View
222
Download
3
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
11
Discriminating Word Senses Discriminating Word Senses Using Using
McQuitty’s Similarity AnalysisMcQuitty’s Similarity Analysis
Amruta PurandareAmruta PurandareUniversity of Minnesota, DuluthUniversity of Minnesota, Duluth
Advisor : Dr Ted PedersenAdvisor : Dr Ted Pedersen
Research supported by National Science Foundation Research supported by National Science Foundation (NSF)(NSF)
Faculty Early Career Development Award Faculty Early Career Development Award (#0092784)(#0092784)
22
Discriminating “line”Discriminating “line”
They will begin line formation before ceremonyConnect modem to any jack on your line
Quit printing after the last line of each fileYour line will not get tied while you are connected to net
Stand balanced and comfortable during line upLines that do not fit a page are truncated
New line service provides reliable connections Pages are separated by line feed characters They stand far right when in line formation
33
They will begin line formation before ceremonyStand balanced and comfortable during line up
They stand far right when in line formation
Your line will not get tied while you are connected to netConnect modem to any jack on your line
New line service provides reliable connections
Quit printing after the last line of each pageLines that do not fit a page are truncated
Pages are separated by line feed characters
44
IntroductionIntroduction• What is Word Sense Discrimination ?What is Word Sense Discrimination ?
• Unsupervised learning Unsupervised learning
Training
Test
Features
Feature Vectors
ClustersClusters
55
Representing contextRepresenting context
• Features (from training)Features (from training)•Bi grams Bi grams
•Unigrams Unigrams
•Second Order Co-occurrences/SOCs Second Order Co-occurrences/SOCs (Schütze98)(Schütze98)
•MixtureMixture
• Feature vectors (Binary)Feature vectors (Binary)
• Measuring similarity Measuring similarity •CosineCosine
•MatchMatch
66
Feature examplesFeature examples
<features> for line<features> for line
UnigraUnigramm
<blank> <text> <service> <connection> <blank> <text> <service> <connection> <modem><modem>
<paragraph> <jack> <reliable> <circuit> <file><paragraph> <jack> <reliable> <circuit> <file>
Bi gramBi gram <blank, <blank, lineline> <text, > <text, lineline> >
<text, paragraph> <blank, space><text, paragraph> <blank, space>
<<lineline, service> <modem, jack>, service> <modem, jack>
<phone, service> <connection, <phone, service> <connection, lineline>>
<reliable, connection><reliable, connection>
SOCsSOCs <space> <paragraph> <phone> <reliable><space> <paragraph> <phone> <reliable>
77
McQuitty’s methodMcQuitty’s method
• Pedersen & Bruce, Pedersen & Bruce, 19971997
• AgglomerativeAgglomerative
• UPGMA / Average UPGMA / Average LinkLink
• Stopping rules Stopping rules – Number of clustersNumber of clusters– Score cutoffScore cutoff
88
EvaluationEvaluationS1S1 S2S2 S3S3 S4S4
C1C1 1010 00 33 22
C2C2 11 11 77 11
C3C3 22 11 11 66
C4C4 22 1515 11 22
99
EvaluationEvaluationS1S1 S3S3 S4S4 S2S2
C1C1 1010 33 22 00 1515
C2C2 11 77 11 11 1010
C3C3 22 11 66 11 1010
C4C4 22 11 22 1515 2020
1515 1212 1111 1717 5555
1111
Experimental DataExperimental Data
LineLine Senseval-2Senseval-2
#Senses#Senses 66 VariableVariable
Selected top 5Selected top 5
#instanc#instanceses
41464146
(1200:600)(1200:600)120/word, 73 words120/word, 73 words
(100-150:50-100)(100-150:50-100)
1212
Scope of the experimentsScope of the experiments
• 584 experiments (73 * 4 * 2)584 experiments (73 * 4 * 2)– 73 Words: 72 Senseval-2, LINE73 Words: 72 Senseval-2, LINE– 4 Features: Bi grams, Unigrams, SOCs, Mix4 Features: Bi grams, Unigrams, SOCs, Mix– 2 Similarity Measures: Match, Cosine2 Similarity Measures: Match, Cosine
