Upload
rajrudrapaa
View
219
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
1/109
Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements
By
This project is submitted in part fulfilment of the HETAC requirements for the award of
Bachelor of Science (Honours) Forensic Investigation and Analysis Degree.
MAY, 2011
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
2/109
2
Title: ANALYSIS OF PROTEIN DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS
Name:
ID: S00093560
Supervisor:
Declaration:
I hereby declare that this project is entirely my own work and that it has not been submitted
for any other academic award, or part thereof, at this or any other education establishment.
_________________
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
3/109
3
Abstract
Protein dietary supplements are widely used across all ages and user groups. Many analyticaltechniques are available to determine what is contained in protein supplements. Moisture,
peptide, total protein and chiral amino acid analysis are all investigated. The moisture content
of the dried products ranged from 3.14% (Sunwarrior) -7.72% (Hemp). Total protein of these
dried products ranged from 37.08% (Hemp) - 83.34% (Soya 90%). All samples (Dried and
hydrolysed liquid) analysed contained levels of D-amino acids with liquid Aminos having
the highest level at 30.72mg/100ml D-Glutamic acid. D-amino acids cannot be assimilated in
the body, and therefore no use to consumers. The D-amino acids are suspected to originatethrough manufacturing processes although no products states their presence on the label.
i
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
4/109
4
Acknowledgements
I would like to acknowledge the ongoing support, guidance and attention of Dr. Fiona Mc
Ardle who help me immensely throughout this project.
I would also like to acknowledge the support, patients and understanding of my family and
Carla who have supported me through this project.
Sincere thanks must go to the technical staff at IT Sligo, without them this project would not
have been successful.
ii
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
5/109
5
Table of Contents
Page
Abstract i
Acknowledgements ii
Contents iii
Introduction 1
Section 1: Literature Review
1.1 What is protein? 3
1.2 Amino Acids 7
1.2.1 Digestion of amino acids 10
1.3 Dietary protein requirements 16
1.4 Stereoisomerism of amino acids 17
1.4.1 Effects of production on chirality 18
1.4.2 Regulation on chirality 19
1.4.3 Forensic applications of amino acid racemisation 20
1.4.4 Chirality and the International Olympic Committee 21
1.5 Methods available for the analysis of protein 22
1.5.1 Total Protein 22
1.5.2 Peptide analysis by RP-HPLC 26
iii
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
6/109
6
Page
1.5.3 Amino acid analysis 29
1.5.4 Chiral separation of amino acids by gas chromatography. 31
Section 2: Methodology
2.1 Introduction 33
2.2 Experimental protocol
2.2.1 Moisture analysis 35
2.2.2 Biuret total protein 36
2.2.3 Hach Persulfate total nitrogen 38
2.2.4 RP-HPLC peptide analysis 40
2.2.5 GCFID analysis of pentafluoropropyl esters of amino acids 42
2.3 Results 46
2.4 Discussion 54
2.5 Conclusion 63
2.6 Recommendations 64
Appendix I 66
Appendix II 70
Appendix III 88
Bibliography 100
iv
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
7/109
7
Introduction
A dietary supplement is a concentrated source of nutrients or other substances with a
nutritional or physiological effect, whose purpose is to supplement the diet. The Sale of
dietary supplements in Europe is worth 0.5 billion euros with dietary supplements are being
used across all ages and user groups. Protein Based supplements will be investigated in this
dissertation.
The sale of dietary supplements as a foodstuff is controlled under the European
Communities Food Supplements amendment regulations 2010 and this is enforced in Ireland
by the food safety authority of Ireland. ISO 22000 is the international standard for the
production of these supplements, few companies however strive to attain ISO 22000:2005 but
may have other standards in place including ISO 9001 (quality system) ISO 17025 (analysis).
All manufactures of Dietary supplements must adhere to food good manufacturing
practices. This is primarily concerned with safety and sanitation whilst ensuring ingredients
used provide a reasonable certainty of no harm.
Although these regulation and guidelines are in place there are claims that there is
insufficient regulation and monitoring regarding dietary supplements in Europe (Petroczi et al
2010)
The EU Rapid Alert System for Food and Feed RASFF report over 10 claims per month
regarding dietary supplements. These claims can be regarding contamination, higher/lower
than stated levels of active ingredient and the illegal inclusion of anabolic steroids or
hormones.
Recent literature links the use of dietary supplement use to hepatotoxicity (Navarro 2009),
renal failure (Krishann et al 2009)and toxic effects caused by an excess intake of vitaminsand minerals (MacFarquhar et al 2010). If the standards regarding the manufacture and
labelling of dietary supplements was that of a pharmaceutical product, these side effects could
be prevented. (MacFarquhar et al 2010).
Analysis of these products is required in order to ascertain whether or not these products are
safe for consumption by people across all user groups.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
8/109
8
The aim of this dissertation is 3 fold;
1. Investigate methods of analysis for protein based dietary supplements.2. Carry out Laboratory based analysis of these products.3. Ascertain if there are any major discrepancies between laboratory analysis and
manufactures nutritional information.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
9/109
9
What is protein?
Proteins are a diverse and plentiful class of biological molecules which make up for over half
of the dry weight of the human body (Garrett 2010). Proteins are of a diverse nature and each
protein needs to carry out specific biological functions. The dominant structural units of
proteins are polymers (called polypeptides) with molecular weights ranging from 10,000 to
several million and are described as highly complex structures. These polypeptides are
formed from amino acid monomer units (Holum 1998). Polypeptides are joined up peptide
molecules. Peptides are short sequences of amino acids (up to 20 amino acids).
Protein structures have 4 levels of complexity:
Primary structures Secondary structures Tertiary structures. Quaternary structures
Primary structure:
The primary (1o) structure is the first and most fundamental level of the protein. This entails
only the sequence of amino acid residue in the proteins polypeptide(s). A peptide bond joinsamino acids together to form a polypeptide. This system is considered an amide system
because of the Carbonyl to Nitrogen bond. When two amino acids are joined in the body a
molecule of water expels from the reaction, as shown in the figure 1 below(Holum 1998).
Fig. 1
Figure 1: Diagram of 2 amino acids joining to form dipeptide, expelling water during
reaction.(www.molecularsciences.orgaccessed 16-03-2010)
NB: Amino acids will be discussed further in this section.
Secondary structures:
http://www.molecularsciences.org/http://www.molecularsciences.org/http://www.molecularsciences.org/http://www.molecularsciences.org/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
10/109
10
The polypeptide chain can arrange itself into conformations including pleated and helical
formations (fig 2). This is achieved through non-covalent Hydrogen bonding and hydrophobic
interactions between adjacent amino acids. These bonds determine how a polypeptide
conforms into a specific shape. It is primarily the hydrophobic interactions that define the
formation of the polypeptide shape and the hydrogen bonds stabilize the structure. Beta
pleated sheets and alpha helix structures (fig2) are the common shape of polypeptides, due to
the twisting and folding caused by hydrogen bonding and hydrophobic interaction. (Garrett
2010)
Fig2.
Figure 2: Illustrating the hydrogen bonding in alpha helix and beta pleated sheet
formations of secondary structures of a polypeptide.
(www.abcte.orgaccessed 16-Mar-2011)
http://www.abcte.org/http://www.abcte.org/http://www.abcte.org/http://www.abcte.org/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
11/109
11
Tertiary Structures.
The tertiary 3o structure involves the bending and folding of secondary structures so that they
can assume a three-dimensional shape and become more compact as a structure. It is at this
point the molecule becomes globular in shape. It is this globular shape that gives the lowest
volume to surface ratio which lowers the interaction with the molecule and its environment
(Garrett 2010).
During the formation of tertiary structures, alpha helix and beta pleated sheets undergo
extensive folding and twisting in order for the hydrophobic groups to be tucked inside the
molecule and the hydrophilic groups are exposed on the outermost of the structure (Holum
1998).
Ionic bonds help stabilize tertiary structures. These bonds are formed from positive or
negative charges each occurring on a side chain of an amino acid. Disulphide bonds present in
tertiary structures will give rise to loops in polypeptides or have the ability to join strands of
polypeptide together. Van der Waals forces are also present at this point between R groups or
side chains of the amino acids.
Fig. 3
Figure 3: illustration of bonds and interactions within tertiary structure of protein.
(http://www-3.unipv.itaccessed 18-Apr-2011)
http://www-3.unipv.it/http://www-3.unipv.it/http://www-3.unipv.it/http://www-3.unipv.it/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
12/109
12
Quaternary structure:
Some proteins have final shapes at the tertiary level, i.e. Myoglobin because it only consists
of one chain of amino acids and therefore it is a single peptide. If a protein is made up of two
or more polypeptides, this results in a quaternary ( 4o) structure to the protein. Shown below
(fig. 4) is an illustrated version of the 4 structures of protein complexity.
