DECLARATION OF STEVEN J. SEIDEMAN – 1

Scott E. Randolph (ISB #6768) A. Dean Bennett (ISB #7735) HOLLAND & HART LLP 101 South Capitol Boulevard, Suite 1400 P.O. Box 2527 Boise, Idaho 83701-2527 Telephone: (208) 342-5000 Facsimile: (208) 343-8869 Email: serandolph@hollandhart.com

adbennett@hollandhart.com Mark A. Miller (UT Bar No. 9563) (admitted pro hac vice) Ginger Utley (UT Bar No. 11766) (admitted pro hac vice) HOLLAND & HART LLP 222 S. Main Street, Suite 2200 Salt Lake City, Utah 84101 Telephone: (801) 799-5800 Facsimile: (801) 799-5700 Email: mmiller@hollandhart.com gutley@hollandhart.com Attorneys for Plaintiff BATTELLE ENERGY ALLIANCE, LLC

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF IDAHO

BATTELLE ENERGY ALLIANCE, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, Plaintiff, vs. SOUTHFORK SECURITY, INC., an Idaho corporation, COREY THUEN, an individual, and DOES 1 through 10, inclusive, Defendants.

Case No. 4:13-cv-00442-BLW DECLARATION OF STEVEN J. SEIDEMAN

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 1 of 14

DECLARATION OF STEVEN J. SEIDEMAN – 2

I, Steven J. Seideman, hereby declare and state as follows:

1. I am the founder and President of Assured Information Solutions which

specializes in computer and database consulting. I have been retained by the law firm Holland &

Hart, LLP, as a computer application and database expert for purposes of this litigation. I make

this declaration based on my personal knowledge and based upon my education, training, and

experience in working with computers and computer systems.

2. On October 21, 2013, I accessed the website https://github.com. From the main

Github page, I searched for and accessed Visdom and a related program called Mimir. From the

Github site, I was able to confirm that Corey Thuen – identified on Github as a user called

Remasis – first uploaded the code for Visdom to github on March 28, 2013 at 2:12:04 p.m. The

application Visdom was substantially complete when Mr. Thuen uploaded it in March. He

completed numerous revisions of Visdom between the initial upload date and July 23, 2013 at

01:01:17 AM. The functional changes to the code appear to have ended by June 29, 2013. See

Exhibits A through E. for a complete list of all changes to the code as recorded by github.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the foregoing is

true and correct.

Executed this 22nd day of October, 2013, at Boise, Idaho.

/s/ Steven J. Seideman Steven J. Seideman

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 2 of 14

DECLARATION OF STEVEN J. SEIDEMAN – 3

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY that on the 22nd day of October, 2013, I filed the foregoing electronically through the CM/ECF system, which caused the following parties or counsel to be served by electronic means, as more fully reflected on the Notice of Electronic Filing:

Bradlee R. Frazer Jason D. Scott Hawley Troxell Ennis & Hawley, LLP 877 W. Main Street, Suite 1000 Boise, Idaho 83702-5883 Telephone: (208) 344-6000 Attorneys for Defendants Southfork Security, Inc. and Corey Thuen

bfrazer@hawleytroxell.com jscott@hawleytroxell.com

/s/ Scott E. Randolph Scott E. Randolph

6474249_1.DOCX

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 3 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master 1/2

Jul 23, 2013

Jul 22, 2013

Jul 18, 2013

Jun 29, 2013

Jun 27, 2013

Jun 26, 2013

Sign up Sign in

5 2 Star Forkvisdom / visdomPUBLIC

masterbranch: v isdom / Commits

Update README.mdremasis authored 3 months ago

02020aedc9

Brow se code

add quickstart guideremasis authored 3 months ago

66ce395743

Brow se code

change gitignore for quickstart guideremasis authored 3 months ago

1614ba03a1

Brow se code

add mimir reference to READMEremasis authored 3 months ago

4653ed21a2

Brow se code

Merge branch 'dev 'remasis authored 4 months ago

205c1a694e

Brow se code

Merge branch 'refactorVtoAng' into devremasis authored 4 months ago

0dc2c0fe83

Brow se code

clar if ied error message on disconnectremasis authored 4 months ago

51df095171

Brow se code

remov e reconnection attempt and instruct them to refreshremasis authored 4 months ago

d2c6d278a6

Brow se code

3D entit ies/groups are clickable and nav igate to the proper page (thr… remasis authored 4 months ago

