"11&/%*9�%�

$PNNVOJUZ�%FTJHO�

8PSLTIPQT�3FTVMUT�

109

110

111

112

113

114

115

116

117

118

119

120

121

122

123

124

125

126

127

128

129

130

131

132

133

Name Description Do you have any other comments to add about this area?

Napili Beach Napili Beach, like all the West Maui beaches is disappearing due to sea level rise. Maui's economy is largely driven by 'tourists who come for our beaches and the associated recreational opportunities. Its time for Maui County to put funding mechanisms in place for preserving the beaches and reefs as part of building resilient coastal resources for a resilient economy. I'd like to suggest some ideas : a modest airport "malama aina" (?) fee - $1 or $2/person dedicated to maintaining beaches and reef health; a modest uptick on prop taxes for those living in beach communities (sliding scale based on home value...maybe an extra 0.5%?). Who decides who can use the monies? I'd suggest an existing committee or two (Economic Dev as well as Environmental Manage ent an a e ann al al itte nitie

i en t e e t e e gen e i n it ati n e e in e t Ma i t i l e in tit te A A

What else needs to change? Given the number of new hotel rooms in Kaanapali , the Lahaina bypass (awesome!) needs to expand north of Kaanapali .. a l t a ana a ea

Beach parking and public restrooms at beaches should also be put in place to preserve the environment, make beach access safe, and, frankly, provide a convenient place for folks to pee, rather than in our bay.

As indicated in earlier feedback: keep Napili low rise and casual Hawaiian style, but make the improvements outlined above.

Lahaina More AFFORDABLE housing for the local people ! A house that one local family doesn’t have to work 2 full time job for each parent to be able to provide for a family of 6 .

There is too much developments that’s the local community cannot afford bringing in out of state owners who do not pitch in for our community .. stop driving the local people away with the cost of living help to provide a sustainable affordable community for locals to be able to afford and continue to live on our beatifiul island .

Lahaina Wainee Village should be re-established with residencesl for the locals, not million dollar homes. There should be some shopping areas in the village so that residents can get their goods locally by walking or biking and not having to go on Honoapiilani Highway.

We need more housing for locals who work in Lahaina and Kaanapali and the old Wainee Village is the perfect place for it.

Lahaina South Short term - add better sidewalks down Waine'e Street to Honoapiilani Highway. Build a pedestrian overpass at Shaw Street. This will provide easier and safer access for children heading to the pool, skate park, boys and girls club and sports fields for activities. Pedestrian overpasses at Keawe St, a ainal na an a ni k a k l al e g eat t

Short term - upgrade the aquatic center facilities. Begin charging a small usage fee. Even $1.00 per person would help pay for upgrades and keep the i a t

t te e t e al ati n A an et ing t kee t e le ele e le a a t e l a ea

Long term - move the public elementary school to the mauka side of the highway. Create/use existing location of King Kamehameha III school as park/museum/outdoor amphitheater for community activities.

This is a very family oriented neighborhood and there are a lot of visitors that stay in vacation rentals in this area too. It's a shame the visitors that come and spend so much money are subjected to the hobos and drug addicts that roam the area from the Banyan Tree to 505.

Olowalu Mauka Off stream water supply. Sea level rise impacts such as relocation of highway. Pali highway changes to address increased traffic load from airport improvement.

Ukumehame t e t a t it l ta t e a e A l t a age a al ea een ne it t e Makila lan e el ent in ani k an t e a

a ate ent l e ne t e ent il i e like t e ne in A g t

134

Lahaina M e i e i ie a ing t all a

M e a aiian lt al a ti e a e gat e ing ate al i t e e e

A a le e lti gene ati nal a ilie

Ag i lt e lan l e e g ing n gentle an e tate a

A ti itie an a k l al nit i t ette a k ki all age la g n e i ent n t t t le

ne t i all e t t e l e ta e

A n t e e t i e

Ag i lt e lan l all a ani al

M e a t an l ntee ing

M e nati e e t ate

e el e a e anaka ea a k

Need a Hawaiian cultural center and more Hawaiian plants. (Hala, Ulu, ohia)

Kaanapali lanne g t a ea n t e n a ea in n k ai l e ag i lt al l t it n- Planned growth area mauka of Hanakao'o Beach Park should remain open space to ensure our beaches below are not inundated with sediment, run off,

No building & development should happen in this area until the northern terminus of the bypass is completed UNLESS it is the DHHL agricultural plots.

lahaina ange t e a t t e l n t a i a e e ning g ing t l

West Maui Greenway Add a multi-use trail currently referred to as the West Maui Greenway through Lahaina area.The Phase I currently in planning stages should expand in both directions to provide an off-road opportunity for walking, biking, races, etc. to increase safety for walkers and bikers and racers and to encourage e i ent an i it t e e i e an e l e Ma i t i e t ei a t ile

Kaanapali Continue West Maui Greenway multi-use trail through Kaanapali to Kapalua - by providing connections with the multi-use trail route through the vaious West Maui areas we provide a real opportunity for a legacy project to enhance the West Maui experience for generations to come. There will never be an ea ie ti e t get t i ne

Lahaina Medium Term- Fill in the roads of Lahaina to get rid of the cracks. The roads need new cement put in to let drivers drive smoothly, this can reduce the risk of car incidents.