Fig 4
Figure 4: Illustration of the 4 levels of complexity in the structures of proteins.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
13/109
13
Amino Acids:
There are 20 -amino acids (nineteen amino acids and one imino acid) that are used in the
synthesis of peptides and proteins by the human body and these are essentially the building
blocks of protein. Amino acids are the primary products of protein degradation. These 20 -
amino acids are needed to build the various proteins that are used by the body for growth,
repair and maintenance of body tissue. The syntheses of these proteins are controlled by genes
(Holum 1998).
The structure of amino acids.
The term Amino Acid comes from Aminoalkanoic Acid which is an organic compound
comprising of an amino group and a carboxylic acid group (Barrett 1998). The -amino acidterm is used by chemists to identify the carbon atoms in sequence along a chain starting from
the atom next to a major functional group, i.e. Carboxyl group (fig 5). The amino acids that
occur in proteins are strictly -amino acids since their amino group is carried by the alpha
carbon. At physiological pH, in addition to the positive charge on the amino group and the
negative charge on the carboxyl group, five of the twenty -amino acids also carry a charge
on their R-group or side chain. Other side chains are polar, but some are non-polar. See table
1 (Marks et al 1996).
Fig 5
Figure 5: Illustration of the general formula of amino acids. (www.cr4.globalspec.com
accessed 20/03/2011)
Nineteen of the twenty -amino acids follow this formula with proline not conforming to this
formula as in the following table (table 1).
http://www.cr4.globalspec.com/http://www.cr4.globalspec.com/http://www.cr4.globalspec.com/http://www.cr4.globalspec.com/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
14/109
14
Polar properties of amino acids;
Glycine, Alanine, and Proline have small, non-polar side chains and are all weakly
hydrophobic. Phenylalanine, Valine, Leucine, Isoleucine, and Methionine have larger side
chains and are more strongly hydrophobic.
There are also eight -amino acids with polar, uncharged side chains. Serine and Threonine
have hydroxyl groups. Asparagine and Glutamine have amide groups. Histidine and
Tryptophan have heterocyclic aromatic amine side chains. Cysteine has a sulfhydryl group.
Tyrosine has a Phenolic side chain. The sulfhydryl group of Cysteine, phenolic hydroxyl
group of tyrosine, and imidazole group of Histidine all show some degree of pH-dependent
ionization (Holum 1998).
There are four -amino acids with charged side chains. Aspartic acid and Glutamic acid have
carboxyl groups on their side chains. Each acid is fully ionized at pH 7.4. Arginine and lysine
have side chains with amino groups. Their side chains are fully protonated at pH 7.4
(Helmenstine 2011).
Table 1: Diagram outlining the properties of the 20 -amino acids.
(www.personal.psu.eduAccessed 20-Mar-2011)
http://www.personal.psu.edu/http://www.personal.psu.edu/http://www.personal.psu.edu/http://www.personal.psu.edu/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
15/109
15
Although Methionine is listed in table 1 as non-polar, Marks et al 1996 states that this is
somewhat polar, and also states that tryptophan is relatively polar because of its indole ring.
Isoelectric point, symbols and Hydropathy index (pI) of-amino acids
The pI of an amino acid or protein is that pH at which the average charge of the species is 0.
When a protein is at its pI, it will not go into solution. When milk (casein) turns sour, a
precipitate is formed because a change in pH causes the casein molecules to become
Isoelectric (Holum 1998). The following shown in table 2 are the pI values for individual -
amino acids and their symbols
Name
One letter
symbol
Three letter
symbol pI
Hydropathy
Index
Glycine G Gly 6.06 -0.4
Alanine A Ala 6.11 1.8
Valine V Val 6.00 4.2
Leucine L Leu 6.04 3.8
Isoleucine I Ile 6.04 4.5
Phenylalanine F Phe 5.91 2.8
Tryptophan W Trp 5.88 -0.9Proline P Pro 6.30 -1.6
Serine S Ser 5.68 -0.8
Threonine T Thr 5.64 -0.7
Tyrosine Y Tyr 5.63 -1.3
Aspartic acid D Asp 2.98 -3.5
Glutamic acid E Glu 3.08 -3.5
Asparagine N Asn 5.41 -3.5Glutamine Q Gln 5.65 -3.5
Lysine K Lys 9.47 -3.9
Arginine R Arg 10.76 -4.5
Histidine H His 7.64 -3.2
Cysteine C Cys 5.07 2.5
Methionine M Met 5.74 1.9
Table 2: -amino acids and chemical properties. Essential Amino acids are marked in bold.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
16/109
16
At thepIvalue these molecules become zwitterions and will not migrate in an electric field
because the amount of negative charge on the molecule is equal to that of the positive charge.
TheHydropathy index is a measure of the hydrophobicity of the amino acid. The greater the
value, the more hydrophobic the amino acid is. The symbols are shortened versions for
writing many amino acids, in the case of a peptide being illustrated at amino acid level
(Marks et al 1996 & Holum 1998).
Essential and non-essential Amino acids
There are 11 -amino acids that can be synthesised by the body by using Carbon, Ammonia,
carbohydrate and/or fat as the source. These are considered non-essential amino acids, as they
are not directly required from a persons diet (normal text table 1). However, the other 9
amino acids, marked in bold above, are essential amino acids and must be sought from a
persons diet in order to ensure that body protein levels are not diminished.
Metabolism of amino acids in the body
When protein is ingested the digestion process starts in the stomach and travels through the
intestine where the products of digestion, the amino acids and small peptides are rapidly
transported across the walls of the small intestine. See fig. 6.
Advances in understanding protein metabolism have been made in the last few years with the
advent of dual tracer methodology for assessing differences between exogenous and
endogenous amino acid contribution to the protein pool, enhancing the comprehension of
amino acid absorption kinetics (Bilsborough et al 2006).
Enzymatic digestion
Proenzymes- Trypsinogen, Chymotrypsinogen, Proelastase and Procarboxypeptidases (a+b)
excreted from the pancreas are inactive until they reach the lumen of the digestive tract where
they are cleaved to form active enzymes which digest the peptides into amino acids. No single
enzyme can fully digest a protein, but by working together this is achievable (Marks et al
1996).
The excretion of Hydrochloric acid in the stomach enables Pepsinogen to be cleaved to form
Pepsin, which is an active protease. The acid environment also allows for the denaturation ofthe protein.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
17/109
17
Fig 6
Figure 6: Illustration of the digestion of protein in food into amino acids(Marks 1996).
Amino acid catabolism
Once these amino acids enter circulation, theybecome part of the Nitrogen pool. The
nitrogen pool represents all the nitrogenous compounds throughout the body (Holum 1998).
These nitrogenous compounds are used for the synthesis of proteins or they are oxidized as
energy.
Unlike some compounds, such as fats and carbohydrates, the body cannot store amino acids.
Amino acids in the nitrogen pool, which are free (i.e.: amino acids that are not needed to
make other amino acids), are soon catabolised. This is primarily carried out in the liver but,
under fasting conditions, will also take place in the kidneys. The nature of amino acids and
their molecular make up allow for amino acids to be used to synthesise anything the body
requires. The end product of complete amino acid catabolism is Carbon Dioxide, Water and
Urea. (See urea cycle fig.7)
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
18/109
18
All the pathways for use of carbohydrate, fats and protein interact within one way or another,
as visible in fig 7. The carbon skeletons of the essential amino acids outlined in table 2
cannot be synthesized by the body. It is for this reason that they are essential and required
from the diet.
Figure 7: Illustration of amino acid metabolism and interaction pathways in the body.
KG: ketogluarate; OAA: oxyloacetate; G-6-P: glucose 6- phosphate; G-1-P: glucose 1-
phosphate (Marks 1996).
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
19/109
19
Transamination and Deamination
Amino acid metabolism involves the amino acid undergoing transamination, (fig 8) which is
the transfer of an amino group from the amino acid to a keto acid (carbon skeleton). This
carbon skeleton is then oxidized and most of the carbons are converted to energy in the form
of pyruvate, intermediates of the tricaboxylic acid cycle or to acetyl CoA.All amino acids can
undergo this type of reaction except lysine and Threonine. For the majority of these reactions
-ketoglutarate and glutamate serve as an -keto/amino pair needed along with the cofactor
pyridoxal phosphate. This reaction is reversible and for this reason is involved in both
synthesis and degradation of amino acids (Marks et al 1996). Deamination removes amino
groups from the amino acids. Three types of deamination can occur; oxidative, reductive and
direct.
Fig. 8.
Figure 8: Illustration of transamination.Pairs of amino acids and their corresponding -
keto acids are involved in this type of reaction (Marks 1996).
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
20/109
20
Urea Cycle.
The body cannot store amino acids and once the degradation/synthesis of amino acids has
taken place and the excess amino acids are converted to proteins and energy, the body must
remove excess ammonia groups which are the product of many reactions- See figure 9.This occurs because ammonia is toxic to the body, especially to the brain and central nervous
system. There are two sources of nitrogen being converted to the urea.
1. Oxidatative deamination of glutamate which produce an ammonium ion.2. Asparatate.
The urea cycle produces urea from ammonium ion, carbon dioxide and asparatate. (Fig 9)
Water soluble urea leaves the body via the kidneys in the form of urine. Amino acidcatabolism must occur in a way that does not elevate ammonia levels in the blood. The rate of
amino acid derived ammonia converted to urea is limited (Marks et al 1996).In addition
nitrogenous compounds are also excreted in faeces and sweat but to a far lesser extent (Lemon
1991).
