,-.! N%44! 1.K(%1.&!

')*&%?.13,%)*!)+! ,-.! +3%1! ,1%34! 1%/-,&!/(313*,..?! %*! &!:P!)+! ,-.!N%44!)+!5%/-,&!#',D!3*?! %*!

631,%'(431!,-.!1%/-,!%*!&!:PU%V!hMMM!%*!,-.!'3&.!)+!3!'-%4?D!,)!7.!?.34,!B%,-!%*!3!23**.1!,-3,!

,3L.&!3'')(*,!)+!,-.!'-%4?v&!3/.Mb:"`!

!

A-.!1.6)1,!34&)!*),.?!,-3,!3!":!)1!"H!8.31!)4?! U3&!B.44!3&!"SD!"PD!"Q!3*?!"g!8.31!)4?&V!

'-31/.?!B%,-!3!&.1%)(&!)++.*'.!238!)6,!+)1!,1%34!78![(18D!B-%'-!B%44!1.2)F.!,-.!-.31%*/!

+1)2! ,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!3*?!643'.! %,! %*,)! ,-.!#?(4,!0)(1,M! W*! ,-3,! &%,(3,%)*! ,-.!61.&%?%*/!

E(?/.!B%44!7.!(*?.1!3*!)74%/3,%)*!,)!.*&(1.!')264%3*'.!B%,-!&:PU%VD::;!3*?!,-.!61%*'%64.&!

(*?.148%*/! ,-.! ^)(,-! E(&,%'.! 1./%2.! B%44! /.*.13448! ')*,%*(.! ,)! 7.! 3664%.?M::"! W,! %&!

31/(374.!-)B.F.1D!,-3,!,-%&!61)6)&%,%)*!*)!4)*/.1!.O%&,&!B%,-!,-.!?.'%&%)*!)+!,-.!0)(1,!

)+!#66.34!%*!]!!P!<!N*,72)'&!B-%'-!-.4?!,-3,!B-.*!&.*,.*'%*/!3!'-%4?!%*!,-.!3?(4,!0)(1,&!

,-.![(?/.!'3**),!-3F.!1./31?!,)!,-.!61%*'%64.&!&.,!)(,!%*!,-.!0^_>!#',D!%*&,.3?!)*48!,-.!

R.*,.*'%*/!#',!:;;:!%&!)+!1.4.F3*'.M:::!

!

o))L%*/! +(1,-.1! 3+%.4?! ,-.! GX0590! %&! ,-.!2)&,! 1.4.F3*,! 6%.'.! )+! %*,.1*3,%)*34! 43B! %*!

1./31?&!,)!X.B!Y.343*?Z&!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2M!W,!/%F.&!,-.!1%/-,&!)+!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!

6.)64.D! 3,! 4.3&,! %*! ,-.)18D! 3! '.*,134!643'.! %*! %*,.1*3,%)*34! 43BM!N8! &%/*%*/!3*?! 13,%+8%*/!

,-.!GX0590D!X.B!Y.343*?!-3&!&%/*%+%.?! %,&!B%44%*/*.&&!,)!7.!7)(*?!78! %,&!61%*'%64.&M::H!

q-%4&,! ,-.! &,3,(&! )+! ,-.! GX0590! %*! ?)2.&,%'! 43B! 1.23%*&! %*,.161.,%F.! 13,-.1! ,-3*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:"T!&""!]!,-.!1%/-,!,)!1.+(&.!,)!(*?.1/)!2.?%'34!,1.3,2.*,D!&"g!]!+1..?)2!)+!3&&)'%3,%)*D!&::!]!4%7.1,8!)+!,-.!6.1&)*D!&:PU"V!]!2%*%2(2!&,3*?31?&!)+!'1%2%*34!61)'.?(1.!:"`!R..!34&)!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!0)*F.*,%)*!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!0-%4?D!31,%'4.!S;M!::;!R..D!+)1!.O3264.D!R0!F!G*%,.?!d%*/?)2!U:;;PV!S;!pn55!";D!I:`JM!!::"!!P!<!G!U0#H":i`"D!:Ti;`i`"V!!:::!q-%4&,!3/.!%&!&,%44!')*&%?.1.?!3!2%,%/3,%*/!+3',)1!(*?.1!,-.!R.*,.*'%*/!#',!%,!%&!4%L.48!,-3,!,-)&.!')*F%',.?!,)!,-.&.!0)(1,&!+)1!,-.!')22%&&%)*!)+!&.1%)(&!)++.*'.&!238!1.'.%F.!&(7&,3*,%34!&.*,.*'.&!?(.!,)!&('-!&.*,.*'%*/!61)'.&&.&!3&!&,31,%*/!6)%*,&!3*?!/(%?.4%*.![(?/2.*,&!B-%'-!a7%*?b!,-.!')(1,M!::H!R(7[.',!)+!')(1&.!,)!,-.!,-1..!1.&.1F3,%)*&!B-%'-!X.B!Y.343*?!-3&!.*,.1.?M!A-.!X.B!Y.343*?!<)F.1*2.*,!13,%+%.?!,-.!GX0590!%*!@31'-!"``HD!+)44)B%*/!3!')261.-.*&%F.!1.F%.B!)+!4./%&43,%)*M!W*!?)%*/!&)D!X.B!Y.343*?!7.'32.!,-.!)*.!-(*?1.?!3*?!,-%1,8f+%1&,!')(*,18!,)!13,%+8!,-.!0)*F.*,%)*M!A-.!X.B!Y.343*?!<)F.1*2.*,!.*,.1.?!,-1..!1.&.1F3,%)*&!,)!GX0590!B-.*!13,%+8%*/!,-.!')*F.*,%)*!%*!"``HM!A-.&.!1.&.1F3,%)*&!B-%'-!&,%44!&,3*?!B.1.!23?.!%*!1.&6.',!)+!,-.!+)44)B%*/!#1,%'4.&!)+!,-.!0)*F.*,%)*=!

f #1,%'4.!::M"!]!1.K(%1.&!R,3,.!_31,%.&!,)!,3L.!3661)61%3,.!2.3&(1.&!,)!.*&(1.!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!&..L%*/!1.+(/..!&,3,(&!31.!61)F%?.?!B%,-!,-.!&32.!1%/-,&!(*?.1!,-.!GX0590!3&!),-.1!'-%4?1.*!3&!B.44!3&!3661)61%3,.!61),.',%)*!3*?!-(23*%,31%3*!3&&%&,3*'.M!!

f #1,%'4.!H:M:!]!1.K(%1.&D!%*,.1!34%3D!R,3,.!_31,%.&!,)!61)F%?.!3!2%*%2(2!3/.!)+!.*,18!%*,)!.264)82.*,M!!

f #1,%'4.!HgU'V!]!1.K(%1.&D!%*,.1!34%3D!,-3,!R,3,.!631,%.&!.*&(1.!,-3,!'-%4?1.*!?.61%F.?!)+!,-.%1!4%7.1,8!31.!&.6313,.?!+1)2!3?(4,&!(*4.&&!%,!%&!%*!,-.!'-%4?Z&!7.&,!%*,.1.&,!*),!,)!?)!&)M!!

Page 45: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! SH!

?.+%*%,%F.D! %,! -3&! 3! F%,34! 1)4.! %*! 61)F%?%*/! 3! 7.*'-231L! 3/3%*&,!B-%'-! ,-.!X.B!Y.343*?!

8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!'3*!7.!2.3&(1.?M::S!

!

#1,%'4.! HU"V! )+! ,-.! GX0590! ]! 32)*/&,! ,-.!2)&,!B%?.48! 3?)6,.?! %*,.1*3,%)*34! -(23*!

1%/-,&!%*&,1(2.*,!%*!-%&,)18!61)F%?.&=::P!

!

%*!344!3',%)*&!')*'.1*%*/!'-%4?1.*D!B-.,-.1!(*?.1,3L.*!78!6(74%'!)1!61%F3,.!&)'%34!

B.4+31.! %*&,%,(,%)*&D! ')(1,&! )+! 43BD! 3?2%*%&,13,%F.! 3(,-)1%,%.&! )1! 4./%&43,%F.!

7)?%.&D!,-.!7.&,!%*,.1.&,&!)+!,-.!'-%4?!&-344!7.!3!61%2318!')*&%?.13,%)*M!

!

@)1.! &6.'%+%'3448D! #1,%'4.! S;! )+! GX0590! .&,374%&-.&! 3! &.,! )+! 2%*%2(2! %*,.1*3,%)*34!

[(F.*%4.![(&,%'.!&,3*?31?&D!%*'4(?%*/=::Q!!

!

A-3,!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.!&-344!7.!,1.3,.?!%*!3!23**.1!B-%'-!,3L.&!%*,)!

3'')(*,! ,-.%1! 3/.! 3*?! ,-.! ?.&%137%4%,8! )+! 61)2),%*/! 1.%*,./13,%)*! 3*?! ,-.%1!

3&&(2%*/!3!')*&,1(',%F.!1)4.!%*!&)'%.,8::g!s!A-3,!R,3,.!_31,%.&!&-344!.&,374%&-!3!

2%*%2(2!3/.!7.4)B!B-%'-!'-%4?1.*!&-344!7.!61.&(2.?!*),!,)!-3F.!,-.!'363'%,8!

,)!%*+1%*/.!,-.!6.*34!43BM!

!

A-.!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!0-%4?::T!1.')22.*?&!a,-.!3/.!)+!":!

8.31&!3&!,-.!37&)4(,.!2%*%2(2Z!3*?!.*')(13/.&!/)F.1*2.*,&!,)!\')*,%*(.!,)!%*'1.3&.!%,!

,)!3!-%/-.1!4.F.4bM::`!

!

A-.! 61)F%&%)*&! )+! GX0590! 31.! ')264.2.*,.?! 78! ,-.! GX! <(%?.4%*.&! +)1! ,-.!

#?2%*%&,13,%)*!)+! E(F.*%4.!$.4%*K(.*'8!aA-.!5%83?-!<(%?.4%*.&bD:H;! ,-.!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!::S!X.&&3!o8*'-D!\^)(,-!E(&,%'.!%*!X.B!Y.343*?=!#!0-%4?1.*Z&!5%/-,&!_.1&6.',%F.Z!U:;;TV!T!E*,(2!H,%($5&!:"PM!!::P!;+$(&#!O)($*+%!G*+<&+($*+!*+!(2&!P$32(%!*1!(2&!G2$0#!U)6.*.?!+)1!&%/*3,(1.!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!3?)6,.?!:;!X)F.27.1!"`T`D!.*,.1.?!%*,)!+)1'.!:!R.6,.27.1!"``;VM!::Q!GX0590!U#1,%'4.!S;MHU3VV!::g!GX0590!U#1,%'4.!S;M"V!::T!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!0-%4?!:;;gD!6313M!"QV!!::`!N!<)4?&)*D!37)F.!*QD!3,!T!:H;!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!<(%?.4%*.&!+)1!,-.!_1.F.*,%)*!)+!E(F.*%4.!$.4%*K(.*'8!UaA-.!5%83?-!<(%?.4%*.&bVD!<M#!1.&!SPi"":D!3**.OD!SP!GMX!<#95!R(66M!UX)S`#V!3,!:;"!GMX!$)'M!#iSPiS`!U"``;VM!! A-.!5%83?-!<(%?.4%*.&!%*&%&,!,-3,!8)(*/!6.)64.!&-)(4?!-3F.!3*!3',%F.!1)4.!3*?!631,*.1&-%6!B%,-%*!&)'%.,8!3*?!&-)(4?!*),!7.!&..*!3&!a)7[.',&!)+!&)'%34%j3,%)*!)1!')*,1)4Mb!#*,%f&)'%34!7.-3F%)(1!&-)(4?!7.!&..*!3&!a631,!)+!,-.!23,(13,%)*!C!/1)B,-!61)'.&&b!,-3,!B%44!?%&366.31!B%,-!,-.!,13*&%,%)*!,)!3?(4,-))?M!!

Page 46: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! SS!

5(4.&!+)1!,-.!_1),.',%)*!)+!E(F.*%4.&!$.61%F.?!)+!,-.%1!o%7.1,8D:H"!3*?!,-.!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!

R,3*?31?!@%*%2(2!5(4.&!+)1!#?2%*%&,13,%)*!)+!E(F.*%4.!E(&,%'.!a,-.!N.%[%*/!5(4.&b!7.%*/!

,-.!2)&,! 1.4.F3*,M:H:! A-.! N.%[%*/! 5(4.&! 31.! *),! 3! 4./3448! 7%*?%*/! ,1.3,8! )+! ,-.2&.4F.&D!

7.%*/! &%2648! G*%,.?! X3,%)*&! 1.')22.*?3,%)*&! )*! 2%*%2(2! &,3*?31?&! +)1! *3,%)*34!

8)(,-! [(&,%'.!&8&,.2&D!-)B.F.1! ,-.8!.O63*?!)*! ,-.! %*,.1*3,%)*34!*)12&!&.,!)(,! %*! ,-.!

GX0590D!&,3,%*/!3,!'43(&.!SM"=:HH!

!

%*! ,-)&.! 4./34! &8&,.2&! 1.')/*%j%*/! ,-.! ')*'.6,! )+! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!+)1![(F.*%4.&D!,-.!7./%**%*/!)+!,-3,!3/.!&-344!*),!7.!+%O.?!3,!,))!

4)B! 3*! 3/.! 4.F.4D! 7.31%*/! %*! 2%*?! ,-.! +3',&! )+! .2),%)*34D! 2.*,34! 3*?!

%*,.44.',(34!23,(1%,8M!

!

A-.!0)22.*,318!,)!'43(&.!SM"M!)+!,-.!N.%[%*/!5(4.&!61)F%?.&!+(1,-.1!')*,.O,!&,3,%*/=!

!

A-.!2)?.1*!3661)3'-!B)(4?!7.!,)!')*&%?.1!B-.,-.1!3!'-%4?!'3*!4%F.!(6!,)!,-.!

2)134!3*?!6&8'-)4)/%'34!')26)*.*,&!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8s!%+!,-.!3/.!)+!

'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!%&!&.,!,))!4)B!)1!%+!,-.1.!%&!*)!4)B.1!3/.!4%2%,!3,!344D!,-.!

*),%)*!)+! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!7.')2.&!2.3*%*/4.&&!s!p++)1,&! &-)(4?! ,-.1.+)1.!7.!

23?.! ,)! 3/1..! )*! 3! 1.3&)*374.! 4)B.&,! 3/.! 4%2%,! ,-3,! %&! 3664%'374.!

%*,.1*3,%)*3448M!!

!

#4,-)(/-!,-.&.!?)'(2.*,&!61)F%?.!*)!61.'%&.!%*?%'3,%)*!B-3,!,-3,!3/.!&-)(4?!7.!]!3*?!

?%++.1.*,!3/.&!3,,13',!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!%*!?%++.1.*,!')(*,1%.&D:HS!,-.!GX!0)22%,,..!

1.&6)*&%74.!+)1!2)*%,)1%*/!')264%3*'.!B%,-!GX0590!-3&!341.3?8!')22.*,.?!*./3,%F.48!

)*! ,-.! 3/.! 3,! B-%'-! 3! '-%4?! '3*! 7.! '-31/.?! B%,-! 3! &.1%)(&! '1%2%*34! )++.*'.! %*! X.B!

Y.343*?M:HPX.B! Y.343*?Z&! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! B3&! ')*&%?.1.?! 78! ,-.! GX! %*!

:;;HD! 3&!631,!)+! ,-.!X.B!Y.343*?!<)F.1*2.*,Z&! 1.6)1,%*/!)74%/3,%)*&!(*?.1!GX0590M!

53,-.1! ,-3*! +%*?%*/! ,-3,! X.B! Y.343*?Z&! '(11.*,! 43B&! ')*+)12.?! B%,-! %*,.1*3,%)*34!

[(F.*%4.! [(&,%'.!*)12&D!,-.!GX!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!0-%4?! %*&,.3?!.O61.&&.?!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:H"!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!5(4.&!+)1!,-.!_1),.',%)*!)+!E(F.*%4.&!$.61%F.?!)+!,-.%1!o%7.1,8D!<M#M!1.&!SPi""HD!3**.OD!SP!GMXM!<#95!R(66M!UX)MS`#V!3,!:;PD!GMXM!$)'!#iSPiS`!U"``;V!! A-.&.!1(4.&!?.&'1%7.!)6,%234!'(&,)?%34!3113*/.2.*,&!+)1!'-%4?1.*M!A-.&.!%*'4(?.!%261%&)*2.*,!%*!&2344!)6.*!+3'%4%,%.&!B%,-!%*?%F%?(34%j.?!,1.3,2.*,D!')*,3',!B%,-!+32%48!2.27.1&D!3*?!&,3++!,13%*.?!%*!'-%4?!B.4+31.!3*?!-(23*!1%/-,&M!!:H:!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!R,3*?31?!@%*%2(2!5(4.&!+)1!#?2%*%&,13,%)*!)+!E(F.*%4.!E(&,%'.D!<M#M!1.&M!S;iHHD!#**.OD!S;!GMXM!<#95!R(66MX)MPHD!3,!:;gD!GMXM!$)'M!#iS;iPH!U"`TPVM!n.1.%*3+,.1!,-.!N.%[%*/!5(4.&!!:HH!N.%[%*/!5(4.&!043(&.!SM"!!:HS!&..!37)F.!*"P!:HP!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!0-%4?!:;;HD!:;;g!1.6)1,&M!!

Page 47: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! SP!

%,&!')*'.1*!3,!X.B!Y.343*?Z&!4)B!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8:HQ!3*?!1.')22.*?.?!,-3,!

,-.!<)F.1*2.*,=:Hg!

!

13%&.! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! ,)! 3*! %*,.1*3,%)*3448! 3''.6,374.! 3/.!

3*?! .*&(1.! ,-3,! %,! 3664%.&! ,)! 344! '1%2%*34! )++.*'.&:HTm! 3*?! s! .O,.*?! ,-.!

0-%4?1.*D!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!#',!)+!"`T`!,)!344!6.1&)*&!(*?.1!

,-.!3/.!)+!"TM!

!

>(1,-.12)1.! %*! %,&!:;;g!<.*.134!0)22.*,!)*!0-%4?1.*Z&!5%/-,&! %*! E(F.*%4.! E(&,%'.D! ,-.!

GX!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!0-%4?!&,1)*/48!1.')22.*?.?!,-3,!,-.!4)B.&,!3/.!+)1!

'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!7.!&.,!3,!"S!)1!"Q!8.31&!3*?!.O61.&&48!(1/.?!R,3,.!_31,%.&!3/3%*&,!

4)B.1%*/!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!,)!":=:H`!!

!

5(4.! S! )+! ,-.! N.%[%*/! 5(4.&! 1.')22.*?&! ,-3,! ,-.! 7./%**%*/! )+! ,-.!@%*%2(2!

#/.!)+!01%2%*34!5.&6)*&%7%4%,8!U@#05V!&-344!*),!7.!+%O.?!3,!,))!4)B!3*!3/.!4.F.4D!

7.31%*/!%*!2%*?!,-.!+3',&!)+!.2),%)*34D!2.*,34!3*?!%*,.44.',(34!23,(1%,8M!W*!4%*.!

B%,-! ,-%&! 1(4.! ,-.! 0)22%,,..! -3&! 1.')22.*?.?! R,3,.&! 631,%.&! *),! ,)! &.,! 3!

@#05! 3,! 3! ,))! 4)B! 4.F.4! 3*?! ,)! %*'1.3&.! ,-.! .O%&,%*/! 4)B! @#05! ,)! 3*!

%*,.1*3,%)*3448! 3''.6,374.! 4.F.4sM! ':*! A3%%<''**! ()@*8! +'&'*! L&)'<*8! #3'! '3!

630*)!':*<)!d"AE!'3!':*!&@*!32!JRI#!-%/-.1!@#05D!+)1!%*&,3*'.!"S!)1!"Q!8.31&!

)+! 3/.D! ')*,1%7(,.&! ,)! 3! [(F.*%4.! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2D! B-%'-! %*! 3'')1?3*'.! B%,-!

#1,%'4.! S;UHVU7V! )+! 050! D! ?.34&! B%,-! '-%4?1.*! %*! ')*+4%',! B%,-! ,-.! 43B! B%,-)(,!

1.&)1,%*/! ,)! [(?%'%34! 61)'..?%*/&D! 61)F%?%*/! ,-3,! ,-.! '-%4?Z&! -(23*! 1%/-,&! 3*?!

4./34!&3+./(31?&!31.!+(448!1.&6.',.?:S;!I.26-3&%&!3??.?J!!

!

A-(&!34,-)(/-!,-.!-(23*!1%/-,&!%*&,1(2.*,&!1.+13%*!+1)2!&6.'%+8%*/!3*!317%,1318!3/.!)+!

'1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8D! %,! '3*! 7.! 3&&(2.?! ,-3,! ,-.! 613',%'.&! )+! (*.K(%F)'3448!

\1.&6)*&%7%4%&%*/Z! 3*?! \3?(4,%+8%*/Z! '-%4?1.*! +1)2! ,-.! 3/.! )+! ":! 8.31&! %&! '4.3148! 3,! )??&!

B%,-!,-.!')1.!61%*'%64.&!(*?.16%**%*/!,-.!\N.%[%*/!5(4.&ZD!,-.!GX0590!3*?!&.F.134!),-.1!

3(,-)1%,3,%F.! &,3,.2.*,&!)+! ! '-%4?1.*Z&!-(23*! 1%/-,&M:S"! A-%&! %&! .&6.'%3448! &)!B-.*!)*.!