On Lahainaluna road, there is an intersection that gets traffic every morning. 7am-8am. The reason why there is traffic because there is three schools that people need to drive to. The change should be stop lights or some sort of way to ease the traffic congestion that is being made by this intersection.

Lahaina No homes or growth area mauka of the highway above canoe beach. It should be a park/greenbelt.

135

Kapalua This area should be cleared and have an arboredum in this area. The arboretum should only hold native plants. Preferably endangered native plants. With this arboretum, the native plants will have a greater chance of making a comeback.

LahainaLuna High School They should let the fresh water flow threw Lahaina Luna High School again.

Lahaina I would like to have Front Street change stores , front street is a very welcoming place, but there are too much non-local businesses I would like to see local run businesses, the businesses with “models†t at e t t e le n t e t eet

Lahaina I think the hike to the L should change from being private to being open to public. Long term. Tourists would enjoy it too, but locals would probably also enjoy being able to hike it. People already hike it despite the no trespassing sign, so there is no point in it being private.

Lahaina I would like to change everything back to the way it was before the taking of the Hawaiian kingdom. Everything would be better if we stop destroying the beautiful environment that we live in I would advise to just stop all construction of buildings and businesses.

No comment.

Lahaina I would like to see the buildings by front street apartments to be finished, the development of the apartments has been seized. I would like for them to finish

Kaanapali I would like to see some of the cement removed from the ocean. There is a lot of cement sitting right off the shore. I would also like to see the sewer stop being emptied into airport beach.

Kaanapali I would like to see some of the cement removed from the ocean. There is a lot of cement sitting right off the shore. I would also like to see the sewer stop being emptied into airport beach.

Kapalua I think there should be more public parking by Cliff House. Because the parking is only available for those staying at the hotel, it is very inconvenient for people who aren’t staying at that hotel to go to Cliff House.

Lahaina bypass I believe we should add a sidewalk at Lahaina bypass. walk down there but there’s no sidewalk so they’re very close to the driving cars.

Kahoma stream (the one by panda express)

I'm not the only one who wants this, but we want more water to pass through Kahoma stream or just remove the cement. No

Launipoko Why is the red light at Launiupoko so long? I feel like it lasts 10 years and it’s a very hot crosswalk to wait at. People are carrying surfboards and dogs and beach chairs, and they just stand there for about 5 minutes waiting for the red light to turn green. I believe the red lighting at the cross walk in Launiupoko should not be as long.

Lahaina The county of Maui should supply the county brown trash cans and trash pick up twice a week. Right now we have to buy trash cans and limit the amount of trash we make because we only have trash pick up once a week.

Maui lahaina l like e le t t il ing l like le illi n e

e e l e le a

e l ake a all ate a ke l i t e i e in la aina

They should remove the train tracks

136

Lahaina I would like the land to be clean so we can grow a lot of plants and also so we can raise animals also and we can have a lot of nice gardens for people that wants to plant things like vegetables and fruits and also this would be a good place for any to farm like any can be here in Luna village and. People would be happy if there is a garden for everyone. And people would be happy if this happened so thank you very much for my opinion and I hope you get back to me about my idea. â

Please help this place we really need a garden for plantings and animals and for small houses

Lahaina I would like the land to be clean so we can grow a lot of plants and also so we can raise animals also and we can have a lot of nice gardens for people that wants to plant things like vegetables and fruits and also this would be a good place for any to farm like any can be here in Luna village and. People would be happy if there is a garden for everyone. And people would be happy if this happened so thank you very much for my opinion and I hope you get back to me about my idea. â

Please help this place we really need a garden for plantings and animals and for small houses

Lahaina What I think should stay the same is kaanapali because they are making a lot of buildings there and that means there will be way more traffic and a lot more tourists coming in.I also think it should stay the same because they will start making fair ways hops and all that more expensive.What I think should change is the buildings that the people are making because there will be a bunch of tourism and people will be getting to work late.It will also mean that the air will be more polluted.

Lahaina Bypass We should build agricultures there. We need more trees to help make our air more clean. If we don't do something about that we could end up having another massive fire like we did 5 months ago.

We should use a small portion by the bypass to build affordable apartments so those who can not afford nice homes can live there. We should get rid of the channelizing river and let the river flow naturally. If we leave it there for too long peoples houses will be gone because when it rains the river floods at the top and wash away the houses.

Honokawai Sewage Plant

i would want to change the sewage plant in honokawai because it really stinks and it spreads for a long ways. When I’m driving past, I can smell it for a ile all

-Breauna Higgs, Lahainaluna High School junior

Honokawai Sewage Plant

i would want to change the sewage plant in honokawai because it really stinks and it spreads for a long ways. When I’m driving past, I can smell it for a ile all

-Breauna Higgs, Lahainaluna High School junior

KÄ ana ali a ea il e ital A e a k e e il en in t ei n a ine

ange t e ken ail e e t t at e le n t a e an a l t t at e t i e e an

Lahaina Should put more restaurants and restroom Should have a cerfew

hokiokio long-term: If possible, there should be a wall to block any noises from traffic because the bypass gets pretty loud when cars drive by.

hokiokio long-term: If possible, there should be a wall to block any noises from traffic because the bypass gets pretty loud when cars drive by.

hokiokio long-term: If possible, there should be a wall to block any noises from traffic because the bypass gets pretty loud when cars drive by.

