10 Ideas for Defense and Diplomacy, 2011

8/6/2019 10 Ideas for Defense and Diplomacy, 2011

1/36

10

idea

sfo

r

de

fense+diplomac

y

2011 | reimaginedevelopment in foreign policy


2/36

Ideas or Deense & DiplomacyJ2011

ND

Hilary Doe

DO

Tarsi Dunlop

LSD&D

Rocky Taylor Cole

E

James M. A. Hobbs

AR

Brad BossermanCharsaree Clay

Kevin PowersTaylor Jo Isenberg

TRICNwAdRI

455MANWS650WDC20001

C2011RIAd

TwdxdTdxwRId


3/36

10

ID FOR

Deense & Diplomacy


4/36


5/36

Congraulaions o

Chris canzoniwih Chrisian Blanco

Mark Caine

arah Hadburg

nhony Pei

Rose anley

auhors oThe Moral quivalen o War

Nominee orPolicy o he Year


6/36


7/36

Inside he Issue PEFAd

Kevin Dean

SOMichael Francus

ANwA21CGAshley Herzovi

RwEIPKeri Majikes

RPSCUPeer Nauka

CdFdAdP

Hannah Nemer

AExddHIV/AIDSRFHannah Nemer

BdANxGdAJonahan R. Sherman

SdSdBUSSElizabeh Wakins

HAdRUSMMarie Zoglo

TMEqWChris Scanzoni wih Chrisian Blanco, Mark Caine, Sarah Hadburg,

Anhony Peti, and Rose Sanley

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

22

24

26

28


8/36

pLeer rom Washingon

Wddddd10IdSC-dxdwSdddwRddwdxddd

Iw2009RICNwd-dT2040dwMwdddddT2040wT2040wddddTdwddBMA;wddwwdwdd2040Yw Ad

wTwdd-ddddwMdddwwddAdwqAqd;-wdwd-IdwddRddwd-

;dxdwddx-YwNwHw--wdwYIddNwUdd-ddwwdEILSdDCwTAw-WDCdASUwdd-

ddSddwwdddwWdwdddwd

TDDO


9/36

raegiss NoeP

TRICNwwdwdAdIddddwdddW-ddddwddwdddWCNwdwd

dqdMd-ddwd

Uw

TDdDCdddddWwT2040wddMA w d Wd DD-

dDCGW UwwddddFwdBudge or Mil-lennial Americawxdd-ddT2040dDDdDC

TwddwRdI

ddwdddddd

TdM21 ddd-ddddd-Tdw

d dd W

RCLdSDdD


10/36

8

Entrepreneurial Foreign AidKevin Dean, Michigan State University

Congress and he Sae Deparmen should creae an online markeplace ha allowsenrepreneurs and small businesses in developing counries o connec wih consum-ers in he Unied Saes.

T S CG E P(GEP)dd-M wdwd w - d- dd dwUdS Pd O dPdSE-A20101

nalysis

CdSDd S SCGEP--ddWNGO-USwddddddTSD US ddddUdSwd

TwdwdUdSCdwdddTwUSddTwdxddB-wdwdd-ddAdddwwddTUSdddGdSP(GSP)dUSwdw--USdddwd-wdUSd

AwddSUSwddA-wddGSPwF

Key FacsI2,HC-tU-

w

GP(GP).3

G

M(GM),22.8w-

, w -

2.6 w -3.4

j-

w.5


11/36

ddw-USTwd-Aw

O - -wdddUdSO-w d Twdw d ddddx-T - ddwd d Exdddddw d d d dd ddC -d d-dqd-

TddxGEPIN2010SDddwANwPUSFP2TSDdwddwwwddEx-wxdwdWUSdwwdSUSwdwdwddd-d

ndnoes1SRKEwE:ANwPUSFPN172010dM12011://www

//-/2010/N/20101117124926097896982KEwE3USDSAGEPA272010dJ82011://www

//x-/2010/A/20100428114705x011876644DJKNBdJEAGEM2010GR23C

d:ABEGGIJPSdAUdVWBdGSdZ

5K2010GR446FdKdMdMMAB:AGwIDCEx?