In a specific study a maximal rate of 55mg urea N .h-1. Kg-0.75 excretion is observed when
0.53g protein N/kg-0.75 is ingested, this rate was maintained even though a further increase in
protein consumption was undertaken. This rate is not specific to everyone however, because
the amount of dietary protein that can be deaminated by the liver is dependent on body weight
and individual variation in efficiency of this process (Bilsborough et al 2006). Problems may
occur if a diet consists of protein content that is greater than the bodys ability to excrete
unwanted ammonia.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
21/109
21
Figure 9: Illustration of the sources of ammonia (left) and the Urea cycle (right) (Marks
et al 1996)
Nitrogen Balance:
For a person to be in nitrogen balance they will have ingested the amount of nitrogen in the
form of protein which is equal to the amount of nitrogen excreted (Marks 1996).
Furthermore, Stuart et al 2007 states the nitrogen balance is a likely and acceptable method
for establishing nitrogen or amino acid requirements necessary to prevent deficiency. In
contrast, using the nitrogen balance to determine the protein needs of the individual is flawed
according to Trumbo 2002. The reason that this is flawed is twofold; 1: high nitrogen balances
are observed with high protein intakes. 2: increased economy nitrogen is observed at low
protein intakes. These balances are often estimated and do not take into account dermal and
miscellaneous losses of nitrogen. The World Health Organisation (WHO) concurs with this
theory and states that using this method results in a lower amount than is truly needed to
establish daily allowances for protein consumption.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
22/109
22
Dietary protein requirements:
Dietary protein requirements has been a long debated area of nutrition. There are many
parameters that effect the dietary protein requirements (WHO 2001)of individuals. These
include lifestyle, metabolic demand, growth and the efficiency of the body to use protein. Theprimary lifestyle influences on an individuals need for protein will depend on the level of
physical activity. Whilst an increase in physical activity will increase the demand for protein
the extent of this can be reduced through training, as the body will adapt to the physical
activity. Physical activity increases oxidation of amino acids which leads to increased
ureagenesis and the loss of nitrogen (Rennie et al 2000). The type and intensity of the
physical activity can have an effect in the way that amino acids are utilized in the body.
Hargreaves et al 2001 explain that during prolonged exercise, individuals show catabolism of
branched chain amino acids (BCAAs). The catabolism of Isoleucine, Valine and especially
Leucine, indicate that there is an increase in the uptake of BCAAs in the contracting muscle,
an increase in the oxidation of BCAAs within the muscle and an increase in the production of
carbon dioxide as a by-product.
The World Health Organisation states that the safe protein requirement for protein is 0.83
g/kg per day, for proteins with a protein digestibility-corrected amino acid score value of 1.0.(WHO 2007)
Table 3.
Table 3: The safe protein level for both men and woman (>18 yrs) according to their
bodyweight.
The WHO 2007 have not set an upper limit for protein consumption, but they do recommend
that caution is taken if individuals are to ingest 3 or 4 times the safe limit, as these cannot be
assumed to be risk free.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
23/109
23
Stereoisomerism of -amino acids
All the -amino acids, except glycine, are chiral molecules and can be present in
dextrorotatory (D) or laevorotatory (L) configuration. The D- and L- enantiomers are mirror
images of each other that cannot be superimposed on each other by rotating the molecule.
Enantiomers are optical isomers and are known to have identical chemical and physical
properties.
Enantiomers cause rotation of polarized light in opposite direction. (L- rotates light tothe left & D- rotates light to the right)
Enantiomers react with other optical active compounds at different rates.(Zawirska-Wojtasiak 2006)
Holum 1998 states that nature supplies only one of the two enantiomers. The amino acids
concerned with humans and human nutrition belong to the L- optical family. All the proteins
in the human body are synthesized from L-amino acids, and all these are chiral. Some D-
amino acids are formed in bacteria and this configuration helps the bacteria to survive in
humans where the enzymes used to destroy infecting protein organisms only recognize the L-
form of the organism. See figure 10 below.
Fig 10.
Figure 10: Illustration of D- & L- configuration of amino acids and Glycine (Marks et al
1996).
Glycine is not a chiral compound because the -Carbon is not asymmetric as it contains two
groups which are identical.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
24/109
24
Effects of production on chirality in protein rich foodstuffs
In the production of foods, specifically protein sports supplements and infant formula the
starting material is generally a protein rich food source, such as milk or whey. Production
techniques may involve heat, irradiation, fermentation, addition of synthetic materials and the
adjustment of pH which may induce racemisation.
Racemisation is the transformation of one-half of the molecules of an optically active
compound into molecules that possess exactly the opposite (mirror-image) configuration, with
complete loss of rotatory power because of the statistical balance between equal numbers of
dextrorotatory and levorotatory molecules (Miller-Keane 2003).
An example of racemisation is discussed byZawirska-Wojtasiak 2006 who claims that
microwave heating of reconstituted infant formula may lead to the formation of D-proline.
This, however, is rebutted by Marchelli 1996 & Sibre 1996 who state that No significant
racemisation occurred in either the free or protein-bound amino acids under the conditions
used. The conditions used to test this theory included a domestic microwave oven, a
conventional oil bath and a wave guide device. This study did not investigate other production
techniques that may involve intense heat or irradiation. Marchelli 1996 elaborates, stating thatthere is no toxicity of D-amino acids in humans and even in infants, although their metabolic
rate has not been established.
Proteins play an important role in tasteperception and in all amino acids except Methionine
depending on their D- of L- configuration are either neutral, bitter or sweet. (Prescott et al
1995)
During production a protein based product may be chemically altered and certain amino acids
may undergo racemisation to exhibit a specific taste. In the case of sports supplements, an
amino acid profile may be visible on the label but, in some cases, it may not state if the amino
acids are in the L-form which the body may use in the synthesis of proteins to aid the athlete.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
25/109
25
Regulation on chirality:
A world-wide scare occurred when Thalidomide, a sedative drug was manufactured by
Chemie Grunenthal (a German chemical company). It was sold around the world from 1957-
1961 and it caused 10,000+ birth defects (Riehl 2010).
This drug never made it into the U.S.A on a commercial basis, as the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) demanded further evidence that this was effective and safe. However,
it was used on an experimental basis, causing 17 birth defects in the US.
The issue with this particular drug is that L-isomer is teratogenicand D-isomer is an active
drug to treat morning sickness. A further complication with this drug is that it can racemize
in vivo. Therefore, even if only one isomer is administered both will be found in the serum.
Often only one isomer of a racemic chiral drug is the effective agent that is therapeutic, whilst
the other isomer may display limited effects, no effects or may even be toxic like L-
Thalidomide.
1987 saw the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) include, for the first time, the area of
stereo-chemical regulation in their drug substance guidelines. Today, this proves to be afundamental part of drug design, as in 2006 when more than 80% of new drugs approved by
the FDA were chiral compounds (Riehl 2010).
However, it was not until 1992, twenty-nine years after president Kennedy signed an
amendment regarding a new drug safety policy, that the FDA insisted that, in order to market
a chiral drug as a racemic mixture, the company must determine the pharmacological and
toxicological activities of both enantiomers in animals and in humans.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
26/109
26
Forensic application of Amino Acid racemisation.
A valued method being used by the forensic community to estimate the age (age at death) of
the remains for the past 30 years is called amino acid racemisation (AAR). This method is
based on the understanding that through the racemisation process, the native protein buildingL- enantiomers are spontaneously converted into D- enantiomers in a time dependent manner.
The most commonly used amino acid is aspartic acid (Asp). However, others have been used
with success and these include glutamate, alanine and serine (Arany et al 2010). The
accuracy of this technique is (+/-) 3yrs (Waite 1999, Arany et al 2010).
The rate of racemisation of these amino acids is dependent on pH, temperature, protein
concentration and environmental water concentration (Arany et al 2010). Dentin is usedbecause the proteins in the dentin are metabolically isolated and are kept at a constant
temperature of 37oC (+/- 1oC) during life (Waite 1999). The racemised form of the original
protein can then accumulate over time and the extent of this racemisation can then be used to
estimate the age at which the person died.
An extensive study carried out in 1999 by Waite discovered a range of racemisation rates
(dentin) published by a series of authors. These values ranged from 5.688 X 10-4 yr-1 to 8.35 X
10-4 yr-1. The reason for the extensive variation among the authors was believed to be down to
the differences in the methods used to determine the rate.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
27/109
27
Chirality and the International Olympic Committee.