Hokiokio Long-term: I was wondering if it would be possible to get a wall, kind of like the one that’s stone wall covering the highway because it gets really noisy for the people that live across the bypass when cars are passing by on the bypass. Thank you.

137

Lahaina Cannery Mall, what I would want to change is making it more affordable for places to stay there and try to get more business. Cannery Mall doesn’t have a lot and I used to go there a lot as a kid and now most of the stuff is gone. I would wanna see more stores in cannery and more places to eat so it can attract more people. The cannery would also be better if they have a place for kids to game. I want to see the Cannery have a new look also. I would like to see this happen soon.

Kaanapali Me i ant t e e e t e e t t e nt e lanng te e e e t e i t i al lan a k

Long-term - come up with some ideas to stop the sea rising.

Ka'anapali What I would like to change about the Ka'anapali Subarea is reduce the Urban Growth Boundary around Ka'anapali, because I would like to keep Ka'anapali Urban Growth lower in order to provide more room for Rural Growth. It should be a long term solution.

Lahaina They should have roads that go straight to the schools, more security around the area to keep the children safe, and a safer route for kids to walk home. No.

Lahaina Improve the road going to Lahaina Intermediate and Lahainaluna so there's less congestion after 7am.(Long Term) Cheaper/affordable housing.(Long Term) Better park around upper Lahainaluna Road, with a basketball court.(Long-Term)

Lahaina Improve the road going to Lahaina Intermediate and Lahainaluna so there's less congestion after 7am.(Long Term) Cheaper/affordable housing.(Long Term) Better park around upper Lahainaluna Road, with a basketball court.(Long-Term)

240 Dickenson St. l like t ee ange nl i it ene it t e li e an ai e a ilie e e For almost 30 years Dickenson Street south of Hwy 30 has several challenges that have not been addressed. The wall built ant Hwy 30 creates a dangerous blind turn and potential for a rear end collision on Hwy 30. All pedestrians must rick their lives just to get to the crosswalk at the Hwy. As for the opposite end at Front and Dickenson it is deplorable what has been left to anyone who has a wheelchair or stroller or even a simple pedestrian just to be on the sidewalk is nearly impossible because everything in the Lahaina Town infrastructure has been mounted in and around the only sidewalk. Dickenson Street must be one way INTO Lahaina NOT out. A school, Church and the amount of foot traffic from the other side of Hwy 30 would dictate that a sidewalk be in order as well. People have to be able to SAFELY get from one end of Dickenson to the other without fear of being killed. Which is a very real fear. The County and State may have opened themselves up to liability between either end of Dickenson Street should anyone have an injury or

il a at t e an lanning an n e e ente la k a et t e li I have lived on Dickenson for 15 years and have seen cars flipped over and people critically injured at both intersections. Vehicles race north towards Honoapiilani Hwy at excessive speeds trying to make the green, yellow and very often the RED light at The Hwy to get out of town. This is an incredible

ange t e e neTraffic coming south towards Front street into the heart of Lahaina are consistently slower and in "cruise mode." A sidewalk on the east (where our homes are) side in tandem with slow traffic coming ONE WAY INTO the Historic district would be the best way to improve and PRESERVE the VIBE and ALOHA of LAHAINA.

We may not be able to stop progress but we can integrate our Aloha into it.

Lahaina In my opinion, I think this area should change. We should add more roads. The reason behind that is there are many accidents happening on the Pali. If an accident occurred, there will be traffic. Most people lives in the other side and they drive all the way to Lahaina to work. We have a lot of jobs offered here because of our hotels.

Lahaina Lahaina it’s a really nice place, but lately it’s been a lot of violence and kidnapping attempts, so I would like to say that we need more police officers to check out there and try to keep it safe.

I really like going to Lahaina, like front street it the beach, but now I feel unsafe and uncomfortable, not just there because it can happen anywhere, so I think we just need more security.

Lahaina Preserve the stream by the canal. New houses are being built by the canal might cause problems with the land/ area around it.

138

Lahaina More trees around bypass and and more parks Maui Destroy buildings that serve no purpose to the community they are taking up space that could be used for other purposes. Some buildings in Lahaina have

at lea t ne t at lea t t in t e e e t e e t t e a e i e t an t n ig e i e t at a e na le t a There should add a least a bigger road to less the amount of traffic during the day and night time. So it could lower the amount of bad car crashes.

Kaanapali More playgrounds for the kids

Lahaina More parking lots and restrooms

Lahaina Move parking lots and restroom

Wailuku More sightseeing/ parks

Lahaina Move parking lots and restroom

Lahaina Move parking lots and restroom

Kaanapali Move parking lots and restroom

Olowalu Cultural Reserve (cliffs of. Petroglyphs)

Road Access to this cliff of historic petroglyphs is a combination of deteriorated asphalt paving, potholes, and rock surfacing. Improve road access, and i e inte eti e ignage i a e te a e e e a age Emphasize penalties for DEFACING petroglyphs and for adding graffiti, and perhaps install video surveillance cameras to reduce vandalism.

Intriguing parts of Maui heritage such as this need to be preserved.