I Td F 2003 d M 1 2011 ://wwwd/w//d/552/M_A_B:_A_Gw_I__D_C_Ex_

9

Talking Poins,.-,

w.jWTO-UNI- T C, -

(LDC)-

w-.6

N-,-

f-.

D -w,

, w -fU..w.


12/3610

Scrapping the OspreyMichael Francus, University o Chicago

Terminaing he oudaed and unnecessary V-22 Osprey program would cu waseuldeense spending and save lives.

Idd-wdTOwwwdGdd$50wdCdO

AIddddwddfdTOwSdd(-d30d)dd

w-SDDCddGHWBd19891Ad O w ddwFDD q w--dd

C T dddC-2I-d d ddSDGwddd3

nalysisSC1989OddIdF-ddd1000$377Tw458d$934EddOdId-dddd70wwdd8045TwxdI

xw30xdd6TdOdwd-wwwddIdwdd7EOwdqwdddwd

Key FacsT O f

982$53.3.O3,

w F-

.

T -458$93.4-

,

$37.7.2


13/36

11

Ne eps

IdddWR-ddwdddM

R(TPw)dwddwx8T O 3500 276dwd 9Nwwwd-dwO

ndnoes1MTAFS Time MagazineS2620072MSwDAq:HwDODAqWSdRERPCR-

S20103AMSd:Tdw The EconomisF1020114JGV-22OT-RA:BddICCRS20095USCHCOdGRTFV-22OP:HC-

OdGR111C1J2320096GV-22OT-RA7Id8EBdTSPBdCSGOPThe New York TimesJ272011AdM272011://

www/2011/01/27///279LGdV-22O:WdWWdw-M?CDI200610GV-22OT-RA11HCOdGRTFV-22OP

12GV-22OT-RA13HCOdGRTFV-22OP14Id15TAFS

Talking PoinsTOf. 3

T wf 3- xw.

T , w VPDCCCtO

GRO. 4,5

CtOww.


14/36

12

A New Approach to 21st Century GovernanceAshley Herzovi, Michigan State University

The Unied Naions should repurpose he Truseeship Council o oversee saes wihlong-erm issues o sel-governance due o conic ha are hus unable o provide

basic human necessiies o heir consiuens.

TdddCVIIUdN(UN)CCVIIwUNdd(d-)1Hwd-dI ddwTddddd

21

Twdwd:-dd;d-CwUNwRP(R2P)ddd 2

I w dwUNA d

dLNdMdSWdWIIT-CwwA-d wd wUNdd-R2P-ddB

TCUNwdwdd-wd

nalysis

Tdd-dw-wfCdUNSd(UNAMID)wwdd-BJ12009900026000xdwdd 3T35xdwJ20074IUNAMIDwdd-AddUNAMIDSddd-5BTCwdTUNwdwwT-

Key FacsTTCw-

LNM.I 994, T C -

wf.6

B , w

. D

,

j -

.


15/36

13

wTddSCddTCddPF

Ne eps

TUNGAd-w-TCIddTCUNdCVIIP-OSdGACVIIPOw -FTCwdw:

Aggregate inormation regarding

the confict known to the other U.N.

bodies and councils.

Assist the Department o Peace-

keeping Operations with any cur-

rent peacekeeping missions in the

trust state.

Develop an action plan that seeks

to stabilize political, economic, and

social tensions in the state.

O w - T UNwdGAdddTCwdddHd-ddddT

CwdddqAddwdUNwdqdUNCw-RxwwdwRddwdddUNAd dddxUNd

ndnoes1UdNC Ud NW Ud N:IYWd://www//d//

7(dM92011)2JRdLEdTGWPdSI UN Ideas ha Changed he WorldB:Id

UP2009174-1753RTTFUNAMID The GuardianJ120094AU/UdNHdD(UNAMID)UdNdF242011://www//-

//d/5TTFUNAMID6TCUdNdF172011://www/D/d/d/

Talking PoinsTwU.N.w-

.C-

,wU.N..

CVIIPO U.N. w -

,-.

C VII U.N. -w-,

w w w -.