… 0396e439aa

Brow se code

license is ugly on v ersion pageremasis authored 4 months ago

9ac06a7bc2

Brow se code

put license on indexremasis authored 4 months ago

a499f3cba7

Brow se code

copyright notices attached to .js filesremasis authored 4 months ago

2cd98f9cc9

Brow se code

Apache 2 copyright licenseremasis authored 4 months ago

c87c626c93

Brow se code

f ixed unit testsremasis authored 4 months ago

e01f9f448b

Brow se code

aesthetics cleanupremasis authored 4 months ago

e315f7ba2c

Brow se code

switched to fps counter by default for releaseremasis authored 4 months ago

01e517ffb9

Brow se code

mov ed fps counter out of the wayremasis authored 4 months ago

7338993afc

Brow se code

Explore Features Enterprise BlogSearch or type a commandThis repos itory

EXHIBIT A

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 4 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master 2/2

Jun 25, 2013

Jun 24, 2013

nav bar cleanupremasis authored 4 months ago

a50494d1f7

Brow se code

renabled 3Dremasis authored 4 months ago

2566e630ff

Brow se code

cleanup v ersion pageremasis authored 4 months ago

a1248d6f5c

Brow se code

added blacklisting/whitelisting for all matching flowsremasis authored 4 months ago

2069512877

Brow se code

blacklisting supported on entit ies and flows from their details pageremasis authored 4 months ago

62c6f8da16

Brow se code

blacklisting and fingerpr inting alerts working for flowsremasis authored 4 months ago

ed49a52136

Brow se code

created notify serv iceremasis authored 4 months ago

9da64a7a18

Brow se code

f ixed orderby on flowv iewremasis authored 4 months ago

c8b81dc26b

Brow se code

mov ed socketFlow to it 's own filesremasis authored 4 months ago

6c6fae630d

Brow se code

create core nav Serv ice for modules to register dialog and buttons on … remasis authored 4 months ago

… 675d84c31e

Brow se code

mov ed filters to a modal dropdownremasis authored 4 months ago

bc8eb4abec

Brow se code

socketFlow emits ev ents for flow update, creation, and delectionremasis authored 4 months ago

58d46b6d6d

Brow se code

Flow graph in flowDetail v iewremasis authored 4 months ago

1964d572cb

Brow se code

added new commonFilter. remasis authored 4 months ago

… 98f80091ad

Brow se code

updated angular-ui-bootstrap to 0.4.0remasis authored 4 months ago

605e397724

Brow se code

bugfix on sort buttonremasis authored 4 months ago

8fc14e3d67

Brow se code

chart cleanup. unit test f ixing.remasis authored 4 months ago

7369257e7f

Brow se code

f ilterPrinter directiv e workingremasis authored 4 months ago

af9c866235

Brow se code

« Newer Older »

Status API Training Shop Blog About© 2013 GitHub, Inc. Terms Privacy Security Contact

EXHIBIT A

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 5 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master?page=2 1/3

Jun 23, 2013

Jun 22, 2013

Jun 21, 2013

Jun 20, 2013

Sign up Sign in

5 2 Star Forkvisdom / visdomPUBLIC

masterbranch: v isdom / Commits

renamed sampleFilters to sampleFlowFiltersremasis authored 4 months ago

efa706bf8d

Brow se code

sampleFlowFilters workingremasis authored 4 months ago

92304358e9

Brow se code

f ilter logic improv ed. commonFilters serv ice workingremasis authored 4 months ago

e434f2500f

Brow se code

updated gitignore to remov e angular docsremasis authored 4 months ago

45848c6beb

Brow se code

added a login landing page when users are not authenticatedtraetox authored 4 months ago

b8cbc16597

Brow se code

added serv ice for the commonFiltersremasis authored 4 months ago

503f0ca59e

Brow se code

f ilter improv ements. Logical AND/OR and filter group supportremasis authored 4 months ago