Puunene /Alexander Baldwin Sugar Mill

DON'T TEAR DOWN the last remaining sugar mill in Hawaii. Upgrade environmental factors with scrubbers on chimneys and Update its usage perhaps to in ine ate ti le t a Begin a trial or pilot project to test procedures in a smaller area, and then in phase 2, expand to all of Maui, and phase 3, to all of Hawaii and even

e n eate e taina le e ate Ma i e i ent an i it n a ti al n e ati n an en i n ental taina ilit Create a smaller educational area to demonstrate sugarcane processing

Consider how preservation of a historic facility would be valued by i it an e i ent

Ames, IOWA incinerated combustible trash, as does Japan. Costs of land and construction of new facilities are not warranted when This historic facility could be made functional AND supplement electric power for the community.

Moku'ula & Mokuhinia M e a n e a ati n an e t ati n These valuable cultural and historical areas should be redirected and preserved. STOP THE EXCESSIVE. STUDIES and do some hands on archeology. We

ant t el an e e e ti ie in an a a A A A a ge l gi tPlease keep us in the loop. We visit Maui each year for 3 weeks.

The portraits of Ali'i royalty being painted by Avi should become part of the publicity program to promote redirection of Moku'ula and Mokuhinia.

Lahaina More buildings in this area, with a school by the ocean, a large football stadium with volleyball court and basketball court A HUGE MALL ALSO WITH SO MANY SHOPPING CENTERS

Lahaina Add a farmer's village or like a huge farm with so many different plants and can be seen by the public free parking lots also

Lahaina more houses in this part; houses that are huge and modern

Lahaina a underwater park where you can see fishes and other marine animals

Lahaina Maui is in dire need of housing for local residents and any building of homes should take place around Lahaina closer to more jobs and shopping. What is needed as soon as possible is a proper bike path.

Kaanapali Kaanapali is in need of a proper bike path for residents and visitors that is separate from the roadway in the very near future.

139

Olowalu I would like all of Olowalu to have their ahupuaa back. From mauka to makai. All the loi patches, medicinal plants, endemic forests, water flowing naturally, wetlands and estuaries, restored. It’s important to restore Olowalu to how it was for thousands of years because right now we are killing off our coral reef. The reef fronting Olowalu is where all reef come from in West Maui. It is the mother reef. And there are signs of bleaching and the brown

i t i a ing t e ntain an e ing t e ee in e t e e i n etlan t lean e t e t e e it ente t e ean

Also, we have the chance to restore an ahupuaa before it gets developed into something non Hawaiian like millionaire homes or suburbs. Now is the time t let t e ate l e t e l al t it e gl e e t e e a an nt e a ea in e t Ma i it l e l al

Please do the right thing and restore the ahupuaa. For our children’s sake. Not everything has to be developed.

Lahaina Reduce vehicle traffic, limit vacation rentals and monitor existing ones, increase vacation rental taxes so the County can make money and be able to reduce the amount of rental cars allowed. Conserve water resources by enforcing excessive sprinkler usage by resorts. Our mountains are drier than they have ever been in winter.

kaanapali resort There should be a dedicated walking/bike path off of the highway from Lahina town (Front street) to Lower Honoapiilani Road in Honokawai. Seen too many tourists and local walking along the highway. Its not safe and an off highway route would promote more walking and biking.

Lahaina For long-term goals, we should add a continuation to the Lahaina Bypass. I’m proposing to add another extension of that road to go from Lahaina to Wailuku. I think this proposition would be an effiecient way to limit traffic from Lahaina to Wailuku. For short-term goals, I’m proposing a new solar panel field for sufficient energy. Lahaina is a well known place for having majority sunshine throughout the year. I believe this will help the town be more energy sufficient and earth-friendly.

This area is a natural area where plants and forests should thrive. Keeping it in its natural will only effect Hawai’i and its values of nature.

Lahaina Change is inevitable, but it could be done with better planning. I think Lahaina should focus on in-fill development and cautiously expand to utilize e i ting in a t t e a e t a i leBypass needs to be completed before any significant development

This area is part of the islands heartbeat and also generates significant income and opportunity. It needs to preserve its charm, community and beautiful spaces mauka and makai to ensure it continues to provide.

The South bypass instead of building a north bypass for traffic, how about we focus on a southpass to to avoid the rising ocean. from launiupoko to the pali. Its going to take a lot of time and money. it should be the number 1 priority for the westside.

lahaina t te e ten i t i i t i t la i i ati n t in l e a aina Mi i n an i a e ete ea a e a king e t l t nea Mala at l e g a ele a king an at an ea e a ilitie n ati e ignage at ea a e ega ing ee li e te ting en ange e t tle nk eal g lea la al l an iga ette la M e a ti e e e ati n i a e ete an ne e i n i e

Me i ng te M e e ete e t ea le el i e an t n t e a ea int a ea a k e t e Mala a

Currently the area is trafficked by many homeless either sleeping in the cemetery, on the beach or in cars. Homeless in cemetery should be addressed immediately, the more people walking in the cemetery the quicker the sand moves unearthing more graves. More needs to be done about the erosion of the sand dune due to human traffic, wind. Either barriers need to be put up or vegetation put into place to help slow down loss of sand.