16/36

14

Renewable Energy as an Incentive for PeaceKeri Majikes, University o North Carolina at Chapel Hill

The U.S. can eliminae Irans incenives or developing nuclear echnology wihou be-coming miliarily involved by creaing an economic agreemen ha esablishes Iran as

a leader in renewable energy.

TUdSd- dI-FIdd1SdIdd-I-

dMddEFIwdMddEwdw- dd d

DwddIdd-w2CI

ddTdIdddddIdddd3AddId ddC I TwdddddwwddMddETUdSdI

nalysis

BIdwwwdwdddwUdSdIFdI-wIIdddddwdwAddww

MddEAwddwTwdddIMddEww

Ad-dIxd

Key Facsj- I w

.5

O, I, w w

75-.6

I

w -w

w

.7


17/36

15

xI-ddI4I- d wdI w

WxUdSwd fwIIAdd-wdxdd w wd d MddETddUdSddCdIwdddd

Ne eps

AdddIUdS d w Iwd -IddwdTdwwMddEdII-IwdddwTdwdqdIdMddEwwTdwdqddAd-

ndnoes1GBSS:ICFRO72010dM12011://www//--

/93622MdSE:INdNPw The New York TimesO142003dM12011://www

/2003/10/14//14-d_d3_3HAUddIDNP Radio Free Europe Radio LiberyD12009dM12011://

www//Udd_I_D_N_P_/18924044PRDISWPN32010dM12011://www//

w/_wd/20101103_D__I___w5BBAMBNIWashingon TimesA62010dM12011://wwww/

w/2010//6/----wd-w--d--/6SE:INdNPw

7FARwEI:CdOSD Inernaional Journal o Environmenal Scienceand Technology11(2004):69-80

Talking PoinsTU..-I

w-

w.

T U.. -w-

I

x

I.

wx

I.


18/36

16

Reforming Private Security Contractor UsePeter Nauka, University o Caliornia, Los Angeles

To aid and accelerae our missions in Iraq and Aghanisan, he Unied Saes Con-gress, Deparmen o Deense, and Deparmen o Jusice should work ogeher obring more accounabiliy and ransparency o privae, or-pro miliary conracors.

SdCdWdw-wqddddwdPSC(PSC)EPSCdw1APSC d d Bw NSqdAGBdw-ddxPSCw-wwT$200PSCd

x 2OdwdPSC3FPSCw A d Iq d dd ddd45

C w ddIAwddPSCwwdd-

w6Idd-wwdI2004 Bw d dFw M T wddwdwMwdI M dd

dd-Tddwdd7Add-f8

nalysis

TdPSCddd-wUSdwUSdMddETdw

dddIqdA 910YdTPSCww1112TdUSdw1314TwfxwPSCdwd

Key FacsTU..w

, x

PC.

C $2--

--.6PC w,,

.


19/36

17

Ne eps

Pdd-dd dq TDD(DD)w-

w D J (DJ)dCdFDDIddddwdwTwdddd-dPSCIddSd Pd d OT(SPOT)dJ2007dddxddTSPOT-wdddwddwddddTdwddxdddSddwwddwdw

IddDDwUSdwdTDJwwCdMExJdAddwwdwIqdAwwFCdd--d-dqdddd15

ndnoes

1PWSOWBI20052PWSCorporae Warriors: The Rise o he Privaized Miliary Indusry.(I:CUP2003)3SOW4PWSCOIqAAdBIM1220085AJUSwdAAsia Times OnlineS222009dM12011://www//

S_A/KI22D036KBLFKForeign PolicyN3020097PWSCWWECGTWWE:PMCdCBI

S20078PWSCW:TRPdMIddIRISInernaional

Securiy263(2002):186-2209MSwCRSRCDDCIqdA:BddAC-

RSJ2201010AMPSCFIPFU.S. News and World ReporO52007dM12011

://wwww/w/q//2007/10/05/-----

11GCCAAqdPMExdOO31200712DODIdRSCExL-dCGAOT

SDCAHRA32008dM12011://www/w/d08621d

13WMwUSIqxd Deense NewsA12201014JFHwTPFWA:MC Invesing DailyA12201015RdFdJNCCf:TPRCNwASJ201016PWSCorporae Warriors: The Rise o he Privaized Miliary Indusry.(I:CUP2003)

Talking PoinsT D D

w POT

,.