In 2002 Alan Baxter an Olympic bronze medal winner was forced to forfeit his medal because
he tested positive for speed after using a Vicks vapour inhaler nasal decongestant. This is
because the active enantiomer in the inhaler is L-Methamphetamine. The banned substanceSpeed is D-Methamphetamine. IOC drug testing use standard GC and these enantiomers will
have the same retention. This is why the International Olympic Committee (IOC) stripped the
athlete of the medal. If a Chiral GC column was used enantiomers would have different
retention times (Ahern 2004). Although it was later proven this athlete did not Speed the IOC
rules required the medal to be forfeited, an in addition the IOC updated there prohibited list
(class 1.Aa and 1.Ab stimulants) to include both enantiomers of prohibited drugs (Mottram
2003).
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
28/109
28
Methods available for the analysis of protein
There are a wide range of methods available for protein analysis. Depending on the protein
characteristics and what information the analyst requires will depict what method an analyst
will use. For the purpose of this study, the focus will remain with total protein quantification
of intact proteins, peptide identification and amino acid determination.
Total Protein quantification
Kjeldahl
This method is based on the understanding that when organic nitrogen- containing compounds
such as protein- is digested/heated with H2SO4 (catalyst present) the nitrogen is converted to
(NH4)2SO4. The digestion process is carried out using a digestion block, as in figure 11 b,
below. The digestion products are treated with excess alkali (NaOH) (Fig 11b) and ammonia,
produced by distillation and collected in a flask containing boric acid. The receiving flask is
then titrated to a grey colour using hydrochloric acid.
Calculation:
%N= ( )
Sample Weight (grams) X 10
(Royal Society of Chemistry 2005)
This has been used as a standard method for the determination of nitrogen content in protein
compounds for over 100 years and is a standard method in the pharmaceutical, agricultural,
food sector, biological sediments and in waste water matrices. Furthermore, Owusu-Apenten
2002 state that this method gives accurate readings, no matter what state the sample is in.
This method, however, is labour intensive, time consuming and involves toxic/corrosive
chemicals, although this is considered a very accurate and reliable method as it is an absolute
method of analysis. Kjeldahl analysis has a reported detection limit of 0.053 mg N and a
quantification limit of 0.159mg N. (www.bushi.fr Accessed 06/04/2011)
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
29/109
29
Figure 11a: Buchi Distillation/condenser unit. Figure 11b: Buchi Digestion block.
(www.buchi.fr. Accessed 06/03/2011) (www.imlab.comAccessed 06/03/2011)
Domini et al 2009 developed a method based on the Kjeldalh method. The difference is that
this method used microwave and ultrasound energy to assist the digestion. This two-step
(mineralization & oxidation) digestion means that there is a significant reduction in the time
taken for the analysis which is approximately 7 minutes. This closed vessel low pressuretechnique reduced analysis time and risk, as it resulted in less exposure time to toxic
chemicals.
http://www.buchi.fr/http://www.buchi.fr/http://www.buchi.fr/http://www.imlab.com/http://www.imlab.com/http://www.imlab.com/http://www.imlab.com/http://www.buchi.fr/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
30/109
30
Bradford assay
The Bradford assay is a dye-based assayfor determining protein content in solution. The dye
(Serva blue G dye) interacts with the protein and the protein dye complex is detectable using a
spectrometer at 595nm. A standard curve, with samples of known concentration, must be
prepared in parallel with the unknown protein solution. The concentration of the unknown
protein can then be determined from the standard curve. A common standard used is Bovine
Serum Albumin (BSA).
This assay is fast at approximately 10 minutes (2 min development time), but does involve the
use of phosphoric acid which is corrosive. Bradford assay sensitivity ranges from 25g/ml -
200g/ml. If the samples are left for over 10 minutes, then they may start to precipitate due to
the acidic conditions. However, this method is not widely used due to the fact that the dye
interacts more or less strongly with different proteins and thus is not strictly quantitative
(Bradford 1976, Bollag et al 1991).
Pierce Biotechnology, a member of the Thermo scientific group has designed an assay that is
quantitative, based on the Bradford method. This method utilises higher concentrations of
protein samples, at 125- 1500g/ml, and uses Comaomassie G as its dye. (Fig 12)
(www.qcbio.comaccessed 06/04/2011)
Fig 12.
Figure 12: Illustration of the expanded Bradford method, Comaomassie Plus, as sold
by Pierce Biotechnology. (www.qcbio.comaccessed 06/04/2011)
http://www.qcbio.com/http://www.qcbio.com/http://www.qcbio.com/http://www.qcbio.com/http://www.qcbio.com/http://www.qcbio.com/http://www.qcbio.com/http://www.qcbio.com/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
31/109
31
Biuret assay
Compounds containing 2 or more peptide bonds react with the Biuret solution, which is dilute
alkali copper sulphate solution, and gives a characteristic purple colour. The colour reaction
comes from the formation of a compound, formed from the copper atom and the four nitrogen
atoms, two from each of the two peptide chains (Fig 13).
Figure 13 : Illustration of 4 Nitrogen molecules (from 2 peptides) binding to copper to
form complex.
Similar to the Bradford test, the Biuret test is based on the principal of spectroscopy and must
also have a standard curve produced in order to quantify the protein in a sample. The intensity
of the colour is proportional to the amount of protein in the sample and this is determined by
measuring the absorbance at 570nm. This method is described as a quantitative estimation so,
therefore, is not as reliable as an analytical scientist would require (Bollag 1991).
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
32/109
32
Protein/Peptide analysis by liquid chromatography
Liquid chromatography is a separation technique used for the analysis of a mixture of
compounds or chemicals. This technique involves 2 phases, a mobile phase which is a liquid
and a stationary phase which is a solid. The sample is injected into the liquid mobile phase
and this passes through a column which contains the stationary phase (fig.12). Due to
chemical and/or physical interactions between the analyte, the mobile phase and the stationary
phase, will determine how long the analyte is retained on the stationary phase. Compounds
are separated based on retention time that is assigned to each compound as they pass through
the detector at the end of the system.
Fig 12.
Figure 12: Illustration of a liquid chromatographic system.
(http://www.appliedporous.comaccessed 11-04-2011)
Several techniques have been developed to analyse proteins and peptides based on liquid
chromatography. These chromatographic modes include: reverse phase high pressure
(RPHPLC), hydrophobic interaction, size exclusion, affinity and isoelectric. The most widelyused method is RPHPLC (Corradini 2010).
http://www.appliedporous.com/http://www.appliedporous.com/http://www.appliedporous.com/http://www.appliedporous.com/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
33/109
33
Reverse Phase High Pressure Liquid Chromatography separation of proteins
Reverse phase means that the stationary phase is non-polar (hydrophobic) or weakly polar and
the mobile phase is more polar (hydrophilic).
When using RPHPLC for the analysis of proteins, the mobile phase generally consists of a
mixture of water and an organic solvent. Acetonitrile is a suitable organic solvent for this
purpose as it has a low ultra violet (UV) absorbance that will have minimal response with the
UV detector, low viscosity and high elution strength.
An organic acid is also added to the mobile phase. This acts as a counter ion of any charged
amino acid which may increase peptide retention with the charged silanols of the silica
support. Trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) is an organic acid that is widely used for this purpose, aswell as the less popular additives such as acetic acid, formic acid, phosphoric acid and
ammonium acetate. TFA is most popular due to its volatile nature, UV transparency and
strong ion pairing nature (Corradini 2010).
Proteins are separated using a solvent gradient system, which alters the polarity of the mobile
phase over time, therefore altering the hydrophobic nature of the mobile phase. During the
solvent gradient, when the amount of organic solvent reaches a precise concentration unique
to each protein, the protein desorbs from the hydrophobic surface and elutes from the column,
therefore being separated based on hydrophobic interaction. Where an UV detection system is
unavailable, Electrospray Light Scattering Detection (ELSD) can also be used to detect
proteins post separation. A refractive index detector may be used but has a detection level
approximately 1000 times lower that UV (Harris 2003).
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
34/109
34
Other separation techniques
Protein analysis can also be carried out using Capillary Electrophoresis (CE). This technique
separates the proteins molecules based on charge and size. The analytes travel through a
buffer solution (CE) or through a polymer immersed in a buffer (capillary gelelectrophoresis).
A range of slab gel electrophoresis techniques that use both denaturing and non-denaturing
methods can also be used for the separation of proteins. Similar to capillary gel
electrophoresis, this uses an electrical current to separate analytes based on charge and size.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
35/109
35
Amino Acid analysis
Amino acid analysis can be used to quantify the protein content, determine the amino acid
composition and help detect contaminants within a protein matrix.
Hydrolysis:
Before the amino acids in the protein can be analysed, the protein must undergo a hydrolysis
step (fig.13) which breaks down the protein into individual amino acids by way of breaking
the peptide link. Hydrolysis can be achieved by using acid, alkaline or enzymatic methods.
The more common method is by means of acid. This is usually carried out in the presence of
6M hydrochloric acid over a 24 hour period at a constant 110oC, although microwave
methods are being used as they can speed up this hydrolysis step to under 30 minutes.
(www.milesonesci.comAccessed 10/05/2011) The amino acids are in the form of their
positive ion state due to the hydrogen ions from Hydrochloric acid.
