Upload
arte
View
230
Download
6
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
2012 문화예술교육 효과분석 연구 예술꽃씨앗학교
Citation preview
2012
������ �� �
- ���� ���
2012
������ �� �
- ���� ���
���
�� �
���
2013.1 .
���
����� ���
�
� ����� � ��
� ���� �� �
� ��� ���
�
KACES-1 240-R028
ISBN
978-89-6748-01 3-4� 93370
�
Tel.� (02)6209-5900
Fax.� (02)6209-5999
E-mail.� [email protected]
www.arte.or.kr
ⓒ� #$% & '*+ ,*/ :;< =>? BD G HIJL
�? I MNOP.�
� � � #$% & Q UV � ����� ���; WXOP.
�
���
�������� � ��
「2012 ���� ���� ��–���� ��」
��� � �!"# $.
���
�����
� �Y Z,� [\� ]^ � _ �`
�����
��� ,J[\� b=[\� �]_�
������� ��� ��� �c& '*� ����� ���& & f_ bg J� h+ ` WXOP.
jp| i
��
Ⅰ. � � 1
1. �� %& 3
2. �� '() * +, 6
3. �� -/ 8
4. �� 57 9
Ⅱ. ���� ��� ���� � � ! 13
1. ����: : ; 15
2. ���� �� = >?: @(A �� 17
3. 2012C =D ���� ��: >? �� 20
4. ��) = E: FD G� H� @I 29
Ⅲ. ���� ��� ���� � �� 45
1. �J 47
2. � 94
3. = K>L 134
Ⅳ. $� % �& 169
1. MN 171
2. � O 176
'(�) 179
*+ 183
ii| 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<E Ⅰ -1> T> - / 8
<E Ⅱ-1> 2012C V WX 10@ ���� �� YZ 26
<E Ⅱ-2> ‘2011 ���� ��) �� – ���� �� [\ ]^’_�
�J _ `� ��) = E
32
<E Ⅱ-3> @aX �J : ��) b c de * �f �g 34
<E Ⅱ-4> �J : ��) hi �g 35
<E Ⅱ-5> ‘2011 ���� ��) �� – ���� �� [\ ]^’_�
�_ `� ��) = E
36
<E Ⅱ-6> �_ `� ��) = E_ jk �f �g 37
<E Ⅱ-7> �_ `� ��) = EA hi �g 39
<E Ⅱ-8> ‘2011 ���� ��) �� – ���� �� [\ ]^’_�
= K>L_ `� ��) = E
41
<E Ⅱ-9> @aX = K>L_ `� ��) =E_ jk �f �g 41
<E Ⅱ-10> @aX = K>L_ `� ��) b c de � hi �g 43
<E Ⅲ-1> �J Em : n) 47
<E Ⅲ-2> op �qr 48
<E Ⅲ-3> ‘st ���� �u_ Fqv w$.’ 49
<E Ⅲ-4> ‘���� xyz �{�| = }�$ ~ ��� � w$� J ��$.’ 50
<E Ⅲ-5> ‘st s_� ��� ��_ m [� � �$.’ 52
<E Ⅲ-6> ‘st s_� ��� ��� /� ha� $�$.’ 53
<E Ⅲ-7> ‘� q�]^t � `^ � � wt �v �$.’ 54
<E Ⅲ-8> ‘st s_� ��� �c �$.’ 55
<E Ⅲ-9> ‘st ��v�= o�v w$.’ 56
! ��
jp| iii
<E Ⅲ-10> ���� r�) 57
<E Ⅲ-11> ‘st ���� xy� �� ry� � ��$.’ 58
<E Ⅲ-12> ‘s_� ���� xyz [(�$.’ 60
<E Ⅲ-13> ‘���� xy� �� s: J xv �� ��$.’ 61
<E Ⅲ-14> ‘st >� � ���� xy_ `� vup � �v �t ¡v$.’ 62
<E Ⅲ-15> ‘st ���� xy_ `� = }�$ ~ ¢� £$.’ 63
<E Ⅲ-16> ‘st g¤ �����u ¥V ㆍ §�� �� £$.’ 64
<E Ⅲ-17> ‘st ����_ `� ¨\ v �$.’ 65
<E Ⅲ-18> ©: ) b c 66
<E Ⅲ-19> ‘st F ; wt J � � �v �$.’ 67
<E Ⅲ-20> ‘st ª ^« �� � J �� ¬$.’ 68
<E Ⅲ-21> ‘st ª ^« 5 ]^ �� � �M�t & ®c �$.’ 69
<E Ⅲ-22> ‘st ©:, v¯t ° ±� � �c �$.’ 70
<E Ⅲ-23> ‘st � c= � �| ²³ c= J � v ´ µk$.’ 71
<E Ⅲ-24> ‘¶� v �= ·t ª ^« J �� �t �v �¸ $.’ 72
<E Ⅲ-25> ‘ª ^« �� %®t �v �$.’ 73
<E Ⅲ-26> op T¹�(§» ) ) b c 74
<E Ⅲ-27> ‘st �c st ½v w~¯H ¾� � w$.’ 75
<E Ⅲ-28> ‘st �¿: À�vs ÁÂ� � vÃ Ä � w$.’ 75
<E Ⅲ-29> ‘ÅÆ�Ç H ÈÉ� �D V Ê � w$.’ 76
<E Ⅲ-30> ‘st ii ËÌc� �Í� £$.’ 76
<E Ⅲ-31> ‘st �c s� ÎÍ� =Ï� s �Oc� Ð�� £� �c w$.’ 77
<E Ⅲ-32> ‘st ¶�s e � � o� Ñ«$.’ 78
<E Ⅲ-33> ‘st Ò� �v �t ¡v$.’ 78
<E Ⅲ-34> op EY� IE� b c 80
<E Ⅲ-35> ‘st � J �� � Ó�t ¡v$.’ 81
<E Ⅲ-36> ‘�c �Ôt p �� $k >� v �t �v Õ$.’ 82
<E Ⅲ-37> ‘���� xy� �� s: p �vs J �� EY� � w$.’ 83
iv| 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<E Ⅲ-38> ‘$k ¶� Ö_� IE�t �v �¸ $.’ 84
<E Ⅲ-39> ‘st IE� � Ð׳Ø� ��$.’ 85
<E Ⅲ-40> ‘st aJ Ù v V Úp ¥_ ÛÛ^ IE� �c �$.’ 86
<E Ⅲ-41> ‘st � J �� � `^ EY�= Ü� �c �$.’ 87
<E Ⅲ-42> Ý y� >L) b c 88
<E Ⅲ-43> ‘st ¶� � � v��$.’ 89
<E Ⅲ-44> ‘st ¶� � >v�� = ¬$.’ 89
<E Ⅲ-45> ‘st ¶� � � HAÞ$.’ 89
<E Ⅲ-46> ‘st ¶� : Ó� � �Þ$.’ 90
<E Ⅲ-47> ‘st $k ¶�_�t ¨\ v �$.’ 90
<E Ⅲ-48> ‘st ß� f à� � c �$.’ 91
<E Ⅲ-49> ‘st � J �� á¯H ¥â ¶� : :ã� jk$.’ 91
<E Ⅲ-50> ä å) æ � 92
<E Ⅲ-51> > * ç>: Em n) 95
<E Ⅲ-52> �: ���� è& @a 95
<E Ⅲ-53> é, ㆍ å, oê ëì 96
<E Ⅲ-54> ‘®Í �t ����í^îï� «ð�tñ xò � � wt H�s
F óc �$.’
96
<E Ⅲ-55> ‘®Í �t ����í^îï� «ð � � wt V ô v �z
¡v$.’
97
<E Ⅲ-56> ‘®Í �_t ����� õö� � wt � v w$.’ 97
<E Ⅲ-57> ‘®Í �t ����� & ÷ � � wt p Lc �z ¡v$.’ 98
<E Ⅲ-58> p ¨ � >L oê e ) 98
<E Ⅲ-59> ‘®Í �t >A ç>: døv xI�$.’ 98
<E Ⅲ-60> ‘®Í �t �i y�Í xyv xI�$.’ 99
<E Ⅲ-61> ‘®Í �t >, �Ðd, �J , =K�úv ûü : ý�t ½v �$.’ 99
<E Ⅲ-62> �: `þ, ÿ��� e ) 100
<E Ⅲ-63> ‘®Í �t =K>L: ���� p ¨ㆍ �âA Ý �� �$.’ 100
jp| v
<E Ⅲ-64> ‘= K>Lt ®Í �: ���� �� >?� ¢� w$.’ 100
<E Ⅲ-65> ‘®Í �t =K>L: ���� �>_ ¾²�$.’ 101
<E Ⅲ-66> ‘®Í �A =K>Lt ���� ¨� D �� §Á�$.’ 102
<E Ⅲ-67> � �) : ����, K� �� 102
<E Ⅲ-68> ���� Á 103
<E Ⅲ-69> ‘®Í �t �����u ¥V L� �$.’ 104
<E Ⅲ-70> ‘®Í �t �����u §�� �$.’ 104
<E Ⅲ-71> ‘®Í �t ����v J x�� w$.’ 105
<E Ⅲ-72> ���� 105
<E Ⅲ-73> ‘®Í �t $�� ���� í^îï� «ð �$.’ 105
<E Ⅲ-74> ‘®Í � > z ����_ `� ¨\ � q�v w$.’ 106
<E Ⅲ-75> ‘®Í �t ����: x) �_ �z ��� p å$.’ 107
<E Ⅲ-76> ‘®Í �t Ë�s �p� �| ����� �� � w$.’ 107
<E Ⅲ-77> ���� ©W 107
<E Ⅲ-78> ‘®Í �: �����u ¥V t ¾��$.’ 108
<E Ⅲ-79> ‘®Í �: ���� §�z ¾��$.’ 108
<E Ⅲ-80> ‘®Í �t ª ^« ���� �u_ `� ¨\ v ��, � «ð_
�+��� ���$.’
109
<E Ⅲ-81> �: ¥�, � ¤ 110
<E Ⅲ-82> � �� «ð ��: ¿� 110
<E Ⅲ-83> ‘®Í �t $k �_ f � �� �D «ð 57v ��� X$.’ 111
<E Ⅲ-84> ‘®Í �: �� �D «ðz ��� ��st & ®c �$.’ 111
<E Ⅲ-85> ‘®Í �t ¥�, å 5 � $Ï� �� «ð ��� �«$.’ 111
<E Ⅲ-86> � �D : ¿� 112
<E Ⅲ-87> ‘®Í �: �D z $k �A �^ �vc �$.’ 113
<E Ⅲ-88> ‘®Í � �D z $k �_ f � ����: f [v �z
¡v$.’
114
<E Ⅲ-89> ‘®Í � �D z “���� �� >? ” V� v¥� $Ï$.’ 115
vi| 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<E Ⅲ-90> � «ð +E [æ >? ¿� 115
<E Ⅲ-91> ‘®Í �t �= � [\ ]^ «ð X$.’ 116
<E Ⅲ-92> ‘®Í �t ����� [\ ]^ «ðX$.’ 117
<E Ⅲ-93> ‘®Í �t �����u â÷ xyv �z ¡v$.’ 117
<E Ⅲ-94> � �� �M �� 118
<E Ⅲ-95> ‘®Í �t J x= Hc � Æ t ¡v$.’ 118
<E Ⅲ-96> ‘®Í � �J z ��c �$.’ 119
<E Ⅲ-97> ‘®Í � �J z Ò� �v �t ¡v$.’ 120
<E Ⅲ-98> ‘®Í � �J z o� $�v ��= t ¡v$.’ 120
<E Ⅲ-99> >: ¥�) ¤ 121
<E Ⅲ-100> ‘®Í � > z �J : �& � �t$.’ 122
<E Ⅲ-101> ‘®Í � > z $�� �7� >ò�$.’ 122
<E Ⅲ-102> ‘®Í � > z ��& ð� � �t ¡v$.’ 123
<E Ⅲ-103> ‘®Í � > z �����u �q�v ��s$.’ 123
<E Ⅲ-104> `þ , �� �� 124
<E Ⅲ-105> �_ `� `þ v; = @a 124
<E Ⅲ-106> ‘®Í �t �D X v; = c w$.’ 125
<E Ⅲ-107> ‘®Í �t �J �c æ æ � �v$.’ 125
<E Ⅲ-108> ‘����]^ ®Í �_ `� ª^« å� \� � w� �v$.’ 125
<E Ⅲ-109> ‘®Í �^ ¥� µ�t ¤õ >!c w$.’ 126
<E Ⅲ-110> �_ `� ¤/ �D p ¨: ¨\ � = 126
<E Ⅲ-111> ‘"vs = "_� ®Í �_ `� �z = � �$.’ 127
<E Ⅲ-112> ‘®Í = 5o#�â_� ®Í �_ ¨\ � = � � Þ$.’ 127
<E Ⅲ-113> ‘¤� p ¨ v ®Í �� ° ±�$.’ 128
<E Ⅲ-114> = K>L: ���� åí¯ xò 128
<E Ⅲ-115> = K p� V ô xò 129
<E Ⅲ-116> ‘®Í �t ����� ¨�� =K: V ô � xò�$.’ 129
<E Ⅲ-117> ‘®Í �t =K: = Í, ²$� ����_ � xò�$.’ 130
jp| vii
<E Ⅲ-118> ‘= K>Lc ����� ¨��² ®Í �� xò�$.’ 130
<E Ⅲ-119> = K ��: K>) � ¥�� �ð� ����W%©T 130
<E Ⅲ-120> ‘®Í �t =K��� ����_ � xò�$.’ 131
<E Ⅲ-121> ‘®Í �: ����z ®Í = K: ¥�� &Í�� ���$.’ 131
<E Ⅲ-122> ‘®Í �: ����_t = K: K>c õà w$.’ 132
<E Ⅲ-123> = K�ú Em n) 134
<E Ⅲ-124> = K: ���� è& @a 135
<E Ⅲ-125> é, ㆍ å, oê ëì 135
<E Ⅲ-126> ‘®Í = K_t ����� � � wt V ô v � � w$.’ 136
<E Ⅲ-127> ‘®Í = Kz ����_ xò� � wt H�s Fóc �$.’ 137
<E Ⅲ-128> ‘®Í = K_t ����� � cÏ'�t � v w$.’ 138
<E Ⅲ-129> ‘®Í = K_� ����� % � wt p Lc �z ¡v$.’ 139
<E Ⅲ-130> = K>L � >L oê e ) 139
<E Ⅲ-131> ‘®Í = K_� t = K�ú, �, §§p ¨, p ? (v ���� xy_
¨�� � ^ Ý �� � �$.’
140
<E Ⅲ-132> ‘®Í = K_t ����� ¨�X >� : døv xI�$.’ 141
<E Ⅲ-133> ‘®Í = K_� t ���� p ¨ㆍ �â v � ^ Ý �� ��$.’ 142
<E Ⅲ-134> ‘®Í = K_ wt �t = K>LA )�� ¨�� *� w$.’ 143
<E Ⅲ-135> ‘®Í = K: �t = K>L �>_ �v ¾²�$.’ 143
<E Ⅲ-136> = K�ú: ����, K� �� 144
<E Ⅲ-137> ���� Á 145
<E Ⅲ-138> ‘®Í = Kz �i ¥V Lc �v +,$.’ 146
<E Ⅲ-139> ‘®Í = Kz �i §�v �v +,$.’ 146
<E Ⅲ-140> ���� 147
<E Ⅲ-141> ‘®Í = K �ú z ����_ `� ¨\ � q�v �$.’ 147
<E Ⅲ-142> ‘®Í = Kz ����_ �z -o� �$.’ 148
<E Ⅲ-143> ���� ©W 149
<E Ⅲ-144> ‘®Í =K �ú z ��� ��s ���� W%� � �. pLc w$.’ 150
viii| 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<E Ⅲ-145> ‘®Í = Kz �ú v ��� �� s ���� W%� � � wH/
0��t �/p v$.’
150
<E Ⅲ-146> = K: è& @a 151
<E Ⅲ-147> éÍ, è& @a 152
<E Ⅲ-148> ‘®Í = Kz J x�tñ Å¡ûv �t V ô � 12� w$.’ 152
<E Ⅲ-149> ‘®Í = Kz ²³ c= V ô v w$.’ 153
<E Ⅲ-150> >L oê ¤ 153
<E Ⅲ-151> ‘®Í = K_� t = K�ú, �, §§p ¨, p ? v � ^ � Ý ��t
�/p v$.’
154
<E Ⅲ-152> ‘®Í = K_� t ²³ c= dø v xI�$.’ 155
<E Ⅲ-153> = K>L �� �M 155
<E Ⅲ-154> ‘®Í = K_� t >$·>�c �v ½�à$.’ 156
<E Ⅲ-155> ‘®Í = K_� t v3ÔÍ $-t & ®c �$.’ 157
<E Ⅲ-156> ‘���� xyz ®Í =K >� � �MV Ê �v$.’ 157
<E Ⅲ-157> = K>L `þ , �� 158
<E Ⅲ-158> ‘®Í = Kz æ æ �ú v ��$.’ 158
<E Ⅲ-159> ‘®Í = Kz &p �z 4v$.’ 159
<E Ⅲ-160> ‘®Í = Kv o5Û6$.’ 160
<E Ⅲ-161> = K: ���� åí¯ xò 161
<E Ⅲ-162> = K>L � ¥V �, §��, 7é¨, H� ¨ xò 161
<E Ⅲ-163> ‘®Í = K: ¥V �vs §��z vò8v �$.’ 162
<E Ⅲ-164> ‘®Í = K: 7é¨vs H� ¨ ( ��V ô z vò8v �$.’ 163
<E Ⅲ-165> = K>L � ��Á9-ô �, Á,= , >: , /å (-xò 164
<E Ⅲ-166> ‘®Í = K_� t = K: ��Á9� ����_ � xò�� w$.’ 165
<E Ⅲ-167> ‘����z ®Í = K>L I¥_ ;D , å ð� ; ¶$� J ��$.’ 166
jp| ix
<î< Ⅰ -1> ���� �� YZ(¥� 26@) 4
<î< Ⅰ -2> �g @I ¹� 10
<î< Ⅱ-1> ����: p ê, (Î 15
<î< Ⅱ-2> ; �: �� EÞ�D (NSAE): i= 30
<î< Ⅱ-3> ��) = E: �D 31
<î< Ⅲ-1> op �qr > 48
<î< Ⅲ-2> op �qr & � è& 48
<î< Ⅲ-3> �����u F q(�C) 49
<î< Ⅲ-4> �����u F q()� ) 49
<î< Ⅲ-5> �����u F q(>) 49
<î< Ⅲ-6> �����u F q(& � è& ) 49
<î< Ⅲ-7> ���� �{�| ��� � w$(�C) 51
<î< Ⅲ-8> ���� �{�| ��� � w$()� ) 51
<î< Ⅲ-9> ���� �{�| ��� � w$(>) 51
<î< Ⅲ-10> ���� �{�| ��� � w$(& � è& ) 51
<î< Ⅲ-11> �� m [ DH(�C) 52
<î< Ⅲ-12> �� m [ DH()� ) 52
<î< Ⅲ-13> �� m [ DH(>) 52
<î< Ⅲ-14> �� m [ DH(& � è& ) 52
<î< Ⅲ-15> ��� �� _ m [(�C) 53
<î< Ⅲ-16> � q�]^ � � wt �v �$(�C) 54
<î< Ⅲ-17> � q�]^ � � wt �v �$(>) 54
<î< Ⅲ-18> s_� � �� �c w$(�C) 55
,/ ��
x| 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<î< Ⅲ-19> o�r(�C) 56
<î< Ⅲ-20> o�r()� ) 56
<î< Ⅲ-21> o�r(>) 56
<î< Ⅲ-22> o�r(& � è& ) 56
<î< Ⅲ-23> ���� r�) (�C) 57
<î< Ⅲ-24> ���� r�) ()� ) 57
<î< Ⅲ-25> ���� r�) (& � è& ) 58
<î< Ⅲ-26> ����� �� ry(�C) 59
<î< Ⅲ-27> ����� �� ry()� ) 59
<î< Ⅲ-28> ����� �� ry(& � è& ) 59
<î< Ⅲ-29> ���� xy [(H(�C) 60
<î< Ⅲ-30> ���� xy [(H()� ) 60
<î< Ⅲ-31> ���� xy [(H(& � è& ) 60
<î< Ⅲ-32> ����� �� J x: �� �> (�C) 61
<î< Ⅲ-33> ����� �� J x: �� �> ()� ) 61
<î< Ⅲ-34> ����� �� J x: �� �> (& �¤Z) 62
<î< Ⅲ-35> ����_ `� ~ ¢� £$(�C) 63
<î< Ⅲ-36> ����_ `� ~ ¢� £$()� ) 63
<î< Ⅲ-37> ����_ `� ~ ¢� £$(& �è& ) 63
<î< Ⅲ-38> �����u ¥V ㆍ §� ¨\ (�C) 64
<î< Ⅲ-39> �����u ¥V ㆍ §� ¨\ ()� ) 64
<î< Ⅲ-40> �����u ¥V ㆍ §� ¨\ (& � è& ) 65
<î< Ⅲ-41> ����_ `� ¨\ (�C) 66
<î< Ⅲ-42> ����_ `� ¨\ ()� ) 66
<î< Ⅲ-43> ����_ `� ¨\ (& � è& ) 66
<î< Ⅲ-44> ©:) (�C) 67
<î< Ⅲ-45> ©:) (& � è& ) 67
<î< Ⅲ-46> F ; wt J �(�C) 68
jp| xi
<î< Ⅲ-47> ª ^« J �(�C) 69
<î< Ⅲ-48> ª ^« J �()� ) 69
<î< Ⅲ-49> ª ^« 5 ]^ �� �M()� ) 69
<î< Ⅲ-50> ©:, (�C) 70
<î< Ⅲ-51> ©:, (& � è& ) 70
<î< Ⅲ-52> � c= � �| ²³ c= � J ��$(& � è& ) 71
<î< Ⅲ-53> ª ^« J ��t �� Ø(�C) 72
<î< Ⅲ-54> ª ^« � %®t �� Ø(�C) 73
<î< Ⅲ-55> op T¹�ㆍ §» �(�C) 74
<î< Ⅲ-56> op T¹�ㆍ §» �(& � è& ) 74
<î< Ⅲ-57> �¿: À�vs Á ?@(& � è& ) 75
<î< Ⅲ-58> Bå �B(�C) 76
<î< Ⅲ-59> �c s ÎÍ� = Ï� s é$CD(�C) 77
<î< Ⅲ-60> Òô >ò DH(�C) 79
<î< Ⅲ-61> Òô >ò DH()� ) 79
<î< Ⅲ-62> Òô >ò DH(>) 79
<î< Ⅲ-63> Òô >ò DH(& � è& ) 79
<î< Ⅲ-64> op EY� IE� b c(�C) 80
<î< Ⅲ-65> op EY� IE� b c(>) 80
<î< Ⅲ-66> op EY� IE� b c(& �è& ) 80
<î< Ⅲ-67> � J �� EY(�C) 81
<î< Ⅲ-68> � J �� EY(& � è& ) 81
<î< Ⅲ-69> Båv � J �� �t �v Õ$(& � è& ) 82
<î< Ⅲ-70> ����� �� s: p � EY(�C) 83
<î< Ⅲ-71> ����� �� s: p � EY(& � è& ) 83
<î< Ⅲ-72> Bå Ö_� IE�t �� Ø(�C) 84
<î< Ⅲ-73> Bå Ö_� IE�t �� Ø(& �è& ) 84
<î< Ⅲ-74> IE� � Ð×F�G (& � è& ) 85
xii| 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<î< Ⅲ-75> ÛÛ^ IE(�C) 86
<î< Ⅲ-76> � J �EY Üû(�C) 87
<î< Ⅲ-77> � J �EY Üû(>) 87
<î< Ⅲ-78> � J �EY Üû(& � è& ) 87
<î< Ⅲ-79> Ý y� >L) (�C) 88
<î< Ⅲ-80> Ý y� >L) (>) 88
<î< Ⅲ-81> äå) æ �(�C) 92
<î< Ⅲ-82> äå) æ �(>) 92
<î< Ⅲ-83> äå) æ �(& � è& ) 92
<î< Ⅲ-84> é, ㆍ å, oê ëì(����) 96
<î< Ⅲ-85> = K>Lc ���>?� Æ$(¥§) 101
<î< Ⅲ-86> �c = K>L: �����>_ ¾²(¥§) 101
<î< Ⅲ-87> �A = K>L ���� D � §Á(¥§) 102
<î< Ⅲ-88> ���� Á(¥§) 103
<î< Ⅲ-89> �c �����u §�(¥§) 104
<î< Ⅲ-90> >: ���� ¨\ (& �) 106
<î< Ⅲ-91> �: ���� §� ¾�(& �) 109
<î< Ⅲ-92> �: ���� §� ¾�(¥§) 109
<î< Ⅲ-93> �: ª ^« ���� ¨\ (¥§) 109
<î< Ⅲ-94> � �D: ¿�(¥§) 112
<î< Ⅲ-95> $k �A �D �v(& �) 113
<î< Ⅲ-96> ���� f [(����) 114
<î< Ⅲ-97> ���� f [(¥§) 114
<î< Ⅲ-98> ��� vH �D ¿�(& �) 115
<î< Ⅲ-99> ��� vH �D ¿�(¥§) 115
<î< Ⅲ-100> � [æ >? ¿�(����) 116
<î< Ⅲ-101> � [æ >? ¿�(¥§) 116
<î< Ⅲ-102> ���� [æ (����) 117
jp| xiii
<î< Ⅲ-103> �����u â÷ xy(����) 118
<î< Ⅲ-104> �����u â÷ xy(¥§) 118
<î< Ⅲ-105> �J z ��c �$(& � ) 119
<î< Ⅲ-106> >: ¥�) ¤(& �) 121
<î< Ⅲ-107> >t �& � �t$(& � ) 122
<î< Ⅲ-108> >: ��& ð(& �) 123
<î< Ⅲ-109> " /= "_� = (¥§) 127
<î< Ⅲ-110> = K���� è& @a(����) 135
<î< Ⅲ-111> é, ㆍ å, oê ëì(����) 136
<î< Ⅲ-112> = K: ����V ô (����) 136
<î< Ⅲ-113> ���� F ó * H�(����) 137
<î< Ⅲ-114> = K: ����(����) 138
<î< Ⅲ-115> ���� p L(����) 139
<î< Ⅲ-116> ���� p L(� �p�) 139
<î< Ⅲ-117> >L oê e ) (����) 140
<î< Ⅲ-118> ���� xy Ý �(����) 140
<î< Ⅲ-119> ���� dø(����) 141
<î< Ⅲ-120> ���� dø(� �p� ) 141
<î< Ⅲ-121> ���� p ¨ Ý �(����) 142
<î< Ⅲ-122> �A = K>L: ¨� (����) 143
<î< Ⅲ-123> �c = K>L �>¾²(����) 144
<î< Ⅲ-124> ����, K� ��(����) 144
<î< Ⅲ-125> ���� Á(����) 145
<î< Ⅲ-126> ���� (����) 147
<î< Ⅲ-127> ���� ¨\ (����) 148
<î< Ⅲ-128> ���� -o(����) 148
<î< Ⅲ-129> ���� ©W(����) 149
<î< Ⅲ-130> ���� W% � p L(����) 150
xiv| 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<î< Ⅲ-131> ���� 0� �/p (����) 151
<î< Ⅲ-132> = K: è& @a(� �p� ) 151
<î< Ⅲ-133> >L oê ¤(� �p�) 153
<î< Ⅲ-134> = K�ú, �, §§p ¨, p ? Ý � �/p (� �p�) 154
<î< Ⅲ-135> ²³ dø xI D H(� �p� ) 155
<î< Ⅲ-136> >$>� D H(����) 156
<î< Ⅲ-137> >$>� D H(& � ) 156
<î< Ⅲ-138> ���� = K�ú �M HØ(& � ) 157
<î< Ⅲ-139> �ú � rÎ(J?) 159
<î< Ⅲ-140> �ú � rÎ(����) 159
<î< Ⅲ-141> � �§�]^� : �KH(J?) 159
<î< Ⅲ-142> = Kv o5Û6$(J?) 160
<î< Ⅲ-143> ���� åí¯ xò(J?) 161
<î< Ⅲ-144> ���� åí¯ xò(����) 161
<î< Ⅲ-145> ¥V �, §��, 7é¨, H� ¨ xò(����) 162
<î< Ⅲ-146> ¥V �vs §�� vò8(J?) 163
<î< Ⅲ-147> ¥V �vs §�� vò8(����) 163
<î< Ⅲ-148> ��V ô vò8(����) 163
<î< Ⅲ-149> = K>L � ��Á9xò(J?) 164
<î< Ⅲ-150> = K>L � ��Á9xò(����) 164
<î< Ⅲ-151> = K>L � ��Á9xò(& � ) 165
<î< Ⅲ-152> = K: ��Á9 xò(J?) 166
<î< Ⅲ-153> = K: ��Á9 xò(����) 166
<î< Ⅲ-154> = K>L: ;D , ð(����) 167
<î< Ⅲ-155> = K>L: ;D , ð(& � ) 167
|}| xv
78
1. � :7� % �;
1) �= :7�
◦ �������� z ‘2011 ���� ��) �� - ���� ��� [\ ]^’�
���² ������ = >?: ���� ��) =E� @I��, î ��� �� �
M w]s $� Oz ��: '() v �pP
◦ ��) = E_� �/ ðK: [@�� �M
• �J ðK_� å) , ðK� ����, ðK� ���² �� � M� �â, �� z cq
�s ¤Q[@, å �òv ��� v� �"� '(c IJ û
◦ ¤`, ]^ R�X å) , ��_ `� �Tv '(
• ���� ���� _� ������ = >?v hU IJ� �V� (: ���
�M� � wt ;D, ��c �v IãP_ j¯ v� ��) =E_ �T� '(c wÉ
◦ �A = K>L: ¿�_ `� W¨e b c�g @I '(
• �A = K>L: ¿�� XY�p /� |�T>� � V � M , ê >?: ��� =Z,
]^ [D �� W¨, �� � / �� t W¨e b c�g]^ @I� '(c wÉ
2) �= �;
◦ ê ��t 2011C @IX ���� ��) = E� @a��, v� �� � W¨e b c
�g� @I�² 2012C �\ ���� ��: ���� ��) � oâ , ]^ �� �
� wt H�� � §�tñ +, v wÉ
◦ ��) = E: @a
• �J ðK_� å) � ����) ðK� �"�² p� = E: [@�� � �M��, >L
, ]^ �� c � w�, ������c �ð] � wt �V�¨� ðK� �H^
�Í�² �/ ðK]^ �) û
xvi| 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
◦ �A = K>L: ¿�_ `� W¨e b c�g @I
• �A = K>L: ¿�� =Z, ]^ f �� �p /� W¨, å b c�g� @I�²
� §û
2. � >? % @A
1) � >?
◦ ê ��t ‘2011 ���� ��) �� – ���� �� [\ ]^’_� @IX ��)
= E� �D �T��, v_ j¯ b c�g� �D * @I�² 2012C �\^ aDX 1C�
10@ ^(�: =à 1C� >? ��� T>��o û. �â , å T> `¤z �J , �,
= K>L: ¿�ø
◦ ��) �� � /� H�t �J , �, =K>L ( �� `¤_ j¯ $_ . ‘2011 ����
��) �� – ������ [\]^’: &® �J: &®� ô�=� vò� ��)
[D� �`]a , �A =K�ú: &® |�� �� T>^ ��) �� � �`É
◦ ‘2012C ���� �� ��) �� ��’_� t �J , �, = K�ú db$ ô �= �
vò� ��) � �� û. v_ �J , �, = K�ú� ��`¤]^ � ��) = EA �g
� �D�� @Iû
◦ �J
• �DX b c�g]^ 10@ �\ ���� �� ^(� 3, 4, 5, 6�C `¤]^ 9c_
T>� �V ��, î oó� b c �g: BöHA �dH� e��tñ xò�² �D X
hi b c�g� MD û
• �J : &® ��) =Ec å) � ��) v �"� ‘op �qr’, ‘���� r�) ’, ‘©
:) ’, ‘op T¹�(§» ) )’, ‘op EY� IE�’, ‘Ý y� >L) ’ ( 6@ ðK]^ �Dû
• v H�� 2012C >?ió V æ _ T>�² �� �� : oó^ xòû
◦ �
• @I� b c�g]^ 10@ �\ ���� �� > * ç>� `¤]^ 9c_ T>��,
î oó� b c �g: BöHA �dH� e��tñ xò�² �D X hi b c�g�
MDû
|}| xvii
• �: & ® ‘�: ���� è& @ a’, ‘� �) : ����, K� ��’, ‘�:
¥�, � ¤’, ‘`þ , �� ��’, ‘= K>L: ���� åí¯ xò’ ( 5@ ðK
: b c�g]^ @Iû
• v H�� 2012C >?ió V æ _ T>�² �� �� : oó^ xòû
◦ = K>L
• @I� bc�g]^ 10@ �\ ������ =K �ú� `¤]^ 9c_ T>��, î
oó� bc �g: BöHA �dH� e��tñ xò�² �DX hi bc�g� MDû
• = K>L: & ® ‘= K: ���� è& @a’, ‘= K�ú: ����, K� ��’, ‘=K:
è& @a ’, ‘=K: ���� åí¯ xò’ ( 4@ ðK: b c�g]^ @Iû
• v H�� 2012C >?ió V æ _ T>�² �� �� : oó^ xòû
2) � @A
◦ a��� * ¨� �foó ( p^oó: T> * ��
• ���� ¨� Dg ����� , �� ý�, ¨� �; s IEoó ( T>
• nh �������� _� ���`i ���� >? b c * ��) _ ¨�
��� � m [ ��
◦ �þ : ���� ¨� p ¨: �f * �� ��� T>
◦ ���� �� >?�� * «ð��� ( ¨� oó� �m �² ��
◦ �������� ( >? �¨ p ¨: ¨�oA |õ� �� >?: 5) * �ò�
n) � Cj
◦ ‘���� �� = >?’� V��`� s V��� wt �_ 5�� ¨�oA |õ
◦ >?� ��ki > � ��l� m`^ p^ oó: YZ * �ò� n) � ��
◦ T> `¤ aD
• T> `¤z 20112C �\ = D ���� �� �J , > * ç>, îÍ � = K�úø
xviii| 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
~] [�
c s [ �
\� 201 2� � � � � �vy z\� 1 0�� 3,� 4,� 5,� 6\� �`~]
\� 201 2� � � � � �vy z\� 1 0�� �] � �] ��
� �]^ 201 2� � � � � �vy z\� 1 0�� ��� �� 10H '�
◦ ��) b c �g @I * e>
• ��) b c H�: W¨,va ��, å M� �� � /�� �f��, a���: xò,
¨�o |� , ��, e� , ¥�c o� (: 57� �� $É� Oz ¹�^ @Iû
� � � c ' *
�_Y � � � cY ��� & cY ��_ �_Y �� �� $�,�
�vy z\�& j� _ ����+ �� �| |� su
⇩
��� �� �� cY ��_ �� I¡& ¢£ ��+ `¤J$ ¥G
¦§JL ��
⇩
1p ¨©ª«£ ¦¬ �c � ��®(�` � �])& ^ & � �+ �� �
��& � ¯Y ¦¬
⇩
°b± ²³´ ��; [� °b± ²³´µ su
(OO� � � ·¸\� 4,� 5,� 6\� 6� \¹ [�)�
⇩
2p ¨©ª«£ ¦¬ �c � °b± ²³´ ºL �]µ »& G ��
� ��& �¯Y ¦¬
⇩
¼�~] ½? � � 10� �vy z\� 3,� 4,� 5,� 6� \� [�¾� ~] ½ ?
⇩
� ¿ £ ¦¬ �¿ £ su
⇩
À Á  ® �� Ã� �vy z\� ºL �]µ Ä ÅÆ+ �� ��³ÅÇ È
À Á �� Ã�
|}| xix
3. ���� ��� ���� � �!
◦ ê ��t ‘2011 ���� ��) �� – ���� �� [\ ]^’_� @IX ��)
= E� �T�� b c�g� @I�² 2012C �\ ���� �� ��) �� _ >ò]
��) = E� �D �`É
◦ v =E_ U� �² �J , �, = K>L: ��) e> H�� @Iû
4. ���� ��� ���� � ��
◦ �D * @I� H�^ 2012C �\ ���� �� 10@ ^(�: 3, 4, 5, 6�C ¥â
A �ö �: > * ç>, îÍ � = K�ú_ `� T>� � V �`É
1) �B
◦ �J � `¤]^ � ��) e>: äæ z bn 3.81^ sBß. `â^ o�C]^ ��p�
/ , cDè&v ���/ , îÍ� >� �z �J v ;D,]^ qrû
xx| 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
◦ op �qr: bn æ �t 3.69^ sBß
• >� �t �J (3.73)½�/ , & � è& (¤ : 3.92, [ : 3.92, �: 3.42)v ���/ , o
p �qrv �tÉ. ����v �J : o�r� �²�u�, v�z ½�, å o�
r]^ ë�] cq) � �²v
<�Ê>� I �ÌÍ ]� <�Ê>� I �ÌÍ ZÎ ÏZ
◦ ���� r�) : bn æ �t 3.71^ sBß
• `Ð�: �g_� o�C½�/ , ²�J ½�/ , & � è& v ���/ ¤`, ]^ �z æ
�� �ø. �g� �� � �| ���� xyv �J � �¸ � ��, �J v ����
xy_ `� ~ ¢� £� �a & ÷ �� £� �=� �J ����_ `� vup � �
v sw DHt �x �]^ sBs V W��ø� ¢ � wÉ
<�Ê>� � � Í`Y (\�) <�Ê>� �� Í`Y (ZÎ ÏZ)
◦ ©: ) : bn æ �t 3.69^ sBß
• o�C½�/ , & �è& (¤ : 4.07, [ : 3.77, �: 3.67)v ���/ �� sBß. �J z
©:,å xy� ���=� �¿_� îy »�� �t ½z �= ·$t �� . � wÉ
|}| xxi
<�Ê>� Ð& Y (\�) <�Ê>� Ð& Y (ZÎ ÏZ)
◦ op T¹�: bn æ �t 3.55^ sBß
• o�C(3�C : 3.70, 4�C : 3.59, 5�C : 3.54, 6�C : 3.42)]^ ��p�/ , & � è& (¤ :
3.78, [ : 3.55, �: 3.35)v ���/ op T¹�v �É
<�Ê>� I ~¯Ñ·ÓÔÑ(\�) <�Ê>� I ~¯Ñ·ÓÔÑ(ZÎ ÏZ)
◦ op EY�� IE�: bn æ �t 3.69^ sBß
• �C(3: 3.42, 4: 3.26, 5 : 3.24, 6: 3.19)v ��p�/ , & � è& (¤ : 4.03, [ : 3.65, �:
3.21)v ���/ ;D , å zH� �ø. >� �z �J (3.30)v >� �= ·z
�J(3.17)�$ ;D , ]^ qrû
<�Ê>� I�ÕÑ ��Ñ Â ®(\�) <�Ê>� I�ÕÑ ��Ñ Â ®(]� )
xxii| 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
◦ Ý y� >L) : bn æ �t 3.79^ sBß
• 3�C(3.90)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , >� �t �J (3.81)v >� �=
·t �J (3.70)_ f � ;D , å zH� �ø
<�Ê>� » Ö_ ]^ Y (\�) <�Ê>� » Ö_ ]^ Y (]� )
2) ��
◦ �: ���� è& @a ðK_� ¥â bn æ�t 4.14^ f , ;D , ]^ sB{]a
¿å�^ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·É
• �/ ðK� æ �� �| ‘é, ㆍ å, oê ëì’z 4.23: �z æ �� �`� � ¥
§(4.41)v ��� ¥§(3.97)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]^ qrû. �g [_ ‘®Í �t
����� & ÷ � � wt p Lc �z ¡v$.’_� qro: 87.7%c ;D, å z
H� �`]a , bn 4.34: �z æ �� �² ���� �� = >?v ;D , b c�
�t �� ¢ � wÉ
• ‘p ¨ � >L oê e ) ’H bn 4.05: �z æ �� �`tñ vt �) �: xI�
¨�c e )uÉ� �²v
• ‘�: `þ, ÿ��� e ) ’: bn æ �t 4.05va , = K>Lc ���� �� = >
?� ¢� w]a , ����D �� §Á��, �c =K>L: �>_ ,?,]^ ¾²�t
�]^ sBß
�� J× �� Ø Â Ù Ú `(5.00ÛÚ )
��
ÏZ
�Ü
Ý� ㆍ ,� � Ãß 4.23
I� ' ]^ � àY 4.05
\�& [� � á´Ä Å à Y 4.05
��  ٠Ú` 4.1 4
|}| xxiii
◦ � �) : ����, K� ��: ¥â bn æ �t 4.33^ �� sBß
• �/ ðK� æ �� �| ‘���� Á’_ ¨�� t bn 4.36: �z æ �� �`]a
¿å�^t � ¥§(4.47)v ��� ¥§(4.20)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b cû. �
g�^ �| ����: ¥V * §�, îÍ� ����v J x�� w$� qrû
• ‘���� ’: bn æ �H 4.50]^ �� sB{]a , �g�^ �| $�� ����
í^îï� x) �_ `� ��_ �z æ �� �u�, nh ‘®Í �t Ë�s �
p� �| ����� �� � w$.’_ qro: 93.9%c ;D , å zH� �`]a ,
bn 4.48: �z æ �� �² ���� ��c ����: p L � §_ p ²�� w
É� �ø
• ‘���� ©W’: bn æ �t bn 4.26]^ sBß.
�� J× ��Ø Â Ù Ú `(5.00ÛÚ )
\�
cY � &
� ��
�⠬�
� � ãä 4.36
��� & åY 4.50
� � ÐU 4.26
��  ٠Ú` 4.33
◦ �: ¥�, � ¤: bn æ �t 3.96]^ sBß
• �/ ðK� æ �� �| ‘� �� «ð ��: ¿�’: bn æ �t 3.78^ sB{�,
�g�^ �| ‘®Í �t $k �_ f � �� �D «ð 57v ��� X$.’_
bn 4.38: �z æ �� �å �| ‘®Í �: �� �D «ðz ��� ��st
& ®c �$.’_ bn 3.06: æ �� �² �D z ���u=� ���D «ð
��: ½¨) z $Î }�= t �]^ sBß
• ‘� �D : ¿�’: bn æ �t 4.07^ �z æ �� �ø. � ¥§(4.27)v ��
� ¥§(3.76)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b cû. �g�^ �| ‘®Í � �Dz $
k �_ f� ����v f[v �z ¡v$.’_ qro: 95.4%c ;D ,å zH
� �`]a , bn 4.51: $Î �z æ �� �ø. ‘� «ð +E [æ >? ¿�’: bn
æ �t 3.86: æ �� �ø. �g�^ �| ‘®Í �t ����� [\ ]^ «ðX
$.’_ `� qro: 87.7%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.14: �z æ �� �ø.