• Window = 5 Window = 5 – for Bi grams and SOCsfor Bi grams and SOCs
• Frequency cutoff = 2Frequency cutoff = 2
1313
Senseval-2 Results POS wiseSenseval-2 Results POS wise
66 77
55 33
77 88
COSCOS MATMAT
SOSOCC
BIBI
UNIUNI
COCOSS
MAMATT
COCOSS
MAMATT
11 11
00 00
11 00
1111 66
55 55
1313 99
SOSOCC
BIBI
UNIUNI
SOSOCC
BIBI
UNIUNI
No of words of a POS for which experiment obtained
accuracy more than Majority
1414
Senseval-2 Results Feature Senseval-2 Results Feature wisewise
66 77
1111 66
11 11
COSCOS MATMAT
NN
VV
ADJADJ
COCOSS
MAMATT COCO
SSMAMATT
77 88
1313 99
11 00
55 33
55 55
00 00
NN
VV
ADJADJNN
VV
ADJADJ
1515
Senseval-2 Results Measure Senseval-2 Results Measure wisewise
66 55 77
1111 55 1313
11 00 11
SOCSOC BIBI UNIUNI
NN
VV
ADJADJ
SOSOCC
BIBI UNIUNI
77 33 88
66 55 99
11 00 00
NN
VV
ADJADJ
1616
0.250.25 0.230.23
0.190.19 0.180.18
0.210.21 0.200.20
COSCOS MATMAT
SOCSOC
BIBI
UNIUNI
Line Results Line Results
On uniform distribution of 6 senses
1717
Sample Confusion Table Sample Confusion Table (fine.soc.cos)(fine.soc.cos)
5.005.00
11.6711.67
63.3363.33
16.6716.67
3.333.33
11.611.677
8.338.33 5050 23.323.333
6.66.677
22 00 00 11 00
11 00 44 22 00
22 55 2525 22 44
11 00 00 99 00
11 00 11 00 00
S0S0 S1S1 S2S2 S3S3 S4S4
77 55 3030 1414 44
33
77
3838
1010
22
60 S0 = elegantS1 = small grained
S2 = superior S3 = satisfactory
S4 = thin
1818
ConclusionsConclusions• Small set of SOCs was powerfulSmall set of SOCs was powerful
– Half the number of unigrams/bigramsHalf the number of unigrams/bigrams• Scaling done by Cosine helps !Scaling done by Cosine helps !• Need more training data!Need more training data!• Need to improve feature… Need to improve feature…
• Selection (Tests of associations)Selection (Tests of associations)• extraction (Stemming)extraction (Stemming)• matching (Fuzzy matching)matching (Fuzzy matching)
… …strategies for bi grams strategies for bi grams • Explore new featuresExplore new features
• POS POS • CollocationsCollocations
1919
Recent workRecent work
• PDL implementation PDL implementation • Cluto - Clustering Toolkit Cluto - Clustering Toolkit
http://www-users.cs.umn.edu/~karypis/clutohttp://www-users.cs.umn.edu/~karypis/cluto•6 clustering methods, 12 merging criteria6 clustering methods, 12 merging criteria
• PlansPlans– Comparing clustering in Comparing clustering in
similarity space Vs vector space (similarity space Vs vector space (Schütze, Schütze, 19981998))
– Stopping rulesStopping rules
2020
They will begin line formation before ceremonyStand balanced and comfortable during line up
They stand far right when in line formation
Your line will not get tied while you are connected to netConnect modem to any jack on your line
New line service provides reliable connections
Quit printing after the last line of each fileLines that do not fit a page are truncated
Pages are separated by line feed characters
Sense labelingSense labeling
2121
Software PackagesSoftware Packages
• SenseClusters SenseClusters (Our Discrimination Toolkit)(Our Discrimination Toolkit) http://www.d.umn.edu/~tpederse/senseclusters.htmlhttp://www.d.umn.edu/~tpederse/senseclusters.html
• PDL PDL (Used to implement clustering algorithms)(Used to implement clustering algorithms)http://pdl.perl.org/http://pdl.perl.org/
• NSP NSP (Used for extracting features)(Used for extracting features)http://www.d.umn.edu/~tpederse/nsp.htmlhttp://www.d.umn.edu/~tpederse/nsp.html
• SenseTools SenseTools (Used for preprocessing, feature (Used for preprocessing, feature matching)matching)http://www.d.umn.edu/~tpederse/sensetools.htmlhttp://www.d.umn.edu/~tpederse/sensetools.html
• Cluto Cluto (Clustering Toolkit)(Clustering Toolkit)http://www-users.cs.umn.edu/~karypis/clutohttp://www-users.cs.umn.edu/~karypis/cluto