11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31 Order, C DoWSoE Kings Altered Exhibit 3 Bate Stamp Missing on Previously

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    1/54

    Hearing

    Sae Bar f evaa vs. Cughlin

    SUNSHNEigation

    Ciscover epositons ecisios

    b 170008 b 0001

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    2/54

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    3/54

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    4/54

    \

    Rule .Competence A lawe shal provde compeentepresetaton to a cliet Copetent repesenato equires the legakowedge, sll hoougess ad peparaio reasonably necessay fothe epesetaio.

    e Scope of epresetaion ad Aocato o Authoiy

    Between Ciet a d awyeSubjec o paagaphs (c)

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    5/54

    33 ule Cor Tow he Tbal. lawyer sall not knowigly: (a) Mae a ase satement of act o law to a trbal o fa to corect a fas staemen o aeal a or awprevosy ade to te tbnal by e awyer;Fal to dscose o e tbna ega 2 atoty n e contolngjsdcto own to te awye to drecty advese to te poston o te

    cet ad not dscosed by opposg cose; orOer evdece tat te awyer ows to be 3) ase I a awyer, teawyes cen o a wtness caed by te awyer as oeed mateaevdence ad e awye coes to ow o its asty, te awye sa taereasoabe emedal measres cdng f essa dsose to erba awyer may ese o oer evdece oter ta te estmoy oa deedant a crma mate tat te awyer reasonaby beeves saseA awyer wo repesets a cent a addcave (b proceedg adwo ows tat a peson ntends to egage, s engagng or as engaged cal o fadle cod elaed o e poeedg sall aereasonabe reeda eases ncldg necessa, dscosre to tetbnale dtes sated n paragaps (a and b conte (c to e csono te poceedg ad appy eve f compac reqres dscosre onomato oterwse potected by Re .6.In an ex parte proceedng a awyer sal norm te d) trba o amateral acs nown o te awer tat wl eabe te trbal to mae annomed deCson, weter o not te acts are adverse

    3 le Firss Osing Pa n Couns A awye sanot:Unawy obstrct aoter pary's access to a evdence or lawyater destroy or cocea a docmet or oter matera avg potentaevdetary va awer sa ot conse or assst aoter perso to doay sc acasy evdece conse or asss a wess o b) testy fasey or oera dcement to a wtness tat s probted by lawKwgy dsobey a oblgaton de te res o a (c trba except oan ope esa based on a asserto ta o vad obgaton exsts;In preta procedre mae a rvoos dscovey d eest or a to maeeasoaby dgent eo to compy wt a egay proper dscove reestby an opposg party

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    6/54

    In tral, aude to ay matter ha he awye does e) ot reasoaby beieves eevat o tha wil ot be suppoted by admissibe evidece, assepersona knowedge of facs in issue excep whe tesifyg as a wiess orsate a persoa opinio as to the jsess of a case, the cedibiy of awtness he cupabty o a cv tgat o the gt o ocece of aaccsed; or

    Reqest a peson other than a ce to rerain rom f votaiy givingreevat formation to another paty ness:The peso s a eaive or a empoyee or other age o a cle; adhe awye easoaby beeves that the peson's eess w o beadversey afeced by reraing om givg sch iomatio.

    35 u .Ipaiaity a Dorum of e Tibua a atiosWit A awyer sha no seek to infuece a dge, juror, a prospecive juror ooher offca by meas pohbed by awA awyer sha ot commcate e pae wih a b jdge juror,pospectve jro o other ofca excep as pemted by law.Subect to the imiatos mposed by this e o c by aw s a awyersight aer he y has bee dischaged to teew he juros odetermie wheher hei verdict s sbject to ay ega chaenge A awyersha not commuicate with a jror or prospecve or after dscharge ofhe juy the jror has made ow o he awyer a desire o tocommucae o the commncaon voves msepresetao coercodress or harassmen he scope o he evew shod be esticted ad

    cautio shod be sed to avoid embarrassmen to any juror or to iuecehis or her action i any sbseqet jy sevice.A awyer sha not egage condct ieded to d disrp a ribna.Beore the jy s swo o t he case a awyer e may ivesgae heprospecve juros to ascetan ay basis for caege provded hat aawyer or the awyes empoyees or dependet cotractors may ot, atay time beoe he commecement of he ia codct o ahoze ayivesigao of the prospecve os hogh any means which arecacaed or key o ead o commuicao wth prospecve jros of anyaegations or facta circumstances reatig to he case at sse Codctprohbited by his Rue icdes, but s o imited to ay diect or dieccommicatio wih a pospectve o, a member o he jros famiy aempoyer or ay oher perso hat may ead to drect or dectcommcato wth a prospective juror

