2007 Systematic review results (ISO 999; ISO 2788; ISO ... · Systematic review balloting Thacker, Jane M. Ms. Friday, 2007-07-13 Search > ISO 999:1996 Information Result Participation

Systematic review balloting Thacker, Jane M. Ms. Friday, 2007-07-13

Search > ISO 999:1996

Information Result Participation

Download

Voting result as a Zip file

Reference ISO 999:1996 Committee ISO/TC 46/SC 9

Edition number 2 Vienna agreement

English title Information and documentation -- Guidelines for the content, organization and presentation of indexes

French title Information et documentation -- Principes directeurs pour l'élaboration, la structure et la présentation des index

Start date 2007-01-15 End date 2007-06-18

Opened by ISO/CS on 2007-01-15 00:11:51 Closed by ISO/CS on 2007-06-20 03:24:30

Status Closed

Voting stage Systematic review Version number 2

Vote in parallel with

Note

Questions

Q.1 "Recommended action"

Q.2 "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?"

Q.3 "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?"

Q.4 "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?"

Q.5 "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?"

Votes by members

Country Member Participation Vote Withdraw Revise/Amend Confirm Confirm Q.2 Q.3 Q.4 Q.5

Page 1 of 6ISO 999:1996

7/13/2007http://isotc.iso.org/livelink/eb3/part/sr/ballotAction.do?method=doViewResult&id=4246

ISO/TC46/SC9 N 4712007 Systematic review results (ISO 999; ISO 2788; ISO 5963; ISO 5964; ISO 15706)

& correct

Australia SA P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Bulgaria BDS P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Canada SCC Secretariat Valid X No Yes No

China SAC P-Member Missing

Colombia ICONTEC P-Member Valid X No No No

Croatia HZN P-Member Missing

Czech Republic

CNI P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Denmark DS P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Estonia EVS O-Member Valid X No Yes No

Finland SFS P-Member Valid X No Yes No

France AFNOR P-Member Valid X Yes Identical No No

Germany DIN P-Member Valid X No No No

Hungary MSZT P-Member Abstain

Italy UNI P-Member Valid X Yes Identical No No

Japan JISC P-Member Valid X No Yes No

Kenya KEBS P-Member Missing

Korea, Republic of

KATS P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Norway SN P-Member Abstain

Poland PKN P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Portugal IPQ P-Member Missing

Russian Federation

GOST R P-Member Missing

South Africa

SABS P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Page 2 of 6ISO 999:1996


Spain AENOR P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Sweden SIS P-Member Abstain

Switzerland SNV P-Member Abstain

Ukraine DSSU P-Member Abstain

United Kingdom

BSI P-Member Valid X Yes Identical No No

USA ANSI P-Member Valid X No Yes No

P-Member TOTALS 22 Valid

5 Missing

0 2 15 0 11 Yes 6 No

11 Identical

0 Modified

12 Yes 5 No

0 Yes 17 No

TOTALS 23 Valid

0 2 16 0 11 Yes 7 No

11 Identical

0 Modified

13 Yes 5 No

0 Yes 18 No

Answers to Q.1: "Recommended action" (all votes)

16 x Confirm AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) DS (Denmark) EVS (Estonia) ICONTEC (Colombia) JISC (Japan) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) UNI (Italy)

5 x Abstain DSSU (Ukraine) MSZT (Hungary) SIS (Sweden) SN (Norway) SNV (Switzerland)

2 x Revise/Amend BSI (United Kingdom) DIN (Germany)

0 x Abstain with survey replies

0 x Confirm, with correction of errors

0 x Withdraw

Answers to Q.2: "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?" (all votes)

11 x Yes AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DS

Page 3 of 6ISO 999:1996


(Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) UNI (Italy)

7 x No ANSI (USA) DIN (Germany) EVS (Estonia) ICONTEC (Colombia) JISC (Japan) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland)

Answers to Q.3: "Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?" (all votes)

11 x Identical AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DS (Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) UNI (Italy)

0 x Modified

Answers to Q.4: "Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?" (all votes)

13 x Yes AENOR (Spain) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) DS (Denmark) EVS (Estonia) JISC (Japan) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland)