T D J w w C w

.

C .


20/36

18

Child Friendly Aid ProvisionHannah Nemer, University o North Carolina at Chapel Hill

The Unied Saes Congress should acively endorse legislaion ha reduces insanceso child marriage in an efor o creae more efecive oreign-aid invesmens.

T Ud S d d-ID2010I-P G PCdMA(S987)d S U HRwdw-dd- D -d d wd-d-Hwdd;-dwd$67ddx1TUdSCRCd(CRC)wdSACRCwddUdSdddTUdNdCRCS

nalysis

BIPGPCdMAxdwdwdddwddSCRCqd-ddEqdwdd-dTwddddd2AddddSdddwdBwdw-dUdSAID(USAID)USwdwddd

WCRCUdSwdCRCdTwddwdIdd-d

Key FacsI,, 8,

5.3

B . P-

5-9-,

w .4

x

,HIV w. I Z ,

w 6

HIV/ID

.5


21/36

19

TdwdwddwddBd-dxwdfddw-dd

Ne eps

TIPGPCdMA-ddTddOddwCwdIdw-dCRCSDw2009Hw-dSwIPGPCdMATdddwOCwddddqd-WwddUdSwd-ddd

ndnoes1JFCd:CwwOLJ12011dM102011

://www//dx/2011/01/d___w2SRSIPGPCdMACdM102011://www

//_______d__RSIPGPCdMA

3CdMFTEddM102011://wwwd/d/Cd_M_Fd4CdMF5SCEMdHIVRS-SASdFP35I3(2004):140-1606RSIPGPCdMA

Talking PoinsC-x. 6

w.

RHIV/ID,w.T-

,w.


22/36

20

The Unied Saes should remove he Ani-Prosiuion Mandae rom he PresidensEmergency Plan or AIDS Relie (PEPFAR) relie program, and insead acively sup-por condom disribuion o sex workers.

I 2003 Pd B dd $115 HIV/AIDS PEPFARWPEPFARddwAPEPFAR- w d- wT-ddx-wd

ddxw-1CdFAd- d US - d d Od dUS-dddwHww2

nalysis

WUdSHIV/AIDSdddxdCqPEPFARdxxwwddddd 3EddddPEPFARdwxwdTOG

AIDSCdPEPFARdUdSdd4OddddddAIDSdd5TddwHIV/AIDSd

W - d d d -ddHIV/AIDSP-wddddAIDSd6

IAIDSdAdddwNGODwdHIV/AIDSAdddAw-d01d7OdddHIV/AIDSd NGO

An Expanded HIV/AIDS Relief FocusHannah Nemer, University o North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Key FacsIw, f x w-

wHIV.

G, w 8 x w

w

.

I,ww

-

x-

xw,42.2-

xw

-

2.2.2


23/36

21

dddwddx-ddNGO-UdSdwdPEPFARd

Ne eps

T US d wd - d dqwxPEPFAR-dCdd-ddxwxw-dddTUSd- x wdwd8

Twd-USddd-dqOCHdGdEqddddddd-d9BddddUSddHIV/AIDS

ndnoes1MPW:LZRUSRGHIV/AIDSEdSxI-

dEdCUdSAdA282011LMdd-A2009:///dx?=FwF&FID=1767

2HTHIV/AIDSdSxSHRACCHdGdEqAdF 25 2011 L dd O 2011 ://wwwd//d///H_T-_HIVAIDS_d__Sx_S_12_3_2010FINALd

3PdEPAIDSR(PEPFAR):PEPFARdAVERTAdA282011://www/

4DdBdCdqddPEPFARSS:HIV&TBNwAdA282011L dd F 2 2011 :///2011/02/02/d--q-d-d--/?_=d&_d=d&_=Fd%3A+SSHTNw+%28S+S%3A+HIV+%26+TB+Nw%29

