91
1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCK•CEN

1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

1

Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities

Mathieu Ponnet

SCK•CEN

Page 2: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

2

• Objectives and selection criteria• Full System Decontamination• Decontamination of components/parts• Conclusions

One detail example (BR3 case) in each part

Summary

Page 3: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

3

Definition

• Decontamination is defined as the removal of contamination from surfaces by

Washing Heating Chemical or electrochemical action Mechanical action Others (melting…)

Page 4: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

4

3 main reasons

• To remove the contamination from components to reduce dose level in the installation (save dose during dismantling)

• To minimize the potential for spreading contamination during decommissioning

• To reduce the contamination of components to such levels that may be Disposed of at a lower category Recycled or reused in the conventional

industry (clearance of material)

Page 5: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

5

Decontamination for decommissioning

• In maintenance work, we must avoid any damage to the component for adequate reuse

• In decommissioning, decontamination techniques can be destructive, the main goal being the removal of as much activity as possible (high DF)

Page 6: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

6

Decontamination before Dismantling

Objectives : Reduction of occupational Exposure

Pipe Line System Decontamination

Closed systemPool, Tank

Open system

Chemical Method

Mechanical method

Hydro jet Method

Blast Method

Strippable coating Method

Page 7: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

7

Decontamination after Dismantling

Objectives : Reduction of radioactive waste or recycling

Pipes, Components

Open or closed system

Chemical Immersion Method

Electrochemical Method

Blast Method

Ultrasonic wave Method

Gel Method

Page 8: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

8

Decontamination Of Building

Objectives : Reduction of radioactive concrete waste or Release of building

Concrete Surface

Mechanical Method

Scabbler

Shaver

Blast Method

Concrete Demolition

Explosives

Jackhammer

Drill &Spalling

Page 9: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

9

Selecting a specific decontamination technique

• Need to be considered Safety: Not increase radiological or classical

hazards Efficiency: Sufficient DF to reach the objectives Cost-effectiveness: should not exceed the

cost for waste treatment and disposal Waste minimization: should not rise large

quantities of waste resulting in added costs, work power and exposure

Feasibility of industrialization: Should not be labour intensive, difficult to handle or difficult to automate.

Page 10: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

10

Parameters for the selection of a decontamination process

• Type of plant and plant process• Operating history of the plant• Type of components: pipe, tank• Type of material: steel, Zr, concrete• Type of surface: rough, porous, coated…• Type of contaminants: oxide, crud, sludge…• Composition of the contaminant (activation products, actinides… and

radionuclide involved)• Ease of access to areas/plant, internal or external contaminated

surface• Decontamination factor required• Destination of the components after decontamination• Time required for application• Capability of treatment and conditioning of the secondary waste

generated

Page 11: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

11

Some examples about the type of material

• Stainless steel: Resistant to corrosion, difficult to treat, needs a strong decontamination process to remove several µm • Carbon steel: Quite porous and low resistance to corrosion, needs a soft process but the contamination depth reaches several thousand µm (more secondary waste)• Concrete: The contamination will depend of the location and the history of the material, the contamination depth can be few mm to several cm.

Page 12: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

12

Some examples about the type of surface

•Porous: Avoid wet techniques which are penetrant. •Coated: Do we have to remove paint ? (contamination level, determinant for the use of electrochemical techniques)•Presence of crud: what are the objectives ? (reduce the dose or faciliting the waste evacuation)

Right decontamination technique

Page 13: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

13

Some examples about decontamination factor

required

Primary circuit of BWR and PWR reactors

Outer layer : Fe2O3, Iron rich

Intermediate layer (CRUD) : FeCr2O4, Cr2O3, Chromium rich

Base alloy : Fe, Cr, Ni

DF

1-5

5-50

50-10,000

Soft decontamination process

Thorough decontamination process

1-5 µm

2-10 µm

5 – 30 µm

Right decontamination technique

Page 14: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

14

Pipes, tanks, pools…

Some examples about the type of components

Right decontamination technique

Decontamination in a closed system? (avoids the spreading of contamination…) Decontamination in an open system after dismantling? (secondary waste…) Connection to the components, dose rate, the total filling up of the component, auxiliary…

Page 15: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

15

Some examples about the treatment of secondary waste

Availability of a facility to treat secondary waste from decontamination (chemical solutions, aerosols, debris, …) Final products (packaging, decontaminated effluent,…) have to be conform for final disposal. In decontamination processes, the final wastes are concentrated, representing a significant radiation source.