~� ‘®Í �t �����u â ÷ xyv �z ¡v$.’_ 95.4%c ;D, å zH� �
`]a , bn 4.48: æ �� �`$. ‘� �� �M ��’t 4.03: �z æ �� �ø
• ‘>: ¥�) ¤’z 4.08: æ �� �ø. & � 20C v�(4.29)c c� ;D, ]^ qr
�`]a , $É]^ 10C v�(4.20): �]^ sBß
xxiv| 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
�� J× ��Ø Â Ù Ú `(5.00ÛÚ )
\�&
�=�
� Ñ
ã�
�� ãä 4.36
\� �æ
ç� �è& �
é
��Ø
3.78
�� Ú`
êë \�< Pì \�; ��
�æ � _� ç� íî¥
pØ P
4.38
êë \�& �æ � _�
ç�� �è + ïðñ< Zê® òP 3.06
\�
� _� &
é
��Ø
4.07
�� Ú`
êë \� � _� � Pì \�;
�� ��� ¥ �ó¥ ô�
õ ¥P
4.51
\� ç�
j� óÚ
]ö é
��Ø
3.86
�� Ú`
êë \�< � �� +
ó÷ ¾� ç� P 4.14
êë \�< ��sø
�ù åÖ¥ ò� õ ¥P 4.48
�' �Î � ú �_ 4.03
�]&
��Y ã�
��Ø
4.08�� Ú`
êë \� �]û� Pü� �`î+
]*�P 4.17
��  ٠Ú` 3.96
◦ `þ , �� ��: bn æ �t 3.78^ sBß
• �/ ðK�^ �| ‘�_ `� `þ v;= @a’z 3.82: bn æ �� �ø. �g�^
�| ‘����]^ ®Í �_ `� ª ^« å � \ � � w� �v$.’c 4.44
: �z æ �� �`�, ‘®Í �^ ¥� µ�t ¤õ >!c w$.’_ 4.10: æ �� �
² �: v; = @a_ ��c wÉ� �²v
• ‘�_ `� ¤/ �D p¨: ¨\� = ’z 3.95: æ �� �ø. �g�^ �| ‘¤
� p ¨ v ®Í �� ° ±�$.’_ 4.25: �z æ �� �`É. � ¤/ �D p
¨: = = � �� wÉ� . � wÉ
|}| xxv
�� J× ��Ø Â Ù Ú `(5.00ÛÚ )
[� �
�_
¬�
\�; [�
[� ¥ý�
�Ü
��Ø
3.82
�� Ú `
��� ¾� êë \�; [�
þ�ç ,ÿ + ÷ ð� ` W+
�¥P
4.44
êë \�� �\ ��< ��
]�® WP 4.10
\�; [�
�× �
�� I�&
�÷_ ��
��Ø
3.95�� Ú `
�¹ I�û¥ êë \�G �P 4.25
�� Â Ù Ú ` 3.78
◦ = K>L: ���� åí¯ xò: bn æ �t 4.11^ sBß
• ‘= K p� V ô xò’z 4.13: æ �� �`�, ‘= K ��: K>) � ¥�� �ð� ��
��W%©T’t 4.10: æ �� �ø
3) �C DE
◦ = K: ���� è& @a: bn æ �t 3.03va , ����� �p t =K�ú(3.24)v
����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.67)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b cû
• ‘é, ·å, oê ëì’: bn æ �t 3.27^ sB{]a , �g�^ �| ‘®Í =K_t �
���� � � wt V ô v � � w$.’: bn æ �c 2.84, ‘®Í =K_t ����
� � cÏ'�t � v w$.’c 2.89^ ¤`, ]^ �z æ �� �² ����� � �
wt é, ·å, oêv ì��= ·É� �²v
• ‘=K>L � >L oê e ) ’: bn æ�t 3.00: æ�� �`]a , ����� �p t =
K�ú(3.23)v ����� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.61)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D,]^ bcû
• ‘`þ, ÿ��� e ) ’: bn æ �t 3.45^ sB{]a , �g�^ �| ‘®Í = K_� t
���� p ¨ㆍ �â v � ^ Ý �� ��$.’_ 2.99: ¤`, ]^ �z æ �� �² �
Jz `þ , ÿ���c � e )� wÉ� �²v
xxvi| 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
�� J× �� Ø Â Ù Ú `(5.00ÛÚ )
� �&
��
ÏZ �Ü
Ý� ·,�
� Ãß
��Ø
3.27
�� Ú `
êë � �;< ��+ / `
W< ? ¼¥ ��ð WP 2.84
êë � �;< ��+ �
® ��< sû¥ WP 2.89
��]^ ' ]^ � àY 3.00
[� �
á´Ä Å
à Y
��Ø
3.45
�� Ú `
êë � �;% < � �
I�ㆍ ��û¥ % � » Ñ+ ��P2.99
��  ٠Ú` 3.03
◦ = K: ����, K� ��: bn æ �t 2.79^ ¤`, ]^ �� sB{]a , ¿å�^
t ����� �p t = K�ú(3.00)v ����� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.44)�$ ¤`,
]^ ;D , ]^ b cû
• ‘���� Á’t 2.73, ‘���� ’z 2.85, ‘���� ©T’t 2.85: æ �� �`]
a , `â^ ����� �p t =K�úv ����� �p = ·t = K�ú�$ ¤`, ]
^ ;D , ]^ b cû
◦ = K: è& @a_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.33]^ sB{]a . 16C v¤ � �� = K�
ú(3.54)v 15C v� � �� = K�ú(3.25)A 5C v� � �� =K�ú(3.21)�$ ¤`,
]^ ;D, ]^ b cû. �/ ðK�^ �| ‘éÍ, è& @ a’: bn æ �t 3.54, ‘>L
oê ¤’_t 3.05: æ �� �ø. nh 16C v¤ � �� = K�ú(3.44)v 15C v� �
�� = K�ú(2.93)� 5C v� � �� = K�ú(2.82)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b cû
• ‘= K>L �� �M ’: bn æ �t 3.84^ f , �� sB{]a , ‘`þ, ��’t bn
3.45: æ �� �ø
�� J× ��Ø Â Ù Ú `(5.00ÛÚ )
� �&
ÏZ �Ü
Ýë� ÏZ �Ü 3.54
]^ � ã� 3.05
� �]^ �Î �ú 3.84
[� � �_ 3.45
�� Â Ù Ú ` 3.33
|}| xxvii
◦ =K: ���� åí¯ xò_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.23]^ sB{]a , ����� �
p t = K�ú(3.37)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.96)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^
b cû
• �/ ðK�^ �| ‘= K>L � ¥V �, §��, 7é¨, H� ¨ xò’: bn æ �c
2.96]^ ��: zH� �`=� ‘= K>L � ��Á9-ô �, Á, = , >: , /å (-x
ò’: bn æ �c 3.52^ �� v¤: zH� �ø. �g�^ �| ‘����z ®Í = K
>L I¥_ ;D , å ð� ; ¶$� J ��$.’c 3.93: �z æ �� �ø
�� J× �� Ø Â Ù Ú `(5.00ÛÚ )
� �&
��
,��
å*
� �]^ ' �?�,� Ó��,� �Ý�,� £% � å* 2.96
� �]^ ' �ä�
-¼,� ä� � ,� ]�,� × , ¸-å* 3.52
��� êë � �]^ ��; �� � , �ã+ ý�P$
���P 3.93
��  ٠Ú` 3.23
5) $� % �&
◦ �J
• �J � `¤]^ � ��) e>: äæ z bn 3.81^ sBß. `â^ o�C]^ ��p
�/ , cDè&v ���/ , îÍ� >� �z �J v ;D,]^ qrû
• ��) e>_� ����_ `� ;D , å zHA p `r� �²�u=� , >�
�� s & � è& v �z �J : æ �c �z �z ‘���� �� = >?’ � � vp
��_ ì�� ���� ��c sBs= ·tp ��]^ �ø
• op �qr: bnæ �t 3.69^ sBß
• ���� r�) : bnæ �t 3.71^ sBß
• ©:) : bn æ �t 3.69^ sBß
• op T¹�: bn æ �t 3.55^ sBß
• op EY�� IE�: bn æ �t 3.69^ sBß
• Ý y� >L) : bn æ �t 3.79^ sBß
xxviii| 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
◦ �
• �: ���� è& @a ðK_� ¥â bn æ�t 4.14^ f , ;D , ]^ sB{]a
¿å�^ ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·É
• � �) : ����, K� ��: ¥â bn æ �t 4.33]^ �� sBß
• �: ¥�, � ¤: bn æ �t 3.96]^ sBß
• `þ, �� ��: bn æ �t 3.78^ sBß
• = K>L: ���� åí¯ xò: bn æ �t 4.11^ sBß
◦ = K>L
• = K: ���� è& @a: bn æ �t 3.03va , ����� �p t =K�ú(3.24)v
����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.67)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b cû
• = K: ����, K� ��: bn æ �t 2.79^ ¤`, ]^ �� sB{]a , ¿å�^
t ����� �p t = K�ú(3.00)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.44)�$ ¤`
, ]^ ;D ,]^ b cû
• = K: è& @a_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.33]^ sB{]a . 16C v¤ � �� =K�
ú(3.54)v 15C v� � �� =K�ú(3.25)A 5C v� � �� = K�ú(3.21)�$ ¤`,
]^ ;D ,]^ bcû. �/ ðK�^ �| ‘éÍ, è& @a’: bn æ�t 3.54, ‘>L
oê ¤’_t 3.05: æ �� �ø. nh 16C v¤ � �� = K�ú(3.44)v 15C v� �
�� =K�ú(2.93)A 5C v� � �� =K�ú(2.82)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D, ]^ bcû
◦ ê ���D � �� M�� �� � c= � O� �| $É� OÉ
◦ ô �T>A |�T>� ��� '(c wÉ
• ô �T>t W¨ �g]^ �)� wp ��_ W¨, å f � � � wt �, oó
: �æ � c= � wÉ. î³s W¨ �g]^ ��Ä � �t �� � ¢��t ñ t
��� c= � wÉ. �|_ oÁ�� �G� Ó�� �t |�T>_� t ��oc : H�
� s ;� J ��= Ü� �� � Iã� ²= c �É. nh ����z �® �- � ��
� �� � wt ðKv�� ~� î� cq) v �É. ê ��: ô �H�� xò� �
/�_� t |�T>H ��� '(c wÉ
◦ ô �T> ���� � '(c wÉ
• ô �T>t �g� ��t �_� Ð� � V �t �D�= �® ¥�, å = � p �v '
(û. ô �T>� �t ¤Z_ j¯ î M�: �vc �p ��ø. j¯� ô �T>� D
ë�� �� î M�� �� � � wt ���� ��� '(c wÉ
|}| xxix
◦ T> V p � � a��u û
• �� í^îï� -���, î ��� �p /�� t T>: V p c �® [(û. ��
� í^îïv v; V Wutñ >¥ T>� �� s `¤_� � å¤vs ð� I�
� wt xyv �sp H ¥_ >H T>� �t �z D ë� ��� �� � � �� �t
(åv P . j¯� T>: V p t D ë�� =�= t �v M�Jû
◦ �È$ nY wt í^îïv w]�^ î�: ��� [D� � wt oâ H�� @I
�² >ò� '(c wÉ
• ê ô �H�t d� ���� ��c §�]^ >ò� � wH/ @IX �v�^ $Î
2¤, ½ �H w�, �� �_� t :; c R� �gv �û] �H wÉ. ~� �� �
c m [, ]^ �t í^îï_ ¨�X ��� �â,]^ b c��p �� �gH w�
�ø. j¯� �/� v o� v 2�� +, � � ò� ���² oâ , ]^ @I� b
c�g� 2c^ >ò� '(H wÉ
◦ ¥� ¥!�t �J , >A ç> � ��) b c_ �ûV Ê �å= %� � �å= � �
���u û
• ���� ��t Î\d �vp � �_ �J vs > * ç> v ¥�vs ¥!� &
® � >�: qrv ¥â bn_ ;#t ðv W= ·É. j¯� ��� �� �tñ �
V Ê � wÉ. j¯� ��) � �� � �t v³� �J vs > * ç>� �¡� �
Í�= ì�h ��� '(c wÉ
◦ ���� ��� aI�tñ w�� ¢ë� p Þ� È��u û
• ���� �� = >?z ����� �p �� Î\d ^(�A = K>L� =
�� �J , �, = K�ú_� ����è& � @a�� ����, K�� £³�t ñ_
+,v wÉ. �=� �� `¤ ���� ��t $k p ¨_� H [@ = � �t �
c aIX 4v , = ·� � � ���� = v '(� �� ¤a� '(c wÉ
◦ = K ���� å, ·é, o � xò�t ñ w�� â�, å = � ¨Íc '(û
• ‘���� �� = >?’� �p ^ = K ����c: xy� ����, >A ����
ç>, �Ï� > * ç>: = , �� = ( ‘>L, oê’: �� �� �²u û. �
³ Wz \dv=� ����¨� é�, -oA ¨Í� �� = K: ����è& @ a
: �p ^ ] � wH/ =5o#�â ~t = K>L ����p ¨�: Ý �H ç���
cV , v� =Z, å ����x) �� ÁH� '(c wÉ
xxx| 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
◦ ���� �� v � ^: ���� í^îï� ���� è& � §Á�� =�
� wt �� x) � V Ê '(c wÉ
• 4C� ���� ��� «ð� > z v³� =p Lc �® '(�a �z HØ�
�� X$� �Oû. îÍ� v³� =� �� ��®c Ë,a , �� ¡��v =
>?: +Ec á)] �]^ J �P
I. � �
1. � FG
2. � :7� % �;
3. � >?
4. � @A
Ⅰ .� %�│ 3
I. � �
1. � FG
���� Dg>?z 「 ���� = 7 」 : 78, åí¯A ����� õö
�t p ¨å �������� v ô GX vH ê» , ]^ V Wu$. 2012C YF ��
������ v ���� wt ���� >?_t ¥§p� , �����, >L
����, å��) , `þ Ý � , �� = , = D ��, ����@I, ©: ¨� , µ
©Û�¯ ( + c= c w$. v [ ©: ¨�t ^·[( ��x) � p ê5Æ1)_
j¯ � � $�� ����: x) �� /� 2010C ô#u]a , 2012C YF ��
�� wt >?]^t �Dª�e (��[æ ) ©: & ð�A ‘���� �� = >?’v
w$.
v [ ©:¨�: `E>?v¯ � � wt ‘���� �� = >?’z Î\d ^(�
� `¤]^ ¥J v �_� ����� �]a , ��, r�) � c� ©: ,å >�
]^ ) ��� HA�t �� +, ]^ 2008C 10@ �� aD �² 2011C�= = �`$.
2011C_t ª�� 16@: ^(�� aD �² YF�= = �� w]a , 2012C 10@: ^
(�� 2c^ aD�² «ð�� w$. = � �t ^(�A �J z ��D ~t 5
� H �D � �� ���� í^îï: = � �t$. v� /� ��������
z � �_ ��ç>� = ��, v_ '(� í^îï * p oF (� = �² ���
?`��� w$. 2008C �É V W�² 2011C�= 4C: = � �z 10@: ^(�t
��p �Ð: ���c u]a , v [ 3@: �t ‘���ª«�’^ = D�� p ?H
� �� 2c= � �� w$.
1) (�� � � �� �� �) �· � ������ � � ���� 2010 ���� ��!�����"# (2010
% 5& 25'*+ 28',- . /3. 46 79:) 46 ; !�<�=>*? ���@� �*A B CDE 2010
% 7& 8' GH9I. �· � ������ � � ���� 64� LMN�O; P� 7 Q RI. S ���T
3. � ���� U� V ��·<� L@� �� � W X" Y Z[ ���=� ��\ ��� - ] X" ^
�@� ��� _` �� ab c @�? - de# f�g _� ���� U� ⑥ ���� - ] B C<�
Pi(!�<�=>*·���@� �*, 2010)
4 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅰ -1 >� �vy z\� Õ�(�� 26��)
BD :� ����� ��� (http://intro.arte.or.kr/business/creativityEdu2012.jsp)
‘���� �� = >?’z �J¬ �# ¯, >, �Ðd, = K>Lc ûü �� ����
: ¨�^ � �p � wH/ HA�t >?v$. v = >?: ��t ²³ ø¤, ��
A �� * 5: ®F � �� ¯Í ¢�°$(�p - þ , 2011; D �) þ , 2011) . nh D �
) þ(2011)c ‘2011 ���� ��) �� – ���� ��� [\ ]^’ ��� � ��
‘���� �� = >?’v �J , �, = K�ú_� $�� ðK_� ;D, å ��� ��
wÉ� e�� M w$. îÍ� v ��t �½ ���� = >?_ `� �â, ��) b c
¯t æ � >?: n) _ ²t ��) b c d³� �Æk$t ñ _ ::c w$.
�=� ´z ��p� � �_ � @c: xy ¥H f ^ ��) � µ��p _t ��c w
$. ~� � ^(�È$ � ^ $k è& � c= � w]a , ���� �uH � �� $Ï
$t æ _� ��M�: �� _H �[�u � '(H w$. v ��_� � V � �J ��)
=E: & ® å) , ��) � ����, ��) b @^� ��� æ H @a� '(c w$.
Ⅰ .� %�│ 5
å) , ðK: & ® ‘o�/�@r’, ‘EY /©:) ’, ‘Ý y/>L) ’]^ �)� w]s, ‘o�/�
@r’z ¶� ½�, å n) ]^ ����� J�, ¨�) v ¸$t ��æ v wu$.
2011C T> M�_� H ‘o�/�@r’_� t ��,]^ Á:; � ��c sBs= ·t$. å
) ðK: ‘Ý y/>L) ’� ����ðK: ‘>L) ’� ‘©:) /����, r) ’v [@X æ H
wu$. îÍ � hU �V�Y¤� ¨�X ‘op �H) ’, ‘op T¹�’, ‘Û�¹Û = �’ (v
å) ðK]^ ì�h �ð= ·z æ H =,u$. ����ðK: & ® Éj, ; �, §� �
c= �/ ðKv � Æu]s, ð�, �? , º=» , �j ( ���� ��: $�� ���
� í^îï� db õ��= Ü�$t æ H = ,u$. � ³ Éj, ; �, §�]^ ðK
� ���t U� H �¢�= ·$t = ,H wu$.
� ��) : & ®, ‘�: ���� è& @a’, ‘� �) : ����, K���’, ‘�
: ¥�, � ¤’, ‘`þ, ����’, ‘= K>L: ���� åí¯ xò’ (]^ �/
ðK� ���² � ¨Ío, >, �ÐdA: |� T>�� �� �� �`$. = K>L ��
) de : & ®H ‘= K: ���� è& @a ’, ‘=K�ú: ����, K���’, ‘= K: è
& @a ’, ‘= K: ���� åí¯ xò’ (: �/ ðK� ���² =K�ú� ç> �: |
� T>�� �� �� �`$. \¼ |�T>� �� �� ,]^ �� ¿�c ½�{t= _ ¨
�X ~ �â, M�� �� � wu$. î³s �/��^ =Z,å ��) � b c��, @
a�p /�� t D�, å ñv�� ½, � '(c �Vu$. � , î�È$ |�T>� �t
��$t W¨, b cH�c '(� �v$. îÍ� ��`¤]^� �Ðdt �c �# ¯ =
K>L, ç>t = K>Lc �# ¯ �_ Z� �]^ �t �v Bö�$t æ H =,u$.
îÍ� 2012C 10@: �\ ���� ��c !-�t �¾ ö�_ ��c ���u � ,
V ) H � pu$.
v_ ê ��t `¤� ¿ ~ �¢h ��, @aX = EA b c�g� @I�`$. ~� @a
X b c�g]^ �\ = D X 10@ �: 1C� = >? ��� [D ��o �$. �À�|
Ö]^ 4C�: ¿�� ¢��p /� y½� ÁH^ �C [D� '(c wp ��v$. v�
/� ‘���� �� = >?’: +, � �/ �: >? �� * í^îï� ¿ ~ â�,
]^ �� ��, v� �� p `t �J : ��) b c = E� @a�² �g� @I��, �
A = K>Lt p�: b c=E_ U� �� ª�� �g� @I��o �`$. �J : & ®
[@X �z D Í�� ÐK� ðK� �T�² å) � ����, ðK ¥�_ ¶ ª ^« b
c= E� @I�� ª ^« �g� �� [D ��o �`$. �A = K>L: & ® |�= `
� W¨, å b c�g� @I�² [D ��o �`$.
6│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
2. � :7� % �;
1) �= :7�
‘���� �� = >?’z �âA r) /�: Iá��_ wt ^(�J _� � �
D_� Îþ� wt ����� � §�$. nh = `¤v ÷9·�Ä: Î\d ^(�
^ ���� â÷ p Lc f, , z �J , �, = K>L_ ¥���ç>, ��� / �
V ô , ¥�, í^îï, â÷ /�: í^îï ( �z �Þ: ���� è& � �� EY
: p L� �§�Þ$. v³� æ _� ‘���� �� = >?’z @= ~t ��@= �
_� H :; c w$.
�������� z 2011C_ ‘���� �� = >?’: ��) ��� � V �² =
>?: n) _ ²t ��) b c d³� @I�`$. �=� ��p�: ��^ å�� >¥
e>c ���� �� í^îïv v; V W X H_ �V�, �� í^îïv $ È#p ¥
_ >He>c � Vup ��_ î ��� ¤)�� b ck$� �p � $. nh �\ = D
X �: & ® Å� � @c: xy]^ � ¿�� sBsp � p `�t �H �Ív$. ��
m���_� t �J _ `� ��) =E_� [@X ðK� ;� �ð�= Ü� ðKv wu
$. ~� �A = K>L: ¿�_ `�� t \¼ |�T>� � V �² î ��� e���o
�`]�^ ô �T>A Oz W¨, oó� �m � � �u$t ��H wu$. ��� =Z,
]^ [D�p /�� t Å� xò� � wt W¨e b c�g� @I� '(c wu$. v_
�J : ��) b c �g� @a��, � * = K>L: ��) � b c� � wt ª ^« �
g� @I� '(c wu$. �/ � � _� v³� W¨, b c �g� xò�² =Z, ]
^ >?: ��� oâ b c�� Æ�Ç� �� í^îï� æe�� @a�tñ � HØ�
� w� �v$. v_ ��: '() � D�| $� O$.
�È , p� ��: b c=E� @a� '(c w$. p�: ��_� [@X ðK� [D�=
Ü� ðK� �D �T�� ª�� @I� b c= E^ 2012C �\ =D ���� ��Ð�
��) � �� � oó� � §��o �$. v� m`^ �C =Z, å b cA Æ�Ç xò� �
� í^îï @a_ xò�H/ � '(c w$.
ÉÈ , p� ��_� |�T>ò]^ @IX b c=E_ `� D�, [D v cq� �g�
@I� '(c w$. \¼|�z ô �= ^ Iã� � wt �, oó� �§�=� yV _ W¨
,å oó� ë��tñ ��Øv w$. ~� �C =Z, å b c^ ��� f �� �p /�
� t D�, oóH '(�$. v_ j¯ �: ¿�A = K>L: ¿� ðK_� W¨, b c
�g� @I� '(c w$. � ³ @IX b c�g]^ 2012CH ��� [D�² H =Z
,å b c: p Þ]^ xò� � w$.
ÊÈ , @IX b c�g� T>X M�t �/�: í^îï @I_H xò� � w=� ¤
Ⅰ .� %�│ 7
/p ¨: Dg�G� = : U� oó^H xò� � w$. D ÐA = 5o#�â * = K �
_� ���� Dg�G� = _ '(� & ÷ , oó� � §û]^Ë Dg= â�: ç
�, >?: 2� * ë9_ `� Bö) � ç��tñ '(�$.
2) �= �; % ==
ê ��t $É� Oz +, _ :� ��u$.
�È , ©:¨�: >?]^ = �� wt ‘���� �� = >?’_ , "� ��)
=E� �D F D G�� �â, �g� �D * @I�$.
‘���� �� = >?’z �J¬� �# ¯, >, �Ðd, =K�ú� `¤]^ �t ��
�� í^îïv$. 2011C ‘���� �� = >?’: ��) � �� � � wt b c= E
� @I� M w$. î³s �J `¤_� ðK [@ * ËÌX ðK� �T��, � * =K>
L `¤: W¨, �g@I: '() _ j¯ v� �D �T� bc= EA �g� @I�$.
ÉÈ , 2012C �\ = D X ���� ��: 1C� >? ��� T>�$.
@IX b c= EA v_ jk b c�g]^ �\ =D X 10@ �: ��) � [D �$. v
oót 1C� ��) � b c�t oóvp H �=� �C y½� T>� � V �² ��� ^�
Í_ jk ��: emA í^îï: @a_ xò� � w� �v$. � ³ Dg, = : U
� oó^H xò] � w$.
ÊÈ , ��� ^�Í_ jk b c_ xò] b c�g� � §�$.
‘���� �� = >?’z 1�CH(�ß : p�T) ) - 2�CH(n) : ) �p ) - 3�CH
(ûü : ë9p ) - 4�CH(=Z: DÎp ): ��� ^�Í_ j¯ ��X$. v� b c�p /
�� t �C §�]^ b c� �g� ���^ m []^ xò� �gv $� � w$. ê ��
_� @IX �gz � @� ���� ��c oâ,]^ �g� a��� s �D �T�²
xò� � w$.
ê ��: ���� :: t b c= ^ (R� � w$.
�È , ��, å : :^ ����: �� z �� d{]^ sBst= � �J � �,
îÍ� = K>L: [|_� Ïh�, $�� ¿å � =K>L: n) v ����� �
{� � �� Y¤v IJ �t= ÏÐ�t ����: ��) � �� �t de � � V �$.
nh ����: �- � �� � ä�¯û]^Ë ����: ��_ `� vN D G
� ��_ � p ²� � �]^ p `X$.
ÉÈ , Dg, å ::^ ���� ��) =E� � Æk$t æ v$. nh ���� ��
= >?v¯t nY� ��� ��) =E� �²v]^Ë , Á>� $k i=: ����
í^îï: ��) =E @I_ HØ� �u$t æ v$. v³� =E_ U� � =Z, å ��
V ÛÑv � � = | ���� >?: =Z) � �Ò) �` ( Dg M D _ xò��,
8│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
D�: §ÁA í^îï: @a (: Ðc,å ��H �É � w$. ~� ���� �D_�
IJ �t ��æ � â�,]^ ÏÐ��, @a `Æ� � ��t U� ^H xò� � w$.
3. � >?
ê ��t ‘2011 ���� ��) �� –���� �� [\ ]^-’_� @IX ��)
=E� �D �T��, b c�g� �D * @I�² 2012C �\^ aDX 1C� 10@ ^(�
: = à 1C� >? ��� T>��o �$. �â,å T> -/ t �J , �, = K>L:
¿�v$.
�È , ��`¤]^ �J z 10@ ^(� 3, 4, 5, 6�C ¥�T>� �$. �D X �g]^
9c T>� � V ��, î oó� �g: BöHA �dH� e��tñ xò�² �D X hi
�g� MD�$. îÍ� v H�� 2012C >?ió V æ _ T>�² ��) oó^ xò�$.
ÉÈ , ��`¤]^ �t > * ç>� `¤]^ @ I� �g� 9c_ T>��, î oó
� �g: BöHA �dH� e��tñ xò�$. îÍ� �D� H�� 2012C >?ió V
æ _ T>�² ��) oó^ xò�$.
ÊÈ , ��`¤]^ =K>Lt =K�ú� `¤]^ @ I� �g� 9c_ T>��, î oó
� �g: BöHA �dH� e��tñ xò�$. îÍ� �D� H�� 2012C >?ió V
æ _ T>�² ��) oó^ xò�$.
c s [ �
\� 201 2� � � � � �vy z\� 1 0�� 3,� 4,� 5,� 6\� �`~]
\� 201 2� � � � � �vy z\� 1 0�� �] � �] ��
� �]^ 201 2� � � � � �vy z\� 1 0�� ��� �� 10H '�
<� Ⅰ -1 >� ~] �×
��) �� � /� H�t �J , �, = K>L ( �� `¤_ j¯ $Ï$. 2011C ��
�� �� ��) �� ��: & ® �J : & ®� ô �= � vò� ��) [D � �`]a ,
�A = K�ú: & ®_t XYT>� ��kp ��_ |� T>^ ��) �� � �`$.
2012C ���� �� ��) �� ��_� t �J , �, = K�ú db$ ô �= � vò�
��) � �� �� X$. v_ �J , �, = K�ú� ��`¤]^ � ��) = EA �gv
�D * ª�� @Iu$.
�È , �J : ��) =Et å) � ��) v �"� ‘op �qr’, ‘���� r�) ’, ‘©
:) ’, ‘op T¹�(§» ) ) ’, ‘op EY� IE�’, ‘Ý y� >L) ’ ( 6@ ðK]^ �D �`]
Ⅰ .� %�│ 9
a �� 7@ , db 42�g]^ � w$.
ÉÈ , �: & ®_t 2011C ��A y½�� ‘�: ���� è& @a’, ‘� �) :
����, K� ��’, ‘�: ¥�, � ¤’, ‘`þ, �� ��’, ‘= K>L: ����
åí¯ xò’ ( 5@ ðK_� W¨ �gv @Iu$.
ÊÈ , = K>L: & ®_H 2011C ��A y½�� ‘= K: ���� è& @a’, ‘= K�ú
: ����, K� ��’, ‘= K: è& @a’, ‘= K: ���� åí¯ xò’ ( 4@ ðK:
W¨ �gv @Iu$.
4. � @A
1) HJ � % K LMN= O� % ��
ê ��A ¨�X a� �� * p^oó� T>�² �� �`$.
�È , ‘���� �� = >?’: Ú��å ����: @Ó� +E * �ò �� � /
� ¨� �� �f� T>�`$. v� /� ���� ¨� Dg ����� , �� ý�,
� , (� T>�² '(� oó� �m �`$. �� oó vþ_H �þ : ���� ¨�
p ¨: �fH �m �² �� �`$.
ÉÈ , ����v å) � ����) _ ;#t ��� ¢p /� ^(�J : å) * �
���) _ `� �foó� �m �`$. � ³ ‘���� �� = >?’v ^(�_� �
�� wt >?å �¾ YF V�� wt ^(� �D : �òH �� �`$.
ÊÈ , 10@ �\ ���� ��: >?�� * «ð��� ( ¨� �f oó� �m �²
�� �`$. �À�| 4C�: >?��_ ����: xy�ò� p `��c �û� w
p ��v$. vt ��) � �â��tñ [(� p Þv X$. � ³ ¿ ~ Dë� �� � /
� �������� ( >?� �¨�t p ¨: ¨�oA |õ� �t ( >?: 5
) * �ò� n) � Cj�� �� �`$. nh ‘���� �� = >?’� �`� s V��
� wt �_ 5�� ¨�oA |õ� �`]a , >?� ��ki > � ��l� m`^
p^ oó: YZ * �ò� n) � �� �`$.
ÔÈ , ��) =E: @a_ '(� oó �m * �� � �`$. vt b cðK]^ nh �
������� _� ���`i ���� >? b c * ��) _ ¨� ��� � �
^ ¾��`$.
2) � P� QR % S �
‘���� �� = >?’z 2011C ¨� ��A ²³ ø¤, ��� �� �J : ���
�, q�� ��VÕ� ¬� �# ¯ å) , [|_� H ;D , ¿�H ½]Õ$. ~� �A
10│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
=K>L: ���� è& : ¿�� ÖI�² �¬� �# ¯ =K>L� x) �V Út
) §� >?]^ åD�t$. v�t v³� ��� =Z, ]^ �� ��, ë`�p /� `g
v '(�$. v� /� D � >?��� ëå��, Æ�Ç� �� =Z, I¥� � � wH
/ �ö �/�c ÛÛ^ xò� � wt ��) = EA b cH�� @I� '(c � pu
$. v_ Ö]^ 4C� >?� =Z� 2012C �\ 10@ ���� �� v o� : >?�
ÛÛ^ b c�� @a�p /� = EA H�c '(�� u$. v_ ê ��t �J , � *
=K>L: ��) e> H�� @I�`$. ��) e> H�: W¨, va ��,å M� �
� � /�� �f��, a���: xò, ¨�o |� , ��, e� , ¥�c o� (: 57�
�� <î< Ⅰ -2>� Oz ¹�^ @I�`$.
� � � c ' *
�_Y � � � cY ��� & cY ��_ �_Y �� �� $�,� �vy z\�&
j� _ ����+ �� �| |� su
⇩
��� �� �� cY ��_ �� I¡& ¢£ ��+ `¤J$ ¥G ¦§JL
��
⇩
1p ¨©ª«£ ¦¬ �c � ��®(�` � �])& ^ & � �+ �� � ��&
�¯Y ¦¬
⇩
°b± ²³´ ��; [� °b± ²³´µ su
(OO� � � ·¸\� 4,� 5,� 6\� 6� \¹ [�)�
⇩
2p ¨©ª«£ ¦¬ �c � °b± ²³´ ºL �]µ » & G ��
� ��& � ¯Y ¦¬
⇩
¼�~] ½? � � 10� �vy z\� 3,� 4,� 5,� 6� \� [�¾� ~] ½ ?
⇩
� ¿ £ ¦¬ �¿ £ su
⇩
À Á  ® �� Ã� �vy z\� ºL �]µ Ä ÅÆ+ �� ��³ÅÇ È
À Á �� Ã�
<�Ê Ⅰ -2>� �� �� ¯p
Ⅰ .� %�│ 1 1
�J : ��) = E H�t �� ‘op �qr’, ‘���� r�) ’, ‘©:) ’, ‘op T¹�(§
» �)’, ‘op EY� IE� ’, ‘Ý y� >L) ’ ( 6c= ^ ���`]a ä 42�gv$.
�: ��) = E H�t �� ‘�: ���� è& @a ’, ‘� �) : ����, K
� ��’, ‘�: ¥�, � ¤’, ‘`þ , �� ��’, ‘=K>L: ���� åí¯ xò’
( 5c= ^ ���`$. ‘�: ���� è& @a ’: & ® ‘é, ·å, oê ëì’, ‘p ¨ �
>L oê e ) ’, ‘�: `þ , ÿ��� e ) ’ (� ‘� �) : ����, K� ��’:
& ® ‘����Á’, ‘����’, ‘����©W’ (� ‘�: ¥�, � ¤’: & ®
‘� �� «ð ��: ¿�’, ‘� �D : ¿�’, ‘� «ð +E [æ >? ¿�’, ‘�
�� �M ��’, ‘>: ¥�) ¤’ (� ‘`þ , �� ��’: & ® ‘�_ `� `þ v;
= @a ’, ‘�_ `� ¤/ �D p ¨: ¨\ � = ’ (� ‘= K>L: ���� åí¯
xò’: & ® ‘= K p� V ô xò’, ‘= K ��: K>) � ¥�� �ð� ����W% ©T’
(: �/ ��ðK� �û�� w$.
= K>L: ��) = E H�t �� ‘=K: ���� è& @a ’, ‘= K�ú: ����,
K� ��’, ‘= K: è& @a’, ‘=K: ���� åí¯ xò’ ( 4c= ^ ���`$. ‘= K:
���� è& @a ’: & ® ‘é, ·å, oê ëì’, ‘= K>L � >L oê e ) ’, ‘`þ, ÿ�
�� e ) ’ (� ‘= K�ú: ����, K� ��’: & ® ‘����Á’, ‘����’, ‘�
���©W’ (� ‘=K: è& @a’: & ® ‘éÍ, è& @a’, ‘>L oê ¤’, ‘= K>L
�� �M ’, ‘`þ, ��’ (� ‘= K: ���� åí¯ xò’: & ® ‘= K>L � ¥V �’,
‘§��’, ‘7騒, ‘H� ¨ xò’, ‘= K>L � ��Á9-ô �, Á, = , >: , /å (-xò’ (
: �ò� �û�� w$.
Ⅱ. ���� ��� ����
� �!
1. ������= =T
2. ������� ����= Q7U
3. 2012V �W �������= �� ��
4. � �!= XWY P� QR
II.� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y ��| 1 5
II. ������� ���� � �!
1. ������= =T
� J �� � � c= p ê,å (Î� ���� X$. �{ot Ë�å= , ��v cÏ
'Ç u �t= , >L c _ (��t c#t ��å= v$. ����� �� | �
���� %®t �{ot Ë�va , cÏ'=t ����z �� �òv�u �a , îÍ � �
���v v×�Ç u �t >L, c#t ��å= c ���u �$(Day & Hurwitz,
2012) .
<�Ê Ⅱ -1 >� ��� & I�� |�
BD :� Day,� M .� &� Hurwitz,� A.(201 2) .� Children� and� their� art:� art� education� for� elementary� and�
middle� schools.� CA:� Wadsworth� cengage� learning ,� pp.3-1 5.;% õ ¤
ã��: Iáz ����� �{o: n) _ �® [(� V >æ � � §� �u$. nh $
[= q: @Óz ����: [() � ëåV��u�, ã��z ����v �,v: ãIá_
[(� K�� �$t æ � ÏÐ�u$(Gardner, 1985) . î³�^ ����z î �u_ Fq�
�vt Î�: �J � /� �v �# ¯ ½�]^� �_� [(�� ®��u û
� çTk$(Sylwester, 1998) .
16│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
nh � êÈ >L, c#t hU ����: x) �_ MD , (Îv$. b J V `å
µëì >L, (�c _ � ð� ;#p ��v$. �� ��z 21�p � `f � åF
�) � /�² ‘����’� çT�� w$(� �� ·hz ·h; ð, 2010; �Y, íò½, Æ
Fð, 2008) . �z �c v ª ^« f ¥]^ ´ µÏ� wt ��: �p _ ,?, ]^ `q�
� w]a , v³� �¤z a��½�/ ~ b�³= � sBà$. ; �z 1994C �� EÞ
�D(National Standard for Arts Education)� @ I��, â�, ]^ ��� 2��
ñ$(Consortium of National Arts Education Associations, 1994; Eisner & Day, 2004) .
2009C ‘Á6: ���_ `� ��� ’_� t Á6 30@�: ����� YZ_
`� T>��, `Ð�: �c v ��: +E� ‘��, p �, ��_ `� = � v�’,
‘fµ, r¤’, ‘��Á9 ’ , ‘@å, rD � Dâ) E!’, ‘��, $�) ’ îÍ� ‘©:) ’� �
wÉ� ���`$. ����v ©: �: ôva ����9?z = p�& �: ãå� K�
� o��� wÉ� �²Þ$. = p�& � _� ©:) z õ �c &ö�va , ��, c#c
�÷: ôv � �c: /¤� MD�t V `_ �� D â) � ��: �c) z ©:�:
dzc X$. Root-Bernstein(2001)z ©:) : ú\ z ��_ w$� �`$. >� ��
��v ©:) � ÖI�t åv¯t �z 1940C`A 1950C` �z �� v �²�u$
(Day & Hurwitz, 2012) . î³s hU ©:) _ >L, c#c Ð�|� ~ Å� ����v
çTX �v$.
~ �s: >L, (�t å) : çTv$. �� å) z ð�^ ‘personality’ , å» z
‘character’^ êK�=� ®Ís¯t å» v¯t ò�c ¶� Ý :, v�� �^ å)
v¯t ò�� >ò�$. å) (�� )vý Ó î`^ >�P: v$(D �) þ , 2013) .
>�Pvý å�v Èþh cÇu � ‘= ㆍ D ㆍ : ’� T��� IáV Út � Ó�$. î
T�c �¶°� � å�r= Ü� �y v sBà$. nh ®Ís¯t ‘= ’_ #[� ñ
p ��_ ‘D ’� ‘: ’c ÐK�� �� c IJ �p � �_ å) z ÿh Ho� [\ ]^ J
��t &v w$. hU �V� ( >L��c Ð�|� å) v $V çT� w$.
îyñ �¡]^ m [, ]^ ����� �z "ÎC : å) v Q¥t �� v IE
|� ����� å) : ¨�) _ `� ¨\ v ��°$. �������� (2012)
z ‘2012 �����F ’_� ‘���� ©T, _¶= ^ �V�� ��� $’¯t �
�^ ����v å) _ ;#t ²³ c= ;D , �� � � V �² � Qq� �z
M w$. K]^ J ��| $�� p Lc � §| ‘= ㆍ D ㆍ : ’� T��� Iá�² "Î
C: å) v ne � ��=� ���� Ð�: MDv �V� ( f�]^ sB{$� 2[
� �H w$. j¯� ����: L@ , ~t ����: çTc å) v¯t >L
, (�_ �� �� wt �v$.
î³s ����z c�h wt >�_� o¹^ $cµ= ·t$. Deweyc Ó�t ‘�þ,
å & ÷ (extraordinary experience) ’ , Maxine Greenev Ó�t ‘¯Í �� wÉ’� & ÷ �H/
II.� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y ��| 1 7
����]^ >� _� ,?, ]^ $ccu �$(Greene, 2011) . � ����v
[(� �v$. nh ^(�J z r) � �â c �»h Iá�t ��_ w]a v _�t
Iá��_ ,¹� ����� & ÷ � p Lc � §� u �$(Steiner, 2006a; Steiner, 2006b) .
vt �J v ÛÛ^ ��� & ÷ � ��= p $�u �t �v �# ¯ v : Iá��_ ,
"� D aX ����& ÷ � �D ]^ � � � §�u �t �v �: : �v$. ~�
b J V `_t �s = K>Lc ��� w= ·� §Á�t §�� ¨�^� , îÍ� �
F, �D ]^� o�Û6� ����� �� � wt è& v �u �$(������
�� , 2008; Chan, 2010) .
2. ���� ��� ����= Q7U
1) ����= Q7
®Ís¯H ����� �� ©: ㆍ å) v ��,å 2�c � wÉ� JV ��,
hU 10² C� ����� /� = � Dg� x) ��� w$(� �� ·0� ·µ= ,
2010; � ����= ¨� -� ��F� , 2009; � ��F� , 2009; ®� , 2008) . n
h 2005C ���� = 7� �D �|� Dg� = v �â � u$. �V / �: ��
¤Z_H Å���, �J � /�² ��,å : c#� � Y� � wt 5� � Æ�
� �_� $�� ����í^îï� �§�p /� ��� ñ$. nh hU_t 2010C Á
ÿÛ� ������`L� Á#��, ‘©:) � v��Ä � wt �� ç�’¯t 「Á
ÿÛ� � aO」 : �_ v� , ��â ¨�ÐA ��p �Ðc 「©:) � å) û��
/� ^ ㆍ [( ��x) � p ê5Æ」 (2010)� §y IE�`$. v 5Æ: [æ 2���
t �xy_� : �� ç�, �-= K>L ��� �� �� ç�, �� ㆍ â[æ
� x) � * ë` , �� p ¨: ��\ � = ë` , ��� ��: �" �
V , �� = Ý �â� �½� � V �� w$. vt ®Ís¯: ��Dg� Dg� ¨
��� wt � ��Ð�c Ý � �² ©: ㆍ å) û�: ú\ �uå ����: x) ��
p ��o �t Dg, := � E¢� �]^ . � w$.
����z ‘��, ; �(qò; �� �û�$), Éj, �ò, �? , ð�, ��, �j, >�, $
½ , �� * !µ� Ó�$.’(������7 � 2T) ����z �� b c=^ ��X$.
�st ����V ô * �����âA �i V ô * �â (_� ��t ����
� þ: d� ez: ����� Ó�$. $k �st �,vm , Á# , ^·[(�_
� �D: ½è]^ ��²= t ����v$(µ�� , 2008) .
>L ����z ����: Uê,å ®=A Ov ���� �u: p q, {��
$ ���� &÷ � �� Î�: p L� �§�� ��·��, &÷ � �� @å: : � ¤
� >L: ;D , ¿�� v�� ��o �$. >L���� >?]^t ��ç> = >?,
18│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
=Kp� >L���� x) �, >L���� d³@I, F þy� = >?, J x��§
yâ � p >? (v w$.
� ����z ���� x) �A ¥�å� �) (� /� Dg� :Ò, ]^ 2
�� µ|� ��ç> = >?, ���� �� = >?, Îþ �y ·"ÎC ���� =
>?, Á����� = >?, �����u ¥�) ç� = >? * > oÒ��d
ø = >?, ����aH� = >?(2010C = ) (� �� $��� =Z, å ez
^ = � w$.
��ç> = >?z ��Y�� § ��� �� ‘�: ���� x) �’A ‘��
��� �� �J : ��, Î�å ©:, åF�) ’� /� 2000CHÐ� � V� wt
>?v$. 2011C YF �j, �? , ð�, �ò, ���#�v� , §�, >�, �oå ( 8@ �
u_� ��ç> 4,164¢v ¥� 5,772@ ^(�, [� * �(�(n� * `Æ� �
û)_ Cãu$. � �_� x� �?v ��] � wH/ , ���� �?_ '(�
p oF A F � = �� w$. nh , 2011C_t �� �uA º=» �uV - >?� �
V �� w]a , v_ `� ��) v e�| ��ç> = >?� ,ò� �Dv$.
���� �� = >?z ����_ �z := � 1� wt à ㆍ 9 ㆍ �Ä ÎF ^(
�� `¤]^ p^ Î�� ���� , Y�â÷ � §� IE = ( = K>L F J
� x� � §�t �� +, ]^ 2008C 10@ �� aD �² = �`$. v >?v �z �
q� �� o 2011C_t 16�� ª ^ aD �² H 4C� = �p ^ �`$. D\
�D �_� îÍ� 5�H xy� �� = � d� �J v ���� xy� � � wH
/ = �$. v� /� ���� ��t oâ, å �D � �) ��, v_ '(� ½D �
o» � 1� = K: ¥� ���� ç>� ^�� � w�, ����� /� p oF ��
( 4C� = � �� X$.
nh 2011C_t ����� x) �� / �² 16@ V ㆍ H ": �����
õö ��> � =Z, å Ý :L� �� ÿ��� â��½ , ��ç>A xy = � /�
/ L * ç>Ý :L «ð, ��ç> xy b c ( >?��� ?`��p /� $�
� = � �� w$. 2012C_t ª�� 10@ ^(�� aD = �� w$.
