224
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

2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���&1B5?10�$1:-8��;01���'<1/5-8� -C?��$>1?501:@5-8��1/>11?��-:0��D1/A@5B1�#>01>?

�;;7�

� �A:0-91:@-8�$>5:/5<81?

,� �01494?4:9�:1��=4849,7��,B

��3C2?49�@7�>F?:4:A2=�=2H�H9:49�567:?6D�4C:>6D��EC62ED�@7�E96:C�?2EFC6�2?5�AC@G:56D7@C�E96:C�AF?:D9>6?E

4� �4110=09.0�-0?B009 ������� ���������������

�!,! ).�3% �!,!�02/()")4!

.:@=2E:@?D�@7�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56 .:@=2E:@?D�@7�DA64:2=�=2HD�

/;IJ�JE�:;J;HC?D;�?<�L?EB7J?ED�E<�IF;9?7B�B7M�?I /#.7/�241*+$+67/ EH/#.7/�+0�5'�

�D7BOP;�J>;�L?EB7J?ED�� � $I� ?J�MHED=�8;97KI;�J>;H;� ?I�7� B7M�FHE>?8?J?D=� ?J�EH�FKD?I>?D=� ?J�7I� IK9>�� � $<�OEK

H;CEL;�J>;�B7M��M?BB�J>;�79J�IJ?BB�8;�MHED=�

$<� J>;�MEH:?D=� E<� J>;� B7M�FKD?I>?D=� J>;� 9H?C;� KI;I� J>;�MEH:� ZM?BB<KBBO[�� J>;D�C7B?9;�CKIJ� 8;� FHEL;D

2>;H;�C7B?9;�?I�7�<79JEH��=EE:�<7?J>�?I�7�:;<;DI;

$D�L?EB7J?ED�E<� IF;9?7B� B7M�� J>;�79J� 9EDIJ?JKJ?D=� J>;�9H?C;� ?I�7�FHE>?8?J;:�79J� � />;H;<EH; %7.2# ?I�DEJ�7

87I?I�E<�B?78?B?JO��KDB;II�J>;�IF;9?7B�B7M�FKD?I>;I�7D�EC?II?ED

2>;D�=?L;D�7�FHE8B;C��J7A;�DEJ;�?<�J>;�9H?C;�?I�7�L?EB7J?ED�E<�J>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:;�EH�7�IF;9?7B�B7M�M>?9>�B?J;H7BBO�C;7DI��J>7J�J>;�79J�?I�?D>;H;DJBO�;L?B�EH�87:�EH 2'4�5' MHED=<KB

�)EJ�7BB�L?EB7J?EDI�E<�IF;9?7B�B7MI�7H; /#.#�241*+$+6#��2>?B;�?DJ;DJ?ED7B�<;BED?;I�7H;�7BM7OI�C7B7�?D�I;��?J

:E;I�DEJ�<EBBEM�J>7J�FHE>?8?J;:�79JI�:ED;�?D�L?EB7J?ED�E<�IF;9?7B�B7MI�7H;�7BM7OI /#.#�241*+$+6#� L;D�?<

J>;�9H?C;�?I�FKD?I>;:�KD:;H�7�IF;9?7B�B7M��?<�J>;�79J�FKD?I>;:�?I�ED;�M>?9>�?I�?D>;H;DJBO�MHED=��J>;�I7C;�?I

/#.7/�+0�5'��7D:��J>;H;<EH;��=EE:�<7?J>�7D:�J>;�B79A�E<�9H?C?D7B�?DJ;DJ�?I�7�L7B?:�:;<;DI;��KDB;II�?J� ?I�J>;

FHE:K9J�E<�9H?C?D7B�D;=B?=;D9;�EH�9KBF7

'?A;M?I;�M>;D J>;� IF;9?7B� B7M� H;GK?H;I� J>7J� J>;� FKD?I>;:� 79J� 8;� 9ECC?JJ;:� ADEM?D=BO� 7D:�M?BB<KBBO�

9H?C?D7B�?DJ;DJ�?I�H;GK?H;:�JE�8;�FHEL;:�8;<EH;�9H?C?D7B�B?78?B?JO�C7O�7H?I;

2>;D�J>;�79J�F;D7B?P;:�?I�DEJ�?D>;H;DJBO�MHED=��?J�?I�MHED=�EDBO�8;97KI;�7�B7M�FKD?I>;I J>;�I7C;

Page 2: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

-� &.:;0�:1��;;74.,?4:9�,9/��3,=,.?0=4>?4.>�:1�?30�#3474;;490��=4849,7

�,B

�090=,74?D� ,96�=2H�:D�3:?5:?8�E@�2==�A6CD@?D�H9@�=:G6�@C�D@;@FC?�:?�E96(9:=:AA:?6D

'0==4?:=4,74?D� ,96�=2H�:D�3:?5:?8�E@�2==�4C:>6D�4@>>:EE65�H:E9:?�E96&2E:@?2=�,6CC:E@CJ�@7 E96�(9:=:AA:?6D

#=:>;0.?4A4?D ,96�=2H�5@6D�?@E�92G6�2?J�C6EC@24E:G6�67764E�

�";D;H7B?JO E<� 9H?C?D7B� B7M�C;7DI� J>7J� J>;� 9H?C?D7B� B7M� E<� J>;� 9EKDJHO� =EL;HDI� 7BB� F;HIEDI�M?J>?D� J>;

9EKDJHO�H;=7H:B;II�E<�J>;?H�H79;��8;B?;<��I;N��EH�9H;;:��#EM;L;H��?J�?I�IK8@;9J�JE�9;HJ7?D�;N9;FJ?EDI�8HEK=>J

78EKJ� 8O� ?DJ;HD7J?ED7B� 7=H;;C;DJ� � �C87II7:EHI�� 9>?;<I� E<� IJ7J;I� 7D:� EJ>;H� :?FBEC7J?9� E<<?9?7BI 7H;

?CCKD;�<HEC�J>;�7FFB?97J?ED�E<�F;D7B�B7MI�M>;D�J>;O�7H;�?D�J>;�9EKDJHO�M>;H;�J>;O�7H;�7II?=D;:

N9;FJ?EDI�JE�=;D;H7B�7FFB?97J?ED�E<�9H?C?D7B�B7M�

7��FH?D9?FB;I�E<�FK8B?9�?DJ;HD7J?ED7B�B7M

8��JH;7J?;I�EH�JH;7JO�IJ?FKB7J?EDI

9� B7MI�E<�FH;<;H;DJ?7B�7FFB?97J?ED

�EDIKBI�7H;�DEJ�:?FBEC7J?9�E<<?9;HI />?I�?D9BK:;I�9EDIKB=;D;H7B��L?9;9EDIKB�EH�7DO�9EDIKB�?D�7�<EH;?=D

9EKDJHO��M>E�7H;�J>;H;<EH;��DEJ�?CCKD;�JE�J>;�EF;H7J?ED�EH�7FFB?97J?ED�E<�J>;�F;D7B�B7M�E<�J>;�9EKDJHO

M>;H;�J>;O�7H;�7II?=D;:���EDIKBI�7H;�IK8@;9J�JE�J>;�F;D7B�B7MI�E<�J>;�9EKDJHO�M>;H;�J>;O�7H;�7II?=D;:

$J�>7I�DE�H;<;H;D9;�JE�J;HH?JEHO 2>;D;L;H�OEK�7H;�7IA;:�JE�;NFB7?D�J>?I��?J�:E;I�DEJ�?D9BK:;�J;HH?JEHO��$J

H;<;HI�JE�F;HIEDI�J>7J�C7O�8;�=EL;HD;:�8O�J>;�F;D7B�B7M� N9;FJ?EDI�JE�/;HH?JEH?7B��FFB?97J?ED�

$DIJ7D9;I�;DKC;H7J;:�KD:;H��HJ?9B;����I;;�-;<;H;D9;�� N9;FJ?ED�JE�+HEIF;9J?L;��FFB?97J?ED�

2>;D�D;M� IJ7JKJ; ?I� <7LEH78B;� JE� J>;�799KI;:�M>E� ?I� DEJ� 7�>78?JK7B� :;B?DGK;DJ �FFB?978B;� JE� IF;9?7B

B7MI�M>?9>�FHEL?:;�CEH;�<7LEH78B;�9ED:?J?EDI�JE�J>;�799KI;:

Page 3: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

4� �:9>?4?@?4:9,7�7484?,?4:9>�:9�?30�;:B0=�:1��:92=0>>�?:�09,.?�;09,7

7,B>� 49�?30��477�:1�%423?>

�BF2=�AC@E64E:@? �?J�A6CD@?�D92==�?@E�36�56?:65�E96�6BF2= AC@E64E:@?�@7�E96=2HD�

�F6�AC@46DD &@�A6CD@?�D92==�36�56AC:G65�@7�=:76��=:36CEJ�@C�AC@A6CEJH:E9@FE�5F6�AC@46DD�@7�=2H�

&@?�:>A@D:E:@?�@7�4CF6=�2?5F?FDF2=�AF?:D9>6?E�@C6I46DD:G6�7:?6D

�4E�(C@9:3:E:?8�E96�!>A@D:E:@?�@7��62E9�(6?2=EJ�:?�E96(9:=:AA:?6D��

�:==�@7�2EE2:?56C � =68:D=2E:G6�24E�H9:49�:?7=:4ED�AF?:D9>6?E�H:E9@FE�;F5:4:2=EC:2=

�8�0/34�&!#4/ =2H '?6�H9:49�>2<6D�2?�24E:@?�5@?6�367@C6�E96�A2DD286�@7�E96=2H�2?5�H9:49�H2D�:??@46?E�H96?�5@?6�4C:>:?2=�2?5AF?:D96D�DF49�24E:@?

�*DBO�J>;�B;=?IB7J?L;�8H7D9>�E<�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ�97D�;D79J�F;D7B�B7MI�2>?B;�J>;�+H;I?:;DJ�C7O�:;<?D;�7D:

FKD?I> 7D�79J�7I�7�9H?C;��IK9>�;N;H9?I;�E<�FEM;H�?I�DEJ�;N;9KJ?L;�8KJ�B;=?IB7J?L;�7I�>;�:;H?L;I�IK9>�FEM;H

<HEC�J>;�B7MC7A?D=�8E:O�$J�?I�?D�;II;D9;��7D�;N;H9?I;�E<�B;=?IB7J?L;�FEM;H�8O�J>;��>?;<� N;9KJ?L;��HJ�$$$��.;9� �� �����EDIJ?JKJ?ED

�$8?:

�-� ����

Page 4: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

����18;:51?

�4ED�@C�@>:DD:@?D�AF?:D923=6�3J�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56

,� �7,>>414.,?4:9>�:1��07:940>

�44@C5:?8�E@�E96�>2??6C�@7�E96:C�4@>>:DD:@?

!?E6?E:@?2= �F=A23=6

,9@D6�4@>>:EE65�H:E9 56=:36C2E6�:?E6?E� ,9@D6�C6DF=E:?8�7C@>�?68=:86?46��C64<=6DD:>ACF56?46�� =24<� @7� 7@C6D:89E� @C� =24<� @7D<:==��

�44@C5:?8�E@�E96�DE286D�@7�E96:C�6I64FE:@?

�EE6>AE65 �CFDEC2E65 �@?DF>>2E65

,96� @776?56C� 4@>>6?46DE96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @7� 2� 76=@?J5:C64E=J� 3J� @G6CE� 24ED�� 2?55@6D�?@E�A6C7@C>�2==�E96�24ED@7� 6I64FE:@?� H9:49� D9@F=5AC@5F46�E96�76=@?J�3J�C62D@?@7� D@>6� 42FD6� @C� 244:56?E@E96C� E92?� 9:D� @H?DA@?E2?6@FD�56D:DE2?46

,96� @776?56C� 4@>>6?46DE96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @7� 2� 76=@?J2D� 2� 4@?D6BF6?46� 3FE� H9:49H@F=5�AC@5F46� E96� 76=@?J�2D2� 4@?D6BF6?46� 3FE� H9:49?6G6CE96=6DD� 5@� ?@E� AC@5F46E96� 76=@?J� 3J� C62D@?� @742FD6D� :?56A6?56?E� @7� E96A6CA6EC2E@C�

�==� E96� 6=6>6?ED� ?646DD2CJ7@C� :ED� 6I64FE:@?� 2C6AC6D6?E�

�44@C5:?8�E@�E96:C 8C2G:EJ

�C2G6 $6DD�8C2G6 $:89E

�EE2496D� E96� 42A:E2=AF?:D9>6?E� @C� A6?2=E:6DH9:49�:?�2?J�@7�E96:C�A6C:@5D2C6�277=:4E:G6

,96� =2H� AF?:D96D� H:E9A6?2=E:6D� H9:49� :?� E96:C>2I:>F>� A6C:@5� H2D#/22%##)/.!,�

!?7C24E:@?D� @7� =2H� 7@C� E964@>>:DD:@?� @7� H9:49� E96A6?2=EJ�:D !22%34/�-%./2��

�HJ��

��HJ��

��HJ��

Page 5: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

-� �70809?>�:1��=4849,7��4,-474?D

:� 24E�@C�@>:DD:@?

::� AF?:D923=6�3J�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56

:::� 4@>>:EE65�3J�6:E96C $/,/ @C #5,0!

.� �8;:>>4-70��=480�� � @?6�H9:49�H@F=5�36�2?�@776?D6�282:?DE�A6CD@?D�@CAC@A6CEJ��H6C6�:E�?@E�7@C�E96�:?96C6?E�:>A@DD:3:=:EJ�@7�:ED�244@>A=:D9>6?E�@C�@?244@F?E�@7�E96�6>A=@J>6?E�@7�:?256BF2E6�@C�:?67764EF2=�>62?D��

/� &?,20>�:1��C0.@?4:9��

��HJ����F7H��

� *<<;D:;H�CKIJ�8;B?;L;�J>7J�>;�97D�9EDIKCC7J;�J>;�?DJ;D:;:�9H?C;��7�C7D�IJ788?D=�7DEJ>;H�M>E�>;

AD;M�M7I�7BH;7:O�:;7:�97DDEJ�8;�B?78B;�<EH�7D�?CFEII?8B;�9H?C;

� />;�B7M�?DJ;D:I�JE�FKD?I>�J>;�9H?C?D7B�?DJ;DJ

� />;H;�?I�DE�7JJ;CFJ;:�EH�<HKIJH7J;:�?CFEII?8B;�9H?C;

-;GK?I?J;I�

��9J�MEKB:�>7L;�8;;D�7D�E<<;DI;�7=7?DIJ�F;HIEDI�EH�FHEF;HJO

���9J�?I�DEJ�7D�79JK7B�L?EB7J?ED�E<�7DEJ>;H�FHEL?I?ED�E<�J>;��E:;�EH�E<�7�IF;9?7B�F;D7B�B7M

��/>;H;�M7I 9H?C?D7B�?DJ;DJ

���99ECFB?I>C;DJ�M7I�?D>;H;DJBO�?CFEII?8B;��EH�?D7:;GK7J;�EH�?D;<<;9JK7B�C;7DI�M;H;�;CFBEO;: �I;;��B7II?<?97J?ED�E<�!;BED?;I��IKFH7

�1'5�016�#22.;�+0�

*<<;DI;I�FKD?I>78B;�8O�.F;9?7B�+;D7B�'7MI��KDB;II�J>;�EJ>;HM?I;�?I�FHEL?:;:�<EH

� !EHC7B�9H?C;I��;=��IB7D:;H��7:KBJ;HO��;J9�

� $CFEII?8B;��H?C;I

� �H?C;I�9EDIKCC7J;:�8O�C;H;�7JJ;CFJ �:#/2.'5� 7JJ;CFJ�JE�<B;;�JE�7D�;D;CO�9EKDJHO��JH;7IED�

9EHHKFJ?ED�E<�C?DEHI

� !;BED?;I�8O�EC?II?ED

� �H?C;I� 9ECC?JJ;:� 8O� C;H;� 7=H;;C;DJ �:#/2.'5� 8;JJ?D= ?D� IFEHJI� �;D:?D=I� ?D� 87IA;J87BB��

9EHHKFJ?ED�E<�FK8B?9�E<<?9;HI

Page 6: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

0� �:9>;4=,.D�� ,9/�#=:;:>,7

�@?DA:C24J�� (C@A@D2=��

/96?� EH@� @C� >@C6� A6CD@?D� 4@>6� E@� 2?28C66>6?E� 4@?46C?:?8� E96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @7� 276=@?J�2?5�564:56�E@�4@>>:E�:E

/96?� E96� A6CD@?� H9@� 92D� 564:565� E@4@>>:E� 2� 76=@?J� AC@A@D6D� :ED� 6I64FE:@?� E@D@>6�@E96C�A6CD@?�@C�A6CD@?D

�/ME�A?D:I�E<�9EDIF?H79O�

� � �EDIF?H79O�7I�7�9H?C;��7D:

��� �EDIF?H79O�7I�7�C7DD;H�E<�?D9KHH?D=�9H?C?D7B�B?78?B?JO

2>;D�9EDIF?H79O� ?JI;B<� ?I�7� 9H?C;��DE�EL;HJ�79J� ?I�D;9;II7HO� JE�8H?D=�78EKJ� J>;�9H?C?D7B� B?78?B?JO� � />;

C;H;� 9EDIF?H79O� ?I� J>;� 9H?C;� ?JI;B< />?I� ?I� EDBO� JHK;� M>;D� J>;� B7M� ;NFH;IIBO� FKD?I>;I� J>;� C;H;

9EDIF?H79O�� EJ>;HM?I;�� J>;� 9EDIF?H79O� :E;I� DEJ� 8H?D=� 78EKJ� J>;� 9ECC?II?ED� E<� J>;� 9H?C;� 8;97KI;

9EDIF?H79O� ?I�DEJ�7D�EL;HJ�79J�8KJ�7�C;H;�FH;F7H7JEHO�79J� �/H;7IED��H;8;BB?ED��I;:?J?ED��7D:�9EKF�:Y;J7J

7H;�J>;�EDBO�9H?C;I�M>;H;�J>;�9EDIF?H79O�7D:�FHEFEI7B�JE�9ECC?J�JE�J>;C�7H;�FKD?I>78B;

2>;D� J>;� 9EDIF?H79O� ?I� EDBO� 7� 87I?I� E<� ?D9KHH?D=� 9H?C?D7B� B?78?B?JO� J>;H;� CKIJ� 8;� 7D� EL;HJ� 79J� :ED;

8;<EH;�J>;�9E9EDIF?H7JEHI�8;9EC;�9H?C?D7BBO�B?78B;

2>;D�J>;�9EDIF?H79O�?JI;B<�?I�7�9H?C;� J>?I�97DDEJ�8;�?D<;HH;:�EH�:;:K9;:�8;97KI;�J>;H;�?I�DE�EL;HJ�79J

�BB�J>7J�J>;H;�?I�J>;�7=H;;C;DJ��*D�J>;�EJ>;H�>7D:��?< J>;�9E9EDIF?H7JEH�EH�7DO�E<�J>;C�MEKB:�;N;9KJ;�7D

EL;HJ�79J��J>;�9H?C;�MEKB:�DE�BED=;H�8;�J>;�9EDIF?H79O�8KJ�J>;�EL;HJ�79J�?JI;B<

$<�J>;�9EDIF?H79O�?I�EDBO�7�87I?I�E<�9H?C?D7B�B?78?B?JO� DED;�E<�J>;�9E9EDIF?H7JEHI�MEKB:�8;�B?78B;��KDB;II

J>;H;�?I�7D�EL;HJ�79J��.E��<EH�7I�BED=�7I�7DOED;�I>7BB�:;I?IJ�8;<EH;�7D�EL;HJ�79J�?D�<KHJ>;H7D9;�E<�J>;�9H?C;

M7I�9ECC?JJ;:��IK9>�7�:;I?IJ7D9;�MEKB:�D;=7J;�9H?C?D7B�B?78?B?JO !EH�7I�BED=�7I�DED;�E<�J>;�9EDIF?H7JEHI

>7I�9ECC?JJ;:�7D�EL;HJ�79J��J>;H;�?I�DE�9H?C;�O;J �KJ�M>;D�ED;�E<�J>;C�9ECC?JI�7DO�EL;HJ�79J��7BB�E<

J>;C� I>7BB� 8;� >;B:� B?78B;� KDB;II � 7� 9E9EDIF?H7JEH�M7I� 78I;DJ� <HEC� J>;� I9;D;� E<� J>;� 9H?C;� EH� �� >;

I>EM;:�KF��8KJ�>;�JH?;:�JE�FH;L;DJ�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<�J>;�9H?C;

�I�7�=;D;H7B�HKB;� ?<�J>;H;�>7I�8;;D�7�9EDIF?H79O�JE�9ECC?J�7�9H?C;�?D�7�F7HJ?9KB7H�FB79;��7DOED;�M>E�:?:

DEJ�7FF;7H�I>7BB�8;�FH;IKC;:�JE�>7L;�:;I?IJ;:��/>;�;N9;FJ?ED�JE�J>?I�?I ?<�IK9>�F;HIED�M>E�:?:�DEJ�7FF;7H

M7I�J>;�C7IJ;HC?D:

�EDIF?H79O�7I�7�9H?C;� CKIJ�>7L;�7�9B;7H�7D:�9EDL?D9?D=�;L?:;D9;�E<�?JI�;N?IJ;D9;�� L;HO�9H?C;�CKIJ�8;

FHEL;:�8;OED:�H;7IED78B;�:EK8J

2>;D�J>;�9EDIF?H79O�?I�@KIJ�7�87I?I�E<�?D9KHH?D=�9H?C?D7B�B?78?B?JO� >EM;L;H��J>;�I7C;�C7O�8;�:;:K9;:�EH

?D<;HH;:�<HEC�J>;�79JI�E<�I;L;H7B�E<<;D:;HI�?D�97HHO?D=�EKJ�J>; 9ECC?II?ED�E<�J>;�9H?C;��/>;�;N?IJ;D9;�E<

7�9EDIF?H79O�C7O�8;�H;7IED78BO�?D<;HH;:�<HEC�J>;�79JI�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;HI�M>;D�IK9>�79JI�:?I9BEI;�EH�I>EM�7

9ECCED�FKHIK?J�E<�J>;�9H?C?D7B�E8@;9J?L;

�EDIF?H79O�?I�7�C7JJ;H�E<�IK8IJ7D9;�M>?9>�CKIJ�8;�7BB;=;:�?D�J>;�?D<EHC7J?ED��EJ>;HM?I;��J>;�9EKHJ�M?BB

DEJ�9EDI?:;H�J>;�I7C;

��9EDIF?H79O�?I�FEII?8B;�;L;D�M>;D�F7HJ?9?F7DJI�7H;�DEJ�ADEMD�JE�;79>�EJ>;H

/>;H;�?I�9EDIF?H79O�M>;D�J>;�E<<;D:;HI�79J;:�I?CKBJ7D;EKIBO�FKHIK?D=�7�9ECCED�9H?C?D7B�:;I?=D��J>KI�

79J?D=�EKJ�7�9ECCED�9H?C?D7B�?DJ;DJ

L;D�J>EK=>�J>;H;�M7I�9EDIF?H79O��?<�7�9E9EDIF?H7JEH�C;H;BO�9EEF;H7J;:�?D�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<�J>;�9H?C;

M?J>�?DI?=D?<?97DJ�EH�C?D?C7B�79JI��IK9>�J>7J�;L;D�M?J>EKJ�>?I�9EEF;H7J?ED��J>;�9H?C;�9EKB:�8;�97HH?;:�EKJ

7I�M;BB��IK9>�9E9EDIF?H7JEH�I>EKB:�8;�FKD?I>;:�7I�7D�799ECFB?9;�EDBO �+KD?I>78B;�?D�J>;�<EBBEM?D=�97I;I��JH;7IED��H;8;BB?ED�EH�?DIKHH;9J?ED��I;:?J?ED� %172�&=�'6#6��7HIED��7D:

CEDEFEB?;I�7D:�9EC8?D7J?EDI�?D�H;IJH7?DJ�E<�JH7:; �*DBO�J>;�F;HIED�FHEFEI?D=�EH�J>; FHEFED;DJ�?I�9H?C?D7BBO�B?78B;

+HEFEI7B� ?I� JHK;� EDBO� KF� JE� J>;� FE?DJ�M>;H;� J>;� F7HJO� JE�M>EC� J>;� FHEFEI7B�M7I�C7:;� >7I� DEJ� O;J

799;FJ;:�J>;�FHEFEI7B��*D9;�J>;�FHEFEI7B�M7I�799;FJ;:��7�9EDIF?H79O�7H?I;I��+HEFEI7B�?I�KD?B7J;H7B��ED;

F7HJO�C7A;I�7�FHEFEI?J?ED�JE�J>;�EJ>;H��9EDIF?H79O�?I�8?B7J;H7B��?J�H;GK?H;I�JME�F7HJ?;I

Page 7: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

�=6>6?ED 2 �8C66>6?E� 2>@?8� � @C� >@C6A6CD@?D�E@�4@>>:E�2�4C:>6

3 ,96J�564:56�E@�4@>>:E�:E

2 �� A6CD@?� 92D� 564:565� E@� 4@>>:E� 24C:>6

3 6� AC@A@D6D� :ED� 4@>>:DD:@?� E@2?@E96C

�C:>6D 2 �@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E D65:E:@?

3 �@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�C636==:@?

4 �@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�EC62D@?

2 (C@A@D2=�E@�4@>>:E�EC62D@?

3 (C@A@D2=� E@� 4@>>:E� C636==:@?� @C:?DFCC64E:@?

1� @7?4;70�"1109/0=>��/4110=09.0>��=@70>��0110.?>�

23:EF2=�56=:?BF6?4J *64:5:G:D>

,H@�4@?G:4E:@?D�2C6�6?@F89 �E�=62DE�E9C66�4@?G:4E:@?D�2C6�C6BF:C65

,96�4C:>6D�2C6�?@E�DA64:7:65��:E�:D�6?@F89�E92EE96J�>2J�36�6>3C2465�F?56C�E96�D2>6�E:E=6�@7E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56

,96�4C:>6D�2C6�=:>:E65�2?5�DA64:7:65�E@�

�2��D6C:@FD�A9JD:42=�:?;FC:6D�

�3��=6DD�D6C:@FD�A9JD:42=�:?;FC:6D�

�4��C@336CJ�

�5��E967E�

�6��6DE272�@C�DH:?5=:?8�2?5

�7��72=D:7:42E:@?

,96C6� :D� ?@� E:>6� =:>:E� 36EH66?� E96� 7:CDE4@?G:4E:@?� 2?5� E96� DF3D6BF6?E� 4@?G:4E:@?*64:5:G:D>�:D�:>AC6D4C:AE:3=6

,96C6� :D� 2� E:>6� =:>:E� @7� ?@E�>@C6� E92?� ��J62CD� 36EH66?� 6G6CJ� 4@?G:4E:@?D� 4@>AFE657C@>� E96� 7:CDE� 4@?G:4E:@?� @C� C6=62D6� 7C@>AF?:D9>6?E� E96C6@7� E@� 4@?G:4E:@?4@>AFE65� 7C@>� E96� D64@?5� 4@?G:4E:@?� @CC6=62D6 E96C67C@>� E@� E96� E9:C5� 4@?G:4E:@?2?5�D@�@?�

Page 8: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

!E�:D�2�86?6C:4�288C2G2E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46�H9:4942?� 36� @77D6E� 3J� 2?� @C5:?2CJ� >:E:82E:?84:C4F>DE2?46� !7� ?@E� @77D6E�� :E� H@F=5� @?=J:?4C62D6�E96�A6?2=EJ�AC6D4C:365�3J�=2H�7@C�E964C:>6�4@>>:EE65�E@�:ED >2I:>F>�A6C:@5

!E� :D� 2� DA64:2=� 288C2G2E:?8� 4:C4F>DE2?46�96?46� :E�42??@E�36�@77D6E�3J�2?J�>:E:82E:?84:C4F>DE2?46� �D:56� 7C@>� E96� A6?2=EJAC6D4C:365�3J�=2H�7@C�E96�4C:>6�4@>>:EE65�2?� 255:E:@?2=� A6?2=EJ� D92==� 36� :>A@D6556A6?5:?8� FA@?� H96E96C� :E� :D� 2=C625J� E96E9:C5�4@?G:4E:@?��E96�7@FCE9��E96�7:7E9�2?5�D@@?�

,96� 4:C4F>DE2?46�?665�?@E�36� 2==6865� :?� E96:?7@C>2E:@?

,96� 4:C4F>DE2?46� >FDE� 36� 2==6865� :?� E96:?7@C>2E:@?�� @E96CH:D6� E96� 4@FCE� 42??@E24BF:C6� ;FC:D5:4E:@?� E@� :>A@D6� 255:E:@?2=A6?2=EJ

��/>KI��?<���>7I�8;;D�9EDL?9J;:�E<�(KH:;H��7D:�7<J;H�=H7DJ�E<�F7HEB;�9ECC?JJ;:�#EC?9?:;��>;�B78EHI�KD:;H

J>?I�F7H7=H7F>�� ���ADEMD�7I 4'+6'4#%+10��8KJ�>;�?I�7BIE�IK<<;H?D=�<HEC�H;9?:?L?IC��4'%+&'0%+#�� � $D�IK9>�7

97I;��>;�M?BB�8;�9EDI?:;H;:�EDBO�7I�H;9?:?L?IJ��7D:�F7H� ��M?BB�DE�BED=;H�7FFBO�JE�>?C

�%)4%2!#)/. � *64:5:G:D>

&646DD2CJ� E92E� @776?56C� D92==� 92G6� D6CG65@FE�9:D�D6?E6?46�7@C�E96�7:CDE�D6?E6?46

�?@F89� E92E� 7:?2=� ;F58>6?E� 92D� 366?C6?56C65�:?�E96�7:CDE�@776?D6

(C6G:@FD� 2?5� DF3D6BF6?E� @776?D6D�>FDE� ?@E36�6>3C2465�:?�E96�D2>6�E:E=6�@7 E96��@56

+2>6�E:E=6

&@E�2=H2JD�2?�288C2G2E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46 �=H2JD�288C2G2E:?8

Page 9: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

'776?56CD �7764ED

*64:5:G:DE G @?6�H9@�2E� E96� E:>6�@7�9:D� EC:2=7@C� @?6� 4C:>6�� D92==� 92G6� 366?� AC6G:@FD=J4@?G:4E65�3J�7:?2=�;F58>6?E�@7�2?@E96C�4C:>66>3C2465�:?�E96�D2>6�E:E=6�@7�E96�*(� �

�6?6C:4�288C2G2E:?8

�%)4%2!#)/. @C�923:EF2=:EJ L @?6�H9@�92D�366?AF?:D965� 7@C� 2?� @776?D6� E@� H9:49� E96� =2H2EE2496D�2?�6BF2=�@C�8C62E6C�A6?2=EJ

%2J� 36� 288C2G2E:?8 56A6?5:?8� @?� E965:D4C6E:@?�@7�E96�4@FCE

)F2D:�C64:5:G:D> L 2?J� A6CD@?� H9@� D92==4@>>:E�2�76=@?J�27E6C�92G:?8�366?�4@?G:4E653J�7:?2=�;F58>6?E��367@C6�368:??:?8�E@�D6CG6DF49� D6?E6?46�� @C� H9:=6� D6CG:?8� E96� D2>6�D92==�36�AF?:D965�3J�E96�>2I:>F>�A6C:@5�@7E96� A6?2=EJ� AC6D4C:365� 3J� =2H� 7@C� E96� ?6H76=@?J

,96�A6?2=EJ�:D�C2:D65�E@�E96�>2I:>F>�A6C:@5@7�E96�A6?2=EJ�AC6D4C:365�7@C�E96�?6H�76=@?J

� $J� ?I� ?CFEHJ7DJ�J>7J�J>;�9EDL?9J?ED�M>?9>�97C;�;7HB?;H�CKIJ�H;<;H�JE�J>;�9H?C;�9ECC?JJ;:�;7HB?;H�J>7D

J>;�IK8I;GK;DJ�9EDL?9J?ED

�7I?I� "H;7J;H�F;HL;HI?JO�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�7I�I>EMD�8O�>?I�?D9B?D7J?ED�JE�9ECC?J�9H?C;I

-;GK?I?J;I�

7 E<<;D:;H�?I�ED�JH?7B�<EH�7D�E<<;DI;

8 >;�M7I�FH;L?EKIBO�9EDL?9J;:�8O�<?D7B�@K:=C;DJ� E<�7DEJ>;H�9H?C;

9 J>7J�8EJ>�J>;�<?HIJ�7D:�J>;�I;9ED:�E<<;DI;I�7H; ;C8H79;:�?D�J>;�I7C;�J?JB;�E<�J>;�-+���DEJ�IF;9?7B

B7M�

: J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�9EDL?9J;:�E<�J>;�D;M�E<<;DI;

-;9?:?L?IC�CKIJ�8;�J7A;D�?DJE�799EKDJ�DE�C7JJ;H�>EM�C7DO�O;7HI�>7L;�?DJ;HL;D;:�8;JM;;D�J>;�<?HIJ

7D:�I;9ED:�<;BED?;I

/E� FHEL;� H;9?:?L?IC�� ?J CKIJ� 8;� 7BB;=;:� ?D� J>;� ?D<EHC7J?ED� 7D:�M?J>� 7JJ79>;:� 9;HJ?<?;:� 9EF?;I� E<� J>;

I;DJ;D9;I�H;D:;H;:�7=7?DIJ�J>;�799KI;:

N9;FJ?EDI�� ?<� J>;�799KI;:�:E;I�DEJ�E8@;9J�7D:�M>;D�>;�7:C?JI� ?D�>?I�9ED<;II?ED�7D:�ED�J>;�M?JD;II

IJ7D:��$D 4'+6'4#%+10� J>;�F;D7BJO 7JJ79>;:�JE�J>;�9H?C;�IK8I;GK;DJBO�9ECC?JJ;:�I>EKB:�8;�>?=>;H�EH�7J�B;7IJ

;GK7B�JE�J>;�F;D7BJO�J>7J�>;�>7I�7BH;7:O�I;HL;: $<�J>7J�?I�J>;�I?JK7J?ED��J>7J�C;7DI�J>7J�J>;�E<<;D:;H�M7I

D;L;H� H;<EHC;:�8O� J>;� <79J� J>7J�>;�7BH;7:O� I;HL;:� J>;�F;D7BJO� ?CFEI;:�ED�>?C�ED� J>;� <?HIJ� 9EDL?9J?ED

#EM;L;H��?<�>;�9ECC?JI�7�<;BEDO�97HHO?D=�7�B?=>J;H�F;D7BJO� IK8I;GK;DJBO��J>;�B7M�9EDI?:;HI�J>7J�IEC;>EM

>;�>7I�8;;D� H;<EHC;: 8KJ� ?<� >;��7=7?D�9ECC?JI�7DEJ>;H� <;BEDO�M>?9>�97HH?;I�7� B?=>J;H�F;D7BJO�� J>;D�>;

8;9EC;I�7�H;F;7J;H�8;97KI;�J>7J�C;7DI�>;�>7I�DEJ�O;J�H;<EHC;:

4EK�M?BB�EDBO�9EDI?:;H�J>;�F;D7BJO�?D 4'+6'4#%+10 ?<�J>;H;�?I�7BH;7:O�7�I;9ED:�9EDL?9J?ED� 2>;D�J>;H;�?I�7

J>?H:� 9EDL?9J?ED�� OEK� :?IH;=7H:� M>7J;L;H� F;D7BJO� <EH� J>;� IK8I;GK;DJ� 9H?C;I� 9ECC?JJ;:� L;D� ?<� J>;

F;D7BJO� <EH� J>;� IK8I;GK;DJ�9H?C;I�9ECC?JJ;:�7H;� B?=>J;H� J>7D� J>;�ED;I�7BH;7:O� I;HL;:�� I?D9;� J>;H;�7H;

7BH;7:O�JME�E<�J>;C�IK8I;GK;DJBO��J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�7BH;7:O�7�H;F;7J;H

#EM;L;H� ?<�J>;H;�?I�EDBO�7�I;9ED:�9EDL?9J?ED��F7O�7JJ;DJ?ED�JE�J>;�F;D7BJO�7JJ79>;:�JE�J>;�9H?C;�M>?9>

M7I�9ECC?JJ;:�<EH�J>;�I;9ED:�9H?C;�/>7J�?I�M>O�?J�?I�I7?:�J>7J 4'+6'4#%+10 ?I�DEJ�7BM7OI�7==H7L7J?D=�/>?I

?I�IE�8;97KI;�?<�J>;�F;D7BJO�7JJ79>;:�JE�J>;�<;BEDO�IK8I;GK;DJBO�9ECC?JJ;:�?I�DEJ�;GK7B�EH�>?=>;H�J>7D�J>;

F;D7BJO�7BH;7:O�I;HL;:��;L;D�?<�B?J;H7BBO��J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�7�H;F;7J;H��H;F;J?J?ED�?I�DEJ�7==H7L7J?D=

Page 10: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

23:EF2=� 56=:?BF6?4J L H96?� 2� A6CD@?�H:E9:?�2�A6C:@5�@7����J62CD�7C@>�E96�52E6�@79:D�C6=62D6�@C�=2DE�4@?G:4E:@?�@7�E96�4C:>6D�@7D6C:@FD� @C� =6DD� D6C:@FD� A9JD:42=� :?;FC:6D�C@336CJ��E967E��6DE272�@C�72=D:7:42E:@?��:D�7@F?58F:=EJ� @7� 2?J� @7� D2:5� 4C:>6D� 2� E9:C5� E:>6� @C@7E6?6C �

2��-A@?� 2� E9:C5� 4@?G:4E:@?�� E96� 4F=AC:E� D92==36�D6?E6?465�E@�E96�A6?2=EJ�AC@G:565�3J�=2H7@C�E96�=2DE�4C:>6�@7�H9:49�96�36�7@F?5�8F:=EJ2?5� E@� E96� 255:E:@?2=� A6?2=EJ� @7 02)3)/.#/22%##)/.!, :?� :ED� >65:F>� 2?5� >2I:>F>A6C:@5D�

3��-A@?�2�7@FCE9�4@?G:4E:@?��E96�4F=AC:E�D92==36�D6?E6?465�E@�E96�A6?2=EJ�AC@G:565�7@C�E96=2DE�4C:>6�@7�H9:49�96�36�7@F?5�8F:=EJ�2?5�E@E96� 255:E:@?2=� A6?2=EJ� @7 02)3)/.� -!9/2 :?� :ED>:?:>F>�2?5�>65:F>�A6C:@5D��2?5

4��-A@?�2�7:7E9�@C�255:E:@?2=�4@?G:4E:@?��E964F=AC:E� D92==� 36� D6?E6?465� E@� E96� A6?2=EJAC@G:565� 7@C� E96� =2DE� 4C:>6� @7� H9:49� 96� 367@F?5�8F:=EJ�2?5�E@�E96�255:E:@?2=�A6?2=EJ�@702)3)/.� -!9/2 :?� :ED� >2I:>F>� A6C:@5� E@C64=FD:@?�E6>A@C2=�:?�:ED�>:?:>F>�A6C:@5

&@EH:E9DE2?5:?8�� E96� E@E2=� @7� E96� EH@A6?2=E:6D� E@� 36� :>A@D65� FA@?� E96� @776?56CD92==�:?�?@�42D6�6I4665����J62CD �

��2>;D�J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�7�H;9?:?L?IJ�7D:�7J�J>;�I7C;�J?C;�7�>78?JK7B�:;B?DGK;DJ��J>;�F;D7BJO�<EH�J>;�9H?C;

<EH� M>?9>� >;� M?BB� 8;� 9EDL?9J;:� M?BB� 8;� ?D9H;7I;:� JE� J>;�C7N?CKC� F;H?E:� KDB;II� E<<I;J� 8O� 7�C?J?=7J?D=

9?H9KCIJ7D9;��<J;H�:;J;HC?D?D=�J>;�9EHH;9J�F;D7BJO�<EH�J>;�B7IJ�9H?C;�9ECC?JJ;:��7D�7::;:�F;D7BJO�M?BB

8;�?CFEI;:�?D�799EH:7D9;�M?J>��HJ?9B;���

#78?JK7B� :;B?DGK;D9O�� 8;?D=� 7� IF;9?7B� EH� IF;9?<?9� 7==H7L7J?D=� 9?H9KCIJ7D9;� CKIJ� 8;� 7BB;=;:� ?D� J>;

?D<EHC7J?ED�$<� ?J� ?I�DEJ�7BB;=;:�?D�J>;�?D<EHC7J?ED�7D:�?D�J>;�9EKHI;�E<�J>;�JH?7B��J>;�FHEI;9KJ?ED�JH?;:�JE

FHEL;� J>7J� J>;� E<<;D:;H� ?I� 7� >78?JK7B� :;B?DGK;DJ� EL;H� J>;� E8@;9J?ED� E<� J>;� 799KI;:�� J>;� 9EKHJ� >7I� DE

@KH?I:?9J?ED�JE�9EDI?:;H�J>;�E<<;D:;H�7�>78?JK7B�:;B?DGK;DJ���HJ�����DE��

Page 11: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

2� �:8;70C��=480> ��� &;0.4,7��:8;70C��=480> �

�@>A=6I�4C:>6 +A64:2=�4@>A=6I�4C:>6 �

�@>>:EE65� 6:E96C� H96?� 2� D:?8=6� 24E4@?DE:EFE6D� EH@ @C�>@C6� 8C2G6� @C� =6DD� 8C2G676=@?:6D�� @C� H96?� 2?� @776?D6� :D� 2� ?646DD2CJ>62?D� 7@C� 4@>>:EE:?8� E96� @E96C � !?� 3@E942D6D��E96�A6?2=EJ�7@C�E96�>@C6�D6C:@FD�4C:>6D92==� 36� :>A@D65� 2?5� :D� E@� 36� 2AA=:65� :?� :ED>2I:>F>� A6C:@5� !E� 92D� EH@� <:?5D�4@>A@F?5� 4C:>6 � 2?5� 4@>A=6I� 4C:>6AC@A6C �

%256�FA�@7�>@C6�E92?�@?6�4C:>6��3FE�H9:49�:?� E96� 6J6D� @7� E96� =2H�� H2CC2?ED� 2� D:?8=6:?5:G:D:3=6� @776?D6� ,96J� 2C6� C682C565� 2D� 2DA64:2=� DA64:6D� @7� 4@>A=6I� 4C:>6� 3642FD6E96C6�:D�@?6�DA64:7:4�A6?2=EJ�:>A@D65��

�CE����:D�?@E 2AA=:423=6�:?�42D6�@7�DA64:2=�4@>A=6I�4C:>6D�DA64:2==J�AC@G:565�7@C�:?E96� *6G:D65� (6?2=� 4@56� =:<6� *@336CJ� H:E9� @>:4:56� @C� *2A6� @C� �CD@?�� @C� *2A6� H:E9 @>:4:56� 2?5�2AA=:6D�@?=J�H96?�?@�DA64:7:4�A6?2=EJ�:D�DE2E65�:?�E96�=2H

��$D� 97I;� J>;� 9H?C;� 9ECC?JJ;:� ?I� 7� 9ECFEI?J;� 9H?C;� J>;� 9EDIF?H7JEH� M?BB� 8;� B?78B;� <EH� 7BB� J>;� 79JI

9ECC?JJ;:�:KH?D=�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<�J>;�9H?C;�7=H;;:�KFED��/>?I�?I�8;97KI;��?D�J>;�;O;I�E<�J>; B7M��7BB

J>EI;�79JI�:ED;�?D�FKHIK7D9;�E<�J>;�9H?C;�7=H;;:�KFED�7H;�79JI�M>?9>�9EDIJ?JKJ;�7�I?D=B;�9H?C;��EH�9ECFEI?J;�9H?C;

���HJ���

��2>;D�7 I?D=B;�79J�9EDIJ?JKJ;I���EH�CEH;�=H7L;�EH�B;II�=H7L;�<;BED?;I

-;GK?I?J;I�

� J>7J�EDBO�ED;�I?D=B;�79J ?I�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�J>;�E<<;D:;H

�� J>7J�J>;�I?D=B;�79J�FHE:K9;I

7� ��EH�CEH;�=H7L;�<;BED?;I

8� ED;�EH�CEH;�=H7L;�7D:�ED;�EH�CEH;�B;II�=H7L;�<;BED?;I

9� ��EH�CEH;�B;II�=H7L;�<;BED?;I��2>;D�7D�E<<;DI;�?I�7�D;9;II7HO�C;7DI�<EH�9ECC?JJ?D=�7DEJ>;H

-;GK?I?J;I�

���J>7J�7J�B;7IJ���E<<;DI;I�7H;�9ECC?JJ;:

����J>7J�ED;�EH�IEC;�E<�J>;�E<<;DI;I�CKIJ�8;�D;9;II7HO�JE�9ECC?J�J>;�EJ>;H

����J>7J�8EJ>�EH�7BB�J>;�E<<;DI;I�CKIJ�8;�FKD?I>;:�KD:;H�J>;�I7C;�IJ7JKJ;��

�D� ;N7CFB;� E<� IF;9?7B� 9ECFB;N� 9H?C;� ?I� H7F;� M?J>� >EC?9?:;�� M>;D� J>;� >EC?9?:;� ?I� 9EDIKCC7J;:�

EJ>;HM?I;�J>;O�7H;�I;F7H7J;�E<<;DI;I��A?:D7FF?D=�M?J>�>EC?9?:;��HE88;HO�M?J>�7HIED� .;9����-�������7C;D:?D=�F7H� �E<��HJ����

��.;9� � ?:�7C;D:?D=��HJ����

Page 12: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

� �5>/A9?@-:/1?�C45/4 �221/@��>595:-8� 5-.585@E

,� �@>?41D492��4=.@8>?,9.0>��

,96� 24ED� @7� E96� 24E@C� 2C6� :?� 244@C52?46� H:E9� =2H� 2?5� 96?46�� 96� :D� ;FDE:7:65�� ?@4C:>:?2=�2?5�4:G:=�=:23:=:EJ�3642FD6�E96C6�:D�?@�4C:>6

4� �9?4�)4:709.0�,2,49>?�*:809�,9/�?304=��347/=09��.?�:1�� ��

,� �,??0=0/�B:8,9��>D9/=:80

� D4:6?E:7:42==J�567:?65�A2EE6C?�@7�ADJ49@=@8:42=�2?5�3692G:@C2=�DJ>AE@>D�7@F?5�:?H@>6?�=:G:?8�:?�32EE6C:?8�C6=2E:@?D9:AD�2D�2�C6DF=E�@7�4F>F=2E:G6�23FD6��

�92C24E6C:K65 3J E96 D@� 42==65 4J4=6 @7 G:@=6?46� H9:49 92D � A92D6D�

� ,6?D:@? 3F:=5:?8 A92D6

�4FE6 32EE6C:?8 :?4:56?E

� ,C2?BF:=� =@G:?8�� A92D6��

-� �C08;?492��4=.@8>?,9.0>��

,96C6�:D�2?�23D6?46�@7�G@=F?E2C:?6DD��2?5�96?46��E9@F89�E96C6�:D�2�4C:>6� E96C6�:D�?@4C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ

��.;;�-;<;H;D9;

��-������

���� MEC7D M>E ?I H;F;7J;:BO IK8@;9J;: JE 7DO <EH9;<KB F>OI?97B EH FIO9>EBE=?97B 8;>7L?EH 8O 7 C7D ?D

EH:;H JE 9E;H9; >;H JE :E IEC;J>?D= >; M7DJI >;H JE :E M?J>EKJ 9ED9;HD <EH >;H H?=>JI

$D9BK:;I M?L;I EH MEC;D ?D 7DO <EHC E< ?DJ?C7J; H;B7J?EDI>?F M?J> C;D

$D EH:;H JE 8; 9B7II?<?;: 7I 7 87JJ;H;: MEC7D� J>;� 9EKFB; CKIJ =E J>HEK=>� J>; 87JJ;H?D= 9O9B; 7J B;7IJ

JM?9; �DO MEC7D C7O <?D: >;HI;B< ?D 7D 78KI?L; H;B7J?EDI>?F M?J> 7 C7D ED9; $< ?J� E99KHI 7 I;9ED: J?C;�

7D: I>; H;C7?DI ?D J>; I?JK7J?ED� I>; ?I :;<?D;: 7I 7 87JJ;H;: MEC7D ��'12.' 8��'015#� "- )E ���

� � %7D �� �������.;9����9�

��EH��7J��B;7IJ��DEDL?EB;DJ

��*D;�CKIJ�KD:;H=E�����F>7I;I��JE��;IJ78B?I>��J>;�F7JJ;HD��E<��L?EB;D9;��*D;�CKIJ��F7II�����9O9B;I���;79>

M?J>���F>7I;I��.;;�-;<;H;D9;

Page 13: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

4� �@A09470��@>?4.0�,9/ *071,=0��.?�:1������ ,7>:�=010=� ?:��347/

,9/�+:@?3�*071,=0��:/0��

� �01494?4:9�:1�F.347/�49�.:9174.?�B4?3�?30�7,BG

� 49:=5�H9@�:D�2==6865�2D��244FD65�@7��@C�25;F5865�2D��92G:?8�4@>>:EE65�2?�@776?D6F?56C�(9:=:AA:?6�=2HD�

�� 4948@8�,20�:1�.=4849,7 =0>;:9>4-474?D

�86 �C24<6E �C:>:?2= $:23:=:EJ ,C62E>6?E

�� J62CD @=5 @C 36=@H �I6>AE ,96 49:=5 D92== 36 DF3;64E65E@ 2? :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2>

�3@G6 �� 3FE 36=@H ��� H9@24E65 H:E9@FE 5:D46C?>6?E

�I6>AE ,96 49:=5 D92== 36 DF3;64E65 E@2? :?E6CG6?E:@? AC@8C2>

�3@G6 �� 3FE 36=@H ��� H9@ 24E65 H:E9 5:D46C?>6?E

&@E 6I6>AE ,96 49:=5 D92== 36 DF3;64E65 E@E96� 2AAC@AC:2E6AC@4665:?8D :? 244@C52?46H:E9�E96��4E

,96�6I6>AE:@? 7C@>�4C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ�5@6D�?@E�:?4=F56�6I6>AE:@?�7C@>�4:G:=�=:23:=:EJ�H9:49�D92==�36�6?7@C465�:?�244@C52?46�H:E9�6I:DE:?8�=2HD��

�� �0?0=849,?4:9�:1�,20

,96 286 @7 2 49:=5 >2J 36 56E6C>:?65 7C@> E96 49:=5�D�

� �:CE9 46CE:7:42E6

�2AE:D>2= 46CE:7:42E6

� �?J @E96C A6CE:?6?E 5@4F>6?ED

!? E96 23D6?46 @7 E96D6 5@4F>6?ED� 286 >2J 36 32D65 @? :?7@C>2E:@? 7C@>E96 49:=5 9:>D6=796CD6=7� E6DE:>@?:6D @7 @E96C A6CD@?D� E96 A9JD:42= 2AA62C2?46 @7 E96

��-������

� +�������7I�7C;D:;:

��.;9����;���-������

/>; 9>?B: ?D 9ED<B?9J M?J> J>; B7M I>7BB ;D@EO J>; FH;IKCFJ?ED E< C?DEH?JO #;�I>; I>7BB ;D@EO 7BB

J>; H?=>JI E< 7 9>?B: ?D 9ED<B?9J M?J> J>; B7M KDJ?B >;�I>; ?I FHEL;D JE 8; � O;7HI EB: EH EB:;H��.;9��� -������

Page 14: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

49:=5 2?5 @E96C C6=6G2?E 6G:56?46�� !? 42D6 @7 5@F3E 2D E@ E96 286 @7 E96 49:=5� :ED92== 36 C6D@=G65 :? 9:D96C 72G@C

� �C08;?4:9�1=:8�.=4849,7�74,-474?D��

.� 4?42,?492�.4=.@8>?,9.0>��

2G6�E96�67764E�@7�C65F4:?8�E96�A6?2=EJ�3642FD6�E96C6�:D�2�5:>:?FE:@?�@7�2?J�@7�E966=6>6?ED�@7 $/,/ @C #5,0!��H9:49�>2<6D�E96�24E�G@=F?E2CJ�@C�3642FD6�@7�E96�=6DD6C�A6CG6CD:EJ�@7E96�@776?56C

/� �22=,A,?492�.4=.@8>?,9.0>��

+6CG6� E@� :?4C62D6� E96� A6?2=EJ H:E9@FE� 6I4665:?8� E96� >2I:>F>� AC@G:565� 3J� =2H3642FD6�@7�E96�8C62E6C�A6CG6CD:EJ�@7� E96�@776?56C�2D�D9@H?�3J�E96�>@E:G2E:?8�A@H6C�@7�E964@>>:DD:@?� @7� E96� 4C:>6�� E96� E:>6� 2?5� A=246� @7� 4@>>:EE:?8� E96� 4C:>6� 2?5� E96� >62?D6>A=@J65�@C�E96�A6CD@?2=�4:C4F>DE2?46D @7�E96�@776?56C

�090=4. $@,741D492

�6?6C2==J�2AA=:6D�E@�2==�4C:>6D�� �92?86D�E96�?2EFC6�@7�E96�76=@?J��

�2? 36 @77D6E 3J 2? @C5:?2CJ >:E:82E:?84:C4F>DE2?46

�2??@E�36 @77D6E 3J 2?J>:E:82E:?8 4:C4F>DE2?46D

!E :D ?@E 2? :?8C65:6?E @7 2 4C:>6 !E @?=J27764ED E96 A6?2=EJ E@ 36 :>A@D65 3FE E964C:>6 C6>2:?D E96 D2>6

,96 4:C4F>DE2?46 :D 24EF2==J 2? :?8C65:6?E @7E96 4C:>6 ,96 4:C4F>DE2?46 27764ED E96?2EFC6 @7 E96 4C:>6 :ED6=7 DF49 E92E E96@776?56C D92== 36 =:23=6 7@C 2 >@C6D6C:@FD 4C:>6

&@ ?665 E@ 2==686 E9:D 4:C4F>DE2?46 :? E96:?7@C>2E:@?� 2D =@?8 2D :E :D AC@G6? 5FC:?8EC:2=

!7 :E :D AC@G65 5FC:?8 EC:2=� E96 D2>6 :D4@?D:56C65 :? :>A@D:?8 E96 A6?2=EJ

,@ 36 2AAC64:2E65 2D DF49� >FDE 36DA64:7:42==J 2==6865 :? E96 4@>A=2:?E @C:?7@C>2E:@?

!7 ?@E 2==6865 3FE AC@G6? 5FC:?8 E96 EC:2=� :EH:== 36 4@?D:56C65 @?=J 2D 86?6C:4

��.;9����?8?:

��.;; (?D?CKC�7=;�E<�9H?C?D7B�H;IFEDI?8?B?JO��IKFH7

��.;;�-;<;H;D9;

��$8?:

��B?A; H;9?:?L?IC

��7I�JH;79>;HO�?D�>EC?9?:;�JE�CKH:;H

Page 15: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

288C2G2E:?8 4:C4F>DE2?46 !7 E9:D 92AA6?D�E96J 2C6 DFD46AE:3=6 @7 36:?8 @77D6E 3J 2?@C5:?2CJ >:E:82E:?8 4:C4F>DE2?46��

,� �0.=00��:/41D492�?30��,B>�:9��7702,7���(97,B1@7

#:>>0>>4:9�� ,9@1,.?@=0���0,7492�49���.<@4>4?4:9�:=

�4>;:>4?4:9��:1��4=0,=8>���88@94?4:9�:=��C;7:>4A0>��

,>�,9�,22=,A,?492 .4=.@8>?,9.0

,96 FD6 @7 2? F?=:46?D65 7:C62C> E@ 4@>>:E >FC56C @C 9@>:4:56 :D 2?288C2G2E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46 6?46� :==682= A@DD6DD:@? @C FD6 @7 F?=:46?D65 7:C62C> :D ?@�=@?86CAF?:D965 2D 2 D6A2C2E6 @776?D6�

�=E9@F89� E96� 4:C4F>DE2?46� E92E� 9F>2?� =:76� H2D� 56DEC@J65� H:E9� E96� FD6� @7� 2?F?=:46?D65� 7:C62C>� :D� ?@E� 288C2G2E:?8� F?56C� �CE� ���� *(��� :E� >2J� DE:==� 36� E2<6?� :?E@4@?D:56C2E:@?� E@� :?4C62D6� E96�A6?2=EJ�3642FD6�@7� E96� 6IA=:4:E� AC@G:D:@?D�@7� E96�(C6D:56?E:2=�64C66�&@������ 2D�2>6?565�3J�*��� ��

*� � ���A6?2=:K6D� D:>A=6� :==682=�A@DD6DD:@?�@7� 7:C62C>D��AC@G:565� E92E� E96�A6CD@?2CC6DE65�4@>>:EE65�?@�@E96C�4C:>6��FCE96C>@C6��:7�E96�A6CD@?�:D�96=5�=:23=6�7@C�>FC56C�@C9@>:4:56�� :==682=� A@DD6DD:@?� @7� 7:C62C>D� :D� 2?� 288C2G2E:?8� 4:C4F>DE2?46�� 3FE� ?@E� 2� D6A2C2E6@776?D6��

-?56C� +64� �� E96C6@7�� H96?� 2� A6CD@?� 4@>>:ED� 2?J� @7� E96� 4C:>6D� 567:?65� :?� E96*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56�@C�DA64:2=�=2HD�H:E9�E96�FD6�@7�6IA=@D:G6D�=:<6�A:==�3@I��>@E@=@G�4@4<E2:=3@>3D��7:C63@>3D�@C�@E96C�:?46?5:2CJ�56G:46D�H9:49�C6DF=E�:?�E96 562E9�@7�2�A6CD@?��DF49�FD6D92==�36�4@?D:56C65 2D�2?�288C2G2E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46

��2>;D J>;H; ?I CEH; J>7D ED; GK7B?<O?D= 7==H7L7J?D= 9?H9KCIJ7D9; FH;I;DJ� ED; E< J>;C M?BB 8;

7FFH;9?7J;: 7I GK7B?<O?D= 7==H7L7J?D= M>?B; J>; EJ>;HI M?BB 8; 9EDI?:;H;: 7I =;D;H?9 7==H7L7J?D=� +�� �����7I�7C;D:;:�8O�-������

��$<� � J>;� � ?BB;=7B� � FEII;II?ED� � EH� � KI;� � E<� KDB?9;DI;:� � <?H;7HC� �EH� � ;NFBEI?L;I� � ?I� � ?D� <KHJ>;H7D9;� � E<�� � EH

?D9?:;DJ� � JE�� �EH� � ?D� 9EDD;9J?ED� �M?J>� � J>;� � 9H?C;I� �E<� � H;8;BB?ED�� ?DIKHH;9J?ED�� �EH� � IK8L;HI?ED� � I>7BB� �8;

78IEH8;:�7I�7D�;B;C;DJ�E<�IK9>�9H?C;I

+;D7BJO��<EH��C;H;��FEII;II?ED��E<��7D�KDB?9;DI;:��<?H;7HC��?I��87I;:��ED��M>;J>;H�J>;��<?H;7HC��?I��BEM

FEM;H;:��EH��>?=>FEM;H;:

0DB?9;DI;:��<?H;7HC��I>7BB� � ?D9BK:;�� � <?H;7HCI�M?J>� �;NF?H;:� � B?9;DI;�� �EH�KD7KJ>EH?P;:� �KI;�E<� � B?9;DI;:

<?H;7HC��?D��J>;��9ECC?II?ED��E<�J>;�9H?C;��#;D9;��M>;H;�7D�799KI;:�M7I�9EDL?9J;:�E<�:?H;9J�7II7KBJ�M?J>�CKBJ?FB;�7JJ;CFJ;:�>EC?9?:;�<EH�<?H?D=�7D

KDB?9;DI;:�( ��H?<B;�7J�I;L;H7B�FEB?9;C;D�M>E�M;H;�78EKJ�JE�I;HL;�7 I;7H9>�M7HH7DJ��>;�97DDEJ�8;�>;B:

=K?BJO�E<�J>;�I;F7H7J;�E<<;DI;�E<�?BB;=7B�FEII;II?ED�E<�<?H;7HCI���'12.'�85� �#&,##/.#/�

Page 16: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

-� '30��:8;=0309>4A0��,920=:@>��=@2>��.?�:1�����

4� �>�,�<@,741D492�,22=,A,?492�.4=.@8>?,9.0

� A@D:E:G6�7:?5:?8�7@C�E96�FD6�@7�52?86C@FD�5CF8D�D92==�36�2�BF2=:7J:?8 288C2G2E:?84:C4F>DE2?46�:?�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�2�4C:>6�3J�2?�@776?56C��2?5�E96�2AA=:42E:@?�@7�E96�A6?2=EJAC@G:565�7@C�:?�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56�D92==�36�2AA=:423=6��

44� �88@94?D� 1=:8� ;=:>0.@?4:9� ,9/� ;@94>3809?�

.:A0=,20

�?J�A6CD@?�H9@�92D� G:@=2E65� +64E:@?D� ��� ���� � �� ���� ���� 2?5� �����CE:4=6� !!� @7� E9:D�4E��� H9@�G@=F?E2C:=J�8:G6D�:?7@C>2E:@?�23@FE�2?J�G:@=2E:@?�@7�+64E:@?D���������������������2?5�����CE:4=6�!!�@7�E9:D��4E�� 2D�H6==�2D�2?J�G:@=2E:@?�@7�E96�@776?D6D�>6?E:@?65�:7�4@>>:EE65�3J2�5CF8�DJ?5:42E6� @C�2?J�:?7@C>2E:@?�=625:?8�E@�E96�H96C623@FED��:56?E:E:6D�2?5�2CC6DE�@7�2==�@C2?J� @7� E96�>6>36CD� E96C6@7�� 2?5�H9@�H:==:?8=J� E6DE:7:6D� 282:?DE� DF49� A6CD@?D� 2D� 56D4C:36523@G6��D92==�36�6I6>AE65�7C@>�AC@D64FE:@?�@C�AF?:D9>6?E�7@C�E96�@776?D6�H:E9�C676C6?46 E@H9:49�9:D96C� :?7@C>2E:@?�@7� E6DE:>@?J�H6C6�8:G6?��2?5�>2J�A=625�@C�AC@G6� E96�8:G:?8�@7DF49�:?7@C>2E:@?�2?5�E6DE:>@?J�:?�32C�@7�DF49�AC@D64FE:@?

�@?5:E:@?D�

���,96� :?7@C>2E:@?� 2?5� E6DE:>@?J� 2C6� ?646DD2CJ� 7@C� E96� 4@?G:4E:@?� @7� E96�A6CD@?D56D4C:365 23@G6�

��+F49�:?7@C>2E:@?�2?5�E6DE:>@?J�2C6�?@E�J6E�:?�E96�A@DD6DD:@?�@7�E96�+E2E6�

���+F49�:?7@C>2E:@?�2?5�E6DE:>@?J�42?�36�4@CC@3@C2E65�@?�:ED�>2E6C:2=�A@:?ED�

���E96�:?7@C>2?E�@C�H:E?6DD�92D�?@E�366?�AC6G:@FD=J�4@?G:4E65�@7�2�4C:>6�:?G@=G:?8>@C2= EFCA:EF56��6I46AE�H96?�E96C6�:D�?@�@E96C�5:C64E�6G:56?46�2G2:=23=6�7@C�E96�+E2E6�@E96CE92?�E96�:?7@C>2E:@?�2?5�E6DE:>@?J�@7�D2:5�:?7@C>2?E�@C�H:E?6DD��2?5

���,96� :?7@C>2?E� @C�H:E?6DD� D92==� DEC:4E=J� 2?5� 72:E97F==J� 4@>A=J�H:E9@FE� 56=2J�� 2?J4@?5:E:@?� @C� F?56CE2<:?8�� C65F465� :?E@� HC:E:?8�� =2H7F==J� :>A@D65� 3J� E96� +E2E6� 2D� 7FCE96C4@?D:56C2E:@?�7@C�E96�8C2?E�@7�:>>F?:EJ�7C@>�AC@D64FE:@?�2?5�AF?:D9>6?E

,96 :>>F?:EJ�>2J�36�6?;@J65�3J�DF49�:?7@C>2?E�@C�H:E?6DD�H9@�5@6D�?@E�2AA62C�E@36�>@DE� 8F:=EJ� 7@C� E96� @776?D6 H:E9� C676C6?46� E@� H9:49� 9:D96C� :?7@C>2E:@?� @C� E6DE:>@?JH6C6�8:G6?�2?5 E96C6�:D�?@�5:C64E�6G:56?46�2G2:=23=6�7@C�E96�+E2E6�6I46AE�7@C�E96�:?7@C>2E:@?2?5�E6DE:>@?J�@7�E96�D2:5�:?7@C>2?E�@C�H:E?6DD��

��-��� ��

��.;9���

��.;;�-;<;H;D9;

��?8?:

��.;9���

Page 17: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

444� 49:=�:1109/0=>

�?�244FD65�H9@�:D�@G6C�7:7E66?������J62CD�@7�286�2E�E96�E:>6�@7�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�E96@776?D6�>6?E:@?65�:?�+64E:@?����� @7�E9:D��4E��3FE�?@E�>@C6�E92?�6:89E66?������J62CD�@7�2862E�E96�E:>6�H96?�;F58>6?E�D9@F=5�92G6�366?�AC@>F=82E65�27E6C�92G:?8�366?�7@F?5�8F:=EJ�@7D2:5�@776?D6��>2J�36�8:G6?�E96�36?67:ED�@7�2�DFDA6?565�D6?E6?46

�@?5:E:@?D�

2�� 6D96�92D�?@E�366?�AC6G:@FD=J�4@?G:4E65�@7�G:@=2E:?8�2?J�AC@G:D:@?�@7�E9:D��4E�@C�@7�E96��2?86C@FD��CF8D��4E�@7���� ��2D�2>6?565��@C�@7�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56��@C�@72?J�DA64:2=�A6?2=�=2HD�

3�� 6D96�92D�?@E�366?�AC6G:@FD=J�4@>>:EE65�E@�2��6?E6C�@C�E@�E96�42C6�@7�2��' �244C65:E65�A9JD:4:2?��2?5

4��,96��@2C5�72G@C23=J�C64@>>6?5D�E92E�9:D96C�D6?E6?46�36�DFDA6?565

/9:=6� F?56C� DFDA6?565� D6?E6?46�� 96D96� D92==� 36� F?56C� E96� DFA6CG:D:@?� 2?5C6923:=:E2E:G6�DFCG6:==2?46�@7�E96��@2C5��F?56C�DF49�4@?5:E:@?D�E92E�E96�4@FCE�>2J�:>A@D6�7@C2�A6C:@5�C2?8:?8�7C@>�D:I�����>@?E9D�E@�6:89E66?������>@?E9D

-A@?� C64@>>6?52E:@?� @7� E96� �@2C5�� E96� 4@FCE� >2J� 4@>>:E� E96� 244FD65� F?56CDFDA6?565�D6?E6?46�E@�2��6?E6C��@C�E@�E96�42C6�@7�2��' �244C65:E65�A9JD:4:2?�7@C�2E�=62DE�D:I����>@?E9D��H:E9�27E6C�42C6�2?5�7@==@H�FA�AC@8C2>�7@C�?@E�>@C6�E92?�6:89E66?������>@?E9D

!?�E96�42D6�@7�>:?@CD�F?56C�7:7E66?������J62CD�@7�286�2E�E96�E:>6�@7�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@72?J� @776?D6� A6?2=:K65� F?56C� E9:D� �4E�� �CE:4=6� �� �� @7� (C6D:56?E:2=� �64C66� &@� ����@E96CH:D6�<?@H?�2D�E96��9:=5�2?5�1@FE9�/6=72C6��@56��2D�2>6?565�3J�(C6D:56?E:2=��64C66&@����� D92==�2AA=J��H:E9@FE�AC6;F5:46�E@�E96�2AA=:42E:@?�@7�E96�AC@G:D:@?D�@7�E9:D�+64E:@?��

4A� �;;74.,?4:9�!:9�,;;74.,?4:9�:1�%#��;=:A4>4:9>

.1���=?���� %#�

,96� AC@G:D:@?D� @7� E96� *6G:D65� (6?2=� �@56�� 2D� 2>6?565�� D92==� ?@E� 2AA=J� E@� E96AC@G:D:@?D�@7�E9:D��4E��6I46AE�:?�E96�42D6�@7�>:?@C�@776?56CD�/96C6�E96�@776?56C�:D�2�>:?@C�E96� A6?2=EJ� 7@C� 24ED� AF?:D923=6� 3J� =:76� :>AC:D@?>6?E� E@� 562E9� AC@G:565� 96C6:?� D92==� 362%#,53)/.�0%20%45! E@�562E9��

��.;;�-;<;H;D9;

��$8?:

� .;9���

��.;;�-;<;H;D9;

��.;9���

Page 18: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

0� �7?0=9,?4A0��4=.@8>?,9.0>��

,9@D6 H9:49 >FDE 36 E2<6? :?E@ 4@?D:56C2E:@? 2D 288C2G2E:?8�@C�>:E:82E:?8�244@C5:?8E@�E96�?2EFC6�2?5�67764ED�@7�E96�4C:>6�2?5�@E96C�4@?5:E:@?D�2EE6?5:?8�:ED�4@>>:DD:@?

1� �->:7@?:=D��,@>0

�� 4:C4F>DE2?46 H9:49� :D� AC6D6?E� AC:@C� E@� @C� D:>F=E2?6@FD=J� H:E9� E96� @776?D6�� 3JC62D@?�@7�H9:49��E96�244FD65�H9@�24ED�H:E9�4C:>:?2=�:?E6?E��7C665@>��2?5�:?E6==:86?46��5@6D?@E�:?4FC�4C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ�7@C�2?�24E��H9:49�4@?DE:EFE65�2�4C:>6

!E :D�AC6D6?E��H96C6�E96�24E�4@>>:EE65�:D�2�4C:>6�3FE�7@C�C62D@?D�@7�AF3=:4�A@=:4J�2?5D6?E:>6?E�E96C6�:D�?@�A6?2=EJ�:>A@D65P��

��.;;�-;<;H;D9;

��$�-;O;I��/>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:;�� �J>�;:�� �����FF��� ���

�HJ?9B;�����?I�7D�;N7CFB;�E<�7D�78IEBKJEHO�97KI; �I;;�-;<;H;D9;�

Page 19: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

��$1>?;:?��>595:-88E� 5-.81��13>11�;2�$->@5/5<-@5;:

,� �0.=00�#09,74E492�"->?=@.?4:9�:1��;;=0309>4:9�,9/�#=:>0.@?4:9�:1

�=4849,7�"1109/0=>��

4� #@94>3,-70�,.?>

�?J�A6CD@? H9@�<?@H:?8=J�@C�H:==7F==J�@3DECF4ED�� :>A656D�� 7CFDEC2E6D�@C�56=2JD� E962AAC696?D:@?� @7� DFDA64ED� 2?5� E96� :?G6DE:82E:@?� 2?5� AC@D64FE:@?� @7� 4C:>:?2=� 42D6D� 3J4@>>:EE:?8�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

�2��AC6G6?E:?8�H:E?6DD6D�7C@>�E6DE:7J:?8�:?�2?J�4C:>:?2=�AC@4665:?8�@C�7C@>�C6A@CE:?8E96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @7� 2?J� @776?D6� @C� E96� :56?E:EJ� @7� 2?J� @776?56CD� 3J� >62?D� @7� 3C:36CJ�>:DC6AC6D6?E2E:@?��5646:E��:?E:>:52E:@?��7@C46�@C�E9C62ED�

�3�� 2=E6C:?8�� 56DEC@J:?8�� DFAAC6DD:?8�@C� 4@?462=:?8�2?J�A2A6C�� C64@C5�� 5@4F>6?E�� @C@3;64E��H:E9� :?E6?E�E@� :>A2:C� :ED�G6C:EJ��2FE96?E:4:EJ�� =68:3:=:EJ��2G2:=23:=:EJ��@C�25>:DD:3:=:EJ�2D6G:56?46�:?�2?J�:?G6DE:82E:@?�@7�@C�@77:4:2=�AC@4665:?8D�:?��4C:>:?2=�42D6D��@C�E@�36�FD65�:?�E96:?G6DE:82E:@?�@7��@C�@77:4:2=�AC@4665:?8D�:?��4C:>:?2=�42D6D�

�4��92C3@C:?8�@C�4@?462=:?8��@C�724:=:E2E:?8�E96�6D42A6�@7��2?J�A6CD@?�96�<?@HD��@C�92DC62D@?23=6� 8C@F?5� E@� 36=:6G6� @C� DFDA64E�� 92D� 4@>>:EE65� 2?J� @776?D6� F?56C� 6I:DE:?8� A6?2==2HD�:?�@C56C�E@�AC6G6?E�9:D�2CC6DE�AC@D64FE:@?�2?5�4@?G:4E:@?�

�5��AF3=:4=J� FD:?8� 2� 7:4E:E:@FD�?2>6� 7@C� E96�AFCA@D6�@7� 4@?462=:?8�2� 4C:>6�� 6G25:?8AC@D64FE:@?�@C�E96�6I64FE:@?�@7�2�;F58>6?E��@C�4@?462=:?8�9:D�ECF6�?2>6�2?5�@E96C�A6CD@?2=4:C4F>DE2?46D�7@C�E96�D2>6�AFCA@D6�@C�AFCA@D6D�

�6��56=2J:?8�E96�AC@D64FE:@?�@7�4C:>:?2=�42D6D�3J�@3DECF4E:?8�E96�D6CG:46�@7�AC@46DD�@C4@FCE�@C56CD�@C�5:DEFC3:?8�AC@4665:?8D�:?�E96�7:D42=�D�@77:46D��:?�,2?@532J2?��@C�:?�E96�4@FCED�

�7�� >2<:?8�� AC6D6?E:?8� @C� FD:?8� 2?J� C64@C5�� 5@4F>6?E�� A2A6C� @C� @3;64E� H:E9<?@H=6586�@7�:ED�72=D:EJ�2?5�H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�27764E�E96�4@FCD6�@C�@FE4@>6�@7�E96�:?G6DE:82E:@?@7��@C�@77:4:2=�AC@4665:?8D�:?��4C:>:?2=�42D6D�

�8�� D@=:4:E:?8�� 2446AE:?8�� @C� 28C66:?8� E@� 2446AE� 2?J� 36?67:E� :?� 4@?D:56C2E:@?� @723DE2:?:?8�7C@>��5:D4@F?E:?8��@C�:>A65:?8�E96�AC@D64FE:@?�@7�2�4C:>:?2=�@776?56C�

�9�� E9C62E6?:?8�5:C64E=J�@C� :?5:C64E=J� 2?@E96C�H:E9� E96� :?7=:4E:@?�@7�2?J�HC@?8�FA@?9:D�A6CD@?��9@?@C�@C�AC@A6CEJ�@C�E92E�@7�2?J�:>>65:2E6�>6>36C�@C�>6>36CD�@7�9:D�72>:=J�:?@C56C�E@�AC6G6?E�DF49�A6CD@?�7C@>�2AA62C:?8�:?�E96�:?G6DE:82E:@?�@7��@C�@77:4:2=�AC@4665:?8D:?��4C:>:?2=�42D6D��@C�:>A@D:?8�2�4@?5:E:@?��H96E96C�=2H7F=�@C�F?=2H7F=��:?�@C56C�E@�AC6G6?E�2A6CD@?�7C@>�2AA62C:?8�:?�E96�:?G6DE:82E:@?�@7�@C�:?�@77:4:2=�AC@4665:?8D�:?��4C:>:?2=�42D6D�

�:�� 8:G:?8� @7� 72=D6� @C� 723C:42E65� :?7@C>2E:@?� E@� >:D=625� @C� AC6G6?E� E96� =2H6?7@C46>6?E� 286?4:6D� 7C@>� 2AAC696?5:?8� E96� @776?56C� @C� 7C@>� AC@E64E:?8� E96� =:76� @C

��+�� ���

Page 20: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

AC@A6CEJ�@7�E96�G:4E:>��@C�723C:42E:?8� :?7@C>2E:@?�7C@>�E96�52E2�82E96C65� :?�4@?7:56?46�3J:?G6DE:82E:?8� 2FE9@C:E:6D� 7@C� AFCA@D6D� @7� 324<8C@F?5� :?7@C>2E:@?� 2?5� ?@E� 7@C� AF3=:42E:@?2?5�AF3=:D9:?8�@C�5:DD6>:?2E:?8�E96�D2>6�E@�>:D=625�E96 :?G6DE:82E@C�@C�E@�E96�4@FCE

!7� 2?J� @7� E96� 24ED� >6?E:@?65� 96C6:?� :D� A6?2=:K65� 3J� 2?J� @E96C� =2H� H:E9� 2� 9:896CA6?2=EJ��E96�9:896C�A6?2=EJ�D92==�36�:>A@D65��

44���:8;,=0�B4?3��=?4.70����� %#�

,96�A6?2=E:6D�AC6D4C:365� 7@C� 2446DD@C:6D� D92==� ?@E�36� :>A@D65�FA@?� E9@D6�H9@� 2C6DF49�H:E9�C6DA64E�E@�E96:C�DA@FD6D��2D46?52?ED��56D46?52?ED��=68:E:>2E6��?2EFC2=��2?5�25@AE653C@E96CD� 2?5� D:DE6CD�� @C� C6=2E:G6D� 3J� 277:?:EJ� H:E9:?� E96� D2>6� 568C66D� 6I46AE 2446DD@C:6D72==:?8�H:E9:?�E96�AC@G:D:@?D�@7�A2C28C2A9���� @7 �CE:4=6�����*(�

��.;9� ��?:

���99;IIEH?;I�M>E�7H;�;N;CFJ�<HEC�9H?C?D7B�B?78?B?JO

�7I?I� /?;I�E<�8BEE:�7D:�J>;�FH;I;HL7J?ED�E<�J>;�9B;7DB?D;II�E<�ED;YI�D7C;�M>?9>�9ECF;BI�ED;�JE�9ED9;7B

9H?C;I�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�H;B7J?L;I�IE�D;7H�7I�J>EI;�C;DJ?ED;:

);F>;M�7D:�)?;9;�DEJ�?D9BK:;:

�99;IIEHO� DEJ� ;N;CFJ M>;D� >;BF;:� 7� H;B7J?L;FH?D9?F7B� 8O� FHE<?J?D=� <HEC� J>;� ;<<;9JI� E<� J>;� 9H?C;�� EH

7II?IJ;:�J>;�E<<;D:;H�JE�FHE<?J�<HEC�J>;�;<<;9JI�E<�J>;�9H?C;

*DBO�799;IIEH?;I�9EL;H;:�8O�F7H���7D:���7H;�;N;CFJ;:

+K8B?9� E<<?9;H� M>E� >;BF;:� >?I� =K?BJO� 8HEJ>;H� ;I97F;� :E;I� DEJ� ?D9KH� 9H?C?D7B� B?78?B?JO� 7I� J?;I� E< 8BEE:

9EDIJ?JKJ;I�7�CEH;�FEM;H<KB�?D9;DJ?L;�J>7D�J>;�97BB�E<�:KJO��.;;�-;<;H;D9;

Page 21: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

���$1:-8@51?

(6?2=EJ�:D�E96�AF?:D9>6?E�:>A@D65�3J�=2H7F=�2FE9@C:EJ�FA@?�2�A6CD@?�H9@�4@>>:ED2?�F?=2H7F=��56=:36C2E6�@C�?68=:86?E�24E��

2� �090=,7�#=49.4;70> � �.? #=:34-4?492�?30��8;:>4?4:9�:1��0,?3�#09,7?D�49

?30�#3474;;490>��

,96�:>A@D:E:@?�@7�562E9�A6?2=EJ�92D�366?�AC@9:3:E65�(FCDF2?E�E@�+64E:@?� @7�*�������E96�AC@A6CEJ�A6?2=EJ�E@�36�:>A@D65�@?�2AA6==2?E�:D 2%#,53)/.�0%20%45!�*� �����D9@F=536�2AA=:65�6G6? :7�E96�4C:>6�H2D�4@>>:EE65�AC:@C�E@�E96�6?24E>6?E�@7�E96�=2H�:?�G:6H�@7�E96AC:?4:A=6� :?�4C:>:?2=� =2H�E92E &!6/2!"),)!� 35.4�!-0,)!.$!�!$)/3!�2%342)'%.$!�(6?2=� =2HD�H9:49�2C672G@C23=6�E@�E96�244FD65�2C6�8:G6?�C6EC@24E:G6�67764E�

-� #@=;:>0>

� �6E6CC6?46 � E@�AC6G6?E�4C:>6D

*6EC:3FE:@? � E@�AF?:D9�E96>�7@C�H92E�E96J�5:5

��*6923:=:E2E:@? � E@�86E�E96>�H9:AA65�324<�:?E@�D92A6

��+276EJ � E@�AC@E64E�E96�AF3=:4�7C@>�52?86C@FD�4C:>:?2=D

���'12.'�85���14#0�����+>?B���

� -������

�����8���#0761��"-�)E� ����������%KBO�����������.�-����������

Page 22: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

.� �7,>>414.,?4:9

+42=6

(C:?4:A2=�(6?2=E:6D �446DD@CJ�(6?2=E:6D

�2A:E2=�AF?:D9>6?E�

�62E9

(6CA6EF2=�@C�E6>A@C2CJ�23D@=FE65:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�

(6CA6EF2=�@C�E6>A@C2CJ�DA64:2=5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�

+FDA6?D:@?�7C@>�AF3=:4�@77:46��E96C:89E�E@�G@E6�2?5�36�G@E65�7@C��E96�AC@76DD:@?@C����42==:?8

�:G:=�:?E6C5:4E:@?�

!?56>?:7:42E:@?�

�@C76:EFC6�@C�4@?7:D42E:@?�@7:?DECF>6?ED�2?5�AC@4665D�@7�E96�@776?D6�

(2J>6?E�@7�4@DED��

�77=:4E:G6�A6?2=E:6D�

�%#,53)/.�0%20%45!��%#,53)/.�4%-0/2!,�(6CA6EF2=�@C�E6>A@C2CJ�23D@=FE6

5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�(6CA6EF2=�@C�E6>A@C2CJ�DA64:2=

5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?��2)3)/.�-!9/2�

�@CC64E:@?2=�A6?2=E:6D�

�2)3)/.�#/22%##)/.!,��22%34/�-!9/2�+FDA6?D:@?��%34)%22/�

$:89E�A6?2=E:6D�

�22%34/�-%./2�(F3=:4�46?DFC6

(6?2=E:6D�4@>>@?�E@�E96�E9C66 AC6465:?84=2DD6D�

�:?6��2?5�@?5�E@�<66A�E96�A6246

���HJ���

Page 23: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

5� �FC2E:@?�2?5��7764ED

�FC2E:@?

�%#,53)/.�0%20%45! ,H6?EJ� � ���J62CD�2?5�@?6�52J� E@� 7@CEJ� ����J62CD

�%#,53)/.�4%-0/2!, ,H6=G6��� ��J62CD�2?5 @?6�52J�E@�EH6?EJ�� ��J62CD

�2)3)/.�-!9/2 2?5 4%-0/2!29�$)315!,)&)#!4)/. +:I�����J62CD�2?5�@?6�52J�E@�EH6=G6��� ��J62CD�6I46AE�H96?�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�:D:>A@D65� 2D� 2?� 2446DD@CJ� A6?2=EJ�� :?� H9:4942D6�� :ED� 5FC2E:@?� D92==� 36� E92E� @7� E96AC:?4:A2=�A6?2=EJ

�2)3)/.�#/22%##)/.!,� DFDA6?D:@?��2?5 $%34)%22/ +:I� ����>@?E9D�2?5�@?6�52J� E@�D:I� ����J62CD�6I46AE� H96?� DFDA6?D:@?� :D� :>A@D65� 2D� 2?2446DD@CJ�A6?2=EJ��:?�H9:49�42D6��:ED�5FC2E:@?D92==�36�E92E�@7�E96�AC:?4:A2=�A6?2=EJ

�22%34/ -!9/2 '?6� ���� >@?E9� 2?5� @?6� 52J� E@� D:I� ���>@?E9D

�22%34/�-%./2 '?6�����52J�E@�E9:CEJ������52JD

�@?5�E@�<66A�E96�A6246 *6BF:C65�E@�4@G6C�DF49�A6C:@5�@7�E:>6�2D�E964@FCE�>2J�56E6C>:?6��

���HJ�����?8?:�7I 7C;D:;:�8O�.;9�� ��-�� ����

Page 24: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�7764ED

,96� A6?2=E:6D� @7� A6CA6EF2=� @C� E6>A@C2CJ� 23D@=FE6� 5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?� 7@C� AF3=:4� @77:46D92==�AC@5F46�E96�7@==@H:?8�67764ED�

��,96�56AC:G2E:@?�@7� E96�AF3=:4�@77:46D�2?5�6>A=@J>6?ED�H9:49� E96�@776?56C�>2J92G6�96=5�6G6?�:7�4@?76CC65�3J�A@AF=2C�6=64E:@?

,96�56AC:G2E:@?�@7�E96�C:89E�E@�G@E6�:?�2?J�6=64E:@?�7@C�2?J�A@AF=2C�6=64E:G6�@77:46@C�E@�36�6=64E65�E@�DF49�@77:46

� ,96�5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�7@C�E96�@77:46D�@C�AF3=:4�6>A=@J>6?ED�2?5�7@C�E96�6I6C4:D6�@72?J�@7�E96�C:89ED�>6?E:@?65

!?� 42D6� @7� E6>A@C2CJ� 5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�� DF49� 5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?� 2D� :D� 4@>AC:D65� :?A2C28C2A9D� �2?5���@7�E9:D�2CE:4=6�D92==�=2DE�5FC:?8�E96�E6C>�@7�E96�D6?E6?46

� ,96� =@DD�@7�2==� C:89ED� E@� C6E:C6>6?E�A2J�@C�@E96C�A6?D:@?�7@C�2?J�@77:46� 7@C>6C=J96=5��

,96� A6?2=E:6D� @7� A6CA6EF2= @C� E6>A@C2CJ� DA64:2=� 5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?� 7@C� AF3=:4� @77:46�AC@76DD:@?�@C�42==:?8�D92==�AC@5F46�E96�7@==@H:?8�67764ED�

��,96�56AC:G2E:@?�@7�E96�@77:46��6>A=@J>6?E��AC@76DD:@?�@C�42==:?8�27764E65�

�,96�5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�7@C�9@=5:?8�D:>:=2C�@77:46D�@C�6>A=@J>6?ED�6:E96C�A6CA6EF2==J@C�5FC:?8�E96�E6C>�@7�E96�D6?E6?46��244@C5:?8�E@�E96�6IE6?E�@7�DF49�5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?��

,96�A6CA6EF2=� @C� E6>A@C2CJ� DA64:2=� 5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?� 7@C� E96� 6I6C4:D6�@7� E96� C:89E�@7DF77C286�D92==�56AC:G6�E96�@776?56C�A6CA6EF2==J�@C�5FC:?8�E96�E6C>�@7�E96�D6?E6?46��244@C5:?8E@�E96�?2EFC6�@7�D2:5�A6?2=EJ��@7�E96�C:89E�E@�G@E6�:?�2?J�A@AF=2C�6=64E:@?�7@C�2?J�AF3=:4�@77:46@C�E@�36�6=64E65�E@�DF49�@77:46�%@C6@G6C�� E96�@776?56C�D92==�?@E�36�A6C>:EE65�E@�9@=5�2?JAF3=:4�@77:46�5FC:?8�E96�A6C:@5�@7�9:D�5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?��

,96�DFDA6?D:@?�7C@>�AF3=:4�@77:46��AC@76DD:@?�@C�42==:?8��2?5�E96�6I6C4:D6�@7�E96�C:89E@7� DF77C286� D92==� 5:DBF2=:7J� E96� @776?56C� 7C@>� 9@=5:?8� DF49� @77:46� @C� 6I6C4:D:?8� DF49AC@76DD:@?�@C�42==:?8�@C�C:89E�@7�DF77C286�5FC:?8�E96�E6C>�@7�E96�D6?E6?46

,96� A6CD@?� DFDA6?565� 7C@>� 9@=5:?8� AF3=:4� @77:46� D92==� ?@E� 9@=5� 2?@E96C� 92G:?8D:>:=2C�7F?4E:@?D�5FC:?8�E96�A6C:@5�@7�9:D�DFDA6?D:@?��

�:G:=� :?E6C5:4E:@?� D92==� 56AC:G6� E96�@776?56C�5FC:?8� E96� E:>6�@7�9:D� D6?E6?46�@7� E96C:89ED�@7�A2C6?E2=�2FE9@C:EJ��@C�8F2C5:2?D9:A��6:E96C�2D�E@�E96�A6CD@?�@C�AC@A6CEJ�@7�2?J�H2C5�

���HJ���

���HJ��

���HJ���

���HJ���

Page 25: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

@7�>2C:E2=�2FE9@C:EJ��@7�E96�C:89E�E@�>2?286�9:D�AC@A6CEJ�2?5�@7�E96�C:89E�E@�5:DA@D6�@7�DF49AC@A6CEJ�3J�2?J�24E�@C�2?J�4@?G6J2?46 ).4%2�6)6/3��

�� A2C5@?� D92==� ?@E�H@C<� E96� C6DE@C2E:@?� @7� E96� C:89E� E@� 9@=5� AF3=:4� @77:46�� @C� E96C:89E�@7�DF77C286��F?=6DD�DF49�C:89ED�36�6IAC6DD=J�C6DE@C65�3J�E96�E6C>D�@7�E96�A2C5@?��

��A2C5@?�D92==�:?�?@�42D6�6I6>AE�E96�4F=AC:E�7C@>�E96�A2J>6?E�@7�E96�4:G:=�:?56>?:EJ:>A@D65�FA@?�9:>�3J�E96�D6?E6?46

�@DED� D92==� :?4=F56� 766D� 2?5� :?56>?:E:6D� :?� E96� 4@FCD6� @7� E96� ;F5:4:2=� AC@4665:?8D�H96E96C�E96J�36�7:I65�@C�F?2=E6C23=6�2>@F?ED�AC6G:@FD=J�56E6C>:?65�3J�=2H�@C�C68F=2E:@?D�:?7@C46��@C�2>@F?ED�?@E�DF3;64E�E@�D4965F=6��

!?�42D6�E96�AC@A6CEJ�@7�E96�@776?56C�D9@F=5�?@E�36�DF77:4:6?E�7@C�E96�A2J>6?E�@7�2==9:D�A64F?:2CJ�=:23:=:E:6D��E96�D2>6�D92==�36�>6E�:?�E96�7@==@H:?8�@C56C��

��,96�C6A2C2E:@?�@7�E96�52>286�42FD65 �!?56>?:7:42E:@?�@7�4@?D6BF6?E:2=�52>286D��,96�7:?6��,96�4@DED�@7�E96�AC@4665:?8D

!7� E96�4@?G:4E�92D�?@�AC@A6CEJ�H:E9�H9:49� E@�>66E� E96� 7:?6�>6?E:@?65��96�D92==�36DF3;64E�E@�2�DF3D:5:2CJ�A6CD@?2=�=:23:=:EJ�2E�E96�C2E6�@7�@?6�52J�7@C�6249�6:89E�A6D@D��DF3;64E�E@E96�7@==@H:?8�CF=6D�

�� !7� E96� AC:?4:A2=� A6?2=EJ� :>A@D65�36 02)3)/.� #/22%##)/.!, @C !22%34/ 2?5� 7:?6�� 96� D92==C6>2:?�F?56C�4@?7:?6>6?E�F?E:=�9:D�7:?6�C676CC65�:?�E96�AC6465:?8�A2C28C2A9�:D�D2E:D7:65��3FE9:D�DF3D:5:2CJ�:>AC:D@?>6?E�D92==�?@E�6I4665�@?6�E9:C5�@7�E96�E6C>�@7�E96�D6?E6?46��2?5�:??@ 42D6�D92==� :E�4@?E:?F6� 7@C�>@C6�E92?�@?6�J62C��2?5�?@�7C24E:@?�@C�A2CE�@7�2�52J�D92==�364@F?E65�282:?DE�E96�AC:D@?6C

�/96?�E96�AC:?4:A2=�A6?2=EJ� :>A@D65�36�@?=J�2�7:?6�� E96�DF3D:5:2CJ� :>AC:D@?>6?ED92==� ?@E� 6I4665� D:I�>@?E9D�� :7� E96� 4F=AC:E� D92==� 92G6 366?� AC@D64FE65� 7@C� 2� 8C2G6� @C� =6DD8C2G6�76=@?J��2?5�D92==�?@E�6I4665�7:7E66?�52JD��:7�7@C�2�=:89E�76=@?J

��/96?�E96�AC:?4:A2=�A6?2=EJ�:>A@D65�:D�9:896C�E92? 02)3)/.�#/22%##)/.!, ?@�DF3D:5:2CJ:>AC:D@?>6?E�D92==�36�:>A@D65�FA@?�E96�4F=AC:E

��!7�E96�AC:?4:A2=�A6?2=EJ�:>A@D65�:D�?@E�E@�36�6I64FE65�3J�4@?7:?6>6?E�:?�2�A6?2=:?DE:EFE:@?�� 3FE� DF49� A6?2=EJ� :D� @7� 7:I65� 5FC2E:@?�� E96� 4@?G:4E�� 5FC:?8� E96� A6C:@5� @7� E:>66DE23=:D965�:?�E96�AC6465:?8�CF=6D��D92==�4@?E:?F6�E@�DF776C�E96�D2>6�56AC:G2E:@?�2D�E9@D6�@7H9:49�E96�AC:?4:A2=�A6?2=EJ�4@?D:DED

���HJ���

���HJ���

� �HJ���

���HJ���

Page 26: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

��,96�DF3D:5:2CJ�A6CD@?2=�=:23:=:EJ�H9:49�E96�4@?G:4E�>2J�92G6�DF776C65�3J�C62D@?�@79:D�:?D@=G6?4J�D92==�?@E�C6=:6G6�9:>�7C@>�E96�7:?6�:?�42D6�9:D�7:?2?4:2=�4:C4F>DE2?46D�D9@F=5:>AC@G6��

0� �;;74.,?4:9

4� �9/0?0=849,?0�&09?09.0��,B��

�@G6C?D�H96E96C�E96�4C:>6�:D�AF?:D923=6�F?56C�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56�@C�2�DA64:2=$2H !E�:D�?@E�=:>:E65�E@�G:@=2E:@?D�@7�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56

!E�2AA=:6D�@?=J�H96?� E96�A6?2=EJ�D6CG65� :D� :>AC:D@?>6?E !7�?@E�3J :>AC:D@?>6?E�E96?�:E�5@6D�?@E�2AA=J

,� �;;74.,?4:9�:9�?30�48;:>0/�>09?09.0

�@FCED�2C6�C6BF:C65�E@�7:I�2�>:?:>F>�2?5�2�>2I:>F>�@7�E96�D6?E6?46�E92E�E96J�2C6E@� :>A@D6� FA@?� 2?� @776?56C� H96?� 7@F?5� 8F:=EJ� @7� E96� 4C:>6� 492C865� � +@��H96?6G6C� E96!?56E6C>:?2E6�+6?E6?46�$2H�:D�2AA=:423=6��E96C6�:D�2=H2JD�2�>:?:>F>�2?5�>2I:>F>�@7�E96D6?E6?46�E92E� E96�4@?G:4E�D92==�D6CG6 !7� E96�4C:>6� :D�AF?:D965�3J�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56�E96� =2H� AC@G:56D� E92E� E96�>2I:>F>� D92==� 36� 2CC:G65� 2E� 3J� 4@?D:56C:?8� E96�>:E:82E:?8� 2?5288C2G2E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46D�:?�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�E96�4C:>6�244@C5:?8�E@�E96�AC@A6C�CF=6D�@7E96� *6G:D65� (6?2=� �@56� � ,@� 7:I� E96� >2I:>F>�� 4@?D:56C� E96� >:E:82E:?8� 2?5� 288C2G2E:?84:C4F>DE2?46D�244@C5:?8�E@�E96�CF=6D�7@F?5�:?��CE:4=6�����

3� �:A0=,20

!E�2AA=:6D�E@

� �C:>6D�AF?:D965�3J�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56

+A64:2=�$2HD��

���HJ ��� 7I�7C;D:;:�8O�-� �������FH?B�� �� ���

��-��� ����7I�7C;D:;:

$.'�I>EKB:�DEJ�8;�7FFB?;:�M>;D�?J�?I�KD<7LEH78B;�JE�J>;�799KI;:

$.'�:E;I�DEJ�7FFBO�JE�DED:?L?I?8B;�F;D7BJ?;I

-KB;�KD:;H��HJ����I>7BB�7FFBO�?D�:;J;HC?D?D=�J>;�C7N?CKC�8KJ�DEJ�?D�:;J;HC?D?D=�J>;�C?D?CKC��/>?I�C;7DI W

�+;D7BJ?;I�FH;I9H?8;:�8O�J>;�B7M�<EH�J>;�9H?C;�9ECC?JJ;:�I>7BB�8;�?CFEI;:�?D�J>;�C;:?KC�F;H?E:�?<�DE

C?J?=7J?D=�EH�7==H7L7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;�

���$<�J>;H;�?I�7==H7L7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;��DE�C?J?=7J?D=��F;D7BJO�I>7BB�8;�?CFEI;:�?D�J>;�C7N?CKC�

��$<�J>;H;�?I�C?J?=7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;��DE�7==H7L7J?D=��F;D7BJO�I>7BB�8;�?D�J>;�C?D?CKC�

�� $<� J>;H;�7H;�I;L;H7B�C?J?=7J?D=�7D:�7==H7L7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�� J>;O� I>7BB�E<<I;J�7=7?DIJ�;79>�EJ>;H

2>7J;L;H�H;C7?DI��7FFBO�J>;�HKB;I

�� $<� J>;H;� 7H;� JME� EH�CEH;�C?J?=7J?D=� 9?H9KCIJ7D9;� 7D:� DE� 7==H7L7J?D=� 9?H9KCIJ7D9;�� F;D7BJO� D;NJ

BEM;H�?D�:;=H;;�I>7BB�8;�J>;�ED;�?CFEI;:��/>;�$D:;J;HC?D7J;�.;DJ;D9;�'7M�I>7BB�DEJ�7FFBO�JE�

�+;HIEDI�9EDL?9J;:�E<�E<<;DI;�FKD?I>78B;�M?J>�:;7J>�F;D7BJO�EH�B?<;�?CFH?IEDC;DJ�

Page 27: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

.� �:9/4?4:9>�:1�;,=:70

,96�AC:D@?6C�4@F=5�36� C6=62D65�@?�A2C@=6� 27E6C� D6CG:?8� E96�>:?:>F>�D6?E6?46�2?54@F=5�36�C6�2CC6DE65�E@�D6CG6�E96�>2I:>F>

44� '3=00�1:7/�%@70

,96�>2I:>F>�5FC2E:@? @7� E96�4@?G:4END� D6?E6?46� D92==�?@E�36�>@C6� E92?� E9C66 ���E:>6D E96� =6?8E9�@7� E:>6�4@CC6DA@?5:?8� E@� E96�>@DE� D6G6C6�@7� E96�A6?2=E:6D� :>A@D65�FA@?9:>�2?5�D92==�?@E�6I4665 7@CEJ����� J62CD &@�@E96C�A6?2=EJ�D92==�36�:?7=:4E65�27E6C�E96�DF>�@7E9@D6�:>A@D65�6BF2=D�E96�D2:5�>2I:>F>�A6C:@5�� ,96�O>@DE�D6G6C6�A6?2=E:6DP�:?4=F56�6BF2=A6?2=E:6D� @H6G6C�� E96� ��7@=5� CF=6� 2AA=:6D� @?=J� H96?� E96� 4@?G:4E� 92D� E@� D6CG6� 2E� =62DE� �D6?E6?46D��

444� &@->4/4,=D��8;=4>:9809?

!E :D� :>A@D65� H96?� E96� A6CD@?� 92D� ?@� AC@A6CEJ H:E9� H9:49� E@� >66E� E96� 7:?6>6?E:@?65�:?��CE:4=6�����A2C���2E�E96�C2E6�@7�@?6�52J�7@C�6249�(�����

@H6G6C�� :?� @C56C� E92E� DF3D:5:2CJ� :>AC:D@?>6?E� >2J� 36� 6?7@C465�� :E� >FDE� 366IAC6DD=J� DE2E65� :?� E96� ;F58>6?E� E92E� :?� 42D6� @7� 72:=FC6� E@� A2J� E96� 7:?6�� E96� 244FD65�>FDEDF776C� DF3D:5:2CJ� :>AC:D@?>6?E� !?� 23D6?46� @7� DF49� 6IAC6DD� DE2E6>6?E�� E96� DF3D:5:2CJ:>AC:D@?>6?E� 42??@E� 36� :>A@D65� ,96� C62D@?� :D� 3642FD6� DF3D:5:2CJ� :>AC:D@?>6?E� :D� 2DF3DE:EFE6�AC:?4:A2=�A6?2=EJ��?@E�2?�2446DD@CJ�A6?2=EJ��

!E� :D� E96�A6CD@?2= A6?2=EJ�AC6D4C:365�3J� =2H� :?� DF3DE:EFE:@?�@7� E96 A2J>6?E�@7� 7:?66>3@5:65� :?� E96� 564:D:@?� H96?� E96� D2>6� 42??@E� 36� D2E:D7:65� 3642FD6� @7� E96� 4F=AC:END:?D@=G6?4J��

��+;HIEDI�9EDL?9J;:�E<�JH;7IED��9EDIF?H79O�EH�FHEFEI7B�JE�9ECC?J�JH;7IED�

��+;HIEDI�9EDL?9J;:�E<�C?IFH?I?ED�E<�JH;7IED��H;8;BB?ED��I;:?J?ED��;IF?ED7=;�

��+;HIEDI�9EDL?9J;:�E<�F?H79O�

��+;HIEDI�M>E�7H;�>78?JK7B�:;B?DGK;DJI�

��+;HIEDI�M>E�I>7BB�>7L;�;I97F;:�<HEC�9ED<?D;C;DJ�EH�;L7:;:�I;DJ;D9;�

��/>EI;�M>E�>7L;�8;;D�=H7DJ;:�9ED:?J?ED7B�F7H:ED�8O�J>;��>?;<� N;9KJ?L;�7D:�I>7BB�>7L;�L?EB7J;:�J>;

J;HC�J>;H;JE�

�� />EI;� M>EI;� C7N?CKC� J;HC� E<� ?CFH?IEDC;DJ� :E;I� DEJ� ;N9;;:� ED;� � �� O;7H�� 8KJ� DEJ� JE� J>EI;

7BH;7:O�I;DJ;D9;:�8O�<?D7B�@K:=C;DJ�7J�J>;�J?C;�E<�J>;�7FFHEL7B�E<�$D:;J;HC?D7J;�.;DJ;D9;�'7M

��/>EI;�I;DJ;D9;:�JE &'56+'41 EH�IKIF;DI?ED��J>?I�7H; DEJ�FKD?I>78B;�8O�?CFH?IEDC;DJ���F7HI���7D:�����HJ���

��$J�I>EKB:�8;�DEJ;:�>EM;L;H��J>7J�J>;�:KH7J?ED�E<�J>;�9EDL?9JYI�I;DJ;D9;�H;<;HI�JE�I;L;H7B�F;D7BJ?;I�<EH

:?<<;H;DJ�E<<;DI;I��DEJ�O;J�I;HL;:���HJ���

���#/15�8���1010)�����.�-����

� �'12.'�85���#47/#;#0�����*"����

/>;H;�?I�DE�IK8I?:?7HO�F;D7BJO�?<�

7�/>;�FH?D9?F7B�F;D7BJO�?I�>?=>;H�J>7D 24+5+10�%144'%%+10#.�

8�$J�?I�DEJ�E<�<?N;:�:KH7J?ED�

Page 28: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

1� �C0.@?4:9�,9/�&0=A4.0

4� #=:-,?4:9��,B�

,� �01494?4:9�:1�?0=8>

(C@32E:@? ��5:DA@D:E:@?�F?56C�H9:49�2�5676?52?E��27E6C4@?G:4E:@?� 2?5� D6?E6?46�� :D� C6=62D65� DF3;64EE@� 4@?5:E:@?D� :>A@D65� 3J� E96� 4@FCE� 2?5� E@E96�DFA6CG:D:@?�@7�2�AC@32E:@?�@77:46C

(C@32E:@?6C ��A6CD@?�A=2465�@?�AC@32E:@?