Page 16: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

16

Overview of decontamination process for metals

• Chemical process In closed system (APCE, TURCO, CORD, SODP, EMMA,

LOMI, DFD, Foams or various reagents…) In open system on dismantled components (MEDOC,

Cerium/nitric acid, CANDEREM, DECOHA, DFDX or various reagents, HNO3, HCl, HF,…)

• Electrochemical process (open or close system) Phosphoric acid, Nitric acid, Oxalic or citric acid, sulfuric

acid or others process• Physical process (open system)

Wet or dry abrasives, Ultrasonic cleaning, HPW, CO2 ice blasting, others…

Page 17: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

17

Decontamination Techniques Used in Decommissioning Activities

• Objectives and selection criteriaObjectives and selection criteria• Full system Decontamination

General consideration Chemical reagents Spent decontamination solutions Guidelines for selecting appropriate FSD The case of BR3 (CORD)

• Decontamination of components/partsDecontamination of components/parts• ConclusionsConclusions

Page 18: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

18

Full system and closed system Decontamination

• Objectives Reduce the dose rate and avoid spreading of

contamination during dismantling Typical decontamination factor 5 to 40

• Application Decontamination of the primary circuit (RPV,PP, SG

and auxiliary circuits) directly after the shutdown of the reactor

Decontamination of components in a closed loop

• Practical objectives Remove the crud layer of about 5 to 10 µm inside the

primary circuit

Page 19: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

19

Chemical process

• Chemical process commonly used CORD Chemical Oxidizing Reduction

Decontamination based on the used of permanganic acid (AP).

LOMI Low Oxidation State Metal Ion (AP) APCE Process based on the use of

permanganate in alkaline solution NITROX or CITROX based on the use of

nitric or citric acid. EPRI DFD (Decontamination For

Decommissioning) based on the use of fluoroborique acid.

Siemens

England

Russia

Westinghouse

EPRI

Page 20: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

20

Multi-step decontamination process

• Oxidation step Oxidation of the insoluble chromium with

permanganate in alkaline or acidic media, Nitric acid or fluoroboric acid

• Decontamination step A dissolution step is carried out with oxalic acid to

dissolve the crud layer The reduction / dissolution step is enhanced by

complexing agent

• Purification step The excess of oxalic acid is removed using

permanganate or hydrogen peroxide The dissolved cations and the activity are removed

using Ion Exchange Resins.

Page 21: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

21

Chemical reagent

MnO4-

HNO3

HBF4

H2C2O4

oxalatesanionic species

H2O2

CrIII to CrVI

CO2After destruction

Water

Oxidizing agent

for chromium oxide

Dissolving agent

Minimize secondary waste

Destruction agent

Minimize secondary waste

Page 22: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

22

The Full System Decontamination of the primary system of the BR3-PWR reactor

with the Siemens CORD Process

Objectives• Reduce the radiation dose rate by a factor of 10• Remove the surface contamination, the so-called

CRUD to avoid dispersion of contamination during dismantling of contaminated loops

with a particular attention to:• Minimize the amount of secondary wastes• Minimize the radiation exposure of the workers• Minimize the modifications to be done to the plant

for the decontamination operation.