5 x No AFNOR (France) BSI (United Kingdom) DIN (Germany) ICONTEC (Colombia) UNI (Italy)

Answers to Q.5: "Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?" (all votes)

18 x No AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) DS (Denmark) EVS (Estonia) ICONTEC (Colombia) JISC (Japan) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) UNI (Italy)

0 x Yes

Comments from Voters

Comment(s) to Q.1:

MSZT (Hungary) Abstention is based on the response from those concerned

Comment(s) to Q.2:

Page 4 of 6ISO 999:1996


AENOR (Spain) UNE 50111

AFNOR (France) NF/ISO 999

BDS (Bulgaria) BDS intends to adopt it as a national standard.

BSI (United Kingdom) BS ISO 999:1996

CNI (Czech Republic) CSN ISO 999:1998

DS (Denmark) DS/ISO 999:1998

KATS (Korea, Republic of) KS X ISO 999

PKN (Poland) PN-ISO 999-2001

SA (Australia) AS/NZS ISO 999:1999

SABS (South Africa) SANS 438:2005

UNI (Italy) UNI ISO 999:2005

Comment(s) to Q.3:

Comment(s) to Q.4:

AFNOR (France) No, use of NF/ISO 999

BSI (United Kingdom) It is adopted as BS ISO 999:1996

DIN (Germany) There exists a national standard DIN 31630-1 (1988-06) with the same topic but dated before the ISO standard was issued.

ICONTEC (Colombia) Thera ase no products base on this standard.

UNI (Italy) We adopt the UNI ISO standard

Comment(s) to Q.5:

Comment file(s)

Page 5 of 6ISO 999:1996


DIN (Germany) DIN(Germany).doc

Comments from Commenters

Back to list of ballots

Electronic Balloting ® Version 3 (prod), Copyright © 2007, ISO/CS, All rights reserved.

Page 6 of 6ISO 999:1996





Metadata



English title Information and documentation -- Guidelines for the content, organization and presentation of indexes

French title Information et documentation -- Principes directeurs pour l'élaboration, la structure et la présentation des index


Opened by ISO/CS on 2007-01-15 00:11 Closed by ISO/CS on 2007-06-20 03:24

Status Closed



Type Participant Participation Date

AENOR (Spain) Recommended action Confirm

Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future as a national standard or other publication?

Yes

Is the national publication identical to the International Standard or was it modified?

Identical

Is this International Standard used in your country without national adoption or are products used in your country based on this standard?

Yes

Is this International Standard, or its national adoption, referenced in regulations in your country?

No

P-Member 2007-06-18 14:24

AFNOR (France) Recommended action Confirm


Yes

P-Member 2007-06-15 14:29

Page 1 of 7ISO 999:1996

7/13/2007http://isotc.iso.org/livelink/eb3/part/sr/ballotAction.do?method=doView&id=4246&tab=ballot.information.label


Identical


No


No

ANSI (USA) Recommended action Confirm


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 20:08

BDS (Bulgaria) Recommended action Confirm


Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-07 15:33

BSI (United Kingdom) Recommended action Revise/Amend


Yes


Identical


No


No

P-Member 2007-05-03 12:19

CNI (Czech Republic) Recommended action Confirm

Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted Yes

P-Member 2007-06-07 14:33

Page 2 of 7ISO 999:1996


in the future as a national standard or other publication?