3551a697bd

Brow se code

conv erted flow markup to a template directiv eremasis authored 4 months ago

8cda73a7e9

Brow se code

UI cleanupremasis authored 4 months ago

91c3d54f3b

Brow se code

Merge branch 'f lowsort' into refactorVtoAngremasis authored 4 months ago

3cec5cd42a

Brow se code

mock tmp remov alremasis authored 4 months ago

30925eed6e

Brow se code

mov ed 3d handleUpdate to v is3d serv iceremasis authored 4 months ago

ab47eb3780

Brow se code

remov ed debugging code. cean up v iewremasis authored 4 months ago

6dda0c55ad

Brow se code

sorting works...supposeblyremasis authored 4 months ago

56d71f09b3

Brow se code

added binaryInsert for sortable flow listremasis authored 4 months ago

16275c1042

Brow se code

broadcast ev ent on flow deletionremasis authored 4 months ago

f67ac3ad80

Brow se code

Merge branch 'f lowfilter ' into refactorVtoAngremasis authored 4 months ago

0b7fd37919

Brow se code

f low and entity detail v iew workingremasis authored 4 months ago

73aac082e3

Brow se code

updated detail contollers for flow and entity

Explore Features Enterprise BlogSearch or type a commandThis repos itory

EXHIBIT B

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 6 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master?page=2 2/3

Jun 19, 2013

Jun 18, 2013

Jun 13, 2013

Jun 12, 2013

Jun 11, 2013

Jun 09, 2013

Jun 01, 2013

remasis authored 4 months ago d71ab041fa

Brow se code

added routing for flow/entity detail v iew. stub of entView moduleremasis authored 4 months ago

f30a97a39a

Brow se code

type conv ersion for filter inputremasis authored 4 months ago

4f217a6dc7

Brow se code

f low picker/builder workingremasis authored 4 months ago

7ca8fb5795

Brow se code

mov ed flow filters to an array instead of an object mapremasis authored 4 months ago

b3ab689c6d

Brow se code

mov ed filterbuilder to directiv e but brokenremasis authored 4 months ago

80a15395d3

Brow se code

cleanup. begin mov ing to filterbuilder directiv eremasis authored 4 months ago

bf1780644d

Brow se code

f ixed select css remasis authored 4 months ago

… 254f614947

Brow se code

added keyObj generatorremasis authored 4 months ago

81c175c0a2

Brow se code

static filter working on flowfilter pageremasis authored 4 months ago

97281e9207

Brow se code

added logic for f ilter ing on objects that don't hav e that property (t… remasis authored 4 months ago

… 844f57ac6e

Brow se code

added filterOp = support for numbersremasis authored 4 months ago

1d36fcef26

Brow se code

added support for str ing filter Opsremasis authored 4 months ago

85eaed119e

Brow se code

functions and tests for filtersremasis authored 4 months ago

97a6021b3e

Brow se code

posture for socketFlow filtersremasis authored 4 months ago

92d93e9753

Brow se code

f lowfilter testingremasis authored 5 months ago

402d32c4dc

Brow se code

mov ed v isdom spark handling to v is3d controller and flowSocket just remasis authored 5 months ago

… ae7115ad38

Brow se code

« Newer Older »

Status API Training Shop Blog About© 2013 GitHub, Inc. Terms Privacy Security Contact EXHIBIT B

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 7 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master?page=2 3/3EXHIBIT B

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 8 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master?page=3 1/2

May 30, 2013

May 29, 2013

May 28, 2013

May 27, 2013

May 25, 2013

Sign up Sign in

5 2 Star Forkvisdom / visdomPUBLIC

masterbranch: v isdom / Commits

renamed v isdom spark stuff in flowSocket to dispatchUpdate for genericremasis authored 5 months ago

35bdf9ee89

Brow se code

bugfixes and more unit testsremasis authored 5 months ago

ef20526e42

Brow se code

remov ed debug commentremasis authored 5 months ago

69955074fd

Brow se code

debugging on entity resolutionremasis authored 5 months ago

b9ed9aad09

Brow se code

Merge branch 'angAddEntit ies' into refactorVtoAngremasis authored 5 months ago

f677839f33

Brow se code

deleting a flow now clears itself from the entity queues and remov es remasis authored 5 months ago

… 434f20d53d

Brow se code

changed entity resolution to static v alue temporarily until mimir remasis authored 5 months ago

… 76419d4014

Brow se code

added entity information resolution and testingremasis authored 5 months ago

42b9f25187

Brow se code

mov ed socketFlow serv ice to core instead of f lowView moduleremasis authored 5 months ago

a203fd982f

Brow se code

remov ed test coderemasis authored 5 months ago

060b530f0a

Brow se code

mov ed v isdom3D to directiv eremasis authored 5 months ago

04a8832069

Brow se code

put v is3d dependency on all f lows controllerremasis authored 5 months ago

f7c53639be

Brow se code

mov ed v isdom init code to angular serv ice v is3dremasis authored 5 months ago

98ec854850

Brow se code

mov ed colors to v isdom objremasis authored 5 months ago

df038ff85c

Brow se code

Merge branch 'dev 'remasis authored 5 months ago

8d044e6309

Brow se code

remov ed debugremasis authored 5 months ago

fb659563db

Brow se code

mov ed entit ies, groups, and other objs into v isdom objremasis authored 5 months ago

dc157aede1

Brow se code

mov ed SELECTED, INTERSECTED, and mouse (for 3d picking) to v isdom obj b467e6cb81