(C@32E:@?�'77:46C '?6�H9@�:?G6DE:82E6D�7@C�E96 4@FCE�2�C676CC2=7@C�AC@32E:@?�@C�DFA6CG:D6D�2�AC@32E:@?6C�@C3@E9��

-� #@=;:>0

,@�6DE23=:D9�2�>@C6�6?=:89E6?65�2?5�9F>2?6�4@CC64E:@?2=�DJDE6>D�E92E�H:==�AC@>@E6E96�C67@C>2E:@?�@7�@776?56CD�2?5�E96C63J�C65F46�E96�:?4:56?46�@7�C64:5:G:D>��

.� �=,9?�:1 ;=:-,?4:9��8,990=�,9/�.:9/4?4:9>

,96� 4@FCE�>2J�� 27E6C� :E� D92==� 92G6� 4@?G:4E65� 2?5� D6?E6?465� 2� 5676?52?E� 2?5� FA@?2AA=:42E:@?�2E�2?J�E:>6�@7�D2:5�5676?52?E��DFDA6?5�E96�6I64FE:@?�@7�D2:5�D6?E6?46�2?5�A=246E96�5676?52?E�@?�AC@32E:@?�7@C�DF49�A6C:@5�2?5 FA@?�DF49�E6C>D�2?5�4@?5:E:@?D�2D�:E�>2J566>�36DE

(C@32E:@?�>2J�36�8C2?E65�H96E96C�E96�D6?E6?46�:>A@D6D�2�E6C>�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�@C2�7:?6�@?=J��?�2AA=:42E:@?�7@C�AC@32E:@?�D92==�36�7:=65�H:E9�E96�EC:2=�4@FCE��H:E9�?@E:46�E@�E962AA6==2E6�4@FCE�:7�2?�2AA62=�92D�366?�E2<6?�7C@>�E96�D6?E6?46�@7�4@?G:4E:@?�,96�7:=:?8�@7�E962AA=:42E:@?�D92==�36�566>65�2�H2:G6C�@7�E96�C:89E�E@�2AA62=��@C�E96�2FE@>2E:4�H:E95C2H2=�@7�2A6?5:?8�2AA62=

�?�@C56C�8C2?E:?8�@C�56?J:?8�AC@32E:@?�D92==�?@E�36�2AA62=23=6��

9�/>;�IK8I?:?7HO�F;D7BJO��J>EK=>�FHEF;HBO�?CFEI78B;�?I�DEJ�;NFH;IIBO�IJ7J;:�?D�J>;�@K:=C;DJ�

:�/>;�F;D7BJO�?I�DEJ�!$�.��!?D;��$CFH?IEDC;DJ�7D:�<?D;� &'56+'441 7D:�<?D;��IKIF;DI?ED�7D:�<?D;���EH

;�/>;�F;D7BJO�:E;I�DEJ�?D9BK:;�<?D;��+�������7I�7C;D:;:

��.;9��

��2# - �.�9B7KI;

��.;9��

Page 29: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

,96 AC@32E:@?�=2H�:>A@D6D�EH@�<:?5D�@7�4@?5:E:@?D

%2?52E@CJ�4@?5:E:@?D �:D4C6E:@?2CJ�4@?5:E:@?D�

��� � ,96� 4@?G:4E� >FDE� C6A@CE� E@� E96� (C@32E:@?'77:46C� �('�� 56D:8?2E65� :?� E96� 4@FCE� @C56C2AAC@G:?8�9:D� 2AA=:42E:@?� 7@C�(C@32E:@?�H:E9:?� �9@FCD�7C@>�C646:AE�@7�&@E:46�@7�DF49�@C56C2AAC@G:?8�9:D�2AA=:42E:@?��2?5

�� �,96� 4@?G:4E�� 2D� 2�AC@32E:@?6C��>FDE� C6A@CEE@� E96� ('� 2E� =62DE� @?46� 2� >@?E9� 5FC:?8� E96A6C:@5� @7� AC@32E:@?� F?=6DD� D@@?6C� C6BF:C65� 3JE96�('

,96D6� 4@?5:E:@?D� 36:?8� >2?52E@CJ�� E96>@>6?E 2?J�@7�E96D6�:D�G:@=2E6��E96�AC@32E:@?�:D42?46==65�

,96� EC:2=� 4@FCE�� H9:49� 2AAC@G65� E962AA=:42E:@?� 7@C� AC@32E:@?�� >2J� :>A@D62?J�4@?5:E:@?�H9:49�>2J�36�4@?DECF4E:G6E@� E96� 4@CC64E:@?� @7� E96� @776?56C�AC@G:565�E96�D2>6�H@F=5�?@E�G:@=2E6�E964@?DE:EFE:@?2=� C:89ED�@7� E96�@776?56C� 2?5DF3;64E�E@�E9:D�EH@�� ��C6DEC:4E:@?D�

����E96�4@?5:E:@?D�:>A@D65�D9@F=5�?@E�36F?5F=J�C6DEC:4E:G6�@7�E96�AC@32E:@?6C��2?5

� �� DF49� 4@?5:E:@?� D9@F=5� ?@E� 36:?4@>A2E:3=6� H:E9� E96� 7C665@>� @74@?D4:6?46�@7�E96�AC@32E:@?6C

/���=4?0=4,�:1�;7,.492�,9�:1109/0=�:9�;=:-,?4:9

,96� 4@FCE� D92==� 4@?D:56C� 2==� :?7@C>2E:@?� C6=2E:G6 E@� E96� 492C24E6C�� 2?E64656?ED�6?G:C@?>6?E��>6?E2=�2?5�A9JD:42=�4@?5:E:@?�@7�E96�@776?56C��2?5�2G2:=23=6�:?DE:EFE:@?2=�2?54@>>F?:EJ�C6D@FC46D�(C@32E:@?�D92==�36�56?:65�:7�E96�4@FCE�7:?5D�E92E�

2� E96 @776?56C� :D� :?� ?665� @7� 4@CC64E:@?2=� EC62E>6?E� E92E� 42?� 36� AC@G:565� >@DE67764E:G6=J�3J�9:D�4@>>:E>6?E�E@�2?�:?DE:EFE:@?��@C

3� E96C6�:D�F?5F6�C:D<�E92E�5FC:?8�E96�A6C:@5�@7�AC@32E:@?�E96�@776?56C�H:==�4@>>:E2?@E96C�4C:>6��@C

4� AC@32E:@?�H:==�56AC64:2E6�E96�D6C:@FD?6DD�@7�E96�@776?D6�4@>>:EE65

0���4><@,74140/�:1109/0=>

,9@D6�

2� D6?E6?465�E@�D6CG6�2�>2I:>F>�E6C>�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�@7�>@C6�E92?�D:I ��� J62CD�

3� 4@?G:4E65�@7�2?J�@776?D6�282:?DE�E96�D64FC:EJ�@7�E96�+E2E6�

4��H9@�92G6�AC6G:@FD=J�366?�4@?G:4E65�3J�7:?2=�;F58>6?E�@7�2?�@776?D6�AF?:D965�3J:>AC:D@?>6?E�@7�?@E�=6DD�E92?�@?6�>@?E9�2?5�@?6�52J�2?5@C�2�7:?6�@7�?@E�=6DD�E92?�,H@ F?5C65�(6D@D�

5� H9@�92G6�366?�@?46�@?�AC@32E:@?�F?56C�E96 AC@G:D:@?D�@7�E9:D��64C66��2?5

Page 30: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

6�� H9@ 2C6� 2=C625J� D6CG:?8� D6?E6?46� 2E� E96� E:>6� E96� DF3DE2?E:G6� AC@G:D:@?D� @7� E9:D�64C66�3642>6�2AA=:423=6��

1��#0=4:/�:1�;=:-,?4:9

2�� +6?E6?465� E@� 2� E6C>� @7� :>AC:D@?>6?E� @7?@E�>@C6�E92?�@?6�����J62C

&@E�E@�6I4665�EH@�� ��J62CD

!?� 2==� @E96C� 42D6D�� D2:5 A6C:@5� D92==� ?@E6I4665�D:I�����J62CD

3�� +6?E6?46� :>A@D6D� 2� 7:?6� @?=J� 2?5� E96@776?56C� :D� >256� E@� D6CG6� DF3D:5:2CJ:>AC:D@?>6?E�:?�42D6�@7�:?D@=G6?4J

&@E� =6DD� E92?�?@C�>@C6� E92?� EH:46� E96� E@E2=?F>36C� @7� 52JD� @7� DF3D:5:2CJ:>AC:D@?>6?E��

2���==0>?�:1�;=:-,?4:90=

�E� 2?J� E:>6� 5FC:?8� AC@32E:@?�� E96� 4@FCE� >2J� :DDF6� 2� H2CC2?E� 7@C� E96� 2CC6DE� @7� 2AC@32E:@?6C� 7@C� G:@=2E:@?� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� 4@?5:E:@?D� @7� AC@32E:@?� ,96� AC@32E:@?6C�� @?462CC6DE65� 2?5�56E2:?65�� D92==� :>>65:2E6=J�36�3C@F89E�367@C6� E96� 4@FCE� 7@C� 2 962C:?8��H9:49>2J�36�:?7@C>2=�2?5�DF>>2CJ��@7�E96�G:@=2E:@?�492C865�,96�5676?52?E�>2J�36�25>:EE65�E@32:=�A6?5:?8�DF49�962C:?8�!?�DF49�2�42D6��E96�AC@G:D:@?D�C682C5:?8�C6=62D6�@?�32:=�@7�A6CD@?D492C865�H:E9�2�4C:>6�D92==�36�2AA=:423=6�E@�AC@32E:@?6CD�2CC6DE65�F?56C�E9:D�AC@G:D:@?�!7�E96G:@=2E:@?� :D� 6DE23=:D965�� E96� 4@FCE� >2J� C6G@<6� @C� 4@?E:?F6� 9:D� AC@32E:@?� 2?5� >@5:7J� E964@?5:E:@?D� E96C6@7� !7� C6G@<65�� E96�4@FCE� D92==�@C56C� E96�AC@32E:@?6C� E@� D6CG6� E96� D6?E6?46@C:8:?2==J� :>A@D65��?�@C56C� C6G@<:?8� E96� 8C2?E�@7�AC@32E:@?�@C�>@5:7J:?8� E96� E6C>D� 2?54@?5:E:@?D�E96C6@7�D92==�?@E�36�2AA62=23=6��

3��'0=849,?4:9�:1�;=:-,?4:9� 0C.0;?4:9>

�7E6C� E96� A6C:@5� @7� AC@32E:@?� 2?5� FA@?� 4@?D:56C2E:@?� @7� E96� C6A@CE� 2?5C64@>>6?52E:@?� @7� E96� AC@32E:@?� @77:46C�� E96� 4@FCE >2J� @C56C� E96� 7:?2=� 5:D492C86� @7� E96AC@32E:@?6C�FA@?�7:?5:?8�E92E�96�92D�7F=7:==65�E96�E6C>D�2?5�4@?5:E:@?D�@7�9:D�AC@32E:@?�2?5E96C6FA@?�E96�42D6�:D�566>65�E6C>:?2E65

,96�7:?2=�5:D492C86�@7�E96�AC@32E:@?6C�D92==�@A6C2E6�E@�C6DE@C6�E@�9:>�2==�4:G:=�C:89ED=@DE�@C�DFDA6?5�2D�2� C6DF=E�@7�9:D�4@?G:4E:@?�2?5� E@� 7F==J�5:D492C86�9:D� =:23:=:EJ� 7@C�2?J� 7:?6:>A@D65�2D�E@�E96�@776?D6�7@C�H9:49�AC@32E:@?�H2D�8C2?E65

��.;9��

��9ECFKJ;: 7J J>;�H7J;�;IJ78B?I>;:�?D��HJ �� E<�J>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:; �.;9� ��

��.;9� �

Page 31: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

,96� AC@32E:@?6C� 2?5� E96� AC@32E:@?� @77:46C� D92==� 6249� 36� 7FC?:D965�H:E9� 2� 4@AJ� @7DF49�@C56C��

4� '30��:8;=0309>4A0��,920=:@>��=@2>��.?�:1

�����

�?J�A6CD@?�4@?G:4E65� 7@C�5CF8� EC277:4<:?8�@C�AFD9:?8�F?56C� E9:D��4E�� C682C5=6DD�@7E96�A6?2=EJ�:>A@D65�3J�E96��@FCE��42??@E�2G2:=�@7�E96�AC:G:=686�8C2?E65�3J�E96�(C@32E:@?�$2H@C�(C6D:56?E:2=��64C66�&@������2D�2>6?565���

44� �@A09470��@>?4.0�,9/�*071,=0��.?�:1������ ,7>:

=010=�?: �347/�,9/�+:@?3�*071,=0��:/0���

,�� �01494?4:9� :1� .347/� 49� .:9174.?� B4?3� ?30

7,B���

-� �C08;?4:9�1=:8�.=4849,7�74,-474?D���

.� �@A09470�5@>?4.0�,9/�B071,=0�>D>?08

� DJDE6>�562=:?8 H:E9�49:=5C6?�2E� C:D<� 2?5�49:=5C6?� :?�4@?7=:4E�H:E9� E96� =2H��H9:49AC@G:56D� 49:=5�2AAC@AC:2E6� AC@4665:?8D�� :?4=F5:?8� AC@8C2>D� 2?5� D6CG:46D� 7@C� AC6G6?E:@?�5:G6CD:@?�� C6923:=:E2E:@?�� C6�:?E68C2E:@?� 2?5� 27E6C42C6� E@� 6?DFC6� E96:C� ?@C>2=� 8C@HE9� 2?556G6=@A>6?E

8� �:DE:?8F:D965�7C@>�AC6G6?E:G6�:>AC:D@?>6?E

(C6G6?E:G6� :>AC:D@?>6?E� :D� E96� :?42C46C2E:@?� F?56C8@?6� 3J� 2� A6CD@?� 244FD65� @7� 24C:>6�H9:49�:D�?@E�32:=23=6��@C�6G6?�:7�32:=23=6��42??@E�277@C5�E@�A@DE�E96�3@?5��FC:?8�E96EC:2=�@7�9:D�42D6��96�:D�56E2:?65 :?�;2:=� 6�:D�<?@H?�2D�56E6?E:@?�AC:D@?6C���

��.;9� �

����������

� .;9�����?:

��-������

��+�������7I�7C;D:;:

��IKFH7

��?8?:

���HJ ��� E<� J>;� -+�� �F;H?E:� E<� FH;L;DJ?L;� ?CFH?IEDC;DJ� :;:K9J;:� <HEC� J;HC� E<� ?CFH?IEDC;DJ�� ?I

7FFB?978B;�JE�8EJ>�:?L?I?8B;�7D:�?D:?L?I?8B;�F;D7BJ?;I�8;97KI;�I7?:�7HJ?9B;�:?:�DEJ�C7A;�7DO�:?IJ?D9J?EDI

Page 32: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�!;0525/-@5;:�-:0��D@5:/@5;:�;2��>595:-8� 5-.585@E

,� #=0>.=4;?4:9�:1�.=480>

!E� :D�E96�7@C76:EFC6�@C�=@DD�@7�E96�C:89E�@7�E96 +E2E6 E@�AC@D64FE6�E96�@776?56C�@C�7:=64C:>:?2=�24E:@?�27E6C�E96�=2AD6�@7�2�46CE2:?�A6C:@5�@7�E:>6���

,96�A6C:@5�@7�AC6D4C:AE:@?�D92==�4@>>6?46�E@�CF?�7C@>�E96�52J�@7�5:D4@G6CJ�@7�E964C:>6�3J�E96�@776?565�A2CEJ��E96�2FE9@C:E:6D�@C�E96:C�286?ED���

,96�A6C:@5 D92==� 36� :?E6CCFAE65�3J� E96� 7:=:?8�@7� E96� 4@>A=2:?E�@C� :?7@C>2E:@?�� 2?5D92==� 4@>>6?46� E@� CF?�282:?�H96?� DF49�AC@4665:?8D� E6C>:?2E6�H:E9@FE� E96�244FD65�36:?84@?G:4E65�@C�24BF:EE65��@C�2C6�F?;FDE:7:23=J�DE@AA65�7C@>�2?J�C62D@?�?@E�:>AFE23=6�E@�9:>���

�C:>6D�AF?:D923=6�3J�562E9� 2%#,53)/.�0%20%45! @C2%#,53)/.�4%-0/2!,

,H6?EJ�� ���J62CD

�C:>6D�AF?:D923=6�3J�@E96C�277=:4E:G6�A6?2=E:6D �:7E66?������J62CD

�@CC64E:@?2=�A6?2=EJ ,6?������J62CD���

$:36=�@C�@E96C�D:>:=2C�@776?D6D '?6�����J62C

'C2=�5672>2E:@?�2?5�D=2?56C�3J�5665 +:I�����>@?E9D

$:89E�@776?D6D ,H@�� ��>@?E9D

��.;;�-;O;I��-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:;���EEA�$

���HJ��

��$8?:

� N9;FJ�J>EI;�FKD?I>78B;�8O #44'561�/#;14 <?L;�����O;7HI

Page 33: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

-� #=0>.=4;?4:9�:1�;09,7?40>

,96� =@DD� @C� 7@C76:EFC6� @7� E96� C:89E� @7� E96� +E2E6� E@� 6I64FE6� E96� 7:?2=� D6?E6?46� @74@?G:4E:@?� 27E6C� E96� =2AD6� @7� 2� 46CE2:?� A6C:@5� @7� E:>6� ,96� A6?2=EJ�� E@� 36� DF3;64E� @7AC6D4C:AE:@?��>FDE�92G6�366?�:>A@D65�3J�7:?2=�;F58>6?E

�62E9�2?5 2%#,53)/.�0%20%45! ,H6?EJ�� ���J62CD

'E96C�277=:4E:G6�A6?2=E:6D �:7E66?������J62CD

�@CC64E:@?2=�A6?2=E:6D ,6?������J62CD���

$:89E�A6?2=E:6D '?6�����J62C ��

.��#,=/:9��� -D�:1109/0/�;,=?D

'?=J� 6IE:?8F:D96D� 4:G:=� =:23:=:EJ� @H6G6C�� :?� 42D6D� @7� 25F=E6CJ�� 4@?4F3:?286�� C2A6�24ED� @7� =2D4:G:@FD?6DD�� D65F4E:@?� @C� 235F4E:@?� H96?� 8C2?E65� 367@C6� E96� :?DE:EFE:@?� @7� E964C:>:?2=�24E:@?�2=D@�6IE:?8F:D96D 4C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ���

-?56C�*��������:?�E96�4C:>6�@7�C2A6��:7�:E�:D�E96�9FD32?5�H9@�:D�E96�@776?56C��E96DF3D6BF6?E�7@C8:G6?6DD�3J�E96�H:76�D92==�6IE:?8F:D9�E96�4C:>:?2=�24E:@?�@C�E96�A6?2=EJ�6I46AEH96?�E96�>2CC:286�:D 6/)$�!"�).)4)/���

/��#,=/:9�-D�?30 �3401��C0.@?4A0

�IE:?8F:D96D�4C:>:?2=� =:23:=:EJ @7�E96�@776?56C !E 42??@E� :?4=F56�4:G:=� =:23:=:EJ�H9:49E96�@776?56C�>FDE�A2J�!E�:D�8C2?E65�@?=J�27E6C�4@?G:4E:@?�2?5�>2J�36�6IE6?565�E@�2?J�@7�E96@776?56CD

0���890>?D

��A2C5@?�6IE6?565�3J�E96�8@G6C?>6?E�E@�2�8C@FA�@C�4=2DD�@7�A6CD@?D��FDF2==J�7@C�2A@=:E:42=� @776?D6�� E96� 24E� @7� D@G6C6:8?� A@H6C� @77:4:2==J� 7@C8:G:?8� 46CE2:?� 4=2DD6D� @7� A6CD@?DH9@�2C6�DF3;64E�E@�EC:2=�3FE�92G6�?@E�J6E�366?�4@?G:4E65���

N9;FJ�J>;�F;D7BJO�E< #44'561�/#;14 W <?L;�����O;7HI

��HJ���

��D�79J�E<�=H79;�M>?9>�;N;CFJI�J>;�?D:?L?:K7B�ED�M>EC�?J�?I�8;IJEM;:�<HEC�J>;�FKD?I>C;DJ�M>?9>�J>;

B7M�?D<B?9JI�<EH�J>;�9H?C;�>;�>7I�9ECC?JJ;:���'��'10�85���+4���(��4+5105��� �+>?B���� �

�HJ���� �

.;9��

Page 34: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

&665D� 4@?4FCC6?46� @7� 4@?8C6DD !E� =@@<D� 324<H2C5� 2?5� 23@=:D96D� 2?5� AFED� :?E@@3=:G:@?� E96� @776?D6� :ED6=7�� :E� D@� @G6C=@@<D� 2?5� @3=:E6C2E6D� E96� @776?D6� H:E9� H9:49� 96� :D492C865� E92E� E96�A6CD@?� C6=62D65�3J� 2>?6DEJ� DE2?5D�367@C6� E96� =2H�AC64:D6=J� 2D� E9@F89�96925� 4@>>:EE65� ?@� @776?D6��� ,9FD�� �CE� ��� D2JD� OIII� 3J� 2>?6DEJ� H9:49� 4@>A=6E6=J6IE:?8F:D96D�E96�A6?2=EJ�2?5�2==�:ED�67764EDP

��B79AYI�'7M��?9J?ED7HO���

J> :

��#44137+061��'6�#.���'40#0&'<��;J�7B�����+>?B����

Page 35: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

� �>591?��3-5:?@�"-@5;:-8�'1/A>5@E

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED

(>1-?;:��� 2��,96 @776?56C�@H6D�2==68:2?46�E@�E96�@G6C?>6?E�@7�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D

3��,96C6�:D�2�H2C�:?�H9:49�E96(9:=:AA:?6D�:D�:?G@=G65

4���,96�@776?56C�6:E96C L

���=6G:6D�H2C�282:?DE�E96�8@GE��� @C

��HJ� �

/H;7IED��8H;79>�E<�7BB;=?7D9;�JE�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ��9ECC?JJ;:�8O�7�F;HIED�M>E�EM;I�7BB;=?7D9;�JE�?J

L?:;DJ�FH;C;:?J7J?ED��IKF;H?EH�IJH;D=J>�7D:�JH;79>;HO�7H;�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�?D>;H;DJ�?D�JH;7IED��7D:�7H;�

J>;H;<EH;��DEJ�7==H7L7J?D=

/H;7IED�97DDEJ�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�?D�J?C;I�E<�F;79;��EDBO�?D�J?C;I�E<�M7H W 79JK7B�>EIJ?B?J?;I��KJ�DE�D;;:

<EH�:;9B7H7J?ED�E<�M7H

';LO?D=� E<� M7H�� 7�� J>7J� J>;H;� 8;� 7D� 79JK7B� 7II;C8B?D=� E<� C;D�� 8�� <EH� J>;� FKHFEI;� E<� ;N;9KJ?D=� 7

JH;7IED78B;�:;I?=D�8O�<EH9;��:;B?L;H�J>;�9EKDJHO�?D�M>EB;�EH�?D�F7HJ�JE�J>;�;D;CO�

/H;7IED�97DDEJ�8;�FHEL;:�8O�9?H9KCIJ7DJ?7B�;L?:;D9;�EH�8O�;NJH7@K:?9?7B�9ED<;II?ED�E<�J>;�799KI;:

�9JK7B�>EIJ?B?J?;I�C7O�:;J;HC?D;�J>;�:7J;�E<�J>;�9ECC;D9;C;DJ�E<�M7H

)E�IK9>�J>?D=�7I�7JJ;CFJ;:�JH;7IED��C;H;�7JJ;CFJ�9EDIKCC7J;I�J>;�9H?C;

"?L?D=� 7?:� EH� 9EC<EHJ W C7J;H?7B� ;B;C;DJ�� ;D>7D9;I� <EH9;I� E<� J>;� ;D;CO� 9EKDJHO� �9JI� M>?9>

IJH;D=J>;D�EH� J;D:�JE� IJH;D=J>;D�J>;�;D;CO� ?D� J>;�9ED:K9J�E<�M7H�7=7?DIJ� J>;�JH7?JEHYI�9EKDJHO�EH� J>7J

M>?9>�M;7A;D�7D:�J;D:�JE�M;7A;D�J>;�FEM;H�E<�J>;�I7C;

�:>;H;D9; 7D:�=?L?D=�7?:�EH�9EC<EHJ�CKIJ�9ED9KH�JE=;J>;H��KJ�C;C8;HI>?F�?D�J>;�FEB?9;�<EH9;�:KH?D=

J>;�E99KF7J?ED�?I�DEJ�JH;7IED

�:>;H;D9;� C7O� 8;� FHEL;:� 8O�� � �� ED;� M?JD;II�� ���� <HEC� J>;� D7JKH;� E<� J>;� 79J� ?JI;B<�� ���� <HEC� J>;

9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�IKHHEKD:?D=�J>;�79J

/H;7IED�?I�7�9EDJ?DK?D=�9H?C;� L;D�7<J;H�J>;�M7H��E<<;D:;H�97D�8;�FHEI;9KJ;:

2>;D�A?BB?D=I�7D:�EJ>;H�9ECCED�9H?C;I�7H;�9>7H=;:�7I�EL;HJ�79J�E<�JH;7IED��J>;O�97DDEJ�8;�H;=7H:;:

7I�� ��I;F7H7J;�9H?C;I�EH�����7I�9ECFB;N�M?J>�JH;7IED

*D��?J?P;DI>?F�

7 !?B?F?DE� 9?J?P;DI� 97D� 9ECC?J� JH;7IED� EKJI?:;� J>;� +>?B?FF?D;I� �KJ� J>7J� E<� 7D� 7B?;D� CKIJ� 8;

9ECC?JJ;:�?D�J>;�+>?B?FF?D;I

8 *DBO�!?B?F?DE�9?J?P;DI�EH�F;HC7D;DJ�H;I?:;DJ 7B?;DI�97D�8;�>;B:�B?78B;

9 �B?;D�� M?J>� F;HC7D;DJ� H;I?:;DJ� IJ7JKI� <HEC� J>;� �$� W ?J� ?I� D;?J>;H� J>;� B;D=J>� E<� IJ7O� ?D� J>;

+>?B?FF?D;I�DEH�J>;�C7HH?7=;�M?J>�7�!?B?F?DE�J>7J�C7JJ;HI

27OI�E<�FHEL?D=�JH;7IED�

7 ��M?JD;II;I�J;IJ?<O?D=�JE�I7C;�EL;HJ�79J

N7CFB;�� 3� I7M� 7HCI� B7D:;:� ?D� '7� 0D?ED� 7D:� BE7:;:� ?DJE� 7�CEJEH� L;>?9B;� �J� J>?I� IJ7=;�� DEJ

IK<<?9?;DJ�JE�9EDL?9J�O;J�4�B7J;H�I7M�J>;�7HCI�KDBE7:;:�?D�7�M7H;>EKI;�2?BB�3���4�8;�IK<<?9?;DJ�M?JD;II;I

JE�9EDL?9J���DIM;H��)E��;97KI;�J>;�B7M�H;GK?H;I�J>7J���M?JD;II;I�I;;�J>;�I7C;�EL;HJ�79J

8 �ED<;II?ED�E<�J>;�799KI;:�?D�EF;D�9EKHJ

�;;7���

Page 36: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�2596C6D�E@�E96�6?6>:6D��8:G:?8E96>�2:5�2?5�4@>7@CE� �

�;:?<5>-/E�@;�/;995@�@>1-?;:� � 2��!?�E:>6D�@7�H2C

3� �@C�>@C6�A6CD@?D�4@>6�E@�2?28C66>6?E�E@

��=6GJ�H2C�282:?DE�E96�8@GE�@C �2596C6�E@�E96�6?6>:6D�2?5�E@�8:G6

E96>�2:5�@C�4@>7@CE�

4����,96J�564:56�E@�4@>>:E�:E

$>;<;?-8�@; /;995@�@>1-?;: 2��!?�E:>6D�@7�H2C

3���A6CD@?�H9@�92D�564:565�E@�=6GJ�H2C282:?DE� E96� 8@G6C?>6?E�� @C� E@� 2596C6� E@E96� 6?6>:6D� 2?5� E@� 8:G6� E96>� 2:5� @C4@>7@CE��AC@A@D6D�:ED�6I64FE:@?�E@�D@>6@E96C�A6CD@?D

$<�>;�>7I�FB;7:;:�DEJ�=K?BJO�7BH;7:O�:KH?D=�7HH7?=DC;DJ��>;�97D�IJ?BB�9ED<;II�?D�EF;D�9EKHJ�8O�IJ7J?D=�J>;

F7HJ?9KB7H�79JI�9EDIJ?JKJ?D= JH;7IED

�KH?D=�JH?7B��I?CFBO�I7O?D=�Z$YC�=K?BJO[�?I�DEJ�;DEK=>

2?J>:H7M?D=�FB;7�E<�ZDEJ�=K?BJO[�:KH?D=�7HH7?=DC;DJ�DEJ�D;9;II7HO

$<�:KH?D=�7HH7?=DC;DJ�>;�FB;7:I�=K?BJO��9EKHJ�M?BB�7IA�?<�J>;�799KI;:�KD:;HIJ7D:I�?I�FB;7�.K8C?II?ED�E<

7<<?:7L?J�:KH?D=�JH?7B��;L;D�?<�7II?IJ;:�8O�9EKDI;B�?I�DEJ�;DEK=> �

8H;79>�E<�7BB;=?7D9;

�79JK7B�7II;C8B?D=�E<�C;D

�<EH�J>;�FKHFEI;�E<�;N;9KJ?D=�7�H;7IED78B;�:;I?=D ��

�8H;79>�E<�7BB;=?7D9;

�7:>;H;D9;

��=?L?D=�7?:�EH�9EC<EHJ�JE�J>;�;D;CO �

�HJ� �

(;H;�7=H;;C;DJ�7D:�:;9?I?EDI�JE�9ECC?J�JH;7IED�?I�FKD?I>78B;

(;H;�FHEFEI7B�;L;D�M?J>EKJ�799;FJ7D9;�?I�FKD?I>78B;�JEE�$<�J>;�EJ>;H�799;FJI��?J�?I�7BH;7:O�9EDIF?H79O

Page 37: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

!5?<>5?5;:�;2�@>1-?;:� 2 ,96 @776?56C�>FDE�36�@H:?8�2==68:2?46E@�E96�8@G6C?>6?E��2?5�?@E�2�7@C6:8?6C

3 6� 92D� <?@H=6586� @7� 2?J� 4@?DA:C24J�E@� 4@>>:E� EC62D@?�� 282:?DE� E968@G6C?>6?E

4 6 4@?462=D�@C�5@6D�?@E�5:D4=@D6 2?5>2<6� <?@H?� E96� D2>6� 2D� D@@?� 2DA@DD:3=6� E@� E96�8@G6C?@C�@C� 7:D42=�@7� E96AC@G:?46� @C� E96� >2J@C� @C� 7:D42=� @7� E964:EJ�:?�H9:49�96�C6D:56D

�?<5;:-31� � 2 �?E6C:?8�� H:E9@FE� 2FE9@C:EJ� E96C67@C�H2CD9:A�� 7@CE�� @C� ?2G2=� @C� >:=:E2CJ6DE23=:D9>6?ED� @C� C6D6CG2E:@?� E@� @3E2:?2?J� :?7@C>2E:@?�� A=2?D�� A9@E@8C2A9D� @C@E96C 52E2� @7� 2� 4@?7:56?E:2=� ?2EFC6C6=2E:G6�E@�E96�5676?D6�@7�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D

3� �:D4=@D:?8� E@� E96� C6AC6D6?E2E:G6� @7� 27@C6:8?� ?2E:@?� E96� 4@?E6?ED� @7� E962CE:4=6D�� 52E2�� @C� :?7@C>2E:@?�>6?E:@?65�H9:49�96�925�:?�9:D�A@DD6DD:@?�3J�C62D@?@7�E96�AF3=:4�@77:46 9@=5D� �

���HJ� �

*<<;D:;H�?I�FKD?I>;:�7I�7D�799;IIEHO�JE�J>;�9H?C;�E<�JH;7IED

/>?I�9H?C;�:E;I�DEJ�7FFBO�?<�J>;�9H?C;�E<�JH;7IED�?I�7BH;7:O�9ECC?JJ;:

�H?C;�E<�EC?II?ED

Z/E�H;FEHJ�M?J>?D�7�H;7IED78B;�J?C;[ W :;F;D:I�ED�J?C;��FB79;�7D:�9?H9KCIJ7D9; W J>;�-+��:?:�DEJ�<?N

J?C;

-+� IJ7J;I��� ?D:?L?:K7BI��M>7J� ?<� OEK� H;FEHJ� JE� IEC;�EJ>;H�>?=>H7DA?D=� =EL;HDC;DJ�E<<?9?7B�� N� +)+

�?H;9JEH��%K:=;�+?C;DJ;B�I7OI�7DO�=ELYJ�E<<?9?7B�E<�J>;��$'"�?I�*& ��

�HJ� �

IF?ED7=;��J>;�E<<;DI;�E<�=7J>;H?D=��JH7DIC?JJ?D=��EH�BEI?D=�?D<EHC7J?ED�H;IF;9J?D=�J>;�D7J?ED7B�:;<;DI;

M?J>�J>;�?DJ;DJ�EH�H;7IED�JE�8;B?;L;�J>7J�J>;�?D<EHC7J?ED�?I�JE�8;�KI;:�JE�J>;�?D@KHO�E<�J>;�+>?B?FF?D;I�EH

J>;�7:L7DJ7=;�E<�7DO�<EH;?=D�D7J?ED��$J�?I�DEJ�9ED:?J?ED;:�ED�9?J?P;DI>?F ��

+KHFEI;��JE�=7J>;H�:7J7

)EJ�D;9;II7HO�J>7J�+>?B?FF?D;I�?I�7J�M7H�M?J>�J>;�9EKDJHO�JE�M>?9>�J>;�?D<EHC7J?ED�M7I�H;L;7B;:�2>7J

?I�?CFEHJ7DJ�?I�J>7J�J>;�?D<EHC7J?ED�H;B7J;:�?I�9EDD;9J;:�M?J>�J>;�:;<;DI;�IOIJ;C�E<�J>;�+>?B?FF?D;I

2?H;J7FF?D=�?I�)*/�;IF?ED7=;�?<�J>;�FKHFEI;�?I�DEJ�IEC;J>?D= 9EDD;9J;:�M?J>�J>;�:;<;DI;

Page 38: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�:/5@5:3� @;� C->� ;>� 35B5:3� 9;@5B1?� 2;>>1<>5?-8?� �

2� ,96� @776?56C� A6C7@C>D� F?=2H7F=� @CF?2FE9@C:K65�24ED

3� � +F49� 24ED� AC@G@<6� @C� 8:G6� @442D:@?7@C� 2� H2C� :?G@=G:?8� @C� =:23=6� E@� :?G@=G6E96� (9:=:AA:?6D� @C� 6IA@D6� �:=:A:?@4:E:K6?D�E@�C6AC:D2=D @?�E96:C�A6CD@?D�@CAC@A6CEJ

*5;8-@5;:�;2�:1A@>-85@E� � 2�,96C6� :D�H2C� :?�H9:49� E96�(9:=:AA:?6D:D�?@E�:?G@=G65

3� ,96C6� :D� 2� C68F=2E:@?� :DDF65� 3J4@>A6E6?E� 2FE9@C:EJ� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @76?7@C4:?8�?6FEC2=:EJ

4��,96�@776?56C�G:@=2E6D�DF49�C68F=2E:@?

�;>>1?<;:01:/1�C5@4�4;?@581�/;A:@>E� � 2 !?� E:>6D @7� H2C� :?� H9:49� E96(9:=:AA:?6D�:D�:?G@=G65

3 ,96� @776?56C� >2<6D� 4@CC6DA@?56?46H:E9� 2?� 6?6>J� 4@F?ECJ� @C� E6CC:E@CJ

���HJ� �

�H?C;�?I�9ECC?JJ;:�?D�J?C;�E<�F;79;��?DJ;DJ�?I�?CC7J;H?7B

$D9?J?D=�JE�M7H W E<<;D:;H�?I�7DO�F;HIED

-;FH?I7BI� ?I� DEJ� B?C?J;:� JE�C?B?J7HO� 79J?ED�� ?J� 9EKB:�8;�;9EDEC?9� H;FH?I7BI�� EH�:;D?7B� E<� ;DJHO� ?DJE� J>;?H

9EKDJHO �:#/2.'� 3� 8KHDI� �>?D;I;� <B7=� $<� �>?D7� 87DI� J>;� ;DJHO� E<� !?B?F?DEI� ?DJE� �>?D7�� J>7J� ?I� 7BH;7:O

H;FH?I7B ��

�HJ� �

"ELYJ�CKIJ�>7L;�:;9B7H;:�J>;�D;KJH7B?JO�E<�J>;�+>?B�?D�7�M7H�8;JM;;D���EJ>;H�9EKDJH?;I

$J�?I�D;KJH7B?JO�E<�J>;�+>?B�J>7J ?I�L?EB7J;:

�ED=H;II�>7I�J>;�H?=>J�JE�:;9B7H;�D;KJH7B?JO ��

�HJ� ��

�?H9KCIJ7D9;I�GK7B?<O?D=�J>;�E<<;DI;�

7�DEJ?9;�EH�?D<EHC7J?ED�C?=>J�8;�KI;<KB�JE�J>;�;D;CO

8�E<<;D:;H�?DJ;D:;:�JE�7?:�J>;�;D;CO

#EIJ?B;�9EKDJHO�;N?IJ�EDBO�:KH?D=�>EIJ?B?J?;I�EH�7<J;H�J>;�:;9B7H7J?ED�E<�M7H

�EHH;IFED:;D9;�JE�;D;CO�9EKDJHO W 9EHH;IFED:;D9;�JE�E<<?9?7BI�E<�;D;CO�9EKDJHO W ;L;D�?<�H;B7J;:�JE

OEK

$J�?I�DEJ�9EHH;IFED:;D9;�M?J>�FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B�?D�;D;CO�9EKDJHO

$<�9?F>;HI�M;H;�KI;:��DE�D;;:�<EH�FHE>?8?J?ED

$<�9?F>;HI�M;H;�DEJ�KI;:��J>;H;�?I�7�D;;:�<EH�FHE>?8?J?ED

$D�7DO�97I;��?J�CKIJ�8;�9EHH;IFED:;D9;�M?J>�J>;�;D;CO�9EKDJHO

�E;IDYJ�C7JJ;H�?<�9EHH;IFED:;D9;�9EDJ7?DI�?DDE9;DJ�C7JJ;HI W ?<�FHE>?8?J;:��FKD?I>78B;

Page 39: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

@44FA:65�3J�6?6>J�EC@@AD

4 ,96�4@CC6DA@?56?46�:D�6:E96C L

� AC@9:3:E65�3J�E96 8@GE��@C42CC:65� @?� :?� 4:A96CD� @C� 4@?G6?E:@?2=D:8?D��@C 4@?E2:?:?8� ?@E:46� @C� :?7@C>2E:@?

H9:49�>:89E�36�FD67F=�E@�E96�6?6>J

�8534@�@;�1:19EH?�/;A:@>E� � 2�,96C6�:D�2�H2C�:?�H9:49�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D:D�:?G@=G65

3� ,96� @776?56C� � >FDE� 36� @H:?82==68:2?46�E@�E96�8@G6C?>6?E

4�,96�@776?56C�2EE6>AED�E@�7=66�@C�8@�E@6?6>J�4@F?ECJ

5� /9:49� :D� AC@9:3:E65� 3J� 4@>A6E6?E2FE9@C:EJ

���HJ�� �

(;H;�7JJ;CFJ�9EDIKCC7J;I�J>;�9H?C;

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�7�FHE>?8?J?ED�$<�DED;��;L;D�?<�M;DJ�JE�;D;CO�9EKDJHO W DE�L?EB7J?ED

�B?;D�H;I?:;DJ�C7O�8;�=K?BJO�>;H; ��

!?B?F?DE�EH�H;I?:;DJ�7B?;D

Page 40: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

$5>-/E��� 2� �� G6DD6=� :D� @?� E96� 9:89D62D���(9:=:AA:?6�H2E6CD

3��,96�@776?56CD�2C6�?@E >6>36CD�@7�:ED4@>A=6>6?E�@C�A2DD6?86CD�@7�E96�G6DD6=

4���,96�@776?56CD L

� 2EE24<�@C�D6:K6�E92E�G6DD6=�� @C � � D6:K6� E96� H9@=6� @C� A2CE� @7� E96

42C8@� @7� D2:5� G6DD6=�� :ED� 6BF:A>6?E� @CA6CD@?2=� 36=@?8:?8D� @7� :ED� 4@>A=6>6?E@C�A2DD6?86CD

%A-852510 <5>-/E��� 2���'776?56CD�D6:K65�2�G6DD6=�3J�3@2C5:?8@C�7:C:?8�FA@?�E96�D2>6

3� � ,96J� 92G6� 232?5@?65� E96:C� G:4E:>DH:E9@FE�>62?D�@7�D2G:?8�E96>D6=G6D

4��,96�4C:>6�:D�244@>A2?:65�3J�>FC56C�9@>:4:56��A9JD:42=�:?;FC:6D��@C�C2A6���

���HJ� ��

/ME ����27OI�E<��ECC?JJ?D=�+?H79O�

7 �O�7JJ79A?D=�EH�I;?P?D=�7�L;II;B�ED�J>;�>?=>�I;7I�EH�?D�J>;�+>?B?FF?D;�M7J;HI��+������

8 �O�I;?P?D=�J>;�M>EB;�EH�F7HJ�E<�J>;�97H=E�E<�I7?:�L;>?9B;I��?JI�;GK?FC;DJ�EH�F;HIED7B�8;BED=?D=I�E<

?JI�9ECFB;C;DJ�EH�F7II;D=;HI

+?H79O�?D�>?=>�I;7I W @KH?I:?9J?ED�?I�M?J>�7DO�9EKHJ�M>;H;�E<<;D:;HI�7H;�<EKD:�EH�7HH;IJ;:

+?H79O�?D�?DJ;HD7B�M7J;HI W @KH?I:?9J?ED�?I�EDBO�M?J>�+>?B?FF?D;�9EKHJI

!EH�FKHFEI;�E<��DJ?!;D9?D=�'7M��F?H79O�?I�F7HJ�E<��HE88;HO�7D:�J>;<J �

�DO�M7J;HI�ED�J>;�I;7�9E7IJ�M>?9>�7H;�M?J>EKJ�J>;�8EKD:7H?;I�E<�J>;�BEM�M7J;H�C7HA�7BJ>EK=>�IK9>

M7J;HI�C7O�8;�?D�J>;�@KH?I:?9J?ED7B�B?C?JI�E<�7�<EH;?=D�=ELYJ ��

?<�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�9H;M�EH�F7II;D=;HI��J>;�9H?C;�?I�DEJ�F?H79O�8KJ�HE88;HO�?D�J>;�>?=>�I;7I ��

�HJ ��

+7HH?9?:;�?D<7DJ?9?:;�I>EKB:�8;�?D9BK:;:��%K:=;�+?C;DJ;B�

(KH:;H�H7F;�>EC?9?:;�F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I� CKIJ� >7L;� 8;;D� 9ECC?JJ;:� ED� J>;� F7II;D=;HI� EH

9ECFB;C;DJ ��

/>;�78EL;�C7O�H;IKBJ�JE�GK7B?<?;:�CKJ?DO

Page 41: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

,� �9?4�#4=,.D�,9/ �9?4� �423B,D�%:--0=D���

4���01494?4:9�:1�?0=8>

(9:=:AA:?6�/2E6CD �==�3@5:6D�@7�H2E6C�� DF49�2D�3FE�?@E� =:>:E65E@�� D62D�� 8F=7D�� 32JD� 2C@F?5�� 36EH66?� 2?54@??64E:?8� 6249� @7� E96� !D=2?5D� @7� E96(9:=:AA:?6� �C49:A6=28@�� :CC6DA64E:G6� @7� :ED56AE9��3C625E9� =6?8E9�@C�5:>6?D:@?��2?5�2==@E96C�H2E6CD�36=@?8:?8�E@�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D�3J9:DE@C:4�@C�=682=�E:E=6��:?4=F5:?8�E6CC:E@C:2=�D62�E96� D62�365�� E96� :?DF=2C� D96=G6D�� 2?5� @E96CDF3>2C:?6� 2C62D� @G6C� H9:49� E96� (9:=:AA:?6D92D�D@G6C6:8?EJ�@C�;FC:D5:4E:@?

.6DD6= �?J� G6DD6=� @C� H2E6C4C27E� FD65� 7@C� EC2?DA@CE@7� A2DD6?86CD� 2?5� 42C8@� 7C@>� @?6� A=246� E@2?@E96C� E9C@F89� (9:=:AA:?6� /2E6CD� !E� D92==:?4=F56�2==�<:?5D�2?5�EJA6D�@7�G6DD6=D�@C�3@2EDFD65�:?�7:D9:?8

(9:=:AA:?6� :89H2J �?J� C@25�� DEC66E�� A2DD286�� 9:89H2J 2?53C:586D�@C�@E96C�A2CED� E96C6@7��@C� C2:=H2J�@CC2:=C@25� H:E9:?� E96� (9:=:AA:?6D� FD65� 3JA6CD@?D��@C�G69:4=6D��@C�=@4@>@E:G6D�@C�EC2:?D7@C� E96�>@G6>6?E� @C� 4:C4F=2E:@?� @7� A6CD@?D@C� EC2?DA@CE2E:@?� @7� 8@@5D�� 2CE:4=6D�� @CAC@A6CEJ�@C�3@E9

(:C24J �?J�2EE24<�FA@?�@C�D6:KFC6�@7�2?J�G6DD6=��@CE96�E2<:?8�2H2J�@7�E96�H9@=6�@C�A2CE�E96C6@7@C� :ED� 42C8@�� 6BF:A>6?E�� @C� E96� A6CD@?2=36=@?8:?8D�@7�:ED�4@>A=6>6?E�@C�A2DD6?86CD�:CC6DA64E:G6�@7�E96�G2=F6�E96C6@7��3J�>62?D�@7G:@=6?46� 282:?DE� @C� :?E:>:52E:@?� @7� A6CD@?D@C� 7@C46� FA@?� E9:?8D�� 4@>>:EE65� 3J� 2?JA6CD@?�� :?4=F5:?8�2�A2DD6?86C�@C�>6>36C�@7E96�4@>A=6>6?E�@7�D2:5�G6DD6=�� :?�(9:=:AA:?6H2E6CD�,96�@776?56CD�D92==�36�4@?D:56C65�2DA:C2E6D

��+� ���

Page 42: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

:89H2J�*@336CJ�C:82?5286 ,96� D6:KFC6� @7� 2?J� A6CD@?� 7@C� C2?D@>�6IE@CE:@?�@C�@E96C�F?=2H7F=�AFCA@D6D��@C�E96E2<:?8� 2H2J� @7� E96� AC@A6CEJ� @7� 2?@E96C� 3J>62?D�@7�G:@=6?46�282:?DE�@C� :?E:>:52E:@?�@7A6CD@?� @C� 7@C46� FA@?� E9:?8D� @7� @E96CF?=2H7F=� >62?D�� 4@>>:EE65� 3J� 2?J� A6CD@?@?�2?J�(9:=:AA:?6� :89H2J

44��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

2 (:C24J���

3 :89H2J�*@336CJ�C:82?5286���

4 �:5:?8� A:C2E6D� @C� 9:89H2J� C@336CD3C:82?5D� @C� 236EE:?8� A:C24J� @C� 9:89H2JC@336CJ3C:82?5286���

-� �9?4��45,.6492��,B���

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>���

2 �?J�A6CD@?�H9@�4@>A6=D 2�492?86� :?� E96�4@FCD6�@C�56DE:?2E:@?�@7�2?�2:C4C27E�@7(9:=:AA:?6�C68:DECJ��@C�E@�D6:K6�FA�@C�FDFCA�E96�4@?EC@=�E96C6@7��H9:=6�:E�:D�:?�7=:89E���

3 �?J� A6CD@?� H9@� 4@>A6=D 2?� 2:C4C27E� @7� 7@C6:8?� C68:DECJ� E@� =2?5� :?� (9:=:AA:?6E6CC:E@CJ�@C�E@�D6:K6�@C�FDFCA�E96�4@?EC@=�E96C6@7�H9:=6�:E�:D�H:E9:?�E96�D2:5�E6CC:E@CJ

��/>;� F;D7BJO� ?I 4'%.75+10� 6'/214#. ?D� ?JI�C;:?KC� 7D: C7N?CKC�F;H?E:I� $<� F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I� EH� EJ>;H

9H?C;I�7H;� 9ECC?JJ;:�7I�7� H;IKBJ�EH�ED� J>; E997I?ED� J>;H;E<�� J>;�F;D7BJO� ?I 4'%.75+10�2'42'67#� $<� H7F;�

CKH:;H� EH� >EC?9?:;� ?I� 9ECC?JJ;:� 7I� 7� H;IKBJ� EH� ED� J>;� E997I?ED� E<� F?H79O�� EH� M>;D� J>;� E<<;D:;HI

787D:ED;:�J>;�L?9J?CI�M?J>EKJ�C;7DI�E<�I7L?D=�J>;CI;BL;I��EH�M>;D�J>;�I;?PKH;�?I�799ECFB?I>;:�8O�<?H?D=

KFED�EH�8E7H:?D=�7 L;II;B��J>;�C7D:7JEHO�F;D7BJO�?I�:;7J> ��

/>;� F;D7BJO ?I 4'%.75+10� 6'/214#. ?D� ?JI C?D?CKC� F;H?E:� $<� F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I� EH� EJ>;H� 9H?C;I� 7H;

9ECC?JJ;:�:KH?D=�EH�ED�J>;�E997I?ED�E<�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<�HE88;HO�EH�8H?=7D:7=;��J>;�F;D7BJO +5�4'%.75+10

6'/214#. ?D� ?JI� C;:?KC� 7D:� C7N?CKC� F;H?E:I� $<� A?:D7FF?D=� <EH� H7DIEC� EH� ;NJEHJ?ED�� EH� CKH:;H� EH

>EC?9?:;��EH�H7F;�?I�9ECC?JJ;:�7I�7�H;IKBJ�EH�ED�J>;�E997I?ED�J>;H;E<��J>;�F;D7BJO�?I�:;7J>��.;9�����

�DO�F;HIED�M>E�ADEM?D=BO�7D:�?D�7DO�C7DD;H�7?:I�EH�FHEJ;9JI�F?H7J;I�EH�>?=>M7O�HE88;HI�8H?=7D:I�

IK9>�7I�=?L?D=�J>;C�?D<EHC7J?ED�78EKJ�J>;�CEL;C;DJ�E<�FEB?9;�EH�EJ>;H�F;79;�E<<?9;HI�E<�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ�

EH�79GK?H;I�EH�H;9;?L;I�FHEF;HJO�J7A;D�8O�IK9>�F?H7J;I�EH�8H?=7D:I�EH� ?D�7DO�C7DD;H�:;H?L;I�7DO�8;D;<?J

J>;H;<HEC��EH�7DO�F;HIED�M>E�:?H;9JBO�EH�?D:?H;9JBO�78;JI�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<�F?H79O�EH�>?=>M7O�HE88;HO�EH

8H?=7D:7=;�� I>7BB� 8;� 9EDI?:;H;:� 7I� 7D� 799ECFB?9;� E<� J>;� FH?D9?F7B� E<<;D:;HI� 7D:� 8;� FKD?I>;:� ?D

799EH:7D9;�M?J>�J>;�-KB;I�FH;I9H?8;:�8O�J>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:;

$J I>7BB�8;�FH;IKC;:�J>7J�7DO�F;HIED�M>E�:E;I�7DO�E<�J>;�79JI�FHEL?:;:�?D�J>?I�.;9J?ED�>7I�F;H<EHC;:

ADEM?D=BO��KDB;II�J>;�9EDJH7HO�?I�FHEL;D��.;9������

+������ ��

.;9� �

�D�7?H9H7<J�?I�?D�<B?=>J�<HEC�J>;�CEC;DJ�7BB�?JI�;NJ;HD7B�:EEHI�7H;�9BEI;:�<EBBEM?D=�;C87HA7J?ED�KDJ?B�7DO

E<�IK9>�:EEHI�?I�EF;D;:�<EH�:?I;C87HA7J?ED

Page 43: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

.� �@8,9�&0.@=4?D��.?�:1�����

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>�:1�?0==:=4>8

�?J�A6CD@?�H9@�4@>>:ED�2?�24E�AF?:D923=6�F?56C�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�AC@G:D:@?D�@7E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56�

2 (:C24J :?��6?6C2=�2?5�%FE:?J�:?�E96� :89�+62D�@C�:?�E96�(9:=:AA:?6�/2E6CD���

3 *636==:@?�@C�!?DFCC64E:@?���

4 �/50�$���4!4���� :?4=F5:?8�24ED�4@>>:EE65�3J�AC:G2E6�A6CD@?D

5��%FC56C���

6 #:5?2AA:?8�2?5�+6C:@FD�!==682=��6E6?E:@?���

7���C:>6D�!?G@=G:?8��6DECF4E:@?���� @C�F?56C

��,96�$2H�@?��CD@?���

,@I:4� +F3DE2?46D� 2?5� 2K2C5@FD� 2?5� &F4=62C� /2DE6� �@?EC@=� �4E� @7�������

� �E@>:4��?6C8J�*68F=2E@CJ�2?5�$:23:=:EJ��4E�@7��������

���?E:� :;24<:?8�$2H��

� �?E:�(:C24J�2?5��?E:� :89H2J�*@336CJ�$2H�@7��������� 2?5�

� �64C66 �@5:7J:?8� E96� $2HD� @?� !==682=� 2?5� -?=2H7F=� (@DD6DD:@?�%2?F724EFC6�� �62=:?8� :?�� �4BF:D:E:@?� @C� �:DA@D:E:@?� @7� �:C62C>D��>>F?:E:@?D�@C��IA=@D:G6D���

��-������

���HJ� ��

���HJ� ��

���HJ� ��7

���HJ����

���HJ����

���HJ����

��+���)E� � �

��-���)E�����

� -���)E�����

��-���)E�����

��+���)E����

��+���)E� �����7I 7C;D:;:

Page 44: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

E96C63J D@H:?8� 2?5� 4C62E:?8� 2� 4@?5:E:@?� @7� H:56DAC625� 2?5� 6IEC2@C5:?2CJ� 762C� 2?5� A2?:42>@?8�E96�A@AF=246�� :?�@C56C�E@�4@6C46�E96�8@G6C?>6?E�E@�8:G6� :?�E@�2?�F?=2H7F=�56>2?5D92==�36�8F:=EJ�@7�E96�4C:>6�@7�E6CC@C:D>���

44��*3:�,=0�74,-70

� (6CD@?D�H9@�4@?DA:C6�E@ 4@>>:E�E96�4C:>6�@7�E6CC@C:D>���

�?J� A6CD@?�H9@�� ?@E� 36:?8� 2� AC:?4:A2=��� @C� 2� 4@?DA:C2E@C���� 4@@A6C2E6D� :?� E966I64FE:@?�@7�6:E96C�E96�4C:>6�@7�E6CC@C:D>�@C�4@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�E6CC@C:D>�3J�AC6G:@FD�@CD:>F=E2?6@FD�24ED���

� �?J�A6CD@?�H9@��92G:?8 <?@H=6586�@7�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�E96�4C:>6�@7�E6CC@C:D>@C� 4@?DA:C24J� E@� 4@>>:E� E6CC@C:D>�� 2?5� H:E9@FE� 92G:?8� A2CE:4:A2E65� E96C6:?�� 6:E96C� 2DAC:?4:A2=�@C�244@>A=:46���� E2<6D�A2CE�DF3D6BF6?E�E@� :ED�4@>>:DD:@?� :?�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8>2??6C�

�2��3J AC@7:E:?8�9:>D6=7�@C�2DD:DE:?8�E96�@776?56C�E@�AC@7:E�3J�E96�67764ED�@7�E964C:>6�

�3�� 3J� 4@?462=:?8� @C� 56DEC@J:?8� E96� 3@5J� @7� E96� 4C:>6�� @C� E96� 67764ED�� @C:?DECF>6?ED�E96C6@7��:?�@C56C�E@�AC6G6?E�:ED�5:D4@G6CJ�

�4�� 3J 92C3@C:?8�� 4@?462=:?8�� @C� 2DD:DE:?8� :?� E96� 6D42A6� @7� E96� AC:?4:A2=� @C4@?DA:C2E@C�@7�E96�4C:>6���

��/>;�F;D7BJO�?I <EHJO������O;7HI�E<�?CFH?IEDC;DJ��M?J>EKJ�J>;�8;D;<?J�E<�F7HEB;�7I�FHEL?:;:�<EH�KD:;H��9J

)E�� ����EJ>;HM?I;�ADEMD�7I�J>;�$D:;J;HC?D7J;�.;DJ;D9;�'7M��7I�7C;D:;:��.;9��� ��

�EDIF?H79O�JE��ECC?J�/;HHEH?IC

/>;H;�?I�9EDIF?H79O M>;D�JME�EH�CEH;�F;HIEDI�9EC;�JE�7D�7=H;;C;DJ�9ED9;HD?D=�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<

J>;�9H?C;�E<�J;HHEH?IC�7I�:;<?D;:�?D�.;9J?ED���>;H;E<�7D:�:;9?:;�JE�9ECC?J�J>;�I7C;��.;9���

/>;�F;D7BJO�?I <EHJO������O;7HI�E<�?CFH?IEDC;DJ ��

KD:;H��HJ ��E<�J>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:; ��

7I�:;<?D;:�?D�.;9J?ED�� J>;H;E< ��

�99ECFB?9; �.;9���

/>;� F;D7BJO� ?I <HEC� I;L;DJ;;D� � ��� O;7HI�� <EKH� ���� CEDJ>I� ED;� :7O� JE� JM;DJO� ����� O;7HI� E<

?CFH?IEDC;DJ ��

KD:;H��HJI ��7D:� ��E<�J>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:; �.;;�-;<;H;D9;� �

�99;IIEHO

Page 45: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

����>591?��3-5:?@�@41��A:0-91:@-8� -C?�;2�@41�'@-@1

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED

�>.5@>->E�01@1:@5;:�� 2�'776?56C :D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3�� 6�56E2:?D�2�A6CD@?���

4 ,96�56E6?E:@?�H2D�H:E9@FE�=682=�8C@F?5D

���HJ� ��

�B7II;I�E<��H8?JH7HO��;J;DJ?ED�

7 �O�:;J7?D?D=�7�F;HIED�M?J>EKJ�B;=7B�=HEKD:

8 �;B7O�?D�J>;�:;B?L;HO�E<�:;J7?D;:�F;HIEDI�JE�J>;�FHEF;H�@K:?9?7B�7KJ>EH?J?;I

�;J;DJ?ED��M>;D�7�F;HIED�?I�FB79;:�?D�9ED<?D;C;DJ�EH�J>;H;�?I 7�H;IJH7?DJ�ED�>?I�F;HIED

/>EK=>�J>;�;B;C;DJI�IF;9?<O�J>7J�J>;�E<<;D:;H�8;�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�EH�;CFBEO;;��FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7BI�M>E

9EDIF?H;�M?J>�FK8B?9�E<<?9;HI�97D�7BIE�8;�B?78B;

';=7B�=HEKD:I�<EH�J>;�:;J;DJ?ED�E<�7DO�F;HIED�

7 9ECC?II?ED�E<�7�9H?C;

8 L?EB;DJ�?DI7D?JO�EH�EJ>;H�7?BC;DJ�H;GK?H?D=�9ECFKBIEHO�9ED<?D;C;DJ�E<�J>;�F7J?;DJ�?D�7�>EIF?J7B

2?J>EKJ�B;=7B�=HEKD:I�

7 >;�>7I�DEJ�9ECC?JJ;:�7DO�9H?C;�EH�DE�H;7IED78B;�=HEKD:�E<�IKIF?9?ED�J>7J�>;�>7I�9ECC?JJ;:�7

9H?C;

8 DEJ�IK<<;H?D=� <HEC�L?EB;DJ� ?DI7D?JO EH�7DO�EJ>;H�7?BC;DJ�H;GK?H?D=�9ECFKBIEHO�9ED<?D;C;DJ� ?D�7

>EIF?J7B

"HEKD:I�<EH�M7HH7DJB;II�7HH;IJ�

7 �H?C;�?I�78EKJ�JE�8;��?I�8;?D=��>7I�8;;D�9ECC?JJ;:

8 *<<?9;H�CKIJ�>7L;�H;7IED78B;�ADEMB;:=;�J>7J�J>;�F;HIED�FHE878BO�9ECC?JJ;:�J>;�9H?C;

!EH�;I97F;:�FH?IED;H W DE�D;;:�<EH�M7HH7DJ ��

79JK7B�H;IJH7?DJ

Page 46: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�18-E� 5:� @41� 0185B1>E� ;2� 01@-5:10<1>?;:?���

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3 6�92D�56E2:?65 2�A6CD@?�7@C�D@>6�=682=�8C@F?5

4� 6 72:=D� E@� 56=:G6C� DF49� A6CD@?� E@� E96� AC@A6C;F5:4:2=�2FE9@C:EJ�H:E9:?�

� � � 9@FCD�� :7� 56E2:?65� 7@C� 4C:>6D@776?D6DAF?:D923=6�3J�=:89E�A6?2=E:6D��@C�E96:C�6BF:G2=6?E

��� 9@FCD�� 7@C� 4C:>6D@776?D6D� AF?:D923=63J�4@CC64E:@?2=�A6?2=E:6D� @C�E96:C�6BF:G2=6?E�@C

� ��� 9@FCD�� 7@C� 4C:>6D@776?D6D� AF?:D923=63J�42A:E2=�AF?:D9>6?E�@C277=:4E:G6�A6?2=E:6D��@C�E96:C�6BF:G2=6?E

�18-E5:3�>181-?1��� 2�'776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3� ,96C6� :D� 2� ;F5:4:2=� @C� 6I64FE:G6� @C56C 7@C� E96C6=62D6�@7� 2�AC:D@?6C�@C�56E6?E:@?�AC:D@?6C��@C� E92EE96C6� :D� 2� AC@4665:?8� FA@?� 2� A6E:E:@?� 7@C� E96=:36C2E:@?�@7�DF49�A6CD@?

4�'776?56C�H:E9@FE�8@@5�C62D@?�56=2JD�

��E96�D6CG:46�@7�E96�?@E:46�@7�DF49�@C56C�E@�E96

���HJ� ��

�;J;DJ?ED� ?I� B;=7B� ?D� J>;� 8;=?DD?D=�� 8KJ� ?BB;=7B?JO� IJ7HJI� <HEC� J>;� ;NF?H7J?ED� E<� J>;� IF;9?<?;:� F;H?E:I

M?J>EKJ�J>;�F;HIEDI�:;J7?D;:�>7L?D=�8;;D�:;B?L;H;:�JE�J>;�FHEF;H�@K:?9?7B�7KJ>EH?JO

-;7BBO�C;7DI� :;B7O� ?D� <?B?D=� D;9;II7HO� ?D<EHC7J?ED� EH� 9>7H=?D=� E<� F;HIED� :;J7?D;:� ?D� 9EKHJ�(7O� 8;

M7?L;:�?<�7�FH;B?C?D7HO�?DL;IJ?=7J?ED�?I�7IA;:�<EH

�E;I� DEJ� 9EDJ;CFB7J;� 79JK7B� F>OI?97B� :;B?L;HO� 8KJ� 7J� B;7IJ� J>;H;� CKIJ� 8;� 7� 9ECFB7?DJ� <?B;:� �KJO

9ECFB?;:�M?J>�KFED�J>;� <?B?D=�E<� J>;�9ECFB7?DJ�M?J>�J>;� @K:?9?7B�7KJ>EH?JO� �9EKHJI��FHEI;9KJEHI W J>EK=>

J;9>D?97BBO�DEJ�7�@K:?9?7B�7KJ>EH?JO��<EH�FKHFEI;I�E<�J>?I�7HJ?9B;��>;YI�9EDI?:;H;:�7I�ED;�

/>;� <?B?D=�E<� J>;� ?D<EHC7J?ED� ?D� 9EKHJ�:E;I�DEJ� 9KH;� ?BB;=7B?JO�E<� :;J;DJ?ED�);?J>;H� :E;I� ?J� 7<<;9J� J>;

B;=7B?JO�E<�J>;�9ED<?D;C;DJ�KD:;H�FHE9;II�?IIK;:�8O�J>;�9EKHJ

/E�;I97F;�<HEC�J>?I��E<<?9;HI�KIK7BBO�7IA�799KI;:�JE�;N;9KJ;�7�M7?L;H�M>?9>�I>EKB:�8;�KD:;H�E7J>�7D:

M?J>�7II?IJ7D9;�E<�9EKDI;B�.K9>�M7?L;H�?I�DEJ�L?EB7J?L;�E<�J>;�799KI;:YI 9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B�H?=>J

2>7J�?I�B;D=J>�E<�M7?L;H��'?=>J�E<<;DI; W ��:7OI�.;H?EKI�7D:�B;II�I;H?EKI�E<<;DI;I W ��JE� ��:7OI��%K:=;

+?C;DJ;B�

�HJ?9B;�:E;I�DEJ�7FFBO�M>;D�7HH;IJ�?I�L?7�7�M7HH7DJ�E<�7HH;IJ

$<�E<<;D:;H�?I�7�FH?L7J;�F;HIED��9H?C;�?I�?BB;=7B�:;J;DJ?ED ��

�HJ ��

27H:;DI�7D:�@7?B;HI�7H;�J>;�F;HIEDI�CEIJ�B?A;BO�JE�L?EB7J;�J>?I�FHEL?I?ED

+HEL?I?ED�:E;I�DEJ�?D9BK:;�B;=?IB7J?ED

Page 47: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

AC:D@?6C��@C

E96�A6C7@C>2?46�@7�DF49�;F5:4:2=�@C�6I64FE:G6@C56C�7@C�E96�C6=62D6�@7�E96�AC:D@?6C��@C

�� E96� AC@4665:?8D� FA@?� 2� A6E:E:@?� 7@C� E96C6=62D6�@7�DF49�A6CD@?

�D<A8?5;:��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3 6� 6IA6=D� 2?J� A6CD@?� 7C@> E96�(9:=:AA:?6D�� @C4@>A6=D�2�A6CD@?�E@�492?86�9:D�C6D:56?46

4 6 :D�?@E�2FE9@C:K65�E@�5@�D@�3J�=2H

*5;8-@5;:�;2�0;95/581��� 2���'776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3� � 6� :D� ?@E� 2FE9@C:K65�3J� ;F5:4:2=� @C56C� E@� 6?E6CE96� 5H6==:?8� 2?5@C� E@�>2<6� 2� D62C49� � E96C6:?� 7@CA2A6CD�@C�@E96C�67764ED

4��� 6�4@>>:ED�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

���HJ� ��

��79JI�FKD?I>78B;�

7 8O�;NF;BB?D= 7�F;HIED�<HEC�J>;�+>?B?FF?D;I

8 8O�9ECF;BB?D=�7�F;HIED�JE�9>7D=;�>?I�H;I?:;D9;

/>;� 9H?C;� E<� ;NFKBI?ED� 78IEH8I� J>7J� E<� =H7L;� 9E;H9?ED� $<� :ED;� 8O� 7� FH?L7J;� F;HIED��M?BB� 7CEKDJ� JE

=H7L;�9E;H9?ED

�E;I�DEJ�?D9BK:;�KD:;I?H78B;�7B?;DI� &'56+'441��EH�M>;D�I;DJ�JE�FH?IED

$<� 3� �!?B?F?DE�� 7<J;H� >;� LEBKDJ7H?BO� B;<J�� ?I� H;<KI;:� H;;DJHO W ?I� 9EDI?:;H;:� <EH9?D=� >?C� JE� 9>7D=;� >?I

7::H;II�>;H;

/>H;7J�JE�D7J?ED7B�I;9KH?JO�?I�DEJ�7�=HEKD:�JE�;NF;B�EH�9>7D=;�>?I�7::H;II ��

�HJ� ��

$<�J>;�E<<;D:;H M>E�;DJ;HI�J>;�:M;BB?D=�7=7?DIJ�J>;�M?BB�E<�J>;�EMD;H�J>;H;E<�?I�7�FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B��J>;

9H?C;�9ECC?JJ;:�?I�JH;IF7II�JE�:M;BB?D=���HJ�����

2>;D� 7� FK8B?9� E<<?9;H� I;7H9>;:� 7� F;HIED� ZEKJI?:;� >?I� :M;BB?D=[� M?J>EKJ� 7� I;7H9>� M7HH7DJ� 7D:� IK9>

F;HIED�?I�DEJ�B;=7BBO�7HH;IJ;:�<EH�7D�E<<;DI;��J>;�9H?C;�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�?I�=H7L;�9E;H9?ED��?<

L?EB;D9;�EH� ?DJ?C?:7J?ED� ?I�KI;:� ��HJ�������EH�KD@KIJ�L;N7J?ED�� ?<� J>;H;� ?I�DE�L?EB;D9;�EH� ?DJ?C?:7J?ED� ��HJ

����

�� FK8B?9� E<<?9;H�M?J>EKJ� 7� I;7H9>�M7HH7DJ� 97DDEJ� B7M<KBBO� ;DJ;H� J>;� :M;BB?D=� 7=7?DIJ� J>;� M?BB� E<� J>;

EMD;H��;L;D�?<�>;�AD;M�J>7J�IEC;ED;�?D�J>7J�:M;BB?D=�?I�>7L?D=�KDB7M<KB�FEII;II?ED�E<�EF?KC

Z�;?D=� 7KJ>EH?P;:� 8O� B7M[ W C;7DI� M?J>� I;7H9>� M7HH7DJ�� I7L;� >?CI;B<� EH� :E� IEC;� J>?D=I� =EE:� <EH

>KC7D?JO

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�;NFH;II?ED�J>7J�;DJHO�?I�:;D?;:�EH�J>7J�>;�?I�7IA;:�JE�B;7L;

+7F;HI�7D:�;<<;9JI�D;;:�DEJ�8;�F7HJ�E<�7�9H?C;

Page 48: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

� 6?E6C:?8�2?J�5H6==:?8�282:?DE�E96�H:==�@7�E96@H?6C�E96C6@7�

� D62C49:?8� A2A6CD� @C� @E96C� 67764ED� 7@F?5E96C6:?� H:E9@FE� E96� AC6G:@FD� 4@?D6?E� @7� DF49@H?6C�

�� C67FD:?8� E@� =62G6� E96�AC6>:D6D��27E6C�92G:?8DFCC6AE:E:@FD=J� 6?E6C65� D2:5� 5H6==:?8� 2?5� 27E6C92G:?8�366?�C6BF:C65�E@�=62G6�E96�D2>6�

'1->/4� C->>-:@?� 9-85/5;A?8E;.@-5:10

-:0

�.A?1� 5:� @41� ?1>B5/1� ;2� @4;?1813-88E�;.@-5:10��

2���'776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3�� 6�AC@4FC6D�2�D62C49�H2CC2?E

4���,96C6�:D�?@�;FDE�42FD6

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3 6�92D�=682==J�AC@4FC65�2�D62C49�H2CC2?E

4� 6� 6I4665D� 9:D� 2FE9@C:EJ @C� FD6D� F??646DD2CJD6G6C:EJ�:?�6I64FE:?8�E96�D2>6

���HJ?9B;� ��

�8KI;� ?D� J>;� I;HL?9;� E<�M7HH7DJ� EH� ;N9;;:?D=� 7KJ>EH?JO� EH� KI?D=� KDD;9;II7HO� I;L;H?JO� ?D� ;N;9KJ?D=� 7

I;7H9>�M7HH7DJ�B;=7BBO�FHE9KH;:

.;7H9>�M7HH7DJ�?I�L7B?:�<EH� ��:7OI�<HEC�?JI�:7J;

.;7H9>� M7HH7DJ� ?I� 7D� EH:;H� ?D� MH?J?D=� ?IIK;:� ?D� J>;� D7C;� E<� J>;� +;EFB;�� I?=D;:� 8O� J>;� @K:=;� 7D:

:?H;9J;:�JE�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H��9ECC7D:?D=�>?C�JE�I;7H9>�<EH�F;HIED7B�FHEF;HJO�:;I9H?8;:�J>;H;?D�7D:�8H?D=

?J�8;<EH;�J>;�9EKHJ

)E�@KIJ�97KI; W M7HH7DJ�?I�KD@KIJ?<?;:

.;7H9> W B?C?J;:�JE�M>7J�?I�:;I9H?8;:�?D�J>;�M7HH7DJ��7BB�:;J7?BI�CKIJ�8;�M?J>�F7HJ?9KB7H?JO

(7B?9?EKI�M7HH7DJ� N7CFB;�3�M7I�7�H;IFED:;DJ�E<�7�I;7H9>�M7HH7DJ�<EH�?BB;=7B�FEII;II?ED�E<�<?H;7HCI

��H;JKHD�M7I�C7:;�/>;�=KD�:?:�DEJ�8;BED=�JE�3�7D:�J>;�M?JD;II�>7:�DE�F;HIED7B�ADEMB;:=;�J>7J�J>;H;�?I

7�=KD�?D�J>7J�FB79;

�8KI;� N7CFB;I�

7 3�EMD;H�M7I�>7D:9K<<;:�M>?B;�I;7H9>�M7I�=E?D=ED

8 /7DA�M7I�KI;:�JE�H7C�=7J;�FH?EH�JE�7DDEKD9;C;DJ�J>7J��7�I;7H9>�M?BB�8;�C7:;

9 +;HIEDI�M>E�M;H;�DEJ�H;IFED:;DJI�M;H;�I;7H9>;:

Page 49: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

'1->/45:3� 0;95/581� C5@4;A@C5@:1??1?���

2��'776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3� � 6� :D� 2C>65� H:E9� 2� D62C49� H2CC2?E� =682==JAC@4FC65

4� 6� D62C496D� E96� 5@>:4:=6�� A2A6CD� @C� @E96C36=@?8:?8D�@7�2?J�A6CD@?

5�,96�@H?6C��@C�2?J�>6>36C�@7�9:D�72>:=J��@C�EH@H:E?6DD6D� C6D:5:?8� :?� E96� D2>6� =@42=:EJ� 2C6� ?@EAC6D6?E

$>;45.5@5;:��5:@1>>A<@5;:��-:005??;8A@5;:�;2�<1-/12A8911@5:3?���

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3 6�A6C7@C>D�2?J @7�E96�77�24ED�

�� AC@9:3:E:?8� @C� :?E6CCFAE:?8�� H:E9@FE� =682=8C@F?5� E96� 9@=5:?8� @7� 2� A62467F=� >66E:?8�� @C5:DD@=G:?8�E96�D2>6���

� 9:?56C:?8� 2?J� A6CD@?� 7C@>� ;@:?:?8� 2?J=2H7F=� 2DD@4:2E:@?� @C� 7C@>� 2EE6?5:?8� 2?J� @7� :ED

���HJ?9B;� ��

*H:;H�E<�J>EI;�M>E�CKIJ�M?JD;II�J>;�I;7H9>�

7 #EC;EMD;H

8 (;C8;HI�E<�J>;�<7C?BO�E<�IK<<?9?;DJ�7=;�7D:�:?I9H;J?ED

9 -;IFEDI?8B;�C;C8;HI�E<�J>;�9ECCKD?JO��97DYJ�8;�?D<BK;D9;:�8O�J>;�I;7H9>?D=�F7HJO�

17B?:?JO�E<�J>;�I;7H9>�M7HH7DJ�97D�8;�GK;IJ?ED;:�EDBO� ?D���9EKHJI��M>;H;� ?IIK;: EH�M>;H;�J>;�97I;� ?I

F;D:?D=�'7JJ;H�?I�FH;<;HH;:�<EH�E8@;9J?L;�:;J;HC?D7J?ED ��

�HJ?9B;� �

+HE>?8?J?D=�EH�>?D:;H?D=�7DO�F;HIED�<HEC�7::H;II?D=��;?J>;H�7BED;�EH�JE=;J>;H�M?J>�EJ>;HI��7DO�F;J?J?ED

JE�J>;�7KJ>EH?J?;I�<EH�J>;�9EHH;9J?ED�E<�78KI;I�EH�H;:H;II�E<�=H?;L7D9;I

$<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�7�FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B��J>;�9H?C;�?I�:?IJKH87D9;�E<�FK8B?9�EH:;H���HJ� ���

(;;J?D=�CKIJ�8;�F;79;<KB�7D:�J>;H;�?I�DE�B;=7B�=HEKD:�<EH�FHE>?8?J?D=��:?IIEBL?D=�EH�?DJ;HHKFJ?D=�J>7J

C;;J?D=

(;;J?D=�?I�IK8@;9J�JE�H;=KB7J?ED

*<<;D:;H�CKIJ�8;�7�IJH7D=;H��DEJ�7�F7HJ?9?F7DJ��?D�J>;�F;79;<KB�C;;J?D=��EJ>;HM?I;��?JYI�KD@KIJ�L;N7J?ED

$DJ;HHKFJ?D=�7D:�:?IIEBL?D=�7�C;;J?D=�E<�J>;�CKD?9?F7B�9EKD9?B�8O�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�?I�7�9H?C;�7=7?DIJ�J>;

B;=?IB7J?L;�8E:O��DEJ�FKD?I>78B;�KD:;H�J>?I�7HJ?9B;

/>;�F;HIED�J7BA?D=�ED�7�FHE>?8?J;:�IK8@;9J�7J�7�FK8B?9�C;;J?D=�9EDJH7HO�JE�7=H;;C;DJ�J>7J�DE�IF;7A;H

I>EKB:�JEK9>�ED�FEB?J?9I�C7O�8;�IJEFF;:

�KJ�IJEFF?D=�J>;�IF;7A;H�M>E�M7I�7JJ79A?D=�9;HJ7?D�9>KH9>;I� ?D�FK8B?9�C;;J?D=� ?I�7�L?EB7J?ED�E<� J>?I

7HJ?9B;

+HE>?8?J?ED�CKIJ�8;�M?J>EKJ�B7M<KB�97KI;�EH�M?J>EKJ�B7M<KB�7KJ>EH?JO

/>EI;� >EB:?D=� F;79;<KB� C;;J?D=I� CKIJ� 9ECFBO� M?J>� BE97B� EH:?D7D9;I� N7CFB;�� *H:?D7D9;� H;GK?H;I

F;HC?JI�<EH�C;;J?D=I�?D�FK8B?9�FB79;I��KJ�?<�FEB?9;�IJEFI�7�C;;J?D=�?D�7�FH?L7J;�FB79;�8;97KI;�J>;H;YI�DE

F;HC?J��E<<?9;H�?I�B?78B;�<EH�IJEFF?D=�J>;�C;;J?D= �

;= :;D?7B�E<�F;HC?J�?D�7H8?JH7HO�C7DD;H

Page 50: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

>66E:?8D

�:@1>>A<@5;:� ;2� >18535;A?C;>?45<��

2��'776?56C :D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3� *6=:8:@FD� 46C6>@?:6D� @C� >2?:76DE2E:@?D� @7� 2?JC6=:8:@?�2C6�23@FE�E@�E2<6�A=246�@C�2C6�8@:?8�@?

4�� 6 AC6G6?ED�@C�5:DEFC3D�E96�D2>6

#221:05:3�>18535;A?�21185:3?��� 2�,96�24ED�4@>A=2:?65�@7�H6C6�A6C7@C>65 L

� :?�2�A=246�56G@E65�E@�C6=:8:@FD�766=:?8D���� @C 5FC:?8� E96� 46=63C2E:@?� @7� 2?J� C6=:8:@FD

46C6>@?J

3� � ,96� 24ED�>FDE� 36� ?@E@C:@FD=J� @776?D:G6� E@� E96766=:?8D�@7�E96�72:E97F=���

4���'776?56C�:D�2?J�A6CD@?

5��,96C6�:D�2�56=:36C2E6�:?E6?E�E@�9FCE�E96�766=:?8D�@7E96�72:E97F=��5:C64E65�282:?DE�C6=:8:@FD�E6?6E

���HJ� ��

�?H9KCIJ7D9;�GK7B?<O?D=�J>;�E<<;DI;��?<�9ECC?JJ;:�M?J>�L?EB;D9;�EH�J>H;7JI

-;7:?D=� E<� �?8B;� 7D:� J>;D� 7JJ79A?D=� 9;HJ7?D� 9>KH9>;I� ?D� 7� FK8B?9� FB7P7� ?I� DEJ� 7� 9;H;CEDO� EH

C7D?<;IJ7J?ED� E<� H;B?=?ED�� 8KJ EDBO� 7�C;;J?D=� E<� 7� H;B?=?EKI� I;9J� �KJ� ?<� :ED;� ?D� 7� FH?L7J;� >EC;�� ?JYI� 7

H;B?=?EKI�I;HL?9;

-;B?=?EKI� 2EHI>?F�� F;EFB;� ?D� J>;� 79J� E<� F;H<EHC?D=� H;B?=?EKI� H?J;I� <EH� 7� H;B?=?EKI� 9;H;CEDO�� 7

C7D?<;IJ7J?ED�E<�H;B?=?ED� N�(7II��87FJ?IC��C7HH?7=;

3�� 7� FH?L7J;� F;HIED�� 8EN;:� 7� FH?;IJ� M>?B;� J>;� FH?;IJ� M7I� =?L?D=� >EC?BO� 7D:� M>?B;� J>;� B7JJ;H� M7I

C7B?=D?D=�7�H;B7J?L;�E<�3�$I�3�B?78B;��3�C7O�8;�B?78B;�KD:;H��HJ ���8;97KI;�3�?I�7�FH?L7J;�F;HIED

2>;D�FH?;IJ�?I�IEB;CD?P?D=�C7HH?7=;��>;�?I�7�F;HIED�?D�7KJ>EH?JO��7BJ>EK=>�?D�EJ>;H�97I;I��>;YI�DEJ ��

�HJ� ��

$<�?D�7�FB79;�:;LEJ;:�JE�H;B?=?EKI�FKHFEI;��J>;H;�?I�DE�D;;:�<EH�7D�ED=E?D=�H;B?=?EKI�9;H;CEDO

N7CFB;�E<� H;B?=?EKI�9;H;CEDO��79JI�F;H<EHC;:�EKJI?:;�J>;�9>KH9>��+HE9;II?EDI�7D:�IF;9?7B FH7O;HI

<EH�8KHO?D=�:;7:�F;HIEDI�8KJ�DEJ�FH7O;H�H7BB?;I

�9JI� CKIJ� 8;� :?H;9J;:� 7=7?DIJ� H;B?=?EKI� FH79J?9;� EH� :E=C7� EH� H?JK7B� <EH� J>;� FKHFEI;� E<� H?:?9KB;�� 7I

CE9A?D=�EH�I9E<<?D=�EH�7JJ;CFJ?D=�JE�:7C7=;�7D�E8@;9J�E<�H;B?=?EKI�L;D;H7J?ED

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�:;B?8;H7J;�?DJ;DJ�JE�>KHJ�J>;�<;;B?D=I�E<�J>;�<7?J><KB��C;H;�7HHE=7D9;�EH�HK:;D;II�?I�DEJ

;DEK=> ��

<EH�J>?I�;B;C;DJ��DE�D;;:�E<�H;B?=?EKI�9;H;CEDO��EDBO�J>;�FB79;�?I�C7J;H?7B ��

:;B?8;H7J;�?DJ;DJ�JE�>KHJ�J>;�<;;B?D=I

Page 51: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

�C:>6 &2EFC6�@7��C:>6 /9@�2C6�$:23=6 !7��=6>6?E�%:DD:?8

(C@9:3:E:@?�!?E6CCFAE:@?� 2?5�:DD@=FE:@?� @7(62467F=�%66E:?8

�C:>6� 282:?DE� E967F?52>6?E2=� =2H� @7E96�DE2E6

(F3=:4� @77:46CD�'FED:56CD

!7� ?@E� 3J� AF3=:4� @77:46C� �EF>F=ED

!?E6CCFAE:@?� @7*6=:8:@FD/@CD9:A

�C:>6� 282:?DE� E967F?52>6?E2=� =2H� @7E96�DE2E6

(F3=:4� @77:46CD�'FED:56CD

!7� 3J� :?D:56C� �� F?;FDEG6I2E:@?!7�?@E�C6=:8:@FD ��EF>F=E�@C2=2C>D!7�?@E�?@E@C:@FD=J�@776?D:G6��F?;FDE�G6I2E:@?

'776?5:?8� E96*6=:8:@FD��66=:?8

�C:>6�282:?DE�AF3=:4@C56C

(F3=:4� @77:46CD�AC:G2E6� A6CD@?D�@FED:56CD

!7� ?@E� EF>F=ED� �� 2=2C>D2?5�D42?52=!7�>66E:?8�:==682=�2E�@?D6E��:?4:E:?8� E@ D65:E:@?� @CC636==:@?

,� �@8,9�&0.@=4?D��.?�:1������

���#0=4:/�:1�/0?09?4:9

,96� AC@G:D:@?D� @7� �CE:4=6� � ���� @7� E96� *6G:D65� (6?2=� �@56� E@� E96� 4@?EC2CJ?@EH:E9DE2?5:?8�� 2?J� A@=:46� @C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� A6CD@??6=�� H9@�� 92G:?8� 366?� 5F=J2FE9@C:K65�:?�HC:E:?8�3J�E96��?E:�,6CC@C:D>��@F?4:=�92D�E2<6?�4FDE@5J�@7�2�A6CD@?�492C865H:E9�@C�DFDA64E65�@7�E96�4C:>6�@7�E6CC@C:D>�@C�E96�4C:>6�@7�4@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�E6CC@C:D>D92==��H:E9@FE�:?4FCC:?8�2?J�4C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ�7@C�56=2J�:?�E96�56=:G6CJ�@7�56E2:?65�A6CD@?D�E@E96�AC@A6C�;F5:4:2=�2FE9@C:E:6D��56=:G6C�D2:5�492C865�@C�DFDA64E65�A6CD@?�E@�E96�AC@A6C�;F5:4:2=2FE9@C:EJ�H:E9:?�2�A6C:@5�@7� E9C66 ��� 52JD� 4@F?E65� 7C@>� E96�>@>6?E� E96� D2:5� 492C865�@CDFDA64E65�A6CD@?�92D�366?�2AAC696?565�@C�2CC6DE65��56E2:?65��2?5�E2<6?�:?E@�4FDE@5J�3J�E96D2:5� A@=:46�� @C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� A6CD@??6=� ,96� 2CC6DE� @7� E9@D6� DFDA64E65� @7� E96� 4C:>6� @7E6CC@C:D>�@C�4@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�E6CC@C:D>�>FDE�C6DF=E�7C@>�E96�DFCG6:==2?46�F?56C�+64E:@?���� 2?5�6I2>:?2E:@?�@7�32?<�56A@D:ED�F?56C�+64E:@?� ���� @7�E9:D��4E

,96� A@=:46� @C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� A6CD@??6=� 4@?46C?65� D92==�� 367@C6� 56E2:?:?8� E96A6CD@?� DFDA64E65� @7� E96� 4C:>6� @7� E6CC@C:D>�� AC6D6?E� 9:>� @C� 96C� 367@C6� 2?J� ;F586� 2E� E96=2EE6C�D�C6D:56?46�@C�@77:46�?62C6DE�E96�A=246�H96C6�E96�2CC6DE�E@@<�A=246�2E 2?J�E:>6�@7�E96�52J

��-������

��.;;�-;<;H;D9;

��$8?:

��$8?:

Page 52: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

@C�?:89E�!E�D92==�36�E96�5FEJ�@7�E96�;F586��2>@?8�@E96C�E9:?8D��E@�2D46CE2:?�E96�:56?E:EJ�@7�E96A@=:46� @C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� A6CD@??6=� 2?5� E96� A6CD@?� @C� A6CD@?D� E96J� 92G6� 2CC6DE65� 2?5AC6D6?E65� 367@C6� 9:>� @C� 96C�� E@� :?BF:C6� @7� E96>� E96 C62D@?D� H9J� E96J� 92G6� 2CC6DE65� E96A6CD@?�2?5�56E6C>:?6�3J�BF6DE:@?:?8�2?5�A6CD@?2=�@3D6CG2E:@?�H96E96C�@C�?@E�E96�DFDA64E92D�366?�DF3;64E65�E@�2?J�A9JD:42=��>@C2=�@C�ADJ49@=@8:42=�E@CEFC6�3J�H9@>�2?5�H9J�,96;F586�D92==�E96?�DF3>:E�2�HC:EE6?�C6A@CE�@7�H92E�96D96�925�@3D6CG65�H96?�E96�DF3;64E�H2D3C@F89E�367@C6�9:>�E@�E96�AC@A6C�4@FCE�E92E�92D�;FC:D5:4E:@?�@G6C�E96�42D6�@7�E96�A6CD@?�E9FD2CC6DE65�,96�;F586�D92==�7@CE9H:E9�DF3>:E�9:D96C�C6A@CE�H:E9:?�E9C66�42=6?52C�52JD�7C@>�E96E:>6�E96�DFDA64E�H2D�3C@F89E�E@�9:D96C�C6D:56?46�@C�@77:46

!>>65:2E6=J�27E6C�E2<:?8�4FDE@5J�@7�2�A6CD@?�492C865�H:E9�@C�DFDA64E65�@7�E96�4C:>6@7� E6CC@C:D>� @C� 4@?DA:C24J� E@� 4@>>:E� E6CC@C:D>�� E96� A@=:46� @C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� A6CD@??6=D92==� ?@E:7J� :?�HC:E:?8� E96� ;F586� @7� E96� 4@FCE ?62C6DE� E96� A=246� @7� 2AAC696?D:@?� @C� 2CC6DE�(C@G:565��,92E�H96C6�E96�2CC6DE� :D�>256�5FC:?8�+2EFC52JD��+F?52JD��9@=:52JD�@C�27E6C�@77:469@FCD��E96�HC:EE6?�?@E:46�D92==�36�D6CG65�2E�E96�C6D:56?46�@7�E96�;F586�?62C6DE�E96�A=246�H96C6E96�244FD65�H2D�2CC6DE65

,96�A6?2=EJ�@7�E6?������J62CD�2?5�@?6�52J�E@�EH6=G6��� ��J62CD�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�D92==36�:>A@D65�FA@?�E96�A@=:46�@C�=2H�6?7@C46>6?E�A6CD@??6=�H9@�72:=D�E@�?@E:7J�2?5�;F586�2D(C@G:565�:?�E96�AC6465:?8�A2C28C2A9���

!?�E96 6G6?E�@7�2?�24EF2=�@C�:>>:?6?E E6CC@C:DE�2EE24<��DFDA64ED�>2J�?@E�36�56E2:?657@C�>@C6�E92?�E9C66 ��� 52JD�H:E9@FE�E96�HC:EE6?�2AAC@G2=�@7�2�>F?:4:A2=��4:EJ��AC@G:?4:2=�@CC68:@?2=� @77:4:2=� @7� 2� F>2?�*:89ED��@>>:DD:@?� @C� ;F586� @7� E96�>F?:4:A2=�� C68:@?2=� EC:2=4@FCE��E96 �!.$)'!."!9!. @C�2�;FDE:46�@7�E96��@FCE�@7��AA62=D�?62C6DE�E96�A=246�@7�E96�2CC6DE�!7E96� 2CC6DE� :D�>256� 5FC:?8� +2EFC52JD�� +F?52JD�� 9@=:52JD� @C� 27E6C� @77:46� 9@FCD�� E96� 2CC6DE:?8A@=:46�@C�=2H�6?7@C46>6?E�A6CD@??6=�D92==�3C:?8�E96�A6CD@?�E9FD�2CC6DE65�E@�E96�C6D:56?46�@72?J�@7�E96�@77:4:2=D�>6?E:@?65�23@G6�E92E�:D�?62C6DE�E96�A=246�H96C6�E96�244FD65�H2D�2CC6DE65,96� 2AAC@G2=� :?�HC:E:?8� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� D2:5� @77:4:2=D� D92==� 36� D64FC65� 3J� E96� A@=:46� @C� =2H6?7@C46>6?E� A6CD@??6=� 4@?46C?65� H:E9:?� 7:G6� 52JD� 27E6C� E96� 52E6� @7� E96� 56E6?E:@?� @7� E96A6CD@?D� 4@?46C?65�/:E9:?� E9C66� 52JD� 27E6C� E96� 56E6?E:@?� E96� DFDA64ED��H9@D6� 4@??64E:@?H:E9�E96�E6CC@C�2EE24<�@C�E9C62E�:D�?@E�6DE23=:D965��D92==�36�C6=62D65�:>>65:2E6=J���

-� �9?4�':=?@=0��.?��

���#@94>3,-70�,.?>

�2��(9JD:42=� E@CEFC6 :D� 2� 7@C>�@7� EC62E>6?E�@C�AF?:D9>6?E� :?7=:4E65�3J� 2�A6CD@?� :?2FE9@C:EJ� @C� 286?E� @7� 2� A6CD@?� :?� 2FE9@C:EJ� FA@?� 2?@E96C� :?� 9:D96C� 4FDE@5J� E92E� 42FD6DD6G6C6�A2:?��6I92FDE:@?��5:D23:=:EJ�@C�5JD7F?4E:@?�@7�@?6�@C�>@C6�A2CED�@7�E96�3@5J��DF49�2D�

���� +JDE6>2E:4� 362E:?8�� 9625 32?8:?8�� AF?49:?8�� <:4<:?8�� DEC:<:?8� H:E9ECF?496@?�@C�C:7=6�3FEE�@C�@E96C�D:>:=2C�@3;64ED��2?5�;F>A:?8�@?�E96�DE@>249�

��.;9� �

� .;9� �

��-������

Page 53: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

� ���@@5�56AC:G2E:@?�@C�7@C4:3=6�7665:?8�H:E9�DA@:=65�7@@5��2?:>2=�@C�9F>2?6I4C6E2�2?5�@E96C�DEF77�@C�DF3DE2?46D�?@E�?@C>2==J�62E6?�

�����=64EC:4�D9@4<�

�����:82C6EE6�3FC?:?8��3FC?:?8�3J�6=64EC:42==J�962E65�C@5D��9@E�@:=��24:5��3J�E96CF33:?8�@7�A6AA6C�@C�@E96C�496>:42=�DF3DE2?46D�@?�>F4@FD�>6>3C2?6D��@C�24:5D�@CDA:46D�5:C64E=J�@?�E96�H@F?5�D��

����,96�DF3>6CD:@?�@7�E96 9625� :?�H2E6C�@C�H2E6C�A@==FE65�H:E9�6I4C6>6?E�FC:?6��G@>:E�2?5@C�3=@@5�F?E:=�E96�3C:?<�@7�DF77@42E:@?�

�����6:?8�E:65�@C�7@C465�E@�2DDF>6�7:I65�2?5�DEC6DD7F=�3@5:=J�A@D:E:@?�

����*2A6�2?5�D6IF2=�23FD6��:?4=F5:?8�E96�:?D6CE:@?�@7�7@C6:8?�@3;64ED�:?E@�E96D6I�@C82?�@C�C64EF>��@C�6=64EC:42=�E@CEFC6�@7�E96�86?:E2=D�

����%FE:=2E:@?�@C� 2>AFE2E:@?�@7� E96�6DD6?E:2=�A2CED�@7� E96�3@5J� DF49�2D� E9686?:E2=:2��62C��E@?8F6��6E4�

�����6?E2=�E@CEFC6�@C�E96�7@C465�6IEC24E:@?�@7�E96�E66E9�

�����(F==:?8�@FE�@7�7:?86C?2:=D�

����� 2C>7F=�6IA@DFC6�E@�E96�6=6>6?ED�DF49�2D�DF?=:89E�2?5�6IEC6>6�4@=5�

�� ��,96�FD6�@7�A=2DE:4�328�2?5�@E96C�>2E6C:2=D�A=2465�@G6C�E96�9625�E@�E96A@:?E�@7�2DA9JI:2E:@?�

����� ,96� FD6� @7� ADJ49@24E:G6� 5CF8D� E@� 492?86� E96� A6C46AE:@?�� >6>@CJ2=6CE?6DD�@C H:==�@7�2�A6CD@?��DF49�2D�

�:��,96�25>:?:DEC2E:@?�@C�5CF8D� E@� :?5F46�4@?76DD:@?�2?5@C� C65F46>6?E2=�4@>A6E6?4J��@C

�::��,96�FD6�@7�5CF8D�E@�:?5F46�6IEC6>6�A2:?�@C�46CE2:?�DJ>AE@>D�@7�25:D62D6��2?5

�����'E96C�2?2=@8@FD�24ED�@7�A9JD:42=�E@CEFC6��2?5

�3� �%6?E2=(DJ49@=@8:42=�,@CEFC6��C676CD�E@�24ED�4@>>:EE65�3J�2�A6CD@?�:?�2FE9@C:EJ@C�286?E�@7�2�A6CD@?�:?�2FE9@C:EJ�H9:49�2C6�42=4F=2E65�E@�27764E�@C�4@?7FD6�E96�>:?52?5@C�F?56C>:?6�2�A6CD@?�D�5:8?:EJ�2?5�>@C2=6��DF49�2D�

Page 54: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�����=:?57@=5:?8�

� � ,9C62E6?:?8�2�A6CD@?�D��@C�9:D96C�C6=2E:G6�D��H:E9�3@5:=J�92C>��6I64FE:@?@C�@E96C�HC@?87F=�24ED�

�����@?7:?6>6?E�:?�D@=:E2CJ�46==D�@C�D64C6E�56E6?E:@?�A=246D�

����(C@=@?865�:?E6CC@82E:@?�

���� (C6A2C:?8� 2� AC:D@?6C� 7@C� 2� �D9@H� EC:2=��� AF3=:4� 5:DA=2J� @C� AF3=:49F>:=:2E:@?�@7�2�56E2:?66�@C�AC:D@?6C�

�����2FD:?8� F?D4965F=65� EC2?D76C� @7� 2� A6CD@?� 56AC:G65� @7� =:36CEJ� 7C@>�@?6A=246�E@�2?@E96C��4C62E:?8�E96�36=:67�E92E�96D96�D92==�36�DF>>2C:=J�6I64FE65�

����%2=EC62E:?8�2�>6>36CD�@7�2�A6CD@?�D�72>:=J�

���� �2FD:?8� E96� E@CEFC6� D6DD:@?D� E@� 36� H:E?6DD65� 3J� E96� A6CD@?�D� 72>:=J�C6=2E:G6D�@C�2?J�E9:C5�A2CEJ�

�����6?:2=�@7�D=66AC6DE�

�����+92>6�:?7=:4E:@?�DF49�2D�DEC:AA:?8�E96�A6CD@?�?2<65��A2C25:?8�9:>96C:?�AF3=:4�A=246D��D92G:?8�E96�G:4E:>�D�9625�@C�AFEE:?8�>2C<D�@?�9:D96C 3@5J�282:?DE9:D96C�H:==�

������6=:36C2E6=J�AC@9:3:E:?8�E96�G:4E:>�E@�4@>>F?:42E6�H:E9�2?J�>6>36C�@79:D96C�72>:=J��2?5

�� ��'E96C�2?2=@8@FD�24ED�@7�>6?E2=ADJ49@=@8:42=�E@CEFC6���

����*3:�,=0�74,-70���

�?J� A6CD@?� H9@� 24EF2==J� A2CE:4:A2E65� @C� :?5F465 2?@E96C� :?� E96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @7E@CEFC6�@C�@E96C�4CF6=��:?9F>2?�2?5�568C25:?8�EC62E>6?E�@C�AF?:D9>6?E�@C�H9@�4@@A6C2E65:?� E96�6I64FE:@?�@7� E96�24E�@7� E@CEFC6�@C�@E96C� 4CF6=�� :?9F>2?�2?5�568C25:?8� EC62E>6?E�@CAF?:D9>6?E�3J�AC6G:@FD�@C�D:>F=E2?6@FD�24ED�D92== 36�=:23=6�2D�AC:?4:A2=

�?J� DFA6C:@C� >:=:E2CJ�� A@=:46� @C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� @77:46C� @C� D6?:@C� 8@G6C?>6?E@77:4:2=�H9@�:DDF65�2?�@C56C�E@�2?J�=@H6C�C2?<:?8�A6CD@??6=�E@�4@>>:E�E@CEFC6�7@C�H92E6G6CAFCA@D6�D92==�36�96=5�6BF2==J�=:23=6�2D�AC:?4:A2=D

,96� :>>65:2E6� 4@>>2?5:?8� @77:46C� @7� E96� F?:E� 4@?46C?65� @7� E96� ��(� @C� E96:>>65:2E6� D6?:@C� AF3=:4� @77:4:2=� @7� E96� (&(� 2?5�@E96C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� 286?4:6D� D92==� 36

��.;9��

��9H?C?D7BBO

Page 55: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

96=5� =:23=6� 2D� 2�AC:?4:A2=� E@� E96�4C:>6�@7� E@CEFC6�@C�@E96C� 4CF6=�@C� :?9F>2?�2?5�568C25:?8EC62E>6?E�@C�AF?:D9>6?E�7@C�2?J�24E�@C�@>:DD:@?��@C�?68=:86?46�4@>>:EE65�3J�9:>96C�E92ED92==� 92G6� =65�� 2DD:DE65�� 236EE65� @C� 2==@H65��H96E96C� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J�� E96� 4@>>:DD:@?E96C6@7�3J�9:D96C�DF3@C5:?2E6D�!7�96D96�92D�<?@H=6586�@7�@C��@H:?8�E@�E96�4:C4F>DE2?46D2E�E96�E:>6��D9@F=5�92G6�<?@H?�E92E�24ED�@7�E@CEFC6�@C�@E96C�4CF6=�� :?9F>2?�2?5�568C25:?8EC62E>6?E�@C�AF?:D9>6?E�D92==�36�4@>>:EE65��:D�36:?8�4@>>:EE65��@C�92D�366?�4@>>:EE65�3J9:D96C� DF3@C5:?2E6D� @C� 3J� @E96CD� H:E9:?� 9:D96C� 2C62� @7� C6DA@?D:3:=:EJ� 2?5�� 56DA:E6� DF49<?@H=6586��5:5�?@E�E2<6�AC6G6?E:G6�@C�4@CC64E:G6�24E:@?�6:E96C�367@C6��5FC:?8�@C�:>>65:2E6=J27E6C�:ED�4@>>:DD:@?��H96?�96D96�92D�E96�2FE9@C:EJ�E@�AC6G6?E�@C�:?G6DE:82E6�2==682E:@?D�@7E@CEFC6�@C�@E96C�4CF6=��:?9F>2?�2?5�568C25:?8�EC62E>6?E @C�AF?:D9>6?E�3FE�72:=65�E@�AC6G6?E@C�:?G6DE:82E6�2==682E:@?D�@7�DF49�24E��H96E96C�56=:36C2E6=J�@C�5F6�E@�?68=:86?46�D92==�2=D@�36=:23=6�2D�AC:?4:A2=D

�?J� AF3=:4� @77:46C� @C� 6>A=@J66� D92==� 36� =:23=6� 2D� 2?� 2446DD@CJ� :7� 96D96� 92D<?@H=6586� E92E� E@CEFC6�@C�@E96C�4CF6=�� :?9F>2?�2?5�568C25:?8� EC62E>6?E�@C�AF?:D9>6?E� :D36:?8�4@>>:EE65�2?5�H:E9@FE�92G:?8�A2CE:4:A2E65�E96C6:?��6:E96C�2D�AC:?4:A2=�@C�244@>A=:46�E2<6D�A2CE�DF3D6BF6?E�E@�:ED�4@>>:DD:@?�:?�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�>2??6C�

�2���J�E96>D6=G6D�AC@7:E:?8 7C@>�@C�2DD:DE:?8�E96�@776?56C�E@�AC@7:E�7C@>�E96�67764ED@7�E96�24E�@7�E@CEFC6�@C�@E96C�4CF6=��:?9F>2?�2?5�568C25:?8�EC62E>6?E�@C�AF?:D9>6?E�

�3���J�4@?462=:?8�E96�24E�@7�E@CEFC6�@C�@E96C�4CF6=��:?9F>2?�2?5�568C25:?8�EC62E>6?E@C�AF?:D9>6?E�2?5@C�56DEC@J:?8�E96�67764ED�@C�:?DECF>6?ED�E96C6@7�:?�@C56C�E@�AC6G6?E�:ED5:D4@G6CJ��@C

�4���J�92C3@C:?8��4@?462=:?8�@C�2DD:DE:?8�>�E96�6D42A6�@7�E96�AC:?4:A2=D�:?�E96�24E�@7E@CEFC6�@C�@E96C�4CF6=��:?9F>2?�2?5�568C25:?8�EC62E>6?E�@C�AF?:D9>6?E��(C@G:565��,92E�E962446DD@CJ�24ED�2C6�5@?6�H:E9�E96�23FD6�@7�E96�@77:4:2=�D�AF3=:4�7F?4E:@?D���

��.;9� �

Page 56: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�� �>591? �3-5:?@�$A.85/�#>01>

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED

&1.1885;:�;>�5:?A>>1/@5;:��� 2 ,96C6�36 L

���HJ� ��

.K99;II�?I�?CC7J;H?7B��FKHFEI;�?I�7BM7OI�FEB?J?97B

-;8;BB?ED� KI;:� M>;H;� J>;� E8@;9J� E<� J>;� CEL;C;DJ� ?I� 9ECFB;J;BO� JE� EL;HJ>HEM� 7D:� IKF;HI;:;� J>;

;N?IJ?D=�=EL;HDC;DJ

$DIKHH;9J?ED�H;<;HI�JE�7�CEL;C;DJ�M>?9>�I;;AI�C;H;BO�JE�;<<;9J�IEC;�9>7D=;�E<�C?DEH�?CFEHJ7D9;�JE

FH;L;DJ�J>;�;N;H9?I;�E<�=ELYJ�7KJ>EH?JO�M��H;IF;9J�JE�F7HJ?9KB7H�C7JJ;HI�EH�IK8@;9JI

�9JK7B� 9B7I>� E<� 7HCI� M�� J>;� <EH9;I� E<� J>;� =ELYJ�� DEJ� D;9;II7HO� JE� 9EDL?9J� J>;� 799KI;:� M>E� ?I� ?D

9EDIF?H79O�M��EJ>;HI�79JK7BBO�J7A?D=�7HCI�7=7?DIJ�J>;�=ELYJ

+KHFEI;�E<�J>;�KFH?I?D=�CKIJ�8;�I>EMD�8KJ�?J�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO�J>7J�?J�8;�799ECFB?I>;:

��9>7D=;�E<�=EL;HDC;DJ�M�E�;NJ;HD7B�F7HJ?9?F7J?ED

-?I?D=� FK8B?9BO� 7D:� J7A?D=� 7HCI� 7=7?DIJ� =EL;HDC;DJ W 79JK7B� F7HJ?9?F7J?ED� � $<� J>;H;� ?I� DE� FK8B?9

KFH?I?D=��J>;�9H?C;�?I�E<�:?H;9J�7II7KBJ

(;H;� =?L?D=� E<� 7?:� EH� 9EC<EHJ� ?I� DEJ� 9H?C?D7B� ?D� J>;� 97I;� E<� H;8;BB?ED� (;H;BO� IOCF7J>?P?D=� ?I� DEJ

F7HJ?9?F7J?ED��J>;H;�CKIJ�8;�79JK7B�F7HJ?9?F7J?ED

)EJ�D;9;II7HO�J>7J�J>;H;�?I�A?BB?D=��C;H;�J>H;7J�E<�H;CEL?D=�+>?B�?I�IK<<?9?;DJ

-;8;BB?ED� 97DDEJ� 8;� 9ECFB;N;:� M?J>� 7DO� EJ>;H� 9H?C;� � #EM;L;H�� ?BB;=7B� FEII;II?ED� E<� <?H;7HCI� ?D

<KHJ>;H7D9;�E<�H;8;BB?ED�?I�:?IJ?D9J�<HEC�J>;�9H?C;�E<�H;8;BB?ED�!KHJ>;HCEH;��?J�?I�7�9EDJ?DK?D=�9H?C;�IK9>

7BED=�M?J>�J>;�9H?C;�E<�9EDIF?H79O�EH�FHEFEI7B�JE�9ECC?J�IK9>

��FH?L7J;�9H?C;�C7O�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�:KH?D=�H;8;BB?ED� N7CFB;I��A?BB?D=��FEII;II?EDI�E<�<?H;7HCI��?BB;=7B

7IIE9?7J?ED�7H;�78IEH8;:�-7F;��;L;D�?<�DEJ�?D�<KHJ>;H7D9;�E<�H;8;BB?ED�97DDEJ�8;�9ECFB;N;:

$<�A?BB?D=�� HE88?D=�M;H;�:ED;�<EH�FH?L7J;�FKHFEI;I�EH� <EH�FHE<?J��M?J>EKJ�7DO�FEB?J?97B�CEJ?L7J?ED�� J>;

9H?C;�MEKB:�8;�I;F7H7J;BO�8;�FKD?I>;:�7D:�MEKB:�DEJ�8;�;C8H79;:�8O�H;8;BB?ED���'12.'�8���'40#0&1�

+;HIED�:;;C;:�B;7:;H�E<�H;8;BB?ED�?D�97I;�>;�?I�KDADEMD�

�DO�F;HIED�M>E�?D�<79J�

7 :?H;9J;:�J>;�EJ>;HI

8 IFEA;�<EH�J>;C

9 I?=D;:�H;9;?FJI�7D:�EJ>;H�:E9KC;DJI�?IIK;:�?D�J>;?H�D7C;

: F;H<EHC;:�I?C?B7H�79JI�ED�8;>7B<�E<�J>;�H;8;BI

+;HIEDI�B?78B;�<EH�H;8;BB?ED�

?��DO�F;HIED�M>E�

��FHECEJ;I

���C7?DJ7?DI��EH

���>;7:I�7�H;8;BB?ED�EH�?DIKHH;9J?ED��EH

??��DO�F;HIED�M>E��M>?B;�>EB:?D=�7DO�FK8B?9�E<<?9;�EH�;CFBEOC;DJ��J7A;I�F7HJ�J>;H;?D�8O�

;D=7=?D=�?D�M7H�7=7?DIJ�J>;�<EH9;I�E<�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ

� :;IJHEO?D=�FHEF;HJO�EH�9ECC?JJ?D=�I;H?EKI�L?EB;D9;

� ;N79J?D=�9EDJH?8KJ?EDI�EH�:?L;HJ?D=�FK8B?9�<KD:I�<HEC�J>;�B7M<KB�FKHFEI;�<EH�M>?9>�J>;O�>7L;

8;;D�7FFHEFH?7J;:��)EJ;��Z:?L;HJ?D=�FK8B?9�<KD:I[�?I�C7BL;HI7J?ED�78IEH8;:�?D�H;8;BB?ED��

� �DO�F;HIED�C;H;BO�F7HJ?9?F7J?D=�EH�;N;9KJ?D=�J>;�9ECC7D:�E<�EJ>;HI�?D�H;8;BB?ED

.;H?EKI� L?EB;D9;� ?I� J>7J� ?D<B?9J;:� KFED� 9?L?B?7DI�� M>?9>� C7O� H;IKBJ� ?D� >EC?9?:;� $J� ?I� DEJ� B?C?J;:� JE

>EIJ?B?J?;I�7=7?DIJ�J>;�7HC;:�<EH9;

+K8B?9�E<<?9;H�CKIJ�J7A;�79J?L;�F7HJ�8;97KI;�C;H;�I?B;D9;�EH�EC?II?ED�DEJ�FKD?I>78B;�?D�H;8;BB?ED

$J� ?I� DEJ� 7�:;<;DI;� ?D� H;8;BB?ED� J>7J� J>;�799KI;:�D;L;H� JEEA� J>;�E7J>�E<� 7BB;=?7D9;� JE�� EH� J>7J� J>;O

D;L;H�H;9E=D?P;:�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ

-;8;BB?ED�97DDEJ�8;�9ECFB;N;:�M?J>�CKH:;H�7D:�EJ>;H�9ECCED�9H?C;I�9ECC?JJ;:�?D�FKHIK7D9;�E<

J>;�CEL;C;DJ JE�EL;HJ>HEM�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ

Page 57: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

� AF3=:4�FAC:D:?8�2?5 E2<:?8�2C>D�282:?DE�E96 8@G6C?>6?E���

3��(FCA@D6�@7�E96�FAC:D:?8�@C�>@G6>6?E�:D�6:E96C

� E@� C6>@G6� 7C@>� E96� 2==68:2?46� E@� D2:58@G6C?>6?E�@C�:ED�=2HD L

:��E96�E6CC:E@CJ�@7�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D�@C�2?J�A2CEE96C6@7��@C

::� 2?J3@5J� @7� =2?5�� ?2G2=� @C� @E96C 2C>657@C46D��@C

E@� 56AC:G6� E96� 49:67� 6I64FE:G6� @C� 4@?8C6DD�H9@==J� @C� A2CE:2==J�� @7� 2?J� @7� � E96:C� A@H6CD� @CAC6C@82E:G6D

�).*� �!1-�-��� 2 +H:7E�2EE24<

3 �44@>A2?:65� 3J� G:@=6?46�� :?E:>:52E:@?�� E9C62E�DEC2E68J�@C�DE62=E9

4 �:C64E65�282:?DE�

� 5F=J�4@?DE:EFE65�2FE9@C:E:6D 2?J�>:=:E2CJ�42>A�@C�:?DE2==2E:@?� 4@>>F?:42E:@?�?6EH@C<D�@C�AF3=:4�FE:=:E:6D� @E96C� 724:=:E:6D� ?66565� 7@C� E96� 6I6C4:D6� 2?54@?E:?F65�A@DD6DD:@?�@7�A@H6C

5 +:?8=J�@C�D:>F=E2?6@FD=J�42CC:65�@FE�2?JH96C6�:?E96�(9:=:AA:?6D

@C

6 �@>>:EE65�3J�2?J�A6CD@?�@C�A6CD@?D�36=@?8:?8E@�E96�>:=:E2CJ�@C�A@=:46�@C�9@=5:?8�2?J�AF3=:4�@77:46@C�6>A=@J>6?E��H:E9�@C�H:E9@FE 4:G:=:2?�DFAA@CE�@CA2CE:4:A2E:@?

7 (FCA@D6�@7�D6:K:?8�@C�5:>:?:D9:?8�DE2E6�A@H6C

7 &?BB?D=�� HE88?D=� ;J9� <EH� FH?L7J;� F;HIEDI� EH� <EH� FHE<?J�� M?J>EKJ� 7DO� FEB?J?97B� CEJ?L7J?ED�� MEKB:� 8;

I;F7H7J;BO�FKD?I>;:�7D:�MEKB:�DEJ�8;�78IEH8;:�?D�J>;�H;8;BB?ED ��

<EH9;�L?EB;D9; ��

�HJ� ���

Page 58: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�;:?<5>-/E� @;�/;995@� >1.1885;:�;>5:?A>>1/@5;:���

2 �>@C6� A6CD@?D� 4@>6� E@� 2?� 28C66>6?E� E@� C:D6AF3=:4=J�2?5�E2<6�2C>D�282:?DE�E96�8@G6C?>6?E

3 �@C�2?J�@7�E96�AFCA@D6D�@7�C636==:@?

4 ,96J�564:56�E@�4@>>:E�:E

$>;<;?-8� @;� /;995@� >1.1885;:� ;>5:?A>>1/@5;:���

2 ��A6CD@?�H9@�92D�564:565� E@� C:D6�AF3=:4=J� 2?5E2<6�2C>D�E96�8@G6C?>6?E

3 �@C�2?J�@7�E96�AFCA@D6D�@7�C636==:@?

4 (C@A@D6D�:ED�6I64FE:@?�E@�D@>6�@E96C�A6CD@?D

�5?8;E-8@E� ;2� <A.85/� ;225/1>?� -:019<8;E11?���

2 �2:=:?8�E@�C6D:DE�C636==:@?�3J�2==�E96�>62?D�:?�E96:CA@H6C

3 �@?E:?F:?8� E@� 5:D492C86� E96� 5FE:6D� @7� E96:C@77:46D�F?56C�E96�4@?EC@=�@7�C636=D

4 �446AE:?8�2AA@:?E>6?E�E@�@77:46�F?56C�C636=D

�:/5@5:3�@;�>1.1885;:�;>5:?A>>1/@5;:��

2 '776?56C�5@6D�?@E� E2<6�2C>D�@C� :D�?@E� :?�@A6?9@DE:=:EJ�282:?DE�E96�8@G6C?>6?E

3�� 6�:?4:E6D�@E96CD�E@�E96�6I64FE:@?�@7�2?J�@7�E96

���HJ� ��

��*H=7D?P?D=�7�=HEKF�E<�IEB:?;HI��IEB?9?J?D=�C;C8;HI>?F�?D��7D:�IEB?9?J?D=�<KD:I�<EH�J>;�EH=7D?P7J?ED�I>EM

9EDIF?H79O�JE�EL;HJ>HEM�J>;�=ELYJ

/>;�C;H;� <79J�E<�=?L?D=� �7D:� H;D:;H?D=� IF;;9>;I� <7LEH?D=��ECCKD?IC�MEKB:�DEJ�C7A;� J>;�799KI;:

=K?BJO� E<� 9EDIF?H79O� ?<� J>;H;YI� DE ;L?:;D9;� J>7J� J>;� >;7H;HI� J>;D� 7D:� J>;H;� 7=H;;:� JE� H?I;� KF� ?D� 7HCI

7=7?DIJ�J>;�=ELYJ

�EDIF?H79O�CKIJ�8;�?CC;:?7J;BO�FH?EH�JE�H;8;BB?ED

$<�?J�?I�:KH?D=�J>;�H;8;BB?ED��J>;D�?J�?I�7BH;7:O�J7A?D=�F7HJ�?D�?J �

�HJ� ��

+H;IKFFEI;I�;N?IJ;D9;�E<�H;8;BB?ED

(KIJ�DEJ�8;�?D�9EDIF?H79O�M?J>�H;8;BI�EH�9EKF�FBEJJ;HI

$<�J>;H;�7H;�C;7DI�JE�FH;L;DJ�J>;�H;8;BB?ED�8KJ�:?:�DEJ�H;I?IJ�?J��J>;D�J>;H;YI�:?IBEO7BJO�$<�J>;H;�7H;�DE

C;7DI��DE�<7KBJ

$<�FEI?J?ED�?I�799;FJ;:�?D�EH:;H�JE�FHEJ;9J�J>;�F;EFB;��DEJ�9EL;H;:�8O�J>?I

/>;�9EBB78EH7JEH�CKIJ�DEJ�>7L;�JH?;:�JE�?CFEI;�J>;�M?I>;I�E<�J>;�H;8;BI�E<�J>;�F;EFB; ��

�HJ� ��

$DJ;DJ?ED7BBO�97B9KB7J;:�JE�I;:K9;�EJ>;HI�JE�H;8;BB?ED

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�KFH?I?D=�JE�J7A;�KF�7HCI�7D:�H?I;�FK8B?9BO�<EH�J>;�FKHFEI;I�?D:?97J;:�?D��HJ� ��

Page 59: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

24ED�@7�C636==:@?

4� ,96� :?4:E:?8� :D� 5@?6� 3J� >62?D� @7� DA66496D�AC@4=2>2E:@?D��HC:E:?8D��6>3=6>D��32??6CD�@C�@E96CC6AC6D6?E2E:@?D�E6?5:?8�E@�E96�D2>6�6?5

'105@5;:��� 2��'776?56CD�C:D6 L

� (F3=:4=J���

,F>F=EF@FD=J���

3�,96J�6>A=@J�7@C46��:?E:>:52E:@?��@C�@E96C�>62?D@FED:56�@7�=682=�>6E9@5D

4� �'776?56CD�6>A=@J�2?J�@7�E9@D6�>62?D�E@�2EE2:?2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�@3;64ED�

� E@�AC6G6?E� E96�AC@>F=82E:@?�@C� 6I64FE:@?�@72?J�=2H�@C�E96�9@=5:?8�@7�2?J�A@AF=2C�6=64E:@?