2) ����=
����: :; A ��_ `�� t �z �� v w$(�p-, 2010; v�Þ, 2009;
Gardner, 1990; v� þ, 2010). î³s �â, = >?_ `� ��� \¼,]^ ��� ��t
�é$. �������� _� t 2011CH_ ���� �� = >?: ��_ `� e
�� ��o ��) �� ��� V�� M w$. ���� �� = >?: ��t �i ;�
�¤_� $� �HuÉ_H Å��� ��^ �´� ��c wt= DÍc '(� ¤Zvup
II.� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y ��| 1 9
��v$. ��: �( +,z ���� �� = >?: ) » � í^îï� �� ��, ��)
=E� �G�² ���� ��: ��) � e��tñ wu$. ��`¤z �J : & ® 1C�
���� �� 16@A 4C� ���� �� 10@A �� m� 5@: 4, 5, 6�C ^(
�J _ `� Em � �� ��c V�u$. �: & ® 4C� ���� �� 3@, 1C
� ���� �� 5@ : �¨Ío * õö>, �Ðd� `¤]^, ~ =K>L: & ®,
���� ��c ÎF � = K>L: = K�ú� ����ç> _ `� EÞ�X |�H��
�� ��c V�u$. ���� �� = >?v J ·��, ]^ �A = K>L_ �� ð
� Ô#t=_ `� ��>!c � : �p ��_ XY, � _� \¼|�T>c v×�°
$. yV _ ��_ `� |�T>H v×�°$.
���� �� = >?: ��t $� Ov sB{$.
�È , �J : & ® å) , [|_� ^(�J : EY�, ©:) , Ý y\ , >L) � û��t
ñ ��, å �]^ sB{$. ����, [|_� �|, Éj ðK_� ��) v b�³= �
sB{$. 8@ : Éj ðK [ Éj D� � � þ� Éj �qr, Éj p q, Éj �_ `�
zH, Éj ©:) , Éj EY� , Éj Í~� , Éj >L) db_� ��,]^ Á: ; � ¤
� �`$. ; �ðK: & ® ; � �qr� ; � D� � � þ� d� ðK_� ��) v sB{
$. §�ðK: & ®t §� �qr, §� p q, §� �_ `� zH, §� ©:) , §� E
Y�, §� D � , §� Í~� , §� >L) ( 8@: �/ ðK db Á: ; � ¤� �`$.
v³� ���� �� = >?z >� �= ·z �J _� nh ��,å �]^ sB
{$. nh ½��_� >� �= ·z �J m�_� t Á: ; � �vc sBs= ·t=
�, ���� �� = >?� �� ����� �z �J _�t Á:; � ¤� . �
wu$. vt ���� �� = >?v >� �= ·z ÷9·�Ä: �J _� ��, ]
^ ����: p L� � §�`É� ¢ � w$.
ÉÈ , �: & ® �: ���� è& @a: [|, ��) : ����, K� ��
[|, �: ¥�, � ¤ [|, �: `þ, v; = ¤ [|, = K>L: ����
åí¯ xòH [| ( d� ðK_� ��, å �]^ sB{$.
®a �: ���� è& @a [|_� �| �: é, ·å, oêv ëìX �]^ sB
{$. p�: ô f � @a�² xòH� �`]a , p oF: ë�c �-/�� v×�°�, p
oF xò: �Ò) H �� ¤X �]^ sB{$. ~� = K>L: ���� å, o � x
òz í^îï ��) ��: y�]^ Wòk$. �$c = K>L � ���� �â A: Ý
�¨�� e ) �² �����>� @h�t ( xI� xyv wu$.
��) : ����, K� �� [|_� t � �) : �� Á p Lc ë`�
> v �J : $�� ��, F q� Cj�� ) �tñ HØ� Þ �]^ sB{$. ~
� ��: [|_� t ����v �J [\ , â ÷ [\ , xy[\ ]^ v×�>]^Ë
20│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
��: K>, p 7 , ; � (v �"X &�wt � cq© �Þ �]^ sB{$. >_�
t ¨� ðK: ¨\ , � ·�{ 57 , b c7 : ¥è� ¤� cÇ µ� k$. ��©W: [|
_� t §�¾c p L: ë` (]^ >A �J : ��©T�_ p ²� �]^ sB{$.
�: ¥�, � ¤ [|_� t � �D v ���� [\ ]^ ¡)� $
��� «ðu$. �= H_ w�� H �A �� í^îï� �"�² ���`]a ,
�þ = H_ w�� t ��xy, s�� %� , Ý y� çT� xy]^ �y : �yv
D� D� , ]^ ÆD � #Á: ��� �� u$. > _�t op o�� ):��
�7 @I: �p � �§�É]^ >^� : ¥�) ��: p Lc �, = H: K�� ç
�� � wt ��� cÇñ$.
�: `þ, v; = ¤ [|_� H ��c wu$. í^îïv $��=� >: ¥
�) v ¤P_ j¯ `HV _� ¥�� µt �J v �c�t �]^ sB{]a , ¤/
�D p ¨: ¨\ � = � �t ��� cÇñ$.
= K>L: ���� åí¯ xòH [|_� t =K>L: p�V ô : xòH� �v� =
K>L � ���� å, o : xò, =K>L: = � ¨\ ]^ �: ����: ��
� ?`�VÕ$.
ÊÈ , =K>L: & ® =K: ���� è& @a, =K�ú: ����, K� ��, =K>
L: è& @a, = K>L: ���� åí¯ xò ( d� ðK_� ��, å �]^ sB{$.
®a =K: ���� è& @a [|_� t = K>L � _ ���� ¥�å�v �c�
� V ô v ëìt ( ���� åí¯c ëìu$. ~� �, �����â , B= K �
(v � ^ ����� /� ÿ���� e ) �t ��� cÇñ$.
= K�ú: ����, K� �� [|_� t = K�ú: ��, K� ��_ �� p ²�`
$. =K�úv ����� �� p L� 1� |� ����_ `� ¨\ v �c��. í
^îï_ ¾²�² ����, r�) � K�v ¤u$.
= K>L: ���� åí¯ xò [|_� t = KÈ$ ²$v á�=� = K: ½� s ��
, è& � h`� xò�t yp ^ Wy�`$.
3. 2012V �W ���� ���= �� ��
Î\d ^(�� `¤]^ p^ Î�� ����, Y�â÷ � §�IE ( =K>
L FJ � x� � §� +, ]^ �t ���� ��t 2012C 10@: ^(�� �\^ a
D�`$. 2012C ���� �� = >?_ aDX �^t �=^ , ßa^ , `��)^ , �
@�^ , �ß^ , ��^ , ö�^ , �¢^ , ) ß^ , ©Q^ ( 10@ ^(�c w$. ^(�
� >?�ò� ���� í^îï� D Í�| $É� O$.
II.� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y ��| 21
1) G Z [ \L]��
�=^(�t & ¤ßH �) Ì_ /#� ^(�^ ¥â �J �c ä 133¢v$. �=^
(�t ¥J � `¤]^ ���� í^îï� «ð�$. jp ^t �j_� cu}, �
��, �ö , �}, `}, Î}, ÆÍ (v w]a �j_t Mv�, , î �_ �é� "©v w
$. î �_ � �� ¥����� â÷ xy * ²_5� ���� í� «ð�a , = K�ú
� ûü�t �éy�Í, H�� , !� (: ���� í^îï� «ð�$. >: &
®H ���� K�� ç�� � wt ��A ��l� � V �$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^ í^îï: & ® "v×; �)Ã(Ð, "v×; �j
¨YjÐ(cu}, � ��, `}, Î}, ÆÍ , �ö , �}, Bj) , "v×; �) µ�` #vÐ, "
v×; �) µ�` �éÐ, "v×; �) µ�` d$�Ð, Mv�,Ð, "©Ð, m(�����
, ���� §�¨�, ���� â÷ xy, ²_5� ���� íc w]a , ��>?:
& ® H�� (�Ðd), >, ç> K�ç� �� (v w$.
2) ^_ ZHL]��
ßa^(�t `¥�KV Á) �_ /#� �^ ¥â �J �c ä 61¢v$. ßa^(
�t ��#v�� �j¨Y�� �) �² 1å2jp ��p q� ÷h�o �$. `®BA �
ò� y�Í� �) �² �j¨Yj� xò� %[? xy� ¥@��o �$. ~� �,v %
[? xy� �� ¥�����_ `� â ÷ � ë��� ��, r�) � £³ J x Z ���
�å]^ ) �� � wH/ &�o �$. v� /� ßa �=�j¨Yj�_� ��, cu},
�}, � ��, ÆÍ , `}, Î}, �ö , '�� �a , ßa (Z��#v�_� t 1-2�Cv
1å1jp � ��� � wH/ �$. ßa `®B , �ò� y�Í� «ð� sI, s�, zb Î,
ò�, M¯, «¯: ��p q� ÷h� �� w]a , à��jâ÷ í, �D �j §� â÷ ,
}ç��¨� Hop â÷ ( ¥�����â ÷ í� «ð�$. �ÐdA = K�ú: ���
� K� ç�� /�� t �)Åv `}� , a©�é#v� (: �j� � «ð�a , J
: & ® J �j�� �jÝ �� ·�{ d*� @I� �j� � «ð�$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^t ßa(Z ��#v�(��), �j¨Yj�(cu}, � ��,
�}, �ö , `}, Î}, ÆÍ , "�), �ò�, `®B , ²_5� ����, �j�?, §��?,
�?�?, ßa J �j y�Í , �)Åv `}� , a©È� �é#v� , ¥�����â
÷ xy, ¥����� í(à��j ), ¥�����â÷ xy(§� * ¥V L ¨�), ����
<Èö, ���+# (IEL), ������� W, ¨�o ��l ¾c, õöo �þ �� ¾c,
>K� ç�>?(y�Í ��= , ·ç> ��l = ), ) �d³ @I>?(¥�c xò, =
xy) (v w$.
22 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
3) ^� ` � L]��
�)^(�t `��KV y�_ /#� ^(�^ ¥â �J �t 365¢v$. �)^(
�t 1å1jp ���t �� +,]^ ¨j"��� «ð�� Éj 5�H� í^î
ï� «ð�$. ��>?]^� = Kú� ûü�t ��L, `L¾c, jp �{ í, ��L
(� «ð�$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^ í^îï: & ® ��y�Í xy(y(� , µ,Ís
� , n�xy(Éj �I xy), jp� C� �{, "� �{, Mv�, � , -^ � , ®.
/¹ � v w]a , ��>?: & ® = K�ú� ûü�t ��L @ h, `�J 0m1 , ¥�`
L ¾c, ¨j��L ¨�, jp �{ í, > K� ç� >?, ���� �Ðd ��L
(v w$.
4) � a Q�L]��
@�^(�t � n�V ç� �_ /#� ^(�^ ¥â �J �t ä 255¢v$. @�
^(�t �D � ��� $��� â�,å ���� xy� �� �J @@å: �
FX �q, F q� �I��, o�� Y: p^� È��a , ��A r) v 2Ït �_$« �
, �� « �, 3é� £z �c H/ �a , = K� ûü�t §yâ ���� xy�
�� ~ Å� �@� ��V ú]^ ) �V Út �� +, ]^ �$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^t �?]^ �¤�p , Éjz � ¶�, �_$« � �
p , ��� � � \ p (v w$. �?]^ �¤ �p _� t � �� ©: �� â÷ �?� �
� o�C �J : ¨:�, ��, EYq�, ©:) ��� /� í^îï� �V �$. Éjz
� ¶�_� t ��C Éj y�Íxy * ¥�C �J [ Éj, ®; * Fq� c� �J �
`¤]^ � 5�H Éjy�Í xy� �� ��, r�) � û�V4$. �_$« � �
p _� t � �C� �(; �, �� «J x, � �)A ��� �J W%� �W * ô#�² �_
$« � � p í^5�� 2��$. ��� � � \ p _� t �J , �Ðd, >: ����
, Î� �I� /� $�� â÷ xy � V * � ·�{oó, 6�oó� W� = �$.
5) G K bZL]��
�ß^(�t & p H í�V `7|_ /#� ^(�^ ¥â �J �t 56¢v$. �ß
^(�t ���� b�< í^5��{� �� ‘����^ 3Év �#t � ’, $�� �
��� â÷ xy� �� ‘����^ �@� �’, §yâc Î�� Ý �: ����
� �� ‘ûü�t �@ �����’� «ð�$. ‘����^ 3Év �#t � ’_� t
� Z $�� ���� � Y� / � �D � F �) �a , $�� ���� xy�
II.� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y � �| 23
/� ���^ ��í^îï� @I�$. ‘����^ �@� �’_� t � �� Z ���
� xy� /� í^îï� @I�� ����: $�� â÷ � /� �� í * â÷ : ì�
«ð�$. ‘ûü�t �@ �����’_� t �A = K � � < §� í^îï� @I�
�, ���� xy� /� = K �ú ¾² í^îï� @I�$. ~� >, �J , �Ðd:
���� = � /� $�� í^îï� «ð�$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^ í^îï: & ® d8� , �oå, �ò, ð�º=» , �
}, �oå, �? , `}, §��oå, ð�, ¥���â÷ : ì , Jz��â ÷ xyv w]a ,
��>?: & ® cu} � , �� í, ���� IE * ¥V Lc w$.
6) _Z (� L]��
��^(�t ¥¯ßH õ�Ì_ /#� ^(�^ ¥â �J �t 155¢v$. ��^(
�t ���� í^5� >?� �� ‘�? , ¾ F ; w$’, ‘�, �?z v9� �t�s.’,
‘®Íc �� �?v_(.’ í^îï� «ð�$. ‘�? , ¾ F; w$’_� t ������L¨_
� ���� §�� ¨��$. = K: �?å� �sa , ²_5� �? í� «ð�$. ‘�,
�?z v9� �t�s.’_� t �?� �� �" í^îï * �?� ��v ûü�t 5� H
í^îï� > : ����_ `� K�ç�� /� í^îï� «ð�$. ‘®Íc �� �
?v_(’_� t � 1L Wz �� : È� �?� � @ h�$. ² p _t ¥J v ¾²�a �
J L� [\ ]^ «ðX$. �Ðd �?�> y�Ít �` ô# * ��� = �$. =K�ú
z `s�½� , �H½� (: ���>_ ¾²� ���� K�� ç��$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^ í^îï: & ® �D (è& Èö? , mN? , �ò? ,
î<o? , åe? , Èö? , c|? , º=» , ���� §�¨�), 5�H(; �Ð, Mv�,Ð, ð
�º=»Ð, Èö?Ð, ��� ;�Ð, :È� >é#vÐ, �òÐ)c w]a , ��>?: & ®
c<§�, f˧�, >��lv w$.
7) _d edL]��
ö�^(�t ¥¯�H Ì9V _ /#� ^(�^ ¥â �J �t 149¢v$. ö�^(
�t �J _� $�� ¥�����â ÷ xy� â�, v� =Z, ]^ � V �² �F X ©
:) * Mk å) � Ú®�, ¥�����_ `� o;\ �®A Á� Hd�� ö�§yâ
: ��� � �\ p xy� ¥@û� +, ]^ �$. v� /� ©W ‘�j? xy� �� ¥�
����� ¶�p ’ ���� í^5� >?� �� ©W �j? ��â÷ xy� $��
�� xy� � V û]^ �J v ����� �p � J x� � wH/ �$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^ í^îï: &® �j�p(cu}, �}, �}, Î}, Bj,
24│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
�j � �j) , ©W�j?(�? , µÎÍ, �j? ©W, �jy( [©, �j? EYxy, pBA
®./¹ ) , ¥�y( ·�ò(¥�y(/ú(, �ò), ��� µrX�xyv w]a , ��>?: &
® �j¨� �� � V , J y�Í(�jp ), �Ðd ·= Kú y�Í(���b J í^îï),
�Ðd * §� ¨�, �j �� â÷ �{ �V c w$.
8) *g � hL]��
�¢^(�t Ð9�KV }D�_ /#� ^(�^ ¥â �J �t 271¢v$. �¢^
(�t ���� í^5� >?å ‘ÿ BÍ^ î�ct �_$« �¤ : 3-84 �@ �
d# ’A ‘D\ �D� ��� �����’� «ð�$. ‘ÿ BÍ^ î�ct �_$
« �¤ : 3-84 �@ �d# ’: & ® �D : �� � �� �{� ò� ¡) �� ����
� /� è& � T) �$. ‘D\ �D� ��� �����’: & ® Ø: �d# ,
=É: �d# , �>: �d# , s�: �d# ^ ���² í^îï� «ð�$. Ø: �d#
t �� �� í^îï� @ I ·«ð��, =É: �d# t � þ xyå 5�H �s
m(Û. , 5�� �� í^îï� @I ·«ð��, �>: �d# t §yâA ûü�t ��
��� � Y��, s�: �d# t ���� � æ �^� í^îï� «ð�$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^ í^îï: & ® Ø: �d# , =É: �d# , �>:
�d# , s�: �d# c w]a , ��>?: & ® �������� : ��ç> = >
?å �? , �j, Ð9����= ¨�: 2012 �,v �Y��F ����� å �ðu= ,
�ðu= úZ��L: y�Í, �GÐ9 �j : �j¨Yj� , � BÍ �ÐdL: oÒy
�Í * o?A ûü�t �Ðdy�Íc w$.
9) iZ � ZL]��
) ß^(�t ì"ßH ôÆV yß�_ /#�t ^(�^ ¥â �J �t 57¢v$.
) ß^(�t ���� �� = >?� ‘���� � �\ p ’, ‘���� � Æ®p ’, ‘���
� +� *p ’^ �) �`$. ‘���� � �\ p ’_� t ����: K�� @p /� J
��c w]a , ���� �{� /� è& � T) �p / � p oF � ëì�� å,
åí¯� �½�$. ~� ���� ¨� â÷ �{ * §�¨�]^ ����� � � wt
²$� T) �$. ‘���� � Æ®p ’_� t í^5� �{ [\ : � �"�D� «ð
�$. )j(c©), pj(Æ�� , Mv�, , -^)� �?�a , î �_ �`; �� ; �¨� â÷
�� �? , vup A� , ºB¯ V s͵ Cp , I¹ , DEÛ, WcA: �ß (: �D �
«ð�$. ~� ����y�ÍA 5� H �� «ð�$. ����y�Í_� t I¹ , EÛÛ
�F, DEÛ, Æ�� 3[�(Æ�� , Mv�, , -^), �pB (� �a , 5� H �_� t
II.� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y � �| 25
+§, EÛÛ�F , �? , µ,Ís, �pB , >é#v, ; � (: �?�ò� «ð�$.
� ³ ºB¯ �¹ í� ���$. ‘���� +�*p ’_� t = K §yâ A: � <�
/� �]^ � §� Z §yâ y�Í� «ð��, È�L¨ §� * G>� �a , º=
» ð¤ * ð�� ¤ð�� È�H�� î,$. ~� r�) : +�� Ú®p /� §�� �
��$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^ í^îï: & ® í^5� �?: �" �D (c©,
Mv�, , -^, Æ�� , �`; �, +§, vup A� , ºB¯ V s͵, �? , WcA: �ß,
I¹ , DEÛ), ����y�Í(I¹ , EÛÛ�F , IEÛ, �pB , Æ�� 3[�), 5� H �
(�? , µ,Ís, +§� , EÛÛ�F , >é#v, �pB , ; �), ºB¯ ²_·c��¹ í
(V s͵, �`; �, +§, �oåâ÷ , ºB¯ ÍJô )c w$. ��>?: & ® ���� §�
� � $, ��" �D «ð� /� í^5� �, â÷ [\ : J * �J ���
� â÷ , � §� Z §yâ y�Í «ð, È�v �$-��ct ���p , r�) :
+�� ڮ$ (v w$.
10) G Z jkL]��
©Q^(�t & ¤ßH � �V _ /#�t ^(�^ ¥â �J �t 46¢v$. ©Q^(
�: ���� �� í^îï_t �D � ��� ����� «ð, ���� y�
Í, 5� H � «ð� �� ���� � V , §yâ (�J , >, �Ðd)c ûü ¾²
�t >? 2� (: �ò� õ� w$. ®a �D � ��� ����� «ð�p /�
�D _� ���� ¨� �ò� 2!�a , �D � F �) �² ©:, â÷ xy *
� �>A ���² í^îï� «ð�$. ���� y�Í, 5� H � «ð� �� ��
��� � V �p /�� t KLÐ * N¯ÍÔÐ (: ¨jp ¨� y�Í� «ð�a , 5
� H � Ð� ^ Æ�� , Mv�, , d$� , � �� �$. §yâ (�J , >, �Ð
d)c ûü ¾²�t >? 2�� /�� t J y�Í� TJ, ]^ «ð�a , ¬� �# ¯
�Ðd, = K�ú� `¤]^ �t y�ÍH «ð�$.
2012C «ð�t í^îï¢]^ í^îï: & ® ©Q KLÐ, ©Q N¯ÍÔÐ, Æ�
� , Mv�, , >é#v, d$@ , � �, UCC�W y�Í, cT>5 J y�Í , cT>5
�Ðd y�Íc w]a , ��>?: & ® �IEL, ����â÷ í^îï, ²_����
í, >(| = K�> ¾c, ���� ��� � W, õöo ��l ¾c, ���� �� �
=xy (v w$.
2012C ª�� = DX �=^ , ßa^ , `��)^ , � @�^ , �ß^ , ��^ , ö�^ , �¢
^, ) ß^ , ©Q^ ( 10@ ���� ��: YZ� DÍ �| <E Ⅱ-1>� O$.
26│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
\�H j� �� j� �| |�
Z�
��·
��_ �Õ� ¸& P
ü� ��� + �
� \�û& ���
Í`Y � ��� ,Y
_ Ð&Y+ ��?�
� ,� ! W< ���
�� + ½?/ `
W< � ÏZ& I=+
~Y
-� ��� ����+ ��ㆍ ç�"¾�# \�
'; ��� �� åÖ ����¥ �$% �
¥�,� \�û& �'_ �Y+ ��J� \�û¥ (
�ç \�� + �×/ ` W£) "
-� Pü� Ð&� �ùåÖ+ ��"¾� ]� �G ¯
ÍJ$ Ó� & �¿Y ^*
-� ��� ��\�û;+ Pü� � & I^G ÎÓ
"¾� ,½Õ& I^G ÎÓJ$ ��+ ,-
$ #¡J�< .0_ ��; [� �Í+ 1+
"
-� �]& ��Y¥ ��% �¥� ,� Pü� �ùåÖ+
×� '¥ "ü% �2
-� �� _ �� \� � ��& �� \�&
�¿Y¥ ô,' �¥� ,� \�® ���& 34�
% IÌ+ J£) "
-� í\ ó ��� 5� � ���ù\X ç
�+ �� ý��ùåÖ& I^G �L/ �¥�
�� Í`Y+ I + / �2
-� �®µ& Û�+ �� ��& 67+ Ûû `
W+ �¥�,� ��& �� �ù+ �� ��]^
�ÏZ; [� �÷+ $8?�� ,� ��;
[� f�¥ 9;' �2
-� ����_ "<J< �� ��]ö 6�
·�'_ �Y ��
·I�f
·Ð&Y,� ,Y
·,½Õ
·�Í
·Pü� � & I^
·�]& ��Y ��
·Ó� ¥ý� é
·\�® ��& �34
IÌ
·��; [� f�
�
·�� Í`Y
·ý��ùåÖ& I^ �
L
[�
�ܷ
���Õ�+ å*� ð
Ç¥ =ó> åÖ¾�
���� Í`Y "
ü
-� ®ø?,� ��$,� �?,� ,@,� [?,� �?,� Aë,� B$
¸& �I� ���Õ�� ç� � \�û& �I
IÌ+ ��
-� ���¥ ��I ��IÌ+ C; �����
+ �� �� Í`Y+ �E � Ð&ㆍ ,Y "ü
-� ����� ÏZ � �` ÏZ+ ~Y/ �2
-� \�& ����� + �� ��]^ � \�F
µ& ��G �� ����� & �Ú¥ % �
¥�,� GJ& ��å+ ã�?�+ % �2
-� [8ª,� D*K,� �>(=ó>)� ̧ & �����
åÖ¾� �� � _�+ ¥`J� ,� =ó> �Õå
Ö+ J+ % �2
-� \�,� �],� \�F& ����� & �>� º
L� \�& �� �'_ L�ÌÑ+ ��/ `
W0
·����; [� �
ù Ã�
·Í`Y
·Ð&ㆍ ,Y
·\�F-��]^ æ ��
·����� �Ú
·GJ ��å ã�
·�� �'_ L�ÌÑ
��
[c
NY·
��O�� åÖ+ ��
\�û& Í`Y � Ð
&Y �� � ��]^
; �á´ÄÅ cP
-� 1, 1�I �� � O� åÖ¾� �,& ��ÌÑ
+ ã�?�� ,� �� Í`Y � �ÕÑ ¬[ � 0
���G �fJ$ üYJ< ��� I�& �/+
�«/ �2
-� ��O�� åÖ+ �� ��+ (I$ ãäJ�
�Q; [� �ÕÑ¥ ã��ð ��O�� ��&
��Ñ¥ ã��� ,� í_È\� �B& '½; I
L/ ` W¾� ��ÜR& �+ Ã[J< I^G
ÎÓ
·�� Í`Y � �Õ
Ñ ¬[
·0���� I�& �
/
·�ãä
·í_È\� �B '½
·�ÕÑ ã�
·Ó� & '½
·��]^& �åY
<� Ⅱ -1 >� 201 2� ? U 1 0� �vy z\� Õ�
II.� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y � �| 27
-� Ó� p�& ��� & åY® % ` W<
�I .�
-� ���+ ×� ��� ����+ ç�"¾�
��]^& � åY; ILJ< á´ÄÅ cP
-� ���¥ �Ö,ëåÖ � í_È\�G �� �
� �ü+ Ië$ 0�� Í`Y � Ð&Y "ü
; IL
·��ÜR& � Ã[
·�� �ü
·Í`Y
·Ð&Y
%S
�·
\�û� T+ U$,� \
�< ,VPç \�G
Ûû�,� ��_ "<J
< �*� �?�+
Y
-� �� XR;% �� \�û;+ PüJ$ ���
, �� Zù_ åÖ+ ÎÓ"¾� ���
Í`Y � Ð&Y ��
-� �� ÷Y��+ �� \�YÑ �Î ��; £Z
-� \�û� �& L� �� �Ì+ �fJL �
�J$ ,½Õ& I·G .�J$ ��+ �>
ãäJ< ����,� ñ,® �, üY& I=
+ .�
-� �µ ÍY¥ [ < ,VPç \�,� (�ç \�,� \
Ý$ ]� \�® ��,� \�û;+ �� Í�+ �
S ` W< Óæ¾� �cYJL \�` ¹Í¾� ,
� \�& ¡^�ÎG �ú
-� ��Ø ���] _`¾� �� � _�¨+ ��
� ��� �]& �£ÌÑ+ ��
-� ��]^& �� ña åÖ � ��PÎ ��^
ºL ¸ ��; [� deY � ��� +
�� ��& I^ ¬®� ‘�v\� ’�< ik>®
ëlmJL \�,� \�F,� �] Fn® ÛoJ<
��& �� óÚ\�® % �2 .
-� ,e\�µ ��� ��� ���� `� �
ÄÅÆ ½?� ��& ��+ �� ÓÖ�Y ã
�
-� \�Fㆍ ����+ [�¾� J< Â��½ � �]
�Ö,ë ~q ç�
·��� Í`Y �
Ð&Y ��
·\�YÑ �Î ��;
£Z
·,½Õ
·�� �Ì �f
·�' ��
·���
·�, üY
·\�& �� � Ï
Z �Ü
·\�& ¡^�Î �ú
·�� � _�¨ �
�
·��& I^ ¬®
·ÓÖ�Y
·�� deY ¬®
·�� óÚ\�
ZI
`�·
��� r0¥ tg
< �½,� �*� \�,�
"<J< �* ��
\�
-� �½ v Pü� ��� ½Õ+ ×� 0�,� w
,,� � (�ð)� �� ��� _� �cY
-� Pü� ��� åÖ+ ×� ��� åÖ
'*+ Ü�J$ \�Ø � ��Ø ������ �
� � � åÖ ��
-� \X ó÷& ��� åÖ ç�+ ×� � _
� �cY � �]& �` åY
-� \� � v �� åÖ+ ×� ���� ��
-� ��& Pü� �ù+ ×� ,´5� � �ù&
x ç�
-� ��� åÖ+ ×� �� �� ºL ����
��
-� �],� \�,� \�F �� ��+ ×� Pü� �
��� ç�
-� �_ v ��� + �� Ð&Y � ý� Í�
ã�
-� �Õ � ,�� ��� & `�� de+ ��
'© � �ÕÌÑ ��
·Pü� �ùI^ ÎÓ
·�{��ù
·Ð&Y ã�
·ý�Í� ã�
·�ÕÌÑ ��
·`| Ø �
28│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
��
$%·
\�û& �� �ü
XE � �� Í`Y
"ü_ \�µ ��]^
®� ��+ ãäJ<
�åÓÖ�G àY
-� ��� + �� \�û& ��� Í`Y+
"üJL ����& �� � Ð~& �/+
`�
-� í_È\�; ��� ����+ �� ��
�ü+ IG �2
-� �� XR¾��4 ���$ W< \�û;+ �
�� + ���¾� ��"¾�% � � |c;
�}J� ��J$ ~Mì ,Y � Ð&Y "ü;
��� �ã
-� ��� ¥ Y \�� ���� ��
� ����¥ \�& ik> �ð GðJ� &
åY; IL
-� ��& �� ��µ& á´ÄÅG �� ��
� ÓÍ[G àYJ$,� \�® ��& �i�%
ëlm
-� \�F,� ���û_ "<J< �� åÖ+ ��
��� ÓÍ[G àY
·Í`Y
·\�® ����&
�� � Ð~�& �/
`�
·\�& ,ÿ�Ü
·�� �ü
·Ð&Y � ,Y "ü
·�'��
·��� ÓÍ[
��
«�·
Pü� �����
ùåÖ+ ���¥� �
v�¾� ½?JL Ð&
ㆍ ,Y+ �ê$,� ��
��; [� �÷
$8µ ãäG £F
-� \�& �� ÍY+ b�ê< ��½I� �
��� � ��� Ö,ë åÖ+ �� ��]^
�åY .,>G ~Y
-� ��� åÖ; ºL"¾�% �& �� L
�ÌÑ+ ��ㆍ ��J$ ,½Õ& I·G P�<
I^ ÎÓ
-� ��]^& ����& c÷Ú¥ �< ��
� F�+ cP/ �
-� ÐU ��> åÖ& �� ºLG �JL �+ �
åJ$ �,& ÷ýÑ¥ ¬[% �¥� ,� �& '%
G �ê� »Ö÷+ �ê$ Ð&ㆍ ,Y� ; IL
·Ð&ㆍ ,Y� ; IL
·�åY .,> ~Y
·�� ÍY
·,½Õ
·L�ÌÑ ��·��
·»Ö÷
·÷ýÑ
��
%H·
�� � _�_ ���
\���� ���
�+ ��ㆍ ç�"¾�
\�û& L�ÌÑ ��
_ ��� ÍY "ü
-� �� � _�_ ��� \���� ¥ \�û
& �� ÍY_ ¡Í ã�; £Z
-� � _� '½G �� \���� ����& ç
�¾� \���� & F�+ Î?
-� \�® �� ��� & �iµ �Ú\��% �
½~ Õ�+ >*J$ ª��& ��� ; �
��, �ã
-� \�û& �ÕÌÑã�_ ��� Í`Y& '+
ôL ��� ¡Í+ 1+ J� �,� ; £Z
-� ®�,� \�,� ��]^® "<J< ��� �ù
� ¾� �*� ÓÖ�G ~YJ� \�,� \�F,�
��]^ Fn& �& ' ã�; IL
·¡Í ã�
·��� Í`Y
·�,�
·�& ' ã�
·ÓÖ�
·�½~ Õ� >*
�
Y�·
� ��O� _�
ç�+ �� �*� �
�� \�ÛûI& þ�
ç F�+ Î?
-� �� �� �ù\X � Ó��� � �� �
ü "ü+ ×� �q� �`µ ��� ÏZ
�Ü � � I� Ãß,� ��� + �� ��
& ,Y "ü j� ¼� ¸ �� íã¾�& �
_� ���
-� \�® �_�O� _� ����+ ��J$ \�,�
�],� \�F® ��_& M�q� ��� ��
F�+ Î?JL G�J��& ��� & �à
+ Ûûð b=; IL � GJ��& åY
·��& ,Y"ü
·GJ��& åY
·ÓÖ�
·�é_ Ó¡
·�� Í`Y
·&]��& I^
·�Í �
II.� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y � �| 29
-� \� Óæ v \�Fµ ���¥ ��® �ð Ö,ë
G ç�J$,� �� Óæ¾� å*"¾� \��
�� ; [� ,ÿÃ[µ ��& ÓÖ� �I
=+ ~Y"
-� \�cY�_ ����¥ "< ñKG ¥*� ø�
�Ó�� ¼� � ÎU���´G ��JL jÎ� ��
jÓ; [� �÷+ ¬[?��,� �Ó��;% Pì �
�� åÖ+ ®Ì� "
-� Pü� �ù ó÷& �_ �O� de ¨¾� \�û
;+ ' ô� ý�� _ Ó���& ZùÃ[µ
�� Í`Y+ >[ "
-� \�û_ ����û& �I� �Ó� ½?�
\�µ ��_& ä[�� � � &]��& I
^ �
-� \';%Û ½���� �� åÖ+ ����_
"<J< Ó�åÖ+ �� ��K[;% ��J< I
^µ "< �Í �
Z�
Ð�·
��� ����
+ ��ㆍ �*"¾�#
\�û& T_ ÍY+
�ê�,� � �� \�
û& Iㆍ �Y+ ��
J$ Ó� & �¿G
^*J$ "
-� �I�cG �� ÷ý� Í`Y ��_ »�G �
� »Ö÷,� ��÷ ��¾� \�û& T_ ÍY
�� � ,½Õ
-� ���¥ ºLJL �I �� IÌ+ ��/ ` W<
Y ��� ���� ��JL \�û¥
�IG P�©% ÷ý� Í�_ ÍY¥ '© %
�2
-� �� '; ��� 34G ç�J$ ���
,��G cPJL ��; ��� & L�+ ~Y
J$ ÏZ+ cYJL \��Û ,O� � ÓÖ� F
n® "<J< ��� & §[G .�J$,� �
�¥ �$J+ "
·,½Õ
·Í`Y ��
·»Ö÷
·��÷
·÷ý� Í�_ ÍY&
'©
·�� ' ���
L� ~Y
·��� & L�+
~YJ$ ÏZ+ cY
4. � �!= XWY P� QR
ê ��_� ���� �� = >? �� �� � /� de z a���A 「 2011 ����
��) �� – ���� ��� [\ ]^ 」 _ sA wt �J , �, = K>L b c= E
� MO]^ �) �`$. �D � ��) de : nPz $� O$.
�È , �J , �, = K>L � ðK: p ê Q� Á= �$. vt ���� �� = >?:
p ê, R�v$. � ����� �� �J � �t éN = K>L_�= ð� Ô' Ý
�� = � �� dbc SS(win-win)�t V¶= ��� Hd�p / ûv$. î³�^ ��
�� ��: ��) z v � ðK_� $×�Ç u �$.
ÉÈ , �J: &® å) � ���� ðK� ���t ��$ �s: ðK]^ $×t �v Bö
�$(Evans & Skelton, 2001; Freedman, 2003; Prince, 2008; Gardner, 1990; Gelineau, 2012) .
; �: & ®, ��: EÞ�D � �ò, Éj , �? , V �]^ ���`]s v t �
30│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
�Ï� �Þ� �=�p /� �v= �Í�� cÏ#¯t :Ht �# $. ��: ��, å
[|� J �� � d� �Ï� �"�² cÏ#t �v M�J�$. ���� ��: ����
H � �È$ [\ � bt �Ït w]s p ê, ]^ �"� =��, � � ����z
�� , vp �$t �", å n) � 1t$(ç&W ㆍ �Î , 2008; z�; , 2010) . ¬� �# ¯
å) KV �Í] � wt �v �# ¯ �") � nP]^ �$. j¯� å) � ����� ��
�² ��) � �� �p �$t cq�| � ðK� [\ ]^ $×t �v M�J�$. v³�
5 z [@t ðK� ½ � wt �æ H w$.
<�Ê Ⅱ -2>� ý�& �� �|� _� (NSAE)& Á�
BD :� Consortium� of� National� Arts� Education� Associations(1 994).� National� Standarts� for� Arts�
Education:�What�every�young�american�should�know�and�be�acble�to�do�in�the�arts.� VA:� Music�
Educators� National� Conference.
ÊÈ , =Z, å ¨:� �� � /�� t �, oó: ½,� fc '(�$. nh �A
=K>L ðKz �� ¿�c wt= XY, ��c '(kp ��_ 2011C ��_� t \¼
|�57� >ò�`$. v� �� ���� �� = >?v �� ð� cǵt= � ��
�tñ �� p ²� M w$. � +, |�57z ��os >?��oc ;� �[�= Ü�
�� � ���t �z 57v$. î³s v³� ��� �� ��¬ ��c D ÍX �¾ v�
t v³� �� : D H� ëå� � wt W¨, oó� ½, �� f �t ½v [(�$.
v� /�� t � ðK� W¨ �g@Iv '(�$. v_ �A = K>L: �/=E�^
W¨ �g� @I�`$.
II.� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y ��| 31
⇓
<�Ê Ⅱ-3>� �_Y � �& `�
32 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
2011C_ � V � ‘2011 ���� ��) �� – ���� ��� [\ ]^’_� t a
���A ‘���� �� = >?’: n) � em�² �J , �, =K>L � ðK: ��)
=E� �) �² ��) � �� �`$. �J : & ® e>= � �� �, H�� >ò�`�, �
A = K>Lt \¼|� H�� >ò�`$. �J : & ® �J : Iá_ ¨� ��s \ ; ,
�� �� v �v ½,� w�� W¨, �g� @I�t �v cq�$. î³s ����
� �� �A =K>L: ¿�_ ¨� ��t � : ��, ½, X ��M �H ��� W¨,
�g� � p c Å= ·$. î³�^ XY, � _� \¼|�57 � >ò�`$. î M��
m`^ � c= �/ = E � �â, �� � ���u$. v� m`^ �Æ� �v <î<Ⅱ
-3>: p� ��) b c de v$.
1) �B lC
2011 ��_�t �J: ��)z o�/�@r, EY/©:), Ýy/>L) ðK: å), ��A
Éj, ;�, §�: ����, ��) � [D�`$. v � ðK -� �_�H p�: �
���: �� _� sBà $�� �� � �û��o �`$. v_ op�qr, pq, ©:
)/����, r), Í~� , ��{zH, D���, opEY/IE�, >L) (� -�� ��)
bc de_ �û�`$. <E Ⅱ-2>t 「 2011 ������ ��) �� 」 _�: �J_ `� �
�) =E� �â,]^ sB¬ �v$.
cs �� s�
,Y
¡/�*Í
�Õ/Ð&Y
»Ö/]^Y
�
�Y
0�
ý�
Ó�
1.I�ÌÍ
2.IÌ
3.Ð&Y /��� ÍY
4.�
5.�_\X{£
6.�%�Î
7.I�Õ/��Ñ
8.]^Y
<� Ⅱ-2>� ‘2011� ��� �_Y �c –� �vyz\� ó÷¾� ’;% \�; [� �_Y ��
II.� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y � �| 33
2012C ª�� 10@ ^(�c ������^ =DP_ j¯ 1� CHÐ� î ��)� ��
� '()v �pu$. v� /� p�: ��) de� em�² �D� '(H �pu$. v_
���Ý:LA 4C� ������� «ðki > � m[ ��l� �� $É: ��æv =
,u$.
�È , �J _ `� ��) b c_� å) , ðKÐ�å o�/�@rv �����: ¨�) _
� }� �$t �� æ v � pu$. T>M�_� H o�/�@rv ���� �� ��) �
� _� Á:; � �vc sBs= ·z �]^ ëåu$.
ÉÈ , hU �V�� ¨�� çT� wt op �H) , op T¹� , Û�¹Û =� (
v ¿ ~ �â , å å) , ðK_ �T] '() v �pu$.
ÊÈ , ����, ðK_� t Éj, ; �, §�: � �/ ðKv ���� �� ��) b
cde v $�� ‘���� �� = >?’: í^îï� õ��= Ü�� w]a , ��: U�
H �¢�= ·z �]^ �� c � pu$. nh hU ��z éNv� # A ����H �X ,
�", i"�: &v w�, b c_� H ��b c ( å�: å) vs q�� i",]^ b c
�t &� ��� � �Ï: ��z �z 57 v �# $. ¬� �# ¯ å) , ðKå Ý y/>
L) � ����, ðK: >L) v [@X$t =, H wu$.
ÔÈ , p�: �g H Ð�,]^ �T�� �D� '() H �p u$.
v_ �J _ `� ��) �� _� å) , ðK� ����, ðK� ���= ·� �"�
² b c= E� W) �`$. v� � @: � ðK� ô D �² [@� Y�, ����� å) ð
K� $ õ� � wt 6c= ðK� ô D�`$. � ³ � ðK_� �g� �¤� , =s#
� �z �g]^ å� Å) � � qr� Yp / � cq� �g�� � ��² �) �`$. <E
Ⅱ-3>z �J ðK: 6c= ðK� �f �gv$()z� , 2006; µ&oㆍ �zZㆍ vZ�ㆍ 6ç:,
2007; øðㆍ �)Qㆍ D&z, 2008; Achenbach & Edelbrock, 1983; Achenbach, 1991).
34│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
® �� � �� �$
1.� I �ÌÍ
-ñ< ��; �Ì¥ WP.
-�XJ© �?#P � �,' ` WP$ ���P.
-ñ< ñ;+ �ð� _ÎG ¤ó+ � �P.
-ñ< ñ;+ �ð� _ÎG ÀÜ+ P�%< J< õ¥P.
-' ÌѾ�< Î[� / ` W< �¥ �P.
-ñ< ñ;+ ½�/ :® òP.
-ñ< K�¥�� �¥ WP.
,Y��&
¡Í �O
2.� �� Í`Y
-ñ< ��+ �� ÍÖ+ � ��P.
-ñ;+ ��� ó|JP.
-ñ< ��+ �� �¥ (�Ä�P.
-ñ< ]�û_ �� ¥øIG ò¥ J< õ¥P.
-ñ< ��+ �?#P � �$ ]P.
-ñ< �� ��Ó�+ #$ ]P.
-ñ< ��; [� �÷ �P.
3.� Ð&Y
-ñ< �ýW< ��û+ ò¥ �P.
-ñ< þ�ç �+ � ��� �P.
-ñ< þ�ç íÿ¾� �ÎG �úJ< Zê® òP.
-ñ< Ð&�¥�< + û+ :® òP.
-ñ< � ®�G #© L ®� ��û¥ ¡�ìP.
-�cû¥ J� h< þ�ç ��+ J< �¥ (¢P.
-þ�ç �+ �ê< �¥ �P.
,Y��&
Ð&Y �O
4.� I ~¯Ñ
(ÓÔY)
-® ñ< b¥ W��£ º+ ` WP.
-ñ< �é& £Ñ¥ñ ä�+ � ¥¤¥ ` WP.
-¦¨�§£ .0+ ��?¨ ` WP.
-ñ< ÁÁ ©ª®G :� �$ ]P.
-ñ< ® ñ% �ëG � �ñ K«®G �`$ ]+ :® WP.
-ñ< �cñ àÎû_ � ¬çP.
-ñ< + ò¥ J< õ¥P.
5.� I�Õ_
��Ñ
-ñ< ' ��+ � ®J< õ¥P.
-'® �-< Í�+ Pì ]�û¥ ,< �¥ ¯P.