7.31&! %*!2%*?! ,-.! .F%?.*'.! ?%&'(&&.?! .314%.1!B-%'-! &,3,.&! ,-3,! ,-.! .2),%)*34D!2.*,34!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:HQ!050i0i"Pi#??M:"Q!3,!6313M!:;M!:Hg!%7%?M!3,!6313M!:"U7VM!:HT!%7%?M!3,!6313M!:"U3VM!:H`!050i0i<0i";D!:;;gD!3,!6313&M!H:!3*?!HH!:S;!%7%?D!3,!6313&MH:!3*?!HH!:S"!R..!+)1!.O3264.D!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!0-%4?!:;;gD!0)(*'%4!)+!p(1)6.!0)22%&&%)*.1!+)1!n(23*!5%/-,&!:;;`D!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!0)*F.*,%)*!3/3%*&,!A)1,(1.!3*?!9,-.1!01(.4D!W*-(23*!)1!$./13?%*/!A1.3,2.*,!)1!_(*%&-2.*,!U"`TSV!

Page 48: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! SQ!

3*?!%*,.44.',(34!23,(1%,8!)+!,-.&.!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!U3/.?!":!3*?!"HV!%&!&)!4)BM!W+!3!

":!8.31!)4?!2(&,!+3'.!,-.!3?(4,!')(1,!61)'.&&!)1!&)2.,-%*/!&%2%431!,)!%,D!%,!'3*!-31?48!7.!

&3%?!,-3,!,-.!%*,.1*3,%)*34!61%*'%64.&!31.!7.%*/!(6-.4?M!!

!

W,!+)44)B&!,-3,!78!4)B.1%*/!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!61)&.'(,%)*D!,-.!#2.*?2.*,!2)F.&!%*!3*!

)66)&%,.!?%1.',%)*! +1)2!,-.! %*,.1*3,%)*34!8)(,-!&,3*?31?&!3*?!61%*'%64.&! ,-3,! ,-.!X.B!

Y.343*?!<)F.1*2.*,!-3&!64.?/.?!,)!%264.2.*,M!#&!3!1.&(4,!,-%&!#2.*?2.*,!238!71%*/!

X.B!Y.343*?!3!?./1..!)+!%*,.1*3,%)*34!?%&1.6(,.!B-%4.!34&)!?323/%*/!)(1!1.6(,3,%)*!3&!

3!*3,%)*!B-%'-!,3L.&!%,&!%*,.1*3,%)*34!-(23*!1%/-,&!)74%/3,%)*&!&.1%)(&48M!

!

$(1%*/!,-.!R.4.',!0)22%,,..!61)'.&&!2('-!'1%,%'%&2!B3&!?%1.',.?!3,!,-.!N%44!?(.!,)!,-.!

%*')*&%&,.*'8! 7.,B..*! ,-.! #2.*?2.*,&! 3*?! ,-.&.! W*,.1*3,%)*34! n(23*! 5%/-,&!

W*&,1(2.*,&M!A-.!1.&6)*&.!1.6.3,.?48!/%F.*!,)!&('-!'1%,%'%&2&!B3&!,-3,!a7.'3(&.!&('-!3!

-%/-! ,-1.&-)4?!-3&! 7..*! &.,D:S:! ,-.! 4)B.1%*/!)+! ,-.! 3/.!)+! '1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! ?).&!

*),!(*?(48!%*'1.3&.!')&,&!)1!(**.'.&&31%48!.O6)&.!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!,)!,-.!'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!

&8&,.2Mb:SH! W*! &6%,.! )+! ,-%&! %,! %&! '4.3148! 3! ')*'.1*! ,-3,! ,-.! 3+)1.2.*,%)*.?! 1%/-,&! -3F.!

7..*!?%&2%&&.?!78!)++%'%34&D!3&!&..*! %*!,-.!.O643*3,)18!*),.!,)!,-.!N%44D!)*!,-.!61.2%&.!

,-3,!)*48!3!+.B!8)(*/!6.)64.!B%44!7.!61)&.'(,.?!(*?.1!,-.2M!A-.!#2.*?2.*,&!?)!*),!

')2648! B%,-! %*,.1*3,%)*34! -(23*! 1%/-,&! &,3*?31?&! %11.&6.',%F.! )+! -)B! 23*8! 8)(*/!

6.)64.!31.!61)&.'(,.?M!!

! !

NIX! !A3#.6(8<3#!!

!

W*! &(22318D! ,-%&! .F%?.*'.! &(//.&,&! ,-3,! 4)B.1%*/! )+! ,-.! 3/.! )+! '1%2%*34! 61)&.'(,%)*!

1.61.&.*,&!3!23[)1! 4./%&43,%F.!+3%4(1.M!A-.!2)&,!&34%.*,!,-1..!1.3&)*&!7.%*/m! %,!?).&!*),!

23,'-!B%,-!&'%.*,%+%'!.F%?.*'.!1./31?%*/!,-.!'363'%,8!)+!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?&!U631,%'(43148!

,-)&.!4%L.48!,)!7.!71)(/-,!7.+)1.!,-.!0)(1,Vm!+(1,-.1D!%,!%&!(*4%L.48!,)!4.3?!,)!3!1.?(',%)*!

%*! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?%*/! 3*?D! +%*3448D! %,! ?).&! *),! ')2648! B%,-! ,-.! %*,.1*3,%)*34!

3/1..2.*,&! 1./31?%*/! ,-.! 1%/-,&! )+! '-%4?1.*! ,)! B-%'-! X.B! Y.343*?! %&! 3! 631,8M! R('-!

.F%?.*'.!3*?!?)'(2.*,&!'4.3148!-3F.!3! 1)4.! ,)!6438! %*! ,-.! 4./%&43,%F.!?.'%&%)*&!)+!X.B!

Y.343*?Z&!<)F.1*2.*,M!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:S:!9++.*'.&!6(*%&-374.!78!3!&.*,.*'.!)+!"S!8.31&!%261%&)*2.*,!)1!2)1.!3*?!1.6.3,!)++.*?%*/!+)1!)++.*'.&!6(*%&-374.!78!";!8.31&!%261%&)*2.*,!)1!2)1.M!!:SH!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!"!F'&%2!M()'(!1*'!E*,+3!>11&+#&'%A!P&3,0)(*'=!?./)5(!M()(&.&+(!UpO.'(,%F.!R(22318D!:;;`V!3,!:!!

Page 49: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! Sg!

$.&6%,.!,-.&.!1.&.1F3,%)*&!%,!%&!1.')/*%&.?!,-3,!,-.!32.*?.?!4./%&43,%)*!-3&!7..*!63&&.?!

3*?! '32.! %*,)! +)1'.! )*! "&,! )+! 9',)7.1! ,-%&! 8.31M:SS! A-.&.! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?.1&! B%44!

7.')2.!3*! %*,./134! 631,!)+! ,-.!X.B!Y.343*?!^)(,-! E(&,%'.! &8&,.2! +)1! ,-.! +)1.&..374.!

+(,(1.M!A-.!*.O,!'-36,.1!3'L*)B4.?/.&!,-%&!3*?!&(//.&,&!4./34!3*?!6)4%'8!'-3*/.&!,)!,-.!

'(11.*,!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!,-3,!'3*!2%,%/3,.!,-.&.!+43B&M!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:SS!$3,.!)+!#&&.*,!e!Q!@31'-!:;";M!!

Page 50: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! ST!

AK"LCDE!_BGE!!

C:*!S&=!_3)0&)1!

!

#&!.F%?.*'.?! %*!'-36,.1! ,-1..!71%*/%*/!":!3*?!"H!8.31!)4?!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&! %*,)!

,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! [(1%&?%',%)*! -3&! 2(4,%64.! +43B&M! >%1&,48! %,! 238! 71%*/! X.B! Y.343*?Z&!

%*,.1*3,%)*34!1.6(,3,%)*!%*,)!?%&1.6(,.m!&.')*?48!%,!%&!4%L.48!,)!+3%4!,)!1.?('.!1.f)++.*?%*/m!

3*?!,-%1?48!&('-!1.?(',%)*!+3%4&!,)!1.')/*%&.!,-.!4%2%,.?!'(4637%4%,8!)+!,-.&.!%*?%F%?(34&M!!

!

A-%&! '-36,.1! &.,&! )(,! ,)! )++.1! &)2.! 613',%'34! &(//.&,%)*&! ,)! ')273,! ,-.&.! 61)74.2&M!

q-%4&,!3*!)7F%)(&!)6,%)*!B)(4?!7.! ,)! 1.6.34! ,-.! 4./%&43,%)*! f! ! ,-%&! %&!(*4%L.48!3*?! ,-(&!

),-.1! 34,.1*3,%F.&!2(&,! 7.! 6(,! +)1B31?M! W*! )1?.1! ,)! &,)6! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! +1)2! +344%*/!

&-)1,!)+!%,&!6),.*,%34!%,!%&!&(//.&,.?!,-3,!_314%32.*,!4./%&43,.!,)!.O63*?!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,Z&!

[(1%&?%',%)*!,)!%*'4(?.!"g!8.31!)4?&D!3*?!34&)!,)!61)F%?.!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!B%,-!&!TH!6)B.1&!

)+! ,-.! >32%48! 0)(1,!B-%'-!B%44! /%F.! ,-.2! ,-.! 37%4%,8! ,)! ?.34! B%,-! '31.! 3*?! 61),.',%)*!

%&&(.&!3,!,-.!1)),!)+!,-.!'-%4?Z&!)++.*?%*/M!>%*3448!,-%&!'-36,.1!B%44!3,,.26,!,)!+)1.&-3?)B!

3!61%*'%64.?!3661)3'-!,)!,-.!&.*,.*'%*/!)+!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!3*?!8)(,-!)++.*?.1&!,3L%*/!%*,)!

3'')(*,!,-.!&'%.*,%+%'!.F%?.*'.!?%&'(&&.?!%*!'-36,.1!,-1..!B%,-!1./31?!,)!,-.!'(4637%4%,8!

)+!,-.!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1M!!

!

XI!J!! "!_()':*)!D`'*#8<3#!32!':*!93(':!A3()'78!;()<81<.'<3#!!

!

A-%&!636.1!1.')22.*?&!,-3,!,-.!1.3'-!)+!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!7.!.O,.*?.?!,)! %*')16)13,.!

"g! 8.31! )4?&! %*,)! %,&! [(1%&?%',%)*MA-.! .O'4(&%)*! )+! "g! 8.31! )4?&! +1)2! ,-.! 0^_>! #',! %&!

%*')*&%&,.*,!B%,-!,-.!?.+%*%,%)*!)+!3!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*!(*?.1!GX0590!B-%'-!?.+%*.&!

3?(4,-))?! 3&! &,31,%*/! 3,! 3! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*&! "T,-! 7%1,-?38M! A-.! GX! 0)22%,,..! -3&!

1.')22.*?.?D!)*!,B)!)''3&%)*&D!,-3,!X.B!Y.343*?!&-)(4?!71%*/!%,&!4./%&43,%)*!%*,)!4%*.!

B%,-! GX0590! 78! 13%&%*/! ,-.! 3/.! ,-3,! 3*! )++.*?.1! '3*! &,38! B%,-%*! ,-.! 0)(1,Z&!

[(1%&?%',%)*:SPM!

!

A-%&! 61)6)&34! %&! *),! *.B! ,)! _314%32.*,M! W*! $.'.27.1! :;;g! ,-.! 0-%4?1.*D! ^)(*/! _.1&)*&! 3*?!

A-.%1!>32%4%.&!#2.*?2.*,!N%44! UX)!QV!B3&! %*,1)?('.?!,)!_314%32.*,!3*?!B3&! 1.,(1*.?!,)! ,-.!

n)(&.!+)44)B%*/!3!1.6)1,!78!,-.!R)'%34!R.1F%'.&!R.4.',!0)22%,,..! %*!#(/(&,!:;;TM!9*.!)+!,-.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:SP!G*%,.?!X3,%)*&!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!0-%4?!:;;H!3*?!:;;g!1.6)1,&!

Page 51: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! S`!

L.8! 32.*?2.*,&! ,-%&! N%44! 61)6)&.?! B3&! ,)! %*'4(?.! "g! 8.31! )4?&! %*! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,!

E(1%&?%',%)*M:SQ!

!

q%,-! ,-.%1! *.B48! %*'1.3&.?! )1?.1&D! &('-! 3&! ,-.! .O,.*?.?! 4.*/,-! )+! &(6.1F%&%)*! )1?.1&! 3*?!

34')-)4!3*?!?1(/!61)/1322.&D!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!%&!*)B!7.,,.1!.K(%66.?!,)!?.34!B%,-!"g!8.31!)4?!

)++.*?.1&m! ,-.1.+)1.! 31/(3748! 23L%*/! %,! ,-.! %?.34! ,%2.! ,)! 23L.! ,-%&! 32.*?2.*,M! A-%&!

32.*?2.*,!238!34&)!')(*,.17343*'.! ,-.! %*,.1*3,%)*34!?%&1.6(,.!X.B!Y.343*?! 1%&L&!B%,-! ,-.!

4)B.1%*/!)+!,-.!3/.!)+!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8D:Sg!3*?!+%*3448!%,!B%44!344)B!+)1!,-)&.!"g!8.31&!,-3,!

'3*!7.!?.34,!B%,-!.++.',%F.48!%*!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!,)!1.23%*!)(,!)+!,-.!3?(4,![(1%&?%',%)*M!

!

A-.!61)6)&.?!%*'4(&%)*!)+!"g!8.31!)4?&!%*!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!B)(4?!71%*/!X.B!Y.343*?!%*,)!

4%*.!B%,-!,-.!GX0590D!3*?!2)&,!)+!,-.!B)14?Z&!),-.1!23[)1!?.2)'13'%.&D!%*'4(?%*/!2)&,!

#(&,134%3*!R,3,.&D!HT!GR!R,3,.&D!03*3?3!3*?!<1.3,!N1%,3%*M!R('-!32.*?2.*,!B)(4?!71%*/!

X.B!Y.343*?!%*,)!.K(%4%71%(2!B%,-!),-.1![(1%&?%',%)*&!3*?!aB)(4?!7.!')*&%&,.*,!B%,-!)(1!

%*,.1*3,%)*34!)74%/3,%)*&bM:ST!W,!%&!X.B!Y.343*?!B-%'-!%&!'4.3148!)(,!)+!&,.6!3,!,-.!61.&.*,M!!

!

A-.!3/.!)+!3?(4,!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!&6.'%+%.?!%*!23*8!),-.1!X.B!Y.343*?!&,3,(,.&!%&!"TM!9*.!

)+!,-.!*),374.!.O'.6,%)*&!%&!(*?.1!&!:;!)+!,-.!o3*?!A13*&6)1,!#',D!B-%'-!344)B&!"P!8.31!

)4?&!,)!-)4?!?1%F.1!4%'.*'.&M!W,!%&!*)!')%*'%?.*'.!,-3,!,-.!2%*%2(2!3/.!)+!?1%F.1!4%'.*&%*/!

%&!34&)!3!+1.K(.*,!,31/.,!+)1!'344&!)+!43B!1.+)12M:S`!A-.1.!31.!3!&%/*%+%'3*,!*(27.1!)+!X.B!

Y.343*?!&,3,(,.&!,-3,!1.&,1%',!3',%F%,%.&!3*?!%*F)4F.2.*,!+)1!,-)&.!(*?.1!"TM!>)1!%*&,3*'.!

3!6.1&)*!'3**),!F),.D!.*4%&,!%*!,-.!2%4%,318!B%,-)(,!')*&.*,D!7(8!34')-)4!3*?!,)73'')!)1!

.*,.1! %*,)!')*,13',&!(*,%4! ,-.8!31.!"TM!_1.&(23748!,-.!73&%&! +)1!,-.&.! 43B&! %&! ,-3,!(*,%4!

"TD! %,! %&! *),! 3661)61%3,.! ,)! ,1.3,! 8)(*/! 6.)64.! 3&! 3?(4,&! 3*?! ,-.8! *..?! /(%?3*'.! 3*?!

61),.',%)*M!A-%&!32.*?2.*,!B)(4?!,-.1.+)1.!7.!6.1+.',48!')*&%&,.*,!B%,-!,-%&!3661)3'-!

B-%'-! %&! 1.+4.',.?! %*!&)!23*8!),-.1!31.3&D!.&&.*,%3448! ,-3,!8)(*/!6.)64.!&-)(4?!*),!7.!

?.34,!B%,-!%*!,-.!3?(4,!')(1,&!(*,%4!,-.8!31.!"TM!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:SQ!0(11.*,48!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!4)&.!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,Z&![(1%&?%',%)*!)*!,-.!?3B*%*/!)+!,-.%1!"g,-!7%1,-?38!!:Sg!!#&!2.*,%)*.?!%*!'-36,.1!,-1..D!X.B!Y.343*?!%&!341.3?8!)(,!)+!+3F)(1!B%,-!,-.!GX!0)22%,,..!)*!,-.!5%/-,&!)+!,-.!0-%4?!?(.!,)!)(1!+3%4(1.!,)!3'')1?!B%,-!,-.!61)F%&%)*&!)+!,-.!GX0590M!X.B!Y.343*?!%&!4%L.48!,)!7.!71)(/-,!%*,)!.F.*!+(1,-.1!%*,.1*3,%)*34!?%&1.6(,.D!3&!B.!31.!*)B!')*+4%',%*/!B%,-!,-.!GX0590!3,!7),-!.*?&!)+!,-.!&6.',1(2M!:ST!$.'.27.1!:;;g!0)(1,!%*!,-.!#',D!^)(,-!0)(1,!X.B&4.,,.1D!E(?/.!N.'1)+,!:S`!o3*?!A13*&6)1,!U5)3?!R3+.,8!3*?!9,-.1!@3,,.1&V!#2.*?2.*,!N%44!f!_314%32.*,=!S`!N%44!*)=!:"Hf"!W*,1)?(',%)*=!"Hi`i";!>%1&,!1.3?%*/=!"Qi`i";!5.+.11.?!,)=!A13*&6)1,!3*?!W*?(&,1%34!5.43,%)*&!0)22%,,..!!

Page 52: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! P;!

0-36,.1! ,-1..! 61)F%?.?! ,-3,! 1.+.1.*'.&! ,)! ?.F.4)62.*,34! &'%.*'.! 31.! (&.+(4! B-.*!

23L%*/! 4./%&43,%F.!?.'%&%)*&! 1./31?%*/! ,-.!?13B%*/!)+! 4%*.&! %*! 1.+.1.*'.! ,)!3/.M!5.'.*,!

1.&.31'-! %*,)! ,-.! ?.F.4)62.*,! )+! ,..*3/.! 713%*&! &(//.&,&! ,-3,! ?.'%&%)*! 23L%*/! 3*?!

')/*%,%F.!+(*',%)*&!?)!*),!+(448!?.F.4)6!(*,%4!3!6.1&)*!1.3'-.&!,-.%1!2%?!,B.*,%.&M:P;!A-%&!

&(//.&,&! ,-3,! "g! 8.31! )4?&! &-)(4?! *),! 7.! %*'4(?.?! %*! 3?(4,! 4./%&43,%)*M! >(1,-.12)1.!

%*'4(?%*/! "g! 8.31! )4?&! %*! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! [(1%&?%',%)*! .O,.*?&! ,-.! &8&,.2Z&! 37%4%,8! ,)!

36648! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.! &)4(,%)*&! ,)! ,-%&! /1)(6! )+! )++.*?.1&! 3*?! ,-.%1! +32%4%.&D! 3*?! ,)!

61)2),.!2.3*%*/+(4!3*?!4)*/!43&,%*/!3'')(*,37%4%,8M:P"!R('-!'-3*/.!B)(4?!34&)!13?%'3448!

%*'1.3&.! ,-.! )66)1,(*%,%.&! +)1! ?%F.1,%*/! 4.&&! &.1%)(&! "g! 8.31! )4?! )++.*?.1&! )(,! )+! ,-.!

'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!&8&,.2D!B-%'-!-3&!7..*!(&.?!,)!&('-!/1.3,!.++.',!78!_)4%'.!^)(,-!#%?!+)1!

"S! ]! "Q! 8.31! )4?&M:P:! A-%&!B)(4?! 34&)!-.46! ,)! 1.?('.! ,-.! &)! '344.?! a6%6.4%*.b! .++.',! 78!

1.&,1%',%*/! ,-.! .*,18! )+! 3! "g! 8.31! )4?! %*,)! ,-.! +)1234! '1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2M:PH!

>(1,-.12)1.!,-.!3??%,%)*34!)1?.1&!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!-3&!1.'.%F.?D:PS!61)F%?.!2)1.!37%4%,8!

+)1!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!E(?/.!,)!-)4?!,-.!)4?.1!8)(,-!3'')(*,374.!+)1!,-.%1!)++.*?%*/D!B-%4&,!

34&)!L..6%*/!,-.2!3B38!+1)2!,-.!*./3,%F.!.++.',&!)+!.*,.1%*/!,-.!3?(4,![(1%&?%',%)*M!!

!

W,!&-)(4?!34&)!7.!.26-3&%&.?!,-3,!6(74%'!')*'.1*!,-3,!%*'4(?%*/!"g!8.31!)4?&!B%,-%*!,-.!

8)(,-! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2! B%44! 1.&(4,! %*! 3! a&)+,! 3661)3'-b! +)1! "g! 8.31! )4?&D! %&! %44! +)(*?.?M!

R.',%)*! SU+VU%V)+! ,-.! 0^_>! #',! ?%1.',&! ,-.! 0)(1,! 3*?! 344! %*F)4F.?! %*! ,-.! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.!

&8&,.2!,)!.*&(1.!,-3,!8)(*/!6.)64.!31.!-.4?!3'')(*,374.!3*?!31.!.*')(13/.?!,)!3''.6,!

1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!+)1!,-.%1!7.-3F%)(1M!!W,!%&!')11.',!,-3,!"g!8.31!)4?&!B)(4?!7.!.*,%,4.?!,)!,-.!