E@� AC6G6?E� E96� ?2E:@?2=� 8@G6C?>6?E�� @C� 2?JAC@G:?4:2=� @C�>F?:4:A2=� 8@G6C?>6?E�� @C� 2?J�AF3=:4E96C6@7� 7C@>� 7C66=J� 6I6C4:D:?8� :ED� @C� 9:D� 7F?4E:@?D�@C AC6G6?E� E96� 6I64FE:@?� @7� 2?J� 25>:?:DEC2E:G6@C56C

� E@�:?7=:4E�2?J�24E�@C�92E6�@C�C6G6?86�FA@?�E96A6CD@?� @C� AC@A6CEJ� @7� 2?J� AF3=:4� @77:46C� @C6>A=@J66

��E@�4@>>:E�7@C�2?J�A@=:E:42=�@C�D@4:2=�6?5��2?J24E�@7�92E6�@C�C6G6?86�282:?DE�AC:G2E6�A6CD@?D�@C�2?J

���HJ� ��

.;:?J?ED�� H7?I?D=� E<� 9ECCEJ?ED� EH� :?IJKH87D9;I� ?D� J>;� .J7J;� $JI� KBJ?C7J;� E8@;9J� ?I� 7� L?EB7J?ED� E<� J>;

FK8B?9�F;79;�EH�7J�B;7IJ�IK9>�C;7IKH;I�J>7J�;L?:;DJBO�;D=;D:;HI�?J

�?<<;H;D9;�<HEC�H;8;BB?ED W E8@;9J�EH�FKHFEI;�E<�J>;�IKHFH?I?D=�!EH�I;:?J?ED W IK<<?9?;DJ�J>7J�KFH?I?D=�?I

JKCKBJKEKI�$D�H;8;BB?ED W J>;H;�CKIJ�8;�J7A?D=�KF�E<�7HCI�7=7?DIJ�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ

.;:?J?ED W FKHFEI;�C7O�8;�;?J>;H�FEB?J?97B�EH�IE9?7B�$D�H;8;BB?ED W 7BM7OI�FEB?J?97B

/KCKBJKEKI W 97KI;:�8O�CEH;�J>7D���F;HIEDI�M>E�7H;�7HC;:�EH�FHEL?:;:�M?J>�C;7DI�E<�L?EB;D9;

+H;L;DJ?D=�FK8B?9�E<<?9;HI�<HEC�<H;;BO�;N;H9?I?D=�J>;?H�<KD9J?EDI

$D�I;:?J?ED W E<<;D:;H�C7O�8;�7 FH?L7J;�EH�FK8B?9�F;HIED�� N�.EB:?;H�

+K8B?9�KFH?I?D=�7D:�J>;�E8@;9J�E<�I;:?J?ED�CKIJ�9ED9KH

+;HIEDI�B?78B;�<EH�I;:?J?ED�

7 B;7:;H�E<�J>;�I;:?J?ED��7D:

8 EJ>;H�F;HIEDI�F7HJ?9?F7J?D=�?D�J>;�I;:?J?ED ��

?<�DE�FK8B?9�KFH?I?D=���JKCKBJ�7D:�EJ>;H�:?IJKH87D9;�E<�FK8B?9�EH:;H ��

L?IQL?I�H;8;BB?ED�M>;H;�J>;H;�CKIJ�8;�7�J7A?D=�E<�7HCI

Page 60: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

D@4:2=�4=2DD���

� E@�56DA@:=��7@C�2?J�A@=:E:42=�@C�D@4:2=�6?5��2?JA6CD@?�� >F?:4:A2=:EJ� @C� AC@G:?46�� @C� E96?2E:@?2=� 8@G6C?>6?E� @7� 2==� :ED� AC@A6CEJ� @C2?J�A2CE�E96C6@7

�:/5@5:3�@;�?105@5;:��� 2��'776?56C�5@6D�?@E�E2<6�2�5:C64E�A2CE�:?�E96�4C:>6@7�D65:E:@?

3�� 6�:?4:E6D�@E96CD�E@�E96�244@>A=:D9>6?E�@7�2?J@7�E96�24ED�H9:49�4@?DE:EFE6�D65:E:@?���

4� ,96� :?4:E:?8� :D� 5@?6� 3J� >62?D� @7� DA66496D�AC@4=2>2E:@?D� HC:E:?8��6>3=6>D��42CE@@?D��32??6CD�@C�@E96C�C6AC6D6?E2E:@?D�E6?5:?8�E@�E96�D2>6�6?5���

��>;D9;��;L;D�FH?L7J; F;HIEDI�C7O�8;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJ?;I

���HJ ��

�9JI�FKD?I>;:�

$D9?J?D=�EJ>;HI�JE�J>;�799ECFB?I>C;DJ�E<�7DO�E<�J>;�79JI�M>?9>���9EDIJ?JKJ;���I;:?J?ED���8O���C;7DI

E<���IF;;9>;I��FHE9B7C7J?EDI��MH?J?D=I��;C8B;CI��;J9�

�����0JJ;H?D=�I;:?J?EKI��MEH:I��EH��IF;;9>;I��M>?9>��J;D:��JE�:?IJKH8�J>;�FK8B?9��F;79;�

���2H?J?D=����FK8B?I>?D=����EH���9?H9KB7J?D=���I9KHH?BEKI���B?8;BI�7=7?DIJ�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ�EH�7DO�E<�J>;�:KBO

9EDIJ?JKJ;:�7KJ>EH?J?;I�J>;H;E<��M>?9>�J;D:�JE�:?IJKH8�J>;�FK8B?9�F;79;

�?<<;H;DJ�79JI�E<�?D9?J?D=�JE�I;:?J?ED�

7 $D9?J?D=�EJ>;HI�JE�J>;�799ECFB?I>C;DJ�E<�7DO�E<�J>;�79JI�M>?9>�9EDIJ?JKJ;�I;:?J?ED�8O�C;7DI�E<

IF;;9>;I��FHE9B7C7J?EDI��MH?J?D=I��;C8B;CI�;J9

8 0JJ;H?D=� I;:?J?EKI� MEH:I� EH� IF;;9>;I� M>?9>� J;D:� JE� :?IJKH8� J>;� FK8B?9� F;79;� EH� MH?J?D=�

FK8B?I>?D=��EH�9?H9KB7J?D=�I9KHH?BEKI�5LKB=7H��C;7D��B?8;BEKI6�B?8;BI�7=7?DIJ�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ�EH�7DO

E<�J>;�:KBO�9EDIJ?JKJ;: 7KJ>EH?J?;I�J>;H;E<��M>?9>�J;D:�JE�:?IJKH8�J>;�FK8B?9�F;79;

9 &DEM?D=BO�9ED9;7B?D=�IK9>�;L?B�FH79J?9;I

2>;D�FKD?I>78B;�

7 M>;D�J>;O�J;D:�JE�:?IJKH8�EH�E8IJHK9J�7DO�B7M<KB�E<<?9;H�?D�;N;9KJ?D=�J>;�<KD9J?EDI�E<�>?I�E<<?9;�

EH

8 M>;D�J>;O�J;D:�JE�?DIJ?=7J; EJ>;HI�JE�9787B�7D:�C;;J�JE=;J>;H�<EH�KDB7M<KB�FKHFEI;I

9 M>;D�J>;O�IK==;IJ�EH�?D9?J;�H;8;BB?EKI�9EDIF?H79?;I�EH�H?EJI��EH

: M>;D�J>;O�B;7:�EH�J;D:�JE�IJ?H�KF�J>;�F;EFB;�7=7?DIJ�J>;�B7M<KB�7KJ>EH?J?;I�EH�JE�:?IJKH8�J>;�F;79;

E<�J>;�9ECCKD?JO��J>;�I7<;JO�7D:�EH:;H�E<�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ ��

�HJ� �� ��

+KHFEI;��97KI;�9ECCEJ?ED�DEJ�;N79JBO�7=7?DIJ�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ��79JK7B�:?IJKH87D9;�DEJ�D;9;II7HO

Page 61: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

�/@?� @1:05:3� @;� <>1B1:@� @41911@5:3� ;2� /;:3>1??� -:0� ?5958->.;051? ��

2� ,96C6� 36� 2� AC@;64E65� @C� 24EF2=� >66E:?8� @7�@?8C6DD� @C� 2?J� @7� :ED� 4@>>:EE66D� @CDF34@>>:EE66D�� 4@?DE:EFE:@?2=� 4@>>:DD:@?D� @C4@>>:EE66D�@C�5:G:D:@?�E96C6@7��@C�@7�2?J�AC@G:?4:2=3@2C5�@C�4:EJ�@C�>F?:4:A2=�4@F?4:=�@C�3@2C5

3�'776?56C�H9@�>2J�36�2?J�A6CD@?D�AC6G6?ED�DF49>66E:?8�3J�7@C46�@C�7C2F5

�5?@A>.-:/1�;2�<>;/1105:3? �� 2� ,96C6� 36� 2 >66E:?8� @7� �@?8C6DD� @C� 2?J� @7� :ED4@>>:EE66D�� 4@?DE:EFE:@?2=� 4@>>:DD:@?D� @C4@>>:EE66D� @C� 5:G:D:@?D� E96C6@7�� @C� @7� 2?JAC@G:?4:2=� 3@2C5� @C� 4:EJ� @C� >F?:4:A2=� 4@F?4:=� @C3@2C5

3�'776?56C�5@6D�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

� 96�5:DEFC3D�2?J�@7�DF49�>66E:?8D

96�3692G6D�H9:=6�:?�E96�AC6D6?46�@7�2?J�DF493@5:6D� :?� DF49� 2� >2??6C� 2D� E@� :?E6CCFAE� :EDAC@4665:?8D�@C�E@�:>A2:C�E96 C6DA64E�5F6�:E

*5;8-@5;:� ;2� <->85-91:@->E599A:5@E �

2�'776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3� 6�2CC6DED�@C�D62C496D�2?J�>6>36C�@7��@?8C6DD

����HJ� ��

�>?;<�E<�+EB?9;�7D:�C7OEH�M>E�FH;L;DJ;:�J>;�C;;J?D=�E<�J>;�CKD?9?F7B�9EKD9?B�7H;�B?78B;�KD:;H��HJ� ���

M>;D�J>; :;<;9J�E<�J>;�C;;J?D=�?I�DEJ�C7D?<;IJ�7D:�H;GK?H;I�7D�?DL;IJ?=7J?ED�8;<EH;�?JI�;N?IJ;D9;�97D�8;

:;J;HC?D;:��

�HJ� ��

�ECFB7?DJ� CKIJ� 8;� <?B;:� 8O� C;C8;H� E<� J>;� ';=?IB7J?L;� 8E:O� �99KI;:� C7O� 7BIE� 8;� FKD?I>;:� <EH

9EDJ;CFJ���

�HJ� ��

�HJ?9B;�F7HJBO ?DEF;H7J?L;�8;97KI;�E<�J>;� �����EDIJ?JKJ?ED

�9JI�FKD?I>78B;�

7 �O�KI?D=�<EH9;��?DJ?C?:7J?ED��J>H;7JI��EH�<H7K:I�JE�FH;L;DJ 7DO�C;C8;H�E<��ED=H;II�<HEC W

7JJ;D:?D=�J>;�C;;J?D=�E<�J>;�7II;C8BO�EH�7DO�E<� ?JI�9ECC?JJ;;I��9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B�9ECC?II?EDI�EH

9ECC?JJ;;I�EH�:?L?I?EDI�J>;H;E<��EH�<HEC

� ;NFH;II?D=�>?I�EF?D?EDI�EH

� 97IJ?D=�>?I�LEJ;

8 �O�7HH;IJ?D=�EH�I;7H9>?D=�7DO�C;C8;H�J>;H;E<�M>?B;��ED=H;II� ?I� ?D�7�H;=KB7H�EH�IF;9?7B�I;II?ED�

;N9;FJ�?D�97I;�IK9>�C;C8;H�>7I�9ECC?JJ;:�7�9H?C;�FKD?I>78B;�KD:;H�J>;�9E:;�8O�7�F;D7BJO�>?=>;H�J>7D

FH?I?ED�C7OEH

Page 62: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4 �@?8C6DD��2E� E96� E:>6�@7�2CC6DE�@C� D62C49�� :D� :?� 2C68F=2C @C�DA64:2=�D6DD:@?

5� ,96� >6>36C� D62C4965� 92D� ?@E� 4@>>:EE65� 24C:>6� AF?:D923=6� F?56C� E96� � � 4@56� 3J� 2� A6?2=EJ9:896C�E92? 02)3)/.�-!9/2�

�8813-8�-??19.851? �� 2 %66E:?8�@7�E96�7:CDE�7@C>

� %66E:?8�� 82E96C:?8� @C� 8C@FA� @7� A6CD@?DH96E96C�:?�2�7:I65�A=246�@C�>@G:?8

�AFCA@D6��E@�4@>>:E�2?J�@7�4C:>6D�AF?:D923=6F?56C�E96�4@56

� >66E:?8�2EE6?565�3J�2C>65�A6CD@?D

3 %66E:?8�@7 E96�D64@?5�7@C>

� %66E:?8�� 82E96C:?8� @C� 8C@FA� @7� A6CD@?DH96E96C�:?�2�7:I65�A=246�@C�>@G:?8 �F5:6?46�H96E96C�2C>65�@C�?@E��:D�:?4:E65�E@

E96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @7� E96� 4C:>6� @7� EC62D@?�� C636==:@?@C�:?DFCC64E:@?��D65:E:@?�@C�5:C64E�2DD2F=E

�8813-8�-??;/5-@5;:? ��2�'C82?:K65� E@E2==J�@C�A2CE:2==J� 7@C� E96�AFCA@D6�@74@>>:EE:?8�2?J�@7�E96�4C:>6D�:?�*(�

3�'C�7@C�D@>6�AFCA@D6�4@?EC2CJ�E@�AF3=:4�>@C2=D

��� ���� 9EDIJ?JKJ?ED�� FH?L?B;=;� <HEC� 7HH;IJ� M>?B;� 9ED=H;II� ?D� I;II?ED� ?D� 7BB� E<<;DI;I� FKD?I>78B;� 8O� DEJ

CEH;�J>7D���O;7HI�?CFH?IEDC;DJ���

�HJ� ��

)EJ�7BB�J>;�F;HIEDI�FH;I;DJ�7J�J>;�C;;J?D=�E<�J>;�<?HIJ�<EHC�E<�?BB;=7B�7II;C8BO�CKIJ�8;�7HC;:

+;HIEDI�B?78B;�<EH�?BB;=7B�7II;C8BO

7 J>;�EH=7D?P;HI EH�B;7:;HI�E<�J>;�C;;J?D=

8 F;HIEDI�C;H;BO�FH;I;DJ�7J�J>;�C;;J?D=��;N9;FJ�M>;D�FH;I;D9;�?I�EKJ�E<�9KH?EI?JO W DEJ�B?78B;�

-;IFEDI?8?B?JO�E<�F;HIEDI�C;H;BO�FH;I;DJ�7J�J>;�C;;J?D=

#� ?<�J>;O�7H;�DEJ�7HC;:��F;D7BJO�?I #44'561�/#;14

$� ?<�J>;O�97HHO�7HCI��B?A;�8EBEI�EH�AD?L;I��EH�B?9;DI;:�<?H;7HCI��F;D7BJO�?I 24+5+10�%144'%%+10#.

+H;IKCFJ?EDI�?<�F;HIED�FH;I;DJ�7J�J>;�C;;J?D=�97HH?;I�7D�KDB?9;DI;:�<?H;7HC�

7 FKHFEI;�E<�J>;�C;;J?D=�?I�JE�9ECC?J�79JI�FKD?I>78B;�KD:;H�J>;�-+�

8 9EDI?:;H;:�7I�B;7:;H�EH�EH=7D?P;H�E<�J>;�C;;J?D=���

�HJ� ��

+;HIEDI�B?78B;�

7 <EKD:;HI��:?H;9JEHI�7D:�FH;I?:;DJ�E<�J>;�7IIE9?7J?ED

8 C;H;�C;C8;HI�E<�J>;�7IIE9?7J?ED

Page 63: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�5>1/@�-??-A8@ �� �DE 7@C>�

2��'776?56C�6>A=@JD�7@C46�@C�:?E:>:52E:@?

3 ,96� 2:>�@7� E96� @776?56C� :D� E@� 2EE2:?� 2?J� @7� E96AFCA@D6D� @7� E96� 4C:>6� @7� C636==:@?� @C� 2?J� @7� E96@3;64ED�@7�E96�4C:>6D�@7�D65:E:@? ��

4��,96C6�:D�?@�AF3=:4�FAC:D:?8

?5 7@C>

2��'776?56C

���>2<6D�2?�2EE24<�

��6>A=@JD�7@C46�

���>2<6D�2�D6C:@FD�:?E:>:52E:@?��@C

���>2<6D�2�D6C:@FD�C6D:DE2?46

3�,96�A6CD@?�2DD2F=E65� :D�2�A6CD@?� :?�2FE9@C:EJ�@C9:D�286?E

4��E�E96�E:>6�@7�E96�2DD2F=E�E96�A6CD@?�:?�2FE9@C:EJ

����HJ ��

�?H;9J�7II7KBJ�97DDEJ�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�:KH?D=�H;8;BB?ED

�BM7OI�9ECFB;N;:�M?J>�J>;�C7J;H?7B�9EDI;GK;D9;�E<�J>;�79J��;=�:?H;9J�7II7KBJ�M?J>�CKH:;H��;N9;FJ�?<

H;IKBJ?D=�?D�7�B?=>J�<;BEDO��?D�M>?9>�97I;��J>;�9EDI;GK;D9;�?I�78IEH8;:

#?JJ?D=�J>;�FEB?9;C7D�ED�J>;�9>;IJ�M?J>�<?IJ�?I�DEJ�:?H;9J�7II7KBJ�8;97KI; ?<�:ED;�7=7?DIJ�7D�7=;DJ�E<�7

F;HIED�?D�7KJ>EH?JO��J>;�<EH9;�;CFBEO;:�CKIJ�8;�E<�I;H?EKI�9>7H79J;H

/>;�<EH9;�;CFBEO;:�D;;:�DEJ�8;�I;H?EKI�M>;D�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO�?I�7�F;HIED�?D�7KJ>EH?JO��;N�'7O?D=�E<

>7D:I�

/>;�?DJ?C?:7J?ED�EH�H;I?IJ7D9;�CKIJ�8; I;H?EKI�M>;J>;H�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO�?I�7D�7=;DJ�EDBO�EH�7�F;HIED

?D�7KJ>EH?JO��;N�+E?DJ?D=�7�=KD�

L;D�M>;D�J>;�F;HIED�?D�7KJ>EH?JO�EH�J>;�7=;DJ�7=H;;I�JE�<?=>J��IJ?BB�:?H;9J�7II7KBJ

2>;D�J>;�F;HIED�?D�7KJ>EH?JO�EH�J>;�7=;DJ�FHELEA;:�7JJ79A;:�<?HIJ��?DDE9;DJ�F7HJO�?I�;DJ?JB;:�JE�:;<;D:

>?CI;B<� 7D:� 97DDEJ� 8;� >;B:� B?78B;� <EH� 7II7KBJ� EH� H;I?IJ7D9;� DEH� <EH� F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I�� 8;97KI;� >;� 79JI� ?D

B;=?J?C7J;�I;B<:;<;DI;

/>;H;�97D�8;�DE�7II7KBJ�KFED�EH�:?IE8;:?;D9;�JE�ED;�7KJ>EH?JO�8O�7DEJ>;H�M>;D�J>;O�8EJ>�9EDJ;D:

J>7J�J>;O�M;H;�?D�J>;�;N;H9?I;�E<�J>;?H�H;IF;9J?L;�:KJ?;I

2>;D� 7II7KBJ� ?I� C7:;� 8O� H;7IED� E<� J>;� F;H<EHC7D9;� E<� >?I� :KJO� J>;H;� ?I� DE� D;;:� <EH� 79JK7B

F;H<EHC7D9;�E<�>?I�E<<?9?7B�:KJO�M>;D�7JJ79A;:

�?H9KCIJ7D9;I�GK7B?<O?D=�J>;�E<<;DI;��,K7B?<?;:��II7KBJ��

7 M>;D�J>;�7II7KBJ�?I�9ECC?JJ;:�M?J>�7�M;7FED

8 M>;D�J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�EH�;CFBEO;;

9 M>;D�J>;�E<<;D:;H�B7OI�>7D:�KFED�7�F;HIED�?D�7KJ>EH?JO

�ECFB;N�9H?C;�E<�:?H;9J�7II7KBJ�M?J>�>EC?9?:;�EH�CKH:;H��EH�M?J>�I;H?EKI F>OI?97B�?D@KH?;I���

L?9J?C�D;;:�DEJ�8;�F;HIED�?D�7KJ>EH?JO

Page 64: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

@C�9:D�286?E

��:D�6?82865�:?�E96�24EF2=�A6C7@C>2?46�@7�@77:4:2=5FE:6D� �� @C�E92E�96�:D�2DD2F=E65

�3J� C62D@?�@7� E96�A2DE�A6C7@C>2?46�@7�@77:4:2=5FE:6D ��

2� � � '776?56C� <?@HD� E92E� E96� @?6� 96� :D2DD2F=E:?8�:D�2�A6CD@?�:?�2FE9@C:EJ�@C�9:D�286?E�:?�E966I6C4:D6�@7�9:D�5FE:6D ��

3�,96C6�:D�?@�AF3=:4�FAC:D:?8

�:05>1/@�-??-A8@ �� 2� ���A6CD@?� :?�2FE9@C:EJ�@C�9:D�286?E� :D� E96�G:4E:>@7�2?J�@7�E96�7@C>D�@7�5:C64E�2DD2F=E�567:?65�:?��CE���

3����A6CD@?�4@>6D�E@�E96�2:5�@7�DF49�2FE9@C:EJ�@C9:D�286?E

4� '776?56C� >2<6D FD6� @7� 7@C46� @C� :?E:>:52E:@?FA@?� DF49� A6CD@?� 4@>:?8� E@� E96� 2:5� @7� E962FE9@C:EJ�@C�9:D�286?E

�5?;.1051:/1�@;�?A99;:? � 2�*67FD:?8�H:E9@FE�=682=�6I4FD6�E@�@36J�DF>>@?D

3�*67FD:?8�E@�36�DH@C?�@C�A=2465�F?56C�277:C>2E:@?

4�*67FD:?8� E@�2?DH6C� 2?J =682=� :?BF:CJ� E@�AC@5F463@@<D��C64@C5D�6E4

5�*6DEC2:?:?8�2?@E96C�7C@>�2EE6?5:?8�2D�H:E?6DD�:?DF49�3@5J

���CEJ?L;�?I�DEJ�;II;DJ?7B

���CEJ?L;�?I�;II;DJ?7B

� �M?J>�?DJ;DJ?ED�JE�E<<;D:��?D@KH;�EH�7II7KBJ

� �HJ ��

$D:?H;9J�7II7KBJ�97D�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�EDBO�M>;D�7�:?H;9J�7II7KBJ�?I�7BIE�9ECC?JJ;:

/E� 8;� ?D:?H;9J� 7II7KBJ�� J>;� F;HIED� M>E� I>EKB:� 8;� 7?:;:� ?I� J>;� 7=;DJ� �DEJ� J>;� F;HIED� ?D� 7KJ>EH?JO

8;97KI;� ?J� ?I� 7BH;7:O� :?H;9J� 7II7KBJ�� J>;� F;HIED� 9EC?D=� JE� J>;� 7?:� E<� J>;� F;HIED� ?D� 7KJ>EH?JO� 8;?D=

9EDI?:;H;:�7I�7D�7=;DJ�7D:�7D�7JJ79A�ED�J>;�B7JJ;H�?I�7BH;7:O�:?H;9J�7II7KBJ�� N7CFB;��?:?D=�7�FEB?9;C7D

KD:;H�7JJ79A� �

�HJ� ��

Page 65: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

6� !?5F4:?8� 5:D@365:6?46� E@� 2� DF>>@?D� @C� C67FD2=E@�36�DH@C?

&1?5?@-:/1� -:0� 05?;.1051:/1� @;� -<1>?;:�5:�-A@4;>5@E�;>�@41�-31:@�;2?A/4�<1>?;: ��

2 ��A6CD@?� :?�2FE9@C:EJ�@C�9:D�286?E� :D�6?82865� :?E96� A6C7@C>2?46� @7� @77:4:2=� 5FEJ� @C� 8:G6D� 2� =2H7F=@C56C�E@�E96�@776?56C

3 '776?56C� C6D:DED� @C� D6C:@FD=J� 5:D@36JD� DF49A6CD@?�:?�2FE9@C:EJ�@C�9:D�286?E

4� ,96� 24E� @7� E96� @776?56C� :D� ?@E :?4=F565� :?� E96AC@G:D:@?D�@7��CED����������2?5����

5 �?�286?E�@7� 2�A6CD@?� :?� 2FE9@C:EJ� :D� 6?82865� :?E96�A6C7@C>2?46�@7�@77:4:2=�5FEJ�8:G6D�2�=2H7F=�@C56CE@�E96�@776?56C

� ��HJ� � � F7H�

+;HIEDI�?D�7KJ>EH?JO��=;DJI�E< F;HIEDI�?D�7KJ>EH?JO���HJ� ���

+;HIED� ?D� �KJ>EH?JO W 7DO� F;HIED� :?H;9JBO� L;IJ;:�M?J>� @KH?I:?9J?ED��M>;J>;H� 7I� 7D ?D:?L?:K7B� EH� 7I� 7

C;C8;H�E<�IEC;�9EKHJ�EH�=EL;HDC;DJ7B�9EHFEH7J?ED��8E7H:�EH�9ECC?II?ED

7 �7H7D=7O�97FJ7?D

8 �7H7D=7O�9>7?HC7D

9 /;79>;HI

: +HE<;IIEHI

; +;HIEDI�9>7H=;:�M?J>�J>;�IKF;HL?I?ED�E<�FK8B?9�EH :KBO�H;9E=D?P;:�FH?L7J;�I9>EEBI��9EBB;=;I�7D:

KD?L;HI?J?;I

< '7MO;HI� ?D� J>;� 79JK7B� F;H<EHC7D9;� E<� J>;?H� FHE<;II?ED7B� :KJ?;I� EH� ED� J>;� E997I?ED� E<� IK9>

F;H<EHC7D9;

�=;DJ� E<� +;HIED� ?D� �KJ>EH?JO W 7DO� F;HIED� M>E�� 8O� :?H;9J� FHEL?I?ED� E<� B7M� EH� 8O� ;B;9J?ED� EH� 8O

7FFE?DJC;DJ�8O�9ECF;J;DJ�7KJ>EH?JO��?I�9>7H=;:�M?J>�J>;�C7?DJ;D7D9;�E<�FK8B?9�EH:;H�7D:�J>;�FHEJ;9J?ED

7D: I;9KH?JO�E<�B?<;�7D:�FHEF;HJO

7 �7HH?E�9EKD9?BC7D

8 �7HH?E�FEB?9;C7D

9 �7H7D=7O�B;7:;H

: CKD?9?F7B�JH;7IKH;H

; FEIJC7IJ;H

< .>;H?<<

= 7=;DJI�E<�J>;��$-

> (7B797U7D=�9ED<?:;DJ?7B�7=;DJ

? �DO�F;HIED�M>E�9EC;I�JE J>;�7?:�E<�F;HIEDI�?D�7KJ>EH?JO

.;9 ���� E<� J>;� 'E97B� "ELYJ� �E:;� FHEL?:;I� J>7J� Z<EH� FKHFEI;I� E<� J>;� -+��� J>; 27010)� $#4#0)#;�

5#0))70+#0)�$#4#0)#; C;C8;HI�7D:�C;C8;HI�E<� J>; .7210)� 6#)#2#/#;#2# ?D�;79>�87H7D=7O� I>7BB�8;

:;;C;:�7I�F;HIEDI� ?D� 7KJ>EH?JO� ?D� J>;?H� @KH?I:?9J?EDI��M>?B;�EJ>;H�87H7D=7O�E<<?9?7BI� 7D:�C;C8;HI�M>E

C7O�8;�:;I?=D7J;:�8O�B7M�EH�EH:?D7D9;�7D:�9>7H=;:�M?J>�J>;�C7?DJ;D7D9;�E<�FK8B?9�EH:;H��FHEJ;9J?ED�7D:

J>;� I;9KH?JO� E<� B?<;�� FHEF;HJO�� EH� J>;� C7?DJ;D7D9;� E<� 7� :;I?H78B;� 7D:� 87B7D9;:� ;DL?HEDC;DJ�� 7D:� 7DO

87H7D=7O�C;C8;H�M>E� 9EC;I� JE� J>;� 7?:� E<� F;HIEDI� ?D� 7KJ>EH?JO� I>7BB� 8;� :;;C;:� 7=;DJ� E<� F;HIEDI� ?D

7KJ>EH?JO

Page 66: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

'59<81�05?;.1051:/1 �� 2� '776?56C� 5:D@36JD� DF49� 286?E� @7� 2� A6CD@?� :?2FE9@C:EJ

3�+F49�5:D@365:6?46�:D�?@E�@7�2�D6C:@FD�?2EFC6

(A9A8@?�-:0�;@41>�05?@A>.-:/1?�;2<A.85/�;>01> ��

2��2FD:?8�2?J�D6C:@FD�5:DEFC32?46�:?�2�AF3=:4�A=246�@77:46�@C�6DE23=:D9>6?E

3� !?E6CCFAE:?8� @C� 5:DEFC3:?8� AF3=:4� A6C7@C>2?46D�7F?4E:@?D� 82E96C:?8D�@C�A62467F=�>66E:?8D��:7�E96�24E:D�?@E�:?4=F565�:?��CE�����2?5��� ��

4�%2<:?8�2?J�@FE4CJ� E6?5:?8� E@� :?4:E6� C636==:@?�@CD65:E:@?�:?�2?J�>66E:?8��2DD@4:2E:@?�@C�AF3=:4�A=246

5��:DA=2J:?8�A=242C5D�@C�6>3=6>D�H9:49�AC@G@<6�25:DEFC32?46�@7�AF3=:4�@C56C�:?�DF49�A=246

6� �FCJ:?8� H:E9� A@>A� E96� 3@5J� @7� 2� A6CD@?� H9@92D�366?�=682==J�6I64FE65

):8-C2A8� A?1� ;2� 91-:?� ;2<A.85/-@5;:� -:0� A:8-C2A8A@@1>-:/1? ��

2�(F3=:D9:?8�@C�42FD:?8�E@�36�AF3=:D965��3J�>62?D@7� AC:?E:?8�� =:E9@8C2A9J� @C 2?J� @E96C� >62?D� @7AF3=:42E:@?� 2D� ?6HD� 2?J� 72=D6� ?6HD� H9:49� >2J6?52?86C� E96�AF3=:4�@C56C��@C�42FD6�52>286� E@� E96:?E6C6DE�@C�4C65:E�@7�E96�+E2E6

3� �?4@FC28:?8� 5:D@365:6?46� E@� E96� =2H� @C� E@� E964@?DE:EFE65� 2FE9@C:E:6D� @C� 3J� AC2:D:?8�� ;FDE:7J:?8� @C6IE@==:?8� 2?J� 24E� AF?:D965� 3J� =2H�� 3J� E96� D2>6>62?D�@C�3J�H@C5D��FEE6C2?46D�@C�DA66496D

� �$:��F7H��

� ��HJ� ��

$<� J>;�79J�E<� :?IJKH8?D=�EH� ?DJ;HHKFJ?D=� 7�C;;J?D=�EH� H;B?=?EKI� 9;H;CEDO� ?I�)*/� 9ECC?JJ;:�8O�FK8B?9

E<<?9;HI��EH� ?<�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�FK8B?9�E<<?9;HI�J>;O�7H;�DEJ�F7HJ?9?F7DJI�J>;H;?D��J>?I�7HJ?9B;�7FFB?;I��HJ� �

7D:� ���FKD?I>;I�J>;�I7C;�79JI�?<�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�FK8B?9�E<<?9;HI�M>E�7H;�)*/�F7HJ?9?F7DJI�?D�J>;�C;;J?D=

/>;� EKJ9HO� ?I�C;H;BO� 7� FK8B?9� :?IEH:;H� ?<� ?J� ?I� 7D� KD9EDI9?EKI� EKJ8KHIJ�M>?9>�� 7BJ>EK=>� H;8;BB?EKI� EH

I;:?J?EKI� ?D� D7JKH;�� ?I� DEJ� ?DJ;DJ?ED7BBO� 97B9KB7J;:� JE� ?D:K9;� EJ>;HI� JE� 9ECC?J� H;8;BB?ED� EH� I;:?J?ED�

EJ>;HM?I;��?JI�?D9?J?D=�JE�H;8;BB?ED�EH�I;:?J?ED

/KCKBJKEKI W ?<� 97KI;:�8O�CEH;� J>7D���F;HIEDI�M>E�7H;�7HC;:�EH�FHEL?:;:�M?J>�C;7DI�E<�L?EB;D9;

�9?H9KCIJ7D9;�GK7B?<O?D=�J>;�:?IJKH87D9;�?DJ;HHKFJ?ED� W ZJKCKBJKEKI�?D�9>7H79J;H[� �

+K8B?9�*<<?9;HI�?DJ;HHKFJ?D=�F;79;<KB�C;;J?D=I�EH�H;B?=?EKI�MEHI>?F� �

�HJ� ��

Page 67: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4� � %2=:4:@FD=J� AF3=:D9:?8� @C� 42FD:?8� E@� 36AF3=:D965� 2?J� @77:4:2=� C6D@=FE:@?� @C� 5@4F>6?EH:E9@FE�AC@A6C�2FE9@C:EJ��@C�367@C6�E96J�92G6�366?AF3=:D965�@77:4:2==J

5� (C:?E:?8�� AF3=:D9:?8� @C� 5:DEC:3FE:?8� @C� �42FD:?8E96� D2>6��3@@<D�� A2>A9=6ED�� A6C:@5:42=D�@C� =627=6EDH9:49�5@�?@E�362C�E96�C62=�AC:?E6CND�?2>6�@C�H9:492C6�4=2DD:7:65�2D�2?@?J>@FD

�8->9?�-:0�?/-:0-8? �� 2� � ��:D492C8:?8�2?J�7:C62C>��C@4<6E�� 7:C64C24<6C��@C@E96C� 6IA=@D:G6� H:E9:?� 2?J� E@H?� @C� AF3=:4� A=246�42=4F=2E65�E@�42FD6�2=2C>�@C�52?86C

3� !?DE:82E:?8�@C� E2<:?8� 24E:G6�A2CE� :?� 2?J� 492C:G2C:@C�@E96C�5:D@C56C=J�>66E:?8�@776?D:G6�E@�2?@E96C�@CAC6;F5:4:2=�E@�AF3=:4�EC2?BF:=:EJ

4 �:DEFC3:?8� E96� AF3=:4� A6246� H9:=6� H2?56C:?823@FE� 2E� ?:89E� @C� H9:=6� 6?82865� :?� 2?J� @E96C?@4EFC?2=�2>FD6>6?E

5� �2FD:?8� 2?J� 5:DEFC32?46� @C� D42?52=� :?� AF3=:4A=246D�H9:=6� :?E@I:42E65�@C�@E96CH:D6��AC@G:565�E9624E�:D�?@E�4@G6C65�3J��CE���� ��

�185B1>5:3�<>5?;:1>?�2>;9�6-58 � 2 ,96C6� :D� 2� A6CD@?� 4@?7:?65� :?� 2� ;2:=� @C� A6?2=6DE23=:D9>6?E

3 '776?56C�C6>@G6D�E96C67@C�DF49�A6CD@?��@C�96=ADE96�6D42A6�@7�DF49�A6CD@? �

� ��HJ� ��

� �/KCKBJ

�>7H?L7H? W CE9A�I;H;D7:;�EH�:?I9EH:7DJ�DE?I;I�C7:;�M?J>�A;JJB;I�� J?D�>EHDI�;J9��:;I?=D;:�JE�:;H?:;�

?DIKBJ�EH�7DDEO

!?H;7HC�CKIJ�DEJ�8;�FE?DJ;:�7J�7�F;HIED��EJ>;HM?I;��?J�?I�?BB;=7B�:?I9>7H=;

2>7J�=EL;HDI�?I�J>;�H;IKBJ��DEJ�J>;�?DJ;DJ���

�HJ� ��

+H?IED;H�C7O�8;�:;J;DJ?ED�FH?IED;H�EH�ED;�I;DJ;D9;:�8O�L?HJK;�E<�7�<?D7B�@K:=C;DJ

��FEB?9;C7D�7II?=D;:�JE�J>;�9?JO�@7?B�7I�=K7H:�M>E�M>?B;�E<<:KJO�H;B;7I;:�7�FH?IED;H�?I�B?78B;�>;H;

$J�C7O�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�J>HEK=>�D;=B?=;D9;

�?H9KCIJ7D9;I�GK7B?<O?D=�J>;�E<<;DI; W ?I�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�C;7DI�E<�L?EB;D9;��?DJ?C?:7J?ED�EH�8H?8;HO

(?J?=7J?D=� 9?H9KCIJ7D9; W ?<� ?J� J7A;I� FB79;� EKJI?:;� J>;� F;D7B� ;IJ78B?I>C;DJ� 8O� J7A?D=� J>;� =K7H:I� 8O

IKHFH?I;��

?<�J>;�;I97F;;�?I�I;HL?D=�<?D7B�@K:=C;DJ��>; ?I =K?BJO�E<�;L7I?ED�E<�I;DJ;D9;

Page 68: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4��'776?56C�:D�2�AC:G2E6�:?5:G:5F2=

�B-?5;:�;2�?1:@1:/1�;>�?1>B5/1 2��'776?56C :D�2�4@?G:4E�3J�7:?2=�;F58>6?E

3� 6� :D� D6CG:?8� 9:D� D6?E6?46� H9:49� 4@?D:DED� :?56AC:G2E:@?�@7�=:36CEJ �

4� � 6� 6G256D� E96� D6CG:46� @7� 9:D� D6?E6?46� 3J6D42A:?8�5FC:?8�E96�E6C>�:7�9:D�D6?E6?46 �

�B-?5;:� ;2� ?1>B5/1� ;2� ?1:@1:/1� ;:@41� ;//-?5;:� ;2 05?;>01>?�/;:28-3>-@5;:?�� 1->@4=A-71?� ;>;@41>�/-8-95@51? �

2�'776?56C� :D� 2� 4@?G:4E� 3J� 7:?2=� ;F58>6?E�H9@� :D4@?7:?65�:?�2�A6?2=�:?DE:EFE:@?

3�,96C6�:D�5:D@C56C��C6DF=E:?8�7C@>�

��4@?7=28C2E:@?�

�62CE9BF2<6�

��6IA=@D:@?��@C

��D:>:=2C�42E2DEC@A96��@C

��>FE:?J�:? H9:49�96�92D�?@E�A2CE:4:A2E65

4� '776?56C� 6G256D� E96� D6CG:46� @7� 9:D� D6?E6?46� 3J=62G:?8� E96� A6?2=� :?DE:EFE:@?�H96C6� 96� :D� 4@?7:?65�@?� E96� @442D:@?� @7� DF49 5:D@C56C� @C� 5FC:?8� E96>FE:?J

����HJ� ��

��9EDJ?DK?D=�E<<;DI;

*<<;D:;HI W DEJ�C?DEH�:;B?DGK;DJI�DEH�:;J;DJ?ED�FH?IED;HI

$<�;I97F;:�M?J>?D�J>;� ��:7O�7FF;7B�F;H?E: W DE�;L7I?ED

)E�7FFB?978B;�JE�:;FEHJ7J?ED�7I�J>;�I;DJ;D9;

!B?CIO ;N9KI;�<EH�L?EB7J?D= &'56+'441 W DEJ�799;FJ78B;

�?H9KCIJ7D9;I�GK7B?<O?D=�J>;�E<<;DI;��:ED;�J>HK��

7 KDB7M<KB�;DJHO��8O�ZI97B?D=[�

8 8H;7A?D=�:EEHI��M?D:EMI��=7J;I��M7BBI��HEE<I�EH�<BEEHI

9 KI?D=�F?9ABE9AI��<7BI;�A;OI��:?I=K?I;��:;9;?J��L?EB;D9;�EH ?DJ?C?:7J?ED

: 9EDD?L7D9;�M?J>�EJ>;H�9EDL?9JI�EH�;CFBEO;;I�E<�J>;�F;D7B�?DIJ?JKJ?ED���

&'56+'441 ?D9BK:;:���

<79J�E<�H;JKHD�?CC7J;H?7B���

�HJ� ��

+;D7BJO��7D�?D9H;7I;�8O� ���E<�J>;�J?C;�H;C7?D?D=�JE�8;�I;HL;:�KD:;H�J>;�EH?=?D7B�I;DJ;D9;��?D�DE�97I;

JE�;N9;;:���CEDJ>I

*<<;D:;H�CKIJ�;I97F;�JE�8;�;DJ?JB;:�JE�7BBEM7D9;

(KJ?DO W EH=7D?P;:�KDB7M<KB�H;I?IJ7D9;�JE�7�IKF;H?EH�E<<?9;H��7�I;:?J?ED��7�H;LEBJ

�?I7HC?D=�J>;�=K7H:I ?I�DEJ�CKJ?DO

Page 69: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

5� '776?56C� 72:=D� E@� 8:G6� 9:>D6=7� FA� E@� E962FE9@C:E:6D�H:E9:?����9@FCD�7@==@H:?8�E96�:?DFC2?46@7� 2� AC@4=2>2E:@?� 3J� E96� 49:67� 6I64FE:G62??@F?4:?8�E96�A2DD:?8�2H2J�@7�DF49�42=2>:EJ

*5;8-@5;:�;2�/;:05@5;:-8�<->0;: � 2 '776?56C�H2D�2�4@?G:4E

3� 6�H2D�8C2?E65�2�4@?5:E:@?2=�A2C5@?�3J�E96�49:676I64FE:G6

4� 6�G:@=2E65�2?J�@7�E96�4@?5:E:@?D�@7�DF49�A2C5@?

,� �0.=00��:/41D492�?30��,B>�:9��7702,7���(97,B1@7

#:>>0>>4:9�� ,9@1,.?@=0���0,7492�49���.<@4>4?4:9�:=

�4>;:>4?4:9��:1��4=0,=8>���88@94?4:9�:=��C;7:>4A0> �

,>�,9�070809?�:1�?30�.=480>�:1�=0-0774:9��49>@==0.?4:9�

>0/4?4:9��:=�,??08;?0/ ������� �� �

-� �@8,9�&0.@=4?D��.?�:1��� �

���#@94>3,-70�,.?>�:1�?0==:=4>8 ��

����*3:�,=0�74,-70 ��

�����->:=;?4:9�;=49.4;70 49�=07,?4:9�?:�.:8;70C

.=480>

'E96C� 4C:>6D� 4@>>:EE65� :?� E96� 4@FCD6� @7� 24ED� @7� E6CC@C:D> 2C6� 566>6523D@C365 6:E96C 2D� 2� >62?D� ?646DD2CJ� 7@C� E96:C 4@>>:DD:@?� @C� 2D� 2?� F?:?E6?56567764E�@7�24ED�@7�E6CC@C:D>

,96J�42??@E�36�492C865�2D�D6A2C2E6�@776?D6D�:?�E96>D6=G6D

����HJ� ��

$D<H?D=;C;DJ�E<�9ED:?J?EDI�J;HCI�E<�+H;I?:;DJ

�ED:?J?ED�;NJ;D:I�JE�IF;9?7B�B7MI W L?EB7J?ED�E<�?BB;=7B�LEJ?D=

*<<;D:;H�CKIJ�>7L;�8;;D�<EKD:�=K?BJO�E<�J>;�IK8I;GK;DJ�E<<;DI;�8;<EH;�>;�97D�8;�FHEI;9KJ;:�KD:;H

J>?I� �HJ?9B;� �KJ� ?<� KD:;H� -;L?I;:��:C?D� �E:;�� DE� 9EDL?9J?ED� D;9;II7HO� +H;I?:;DJ� >7I� FEM;H� JE� 7HH;IJ�

H;?D97HD7J;�E<<;D:;H�M?J>EKJ�JH?7B���

+�� �����7I�7C;D:;:�8O�-���������

IKFH7���

-���������

IKFH7��

$8?:

Page 70: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

���>591?��3-5:?@�$A.85/ �:@1>1?@

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED @H 4@>>:EE65

�;A:@1>215@5:3� 3>1-@� ?1-8� ;23;B1>:91:@ �

2 �@C8:?8�E96�8C62E�D62=�@7�E96��@G6C?>6?E

3 �@C8:?8�E96�D:8?2EFC6�@7�E96�(C6D:56?E

4 �@C8:?8�E96�DE2>A�@7�E96�(C6D:56?E

)?5:3� 2;>310� ?53:-@A>1� ;>/;A:@1>215@�?1-8�;>�?@-9< ��

2� �,96�8C62E�D62=�@7�E96�C6AF3=:4�H2D�4@F?E6C76:E65@C�E96�D:8?2EFC6�@C�DE2>A�@7�E96�49:67�6I64FE:G6�H2D7@C865�3J�2?@E96C�A6CD@?

3��'776?56C <?6H�@7�E96�4@F?E6C76:E:?8�@C�7@C86CJ

4�� 6�FD65�E96�4@F?E6C76:E�D62=�@C�7@C865�D:8?2EFC6@C�DE2>A

!-75:3� -:0� 59<;>@5:3� -:0A@@1>5:3�2-8?1�/;5:? ��

2�,96C6�36�72=D6�@C�4@F?E6C76:E65�4@:?D ��

3�'776?56C�6:E96C�>256�� :>A@CE65�@C�FEE6C65�DF494@:?D

4� !?� 42D6� @7� FEE6C:?8� DF49� 72=D6� @C� 4@F?E6C76:E654@:?D��96�4@??:G6D�H:E9�4@F?E6C76:E6CD�@C�:>A@CE6CD

!A8@58-@5;:� ;2� /;5:? G 59<;>@-@5;:-:0�A@@1>-:/1 ��

����HJ� �

2>;D�J>;�I?=D7JKH;�E<�J>;�+H;I?:;DJ�?I�<EH=;:��?J�?I�DEJ�<7BI?<?97J?ED�8KJ�<EH=?D=�E<�I?=D7JKH;�KD:;H�J>?I

7HJ?9B;

.?=D7JKH;�CKIJ�8;�<EH=;:��EJ>;HI�I?=D;:�?J W DEJ�J>;�+H;I?:;DJ���

�HJ� ��

*<<;D:;H�?I�DEJ�J>;�<EH=;H�DEJ�J>;�97KI;�E<�J>;�9EKDJ;H<;?J?D=���

0JJ;H W JE�F7II�9EKDJ;H<;?J;:�9E?DI��:;B?L;H�EH�=?L;�7M7O

$CFEHJ W JE�8H?D=�JE�FEHJ�J>;�I7C;

�EJ>�+>?B?FF?D;�7D:�<EH;?=D�IJ7J;�9E?DI

�FFB?;I�7BIE�JE�9E?DI�M?J>:H7MD�<HEC�9?H9KB7J?ED

II;D9;�E<�7HJ?9B;��C7A?D=�E<�9E?DI�M?J>EKJ�7KJ>EH?JO���

);;:�DEJ�8;�B;=7B�J;D:;H

�EKDJ;H<;?J?D= W ?C?J7J?ED�E<�B;=7B�EH�=;DK?D;�9E?D��C7O�9EDJ7?D�CEH;�I?BL;H��:?<<;H;DJ�:;I?=D��IK9>�7I

JE�:;9;?L;�7D�EH:?D7HO�F;HIED�?D�8;B?;L?D=�?J�JE�8;�=;DK?D;���

�HJ� ��

/>?I�>7I�8;;D�H;F;7B;:�8O�+�����

Page 71: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

'1885:3� ;2� 2-8?1� ;>� 9A@58-@10� /;5:�C5@4;A@�/;::5B-:/1 ��

��(@DD6DD:@?�@7�4@:?� 4@F?E6C76:E65@C�>FE:=2E65� 3J� 2?@E96C� A6CD@?��H:E9:?E6?E�E@�FEE6C�E96�D2>6��<?@H:?8�E92E:E�:D�72=D6�@C�>FE:=2E65

� �4EF2==J� FEE6C:?8� DF49� 72=D6� @C>FE:=2E65� 4@:?�� <?@H:?8� E96� D2>6� E@36�72=D6�@C�>FE:=2E65

2���A@DD6DD:@?3���H:E9�:?E6?E�E@ FEE6C��2?54���<?@H=6586

2���24EF2==J�FEE6C:?8��2?53���<?@H=6586

�;>35:3� @>1-?A>E� ;>� .-:7� :;@1? G59<;>@5:3�-:0�A@@1>5:3 ��

�@C8:?8� @C� 72=D:EJ� @7� EC62DFCJ32?<� ?@E6D� @C5@4F>6?ED�A2J23=6�E@�362C6C

3 !>A@CE:?8�@7�DF49�?@E6D

0D:;H�J>?I�+���J>;�79JI�FKD?I>78B;�7H;�

7 M?BB<KB�:;<79;C;DJ

8 CKJ?B7J?ED

9 J;7H?D=

: 8KHD?D=

; :;IJHK9J?ED�E<��;DJH7B��7DA�DEJ;I�7D:�9E?DI

(KJ?B7J?ED�KD:;H�J>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:;�?I�JHK;�EDBO�JE�9E?DI��$J�97DDEJ�8;�7�9H?C;�KD:;H�J>;�-;L?I;:

+;D7B��E:;�JE�CKJ?B7J;�F7F;H�8?BBI�8;97KI;�J>; ?:;7�E<�CKJ?B7J?ED�KD:;H�J>;�9E:;�?I�9EBB;9J?D=�J>;�FH;9?EKI

C;J7B�:KIJ��#EM;L;H��KD:;H�+H;I?:;DJ?7B��;9H;;�)E������CKJ?B7J?ED�?I�DEJ�B?C?J;:�JE�9E?DI

�HJ� ��

(KJ?B7J?ED W JE� J7A;� E<<� F7HJ� E<� J>;�C;J7B� ;?J>;H� 8O� <?BB?D=� ?J� EH� IK8IJ?JKJ?D=� ?J� <EH� 7DEJ>;H�C;J7B� E<

?D<;H?EH�GK7B?JO��JE�:?C?D?I>�8O�?D<;H?EH�C;7DI��JE�:?C?D?I>�C;J7B�9EDJ;DJI�

!EH;?=D�DEJ;I�7D:�9E?DI�DEJ�?D9BK:;:�(KIJ�8;�B;=7B�J;D:;H

(KIJ�8;�?DJ;DJ?ED�JE�CKJ?B7J;���

�HJ� ��

+EII;II?ED�:E;I�DEJ�H;GK?H;�B;=7B�J;D:;H�?D�<EH;?=D�9E?DI

$D9BK:;I�9EDIJHK9J?L;�FEII;II?ED���

�HJ� ��

!EH=?D= W 8O�=?L?D=�7�JH;7IKHO�EH�87DA�DEJ;�EH�:E9KC;DJ�F7O78B;�JE�8;7H;H�EH:;H�7D�7FF;7H7D9;�E<�7

JHK;�7D:�=;DK?D;�:E9KC;DJ

!7BI?<?97J?ED W 8O�;H7I?D=��IK8IJ?JKJ?D=��9EKDJ;H<;?J?D=�EH�7BJ;H?D=�8O�7DO�C;7DI�J>;�<?=KH;I�7D:�B;JJ;HI�

MEH:I��I?=DI�9EDJ7?D;:�J>;H;?D

;=�<7BI?<O?D= W BEJJE�EH�IM;;FIJ7A;I�J?9A;J��JJ;CFJ;:�;IJ7<7�J>HEK=>�<7BI?<?97J?ED�E<�7D�E8B?=7J?ED�EH

I;9KH?JO�E<�J>;�+>?B

����%*'%-5�016�+0%.7&'&�*'4' W ?JYI�<7BI?<?97J?ED�E<�9ECC;H9?7B�:E9KC;DJ�KD:;H��HJ?9B;� ��

*8B?=7J?ED�EH�I;9KH?JO�?D9BK:;I� 8ED:I��9;HJ?<?97J;�E<�?D:;8J;:D;II��8?BBI��D7J?ED7B�87DA�DEJ;I��9EKFEDI�

JH;7IKHO�DEJ;I��9;HJ?<?97J;�E<�:;FEI?JI��9>;9AI��:H7<JI�<EH�CED;O��IM;;FIJ7A;I�CED;O

$<�J>;�<7BI?<?97J?ED�?I�:ED;�ED�7�:E9KC;DJ�J>7J�?I�9B7II?<?;:�7I�7�=EL;HDC;DJ�I;9KH?JO��J>;D�J>;�9H?C;�?I

FKD?I>;:�KD:;H��HJ?9B;� ���*D�J>;�EJ>;H�>7D:��?<�?J�?I�DEJ�7�=EL;HDC;DJ�I;9KH?JO��J>;D�J>;�E<<;D:;H�C7O

;?J>;H�>7L;�L?EB7J;:��HJ?9B;� � �EH� ��

Page 72: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4 -EE6C:?8�@7 DF49� 72=D6�@C� 7@C865�@3=:82E:@?D� 2?5?@E6D�:?�4@??:G2?46�H:E9�7@C86CD�2?5�:>A@CE6CD

�;A:@1>215@5:3�� 59<;>@5:3�� -:0A@@1>5:3� 5:?@>A91:@?� :;@� <-E-.81@;�.1->1> ��

2�,96C6�36 2?�:?DECF>6?E�A2J23=6�E@�@C56C�@C�@E96C5@4F>6?E�@7�4C65:E�?@E�A2J23=6�E@�362C6C

3�'776?56C�6:E96C�7@C865��:>A@CE65�@C�FEE6C65�DF49:?DECF>6?ED

4� ,92E� :?� 42D6� @7� FEE6C:?8�� 96� 4@??:G65� H:E9� E967@C86C�@C�:>A@CE6C

�8813-8�<;??1??5;:�-:0�A?1�;2 2-8?1@>1-?A>E�;>�.-:7�:;@1?�-:0�;@41>5:?@>A91:@�;2�/>105@ ��

2 �?J�EC62DFCJ�@C�32?<�?@E6�@C�46CE:7:42E6�@C�@E96C@3=:82E:@?� 2?5� D64FC:EJ� A2J23=6� E@� 362C6C�� @C� 2?J:?DECF>6?E�A2J23=6� E@�@C56C�@C�@E96C�5@4F>6?E�@74C65:E�?@E�A2J23=6�E@�362C6C�:D�7@C865�@C�72=D:7:65�3J2?@E96C�A6CD@?

3 '776?56C�<?@HD�E92E�2?J�@7�E9@D6�:?DECF>6?ED�:D7@C865�@C�72=D:7:65

4 6�A6C7@C>D�2?J�@7�E96D6�24ED L

� FD:?8� 2?J� @7� DF49� 7@C865� @C� 72=D:7:65:?DECF>6?E��@C

A@DD6DD:?8 H:E9� :?E6?E� E@� FD6� 2?J� @7� DF497@C865�@C�72=D:7:65�:?DECF>6?E

�;>31>E �� 2� �J� 8:G:?8� E@� 2� EC62DFCJ� @C� 32?<� ?@E6� @C� 2?J

����HJ� ��

����HJ� ��

�9J�IEK=>J�JE�8;�FKD?I>;:�

&DEM?D=BO�FEII;II?D=�M?J>�?DJ;DJ�JE�KI;�7DO�E<�IK9>�<EH=;:�JH;7IKHO�EH�87DA�DEJ;I��

�HJ?9B;� ��

!EH=;HO� KD:;H� J>;� -;L?I;:� +;D7B� �E:;� 7FFB?;I� JE� F7F;HI�� M>?9>� 7H;� ?D� J>;� <EHC� E<� E8B?=7J?EDI� 7D:

I;9KH?J?;I� ?IIK;:�8O�J>;�+>?B?FF?D;�=EL;HDC;DJ�7I� ?JI�EMD�E8B?=7J?EDI��M>?9>� ?I�=?L;D�J>;�I7C;�IJ7JKI�7I

B;=7B� J;D:;H� �";D;H7BBO�� J>;�MEH:�Z9EKDJ;H<;?J?D=[� ?I�DEJ�KI;:�M>;D� ?J� 9EC;I� JE�DEJ;I��M>7J� ?I�KI;:� ?I

Z<EH=;HO[���EKDJ;H<;?J?D=�H;<;HI�JE�CED;O��M>;J>;H�9E?DI�EH�8?BBI

)EJ?9;� J>7J�C;H;� 9>7D=;� ED� 7� :E9KC;DJ� :E;I� DEJ� 7CEKDJ� JE� J>?I� 9H?C;� � />;� ;II;D9;� E<� <EH=;HO� ?I

=?L?D=� 7� :E9KC;DJ� J>;� 7FF;7H7D9;� E<� 7� JHK;� 7D:� =;DK?D;� :E9KC;DJ� � )EJ� 7DO� 7BJ;H7J?ED� E<� 7� B;JJ;H�

DKC8;H��<?=KH;�EH�:;I?=D�MEKB:�7CEKDJ�JE�<EH=;HO �J�CEIJ��?J�MEKB:�EDBO�8;�<HKIJH7J;:�<EH=;HO

2>;D�M>7J� ?I� 8;?D=� 9EKDJ;H<;?J;:� ?I� E8B?=7J?ED�EH� I;9KH?J?;I��M>?9>�KD:;H� J>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:;� ?I

=?L;D�7�IJ7JKI�E<�CED;O�EH�B;=7B�J;D:;H��J>;�9H?C;�9ECC?JJ;:�?I�<EH=;HO

�?IJ?D9J?ED�8;JM;;D�<7BI?<?97J?ED�7D:�<EH=;HO

Page 73: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

:?DECF>6?E� A2J23=6� E@� 362C6C� @C� E@� @C56C�� E962AA62C2?46�@7�2�ECF6�2?5�86?F:?6�5@4F>6?E

3� ��J 6C2D:?8�� DF3DE:EFE:?8�� 4@F?E6C76:E:?8�� 2=E6C:?83J�2?J�>62?D�E96�7:8FC6D��=6EE6CD�@C�H@C5D��@C�D:8?D4@?E2:?65�E96C6:?

�-8?525/-@5;:� ;2� 8135?8-@5B10;/A91:@? �

2 � 3:==�� C6D@=FE:@?� @C� @C5:?2?46� 6?24E65� @C2AAC@G65� @C� A6?5:?8� 2AAC@G2=� � � 3J� E96� ?2E:@?2=2DD6>3=J� @C� 2?J� AC@G:?4:2=� 3@2C5� @C� >F?:4:A2=4@F?4:= ��

3 '776?56C�2=E6CD�E96�D2>6

4��� 6�92D�?@�AC@A6C�2FE9@C:EJ�E96C67@C

5 ,96� 2=E6C2E:@?� 92D� 492?865� E96 >62?:?8� @7� E965@4F>6?E

!7BI?<?97J?ED� ?I�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<�7DO�E<�J>;�;?=>J 79JI�C;DJ?ED;:�?D��HJ � �ED�B;=?IB7J?L;��FK8B?9�EH

E<<?9?7B��9ECC;H9?7B��EH�FH?L7J;�:E9KC;DJI��EH�M?H;B;II��EH�J;B;=H7F>�C;II7=;I

/>; J;HC�<EH=;HO 7I�KI;:� ?D��HJ ���H;<;HI�JE�J>;� <7BI?<?97J?ED�7D:�9EKDJ;H<;?J?D=�E<�JH;7IKHO�EH�87DA

DEJ;I�EH�7DO�?DIJHKC;DJI�F7O78B;�JE�8;7H;H�EH�JE�EH:;H���

�HJ ��

�99KI;:�CKIJ� DEJ� 8;� 7� FK8B?9� E<<?9?7B� ;DJHKIJ;:�M?J>� J>;� 9KIJE:O� EH� FEII;II?ED� E<� IK9>� :E9KC;DJ�

EJ>;HM?I;���HJ� � �7FFB?;I

/>;� <7BI?<?97J?ED� CKIJ� 8;� 9ECC?JJ;:� ED� 7� =;DK?D;�� JHK;� 7D:� 7KJ>;DJ?9� B;=?IB7J?L;� :E9KC;DJ� $<

9ECC?JJ;:�ED�7�I?CKB7J;:��IFKH?EKI�EH�<78H?97J;:�B;=?IB7J?L;�:E9KC;DJ��J>;�9H?C;�?I�DEJ�FKD?I>;:�KD:;H

J>?I�7HJ?9B;�8KJ�KD:;H��HJ � �EH� �����

/>;�MEH:I��CKD?9?F7B�9EKD9?B��I>EKB:�?D9BK:;�J>;�9?JO�9EKD9?B�EH�CKD?9?F7B�8E7H: W -;O;I

Page 74: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�-8?525/-@5;:� ;2� 0;/A91:@?� .E<A.85/�;225/1>��19<8;E11��;>�:;@->E;>�1//81?5-?@5/-8�95:5?@1> ��

2�'776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C��6>A=@J66��@C�?@E2CJAF3=:4

3� 6�E2<6D�25G2?E286�@7�9:D�@77:4:2=�A@D:E:@?

4� 6�72=D:7:6D�2�5@4F>6?E�3J�4@>>:EE:?8�2?J @7�E967@==@H:?8�24ED�

���@F?E6C76:E:?8� @C� :>:E2E:?8� 2?J� 92?5HC:E:?8�D:8?2EFC6�@C�CF3C:4

*6BF:D:E6D�

:� ,96C6� 36� 2?� :?E6?E� E@� :>:E2E6�� @C� 2?2EE6>AE�E@�:>:E2E6

::� �,96� EH@� D:8?2EFC6D�@C�92?5HC:E:?8D�� E9686?F:?6�2?5� E96� 7@C865��362C�D@>6�C6D6>3=2?46� E@6249�@E96C

� �2FD:?8� :E� E@� 2AA62C� E92E� A6CD@?D� 92G6A2CE:4:A2E65�:?�2?J�24E�@C�AC@4665:?8�H96?�E96J�5:5?@E�:?�724E�D@�A2CE:4:A2E6

����EEC:3FE:?8�E@�A6CD@?D�H9@�92G6�A2CE:4:A2E65:?�2?�24E�@C�AC@4665:?8�DE2E6>6?ED�@E96C�E92?�E9@D6:?�724E�>256�3J�E96>

*6BF:D:E6D�

:� � '776?56C� 42FD65� :E� E@� 2AA62C� :?� 25@4F>6?E�E92E�2�A6CD@?D�A2CE:4:A2E65�:?�2?�24E�@C�2AC@4665:?8��2?5

::� +F49� A6CD@?D� 5:5� ?@E� :?� 724E� D@A2CE:4:A2E6�:?�E96�24E�@C�AC@4665:?8

���%2<:?8�F?ECFE97F=�DE2E6>6?ED�:?�2�?2CC2E:@?@7�724ED ��

����HJ �

���!EH�ED;�JE�8;�>;B:�9H?C?D7BBO�B?78B;��J>;�KDJHKJ><KB�IJ7J;C;DJ�CKIJ�8;�IK9>�7I�JE�;<<;9J�J>;�?DJ;=H?JO�E<

J>;�:E9KC;DJ�EH�JE�9>7D=;�J>;�;<<;9JI�M>?9>�?J�MEKB:�EJ>;HM?I;�FHE:K9;

';=7B�E8B?=7J?ED�C;7DI�J>7J�J>;H;�?I�7�B7M�H;GK?H?D=�J>;�:?I9BEIKH;�E< J>;�JHKJ>�E<�J>;�<79JI�D7HH7J;:� N

-;I?:;D9;�9;HJ?<?97J;I

/>;�F;HIED�C7A?D=�J>;�D7HH7J?ED�E<�<79JI�CKIJ�8;�7M7H;�E<�J>;�<7BI?JO�E<�J>;�<79JI�D7HH7J;:�8O�>?C�/>?I

A?D:�E<�<7BI?<?97J?ED�C7O�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�EC?II?ED

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�7�D7HH7J?ED�E< <79JI��DEJ�7�9ED9BKI?ED�E<�B7M�(KIJ�8;�ED�7�C7J;H?7B�C7JJ;H

Page 75: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

*6BF:D:E6D�

:� � � '776?56C� >2<6D� :?� 2� 5@4F>6?EDE2E6>6?ED�:?�2�?2CC2E:@?�@7�724ED

::�� 6�92D�2�=682=�@3=:82E:@?�E@�5:D4=@D6�E96ECFE9�@7�E96�724ED�?2CC2E65�3J�9:>���C6BF:C65�3J�=2HE@�36�5@?6��2?5

:::� ,96� 724ED� ?2CC2E65� 3J� E96� @776?56C� 2C623D@=FE6=J�72=D6��2?5

:G�,96�A6CG6CD:@?�@C�ECFE9�:?�E96�?2CC2E:@?@7� 724ED� H2D� >256� H:E9� E96� HC@?87F=� :?E6?E� @7:?;FC:?8�2�E9:C5�A6CD@?

����=E6C:?8�ECF6�52E6D ��

�� %2<:?8� 2?J� 2=E6C2E:@?� @C� :?E6C42=2E:@?� :?� 286?F:?6�5@4F>6?E�H9:49�492?86D�:ED�>62?:?8

*6BF:D:E6D�

:� � ,96C6� 36� 2?� 2=E6C2E:@?� �492?86�� @C:?E6C42=2E:@?��:?D6CE:@?��@?�2�5@4F>6?E

::��%256�@?�2�86?F:?6�5@4F>6?E

:::� ,96� 2=E6C2E:@?:?E6C42=2E:@?� 92D� 492?865E96�>62?:?8�@7�E96�5@4F>6?E

:G� ,96� 492?86� >256� E96� 5@4F>6?E� DA62<D@>6E9:?8�72=D6

��!DDF:?8� :?�2?�2FE96?E:42E65�7@C>�2�5@4F>6?EAFCA@CE:?8� E@� 36� 2� 4@AJ� @7� 2?� @C:8:?2=� 5@4F>6?EH96?� ?@� DF49� @C:8:?2=� 6I:DED�� @C� :?4=F5:?8� :?� DF494@AJ�2�DE2E6>6?E�4@?EC2CJ�E@��@C�5:776C6?E�7C@>��E92E@7�E96�86?F:?6�@C:8:?2= �� @C

����7J;�CKIJ�8;�;II;DJ?7B

/>;�:E9KC;DJ�CKIJ�8;�C7J;H?7B�JE�J>;�H?=>J�9H;7J;:�EH�JE�J>;�E8B?=7J?ED�J>7J�?I�;NJ?D=K?I>;:���

+(�01�-019.'&)'��(#.5+(+%#6+10�6*417)*�0').+)'0%'

/>;�79JI�E<�<7BI?<?97J?ED�C;DJ?ED;:�?D�J>?I�F7H7=H7F>�7H;�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�EH�8O�7�DEJ7HO

FK8B?9�M>E� J7A;I� 7:L7DJ7=;�E<�>?I� E<<?9?7B� FEI?J?ED�7I� 9KIJE:?7D�E<� J>;�:E9KC;DJ� $J� 97D�7BIE� H;<;H� JE� 7

FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�EH�DEJ7HO�M>E�FH;F7H;:�7D:�H;J7?D;:�7�9EFO�E< J>;�:E9KC;DJ *'�(#.5+(+%#6+10�%#0�$'�&10'

+0�691�9#;5�$J�97D�8;�7�9;HJ?<?97J?ED�FKHFEHJ?D=�JE�I>EM�J>7J�J>;�:E9KC;DJ�?IIK;:�?I�7�9EFO�E<�J>;�EH?=?D7B

Page 76: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�-8?525/-@5;:�.E�<>5B-@1�5:05B50A-8?-:0�A?1�;2 2-8?52510�0;/A91:@?

�-8?525/-@5;:�;2�<>5B-@1�0;/A91:@ ��

)?1�;2�2-8?52510�0;/A91:@

� !?E6C42=2E:?8� 2?J� :?DECF>6?E� @C� ?@E6� C6=2E:G6E@� E96� :DDF2?46� E96C6@7� :?� 2� AC@E@4@=�� C68:DECJ�� @C@77:4:2=�3@@<

2�'776?56C�:D�2�AC:G2E6�:?5:G:5F2=�@C�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C@C� 6>A=@J66� H9@� 5:5� ?@E� E2<6� 25G2?E286� @7� 9:D@77:4:2=�A@D:E:@?

3� 6� 4@>>:EE65� 2?J� @7� E96� 24ED� @7� 72=D:7:42E:@?6?F>6C2E65�:?��CE���� ��

4�,96�72=D:7:42E:@?�H2D�4@>>:EE65�:?�2?J�AF3=:4�@C@77:4:2=�@C�4@>>6C4:2=�5@4F>6?E ��

2� '776?56C� 4@>>:EE65� 2?J� @7� E96� 24ED� @772=D:7:42E:@?�� 6I46AE� E9@D6� :?� A2C28C2A9� �� 2?5� ��6?F>6C2E65�:?��CE����

3� ,96� 72=D:7:42E:@?� H2D� 4@>>:EE65� :?� 2?J� AC:G2E65@4F>6?E

4�,96�72=D:7:42E:@?�42FD65�52>286 �� E@�2�E9:C5�A2CEJ@C� 2E� =62DE� E96� 72=D:7:42E:@?� H2D� 4@>>:EE65� H:E9:?E6?E�E@�42FD6�DF49�52>286

2 !?EC@5F4:?8�:?�2�;F5:4:2=�AC@4665:?8�

��'776?56C�<?6H� E92E� 2�5@4F>6?E�H2D� 72=D:7:653J�2?@E96C�A6CD@?

�,96�72=D6�5@4F>6?E�:D�6>3C2465�:?�2CE�����@C

ED�H;9EH:�M>;D�DE�IK9>�EH?=?D7B�;N?IJI�$J�97D�7BIE�8;�?D�J>;�<EHC�E<�7�9;HJ?<?97J?ED�JE�J>;�;<<;9J�J>7J�J>;

:E9KC;DJ� ED� <?B;� 9EDJ7?DI� IJ7J;C;DJI� EH� ?D9BK:?D=� ?D� J>;� 9EFO� ?IIK;:�� ;DJH?;I�M>?9>� 7H;� DEJ� <EKD:� ED

9EDJH7HO�JE��EH�:?<<;H;DJ�<HEC�J>;�EH?=?D7B�=;DK?D;�:E9KC;DJ�ED�<?B;���

�HJ� ��

!7BI?<?97J?ED�E<�+H?L7J;��E9KC;DJI�

+H;@K:?9;�JE�J>?H:�F7HJO�?I�7D�;B;C;DJ�E<�J>;�E<<;DI;

!7BI?<?97J?ED�E<�+K8B?9�*<<?9?7B��E9KC;DJI�

+H;@K:?9;� JE� J>?H:� F;HIEDI� ?I� ?CC7J;H?7B�� M>7J� ?I� FKD?I>;:� ?I� J>;� L?EB7J?ED� E<� FK8B?9� <7?J>� 7D:

F;HL;HI?ED�E<�JHKJ>�M>?9>�J>;�:E9KC;DJ�FHE9B7?CI���

IKFH7���

0D:;H�J>?I�F7H7=H7F>� &#/#)'�+5�016�'55'06+#.��?J�?I�FH;IKC;:

$<� J>;� <7BI?<?97J?ED E<�FK8B?9�� E<<?9?7B� EH� 9ECC;H9?7B� :E9KC;DJI��M>;J>;H� J>;O�8;�FK8B?9�E<<?9?7B� EH�8O

FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7BI� +6�+5�016�0'%'55#4;�6*#6�6*'4'�$'�24'5'06�6*'�+&'#�1(�)#+0�14�6*'�+06'06�61�+0,74'�#�6*+4&

2'4510�2>7J�?I�FKD?I>;:�KD:;H�J>;�B7M�?I�J>;�L?EB7J?ED�E<�FK8B?9�<7?J>�7D:�J>;�F;HL;HI?ED�E<�J>;�JHKJ>�7I

IEB;CDBO�FHE9B7?C;:�8O�J>;�D7JKH;�E<�J>;�:E9KC;DJ ��#4'2�85���#0&+)#0$#;#0���

;II;DJ?7B�;B;C;DJ��>;D9;��DE�9H?C;�E<�;IJ7<7�J>HK�<7BI?<?97J?ED�E<�FH?L7J;�:E9KC;DJ

Page 77: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

:?�2?J�DF35:G:D:@?D�?@D���2?5� �@7�2CE���

�� 6� :?EC@5F465� D2:5� 5@4F>6?E� :?� 6G:56?46 :?2?J�;F5:4:2=�AC@4665:?8 �

3�-D6�:?�2?J�@E96C�EC2?D24E:@?�

��'776?56C�<?6H�E92E�2�5@4F>6?E�H2D�72=D:7:653J�2?@E96C�A6CD@?

�,96�72=D6�5@4F>6?E�:D�6>3C2465�:?�2CE�����@C:?�2?J�@7�DF35:G:D:@?D�?@D���2?5� �@7�2CE���

�� 6�FD65�DF49 5@4F>6?ED ��

�� ,96� FD6� @7� E96� 5@4F>6?ED� 42FD65� 52>286� E@2?@E96C� @C� 2E� =62DE� H2D� FD65� H:E9� :?E6?E� E@� 42FD6DF49�52>286

�-8?525/-@5;:� ;2� C5>181??�� /-.81�@1813>-<4�� -:0� @181<4;:191??-31?��-:0�A?1�;2�?-50�2-8?5251091??-31? ��

� -EE6C:?8 7:4E:E:@FD�� H:C6=6DD�E6=68C2A9�@C�E6=6A9@?6�>6DD286

2� '776?56C� :D� 2?� @77:46C� @C� 6>A=@J66� @7� E968@G6C?>6?E�@C�2? @77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66�@7�2�AC:G2E64@CA@C2E:@?�� 6?82865� :?� E96� D6CG:46� @7� D6?5:?8� @CC646:G:?8�H:C6=6DD��423=6�@C�E6=6A9@?6�>6DD286

3���44FD65�4@>>:ED�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

:� FEE6C:?8� 7:4E:E:@FD�H:C6=6DD�� 423=6�� E6=68C2A9�@C�E6=6A9@?6 >6DD286��@C

::� � 72=D:7J:?8� H:C6=6DD�� 423=6�� E6=68C2A9�� @CE6=6A9@?6�>6DD286

���?DJ;DJ�JE�97KI;�:7C7=;�DEJ�D;9;II7HO

���DEJ�?D�@K:?9?7B�FHE9;;:?D=I

/>;�KI;H�E<�J>;�<7BI?<?;:�:E9KC;DJ�?I�:;;C;:�J>;�7KJ>EH�E<�<7BI?<?97J?ED��?<�

7��J>;�KI;�?I�IE�9BEI;BO�9EDD;9J;:�?D�J?C;�M?J>�J>;�<7BI?<?97J?ED

8�J>;�KI;H�>7:�J>;�97F79?JO�E<�<7BI?<O?D=�J>;�:E9KC;DJ���

�HJ� ��

/>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H��JE�8;�B?78B;� CKIJ�8;�;D=7=;:�?D�J>;�I;HL?9;�E<�I;D:?D=�EH�H;9;?L?D=�M?H;B;II��978B;

7D:�J;B;=H7F>�EH�J;B;F>ED;�C;II7=;

Page 78: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

� � �2=D:7J:?8� H:C6=6DD�� E6=68C2A9@C�E6=6A9@?6�>6DD286

��-D:?8�DF49�72=D:7:65�>6DD286

2� '776?56C� :D� 2?� @77:46C� @C� 6>A=@J66� @7� E968@G6C?>6?E�@C�2?�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66�@7�2�AC:G2E64@CA@C2E:@?�� 6?82865� :?� E96� D6CG:46� @7� D6?5:?8� @CC646:G:?8�H:C6=6DD��423=6�@C�E6=6A9@?6�>6DD286

3��44FD65�4@>>:ED�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

:�FEE6C:?8�7:4E:E:@FD�H:C6=6DD��423=6��E6=68C2A9�@C�E6=6A9@?6�>6DD286��@C

::� 72=D:7J:?8� H:C6=6DD�� 423=6�� E6=68C2A9�� @CE6=6A9@?6�>6DD286

2 �44FD65� <?6H� E92E�H:C6=6DD�� 423=6�� E6=68C2A9�� @CE6=6A9@?6� >6DD286� H2D� 72=D:7:65� 3J� 2?J� @7� E96A6CD@?�DA64:7:65�:?�E96�7:CDE�A2C28C2A9 ��

3��44FD65�FD65�DF49�72=D:7:65�5:DA2E49

4� ,96� FD6� @7� E96� 72=D:7:65� 5:DA2E49� C6DF=E65� :?� E96AC6;F5:46� @7� 2� E9:C5 A2CEJ�� @C� E92E� E96� FD6� E96C6@7H2D�H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�42FD6�DF49�AC6;F5:46

�-8?525/-@5;:� ;2� 9105/-8/1>@525/-@1?�� /1>@525/-@1?� ;2�91>5@� ;>?1>B5/1�-:0�@41�8571 ��

2�(9JD:4:2?�@C�DFC86@?�H9@��:?�4@??64E:@?�H:E9�E96AC24E:46�@7�9:D�AC@76DD:@?��:DDF65�2 72=D6�46CE:7:42E6 ��

3� (F3=:4� @77:46C� H9@� :DDF65� 2� 72=D6� 46CE:7:42E6� @7>6C:E� @7� D6CG:46�� 8@@5� 4@?5F4E� @C� D:>:=2C4:C4F>DE2?46D

4�(C:G2E6�:?5:G:5F2=�H9@�72=D:7:65�2�46CE:7:42E6�F?56C�2��2?5��3�

)?5:3�2-8?1�/1>@525/-@1?��� 2���A9JD:4:2?�@C�DFC86@?�92D�:DDF65�2�72=D6�>65:42=46CE:7:42E6�� @C� 2� AF3=:4� @77:46C� 92D� :DDF65� 2� 72=D646CE:7:42E6� @7� >6C:E� @C� D6CG:46�� 8@@5� 4@?5F4E�� @CD:>:=2C� 4:C4F>DE2?46D�� @C� 2� AC:G2E6� A6CD@?� 925

���IKFH7

����HJ� ��

���.K9>�9;HJ?<?97J;�CKIJ�H;<;H�JE�J>;�?BBD;II�EH�?D@KHO�E<�7�F;HIED

����HJ� ��

Page 79: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

72=D:7:65�2?J�@7�D2:5�46CE:7:42E6D

3�'776?56C�<?6H E92E�E96�46CE:7:42E6�H2D�72=D6

4� 6�FD65�E96�D2>6

!-:A2-/@A>5:3� -:0� <;??1??5;:� ;25:@>A91:@?� ;>� 59<8191:@?� 2;>2-8?525/-@5;:���

2 %2<:?8� @C� :?EC@5F4:?8� :?E@� E96� (9:=:AA:?6D� 2?JDE2>AD�� 5:6D� @C� >2C<D� @C� @E96C� :?DECF>6?ED� @C:>A=6>6?ED�7@C 4@F?E6C76:E:?8�@C�72=D:7:42E:@?

3 (@DD6DD:?8�H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�FD6�E96�:?DECF>6?ED�@C:>A=6>6?ED�7@C�4@F?E6C76:E:?8�@C�72=D:7:42E:@?�>256:?� @C� :?EC@5F465� :?E@� E96� (9:=:AA:?6D� 3J� 2?@E96CA6CD@?

)?A><-@5;:� ;2� -A@4;>5@E� ;>� ;225/5-82A:/@5;:?��

�� �J <?@H:?8=J� 2?5� 72=D6=JC6AC6D6?E:?8� @?6D6=7� E@� 36� 2?� @77:46C�286?E� @C� C6AC6D6?E2E:G6� @7� 2?J56A2CE>6?E� @C� 286?4J� @7� E96(9:=:AA:?6� 8@GNE� @C� 2?J� 7@C6:8?8@GNE ��

2� � '776?56C� <?@H:?8=J� 2?5� 72=D6=J� C6AC6D6?ED9:>D6=7�

3� �D� 2?� @77:46C�� 286?E� @C� C6AC6D6?E2E:G6� @7� 2?J56A2CE>6?E�@C�286?4J�@7�E96�(9:=:AA:?6�8@G6C?>6?E@C�@7�2?J�7@C6:8?�8@G6C?>6?E

����HJ� ��

/>;�?CFB;C;DJ�9ED<?I97J;:�D;;:�DEJ�<EHC�7�9ECFB;J;�I;J

�EDIJHK9J?L;�FEII;II?ED�?I�7BIE�FKD?I>;:���

�HJ� ��

$D�KIKHF7J?ED�E<�7KJ>EH?JO� />;�C;H;�79J�E<�ADEM?D=BO�7D:�<7BI;BO�H;FH;I;DJ?D=�ED;I;B<��?I�IK<<?9?;DJ�)EJ

D;9;II7HO�J>7J�>;�F;H<EHCI�7D�79J�F;HJ7?D?D=�JE�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H

$D� KIKHF7J?ED� E<� E<<?9?7B� <KD9J?EDI� $J� ?I� ;II;DJ?7B� J>7J� J>;� E<<;D:;H� I>EKB:� >7L;� F;H<EHC;:� 7D� 79J

F;HJ7?D?D=�JE�7�F;HIED�?D�7KJ>EH?JO

��FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�C7O�7BIE�8;�7D�E<<;D:;H

/>;�79J�F;H<EHC;:�M?J>EKJ 8;?D=�B7M<KBBO�;DJ?JB;:�JE�:E�IE�CKIJ�F;HJ7?D�

7 JE�J>;�=ELYJ

8 JE�7DO�F;HIED�?D�7KJ>EH?JO

9 JE�7DO�FK8B?9�E<<?9;

$<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�9ECC?JI�J>;�79JI�E<�KIKHF7J?ED�7I�9EDJ;CFB7J;:�>;H;?D��7D:�>;�:E;I�?J�8;97KI;�>;�?I�7

H;8;B�7D:�FKHIK7DJ� JE�J>;�9H?C;�E<� H;8;BB?ED�EH� ?DIKHH;9J?ED�EH�I;:?J?ED��>;�M?BB�DEJ�8;� B?78B;�KD:;H� J>?I

7HJ?9B;�8;97KI;�M>7J� ?I�7JJH?8KJ;:�7=7?DIJ�>?C 7I�7�9H?C;�E<�KIKHF7J?ED� ?I� ?D�<79J�ED;�E<�J>;�;B;C;DJI�E<

9ECC?JJ?D=�H;8;BB?ED

/>;�;B;C;DJI�E< (#.5'�24'6'05' ?I�D;9;II7HO�JE�9ECC?J�J>;�9H?C;�E<�KIKHF7J?ED��E<�E<<?9?7B�<KD9J?ED��

!EH;?=D� =EL;HDC;DJ� H;<;HI� JE�FK8B?9� E<<?9;HI�:KBO� 7KJ>EH?P;:� JE�F;H<EHC�=EL;HDC;DJ7B� :KJ?;I� ?D� J>;

+>?B?FF?D;I� />;� B7M� 97DDEJ� H;<;H� JE�EJ>;H� <EH;?=D� =EL;HDC;DJI� 7I� ?JI� 7FFB?97J?ED�C7O�8H?D=�KI� JE� B;=7B

FHE8B;CI�M>?9>�C7O�?D<H?D=;�ED�9EDIJ?JKJ?ED7B�8EKD:7H?;I

Page 80: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

� �J� A6C7@C>:?8� 2?� 24EA6CE2:?:?8� E@� 2?J� A6CD@?� :?� 2FE9@C:EJ@C�AF3=:4�@77:46C @7� E96�(9:=� 8@GNE� @C7@C6:8?� 8@GNE� F?56C� E96� AC6E6?D6� @7DF49� @77:4:2=� A@D:E:@?�� 2?5� H:E9@FE36:?8�=2H7F==J�6?E:E=65�E@�5@�D@

2��'776?56C�A6C7@C>D�2?J�24E�

3� (6CE2:?:?8� E@� 2?J� A6CD@?� :?� 2FE9@C:EJ� @C� AF3=:4@77:46C�@7�E96�(9:=:AA:?6�8@G6C?>6?E�@C�2?J�7@C6:8?8@G6C?>6?E��@C�2?J�286?4J�E96C6@7�

4��-?56C�AC6E6?D6�@7�@77:4:2=�A@D:E:@?�

5���/:E9@FE�36:?8�=2H7F==J�6?E:E=65�E@�5@�D@

)?5:3�25/@5@5;A?�:-91���

-:0

/;:/1-85:3�@>A1�:-91���

2�'776?56C�FD6D�2�?2>6�@E96C�E92?�9:D�C62=�?2>6

3� 6�FD6D�E92E�7:4E:E:@FD ?2>6�AF3=:4=J

4�(FCA@D6�@7�E96�@776?56C�:D L

� E@�4@?462=�2�4C:>6� E@�6G256�E96�6I64FE:@?�@7�2�;F58>6?E��@C� E@�42FD6�52>286�E@�AF3=:4�:?E6C6DE ��

2�'776?56C�4@?462=D L

�����9:D�ECF6�?2>6��2?5 2==�@E96C�A6CD@?2=�4:C4F>DE2?46D� E92E E96� AFCA@D6� :D� @?=J� E@� 4@?462=� 9:D:56?E:EJ

���/>;�D7C;�E<�7�F;HIED�?I�M>7J�7FF;7HI�?D�>?I�8?HJ>�9;HJ?<?97J;�/>;�D7C;�E<�7�F;HIED�H;<;HI�JE�>?I�<?HIJ

D7C;��IKHD7C;��7D:�C7J;HD7B�D7C;��DO�EJ>;H�D7C;�M>?9>�7�F;HIED�FK8B?9BO�7FFB?;I�JE�>?CI;B<�M?J>EKJ

7KJ>EH?JO�E<�B7M�?I�7�<?9J?J?EKI�D7C;���

�HJ� ��

2>7J�J>;�E<<;D:;H�:E;I�JE�L?EB7J;�EH�9ECC?J� J>?I�79J� ?I <EH�>?C�JE�9ED9;7B�>?I� JHK;�D7C;�7D:�EJ>;H

F;HIED7B� 9?H9KCIJ7D9;I� #?I� EDBO�CEJ?L;� ?D� :E?D=� IE� ?I� JE� 9ED9;7B� >?I� ?:;DJ?JO� $D� 9ED9;7BC;DJ� E<� JHK;

D7C;��J>;�:;9;FJ?ED�?I�:ED;�CEC;DJ7H?BO��@KIJ�;DEK=>�JE�9ED9;7B�J>;�D7C;�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�$D�J>;�KI;�E<

<?9J?J?EKI�D7C;��J>;�E<<;D:;H�FH;I;DJI�>?CI;B<�8;<EH;�J>;�FK8B?9�M?J>�7DEJ>;H�D7C;

��F;HIED�KD:;H� ?DL;IJ?=7J?ED�8O�J>;�FEB?9;�M>E�=?L;I�7� <7BI;�D7C;�7D:�<7BI;�F;HIED7B�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�

KFED�8;?D=�?DJ;HHE=7J;:��?I�=K?BJO�E<�J>?I�9H?C;���

;N�.?=D?D= <?9J?J?EKI�D7C;�<EH�7�F7IIFEHJ

Page 81: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

�8813-8�A?1�;2�A:52;>9�;>�5:?53:5- �� 2�'776?56C�>2<6D�FD6�@7�:?D:8?:2��F?:7@C>�@C�5C6DD

3� ,96� :?D:8?:2�� F?:7@C>� @C� 5C6DD� A6CE2:?D� E@� 2?@77:46� ?@E� 96=5� 3J� E96� @776?56C� @C� E@� 2� 4=2DD� @7A6CD@?D�@7�H9:49 96�:D�?@E�2�>6>36C

4� +2:5� :?D:8?:2�� F?:7@C>� @C� 5C6DD� :D� FD65� AF3=:4=J2?5�:>AC@A6C=J

�-8?1� @1?@59;:E� -3-5:?@� -0121:0-:@ ��

2�-?56C�@2E9�282:?DE�E96�5676?52?E�E96C6:?

3 '776?56C�H9@�8:G6D�72=D6�E6DE:>@?J�<?@HD�E92E�:E:D�72=D6

4 ,96 5676?52?E�282:?DE�H9@>�E96�72=D6�E6DE:>@?J:D� 8:G6?� :D� 6:E96C� 24BF:EE65� @C� 4@?G:4E65� :?� 2� 7:?2=;F58>6?E

5 ,96C6�36�2�4C:>:?2=�AC@4665:?8

6 '776?56C�E6DE:7:6D�72=D6=J

����HJ� ��

/>;� M;7H?D=� E<� 7� KD?<EHC�� EH� ?DI?=D?7� E<� 7� DED;N?IJ?D=� E<<?9;� EH� ;IJ78B?I>C;DJ� ?I� DEJ� 7� 9H?C;� $J� ?I

D;9;II7HO� J>7J� J>;� KD?<EHC�EH� ?DI?=D?7� H;FH;I;DJI� 7D� E<<?9;�M>?9>� 97HH?;I� 7KJ>EH?JO�� H;IF;9J�� :?=D?JO�� EH

?D<BK;D9;�M>?9>�J>;�FK8B?9�BEEAI�KF�JE

.E�7BIE� #0�':#%6�+/+6#6+10�1(�#�70+(14/�14�&4'55�+5�700'%'55#4;��7�9EBEH78B;�H;I;C8B7D9;�97B9KB7J;:�JE

:;9;?L;�J>;�9ECCED�HKD�E<�F;EFB;�?I�IK<<?9?;DJ

/>;� M;7H?D=� E<� ?DI?=D?7�� 87:=;� EH� ;C8B;C� E<� H7DA� E<� J>; C;C8;HI� E<� J>;� 7HC;:� <EH9;:� E<� J>;

+>?B?FF?D;I�EH�9EDIJ78KB7HO��DEM�+)+��?I�FKD?I>;:�8O�-;FK8B?9��9J�)E����

2>;D� J>;� KD?<EHC� EH� ?DI?=D?7� ?I� KI;:� JE� ;CF>7I?P;� J>;� F7=;7DJHO� E<� 7� FB7O� EH� :H7C7� EH� ?D�CEL?D=

F?9JKH;�<?BCI��J>;�9H?C;�?I�DEJ�9ECC?JJ;:���

�HJ� ��

-;GK?H;I� 9H?C?D7B� ?DJ;DJ�� 97DYJ� 8;� 9ECC?JJ;:� J>HEK=>� D;=B?=;D9; );;:� DEJ� ?CFKJ;� =K?BJ� KFED� J>;

799KI;:

/>;� :;<;D:7DJ� CKIJ� 7J� B;7IJ� 8;� I;DJ;D9;:� JE� 7� 9EHH;9J?ED7B� F;D7BJO� EH� 7� <?D;� EH� CKIJ� >7L;� 8;;D

79GK?JJ;:

/>;�M?JD;II�M>E�=7L;�<7BI; J;IJ?CEDO�?I�B?78B;�;L;D�?<�J>;�9EKHJ�:?:�DEJ�9EDI?:;H�>?I�J;IJ?CEDO

!7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO ?I�J>;�:;9B7H7J?ED�KD:;H�E7J>�E<�7�M?JD;II�?D�7�@K:?9?7B�FHE9;;:?D=�M>?9>�?I�9EDJH7HO�JE

M>7J�?I�JHK;��EH�JE�:;DO�J>;�I7C;��EH�JE�7BJ;H�;II;DJ?7BBO�J>;�JHKJ>

)7JKH;�E<�J>;�9H?C;�E<�<7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO

$J� 97DDEJ� 8;� 9ECC?JJ;:� J>HEK=>� H;9AB;II� ?CFHK:;D9;� 8;97KI;� <7BI;� J;IJ?CEDO� H;GK?H;I� 9H?C?D7B

?DJ;DJ�EH�?DJ;DJ�JE�L?EB7J;�J>;�B7M�?I�7D�;II;DJ?7B�;B;C;DJ�E<�J>;�9H?C;

� $<�J>;�<7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO�?I�:K;�JE >ED;IJ�C?IJ7A;�EH�;HHEH�EH�J>;H;�M7I�=EE:�<7?J>�?D�C7A?D=�J>;�<7BI;

J;IJ?CEDO��DE�9H?C;�?I�9ECC?JJ;:

Page 82: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�-8?1� @1?@59;:E� 5:� 2-B;>� ;20121:0-:@�5:�-�/>595:-8�/-?1 ��

2���A6CD@?�8:G6D�72=D6�E6DE:>@?J�

3�!?�72G@C�@7�E96�5676?52?E�

4�!?�2�4C:>:?2=�42D6

�-8?1�@1?@59;:E�5:�/5B58�/-?1? �� 2�,96�E6DE:>@?J�>FDE�36�8:G6?�:?�2�4:G:=�42D6

3�,96�E6DE:>@?J�>FDE�C6=2E6�E@�E96�:DDF6D�AC6D6?E65:?�D2:5�42D6

4�,96�E6DE:>@?J�>FDE�36�72=D6

5� ,96� 72=D6� E6DE:>@?J� >FDE� 36� 8:G6?� 3J� E965676?52?E�<?@H:?8�E96�D2>6�E@�36�72=D6

6���,96�E6DE:>@?J�>FDE�36�>2=:4:@FD�2?5�8:G6?�H:E92?� :?E6?E� E@� 27764E� E96� :DDF6D�AC6D6?E65� :?� E96� D2:542D6

�-8?1�@1?@59;:E�5:�;@41>�/-?1?�-:0<1>6A>E�5:�?;819: -225>9-@5;: ��

�?�244FD65�>256�2�DE2E6>6?E�F?56C�@2E9�@C�>2562?�277:52G:E�FA@?�2�>2E6C:2=�>2EE6C

����HJ� �

!7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO�8O�D;=7J?L;�IJ7J;C;DJ�?I�?D�<7LEH�E<�J>;�:;<;D:7DJ

!7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO�D;;:�DEJ�?D�<79J�8;D;<?J�J>;�:;<;D:7DJ

��IJ7J;C;DJ�E<�7�C;H;�EF?D?ED�?I�DEJ�FKD?I>78B;

�EDL?9J?ED�EH�79GK?JJ7B�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO��<?D7B�@K:=C;DJ�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO���/>;�<7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO�D;;:�DEJ

?D<BK;D9;�J>;�79GK?JJ7B

��:;<;D:7DJ�M>E�LEBKDJ7H?BO�=E;I�KF�ED�J>;�M?JD;II�IJ7D:�7D:�<7BI;BO�?CFKJ;I�J>;�E<<;DI;�JE�7DEJ>;H

F;HIED�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<�J>;�E<<;DI;� ?I� B?78B;�KD:;H�J>?I�7HJ?9B;� $<�>;�C;H;BO�:;D?;I�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<

J>;�E<<;DI;��>;�?I�DEJ�B?78B;���

�HJ� ��

)EJ�7FFB?978B;�M>;D�J;IJ?CEDO�=?L;D�?D�7�IF;9?7B�FHE9;;:?D=��?D J>?I�97I;��J>;�9H?C;�?I�F;H@KHO����

�HJ� ��

��M7OI�E<�9ECC?JJ?D=�F;H@KHO�

7��8O�<7BI;BO�J;IJ?<O?D=�KD:;H�E7J>

8��8O�C7A?D=�7�<7BI;�IJ7J;C;DJ

!7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO�LI�+;H@KHO�

2>;D� ED;� J;IJ?<?;I� <7BI;BO� 8;<EH;� J>;� 9EKHJ�� J>;� 9H?C;� 9ECC?JJ;:� ?I� <7BI;� J;IJ?CEDO� $<� ED;� J;IJ?<?;I

<7BI;BO�?D�7�DED@K:?9?7B�FHE9;;:?D=��J>;�9H?C;�9ECC?JJ;:�?I�F;H@KHO�$D�<7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO��?J� ?I�DEJ�H;GK?H;:

J>7J� J>;� E<<;D:;H� 7II;HJI� 7� <7BI;>EE:� ED� 7� C7J;H?7B� C7JJ;H� $J� ?I� ;DEK=>� J>7J� >;� J;IJ?<?;I� <7BI;BO� M?J>

:;B?8;H7J;� ?DJ;DJ� $D� F;H@KHO�� J>;�M?JD;II�CKIJ� J;IJ?<O� EH� 7II;HJ� 7� <79J� ED� 7�C7J;H?7B�C7JJ;H�M?J>� 7� <KBB

ADEMB;:=;�J>7J�J>;�?D<EHC7J?ED�=?L;D�?I�;II;DJ?7BBO�9EDJH7HO�JE�J>;�JHKJ>

� Z9ECF;J;DJ�F;HIED�7KJ>EH?P;:�JE�7:C?D?IJ;H�7D�E7J>[ C;7DI�7�F;HIED�M>E�>7I�7�H?=>J�JE�?DGK?H;�?DJE

J>;�GK;IJ?EDI�FH;I;DJ;:�JE�>?C�KFED�C7JJ;HI�KD:;H�>?I�@KH?I:?9J?ED

Page 83: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

2� ,96� DE2E6>6?E� @C� 277:52G:E� H2D� >256� 367@C6� 24@>A6E6?E� @77:46C�� 2FE9@C:K65� E@� C646:G6� 2?525>:?:DE6C�@2E9

3�!?�E92E�DE2E6>6?E�@C�277:52G:E��E96 244FD65�>256�2H:==7F=�2?5�56=:36C2E6�2DD6CE:@?�@7�2�72=D69@@5��2?5

4�,96� DH@C?� DE2E6>6?E�@C� 277:52G:E� 4@?E2:?:?8� E9672=D:EJ�:D�C6BF:C65�3J�=2H

#221>5:3� 2-8?1� @1?@59;:E� 5:1B501:/1 ��

2���'776?56C�@776C65�:?�6G:56?46�2�72=D6�H:E?6DD�@C72=D6 E6DE:>@?J

/>;H;� ?I�DE�F;H@KHO� ?<� J>;�799KI;:�I?=D;:�7D:�IMEH;�J>;�IJ7J;C;DJ�8;<EH;�7�F;HIED�DEJ�7KJ>EH?P;:�JE

7:C?D?IJ;H�E7J> ��'12.'�85���'..#��#8+&��

/>;H;� ?I 01�2'4,74;� 6*417)*�0').+)'0%'�14� +/247&'0%' I?D9;�J>;�7II;HJ?ED�E<� <7BI;>EE:�CKIJ�8;�M?BB<KB

7D:�:;B?8;H7J;

�;97KI;�E<�J>;�D7JKH;�E<�F;H@KHO��M>?9>�?I�J>;�M?BB<KB�7D:�9EHHKFJ�7II;HJ?ED�E<�7�<7BI;>EE:��J>;H;�?I�DE

F;H@KHO�9ECC?JJ;:�J>HEK=>�H;9AB;II�?CFHK:;D9;�EH�I?CFB;�D;=B?=;D9;�KD:;H��HJ?9B;�����.?D9;�7:C?JJ;:BO

F;H@KHO�97D�EDBO�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�C;7DI�E< &1.1��J>;D )11&�(#+6*�14�.#%-�1(�/#.+%'�+5�#�)11&�&'('05'�9*'0

10'�+5�+0&+%6'&�(14�6*'�%4+/'�1(�2'4,74;�

L;D�?<�J>;H;�?I�DE�B7M�H;GK?H?D=�J>;�IJ7J;C;DJ�JE�8;�C7:;�KD:;H�E7J>� #5�.10)�#5�+6�+5�/#&'�(14�#�.')#.

274215'��+6�+5�57((+%+'06

$<�J>;H;� ?I�DE�H;GK?H;C;DJ�E<� B7M�JE�FB79;�J>;�IJ7J;C;DJ�EH�J;IJ?CEDO�KD:;H�E7J>��J>;H;� ?I�DE�+;H@KHO

9EDI?:;H?D=�J>;�F>H7I;I�ZE7J>�?D�97I;I�?D�M>?9>�J>;�B7M�IE�H;GK?H;I[�?D��HJ?9B;� ��

/>;�7<<?:7L?J�EH�IMEHD�IJ7J;C;DJ�CKIJ�8;�H;GK?H;:�8O�B7M�B?A;�7<<?:7L?J�E<�7:L;HI;�9B7?C�JE�FHEJ;9J�ED;YI

?DJ;H;IJ�ED�H;7B�FHEF;HJO��EH�7D�7<<?:7L?J�E<�=EE:�CEH7B�9>7H79J;H� JE�J7A;�J>;�87H�;N7C?D7J?ED � .E� ?<� J>;

7<<?:7L?J�M7I�C7:;�8KJ� J>;� I7C;� ?I� DEJ� H;GK?H;:�8O� B7M�� ;L;D� ?<� J>;� 7BB;=7J?EDI� 7H;� <7BI;�� J>;� 9H?C;�E<

F;H@KHO�?I�DEJ�9ECC?JJ;: ��+#<�85���'12.'����������� ��

+;H@KHO� ?I� 7D� E<<;DI;� M>?9>� 9EL;HI� <7BI;� E7J>I� EJ>;H� J>7D� J>EI;� J7A;D� ?D� J>;� 9EKHI;� E<� @K:?9?7B

FHE9;;:?D=I

!7BI;� J;IJ?CEDO� 8;<EH;� J>;� @KIJ?9;� E<� J>;� F;79;� :KH?D=� J>;� +$�C7O� =?L;� H?I;� JE� J>;� 9H?C;� E<� F;H@KHO

8;97KI;� <7BI;� J;IJ?CEDO� ?D� @K:?9?7B� FHE9;;:?D=I� 9EDJ;CFB7J;I� 7D� 79JK7B� JH?7B� M>;H;� 7� @K:=C;DJ� E<

9EDL?9J?ED�EH�79GK?JJ7B�?I�H;D:;H;:

��F;HIED�M>E�ADEM?D=BO�7D:�M?BB<KBBO�FHE9KH;I�7DEJ>;H�JE�IM;7H�<7BI;BO�9ECC?JI 57$140#6+10�1(�2'4,74;

7D:�J>;�M?JD;II�IK8EHD;:�:E;I�J;IJ?<O�KD:;H�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�H;D:;H?D=�>?C�=K?BJO�E<�F;H@KHO

/>;�<7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO ?I�DEJ�?D�7�@K:?9?7B�FHE9;;:?D=���

�HJ� ��

/>;�<7BI;�M?JD;II�D;;:�DEJ�8;�9EDL?9J;:�E<�<7BI;�J;IJ?CEDO��/>;�C;H;�E<<;H�?I�IK<<?9?;DJ

/>;�E<<;D:;H�?D�J>?I�7HJ?9B;�ADEMI�J>7J�J>;�M?JD;II�JE�8;�FH;I;DJ;:�?I�7�<7BI;�M?JD;II�EH�J>7J�J>;�M?JD;II

M?BB�B?;�M>?B;�J;IJ?<O?D=�/>;�FHE9;;:?D=I�7H;�;?J>;H�@K:?9?7B�EH�E<<?9?7B�/>;H;�?I�7�<EHC7B�E<<;H�E<�J;IJ?CED?7B

;L?:;D9;� ?D� J>;� FHE9;;:?D=I� />;�M?JD;II� ?I� 78B;� JE� J;IJ?<O� 7D:� J>;� E<<;D:;H�� ADEM?D=� J>;� J;IJ?CEDO� ?I

=?L;D�8O�J>;�M?JD;II�JE�8;�<7BI;��D;L;HJ>;B;II�E<<;HI�J>;�I7C;�?D�;L?:;D9;�$D�J>?I 97I;��J>;�F;HIED�E<<;H?D=

J>;� <7BI;� J;IJ?CEDO�CKIJ� >7L;� DEJ>?D=� JE� :E� ?D� J>;�C7A?D=� E<� J>;� <7BI;� J;IJ?CEDO�#;� ADEMI� J>7J� J>;

M?JD;II� ?I�<7BI;�7D:�O;J�>;�7IAI�>?C�JE�J;IJ?<O�7D:�J>;H;7<J;H�E<<;HI�J>;�J;IJ?CEDO�?D�;L?:;D9;�.E� ?<�J>;

E<<;HEH��7I?:;�<HEC�8;?D=�IK9>��?I�7BIE�J>;�F;HIED�H;IFEDI?8B;�?D�?D:K9?D=�EH�9EDL?D9?D=�J>;�<7BI;�M?JD;II�JE

B?;���HJ ���M?BB�DEJ�7FFBO�/>;�7FFB?978B;�7HJ?9B;�M?BB�8;��HJ?9B;� ���� � �� ����EH� ���7I�J>;�97I;�C7O�8;

/>;�E<<;D:;HI� ?D� J>?I�97I;�M?BB�8;�9>7H=;:�M?J>�F;H@KHO� J>;� ?D:K9;H�7I�FH?D9?F7B�8O� ?D:K9;C;DJ�7D:�J>;

?D:K9;:�F7HJO�7I�J>;�FH?D9?F7B�8O�:?H;9J�F7HJ?9?F7J?ED

Page 84: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3��� 6�<?6H�E96�H:E?6DD�@C�E96�E6DE:>@?J�H2D�72=D6

4� � � ,96� @776C� H2D� >256� :?� 2� ;F5:4:2=� @C� @77:4:2=AC@4665:?8

!-/45:-@5;:?�5:�<A.85/�-A/@5;: �� 2���,96C6�36�2�AF3=:4�2F4E:@?

3� � � �44FD65� D@=:4:E65� 2?J� 8:7E� @C� 2� AC@>:D6� 7C@>2?J�@7�E96�3:556CD

4���+F49�8:7ED�@C�AC@>:D6�H2D�E96�4@?D:56C2E:@?�7@C9:D� C67C2:?:?8� 7C@>� E2<:?8� A2CE� :?� E92E� AF3=:42F4E:@?