Identical


Yes


No

DIN (Germany) Recommended action Revise/Amend


No



No


No

P-Member 2007-06-05 16:33

DS (Denmark) Recommended action Confirm


Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-12 12:51

DSSU (Ukraine) Recommended action Abstain





P-Member 2007-06-18 09:42

EVS (Estonia) Recommended action Confirm

O-Member 2007-06-17 15:41

Page 3 of 7ISO 999:1996



No



Yes


No

ICONTEC (Colombia) Recommended action Confirm


No



No


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 23:10

JISC (Japan) Recommended action Confirm


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 07:16

KATS (Korea, Republic of) Recommended action Confirm


Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 07:05

MSZT (Hungary) P-Member 2007-06-12 10:38

Page 4 of 7ISO 999:1996


Recommended action Abstain





PKN (Poland) Recommended action Confirm


Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-13 11:12

SA (Australia) Recommended action Confirm


Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-18 09:11

SABS (South Africa) Recommended action Confirm


Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 11:50

Page 5 of 7ISO 999:1996


SCC (Canada) Recommended action Confirm


No



Yes


No

Secretariat 2007-06-05 17:02

SFS (Finland) Recommended action Confirm


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-11 13:17

SIS (Sweden) Recommended action Abstain





P-Member 2007-06-15 12:04

SN (Norway) Recommended action Abstain





P-Member 2007-06-04 09:41

Page 6 of 7ISO 999:1996


SNV (Switzerland) Recommended action Abstain





P-Member 2007-06-07 10:36

UNI (Italy) Recommended action Confirm


Yes


Identical


No


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 12:20



Page 7 of 7ISO 999:1996





Download




English title Documentation -- Guidelines for the establishment and development of monolingual thesauri

French title Documentation -- Principes directeurs pour l'établissement et le développement de thésaurus monolingues



Status Closed



Note

Questions






Votes by members


Page 1 of 6ISO 2788:1986



& correct

Australia SA P-Member Valid X No Yes No






Czech Republic

CNI P-Member Valid X Yes Modified Yes No




France AFNOR P-Member Valid X Yes Modified Yes No

Germany DIN P-Member Abstain

No Yes No



Japan JISC P-Member Valid X No No No


Korea, Republic of


Norway SN P-Member Valid X No Yes No

Poland PKN P-Member Valid X No Yes No


Russian Federation


South Africa


Page 2 of 6ISO 2788:1986






United Kingdom

BSI P-Member Valid X Yes Identical No No



5 Missing

1 7 9 0 9 Yes 9 No

7 Identical

2 Modified

14 Yes 4 No

0 Yes 18 No

TOTALS 23 Valid

1 8 9 0 9 Yes 10 No

7 Identical

2 Modified

15 Yes 4 No

0 Yes 19 No


9 x Confirm AENOR (Spain) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) DS (Denmark) ICONTEC (Colombia) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SFS (Finland)

8 x Revise/Amend AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BSI (United Kingdom) EVS (Estonia) JISC (Japan) SCC (Canada) SN (Norway) UNI (Italy)

4 x Abstain DSSU (Ukraine) MSZT (Hungary) SIS (Sweden) SNV (Switzerland)

1 x Abstain with survey replies DIN (Germany)

1 x Withdraw PKN (Poland)



10 x No ANSI (USA) DIN (Germany) EVS (Estonia) ICONTEC (Colombia) JISC (Japan) PKN (Poland) SA

Page 3 of 6ISO 2788:1986


(Australia) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) SN (Norway)

9 x Yes AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DS (Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SABS (South Africa) UNI (Italy)


7 x Identical AENOR (Spain) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) DS (Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SABS (South Africa) UNI (Italy)

2 x Modified AFNOR (France) CNI (Czech Republic)


15 x Yes AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) DS (Denmark) EVS (Estonia) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) SN (Norway)

4 x No BSI (United Kingdom) ICONTEC (Colombia) JISC (Japan) UNI (Italy)


19 x No AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) DS (Denmark) EVS (Estonia) ICONTEC (Colombia) JISC (Japan) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) SN (Norway) UNI (Italy)

0 x Yes


Comment(s) to Q.1:

EVS (Estonia) Recommended is to have one standard for monolingual and multilingual thesauri.

SCC (Canada) BSI has submitted a new work item proposal which covers the provisions of ISO 5964 and ISO 2788.

UNI (Italy) We propose to review some sections (in particular clauses 9.4 and 10.6 - 10.8)

Page 4 of 6ISO 2788:1986


MSZT (Hungary) Abstention is based on the response from those concerned.

Comment(s) to Q.2:


AFNOR (France) NF Z 47-101:1990

BDS (Bulgaria) BDS ISO 2788:2002.

BSI (United Kingdom) UK adopted it as a national standard until 2005, when it was superseded by BS 8723 parts 1 and 2

CNI (Czech Republic) CSN 010193:1996





Comment(s) to Q.3:

AFNOR (France) Technical concordance

CNI (Czech Republic) Adapted in the parts of examples and abbreviations.

