3
Introduction Compared to other continents, Africa has the least developed climate science in the world. Instrumental weather records in southern Africa are largely limited to the last 100 years and documentary weather-related data are rare prior to the 1800s, which is why only a few studies of the temporal variability of precipitation have been made in Africa, particularly in south- ern Africa. The relatively short instrumental record makes it difficult to as- sess tropical climate variability, such as long-term trends and extremes in precipitation. It’s clear that precise, long-term records of precipitation vari- ability are needed to improve long-range seasonal forecasts of hydrologic activity in southern Africa. Trees are archives of climatic history and one of their greatest hidden potentials is as recorders of oxygen isotopes (δ 18 O) incorporated from the environment each year and imprinted in their annual rings. The measure- ment of stable isotope ratios in tree rings has contributed greatly to the un- derstanding of past climatic conditions. Tree ring samples can provide ex- cellent records of paleoclimate variability, most often for precipitation and temperature fluctuations as well as drought indices and large-scale circula- tion patterns Few studies have examined δ 18 O of trees growing in tropical locations, and the environmental conditions under which variation in oxygen isotopes are recorded in tree rings as well as the climatic significance of this variabil- ity remains poorly understood. The few available oxygen isotope studies of trees from the tropics have shown the presence of a significant inverse cor- relation between δ 18 O of tree rings (δ 18 O tr) and precipitation amount. The inverse correlation between δ 18 O tr and precipitation is known as the “amount effect” (or degree of rainout). Correlations have also been found among the stable isotope values of tree wood and temperature. Though temperature effects may contribute to δ 18 O tr variation in the tropics, it has been suggested that in tropical regions, isotopic temperature effects may be overridden by the amount effect due to wet season precipitation amount and warm temperatures coinciding. Methods Study Site The study site is located in the arid to semi-arid Mzola region of western Zimbabwe (Figures 1 & 2; -18.20°, 27.40°, 1,106 meters asl). Temperatures remain fairly constant throughout the year with a diurnal temperature range of about 10 to 15°C and an annual range that does not exceed 6°C, with November being the warmest month (~ 30.7°C), and July and August being the coolest (~23.6°C). Total annual rainfall exhibits a high degree of spatial and temporal variation with a mean of ~700 mm per year. Approximately 80% of annual precipitation occurs between November and February (~579 mm) whereas, during the dry season months of June-October, ~5% of annual precipitation occurs. Field and Lab Methods Four wedge-shaped partial cross sections (Figure 3) collected from P. angolensis cut stumps and felled logs in the Mzola Forest will be usedd in this study. Ring-width indices from the exactly dated P. angolensis tree rings were obtained from a previous study con- ducted by Therrell et al. (2006). For oxygen isotope analysis, powdered samples will be extracted from each wedge for the years 1900-1990 using a drill bit width of 0.4 to 0.5 mm. Early wood δ 18 O tr values are influenced by the previous year’s climate, therefore late wood samples were chosen for analysis. Isotope Analysis An amount of approximately 0.30 to 0.50 mg of powdered wood extracted from each ring was placed into 3.5 x 5 mm silver capsules for δ 18 O tr analysis and compressed gently into a tiny ball to remove any extraneous atmosphere. The pyrolysis of samples to CO will be performed in a Thermal Conversion/Elemental Analyzer (TC/EA). Results δ 18 O Analysis in Tree Rings of Pterocarpus angolensis in Zimbabwe This study was designed to identify the relationships between climate pa- rameters, such as precipitation amount and temperature fluctuations, and δ 18 O tr extracted from exactly dated tree rings of Pterocarpus angolensis growing in the Mzola region of western Zimbabwe. This species is known to be sensi- tive to variation in rainfall. Here we present preliminary results from four wedge-shaped partial cross sections collected in the Mzola region of Zimba- bwe. This is the first tree-ring research focused as a systematic study of the in- terannual climate variability in southern Africa using the stable isotope ratios of oxygen and ring widths in Zimbabwe. These isotopic records will provide new paleoclimate data for use in the study of large-scale climate phenomenon such as drought and flooding. Research objectives: 1) To assess the potential of δ 18 O tr as a proxies for precipitation and tempera- ture variability in Zimbabwe; 2) δ 18 O tr analysis to reveal changes in the frequency and intensity of extreme climatic events (drought/floods) in Zimbabwe; Fig 1 Location of the Mzola forest study site. Fig. 3 Partial cross-section of Pterocarpus an- golensis from the Mzola forest. Fig. 2 Mzola Forestland. The forest is dominated by Baikiaea plurijuga, Brachystegia spiciformis, and Pterocar- pus angolensis Fig. 4 δ 18 O tr values of sample 1 (red line), sample 2 (blue line), sample 