5��44FD65�925�E96�:?E6?E�E@�42FD6�E96�C65F4E:@?�@7E96�AC:46�@7�E96�E9:?8�2F4E:@?65

!;:;<;851?� -:0� /;9.5:-@5;:?� 5:>1?@>-5:@�;2 @>-01 �

� �@>3:?2E:@?� E@� AC6G6?E� 7C664@>A6E:E:@?�:?�E96�>2C<6E

�� �J� 6?E6C:?8� :?E@� 2� 4@?EC24E� @C28C66>6?E�@C�E2<:?8�A2CE�:?�2?J4@?DA:C24J� @C� 4@>3:?2E:@?� :?E96� 7@C>� @7� 2� ECFDE� @C

2� � �?E6C:?8� :?E@� 2?J� 4@?EC24E� @C� 28C66>6?E� @CE2<:?8�A2CE�:?�2?J 4@?DA:C24J�@C�4@>3:?2E:@?�:?�E967@C>�@7�2�ECFDE�@C�@E96CH:D6�

3��!?�C6DEC2:?E�@7�EC256�@C�4@>>6C46�@C�E@�AC6G6?E3J�2CE:7:4:2=�>62?D�7C66�4@>A6E:E:@?�:?�E96�>2C<6E

2� ��J�>@?@A@=:K:?8�2?J�>6C492?5:D6�@C�@3;64E�@7EC256� @C� � 4@>>6C46�� @C� 3J� 4@>3:?:?8� H:E9� 2?J@E96C� A6CD@?� @C� A6CD@?D� E@� >@?@A@=:K6� D2:5>6C492?5:D6�@C�@3;64E�

$J�?I�<EH�J>?I�H;7IED�J>7J IK8EHD7J?ED�E<�F;H@KHO ?I�DE�BED=;H�JH;7J;:�7I�7�IF;9?<?9�<;BEDO�M?J>�7�I;F7H7J;

7HJ?9B;�E<� ?JI� EMD�);L;HJ>;B;II�� ?J� ?I� 7� 9H?C;�:;<?D;:�7D:�FKD?I>;:�KD:;H� J>;�-;L?I;:� +;D7B��E:;� />;

9H?C;� 9ECC?JJ;:� 8O� ED;� M>E� ?D:K9;I� 7DEJ>;H� JE� J;IJ?<O� <7BI;BO� 7D:� J>;� F;HIED� M>E� 7=H;;I� 7D:� ?D

9EDIF?H79O�M?J>�J>;�?D:K9;H��J;IJ?<?;I�<7BI;BO��?I�F;H@KHO ��'12.'�85���#&1.������*+.�������

�HJ� �����

�HJ� ��

/>;�FKHFEI;�?I�

7 JE�C7A;�JH7DI79J?EDI�FH;@K:?9?7B�JE�B7M<KB�9ECC;H9;

8 JE� ?D9H;7I;� J>;� C7HA;J� FH?9;� E<� 7DO� C;H9>7D:?I;� EH� E8@;9J� E<� 9ECC;H9;� C7DK<79JKH;:�

FHE:K9;:��FHE9;II;:��7II;C8B;:�EH�?CFEHJ;:�?DJE�J>;�+>?B

�))4#8#6'&�+(�+6'/5�#4'�

7 <EE:�IK8IJ7D9;

8 CEJEH�<K;B�EH�BK8H?97DJI

9 =EE:I�E<�FH?C;�D;9;II?JO

Page 85: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

@E96CH:D6�� :?� C6DEC2:?E� @7� EC256@C� 4@>>6C46� @C� AC6G6?E� 3J2CE:7:4:2= >62?D� 7C664@>A6E:E:@?�:?�E96�>2C<6E ��

� %@?@A@=J� E@� C6DEC2:?� 7C664@>A6E:E:@?�:?�E96�>2C<6E

� %2?F724EFC6C�� AC@5F46C� @CAC@46DD@C� @C� :>A@CE6C4@>3:?:?8�� 4@?DA:C:?8� @C28C66:?8� H:E9� 2?J� A6CD@?� E@>2<6�EC2?D24E:@?D�AC6;F5:4:2=�E@=2H7F=�4@>>6C46�@C�E@�:?4C62D6E96� >2C<6E� AC:46� @7� E96>6C492?5:D6 ��

�9<;>@-@5;:� -:0� 05?<;?5@5;:� ;22-8?18E� 9->710� ->@5/81?� ;>91>/4-:05?1� 9-01� ;2� 3;80�� ?58B1>�;>� ;@41>� <>1/5;A?� 91@-8?� ;>� @415>-88;E? ��

3��!?�@C56C�E@�2=E6C�E96�AC:46D�E96C6@7�3J�DAC625:?872=D6�CF>@CD�@C���>2<:?8�FD6�@7�2?J�@E96C�2CE:7:46�

4��,@�C6DEC2:?�7C66�4@>A6E:E:@?�:?�E96�>2C<6E

2�%2?F724EFC6C� AC@5F46C��AC@46DD@C�@C�:>A@CE6C�@72?J�>6C492?5:D6�@C�@3;64E�@7�4@>>6C46�

3���@>3:?6D��4@?DA:C6D�@C�28C66D�H:E9�2?J�A6CD@?�

4� � (FCA@D6� :D� E@� >2<6� EC2?D24E:@?D� AC6;F5:4:2=� E@=2H7F=�4@>>6C46�@C�E@��:?4C62D6�E96�>2C<6E�AC:46�@72?J >6C492?5:D6� @C� @3;64E @7� 4@>>6C46>2?F724EFC65�� AC@5F465�� AC@46DD65�� 2DD6>3=65� @C:>A@CE65�:?E@�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D

2� '776?56C� :>A@CED�� D6==D� @C� 5:DA@D6D� @7� 2?J� @7E9@D6�2CE:4=6D�@C�>6C492?5:D6

3� � �,96�DE2>AD��3C2?5D��@C�>2C<D�@C�E9@D6�2CE:4=6D@C�>6C492?5:D6� 72:=D� E@� :?5:42E6 E96�24EF2=� 7:?6?6DD@C�BF2=:EJ�@7�D2:5�>6E2=D�@C�2==@JD

���$J�?I�;DEK=>�J>7J�?D?J?7B�IJ;FI�7H;�J7A;D�$J�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO�J>7J�J>;H;�8;�79JK7B�H;IJH7?DJ�E<�JH7:;

���+;HIED�I�B?78B;�

7 C7DK<79JKH;H

8 FHE:K9;H

9 FHE9;IIEH

: ?CFEHJ;H

�H?C;�?I�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�

7 9EC8?D?D=

8 9EDIF?H?D=

9 7=H;;?D=�M?J>�7DEJ>;H�F;HIED

�BIE�B?78B;�7I�FH?D9?F7BI�

7 9EHFEH7J?ED�7IIE9?7J?ED

8 7=;DJ�H;FH;I;DJ7J?L;

9 :?H;9JEH�C7D7=;H W M>E�M?BB?D=BO�F;HC?JJ;:�EH�<7?B;:�JE�FH;L;DJ�9ECC?II?ED�E<�78EL;�E<<;DI;���

�HJ� ��

/E�8;�9H?C?D7BBO�B?78B;��?J�?I�?CFEHJ7DJ�JE�;IJ78B?I>�J>7J�J>;�E<<;D:;H�ADEMI�J>;�<79J�J>7J�J>; ?CFEHJ;:

C;H9>7D:?I;�<7?BI�JE�?D:?97J;�J>;�79JK7B�<?D;D;II�EH�GK7B?JO�E<�J>;�FH;9?EKI�C;J7B�$<�J>;�?CFEHJ;H�>7I�DE

;NF;HJ?I;�ED�J>;�C7JJ;H�IK9>�J>7J�>;�>7I�DE�M7O�E<�ADEM?D=�>EM�J>;�<H7K:�M7I�9ECC?JJ;:��J>;�;N?IJ;D9;

E<�IK9>�<79J�C7O�8;�I;H?EKIBO�9EDI?:;H;:�7I�7�:;<;DI;

2>7J�J>;�B7M�FKD?I>;I�>;H;?D�?I�J>;�I;BB?D=�E<�C?I8H7D:;:�=EE:I�C7:;�E<�=EB:��I?BL;H�7D:�EJ>;H�FH;9?EKI

C;J7BI�/>;H;<EH;�� ?J�CKIJ�8;� I>EMD� J>7J� J>;� I;BB;H�ADEMI� J>7J� J>;�C;H9>7D:?I;� ?I�C?I8H7D:;:�#;D9;�

&+5*10'56;�+5�#0�'55'06+#. '.'/'06�1(�6*'�%4+/'

Page 86: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4����'776?56C�<?@HD�E92E�E96�D2:5�DE2>A��3C2?5��@C>2C<� 72:=D� E@� :?5:42E6� E96�24EF2=� 7:?6?6DD�@C�BF2=:EJ@7�E96�>6E2=D�@C�2==@JD

,� '30�!0B�#@-74.��4//492��,B ��

��#=:34-4?0/�,.?>

�2� (F3=:4�@77:46CD�H9@�4@>>:E�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�D92==�DF776C�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7:>AC:D@?>6?E�@7�?@E�=6DD�E92?�D:I�����J62CD�2?5�@?6�����52J��3FE�?@E�>@C6�E92?�7:7E66?�����J62CD�

��'A6?�2?J�D62=65��:5� :?4=F5:?8�3FE�?@E�=:>:E65�E@��:5D�E92E�>2J�92G6�366?DF3>:EE65� E9C@F89� E96�6=64EC@?:4�DJDE6>�2?5�2?J�2?5�2==�5@4F>6?ED� C6BF:C65� E@�36D62=65�@C�5:GF=8:?8�E96:C�4@?E6?ED��AC:@C�E@�E96�2AA@:?E65�E:>6�7@C�E96�AF3=:4�@A6?:?8@7��:5D�@C�@E96C�5@4F>6?ED

��6=2J:?8��H:E9@FE�;FDE:7:23=6�42FD6��E96�D4C66?:?8�7@C�6=:8:3:=:EJ��@A6?:?8�@73:5D��6G2=F2E:@?�2?5�A@DE�6G2=F2E:@?�@7�3:5D��2?5�2H2C5:?8�@7�4@?EC24ED�36J@?5� E96AC6D4C:365�A6C:@5D�@7��:5D�@C�@E96C�5@4F>6?ED

��-?5F=J�:?7=F6?4:?8�@C�6I6CE:?8�F?5F6�AC6DDFC6�@?�2?J�>6>36C�@7�E96����@C�2?J�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66�@7 E96�AC@4FC:?8�6?E:EJ�E@�E2<6�2�A2CE:4F=2C�3:556C

�� +A=:EE:?8� @7� 4@?EC24ED� H9:49� 6I4665� AC@465FC2=� AFC492D6� =:>:ED� 2?54@>A6E:E:G6�3:55:?8

��/96?�E96�9625�@7�E96�286?4J�23FD6D�E96�6I6C4:D6�@7�9:D�A@H6C�E@�C6;64E�2?J2?5�2==�3:5D�2D�>6?E:@?65�F?56C�+64E:@?��� �� @7�E9:D��4E�H:E9�>2?:76DE�AC676C6?46�E@2?J�3:556C�H9@�:D�4=@D6=J�C6=2E65�E@�9:>�:?�244@C52?46�H:E9�+64E:@?��� �� @7�E9:D��4E

����������

���-;I;HL7J?ED��B7KI; />;�#;7:�E<� J>;��=;D9O�H;I;HL;I�J>;�H?=>J� JE�H;@;9J�7DO�7D:�7BB��?:I��:;9B7H;�7

<7?BKH;�E<�8?::?D=��EH�DEJ�7M7H:�J>;�9EDJH79J�?D�J>;�<EBBEM?D=�I?JK7J?EDI�

7�$<�J>;H;�?I�FH?C7�<79?;�;L?:;D9;�E<�9EBBKI?ED�8;JM;;D�7FFHEFH?7J;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;HI�EH�;CFBEO;;I�E<�J>;

+HE9KH?D=� DJ?JO��EH�8;JM;;D�J>;�����7D:�7DO�E<�J>;�8?::;HI��EH�?<�J>;�9EBBKI?ED�?I�8;JM;;D�EH�7CED=�J>;

8?::;HI�J>;CI;BL;I��EH�8;JM;;D�7�8?::;H 7D:�7�J>?H:�F7HJO��?D9BK:?D=�7DO�79J�M>?9>�H;IJH?9JI��IKFFH;II;I�EH

DKBB?<?;I�EH�J;D:I�JE�H;IJH?9J��IKFFH;II�EH�DKBB?<O�9ECF;J?J?ED�

8�$<�J>;�����?I�<EKD:�JE�>7L;�<7?B;:�?D�<EBBEM?D=�J>;�FH;I9H?8;:�8?::?D=�FHE9;:KH;I��EH

9�!EH�7DO�@KIJ?<?78B; 7D:�H;7IED78B;�=HEKD:�M>;H;�J>;�7M7H:�E<�J>;�9EDJH79J�M?BB�DEJ�H;:EKD:�JE�J>;

8;D;<?J�E<�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ�7I�:;<?D;:�?D�J>;�$--���

�?I9BEIKH;�E<�-;B7J?EDI $D�7::?J?ED�JE�J>;�FHEFEI;:�9EDJ;DJI�E<� J>;� $DL?J7J?ED�JE��?:�7I�C;DJ?ED;:

KD:;H� .;9J?ED� � � E<� J>?I �9J�� 7BB� 8?::?D=� :E9KC;DJI� I>7BB� 8;� 799ECF7D?;:� 8O� 7� IMEHD� 7<<?:7L?J� E<� J>;

8?::;H�J>7J�>;�EH�I>;�EH�7DO�E<<?9;H�E<�J>;?H�9EHFEH7J?ED�?D�DEJ�H;B7J;:�JE�J>;�#;7:�E<�J>;�+HE9KH?D=� DJ?JO

8O� 9EDI7D=K?D?JO� EH� 7<<?D?JO� KF� JE� J>;� J>?H:� 9?L?B� :;=H;;� !7?BKH;� JE 9ECFBO� M?J>� J>;� 7<EH;C;DJ?ED;:

Page 87: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

/96?� 2?J� @7� E96� 7@C68@:?8� 24ED� :D� 5@?6� :?� 4@==FD:@?� H:E9� AC:G2E6� :?5:G:5F2=D�� E96AC:G2E6�:?5:G:5F2=D�D92==�=:<6H:D6�36 =:23=6�7@C�E96�@776?D6

!?� 255:E:@?�� E96� AF3=:4� @77:46C� :?G@=G65� D92==� 2=D@� DF776C� E96� A6?2=EJ� @7� E6>A@C2CJ5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?� 7C@>� AF3=:4� @77:46�� H9:=6� E96� AC:G2E6� :?5:G:5F2=� D92==� 36� A6C>2?6?E=J5:DBF2=:7:65�7C@>�EC2?D24E:?8�3FD:?6DD�H:E9�E96�8@G6C?>6?E

�3��(C:G2E6� :?5:G:5F2=D�H9@�4@>>:E� 2?J�@7� E96� 7@==@H:?8�24ED�� :?4=F5:?8�2?J�AF3=:4@77:46C��H9@�4@?DA:C6D�H:E9�E96>��D92==�DF776C�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�@7�?@E�=6DD�E92?D:I�����J62CD�2?5�@?6�����52J�3FE�?@E�>@C6�E92?�7:7E66?������J62CD�

��/96?�EH@�@C >@C6�3:556CD�28C66�2?5�DF3>:E�5:776C6?E��:5D�2D�:7�E96J�H6C63@?2�7:56��H96?�E96J�<?6H�E92E�@?6�@C�>@C6�@7�E96>�H2D�D@�>F49�9:896C�E92?�E96@E96C� E92E� :E� 4@F=5� ?@E� 36� 9@?6DE=J� 2446AE65� 2?5� E92E� E96� 4@?EC24E� H:==� DFC6=J� 362H2C565�E@�E96�AC6�2CC2?865�=@H6DE��:5

�/96?� 2� 3:556C�>2=:4:@FD=J� DF3>:ED� 5:776C6?E� �:5D� E9C@F89� EH@� @C�>@C6A6CD@?D�� 4@CA@C2E:@?D�� A2CE?6CD9:AD� @C� 2?J� @E96C� 3FD:?6DD� 6?E:EJ� :?� H9:49� 96� 92D:?E6C6DE�@7�4C62E6�E96�2AA62C2?46�@7�4@>A6E:E:@?�E92E�5@6D�?@E�:?�724E�6I:DE�D@�2D�E@�3625;F5865�2D�E96�H:??:?8�3:556C

��/96?�EH@�@C�>@C6�3:556CD�6?E6C�:?E@�2?�28C66>6?E�H9:49�42==�FA@?�@?6E@�C67C2:?�7C@>�3:55:?8�7@C�(C@4FC6>6?E�4@?EC24ED��@C�H9:49�42==� 7@C�H:E95C2H2=�@73:5D� 2=C625J� DF3>:EE65�� @C� H9:49� 2C6� @E96CH:D6� :?E6?565� E@� D64FC6� 2D� F?5F625G2?E286�E@�2?J�@?6�@7�E96>

��/96?�2�3:556C��3J�9:>D6=7�@C�:?�4@??:G2?46�H:E9�@E96CD��6>A=@J�D496>6DH9:49� E6?5� E@� C6DEC2:?� E96� ?2EFC2=� C:G2=CJ� @7� E96� A2CE:6D� @C� @A6C2E6D� E@� DE:7=6� @CDFAAC6DD�4@>A6E:E:@?�2?5�E9FD�AC@5F46�2�C6DF=E�5:D25G2?E286@FD�E@�E96 AF3=:4

!?� 255:E:@?�� E96� A6CD@?D� :?G@=G65� D92==� 2=D@� DF776C� E96� A6?2=EJ� @7� E6>A@C2CJ� @CA6CA6EF2=� 5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?� 7C@>� AF3=:4� @77:46� 2?5� 36� A6C>2?6?E=J� 5:DBF2=:7:65� 7C@>EC2?D24E:?8�3FD:?6DD�H:E9�E96�8@G6C?>6?E

�4��(C:G2E6�:?5:G:5F2=D�H9@�4@>>:E�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED��2?5�2?J�AF3=:4�@77:46C4@?DA:C:?8�H:E9�E96>��D92==�DF776C�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�@7�?@E�=6DD�E92?�D:I�����J62CD2?5�@?6�����52J�3FE�>@C6�E92?�7:7E66?������J62CD�

�� +F3>:E� 6=:8:3:=:EJ� C6BF:C6>6?ED�@7�H92E6G6C� <:?5� 2?5�?2EFC6� E92E� 4@?E2:?72=D6�:?7@C>2E:@?�@C�72=D:7:65�5@4F>6?ED�42=4F=2E65�E@�:?7=F6?46�E96�@FE4@>6�@7�E966=:8:3:=:EJ� D4C66?:?8� AC@46DD� @C� 4@?462=� DF49� :?7@C>2E:@?� :?� E96� 6=:8:3:=:EJC6BF:C6>6?ED� H96?� E96� :?7@C>2E:@?� H:==� =625� E@� 2� 564=2C2E:@?� @7� :?6=:8:3:=:EJ� 7C@>A2CE:4:A2E:?8�:?�AF3=:4�3:55:?8

FHEL?I?ED�I>7BB�8;�7�=HEKD:�<EH�J>;�7KJEC7J?9�:?IGK7B?<?97J?ED�E<�J>;�8?:�?D�9EDIED7D9;�M?J>�.;9J?ED ���E<

J>?I��9J

Page 88: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

� +F3>:E� �:55:?8� �@4F>6?ED� @7� H92E6G6C� <:?5� 2?5� ?2EFC6� E92?� 4@?E2:?72=D6�:?7@C>2E:@?�@C�72=D:7:65�5@4F>6?ED�@C�4@?462=�DF49�:?7@C>2E:@?�:?�E96��:55:?8�@4F>6?ED��:?�@C56C�E@�:?7=F6?46�E96�@FE4@>6�@7�E96�AF3=:4�3:55:?8

��(2CE:4:A2E6�:?�2�AF3=:4�3:55:?8�FD:?8�E96�?2>6�@7�2?@E96C�@C�2==@H�2?@E96CE@�FD6�@?6�D�?2>6�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�A2CE:4:A2E:?8�:?�2�AF3=:4�3:55:?8

�� /:E95C2H� 2� �:5�� 27E6C� :E� D92==� 92G6� BF2=:7:65� 2D� E96� $@H6DE� �2=4F=2E65�:5 :896DE� *2E65� �:5�� @C� E@� 2446AE� 2?5 2H2C5�� H:E9@FE� ;FDE� 42FD6� @C� 7@C� E96AFCA@D6� @7� 7@C4:?8� E96� (C@4FC:?8� �?E:EJ� E@� 2H2C5� E96� 4@?EC24E� E@� 2?@E96C� 3:556C,9:D� D92==� :?4=F56� E96�?@?�DF3>:DD:@?�@7� C6BF:C6>6?ED� DF49� 2D�� 3FE�?@E� =:>:E65� E@�A6C7@C>2?46�D64FC:EJ��AC6A2C2E@CJ�E@�E96�7:?2=�2H2C5�@7 E96�4@?EC24E

�5� /96?�E96�3:556C�:D�2�;FC:5:42=�6?E:EJ��4C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ�2?5�E96�2446DD@CJ�A6?2=E:6DD92==� 36� :>A@D65� @?� :ED� 5:C64E@CD�� @77:46CD� @C� 6>A=@J66D� H9@� 24EF2==J� 4@>>:E� 2?J� @7� E967@C68@:?8�24ED ��

-� �9?4��74,>��,B ��

��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

&@ A6CD@?�D92==�FD6�2?J�?2>6�5:776C6?E�7C@>�E96�@?6�H:E9�H9:49�96�H2D�C68:DE6C65�2E3:CE9�:?�E96�@77:46�@7�E96�=@42=�4:G:=�C68:DECJ�@C�H:E9�H9:49�96�H2D�32AE:K65�7@C�E96�7:CDE�E:>6�@C�:?�42D6�@7�2?�2=:6?��H:E9�H9:49�96�H2D�C68:DE6C65�:?�E96�3FC62F�@7�:>>:8C2E:@?�FA@?�6?ECJ�@C�DF49�DF3DE:EFE6�?2>6�2D�>2J�92G6�366?�2FE9@C:K65�3J�2�4@>A6E6?E�4@FCE ��

,96� 24E� @7� FD:?8� 2?� 2=:2D� ?2>6�� F?=6DD� DF49� 2=:2D� H2D� 5F=J� 2FE9@C:K65� 3J� AC@A6C;F5:4:2=�AC@4665:?8D�2?5�C64@C565�:?�E96�4:G:=�C68:DE6C �

����C.0;?4:9

�D�2�AD6F5@?J>�D@=6=J�7@C� =:E6C2CJ��4:?6>2�� E6=6G:D:@?��C25:@�@C�@E96C�6?E6CE2:?>6?EAFCA@D6D�2?5�:?�2E9=6E:4�6G6?ED�H96C6�E96�FD6�@7�AD6F5@?J> :D�2�?@C>2==J�2446AE65�AC24E:46

���.;9���

������ ��

�� .;9�

���/>;H;� CKIJ� 8;� 7� �I?=D� EH� ?D:?97J?ED� J>7J� J>;� KI;H� ?DJ;D:I� JE� 8;� ADEMD� 8O� J>?I� D7C;� �J>;� 7B?7I�� ?D

7::?J?ED� JE� >?I� H;7B� D7C;� <HEC� J>7J� :7O� <EHJ>� \� 5<EH� J>;� KI;� E<� 7B?7I� JE6� <7BB� M?J>?D� J>;� FHE>?8?J?ED

9EDJ7?D;:�?D����)E� ���7I�7C;D:;:��!457# 97I;�

Page 89: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

����>591?�&18-@5B1�@;�#<5A9�-:0�;@41>�$>;45.5@10��>A3?

,� '30��:8;=0309>4A0��,920=:@>��=@2>��.?�:1��� ��

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

� !>A@CE2E:@?� @7� �2?86C@FD� �CF8D� 2?5@C� �@?EC@==65� (C64FCD@CD� 2?5� �DD6?E:2=�96>:42=D ��

+2=6�� ,C25:?8�� �5>:?:DEC2E:@?�� �:DA6?D2E:@?�� �6=:G6CJ�� �:DEC:3FE:@?� 2?5,C2?DA@CE2E:@?� @7� �2?86C@FD� �CF8D� 2?5@C� �@?EC@==65� (C64FCD@CD� 2?5� �DD6?E:2=�96>:42=D ��

� %2:?E6?2?46�@7�2��6?���:G6�@C�*6D@CE ��

� %2?F724EFC6� @7� �2?86C@FD� �CF8D� 2?5@C� �@?EC@==65� (C64FCD@CD� 2?5� �DD6?E:2=�96>:42=D ��

� !==682=��96>:42=��:G6CD:@?�@7��@?EC@==65�(C64FCD@CD�2?5��DD6?E:2=��96>:42=D ��

� %2?F724EFC6� @C� �6=:G6CJ� @7� �BF:A>6?E�� !?DECF>6?E�� �AA2C2EFD�� 2?5� 'E96C(2C2A96C?2=:2� 7@C� �2?86C@FD� �CF8D� 2?5@C� �@?EC@==65� (C64FCD@CD� 2?5� �DD6?E:2=�96>:42=D ��

� (@DD6DD:@?�@7��2?86C@FD��CF8D ��

� (@DD6DD:@?� @7� �BF:A>6?E�� !?DECF>6?E�� �AA2C2EFD� 2?5� 'E96C� (2C2A96C?2=:2� 7@C�2?86C@FD��CF8D ��

� (@DD6DD:@?�@7��2?86C@FD��CF8D��FC:?8�(2CE:6D��+@4:2=��2E96C:?8D�@C�%66E:?8D �

�� (@DD6DD:@?� @7��BF:A>6?E�� !?DECF>6?E���AA2C2EFD� 2?5�'E96C� (2C2A96C?2=:2� 7@C�2?86C@FD��CF8D��FC:?8�(2CE:6D��+@4:2=��2E96C:?8D�@C�%66E:?8D ��

�� -D6�@7��2?86C@FD��CF8D ��

���-��� ��

���.;9��

���.;9��

���.;9��

���.;9��

���.;9��

���.;9� �

���.;9�

�� .;9� �

���.;9� �

���.;9� �

Page 90: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

� �F=E:G2E:@?�@C��F=EFC6�@7�(=2?ED��=2DD:7:65� 2D��2?86C@FD��CF8D�@C� 2C6� +@FC46D,96C6@7 ��

�� %2:?E6?2?46� 2?5�#66A:?8� @7�'C:8:?2=� *64@C5D� @7� ,C2?D24E:@?D� @?��2?86C@FD�CF8D�2?5@C��@?EC@==65�(C64FCD@CD�2?5��DD6?E:2= �96>:42=D ��

�� -??646DD2CJ�(C6D4C:AE:@?�@7��2?86C@FD��CF8D ��

�� -?=2H7F=�(C6D4C:AE:@?�@7��2?86C@FD��CF8D ��

44��*3:�,=0�74,-70

/:E9�C6DA64E�E@�&@

� �?J� A6CD@?�� H9@�� F?=6DD� 2FE9@C:K65� 3J� =2H�� D92==� :>A@CE� @C� 3C:?8� :?E@� E96(9:=:AA:?6D�2?J�52?86C@FD 5CF8��C682C5=6DD�@7�E96�BF2?E:EJ�2?5�AFC:EJ�:?G@=G65��:?4=F5:?8�2?J2?5�2==�DA64:6D�@7�@A:F>�A@AAJ�@C�2?J�A2CE�E96C6@7�@C�DF3DE2?46D�56C:G65�E96C67C@>�6G6?�7@C7=@C2=��564@C2E:G6�2?5�4F=:?2CJ�AFCA@D6D

�?J� A6CD@?��H9@�� F?=6DD� 2FE9@C:K65� 3J� =2H�� D92==� :>A@CE� 2?J� 4@?EC@==65� AC64FCD@C2?5�6DD6?E:2=�496>:42=

�?J�A6CD@?��H9@�� F?=6DD� 2FE9@C:K65�F?56C� E9:D��4E�� D92==� :>A@CE�@C�3C:?8� :?E@� E96(9:=:AA:?6D�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�2?5@C�4@?EC@==65�AC64FCD@C�2?5�6DD6?E:2=�496>:42=�E9C@F89E96�FD6�@7�2�5:A=@>2E:4�A2DDA@CE��5:A=@>2E:4�724:=:E:6D�@C�2?J�@E96C�>62?D�:?G@=G:?8�9:D96C@77:4:2=� DE2EFD� :?E6?565� E@� 724:=:E2E6� E96� F?=2H7F=� 6?ECJ� @7� E96� D2>6� !?� 255:E:@?�� E965:A=@>2E:4�A2DDA@CE�D92==�36�4@?7:D42E65�2?5�42?46=65

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� @C82?:K6D��>2?286D� @C� 24ED� 2D� 2� �7:?2?4:6C�� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� :==682=24E:G:E:6D�AC6D4C:365�:?�E9:D�+64E:@?

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� 24ED� 2D� 2� �AC@E64E@C4@55=6C�� @7� 2?J� G:@=2E@C� @7� E96� AC@G:D:@?DF?56C�E9:D�+64E:@?

�?J�A6CD@?��H9@��F?=6DD�2FE9@C:K65�3J�=2H��D92==�D6==��EC256��25>:?:DE6C��5:DA6?D6�56=:G6C��8:G6�2H2J�E@�2?@E96C��5:DEC:3FE6�5:DA2E49�:?�EC2?D:E�@C�EC2?DA@CE�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�:?4=F5:?8�2?J�2?5�2==�DA64:6D�@7�@A:F>�A@AAJ�C682C5=6DD�@7�E96�BF2?E:EJ�2?5 AFC:EJ�:?G@=G65�@C�D92==�24E�2D�2�3C@<6C�:?�2?J�@7�DF49�EC2?D24E:@?D

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@�� F?=6DD� 2FE9@C:K65� 3J� =2H�� D92==� D6==�� EC256�� 25>:?:DE6C�� 5:DA6?D6�56=:G6C�� 8:G6� 2H2J� E@� 2?@E96C�� 5:DEC:3FE6�� 5:DA2E49� :?� EC2?D:E� @C� EC2?DA@CE� 2?J� 4@?EC@==65AC64FCD@C�2?5�6DD6?E:2=�496>:42=��@C�D92==�24E�2D�2�3C@<6C�:?�DF49�EC2?D24E:@?D

���.;9� �

���.;9� �

���.;9� �

���.;9� �

���.;9� �

Page 91: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

�CF8� AFD96CD� H9@� FD6� >:?@CD� @C� >6?E2==J� :?42A24:E2E65� :?5:G:5F2=D� 2D� CF??6CD�4@FC:6CD�2?5�>6DD6?86CD��@C�:?�2?J�@E96C�42A24:EJ�5:C64E=J�4@??64E65�E@�E96�52?86C@FD�5CF8D2?5@C�4@?EC@==65�AC64FCD@CD�2?5�6DD6?E:2=�496>:42=�EC256

�?J� A6CD@?� H9@� @C82?:K6D�� >2?286D� @C� 24ED� 2D� 2� �7:?2?4:6C�� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� :==682=24E:G:E:6D�AC6D4C:365�:?�E9:D�+64E:@?

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� 24ED� 2D� 2� �AC@E64E@C4@55=6C�� @7� 2?J� G:@=2E@C� @7� E96� AC@G:D:@?DF?56C�E9:D +64E:@?

� �?J�A6CD@?�@C�8C@FA�@7�A6CD@?D�H9@�D92==�>2:?E2:?�2�56?��5:G6�@C� C6D@CE�H96C62?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�:D�FD65�@C�D@=5�:?�2?J�7@C>

�?J�A6CD@?�@C�8C@FA�@7�A6CD@?D�H9@�D92==�>2:?E2:?�2�56?��5:G6��@C�C6D@CE�H96C6�2?J4@?EC@==65�AC64FCD@C�2?5�6DD6?E:2= 496>:42=�:D�FD65�@C�D@=5�:?�2?J�7@C>

�?J� A6CD@?� H9@� @C82?:K6D�� >2?286D� @C� 24ED� 2D� 2� �7:?2?4:6C�� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� :==682=24E:G:E:6D�AC6D4C:365�:?�E9:D�+64E:@?

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� 24ED� 2D� 2� �AC@E64E@C4@55=6C�� @7� 2?J� G:@=2E@C� @7� E96� AC@G:D:@?DF?56C�E9:D�+64E:@?

� �?J�A6CD@?��H9@��F?=6DD�2FE9@C:K65�3J�=2H��D92==�6?8286�:?�E96�>2?F724EFC6�@7�2?J52?86C@FD�5CF8

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@�� F?=6DD� 2FE9@C:K65� 3J� =2H�� D92==� >2?F724EFC6� 2?J� 4@?EC@==65AC64FCD@C�2?5�6DD6?E:2=�496>:42=

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� @C82?:K6D��>2?286D� @C� 24ED� 2D� 2� �7:?2?4:6C�� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� :==682=24E:G:E:6D�AC6D4C:365�:?�E9:D�+64E:@?

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� 24ED� 2D� 2� �AC@E64E@C4@55=6C�� @7� 2?J� G:@=2E@C� @7� E96� AC@G:D:@?DF?56C�E9:D�+64E:@?

� �?J� A6CD@?�� H9@�� F?=6DD� 2FE9@C:K65� 3J� =2H�� D92==� :==682==J� 5:G6CE� 2?J� 4@?EC@==65AC64FCD@C�2?5�6DD6?E:2=�496>:42=

� �?J�A6CD@?�H9@�D92==�56=:G6C��A@DD6DD�H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�56=:G6C��@C�>2?F724EFC6�H:E9:?E6?E� E@� 56=:G6C� 6BF:A>6?E�� :?DECF>6?E�� 2AA2C2EFD� 2?5� @E96C� A2C2A96C?2=:2� 7@C� 52?86C@FD5CF8D��<?@H:?8��@C�F?56C�4:C4F>DE2?46D H96C6�@?6�C62D@?23=J�D9@F=5�<?@H��E92E� :E�H:==�36FD65� E@� A=2?E�� AC@A282E6�� 4F=E:G2E6�� 8C@H�� 92CG6DE�� >2?F724EFC6�� 4@>A@F?5�� 4@?G6CE�AC@5F46�� AC@46DD�� AC6A2C6�� E6DE�� 2?2=JK6�� A24<�� C6A24<�� DE@C6�� 4@?E2:?� @C� 4@?462=� 2?J52?86C@FD�5CF8�2?5@C�4@?EC@==65�AC64FCD@C�2?5�6DD6?E:2=�496>:42=�:?�G:@=2E:@?�@7�E9:D��4E

�?J�A6CD@?��H9@�FD6D�2�>:?@C�@C�2�>6?E2==J�:?42A24:E2E65�:?5:G:5F2=�E@�56=:G6C�DF496BF:A>6?E��:?DECF>6?E��2AA2C2EFD�2?5�@E96C�A2C2A96C?2=:2�7@C�52?86C@FD�5CF8D

Page 92: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

� �?J�A6CD@?��H9@��F?=6DD�2FE9@C:K65�3J� =2H��D92==�A@DD6DD�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8� :?E96�BF2?E:E:6D�>6?E:@?65��C682C5=6DD�@7�E96�568C66�@7�AFC:EJ�E96C6@7�

� �?J�A6CD@?��H9@��F?=6DD�2FE9@C:K65�3J� =2H��D92==�A@DD6DD�@C�92G6�F?56C�9:D96C4@?EC@=� 2?J� 6BF:A>6?E�� :?DECF>6?E�� 2AA2C2EFD� 2?5� @E96C� A2C2A96C?2=:2� 7:E� @C� :?E6?565� 7@CD>@<:?8��4@?DF>:?8��25>:?:DE6C:?8�� :?;64E:?8�� :?86DE:?8��@C�:?EC@5F4:?8�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8:?E@�E96�3@5J�

� �?J� A6CD@?� 7@F?5�A@DD6DD:?8� 2?J� 52?86C@FD� 5CF8� 5FC:?8� 2� A2CEJ�� @C� 2E� 2� D@4:2=82E96C:?8�@C�>66E:?8��@C�:?�E96�AC@I:>2E6�4@>A2?J�@7�2E�=62DE�EH@�� ��A6CD@?D

�� �?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� D92==� A@DD6DD� @C� 92G6� F?56C� 9:D96C� 4@?EC@=� 2?J� 6BF:A>6?E�:?DECF>6?E�� 2AA2C2EFD� 2?5� @E96C� A2C2A96C?2=:2� 7:E� @C� :?E6?565� 7@C� D>@<:?8�� 4@?DF>:?8�25>:?:DE6C:?8��:?;64E:?8��:?86DE:?8��@C�:?EC@5F4:?8�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�:?E@�E96�3@5J��5FC:?8A2CE:6D�� D@4:2=� 82E96C:?8D� @C� >66E:?8D�� @C� :?� E96� AC@I:>2E6� 4@>A2?J� @7� 2E� =62DE� EH@� � �A6CD@?D

�� ��A6CD@?�2AAC696?565�@C� 2CC6DE65��H9@� :D� 7@F?5� E@�36�A@D:E:G6� 7@C�FD6�@7� 2?J52?86C@FD�5CF8��27E6C�2�4@?7:C>2E@CJ�E6DE� Q DF3;64E�E@�E96�AC@G:D:@?D�@7��CE:4=6�.!!! �� @7E9:D��4E

� �?J�A6CD@?��H9@�D92==�A=2?E��4F=E:G2E6�@C�4F=EFC6�>2C:;F2?2��@A:F>�A@AAJ�@C�2?J@E96C�A=2?E�C682C5=6DD�@7�BF2?E:EJ��H9:49�:D�@C�>2J�96C627E6C�36�4=2DD:7:65�2D�2�52?86C@FD�5CF8@C�2D 2�D@FC46�7C@>�H9:49�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�>2J�36�>2?F724EFC65�@C�56C:G65

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� @C82?:K6D��>2?286D� @C� 24ED� 2D� 2� �7:?2?4:6C�� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� :==682=24E:G:E:6D�AC6D4C:365�:?�E9:D�+64E:@?

�?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� 24ED� 2D� 2� �AC@E64E@C4@55=6C�� @7� 2?J� G:@=2E@C @7� E96� AC@G:D:@?DF?56C�E9:D�+64E:@?

�� �?J� AC24E:E:@?6C�� >2?F724EFC6C�� H9@=6D2=6C�� :>A@CE6C�� 5:DEC:3FE@C�� 562=6C� @CC6E2:=6C�H9@� G:@=2E6D� @C� 72:=D� E@� 4@>A=J�H:E9� E96�>2:?E6?2?46� 2?5� <66A:?8� @7� E96� @C:8:?2=C64@C5D� @7� EC2?D24E:@?D� @?� 2?J� 52?86C@FD� 5CF8� 2?5@C� 4@?EC@==65� AC64FCD@C� 2?5� 6DD6?E:2=496>:42=�:?�244@C52?46�H:E9�+64E:@?������ @7�E9:D��4E

�� �?J�A6CD@?��H9@��F?=6DD�2FE9@C:K65�3J�=2H��D92==�>2<6�@C�:DDF6�2�AC6D4C:AE:@?�@C2?J�@E96C�HC:E:?8�AFCA@CE:?8�E@�36�2�AC6D4C:AE:@?�7@C�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8

���+HE=H7C�<EH�/H;7JC;DJ�7D:�-;>78?B?J7J?ED�E<��HK=��;F;D:;DJI

���-;9EH:I�-;GK?H;:�<EH�/H7DI79J?EDI�ED��7D=;HEKI��HK=�7D:�+H;9KHIEHI�7D:� II;DJ?7B��>;C?97BI

Page 93: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

444���??08;?�:=�.:9>;4=,.D��0110.?�:9�74,-474?D

�?J�2EE6>AE�@C�4@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�E96�7@==@H:?8�F?=2H7F=�24ED�D92==�36�A6?2=:K653J�E96�D2>6�A6?2=EJ�AC6D4C:365�7@C�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�E96�D2>6�2D�AC@G:565�F?56C�E9:D��4E�

�2��!>A@CE2E:@?�@7�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�2?5@C�4@?EC@==65�AC64FCD@C�2?5�6DD6?E:2=496>:42=�

�3��+2=6��EC25:?8��25>:?:DEC2E:@?��5:DA6?D2E:@?��56=:G6CJ��5:DEC:3FE:@?�2?5EC2?DA@CE2E:@?�@7�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�2?5@C�4@?EC@==65�AC64FCD@C�2?5�6DD6?E:2=�496>:42=�

�4��%2:?E6?2?46�@7�2�56?��5:G6�@C C6D@CE�H96C6�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�:D�FD65�:?�2?J7@C>�

�5��%2?F724EFC6�@7�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�2?5@C�4@?EC@==65�AC64FCD@C�2?5�6DD6?E:2=496>:42=��2?5

�6���F=E:G2E:@?�@C�4F=EFC6�@7�A=2?ED�H9:49�2C6�D@FC46D�@7�52?86C@FD�5CF8D���

�4A����88@94?D 1=:8�;=:>0.@?4:9�,9/�;@94>3809?

�?J�A6CD@?�H9@�92D�G:@=2E65�+64E:@?D��������� ����������2?5������ �CE:4=6�!!�@7�E9:D�4E��H9@�G@=F?E2C:=J�8:G6D�:?7@C>2E:@?�23@FE�2?J�G:@=2E:@?�@7�+64E:@?D���������������������2?5������ �CE:4=6�!!�@7�E9:D��4E�2D�H6==�2D�2?J�G:@=2E:@?�@7�E96�@776?D6D�>6?E:@?65�:7�4@>>:EE653J�2�5CF8�DJ?5:42E6��@C�2?J�:?7@C>2E:@?�=625:?8�E@�E96�H96C623@FED�� :56?E:E:6D�2?5�2CC6DE�@72==� @C� 2?J� @7� E96� >6>36CD� E96C6@7�� 2?5� H9@� H:==:?8=J� E6DE:7:6D� 282:?DE� DF49� A6CD@?D� 2D56D4C:365� 23@G6�� D92==� 36� 6I6>AE65� 7C@>�AC@D64FE:@?�@C�AF?:D9>6?E� 7@C� E96�@776?D6�H:E9C676C6?46�E@�H9:49�9:D96C�:?7@C>2E:@?�@7�E6DE:>@?J�H6C6�8:G6?��2?5�>2J�A=625�@C�AC@G6�E968:G:?8�@7�DF49�:?7@C>2E:@?�2?5�E6DE:>@?J�:?�32C�@7�DF49�AC@D64FE:@?

�@?5:E:@?D�

����,96� :?7@C>2E:@?�2?5 E6DE:>@?J�2C6�?646DD2CJ� 7@C� E96�4@?G:4E:@?�@7� E96�A6CD@?D56D4C:365�23@G6�

� ��+F49�:?7@C>2E:@?�2?5�E6DE:>@?J�2C6�?@E�J6E�:?�E96�A@DD6DD:@?�@7�E96�+E2E6�

����+F49�:?7@C>2E:@?�2?5�E6DE:>@?J�42?�36�4@CC@3@C2E65�@?�:ED�>2E6C:2=�A@:?ED�

����E96�:?7@C>2?E�@C�H:E?6DD�92D�?@E�366?�AC6G:@FD=J�4@?G:4E65�@7�2�4C:>6�:?G@=G:?8>@C2=�EFCA:EF56��6I46AE�H96?�E96C6�:D�?@�@E96C�5:C64E�6G:56?46�2G2:=23=6�7@C�E96�+E2E6�@E96CE92?�E96�:?7@C>2E:@?�2?5�E6DE:>@?J�@7�D2:5�:?7@C>2?E�@C�H:E?6DD��2?5

�� .;9���

���?:

���?:

Page 94: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

����,96� :?7@C>2?E�@C�H:E?6DD� D92==� DEC:4E=J� 2?5� 72:E97F==J� 4@>A=J�H:E9@FE�56=2J�� 2?J4@?5:E:@?� @C� F?56CE2<:?8�� C65F465� :?E@� HC:E:?8�� =2H7F==J� :>A@D65� 3J� E96� +E2E6� 2D� 7FCE96C4@?D:56C2E:@?�7@C�E96�8C2?E�@7�:>>F?:EJ�7C@>�AC@D64FE:@?�2?5�AF?:D9>6?E

(C@G:565��7FCE96C��,92E�E9:D�:>>F?:EJ�>2J 36�6?;@J65�3J�DF49�:?7@C>2?E�@C�H:E?6DDH9@� 5@6D� ?@E� 2AA62C� E@� 36� >@DE� 8F:=EJ� 7@C� E96� @776?D6� H:E9� C676C6?46� E@� H9:49� 9:D96C:?7@C>2E:@?� @C� E6DE:>@?J� H6C6� 8:G6?�� (C@G:565�� 7:?2==J�� ,92E� E96C6� :D� ?@� 5:C64E� 6G:56?462G2:=23=6� 7@C� E96� +E2E6� 6I46AE� 7@C� E96� :?7@C>2E:@?� 2?5� E6DE:>@?J� @7� E96� D2:5� :?7@C>2?E� @CH:E?6DD���

���.;9���

Page 95: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�� �>591?��3-5:?@�$A.85/�!;>-8?

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED(6CD@?D�=:23=6

�>-B1�?/-:0-8��� '776?56C�A6C7@C>D�2?�24E

2 :89=J�D42?52=@FD�2D�@776?5:?8�282:?DE�5646?4J�@C8@@5�4FDE@>D

3 :89=J�D42?52=@FD�4@?5F4E�5@6D�?@E�6IAC6DD=J� 72==H:E9:?�2?J�@E96C�2CE:4=6�@7�E96�*(�

4 �@>>:EE65� :?� 2� AF3=:4� A=246� @C�H:E9:?� E96� AF3=:4<?@H=6586�@C�G:6H���

�99;>-8� 0;/@>5:1?�� ;.?/1:1<A.85/-@5;:?�-:0�1D45.5@5;:?���

2 ,9@D6�H9@�AF3=:4=J�6IA@F?5�@C AC@4=2:>�5@4EC:?6DE92E�2C6�4@?EC2CJ�E@�AF3=:4�>@C2=D

3 �FE9@CD�@7�@3D46?6�=:E6C2EFC6��AF3=:D965�H:E9�E96:C<?@H=6586�:?�2?J�7@C>

4 �5:E@CD�AF3=:D9:?8�DF49�@3D46?6�=:E6C2EFC6

5 'H?6CD� @C� @A6C2E@CD� @7� 6DE23=:D9>6?ED� D6==:?8@3D46?6�=:E6C2EFC6

����HJ����

"H7L;�I97D:7B��9EDI?IJI�E<�79JI�M>?9>�7H;�E<<;DI?L;�JE�:;9;D9O�7D:�=EE:�9KIJECI�/>;O�7H;�9ECC?JJ;:

FK8B?9BO�7D:�J>KI��=?L;�H?I;�JE�FK8B?9�I97D:7B�JE�F;HIEDI�M>E�>7L;�799?:;DJ7BBO�M?JD;II;:�J>;�79JI

�;9;D9O��C;7DI�FHEF;HBO�E8I;HL?D=�J>;�H;GK?H;C;DJI�E<�CE:;IJO��=EE:�J7IJ;� ;J9

�KIJECI��H;<;HI�JE�;IJ78B?I>;:�KI7=;��IE9?7B�9EDL;DJ?EDI�97HH?;:�ED�8O�JH7:?J?ED�7D:�;D<EH9;:�8O�IE9?7B

:?I7FFHEL7B�?D�97I;�E<�L?EB7J?ED

$<�J>;�79JI�9ECFB7?D;:�E<�7H;�FKD?I>78B;�KD:;H�7DEJ>;H�FHEL?I?ED�E<�J>;�-+����HJ�����?I�DEJ�7FFB?978B;

/>;�;II;D9;�E<�=H7L;�I97D:7B�?I�FK8B?9?JO�7D:�J>7J�J>;�79JI�9ECC?JJ;:�7H;�DEJ�EDBO�9EDJH7HO�JE�CEH7BI

7D:�=EE:�9KIJECI�8KJ�CKIJ�B?A;M?I;�8;�E<�IK9>�9>7H79J;H�7I�JE�97KI;�FK8B?9�I97D:7B�JE�J>EI;�M?JD;II?D=�?J���

/>;�FK8B?9�L?;M� ?I�DEJ�H;GK?H;:�� ?J� ?I�IK<<?9?;DJ� ?<� ?D�FK8B?9�FB79;� �!EH�FK8B?9�ADEMB;:=;�� ?J�C7O�E99KH

;L;D�?D�7�FH?L7J;�FB79;��J>;�DKC8;H�E<�F;EFB;�M>E�I;;I�?J�?I�DEJ�C7J;H?7B����

�HJ���

(EH7BI�� ?CFB?;I� 9ED<EHC?JO� JE� =;D;H7BBO� 799;FJ;:� IJ7D:7H:I� E<� =EE:D;II� EH� H?=>JD;II� ?D� 9ED:K9J� EH

9>7H79J;H

/;IJ�E<�E8I9;D?JO��M>;J>;H�J>;�C7JJ;H�>7I�7�J;D:;D9O�JE�:;FH7L;�EH�9EHHKFJ�J>;�C?D:I�E<�J>EI;�M>E�7H;

EF;D� JE� ?CCEH7B� ?D<BK;D9;I� �� C7JJ;H� 97D� 7BIE� 8;� 9EDI?:;H;:� E8I9;D;� ?<� ?J� I>E9AI� J>;� EH:?D7HO� 7D:

9ECCED�I;DI;�E<�C;D�7I�?D:;9;D9O

(;H;�DK:?JO�?D�F7?DJ?D=I�7D:�F?9JKH;I�?I�DEJ�E8I9;D;

+?9JKH;I�M��7�IB?=>J�:;=H;;�E<�E8I9;D?JO�>7L?D=�DE�7HJ?IJ?9�L7BK;�7D:�?DJ;D:;:�<EH�9ECC;H9?7B�FKHFEI;I

<7BB�M?J>?D�J>?I�7HJ?9B;

+K8B?9?JO�?I�7D�;II;DJ?7B�;B;C;DJ

Page 96: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

6 ,9@D6� H9@� 6I9:3:E� :?5646?E� @C� :>>@C2=� A=2JD�D46?6D�� 24ED� @C� D9@HD� :@?� E962E6CD�� 72:CD�� 4:?6>2D� @C2?J�@E96C�A=246

7 ,9@D6� H9@� D6==�� 5:DEC:3FE6�� @C� 6I9:3:E� AC:?ED�6?8C2G:?8��D4F=AEFC6D�@C�=:E6C2EFC6�H9:49�2C6�@776?D:G6E@�>@C2=D

*-3>-:@?

-:0

$>;?@5@A@1?���

2 ,9@D6�H9@�92G6�?@�2AA2C6?E�>62?D�@7�DF3D:DE6?462?5�H9@�92G6�E96�A9JD:42=�23:=:EJ�E@�H@C<�J6E�?68=64EE@�2AA=J�E96>D6=G6D�E@�D@>6�FD67F=�42==:?8

3 (6CD@?D� 7@F?5� =@:E6C:?8� 2C@F?5� AF3=:4� 2?5� D6>:�AF3=:4�A=246D H:E9@FE�G:D:3=6�>62?D�@7�DFAA@CE

4 (6CD@?D�EC2>A:?8�@C�H2?56C:?8�2C@F?5�E96�4@F?ECJ@C�E96�DEC66ED�H:E9�?@�G:D:3=6�>62?D�@7�DFAA@CE

5 !5=6�@C�5:DD@=FE6�A6CD@?D� =@58:?8� :?�9@FD6D�@7� :==�72>6

6 *F77:2?D� @C� A:>AD� 2?5� E9@D6� H9@� 923:EF2==J2DD@4:2E6�H:E9 AC@DE:EFE6D���

7 (6CD@?D�7@F?5�=@:E6C:?8�:?�:?923:E65�@C�F?:?923:E65A=246D� 36=@?8:?8� E@� @E96CD�� H:E9@FE� 2?J� =2H7F=� @C;FDE:7:23=6�C62D@?�AC@G:565�E96�24E�5@6D�?@E�72==�H:E9:?2?J�@E96C�2CE:4=6�@7�E96�*(�

/@>6?�H9@�923:EF2==J� :?5F=86� :?� D6IF2= :?E6C4@FCD6@C�=2D4:G:@FD�4@?5F4E�7@C�>@?6J�@C�AC@7:E���

����HJ����

���C7O�?D9BK:;�;L;D�J>;�H?9>

� �?<�7�C7D�?D:KB=;I�?D�J>;�I7C;�9ED:K9J��L7=H7D9O

Page 97: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�� �>591?��;995@@10�.E�$A.85/�#225/1>? ���

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED(6CD@?D�=:23=6

�:;C5:38E� >1:01>5:3� -:� A:6A?@6A0391:@��

2 '776?56C�:D�2 ;F586

3 *6?56CD�2�;F58>6?E�:?�E96�42D6�DF3>:EE65�E@�9:>7@C�;F58>6?E

4 "F58>6?E�:D�F?;FDE

5 #?@H=6586�E92E�E96�564:D:@?�:D�F?;FDE

�A0391:@� >1:01>10� @4>;A34:138531:/1���

2 '776?56C��:D�2�;F586

3 *6?56CD�2 ;F58>6?E�:?�2�42D6�DF3>:EE65�E@�9:>�7@C564:D:@?

4 "F58>6?E�:D�>2?:76DE=J�F?;FDE

5 �F6�E@�:?6I4FD23=6�?68=:86?46�@C�:8?@C2?46

� �HJ����

+K8B?9�E<<?9;H

7 /7A;I�F7HJ�?D�J>;�F;H<EHC7D9;�E<�FK8B?9�<KD9J?EDI ?D�J>;�"EL;HDC;DJ��EH

8 +;H<EHCI�FK8B?9�:KJ?;I�7I�7D�;CFBEO;;��7=;DJ�EH�IK8EH:?D7J;�E<<?9?7B�?D�J>;�=ELYJ�EH�7DO�E<�?JI

8H7D9>;I

+K8B?9�E<<?9;HI��;C8H79;I�;L;HO�FK8B?9�I;HL7DJ�<HEC�J>;�BEM;IJ�JE�J>;�>?=>;IJ�H7DA

��=EL;HDC;DJ B78EH;H�?I�DEJ�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�#EM;L;H��J;CFEH7HO�F;H<EHC7D9;�8O�7�B78EH;H�E<�FK8B?9

<KD9J?EDI�C7A;I�>?C�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H

(?I<;7I7D9;��C;7DI�?CFHEF;H�F;H<EHC7D9;�E<�7D�79J�M>?9>�C?=>J�8;�FHEF;HBO�8;�F;H<EHC;:

(7B<;7I7D9;��C;7DI�F;H<EHC7D9; E<�7D�79J�M>?9>�EK=>J�DEJ�JE�8;�:ED;

)ED<;7I7D9;��C;7DI�EC?II?ED�E<�7D�79J�M>?9>�EK=>J�JE�8;�:ED;� �

�HJ����

%K:=C;DJ��?I�7�<?D7B�9EDI?:;H7J?ED�7D:�:;J;HC?D7J?ED�8O�7�9EKHJ�E<�9ECF;J;DJ�@KH?I:?9J?ED�E<�J>;�?IIK;I

IK8C?JJ;:�JE�?J�?D�7D�79J?ED�EH�FHE9;;:?D=

0D@KIJ�@K:=C;DJ��ED;�M>?9>�?I�9EDJH7HO�JE�B7M��EH�DEJ�IKFFEHJ;:�8O�J>;�;L?:;D9;��EH�8EJ>

�D�KD@KIJ�@K:=C;DJ�C7O�H;IKBJ�<HEC�

;HHEH��M?J>�87:�<7?J>�

?BBM?BB�EH�H;L;D=;

8H?8;HO

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�;L?:;D9;�J>7J�J>;�:;9?I?ED�H;D:;H;:�?I�KD@KIJ�$J�?I�DEJ�FH;IKC;:

�8KI;�E<�:?I9H;J?ED�EH�C;H;�;HHEH�E<�@K:=C;DJ�97DDEJ�B?A;M?I;�I;HL;�7I�87I?I�<EH�H;D:;H?D=�7D�KD@KIJ

@K:=C;DJ�?D�J>;�78I;D9;�E<�FHEE<�EH�;L;D�7D�7BB;=7J?ED�E<�87:�<7?J>��CEJ?L;�EH�?CFHEF;H�9EDI?:;H7J?ED�� �

�HJ����

(7D?<;IJBO� KD@KIJ� @K:=C;DJ�� ED;� J>7J� ?I� IE� 9EDJH7HO� JE� B7M� J>7J� ;L;D� 7� F;HIED� >7L?D=� C;7=;H

ADEMB;:=;�E<�J>;�B7M�97DDEJ�:EK8J�J>;�?D@KIJ?9;

Page 98: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

):6A?@ 5:@1>8;/A@;>E�;>01>���2 '776?56C�:D�2�;F586

3 6�A6C7@C>D�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

� <?@H:?8=J� C6?56CD� F?;FDE� :?E6C=@4FE@CJ@C56C�@C�564C66� @C

C6?56CD� 2� >2?:76DE=J� F?;FDE� :?E6C=@4FE@CJ@C56C� @C� 564C66� E9C@F89� :?6I4FD23=6� ?68=:86?46� @C:8?@C2?46

!-85/5;A?� 018-E� 5:� @41-095:5?@>-@5;:�;>�6A?@5/1��

2 '776?56C�:D�2�;F586

3 ,96C6�:D�2�AC@4665:?8�:?�9:D�4@FCE

4 6�56=2JD�E96 25>:?:DEC2E:@?�@7�;FDE:46

5 ,96�56=2J�:D�>2=:4:@FD��E92E�:D��E96�56=2J�:D�42FD653J�E96�;F586�H:E9�56=:36C2E6�:?E6?E�E@�:?7=:4E�52>286@?�6:E96C�A2CEJ�:?�E96�42D6

�1>185/@5;:� ;2� 0A@E� 5:� @41<>;?1/A@5;:�;2�;221:?1?���

2 '776?56C� :D� 2�AF3=:4 @77:46C�@C�@77:46C�@7� E96� =2HH9@� 92D� 2� 5FEJ� E@� 42FD6� E96� AC@D64FE:@?� @7�� @C� E@AC@D64FE6�@776?D6D

3 ,96C6�:D�56C6=:4E:@?�@7�E96�5FE:6D�@7�9:D�@77:46���

4 '776?56C�24ED�H:E9�>2=:46�2?5�56=:36C2E6�:?E6?E�E@

� ��HJ����

$DJ;HBE9KJEHO�EH:;H��ED;�?IIK;:�8O�J>;�9EKHJ�:;9?:?D=�7�9EBB7J;H7B�EH�?D9?:;DJ7B�C7JJ;H�$J� ?I�DEJ�7�<?D7B

:;J;HC?D7J?ED�E<�J>;�?IIK;I�E<�J>;�79J?ED�EH�FHE9;;:?D=� �

�HJ ���

(;H;�:;B7O�M?J>EKJ�C7B?9;�?I�DEJ�FKD?I>78B;� �

�HJ����

�4'8#4+%#%+10��D;=B?=;D9;�7D:�JEB;H7D9;�?D�J>;�FHEI;9KJ?ED�E<�7D�E<<;DI;

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�7�:KJO�ED�J>;�F7HJ�E<�J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�JE�FHEI;9KJ;�EH�CEL;�<EH�J>;�FHEI;9KJ?ED�E<�J>;

E<<;D:;H� )EJ;� >EM;L;H�� J>7J� 7� <?I97B� ?I� KD:;H� DE� 9ECFKBI?ED� JE� <?B;� 7D� ?D<EHC7J?ED� 87I;:� KFED� 7

9ECFB7?DJ�?<�>;�?I�DEJ�9EDL?D9;:�J>7J�J>;�;L?:;D9;�8;<EH;�>?C�:E;I�DEJ�M7HH7DJ�<?B?D=�7D�79J?ED�?D�9EKHJ

/>;�9H?C;�CKIJ�8;�FHEL;:�<?HIJ�8;<EH;�7D�E<<?9;H�97D�8;�9EDL?9J;:�E<�:;H;B?9J?ED�E<�:KJO

��FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�M>E�>7H8EHI�� 9ED9;7BI��EH�7II?IJI� ?D� J>;�;I97F;�E<�7D�E<<;D:;H��M>;D� ?J� ?I�>?I�:KJO� JE

FHEI;9KJ;�>?C�?I�B?78B;�7I�FH?D9?F7B�?D�J>;�9H?C;�E<�:;H;B?9J?ED�E<�:KJO�?D�J>;�FHEI;9KJ?ED�E<�E<<;DI;I�#;�?I

DEJ�7D�799;IIEHO

�HJ?9B;�DEJ�7FFB?978B;�JE�H;L;DK;�E<<?9;HI� �

J>7J�?I��ADEM?D=�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<�J>;�9H?C;��>;�:E;I�DEJ�97KI;��7��J>;�FHEI;9KJ?ED�E<�J>;�9H?C?D7B���EH

�8�� ADEM?D=� J>7J� 7� 9H?C;� ?I� 78EKJ� JE� 8;� 9ECC?JJ;:� >;� JEB;H7J;I� ?JI� 9ECC?II?ED� �?<� =?<J�FHEC?I;� ?I� 7

9EDI?:;H7J?ED�<EH�>?I�9ED:K9J��:?H;9J�8H?8;HO�

Page 99: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

72G@C�E96�G:@=2E@C�@7�E96�=2H

�1@>-E-8�;2 @>A?@�.E�-:�-@@;>:1E�;>?;85/5@;>��

2 �2FD:?8�52>286�E@�4=:6?E��� 6:E96C

� 3J� 2?J�>2=:4:@FD� 3C6249� @7� AC@76DD:@?2=� 5FEJ�@C

3J�:?6I4FD23=6�?68=:86?46�@C�:8?@C2?46

3 *6G62=:?8�2?J�@7� E96� D64C6ED�@7�9:D� 4=:6?E� =62C?653J�9:>�:?�9:D AC@76DD:@?2=�42A24:EJ� �

4 -?56CE2<:?8�E96�5676?D6�@7�E96�@AA@D:?8�A2CEJ�@7E96� �DE 4=:6?E� 2?5@C� 92G:?8� C646:G65� 4@?7:56?E:2=:?7@C>2E:@?� 7C@>� E96� =2EE6C� 2?5�H:E9@FE� E96� =2EE6CND4@?D6?E� �

�5>1/@�.>5.1>E��� 2�'776?56C�36 2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�H:E9:?� E96� D4@A6�@7�CE� ��� �

� ��HJ���� )EJ�D;9;II7H?BO�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�7BJ>EK=>�7BB�B7MO;HI�7H;�E<<?9;HI�E<�J>;�9EKHJ

� �FH;@K:?9;�?I�;II;DJ?7B

���:7C7=;�DEJ�D;9;II7HO

�� ?:

����HJ�� �

!EH� FKHFEI;I� E<� J>?I� 7HJ?9B;�� J;CFEH7HO� F;H<EHC7D9;� E<� FK8B?9� <KD9J?EDI� ?I� IK<<?9?;DJ� JE� 9EDIJ?JKJ;� 7

F;HIED� 7� FK8B?9� E<<?9;H� � �� FH?L7J;� F;HIED�C7O� 9ECC?J� J>?I� 9H?C;� EDBO� ?D� J>;� 97I;� ?D�M>?9>� 9KIJE:O� E<

FH?IED;HI�?I�;DJHKIJ;:�JE�>?C

�FFB?978B;� 7BIE� JE� 7II;IIEHI�� 7H8?JH7JEHI�� 7FFH7?I7B� 7D:� 9B7?C� 9ECC?II?ED;HI�� ;NF;HJI� EH� 7DO� EJ>;H

F;HIED�F;H<EHC?D=�FK8B?9�:KJ?;I

�7DDEJ�8;�<HKIJH7J;:��EDBO�7JJ;CFJ;:�EH�9EDIKCC7J;:

�H?8;HO�;N?IJI�M>;D�J>;�=?<J�?I�

7 LEBKDJ7H?BO�E<<;H;:�8O�7�FH?L7J;�F;HIED

8 IEB?9?J;:�8O�J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�7D:�LEBKDJ7H?BO�:;B?L;H;:�8O�J>;�FH?L7J;�F;HIED

9 IEB?9?J;:�8O�J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�8KJ�J>;�FH?L7J;�F;HIED�:;B?L;HI� ?J�EKJ�E<�<;7H�E<�J>;�9EDI;GK;D9;I

I>EKB:�J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�F;H<EHC�>?I�<KD9J?EDI��>;H;�J>;�9H?C;�8O�=?L;H�?I�DEJ�9EHHKFJ?ED�E<�FK8B?9�E<<?9?7BI

:K;�JE�?DLEBKDJ7H?D;II�

�9JK7B�H;9;?FJ�E<�J>;�=?<J�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO��D�799;FJ;:�E<<;H�EH�FHEC?I;�E<�7�=?<J�?I�IK<<?9?;DJ�#EM;L;H�

?<�J>;�E<<;H�?I�DEJ�799;FJ;:��EDBO�J>;�F;HIED�E<<;H?D=�J>;�=?<J�?I�B?78B;�<EH�7JJ;CFJ;:�9EHHKFJ?ED�E<�7�FK8B?9

E<<?9;H

/>;� =?<J� CKIJ� >7L;� 7� L7BK;� EH� 97F78B;� E<� F;9KD?7HO� ;IJ?C7J?ED� $J� 9EKB:� 8;� ?D� J>;� <EHC� E<� CED;O�

FHEF;HJO�EH�I;HL?9;I

$<�J>;�79J�H;GK?H;:�E<�J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�7CEKDJI�JE�7�9H?C;�7D:�>;�9ECC?JI�?J��>;�I>7BB�8;�B?78B;�<EH�J>;

F;D7BJO�9EHH;IFED:?D=�JE�J>;�9H?C;

/>;�J>?H:�JOF;�E<�8H?8;HO�7D: 24'8#4+%#%+10 7H;�I?C?B7H�E<<;DI;I��8EJ>�9EDI?IJ?D=�E<�EC?II?EDI�JE�:E�7D

79J�H;GK?H;:�JE�8;�F;H<EHC;:�$D�:?H;9J�8H?8;HO�>EM;L;H��7�=?<J�EH�FHEC?I;�?I�=?L;D�?D�9EDI?:;H7J?ED�E<�J>;

EC?II?ED�/>?I�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO�?D 24'8#4+%#%+10���

IKFH7

Page 100: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3�'776?56C�2446AED�2?�@776C�@C�AC@>:D6�@C�C646:G6D�28:7E�@C�AC6D6?E�3J�9:>D6=7�@C�E9C@F89�2?@E96C

4�+F49�@776C�@C�AC@>:D6�36�2446AE65�@C�8:7EAC6D6?EC646:G65�3J�E96�AF3=:4�@77:46C� �

� H:E9�2�G:6H�E@�4@>>:EE:?8�D@>6�4C:>6� � @C

:?� 4@?D:56C2E:@?� @7� 2?� 6I64FE:@?� :7� 2?� 24EH9:49�5@6D�?@E�4@?DE:EFE6�2�4C:>6��3FE�E96�24E�>FDE36�F?;FDE�� � @C

� E@� C67C2:?� 7C@>�5@:?8�D@>6E9:?8�H9:49� :D�9:D@77:4:2=�5FEJ�E@�5@

5�,96�24E�H9:49�E96�@776?56C�28C66D E@�A6C7@C>�@CH9:49� 96� 6I64FE6D� 36� 4@??64E65� H:E9� E96A6C7@C>2?46�@7�9:D�@77:4:2=�5FE:6D

�:05>1/@�.>5.1>E��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6�2446AED�8:7ED

4 +2:5� 8:7ED� 2C6� @776C65� E@� 9:>� 3J� C62D@?� @7� 9:D@77:46

%A-852510�.>5.1>E��� 2 (F3=:4�@77:46C�6?ECFDE65�H:E9�=2H�6?7@C46>6?E

���C;H; 7=H;;C;DJ�9EDIKCC7J;I�J>;�9H?C;

���:;B?L;HO�E< 9EDI?:;H7J?ED�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO

���:;B?L;HO�E<�9EDI?:;H7J?ED�?I�D;9;II7HO

����HJ��

/>;�=?<J�?I�=?L;D��?D�7DJ?9?F7J?ED�E<�<KJKH;�<7LEH�<HEC�J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�9B;7H� ?DJ;DJ?ED�ED�J>;�F7HJ�E<�J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�JE�J7A;�J>;�=?<J�E<<;H;:�7D:�9EDI?:;H�J>;

FHEF;HJO� 7I� >?I� EMD� <EH� J>7J� CEC;DJ� (;H;� F>OI?97B� H;9;?FJ� KD799ECF7D?;:� 8O� 7DO� EJ>;H I?=D�

9?H9KCIJ7D9;�EH�79J�JE�I>EM�IK9>�799;FJ7D9;�?I�DEJ�IK<<?9?;DJ�JE�9EDL?9J�J>;�E<<?9;H

/>;H;�?I�DE�7JJ;CFJ;:�EH�<HKIJH7J;:�?D:?H;9J�8H?8;HO

/>;�FH?D9?F7B�:?IJ?D9J?ED�8;JM;;D�:?H;9J�7D:�?D:?H;9J�8H?8;HO�?I�J>7J�?D�J>;�<EHC;H��J>;�E<<?9;H�7=H;;I�JE

F;H<EHC�EH�H;<H7?D� <HEC�:E?D=�7D�79J� ?D�9EDI?:;H7J?ED�E<� J>;�=?<J�EH�FHEC?I;� $D� J>;� B7JJ;H�97I;�� ?J� ?I�DEJ

D;9;II7HO�J>7J�J>;�E<<?9;H�:E�7DO�79J�$J�?I�IK<<?9?;DJ�J>7J�>;�799;FJI�J>;�=?<J�E<<;H;:�8O�H;7IED�E<�>?I�E<<?9;

+K8B?9�E<<?9;HI�H;9;?L?D=�=?<JI�7D:�FH?L7J;�F;HIEDI�=?L?D=�=?<JI�ED�7DO�E997I?ED��?D9BK:?D=��>H?IJC7I�7H;

B?78B;�KD:;H�+� ��

/>;�9H?C?D7B�F;D7BJO�EH� ?CFH?IEDC;DJ� ?I�:?IJ?D9J�<HEC�J>;�7:C?D?IJH7J?L;�F;D7BJO�E<�IKIF;DI?ED�<HEC

J>;�I;HL?9;���

�HJ�� �

Page 101: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

3 *67C2:?D� 7C@>�2CC6DE:?8AC@D64FE:?8�@776?56C� 7@C4C:>6�AF?:D923=6�3J 2%#,53)/.�0%20%45! 2?5@C�562E9� �

4 !?�4@?D:56C2E:@?�@7�2?J�@776C��AC@>:D6�@C�8:7E

�;>>A<@5;:�;2�<A.85/�;225/5-8?�� 2 '776?56C >2<6D�@776CD�@C�AC@>:D6D�@C�8:G6D�8:7ED@C�AC6D6?E�E@�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3� 6� @776CD� @C� AC@>:D6D� 2C6� >256� @C� E96� 8:7ED� @CAC6D6?ED� 8:G6?� E@� 2� AF3=:4� @77:46C�� F?56C4:C4F>DE2?46D�E92E�H:==�>2<6�E96�AF3=:4�@77:46C�=:23=67@C�5:C64E�3C:36CJ�@C�:?5:C64E�3C:36CJ

�>-A0?�-3-5:?@�<A.85/�@>1-?A>E��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6�D9@F=5�92G6�E2<6?�25G2?E286�@7�9:D�@77:46��E92E:D�� 96� :?E6CG6?65� :?� E96� EC2?D24E:@?� :?� 9:D� @77:4:2=42A24:EJ

4 6�6?E6C65�:?E@�2?�28C66>6?E�H:E9�2?J�:?E6C6DE65A2CEJ�@C DA64F=2E@C�@C�>256�FD6�@7�2?J�@E96C�D496>6H:E9�C682C5�E@��2��7FC?:D9:?8�DFAA=:6D��3��E96�>2<:?8@7� 4@?EC24ED�� @C� �4�� E96� 25;FDE>6?E�@C� D6EE=6>6?E�@7244@F?E�C6=2E:?8�E@�2�AF3=:4�AC@A6CEJ�@C�7F?5D

5 �44FD65�925�:?E6?E�E@�567C2F5�E96�8@G6C?>6?E

���?<�BEM;H�F;D7BJO�J>7D�IJ7J;:��J>;�9H?C;�?I�:?H;9J�8H?8;HO

����HJ�� �

/>;� E<<;D:;H� ?I� J>;� =?L;H� E<� J>;� =?<J� EH� J>;� E<<;HEH� E<� J>;� FHEC?I;� />;� 79J� C7O� EH� C7O� DEJ� 8;

799ECFB?I>;:

0D:;H�+� �����=?L;HI�E<�8H?8;I�7D:�EJ>;H�=?<JI�7I�M;BB�7I�799ECFB?9;I�?D�8H?8;HO�7D:�EJ>;H�=H7<J�97I;I

7H;�?CCKD;�<HEC�FHEI;9KJ?ED�KD:;H�J>;�<EBBEM?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�

7 ?D<EHC7J?ED�H;<;HI�JE�9EDIKCC7J;:�L?EB7J?EDI

8 D;9;II?JO�E<�J>;�?D<EHC7J?ED�EH�J;IJ?CEDO

9 J>; ?D<EHC7J?ED�7D:�J;IJ?CEDO�7H;�DEJ�O;J�?D�J>;�FEII;II?ED�E<�J>;�.J7J;

: ?D<EHC7J?ED�7D:�J;IJ?CEDO�97D�8;�9EHHE8EH7J;:�ED�?JI�C7J;H?7B�FE?DJI

; ?D<EHC7DJ�>7I�8;;D�FH;L?EKIBO�9EDL?9J;:�E<�7�9H?C;�?DLEBL?D=�CEH7B�JKHF?JK:;��

�HJ � �� F7H�

)EJ;I�

7 />;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�CKIJ�79J�?D�>?I�E<<?9?7B�97F79?JO

8 />;�<;BEDO�?I�9EDIKCC7J;:�8O�C;H;BO�;DJ;H?D=�?DJE�7D�7=H;;C;DJ�M?J>�7DO�?DJ;H;IJ;:�F7HJO

EH�IF;9KB7JEH�EH�8O�C;H;BO�C7A?D=�KI;�E<�7DO�I9>;C;�JE�:;<H7K:�J>;�"EL;HDC;DJ

Page 102: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�8813-8�1D-/@5;:?��� 2� '776?56C� :D� 2� AF3=:4� @77:46C� 6?ECFDE65� H:E9� E964@==64E:@?�@7�E2I6D��=:46?D6D��766D�2?5�@E96C�:>A@DED

3 6� :D� 8F:=EJ� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� 7@==@H:?8� 24ED� @C@>:DD:@?D�

� 56>2?5:?8�� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J� E96� A2J>6?E@7� DF>D� 5:776C6?E� 7C@>� @C� =2C86C� E92?� E9@D62FE9@C:K65�3J�=2H��@C

72:=:?8� G@=F?E2C:=J� E@� :DDF6� 2� C646:AE�� 2DAC@G:565�3J�=2H��7@C�2?J�DF>�@7�>@?6J�4@==64E65�3J9:>�@77:4:2==J��@C

� �@==64E:?8�@C�C646:G:?8��5:C64E=J�@C�:?5:C64E=J��3JH2J�@7�A2J>6?E�@C�@E96CH:D6��E9:?8D�@C�@3;64ED�@7�2?2EFC6�5:776C6?E�7C@>�E92E�AC@G:565�3J�=2H

#@41>�2>-A0?��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6�E2<6D�25G2?E286�@7�9:D�@77:4:2=�A@D:E:@?

4 6� 4@>>:ED� 2?J� @7� E96� 7C2F5D� @C� 5646:ED6?F>6C2E65�:?��CED�����2?5�������

$>;45.5@10�@>-:?-/@5;:?��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2?�2AA@:?E:G6�AF3=:4�@77:46C

���(;H;�:;C7D:�E<�7�B7H=;H�EH�:?<<;H;DJ�7CEKDJ�?I�IK<<?9?;DJ�JE�9EDIKCC7J;�J>;�9H?C;�/>;�;II;D9;�?I�J>;

?CFHEF;H�9EBB;9J?ED��:7C7=;�JE�=ELYJ�?I�DEJ�H;GK?H;:�

$<� IKCI� 7H;� H;9;?L;:� M?J>EKJ� :;C7D:?D=� J>;� I7C;�� 7� <;BEDO� KD:;H� J>?I� 7HJ?9B;� ?I� DEJ� 9ECC?JJ;:

#EM;L;H��?<�J>;�IKC�?I�=?L;D�7I�7 IEHJ�E<�=?<J�EH�=H7J?<?97J?ED��J>;�9H?C;�?I�?D:?H;9J�8H?8;HO

2>;D�J>;H;�?I�:;9;?J�?D�:;C7D:?D=�B7H=;H�<;;I��J>;�9H?C;�9ECC?JJ;:�?I�;IJ7<7

(7O�8;�9ECFB;N;:�M?J>�C7BL;HI7J?ED

*<<?9;HI�7D:�;CFBEO;;I�E<�J>;��$-�EH��KIJECI�7H;�DEJ�9EL;H;:�8O�J>; 7HJ?9B;

/>;�)$-��E<��:C?D?IJH7J?L;��E:;�?I�J>;�7FFB?978B;�B7M���

�HJ�� �

-/��>7I�@KH?I:?9J?ED�EL;H�J>;�E<<;DI;�8;97KI;�J>;�FH?D9?F7B�F;D7BJO�?I�:?IGK7B?<?97J?ED���

;IJ7<7��IM?D:B?D=���

�HJ��� �

N7CFB;I�E<�JH7DI79J?EDI�E<�;N9>7D=;�EH�IF;9KB7J?ED�7H;��8KO?D=�7D:�I;BB?D=�IJE9AI��9ECCE:?J?;I��B7D:

;J9�M>;H;?D�ED;�>EF;I�JE�J7A;�7:L7DJ7=;�E<�7D�;NF;9J;:�H?I;�EH�<7BB�?D�FH?9;

+KH9>7I?D=�E<� IJE9AI�EH� I>7H;I� ?D�7� 9ECF7DO� ?I� I?CFB;� ?DL;IJC;DJ�7D:�DEJ�7� L?EB7J?ED�E<� J>;�7HJ?9B;

#EM;L;H��H;=KB7HBO�8KO?D=�I;9KH?J?;I�<EH�H;I7B;�?I�IF;9KB7J?ED

Page 103: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3 6� 364@>6D� :?E6C6DE65�� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J�� :?2?J�EC2?D24E:@?�@7�6I492?86�@C�DA64F=2E:@?

4 ,96� EC2?D24E:@?� E2<6D� A=246� H:E9:?� E96� E6CC:E@CJDF3;64E�E@�9:D�;FC:D5:4E:@?

6�364@>6D� :?E6C6DE65� :?�E96�EC2?D24E:@?�5FC:?8�9:D:?4F>36?4J

$;??1??5;:�;2�<>;45.5@10� 5:@1>1?@?.E�-�<A.85/�;225/1>���

2 (F3=:4� @77:46C L :?� 2?J� 4@?EC24E� @C� 3FD:?6DD� :?H9:49�:E�:D�9:D�@77:4:2=�5FEJ�E@�:?E6CG6?6

3 �IA6CED�� 2C3:EC2E@CD� 2?5 AC:G2E6� 244@F?E2?ED L :?2?J�4@?EC24E�@C�EC2?D24E:@?�4@??64E65�H:E9�E96�6DE2E6@C� AC@A6CEJ� :?� E96� 2AAC@G2=�� 5:DEC:3FE:@?� @C25;F5:42E:@?�@7�H9:49�E96J�925�24E65

4 �F2C5:2?D� 2?5� 6I64FE@CD L H:E9� C6DA64E� E@AC@A6CEJ�36=@?8:?8�E@�E96:C�H2C5D�@C�E96�6DE2E6

!-8B1>?-@5;:� ;2� <A.85/� 2A:0?� ;><>;<1>@E���

2 '776?56C�36�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C���

����HJ�� �

�9JK7B�<H7K:�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO

�9J�?I�FKD?I>;:�8;97KI;�E<�J>;�FEII?8?B?JO�J>7J�<H7K:�C7O�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�EH�J>7J�J>;�E<<?9;H�C7O�FB79;

>?I�EMD�?DJ;H;IJ�78EL;�J>7J�E<�J>;�"EL;HDC;DJ�EH�F7HJO�M>?9>�>;�H;FH;I;DJI���

�HJ � �

(7BL;HI7J?ED�?I�EJ>;HM?I;�97BB;:�;C8;PPB;C;DJ

$J�97D�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�;?J>;H�M?J>�C7B?9;�EH�J>HEK=>�D;=B?=;D9;�EH�?CFHK:;D9;

$D�:;J;HC?D?D=�M>;J>;H�J>;�E<<;D:;H� ?I�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H��M>7J� ?I�9EDJHEBB?D=� ?I�J>;�D7JKH;�E<�>?I�E<<?9;

7D:�DEJ�J>;�:;I?=D7J?ED

/>;� <KD:I� EH� FHEF;HJO�CKIJ� 8;� H;9;?L;:� ?D� 7D� E<<?9?7B� 97F79?JO� *J>;HM?I;�� J>;� 9H?C;� 9ECC?JJ;:� ?I

;IJ7<7

2>;D 7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�>7I�E<<?9?7B�9KIJE:O�EH�J>;�:KJO�JE�9EBB;9J�EH�H;9;?L;�<KD:I�:K;�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ�

EH�J>;�E8B?=7J?ED�JE�799EKDJ�<EH�J>;C��>?I�C?I7FFHEFH?7J?ED�E<�J>;�I7C;�9EDIJ?JKJ;I�C7BL;HI7J?ED

��FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�M>E�>7I�GK7B?<?;:�9>7H=;�E<�=ELYJ�FHEF;HJO�M?J>EKJ�7KJ>EH?JO�JE�F7HJ�M?J>�?JI�F>OI?97B

FEII;II?ED�KFED�EH:;H�E<�7D�?CC;:?7J;�IKF;H?EH��>;�97DDEJ�8;�>;B:�B?78B;�KD:;H�J>?I�7HJ?9B;

+H?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7BI�97D�7BIE�8;�>;B:�B?78B;�<EH�C7BL;HI7J?ED�KD:;H���9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�

7 M>;D�J>;O�7H;�?D�9EDIF?H79O�M?J>�FK8B?9�E<<?9;HI��7D:

8 M>;D� J>;O�>7L;�9>7H=;�E<�D7J?ED7B��FHEL?D9?7B�EH�CKD?9?F7B� <KD:I�� H;L;DK;I�EH�FHEF;HJO� ?D

7DO�97F79?JO

$D� C7BL;HI7J?ED� J>HEK=>� D;=B?=;D9;�� J>;� D;=B?=;D9;� E<� J>;� 799EKDJ78B;� FK8B?9� E<<?9;H� CKIJ� 8;

FEI?J?L;BO�7D:�9B;7HBO I>EMD�JE�8;�?D;N9KI78B;��7FFHEN?C7J?D=�<H7K:�EH�C7B?9;

/>;�C;7IKH;�E<�D;=B?=;D9;�JE�8;�E8I;HL;:�?I�J>;�IJ7D:7H:�E<�97H;�9ECC;DIKH7J;�M?J>�J>;�E997I?ED

2>;D�C7BL;HI7J?ED� ?I� DEJ� 9ECC?JJ;:� J>HEK=>� D;=B?=;D9;�� B79A� E<� 9H?C?D7B� ?DJ;DJ� EH� =EE:� <7?J>� ?I� 7

:;<;DI;

Page 104: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3 6� 925� E96� 4FDE@5J� @C� 4@?EC@=� @7� 7F?5D� @CAC@A6CEJ���

4 ,9@D6� 7F?5D� @C� AC@A6CEJ� H6C6� AF3=:4� 7F?5D� @CAC@A6CEJ���

5 6�

� �AAC@AC:2E65�E96�7F?5D�@C�AC@A6CEJ

,@@<�@C�>:D2AAC@AC:2E65�E96>

� �@?D6?E65� @C�� E9C@F89� 232?5@?>6?E� @C?68=:86?46��A6C>:EE65�2?J�@E96C�A6CD@?�E@�E2<6�DF49AF3=:4�7F?5D�@C�AC@A6CEJ���

�-58A>1� ;2� -//;A:@-.81� ;225/1>� @;>1:01>�-//;A:@?� �

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4 @77:46C��H96E96C�:?�E96�D6CG:46@C�D6A2C2E65�E96C67C@>

3 6� >FDE� 36� 2?� 244@F?E23=6� @77:46C� 7@C� AF3=:47F?5D�AC@A6CEJ

4 6� :D� C6BF:C65� 3J� =2H� @C� C68F=2E:@?� E@� C6?56C244@F?ED� E@� E96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @?� 2F5:E�� @C� E@� 2AC@G:?4:2=�2F5:E@C

4 6�72:=D�E@�5@�D@�7@C�2�A6C:@5�@7�EH@�>@?E9D�27E6CDF49�244@F?ED�D9@F=5�36�C6?56C65

/>;�<7?BKH;�E<�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�JE�>7L;�7DO�:KBO�<EHJ>9EC?D=�FK8B?9�<KD:I�EH�FHEF;HJO�KFED�:;C7D:��8O

7DO�7KJ>EH?P;:�E<<?9;H�� I>7BB� 8;�FH?C7� <79?;�;L?:;D9;� J>7J�>;�>7I�FKJ� IK9>�C?II?D=� <KD:I�EH�FHEF;HJO� JE

F;HIED7B�KI;�#EM;L;H��?<�7J�J>;�L;HO�CEC;DJ�M>;D�J>;�I>EHJ7=;�?I�:?I9EL;H;:��J>;�799EKDJ78B;�E<<?9;H�?I

DEJ?<?;:��7D:�>;�?CC;:?7J;BO�F7OI�J>;�7CEKDJ�<HEC�>?I�FE9A;J��J>;�FH;IKCFJ?ED�:E;I�DEJ�7H?I;

-;JKHD?D=�J>;�;C8;PPB;:�<KD:I�?I�DEJ�;N;CFJ?D=��?J�?I�EDBO�C?J?=7J?D=

/>;H;� ?I� 7BIE� DE� C7BL;HI7J?ED� M>;D� J>;� 799EKDJ78B;� E<<?9;H� ?I� E8B?=;:� JE� =E� EKJ� E<� >?I� E<<?9;� 7D:

8EHHEM� J>;� 7CEKDJ� 9EHH;IFED:?D=� JE� J>;� I>EHJ7=;� 7D:� B7J;H�� J>;� C?II?D=� 7CEKDJ� ?I� <EKD:� ?D� 7D

KD799KIJEC;:�FB79;

��F;HIED�M>EI;�D;=B?=;D9;�C7:;�FEII?8B; J>;� 9ECC?II?ED�E<�C7BL;HI7J?ED�8O� 7DEJ>;H� 97D�8;�>;B:

B?78B;�7I�7�FH?D9?F7B�8O�?D:?IF;DI78B;�9EEF;H7J?ED

�;C7D:�7I�M;BB�7I�:7C7=;�JE�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ�7H;�DEJ�D;9;II7HO�;B;C;DJI���

EH�FH?L7J;�F;HIED�?<�;DJHKIJ;:�M?J>�FK8B?9�<KD:I�EH�9EDD?L;:�M?J>�FK8B?9 E<<?9;HI���

$<�DEJ�799EKDJ78B;�<EH�J>; <KD:I��J>;<J�EH�GK7B?<?;:�J>;<J���

L;D�?<�FH?L7J;�<KD:I�?<�7JJ79>;:��I;?P;:��:;FEI?J;: EH�9ECC?D=B;:�M?J>�FK8B?9�<KD:I��

$J� ?I� DEJ� D;9;II7HO� J>7J� J>;� E<<;D:;H� FHE<?J;:� J>;H;8O� #?I� 8;?D=� H;C?II� ?D� J>;� :KJO� E<� I7<;A;;F?D=

FK8B?9�<KD:I�L?EB7J;I�J>;�JHKIJ�H;FEI;:���

�HJ�� �

�;C7D:�7D:�C?I7FFHEFH?7J?ED�7H;�DEJ�D;9;II7HO

Page 105: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�-58A>1� ;2� -� >1?<;:?5.81� <A.85/;225/1>� @;� >1:01>� -//;A:@?� .12;>181-B5:3�@41�/;A:@>E� �

�8813-8� A?1� ;2� <A.85/� 2A:0?� ;><>;<1>@E�

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6� >FDE� 36� 2?� 244@F?E23=6� @77:46C� 7@C� AF3=:47F?5D�@C�AC@A6CEJ

4 6� >FDE� 92G6� F?=2H7F==J� =67E��� E96� (9:=:AA:?6DH:E9@FE� D64FC:?8� 7C@>� E96��@>>:DD:@?� @?��F5:E� 246CE:7:42E6� D9@H:?8� E92E� 9:D� 244@F?ED� 92G6� 366?7:?2==J�D6EE=65

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4 @77:46C

3 ,96C6� :D� AF3=:4� 7F?5� @C� AC@A6CEJ� F?56C� 9:D25>:?:DEC2E:@?

4 +F49� AF3=:4� 7F?5� @C� AC@A6CEJ� 92D� 366?2AAC@AC:2E65�3J�=2H�@C�@C5:?2?46���

5 6�2AA=:6D�E96�D2>6�E@�2�AF3=:4�FD6�@E96C�E92?�7@CH9:49�DF49�7F?5�@C�AC@A6CEJ�92D�366?�2AAC@AC:2E653J�=2H�@C�@C5:?2?46

�-58A>1�@;�9-71�0185B1>E�;2�<A.85/2A:0?�;>�<>;<1>@E� �

2 '776?56C� 92D� 8@GNE� 7F?5D� @C� AC@A6CEJ� :?� 9:DA@DD6DD:@?

3 6�:D�F?56C�@3=:82E:@?�E@�6:E96C�

� >2<6�A2J>6?E�7C@>�DF49�7F?5D

����HJ�� �

/>;�79J�E<�B;7L?D=�J>;�+>?B?FF?D;I�CKIJ�8;�KD7KJ>EH?P;:�EH�DEJ�F;HC?JJ;:�8O�B7M���

�HJ�����/;9>D?97B�C7BL;HI7J?ED

/E :?IJ?D=K?I>�J>?I�7HJ?9B;�M?J>��HJ � ���@KIJ�H;C;C8;H�J>7J�?D�?BB;=7B�KI;�E<�FK8B?9�<KD:I�EH�FHEF;HJO�

J>;�E<<;D:;H�:E;I�DEJ�:;H?L;�7DO�F;HIED7B�=7?D��J>;�<KD:I�7H;�C;H;BO�:;LEJ;:�JE�IEC;�EJ>;H�FK8B?9�KI;

�8I;D9;�E<�:7C7=;�?I�EDBO�7�C?J?=7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;���

EH�8;�ED�J>;�FE?DJ�E<�B;7L?D=���

M?J>EKJ�J>?I��?J�?I�I?CFB;�C7BL;HI7J?ED�;L;D�?<�7FFB?;:�JE�EJ>;H�FK8B?9�FKHFEI;���

�HJ���

+;D7BJO�?I�87I;:�ED�L7BK;�E<�<KD:I�FHEF;HJO�JE�8;�:;B?L;H;:

+;HIEDI�M>E�C7O�8;�>;B:�B?78B;�KD:;H��HJI � ��JE��� �

+H?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B�M>E��?D�7DO�97F79?JO��>7L;�9>7H=;�E<�7DO�D7J?ED7B��FHEL?D9?7B�EH�CKD?9?F7B�<KD:I�

H;L;DK;��EH�FHEF;HJO

� �:C?D?IJH7JEH�EH�:;FEI?J7HO�E<� <KD:I�EH�FHEF;HJO� J>7J�>7I�8;;D�7JJ79>;:��I;?P;:�EH�:;FEI?J;:�8O

FK8B?9�7KJ>EH?JO��;L;D�?<�EMD;:�8O�7�FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B

Page 106: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

E@� 56=:G6C� AC@A6CEJ� :?� 9:D� 4FDE@5J� @C25>:?:DEC2E:@?�H96?�@C56C65�3J�4@>A6E6?E�2FE9@C:EJ

4 6�>2=:4:@FD=J�72:=D�@C�C67FD6D�E@�5@�D@

�;::5B5:3� C5@4� ;>� /;:?1:@5:3� @;1B-?5;:� �

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C��@?�5FEJ�

3 6�:D�492C865�H:E9�E96�4@?G6J2?46�@C�4FDE@5J�@7�2AC:D@?6C�� 6:E96C 56E6?E:@?� AC:D@?6C� @C� AC:D@?6C� 3J7:?2=�;F58>6?E

4 +F49�AC:D@?6C�6D42A65�7C@>�9:D�4FDE@5J

5 6� H2D� :?� 4@??:G2?46� H:E9� E96� AC:D@?6C� :?� E96=2EE6CND�6D42A6

�B-?5;:�@4>;A34�:138531:/1��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6�:D�492C865�H:E9�E96 4@?G6J2?46�@C�4FDE@5J�@7�2AC:D@?6C�� 6:E96C� 56E6?E:@?� AC:D@?6C� @C� AC:D@?6C� 3J7:?2=�;F58>6?E

4 +F49�AC:D@?6C�6D42A6D�E9C@F89�9:D�?68=:86?46���

�?/-<1� ;2� <>5?;:1>?� A:01>� @41/A?@;0E� ;2� -� <1>?;:� :;@� -� <A.85/;225/1>��

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AC:G2E6�A6CD@?��

3 ,96� 4@?G6J2?46� @C� 4FDE@5J� @7� 2� AC:D@?6C� @C

����HJ����

�;J;DJ?ED�FH?IED;H��H;<;HI�JE�7�F;HIED�?D�B;=7B�9KIJE:O��7HH;IJ;:�<EH�7D:�9>7H=;:�M?J>�IEC;�9H?C;�EH

FK8B?9�E<<;DI;

/>;�H;B;7I;�E<�7�:;J;DJ?ED�FH?IED;H�M>E�9EKB:�DEJ�8;�:;B?L;H;:�JE�@K:?9?7B�7KJ>EH?J?;I�M?J>?D�J>;�J?C;

<?N;:� 8O� B7M� ?I� DEJ� ?D<?:;B?JO� ?D� J>;� 9KIJE:O� E<� 7� FH?IED;H� );?J>;H� ?I� C;H;� B;D?;D9O� EH� B7N?JO� ?D� J>;

F;H<EHC7D9;�E<�:KJO�9EDIJ?JKJ?L;�E<�?D<?:;B?JO

/>;H;� ?I� H;7B� 7D:� 79JK7B� ;L7I?ED� E<� I;HL?9;� E<� I;DJ;D9;�M>;D� J>;� 9KIJE:?7D� F;HC?JI� J>;� FH?IED;H� JE

E8J7?D�7�H;B7N7J?ED�E<�>?I�?CFH?IEDC;DJ���

�HJ����

/>;�7HJ?9B;�FKD?I>;I�7�:;<?D?J;�B7N?JO�M>?9>�7CEKDJI�JE�:;B?8;H7J;�DEDF;H<EHC7D9;�E<�7�:KJO

/>;� <79J� J>7J� J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H� H;97FJKH;:� J>;�FH?IED;H�M>E�>7:�;I97F;:� <HEC�>?I� 9KIJE:O�:E;I�DEJ

7<<EH:�9ECFB;J;�;N9KBF7J?ED

/>;�B?78?B?JO�E<�7D�;I97F?D=�FH?IED;H�

7 ?<�>;�?I�7�FH?IED;H�8O�<?D7B�@K:=C;DJ��>;�?I B?78B;�<EH�;L7I?ED�E<�I;HL?9;���HJ ���

8 ?<�>;�?I�7�:;J;DJ?ED�FH?IED;H��>;�:E;I�DEJ�?D9KH�9H?C?D7B�B?78?B?JO��KDB;II�9EEF;H7J?D=�M?J>�J>;

E<<;D:;H����

+;D7BJO�87I;:�ED�D7JKH;�E<�?CFH?IEDC;DJ

Page 107: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

A6CD@?�F?56C�2CC6DE�:D�4@?7:?65�E@�9:>

4 ,96�AC:D@?6C�@C�A6CD@?�F?56C�2CC6DE�6D42A6D

5 '776?56C� 4@?D6?ED� E@� E96� 6D42A6� @7� E96� AC:D@?6C@C�A6CD@?�F?56C�2CC6DE��@C�E92E�E96�6D42A6�E2<6D�A=246E9C@F89 9:D�?68=:86?46

&19;B-8�� /;:/1-891:@�� ;>01?@>A/@5;:�;2�0;/A91:@?���

2 '776?56C�36�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6�23DEC24ED��56DEC@JD�@C�4@?462=D�2�5@4F>6?E�@CA2A6C

4 +2:5� 5@4F>6?E� @C� A2A6C� D9@F=5� 92G6� 366?6?ECFDE65� E@� DF49� AF3=:4� @77:46C� 3J� C62D@?� @7� 9:D@77:46

5 �2>286��H96E96C�D6C:@FD�@C�?@E�� E@�2� E9:C5�A2CEJ@C�E@�E96�AF3=:4�:?E6C6DE�D9@F=5�92G6�366?�42FD65

#225/1>�.>1-75:3�?1-8��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

�� �HJ����

/>?I�7HJ?9B;�?I�DEJ�7FFB?978B;�?<�7�FH?L7J;�F;HIED�C7:;�J>;�7HH;IJ�7D:�>;�9EDI;DJ;:�JE�J>;�;I97F;�E<�J>;

F;HIED�>;�7HH;IJ;:���

CKIJ�8;�ED�:KJO���

�HJ����

/>;�:E9KC;DJ�CKIJ�8;�9ECFB;J;�7D:�ED;�8O�M>?9>�7�H?=>J�9EKB:�8;�;IJ78B?I>;:�EH�7D�E8B?=7J?ED�9EKB:

8;�;NJ?D=K?I>;:

�EEAI��F;H?E:?97BI��F7CF>B;JI�;J9�7H;�DEJ�:E9KC;DJI

Z+7F;HI[�MEKB:�?D9BK:;�9>;9AI��FHEC?IIEHO�DEJ;I�7D:�F7F;H�CED;O

��FEIJ�E<<?9;�E<<?9?7B�M>E�H;J7?D;:�J>;�C7?B�M?J>EKJ�<EHM7H:?D=�J>;�B;JJ;HI�JE�J>;?H�:;IJ?D7J?ED�?I�=K?BJO

E<�?D<?:;B?JO�?D�J>;�9KIJE:O�E<�F7F;HI

-;CEL7B� E<� 7� :E9KC;DJ� EH� F7F;H� CKIJ� 8;� <EH� 7D� ?BB?9?J� FKHFEI;� />;H;� ?I� ?BB?9?J� FKHFEI;� M>;D� J>;

?DJ;DJ?ED�E< J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�JE�

7 J7CF;H�M?J>�?J

8 JE�FHE<?J�8O�?J

9 JE�9ECC?J�7DO�79J�9EDIJ?JKJ?D=�7�8H;79>�E<�JHKIJ�?D�J>;�E<<?9?7B�J>;H;E<

-;CEL7B�?I�9EDIKCC7J;:�KFED�H;CEL7B�EH�I;9H;J?D=�7M7O�E<�J>;�:E9KC;DJ�<HEC�?JI�KIK7B�FB79;�$J� ?I

?CC7J;H?7B�M>;J>;H�EH�DEJ�J>; ?BB?9?J�FKHFEI;�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�>7I�8;;D�799ECFB?I>;:

$D<?:;B?JO� ?D�J>;�9KIJE:O�E<�:E9KC;DJI�J>HEK=>�:;IJHK9J?ED�EH�9ED9;7BC;DJ�:E;I�DEJ�H;GK?H;�FHEE<�E<

7D�?BB?9?J�FKHFEI;

�;B?L;H?D=�J>;�:E9KC;DJ�JE�J>;�MHED=�F7HJO�?I�?D<?:;B?JO�?D�J>;�9KIJE:O J>;H;E<

/>;�:7C7=;�C7O�;?J>;H�8;�=H;7J�EH�IC7BB

/>;�E<<;D:;H�CKIJ�8;�?D�9KIJE:O�E<�IK9>�:E9KC;DJI���

�HJ����

$J�?I�J>;�8H;7A?D=�E<�J>;�I;7BI�7D:�DEJ�J>;�EF;D?D=�E<�7�9BEI;:�;DL;BEF;�M>?9>�?I�FKD?I>;:

�7C7=;�EH�?DJ;DJ�JE�97KI;�:7C7=;�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO��:7C7=;�?I�FH;IKC;:

Page 108: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3 6� :D� 492C865� H:E9� E96� 4FDE@5J� @7� A2A6CD� @CAC@A6CEJ

4 ,96D6� A2A6CD� @C AC@A6CEJ� 2C6� D62=65� 3J� AC@A6C2FE9@C:EJ

6�3C62<D�E96�D62=D�@C�A6C>:ED�E96>�E@�36�3C@<6?

#<1:5:3�;2�/8;?10�0;/A91:@?��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 �?J� 4=@D65� A2A6CD�� 5@4F>6?ED�� @C� @3;64ED� 2C66?ECFDE65�E@�9:D�4FDE@5J

4 6� @A6?D� @C A6C>:ED� E@� 36� @A6?65� D2:5� 4=@D65A2A6CD��5@4F>6?ED�@C�@3;64ED

5 6�5@6D�?@E�92G6�AC@A6C�2FE9@C:EJ

&1B18-@5;:�;2�?1/>1@�.E�-:�;225/1>���

� �J� C62D@?� @7� 9:D� @77:4:2=42A24:EJ

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6� <?@HD� @7� 2� D64C6E� 3J� C62D@?� @7� 9:D� @77:4:2=42A24:EJ

4 6� C6G62=D� DF49� D64C6E� H:E9@FE� 2FE9@C:EJ� @C;FDE:7:23=6�C62D@?D

5 �2>286�� 8C62E� @C� D>2==�� 36� 42FD65� E@� E96� AF3=:4:?E6C6DE

����HJ����

�7C7=;�7BIE�DEJ�D;9;II7HO���

�HJ����

.;9H;J�CKIJ�7<<;9J�FK8B?9�?DJ;H;IJ

.;9H;JI�E<�7�FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B�?I�DEJ�?D9BK:;:

IF?ED7=;� <EH� J>;� 8;D;<?J� E<� 7DEJ>;H� .J7J;� ?I� DEJ� 9EDJ;CFB7J;:� 8O J>;� 7HJ?9B;� $<� H;=7H:?D=�C?B?J7HO

I;9H;JI�EH�I;9H;JI�7<<;9J?D=�IJ7J;�I;9KH?JO��J>;�9H?C;�C7O�8;�;IF?ED7=;

Page 109: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�� �6=:G6C:?8� HC@?87F==J� A2A6CD@C�4@A:6D�@7�A2A6CD @7�H9:49�96�>2J92G6� 492C86��� 2?5�H9:49� D9@F=5�?@E36�AF3=:D965�

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6�92D�492C86�@7�A2A6CD

4 ,9@D6�A2A6CD�D9@F=5�?@E�36�AF3=:D965

5 6� 56=:G6CD� E9@D6� A2A6CD� @C� 4@A:6D� E96C6@7� E@� 2E9:C5�A6CD@?

6 ,96�56=:G6CJ�:D�HC@?87F=

7 �2>286�36�42FD65�E@�AF3=:4�:?E6C6DE

$A.85/� ;225/1>� >1B1-85:3� ?1/>1@?� ;2<>5B-@1�5:05B50A-8���

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6�<?@HD�@7�E96�D64C6E�@7�2�AC:G2E6�:?5:G:5F2=�3JC62D@?�@7�9:D�@77:46

4 6� C6G62=D� DF49� D64C6ED� H:E9@FE 2FE9@C:EJ� @C;FDE:7:42E:@?�C62D@?

#<1:�05?;.1051:/1��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�;F5:4:2=�@C�6I64FE:G6�@77:46C

3 ,96C6�:D�2�;F58>6?E��564:D:@?�@C�@C56C�@7�DFA6C:@C2FE9@C:EJ

4 +F49� ;F58>6?E�� 564:D:@?� @C� @C56C� H2D� >256H:E9:?� E96� D4@A6�@7� E96� ;FC:D5:4E:@? @7� E96� DFA6C:@C2FE9@C:EJ�2?5�:DDF65�H:E9�2==�E96�=682=�7@C>2=:E:6D

5 '776?56C� H:E9@FE� 2?J� =682=� ;FDE:7:42E:@?� @A6?=J

���Z�>7H=;[��C;7DI�9KIJE:O�EH�9EDJHEB�$<�>;�?I�C;H;BO�;DJHKIJ;:�M?J>�J>;�F7F;HI�7D:�DEJ�M?J>�J>;�9KIJE:O

J>;H;E<��>;�?I�DEJ�B?78B;�KD:;H�J>?I�7HJ?9B;

$<� J>;� F7F;HI� 9EDJ7?D� I;9H;JI� M>?9>� I>EKB:� DEJ� 8;� FK8B?I>;:�� 7D:� J>;� FK8B?9� E<<?9;H� >7L?D=� 9>7H=;

J>;H;E<�H;CEL;I�7D:�:;B?L;HI�J>;C�MHED=<KBBO�JE�7�J>?H:�F;HIED��J>;�9H?C;�?I�H;L;B7J?ED�E<�I;9H;JI�*D�J>;

EJ>;H� >7D:�� ?<� J>;� F7F;HI� :E� DEJ� 9EDJ7?D� I;9H;JI�� J>;?H� H;CEL7B� <EH� 7D� ?BB?9?J� FKHFEI;� ?I� ?D<?:;B?JO� ?D� J>;

9KIJE:O�E<�:E9KC;DJI

�7C7=;�?I�;II;DJ?7B�JE�J>;�79J�9ECC?JJ;:���

�HJ����

-;L;B7J?ED�JE�ED;�F;HIED�?I�IK<<?9?;DJ

$<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�7D�7JJEHD;O��>;�?I�FHEF;HBO�B?78B;�KD:;H��HJ������8;JH7O7B�E<�JHKIJ�8O�7D�7JJEHD;O�

�7C7=;�JE�FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO���

�HJ���

%K:=C;DJ�I>EKB:�>7L;�8;;D�H;D:;H;:�?D�7�>;7H?D=�7D:�?IIK;:�M?J>?D�FHEF;H�@KH?I:?9J?ED�M?J>�7BB� B;=7B

IEB;CD?J?;I�H;GK?H;:

Page 110: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

C67FD6D� E@� 6I64FE6� E96� D2:5� ;F58>6?E�� 564:D:@?� @CF?56C�H9:49�96�:D�5FEJ�3@F?5�E@�@36J

�5?;.1051:/1� @;�;>01>� ;2� ?A<1>5;>;225/1> C41:� ?-50� ;>01>� C-??A?<1:010�.E�5:21>5;>�;225/1>���

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 �?�@C56C�:D�:DDF65�3J�9:D�DFA6C:@C�7@C�6I64FE:@?

4 6�92D� 7@C� 2?J� C62D@?� DFDA6?565� E96�6I64FE:@?@7�DF49�@C56C

5 :D� DFA6C:@C� 5:D2AAC@G6D� E96� DFDA6?D:@?� @7 E966I64FE:@?�@7�E96�@C56C

6 '776?56C� 5:D@36JD� 9:D� DFA6C:@C� 56DA:E6� E965:D2AAC@G2=�@7�E96�DFDA6?D:@?

&12A?-8�;2�-??5?@-:/1�� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 �� 4@>A6E6?E� 2FE9@C:EJ� 56>2?5D� 7C@>� E96@776?56C� E92E� 96� =6?5� 9:D� 4@@A6C2E:@?� E@H2C5D E9625>:?:DEC2E:@?�@7�;FDE:46�@C�@E96C�AF3=:4�D6CG:46

4 '776?56C�72:=D�E@�5@�D@�>2=:4:@FD=J

&12A?-8� @;� 05?/4->31� 181/@5B1;225/1���

2 '776?56C�:D�6=64E65�3J�A@AF=2C�6=64E:@?�E@�2�AF3=:4@77:46

3 6�C67FD6D�E@�36�DH@C?�:?�@C�5:D492C86�E96�5FE:6D@7�D2:5�@77:46

4 ,96C6� :D� ?@� =682=� >@E:G6� 7@C� DF49� C67FD2=� E@� 36DH@C?�:?�@C�E@�5:D492C86�E96�5FE:6D�@7�D2:5�@77:46

����HJ����

��FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�?I�DEJ�B?78B;�?<�J>;�EH:;H�E<�J>;�IKF;H?EH�?I�?BB;=7B��

�HJ����

$DLEBL;I�7�H;GK;IJ�<HEC�ED;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�JE�7DEJ>;H

�7C7=;�JE�J>;�FK8B?9�?DJ;H;IJ�EH�J>?H:�F7HJO�?I�;II;DJ?7B

�;C7D:�?I�D;9;II7HO���

�HJ����

L;D� ?<� J>;�F;HIED�:?:�DEJ� HKD� <EH� J>;�E<<?9;�ED�>?I�EMD�M?BB� 7I� J>;��EDIJ?JKJ?ED�FHEL?:;I� J>7J�;L;HO

9?J?P;D�C7O�8;�H;GK?H;:�JE�H;D:;H�I;HL?9;

Page 111: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

!-8@>1-@91:@�;2�<>5?;:1>?��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66

3 6� 92D� F?56C� 492C86� 2� AC:D@?6C� @C� 56E6?E:@?AC:D@?6C���

4 6� >2=EC62ED� DF49� AC:D@?6C� :?� 6:E96C� @7� E967@==@H:?8�>2??6CD�

� 3J� @G6C5@:?8� 9:>D6=7� :?� E96� 4@CC64E:@?� @C92?5=:?8� @7� 2� AC:D@?6C� @C� 56E6?E:@?� AC:D@?6C� F?56C9:D�492C86�6:E96C L

: 3J� E96� :>A@D:E:@?� @7� AF?:D9>6?ED� ?@E2FE9@C:K65�3J�E96�C68F=2E:@?D��@C

:: 3J�:?7=:4E:?8�DF49�AF?:D9>6?ED��� :?�2�4CF6=2?5�9F>:=:2E:?8�>2??6C��@C

3J� >2=EC62E:?8� DF49� AC:D@?6C� E@� 6IE@CE� 24@?76DD:@?�@C�E@�@3E2:?�D@>6�:?7@C>2E:@?�7C@>�E96AC:D@?6C

�:@5/5<-@5;:� ;2� 0A@51?� ;2� - <A.85/;225/1���

2 '776?56C� :D� 6?E:E=65� E@� 9@=5� 2� AF3=:4� @77:46� @C6>A=@J>6?E��6:E96C�3J�6=64E:@?�@C�2AA@:?E>6?E

3 ,96�=2H�C6BF:C6D�E92E�96�D9@F=5�7:CDE�36�DH@C?�:?2?5@C�D9@F=5�7:CDE�8:G6�2�3@?5

4 6� 2DDF>6D� E96� A6C7@C>2?46� @7� E96� 5FE:6D� 2?5A@H6CD�@7�DF49�@77:46

5 6�92D�?@E�E2<6?�9:D�@2E9�@7�@77:46�2?5@C�8:G6?E96�3@?5�C6BF:C65�3J�=2H

$>;8;:35:3� <1>2;>9-:/1� ;2� 0A@51?-:0�<;C1>?���

2 '776?56C�:D�9@=5:?8�2�AF3=:4�@77:46

����HJ����

/>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�CKIJ�>7L;�79JK7B�9>7H=;�E<�J>;�FH?IED;H�?D�EH:;H�JE�8;�>;B:�B?78B;

/E�8;�9EDI?:;H;:�7�:;J;DJ?ED�FH?IED;H��J>;�F;HIED�7HH;IJ;:�CKIJ�8;�FB79;:�?D�@7?B�;L;D�<EH�@KIJ�7�I>EHJ

M>?B;

*<<;D:;H�C7O�7BIE�8;�>;B:�B?78B;�<EH�F>OI?97B�?D@KH?;I�EH�:7C7=;�97KI;:���

EJ>;HM?I; J>;�9H?C;�?I�F>OI?97B�?D@KH?;I���

J>EI;�7KJ>EH?P;:���

�HJ�������

�HJ����

Page 112: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

3 ,96�A6C:@5�AC@G:565�3J�=2H��C68F=2E:@?D�@C�DA64:2=AC@G:D:@?D� 7@C� 9@=5:?8 DF49� @77:46� 92D� 2=C625J6IA:C65

4 6�4@?E:?F6D�E@�6I6C4:D6�E96�5FE:6D�2?5�A@H6CD�@7DF49�@77:46

�.-:0;:91:@� ;2� ;225/1� ;><;?5@5;:���

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6 7@C>2==J�C6D:8?D�7C@>�9:D�A@D:E:@?

4 :D�C6D:8?2E:@?�92D�?@E�J6E�366?�2446AE65

5 6� 232?5@?D� 9:D� @77:46� E@� E96� 56EC:>6?E� @7� E96AF3=:4�D6CG:46

)?A><-@5;:�;2�8135?8-@5B1�<;C1>?��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2?�6I64FE:G6�@C�;F5:4:2=�@77:46C

3 6

��� �>2<6D�86?6C2=�CF=6D�@C�C68F=2E:@?D�36J@?5E96�D4@A6�@7�9:D�2FE9@C:EJ�@C

���2EE6>AED�E@�C6A62=�2�=2H�@C

����DFDA6?5D�E96�6I64FE:@?�E96C6@7

)?A><-@5;:� ;2� 1D1/A@5B12A:/@5;:?���

2 '776?56C�:D�2�;F586

/>;� 7HJ?9B;� 9EDJ;CFB7J;I� E<<?9;HI� M>E� >7L;� 8;;D� IKIF;D:;:�� I;F7H7J;:� EH� :;9B7H;:� EL;H7=;:� EH

:?IC?II;:���

�HJ����

/>;H;�?I�79JK7B�787D:EDC;DJ�J>HEK=>�H;I?=D7J?ED�JE�;L7:;�J>;�:?I9>7H=;�E< :KJ?;I

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�<EHC7B�EH�MH?JJ;D�H;I?=D7J?ED

/>;�E<<;DI;� ?I� GK7B?<?;:� ?<� J>;�FKHFEI;�8;>?D:� J>;�787D:EDC;DJ� ?I� JE� ;L7:;� J>;�:?I9>7H=;�E<�:KJ?;I

9EDI?IJ?D=�E<�FH;L;DJ?D=��FHEI;9KJ?D=�EH�FKD?I>?D=�7DO�E<�J>;�9H?C;I�7=7?DIJ�D7J?ED7B�I;9KH?JO />;�F;D7BJO

?I�>?=>;H

�;H;B?9J?ED�E<��KJO FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�:E;I�DEJ�787D:ED�>?I�E<<?9;�8KJ�C;H;BO�<7?BI�JE�FHEI;9KJ;�7�L?EB7J?ED

E<�J>;�B7M���

�HJ�������

�HJ����

';=?IB7J?L;�E<<?9;HI�7H;�DEJ�B?78B;�<EH�KIKHF7J?ED�E<�;N;9KJ?L;�<KD9J?EDI

Page 113: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

3 6

���2DDF>6D�2�A@H6C�A6CE2:?:?8�E@�E96�6I64FE:G62FE9@C:E:6D��@C

��@3DECF4ED�6I64FE:G6�2FE9@C:E:6D�:?�E96�=2H7F=6I6C4:D6�@7�E96:C�A@H6CD

)?A><-@5;:�;2�6A05/5-8�2A:/@5;:?�� 2 '776?56C� :D�2?�@77:46C�@7� E96�6I64FE:G6 3C2?49�@7E96�8@G6C?>6?E

3 6

� 2DDF>6D�;F5:4:2=�A@H6CD��@C

@3DECF4E� E96�6I64FE:@?�@7� 2?J�@C56C�564:D:@?C6?56C65�3J�2?J�;F586�H:E9:?�9:D�;FC:D5:4E:@?

�5?;.1E5:3� >1=A1?@� 2;>05?=A-8525/-@5;:��

2 '776?56C :D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 �� AC@4665:?8� :D� A6?5:?8� 367@C6� DF49� AF3=:4@77:46C

4 ,96C6� :D� 2� BF6DE:@?� 3C@F89E� 367@C6� E96� AC@A6C2FE9@C:EJ� C682C5:?8�9:D� ;FC:D5:4E:@?��H9:49� :D�?@E�J6E564:565

5 6� 92D� 366?� =2H7F==J� C6BF:C65� E@� C67C2:?� 7C@>4@?E:?F:?8�E96 AC@4665:?8

6 6�4@?E:?F6D�E96�AC@4665:?8

�00>1??5:3� ;>01>?� ;>� >1=A1?@?� .E1D1/A@5B1� ;225/1>� @;� -:E� 6A05/5-8-A@4;>5@E���

2 '776?56C�:D�2?�6I64FE:G6�@77:46C

3 6� 255C6DD6D� 2?J� @C56C� @C� DF886DE:@?� E@� 2?J;F5:4:2=�2FE9@C:EJ

�� �HJ���

��C7OEH�?I�=K?BJO�KD:;H�J>?I�7HJ?9B;�M>;D�>;� ?DL;IJ?=7J;I�7�97I;�M>?B;�7�@KIJ?9;�E<�J>;�F;79;�?I�?D�J>;

CKD?9?F7B?JO���

�HJ ������

�HJ����

';=?IB7J?L;�EH�@K:?9?7B�E<<?9;HI�7H;�DEJ�B?78B;�KD:;H�J>?I�7HJ?9B;

Page 114: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

4 ,96� @C56C� @C DF886DE:@?� C6=2E6D� E@� 2?J� 42D6� @C3FD:?6DD�4@>:?8�H:E9:?� E96�6I4=FD:G6� ;FC:D5:4E:@?�@7E96�4@FCED�@7�;FDE:46

):8-C2A8�-<<;5:@91:@?��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6� ?@>:?2E6D� @C� 2AA@:?ED� 2� A6CD@?� E@� 2� AF3=:4@77:46

4 +F49�A6CD@?�=24<D�E96 =682=�BF2=:7:42E:@?�E96C67@C

5 '776?56C� <?@HD� E92E� 9:D� ?@>:?66� @C� 2AA@:?E66=24<D� E96� BF2=:7:42E:@?� 2E� E96� E:>6� 96� >256� E96?@>:?2E:@?�@C�2AA@:?E>6?E

�.A?1?�-3-5:?@�/4-?@5@E��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

3 6�D@=:4:ED�@C�>2<6D�:>>@C2=�@C :?5646?E�25G2?46D�E@�2H@>2?