Page 23: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

23

The BR3 primary loop

Page 24: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

24

Full System Decontamination of the primary and auxiliary loops in 1991

• 3 Decontamination Cycles at 80 to 100 °C in 9 days

• For each cycle : 3 steps oxidation step with HMnO4

Reduction step with H2C2O4

Cleaning step with anionic and cationic IEX resins and removal of excess oxalic acid by oxidation with HMnO4 or with H2O2 on catalysts

CORD®: Chemical Oxidizing-Reducing Decontamination

Page 25: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

25

Chemistry of the process

Oxidation Step with Permanganic Acid HMnO4 at 0.3 g/lFor the oxidation of the Chromium from Cr3+ to Cr6+

Temperature 100°C

Decontamination step with Oxalic Acid H2C2O4 at 3 g/lDissolution step for the hematite dissolution and the activity dissolution

Temperature 80°C to 100°C

Cleaning step: Destruction of the excess oxalic acid by oxidation with permanganic acid or with hydrogen peroxide on a catalyst

Combined with fixation of corrosion products on Ion Exchange resinsTemperature: 80 to 60°C (last cycle)

Page 26: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

26

Process steps for each cycle

Step nr 1: OxidationInjection of permanganic acid

Circulation during several hours

Step nr 2: Reduction + Decontamination

Injection of oxalic acid - CirculationPurification on ion exchange

Step nr 3: Cleaning Destruction of organics +

purification on ion exchange

Process Steps Chemicals in solution Ion exchangeResins

MnO4-

C2O42-

Cr, Fe oxalatesanionic species

Water, CO2

Ni2+, Mn2+, Co2+

Fixation on cationic IEX

Cr, Fe oxalatesFixation on

anionicIEX

Page 27: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

27

Total activity removed for each cycle

Page 28: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

28

Primary loop Decontamination factors

ComponentDose rate before

mSv/hDose rate after

mSv/hDF

HOT LEG 1.74 0.125 14

COLD LEG 1 1.58 0.16 10

COLD LEG 2 0.74 0.11 7

MAKE UP EJECTOR 4.40 1.50 3

PRIMARY PUMP 1 0.46 0.15 3

PRIMARY PUMP 2 0.49 0.13 4

PRESSURIZER 0.47 0.14 3.5

STEAM GENERATOR 0.905 0.05 16

! In some points, still some hot spots due to redeposition in dead zones

horizontal line of the pressurizer, dead zones in heat exchangers..

Page 29: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

29

• Phase I : Preparatory phase manual closure of the reactor pressure

vessel maintenance of the components modifications to the circuits

• Phase II : Decontamination operation hot run 3 decontamination Cycles

• Phase III : Post decontamination operations evacuation of the liquid wastes evacuation of the solid wastes

The total dose amounted to only 159 man*mSvThe dose saving up to now is over 500 man*mSv

16.9 man*mSv

6.4 man*mSv

135.3 man*mSv

Radiological aspects

Page 30: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

30

Main data and results

• Contaminated surface treated 1200 m2

• Primary system volume 15 m3

• Corrosion products removed 33 kg• Mean Crud layer removed 5 µm• IEX Waste volume produced 1.35 m3

• Final waste volume 8 m3

• Dose rate in primary system 0.08 mSv/h • Dose rate purification system 0.06 mSv/h • Mean Decontamination factor ~ 10• Collective Dose exposure 0.16 man.Sv

Page 31: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

31

• Expected ... Smooth process, minor operational problems Careful and detailed preparation is a must Requires a reactor in full satisfactory conditions To be performed shortly after the operation Man-Sv savings for future dismantling justify the operation

• Unexpected ... More ion exchange resins needed and higher liquid waste

volume Pollution of the reactor pool during reactor opening due to

the presence of insoluble iron oxalate and loose crud: could be easily removed by the plant filtration

Internals of RPV remarkably clean facilitating inspection and dismantling and allowing to evacuate waste in a lower category LAW vs MAW

Lessons drawn from the operation …

Page 32: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

32

Guidelines for selecting appropriate FSD

• Objectives in terms of Decontamination Factor• Type of material: Acidic solution is not appropriate for

carbon steel• Volume of secondary waste: preferred regenerative

process (Lomi, DfD, CORD…)• Composition of secondary waste: avoid organic element

like EDTA (Complexing agent)• Type of oxide layer: Select an oxidizing process for high

chromium content in the CRUD• Capability of treatment and conditioning of the

secondary waste generated (Evaporation, IEX, Precipitation, filtration…)

Page 33: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

33

Decontamination Techniques Used in Decommissioning Activities

• Objectives and selection criteriaObjectives and selection criteria• Full system decontaminationFull system decontamination• Decontamination of components/parts