Comment(s) to Q.4:

BSI (United Kingdom) we now use BS 8723 series of standards which can be used as a basis to revise this standard. See document N458 for the NWIP proposal

ICONTEC (Colombia) There are no products based on this standard.

JISC (Japan) This standard is not referred in Japanese national standards.


Comment(s) to Q.5:

Page 5 of 6ISO 2788:1986


Comment file(s)

ANSI (USA) ANSI(USA).doc

SN (Norway) SN(Norway).doc




Page 6 of 6ISO 2788:1986





Metadata



English title Documentation -- Guidelines for the establishment and development of monolingual thesauri

French title Documentation -- Principes directeurs pour l'établissement et le développement de thésaurus monolingues



Status Closed






Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-18 14:21

AFNOR (France) Recommended action Revise/Amend


Yes

P-Member 2007-06-14 13:19

Page 1 of 7ISO 2788:1986



Modified


Yes


No

ANSI (USA) Recommended action Revise/Amend


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 20:10



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-07 15:29



Yes


Identical


No


No

P-Member 2007-05-03 12:16



P-Member 2007-06-08 09:44

Page 2 of 7ISO 2788:1986




Modified


Yes


No

DIN (Germany) Recommended action Abstain with survey replies


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-05 16:39



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-12 12:46






P-Member 2007-06-18 09:43

EVS (Estonia) Recommended action Revise/Amend

O-Member 2007-06-17 15:35

Page 3 of 7ISO 2788:1986



No



Yes


No



No



No


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 23:12

JISC (Japan) Recommended action Revise/Amend


No



No


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 07:10



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 07:02


Page 4 of 7ISO 2788:1986







PKN (Poland) Recommended action Withdraw


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-13 11:12



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-18 09:09



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 11:52

Page 5 of 7ISO 2788:1986


SCC (Canada) Recommended action Revise/Amend


No



Yes


No

Secretariat 2007-06-05 17:06



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-11 13:15






P-Member 2007-06-15 12:05

SN (Norway) Recommended action Revise/Amend


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-04 09:58

Page 6 of 7ISO 2788:1986







P-Member 2007-06-07 10:36

UNI (Italy) Recommended action Revise/Amend


Yes


Identical


No


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 12:15



Page 7 of 7ISO 2788:1986





Download




English title Documentation -- Methods for examining documents, determining their subjects, and selecting indexing terms

French titleDocumentation -- Méthodes pour l'analyse des documents, la détermination de leur contenu et la sélection des termes d'indexation



Status Closed



Note

Questions






Votes by members

Page 1 of 5ISO 5963:1985



Country Member Participation Vote Withdraw Revise/Amend Confirm Confirm & correct

Q.2 Q.3 Q.4 Q.5







Czech Republic


Denmark DS P-Member Abstain



France AFNOR P-Member Valid X No Yes No

Germany DIN P-Member Valid X No Yes No





Korea, Republic of





Russian Federation


South SABS P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Page 2 of 5ISO 5963:1985


Africa


Sweden SIS P-Member Valid X No Yes No



United Kingdom

BSI P-Member Valid X No No No



5 Missing

2 4 12 0 6 Yes 12 No

6 Identical

0 Modified

14 Yes 4 No

0 Yes 18 No

TOTALS 23 Valid

2 5 12 0 6 Yes 13 No

6 Identical

0 Modified

15 Yes 4 No

0 Yes 19 No


12 x Confirm AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) BDS (Bulgaria) DIN (Germany) ICONTEC (Colombia) JISC (Japan) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) UNI (Italy)

5 x Revise/Amend ANSI (USA) CNI (Czech Republic) EVS (Estonia) SIS (Sweden) SN (Norway)

4 x Abstain DS (Denmark) DSSU (Ukraine) MSZT (Hungary) SNV (Switzerland)

2 x Withdraw BSI (United Kingdom) PKN (Poland)

0 x Abstain with survey replies



13 x No AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BSI (United Kingdom) DIN (Germany) EVS (Estonia) ICONTEC

