1

Urban TransportationLand Urban TransportationLand

Useand the Environment Useand the Environment in Latin Americain Latin America

A Case Study ApproachA Case Study Approach

Lecture 5

Introducing the Case Study Cities and the Case Study

Approach

2

The Two CitiesThe Two CitiesSantiago Mexico

Population 18 million

(18of national)

55 million

(40of national)

Urbanized area 1500km2 600 km2

Density

(popkm 2 )

12000 (center)

2700 (periphery)

11000 (center)

~3000 (periphery)

GDPCapita (US$)

$7750 (2000) $5200 (1998)

Total VehFleet 32 million (1999) 870000 (1998)

Private Veh1000 166 (1996) 130 (1998)

VKT (KMsDay) 153 million 55 million

Days Ozone

Exceeded Std

~80

(1999)

40

(1999)

Peak PM10 conc 202 microm 3 (1999) 335 microm 3 (1999)

NOx (tonnesyr) 206000 (1998)

(80vehicles)

55000 (2000)

(84vehicles)

VOC (tonnesyr) 475000 (1998)

(40vehicles)

81000 (2000)

(20vehicles)

Local Jurisdictions

54 ~40

PopGrowth (90s)

17 18

Household Size 42 42

3

The Case Study Approach

bull The ldquoConsultant Teamrdquo ndash Working with ldquoDirectorsrdquo (Joe Chris)

bull 1 ldquoprogress assessmentrdquo week ndash Answering to ldquoStakeholdersrdquo (rest of class) ndash 45 Weeks1048698

bull Approximately 200 person-hours

4

Expected Output A Strategic Transportation Infrastructure and Land Use Plan for the Metro Region

Covering a 20-Year Time Horizon Understanding the Planning Context

ndash Applying the CLIOS construct Showing Range Estimates of Key

Influencing Factors ndash Economy Demographics Traveler Demand (trips distances modes etc) Freight Transport Demand Land Development Demand Technology hellip

5

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Identifying Goals Objectives Indicators ndash For Sustainability

Identifying the ldquoRegional Architecturerdquo and influencing factors ndash Public amp Private Institutions ndash Role of Relevant national policies ndash Dynamic Issues

Outlining major options to be considered to fulfill goalsobjectives ndash Infrastructure amp Land Development ndash Policy amp Technology deployment

6

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Presenting the Framework for evaluating and justifying the selected options ndash Fulfillment of goals and objectives ndash Recognition of trade-offs

Presenting the Proposed Financing Plan ndash Including fees taxes charges transfers

Presenting the Proposed Implementation Plan ndash Institutional responsibilties ndash Public Participation

Identifying Main Sources of Uncertainty ndash Highlighting data and methodological needs

7

Expected Products Interim Presentation (week 3)

ndash For stakeholder feedback Final Presentation (week 4) ndash

Incorporating stakeholder concerns

Final Report (due in class week 5) ndash Approximately 30 pages

Expectations ndash Add value to the already existing information (ie readings) indicate additional resource consultations ndash Scenario Planning is encouraged but not required

2

The Two CitiesThe Two CitiesSantiago Mexico

Population 18 million

(18of national)

55 million

(40of national)

Urbanized area 1500km2 600 km2

Density

(popkm 2 )

12000 (center)

2700 (periphery)

11000 (center)

~3000 (periphery)

GDPCapita (US$)

$7750 (2000) $5200 (1998)

Total VehFleet 32 million (1999) 870000 (1998)

Private Veh1000 166 (1996) 130 (1998)

VKT (KMsDay) 153 million 55 million

Days Ozone

Exceeded Std

~80

(1999)

40

(1999)

Peak PM10 conc 202 microm 3 (1999) 335 microm 3 (1999)

NOx (tonnesyr) 206000 (1998)

(80vehicles)

55000 (2000)

(84vehicles)

VOC (tonnesyr) 475000 (1998)

(40vehicles)

81000 (2000)

(20vehicles)

Local Jurisdictions

54 ~40

PopGrowth (90s)

17 18

Household Size 42 42

3

The Case Study Approach

bull The ldquoConsultant Teamrdquo ndash Working with ldquoDirectorsrdquo (Joe Chris)

bull 1 ldquoprogress assessmentrdquo week ndash Answering to ldquoStakeholdersrdquo (rest of class) ndash 45 Weeks1048698

bull Approximately 200 person-hours

4

Expected Output A Strategic Transportation Infrastructure and Land Use Plan for the Metro Region

Covering a 20-Year Time Horizon Understanding the Planning Context

ndash Applying the CLIOS construct Showing Range Estimates of Key

Influencing Factors ndash Economy Demographics Traveler Demand (trips distances modes etc) Freight Transport Demand Land Development Demand Technology hellip

5

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Identifying Goals Objectives Indicators ndash For Sustainability

Identifying the ldquoRegional Architecturerdquo and influencing factors ndash Public amp Private Institutions ndash Role of Relevant national policies ndash Dynamic Issues

Outlining major options to be considered to fulfill goalsobjectives ndash Infrastructure amp Land Development ndash Policy amp Technology deployment

6

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Presenting the Framework for evaluating and justifying the selected options ndash Fulfillment of goals and objectives ndash Recognition of trade-offs

Presenting the Proposed Financing Plan ndash Including fees taxes charges transfers

Presenting the Proposed Implementation Plan ndash Institutional responsibilties ndash Public Participation

Identifying Main Sources of Uncertainty ndash Highlighting data and methodological needs