4 +F49�H@>2?�>FDE�36 L

� :?E6C6DE65� :?�>2EE6CD�A6?5:?8� 367@C6� E96� @776?56C7@C� 564:D:@?�� @C�H:E9� C6DA64E� E@�H9:49� 96� :D� C6BF:C65� E@DF3>:E�2�C6A@CE�E@�@C�4@?DF=E�H:E9�2�DFA6C:@C�@77:46C��@C

F?56C�E96�4FDE@5J�@7�E96�@776?56C�H9@�:D�2�H2C56?@C� @E96C� AF3=:4� @77:46C� 5:C64E=J� 492C865� H:E9� 42C6� 2?54FDE@5J�@7�AC:D@?6CD�@C�A6CD@?�F?56C�2CC6DE��@C

� E96 H:76�� 52F89E6C�� D:DE6C� @C� C6=2E:G6� H:E9:?� E96D2>6�568C66� 3J� 277:?:EJ� @7� E96� A6CD@?� :?� E96� 4FDE@5J�@7E96�@776?56C

����HJ����

-;9ECC;D:?D=��ADEM?D=�J>7J�J>;�F;HIED�H;9ECC;D:;:�?I�DEJ�GK7B?<?;:�?I�DEJ�7�9H?C;

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�7� B7M�FHEL?:?D=� <EH� J>;�GK7B?<?97J?EDI�E<�7�F;HIED�JE�8;�DEC?D7J;:�EH�7FFE?DJ;:�JE�7

FK8B?9�E<<?9;���

�HJ����

/>;�CEJ>;H�E<�J>;�F;HIED�?D�J>;�9KIJE:O�E<�J>;�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�?I�DEJ�?D9BK:;:

.EB?9?J��C;7DI�JE�FHEFEI;�;7HD;IJBO�7D:�F;HI?IJ;DJBO�IEC;J>?D=�KD9>7IJ;�7D:�?CCEH7B�JE�7�MEC7D

/>;�7:L7D9;I�CKIJ�8;�?CCEH7B�EH�?D:;9;DJ

/>;�9H?C;�?I�9EDIKCC7J;:�8O�C;H;�FHEFEI7B

+HEE<�E<�IEB?9?J7J?ED�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO�M>;D�J>;H;�?I�I;NK7B�?DJ;H9EKHI;

Page 115: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

,� �9?4��=,1?�,9/��:==@;?�#=,.?4.0>��.? ���

4���:A0=,20

�6CE2:?� 24ED� @7� AF3=:4� @77:46CD� 2?5� AC:G2E6� A6CD@?D� 2=:<6� H9:49� 4@?DE:EFE6� 8C27E� @C4@CCFAE�AC24E:46D�@C�H9:49�>2J�=625�E96C6E@

44��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

2 �?J�AF3=:4�@77:46C�H9@�D92==�A6C7@C>�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

� (6CDF25:?8�� :?5F4:?8�@C� :?7=F6?4:?8�2?@E96C�AF3=:4�@77:46C� E@�A6C7@C>�2?24E�4@?DE:EFE:?8�2�G:@=2E:@?�@7�CF=6D�2?5 C68F=2E:@?D�5F=J�AC@>F=82E65�3J�4@>A6E6?E2FE9@C:EJ�@C�2?�@776?D6�:?�4@??64E:@?�H:E9�E96�@77:4:2=�5FE:6D�@7�E96�=2EE6C��@C�2==@H:?89:>D6=7�E@�36�A6CDF2565��:?5F465��@C�:?7=F6?465�E@�4@>>:E�DF49�G:@=2E:@?�@C�@776?D6

�:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J� C6BF6DE:?8� @C� C646:G:?8� 2?J� 8:7E�� AC6D6?E�� D92C6�A6C46?E286�� @C� 36?67:E� 7@C� 9:>D6=7� @C� 7@C� 2?J� @E96C� A6CD@?� :?� 4@??64E:@?�H:E9� 2?J4@?EC24E� @C� EC2?D24E:@?� 36EH66?� E96� 8@G6C?>6?E� 2?5� 2?J� @E96C� A2CEJ� H96C6:?� E96AF3=:4�@77:46C�:?�9:D�@77:4:2=�42A24:EJ�92D�E@�:?E6CG6?6 F?56C�E96�=2H

� �:C64E=J�� @C� :?5:C64E=J� C6BF6DE:?8� @C� C646:G:?8� 2?J� 8:7E�� AC6D6?E�� @C� @E96CA64F?:2CJ�@C�>2E6C:2=�36?67:E��7@C�9:>D6=7�@C�7@C�2?@E96C��7C@>�2?J�A6CD@?�7@C�H9@>E96�AF3=:4�@77:46C��:?�2?J�>2??6C�@7�42A24:EJ��92D�D64FC65�@C�@3E2:?65��@C�H:==�D64FC6@C�@3E2:?��2?J��@G6C?>6?E�A6C>:E�@C�=:46?D6��:?�4@?D:56C2E:@?�7@C�E96�96=5�8:G6?�@CE@�36�8:G6?

� �446AE:?8� @C� 92G:?8� 2?J�>6>36C� @7� 9:D� 72>:=J� 2446AE� 6>A=@J>6?E� :?� 2AC:G2E6�6?E6CAC:D6�H9:49�92D�A6?5:?8�@77:4:2=�3FD:?6DD�H:E9�9:>�5FC:?8�E96�A6?56?4JE96C6@7�@C�H:E9:?�@?6�J62C�27E6C�:ED�E6C>:?2E:@?

� �2FD:?8� 2?J� F?5F6� :?;FCJ� E@� 2?J� A2CEJ�� :?4=F5:?8� E96� �@G6C?>6?E�� @C8:G:?8� 2?J� AC:G2E6� A2CEJ� 2?J� F?H2CC2?E65� 36?67:ED�� 25G2?E286�� @C� AC676C6?46� :?� E965:D492C86� @7� 9:D� @77:4:2=�� 25>:?:DEC2E:G6� @C ;F5:4:2=� 7F?4E:@?� E9C@F89� >2?:76DEA2CE:2=:EJ�� 6G:56?E� 325� 72:E9� @C� 8C@DD� :?6I4FD23=6� ?68=:86?46� � ,9:D� AC@G:D:@?� D92==2AA=J�E@�@77:46CD�2?5�6>A=@J66D�@7�@77:46D�@C�8@G6C?>6?E�4@CA@C2E:@?D�492C865�H:E9E96�8C2?E�@7�=:46?D6D�@C�A6C>:ED�@C�@E96C�4@?46DD:@?D

� &68=64E:?8� @C� C67FD:?8�� 27E6C� 5F6� 56>2?5� @C� C6BF6DE�� H:E9@FE� DF77:4:6?E;FDE:7:42E:@?�� E@�24E�H:E9:?�2� C62D@?23=6� E:>6�@?�2?J�>2EE6C�A6?5:?8�367@C6�9:>�7@CE96� AFCA@D6� @7� @3E2:?:?8� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J�� 7C@>� 2?J� A6CD@?� :?E6C6DE65� :?� E96>2EE6C� D@>6� A64F?:2CJ� @C� >2E6C:2=� 36?67:E� @C� 25G2?E286�� @C� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @772G@C:?8� 9:D� @H?� :?E6C6DE� @7� 8:G:?8� F?5F6� 25G2?E286� :?� 72G@C� @7� @C� 5:D4C:>:?2E:?8282:?DE�2?J�@E96C�:?E6C6DE65�A2CEJ

���-���� ���7I�7C;D:;:

Page 116: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

� �?E6C:?8��@?�3692=7�@7� E96��@G6C?>6?E�� :?E@�2?J�4@?EC24E�@C� EC2?D24E:@?>2?:76DE=J� 2?5� 8C@DD=J� 5:D25G2?E286@FD� E@� E96� D2>6�� H96E96C� @C� ?@E� E96� AF3=:4@77:46C�AC@7:E65�@C�H:==�AC@7:E�E96C63J

� �:C64E=J�@C�:?5:C64E=J�92G:?8�7:?2?4:2=�@C�A64F?:2CJ�:?E6C6DE�:?�2?J�3FD:?6DD�4@?EC24E� @C� EC2?D24E:@?� :?� 4@??64E:@?�H:E9�H9:49 96� :?E6CG6?6D� @C� E2<6� A2CE� :?� 9:D@77:4:2=�42A24:EJ��@C�:?�H9:49�96�:D�AC@9:3:E65�3J�E96�4@?DE:EFE:@?�@C�3J�2?J�=2H�7C@>92G:?8�2?J�:?E6C6DE

�� �:C64E=J�@C�:?5:C64E=J�364@>:?8�:?E6C6DE65��7@C�A6CD@?2=�82:?��@C�92G:?8�2>2E6C:2=�:?E6C6DE�:?�2?J�EC2?D24E:@?�@C�24E�C6BF:C:?8�E96�2AAC@G2=�@7�2�3@2C5��A2?6=��@C8C@FA� @7�H9:49� 96� :D� 2�>6>36C�� 2?5�H9:49� 6I6C4:D6D� 5:D4C6E:@?� :?� DF49� 2AAC@G2=�6G6?�:7�96�G@E6D�282:?DE�E96�D2>6�@C�5@6D�?@E�A2CE:4:A2E6�:?�E96�24E:@?�@7�E96�3@2C5�4@>>:EE66��A2?6=�@C�8C@FA

�� #?@H:?8=J�2AAC@G:?8�@C�8C2?E:?8�2?J�=:46?D6��A6C>:E��AC:G:=686��@C�36?67:E:?�72G@C�@7�2?J�A6CD@?�?@E�BF2=:7:65�7@C�@C�?@E�=682==J�6?E:E=65�E@�DF49�=:46?D6��A6C>:E�AC:G:=686��@C�25G2?E286��@C�@7�2�>6C6�C6AC6D6?E2E:G6�@C�5F>>J�@7�@?6�H9@�:D�?@E�D@BF2=:7:65�@C�6?E:E=65

� �:GF=8:?8� G2=F23=6� :?7@C>2E:@?� @7� 2� 4@?7:56?E:2=� 492C24E6C�� 24BF:C65� 3J9:D�@77:46�@C�3J�9:>�@?�244@F?E�@7�9:D�@77:4:2=�A@D:E:@?�E@�F?2FE9@C:K65�A6CD@?D��@CC6=62D:?8�DF49�:?7@C>2E:@?�:?�25G2?46�@7�:ED�2FE9@C:K65�C6=62D6�52E6

3 �?J A6CD@?�92G:?8�72>:=J�@C�4=@D6�A6CD@?2=�C6=2E:@?�H:E9�2?J�AF3=:4�@77:4:2=�H9@D92==� 42A:E2=:K6� @C� 6IA=@:E� @C� E2<6� 25G2?E286� @7� DF49� 72>:=J� @C� 4=@D6� A6CD@?2=� C6=2E:@?� 3J5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J� C6BF6DE:?8� @C� C646:G:?8� 2?J� AC6D6?E�� 8:7E�� @C� >2E6C:2=�� @C� A64F?:2CJ25G2?E286� 7C@>� 2?J� A6CD@?� 92G:?8� D@>6� 3FD:?6DD�� EC2?D24E:@?�� 2AA=:42E:@?�� C6BF6DE�� @C4@?E24E�H:E9�E96�8@G6C?>6?E�:?�H9:49�DF49�AF3=:4�@77:4:2=�92D�E@�:?E6CG6?6���

4 �?J�A6CD@?�H9@�D92==�<?@H:?8=J� :?5F46�@C�42FD6�2?J�AF3=:4�@77:4:2=� E@�4@>>:E2?J�@7 E96�@776?D6D�F?56C�������

5 +A@FD6�@C�2?J�C6=2E:G6��3J�4@?D2?8F:?:EJ�@C�277:?:EJ��H:E9:?�E96��C5 4:G:=�568C66��@7E96�AC6D:56?E�@7�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D��E96�G:46�AC6D:56?E��E96�AC6D:56?E�@7�E96�+6?2E6��@C�DA62<6C�@7E96� 9@FD6� @7� *6AC6D6?E2E:G6D�� H9@� D92==� :?E6CG6?6�� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J�� :?� 2?J� 3FD:?6DDEC2?D24E:@?��4@?EC24E�@C�2AA=:42E:@?�H:E9�E96�8@GNE���

���.;9��

���?8?:

���.;9��

Page 117: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

444���C.0;?4:9>

� �?J�A6CD@?�H9@��AC:@C�E@�E96�2DDF>AE:@?�@7�@77:46�@7�2?J�@7�E96�23@G6�@77:4:2=D�E@H9@>�96�:D�C6=2E65��92D�366?�2=C625J�562=:?8�H:E9�E96�8@GNE�2=@?8�E96�D2>6�=:?6�@7�3FD:?6DD�

�?J�EC2?D24E:@?��4@?EC24E�@C�2AA=:42E:@?�2=C625J�6I:DE:?8�@C�A6?5:?8�2E�E96�E:>6�@7DF49�2DDF>AE:@?�@7�AF3=:4�@77:46�

� �?J� 2AA=:42E:@?� 7:=65�3J�9:>�� E96� 2AAC@G2=�@7�H9:49� :D� ?@E�5:D4C6E:@?2CJ�@?� E96A2CE�@7� E96�@77:4:2=�D��4@?46C?65�3FE�56A6?5D�FA@?�4@>A=:2?46�H:E9�C6BF:D:E6D�AC@G:565�3J=2H��@C�CF=6D @C�C68F=2E:@?D�:DDF65�AFCDF2?E�E@�=2H�

� �?J�24E�=2H7F==J�A6C7@C>65�2?�@77:4:2=�42A24:EJ�@C�:?�E96�6I6C4:D6�@7�2�AC@76DD:@?

� �?J�>6>36C� @7� 4@?8C6DD�� 5FC:?8� E96� E6C>� 7@C�H9:49� 96� 92D� 366?� 6=64E65��H9@D92==� 24BF:C6� @C� C646:G6� 2?J� A6CD@?2=� A64F?:2CJ :?E6C6DE� :?� 2?J� DA64:7:4� 3FD:?6DD� 6?E6CAC:D6H9:49� D92==� 36� 5:C64E=J� 2?5� A2CE:4F=2C=J� 72G@C65� @C� 36?67:E65� 3J� 2?J� =2H� @C� C6D@=FE:@?2FE9@C65�3J�9:>�AC6G:@FD=J�2AAC@G65�@C�25@AE65�3J��@?8C6DD�5FC:?8�9:D�E6C>

� �?J�AF3=:4�@77:46C�H9@� D92==� 72:=� E@� 7:=6� 2 ECF6�� 56E2:=65� 2?5� DH@C?� DE2E6>6?E�@72DD6ED�2?5�=:23:=:E:6D�H:E9:?����52JD�27E6C�2DDF>:?8�@77:46�2?5�E96C627E6C�@?�@C�367@C6�E96���E9

52J�@7��AC:=�7@==@H:?8�E96�4=@D6�@7�6G6CJ�42=6?52C�J62C��2D�H6==�2D�FA@?�E96�6IA:C2E:@?�@7�9:DE6C>�@7�@77:46��@C�FA@?�9:D�C6D:8?2E:@?�@C�D6A2C2E:@?�7C@>�@77:46���

� -?D@=:4:E65�8:7ED�@C�AC6D6?ED�@7�D>2==�@C� :?D:8?:7:42?E�G2=F6�@776C65�@C�8:G6?�2D�2>6C6�@C5:?2CJ�E@<6?�@7�8C2E:EF56�@7�7C:6?5D9:A�244@C5:?8�E@�=@42=�4FDE@>D�@C�FD286���

���.;9��

�� .;9� �

Page 118: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

-� �9?4�#7@9/0=��.?��

4���01494?4:9�:1�?0=8>

(F3=:4�'77:46C �?J�A6CD@?�9@=5:?8�2?J�AF3=:4�@77:46� :?� E96�@G6C?>6?E� @7� E96� *6AF3=:4� @7� E96(9:=:AA:?6D� 3J� G:CEF6� @7� 2?� 2AA@:?E>6?E�6=64E:@?�@C�4@?EC24E

�@G6C?>6?E !?4=F56D� E96�&2E:@?2=��@G6C?>6?E��2?5�2?J@7� :ED� DF35:G:D:@?D� 286?4:6D� @C:?DECF>6?E2=:E:6D�� :?4=F5:?8� 8@G6C?>6?E�@H?65�@C �4@?EC@==65�4@CA@C2E:@?D�2?5�E96:CDF3D:5:2C:6D

(6CD@? !?4=F56D� 2?J� ?2EFC2=� @C� ;FC:5:42=� A6CD@?�F?=6DD�E96�4@?E6IE�:?5:42E6D�@E96CH:D6���

44���77�2:??09�B0,7?3

�?J�2DD6E��AC@A6CEJ� 3FD:?6DD�6?E6CAC:D6�@C�>2E6C:2=�A@DD6DD:@?�@7�2?J�A6CD@?�H:E9:?E96� AFCG:6H� @7� +64E:@?� ,H@� � ���� 96C6@7�� 24BF:C65� 3J� 9:>� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J� E9C@F895F>>:6D��?@>:?66D��286?ED��DF3@C5:?2E6D�2?5@C�3FD:?6DD�2DD@4:2E6D�3J�2?J�4@>3:?2E:@?�@CD6C:6D�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�>62?D�@C�D:>:=2C�D496>6D�

���,9C@F89�>:D2AAC@AC:2E:@?��4@?G6CD:@?��>:DFD6��@C�>2=G6CD2E:@?�@7�AF3=:4�7F?5D�@CC2:5D�@?�E96�AF3=:4�EC62DFCJ�

�� �J� C646:G:?8�� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J�� 2?J� 4@>>:DD:@?�� 8:7E�� D92C6�� A6C46?E286�<:4<324<D� @C� 2?J� @E96C� 7@C>� @7� A64F?:2CJ� 36?67:E� 7C@>� 2?J� A6CD@?� 2?5@C� 6?E:EJ� :?4@??64E:@?�H:E9�2?J�8@G6C?>6?E�4@?EC24E�@C�AC@;64E�@C�3J�C62D@?�@7�E96�@77:46�@C�A@D:E:@?�@7E96�AF3=:4�@77:46C�4@?46C?65�

����J� E96� :==682=�@C� 7C2F5F=6?E�4@?G6J2?46�@C�5:DA@D:E:@?�@7�2DD6ED�36=@?8:?8 E@� E96&2E:@?2=� �@G6C?>6?E� @C� 2?J� @7� :ED� DF35:G:D:@?D�� 286?4:6D� @C� :?DECF>6?E2=:E:6D� @C8@G6C?>6?E�@H?65�@C �4@?EC@==65�4@CA@C2E:@?D�2?5�E96:C�DF3D:5:2C:6D�

��� �J� @3E2:?:?8�� C646:G:?8� @C� 2446AE:?8� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J� 2?J� D92C6D� @7� DE@4<�6BF:EJ�@C�2?J @E96C�7@C>�@7�:?E6C6DE�@C�A2CE:4:A2E:@?�:?4=F5:?8�AC@>:D6�@7�7FEFC6�6>A=@J>6?E:?�2?J�3FD:?6DD�6?E6CAC:D6�@C�F?56CE2<:?8�

���-��������7I�7C;D:;:

���.;9� ��79�

���?D<H7

Page 119: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

��� �J� 6DE23=:D9:?8� 28C:4F=EFC2=�� :?5FDEC:2=� @C� 4@>>6C4:2=� >@?@A@=:6D� @C� @E96C4@>3:?2E:@?D� 2?5@C� :>A=6>6?E2E:@?� @7� 564C66D� 2?5�@C56CD :?E6?565� E@� 36?67:E� A2CE:4F=2CA6CD@?D�@C�DA64:2=�:?E6C6DED��@C

����J�E2<:?8�F?5F6�25G2?E286�@7�@77:4:2=�A@D:E:@?��2FE9@C:EJ��C6=2E:@?D9:A��4@??64E:@?@C�:?7=F6?46�E@�F?;FDE=J�6?C:49�9:>D6=7�@C�E96>D6=G6D�2E�E96�6IA6?D6�2?5�E@�E96�52>286�2?5AC6;F5:46�@7 E96��:=:A:?@�A6@A=6�2?5�E96�*6AF3=:4�@7�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D���

444��#7@9/0=

�?J�AF3=:4� @77:46C�H9@�� 3J� 9:>D6=7� @C� :?� 4@??:G2?46�H:E9�>6>36CD� @7� 9:D� 72>:=J�C6=2E:G6D� 3J� 277:?:EJ� @C� 4@?D2?8F:?:EJ�� 3FD:?6DD� 2DD@4:2E6D�� DF3@C5:?2E6D� @C� @E96C� A6CD@?D�2>2DD6D� 244F>F=2E6D�@C�24BF:C6D�:==�8@EE6?�H62=E9�E9C@F89�2�4@>3:?2E:@?�@C�D6C:6D�@7�@G6CE4C:>:?2=�24ED�2D�56D4C:365�:?�+64E:@?����5���� 96C6@7�:?�E96�288C682E6�2>@F?E�@C�E@E2=�G2=F6�@72E�=62DE��:7EJ�>:==:@?�A6D@D��(��������������D92==�36�8F:=EJ�@7�E96�4C:>6�@7�A=F?56C�2?5�D92==36�AF?:D965�3J 2%#,53)/.�0%20%45! E@�562E9

�?J�A6CD@?�H9@�A2CE:4:A2E65�H:E9� E96� D2:5�AF3=:4�@77:46C� :?� E96� 4@>>:DD:@?�@7� 2?@776?D6�4@?EC:3FE:?8�E@�E96�4C:>6�@7�A=F?56C�D92==�=:<6H:D6�36�AF?:D965�7@C�DF49�@776?D6�!?E96�:>A@D:E:@?�@7�A6?2=E:6D��E96�568C66�@7�A2CE:4:A2E:@?�2?5�E96�2EE6?52?46�@7�>:E:82E:?8�2?56IE6?F2E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46D�� 2D�AC@G:565�3J� E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56�� D92==�36�4@?D:56C65�3JE96�4@FCE�,96�4@FCE�D92==�564=2C6�2?J�2?5�2==� :==�8@EE6?�H62=E9�2?5�E96:C� :?E6C6DED�2?5�@E96C:?4@>6D�2?5�2DD6ED�:?4=F5:?8�E96�AC@A6CE:6D�2?5�D92C6D�@7�DE@4<D�56C:G65�7C@>�E96�56A@D:E�@C:?G6DE>6?E�E96C6@7�7@C76:E65�:?�72G@C�@7�E96�+E2E6���

4A��&0=40>����:8-49,?4:9���

A� #,??0=9

�@C�AFCA@D6D�@7�6DE23=:D9:?8�E96�4C:>6�@7�A=F?56C��:E�D92==�?@E�36�?646DD2CJ�E@�AC@G66249�2?5�6G6CJ�4C:>:?2=�24E�5@?6�3J�E96�244FD65�:?�7FCE96C2?46�@7�E96�D496>6�@C�4@?DA:C24JE@� 2>2DD�� 244F>F=2E6� @C� 24BF:C6� :==�8@EE6?� H62=E9�� :E� 36:?8� DF77:4:6?E� E@� 6DE23=:D9� 36J@?5C62D@?23=6�5@F3E�2�A2EE6C?�@7�@G6CE�@C�4C:>:?2=�24ED�:?5:42E:G6�@7�E96�@G6C2==�F?=2H7F=�D496>6@C�4@?DA:C24J���

���.;9� ��:�

���IKFH7

���.;9����7I�7C;D:;:�8O�-������

���I;; +BKD:;H��IKFH7

���.;9��

Page 120: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

.� �@8,9�&0.@=4?D��.?�:1������

4� �,47@=0�?:�/074A0=�>@>;0.?�?:�;=:;0=�5@/4.4,7�,@?3:=4?D���

,96�A6?2=EJ�@7�E6?������J62CD�2?5�@?6�52J�E@�EH6=G6��� ��J62CD�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�D92==36� :>A@D65� FA@?� 2?J A@=:46� @C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� A6CD@??6=� H9@� 92D� 2AAC696?565� @C2CC6DE65��56E2:?65�2?5�E2<6?�4FDE@5J�@7�2�A6CD@?�492C865�H:E9�@C�DFDA64E65�@7�E96�4C:>6�@7E6CC@C:D>�@C�4@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�E6CC@C:D>�2?5�72:=D�E@�56=:G6C�DF49�492C865�@C�DFDA64E65A6CD@?�E@�E96�AC@A6C�;F5:4:2=�2FE9@C:EJ�H:E9:?�E96�A6C:@5�@7�E9C66�52JD

44� �914/074?D�49�?30�.@>?:/D�:1�/0?,490/�;0=>:9>

�?J� AF3=:4� @77:46C� H9@� 92D� 5:C64E� 4FDE@5J� @7� 2� 56E2:?65� A6CD@?� @C� F?56C� E96AC@G:D:@?D�@7�E9:D��4E�2?5�H9@�3J�9:D�56=:36C2E6�24E��>:D4@?5F4E��@C�:?6I4FD23=6�?68=:86?4642FD6D�@C�2==@HD�E96�6D42A6�@7�DF49�56E2:?65�A6CD@?�D92==�36�8F:=EJ�@7�2?�@776?D6�2?5�D92==DF776C�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�

�2�� EH6=G6� �� �� J62CD� 2?5� @?6� 52J� E@� EH6?EJ� � ��� J62CD� @7� :>AC:D@?>6?E�� :7� E9656E2:?65� A6CD@?� 92D� 2=C625J� 366?� 4@?G:4E65� 2?5� D6?E6?465� :?� 2� 7:?2=� ;F58>6?E� @7� 24@>A6E6?E�4@FCE��2?5

�3��D:I�J62CD�2?5�@?6�52J�E@�EH6=G6��� ��J62CD�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E��:7�E96�56E2:?65�A6CD@?92D�?@E�366?�4@?G:4E65�2?5�D6?E6?465�:?�2�7:?2=�;F58>6?E�@7�2�4@>A6E6?E�4@FCE��

444� �,7>0�;=:>0.@?4:9

-A@?� 24BF:EE2=�� 2?J� A6CD@?� H9@� :D� 244FD65� @7� E6CC@C:D>� D92==� 36� 6?E:E=65� E@� E96A2J>6?E�@7�52>286D�:?�E96�2>@F?E�@7��:G6�9F?5C65�E9@FD2?5�A6D@D��(�����������7@C�6G6CJ52J�E92E�96�@C�D96�92D�366?�56E2:?65�@C�56AC:G65�@7�=:36CEJ�@C�2CC6DE65�H:E9@FE�2�H2CC2?E 2D�2C6DF=E�@7�DF49�2?�244FD2E:@?�,96�2>@F?E�@7�52>286D�D92==�36�2FE@>2E:42==J�492C865�282:?DEE96� 2AAC@AC:2E:@?D� @7� E96� A@=:46� 286?4J� @C� E96� �?E:�,6CC@C:D>� �@F?4:=� E92E� 3C@F89E� @CD2?4E:@?65�E96�7:=:?8�@7�E96�492C86D�282:?DE�E96�244FD65�!E�D92==�2=D@�36�C6=62D65�H:E9:?�7:7E66?�����52JD� 7C@>�E96�52E6�@7� E96�24BF:EE2=�@7� E96�244FD65�,96�2H2C5�@7�52>286D�>6?E:@?6523@G6� D92==� 36� H:E9@FE� AC6;F5:46� E@� E96� C:89E� @7� E96� 24BF:EE65� 244FD65� E@� 7:=6� 4C:>:?2=� @C25>:?:DEC2E:G6�492C86D�282:?DE�E9@D6�C6DA@?D:3=6�7@C�492C8:?8�9:>�H:E9�E96�42D6�@7�E6CC@C:D>

�?J� @77:46C�� 6>A=@J66�� A6CD@??6=�� @C� A6CD@?� H9@� 56=2JD� E96� C6=62D6� @C� C67FD6D� E@C6=62D6�E96�2>@F?ED�2H2C565�E@�E96�:?5:G:5F2=�24BF:EE65�@7�E96�4C:>6�@7�E6CC@C:D>�D92==�DF776CE96�A6?2=EJ�@7�D:I ��� >@?E9D�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E

!7�E96�565F4E:@?D�2C6�=6DD�E92?�E96�2>@F?ED�5F6�E@�E96�56E2:?65�A6CD@?D��E96�2>@F?E?66565� E@� 4@>A=6E6� E96� 4@>A6?D2E:@?� D92==� 36� E2<6?� 7C@>� E96� 4FCC6?E� 2AAC@AC:2E:@?D� 7@C:?E6==:86?46��6>6C86?4J��D@4:2=�@C�@E96C�7F?5D�@7�E96�'77:46�@7�E96�(C6D:56?E

������������

�� .;9���

���.;9���

Page 121: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

!?�E96�6G6?E�E92E�E96�2>@F?E�42??@E�36�4@G6C65�3J�E96�4FCC6?E�3F586E�@7�E96�A@=:46@C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� 286?4J� 4@?46C?65�� E96� 2>@F?E� D92==� 36� 2FE@>2E:42==J� :?4=F565� :?� E962AAC@AC:2E:@?D�@7�E96�D2:5�286?4J�7@C�E96�4@>:?8�J62C���

���.;9���

Page 122: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

����>591?��3-5:?@�$1>?;:?

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED*6BF:D:E6D

$->>5/501�� 2 ��A6CD@?�:D�<:==65

3 ,96�56462D65�:D�<:==65�3J�E96�244FD65

4 ,96� 56462D65� :D� E96� 72E96C�� >@E96C�� @C� 49:=5�H96E96C� =68:E:>2E6� @C :==68:E:>2E6�� @C� 2� =68:E:>2E6@E96C� 2D46?52?E� @C� @E96C� 56D46?52?E�� @C� E96=68:E:>2E6�DA@FD6�@7�E96�244FD65

�1-@4�;>�<4E?5/-8� 5:6A>51?�A:01>1D/1<@5;:-8�/5>/A9?@-:/1?���

2 �� =682==J� >2CC:65� A6CD@?� @C� A2C6?E� DFCAC:D6D� 9:DDA@FD6�@C�52F89E6C��� :?�E96�24E @7�4@>>:EE:?8�D6IF2=:?E6C4@FCD6�H:E9�2?@E96C�A6CD@?

3 6D96�<:==D�2?J�@C�3@E9�@7�E96>�@C�:?7=:4ED�FA@?2?J� @C� 3@E9� @7� E96>� 2?J� D6C:@FD� A9JD:42=� :?;FCJ� :?E96�24E�@C�:>>65:2E6=J�E96C627E6C

����HJ����

/>;�H;B7J?EDI>?F�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�M?J>�J>;�L?9J?C�?I�J>;�;II;DJ?7B�;B;C;DJ�E<�J>;�<;BEDO

+7H;DJI�7D:�9>?B:H;D�7H;�DEJ�?D9BK:;:�?D�J>;�J;HC�Z7I9;D:7DJI[�EH�Z:;I9;D:7DJI[

/>;�EJ>;H�7I9;D:7DJ�EH�:;I9;D:7DJ�CKIJ�8;�B;=?J?C7J;�*D�J>;�EJ>;H�>7D:��J>;�<7J>;H��CEJ>;H�EH�9>?B:

C7O�8;�B;=?J?C7J;�EH�?BB;=?J?C7J;

/>;�9>?B:�I>EKB:�DEJ�8;�B;II�J>7D���:7OI�EB:�*J>;HM?I;��J>;�E<<;DI;�?I�?D<7DJ?9?:;

-;B7J?EDI>?F�CKIJ�8;�7BB;=;:

��IJH7D=;H�M>E�9EEF;H7J;I�?D�9ECC?JJ?D=�F7HH?9?:;�?I�B?78B;�<EH�CKH:;H�EH�>EC?9?:;

L;D�?<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�:?:�DEJ�ADEM�J>7J�J>;�F;HIED�>;�>7:�A?BB;:�?I�>?I�IED��>;�?I�IJ?BB�B?78B;�<EH�F7HH?9?:;

8;97KI;�J>;�B7M�:E;I�DEJ�H;GK?H;�ADEMB;:=;�E<�J>;�H;B7J?EDI>?F���

�HJ����

�HJ?9B;�:E;I�DEJ�:;<?D;�EH�F;D7B?P;�7�<;BEDO

)EJ�D;9;II7HO�J>7J�J>;�F7H;DJ�8;�B;=?J?C7J;

�HJ?9B;�7FFB?;I�EDBO�M>;D�J>;�:7K=>J;H�?I�I?D=B;

.KHFH?I;��C;7DI�JE�9EC;�KFED�IK::;DBO�EH�KD;NF;9J;:BO

�HJ�����?I�7FFB?978B;�M>;D�J>;�799KI;:�:?:�DEJ�I;;�>?I�IFEKI;�?D�J>;�79J�I;NK7B�?DJ;H9EKHI;�M?J>�7DEJ>;H

F;HIED�#EM;L;H��?J�?I�;DEK=>�J>7J�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�H;7IED78BO�I>EM�J>7J�J>;�97HD7B�79J�?I�8;?D=�9ECC?JJ;:

EH�>7I�8;;D�9ECC?JJ;:

.;NK7B�?DJ;H9EKHI;�:E;I�DEJ�?D9BK:; FH;F7H7JEHO�79JI

$CC;:?7J;BO�J>;H;7<J;H��C;7DI�J>7J�J>;�:?I9EL;HO��;I97F;��FKHIK?J�7D:�J>;�A?BB?D=�CKIJ�7BB�<EHC�F7HJI�E<

ED;�9EDJ?DKEKI�79J

/>;�A?BB?D=�CKIJ�8;�J>;�:?H;9J�8OFHE:K9J�E<�J>;�H7=;�E<�J>;�799KI;:

)E� 9H?C?D7B� B?78?B?JO� ?I� ?D9KHH;:�M>;D� B;II� I;H?EKI�EH� IB?=>J�F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I� 7H;� ?D<B?9J;:�(EH;EL;H�� ?D

97I;�J>?H:�F;HIEDI�97K=>J� ?D�J>;�9HEII<?H;�IK<<;H�F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I��J>;�799KI;:�?I�DEJ� B?78B;�/>;�FH?D9?FB;

J>7J�ED;�?I�B?78B;�<EH�J>;�9EDI;GK;D9;I�E<�>?I�<;BED?EKI�79J�?I�DEJ�7FFB?978B;�8;97KI;�>;�?I�DEJ�9ECC?JJ?D=

7�<;BEDO���

J>;�B7JJ;H�CKIJ�8;�KD:;H� ��7D:�B?L?D=�M?J>�J>;C

Page 123: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4 6� 92D� ?@E� AC@>@E65� @C� 724:=:E2E65� E96AC@DE:EFE:@?� @7� 9:D H:76� @C� 52F89E6C�� @C� E92E� 96� 92D?@E�4@?D6?E65�E@�E96�:?7:56=:EJ�@7�E96�@E96C�DA@FD6

!A>01>��� 2 ��A6CD@?�H2D�<:==65

3 ,96�244FD65�<:==65�9:>

4 ,96�<:==:?8�H2D� 2EE6?565�3J�2?J�@7� E96� 7@==@H:?8BF2=:7J:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46D�

� H:E9� EC62496CJ� E2<:?8� 25G2?E286� @7� DFA6C:@CDEC6?8E9��H:E9� E96� 2:5� @C� 2C>65�>6?�� @C� 6>A=@J:?8>62?D� E@� H62<6?� E96� 5676?D6� @C� @7� >62?D� @CA6CD@?D�E@�:?DFC6�@C�277@C5�:>AF?:EJ

:?�4@?D:56C2E:@?�@7�AC:46��C6H2C5�@C�AC@>:D6

� 3J� >62?D� @7� :?F?52E:@?�� 7:C6� A@:D@?�6IA=@D:@?��D9:AHC64<��DEC2?5:?8�@7�G6DD6=��56C2:=>6?E@C� 2DD2F=E� FA@?� 2� DEC66E� 42C� @C� =@4@>@E:G6�� 72==� @72:CD9:A��3J�>62?D�@7�>@E@C�G69:4=6D�@C�H:E9�E96�FD6@7�2?J�@E96C�>62?D�:?G@=G:?8�8C62E�H2DE6�@C�CF:?

� @?� @442D:@?� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� 42=2>:E:6D6?F>6C2E65� :?� E96� AC6465:?8� A2C28C2A9�� @C� @7� 2?62CE9BF2<6�� 6CFAE:@?� @7� 2� G@=42?@�� 56DECF4E:G64J4=@?6��6A:56>:4�@C�2?J�@E96C�AF3=:4�42=2>:EJ

� H:E9�6G:56?E�AC6>65:E2E:@?

� H:E9� 4CF6=EJ�� 3J� 56=:36C2E6=J� 2?5� :?9F>2?6=J2F8>6?E:?8�E96 DF776C:?8�@7�E96�G:4E:>�@C�@FEC28:?8@C�D4@77:?8�2E�9:D�A6CD@?�@C�4@CAD6�

� ,96�<:==:?8�:D�?@E�A2CC:4:56�@C�:?72?E:4:56

����HJ����

/>;�L?9J?C�CKIJ�8;�A?BB;:� ?D�EH:;H� JE�9EDIKCC7J;�J>;�E<<;DI;�*J>;HM?I;�� ?J�MEKB:�8;�7JJ;CFJ;:�EH

<HKIJH7J;:�CKH:;H

(KH:;H� M?BB� ;N?IJ� M?J>� EDBO� ED;� E<� J>;� 9?H9KCIJ7D9;I� />;� EJ>;H� 9?H9KCIJ7D9;I� 7H;� 78IEH8;:� EH

?D9BK:;:�?D�ED;�GK7B?<O?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;�/>;O�97DDEJ�8;�9EDI?:;H;:�7I�=;D;H?9�7==H7L7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I

�DO�E<� J>;�GK7B?<O?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�CKIJ�8;�7BB;=;:� ?D� J>;� ?D<EHC7J?ED�*J>;HM?I;�� J>;O�M?BB�EDBO�8;

9EDI?:;H;:�7I�=;D;H?9�7==H7L7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I

/H;79>;HO�7D:�FH;C;:?J7J?ED�7H;�?D>;H;DJ�?D�CKH:;H�M?J>�J>;�KI;�E<�FE?IED

Page 124: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�;95/501��� 2 ��A6CD@?�H2D�<:==65

3 ,96� 244FD65� <:==65� 9:>� H:E9@FE� 2?J� ;FDE:7J:?84:C4F>DE2?46D

4 ,96� 244FD65� 925� E96 :?E6?E:@?� E@� <:==�� H9:49� :DAC6DF>65

5 ,96� <:==:?8� H2D� ?@E� 2EE6?565� 3J� 2?J� @7� E96BF2=:7J:?8� 4:C4F>DE2?46D� @7� >FC56C�� @C� 3J� E92E� @7A2CC:4:56�@C�:?72?E:4:56

�1-@4�5:�-�@A9A8@;A?�-22>-E��� 2 ,96C6�36�D6G6C2=�A6CD@?D

3 ,96J� 5:5� ?@E� 4@>A@D6� 8C@FAD @C82?:K65� 7@C� E964@>>@?� AFCA@D6� @7� 2DD2F=E:?8� 2?5� 2EE24<:?8� 6249@E96C�C64:AC@42==J

4 ,96D6�D6G6C2=�A6CD@?D�BF2CC6=65�2?5�2DD2F=E65�@?62?@E96C�:?�2�4@?7FD65�2?5�EF>F=EF@FD�>2??6C

5 +@>6@?6�H2D�<:==65�:?�E96�4@FCD6�@7�E96�277C2J

6 !E� 42??@E� 36 2D46CE2:?65� H9@� 24EF2==J� <:==65� E9656462D65

7 ,96� A6CD@?� @C� A6CD@?D� H9@� :?7=:4E65� D6C:@FDA9JD:42=� :?;FC:6D� @C� H9@� FD65� G:@=6?46� 42?� 36:56?E:7:65

����HJ����

$DJ;DJ�JE�A?BB�?I�9ED9BKI?L;BO�FH;IKC;:�M>;D�:;7J> H;IKBJ;:�#;D9;��;L?:;D9;�E<�?DJ;DJ�JE�A?BB�?I�H;GK?H;:

EDBO�?D�7JJ;CFJ;:�EH�<HKIJH7J;:�>EC?9?:;

/>;H;�?I�DE�9H?C;�E<�<HKIJH7J;:�>EC?9?:;�J>HEK=>�D;=B?=;D9;

2>;D� J>;�MEKD:I� J>7J� 97KI;:� :;7J>�M;H;� ?D<B?9J;:� 8O� �� :?<<;H;DJ� F;HIEDI�� ;L;D� ?<� J>;O�M;H; DEJ� ?D

9EDIF?H79O��;79>�ED;�E<�J>;C�?I�=K?BJO�E<�>EC?9?:;

$D�7BB�9H?C;I�7=7?DIJ�F;HIEDI�?D�M>?9>�J>;�:;7J>�E<�J>;�L?9J?C�?I�7D�;B;C;DJ��J>;H;�CKIJ�8;�I7J?I<79JEHO

;L?:;D9;�E<�� ��J>;�<79J�E<�:;7J>�7D:�����J>;�?:;DJ?JO�E<�J>;�L?9J?C���

�HJ����

/KCKBJKEKI�7<<H7O�;N?IJI�>;D�7J�B;7IJ���F;HIEDI�J7A;�F7HJ�?D�?J

2>;D�J>;H;�7H;���?:;DJ?<?;:�=HEKFI�E<�C;D�M>E�7II7KBJ;:�;79>�EJ>;H��J>;H;�?I�DE�JKCKBJKEKI�7<<H7O

+;HIEDI�B?78B;�7H;�

7 F;HIED�I�M>E�?D<B?9J;:�I;H?EKI�F>OI?97B�?D@KH?;I

8 ?<� ?J� ?I�DEJ�ADEMD�M>E� ?D<B?9J;:�I;H?EKI�F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I�ED�J>;�:;9;7I;:��7BB�F;HIEDI�M>E�KI;:

L?EB;D9;�KFED�J>;�F;HIED�E<�J>;�L?9J?C

Page 125: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

$4E?5/-8� 5:6A>51?� 5:285/@10� 5:� -@A9A8@;A?�-22>-E���

2 ,96C6� :D�2� EF>F=EF@FD�277C2J�2D�C676CC65 E@� :?�E96AC6465:?8�2CE:4=6

3 ��A2CE:4:A2?E�@C� D@>6�A2CE:4:A2?ED� E96C6@7� DF776CD6C:@FD�A9JD:42=�:?;FC:6D�@C�A9JD:42=�:?;FC:6D@7�2�=6DD�D6C:@FD�?2EFC6�@?=J

4 ,96� A6CD@?� C6DA@?D:3=6� E96C67@C� 42??@E� 36:56?E:7:65

5 �==�E9@D6�H9@�2AA62C�E@�92G6�FD65 G:@=6?46�FA@?E96�A6CD@?�@7�E96�@776?565�A2CEJ�2C6�<?@H?

�5B5:3�-??5?@-:/1�@;�?A5/501 2 �DD:DE:?8�2?@E96C� E@�4@>>:E�DF:4:56��H96E96C� E96DF:4:56�:D�4@?DF>>2E65�@C�?@E

3 $6?5:?8� 9:D� 2DD:DE2?46� E@� 2?@E96C� E@� 4@>>:EDF:4:56�E@�E96�6IE6?E�@7�5@:?8 E96�<:==:?8�9:>D6=7

�5?/4->31�;2�25>1->9? � 2 '776?56C� 5:D492C86D� 2� 7:C62C>� 282:?DE� @C� 2E2?@E96C�A6CD@?

3 '776?56C�92D�?@�:?E6?E:@?�E@�<:==�E92E�A6CD@?

����HJ����

�� �HJ����

��F;HIED�M>E�7JJ;CFJI�JE�9ECC?J�IK?9?:;�?I�DEJ�9H?C?D7BBO�B?78B;

��FH;=D7DJ�MEC7D�M>E�JH?;:�JE�9ECC?J�IK?9?:;�8O�C;7DI�E<�FE?IED�8KJ�?DIJ;7:�E<�:O?D=��J>;�<;JKI�?D

>;H�MEC8�M7I�;NF;BB;:��?I�DEJ�B?78B;�<EH�78EHJ?ED

�II?IJ7D9;�JE�IK?9?:;�?I�:?<<;H;DJ�<HEC�C;H9OA?BB?D=� KJ>7D7I?7�?I�J>;�FH79J?9;�E<�F7?DB;IIBO�FKJJ?D=�JE

:;7J>�7�F;HIED�IK<<;H?D=� <HEC�IEC; ?D9KH78B;�:?I;7I;� $D� J>?I�97I;�� J>;�F;HIED�:E;I�DEJ�M7DJ� JE�:?;��

:E9JEH�M>E�H;IEHJI�JE�;KJ>7D7I?7�C7O�8;�>;B:�B?78B;�<EH�CKH:;H

+;D7BJO�?I�C?J?=7J;:�?<�IK?9?:;�?I�DEJ�IK99;II<KB���

�HJ����

/>;�E<<;D:;H�CKIJ�I>EEJ�7J�7DEJ>;H�M?J>�7DO�<?H;7HC M?J>EKJ�?DJ;DJ?ED�E<�A?BB?D=�>?C�$<�J>;�<?H;7HC�?I

DEJ�:?I9>7H=;:�7J�7�F;HIED��J>;�79J�?I�DEJ�FKD?I>;:�KD:;H�J>?I�7HJ?9B;

��:?I9>7H=;�JEM7H:I�J>;�>EKI;�E<�J>;�L?9J?C�?I�DEJ�:?I9>7H=;�E<�<?H;7HC�*D�J>;�EJ>;H�>7D:��<?H?D=�7�=KD

7=7?DIJ� J>;�>EKI;�E<� J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO�7J� H7D:EC��DEJ�ADEM?D=� ?D�M>7J�F7HJ�E<� J>;�>EKI;� J>;�F;EFB;

M;H;��?J�?I�EDBO�7B7HC�KD:;H��HJ ��

0IK7BBO��J>;�FKHFEI;�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�EDBO�JE�?DJ?C?:7J;�EH�<H?=>J;D�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO

$DJ;DJ�JE�A?BB�?I�D;=7J;:�8O�J>;�<79J�J>7J�J>;�:?IJ7D9;�8;JM;;D�J>;�L?9J?C�7D:�J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�����O7H:I

��F;HIED�97D�8;�>;B:�B?78B;�<EH�:?I9>7H=;�;L;D�?<�J>;�=KD�M7I�DEJ�FE?DJ;:�7J�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO�M>;D�?J

<?H;:�<EH�7I�BED=�7I�?J�M7I�?D?J?7BBO�7?C;:�7J�EH�7=7?DIJ�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO

Page 126: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�:2-:@5/501��� 2 ��49:=5�H2D�<:==65

3 ,96� 56462D65� 49:=5� H2D� =6DD� E92?� E9C66� ��� 52JD�� �9@FCD��@7�286

4 ,96�244FD65�<:==65�E96�D2:5�49:=5

�:@1:@5;:-8�-.;>@5;:��� 2 ,96C6�:D�2�AC68?2?E�H@>2?

3 .:@=6?46� :D� 6I6CE65�� @C� 5CF8D� @C� 36G6C286D25>:?:DE6C65�� @C� E92E� E96� 244FD65� @E96CH:D6� 24EDFA@?�DF49�AC68?2?E�H@>2?

4 �D� 2 C6DF=E� @7� E96� FD6� @7� G:@=6?46� @C� 5CF8D� @C36G6C286D�FA@?�96C��@C�2?J�@E96C�24E�@7�E96�244FD65�E96� 76EFD� 5:6D�� 6:E96C� :?� E96� H@>3� @C� 27E6C� 92G:?8366?�6IA6==65�E96C67C@>

5 ,96�23@CE:@?�:D�:?E6?565

):5:@1:@5;:-8�-.;>@5;:��� 2 ,96C6�:D�2�AC68?2?E H@>2?

3 .:@=6?46� :D� FD65� FA@?� DF49� AC68?2?E� H@>2?H:E9@FE�:?E6?5:?8�2?�23@CE:@?

4 ,96�G:@=6?46�:D�:?E6?E:@?2==J�6I6CE65

5��D�2�C6DF=E�@7�E96�G:@=6?46�E92E�76EFD�5:6D��6:E96C�:?

����HJ����

2>;D�J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�J>;�<7J>;H��CEJ>;H�EH�B;=?J?C7J;�7I9;D:7DJ��>;�I>7BB�IK<<;H�J>;�F;D7BJO�FH;I9H?8;:

<EH�F7HH?9?:;�$<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�?I�7DO�EJ>;H�F;HIED��J>;�F;D7BJO�?I�J>7J�<EH�CKH:;H�$D�;?J>;H�97I;��J>;�FHEF;H

GK7B?<?97J?ED�<EH�J>;�E<<;DI;�?I�?D<7DJ?9?:;

2>;D� ?D<7DJ?9?:;� ?I� 9ECC?JJ;:� 8O� J>;� CEJ>;H� EH� C7J;HD7B� =H7D:CEJ>;H� ?D� EH:;H� JE� 9ED9;7B� J>;

:?I>EDEH��IK9>�<79J ?I�EDBO�C?J?=7J?D=

/>;�:;B?DGK;DJ�CEJ>;H�M>E�9B7?CI�J>7J�I>;�9ECC?JJ;:�J>;�E<<;DI;�JE�9ED9;7B�J>;�:?I>EDEH�CKIJ�8;�E<

=EE:�H;FKJ7J?ED�#;D9;�� ?<�I>;� ?I�7�FHEIJ?JKJ;��I>;� ?I�DEJ�;DJ?JB;:�JE�7� B;II;H�F;D7BJO�8;97KI;�I>;�>7I�DE

>EDEH�JE�9ED9;7B

/>;H; ?I�DE� ?D<7DJ?9?:;�M>;D� J>;� 9>?B:�M7I�8EHD�:;7:��EH� 7BJ>EK=>�8EHD�7B?L;� ?J� 9EKB:�DEJ� IKIJ7?D� 7D

?D:;F;D:;DJ�B?<;�M>;D�?J�M7I�A?BB;:���

�HJ�������

�HJ����

0D?DJ;DJ?ED7B�78EHJ?ED�97D�7BIE�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�J>HEK=>�D;=B?=;D9;

/>;�799KI;:�97D�EDBO�8;�>;B: B?78B;�?<�>;�AD;M�J>7J�J>;�MEC7D�M7I�FH;=D7DJ

$<�J>;H;�?I�DE�?DJ;DJ?ED�JE�97KI;�78EHJ?ED�7D:�D;?J>;H�M7I�L?EB;D9;�;N;HJ;:��7HJI�����7D:�����:E;I�DEJ

7FFBO

Page 127: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

E96�H@>3�@C�27E6C�92G:?8�366?�6IA6==65�E96C67C@>

�.;>@5;: <>-/@5/10� .E� @41C;9-:� 41>?182� ;>� .E� 41><->1:@? �

2 ,96C6� :D� 2�AC68?2?E�H@>2?�H9@�92D� DF776C65� 2?23@CE:@?

3 ,96�23@CE:@?�:D�:?E6?565

4 ,96�23@CE:@?�:D�42FD65�3J L

� E96�AC68?2?E�H@>2?�96CD6=7

2?J�@E96C�A6CD@?��H:E9�96C�4@?D6?E��@C

� 2?J� @7� 96C� A2C6?ED�� H:E9� 96C� 4@?D6?E� 7@C� E96AFCA@D6�@7�4@?462=:?8�96C�5:D9@?@C

�.;>@5;:� <>-/@5/10� .E� -<4E?5/5-:� ;>� 950C521� -:005?<1:?5:3�;2�-.;>@5B1?���

2 ,96C6� :D� 2�AC68?2?E�H@>2?�H9@�92D� DF776C65� 2?23@CE:@?

3 ,96�23@CE:@?�:D�:?E6?565

4 '776?56C�� H9@�>FDE� 36� 2� A9JD:4:2?� @C� >:5H:76�42FD6D�@C�2DD:DED�:?�42FD:?8�E96�23@CE:@?

5 +2:5�A9JD:4:2?�@C�>:5H:76� E2<6D� 25G2?E286�@7�9:D@C�96C�D4:6?E:7:4�<?@H=6586�@C�D<:==

&1?<;:?5.585@E� ;2� <->@5/5<-:@?� 5:-�0A18���

2 #:==:?8�@?6ND�25G6CD2CJ :?�2�5F6=

����HJ����

'?78?B?JO�E<�J>;�FH;=D7DJ�MEC7D�?I�C?J?=7J;:�?<�J>;�FKHFEI;�?I�JE�9ED9;7B�>;H�:?I>EDEH�#EM;L;H��J>;H;

?I�DE�B?J?=7J?ED�<EH�J>;�F7H;DJI�E<�J>;�FH;=D7DJ�MEC;D�;L;D�?<�J>;?H�FKHFEI;�?I�JE�9ED9;7B�J>;?H�:7K=>J;HYI

:?I>EDEH

$D� ?D<7DJ?9?:;�� F7H;DJI� 97D� 7L7?B� E<� J>;� C?J?=7J?D=� 9?H9KCIJ7D9;� E<� 9ED9;7B?D=� J>;� :?I>EDEH� E<� J>;?H

:7K=>J;H />?I�?I�DEJ�IE�<EH �HJ ������

�HJ����

$J�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO�J>7J�J>;�F>7HC79?IJ�AD;M�J>7J�J>;�78EHJ?L;�MEKB:�8;�KI;:�JE�97KI;�78EHJ?ED�2>7J

?I�FKD?I>;:�?I�J>;�79J�E<�:?IF;DI?D=�7D�78EHJ?L;�M?J>EKJ�J>;�FHEF;H�FH;I9H?FJ?ED� $J� ?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO�J>7J

J>;�78EHJ?L;�8;�79JK7BBO�KI;:

$<�J>; F>7HC79?IJ�AD;M�J>7J�J>;�78EHJ?L;�MEKB:�8;�KI;:�JE�97KI;�78EHJ?ED�7D:�78EHJ?ED�H;IKBJI��>;�?I

B?78B;�7I�7D�799ECFB?9;���

�HJ����

+;HIEDI�B?78B;�

Page 128: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3 !?7=:4E:?8� FA@?� E96� 25G6CD2CJ� D6C:@FD� A9JD:42=:?;FC:6D

4 %2<:?8� 2� 4@>32E� 2=E9@F89� ?@� A9JD:42=� :?;FC:6D92G6�366?�:?7=:4E65

�4-881:35:3�@;�-�0A18��� 2 �92==6?8:?8�2?@E96C�E@�2�5F6=

3 !?4:E:?8�2?@E96C�E@�8:G6�@C�2446AE�2�492==6?86�E@ 25F6=

4 +4@77:?8�2E�@C�564CJ:?8�2?@E96C�AF3=:4=J�7@C�92G:?8C67FD65�E@�2446AE�2�492==6?86�E@�7:89E�2�5F6=

!A@58-@5;: 2 ,96C6� 36� 2� 42DEC2E:@?� :6� >FE:=2E:@?� @7� @C82?D?646DD2CJ�7@C�86?6C2E:@?

3 %FE:=2E:@?�:D�42FD65�AFCA@D6=J�2?5�56=:36C2E6=J

+H?D9?F7BI W F;HIED�M>E�A?BB;:�EH�?D<B?9J;:�F>OI?97B�?D@KH?;I�KFED�>?I�7:L;HI7HO��EH�8EJ>�9EC87J7DJI�?D

7DO�EJ>;H�97I;I

� �99ECFB?9;I W 7I�I;9ED:I

�K;B��7�<EHC7B�EH�H;=KB7H�9EC87J�FH;L?EKIBO�9ED9;HJ;:�8;JM;;D���F7HJ?;I�?D�J>;�FH;I;D9;�E<���EH�CEH;

I;9ED:I�E<�B7M<KB�7=;�ED�;79>�I?:;��M>E�C7A;�J>;�I;B;9J?ED�E<�7HCI�7D:�<?N�7BB�J>;�EJ>;H�9ED:?J?EDI�E<�J>;

<?=>J

$<�:;7J>�H;IKBJI��J>;�F;D7BJO�?I�J>;�I7C;�7I�J>7J�<EH�>EC?9?:;���

�HJ���

+;HIEDI�B?78B;�

�>7BB;D=;H

� $DIJ?=7JEHI� �

�HJ����

&?D:I�E<�(KJ?B7J?ED

$DJ;DJ?ED7BBO�CKJ?B7J?D=� 7DEJ>;H� 8O� :;FH?L?D=� >?C�� JEJ7BBO� EH� F7HJ?7BBO�� E<� IEC;� ;II;DJ?7B� EH=7D� <EH

H;FHE:K9J?ED

$DJ;DJ?ED7BBO� C7A?D=� 7DEJ>;H� CKJ?B7J?ED�� ?;� BEFF?D=�� 9B?FF?D=� E<<� 7DO� F7HJ� E<� J>;� 8E:O� E<� J>;

E<<;D:;:�F7HJO��EJ>;H�J>7D J>;�;II;DJ?7B�EH=7D�<EH�H;FHE:K9J?ED��JE�:;FH?L;�>?C�E<�J>7J�F7HJ�E<�J>;�8E:O

$D�J>;�<?HIJ�A?D:�E<�CKJ?B7J?ED��J>;�97IJH7J?ED�CKIJ�8;�C7:;�FKHFEI;BO�*J>;HM?I;��?J�M?BB�8;�9EDI?:;H;:

7I�CKJ?B7J?ED�E<�J>;�I;9ED:�A?D:

(7O>;C��H;<;HI�JE�7DO�EJ>;H�?DJ;DJ?ED7B�CKJ?B7J?ED

Page 129: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

'1>5;A?�<4E?5/-8�5:6A>51?��� 2 !?;FC65� A6CD@?� 364@>6D� :?D2?6�� :>364:=6�:>A@E6?E�@C�3=:?5

3 !?;FC65�A6CD@? L

� =@D6D�E96�FD6�@7�DA6649�@C�E96�A@H6C�E@�962C�@CE@�D>6==��=@D6D�2?�6J6��2�92?5��7@@E��2C>�@C�=68

� �HJ����

#EM��ECC?JJ;:

2EKD:?D=

� �;7J?D=

� �II7KBJ?D=

� �:C?D?IJ;H?D=�?D@KH?EKI�IK8IJ7D9;I

.;H?EKI� F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I� ?I� GK7B?<?;:� M>;D� J>;� 9H?C;� ?I� 9ECC?JJ;:� 7=7?DIJ� J>;� I7C;� F;HIEDI

;DKC;H7J;:� ?D 6*'� #46+%.'� 10� 2#44+%+&'� 14�9*'0� +6� +5� #66'0&'&� $;� #0;� 1(� 6*'� %+4%7/56#0%'5� &'(+0+0)� 6*'

%4+/'�1(�/74&'4� #EM;L;H�� I;H?EKI�F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I� H;IKBJ?D=� <HEC�;N9;II?L;�9>7IJ?I;C;DJ�8O�F7H;DJI� ?I

DEJ�GK7B?<?;:�I;H?EKI�F>OI?97B�?D@KH?;I

.;H?EKI�F>OI?97B�?D@KH?;I�C7O�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�J>HEK=>�H;9AB;II�?CFHK:;D9;�EH�I?CFB;�?CFHK:;D9;

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�DE�?DJ;DJ�JE�A?BB

$CFEJ;DJ�I>EKB:�?D9BK:;�?D78?B?JO�JE�9EFKB7J;�7D:�IJ;H?B?JO

�B?D:D;II�H;GK?H;I�BEII�E<�L?I?ED�?D�8EJ>�;O;I�(;H;�M;7AD;II�?D�L?I?ED�?I�DEJ�9EDJ;CFB7J;:

'EII� E< FEM;H� JE� >;7H� CKIJ� ?DLEBL;� 8EJ>� ;7HI� *J>;HM?I;�� ?J� M?BB� 8;� 9EDI?:;H;:� 7I� I;H?EKI� F>OI?97B

?D@KH?;I�KD:;H�F7H��

'EII�E<�KI;�E<�>7D:�EH�?D97F79?JO�E<�KIK7B�MEHA�?D�F7H���CKIJ�8;�F;HC7D;DJ

+7H���H;<;HI�JE�FH?D9?F7B�C;C8;HI�E<�J>;�8E:O�+7H���ED�J>;�EJ>;H�>7D:��9EL;HI�7DO�EJ>;H�C;C8;H�M>?9>

?I�DEJ�7�FH?D9?F7B�F7HJ�E<�J>;�8E:O�$D�J>?I�H;IF;9J��7�<HEDJ�JEEJ>�?I�9EDI?:;H;:�7I�7�C;C8;H�E<�J>;�8E:O�

EJ>;H�J>7D�7�FH?D9?F7B�C;C8;H

�;<EHC?JO��C;7DI�F>OI?97B�K=B?D;II��F;HC7D;DJ�7D:�:;<?D?J;�78DEHC7B?JO�)EJ�9KH78B;�8O�D7JKH7B�C;7DI

EH�8O�D7JKH;�$J�CKIJ�8;�9EDIF?9KEKI�7D:�L?I?8B;�/>KI��?<�J>;�I97H�?I�KIK7BBO�9EL;H;:�8O�7�:H;II��?J�MEKB:

DEJ�8;�9EDIF?9KEKI�7D:�L?I?8B;

/>;�BEII�E<���?D9?IEHI�?I�7�L?I?8B;�:;<EHC?JO�'EII�E<�ED;�?D9?IEH�?I�DEJ�#EM;L;H� BEII�E<�ED;�JEEJ>�M>?9>

?CF7?H;:�7FF;7H7D9;�?I�7�:;<EHC?JO

�;<EHC?JO�8O�BEII�E<�J;;J>�H;<;HI�JE�?D@KHO�M>?9>�97DDEJ�8;�?CF7?H;:�8O�J>;�79J?ED�E<�J>;�D7JKH;

'EII�E<�8EJ>�EKJ;H�;7HI�9EDIJ?JKJ;I�:;<EHC?JO�7D:�7BIE�BEII�E<�J>;�FEM;H�JE�>;7H�(;7DM>?B;��BEII�E<�J>;

BE8KB;�E<�J>;�;7H�?I�EDBO�7�:;<EHC?JO

'EII�E<�J>;�?D:;N�7D:�C?::B;�<?D=;HI�?I�;?J>;H�7�:;<EHC?JO�EH�BEII�E<�7�C;C8;H��DEJ�7�FH?D9?F7B�ED;�E< >?I

8E:O�EH�KI;�E<�J>;�I7C;

'EII�E<�J>;�FEM;H�JE�>;7H�?D�J>;�H?=>J�;7H�?I�9EDI?:;H;:�7I�C;H;BO�BEII�E<�KI;�E<�IEC;�EJ>;H�F7HJ�E<�J>;

8E:O

$<�J>;�?D@KHO�MEKB:�H;GK?H;�C;:?97B�7JJ;D:7D9;�<EH�CEH;�J>7D����:7OI��J>;�?BBD;II�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO

C7O 8;� 9EDI?:;H;:� 7I� B7IJ?D=�CEH;� J>7D� ��� :7OI� />;� <79J� J>7J� J>;H;�M7I�C;:?97B� 7JJ;D:7D9;� <EH� J>7J

F;H?E:�E<�J?C;�I>EMI�J>7J�J>;�?D@KH?;I�M;H;�DEJ�9KH;:�<EH�J>7J�B;D=J>�E<�J?C;

0D:;H�F7H����7BB�J>7J�?I�H;GK?H;:�?I�?BBD;II�EH�?D97F79?JO��DEJ�C;:?97B�7JJ;D:7D9;

$D�:;J;HC?D?D=� ?D97F79?JO�� J>;� ?D@KH;:�F7HJO�CKIJ�>7L;�7D�7LE97J?ED�7J� J>;� J?C;�E<� J>;� ?D@KHO�2EHA�

?D9BK:;I�IJK:?;I�EH�FH;F7H7J?ED�<EH�7�FHE<;II?ED

2>;D�J>;�97J;=EHO�E<�J>;�E<<;DI;�E<�I;H?EKI�F>OI?97B� ?D@KH?;I�:;F;D:I�ED�J>;�F;H?E:�E<�J>; ?BBD;II�EH

?D97F79?JO�<EH�B78EH��J>;H;�CKIJ�8;�;L?:;D9;�E<�J>;�B;D=J>�E<�J>7J�F;H?E:�*J>;HM?I;��J>;�E<<;DI;�M?BB�EDBO

8;�9EDI?:;H;:��7I�IB?=>J�F>OI?97B�?D@KH?;I

/>;H;� ?I�DE� ?D97F79?JO� ?<�J>;� ?D@KH;:�F7HJO�9EKB:�IJ?BB�;D=7=;�?D�>?I�MEHA�7BJ>EK=>�B;II ;<<;9J?L;BO�J>7D

8;<EH;

Page 130: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

=@D6D�E96�FD6 @7�2?J�DF49�>6>36C

� 364@>6D� :?42A24:E2E65� 7@C� E96�H@C<� :?�H9:4996�925�366?�923:EF2==J�6?82865

3 !?;FC65�A6CD@? L

� 364@>6D�567@C>65

=@D6D�2?J�@E96C�>6>36C�@7�9:D�3@5J

� =@D6D�E96�FD6�E96C6@7

� 364@>6D� :==� @C� :?42A24:E2E65� 7@C� E96A6C7@C>2?46� @7� E96� H@C<� :?� H9:49� 96� 925� 366?923:EF2==J�6?82865�:?�7@C�>@C6�E92?����52JD

4 !?;FC65� A6CD@?� 364@>6D� :==� @C� :?42A24:E2E65� 7@C=23@C�7@C�>@C6�E92?����52JD��

�095:5?@1>5:3� 5:6A>5;A??A.?@-:/1?�;>�.1B1>-31?���

2 '776?56C� :?7=:4E65� FA@? 2?@E96C� A6CD@?� 2?JD6C:@FD�A9JD:42=�:?;FCJ

3 !E�H2D�5@?6�<?@H:?8=J� 25>:?:DE6C:?8� E@�9:>�2?J:?;FC:@FD� DF3DE2?46D� @C� 36G6C286D� @C� 3J� E2<:?825G2?E286�@7�9:D�H62<?6DD�@7�>:?5�@7�4C65F=:EJ

4 6�925�?@�:?E6?E�E@�<:==

1??�?1>5;A?�<4E?5/-8�5:6A>51?��� 2 '776?565� A2CEJ� :D� :?42A24:E2E65� 7@C� =23@C� 7@C� ��52JD�@C�>@C6���� @C�?665D�>65:42=�2EE6?52?46�7@C�E96

� �8KJ�DEJ�CEH;�J>7D����:7OI

� ��HJ����

$J�?I�<HKIJH7J;:�CKH:;H�M>;D�J>;H;�?I�?DJ;DJ�JE�A?BB

�:C?D?IJ;H?D=�C;7DI�?DJHE:K9?D=�?DJE�J>;�8E:O�J>;�IK8IJ7D9;��J>KI�J>HEM?D=�E<�J>;�79?:�?D�J>;�<79;�?I

DEJ�9EDJ;CFB7J;:� �

�HJ����

�?H9KCIJ7D9;I�GK7B?<O?D=�J>;�E<<;DI;�

7 M>;D�J>;H;�?I�C7D?<;IJ�?DJ;DJ�JE�?DIKBJ�EH�E<<;D:�J>;�?D@KH;:�F;HIED

8 M>;D�J>;H;�7H;�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�7::?D=�?=DEC?DO�JE�J>;�E<<;DI;

9 M>;D�J>;�L?9J?C�?I�;?J>;H�J>;�E<<;D:;HYI�F7H;DJI��7I9;D:7DJI��=K7H:?7DI��9KH7JEHI EH�J;79>;HI

: M>;D� J>;� L?9J?C� ?I� 7� F;HIED� E<� H7DA� EH� F;HIED� ?D� 7KJ>EH?JO�� FHEL?:;:� J>;� 9H?C;� ?I� DEJ� :?H;9J

7II7KBJ

$J�<7BBI�KD:;H�J>?I�7HJ?9B;�;L;D�?<�J>;H;�M7I�DE�?D97F79?JO�8KJ�J>;�C;:?97B�JH;7JC;DJ�M7I�<EH� ��:7OI

Page 131: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

D2>6�A6C:@5�@7�E:>6

3 ,96�A9JD:42=�:?;FC:6D�>FDE�?@E�36�E9@D6�56D4C:365:?�E96�AC6465:?8�2CE:4=6D

'8534@�<4E?5/-8�5:6A>51? � 2 !?42A24:E2E65�E96 @776?565�A2CEJ�7@C�=23@C�7C@>����� 52JD� @C� C6BF:C65� >65:42=� 2EE6?52?46� 5FC:?8� E96D2>6�A6C:@5

3 /9:49� 5:5� ?@E� AC6G6?E� E96� @776?565� A2CEJ� 7C@>6?828:?8� :?� 9:D� 923:EF2=� H@C<� @C� H9:49� 5:5� ?@EC6BF:C6�>65:42=�2EE6?52?46���

4 !==�EC62E>6?E� @7� 2?@E96C� 3J� 5665�H:E9@FE� 42FD:?82?J�:?;FCJ���

� �8KJ�DEJ�CEH;�J>7D����:7OI

� ��HJ ���

� �;N��B79A;O;

� �;N�IB7FF?D=�8KJ�M?J>EKJ�97KI?D=�:?I>EDEH

Page 132: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

,� �9?4�)4:709.0�,2,49>?�*:809�,9/�?304=��347/=09��.?�:1�� ���

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

,96�4C:>6�@7�G:@=6?46�282:?DE�H@>6?�2?5�E96:C�49:=5C6?�:D�4@>>:EE65�E9C@F89�2?J@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

�2���2FD:?8�A9JD:42=�92C>�E@�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�

�3��,9C62E6?:?8�E@�42FD6�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�A9JD:42=�92C>�

�4���EE6>AE:?8�E@�42FD6�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�A9JD:42=�92C>�

�5��(=24:?8�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�:?�762C�@7�:>>:?6?E�A9JD:42=�92C>�

�6�� �EE6>AE:?8� E@� 4@>A6=� @C� 4@>A6==:?8� E96� H@>2?� @C� 96C� 49:=5� E@� 6?8286� :?4@?5F4E�H9:49�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�92D�E96�C:89E�E@�56D:DE�7C@>�@C�56D:DE�7C@>�4@?5F4EH9:49� E96� H@>2?� @C� 96C� 49:=5� 92D� E96� C:89E� E@� 6?8286� :?�� @C� 2EE6>AE:?8� E@� C6DEC:4E� @CC6DEC:4E:?8�E96�H@>2?�D�@C�96C�49:=5�D�7C665@>�@7�>@G6>6?E�@C�4@?5F4E�3J�7@C46�@C�E9C62E�@77@C46��A9JD:42=�@C�@E96C�92C>�@C� E9C62E�@7�A9JD:42=�@C�@E96C�92C>��@C� :?E:>:52E:@?�5:C64E65282:?DE�E96�H@>2?�@C�49:=5

,9:D�D92==�:?4=F56��3FE�?@E�=:>:E65�E@��E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�4@>>:EE65�H:E9�E96�AFCA@D6@C�67764E�@7�4@?EC@==:?8�@C�C6DEC:4E:?8�E96�H@>2?�D�@C�96C�49:=5�D�>@G6>6?E�@C�4@?5F4E�

����,9C62E6?:?8� E@�56AC:G6�@C� 24EF2==J�56AC:G:?8� E96�H@>2?�@C�96C� 49:=5�@74FDE@5J�E@�96C9:D�72>:=J�

� �� �6AC:G:?8� @C� E9C62E6?:?8� E@� 56AC:G6� E96� H@>2?� @C� 96C� 49:=5C6?� @77:?2?4:2=�DFAA@CE�=682==J�5F6�96C�@C�96C�72>:=J��@C�56=:36C2E6=J�AC@G:5:?8�E96�H@>2?�D49:=5C6?�:?DF77:4:6?E�7:?2?4:2=�DFAA@CE�

�����6AC:G:?8� @C� E9C62E6?:?8� E@� 56AC:G6� E96�H@>2?� @C� 96C� 49:=5� @7� 2� =682=C:89E�

���� (C6G6?E:?8� E96� H@>2?� :?� 6?828:?8� :?� 2?J� =68:E:>2E6� AC@76DD:@?�@44FA2E:@?�� 3FD:?6DD� @C� 24E:G:EJ� @C� 4@?EC@==:?8� E96� G:4E:>�D� @H?� >@?�6J� @CAC@A6CE:6D��@C�D@=6=J�4@?EC@==:?8�E96�4@?;F82=�@C�4@>>@?�>@?6J��@C�AC@A6CE:6D�

�7�� !?7=:4E:?8� @C� E9C62E6?:?8� E@� :?7=:4E� A9JD:42=� 92C>� @?� @?6D6=7� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @74@?EC@==:?8�96C�24E:@?D�@C�564:D:@?D�

� �-������

Page 133: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�8���2FD:?8�@C�2EE6>AE:?8�E@�42FD6�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�E@�6?8286� :?�2?J�D6IF2=24E:G:EJ�H9:49�5@6D�?@E�4@?DE:EFE6�C2A6��3J�7@C46�@C�E9C62E�@7�7@C46��A9JD:42=�92C>��@C�E9C@F89:?E:>:52E:@?�5:C64E65�282:?DE�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�@C�96C9:D�:>>65:2E6�72>:=J�

�9�� �?828:?8� :?� AFCA@D67F=�� <?@H:?8�� @C� C64<=6DD� 4@?5F4E�� A6CD@?2==J� @C� E9C@F892?@E96C�E92E 2=2C>D�@C�42FD6D�DF3DE2?E:2=�6>@E:@?2=�@C�ADJ49@=@8:42=�5:DEC6DD�E@�E96�H@>2?@C�96C�49:=5�,9:D�D92==�:?4=F56��3FE�?@E�36�=:>:E65�E@��E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

����+E2=<:?8�@C�7@==@H:?8�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�:?�AF3=:4�@C�AC:G2E6�A=246D�

� ��(66C:?8�:?�E96�H:?5@H�@C�=:?86C:?8�@FED:56�E96�C6D:56?46�@7�E96�H@>2?�@C96C�49:=5�

�����?E6C:?8�@C�C6>2:?:?8�:?�E96�5H6==:?8�@C�@?�E96�AC@A6CEJ�@7�E96�H@>2?�@C96C�49:=5�282:?DE�96C9:D�H:==�

���� �6DEC@J:?8� E96� AC@A6CEJ� 2?5� A6CD@?2=� 36=@?8:?8D� @C� :?7=:4E:?8� 92C>� E@2?:>2=D�@C�A6ED�@7�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5��2?5

�����?828:?8�:?�2?J�7@C>�@7�92C2DD>6?E�@C�G:@=6?46�

�:���2FD:?8�>6?E2=�@C�6>@E:@?2=�2?8F:D9��AF3=:4�C:5:4F=6�@C�9F>:=:2E:@?�E@�E96�H@>2?@C�96C�49:=5��:?4=F5:?8��3FE�?@E�=:>:E65�E@��C6A62E65�G6C32=�2?5�6>@E:@?2=�23FD6��2?5�56?:2=�@77:?2?4:2=�DFAA@CE�@C�4FDE@5J�@7�>:?@C�49:=5C6?�@7�2446DD�E@�E96�H@>2?�D�49:=549:=5C6?� �

-� �9?4��347/�#:=9:2=,;3D��,B� �

4���01494?4:9�:1�?0=8>

�9:=5 � A6CD@?� 36=@H� 6:89E66?� ����� J62CD� @7� 286� @C� @G6C�� 3FE� :DF?23=6� E@� 7F==J� E2<6� 42C6� @7� 9:>D6=796CD6=7� 7C@>� 23FD6�?68=64E�� 4CF6=EJ�� 6IA=@:E2E:@?�@C�5:D4C:>:?2E:@?�3642FD6�@7� 2A9JD:42=�@C�>6?E2=�5:D23:=:EJ�@C�4@?5:E:@?

�=D@�C676CD E@�

����2�A6CD@?�C682C5=6DD�@7�286�H9@�:D�AC6D6?E65��56A:4E65�@CA@CEC2J65�2D�2�49:=5�2D�567:?65�96C6:?��2?5

� ��4@>AFE6C�86?6C2E65��5:8:E2==J�@C�>2?F2==J�4C27E65�:>286D@C�8C2A9:4D�@7�2�A6CD@?�H9@�:D�C6AC6D6?E65�@C�H9@�:D�>256E@�2AA62C�E@�36�2�49:=5�2D�567:?65�96C6:?

���.;9��

�� -������

Page 134: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�9:=5 A@C?@8C2A9J�?J� C6AC6D6?E2E:@?�� H96E96C� G:DF2=�� 2F5:@�� @C� HC:EE6?4@>3:?2E:@?� E96C6@7�� 3J� 6=64EC@?:4�� >6492?:42=�� 5:8:E2=�@AE:42=��>28?6E:4� @C� 2?J� @E96C�>62?D�� @7� 49:=5� 6?82865� @C:?G@=G65�:?�C62=�@C�D:>F=2E65�6IA=:4:E�D6IF2=�24E:G:E:6D

�IA=:4:E�+6IF2=��4E:G:EJ !?4=F56D�24EF2=�@C�D:>F=2E65 �

�����D�E@�7@C>�

�:��D6IF2=�:?E6C4@FCD6�@C�=2D4:G:@FD�24E�:?4=F5:?8��3FE�?@E=:>:E65�E@��4@?E24E�:?G@=G:?8�86?:E2=�E@�86?:E2=��@C2=�E@�86?:E2=�2?2=�E@�86?:E2=��@C�@C2=�E@�2?2=��H96E96C�36EH66?�A6CD@?D�@7E96 D2>6�@C�@AA@D:E6�D6I�

� ��36DE:2=:EJ�

����>2DEFC32E:@?�

����D25:DE:4�@C�>2D@49:DE:4�23FD6�

���� =2D4:G:@FD� 6I9:3:E:@?� @7� E96� 86?:E2=D�� 3FEE@4<D�� 3C62DED�AF3:4�2C62�2?5@C�2?FD��@C

����FD6�@7�2?J�@3;64E�@C :?DECF>6?E�7@C�=2D4:G:@FD�24ED

!?E6C?6E 255C6DD �� H63D:E6�� 3F==6E:?� 3@2C5� D6CG:46�� :?E6C?6E� 492E� C@@>� @C?6HD� 8C@FA�� @C� 2?J� @E96C� :?E6C?6E� @C� D92C65� ?6EH@C<AC@E@4@=�255C6DD

!?E6C?6E�4276�@C�<:@D< �?�6DE23=:D9>6?E�E92E�@776CD�@C�AC@A@D6D�E@�@776C�D6CG:46D�E@E96�AF3=:4�7@C�E96�FD6�@7�:ED�4@>AFE6CD�@C�4@>AFE6C�DJDE6>7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7� 2446DD:?8� E96� :?E6C?6E�� 4@>AFE6C� 82>6D@C�C6=2E65�D6CG:46D

!?E6C?6E�4@?E6?E�9@DE � A6CD@?� H9@� 9@DED� @C� H9@� AC@A@D6D� E@� 9@DE� :?E6C?6E4@?E6?E�:?�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D

!?E6C?6E� D6CG:46� AC@G:56C�!+(�

� A6CD@?�@C� 6?E:EJ� E92E� DFAA=:6D� @C� AC@A@D6D� E@� DFAA=J�� 2?:?E6C?6E�42CC:286�D6CG:46�E@�E96�AF3=:4

�C@@>:?8 ,96�24E�@7�AC6A2C:?8�2�49:=5�@C�D@>6@?6�H9@�E96�@776?56C

Page 135: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

36=:6G6D� E@� 36� 2� 49:=5� 7@C� D6IF2=� 24E:G:EJ� @C� D6IF2=C6=2E:@?D9:A� 3J� 4@>>F?:42E:?8� 2?J� 7@C>� @7� 49:=5A@C?@8C2A9J� !E� :?4=F56D� @?=:?6� 6?E:46>6?E� @C� 6?E:46>6?EE9C@F89�2?J�@E96C�>62?D

$FC:?8 ��� ,96� 24E� @7� 4@>>F?:42E:?8�� 3J� >62?D� @7� 2� 4@>AFE6CDJDE6>��H:E9�2�49:=5�@C�D@>6@?6�H9@�E96�@776?56C�36=:6G6DE@�36�2�49:=5�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7 724:=:E2E:?8�E96�4@>>:DD:@?@7� D6IF2=� 24E:G:EJ� @C� AC@5F4E:@?� @7� 2?J� 7@C>� @7� 49:=5A@C?@8C2A9J

� ���6DE:2=:EJ

(2?56C:?8 ,96�24E�@7�@776C:?8��25G6CE:D:?8��AC@>@E:?8��C6AC6D6?E:?8�@C5:DEC:3FE:?8� E9C@F89� 2?J� >62?D� 2?J� >2E6C:2=� @C� AFCA@CE65>2E6C:2= E92E�:D�:?E6?565�E@�42FD6�2?@E96C�E@�36=:6G6�E92E�E96>2E6C:2=� @C� AFCA@CE65� >2E6C:2=� 4@?E2:?D� 2?J� 7@C>� @7� 49:=5A@C?@8C2A9J��C682C5=6DD�@7�E96�24EF2=�4@?E6?E�@7�E96�>2E6C:2=@C�AFCA@CE65�>2E6C:2=

(6CD@? �?J�?2EFC2=�@C�;FC:5:42=�6?E:EJ�

44��(97,B1@7 :=�;@94>3,-70�,.?>

�2�� ,@� 9:C6�� 6>A=@J�� FD6�� A6CDF256�� :?5F46� @C� 4@6C46� 2� 49:=5� E@� A6C7@C>� :?� E964C62E:@?�@C�AC@5F4E:@?�@7�2?J�7@C>�@7�49:=5�A@C?@8C2A9J�

�3��,@�AC@5F46��5:C64E��>2?F724EFC6�@C�4C62E6�2?J�7@C>�@7�49:=5�A@C?@8C2A9J�

�4��,@�AF3=:D9�@776C� EC2?D>:E�� D6==��5:DEC:3FE6��3C@2542DE��25G6CE:D6��AC@>@E6��6IA@CE@C�:>A@CE�2?J�7@C>�@7�49:=5�A@C?@8C2A9J�

�5�� ,@� A@DD6DD� 2?J� 7@C>� @7� 49:=5� A@C?@8C2A9J� H:E9� E96� :?E6?E� E@� D6==�� 5:DEC:3FE6�AF3=:D9�� @C� 3C@2542DE�� (C@G:565� ,92E� A@DD6DD:@?� @7� E9C66� ���� @C� >@C6� 2CE:4=6D� @7� 49:=5A@C?@8C2A9J�@7�E96�D2>6�7@C>�D92==�36�AC:>2�724:6�6G:56?46�@7�E96�:?E6?E�E@�D6==��5:DEC:3FE6�AF3=:D9�@C�3C@2542DE�

�6��,@�<?@H:?8=J��H:==7F==J�2?5�:?E6?E:@?2==J�AC@G:56�2�G6?F6�7@C�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7AC@9:3:E65�24ED�2D��3FE�?@E� =:>:E65 E@��56?D��AC:G2E6� C@@>D��4F3:4=6D��4:?6>2D��9@FD6D�@C� :?6DE23=:D9>6?ED�AFCA@CE:?8�E@�36�2�=68:E:>2E6�3FD:?6DD�

���.;9��

Page 136: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�7���@C�7:=>�5:DEC:3FE@CD�� E962E6CD�2?5�E6=64@>>F?:42E:@?�4@>A2?:6D��3J�E96>D6=G6D@C�:?�4@@A6C2E:@?�H:E9�@E96C�6?E:E:6D��E@�5:DEC:3FE6�2?J�7@C>�@7�49:=5�A@C?@8C2A9J�

�8�� �@C� 2� A2C6?E�� =682=� 8F2C5:2?� @C� A6CD@?� 92G:?8� 4FDE@5J� @C� 4@?EC@=� @7� 2� 49:=5� E@<?@H:?8=J�A6C>:E�E96�49:=5�E@�6?8286��A2CE:4:A2E6�@C�2DD:DE�:?�2?J�7@C>�@7�49:=5�A@C?@8C2A9J�

�9��,@�6?8286�:?�E96�=FC:?8�@C�8C@@>:?8�@7�2�49:=5�

�:� ,@�6?8286�:?�A2?56C:?8�@7�2?J�7@C>�@7�49:=5�A@C?@8C2A9J�

�;��,@�H:==7F==J�2446DD�2?J�7@C>�@7�49:=5�A@C?@8C2A9J�

�<�� ,@� 4@?DA:C6� E@� 4@>>:E� 2?J� @7� E96� AC@9:3:E65� 24ED� DE2E65� :?� E9:D� D64E:@?�@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�2?J�7@C>�@7�49:=5�A@C?@8C2A9J�D92==�36�4@>>:EE65�H96?�EH@�� ��@C>@C6� A6CD@?D� 4@>6� E@� 2?� 28C66>6?E� 4@?46C?:?8� E96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @7� 2?J� @7� E96� D2:5AC@9:3:E65�24ED�2?5�564:56�E@�4@>>:E�:E��2?5

�=��,@�A@DD6DD�2?J�7@C>�@7�49:=5�A@C?@8C2A9J� �

.� �9?4��,E492��,B� �

4���,E492

,���01494?4:9

�?� :?:E:2E:@?� C:E6 @C� AC24E:46� 2D� 2� AC6C6BF:D:E6� 7@C� 25>:DD:@?� :?E@�>6>36CD9:A� :?� 27C2E6C?:EJ�� D@C@C:EJ� @C� @C82?:K2E:@?� 3J� A=24:?8� E96� C64CF:E�� ?6@A9JE6� @C� 2AA=:42?E� :?� D@>66>32CC2DD:?8�@C�9F>:=:2E:?8� D:EF2E:@?D� DF49� 2D� 7@C4:?8�9:>� E@�5@�>6?:2=�� D:==J�� 7@@=:D9� 2?5@E96C� D:>:=2C� E2D<D� @C� 24E:G:E:6D� @C� @E96CH:D6� DF3;64E:?8� 9:>� E@� A9JD:42=� @C� ADJ49@=@8:42=DF776C:?8�@C�:?;FCJ� �

�-���77:B0/�494?4,?4:9�=4?0>

&@� 92K:?8� @C� :?:E:2E:@?� C:E6D� :?� 2?J� 7@C>� @C� >2??6C� 3J� 2� 7C2E6C?:EJ�� D@C@C:EJ� @C@C82?:K2E:@?�D92==�36�2==@H65�H:E9@FE AC:@C�HC:EE6?�?@E:46�E@�E96�D49@@=�2FE9@C:E:6D�@C�9625@7�@C82?:K2E:@?�D6G6?�����52JD�367@C6�E96�4@?5F4E�@7�DF49�:?:E:2E:@?�,96�HC:EE6?�?@E:46�D92==:?5:42E6� E96� A6C:@5� @7� E96� :?:E:2E:@?� 24E:G:E:6D� H9:49� D92==� ?@E� 6I4665� E9C66� ���� 52JD�� D92==:?4=F56� E96 ?2>6D�@7� E9@D6� E@�36� DF3;64E65� E@� DF49�24E:G:E:6D�� 2?5� D92==� 7FCE96C� 4@?E2:?�2?F?56CE2<:?8�E92E�?@�A9JD:42=�G:@=6?46�36�6>A=@J65�3J�2?J3@5J�5FC:?8�DF49�:?:E:2E:@?�C:E6D� �

���.;9��

���-������

���.;9�

���.;9��

Page 137: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

44��*3:�,=0�74,-70

,96� @77:46CD� 2?5�>6>36CD� @7� E96� 7C2E6C?:EJ�� D@C@C:EJ� @C @C82?:K2E:@?� H9@� 24EF2==JA2CE:4:A2E65�:?�E96�:?7=:4E:@?�@7�A9JD:42=�92C>�D92==�36�=:23=6�2D�AC:?4:A2=D� �

,96�@H?6C�@7�E96�A=246�H96C6�92K:?8�:D�4@?5F4E65�D92==�36�=:23=6�2D�2?�244@>A=:46�H96?�96�92D�24EF2=�<?@H=6586�@7�E96�92K:?8�4@?5F4E65�E96C6:?�3FE�72:=65�E@�E2<6�2?J�24E:@?E@�AC6G6?E�E96�D2>6�7C@>�@44FCC:?8�!7�E96�92K:?8�:D�96=5�:?�E96�9@>6�@7�@?6�@7�E96�@77:46CD@C� >6>36CD� @7� E96� 7C2E6C?:EJ�� 8C@FA�� @C� @C82?:K2E:@?�� E96� A2C6?ED� D92==� 36� 96=5� =:23=6� 2DAC:?4:A2=D�H96?� E96J�92G6� 24EF2=� <?@H=6586�@7� E96 92K:?8� 4@?5F4E65� E96C6:?�3FE� 72:=65� E@E2<6�2?J�24E:@?�E@�AC6G6?E�E96�D2>6�7C@>�@44FCC:?8

,96�D49@@=�2FE9@C:E:6D�:?4=F5:?8�724F=EJ�>6>36CD�H9@�4@?D6?E�E@�E96�92K:?8�@C�H9@92G6� 24EF2=� <?@H=6586� E96C6@7�� 3FE� 72:=65� E@� E2<6� 2?J� 24E:@?� E@� AC6G6?E� E96� D2>6 7C@>@44FCC:?8� D92==� 36� AF?:D965� 2D� 244@>A=:46D� 7@C� E96� 24ED� @7� 92K:?8� 4@>>:EE65� 3J� E96A6CA6EC2E@CD

,96� @77:46CD�� 7@C>6C� @77:46CD�� @C� 2=F>?:� @7� E96� @C82?:K2E:@?�� 8C@FA�� 7C2E6C?:EJ� @CD@C@C:EJ�H9@�24EF2==J�A=2??65�E96�92K:?8�2=E9@F89�?@E�AC6D6?E�H96?�E96 24ED�4@?DE:EFE:?8�E9692K:?8�H6C6�4@>>:EE65�D92==�36�=:23=6�2D�AC:?4:A2=D���7C2E6C?:EJ�@C�D@C@C:EJ�D�25G:D6C�H9@�:DAC6D6?E�H96?� E96�24ED�4@?DE:EFE:?8� E96�92K:?8�H6C6�4@>>:EE65�2?5�72:=65� E@� E2<6�24E:@?� E@AC6G6?E�E96�D2>6�7C@>�@44FCC:?8�D92==�36�=:23=6 2D�AC:?4:A2=

,96�AC6D6?46�@7�2?J�A6CD@?�5FC:?8�E96�92K:?8�:D 02)-!�&!#)% 6G:56?46�@7�A2CE:4:A2E:@?E96C6:?�2D�AC:?4:A2=�F?=6DD�96�AC6G6?E65�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�E96�24ED�AF?:D923=6�96C6:?

�?J� A6CD@?� 492C865� F?56C� E9:D� AC@G:D:@?� D92==� ?@E� 36� 6?E:E=65� E@� E96� >:E:82E:?84:C4F>DE2?46�E92E�E96C6�H2D�?@�:?E6?E:@?�E@�4@>>:E�D@�8C2G6�2�HC@?8

,9:D� D64E:@?� D92==� 2AA=J� E@� E96� AC6D:56?E�� >2?286C�� 5:C64E@C� @C� @E96C� C6DA@?D:3=6@77:46C�@7�2�4@CA@C2E:@?�6?82865�:?�92K:?8�2D�2�C6BF:C6>6?E�7@C�6>A=@J>6?E�:?�E96�>2??6CAC@G:565�96C6:?� �

444��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

��!7�562E9��C2A6��D@5@>J�@C�>FE:=2E:@?�C6DF=ED�E96C6�7C@>

�!7�:?�4@?D6BF6?46�@7�E96�92K:?8�E96�G:4E:>�D92==�364@>6�:?D2?6��:>364:=6��:>A@E6?E@C�3=:?5

��!7�:?�4@?D6BF6?46�@7�E96�92K:?8�E96�G:4E:>�D92==�92G6�=@DE E96�FD6�@7�DA6649�@C�E96A@H6C�E@�962C�@C�E@�D>6==��@C�D92==�92G6�=@DE�2?�6J6��2�92?5��2�7@@E��2?�2C>�@C�2�=68�@C�D92==92G6� =@DE� E96�FD6�@7� 2?J� DF49�>6>36C� D92==� 92G6�364@>6� :?42A24:E2E65� 7@C� E96� 24E:G:EJ�@CH@C<�:?�H9:49�96�H2D�923:EF2==J�6?82865

���.;9��

���$8?:

Page 138: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

��!7 :?�4@?D6BF6?46�@7�E96�92K:?8�E96�G:4E:>�D92==�364@>6�567@C>65�@C�D92==�92G6=@DE�2?J�@E96C�A2CE�@7�9:D�3@5J��@C�D92==�92G6� =@DE� E96�FD6�E96C6@7��@C�D92==�92G6�366?� :==�@C:?42A24:E2E65�7@C�E96�A6C7@C>2?46�@?�E96�24E:G:EJ�@C�H@C<�:?�H9:49�96�H2D�923:EF2==J 6?828657@C�2�A6C:@5�@7�>@C6�E92?�?:?6EJ������52JD

��!7�:?�4@?D6BF6?46�@7�E96�92K:?8�E96�G:4E:>�D92==�92G6�366?�:==�@C�:?42A24:E2E65�7@CE96�A6C7@C>2?46�@?�E96�24E:G:EJ�@C�H@C<�:?�H9:49�96�H2D�923:EF2==J�6?82865�7@C�2�A6C:@5�@7>@C6�E92?�E9:CEJ������52JD

��!7��:?�4@?D6BF6?46�@7�E96�92K:?8�E96�G:4E:>�D92==�92G6�366?�:==�@C�:?42A24:E2E65�7@CE96�A6C7@C>2?46�@?�E96�24E:G:EJ�@C�H@C<�:?�H9:49�96�H2D�923:EF2==J�6?82865�7@C�2�A6C:@5�@7E6?� �����52JD�@C�>@C6�� @C� E92E� E96� :?;FCJ� DFDE2:?65� D92==� C6BF:C6�>65:42=� 2DD:DE2?46� 7@C� E96D2>6�A6C:@5

��!7�:?�4@?D6BF6?46�@7�E96�92K:?8�E96�G:4E:>�D92==�92G6�366?�:==�@C�:?42A24:E2E65�7@CE96�A6C7@C>2?46�@?�E96�24E:G:EJ�@C�H@C<�:?�H9:49�96�H2D�923:EF2==J�6?82865�7C@>�@?6�����E@?:?6�����52JD��@C�E92E�E96�:?;FCJ�DFDE2:?65 D92==�C6BF:C6�>65:42=�2DD:DE2?46�7@C�E96�D2>6�A6C:@5

� !7� :?�4@?D6BF6?46�@7� E96�92K:?8� E96�G:4E:>�DFDE2:?65�A9JD:42=� :?;FC:6D�H9:49�5@?@E� AC6G6?E� 9:>� 7C@>� 6?828:?8� :?� 9:D� 923:EF2=� 24E:G:EJ� @C� H@C<� ?@C� C6BF:C6� >65:42=2EE6?52?46

,96� C6DA@?D:3=6� @77:4:2=D� @7� E96� D49@@=� @C� @7� E96� A@=:46�� >:=:E2CJ� @C� 4:E:K6?�D� 2C>JEC2:?:?8�@C82?:K2E:@?��>2J�:>A@D6�E96�2AAC@AC:2E6�25>:?:DEC2E:G6�D2?4E:@?D�@?�E96�A6CD@?�@CE96� A6CD@?D� 492C865� F?56C� E9:D� AC@G:D:@?� 6G6?� 367@C6� E96:C� 4@?G:4E:@?� ,96� >2I:>F>A6?2=EJ�96C6:?�AC@G:565�D92==�36�:>A@D65�:?�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�:?DE2?46D�

�2��H96?� E96� C64CF:E>6?E� :D� 244@>A2?:65�3J� 7@C46��G:@=6?46�� E9C62E�� :?E:>:52E:@?�@C5646:E�@?�E96�A6CD@?�@7�E96�C64CF:E�H9@�C67FD6D�E@�;@:?�

�3�� H96?� E96� C64CF:E�� ?6@A9JE6� @C� 2AA=:42?E� :?:E:2==J 4@?D6?ED� E@� ;@:?� 3FE� FA@?=62C?:?8�E92E�92K:?8�H:==�36�4@>>:EE65�@?�9:D�A6CD@?��:D�AC6G6?E65�7C@>�BF:EE:?8�

�4��H96?� E96� C64CF:E�� ?6@A9JE6� @C� 2AA=:42?E� 92G:?8� F?56C8@?6� 92K:?8� :D� AC6G6?E657C@>�C6A@CE:?8�E96�F?=2H7F=�24E�E@�9:D�A2C6?ED�@C�8F2C5:2?D��E@�E96�AC@A6C�D49@@=�2FE9@C:E:6D�@C�E@�E96�A@=:46�2FE9@C:E:6D��E9C@F89�7@C46��G:@=6?46��E9C62E�@C�:?E:>:52E:@?�

�5��H96?�E96�92K:?8�:D�4@>>:EE65�@FED:56�@7�E96�D49@@=�@C�:?DE:EFE:@?��@C

�6��H96? E96�G:4E:>�:D�36=@H�EH6=G6��� ��J62CD�@7�286�2E�E96�E:>6�@7�E96�92K:?8� �

���$8?:

Page 139: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

/� &;0.4,7�#=:?0.?4:9�:1��347/=09��2,49>?��347/��-@>0���C;7:4?,?4:9��,9/

�4>.=4849,?4:9��.?���

4���:A0=,20

+A64:2=�AC@E64E:@?�E@�49:=5C6?��� 7C@>�2==�7@C>D�@7�23FD6��?68=64E��4CF6=EJ�6IA=@:E2E:@?2?5�5:D4C:>:?2E:@?�2?5�@E96C�4@?5:E:@?D��AC6;F5:4:2= E@ E96:C�56G6=@A>6?E��AC@G:56�D2?4E:@?D7@C� E96:C� 4@>>:DD:@?�2?5�42CCJ�@FE� 2�AC@8C2>�7@C�AC6G6?E:@?�2?5�56E6CC6?46�@7� 2?5�4C:D:D:?E6CG6?E:@?�:?�D:EF2E:@?D�@7 49:=5�23FD6�� ��6IA=@:E2E:@?�2?5�5:D4C:>:?2E:@?���

44���347/�;=:>?4?@?4:9��;@94>3,-70�,.?>

�9:=5C6?��H96E96C�>2=6�@C�76>2=6��H9@�7@C�>@?6J��AC@7:E��@C�2?J�@E96C�4@?D:56C2E:@?@C� 5F6� E@� E96� 4@6C4:@?� @C� :?7=F6?46� @7� 2?J� 25F=E�� DJ?5:42E6� @C� 8C@FA�� :?5F=86� :?� D6IF2=:?E6C4@FCD6�@C� =2D4:G:@FD� 4@?5F4E�� 2C6�566>65� E@�36� 49:=5C6?� 6IA=@:E65� :?�AC@DE:EFE:@?� 2?5@E96C�D6IF2=�23FD6

,96�A6?2=EJ�@7� C64=FD:@?�E6>A@C2=� :?� :ED�>65:F>�A6C:@5� E@ 2%#,53)/.�0%20%45! D92==�36:>A@D65�FA@?�E96�7@==@H:?8�

�2�� ,9@D6�H9@� 6?8286� :?� @C AC@>@E6�� 724:=:E2E6� @C� :?5F46� 49:=5� AC@DE:EFE:@?�H9:49:?4=F56��3FE�2C6�?@E�=:>:E65�E@��E96�7@==@H:?8�

�����4E:?8�2D�2�AC@4FC6C�@7�2�49:=5�AC@DE:EFE6�

� ��!?5F4:?8�2�A6CD@?�E@�36�2�4=:6?E�@7�2�49:=5�AC@DE:EFE6�3J�>62?D�@7�HC:EE6?@C�@C2=�25G6CE:D6>6?ED�@C @E96C�D:>:=2C�>62?D�

���� ,2<:?8� 25G2?E286� @7� :?7=F6?46� @C� C6=2E:@?D9:A� E@� AC@4FC6� 2� 49:=5� 2DAC@DE:EFE6�

���� ,9C62E6?:?8� @C� FD:?8� G:@=6?46� E@H2C5D� 2� 49:=5� E@� 6?8286� 9:>� 2D� 2AC@DE:EFE6��@C

���-���� ���7I�7C;D:;:

�� H;<;HI� JE�F;HIED�8;BEM�;?=>J;;D�� ���O;7HI�E<�7=;�EH� J>EI;�EL;H�8KJ�7H;�KD78B;�JE� <KBBO� J7A;�97H;�E<

J>;CI;BL;I�EH�FHEJ;9J�J>;CI;BL;I�<HEC�78KI;��D;=B;9J��9HK;BJO��;NFBE?J7J?ED�EH�:?I9H?C?D7J?ED�8;97KI;�E<�7

F>OI?97B�EH�C;DJ7B�:?I78?B?JO�EH�9ED:?J?ED����

�>?B:�78KI;��H;<;HI�JE�J>;�C7BJH;7JC;DJ��M>;J>;H�>78?JK7B�EH�DEJ��E<�J>;�9>?B:�M>?9>� ?D9BK:;I�7DO�E<

J>;�<EBBEM?D=�

� ��+IO9>EBE=?97B�7D:�F>OI?97B�78KI;��D;=B;9J��9HK;BJO��I;NK7B�78KI;�7D:�;CEJ?ED7B�C7BJH;7JC;DJ�

�����DO�79J�8O�:;;:I�EH�MEH:I�M>?9>�:;87I;I��:;=H7:;I�EH�:;C;7DI�J>;�?DJH?DI?9�MEHJ>�7D:�:?=D?JO�E<

7�9>?B:�7I�7�>KC7D�8;?D=�

����0DH;7IED78B;�:;FH?L7J?ED�E<�>?I�87I?9�D;;:I�<EH�IKHL?L7B��IK9>�7I�<EE:�7D:�I>;BJ;H��EH

����!7?BKH;�JE�?CC;:?7J;BO�=?L;�C;:?97B�JH;7JC;DJ�JE�7D�?D@KH;:�9>?B:�H;IKBJ?D=�?D�I;H?EKI�?CF7?HC;DJ�E<

>?I�=HEMJ>�7D:�:;L;BEFC;DJ�EH�?D�>?I�F;HC7D;DJ�?D97F79?JO�EH�:;7J>���

.;9��

Page 140: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

���� �:G:?8� >@?6E2CJ� 4@?D:56C2E:@?� 8@@5D� @C� @E96C� A64F?:2CJ� 36?67:E E@� 249:=5�H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�6?8286�DF49�49:=5�:?�AC@DE:EFE:@?

�3�� ,9@D6�H9@� 4@>>:E� E96� 24E� @7� D6IF2=� :?E6C4@FCD6� @7� =2D4:G:@FD� 4@?5F4E� H:E9� 249:=5�6IA=@:E65�:?�AC@DE:EFE:@?�@C DF3;64E�E@�@E96C�D6IF2=�23FD6���� 2?5

�4��,9@D6�H9@ 56C:G6�AC@7:E�@C�25G2?E286�E96C67C@>��H96E96C�2D�>2?286C�@C�@H?6C@7� E96�6DE23=:D9>6?E�H96C6� E96�AC@DE:EFE:@?� E2<6D�A=246��@C�@7� E96�D2F?2��5:D4@��32C�� C6D@CE�A=246�@7�6?E6CE2:?>6?E�@C�6DE23=:D9>6?E�D6CG:?8�2D�2�4@G6C�@C�H9:49�6?8286D�:?�AC@DE:EFE:@?:? 255:E:@?�E@�E96�24E:G:EJ�7@C�H9:49�E96�=:46?D6�92D�366?�:DDF65�E@�D2:5�6DE23=:D9>6?E���

444���347/�?=,114.6492��;@94>3,-70�,.?>

�?J�A6CD@?�H9@�D92==�6?8286�:?�EC25:?8�2?5�562=:?8�H:E9�49:=5C6?�:?4=F5:?8��3FE�?@E=:>:E65�E@��E96�24E�@7�3FJ:?8�2?5�D6==:?8�@7 2�49:=5�7@C�>@?6J��@C�7@C�2?J�@E96C�4@?D:56C2E:@?�@C�32CE6C��D92==�DF776C�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7 2%#,53)/.�4%-0/2!, E@ 2%#,53)/.�0%20%45!�,96�A6?2=EJ�D92==�36:>A@D65�:?�:ED�>2I:>F>�A6C:@5�H96?�E96�G:4E:>�:D�F?56C�EH6=G6��� ��J62CD�@7�286���

���2>;D�J>;�L?9J?C�?I�KD:;H�JM;BL;�� ���O;7HI�E<�7=;��J>;�F;HF;JH7JEHI�I>7BB�8;�FHEI;9KJ;:�KD:;H��HJ?9B;

�����F7H7=H7F>����<EH�H7F; 7D:��HJ?9B;�����E<��9J�)E��� ���7I�7C;D:;:��J>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:;��<EH�H7F;

EH�B7I9?L?EKI�9ED:K9J��7I�J>;�97I;�C7O�8;�/>;�F;D7BJO�<EH�B7I9?L?EKI�9ED:K9J�M>;D�J>;�L?9J?C�?I�KD:;H

JM;BL;�� ���O;7HI�E<�7=;�I>7BB�8;�H;9BKI?ED�J;CFEH7B�?D�?JI�C;:?KC�F;H?E:���

.;9�����

.;9��

Page 141: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

0� �@A09470 �@>?4.0� ,9/�*071,=0� �.?� :1� ������ ,7>:� =010=� ?:� �347/� ,9/

+:@?3�*071,=0��:/0���

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

!?�E96�4@?5F4E�@7�E96�AC@4665:?8D�368:??:?8�7C@>�E96�:?:E:2=�4@?E24E�H:E9�E96�49:=5�E96� 4@>A6E6?E� 2FE9@C:E:6D� >FDE� C67C2:?� 7C@>� 3C2?5:?8� @C� =236=:?8 49:=5C6?� 2D� J@F?84C:>:?2=D�� ;FG6?:=6� 56=:?BF6?ED�� AC@DE:EFE6D� @C� 2EE249:?8� E@� E96>� :?� 2?J� >2??6C� 2?J� @E96C56C@82E@CJ� ?2>6D� $:<6H:D6�� ?@� 5:D4C:>:?2E@CJ� C6>2C<D� 2?5� AC24E:46D� D92==� 36� 2==@H65A2CE:4F=2C=J�H:E9�C6DA64E�E@�E96�49:=5�D�4=2DD�@C�6E9?:4�@C:8:?���

,96� 7@==@H:?8� 2?5� 2?J� @E96C� D:>:=2C� 24ED� D92==� 36� 4@?D:56C65� AC6;F5:4:2=� 2?556EC:>6?E2=� E@� E96�ADJ49@=@8:42=��6>@E:@?2=�� D@4:2=��DA:C:EF2=��>@C2=�2?5�A9JD:42=�962=E9�2?5H6==�36:?8�@7�E96�49:=5�:?�4@?7=:4E�H:E9�E96�=2H�2?5�E96C67@C6��AC@9:3:E65�

� �>A=@J>6?E�@7�E9C62ED�@7�H92E6G6C�<:?5�2?5�?2EFC6�

�>A=@J>6?E�@7�23FD:G6��4@6C4:G6�2?5�AF?:E:G6�>62DFC6D�DF49�2D�4FCD:?8��362E:?8�DEC:AA:?8��2?5�D@=:E2CJ�4@?7:?6>6?E�

� �>A=@J>6?E� @7� 568C25:?8�� :?9F>2?� 6?5� 4CF6=� 7@C>D� @7� AF?:D9>6?E� DF49� 2DD92G:?8�E96�9625D��A@FC:?8�:CC:E2E:?8��4@CC@D:G6�@C�92C>7F=�DF3DE2?46D�@G6C�E96�3@5J�@7�E9649:=5� :?� 4@?7=:4E�H:E9� E96� =2H��@C� 7@C4:?8�9:>96C� E@�H2=<� 2C@F?5� E96� 4@>>F?:EJ�H62C:?8D:8?D�H9:49�6>32CC2DD��9F>:=:2E6��2?5�568C256�9:D96C�A6CD@?2=:EJ�2?5�5:8?:EJ��2?5

� �@>A6==:?8�E96�49:=5�E@�A6C7@C>�:?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56�:?�2?J�2?5�2==�7@C>D�F?56C2?J�2?5�2==�:?DE2?46D���

�C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ�D92==�2EE249�E@�2?J�A2C6?E�H9@�

���@?462=D�@C�232?5@?D�E96�49:=5�H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�>2<6�DF49�49:=5�=@D6�9:D�4:G:=�DE2EFD

��32?5@?D E96�49:=5�F?56C�DF49�4:C4F>DE2?46D�2D�E@�56AC:G6�9:>�@7�E96�=@G6��42C62?5�AC@E64E:@?�96�?665D

��+6==D�@C�232?5@?D�E96�49:=5�E@�2?@E96C�A6CD@?�7@C�G2=F23=6�4@?D:56C2E:@?

��&68=64ED�E96�49:=5�3J�?@E�8:G:?8�9:>�E96�65F42E:@?�H9:49�E96�72>:=J�D�DE2E:@?�:?�=:762?5�7:?2?4:2=�4@?5:E:@?D�A6C>:E

�� �2:=D� @C� C67FD6D�� H:E9@FE� ;FDE:7:23=6� 8C@F?5D�� E@� 6?C@==� E96� 49:=5� 2D� C6BF:C65� 3J�CE:4=6��

���-������

���+�������7I�7C;D:;:

���.;9�����-������

���.;9 ����+&�

Page 142: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

���2FD6D��232E6D��@C�A6C>:ED�E96�ECF2?4J��� @7�E96�49:=5�7C@>�E96�D49@@=�H96C6�96�:D6?C@==65

��!E�D92==�36�E96�5FEJ�@7�E96�E62496C�:?�492C86�E@�C6A@CE�E@�E96�A2C6?ED�E96�23D6?46D@7�E96�49:=5�E96�>@>6?E�E96D6�6I4665�7:G6 ��� D49@@=52JD

�� !>AC@A6C=J� 6IA=@:ED� E96� 49:=5� 3J� FD:?8� 9:>�� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J�� DF49� 2D� 7@CAFCA@D6D�@7�3688:?8�2?5�@E96C�24ED�H9:49�2C6�:?:>:42=�E@�9:D�:?E6C6DE�2?5�H6=72C6

��!?7=:4ED�4CF6=�2?5�F?FDF2=�AF?:D9>6?E�FA@?�E96�49:=5�@C�56=:36C2E6=J�DF3;64ED�9:>E@�:?5:8?2E:@?�2?5�@E96C�6I46DD:G6 492DE:D6>6?E�E92E�6>32CC2DD6D�@C�9F>:=:2E6D 9:>

����2FD6D�@C�6?4@FC286D�E96�49:=5�E@�=625�2?�:>>@C2=�@C�5:DD@=FE6�=:76

���(6C>:ED� E96�49:=5� E@�A@DD6DD��92?5=6�@C�42CCJ�2�5625=J�H62A@?�� C682C5=6DD�@7� :ED@H?6CD9:A

� ��==@HD�@C�C6BF:C6D�E96�49:=5�E@�5C:G6�H:E9@FE�2�=:46?D6�@C�H:E9�2�=:46?D6�H9:49�E96A2C6?E� <?@HD� E@� 92G6� 366?� :==682==J� AC@4FC65� !7� E96� >@E@C� G69:4=6� 5C:G6?� 3J� E96� 49:=536=@?8D� E@� E96� A2C6?E��� :E� D92==� 36� AC6DF>65� E92E� 96� A6C>:EE65� @C� @C56C65� E96� 49:=5� E@5C:G6���

�� A6CD@?� H96E96C� E96� A2C6?E� @C� 8F2C5:2?� @7� E96� 49:=5� @C� ?@E�� H9@� <?@H:?8=J� @CH:=7F==J�

���:5D��42FD6D� 236ED�@C�4@??:G6D�H:E9�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�3J�2�49:=5�@7�2�56=:?BF6?4J�@C

��@6D�2?J�24E�AC@5F4:?8��AC@>@E:?8��@C�4@?EC:3FE:?8�E@�2�49:=5�D�36:?8�@C 364@>:?82�;FG6?:=6�56=:?BF6?E���

1� �@8,9�&0.@=4?D��.?�:1������

4� #@94>3,-70�,.?>�:1�?0==:=4>8���

44� *3:�,=0�74,-70���

�� �8I;D9;�M?J>EKJ�97KI;�<EH�CEH;�J>7D�JM;DJO ���� I9>EEB:7OI��DEJ�D;9;II7H?BO�9EDI;9KJ?L;

���$D9BK:;�J>;�=K7H:?7D�7D:�J>;�>;7:�E<�J>;�?DIJ?JKJ?ED�EH�<EIJ;H�>EC; M>?9>�>7I�9KIJE:O�E<�J>;�9>?B:

����HJ�����+�����

����HJ������?:

������������

���IKFH7

���$8?:

Page 143: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

����>591?��3-5:?@�$1>?;:-8 5.1>@E�-:0�'1/A>5@E

�>591? �=6>6?ED

�50:-<<5:3� -:0� ?1>5;A?� 58813-801@1:@5;:���

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AC:G2E6�:?5:G:5F2=

3 6�<:5?2AD�@C�56E2:?D� 2?@E96C��@C� :?�2?J�@E96C>2??6C�56AC:G6D�E96�=2EE6C�@7�9:D�=:36CEJ

4 ,96� 24E� @7� 56E6?E:@?� @C� <:5?2AA:?8� >FDE� 36:==682=

5 !?� E96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @7� E96� @776?D6�� 2?J� @7� E967@==@H:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46D�2C6�AC6D6?E����

� #:5?2AA:?856E6?E:@?� =2DED�7@C�>@C6�E92?��52JD

!E�:D 4@>>:EE65�D:>F=2E:?8�AF3=:4�2FE9@C:EJ

� �?J� D6C:@FD� A9JD:42=� :?;FC:6D� 2C6� :?7=:4E65FA@?�E96�A6CD@?�<:5?2AA65�@C�56E2:?65�@C�E9C62EDE@�<:==�9:>�2C6�>256��@C

� E92E� E96� A6CD@?� <:5?2AA65� @C� 56E2:?65� :D� 2>:?@C���� 76>2=6�@C�2�AF3=:4�@77:46C

'8534@�58813-8�01@1:@5;:��� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AC:G2E6�A6CD@?