3 (green line), and the average of the three samples (black line). Fig. 5 Correlations between average δ 18 O tr and total precipitation for (a) the previous-year December ( r = -0.34, p = 0.001, (b) current year January ( r = - 0.45, p < 0.0001, and (c) the combined wet season months of November, De- cember and January ( r = -0.55, p < 0.001). a. b. c. Fig. 6 Correlations between average δ 18 O tr and maximum temperature for the (a) month of January ( r = 0.37, p < 0.0005 and (b) average maximum temperature for the months of November, December, January, and February ( r = .0.45, p < 0.0001). a. b. Fig. 7 (a) Time series of November, December, and January total precipitation (blue line) and average δ 18 O tr (black line). Note, precipitation values are shown in re- verse order (b) Average maximum temperature for the months of November, December, January and February (red line) and average δ 18 O tr (black line). Discussion The annually resolved oxygen isotope series spans 90 years, from 1900-1990, allowing for analysis of precipitation and temperature controls on the δ 18 O tr and, therefore, insight into such climate fluctuations over Zimbabwe during this time period. The following correlations have been observed: I. The observed relationship between the δ 18 O tr values in P. angolensis and precipitation amount shows that 18 O tr depletion/ 18 O tr enrichment occurs in response to increases/ decreases in the amount of precipitation. The strongest monthly correlations between δ 18 O tr and precipitation amount occurs during the previous year December and current year January (Figure 5), which are the two wettest months during the year. A significant in- verse relationship was also identified between δ 18 O tr and combined precipitation totals for the months of November, December, and January. Because of the statistical significance of these relationship, our preliminary results are promising and suggest that fluctuations in precipitation are recorded in the δ 18 O tr of P. angolensis and that these parameters could be used as a possible proxy for precipitation variability in Zimbabwe. II. The strongest monthly correlation between δ 18 O tr and maximum temperature was iden- tified during the month of January (Figure 6), which is the warmest month of the year. A significant correlation was also identified between the average maximum temperature for the wet season months of November, December, January, and February. These results are promising for identifying and isotopic temperature effect and the direct correlations be- tween the δ 18 O tr record and wet season maximum temperature may indicate an association between the direct effect of temperature on oxygen isotopic composition of meteoric wa- ter and/or the evaporative enrichment of soil water. III. By analyzing the inter-annual variability in the δ 18 O tr values, it has been suggested that δ 18 O tr fluctuate on annual timescales and that the fluctuations correspond most strongly with wet season precipitation patterns and maximum temperature, suggesting that δ 18 O tr values in P. angolensis could be used to estimate seasonal precipitation amounts and temper- ature fluctuations in western Zimbabwe prior to the instrumental record. Acknowledgements This research is supported by the U.S. National Science Foundation (AGS- 1003699). We would like to thank Mihai Lefticariu from the Mass Spectrometry Department of Southern Illinois University, Carbondale. References 1. Brienen, R. J., Helle, G., Pons, T. L., Guyot, J. L., & Gloor, M. (2012). Oxygen isotopes in tree rings are a good proxy for Amazon precipitation and El Niño-Southern Oscillation variability. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sci- ences, 109(42), 16957-16962. 2. Evans, M. N., & Schrag, D. P. (2004). A stable isotope-based approach to tropical dendroclimatology. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 68(16), 3295-3305. 3. Loader, N. J., G. H. F. Young, D. McCarroll, and R. J. S. Wilson. 2013. “Quantifying Uncertainty in Isotope Dendro- climatology.” The Holocene 23 (9): 1221–26. 4. Managave, S. R., & Ramesh, R. (2012). Isotope dendroclimatology: A review with a special emphasis on tropics. In Handbook of Environmental Isotope Geochemistry (pp. 811-833). Springer Berlin Heidelberg. 5. Therrell, Matthew D., David W. Stahle, Lydia P. Ries, and Herman H. Shugart. 2006. “Tree-Ring Reconstructed Rain- fall Variability in Zimbabwe.” Climate Dynamics 26 (7-8): 677–85. Kerry McLeran 1 , Liliana Lefticariu 2 , Matthew Therrell 3 , Justin Schoof 4 [email protected] 1 Department of Environmental Resources and Policy 2 Department of Geology 3 Department of Geography Conclusion As one of the first δ 18 O tr proxy records developed from tree rings in Zimbabwe, this study is providing framework for the future analysis of precipitation and temperature variability over this region and will contribute to isotope dendro-paleoclimatology in the tropics and to understanding hydroclimate variability and change in this part of the world. The potential of using stable isotopes in tree rings as proxies for paleoclimate analyses in southern Africa has not been fully exploited yet, though stable isotopes analysis appears to be a promising method for assessing paleoclimate variability in this region. a. b.

