1. People vs Lizada

8/12/2019 1. People vs Lizada

1/22

!"#$%&'( *+ ,-" .-'&'##'/"0

!"#$%&% ()"$*

12/'&2

34 5647

+,$, -./, 012134560 789:8;< =1> =??2

*@% #%)#A% )B *@% #@CAC##C-%!>#&2'/,'++82##"&&""9

:0;

B$%DDC% ACEFDF G B$%DC% ACEFDF>2(($0" ,-" %?2('/C -"?9 V'00'/C 2/*:'/C -"? 0V'?, 2/< #2/,I9 #&2('/C

-'>0"&+ */ ,*# *+ -"? 2/< ,?I'/C ,* '/0"?, -'0 #"/'0 '/,* -"? :2C'/2 2/< 0$((""


3/22

M/ ,-" >"2/,'>"9 !*0" 0"($?"< 2 &*2/ 2/"@ 2/< $0"< ,-" #?*(""" '/ BQQ^9 6/2&'2 @20 '/ -"? ?**> @-"/ 2(($0"*:"< -'0 +'/C"? 2/< '/0"?,"< -'0 #"/'0 '/ -"? :2C'/2; 1*>"/,2?'&I9 0-" +"&,

2 0,'(VI 0$%0,2/(" (*>'/C *$, +?*> -'0 #"/'0; T-" 2&0* +"&, #2'/ '/ -"? 0"W *?C2/;

T2,'2," *+ 6/2&'29 #&2(" *+ 6/2&'2; `" @20 @"2?'/C 2 #2'? *+ 0-*?,

#2/,0 2/< @20 /2V"< +?*> @2'0, $#; 6/2&'2 *:"< -"? #2/,I 2/< ,*$(-"< -"? 0"W *?C2/; 6(($0"


4/22


5/22

-"? 0,2,">"/,9 6/2&'2 ?":"2&"< ,* -"? >*,-"? ,-2, 2(($0"%"? BD9 BQQR9 6/2&'2 "W"($,"< 2 P4)$5)$ #)

6)0)(3)( #$ 7)$2)2)-0)P 2/< (-2?C"< 2(($0""< ,-2, -" &*:"< ,-" (-'&


6/22

f; 600'C/"< 3??*?0 *+ ,-" =?'2& 7*$?,

6(($0""/, *+ "??*?9 2(($0"#&I @',- ,-" ?"L$'?">"/,0 *+ T"(,'*/ BE9

6?,'(&" fMMM *+ ,-" BQRZ 7*/0,',$,'*/ 2/< T"(,'*/ B9 !$&" Y^ *+ ,-" BQQZ !$&"0 *+ 7':'&.?*("" #"/2&,I *+ 2I @"&&8/'C- 0I/,-"0'H" 2/#&'("9 *? 2(("00*?I 2+,"? ,-" +2(,] J(K ,-" #"/2&,I '>#*0"< $#*/

,-" 2(($0" ,-" 2(($0"< %I ,-" *++"/$0, %" 200$?"< +?*> 2 ?"2"/, 2?"O

PF*? */" ,-'/C9 ,-" &*0'/C #2?,I >$0, %" C':"/ 2/ *##*?,$/',I ,* 2/2&IH" ,-"

',," ,-" T$#?">" 7*$?,9

@'&& (*/0,',$," 2 :2&$2%&" %*'/2& .?*(""0 (-2?C"


8/22

,-" ,?'2& (*$?,9 */" '0 2#, ,* (*/(&$2/< ,-" (20" ,* ,-" ,?'2& (*$?, %"(2$0" *+ ,-" '/+'?>',I *+

,-" " *+ ?2#"9 ,-" ,"0,'>*/I *+ ,-" (*>#&2'/2/, 0-*$&< %" 0(?$,'/'H"< @',- C?"2,

(2$,'*/] JYK ,-" ":'"?',0 2/#&2'/2/,;

M, %"2?0 0,?"00'/C ,-2, $/2,'*/09 ,-" ?2#" '/('%"? BD9 BQQRP 2/< P*/ *? 2%*$, S(,*%"? NN9

BQQR;P =-" @*?%"? BD9 BQQR *? S(,*%"? NN9 BQQR; =-" #?*0"($,'*/ >2I #?*:" ,-2, ,-"