7

Expected Products Interim Presentation (week 3)

ndash For stakeholder feedback Final Presentation (week 4) ndash

Incorporating stakeholder concerns

Final Report (due in class week 5) ndash Approximately 30 pages

Expectations ndash Add value to the already existing information (ie readings) indicate additional resource consultations ndash Scenario Planning is encouraged but not required

3

The Case Study Approach

bull The ldquoConsultant Teamrdquo ndash Working with ldquoDirectorsrdquo (Joe Chris)

bull 1 ldquoprogress assessmentrdquo week ndash Answering to ldquoStakeholdersrdquo (rest of class) ndash 45 Weeks1048698

bull Approximately 200 person-hours

4

Expected Output A Strategic Transportation Infrastructure and Land Use Plan for the Metro Region

Covering a 20-Year Time Horizon Understanding the Planning Context

ndash Applying the CLIOS construct Showing Range Estimates of Key

Influencing Factors ndash Economy Demographics Traveler Demand (trips distances modes etc) Freight Transport Demand Land Development Demand Technology hellip

5

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Identifying Goals Objectives Indicators ndash For Sustainability

Identifying the ldquoRegional Architecturerdquo and influencing factors ndash Public amp Private Institutions ndash Role of Relevant national policies ndash Dynamic Issues

Outlining major options to be considered to fulfill goalsobjectives ndash Infrastructure amp Land Development ndash Policy amp Technology deployment

6

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Presenting the Framework for evaluating and justifying the selected options ndash Fulfillment of goals and objectives ndash Recognition of trade-offs

Presenting the Proposed Financing Plan ndash Including fees taxes charges transfers

Presenting the Proposed Implementation Plan ndash Institutional responsibilties ndash Public Participation

Identifying Main Sources of Uncertainty ndash Highlighting data and methodological needs

7

Expected Products Interim Presentation (week 3)

ndash For stakeholder feedback Final Presentation (week 4) ndash

Incorporating stakeholder concerns

Final Report (due in class week 5) ndash Approximately 30 pages

Expectations ndash Add value to the already existing information (ie readings) indicate additional resource consultations ndash Scenario Planning is encouraged but not required

4

Expected Output A Strategic Transportation Infrastructure and Land Use Plan for the Metro Region

Covering a 20-Year Time Horizon Understanding the Planning Context

ndash Applying the CLIOS construct Showing Range Estimates of Key

Influencing Factors ndash Economy Demographics Traveler Demand (trips distances modes etc) Freight Transport Demand Land Development Demand Technology hellip

5

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Identifying Goals Objectives Indicators ndash For Sustainability

Identifying the ldquoRegional Architecturerdquo and influencing factors ndash Public amp Private Institutions ndash Role of Relevant national policies ndash Dynamic Issues

Outlining major options to be considered to fulfill goalsobjectives ndash Infrastructure amp Land Development ndash Policy amp Technology deployment

6

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Presenting the Framework for evaluating and justifying the selected options ndash Fulfillment of goals and objectives ndash Recognition of trade-offs

Presenting the Proposed Financing Plan ndash Including fees taxes charges transfers

Presenting the Proposed Implementation Plan ndash Institutional responsibilties ndash Public Participation

Identifying Main Sources of Uncertainty ndash Highlighting data and methodological needs

7

Expected Products Interim Presentation (week 3)

ndash For stakeholder feedback Final Presentation (week 4) ndash

Incorporating stakeholder concerns

Final Report (due in class week 5) ndash Approximately 30 pages

Expectations ndash Add value to the already existing information (ie readings) indicate additional resource consultations ndash Scenario Planning is encouraged but not required

5

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Identifying Goals Objectives Indicators ndash For Sustainability

Identifying the ldquoRegional Architecturerdquo and influencing factors ndash Public amp Private Institutions ndash Role of Relevant national policies ndash Dynamic Issues

Outlining major options to be considered to fulfill goalsobjectives ndash Infrastructure amp Land Development ndash Policy amp Technology deployment

6

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Presenting the Framework for evaluating and justifying the selected options ndash Fulfillment of goals and objectives ndash Recognition of trade-offs

Presenting the Proposed Financing Plan ndash Including fees taxes charges transfers

Presenting the Proposed Implementation Plan ndash Institutional responsibilties ndash Public Participation

Identifying Main Sources of Uncertainty ndash Highlighting data and methodological needs

7

Expected Products Interim Presentation (week 3)

ndash For stakeholder feedback Final Presentation (week 4) ndash

Incorporating stakeholder concerns

Final Report (due in class week 5) ndash Approximately 30 pages

Expectations ndash Add value to the already existing information (ie readings) indicate additional resource consultations ndash Scenario Planning is encouraged but not required

6

Expected Output (contrsquod)

Presenting the Framework for evaluating and justifying the selected options ndash Fulfillment of goals and objectives ndash Recognition of trade-offs

Presenting the Proposed Financing Plan ndash Including fees taxes charges transfers

Presenting the Proposed Implementation Plan ndash Institutional responsibilties ndash Public Participation

Identifying Main Sources of Uncertainty ndash Highlighting data and methodological needs

7

Expected Products Interim Presentation (week 3)

ndash For stakeholder feedback Final Presentation (week 4) ndash

Incorporating stakeholder concerns

Final Report (due in class week 5) ndash Approximately 30 pages

Expectations ndash Add value to the already existing information (ie readings) indicate additional resource consultations ndash Scenario Planning is encouraged but not required

7

Expected Products Interim Presentation (week 3)

ndash For stakeholder feedback Final Presentation (week 4) ndash

Incorporating stakeholder concerns

Final Report (due in class week 5) ndash Approximately 30 pages

Expectations ndash Add value to the already existing information (ie readings) indicate additional resource consultations ndash Scenario Planning is encouraged but not required