Page 3 of 5ISO 5963:1985


(Colombia) JISC (Japan) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) SIS (Sweden) SN (Norway)

6 x Yes AENOR (Spain) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SABS (South Africa) UNI (Italy)


6 x Identical AENOR (Spain) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SABS (South Africa) UNI (Italy)

0 x Modified


15 x Yes AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) EVS (Estonia) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) SIS (Sweden) SN (Norway)

4 x No BSI (United Kingdom) ICONTEC (Colombia) JISC (Japan) UNI (Italy)


19 x No AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) EVS (Estonia) ICONTEC (Colombia) JISC (Japan) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) SIS (Sweden) SN (Norway) UNI (Italy)

0 x Yes


Comment(s) to Q.1:


Comment(s) to Q.2:


Page 4 of 5ISO 5963:1985


BDS (Bulgaria) BDS ISO 5963:2002





Comment(s) to Q.3:

Comment(s) to Q.4:

BSI (United Kingdom) This Standard is part replaced by ISO 999 and BS 8723 part 1 and 2

ICONTEC (Colombia) There are no products based on this standard.



Comment(s) to Q.5:

Comment file(s)






Page 5 of 5ISO 5963:1985





Metadata



English title Documentation -- Methods for examining documents, determining their subjects, and selecting indexing terms

French titleDocumentation -- Méthodes pour l'analyse des documents, la détermination de leur contenu et la sélection des termes d'indexation



Status Closed






Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-18 14:22



No

P-Member 2007-06-15 14:27

Page 1 of 7ISO 5963:1985




Yes


No



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 20:11



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-07 15:30

BSI (United Kingdom) Recommended action Withdraw


No



No


No

P-Member 2007-05-03 12:16

CNI (Czech Republic) Recommended action Revise/Amend


P-Member 2007-06-07 14:31

Page 2 of 7ISO 5963:1985




Identical


Yes


No

DIN (Germany) Recommended action Confirm


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-05 16:45

DS (Denmark) Recommended action Abstain





P-Member 2007-06-12 12:40






P-Member 2007-06-18 09:45


O-Member 2007-06-17 15:38

Page 3 of 7ISO 5963:1985



No



Yes


No



No



No


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 23:06



No



No


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 07:13



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 07:02


Page 4 of 7ISO 5963:1985







PKN (Poland) Recommended action Withdraw


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-13 11:13



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-18 09:08



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 11:54

Page 5 of 7ISO 5963:1985




No



Yes


No

Secretariat 2007-06-05 17:05



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-11 13:15

SIS (Sweden) Recommended action Revise/Amend


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 12:02



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-04 10:02

Page 6 of 7ISO 5963:1985







P-Member 2007-06-07 10:36



Yes


Identical


No


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 12:17



Page 7 of 7ISO 5963:1985





Download




English title Documentation -- Guidelines for the establishment and development of multilingual thesauri

French title Documentation -- Principes directeurs pour l'établissement et le développement de thesaurus multilingues



Status Closed



Note

Questions






Votes by members


Page 1 of 5ISO 5964:1985



& correct





Colombia ICONTEC P-Member Missing


Czech Republic





France AFNOR P-Member Valid X No Yes No

Germany DIN P-Member Abstain

No Yes No


Italy UNI P-Member Abstain



Korea, Republic of





Russian Federation


South SABS P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No

Page 2 of 5ISO 5964:1985


Africa





United Kingdom

BSI P-Member Valid X No No No



6 Missing

1 7 7 0 6 Yes 10 No

6 Identical

0 Modified

14 Yes 2 No

0 Yes 16 No

TOTALS 22 Valid

1 8 7 0 6 Yes 11 No

6 Identical

0 Modified

15 Yes 2 No

0 Yes 17 No


8 x Revise/Amend AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) EVS (Estonia) JISC (Japan) SCC (Canada) SN (Norway)

7 x Confirm AENOR (Spain) BDS (Bulgaria) DS (Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SFS (Finland)

5 x Abstain DSSU (Ukraine) MSZT (Hungary) SIS (Sweden) SNV (Switzerland) UNI (Italy)

1 x Abstain with survey replies DIN (Germany)

1 x Withdraw PKN (Poland)