(?'>" (-2?C"< @20 (*>>',,"< */ *? 2%*$, T"#,">%"? BD9 BQQR 2/< */ *? 2%*$,

S(,*%"? NN9 BQQR;

M/ 7%+10% ")#)#9NB

,-'0 7*$?, 2++'?>"< ,-" (*/:'(,'*/ *+ 2(($0">',,"< '/ A"(">%"? BQQN9 */ 2 (?'>'/2& (*>#&2'/, +*? >$&,'#&" ?2#"9

:'HO

P=-2, 0*>",'>" '/ 4*:">%"? BQQD9 2/< 0*>" *((20'*/0 #?'*? 2/2?'i209 .?*:'/(" *+ 72:',"9 2/" "&I *%\"(,'*/ %20"< */ ,-'0 C?*$/< (*/0,',$,"0 2 @2':"? *+ -'0 ?'C-, ,*

*%\"(,;PNY

1*?"*:"?9 @-"/ ,-" #?':2," (*>#&2'/2/, ,"0,'+'"< */ -*@ 2(($0""0 2 @""V +?*> BQQ^ $/,'& BQQR9 2(($0"#&2'/2/, */

-"? ,"0,'>*/I */ >',,"< ,@* ,'>"0 2

@""V +?*> BQQ^ $/,'& BQQR J@-'(- '/(&$"/"/, *+9 ,-" 2+*?"02'2,'*/0 ,* (*/+*?> ,* ,-" ":'";NE

3:"/9 ,-" 0&'C-,"0, #"/",?2,'*/ *+ ,-" 0)-")%I ,-" >2&" *?C2/ *? ,-" >"?" "/,?I

*+ ,-" #"/'0 '/,* ,-" 2#"?,$?" (*/0,',$,"0 (*/0$>>2,"< ?2#"; M, '0 0$++'('"/, ,-2, ,-"?"

%" "/,?2/(" *+ ,-" >2&" *?C2/ @',-'/ ,-" 0)-")*+ ,-"1.5%#5.,;ND

M/7%+10% "/ @',-*$, '/\$?I; M/ ,-"0" (20"09 ,-" #?':2," (*>#&2'/2/, ,"0,'+'"< ,-2, ,-"

#"/'0 *+ 2(($0"0"&+ */ ,*# *+ >"9 0'?;

l a-2, 2 @',/"009 @-2,


11/22

a" 2C?"" @',- 2(($0"#&2'/2/,9 (*/($??'/C @',-

,-" +2(, ,-2, 2(($0">*/8&2@ -$0%2/< *+ ,-" :'(,'>g0 >*,-"?9 '0 20#"('2& L$2&'+I'/C ('?($>0,2/(" @2??2/,'/C ,-" '>#*0','*/ *+ ,-" 0,2/(" @20 /*, 2&&"C"< '/ ,-" M/+*?>2,'*/0 20 ?"L$'?"'/2& .?*("#&" ?2#"; c/#&" ?2#" '0 &%:0.3"+# 1%&1%/.); 7*/+*?>2%&I @',- ($??"/, \$?'0#?$#&2'/2/, +*? (':'& '/*$/, *+

.D[9[[[;[[ 2/< >*?2& 2C"0 '/ ,-" 2>*$/, *+ .D[9[[[;[[ +*? "2(- (*$/, *+ ?2#"9 *? 2

,*,2& *+ .N[[9[[[;[[;

!"O 7?'>'/2& 720"0 4*0; QQ8BZBYQ[ 2/< QQ8BZBYQB J(*:"?'/C ,-" (?'>"