18O Analysis in Tree Rings of Pterocarpus angolensis in ...€¦ · and the environmental conditions under which variation in oxygen isotopes are recorded in tree rings as well as

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 18O Analysis in Tree Rings of Pterocarpus angolensis in ...€¦ · and the environmental conditions under which variation in oxygen isotopes are recorded in tree rings as well as

Introduction

Compared to other continents, Africa has the least developed climate science in the world. Instrumental weather records in southern Africa are largely limited to the last 100 years and documentary weather-related data are rare prior to the 1800s, which is why only a few studies of the temporal variability of precipitation have been made in Africa, particularly in south-ern Africa. The relatively short instrumental record makes it difficult to as-sess tropical climate variability, such as long-term trends and extremes in precipitation. It’s clear that precise, long-term records of precipitation vari-ability are needed to improve long-range seasonal forecasts of hydrologic activity in southern Africa.

Trees are archives of climatic history and one of their greatest hidden potentials is as recorders of oxygen isotopes (δ18O) incorporated from the environment each year and imprinted in their annual rings. The measure-ment of stable isotope ratios in tree rings has contributed greatly to the un-derstanding of past climatic conditions. Tree ring samples can provide ex-cellent records of paleoclimate variability, most often for precipitation and temperature fluctuations as well as drought indices and large-scale circula-tion patterns

Few studies have examined δ18O of trees growing in tropical locations, and the environmental conditions under which variation in oxygen isotopes are recorded in tree rings as well as the climatic significance of this variabil-ity remains poorly understood. The few available oxygen isotope studies of trees from the tropics have shown the presence of a significant inverse cor-relation between δ18O of tree rings (δ18Otr) and precipitation amount. The inverse correlation between δ18Otr and precipitation is known as the “amount effect” (or degree of rainout). Correlations have also been found among the stable isotope values of tree wood and temperature. Though temperature effects may contribute to δ18Otr variation in the tropics, it has been suggested that in tropical regions, isotopic temperature effects may be overridden by the amount effect due to wet season precipitation amount and warm temperatures coinciding.