Acid hydrolysis impedes the ability to detect tryptophan, aspartic acid and glutamine post-
hydrolysis as these are destroyed (www.nhis.go.jpAccessed 05/05/2011). Cysteine is partially
destroyed. For this reason, acid hydrolysis limits the analyst to use 16 amino acids for
quantification and identification. (www.sigmaaldrich.comAccessed 10-05-2011)
Fig. 13
Fig.13: Illustration of an Acid hydrolysis mechanism. (www.chemguide.comaccessed 19-
Apr-2011)
Once the peptide is hydrolysed into its constituent amino acids they usually need to be
derivatized. The type of derivatization that is required will depend on, and be determined by,
the analysis technique that is used. Generally, 2 methods are used to analyse amino acids:
Liquid chromatography (HPLC) or Gas chromatography (GC)
http://www.milesonesci.com/http://www.milesonesci.com/http://www.milesonesci.com/http://www.nhis.go.jp/http://www.nhis.go.jp/http://www.nhis.go.jp/http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/http://www.chemguide.com/http://www.chemguide.com/http://www.chemguide.com/http://www.chemguide.com/http://www.sigmaaldrich.com/http://www.nhis.go.jp/http://www.milesonesci.com/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
36/109
36
HPLC detection systems that use spectrometric methods require the analyte to contain a
chromophore, which once excited at one wavelength, will emit light at a different wavelength,
specific to the analyte. The problem with amino acids is that they do not all have aromatic
systems or a series of single/double bonds; therefore, they are not chromophores.
Pre-column and post-column derivatization is available for the detection of amino acids using
HPLC. Pre-column derivatives include 9-fluorenylmethyloxycarbonyl (FMOC) and 0-
phthalaldehyde (OPA) (Jambor et al 2009).
Gas Chromatography:
In gas chromatography (GC) the sample (gas or liquid) containing the analyte of interest is
injected through a septum. The analyte is then vaporised in a heated chamber before it iscarried onto the column by a carrier gas. The carrier gas, as the name suggests, is only used to
move the analyte through the GC system (fig.14) and does not interact with the analyte,
unlike liquid chromatography. The column in this case is in the form of either solid particles
or a non-volatile viscous liquid on a solid support. A detector detects the analytes as they
leave the column and reports this onto a computer. A range of detectors are available and
cater for the varying amounts of information that is required from the analysis and the
available budget. These detectors include Thermal conductivity; Flame ionization; Electroncapture; Mass spectrometry (Harris 2003).
Fig14.
Figure 14: Illustration of a basic Gas chromatography system.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
37/109
37
Chiral separation of Amino Acids
Amino acids are not volatile; therefore the amino acid analyte must undergo derivatization.
Derivatization makes the amino acid volatile so it can be used in the GC system. An example
of derivatization is by creating pentafluoropropyl isopropyl esters of amino acids. This
involves esterification and acetylation steps to change the native amino acids into esters of
amino acids (Drozd 1981).
Enantiomers of amino acids are separated on a Chiral Colum, a column modified to contain a
chiral molecule that is specific to amino acids. A commonly used column is the CHIRASIL-
Val Colum. This modified column contains L-Valine-tert.-butylamide poly-
cyanopropylmethylsiloxanes which interact with the derivitized amino acids through
hydrogen bonding between analyte and stationary phase. L- amino acids are retained slightly
longer than D-amino acids when using this column due to the strategic positioning of the L-
valine-tert butylamide inside the stationary phase which allows two hydrogen bonds to form
where as D-amino acids may only form one, enabling less retention on the column (Rotzsche
1991)
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
38/109
38
Methodology
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
39/109
39
Introduction
Many food supplements have been reported as potentially dangerous to consumers especiallywhen large amounts of dietary supplements are consumed. The manufactures of these dietary
supplements only need to include basic information on the label such as macromolecule
composition. No consideration is given to how certain components of the dietary supplements
may interact with other drugs or medication consumers have taken.
The European Union Rapid Alert System for Food and Feed has called for routine thorough
analysis as the number of notifications to them has increased 6 fold in last 7 years. This
indicates this problem is getting worse and the need for better quality control and compliancein this sector is required to ensure consumers are not at risk.
In order to find out if the supplements sold on the Irish high street are what the manufactures
claim them to be, analysis of 5 products will be carried out. Of these products 4 will be highly
concentrated dried protein products and one will be a liquid amino acid product.
This report will look at protein dietary supplements covering 3 major areas; moisture content;
total protein content and individual amino acids composition. Further to the amino acidanalysis, chiral characterisation of the amino acids will also be investigated as this is an area
not routinely studied at in food industry. Protein analysis and characterisation of proteins
using hydrophobic interaction will also be investigated.
Chiral characterisation of food stuffs and proteins in particular are important as, this analysis
proves manufacturing technologies can cause racemisation of amino acids that were in their
native L- form prior to manufacture of the product.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
40/109
40
In this section 4 areas of analysis will be discussed. These relate to Moisture content, total
protein concentration, HPLC Peptide analysis and Gas chromatography of amino acid
derivatives.
All protein powder subjects purchased from Holland & Barrett, Ireland except Sunwarriorwhich was sourced by Dr. Fiona Mc Ardle.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
41/109
41
Moisture analysis
Subjects:
Hemp Natural Protein powder (Unflavoured) 90% Soya Protein instant powder ( Strawberry) Instant Milk & Egg protein. (Strawberry) Sunwarrior Raw Vegan protein (Chocolate)
Equipment:
Binder ED11 Convection Oven (105oC) 12 * Aluminium dishes with lids. Desiccator. Oven proof gloves. Shimadzu AX 200 Analytical balance
Experimental protocol.
1. Weigh in triplicate approximately 1 gram of sample into a tared dish on an analyticalbalance (the dishes must have been heated for at least one hour at 100oC and
subsequently, cooled and stored in a dessicator prior to use.
2. Distribute the sample over the bottom of the dishes.3. Place the dishes in the oven ensuring they are identifiable.4. After 2 hours remove the dishes from the oven using oven proof gloves.5. Cool in a dessicator for 30 minutes.6. Weigh the dishes and dried powder on an analytical balance.7. Place back into oven for 30 minutes and repeat steps 5-7 until constant weight is
achieved.
Analysis.
Calculations: % Moisture = Loss in weight (g)*100 / weight of sample (g)
Report results on a column chart.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
42/109
42
Biuret Total Protein
Subjects:
Hemp Natural Protein powder (Unflavoured) 90% Soya Protein instant powder ( Strawberry) Instant Milk & Egg protein. (Strawberry) Sunwarrior Raw Vegan protein (Chocolate)
Equipment:
Shimadzu 160U UV spectrometer 570nm Micropipette. P1000 Graduated pipettes (Grade A) 12 test tubes Vortex Mixer
Reagents:
Standard protein solution (BSA 10mg/ml in 5% acetic acid/ ultrapure water) Biuret Reagent Samples diluted to 5mg/ml using 5% acetic acid/95% ultrapure water and filtered
through Whatman (#54) filterpaper to remove particulates.
Experimental Protocol:
1. Label 18 tubes (6 standards and sample to be carried out in triplicate).2. Pipette 0.0, 0.4, 0.8, 1.2, 1.6, 2.0ml of standard protein solution into a series of 6 test
tubes.
3. Make these volumes up to 2ml with 5% acetic acid/95% ultrapure water.4. Pipette 2ml diluted samples into each of 3 test tubes.5. Add 8ml Biuret reagent to each standard and sample tubes.6. Allow colour to develop for 30 minutes.7. After 30 minutes read absorbance of standards and sample against reagent blank
(ultrapure water) at 570nm.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
43/109
43
Analysis:
Using the data, draw a standard protein curve in Microsoft Excel (absorbance Vweight of protein).
From the standard protein curve get the trend line equation, Y= MX +C (i.e. y = 0.025X + 0.1083)
Use X= (AbsorbanceC)/M to determine (M) mg protein per sample. Calculate the concentration of protein in the protein sample as (%w/v, i.e. g/100ml),
not forgetting the dilution factor.
Compare concentration of protein in samples to expected protein concentrations andreport on a column chart.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
44/109
44
Hach Test n Tube Persulfate Total Nitrogen
Subjects:
Hemp Natural Protein powder (Unflavoured) 90% Soya Protein instant powder ( Strawberry) Instant Milk & Egg protein. (Strawberry) Sunwarrior Raw Vegan protein (Chocolate)
Equipment:
Hach DRB 200 programmable reactor Digestion block.(105oC) Hach DR2800 UV portable spectrometer.
Reagents:
Hach Test n Tube Kit# 2672245 consisting of:
1. LR Total Nitrogen Hydroxide digestion vials.2. Total Nitrogen Persulphate reagent powder pillow.3. Total Nitrogen reagent ABisulfite powder pillow.4. Total nitrogen reagent B- Indicator Powder.5. Total Nitrogen Reagent CAcid solution vials6. Reagent water7. Plastic funnel (not included in kit)8. Protein samples: 5g/L
Experimental Protocol:
As per Hach method #10071 Total Nitrogen by Persulfate digestion.