(*>>',,"< */ *? 2%*$, 6$C$0, BQQR 2/< 4*:">%"? D9 BQQRK

6(($0"2,"?'2& '/C?""; =-" #?*0"($,'*/ 2#&2'/2/, */ *? 2%*$, 6$C$0,

BQQR9 20 C&"2/"< +?*> -"? ,"0,'>*/I " *+ ?2#" '0 /*, 2/ "00"/,'2& "&">"/,

*+ ,-" (?'>"; F2'&$?" ,* 0#"('+I ,-" "W2(, >',,"" '0 ,-" +2(, *+ (2?/2& V/*@&">',,"< 2, 2/I ,'>" 20 /"2? ,* ,-" 2(,$2&

>',,"< P3+,%/",% 5.&"#$ /2% ,+#/2 +! J)&:2 ADDK +&

/2%&%)-+./CF F3+,%/",% 5.&"#$ /2% ,+#/2 +! L1&"0 ADDK +& /2%&%)-+./CF

F3+,%/",% 5.&"#$ /2% ,+#/2 +! J)( ADDK +& /2%&%)-+./P 0$%0,2/,'2&&I 2##?'0"#&2'/ ,-2, -" @20

'/2& 720" 4*; QQ8BZBYQB9 2(($0"%"? D9 BQQR9 2(($0"


13/22

-"? -2/#&2'/2/,; =-" ,"0,'>*/I *+

#?':2," (*>#&2'/2/, */ ",'>"0 ,@* JNK ,'>"0 2 @""V;

l M/ 4*:">%"? *+ BQQR9 " #"?0*/ I*$ #*'/,"< ,* "2?&'"?k6 X"09 0'?;

l X*$ 02'< -" #&2("< -'>0"&+ */ ,*# *+ I*$ '/ 4*:">%"?9 BQQR9 @-2, 2 @',/"00k

6 `" @20 2&0* ,*$(-'/C >I 0"W *?C2/9 0'?;

l a-2, "&0"9 '+ 2/Ik

6,,I; 30,*?(*O

12I @" ,2V" /*," *+ ,-" 02>" *%\"(,'*/ I*$? -*/*?9 ,-" #?*0"($,'*/ d

7*$?,O

T2>" ?$&'/C; G", ,-" (*>#&2'/2/, (*/,'/$" (*/0'


14/22

l a-2, 2%*$, 2+,"? 4*:">%"? BQQR d @20 ,-'0 ,-" &20, '/('"9 ,-" */" I*$ /2??2,"< '/ 4*:">%"? BQQRk

6 X"09 0'?;PYN

S/ (?*008"W2>'/2,'*/9 ,-" #?':2," (*>#&2'/2/, ,"0,'+'""%*k

6 1I 0,"#+2,-"? F?""


15/22

6 M 2/I ,-'/C0 I*$? -*/*?;

7*$?,O

X"09 ,-2,g0 @-I M 2> 20V'/C I*$ -*@ &*/C @'&& ', ,2V" I*$ ,* +'/'0- I*$?

(?*00k

6,,I; 52&2%2O

6%*$, 2/*,-"? -*$?9 0'?;

7*$?,O

T* @" @'&& %" +'/'0-"< %I BBOBD9 #?*(""%"? @-'(- &"C @20 -"&< %I F?""*,'*/'/C ,* ?"0'0, -'>9 0* ,-2, -" @*$&< C**$,9 0'?; M @20 0,?$CC&'/C ,* +?"" >I0"&+ +?*> -'>9 0'?;

l 6/< I*$ @"?" /*, 2%&" ,* "W,?'(2," I*$?0"&+ +?*> -'>k

6 M @20 /*, 2%&" ,* "W,?'(2," >I0"&+9 0'?;

l X*$ @"?" 0,?$CC&'/C @',- */" 2?> *+ G'H2*/I; " ,"0,'+'"< */


16/22

l 4*@9 */ 4*:">%"? N9 BQQR "k

6 BNDN _*0" 6%2< T2/,*09 =*/


17/22

6 `" 0(*&"9 -" ,*&< >" 0*>",-'/C 2/< 2+,"? ,-2, -"

@"/, ,* ,-" *,-"? ?**> 2/< 0&"#,9 0'?;PYE

!*00"& ,"0,'+'"< */ (?*008"W2>'/2,'*/9 ,-$0O

Pl T* I*$ C*, ,-'?0,I9 '0 ,-2, (*??"(,9 2/< @"/, '/0'" ,-2, I*$ 02@ ,-" 2(($0"< F?"" @-"?" >I 0'0,"? 0&""#09 0'?;

l T* ,-" *:'/C

,-" #2/,I *+ I*$? 0'0,"?k

6 4*, I",9 0'?9 %$, 2+,"? 2 @-'&" -" &**V"< 2, ,-" ?"+?'C"?2,*? %"(2$0" -"

>'C-, %" ,-'?0,I;

l T* d I*$ 02'< ,-" 2(($0"< @20 ,*$(-'/C I*$? 0'0,"?; a-2, #2?, *+ -"?