Methods

Study Site

The study site is located in the arid to semi-arid Mzola region of western Zimbabwe (Figures 1 & 2; -18.20°, 27.40°, 1,106 meters asl). Temperatures remain fairly constant throughout the year with a diurnal temperature range of about 10 to 15°C and an annual range that does not exceed 6°C, with November being the warmest month (~ 30.7°C), and July and August being the coolest (~23.6°C). Total annual rainfall exhibits a high degree of spatial and temporal variation with a mean of ~700 mm per year. Approximately 80% of annual precipitation occurs between November and February (~579 mm) whereas, during the dry season months of June-October, ~5% of annual precipitation occurs.

Field and Lab Methods

Four wedge-shaped partial cross sections (Figure 3) collected from P. angolensis cut stumps and felled logs in the Mzola Forest will be usedd in this study. Ring-width indices from the exactly dated P. angolensis tree rings were obtained from a previous study con-ducted by Therrell et al. (2006).

For oxygen isotope analysis, powdered samples will be extracted from each wedge for the years 1900-1990 using a drill bit width of 0.4 to 0.5 mm. Early wood δ18Otr values are influenced by the previous year’s climate, therefore late wood samples were chosen for analysis.

Isotope Analysis

An amount of approximately 0.30 to 0.50 mg of powdered wood extracted from each ring was placed into 3.5 x 5 mm silver capsules for δ18Otr analysis and compressed gently into a tiny ball to remove any extraneous atmosphere. The pyrolysis of samples to CO will be performed in a Thermal Conversion/Elemental Analyzer (TC/EA).

Results

δ18

O Analysis in Tree Rings of Pterocarpus angolensis in Zimbabwe

This study was designed to identify the relationships between climate pa-rameters, such as precipitation amount and temperature fluctuations, and δ18Otr extracted from exactly dated tree rings of Pterocarpus angolensis growing in the Mzola region of western Zimbabwe. This species is known to be sensi-tive to variation in rainfall. Here we present preliminary results from four wedge-shaped partial cross sections collected in the Mzola region of Zimba-bwe. This is the first tree-ring research focused as a systematic study of the in-terannual climate variability in southern Africa using the stable isotope ratios of oxygen and ring widths in Zimbabwe. These isotopic records will provide new paleoclimate data for use in the study of large-scale climate phenomenon such as drought and flooding. Research objectives:

1) To assess the potential of δ18Otr as a proxies for precipitation and tempera-ture variability in Zimbabwe;

2) δ18Otr analysis to reveal changes in the frequency and intensity of extreme climatic events (drought/floods) in Zimbabwe;

Fig 1 Location of the Mzola forest study site.

Fig. 3 Partial cross-section of Pterocarpus an-golensis from the Mzola forest.

Fig. 2 Mzola Forestland. The forest is dominated by Baikiaea plurijuga, Brachystegia spiciformis, and Pterocar-pus angolensis

Fig. 4 δ18

O tr values of sample 1 (red line), sample 2 (blue line), sample 3 (green line), and

the average of the three samples (black line).

Fig. 5 Correlat ions between average δ

18O tr

and total precipitation for (a) the

previous-year December (r = -0.34, p = 0.001, (b) current year January (r = -0.45, p < 0.0001, and (c) the combined wet season months of November, De-cember and January (r = -0.55, p < 0.001).

a. b.

c.

Fig. 6 Correlat ions between average δ18

O tr and maximum temperature for the (a)

month of January (r = 0.37, p < 0.0005 and (b) average maximum temperature for the months of November, December, January, and February ( r = .0.45, p < 0.0001).

a.

b.

Fig. 7 (a) Time ser ies o f November, December, and January to tal prec ip i tat ion (blue line) and average δ

18O tr

(black line). Note, precipitation values are shown in re-

verse order (b) Average maximum temperature for the months of November, December, January and February (red line) and average δ

18O tr

(black line).