&32.!61),.',%)*&!3*?!61)'.?(134! &3+./(31?&!3&!31.!'(11.*,48!.*[)8.?! +)1!"S!]!"Q!8.31!

)4?&!%+!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,Z&![(1%&?%',%)*!B.1.!,)!7.!.O,.*?.?!,)!%*'4(?.!,-.2M!n)B.F.1D!%*!

)*.!'1('%34!1.&6.',D!"g!8.31!)4?&!B%44!7.!,1.3,.?!?%++.1.*,48!,)!"S!]!"Q!8.31!)4?&M!R.',%)*!

"T! )+! ,-.! R.*,.*'%*/! #',! :;;:! 61)-%7%,&! %261%&)*2.*,! 7.%*/! %26)&.?! )*! ,-)&.! B-)!

)++.*?! 3&! (*?.1! "g! 8.31! )4?&! +)1! 344! 7(,! 6(1.48! %*?%',374.! )++.*'.&M! R.4+f.F%?.*,48D! ,-%&!

1.&,1%',%)*!B)(4?!*),!36648! ,)!)++.*'.&!')22%,,.?!78!"g!8.31!)4?&M!A-(&D!"g!8.31!)4?&!

B-)!')22%,!&.1%)(&!)1!6.1&%&,.*,!*)*f6(1.48!%*?%',374.!)++.*'.&D!B)(4?!&,%44!7.!4%374.!,)!

%261%&)*2.*,! [(&,! 3&! ,-.8! 31.!*)BD! ,-1)(/-! ,-.!)6.13,%)*!)+! &:THU)V! )+! ,-.!0^_>!#',!

B-%'-!344)B&!,-.!0)(1,!,)!')*F%',!3*?!,13*&+.1!,-.!8)(*/!6.1&)*!,)!,-.!$%&,1%',!0)(1,!+)1!

&.*,.*'.M! ! W*!1.&6)*&.!,)!')22.*,318!B-%'-!&(//.&,&!,-3,!%*'1.3&%*/!,-.!3/.!)+!^)(,-!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:P;!?%&'(&&.?!%*!2)1.!?.6,-!3,!0-36,.1!HM"!!:P"!A-1)(/-!&('-!)6,%)*&!3&!,-.!>32%48!<1)(6!0)*+.1.*'.!!:P:!@%*%&,18!)+!E(&,%'.!G2$0#!)+#!E*,(2!>11&+#$+3!M()($%($5%!$+!O&7!R&)0)+#A!XYYZ!W!ZVV[!U@%*%&,18!)+!E(&,%'.D!#61%4!:;";VM!!:PH!#&!?%&'(&&.?!%*!0-36,.1!HM:!!:PS!_31.*,%*/!)1?.1&D!')(*&.4%*/D!34')-)4!3*?!?1(/!1.-37%4%,3,%)*!61)/1322.&D!4)*/.1!&(6.1F%&%)*!.,'M!

Page 53: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! P"!

0)(1,![(1%&?%',%)*!,)!"T!B%44!2.3*!,-3,!"g!8.31!)4?&!B%44!*),!7.!-.4?!,)!3'')(*,!+)1!,-.%1!

)++.*?%*/D!E(?/.!N.'1)+,!-3&!&3%?!,-3,!,-.&.!%?.3&!31.!a(*-.46+(4D!2%&4.3?%*/D!%*3''(13,.!

3*?![(&,!643%*!B1)*/bM:PP!!

!

!#*!31,%'4.! %*! a0)(1,! %*! ,-.!#',b:PQ! +1)2!E3*(318!:;;`!&(2231%&.&! ,-.!B)1L!)+!5%'-31?!

5.??%*/!3*?!%&!.*,%,4.?!aE(F.*%4.!A13*&+.1!o3B&=!#*!p++.',%F.!$.,.11.*,!,)!$.4%*K(.*'8kb!

W*!&(22318!5.??%*/Z&!1.F%.B!)+!&%O!431/.!&'34.!&,(?%.&!+)(*?!-%/-.1!1.'%?%F%&2!13,.&!+)1!

8)(*/! )++.*?.1&! ,13*&+.11.?! ,)! ,-.! #?(4,! 0)(1,! ,-3*! +)1! ,-)&.! 1.,3%*.?! %*! ,-.! ^)(,-!

0)(1,M! A-.! 31,%'4.! /).&! )*! ,)! ?.&'1%7.! %*! ?.,3%4! ,-.! 1.3&)*&!B-8! 8)(,-! ,1%.?! 3&! 3?(4,&!

-3F.!-%/-.1!1.'%?%F%&2!13,.&M:PgD!:PT!!

!

#44! ,-.! 3+)1.2.*,%)*.?! ?%&'(&&%)*! 61)F%?.&! &(66)1,! +)1! ,-%&! 4./%&43,%F.! 32.*?2.*,! ,)!

,-.! [(1%&?%',%)*! )+! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,M! W*,.1.&,%*/48! ,-%&! N%44! B3&! 1.%*&,3,.?! %*! ,-.! S`,-!

_314%32.*,! 3*?! %&! ,-(&! &,%44! ,.'-*%'3448! )*! ,-.! <)F.1*2.*,Z&! 4./%&43,%F.! 3/.*?3D! 7(,! %&!

'(11.*,48!&,344.?!B%,-!,-.!R)'%34!R.1F%'.&!R.4.',!0)22%,,..M:P`!A-%&!4.3F.&!,-.!6)&&%7%4%,8!

)+!&('-!4./%&43,%F.!32.*?2.*,!3&!3!/.*(%*.!)6,%)*D!3F3%4374.!,)!,-.!<)F.1*2.*,!)+!,-.!

?38M!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:PP!$.'.27.1!:;;g!0)(1,!%*!,-.!#',D!^)(,-!0)(1,!X.B&4.,,.1D!E(?/.!N.'1)+,!:PQ!$.'.27.1!:;;g!0)(1,!%*!,-.!#',D!^)(,-!0)(1,!X.B&4.,,.1D!E(?/.!N.'1)+,!:Pg!5%'-31?!5.??%*/!U:;;gV!E(F.*%4.!A13*&+.1!o3B&=!#*!p++.',%F.!$.,.11.*,!,)!?.4%*K(.*'8k!]!0)(1,!%*!,-.!#',D!^)(,-!0)(1,!X.B&4.,,.1!:PT!C)&#82*)!6&08!13!#3'!630*)!=3(':!.)<%*!"`T;&!E.*&.*!3*?!@.,&/.1!U"``SVM!A%2.f&.1%.&!3*348&%&!+)1!"`gQ!,)!"`TQ!+)(*?!"Hw!%*'1.3&.!%*!311.&,!+)1!"Sf"T!8.31!)4?&!%*!W?3-)!3+,.1!,-3,!&,3,.!%*,1)?('.?!%,&!,13*&+.1!43B!%*!"`T"MR,.%*.1!3*?!q1%/-,!U:;;QV!@(4,%f!&,3,.!U"SVM!A%2.f&.1%.&!"`gPf:;;;M!A13*&+.1!43B&!-3?!*)!/.*.134!?.,.11.*,!.++.',M!"H!.%,-.1!%*'1.3&.?!)1!&,38.?!&32.M!@%'-%/3*!?.'1.3&.?M!C)&#82*)!6&08!:&V*!#3!*22*.'!

R%*/.1!3*?!@'$)B344!U"`TTV!%*!,%2.!&.1%.&! 3*348&%&D! X.B! ^!)1L! *)! ?.,.11.*,!.++.',!)*!8)(,-!'1%2.!"`gSf"`TSM!o..!3*?!@'0318!U:;;PV!%*!>4)1%?3M!^_!?%?!*),!4)B.1!,-.%1!)++.*?%*/!13,.&!(6)*!,(1*%*/!"T!U3?(4,!&3*',%)*&!*),!3!?.,.11.*,VM!F*'*))*#.*!

A-.!+)44)B%*/!&,(?%.&!.O32%*.?!,-.!%*'1.3&.!%*!1.'%?%F%&2!+)1!^_!,13*&+.11.?!,)!3?(4,!')(1,&!')2631.?!,)!8)(,-!')(1,&=!>3/3*! U"``QV!.O32%*.?! T;;! ^!9!'-31/.?!B%,-!7(1/4318!"`T"fT:M!`"w!1.'%?%F%&2!')2631.?!gHw!%*!^0M!N%&-)6!U"``QV!')2631.?!"!8.31!1.'%?%F%&2!13,.!)+!:DgHT!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!%*!>4)1%?3M!5.311.&,!13,.&!B.1.!-%/-.1!32)*/!,13*&+.11.?!8)(,-!U;MPS!F.1&(&!;MH:VM!A-.!3F.13/.!,%2.!,)!1.)++.*?%*/!B3&!&-)1,.1!34&)!U"HP!F.1&(&!::g!?38&[email protected]&!U:;;"D!:;;HV!.O32%*.?!"T!2)*,-!1.'%?%F%&2!)+!S`S!8)(*/!)++.*?.1&!%*!_.**&84F3*%3!%*!"``SM!A13*&+.11.?!8)(,-!B.1.!:!,%2.&!2)1.!4%L.48!,)!7.!1.311.&,.?!3*?!,)!1.)++.*?M!9EE$_!+(*?.?!&,(?%.&M!o3*j3fL3?('.!3*?!')44.3/(.&!U:;;PV=!`P;!8)(*/!3?(4,!)++.*?.1&!&,(?%.?M!n34+!-3?!7..*!,13*&+.11.?!3*?!-34+!')22%,,.?!%*!3!^)(,-!0)(1,M!9F.1344!)++.*'.&!]!S`w!)+!,13*&+.11.?!)++.*?.1&!1.)++.*?.?!')2631.?!,)!HPw!)+!,-)&.!1.,3%*.?!%*!3!8)(,-!')(1,M!:P`!0-%4?1.*!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!#2.*?2.*,!N%44!UX)!QV!

Page 54: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! P:!

XIR!! C)&#82*)! 32! _&%<6=! A3()'78! A&)*! &#1! L)3'*.'<3#!B)1*)8! '3! ':*! 93(':!

A3()'!

!

A-%&!636.1!-3&!31/(.?!,-3,!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!%&!*),!,-.!')11.',![(1%&?%',%)*!+)1!":!3*?!"H!

8.31! )4?&! 61%231%48! 7.'3(&.! ,-.8! &-)(4?! *),! 7.! -.4?! '1%2%*3448! 1.&6)*&%74.! +)1! ,-.%1!

3',%)*&D!)*!,-.!73&%&!,-3,!,-.!1)),!'3(&.&!)+!,-.%1!)++.*?%*/!31.!4%L.48!,)!7.!)+!3!'31.!3*?!

61),.',%)*!)1%/%*M:Q;!A-.!)++.*?%*/!%&!F%.B.?!3&!&8&,.2%'!)+!,-.!.*F%1)*2.*,!,-.!'-%4?!%&!

'(11.*,48! 4%F%*/! %*! 13,-.1! ,-3*! 7.%*/! +)'(&.?! )*! ,-.! %*?%F%?(34M! A-(&! ?.34%*/! B%,-! ,-.!

'-%4?!)++.*?.1!%*!3!'1%2%*34![(1%&?%',%)*D!347.%,!3![(F.*%4.!)*.D!%&! %*3661)61%3,.!,)!1.+4.',!

,-.!4%2%,.?!'(4637%4%,8!)*!,-.%1!7.-34+M! W,! %&!34&)!4%L.48!,)!7.!%*.++.',%F.!3,!1.?('%*/!,-.%1!

1.f)++.*?%*/! 78! +3%4%*/! ,)! ?.34!B%,-! ,-.! 1.34! '3(&.&! )+! ,-%&! &.1%)(&! )++.*?%*/M! A-.! +.B!

.F34(3,%)*&! )+! 61)/1322.&! ,-3,! +)'(&! )*! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?.1&! &-)B! ,-3,! ,)! 7.!

&(''.&&+(4!B%,-!1.-37%4%,3,%*/!,-.2!B)1L!2(&,!)1%/%*3,.!B%,-!,-.%1!+32%4%.&!3*?!61)74.2&!

61.&.*,!%*!,-.%1!(671%*/%*/M:Q"!

!

0-36,.1! ,B)!)+! ,-%&!636.1!?%&'(&&.?! ,-.!'4.31! 4%*.!?13B*! %*! ,-.!0^_>!#',!7.,B..*!,-.!

&.6313,.![(1%&?%',%)*&!)+!,-.!>32%48!0)(1,!3*?!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,M!R('-!&,1%',!?.4%*.3,%)*!%&!

.&&.*,%34! ,)!.*&(1.!,-3,!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*! %&&(.&!31.!*),! ,)!7.!6(1&(.?! %*! ,-.!8)(,-!

[(&,%'.!+)1(2M:Q:!A-.1.!%&!3!&,1)*/!.26-3&%&!3/3%*&,!B.4+31%&%*/!,-.!1.&6)*&.!,)!3*8!+)12!

)+! )++.*?%*/M:QH! X)B! ,-3,! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! )++.*?.1&! -3F.! 7..*! 71)(/-,! %*,)! ,-.! ^)(,-!

0)(1,Z&![(1%&?%',%)*!31/(3748!,-.!4%*.!7.,B..*!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!%&&(.&!3*?!)++.*?%*/!

7.-3F%)(1!-3&!341.3?8!7..*!74(11.?M!!

!

A-.! %&&(.! ,-.*! 7.')2.&! -)B! %&! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! ,)! ?.34! B%,-! &('-! )++.*?.1&! %+! ,-.!

3F3%4374.!&.*,.*'%*/!)6,%)*&!,-.!0)(1,!-3&!'3**),!3??1.&&!,-.!73&%&!)+!,-.!)++.*?%*/!]!

.&&.*,%3448! ,-3,! )+! ,-.%1! .*F%1)*2.*,M! $(1%*/! ,-.! R.4.',! 0)22%,,..! 61)'.&&! ,-.! ^)(,-!

0)(1,! .O61.&&.?! ,-.%1! 3661.-.*&%)*! ,-3,! ,-.8! aI?)J! *),! -3F.! ,-.! *.'.&&318!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:Q;!R..!'-36,.1!,B)!+)1!+(1,-.1!?%&'(&&%)*!)*!,-%&M!!:Q"!0!X..!aA-.!9++.*?.1v&!_.1&6.',%F.!9*!01%2.=!@.,-)?&!3*?!_1%*'%64.&!%*!$3,3!0)44.',%)*b!%*!#!X..?&!3*?!<!A)B4!U.?&V!"//0=$+3!N%=52*0*3=!(*!F*'&+%$5!N')5($5&M!UN_R!N43'LB.44D!o)*?)*D!:;;SV!3,!`"!!:Q:!R:;TU7V!0^_>!#',!!:QH!A-.!.&,374%&-2.*,!)+!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!(*?.14%*.&!,-.!%26)1,3*'.!)+!,-.!61%*'%64.!,-3,!,-.!)++.*?%*/!)+!8)(*/!6.)64.!&-)(4?!7.!61.2%&.?!)*!'1%2%*34![(&,%'.!*),!B.4+31.!61%*'%64.&m!,-3,!%&D!)*!*),%)*&!)+!3'')(*,37%4%,8!3*?!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!+)1!3',%)*&D!?(.!61)'.&&D!4./34!1.61.&.*,3,%)*D!1.K(%1%*/![(?/.&!,)!/%F.!1.3&)*&!+)1!'.1,3%*!?.'%&%)*&D!3*?!%26)&%*/!&3*',%)*&!B-%'-!31.!61)6)1,%)*3,.!,)!,-.!/13F%,8!)+!,-.!)++.*'.M!

Page 55: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! PH!

\322(*%,%)*Z! ,)! ?.34! B%,-! ,-.! %*.F%,374.! '31.! 3*?! 61),.',%)*! %&&(.&! 3,! ,-.! 1)),! )+!

)++.*?%*/bM:QS!

!

#&!2.*,%)*.?!37)F.D!,-.!0^_>!#',!61)F%?.&!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!B%,-!3!13*/.!)+!\&.*,.*'%*/Z!

)6,%)*&! 1.+.11.?! ,)! 3&! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! )1?.1&D! %*'4(?%*/!4)B.1! ,31%++! )1?.1&! &('-! 3&!

3?2)*%&-2.*,D! +%*.&D! 1.6313,%)*! 3*?! 1.&,%,(,%)*M!! n%/-.1! ,31%++! )1?.1&! 31.! &(6.1F%&%)*D!

')22(*%,8! B)1LD! &(6.1F%&%)*! B%,-! 3',%F%,8! 3*?! &(6.1F%&%)*! B%,-! 1.&%?.*'.M!! A-.!

&(6.1F%&%)*!B%,-!1.&%?.*'.!)1?.1!%&!,-.!&)4.!'(&,)?%34!)1?.1!3F3%4374.!,)!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,M!

#44!)+!,-.&.!)1?.1&!61)F%?.!+)1!&-)1,!,.12!%*,.1F.*,%)*&!3%2.?!3,!6(1&(%*/!,-.!?(34!/)34!

)+! ,-.! ^)(,-! E(&,%'.! 61%*'%64.&! ]!23L%*/! ,-.! )++.*?.1! 3'')(*,374.! +)1! ,-.%1! )++.*?%*/!

B-%4&,! 6(1&(%*/! ,-.%1! 1.-37%4%,3,%)*M! X)*.! )+! ,-.&.! -)B.F.1D! 61)F%?.! +)1! ,-.! 37%4%,8! ,)!

%*,.1F.*.!%*!,-.!+32%48!4%+.!)+!,-.!'-%4?M!!

!

A-.!>32%48!0)(1,!)*!,-.!),-.1!-3*?!B-.*!?.34%*/!B%,-!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!-3&!3!2('-!B%?.1!

31138!)+!)1?.1&!3*?!1.&6)*&.&!%,!'3*!23L.M!>)1!%*&,3*'.D!,-.!>32%48!0)(1,!-3&!6)B.1&!,)!

23L.! '(&,)?8! 3*?! /(31?%3*&-%6! )1?.1&D:QP! 3*?! 34&)! ')(*&.4%*/! )1?.1&D! %*! 1.&6.',! )+!

631.*,&D! /(31?%3*&! 3*?! 3*8! 6.1&)*!B-)! %&!23?.! ,-.! &(7[.',! )+! 3! 1.&,13%*%*/! )1?.1! %*!

1.&6.',! )+! ,-3,! '-%4?M:QQ! R.1F%'.! )1?.1&! ,)! 61)F%?.! &.1F%'.&! ,)! ,-.! '-%4?! )1! ,-.! 6.1&)*!

'31%*/! +)1! ,-.! '-%4?D:Qg! 3*?! &(66)1,! )1?.1&D! B-%'-! '3*! 7.! )1?.1.?! ,)! 2)*%,)1! ,-.!

&,3*?31?!)+!'31.!7..*!/%F.*!,)!,-.!'-%4?D!'3*!34&)!7.!23?.M:QTR('-!)1?.1&D!%*!631,%'(431D!

,-.!61.&.*'.!)+!3!>32%48!0)(1,!'(&,)?8!)1?.1!31.!)+,.*!6%F),34!+)1!3!&(''.&&+(4!)(,')2.!

+)1! ,-.!'-%4?!)++.*?.1! %*F)4F.?M:Q`!pF%?.*'.! %*?%'3,.&! ,-3,! ,-.! ,86.!)+! &(66)1,!/%F.*! ,)!

'31./%F.1&! B-.*! '-%4?1.*! 7.')2.! &.1%)(&! )++.*?.1&! %&! '1('%34! %+! ,-.&.! '-%4?1.*! 31.! ,)!

1.?('.!,-.%1!)++.*?%*/M:g;!#4&)!,-.!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!1.&6)*&.!'3*!')*,%*(.!4)*/!3+,.1!

,-.!*..?!+)1!,-.![(&,%'.!1.&6)*?!-3&!.*?.?M!!

!

A-.! 23[)1%,8! )+! ,-.&.! 6)B.1&! 31.! 61)F%?.?! ,)! ,-.! >32%48! 0)(1,! ,-1)(/-! &! TH! )+! ,-.!

0-%4?1.*! ^)(*/! _.1&)*&! 3*?! A-.%1! >32%4%.&! #',! "`T`M:g"! A-%&! 636.1! &(//.&,&! ,-3,! ,-.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:QS!&..!37)F.!*!:;Q!!:QP!R.',%)*!";"!0^_>!#',!!:QQ!R.',%)*!TH!0^_>!#',!:Qg!R.',%)*!TQ!0^_>!#',!:QT!R.',%)*!`"!0^_>!#',!:Q`!@'o31.*D!d!E*,(2!>11&+#$+3!I&).%A!J2)(!S*&%+^(!J*'@!(*!P&#,5&!>11&+#$+3!-=!E*,+3!N&*/0&!U@%*%&,18!)+!E(&,%'.D!:P!E3*(318!:;;PV!-,,6=iiBBBM[(&,%'.M/)F,M*ji6)4%'8f3*?f')*&(4,3,%)*i8)(,-i.f+43&-.&ipf+43&-w:;"`M6?+!!:g;!5)7.1,&)*D!$!U:;;`Vm!>.1/(&&)*D!$M!U:;;`V!%*[email protected]!U:;;`V!)6!'%,M!RWJ

!+!^N!B)1*)8!32!.3()'!3#!%&/<#@!32!1*.6&)&'<3#!

Page 56: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! PS!

\322(*%,%)*Z! %*! &! TH! &-)(4?! 7.! 61)F%?.?! ,)! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! ,)! .*374.! ,-.2! ,)!23L.!

%*,.1F.*,%)*&!%*,)!,-.!'-%4?Z&!+32%4%34!4%+.!B-.1.!*.'.&&318M!!