%*


18/22

7*$?, M/,"?#?","?O

a',/"00 ?2'0'/C -'0 ?'C-, -2/*:"< @',- ,-" &"+, -2/< *+ ,-"

2(($0"2O

`" 02'< ?">*:'/C ,-" #2/,I;

6,,I; 52&2%2O

M0 ,-2, #2/,Ik Mg> 0*??I;

l T*9 ,-" 2(($0"< @20 ,*$(-'/C @',- -'0 ?'C-, -2/< ,-" &"+, ,-'C- *+ I*$?

0'0,"? d

F'0(2& 72?'0>2O=-" ?'C-, ,-'C-;

6,,I; 52&2%2O

l !2,-"? ,-" ?'C-, ,-'C- *+ I*$? 0'0,"? 2/< @',- -'0 &"+, -2/< ?">*:'/C ,-"

#2/,I9 '0 ,-2, @-2, I*$ 2?" ,"&&'/C ,* ,"&& $0k

6 X"09 0'?;

l 6/< I*$? 0'0,"? 2&& ,-" ,'>" @20 ,?I'/C ,* d @20 0,?$CC&'/C ,* C", +?""9 '0

,-2, /*, (*??"(,k

6 X"09 0'?9 0-" @20 ?"0'0,'/C; J@',/"00 '/2&&I &'2%&" +*? (*/0$>>2,"< ?2#";Y^


19/22

=-" '00$" ,-2, /*@ (*>"0 ,* +*?" '0 @-",-"? *? /*, 2(($0"#,"< ?2#" $/"/0,2/("0

>"/,'*/"< '/ ,-" #?"("#$?',I] *? ,-2, @-'(- '0 (2??'"< */ 2 @2/,*/

>2//"?;YQ

=-" &20, #2?2C?2#- *+ 6?,'(&" ^ *+ ,-" !":'0"< ."/2& 7*'00'*/ *+ ,-" +"&*/I


20/22

=-" +'?0, ?"L$'0'," *+ 2/ 2,,">#,"< +"&*/I (*/0'0,0 *+ ,@* "&">"/,09 /2>"&IO

PJBK =-2, ,-"?" %" %P/%)0 ):/3]

JNK T$(- "W,"?/2& 2(,0 -2:" " "#/%#5%5 /+ -%

:+,,"//%5;PEB

6/ *:"?, *? "W,"?/2& 2(, '0 " #-I0'(2& 2(,':',I *? *?" ,-2/ 2 >"?" #&2//'/C *? #?"#2?2,'*/9

@-'(- '+ (2??'"< *$, ,* ',0 (*>#&"," ,"?>'/2,'*/ +*&&*@'/C ',0 /2,$?2& (*$?0"9 @',-*$,

%"'/C +?$0,?2,"< %I "W,"?/2& *%0,2(&"0 /*? %I ,-" 0#*/,2/"*$0 2\*?',I *+ (20"09 ,-" (*/"?"&I *+ 2(,0 *+ #?"#2?2,'*/ -20 /":"? ("20"< ,* %"

"L$':*(2&] 2/< ,-'0 '0 /"("002?'&I 0*9 '??"0#"(,':" *+ -'0 2I %" 02'" ',0"&+ -20 %""/ (*>>',,"2," */" +*?

(*>#&",'*/; M, '0 /"("002?I9 -*@":"?9 ,-2, ,-" 2,,">#, >$0, -2:" 2 (2$02& ?"&2,'*/ ,*

,-" '/,"/"/, *+ 2 2&"+2(,*? '0 C$'&,I *+ 0$(- (*/0$>>2,"" 7*$?, *+ T#2'/9 '/ ',0 >2,"< 20 ,-" >2,"?'2& 2C"'0 @2/,'/C9 ,-" /2,$?" *+ ,-" 2(,'*/ '/,"/ ,-" /2,$?" *+ ,-" 2(,0 "W"($,"< J)::"+#

,%5"+K;D[

`"/("9 ', '0 /"("002?I ,-2, ,-" 2(,0 *+ ,-" 2(($0"< >$0, %" 0$(- ,-2,9 %I ,-"'?