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    7/54

    35 Ru Rts Wt Osing Cs When a awyerkows or reasonably sold kow the idetiy of a awer representig aopposig pay. e o she sould not take advatage of te lawyer ycausg ay defat or dismissa to e etered wihout irs iqirg abot

    e opposig awye's iteion to poceed

    Ru .rtss i Sttmts t Ots I e ourse ofrepresetng a clet a lawyer sa o kowngy:Make a fase stateet of maera fact o law to a (a) tird peso; orFai to disclose a aerial fact to a tird perso () we disclosre isecessay to avod assistng a crmia o fade a a e, uessdiscosre is pohiited y Rle .6.

    44 R Rst r Rig Tr Pss epseti a lie, a awyer saU ot se (a means tat ave nossatial ppose ote a o emarass delay or rde a tirdperso or se etods of otaiing evidece tat vioate the ega rigts ofsc a personA awye wo reives a documen relatng o te () represetato of elawyes clie ad kows o easoaly sould ow tat he documenwas inadveetly set sa prompty oty te seder

    Ru Ba Amssin Disiry Mrs. A applcan foadmission te ar o a awyer i conectio with a ar admssioappicatio o in conectio wit a disciplinary maer sall not

    Kowigly make a false stateet of mateial fa a oail to discose a fat eessa to coret a ( msappreesio owny te perso to have arise i the atter o kwigy fal to espod to aawl demad for information fro an admissions or disciplnary atorityexcept at tis Re does ot reqe dsclose of ifoato oeseprotected y Re .6.

    Ru Jici OcisA awye sha not make a saeet that the awyer (a kows o e faseor wth reckless dsegard as to ts trt or fasity conceing te

    qafcatios or itegity of a jdge addicatory oficer or plic legaofcer or of a cadidate for eeion or appoitment to dicial or legalofceA lawye wo is a cadidate for dical office ( sal comply wit teapplicae provisios of te Code of Jdicial Condct

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    8/54

    4 Rule .Misconduc I i prfea mt r a wyer t:Ve aep t ve e e () Prea C,kwgy r de aer r hrgh he aer;C m t ree dverey he (b wye' etyrwe r e a awyer er reeEgage g he a ee mereet;Egge tha rejd t te dtr teSte py bl t ee imppey a (e) gvere ageyr a r aheve re by e vae he e re C r er w; rKwigy i dge d fer dt h va apae e t r er w

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    9/54

    s7

    8

    1

    "7

    "

    G ase No -4, 35 a 43

    wSE O EVD

    ORER EVD DSCNY OD

    STAE BAR O NVAA,olaia

    ZAHARY B. OULIN SQ.,Ba o. 943

    R nt

    COLN

    PEASE TAE OE a suan o Suem o Rle () a

    VERFIE RESONSE OR NWE is omlan ms e le w e Oc Baonse Sae Ba of Nevaa 9 oe R Bolva Se Reno evaa 895

    wii wen ( as o sei o hs opi eue grdg s

    aess in SR 9

    olaia Sae Ba o Nevaa Sae Ba) a oug is Asss Ba

    osl Pa O Kg iome a believes as ollwsahe ougn Resone) Ba umbe 973 is a mebe o he Sa Ba o

    Nevaa d on Ma Resoen's a of i is Seee 7 97

    The aess ha Resoen as o le ih h Sae Ba o Nevaa i aco

    Re o oessonal Cd ("RP) 79((a) s P Oe 39 Reo 9.se eed i cs scdu aig he iposio o possi

    dscipie. he Sae Ba lgs s lls

    Mulpe gevaes wee eeive he fe of Ba ose ewee e au 14 nd ah . oni sponden De o e s0001

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    10/54

    1

    7

    1

    1

    2

    13

    "

    17

    1

    1

    3

    alegas mi gevac les opene and an vstgaon was inita y

    Assistan Ba r Co Patk ng.