!

q-%4&,! ')*+.11%*/! >32%48! 0)(1,! 6)B.1&! )*! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! %&! 4%L.48! ,)! 74(1! ,-.%1!

[(1%&?%',%)*&D!%,!%&!')*,.*?.?!,-3,!,-%&!-3&!341.3?8!7..*!?)*.!78!71%*/%*/!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!

3'1)&&!,)!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,M!9*.!)+!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!61%*'%64.&!)+!,-.!#',!%&!,-3,!'1%2%*34!

61)'..?%*/&!&-)(4?!*),!7.!(&.?!&)4.48!,)!3??1.&&!B.4+31.!')*'.1*&M:g:!R.',%)*!:TSU:V!)+!

,-.!0^_>!#',!61.F.*,&! ,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,! +1)2!23L%*/!3!&(6.1F%&%)*!)1?.1D!3!')22(*%,8!

B)1L! )1?.1D! 3! &(6.1F%&%)*! B%,-! 3',%F%,8! )1?.1D! )1! 3! &(6.1F%&%)*! B%,-! 1.&%?.*'.! )1?.1D!

2.1.48! 7.'3(&.! ,-.! 0)(1,! ')*&%?.1&! ,-3,! ,-.! 8)(*/! 6.1&)*! %&! %*! *..?! )+! '31.! 3*?!

61),.',%)*M!W,!%&!31/(374.!-)B.F.1!,-3,!,-%&!*.'.&&%,3,.&!,-.!*..?!+)1!34,.1*3,%F.!)1?.1&!

,-3,!?)!*),!')*&%/*!'1%2%*34!&3*',%)*&!)*!,-.!'-%4?!)++.*?.1!B-.*!,-.!')*'.1*&!3&!,)!,-.!

'3(&.&!)+!,-.%1!)++.*?%*/!31.!)+!3!B.4+31.!*3,(1.M!!A-.!/)34!-.1.!B)(4?!*),!7.!3'-%.F.?!

78!36648%*/!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!&)4(,%)*&!,)!'1%2%*)/.*%'! %&&(.&!U)1!F%'.!F.1&3VD!7(,!78!

(&%*/! ,-.! 3661)61%3,.! 631,&! )+! ,-.! #',! ,)! 3??1.&&! ,-.! %&&(.&! ,-.8! B.1.! ?.&%/*.?! ,)!

3??1.&&!U-.1.!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!61)F%&%)*&!e!3??1.&&%*/!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!%&&(.&VM!!

!

#&!341.3?8!&,3,.?D! '1%2.! 1.?(',%)*!61)/1322.&! +)1!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&!31.!/.*.13448!2)1.!

.++.',%F.!B-.*!,-.8!%*F)4F.!,-.!+32%48!3*?!B-3*3(D!631,%'(43148!B-.1.!3*!3*348&%&!)+!,-.!

)++.*?.1&Z!1%&L&!+3',)1&!%*?%'3,.&!,-3,!,-.1.!%&!3!*..?!,)!%261)F.!+32%48!')22(*%'3,%)*!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!U"V!q-.1.!,-.!')(1,!23L.&!3!?.'4313,%)*!(*?.1!&.',%)*!Qg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

! ,-.!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*=!! U%%V!3*8!631.*,!)1!/(31?%3*!)1!),-.1!6.1&)*!-3F%*/!,-.!'31.!)+!,-.!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*=!! U%%%V!3*8!6.1&)*!%*!1.&6.',!)+!B-)&.!')*?(',!3!1.&,13%*%*/!)1?.1!)1!3*!%*,.1%2!1.&,13%*%*/!

)1?.1!B3&!&)(/-,!)1!23?.!%*!,-.!61)'..?%*/&=!U?V!23L.!3!&.1F%'.&!)1?.1!(*?.1!&.',%)*!TQ=!U.V!23L.!3!1.&,13%*%*/!)1?.1!(*?.1!&.',%)*!Tg=!U+V!23L.!3!&(66)1,!)1?.1!(*?.1!&.',%)*!`"=!U/V!23L.!3!'(&,)?8!)1?.1!(*?.1!&.',%)*!";"=!U-V!23L.!3*!)1?.1!(*?.1!&.',%)*!"";!366)%*,%*/!3!/(31?%3*!)+!,-.!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*M!

U:V!q-.1.!,-.!')(1,!23L.&!3*!)1?.1!(*?.1!&(7&.',%)*!U"VU'VD!&.',%)*&!gS!,)!gg!&-344!36648D!B%,-!344!*.'.&&318!2)?%+%'3,%)*&D!B%,-!1.&6.',!,)!,-3,!)1?.1!3&!%+!%,!B.1.!3!?%1.',%)*!23?.!(*?.1!&.',%)*!gSU"VM!0)2631.=!"`gS!X)!g:!&!H"U"VU7VD!U'VD!U?VD!U-Vm!"`TH!X)!":`!&!gU"V!

:g:!R.',%)*!:;TU7V!0^_>!#',!"`T`!!

Page 57: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! PP!

)1! ?8*32%'&M! _1)/1322.&! B-%'-! 61)F%?.! 631.*,%*/! ,13%*%*/! -3F.! 61)F.*! ,)! 7.!

.++.',%F.M:gHA-.! 1.'.*,! #2.*?2.*,&! 61)F%?.! +)1! ,-.! %*,1)?(',%)*! )+! 631.*,%*/! )1?.1&!

B-%'-!31.!'4.3148!3%2.?!3,!3??1.&&%*/!,-.!'3(&.&!)+!,-.!'-%4?Z&!)++.*?%*/M:gS!W+!'1%,%'%&2&!

B.1.!6)%*,.?!3,!,13*&+.11%*/!,-.!6)B.1&!)+!&!TH!,)!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!?(.!,)!,-%&!74(11%*/!

,-.!&.6313,.![(1%&?%',%)*&D!%,!')(4?!7.!31/(.?!,-3,!,-%&!-3&!341.3?8!7..*!?)*.!78!344)B%*/!

631.*,%*/!)1?.1&!,)!.*,.1!,-.!0)(1,Z&!31138!)+!)6,%)*&!]!'4.3148!3%2.?!3,!,-.!B.4+31.!)+!

,-.!)++.*?.1M!!

!

_31.*,%*/!)1?.1&!)*!,-.%1!)B*!-)B.F.1D!31.!4%L.48!,)!7.!%*&(++%'%.*,!,)!?.34!B%,-!,-.!'31.!

3*?!61),.',%)*!%&&(.&!,-3,!31.!61.&.*,!%*!,-.!23[)1%,8!)+!,-.&.!&.1%)(&!'-%4?!)++.*?.1&M:gP!

A-.! 6)B.1&! /%F.*! %*! &! TH! )*! ,-.! ),-.1! -3*?! 31.! 2('-! 2)1.! .O,.*&%F.! 3*?! .*374.!

')261.-.*&%F.!%*,.1F.*,%)*!%*,)!,-.!'-%4?Z&!4%+.!B-.*!*.'.&&318M:gQ!#??%,%)*3448!23*8!)+!

,-.!E(?/.&!B-)!&%,!)*!,-.!^)(,-!0)(1,!34&)!-3F.!.O6.1%.*'.!%*!,-.!>32%48!0)(1,!3*?!,-(&!

31.!4%L.48!,)!-3F.!.O6.1%.*'.!%*!?.'%?%*/!B-.*!&('-!)1?.1&!31.!3661)61%3,.M!!

!

$.&6%,.! ,-.!-%&,)18!)+!7)(*?318! %&&(.&!7.,B..*!'31.!3*?!61),.',%)*!3*?!8)(,-! [(&,%'.!

B%,-%*! ,-.! 0^_>! #',D! %,! %&! &(72%,,.?! ,-3,! %,!23L.&! *)! &.*&.! +)1! ,-.! >32%48! 0)(1,! 3*?!

^)(,-!0)(1,!,)!?.34!%*!%&)43,%)*!B%,-!,-.!&32.!8)(*/!6.1&)*!B-)&.!)++.*?%*/!3*?!'31.!

3*?!61),.',%)*!*..?&!31.!%*,%23,.48!3*?!%*,1%'3,.48!1.43,.?M:gg!!

!

R('-! ,13*&+.1! )+! 4./%&43,%F.! 6)B.1!B)(4?! -3F.! ,)! 7.! ?)*.! 78! ,-.!2.3*&! )+! 4./%&43,%F.!

32.*?2.*,M! A-%&! ')(4?! 7.! ?)*.! 78! .%,-.1! .O,.*?%*/! _31,! ,B)! )+! ,-.! 0^_>! #',! B-%'-!

/)F.1*&! ,-.! '31.! 3*?! 61),.',%)*! )+! 8)(*/! 6.)64.! ,)! %*'4(?.! ,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! )1!

34,.1*3,%F.48!78!1.64%'3,%*/!,-.!&,3,(,)18!6)B.1&!%*!&!TH!,)!7.!%*'4(?.?!%*!,-.!_31,!>)(1!)+!

,-.!#',!B-%'-!/)F.1*&!^)(,-!E(&,%'.M!<3%*%*/!6)B.1&!(*?.1!&!TH!B)(4?!34&)!1.K(%1.!,-3,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:gH!$!>311%*/,)*!U:;;HV!a$.F.4)62.*,34!3*?!4%+.f')(1&.!'1%2%*)4)/8=!d.8!,-.)1.,%'34!3*?!.26%1%'34!%&&(.&b!S"!01%2%*)4)/8!3,!"SP!:gS!&..!37)F.!*!T;!!:gP!@%*%&,18!)+!R)'%34!$.F.4)62.*,!"!F'&%2!M()'(!1*'!E*,+3!>11&+#&'%A!P&3,0)(*'=!?./)5(!M()(&.&+(!UpO.'(,%F.!R(22318D!:;;`VM!:gQ!031.!3*?!61),.',%)*!61)'..?%*/&!%*!1.&6.',!)+!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.!B-)!31.D!)1!B-)!31.!4%L.48!,)!7.!-312.?D!37(&.?!)1!*./4.',.?!34&)!.*')263&&!'%1'(2&,3*'.&!B-.*!,-.1.!%&!&.1%)(&!')*'.1*!+)1!,-.!B.447.%*/!)+!3!'-%4?!3/.?!";!]!"H!8.31&!3&!3!1.&(4,!)+!,-.!*(27.1D!*3,(1.!)1!23/*%,(?.!)+!)++.*'.&!344./.?!,)!-3F.!7..*!')22%,,.?!78!,-3,!'-%4?M!!:gg!!E(?/.!>%,j/.134?Z&!W*,.*&%F.!@)*%,)1%*/!<1)(6!0)(1,!%*!#('L43*?!0%,8!%&!3*!.O'.44.*,!.O3264.!)+!-)B!3!')4437)13,%F.!3661)3'-!'3*!7.*.+%,!7),-!,-.!^)(*/!6.1&)*!3*?!,-.!F31%)(&!3/.*'%.&!'-31/.?!B%,-!-%&!)1!-.1!'31.M!!

Page 58: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! PQ!

,-.! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! ,)! 7.! /%F.*! ,-.! 37%4%,8! (*?.1! &! Qg! )+! ,-.! #',! ,)!23L.!/1)(*?&! +)1! 3!

?.'4313,%)*!,-3,!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*!%&!%*!*..?!)+!'31.!)1!61),.',%)*M:gT!

!

XIN!! -)<#@<#@!+.<*#'<2<.!DV<1*#.*!<#'3!+*#'*#.<#@!a!"!b(&6<'&'<V*6=!1<22*)*#'!

&,,)3&.:!

!

>%*3448D! ,-%&!636.1!&(//.&,&! ,-3,!3!K(34%,3,%F.48!?%++.1.*,!3661)3'-!,)! ,-.!&.*,.*'%*/!)+!

'-%4?!3*?!8)(,-!)++.*?.1&! %*! ,-.!3?(4,! ')(1,&! %&!*.'.&&318M! R('-!3! &.*,.*'.!B)(4?!(&.!

&'%.*,%+%'!.F%?.*'.!,)!,3%4)1!,-.!&.*,.*'.!,)!1.+4.',!,-.!?.F.4)62.*,34!%223,(1%,8!)+!,-.!

8)(*/!)++.*?.1!%*!')2631%&)*!,)!,-.%1!3?(4,!')(*,.1631,&M!!

!

A-.!/.*.134!61%*'%64.&!1.43,%*/!,)!&.*,.*'%*/!8)(*/!6.)64.! %*!,-.!3?(4,!')(1,&!31.!*)B!

.27)?%.?!%*!,-.!0)(1,!)+!#66.34!?.'%&%)*!N*,72)'&!<!PB!:g`!N*,72)'&!')*'4(?.?!,-3,=!

o ^)(,-! E(&,%'.! 61%*'%64.&! ?)! *),! 36648! ,)! 8)(*/! 6.)64.! &.*,.*'.?! %*! 3*!

3?(4,!')(1,m!

o #?(4,! ')(1,! ,31%++! '3&.&! ?)! 36648! B-.*! &.,,%*/! &,31,%*/! 6)%*,&! +)1!

&.*,.*'%*/!8)(*/!6.)64.!%*!3*!3?(4,!')(1,m!3*?!

o A-.1.! %&! *)! 4%2%,! ,)! ,-.! ?%&')(*,! ,-3,! '3*! 7.! /%F.*! +)1! 3/.! (*?.1! ,-.!

R.*,.*'%*/!#',M:T;!!

!

A-%&! 3661)3'-!B3&! '4.3148!23*?3,.?!78! ,-.!B)1?%*/!)+! ,-.! 1.4.F3*,! 4./%&43,%)*M:T"! A-.!

')27%*.?!.++.',!)+! ,-.!37)F.!61%*'%64.&!B)(4?!61)73748!-3F.!23?.! 4%,,4.!?%++.1.*'.!,)!

,-.! .*?! 1.&(4,! +)1! 2)&,! 8)(*/! 6.)64.! &.*,.*'.?! %*! ,-.! 3?(4,! ')(1,! %11.&6.',%F.! )+!

B-.,-.1!,-.!0)(1,!-3?!,3L.*!,-.!?%++.1.*,!3661)3'-!&(//.&,.?!78!,-.!?.+.*'.!,)!36648!

,-.!0^_>!#',M!

!

X.F.1,-.4.&&D! %,! B3&! 6.1-36&! ?%&366)%*,%*/! ,-3,! ,-.! )66)1,(*%,8! B3&! *),! ,3L.*! 78!

?.+.*'.!')(*&.4!,)!%*,1)?('.!,-.!2)&,!1.'.*,!.F%?.*'.!1./31?%*/!713%*!?.F.4)62.*,!3,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:gT!&\W!Y)3(#18!23)!1*.6&)&'<3#!':&'!.:<61!3)!=3(#@!,*)83#!<8!<#!#**1!32!.&)*!3)!,)3'*.'<3##!')(1,!238D!)*!3664%'3,%)*D!B-.1.!%,!%&!&3,%&+%.?!)*!3*8!)+!,-.!/1)(*?&!&6.'%+%.?!%*!&.',%)*!"SU"V!,-3,!3!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*!%&!%*!*..?!)+!'31.!)1!61),.',%)*D!23L.!3!?.'4313,%)*!,-3,!,-.!'-%4?!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*!%&!%*!*..?!)+!'31.!)1!61),.',%)*M!:g`!P!<!N*,72)'&!I:;";J!!XY0#!:QT!:T;!>)1!2)1.!%*+)!&..!'-36,.1!,B)!)*!&.*,.*'%*/!:T"!A-.!0)(1,!-.4?!,-3,!,-.!R.*,.*'%*/!#',!3*348&%&!B)(4?!7.!1.*?.1.?!%*')-.1.*,!%+!%,&!6(16)&.&D!61%*'%64.&D!3*?!3//13F3,%*/!3*?!2%,%/3,%*/!+3',)1&!?%?!*),!.++.',%F.48!?%&643'.!!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&.*,.*'%*/!61%*'%64.&!%*!&:;T!)+!,-.!0^_>!#',M!!

Page 59: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! Pg!

,-.! &.*,.*'%*/! &,3/.M:T:! W,! %&! &(72%,,.?! ,-3,! %+! ,-%&! .F%?.*'.! -3?! 7..*! %*,1)?('.?D! 3!

?%++.1.*,! 3*?! 61%*'%64.?! 3661)3'-! ')(4?! -3F.! 6)&&%748! 7..*! +)1.&-3?)B.?! +)1! 8)(*/!

6.)64.! +3'%*/! '-31/.&! +)1! &.1%)(&! )++.*?%*/M! A-.1.! B3&! 3,! 4.3&,! 3*! )66)1,(*%,8D! .F.*!

/%F.*! ,-.! '(11.*,! 4./%&43,%)*D! ,)! ')*&%?.1! B-.,-.1! 3! &(7&,3*,%3448! ?%++.1.*,! 3661)3'-!

')(4?!7.!,3L.*!+)1!&.1%)(&!8)(,-!)++.*?.1&!,)!,1.3,!,-.2!3&!'-%4?1.*!)1!8)(*/!6.1&)*&!

13,-.1! ,-3*! [(*%)1!3?(4,&M! R('-!3*!3661)3'-!B)(4?!*),!*.'.&&%,3,.!3?-.1.*'.! ,)!3?(4,!

,31%++! &,31,%*/! 6)%*,&! 3*?! B)(4?! /%F.! ,-.! ')(1,&! +4.O%7%4%,8! ,)! ?%&6.*&.! B%,-! 3*! 3?(4,!

&,31,%*/! 6)%*,! 3*?! ,)! ,3%4)1! ,-.! &.*,.*'.! ,)! ,-.! ?.F.4)62.*,34! 4.F.4! )+! ,-.! 8)(*/!

)++.*?.1M!!

!

5.'.*,! ?.'%&%)*&! )+! ,-.! R(61.2.! 0)(1,! )+! ,-.! G*%,.?! R,3,.&! -3F.! (&.?! &'%.*,%+%'!

.F%?.*'.!1./31?%*/!713%*!?.F.4)62.*,!,)!61)F%?.!+)1!3!K(34%,3,%F.48!?%++.1.*,!3661)3'-!

,)!&.*,.*'%*/!+)1![(F.*%4.&!?(.!,)!,-.%1!(*%K(.!?.F.4)62.*,34!23,(1%,8M!W*!%,&!43*?231L!

:;;P! ?.'%&%)*! P*/&'! <! M$..*+%Q!B-%'-! 37)4%&-.?! ,-.! [(F.*%4.! ?.3,-! 6.*34,8D! ,-.! GR!

R(61.2.! 0)(1,! -.4?! ,-3,! ,-.! %*-.1.*,! %223,(1%,8! )+! 3?)4.&'.*,&! 1.43,%F.&! ,)! 3?(4,&!

2%,%/3,.?!,..*3/.1&Z!'1%2%*34!1.&6)*&%7%4%,8!,)!,-.!.O,.*,!,-3,!%,!7311.?!,-.!%26)&%,%)*!)+!

'36%,34! 6(*%&-2.*,! +)1! '1%2.&! ')22%,,.?! (*?.1! ,-.! 3/.! )+! "TD! 1./31?4.&&! )+! ,-.%1!

-.%*)(&*.&&M:TH!

!

#4,-)(/-! ,-.! R(61.2.!0)(1,Z&! ?.'%&%)*! %*!P*/&'! <! M$..*+%Z[_!?%?! *),! &6.'%+%'3448! '%,.!

3*8! ?.F.4)62.*,34! *.(1)&'%.*'.D! &.F.134! )+! ,-.! 32%'(&! '(1%3.! 71%.+&! &(72%,,.?! %*! ,-.!

'3&.D!%*'4(?%*/!,-3,!)+!,-.!#2.1%'3*!_&8'-)4)/%'34!#&&)'%3,%)*!U:;;SVD!?1.B!,-.![(&,%'.&Z!

3,,.*,%)*!,)!,-3,!7)?8!)+!1.&.31'-D!&,3,%*/=:TP!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:T:!0-36,.1!,-1..!'4.3148!.&,374%&-.?!,-3,!8)(*/!6.)64.!31.!*),![(*%)1!3?(4,&=!?.F.4)62.*,3448!,-.8!31.!231L.?48!2)1.!%223,(1.M!!:TH!o!R,.%*7.1/D!37)F.!*"P"D!3,!PTH!:TS!P*/&'!<!M$..*+%!!PSH!GR!U:;;PV!:TP!%7%?!aq-8!?)!3?)4.&'.*,&!&-)B!?%++.1.*'.&!+1)2!3?(4,&!B%,-!1.&6.',!,)!1%&Lf,3L%*/D!643**%*/D!%*-%7%,%*/!%26(4&.&D!3*?!/.*.13,%*/!34,.1*3,%F.&k!5.'.*,!1.&.31'-!&(//.&,&!3!7%)4)/%'34!?%2.*&%)*!,)!3?)4.&'.*,!7.-3F%)(134!%223,(1%,8=!,-.!-(23*!713%*!?).&!*),!&.,,4.!%*,)!%,&!23,(1.D!3?(4,!+)12!(*,%4!3+,.1!,-.!3?)4.&'.*,!8.31&!-3F.!63&&.?!3*?!3!6.1&)*!-3&!.*,.1.?!8)(*/!3?(4,-))?s!)+!631,%'(431!%*,.1.&,!B%,-!1./31?!,)!?.'%&%)*!23L%*/!3*?!'1%2%*34!'(4637%4%,8!%&!,-.!?.F.4)62.*,!)+!,-.!+1)*,34!4)7.&!)+!,-.!713%*M!A-.!+1)*,34!4)7.&D!.&6.'%3448!,-.!61.+1)*,34!')1,.OD!6438!3!'1%,%'34!1)4.!%*!,-.!.O.'(,%F.!)1!a0p9b!+(*',%)*&!)+!,-.!713%*!B-%'-!31.!')*&%?.1.?!,-.!-%/-.1!+(*',%)*&!)+!,-.!713%*s!,-.8!31.!%*F)4F.?!B-.*!3*!%*?%F%?(34!643*&!3*?!%264.2.*,&!/)34f?%1.',.?!7.-3F%)(1&!78!&.4.',%*/D!'))1?%*3,%*/D!3*?!36648%*/!,-.!')/*%,%F.!&L%44&!*.'.&&318!,)!3'')264%&-!,-.!/)34sM!X.(1)?.F.4)62.*,!@5W!&,(?%.&!%*?%'3,.!,-%&!.O.'(,%F.!31.!)+!,-.!713%*!%&!)*.!)+!,-.!43&,!631,&!)+!,-.!713%*!,)!1.3'-!23,(1%,8B!!