Page 3 of 5ISO 5964:1985


11 x No AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BSI (United Kingdom) DIN (Germany) EVS (Estonia) JISC (Japan) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) SN (Norway)

6 x Yes AENOR (Spain) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) DS (Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SABS (South Africa)


6 x Identical AENOR (Spain) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) DS (Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SABS (South Africa)

0 x Modified


15 x Yes AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) DS (Denmark) EVS (Estonia) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) SN (Norway)

2 x No BSI (United Kingdom) JISC (Japan)


17 x No AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) DS (Denmark) EVS (Estonia) JISC (Japan) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) SN (Norway)

0 x Yes


Comment(s) to Q.1:

EVS (Estonia) Recommended is to have one standard for monolingual and multilingual thesauri.

SCC (Canada) BSI has submitted a new work item proposal which will update the provisions of ISO 2788 and ISO 5964.

Page 4 of 5ISO 5964:1985



UNI (Italy) Abstention due to lack of technical expertise

Comment(s) to Q.2:


BDS (Bulgaria) BDS plans to adopt it as a national standard





Comment(s) to Q.3:

Comment(s) to Q.4:

BSI (United Kingdom) BS 6723 is the national standard equivalent to ISO 5964, it will soon be superseded by BS 8723 part 4. Which can be used as a basis to revise ISO 5964. See document N458 for the NWIP proposal


Comment(s) to Q.5:

Comment file(s)






Page 5 of 5ISO 5964:1985





Metadata



English title Documentation -- Guidelines for the establishment and development of multilingual thesauri

French title Documentation -- Principes directeurs pour l'établissement et le développement de thesaurus multilingues



Status Closed






Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-18 14:23

AFNOR (France) Recommended action Revise/Amend


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 13:24

Page 1 of 7ISO 5964:1985




Yes


No



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 20:12



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-07 15:31



No



No


No

P-Member 2007-05-03 12:18

CNI (Czech Republic) Recommended action Revise/Amend


P-Member 2007-06-07 14:35

Page 2 of 7ISO 5964:1985




Identical


Yes


No

DIN (Germany) Recommended action Abstain with survey replies


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-05 16:46



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-12 12:43






P-Member 2007-06-18 09:44


O-Member 2007-06-17 15:40

Page 3 of 7ISO 5964:1985



No



Yes


No

JISC (Japan) Recommended action Revise/Amend


No



No


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 07:14



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 07:04

MSZT (Hungary) Recommended action Abstain





P-Member 2007-06-12 10:41

PKN (Poland) P-Member 2007-06-13 11:15

Page 4 of 7ISO 5964:1985


Recommended action Withdraw


No



Yes


No



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-18 09:07



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 11:53

SCC (Canada) Recommended action Revise/Amend


No



Yes


No

Secretariat 2007-06-05 17:04

Page 5 of 7ISO 5964:1985




No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-11 13:16






P-Member 2007-06-15 12:03



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-04 10:03






P-Member 2007-06-07 10:36

Page 6 of 7ISO 5964:1985


UNI (Italy) Recommended action Abstain





P-Member 2007-06-14 12:18



Page 7 of 7ISO 5964:1985



Search > ISO 15706:2002


Download




English title Information and documentation -- International Standard Audiovisual Number (ISAN)

French title Information et documentation -- Numéro international normalisé d'oeuvre audiovisuelle (ISAN)



Status Closed



Note

Questions






Votes by members


Page 1 of 5ISO 15706:2002



& correct

Australia SA P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No




Colombia ICONTEC P-Member Abstain


Czech Republic



Estonia EVS O-Member Abstain


France AFNOR P-Member Valid X Yes Identical No No

Germany DIN P-Member Valid X No Yes No


Italy UNI P-Member Valid X No Yes No



Korea, Republic of


Norway SN P-Member Abstain

Poland PKN P-Member Abstain

No Yes No


Russian Federation


Page 2 of 5ISO 15706:2002


South Africa


Spain AENOR P-Member Valid X No Yes No




United Kingdom

BSI P-Member Valid X Yes Identical Yes No



5 Missing

0 0 15 0 8 Yes 8 No

8 Identical

0 Modified

14 Yes 2 No

0 Yes 16 No

TOTALS 23 Valid

0 0 15 0 8 Yes 8 No

8 Identical

0 Modified

14 Yes 2 No

0 Yes 16 No


15 x Confirm AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) DS (Denmark) JISC (Japan) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) UNI (Italy)

