12
1 PIM-SM over UDLR [email protected] 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

1 PIM-SM over UDLR [email protected] 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

1

PIM-SM over UDLR

[email protected]

54th IETF, 2002/07/16

Page 2: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

2

URL

The document is on the web.

http://sfc-cpu.ai3.net/~husni/pim-udlr-config/

Page 3: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

3

We Did These

• Experiment in AI3 C-band UDL network• Generalize the experiment result

– network topology

http://sfc-cpu.ai3.net/~husni/pim-udlr-config/

Page 4: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

4

Objective

• to investigate the simplest effective configuration of PIM-SM over UDLR– where routing is asymmetric and – there is no separate MRIB

http://sfc-cpu.ai3.net/~husni/pim-udlr-config/

Page 5: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

5

A Unicast Routing in UDLR

• FEED -> RECV : UDL• RECV -> FEED : BDL

FEED networkFB1

FU

HF

RECV network RU1

RB1

H1RECV networkRU2

RB2

H2

FB2

BDLnet2BDLnet1

UDLnet

Page 6: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

6

Problem in Using PIM-SM

• Multicast traffic flow via BDL

FEED networkFB1

FU

SF

RECV network RU1

RB1

R1

RECV networkRU2

RB2

R2

FB2RP

BDLnet2BDLnet1

UDLnet

RP Tree Shortest Path Tree

Page 7: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

7

Proposed Configuration (1/3)

FEED networkFB1

FU

HF

RECV network RU1

RB1

H1RECV networkRU2

RB2

H2

FB2

BDLnet2BDLnet1

RP

To RECV net.To FEED net.

To UDLnet

UDLnet

Page 8: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

8

Proposed Configuration (2/3)

① RP is the address of the UDL interface of the feed router

② Receivers in receive network never to switch to SPT

③ Configure the networks so receive networks reach RP through the UDL

• Join path uses UDL

Page 9: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

9

Proposed Configuration (3/3)

• Item ③– If using routing protocol– Cost of the unidirectional link interface of recei

ve routers is not to be huge– Re-compute interface costs of routers

• achieve routing config. as the previous slide• minimize the number of re-computed interfaces

– A rule of thumb to configure interface costs• for a more general network topology

Page 10: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

10

A Rule of Thumb for Interface Costs

• V is a constant

FEED networkFB1

FU

HF

RECV network RU1

RB1

H1RECV networkRU2

RB2

H2

FB2

2V

5V

7V2V

5V

V

V3V

BDLnet2BDLnet1

UDLnet

5V

V

2V

7V

3VV

Page 11: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

11

Determining V

• Set V such that V is the determinant of inter-network path selection

• V > 2*max(rc(R,U)-rc(R,B), rc(X2,R) – rc(Y2-R), …)

• Placing U and B on one subnet simplifies our life.

Net X

X1

X2Net Y

Y1

Y2

U B

R

Page 12: 1 PIM-SM over UDLR husni@ai3.net 54 th IETF, 2002/07/16

12

Next Step…

• I-D