Discussion

The annually resolved oxygen isotope series spans 90 years, from 1900-1990, allowing for analysis of precipitation and temperature controls on the δ18Otr and, therefore, insight into such climate fluctuations over Zimbabwe during this time period. The following correlations have been observed:

I. The observed relationship between the δ18Otr values in P. angolensis and precipitation amount shows that 18Otr depletion/18Otr enrichment occurs in response to increases/decreases in the amount of precipitation. The strongest monthly correlations between δ18Otr and precipitation amount occurs during the previous year December and current year January (Figure 5), which are the two wettest months during the year. A significant in-verse relationship was also identified between δ18Otr and combined precipitation totals for the months of November, December, and January. Because of the statistical significance of these relationship, our preliminary results are promising and suggest that fluctuations in precipitation are recorded in the δ18Otr of P. angolensis and that these parameters could be used as a possible proxy for precipitation variability in Zimbabwe.

II. The strongest monthly correlation between δ18Otr and maximum temperature was iden-tified during the month of January (Figure 6), which is the warmest month of the year. A significant correlation was also identified between the average maximum temperature for the wet season months of November, December, January, and February. These results are promising for identifying and isotopic temperature effect and the direct correlations be-tween the δ18Otr record and wet season maximum temperature may indicate an association between the direct effect of temperature on oxygen isotopic composition of meteoric wa-ter and/or the evaporative enrichment of soil water.

III. By analyzing the inter-annual variability in the δ18Otr values, it has been suggested that δ18Otr fluctuate on annual timescales and that the fluctuations correspond most strongly with wet season precipitation patterns and maximum temperature, suggesting that δ18Otr values in P. angolensis could be used to estimate seasonal precipitation amounts and temper-ature fluctuations in western Zimbabwe prior to the instrumental record.

Acknowledgements This research is supported by the U.S. National Science Foundation (AGS-1003699). We would like to thank Mihai Lefticariu from the Mass Spectrometry Department of Southern Illinois University, Carbondale.

References 1. Brienen, R. J., Helle, G., Pons, T. L., Guyot, J. L., & Gloor, M. (2012). Oxygen isotopes in tree rings are a good proxy

for Amazon precipitation and El Niño-Southern Oscillation variability. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sci-ences, 109(42), 16957-16962.

2. Evans, M. N., & Schrag, D. P. (2004). A stable isotope-based approach to tropical dendroclimatology. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta, 68(16), 3295-3305.

3. Loader, N. J., G. H. F. Young, D. McCarroll, and R. J. S. Wilson. 2013. “Quantifying Uncertainty in Isotope Dendro-climatology.” The Holocene 23 (9): 1221–26.

4. Managave, S. R., & Ramesh, R. (2012). Isotope dendroclimatology: A review with a special emphasis on tropics. In Handbook of Environmental Isotope Geochemistry (pp. 811-833). Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

5. Therrell, Matthew D., David W. Stahle, Lydia P. Ries, and Herman H. Shugart. 2006. “Tree-Ring Reconstructed Rain-fall Variability in Zimbabwe.” Climate Dynamics 26 (7-8): 677–85.

Kerry McLeran1, Liliana Lefticariu 2, Matthew Therrell 3, Justin Schoof 4 [email protected]

1Department of Environmental Resources and Policy 2Department of Geology 3Department of Geography

Conclusion

As one of the first δ18Otr proxy records developed from tree rings in Zimbabwe, this study is providing framework for the future analysis of precipitation and temperature variability over this region and will contribute to isotope dendro-paleoclimatology in the tropics and to understanding hydroclimate variability and change in this part of the world. The potential of using stable isotopes in tree rings as proxies for paleoclimate analyses in southern Africa has not been fully exploited yet, though stable isotopes analysis appears to be a promising method for assessing paleoclimate variability in this region.

a. b.

Page 2: 18O Analysis in Tree Rings of Pterocarpus angolensis in ...€¦ · and the environmental conditions under which variation in oxygen isotopes are recorded in tree rings as well as
Page 3: 18O Analysis in Tree Rings of Pterocarpus angolensis in ...€¦ · and the environmental conditions under which variation in oxygen isotopes are recorded in tree rings as well as