-��+ �� ' Is¥ñ ��+ �Õ/ ` WP.
-Pì ]�û °;% ��J< �¥ (¢P.
-ñ< ��/ : �± Z+ ��P.
-©® ?�I #P< ³³� ñ%% ��/ :® òP.
-ñ< ' ��+ Î[� �Õ ²/ :® òP.
6.� »Ö_ ]^Y
-ñ< Pì ]�& `�+ � ¥�J< õ¥P.
-ñ< �cû_ � �'< õ¥P.
-ñ< ]�û+ � £µ|P.
-ñ< �cû& ®+ � ûð |P.
-ñ< ' / bÛ J� Pì ]�;+< �÷¥ �P.
-ñ< �+ �³/ :® òP.
-ñ< ' ��_ ´�£ �� &f+ µìP.
,Y��&
»Ö/]^Y
�O
<� Ⅱ-3>� �Ü \�& �_Y ® Fà � � ��
II.� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y � �| 35
�� ¶� �� '* �¿ £
I �ÌÍ
1 ñ< � � sø; � Ì¥ WP.
.773
2 � � åÖ� �XJ© �?#P � �,' ` WP$ � ��P.
3 ñ< ñ;+ �ð � _Î ; ¤ ó+ � �P.
4 ñ< ñ;+ �ð � _Î G × � À Ü + P�P.�
5 ' ÌѾ�< Î [� / ` W< �¥ �P.(R)
6 ñ< ñ;+ ½�/ : ® òP.(R)
7 ñ< K�¥�� � ¥ WP.
��Í`Y
8 ñ< � � åÖ+ �� ÍÖ+ � ��P.
.895
9 ñ;+ � � åÖ� ó|JP.
10 � � åÖ+ �� ñ& � å¥ (�Ä �P.
1 1 ñ< ]�û_ � � åÖ; [� ¥ øI G ò¥ J< õ ¥ P.
1 2 ñ< � � åÖ; [� �?#P � �$ ]P.
1 3 ñ< �� � �sø �? ㆍ Ó�+ #$ ]P.
14 ñ< � �; [� �÷ ¥ �P.(R)
Ð& Y
15 ñ< � ýW< � �û+ ò¥ �P.
.895
16 ñ< þ �ç �+ � � �� �P.
17 ñ< þ �ç íÿ ¾� �Î G � úJ< Zê® òP.
18 ñ< Ð& � ¥�< + û+ : ® òP.
19 ñ< � ®� G #© L ®� � �û¥ ¡�ìP.
20 �cû¥ J� h< þ �ç � �+ J< �¥ (¢P.
21 þ �ç �+ �ê< �¥ �P.
I~¯Ñ
(ÓÔY )
22 ñ< ® ñ< b¥ W��£ º+ ` WP.
.720
23 ñ< �é& £Ñ¥ ñ ä�+ � ¥¤¥ ` WP.
24 ¦¨�§£ .0+ �� ?¨ ` WP.
25 ñ< ÁÁ ©ª®G : ë$ ]P.(R)
26 ñ< ® ñ% �ëG � �ñ K«®G �`$ ]+ :® WP.(R)
27 ñ< �cñ à Î û_ � ¬çP.(R)
28 ñ< + ò¥ J< õ ¥ P.(R)
<� Ⅱ -4>� \�& �_Y À Á ��
���� ���� �� õö> �: Ý : ^ �gv aDu]a OO=K 4, 5, 6 �C
�� 3�� , db 9@ �� �J � `¤]^ C½\ e>� � V �`$. ô �� � V � >
� �� �g: �Þvs v�� (_ `� :ã� sËu]a ²]7 ( Ro� � þ ��t
n�h �D� �òv �$� µ��² 9c_ 10@ �\ ���� �� 4, 5, 6�C� `¤]
^ T>� � V �`$. î M� � ðK� �dHA ¥â �dH(Cronbach ¢C )c �Q��
sA hi �g]^ ëD �`$. hi, ]^ aD X �g� �dHt <E Ⅱ-4>A O$.
36│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
�� �_Y ��
1 .� \�& �� ÏZ �Ü
1 )� Ý�ㆍ ,� � Ãß
2)� I� ' ]^ � àY
3)� \�& [�� á´ÄÅ àY
2. \� cY�& ��� �⠬�
1 )� �� ãä
2)� �� �
3)� �� ÐU
3.� \�& �=� � Ñ ã�
1 )� \� �æ ç� �è& é
2)� \� � _�& é
3)� \� ç� j� óÚ ]ö é
4)� �' �Î �ú �_
5)� �]& ��Y ã�
<� Ⅱ-5>� ‘2011� ��� �_Y �c –� �vyz\� ó÷¾� ’;% \�; [� �_Y ��
�Õ � ��Ñ
29 ñ< ' � �+ � ®J< õ ¥P.
.723
30 '® �-< I s+ Pì ]�û¥ ,< �¥ ¯P.(R)
31 � � åÖ+ �� ñ& I s¥ ñ � �+ �Õ/ ` WP.
32 Pì �cû °; % ��J< �¥ (¢P.�
33 ñ< ��/ : �± Z+ ��P.(R)
34 ñ< Ü �·¥ ?�I �; ³³� ��/ : ® òP.
35 ñ< ' � �+ Î [� �ÕJ� ²/ : ® òP.(R)
» Ö � ]^ Y
36 ñ< �cû+ � ¥ � �P.
.794
37 ñ< �cû_ ]¥�+ ��P.
38 ñ< �cû+ � £µ|P.
39 ñ< �cû& ®+ � ûð|P.
40 ñ< Pì �c;+< �÷ ¥ �P.(R)
41 ñ< �+ �³/ : ® òP.(R)
42 ñ< ' � �_ ´�£ �� �cû& & f+ µìP.
*� (R)� ��� �� �¿£ =� .930
2) �� lC
�: ��) =Et �: é, , å, n) � ���² � ¨Ío, >, �ÐdA: |
�T>� �� 2!�`]a , �: ���� è& @a, � �) : ����, K� ��,
�: ¥�, � ¤, `þ, �� ��, =K>L: ���� åí¯ xò (]^ �)
utñ, v_ `��t �D�u �$t :ãv �u$. <E Ⅱ-5>t 「 2011 ������ ��
) �� 」 _�: �_ `� ��) =Ev$.
II.� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y � �| 37
4.� [�� �_ ¬�1)� \�; [� [� ¥ý� �Ü
2)� \�; [� �× � �� I�& �÷_ ��
5.� ��]^& �� ,�� å*1 )� �� I= ?¼ å*
2)� �� �& �]Y_ ��+ =�� ��U� Ð~
�� � ��
1.� \�& ��
ÏZ �Ü
1 )� Ý�ㆍ ,� � Ãß
-êë \�;< ��+ / ` W< £cñ �º® òP.
-êë \�;< ��+ / ` W< ?¼¥ �� õ¥P.
-êë \�;< ��+ � ® ��< sû¥ WP.�
-êë \�;% ��+ �S ` W< I^® ò� õ¥P.�
-êë \�;< ��� + ×� � º® ßs� õ¥P.
-êë \�< ��� + ×� �¥ ßsJP.
2)� I� ' ]^ � àY
-êë \�< �� �]G � å*�P.
-êë \�< \�Fû¥ \�;% åÖ+ ò¥ �P.
-êë \�< ��� �Ø� �£® ®ÌJP.
3)� \�& [�� á´ÄÅ àY
-êë \�< ��]^& ����µ »Ñ+ � �P.
-êë \�µ ��]^< »d� ��G ¼$ WP.
-êë \�< ��]^ �]; ò¥ ºL�P.
-êë \�< �� ' ��I�& ��+ ½<P.
(-êë \�< �� ' ��I�& � � »~G ½<P)
2.� \� cY�&
��� �⠬�
1 )� �� ãä
-êë \�< �Á �?^G ò¥ �P.
-êë \�< Ó�+ ò¥ �P.
-êë \�< Ó� � �? ��+ ò¥ �P.
-êë \�< �� 5�G �P.
-êë \�;< ��� ¾�O¿ àY¥ � �ð WP.
2)� �� �
-êë \�< Pü� �� � + �P.
-êë \�< �]û& ��; [� �÷_ ÌÑ¥ ò� � ÀP.
-êë \�< ��� ; ò� ÁÑ+ �P.
-êë \�< �� `ö ?æ¥ òP.
-êë \�< �� sø äH� ]�¥ µ% `ö+ ��� �¥ WP.
3)� �� ÐU
-êë \�< þ�ç �� U�+ Û�P.
-êë \�< þ�ç ��+ ÐU�P.
-êë \�;< �� ÐU åÖ+ / ` W< Óæ¥ ò¥ WP.
-êë \�;< \�û¥ �& ��� �'+ �Õ/ ` W< Óæ¥ WP.
<� Ⅱ-6>� \�; [� �_Y ��; µì � ��
�: ��) = E� p Þ]^ ���v �f �g� @I� �v <E Ⅱ-6>_ sBs w$.
38│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
3.� \�& �=�
� Ñ ã�
1 )� \� �æ ç� �è& é
-êë \�< Pì \�; �� � _� ç�¥ P + ç��< � ÀP.
-êë \�& �æ � _� ç�� ÂóÄP.� �
-êë \�< \�� _� ç� ? ���, ��¥ � ¥�ð�$ W< � ÀP.
2)� \� � _�& é
-êë \�< Pì \�µ Ø� p¥® �P.
-êë \�< Pì \�; �� ��� & �ó¥ ô� õ¥P.
-êë \�< ��� + ×� �`·\Xíî+ ��JÅP/�c�P.
-êë \�& ��� + ×� � _�¥ Pì \�; �� ���¥P.
3)� \� ç� j� óÚ ]ö é
-êë \�< �� �_ ó÷¥P.
-êë \�< ��� ó÷¾� ç� P.
-êë \�< �ùåÖ+ ó?�P.
-êë \�& � íî� Ð&�¥P.
-êë \�< �,�, ,æ¾� Y�J+ J<Æ óÚ+ n$ WP.
4)� �' �Î �ú �_
-êë \�< �å�£® � ¨ �< õ¥P.
-êë \� ,¥û� �ή òP.
-êë \� ,¥û� + ò¥ �P.
-êë \� ,¥û� � ¬çP.
-êë \� ,¥û� �]û_ &]��¥ � ¨ �< õ¥P(R).
5)� �]& ��Y ã�
-êë \� �]û� ê`JP.
-êë \� �]û� Pü� �`î+ ]*�P.
-êë \� �]û� \¹Z�+ � J< õ¥P.
-êë \� �]û& ��� �ù I^® W< õ¥P.
-êë \� �]û� ��� ÌÑ+ 1Ç õ¥P.
-êë \� �]û� ��� .,>® cP�ð WP.
-êë \� �]û� ��� ; �>�¥P.
4.� [�� �_ ¬�
1)� \�; [� [� ¥ý� �Ü
-êë \� ¥ý�< é"¥ �P.
-êë \�< \� `® ÚÚ �ðû �¥P.
-êë \�< °¾� Å+ ��/ �¥P.� �
-êë \�< �� ]^ ��; £Z¥ P.
2)� \�; [� �× � �� I�& �÷_ ��
-� È;% êë \�; [� ò� ��+ �P.
-� È;% êë \�; [� É�+ �P.
-� È;% êë \�G �P.�
-� È;% êë \�& � _�; �÷¥ òP.
-� È;% êë \�& ��� `ö; �÷¥ òP.
-� È;% êë \�; ��� ���� �� ��+ ò¥ �P.
5.� ��]^& ��
,�� å*
1 )� � � I= ?¼ å*
-êë \�< � �& ?¼+ � å*J< õ¥P.
-êë \�< � �& � ë� L�+ � ; å*�P.
-êë \�< � �& �� I�& » ~G c�P.
2)� �� �& �]Y_ ��+ =�� ��U� Ð~
-êë \�< êë � ��G � ; � å*�P.
-êë \�< êë � �& �]µ ��+ Êë�$ ÁÑ�P.
-êë \�< � � ]^ ; �� ��& �+ cPJ�$ ÁÑ�P.
II.� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y � �| 39
�� J× �� ¶� �� '* � ¿ £
��
ÏZ�Ü
Ý� ·,
� �
1 êë \�< ��� ����+ ç�J<Æ å* ` W< £c
ñ �º® òP.
.880
2 êë \�< ��� ����+ ç� / ` W< ? ¼¥ ��
õ¥P.
3 êë \�;< ��� + �«/ ` W< sû¥ WP.�
4 êë \�< ��� + Zù/ ` W< I^ ® ò� õ¥P.�
]^ �
à Y
5 êë \�< �]µ �]& F2¥ å�JP.
6 êë \�< �Á Ö,ë åÖ¥ å�JP.
7 êë \�< �],� \�F,� \�,� ����¥ "< &ËJ< b¥ òP.
[� �
á´Ä Å
8 êë \�< � �]^ & �� I�ㆍ ��µ »Ñ+ �P.
9 � � ]^ < êë \�& �vy z\� ]ö+ �$ WP.
1 0 êë \�< � �]^ & �� �]; ºL �P.
1 1 êë \�µ � �]^ < �� �� � #G Óä�P.
��
� �
ãä
12 êë \�< � �sø �?^ G �P.
.907
1 3 êë \�< � �sø Ó�+ �P.
1 4 êë \�< � �� ¥ �å�ð WP.
�
15 êë \�< Pü� � �� ����+ ç� �P.
1 6 êë \� �]û� � �; [� �÷ _ ÌÑ¥ WP.
1 7 êë \�< � �� & åY ; ò� ÁÑ+ IS,P.
1 8 êë \�< ©cñ � JIÛ J© � �� + ½+ ` WP.
ÐU
19 êë \�& � �sø �?< º� JP.
20 êë \�& � � Ó�� º�JP.
21 êë \�< þ �ç �� sø; [� �÷ ¥ ô$,� \� ç�;
djJ�$ ÁÑ�P.
� Ñ
ã�
�æç�
�è
22 êë \�< Pì \�; �� �æ � _� ç� íî¥ pØ P.
.871
23 êë \�& �æ � _� ç�� �è + ïðñ< Zê® òP.(R)
24 êë \�< ��� , íÿ _ P + �æ ç� �è + �çP.
� _�
é
25 êë \�& � _�� Pì \�µ Ø� p¥® �P.(R)
26 êë \� � _� � Pì \�; �� � �� & �ó¥ ô
� õ¥P.
27 êë \� � _� � “�vy z\� ]ö ”� ?� ¥�_ P P.
<� Ⅱ -7>� \�; [� �_Y � �µ À Á ��
���� ���� �� õö> �: Ý :^ �g� aD �² 9c_ 10@ �\ ����
��: >A ç>� `¤]^ e>� � V �`$. î M� � ðK� �dHA ¥â �dH
(Cronbach ¢C )c �Q�� sA� hi �g]^ ëD�`$. hi,]^ aDX �gz <E
Ⅱ-7>� O$.
40 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
ç�j�
óÚ ]ö
28 êë \�< �� �_ ó÷ ¾� ç� P.(R)
29 êë \�< � �� + ó÷ ¾� ç� P.
30 êë \�< � �sø �ùåÖ¥ ò� õ ¥P.
�'�Î
� ú
31 êë \�< �å� £® � ¨ �< õ ¥P.(R)
32 êë \� \�û� �ή òP.(R)
33 êë \� \�û� + ò¥ J< õ ¥P.(R)
34 êë \� \�û� � PÎ¥ Ïð� < õ ¥P.(R)
�]
��Y
35 êë \� �]û� \�û& ¡Z+ ½<P.
36 êë \� �]û� Pü� �`î+ ]*�P.
37 êë \� �]û� \¹Z�+ � J< õ ¥P.
38 êë \� �]û� � �sø �`ÌÑ¥ ÐðñP.
[� �
�_¬�
¥ý�
�Ü
39 êë \�< $� ¥ý� ® WP.(R)
.789
40 êë \�< \� `® Ú Ú �ðû �¥P.(R)
41 ��� ¾� êë \�; [� þ �ç ,ÿ + ÷ ð� ` W+
�¥P.�
42 êë \�� �\ ��< �� ]�® WP.
�× I�
� �
43 � È¥ñ � � �È;% êë \�; [� ò� � � + �P.
44 êë � íg ��; % êë \�; �÷ _ � � + � |P.
45 �¹ I�û¥ êë \�G �P.
� �
,��
å*
� �? ¼
å*
46 êë \�< � �_ ��� � � & ? ¼+ å*�P.
.902
47 êë \�< � �& � ë� L�+ � �� ; � å*�P.
48 � � ]^ ® ��_ ��JL êë \�G å*�P.
� ��
å*
49 êë \�< � ��G ��� ; � å*�P.
50 êë \�& � �� � êë � �& ��+ Êë�$ ÁÑ�P.
51 êë \�& � �� ;< � �& �]® �¤WP.
*� (R)� �� � �� � ¿ £ =� .956
3) �C�m lC
= K>L: ��) =Et �^ 4C� ���� ��: = K�ú� ç> : |�T>� �
� 2!�`]a , <E Ⅱ-8>� Ov =K: ���� è& @a, = K�ú: ����, K�
��, = K: è& @a , = K: ���� åí¯ xò (]^ �)�`$.
II.� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y ��| 41
�� � ��
1 .� ��& ��
ÏZ �Ü
1 )� Ý�ㆍ ,� � Ãß
-êë ��;< ��+ / ` W< ?¼¥ � �ð WP.
-êë ��;< ��+ / ` W< £cñ �º® òP.
-êë ��;< ��+ � ® ��< sû¥ WP.
-êë ��;% ��+ �S ` W< I^® ò� õ¥P.�
-êë ��;< �� ¾�O¿® cP�ð WP.
2)� ��]^ ' ]^ � àY
-êë ��� �� �]G c/ ` WP.
-êë ��� ��+ J< ]�û¥ òP.
-êë ��; �� åÖ; ºLJ< ]�¥ òP.
-êë ��;< �� ��Y+ ®� ]�û¥ òP.
3)� [�� á´ÄÅ àY
-êë ��� ��]^& ����û¥ %� »Ñ+ ��P.
-êë \�µ ��]^< »d� ��G ¼$ WP.
-êë �� \�® ��]^ �]; ò¥ ºL�P.�
-êë �� ' ��I�û� �� ' ��� ,ÿ Ã�; ILG J$ WP.
2.� ����&
��� �⠬�
1 )� �� ãä
-êë ��� �Á �?^G ò¥ �P.
-êë ��� Ó�+ ò¥ �P.
-êë �� ' �� ºL I^® òP.
-êë ��� �� �ù Óæ¥ òP.
<� Ⅱ-9>� �Ü ��]^; [� �_Y ��; µì � ��
� �� �_Y ��
1.� ��& �� ÏZ �Ü
1 )� Ý� ㆍ ,� � Ãß
2)� ��]^ ' ]^ � àY
3)� [� � á´ÄÅ àY
2.� ����& ��� �⠬�
1 )� �� ãä
2)� �� �
3)� �� ÐU
3.� ��& ÏZ �Ü
1 )� Ýë� ÏZ �Ü
2)� ]^ � ã�
3)� ��]^ �Î �ú
4)� [� � �_
4.� ��& �� ,�� å* 1 )� ��]^ ' �?�,� Ó��,� �Ý�,� £% � å*
2)� ��]^ ' �ä�-¼,� ä�� ,� ]�,� × , ¸-å*
<� Ⅱ-8>� ‘2011� ��� �_Y �c –� �vyz\� ó÷¾� ’;% ��]^; [� �_Y ��
���v = K>L: ��) = E� p Þ]^ �f �g� @ I� �v <E Ⅱ-9>_ sBs
w$.
42 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
2)� �� �
-êë ��� Pü� �� � + �P.
-êë ��� ��û& ��; [� �÷_ ÌÑ¥ ò� � ÀP.
-êë ��� ��� ; ò� ÁÑ+ �P.
-êë ��� ��+ ×� � � �¥ òP.
-êë ��; ��� .,> Ã�+ ×� ��� ����û¥ WP.
3)� �� ÐU
-êë ��;%< �� U�+ Û>< ]�û¥ òP.
-êë ��� þ�ç ��¥ Ûûð�< Ñ¥P.
-êë ��� ��� �Õ+ / ` W< Ñ¥P.
3.� ��& ÏZ �Ü
1 )� Ýë� ÏZ �Ü
-êë ��;%< �� ?¼¥ �P.
-êë ��;%< .0Û Ò¾© ��+ (Ó ` W< ÏZ¥P.
-êë ��& �I= ?¼ ×gG �$ WP.
2)� ]^ � ã�
-êë ��;%< �� Ó�J< ]�û¥ òP.
-êë ��;%< ��+ �&/ ` W< ]�û¥ òP.
-êë ��;%< ��+ �ê< ]�¥ òP.
-êë ��; ��+ �ê �< ]�¥ WP.
3)� ��]^ �Î �ú
-êë ��;%< ]� ]$® ò¥ bð³P.
-êë ��;%< ¥r-ë ¬ê< Zê® òP.
-��� êë �� ]�û+ �ú?ÔP.
-êë ��� ÓÖ�&ÿ¥ �JP.
-êë �� ��û� ��® �P.
4)� [�� �_
-êë ��� ÚÚ ��û¥ �ð�P.
-êë ��� ÊI �� Ñ¥P.
-êë ��¥ Õ³ÄP.�
-êë ��+ �Õ/ ` WP.
-êë ��; [�% �+ ��P.
-êë ��+ Ö#/ �¥P.
4.� ��& ��
� ,�� å*
1 )� ��]^ ' �?�,� Ó��,� �Ý�,� £%� å*
-êë ��� �?�¥ñ Ó��+ ò¥ ¥*�P.
-êë ��� �Ý�¥ñ £%� ¸+ ò¥ ¥*�P.
-êë ��;< ��& Y+ Ê× ` W< �� ?¼¥ WP.
-êë ��; Pì Öá ]�û;+ �ë$ ]� �I=?¼¥ WP.
-êë ��;< êë ��+ [�/ ` W< �?¼¥ L± WP.
-êë ��; ����¥ ºL/ ` W< �?¼¥ WP.
2)� ��]^ ' �ä�-¼,� ä��,� ]�,� ×, ¸-å*
-êë ��� ��& �ä�+ ��� ; � å*J$ WP.
-êë ��� �ä�; �� ��� � ýØJP.
-êë ��; ×g� \�< ��]^ ' �ä�+ �_�¾� å*J$ WP.
-êë ��� �� Ö#G � J$ WP.
-êë ��� ��I� �� º¤_ Ö#¤¥ WP.
-êë ��� �I� º¤+ ÎU� �¥ WP.
II.� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y � �| 43
m '�� ���� �� õö> �: Ý :^ �g� aD �² 9c_ 10@ �\ ����
��: =K�ú� `¤]^ e>� � V �`$. îÍ� � ðK� �dHA ¥â �dHc
�Q�� sA� hi �g]^ ëD �`$.
�� J× �� ¶� � � � ¿ £
��
ÏZ�Ü
Ý� ·,�
�
1 êë � � ;< ��+ / ` W< ? ¼ ¥ � �ð WP.
.928
2 êë � � � � �; å*/ ` W< £cñ �º® òP.
3 êë � � ;< ��+ � ® ��< sû¥ WP.
4 êë � � ;% ��+ �S ` W< I^ ® ò� õ ¥P.
]^ �
à Y
5 êë � �;% < � ���,� \�,� ÓÓI�,� Iö ¸¥ �� ¸
; �� % % � » Ñ+ � �P.
6 êë � � ;< ��_ �� ]�û& F2¥ å�JP.
á´Ä Å
7 êë � � ;% < � � I�ㆍ ��û¥ % � »Ñ+ ��P.
8 êë � � ; W< \�< � �]^ µ »d� ��G ¼$ WP.
9 êë � � & \�< � �]^ �]; ò¥ ºL�P.
��
��
ãä 10 êë � � � �Á �? ^ ® ò¥ ÙÇP.
.826
1 1 êë � � � �Á Ó�¥ ò¥ ÙÇP.
� 12 êë � � ��û� � �; [� �÷ _ ÌÑ¥ òP.
1 3 êë � � � � �� ; ò� _G �P.
ÐU
14 êë �� ��û� ��G J�ñ �� U�+ ûðÚ I^® WP.
15 êë � � � ��û¥ ��G J�ñ �� U�+ Ûû ` W£
) V�J< s× I¥P.
� �&
ÏZ�Ü
Ýë�
ÏZ
16 êë � � � �åJ<Æ ¦õ"¥ �< ? ¼+ 16$ WP.
.863
1 7 êë � � � L ®� ? ¼¥ WP.
]^ �
ã�
18 êë � � ;% < � ���,� \�,� ÓÓI�,� Iöû¥ % � � » Ñ
J< s× I¥P.
19 êë � � ;% < L ®� F2û¥ å�JP.
� � �Î
� ú
20 êë � � ;% < ]� �]$® ò¥ bð³P.(R)
21 êë � � ;% < ¥r-ë P_< Zê® òP.(R)
22 �� åÖ� êë � � ]�û+ �ú?¨ �¥P.
[� �
�_
23 êë � � � ÚÚ ��û¥ �ð�P.(R)
24 êë � � � ÊI �� Ñ¥P.
25 êë � � ¥ Õ³ÄP.
,��
å*
? ¼ å* 26 êë � � & �? �¥ñ Ó��� ¥*Û¥ ôP.
.81827 êë � � & �Ý�¥ñ £% � ¸ �? ¼� ¥*Û¥ ôP.
�ä�
å*
28 êë ��;%< ��& �ä�+ ��� ; � å*J$ WP.
29 ��� êë ��]^ ��; ���, �ã+ ý�P$ ���P.
*� (R)� ��� �� � ¿ £ =� .91 7
<� Ⅱ -1 0>� �Ü � �]^ ; [� �_Y  ® Fà _ À Á ��
Ⅲ. ���� ��� ����
� ��
1. �B
2. ��
3. �C�m
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 47
Ⅲ. ���� ��� ���� � ��
��) T>t 10@ ���� �� í^îï v È�Ít 12c_ � Vu]a , �J :
& ® í^îï: ¾²c �= ·z 1, 2�Cz � þ��, 3, 4, 5, 6�C� ` ¤]^ ¥� T>
�`$. îÍ� �ö �: >A ç>H ¥� T>�`]a , = K�ú: & ®_t �� 10
¢ ¥H^ T>�`$.
1. �B
�m X qr= [ Á�� qr=: Em n) z <E Ⅲ-1>� O$.
�J : ��) `� T> M�t ²^ ðK�^ bn æ �A �g�^ bn æ �� �� �$.
¿å�^ ��, å �vc sBà �� EA î�í^ � V �$. �g�^t =|¨�¤ db
�� �= ·�, ��, �vc à � [ : ; wt � [\ ]^ a��� p ��$. db 5æ
ÁH^ æ �c ���/ �ö ��_ ;D, ]^ r� �� :; �$. ¢+ÁHA fÒÁH:
n) � db 1� wp ��_ ��� � bnf �� � M�� ûü � Vk$. ��#t t
~t F _� � Vk$. Á:; � �vc à �z ¢p ÅH/ î�íH � Vk$.
N=820
cs ÝsÞ
Y Ø
� 55.3
L 44.7
]�
½0 80.3
¨½0 1 9.7
ZÎ ÏZ
� 4.4
ó 92.0
J 3.6
� 1 00%
<� Ⅲ-1>� \� �¤& Y
48│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
1) MK no
op �qr_ `� �J : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-2>_ sBs w$. op �qr_ ¨� ¥â
æ �t bn 3.69^ sB{$. ¿å�^t >� �t �J (3.73)v >� �= ·t �
J(3.57)_ f � op �qrv �t$(p<.01) . ~� & � è& v ¤å �J (3.92)v [å �J
(3.69)� �å �J (3.42)�$ �t$(p<.01) .
N=820
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
]� ½0 3.7304 .56458 t=3.157
p=.002**¨½0 3.5705 .59908
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 3.921 1 .61 843
F=6.1 34
p=.002**ó 3.6985 .57142
J 3.4235 .48325
� 3.6994 .57453
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -2>� I �ÌÍ
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 >� I �ÌÍ ]� <�Ê Ⅲ -2>� I �ÌÍ ZÎ ÏZ
op �qr� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘st ���� �u_ F qv w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-3>_ sBs w$. qr�J :
54.9%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.63: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , >²Ð, & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , `â^ o�C]^ ��p�/ ;D ,å zH� �`$. 3�C(3.78)v c� �t]a
$É]^ 4�C(3.64) , 6�C(3.57) , 5�C(3.54): �]^ sB{$(p<.05) . ÉÈ , ²�J (3.71)
v ß�J (3.56)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ qr�`$(p<.05) . ÊÈ , >� �t �J (3.67)
v >� �= ·z �J (3.46)�$ ;D , å zH� �`$. ÔÈ , & �è& v ¤å �J (3.
93)v & �è& v [å �J (3.63)� & �è& v �å �J (3.32)�$ ;D, å zH� �`$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 49
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP � ÂÙ ��g
\�
3 2.0% 6.0% 29.0% 38.0% 25.0% 1 00% 3.78
F=2.801
p=.039*
4 1 .8% 6.5% 35.9% 37.6% 18.2% 1 00% 3.64
5 2.8% 5.6% 39.5% 39.1% 1 3.0% 1 00% 3.54
6 1 .3% 6.8% 42.1% 32.8% 17.0% 1 00% 3.57
Y� 3.2% 7.8% 36.2% 35.5% 17.3% 1 00% 3.56 t=-2.402
p=.017*L 0.5% 4.4% 37.8% 38.1% 19.2% 1 00% 3.71
]� ½0 1 .5% 5.7% 36.3% 37.3% 19.2% 1 00% 3.67 t=2.563
p=.01 1*¨½0 3.8% 8.2% 39.9% 34.2% 1 3.9% 1 00% 3.46
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 5.0% 2.5% 20.0% 40.0% 32.5% 1 00% 3.93
F=3.698
p=.025*ó 1 .9% 6.0% 38.0% 36.0% 1 8.1% 1 00% 3.63
J 0.0% 17.9% 32.1% 50.0% 0.0% 1 00% 3.32
� 2.0% 6.2% 37.0% 36.7% 18.2% 1 00% 3.63
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-3>� ‘ñ< �� sø; �Ì¥ WP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -3>� ��sø � Ì(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -4>� ��sø � Ì(Y Ø)
<�Ê Ⅲ -5>� ��sø � Ì(]� ) <�Ê Ⅲ -6>� ��sø � Ì(ZÎ ÏZ)
50│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
‘���� xyz �{�| =}�$ ~ ��� � w$� J��$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-4>
_ sBs w$. qr�J : 78.2%c ;D,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.16: æ�� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , >²Ð, & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C(4.36)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 4�C(4.22) , 6�C(4.10) , 5�
C(4.00): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ÉÈ , ²�J (4.26)v ß�J (4.08)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,
]^ sB{$(p<.01) . ÊÈ , >� �z �J (4.20)v >� �= ·z �J (4.01)�$ ;
D, å zH� �`$(p<.05) . ÔÈ , & � è& (¤ : 4.40 [ : 4.16 �: 3.82)v ���/ ;D ,
å zH� �`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 1 .5% 1 .0% 1 2.9% 29.4% 55.2% 1 00% 4.36
F=6.388
p=.000***
4 0.6% 2.4% 1 7.6% 32.9% 46.5% 1 00% 4.22
5 1 .4% 2.3% 23.3% 40.5% 32.6% 1 00% 4.00
6 0.9% 3.8% 1 8.7% 37.9% 38.7% 1 00% 4.1 0
Y � 1 .6% 3.0% 20.9% 34.7% 39.8% 1 00% 4.08 t=-2.861
p=.004**L 0.5% 1 .8% 1 5.3% 36.3% 46.1% 1 00% 4.26
]� ½0 0.9% 2.0% 1 6.9% 36.7% 43.6% 1 00% 4.20 t=2.492
p=.01 3*¨½0 1 .9% 4.4% 24.1% 30.4% 39.2% 1 00% 4.01
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 0.0% 2.5% 1 5.0% 22.5% 60.0% 1 00% 4.40
F=3.553
p=.029*ó 1 .2% 2.1% 1 8.3% 35.9% 42.5% 1 00% 4.1 6
J 0.0% 1 0.7% 21 .4% 42.9% 25.0% 1 00% 3.82
� 1 .1% 2.4% 1 8.3% 35.4% 42.8% 1 00% 4.1 6
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -4>� ‘�� åÖ� �XJ© �?#P � �,' ` WP$ ���P.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 51
<�Ê Ⅲ-7>� �� �XJ© �,' ` WP(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ-8>� �� �XJ© �,' ` WP(YØ)
<�Ê Ⅲ-9>� �� �XJ© �,' ` WP(]� ) <�Ê Ⅲ-10>� �� �XJ© �,' ̀ WP(ZÎÏZ)
‘st s_� ��� �� _ m [� ��$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-5>_ sBs w$. qr
�J : 57.6%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.70: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , >²Ð, & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C(3.82)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 4�C(3.71) , 6�C(3.71) , 5�
C(3.57): �]^ sB{$(p<.05) . ÉÈ , ß�J (3.71)v ²�J (3.69)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,
]^ sB{$(p<.05) . ÊÈ , >� �z �J (3.74)v >� �= ·z �J (3.54)�$ ;
D, å zH� �`$(p<.05) . ÔÈ , & � è& (¤ : 4.00 [ : 3.69 �: 3.50)v ���/ ;D ,
å zH� �`$(p<.05) .
52 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 1 .0% 3.0% 35.8% 33.8% 26.4% 1 00% 3.82
F=2.730
p=.043*
4 1 .2% 5.9% 32.9% 40.6% 1 9.4% 1 00% 3.71
5 0.9% 7.0% 40.5% 37.2% 1 4.4% 1 00% 3.57
6 1 .7% 3.4% 35.7% 40.0% 1 9.1% 1 00% 3.71
Y � 1 .4% 3.9% 37.9% 35.9% 20.9% 1 00% 3.71 t=.303
p=.019*L 1 .0% 5.7% 34.7% 40.2% 1 8.4% 1 00% 3.69
]� ½0 1 .1% 4.1% 35.4% 38.8% 20.7% 1 00% 3.74 t=2.510
p=.01 2*¨½0 1 .9% 7.6% 40.5% 34.2% 1 5.8% 1 00% 3.54
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 0.0% 7.5% 20.0% 37.5% 35.0% 1 00% 4.00
F=3.090
p=.046*ó 1 .2% 4.4% 37.6% 37.6% 1 9.3% 1 00% 3.69
J 3.6% 1 0.7% 28.6% 46.4% 1 0.7% 1 00% 3.50
� 1 .2% 4.8% 36.4% 37.9% 1 9.7% 1 00% 3.70
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-5>� ‘ñ< ñ;+ �ð� _Î; ¤ó+ � �P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 >� _Î ¤ ó � £(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 2>� _Î ¤ó � £(Y Ø)
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 3>� _Î ¤ ó � £(]� ) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 4>� _Î ¤ ó � £(ZÎ ÏZ)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 53
‘st s_� ��� �� � /� ha� $�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-6>_ sBs w$.
qr�J : 49.9%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.39: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C_�� Á: ; � �vc sB{$. 4�C(3.92)v c� ;D ,å zH�
�`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.85) , 5�C(3.74) , 3�C(2.02): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 38.7% 29.1% 25.1% � 6.0% � 1 .0% 1 00% 2.02
F=206.767
p=.000***
4 � 0.6% � 4.1% 28.8% 35.3% 31 .2% 1 00% 3.92
5 � 0.5% � 5.1% 34.0% 40.5% 20.0% 1 00% 3.74
6 � 1 .3% � 1 .7% 32.5% 39.7% 24.8% 1 00% 3.85
� 1 0.0% � 9.8% 30.3% 30.8% 1 9.1% 1 00% 3.39
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -6>� ‘ñ< ñ;+ � ð � _ Î G × � À Ü + P�P. ’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 5>� �ð � _Î ; ¤ ó(\�)
‘� q�]^t �`^ � � wt �v �$’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-7>_ sBs w$. K
�` �gvp ��_ qr�J : 67.1%c o�: q�]^ � � wt �v �$t a]^
qr�`]a , bn 3.85: ;D, æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C� >²Ð_� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 5�C(4.00)v c� �t�, $É]^ 3�C(3.96) , 4�C(3.84) , 6�C(3.64): �]^
sB{$(p<.01) . ÉÈ , >� �z �J (3.90)v >� �= ·z �J (3.67)�$ �t$
(p<.05) .
54 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 4.0% 7.5% 1 7.9% 30.3% 40.3% 1 00% 3.96
F=4.933p=.002**
4 3.5% 7.6% 22.9% 33.5% 32.4% 1 00% 3.84
5 0.9% 5.1% 21 .9% 37.2% 34.9% 1 00% 4.00
6 7.2% 8.5% 23.8% 33.6% 26.8% 1 00% 3.64
]� ½0 3.8% 5.9% 21 .6% 34.5% 34.2% 1 00% 3.90
t=2.347p=.029*
¨½0 5.1% 1 2.7% 22.2% 30.4% 29.7% 1 00% 3.67
� 4.0% 7.2% 21 .7% 33.7% 33.4% 1 00% 3.85
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-7>� ‘' ÌѾ�< Î [� / ` W< �¥ �P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ-16>� ' ÌѾ� / ` W< �¥ �P(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 7>� ' ÌѾ� / ̀ W< �¥ �P(]� )
‘st s_� ��� � c �$’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-8>_ sBs w$. K�` �g]^
bn 3.52: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C_�� Á:; � �vc sB{$. v �g_ `� 3�C(3.66)v c� �
t�, $É]^ 5�C(3.63) , 4�C(3.61) , 6�C(3.24): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 55
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 5.5% 1 4.5% 22.0% 24.5% 33.5% 1 00% 3.66
F=6.346
p=.000***
4 6.5% 1 1 .2% 25.9% 28.2% 28.2% 1 00% 3.61
5 3.7% 1 1 .6% 27.9% 31 .6% 25.1% 1 00% 3.63
6 8.5% 1 7.4% 33.6% 22.6% 1 7.9% 1 00% 3.24
� 6.1% 1 3.9% 27.7% 26.6% 25.7% 1 00% 3.52
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-8>� ‘ñ< ñ;+ ½�/ :® òP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 8>� ñ;+ ½�/ :® WP(\�)
‘st ��v�= o�v w$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ-9>_ sBs w$. qr�J : 51.9%
c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.64: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , >²Ð, & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C(3.93)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.58) , 4�C(3.53) , 5�
C(3.52): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ÉÈ , ß�J (3.71)v ²�J (3.56)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,
]^ sB{$(p<.05) . ÊÈ , >� �z �J (3.67)v >� �= ·z �J (3.49)�$ ;
D, å zH� �`$(p<.05) . ÔÈ , & � è& (¤ : 4.08 [ : 3.63 �: 3.25)v ���/ ;D ,
å zH� �`$(p<.01) .
56│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 1 .5% 6.5% 25.4% 31 .3% 35.3% 1 00% 3.93
F=8.1 33p=.000***
4 1 .8% 1 1 .2% 38.2% 30.0% 1 8.8% 1 00% 3.53
5 1 .9% 7.4% 44.7% 29.3% 1 6.7% 1 00% 3.52
6 1 .7% 6.8% 44.7% 25.5% 21 .3% 1 00% 3.58
Y � 1 .8% 6.4% 36.6% 29.4% 25.7% 1 00% 3.71
t=2.220p=.027*
L 1 .6% 9.3% 40.9% 28.2% 1 9.9% 1 00% 3.56
]� ½0 1 .7% 6.8% 37.9% 30.2% 23.5% 1 00% 3.67
t=2.060p=.040*
¨½0 1 .9% 1 2.0% 41 .8% 23.4% 20.9% 1 00% 3.49
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 0.0% 7.5% 20.0% 30.0% 42.5% 1 00% 4.08
F=6.352p=.002**
ó 1 .7% 7.4% 39.8% 28.3% 22.7% 1 00% 3.63
J 3.6% 1 7.9% 32.1% 42.9% 3.6% 1 00% 3.25
� 1 .7% 7.8% 38.6% 28.9% 23.0% 1 00% 3.64
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-9>� ‘ñ< K�¥�� �¥ WP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 9>� � Í(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -20>� �Í(Y Ø)
<�Ê Ⅲ -21 >� �Í(]� ) <�Ê Ⅲ -22>� � Í(ZÎ ÏZ)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 57
2) ���� ob�
���� r�) _ `� �J : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-10>_ sBs w$. ���� r�) _
¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.71^ sB{$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (3.93)v c� ;D, å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 4�C(3.72) , 6�C
(3.65) , 5�C(3.57): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ÉÈ , ²�J (3.84)v ß�J (3.60)_ f � ��
�� r�) v �t$(p<.001) . ÊÈ , & � è& v ¤å �J (3.95)v [å �J (3.71)� �å �
J(3.34)�$ �t$(p<.01) .
N=820
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
\�
3 3.9304 .78573
F=7.587
p=.000***
4 3.7277 .84683
5 3.5781 .78780
6 3.6590 .71 207
Y � 3.6028 .82597 t=-4.482
p=.000***L 3.8463 .72374
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 3.9560 .89224
F=5.01 1
p=.007**ó 3.71 87 .77910
J 3.3418 .77892
� 3.71 71 .78862
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 0>� �� Í`Y
<�Ê Ⅲ -23>� �� Í`Y (\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -24>� � � Í`Y (Y Ø)
58│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -25>� � � Í`Y (ZÎ ÏZ)
���� r�) : �g�^ �� � �| $� O$.
‘st ���� xy� �� ry� � ��$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-11>_ sBs w$.
qr�J : 53.3%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.62: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (3.76)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.65) , 4�C(3.5
7) , 5�C(3.48): �]^ sB{$(p<.05) . ÉÈ , ²�J (3.70)v ß�J (3.54)_ f � ����
r�) v �t$(p<.05) . ÊÈ , & � è& (¤ : 3.95, [ : 3.61, �: 3.36)v ���/ ;D ,å z
H� �`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 2.5% 9.5% 28.9% 28.4% 30.8% 1 00% 3.76
F=2.91 5
p=.033*
4 2.9% 9.4% 34.1% 34.7% 1 8.8% 1 00% 3.57
5 2.8% 8.8% 38.6% 36.7% 1 3.0% 1 00% 3.48
6 1 .3% 5.1% 42.1% 30.6% 20.9% 1 00% 3.65
Y � 3.9% 8.5% 37.0% 31 .0% 1 9.5% 1 00% 3.54 t=-2.426
p=.01 5*L 0.5% 7.5% 35.5% 34.2% 22.3% 1 00% 3.70
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 5.0% 2.5% 22.5% 32.5% 37.5% 1 00% 3.95
F=3.373
p=.035*ó 2.1% 8.0% 37.3% 32.3% 20.3% 1 00% 3.61
J 3.6% 1 7.9% 28.6% 39.3% 1 0.7% 1 00% 3.36
� 2.3% 8.0% 36.3% 32.5% 20.8% 1 00% 3.62
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-11>� ‘ñ< �� åÖ+ �� ÍÖ+ � ��P.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 59
<�Ê Ⅲ -26>� � �+ �� ÍÖ(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -27>� ��+ �� ÍÖ(Y Ø)
<�Ê Ⅲ -28>� ��+ �� ÍÖ(ZÎÏZ)
‘s_� ���� xyz [(�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-12>_ sBs w$. qr�J :
58.4%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.79: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (3.97)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 4�C(3.81) , 6�C(3.7
8) , 5�C(3.63): �]^ sB{$(p<.01) . ÉÈ , ²�J (3.88)v ß�J (3.71)_ f � �z æ �
� �`$(p<.01) . ÊÈ , & � è& (¤ : 4.25, [ : 3.78, �: 3.54)v ���/ ;D, å zH�
�`$(p<.01) .