Page 60: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! PT!

aq-.*!')2631.?!,)!3*!3?(4,!2(1?.1.?D!3![(F.*%4.!)++.*?.1!B-)!?%?!*),!

L%44!)1! %*,.*?! ,)!L%44!-3&!3! ,B%'.!?%2%*%&-.?!2)134! '(4637%4%,8M!A-.!3/.!)+!

,-.!)++.*?.1!3*?!,-.!*3,(1.!)+!,-.!'1%2.!.3'-!7.31!)*!,-.!3*348&%&Mb!UPQ;!

GR!3,!"TV!!

!

$.F.4)62.*,34!&'%.*'.!B3&!34&)!+1)*,!3*?!'.*,1.!%*!3*),-.1!GR!R(61.2.!0)(1,!?.'%&%)*!

+1)2!,-%&!8.31D!]')2).!<!F0*'$#)M:TQ!A-.!R(61.2.!0)(1,!1(4.?!,-3,![(F.*%4.&!B-)!')22%,!

'1%2.&! %*! B-%'-! *)! )*! %&! L%44.?! 238! *),! 7.! &.*,.*'.?! ,)! 4%+.! %*! 61%&)*! B%,-)(,! ,-.!

6)&&%7%4%,8!)+!631)4.M!A-.!0)(1,Z&!1(4%*/D!B-%'-!?1.B!.O,.*&%F.48!)*!3*!32%'(&!'(1%3.!71%.+!

&(72%,,.?! 78! ,-.! #2.1%'3*! _&8'-)4)/%'34! #&&)'%3,%)*! B3&! %*+)12.?! 78! 3! 1.'.*,!

&(22318!)+!1.4.F3*,!1.&.31'-!)*!6&8'-)4)/%'34!?.F.4)62.*,!?(1%*/!3?)4.&'.*'.M!:Tg!A-.!

GR!R(61.2.!0)(1,!23?.!,-.&.!')22.*,&=!

!

a$.F.4)62.*,&! %*!6&8'-)4)/8!3*?!713%*!&'%.*'.!')*,%*(.!,)!&-)B!+(*?32.*,34!

?%++.1.*'.&!7.,B..*![(F.*%4.!3*?!3?(4,!2%*?&M!UPQ;!GR!3,!"gV!!U32%'(&!'(1%3.!"Q!

]!:S!C!::!]!:gVb!

!

A-.&.! 1.'.*,! ?.'%&%)*&! %*! ,-.!GR! R(61.2.!0)(1,:TT! 1.%*+)1'.! ,-.! ')*F%',%)*! ,-3,! 713%*!

&'%.*'.!.F%?.*'.! %&! 1.4.F3*,! ,)!?.34%*/!B%,-!'-%4?1.*!3*?!8)(*/!6.)64.! %*!0)(1,M! W*!3*!

31,%'4.! 6(74%&-.?! %*! ,-.! E)(1*34! )+! #?)4.&'.*,! 5.&.31'-! 43,.! 43&,! 8.31D! $.o%&%! .,! 34!

?.&'1%7.?!,-.!?.'%&%)*!%*!P*/&'!<!M$..*+%Q!B-%'-!1(4.?!,-3,!,-.!?.3,-!6.*34,8!')(4?!*),!

7.!3664%.?!,)!8)(*/!6.)64.!(*?.1!,-.!3/.!)+!"T!U+)1!1.3&)*&!%*'4(?%*/!,-.%1!*),!8.,!+(448!

?.F.4)6.?! 3*?! 23,(1.! 713%*! 3*?! 6.1&)*34%,8VD! 3&! a71.3,-,3L%*/48! 61)/1.&&%F.Mb:T`! A-.!

X.B!Y.343*?!')(1,&!&-)(4?!,18!3*?!L..6!(6!B%,-!&('-!61)/1.&&%F.!61.'.?.*,M!!

!

A-.!R.*,.*'%*/!#',!'(11.*,48!344)B&!+)1!3/.!,)!7.!71)(/-,!%*!3&!3!2%,%/3,%*/!+3',)1!%*!,-.!

R.*,.*'%*/!_1)'.&&!(*?.1!&`U:VU3VD!3*?!%,!%&!&..*!3&!3!+3',)1!)+!')*&%?.1374.!%26)1,3*'.!

B-.*!?.,.12%*%*/!3*!3661)61%3,.!&.*,.*'.M:`;!A-.!0)(1,&!-3F.!-.4?!,-3,!a8)(,-!34)*.!

?).&!*),!3(,)23,%'3448! [(&,%+8! 4.*%.*'8Db:`"!7(,! %,! %&!3!-%/-48!1.4.F3*,!')*&%?.13,%)*!3*?!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:TQ!]')2).!<!F0*'$#)!PQ;!GR!U:;";VM!!:Tg!#1.!3?)4.&'.*,&!4.&&!23,(1.!,-3*!#?(4,&k!R,.%*7.1/!6/!6/!PTH!! a$.F.4)62.*,&!%*!6&8'-)4)/8!3*?!713%*!&'%.*'.!')*,%*(.!,)!&-)B!+(*?32.*,34!?%++.1.*'.&!7.,B..*![(F.*%4.!3*?!3?(4,!2%*?&M!UPQ;!GR!3,!"gV!!U32%'(&!'(1%3.!"Q!]!:S!C!::!]!:gV!:TT!P*/&'!<!M$..*+%!U:;;PV!PSH!GMRM!PP"m!]')2).!<!F0*'$#)!U:;";V!PQ;!GRM!:T`!@D!$.o%&%M!3*?!),-.1&!aX3,(1.!3*?!X(1,(1.!78!$.+%*%,%)*[email protected]*&!N),-=!#!5.&6)*&.!,)!@34.&b!U:;";V!I:SJ!:PU"V!E)(1*34!)+!#?)4.&'.*,!5.&.31'-M!:`;!P!<!",()3)<)$)!I"`TPJ!"!XYo5!H`T!U0#V!:`"!P!<!"55,%&#!U0#!:QPiTTVm!I"`T`J!"!XYo5!QSH!U0#V!N%&&)*!ED!3,!QPP!]!!

Page 61: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! P`!

,-.! 8)(*/.1! ,-.! )++.*?.1! ,-.! 2)1.! &%/*%+%'3*,! 7.')2.&! ,-.! 1.4.F3*'.! )+! 3/.M:`:! W,! %&!

')*,.*?.?!-)B.F.1D!,-3,!,-%&!%&!&,%44!%*&(++%'%.*,!,)!,3L.!%*,)!3'')(*,!,-.!?.F.4)62.*,34!

%223,(1%,8! )+! 23*8! &.1%)(&! '-%4?! 3*?! 8)(,-! )++.*?.1&! B-.*! ,-.8! .*,.1! ,-.! 3?(4,!

'1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! &8&,.2M!q%,-! ,-.!*.B!#2.*?2.*,! '-%4?1.*!3&! 8)(*/!3&!":!238!.*,.1!

,-.! 3?(4,! [(1%&?%',%)*D! 347.%,! %,! )*! 3*! .O,1.2.48! 4%2%,.?! 73&%&M! A-.&.! '-%4?1.*! 238! %*!

3',(34! +3',!7.!.F.*!2)1.!?.F.4)62.*,3448!8)(*/!?(.!,)! 4)B.1! %*,.44.',(34!'3637%4%,%.&D!

43'L!)+!&'-))4%*/!3*?!2.*,34!3*?!6-8&%'34!?%&37%4%,%.&M!A-.!0)(1,!)+!#66.34!-3&!&3%?!,-3,!

aB-3,! &.*,.*'.! %&!61)6.1! %*! ,86.!3*?! %*! 4.*/,-! %&!*),!')*&,13%*.?!78!3*8!6.1'.*,3/.Mb!

n)B.F.1D! 1.&.31'-! &-)B&! ,-3,! 3! 1.?(',%)*! )+! (6! ,)! Q;! )1! g;! 6.1'.*,! -3&! *.F.1! 7..*!

')(*,.*3*'.?!)*!366.34!7.+)1.!%*!X.B!Y.343*?!')(1,&M!A-(&!B-%4&,!&('-!1.?(',%)*!%&!*),!

61.'4(?.?D!%,!%&!(*4%L.48!,)!7.!/%F.*M!!

!!

9*.!,.'-*%K(.!+)1!/(%?%*/![(?%'%34!?%&'1.,%)*!%*!,-.!&.31'-!+)1!(*%+)12%,8!)+!3661)3'-!,)!

&.*,.*'%*/! %&! ,-.! /(%?.4%*.! [(?/.2.*,M! R('-! [(?/2.*,&! )+,.*! &.,! &,31,%*/! 6)%*,&! )1!

7.*'-231L&!78!&'-.?(4%*/!6.*34,%.&! %26)&.?! %*!61.F%)(&!?.'%&%)*&!)+! ,-.!0)(1,M!A-.&.!

73*?&!3*?!&,31,%*/!6)%*,&!,-.*!/(%?.!&.*,.*'%*/!%*!+(,(1.!'3&.&M!W,!%&!&(72%,,.?!,-3,!&('-!

/(%?.4%*.&!31.!%*3661)61%3,.!+)1!23*8!8)(,-!)++.*?.1&!B-)!31.!+(*?32.*,3448!?%++.1.*,!

,)!,-.%1!3?(4,!')(*,.1631,&!%*!,.12&!)+!,-.%1!4.F.4!)+!'(4637%4%,8M!!

!

E(?/.! N.'1)+,! &,3,.?! %*! ,-.! $%&,1%',! 0)(1,! -.31%*/! )+! ,-3,! ^)(,-! 0)(1,! E(?/.&! )*!

,13*&+.11%*/!)++.*?.1&!,)!,-.!#?(4,!0)(1,&!-3F.!aB3*,I.?J!2('-!2)1.!+4.O%7%4%,8!,-3*!3!

,31%++! 3661)3'-! '3*! 344)BD! .&6.'%3448! ,)! ,3L.! %*,)! 3'')(*,D! %223,(1%,8D! B-3,! %&! '344.?!

\?.F.4)62.*,34!43/ZD!3*?!,)!&%/*%+%'3*,48!1.?('.!,-.!6.1%)?&!)+!%261%&)*2.*,!,-3,!B)(4?!

),-.1B%&.!36648Mb!!

!

W*! ,-.! $%&,1%',! 0)(1,! )1! n%/-! 0)(1,D! (*?.1! ,-.! R.*,.*'%*/! #',D! ,-.! E(?/.! %&! )74%/.?! ,)!

7./%*!B%,-!,-.!)++.*'.!%*!%,&!)7[.',%F.!&.1%)(&*.&&!3*?!)*48!,-.*!4))L!,)!,-.!)++.*?.1M:`H!

W,! %&! ')*,.*?.?! %*! ,-.! '3&.! )+! 3! '-%4?! )1! 8)(,-! )++.*?.1D! ,-.! +)'(&! &-)(4?! 7.! )*! +%1&,!

3&'.1,3%*%*/! ,-.%1! 4.F.4! )+! ?.F.4)62.*,34! 23,(1%,8D! ,-.! +)'(&! 7.%*/! )*! ,-.!

?.F.4)62.*,34! 3/.! )+! ,-.! )++.*?.1! 3*?! ,-.%1! 37%4%,8! ,)! ')261.-.*?! ,-.%1! '1%2%*34!

3',%)*&M!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:`:!P!<!G!U0#!HH:i`PD!:T!R.6,.27.1!"``PD!5%'-31?&)*D!A-)16!3*?!q%44%32&)*!EEV!I"``Hf"``PJ!N0o$!:"Q"M!:`H!P!<!I),&@$!I:;;PJ!H!XYo5!Hg:!U0#V!

Page 62: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! Q;!

A-(&! 3! *.B! 3661)3'-! ')(4?! 7.! ?.F.4)6.?! 78! ,-.! 0)(1,&! )F.1,%2.M! R('-! 3*! 3661)3'-!

B)(4?!&,31,!+1)2!,-.!61.2%&.!,-3,!,-.!8)(,-!%&!+(*?32.*,3448!?.F.4)62.*,3448!?%++.1.*,!

3*?!,-(&!*),!7)(*?!78!3?(4,!&,31,%*/!6)%*,&!3*?!,-.!61)'.&&!&.,!)(,!%*!I),&@$M! ! W*&,.3?!

)*'.! .F%?.*'.! %&! &(72%,,.?! 78! ')(*&.4! 1./31?%*/! ,-.! 4)B! ?.F.4)62.*,34! 4.F.4! )+! ,-.!

?.+.*?3*,! %,! B)(4?! 7.! 4.+,! ,)! ,-.! [(?/.&! ?%&'1.,%)*! ,)! ?.631,! +1)2! .&,374%&-.?!

/(%?.4%*.&M!A-.!?.F.4)62.*,34! %223,(1%,8!)+! ,-.!)++.*?.1!B)(4?!-3F.! ,)!7.!&-)B*!,)!

*.'.&&%,3,.! 3! ?.631,(1.! +1)2! ,-.! 73*?&! &(//.&,.?! ,-(&! 61)F%?%*/! 1))2! +)1! %*?%F%?(34!

'%1'(2&,3*'.&! )+! ,-.! 8)(,-i'-%4?! )++.*?.1! ,)! 7.! 3'')(*,.?! +)1M! G4,%23,.48! ,-.! ')(1,&!

a-3F.! 431/.!2.3&(1.!)+!?%&'1.,%)*! %*!?.,.12%*%*/! &.*,.*'.&! %*! %*?%F%?(34! '3&.&b:`S!3*?!

,-(&! ?.631,(1.! +1)2! /(%?.4%*.! [(?/2.*,&! B-.*! ,-.%1! (&.! %+! &..*! 3&! %*3661)61%3,.! %&!

6)&&%74.M!

!5.34! '-344.*/.&!B)(4?!.O%&,! +)1! ')(*&.4! 3*?! [(?/.&!B%&-%*/! ,)!71%*/!713%*! &'%.*'.! %*,)!

,-.%1! 0)(1,! B)1L! B%,-! %*,./1%,8! 3*?! %*,.44%/.*'.M! 5.34%&,%'3448D! %,! %&! %26)&&%74.! ,)! +(448!

.O64)1.!344! ,-.! %*,.1')**.',%*/D!.*F%1)*2.*,34D!7.-3F%)(134!3*?!?.F.4)62.*,34! +3',)1&!

,-3,!')*,1%7(,.!,)!,-.!6%',(1.!)+!3!8)(*/!6.1&)*Z&!'(4637%4%,8M!n)B.F.1D!,1.3,%*/!8)(*/!

)++.*?.1&!%*!3!aK(34%,3,%F.48!?%++.1.*,!B38b!%*!)1?.1!,)!1.+4.',!,-.!GX0590D!13,-.1!,-3*!

3&!a[(*%)1!3?(4,&b!B%,-!3!/1.3,.1!?%&')(*,! +)1!8)(,-!7.%*/! +3',)1.?! %*,)!,-.!&.*,.*'%*/!

61)'.&&!%&D!%*!28!F%.BD!,-.!2)1.!&3,%&+3',)18!3661)3'-M!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:`S!!

Page 63: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

! Q"!

AB4AUG+$B4!

!

A-%&!636.1!-3&! %*&%&,.?! ,-3,! ,1.3,2.*,!)+! '-%4?!3*?!8)(,-!)++.*?.1&!2(&,!7.!73&.?!)*!

+(*?32.*,34! 61%*'%64.&! &('-! 3&! ,-)&.! +)(*?! %*! ,-.!GX0590M! A-.! &.,,%*/!)+! ,-.! 3/.!)+!

'1%2%*34! 1.&6)*&%7%4%,8! 2(&,! 3,,.26,! ,)! 3''(13,.48! 1.+4.',! 1.&.31'-! &(11)(*?%*/! ,-.!

4%2%,.?! '(4637%4%,8!)+! ,-.!)++.*?.1!B-%4&,! .*&(1%*/! ,-3,! .*,13*'.! %*,)! ,-.! 8)(,-! [(&,%'.!

&8&,.2!)''(1&!B-.*!%,!'3*!61)F%?.!,3*/%74.!)(,')2.&M!!

!

W,! %&!*.F.1!.3&8! ,)!3*&B.1! ,-.!a-31?!K(.&,%)*&b! %*! 1.43,%)*! ,)!8)(,-! [(&,%'.!7(,D!3,! ,-.!

F.18! 4.3&,D!3!61%*'%64.?!&8&,.2!&-)(4?!.O-%7%,! ,B)!L.8! +.3,(1.&M!>%1&,48D! '-%4?1.*!&-)(4?!

7.!?.34,!B%,-!%*!3!?%&,%*',!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2!,-3,!%&!K(34%,3,%F.48!?%++.1.*,!,)!%,&!3?(4,!

'1%2%*34! [(&,%'.! ')(*,.1631,! %*! 7),-! ,1.3,2.*,! 3*?! &.*,.*'%*/! %*! )1?.1! ,)! ,3L.! %*,)!

3'')(*,! ,-.! %*-.1.*,! %223,(1%,8! )+! ,-.! 8)(*/! )++.*?.1M! A-%&! ?%&,%*',! &8&,.2! &-)(4?!

(6-)4?! ,-.! 1%/-,&! )+! '-%4?1.*! 78! &..L%*/! ,)! 3?-.1.! ,)! ,-.! 61%*'%64.&! +)(*?! %*!

%*,.1*3,%)*34! %*&,1(2.*,&M!#*?!&.')*?48D!8)(,-! [(&,%'.!61)+.&&%)*34&!3*?!6)4%'8!23L.1&!

&-)(4?! 1.23%*! ')/*%&3*,! )+! 1.4.F3*,! 1.&.31'-! %*,)! '-%4?! )++.*?%*/! 3*?!6&8'-)4)/8! 3*?!

,3%4)1!,-.%1!&8&,.2&!3*?!4./%&43,%)*!,)!3'')22)?3,.!,-.!&6.'%+%'!*..?&!)+!'-%4?1.*M!

!

q-%4&,! ,-.1.! %&! 3! 643'.! +)1! 3! 6(*%,%F.! 1.&6)*&.! 3*?! ,-.! &3+.,8! )+! ,-.! 6(74%'! 2(&,! 7.!

63132)(*,D!,-.!'-%4?!)++.*?.1!2(&,!34&)!7.!?.34,!B%,-!%*!3!61%*'%64.?!23**.1M!0-%4?1.*!

%*!')*+4%',!B%,-!,-.! 43B!&,3*?!3,!3!'1)&&1)3?&!]!,-.8!31.!.%,-.1!,)2)11)BZ&! 43Bf37%?%*/!

'%,%j.*&D! )1! ,)2)11)BZ&! &.1%)(&! )++.*?.1&M! W*! 23*8! '3&.&D! B-%'-! 1)3?! ,-.8! ,3L.! %&!

?.,.12%*.?!78!,-.!8)(,-![(&,%'.!&8&,.2M!A-.!0-%4?1.*D!^)(*/!_.1&)*&!3*?!A-.%1!>32%4%.&!

#',! "`T`! %&! 3! 43*?231L! %*!X.B! Y.343*?Z&! ,1.3,2.*,! )+! 8)(*/! )++.*?.1&M!X.B! Y.343*?!

&-)(4?!1.&%&,!3*8!2)1.!2)F.&!,)!&.,!,-.!'4)'L!73'LM!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Page 64: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

!"#

$%$&%'()*+,-#

!"#$%"&'()*"+,('

-,.'/,%0%-1'

0,2#(0%3#)-'

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:6#;52#</403#=;>0104:#*?@#ABCBD#

./0123456# -7859# +43:75:6# ;52# </403# =;>0104:# E-78@/# .783@:# F830:20?@075# ;52# '3243:G#

*>452>45@#*?@#"HAHD#

.30>4:#*?@#AB!AD#

I45@45?059#*?@#"HH"D##

4#00('

./012345#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#*>452>45@#$011#"HHJ#EK7#!G#EACLM"G#

&;52#<3;5:N73@#E)7;2#I;O4@P#;52#'@/43#Q;@@43:G#*>452>45@#$011#"HAH#E"ALMAGD#

-7859#'OO45243:#EI43078:#.30>4:G#$011#"HH!#E"CMAG#

5%-(%"1'

EAC#=4R#"HHBG#!S"#KT+U#AVVHD##

EAH#=4R#"HAHG#!!H#KT+U#CJJJD##

E"L#=4R#"HAHG#!!H#KT+U#BLVAD##

+%(,'0%.'