General considerations Chemical decontamination Electrochemical decontamination Mechanical decontamination Decontamination by melting Guidelines for selecting appropriate decontamination

techniques The case of BR3 (ZOE - MEDOC)

• ConclusionsConclusions

Page 34: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

34

Decontamination of components/parts

• To reduce the contamination of components to such levels that they may be Disposed of at a lower category -

decategorization Recycled or reused in the conventional

industry (clearance of material)

• The decontamination can be applied: In a closed system on an isolated

component (circuits, steam generator…)

In an open system on dismantling material in batch treatment.

Page 35: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

35

• Multi-step processesSame processes : Lomi, Cord,

Canderem

• Processes in one single step (Hard decontamination process)Cerium IV process : SODP,

REDOX, MEDOCHNO3/HF

HBF4 : Decoha, DfD..

Chemical decontamination

Page 36: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

36

Cerium IV process

• The cerium IV process is a one step treatment.

• The cerium is a strong oxidizing agent (Eo = 1.61 V) in mixture with acid (Nitric acid or Sulfuric acid)

• The cerium IV dissolves oxide layer and the base metal.

• Cerium can be regenerated and recycled.• The neutralization of cerium IV and the

treatment of the solution for final conditioning are simple.

Page 37: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

37

Cerium IV process

T (°C) Acid Regeneration

Origin Appli-cation

Speed

SODP Amb HNO3 O3 Sweden Closed loop

Low

REDOX 60-80°C HNO3 Electro-chemical

Japan Open system

High

MEDOC 80°C H2SO4 O3 Belgium Open and

closed loop

High

Page 38: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

38

The MEDOC process has been selected for its high decontamination efficiency

Clearance of material

Objectives

MEDOC process at BR3

Page 39: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

39

MEDOC : Only one step treatment

Regenerationof cerium IV

Ce 4+

Ce 3+

Cerium solutionO2

Ozonegas

ContaminatedMaterial

Free release

Decontamination

Page 40: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

40

BR3 industrial plant is characterized by three stages

O3

O2

waste treatment

Decon.loop

Rinsingloop

1

2

3

Page 41: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

41

Effluents are partially treated by SCK and transported to Belgoprocess

Waste

SCK-CEN Belgoprocess

Ph NeutralizationPrecipitationFiltration

15 kg/m3 total4 Gbq/m3

Cerium neutralizationNitric acid

10 T < 5 %

0.3 T

Asphalt

Page 42: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

42

Medoc workshop after installation

Page 43: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

43

Control room

Page 44: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

44

Safety precautions taken in the MEDOC installation

Due to the combined radioactive and chemical hazards construction materials selected to resist to the aggressive

process unreacted ozone thermally destroyed before release O3 and H2 detectors with automatic actions on the process two independent ventilation systems

Page 45: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

45

Material after decontamination

Page 46: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

46

25 tons of contaminated material have already been treated

Treatment capacity is 0.5 ton per treatment (20 m2)

Average corrosion rate 2.5 µm/h

The treatment time is about 4 to 10 hours

Very low residual contamination < 0.1 Bq/g

Specific activity of material after decontamination in

200 Liters drums

0

0,02

0,04

0,06

0,08

0,1

Page 47: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

47

Steam generator and pressurizer decontamination

in May 2002

Main goal Make the demonstration of large components decontamination using MEDOC Reach the clearance contamination level after melting

Steam generator characteristics (primary loop - SS)

30 tons of mixed stainless and carbon steel Number of tubes 1400 in stainless steel Total length of tubes 15 km Total surface 620 m2 Volume 2.7 m3

7,94

m

Page 48: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

48

Handling of the SG before decontamination

The SG has been removed and placed horizontally

to allow the total filling up of the primary side

Page 49: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

49

Main circulation loop between SG and MEDOC plant

T01

ROV 01

ROV 17HV 02

ROV 21

ROV 18

ROV 04

ROV 03

F01ROV 16

RO

V 2

2

T02

RO

V 0

5

ROV 19

ROV 13

P05P02

MS01

ROV 07

ROV 08

R01

ROV 09

FLT 01

RBS 82

RBS81

PCV 02

RBS 85

RBS 80

RBS83

Treatment gas Medoc

RBS 86 RBS 84RBS 87

Decontamination step I

MEDOC

Page 50: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

50

Workload

30 decontamination cycles are needed :

Decontamination (2 hours)

Regeneration of cerium IV (4 hours)

After 15 cycles, the SG was rotated for homogenous attack on the primary side.