5Id6PDAIDSPdMTOFPRwdNwMdPAdM27

2011://wwwxw/d-/M--d-----AIDS_399947Id8HTHIV/AIDSdSxSHRACCHdGdEq9Id10HTHIV/AIDSdSxSHRA11SxWdHIVPAAdF252011://www/x-w

12OCSxW:PSTWdHOAdA92011LMdd2002A-d://wwww////w_/x//dx3PDF

13WPAFAIDSMWPAFAIDS The Washingon PosAdF252011LddM22006://wwww/wd///2006/03/01/AR200603002316

14PPUSdBOddAIDSP New York TimesAdF252011LddJ242005://www/2005/07/24///24

Talking PoinswHIV/ID

-

. P

HIV,w

.

P , x w w

x.3

B,-xw- ,

HIV-

w.4


24/36

22

Congress should raiy he Korea-Unied Saes (KORUS) Free Trade Agreemen osolidiy he Unied Saes sraegic securiy, economic, and poliical inuence in EasAsia.

SKUdS60S-MDT1953wddddSKUdSddD2008dwSKdG20SKUSEAw27000AdCdFCd(CFC)SddNK1978M-

wwwxdwdM2010-SKNK

W d SKAdTCHdd C- KORUS FTdA$3d10000w-

d K AdTxHd-

d q d Pd OTd R d $10$12 wd ddd US GDP 1TdC

wd95dwSKd-3

nalysis

IdCKORUSFTdAwd-dUS-KMDT1953IwdAUSdSKdCd

WdTdO(WTO)ddIwddUdSd wAS A N(ASEAN)dAwwUdS 2TwdUSdd-w-dUSxIwdAd40xdUdS

Building Americas Next Great AllianceJonathan R. Sherman, American University

Key FacsT w 95 -

ww-3,-

x

.6

TKORUFTwx-U..$3

,x-

46.7

TwU..- f $

.

TKORUFTwU..

f$4.8


25/36


26/36

24

U.S. recogniion o Somaliland as an independen sae will aid in he gh agains pi-racy and help preven Somaliland rom being used as a saging ground or errorism.

SdSdddd19911WSddSdddwdwd-dwdddNdUSSdTUSwAwEwUS2M-dUSdww 3

nalysis

TUSSdwdwwdfdwwddC-SddddwI-MFddSdTwSd-wddd-

ddd

IdAw-wSdwTdd-USSdwR Sd wd Sd

w w dd dBSdddUNRS-dwd-wd-dUSd

IUSSdwd

wAdS-wwHAdMddEBdddUSw-ddT-

Statehood for Somaliland Benefits U.S SecurityElizabeth Watkins, Wheaton College

Key Facs w

U.N. - 96 w

w.5

M,

J 2

-

, I- R I

P.6,7

I- I

MF,

j

IMF . , -

w,

IMF.8U.N.-

.9


27/36

25

wdwUSSd-wwd S Sd d US-d wFUSM d d dd d d d MddEdwwI

Sd dwd- dxd wd 4T USwd dTwwdwddSddw

Ne eps

TxUSSdAwddSSdCdExBdwAxwdddwSdwCdwwdSdAwddSdd-Sd

ndnoes1Sd:Dd DICGJ 82003dM3 2011://www/-

wd/dd/352180042KSRSd:FwdSCT?RUdSIDSdJ

150(2005):46-523JCFS:RSdJ72009dA162011://dd/--f/-

-4FLIEA:ABSAdANPRdO272010dM32011://www

///?Id=1308578995Rd:SdBBdCD12010dM32011://w/2//

/_/37948476SdHdCdPdEIRIJ272010dM82011://www/w-

--/w/d-d-d-d-7Sd:xwPJ282010dM82011://www//

w/d---x--w8MIMFddM32011://www/x//9PWUNSRJ252011d3M2011://www

//2011/01/25/----dUSTRE70O6J420110125

Talking Poins,,

w -

.T U.. w f

w -

w

-

.

w-f

.T U.. - w,

ww

.


28/36

26

Congress should sreamline he miliarys exising srucure or humaniarian aid byremoving redundancies and creaing a unied humaniarian aid command.