!"#$%&'()*)+#W"HAHX#KT.*#"!CD#

!"#$%&'()*)+#,.#Y;59;5806#.)%#"HAHMVCLMAA6#A!#*N301#"HAHD#

+)*),--#.(/#WABCBX#A#KT&)#!VL#E.*G#D#

+)*),#0&1&*2&#WABCSX#A#KT&)#LBC#E.*GD##

+)*)3#WABBAX#KT.*#LA"D##

Page 65: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

!L#

+)*)3#WABBSX#KT.*#LL"D#

+)*)4".&5#U.#Y411059@75#.)%M"HHBM"CLMSB6#AB#K7Z4>R43#"HHBD##

+)*)67&/()8)9'.)W"HHSX#"#KT&)#S"!#E.*GD#

+)*):&#(;2)W"HHSX#L#KT&)#LJ"#E.*GD#

(,0,+3'+)$$#33,,'(*4$#((#)-('

*2Z45@834#U4Z417N>45@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

*2Z0:73P#(378N#75#.7528?@#+37R14>:#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#

75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@##

*1?7/71#U389#*::7?0;@075#K4]#T4;1;52#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#

75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

*7@4;37;#K4]#T4;1;52#*::7?0;@075#7O#I7?0;1#Y73^43:#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#

I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#

F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

*:/@756#F82P#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#

+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

$;35;27:#K4]#T4;1;52#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#

-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#

$011\D#

./;>N0756#)7R05#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#

-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#

$011\D#

./012345_:#.7>>0::07543#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

Page 66: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

!V#

.7>>850@P#*1?7/71#;52#U389#I43Z0?4:#-78@/#<4;>#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#

.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#

;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

.7>>850@P#$;:42#I4`8;1#'OO45243#<34;@>45@#I4?@73#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#

I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#

F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

.752436#F8;50@;#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#

+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

aZ71Z4#M#Y411059@75#-78@/#I43Z0?4:#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#

@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

a`N43@#*2Z0:73P#(378N#.7528?@#+37R14>:#7O#@/4#Q050:@304:#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@6#

,4;1@/#;52#a28?;@075#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#

-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#

$011\D#

=;>0104:#.7>>0::075#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#

-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#

$011\D#

=;>0104:6#./012345#;52#*220?@075:#<38:@#Eb05;#<38:@G#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#

.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#

;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

=;>01P#+1;55059#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#

+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

=7852;@075#O73#-78@/#U4Z417N>45@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#

@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

(7]6#&052;#.1050?;1#+:P?/71790:@6#)49075;1#-78@/#=7345:0?#I43Z0?4#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#

I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#

.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

Page 67: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

!S#

,45]772#<38:@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#

+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

,8>;5#)09/@:#.7>>0::075#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

b;830#.45@34#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#

+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

&49;1#*2Z0:73P#.7>>0@@44#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

&82R377^6#)7R43@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#

-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#

$011\D#

Q;/0;#Q;0#;#Y/;0#<;3;#<38:@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

Q;`]4116#(;R3041146#I45073#*::7?0;@46#%5:@0@8@4#7O#+710?P#I@8204:6#c0?@730;#d50Z43:0@P#7O#

Y411059@75#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#

+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011#\D#

Q45@;1#,4;1@/#.7>>0::075#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

K;@075;1#.7>>0@@44#O73#*220?@075#<34;@>45@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#

.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#

;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

K;@075;1#.785?01#7O#Y7>45#7O#K4]#T4;1;52#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#

.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#

;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

Page 68: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

!!#

K4]#T4;1;52#*7@4;37;#*2714:?45@#,4;1@/#;52#U4Z417N>45@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#

I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#

.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

K4]#T4;1;52#.785?01#7O#./30:@0;5#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#

.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#

;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

K4]#T4;1;52#U389#=7852;@075#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

K4]#T4;1;52#=4243;@075#7O#$8:054::#;52#+37O4::075;1#Y7>45#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#

I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#

.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

K4]#T4;1;52#&;]#I7?04@P#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

K4]#T4;1;52#K83:4:#*::7?0;@075#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

K4]#T4;1;52#+710?4#*::7?0;@075#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

K4]#T4;1;52#+:P?/71790?;1#I7?04@P#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#

@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

K4]#T4;1;52#-7859#&;R783#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

Page 69: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

!J#

+34>043#-78@/#<3;05059#&0>0@42#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

)4@/05^059#.30>4#;52#+850:/>45@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#

@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

I78@/1;52#-78@/#'OO452059#<4;>#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#

@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

<;3;]/0@0#.7>>850@P#&;]#<38:@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

<4#'3;#,;8#*7@4;37;#%5?#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

</4#.711;R73;@0Z4#O73#)4:4;3?/#;52#<3;05059#05#-78@/#,4;1@/#;52#U4Z417N>45@#<38:@#

[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#

</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

</4#)4109078:#I7?04@P#7O#=30452:#Ee8;^43:G#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#

.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#

;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

</4#-78@/#.783@#7O#K4]#T4;1;52#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

dK%.a=#K4]#T4;1;52#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#

-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#

$011\D#

Page 70: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

!C#

c054P;32#.7>>850@P#<38:@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#

./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#

*>452>45@#$011\D#

Y7>45_:#%5@435;@075;1#&4;984#O73#+4;?4#;52#=34427>#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#

I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#

F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

-78@/#,730f75:#<38:@#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#

-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#

$011\D#

-78@/#F8:@0?4#%524N45245@#*2Z0:73P#(378N#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#

.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#

;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

-78@/#&;]#<057#);59;@03;@;59;#<;0@;>;30^0#[I8R>0::075#@7#I7?0;1#I43Z0?4:#I414?@#

.7>>0@@44#75#@/4#./0123456#-7859#+43:75:#;52#</403#=;>0104:#E-78@/#.783@#F830:20?@075#

;52#'3243:G#*>452>45@#$011\D#

2)6,"-$,-3'!*40#+%3#)-(#

&78]345:6#Q;@@/4]#3%27/'(<)="#<1)!('."<.)&</):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0)A#'2./2-02"<)

&</)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277D)6#??&'5)"E)6#F?2..2"<.)E"')GH)I&5)JKKL#E'OO0?4#7O#@/4#

.143^#7O#@/4#,78:4#7O#)4N34:45@;@0Z4:6#AA#Q;P#"HHBGD#

&78]345:6#Q;@@/4]#3%27/'(<M)="#<1)!('."<.)&</):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0)A#'2./2-02"<)

&</)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277D)6#??&'5)"E)6#F?2..2"<.)E"')N)I&5)JKKL#E'OO0?4#7O#@/4#

.143^#7O#@/4#,78:4#7O#)4N34:45@;@0Z4:6#V#Q;P#"HHBGD#

&78]345:6#Q;@@/4]#3%27/'(<M)="#<1)!('."<.)&</):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0)A#'2./2-02"<)

&</)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277D)6#??&'5)"E)6#F?2..2"<.)E"')JO)I&5)JKKL)E'OO0?4#7O#@/4#

.143^#7O#@/4#,78:4#7O#)4N34:45@;@0Z4:6#"S#Q;P#"HHBGD#

Q050:@3P#7O#F8:@0?4#3%27/)&</)="#0%)9EE(</2<1)60&02.02-.)2<)P($)Q(&7&</D)GLLJ)R)JKKS#

EQ050:@3P#7O#F8:@0?46#*N301#"HAHGD#

Page 71: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

!B#

Q050:@3P#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@#[=34:/#I@;3@#+;?^;94#O73#-7859#'OO45243:\#EN34::#

3414;:46#"!#*898:@#"HHB#GD#

Q050:@3P#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@#,)>'(.%)60&'0)E"')="#<1)9EE(</('.D)+(1#7&0"'5)T?U&-0)

60&0(?(<0#Ea`4?8@0Z4#I8>>;3P6#"HHBGD#

Q050:@3P#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@#3%27/'(<M)="#<1)!('."<.)&</):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0)

A#'2./2-02"<)&</)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277)R)>"#'0%)+(.U"<.()0")V#(.02"<.)E'"?)0%()6"-2&7)

6('*2-(.)3"??200(()EF854#"HHBGD#

Q050:@3P#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@#3%27/'(<M)="#<1)!('."<.)&</):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0)

A#'2./2-02"<)&</)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277)R)+(.U"<.()0")V#(.02"<.)E'"?)0%()6"-2&7)6('*2-(.)

3"??200((#EQ;P#"HHBGD#

Q050:@3P#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@#3%27/'(<M)="#<1)!('."<.)&</):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0)

A#'2./2-02"<)&</)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277)R)T<202&7)C'2(E2<1)0")0%()6"-2&7)6('*2-(.)3"??200((#

E*N301#"HHBG#

Q050:@3P#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@#3%27/'(<M)="#<1)!('."<.)&</):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0)

A#'2./2-02"<)&</)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277)R)W(*(7"U?(<0&7)+(U"'0X#E'?@7R43#"HHBGD#

Q050:@3P#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@#3%27/'(<M)="#<1)!('."<.M)&</):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0)

A#'2./2-02"<)&</)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277)R)W(U&'0?(<0&7)+(U"'0#E'?@7R43#"HHBG#

Q050:@3P#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@#3%27/'(<M)="#<1)!('."<.M)&</):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0)

A#'2./2-02"<)&</)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277)R)W(U&'0?(<0&7)+(U"'0#E'?@7R43#"HHBG#

Q050:@3P#7O#-78@/#U4Z417N>45@#Y<20(/)P&02"<.)3"<*(<02"<)"<)0%()+21%0.)"E)0%()3%27/)

>2*(R=(&')Z"';)!'"1'&??()JKKN)0")JKKS#EI4N@4>R43#"HHVGD#

(!,,+5,('%-1'+)-7,",-+,'!%!,"('

$4554@@6#,75#+;81;6#Q050:@43#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@#;52#a>N17P>45@#

E/@@Nghh]]]DR44/0Z4D97Z@D5fh3414;:4hO34:/i:@;3@iP7859i7OO45243:G#*#=34:/#I@;3@#O73#

-7859#'OO45243:\#EA!#=4R38;3P#"HHBGD#

F8294#Q?a134;#[K4]#T4;1;52#-78@/#.783@g#*#Q7241#O73#U4Z417N>45@#05#7@/43#.783@:j\#

EK;@075;1#.75O4345?4#7O#U0:@30?@#.783@#F8294:6#)7@738;6#K4]#T4;1;526#*N301G#

Page 72: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

JH#

b4P6#F7/5g#I@;@4#7O#@/4#K;@075#IN44?/6#"B#F;58;3P#"HHC#

/@@Nghh]]]D5f/43;12D?7D5fh5fh54]:h;3@0?14D?O>j?k02lAm7Rn4?@02lAHVCBV"V##

Q;`]4116#U3#(;R304114#[./;59059#.30>4#);@4:#ABBC#M#"HHJ\#E%+I#=738>#*2234::059#@/4#

?;8:4:#7O#7OO4520596#Y411059@756#=4R38;3P#"HHBGD#

+7]436#,75783;R14#I0>75#[U30Z43:#7O#.30>4#Q050:@430;1#Q44@059#'N45059#*2234::\#

EY411059@756#HL#*N301#"HHBGD#

+7]436#,75783;R14#I0>75#[U30Z43:#7O#.30>4#Q050:@430;1#Q44@059#'N45059#*2234::\#

EY411059@756#HL#*N301#"HHBGD#

+7]436#I0>75#[U30Z43:#7O#.30>4#Q050:@430;1#Q44@059#'N45059#*2234::\#EY411059@756#HL#

*N301#"HHBGD#

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294##*5234]#$4?37O@#["HAH6#;#R09#P4;3#O73#@/4#-78@/#.783@#M#

<835059#"A#;52#94@@059#@/4#>7:@#78@#7O#@/4#*?@\#E<304550;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294:#

.75O4345?46#Y;0N85;#&72946#*8?^1;526#C#M#AH#I4N@4>R43#"HAHGD#

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294##*5234]#$4?37O@#[U389#&;]#;52#@/4#K4]#T4;1;52#-78@/#

.783@\#E%5@435;@075;1#U389#IP>N7:08>g#,4;1@/P#U389#&;]6#<4#+;N;#<759;34];6#

Y411059@75#K4]#T4;1;526#AB#=4R38;3P#"HHBGD#

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294##*5234]#$4?37O@#[-78@/#F8:@0?4#=;>01P#(378N#.75O4345?4:g#*#

e80?^#oK0N#;52#<8?^p#73#<3;5:N1;5@#I83943P#q#Y/;@#]7812#@/4#U7?@73#73243#05#"HH!\#

EN;N43#N34:45@42#;@#@/4#%5@435;@075;1#.75O4345?4#75#@/4#=;>01P#(378N#.75O4345?4#M##

.7>059#,7>46#<4#,7^059;#Q;06#Y411059@756#K4]#T4;1;52#"JM"B#K7Z4>R43#"HH!GD#

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294##*5234]#$4?37O@#+305?0N;1#[./012345#;52#-7859#+47N14#05#

.75O10?@#]0@/#@/4#&;]g#*:^059#@/4#,;32#e84:@075:\#Erc%%#Y7312#.75934::#7O#@/4#

%5@435;@075;1#*::7?0;@075#7O#-78@/#;52#=;>01P#F8294:#;52#Q;90:@3;@4:6#$41O;:@6#%341;526#

LA#*898:@#"HH!GD#

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294#*5234]#$4?37O@#[*1@435;@0Z4#*NN37;?/4:#@7#I45@45?059#\#

E.QF*#<304550;1#.75O4345?46#<7375@76#.;5;2;6#A"#I4N@4>R43#"HH!GD#

Page 73: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

JA#

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294#*5234]#$4?37O@#[Y/;@#?;8:4:#P78@/#?30>46#;52#]/;@#?;5#

]4#27#;R78@#0@j\#EKT#$184109/@#c45@834:#%5?6#.75O4345?4#;52#*(Q6#e8445:@7]56#K4]#

T4;1;526#A#Q;P#"HHBGD#

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294#*5234]#$4?37O@6#o-78@/#F8:@0?4#q#</4#K4]#T4;1;52#

a`N43045?4#+;:@#&4::75:#;52#=8@834#./;114594:pD#+;N43#N34:45@42#;@#*8:@3;10;5#%5:@0@8@4#

7O#.30>057179Ph#KIY#U4N;3@>45@#7O#F8Z45014#F8:@0?4#.75O4345?4g#A#*(<27()A#.02-(D)>'"?)

[(.."<.)"E)0%()!&.0)0")&)+"&/)E"')0%()>#0#'(M#IP254P6#AM"#U4?4>R43#"HHL6#AHD##

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294#*5234]#$4?37O@6#+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294#[-78@/#F8:@0?4#

05#K4]#T4;1;52g#=8@834#./;114594:\#EN;N43#N34:45@42#;@#@/4#K4]#T4;1;52#-78@/#F8:@0?4#

.75O4345?46#K4]#T4;1;52#-78@/#F8:@0?4#.75O4345?4g#[K4Z43#<77#a;31P6#K4Z43#<77#&;@4\#

Y411059@756#AJ#qqAB#Q;P#"HHVGD#

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294#*5234]#$4?37O@6#I452059#78@#;5#I'I#q#-78@/#F8:@0?4#5442:#

@/4#.7>>850@P6#6#Y73^059#<794@/43#.75O4345?46#K7Z4>R43#"HHJD#

+305?0N;1#-78@/#.783@#F8294#7O#K4]#T4;1;526*5234]#$4?37O@6##[,7]#<7#<835#*#./012#

'OO45243#%5@7#*5#*281@#.30>05;1#M#%5#AH#a;:P#I@4N:\#E./012345#;52#@/4#&;]#%5@435;@075;1#

.75O4345?46#+3;@76#<8:?;5P6#%@;1P6#J#I4N@4>R43#"HHBGD#

)7]46#*::7?0;@4#+37O4::73#Q0?/;41#[+710?059#;52#o?3;?^059#27]5#75#?30>4pg#@789/#

s84:@075:#;52#@789/#;5:]43:\#E%+I#=738>#*2234::059#@/4#.;8:4:#7O#'OO4520596#

Y411059@756#K4]#T4;1;526#=4R38;3P#"HHBGD#

)35,"'

$4?37O@6#*#[.783@#05#@/4#*?@\#="#0%)3"#'0)P($.7(00('#EU4?4>R43#"HHJG###

.;:4P6#c0?@730;#,/*2-()0")0%(),00"'<(5R\(<('&7)"<)0%()3"<.2.0(<-5)$20%)0%()P($)Q(&7&</)

C277)"E)+21%0.),-0)GLLK)"E)0%()3%27/'(<)="#<1)!('."<.)8):%(2')>&?272(.)@="#0%)3"#'0.)

A#'2./2-02"<)8)9'/('.B),?(</?(<0)C277#E.37]5#&;]6#S#=4R38;3P#"HHBG#

/@@Nghh]]]Dn8:@0?4D97Z@D5fhN710?PM;52M?75:81@;@075h1490:1;@075hR011M7OM309/@:h?/012345M

P7859MN43:75:M@/403MO;>0104:MP78@/M?783@:Mn830:20?@075M73243:M;>452>45@M

R011hj:4;3?/@43>l./012345t"H-7859t"H+43:75:t"H;52t"H</403t"H=;>0104:t"Ht"C-

78@/t"H.783@t"HF830:20?@075t"H;52t"H'3243:t"Bt"H*>452>45@t"H*?@!

Page 74: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

J"#

Q?&;3456#b#="#0%)9EE(</2<1):(&?.D)Z%&0)W"(.<]0)Z"';)0")+(/#-()9EE(</2<1)F5)="#<1)

!("U7(#EaM#O1;:/#AB6#Q050:@3P#7O#F8:@0?46#"S#F;58;3P#"HHSG#

/@@Nghh]]]Dn8:@0?4D97Z@D5fhN710?PM;52M?75:81@;@075hP78@/h4MO1;:/4:haMO1;:/t"HABDN2O##

'

)6,"(,%('

0,2#(0%3#)-''

./012345p:#*?@#"HHA#E%341;52GD#

-78@/#.30>05;1#F8:@0?4#*?@#"HH"#E.;5;2;GD#

-7859#'OO45243:#*?@#ABBJ#EK4]#I78@/#Y;14:GD###

-7859#'OO45243:#*?@#ABBL#EI78@/#*8:@3;10;GD#

'

+%(,'0%.'

d50@42#b05927>#

3)*)W!!#WABBSX#*11#a)#VL#E,&G#

63)*)Y<20(/)^2<1/"?#E"HHSG#VH#a,))#AH##

#

d50@42#I@;@4:#

\'&%&?)*)>7"'2/&##S!H#dI#E"HAHG#

+"U(')*)62??"<.##SVL#dI#E"HHSG#

#

#

Page 75: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

JL#

(,+)-1%"&'

",!)"3('

$;33P6#Q750?;#_EE(-02*(),UU'"&-%(.)0")+2.;),..(..?(<0)2<)6"-2&7)Z"';D),<)T<0('<&02"<&7)

[20('&0#'()+(*2($#E%I$Kg#HMJSSBM!SSVA6#I?7@@0:/#a`4?8@0Z4#I7?0;1#)4:4;3?/6#"HHJGD#

$83>;56#Q0?/414u# *3>:@37596# I;3;/u# $;@?/41736# I8:;5u#Q?K40116# =4398:# ;52#K0?/71:756#

F;5#+(.(&'-%)&</)!'&-02-()2<)+2.;),..(..?(<0)8)+2.;)I&<&1(?(<0)"E)3%27/'(<)&</)="#<1)

!("U7()_<1&12<1) 2<)9EE(</2<1)C(%&*2"#'.D),)[20('&0#'()+(*2($# E</4#I?7@@0:/#.45@34# O73#

.30>4#;52#F8:@0?4#)4:4;3?/6#)0:^#Q;5;94>45@#*8@/730@P#)4:4;3?/6#"HHCGD#

U72946#b4554@/#*u#U0:90756#</7>;:#F#;52#&;52:O7326#F4550O43#a#W(*2&<0)!((')T<E7#(<-(.)

2<) T<0('*(<02"<) &</) !#F72-) !"72-5) E"') ="#0%) EI7?0;1# +710?P# )4N73@6# *# +8R10?;@075# 7O# @/4#

I7?04@P#O73#)4:4;3?/#05#./012#U4Z417N>45@6#"HH!GD#

U771;56#Q0^4#="#0%)A#.02-(D)[(12.7&02"<)&</)!'&-02-(# # 05#$73]56#$#F#;52#Q?a134;#=#Y#Q#

Ea2:DG# ="#0%) 3"#'0) 2<) P($) Q(&7&</D) ,)I"/(7) "E) A#.02-() E)4N73@# 57# LV6# &49;1# )4:4;3?/#

=7852;@0756#Y411059@756#ABBLG#ASD##

(30OO056# +;@30?^# W2EE('(<0) E'"?) ,/#70.D) ,<) YU/&0(/) ,<&75.2.) "E) A#*(<27() :'&<.E(') &</)

C7(</(/)6(<0(<-2<1)[&$)$20%)+(-"??(</&02"<.)E"')+(E"'?)EK;@075;1#.45@34#O73#F8Z45014#

F8:@0?46#"HHCGD#

,;f416#U3#K4;1#.37::#P&02"<&7)3"?U&'2."<)"E)="#0%)A#.02-(#E-78@/#F8:@0?4#$7;326#d50@42#

b05927>6#"HHCGD#

b77P6# a10f;R4@/#3%&77(<12<1) 3"#'.(D) ,) +(*2($) "E) 0%() >2'.0) :$") =(&'.) "E) W'#1) :'&<.E(')

+(E"'?)2<)T772<"2.)E%110570:#F8Z45014#F8:@0?4#%50@0;@0Z46#"HHCGD#

Q;`]4116# (;R304114u# b05906# c454f0;u# )7R43@:756# F434>Pu# Q7330:6# *110:75u# .855059/;>6#

./03:#,-%2(*2<1)_EE(-02*()9#0-"?(.) 2<)="#0%) A#.02-()=05;1#)4N73@# E%I$Kg#HMVJCM"SAV"MV6#

Q050:@3P#7O#I7?0;1#U4Z417N>45@6#"HHVGD#

Q;`]4116# (;R304114# Q# ;52# Q7330:6# *110:75# Y</('.0&</2<1) +("EE(</2<1D) >#77) +(U"'0)

E%5:@0@8@4#7O#.30>057179P6#c0?@730;#d50Z43:0@P#7O#Y411059@756#Y411059@756#ABBBGD#

Page 76: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

JV#

Q;`]4116#(;R304114#Q#;52#)7R43@:756#F434>P#3%27/)9EE(</('.D#,)+(U"'0)0")0%()I2<2.0('.)