    2. Respodet was advised te grievans via US. mail mail ad by a brief

    wih M ig a he Se Ba O Reo Respode did a wh

    Ihe ivstigaion ad aher than rspond the gevances as reqet, Respodent sn

    non-esiv ad disparaging e-mals

    Respodet o made a request be placed o disabiliy stas, or as

    no age a he ay ha mea imiy llness or addiio.

    Tna ivestigatio o Ihe grievaces agans Responde sow a seous

    aer mu O Seee Respoden shope a andy a ad ugh dops

    rom a WalMa stwih an appoiate vae oee dolas ($4.00). On Noveb

    0, 20 Mnicipal Cou Jdge Keeth R. Hward ond Respodet guly of te ofese

    o eit Larey a volation RMC 81004 Resodet appead te jdgment

    conv. The dgmen of cnctio was afed on appea See Exhib 1

    Dug te rial Respondens coduc as so dsrptve tat dge ard

    foud Respoden i dire cotemp o Co and seend hm to see tee ( days in

    jai ee xhiit 2

    . O Augs 20' Respoden was arested on a secd laeny age or

    eed stealig a el one. hose charges are rreny peding i Reo ustice Cot

    8Respoden

    was again arsed Jaay 202 allgdly ausng 911

    emegency sevies, a goss

    On FebraY 2012 led a domen eited op ranc" El a of NGuly Wver Rht Aagm nMion mss

    0002

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    11/54

    in one of is pending mina maters Cas No RCR-202 06563 o eo v Z og. dome ea sows esnents npossonal, disptiv ndct

    a lak of respet f te c opposng conse

    "

    "

    10. Respondent was arested on November 13, 211 y eno olice epatment

    and chaged wth tespassing a misdemeano or whih he was Jater onvicted.

    Te irumstances leading to e aontoed ast are as folows: at an

    evion heaing stce o te Peace odered at Respondent vaae the

    home he was rentng efectve Noveme 1 2011 er the locks were changed ad Ihe

    evition noti was posted on the front door the wer r. erli discoveed tha soeone

    had broken int a was baraded in the basemen e Reo oi trd oax wh was in th basement open th doo Meiss was fored to iopen the

    door wee te Ren Poce ond Responden. Respondent had boken into te home and

    was iving in the basemen Respondent was arrested fo crimnal trespass and was

    subseently vited of hat age

    2. espodent, represening himse as nse led a 6page moton to

    dsmiss on Marc 5 02. e motion was dened b udge Wlam Gadner and was

    deerned be wihot met he moton on its face, demonsrates that esondnlacks

    competnce to raie law

    Oe Respndent was evicted an ode was obtaind to emove his

    belonings rom the home. Resondent inteeed with the cotrato who was hied to

    rmov Ronden's personal beongings. he li we caled and ae alig wihRsoen they recommended tat he nd somehing lse do Resoet efsed o

    llow their advice and was ssequent arested b he Reno oie

    0003

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    12/54

    2

    6

    9

    2

    3617 9

    0

    15

    14 In the ase f eo v ae o ase o. TR

    26800 21, a ra ws hd n a trf itaton issed t Responent The ate as called

    at appimatey 3:0 p. and concuded withou a verdic at abot 4:3 p ae he u

    held Repndent n criina np cout f hs behao and ativits ited in e

    dre pesence f the cu dung al.

    15. n a March 12 212 Ode Munipa u Judge Drothy Nash Hoes fund

    by "cea and cnvincng evdence ta Mr Coghln mmted numeous acts f aey

    iscoduct. See Exhibi 3 Judg Homes p!aie in he Oer ha aer Respondent

    seed his -ay ntept u sann imposed by the u on ebua 27 202

    esponden K t the cu a 224-page document udge Hoes fud hat the

    dcumet ntaied ambng reereces his pesnal ife and ws inohrent

    6 n her Orde Judge Homes found bV cear and nvncng eden that

    espdent iolaed ue of Pressional Condu RPC) 1.(opetene) 3

    ligene) PC 31 (Meorus Cas and ntenons) RP 3.2 (Expedng Laion)