60 hours decontamination and 130 hours of regeneration about 3 weeks with 2 working teams.

Page 51: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

51

• 10 µm or 42 kg of material were removed on the overall surface.

• 2.06 Gbq of Co60

• The tube bundle was manually rinsed via the primary head with pressurized water.

• Low radiation level in the primary head (few µSv/h) - no free contamination

Reach the clearance contamination level after melting

Page 52: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

52

Conclusions on MEDOC

Contaminated materials are successfully decontaminated using a batchwise technique in MEDOC plant.

Up to now, 80% of treated materials have been cleared and sold to a scrap dealer (including primary pipes)

Remaining 20% can be cleared after melting (< 1 Bq/g) The loop treatment of the BR3-SG was also a success

It will easy the post-operation dismantling (HPWJC), It will avoid the evacuation of huge components in a

waste category.

Page 53: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

53

HNO3/HF processes

• The sulfonitric mixture is commonly used for the etching of stainless steel

in batch process in pulverization solution

• The liquid penetrates the oxide layer to attack the base metal (thorough decontamination process).

• The oxides come off the surface and stay in the solution.

• The oxides are eliminated by filtration.

Page 54: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

54

• The efficiency increases with the concentration and the temperature.

• However, it decreases with the increasing of dissolved material.

• This is not a regenerative process, new HF has to be added to the solution and produces more effluents.

HNO3/HF processes

Page 55: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

55

• Application : Not very attractive in batch

treatment due to the consumption of reagent

Good result in pulverisation process at low temperature followed by rinsing with pressurised water jet.

HNO3/HF processes

• Safety Need of special attention to the

worker safety due to the presence of HF and fluoride.

Page 56: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

56

HBF4 processes

• The fluororic acid is able to dissolve both the oxide layer and the base alloy on stainless or carbon steel

• This process is used in batch treatment or in pulverization process

• The fluoroboric acid can be regenerated by electrodeposition of the metal.

Decoha or DfD processes

Page 57: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

57

Regeneration of HBF4

Cathode (-) Anode (+)

Ion

Exchange

Membrane

H+

Inlet solution

Outlet solution to filter

Metal Particles

Dissolution reaction (Decontamination)

Fe + 2 HBF4 Fe(BF4)2 + H2

Cathodics reactions

Fe(BF4)2 + 2e- Fe + 2 BF4 -

Anodic reaction

H2O 2 H+ + 2e- + ½ O2

Recombination after membrane transfer

2H+ + 2 BF4 - HBF4

2H+ + 2 e-- H2

Page 58: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

58

Application

• Compared to the cerium or sulphonitric process, it is less aggressive (lower rate)

• Due to the formation of hydrogen in the decontamination and regeneration steps, the process required special safety attention (monitoring, ventilation, dilution with air…)

• The 137Cs which is not deposited has to be eliminated in IEX or by added chemical treatment.

Page 59: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

59

Advantages for chemical decontamination

• Chemical decontamination allows the treatment of complex geometry material (hidden parts, inside parts of tubes,…)

• With strong mineral acids, DF over 104 can be reached allowing the clearance of material

• With proper selection of chemicals, almost all radionuclides may be removed

• Chemical decontamination is a known practice in many nuclear plants and facilities (experience…)

Page 60: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

60

• The main disadvantage is the generation of secondary liquid waste which requires appropriate processes for final treatment and conditioning

• The safety due to the chemical hazard with high corrosive products (Acid, gas,…) and by-products (H2, HF, …)

• Chemical decontamination is mostly not effective on porous surfaces

Disadvantages for chemical decontamination

Page 61: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

61

Electrochemical decontamination

• Electrolytic polishing is an anodic dissolution technique

• Material to be decontaminated is the anode, the cathode being an electrode or the tank itself