1. Using funnel, add contents of a total Nitrogen Persulfate reagent powder pillow toeach of labelled total Nitrogen Hydroxide vials.
2. Prepared sample: Add 2ml of sample to sample vials. Blank: Add 2 ml of deionisedwater to a blank vials.
3. Cap vials and shake vigorously for at least 30 seconds to mix.4. Insert the vials into the reactor and close the lid. Heat for exactly 30 minutes.5. Remove the vials immediately and allow cooling to room temperature.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
45/109
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
46/109
46
High Pressure Liquid Chromatography-Peptide analysis
Subjects:
Bovine Serum albumin. (3.53mg/ml)(67.0kDa) Myoglobin (2.80mg/ml)(18.8kDa) Cytochrome C (4.27mg/ml)(12.4kDa)
(All subjects made up in mobile phase A and filtered through Whatman filter paper
#54).
Equipment:
Dionex ultimate 3000 HPLC with discovery BIO wide pore C5 column(15cm*4.6mm,5m)
Micropipette P1000.Reagents:
Temperature analysis:
Mobile phase (A) 0.1% (v/v) TFA (ion paring agent) in ultrapure H2O: MeCN (75:25),(B) 0.1% (v/v) TFA in ultrapure H2O: MeCN (25:75) on gradient 0-100%B in 25
TFA Analysis:
0.005% TFA Mobile phase (A) 0.005% (v/v) TFA (ion paring agent) in ultrapureH2O: MeCN (75:25), (B) 0.005% (v/v) TFA in ultrapure H2O: MeCN (25:75) on
gradient 0-100%B in 25
0.01% TFA Mobile phase (A) 0.01% (v/v) TFA (ion paring agent) in ultrapure H 2O:MeCN (75:25), (B) 0.01% (v/v) TFA in ultrapure H2O: MeCN (25:75) on gradient 0-
100%B in 25
0.1% TFA Mobile phase (A) 0.1% (v/v) TFA (ion paring agent) in ultrapure H2O:MeCN (75:25), (B) 0.1% (v/v) TFA in ultrapure H2O: MeCN (25:75) on gradient 0-
100%B in 25
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
47/109
47
Experimental Protocol:
1. Allow column to equilibrate for at least 2 hours (flow rate 1ml/min) when adjustingmobile phase. If switching mobile phase from 0.1% TFA to no TFA allow overnight
equilibration.2. Pipette 2ml of sample into brown HPLC sample vial.3. Place on carousel and note position. Assign name to position # on carousel via
Chromeleon Software.
4. Ensure system has been purged, free of air bubbles and mobile phase is degassed.5. Set UV detector to 220 nm, flow rate to 1ml/min, injection 10l.6. For temperature analysis set to desired temperature per individual run, otherwise set to
30o
C.7. For TFA analysis Adjust TFA concentration and allow to equilibrate as above.8. To run sample- Select sequence Fiona/Cormac protein mod 1, add sample to batch
and name, ensure correct parameters are set. Connect pump, detector, auto sampler
and oven. Click Start batch from upper tabs, ready check and then start.
9. Run should take 28 minutes and chromatograph will be stored on system.Analysis
Note subjects retention time and any other obvious observations. Prepare a bar chart in Excel, one for temperature adjustment and one for TFA
adjustment.
Present parameter change Vs retention time and report observations.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
48/109
48
Gas Chromatography (GC) of Pentafluoropropyl Isopropyl Esters of Amino Acids using
Flame Ionisation Detection.
3 step technique:
1. Acid hydrolysis.2. Derivatization of Amino acids.3. GCFID analysis.
Subjects:
Hemp Natural Protein powder (Unflavoured) 90% Soya Protein instant powder ( Strawberry) Instant Milk & Egg protein. (Strawberry) Sunwarrior Raw Vegan protein (Chocolate) Aminos Drink (Hydrolysed amino acid liquid.)
Equipment:
Binder ED11 Convection Oven 5 glass hydrolysis tubes. (COD vials soaked in 10% Nitric acid 0vernight) Heating block 115oC+. Nitrogen Stream apparatus. Shimadzu GC17 Gas chromatography system & CHIRASIL-Val(All Tech) Chiral
Column.
Reagents:
Hydrolysis solution: 6M hydrochloric acid containing 0.5% Phenol. PFP-IPA Amino Acid Derivatization Kit. Cat #18093-Lennox. Standards: D/L- Valine, D/L -Glutamic Acid, D/L -Aspartic Acid, D-Leucine, D/L-
Methionine (Sigma 99% Puris grade)
Diethylether (AnaLaR grade).
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
49/109
49
Experiment protocol:
Acid Hydrolysis1. Place 25mg of protein powder into hydrolysis tube.2. Add 10ml of hydrolysis solution.3. Hydrolyse samples at 110oC for 24 hours in an oven.
NB: Aminos Amino Acid drink does not require hydrolysis.
4. Once cooled, open cap and place on hotplate at 115oC under stream ofNitrogen until hydrolysis solution has completely evaporated.
5. Allow to cool to ambient.
Derivatization of Amino Acids.1. Add 3 ml of 0.2M Hydrochloric acid to sample tube, heat solution to approx 110oC
for 5 minutes, and dry under stream of Nitrogen.
2. Slowly add 1.25ml Acetyl Chloride to 5ml Isopropanol. Add to dry Amino acid,cap tube and heat to approximately 100oC for 45 minutes in oven. Allow to cool.
3. Uncap and heat to approximately 115oC under a stream of Nitrogen to removeexcess reagent, allow cooling to ambient then place tube in an ice bath.
4. Add 3ml Dichloromethane (Methylene Chloride) and one ampoule of PFPA, capand heat to 100oC for 15 minutes.
5. After cooling to ambient, evaporate excess reagent under stream of Nitrogen andreconstitute in 500ul Diethylether.
GCFID Analysis.1. Switch on GCFID instrument, Nitrogen carrier Gas, Hydrogen and Air.2.
Start GC17 software and select GC instrument.
3. Open method: class-vp\martin\cychex.met.4. Ensure parameters are: Oven Temperature 90oC(4minute hold) to 190oC at
4oC/minute;Injection temperature 250oC;Detector temperature 275oC; Split
ratio 56:1; Carrier gas Nitrogen; Flow rate 1.07ml/minute;Linear velocity
22.2cm/sec; Pressure 6.4psi; Sample size 1l.
5. Prior to injection, select single run, assign # to sample and press ok.6. Wait until dialog box appears prompting injection, then inject and press data
acquisition start immediately.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
50/109
50
7. Manually assign peaks on samples by comparing retention times of standardsto retention times of samples.
8. Report amino acid concentration in a bar chart and compare to informationsupplied with each product.
NB: When available an internal standard, which should be an unnaturally
occurring primary amino acid such as Nitrotyrosine should be used in order to
monitor chemical and physical losses as well as variations during amino acid
analysis.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
51/109
51
Results
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
52/109
52
Oven Drying Moisture analysis:
Fig A
Figure A: Column chart illustrating the moisture content of 4 protein products following an
oven drying method at 105oC.(Appendix II table 3)
3.14
7.72
4.323.65
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Sun warrior Hemp Milk and Egg Soya 90%
%Moisture
Product
Moisture analysis of Protein Products
Moisture content
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
53/109
53
Biuret Total Protein & Hach total Nitrogen: Fig B 1
Fig B 1: Column chart illustrating the Total Protein content of 4 protein products following
Biuret Total protein analysis and Hach Total Nitrogen (Nitrogen converted to protein by
conversion factor of 6.38. (Appendix II table 4-5. Appendix II fig 13)
49.48
37.08
67.61
83.34
71.00
47.00
73.00
86.00
52.94
45.63
79.69 81.38
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Sunwarrior Hemp Milk and Egg Soya
%ProteinContent
Protein Product
Buiret and Hach Analysis of Protein
Reported
Buiret %
On label %
Reported
Hach %
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
54/109
54
Hach Total Nitrogen: Fig B 2
Figure B 2: Hach Persulfate results as in B1 except, the conversion factor for specific food
types has been applied, these are; Sunwarrior *5.40; Hemp *5.36; Milk & Egg *5.94; Soya
90% *5.40. (Salovaananen et al 1996) (Appendix II table 4-5.Appendix II fig 13).
52.94
45.63
79.69 81.3871.00
47.00
73.00
86.00
45.7439.13
75.70
65.62
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Sunwarrior Hemp Milk and Egg Soya 90%
%ProteinContent
Protein Product
Hach Persulfate analysis of Protein Supplements
Reported Hach
(*6.25%)
On label %
Reported using food
group conversion
factors
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
55/109
55
Reverse Phase High Pressure liquid Chromatography parameter evaluation
using protein / peptide standards.