Pddd-d F w dd dWwdx--Qdw d dddMdwd-

ddUSd F d -dd2004d-dIdOIUS Ndd qdddwdwCwwdwddd

T q d dddd-ddIddd-dwdFUSdddddddd-GddddddExdddCExD-MdHAwUSPC-d; Cd E R PC D dHAMddDMdEMddPDC 1IPUSd5000Pddd634000dwfd20102SddAIqHdSAd2004FwA-ddwUSd1538Id3

nalysis

CUSdddDD-ddd-d

Humanitarian Aid Reforms for the U.S. MilitaryMarie Zoglo, American University

Key Facs$8wf2

,

w $4.5 -

,

I, P $2.8

H -

.4(If27,

D

D-

w$95.5)

T f -

,

.


29/36

27

ddTDD-dd-dddddddTdxdD-Ddd

TDD-dddddTwdd-d d - dCdwd d d d d T ddw w dd

Ne eps

AwdDDdddqdIddddddJCSwddd-T-ddd-wUdUdCCddddddwdddddOddNSCwdDDdwDSUdSAID(USAID)UdNNATOIMFdd-

ndnoes1JP3-29FHAJCSM172009dM12011://wwww/w/

/d900d/EGUA-7R7PVJ/$/----09d2JGUSMCPREAFPSA192010dN42010

://wwwd/Nw/NwAx?ID=605133AIWd:FdPwGAdPPwRCM142007dM12011

://w/2007/03/14/----wd-d---w--d-/4FY2010SWDAHRdOPCRSJ272010d

M12011://www////R41232d5 FY (FY) 2007Bd E:OH DAdCAd (OHDACA)D D

SCAF2006dM1 2011://d/dd/2007/d_/d/01_O_d_M/O_M_VOL_1_PARTS/OHDACAd

Talking PoinsR

- w,-

f,

,.

Tx-,

x-

-.


30/36

I1977PdJCddddA-wqwSUSddddddIdddwdP-dd-dAddd

Twd-d

dxWdfddddd Odd dAEdC-dddqA

PdCwdW-wdd-dAddd-

-ddTM-ddddddxwdA

The Moral Equivalent of War:

A Program for Energy SecuritySenior Fello Chris Scanzoni, University o North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Co-Authors Christian Blanco, University o Caliornia at Berkeley Mark Caine, University o Cambrige Sarah Haburg, University o Caliornia at Los Angeles Anthony Petti, University o Caliornia at Berkeley Rose Stanley, Cornell University

28

Innovaio n Prioriies

DDD ddddddARPA-Ed

RSTEMdxIdwRdFwCddUdS

We are proud o nominae The Moral Equivilan o War or policy idea o he year. I ishe rs suden-generaed whie paper o receive his disincion.


31/36

Recommendaions

W w x -ddwEdw-qdqddUdSWddddWw

Inves Deparmen o Deense Federal Grans in RP-

TDD(DD)qddd-dddAddDD d - -wd d w ddCwDDR&DdddARPA-Ewd

Resrucure TM pecaions

TUSddddd(STEM)ddTdd:STEMd;ddSTEMd;ddSTEMdd-d

Inves in mar Grid Technologies

Addddd;dqdw-ddddddwATwdwdw-dddd Tdwdwd-dd

Reassess Nuclear ubsidies

TUdS wwTdddddAxdddwTd ddddd

renghen Formal merican-Canadian Parnerships

G-dddddw-dw Ud S d Cd d ddddWwTddd-

29


32/36

dddPwwwddwddddwBdddddUdSxdd

Conclusion

WwddddddOdR&Dd-wd:dd-dIqdJAwxwAd-dwx-d-ddxwfwqHwwwwdAd 21

T x wd ddw d d d S d dCdEd-w qAS-xwWdxdd

WdWIIdddddddwddUdSwddTqxdddEdd;A

Iqw

R www.w.

30


33/36


34/36


35/36

Get in the spotlight.

W+=.

Tx:

New York DC Boston Detroit San Francisco

rooseveltcampusnetwork.org/young-professionals-network


36/36

Documents

10 Ideas for Defense and Diplomacy, 2011