60 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 1 .5% 3.5% 28.9% 28.9% 37.3% 1 00% 3.97
F=4.357
p=.005**
4 1 .8% 7.6% 31 .2% 27.1% 32.4% 1 00% 3.81
5 1 .4% 4.7% 42.3% 32.6% 1 9.1% 1 00% 3.63
6 1 .3% 4.3% 37.0% 30.2% 27.2% 1 00% 3.78
Y � 2.5% 5.7% 36.1% 29.2% 26.4% 1 00% 3.71 t=-2.566
p=.01 0**L 0.3% 3.9% 34.2% 30.6% 31 .1% 1 00% 3.88
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 2.5% 5.0% 1 2.5% 25.0% 55.0% 1 00% 4.25
F=5.683
p=.004**ó 1 .3% 4.8% 36.4% 29.7% 27.8% 1 00% 3.78
J 3.6% 7.1% 35.7% 39.3% 1 4.3% 1 00% 3.54
� 1 .5% 4.9% 35.2% 29.8% 28.6% 1 00% 3.79
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-12>� ‘ñ;+ � � åÖ � ó | JP. ’
<�Ê Ⅲ -29>� �� åÖ ó|£(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -30>� �� åÖ ó|£(Y Ø)
<�Ê Ⅲ -31 >� � � åÖ ó|£(ZÎ ÏZ)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 61
‘���� xy� �� s: J xv �� ��$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-13>_ sBs w$.
qr�J : 63.8%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.90: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (4.17)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 4�C(3.90) , 6�C(3.8
1) , 5�C(3.73): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ÉÈ , ²�J (4.02)v ß�J (3.79)_ f � �z æ
�� �`$(p<.001) . ÊÈ , & �è& (¤ : 4.10, [ : 3.90, �: 3.46)v ���/ ;D , å zH
� �`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 1 .5% 3.0% 20.5% 27.5% 47.5% 1 00% 4.1 7
F=8.058
p=.000***
4 1 .8% 4.7% 31 .8% 25.3% 36.5% 1 00% 3.90
5 1 .9% 5.6% 32.6% 37.7% 22.3% 1 00% 3.73
6 0.4% 5.5% 34.9% 30.6% 28.5% 1 00% 3.81
Y Ø
� 2.3% 5.3% 32.3% 31 .6% 28.6% 1 00% 3.79t=-3.386
p=.001***L 0.3% 4.1% 27.7% 29.5% 38.3% 1 00% 4.02
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 2.5% 7.5% 1 5.0% 27.5% 47.5% 1 00% 4.1 0
F=3.71 6
p=.025*ó 1 .2% 4.4% 30.7% 30.6% 33.1% 1 00% 3.90
J 3.6% 1 0.7% 35.7% 35.7% 1 4.3% 1 00% 3.46
� 1 .3% 4.8% 30.1% 30.6% 33.2% 1 00% 3.90
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 3>� ‘� � åÖ+ �� ñ& � å¥ (�Ä �P. ’
<�Ê Ⅲ-32>� ��+ �� �å& (�Äá(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ-33>� ��+ �� �å& (�Äá(YØ)
62 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ-34>���+ �� �å& (�Äá(ZÎ��)
‘st >� � ���� xy_ `� vup � �v �t ¡v$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ
-14>_ sBs w$. 40.3%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.38: æ �� �`$. ¿å�
^t Á:; � �vt sBs= ·t$.
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 4.1% 1 5.2% 40.7% 22.8% 1 7.2% 1 00% 3.34 t=-1 .1 68
p=.243L 1 .6% 1 4.2% 43.5% 21 .8% 1 8.9% 1 00% 3.42
� 2.9% 1 4.7% 42.0% 22.3% 1 8.0% 1 00% 3.38
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 4>� ‘ñ< ]�û_ �� åÖ; [� ¥øIG ò¥ J< õ¥P.’
‘st ���� xy_ `� = }�$ ~ ¢� £$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-15>_ sBs
w$. qr�J : 62.0%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.87: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (4.13)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 4�C(3.88) , 6�C(3.8
0) , 5�C(3.70): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ÉÈ , ²�J (4.00)v ß�J (3.75)_ f � �z æ
�� �`$(p<.001) . ÊÈ , & �è& (¤ : 4.10, [ : 3.87, �: 3.46)v ���/ ;D , å zH
� �`$(p<.05) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 63
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 2.0% 5.6% 1 7.7% 26.8% 48.0% 1 00% 4.1 3
F=7.051
p=.000***
4 3.5% 4.7% 31 .2% 21 .8% 38.8% 1 00% 3.88
5 2.3% 7.0% 33.2% 33.6% 23.8% 1 00% 3.70
6 0.4% 3.4% 39.6% 28.5% 28.1% 1 00% 3.80
Y � 3.0% 7.2% 32.3% 26.6% 30.9% 1 00% 3.75 t=-3.591
p=.000***L 0.8% 2.9% 29.2% 29.7% 37.5% 1 00% 4.00
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 5.1% 7.7% 1 0.3% 25.6% 51 .3% 1 00% 4.1 0
F=3.332
p=.036*ó 1 .7% 4.7% 31 .9% 28.0% 33.7% 1 00% 3.87
J 3.6% 1 4.3% 32.1% 32.1% 1 7.9% 1 00% 3.46
� 2.0% 5.1% 30.8% 28.0% 34.0% 1 00% 3.87
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-15>� ‘ñ< �� åÖ; [� �?#P � �$ ]P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ-35>� ��; [� � �$ ]P(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ-36>� ��; [� � �$ ]P(YØ)
<�Ê Ⅲ-37>� ��; [� � �$ ]P(ZÎÏZ)
64│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
‘st g¤ �����u ¥V §�� �� £$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-16>_ sBs w$.
qr�J : 56.7%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.74: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (4.06)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.69) , 4�C(3.6
5) , 5�C(3.57): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ÉÈ , ²�J (3.91)v ß�J (3.58)_ f � �z æ
�� �`$(p<.001) . ÊÈ , & �è& (¤ : 4.15, [ : 3.73, �: 3.43)v ���/ ;D , å zH
� �`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 2.0% 6.5% 21 .5% 23.5% 46.5% 1 00% 4.06
F=8.977
p=.000***
4 2.9% 1 0.6% 30.0% 31 .8% 24.7% 1 00% 3.65
5 2.8% 1 1 .2% 36.7% 25.1% 24.2% 1 00% 3.57
6 1 .7% 6.0% 40.0% 26.4% 26.0% 1 00% 3.69
Y � 3.9% 9.9% 36.3% 23.7% 26.2% 1 00% 3.58 t=-4.576
p=.000***L 0.5% 6.8% 28.3% 29.6% 34.8% 1 00% 3.91
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 2.5% 5.0% 1 7.5% 25.0% 50.0% 1 00% 4.1 5
F=4.344
p=.01 3*ó 2.4% 8.0% 33.4% 26.9% 29.4% 1 00% 3.73
J 0.0% 25.0% 32.1% 1 7.9% 25.0% 1 00% 3.43
� 2.3% 8.4% 32.6% 26.5% 30.2% 1 00% 3.74
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-16>� ‘ñ< �� ��sø �?ㆍ Ó�+ #$ ]P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -38>� ��sø �? ·Ó� �÷ (\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -39>� � �sø �? ·Ó� �÷ (Y Ø)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 65
<�Ê Ⅲ-40>� ��sø �?·Ó� �÷(ZÎÏZ)
‘st ����_ `� ¨\ v �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-17>_ sBs w$. qr�J :
62.3%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.73: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , `â^ o�C]^ ��p�/ ;D , å zH� �`$. 3�C �J (3.97)v c� ;D
,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 4�C(3.92) , 5�C(3.67) , 6�C(3.43): �]^ sB{$(p<.0
01) . ÉÈ , ²�J (3.95)v ß�J (3.53)_ f � �z æ �� �`$(p<.001) . ÊÈ , & � è& v
[å �J (3.75)c & � è& v ¤å �J (3.70)� & �è& v �å �J (3.11)�$ ;D , å z
H� �`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 9.0% 6.0% 1 2.5% 24.5% 48.0% 1 00% 3.97
F=8.863
p=.000***
4 4.7% 7.6% 1 6.5% 33.5% 37.6% 1 00% 3.92
5 4.7% 9.3% 27.9% 30.2% 27.9% 1 00% 3.67
6 1 1 .1% 8.5% 29.4% 28.1% 23.0% 1 00% 3.43
Y � 1 0.3% 8.7% 25.5% 28.0% 27.4% 1 00% 3.53 t=-4.942
p=.000***L 4.4% 7.0% 1 8.4% 29.9% 40.3% 1 00% 3.95
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 1 5.0% 1 5.0% 2.5% 20.0% 47.5% 1 00% 3.70
F=3.81 9
p=.022*ó 6.9% 7.0% 23.3% 29.5% 33.2% 1 00% 3.75
J 1 4.3% 21 .4% 21 .4% 25.0% 1 7.9% 1 00% 3.1 1
� 7.6% 7.9% 22.2% 28.9% 33.4% 1 00% 3.73
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-17>� ‘ñ< � �; [� �÷ ¥ �P. ’
66│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -41 >� � �; [� �÷ (\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -42>� ��; [� �÷ (Y Ø)
<�Ê Ⅲ -43>� ��; [� �÷ (ZÎ ÏZ)
3) j=�
©:) _ `� �J : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-18>_ sBs w$. ©: ) _ ¨� ¥â æ �t b
n 3.69^ sB{$. ¿å�^t 3�C �J (3.97)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^
6�C(3.75) , 4�C(3.74) , 5�C(3.68): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ~� & �è& (¤ : 4.07, [ :
3.77, �: 3.67)v ���/ ;D ,å zH� �`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
\�
3 3.9726 .69664
F=6.043
p=.000***
4 3.7437 .71 554
5 3.6837 .74309
6 3.7514 .76369
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 4.0714 .80795
F=3.227
p=.040*ó 3.7751 .73156
J 3.6786 .79170
� 3.7855 .73926
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 8>� Ð& Y Â ®
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 67
<�Ê Ⅲ -44>� Ð& Y (\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -45>� Ð& Y (ZÎ ÏZ)
©:) � �g�^ �� � �| $É� O$.
‘st F; wt J � � �v �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-19>_ sBs w$. qr�J :
70.2%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.01: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C: ðK_�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
3�C �J (4.25)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.96) , 5�C(3.94) , 4�
C(3.89): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 1 .5% 1 .5% 1 6.4% 31 .8% 48.8% 1 00% 4.25
F=6.1 68
p=.000***
4 1 .2% 4.1% 31 .2% 31 .2% 32.4% 1 00% 3.89
5 0.9% 3.3% 28.4% 35.3% 32.1% 1 00% 3.94
6 0.9% 3.0% 27.7% 36.2% 32.3% 1 00% 3.96
� 1 .1% 2.9% 25.8% 33.9% 36.3% 1 00% 4.01
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-19>� ‘ñ< �ýW< ��û+ ò¥ �P.’
68│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -46>� � ýW< ��(\�)
‘st ª ^« �� � J �� ¬$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ-20>_ sBs w$. qr�J :
61.2%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.84: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C� )� ðK_� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (4.06)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.77) , 5�C(3.7
7) , 4�C(3.75): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ÉÈ , ß�J (3.91)v ²�J (3.76)�$ ¤`,]^
;D , ]^ qr�`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 1 .0% 2.5% 23.4% 35.8% 37.3% 1 00% 4.06
F=5.369
p=.001***
4 0.6% 4.1% 39.4% 31 .8% 24.1% 1 00% 3.75
5 1 .4% 5.1% 35.8% 30.7% 27.0% 1 00% 3.77
6 0.4% 4.7% 37.0% 32.8% 25.1% 1 00% 3.77
Y � 0.9% 2.8% 32.0% 33.3% 31 .0% 1 00% 3.91 t=2.373
p=.018*L 0.8% 5.7% 36.0% 32.1% 25.4% 1 00% 3.76
� 0.9% 4.1% 33.9% 32.8% 28.4% 1 00% 3.84
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-20>� ‘ñ< þ�ç �+ � ��� �P.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 69
<�Ê Ⅲ -47>� þ �ç ��(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -48>� þ�ç ��(Y Ø)
‘st ª ^« 5 ]^ ��� �M�t & ®c �$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ-21>_ sBs
w$. qr�J : 62.3%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.73: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| )�: ðK_�� Á: ; � �vc sB{$. ß�J (3.58)v ²�J (3.38)�
$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ qr�`$(p<.01) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 3.4% 9.9% 34.7% 29.2% 22.8% 1 00% 3.58 t=2.898
p=.004**L 1 .8% 1 0.9% 47.9% 26.2% 1 3.2% 1 00% 3.38
� 2.7% 1 0.4% 40.9% 27.8% 1 8.3% 1 00% 3.49
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-21>� ‘ñ< þ�ç íÿ¾� �ÎG �úJ< Zê® òP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -49>� þ �ç íÿ ¾� �Î � ú(Y Ø)
70│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
‘st ©:, v¯t ° ±� � �c �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-22>_ sBs w$. qr
�J : 42.3%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.41: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C� & � è& ðK_� Á: ; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (3.61)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.46) , 4�C(3.35) ,
5�C(3.23): �]^ sB{$(p<.01) . ÉÈ , & � è& (¤ : 3.92, [ : 3.39, � : 3.36)v ���
/ ;D , å zH� �`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 4.0% 1 1 .1% 31 .7% 26.6% 26.6% 1 00% 3.61
F=5.1 36
p=.002**
4 2.9% 1 4.7% 41 .2% 27.1% 1 4.1% 1 00% 3.35
5 4.7% 1 2.1% 48.8% 24.2% 1 0.2% 1 00% 3.23
6 1 .3% 1 2.8% 44.7% 21 .3% 20.0% 1 00% 3.46
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 0.0% 1 2.8% 25.6% 1 7.9% 43.6% 1 00% 3.92
F=5.1 83
p=.006**ó 3.2% 1 2.5% 43.0% 25.0% 1 6.4% 1 00% 3.39
J 7.1% 1 4.3% 35.7% 21 .4% 21 .4% 1 00% 3.36
� 3.2% 1 2.6% 41 .9% 24.5% 1 7.8% 1 00% 3.41
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-22>� ‘ñ< Ð& � ¥�< + û+ :® òP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -50>� Ð& � (\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -51 >� Ð& � (ZÎ ÏZ)
‘st � c= � �| ²³ c= J � v ´ µk$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-23>_ sBs
w$. qr�J : 56.6%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.71: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| & � è& ðK_�� Á: ; � �vc sB{$.
& � è& (¤ : 4.10, [ : 3.70, �: 3.43)v ���/ ;D ,å zH� �`$(p<.01) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 71
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 0.0% 7.7% 20.5% 25.6% 46.2% 1 00% 4.1 0
F=4.383
p=.01 3**ó 2.1% 5.2% 36.8% 32.3% 23.6% 1 00% 3.70
J 1 0.7% 1 4.3% 21 .4% 28.6% 25.0% 1 00% 3.43
� 2.3% 5.6% 35.5% 31 .8% 24.8% 1 00% 3.71
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-23>� ‘ñ< � ®�G #© L ®� ��û¥ ¡�ìP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ-52>�� ®�G #© L ®�G ���P(ZÎÏZ)
‘¶� v �= ·t ª ^« J �� �t �v �¸ $.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ-24>_ sBs
w$. qr�J : 61.9%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.85: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C ðK_�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
3�C �J (4.06)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.80) , 4�C(3.77) , 5�
C(3.77): �]^ sB{$(p<.01) .
72 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 3.5% 4.5% 21 .4% 23.4% 47.3% 1 00% 4.06
F=4.206
p=.006**
4 1 .8% 6.5% 31 .2% 34.1% 26.5% 1 00% 3.77
5 1 .4% 5.6% 33.5% 34.0% 25.6% 1 00% 3.77
6 1 .7% 4.3% 36.6% 27.7% 29.8% 1 00% 3.80
� 2.1% 5.1% 30.9% 29.6% 32.3% 1 00% 3.85
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-24>� ‘�cû¥ J� h< þ�ç ��+ J< �¥ (¢P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -53>� þ �ç � �J< (�Z(\�)
‘ª ^« �� % ®t �v �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-25>_ sBs w$. qr�J :
77.0%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.19: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C ðK_�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
`â,]^ o�C]^ ��p�/ ;D , å zH� �`$. 3�C �J (4.42)v c� ;D ,
å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 4�C(4.29) , 5�C(4.08) , 6�C(4.01): �]^ sB{$(p<.00
1) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 73
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 0.5% 2.5% 1 3.9% 20.9% 62.2% 1 00% 4.42
F=9.31 9
p=.000***
4 1 .8% 1 .2% 1 4.1% 31 .8% 51 .2% 1 00% 4.29
5 0.5% 2.8% 21 .4% 38.6% 36.7% 1 00% 4.08
6 1 .3% 3.4% 26.4% 30.6% 38.3% 1 00% 4.01
� 1 .0% 2.6% 1 9.5% 30.6% 46.4% 1 00% 4.1 9
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -25>� ‘þ �ç �+ �ê< �¥ �P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -54>� þ �ç � �ê< (�Z(\�)
4) MK Opq(st�)
op T¹�(§» ) )_ `� �J : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-26>_ sBs w$. op T¹�(§
» ) )_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.55^ sB{$. ¿å�^t o�C]^ ��p�/ ;D , å
zH� �`$. 3�C(3.70)v c� �t]a , 4�C(3.59) , 5�C(3.54) , 6�C(3.42): �]^
sB{$(p<.001) . ~� & � è& (¤ : 3.78, [ : 3.55, �: 3.35)v ���/ �z æ �� �`$
(p<.05) .
74 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
\�
3 3.7085 .68253
F=7.199
p=.000***
4 3.591 6 .60215
5 3.5429 .65235
6 3.4201 .66491
ZÎ ÏZ
� 3.7821 .72193
F=3.700
p=.025*ó 3.5537 .65160
J 3.3520 .75240
� 3.5580 .66087
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -26>� I ~¯Ñ(ÓÔY )�  ®
<�Ê Ⅲ -55>� I ~¯Ñ·ÓÔÑ(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -56>� I ~¯Ñ·ÓÔÑ(ZÎ ÏZ)
op T¹�(§» ) ): �g�^ �� � �| $É� O$.
‘st �c st ½v w~ ¯H ¾� � w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-27>_ sBs w$. q
r�J : 53%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.57: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��,]^
Á: ; � �vt sBs= ·t$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 75
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 4.8% 7.8% 30.3% 37.5% 1 9.5% 1 00% 3.59 t=.788
p=.431L 1 .3% 9.6% 40.7% 31 .1% 1 7.4% 1 00% 3.54
� 3.2% 8.6% 35.2% 34.5% 1 8.5% 1 00% 3.57
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -27>� ‘ñ< ® ñ< b¥ W��£ º+ ` WP. ’
‘st �¿: À�vs ÁÂ� � vÃ Ä � w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-28>_ sBs w
$. qr�J : 58.2%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.70: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| & � è& _�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
& � è& (¤ : 4.05, [ : 3.69, �: 3.46)v ���/ ;D ,å zH� �`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 0.0% 7.5% 22.5% 27.5% 42.5% 1 00% 4.05
F=3.669
p=.026*ó 2.0% 5.6% 34.5% 36.8% 21 .1% 1 00% 3.69
J 3.6% 1 4.3% 32.1% 32.1% 1 7.9% 1 00% 3.46
� 1 .9% 6.0% 33.9% 36.2% 22.0% 1 00% 3.70
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-28>� ‘ñ< �é& £Ñ¥ñ ä�+ � ¥¤¥ ` WP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ-57>� �é& £Ñ¥ñ ä� >*(ZÎÏZ)
‘ÅÆ�Ç H ÈÉ� �DV Ê � w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-29>_ sBs w$. qr�J
: 61.7%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.76: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ��, ]^ Á
:; � �vt sBs= ·t$.
76│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 3.2% 3.2% 28.6% 38.9% 26.0% 1 00% 3.81 t=1 .802
p=.072L 1 .6% 6.2% 34.2% 37.3% 20.7% 1 00% 3.69
� 2.4% 4.6% 31 .2% 38.2% 23.5% 1 00% 3.76
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-29>� ‘¦¨�§£ .0+ �� ?¨ ` WP. ’
‘st ii ËÌc� �Í� £$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-30>_ sBs w$. K�` �g]
^ bn 3.62: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C ðK_�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
`â,]^ ��C]^ p�/ §» , zH� �`$. 3�C �J (3.88)v c� �t�, $É
]^ 4�C(3.64) , 5�C(3.63) , 6�C(3.37): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 3.5% 9.5% 22.0% 25.5% 39.5% 1 00% 3.88
F=6.665
p=.000**
*
4 4.7% 1 3.5% 23.5% 29.4% 28.8% 1 00% 3.64
5 2.8% 1 1 .6% 31 .6% 27.9% 26.0% 1 00% 3.63
6 1 1 .9% 1 3.6% 22.6% 28.9% 23.0% 1 00% 3.37
� 6.0% 1 2.1% 25.0% 27.9% 29.0% 1 00% 3.62
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -30>� ‘ñ< ÁÁ ©ª®G :ë$ ]P. ’
<�Ê Ⅲ -58>� ª, cª(\�)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 77
‘st �c s� ÎÍ� =Ï� s �Oc� Ð�� £� �c w$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ
-31>_ sBs w$. K�` �g]^ bn 3.36: � �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C ðK_�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
3�C �J (3.52)v c� ��, $É]^ 5�C(3.48) , 4�C(3.36) , 6�C(3.12): �]^ s
B{$(p<.01) . � 6�C �J v c� §» ) v �t$.
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 1 2.9% 1 6.4% 22.4% 1 8.4% 29.9% 1 00% 3.36
F=4.1 73
p=.006**
4 8.8% 1 1 .2% 27.6% 24.1% 28.2% 1 00% 3.52
5 5.1% 1 8.6% 24.2% 27.0% 25.1% 1 00% 3.48
6 1 5.7% 1 7.4% 24.7% 23.4% 1 8.7% 1 00% 3.1 2
� 1 0.8% 1 6.2% 24.6% 23.3% 25.1% 1 00% 3.36
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-31>� ‘ñ< ® ñ% �ëG � �ñ K«®G �`$ ]+ :® WP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ-59>� ® ñ �ëG � �ñ Ý�°â(\�)
‘st ¶�s e � � o� Ñ«$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-32>_ sBs w$. K�` �g
]^, bn 3.24: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| & � è& ðK_�� Á:; � �vc sB{
$. & � è& (¤ : 3.53, [ : 3.24, �: 2.71)v �= ·��/ §» ) v �t$(p<.05) .
78│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 12.5% 1 0.0% 25.0% 1 7.5% 35.0% 1 00% 3.53
F=3.579
p=.028*ó 10.0% 1 6.9% 31 .5% 22.3% 1 9.4% 1 00% 3.24
J 17.9% 32.1% 25.0% 1 0.7% 1 4.3% 1 00% 2.71
� 10.4% 1 7.1% 30.9% 21 .7% 20.0% 1 00% 3.24
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -32>� ‘ñ< �cñ àÎ û_ � ¬çP.’
‘st Ò� �v �t ¡v$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-33>_ sBs w$. K�g]^ bn
3.66: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, )� , >²Ð, & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , `â^ o�C]^ p�/ Ò� , � k$. 3�C �J (4.13)v c� æ �c ��, $É
]^ 4�C(3.77) , 5�C(3.68) , 6�C(3.15): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ÉÈ , ²�J (3.78)v
ß�J(3.56)_ f � Ò� ��`$.(p<.01) . ÊÈ , >� �t �J (3.70)v >� �=
·t �J (3.49)�$ Ò� � �`$(p<.05) . ÔÈ , & � è& (¤ : 4.18, [ : 3.64, �: 3.57)v �
��/ � � �`$(p<.01) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 4.0% 3.5% 1 5.4% 29.4% 47.8% 1 00% 4.1 3
F=32.892
p=.000***
4 1 .2% 7.1% 31 .2% 34.7% 25.9% 1 00% 3.77
5 1 .9% 4.7% 40.9% 28.4% 24.2% 1 00% 3.68
6 1 1 .5% 1 2.3% 40.4% 20.9% 1 4.9% 1 00% 3.1 5
Y � 6.7% 7.8% 33.3% 27.6% 24.6% 1 00% 3.56 t=-2.873
p=.004**L 3.1% 6.2% 31 .6% 28.0% 31 .1% 1 00% 3.78
]� ½0 4.4% 6.6% 31 .8% 28.8% 28.4% 1 00% 3.70 t=2.194
p=.029*¨½0 7.6% 8.9% 35.4% 23.4% 24.7% 1 00% 3.49
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 7.5% 0.0% 1 5.0% 22.5% 55.0% 1 00% 4.1 8
F=4.656
p=.01 0**ó 4.9% 7.0% 33.7% 28.2% 26.2% 1 00% 3.64
J 3.6% 1 7.9% 25.0% 25.0% 28.6% 1 00% 3.57
� 5.0% 7.1% 32.5% 27.8% 27.6% 1 00% 3.66
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -33>� ‘ñ< + ò¥ J< õ ¥P.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 79
<�Ê Ⅲ -60>� ¼ ]* �£(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -61 >� ¼ ]* � £(Y Ø)
<�Ê Ⅲ -62>� ¼ ]* � £(]� ) <�Ê Ⅲ -63>� ¼ ]* � £(ZÎ ÏZ)
5) MK!u R!q
op EY� IE�_ `� �J : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-34>_ sBs w$. op EY� IE�
_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.69^ sB{$.
¿å�^ �| �C, >²Ð, & � è& ðK_� Á:; � �vc sB{$. �È , `â^
o�C]^ ��p�/ ;D ,å zH� �`$. 3�C(3.42)]^ c� �t]a , $É]^ 4�
C(3.26) , 5�C(3.24) , 6�C(3.19): �]^ sB{$(p<.01) . ÉÈ , >� �z �J (3.30)
v >� �= ·z �J (3.17)�$ ;D , ]^ qr�`$(p<.05) . ÊÈ , & �è& (¤ : 4.03,
[: 3.65, �: 3.21)v ���/ ;D , å zH� �`$(p<.001) .
80│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
\�
3 3.4205 .71 151
F=4.817
p=.002**
4 3.2688 .64169
5 3.2485 .58458
6 3.1 982 .57217
]� ½0 3.3033 .631 71 t=2.228
p=.026*¨½0 3.1 786 .61 507
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 3.421 2 .63883
F=8.633
p=.000***ó 3.2892 .62146
J 2.821 4 .67861
� 3.2794 .63010
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -34>� I�Õ_ ��Ñ Â ®
<�Ê Ⅲ -64>� I�ÕÑ ��Ñ Â ®(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -65>� I�ÕÑ ��Ñ Â ®(]� )
<�Ê Ⅲ -66>� I�ÕÑ ��Ñ Â ®(ZÎ ÏZ)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 81
op EY� IE�: �g�^ �� � �| $� O$.
‘st � J �� � Ó�t ¡v$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ-35>_ sBs w$. qr�J :
52.5%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.65: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, & �è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (3.82)v c� ;D, å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.60) , 5�C
(3.60) , 4�C(3.57): �]^ sB{$(p<.05) . ÉÈ , & � è& (¤ : 4.03, [ : 3.65, �: 3.21)v
���/ ;D , å zH� �`$(p<.01) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 3.0% 6.5% 29.4% 27.9% 33.3% 1 00% 3.82
F=2.81 9
p=.038*
4 0.0% 7.6% 45.3% 29.4% 1 7.6% 1 00% 3.57
5 1 .4% 6.0% 41 .4% 33.0% 1 8.1% 1 00% 3.60
6 0.4% 1 2.8% 36.6% 26.4% 23.8% 1 00% 3.60
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 0.0% 1 2.5% 20.0% 20.0% 47.5% 1 00% 4.03
F=5.91 0
p=.003**ó 1 .1% 7.7% 39.0% 29.9% 22.3% 1 00% 3.65
J 7.1% 21 .4% 32.1% 21 .4% 1 7.9% 1 00% 3.21
� 1 .2% 8.4% 37.9% 29.1% 23.4% 1 00% 3.65
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -35>� ‘ñ< ' ��+ � ®J< õ¥P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -67>� ' � �+ �Õ(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -68>� ' ��+ �Õ(ZÎ ÏZ)
82 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
‘�c �Ôt p �� $k >� v �t �v Õ$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-36>_ sBs
w$. qr�J : 36.1%c ÐD, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.14: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
& � è& v [å �J (3.17)v & �è& v ¤å �J (2.97)� & � è& v �å �J (2.46)�$
;D , ]^ qr�`$(p<.01) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 17.9% 1 7.9% 30.8% 1 5.4% 1 7.9% 1 00% 2.97
F=5.085
p=.006**ó 10.9% 1 4.5% 37.8% 20.1% 1 6.7% 1 00% 3.1 7
J 28.6% 21 .4% 28.6% 1 7.9% 3.6% 1 00% 2.46
� 1 1 .8% 1 4.9% 37.2% 1 9.8% 1 6.3% 1 00% 3.1 4
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -36>� ‘'® �-< Is+ Pì ]�û¥ ,< �¥ ¯P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ-69>�ª,¥ ' ��+ ,< �¥ ¯P(ZÎÏZ)
‘���� xy� �� s: p �vs J �� EY� � w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-37>_
sBs w$. qr�J : 49.3%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.61: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, & �è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (3.82)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 6�C(3.57) , 5�C(3.5
5) , 4�C(3.50): �]^ sB{$(p<.01) . ÉÈ , & � è& (¤ : 3.97, [ : 3.60, �: 3.29)v �
��/ ;D, å zH� �`$(p<.05) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 83
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 2.0% 7.1% 31 .8% 24.7% 34.3% 1 00% 3.82
F=4.605
p=.003**
4 3.0% 9.5% 42.6% 24.9% 20.1% 1 00% 3.50
5 0.5% 5.1% 47.0% 34.0% 1 3.5% 1 00% 3.55
6 0.0% 9.4% 44.7% 25.5% 20.4% 1 00% 3.57
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 2.6% 1 0.3% 20.5% 20.5% 46.2% 1 00% 3.97
F=4.543
p=.01 1*ó 1 .1% 7.2% 42.8% 28.1% 20.8% 1 00% 3.60
J 3.6% 1 7.9% 42.9% 1 7.9% 1 7.9% 1 00% 3.29
� 1 .2% 7.7% 41 .7% 27.4% 21 .9% 1 00% 3.61
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -37>� ‘�� åÖ+ �� ñ& Is¥ñ ��+ �Õ/ ` WP. ’
<�Ê Ⅲ-70>� ��+ �� ñ& Is �Õ(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ-71>���+ �� ñ& Is �Õ(ZÎÏZ)
‘$k ¶� Ö_� IE�t �v �¸ $.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-38>_ sBs w$. qr
�J : 37.4%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.37: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, & �è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , `â^ o�C]^ ��p�/ ;D , å zH� �`$. 3�C �J (3.60)v c� ;D
,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 4�C(3.35) , 5�C(3.30) , 6�C(3.25): �]^ sB{$(p<.0
1) . ÉÈ , & �è& (¤ :3.64, [ : 3.37, �: 3.00)v ���/ ;D ,å zH� �`$(p<.05) .
84│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 4.0% 1 0.6% 36.2% 20.1% 29.1% 1 00% 3.60
F=4.555
p=.004**
4 4.7% 1 3.5% 41 .8% 22.4% 1 7.6% 1 00% 3.35
5 3.7% 1 0.7% 52.6% 1 7.7% 1 5.3% 1 00% 3.30
6 3.8% 1 4.0% 52.3% 1 3.2% 1 6.6% 1 00% 3.25
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 5.1% 1 2.8% 28.2% 20.5% 33.3% 1 00% 3.64
F=3.031
p=.049*ó 4.0% 1 1 .8% 46.8% 1 8.2% 1 9.1% 1 00% 3.37
J 3.6% 21 .4% 57.1% 7.1% 1 0.7% 1 00% 3.00
� 4.0% 1 2.2% 46.3% 1 7.9% 1 9.5% 1 00% 3.37
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -38>� ‘Pì �cû °;% ��J< �¥ (¢P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -72>� ª, °;% ��J< (�Z(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ-73>� ª, °;% ��J< (�Z(ZÎÏZ)
‘st IE� � Ð׳Ø� ��$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-39>_ sBs w$. K�` �g
]^ 3.02: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| & � è& _�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
& � è& v �å �J (2.36)v [å �J (3.05)� ¤å �J (2.92)�$ Ð׳Ø� �v �Ô
t �]^ qr�`$(p<.01) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 85
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 17.9% 1 7.9% 28.2% 25.6% 1 0.3% 1 00% 2.92
F=4.677
p=.01 0**ó 10.8% 22.0% 33.2% 1 9.5% 1 4.5% 1 00% 3.05
J 21 .4% 39.3% 25.0% 1 0.7% 3.6% 1 00% 2.36
� 1 1 .5% 22.4% 32.7% 1 9.5% 1 3.9% 1 00% 3.02
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -39>� ‘ñ< ��/ : �± Z+ ��P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -74>� ��/ : �±ã�ä (ZÎ ÏZ)
‘st aJ Ù v V Úp ¥_ ÛÛ^ IE� �c �$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ-40>_ sBs
w$. qr�J : 29%�v ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.05: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C: ðK_�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
4�C �J (3.17)v c� ;D ,å zH� �`]a , $É]^ 3�C(3.16) , 6�C(3.04) , 5�
C(2.88): �]^ sB{$(p<.05)
86│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 1 1 .1% 1 7.7% 32.3% 22.2% 1 6.7% 1 00% 3.1 6
F=3.076
p=.027*
4 3.5% 22.9% 42.4% 1 5.3% 1 5.9% 1 00% 3.1 7
5 8.8% 20.5% 51 .2% 1 3.0% 6.5% 1 00% 2.88
6 6.8% 23.8% 41 .7% 1 3.6% 1 4.0% 1 00% 3.04
� 7.7% 21 .3% 42.1% 1 5.9% 1 3.1% 1 00% 3.05
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -40>� ‘ñ< Ü�·¥ ?�I �; ³³� ��/ :® òP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -75>� ³³� ��(\�)
‘st � J �� � `^ EY�= Ü� � c �$.’¯t ô �_ `� qrv <E Ⅲ-41>_
sBs w$. K�` �g]^ bn 3.14: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C, >²Ð, & �è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , 3�C �J (3.25)v c� EY� ��t �]^ sB{]a , $É]^ 5�C(3.24) , 4�
C(3.19) , 6�C(2.91): �]^ sB{$(p<.01) . ÉÈ , >� �z �J (3.19)v >�
�= ·z �J (2.91)�$ EY� ��$� qr�`$(p<.01) . ÊÈ , & � è& (¤ : 3.31, [ : 3.
15, �: 2.57)v ���/ EY� ��t �]^ sB{$(p<.05) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 87
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 8.0% 1 8.5% 33.0% 21 .5% 1 9.0% 1 00% 3.25
F=5.078
p=.002**
4 4.7% 20.6% 38.8% 22.9% 1 2.9% 1 00% 3.1 9
5 3.7% 1 5.3% 43.7% 27.4% 9.8% 1 00% 3.24
6 1 3.2% 1 9.6% 38.3% 21 .3% 7.7% 1 00% 2.91
]� ½0 7.1% 1 7.5% 37.8% 24.3% 1 3.3% 1 00% 3.1 9 t=2.983
p=.003**¨½0 1 0.1% 22.2% 41 .8% 1 9.0% 7.0% 1 00% 2.91
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 10.3% 1 2.8% 28.2% 33.3% 1 5.4% 1 00% 3.31
F=4.318
p=.01 4*ó 7.0% 1 8.5% 39.2% 23.2% 1 2.1% 1 00% 3.1 5
J 21 .4% 25.0% 35.7% 1 0.7% 7.1% 1 00% 2.57
� 7.7% 1 8.4% 38.5% 23.3% 1 2.1% 1 00% 3.1 4
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -41 >� ‘ñ< ' ��+ Î[� �ÕJ� ²/ :® òP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -76>� ' ���Õ ²"(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -77>� ' ���Õ ²"(]� )
<�Ê Ⅲ -78>� ' ���Õ ²"(ZÎÏZ)
88│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
6) vw �m�
Ý y� >L) _ `� �J : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-42>_ sBs w$. Ý y� >L) _ ¨�
¥â æ �t bn 3.79^ sB{$. ¿å�^t 3�C(3.90)v c� ;D, å zH� �`]a ,
$É]^ 5�C(3.79) , 6�C(3.74) , 4�C(3.72): �]^ ;D , ]^ qr�`$(p<.05) . ~�
>� �t �J (3.81)v >� �= ·t �J (3.70)_ f� ;D ,å zH� �`$
(p<.05) .
N=820
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
\�
3 3.9045 .61751
F=3.476
p=.016*
4 3.721 0 .60102
5 3.7991 .62413
6 3.7483 .57102
]� ½0 3.81 58 .59856 t=2.1 32
p=.033*¨½0 3.701 6 .62725
� 3.7936 .60553
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -42>� » Ö_ ]^ Y Â ®
<�Ê Ⅲ -79>� » Ö_ ]^ Y (\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -80>� » Ö_ ]^ Y (]� )
Ýy� >L): �g�^ ��� �| $É� O$.
‘st ¶� � � v��$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-43>_ sBs w$. qr�J : 61.5%
c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.83: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��,]^ Á:;� �vt
sBs= ·t$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 89
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 2.3% 3.2% 33.6% 31 .6% 29.3% 1 00% 3.82 t=-.221
p=.825L 0.8% 2.8% 34.2% 36.3% 25.9% 1 00% 3.84
� 1 .6% 3.0% 33.9% 33.8% 27.7% 1 00% 3.83
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -43>� ‘ñ< �cû+ � ¥��P.’
‘st ¶� � >v�� =¬$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-44>_ sBs w$. qr�J :
73.9%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.05: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��,]^ Á:;�
�vt sBs= ·t$.
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 1 .2% 3.0% 22.4% 36.4% 37.1% 1 00% 4.05 t=-.024
p=.981L 0.5% 1 .0% 24.1% 41 .2% 33.2% 1 00% 4.05
� 0.9% 2.1% 23.2% 38.7% 35.2% 1 00% 4.05
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -44>� ‘ñ< �cû_ ]¥�+ ��P.’
‘st ¶� � � HAÞ$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-45>_ sBs w$. qr�J : 58.2%
c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.78: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��,]^ Á:;� �vt
sBs= ·t$.
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.9% 3.4% 38.6% 31 .5% 25.5% 1 00% 3.77 t=-.31 5
p=.753L 1 .0% 3.4% 36.1% 34.3% 25.2% 1 00% 3.79
� 1 .0% 3.4% 37.4% 32.8% 25.4% 1 00% 3.78
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -45>� ‘ñ< �cû+ � £µ|P.’
90│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
‘st ¶� : Ó� � �Þ$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-46>_ sBs w$. qr�J :
64.7%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.87: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��,]^ Á:;�
�vt sBs= ·t$.
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 1 .1% 3.9% 33.6% 34.3% 27.1% 1 00% 3.82 t=-1 .747
p=.081L 0.5% 2.3% 28.6% 40.8% 27.8% 1 00% 3.93
� 0.9% 3.2% 31 .2% 37.3% 27.4% 1 00% 3.87
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -46>� ‘ñ< �cû& ®+ � ûð|P. ’
‘st $k ¶�_�t ¨\ v �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-47>_ sBs w$. K�` �g
]^ bn 3.79: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C: ðK_�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
3�C �J (3.97)v c� ��, $É]^ 5�C(3.92) , 4�C(3.84) , 6�C(3.47): �]^ s
B{$(p<.001) . � 6�Cv c� ¨\ v �$� qr�`$.
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 6.5% 5.5% 1 6.5% 27.5% 44.0% 1 00% 3.97
F=8.939
p=.000**
*
4 4.7% 4.7% 24.7% 33.5% 32.4% 1 00% 3.84
5 2.3% 4.2% 28.4% 29.8% 35.3% 1 00% 3.92
6 1 1 .5% 8.5% 23.0% 35.7% 21 .3% 1 00% 3.47
� 6.5% 5.9% 23.2% 31 .7% 32.8% 1 00% 3.79
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -47>� ‘ñ< Pì �c;+< �÷ ¥ �P.’
‘st ß� f à� �c �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-48>_ sBs w$. K�` �g]^
bn 3.67: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| �C: ðK_�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 91
`â^ ��C]^ p�/ f à� ��t �]^ sB{$. 3�C �J (3.98)c c� ��,
$É]^ 4�C(3.75) , 5�C(3.65) , 6�C(3.38): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
\�
3 5.5% 3.5% 20.1% 29.1% 41 .7% 1 00% 3.98
F=1 1 .729
p=.000**
*
4 1 .2% 7.7% 32.0% 33.7% 25.4% 1 00% 3.75
5 1 .9% 6.0% 37.7% 34.4% 20.0% 1 00% 3.65
6 1 1 .1% 9.4% 27.7% 34.5% 1 7.4% 1 00% 3.38
� 5.3% 6.7% 29.3% 33.0% 25.7% 1 00% 3.67
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -48>� ‘ñ< �+ �³/ :® òP.’
‘st � J �� á¯H ¥â ¶� : : ã� jk$.’¯t ô �_ `� qrv <E Ⅲ-49>
_ sBs w$. 48.3%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.54: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| & � è& _�� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
& � è& v [å �J (3.57)v & �è& v �å �J (3.50)� & � è& v ¤å �J (3.13)�$
;D , ]^ qr�`$(p<.05) .
N=820
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 4.1% 6.7% 40.0% 28.0% 21 .1% 1 00% 3.55 t=.401
p=.689L 1 .8% 6.0% 44.9% 32.2% 1 5.1% 1 00% 3.53
� 3.0% 6.3% 42.3% 30.0% 1 8.3% 1 00% 3.54
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -49>� ‘ñ< ' ��_ ´�£ �� �cû& & f+ µìP.’
äå) æ �_ `� �J : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-50>_ sBs w$. äå) æ �_ ¨� ¥â
æ �t bn 3.81^ sB{$.
¿å�^ �| �C, >²Ð, & �è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$.
�È , `â^ o�C]^ ��p�/ ;D,å zH� �`$. 3�C �J (3.76)v c� �t]
a $É]^ 4�C(3.63) , 5�C(3.59), 6�C(3.57): �]^ sB{$(p<.001) . ÉÈ , >�
92 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
�z �J (3.65)v >� �= ·z �J(3.54)�$ ;D,]^ qr�`$(p<.01) . ÊÈ , &�
è&(¤: 3.81, [ : 3.63, �: 3.37)v ���/ ;D,å zH� �`$(p<.01).
N=820
cs  ٠�|õp ��g
\�
3 3.7639 .48735
F=5.894
p=.001***
4 3.6327 .51353
5 3.5957 .50845
6 3.5734 .45567
]� ½0 3.6581 .48961 t=2.653
p=.008**¨½0 3.5412 .50384
ZÎ
ÏZ
� 3.81 47 .53541
F=6.277
p=.002**ó 3.6361 .48971
J 3.3793 .46368
� 3.6353 .49426
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -50>� å,Y Ú `
<�Ê Ⅲ -81 >� å,Y Ú `(\�) <�Ê Ⅲ -82>� å,Y Ú `(]� )
<�Ê Ⅲ -83>� å,Y Ú `(ZÎ ÏZ)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 93
7) x$
�J � `¤]^ � ��) e>: äæ z bn 3.81^ sB{$.
¿å�^ �| �C, >²Ð, & �è& _� Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �È , `â^ o�
C]^ ��p�/ ;D,å zH� �`$. 3�C �J (3.76)v c� �t]a $É]^ 4�C
(3.63) , 5�C(3.59), 6�C(3.57): �]^ sB{$(p<.001). ÉÈ , >� �z �J (3.65)v
>� �= ·z �J (3.54)�$ ;D,]^ qr�`$(p<.01). ÊÈ , &�è&(¤: 3.81, [ :
3.63, �: 3.37)v ���/ ;D,å zH� �`$(p<.01).
v T>t 1�CHø� ��� � ����: ���$t �zT>_ cc$. � v� V
W�t ��^ ��bc¯� . � w$. î³�^ >� ��s &�, è&v ���/ ;D
,å zH� �å �z o�Û³« Y¤]^ �å$. îÍ� ��C]^ �¯p�/ dÎ,å �
q� �vt &z ²¥h IãX$.
²^ c= �/ ðK_ `� M �� (R�| $É� O$.
�È , op �qr: bnæ �t 3.69^ [��$ �z DH^ sB{$. >²ÐA & �
è& ¿å_� Á:; � �vc sB{$. >� �t �J (3.73)� & � è& (¤ : 3.92, [ :
3.92, �: 3.42)v ���/ op �qrv �z �]^ sB{$. � �g� �� ��| ‘st
���� �u_ F qv w$.’_ `� bn 3.63: æ �� �`tñ, ²�J v ß�J �$, o
�C½�/ �� sB{$. î³s ‘���� xyz �{�| =}�$ ~ ��� � w$�
J ��$.’_ `�� t bn 4.16: �z æ �� �² �J v ;�_ `� o�r� 1�
uÉ� ¢ � w$. �|_ ½�, å o�r� éz ‘st ��v�= o�v w$.’_ bn æ
�c bn 3.64å �� ���$| ���� xy_ `� o�rz �® �z �� ¢ � w$.