Effect of temperature on peptide separation: Fig C1
Figure C1: The result of adjusting the temperature from 14oC- 42oC in 4oC increments, and
its effect on retention time of three peptides using RPHPLC. (Appendix II fig 4-12, Appendix
II Table 2)
Effect of Trifluoroaceticacid (TFA) on peptide separation: Fig C2
Figure C2: The Result of the concentration adjustment of TFA, an ion pair reagent on
retention of three Peptides using RPHPLC.(Appendix II fig 1-3, Appendix II table 1)
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14 18 22 26 30 34 38 42
RetentionTime(Minutes)
Temperature (OC)
Efect of Temperature on Peptide Retention by RPHPLC
Cytochrome C
(4.27mg/ml)
BSA (3.53mg/ml)
Myoglobin(2.80mg/ml)
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
0.005 0.010 0.100
Retention
Time(minutes)
% Trifluoroaceticacid (TFA)
Effect of TFA concentration on Peptide Retention by RPHPLC.
Cytochrome C
(4.27mg/ml)
BSA (3.53mg/ml)
Myoglobin
(2.80mg/ml)
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
56/109
56
Gas Chromatography Flame Ionisation Detection of Pentafluoropropyl Isopropyl
Esters of Amino Acids following Hydrolysis and PFPA Derivatization of Protein
Products.
SUNWARRIOR Amino Acid Analysis: Fig D 1
Figure D 1: Partial GC Amino Acid profile of SUNWARRIOR protein following hydrolysis
and PFPA Derivatization.(Appendix III fig 7. Appendix III table 1-2)
5.22
14.26
7.56
38.45
4.29
12.34
6.19
0 10 20 30 40 50
D-Valine
L-Valine
D-Methionine
L-Methionine
D-Glutamic Acid
L-Glutamic Acid
D-Aspartic Acid
L- Aspartic acid
mg Amino Acid/100mg product
Amin
oAcid
Sunwarrior Amino Acid Analysis
Sunwarrior mg/ml
On Label*
Sunwarrior mg/ml
Reported
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
57/109
57
HEMP Amino acid analysis: Fig D2
Figure D 2: Partial GC Amino Acid profile of HEMP protein following hydrolysis and PFPA
derivatization. .(Appendix III fig 4. Appendix III table 1-2)
SOYA 90% Amino acid analysis: Fig D3
Figure D 3: Partial GC Amino Acid profile of SOYA 90% protein following hydrolysis and
PFPA derivatization. .(Appendix III fig 6. Appendix III table 1-2)
9.30
24.96
17.55
33.48
0 10 20 30 40
D-Valine
L-Valine
D-Glutamic Acid
L-Glutamic Acid
D-Aspartic Acid
L- Aspartic acid
mg Amino Acid/100mg Product
AminoAcid
Hemp Amino Acid Analysis
On Label**
Reported
4.40
16.40
10.00
2.32
7.34
3.15
7.41
0 5 10 15 20
D-Valine
L-Valine
D-Methionine
L-Methionine
D-Glutamic Acid
L-Glutamic Acid
D-Aspartic Acid
L- Aspartic acid
mg Amino Acid/100mg Product
AminoAcid
Soya 90% Amino Acid Analysis
Reported
On label*
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
58/109
58
Milk & Egg Amino acid analysis: Fig D4
Figure D4: Partial GC Amino Acid profile of Milk & Egg protein following hydrolysis and
PFPA derivatization. .(Appendix III fig 5. Appendix III table 1-2)
Aminos Drink Amino acid analysis: Fig D5
Figure D5: Partial GC Amino Acid profile of Milk & Egg protein following hydrolysis and
PFPA derivatization. .(Appendix III fig 3. Appendix III table 1-2)
4.10
5.10
4.00
5.05
5.98
0 2 4 6 8
D-Valine
L-Valine
D-Methionine
L-Methionine
D-Glutamic Acid
L-Glutamic Acid
D-Aspartic Acid
L- Aspartic acid
mg Amino Acid/100mg Product
AminoAcid
Milk & Egg Amino Acid Analysis
Reported
On Label*
10.67
4.37
48.53
6.74
1.52
6.43
30.72
0 20 40 60
D-Valine
L-Valine
D-Methionine
L-Methionine
D-Glutamic Acid
L-Glutamic Acid
D-Aspartic Acid
L- Aspartic acid
mg Amino Acid/mg Product
Am
inoAcid
Aminos Drink Amino Acid Analysis
Reported
On label***
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
59/109
59
Discussion
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
60/109
60
Moisture analysis (Fig A):
Milk & Egg had 4.32% moisture. This value is within the Codex Alimentarius guidelines for
moisture content of dried dairy based products. Milk & Egg contains Calcium Caseinate and
Whey protein isolate as well as egg white solids. As prescribed by Codex and the FDA, DriedCaseinate has an upper limit of 8% and Whey protein isolate has an upper limit of 6 %
moisture content. Milk and Egg however is within the regulation values for moisture content.
Sun warrior had the lowest moisture content at 3.14%, unlike the highly regulated dairy
industry which produces dried dairy products, other manufactures that product dietary
supplements are not held to the same strict guidelines. Therefore comparison of Sunwarrior to
regulation standards for moisture is not possible. The FDA state generally, manufacturers do
not need to register their products with FDA nor get FDA approval before producing or
selling dietary supplements. The FDA however have implemented a Good manufacturer
practices (GMP) policy to ensure dietary supplements are made in a quality manner. This
suggests that this area of manufactured is somewhat under regulated, and a lot of
responsibility lies with the manufacturer to ensure these products are safe for human
consumption, unlike the pharmaceutical industry.
Soya has a moisture content of 3.65%, well below the recommended 6% which is usuallyexpected in dried soya products. (Shurtleff et al 1990) This low value may be to increase over
all protein value of the product per weight.
Hemp has the highest moisture content at 7.72%, over twice the moisture content as compared
to Sunwarrior and Soya 90%. This product claims to be made from 100% hemp, and
undergoes limited processing unlike the other products. Hemp protein is a plant based
product, and over drying may affect its ability to mix in a customers drink.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
61/109
61
Total protein. (Fig B)
The standard pharmacopeia method for total protein analysis is Kejdalh Total Nitrogen. This
method was investigated, but the only available literature similar to high content dried protein
products were methods relating to Infant formula. Several attempts were made, adjustingvarious parameters but the digestion solution kept frothing up and sample was lost. Due to the
Hazardous nature of the chemicals used in Kejdalh, two safer methods were adopted namely
Hach Persulfate and Biuret. It is understood now that too much protein sample was being
used, as some of the protein samples contain over fifty times more protein than the infant
formula. A dilution of at least one in fifty would be recommended if one is to follow the
Kejdalh infant formula procedure and apply it to these types of high protein products.
TheBiuret method(fig B) for analysis of these dried protein products was adapted from a
method used to estimate total protein in blood serum. This method isnt very sensitive,
therefore samples was carried through at 10mg/ml. Samples were dissolved in ultra pure
water/ 5% acetic acid to decrease the pH from around the Isoelectric point, so as they would
go into solution. Prior to UV detection, samples were filtered to remove particulates which
were especially evident in Hemp due to its plant material.
The Biuret method found Soya 90% and Milk & Egg to both contain slightly less protein asstated on the label, as with Hemp which had almost 10% less. Sunwarrior had over 20% less
protein which is a considerable decrease when this product is being sold as a high protein
food supplement. There are limited interferences with this method, but the presence of high
concentration of carbohydrate can lead to opalescence, which can cause the scattering of light
which in turn may increase absorbance and therefore concentration . (Nielsen 2010) Hemp had
the highest concentration (15%) of carbohydrates and Soya (1%) the lowest. This factor does
not appear to have affected the results.
TheHach Persulfate method uses a kit supplied by Hach to measure the total Nitrogen
content of samples, commonly used for water analysis. This step wise digestion converts all
form of Nitrogen to nitrate which then reacts with chromotropic acid to form a yellow
complex. This method claims to have a minimum of 95% recovery and sensitivity of 0.5mg/L
and is a standard test in waste water analytical laboratories.
The recommended conversion factor of Nitrogen to protein is *6.25, based on the
observation that animal proteins contain approximately 16% Nitrogen. This gives the crude
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
62/109
62
protein value and is widely used when converting Nitrogen to Protein. The true protein
content in food is determined by the amount the twenty L-amino acids bound in the proteins.
The food group specific conversion factors relate to the total nitrogen content from the
individual amino acids present in the food, and are therefore more accurate. (Salovaananen
1996)
When the food specific conversion factor is applied to the Nitrogen content, all protein
products in this study fall below the standard *6.25 conversion values. Salovaananen 1996
suggests that to truly quantify the Total protein, one must quantify individual amino acid
concentrations.
(Values taken from Fig B 2 Food group conversion factor)
Similar to the Biuret method, Milk & Egg and Hemp are within 10% of their labelled protein
value although Milk & Egg has a higher than reported on the label. Again Sunwarrior has an
over 20% difference in the reported protein content as compared to labelled value. Soya 90%
had a difference of over 20% also which was not consistent with the Biuret method or the
labelled value. Soya 90% also contains egg white solids as a source of protein that is not taken
into account by this conversion factor, therefore contributing to the lower value.
Milk & Egg and Soya contain mixtures of protein sources; therefore assigning one conversion
factor for all components will lead to result discrepancies. These products do not state how
much of each type of protein is present, just the total protein content.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
63/109
63
Reverse Phase High Pressure liquid Chromatography.