Family Fun Center Family fun Center to serve locals and tourists. It would consist of a skating rink, bowling alley, arcade, compact water park similar to KROC Center in Oahu, amphitheater for performing arts, concerts.

Preferably in Lahaina or Kaanapali.

140

Social Service Offices Social Services Offices. Like probation, parole, mental health counselors, psychiatrists. We also need larger buildings for existing health clinics like Maui Me i al ai e Mala a ke la nit lini Ma i t te e a e t e le l a e een a e e e a e ag

Substance Abuse Rehabilitaion- Lahaina and Olowalu have a huge population of addicts that are not being served. They desperately need services to serve the population. Right now, only a small percentage of the population can get help because the waitlist is 9 months. It is a battle that is not being won. The overwhelming amount of addicts is multiplying because they are like crabs, drawing more and more of their friends into the bucket of addiction.

Currently, people who are trying to work with the court system to change their lives for the better must attend their court ordered probation, parole appointments in Central Maui during buisness hours. Some of these people need to take public transportation. It is difficult and stresses their job and family commitments. Also, there is a shortage of counselors and psychiatrists providing inpatient services to serve the huge population of people who are seeking mental health help. They have no choice, but to find services in Central Maui which are also short on inpatient services.

Shores of Puamana to Papapalua and around the Pali

Create a Marine Reserve and protect our natural resources from commercialization. The County should be working with the State to tax all commercialized shoreline/ocean recreation within the areas from Puamana to Papapalua whether its through a right of entry permit for commercial activity or other required permits. With these tax monies, the County should create a Cultural Preservation Funds to specifically go to native Hawaiian organizations including the Kuleana owners and those who have right under Article XII Section 7 in order to preserve and protect the cultural and natural resources of this area.

solar lights on dividers cars run over the skinny concrete dividers on the highway form aholo to dickenson.. they need solar lights and/or reflective tape on the ground for visibility

Lahaina n t e nea e t te i le t e a l e e ten e t a le te inal Ma e t e i i ente The Oluwalu end of the bypass causes huge traffic headaches leaving Lahaina. I don't have a solution. Lahaina no kai oi!

Lahaina Short term--reduce the amount of rental cars allowed on the island! Bypass will not be a solution if the number of cars continues to be at all time highs. We can build all the roads we want, but the problem lies with the number of cars allowed to be rented out. Maui used to be special and a destination

e le ait t ei le li e t i it n e e like i ne an e a

Short term--water conservation and limiting number of tourists allowed. We need the tourists, but we also need to protect our island from over-use and over-tourism before all that we love is depleted.

Kaanapali Short term--reallocate parking spaces for beach parking. Boat tour employees are using it instead of it being available to the public. Also need to replenish the sand and build the beach back up.

Shoreline development No new shoreline development in sea level rise exposure area

Existing homes Protect existing homeowners

Lahaina Front Street No more Rural growth development until these developments can show how their projects will have the adequate amount of water without impacting the natural flow of the surface water, Ipacts to fauna and species and not obstruct the right of Kalo farmers in Kaua'ula Kahoma, Kanaha, Olowalu

k e a e an n

All i e lan e le t ag i lt al

141

Makila Area of Launiupoko

Retain agricultural zoning for this area. Please do not create new islands of development leading to hopscotch sprawl in West Maui. More housing is needed but focus new development on infill (like Kahoma) and to areas adjacent to existing development and infrastructure (like the 450+ acres of State Housing Development land adjacent to the Kapunakea area of Lahaina and the 200+ acres of private lands surrounding the pool and ballfields).

When the proposal to develop this area came to the County Council in 2017, the zoning change was rejected due to infrastructure and environmental impact concerns. Rather than force fit dense neighborhoods into agricultural areas, which naturally creates extra challenges and concerns, please promote new development in areas where infrastructure and services are already available nearby. Where possible, retain neighborhood character; keep “urban-urban†an keep “country-countryâ€

Olowalo Town, Olowalo Retain existing agricultural zoning for this area. Please do not create new islands of dense development leading to hopscotch sprawl in West Maui. More housing is needed but focus new development on infill (like Kahoma) and to areas adjacent to existing development and infrastructure (like the 450+ acres of State Housing Development land adjacent to the Kapunakea area of Lahaina and the 200+ acres of private lands surrounding the pool and ballfields).

When the proposal to develop Olowalo Town was reviewed by the State Land Use Commission in 2016, the environmental impact report was rejected and the developers pulled their petition in face of widespread opposition. There were many concerns raised by the State, the County, environmental professionals and the public. A quick review of the LUC petition record creates a convincing argument that Olowalo should be exempted from dense development. Olowalo Reef is one of the most extensive in Hawaii which should be preserved at all costs.

The Vintage at Ka'anapali

e en a e i g ee t e g l e e a e t e en a e i g t e e l g(In the long term, if more resorts come in, be mindful about traffic flow. Also be mindful about the resorts training employees about Hawaiian history and culture. If there is more development, then ask the developers to educate their employees to be stewards of West Maui). It is possible to have more development, however please be respectful of the natural beauty and keep/make/preserve the land and ocean.