� ����v �J : o�r� �²�u�, v�z ½�, å o�r]^ ë�] cq)
� �²Þ$.
ÉÈ , ���� r�) : bnæ �t 3.71^ [��$ �z D H^ sB{$. �C, )� , &
�è& ¿å_� Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �C�^t 3�C �J (3.93)v c� �t�, ²�
J(3.84)v ß�J (3.60)_ f� ���� r�) v �t�, & �è& (¤ : 3.95, [ : 3.71, � :
3.34)v ���/ �t$. `Ð�: �g_� o�C½�/ , ²�J ½�/ , & � è& v ���/
¤`, ]^ �z æ �� �`$. nh ‘���� xy� �� s: J xv �� ��$.’_ `�
� t qr�J : 63.8%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.90: �z æ �� �`$. ~�
‘st ���� xy_ `� =}�$ ~ ¢� £$.’_H 3.87: �z æ �� �`$. î³s
‘st >� � ���� xy_ `� vup � �v �t ¡v$.’_ `�� t bn 3.38: �
z æ �� �`� ¿å � �vH sBs= ·t$. � ���� xyv �J � �¸ � ��,
�J z ����_ `� ~ ¢� £� & ÷ �� £=� Y� z �J ����_ `� vup
� �v sw D Ht �# ¯t a]^ �� X$.
94 │ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
ÊÈ , ©:) : bn æ �t 3.69^ [��$ �z D H^ sB{$. �C� & � è& ¿å_
� Á:; � �vc sB{$. �C�^t 3�C �J (3.93)v c� �t�, & � è& (¤ : 4.07,
[: 3.77, �: 3.67)v ���/ �� sB{$. �g�^ �| ‘st F ; wt J � � �v
�$.’_ bn 4.01: �z æ �� �`$. nh 3�C �J (4.25)v �z æ �� �`$. ‘st
©: , v¯t ° ±� � � c �$.’_ `�� t ¤`, ]^ f , �z 3.41: æ �� �`
$. ‘ª ^« �� %®t �v �$.’_ `�� t bn 4.19: �z æ �� �`$. � �J z
©: , å xyz ���=� �¿_� îy »�� �t ½z �= ·$t �� ¢ � w$.
ÔÈ , op T¹�: bn æ �t 3.55^ sB{$. �C� & � è& ¿å_� Á:; � �v
c sB{$. o�C(3�C : 3.70, 4�C : 3.59, 5�C : 3.54, 6�C : 3.42)]^ ��p�/ & �
è&(¤ : 3.78, [ : 3.55, �: 3.35)v ���/ op T¹�v �t$. �g�^t nh ‘st
Ò� �v �t ¡v$.’_ `�� �C, )� , >²Ð, & � è& _� db Á:; � �vc
sB{$. o�C]^ ��p�/ , & � è& v ���/ , ²�J � >� �z �J v Ò�
� �$� qr�`$.
$^È , op EY�� IE�: bn æ �t 3.69^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| �C, >²
Ð, & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$. �C(3: 3.42, 4: 3.26, 5 : 3.24, 6: 3.19)v ��
p�/ , & � è& (¤ : 4.03, [ : 3.65, �: 3.21)v ���/ ;D, å zH� �`$. >�
�z �J (3.30)v >� �= ·z �J (3.17)�$ ;D ,]^ qr�`$.
²^È , Ý y� >L) : bn æ �t 3.79^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| �C� > ²Ð_
j¯ Á:; � �vc wu$. 3�C(3.90)v c� ;D , å zH� �`]a , >� �t �
J(3.81)v >� �= ·t �J (3.70)_ f � ;D , å zH� �`$.
2. ��
�: ¿�_ `� T> M�t 5c= ðK� î_ jk �� �/ ðK�^ �� �$. ¿
å�^ ��,å �vc sBà �� E^ � V �a , �g � _� t nP, å M�c se �
� a�, ]^ � V �$. Em : n) z $É� O$. `Ð� Î\d �²� qr� ¥â f
ot , z ¡v$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 95
N=79
cs ÝsÞ
Y � 46.6
L 53.4
ZÑ
3�¥J 25.9
1 0�¥J 29.3
20�¥J 36.2
21�¥� 8.6
�Ó� \ 66.0
�\ 34.0
��(m 94.6
¨ (m � 5.4
� 1 00,0
<� Ⅲ -51 >� �] � �]& �¤ Y
1) ��= ���� yG QH
�: ���� è& @a_ `� � >A ç> : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-52>_ sBs
w$. �: ���� è& @a_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 4.14^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| �
�, ]^ Á: ; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 4.1 009 .51 259 t=-.532
p=.597L 4.1 786 .64315
� 4.1 427 .58337
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -52>� \�& �� ÏZ �Ü
�: ���� è& @a ðKz ‘é, ㆍ å, oê ëì’, ‘p ¨ � >L oê e ) ’, ‘�
: `þ , ÿ��� e ) ’]^ ���`$.
96│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
(1) z; ·{; M| }i
é, ·å, oê ëì_ ¨�� t bn 4.23: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| � ¥
§(4.41)v ��� ¥§(3.97)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�Ó� \ 4.41 25 .59256 t=2.520
p=.015*�\ 3.9706 .63666
� 4.2385 .66648
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -53>� Ý� ㆍ ,� � Ãß
<�Ê Ⅲ -84>� Ý� ㆍ ,� � Ãß(� �)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t ����í^îï� «ð�tñ xò � � wt H�s Fóc �$.’_
`� M�c <E Ⅲ-54>_ sBs w$. qro: 90.8%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn
4.20: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 1 0.0% 56.7% 33.3% 1 00% 4.23 t=.385
p=.702L 0.0% 2.9% 5.7% 62.9% 28.6% 1 00% 4.1 7
� 0.0% 1 .5% 7.7% 60.0% 30.8% 1 00% 4.20
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -54>� ‘êë \�< ��� ����+ ç�J<Æ å* / ` W< £cñ �º® òP.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 97
‘®Í �t ����í^îï� «ð � � wt V ô v �z ¡v$.’_ `� M�c
<E Ⅲ-55>_ sBs w$. qro: 72.3%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.89: æ ��
�`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 1 0.0% 30.0% 36.7% 23.3% 1 00% 3.73 t=-1 .408
p=.1 65L 0.0% 2.9% 1 4.3% 60.0% 22.9% 1 00% 4.03
� 0.0% 6.2% 21 .5% 49.2% 23.1% 1 00% 3.89
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -55>� ‘êë \�< ��� ����+ ç� / ` W< ? ¼¥ �� õ ¥P. ’
‘®Í �t ����� õö� � wt � v w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-56>_ s
Bs w$. qro: 86.2%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.12: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^
�| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 3.3% 1 0.0% 60.0% 26.7% 1 00% 4.1 0 t=-.225
p=.823L 0.0% 5.7% 8.6% 51 .4% 34.3% 1 00% 4.1 4
� 0.0% 4.6% 9.2% 55.4% 30.8% 1 00% 4.1 2
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -56>� ‘êë \�;< ��� + �«/ ` W< sû¥ WP.’
‘®Í �t ����� & ÷ � � wt p Lc �z ¡v$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ
-57>_ sBs w$. qro: 87.7%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.34: æ �� �`
$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
98│ 2012� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 1 0.0% 56.7% 33.3% 1 00% 4.23 t=-1 .01 1
p=.316L 0.0% 5.7% 8.6% 22.9% 62.9% 1 00% 4.43
� 0.0% 3.1% 9.2% 38.5% 49.2% 1 00% 4.34
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -57>� ‘êë \�< ��� + Zù/ ` W< I^ ® ò� õ ¥P.’
(2) K ~ � �m M| � �
p ¨ � >L oê e ) _ ¨�� t bn 4.05: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��,
]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 3.9778 .66628 t=-.733
p=.466L 4.1 1 43 .81 225
� 4.051 3 .74589
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -58>� I� ' ]^ � àY
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t >A ç>: døv xI�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-59>_ sBs w$. q
ro: 73.8%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.97: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��,
]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 6.7% 23.3% 50.0% 20.0% 1 00% 3.83 t=-1 .087
p=.281L 0.0% 1 1 .4% 1 1 .4% 34.3% 42.9% 1 00% 4.09
� 0.0% 9.2% 1 6.9% 41 .5% 32.3% 1 00% 3.97
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -59>� ‘êë \�< �]µ �]& F2¥ å�JP.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 99
‘®Í �t �i y�Í xyv xI�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-60>_ sBs w$. qr
o: 83.1%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.12: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]
^ Á: ; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 1 0.0% 6.7% 56.7% 26.7% 1 00% 4.00 t=-1 .051
p=.297L 0.0% 5.7% 1 1 .4% 37.1% 45.7% 1 00% 4.23
� 0.0% 7.7% 9.2% 46.2% 36.9% 1 00% 4.1 2
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -60>� ‘êë \�< �Á Ö,ë åÖ¥ å�JP.’
‘®Í �t >, �Ðd, �J , = K�úv ûü : ý�t ½v �$.’_ `� M�c <E
Ⅲ-61>_ sBs w$. qro: 78.5%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.06: æ �� �`
$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 23.3% 43.3% 33.3% 1 00% 4.1 0 t=.362
p=.719L 0.0% 5.7% 1 4.3% 51 .4% 28.6% 1 00% 4.03
� 0.0% 3.1% 1 8.5% 47.7% 30.8% 1 00% 4.06
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -61 >� ‘êë \�< �],� \�F ,� \� ,� � ���¥ "< &ËJ< b¥ òP.’
(3) ��= ^�; � ��� � �
�: `þ, ÿ��� e ) _ `� �J : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-62>_ sBs w$. �:
`þ , ÿ��� e ) _ ¨� ¥â bn æ �t 4.05^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| ��,]^ Á
:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
100│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 3.9778 .66628 t=-.733
p=.466L 4.1 1 43 .81 225
� 4.051 3 .74589
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -62>� \�& [� � á´Ä Å àY
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t = K>L: ���� p ¨�âA Ý �� �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-63>_
sBs w$. qro: 81.5%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.20: æ �� �`$. ¿å�
^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 1 6.7% 46.7% 36.7% 1 00% 4.20 t=.000
p=1 .000L 0.0% 2.9% 1 7.1% 37.1% 42.9% 1 00% 4.20
� 0.0% 1 .5% 1 6.9% 41 .5% 40.0% 1 00% 4.20
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -63>� ‘êë \�< � �]^ & �� I�ㆍ �� µ »Ñ+ �P.’
‘= K>Lt ®Í �: ���� �� >?� ¢� w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-64>_
sBs w$. qro: 86.2%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.31: æ �� �`$. ¿å�
^t � ¥§(4.50)v ��� ¥§(3.94)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.01) .
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�Ó� \ 0.0% 0.0% 7.5% 35.0% 57.5% 1 00% 4.50 t=2.866
p=.006**�\ 0.0% 0.0% 29.4% 47.1% 23.5% 1 00% 3.94
� 0.0% 1 .5% 1 2.3% 40.0% 46.2% 1 00% 4.31
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -64>� ‘� �]^ < êë \�& �vy z\� ]ö+ �$ WP.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 01
<�Ê Ⅲ -85>� � �]^ ® �v]ö+ ¨P(�Ó)
‘®Í �t = K>L: ���� �>_ ¾²�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-65>_ sBs
w$. qro: 84.6%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.28: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t
� ¥§(4.45)v ��� ¥§(3.88)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.01) .
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�Ó� \ 0.0% 0.0% 1 0.0% 35.0% 55.0% 1 00% 4.45 t=2.870
p=.006**�\ 0.0% 0.0% 29.4% 52.9% 1 7.6% 1 00% 3.88
� 0.0% 1 .5% 1 3.8% 40.0% 44.6% 1 00% 4.28
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -65>� ‘êë \�< � � ]^ & �� �]; ºL �P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -86>� \�® � � ]^ & � ��]; ºL(�Ó)
‘®Í �A = K>Lt ���� ¨� D �� §Á�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-66>_ s
Bs w$. qro: 83.1%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.17: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^
t � ¥§(4.38)v ��� ¥§(3.88)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
102 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�Ó� \ 0.0% 0.0% 1 0.0% 42.5% 47.5% 1 00% 4.38 t=2.51 7
p=.015*�\ 0.0% 0.0% 29.4% 52.9% 1 7.6% 1 00% 3.88
� 0.0% 1 .5% 1 5.4% 47.7% 35.4% 1 00% 4.1 7
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -66>� ‘êë \�µ � �]^ < �� �� � #G Óä�P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -87>� \�µ � �]^ �� � # Óä(�Ó)
2) �� ���= ����; C� ��
� �) : ����, K� ��_ `� �J : qrM �c <E Ⅲ-67>_ sBs w$.
� �) : ����, K� ��_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 4.33]^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �
| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 4.3076 .46818 t=-.360
p=.720L 4.3546 .51301
� 4.3324 .48849
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -67>� \� cY � & � �� �â ¬�
� �) : ����, K� �� ðKz ‘���� Á’, ‘���� ’, ‘���� ©
W’]^ ���`$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 103
(1) ���� ��
���� Á_ ¨�� t bn 4.37: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t � ¥§(4.47)v
��� ¥§(4.20)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�Ó� \ 4.4778 .45086 t=2.048
p=.045*�\ 4.2059 .47650
� 4.3646 .49345
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -68>� �� ãä
<�Ê Ⅲ -88>� �� ãä(�Ó)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t �����u ¥V L� �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-69>_ sBs w$. qr
o: 78.5%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.98: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]
^ Á: ; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
104 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 1 0.0% 1 3.3% 50.0% 26.7% 1 00% 3.93
t=-.444p=.659
L 0.0% 5.7% 1 4.3% 51 .4% 28.6% 1 00% 4.03
� 0.0% 7.7% 1 3.8% 50.8% 27.7% 1 00% 3.98
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -69>� ‘êë \�< ��sø �? ^ G �P.’
‘®Í �t �����u §�� �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-70>_ sBs w$. qro
: 98.5%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.51: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t �
¥§(4.65)v ��� ¥§(4.29)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�Ó� \ 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 35.0% 65.0% 1 00% 4.65 t=2.565
p=.01 3*�\ 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 70.6% 29.4% 1 00% 4.29
� 0.0% 0.0% 1 .5% 46.2% 52.3% 1 00% 4.51
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -70>� ‘êë \�< � �sø Ó�+ �P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -89>� \�® ��sø Ó�(�Ó)
‘®Í �t ����v J x�� w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-71>_ sBs w$.
qro: 89.2%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.34: f , �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�
^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 105
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 1 3.3% 46.7% 40.0% 1 00% 4.27 t=-.800
p=.427L 0.0% 0.0% 8.6% 42.9% 48.6% 1 00% 4.40
� 0.0% 0.0% 1 0.8% 44.6% 44.6% 1 00% 4.34
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -71 >� ‘êë \�< ��� ¥ �å�ð WP. ’
(2) ���� ��
���� _ `� � >A ç> : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-72>_ sBs w$. ���
� _ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 4.50^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt
Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 4.4537 .41 624 t=-.731
p=.468L 4.5484 .54932
� 4.5043 .49001
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -72>� �� �
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t $�� ���� í^îï� «ð �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-73>_ s
Bs w$. qro: 98.4%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.63: �z æ �� �`$. ¿
å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 50.0% 50.0% 1 00% 4.50 t=-1 .926
p=.059L 0.0% 0.0% 2.9% 20.0% 77.1% 1 00% 4.74
� 0.0% 0.0% 1 .5% 33.8% 64.6% 1 00% 4.63
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -73>� ‘êë \�< Pü� ��� ����+ ç� �P.’
106│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
‘®Í � > z ����_ `� ¨\ � q�v w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-74>_ s
Bs w$. qro: 95.3%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.48: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^
t & �_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �| `â ,]^ & �v µ�]�/ ;
D, å zH� �`$. 21C v¤: & �(4.88)v c� �t]a , $É]^ 20C v�: & �
(4.60) , 10C v�: & �(4.41) , 3C v�: & �(4.13): �]^ sB{$(p<.05) .
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÑ
3�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 6.7% 73.3% 20.0% 1 00% 4.1 3
F=3.1 22p=.032*
1 0�¥J 0.0% 5.9% 5.9% 29.4% 58.8% 1 00% 4.41
20�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 40.0% 60.0% 1 00% 4.60
21�¥� 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1 2.5% 87.5% 1 00% 4.88
� 0.0% 1 .5% 3.1% 41 .5% 53.8% 1 00% 4.48
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -74>� ‘êë \� �]û� ��; [� �÷ _ ÌÑ¥ WP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -90>� �]& ��� �÷ (ZÑ)
‘®Í �t ����: x) �_ �z ��� p å$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-75>_
sBs w$. qro: 95.3%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.55: �z æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 107
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 6.7% 30.0% 63.3% 1 00% 4.57 t=.1 49
p=.882L 0.0% 2.9% 0.0% 37.1% 60.0% 1 00% 4.54
� 0.0% 1 .5% 3.1% 33.8% 61 .5% 1 00% 4.55
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -75>� ‘êë \�< ��� & åY ; ò� ÁÑ+ IS,P.’
‘®Í �t Ë�s �p� �| ����� �� � w$.’_ M�c <E Ⅲ-76>_
sBs w$. qro: 93.9%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.48: �z æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 3.3% 3.3% 50.0% 43.3% 1 00% 4.33 t=-1 .635
p=.1 07L 0.0% 0.0% 5.7% 28.6% 65.7% 1 00% 4.60
� 0.0% 1 .5% 4.6% 38.5% 55.4% 1 00% 4.48
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -76>� ‘êë \�< ©cñ � JIÛ J© ��� + ½+ ` WP.’
(2) ���� j�
���� ©W_ ` � �J : qrM �c <E Ⅲ-77>_ sBs w$. ���� ©W_ ¨
� ¥â æ �t bn 4.26^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á: ; � �v t Iã=
·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 4.2716 .65396 t=.031
p=.975L 4.2667 .54245
� 4.2690 .59241
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -77>� �� ÐU
108│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �: �����u ¥V t ¾��$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-78>_ sBs w$. q
ro: 76.9%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.00: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��,
]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 6.7% 23.3% 36.7% 33.3% 1 00% 3.97 t=-.305
p=.761L 0.0% 2.9% 1 4.3% 60.0% 22.9% 1 00% 4.03
� 0.0% 4.6% 1 8.5% 49.2% 27.7% 1 00% 4.00
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -78>� ‘êë \�& ��sø �? < º�JP.’
‘®Í �: ���� §�z ¾��$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-79>_ sBs w$. qro
: 90.7%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.33: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^t & �v µ�]�/ ;D ,å zH� �`$. 21C v¤: & �(4.71)v c� �t
]a $É]^ 20C v�: & �(4.44) , 10C v�: & �(4.35) , 3C v�: & �(3.93): �]
^ sB{$(p<.05) . ~� ¥§_ j¯ ��,]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �| � ¥
§(4.48)v ��� ¥§(4.06)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ qr�`$(p<.05) .
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÑ
3�¥J 0.0% 6.7% 1 3.3% 60.0% 20.0% 1 00% 3.93
F=2.806p=.047*
1 0�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 1 1 .8% 41 .2% 47.1% 1 00% 4.35
20�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 4.0% 48.0% 48.0% 1 00% 4.44
21�¥� 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 28.6% 71 .4% 1 00% 4.71
�Ó� \ 0.0% 2.5% 5.0% 35.0% 57.5% 1 00% 4.48
t=2.365p=.023*
�\ 0.0% 0.0% 1 1 .8% 70.6% 1 7.6% 1 00% 4.06
� 0.0% 1 .6% 7.8% 46.9% 43.8% 1 00% 4.33
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -79>� ‘êë \�& � � Ó�� º� JP.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 109
<�Ê Ⅲ -91 >� \�& � � Ó� º� (ZÑ) <�Ê Ⅲ -92>� \�& �� Ó� º� (�Ó)
‘®Í �t ª ^« ���� �u_ `� ¨\ v ��, � «ð_ �+��� ���$.’
_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-80>_ sBs w$. qro: 95.3%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , b
n 4.57: $Î �z æ �� �`$.
¿å�^t � ¥§(4.73)v ��� ¥§(4.35)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ qr�`$
(p<.05) .
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�Ó� \ 0.0% 0.0% 2.5% 22.5% 75.0% 1 00% 4.73 t=2.393
p=.020* �\ 0.0% 0.0% 5.9% 52.9% 41 .2% 1 00% 4.35
� 0.0% 0.0% 4.6% 33.8% 61 .5% 1 00% 4.57
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -80>� ‘êë \�< þ �ç �� sø; [� �÷ ¥ ô$,� \� ç�; djJ�$ ÁÑ�P. ’
<�Ê Ⅲ -93>� \�& þ �ç �� �÷ (�Ó)
1 1 0│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
3) ��= _�; ��q ��
�: ¥�, � ¤_ `� � >A ç> : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-81>_ sBs
w$. �: ¥�, � ¤_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.96^ sB{$. ¿å�^ ��,
]^ Á:; � �vt sBs= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 3.9578 .36765 t=-.235
p=.81 5L 3.9794 .36859
� 3.9693 .36538
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -81 >� \�& �=� � Ñ ã�
�: ¥�, � ¤ ðKz ‘� �� «ð ��: ¿�’, ‘� �D : ¿�’,
‘� «ð +E [æ >? ¿�’, ‘� �� �M ��’, ‘>: ¥�) ¤’]^ ���`$.
(1) �� � �l �� = ��
� �� «ð ��: ¿�_ ¨�� t bn 3.78: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]
^ Á: ; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 3.8667 .58460 t=1 .033
p=.306L 3.7143 .60034
� 3.7846 .59346
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -82>� \� �æ ç� �è & é
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t $k �_ f � �� �D «ð 57 v ��� X$.’_ `� M�c <E
Ⅲ-83>_ sBs w$. qro: 95.4%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.38: æ �� �`
$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� �� ]ö �_Y su | 1 1 1
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 50.0% 50.0% 1 00% 4.50 t=1 .505
p=.1 37L 0.0% 0.0% 8.6% 54.3% 37.1% 1 00% 4.29
� 0.0% 0.0% 4.6% 52.3% 43.1% 1 00% 4.38
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -83>� ‘êë \�< Pì \�; �� �æ � _� ç� íî¥ pØ P.’
‘®Í �: �� �D «ðz ��� ��st & ®c �$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ
-84>_ sBs w$. qro: 38.5%c ÐD , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.06: æ �� �`
$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 3.3% 30.0% 23.3% 33.3% 1 0.0% 1 00% 3.1 7 t=.691
p=.492L 8.6% 31 .4% 25.7% 22.9% 1 1 .4% 1 00% 2.97
� 6.2% 30.8% 24.6% 27.7% 1 0.8% 1 00% 3.06
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -84>� ‘êë \�& �æ � _� ç�� �è + ïðñ< Zê® òP.’
‘®Í �t ¥�, å 5 � $Ï� �� «ð ��� �«$.’_ `� M �c <E Ⅲ-85>
_ sBs w$. qro: 70.7%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.91: æ �� �`$. ¿
å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 26.7% 53.3% 20.0% 1 00% 3.93 t=.255
p=.799L 0.0% 2.9% 28.6% 45.7% 22.9% 1 00% 3.89
� 0.0% 1 .5% 27.7% 49.2% 21 .5% 1 00% 3.91
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -85>� ‘êë \�< ��� , íÿ _ P + �æ ç� �è + �çP. ’
1 1 2│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
(2) �� ��W = ��
� �D : ¿�_ ¨�� t bn 4.07: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t � ¥§(4.27)
v ��� ¥§(3.76)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.001) .
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�Ó� \ 4.2750 .53848 t=3.396
p=.001***�\ 3.7647 .46793
� 4.071 8 .56670
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -86>� \� � _� & é
<�Ê Ⅲ -94>� \� � _� & é(�Ó)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �: �Dz $k �A �^ �vc �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-87>_ sBs
w$. qro: 60%c ÐD,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.37: æ�� �`$. ¿å�^t �g
_ j¯ ��,]^ Á:;� �vc sB{$. 40� v�(3.95)c c� ;D,]^ qr�`]
a , $É]^ 35� v�(3.73) , 30� v�(3.09) , 41� v¤(2.78): �]^ sB{$(p<.01) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 1 3
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�æ
30�¥J 9.1% 27.3% 9.1% 54.5% 0.0% 1 00% 3.09
F=4.883
p=.004**
35�¥J 0.0% 1 3.3% 1 3.3% 60.0% 1 3.3% 1 00% 3.73
40�¥J 0.0% 1 0.5% 1 0.5% 52.6% 26.3% 1 00% 3.95
41�¥� 16.7% 27.8% 1 6.7% 38.9% 0.0% 1 00% 2.78
� 6.2% 21 .5% 1 2.3% 49.2% 1 0.8% 1 00% 3.37
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -87>� ‘êë \�& � _� � Pì \�µ Ø� p¥® �P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -95>� Pì \�µ � _� p¥(ZÑ)
‘®Í � �D z $k �_ f� ����v f [v �z ¡v$.’_ `� M�
c <E Ⅲ-88>_ sBs w$. qro: 95.4%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.51: $
Î �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:
; � �vc sB{$. �| ����� �p = ·t ·ç>(5.00)c ����� �p t ·ç
>(4.48)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.001) . ~� ¥§_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ;
� �vc sB{$. � ¥§(4.68)v ��� ¥§(4.29)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D, ]^ qr�
`$(p<.05) .
1 1 4│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 0.0% 1 .7% 3.3% 40.0% 55.0% 1 00% 4.48 t=-6.1 50
p=.000***¨(m 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1 00% 1 00% 5.00
�Ó� \ 0.0% 0.0% 2.5% 27.5% 70.0% 1 00% 4.68 t=2.165
p=.035*�\ 0.0% 5.9% 0.0% 52.9% 41 .2% 1 00% 4.29
� 0.0% 1 .5% 3.1% 38.5% 56.9% 1 00% 4.51
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -88>� ‘êë \� � _� � Pì \�; �� ��� & �ó¥ ô� õ ¥P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -96>� ��� �ó(��) <�Ê Ⅲ -97>� ��� �ó(�Ó)
‘®Í � �D z “���� �� >? ” V� v¥� $Ï$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ
-89>_ sBs w$. qro: 90.8%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.34: æ �� �`
$. ¿å�^t & �_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. 20C v� & �(4.60)v c
� �t]a , $É]^ 3C v� & �(4.53) , 21C v¤ & �(4.38) , 10C v¤ & �(3.76): �
]^ sB{$(p<.05) . ~� ¥§_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. � ¥§
(4.58)v ��� ¥§(3.82)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ qr�`$(p<.01) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 1 5
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Z
Ñ
3�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 46.7% 53.3% 1 00% 4.53
F=3.943
p=.01 2*
1 0�¥J 5.9% 1 1 .8% 1 1 .8% 41 .2% 29.4% 1 00% 3.76
20�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 40.0% 60.0% 1 00% 4.60
21�¥� 0.0% 1 2.5% 0.0% 25.0% 62.5% 1 00% 4.38
�
Ó
� \ 0.0% 5.0% 0.0% 27.5% 67.5% 1 00% 4.58 t=3.1 1 3
p=.003**�\ 5.9% 5.9% 5.9% 64.7% 1 7.6% 1 00% 3.82
� 1 .5% 4.6% 3.1% 40.0% 50.8% 1 00% 4.34
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -89>� ‘êë \� � _�� “�vy z\� ]ö ”� ?� ¥�_ P P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -98>� �v ¥È � _� é(ZÑ) <�Ê Ⅲ -99>� �v ¥È � _� é(�Ó)
(3) �� �l �! �� �� ��
� «ð +E [æ >? ¿�_ ¨�� t bn 3.86: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �|
� ¥§(3.95)v ��� ¥§(3.64)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�
�
(m 3.841 8 .48485 t=-2.097
p=.040*¨(m 4.4444 .50918
�Ó� \ 3.9583 .52400 t=2.169
p=.035*�\ 3.6458 .37454
� 3.8646 .49590
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -90>� \� ç� j� óÚ ]ö é
1 1 6│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 00>� \� óÚ ]ö é(��) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 01 >� \� óÚ ]ö é(�Ó)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t �= � [\ ]^ «ð X$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-91>_ sBs w$. K
�` �g]^ bn 2.97: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã
= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 36.7% 36.7% 23.3% 3.3% 1 00% 2.93
t=-.280p=.780
L 5.9% 26.5% 35.3% 26.5% 5.9% 1 00% 3.00
� 3.1% 31 .2% 35.9% 25.0% 4.7% 1 00% 2.97
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -91 >� ‘êë \�< �� �_ ó÷ ¾� ç� P.’
‘®Í �t ����� [\ ]^ «ðX$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-92>_ sBs w$.
qro: 87.7%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.14: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| ����� �p t=_ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{
$. ����� �p = ·t ·ç>(5.00)v ����� �p t ·ç>(4.10)�$ ¤`,]^
;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 1 7
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 0.0% 1 .7% 1 1 .7% 61 .7% 25.0% 1 00% 4.1 0 t=-2.358
p=.022*¨(m 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1 00% 1 00% 5.00
� 0.0% 1 .5% 1 0.8% 60.0% 27.7% 1 00% 4.1 4
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -92>� ‘êë \�< ��� + ó÷ ¾� ç� P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 02>� �� óÚ � (��)
‘®Í �t �����u â ÷ xyv �z ¡v$.’¯t ô �_ `� qrv <E Ⅲ-93>_
sBs w$. 95.4%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.48: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �|
����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �����
�p = ·t ·ç>(5.00)c ����� ·ç>(4.45)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$
(p<.001) . ~� � ¥§(4.60)v ��� ¥§(4.24)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ qr�`$
(p<.05) .
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 0.0% 0.0% 5.0% 45.0% 50.0% 1 00% 4.45 t=-7.1 67
p=.000**
*¨(m 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1 00% 1 00% 5.00
�Ó� \ 0.0% 0.0% 2.5% 35.0% 62.5% 1 00% 4.60 t=2.289
p=.026*�\ 0.0% 0.0% 5.9% 64.7% 29.4% 1 00% 4.24
� 0.0% 0.0% 4.6% 43.1% 52.3% 1 00% 4.48
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -93>� ‘êë \�< ��sø �ùåÖ¥ ò� õ ¥P.’
1 1 8│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 03>� ��sø �ù åÖ(� �) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 04>� ��sø �ù åÖ(�Ó)
(4) �� �� �$
� �� �M ��_ ¨�� t bn 4.03: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:
; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 3.9167 .84163 t=-1 .206
p=.232L 4.1 357 .61 937
� 4.0346 .73271
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -94>� �' �Î � ú �_
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t J x=Hc � Æ t ¡v$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-95>_ sBs w$. K
�` �g]^ bn 3.91: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã
= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 1 0.0% 1 0.0% 1 3.3% 40.0% 26.7% 1 00% 3.63 t=-1 .959
p=.057L 0.0% 2.9% 8.6% 60.0% 28.6% 1 00% 4.1 4
� 4.6% 6.2% 1 0.8% 50.8% 27.7% 1 00% 3.91
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -95>� ‘êë \�< �å� £® � ¨ �< õ¥P.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 1 9
‘®Í � �J z �� c �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-96>_ sBs w$. K�` �g]
^ bn 4.17: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �g_ j¯ ��,]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �| 40� v�(4.37)v c�
�t�, $É]^ 41� v�(4.33) , 30� v�(4.27) , 35� v�(3.67): �]^ sB{$(p<.05).
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�æ
30�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 9.1% 54.5% 36.4% 1 00% 4.27
F=2.81 5
p=.047*
35�¥J 0.0% 1 3.3% 26.7% 40.0% 20.0% 1 00% 3.67
40�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 5.3% 52.6% 42.1% 1 00% 4.37
41�¥� 0.0% 5.6% 5.6% 38.9% 50.0% 1 00% 4.33
� 0.0% 4.6% 1 0.8% 47.7% 36.9% 1 00% 4.1 7
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -96>� ‘êë \� \�û� �Î ® òP. ’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 05>� \�û� �Î ® òP(ZÑ)
‘®Í � �J z Ò� �v �t ¡v$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-97>_ sBs w$. K
�` �g]^ bn 3.92: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã
= ·t$.
1 20 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 6.7% 20.0% 46.7% 26.7% 1 00% 3.93
t=.093p=.926
L 0.0% 5.7% 1 7.1% 57.1% 20.0% 1 00% 3.91
� 0.0% 6.2% 1 8.5% 52.3% 23.1% 1 00% 3.92
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -97>� ‘êë \� \�û� + ò¥ J< õ¥P. ’
‘®Í � �J z o� $�v ��= t ¡v$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-98>_ sBs w
$. K�` �g]^ bn 4.14: $Î �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:;
� �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 6.7% 1 0.0% 53.3% 30.0% 1 00% 4.07
t=-.661p=.51 1
L 0.0% 2.9% 1 4.3% 42.9% 40.0% 1 00% 4.20
� 0.0% 4.6% 1 2.3% 47.7% 35.4% 1 00% 4.1 4
* p < .05 ** p < .01 *** p < .001
<� Ⅲ -98>� ‘êë \� \� û� � PÎ¥ Ïð � < õ¥P.’
(5) ��= _�� ��
>: ¥�) ¤_ ¨�� t bn 4.08: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t & �_ j¯ ��,
]^ Á:;� �vc sB{$. 20C v�(4.29)c c� ;D,]^ qr�`]a , $É]^ 10C
v�(4.20) , 3C v�(3.78) , 21C v¤(3.75): �]^ sB{$(p<.05) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 21
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
ZÑ
3�¥J 3.7833 .50768
F=3.1 1 9
p=.032*
1 0�¥J 4.2059 .53935
20�¥J 4.2900 .45461
21�¥� 3.7500 1 .1 9523
� 4.0846 .64692
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -99>� �]& ��Y ã�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 06>� �]& ��Y ã�(ZÑ)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í � > z �J : �& � �t$.’¯t ô �_ `� qrv <E Ⅲ-100>_ sB
s w$. 89%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.95: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^ �| & �_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. 20C v�: & �(4.16)v
c� ;D ,]^ qr�`]a , $É]^ 10C v�: & � (4.12) , 3C v�: & �(3.80) , 21C
v¤: & �(3.25): �]^ sB{$(p<.05) .
1 22 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÑ
3�¥J 0.0% 6.7% 6.7% 86.7% 0.0% 1 00% 3.80
F=3.041p=.036*
1 0�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 1 1 .8% 64.7% 23.5% 1 00% 4.1 2
20�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 8.0% 68.0% 24.0% 1 00% 4.1 6
21�¥� 1 4.3% 0.0% 0.0% 71 .4% 1 4.3% 1 00% 3.25
� 1 .6 1 .6 7.8 71 .8 1 7.2 1 00% 3.95
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 00>� ‘êë \� �]û� \�û& ¡Z+ ½<P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 07>� �]< ¡Z+ ½<P(ZÑ)
‘®Í � > z $�� �7 � >ò�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-101>_ sBs w$.
qro: 90.7%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.17: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��
,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 6.7% 70.0% 23.3% 1 00% 4.1 7 t=-.027
p=.978L 2.9% 0.0% 8.6% 54.3% 34.3% 1 00% 4.1 7
� 1 .5% 0.0% 7.7% 61 .5% 29.2% 1 00% 4.1 7
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 01 >� ‘êë \� �]û� Pü� �`î+ ]*�P.’
‘®Í � > z ��& ð� ��t ¡v$.’¯t ô �_ `� qrv <E Ⅲ-102>_ s
Bs w$. 92.3%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.26: æ �� �`$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 1 23
¿å�^ �| & �_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. 20C v�: & �(4.52)v
c� ;D ,]^ qr�`]a , $É]^ 10C v�: & � (4.35) , 21C v¤: & �(4.00) , 3C
v�: & �(3.87): �]^ sB{$(p<.05) .
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÑ
3�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 20.0% 73.3% 6.7% 1 00% 3.87
F=3.429p=.022*
1 0�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 5.9% 52.9% 41 .2% 1 00% 4.35
20�¥J 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 48.0% 52.0% 1 00% 4.52
21�¥� 12.5% 0.0% 0.0% 50.0% 37.5% 1 00% 4.00
� 1 .5% 0.0% 6.2% 55.4% 36.9% 1 00% 4.26
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 02>� ‘êë \� �]û� \¹Z�+ � J< õ¥P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 08>� �]& \¹Z�(ZÑ)
‘®Í � > z �����u �q�v ��s$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-103>_ s
Bs w$. qro: 78.4%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.95: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^
�| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 26.7% 53.3% 20.0% 1 00% 3.93 t=-.1 95
p=.846L 2.9% 2.9% 1 1 .4% 60.0% 22.9% 1 00% 3.97
� 1 .5% 1 .5% 1 8.5% 56.9% 21 .5% 1 00% 3.95
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 03>� ‘êë \� �]û� ��sø �`ÌÑ¥ ÐðñP. ’
1 24│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
4) ^�; ��
`þ, �� ��_ `� � >A ç> : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-104>_ sBs w$. `
þ, �� ��_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.78^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á: ; �
�vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 3.741 7 .61 355 t=-.580
p=.564L 3.8280 .50032
� 3.7894 .55016
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 04>� [� � �_ ¬�
`þ, �� �� ðKz ‘�_ `� `þ v;= @a’� ‘�_ `� ¤/ �D p¨
: ¨\� = ’]^ ���`$.
(1) ��� ^� ^� �T � QH
�_ `� `þ v; = @a_ ¨�� t bn 3.82: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��,
]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õp ��g
Y � 3.7753 .60480
t=-.61 1p=.544
L 3.8595 .49063
� 3.8221 .541 37
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 05>� \�; [� [� ¥ý� �Ü
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t �D X v; =c w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-106>_ sBs w$. K�` �
g]^ bn 2.56: $Î �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vt Iã
= ·t$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 1 25
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 1 3.8% 48.3% 1 7.2% 1 7.2% 3.4% 1 00% 2.48 t=-.527
p=.600L 1 1 .4% 48.6% 1 1 .4% 22.9% 5.7% 1 00% 2.63
� 1 2.5% 48.4% 1 4.1% 20.3% 4.7% 1 00% 2.56
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 06>� ‘êë \�< $� ¥ý� ® WP.’
‘®Í �t �J �c æ æ � �v$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-107>_ sBs w$. K
�` �g]^ bn 3.53: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã
= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 3.4% 1 7.2% 34.5% 20.7% 24.1% 1 00% 3.45
t=-.570p=.570
L 0.0% 1 4.3% 31 .4% 34.3% 20.0% 1 00% 3.60
� 1 .6% 1 5.6% 32.8% 28.1% 21 .9% 1 00% 3.53
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 07>� ‘êë \�< \� `® Ú Ú �ðû �¥P.’
‘����]^ ®Í �_ `� ª ^« å � \ � � w� �v$.’_ `� M�c
<E Ⅲ-108>_ sBs w$. qro: 93.8%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.44: æ �
� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 1 0.3% 37.9% 51 .7% 1 00% 4.41 t=-.279
p=.781L 0.0% 0.0% 2.9% 48.6% 48.6% 1 00% 4.46
� 0.0% 0.0% 6.2% 43.8% 50.0% 1 00% 4.44
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 08>� ‘��� ¾� êë \�; [� þ�ç ,ÿ + ÷ ð� ` W+ �¥P.’
1 26│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
‘®Í �^ ¥� µ�t ¤õ >!c w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-109>_ sBs w$. q
ro: 75.3%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.10: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��,
]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 0.0% 25.0% 42.9% 32.1% 1 00% 4.07 t=-.222
p=.825L 0.0% 0.0% 22.9% 42.9% 34.3% 1 00% 4.1 1
� 0.0% 0.0% 23.8% 42.9% 33.3% 1 00% 4.1 0
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 09>� ‘êë \�� �\ ��< �� ]�® WP.’
(2) ��� ^� �? �� JW K~= ~� ��
�_ `� ¤/ �D p ¨: ¨\ � = _ ¨�� t bn 3.95: æ �� �`$. ¿
å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õp ��g
Y � 3.9333 .76980 t=-.220
p=.827L 3.9785 .75980
� 3.9583 .75762
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 0>� \�; [� �× � �� I�& �÷ _ � �
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘"vs = "_� ®Í �_ `� �z = � �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-111>_
sBs w$. qro: 65.7%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.83: æ �� �`$. ¿å�
^ �| � ¥§(4.03)v ��� ¥§(3.47)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ qr�`$(p<.05) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 1 27
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�Ó� \ 0.0% 5.1% 1 7.9% 46.2% 30.8% 1 00% 4.03
t=2.087p=.042*
�\ 0.0% 1 7.6% 41 .2% 1 7.6% 23.5% 1 00% 3.47
� 0.0% 9.4% 25.0% 39.1% 26.6% 1 00% 3.83
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 1 >� ‘� È¥ñ � � �È;% êë \�; [� ò� � �+ �P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 09>� � È/� � �È;% � � (�Ó)
‘®Í =5o#�â _� ®Í �_ ¨\ � = � � Þ$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-112>_
sBs w$. qro: 67,2%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.92: æ �� �`$. ¿å�
^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 3.4% 31 .0% 37.9% 27.6% 1 00% 3.90
t=-.21 7p=.829
L 0.0% 2.9% 28.6% 40.0% 28.6% 1 00% 3.94
� 0.0% 3.1% 29.7% 39.1% 28.1% 1 00% 3.92
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 2>� ‘êë � íg ��;% êë \�; �÷ _ � � + � |P.’
‘¤� p ¨ v ®Í �� ° ±�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-113>_ sBs w$. qro:
85.7%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.25: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á
:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
1 28 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 3.6% 1 0.7% 53.6% 32.1% 1 00% 4.1 4 t=-1 .067
p=.290L 0.0% 0.0% 1 4.3% 37.1% 48.6% 1 00% 4.34
� 0.0% 1 .6% 1 2.7% 44.4% 41 .3% 1 00% 4.25
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 3>� ‘�¹ I�û¥ êë \�G �P.’
5) �C�m= ���� {�� ��
= K>L: ���� åí¯ xò_ `� � >A ç> : qrM�c <E Ⅲ-114>_
sBs w$. = K>L: ���� åí¯ xò_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 4.11^ sB{$. ¿
å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 4.0000 .59094 t=-1 .231
p=.223L 4.2143 .76757
� 4.1 1 72 .69622
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 4>� � �]^ & �� ,�� å*
= K: ���� åí¯ xò ðKz ‘= K p� V ô xò’, ‘=K ��: K>) � ¥��
�ð� ����W%©T’^ ���`$.
(1) �C K � � � ��
= K p� V ô xò_ ¨�� t bn 4.13: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:
; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 1 29
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 4.0460 .62820 t=-.882
p=.381L 4.2000 .74623
� 4.1 302 .69419
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 5>� � � I= ? ¼ å*
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t ����� ¨�� = K: V ô � xò�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-116>_ s
Bs w$. qro: 85.9%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.19: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^
�| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 3.4% 6.9% 62.1% 27.6% 1 00% 4.1 4 t=-.476
p=.636L 0.0% 2.9% 1 4.3% 40.0% 42.9% 1 00% 4.23
� 0.0% 3.1% 1 0.9% 50.0% 35.9% 1 00% 4.1 9
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 6>� ‘êë \�< � �_ ��� � �& ? ¼ + å*�P.’
‘®Í �t =K: =Í, ²$� ����_ � xò�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-117>_
sBs w$. qro: 84.4%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.17: æ �� �`$. ¿å�
^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
1 30│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 6.9% 1 3.8% 51 .7% 27.6% 1 00% 4.00 t=-1 .567
p=.1 22L 0.0% 2.9% 8.6% 42.9% 45.7% 1 00% 4.31
� 0.0% 4.7% 1 0.9% 46.9% 37.5% 1 00% 4.1 7
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 7>� ‘êë \�< � �& � ë� L�+ ��� ; � å*�P.’