7 x Abstain DSSU (Ukraine) EVS (Estonia) ICONTEC (Colombia) MSZT (Hungary) SIS (Sweden) SN (Norway) SNV (Switzerland)

1 x Abstain with survey replies PKN (Poland)


0 x Revise/Amend

0 x Withdraw

Answers to Q.2: "Has this International Standard been adopted or is it intended to be adopted in the future

Page 3 of 5ISO 15706:2002


as a national standard or other publication?" (all votes)

8 x No AENOR (Spain) ANSI (USA) DIN (Germany) JISC (Japan) PKN (Poland) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) UNI (Italy)

8 x Yes AFNOR (France) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DS (Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa)


8 x Identical AFNOR (France) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DS (Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa)

0 x Modified


14 x Yes AENOR (Spain) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) DS (Denmark) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) UNI (Italy)

2 x No AFNOR (France) JISC (Japan)


16 x No AENOR (Spain) AFNOR (France) ANSI (USA) BDS (Bulgaria) BSI (United Kingdom) CNI (Czech Republic) DIN (Germany) DS (Denmark) JISC (Japan) KATS (Korea, Republic of) PKN (Poland) SA (Australia) SABS (South Africa) SCC (Canada) SFS (Finland) UNI (Italy)

0 x Yes


Comment(s) to Q.1:

EVS (Estonia) Estonia is not adopted this standard number system.


Page 4 of 5ISO 15706:2002


Comment(s) to Q.2:

AFNOR (France) NF/ISO 15706

BDS (Bulgaria) BDS plans to adopt it as a national standard.

BSI (United Kingdom) BS ISO 15706:2002




SA (Australia) AS/NZS ISO 15706:2004


Comment(s) to Q.3:

Comment(s) to Q.4:

AFNOR (France) National adoption

JISC (Japan) This standard is not referred in Japanese n ational standards.

Comment(s) to Q.5:

Comment file(s)




Page 5 of 5ISO 15706:2002



Search > ISO 15706:2002


Metadata



English title Information and documentation -- International Standard Audiovisual Number (ISAN)

French title Information et documentation -- Numéro international normalisé d'oeuvre audiovisuelle (ISAN)



Status Closed






No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-18 14:21



Yes

P-Member 2007-06-13 15:23

Page 1 of 7ISO 15706:2002



Identical


No


No

ANSI (USA) Recommended action Confirm


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 20:13



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-07 15:27

BSI (United Kingdom) Recommended action Confirm


Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-01 11:26



P-Member 2007-06-07 14:32

Page 2 of 7ISO 15706:2002




Identical


Yes


No

DIN (Germany) Recommended action Confirm


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-05 16:57



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-12 12:49






P-Member 2007-06-18 09:45

EVS (Estonia) Recommended action Abstain

O-Member 2007-06-17 15:32

Page 3 of 7ISO 15706:2002






ICONTEC (Colombia) Recommended action Abstain





P-Member 2007-06-15 22:54



No



No


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 07:06



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 07:00


Page 4 of 7ISO 15706:2002







PKN (Poland) Recommended action Abstain with survey replies


No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-13 11:14



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-18 09:13



Yes


Identical


Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-15 11:51

Page 5 of 7ISO 15706:2002




No



Yes


No

Secretariat 2007-06-05 17:07



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-11 13:13






P-Member 2007-06-15 12:04

SN (Norway) Recommended action Abstain





P-Member 2007-06-04 10:27

Page 6 of 7ISO 15706:2002







P-Member 2007-06-07 10:36



No



Yes


No

P-Member 2007-06-14 12:11



Page 7 of 7ISO 15706:2002


Documents

2007 Systematic review results (ISO 999; ISO 2788; ISO ... · Systematic review balloting Thacker, Jane M. Ms. Friday, 2007-07-13 Search > ISO 999:1996 Information Result Participation