Explore Features Enterprise BlogSearch or type a commandThis repos itory

EXHIBIT C

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 9 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master?page=3 2/2

May 21, 2013

remasis authored 5 months ago Brow se code

mov ed projected to v isdom objremasis authored 5 months ago

cbc8fdec6b

Brow se code

mov ed stats and dLight to v isdom objremasis authored 5 months ago

79eef25612

Brow se code

mov ed controls to VISDOM objremasis authored 5 months ago

b731ece0d3

Brow se code

mov ed renderer into VISDOM objectremasis authored 5 months ago

c1e073088d

Brow se code

mov ed global functions to VISDOM objectremasis authored 5 months ago

31aa607340

Brow se code

camera and scene mov ed into VISDOM objectremasis authored 5 months ago

07ad03cece

Brow se code

perf testing on potentially mov ing v isdom into angular. No need to watch remasis authored 5 months ago

… 9ce9fb759f

Brow se code

created shell ang serv ice to demonstrate possible breakout for v is3dremasis authored 5 months ago

e97a51b91b

Brow se code

bug fixesremasis authored 5 months ago

b0c88d8066

Brow se code

cleaned up v ersion pageremasis authored 5 months ago

5dde4452d1

Brow se code

logo testingremasis authored 6 months ago

0115b072fa

Brow se code

new logosremasis authored 6 months ago

687a5c9da4

Brow se code

stub threejs updateremasis authored 6 months ago

82bd5876f9

Brow se code

stubbed: init new webgl context in angular serv ice.remasis authored 6 months ago

5984b2645a

Brow se code

Merge branch 'hotfix-perf' into devremasis authored 5 months ago

0caaabf290

Brow se code

remov ed mater ial.dispose when deleting sparks. Threejs performance remasis authored 5 months ago

… dc0bb2cbc2

Brow se code

updated fav icon to v isdom logoremasis authored 5 months ago

8e3f059973

Brow se code

« Newer Older »

Status API Training Shop Blog About© 2013 GitHub, Inc. Terms Privacy Security Contact

EXHIBIT C

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 10 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master?page=4 1/3

May 20, 2013

May 02, 2013

May 01, 2013

Apr 29, 2013

Apr 27, 2013

Apr 26, 2013

Apr 25, 2013

Apr 24, 2013

Sign up Sign in

5 2 Star Forkvisdom / visdomPUBLIC

masterbranch: v isdom / Commits

Merge branch 'dev 'remasis authored 5 months ago

05911bd779

Brow se code

Merge branch 'geoip' into devremasis authored 6 months ago

8377ef81c3

Brow se code

mov ed map to be more prominentremasis authored 6 months ago

64188e5905

Brow se code

f ixed unit test spec to mock v isdom piecesremasis authored 6 months ago

e0b3f90c4b

Brow se code

GeoIP working...but it 's a hack job. Need to re-work 3D stuff into remasis authored 6 months ago

… 9d4b3836f9

Brow se code

generic GEOLOCATED group working zomgremasis authored 6 months ago

d4605c16c3

Brow se code

updated unit tests. All appear to be working on the angular side. Next remasis authored 6 months ago

… e6b90a9284

Brow se code

cleaned up handleGeoIPResponse returns and commentsremasis authored 6 months ago

7947cf25ec

Brow se code

switched geoIP websocket to use promises and added unit tests for that`remasis authored 6 months ago

495c79f9e1

Brow se code

f ixed testingremasis authored 6 months ago

05c2f85389

Brow se code

customized scrollbarremasis authored 6 months ago

3c3c0399fb

Brow se code

created init ial stub stuff for querying goflow on geoip. I'm an idiot remasis authored 6 months ago

… dd0036bf07

Brow se code

Merge branch 'f ixSmoothies' into devremasis authored 6 months ago

2b323a979c

Brow se code

f ixed smoothie bugremasis authored 6 months ago

20ec8fa60c

Brow se code

added shitty v ersion of logo that shows up on grey. don't tell amanda i remasis authored 6 months ago