3 6� <:5?2AD� @C� 56E2:?D� 2?@E96C� @C� :?� 2?J� @E96C>2??6C� 56AC:G6D� 9:>� @7� 9:D� =:36CEJ� � 7FC?:D965A=246�7@C�E96�A6CA6EF2E:@?�@7�E96�4C:>6

4 ,96� 24E� @7� 56E6?E:@?� @C� <:5?2AA:?8� >FDE� 36:==682=

����HJ����

���8;9EC;I�I;H?EKI

���;N9;FJ�?<�F7H;DJ�?I�J>;�E<<;D:;H

�� �HJ����

+H?L?B;=;:�C?J?=7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�

$<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�

7 LEBKDJ7H?BO H;B;7I;I� J>;� F;HIED� IE� A?:D7FF;:� EH� :;J7?D;:� M?J>?D� �� :7OI� <HEC� J>;

9ECC;D9;C;DJ�E<�J>;�:;J;DJ?ED

8 M?J>EKJ�>7L?D=�7JJ7?D;:�J>;�FKHFEI;�?DJ;D:;:�7D:

9 8;<EH;�J>;�?DIJ?JKJ?ED�E<�9H?C?D7B�FHE9;;:?D=I�7=7?DIJ�>?C

Page 144: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

5 ,96� 4C:>6� :D� 4@>>:EE65�H:E9@FE� E96� 2EE6?52?E@7� 2?J� @7� E96� 4:C4F>DE2?46D� 6?F>6C2E65� :?� �CE ����

):8-C2A8�->>1?@��� 2 '776?56C�2CC6DED�@C�56E2:?D�2?@E96C�A6CD@?

3 ,96�AFCA@D6�@7�E96�@776?56C�:D�E@�56=:G6C�9:>�E@E96�AC@A6C�2FE9@C:E:6D

4 ,96�2CC6DE @C�56E6?E:@?�:D�?@E�2FE9@C:K65�3J�=2H@C�E96C6�:D ?@�C62D@?23=6�8C@F?5�E96C67@C

�50:-<<5:3�-:0�2-58A>1�@;�>1@A>:�-95:;>���

2 '776?56C� :D� 6?ECFDE65� H:E9� E96� 4FDE@5J� @7� 2>:?@C�A6CD@?���

3 6�56=:36C2E6=J�72:=D�E@�C6DE@C6 E96�D2:5�>:?@C�E@9:D�A2C6?ED

�:0A/5:3�-�95:;>� @;�-.-:0;:�45?4;91���

2 ,96�>:?@C��� :D�=:G:?8�:?�E96�9@>6�@7�9:D�A2C6?ED@C� 8F2C5:2?D� @C� E96� A6CD@?� 6?ECFDE65� H:E9� 9:D4FDE@5J�

3 '776?56C� :?5F46D� 2� >:?@C� E@� 232?5@?� DF499@>6

'8-B1>E��� 2 '776?56C� AFC492D6D�� D6==D�� <:5?2AD� @C� 56E2:?D� 2

���IKFH7

����HJ����

*<<;D:;H�?I�7DO�F;HIED��IE�;?J>;H�7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�EH�FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B

-;<;HI�JE�M7HH7DJB;II�7HH;IJI

$D��HJ� ����J>;�:;J;DJ?ED�?I�<EH�IEC;�B;=7B�=HEKD:�M>?B;�>;H;��J>;�:;J;DJ?ED�?I�DEJ�7KJ>EH?P;:�8O�B7M

$D��HJ� ����J>;�9H?C;�F;HJ7?DI�JE�<7?BKH;�JE�:;B?L;H�J>;�F;HIED�JE�J>;�FHEF;H�@K:?9?7B�7KJ>EH?JO�M?J>?D�J>;

FH;I9H?8;:�F;H?E:�M>?B;�>;H;��J>;�7HH;IJ�?I�DEJ�7KJ>EH?P;:�8O�B7M���

�HJ�������

M>;J>;H�EL;H�EH�KD:;H���8KJ�B;II�J>7D� ��OHI�EB:���

�HJ���

$D:K9;C;DJ�CKIJ�8;�79JK7B��9ECC?JJ;:�M?J>�9H?C?D7B�?DJ;DJ�7D:�:;J;HC?D;:�8O�7�M?BB�JE�97KI;�:7C7=;

(?DEH�I>EKB:�DEJ�B;7L;�>?I�>EC;�E<�>?I�EMD�<H;;�M?BB

(?J?=7J?D=�?<�8O�<7J>;H�EH�CEJ>;H���

M>;J>;H�EL;H�EH�KD:;H�����

�HJ����

,K7B?<O?D=� 9?H9KCIJ7D9; W ?<� J>;� FKHFEI;� E<� J>;� E<<;D:;H� ?I� JE� 7II?=D� J>;� E<<;D:;:� F7HJO� JE� IEC;

?CCEH7B�JH7<<?9��FHEIJ?JKJ?ED���J>;�F;D7BJO�?I�>?=>;H

Page 145: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

9F>2?�36:?8

3 ,96�AFCA@D6�@7�E96�@776?56C� :D� E@�6?D=2G6�DF499F>2?�36:?8

�D<8;5@5;:�;2�/4580�8-.;> �� 2 '776?56C�C6E2:?D�2�>:?@C�:?�9:D�D6CG:46

3 !E�:D�282:?DE�E96�H:==�@7�E96�>:?@C

4 !E�:D�F?56C�E96�AC6E6IE�@7�C6:>3FCD:?8�9:>D6=7�@72� 563E� :?4FCC65� 3J� 2?� 2D46?52?E�� 8F2C5:2?� @CA6CD@?�6?ECFDE65 H:E9�E96�4FDE@5J�@7�DF49�>:?@C

'1>B5/1?� >1:01>10� A:01>/;9<A8?5;:�5:�<-E91:@�;2�01.@ �

2 '776?56C� 4@>A6=D� 2� 563E@C� E@� H@C<� 7@C� 9:>�6:E96C�2D�9@FD69@=5�D6CG2?E�@C�72C>�=23@C6C

3 !E�:D�282:?DE�E96�563E@CND�H:==

4 ,96� AFCA@D6� :D� E@� C6BF:C6� @C 6?7@C46� E96A2J>6?E�@7�2�563E

�.-:0;:91:@� ;2� <1>?;:� 5:0-:31>�-:0�-.-:0;:91:@�;2�;:1H?;C:�B5/@59���

� �2:=:?8�E@�C6?56C�2DD:DE2?46 E@2?J�A6CD@?�H9@>�E96�@776?56C�7:?5D:?�2?� :?923:E65�A=246�H@F?565�@C� :?52?86C�@7�5J:?8��H96?�96�42?�C6?56CDF49�2DD:DE2?46�H:E9@FE�56EC:>6?E�E@9:>D6=7�� F?=6DD� DF49� @>:DD:@?� D92==4@?DE:EFE6�2�>@C6�D6C:@FD�@776?D6

� �2:=:?8� E@� 96=A� @C� C6?56C2DD:DE2?46� E@� 2?@E96C� H9@>� E96@776?56C� 92D� 244:56?E2==J� H@F?565@C�:?;FC65

�� � �2:=:?8� E@� 56=:G6C� 2� 49:=5�

2 (=246�:D�?@E�:?923:E65

3 ,96�244FD65�7@F?5�E96C6�2�A6CD@?�H@F?565�@C:?�52?86C�@7�5J:?8

4� ,96� 244FD65� 42?� C6?56C� 2DD:DE2?46� H:E9@FE56EC:>6?E�E@�9:>D6=7

5 ,96�244FD65�72:=D�E@�C6?56C�2DD:DE2?46

����HJ����

����HJ����

�� �HJ����

Page 146: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

F?56C� �� H9@>� E96� @776?56C� 92D7@F?5� 232?5@?65�� E@� E96� 2FE9@C:E:6D@C�E@�9:D�72>:=J��@C�3J�72:=:?8�E@�E2<69:>�E@�2�D276�A=246

�.-:0;:5:3�-�95:;> �� 2 '776?56C�92D�E96�4FDE@5J @7�2�49:=5

3 ,96�49:=5�:D�F?56C�D6G6?�����J62CD�@7�286

4� 6�232?5@?D�DF49�49:=5

5 6�92D�?@�:?E6?E�E@�<:==�E96�49:=5�H96?�E96�=2EE6C:D�232?5@?65

�.-:0;:91:@�;2�95:;>�.E�<1>?;:1:@>A?@10� C5@4� 45?� /A?@;0E�5:05221>1:/1�;2�<->1:@?���

���6=:G6C:?8�2�>:?@C�E@�2�AF3=:4:?DE:EFE:@?� @C� @E96C� A6CD@?D� H@4@?D6?E� @7� E96� @?6� H9@� 6?ECFDE65DF49� >:?@C� E@� E96� 42C6� @7� E96@776?56C� @C�� :?� E96� 23D6?46� @7� E92E@?6�� H:E9@FE� E96� 4@?D6?E� @7� E96AC@A6C�2FE9@C:E:6D

� &68=64E:?8� 9:D��� 49:=5C6?� 3J� ?@E8:G:?8� E96>� 65F42E:@?� H9:49� E96:CDE2E:@?� :?� =:76� C6BF:C6D� 2?5� 7:?2?4:2=4@?5:E:@?�A6C>:ED

2 '776?56C� 92D� 492C865� @7� E96� C62C:?8� @C65F42E:@?�@7�2�>:?@C

3 6�56=:G6CD�D2:5�>:?@C�E@�2�AF3=:4�:?DE:EFE:@?�@C@E96C�A6CD@?D

4 ,96 @?6� H9@� 6?ECFDE65� DF49� 49:=5� E@� E96@776?56C� 92D� ?@E� 4@?D6?E65� E@� DF49� 24E�� @C� :7� E96@?6� H9@� 6?ECFDE65� DF49� 49:=5� E@� E96� @776?56C� :D23D6?E�� E96�AC@A6C�2FE9@C:E:6D�92G6�?@E�4@?D6?E65E@�:E

2 '776?56C�:D�2�A2C6?E

3 6� ?68=64ED� 9:D� 49:=5C6?� 3J� ?@E� 8:G:?8� E96>65F42E:@?

4 :D� DE2E:@?� :?� =:76� C6BF:C6D� DF49� 65F42E:@?� 2?59:D�7:?2?4:2=�4@?5:E:@?�A6C>:ED�:E

����HJ����

�EDI9?EKI��:;B?8;H7J;��F;HC7D;DJ��KDB;II�FKD?I>78B;�8O�7�CEH;�I;H?EKI E<<;DI;

,K7B?<O?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�

7 M>;D�J>;�:;7J>�E<�J>;�C?DEH�H;IKBJ;:�<HEC�IK9>�787D:EDC;DJ

8 ?<�J>;�B?<;�E<�J>;�C?DEH�M7I�?D�:7D=;H�8;97KI;�E<�J>;�787D:EDC;DJ���

�HJ�������

E<<;D:;H

Page 147: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�D<8;5@-@5;:�;2�95:;>?���

���2FD:?8�2?J�3@J�@C�8:C=�F?56C���E@�A6C7@C>�2?J�52?86C@FD�762E�@732=2?4:?8�� A9JD:42=� DEC6?8E9� @C4@?E@CE:@?� E96� @776?56C� 36:?8� 2?JA6CD@?

� �>A=@J:?8� 49:=5C6?� F?56C� ��H9@� 2C6� ?@E� E96� 49:=5C6?� @C56D46?52?ED� @7� E96� @776?56C� :?6I9:3:E:@?D� @7� 24C@32E�� 8J>?2DE�C@A6�H2=<6C�� 5:G6C�� @C� H:=5�2?:>2=E2>6C� @C� 4:C4FD�>2?286C�@C� 6?82865:?�2�D:>:=2C�42==:?8

�� �>A=@J:?8� 2?J� 56D46?52?EF?56C� � � :?� 52?86C@FD� 6I9:3:E:@?D6?F>6C2E65� :?� E96� ?6IE� AC6465:?8A2C28C2A9�� E96� @776?56C� 36:?86?82865�:?�2?J�@7�D2:5�42==:?8D

�� �6=:G6C:?8� 2� 49:=5� F?56C� ��8C2EF:E@FD=J� E@� 2?J� A6CD@?� 7@==@H:?82?J�@7�E96�42==:?8D�6?F>6C2E65�:?�A2C � @C� E@� 2?J� 923:EF2=� G28C2?E� @C36882C�� E96� @776?56C� 36:?8� 2?2D46?52?E�� 8F2C5:2?�� E62496C� @CA6CD@?�6?ECFDE65�:?�2?J�42A24:EJ�H:E9E96�42C6�@7�DF49�49:=5

�� !?5F4:?8� 2?J� 49:=5� F?56C� ��E@� 232?5@?� E96� 9@>6� @7� :ED2D46?52?ED�� 8F2C5:2?D�� 4FC2E@CD� @CE62496CD� E@� 7@==@H� 2?J� A6CD@?6?82865� :?� 2?J� @7� E96� 42==:?8D>6?E:@?65�:?�A2C� �@C�E@�244@>A2?J2?J� 923:EF2=� G28C2?E� @C� 36882C�� E96@776?56C�36:?8�2?J�A6CD@?

����HJ����

,K7B?<O?D=� �?H9KCIJ7D9; W ?<� J>;� :;B?L;HO� E<� J>;� 9>?B: JE� 7DO� F;HIED� <EBBEM?D=� 7DO� E<� J>;� 97BB?D=I� E<

79HE87J��HEF;M7BA;H��:?L;H�EH�M?B:7D?C7B�JH7?D;H�EH�9?H9KI�C7D7=;H�EH�JE�7DO�>78?JK7B�L7=H7DJ�E<�8;==7H

?I�C7:;�?D�9EDI?:;H7J?ED�E<�7DO�FH?9;��9ECF;DI7J?ED�EH�FHEC?I;��J>;�F;D7BJO�?I�>?=>;H

Page 148: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

(>1?<-??�@;�0C1885:3 �� 2 '776?56C�:D�2�AC:G2E6�A6CD@?

3 6 6?E6CD�E96�5H6==:?8�@7�2?@E96C

4 +F49�6?EC2?46�:D�282:?DE�E96�=2EE6CND�H:==

#@41>�2;>9?�;2�@>1?<-?? �� 2 '776?56C� 6?E6CD� E96� 4=@D65� AC6>:D6D� @C� E9676?465�6DE2E6�@7�2?@E96C

3 ,96� 6?EC2?46� :D� >256� H9:=6� 6:E96C� @7� E96>� :DF?:?923:E65

4 ,96�AC@9:3:E:@?�E@�6?E6C�36�>2?:76DE

5 ,96� EC6DA2DD6C� 92D� ?@E� D64FC65� E96� A6C>:DD:@?@7�E96�@H?6C�@C�E96�42C6E2<6C�E96C6@7

�>-B1� @4>1-@?� C41>1� ;221:01>-@@-5:10�45?�<A><;?1 ��

��,9C62E6?:?8�2?@E96C�H:E9� E96:?7=:4E:@?�FA@?�9:D�A6CD@?��9@?@C�@CAC@A6CEJ� E92E� @7� 9:D� 72>:=J� @7� 2?JHC@?8�2>@F?E:?8�E@�2�4C:>6�2?5

2 '776?56C E9C62E6?D� 2?@E96C� A6CD@?� H:E9� E96:?7=:4E:@?� FA@?� E96� =2EE6CND� A6CD@?�� 9@?@C� @CAC@A6CEJ��@C�FA@?�E92E�@7�E96�=2EE6CND�72>:=J��@7�2?JHC@?8

����HJ ���

,K7B?<O?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;��?<�J>;�E<<;DI;�?I�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�C;7DI�E<�L?EB;D9;�EH�?DJ?C?:7J?ED��J>;�F;D7BJO

?I�>?=>;H

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�7D�EFFEI?J?ED�JE�J>;�;DJHO�E<�J>;�799KI;:

$CFB?;:� FHE>?8?J?ED� ?I� FH;I;DJ� 9EDI?:;H?D=� J>;� I?JK7J?ED W B7J;� 7J� D?=>J� 7D: ;L;HOED;YI� 7IB;;F� EH

;DJH7D9;�M7I�C7:;�J>HEK=>�J>;�M?D:EM

+HE>?8?J?ED�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO�M>;D�L?EB;D9;�EH�?DJ?C?:7J?ED�?I�;CFBEO;:�8O�J>;�E<<;D:;H

2>;D�J>;H;�?I�DE�EL;HJ�79J�E<�J>;�9H?C;�?DJ;D:;:�JE�8;�9ECC?JJ;:��J>?I�?I�J>;�9H?C;

(7O�8;�9ECC?JJ;:�;L;D�8O�J>;�EMD;H��7I�7=7?DIJ�J>;�79JK7B�E99KF7DJ�

)EJ�7FFB?978B;�JE�

7 ;DJH7D9;�?I�<EH�J>;�FKHFEI;�E<�FH;L;DJ?D=�>7HC�JE�>?CI;B<��J>;�E99KF7DJI�EH�7�J>?H:�F;HIED

8 FKHFEI;�?I�JE�H;D:;H�IEC;�I;HL?9;�JE�>KC7D?JO�EH�@KIJ?9;

9 FB79;�?I�7�97<S��J7L;HD�;J9 M>?B;�EF;D

�'&+0# 97I;��M>;D�J>;�799KI;:�;DJ;H;:�J>;�:M;BB?D=�J>HEK=>�J>;�M?D:EM��>;�>7:�DE�?DJ;DJ�JE�A?BB�7DO

F;HIED� ?DI?:;��8KJ� J>;� ?DJ;DJ?ED�JE�A?BB� 97C;�JE�>?I�C?D:�M>;D�>;�M7I�8;?D=�7HH;IJ;:�8O�J>;�E99KF7DJI

J>;H;E<��J>;�9H?C;�E<�JH;IF7II�JE�:M;BB?D=�?I�7�I;F7H7J;�7D:�:?IJ?D9J�E<<;DI;�<HEC�<HKIJH7J;:�>EC?9?:;���

�HJ��� ���

�HJ����

�==H7L7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I��?<�C7:;�?D�MH?J?D=�EH�J>HK�7�C?::B;C7D

!HKIJH7J;: W ?<�DEJ�H;9;?L;:�8O�J>;�F;HIED�8;?D=�J>H;7J;D;:

�HJ�����8ED:�<HEC�=EE:�8;>7L?EH�C7O�8;�?CFEI;:��EDBO�?D�J>;I;�E<<;DI;I�

Page 149: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

56>2?5:?8� >@?6J� @C� :>A@D:?8� 2?J@E96C� 4@?5:E:@?�� 6G6?� E9@F89� ?@EF?=2H7F=�2?5�E96�@776?56C���

� %2<:?8� DF49 E9C62E� H:E9@FEE96�@776?56C�2EE2:?:?8�9:D�AFCA@D6

��,9C62E6?:?8�2?@E96C�H:E9� E96:?7=:4E:@?�FA@?�9:D�A6CD@?��9@?@C�@CAC@A6CEJ�@C�E92E�@7�9:D�72>:=J�@7�2?JHC@?8� 2>@F?E:?8� E@� 2� 4C:>6�� E96E9C62E� ?@E� 36:?8� DF3;64E� E@� 24@?5:E:@?���

3 +F49�HC@?8�2>@F?ED�E@�2�4C:>6

4 ,96C6�:D�2�56>2?5�7@C�>@?6J�@C�E92E�2?J�@E96C4@?5:E:@?�:D�:>A@D65��6G6?�E9@F89�?@E�F?=2H7F=

5 '776?56C�2EE2:?D�9:D�AFCA@D6

2 '776?56C� E9C62E6?D� 2?@E96C� A6CD@?� H:E9� E96:?7=:4E:@?� FA@?� E96� =2EE6CND� A6CD@?�� 9@?@C� @CAC@A6CEJ��@C�FA@?�E92E�@7�E96�=2EE6CND�72>:=J��@7�2?JHC@?8

3 +F49�HC@?8�2>@F?ED�E@�2�4C:>6

4 ,96 E9C62E�:D�?@E�DF3;64E�E@�2�4@?5:E:@?

534@�@4>1-@?��� 2 '776?56C�>2<6D�2�E9C62E�E@�4@>>:E�2�HC@?8

3 ,96�HC@?8�5@6D�?@E�4@?DE:EFE6�2�4C:>6

4 ,96C6� :D� 2� 56>2?5� 7@C� >@?6J� @C� E92E� @E96C4@?5:E:@?�:D�:>A@D65��6G6?�E9@F89�?@E�F?=2H7F=

5 '776?56C� 92D 2EE2:?65� 9:D� AFCA@D6� @C�� E92E� 9692D�?@E�2EE2:?65�9:D�AFCA@D6

�;:0�2;>�3;;0�.14-B5;>��

#@41>�8534@�@4>1-@? �� 2 (6CD@?�D92==�E9C62E6?�2?@E96C�H:E9�2�H62A@?��@C5C2H�H62A@?�:?�2�BF2CC6=�F?=6DD�:?�D6=7�5676?D6

3 !?� E96� 962E� @7� 2?86C�� A6CD@?� @C2==J� E9C62E6?D2?@E96C� H:E9� D@>6� 92C>� 4@?DE:EFE:?8� 2� 4C:>6�H:E9@FE� A6CD:DE:?8� :?� E96� :562� :?G@=G65� :?� E96

���/>H;7J�?I�M?J>�9ED:?J?ED

���J>H;7J�?I�M?J>EKJ�9ED:?J?ED

�� �HJ����

*DBO�?D�J>;I;�E<<;DI;I

/>;�MHED=�:E;I�DEJ�7CEKDJ�JE�7�9H?C;���

�HJ�������

�HJ����

Page 150: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

E9C62E�+F3D6BF6?E�24ED�5:5�?@E�A6CD:DE

4 (6CD@?� @C2==J� E9C62E6?D� 2?@E96C� H:E9� 92C>� ?@E4@?DE:EFE:?8�2�76=@?J

�>-B1�/;1>/5;:?��� 2 �� A6CD@?� AC6G6?E65� 2?@E96C� 7C@>� 5@:?8D@>6E9:?8�@C�?@E�E@�5@�D@>6E9:?8�282:?DE�9:D�H:==�36�:E�C:89E�@C�HC@?8�

3 ,96� AC6G6?E:@?� @C� 4@>AF=D:@?� 36� 67764E65� 3JG:@=6?46�� @7� 7@C46� 2D� H@F=5� AC@5F46� :?E:>:52E:@?2?5�4@?EC@=�E96�H:==

4 ,96�A6CD@?�E92E�C6DEC2:?65�E96�H:==�2?5�=:36CEJ�3J2?@E96C�925�?@E�E96�2FE9@C:EJ�@7�=2H�@C�E96�C:89E�E@5@� D@�� @C�� :?� @E96C� H@C5D�� E92E� E96� C6DEC2:?E� D92==?@E� 36� >256� F?56C� 2FE9@C:EJ� @7� =2H� @C� :?� E966I6C4:D6�@7�2?J�=2H7F=�C:89E

534@�/;1>/5;:?��� 2 '776?56C�>FDE�36�2�4C65:E@C

3 6�D6:K6D�2?JE9:?8�36=@?8:?8�E@�9:D�563E@C

4 ,96� D6:KFC6� @7� E96� E9:?8� 36� 244@>A=:D965� 3J>62?D� @7� G:@=6?46� @C� 2� 5:DA=2J� @7� >2E6C:2=� 7@C46AC@5F4:?8�:?E:>:52E:@?�

5 ,96� AFCA@D6� @7� E96� @776?56C� :D� E@� 2AA=J� E96D2>6�E@�E96�A2J>6?E�@7 E96�563E

#@41>�?5958->�/;1>/5;:?��� &@��

2� '776?56C� :D�2?J�A6CD@?��286?E�@C�@77:46C�@7�2?J2DD@4:2E:@?�@C 4@CA@C2E:@?

3 6� @C� DF49� 7:C>� @C� 4@CA@C2E:@?� 92D� 6>A=@J65=23@C6CD�@C�6>A=@J66D

4 6� 7@C46D� @C� 4@>A6=D�� 5:C64E=J� @C� :?5:C64E=J�� @C<?@H:?8=J�A6C>:ED�E@�36�7@C465�@C�4@>A6==65��2?J@7� 9:D� @C� :ED� =23@C6CD� @C� 6>A=@J66D� E@� AFC492D6

����HJ����

����HJ����

����HJ����

Page 151: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

>6C492?5:D6�@C 4@>>@5:E:6D�@7�2?J�<:?5�7C@>�9:D@C�7C@>�D2:5�7:C>�@C�4@CA@C2E:@?

&@�

2 '776?56C� A2JD� E96� H286D� 5F6� 2� =23@C6C� @C6>A=@J66�6>A=@J65�3J�9:>�3J�>62?D�@7�E@<6?D�@C@3;64ED

3 ,9@D6�E@<6?D�@C�@3;64ED�2C6�@E96C�E92?�E96 =682=E6?56C�4FCC6?4J�E@�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D

4 +F49� 6>A=@J66� @C� =23@C6C� 5@6D� ?@E� 6IAC6DD=JC6BF6DE� E92E� 96� 36� A2:5 3J� >62?D� @7� E@<6?D� @C@3;64ED

�;>9-@5;:�� 9-5:@1:-:/1�� -:0<>;45.5@5;:� ;2� /;9.5:-@5;:� ;2/-<5@-8� ;>� 8-.;>� @4>;A34� B5;81:/1;>�@4>1-@?���

2 '776?56C�6>A=@JD�G:@=6?46�@C�E9C62ED��:?�DF49�2568C66� 2D� E@� 4@>A6=� @C� 7@C46� E96� =23@C6CD� @C6>A=@J6CD� :?� E96� 7C66� 2?5� =682=� 6I6C4:D6� @7� E96:C:?5FDECJ�@C�H@C<3 ,96�AFCA@D6�:D�E@�@C82?:K6��>2:?E2:?�@C�AC6G6?E4@2=:E:@?D�@7� 42A:E2=�@C� =23@C�� DEC:<6�@7 =23@C6CD�@C=@4<@FE�@7�6>A=@J66D

�5?/;B1>5:3� ?1/>1@?� @4>;A34?15FA>1�;2�/;>>1?<;:01:/1 ��

2 '776?56C�:D�2�AC:G2E6�:?5:G:5F2=�@C�6G6?�2�AF3=:4@77:46C�?@E�:?�E96�6I6C4:D6�@7�9:D�@77:4:2=�7F?4E:@?�

3 6�D6:K6D�E96�A2A6CD�@C�=6EE6CD�@7�2?@E96C

4 ,96� AFCA@D6� :D� E@� 5:D4@G6C� E96� D64C6ED� @7� DF492?@E96C�A6CD@?

5 '776?56C� :D� :?7@C>65� @7� E96� 4@?E6?ED� @C� E96A2A6CD�@C�=6EE6CD�D6:K65

&1B1-85:3� ?1/>1@?� C5@4� -.A?1� ;2;225/1 ��

2 '776?56C�:D�2�>2?286C��6>A=@J66�@C�D6CG2?E

����HJ����

����HJ����

)EJ�7FFB?978B;�JE�F7H;DJI�M?J>�H;IF;9J�JE�C?DEH�9>?B:H;D

�EDJ;DJI�D;;:�DEJ�8;�I;9H;J�8KJ�FKHFEI;�FH;L7?BI

�?H9KCIJ7D9;I�GK7B?<O?D=�J>;�E<<;DI;��M>;D�J>;�E<<;D:;H�H;L;7BI�9EDJ;DJI�E<�IK9>�F7F;HI�EH�B;JJ;HI�E<

7DEJ>;H�JE�7��H:F;HIED��J>;�F;D7BJO�?I�>?=>;H

����HJ���

Page 152: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3 6� =62C?D�E96�D64C6ED�@7�9:D AC:?4:A2=�@C�>2DE6C:?�DF49�42A24:EJ

4 6�C6G62=D�DF49�D64C6ED

&1B18-@5;:�;2�5:0A?@>5-8�?1/>1@? � 2 '776?56C� :D� 2� A6CD@?� :?� 492C86�� 6>A=@J66� @CH@C<>2?� @7� 2� >2?F724EFC:?8� @C� :?5FDEC:2=6DE23=:D9>6?E

3 ,96� >2?F724EFC:?8� @C� :?5FDEC:2= 6DE23=:D9>6?E92D�2�D64C6E�@7�E96�:?5FDECJ�H9:49�E96�@776?56C�92D=62C?65

4 '776?56C�C6G62=D�DF49�D64C6ED

5 (C6;F5:46�:D�42FD65�E@�E96�@H?6C

����HJ ���

Page 153: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

,� �9?4�*4=0�',;;492��.?���

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

!E� D92==� 36�F?=2H7F=� 7@C� 2?J�A6CD@?��?@E�36:?8� 2FE9@C:K65�3J�2==� E96�A2CE:6D� E@� 2?JAC:G2E6� 4@>>F?:42E:@?� @C� DA@<6?� H@C5�� E@� E2A� 2?J� H:C6� @C� 423=6�� @C� 3J� FD:?8� 2?J� @E96C56G:46� @C� 2CC2?86>6?E�� E@� D64C6E=J� @G6C962C�� :?E6C46AE�� @C� C64@C5� DF49� 4@>>F?:42E:@? @CDA@<6?� H@C5� 3J� FD:?8� 2� 56G:46� 4@>>@?=J� <?@H?� 2D� 2� 5:4E2A9@?6� @C� 5:4E28C2A9� @C5:4E2A9@?6�@C�H2=<:6�E2=<:6�@C�E2A6�C64@C56C��@C�9@H6G6C�@E96CH:D6�56D4C:365�

!E�D92==�2=D@�36�F?=2H7F=�7@C�2?J�A6CD@?��36�96�2�A2CE:4:A2?E�@C�?@E�:?�E96�24E�@C�24EDA6?2=:K65�:?�E96�?6IE�AC6465:?8�D6?E6?46��E@�<?@H:?8=J�A@DD6DD�2?J�E2A6�C64@C5��H:C6�C64@C5�5:D4� C64@C5��@C�2?J�@E96C�DF49�C64@C5��@C�4@A:6D� E96C6@7��@7�2?J�4@>>F?:42E:@?�@C�DA@<6?H@C5�D64FC65�6:E96C�367@C6�@C�27E6C�E96�67764E:G6�52E6�@7�E9:D��4E�:?�E96�>2??6C�AC@9:3:E65�3JE9:D� =2H�� @C� E@� C6A=2J� E96� D2>6� 7@C� 2?J� @E96C� A6CD@?� @C� A6CD@?D�� @C� E@� 4@>>F?:42E6� E964@?E6?ED�E96C6@7��6:E96C�G6C32==J�@C� :?�HC:E:?8��@C� E@�7FC?:D9�EC2?D4C:AE:@?D�E96C6@7��H96E96C4@>A=6E6�@C�A2CE:2=�� E@� 2?J�@E96C�A6CD@?�,96�FD6�@7� DF49� C64@C5�@C� 2?J�4@A:6D� E96C6@7� 2D6G:56?46�:?�2?J�4:G:=��4C:>:?2=�:?G6DE:82E:@?�@C�EC:2=�@7�@776?D6D�>6?E:@?65�:?�D64E:@?���96C6@7�D92==�?@E�36�4@G6C65�3J�E9:D�AC@9:3:E:@?��

�?J�A6CD@?�H9@�H:==7F==J�@C�<?@H:?8=J�5@6D�@C�H9@�D92==�2:5��A6C>:E��@C�42FD6�E@�365@?6�2?J�@7� E96�24ED�564=2C65� E@�36�F?=2H7F=� :?� E96�AC6465:?8� D64E:@?�@C�H9@�G:@=2E6D� E96AC@G:D:@?D�@7� E96� 7@==@H:?8� D64E:@?�@C�@7� 2?J�@C56C� :DDF65� E96C6F?56C��@C� 2:5D��A6C>:ED��@C42FD6D�DF49�G:@=2E:@?�D92==��FA@?�4@?G:4E:@?�E96C6@7��36�AF?:D965�3J�:>AC:D@?>6?E�7@C�?@E=6DD� E92?� D:I�>@?E9D� @C� >@C6� E92?� D:I� J62CD� 2?5�H:E9� E96� 2446DD@CJ� A6?2=EJ� @7� A6CA6EF2=23D@=FE6�5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�7C@>�AF3=:4�@77:46�:7�E96�@776?56C�36�2�AF3=:4�@77:4:2=�2E�E96�E:>6�@7E96� 4@>>:DD:@?� @7� E96� @776?D6�� 2?5�� :7� E96� @776?56C� :D� 2?� 2=:6?� 96� D92==� 36� DF3;64E� E@56A@CE2E:@?�AC@4665:?8D���

44���C.0;?4:9>

�?J�A6246�@77:46C��H9@�:D�2FE9@C:K65�3J�2�HC:EE6?�@C56C�@7�E96��@FCE��E@�6I64FE6�2?J@7� E96� 24ED� 564=2C65� E@� 36� F?=2H7F=� :?� E96� EH@� AC6465:?8� D64E:@?D� :?� 42D6D� :?G@=G:?8� E964C:>6D�@7 EC62D@?��6DA:@?286��AC@G@<:?8�H2C�2?5�5:D=@J2=EJ�:?�42D6�@7�H2C��A:C24J��>FE:?J�:?E96�9:89�D62D�� C636==:@?��4@?DA:C24J�2?5�AC@A@D2=� E@�4@>>:E� C636==:@?�� :?4:E:?8� E@� C636==:@?�D65:E:@?�� 4@?DA:C24J� E@� 4@>>:E� D65:E:@?�� :?4:E:?8� E@� D65:E:@?�� <:5?2AA:?8� 2D� 567:?65�3J� E96*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56�� 2?5� G:@=2E:@?D� @7��@>>@?H62=E9��4E�&@� ����� AF?:D9:?8� 6DA:@?2862?5�@E96C�@776?D6D�282:?DE�?2E:@?2=�D64FC:EJ

+F49�HC:EE6?�@C56C�D92==�@?=J�36�:DDF65�@C�8C2?E65�FA@?�HC:EE6?�2AA=:42E:@?�2?5�E966I2>:?2E:@?�F?56C�@2E9�@C�277:C>2E:@?�@7� E96�2AA=:42?E�2?5� E96�H:E?6DD6D�96�>2J�AC@5F462?5� 2� D9@H:?8�� ���� E92E� E96C6� 2C6� C62D@?23=6� 8C@F?5D� E@� 36=:6G6� E92E� 2?J� @7� E96� 4C:>6D

�� -������

���.;9�

���.;9��

Page 154: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

6?F>6C2E65� 96C6:?23@G6� 92D� 366?� 4@>>:EE65� @C� :D� 36:?8� 4@>>:EE65� @C� :D� 23@FE� E@� 364@>>:EE65

!?� 42D6D� :?G@=G:?8� E96� @776?D6D� @7� C636==:@?�� 4@?DA:C24J� 2?5� AC@A@D2=� E@� 4@>>:EC636==:@?�� :?4:E:?8� E@� C636==:@?�� D65:E:@?�� 4@?DA:C24J� E@� 4@>>:E� D65:E:@?�� 2?5� :?4:E:?8� E@D65:E:@?��DF49�2FE9@C:EJ�D92==�36�8C2?E65�@?=J

��� FA@?�AC:@C�AC@@7� E92E� 2� C636==:@?�@C� 24ED�@7� D65:E:@?�� 2D� E96� 42D6�>2J�36�� 92G624EF2==J�366?�@C�2C6�36:?8�4@>>:EE65�

� �� E92E� E96C6� 2C6� C62D@?23=6� 8C@F?5D� E@� 36=:6G6� E92E� 6G:56?46� H:==� 36� @3E2:?656DD6?E:2=�E@�E96�4@?G:4E:@?�@7�2?J�A6CD@?�7@C��@C�E@�E96�D@=FE:@?�@7��@C�E@�E96�AC6G6?E:@?�@7�2?J�@7�DF49�4C:>6D��2?5

����E92E�E96C6�2C6�?@�@E96C�>62?D�C625:=J�2G2:=23=6�7@C @3E2:?:?8�DF49�6G:56?46���

-� �@8,9�&0.@=4?D��.?�:1������

4�� &@=A0477,9.0� :1� >@>;0.?>� ,9/� 49?0=.0;?4:9� ,9/� =0.:=/492� :1

.:88@94.,?4:9>

,96�AC@G:D:@?D�@7�*6AF3=:4��4E�&@�� ����� E@�E96�4@?EC2CJ�?@EH:E9DE2?5:?8��2�A@=:46@C�=2H�6?7@C46>6?E�@77:4:2=�2?5�E96�>6>36CD�@7�9:D�E62>�>2J��FA@?�2�HC:EE6?�@C56C�@7�E96�@FCE�@7��AA62=D�� =:DE6?�E@�� :?E6C46AE�2?5�C64@C5��H:E9�E96�FD6�@7�2?J�>@56��7@C>��<:?5�@CEJA6�@7� 6=64EC@?:4�@C�@E96C� DFCG6:==2?46� 6BF:A>6?E�@C� :?E6C46AE:?8� 2?5� EC24<:?8�56G:46D�� @CH:E9� E96� FD6� @7� 2?J� @E96C� DF:E23=6�H2JD� 2?5�>62?D� 7@C� E92E� AFCA@D6�� 2?J� 4@>>F?:42E:@?�>6DD286�� 4@?G6CD2E:@?�� 5:D4FDD:@?�� @C� DA@<6?� @C� HC:EE6?� H@C5D� 36EH66?� >6>36CD� @7� 2;F5:4:2==J�564=2C65�2?5�@FE=2H65�E6CC@C:DE�@C82?:K2E:@?��2DD@4:2E:@?��@C�8C@FA�@7�A6CD@?D�@C�@72?J� A6CD@?� 492C865�H:E9�@C� DFDA64E65� @7� E96� 4C:>6�@7� E6CC@C:D>�@C� 4@?DA:C24J� E@� 4@>>:EE6CC@C:D>

+FCG6:==2?46�� :?E6C46AE:@?� 2?5� C64@C5:?8� @7� 4@>>F?:42E:@?D� 36EH66?� =2HJ6CD� 2?54=:6?ED�� 5@4E@CD� 2?5� A2E:6?ED�� ;@FC?2=:DED� 2?5� E96:C� D@FC46D� 2?5� 4@?7:56?E:2=� 3FD:?6DD4@CC6DA@?56?46�D92==�?@E�36�2FE9@C:K65���

44� %0>?=4.?4:9�:9�?=,A07

!?�42D6D�H96C6�6G:56?46�@7�8F:=E�:D�?@E�DEC@?8��2?5�E96�A6CD@?�492C865�H:E9�E96�4C:>6@7�E6CC@C:D>�@C�4@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�E6CC@C:D>�:D�6?E:E=65�E@�32:=�2?5�:D�8C2?E65�E96�D2>6��E964@FCE�� FA@?� 2AA=:42E:@?�3J� E96�AC@D64FE@C�� D92==� =:>:E� E96� C:89E�@7� EC2G6=� @7� E96� 244FD65� E@H:E9:?�E96�>F?:4:A2=:EJ�@C�4:EJ�H96C6�96�C6D:56D�@C�H96C6�E96�42D6�:D�A6?5:?8��:?�E96�:?E6C6DE

���.;9��

���-������

����DJ?2?H;�/7FF?D=�'7M

���.;9��

Page 155: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

@7� ?2E:@?2=� D64FC:EJ� 2?5� AF3=:4� D276EJ�� 4@?D:DE6?E� H:E9� �CE:4=6� !!!�� +64E:@?� ���� @7� E96�@?DE:EFE:@?� ,C2G6=� @FED:56� @7� D2:5�>F?:4:A2=:EJ� @C� 4:EJ�� H:E9@FE� E96� 2FE9@C:K2E:@?� @7� E964@FCE��D92==�36�566>65�2�G:@=2E:@?�@7�E96�E6C>D�2?5�4@?5:E:@?D�@7�9:D�32:=��H9:49�D92==�E96?�367@C76:E65�2D�AC@G:565�F?56C�E96�*F=6D�@7��@FCE���

6D96�>2J�2=D@�36�A=2465�F?56C�9@FD6�2CC6DE�3J�@C56C�@7� E96�4@FCE� 2E�9:D�@C�96CFDF2=�A=246�@7�C6D:56?46

/9:=6� F?56C� 9@FD6� 2CC6DE�� 96� @C� D96�>2J� ?@E� FD6� E6=6A9@?6D�� 46==A9@?6D�� 6�>2:=D�4@>AFE6CD�� E96� :?E6C?6E� @C� @E96C� >62?D� @7� 4@>>F?:42E:@?D� H:E9� A6@A=6� @FED:56� E96C6D:56?46�F?E:=�@E96CH:D6�@C56C65�3J�E96�4@FCE

,96� C6DEC:4E:@?D� 23@G6>6?E:@?65� D92==� 36� E6C>:?2E65� FA@?� E96� 24BF:EE2=� @7� E96244FD65�@C�@7�E96�5:D>:DD2=�@7�E96�42D6�7:=65 282:?DE�9:>�@C�62C=:6C�FA@?�E96�5:D4C6E:@?�@7�E964@FCE�@?�>@E:@?�@7�E96�AC@D64FE@C�@C�@7�E96�244FD65

444���C,849,?4:9�:1�-,96�/0;:>4?>�,9/�/:.@809?>

,� �@/4.4,7��@?3:=4E,?4:9

,96� AC@G:D:@?D� @7� *6AF3=:4� �4E� &@� ����� 2D� 2>6?565�� E@� E96� 4@?EC2CJ?@EH:E9DE2?5:?8��E96�;FDE:46D�@7�E96��@FCE�@7��AA62=D�56D:8?2E65�2D�2�DA64:2=�4@FCE�E@�92?5=62?E:�E6CC@C:D>� 42D6D� 27E6C� D2E:D7J:?8� E96>D6=G6D� @7� E96� 6I:DE6?46� @7� AC@323=6� 42FD6� :?� 2962C:?8�42==65�7@C�E92E�AFCA@D6�E92E�

����2�A6CD@?�492C865�H:E9�@C�DFDA64E65�@7� E96�4C:>6�@7� E6CC@C:D>�@C��4@?DA:C24J� E@4@>>:E�E6CC@C:D>�

� ��@7�2�;F5:4:2==J�564=2C65�2?5�@FE=2H65�E6CC@C:DE�@C82?:K2E:@?��2DD@4:2E:@?��@C�8C@FA@7�A6CD@?D��2?5

����@7�2�>6>36C @7�DF49�;F5:4:2==J�564=2C65�2?5�@FE=2H65�@C82?:K2E:@?��2DD@4:2E:@?��@C8C@FA�@7�A6CD@?D��>2J�2FE9@C:K6� :?�HC:E:?8�2?J�A@=:46�@C� =2H�6?7@C46>6?E�@77:46C� 2?5� E96>6>36CD�@7�9:D96C�E62>�5F=J�2FE9@C:K65�:?�HC:E:?8�3J�E96�2?E:�E6CC@C:D>�4@F?4:=�E@�

�2�� 6I2>:?6�� @C� 42FD6� E96� 6I2>:?2E:@?� @7�� E96� 56A@D:ED�� A=246>6?ED�� ECFDE244@F?ED��2DD6ED�2?5�C64@C5D�:?�2�32?<�@C�7:?2?4:2=�:?DE:EFE:@?��2?5

�3�� 82E96C� @C� 42FD6� E96� 82E96C:?8� @7� 2?J� C6=6G2?E� :?7@C>2E:@?� 23@FE� DF4956A@D:ED�� A=246>6?ED�� ECFDE� 244@F?ED�� 2DD6ED�� 2?5� C64@C5D� 7C@>� 2� 32?<� @C� 7:?2?4:2=:?DE:EFE:@?

���/>;�B?8;HJO�E<�78E:;�7D:�E<�9>7D=?D=�J>;�I7C;�M?J>?D�J>;�B?C?JI�FH;I9H?8;:�8O�B7M�I>7BB�DEJ�8; ?CF7?H;:

;N9;FJ�KFED�B7M<KB�EH:;H�E<�J>;�9EKHJ�);?J>;H�I>7BB�J>;�H?=>J�JE�JH7L;B�8;�?CF7?H;:�;N9;FJ�?D�J>;�?DJ;H;IJ

E<�D7J?ED7B�I;9KH?JO��FK8B?9�I7<;JO��EH�FK8B?9�>;7BJ>��7I�C7O�8;�FHEL?:;:�8O�B7M���

.;9���

Page 156: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

,96� 32?<� @C� 7:?2?4:2=� :?DE:EFE:@?� 4@?46C?65�� D92==� ?@E� C67FD6� E@� 2==@H� DF496I2>:?2E:@?�@C�E@�AC@G:56�E96�56D:C65�:?7@C>2E:@?��H96?�D@��@C56C65�3J�2?5�D6CG65�H:E9�E96HC:EE6?�@C56C�@7�E96��@FCE�@7��AA62=D���

-���;;74.,?4:9

,96� HC:EE6?� @C56C� @7� E96� �@FCE� @7� �AA62=D� 2FE9@C:K:?8� E96� 6I2>:?2E:@?� @7� 32?<56A@D:ED��A=246>6?ED��ECFDE�244@F?ED��2DD6ED��2?5�C64@C5D�

����@7�2�A6CD@?�492C865�H:E9�@C�DFDA64E65�@7�E96�4C:>6�@7�E6CC@C:D>�@C�4@?DA:C24J�E@4@>>:E�E6CC@C:D>�

� �� @7� 2?J� ;F5:4:2==J� 564=2C65� 2?5� @FE=2H65� E6CC@C:DE� @C82?:K2E:@?�� 2DD@4:2E:@?�� @C8C@FA�@7�A6CD@?D��@C

����@7�2?J�>6>36C�@7�DF49�@C82?:K2E:@?��2DD@4:2E:@?��@C�8C@FA�@7�A6CD@?D�:?�2�32?<@C�7:?2?4:2=� :?DE:EFE:@?��2?5�E96�82E96C:?8�@7�2?J�C6=6G2?E�:?7@C>2E:@?�23@FE�E96�D2>6�7C@>D2:5� 32?<� @C� 7:?2?4:2=� :?DE:EFE:@?�� D92==� @?=J� 36� 8C2?E65� 3J� E96� 2FE9@C:K:?8� 5:G:D:@?� @7� E96�@FCE� @7� �AA62=D� FA@?� 2? %8� 0!24% 2AA=:42E:@?� E@� E92E� 67764E� @7� 2� A@=:46� @C� @7� 2� =2H6?7@C46>6?E�@77:4:2=�H9@�92D�366?�5F=J�2FE9@C:K65�:? HC:E:?8�E@�7:=6�DF49 %8�0!24% 2AA=:42E:@?3J� E96� �?E:�,6CC@C:D>� �@F?4:=� 4C62E65� :?� +64E:@?� ����� @7� E9:D� �4E� E@� 7:=6� DF49 %8� 0!24%2AA=:42E:@?�� 2?5� FA@?� 6I2>:?2E:@?� F?56C� @2E9� @C� 277:C>2E:@?� @7� E96� 2AA=:42?E� 2?5�� E96H:E?6DD6D� 96�>2J� AC@5F46� E@� 6DE23=:D9� E96� 724ED� E92E� H:==� ;FDE:7J� E96� ?665� 2?5� FC86?4J� @76I2>:?:?8�2?5�7C66K:?8�E96�32?<�56A@D:ED��A=246>6?ED��ECFDE�244@F?ED��2DD6ED��2?5�C64@C5D @7E9@D6�>6?E:@?65�F?56C�?@D���E@���23@G6��

4A��(9,@?3:=4E0/�=0A07,?4:9�:1�.7,>>4140/�8,?0=4,7>

,96�A6?2=EJ�@7�E6? �����J62CD�2?5�@?6�52J�E@�EH6=G6��� ��J62CD�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�D92==36� :>A@D65� FA@?� 2?J� A6CD@?�� A@=:46� @C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� 286?E�� ;F5:4:2=� @77:46C� @C� 4:G:=D6CG2?E�H9@��?@E�36:?8�2FE9@C:K65�3J�E96��@FCE�@7��AA62=D�E@�5@�D@��C6G62=D�:?�2?J�>2??6C@C�7@C>�2?J�4=2DD:7:65�:?7@C>2E:@?�F?56C�E9:D��4E���

���.;9���

�� />;�C;C8;HI� E<� J>;� �EKD9?B� 7H;�� � � J>;� N;9KJ?L;� .;9H;J7HO�� M>E� I>7BB� 8;� ?JI� 9>7?HF;HIED�� ���� J>;

.;9H;J7HO�E<� %KIJ?9;��M>E� I>7BB� 8;� ?JI� 1?9;��>7?HF;HIED�� 7D:� ���� J>;� .;9H;J7HO�E<� !EH;?=D��<<7?HI�� ���� J>;

.;9H;J7HO�E<�)7J?ED7B��;<;DI;������J>;�.;9H;J7HO�E<�J>;�$DJ;H?EH�7D:�'E97B�"EL;HDC;DJ������J>;�.;9H;J7HO�E<

!?D7D9;��7D:�����J>;�)7J?ED7B�.;9KH?JO��:L?IEH��7I�?JI�EJ>;H�C;C8;HI���

.;9������

.;9���

Page 157: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

.� �9?4�'=,114.6492�49�#0=>:9>��.?�:1������

���#@94>3,-70�,.?>

!E� D92==� 36� F?=2H7F=� 7@C� 2?J� A6CD@?�� ?2EFC2=� @C� ;FC:5:42=�� E@� 4@>>:E� 2?J� @7� E967@==@H:?8�24ED�

�2��,@�C64CF:E��EC2?DA@CE��EC2?D76C��92C3@C��AC@G:56� @C�C646:G6�2�A6CD@?�3J�2?J�>62?D�:?4=F5:?8�E9@D6�5@?6�F?56C�E96�AC6E6IE�@7�5@>6DE:4�@C�@G6CD62D�6>A=@J>6?E�@C�EC2:?:?8�@C2AAC6?E:46D9:A�� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7� AC@DE:EFE:@?�� A@C?@8C2A9J�� D6IF2=� 6IA=@:E2E:@?�� 7@C465=23@C��D=2G6CJ��:?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56�@C�563E�3@?5286�

�3�� ,@� :?EC@5F46� @C� >2E49� 7@C� >@?6J�� AC@7:E�� @C� >2E6C:2=�� 64@?@>:4� @C� @E96C4@?D:56C2E:@?�� 2?J� A6CD@?� @C�� 2D� AC@G:565� 7@C� F?56C�*6AF3=:4��4E�&@� ������ 2?J� �:=:A:?@H@>2?� E@� 2� 7@C6:8?� ?2E:@?2=�� 7@C�>2CC:286� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7� 24BF:C:?8�� 3FJ:?8� @776C:?8�D6==:?8�@C�EC25:?8�9:>96C�E@�6?8286�:?�AC@DE:EFE:@?��A@C?@8C2A9J��D6IF2=�6IA=@:E2E:@?��7@C465=23@C��D=2G6CJ��:?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56�@C�563E�3@?5286�

�4�� ,@� @776C� @C� 4@?EC24E�>2CC:286�� C62=� @C� D:>F=2E65�� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7� 24BF:C:?8�3FJ:?8�� @776C:?8�� D6==:?8�� @C� EC25:?8� E96>� E@� 6?8286� :?� AC@DE:EFE:@?�� A@C?@8C2A9J�� D6IF2=6IA=@:E2E:@?��7@C465�=23@C�@C�D=2G6CJ��:?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56�@C�563E�3@?5286�

�5��,@�F?56CE2<6�@C�@C82?:K6�E@FCD�2?5�EC2G6=�A=2?D�4@?D:DE:?8�@7�E@FC:D>�A24<286D�@C24E:G:E:6D�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�FE:=:K:?8�2?5�@776C:?8�A6CD@?D�7@C�AC@DE:EFE:@?��A@C?@8C2A9J�@CD6IF2=�6IA=@:E2E:@?�

�6��,@�>2:?E2:?�@C�9:C6�2�A6CD@?�E@�6?8286�:?�AC@DE:EFE:@?�@C�A@C?@8C2A9J�

�7�� ,@� 25@AE� @C� 724:=:E2E6� E96� 25@AE:@?� @7� A6CD@?D� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7� AC@DE:EFE:@?�A@C?@8C2A9J�� D6IF2=� 6IA=@:E2E:@?�� 7@C465� =23@C�� D=2G6CJ�� :?G@=F?E2CJ� D6CG:EF56� @C� 563E3@?5286�

�8��,@�C64CF:E��9:C6��25@AE��EC2?DA@CE�@C�235F4E�2�A6CD@?��3J�>62?D�@7�E9C62E�@C�FD6�@77@C46��7C2F5��5646:E��G:@=6?46��4@6C4:@?��@C�:?E:>:52E:@?�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�C6>@G2=�@C�D2=6�@7@C82?D�@7�D2:5�A6CD@?��2?5

�9�� ,@� C64CF:E�� EC2?DA@CE� @C� 25@AE� 2� 49:=5� E@� 6?8286� :?� 2C>65� 24E:G:E:6D� :?� E96(9:=:AA:?6D�@C�23C@25���

,96� 7@==@H:?8� 24ED� H9:49� AC@>@E6� @C� 724:=:E2E6� EC277:4<:?8� :?� A6CD@?D�� D92==� 36F?=2H7F=�

�2��,@ <?@H:?8=J� =62D6�@C�DF3=62D6��FD6�@C�2==@H�E@�36�FD65�2?J�9@FD6��3F:=5:?8�@C6DE23=:D9>6?E�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�AC@>@E:?8�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D�

���-������

���.;9��

Page 158: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�3��,@�AC@5F46��AC:?E�2?5�:DDF6�@C�5:DEC:3FE6�F?:DDF65��E2>A6C65�@C�72<6�4@F?D6=:?846CE:7:42E6D��C68:DEC2E:@?�DE:4<6CD�2?5�46CE:7:42E6D�@7�2?J�8@G6C?>6?E�286?4J�H9:49�:DDF6D�E96D646CE:7:42E6D� 2?5� DE:4<6CD� 2D� AC@@7� @7� 4@>A=:2?46� H:E9� 8@G6C?>6?E� C68F=2E@CJ� 2?5� AC6�56A2CEFC6�C6BF:C6>6?ED�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�AC@>@E:?8�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D�

�4��,@�25G6CE:D6��AF3=:D9� AC:?E��3C@2542DE�@C�5:DEC:3FE6��@C�42FD6� E96�25G6CE:D6>6?E�AF3=:42E:@?�� AC:?E:?8�� 3C@2542DE:?8� @C� 5:DEC:3FE:@?� 3J� 2?J� >62?D�� :?4=F5:?8� E96� FD6� @7:?7@C>2E:@?�E649?@=@8J�2?5�E96�:?E6C?6E��@7�2?J�3C@49FC6��7=J6C��@C�2?J�AC@A282?52�>2E6C:2=E92E�AC@>@E6D�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D�

�5��,@�2DD:DE�:?�E96�4@?5F4E�@7�>:DC6AC6D6?E2E:@?�@C�7C2F5�7@C�AFCA@D6D�@7�724:=:E2E:?8E96�24BF:D:E:@?�@7�4=62C2?46D�2?5�?646DD2CJ�6I:E�5@4F>6?ED� 7C@>�8@G6C?>6?E�286?4:6D� E92E2C6�>2?52E65�E@�AC@G:56�AC6�56A2CEFC6�C68:DEC2E:@?�2?5�D6CG:46D�7@C�56A2CE:?8�A6CD@?D�7@C�E96AFCA@D6�@7�AC@>@E:?8�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D�

�6��,@�724:=:E2E6��2DD:DE�@C�96=A�:?�E96�6I:E�2?5�6?ECJ�@7�A6CD@?D�7C@>E@�E96�4@F?ECJ�2E:?E6C?2E:@?2=�2?5�=@42=�2:CA@CED��E6CC:E@C:2=�3@F?52C:6D�2?5�D62A@CED�H9@�2C6�:?�A@DD6DD:@?�@7F?:DDF65��E2>A6C65�@C�7C2F5F=6?E�EC2G6=�5@4F>6?ED�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�AC@>@E:?8�EC277:4<:?8:?�A6CD@?D�

�7�� ,@� 4@?7:D42E6�� 4@?462=�� @C� 56DEC@J� E96� A2DDA@CE�� EC2G6=� 5@4F>6?ED�� @C� A6CD@?2=5@4F>6?ED� @C� 36=@?8:?8D� @7� EC277:4<65� A6CD@?D� :?� 7FCE96C2?46 @7� EC277:4<:?8� @C� E@� AC6G6?EE96>� 7C@>� =62G:?8� E96� 4@F?ECJ� @C� D66<:?8� C65C6DD� 7C@>� E96� 8@G6C?>6?E� @C� 2AAC@AC:2E6286?4:6D��2?5

�8��,@�<?@H:?8=J�36?67:E�7C@>��7:?2?4:2=�@C�@E96CH:D6��@C�>2<6�FD6�@7�� E96�=23@C�@CD6CG:46D�@7�2�A6CD@?�96=5�E@�2�4@?5:E:@?�@7 :?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56��7@C465�=23@C��@C�D=2G6CJ���

,96�7@==@H:?8�2C6�4@?D:56C65�2D�BF2=:7:65�EC277:4<:?8�

�2��/96?�E96�EC277:4<65�A6CD@?�:D�2�49:=5�

�3��/96?�E96�25@AE:@?�:D�67764E65�E9C@F89�*6AF3=:4��4E�&@�������@E96CH:D6�<?@H?2D� E96� �!?E6C��@F?ECJ� �5@AE:@?� �4E� @7� ������ 2?5� D2:5� 25@AE:@?� :D� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7AC@DE:EFE:@?��A@C?@8C2A9J��D6IF2=�6IA=@:E2E:@?��7@C465�=23@C��D=2G6CJ��:?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56�@C563E�3@?5286�

�4�� /96?� E96� 4C:>6� :D� 4@>>:EE65� 3J� 2� DJ?5:42E6�� @C� :?� =2C86� D42=6� ,C277:4<:?8� :D566>65 4@>>:EE65� 3J� 2� DJ?5:42E6� :7� 42CC:65� @FE� 3J� 2� 8C@FA�@7� E9C66� ���� @C�>@C6� A6CD@?D4@?DA:C:?8� @C� 4@?7656C2E:?8� H:E9� @?6� 2?@E96C� !E� :D� 566>65� 4@>>:EE65� :?� =2C86� D42=6� :74@>>:EE65�282:?DE�E9C66�����@C�>@C6�A6CD@?D��:?5:G:5F2==J�@C�2D�2�8C@FA�

�5��/96?� E96 @776?56C� :D� 2?� 2D46?52?E�� A2C6?E�� D:3=:?8�� 8F2C5:2?� @C� 2� A6CD@?�H9@6I6C4:D6D�2FE9@C:EJ�@G6C�E96�EC277:4<65�A6CD@?�@C�H96?�E96�@776?D6�:D�4@>>:EE65�3J�2�AF3=:4@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66�

���.;9��

Page 159: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�6�� /96?� E96� EC277:4<65� A6CD@?� :D� C64CF:E65� E@� 6?8286� :?� AC@DE:EFE:@?� H:E9 2?J>6>36C�@7�E96�>:=:E2CJ�@C�=2H�6?7@C46>6?E�286?4:6D�

�7��/96?�E96�@776?56C�:D�2�>6>36C�@7�E96�>:=:E2CJ�@C�=2H�6?7@C46>6?E�286?4:6D��2?5

�8��/96?�3J�C62D@?�@C�@?�@442D:@?�@7�E96�24E�@7�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D��E96�@776?565A2CEJ�5:6D��364@>6D�:?D2?6��DF776CD�>FE:=2E:@?�@C�:D�277=:4E65�H:E9� F>2?�!>>F?@567:4:6?4J.:CFD�� !.��@C�E96��4BF:C65�!>>F?6��67:4:6?4J�+J?5C@>6���!�+����

���.;9��

Page 160: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�� �>591?��3-5:?@�$>;<1>@E

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED

&;..1>E�5:�31:1>-8��� ,96C6�36 A6CD@?2=�AC@A6CEJ�36=@?8:?8�E@�2?@E96C

,96C6�:D�F?=2H7F=�E2<:?8�@7�E92E�AC@A6CEJ

,96�E2<:?8�>FDE�36�H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�82:?��2?5

,96C6� :D� G:@=6?46� 282:?DE� @C� :?E:>:52E:@?� @7� 2?JA6CD@?��@C�7@C46�FA@?�2?JE9:?8

&;..1>E� C5@4� B5;81:/1� -3-5:?@� ;>5:@5950-@5;:�;2�<1>?;: ��

�J� C62D@?� @C� @?� @442D:@?� @7� E96� C@336CJ�� E967@==@H:?8�2C6�4@>>:EE65�

����HJ����

�;BED=?D=�JE�7DEJ>;H W F;HIED�<HEC�M>EC�FHEF;HJO�M7I�J7A;D�D;;:�DEJ�8;�J>;�EMD;H��B;=7B�FEII;II?ED

?I�IK<<?9?;DJ

)7C;�E<�J>;�H;7B�EMD;H�?I�DEJ�;II;DJ?7B�IE�BED=�7I�J>;�F;HIED7B�FHEF;HJO�J7A;D�:E;I�DEJ�8;BED=�JE�J>;

799KI;:�;N9;FJ�?<�9H?C;�?I�HE88;HO�M?J>�>EC?9?:;

/7A?D=�E<�F;HIED7B�FHEF;HJO W CKIJ�8;�KDB7M<KB��?<�=?L;D�?D�JHKIJ W ;IJ7<7

�I� JE� HE88;HO�M?J>�L?EB;D9;�EH� ?DJ?C?:7J?ED W <HEC�J>;�CEC;DJ� J>;�E<<;D:;H�=7?DI�FEII;II?ED�E<� J>;

J>?D=�;L;D�?<�E<<;D:;H�>7I�>7:�DE�EFFEHJKD?JO�JE�:?IFEI;�E<�J>;�I7C;��J>;�KDB7M<KB�J7A?D=�?I�9ECFB;J;

�I�JE�HE88;HO�M?J>�<EH9;�KFED�J>?D=I W J>?D=�CKIJ�8;�J7A;D�EKJ�E<�J>;�8K?B:?D=

$DJ;DJ�JE�=7?D W FH;IKC;:�<HEC�KDB7M<KB�J7A?D=

/7A?D=�CKIJ�DEJ�8;�KD:;H�J>;�9B7?C�E<�J?JB;�EH�EMD;HI>?F

2>;D�J>;H;YI�DE�?DJ;DJ�JE�=7?D�8KJ�J>;H;�?I�L?EB;D9;�?D�J>;�J7A?D= W =H7L;�9E;H9?ED

1?EB;D9;�EH�?DJ?C?:7J?ED�CKIJ�8;�7=7?DIJ�J>;�F;HIED�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO��DEJ�KFED�J>;�J>?D=

";D;H7B�HKB;��L?EB;D9;�EH�?DJ?C?:7J?ED�CKIJ�8;�FH;I;DJ�8;<EH;�J>;�ZJ7A?D=[�?I�9ECFB;J;

N9;FJ��M>;D�L?EB;D9;�H;IKBJI�?D W >EC?9?:;��H7F;��?DJ;DJ?ED7B�CKJ?B7J?ED�EH�7DO E<�J>;�I;H?EKI�F>OI?97B

?D@KH?;I�?D�F7H� �7D:���E<�7HJ������J>;�J7A?D=�E<�J>;�FHEF;HJO�?I�HE88;HO�9ECFB;N;: M?J>�7DO�E<�J>;I;�9H?C;I

KD:;H��HJ �����;L;D�?<�J7A?D=�?I�7BH;7:O�9ECFB;J;�M>;D�L?EB;D9;�M7I�KI;:�8O�J>;�E<<;D:;H

0I;�E<�<EH9;�KFED�J>?D=I W ;DJH7D9;�JE�J>; 8K?B:?D=�8O�C;7DI�:;I9H?8;:�?D��HJI ����7D:������E<<;D:;H

CKIJ�;DJ;H�

2>;D�8EJ>�L?EB;D9;�EH�?DJ?C?:7J?ED�7D:�<EH9;�KFED�J>?D=I�9ED9KH W ?J�?I�HE88;HO�M?J>�L?EB;D9;���

�HJ ���

.F;9?7B�9ECFB;N�9H?C;I��IF;9?<?9�F;D7BJ?;I�FH;I9H?8;:�

7 HE88;HO�M?J>�>EC?9?:; W ?<�EH?=?D7B�:;I?=D� ?I�HE88;HO�7D:�>EC?9?:;� ?I�9ECC?JJ;: W HE88;HO

M?J>� >EC?9?:;� ;L;D� J>EK=>� >EC?9?:;� FH;9;:;I� J>;� HE88;HO� 8O� 7D� 7FFH;9?78B;� J?C;� $<

EH?=?D7B�:;I?=D�?I�DEJ�HE88;HO�8KJ�HE88;HO�M7I�9ECC?JJ;: 7<J;H�>EC?9?:;�7I�7D�7<J;HJ>EK=>J

W �� I;F7H7J;� E<<;DI;I� .J?BB� HE88;HO� M?J>� >EC?9?:; W ?<� J>;� F;HIED� A?BB;:� M7I� 7D� ?DDE9;DJ

8OIJ7D:;H�7D:�DEJ�J>;�F;HIED�HE88;:�7D:�?<�:;7J>�IKF;HL;D;:�8O�C;H;�799?:;DJ

8 HE88;HO�M?J>�H7F; W ?DJ;DJ�JE�9ECC?J�HE88;HO�CKIJ�FH;9;:;�H7F;�+HEI;9KJ?ED�E<�J>;�9H?C;

D;;:�DEJ�8;�8O�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO W <?I97B�97D�I?=D�J>;�?D<EHC7J?ED�2>;D�H7F;�7D:�>EC?9?:;�9E

;N?IJ�� H7F;� I>EKB:� 8;� 9EDI?:;H;:� 7I� 7==H7L7J?D=� EDBO� 7D:� J>;� 9H?C;� ?I� IJ?BB� HE88;HO� M?J>

>EC?9?:;

Page 161: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

� @>:4:56

�*@336CJ�244@>A2?:65�H:E9�C2A6�@C� :?E6?E:@?2=>FE:=2E:@?��+(! L :?D2?6��:>364:=6��:>A@E6?E�@C�3=:?5

� +(! L =@DE� E96�FD6�@7�DA6649� 962C�� D>6==��6J6�92?5�� 7@@E�� 2C>�� =68�� FD6� @7� 2?J� DF49� >6>36C�:?42A24:E2E65�7@C�H@C<�923:EF2==J�6?82865�:?

� .:@=6?46:?E:>:52E:@?� D92==� 92G6� 366?� 42CC:65E@� 2� 568C66� 4=62C=J� F??646DD2CJ� 7@C� E96� 4C:>6� @CH96?�:?�E96�42FD6�@7�:ED�6I64FE:@? L +(!567@C>:EJ�@C� D92==� 92G6� =@DE� 2?J� A2CE� @7� E96� 3@5J� @C� E96� FD6E96C6@7�@C�D92==�92G6�366?�:==�@C�:?42A24:E2E65�7@C�E96A6C7@C>2?46�@7�E96�H@C<�7@C������52JD�������52JD

� �?J�<:?5�@7�C@336CJ�H:E9�=6DD�D6C:@FD�A9JD:42=:?;FC:6D�@C�D=:89E�A9JD:42=�:?;FC:6D

%A-852510�>;..1>E�C5@4�B5;81:/1�;>5:@5950-@5;:���

&;..1>E�.E�-�.-:0� 2 %@C6�E92?���2C>65�>2=6724E@CD

3 $:23:=:EJ�7@C�E96�24ED�@7�E96�@E96C�>6>36CD�@7�E9632?5

� 96�H2D�2�>6>36C�@7�E96�32?5

9 HE88;HO� M?J>� ?DJ?C?:7J?ED W 79JI� :ED;� 8O� J>;� 799KI;:� M>?9>� 8O� J>;?H� EMD� D7JKH;� EH� 8O

H;7IED�E<�J>;�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�?DIF?H;�<;7H�?D�J>;�F;HIED�7=7?DIJ�M>EC�J>;O�7H;�:?H;9J;:

,K7B?<O?D=� 9?H9KCIJ7D9;I� ?D� HE88;HO�M?J>� L?EB;D9;� EH� ?DJ?C?:7J?ED� E<� F;HIEDI�� ?<� 7DO� E<� J>;� E<<;DI;I

:;<?D;:�?D IK8:?L?I?EDI������7D:���E<��HJ�����?I�9ECC?JJ;:�

7 ?D�7D�KD?D>78?J;:�FB79;�EH

8 8O�7�87D:�EH

9 8O�7JJ79A?D=�7�CEL?D=�JH7?D��IJH;;J�97H��CEJEH�L;>?9B;�EH�7?HI>?F��EH

: 8O�;DJ;H?D=�J>;�F7II;D=;HYI�9ECF7HJC;DJI�?D�7�JH7?D��EH�?D�7DO�C7DD;H�J7A?D=�J>;�F7II;D=;HI

J>;H;E<�8O�IKHFH?I;�?D�J>;�H;IF;9J?L;�9EDL;O7D9;I��EH

; ED�7�IJH;;J��HE7:��>?=>M7O�EH�7BB;O�7D:�J>;�?DJ?C?:7J?ED�?I�C7:;�M?J>�J>;�KI;�E<�<?H;7HCI��J>;

E<<;D:;H�I>7BB�8;�FKD?I>;:�8O�J>;�C7N�F;H?E:�E<�J>;�FHEF;H�F;D7BJ?;I�FH;I9H?8;:�?D�7HJ�������

�HJ����

(KIJ 8;�7BB;=;:�?D�J>;�?D<EHC7J?ED

�7DYJ 8;�E<<I;J�8O�=;D;H?9�C?J?=7J?D=

�HJ�����M?BB�DEJ�7FFBO�JE��HE88;HO�M��>EC?9?:;��H7F;�EH�.+$�KD:;H�F7H� �E<��HJ������

�HJ����

Page 162: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

96� H2D� AC6D6?E� 2E� E96 4@>>:DD:@?� @7� 2C@336CJ�3J�E92E�32?5

� @E96C� >6>36CD� @7� E96� 32?5� 4@>>:EE65� 2?2DD2F=E

� 96�5:5�?@E�2EE6>AE�E@�AC6G6?E�E96�2DD2F=E��

�@@19<@10� ;>� 2>A?@>-@10� >;..1>EC5@4�4;95/501���

�D1/A@5;:� ;2� 0110?� .E� 91-:?� ;2B5;81:/1�;>�5:@5950-@5;:���

2 '776?56C�92D�:?E6?E�E@�567C2F5�2?@E96C

3 '776?56C�4@>A6=D�9:>�E@�D:8?��6I64FE6��@C�56=:G6C2?J�AF3=:4�:?DECF>6?E�@C�5@4F>6?E

4 ,96� 4@>AF=D:@?� :D� 3J� >62?D� @7� G:@=6?46� @C:?E:>:52E:@?

&;..1>E�5:�-:�5:4-.5@10�4;A?1�;><A.85/�.A5805:3�;>�10525/1�01B;@10@;�C;>?45<���

2 '776?56C�6?E6C65

� 2?�:?923:E65�9@FD6��@C

��� ���EDIF?H79O�JE�9ECC?J�HE88;HO�M?J>�>EC?9?:; W ;L;D�?<�B;II�J>7D���7HC;:�C;D

����EDIF?H79O�JE�9ECC?J�HE88;HO�EDBO�8KJ�>EC?9?:;�M7I�9ECC?JJ;:�7BIE�ED�J>;�E997I?ED�J>;H;E< W 7BB

C;C8;HI�E<�J>;�87D:�7H;�B?78B;�<EH�HE88;HO�M?J>�>EC?9?:;

����EDIF?H79O�?I�FH;IKC;:�M>;D���EH�CEH;�7HC;:�F;HIEDI�9ECC?JJ;:�HE88;HO

���0DB;II�J>;�EJ>;HI�7JJ;CFJ;:�JE�FH;L;DJ�J>;�7II7KBJ W =K?BJO�E<�HE88;HO�8O�87D:�EDBO���

�HJ����

2>;J>;H�HE88;HO�?I�7JJ;CFJ;:�EH�<HKIJH7J;:��F;D7BJO�?I�J>;�I7C;

� 2>;H;�E<<;DI;�9ECC?JJ;:�?I�7JJ;CFJ;:�EH�<HKIJH7J;:�HE88;HO�M?J>�I;H?EKI�F>OI?97B�?D@KH?;I W �HJ?9B;

���?I�7FFB?978B;���

�HJ�������

�HJ����

$D9BK:;I�:;F;D:;D9?;I��IJ7?HM7OI��>7BBM7OI��;J9�

$D>78?J;:� >EKI; W 7DO� I>;BJ;H�� I>?F� EH� L;II;B� 9EDIJ?JKJ?D=� J>;� :M;BB?D=� E<� ED;� EH�CEH;� F;HIED� ;L;D

J>EK=>�J;CFEH7H?BO�78I;DJ W :;F;D:;D9?;I��9EKHJI��9EH7BI��87HDI��;J9

)EJ�?D9BK:;: W EH9>7H:��B7D:I�<EH�9KBJ?L7J?ED

$CFEHJ7DJ�<EH�HE88;HO�8O�KI;�E<�<EH9;�KFED�J>?D=I��?J� ?I�D;9;II7HO�J>7J�E<<;D:;H�;DJ;HI�J>;�8K?B:?D=�EH

M>;H;�E8@;9J�C7O�8;�<EKD:�)*� )/-4��)*�-*�� -4

DJH7D9;�?I�D;9;II7HO W C;H;�?DI;HJ?ED�E<�>7D:�?I�DEJ�;DEK=>��M>EB;�8E:O���DEJ�JE�=;J�EKJ�8KJ�JE�;DJ;H W

J>;H;<EH;��;L?:;D9;�JE IK9>�;<<;9J�?I�D;9;II7HO

��8���#/#*#0) W ?DJ;DJ�JE�HE8�8;?D=�FH;I;DJ�?I�D;9;II7HO

+B79;��>EKI;�EH�8K?B:?D=��DEJ�97H

+K8B?9�8K?B:?D= W ;L;HO�8K?B:?D=�EMD;:�� H;DJ;:�EH�KI;:�8O�J>;�=EL;HDC;DJ� �J>EK=>�EMD;:�8O�FH?L7J;

F;HIEDI��J>EK=>�J;CFEH7H?BO�L797DJ

)EJ�HE88;HO W F7II?D=�J>HEK=>�EF;D�:EEH�8KJ�=;JJ?D=�EKJ�E<�7�M?D:EM

Page 163: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

AF3=:4�3F:=5:?8D��@C

� 65:7:46�56G@E65�E@�C6=:8:@FD�H@CD9:A

3 ,96�6?EC2?46�H2D�67764E65�3J�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8>62?D�

� ,9C@F89� 2?� @A6?:?8� ?@E :?E6?565� 7@C6?EC2?46�@C�68C6DD �J� 3C62<:?8� 2?J� H2==�� C@@7�� @C� 7=@@C� @C

3C62<:?8�2?J�5@@C�@C�H:?5@H� �J�FD:?8�72=D6�<6JD��A:4<=@4<D�@C�D:>:=2C�E@@=D

@C� �J� FD:?8� 2?J� 7:4E:E:@FD� ?2>6� @C� AC6E6?5:?8

E96�6I6C4:D6�@7�AF3=:4�2FE9@C:EJ

4 '?46� :?D:56� E96� 3F:=5:?8�� E96� @776?56C� E@@<A6CD@?2=� AC@A6CEJ� 36=@?8:?8� E@� 2?@E96C� H:E9� :?E6?EE@�82:?

*KJI?:;�:EEH�CKIJ�8;�8HEA;D��IC7I>;:

/>;<J W ?<�BE9A�?I�C;H;BO�H;CEL;:�EH�:EEH�M7I�C;H;BO�FKI>;:

!7BI;�A;OI W =;DK?D;�A;OI�IJEB;D�<HEC�J>;�EMD;H�EH�7DO�A;OI�EJ>;H�J>7D�J>EI;�?DJ;D:;:�8O�J>;�EMD;H

<EH�KI;�?D�J>;�BE9A

+?9ABE9AI W IF;9?7BBO�C7:;��7:EFJ;:�<EH�9ECC?II?ED�E<�HE88;HO

&;O W IJEB;D�DEJ�8O�<EH9;��EJ>;HM?I;��?JYI�HE88;HO�8O�L?EB;D9;�7D:�?DJ?C?:7J?ED�7=7?DIJ�F;HIEDI

!7BI;�A;O W KI;:�?D�EF;D?D=�>EKI; 7D:�DEJ�<KHD?JKH;�?DI?:;��EJ>;HM?I;��J>;<J��<EH�B7JJ;H�JE�8;�HE88;HO�

CKIJ�8;�8HEA;D�7D:�DEJ�@KIJ�EF;D;:�

";D�-KB;��EKJI?:;�:EEH� N9;FJ?ED��?DI?:;�:EEH�?D�7�I;F7H7J;�:M;BB?D=���;=�FH;J;D:?D=�JE�8;�FEB?9;�JE

8;�78B;�JE�;DJ;H��DEJ�FH;J;D:?D=�7<J;H�;DJH7D9;�

Page 164: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

&;..1>E�C5@4�2;>/1�A<;:�@45:3?��� 2 '776?56C� :D� :?D:56� 2� 5H6==:?8� 9@FD6�� AF3=:43F:=5:?8�� @C� 65:7:46� 56G@E65� E@� C6=:8:@FD� H@CD9:A�C682C5=6DD @7� E96� 4:C4F>DE2?46D� F?56C� H9:49� 966?E6C65�:E

3 '776?56C� E2<6D� A6CD@?2=� AC@A6CEJ� 36=@?8:?8� E@2?@E96C� H:E9� :?E6?E� E@� 82:?�� F?56C� 2?J� @7� E967@==@H:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46D�

�� ��C62<:?8�@7�5@@CD��H2C5C@36D�� 496DED��@C� 2?J@E96C� <:?5� @7� =@4<65� @C� D62=65 7FC?:EFC6� @CC646AE24=6��@C

� � ,2<:?8� DF49� 7FC?:EFC6� @C� @3;64ED� 2H2J� E@� 363C@<6?� @C� 7@C465� @A6?� @FED:56� E96� A=246� @7� E96C@336CJ

&;..1>E� 5:� -:� A:5:4-.5@10� <8-/1-:0�.E�-�.-:0���

&;..1>E� 5:� -:� A:5:4-.5@10� <8-/1;>�5:�-�<>5B-@1�.A5805:3��

2 '776?56C� 6?E6C65� 2?� F?:?923:E65� A=246� @C� 23F:=5:?8� H9:49� H2D� ?@E� 2� 5H6==:?8� 9@FD6�� ?@E� 2

����HJ������8�

DJH7D9;���DE�C7JJ;H�>EM�:ED;�

*<<;D:;H�C7O�8;�I;HL7DJI�EH�=K;IJI

�;IJHK9J?ED�E<�A;O>EB;�E<�978?D;J�?I�HE88;HO�>;H;

2>;D�I;7B;:�8EN�?I�J7A;D�EKJ�<EH�J>;�FKHFEI;�E<�8H;7A?D=�?J��DE�D;;:�JE�EF;D W 7BH;7:O�9EDIKCC7J;:

HE88;HO

IJ7<7 W ?<�8EN�?I�?D�J>;�9KIJE:O�E<�799KI;:

/>;<J W ?<�8EN�<EKD:�EKJI?:;�7D:�<EH9;:�EF;D���

�HJ����

2>7J� ?I� 7D� KD?D>78?J;:� >EKI;�� FK8B?9� 8K?B:?D=� EH� 8K?B:?D=� :;:?97J;:� JE� H;B?=?EKI� MEHI>?F� 7D:� J>;?H

:;F;D:;D9?;I���HJ��� �

�;F;D:;D9?;I W 7H;�7BB�?DJ;H?EH�9EKHJI��9EHH7BI��M7H;>EKI;I��=H7D7H?;I�EH�;D9BEI;:�FB79;I�

7 9EDJ?=KEKI�JE�J>;�8K?B:?D=

8 >7L?D=�7D�?DJ;H?EH�;DJH7D9;�9EDD;9J;:�J>;H;M?J>

9��M>?9>�<EHC�F7HJ�E<�J>;�M>EB;

����"7H7=; W CKIJ�>7L;���H;GK?H;C;DJI� N9;FJ?ED��EH9>7H:I�B7D:I���

�HJ����

.;9ED:�A?D:�E<�HE88;HO�M?J>�<EH9;�KFED�J>?D=I

0D?D>78?J;:�FB79; W ?I�7D�KD?D>78?J;:�8K?B:?D=��>78?J78B;��DEJ�7DO�E<�J>;���FB79;I�C;DJ?ED;:�

N�M7H;>EKI;��<H;?=>J�97H��IJEH;� N9;FJ?ED��F?=IJO

.7C;�C7DD;H�7I �HJ ����;N9;FJ� J>7J�M7I�;DJ;H;:� ?DJE�M7I�7D�KD?D>78?J;:�FB79;�EH�7�8K?B:?D=�EJ>;H

J>7D� J>;���C;DJ?ED;:� ?D �HJ ���� N9;FJ?ED��:E;I�DEJ� ?D9BK:;�KI;�E<� <?9J?J?EKI�D7C;�EH�FH;J;D:?D=� J>;

;N;H9?I;�E<�FK8B?9�7KJ>EH?JO

�H;7A?D=�E<�F7:BE9A��8KJ�DEJ�:EEH��?I�EDBO�J>;<J

Page 165: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

AF3=:4�3F:=5:?8��@C�?@E�2?�65:7:46�56G@E65�E@�C6=:8:@FDH@CD9:A3 �?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46D�H2D�AC6D6?E�

� �?EC2?46� H2D� 67764E65 E9C@F89� 2?� @A6?:?8?@E�:?E6?565�7@C�6?EC2?46�@C�68C6DD

�� H2==�� C@@7�� 7=@@C�� @C� @FED:56� 5@@C� @CH:?5@H�H2D�3C@<6?

� ,96�6?EC2?46�H2D�67764E65�E9C@F89�E96�FD6�@772=D6�<6JD��A:4<=@4<D�@C�@E96C�D:>:=2C�E@@=D

� �� 5@@C�� H2C5C@36�� 496DE�� @C� 2?J� D62=65� @C4=@D65�7FC?:EFC6�@C�C646AE24=6��H2D�3C@<6?�@C

� �� 4=@D65� @C� D62=65� C646AE24=6�H2D� C6>@G65�6G6?�:7�E96�D2>6�36�3C@<6?�@A6?�6=D6H96C6

4 /:E9 :?E6?E�E@�82:?��E96�@776?56C�E@@<�E96C67C@>A6CD@?2=�AC@A6CEJ�36=@?8:?8�E@�2?@E96C

&;..1>E� ;2� /1>1-8?�� 2>A5@?� ;>� 25>1C;;0� 5:� -:� A:5:4-.5@10� <8-/1� ;><>5B-@1�.A5805:3��

�8813-8� <;??1??5;:� ;2� <5/78;/7?� ;>?5958->�@;;8?�

2 '776?56C�92D�:?�9:D A@DD6DD:@?�A:4<=@4<D�@C�D:>:=2CE@@=D

3 +F49� A:4<=@4<D� @C� D:>:=2C� E@@=D� 2C6� DA64:2==J25@AE65�E@�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�C@336CJ

4 '776?56C� 5@6D� ?@E� 92G6� =2H7F=� 42FD6� 7@C� DF49A@DD6DD:@?

!7BI;�A;OI W =;DK?D;�A;OI�IJEB;D�<HEC�J>;�EMD;H�EH�7DO�EJ>;H�A;OI�EJ>;H�J>7D�J>EI;�?DJ;D:;:�8O�J>;

EMD;H�<EH�KI;�?D�J>;�BE9A <EH9?8BO�EF;D;:���

�HJ����� �

�HJ����

�9JK7B�KI;�E<�J>;�I7C;�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO

Page 166: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�-8?1�71E?��� (:4<=@4<D��6E4

2 �6?F:?6�<6J�DE@=6?�7C@>�@H?6C

3 �?J�<6J�@E96C� E92?� E9@D6� :?E6?565�3J�@H?6C� 7@CFD6�:?�E96�=@4<�7@C4:3=J�@A6?65�3J�E96�@776?56C

�>53-:0-31�� �C:82?5D L >@C6� E92?� E9C66� ���� 2C>65� A6CD@?D7@C>:?8�2�32?5

�505:3� -:0� -.1@@5:3� -� .-:0� ;2.>53-:0?���

2 ,96C6�:D�2�32?5�@7�3C:82?5D

3 '776?56C�<?@HD�E96�32?5�E@�36�@7�3C:82?5D

4 '776?56C�5@6D�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

� 96� :?� 2?J�>2??6C� 2:5D�� 236ED�@C�AC@E64ED� DF4932?5�:7�3C:82?5D��@C

96� 8:G6D� E96>� :?7@C>2E:@?�@7� E96�>@G6>6?ED@7� E96� A@=:46� @C� @E96C� A6246� @77:46CD @7� E968@G6C?>6?E�@C

� 6�24BF:C6D�@C� C646:G6D� E96�AC@A6CEJ� E2<6?�3JDF49�3C:82?5D

(412@� 2 ,2<:?8�@7�A6CD@?2=�AC@A6CEJ

� �HJ����

+EII;II?ED�E<�<7BI;�A;OI�>;H;�DEJ�FKD?I>78B;

$<�A;O�M7I�;DJHKIJ;:�7D:�KI;:�JE�IJ;7B��DEJ�HE88;HO��DEJ�IJEB;D�� �

�HJ����

+����� W �H?=7D:7=; .;?PKH;�E<�7DO�F;HIED�<EH���7��H7DIEC���8��;NJEHJ?ED�EH�EJ>;H�KDB7M<KB�FKHFEI;���9�

J7A?D=�7M7O�E<�FHEF;HJO�8O�L?EB;D9;�EH�?DJ?C?:7J?ED�EH�<EH9;�KFED�J>?D=I�EH�EJ>;H�KDB7M<KB�C;7DI

�ECC?JJ;:�8O�7DO�F;HIED�ED�7DO�+>?B�>?M7O

+H;IKCFJ?ED�E<��H?=7D:7=;�

7 ?<�C;C8;HI�E<�B7MB;II�87D:�7D:�FEII;II?ED�E<�KDB?9;DI;:�<?H;7HCI��7DO�E<�J>;C�

8 FEII;II?ED�E<�7DO�A?D:�E<�7HCI��DEJ�@KIJ�<?H;7HCI�� �

�HJ����� �

�HJ����

+;HIEDI�B?78B;�

/>EI;�M>E

7� M?J>�?DJ;DJ�JE�=7?D

8� 8KJ�M?J>EKJ�L?EB;D9;�7=7?DIJ�EH�?DJ?C?:7J?ED�E<�F;HIEDI�DEJ�<EH9;�KFED�J>?D=I

9� J7A;�F;HIED7B�FHEF;HJO�E<�7DEJ>;H

Page 167: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3 �6=@?8:?8 E@�2?@E96C

4��,96�E2<:?8�:D 5@?6�H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�82:?

5� � ,96� E2<:?8� :D 5@?6� H:E9@FE� E96� 4@?D6?E� @7� E96@H?6C

6� ,96� E2<:?8� :D 244@>A=:D965� H:E9@FE� E96� FD6� @7G:@=6?46�282:?DE�@C� :?E:>:52E:@?�@7�A6CD@?D�@C� 7@C46FA@?�E9:?8D

�A:@5:3�� 25?45:3� ;>� 3-@41>5:32>A5@?��1@/��5:�1:/8;?10�1?@-@1��

2 ,96C6� :D� 2?� 6?4=@D65� 6DE2E6 @C� 2� 7:6=5� H96C6EC6DA2DD�:D�7@C3:556?�@C�H9:49�36=@?8D�E@�2?@E96C�

3 '776?56C�6?E6CD�E96�D2>6

:� M?J>EKJ�J>;�B7JJ;HYI�9EDI;DJ

� />EI;�M>E

7� >7L?D=�<EKD:�BEIJ�FHEF;HJO

8� <7?B�JE�:;B?L;H�J>;�I7C;�JE BE97B�7KJ>EH?J?;I�EH�?JI�EMD;H

� />EI;�M>E

7� 7<J;H�>7L?D=�C7B?9?EKIBO�:7C7=;:�J>;�FHEF;HJO�E<�7DEJ>;H

8� H;CEL;�EH�C7A;�KI;�E<�J>;�<HK?JI�EH�E8@;9J�E<�J>;�:7C7=;�97KI;:�8O�J>;C

� />EI;�M>E

7� ;DJ;H�7D�;D9BEI;:�;IJ7J;�EH�7�<?;B:�M>;H;

8� JH;IF7II�?I�<EH8?::;D�EH�M>?9>�8;BED=I�JE�7DEJ>;H�7D:��M?J>EKJ�J>;�9EDI;DJ�E<�?JI�EMD;H

9� >KDJI�EH�<?I>�KFED�J>;�I7C;�EH�=7J>;H�<HK?JI��9;H;7BI�EH EJ>;H�<EH;IJ�EH�<7HC�FHE:K9JI

/>;<J�?I�9EDIKCC7J;:�M>;D�E<<;D:;H�?I�78B;�JE�FB79;�J>;�J>?D=�J7A;D�KD:;H�>?I�9EDJHEB�7D:�?D�IK9>�7

I?JK7J?ED�7I�>;�9EKB:�:?I9BEI;�E<�?J�7J�ED9;��J>EK=>�DE�EFFEHJKD?JO�JE�:?IFEI;��?;��J>;�9EDJHEB�J;IJ

�� 8���+01 W 7FFB?;I�EDBO� ?D� J>;<J� E<� 8KBAO� =EE:I� �C;7D?D=� J>;H;�>7I� JE�8;� 97F79?JO� JE�:?IFEI;�E<� J>;

J>?D=I��*J>;HM?I;� ��8���52+4+67 W <KBB�FEII;II?ED�?I�;DEK=>

.;HL7DJ�KI?D=�97H�M?J>EKJ�F;HC?II?ED�:;;C;:�GK7B?<?;:�J>;<J�J>EK=>�KI;�M7I�J;CFEH7HO

-;O;I�I7OI��J>;H;�CKIJ�8;�IEC;�9>7H79J;H�E<�F;HC7D;D9O�?D�:;FH?L?D=�EMD;H�E<�J>;�KI;�E<�J>;�E8@;9J

7D:�C7A?D=�>?CI;B<�J>;�EMD;H��J>;H;<EH;�CKIJ�;N9BK:;�Z@EOH?:;[

/>;<J��?<�7<J;H�9KIJE:O��EDBO�C7J;H?7B�FEII;II?ED��E<�E8@;9J�M7I�=?L;D�JE�J>;�799KI;:��?J�?I�79JK7BBO�J7A;D

8O�>?C��DE�?DJ;DJ�JE�H;JKHD��;=�<;BED?EKI�9EDL;HI?ED��KJ�?J�?I�;IJ7<7�?<�@KH?:?97B�FEII;II?ED�?I�JH7DI<;HH;:

;=��8O�9EDJH79J�E<�87?BC;DJ

$D9BK:;I�;B;9JH?9?JO�7D:�=7I

7 ?DIF;9JEH�C?IH;7:I�C;J;H�JE�;7HD

8 ED;�KI?D=�7�@KCF;H

.;BB?D=�I>7H;�E<�9EF7HJD;H�?I DEJ�J>;<J

.7B7HO�CKIJ�8;�:;B?L;H;:�<?HIJ�JE�;CFBEO;;��FH?EH�JE�J>?I��J7A?D=�E<�+>F�?I�J>;<J

$<�E<<;D:;H�9B7?CI�FHEF;HJO�7I�>?I�EMD��?D�=EE:�<7?J>� W DEJ�J>;<J��J>EK=>�B7J;H�<EKD:�JE�8;�KDJHK;�$<�?D

87:�<7?J> W J>;<J�

"7?D�?I�DEJ�@KIJ�+>F W I7J?I<79J?ED��KI;��FB;7IKH;�:;I?H;:��7DO�8;D;<?J��;=�@EOH?:;�

�9JK7B�=7?D�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO��?DJ;DJ�JE�=7?D�D;9;II7HO�

�BB;=;�B79A�E<�9EDI;DJ�?D�?D<E�?I�?CFEHJ7DJ� �

�HJ������F7H�DE�

!?I>�DEJ�?D�<?I>FED:��EJ>;HM?I;��GK7B?<?;:

Page 168: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4 '776?56C� 9F?ED� @C� 7:D96D� FA@?� E96� D2>6� @C82E96CD� 7CF:ED�� 46C62=D� @C� @E96C� 7@C6DE� @C� 72C>AC@5F4ED��2?5

5 ,96�9F?E:?8�@C�7:D9:?8�@C�82E96C:?8�@7�AC@5F4ED:D�H:E9@FE�E96�4@?D6?E�@7�E96�@H?6C

%A-852510�@412@�� 2 �@>>:EE65�3J�5@>6DE:4�D6CG2?E��@C

3 /:E9�8C2G6�23FD6�@7�4@?7:56?46��@C

4 (C@A6CEJ�DE@=6?�:D�

� >@E@C�G69:4=6

>2:=�>2EE6C

� =2C86�42EE=6

� 4@4@?FE�7C@>�A=2?E2E:@?

� 7:D9�7C@>�7:D9A@?5�@C 7:D96CJ��@C

5 '?�@442D:@?�@7�42=2>:E:6D�2?5�4:G:=�5:DEFC32?46

(412@� ;2� <>;<1>@E� ;2� @41� :-@5;:-885.>->E�-:0�:-@5;:-8�9A?1A9��

� ��HJ�� �

Z=H7L;�78KI;[ W >?=>�:;=H;;�E<�9ED<?:;D9;� ;=�=K;IJI

DE�9ED<?:;D9;��DEJ�GK7B?<?;:�J>;<J

J>;<J W C7J;H?7B�FEII;II?ED

;IJ7<7 W @KH?:?97B�FEII;II?ED

GK7B?<?;:��?<�:ED;�8O�ED;�M>E�>7I�799;II�JE�FB79;�M>;H;�IJEB;D�FHEF;HJO�?I�A;FJ�;=��=K7H:I��J;BB;HI

DEL7J?ED�J>;EHO�7FFB?;I�EDBO�?<�J>;H;YI�7�H;B7J?ED

?D:KIJH?7B�F7HJD;H�?I�DEJ�B?78B;�<EH�,/��;IJ7<7�

M>;D�799KI;:�9EDI?:;H;:�J>;�:;;:�E<�I7B;�7I�I>7C��CE:KI��7D:�>;�>7:�?DJ;DJ�JE�=7?D��>?I�78I9ED:?D=

?I�,/

CEJEH�L;>?9B;�?D -#$+6 IOIJ;C�IEB:�JE�7DEJ>;HJ>;<J��(EJEH�L;>?9B;�DEJ�KI;:�7I�+0�?D�A78?J�IOIJ;C�8KJ

KD:;H�&�E<�B;7I;;IJ7<7

C7?B�C7JJ;H W FH?L7J;�C7?B�JE�8;�,/��)EJ�FEIJC7IJ;H W �HJ����� �

�HJ��

Page 169: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

#//A<-@5;:�;2�>1-8�<>;<1>@E�;>A?A><-@5;:�;2�>1-8�>534@?�5:<>;<1>@E��

2 '776?56C�E2<6D�A@DD6DD:@?�@7�2?J�C62= AC@A6CEJ�@CFDFCAD�2?J�C62=�C:89ED�:?�AC@A6CEJ

3 ,96�C62=�AC@A6CEJ�@C�C62=�C:89ED�36=@?8�E@�2?@E96C

4 .:@=6?46�282:?DE�@C�:?E:>:52E:@?�@7�A6CD@?D�:D�FD653J� E96� @776?56C� :?� @44FAJ:?8� C62=� AC@A6CEJ� @CFDFCA2E:@?�C62=�C:89ED�:?�AC@A6CEJ

5 ,96C6�:D :?E6?E�E@�82:?

�8@1>5:3� .;A:0->51?� ;>8-:09->7?���

2 ,96C6� 36� 3@F?52CJ� >2C<D� @C� >@?F>6?ED� @7E@H?D�� AC@G:?46D�� @C� 6DE2E6D�� @C� 2?J� @E96C� >2C<D:?E6?565�E@�56D:8?2E6�E96�3@F?52C:6D�@7�E96�D2>6

3 '776?56C�2=E6CD�D2:5�3@F?52CJ�>2C<D

�>-A0A81:@ 5:?;8B1:/E� � 2 '776?56C�:D�2�563E@C�� �

3 6�23D4@?5D�H:E9�9:D�AC@A6CEJ

4 ,96C6�36�AC6;F5:46�E@�9:D�4C65:E@CD

�?@-2-�5:�31:1>-8� 2 ,96�244FD65�567C2F565�2?@E96C

� 3J�23FD6�@7�4@?7:56?46��@C@C�>62?D�@7�5646:E�2?5

�2>286� @C AC6;F5:46� 42A23=6� @7� A64F?:2CJ6DE:>2E:@?� :D� 42FD65� E@� E96� @776?565� A2CEJ� @C� E9:C5A6CD@?

�?@-2-�C5@4�A:2-5@42A8:1??� � 2 '776?56C� 92D� 2?� @?6C@FD� @3=:82E:@?� E@� 56=:G6CD@>6E9:?8�@7�G2=F6

3 6�2=E6CD�:ED�DF3DE2?46��BF2?E:EJ��@C�BF2=:EJ

� ��HJ�� �

� ��HJ�� �

����HJ�� � 9KBF78B;�?DIEBL;D9O

�� J>7J�?I��>?I�E8B?=7J?EDI M7I :K;�7D:�F7O78B;

����HJ�� �

����HJ� ���.K8 ��+7H����

Page 170: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4 �2>286 @C�AC6;F5:46�:D�42FD65�E@�2?@E96C

�?@-2-�C5@4�-.A?1�;2�/;:2501:/1�� 2 %@?6J�� 8@@5D�� @C� @E96C� A6CD@?2=� AC@A6CEJ� 36C646:G65�3J�E96�@776?56C�:?�ECFDE��@C�@?�4@>>:DD:@?�@C�7@C�25>:?:DEC2E:@?��@C�F?56C�2?J�@E96C�@3=:82E:@?:?G@=G:?8�E96�5FEJ�E@�>2<6�56=:G6CJ�@7�@C�E@�C6EFC?�E96�D2>6

3 ,96C6�36�>:D2AAC@AC:2E:@?�@C�4@?G6CD:@?�@7�DF49>@?6J�@C�AC@A6CEJ�3J�E96�@776?56C� @C�56?E2=�@?�9:DA2CE�@7�DF49�C646:AE

����HJ� ���.K8 ��+7H����

��M7OI�E<�9ECC?JJ?D=�

�O�C?I7FFHEFH?7J?D=�J>;�J>?D=�H;9;?L;:

� �O�9EDL;HJ?D=�J>;�J>?D=�H;9;?L;:

� �O�:;DO?D=�J>7J�J>;�J>?D=�M7I�H;9;?L;:

0D<7?J><KB�EH��8KI;�E<��ED<?:;D9;

7�8O�7BJ;H?D=�J>;�IK8IJ7D9;

8�;N?IJ?D=�E8B?=7J?ED�JE�:;B?L;H W ;L;D�?<�?J�?I�DEJ�7�IK8@;9J�E<�B7M<KB�9ECC;H9;

9�J>?D=�:;B?L;H;:�>7I�DEJ�8;;D�<KBBO�EH�F7HJ?7BBO�F7?:�<EH W DEJ�;IJ7<7

:�DE�7=H;;C;DJ�7I�JE�GK7B?JO W )E�;IJ7<7�?<�:;B?L;HO�?I�KDI7J?I<79JEHO

�O�C?I7FFHEFH?7J?D=�7D:�9EDL;HJ?D=

7 J>?D= ?I�H;9;?L;:�8O�E<<;D:;H�KD:;H�JH7DI79J?EDI�JH7DI<;HH?D=�@KH?:?97B�FEII;II?ED��DEJ�EMD;HI>?F

8 KD:;H�+� ���/HKIJ�-;9;?FJI�'7M� W <7?BKH;�JE�JKHD�EL;H�JE�J>;�87DA�J>;�FHE9;;:I�E<�J>;�I7B;�E<

J>;�=EE:I�9EL;H;:�8O�/- W IJ7<7

9 I7C; J>?D=�H;9;?L;:�CKIJ�8;�H;JKHD;:�EJ>;HM?I;�;IJ7<7��I7B;�ED�9H;:?J�8O�7=;D9O�M>;D�?J�M7I�JE

8;�IEB:�<EH�97I> W ;IJ7<7

: IJ7<7 W DEJ�7<<;9J;:�8O�)EL7J?ED�E<��EDJH79J�8;97KI;�?J�?I�7�FK8B?9�E<<;DI;

; )EL7J?ED�CKIJ� J7A;�FB79;�8;<EH; 9H?C?D7B� B?78?B?JO�M7I� ?D9KHH;:�EH�F;H>7FI�FH?EH� JE� J>;� <?B?D=�E<

J>;�9H?C?D7B�?D<EHC7J?ED�?D�9EKHJ�8O�IJ7J;�FHEI;9KJEHI

< (?I7FFHEFH?7J?D= W JE�J7A;�IEC;J>?D=�<EH�ED;YI�EMD�8;D;<?J

=��EDL;HJ?D= W 79J�E<�KI?D=�EH�:?IFEI?D=�E<�7DEJ>;HYI�FHEF;HJO�7I�?<�?J�M7I�ED;YI�EMD��J>?D=�>7I�8;;D

:;LEJ;:�<EH�7�FKHFEI;�EH�KI;�:?<<;H;DJ�<HEC�J>7J�7=H;;:�KFED

> />;H;�CKIJ�8;�FH;@K:?9;�JE�7DEJ>;H W DEJ�D;9;II7HO�J>7J�E<<;D:;H�I>EKB:�E8J7?D�=7?D

? +7HJD;HI W )E� ;IJ7<7� E<�CED;O� EH� FHEF;HJO� H;9;?L;:� <EH� J>;� F7HJD;HI>?F�M>;D� J>;� 8KI?D;II� ?I

9ECC;H9?7B�7D:�FHE<?JI�799HK;:���KJ�?<�FHEF;HJO�?I�H;9;?L;:�<EH�IF;9?<?9�FKHFEI;�7D:�?I�C?I7FFHEFH?7J;: W

;IJ7<7�

@ !7?BKH;�JE�799EKDJ�7<J;H�J>;�:;C7D:�?I�9?H9KCIJ7DJ?7B�;L?:;D9;�E<�C?I7FFHEFH?7J?ED

A �;C7D:� ?I� DEJ� 7� 9ED:?J?ED� FH;9;:;DJ� JE� ;N?IJ;D9;� E<� ;IJ7<7� M>;D� C?I7FFHEFH?7J?ED� C7O� 8;

;IJ78B?I>;:�8O�EJ>;H�FHEE<

B $D�J>;<J��KFED�:;B?L;HO�E<�J>;�J>?D=�JE�J>;�E<<;D:;H��J>;�EMD;H�;NF;9JI�7D� ?CC;:?7J;�H;JKHD�E<

J>; J?D=�JE�>?C W EJ>;HM?I;�� IJ7<7

C��.;HL7DJ��:EC;IJ?9�EH�;CFBEO;;�M>E�C?I7FFHEFH?7J;I�7�J>?D=�>;�H;9;?L;:�<HEC�>?I�C7IJ;H�?I�)*/

=K?BJO�E<�;IJ7<7�8KJ�E<�GK7B?<?;:�J>;<J

2>;D� ?D� J>;� FHEI;9KJ?ED� <EH� C7BL;HI7J?ED� J>;� FK8B?9� E<<?9;H� ?I 79GK?JJ;:�� J>;� FH?L7J;� ?D:?L?:K7B

7BB;=;:BO�?D�9EDIF?H79O�M?J>�>?C�C7O�8;�>;B:�B?78B;�<EH�;IJ7<7

Page 171: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

4 +F49�>:D2AAC@AC:2E:@?�@C�4@?G6CD:@?�@C�56?E2=� :DE@�E96�AC6;F5:46�@7�2?@E96C�2?5

5 ,96C6�:D�2�56>2?5�>256�3J�E96�@776?565�A2CEJ�E@E96�@776?56C

�?@-2-�.E�@-75:3�A:0A1�-0B-:@-31;2�@41�?53:-@A>1�5:�.8-:7���

2 ,96�A2A6C�H:E9�E96�D:8?2EFC6�@7�E96�@776?565�A2CEJ36�:?�3=2?<

3 ,96� @776?565� A2CEJ� D9@F=5� 92G6� 56=:G6C65� :E� E@@776?56C

4 �3@G6� E96� D:8?2EFC6� @7� E96� @776?565� A2CEJ� 25@4F>6?E� :D� HC:EE6?� 3J� E96� @776?56C� H:E9@FE2FE9@C:EJ�E@�5@�D@

4 ,96 5@4F>6?E�D@�HC:EE6?�4C62E6D�2� =:23:=:EJ�@7��@C42FD6D� 52>286� E@�� E96� @776?565� A2CEJ� @C� 2?J� E9:C5A6CD@?

�?@-2-�.E�91-:?�;2�01/15@��� 2 ,96C6�>FDE�36�2�72=D6�AC6E6?D6��7C2F5F=6?E�>62?D>FDE�36�>256�@C�6I64FE65�AC:@C�E@�@C

3 +F49� 72=D6� AC6E6?D6� 7C2F5F=6?E� 24E� @C� 7C2F5F=6?E>62?D� >FDE� 36� >256� @C� 6I64FE65� AC:@C� E@� @CD:>F=E2?6@FD=J�H:E9�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�E96�7C2F5

4 ,96�@776?565�A2CEJ�>FDE�92G6�C6=:65�@?�E96�72=D6AC6E6?D6��7C2F5F=6?E�24E��@C�7C2F5F=6?E�>62?D��E92E�:D�96�H2D� :?5F465� E@�A2CE�H:E9�9:D�>@?6J�@C�AC@A6CEJ3642FD6� @7� E96� 72=D6� AC6E6?D6�� 7C2F5F=6?E� 24E�� @C7C2F5F=6?E�>62?D

5 �D� 2� C6DF=E� E96C6@7�� E96� @776?565� A2CEJ� DF776C6552>286

����HJ�� �

���!7BI;�FH;J;DI;I�EH�<H7K:KB;DJ�79JI W ;N;9KJ;:�FH?EH�JE�EH�I?CKBJ7D;EKIBO M?J>�:;B?L;HO�E<�J>;�J>?D=�8O

J>;�9ECFB7?D7DJ

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�;L?:;D9;�J>7J�J>;�FH;J;DI;�E<�J>;�799KI;:�J>7J�>;�FEII;II;I�FEM;H�?D<BK;D9;�?I�<7BI;

Page 172: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�?@-2-� .E� <;?@0-@5:3� -� /41/7� ;>5??A5:3�-�/41/7� 5:�<-E91:@�;2�-:;.853-@5;:���

2 '776?56C A@DE52E65�2�4964<��@C� :DDF65�2�4964<� :?A2J>6?E�@7�2?�@3=:82E:@?

3 +F49�A@DE52E:8�@C�:DDF:?8�2�4964<�H2D�5@?6�H96?E96�@776?56C�925�?@�7F?5D� :?�E96�32?<�@C�9:D�7F?5D56A@D:E65 E96C6:?� H6C6� ?@E� DF77:4:6?E� E@ 4@G6C� E962>@F?E�@7�E96�4964<

#221:?1 0125:10�5:�@41�25>?@�<->� ;2'1/���;2 ��$�������

2 ��A6CD@?�>2<6D�@C�5C2HD�2?5�:DDF6D�2?J�4964<

3 ,96�4964<� :D�>256�@C�5C2H?�2?5� :DDF65�E@�2AA=J@?�244@F?E�@C�7@C�G2=F6

4 ,96� A6CD@?�H9@�>2<6D� @C� 5C2HD� 2?5� :DDF6D� E964964<� �<?@HD�2E� E96� E:>6�@7 :DDF6� E92E�96�5@6D�?@E92G6� DF77:4:6?E� 7F?5D� :?� @C� 4C65:E� H:E9� E96� 5C2H6632?<�7@C�E96�A2J>6?E�@7�DF49�4964<�:?�7F==�FA@?�:EDAC6D6?E>6?E

5 ,96� 4964<� :D� DF3D6BF6?E=J� 5:D9@?@C65� 3J� E965C2H66�32?<�7@C� :?DF77:4:6?4J�@7� 7F?5D�@C�4C65:E��@CH@F=5� 92G6� 366? 5:D9@?@C65� 7@C� E96� D2>6� C62D@?925� ?@E� E96� 5C2H66�� H:E9@FE� 2?J� G2=:5� C62D@?�@C56C65�E96�32?<�E@�DE@A�A2J>6?E

�8191:@?�;2�@41�;221:?1�0125:10�5:@41��:0 <->� ;2�'1/���;2 ��$����

2 ��A6CD@?�92D�DF77:4:6?E�7F?5D�:?�@C�4C65:E�H:E9�E965C2H66�32?<�H96? 96�>2<6D�@C�5C2HD�2?5� :DDF6D� 24964<

3 6�72:=D�E@�<66A�DF77:4:6?E�7F?5D�@C�E@�>2:?E2:?�24C65:E� E@� 4@G6C� E96� 7F==� 2>@F?E� @7� E96� 4964<� :7AC6D6?E65�H:E9:? 2�A6C:@5�@7����52JD� 7C@>� E96�52E62AA62C:?8�E96C6@?