In Reverse Phase HPLC the stationary phase particle surface is very hydrophobic due to the
chemical attachment of hydrocarbon groups to its surface. The retention of the peptide on the
stationary phase is determined by how hydrophobic the peptide is. The discovery BIO widepore C5 column which was being used to separate the peptides contained in the protein
products produced results that indicted the column was somewhat damaged. This was
discovered early in the analysis whilst running standards. As part of a familiarisation process
with HPLC, analysis continued investigating the effect parameter changes had on the
retention of peptide standards.
Three standards were used;
1. Bovine serum Albumin(BSA), a transport protein that has 11 hydrophobic domains forbinding hydrophobic compounds such as hormones and fatty acids, consisting of 585
Amino Acids. (Appendix I fig 3)
2. Cytochrome C, (Equine) a compound in the electron transport chain consisting of 104amino acids and hydrophobic core. Cytochrome C enables carrying of electrons from
Cytochrome bc1 complex to Cytochrome oxidase complex. The heme group in
Cytochrome C enables the electron transport. (Appendix I fig 1)3. Myoglobin, (Equine) oxygen binding protein consisting of 153 Amino acids, also
contains a heme group and hydrophobic core.(Hunter 2003) (Appendix I fig 2)
Cytochrome C was retained for the least time, because this, the smallest of the three
compounds has the least amount of hydrophobic amino acids in its peptide (appendix I fig 1).
BSA the largest of the three peptides was second to elute, although this has many
hydrophobic regions, many of these are on the innermost side of the peptide, limiting
maximum interaction with stationary phase and hydrophobic regions. BSA is 140 X 40 X 40. (www.rcsb.orgaccessed 26-Apr-2011) This is relatively large in comparison to the other
peptides, but will still fit in the pore size of 300 of the stationary phase. In relation to the
size of BSA, its hydrophobic footprint was relatively small.
The most retained peptide was Myoglobin, small enough at 25 X 35 X 45 (Meisenberg
2006) to enter the wide pores in the column, and with many hydrophobic regions as visible in
appendix I fig 2, meant this compound had the greatest hydrophobic footprint, even though
http://www.rcsb.org/http://www.rcsb.org/http://www.rcsb.org/http://www.rcsb.org/7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
64/109
64
this was not the largest compound. Due to the addition of TFA, the pH was below 2 for both
mobile phases, well below the isoelectric point for all standards.
Effect of temperature on peptide retention:
The standard peptide samples were subject to a series of runs, where the temperature was
adjusted in 4oC increments from 14-42oC. BSA and Myoglobin were retained longer on the
column as the temperature increased initially, but at 26oC, this effect levels out. This is in
contrast to literature (Chen et al 2003), which suggests that retention of peptides decreases as
temperature increases, due to the lowering of mobile phase viscosity. Cytochrome C showed
a distinct increase in retention at 18oC and then appeared to alternate slightly at each
temperature increment. This may be due to the size of small molecule and the limited
hydrophobic interaction with the stationary phase as compared to the other larger more
hydrophobic peptides. As the temperature was raised past 18oC, an increase in resolution was
observed, with all three peptides being fully resolved from each other. NB: Double peaks
represent one compound; this is due to a damaged column.
Effect of TFA on peptide separation:
TFA is an additive used to control the pH and acts as an ion pair agent. When the ion pairs
form, a reduction of interaction between peptide and stationary phase is observed, to allow
separation based on hydrophobic interaction. TFA also acts to solubilise the protein, by
ensuring the pH (
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
65/109
65
decrease was minimal however in comparison to the increase observed by all peptides when
TFA concentration was changed from 0.01% to 0.1%. All peptides were retained longer on
the column and an increase in resolution of all peptides was observed as the concentration of
TFA increased to 0.1%
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
66/109
66
Gas Chromatography (GC) Flame Ionisation Detection (FID) of Pentafluoropropyl
Isopropyl Esters of Amino Acids following Hydrolysis and PFPA Derivatization of
Protein Products.
In order to analyse the amino acid composition of proteins the proteins must be hydrolysed sothe amide links between amino acids are broken, and individual amino acids are created from
the peptide. Analytes must be somewhat volatile to be analysed using GC. Amino acids in
their native state are not volatile and need to undergo a derivatization procedure. Therefore
the analysis is actually of Pentafluoropropyl Isopropyl Esters of the amino acids.
Initially the digestion step was difficult to complete because proper digestion vessels were not
available and test tubes with rubber stoppers could not withstand the pressure generated
during the reaction which involved 24 hours at 110OC. Digestion of standards and samples
was then carried out using closed vessel microwave digestion. This was considered a clean,
rapid and safe method for carrying out the hydrolysis. All samples and standards were carried
through the derivatization step and analysed using GCFID. These gave results that could only
be attributed to background noise.
T o investigate whether the derivatization step had worked, a hydrolysed amino acid product
namely Liquid Aminos was purchased from the same company as the samples. This productwas not subject to hydrolysis and only subject to the derivatization step. On analysis of the
hydrolysed product, distinct peaks were observed alike those expected from amino acids.
This indicated that the derivatization step has been successful and that the problem lay with
the Hydrolysis. On further investigation, it became apparent the temperature probe on the
microwave digestion unit was broken, and although the microwave cycle would continue, no
heat or pressure was being generated to aid in the hydrolysis of the protein samples.
The hydrolysis reverted back to the conventional 24 hour method. Hach vials were steeped in
nitric acid overnight, rinsed, dried and used as vessels as these were know to withstand the
pressure of hydrolysis. The standards and samples were hydrolysed, derivitized and ran on
the GCFID successfully using the conventional method.
Two sets of standards were used (appendix III fig 1-2) one for the Liquid Aminos were, and
another set for the rest of this samples. This was because the pressure and temperature
programme had to be optimised to reduce retention time.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
67/109
67
Sunwarrior: Sunwarrior protein contained over 6 times the amount of L-Aspartic acid as
compared to that reported on its label, with over 7mg/100mg D-Aspartic Acid. L- Glutamic
acid and L-Valine were similar to expected.
Hemp: Hemp protein contained all the amino acids tested for but also contained D-Asparticacid. There was no amino acid profile with this product for comparison, but hemp does
however contain a full amino acid profile which supports these results.
Soya 90%: Soya 90% contains L-Aspartic Acid and L-Valine in lesser concentration than
expected . The D-aspartic acid concentration indicates racemisation of L-Aspartic acid. The
latter is also apparent in the case L-Glutamic Acid.
Milk & Egg: Milk & Egg contain levels of L-Valine and L-Aspartic acid in quantitiesexpected. There is over 5mg/100mg of D-Aspartic acid also present in this sample. L-
Glutamic acid however which counts for over 14% of this total sample is not present.
Liquid Aminos: Liquid Aminos contained no Aspartic acid, although small amounts were
present in the sample. The Glutamic acid in the Aminos drink was in the D form. Essential
amino acid Valine was present, although in lesser amounts to what was stated on the label.
The opposite was true for Methionine however which contained slightly more than stated on
labelling.
7/29/2019 104295537 Analysis of Protein Dietary Supplements(1)
68/109
68
The presence of D- amino acids were observed in all samples. This presence of these non-
nutritional amino acids may be attributed to manufacturing or technological processes which
involve the use of heat, irradiation, homogenisation, heat sterilisation and powder drying.
(Csapo et al 2009) This can subject these protein powders to extreme heat (over 250oC)
which can cause the racemisation of the amino acids.
Hemp which is subject to the least technological process and still contained D-Aspartic acid.
A study carried out analysing a ranges of food stuffs subject to technological processes such
as heat and alkali environments, found the highest degree of racemisation occurred in aspartic
acid (Masters & Freeman 1979). This suggests Aspartic acid has a tendency to racemize
easily. This supports the evidence that shows 4 protein samples containing D-Aspartic acid.
Hemp is derived from plant matter therefore the presence of bacteria cannot be ruled out,
and because Hemp has a high percentage of moisture bacteria could also survive there.
Bacteria have high levels of D-Aspartic acid in their cell wall peptidoglycans which may be
attributed to the presence of D-Aspartic acid in this product. Further microbiological tests
would be required to confirm this.
The presence of the D-amino acids in these samples shows that processes such as heat and
alkali environments can cause amino acids to racemize. The presence of D-Methionine and D-Glutamic Acid in the Liquid Aminos supports the findings that D- amino acids are also
present in hydrolysed products, and may also be a direct result of the production methods.
In some cases D-amino acids have also been known to act as growth inhibitors (Csapo et al
2009) to mammals, the opposite effects to what people supplementing their diet with protein
are expecting. At the very least D-amino acids will be excreted un-metabolised. The presence
of D-amino acids in protein can leads to a decrease in digestibility and availability of other
amino acids present. (Csapo et al 2009)
When the manufactures analyse these products for total protein, the D-amino acids, will
contribute to the overall protein content, even though they are not assimilated in the body,
therefore total protein should be carried out by L-amino acid analysis to determine t