… c23b754e56

Brow se code

Explore Features Enterprise BlogSearch or type a commandThis repos itory

EXHIBIT D

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 11 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master?page=4 2/3

Apr 23, 2013

Apr 22, 2013

Apr 19, 2013

Apr 17, 2013

Apr 13, 2013

Merge branch 'bootstrap' into devremasis authored 6 months ago

1cab022cfb

Brow se code

scaffolding for array map to make flows (using objects) sortable. For remasis authored 6 months ago

… 569a9134ca

Brow se code

changed data updater to be more intelligent instead of just raw remasis authored 6 months ago

… b7c0f6760d

Brow se code

added bootstrap stuff to hopefully pretty things up a bit.remasis authored 6 months ago

0cd7e66c94

Brow se code

added tmp logos until Amanda gets us the full suiteremasis authored 6 months ago

265200caf0

Brow se code

added more " use str ict"remasis authored 6 months ago

63057b356a

Brow se code

added angularui bootstrap capability and some testing on v ersion pageremasis authored 6 months ago

7e1f1a0525

Brow se code

major cleanup: jshint changes remasis authored 6 months ago

… cbb79b2624

Brow se code

cleaned up smoothiechart directiv e and some other thingsremasis authored 6 months ago

80adaa4ddf

Brow se code

updated testsremasis authored 6 months ago

a1a03193b1

Brow se code

comment cleanupremasis authored 6 months ago

458b58f1f1

Brow se code

format cleanupremasis authored 6 months ago

51410659ca

Brow se code

f ix tooltip lag when camera mov esremasis authored 6 months ago

775e8570a9

Brow se code

Merge branch 'threejsr58' into devremasis authored 6 months ago

7f3680b714

Brow se code

updated to use threejs r58remasis authored 6 months ago

c16032018f

Brow se code

updated comments and remov ed old E2ETESTING debug stuff. remasis authored 6 months ago

… 9c51807fab

Brow se code

Updated three.js to r58 and the Trackball controlsremasis authored 6 months ago

76e2501e4e

Brow se code

Merge branch 'websocket' into devremasis authored 6 months ago

ac174b74c5

Brow se code

modded test page to be idiot proofremasis authored 6 months ago

2de64aa3f1

Brow se code

updated serv ices to update 3d and reconnect on lost socket.remasis authored 6 months ago

a75d24393d

Brow se code

« Newer Older »

EXHIBIT D

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 12 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master?page=4 3/3

Status API Training Shop Blog About© 2013 GitHub, Inc. Terms Privacy Security Contact

EXHIBIT D

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 13 of 14

10/22/13 Commits · visdom/visdom · GitHub

https://github.com/visdom/visdom/commits/master?page=5 1/1

Apr 13, 2013

Apr 12, 2013

Apr 09, 2013

Apr 01, 2013

Mar 29, 2013

Mar 28, 2013

Sign up Sign in

5 2 Star Forkvisdom / visdomPUBLIC

masterbranch: v isdom / Commits

re-added timeSeries graphsremasis authored 6 months ago

2fee1e484b

Brow se code

remov ed superFlow serv ice and mov ed ev erything ov er to use socketFlowremasis authored 6 months ago

fde743e017

Brow se code

updated socketFlow serv ice to use corrected websockets in goflowremasis authored 6 months ago

544c63091b

Brow se code

added simple websocket debug test pageremasis authored 6 months ago

0af7a55b29

Brow se code

Merge branch 'nganimate' into devremasis authored 7 months ago

a1f2a18c35

Brow se code

updated angular to 1.1.4 to try ngAnimate. test code is on v erstion remasis authored 7 months ago

… 4ba9b1636a

Brow se code

added radix to parseInt (best practice)remasis authored 7 months ago

7278a0f917

Brow se code

updated testacular to karma (his recode)remasis authored 7 months ago

236a306b7a

Brow se code

init ial commitremasis authored 7 months ago

28a5325400

Brow se code

init ial test commitremasis authored 7 months ago

7dd984f755

Brow se code

« Newer Older »

Status API Training Shop Blog About© 2013 GitHub, Inc. Terms Privacy Security Contact

Explore Features Enterprise BlogSearch or type a commandThis repos itory

EXHIBIT E

Case 4:13-cv-00442-BLW Document 24 Filed 10/22/13 Page 14 of 14