Yes. Thank you. Do you know Clifford Nae'ole? (He is the Cultural Advisor to The Ritz-Carlton Hotel in Kapalua). Every Friday at 9:30 a.m. he (or one of the other Hawaiian Cultural Advisors) present a short documentary about the history of the Hawaiian people. This presentation is (or was) mandatory to all Ritz employees in Kapalua. And it's open to the Public!!! How about if all the Ka'anapali Hotels/Resorts offer the same presentation? OR, BETTER YET, promote to their guests/owners to go up to the Ritz-Carlton Hotel to learn more about the history/culture of the Hawaiian people??? Why not!!!??? (It's free!, All Maui residents, visitors and guests will benefit). All who see this presentation have respect, empathy and hope for Maui's future! Please help keep this important/beautiful/and compassionate history and culture alive!!!

Lahainaluna e e e l t ee a ne e e a l ang l t ee a e t g t t e t n e e e an e an en a e it in a aina lea e n t ill e e ka it e

an a k an g een a e e iall a n i e an t e ean t te t ateM e nati e an en e i e t an e in lan a ing

ing an e i ent i tM e ati e a aiian i t in ati n an e e ati n a n a aina

a king l t l e ate e ia le it t ee a e an ate a ti n

Policies need to be aimed at keeping locals in houses and local ine e in t e

Empty commercial space (like the Kiawe shopping center) should be ta e ea il

Lahaina The growth areas above Leiali'i, Wahikuli - Kapunakea are ceeded lands and should be used for Hawaiian's First! Hawaiian meaning - anyone with Hawaiian Native Blood! Only Hawaiian Homes should be allowed to build on ceeded lands so that to insure that ceeded lands are occupied by Hawaiians.

I am against the BYPASS connecting with and through Leialii parkway. It should pass Leiali'i and connect to Kaanapali Parkway.

142

Home We need to preserve the land mauka of our subdivision. The mountains and open spaces should never be developed. No additional communities or shops should be added to what is already over developed with hotels and vacation rentals. The mountains need to stay clear and eliminate this "growth area". There is not enough infrastructure for the hotels and houses as is. Roads are too crowded and sewage smells surround our area to the north and south. Before ANY development occurs, these issues must be addressed and define the limitations of any and all future development. West Maui is already losing beach area and has limited green areas and parks. If anything, a West Maui Hospital must be established at least 10 years before inviting more constructions. There also needs to be an absolute ban on non resident owners for any future development.

The best part is the ability to walk and explore and bike and hike behind the neighborhood. The construction of more "luxury homes" or "luxury neighborhoods" should be banned and ONLY around Lahainaluna Rd. and Lahaina should any more AFFORDABLE neighborhoods, hospital, shopping be added.

road into lahaina moving the road away from the shore form olowalu to the pali should be priority #1 for the westside.nothing else matters if we can't drive in and out of the westside to preserve, grow, change other areas north of olowalu.Traffic in and north of lahaina might suck but, water flooding over the road is worse. preserve olowalu area. let additional house and development be in lahaina and north to kapalua closer to where people work, go to school, shop, etc. Think about safety and sustainability.

Lahaina There is a heau in this area that I would like to see preserved. This heau should be open to the public but still protected. It is a beautiful part of Hawai’i and I believe it should be shown.

Kaanapali It should stay the same because its the hawaiian peoples land. Should add more malls

Honokowai A e n k ai t e e a e e la e t at a e ita le ag i lt e e l e le t al ne an n t ilt e e en iti e lan ig t e a g t ag i lt e t ink a i all a ing t at n t ing l e ange an l ta t e a e in a a

Kapalua I would like the Kapalua Subarea to stay the same, as it has always had its small town charm being not overdeveloped. However with that I do have some things I would like to change. I believe that this town is in need of a bit more added to the urban growth boundary as its population is rising and is in need for amenities such as housing and a possible school and gas station in the long term should population growth continues to rise.

Honokowai I think this place is really nice and peaceful, I like that we have beach parks and close stores. I would like to say that I like living there and I feel safe most of the time.

lahaina I think we should preserve canoe beach for the keiki that paddle and swim there. I don't want hotels to take away the beach. No more hotels needed. They say tourism is our only economy but we can make money other ways then adding more hotels and destroying land.

Olowalu General Store Recognize historical and current significance of this vintage business.

Kapalua Kapalua should have no more building in the near future. We have more than enough luxury homes. What is needed are parks and trails for residents. It is currently difficult to get to the beaches with less and less parking made available and far too many visitors.

Kaanapali Kaanapali should remain unchanged in the near future with no further hotels or shopping and no further luxury homes. The only building that should take place in the medium future are homes for residents with decent homes for local families BUT only once the infrastructure is in place.

Kaanapali is at capacity for luxury homes. We don't have real neighborhoods, just big unnecessary homes for the wealthy who are not part of the community, many renting their homes for vacation. Some homes are built and shared as though it was a timeshare. We do not need any more shops with many storefronts sitting empty. What we need is to preserve any green space that is left.

143

Lahaina Preserve Lahaina's historical landmarks, Front Street, and waterfronts. Change (medium-term) the amount of vehicle traffic allowed between Honoapiilani and Front Street from Kapunakea to 505 to encourage pedestrian foot traffic. Short-term: Preserve and strengthen board walk and seawall along primary Front Street areas. Medium-term: Reduce the amount of rental cars allowed on the island in total. We do not need to add roads, we need to return to the restricted amount of cars we had about 6 years ago. Keep Maui special--quality over quantity.