"E) A#.02-(M) !"72-() &</) 6"-2&7) Z(7E&'(# EY411059@756# 'OO0?4# 7O# @/4# .7>>0::07543# O73#

./0123456#ABBSGD#

Y;33456# F810;# ;52# =3;:436# &P20;# :() 4#'2%&<1&) !27"0D# _*&7#&02"<) +(U"'0# E%I$Kg# HMVJCM

"SAV"MV6#+34N;342#O73#@/4#Q050:@3P#7O#F8:@0?46#"HHBGD#

Y;@@6#a>01P#,)42.0"'5)"E)="#0%)A#.02-()2<)P($)Q(&7&</#EU4N;3@>45@#7O#.783@:6#)4:4;3?/#

+;N436#"HHLGD#

-78596#Y;3345#I2<2.0'5)"E)="#0%) A#.02-()&</)6"-2&7)6(-0"')W(72*('5) 0") 0%()3%27/'(<)&</)

="#<1)!("U7()3"<*2-0(/) 2<)+(7&02"<) 0") 0%()W(&0%)"E)I2-%&(7)3%"5M# EQ050:@3P#7O# F8:@0?46#

"HHLG# v/@@Nghh]]]Dn8:@0?4D97Z@D5fhN8R10?;@075:hN8R10?;@075:M;3?/0Z42h"HHLh# P78@/M

n8:@0?4M;52M:7?0;1M:4?@73M:43Z0?4M2410Z43PM@7M@/4M?/012345M;52MP7859MN47N14M?75Z0?@42M

05M341;@075M@7M@/4M24;@/M7OM>0?/;41M?/7PMO4R38;3PM"HHLh34N73@wD#

4))8('

*^4:@436#b;@4#A#.02-()+(.0"'2<1)="#0%)A#.02-(D)P($)W2'(-02"<.)2<)W"?(.02-)&</)

T<0('<&02"<&7)[&$)&</)!'&-02-()EF8:@0?46#&752756#"HHHGD##

*3@/836#);P>752#="#<1)9EE(</('.)&</)0%()[&$)E<;P173#m#=3;5?0:6#,7R7^456#"HAHGD#

$;^436#b433P##I#702R,1(<-5)!#F72-)!'"0(-02"<),''&<1(?(<0.)&</)="#0%)A#.02-()E</4#+710?P#

+34::6#$30:@716#"HHBGD#

$;1;6#K0?/71;:#.##A#*(<27()A#.02-()65.0(?.D),<)T<0('<&02"<&7)3"?U&'2."<)"E)!'"F7(?.)&</)

6"7#02"<.)E</7>N:75#a28?;@075;1#+8R10:/0596#<7375@76#"HH"G#

$411;>P#6#+;81#="#<1)!("U7()&</)\&<1.)2<)P($)Q(&7&</#E+;310;>45@;3P#&0R3;3P6##

$8337]:6#=##60&0#0()[&$)2<)P($)Q(&7&</#EL32#426#&4`0:#K4`0:6#Y411059@756#"HHLGD#

.3;]O7326#*2;>##;52#K4]R835#6<0>#="#0%)9EE(</2<1)&</)+(.0"'&02*()A#.02-(D)

T?U7(?(<02<1)+(E"'?)2<)="#0%)A#.02-(#EY011;56#+73@1;526#"HHLGD#

.855445#6./30:#;52#)U#Y/0@4#A#*(<27()`#.02-(D)="#0%)&</)3'2?()2<),#.0'&72&#E"52#426#

'`O732#d50Z43:0@P#+34::6#Q41R783546#"HH"GD#

Page 77: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

JS#

=73@056#F;54##3%27/'(<a.)+21%0.)&</)0%()W(*(7"U2<1)[&$#EL32#426#.;>R30294#d50Z43:0@P#

+34::6#.;>R302946#"HHBGD#

=3;5^1056#$7R#:%()P($)4&</F"";)"E)3%27/'(<a.)+21%0.D)3"?U&'&02*()!"72-5)&</)!'&-02-()

E"52#426#)78@142946#&752756#"HHAGD#

,45230?^#6,;33P#[,0:@7304:#7O#-78@/#.30>4#;52#F8:@0?4\#05#$;33P#(712:75#;52#F7/5#

Q850?4#E42:G#="#0%)3'2?()&</)A#.02-()EI;94#+8R10?;@075:6#&752756#"HH!GD##

,0RR43@6#Q75;9/;5#;52#7@/43:#3%27/'(<)2<):'"#F7(D):2?()E"')3%&<1(#E$;35;27:6#a::4`6#

d50@42#b05927>6#"HHLGD#

&435436#)0?/;32#Q##;52#&;8345?4#U#I@405R439#4&</F"";)"E),/"7(.-(<0)!.5-%"7"15#EL32#

426#F7/5#Y014P#m#I75:6#,7R7^456#"HHBGD#

Q;`]4116#(;R304114#Q##;52#*110:75#Q7330:#>&?275M)b2-02?.M)&</)3#70#'(D)="#0%)A#.02-()2<)

P($)Q(&7&</)EI7?0;1#+710?P#*945?P#;52#%5:@0@8@4#7O#.30>057179P6#c0?@730;#d50Z43:0@P#7O#

Y411059@756#Y411059@756#ABBLGD#

Q;`]4116#(;R304114#Q##;52#*110:75#Q7330:#+(0%2<;2<1)="#0%)A#.02-(D)>"')C(00(')"')Z"'.(D)

,)3"??(<0)"<)!'"U".&7.)F5)P($)Q(&7&</)3%27/'(<)&</)="#<1)!('."<.)6('*2-()0")

,?&71&?&0()="#0%)A#.02-()&</)3&'()&</)!'"0(-02"<)6('*2-(.#E%5:@0@8@4#7O#.30>057179P6#

c0?@730;#d50Z43:0@P#7O#Y411059@756#Y411059@756#ABBVGD##

Q;`]4116#(;R304114#Q#,//'(..2<1)0%()3&#.(.)"E)9EE(</2<1D)Z%&0)2.)0%()_*2/(<-(c)

E%5:@0@8@4#7O#+710?P#I@8204:6#c0?@730;#d50Z43:0@P6#Y411059@756#"HHBGD#

Q?a134;#E42::G6#:%()="#0%)3"#'0)2<)P($)Q(&7&</D),)P($)I"/(7)"E)A#.02-()E*8?^1;52g#

&49;1#)4:4;3?/#=7852;@0756#ABBLG#LLD##

Q7330:6#*110:75#;52#(;R30411#Q#Q;`]411#+(.0"'&02*()A#.02-()E"')A#*(<27(.D)3"<E('(<-2<1M)

I(/2&02"<)&</)32'-7(.#E,;3@#+8R10:/0596#'`O7326#"HHAGD#

Q7330:6#*110:75#;52#(;R304114#Q#Q;`]411#>&?275)\'"#U)3"<E('(<-(.)&</)3"<*2-02"<.#

E%5:@0@8@4#7O#.30>057179P6#c0?@730;#d50Z43:0@P#7O#Y411059@756#Y411059@756#ABBJGD#

Q85?046#F7/5#;52#(73275#,89/4:#;52#a89454#Q?&789/105#="#0%)A#.02-(D)3'202-&7)

+(&/2<1.#EI;946#&752756#"HH"GD#

Page 78: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

J!#

Q85?046#F7/5#="#0%)&</)3'2?()EL32#426#&752756#I;94#+8R10?;@075:6#"HHBGD#

K446#.##[</4#'OO45243_:#+43:N4?@0Z4#'5#.30>4g#Q4@/72:#;52#+305?0N14:#05#U;@;#

.7114?@075\#05)*#K442:#;52#(#<7]1#E42:G#,UU752<1)!.5-%"7"15)0")>"'(<.2-)!'&-02-(D#E$+I#

$1;?^]4116#&752756#"HHVGD#I4P>7836#F7/5#*#W(&72<1)$20%)9EE(</('.)2<)P($)Q(&7&</D):%()

65.0(?)2<)_*"7#02"<#E&49;1#)4:4;3?/#=7852;@0756#*8?^1;526#ABJ!GD##

I?7@@6#aD6#m#&D#I@405R439D#"HHCD#)4@/05^059#F8Z45014#F8:@0?4D#.;>R302946#Q*g#,;3Z;32#

<71>046#F#;52#Y#$377^R;5^:#3'2?2<&7)A#.02-()2<)P($)Q(&7&</#E&4`0:#K4`0:6#K4]#T4;1;526#

"HHJGD#

Y85243:0@f6#F7P##;52#./30:@054#*1243#>&?275)3"<E('(<-2<1)&</)A#*(<27()A#.02-(D):%()Z&5)

>"'$&'/)"')I2.U7&-(/)9U02?2.?c)E*8:@3;10;5#%5:@0@8@4#7O#.30>057179P6#.;5R433;6#ABBVGD#

T0>30596#=#,?('2-&<)="#0%)b2"7(<-()E'`O732#d50Z43:0@P#+34::6#K4]#-73^6#ABBCGD##

9)*"-%0('

$;3R43#$&6#a??14:#FI#;52#I@754#Q)#[Y/;@4Z43#/;NN4542#@7#@/4#n7?^6#@/4#R3;05#;52#@/4#

N305?4::j#-7859#;281@#N;@/];P:#105^42#@7#;2714:?45@#;?@0Z0@P#05Z71Z>45@#;52#:7?0;1#

0245@0@P\#E"HHAG#A!#F7835;1#7O#*2714:?45@#)4:4;3?/#

$0:/7N6#UQ##[F8Z45014#7OO45243:#05#@/4#;281@#?30>05;1#n8:@0?4#:P:@4>\#E"HHHG#"J#.30>4#

;52#F8:@0?4#CAD##

U410:6#Q#;52#7@/43:#[K;@834#;52#K83@834#RP#U4O050@075#Q4;5:#$7@/g#*#)4:N75:4#@7#

Q;14:\#E"HAHG#"S#F7835;1#7O#*2714:?45@#)4:4;3?/#AD#

=;33059@756#U#[U4Z417N>45@;1#;52#10O4M?783:4#?30>057179Pg#b4P#@/4734@0?;1#;52#4>N030?;1#

0::84:\#E"HHLG#VA#.30>057179P#""AD#

=0?/436#b6#T#I@405#;52#b#,40^^545#[K;337]#*::4::>45@:#Q0:34N34:45@#U4Z417N>45@#;52#

Q0:98024#+710?Pg#.7>>45@#75#I@405R4396#.;8OO>;56#Y771;326#(3;/;>6#;52#$;50?/#\#

E"HHBG#</4#*>430?;5#+:P?/71790:@#WSBSXD##

=30426#.;3304#I#;52#U0?^75#K#)4NN8??0#[.30>05;1#U4?0:075#Q;^059g#</4#U4Z417N>45@#7O#

*2714:?45@#F829>45@6#.30>05;1#)4:N75:0R010@P6#;52#.81N;R010@P\#E"HHAG#"S#&;]#;52#

,8>;5#$4/;Z073#AD#

Page 79: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

JJ#

(04226#FK##;52#7@/43:#[$3;05#24Z417N>45@#283059#?/012/772#;52#;2714:?45?4g#;#

17590@8205;1#Q)%#:@82P\#EABBBG#"#K;@834#K4837:?045?4#AH#;@#C!AD##

(712:756$##[.785@43R1;:@g#U0OO0?81@#@7#d5243:@;52#73#U4O452g#*#)4;:7542#.;:4#O73#

);0:059#@/4#*94#7O#.30>05;1#)4:N75:0R010@P\#E"HHBG#VC#</4#,7];32#F7835;1#7O#.30>05;1#

F8:@0?4#SAVD#

(855;36#F75#6#$435R439#;52#b37/5#U#Q;3Z05#[&;R410596#&0O4#./;5?4:6#;52#*281@#.30>4g#

</4#U034?@#;52#%52034?@#aOO4?@:#7O#'OO0?0;1#%5@43Z45@075#05#*2714:?45?4#75#.30>4#05#a;31P#

*281@/772\#E"HHLG#.30>057179P#A"CJ#

F4/146#F6##.#&4]0:#;52#+#I7R7@;#[U4;1059#]0@/#F8Z45014#'OO45243:#05#@/4#.30>05;1#F8:@0?4#

IP:@4>\#E"HHCG#AV#a837N4;5#F7835;1#75#.30>05;1#+710?P#;52#)4:4;3?/#"LJD#

F7/5:756#&#Q6##&#I0>75:#;52#)#U#.75943#[.30>05;1#F8:@0?4#IP:@4>:#%5Z71Z4>45@#;52#

.75@0580@P#7O#-78@/#.30>4g#*#&759@0@82;1#*5;1P:0:\#E"HHVG#L!#-78@/#;52#I7?04@P#LD#

F7/5:756# &Q#;52#7@/43:# [.30>05;1# n8:@0?4# :P:@4># 05Z71Z4>45@# ;52# ?75@0580@P# 7O# P78@/#

?30>4g#*#17590@8205;1#;5;1P:0:\#E"HHVG#-78@/#m#I7?04@P)#

b8R0;^6#./30:##;52#)0?/;32#,4:@43#[F8:@#24:43@:j#U4Z417N059#N3;?@0?4#05#P78@/#n8:@0?4\#

E"HHCG#C#&4;35059#05#,4;1@/#;52#I7?0;1#.;34#A'

Q;`]4116#(;R304114#;52#*110:75#Q7330:#[-78@/#F8:@0?4#05#K4]#T4;1;52g#)4:@73;@0Z4#F8:@0?4#

05#+3;?@0?4j\#E"HH!G#!"#</4#F7835;1#7O#I7?0;1#%::84:D#

Q?.8117?/6#+##;52#=#Q?K4011#[.75:8>43#I7?04@P6#.7>>720O0?;@075#;52#'OO45243#

Q;5;94>45@\#E"HHJG#.30>057179P#;52#.30>05;1#F8:@0?4#""LD#

Q724?^0#b#[*2234::059#(;N:#05#@/4#Q;@830@P#7O#F829>45@#&0@43;@834g#*94#U0OO4345?4:#

;52#U4105s845?P\#E"HHCG#L"#&;]#;52#,8>;5#$4/;Z073#AD#

Q724?^06#b;@/3P5#&P55##[x%@_:#;#)8:/xg#+:P?/7:7?0;1#.75@45@#7O#*5@0:7?0;1#U4?0:075#

Q;^059#\#E"HHBG#LL#&;]#;52#,8>;5#$4/;Z073#LD#

Q7OO0@#<a#[*2714:?45?4M&0>0@42#;52#&0O4M.783:4#+43:0:@45@#*5@0:7?0;1#$4/;Z0783g#*#

U4Z417N>45@;1#<;`757>Pd)EABBLG)AHH#+:P?/71790?;1#)4Z04]#V#!JVD#

Page 80: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

JC#

Q7OO0@6<43304#a##[*2714:?45?4M10>0@42#;52#10O4M?783:4MN43:0:@45@#;5@0:7?0;1#R4/;Z073g#*#

24Z417N>45@;1#@;`757>P#\#EABBLG#AHHEVG#+:P?/71790?;1#)4Z04]#!JVD#

Q7330:#*110:75#;52##Q;`]4116#(;R304114#[F8Z45014#F8:@0?4#05#K4]#T4;1;52g#*#K4]#

+;3;209>\#EABBLG#"!#*8:@3;10;5#;52#K4]#T4;1;52#F7835;1#7O#.30>057179P#CAD#

+0s8437#*#;52#I@405R439#&#[+8R10?#N34O4345?4:#O73#34/;R010@;@075#Z43:8:#05?;3?43;@075#7O#

n8Z45014#7OO45243:\#E"HAHG#LC#F7835;1#7O#.30>05;1#F8:@0?4D#

I17R79056#./30:@7N/43##;52#Q;3^#)#=752;?;37#[F8Z45014#F8:@0?4g#</4#=783@/#'N@075#\#

E"HHBG#BS#%7];#&;]#)4Z04]D#

I>0@/6#U;Z02##[K4]#&;R783#;52#-78@/#F8:@0?4#\#E"HHLG#AJ#./012345#m#I7?04@P#""!D#

I@405R4396#&##[)0:^#<;^059#05#*2714:?45?4g#K4]#+43:N4?@0Z4:#=37>#$3;05#;52#$4/;Z073;1#

I?045?4\#E"HHJG#A!#.83345@#U034?@075:#05#+:P?/71790?;1#I?045?4#SSD#

I@405R4396#&##;52#a#I?7@@#[I/7812#F8Z45014#'OO45243:#aZ43#$4#I45@45?42#@7#&0O4#]0@/78@#

@/4#+7::0R010@P#7O#+;3714j\#E"HAHG#SL#,8>;5#U4Z417N>45@#"D#

I@405R4396#&##;52#7@/43:#[*34#*2714:?45@:#&4::#Q;@834#</;5#*281@:j#Q0573:_#*??4::#@7#

*R73@0756#@/4#F8Z45014#U4;@/#+45;1@P6#;52#@/4#*114942#*+*#x=10NM=17N\\#E"HHBG#!V#</4#

*>430?;5#+:P?/71790:@#SCLD#

I@405R4396#&##;52#7@/43:#[)4?75?01059#@/4#.7>N14`0@P#7O#,8>;5#U4Z417N>45@#]0@/#@/4#

)4;10@P#7O#&49;1#+710?Pg#)4N1P#@7#=0:?/436#I@4056#;52#,40^^0545\#E"HHBG#!V#</4#*>430?;5#

+:P?/71790:@#!HAD##

I@405R4396#&#;52#*#+0s8437#[Q;50N81;@059#+8R10?#'N05075#*R78@#<3P059#F8Z45014:#;:#

*281@:g#*5#a`N430>45@;1#I@82P\#E"HAHG#.30>4#;52#U4105s845?P#VCJD##

I@405R4396&##[I/7812#@/4#I?045?4#7O#*2714:?45@#$3;05#U4Z417N>45@#%5O73>#+8R10?#

+710?Pj\#E"HHBG#</4#*>430?;5#+:P?/71790:@#JLBD##

!51'

&P5?/6#K4::;#[</4#)09/@:#7O#@/4#-7859#+43:75#05#@/4#K4]#T4;1;52#-78@/#F8:@0?4#=;>01P#

(378N#.75O4345?4\#E+,U#</4:0:6#d50Z43:0@P#7O#'@;976#"HHCGD#

#-3,"-,3'$%3,"#%0('

Page 81: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

JB#

Q050:@3P# 7O# F8:@0?4# [./012# 'OO452059# ;52# -78@/# F8:@0?4# +37?4::4:\# E"HAHG#

v/@@Nghh]]]Dn8:@0?4D97Z@D5fhN710?PM;52M?75:81@;@075hP78@/h?/012M7OO452059M;52MP78@/M

n8:@0?4MN37?4::4:h?/012M7OO452059M;52MP78@/Mn8:@0?4MN37?4::4:wD#

Q050:@3P# 7O# F8:@0?4# [=;>01P# (378N# .75O4345?4\# E"HAHG# v/@@Nghh]]]"Dn8:@0Z4D97Z@D5f#

hP78@/h;R78@MP78@/hO;>01PM9378NM?75O4345?4D;:NwD#

K4]# T4;1;52# K;@075;1# +;3@P6# F8:@0?4# +710?P# E"HAHG# v/@@Nghh]]]D5;@075;1D739D5f#

h+710?P*34;:D;:N`jIlVLwD##

-,.('%"3#+0,('

a;:@756# Q;3^# [.30>46# &04:# ;52# I@;@0:@0?:\# CC3) Ed50@42# b05927>6# AJ# F81P# "HHCG# ;@#

v/@@Nghh]]]DRR?D?7D8^hR179:h@/434N73@43:h>;3^4;:@75h"HHChHJh?30>4:k104:k;52k:@;@0

:@0?:D/@>1wD#

[-78594:@#^01143_:#R02#@7#R4#O344\#EK4]#T4;1;526#"B#*898:@#"HAHG#;@#

/@@Nghh]]]D:@8OOD?7D5fh5;@075;1h?30>4hVHJ"LLLh-78594:@M^01143:MR02M@7MR4MO344#

[+;@?/4:# %245@0OP# </8990:/# &7:43:\# :%() W"?2<2"<) !".0# EY411059@756# K4]# T4;1;526# LH#

I4N@4>R43# "HHCG# ;@# v/@@Nghh]]]D:@8OOD?7D5fh27>05075M

N7:@h7N05075h420@730;1:h!S"SCVwD#

[.7;?/42#<445;94#);N0:@#@7#R4#=3442\#:%()W"?2<2"<)!".0)EY411059@756#K4]#T4;1;526#"L#

*N301# "HHBG# ;@# v/@@Nghh]]]D:@8OOD?7D5fh5;@075;1h?30>4h"LS!ABSh.7;?/42M@445;94M

3;N0:@M@7MR4MO3442wD#

#[=;03# <;^4:# =034# =37>#U385^# -7R:\#I&<&$&0#) 60&</&'/# EK4]# T4;1;526# ""# U4?4>R43#

"HHCG#;@#/@@Nghh]]]D:@8OOD?7D5fh27>05075MN7:@h5;@075;1hJJACH!D##

[*#+;:@#;52#=8@834g#</43;N48@0?# F8:@0?4# O73#-78@/#'OO45243:\#:%()P($)Q(&7&</)4('&7/)