/2,$?"9 %I ,-" +2(,0 ,* @-'(- ,-"I 2?" ?"&2,"


21/22

P=-" ?"&2,'*/ "W'0,'/C %",@""/ ,-" +2(,0 0$%>',,"< +*? 2##?"('2,'*/ 2/< ,-"

*++"/0" @-'(- 02'< +2(,0 2?" 0$##*0"< ,* #?* ,-" +2(,0 2/< ,-"?"+*?" ', '0 /"("002?I9 '/ *?2&"+2(,*? 2&& ,-" 2(,0 *+ "W"($,'*/ %I ?"20*/ *+ -'0

0#*/,2/"*$0 #,"< +"&*/I;DY

=-" &2@ #, ,* (*>>', 2 +"&*/I;DE

=-" ?2,'*/2&" *+ ,-" &2@9 20 "W#&2'/"*?&"00 '/ (20" *+ 0$(- ?",?"2, %"+*?" ', '0 #*00'%&" +*? 2/I ":'&

(*/0"L$"/("0 ,* "/0$"; 4"',-"? 0*('",I9 /*? 2/I #?':2," #"?0*/9 -20 %""/

'/\$?"< %I -'0 2(,; =-"?" '0 /* 2C"9 ,-"?"+*?"9 ,* ?"


22/22

V'00'/C -'0 :'(,'> 2/< &I'/C */ ,*# *+ -"?; `*@":"?9 -" +2'&"< ,* #"?+*?> 2&& ,-"

2(,0 *+ "W"($,'*/ @-'(- 0-*$&< #?*"?"&I ,*$(-"< 12?I _*Ig0 #?':2," *?C2/;

6((*?" (*>>',,"< %I ,-" 2##"&&2/, '0 2,,">#,"< ?2#"9 ,-"

#"/2&,I ,* %" '>#*0"< */ -'> 0-*$&< %" 2/ '/'/2," #?'0*/ ,"?> *+ 0'W J^KI"2?0 *+1&"3"+# :+&&%::"+#)020 >'/'>$> ,* ,@"&:" JBNK I"2?0 *+1&"3"+# ,)(+&20

>2W'>$>;P

=-" #"/2&,I +*? 2,,">#,"< ?2#" '01&"3"+# ,)(+&@-'(- '0 ,@* */,-0 2/< */" $> *+ @-'(- 0-2&& %" ,2V"/ +?*>

,-" >"0,2/("; 6(($0"*?2& 2C"0 '/ ,-" 2>*$/, *+ .ND9[[[;[[;

C- AC+@* )B FAA *@% B)$%+)C-+> NOL DLPI/I.9 .Q NOL $LRI.98K *;I8K (.:;N .Q &89IK8>

S;89PO T1> I/ !%* F!CD%, F9.NOL; U:VRJL9N I/ OL;LW< ;L9VL;LV 8/ Q.KK.X/H

0, C9 (;IJI98K (8/L -., MM50602M?> 8PP:/LV58YYLKK89N I/ OL;LW< Q.:9V R:IKN< WL???,?? W< X8< .Q PIZIK I9VLJ9IN< 89V #T?>???,?? W< X8< .Q J.;8K V8J8RL/[

=, C9 (;IJI98K (8/L -., MM50602M0> 8PP:/LV58YYLKK89N I/ OL;LW< Q.:9V R:IKN< .Q

8NNLJYNLV ;8YL :9VL; F;NIPKL 22T .Q NOL $LZI/LV #L98K (.VL 8/ 8JL9VLV I9 ;LK8NI.9 N.F;NIPKL 3 .Q NOL /8IV (.VL 89V I/ OL;LW< JLNLV 89 I9VLNL;JI98NL YL98KN< .Q Q;.J /I\

Documents

1. People vs Lizada