    PC 33(a) (Candr oa he ibua) RP 34e) (Fainess to Opposig Pa and

    Conse) RPC 84 (c) (ngaging n Dsonesy Faud Det or Misrepesentation) and

    RP 84(d) gage n conduct tat s ejdcal t Admnistatin of ustie Respdent ed Adaits of vety in uppo f s Mton to Ped

    nfora Paupes werein he fais o disclo hat he is a liensd aorney and nstead

    unde moyme ad efmpoymen e deles he as a ack of l ades

    8 Despte a claim of pvey in he ave metioned aaits eden old

    e ou hat hs incaceain f cnemp would adesey aect his cents

    On Mach 22 202 Responden appeaed a he en Muicpa ou

    eain (miey ace) a e pamas epde eame gumeaie nd Mashals

    ee led o him eae 0004

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    13/54

    1 25. On Apl 1, istct Judge nda Garner of te Secod Judca Dstct

    Co exeutd a -er Ae Tra': case No. V8168 I hat as Resodent3 repeseted anCoune Caat er re udge arder epae

    7

    9

    0

    1

    1

    1

    1 5

    1 7

    19

    0

    Respodets appop"ae beavo n pat as foos

    e mos roubng aspec of ts case as M Cous rde, sarcastc anddsespecfl presetato a a; M Cos abty to desad a baacesee hs aure to coduct dscove ad s ack of kowedge egard tothe rs evde ad a procedre. Al o ts was comoded th aconuosy antagos preentao o the ase ha rsted a sht fom aary smpe dve ase to a cotetos dor tra asg a excsseao of me

    forog Resondn oatd RP 11 (Competen) RP

    (gen) RC 1 (eroous Cams ad Cotetos) RC (Candor terual RPC (Faress pposg Pat ad Cous RC 3.5 (mpataty and

    ecor of h buna RC 4 (tulness n Saees Ohes RPC

    Resect or he Rg 01 h esos RC 5A Reaos wt Opposg Cose RPC

    8 snay Matte RPC 8 (Judca and Lgal as and RPC 84 Mscodct

    WHEREFRE, Coana prays as oos

    1 hat a eag e e prsa ada Spee Cou Rle 105 ha Respode e assessed he costs o te dspja pocd

    prsat Srm Cot Re 10(1); ad

    000

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    14/54

    . t p o Supem Cot l 1 uh iiply i b k 2 h Nohem Nvd Diiiy o i poe my dme ppropJ rmne.4

    eplly bmi hi 2 5 dy 01 Aut, 0

    STA A OF NVAA DAVD A AK BA OUNSEL

    By D I

    < King; lsant B oe Nvd No. 5059456

    obl Blv o N 85

    J

    000

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    15/54

    DD

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    16/54

    yIN ril ,\U:CP/L COURT OF lE Y O RO

    NY F WSO AT O [VA SI!RUlT. R

    L,: ' + X

    ,DEFNAT: COUGHLI, ZAARY KERCowt IMI':1 IIIJ'1 mlMALc tUI . OWT rU II '"J fil nl. U'.AI. I IC n :OCAr "T

    L T

    . I,\ 'H l S' Hh F;

    '"JIl, I-

    - &" \1 , \ ILr T 1 _ '

    .

    ,

    ,. " "

    t 1

    pq

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    17/54

    c

    FALE Y Wl nlCH omlO SD wn.L .fT N n SUE 'LUi O M F 1CC C> I FA nJ NRA nN W XAON E T. E L E sn! ,u S REY

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    18/54

    1 lJ\ I "S'UJM \el'UMF w: iN " u.n nF ISI tE Il 'MRSIL lIVIIN;: I lE I\ 0 l RT N C,tCELH 1(B)f c}r mE Ef I IDWS IO'IE lFlOR E O ICr l $ O v E OEFNAU ,. REVIEW,'DL LL WI EolIFAHA LL"IT ni DEEDAN UV\ ADCOr Rf.ED OS OmoE LC D RG

    CILIIT ist INFORA rlN < il 1 e bh 11401 L E IORM PET WS / CTODY i! f E ;

    A ST/SUDU ST nROUGH COR" \IL " I N RfITU CAE[DJ1 ,\IL "SE C E! l "u/Jan ,\T/CORAON: FEE sr IIEIR OR lE l01 OOON"LC.E OMO G B i AlE

    J;! ;

    I ) \ I r n : \ r , n.\ f y P .