E*8?^1;526# K4]# T4;1;526# S# I4N@4>R436# "HHBG# ;@#

v]]]D5f/43;12D?7D5fh5fh54]:h;3@0?14D?O>j?k02lAm7Rn4?@02lAHSBS"VLwD#

#-3,"-%3#)-%0'1)+*$,-3('

,8>;5#)09/@:#.7>>0::075#3"??(<0.)"E)0%()P($)Q(&7&</)4#?&<)+21%0.)3"??2..2"<)"<)

P($)Q(&7&</].)2?U7(?(<0&02"<)"E)0%()Y<20(/)P&02"<.)3"<*(<02"<)"<)0%()+21%0.)"E)0%()

Page 82: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

CH#

3%27/M)+(U"'0M)>"')-"<.2/('&02"<)2<)'(7&02"<)0")P($)Q(&7&</].):%2'/)&</)>"#'0%)!('2"/2-#

EI4N@4>R436#"HHVGD'

Y<20(/)P&02"<.)3"<*(<02"<)"<)0%()+21%0.)"E)0%()3%27/#E7N4542#O73#:095;@834#"H#

K7Z4>R43#ABCB6#;27N@42#"H#K7Z4>R43#ABCB6#45@4342#05@7#O73?4#"#I4N@4>R43#ABBHGD#

Y<20(/)P&02"<.)3"<*(<02"<)&1&2<.0):"'0#'()&</)90%(')3'#(7M)T<%#?&<)"')W(1'&/2<1)

:'(&0?(<0)"')!#<2.%?(<0#EABCVG#

Y<20(/)P&02"<.)\#2/(72<(.)E"')0%()!'(*(<02"<)"E)A#*(<27()W(72<e#(<-5)@f:%()+25&/%)

\#2/(72<(.dB#(*#)4:#VShAA"6#dK#U7?#*hVShVB#EABBHGD#

)

Y<20(/)P&02"<.)+#7(.)E"')0%()!'"0(-02"<)"E)A#*(<27(.)W(U'2*(/)"E)0%(2')[2F('056#(*#)4:#

VShAAL6#dK#U7?#*hVShVB6#;554`6#VS#dK#(*')#I8NND#EK7DVB*#EABBHG#

#

Y<20(/)P&02"<.)60&</&'/)I2<2?#?)+#7(.)E"'),/?2<2.0'&02"<)"E)A#*(<27()A#.02-(6#(*#)4:#

VHhLL6#dK#U7?#*hVHhSL6#*554`6#VH#dDKD#(*')#I8NNDK7DSL#EABCSG#;@#"HJD##

)35,"'

$7:/0436#+4@43#E42G#3%27/)9EE(</('.)I&<#&7)g),)!'&-02-&7)\#2/()0")6#--(..E#7)T<0('*(<02"<)

$20%)3%27/)9EE(</('.#EL32#426#./04O#F8294:#./;>R43:6#Y411059@756#"HH"GD#

$3;0@/];0@46#F7/5#[Y/;@#0:#@7#R4#2754#;R78@#.30>05;1#F8:@0?4\#05#$F#$37]5#;52#=YQ#

Q?a134;#:%()="#0%)3"#'0)2<)P($)Q(&7&</D),)P($)I"/(7)"E)A#.02-(#E&49;1#)4:4;3?/#

=7852;@0756#*8?^1;526#ABBLG##

$80:@6#Q;83445#;52#Y/0@46#$011#T<0('<&02"<&7)_*2/(<-()&F"#0)/(-2.2"<)?&;2<1)&</)

.('*2-(.)E"')-%27/'(<)&</)5"#<1)U("U7()2<*"7*(/)2<)"EE(</2<1#E.30>05;1#F8:@0?4#I7?0;1#Y73^#

U4Z417N>45@#.45@43#O73#I?7@1;526#"HHVGD#

&;>R78356#$;3R;3;#E42G#="#<1)&</),--"#<0&F7(c)6%"#7/)PQ)7"$(')0%()&1()"E)-'2?2<&7)

U'".(-#02"<c)#EI8>>;3P#+7:0@075#+;N436#dK%.a=#KT6#'?@7R43#"HHCGD#

Q?a134;6#=YQ#[*#K4]#Q7241#7O#F8:@0?4\#05#$F#$37]5#;52#=YQ#Q?a134;#:%()="#0%)3"#'0)

2<)P($)Q(&7&</D),)P($)I"/(7)"E)A#.02-(#E&49;1#)4:4;3?/#=7852;@0756#*8?^1;526#ABBLG!

Page 83: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!

!

CA#

I?7@@6#a#;52#I@405R4396#&#6"-2&7)Z(7E&'()&</)>&2'<(..)2<)A#*(<27()3'2?()+(1#7&02"<#

E.718>R0;#+8R10?#&;]#)4:4;3?/#+;N43#K7D#AHM"VL6#*898:@#"HAHG#

Y;8?/7N6#I8:;5#:(<)\"2<1)"<)62h0((<D),)U'"E27()"E)5"#<1)P($)Q(&7&</('.)2<)0%()

0'&<.202"<)5(&'.#EQ050:@3P#7O#-78@/#U4Z417N>45@6#"HAHGD!

!

Page 84: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

!""#$%&'(!)(*+#(,+&-%.#$/(012$3(4#.51$5(6$%(*+#&.(768&-&#5(9012:+(,12.:(;2.&5%&<:&1$(6$%(=.%#.5>(!8#$%8#$:(!<:(?@A@(

(

BC(D#-E6.#(6$%(&$:#.#5:5(1E(<+&-%(1.(F12$3("#.51$("6.6812$:(!"#$%%#&$''()*#)(%$'+",#'-#'.(#$/&+"+*')$'+-"#-)#$00%+1$'+-"#-2#'.+*#31'#4-'.()#'.$"#5$)'*#6#$"/#7#$"/#*(1'+-"*#879#'-#8:;<=#'.(#>(%2$)(#$"/#+"'()(*'*#-2#'.(#1.+%/#-)#?-@",#0()*-"#*.$%%#A(#'.(#2+)*'#$"/#0$)$&-@"'#1-"*+/()$'+-"=#.$B+",#)(,$)/#'-#'.(#0)+"1+0%(*#*('#-@'#+"#*(1'+-"*#7#$"/#98C#

D(1'+-"#:E#*@A*'+'@'(/=#-"#F#G$"@$)?#9HH7=#A?#*(1'+-"#8#-2#'.(#I.+%/)("=#J-@",#5()*-"*=#$"/#K.(+)#L$&+%+(*#3&("/&("'#31'#9HH6#49HH6#M-#9N9<C#

#

5?G(768&-F(3.12"(<1$E#.#$<#(86F(86H#(%#<&5&1$5(6$%(.#<188#$%6:&1$5(6$%(E1.82-6:#("-6$5(49<## 3#2$&+%?#,)-@0#1-"2()("1(#1-"B("(/#@"/()#'.+*#5$)'#&$?#&$O(#*@1.#

/(1+*+-"*#$"/#)(1-&&("/$'+-"*#$"/#2-)&@%$'(#*@1.#0%$"*#$*#+'#1-"*+/()*#"(1(**$)?#-)#/(*+)$A%(#+"#)(%$'+-"#'-#'.(#1$)(#-)#0)-'(1'+-"#-2#'.(#1.+%/#-)#?-@",#0()*-"#+"#)(*0(1'#-2#>.-&#'.(#1-"2()("1(#>$*#1-"B("(/C#

#4N<## !"#&$O+",#*@1.#/(1+*+-"*#$"/#)(1-&&("/$'+-"*#$"/#2-)&@%$'+",#*@1.#

0%$"*=#'.(#1-"2()("1(#*.$%%#.$B(#)(,$)/#'-#'.(#0)+"1+0%(*#*('#-@'#+"#*(1'+-"*#7=#:=#$"/#98C#

#48<## PB()?#1$)(#$"/#0)-'(1'+-"#1-Q-)/+"$'-)#>.-#1-"B("(*#$#2$&+%?#,)-@0#

1-"2()("1(#*.$%%#1$@*(#'-#A(#&$/(#$#>)+''("#)(1-)/#-2#'.(#/('$+%*#-2#'.(#/(1+*+-"*#$"/#)(1-&&("/$'+-"*#&$/(=#$"/#'.(#0%$"*#2-)&@%$'(/=#A?#'.$'#1-"2()("1(#0@)*@$"'#'-#'.+*#*(1'+-"C#

#

5I@(,6.#(6$%(".1:#<:&1$(<1J1.%&$6:1.(:1(5##H(63.##8#$:(:1(%#<&5&1$5/(.#<188#$%6:&1$5/(6$%("-6$5(1E(E68&-F(3.12"(<1$E#.#$<#(

#49<## R.()(#$#2$&+%?#,)-@0#1-"2()("1(#&$O(*#$"?#/(1+*+-"#-)#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#

-)#2-)&@%$'(*#$"?#0%$"=#0@)*@$"'#'-#*(1'+-"#NH49<#-)#*@A*(1'+-"#46<#-2#'.+*#*(1'+-"=#'.(#1$)(#$"/#0)-'(1'+-"#1-Q-)/+"$'-)#>.-#1-"B("(/#'.$'#1-"2()("1(#*.$%%=S#

4$<#>.()(#'.(#1-"2()("1(#>$*#1-"B("(/#@"/()#*(1'+-"#9F49<#-"#'.(#A$*+*#-2#$#)(0-)'#2)-&#$#*-1+$%#>-)O()#-)#$#1-"*'$A%(=S#

4+<#1-&&@"+1$'(#'.$'#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#'-#'.$'#*-1+$%#>-)O()#-)#1-"*'$A%(#4-)#$"?#0()*-"#$1'+",#2-)#'.$'#

Page 85: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

*-1+$%#>-)O()#-)#'.$'#1-"*'$A%(<=#$"/#'-#(B()?#0()*-"#>.-#>+%%#A(#/+)(1'%?#+"B-%B(/#+"#'.(#+&0%(&("'$'+-"#-2#'.(#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"T#$"/#4++<#*((O#'.(#$,)((&("'#-2#'.$'#*-1+$%#>-)O()#-)#1-"*'$A%(#4-)#$"?#0()*-"#$1'+",#2-)#'.$'#*-1+$%#>-)O()#-)#'.$'#1-"*'$A%(<=#$"/#-2#(B()?#-'.()#0()*-"#'-#>.-&#'.$'#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#+*#1-&&@"+1$'(/#0@)*@$"'#'-#*@A0$)$,)$0.#4+<=#'-#'.$'#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"E#

4A<#>.()(#'.(#1-"2()("1(#>$*#1-"B("(/#@"/()#*(1'+-"#9H4N<4$<#-"#'.(#A$*+*#-2#$#)(2())$%#2)-&#$"?#A-/?=#-),$"+*$'+-"=#-)#1-@)'=S#

4+<#1-&&@"+1$'(#'.$'#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#'-#'.$'#A-/?=#-),$"+*$'+-"=#-)#1-@)'=#$"/#'-#(B()?#0()*-"#>.-#>+%%#A(#/+)(1'%?#+"B-%B(/#+"#'.(#+&0%(&("'$'+-"#-2#'.$'#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"T#$"/#4++<#*((O#'.(#$,)((&("'#-2#'.$'#-),$"+*$'+-"#-)#A-/?=#$"/#-2#(B()?#-'.()#0()*-"#4-'.()#'.$"#$#1-@)'<#'-#>.-&#'.$'#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#+*#1-&&@"+1$'(/#0@)*@$"'#'-#*@A0$)$,)$0.#4+<=#'-#'.$'#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"C#

4N<## R.()(=#0@)*@$"'#'-#0$)$,)$0.#4$<4+<#-)#0$)$,)$0.#4A<4+<#-2#*@A*(1'+-"#49<=#$#1$)(#$"/#0)-'(1'+-"#1-Q-)/+"$'-)#&(('*#>+'.#$"?#0()*-"=#A-/?=#-),$"+*$'+-"=#-)#1-@)'#2-)#'.(#0@)0-*(#-2#1-&&@"+1$'+",#'-#'.$'#0()*-"=#A-/?=#-),$"+*$'+-"=#-)#1-@)'#$"?#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#&$/(#-)#2-)&@%$'(/#A?#$#2$&+%?#,)-@0#1-"2()("1(=#'.(#1$)(#$"/#0)-'(1'+-"#1-Q-)/+"$'-)#&$?#A(#$11-&0$"+(/#A?#$#0()*-"#"-&+"$'(/#A?#'.$'#2$&+%?#,)-@0#1-"2()("1(C#

48<## R.()(#$#1$)(#$"/#0)-'(1'+-"#1-Q-)/+"$'-)#+*#@"$A%(#'-#*(1@)(#$,)((&("'=#@"/()#*@A*(1'+-"#49<=#'-#$#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#&$/(#-)#2-)&@%$'(/#A?#$#2$&+%?#,)-@0#1-"2()("1(=#'.(#1$)(#$"/#0)-'(1'+-"#1-Q-)/+"$'-)#&$?=#2-)#'.(#0@)0-*(#-2#("$A%+",#'.$'#1-"2()("1(#'-#)(1-"*+/()#'.$'#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"=#)(1-"B("(#'.$'#1-"2()("1(C#

46<## 3"?#2$&+%?#,)-@0#1-"2()("1(#)(1-"B("(/#@"/()#*@A*(1'+-"#48<#&$?#1-"2+)&=#)(*1+"/=#-)#&-/+2?#+'*#0)(B+-@*#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"=#-)#)(*1+"/#+'*#0)(B+-@*#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#$"/#&$O(#-)#2-)&@%$'(#$#"(>#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"C#

47<## 3"?#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#1-"2+)&(/#-)#&-/+2+(/#@"/()#*@A*(1'+-"#46<=#$"/#$"?#"(>#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#&$/(#-)#2-)&@%$'(/#@"/()#'.$'#*@A*(1'+-"=#*.$%%#A(#/((&(/#'-#.$B(#A(("#&$/(#-)#2-)&@%$'(/#0@)*@$"'#'-#*(1'+-"#NHC#D(1'+-"#8;49<4$<E#$&("/(/=#-"#9#U1'-A()#N;;F=#0@)*@$"'#'-#*(1'+-"#99:4$<4++<#-2#'.(#5-%+1+",#31'#N;;F#4N;;F#M-#VN<C#

Page 86: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

D(1'+-"#8;49<4$<4+<E#$&("/(/=#-"#9#U1'-A()#N;;F=#0@)*@$"'#'-#*(1'+-"#99:4$<4++<#-2#'.(#5-%+1+",#31'#N;;F#4N;;F#M-#VN<C#D(1'+-"#8;49<4$<4++<E#$&("/(/=#-"#9#U1'-A()#N;;F=#0@)*@$"'#'-#*(1'+-"#99:4$<4++<#-2#'.(#5-%+1+",#31'#N;;F#4N;;F#M-#VN<C#

#

5IC(768&-F(3.12"(<1$E#.#$<#(86F(.#<1$K#$#(:1(.#K&#L(&:5(%#<&5&1$5/(.#<188#$%6:&1$5/(6$%("-6$5(49<## R.()(#$"?#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"#+*#&$/(#-)#2-)&@%$'(/#A?#$#

2$&+%?#,)-@0#1-"2()("1(#0@)*@$"'#'-#'.+*#5$)'=#'.(#1$)(#$"/#0)-'(1'+-"#1-Q-)/+"$'-)#>.-#1-"B("(/#'.$'#1-"2()("1(#&$?#2)-&#'+&(#'-#'+&(=#$'#'.$'#1-Q-)/+"$'-)W*#->"#&-'+-"#-)#$'#'.(#)(X@(*'#-2#$'#%($*'#N#&(&A()*#-2#'.$'#1-"2()("1(=#)(1-"B("(#'.$'#1-"2()("1(#2-)#'.(#0@)0-*(#-2#)(B+(>+",#'.$'#/(1+*+-"=#)(1-&&("/$'+-"=#-)#0%$"C#

4N<## D(1'+-"*#N;#'-#87#*.$%%#$00%?=#>+'.#$%%#"(1(**$)?#&-/+2+1$'+-"*=#>+'.#)(*0(1'#'-#(B()?#2$&+%?#,)-@0#1-"2()("1(#)(1-"B("(/#@"/()#'.+*#*(1'+-"C##

(5IAA( B2"#.K&5&1$(L&:+(.#5&%#$<#(1.%#.(49<#!2#$#1.$),(#$,$+"*'#$#?-@",#0()*-"#+*#0)-B(/#A(2-)(#$#J-@'.#I-@)'=#'.(#1-@)'#&$?#&$O(#$"#-)/()#0%$1+",#'.(#?-@",#0()*-"#+"#'.(#1@*'-/?#-2#'.(#1.+(2#(Y(1@'+B(#2-)#$#0()+-/#-2#"-'#%(**#'.$"#8#&-"'.*#$"/#"-'#&-)(#'.$"#:#&-"'.*C#

4N<#!2#$#J-@'.#I-@)'#&$O(*#$"#-)/()#@"/()#*@A*(1'+-"#49<#+"#)(*0(1'#-2#$#?-@",#0()*-"=#'.(#-)/()#&$?#4*@AZ(1'#'-#*(1'+-"#NH;3<#A(#&$/(#*@AZ(1'#'-#'.(#1-"/+'+-"#'.$'#'.(#?-@",#0()*-"#@"/()'$O(#$"?#*0(1+2+(/#0)-,)$&&(#-)#$1'+B+'?C#4N3<#!2#$#J-@'.#I-@)'#&$O(*#$"#-)/()#@"/()#*@A*(1'+-"#49<#+"#)(*0(1'#-2#$#?-@",#0()*-"=#'.(#1-@)'#&@*'S#

o 4$<#$/Z-@)"#'.(#0)-1((/+",*#'-#$#/$'(#A(2-)(#'>-Q'.+)/*#-2#'.(#0()+-/#-2#'.(#-)/()#@"/()#*@A*(1'+-"#49<#>+%%#.$B(#(%$0*(/#$"/#-"#>.+1.#+'#>+%%#1-"*+/()#($)%?#)(%($*(T#$"/#

o 4A<#&$O(#$"#-)/()#@"/()#*(1'+-"#NF84O<#0%$1+",#'.$'#?-@",#0()*-"#@"/()#'.(#*@0()B+*+-"#-2#'.(#1.+(2#(Y(1@'+B(#2-)#$#0()+-/#-2#"-'#%(**#'.$"#:#&-"'.*#$"/#"-'#&-)(#'.$"#9N#&-"'.*C#

48<#K.(#-)/()#)(X@+)(/#A?#*@A*(1'+-"#4N3<4A<#&@*'#A(#&$/(#(+'.()#$'#'.(#*$&(#'+&(#$*#'.(#-)/()#&$/(#@"/()#*@A*(1'+-"#49<#-)#$2'()#'.$'#'+&(#A@'#A(2-)(#'.(#($)%+()#-2#'.(#2-%%->+",E#

o 4$<#'.(#(Y0+)?#-2#'.(#-)/()#&$/(#@"/()#*@A*(1'+-"#49<E#o 4A<#'.(#/$'(#-"#>.+1.#'.(#?-@",#0()*-"#+*#)(%($*(/#2)-&#'.(#1@*'-/?#

-2#'.(#1.+(2#(Y(1@'+B(#@"/()#*(1'+-"#896C#46<#K.(#-)/()#)(X@+)(/#A?#*@A*(1'+-"#4N3<4A<#&@*'#1-&(#+"'-#2-)1(#-"#'.(#($)%+()#-2#'.(#(Y0+)?#*0(1+2+(/#+"#*@A*(1'+-"#48<4$<#$"/#'.(#/$'(#*0(1+2+(/#+"#*@A*(1'+-"#48<4A<=#$"/#&$?#A(#&$/(#*@AZ(1'#'-#$%%#-)#$"?#-2#'.(#2-%%->+",#

Page 87: Sarah Kuper - Dissertation23*?!%,!!!!! ";` "";!!!!!

1-"/+'+-"*#4>.+1.=#+2#+&0-*(/#A?#'.(#1-@)'=#$00%?#+"#$//+'+-"#'-#'.(#1-"/+'+-"*#)(X@+)(/#A?#*(1'+-"#8;7#$"/#'-#$"?#1-"/+'+-"*#'.(#1-@)'#+&0-*(*#@"/()#*(1'+-"#8;:<E#

o 4$<#'.$'#'.(#?-@",#0()*-"#$''("/#$"/#)(&$+"#$'=#2-)#$"?#>((O/$?=#(B("+",=#$"/#>((O("/#.-@)*#($1.#>((O#$"/#2-)#$"?#"@&A()#-2#&-"'.*#'.(#1-@)'#'.+"O*#2+'=#$"?#*0(1+2+(/#1("')(#$00)-B(/#A?#'.(#/(0$)'&("'=#$"/#'$O(#0$)'#+"#$"?#$1'+B+'?#)(X@+)(/#A?#'.(#0()*-"#+"#1.$),(#-2#'.(#1("')(E#

o 4A<#'.$'#'.(#?-@",#0()*-"#@"/()'$O(#$"?#*0(1+2+(/#0)-,)$&&(#-)#$1'+B+'?E#

o 41<#'.$'#'.(#?-@",#0()*-"#)(*+/(#$'#$"#$//)(**#*0(1+2+(/#A?#'.(#1-@)'C#D(1'+-"#899E#*@A*'+'@'(/=#-"#9#U1'-A()#N;9;=#A?#*(1'+-"#8:#-2#'.(#I.+%/)("=#J-@",#5()*-"*=#$"/#K.(+)#L$&+%+(*#4J-@'.#I-@)'*#G@)+*/+1'+-"#$"/#U)/()*<#3&("/&("'#31'#N;9;#4N;9;#M-#N<C#

#