15
MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 1 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO DEBORAH L. TOOMEY, et al., Plaintiffs, vs. CITY OF TRUTH OR CONSEQUENCES, a municipal corporation, Defendant. No. 2:12-CV-01100-SMV-LAM Magistrate Stephan M. Vidmar MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE The undersigned Plaintiffs, all self-represented, hereby file this Motion to Grant Preliminary Injunction pursuant to Rules 5 and 7, and as grounds state: 1. None of the 65 self-represented plaintiffs, except Plaintiff Toomey, have been served with a copy of Defendant’s Response to Motion for Preliminary Injunction, filed on October 29, 2012, Document #5. 2. Rule 5 requires service upon pro se parties. Pro se parties are excused from the mandatory electronic filing. 3. Defendant’s Certificate of Service for the Response to Motion for Preliminary Injunction clearly demonstrates that only one plaintiff out of 65,

121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Plaintiffs object to failure to serve Defendant's Response to Toomey's Motion for Preliminary Injunction requesting immediate granting of preliminary injunction per rules

Citation preview

Page 1: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 1

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW MEXICO

DEBORAH L. TOOMEY, et al.,

Plaintiffs,

vs.

CITY OF TRUTH OR CONSEQUENCES,

a municipal corporation,

Defendant.

No. 2:12-CV-01100-SMV-LAM

Magistrate Stephan M. Vidmar

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE

The undersigned Plaintiffs, all self-represented, hereby file this Motion to

Grant Preliminary Injunction pursuant to Rules 5 and 7, and as grounds state:

1. None of the 65 self-represented plaintiffs, except Plaintiff Toomey,

have been served with a copy of Defendant’s Response to Motion for Preliminary

Injunction, filed on October 29, 2012, Document #5.

2. Rule 5 requires service upon pro se parties. Pro se parties are excused

from the mandatory electronic filing.

3. Defendant’s Certificate of Service for the Response to Motion for

Preliminary Injunction clearly demonstrates that only one plaintiff out of 65,

Page 2: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 2

Deborah Toomey, was served a copy of Defendant’s Response to Toomey’s

Motion for Preliminary Injunction via U.S. mail, or any means, by Defendant.

4. No parties are in default for failure to enter a notice of appearance.

5. Per local Rule 7.1(b), Plaintiffs hereby request the granting of Motion

for Preliminary Injunction for Defendant’s failure to serve a response in opposition

to the Motion for Preliminary Injunction to 64 plaintiffs within 14 days of the

service of a Motion for Preliminary Injunction.

WHEREFORE, the undersigned Plaintiffs respectfully request this Court to

grant the Motion for Preliminary Injunction for failure to serve a response; or, in

the alternative, order Defendant to serve a copy of their Response to Motion for

Preliminary Injunction on the remaining 64 plaintiffs and order a Reply to said

Response is due within 14 days for Plaintiffs, either singly or jointly, from the date

of service of ALL plaintiffs.

DATED: November ___, 2012 DEBORAH TOOMEY

211 W. Riverside Drive

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

505-315-8503

505-214-5771

Page 3: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 3

DATED: November ___, 2012 BARBARA SALASIN

211 W. Riverside Drive

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-497-9549

DATED: November ___, 2012 RON FENN

316 N. Foch Street

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-894 1543

DATED: November ___, 2012 BETHANN FENN

316 N. Foch Street

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-894 1543

DATED: November ___, 2012 GERALD TRUMBULL

905 Pine Street

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-740-5920

DATED: November ___, 2012 REBECCA OTERO

558 Mims

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-894-4078

DATED: November ___, 2012 YARROW DANKERT

819 Ivy Street

Truth or Consequences, NM 87901

575-894-3560

Page 4: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 4

DATED: November ___, 2012 FELICITAS RODRIGUEZ

6 Mud Canyon Road

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-894-7207

DATED: November ___, 2012 DEBRA GEORGE

822 N. Pershing Street

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-894-7486

DATED: November ___, 2012 JAMES C. MALLEN

600 N. Foch Street

Truth or Consequences, NM 87901

575-894-8637

DATED: November ___, 2012 PATRICK FINLEY

417 Charles Street

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

808-426-8068

DATED: November ___, 2012 LINDA SCOTT

508 S. Pershing Street

Truth or Consequences, NM 87901

575-740-6299

DATED: November ___, 2012 PATRICIA SISTRUNK

506 S. Pershing Street, Apt 1

Truth or Consequences, NM 87901

928-274-3613

Page 5: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 5

DATED: November ___, 2012 JOAN CONWAY

316 E. 3rd Avenue

Truth or Consequences, NM 87901

575-894-7408

DATED: November ___, 2012 JOHN PAPE

212 Austin Avenue

Truth or Consequences, NM 87901

575-894-5051

DATED: November ___, 2012 ALISON RASHEDI

214 Oak Street

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-894-4007

DATED: November ___, 2012 ROBERT HANSECK

316 Broadway Avenue

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-405-9378

DATED: November ___, 2012 WILLIAM CHARLES BENNETT JR.