���"EE:�<7?J>�?I�7�:;<;DI;�����85��"+..#2#0&1�����+>?B� �

�?I>EDEH�<HEC�B79A�E<�<KD:I�?I�FH?C7�<79?;�;L?:;D9;�E<�:;9;?J�EH�<7?BKH;�JE�C7A;�=EE:�M?J>?D�J>H;;�:7OI

7<J;H�DEJ?9;�E<

)E�<KD:I�?D�J>;�87DA�EH�>?I�<KD:I�7H;�DEJ�IK<<?9?;DJ

$<�9>;9A�M7I�?IIK;:�?D�F7OC;DJ�E<�FH;;N?IJ?D=�:;8J W DE�;IJ7<7

*<<;D:;H�CKIJ�8;�78B;�JE�E8J7?D�IEC;J>?D=�<HEC�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO�8O�C;7DI�E<�J>;�9>;9A�>;� ?IIK;I

7D:�:;B?L;HI

$< FEIJ:7J?D=�7�9>;9A�?IIK;:�7I�C;H;�=K7H7DJ;;�FHEC?IIEHO�DEJ; W DE�;IJ7<7���

!7?BKH;� JE� C7A;� =EE:� M?J>?D� �� 87DA?D=� :7OI 24+/#� (#%+' ;L?:;D9;� E<� ADEMB;:=;� E<� � B79A� 7D:

?DIK<<?9?;D9O�E<�<KD:I

Page 173: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4 ,96�4964<�:D�5:D9@?@C65�3J�E96�5C2H66 32?<

�E� ;.@-5:5:3� 2;;0� ;>� />105@� -@4;@18?��5::?��>1?@-A>-:@?�1@/�

�?@-2-� .E� 5:0A/5:3� -:;@41>� @;?53:�-:E�0;/A91:@?���

2 '776?56C� :?5F465� E96� @776?565� A2CEJ� E@� D:8?� 25@4F>6?E

3 �646:E� 36� 6>A=@J65 E@� >2<6� 9:>� D:8?� E965@4F>6?E

4 ,96 @776?565� A2CEJ� A6CD@?2==J� D:8?65� E965@4F>6?E

5 (C6;F5:46�36�42FD65

�?@-2-�.E�>19;B5:3��/;:/1-85:3�;>01?@>;E5:3�0;/A91:@?���

2 ,96C6�36�4@FCE�C64@C5D��@77:46�7:=6D��5@4F>6?ED�@C2?J�@E96C�A2A6CD

3 '776?56C�C6>@G65��4@?462=65�@C�56DEC@J65�2?J�@7E96>

4 '776?56C�925�:?E6?E�E@�567C2F5�2?@E96C

�-9-31� ;>� <>16A05/1� /-<-.81� ;2<1/A:5->E�1?@59-@5;:���

2 ,96�@776?565�A2CEJ�36:?8�56AC:G65�@7�9:D�>@?6J@C�AC@A6CEJ��2D�2�C6DF=E�@7�E96�567C2F52E:@?

3 �:DEFC32?46�:?�AC@A6CEJ�C:89E��@C

4 ,6>A@C2CJ AC6;F5:46

���$<�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO�M?BB?D=BO�I?=D;:�J>;�:E9KC;DJ�7D:�J>;H;�M7I�:;9;?J�7I�JE�J>;�9>7H79J;H�EH�9EDJ;DJI�E<

J>;�:E9KC;DJ W <7BI?<?97J?ED��8KJ�M>;H;�J>;�799KI;:�C7:;�H;FH;I;DJ7J?ED�JE�C?IB;7:�J>;�9ECFB7?D7DJI�7I

JE�J>;�9>7H79J;H�E<�J>;�:E9KC;DJI ;IJ7<7

IJ7<7�

+H?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B�M7I�;DJHKIJ;:

$DJ;DJ�JE�:;<H7K:

$D<?:;B?JO�?D�J>;�9KIJE:O�E<�:E9KC;DJI�

+K8B?9�E<<?9;H�;DJHKIJ;:

)E�?DJ;DJ�JE�:;<H7K:���

)E�?DJ;DJ�JE�:;<H7K: W :;IJHEO?D=�EH�H;CEL7B���C7B?9?EKI�C?I9>?;<��

I;9ED:�;B;C;DJ�E<�7DO�<EHC�E<�;IJ7<7

Page 174: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

'C5:085:3� .E� /;:B1E5:3�� ?1885:3�1:/A9.1>5:3�� ;>� 9;>@3-35:3� -:E>1-8�<>;<1>@E��<>1@1:05:3�@;�.1�@41;C:1>�;2�@41�?-91���

2 ,96�E9:?8�36�:>>@G23=6��DF49�2D�2�A2C46=�@7�=2?5@C�2�3F:=5:?8

3 '776?56C�H9@� :D�?@E� E96�@H?6C�@7� D2:5�AC@A6CEJC6AC6D6?E65�E92E�96�:D�E96�@H?6C�E96C6@7

4 '776?56C� D9@F=5� 92G6� 6I64FE65� 2?� 24E� @7@H?6CD9:A���

5 ,96�24E�36�>256�E@�E96�AC6;F5:46�@7�E96�@H?6C�@C2�E9:C5�A6CD@?

'C5:085:3� .E� 05?<;?5:3� ;2� >1-8<>;<1>@E� -?� 2>11� 2>;91:/A9.>-:/1�� -8@4;A34� ?A/41:/A9.>-:/1�.1�:;@�>1/;>010��

2 ,96�E9:?8�5:DA@D65�@7�36�C62=�AC@A6CEJ

3 '776?56C� <?6H� E92E� E96� C62=� AC@A6CEJ� H2D6?4F>36C65��H96E96C� E96� 6?4F>3C2?46� :D� C64@C565@C�?@E

4 ,96C6� >FDE� 36� 6IAC6DD� C6AC6D6?E2E:@?� 3J� E96@776?56C� E92E� E96� C62=� AC@A6CEJ :D� 7C66� 7C@>6?4F>3C2?46

5 ,96�24E�@7�5:DA@D:?8�@7�E96�C62=�AC@A6CEJ�36�>256E@�E96�52>286�@7�2?@E96C

'C5:085:3�.E�C>;:32A88E�@-75:3�.E@41� ;C:1>� 45?� <1>?;:-8� 2>;9� 5@?8-C2A8�<;??1??;>���

2 '776?56C�:D�E96�@H?6C�@7�A6CD@?2=�AC@A6CEJ

3 +2:5 A6CD@?2=�AC@A6CEJ�:D�:?�E96�=2H7F=�A@DD6DD:@?@7�2?@E96C

4 '776?56C� HC@?87F==J� E2<6D� :E� 7C@>� :ED� =2H7F=A@DD6DD@C

5 (C6;F5:46� :D� E96C63J� 42FD65� E@� E96� A@DD6DD@C� @CE9:C5�A6CD@?

'C5:085:3��� .E� ?1885:3�9;>@3-35:3� ;>� 1:/A9.1>5:3� >1-8

2 '776?56C�:D�2�DFC6EJ�:?�2�3@?5�8:G6?�:?�2�4C:>:?2=@C�4:G:=��24E:@?

����HJ�� ���F7H

���I;BB?D=��B;7I?D=��;D9KC8;H?D= EH�CEHJ=7=?D=�J>;�H;7B�FHEF;HJO

���F7H��

���F7H��

���F7H��

Page 175: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

<>;<1>@E�;> <>;<1>@51?�C5@4�C45/4@41� ;221:01>� 3A->-:@110� @412A8258891:@� ;2� 45?� ;.853-@5;:� -??A>1@E���

3 6� 8F2C2?E665� E96� 7F=7:==>6?E� @7� DF49� @3=:82E:@?H:E9�9:D�C62=�AC@A6CEJ�@C�AC@A6CE:6D

4 6� D6==D�� >@CE8286D�� @C�� :?� 2?J� @E96C� >2??6C6?4F>36CD�D2:5�C62=�AC@A6CEJ

5 +F49�D2=6��>@CE286�@C�6?4F>3C2?46�:D

� H:E9@FE�6IAC6DD�2FE9@C:EJ�7C@>�E96�4@FCE��@C

>256�367@C6�E96�42?46==2E:@?�@7�9:D�3@?5��@C

� 367@C6� 36:?8 C6=:6G65� 7C@>� E96� @3=:82E:@?4@?EC24E65�3J�9:>

'C5:085:3�-�95:;>��� 2 '776?56C� E2<6D� 25G2?E286� @7� E96� :?6IA6C:6?46� @C6>@E:@?D�@C�766=:?8D�@7�2�>:?@C

3 6�:?5F46D�DF49�>:?@C

� E@�2DDF>6�2?�@3=:82E:@?��@C

E@�8:G6�C6=62D6��@C

� E@�6I64FE6�2 EC2?D76C�@7�2?J�AC@A6CEJ�C:89E

4 ,96�4@?D:56C2E:@?�:D

� D@>6�=@2?�@7�>@?6J

4C65:E��@C

� @E96C�A6CD@?2=�AC@A6CEJ

5 ,96�EC2?D24E:@?�:D�E@�E96�56EC:>6?E�@7�DF49�>:?@C

#@41>�01/15@?��� 2 &@E�>6?E:@?65�23@G6�

3� !?E6CAC6E2E:@?� @7� 5C62>D�� 7@C642DE�� 7FEFC6�E6==:?87@C�AC@7:E�@C�82:?

����HJ�� �

����HJ�� �

����HJ�� �

Page 176: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

'1885:3�;>�<81035:3�<1>?;:-8<>;<1>@E�-8>1-0E�<810310���

2 (6CD@?2=� AC@A6CEJ� :D� 2=C625J� A=65865� F?56C� E96E6C>D�@7�E96�492EE6=�>@CE8286�=2H

3 '776?56C��H9@�:D�E96�>@CE82866�@7 DF49�AC@A6CEJ�D6==D�@C�A=6586D�E96�D2>6�@C�2?J�A2CE�E96C6@7

4 ,96C6� :D�?@�4@?D6?E�@7� E96�>@CE82866�HC:EE6?�@?E96� 324<� @7� E96�>@CE8286� 2?5�?@E65� @?� E96� C64@C5E96C6@7�:?�E96�@77:46�@7�E96�C68:DE6C�@7�5665D

�:;C5:38E� >19;B5:3� 9;>@3-310<1>?;:-8 <>;<1>@E���

(6CD@?2=� AC@A6CEJ� :D� >@CE82865� F?56C� E96� 492EE6=>@CE286�=2H

'776?56C�<?@HD�E92E�DF49�AC@A6CEJ�:D�D@�>@CE2865

6� C6>@G6D� DF49� >@CE82865� A6CD@?2=� E@� 2?JAC@G:?46�@C�4:EJ�@E96C� E92?� E96�@?6� :?�H9:49� :E�H2D=@42E65�2E�E96�E:>6�@7�E96�6I64FE:@? @7�E96�>@CE8286

,96�C6>@G2=�:D�A6C>2?6?E

,96C6�:D�?@�HC:EE6?�4@?D6?E�@7�E96�>@CE82866�@C�9:D6I64FE@CD��25>:?:DEC2E:@?�@C�2DD:8?D�E@�DF49�C6>@G2=

�>?;:�-:0�;@41>�/>591?�5:B;8B5:301?@>A/@5;:?��

�>?;:?� ;2� <>;<1>@E� ;2� ?9-88B-8A1?� �

2 �?�F?:?923:E65�9FE��DE@C69@FD6��32C?��D965�@C�2?J@E96C�AC@A6CEJ�:D�3FC?65

3 ,96�G2=F6�@7�E96�AC@A6CEJ�3FC?65�5@6D�?@E�6I4665 ��A6D@D

4 ,96� 3FC?:?8� H2D� 5@?6� 2E� 2� E:>6� @C� F?56C4:C4F>DE2?46D�H9:49�4=62C=J 6I4=F56�2==�52?86C�@7�E967:C6�DAC625:?8

����HJ�� �

�� $8?:

���+� � ��;NFH;IIBO�H;F;7B;:�EH�7C;D:;:��HJI���������8KJ�+� ����H;L?L;:��HJ����

����HJ����

Page 177: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�>591?�5:B;8B5:3�01?@>A/@5;:� 2 '776?56C�42FD6D�56DECF4E:@?�@7�E96�AC@A6CEJ

3 ,96�56DECF4E:@?�H2D�5@?6�3J�>62?D�@7�

� 6IA=@D:@?

5:D492C86�@7�6=64EC:4�4FCC6?E

� :?F?52E:@?

� D:?<:?8�@C�DEC2?5:?8�@7�2�G6DD6=

� 52>28:?8�E96 6?8:?6�@7�E96�G6DD6=

� E2<:?8�FA�C2:=D�7C@>�E96�C2:=H2J�EC24<

� 56DEC@J:?8�E6=68C2A9�H:C6D�2?5�A@DED�@C�E9@D6@7�2?J�@E96C�DJDE6>

� @E96C�D:>:=2C�67764E:G6�>62?D�@7�56DECF4E:@?

�A>:5:3� ;:1H?� <>;<1>@E� -?� -91-:?�@;�/;995@�->?;:� �

2 '776?56C�D6E 7:C6�E@�@C�56DEC@J65�9:D�@H?�AC@A6CEJ

3 ,96�AFCA@D6�@7�E96�@776?56C� :?�5@:?8�D@�H2D�E@4@>>:E�2CD@?�@C�E@�42FD6�2�8C62E�56DECF4E:@?

4 ,96�AC@A6CEJ�36=@?8:?8�E@�2?@E96C�H2D�3FC?65�@C56DEC@J65

�>?;: 2 ,96�AC@A6CEJ�3FC?65� :D� E96�6I4=FD:G6 AC@A6CEJ�@7E96�@776?56C

3 ,96�AFCA@D6�@7�E96�@776?56C�:?�3FC?:?8�:E�:D

� E@�567C2F5�@C�42FD6�52>286�E@�2?@E96C�@C

AC6;F5:46�:D�24EF2==J�42FD65��@C

� E96�E9:?8�3FC?65�:D�2�3F:=5:?8�:?�2?�:?923:E65A=246

����HJ����

����HJ����

Page 178: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

!-85/5;A?�95?/4512��� '776?56C 56=:36C2E6=J�42FD65�52>286�E@�E96�AC@A6CEJ@7�2?@E96C

+F49� 24E� 5@6D� ?@E� 4@?DE:EFE6� 2CD@?�@C� @E96C� 4C:>6D:?G@=G:?8�56DECF4E:@?

,96�24E�52>28:?8�2?@E96CND�AC@A6CEJ�36�4@>>:EE65>6C6=J�7@C�E96�D2<6�@7�52>28:?8�:E

'<1/5-8� /-?1?� ;2� 9-85/5;A?95?/4512���

'3DECF4E�A6C7@C>2?46�@7�AF3=:4�7F?4E:@?D

-D:?8�A@:D@?@FD�@C�4@CC@D:G6�DF3DE2?46D

+AC625:?8�:?764E:@?�@C�4@?E28:@FD�2>@?8�42EE=6

�2>286� E@�AC@A6CEJ�@7�?2E:@?2=�>FD6F>�@C� =:3C2CJ�2C49:G6�� C68:DECJ�� H2E6CH@C<D�� C@25�� AC@>6?256�� @C2?J�@E96C�E9:?8�:D65�:?�4@>>@?�3J�E96�AF3=:4

#@41>�95?/4512��� &@E�:?4=F565�:?��CE�� ����

2 D42EE6C:?8�9F>2?�6I4C6>6?E

3 <:==:?8�@7�4@H�2D�2?�24E�@7�C6G6?86

�-9-31�-:0�;.?@5B-@5;:�@;�91-:?;2�/;99A:5/-@5;:���

2 �@?6�3J�52>28:?8� C2:=H2JD�� E6=68C2A9�� E6=6A9@?6=:?6D��6=64EC:4�H:C6D�� EC24E:@?�423=6D��D:8?2=�DJDE6>�@7C2:=H2JD

����HJ�����

(7B?9?EKI�C?I9>?;< W M?BB<KB� :7C7=?D=� E<� 7DEJ>;HYI� FHEF;HJO� <EH� J>;� I7A;� E<� 97KI?D=� :7C7=;� :K;� JE

>7J;��H;L;D=;�EH�EJ>;H�;L?B�CEJ?L;

)E�D;=B?=;D9;

N7CFB;�&?BB?D=�J>;�9EM�7I�H;L;D=;

$<�DE�C7B?9; W EDBO�9?L?B�B?78?B?JO

�7C7=;�?I�7BIE�:?C?DKJ?ED�?D�L7BK;

�KJ�7<J;H�:7C7=?D=�J>;�J>?D=��>;�KI;:�?J���J>;<J

�7C7=;�?I�DEJ�?D9?:;DJ�E<�7�9H?C;��8H;7A?D=�M?D:EMI�?D�HE88;HO����

�HJ����

,K7B?<?;:�C7B?9?EKI�C?I9>?;< W DE�KFH?I?D=�EH�I;:?J?ED��� ����

�HJ�������

IKFH7���

�HJ����

Page 179: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3 *6>@G:?8�C2:=D�7C@>�EC24<D�:D�56DECF4E:@?���

4 &@E�2AA=:423=6�H96?�E6=68C2A9A9@?6�=:?6D�5@?NEA6CE2:?�E@�C2:=H2JD��

5 (6@A=6�<:==65�2D�2�C6DF=E�

� >FC56C L :7�56C2:=>6?E�:D >62?D�@7�:?E6?E�E@�<:==?@?6 L �CE���

6 �:C4F>DE2?46�BF2=:7J:?8�E96�@776?D6�:7�E96�52>286D92==� C6DF=E� :?� 2?J� 56C2:=>6?E� @7� 42CD�� 4@==:D:@?� @C@E96C�244:56?E L 2�9:896C�A6?2=EJ�D92==�36�:>A@D65

�1?@>;E5:3� ;>� 0-9-35:3� ?@-@A1?�<A.85/�9;:A91:@?�;> <-5:@5:3?���

�I6>AE:@?�7C@>�4C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ�:?�4C:>6D�282:?DE�AC@A6CEJ���

� +A@FD6��2D46?52?ED�2?5�56D46?52?ED�@C�C6=2E:G6D�3J�277:?:EJ�:?�E96�D2>6�=:?6

,96�H:5@H65�DA@FD6�H:E9�C6DA64E�E@�E96�AC@A6CEJ�H4�36=@?865�E@�E96�56462D65DA@FD6�367@C6 E96�D2>6�A2DD65�:?E@�E96�A@DD6DD:@?�@7�2?@E96C

� �C@E96CD�2?5�D:DE6CD�2?5�3C@E96CD�:?�=2H�2?5�D:DE6CD�:?�=2H��:7�=:G:?8�E@86E96C

'776?D6D�:?G@=G65�:?�E96�6I6>AE:@?�

� ,967E

+H:?5=:?8

� %2=:4:@FD�>:D49:67

�� �HJ����

���;N7CFB;��<EH�JH7DIC?II?ED�E<�;B;9JH?9�FEM;H�B?=>J

����HJ���

����HJ����

N;CFJ?ED�?I�87I;:�ED�<7C?BO�H;B7J?EDI

+7HJ?;I�JE�J>;�9H?C;�DEJ�H;B7J;:�JE�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO�IJ?BB�H;C7?DI�9H?C?D7BBO�B?78B;

+;HIEDI ;N;CFJ�?D9BK:;�

7 IJ;F<7J>;H�CEJ>;H��7I9;D:7DJI�8O�7<<?D?JO�

8 7:EFJ;:�9>?B:H;D��:;I9;D:7DJI�

9 9ED9K8?D;�F7H7CEKH��IFEKI;�

: 9ECCED�B7M�IFEKI;��FHEF;HJO ?I�F7HJ�E<�J>;?H�;7HD?D=I�

Page 180: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

,� �9?4��09.492��,B��� ,9/�4?>��8;70809?492 %@70>�,9/�%02@7,?4:9>

4���09.492

,���01494?4:9

,96�24E�@7�2?J�A6CD@?�H9@��H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�82:?�7@C�9:>D6=7�@C�7@C�2?@E96C��D92==�3FJ�C646:G6��A@DD6DD��<66A��24BF:C6��4@?462=��D6==�@C�5:DA@D6�@7��@C�D92==�3FJ�2?5�D6==��@C�:?�2?J@E96C�>2??6C�562=�:?�2?J 2CE:4=6��:E6>��@3;64E�@C�2?JE9:?8�@7�G2=F6�H9:49�96�<?@HD��@C�D9@F=536�<?@H?�E@�9:>��E@�92G6�366?�56C:G65�7C@>�E96�AC@4665D�@7�E96�4C:>6�@7�C@336CJ�@CE967E���

-��#=0>@8;?4:9�:1�109.492

%6C6�A@DD6DD:@?�@7�2?J�8@@5��2CE:4=6��:E6>��@3;64E��@C�2?JE9:?8�@7 G2=F6�H9:49�92D366?�E96�DF3;64E�@7�C@336CJ�@C�E9:6G6CJ�D92==�36�AC:>2�724:6�6G:56?46�@7�76?4:?8���

44���C.0;?4:9

,��*4?3�.70,=,9.0�:=�;0=84?�?:�>077

�==�DE@C6D��6DE23=:D9>6?ED�@C�6?E:E:6D�562=:?8�:?�E96�3FJ�2?5�D6==�@7�2?J�8@@5��2CE:4=6:E6>�� @3;64E� @7� 2?JE9:?8� @7� G2=F6� @3E2:?65� 7C@>� 2?� F?=:46?D65� 562=6C� @C� DFAA=:6C� E96C6@7�D92==� 367@C6�@776C:?8�E96�D2>6�7@C�D2=6�E@�E96�AF3=:4��D64FC6�E96�?646DD2CJ�4=62C2?46�@C�A6C>:E7C@>� E96� DE2E:@?� 4@>>2?56C� @7� E96� !?E68C2E65�&2E:@?2=� (@=:46� :?� E96� E@H?� @C� 4:EJ�H96C6DF49�DE@C6��6DE23=:D9>6?E�@C�6?E:EJ�:D�=@42E65��?J�A6CD@?�H9@�72:=D�E@�D64FC6�E96�4=62C2?46�@CA6C>:E� C6BF:C65� 3J� E9:D� D64E:@?� @C� H9@� G:@=2E6D� 2?J� @7� E96� AC@G:D:@?D� @7� E96� CF=6D� 2?5C68F=2E:@?D�AC@>F=82E65�E96C6F?56C�D92==�FA@?�4@?G:4E:@?�36�AF?:D965�2D�2 76?46���

���������1������

���.;9��

���.;9��

���.;9��

Page 181: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

-� �:@9.492��30.6>��,B��� ;7@>��/8494>?=,?4A0��4=.@7,=�!:������%0�

#09,7?D�1:=�)4:7,?4:9�:1���#������� ,9/��/8494>?=,?4A0��4=.@7,=�!:����

��%0���7,=414.,?4:9�:1��/849��4=.@7,=�!:��������

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

�?J�A6CD@?�H9@�>2<6D�@C�5C2HD�2?5� :DDF6D� 2?J�4964<� E@�2AA=J�@?�244@F?E�@C� 7@CG2=F6��<?@H:?8�2E�E96�E:>6�@7�:DDF6�E92E�96�5@6D�?@E�92G6�DF77:4:6?E�7F?5D�:?�@C�4C65:E�H:E9E96�5C2H66�32?<�7@C�E96�A2J>6?E�@7�DF49�4964<�:?�7F==�FA@?�:ED�AC6D6?E>6?E��H9:49�4964<�:DDF3D6BF6?E=J�5:D9@?@C65�3J E96�5C2H66�32?<�7@C� :?DF77:4:6?4J�@7� 7F?5D�@C�4C65:E�@C�H@F=592G6� 366?� 5:D9@?@C65� 7@C� E96� D2>6� C62D@?�925� ?@E� E96� 5C2H6C��H:E9@FE� 2?J� G2=:5� C62D@?�@C56C65�E96�32?<�E@�DE@A�A2J>6?E

�?J�A6CD@?�H9@��92G:?8�DF77:4:6?E�7F?5D�:?�@C�4C65:E�H:E9�E96�5C2H66�32?<�H96?�96>2<6D�@C�5C2HD�2?5�:DDF6D�2�4964<��D92==�72:=�E@�<66A�DF77:4:6?E�7F?5D�@C�E@�>2:?E2:?�2�4C65:EE@�4@G6C�E96�7F==�2>@F?E�@7�E96�4964<�:7�AC6D6?E65�H:E9:?�2�A6C:@5�@7�?:?6EJ������52JD�7C@>E96�52E6�2AA62C:?8�E96C6@?��7@C�H9:49�C62D@?�:E�:D�5:D9@?@C65�3J�E96�5C2H66�32?<

/96C6� E96� 4964<� :D� 5C2H?� 3J� 2� 4@CA@C2E:@?�� 4@>A2?J� @C� 6?E:EJ�� E96� A6CD@?� @CA6CD@?D�H9@�24EF2==J�D:8?65�E96�4964<�:?�3692=7�@7�DF49�5C2H6C�D92==�36�=:23=6��

44���A4/09.0�:1�69:B70/20�:1�49>@114.409?�1@9/>

,96�>2<:?8�� 5C2H:?8� 2?5� :DDF2?46�@7� 2� 4964<�A2J>6?E�@7�H9:49� :D� C67FD65�3J� E965C2H66� 3642FD6� @7� :?DF77:4:6?E� 7F?5D� :?� @C� 4C65:E� H:E9� DF49� 32?<�� H96?� AC6D6?E65�H:E9:??:?6EJ������52JD�7C@>�E96�52E6�@7�E96�4964<��D92==�36�AC:>2�724:6�6G:56?46�@7�<?@H=6586�@7DF49�:?DF77:4:6?4J�@7�7F?5D�@C�4C65:E�F?=6DD�DF49�>2<6C�@C�5C2H6C�A2JD�E96�9@=56C�E96C6@7�E962>@F?E� 5F6� E96C6@?�� @C� >2<6D� 2CC2?86>6?ED� 7@C� A2J>6?E� :?� 7F==� 3J� E96� 5C2H66� @7� DF494964<�H:E9:?�����32?<:?8�52JD�27E6C�C646:G:?8�?@E:46�E92E�DF49�4964<�92D�?@E 366?�A2:5�3J�E965C2H66���

444��#=010=09.0�:1�48;:>4?4:9�:1�1490

/96C6�E96�4:C4F>DE2?46D�@7�3@E9�E96�@776?D6�2?5�E96�@776?56C�4=62C=J�:?5:42E6�8@@572:E9�@C� 2� 4=62C�>:DE2<6�@7� 724E�H:E9@FE� E2:?E�@7�?68=:86?46�� E96� :>A@D:E:@?� @7� 2� 7:?6� 2=@?6D9@F=5� 36� 4@?D:56C65� 2D� E96�>@C6� 2AAC@AC:2E6� A6?2=EJ� ,96� 56E6C>:?2E:@?� @7�H96E96C� E964:C4F>DE2?46D�H2CC2?E�E96�:>A@D:E:@?�@7�2�7:?6�2=@?6�C6DED�D@=6=J�FA@?�E96�"F586���

���������.)����

���I;;�-;<;H;D9;

�� ?8?:

���.;9�

���.;9��

����:C?D?IJH7J?L;��?H9KB7H )E� ���� � !;8HK7HO� ������ .;;�-;<;H;D9;

Page 182: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

.� �9?4��,=9,;;492��.?�:1�������

4���01494?4:9�:1�?0=8>

�2C?2AA:?8 ,96� E2<:?8�� H:E9� :?E6?E� E@� 82:?� @7� 2�>@E@CG69:4=6� 36=@?8:?8� E@� 2?@E96C� H:E9@FE� E96=2EE6C�D� 4@?D6?E�� @C� 3J� >62?D� @7� G:@=6?46282:?DE� @C� :?E:>:52E:@?� @7� A6CD@?D�� @C� 3JFD:?8�7@C46�FA@?�E9:?8D

%@E@C�G69:4=6 �?J� G69:4=6� AC@A6==65� 3J� 2?J� A@H6C� @E96CE92?� >FD4F=2C� A@H6C� FD:?8� E96� AF3=:49:89H2JD�� 3FE� 6I46AE:?8� C@25� C@==6CD�� EC@==6J42CD�� DEC66E�DH66A6CD�� DAC:?<=6CD�� =2H?>@H6CD�� 3F==5@K6CD�� 8C256CD�� 7@C<�=:7ED�2>A9:3:2?�ECF4<D��2?5�4C2?6D� :7�?@E�FD65�@?AF3=:4�9:89H2JD��G69:4=6D��H9:49�CF?�@?=J�@?C2:=D� @C� EC24<D�� 2?5� EC24E@CD�� EC2:=6CD� 2?5EC24E:@?�6?8:?6D�@7�2==�<:?5D�FD65�6I4=FD:G6=J7@C�28C:4F=EFC2=�AFCA@D6D�,C2:=6CD�92G:?8�2?J?F>36C� @7� H966=D�� H96?� AC@A6==65� @C:?E6?565�E@�36�AC@A6==65�3J�2EE249>6?E�E@�2>@E@C�G69:4=6�� D92==�36�4=2DD:7:65�2D� D6A2C2E6>@E@C�G69:4=6�H:E9�?@�A@H6C�C2E:?8

�6724:?8�@C�E2>A6C:?8�H:E9 2�D6C:2=�?F>36C ,96�6C2D:?8�� D4C2E49:?8��2=E6C:?8�@C�492?8:?8@7� E96� @C:8:?2=� 724E@CJ�:?D4C:365� D6C:2=?F>36C�@?�E96�>@E@C�G69:4=6�6?8:?6��6?8:?63=@4<� @C� 492DD:D� @7� 2?J� >@E@C� G69:4=6/96?6G6C� 2?J� >@E@C� G69:4=6� :D� 7@F?5� E@92G6� 2� D6C:2=� ?F>36C� @?� :ED� >@E@C� 6?8:?6�6?8:?6� 3=@4<� @C� 492DD:D� H9:49� :D� 5:776C6?E7C@>�E92E�H9:49�:D�=:DE65�:?�E96�C64@C5D�@7�E96�FC62F� @7� �FDE@>D� 7@C� >@E@C� G69:4=6D:>A@CE65� :?E@� E96� (9:=:AA:?6D�� E92E� >@E@CG69:4=6�D92==�36�4@?D:56C65�E@�92G6�2�5672465@C�E2>A6C65�H:E9�D6C:2=�?F>36C

*6A2:?E:?8 �92?8:?8� E96� 4@=@C� @7� 2� >@E@C� G69:4=6� 3J>62?D� @7� A2:?E:?8� ,96C6� :D� C6A2:?E:?8

�����������

Page 183: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

H96?6G6C�E96�?6H�4@=@C�@7�2�>@E@C�G69:4=6�:D5:776C6?E� 7C@>� :ED� 4@=@C� 2D� C68:DE6C65� :?� E96$2?5�,C2?DA@CE2E:@?��@>>:DD:@?

�@5J�3F:=5:?8 � ;@3� F?56CE2<6?� @?� 2� >@E@C� G69:4=6� :?@C56C� E@� C6A=246� :ED� 6?E:C6� 3@5J�H:E9� 2� ?6H3@5J

*6>@56=:?8 ,96� :?EC@5F4E:@?� @7� D@>6� 492?86D� :?� E96D92A6� @C� 7@C>� @7 E96� 3@5J� @7� E96� >@E@CG69:4=6

�:D>2?E=:?8 ,96� E62C:?8� 2A2CE�� A:646�3J�A:646�@C�A2CE�3JA2CE��@7�2�>@E@C�G69:4=6

'G6C92F=:?8 ,96� 4=62?:?8� @C� C6A2:C:?8� @7� E96� H9@=66?8:?6�@7� 2�>@E@C� G69:4=6�3J� D6A2C2E:?8� E96>@E@C�6?8:?6�2?5�:ED�A2CED�7C@>�E96�3@5J @7E96�>@E@C�G69:4=6���

44� %024>?=,?4:9

/:E9:?� @?6� J62C� 27E6C� E96� 2AAC@G2=� @7� E9:D� �4E�� 6G6CJ� @H?6C� @C� A@DD6DD@C� @7F?C68:DE6C65�>@E@C�G69:4=6�@C�A2CED�E96C6@7�:?�<?@4<�5@H?�4@?5:E:@?�D92==�C68:DE6C�H:E9�E96$2?5�,C2?DA@CE2E:@?��@>>:DD:@?�E96�>@E@C�G69:4=6�6?8:?6��6?8:?6�3=@4<�2?5�492DD:D�:?�9:D?2>6�@C� :?� E96�?2>6�@7� E96� C62=�@H?6C�H9@�D92==�36� C625:=J�2G2:=23=6� E@�2?DH6C� 2?J�4=2:>@G6C� E96� C68:DE6C65� >@E@C� G69:4=6� 6?8:?6�� 6?8:?6� 3=@4<� @C� 492DD:D� ,96C627E6C�� 2==� >@E@CG69:4=6� 6?8:?6D�� 6?8:?6� 3=@4<D� 2?5� 492DD:D� ?@E� C68:DE6C65� H:E9� E96� $2?5� ,C2?DA@CE2E:@?�@>>:DD:@?�D92==�36�4@?D:56C65�2D�F?E2I65�:>A@CE2E:@?�@C�4@>:?8�7C@>�2?�:==682=�D@FC46�@C42C?2AA65��2?5�D92==�36�4@?7:D42E65�:?�72G@C�@7�E96��@G6C?>6?E

�==�@H?6CD�@7�>@E@C�G69:4=6D� :?�2==�4:E:6D�2?5�>F?:4:A2=:E:6D�2C6�C6BF:C65�E@�C68:DE6CE96:C 42CD�H:E9�E96�=@42=�A@=:46�H:E9@FE�A2J:?8�2?J�492C86D���

���.;9��

���.;9��

Page 184: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

444� *3:�,=0�74,-70

,� �@?D�:1�.:770.?:=�:1�.@>?:8>

,96� �@==64E@C� @7� �FDE@>D� @7� 2� AC:?4:A2=� A@CE� @7� 6?ECJ� H96C6� 2?� :>A@CE65�>@E@CG69:4=6��>@E@C�G69:4=6�6?8:?6��6?8:?6�3=@4<�492DD:D�@C�3@5J�:D�F?=@2565��D92==��H:E9:?�D6G6?52JD�27E6C� E96�2CC:G2=�@7� E96� :>A@CE65�>@E@C�G69:4=6�@C�2?J�@7� :ED�A2CED�6?F>6C2E65�96C6:?�>2<6� 2� C6A@CE� @7� E96� D9:A>6?E� E@� E96� $2?5� ,C2?DA@CE2E:@?� �@>>:DD:@?�� DA64:7J:?8� E96>2<6��EJA6�2?5�D6C:2=�?F>36CD��:7�2?J��@7�E96�>@E@C G69:4=6�6?8:?6��6?8:?6�3=@4<�2?5�492DD:D@C� 3@5J�� 2?5� DE2E:?8� E96� ?2>6D� 2?5� 255C6DD6D� @7� E96� @H?6C� @C� 4@?D:8?66� E96C6@7� !7� E96>@E@C� G69:4=6� 6?8:?6�� 6?8:?6� 3=@4<�� 492DD:D� @C� 3@5J� 5@6D� ?@E� 362C� 2?J� D6C:2=� ?F>36C�� E96�@==64E@C�@7��FDE@>D�4@?46C?65�D92==�9@=5�E96�>@E@C�G69:4=6�6?8:?6��6?8:?6�3=@4<��492DD:D@C�3@5J�F?E:=�:E�:D�?F>36C65�3J�E96�$2?5�,C2?DA@CE2E:@?��@>>:DD:@?���

-� �@?D�:1�48;:=?0=>��/4>?=4-@?:=>�,9/�>0770=>

�?J�A6CD@?�6?82865�:?�E96�:>A@CE2E:@?��5:DEC:3FE:@?��2?5�3FJ:?8�2?5�D6==:?8�@7�>@E@CG69:4=6D�� >@E@C� G69:4=6� 6?8:?6D�� 6?8:?6� 3=@4<D�� 492DD:D� @C� 3@5J�� D92==� <66A� 2� A6C>2?6?EC64@C5�@7�9:D�DE@4<D��DE2E:?8�E96C6:?�E96:C�EJA6��>2<6�2?5�D6C:2=�?F>36CD��2?5�E96�?2>6D�2?5255C6DD6D�@7�E96�A6CD@?D�7C@>�H9@>�E96J�H6C6�24BF:C65�2?5�E96�?2>6D�2?5�255C6DD6D�@7�E96A6CD@?D� E@� H9@>� E96J� H6C6� D@=5�� 2?5� D92==� C6?56C� 2?� 244FC2E6� >@?E9=J� C6A@CE� @7� 9:DEC2?D24E:@?D�:?�>@E@C�G69:4=6D�E@�E96�$2?5�,C2?DA@CE2E:@?��@>>:DD:@?���

.� �70,=,9.0�,9/�;0=84?

�?J� A6CD@?�H9@� D92==� F?56CE2<6� E@� 2DD6>3=6� @C� C63F:=5� @C� 42FD6� E96� 2DD6>3=J� @CC63F:=5:?8�@7�2�>@E@C�G69:4=6�D92==�7:CDE�D64FC6�2�46CE:7:42E6�@7�4=62C2?46�7C@>�E96�(9:=:AA:?6�@?DE23F=2CJ� �2/6)$%$� ,92E�?@�DF49�A6C>:E�D92==�36�:DDF65�F?=6DD�E96�2AA=:42?E D92==�AC6D6?E2�DE2E6>6?E�F?56C�@2E9�4@?E2:?:?8�E96�EJA6��>2<6�2?5�D6C:2=�?F>36CD�@7�E96�6?8:?6��492DD:D2?5� 3@5J�� :7� 2?J�� 2?5� E96� 4@>A=6E6� =:DE� @7� E96� DA2C6� A2CED� @7� E96� >@E@C� G69:4=6� E@� 362DD6>3=65�@C�C63F:=E�E@86E96C�H:E9�E96�?2>6D�2?5�255C6DD6D�@7�E96 D@FC46D�E96C6@7

!?�E96�42D6�@7�>@E@C�G69:4=6�6?8:?6D�E@�36�>@F?E65�@?�>@E@C�3@2ED��>@E@C�32?42D

2?5�@E96C� =:89E�H2E6C�G6DD6=D�� E96�2AA=:42?E�D92==�D64FC6�2�A6C>:E�7C@>�E96�(9:=:AA:?6��@2DE

�F2C5��H9:49�@77:46�D92==�:?�EFC?�7FC?:D9�E96�$2?5�,C2?DA@CE2E:@? �@>>:DD:@?�E96�A6CE:?6?E

52E2�4@?46C?:?8�E96�>@E@C�G69:4=6�6?8:?6D�:?4=F5:?8�E96:C�EJA6��>2<6�2?5�D6C:2=�?F>36CD���

4A��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

!E�D92==�36�F?=2H7F=�7@C�2?J�A6CD@?�E@�567246�@C�@E96CH:D6�E2>A6C�H:E9�E96�@C:8:?2=�@CC68:DE6C65�D6C:2=�?F>36C�@7�>@E@C G69:4=6�6?8:?6D��6?8:?6�3=@4<D�2?5�492DD:D���

���.;9��

���.;9��

���.;9� �

�� .;9� �

Page 185: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

/� �@8,9�&0.@=4?D��.?�:1�����

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>�:1�?0==:=4>8���

0� �9?4��=>:9��,B���

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

!��CD@?��� � 2?J�A6CD@?�H9@�3FC?D�@C�D6ED�7:C6�E@�E96�AC@A6CEJ�@7�2?@E96C @C E@ 9:D@H?�AC@A6CEJ�F?56C�4:C4F>DE2?46D�H9:49�6IA@D6�E@�52?86C E96�=:76�@C�AC@A6CEJ�@7�2?@E96C

!!��6DECF4E:G6��CD@? � :7�E96�AC@A6CEJ�3FC?65�:D�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�

�� �?J� 2>>F?:E:@?� 724E@CJ� 2?5� @E96C� 6DE23=:D9>6?E� H96C6� 6IA=@D:G6D�:?7=2>>23=6�@C�4@>3FDE:3=6�>2E6C:2=D�2C6�DE@C65

��?J�2C49:G6��>FD6F>��H96E96C�AF3=:4�@C�AC:G2E6��@C�2?J�65:7:46�56G@E65�E@4F=EFC6��65F42E:@?�@C�D@4:2=�D6CG:46D

���?J� 49FC49� @C A=246� @7�H@CD9:A� @C� @E96C� 3F:=5:?8�H96C6� A6@A=6� FDF2==J2DD6>3=6

� �?J�EC2:?��2:CA=2?6�@C�2?J�2:C4C27E��G6DD6=�@C�H2E6C4C27E��@C�4@?G6J2?46�7@CEC2?DA@CE2E:@?�@7�A6CD@?D�@C�AC@A6CEJ

�� �?J� 3F:=5:?8� H96C6� 6G:56?46� :D� <6AE� 7@C� FD6� :?� 2?J� =68:D=2E:G6�� ;F5:4:2=�25>:?:DEC2E:G6�@C�@E96C�@77:4:2=�AC@4665:?8D

���?J�9@DA:E2=��9@E6=��5@C>:E@CJ��=@58:?8�9@FD6��9@FD:?8�E6?6>6?E��D9@AA:?846?E6C�� AF3=:4� @C� AC:G2E6� >2C<6E�� E962E6C� @C� >@G:6� 9@FD6� @C� 2?J� D:>:=2C� A=246� @C3F:=5:?8

���?J�3F:=5:?8��H96E96C�FD65�2D 2�5H6==:?8�@C�?@E��D:EF2E65�:?�2�A@AF=2E65�@C4@?86DE65�2C62���

!!!� �@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E��CD@?���

������������

���IKFH7

�����������

���.;9�

���.;9��

���.;9��

Page 186: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�� �>591?��3-5:?@��4-?@5@E

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED

�0A8@1>E��� 2 ,96�H@>2?�:D�>2CC:65���

3 +96�92D�D6IF2= :?E6C4@FCD6�H:E9�2�>2?�?@E�96C�9FD32?5

4 �D� C682C5D� E96� >2?� H:E9� H9@>� D96� 92D� D6IF2=:?E6C4@FCD6D��96�>FDE�<?@H�96C�E@�36�>2CC:65

�;:/A.5:-31��� 2 ,96�>2?�>FDE�36�>2CC:65

3 6�4@>>:EE65�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

� #66A:?8�2�>:DEC6DD�:?�E96 4@?;F82=�5H6==:?8

2G:?8� D6IF2=� :?E6C4@FCD6� F?56C� D42?52=@FD4:C4F>DE2?46D�H:E9�2�H@>2?�H9@�:D�?@E�9:D�H:76

� �@923:E:?8�H:E9�96C�:?�2?J�@E96C�A=246

4 �D�C682C5D�E96�H@>2?��D96�>FDE�<?@H�9:>�E@�36�>2CC:65

�/@?�;2�8-?/5B5;A?:1??��� 2 '776?56C�4@>>:ED�2?J�24E�@7�=2D4:G:@FD?6DD�@C�=6H5?6DD

3 �@?6�F?56C�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46D�

� 3J�FD:?8�7@C46�@C�:?E:>:52E:@?��@C

H96?� E96� @776?565� A2CEJ� :D� 56AC:G65� @7� C62D@?� @C@E96CH:D6�F?4@?D4:@FD��@C

� H96?�E96�@776?565 A2CEJ�:D�F?56C�� �J62CD�@7�286

����HJ����

(?J?=7J;:�?<�M?<;�M7I�787D:ED;:�M?J>EKJ� @KIJ?<?97J?ED�8O�J>;�E<<;D:;:�IFEKI;��C7D�?I�DEJ�;DJ?JB;:�JE

J>?I�C?J?=7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;�

�JJ;CFJ;:��97K=>J�:?IHE8?D=�7�BEL;H���

;L;D�?<�C7HH?7=;�IK8I;GK;DJBO�:;9B7H;:�LE?:���

�HJ����

Z.97D:7B[� 9EDI?IJI ?D� 7DO� H;FH;>;DI?8B;� MEH:�:;;:� J>7J� E<<;D:I� FK8B?9� 9EDI9?;D9;�� H;:EKD:I� JE� J>;

:;JH?C;DJ�E<� J>;� <;;B?D=I�E<�>ED;IJ�F;HIEDI�7D:�=?L;I�E997I?EDI�JE�J>;�D;?=>8EHYI�IF?H?JK7B�:7C7=;�7D:

HK?D��

�HJ����

Page 187: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

4 '776?565�A2CEJ�:D�2?@E96C�A6CD@?�@7�6:E96C�D6I

%A-852510�?10A/@5;:��

� +65F4E:@?�@7� 2� G:C8:?�@G6C� � 2?5�F?56C����J62CD�@7�286�3J�46CE2:?A6CD@?D�� DF49� 2D� 2� A6CD@?� :?2FE9@C:EJ��AC:6DE��E62496CD�6E4�2?5

+65F4E:@?� @7� 2� D:DE6C� 3J� 96C3C@E96C� @C� 56D46?52?E� 3J� 96C2D46?52?E�� C682C5=6DD� @7� 96C� 286� @CC6AFE2E:@?���

2� '776?565� A2CEJ� :D� 2� G:C8:?�� H9:49� :D� � AC6DF>65� :7� D96F?>2CC:65�2?5�@7�8@@5�C6AFE2E:@?

3�� 6�>FDE�36�@G6C�� �2?5�F?56C����J62CD�@7�286

5 '776?56C�92D�D6IF2=�:?E6C4@FCD6�H:E9�96C

6 ,96C6� :D� 23FD6� @7� 2FE9@C:EJ�� 4@?7:56?46� @C� C6=2E:@?D9:A@?�E96�A2CE�@7�E96�@776?56C���

'59<81�?10A/@5;:��� 2 '776?565�A2CEJ�:D�@G6C�� �2?5�F?56C����J62CD�@7�286

3 +96�>FDE�36�@7�8@@5�C6AFE2E:@?��D:?8=6�@C H:5@H

4 '776?56C�92D�D6IF2=�:?E6C4@FCD6�H:E9�96C

5 !E�:D�4@>>:EE65�3J�>62?D�@7�5646:E

�/@?� ;2� 8-?/5B5;A?:1??� C5@4� @41/;:?1:@�;2�@41�;221:010�<->@E���

2 '776?56C�4@>>:ED�24ED�@7�=2D4:G:@FD?6DD�@C�=6H5?6DD

3 ,96�24ED�2C6�4@>>:EE65�FA@?�2�H@>2?�H9@� :D�G:C8:?�@C

����HJ����

+;HIEDI�B?78B;�

/>EI;�M>E�78KI;�J>;?H�7KJ>EH?JO�

7 F;HIEDI�?D�FK8B?9�7KJ>EH?JO

8 =K7H:?7D

9 J;79>;H

: F;HIED�M>E��?D�7DO�97F79?JO��?I�;DJHKIJ;:�M?J>�J>;�;:K97J?ED�EH�9KIJE:O�E<�J>;�MEC7D�I;:K9;:

� />EI;�M>E 78KI;:�J>;�9ED<?:;D9;�H;FEI;:�?D�J>;C�

7 FH?;IJ

8 >EKI;�I;HL7DJ

9 :EC;IJ?9

� />EI; M>E�78KI;:�J>;?H�H;B7J?EDI>?F�

7�8HEJ>;H�M>E�I;:K9;:�>?I�I?IJ;H

8 7I9;D:7DJ�M>E�I;:K9;:�>?I�:;I9;D:7DJ���

?D9;IJKEKI�I;:K9J?ED���

F;HIED�;DJHKIJ;:�M?J>�;:K97J?ED�EH�9KIJE:O�E<�L?9J?C��F;HIED�?D�FK8B?9�7KJ>EH?JO��FH?;IJ��I;HL7DJ���

�HJ����

�ECCED�<EHC�?I�KD9ED:?J?ED7B�FHEC?I;�JE�C7HHO���

�HJ����

Page 188: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

D:?8=6�@C�H:5@H�@7� 8@@5� C6AFE2E:@?�� F?56C� ��� J62CD�@7� 2863FE�@G6C�� �J62CD��@C�2�D:DE6C�@C�56D46?52?E�C682C5=6DD�@7�96CC6AFE2E:@?�@C�286

4 '776?56C� 244@>A=:D96D� E96� 24ED� 3J� 23FD6� @7� 2FE9@C:EJ�4@?7:56?46��C6=2E:@?D9:A��@C�5646:E

�;>>A<@5;:�;2�95:;>?��� (C@>@E:?8� @C� 724:=:E2E:?8� E96� AC@DE:EFE:@?� @C� 4@CCFAE:@?� @7A6CD@?D�F?56C286�E@�D2E:D7J�E96�=FDE�@7�2?@E96C

+45@1�?8-B1�@>-01��� 2 �?828:?8�:?�E96�3FD:?6DD�@7�AC@DE:EFE:@?

3 (C@7:E:?8�3J AC@DE:EFE:@?

4 �?=:DE:?8� E96� D6CG:4I6� @7� H@>6?� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7AC@DE:EFE:@?

�;>/5.81�-.0A/@5;:��� 2 ,96�A6CD@?�235F4E65�:D�2?J�H@>2?��C682C5=6DD�@7�96C�286�4:G:=�DE2EFD��@C�C6AFE2E:@?

3 ,96�235F4E:@?�:D�282:?DE�96C�H:==

4 ,96 235F4E:@?�:D H:E9�=6H5�56D:8?D

�;:?1:@10�-.0A/@5;:�� 2 '776?565�A2CEJ�>FDE�36�2�G:C8:?

3 +96�>FDE�36�@G6C�� �2?5�F?56C����J62CD�@7�286

4 ,96�E2<:?8�2H2J�@7�E96�@776?565�A2CEJ�>FDE��36�H:E9�96C4@?D6?E��27E6C�D@=:4:E2E:@?�@C�42;@=6CJ�7C@>�E96�@776?56C

,96 E2<:?8� 2H2J� @7� E96� @776?565� A2CEJ�>FDE� 36� H:E9� =6H556D:8?D

����HJ����

����HJ���

����HJ����

.;NK7B�?DJ;H9EKHI;�?I�DEJ�D;9;II7HO

�4+/'5�#)#+056�%*#56+6;�9*'4'�#)'�#0&�4'276#6+10�1(�8+%6+/�#4'�+//#6'4+#.�

H7F;��79JI�E<�B7I9?L?EKID;II��GK7B?<?;:�I;:K9J?ED�E<�I?IJ;H�:;I9;D:7DJ��<EH9?8B;�78:K9J?ED���

�HJ����

Page 189: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�5F=E6CJ��4@?4F3:?286��D65F4E:@?��235F4E:@?�C2A6�2?5�24ED�@7�=2D4:G:@FD?6DD���

� (C@D64FE:@?�@7 �5F=E6CJ�2?5�4@?4F3:?286�>FDE�36�AC@D64FE65�FA@?4@>A=2:?E 7:=65�3J�E96�@776?565�DA@FD6

+65F4E:@?� 235F4E:@?�� C2A6�� @C� 24ED� @7� =2D4:G:@FD?6DD� >FDE� 36AC@D64FE65�FA@?�4@>A=2:?E 7:=65�3J�

2 @776?565�A2CEJ

3 96C�A2C6?ED

4 8C2?5A2C6?ED

5 8F2C5:2?D�:?�E96�@C56C�:?�H9:49�E96J�2C6�?2>65�23@G6

�:G:=�=:23:=:EJ�@7�A6CD@?D�8F:=EJ�@7�C2A6��D65F4E:@?�@C�235F4E:@?���

� ,@�:56>?:7J�E96�@776?565�H@>6?

,@� 24<?@H=6586� E96� @77DAC:?8�� F?=6DD� E96� =2H� D9@F=5� AC6G6?E� 9:>7C@>�5@:?8�D@

� !?�6G6CJ�42D6�E@�DFAA@CE�E96�@77DAC:?8

$:23:=:EJ�@7�2D46?52?ED��@E96C�A6CD@?D�6?ECFDE65�H:E9�4FDE@5J�@7�@776?565�A2CEJ�H9@3J�23FD6�@7 2FE9@C:EJ�@C�4@?7:56?46�D92==�4@@A6C2E6�2D�244@>A=:6D���

�� �HJ����

(7HH?7=;�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;H�M?J>�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO�;NJ?D=K?I>;I�J>;�9H?C?D7B�79J?ED�EH�H;C?J�J>;�F;D7BJO

7BH;7:O� ?CFEI;:� KFED� >?C� />?I� 7FFB?;I� 7I� M;BB� JE� J>;� 799ECFB?9;I�� 799;IIEH?;I7<J;HJ>;<79J� �KJ

C7HH?7=;I�CKIJ�8;�?D�=EE:�<7?J>�/>?I�HKB;�:E;I�DEJ�7FFBO�?D�97I;�E<�CKBJ?FB;�H7F;���

)EJ�?D9BK:;:��I;;��HJ��������D:

F7H����

�HJ�������

�HJ������I;;�-;<;H;D9;

Page 190: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

,� �9?4�#3:?:�,9/�)4/0:�):D0@=4>8��.?�:1������

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

�2��,@� E2<6� A9@E@� @C� G:56@� 4@G6C286� @7� 2� A6CD@?�@C� 8C@FA�@7� A6CD@?D� A6C7@C>:?8D6IF2=�24E�@C�2?J�D:>:=2C�24E:G:EJ�@C�E@�42AEFC6 2?�:>286�@7�E96�AC:G2E6�2C62�@7�2�A6CD@?D�DF492D� E96�?2<65�@C�F?56C82C>6?E�4=25�86?:E2=D��AF3=:4�2C62��3FEE@4<D�@C� 76>2=6�3C62DE�H:E9@FEE96� 4@?D6?E� @7� E96� A6CD@?D� :?G@=G65� 2?5� F?56C� 4:C4F>DE2?46D� :?� H9:49� E96� A6CD@?D92D92G6�2�C62D@?23=6�6IA64E2E:@? @7�AC:G24J�

�3��,@�4@AJ�@C� C6AC@5F46��@C� E@�42FD6� E@�36�4@A:65�@C� C6AC@5F465�� DF49�A9@E@�@CG:56@�@C�C64@C5:?8�@7�D6IF2=�24E�@C�2?J�D:>:=2C�24E:G:EJ�H:E9�@C�H:E9@FE�4@?D:56C2E:@?�

�4��,@�D6==�@C�5:DEC:3FE6��@C�42FD6�E@�36�D@=5�@C�5:DEC:3FE65��DF49�A9@E@�@C�G:56@�@CC64@C5:?8�@7�D6IF2=�24E��H96E96C�:E�36�E96�@C:8:?2=�4@AJ�@C�C6AC@5F4E:@?�E96C6@7��@C

�5��,@�AF3=:D9�@C�3C@2542DE��@C�42FD6�E@�36�AF3=:D965�@C�3C@2542DE��H96E96C�:?�AC:?E@C�3C@2542DE�>65:2��@C�D9@H�@C�6I9:3:E� E96�A9@E@�@C�G:56@�4@G6C286�@C�C64@C5:?8D�@7�DF49D6IF2=� 24E� @C� 2?J� D:>:=2C� 24E:G:EJ� E9C@F89�.���.��� :?E6C?6E�� 46==F=2C� A9@?6D� 2?5� @E96CD:>:=2C�>62?D�@C�56G:46

,96� AC@9:3:E:@?� F?56C� A2C28C2A9D� �3��� �4�� 2?5� �5�� D92==� 2AA=J� ?@EH:E9DE2?5:?8� E92E4@?D6?E�E@�C64@C5�@C�E2<6�A9@E@�@C�G:56@ 4@G6C286�@7�E96�D2>6�H2D�8:G6?�3J�DF49�A6CD@?D�?J� A6CD@?� H9@� G:@=2E6D� E9:D� AC@G:D:@?� D92==� 36� =:23=6� 7@C� A9@E@� @C� G:56@� G@J6FC:D>� 2D567:?65�96C6:?

-� &;0.4,7�#=:?0.?4:9�:1��347/=09��2,49>?��347/��-@>0���C;7:4?,?4:9��,9/

�4>.=4849,?4:9��.? ���

4���347/�;=:>?4?@?4:9�,9/�:?30=�,.?>�:1�,-@>0

,��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

�2�� ,9@D6�H9@� 6?8286� :?� @C� AC@>@E6�� 724:=:E2E6� @C� :?5F46� 49:=5� AC@DE:EFE:@?�H9:49:?4=F56��3FE�2C6�?@E�=:>:E65�E@��E96�7@==@H:?8�

�����4E:?8�2D�2�AC@4FC6C�@7�2�49:=5�AC@DE:EFE6�

� ��!?5F4:?8�2�A6CD@? E@�36�2�4=:6?E�@7�2�49:=5�AC@DE:EFE6�3J�>62?D�@7�HC:EE6?@C�@C2=�25G6CE:D6>6?ED�@C�@E96C�D:>:=2C�>62?D�

���� ,2<:?8� 25G2?E286� @7� :?7=F6?46� @C� C6=2E:@?D9:A� E@� AC@4FC6� 2� 49:=5� 2DAC@DE:EFE6�

���-������

���-���� ���7I�7C;D:;:

Page 191: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

���� ,9C62E6?:?8� @C� FD:?8� G:@=6?46� E@H2C5D� 2� 49:=5� E@� 6?8286� 9:>� 2D 2AC@DE:EFE6��@C

���� �:G:?8� >@?6E2CJ� 4@?D:56C2E:@?� 8@@5D� @C� @E96C� A64F?:2CJ� 36?67:E� E@� 249:=5�H:E9�:?E6?E�E@�6?8286�DF49�49:=5�:?�AC@DE:EFE:@?

�3�� ,9@D6�H9@� 4@>>:E� E96� 24E� @7� D6IF2=� :?E6C4@FCD6� @7� =2D4:G:@FD� 4@?5F4E� H:E9� 249:=5�6IA=@:E65�:? AC@DE:EFE:@?�@C DF3;64E�E@�@E96C�D6IF2=�23FD6���� 2?5

�4��,9@D6�H9@ 56C:G6�AC@7:E�@C�25G2?E286�E96C67C@>��H96E96C�2D�>2?286C�@C�@H?6C@7� E96�6DE23=:D9>6?E�H96C6� E96�AC@DE:EFE:@?� E2<6D�A=246��@C�@7� E96�D2F?2��5:D4@��32C�� C6D@CE�A=246�@7�6?E6CE2:?>6?E�@C�6DE23=:D9>6?E�D6CG:?8�2D�2�4@G6C�@C�H9:49�6?8286D�:?�AC@DE:EFE:@?:? 255:E:@?�E@�E96�24E:G:EJ�7@C�H9:49�E96�=:46?D6�92D�366?�:DDF65�E@�D2:5�6DE23=:D9>6?E���

-���:8;,=0� ;=:>0.@?4:9� 1:=��.?> :1� �,>.4A4:@>90>>� @9/0=

�=?�������%#��,9/�%������,>�,809/0/

-?56C�*(�� -?56C�*�������

�4ED�@7�=2D4:G:@FD?6DD�>FDE�36AC@D64FE65�FA@?�4@>A=2:?E�7:=65�3J�

� @776?565�A2CEJ�

96C�A2C6?ED�

� 8C2?5A2C6?ED�

� 8F2C5:2?D���

�@>A=2:?ED� @?� 42D6D� @7� F?=2H7F=� 24ED4@>>:EE65� 282:?DE� E96� 49:=5C6?� 2D6?F>6C2E65� 96C6:?� >2J� 36� 7:=65� 3J� E967@==@H:?8�

� '776?565�A2CEJ�

��(2C6?ED�@C�8F2C5:2?D�

�� � �D46?52?E� @C� 4@==2E6C2=� C6=2E:G6� H:E9:?E96�E9:C5�568C66�@7�4@?D2?8F:?:EJ�

�� �'77:46C�� D@4:2=�H@C<6C� @C� C6AC6D6?E2E:G6@7�2�=:46?D65�49:=5�42C:?8�:?DE:EFE:@?�

�� � � '77:46C� @C� D@4:2=� H@C<6C� @7� E96�6A2CE>6?E� @7� +@4:2=� /6=72C6� 2?5�6G6=@A>6?E�

����2C2?82J�492:C>2?��@C�� ��E� =62DE� E9C66�����4@?46C?65�C6DA@?D:3=64:E:K6?D�H96C6�E96�G:@=2E:@?�@44FCC65���

���2>;D�J>;�L?9J?CI�?I�KD:;H�JM;BL;�� ���O;7HI�E<�7=;��J>;�F;HF;JH7JEHI�I>7BB�8;�FHEI;9KJ;:�KD:;H��HJ?9B;

���� F7H7=H7F>����<EH�H7F;�7D:��HJ?9B;�����E<��9J�)E��� ���7I�7C;D:;:��J>;�-;L?I;:�+;D7B��E:;��<EH�H7F;

EH�B7I9?L?EKI�9ED:K9J��7I�J>;�97I;�C7O�8;��+HEL?:;:��/>7J�J>;�F;D7BJO�<EH�B7I9?L?EKI�9ED:K9J�M>;D�J>;

L?9J?C�?I�KD:;H�JM;BL;�� ���O;7HI�E<�7=;�I>7BB�8;�H;9BKI?ED�J;CFEH7B�?D�?JI�C;:?KC�F;H?E:���

.;9�����

?D�J>;�EH:;H�?D�M>?9>�J>;O�7H;�D7C;:

Page 192: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

44��"->.090�#@-74.,?4:9>�,9/�49/0.09?�>3:B>

,��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

�?J� A6CD@?� H9@� D92==� 9:C6�� 6>A=@J�� FD6�� A6CDF256�� :?5F46� @C� 4@6C46� 2� 49:=5� E@A6C7@C>� :?�@3D46?6�6I9:3:E:@?D�2?5� :?5646?E�D9@HD��H96E96C� =:G6�@C� :?�G:56@��@C�>@56=� :?@3D46?6�AF3=:42E:@?D�@C�A@C?@8C2A9:4�>2E6C:2=D�@C�E@�D6==�@C�5:DEC:3FE6�E96�D2:5�>2E6C:2=D�D92==DF776C�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7 02)3)/.�-!9/2 :?�:ED�>65:F>�A6C:@5

!7� E96� 49:=5� FD65� 2D� 2� A6C7@C>6C�� DF3;64E� @C� D6==6C5:DEC:3FE@C� :D� 36=@H� EH6=G6� �� �J62CD�@7�286��E96�A6?2=EJ�D92==�36�:>A@D65�:?�:ED�>2I:>F>�A6C:@5

�?J�2D46?52?E��8F2C5:2?��@C�A6CD@?�6?ECFDE65�:?�2?J�42A24:EJ�H:E9�E96�42C6�@7�2�49:=5H9@�D92==�42FD6�2?5@C�2==@H�DF49�49:=5�E@�36�6>A=@J65�@C�E@�A2CE:4:A2E6�:?�2?�@3D46?6�A=2J�D46?6��24E��>@G:6�@C�D9@H�@C�:?�2?J�@E96C�24ED�4@G6C65�3J�E9:D�D64E:@?�D92== DF776C�E96�A6?2=EJ@7 02)3)/.�-!9/2 :?�:ED�>65:F>�A6C:@5���

4 �?E:�,C277:4<:?8�:?�(6CD@?D��4E�@7� �����

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

!E� D92==� 36� F?=2H7F=� 7@C� 2?J� A6CD@?�� ?2EFC2=� @C� ;FC:5:42=�� E@� 4@>>:E� 2?J� @7� E967@==@H:?8�24ED�

�2��,@�C64CF:E��EC2?DA@CE��EC2?D76C� 92C3@C��AC@G:56��@C�C646:G6�2�A6CD@?�3J�2?J�>62?D�:?4=F5:?8�E9@D6�5@?6�F?56C�E96�AC6E6IE�@7�5@>6DE:4�@C�@G6CD62D�6>A=@J>6?E�@C�EC2:?:?8�@C2AAC6?E:46D9:A�� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7� AC@DE:EFE:@?�� A@C?@8C2A9J�� D6IF2=� 6IA=@:E2E:@?�� 7@C465=23@C��D=2G6CJ��:?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56�@C�563E�3@?5286�

�3�� ,@� :?EC@5F46� @C� >2E49� 7@C� >@?6J�� AC@7:E�� @C� >2E6C:2=�� 64@?@>:4� @C� @E96C4@?D:56C2E:@?�� 2?J� A6CD@?� @C�� 2D� AC@G:565� 7@C� F?56C�*6AF3=:4��4E�&@� ������ 2?J� �:=:A:?@H@>2?� E@� 2� 7@C6:8?� ?2E:@?2=�� 7@C�>2CC:286� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7� 24BF:C:?8�� 3FJ:?8�� @776C:?8�D6==:?8�@C�EC25:?8�9:>96C�E@�6?8286�:?�AC@DE:EFE:@?��A@C?@8C2A9J��D6IF2=�6IA=@:E2E:@?��7@C465=23@C��D=2G6CJ��:?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56�@C�563E�3@?5286�

�4�� ,@� @776C� @C� 4@?EC24E�>2CC:286�� C62=� @C� D:>F=2E65�� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7� 24BF:C:?8�3FJ:?8�� @776C:?8�� D6==:?8�� @C� EC25:?8� E96>� E@� 6?8286� :?� AC@DE:EFE:@?�� A@C?@8C2A9J�� D6IF2=6IA=@:E2E:@?��7@C465�=23@C�@C�D=2G6CJ��:?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56�@C�563E�3@?5286�

�5��,@�F?56CE2<6�@C�@C82?:K6�E@FCD�2?5�EC2G6=�A=2?D�4@?D:DE:?8�@7�E@FC:D>�A24<286D @C24E:G:E:6D�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�FE:=:K:?8�2?5�@776C:?8�A6CD@?D�7@C�AC@DE:EFE:@?��A@C?@8C2A9J�@CD6IF2=�6IA=@:E2E:@?�

�6��,@�>2:?E2:?�@C�9:C6�2�A6CD@?�E@�6?8286�:?�AC@DE:EFE:@?�@C�A@C?@8C2A9J�

���.;9���

�� .;9��

���-������

Page 193: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�7�� ,@� 25@AE� @C� 724:=:E2E6� E96� 25@AE:@?� @7� A6CD@?D� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7� AC@DE:EFE:@?�A@C?@8C2A9J�� D6IF2=� 6IA=@:E2E:@?�� 7@C465� =23@C�� D=2G6CJ�� :?G@=F?E2CJ� D6CG:EF56� @C� 563E3@?5286�

�8��,@�C64CF:E��9:C6��25@AE��EC2?DA@CE�@C�235F4E�2�A6CD@?��3J�>62?D�@7�E9C62E�@C�FD6�@77@C46��7C2F5��5646:E��G:@=6?46��4@6C4:@?��@C�:?E:>:52E:@?�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�C6>@G2=�@C�D2=6�@7@C82?D�@7�D2:5�A6CD@?��2?5

�9�� ,@� C64CF:E�� EC2?DA@CE� @C� 25@AE� 2� 49:=5� E@� 6?8286� :?� 2C>65� 24E:G:E:6D� :?� E96(9:=:AA:?6D�@C�23C@25���

,96� 7@==@H:?8� 24ED� H9:49� AC@>@E6� @C� 724:=:E2E6� EC277:4<:?8� :?� A6CD@?D�� D92==� 36F?=2H7F=�

�2��,@�<?@H:?8=J� =62D6�@C�DF3=62D6��FD6�@C�2==@H�E@�36�FD65�2?J�9@FD6��3F:=5:?8�@C6DE23=:D9>6?E�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�AC@>@E:?8�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D�

�3��,@�AC@5F46��AC:?E�2?5�:DDF6�@C�5:DEC:3FE6�F?:DDF65��E2>A6C65�@C�72<6�4@F?D6=:?846CE:7:42E6D��C68:DEC2E:@?�DE:4<6CD�2?5�46CE:7:42E6D�@7�2?J�8@G6C?>6?E�286?4J�H9:49�:DDF6D�E96D646CE:7:42E6D� 2?5� DE:4<6CD� 2D� AC@@7� @7� 4@>A=:2?46� H:E9� 8@G6C?>6?E� C68F=2E@CJ� 2?5� AC6�56A2CEFC6�C6BF:C6>6?ED�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�AC@>@E:?8�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D�

�4��,@�25G6CE:D6��AF3=:D9��AC:?E��3C@2542DE�@C�5:DEC:3FE6��@C�42FD6� E96�25G6CE:D6>6?E�AF3=:42E:@?�� AC:?E:?8�� 3C@2542DE:?8� @C� 5:DEC:3FE:@?� 3J� 2?J� >62?D�� :?4=F5:?8� E96� FD6� @7:?7@C>2E:@?�E649?@=@8J�2?5�E96�:?E6C?6E��@7�2?J�3C@49FC6��7=J6C��@C�2?J�AC@A282?52�>2E6C:2=E92E�AC@>@E6D�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D�

�5��,@�2DD:DE�:?�E96�4@?5F4E�@7�>:DC6AC6D6?E2E:@?�@C�7C2F5�7@C�AFCA@D6D�@7�724:=:E2E:?8E96�24BF:D:E:@?�@7�4=62C2?46D�2?5�?646DD2CJ�6I:E�5@4F>6?ED� 7C@>�8@G6C?>6?E�286?4:6D� E92E2C6�>2?52E65�E@�AC@G:56�AC6�56A2CEFC6�C68:DEC2E:@?�2?5�D6CG:46D�7@C�56A2CE:?8�A6CD@?D�7@C�E96AFCA@D6�@7�AC@>@E:?8�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D�

�6��,@�724:=:E2E6��2DD:DE�@C�96=A�:?�E96�6I:E�2?5�6?ECJ�@7�A6CD@?D�7C@>E@�E96�4@F?ECJ�2E:?E6C?2E:@?2=�2?5�=@42=�2:CA@CED��E6CC:E@C:2=�3@F?52C:6D�2?5�D62A@CED H9@�2C6�:?�A@DD6DD:@?�@7F?:DDF65��E2>A6C65�@C�7C2F5F=6?E�EC2G6=�5@4F>6?ED�7@C�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�AC@>@E:?8�EC277:4<:?8:?�A6CD@?D�

�7�� ,@� 4@?7:D42E6�� 4@?462=�� @C� 56DEC@J� E96� A2DDA@CE�� EC2G6=� 5@4F>6?ED�� @C� A6CD@?2=5@4F>6?ED� @C� 36=@?8:?8D� @7� EC277:4<65� A6CD@?D� :?� 7FCE96C2?46� @7� EC277:4<:?8� @C� E@� AC6G6?EE96>� 7C@>� =62G:?8� E96� 4@F?ECJ� @C� D66<:?8� C65C6DD� 7C@>� E96� 8@G6C?>6?E� @C� 2AAC@AC:2E6286?4:6D��2?5

�8��,@�<?@H:?8=J�36?67:E�7C@>��7:?2?4:2=�@C�@E96CH:D6��@C�>2<6�FD6�@7�� E96�=23@C�@CD6CG:46D� @7� 2� A6CD@?� 96=5� E@ 2� 4@?5:E:@?� @7� :?G@=F?E2CJ� D6CG:EF56�� 7@C465� =23@C�� @CD=2G6CJ���

����9JI�E<�/H7<<?9A?D=�?D�+;HIEDI �.;9���

����9JI�J>7J +HECEJ;�/H7<<?9A?D=�?D�+;HIEDI��.;9���

Page 194: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

,96�7@==@H:?8�2C6�4@?D:56C65�2D�BF2=:7:65�EC277:4<:?8�

�2��/96?�E96�EC277:4<65�A6CD@?�:D�2�49:=5�

�3��/96?�E96�25@AE:@?�:D�67764E65�E9C@F89�*6AF3=:4��4E�&@�������@E96CH:D6�<?@H?2D� E96 �!?E6C��@F?ECJ� �5@AE:@?� �4E� @7� ������ 2?5� D2:5� 25@AE:@?� :D� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @7AC@DE:EFE:@?��A@C?@8C2A9J��D6IF2=�6IA=@:E2E:@?��7@C465�=23@C��D=2G6CJ��:?G@=F?E2CJ�D6CG:EF56�@C563E�3@?5286�

�4��/96?�E96�4C:>6�:D�4@>>:EE65�3J�2�DJ?5:42E6��@C�:?�=2C86�D42=6���

�5��/96?� E96� @776?56C� :D� 2?� 2D46?52?E�� A2C6?E�� D:3=:?8�� 8F2C5:2?� @C� 2� A6CD@?�H9@6I6C4:D6D�2FE9@C:EJ�@G6C�E96�EC277:4<65�A6CD@?�@C�H96?�E96�@776?D6�:D�4@>>:EE65�3J�2�AF3=:4@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66�

�6�� /96?� E96� EC277:4<65� A6CD@?� :D� C64CF:E65� E@� 6?8286� :?� AC@DE:EFE:@?� H:E9� 2?J>6>36C�@7�E96�>:=:E2CJ�@C�=2H�6?7@C46>6?E�286?4:6D�

�7��/96?�E96�@776?56C�:D�2�>6>36C�@7�E96�>:=:E2CJ�@C�=2H�6?7@C46>6?E�286?4:6D��2?5

�8��/96?�3J�C62D@?�@C�@?�@442D:@?�@7�E96�24E�@7�EC277:4<:?8�:?�A6CD@?D��E96�@776?565A2CEJ�5:6D��364@>6D :?D2?6��DF776CD�>FE:=2E:@?�@C�:D�277=:4E65�H:E9� F>2?�!>>F?@567:4:6?4J.:CFD�� !.��@C�E96��4BF:C65�!>>F?6��67:4:6?4J�+J?5C@>6���!�+����

���/H7<<?9A?D=�?I�:;;C;:�9ECC?JJ;:�8O�7�IOD:?97J;�?<�97HH?;:�EKJ�8O�7�=HEKF�E<�J>H;;�����EH�CEH;�F;HIEDI

9EDIF?H?D=�EH�9ED<;:;H7J?D=�M?J>�ED;�7DEJ>;H

$J�?I�:;;C;:�9ECC?JJ;:�?D�B7H=;�I97B;�?<�9ECC?JJ;:�7=7?DIJ�J>H;;�����EH�CEH;�F;HIEDI��?D:?L?:K7BBO�EH 7I

7�=HEKF����

,K7B?<?;:�/H7<<?9A?D=�?D�+;HIEDI �.;9���

Page 195: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

/� �9?4�)4:709.0�,2,49>?�*:809�,9/�?304=��347/=09��.?�:1�� ��

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

�2���2FD:?8�A9JD:42=�92C>�E@ E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�

�3��,9C62E6?:?8�E@�42FD6�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�A9JD:42=�92C>�

�4���EE6>AE:?8�E@�42FD6�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�A9JD:42=�92C>�

�5��(=24:?8�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�:?�762C�@7�:>>:?6?E�A9JD:42=�92C>�

�6�� �EE6>AE:?8� E@� 4@>A6=� @C� 4@>A6==:?8� E96� H@>2?� @C� 96C� 49:=5� E@� 6?8286� :?4@?5F4E�H9:49�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�92D�E96�C:89E�E@�56D:DE�7C@>�@C�56D:DE�7C@>�4@?5F4EH9:49� E96� H@>2?� @C� 96C� 49:=5� 92D� E96� C:89E� E@� 6?8286� :?�� @C� 2EE6>AE:?8� E@� C6DEC:4E� @CC6DEC:4E:?8�E96�H@>2?�D�@C�96C�49:=5�D�7C665@>�@7�>@G6>6?E�@C�4@?5F4E�3J�7@C46�@C�E9C62E�@77@C46��A9JD:42=�@C�@E96C�92C>�@C� E9C62E�@7�A9JD:42=�@C�@E96C�92C>��@C� :?E:>:52E:@?�5:C64E65282:?DE�E96�H@>2?�@C�49:=5

,9:D�D92==�:?4=F56��3FE�?@E�=:>:E65�E@��E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�4@>>:EE65�H:E9�E96�AFCA@D6@C�67764E�@7�4@?EC@==:?8�@C�C6DEC:4E:?8�E96�H@>2?�D�@C�96C�49:=5�D�>@G6>6?E�@C�4@?5F4E�

����,9C62E6?:?8� E@�56AC:G6�@C� 24EF2==J�56AC:G:?8� E96�H@>2?�@C�96C� 49:=5�@74FDE@5J�E@�96C9:D�72>:=J�

� �� �6AC:G:?8� @C� E9C62E6?:?8� E@� 56AC:G6� E96� H@>2?� @C� 96C� 49:=5C6?� @77:?2?4:2=�DFAA@CE�=682==J�5F6�96C�@C�96C�72>:=J��@C�56=:36C2E6=J�AC@G:5:?8�E96�H@>2?�D49:=5C6?�:?DF77:4:6?E�7:?2?4:2=�DFAA@CE�

�����6AC:G:?8� @C� E9C62E6?:?8� E@� 56AC:G6� E96�H@>2?� @C� 96C� 49:=5� @7� 2� =682=C:89E�

���� (C6G6?E:?8� E96� H@>2?� :?� 6?828:?8� :?� 2?J� =68:E:>2E6� AC@76DD:@?�@44FA2E:@?�� 3FD:?6DD� @C� 24E:G:EJ� @C� 4@?EC@==:?8� E96� G:4E:>�D� @H?� >@?�6J� @CAC@A6CE:6D��@C�D@=6=J�4@?EC@==:?8�E96�4@?;F82=�@C�4@>>@?�>@?6J��@C�AC@A6CE:6D�

�7�� !?7=:4E:?8� @C� E9C62E6?:?8� E@� :?7=:4E� A9JD:42=� 92C>� @?� @?6D6=7� 7@C� E96� AFCA@D6� @74@?EC@==:?8�96C�24E:@?D�@C�564:D:@?D�

�8���2FD:?8�@C�2EE6>AE:?8�E@�42FD6�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�E@�6?8286� :?�2?J�D6IF2=24E:G:EJ�H9:49�5@6D�?@E�4@?DE:EFE6�C2A6��3J�7@C46�@C�E9C62E�@7�7@C46��A9JD:42=�92C>� @C�E9C@F89:?E:>:52E:@?�5:C64E65�282:?DE�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�@C�96C9:D�:>>65:2E6�72>:=J�

���-������

Page 196: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

�9�� �?828:?8� :?� AFCA@D67F=�� <?@H:?8�� @C� C64<=6DD� 4@?5F4E�� A6CD@?2==J� @C� E9C@F892?@E96C��E92E 2=2C>D�@C�42FD6D�DF3DE2?E:2=�6>@E:@?2=�@C�ADJ49@=@8:42=�5:DEC6DD�E@�E96�H@>2?@C�96C�49:=5�,9:D�D92==�:?4=F56��3FE�?@E�36�=:>:E65�E@��E96�7@==@H:?8�24ED�

����+E2=<:?8�@C�7@==@H:?8�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5�:?�AF3=:4�@C�AC:G2E6�A=246D�

� ��(66C:?8�:?�E96 H:?5@H�@C�=:?86C:?8�@FED:56�E96�C6D:56?46�@7�E96�H@>2?�@C96C�49:=5�

�����?E6C:?8�@C�C6>2:?:?8�:?�E96�5H6==:?8�@C�@?�E96�AC@A6CEJ�@7�E96�H@>2?�@C96C�49:=5�282:?DE�96C9:D�H:==�

���� �6DEC@J:?8� E96� AC@A6CEJ� 2?5� A6CD@?2=� 36=@?8:?8D� @C� :?7=:4E:?8� 92C>� E@2?:>2=D�@C�A6ED�@7�E96�H@>2?�@C�96C�49:=5��2?5

�����?828:?8�:?�2?J�7@C>�@7�92C2DD>6?E�@C�G:@=6?46�

�:���2FD:?8�>6?E2=�@C�6>@E:@?2=�2?8F:D9��AF3=:4�C:5:4F=6�@C�9F>:=:2E:@?�E@�E96�H@>2?@C�96C�49:=5��:?4=F5:?8��3FE�?@E�=:>:E65�E@��C6A62E65�G6C32=�2?5 6>@E:@?2=�23FD6��2?5�56?:2=�@77:?2?4:2=�DFAA@CE�@C�4FDE@5J�@7�>:?@C�49:=5C6?�@7�2446DD�E@�E96�H@>2?�D�49:=549:=5C6?���

0� �9?4�&0C@,7��,=,>>809?��.?�:1�������

4��#@94>3,-70�,.?>

/@C<��65F42E:@?�@C�EC2:?:?8�C6=2E65�D6IF2=�92C2DD>6?E�:D�4@>>:EE65�3J�2?�6>A=@J66�>2?286C��DFA6CG:D@C��286?E�@7�E96�6>A=@J6C��E62496C��:?DECF4E@C��AC@76DD@C��4@249��EC2:?@C��@C2?J� @E96C� A6CD@?�H9@�� 92G:?8� 2FE9@C:EJ�� :?7=F6?46� @C�>@C2=� 2D46?52?4J� @G6C� 2?@E96C� :?� 2H@C<� @C� EC2:?:?8� @C� 65F42E:@?� 6?G:C@?>6?E�� 56>2?5D�� C6BF6DED� @C� @E96CH:D6� C6BF:C6D� 2?JD6IF2=�72G@C�7C@>�E96�@E96C��C682C5=6DD�@7�H96E96C�E96�56>2?5��C6BF6DE�@C�C6BF:C6>6?E�7@CDF3>:DD:@?�:D 2446AE65�3J�E96�@3;64E�@7�D2:5�24E

�2� !?�2�H@C<�C6=2E65�@C�6>A=@J>6?E�6?G:C@?>6?E��D6IF2=�92C2DD>6?E�:D�4@>>:EE65H96?�

��� ,96� D6IF2=� 72G@C� :D� >256� 2D� 2� 4@?5:E:@?� :?� E96� 9:C:?8� @C� :?� E966>A=@J>6?E�� C6�6>A=@J>6?E� @C� 4@?E:?F65� 6>A=@J>6?E� @7� D2:5� :?5:G:5F2=�� @C� :?8C2?E:?8� D2:5� :?5:G:5F2=� 72G@C23=6� 4@>A6?D2E:@?�� E6C>D�� 4@?5:E:@?D�� AC@>@E:@?D�� @CAC:G:=686D��@C� E96� C67FD2= E@�8C2?E� E96�D6IF2=� 72G@C� C6DF=ED� :?� =:>:E:?8�� D68C682E:?8�@C4=2DD:7J:?8� E96� 6>A=@J66� H9:49� :?� 2� H2J� H@F=5� 5:D4C:>:?2E6�� 56AC:G6� @C� 5:>:?:D96>A=@J>6?E�@AA@CEF?:E:6D�@C�@E96CH:D6�25G6CD6=J�27764E�D2:5�6>A=@J66�

� � ,96� 23@G6� 24ED�H@F=5� :>A2:C� E96� 6>A=@J66ND� C:89ED�@C�AC:G:=686D�F?56C6I:DE:?8�=23@C�=2HD��@C

���.;9��

��������� ��

Page 197: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

��� ,96� 23@G6� 24ED� H@F=5� C6DF=E� :?� 2?� :?E:>:52E:?8�� 9@DE:=6�� @C� @776?D:G66?G:C@?>6?E�7@C�E96�6>A=@J66

�3� !?�2?�65F42E:@?�@C�EC2:?:?8�6?G:C@?>6?E��D6IF2=�92C2DD>6?E�:D�4@>>:EE65�

��� �82:?DE� @?6� H9@� :D� F?56C� E96� 42C6�� 4FDE@5J� @C� DFA6CG:D:@?� @7� E96@776?56C�

� � �82:?DE� @?6� H9@D6� 65F42E:@?�� EC2:?:?8�� 2AAC6?E:46D9:A� @C� EFE@CD9:A� :D6?ECFDE65�E@�E96�@776?56C�

��� /96?� E96� D6IF2=� 72G@C� :D�>256� 2� 4@?5:E:@?� E@� E96� 8:G:?8� @7� 2� A2DD:?88C256� @C� E96� 8C2?E:?8� @7� 9@?@CD� 2?5� D49@=2CD9:AD�� @C� E96� A2J>6?E� @7� 2� DE:A6?5�2==@H2?46�@C�@E96C�36?67:ED��AC:G:=686D��@C�4@?D:56C2E:@?D��@C

��� /96?�E96�D6IF2=�25G2?46D�C6DF=E�:?�2?�:?E:>:52E:?8��9@DE:=6�@C�@776?D:G66?G:C@?>6?E�7@C�E96�DEF56?E��EC2:?66�@C�2AAC6?E:46

�?J�A6CD@?�H9@�5:C64ED�@C�:?5F46D�2?@E96C�E@�4@>>:E�2?J�24E�@7�D6IF2=�92C2DD>6?E2D�96C6:?�567:?65��@C�H9@�4@@A6C2E6D�:?�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�E96C6@7�3J�2?@E96C�H:E9@FE�H9:49�:EH@F=5�?@E�92G6�366?�4@>>:EE65��D92==�2=D@�36�96=5�=:23=6���

� �.;9��

Page 198: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

����>591?��3-5:?@��5B58�'@-@A?

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED

'59A8-@5;:�;2�.5>@4?��?A.?@5@A@5;:;2� ;:1� /4580� 2;>� -:;@41>�� -:0/;:/1-891:@� ;>� -.-:0;:91:@� ;2-�8135@59-@1�/4580���

2 �9:=5� :D� 32AE:K65�@C� C68:DE6C65� :?� E96 *68:DECJ�@73:CE9�2D�96CD

3 �9:=5�=@D6D�:ED�C62=�DE2EFD�2?5�24BF::C6D�2�?6H�@?6

4 �4E@CND�AFCA@D6�H2D�E@�42FD6�E96�=@DD�@7�2?J�EC2462D�E@�E96�49:=5ND��ECF6�7:=:2E:@?��

)?A><-@5;:�;2�/5B58�?@-@A?�� 2 �@>>:EE65�3J�2�A6CD@?�H9@�C6AC6D6?ED�9:>D6=7�2D2?@E96C� 2?5� � 2DDF>6D� E96� 7:=:2E:@?� @C� C:89EDA6CE2:?:?8�E@�DF49�A6CD@?

3 ,96C6�>FDE� 36� 4C:>:?2=� :?E6?E� E@� 6?;@J� E96� 4:G:=C:89ED�@7�2?@E96C�3J��E96�@776?56C�<?@H:?8�96�:D�?@E6?E:E=65�E96C6E@

4 �@>>:EE65� 3J� 2DF>:?8� E96� 7:=:2E:@?�� @C� E96A2C6?E2=�@C 4@?;F82=�C:89ED�@7�2?@E96C

5 �:C4F>DE2?46D� BF2=:7J:?8� E96� @776?D6�� A6?2=EJ� :D962G:6C�H96?�E96�AFCA@D6�@7�E96�:>A6CD@?2E:@?�:D�E@567C2F5�E96�@776?565�A2CEJ�@C�9:D�96:CD

�53-9E� 2 '776?56C�92D�366?�=682==J�>2CC:65

� �HJ����

�9JI�+KD?I>;:�

��.?CKB7J?ED�E<�8?HJ>I

���.K8IJ?JKJ?ED�E<�ED;�9>?B:�<EH�7DEJ>;H

���ED9;7B?D=�EH�787D:ED?D=�7DO� B;=?J?C7J;�9>?B:�M?J>�J>;� ?DJ;DJ�JE 97KI;�IK9>�9>?B:�JE� BEI;� ?JI�9?L?B

IJ7JKI

-;GK?I?J;I�

/>;�9>?B:�CKIJ�8;�B;=?J?C7J;

� />;�E<<;D:;H�9ED9;7BI�EH�787D:EDI�IK9>�9>?B:

� />;�E<<;D:;H�>7I�J>;�?DJ;DJ�JE�97KI;�J>;�9>?B:�JE�BEI;�?JI�9?L?B�IJ7JKI� �

B;C;DJI�E<�.?CKB7J?ED�E<��?HJ>� �

�HJ����� �

�HJ����

/>;� 9H?C;� :E;I� DEJ� <7BB� M?J>?D� J>;� 97J;=EHO� E<� FH?L7J;� 9H?C;I� J>7J� 97D� 8;� FHEI;9KJ;:� EDBO� 7J� J>;

?DIJ7D9;�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO

��I?CKB7J;:�C7HH?7=;�?I�DEJ�C7HH?7=;�7J�7BB�7D:�97D�8;�KI;:�7I�7�:;<;DI;�<EH�8?=7CO

Page 199: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

3 ,96�>2CC:286�92D�?@E�366? =682==J�5:DD@=G65�@C��:?42D6� 9:D� @C� 96C� DA@FD6� :D� 23D6?E�� E96� 23D6?E� DA@FD64@F=5� ?@E� J6E� 36� AC6DF>65� 5625� 244@C5:?8� E@� E964:G:=�4@56

4 6�4@?EC24ED�2�D64@?5�@C�DF3D6BF6?E�>2CC:286

5 ,96� D64@?5� @C� DF3D6BF6?E� >2CC:286� 92D� 2==� E966DD6?E:2=�C6BF:D:E6D�7@C�G2=:5:EJ

!->>5-31� /;:@>-/@10� -3-5:?@<>;B5?5;:?�;2�8-C?��

2 '776?56C�4@?EC24E65�>2CC:286

3 6�<?6H�2E�E96�E:>6�E92E

� E96�C6BF:C6>6?E�@7�E96�=2H�H6C6�?@E�4@>A=:65H:E9��@C

� E96 >2CC:286� H2D� :?� 5:DC682C5� @7� 2� =682=:>A65:>6?E

$>19-@A>1�9->>5-31�� 2 �� H:5@H� H9@� H:E9:?� ���� 52JD� 7C@>� 562E9� @79FD32?5�� 8@E�>2CC:65� @C� 367@C6� 96C� 56=:G6CJ�� :7� D96H2D�AC68?2?E�2E�E96�E:>6�@7�9:D�562E9

3 ��H@>2?�H9@D6�>2CC:286�92G:?8�366? 5:DD@=G65@C� 2??F==65�� >2CC:65� 367@C6� 96C� 56=:G6CJ� @C� H:E9:?����52JD�27E6C�E96�=682=�D6A2C2E:@?

$1>2;>9-:/1� ;2� 58813-8� 9->>5-31/1>19;:E��

2 (6C7@C>2?46�@7�2?J�:==682=�>2CC:286�46C6>@?J�3J�2AC:6DE� @C�>:?:DE6C� @7� 2?J� C6=:8:@FD� 56?@>:?2E:@?� @CD64E @C�3J�4:G:=�2FE9@C:E:6D

/>;H;�CKIJ�8;�7�IKCC7HO�FHE9;;:?D=�JE�:;9B7H;�J>;�78I;DJ�IFEKI;�FH;IKCFJ?L;BO�:;7:�<EH�FKHFEI;I

E<�H;C7HH?7=;

!7?BKH;�JE�;N;H9?I;�:K;�:?B?=;D9;�JE�7I9;HJ7?D J>;�M>;H;78EKJI�E<�J>;� IJM?<;�?I�8?=7CO�J>HEK=>�H;9AB;II

?CFHK:;D9;

��@K:?9?7B�:;9B7H7J?ED�E<�J>;�DKBB?JO�E<�7�C7HH?7=;�LE?: #$�+0+6+1 ?I�DEM�H;GK?H;:

*D;�9EDL?9J;:�<EH�8?=7CO�C7O�8;�FHEI;9KJ;:�<EH�9ED9K8?D7=;�7I�8EJ>�7H;�:?IJ?D9J�E<<;DI;I

*D;�M>E�LEK9>;I�J>7J�J>;H;�?I�DE�B;=7B�?CF;:?C;DJ�ADEM?D=�J>7J�ED;�E<�J>;�F7HJ?;I�?I�7BH;7:O�C7HH?;:

?I�7D�799ECFB?9;� �

�HJ����

�?H9KCIJ7D9;� GK7B?<O?D=� J>;� E<<;DI;�� ?<� ;?J>;H� E<� J>;� 9EDJH79J?D=� F7HJ?;I� E8J7?DI� J>;� 9EDI;DJ� E<� J>;

EJ>;H�8O�C;7DI�E<�L?EB;D9;��?DJ?C?:7J?ED�EH�<H7K:� �

�HJ��� � �

�HJ����

Page 200: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

�� �>591?��3-5:?@��;:;>

�C:>6D �=6>6?ED

5.18��� 2 ,96C6�>FDE�36�2?�:>AFE2E:@?�@7�2�4C:>6��@C�@7�2

� ��HJ����

'?8;B�?I�7�FK8B?9�7D:�C7B?9?EKI�?CFKJ7J?ED�E<�7�9H?C;��EH�7�L?9;�EH�:;<;9J��H;7B�EH�?C7=?D7HO�EH�7DO�79J�

9ECC?II?ED��9ED:?J?ED��IJ7JKI�EH�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�J;D:?D=�JE�97KI;�J>;�:?I>EDEH� :?I9H;:?J�EH�9EDJ;CFJ�E<�7

D7JKH7B�EH�@KH?:?97B�F;HIED��EH�JE�8B79A;D�J>;�C;CEHO�E<�ED;�M>E�?I�:;7:

&?D:I�E<�C7B?9;���7��C7B?9;�?D�B7M���8��C7B?9;�?D�<79J

(7B?9;�?I�FH;IKC;:�JE�;N?IJ�?D�?D@KH?EKI�FK8B?97J?EDI

+K8B?97J?ED�?I�J>;�9ECCKD?97J?ED�E<�J>;�:;<7C7JEHO�C7JJ;H�JE�IEC;�J>?H:�F;HIED�I

+;HIED�B?8;B;:�CKIJ�8;� ?:;DJ?<?;:��KJ�J>;�FK8B?97J?ED�D;;:�DEJ�H;<;H�8O�D7C;�JE�J>;� B?8;B;:�F7HJO� $<

DEJ�D7C;:�?J�CKIJ�8;�I>EMD�J>7J�J>;�:;I9H?FJ?ED�E<�J>;�F;HIED�H;<;HH;:�JE�?D�J>;�:;<7C7JEHO�FK8B?97J?ED

M7I�IK<<?9?;DJBO�9B;7H�IE�J>7J�7J�B;7IJ�7��H:F;HIED�MEKB:�>7L;�?:;DJ?<?;:�J>;�FB7?DJ?<<

/>;H;�7H;�7I�C7DO�9H?C;I�7I�J>;H;�7H;�F;HIEDI�:;<7C;:

/E�FH;IKC;�FK8B?97J?ED�J>;H;�CKIJ�8;�7�H;7IED78B;�FHE878?B?JO�J>7J�J>;�7BB;=;:�7�B?8;BEKI�C7JJ;H�M7I

J>;H;8O�;NFEI;:�JE�8;�H;7:�EH�I;;D�8O��H:F;HIEDI

�H?J;H?ED�JE�:;J;HC?D;�M>;J>;H�IJ7J;C;DJI�7H;�:;<7C7JEHO

��MEH:I�7H;�97B9KB7J;:�JE�?D:K9;�J>;�>;7H;HI�JE�IKFFEI;�7D:�KD:;HIJ7D:�J>7J�J>;�F;HIED�7=7?DIJ

M>E� J>;O�7H;�KJJ;H;:�M;H;�=K?BJO�E<� 9;HJ7?D�E<<;DI;I��EH�7H;� IK<<?9?;DJ� JE� ?CF;79>� J>;?H�>ED;IJO�

L?HJK;�EH�H;FKJ7J?ED��EH�JE�>EB;�J>;�F;HIED�KF�JE�FK8B?9�H?:?9KB;

�� �9EDIJHK;:�DEJ�EDBO�7I� JE� J>;�;NFH;II?ED�KI;:�8KJ�7BIE�M?J>� H;IF;9J� JE� J>;�M>EB;� I9EF;�7D:

7FF7H;DJ�E8@;9J�E<�J>;�MH?J;H

-;GK?H;C;DJ�E<�FK8B?9?JO���HJ�����

&?D:I�E<�FH?L?B;=;:�9ECCKD?97J?ED�

7 �8IEBKJ;BO�FH?L?B;=;: W DEJ�79J?ED78B;�;L;D�?<�J>;�79JEH�>7I�79J;:�?D�87:�<7?J>

8,K7B?<?;:BO�FH?L?B;=;: W J>EI;�M>?9>�7BJ>EK=>� 9EDJ7?D?D= :;<7C7JEHO� ?CFKJ7J?EDI� 9EKB:�DEJ�8;

79J?ED78B;�KDB;II�C7:;�M?J>�C7B?9;�EH�87:�<7?J>

";D;H7B�-KB;�

L;HO� :;<7C7JEHO� ?CFKJ7J?ED� ?I� FH;IKC;:�C7B?9?EKI� ;L;D� ?<� ?J� 8;� JHK;�� ?<� DE� =EE:� ?DJ;DJ?ED� 7D:

@KIJ?<?78B;�CEJ?L;�<EH�C7A?D=�?J�?I�I>EMD

N9;FJ?ED�

7 +H?L7J;�9ECCKD?97J?ED�?D�F;H<EHC7D9; E<�B;=7B��CEH7B�EH�IE9?7B�:KJO

8 !7?H�7D:�JHK;�H;FEHJ��C7:;�?D�=EE:�<7?J>��M?J>EKJ�7DO�9ECC;DJI�7D:�H;C7HAI

+;HIEDI�H;IFEDI?8B;�<EH�'?8;B���HJ�����

7 ��F;HIED�M>E�FK8B?I>;I��;N>?8?JI�EH�97KI;I�J>;�FK8B?97J?ED�EH�;N>?8?J?ED�� �E<�7DO�:;<7C7J?ED�?D

MH?J?D=�EH�I?C?B7H�C;7DI

8����KJ>EH�EH�;:?JEH�E<�7�8EEA�EH�F7CF>B;J

9�� :?JEH�EH�8KI?D;II�C7D7=;H�E<�7�:7?BO�D;MIF7F;H�C7=7P?D;�EH�I;H?7B�FK8B?97J?ED

:� � *MD;H� E<� J>;� FH?DJ?D=� FB7DJ� M>?9>� FK8B?I>;I� 7� B?8;BEKI� 7HJ?9B;� M?J>� >?I� 9EDI;DJ� 7D:� 7BB� EJ>;H

F;HIEDI�M>E�?D�7DO�M7O�F7HJ?9?F7J;�?D�EH�>7L;�9EDD;9J?ED�M?J>�?JI�FK8B?97J?ED �0.�L�*HJ?P�

1;DK;�E<�9H?C?D7B�7D:�9?L?B�79J?ED�<EH�:7C7=;I�?D�97I;I�E<�MH?JJ;D�:;<7C7J?ED�

7�M>;H;�J>;�B?8;BEKI�7HJ?9B;�?I�FH?DJ;:�7D:� IJ�FK8B?I>;:�EH

8�M>;H;�7DO�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJ?;I�79JK7BBO�H;I?:;I�7J�J>;�J?C;�E<�J>;�9ECC?II?ED�E<�J>;�E<<;DI;

2>;H;�ED;�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJ?;I�?I 7�FK8B?9�E<<?9;H�

7�?<�>?I�E<<?9;�?I�?D�J>;��?JO�E<�(7D?B7

-/��E<�(7D?B7 EH

9?JO�FHEL?D9;�M>;H;�J>;�7HJ?9B;�?I�FH?DJ;:�7D:� IJ�FK8B?I>;:

8�*J>;HM?I;

-/��E<�J>;�9?JO�FHEL?D9;�M>;H;�>;�>;B:�E<<?9;�7J�J>;�J?C;�E<�E<<;DI; EH

Page 201: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

G:46� @C� 56764E�� C62=� @C� :>28:?2CJ�� @C� 2?J� 24E�@>:DD:@?��4@?5:E:@?��DE2EFD��@C�4:C4F>DE2?46D

3 ,96 :>AFE2E:@?�>FDE�36�>256�AF3=:4=J

4 !E�>FDE�36�>2=:4:@FD

5 ,96� :>AFE2E:@?�>FDE�36�5:C64E65�2E�2�?2EFC2=�@C;FC:5:42=�A6CD@?��@C�@?6�H9@�:D�5625

6 ,96�:>AFE2E:@?�>FDE�E6?5�E@�42FD6�E96�5:D9@?@C�5:D4C65:E�@C�4@?E6>AE�@7�E96�A6CD@?�5672>65

5.18 .E� 91-:?� ;2� C>5@5:3� ;>?5958->�91-:?��

�?F>6C2E6D� E96� >62?D� 3J� H9:49� =:36=� >2J� 364@>>:EE65�� HC:E:?8�� AC:?E:?8�� =:E9@8C2A9J�6?8C2G:?8��C25:@�A9@?@8C2A9��A2:?E:?8��E962EC:42=�@C4:?6>2E@8C2A9:4�6I9:3:E:@?D�@C�2?J�D:>:=2C�>62?D

(4>1-@1:5:3� @;� <A.85?4 85.18� -:0;221>� @;� <>1B1:@� ?A/4� <A.85/-@5;:2;>�-�/;9<1:?-@5;:� �

�=62C=J��;FDE�2�42D6�@7�3=24<>2:=� �

$>;45.5@10� <A.85/-@5;:� ;2� -/@?>121>>10�@;�5:�@41�/;A>?1�;2�;225/5-8<>;/1105:3?���

2 '776?56C� :D� 2� C6A@CE6C�� 65:E@C� @C� >2?286C� @7� 2?6HDA2A6C��52:=J�@C�>282K:?6

3 6�AF3=:D96D�724ED�4@??64E65�H:E9�E96�AC:G2E6�=:76@7�2?@E96C4 +F49�724ED�2C6�@776?D:G6�E@�E96�9@?@C��G:CEF6�2?5C6AFE2E:@?�@7�D2:5�A6CD@?

M>;H;�J>;�7HJ?9B;�?I� IJ�FK8B?I>;:

2>;H;�ED;�E<�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJ?;I�?I�7�FH?L7J;�?D:?L?:K7B�

-/��E<�FHEL?D9;�9?JO�M>;H;�>;�79JK7BBO�H;I?:;I�7J�J>;�J?C;�E<�J>;�9H?C;

M>;H;�7HJ?9B;�M7I�FH?DJ;:�EH� IJ�FK8B?I>;:� �

�HJ�������

�HJ������

7DO�KDB7M<KB�;NJEHJ?ED�E<�CED;O�8O�J>H;7JI�E<�799KI7J?ED�7D:�;NFEIKH;

+EII?8B;�?D�B?=>J�J>H;7JI���HJ������7D:�?D�J>H;7J�JE�FK8B?I>���HJ��������

�HJ����

L;D�J>EK=>�C7:;�?D�9EDD;9J?ED�M?J>�EH�KD:;H�J>;�FH;J;NJ�J>7J�?J�?I�D;9;II7HO�?D�J>;�D7HH7J?ED�E<�7DO

@K:?9?7B�EH�7:C?D?IJH7J?L;�FHE9;;:?D=I�M>;H;?D�IK9>�<79JI�>7L;�8;;D�C;DJ?ED;:

'79I7�<EKD:�J>7J�(7HGK;P�M7I�DEJ�7�FHEFH?;J7HO�C;C8;H�E<�+���J>KI DEJ�GK7B?<?;:�JE�8;�FH;I?:;DJ�#;

MHEJ;�JE�J>;��*��7D:�JE�(7HGK;P�#;�97KI;:�JE�FK8B?I>�J>;�I;9ED:�B;JJ;H�# '���';JJ;H�?I�DEJ�FH?L?B;=;:

9ECCKD?97J?ED� /E� 8;� 9B7II?<?;:� 7I� IK9>� ?J� CKIJ� 8;� <H;;� <HEC� C7B?9;� "H7DJ?D=� J>7J� J>;� B;JJ;H� M7I

FH?L?B;=;:�9ECCKD?97J?ED��MH?JJ;D�EKJ�E<�7�:KJO�E<�7D�E<<?9;H�JEM7H:I�J>;�C;C8;HI��IK9>�9>7H79J;H�M7I

BEIJ�M>;D�?J�M7I�FK8B?I>;: ��#%5#�8� ����

Page 202: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

#>-8�012-9-@5;:�?8-:01>��� 2 24E:@?�@7�2�D6C:@FD�2?5�:?DF=E:?8�?2EFC6� �

3 =:89E� :?DF=E� @C� 5672>2E:@? L ?@E� D6C:@FD� :??2EFC6� �

'8-:01>�.E�0110��� 2 '776?56C� A6C7@C>D� 2?J� 24E� ?@E� :?4=F565� :?� 2?J@E96C�4C:>6�282:?DE�9@?@C

3 +F49� 24E� :D� A6C7@C>65� :?� E96� AC6D6?46� @7� @E96CA6CD@?�@C�A6CD@?D

4 +F49� 24E� 42DED� 5:D9@?@C�� 5:D4C65:E� @C� 4@?E6>AEFA@?�E96�@776?565�A2CEJ

�:/>595:-@5:3�5::;/1:@�<1>?;:��� 2 '776?56C�A6C7@C>D�2?�24E

3 +F49�24E�96�5:C64E=J�:?4C:>:?2E6D�@C�:>AFE6D�E@�2?:??@46?E�A6CD@?�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�2 4C:>6

4 +F49�24E�5@6D�?@E�4@?DE:EFE6�A6C;FCJ

����HJ����

!79JEHI�J>7J�:;J;HC?D;�=H7L?JO�E<�J>;�E<<;DI;�

7��;NFH;II?EDI�KI;:

8��F;HIED7B�H;B7J?EDI�E<�J>;�799KI;:�7D:�J>;�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO

9��9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�IKHHEKD:?D=�J>;�97I;

2EH:I�KJJ;H;:�?D�J>;�>;7J�E<�7D=;H�9EDIJ?JKJ;�B?=>J�EH7B�:;<7C7J?ED

$<�J>;�KJJ;H7D9;I�M;H;�C7:;�FK8B?9BO�7D:�M;H;�>;7H:�8O�C7DO�F;EFB;�7D:�J>;�799KI;:�7J�J>;�I7C;�J?C;

B;L;B;:�>?I�<?D=;H�7J�J>;�9ECFB7?D7DJ��EH7B�:;<7C7J?ED�?I %1//+66'&

.;H?EKID;II�:;F;D:I�ED�J>;�IE9?7B�IJ7D:?D=�E<�E<<;D:;:�F7HJO��J>;�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�IKHHEKD:?D=�J>;�79J�

J>;�E997I?ED��;J9���

=H7L;�IB7D:;H���

I?CFB;�IB7D:;H���

�HJ����

'?8;BEKI�H;C7HAI���HJ�����

'?8;BEKI� H;C7HAI� EH� 9ECC;DJI� ED� FH?L?B;=;:�C7JJ;HI� ?<� C7:;� M?J>� C7B?9;� ?D� <79J� M?BB� DEJ� ;N;CFJ� J>;

7KJ>EH�7D:�;:?JEH

/>?I�7HJ?9B;�?I�7�B?C?J7J?ED�JE�J>;�:;<;DI;�E<�FH?L?B;=;:�9ECCKD?97J?ED���

�HJ����

/ME�����&?D:I�

7 C7A?D=�7�IJ7J;C;DJ�M>?9>�?I

?��:;<7C7JEHO�EH

??��F;H@KH?EKI

8����FB7DJ?D=�;L?:;D9;

/>?I�7HJ?9B;�?I�B?C?J;:�JE�FB7DJ?D=�;L?:;D9;�7D:�J>;�B?A;

Page 203: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

�:@>53A5:3�-3-5:?@�4;:;>��� �?J�A6CD@?�H9@�D92==�>2<6�2?J�:?EC:8F6�H9:49�92D7@C� :ED� AC:?4:A2=� AFCA@D6� E@� 3=6>:D9� E96� 9@?@C� @CC6AFE2E:@?�@7�2?@E96C�A6CD@?

,� �/8494>?=,?4A0 �4=.@7,=����� %0���@4/07490>�49�?30�"->0=A,9.0�:1

,�%@70�:1�#=010=09.0�49�?30��8;:>4?4:9�:1�#09,7?40>�49��4-07��,>0>

4��#=010=09.0�:1�48;:>4?4:9�:1�1490

,9:D��5>:?:DEC2E:G6��:C4F=2C�5@6D�?@E�C6>@G6�:>AC:D@?>6?E�2D�2?�2=E6C?2E:G6�A6?2=EJ7@C�E96�4C:>6 @7 =:36=� �

,96� "F586D� 4@?46C?65� >2J�� :?� E96� 6I6C4:D6� @7� D@F?5� 5:D4C6E:@?�� 2?5� E2<:?8� :?E@4@?D:56C2E:@?�E96�A64F=:2C�4:C4F>DE2?46D�@7�6249�42D6��56E6C>:?6�H96E96C�E96�:>A@D:E:@?�@7�27:?6� 2=@?6� H@F=5� 36DE� D6CG6� E96� :?E6C6DED� @7� ;FDE:46� @C� H96E96C� 7@C362C:?8� E@� :>A@D6:>AC:D@?>6?E�H@F=5�56AC64:2E6�E96�D6C:@FD?6DD�@7�E96�@776?D6��H@C<�G:@=6?46�@?�E96�D@4:2=@C56C��@C�@E96CH:D6�36�4@?EC2CJ�E@�E96�:>A6C2E:G6�@7�;FDE:46�

+9@F=5�@?=J�2�7:?6�36�:>A@D65�2?5�E96�244FD65�36�F?23=6�E@�A2J�E96�7:?6��E96C6�:D�?@=682=� @3DE24=6� E@� E96� 2AA=:42E:@?� @7� E96 *6G:D65� (6?2=� �@56 AC@G:D:@?� @?� DF3D:5:2CJ:>AC:D@?>6?E

����HJ����

-;<;HI� JE� 7DO� I9>;C;� EH� FBEJ� :;I?=D;:� JE� 8B;C?I>� J>;� H;FKJ7J?ED� E<� 7DEJ>;H� EH� E<� IK9>� JH?9A;HO� EH

I;9H;J�FBEJ

�ECC?JJ;:�8O�I7O?D=�JE�EJ>;HI�7D�KD7JJH?8KJ78B;�J>?D=��?<�I7?:�JE�J>;�F;HIED�>?CI;B<�?J�?I�IB7D:;H���

KD:;H��HJ�����E<�J>;�-+�

Page 204: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

���>595:-8�"138531:/1

&1/781??�59<>A01:/1�� 2 '776?56C�5@6D�@C�72:=D�E@�5@�2?�24E

3 ,96�5@:?8�@7�@C�E96�72:=FC6�E@�5@�E92E�24E�:D�G@=F?E2CJ

4 /:E9@FE�>2=:46

5 %2E6C:2=�52>286�C6DF=ED

6 ,96C6�:D�:?6I4FD23=6�=24<�@7�AC642FE:@?�@?�E96�A2CE�@7E96�@776?56C��E2<:?8�:?E@�4@?D:56C2E:@?

� 9:D�6>A=@J>6?E�@C�@44FA2E:@?

568C66�@7�:?E6==:86?46��A9JD:42=�4@?5:E:@?��2?5

� @E96C 4:C4F>DE2?46D� C682C5:?8� A6CD@?D�� E:>6� 2?5A=246

'59<81�59<>A01:/1��� 2 ,96C6� :D� =24<� @7� AC642FE:@?� @?� E96� A2CE� @7� E96@776?56C

3 ,96�52>286�:>A6?5:?8�E@�36�42FD65�:?�?@E�:>>65:2E6@C�E96�52?86C�:D�?@E�4=62C=J�>2?:76DE

����HJ����

�� ?8?:

�HJ���ED�C?J?=7J?D=�7D:�7==H7L7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;I�DEJ 7FFB?978B;

!7?BKH;�JE�B;D:�ED�J>;�IFEJ�7II?IJ7D9;�JE�L?9J?C�E<�>?I�D;=B?=;D9;�F;D7BJO�D;NJ�>?=>;H�?D�:;=H;;

�87D:ED?D=� KIK7BBO� FKD?I>78B;� KD:;H� �HJ� ����� ?<� 9>7H=;:� KD:;H� �HJ���� ?I� EDBO� GK7B?<O?D=� 7D:� ?<� DEJ

7BB;=;:�97DDEJ�;L;D�8;�7D�7==H7L7J?D=�9?H9KCIJ7D9;

�EDJH?8KJEHO�D;=B?=;D9;XDEJ�7�:;<;DI;��EDBO�C?J?=7J?D=

'7IJ�9B;7H�9>7D9;�:E9JH?D;

/>;� 9EDJH?8KJEHO� D;=B?=;D9;� E<� J>;� ?D@KH;:� F7HJO�M?BB� DEJ� :;<;7J� J>;� 79J?ED� ?<� ?J� 8;� I>EMD� J>7J� J>;

799KI;:�C?=>J��8O�J>;�;N;H9?I;�E<�H;7IED78B;�97H;�7D:�FHK:;D9;��>7L;�7LE?:;:�J>;�9EDI;GK;D9;I�E<�J>;

D;=B?=;D9;�E<�J>;�?D@KH;:�F7HJO

C;H=;D9O�HKB;

�D�7KJECE8?B;�:H?L;H��M>E��8O�J>;�D;=B?=;D9;�E<�7DEJ>;H�� ?I� IK::;DBO�FB79;:� ?D�7D�;C;H=;D9O�7D:

9ECF;BB;:� JE� 79J� ?DIJ7DJBO� JE� 7LE?:� 7� 9EBB?I?ED�EH� ?D@KHO� ?I� DEJ� =K?BJO�E<� D;=B?=;D9;� ?<� >;�C7A;I� 7� 9>E?9;

M>?9>�7�F;HIED�E<�EH:?D7HO�FHK:;D9;�FB79;:�?D�IK9>�7�FEI?J?ED�C?=>J�C7A;�;L;D�J>EK=>�>;�:?:�DEJ�C7A;

J>;�M?I;IJ�9>E?9;

Page 205: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

���� �A>5?<>A01:/1M (6CE:?6?E� +FAC6>6� �@FCE� 564:D:@?D� AC@>F=82E65� FA� E@ "2?F2CJ� ��� ��

������D/8A010�(;<5/?