‘= K>Lc ����� ¨��² ®Í �� xò�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-118>_ s
Bs w$. qro: 73.4%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.03: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^
�| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 3.4% 20.7% 48.3% 27.6% 1 00% 4.00 t=-.249
p=.804L 0.0% 8.6% 20.0% 28.6% 42.9% 1 00% 4.06
� 0.0% 6.2% 20.3% 37.5% 35.9% 1 00% 4.03
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 8>� ‘� �]^ ® ��_ ��JL êë \�G å*�P.’
(2) �C ��= C�� _ ¡ �l� �����¢jO
= K ��: K>) � ¥�� �ð� ����W%©T_ ¨�� t 4.10: æ �� �`$. ¿
å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
Y � 3.9540 .64071 t=-1 .433
p=.1 57L 4.2286 .85088
� 4.1 042 .76951
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 1 9>� � � �& � ]Y _ ��+ =�� ��U�Ð~
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 31
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í �t = K��� ����_ � xò�$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-120>_ sB
s w$. qro: 73.4%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.11: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^
�| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 3.4% 27.6% 41 .4% 27.6% 1 00% 3.93 t=-1 .499
p=.1 39L 0.0% 2.9% 20.0% 25.7% 51 .4% 1 00% 4.26
� 0.0% 3.1% 23.4% 32.8% 40.6% 1 00% 4.1 1
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 20>� ‘êë \�< � ��G ��� ; � å*�P.’
‘®Í �: ����z ®Í = K: ¥�� &Í�� �� �$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ
-121>_ sBs w$. qro: 76.5%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.14: æ �� �`
$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 3.4% 20.7% 51 .7% 24.1% 1 00% 3.97 t=-1 .51 2
p=.1 36L 0.0% 2.9% 20.0% 22.9% 54.3% 1 00% 4.29
� 0.0% 3.1% 20.3% 35.9% 40.6% 1 00% 4.1 4
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 21 >� ‘êë \�& ��� � êë � �& ��+ Êë�$ ÁÑ�P.’
‘®Í �: ����_t = K: K>c õà w$.’_ `� M�c <E Ⅲ-122>_ s
Bs w$. qro: 75%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.06: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^
�| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
1 32 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=79
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
Y � 0.0% 3.4% 24.1% 44.8% 27.6% 1 00% 3.97 t=-.809
p=.422L 0.0% 5.7% 1 7.1% 34.3% 42.9% 1 00% 4.1 4
� 0.0% 4.7% 20.3% 39.1% 35.9% 1 00% 4.06
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 22>� ‘êë \�& ��� ; < � �& � ]® �¤WP.’
6) x$
�: ¿�_ `� $^ c= ðK�^ M�� DÍ�| $É� O$.
�È , �: ���� è& @a ðK_� ¥â bn æ�t 4.14^ f , ;D ,]^ sB{
$. ¿å�^ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vt Iã= ·t$. �/ ðK� æ �� �| ‘é, ㆍ å
, oê ëì’z 4.23: �z æ �� �`� � ¥§(4.41)v ��� ¥§(3.97)�$ ¤`,
]^ ;D , ]^ qr�`$. �g [_ ‘®Í �t ����� & ÷ � � wt p Lc
�z ¡v$.’_� qro: 87.7%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.34: �z æ �� �²
���� �� = >?v ;D, b c� �t �� ¢ � w$. $É]^ ‘p ¨ � >L oê
e ) ’H bn 4.0513: �z æ �� �`$, vt �) �: xI� ¨�c e )uÉ�
�²Þ$. ‘�: `þ, ÿ��� e ) ’: bn æ �t 4.05^ sB{$. =K>Lc ����
�� = >?� ¢� w]a , ����D �� §Á��, �c = K>L: �>_ ,?, ]
^ ¾²�t �]^ sB{$.
���� ��� V W�t ��_� ¤`, ]^ ���� è& @a_ `� ;D, ]^ b c
� �]^ �å$. ��� ¥§�$ �¥§ > * ç>c ~ ;D , ]^ qr� �z �
�_ `� p `�Þ: �v_� fLX �]^ �å$.
ÉÈ , � �) : ����, K� ��: ¥â bn æ �t 4.33]^ �� sB{$. ¿
å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
�/ ðK� æ �� �| ‘���� Á’_ ¨�� t bn 4.36: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å
�^t � ¥§(4.47)v ��� ¥§(4.20)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]^ b c�`$. �g�
^ �| ����: ¥V * §�, îÍ � ����v J x�� w$� qr�`$.
‘���� ’: bn æ �H 4.50]^ �� sB{$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á: ; �
�vt Iã= ·t$. �g�^ �| $�� ����í^îï� x) �_ `� ��_
�z æ �� �u�, nh ‘®Í �t Ë�s �p� �| ����� �� � w$.’_
qro: 93.9%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.48: �z æ �� �² ���� ��c
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 133
����: p L � §_ p ²�� wÉ� �`$.
‘���� ©W’: bn æ �t bn 4.26]^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á: ; �
�vt Iã= ·t$.
ÊÈ , �: ¥�, � ¤: bn æ �t 3.96]^ sB{$. ¿å�^ ��, ]^ Á
:; � �vt sBs= ·t$.
�/ ðK� æ �� �| ‘� �� «ð ��: ¿�’: bn æ �t 3.78^ sB{�, ¿
å�^t ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$. �g�^ �| ‘®Í �t $k �
_ f � �� �D «ð 57 v ��� X$.’_ bn 4.38: �z æ �� �å �| ‘®Í
�: �� �D «ðz ��� ��st & ®c �$.’_ bn 3.06: æ �� �²
�D z ���u=� ���D «ð ��: ½¨) z $Î }�= t �]^ sB{$.
‘� �D: ¿�’: bn æ �t 4.07^ �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ¥§_ j¯
��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. � ¥§(4.27)v ��� ¥§(3.76)�$ ¤`,]^
;D , ]^ b c�`$. �g�^ �| ‘®Í � �D z $k �_ f � ����
v f[v �z ¡v$.’_ qro: 95.4%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.51: $Î �
z æ �� �`$
‘� «ð +E [æ >? ¿�’: bn æ �t 3.86: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �|
� ¥§(3.95)v ��� ¥§(3.64)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$. �g�^ �| ‘®
Í �t ����� [\ ]^ «ðX$.’_ `� qro: 87.7%c ;D, å zH� �
`]a , bn 4.14: �z æ �� �`$. ~� ‘®Í �t �����u â÷ xyv �z ¡
v$.’_ 95.4%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 4.48: æ �� �`$.
‘� �� �M ��’t 4.03: �z æ �� �`$.
‘>: ¥�) ¤’t 4.08: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t & �_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; �
�vc sB{$. 20C v�(4.29)c c� ;D , ]^ qr�`]a , $É]^ 10C v�(4.20)
: �]^ sB{$. �g�^ �| ‘®Í � > z $�� �7� >ò�$.’c 4.17:
�z æ �� �`$.
ÔÈ , `þ, �� ��: bn æ �t 3.78^ sB{$.
�/ ðK�^ �| ‘�_ `� `þ v;= @a’z 3.8221: bn æ �� �`$. �g�
^ �| ‘����]^ ®Í �_ `� ª ^« å � \ � � w� �v$.’c 4.44:
�z æ �� �`�, ‘®Í �^ ¥� µ�t ¤õ >!c w$.’_ 4.10: æ �� �² �
: v; = @a_ ��c wÉ� �²�u$.
‘�_ `� ¤/ �D p¨: ¨\� = ’z 3.95: æ �� �`$. �g�^ �| ‘¤
� p ¨ v ®Í �� ° ±�$.’_ 4.25: �z æ �� �`$. � ¤/ �D p ¨:
== � �� w� . � w$.
1 34 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
$^È , = K>L: ���� åí¯ xò: bn æ �t 4.11^ sB{$.
‘= K p� V ô xò’z 4.13: æ �� �`�, ‘=K ��: K>) � ¥�� �ð� ���
�W%©T’t 4.10: æ �� �`$.
3. �C�m
= K>L ¿�_ `� T> M�t 4 ðK� �� �/ ðK�^ �� �$. ¿å�^ ��,
å �vc sBà �� E^ �V �a , �g � _� t nP, å M�c se �� a�, ]^
�V �$. Em : n) z $� O$.
N=1 28
cs ÝsÞ
Y � 1 7.7
L 82.3
�æ 40� ¥J 45.2
40� ¥� 54.8
çÏ¥�Ï¥ 65.4
çÏ¥ 34.6
� �(m 72.7
¨ (m 27.3
ZÎÏZ
300Û� ýÛ 34.2
400Û� ýÛ 30.3
400Û� ,� 35.5
� 1 00,0
<� Ⅲ -1 23>� � ��� �¤ Y
1) �C= ���� yG QH
= K: ���� è& @a_ `� = K�ú: qrM�c <E Ⅲ-124>_ sBs w$. = K
: ���� è& @a_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.03]^ sB{$. ¿å�^t ����� �
p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �| ����� �p t =
K�ú(3.24)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.67)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$
(p<.001) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 135
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�
�
(m 3.2494 .81 806 t=3.51 0
p=.001***¨(m 2.6784 .87271
� 3.0397 .86423
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 24>� � �& �� ÏZ �Ü
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 0>� � ��� ÏZ �Ü(� �)
= K�ú: = K: ���� è& @a ðKz ‘é, ·å, oê ëì’, ‘=K>L � >L o
ê e ) ’]^ ���`$.
(1) z; ·{; M| }i
é, ·å, oê ëì_ ¨�� t bn 3.27: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t
=_ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �| ����� �p t = K�
ú(3.45)v ����� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.95)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D,]^ bc�`$(p<.01) .
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�
�
(m 3.4559 .77778 t=3.1 1 7
p=.002**¨(m 2.9561 .92406
� 3.2705 .84559
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 25>� Ý� ㆍ ,� � Ãß
1 36│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 1 >� Ý� ·,� � Ãß(� �)
� �g �^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í =K_t ����� � � wt V ôv � � w$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-126>
_ sBs w$. qro: 26.6%�v ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 2.84: �z æ �� �
`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{
$. �| ����� �p t =K�ú(3.02)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.54)�$ ¤`
,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 6.9% 26.4% 35.6% 1 9.5% 1 1 .5% 1 00% 3.02 t=2.369
p=.019*¨(m 1 5.4% 33.3% 33.3% 1 7.9% 0.0% 1 00% 2.54
� 9.4% 29.7% 34.4% 1 8.8% 7.8% 1 00% 2.84
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 26>� ‘êë � �; < � �+ / ` W< ? ¼ ¥ � �ð WP. ’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 2>� � �& ��? ¼(� �)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 137
‘®Í =Kz ����_ xò� � wt H�s Fóc �$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-127>
_ sBs w$. qro: 27.4%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 2.81: �z æ �� �
`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{
$. ����� �p t = K�ú(3.01)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.51)�$ ¤`, ]
^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.01) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 4.6% 28.7% 34.5% 25.3% 6.9% 1 00% 3.01 t=2.645
p=.009**¨(m 1 0.3% 46.2% 25.6% 1 7.9% 0.0% 1 00% 2.51
� 6.2% 35.2% 31 .2% 22.7% 4.7% 1 00% 2.81
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 27>� ‘êë � � � � �; å*/ ` W< £cñ �º® òP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 3>� �� �º � £c(��)
‘®Í = K_t ����� � cÏ'�t � v w$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-128>_
sBs w$. qro: 28.9%�v ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 2.89: �z æ �� �`$.
¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��,]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �
���� �p t =K�ú(3.08)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.56)�$ ¤`,]^ ;
D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
1 38 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 4.6% 27.6% 34.5% 21 .8% 1 1 .5% 1 00% 3.08 t=2.558
p=.01 2*¨(m 1 5.4% 33.3% 30.8% 20.5% 0.0% 1 00% 2.56
� 7.8% 30.5% 32.8% 21 .1% 7.8% 1 00% 2.89
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 28>� ‘êë � � ;< ��+ � ® ��< sû¥ WP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 4>� � �& ��� (� �)
‘®Í =K_� ����� % � wt p Lc �z ¡v$.’_ `� qrM �c <E Ⅲ
-129>_ sBs w$. qro: 28.9%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 2.82: �z æ �
� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc
sB{$. ����� �p t = K�ú(3.05)v ����� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.44)�$ ¤
`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.01) . ~� � �p�_ j¯ ��,]^ Á:; � �vc s
B{$. 16C v¤ � �� = K�ú(3.19)v 15C v� � �� = K�ú(2.56)� 5C v� � �
� = K�ú(2.74)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 139
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 3.4% 32.2% 29.9% 25.3% 9.2% 1 00% 3.05 t=3.075
p=.003**¨(m 1 7.9% 38.5% 25.6% 1 7.9% 0.0% 1 00% 2.44
��
Iæ
5�¥J 9.5% 31 .0% 40.5% 1 4.3% 4.8% 1 00% 2.74
F=3.213
p=.044*1 5�¥J 10.0% 44.0% 28.0% 1 6.0% 2.0% 1 00% 2.56
16�¥� 3.7% 37.0% 1 4.8% 25.9% 1 8.5% 1 00% 3.1 9
� 7.8% 35.2% 28.1% 22.7% 6.2% 1 00% 2.82
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 29>� ‘êë � � ;% ��+ �S ` W< I^ ® ò� õ¥P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 5>� ��� I^ (��) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 6>� ��� I^ (��Iæ)
(2) �C�m � �m M| � �
= K>L � >L oê e ) _ ¨�� t bn 3.00: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t �����
�p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. ����� �p t =K�
ú(3.23)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.61)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$
(p<.001) .
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
��(m 3.2326 .86670 t=3.553
p=.001***¨(m 2.61 54 .96968
� 3.0082 .93593
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 30>� � �]^ ' ]^ � à Y
1 40│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 7>� ]^ � à Y (� �)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í =K_� t =K�ú, �, §§p ¨, p ? (v ���� xy_ ¨�� � ^ Ý � �
� �$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-131>_ sBs w$. qro: 37%�v ;D , å zH�
�`]a , bn 3.16: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ �
�, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. ����� �p t = K�ú(3.40)v ����� �p =
·t = K�ú(2.77)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.001) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 1 .2% 1 5.1% 38.4% 33.7% 1 1 .6% 1 00% 3.40 t=3.377
p=.001*
**¨(m 1 2.8% 23.1% 43.6% 1 5.4% 5.1% 1 00% 2.77
� 4.7% 1 8.9% 39.4% 27.6% 9.4% 1 00% 3.1 6
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ-131>�‘êë ��;%< ����,�\�,�ÓÓI�,�Iö ¸¥ �� åÖ; ��% %� »Ñ+ � �P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 8>� �� åÖ » Ñ(��)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 41
‘®Í =K_t ����� ¨�X >� : døv xI�$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-132>
_ sBs w$. qro: 28.2%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 2.85: �z æ �� �
`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{
$. ����� �p t = K�ú(3.06)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.46)�$ ¤`, ]
^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.01) . ~� � �p�_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$.
16C v¤ � �� =K�ú(3.15)v 15C v� � �� = K�ú(2.54)� 5C v� � �� = K
�ú(2.83)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à� h
P
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 4.6% 25.3% 36.8% 26.4% 6.9% 1 00% 3.06 t=3.087
p=.002**¨(m 1 7.9% 35.9% 30.8% 1 2.8% 2.6% 1 00% 2.46
��
Iæ
5�¥J 9.5% 26.2% 40.5% 1 9.0% 4.8% 1 00% 2.83
F=3.459
p=.035*1 5�¥J 1 2.0% 40.0% 32.0% 1 4.0% 2.0% 1 00% 2.54
16�¥� 3.7% 22.2% 37.0% 29.6% 7.4% 1 00% 3.1 5
� 8.6% 28.9% 34.4% 22.7% 5.5% 1 00% 2.85
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 32>� ‘êë � � ;< ��_ �� ]�û& F2¥ å�JP. ’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 1 9>� � � F2 (��) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 20>� �� F2 (��Iæ)
1 42 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
(3) ^� ; ��� � � �
`þ, ÿ��� e ) _ ¨�� � �g�^ �� �| $É� O$.
‘®Í =K_�t ���� p¨ㆍ �â v �^ Ý�� ��$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-133>
_ sBs w$. qro: 32.3%�v ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 2.99: �z æ �� �
`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{
$. ����� �p t = K�ú(3.17)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.68)�$ ¤`, ]
^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 4.6% 1 9.5% 36.8% 32.2% 6.9% 1 00% 3.1 7 t=2.535
p=.01 2*¨(m 1 5.8% 21 .1% 44.7% 1 5.8% 2.6% 1 00% 2.68
� 7.9% 20.5% 39.4% 26.8% 5.5% 1 00% 2.99
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 33>� ‘êë � �;% < � � I�ㆍ �� û¥ % � » Ñ+ ��P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 21 >� �� I� » Ñ(��)
‘®Í =K_t ����� ¨�X >� : døv xI�$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-134>
_ sBs w$. qro: 46.9%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.43: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��,]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �
���� �p t =K�ú(3.59)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(3.21)�$ ¤`,]^ ;
D , ]^ b c�`$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 143
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 0.0% 6.9% 40.2% 40.2% 1 2.6% 1 00% 3.59 t=2.208
p=.029*¨(m 7.7% 1 2.8% 43.6% 23.1% 1 2.8% 1 00% 3.21
� 2.3% 1 0.2% 40.6% 34.4% 1 2.5% 1 00% 3.43
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 34>� ‘êë � �; W< \�< � �]^ µ »d� ��G ¼$ WP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 22>� \�µ � �]^ & ��(��)
‘®Í =K: �t =K>L �>_ �v ¾²�$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-135>_ s
Bs w$. qro: 46.4%�v ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 3.39: æ �� �`$. ¿å�
^t ����� �p t=_ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. ����
� �p t = K�ú(3.61)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(3.00)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]
^ b c�`$(p<.001) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 0.0% 9.2% 35.6% 40.2% 1 4.9% 1 00% 3.61 t=3.570
p=.001**
*¨(m 2.6% 28.9% 39.5% 23.7% 5.3% 1 00% 3.00
� 0.8% 1 5.0% 37.8% 34.6% 1 1 .8% 1 00% 3.39
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 35>� ‘êë � � & \�< � � ]^ �]; ò¥ ºL �P.’
1 44│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ-123>� \�® ��]^ �]ºL(��)
2) �CDE= ����; C� ��
= K: ����, K� ��_ `� =K�ú: qrM�c <E Ⅲ-136>_ sBs w$. =
K: ����, K� ��_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 2.79^ sB{$. ¿å�^t �����
�p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. ����� �p t =K�
ú(3.00)v ����� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.44)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D,]^ bc�`$(p<.01).
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�
�
(m 3.0078 .90993 t=3.107
p=.002**¨(m 2.4459 .9371 1
� 2.7969 .94360
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 36>� � ���& ��� � â ¬�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 24>� ��� � â ¬�(��)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 145
= K�ú: ����, K� �� ðKz ‘���� Á’, ‘���� ’, ‘���� ©T’
^ ���`$.
(1) ���� ��
���� Á_ ¨�� t bn 2.73: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `
� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �| ����� �p t = K�ú(2.98)
v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.31)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.001) .
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�
�
(m 2.9884 1 .02319 t=3.362
p=.001***¨(m 2.31 58 1 .03598
� 2.7397 1 .07838
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 37>� � � ãä
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 25>� �� ãä(��)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í =Kz �i ¥V Lc �v +,$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-138>_ sBs w$.
qro: 20.5%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 2.79: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ �
�, ]^ Á: ; � �vt sBs= ·t$.
1 46│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 1 2.2% 29.3% 41 .5% 1 2.2% 4.9% 1 00% 2.68
F=2.634
p=.07615�¥J 8.0% 38.0% 48.0% 2.0% 4.0% 1 00% 2.56
16�¥� 3.7% 25.9% 40.7% 1 8.5% 1 1 .1% 1 00% 3.07
� 7.9% 29.9% 41 .7% 1 3.4% 7.1% 1 00% 2.79
* p < .05 ** p < .01 *** p < .001
<� Ⅲ -1 38>� ‘êë � �� �Á �? ^ ® ò¥ ÙÇP.’
‘®Í = Kz �i §�v �v +,$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-139>_ sBs w$. q
ro: 23.4%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 2.84: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��
,]^ Á:; � �vt sBs= ·t$.
N=28
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 9.5% 26.2% 42.9% 1 6.7% 4.8% 1 00% 2.81
F=1 .926
p=.1 501 5�¥J 8.0% 38.0% 44.0% 6.0% 4.0% 1 00% 2.60
1 6�¥� 3.7% 25.9% 40.7% 22.2% 7.4% 1 00% 3.04
� 7.0% 28.9% 40.6% 1 7.2% 6.2% 1 00% 2.84
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 39>� ‘êë � � � �Á Ó�¥ ò¥ ÙÇP.’
(2) ���� ��
���� _ ¨�� t bn 2.85: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `
� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. ����� �p t = K�ú(3.04)v �
���� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.55)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 147
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�
�
(m 3.0402 .92830 t=2.628
p=.01 0*¨(m 2.5526 1 .01 202
� 2.8566 .96740
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 40>� � � �
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 26>� �� � (� �)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í =K �ú z ����_ `� ¨\ � q�v �$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-141>
_ sBs w$. qro: 25.8%�v ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 2.88: æ �� �`$.
¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��,]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �
���� �p t =K�ú(3.03)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.62)�$ ¤`,]^ ;
D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 5.7% 21 .8% 44.8% 1 8.4% 9.2% 1 00% 3.03 t=2.1 40
p=.034*¨(m 1 0.3% 43.6% 25.6% 1 5.4% 5.1% 1 00% 2.62
� 7.0% 28.9% 38.3% 1 8.0% 7.8% 1 00% 2.88
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 41 >� ‘êë � � ��û� ��; [� �÷ _ ÌÑ¥ òP. ’
1 48│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 27>� �� �÷ (��)
‘®Í = Kz ����_ �z -o� �$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-142>_ sBs
w$. qro: 24.4%�v ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 2.83: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�
^t ����� �p t=_ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. ����
� �p t = K�ú(3.05)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.47)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]
^ b c�`$(p<.01) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 4.6% 20.7% 48.3% 1 8.4% 8.0% 1 00% 3.05 t=3.014
p=.003**¨(m 1 8.4% 36.8% 23.7% 21 .1% 0.0% 1 00% 2.47
� 8.7% 26.0% 40.9% 1 8.9% 5.5% 1 00% 2.83
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 42>� ‘êë � �� ��� ; ò� _G �P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 28>� ��� _(��)
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 149
(3) ���� j�
���� ©W_ ¨�� t bn 2.85: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `
� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. ����� �p t = K�ú(2.98)v �
���� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.31)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�
�
(m 2.9884 1 .02319 t=3.362
p=.001***¨(m 2.31 58 1 .03598
� 2.7397 1 .07838
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 43>� � � ÐU
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 29>� �� ÐU(��)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í = K �ú z ��� �� s ���� W%� � �. p Lc w$.’_ `� qrM
�c <E Ⅲ-144>_ sBs w$. qro: 24.2%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 2.72
: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t = K�ú(2.95)v ����� �p = ·
t = K�ú(2.33)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$(p<.01) .
150│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 6.9% 26.4% 39.1% 1 9.5% 8.0% 1 00% 2.95 t=3.026
p=.003**¨(m 23.1% 43.6% 1 5.4% 1 2.8% 5.1% 1 00% 2.33
� 1 2.5% 32.0% 31 .2% 1 7.2% 7.0% 1 00% 2.72
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 44>� ‘êë � � ��û� ��G J�ñ �� U�+ ÛûðÚ I^ ® WP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 30>� �� U� Ûû I^(��)
‘®Í =Kz �ú v ��� �� s ���� W%� � � wH/ 0��t �/p v
$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-145>_ sBs w$. qro: 26.9%�v ;D , å zH� �
`]a , bn 2.78: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t = K�ú(3.01)v ��
��� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.37)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.01) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 7.0% 25.6% 36.0% 22.1% 9.3% 1 00% 3.01t=3.084p=.003**
¨(m 21 .1% 42.1% 1 8.4% 1 5.8% 2.6% 1 00% 2.37
� 1 1 .1% 31 .7% 30.2% 1 9.8% 7.1% 1 00% 2.78
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 45>�‘êë � �� ��û¥ ��G J�ñ �� U�+ Ûû ` W£) V �J< s× I¥P. ’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 51
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 31 >� �� V � s× I(��)
3) �C= yG QH
= K: è& @ a_ `� =K�ú: qrM�c <E Ⅲ-146>_ sBs w$. = K: è&
@a_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.33]^ sB{$. 16C v¤ � �� =K�ú(3.54)v 15C v
� � �� = K�ú(3.25)A 5C v� � �� = K�ú(3.21)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c
�`$(p<.05) .
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 3.21 43 .56591
F=3.579
p=.031*1 5�¥J 3.2519 .44744
1 6�¥� 3.5433 .56599
� 3.3397 .55043
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 46>� � �& ÏZ �Ü
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 32>� � �& ÏZ �Ü(��Iæ)
= K�ú: è& @a ðKz ‘éÍ, è& @a’, ‘>L oê ¤’, ‘= K>L �� �M ’,
‘`þ , ��’^ ���`$.
152 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
(1) éÍ, è& @a
éÍ, è& @a_ ¨�� t bn 3.54: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��, ]^ Á:; � �
vt sBs= ·tI.
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 3.5079 .55699
F=1 .61 7
p=.2031 5�¥J 3.4236 .56174
1 6�¥� 3.6667 .56990
� 3.5455 .58689
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 47>� Ýë� ÏZ �Ü
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í =Kz J x�tñ Å¡ûv �t V ô � 12� w$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ
-148>_ sBs w$. qro: 28.9%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 2.92: �z æ �
� �`$. ¿å�^ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt sBs= ·t$.
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 16.7% 23.8% 38.1% 1 6.7% 4.8% 1 00% 2.69
F=1 .637
p=.1 991 5�¥J 4.0% 26.0% 44.0% 24.0% 2.0% 1 00% 2.94
1 6�¥� 3.7% 22.2% 40.7% 25.9% 7.4% 1 00% 3.1 1
� 7.8% 22.7% 40.6% 23.4% 5.5% 1 00% 2.92
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 48>� ‘êë � �� �åJ<Æ ¦õ"¥ �< ? ¼ + 16$ WP.’
‘®Í = Kz ²³ c= V ô v w$.’_ `� qrM �c <E Ⅲ-149>_ sBs w$. qr
o: 26.4%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 2.83: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��,
]^ Á:; � �vt sBs= ·t$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 153
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 1 1 .9% 33.3% 33.3% 1 9.0% 2.4% 1 00% 2.67
F=1 .71 9
p=.1 841 5�¥J 6.2% 37.5% 37.5% 1 6.7% 2.1% 1 00% 2.71
1 6�¥� 0.0% 30.8% 38.5% 23.1% 7.7% 1 00% 3.08
� 6.4% 32.0% 35.2% 22.4% 4.0% 1 00% 2.83
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 49>� ‘êë � �� L ®� ? ¼ ¥ WP.’
(2) �m M| ��
>L oê ¤_ ¨�� t bn 3.05: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t 16C v¤ � �� = K
�ú(3.44)v 15C v� � �� = K�ú(2.93)� 5C v� � �� = K�ú(2.82)�$ ¤`, ]
^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.01) .
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õp ��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 2.8214 .82508
F=5.660
p=.005**1 5�¥J 2.9375 .75530
16�¥� 3.4444 .73815
� 3.0579 .82460
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 50>� ]^ � ã�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 33>� ]^ � ã�(��Iæ)
154│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í = K_� t =K�ú, �, §§p ¨, p ? v � ^ � Ý ��t �/p v$.’_ `�
qrM�c <E Ⅲ-151>_ sBs w$. qro: 34.4%�v ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn
3.13: æ �� �`$. 16C v¤ � �� =K�ú(3.44)v 15C v� � �� =K�ú(3.08)�
5C v� � �� =K�ú(2.86)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 4.8% 31 .0% 40.5% 21 .4% 2.4% 1 00% 2.86
F=3.847
p=.024*1 5�¥J 2.0% 20.0% 50.0% 24.0% 4.0% 1 00% 3.08
1 6�¥� 0.0% 1 1 .1% 44.4% 33.3% 1 1 .1% 1 00% 3.44
� 2.3% 20.3% 43.0% 28.9% 5.5% 1 00% 3.1 3
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 51 >� ‘êë � � ;% < � ���,� \�,� ÓÓI�,� Iöû¥ % � � » ÑJ< s× I¥P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 34>� � ���,� \�,� ÓÓI�,� Iö » Ñs× I(��Iæ)
‘®Í = K_� t ²³ c= dø v xI�$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-152>_ sBs
w$. qro: 27.7%�v ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 2.98: �z æ �� �`$. 16C
v¤ � �� = K�ú(3.44)v 15C v� � �� = K�ú(2.79)� 5C v� � �� = K�ú
(2.79)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.01) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 155
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 4.8% 31 .0% 47.6% 1 4.3% 2.4% 1 00% 2.79
F=5.551p=.005**
1 5�¥J 6.2% 31 .2% 43.8% 1 4.6% 4.2% 1 00% 2.79
1 6�¥� 0.0% 1 4.8% 40.7% 29.6% 1 4.8% 1 00% 3.44
� 4.0% 25.4% 42.9% 20.6% 7.1% 1 00% 2.98
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 52>� ‘êë � �;% < L ®� F2û¥ å�JP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 35>� L F2 å� � £(��Iæ)
(3) �C�m �� �$
= K>L �� �M_ ¨�� t bn 3.84: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��,]^ Á:; �
�vt sBs= ·t$.
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 3.8492 .59902
F=1 .046
p=.3551 5�¥J 3.7467 .56166
1 6�¥� 3.9506 .671 1 6
� 3.8455 .58564
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 53>� � �]^ �Î � ú
156│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í =K_� t >$ �>�c �v ½�à$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-154>_ sBs w
$. K�` �g]^ bn 3.72: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t 40� v�: = K�ú(3.51)v 41
� v¤: = K�ú(3.87)�$ >$ �>�c �v ½�à$� qr�`$(p<.05) . ~� & � _ j
¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. c 300� ;�: Î�v wt =K�ú(3.89)v
c 400� ;�: Î�v wt =K�ú(3.82)� c 400� v¤: Î�v wt = K�ú
(3.45)�$ ¤`, ]^ �z æ �� �`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�æ 40�¥J 2.1% 8.5% 38.3% 38.3% 1 2.8% 1 00% 3.51 t=-2.255
p=.026*41�¥� 1 .3% 2.7% 24.0% 52.0% 20.0% 1 00% 3.87
ZÎ
300ÛýÛ 0.0% 2.2% 24.4% 55.6% 1 7.8% 1 00% 3.89
F=3.245
p=.042*400ÛýÛ 0.0% 5.3% 23.7% 55.3% 1 5.8% 1 00% 3.82
400ۥ� 5.0% 7.5% 40.0% 32.5% 1 5.0% 1 00% 3.45
� 1 .6% 4.7% 31 .2% 46.1% 1 6.4% 1 00% 3.72
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 54>� ‘êë � �;% < ]� �]$® ò¥ bð³P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 36>� ]�]$ � £(��) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 37>� ]�]$ � £(ZÎ )
‘®Í = K_� t v3ÔÍ $-t & ®c �$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-155>_ sBs
w$. K�` �g]^ bn 3.87: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��,]^ Á:; � �vt sB
s= ·t$.
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 157
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 2.4% 4.8% 1 9.0% 54.8% 1 9.0% 1 00% 3.83
F=.31 8
p=.7291 5�¥J 0.0% 4.0% 26.0% 54.0% 1 6.0% 1 00% 3.82
1 6�¥� 0.0% 0.0% 25.9% 51 .9% 22.2% 1 00% 3.96
� 0.8% 3.1% 24.2% 54.7% 1 7.2% 1 00% 3.87
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 55>� ‘êë � �;% < ¥r-ë P_< Zê® òP.’
‘���� xyz ®Í =K >� � �MV Ê �v$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-156>_
sBs w$. K�` �g]^ bn 3.94: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t c 400� ;�: Î
�v wt =K�ú(4.26)v c 400� v¤: Î�v wt = K�ú(3.95)� c 300�
;�: Î�v wt = K�ú(3.67)�$ ¤`, ]^ æ �c �t$(p<.05)
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
ZÎ
300ÛýÛ 4.4% 8.9% 20.0% 48.9% 1 7.8% 1 00% 3.67
F=4.102
p=.01 9*400ÛýÛ 0.0% 5.3% 1 0.5% 36.8% 47.4% 1 00% 4.26
400ۥ� 0.0% 7.5% 22.5% 37.5% 32.5% 1 00% 3.95
� 1 .6% 7.0% 1 9.5% 40.6% 31 .2% 1 00% 3.94
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 56>� ‘�� åÖ� êë � � ]�û+ �ú?¨ �¥P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ-1 38>� �� � ��� �ú £Z(ZÎ )
158│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
(4) ^� ;
`þ, ��_ ¨�� bn 3.4541: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vt
sBs= ·t$.
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
��
Iæ
5�¥J 3.4638 .57506
F=.903
p=.4101 5�¥J 3.3462 .59986
1 6�¥� 3.5833 .61 058
� 3.4541 .59401
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 57>� � �]^ [� � �_
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í = Kz æ æ �ú v ��$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-158 >_ sBs w$. K
�` �g]^ bn 2.97: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t þ�v� �t = K�ú(2.82)v ²�v
� �t =K�ú(3.19) �$ �úv ��$� qr�`$(p<.05) . ~� ����� �p t =
K�ú(3.08)v ����� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.69)�$ æ �c �t$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
qö�Ï¥ 1 0.3% 1 9.1% 48.5% 22.1% 0.0% 1 00% 2.82 t=-2.266
p=.025*çÏ¥ 1 .9% 20.4% 37.0% 38.9% 1 .9% 1 00% 3.1 9
�
�
(m 5.8% 1 5.1% 45.3% 32.6% 1 .2% 1 00% 3.08 t=2.347
p=.021*¨(m 7.7% 30.8% 46.2% 1 5.4% 0.0% 1 00% 2.69
� 6.3% 1 9.7% 44.9% 28.3% 0.8% 1 00% 2.97
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 58>� ‘êë � �� Ú Ú ��û¥ �ð�P.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 159
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 39>� �� ` Í�(qö) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 40>� �� ` Í�(��)
‘®Í =Kz &p �z 4v$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-159>_ sBs w$. qro:
70.3%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.89: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t þ�v� �t =
K�ú(4.04)c ²�v� �t =K�ú(3.75)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
qö�Ï¥ 1 .5% 0.0% 22.1% 45.6% 30.9% 1 00% 4.04 t=2.1 45
p=.034*çÏ¥ 0.0% 3.6% 29.1% 56.4% 1 0.9% 1 00% 3.75
� 0.8% 1 .6% 27.3% 49.2% 21 .1% 1 00% 3.89
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 59>� ‘êë � �� ÊI �� Ñ¥P.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 41 >� ��Óæ¾�% & Ûo£(qö)
160│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
‘®Í =Kv o5Û6$.’_ `� qrM �c <E Ⅲ-160>_ sBs w$. qro: 66.9%
c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.77: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t þ�v� �t = K�ú
(3.94)c ²�v� �t = K�ú(3.56)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
qö�Ï¥ 1 .5% 1 .5% 23.9% 47.8% 25.4% 1 00% 3.94 t=2.579
p=.01 1*çÏ¥ 1 .8% 5.5% 32.7% 54.5% 5.5% 1 00% 3.56
� 1 .6% 3.1% 28.3% 51 .2% 1 5.7% 1 00% 3.77
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 60>� ‘êë � �¥ Õ³ÄP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 42>� � �¥ Õ³ÄP(qö)
4) �C= ���� {�� ��
= K: ���� åí¯ xò_ `� =K�ú: qrM�c <E Ⅲ-161>_ sBs w$. =
K: ���� åí¯ xò_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.23]^ sB{$. ¿å�^t ����
� �p t = K�ú(3.37)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.96)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]
^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � � ]ö �_Y su | 1 61
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
qö�Ï¥ 3.41 67 .93473 t=2.263
p=.025*çÏ¥ 3.0648 .76815
�
�
(m 3.3735 .81 888 t=2.469
p=.015*¨(m 2.9605 .93817
� 3.2333 .87431
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 61 >� � �& �� ,�� å*
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 43>� �� ,�� å*(qö) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 44>� �� ,�� å*(��)
= K: ���� åí¯ xò ðKz ‘= K>L � ¥V �, §��, 7é¨, H� ¨ xò’, ‘=
K>L � ��Á9-ô �, Á,= , >: , /å (-xò’]^ ���`$.
(1) �C�m � _� £, s £, ¥z~, P� ~ ��
= K>L � ¥V �, §��, 7é¨, H� ¨ xò_ ¨�� t bn 2.96: æ �� �`$. ¿
å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �|
����� �p t = K�ú(3.10)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.69)�$ ¤`,]^
;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õ p ��g
�
�
(m 3.1 047 .95522 t=2.1 46
p=.034*¨(m 2.6974 1 .01 701
� 2.9628 .98566
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 62>� � �]^ ' �? �,� Ó��,� �Ý�,� £% � å*
162 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ-145>��?�,�Ó��,��Ý�,�£%� å*(��)
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í = K: ¥V �vs §��z vò8v �$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ-163>_ sB
s w$. qro: 24.6%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 2.89: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å
�^t J?_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �| þ�v� �t = K�ú(3.10)
c ²�v� �t = K�ú(2.72)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) . ~� ����
� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��,]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �| ����� �p
t =K�ú(3.06)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.61)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c
�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
qö�Ï¥ 4.5% 28.4% 32.8% 20.9% 1 3.4% 1 00% 3.1 0
t=2.072p=.040*
çÏ¥ 9.3% 25.9% 50.0% 1 3.0% 1 .9% 1 00% 2.72
�
�
(m 4.7% 20.9% 47.7% 1 7.4% 9.3% 1 00% 3.06t=2.308p=.023*
¨(m 1 3.2% 39.5% 26.3% 1 5.8% 5.3% 1 00% 2.61
� 7.1% 26.2% 42.1% 1 6.7% 7.9% 1 00% 2.89
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 63>� ‘êë � �& �? �¥ñ Ó��� ¥*Û¥ ôP.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 163
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 46>� �? �¥ñ Ó�� ¥*Û(qö ) <�Ê Ⅲ-147>� �?�¥ñ Ó�� ¥*Û(��)
‘®Í = K: 7é¨vs H� ¨ ( ��V ô z vò8v �$.’_ `� qrM�c <E Ⅲ
-164>_ sBs w$. qro: 35.7%c ;D , å zH� �`]a , bn 3.09: æ �� �`
$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��,]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{
$. �| ����� �p t =K�ú(3.22)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.82)�$ ¤`
,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 3.5% 1 7.6% 41 .2% 28.2% 9.4% 1 00% 3.22 t=2.097
p=.038*¨(m 7.7% 38.5% 20.5% 30.8% 2.6% 1 00% 2.82
� 4.8% 23.8% 35.7% 28.6% 7.1% 1 00% 3.09
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 64>� ‘êë � �& �Ý�¥ñ £% � ¸ �? ¼ � ¥*Û¥ ôP.’
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 48>� �?¼ ¥*Û(��)
164│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 49>� � �]^ ' �ä�å*(qö ) <�Ê Ⅲ-150>� ��]^ ' �ä�å*(��)
(2) �C�m � ���g-��, �; � , �¦, ? { ]-��
= K>L � ��Á9-ô �, Á, = , >: , /å (-xò_ ¨�� t bn 3.52: æ �� �
`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{
$. �| ����� �p t =K�ú(3.65)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(3.25)�$ ¤`
,]^ ;D ,]^ b c�`$(p<.05) . ~� & � _ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$.
�| c 400� ;�: Î�v wt = K�ú(3.83)v c 400� v¤: Î�v wt = K
�ú(3.43)� c 300� ;�: Î�v wt = K�ú(3.33)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c
�`$(p<.05) .
N=1 28
cs  ٠�|õp ��g
qö�Ï¥ 3.71 32 .91959 t=2.405
p=.018*çÏ¥ 3.3333 .79503
�
�
(m 3.6512 .81555 t=2.365
p=.020*¨(m 3.2564 .96567
ZÎ
300ÛýÛ 3.3333 .90453
F=3.724
p=.027*400ÛýÛ 3.8378 .76425
400ۥ� 3.4375 .90715
� 3.5205 .88467
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 65>� � �]^ ' �ä�-¼ ,� ä� � ,� ]�,� × , ¸-å*
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 165
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 51 >� � � ]^ ' �ä�å*(ZÎ )
� �g�^ �� �| $� O$.
‘®Í = K_� t = K: ��Á9� ����_ � xò�� w$.’_ `� qrM�c
<E Ⅲ-166>_ sBs w$. qro: 33%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.14: æ ��
�`$. ¿å�^t J?_ j¯ ��,]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �| þ�v� �t =
K�ú(3.32)v ²�v� �t = K�ú(2.94)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
~� ����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �| �
���� �p t =K�ú(3.28)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.90)�$ ¤`,]^ ;
D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
qö�Ï¥ 4.4% 1 6.2% 36.8% 27.9% 1 4.7% 1 00% 3.32 t=2.1 88
p=.031*çÏ¥ 1 .9% 29.6% 44.4% 20.4% 3.7% 1 00% 2.94
�
�
(m 1 .2% 1 7.4% 44.2% 26.7% 1 0.5% 1 00% 3.28 t=2.063
p=.041*¨(m 7.7% 28.2% 38.5% 1 7.9% 7.7% 1 00% 2.90
� 3.1% 22.0% 41 .7% 23.6% 9.4% 1 00% 3.1 4
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 66>� ‘êë � �; % < � �& �ä�+ ��� ; � å*J$ WP.’
166│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 52>� � �& �ä� å*(qö) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 53>� � �& �ä� å*(��)
‘����z ®Í = K>L I¥_ ;D , å ð� ; ¶$� J ��$.’_ `� qrM�c
<E Ⅲ-167>_ sBs w$. qro: 67%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.93: æ ��
�`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t =K�ú(4.07)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú
(3.62)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) . ~� c 400� ;�: Î�v wt
=K�ú(4.30)v c 400� v¤: Î�v wt =K�ú(3.88)� c 300� ;�: Î�
v wt = K�ú(3.69)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.05) .
N=128
cs
�;
�à�
hP
�à�
hP
#�
¥P �àP
lê
�àP �  ٠��g
�
�
(m 0.0% 3.5% 24.4% 33.7% 38.4% 1 00% 4.07 t=2.502
p=.014*¨(m 5.1% 5.1% 35.9% 30.8% 23.1% 1 00% 3.62
ZÎ
300ÛýÛ 2.2% 6.7% 31 .1% 40.0% 20.0% 1 00% 3.69
F=4.431
p=.014*400ÛýÛ 0.0% 0.0% 21 .6% 27.0% 51 .4% 1 00% 4.30
400ۥ� 2.5% 5.0% 27.5% 32.5% 32.5% 1 00% 3.88
� 1 .6% 3.9% 27.6% 33.9% 33.1% 1 00% 3.93
*� p� <� .05� � **� p� <� .01 � � ***� p� <� .001
<� Ⅲ -1 67>� ‘� �� êë � �]^ ��; �� � , �ã+ ý�P$ ���P.’
Ⅲ .� �vy z\� � �]ö �_Y su | 167
<�Ê Ⅲ -1 54>� � � ]^ & �� � �ã(��) <�Ê Ⅲ -1 55>� � � ]^ & ��� �ã(ZÎ )
5) �C DE x$
�È , =K: ���� è& @ a: bn æ �t 3.03^ [G, zH� �`$. ¿å�^t
����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. ����� �
p t = K�ú(3.24)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.67)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b
c�`$. ‘é, ·å, oê ëì’: bn æ �t 3.27^ sB{$. �g�^ �| ‘®Í =K_t
����� � � wt V ô v � � w$.’: bn æ �c 2.84, ‘®Í = K_t �����
� cÏ'�t � v w$.’c 2.89^ ¤`, ]^ �z æ �� �`$. � ����� � �
wt é, ·å, oêv ì��= ·É� �²Þ$. ‘=K>L � >L oê e ) ’: bn æ �t
3.00: æ �� �`$. ����� �p t = K�ú(3.23)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú
(2.61)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.001) . �g�^ �| ‘®Í = K_� t =K�
ú, �, §§p ¨, p ? (v ���� xy_ ¨�� � ^ Ý �� � �$.’c 3.16: æ ��
�`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t =K�ú(3.40)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú
(2.77)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$. ‘®Í =K_� t ���� p ¨ㆍ �â v � ^
Ý �� ��$.’_ 2.99: ¤`, ]^ �z æ �� �`$. �Jz `þ , ÿ���c � e )
� wÉ� �²Þ$.