• Objectives : removed hot spot lowered dose rate decategorisation of material

Page 62: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

62

+

-

chemical or

electrochemical

bath with acid or salt

Electrochemical decontamination

• Phosphoric acid• Nitric acid• Sulfuric acid• Sodium sulfate

Electrolyte

High current density at low voltage

Page 63: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

63

Application

• Electropolishing can be used for the treatment of Carbon steel, Stainless steel, Aluminum

• Electropolishing requires conducting surfaces (the paint must be removed)

• Not really adapted for small or complex geometry material with hidden parts (current density inside pipes, …)

Page 64: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

64

Special technique at KRB A plant in Gundremmingen

Decontamination of

stainless steel parts with

phosphoric acid

• quick processing time• reliability• less secondary waste• maximal recycling effect

Electropolishing

Page 65: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

65

Principle of electropolishing

Oxide skin

Base material

before after

+

-

H2PO4

6000 A

at low voltage

chemical or

electrochemical

bath with phosphoric acid

Page 66: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

66

Stainless Steel in Acid Bath

Page 67: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

67

Stainless Steel after Electropolishing

Page 68: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

68

Regeneration of Phosphoric Acid

• Recycling of Phosphoric acid by

• Reuse acid for decontamination

• Thermolysis of iron oxalat

- adding oxalic acid

- precipitate the dissolved iron as

- iron oxalate

- extracting the iron oxalate

- vaporization

- heating the iron oxalate

- transformation into iron oxide for final storage

Page 69: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

69

Schematic principle of Regeneration

Dilute acid to concentrated

Page 70: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

70

Thermolysis plant for iron oxalate

190°C

Page 71: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

71

Example „Secondary Steam Generator“

Vessels of three Steam Generators

decontaminated from 20,000 Bq/cm²

to free release

producing only 1,5% radioactive waste

Page 72: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

72

Electropolishing processes

Electro-lyte

Conc

M

Current density

A/m2

Elec-trode

Time

Hours

Corro-sion rateµm/h

AEA/ Harwell

HNO31 20-30 Ti 2 NC

CEA/UDIN

HNO32 100-300 Basket

Ti1-3 16 – 20

Toshiba H2SO40.5 3000 –

1000060°C

NC <1 60-240

EldeconABB/

Sweden

Na2SO40.5 1000-

6000NC <1 60

Page 73: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

73

Advantages of Electropolishing

• Commercially available and relatively inexpensive

• Large panel of material and geometry (water box of SG, tanks, large pieces,…) can be treated with this technique

• High corrosion rate and quick treatment

• Low volume of secondary waste.

Page 74: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

74

• Electropolishing does not remove fuels, sludge or any insulating material

• Inside parts of tubes or hidden parts are treated poorly

• Like chemical processes, secondary liquid waste are generated. This method is less applicable for industrial decontamination of complex geometries: limited by the size of the batch in immersion

process The access to contaminated parts and free space

are required when an electrode (pad) is used• Handling of components may lead to additional

exposure to workers

Disadvantages of Electropolishing

Page 75: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

75

Mechanical decontamination

• Mechanical decontaminations are often less aggressive than the chemical ones but they are a bit simpler to use.

• Mechanical and chemical techniques are complementary to achieve good results

• The two basic disadvantages The contaminated surface needs to be accessible Many methods produce air bone dust.

Page 76: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

76

Cleaning with ultrasons

Projection of CO2 ice or water ice

Pressurized water jet

Decontamination with abrasives in wet or dry environment

Mechanical action by grinding, polishing, brushing

Typical Mechanical decontamination

Page 77: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

77

Cleaning with ultrasons

• The cleaning in ultrasonic batch is only applicable for slightly fixed contamination

• Does not allow to remove the fixed contamination

• This technique is used in combination with detergent (Decon 90, …)

• However, it is mainly used to enhance the corrosion effect in chemical decontamination processes (Medoc,…)