This area is unique and special to Maui's history and deserves to be preserved and maintained.

Makila Would like to preserve the area in open space, or for future ag operations, in perpetuity.

Lahaina I’d like Lahaina to keep its small town charm. I want Lahaina to be self sustainable by having access to water so we can grow more food crops with out use of harmful pesticides that damage the eco system

We need affordable homes and policing on illegal short term rentals

Kaanapali a ana ali nee t gi e e eline a e t t e l al nit an t in n ti n ell t at en ange ee an ate Hanakao’o beach needs to be preserved as the ONLY place where traditional cultural practice of hoe wa’a or canoe is taught on the west side.

Kaanapali The proposed development along the Kaanapali golf course is going to adversely impact the character of Kaanapali. There are already issues with traffic wastewater treatment and seasonal overcrowding. Additional development will only exacerbate these issues.

This is one of the most beautiful places on the planet and if we are not very careful, we’ll ruin it in a way that cannot be reversed or repaired. We should focus on addressing current issues such as traffic and wastewater treatment rather than make them worse through overdevelopment.

Kaanapali Kaanapali doesn't need anymore growth. We need to maintain the view plains and green spaces. The hotels and beach are already at capacity. Adding anymore people, infrastructure, or cars will impede even more on the quality of life for residence and the visitors experience.

More rules need to be in place and enforced to insure beach access, and make the area friendly to residents, especially for our Hawaiian cultural traditions and practices. Hotels should not feel entitlement to the beach or take up all the beach parking spaces for their personal use or needs.

RURAL GROWTH there are very few areas like this on the west side. we bought here(actually have additional land in launiupoko as well) because it was agriculture rural a ea

e e e l t e e el e t at t i l e ain ag a lan we love the low density. all the animals and farms. we also have serious water issues for years and it isn't resolved. our ag water gets cut off frequently which obviously makes it very challenging to farm. we are very opposed to high density urban growth.

Olowalu ta liant it t e lan lan

Still prefer development based on New Urbanism and building a new town. Piecemeal construction in Olowalu should not occur because we will end up it a linea an g t

There should be a contingent precedent to any development in Olowalu. That condition precendent should be that no development until the by-pass is ilt n ent n t ti n

A e t t e t e ntain an ean all e lea l i enti ie an e e e in e et it

The commercial use of the beaches (mostly where kayaks embark) has caused beachfront erosion. Parking of vehicles has lowered the elevation of the area from the pali to Olowalu. This exacerbates the sea level rise effect, not to mention all the dirt and engine fluids being dragged back into the ocean by the waves.

The current road capacity cannot handle Olowalu at this point and definitely cannot handle any future development until such as time as the bypass is built and completed. The farm stand, Olowalu Store, Leoda's and entrance to Olowalu camp causes daily traffic backup and dangerous situations.

KA’ANAPALI Keep the open spaces and preserve views of Mauka and Makai long term

144

Kauaula, located in the Olawalu District and Papapalua located in the Ukumehame area

Creating a Bird Sanctuary in the "Wao Akua" (Upland Mauka, Forest Areas) areas of the Ahupua'a Land Management System for the Nene, Pueo, and 'Io a a la t k e a e

Hawaiian Goose - Nene, Endemic to the Hawaiian Islands. The World's rarest goose. State bird of Hawaii. The Hawaiian name Nene is derived from the bird's low nay-nay call. The Hawaiian Goose is found in mid-elevation terrestrial habitats and seldom near water. It forages on grass, berries, and some weedy plants. Ka’ua’ula Valley was known as one of the Nene Goose resting grounds. Near the Ka’ua’ula stream, there were flourishing ohelo, ‘akala, Hawaiian huckleberry and pukiawe. Till this day, you can still see the wild geese around the area. They come to eat what is left of the

a aiian kle e an t e kia e it it ink e ie

The Pueo and the Hawaiian Hawk are the only two extant native birds of prey native to the Hawaiian Islands. The pueo is a subspecies of the North American short-eared owl, and is considered by many scientists to be a relatively recent natural arrival to Hawai'i. Survival: The pueo is today restricted to the Island of Hawai'i. While it is still relatively common there, it is considered an endangered species by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, and is therefore an important element of our biodiversity conservation efforts. Ka’ua’ula Valley is also a home for the Pueo. Currently, there are nesting holes l ate n t e i ge a a la e a an ee t e l ing in t e a a la k

The Hawaiian Hawk, or 'Io, lives only in Hawai'i and was a symbol of royalty in Hawaiian culture. It was considered an "'aumakua"—a family or personal god—which made harming or killing this bird taboo. 'Io have shrill, high-pitched calls that echo their Hawaiian name. The 'Io's biggest threats are deforestation from agriculture, development, and logging, along with habitat degradation from introduced livestock and invasive plants. Additional hazards include illegal shooting, poisoning, and collisions. The 'Io is the only native member of the hawk family remaining in the Hawaiian archipelago. ike an a t it in t lig t an a k l a e

Kauaula, located in the Olawalu District and Papapalua located in the Ukumehame area

"Wao Akua" has native species such as Milo and Koa.