    ",r

    .E:_I

    H " 1 ,'1

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    19/54

    51

    10

    S1

    0

    H1

    8

    L

    o Orle b.12"

    IN THE SEO JUDCIAL DSTR OURO H AE OF ADA

    I A OR E ONT O

    QARY BER COGN,

    Appla

    O EO munipal co,

    .

    Ca : CR1-06

    e :

    -DSfNGUNGgNr Is fo ig of e .

    "'d by Ael ZAQAR AE (eea Appa eb 3, Foowg, ebruay 7 212 ln"d h OpeIg o Appe

    on a 0,e O e Re5" Ang e he at s n befo he f It coaUo.

    i e co bre e Cou on pa' te en MkCou O embe ), 2 A w Pe y vo MC 8100 eer ber 201 Ap oc of pp out

    ogh Appr ume e nle e wdevet

    ue, inci,

    di i S Aem h

    on h the Cou ed ii t rn a t t thei g I m5u. t e ws esd to hi

    0

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    20/54

    2

    J56

    8

    7

    hal a vidn pss pusa t e FuAmnmeof ne niuon, at hs convio 15 n u eviden and h "ur poprees nd due proce de-Jn

    aty Aela er p hi argmen el aol

    ltls en Ipay Aela ha l pve hIS Cu wi c o an ng! h RnoMunipal he a a "}pplla as ti e wt 'ns o s dJao I aie In eas el: 31 . 4, 83 P 88(20 (N )3) Fu W 8() oie h [ee a In

    rgag ars In the r shl p y a fe pae of han5 o apix w 150

    ile Apn di ve i CO a Comac D tning the Muncl u s, pelant i not te to pis he om t h fe sud hIs rgu an I I slbUly ehich ns ig Aps rg n pplant dI is ns heod my y pcing a omac DI coing o e en ici O

    en

    In lih ppe lle with an adqt appeUte an Aeas ce Uu te c a hi I ble ainfl 0Aplns pl. Ts, Appellan has il t

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    21/54

    )s

    8

    hs I g a aa at is a l M

    O THRFOR H ORDR that he u f Cou Is FFR

    FRTHR ORRD that ma s ae bac t t RMuiil ou r her pedig.

    Kd 0POT

    DSJe

    It _ h S 4.10( '{IJe Po1 u / ie 1 e dept S h t the rQre o s a t e_ $e h ,nl t

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    22/54

    1

    ,5

    ,

    1

    Il

    "5

    '

    1

    18

    2.

    2

    2

    2l

    ,.

    7

    "

    c m r M A 'U N GIheby ri tl I lcJ f te fwiteOofeCr b

    ung tEFsmwhic, ! ong p icy:

    Z CUN, ES. (orZYHUN

    PE ROBAT ES em O RNO

    DAD tIS 15 'o f. .

    'HOuda Asitant

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    23/54

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    24/54

    \

    K

    2

    710I

    12

    Jl

    II'

    J7

    I

    '20

    l

    2.

    !

    OF REO,

    RENO MUNCIPAL CORF , LEDWASOE CONTY NV\DA

    KOV

    Plantir,

    K N tC e

    OGtN.ORDER FOR SMARPUNSEN CONPTCOMrE N IlE EAE AN RESNE

    Drendnt. O E COUT- I'E.RA.S NR6..n=_ micp judS maypuish for lcmpt the c r omi i e nr th ef ect ped jg1 i pl Neevis S

    HAS S 2 dAI a whe ep;1 mmc the mmvi peee o h Cu r judge a cbe3 i my pi ummy, rwhic: d be m:e eiig he f (\8 such mmde vew c. djuS he p c s h Buiy of wmp hse puih he pd

    WHERAS, un he )O'd Novem 20 , he d de lppebe h u.

    : ZR ON h WitU pllor WHERAS sh idiviJ illd h i n(S) i the immdi i

    r heCo:V Did m iol bir ld hc judsc hc he i

    hi e i hiJUlie.h

    h h e boilu,Jt v Mua i I P h(n. i -;ale vic. di i du 0 he (

  • 7/27/2019 11 14 12 FHE1 SBN King Index of Docs, Complaint, First Design, NOITD, Empanel, Notice Hearing, DoWSoE, 10 31

    25/54

    -

    2]

    S7

    I I

    I .

    7

    2

    2 1

    2