Page 78: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

78

Projection of CO2 ice or water ice

• CO2 ice pellets are projected at high speed against the surface

• The CO2 pellets evaporate and remove the contamination

• The operator works in ventilated suit inside a ventilated room to remove CO2 and contamination

• Needs some decontamination tests before selecting the process (not efficient for deep contamination)

Page 79: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

79

Pressurized water jet

• Low pressure water Jet : 50 – 150 bar Pre-decontamination technique Removal of sludge or deposited oxide Decontamination of tools

• Medium pressure water Jet : 150 – 700 bar Usually used for the decontamination of equipments or

large surfaces (pool walls,…) Large water consumption (60 – 6000 L/h) and

contaminated aerosols Requires a suitable ventilation system and a

recirculation loop with filtration (recycling of water)

Page 80: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

80

Decontamination with abrasives

• Uses the power of abrasives projected at high speed against the surface Wet environment: fluid transporter is water Dry environment: fluid transporter is air

• Imperative to ensure the recycling of the abrasive to reduce the secondary waste production

• Needs a suitable ventilated system to remove contamination and aerosols.

Page 81: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

81

Abrasives in wet environment at BR3

Roof opening for large piecesRoof opening for large pieces

Operator at workOperator at work

Page 82: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

82

Abrasives in dry environment

• Decontamination (Metal, plastics, concrete…)

• Decoating• Cleaning• Degreasing

• Working in enclosed area

Page 83: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

83

Abrasives in dry environment at Belgoprocess

• Automatic process in batch treatment

Declogging filter (ventilation)

Load of material

Page 84: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

84

Comparison of the wet and dry sandblasting

• Choose an abrasive with a long lifetime (recycling) Minerals (magnetite, sand,…) Steel pellets, aluminum oxide Ceramic, glass beads Plastic pellets Natural products

• Wet and dry techniques allow to recycle the abrasive by separation Filtration or decantation in wet sandblasting On declogging filter (ventilation) in dry sandblasting

• The air contamination in dry sandblasting is much more important (cross contamination…)

Page 85: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

85

Advantages/Disadvantages abrasive-blasting

• Advantages Effective and commercially available Removes tightly adherent material

(paint, oxide layer…)• Disadvantages

Produces a large amount of secondary waste (abrasive and dust…)

Care to introduce the contamination deeper in porous material.

Page 86: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

86

Mechanical action by grinding, polishing, brushing

• Large range of abrasive belts or rollers available on the market

• Ideal to remove small contaminated surface• Due to the production of dust, used in a

ventilated enclosure, the operator wears protection clothes

Page 87: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

87

Melting of metals

• The melting of metal can be considered as a decontamination technique 137Cs are eliminated in fumes and dust Heavy elements coming from oxide are

eliminated in slag (radioactive waste)• The melting technique is used for

The recycling of material in nuclear field (container,..)

The clearance of ingots after melting (measurement of activity easier …)

Page 88: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

88

Melting of metals

Country Capacity Material Product

Carla Germany 3 t CS, SS, Al, Cu

Ingot, shield blocks,

containers

Studsvik Sweden 3 t CS, SS, Al

Ingot

Page 89: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

89

Advantages of melting

• Advantages of redistributing of radionuclides in ingots/slag and dust: decontamination effect

• Essential step when releasing components with complex geometries (allows the measurement after melting)

Page 90: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

90

Conclusions

• Selection criteria of decontamination techniques for metals The geometry and size of pieces The objectives of the decontamination (dose

rate or waste management…) The nature and the level of contamination The state of the surface and the type of

material The availability of the process

Page 91: 1 Metal Decontamination Techniques used in Decommissioning Activities Mathieu Ponnet SCKCEN

91

Needs for decommissioning

• For decommissioning we need several complementary techniques To reduce the dose rate before dismantling

FSD To treat materials with complex geometries

Chemical decontamination To treat materials with simple geometries

Sand blasting or electrochemical decontamination To decontaminate tools or slightly contaminated

pieces High pressure jet Manuel cleaning Other mechanical techniques

To remove residual ‘hot spot’ after decontamination Mechanical techniques : grinding, brushing

To help in the evacuation route of materials Melting of metals