Milo is a tree of tropical and warm subtropical climates. It is purely a coastal species. Sea level to 150 m (500 ft); in Hawai‘i it grows as high as 275 m (900 ft), although it is probably planted at higher elevations. Large trees were made into small canoes in ancient times in Hawai‘i, although koa (Acacia koa) was the preferred wood for canoe building (Abbott 1992). Milo’s durable wood is also used for boat building in South Asia and elsewhere in the Pacific.

Koa (Acacia koa Gray.) is unquestionably Hawaii's most prized tree species- culturally, ecologically and economically. Hawaiians have always valued koa for its exceptionally beautiful and durable wood. It remains the premier Hawaiian timber for furniture, cabinetry, interior work and woodcrafts. Equally important, native koa forests provide unique wildlife habitat, critical watershed recharge areas and recreational opportunities.

"Wao Kanaka" is referenced as those agricultural lands where we as Kanaka grow for food and sustainability. This will be located around the Makila, Kauaula, Launiopoko, Olowalu, and Ukumehame.

The God Kane is known for healing, life, freshwater, and procreation. In Hawaiian mythology, Kane would take the form of Ko, sugar cane, or would resemble who Kane represents.

Sugarcane was originally brought here to Hawaii by the ancient Polynesians in their canoes.

Our goal is to revitalize and study all 40 varieties of Ko. In Kauaula, we can once again farm the only place known in the world to have all 40 varieties of Ko.

145

Kauaula, located in the Olawalu District and Papapalua located in the Ukumehame area

Lo‘i kalo are ponds for wetland kalo that are enclosed by banks of earth. They are constructed near kahawai (streams) because they are irrigated with stream water. The Hawaiians used a system that allowed water from the stream to run through an ‘auwai (ditch) into the uppermost lo‘i kalo and flow through the openings in the terraces to each lower lo‘i kalo. The water is eventually discharged back into the stream. Many steps went into making a lo‘i kalo. Fishermen also take advantage of the lo‘i kalo and use them as fishponds

Kahawai System are the streams of Kauaula, Launiopoko, Olawalu, Ukemehame. Especially the Kauaula stream, were once abundant with opae, hihiwai, and varieties of fresh limu. Today, we plan to restore the eco-system.

Creating a Bird Sanctuary in the "Muliwai" (Estuaries, river mouth, and wetlands) areas of the Ahupua'a Land Management System for the Ae'o, 'Alae Ke'oke'o, Koloa, and Kolea, The muliwai stretched from Papapalua to Puamana shoreline.

Ae'o: The Ae’o is an endangered species. This slender, endemic wading bird stands 16 inches tall. Their black back is glossy in males and brown-tinged in females. Juveniles have a brownish back with white patches on their cheeks. Like all of Hawaii’s endangered waterbirds, a major cause of its decline has been habitat destruction due to drainage of marshes and wetlands. The Hawaiian Stilt nests in shallow depressions lined with stone and twigs. Adults will use the “broken wing act†t l e int e a a t ei ne t

Kauaula, located in the Olawalu District and Papapalua located in the Ukumehame area

Alae Ke'oke'o: The ‘alae ke‘oke‘o or Hawaiian coot is a small waterbird (Family: Rallidae) endemic to Hawai‘i. Adult males and females have a black head, a slate gray body with white undertail feathers, and a prominent white frontal shield and bill; feet are lobed rather than webbed and are greenish-gray. The Native Hawaiian considered ‘alae ke‘oke‘o (Hawaiian coot) to be a deity, but also considered it good to eat. The species is somewhat gregarious and uses freshwater and brackish wetlands, including agricultural (e.g., taro fields) wetlands and aquaculture ponds. ‘Alae ke‘oke‘o (Hawaiian coot) are generalists and feed on land, from the surface of the water,or will dive; also will graze on grass adjacent to wetlands. Nesting habitat includes freshwater and brackish ponds, irrigation ditches, and taro fields.

Koloa is registered on the Federal and State list as Endangered. The koloa maoli, or Hawaiian duck, is one of two extant native duck species (Family: Anatidae) found in Hawai‘i and is closely related to the well-known, but non-native mallard (A. platyrhynchos). Koloa maoli (Hawaiian ducks) forage in a wide variety of freshwater habitats, including artificial wetlands. Koloa maoli (Hawaiian duck) are usually found alone or in pairs and are wary, especially when nesting or molting, although during the winter they may gather in larger numbers to exploit abundant food resources. Nesting occurs year round, but most activity occurs between January and May. Nests are usually on the ground near water, but few nests are found in areas frequented by humans or areas supporting populations of mammalian predators. Generally eight to ten eggs are laid, and the precocial chicks hatch after an unknown incubation period, but likely less than 30 days.

Kolea: The kÅlea a i i g l en l e i a e atel all ell an ttle e i a il a a ii ae i inte in t e Main Hawaiian Islands (MHI) and breeds in Siberia and westernmost Alaska. The State recognized Kolea as Indigenous. KÅlea ee i a il n te e t ial insects such as cockroaches, moths, caterpillars, and earwigs, all of which they locate by sight. To protect the ability of wintering kÅlea t i e ile in Hawai‘i is the need to protect the current habitat. Most adults arrive in Hawai‘i in August, while juveniles arrive in October; spring departures begin in late April.

Kauaula Valley To protect the Cultural and archaeological sites located in these areas.

146