560 Mims

P O Box 3

Truth or Consequences, NM 87901

505-699-8518

Page 6: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 6

DATED: November ___, 2012 GORDON MISHLER

604 Sunset Ave

PO Box 684

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 2535

DATED: November ___, 2012 MONICA MISHLER

604 Sunset Ave

PO Box 684

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 2535

DATED: November ___, 2012 AUGUSTA MISHLER

604 Sunset Ave

PO Box 684

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 2535

DATED: November ___, 2012 JOSEPH MISHLER

604 Sunset Ave

PO Box 684

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 2535

DATED: November ___, 2012 GLENN M. ALLEN

610 Sunset Ave

PO Box413

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 4635

Page 7: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 7

DATED: November ___, 2012 JOHN E. RAYBURN

611 Sunset Ave

PO Box 715

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 4425

DATED: November ___, 2012 LYNN LARA

611 Sunset Ave

PO Box 715

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 4425

DATED: November ___, 2012 BENJAMIN A. SANCHEZ

206 Central St

PO Box432

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 4351

DATED: November ___, 2012 BONNIE SUE SANCHEZ

206 Central St

PO Box432

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 4350

DATED: November ___, 2012 MARYANN WALTER

703 Central St

P O Box 403

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 1941

Page 8: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 8

DATED: November ___, 2012 THOMAS P. BARTO

606 Central St

P O Box 83

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 497 0002

DATED: November ___, 2012 GRETCHEN M. BARTO

606 Central St

P O Box 83

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 497 0009

DATED: November ___, 2012 ARTHUR LEVINE

500 Central St

P O Box 37

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 6729

DATED: November ___, 2012 RAMONA LEVINE

500 Central St

P O Box 37

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 6729

DATED: November ___, 2012 ROBERT R. MUNNERLYN

503 Central St

Williamsburg, NM 87942

P O Box 3028

Truth or Consequences, NM 87901

909 973 0961

Page 9: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 9

DATED: November ___, 2012 DIANNE FOX

520 Central St

P O Box 92

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 8667

DATED: November ___, 2012 EARL FOX

520 Central St

P O Box 92

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 8667

DATED: November ___, 2012 LOUIE PALACIOS

500 Central St

P O Box 37

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 5935

DATED: November ___, 2012 JAMES PALACIOS

500 Central St

P O Box 37

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 517 9747

Page 10: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 10

DATED: November ___, 2012 MICHELLE CAMBROTO

401 Central St

P O Box 901

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 1030

DATED: November ___, 2012 PHYLLIS MADISON

401 Central St

P O Box 901

Williamsburg, NM 87942

909 961 3108 I

DATED: November ___, 2012 DAVID MADISON

401 Central St

P O Box 901

Williamsburg, NM 87942

909 770 9881

DATED: November ___, 2012 WILLIAM MATA

705 Ridge Rd

P O Box 85

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 0609

DATED: November ___, 2012 AMANDA BAILEY

205 Central St

P O Box 964

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 740 3660

Page 11: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 11

DATED: November ___, 2012 MILDRED I. REED

6306 Veater

P O Box 201

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 6646

DATED: November ___, 2012 MICHAEL W REED

6306 Veater

P O Box 201

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 6646

DATED: November ___, 2012 CHERYL HOLLINGSWORTH

100 Rio Grande

P O Box 73

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575-894-3685

DATED: November ___, 2012 DON CHILDERS

701 Sunset Ave

P O Box 104

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 5715

DATED: November ___, 2012 SHIRLEY M. CHILDERS

701 Sunset Ave

P O Box 104

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575 894 5715

Page 12: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 12

DATED: November ___, 2012 BETTY DURHAM

613 S. Broadway

P O Box 855

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575-894-6252

DATED: November ___, 2012 MARY ROSE

7036 Sunset Avenue

PO Box 6

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575-894-7249

DATED: November ___, 2012 CAROL NARANJO

705 Carmen

PO Box 752

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575-894-4607

DATED: November ___, 2012 LUCY FARRESTER

717 Carmen

PO Box 909

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575-894-7310

DATED: November ___, 2012 JOHN B. GILLEM

717 Carmen

PO Box 909

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575-894-7310

Page 13: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 13

DATED: November ___, 2012 EDNA COBLE

714 Carmen

PO Box 906

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575-894-8955

DATED: November ___, 2012 BRUCE THOMPSON

714 Carmen

PO Box 906

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575-894-8955

DATED: November ___, 2012 KENNETH HUGHES SMILEY

408 N Magnolia

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-740-3407

DATED: November ___, 2012 ANN B. SMILEY

408 N Magnolia

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-740-3407

DATED: November ___, 2012 MICHAL SCHARTZ

605 S. Pershing

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-497-0020

Page 14: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 14

DATED: November ___, 2012 MARIA BACA

201 W. Riverside

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-894-0935

DATED: November ___, 2012 ALFREDO BACA

201 W. Riverside

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-894-0935

DATED: November ___, 2012 JOSEPH JARAMALLO

1208 Aluminum

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-740-3384

DATED: November ___, 2012 MARCUS JARAMALLO

1208 Aluminum

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-740-3384

DATED: November ___, 2012 MICHELLE ELLINGER

427 Van Patten

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-740-3926

Page 15: 121109 64 Plaintiffs Objection to Failure to Serve

MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO

SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE 15

DATED: November ___, 2012 DANA VILLINES

520 Central Street

PO Box 92

Williamsburg, NM 87942

575-740-3067

DATED: November ___, 2012 DARONDA FOX

520 Central Street

Williamsburg, NM 87942

PO Box 1763

Elephant Butte, NM 87942

575-740-2487

DATED: November ___, 2012 KATHE BACHTEL

590 Mims #5

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

575-894-9406

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

The undersigned hereby certifies that MOTION TO GRANT PRELIMINARY

INJUNCTION FOR FAILURE TO SERVE 64 PLAINTIFFS WITH RESPONSE

was electronically filed through the CM/ECF system, which caused all counsel of

record and parties pro se registered in the CM/ECF system to be served via

electronic mail. In addition, pro se parties not registered (and not a signatory) to

this pleading which were served by U.S. Mail, postage prepaid, include: NONE.

DATED: NOVEMBER 9, 2012 ______________________________

DEBORAH TOOMEY, pro se

211 W. Riverside Drive

Truth or Consequences NM 87901

505-315-8503

505-214-5771 (fax)