ÉÈ , = K: ����, K� ��: bn æ �t 2.79^ ¤`, ]^ �� sB{$. ¿å�
^t ����� �p t = K�ú(3.00)v ����� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.44)�$ ¤`,
]^ ;D, ]^ b c�`$. ‘���� Á’t 2.73: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t �����
�p t = K�ú(2.98)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.31)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^
b c�`$. ‘���� ’z 2.85: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t = K�ú
(3.04)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.55)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$. ‘��
�� ©T’t 2.85: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t =K�ú(2.98)v ����
� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.31)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$.
168│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
ÊÈ , = K: è& @a_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.33]^ sB{$. ¿å�^t � �p�_
`� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �| 16C v¤ � �� =K�ú
(3.5433)v 15C v� � �� = K�ú(3.25)� 5C v� � �� =K�ú(3.21)�$ ¤`, ]
^ ;D, ]^ b c�`$. �/ ðK�^ �| ‘éÍ, è& @a’: bn æ �t 3.5455^ s
B{$. ‘>L oê ¤’_t 3.05: æ �� �`$. nh 16C v¤ � �� = K�ú(3.44)v
15C v� � �� = K�ú(2.93)A 5C v� � �� = K�ú(2.82)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]
^ b c�`$. ‘= K>L �� �M ’: bn æ �t 3.84^ f , �� sB{$. ‘`þ, �
�’t bn 3.45: æ �� �`$.
ÔÈ , = K: ���� åí¯ xò_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.23]^ sB{$. ¿å�^t
����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �| ����
� �p t = K�ú(3.37)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.96)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]
^ b c�`$(p<.05) . �/ ðK�^ �| ‘= K>L � ¥V �, §��, 7é¨, H� ¨ xò’
: bn æ �c 2.96]^ ��: zH� �`$. �|_ ‘= K>L � ��Á9-ô �, Á,= ,
>: , /å (-xò’: bn æ �c 3.52^ �� v¤: zH� �`$. �g�^ �| ‘���
�z ®Í = K>L I¥_ ;D ,å ð� ; ¶$� J ��$.’c 3.93: �z æ �� �`$.
=K>L: & ® d� ðK_� ����� �p = ·t �ú�$ �p t �úv, îÍ� µ�
� ���/ ;D , ]^ b c�t &v �`$. ����_ `� ¨\ � �\ v¯t �¨,
zHc ð� ; ¶ �]^ �å$. vt iÞ� ����� & ÷ �|� ~� ;D , zH
c ¤] � wÉ� V >�Þ$.
Ⅳ. $� % �&
1. $�
2. �&
Ⅳ .� ú� � Ϋ | 1 71
Ⅳ. $� % �&
1. $�
ê ��t 2012C �\ ���� ��: ��) �� � /� p�: ��) =E� @a�
�, ��� ��) � =Z, ]^ ëå�p /� ��u$. �D X ��) =Et �J ðK_
� å) � ���� ðK� �"�² ª�� �) �`�, �ðK� =K>LðK_� t p�
: |�T>� W¨, �g]^ ª�� @I�`$. vt �/ �_� DÅ� �V �� ��
�� �� = >?: ��) � ÛÛ^ �� � � w� = �p /ûv$. îÍ� 1�CHc
�ì jÉ @IX H�^ ��) � T>�² �� �`$.
T>`¤z 2012C �\ ���� �� 10@ ^(�: 3, 4, 5, 6�C ¥âA �ö �:
> * ç> ¥â , îÍ� =K ö 10²¢: = K�úv$. T>M�� (R�| $É� O$.
1) �B
�J : ��) äæz bn 3.81^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| �C, >²Ð, & � è& _�
Á:; � �vc sB{$. �È , `â^ o�C]^ ��p�/ ;D,å zH� �`$. 3�C
�J(3.76)v c� �t]a $É]^ 4�C(3.63), 5�C(3.59) , 6�C(3.57): �]^ sB{$
(p<.001). ÉÈ , >� �z �J(3.65)v >� �= ·z �J(3.54)�$ ;D,]^ qr
�`$(p<.01). ÊÈ , &�è&(¤: 3.81, [: 3.63, �: 3.37)v ���/ ;D,å zH� �`$
(p<.01) .
�J ��) = Et op �qr, ���� r�) , ©: ) , op T¹� , op EY� IE� ,
Ý y� >L) ( 6@^ �) X$. ²^ c= �/ ðK_ `� M�� (R�| $É� O$.
�È , op �qr: bnæ �t 3.69^ [��$ �z D H^ sB{$. >²ÐA & �
è& ¿å_� Á: ; � �vc sB{$. >� �t �J (3.73)� & � è& (¤ : 3.92, [ :
3.92, � : 3.42)v ���/ op �qrv �z �]^ sB{$. � �g�^t ‘st ���
� �u_ F qv w$.’_ `� bn 3.63: æ �� �`tñ , ²�J v ß�J �$, o�C½
�/ �� sB{$. î³s ‘���� xyz �{�| = }�$ ~ ��� � w$� J ��
$.’_ `�� t bn 4.16: �z æ �� �² �J v ;�_ `� o�r� 1� uÉ�
¢ � w$. �|_ ½�, å o�r� éz ‘st ��v�= o�v w$.’_ bn æ �c b
n 3.64å �� ���$| ���� xy_ `� o�rz �® �z �� ¢ � w$. � �
���v �J : o�r� �²�u�, v�z ½�, å o�r]^ ë�] cq) � �
²Þ$.
1 72 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
ÉÈ , ���� r�) : bnæ �t 3.71^ [��$ �z DH^ sB{$. �C, )� , & �
è& ¿å_� Á:; � �vc sB{$. �C�^t 3�C �J (3.93)v c� �t�, ²�J
(3.84)v ß�J (3.60)_ f � ���� r�) v �t]a , & �è& (¤ : 3.95, [ : 3.71, � :
3.34)v ���/ �t$. `Ð�: �g_� o�C½�/ , ²�J ½�/ , & � è& v ���/
¤`, ]^ �z æ �� �`$. nh ‘���� xy� �� s: J xv �� ��$.’_ `�
� t qr�J : 63.8%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 3.90: �z æ �� �`$. ~�
‘st ���� xy_ `� =}�$ ~ ¢� £$.’_H 3.87: �z æ �� �`$. î³s
‘st >� � ���� xy_ `� vup � �v �t ¡v$.’_ `�� t bn 3.38: �
z æ �� �`� ¿å � �vH sBs= ·t$. � ���� xyv �J � �¸ � ��,
�J z ����_ `� ~ ¢� £� & ÷ �� £=� Y� z �J ����_ `� vup
� �v sw D Ht �# ¯t a]^ �� X$.
ÊÈ , ©:) : bn æ �t 3.69^ [��$ �z D H^ sB{$. �C� & � è& ¿å_
� Á:; � �vc sB{$. �C�^t 3�C �J (3.93)v c� �t�, & � è& (¤ : 4.07,
[: 3.77, �: 3.67)v ���/ �� sB{$. g+�^ �| ‘st F ; wt J � � �v
�$.’_ bn 4.01: �z æ �� �`$. nh 3�C �J (4.25)v �z æ �� �`$. ‘st
©: , v¯t ° ±� � � c �$.’_ `�� t ¤`, ]^ f , �z 3.41: æ �� �`
$. ‘ª ^« �� %®t �v �$.’_ `�� t bn 4.19: �z æ �� �`$. � �J z
©: , å xyz ���=� �¿_� îy »�� �t ½z �= ·$t �� . � w$.
ÔÈ , op T¹�: bn æ �t 3.55^ sB{$. �C� & � è& ¿å_� Á:; � �v
c sB{$. o�C(3�C : 3.70, 4�C : 3.59, 5�C : 3.54, 6�C : 3.42)]^ ��p�/ & �
è&(¤ : 3.78, [ : 3.55, �: 3.35)v ���/ op T¹�v �t$. �g�^t nh ‘st
Ò� �v �t ¡v$.’_ `�� �C, )� , >²Ð, & � è& _� db Á:; � �vc
sB{$. o�C]^ ��p�/ , & � è& v ���/ , ²�J � >� �z �J v Ò�
� �$� qr�`$.
$^È , op EY�� IE�: bn æ �t 3.69^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| �C, >²
Ð, & � è& _� Á:; � �vc sB{$. �C(3: 3.42, 4: 3.26, 5 : 3.24, 6: 3.19)v ��
p�/ , & � è& (¤ : 4.03, [ : 3.65, �: 3.21)v ���/ ;D, å zH� �`$. >�
�z �J (3.30)v >� �= ·z �J (3.17)�$ ;D ,]^ qr�`$.
²^È , Ý y� >L) : bn æ �t 3.79^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| �C� > ²Ð_
j¯ Á:; � �vc wu$. 3�C(3.90)v c� ;D , å zH� �`]a , >� �t �
J(3.81)v >� �= ·t �J (3.70)_ f � ;D , å zH� �`$.
v¤: M�_� �J z op �qr, ���� r�) , ©: ) , op T¹�, op EY�
IE�, Ý y� >L) ( 6 c= : ��) = E_ `� o�C½�/ , >� �� s & � è
& v ���/ �z æ �� �`$. vt �J ‘���� �� = >?’v � � vp ��_
Ⅳ .� ú� � Ϋ | 1 73
���� â÷ : ��c ì�h sBs= ·tp � �]^ �å$.
2) ��
� ¿�_ `� $^ c= ðK�^ M�� DÍ�| $É� O$.
�È , �: ���� è& @a ðK_� ¥â bn æ�t 4.14^ f , ;D ,]^ sB{
$. ¿å�^ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vt Iã= ·t$. �/ ðK� æ �� �| ‘é, ㆍ å
, oê ëì’z 4.23: �z æ �� �`� � ¥§(4.41)v ��� ¥§(3.97)�$ ¤`,
]^ ;D , ]^ qr�`$. �g [_ ‘®Í �t ����� & ÷ � � wt p Lc
�z ¡v$.’_� qro: 87.7%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , bn 4.34: �z æ �� �²
���� �� = >?v ;D, b c� �t �� ¢ � w$. $É]^ ‘p ¨ � >L oê
e ) ’H bn 4.05: �z æ �� �`$, vt �) �: xI� ¨�c e )uÉ� �
²Þ$. ‘�: `þ , ÿ��� e ) ’: bn æ �t 4.05^ sB{$. = K>Lc ���� �
� = >?� ¢� w]a , ����D �� §Á��, �c = K>L: �>_ ,?,]^
¾²�t �]^ sB{$.
ÉÈ , � �) : ����, K� ��: ¥â bn æ �t 4.33]^ �� sB{$. ¿
å�^ �| ��,]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$. �/ ðK� æ �� �| ‘����
Á’_ ¨�� t bn 4.36: �z æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t � ¥§(4.47)v ��� ¥
§(4.20)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$. �g�^ �| ����: ¥V * §�, îÍ
� ����v J x�� w$� qr�`$. ‘���� ’: bn æ �H 4.50]^ �� s
B{$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$. �g�^ �| $�� �
���í^îï� x) �_ `� ��_ �z æ �� �u�, nh ‘®Í �t Ë�s
�p� �| ����� �� � w$.’_ qro: 93.9%c ;D ,å zH� �`]a , b
n 4.48: �z æ �� �² ���� ��c ����: p L � §_ p ²�� wÉ�
�`$. ‘���� ©W’: bn æ �t bn 4.26]^ sB{$. ¿å�^ �| ��, ]^ Á
:; � �vt Iã= ·t$.
ÊÈ , �: ¥�, � ¤: bn æ �t 3.96]^ sB{$. ¿å�^ ��, ]^ Á
:; � �vt sBs= ·t$. �/ ðK� æ �� �| ‘� �� «ð ��: ¿�’: b
n æ �t 3.78^ sB{�, ¿å�^t ��, ]^ Á:; � �vt Iã= ·t$. �g�
^ �| ‘®Í �t $k �_ f � �� �D «ð 57v ��� X$.’_ bn 4.38
: �z æ �� �å �| ‘®Í �: �� �D «ðz ��� ��st & ®c �$.’
_ bn 3.06: æ �� �² �D z ���u=� ���D «ð ��: ½¨) z
$Î }�= t �]^ sB{$. ‘� �D : ¿�’: bn æ �t 4.07^ �z æ �� �
`$. ¿å�^t ¥§_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. � ¥§(4.27)v ��
1 74│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
� ¥§(3.76)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]^ b c�`$. �g�^ �| ‘®Í � �D z $
k �_ f � ����v f [v �z ¡v$.’_ qro: 95.4%c ;D, å zH� �
`]a , bn 4.51: $Î �z æ �� �`$. ‘� «ð +E [æ >? ¿�’: bn æ �t
3.86: æ�� �`$. ¿å�^ �| � ¥§(3.95)v ��� ¥§(3.64)�$ ¤`,]^ ;
D,]^ b c�`$. �g�^ �| ‘®Í �t ����� [\ ]^ «ðX$.’_ `�
qro: 87.7%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.14: �z æ�� �`$. ~� ‘®Í �
t �����u â÷ xyv �z ¡v$.’_ 95.4%c ;D, å zH� �`]a , bn 4.48:
æ �� �`$. ‘� �� �M ��’t 4.03: �z æ �� �`$. ‘>: ¥�) ¤’t
4.08: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t & �_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:;� �vc sB{$. 20C v
�(4.29)c c� ;D, ]^ qr�`]a , $É]^ 10C v�(4.20): �]^ sB{$. �g�
^ �| ‘®Í � > z $�� �7� >ò�$.’c 4.17: �z æ �� �`$.
ÔÈ , `þ, �� ��: bn æ �t 3.78^ sB{$. �/ ðK�^ �| ‘�_ `� `
þ v;= @a’z 3.82: bn æ �� �`$. �g�^ �| ‘����]^ ®Í �_
`� ª ^« å � \ � � w� �v$.’c 4.44: �z æ �� �`�, ‘®Í �^ ¥�
µ�t ¤õ >!c w$.’_ 4.10: æ �� �² �: v; = @a_ ��c wÉ� �²�
u$. ‘�_ `� ¤/ �D p¨: ¨\� = ’z 3.95: æ �� �`$. �g�^ �|
‘¤� p ¨ v ®Í �� ° ±�$.’_ 4.25: �z æ �� �`$. � ¤/ �D p ¨
: = = � �� w� . � w$.
$^È , = K>L: ���� åí¯ xò: bn æ �t 4.11^ sB{$. ‘= K p� V ô
xò’z 4.13: æ �� �`�, ‘=K ��: K>) � ¥�� �ð� ����W%©T’t 4.10
: æ �� �`$.
v¤: M�_� >A ç> z �: ���� è& _ `� �® ;D , zHA p
`r� �²�u$. � ¥§oc ��� ¥§o�$ ;D, ]^ b c�² p `#: �v�
�²�u=� ¥�,]^ V W�t � �¯t æ � jp �� ( cV , å è& : ¿�� �v
b c� �]^ �å$.
3) �C DE
=K: ¿�_ `� ÿ c= ðK�^ M�� DÍ�| $É� O$.
�È , =K: ���� è& @ a: bn æ �t 3.03^ [G, zH� �`$. ¿å�^t
����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. ����� �
p t = K�ú(3.24)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.67)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^ b
c�`$. ‘é, ·å, oê ëì’: bn æ �t 3.27^ sB{$. �g�^ �| ‘®Í =K_t
����� � � wt V ô v � � w$.’: bn æ �c 2.84, ‘®Í = K_t �����
Ⅳ .� ú� � Ϋ | 1 75
� cÏ'�t � v w$.’c 2.89^ ¤`, ]^ �z æ �� �`$. � ����� � �
wt é, ·å, oêv ì��= ·É� �²Þ$. ‘=K>L � >L oê e ) ’: bn æ �t
3.00: æ �� �`$. ����� �p t = K�ú(3.23)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú
(2.61)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$(p<.001) . �g�^ �| ‘®Í = K_� t =K�
ú, �, §§p ¨, p ? (v ���� xy_ ¨�� � ^ Ý �� � �$.’c 3.16: æ ��
�`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t =K�ú(3.40)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú
(2.77)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]^ b c�`$ �g�^ �| ‘®Í = K_� t ���� p ¨
ㆍ �â v � ^ Ý �� ��$.’_ 2.99: ¤`, ]^ �z æ �� �`$. �Jz `þ , ÿ�
��c � e )� wÉ� �²Þ$.
ÉÈ , = K: ����, K� ��: bn æ �t 2.79^ ¤`, ]^ �� sB{$. ¿å�
^t ����� �p t = K�ú(3.00)v ����� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.44)�$ ¤`,
]^ ;D, ]^ b c�`$. ‘���� Á’t 2.73: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t �����
�p t = K�ú(2.98)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.31)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D ,]^
b c�`$. ‘���� ’z 2.85: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t = K�ú
(3.04)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.55)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$. ‘��
�� ©T’t 2.85: æ �� �`$. ¿å�^t ����� �p t =K�ú(2.98)v ����
� �p = ·t =K�ú(2.31)�$ ¤`,]^ ;D , ]^ b c�`$.
ÊÈ , = K: è& @a_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.33]^ sB{$. ¿å�^t � �p�_
`� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á:; � �vc sB{$. �| 16C v¤ � �� =K�ú
(3.54)v 15C v� � �� =K�ú(3.25)� 5C v� � �� =K�ú(3.21)�$ ¤`,]^
;D , ]^ b c�`$. �/ ðK�^ �| ‘éÍ, è& @a’: bn æ �t 3.54^ sB{
$. ‘>L oê ¤’_t 3.05: æ �� �`$. nh 16C v¤ � �� = K�ú(3.44)v 15C
v� � �� =K�ú(2.93)� 5C v� � �� = K�ú(2.82)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D , ]^ b
c�`$. ‘= K>L �� �M ’: bn æ �t 3.84^ f , �� sB{$. ‘`þ, ��’ t
bn 3.45: æ �� �`$.
ÔÈ , =K: ���� åí¯ xò_ ¨� ¥â æ �t bn 3.23^ sB{$. ¿å�^t
����� �p t= _ `� ²Ð_ j¯ ��, ]^ Á: ; � �vc sB{$. �| ����
� �p t = K�ú(3.37)v ����� �p = ·t = K�ú(2.96)�$ ¤`, ]^ ;D, ]
^ b c�`$(p<.05) . �/ ðK�^ �| ‘= K>L � ¥V �, §��, 7é¨, H� ¨ xò’
: bn æ �c 2.96^ ��: zH� �`$. �|_ ‘=K>L � ��Á9-ô �, Á, = , >
: , / å (-xò’: bn æ �c 3.52^ �� v¤: zH� �`$. �g�^ �| ‘����
z ®Í = K>L I¥_ ;D ,å ð� ; ¶$� J ��$.’c 3.93: �z æ �� �`$.
v¤: M�_� =K �ú z f , [G, zH� �`$. ���� �� = >?_ `
1 76│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
� ì�h å=�= Ü� æ H w� �]^ �va �J cV ,å Z�vs ¾²: & ÷ v Ð
K�p ��]^ �å$.
2. �&
ê ���D � M�� �� � c= �O� �| $É� O$.
�È , ô �T>A |�T>� ��� '(c w$. ô �T>t W¨ �g]^ �)� w
p ��_ W¨, å f � � � wt �, oó: �æ � c= � w$. î³s W¨ �g]
^ ��Ä � �t �� � ¢��t ñt ��� c= � w$. �|_ oÁ�� o�: J �
� �G� �� �t |�T>_� t ��oc :H�� s ;� J ��= � �� � I
ã� ²= c �$. nh ����z �® �- � ��� �� � wt �v�� ~� î� cq
) v �$. �l` 2011C ���� �� ��) ��_� t |�T>� �� �J : O�
J xv ¿k$t =K�ú: �Ov wu$. �v : `�_ Òô v �® �ttñ, ����
§� (� Þf �|� `�: � òv ����� ¨�X �]^ �= |� o�Û6� Òô v
>¯°$t �v$. v�z ����v :H� +, z �#u]s Ð�, ]^ �� X ��
¯� . � w$. vy � z W¨ T>_� Iã�p � $. î³�^ ê ��: W¨
�g� T>H�^ xò� �/�_� t |�T>H ��� '(c w$.
ÉÈ , T> ���� � '(c w$. T>t �g� ��t �_� Ð� � V �t �D�=
�® ¥�, å = � p �v '(�$. T>� �t ¤Z_ j¯ î M�: �vc �p � �
v$. �l` ^(� o�C� `¤]^ T>� � � t �v v �g: �ò� v��= Ü
�� D ë� T>� �p �� & ®H w$. î� �t T>� �|� �v : ��_ `rH
� ��, Æ�H � �u �$. ¬� �# ¯ �/�_� Å� oó� �Í�� �� � � w
H/ ��� ��57 : Æ�H '(�$. j¯� T>� Dë�� �� î M�� �� � �
wt ���� ��� '(c w$.
ÊÈ , T> V p � � a��u �$. í^îï� -���, î ��� �p /�� t T>:
V p c �® [(�$. �� � í^îïv v; V Wutñ >¥ T>� �� s `¤_�
� å¤vs ð� I� � wt xyv �sp H ¥_ >H T>� �t �z D ë� ���
�� � � �� �t (åv X$. j¯� T>: V p t Dë�� =�= t �v M�J�$.
�p^A �p Ó^ �t �p�: ��� . �H w=� �^t [(� xy� �� s� [
�æe: T>H � � w� �v$. ¥èæ v ] � wt V p _ T>� �t �z í^îï:
��) � ¢��tñ �® [(�$. î³�^ T> V p H �® �[�� MD�u �$.
ÔÈ , �È$ nY wt í^îïv w]�^ î�: ��� [D � � wt oâ H��
@I�² >ò� '(c w$. ê ��_� @I� �gz d� ���� ��c §�]^ >
ò� � wH/ @IX �v�^ $Î 2¤, ½ �H w�, �� �_� t :; c R� �g
Ⅳ .� ú� � Ϋ | 1 77
v �û] �H w$. ~� �� �c m [,]^ �t í^îï_ ¨�X ��� �â, ]^
b c��p �� �gH w� �v$. j¯� �/� v o� v 2�� +, � �ò� �
�� oâ @I� b c�g� 2c^ >ò� '(c w$.
$^È , ¥� ¥!�J , >A ç> � ��) b c_ �ûV Ê �å= %� � �å=� �
���u �$. ���� ��t Î\d �vp ��_ �J vs > * ç> v ¥�vs
¥!� & ® � >�: qrv ¥â bn_ ;#t ðv W= ·$. j¯� ��� �� �t
ñ � V Ê � w$. j¯� ��) � �� � �t v³� �J vs > * ç>� �¡� �
Í�= ì�h ��� '(c w$.
²^È , ���� ��� aI�tñ w� � ¢ë� p Þ� È��u �$. ���� ��
= >?z ����� �p �� Î\d ^(�A = K>L� = �� �J , �, =
K�ú_� ����è& � @a�� ����, K�� £³�t ñ_ +, v w$. �=� ê
�� `¤ ���� ��t $k p ¨_� H [@ = � �t �^ aIX 4v wÉ� I
ã�`$. j¯� � � ���� = v '(� �� ¤a� '(c w$.
½mÈ , = K ���� å, ·é, o � xò�t ñ w�� â�,å = � ¨Íc '(�
$. ‘���� �� = >?’� �p ^ = K ����c: xy� ����, >A ����
ç>, �Ï � > * ç>: = , �� = ( ‘>L, oê’: �� �� �²u �$. �
³ Wz \dv=� ����¨� é�, -oA ¨Í � �� = K: ����è& @a:
�p ^ ] � wH/ = 5o#�â ~t = K>L ����p ¨�: Ý �H ç��� cV , v
� =Z, å ����x) �� ÁH� '(c w$.
²nÈ , ���� �� v � ^: ���� í^îï� ���� è& � §Á��
=� � wt �� x) � V Ê '(c w$. 4C� ���� ��� «ð� > z v³
� =p Lc �® '(�a �z HØ� �� X$� �O�$. îÍ � v³� =� ��
��®c Ë,a , v = >?v V ÛÑ� ] � w� �v$.
'(�)
º$�� I�1 81
'(�)
ç&Wㆍ �Î . (2008). 『 �"��#ó í^îïv op�,v: �G�y * ¶>L, �y_ ;#t ð』 ,
D� ·�y����, 24(3), 189-217.
��â��Ð. (2010). 2011C �(?���: ûü ËÍt �� �@� `�ú�. ��â¨�Ð.
� ��F�. (2009). 2009 �,v ©: ArtsTREE «ð���. � ��F�.
� ����= ¨�-� ��F�. (2009). 2009 � V ���� YZT> ��. � ��F�.
���·hz ·h;ð(2010). 『 þ�: ���� í^îï_ `� �� ��: ;�, ð�, sý�, ½ê� [
\]^』 , ����, 8(2), 1-19.
)z�, (2006). 「 Y` p^���: v�A ,ò」 . � : ��>.
µ&oㆍ �zZㆍ vZ�ㆍ 6ç:. (2007). 「 �,v·"ÎC �ybcÁH (K-CBCL)」 . � : w�lôy .
µ��. (2008). 『 ���� ¨� 7g * �H ��”』 , �ô å���ýä, 22, 5-37.
®� . (2008). 『 5�H� ���� = >?: b c= d³: ç>= d³� �â� d³_ `� f
��』 , ����, 6(2), 35-47.
�Y, íò½, ÆFð. (2008). 『 í5Û ���� Dg� �D �:』 , ��p^Te�L, 9(1),
871-883.
v�Þ. (2009). 『 � ����åc?』 , d�# ��, 2, 5-8
v� þ. (2010). ����� )�bc ��. ��������
øðㆍ �)Qㆍ D&z. (2008). "ÎC å���xy ðK� ��) ÁH @I ��. ��"ÎC��¨� .
�p-. (2010). 『 %&� �ô_ p^� ����: :;A Dâ) 』 , Éj§�, 11, 25-40.
�p- þ. (2011). 2011��� ��� = >? �bc��. ��������
D�) þ. (2013). ��]^ �t å). � : ��>.
D�) þ. (2010). 5�H� ��� ���� = >? ��) �� ��. � ��F�
D�) þ. (2011). �,v ©:�� 5�H� ��� = >? ��) �� ��. � ��F�
h�sㆍ ç�Y. (2007). 『 �"��#óc MDcD �,v: op�qr ¤_ ;#t ð』 , #v#ó��,
11(2), 71-87.
z�;. (2010). 『 ðF� /� ���� �" : '()� ,ò 5Æ』 , �ô å���ýä, 26,
241-273.
������ �� . (2006). ���� Dg�. ��������
������ �� . (2008). =K>L�� ����� V->? ðbc. �������� .
������ �� . (2012). ����, ©T, _¶=^ �V�� ���$. ��������
Achenbach. T. M. (1991). Manual for the Child Behavior Checklist/4-18 and 1991 Profile. Burlington.
VT: University of Vermont.
Achenbach. T. M.. & Edelbrock. C. (1983). Manual for the Child Behavior Checklist and Revised Child
Behavior Profiles. Burlington. VT: University of Vermont.
182 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
Chan, A. (2010). Building Partnerships through Community Engagement Project[Abstract] . Proceedings of
UNESCO the 2nd World Conference on Arts Education, Republic of Korea, 97-98.
Consortium of National Arts Education Associations. (1994) . National Standarts for Arts Education:
What every young american should know and be acble to do in the arts. VA: Music
Educators National Conference.
Day, M . & Hurwitz, A . (2012) . Children and their art: art education for elementary and middle
schools. CA: Wadsworth cengage learning .
Gardner, H. (1985) . Frames of mind: The theory of multiple intelligences. NY : Basic books
Gardner, H . (1990) . Art education and human development. CA: Getty Publications
Eisner, E. W. & Day, M. D .(Eds.) (2004). Handbook of Research and Policy in Art Education: CA:
Routledge.
Evans J. & Skelton, T . (2001) . How to teach art to children. CA: Evan-Moor.
Freedman, K (2003) . Teaching visual culture: curriculum , asthetics and the social life. National art
Education Association.
Gelineau, P. (2012) . Integraing the arts across the elementary school curriculum . CA: Wadsworth
cengage learning.
Prince, E. S. (2008) . Art is fundamental: teaching the elements and principles of art in elementary
school. Chicago: Zephyr Press.
Steiner, R. (2006a) . 「 IHÏí �A î D� 」 . hZ& K. � : ÏzËÍ
Steiner, R. (2006b) . 「 ×�í �Bv¶: å= � ��#ó」 . DD� , D²� K, � : �= >
Steiner, R. (2009) . 「 IHÏí 57N, �:」 . hZ& K. � : ÏzËÍ
Sylwester, R . (1998) . Art for the Brain. Educational Leadership , 56(3) , 31-35.
http: //artsedge.kennedy-center.org/about.aspx(2012. 10. 10)
*+: O� P�
�� | 1 85
*+: O� P�
ID
�vy z\� � �\� ]� ¼ �~] (\� [�)
Æ���#�? ��â¨�ÐA �������� v ûü «ð�� wt ��
�� �� �J � `¤]^ ô �T>� ��� "# $.
○○○Ù : :ãz ��7 _ :� ¤» �� �Q �# $.
☞gø�� : D�) (& å`� �) / @I� ¥�� : ☎ 02-6209-5951
� I�� #
※� ,ê �«�< � � � � �?J�ñ (� � � � � ); � ð ��|.
1 .� ñ< (� � � � ) � \� ¥P.� � � ※� ·¸\� 4/5/6\� [�
2.� ñ< _____ì� � _____í� L
3.� ñ< Àe 1�æ \� ¥ñ _� G _____ì� ½� � W�ñ ½$ WP.�
� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � _____í� ½� � �P.
� � 3-1 .� (3¶ ��; % ì+ ÜR� ]�Û }î� ��|)
※� ½ï�ñ ½$ W< � ; Fn � ��|.
� � � _____ì� 0�sø(A,Á ,� �� ¸)� � � � � � � � �
� � � _____í� ? �sø(ý�,� w, £ Ó )
� � � _____ð� ýwð sø(Û ñOò¥ó ,� ]�,� �)� � � � � � �
� � � _____ô� ���Õ(K*,� {V £¸)� �
� � � _____õ� Ó��sø(�> ,� K*,� ��ö ,� K[�)� � � � � � �
� � � _____⑥� �_(�ð ,� ̀ \ ¸)� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �
� � � _____⑦� Iª (� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � )
4.� êë ¤ � _____ì� �, õ _____í � #� _____ð� ®³� õ
186│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
※� �� '�; [� }î;< �$ ñù �¥ �¾� �î¥ W< �¥ ,úOP.� �
& �ä¥ñ ��; µ� ûqJ+ □; �? � ��|.
� “ ����” � � ?
(� � , � ��. ��), ��(���� � ), ��, ��.
������ �, �� ! "#$ ���� %&' *�� ".
No. � � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
,OP
1 ñ< �� sø; � Ì¥ WP.
2 � � åÖ� �XJ©
�?#P � �,' ` WP$ ���P.
3 ñ< ñ;+ �ð� _Î; ¤ ó+ � �P.
4 ñ< ñ;+ �ð� _ÎG × � À Ü+ P�P.�
5 ' ÌѾ�< Î [� / ` W< �¥ �P.
6 ñ< ñ;+ ½�/ :® òP.
7 ñ< K�¥�� �¥ WP.
No. � � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
,OP
8 ñ< �� åÖ+ �� ÍÖ+ � ��P.
9 ñ;+ �� åÖ� ó|JP.
1 0 � � åÖ+ �� ñ& �å¥ (�Ä �P.
1 1 ñ< ]�û_ �� åÖ; [� ¥øIG ò¥ J< õ¥P.
1 2 ñ< �� åÖ; [� �?#P � �$ ]P.
1 3 ñ< �� ��sø �? ㆍ Ó�+ #$ ]P.
1 4 ñ< ��; [� �÷ ¥ �P.
No. � � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
,OP
1 5 ñ< � ýW< ��û+ ò¥ �P.
1 6 ñ< þ �ç �+ � ��� �P.
1 7 ñ< þ �ç íÿ ¾� �Î G � úJ< Zê® òP.
1 8 ñ< Ð& �¥�< + û+ :® òP.
1 9 ñ< � ®� G #© L ®� ��û¥ ¡�ìP.
20 �cû¥ J� h< þ �ç ��+ J< �¥ (¢P.
21 þ�ç �+ �ê< �¥ �P.
�� | 1 87
No. � � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
,OP
22 ñ< ® ñ< b¥ W��£ º+ ` WP.
23 ñ< �é& £Ñ¥ñ ä�+ � ¥¤¥ ` WP.
24 ¦¨�§£ .0+ �� ?¨ ` WP.
25 ñ< ÁÁ ©ª®G :ë$ ]P.
26 ñ< ® ñ% �ëG � �ñ
K«®G �`$ ]+ :® WP.
27 ñ< �cñ à Î û_ � ¬çP.
28 ñ< + ò¥ J< õ¥P.
No. � � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
,OP
29 ñ< ' ��+ � ®J< õ ¥P.
30 '® �-< Is+ Pì ]�û¥ ,< �¥ ¯P.
31 �� åÖ+ �� ñ& Is¥ñ ��+ �Õ/ ` WP.
32 Pì �cû °;% ��J< �¥ (¢P.�
33 ñ< ��/ : �± Z+ ��P.
34 ñ< Ü�·¥ ?�I �; ³³� ��/ :® òP.
35 ñ< ' ��+ Î [� �ÕJ� ²/ :® òP.
No. � � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
,OP
36 ñ< �cû+ � ¥� �P.
37 ñ< �cû_ ]¥�+ ��P.
38 ñ< �cû+ � £µ|P.
39 ñ< �cû& ®+ � ûð|P.
40 ñ< Pì �c;+< �÷ ¥ �P.
41 ñ< �+ �³/ :® òP.
42 ñ< ' ��_ ´�£ �� �cû& & f+ µìP.
¼�~]; ºL � �ý% Í]OOP.� �
188│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
� � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
�à�
hP
�1.�êë \�< ��� ����+ ç�J<Æ å* ` W< £cñ �º® òP.
�2.� êë \�< ��� ����+ ç� / ` W< ?¼¥ �� õ¥P.
� 3 .� êë \�; < � �� + �«/ ` W< sû¥ WP.�
� 4.� êë \�< � �� + Z ù / ` W< I ^ ® ò� õ ¥ P.�
� 5.� êë \�< � �� sø � � � � �]G � å* �P.
� 6.� êë \�< � �� sø � � � � �]G þ� JI ® ÿP.
� 7.� êë \�< \�Fû¥ \�;% �� �� åÖ+ ò¥ �P.
� 8.� êë \�< � � ]^ & � � I �ㆍ �� µ » Ñ + � �P.
� 9.� � � ]^ < êë \�& �vy z\� ]ö + � �$ WP.
1 0.� êë \�< � � ]^ & � � �]; ò¥ ºL �P.
1 1 .� êë \�µ � � ]^ < � � �� � #G Óä�P.
ID
�vy z\� ��\� ]� ¼ �~] (\� �],� �])
Æ���#�? ��â ¨�ÐA �������� v ûü «ð�� wt ���
� �� �J � `¤]^ ô �T>� ��� "# $.
○○○Ù : :ãz ��7 _ :� ¤» �� �Q �# $.
☞gø�� : D�) (& å`� �) / @I� ¥�� : ☎ 02-6209-5951
� I�� #
※� ,ê �«�< � � � � �? J�ñ (� � � � � ); � ð ��|.
1 .� ñ& ñ¥< (� � � � � � � � )�
2.� ñ< ____ì� � ____í� L
3.� ñ< ��+ ____ì� (I< õ ¥P ____í � (I� h<P
4-1 .� (�])� ñ& �q ZÑ� (� � � � � � )� (� � � � � � ) � ��¥P.
4-2.� (���])� ñ& �] ZÑ� (� � � � � � )� (� � � � )� ��¥P.
5.� ñ& [\� �Ó� (� � � � � � � � � � � � � )¥P.
�� | 1 89
� � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
�à�
hP
1 2.� êë \�< ��sø �? ^ G ò¥ �P.
1 3.� êë \�< ��sø Ó�+ ò¥ �P.
1 4.� êë \�< ��� ¥ �å �ð WP.
1 5.� êë \�< Pü� ��� ����+ ç� �P.
1 6.� êë \� �]û� ��; [� �÷ _ ÌÑ¥ òP.
1 7.� êë \�< � �� & åY ; ò� ÁÑ + IS,P.
18.� êë \�< ©cñ �JIÛ J© ��� + ½+ ` WP.
1 9.� êë \�< þ �ç ��sø �? G ò¥ �P.
20.� êë \�< þ �ç �� Ó�+ ò¥ �P.
21 .� êë \�< þ�ç �� sø; [� �÷ ¥ ô$,� \� ç�;
djJ�$ ÁÑ�P.
� � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
�à�
hP
22.�êë \�< Pì \�; �� �æ � _� ç� íî¥ pØ P.
23.� êë \�& �æ � _� ç�� ÂóÄP.
24.� êë \�< ���, íÿ_ P + �æ ç� �è+ �çP.
25.� êë \�& � _� � Pì \�µ Ø� p¥® �P.
26.� êë \� � _� � Pì \�; �� ��� & �ó¥ ô
� õ¥P.
27.� êë \� � _�� “�vyz\� ]ö ”� ?� ¥�_ P P.
28.� êë \�< �� �_ ó÷ ¾� ç� P.
29.� êë \�< ��� + ó÷ ¾� ç� P.
30.� êë \�< ��sø �ù åÖ+ ò¥ �P.
31 .� êë \�< �å� £® � ¨�< õ ¥P.
32.� êë \� \� û� �Î ® òP.
33.� êë \� \� û� + ò¥ �P.
34.� êë \� \� û� � ¬çP.
35.� êë \� �]û� \� û& ¡Z+ ½<P.
36.� êë \� �]û� Pü� �`î+ ]*�P.
37.� êë \� �]û� \¹Z�+ � J< õ ¥P.
38.� êë \� �]û� ��sø �`ÌÑ¥ ÐðñP.
190│ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
� � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
�à�
hP
39.� êë \� ¥ý� < é"¥ �P.
40.� êë \�< \� `® Ú Ú �ðû �¥P.
41 .� êë \�< ��� ¾� Å+ ��/ �¥P.�
42.� êë \�� �\ ��< �� ]�® òP.
43.� � È; % êë \�; [� ò� � �+ �P.
44.� � È; % êë \�; [� ¦¨� É� + �P.
45.� � È; % êë \�G �P.
� � lê
�àP �àP
#�
¥P
�à�
hP
�;
�à�
hP
46.� êë \�< ��_ ��� ��& ?¼+ å*�P.
47.� êë \�< ��& �ë� L�+ ��� ; � å*�P.
48.� ��]^® ��_ ��JL êë \�G ò¥ å*�P.
49.� êë \�< ���G ��� ; � å*�P.
50.�êë \�& ��� � êë ��& ��+ Êë�$ ÁÑ�P.
51.�êë \�& ��� ;< ��& �]® �¤WP.
¼�~]; ºL � �ý% Í]OOP.� �
�� | 1 91
ID
�vy z\� ��\� ]� ¼ �~] (� ��� [�)
Æ���#�? ��â¨�ÐA �������� v ûü «ð�� wt
���� ��c /#� = K �ú� `¤]^ ô �T>� ��� "# $. ○○○Ù :
:ãz ��7 _ :� ¤» �� �Q �# $.
2012C 10c
☞gø�� : D�) (& å`� �) / @I� ¥�� : ☎ 02-6209-5951
※� ,ê �«�< (� � � � � � ) � �? � ��|.
1 .� ñ< ____ì� 20[ ____í� 30[ ____ð� 40[ ____ô� 50[ ____õ� 60[ ¥�
2.� ñ< ____ì� � ____í� L
3.� ñ< ��+ ____ì� (I< õ¥P ____í� (I� h<P.�
4.� '® ¥ � � ; �� < } (� � � � � � )�¥ P.
� � 5.� ½�� Û,� ��& �  ٠�E� �.`O�?
� � � �
____� ì� 99Û� ¥J ____� í� 1 00~1 99Û� ¥J____� ð� 200~299Û� ¥J
� � � � � � � � � ____� ô� 300~399Û� ¥J ____� õ� 400~499Û� ¥J ____� ⑥� 500Û� ¥�
�
� � 6.� �J& ®� ;% ZÎ åÖ; ºL J< s� � s¥�O�?
____ì� 1H(�Ï¥) ____í� 2H(çÏ¥)� ____ð� Iª(� � � � � � � � � � � � � � )
� � 7.� �J& qö� K�`O�?
____ì� G/2 /ð ö ____í� �ö � � ____ð� �l/% �³q ____ô� IÌ /�Ó
____õ� Z� /�ëq ____⑥� ]K/I�q ____⑦� �� /äq ____⑧ � ®���
____⑨� Kq ____⑩� Iª(� � � � � � � � � � � � � � )
192 │ 201 2� ��� �_su �c –� �vy z\�
� � lê
�àP �àP
#� ¥P
�à� hP
�; �à� hP
1 .� ñ< �vy z\�; [JL ûð� �¥ WP.�
2.� êë ��;< ��+ / ` W< ?¼¥ � �ð WP.
3.� êë ��� ��; å*/ ` W< £cñ �º® òP.
4.� êë ��;< ��+ � ® ��< sû¥ WP.
5.� êë ��;% ��+ �S ` W< I^ ® ò� õ¥P.
6.� êë � �;% < � ���,� \�,� ÓÓI�,� Iö ¸¥ ��
åÖ; ��% % � »Ñ+ � �P.
7.� êë � � ; < � �_ �� ]�û& F2¥ å�JP.
8.� êë ��;%< �� I�ㆍ ��û¥ %� »Ñ+ ��P.
9.� êë ��; W< \�< ��]^ µ »d� ��G ¼$ WP.
10.� êë ��& \�< ��]^ �]; ò¥ ºL�P.
1 1 .� êë � �� �Á �? ^ ® ò¥ ÙÇP.
1 2.� êë � �� �Á Ó�¥ ò¥ ÙÇP.
1 3.� êë �� ��û� ��; [� �÷ _ ÌÑ¥ òP.
14.� êë � �� ��� ; ò� _G �P.
15.� êë �� ��û� ��G J�ñ �� U�+ ÛûðÚ I^®
WP.
16.� êë ��� ��û¥ ��G J�ñ �� U�+ Ûû ` W£)
V�J< s× I¥P.
17.� êë ��� �� åÖ+ / ` W< ? ¼¥ �P.
18.� êë ��;%< .0Û Ò¾© ��+ (Ó ` W< ÏZ¥P.
19.� êë � �;% < � ���,� \�,� ÓÓI�,� Iöû¥ % � � » ÑJ
< s× I¥P.
20.�êë ��;%< ����,�\�,�ÓÓI�,�Iöû& á´ÄÅ® � àY�ð
WP.
21.� êë ��;%< ]��]$® ò¥ bð³P.
22.� êë ��;%< ¥r-ë ¬ê< Zê® òP.
23.� �� åÖ� êë �� ]�û+ �ú?ÔP.
24.�êë ��� ÚÚ ��û¥ �ð�P.
25.�êë ��� ÊI �� Ñ¥P.
26.�êë ��¥ Õ³ÄP.
27.�êë ��& �?�¥ñ Ó��� ¥*Û¥ ôP.
28.�êë ��& �Ý�¥ñ £%� ̧ � ¥*Û¥ ôP.
29.� êë ��;%< ��& �ä�+ ��� ; � å*J$ WP.
30.� ��� êë ��]^ ��; ���, �ã+ ý�P$ ���P.
¼�~]; ºL � �ý% Í]OOP.� �
��× � � �c Iè ㆍ �«�| 1 93
M�? � % � K � ㆍ ©e
< ��>
¬ �M
D�) &å`� >L� �
�®O�
¥ðz å�`� ½�`� 7>�D
<M�?�>
íZW &å`� �� �
7YD � `� �� �
<����ㆍ �>
Z=ð �������� @I��
¥�� �������� @I�
7�� �������� @I� å�
*�� * ô �T>_ ¾²��� ���� �� ¾²o * ¨�o ²³�ü r>�G# $.