���==�+A64:2=�(6?2=�$2HD�2?5�+FAC6>6��@FCE��64:D:@?D�?@E�A6CE:?6?E�E@�E96�23@G6@FE=:?65�E@A:4D�2C6�6I4=F565

��(6?2=E:6D�@7�+A64:7:4��C:>6D

Page 206: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

&���&�"��

&1B5?10�$1:-8��;01

�>@������I46AE�2D�AC@G:565�:?�E96�EC62E:6D�2?5�=2HD�@7�AC676C6?E:2=�2AA=:42E:@?��E96�AC@G:D:@?D�@7�E9:D�@56� D92==� 36� 6?7@C465� ?@E� @?=J� H:E9:?� E96� (9:=:AA:?6� �C49:A6=28@� :?4=F5:?8� :ED� 2E>@DA96C6�� :ED:?E6C:@C�H2E6CD�2?5�%2C:E:>6�K@?6��3FE�2=D@�@FED:56�@7�:ED�;FC:D5:4E:@?��282:?DE�E9@D6�H9@�

���+9@F=5�4@>>:E�2?�@776?D6�H9:=6�@?�2�(9:=:AA:?6�D9:A�@C�2:CD9:A�

� � +9@F=5� 7@C86� @C� 4@F?E6C76:E� 2?J� 4@:?� @C� 4FCC6?4J� ?@E6� @7� E96� (9:=:AA:?6� !D=2?5D� @C@3=:82E:@?D�2?5�D64FC:E:6D�:DDF65 3J�E96��@G6C?>6?E�@7�E96�(9:=:AA:?6�!D=2?5D�

�� � +9@F=5� 36� =:23=6� 7@C� 24ED� 4@??64E65� H:E9� E96� :?EC@5F4E:@?� :?E@� E96D6� :D=2?5D� @7� E96@3=:82E:@?D�2?5�D64FC:E:6D�>6?E:@?65�:?�E96�AC6465:?8�?F>36C�

�� �/9:=6�36:?8�AF3=:4�@77:46CD�@C�6>A=@J66D�� D9@F=5�4@>>:E 2?�@776?D6� :?� E96�6I6C4:D6�@7E96:C�7F?4E:@?D��@C��+@>6�@7�E96D6�4C:>6D�2C6�3C:36CJ��7C2F5�282:?DE�?2E:@?2=�EC62DFCJ��>2=G6CD2E:@?�@7AF3=:4�7F?5D�@C�AC@A6CEJ��2?5�:==682=�FD6�@7�AF3=:4�7F?5D��68����;F586�H9@�2446AED�2�3C:36�H9:=6�:?"2A2?�

���+9@F=5 4@>>:E�2?J�4C:>6D�282:?DE�E96�?2E:@?2=�D64FC:EJ�2?5�E96�=2H�@7�?2E:@?D��567:?65�:?,:E=6�'?6�@7��@@<�,H@�@7�E9:D��@56��,96D6�4C:>6D�:?4=F56�EC62D@?��6DA:@?286��A:C24J��>FE:?J��2?5G:@=2E:@?�@7�?6FEC2=:EJ�

�>@�� � �&&%.3%3� ./4� 35"*%#4� 4/� 4(%� 02/6)3)/.3� /&� 4()3� #/$% ��'776?D6D�H9:49� 2C6�@C� :?� E96� 7FEFC6�>2J�36AF?:D923=6� F?56C� DA64:2=� =2HD� 2C6�?@E� DF3;64E� E@� E96� AC@G:D:@?D� @7� E9:D��@56� �,9:D��@56� D92==� 36DFAA=6>6?E2CJ�E@�DF49�=2HD��F?=6DD�E96�=2EE6C�D9@F=5�DA64:2==J�AC@G:56�E96�4@?EC2CJ

�>@5/81�� �534)&9).'�#)2#5-34!.#%3� � ,96�7@==@H:?8�5@�?@E�:?4FC�2?J�4C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ�

���?J@?6�H9@�24ED�:?�5676?D6�@7�9:D�A6CD@?�@C�C:89ED��AC@G:565�E92E�E96�7@==@H:?84:C4F>DE2?46D�4@?4FC�

�:CDE�-?=2H7F=�288C6DD:@?�

+64@?5�*62D@?23=6�?646DD:EJ�@7�E96�>62?D�6>A=@J65�E@�AC6G6?E�@C�C6A6=�:E�

,9:C5�$24<�@7�DF77:4:6?E�AC@G@42E:@?�@?�E96�A2CE�@7�E96�A6CD@?�5676?5:?8�9:>D6=7

��?J�@?6�H9@�24ED�:?�5676?D6�@7�E96�A6CD@?�@C�C:89ED�@7�9:D�DA@FD6��2D46?52?ED�56D46?52?ED��@C�=68:E:>2E6��?2EFC2=�@C�25@AE65�3C@E96CD�@C�D:DE6CD��@C�@7�9:D�C6=2E:G6D�3J277:?:EJ�:?�E96�D2>6�568C66D��2?5�E9@D6�3J�4@?D2?8F:?:EJ�H:E9:?�E96�7@FCE9�4:G:=�568C66�AC@G:565�E92E�E96�7:CDE�2?5�D64@?5�C6BF:D:E6D�AC6D4C:365�:?�E96�?6IE�AC6465:?8�4:C4F>DE2?462C6�AC6D6?E��2?5�E96�7FCE96C�C6BF:D:E6��:?�42D6�E96�AC@G@42E:@?�H2D�8:G6?�3J�E96�A6CD@?2EE24<65��E92E�E96�@?6�>2<:?8�5676?D6�925�?@�A2CE�E96C6:?

���?J@?6�H9@�24ED�:?�5676?D6�@7�E96�A6CD@?�@C�C:89ED�@7�2�DEC2?86C��AC@G:565�E92E�E96�7:CDE2?5�D64@?5�C6BF:D:E6D�>6?E:@?65�:?�E96�7:CDE�4:C4F>DE2?46�@7�E9:D�2CE:4=6�2C6�AC6D6?E�2?5�E92EE96�A6CD@?�5676?5:?8�36�?@E�:?5F465�3J�C6G6?86��C6D6?E>6?E��@C�@E96C�6G:=�>@E:G6

Page 207: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

���?J�A6CD@?�H9@��:?�@C56C�E@�2G@:5�2?�6G:=�@C�:?;FCJ��5@6D�2?�24E�H9:49�42FD6D�52>286�E@2?@E96C��AC@G:565�E92E�E96�7@==@H:?8�C6BF:D:E6D�2C6�AC6D6?E�

�:CDE�,92E�E96�6G:=�D@F89E�E@�36�2G@:565�24EF2=�6I:DED�

+64@?5�,92E�E96�:?;FCJ�762C65�36�8C62E6C�E92?�E92E�5@?6�E@�2G@:5�:E�

,9:C5�,92E�E96C6�36�?@�@E96C�AC24E:42=�2?5�=6DD�92C>7F=�>62?D�@7 AC6G6?E:?8�:E

���?J�A6CD@?�H9@�24ED�:?�E96�7F=7:==>6?E�@7�2�5FEJ�@C�:?�E96�=2H7F=�6I6C4:D6�@7�2�C:89E�@C@77:46

���?J�A6CD@?�H9@�24ED�:?�@365:6?46�E@�2?�@C56C�:DDF65�3J�2�DFA6C:@C�7@C�D@>6�=2H7F=AFCA@D6

�>@5/81��� �)2#5-34!.#%3�7()#(�%8%-04�&2/- #2)-).!,�,)!"),)49� � ,96�7@==@H:?8�2C6�6I6>AE�7C@>�4C:>:?2==:23:=:EJ�

���?�:>364:=6�@C�2?�:?D2?6�A6CD@?��F?=6DD�E96�=2EE6C�92D�24E65�5FC:?8�2�=F4:5�:?E6CG2=

/96?�E96�:>364:=6�@C�2?�:?D2?6�A6CD@?�92D�4@>>:EE65�2?�24E�H9:49�E96�=2H�567:?6D�2D�276=@?J �56=:E@���E96�4@FCE�D92==�@C56C�9:D�4@?7:?6>6?E�:?�@?6�@7�E96�9@DA:E2=D�@C�2DJ=F>D6DE23=:D965�7@C�A6CD@?D�E9FD�277=:4E65��H9:49�96�D92==�?@E�36�A6C>:EE65�E@�=62G6�H:E9@FE�7:CDE@3E2:?:?8�E96�A6C>:DD:@?�@7�E96�D2>6�4@FCE

���A6CD@?�F?56C�?:?6�J62CD�@7 286

����A6CD@?�@G6C�?:?6�J62CD�@7�286�2?5�F?56C�7:7E66?��F?=6DD�96�92D�24E65�H:E9�5:D46C?>6?E�:?�H9:49�42D6��DF49�>:?@C�D92==�36�AC@466565�282:?DE�:?�244@C52?46�H:E9�E96�AC@G:D:@?D�@72CE:4=6����@7�E9:D��@56

/96?�DF49�>:?@C�:D�25;F5865�E@�36�4C:>:?2==J�:CC6DA@?D:3=6��E96�4@FCE��:?�4@?7@C>:EJ�H:E9E96�AC@G:D:@?D�@7�E9:D�2?5�E96�AC6465:?8�A2C28C2A9��D92==�4@>>:E�9:>�E@�E96�42C6�2?5�4FDE@5J@7�9:D�72>:=J�H9@�D92==�36�492C865�H:E9�9:D�DFCG6:==2?46�2?5�65F42E:@?��@E96CH:D6��96�D92==�364@>>:EE65�E@�E96�42C6�@7�D@>6�:?DE:EFE:@?�@C�A6CD@?�>6?E:@?65�:?�D2:5�2CE:4=6���

���?J�A6CD@?�H9@��H9:=6�A6C7@C>:?8�2�=2H7F=�24E�H:E9�5F6�42C6��42FD6D�2?�:?;FCJ�3J�>6C6244:56?E�H:E9@FE�72F=E�@C�:?E6?E:@?�@7�42FD:?8�:E

���?J�A6CD@?�H9@�24ED�F?56C�E96�4@>AF=D:@?�@7�:CC6D:DE:3=6�7@C46

���?J�A6CD@?�H9@�24ED�F?56C�E96�:>AF=D6�@7�2?�F?4@?EC@==23=6�762C�@7�2?�6BF2=�@C�8C62E6C:?;FCJ

���?J�A6CD@?�H9@�72:=D�E@�A6C7@C>�2?�24E�C6BF:C65�3J�=2H��H96?�AC6G6?E65�3J�D@>6�=2H7F=:?DFA6C23=6�42FD6

Page 208: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

�>@5/81����)4)'!4).' #)2#5-34!.#%3� � ,96�7@==@H:?8�2C6�>:E:82E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46D�

��,9@D6�>6?E:@?65�:?�E96�AC6465:?8�492AE6C��H96?�2==�E96�C6BF:D:E6D�?646DD2CJ�E@�;FDE:7J�E9624E�@C�E@�6I6>AE�7C@>�4C:>:?2=�=:23:=:EJ�:?�E96�C6DA64E:G6�42D6D�2C6�?@E�2EE6?52?E

�,92E�E96�@776?56C�:D�F?56C�6:89E66?�J62CD�@7�286�@C�@G6C�D6G6?EJ�J62CD�!?�E96�42D6�@7�E96>:?@C��96�D92==�36�AC@466565�282:?DE�:?�244@C52?46�H:E9�E96�AC@G:D:@?D�@7�2CE:4=6���

��,92E�E96�@776?56C�925�?@�:?E6?E:@?�E@�4@>>:E�D@�8C2G6�2�HC@?8�2D�E92E�4@>>:EE65

��,92E�DF77:4:6?E�AC@G@42E:@?�@C�E9C62E�@?�E96�A2CE�@7�E96�@776?565�A2CEJ�:>>65:2E6=JAC646565�E96�24E

��,92E�E96�24E�H2D�4@>>:EE65�:?�E96�:>>65:2E6�G:?5:42E:@?�@7�2�8C2G6�@776?D6�E@�E96�@?64@>>:EE:?8�E96�76=@?J��56=:E@��9:D�DA@FD6��2D46?52?ED��56D46?52?ED��=68:E:>2E6��?2EFC2=�@C25@AE65�3C@E96CD�@C�D:DE6CD�@C�C6=2E:G6D�3J�277:?:EJ�H:E9:?�E96�D2>6�568C66D

��,92E�@7�92G:?8�24E65�FA@?�2?�:>AF=D6�D@�A@H6C7F=�2D�?2EFC2==J�E@�92G6�AC@5F465�A2DD:@?@C�@37FD42E:@?

��,92E�E96�@776?56C�925�G@=F?E2C:=J�DFCC6?56C65�9:>D6=7�E@�2�A6CD@?�:?�2FE9@C:EJ�@C�9:D286?ED��@C�E92E�96�925�G@=F?E2C:=J�4@?76DD65�9:D�8F:=E�367@C6�E96�4@FCE�AC:@C�E@�E96AC6D6?E2E:@?�@7�E96�6G:56?46�7@C�E96�AC@D64FE:@?

��,92E�E96�@776?56C�:D�5627�2?5�5F>3��3=:?5�@C�@E96CH:D6�DF776C:?8�D@>6�A9JD:42=�56764EH9:49�E9FD�C6DEC:4ED�9:D�>62?D�@7�24E:@?��5676?D6��@C�4@>>F?:42E:@?�H:E9�9:D�76==@H�36:?8D

��+F49�:==?6DD�@7�E96�@776?56C�2D�H@F=5�5:>:?:D9�E96�6I6C4:D6�@7�E96�H:==�A@H6C�@7�E96@776?56C�H:E9@FE�9@H6G6C�56AC:G:?8�9:>�@7�4@?D4:@FD?6DD�@7�9:D 24ED

����?5��7:?2==J��2?J�@E96C�4:C4F>DE2?46�@7�2�D:>:=2C�?2EFC6�2?5�2?2=@8@FD�E@�E9@D6�23@G6>6?E:@?65

�>@5/81� � �''2!6!4).'�#)2#5-34!.#%3� � ,96�7@==@H:?8�2C6�288C2G2E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46D�

��,92E�25G2?E286�36�E2<6?�3J�E96�@776?56C�@7�9:D�AF3=:4�A@D:E:@?

�,92E�E96�4C:>6�36�4@>>:EE65�:?�4@?E6>AE�@7�@C�H:E9�:?DF=E�E@�E96�AF3=:4�2FE9@C:E:6D

��,92E�E96�24E�36�4@>>:EE65�H:E9�:?DF=E�@C�:?�5:DC682C5�@7�E96�C6DA64E�5F6�E@�E96�@776?565A2CEJ�@?�244@F?E�@7�9:D�C2?<��286��@C�D6I��@C�E92E�:E�36�4@>>:EE65 :?�E96�5H6==:?8�@7�E96@776?565�A2CEJ��:7�E96�=2EE6C�92D�?@E�8:G6?�AC@G@42E:@?

��,92E�E96�24E�36�4@>>:EE65�H:E9�23FD6�@7�4@?7:56?46�@C�@3G:@FD�F?8C2E67F=?6DD

��,92E�E96�4C:>6�36�4@>>:EE65�:?�E96�A2=246�@7�E96��9:67��I64FE:G6��@C�:?�9:D�AC6D6?46��@CH96C6�AF3=:4�2FE9@C:E:6D�2C6�6?82865�:?�E96�5:D492C86�@7�E96:C�5FE:6D��@C�:?�2�A=246�565:42E65E@�C6=:8:@FD�H@CD9:A

Page 209: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

��,92E�E96�4C:>6�36�4@>>:EE65�:?�E96�?:89EE:>6��@C�:?�2?�F?:?923:E65�A=246��@C�3J�2�32?5�H96?6G6C�DF49�4:C4F>DE2?46D�>2J�724:=:E2E6�E96 4@>>:DD:@?�@7�E96�@776?D6

/96?6G6C�>@C6�E92?�E9C66�2C>65�>2=6724E@CD�D92==�92G6�24E65�E@86E96C�:?�E96�4@>>:DD:@?@7�2?�@776?D6��:E�D92==�36�566>65�E@�92G6�366?�4@>>:EE65�3J�2�32?5

��,92E�E96�4C:>6�36�4@>>:EE65�@?�E96�@442D:@?�@7�2�4@?7=28C2E:@?��D9:AHC64<��62CE9BF2<6�6A:56>:4��@C�@E96C�42=2>:EJ�@C�>:D7@CEF?6

��,92E�E96�4C:>6�36�4@>>:EE65�H:E9�E96�2:5�@7�2C>65�>6?�@C�A6CD@?D�H9@�:?DFC6�@C�277@C5:>AF?:EJ

��,92E�E96�244FD65�:D�2�C64:5:G:DE

��C64:5:G:DE�:D�@?6�H9@��2E�E96�E:>6�@7�9:D�EC:2=�7@C�@?6�4C:>6��D92==�92G6�366?�AC6G:@FD=J4@?G:4E65�3J�7:?2=�;F58>6?E�@7�2?@E96C�4C:>6�6>3C2465�:?�E96�D2>6�E:E=6�@7�E9:D��@56

���,92E�E96�@776?56C�92D�366?�AC6G:@FD=J�AF?:D965�7@C�2?�@776?D6�E@�H9:49�E96�=2H�2EE2496D2?�6BF2=�@C�8C62E6C�A6?2=EJ�@C�7@C�EH@�@C�>@C6�4C:>6D�E@�H9:49�:E�2EE2496D�2�=:89E6C�A6?2=EJ

���,92E�E96�4C:>6�36�4@>>:EE65�:?�4@?D:56C2E:@?�@7�2�AC:46��C6H2C5� @C�AC@>:D6

� �,92E�E96�4C:>6�36�4@>>:EE65�3J�>62?D�@7�:?F?52E:@?��7:C6��A@:D@?��6IA=@D:@?��DEC2?5:?8@7�2�G6DD6=�@C�:?E6?E:@?2=�52>286�E96C6E@��56C2:=>6?E�@7�2�=@4@>@E:G6��@C�3J�E96�FD6�@7�2?J@E96C�2CE:7:46�:?G@=G:?8�8C62E�H2DE6�2?5�CF:?

���,92E�E96 24E�36�4@>>:EE65�H:E9�6G:56?E�AC6>65:E2E:@?

���,92E�4C27E��7C2F5��@C�5:D8F:D6�36�6>A=@J65

���,92E�25G2?E286�36�E2<6?�@7�DFA6C:@C�DEC6?8E9��@C�>62?D�36�6>A=@J65�E@�H62<6?�E965676?D6

���,92E�E96�24E�36�4@>>:EE65�H:E9�EC62496CJ��2=6G@D:2�

,96C6�:D�EC62496CJ�H96?�E96�@776?56C�4@>>:ED�2?J�@7�E96�4C:>6D�282:?DE�E96�A6CD@?�6>A=@J:?8�>62?D��>6E9@5D��@C�7@C>D�:?�E96�6I64FE:@?�E96C6@7�H9:49�E6?5�5:C64E=J�2?5DA64:2==J�E@�:?DFC6�:ED�6I64FE:@?��H:E9@FE�C:D<�E@�9:>D6=7�2C:D:?8�7C@>�E96�5676?D6�H9:49�E96@776?565�A2CEJ�>:89E�>2<6

���,92E�>62?D�36�6>A=@J65�@C�4:C4F>DE2?46D�3C@F89E�23@FE�H9:49�255�:8?@>:?J�E@�E96?2EFC2=�67764ED�@7�E96�24E

���,92E�E96�4C:>6�36�4@>>:EE65�27E6C�2?�F?=2H7F=�6?ECJ

,96C6�:D�2?�F?=2H7F=�6?ECJ�H96?�2?�6?EC2?46�:D�67764E65�3J 2�H2J�?@E�:?E6?565�7@C�E96AFCA@D6

���,92E�2D�2�>62?D�E@�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�2�4C:>6�2�H2==��C@@7��7=@@C��5@@C��@C�H:?5@H�363C@<6?

Page 210: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

� �

��,92E�E96�4C:>6�36�4@>>:EE65�H:E9�E96�2:5�@7�A6CD@?D�F?56C�7:7E66?�J62CD�@7�286�@C�3J>62?D�@7�>@E@C�G69:4=6D��>@E@C:K65�H2E6C4C27E��2:CD9:AD��@C�@E96C�D:>:=2C�>62?D���D2>6?565�3J�*6A��4E�&@�������2AAC@G65�+6AE���������

��,92E�E96�HC@?8�5@?6�:?�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�E96�4C:>6�36�56=:36C2E6=J�2F8>6?E65�3J42FD:?8�@E96C�HC@?8�?@E�?646DD2CJ�7@C�:ED�4@>>:DD:@?

�>@5/81��� �(%)2�#/.#%04� � �=E6C?2E:G6�4:C4F>DE2?46D�2C6�E9@D6�H9:49�>FDE�36�E2<6?�:?E@�4@?D:56C2E:@?2D�288C2G2E:?8�@C�>:E:82E:?8�244@C5:?8�E@�E96�?2EFC6�2?5�67764ED�@7�E96�4C:>6�2?5�E96�@E96C�4@?5:E:@?D2EE6?5:?8�:ED�4@>>:DD:@?�,96J�2C6�E96�C6=2E:@?D9:A��:?E@I:42E:@?�2?5�E96�568C66�@7�:?DECF4E:@?�2?565F42E:@?�@7�E96�@776?56C

,96�2=E6C?2E:G6�4:C4F>DE2?46�@7�C6=2E:@?D9:A�D92==�36�E2<6?�:?E@�4@?D:56C2E:@?�H96?�E96�@776?565A2CEJ�:D�E96�DA@FD6��2D46?52?E��56D46?52?E��=68:E:>2E6��?2EFC2=��@C�25@AE65�3C@E96C�@C�D:DE6C��@C�C6=2E:G63J�277:?:EJ�:?�E96�D2>6�568C66D�@7�E96�@776?56C

,96�:?E@I:42E:@?�@7�E96�@776?56C�D92==�36�E2<6?�:?E@�4@?D:56C2E:@?�2D�2�>:E:82E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46�H96?E96�@776?56C�92D�4@>>:EE65�2�76=@?J�:?�2�DE2E6�@7�:?E@I:42E:@?��:7�E96�D2>6�:D�?@E�923:EF2=�@CDF3D6BF6?E�E@�E96�A=2?�E@�4@>>:E�D2:5�76=@?J��3FE�H96?�E96�:?E@I:42E:@?�:D�923:EF2=�@C�:?E6?E:@?2=��:ED92==�36�4@?D:56C65�2D�2?�288C2G2E:?8�4:C4F>DE2?46

�)*%#&$���� ���������� � '30�1:77:B492�,=0�.:9>4/0=0/�;=49.4;,7>�

��'3:>0�B3:�?,60�,�/4=0.?�;,=?�49�?30�0C0.@?4:9�:1�?30�,.?�

���'3:>0�B3:�/4=0.?7D�1:=.0�:=�49/@.0�:?30=>�?:�.:884?�4?�

���'3:>0�B3:�.::;0=,?0�49�?30�.:884>>4:9�:1�?30�:1109>0�-D�,9:?30=�,.?�B4?3:@?�B34.3�4?

B:@7/�9:?�3,A0�-009�,..:8;74>30/�

�)*%#&$�� � ��������� �� � �..:8;74.0>�,=0�?3:>0�;0=>:9>�B3:��9:?�-0492�49.7@/0/�49�,=?4.70���.::;0=,?0�49�?30�0C0.@?4:9�:1�?30�:1109>0�-D�;=0A4:@>�:=�>48@7?,90:@>�,.?>�

�>@����##%33/2)%3 M �446DD@C:6D�2C6�E9@D6�H9@��92G:?8�<?@H=6586�@7�E96�4@>>:DD:@?�@7�E96�4C:>6�2?5�H:E9@FE�92G:?8�A2CE:4:A2E65�E96C6:?��6:E96C�2D�AC:?4:A2=D�@C�244@>A=:46D��E2<6�A2CE�DF3D6BF6?E�E@:ED�4@>>:DD:@?�:?�2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8�>2??6CD�

���J�AC@7:E:?8�E96>D6=G6D�@C�2DD:DE:?8�E96�@776?56C�E@�AC@7:E�3J�E96�67764ED�@7�E96�4C:>6

��J�4@?462=:?8�@C�56DEC@J:?8�E96�3@5J�@7�E96�4C:>6��@C�E96�67764ED�@C�:?DECF>6?ED�E96C6@7��:?@C56C�E@�AC6G6?E�:ED�5:D4@G6CJ

���J�92C3@C:?8��4@?462=:?8��@C�2DD:DE:?8�:?�E96�6D42A6�@7�E96�AC:?4:A2=D�@7�E96�4C:>6��AC@G:565�E962446DD@CJ�24ED�H:E9 23FD6�@7�9:D�AF3=:4�7F?4E:@?D�@C�H96?6G6C�E96�2FE9@C�@7�E96�4C:>6�:D�8F:=EJ�@7EC62D@?��A2CC:4:56��>FC56C��@C�2?�2EE6>AE�E@�E2<6�E96�=:76�@7�E96��9:67��I64FE:G6��@C�:D�<?@H?�E@�36923:EF2==J�8F:=EJ�@7�D@>6�@E96C�4C:>6

�>@5/81���� �%,!9�).�4(%�$%,)6%29�/&�$%4!).%$�0%23/.3�4/�4(%�02/0%2�*5$)#)!,�!54(/2)4)%3� � ,96�A6?2=E:6D�AC@G:565:?�E96�?6IE�AC6465:?8�2CE:4=6�D92==�36�:>A@D65�FA@?�E96�AF3=:4�@77:46C�@C�6>A=@J66�H9@�D92==�56E2:?2?J� A6CD@?� 7@C� D@>6� =682=� 8C@F?5� 2?5� D92==� 72:=� E@� 56=:G6C� DF49� A6CD@?� E@� E96� AC@A6C� ;F5:4:2=2FE9@C:E:6D� H:E9:?� E96� A6C:@5� @7�� EH6=G6� �� �� 9@FCD�� 7@C� 4C:>6D� @C� @776?D6D� AF?:D923=6� 3J� =:89E

Page 211: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

�

A6?2=E:6D��@C�E96:C�6BF:G2=6?E��6:89E66?������9@FCD��7@C�4C:>6D�@C�@776?D6D�AF?:D923=6�3J�4@CC64E:@?2=A6?2=E:6D��@C�E96:C�6BF:G2=6?E��2?5�E9:CEJ�D:I������9@FCD��7@C�4C:>6D�@C�@776?D6D�AF?:D923=6�3J�277=:4E:G6@C�42A:E2=�A6?2=E:6D��@C�E96:C�6BF:G2=6?E

!?�6G6CJ�42D6��E96�A6CD@?�56E2:?65�D92==�36�:?7@C>65�@7�E96�42FD6�@7�9:D�56E6?E:@?�2?5�D92==36�2==@H65�FA@?�9:D�C6BF6DE��E@�4@>>F?:42E6�2?5�4@?76C�2E�2?J�E:>6�H:E9�9:D�2EE@C?6J�@C�4@F?D6=

�CE� �� �%!4(�/2�0(93)#!,�).*52)%3�).&,)#4%$�5.$%2�%8#%04)/.!,�#)2#5-34!.#%3��?J�=682==J�>2CC:65�A6CD@?�H9@�92G:?8�DFCAC:D65�9:D�DA@FD6�:?�E96�24E�@7�4@>>:EE:?8�D6IF2=�:?E6C4@FCD6�H:E9�2?@E96C�A6CD@?��D92== <:==2?J� @7� E96>�@C� 3@E9� @7� E96>� :?� E96� 24E� @C� :>>65:2E6=J� E96C627E6C�� @C� D92==� :?7=:4E� FA@?� E96>� 2?JD6C:@FD�A9JD:42=�:?;FCJ��D92==�DF776C�E96 A6?2=EJ�@7 $%34)%22/��

�CE���� �)!"),)49�/&�!3#%.$!.43��'5!2$)!.3��4%!#(%23��/2�/4(%2�0%23/.3�%.42534%$�7)4(�4(%�#534/$9�/&�4(%�/&&%.$%$�0!249M ,96�2D46?52?ED��8F2C5:2?D��4FC2E@CD��E62496CD�2?5�2?J�A6CD@?�H9@��3J�23FD6�@7�2FE9@C:EJ�@C4@?7:56?E:2=�C6=2E:@?D9:AD��D92==�4@@A6C2E6�2D�244@>A=:46D�:?�E96�A6CA6EC2E:@?�@7�E96�4C:>6D�6>3C2465:?�492AE6CD��D64@?5��E9:C5�2?5�7@FCE9��@7�E9:D�E:E=6��D92==�36�AF?:D965�2D�AC:?4:A2=D492?�C@3=6D�G:CEF2==2H�=:3C2CJ

,62496CD�@C�@E96C�A6CD@?D�:?�2?J�@E96C�42A24:EJ�6?ECFDE65�H:E9�E96�65F42E:@?�2?5�8F:52?46@7�J@FE9��D92==�2=D@�DF776C�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�E6>A@C2CJ�DA64:2=�5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�:?�:ED�>2I:>F>�A6C:@5�E@A6CA6EF2=�DA64:2=�5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?

�?J�A6CD@?�72==:?8�H:E9:?�E96�E6C>D�@7�E9:D�2CE:4=6��2?5�2?J�@E96C�A6CD@?�8F:=EJ�@7�4@CCFAE:@?@7�>:?@CD�7@C�E96�36?67:E�@7�2?@E96C��D92==�36�AF?:D965�3J�DA64:2=�5:DBF2=:7:42E:@?�7C@>�7:==:?8�E96@77:46�@7�8F2C5:2?�

&1B5?10�&A81?�;2��>595:-8�$>;/10A>1

'1/��� �)3#(!2'%�/&�!##53%$�4/�"%�34!4%�7)4.%33 M /96?�EH@�@C�>@C6�A6CD@?D�2C6�;@:?E=J�492C865�H:E9�E964@>>:DD:@?�@7�2?J�@776?D6��FA@?�>@E:@?�@7�E96�AC@D64FE:@?�367@C6�C6DE:?8� :ED�42D6� E96�4@FCE�>2J5:C64E�@?6�@C�>@C6�@7�E96�244FD65�E@�36�5:D492C865�H:E9�E96:C�4@?D6?E�D@�E92E�E96J�>2J�36�H:E?6DD6D7@C�E96�DE2E6�H96?��27E6C�C6BF:C:?8�E96�AC@D64FE:@?�E@�AC6D6?E�6G:56?46�2?5�E96�DH@C?�DE2E6>6?E�@76249�AC@A@D65�DE2E6�H:E?6DD�2E�2�962C:?8�:? DFAA@CE�@7�E96�5:D492C86��E96�4@FCE�:D�D2E:D7:65�E92E�

�2��,96C6�:D�23D@=FE6�?646DD:EJ�7@C�E96�E6DE:>@?J�@7�E96�244FD65�H9@D6�5:D492C86�:D�C6BF6DE65�

�3��,96� :D�?@�@E96C�5:C64E�6G:56?46�2G2:=23=6� 7@C� E96�AC@A6C�AC@D64FE:@?�@7� E96�@776?D6�4@>>:EE65�6I46AE E96�E6DE:>@?J�@7�D2:5�244FD65�

�4��,96�E6DE:>@?J�@7�D2:5�244FD65�42?�36�DF3DE2?E:2==J�4@CC@3@C2E65�:?�:ED�>2E6C:2=�A@:?ED�

�5��+2:5�244FD65�5@6D�?@E�2AA62C�E@�36�E96�>@DE�8F:=EJ��2?5

�6��+2:5�244FD65�92D�?@E�2E�2?J�E:>6�366?�4@?G:4E65�@7�2?J�@776?D6�:?G@=G:?8�>@C2=�EFCA:EF56

�G:56?46�255F465�:?�DFAA@CE�@7�E96�5:D492C86�D92==�2FE@>2E:42==J�7@C>�A2CE�@7�E96�EC:2=�!7�E964@FCE�56?:6D�E96�>@E:@?�7@C�5:D492C86�@7�E96�244FD65�2D�DE2E6�H:E?6DD��9:D�DH@C?�DE2E6>6?E�D92==�36:?25>:DD:3=6�:?�6G:56?46

Page 212: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

� �

(41��;9<>141:?5B1��-:31>;A?��>A3?��/@�;2���

��!�-$)(� � !>A@CE2E:@?� @7� �2?86C@FD� �CF8D� 2?5@C� �@?EC@==65� (C64FCD@CD� 2?5� �DD6?E:2=�96>:42=D� ,96�A6?2=EJ�@7� =:76� :>AC:D@?>6?E� E@�562E9�2?5�2� C2?8:?8�7C@>��:G6�9F?5C65� E9@FD2?5A6D@D��(�����������E@�,6?�>:==:@?�A6D@D��(��������������D92==�36�:>A@D65�FA@?�2?J�A6CD@?��H9@�F?=6DD�2FE9@C:K65�3J�=2H��D92==�:>A@CE�@C�3C:?8�:?E@�E96�(9:=:AA:?6D�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8��C682C5=6DD�@7E96�BF2?E:EJ�2?5�AFC:EJ�:?G@=G65��:?4=F5:?8�2?J�2?5�2==�DA64:6D�@7�@A:F>�A@AAJ�@C�2?J�A2CE�E96C6@7�@CDF3DE2?46D�56C:G65�E96C67C@>�6G6?�7@C�7=@C2=��564@C2E:G6�2?5�4F=:?2CJ�AFCA@D6D 888

��!�-$)(��� +2=6��,C25:?8���5>:?:DEC2E:@?���:DA6?D2E:@?���6=:G6CJ���:DEC:3FE:@?�2?5�,C2?DA@CE2E:@?@7��2?86C@FD��CF8D� 2?5@C��@?EC@==65�(C64FCD@CD� 2?5��DD6?E:2= �96>:42=D � ,96� A6?2=EJ� @7� =:76:>AC:D@?>6?E�E@�562E9�2?5�2�7:?6�C2?8:?8�7C@>��:G6�9F?5C65�E9@FD2?5�A6D@D��(�����������E@�,6?>:==:@?�A6D@D� �(�������������� D92==� 36� :>A@D65�FA@?�2?J�A6CD@?��H9@�� F?=6DD� 2FE9@C:K65�3J� =2H�D92==� D6==�� EC256��25>:?:DE6C��5:DA6?D6��56=:G6C��8:G6�2H2J� E@�2?@E96C��5:DEC:3FE6�5:DA2E49� :?� EC2?D:E�@CEC2?DA@CE� 2?J� 52?86C@FD� 5CF8�� :?4=F5:?8� 2?J� 2?5� 2==� DA64:6D� @7� @A:F>� A@AAJ� C682C5=6DD� @7� E96BF2?E:EJ�2?5�AFC:EJ�:?G@=G65��@C�D92==�24E�2D�2�3C@<6C�:?�2?J�@7�DF49�EC2?D24E:@?D�III

��!�-$)(��� %2:?E6?2?46�@7�2��6?���:G6�@C�*6D@CE � ,96�A6?2=EJ�@7�=:76�:>AC:D@?>6?E�E@�562E9�2?52� 7:?6� C2?8:?8� 7C@>� �:G6� 9F?5C65� E9@FD2?5� A6D@D� �(����������� E@� ,6?� >:==:@?� A6D@D�(��������������D92==�36� :>A@D65�FA@?�2?J�A6CD@?�@C�8C@FA�@7�A6CD@?D�H9@�D92==�>2:?E2:?�2�56?�5:G6�@C�C6D@CE�H96C6�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�:D�FD65�@C�D@=5�:?�2?J�7@C>�0II

'1/@5;:�� �-0,/9%%3�!.$� )3)4/23�/&�!��%.���)6%�/2��%3/24� � ,96�A6?2=EJ�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�C2?8:?8�7C@>EH6=G6��� ��J62CD�2?5�@?6�����52J�E@�EH6?EJ�� ���J62CD�2?5�2 7:?6�C2?8:?8�7C@>�'?6�9F?5C65�E9@FD2?5A6D@D��(�����������E@��:G6�9F?5C65�E9@FD2?5�A6D@D��(�����������D92==�36�:>A@D65�FA@?�

�2���?J�6>A=@J66�@7�2�56?��5:G6�@C�C6D@CE��H9@�:D�2H2C6�@7�E96�?2EFC6�@7�E96�A=246�2D�DF49��2?5

�3���?J�A6CD@?�H9@��?@E�36:?8�:?4=F565�:?�E96�AC@G:D:@?D�@7�E96�?6IE�AC6465:?8��A2C28C2A9��:D�2H2C6@7�E96�?2EFC6�@7�E96�A=246�2D�DF49�2?5�D92==�<?@H:?8=J�G:D:E�E96�D2>6

�'1/@5;:� � �!.5&!#452%� /&� �!.'%2/53� �25'3� !.$�/2� �/.42/,,%$� �2%#523/23� !.$� �33%.4)!,� �(%-)#!,3 � ,96A6?2=EJ�@7�=:76 :>AC:D@?>6?E�E@�562E9�2?5�2�7:?6�C2?8:?8��:G6�9F?5C65�E9@FD2?5�A6D@D��(����������E@�,6?�>:==:@?�A6D@D��(��������������D92==�36�:>A@D65�FA@?�2?J�A6CD@?��H9@��F?=6DD�2FE9@C:K65�3J=2H��D92==�6?8286�:?�E96�>2?F724EFC6�@7�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�0II

�'1/@5;:� �!.5&!#452%� /2� �%,)6%29� /&� �15)0-%.4�� �.3425-%.4�� �00!2!453�� !.$� �4(%2� �!2!0(%2.!,)!� &/2�!.'%2/53� �25'3� !.$�/2� �/.42/,,%$� �2%#523/23� !.$� �33%.4)!,� �(%-)#!,3 � ,96� A6?2=EJ� @7� :>AC:D@?>6?EC2?8:?8� 7C@>� EH6=G6� �� �� J62CD� 2?5�@?6� ����52J� E@� EH6?EJ� � ��� J62CD� 2?5� 2� 7:?6� C2?8:?8� 7C@>�'?69F?5C65� E9@FD2?5� A6D@D� �(����������� E@� �:G6� 9F?5C65� E9@FD2?5� A6D@D� �(����������� D92==� 36:>A@D65� FA@?� 2?J� A6CD@?� H9@� D92==� 56=:G6C�� A@DD6DD� H:E9� :?E6?E� E@� 56=:G6C�� @C� >2?F724EFC6� H:E9:?E6?E� E@� 56=:G6C� 6BF:A>6?E�� :?DECF>6?E�� 2AA2C2EFD� 2?5� @E96C� A2C2A96C?2=:2� 7@C� 52?86C@FD� 5CF8D�<?@H:?8��@C�F?56C�4:C4F>DE2?46D�H96C6�@?6�C62D@?23=J�D9@F=5�<?@H�� E92E� :E�H:==�36�FD65� E@�A=2?E�AC@A282E6��4F=E:G2E6��8C@H��92CG6DE��>2?F724EFC6��4@>A@F?5��4@?G6CE��AC@5F46��AC@46DD��AC6A2C6��E6DE�2?2=JK6��A24<��C6A24<��DE@C6��4@?E2:?�@C�4@?462=�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�2?5@C�4@?EC@==65�AC64FCD@C�2?56DD6?E:2=�496>:42=�:?�G:@=2E:@?�@7�E9:D��4E�II

'1/@5;:� �/33%33)/.� /&� �!.'%2/53� �25'3 � ,96� A6?2=EJ� @7� =:76� :>AC:D@?>6?E� E@� 562E9� 2?5� 2� 7:?6C2?8:?8� 7C@>� �:G6� 9F?5C65� E9@FD2?5� A6D@D� �(����������� E@� ,6?� >:==:@?� A6D@D� �(�������������D92==�36�:>A@D65�FA@?�2?J�A6CD@?��H9@��F?=6DD�2FE9@C:K65�3J�=2H��D92==�A@DD6DD�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8:?�E96�7@==@H:?8�BF2?E:E:6D��C682C5=6DD�@7�E96�568C66�@7�AFC:EJ�E96C6@7�

�������8C2>D�@C�>@C6�@7�@A:F>�� �����8C2>D�@C�>@C6�@7�>@CA9:?6�

Page 213: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

� �

�������8C2>D�@C�>@C6�@7�96C@:?��������8C2>D�@C�>@C6�@7�4@42:?6�@C�4@42:?6�9J5C@49=@C:56��������8C2>D�@C�>@C6�@7�>6E92>A96E2>:?6�9J5C@49=@C:56�@C��D923F���������8C2>D�@C�>@C6�@7�>2C:;F2?2�C6D:?�@C�>2C:;F2?2�C6D:?�@:=���������8C2>D�@C�>@C6�@7�>2C:;F2?2��2?5���� ��� 8C2>D� @C� >@C6� @7� @E96C� 52?86C@FD� 5CF8D� DF49� 2D�� 3FE� ?@E� =:>:E65� E@�>6E9J=6?65:@IJ>6E92>A96E2>:?6� �%���� @C� �64DE2DJ��� A2C2>6E9@IJ2>A96E2>:?6� �(%���EC:>6E9@IJ2>A96E2>:?6� �,%���� =JD6C8:4� 24:5� 5:6E9J=2>:?6� �$+���� 82>>2� 9J5C@IJ2>A96E2>:?6�� ����2?5�E9@D6�D:>:=2C=J�56D:8?65�@C�?6H=J�:?EC@5F465�5CF8D�2?5�E96:C�56C:G2E:G6D��H:E9@FE�92G:?82?J� E96C2A6FE:4� G2=F6� @C� :7� E96� BF2?E:EJ� A@DD6DD65� :D� 72C� 36J@?5� E96C2A6FE:4� C6BF:C6>6?ED�� 2D56E6C>:?65�2?5�AC@>F=82E65�3J�E96��@2C5�:?�244@C52?46�E@�+64E:@?������CE:4=6�0!�@7�E9:D��4E�III

+64E:@?� � �/33%33)/.� /&��15)0-%.4�� �.3425-%.4���00!2!453� !.$��4(%2� �!2!0(%2.!,)!� &/2��!.'%2/53��25'3� �,96�A6?2=EJ�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�C2?8:?8�7C@>�D:I�����>@?E9D�2?5�@?6�����52J�E@�7@FC�����J62CD�2?5�2�7:?6C2?8:?8� 7C@>� ,6?� E9@FD2?5� A6D@D� �(���������� E@� �:7EJ� E9@FD2?5� A6D@D� �(���������� D92==� 36:>A@D65� FA@?� 2?J� A6CD@?�� H9@�� F?=6DD� 2FE9@C:K65� 3J� =2H�� D92==� A@DD6DD� @C� 92G6� F?56C� 9:D96C4@?EC@=�2?J�6BF:A>6?E�� :?DECF>6?E��2AA2C2EFD�2?5�@E96C�A2C2A96C?2=:2� 7:E�@C� :?E6?565�7@C�D>@<:?8�4@?DF>:?8�� 25>:?:DE6C:?8�� :?;64E:?8�� :?86DE:?8�� @C� :?EC@5F4:?8� 2?J� 52?86C@FD� 5CF8� :?E@� E96� 3@5J��2/6)$%$��,92E�:?�E96�42D6 @7�>65:42=�AC24E:E:@?6CD�2?5�G2C:@FD�AC@76DD:@?2=D�H9@�2C6�C6BF:C65�E@�42CCJDF49� 6BF:A>6?E�� :?DECF>6?E�� 2AA2C2EFD� 2?5�@E96C�A2C2A96C?2=:2� :?� E96�AC24E:46�@7� E96:C� AC@76DD:@?�E96��@2C5�D92==�AC6D4C:36�E96�?646DD2CJ�:>A=6>6?E:?8�8F:56=:?6D�E96C6@7

,96�A@DD6DD:@?�@7�DF49�6BF:A>6?E��:?DECF>6?E��2AA2C2EFD�2?5�@E96C�A2C2A96C?2=:2�7:E�@C�:?E6?565�7@C2?J� @7� E96� AFCA@D6D� 6?F>6C2E65� :?� E96� AC6465:?8� A2C28C2A9� D92==� 36 02)-!� &!#)% 6G:56?46� E92E� E96A@DD6DD@C� 92D� D>@<65�� 4@?DF>65�� 25>:?:DE6C65� E@� 9:>D6=796CD6=7� :?;64E65�� :?86DE65� @C� FD65� 252?86C@FD�5CF8�2?5�D92==�36�AC6DF>65�E@�92G6�G:@=2E65�+64E:@?����@7�E9:D��4E

�'1/@5;:� � �/33%33)/.� /&� �!.'%2/53��25'3��52).'� �!24)%3�� �/#)!,� �!4(%2).'3� /2��%%4).'3� ; �?J� A6CD@?7@F?5�A@DD6DD:?8�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�5FC:?8�2�A2CEJ��@C� 2E� 2� D@4:2=� 82E96C:?8�@C�>66E:?8��@C� :?� E96AC@I:>2E6�4@>A2?J�@7�2E�=62DE�EH@�� ��A6CD@?D��D92==�DF776C�E96�>2I:>F>�A6?2=E:6D�AC@G:565�7@C�:?+64E:@?����@7�E9:D��4E��C682C5=6DD�@7�E96�BF2?E:EJ�2?5 AFC:EJ�@7�DF49�52?86C@FD�5CF8D

'1/@5;:� �/33%33)/.� /&� �15)0-%.4�� �.3425-%.4�� �00!2!453� !.$� �4(%2� �!2!0(%2.!,)!� &/2� �!.'%2/53� �25'3�52).'��!24)%3���/#)!,��!4(%2).'3�/2��%%4).'3 � ,96�>2I:>F>�A6?2=EJ�AC@G:565�7@C�:?�+64E:@?�� �@7�E9:D�4E� D92==� 36� :>A@D65� FA@?� 2?J� A6CD@?�� H9@� D92==� A@DD6DD� @C� 92G6� F?56C� 9:D96C� 4@?EC@=� 2?J6BF:A>6?E�� :?DECF>6?E��2AA2C2EFD�2?5�@E96C�A2C2A96C?2=:2� 7:E�@C� :?E6?565�7@C�D>@<:?8��4@?DF>:?8�25>:?:DE6C:?8�� :?;64E:?8�� :?86DE:?8��@C� :?EC@5F4:?8�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8� :?E@�E96�3@5J��5FC:?8�A2CE:6D�D@4:2=�82E96C:?8D�@C�>66E:?8D��@C :?�E96�AC@I:>2E6�4@>A2?J�@7�2E�=62DE�EH@�� ��A6CD@?D

'1/@5;:��� �3%�/&��!.'%2/53��25'3 L ��A6CD@?�2AAC696?565�@C�2CC6DE65��H9@�:D�7@F?5�E@�36�A@D:E:G67@C�FD6�@7�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8��27E6C�2�4@?7:C>2E@CJ�E6DE��D92==�36�:>A@D65�2�A6?2=EJ�@7�2�>:?:>F>�@7D:I�����>@?E9D�C6923:=:E2E:@?�:?�2�8@G6C?>6?E�46?E6C�7@C�E96�7:CDE�@776?D6��DF3;64E�E@�E96 AC@G:D:@?D�@7�CE:4=6�.!!!�@7�E9:D��4E�!7�2AAC696?565�FD:?8�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�7@C�E96�D64@?5�E:>6��96D96�D92==DF776C� E96�A6?2=EJ�@7� :>AC:D@?>6?E�C2?8:?8�7C@>�D:I� ����J62CD�2?5�@?6� ����52J� E@� EH6=G6� �� ��J62CD2?5� 2� 7:?6� C2?8:?8� 7C@>� �:7EJ� E9@FD2?5� A6D@D� �(���������� E@� ,H@� 9F?5C65� E9@FD2?5� A6D@D�( ���������� �2/6)$%$� ,92E�E9:D�+64E:@?�D92==�?@E�36�2AA=:423=6�H96C6�E96�A6CD@?�E6DE65�:D�2=D@�7@F?5E@�92G6�:?�9:D96C�A@DD6DD:@?�DF49�BF2?E:EJ�@7�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�AC@G:565�7@C�F?56C�+64E:@?����@7E9:D��4E��:?�H9:49�42D6�E96�AC@G:D:@?D�DE2E65�E96C6:?�D92==�2AA=J

� '1/@5;:� � �5,4)6!4)/.� /2� �5,452%� /&� �,!.43��,!33)&)%$� !3��!.'%2/53��25'3� /2� !2%� �/52#%3� �(%2%/&� � ,96A6?2=EJ� @7� =:76� :>AC:D@?>6?E� E@� 562E9� 2?5� 2� 7:?6� C2?8:?8� 7C@>� �:G6� 9F?5C65� E9@FD2?5� A6D@D�(����������� E@�,6?�>:==:@?�A6D@D� �(��������������D92==�36� :>A@D65�FA@?�2?J�A6CD@?��H9@�D92==A=2?E��4F=E:G2E6�@C�4F=EFC6�>2C:;F2?2��@A:F>�A@AAJ�@C�2?J�@E96C�A=2?E�C682C5=6DD�@7�BF2?E:EJ��H9:49�:D

Page 214: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

� �

@C�>2J�96C627E6C�36�4=2DD:7:65�2D�2�52?86C@FD�5CF8�@C�2D�2�D@FC46�7C@>�H9:49�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8�>2J36�>2?F724EFC65�@C�56C:G65� �2/6)$%$��,92E� :?�E96�42D6�@7�>65:42=� =23@C2E@C:6D�2?5�>65:42=�C6D62C4946?E6CD�H9:49� 4F=E:G2E6� @C� 4F=EFC6�>2C:;F2?2�� @A:F>� A@AAJ� 2?5� @E96C� A=2?ED�� @C�>2E6C:2=D� @7� DF4952?86C@FD�5CF8D�7@C�>65:42=�6IA6C:>6?ED�2?5�C6D62C49�AFCA@D6D��@C�7@C�E96�4C62E:@?�@7�?6H�EJA6D�@7>65:4:?6��E96��@2C5�D92==�AC6D4C:36�E96�?646DD2CJ�:>A=6>6?E:?8�8F:56=:?6D�7@C�E96�AC@A6C�4F=E:G2E:@?�4F=EFC6��92?5=:?8��6IA6C:>6?E2E:@?�2?5�5:DA@D2=�@7�DF49�A=2?ED�2?5�>2E6C:2=D

'1/@5;:��� �.,!7&5,��2%3#2)04)/.�/&��!.'%2/53��25'3� L ,96�A6?2=EJ�@7�=:76�:>AC:D@?>6?E�E@�562E9�2?5�27:?6�C2?8:?8�7C@>��:G6�9F?5C65�E9@FD2?5�A6D@D��(�����������E@�,6?�>:==:@?�A6D@D��(�������������D92==�36�:>A@D65�FA@?�2?J�A6CD@?��H9@��F?=6DD 2FE9@C:K65�3J�=2H��D92==�>2<6�@C�:DDF6�2�AC6D4C:AE:@?@C�2?J�@E96C�HC:E:?8�AFCA@CE:?8�E@�36�2�AC6D4C:AE:@?�7@C�2?J�52?86C@FD�5CF8

���������� ������������!��������������������������"������������

������������������������������

�%0;@-74.��.?�!:������

�$#*%('��� ���� ����$� � '34>��.?�>3,77�-0�69:B9�,>�?30 ���$��##��" $��$� ������%"�$(����

������$���$��

�$#*%('��� �!�����$�$� �� ���" �"��� � '30��0;,=?809?�:1��@>?4.0��30=049,1?0=�=010==0/�?:�,>

?30��0;,=?809?��?3=:@23�4?>�&0.=0?,=D��>3,77�1:=8@7,?0�,9/�48;70809?�,��*4?90>>�#=:?0.?4:9�

&0.@=4?D�,9/��09014?�#=:2=,8���30=049,1?0=�=010==0/�?:�,>�?30�#=:2=,8��;@=>@,9?�?:�,9/�.:9>4>?09?

B4?3�?30 ;=:A4>4:9>�:1�?34>��.?�

'30��0;,=?809?�8,D�.,77�@;:9�,9D�/0;,=?809?��-@=0,@��:114.0�:=�,9D�:?30=�0C0.@?4A0�,209.D�?:

,>>4>?�49�?30�48;70809?,?4:9�:1�?30�#=:2=,8�,9/�?30�7,??0=�:114.0>�>3,77�-0�@9/0=�702,7�/@?D�,9/

:-742,?4:9�?:�=09/0=�>@.3�,>>4>?,9.0�

�$#*%('��� ����##� ����$ �$����" �"��� � �9D�;0=>:9�B3:�3,>�B4?90>>0/�:=�3,>�69:B70/20�:=

491:=8,?4:9�:9�?30�.:884>>4:9�:1�,�.=480�,9/�3,>�?0>?4140/�:=�4>�?0>?41D492�:=�,-:@?�?:�?0>?41D

-01:=0�,9D�5@/4.4,7�:=�<@,>4�5@/4.4,7�-:/D��:=�-01:=0�,9D�49A0>?42,?492�,@?3:=4?D��8,D�-0�,/84??0/

49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�

#=:A4/0/��'3,?�

,��?30�:1109>0�49�B34.3�34>�?0>?48:9D�B477�-0�@>0/�4>�,�2=,A0�107:9D�,>�/01490/�@9/0=�?30

%0A4>0/�#09,7��:/0��:=�4?>�0<@4A,709?�@9/0=�>;0.4,7�7,B>��������

-��34>�?0>?48:9D�.,9�-0�>@->?,9?4,77D .:==:-:=,?0/�49�4?>�8,?0=4,7�;:49?>�

.��30�:=�,9D�808-0=�:1�34>�1,847D�B4?349�?30�>0.:9/�.4A47�/02=00�:1�.:9>,92@494?D�:=

,11494?D�4>�>@-50.?0/�?:�?3=0,?>�?:�34>�7410�:=�-:/47D�495@=D�:=�?30=0�4>�,�7460743::/�?3,?�30

B477�-0�64770/��1:=.0/��49?484/,?0/��3,=,>>0/�:=�.:==@;?0/�?:�;=0A09?�348�1=:8�?0>?41D492�

:=�?:�?0>?41D�1,7>07D��:=�0A,>4A07D��-0.,@>0�:=�:9�,..:@9?�:1�34>�?0>?48:9D��,9/

Page 215: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

� �

/��30�4>�9:?�,�7,B�091:=.0809?�:114.0=��0A09�41�30�B:@7/�-0�?0>?41D492�,2,49>?�?30�:?30=�7,B

091:=.0809?�:114.0=>���9�>@.3 ,�.,>0��:97D�?30�4880/4,?0�808-0=>�:1�34>�1,847D�8,D

,A,47�?308>07A0>�:1�?30�;=:?0.?4:9�;=:A4/0/�1:=�@9/0=�?34>��.?�

�1�?30��0;,=?809?��,1?0=�0C,849,?4:9�:1�>,4/�,;;74.,9?�,9/�:?30=�=070A,9?�1,.?>��4>�.:9A49.0/�?3,?

?30�=0<@4=0809?>�:1�?34>��.?�,9/�4?>�48;70809?492�=@70>�,9/�=02@7,?4:9>�3,A0�-009�.:8;740/�B4?3�

4?�>3,77�,/84?�>,4/�,;;74.,9?�?:�?30�#=:2=,8��=0<@4=0�>,4/�B4?90>>�?:�0C0.@?0�,�>B:=9�>?,?0809?

/0?,47492�34>�69:B70/20�:=�491:=8,?4:9�:9�?30�.:884>>4:9�:1�?30�.=480��,9/�?30=0,1?0=�4>>@0�?30

;=:;0= .0=?414.,?4:9���:=�;@=;:>0>�:1�?34>��.?��,9D�>@.3�;0=>:9�,/84??0/�?:�?30�#=:2=,8�>3,77�-0

69:B9�,>�?30�*4?90>>�

�$#*%('����$��##��������#��$�&���&�#$���$� �#� � �9�.,>0�:1�7024>7,?4A0�49A0>?42,?4:9>�49�,4/�:1

7024>7,?4:9��,�B4?90>>��B4?3�34>�0C;=0>>�.:9>09?��8,D�-0�,/84??0/�49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�@;:9�?30

=0.:8809/,?4:9�:1�?30�7024>7,?4A0�.:884??00�B30=0�34>�?0>?48:9D�4>�900/0/�B309�49�4?>�5@/2809?

?30=0�4>�;=0>>492�90.0>>4?D�?30=01:=��#=:A4/0/��'3,?�>@.3�=0.:8809/,?4:9�4>�,;;=:A0/�-D�?30

#=0>4/09?�:1�?30�&09,?0�:=�?30�&;0,60=�:1�?30��:@>0�:1�%0;=0>09?,?4A0>��,>�?30�.,>0�8,D�-0�

�$#*%('����� "���%�� ����"�����$���$��$�����"# ��$ �����" $��$��� � �01:=0�,�;0=>:9�4>

;=:A4/0/�;=:?0.?4:9�@9/0=�?34>��.?��30�>3,77�14=>?�0C0.@?0�,�808:=,9/@8�:1�,2=00809?�B34.3

>3,77�>0?�1:=?3�34>�=0>;:9>4-474?40>�49.7@/492�

,��?:�?0>?41D�-01:=0�,9/�;=:A4/0�491:=8,?4:9�?:�,77�,;;=:;=4,?0�7,B�091:=.0809?�:114.4,7>

.:9.0=9492�,77�,;;=:;=4,?0�;=:.00/492>�49�.:990.?4:9�B4?3�:=�,=4>492�1=:8�?30�,.?4A4?40>

49A:7A0/�49�?30�:1109>0�.3,=20/�

-��?:�,A:4/�?30�.:884>>4:9�:1�?30�.=480��������

.��?:�?,60�,77�90.0>>,=D�;=0.,@?4:9>�?:�,A:4/�/0?0.?4:9�-D�:?30=>�:1�?30�1,.?>�.:9.0=9492

?30�;=:?0.?4:9�;=:A4/0/�348�@9/0=�?34>��.?�

/��?:�.:8;7D�B4?3�702,7�:-742,?4:9>�,9/�.4A47�5@/2809?>�,2,49>?�348�

0��?:�.::;0=,?0�B4?3�=0>;0.?�?:�,77�=0,>:9,-70�=0<@0>?>�:1�:114.0=>�,9/�08;7:D00>�:1�?30

�:A0=9809?�B3:�,=0�;=:A4/492�;=:?0.?4:9�@9/0=�?34>��.?��,9/

1��?:�=02@7,=7D�491:=8�?30�,;;=:;=4,?0�;=:2=,8�:114.4,7�:1�34>�.@==09?�,.?4A4?40>�,9/

,//=0>>��������

�$#*%(' �� �"����� ��$������ "���%�� ����"�����$� � &@->?,9?4,7�-=0,.3�:1�?30�808:=,9/@8

:1�,2=00809?�>3,77�-0�,�2=:@9/�1:=�?30�?0=849,?4:9�:1�?30�;=:?0.?4:9�;=:A4/0/�@9/0=�?34>��.?�

#=:A4/0/��3:B0A0=��'3,?�-01:=0�?0=849,?492�>@.3�;=:?0.?4:9��?30�&0.=0?,=D�:1��@>?4.0�>3,77�>09/

9:?4.0�?:�?30�;0=>:9�49A:7A0/�:1�?30�?0=849,?4:9�:1�?30�;=:?0.?4:9�;=:A4/0/�@9/0=�?34>��.?��>?,?492

?30=049�?30�=0,>:9�1:=�>@.3�?0=849,?4:9�

�$#*%('��� � ������$����$(� ���" �������#� � �77�;=:.00/492>�49A:7A492�,;;74.,?4:9�1:=�,/84>>4:9

49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�,9/�?30�,.?4:9�?,609�?30=0:9�>3,77�-0�.:914/09?4,7�49�9,?@=0��!:�491:=8,?4:9�:=

/:.@809?>�24A09�:=�>@-84??0/�49�>@;;:=?�?30=0:1�>3,77�-0�=070,>0/�0C.0;?�@;:9�B=4??09�:=/0=�:1

?30��0;,=?809?�:=�?30�;=:;0=�.:@=?�

Page 216: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

� �

�9D�;0=>:9�B3:�A4:7,?0>�?30�.:914/09?4,74?D�:1�>,4/�;=:.00/492>�>3,77�@;:9�.:9A4.?4:9�-0

;@94>30/�B4?3�48;=4>:9809?�:1�9:?�70>>�?3,9�:90����D0,=�-@?�9:?�8:=0�?3,9�>4C�����D0,=>�,9/

/0;=4A,?4:9�:1�?30�=423?�?:�3:7/�,�;@-74.�:114.0�:=�08;7:D809?�1:=�,�;0=4:/�:1�14A0�����D0,=>�

�$#*%('� � ����$#�����������$#� � '30�B4?90>>�>3,77�3,A0�?30�1:77:B492�=423?>�,9/�-09014?>�

�,��':�3,A0�,�>0.@=0�3:@>492�1,.474?D�@9?47�30�3,>�?0>?4140/�:=�@9?47�?30�?3=0,?��49?484/,?4:9

:=�3,=,>>809?�/4>,;;0,=>�:=�4>�=0/@.0/�?:�,�8,9,20,-70�:=�?:70=,-70�70A07��*309 ?30

.4=.@8>?,9.0>�B,==,9?��?30�*4?90>>�>3,77�-0�09?4?70/�?:�=07:.,?4:9�,9/�:=�.3,920�:1�;0=>:9,7

4/09?4?D�,?�?30�0C;09>0�:1�?30�#=:2=,8��'34>�=423?�8,D�-0�0C?09/0/�?:�,9D�808-0=�:1�?30�1,847D

:1�?30�*4?90>>�B4?349�?30�>0.:9/�.4A47�/02=00�:1�.:9>,92@494?D :=�,11494?D�

�-��'30��0;,=?809?�>3,77��B3090A0=�;=,.?4.,-70��,>>4>?�?30�*4?90>>�49�:-?,49492�,�80,9>

:1�74A0743::/��'30�*4?90>>�=07:.,?0/�;@=>@,9?�?:�?34>��.?�>3,77�-0�09?4?70/�?:�,�149,9.4,7�,>>4>?,9.0

1=:8�?30�#=:2=,8�1:=�34>�>@;;:=?�,9/�?3,?�:1�34>�1,847D�49�>@.3�,8:@9?�,9/�1:=�>@.3�/@=,?4:9�,>

?30��0;,=?809?�>3,77�/0?0=8490�

�.���9�9:�.,>0�>3,77�?30�*4?90>>�-0�=08:A0/�1=:8�:=�/08:?0/�49�B:=6�-0.,@>0�:=�:9

,..:@9?�:1�34>�,->09.0>�/@0�?:�34>�,??09/,9.0�-01:=0�,9D�5@/4.4,7�:=�<@,>4�5@/4.4,7�-:/D�:=

49A0>?42,?492�,@?3:=4?D��49.7@/492�7024>7,?4A0�49A0>?42,?4:9>�49�,4/�:1�7024>7,?4:9��49�2:492�?30=0?:

,9/�49�.:8492�?30=01=:8��#=:A4/0/��'3,?�34>�08;7:D0=�4>�9:?4140/�?3=:@23�,�.0=?414.,?4:9�4>>@0/�-D

?30��0;,=?809?��B4?349�,�;0=4:/�:1�?34=?D�����/,D>�1=:8�?30 /,?0�B309�?30�*4?90>>�7,>?�=0;:=?0/

1:=�B:=6��#=:A4/0/��1@=?30=��'3,?�49�?30�.,>0�:1�;=:7:920/�?=,9>10=�:=�;0=8,909?�=07:.,?4:9��?30

08;7:D0=�>3,77�3,A0�?30�:;?4:9�?:�=08:A0�?30�*4?90>>�1=:8�08;7:D809?�,1?0=�>0.@=492�.70,=,9.0

1=:8�?30��0;,=?809?�@;:9�?30 =0.:8809/,?4:9�:1�?30��0;,=?809?�:1��,-:=�,9/��8;7:D809?�

�9D�*4?90>>�B3:�1,470/�?:�=0;:=?�1:=�B:=6�-0.,@>0�:1�B4?90>>�/@?D�>3,77�-0�;,4/�34>

0<@4A,709?�>,7,=40>�:=�B,20>�.:==0>;:9/492�?:�?30�9@8-0=�:1�/,D>�:1�,->09.0�:..,>4:90/�-D�?30

#=:2=,8���:=�;@=;:>0>�:1�?34>��.?��,9D�1=,.?4:9�:1�,�/,D�>3,77�.:9>?4?@?0�,�1@77�/,D�>,7,=D�:=�B,20�

'34>�;=:A4>4:9�>3,77�-0�,;;74.,-70�?:�-:?3�2:A0=9809?�,9/�;=4A,?0�08;7:D00>�

�/��':�-0�;=:A4/0/�B4?3�=0,>:9,-70�?=,A077492�0C;09>0>�,9/�>@->4>?09.0�,77:B,9.0�-D�?30

#=:2=,8�49 >@.3�,8:@9?�,>�?30��0;,=?809?�8,D�/0?0=8490�1:=�34>�,??09/,9.0�49�?30�.:@=?��-:/D

:=�,@?3:=4?D�B30=0�34>�?0>?48:9D�4>�=0<@4=0/��,>�B077�,>�.:910=09.0>�,9/�49?0=A40B>�B4?3

;=:>0.@?:=>�:=�49A0>?42,?492�:114.0=>�

�0��':�-0�;=:A4/0/�B4?3�1=00�80/4.,7�?=0,?809?��3:>;4?,74E,?4:9�,9/�80/4.490>�1:=�,9D

495@=D�:=�47790>>�49.@==0/�:=�>@110=0/�-D�348�-0.,@>0�:1�B4?90>>�/@?D�49�,9D�;=4A,?0�:=�;@-74.

3:>;4?,7��.7494.��:=�,?�,9D�>@.3�49>?4?@?4:9�,?�?30�0C;09>0�:1�?30�#=:2=,8�

�1���1�,�*4?90>>�4>�64770/��-0.,@>0�:1�34>�;,=?4.4;,?4:9�49�?30�#=:2=,8��34>�304=>�>3,77�-0

09?4?70/�?:�,�-@=4,7�-09014?�:1�9:?�70>>�?3,9�'09�?3:@>,9/�;0>:>��#����1=:8�?30�#=:2=,8

0C.7@>4A0�:1�,9D�:?30=�>4847,=�-09014?>�30�8,D�-0�09?4?70/�?:�@9/0=�:?30=�0C4>?492�7,B>�

�2���9�.,>0�:1�/0,?3�:= ;0=8,909?�49.,;,.4?D��34>�849:=�:=�/0;09/09?�.347/=09�>3,77�-0

09?4?70/�?:�1=00�0/@.,?4:9��1=:8�;=48,=D�?:�.:77020�70A07�49�,9D�>?,?0��:=�;=4A,?0�>.3::7��.:77020�:=

@94A0=>4?D�,>�8,D�-0�/0?0=8490/�-D�?30��0;,=?809?��,>�7:92�,>�?30D�>3,77�3,A0�<@,74140/�?30=0?:�

�$#*%('��� �!���(���"���� "��"���� � �9�,9D�.,>0�B30=0�,�*4?90>>�,/84??0/�49?:�?30�#=:2=,8

>3,77�?0>?41D��?30�5@/4.4,7�:=�<@,>4�5@/4.4,7�-:/D��:=�49A0>?42,?492�,@?3:=4?D�>3,77�,>>@=0�,�>;00/D

Page 217: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

� �

30,=492�:=�?=4,7�,9/�>3,77�09/0,A:=�?:�1494>3�>,4/ ;=:.00/492�B4?349�?3=00�����8:9?3>�1=:8�?30

147492�:1�?30�.,>0�

�$#*%('���� �$�$����$��##� � �9D�;0=>:9�B3:�3,>�;,=?4.4;,?0/�49�?30�.:884>>4:9�:1�,�.=480�,9/

/0>4=0>�?:�-0�,�B4?90>>�1:=�?30�&?,?0��.,9�,;;7D�,9/��41�<@,74140/�,>�/0?0=8490/�49�?34>��.?�,9/�-D

?30��0;,=?809?��>3,77�-0�,/84??0/�49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�B3090A0=�?30�1:77:B492�.4=.@8>?,9.0>�,=0

;=0>09?�

�,��?30�:1109>0�49�B34.3�34>�?0>?48:9D�B477�-0�@>0/�4>�,�2=,A0�107:9D�,>�/01490/�@9/0=�?30

%0A4>0/�#09,7��:/0�:=�4?>�0<@4A,709?�@9/0=�>;0.4,7�7,B>�

�-��?30=0�4>�,->:7@?0�90.0>>4?D�1:=�34>�?0>?48:9D�

�.��?30=0�4>�9:�:?30=�/4=0.?�0A4/09.0�,A,47,-70�1:=�?30�;=:;0=�;=:>0.@?4:9�:1�?30�:1109>0

.:884??0/�

�/��34>�?0>?48:9D�.,9�-0�>@->?,9?4,77D�.:==:-:=,?0/�:9�4?>�8,?0=4,7�;:49?>�

�0��30�/:0>�9:?�,;;0,=�?:�-0�8:>?�2@47?D��,9/

�1��30�3,>�9:?�,?�,9D�?480�-009�.:9A4.?0/�:1�,9D�.=480�49A:7A492�8:=,7�?@=;4?@/0�

�9�,..@>0/�/4>.3,=20/�1=:8�,9�491:=8,?4:9�:=�.=4849,7�.:8;7,49?�-D�?30�.:@=?�49�:=/0=

?3,?�30�8,D�-0�,�&?,?0�*4?90>>�;@=>@,9?�?:�&0.?4:9���,9/��:1�%@70�� :1�?30�%0A4>0/�%@70>�:1

�:@=?�8,D�@;:9�34>�;0?4?4:9�-0�,/84??0/�?:�?30�#=:2=,8�41�30�.:8;740>�B4?3�?30�:?30=

=0<@4=0809?>�:1�?34>��.?��!:?3492�49�?34>��.?�>3,77�;=0A09?�?30�/4>.3,=20�:1�,9�,..@>0/��>:�?3,?�30

.,9�-0�@>0/�,>�,�&?,?0�*4?90>>�@9/0=�%@70���:1�?30�%0A4>0/�%@70>�:1��:@=?�

�$#*%('���� �' "���$�$����$� � �01:=0�,9D�;0=>:9�4>�,/84??0/�49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�;@=>@,9?�?:�?30

90C?�;=0.0/492�&0.?4:9�30�>3,77�0C0.@?0�,�>B:=9�>?,?0809?�/0>.=4-492�49�/0?,47�?30�8,990=�49

B34.3�?30�:1109>0�B,>�.:884??0/�,9/�34> ;,=?4.4;,?4:9�?30=049���1�,1?0=�>,4/�0C,849,?4:9�:1�>,4/

;0=>:9��34>�>B:=9�>?,?0809?�,9/�:?30=�=070A,9?�1,.?>��?30��0;,=?809?�4>�>,?4>140/�?3,?�?30

=0<@4=0809?>�:1�?34>��.?�,9/�4?>�48;70809?492�=@70>�,=0�.:8;740/�B4?3��4?�8,D�,/84?�>@.3�;0=>:9

49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�,9/�4>>@0�?30�.:==0>;:9/492�.0=?414.,?4:9�

�1�34>�,;;74.,?4:9�1:=�,/84>>4:9�4>�/0940/��>,4/�>B:=9�>?,?0809?�,9/�,9D�:?30=�?0>?48:9D�24A09�49

>@;;:=?�:1�>,4/�,;;74.,?4:9�>3,77�9:?�-0�,/84>>4-70�49�0A4/09.0��0C.0;?�1:=�48;0,.3809?�;@=;:>0>�

�$#*%('���� �����$� ������##� �� �����$�$����$��##���$ �$����" �"��� � '30�.0=?414.,?4:9�:1

,/84>>4:9�49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�-D�?30��0;,=?809?�>3,77�-0�24A09�1@77�1,4?3�,9/�.=0/4?�-D�?30

;=:A49.4,7�:=�.4?D�;=:>0.@?:=�B3:�4>�=0<@4=0/�9:?�?:�49.7@/0�?30�*4?90>>�49�?30�.=4849,7�.:8;7,49?

:=�491:=8,?4:9�,9/�41�49.7@/0/�?30=049��?:�;0?4?4:9�?30�.:@=?�1:=�34>�/4>.3,=20�49�:=/0=�?3,?�30�.,9

@?474E0/�,>�,�&?,?0�*4?90>>��'30��:@=?�>3,77�:=/0=�?30�/4>.3,=20�,9/�0C.7@>4:9�:1�?30�>,4/�,..@>0/

1=:8�?30�491:=8,?4:9�

�/84>>4:9�49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�>3,77�09?4?70�>@.3�&?,?0�*4?90>>�?:�488@94?D�1=:8�.=4849,7

;=:>0.@?4:9�1:=�?30�:1109>0�:=�:1109>0>�49�B34.3�34>�?0>?48:9D�B477�-0�24A09�:=�@>0/�,9/�,77�?30

=423?>�,9/�-09014?>�;=:A4/0/�@9/0=�&0.?4:9���30=0:1�

Page 218: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

� �

�$#*%('���� ����%"�� "����%#��� ��$�����$��##�$ ���#$��(� � �9D�*4?90>>�=024>?0=0/�49�?30

#=:2=,8�B3:�1,47>�:=�=01@>0>�?:�?0>?41D�:=�?:�.:9?49@0�?:�?0>?41D�B4?3:@?�5@>?�.,@>0�B309�7,B1@77D

:-7420/�?:�/:�>:��>3,77�-0�;=:>0.@?0/�1:=�.:9?08;?���1�30�?0>?4140>�1,7>07D�:=�0A,>4A07D��30�>3,77�-0

74,-70�?:�;=:>0.@?4:9�1:=�;0=5@=D���1�,�&?,?0�*4?90>>�1,47>�:=�=01@>0>�?:�?0>?41D��:=�?0>?4140>�1,7>07D�:=

0A,>4A07D��:=�A4:7,?0>�,9D�.:9/4?4:9�,..:8;,9D492�>@.3�488@94?D�B4?3:@?�5@>?�.,@>0��,>

/0?0=8490/�49�,�30,=492�-D�?30�;=:;0=�.:@=?��34>�488@94?D�>3,77�-0 =08:A0/�,9/�30�>3,77�-0

>@-50.?�?:�.:9?08;?�:=�.=4849,7�;=:>0.@?4:9�� :=0:A0=��?30�095:D809?�:1�,77�=423?>�,9/�-09014?>

@9/0=�?34>��.?�>3,77�-0�/0080/�?0=849,?0/�

'30�*4?90>>�8,D��3:B0A0=��;@=20�348>071�:1�?30�.:9?@8,.4:@>�,.?>�-D�?0>?41D492�,?�,9D

,;;=:;=4,?0�>?,20�:1�?30�;=:.00/492>�

�$#*%('��� � �!��������#$�� �(� � �9D�*4?90>>�,/84??0/�49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�;@=>@,9?�?:�&0.?4:9>

��,9/��:1�?34>��.?�.,99:?�=01@>0�?:�?0>?41D�:=�24A0�0A4/09.0�:=�;=:/@.0�-::6>��/:.@809?>�

=0.:=/>�:=�B=4?492>�90.0>>,=D�1:=�?30�;=:>0.@?4:9�:1�?30�:1109>0�:=�:1109>0>�1:=�B34.3�30�3,>�-009

,/84??0/�49?:�?30�#=:2=,8�:9�?30�2=:@9/�:1�?30�.:9>?4?@?4:9,7�=423?�,2,49>?�>071�49.=4849,?4:9�-@?

30�>3,77�095:D�488@94?D�1=:8�.=4849,7�;=:>0.@?4:9�,9/�.,99:?�-0�>@-50.?0/�?:�,9D�;09,7?D�:=

1:=104?@=0�1:=�,9D�?=,9>,.?4:9��8,??0=�:=�?3492�.:9.0=9492�34>�.:8;0770/�?0>?48:9D�:=�-::6>�

/:.@809?>��=0.:=/>�,9/�B=4?492>�;=:/@.0/�

�9�.,>0�:1�=01@>,7�:1�>,4/�*4?90>>�?:�?0>?41D�:=�24A0�0A4/09.0�:=�;=:/@.0�-::6>�

/:.@809?>��=0.:=/>��:=�B=4?492>��:9�?30�2=:@9/�:1�?30�=423?�,2,49>?�>071�49.=4849,?4:9��,9/�?30

>?,?0�;=:>0.@?:=�:=�49A0>?42,?:=�-0740A0>�?3,?�>@.3�0A4/09.0�4>�,->:7@?07D�90.0>>,=D�1:=�,

>@..0>>1@7�;=:>0.@?4:9�:1�?30�:1109>0�:=�:1109>0>�.3,=20/�:=�@9/0=�49A0>?42,?4:9��30��B4?3�?30�;=4:=

,;;=:A,7�:1�?30�/0;,=?809?��>3,77�1470�,�;0?4?4:9�B4?3�?30�,;;=:;=4,?0�.:@=?�1:=�?30�4>>@,9.0�:1�,9

:=/0=�=0<@4=492�>,4/�*4?90>>�?:�?0>?41D��24A0�0A4/09.0�:=�;=:/@.0�?30�-::6>��/:.@809?>��=0.:=/>�

,9/�B=4?492>�/0>.=4-0/��,9/�?30�.:@=?�>3,77�4>>@0�?30�;=:;0=�:=/0=�

'30 .:@=?��@;:9�8:?4:9�:1�?30�>?,?0�;=:>0.@?:=�:=�49A0>?42,?:=��>3,77�:=/0=�?30�,==0>?�,9/

/0?09?4:9�:1�?30�*4?90>>�49�,9D�5,47�.:9?42@:@>�?:�?30�;7,.0�:1�?=4,7�:=�49A0>?42,?4:9�@9?47�>@.3�?480

?3,?�?30�*4?90>>�4>�B477492�?:�24A0�>@.3�?0>?48:9D�:=�;=:/@.0�>@.3 /:.@809?,=D�0A4/09.0�

�$#*%('��� ��"�%"(� "�� �$��!$� � !:�*4?90>>�>3,77�-0�0C08;?�1=:8�;=:>0.@?4:9�1:=�;0=5@=D�:=

.:9?08;?�.:884??0/�B3470�24A492�?0>?48:9D�:=�;=:/@.492�0A4/09.0�@9/0=�.:8;@7>4:9�;@=>@,9?�?:

?34>��.?��'30�;09,7?D�90C?�34230=�49�/02=00�>3,77�-0�48;:>0/�49�.,>0�:1�.:9A4.?4:9�1:=�;0=5@=D��'30

;=:.0/@=0�;=0>.=4-0/�@9/0=�%@70���:1�?30�%@70>�:1��:@=?�>3,77�-0�1:77:B0/�49�.:9?08;?

;=:.00/492>�-@?�?30�;09,7?D�?:�-0�48;:>0/�>3,77�9:?�-0�70>>�?3,9�:90����8:9?3�-@?�9:?�8:=0�?3,9

:90����D0,=�48;=4>:9809?�

�$#*%('���� �"�������$(� ����$��##� � �9�,77�.=4849,7�.,>0>��?30�1,.?�:1�?30�09?4?70809?�:1�?30

*4?90>>�?:�?30�;=:?0.?4:9�,9/�-09014?>�;=:A4/0/�1:=�49�?34>��.?�>3,77�9:?�-0�,/84>>4-70�49�0A4/09.0

?:�/48494>3�:=�,110.?�34>�.=0/4-474?D�

�$#*%('���� �����$(�� "��"�##���$� ����$��##� � �9D�;0=>:9�B3:�3,=,>>0>�,�*4?90>>�,9/

?30=0-D�349/0=>��/07,D>��;=0A09?>�:=�/4>>@,/0>�,�*4?90>>�1=:8�

�,��,??09/492�:=�?0>?41D492�-01:=0�,9D�5@/4.4,7�:=�<@,>4�5@/4.4,7�-:/D�:=�49A0>?42,?492

,@?3:=4?D�

Page 219: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

� �

�-��=0;:=?492�?:�, 7,B�091:=.0809?�:114.0=�:=�5@/20�?30�.:884>>4:9�:=�;:>>4-70

.:884>>4:9�:1�,9�:1109>0��:=�,�A4:7,?4:9�:1�.:9/4?4:9>�:=�;=:-,?4:9��;,=:70��:=�=070,>0�;09/492

5@/4.4,7�;=:.00/492>�

�.��>006492�?30�,==0>?�:1�,9:?30=�;0=>:9�49�.:990.?4:9�B4?3�?30�:1109>0�

�/��.,@>492�,�.=4849,7�;=:>0.@?4:9��:=�,�;=:.00/492�1:=�?30�=0A:.,?4:9�:1�,�;,=:70�:=

;=:-,?4:9��:=

�0��;0=1:=8492�,9/�095:D492�?30�=423?>�,9/�-09014?>�@9/0=�?34>��.?�:=�,??08;?>�?:�/:�>:�

>3,77�-0�1490/�9:?�8:=0�?3,9�'3=00�?3:@>,9/�;0>:>��#�����:=�>@110= 48;=4>:9809?�:1�9:?�70>>

?3,9�>4C�����8:9?3>�-@?�9:?�8:=0�?3,9�:90����D0,=��:=�-:?3��,9/�30�>3,77�,7>:�>@110=�?30�;09,7?D�:1

;0=;0?@,7�/4><@,7414.,?4:9�1=:8�3:7/492�;@-74.�:114.0�49�.,>0�:1�,�;@-74.�:114.0=�

�$#*%('�� � �%��#��������%��$� �#� � '30��0;,=?809?�>3,77�;=:8@72,?0�>@.3�=@70>�,9/

=02@7,?4:9>�,>�8,D�-0�90.0>>,=D�?:�48;70809?�?30�49?09?�,9/�;@=;:>0>�:1�?34>��.?��&,4/�=@70>�,9/

=02@7,?4:9>�>3,77�-0�;@-74>30/�49�?B:�����90B>;,;0=>�:1�2090=,7�.4=.@7,?4:9�

�$#*%('���� ��!����������%#�� � �77�7,B>��/0.=00>��0C0.@?4A0�4>>@,9.0>��=@70>�,9/�=02@7,?4:9>

49.:9>4>?09?�B4?3�?34>��.?�,=0�30=0-D�=0;0,70/�:=�8:/4140/�,..:=/4927D�

�$#*%('���� �%������ � '30�,8:@9?�:1�'09�84774:9�;0>:>��#�����4>�30=0-D�,@?3:=4E0/

?:�-0�,;;=:;=4,?0/�:@?�:1�,9D�1@9/>�49�?30 !,?4:9,7�'=0,>@=D�9:?�:?30=B4>0�,;;=:;=4,?0/�?:�.,==D

49?:�0110.?�?30�;@=;:>0�:1�?34>��.?�

�C;09>0>�49.@==0/�49�?30�48;70809?,?4:9�:1�?30�#=:2=,8�8,D�-0�=0.:A0=0/�,>�;,=?�:1�?30

.:>?�:=�49/0894?D�48;:>0/�@;:9�?30�,..@>0/�

�@=?30=8:=0��:?30=�1@9/492�>.3080>�:=�>:@=.0>��>@-50.?�?:�?30�7484?,?4:9>�:1�?30�7,B��>3,77

-0�,77:B0/�49�1@=?30=,9.0�30=0:1�

�$#*%('���� ��!�"�����$(����%#�� � '30�/0.7,=,?4:9�:1�@9.:9>?4?@?4:9,74?D�:=�49A,74/4?D�:1�,9D

;=:A4>4:9�:1�?34>��.?�>3,77�9:?�,110.?�?30�:?30=�;=:A4>4:9>�30=0:1�

�$#*%('���� �����$�&�$(� � '34>��.?�>3,77�?,60�0110.?�,1?0=�141?009�����/,D>�1:77:B492�4?>�;@-74.,?4:9

49�?B:�����90B>;,;0=>�:1�2090=,7�.4=.@7,?4:9�

$>1?501:@5-8��1/>11�";�����(41 �4580�-:0�,;A@4�+182->1��;01��-?�-91:010�.E�$>1?501:@5-8��1/>11�";����

�CE� �� � +FDA6?D:@?� @7� +6?E6?46� 2?5� �@>>:E>6?E� @7� 1@FE97F=� '776?56C� !7� 27E6C� 962C:?8� E966G:56?46�:?�E96�AC@A6C�AC@4665:?8D��E96�4@FCE�D9@F=5�7:?5�E92E�E96�J@FE97F=�@776?56C�92D�4@>>:EE65E96� 24ED� 492C865� 282:?DE� 9:>�� E96� 4@FCE� D92==� 56E6C>:?6� E96� :>A@D23=6� A6?2=EJ�� :?4=F5:?8� 2?J� 4:G:==:23:=:EJ�492C8623=6�282:?DE�9:>� @H6G6C��:?DE625�@7�AC@?@F?4:?8�;F58>6?E�@7�4@?G:4E:@?��E96�4@FCE�FA@?�2AA=:42E:@?�@7�E96�J@FE97F=�@776?56C�:7�:E�7:?5D�E92E�E96�36DE�:?E6C6DE�@7�E96�AF3=:4�2D�H6==�2D�E92E@7�E96�@776?56C�H:==�36�D6CG65�E96C63J��>2J�DFDA6?5�2==�7FCE96C�AC@4665:?8D�2?5�4@>>:E�DF49�>:?@CE@�E96�4FDE@5J�@7�42C6�@7�E96��6A2CE>6?E�@7�+@4:2=�/6=72C6��@C�E@�2?J�EC2:?:?8�:?DE:EFE:@?�@A6C2E65�3JE96�8@G6C?>6?E�@C�2?J�@E96C�C6DA@?D:3=6�A6CD@?�F?E:=�96�D92==�92G6�C624965�EH6?EJ�@?6�J62CD�@7�286�@C� 7@C� 2� D9@CE6C� A6C:@5� 2D� E96� 4@FCE� >2J� 566>� AC@A6C�� 27E6C� 4@?D:56C:?8� E96� C6A@CED� 2?5C64@>>6?52E:@?D� @7� E96��6A2CE>6?E� @7� +@4:2=�/6=72C6� @C� E96� 8@G6C?>6?E� EC2:?:?8� :?DE:EFE:@?� @C

Page 220: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

C6DA@?D:3=6�A6CD@?�F?56C�H9@D6�42C6�96�92D 366?�4@>>:EE65�-A@?�C646:AE�@7�E96�2AA=:42E:@?�@7�E96J@FE97F=�@776?56C� 7@C� DFDA6?D:@?�@7�9:D� D6?E6?46�� E96� 4@FCE�>2J� C6BF:C6� E96��6A2CE>6?E�@7� +@4:2=/6=72C6� E@� AC6A2C6� 2?5� DF3>:E� E@� E96� 4@FCE� 2� D@4:2=� 42D6� DEF5J� C6A@CE� @G6C� E96� @776?56C� 2?5� 9:D72>:=J ,96�J@FE97F=�@776?56C�D92==�36�DF3;64E�E@�G:D:E2E:@?�2?5�DFA6CG:D:@?�3J�2�C6AC6D6?E2E:G6�@7�E96�6A2CE>6?E�@7�+@4:2=�/6=72C6�@C�8@G6C?>6?E�EC2:?:?8�:?DE:EFE:@?�2D�E96�4@FCE�>2J�56D:8?2E6�DF3;64EE@� DF49� 4@?5:E:@?D� 2D� :E� >2J� AC6D4C:36,96� 36?67:ED� @7� E9:D 2CE:4=6� D92==� ?@E� 2AA=J� E@� 2� J@FE97F=@776?56C� H9@� 92D� @?46� 6?;@J65� DFDA6?D:@?� @7� D6?E6?46� F?56C� :ED� AC@G:D:@?D� @C� E@� @?6� H9@� :D4@?G:4E65�@7�2?�@776?D6�AF?:D923=6�3J�562E9�@C�=:76�:>AC:D@?>6?E

�./!($&!��.,-$�!��( ��!&"�+!���-�)"������������ �

�%#4)/.� ����(),$2%.� �%,/7� 4(%��'%� /&��2)-).!,��%30/.3)"),)49� � !7� :E� 92D�366?� 56E6C>:?65� E92E� E96� 49:=5E2<6?�:?E@�4FDE@5J�:D�7:7E66?������J62CD�@=5�@C�36=@H��E96�2FE9@C:EJ�H9:49�H:==�92G6�2?�:?:E:2=�4@?E24EH:E9� E96� 49:=5� 92D� E96� 5FEJ� E@� :>>65:2E6=J� C6=62D6� E96� 49:=5� E@� E96� 4FDE@5J� @7� 9:D96C� A2C6?ED� @C8F2C5:2?��@C�:?�E96�23D6?46�E96C6@7��E96�49:=5�D�?62C6DE�C6=2E:G6�+2:5�2FE9@C:EJ�D92==�8:G6�?@E:46�E@�E96=@42=� D@4:2=� H6=72C6� 2?5� 56G6=@A>6?E� @77:46C� H9@� H:==� 56E6C>:?6� E96� 2AAC@AC:2E6� AC@8C2>D� :?4@?DF=E2E:@?�H:E9�E96�49:=5�2?5�E@�E96�A6CD@?�92G:?8�4FDE@5J�@G6C�E96�49:=5�!7�E96�A2C6?ED��8F2C5:2?D@C�?62C6DE�C6=2E:G6D�42??@E�36�=@42E65��@C�:7�E96J�C67FD6�E@�E2<6�4FDE@5J��E96�49:=5�>2J�36�C6=62D65�E@2?J�@7�E96�7@==@H:?8��2�5F=J�C68:DE6C65�?@?8@G6C?>6?E2=�@C�C6=:8:@FD�@C82?:K2E:@?��2�32C2?82J�@77:4:2=@C�2�>6>36C�@7�E96��2C2?82J��@F?4:=�7@C�E96�(C@E64E:@?�@7��9:=5C6?����(����2�=@42=�D@4:2=�H6=72C62?5�56G6=@A>6?E�@77:46C��@C�H96?�2?5�H96C6�2AAC@AC:2E6��E96��+/��!7�E96�49:=5�C676CC65�E@�96C6:?92D�366?�7@F?5�3J�E96�$@42=�+@4:2=�/6=72C6�2?5��6G6=@A>6?E�'77:46�E@�36�232?5@?65��?68=64E65�@C23FD65�3J�9:D�A2C6?ED��@C�:?�E96�6G6?E�E92E�E96�A2C6?ED�H:==�?@E�4@>A=J�H:E9�E96�AC6G6?E:@?�AC@8C2>�E96� AC@A6C� A6E:E:@?� 7@C� :?G@=F?E2CJ� 4@>>:E>6?E� D92==� 36� 7:=65� 3J� E96��+/�� @C� E96� $@42=� +@4:2=/6=72C6� 2?5� �6G6=@A>6?E�'77:46� AFCDF2?E� E@� (C6D:56?E:2=� �64C66� &@� ����� @E96CH:D6� �<?@H?� 2D�,96��9:=5�2?5�1@FE9�/6=72C6��@56�

'���� � � �#$& +!(� $(� �)("&$�-� 0$-#� -#!� ��0� �$"-!!(� ����� �!�+,� �& � �( � �!&)0� � -A@?67764E:G:EJ� @7� E9:D� �4E�� 42D6D� @7� 49:=5C6?� 7:7E66?� ����� J62CD� @=5� 2?5� 36=@H� 2E� E96� E:>6� @7� E964@>>:DD:@?� @7� E96� 4C:>6� D92==� :>>65:2E6=J� 36� 5:D>:DD65� 2?5� E96� 49:=5� D92==� 36� C676CC65� E@� E962AAC@AC:2E6�=@42=�D@4:2=�H6=72C6�2?5�56G6=@A>6?E�@77:46C�+F49�@77:46C��FA@?�E9@C@F89�2DD6DD>6?E�@7E96�49:=5��D92==�56E6C>:?6�H96E96C�E@�C6=62D6�E96�49:=5�E@�E96�4FDE@5J�@7�9:D96C�A2C6?ED��@C�C676C�E9649:=5� E@� AC6G6?E:@?� AC@8C2>D� 2D� AC@G:565� F?56C� E9:D� �4E� ,9@D6� H:E9� DFDA6?565� D6?E6?46D� 2?5F?56C8@:?8� C6923:=:E2E:@?� 2E� E96� J@FE9� C6923:=:E2E:@?� 46?E6C� D92==� =:<6H:D6� 36� C6=62D65�� F?=6DD� :E� :D4@?EC2CJ�E@�E96�36DE�:?E6C6DE�@7�E96�49:=5

�/@�$>;45.5@5:3�@41��9<;?5@5;:�;2��1-@4�$1:-8@E�5:�@41�$4585<<5:1?��&������ ��

'��(�#"�� ,96� :>A@D:E:@?�@7� E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�562E9� :D�96C63J�AC@9:3:E65��44@C5:?8=J��*6AF3=:4�4E�&@��:89E�,9@FD2?5�'?6� F?5C65�+6G6?EJ�+6G6?��*��&@��������@E96CH:D6�<?@H?�2D�E96��4E�6D:8?2E:?8��62E9� 3J� $6E92=� !?;64E:@?� :D� 96C63J� C6A62=65� *6AF3=:4��4E�&@� +6G6?�,9@FD2?5� +:I F?5C65��:7EJ�&:?6��*��&@��������@E96CH:D6�<?@H?�2D�E96��62E9�(6?2=EJ�$2H��2?5�2==�@E96C�=2HD�6I64FE:G6� @C56CD� 2?5� 564C66D�� :?D@72C� 2D� E96J� :>A@D6� E96� 562E9� A6?2=EJ� 2C6� 96C63J� C6A62=65� @C2>6?565�244@C5:?8=J

'������ !?�=:6F�@7�E96�562E9�A6?2=EJ��E96�7@==@H:?8�D92==�36�:>A@D65�2�� E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�C64=FD:@?�A6CA6EF2��H96?�E96� =2H�G:@=2E65�>2<6D�FD6�@7� E96�?@>6?4=2EFC6�@7� E96A6?2=E:6D�@7�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56��@C�3��E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�=:76�:>AC:D@?>6?E��H96?�E96�=2H�G:@=2E65�5@6D�?@E�>2<6�FD6�@7�E96�?@>6?4=2EFC6@7�E96�A6?2=E:6D�@7�E96�*6G:D65�(6?2=��@56

Page 221: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

��

'���� �� (6CD@?� 4@?G:4E65� @7� @776?D6D� AF?:D965�H:E9 2%#,53)/.� 0%20%45!�� @C�H9@D6� D6?E6?46D�H:==� 36C65F465�E@ 2%#,53)/.�0%20%45!��3J�C62D@?�@7�E9:D��4E��D92==�?@E�36�6=:8:3=6�7@C�A2C@=6�F?56C��4E�&@������@E96CH:D6�<?@H?�2D�E96�!?56E6C>:?2E6�+6?E6?46�$2H��2D�2>6?565

'���� � ,96��@2C5�@7�(2C5@?D�2?5�(2C@=6�D92==�42FD6�E96�AF3=:42E:@?�2E�=62DE�@?6�2�H66<�7@C�E9C664@?D64FE:G6� H66<D� :?� 2� ?6HDA2A6C� @7� 86?6C2=� 4:C4F=2E:@?� @7� E96� ?2>6D� @7� A6CD@?D� 4@?G:4E65� @7@776?D6D�AF?:D965�H:E9�C64=FD:@?�A6CA6EF2�@C�=:76�:>AC:D@?>6?E�3J�C62D@?�@7�E9:D��4E�H9@�2C6�36:?84@?D:56C65�@C�C64@>>6?5�7@C�4@>>FE2E:@?�@C�A2C5@?��(C@G:565��9@H6G6C��,92E�?@E9:?8�96C6:?�D92===:>:E� E96�A@H6C�@7� E96�(C6D:56?E� E@� 8C2?E� 6I64FE:G6� 4=6>6?4J�F?56C� +64E:@?������CE:4=6�.!!�@7� E96�@?DE:EFE:@?D

�A9-:�'1/A>5@E��/@�;2�����&���������

'���� �� �526%),,!.#%� /&� �530%#43� !.$� �.4%2#%04)/.� !.$� �%#/2$).'� /&� �/--5.)#!4)/.3� �,96� AC@G:D:@?D� @7*6AF3=:4��4E�&@� � ��� ��?E:�/:C6�,2AA:?8�$2H�� E@� E96� 4@?EC2CJ�?@EH:E9DE2?5:?8�� 2�A@=:46�@C� =2H6?7@C46>6?E� @77:4:2=� 2?5� E96� >6>36CD� @7� 9:D� E62>� >2J�� FA@?� 2� HC:EE6?� @C56C� @7� E96� �@FCE� @7�AA62=D��=:DE6?�E@��:?E6C46AE�2?5�C64@C5��H:E9�E96 FD6�@7�2?J�>@56��7@C>��<:?5�@C�EJA6�@7�6=64EC@?:4�@C@E96C� DFCG6:==2?46� 6BF:A>6?E� @C� :?E6C46AE:?8� 2?5� EC24<:?8� 56G:46D�� @C� H:E9� E96� FD6� @7� 2?J� @E96CDF:E23=6�H2JD�2?5�>62?D�7@C�E92E�AFCA@D6��2?J�4@>>F?:42E:@?��>6DD286��4@?G6CD2E:@?��5:D4FDD:@?��@CDA@<6? @C� HC:EE6?� H@C5D� 36EH66?� >6>36CD� @7� 2� ;F5:4:2==J� 564=2C65� 2?5� @FE=2H65� E6CC@C:DE@C82?:K2E:@?�� 2DD@4:2E:@?�� @C� 8C@FA�@7� A6CD@?D� @C�@7� 2?J� A6CD@?� 492C865�H:E9� @C� DFDA64E65� @7� E964C:>6�@7�E6CC@C:D>�@C�4@?DA:C24J�E@�4@>>:E�E6CC@C:D>�2/6)$%$�� ,92E� DFCG6:==2?46�� :?E6C46AE:@?� 2?5� C64@C5:?8� @7� 4@>>F?:42E:@?D� 36EH66?� =2HJ6CD� 2?54=:6?ED��5@4E@CD�2?5�A2E:6?ED�� ;@FC?2=:DED�2?5�E96:C�D@FC46D�2?5�4@?7:56?E:2=�3FD:?6DD�4@CC6DA@?56?46D92==�?@E�36�2FE9@C:K65

'������ �!+$) �)"��!-!(-$)(�$(�-#!��/!(-�)"��(���-.�&�)+ �''$(!(-��!++)+$,-��--��%� � !?�E966G6?E�@7� 2?�24EF2=�@C� :>>:?6?E� E6CC@C:DE� 2EE24<�� DFDA64ED�>2J�?@E�36�56E2:?65� 7@C�>@C6� E92?� E9C6652JD�H:E9@FE� E96�HC:EE6?� 2AAC@G2=� @7� 2�>F?:4:A2=�� 4:EJ�� AC@G:?4:2=� @C� C68:@?2=� @77:4:2=� @7� 2� F>2?*:89ED��@>>:DD:@?�@C�;F586�@7�E96�>F?:4:A2=��C68:@?2=�EC:2=�4@FCE��E96�+2?5:82?32J2?�@C�2�;FDE:46�@7E96��@FCE�@7��AA62=D�?62C6DE�E96�A=246�@7�E96�2CC6DE�!7�E96�2CC6DE�:D�>256�5FC:?8�+2EFC52JD��+F?52JD�9@=:52JD� @C� 27E6C� @77:46� 9@FCD�� E96� 2CC6DE:?8� A@=:46� @C� =2H� 6?7@C46>6?E� A6CD@??6=� D92==� 3C:?8� E96A6CD@?�E9FD�2CC6DE65�E@�E96�C6D:56?46�@7�2?J�@7�E96�@77:4:2=D�>6?E:@?65�23@G6�E92E�:D�?62C6DE�E96�A=246H96C6�E96�244FD65�H2D�2CC6DE65�,96�2AAC@G2=�:?�HC:E:?8�@7�2?J�@7�E96�D2:5�@77:4:2=D�D92==�36�D64FC653J�E96�A@=:46�@C�=2H�6?7@C46>6?E�A6CD@??6=�4@?46C?65�H:E9:?�7:G6�52JD�27E6C�E96�52E6�@7�E96�56E6?E:@?@7� E96�A6CD@?D�4@?46C?65� �2/6)$%$��(/7%6%2��,92E�H:E9:?� E9C66�52JD�27E6C�E96�56E6?E:@?� E96�DFDA64ED�H9@D6�4@??64E:@?�H:E9�E96�E6CC@C�2EE24<�@C�E9C62E�:D�?@E�6DE23=:D965��D92==�36 C6=62D65�:>>65:2E6=J

'������� �5$)#)!,��54(/2):!4)/.��%15)2%$�4/��8!-).%��!.+��%0/3)43���##/5.43��!.$��%#/2$3 � ,96�AC@G:D:@?D@7�*6AF3=:4��4E�&@������2D�2>6?565��E@�E96�4@?EC2CJ�?@EH:E9DE2?5:?8��E96�;FDE:46D�@7�E96��@FCE�@7�AA62=D�56D:8?2E65�2D�2�DA64:2=�4@FCE�E@�92?5=6�2?E:�E6CC@C:D>�42D6D�27E6C�D2E:D7J:?8�E96>D6=G6D�@7�E966I:DE6?46�@7�AC@323=6�42FD6� :?�2�962C:?8�42==65�7@C� E92E�AFCA@D6� E92E�� ����2�A6CD@?�492C865�H:E9�@CDFDA64E65�@7�E96�4C:>6�@7� E6CC@C:D>�@C��4@?DA:C24J� E@�4@>>:E�E6CC@C:D>�� � ��@7 2� ;F5:4:2==J�564=2C652?5�@FE=2H65�E6CC@C:DE�@C82?:K2E:@?��2DD@4:2E:@?��@C�8C@FA�@7�A6CD@?D��2?5�����@7�2�>6>36C�@7�DF49;F5:4:2==J� 564=2C65� 2?5� @FE=2H65� @C82?:K2E:@?�� 2DD@4:2E:@?�� @C� 8C@FA� @7� A6CD@?D�� >2J� 2FE9@C:K6� :?HC:E:?8�2?J�A@=:46�@C� =2H�6?7@C46>6?E @77:46C�2?5�E96�>6>36CD�@7�9:D96C�E62>�5F=J�2FE9@C:K65� :?HC:E:?8� 3J� E96� 2?E:�E6CC@C:D>� 4@F?4:=� E@�� �2�� 6I2>:?6�� @C� 42FD6� E96� 6I2>:?2E:@?� @7�� E96� 56A@D:ED�A=246>6?ED�� ECFDE� 244@F?ED�� 2DD6ED� 2?5� C64@C5D� :?� 2� 32?<� @C� 7:?2?4:2=� :?DE:EFE:@?�� 2?5� �3�� 82E96C @C42FD6� E96� 82E96C:?8� @7� 2?J� C6=6G2?E� :?7@C>2E:@?� 23@FE� DF49� 56A@D:ED�� A=246>6?ED�� ECFDE� 244@F?ED�2DD6ED��2?5�C64@C5D�7C@>�2�32?<�@C�7:?2?4:2=�:?DE:EFE:@?�,96�32?<�@C�7:?2?4:2=�:?DE:EFE:@?�4@?46C?65�D92==�?@E�C67FD6�E@�2==@H�DF49�6I2>:?2E:@?�@C�E@�AC@G:56�E96�56D:C65�:?7@C>2E:@?��H96?�D@��@C56C653J�2?5�D6CG65�H:E9�E96�HC:EE6?�@C56C�@7�E96��@FCE�@7��AA62=D

Page 222: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

�;A:/5:3��41/7?� -C����$�����

��%!&!+,*�,!.���!*�-$�*�&'�� � �����63CF2CJ� ��� ���*��� (�&�$,1��'*�.!'$�,!'&�'���(��$��

+64E:@?� �� @7� �( �=8� � ��?� �4E� (6?2=:K:?8� E96�%2<:?8� @C� �C2H:?8� 2?5� !DDF2?46� @7� 2�964<� /:E9@FE� +F77:4:6?E� �F?5D� 7@C� �C65:E� 2?5� 7@C� 'E96C� (FCA@D6D�� :>A@D6D� E96� A6?2=EJ� @7:>AC:D@?>6?E�@7�?@E�=6DD�E92?�E9:CEJ������52JD�3FE�?@E�>@C6�E92?�@?6�����J62C�@C�2�7:?6�@7�?@E�=6DDE92?� 3FE� ?@E� >@C6� E92?� 5@F3=6� E96� 2>@F?E� @7� E96� 4964<�� H9:49� 7:?6� D92==� :?� ?@� 42D6� 6I4665( ��������@C�3@E9�DF49�7:?6�2?5�:>AC:D@?>6?E�2E�E96�5:D4C6E:@?�@7�E96�4@FCE

!?�:ED�564:D:@?�:? �$5!2$/� !#!��6���/524�/&��00%!,3 ��*�&@������������&@G6>36C������ ��+�*������� ����� E96� +FAC6>6��@FCE� �+64@?5��:G:D:@?�� A6C�%C� "FDE:46�.�%6?5@K2��>@5:7:65� E96D6?E6?46�:>A@D65�7@C�G:@=2E:@?�@7��(��=8� �3J�56=6E:?8�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�2?5�:>A@D:?8@?=J�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�7:?6� :?�2?�2>@F?E�5@F3=6�E96�2>@F?E�@7 E96�4964<�!?�;FDE:7:42E:@?�E96C6@7��E96�@FCE�D2:5�

�%4)4)/.%23�!2%�&)234�4)-%�/&&%.$%23���(%9�!2%��),)0)./�%.42%02%.%523�7(/�02%35-!",9�#/.42)"54%�4/�4(%�.!4)/.!,%#/./-9���00!2%.4,9�� 4(%9� "2/5'(4� 4()3� !00%!,�� "%,)%6).'� ).� !,,� '//$� &!)4(�� !,4(/5'(� -)34!+%.,9� 4(!4� 4(%9� (!$� ./4#/--)44%$�!�6)/,!4)/.�/&�������,'�����4(%27)3%��4(%9�#/5,$�3)-0,9�(!6%�!##%04%$�4(%�*5$'-%.4�/&�4(%�42)!,�#/524�!.$!00,)%$� &/2�02/"!4)/.� 4/� %6!$%�!�02)3/.� 4%2-���4�7/5,$�"%34� 3%26%� 4(%� %.$3� /&� #2)-).!,� *534)#%� )&� ).� &)8).'� 4(%�0%.!,497)4().�4(%�2!.'%�/&�$)3#2%4)/.�!,,/7%$�"9��%#4)/.����0!2�����4(%�3!-%�0(),/3/0(9�5.$%2,9).'�4(%��.$%4%2-).!4%��%.4%.#%�!7�)3�/"3%26%$��.!-%,9��4(!4�/&�2%$%%-).'�6!,5!",%�(5-!.�-!4%2)!,�!.$�02%6%.4).'�5..%#%33!29�$%02)6!4)/.�&�0%23/.!,,)"%249�!.$�%#/./-)#�53%&5,.%33�7)4(�$5%�2%'!2$�4/�4(%�02/4%#4)/.�/&�4(%�3/#)!,�/2$%2���.�4()3�#!3%��7%�"%,)%6%�4(!4�!�&).%�).!.� !-/5.4� %15!,� 4/� $/5",%� 4(%� !-/5.4� /&� 4(%� #(%#+� ).6/,6%$� )3� !.� !002/02)!4%� 0%.!,49� 4/� )-0/3%� /.� %!#(� /&� 4(%0%4)4)/.%23

!?� E96� C646?E�42D6 @7 �/3!��)-� 6���%/0,%� /&� 4(%��(),)00).%3 ���*�&@������������+6AE6>36C ������ E96� +FAC6>6� �@FCE� 6?� 32?4�� 2AA=J:?8� .242� 2=D@� 56=6E65� E96� A6?2=EJ� @7� :>AC:D@?>6?E� 2?5D6?E6?465�E96�5C2H6C�@7�E96�3@F?465�4964<�E@�E96�>2I:>F>�@7�E96�7:?6�2==@H65�3J��(��=8 ��:6�( ��������2?5�4@?4=F565�E92E�ODF49�H@F=5�36DE�D6CG6�E96�6?5D�@7�4C:>:?2=�;FDE:46P

�==�4@FCED�2?5�;F586D�4@?46C?65�D9@F=5�96?467@CE9�E2<6�?@E6�@7�E96�7@C68@:?8�A@=:4J�@7�E96+FAC6>6��@FCE�@?�E96�>2EE6C�@7�E96�:>A@D:E:@?�@7�A6?2=E:6D�7@C�G:@=2E:@?D�@7��(��=8� �,96��@FCE�5>:?:DEC2E@C� D92==� 42FD6� E96� :>>65:2E6�5:DD6>:?2E:@?�@7� E9:D��5>:?:DEC2E:G6��:C4F=2C� E@�2==� 4@FCED2?5�;F586D�4@?46C?65

,9:D��5>:?:DEC2E:G6��:C4F=2C��C676CC65�E@�2?5�2AAC@G65�3J�E96�+FAC6>6��@FCE�6?�32?4��D92==E2<6�67764E FA@?�:ED�:DDF2?46

Page 223: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���

��!�"�'(&�(�*����&�) �&�"#�������1.>A->E� ����

(#�� �$$�"-���+

')����(� � �$�*!�!��,!'&�'�� ��%!&!+,*�,!.�� �!*�-$�*� &'� � � ���� '&� , �(�&�$,1��'*�.!'$�,!'&�'����,�+�(�%��&+���$� ��', �*/!+��#&'/&��+, ���'-&�!&��� ��#�$�/

�=2C:7:42E:@?�92D�366?�D@F89E�3J�4@?46C?65�"F586D�2?5�@E96C�A2CE:6D�C682C5:?8�E96�@A6C2E:@?@7 �$-).)342!4)6%��)2#5,!2� ������ )335%$� /.� ���/6%-"%2����� !?�A2CE:4F=2C�� BF6C:6D�92G6�366?�>256C682C5:?8�E96�2FE9@C:EJ�@7�"F586D�E@�

��!>A@D6�E96�A6?2=EJ�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�7@C�G:@=2E:@?D�@7 �!4!3��!-"!.3!��,'�� 2?5 � !>A@D6� DF3D:5:2CJ� :>AC:D@?>6?E� :?� E96� 6G6?E� E92E� E96� 244FD65� H9@� :D� 7@F?5� 8F:=EJ� @7

G:@=2E:?8� E96� AC@G:D:@?D� @7 ����� �,'�� � :D� F?23=6� E@� A2J� E96� 7:?6� H9:49� 96� :D� D6?E6?465� E@� A2J4@?D:56C:?8� E92E �$-).)342!4)6%��)2#5,!2��/�� ����� 25@AE65� E96� CF=:?8D� :? �$5!2$/� !#!� 6���/524� /&�00%!,3 ��*�&@������������&@G6>36C������� ���+�*�������2?5 �/3!��)-�6���%/0,%�/&�4(%��(),)00).%3��*� &@� �������� ��� +6AE6>36C� ����� 2D� 2� A@=:4J� @7� E96� +FAC6>6� �@FCE� @?� E96� >2EE6C� @7� E96:>A@D:E:@?� @7� A6?2=E:6D� 7@C� G:@=2E:@?D� @7� �(� �=8� �� H:E9@FE� >6?E:@?:?8� H96E96C� DF3D:5:2CJ:>AC:D@?>6?E�4@F=5�36�C6D@CE65�E@�:? 42D6�@7�E96�244FD65�D�:?23:=:EJ�E@�A2J�E96�7:?6

,96� 4=62C� E6?@C� 2?5� :?E6?E:@?� @7 �$-).)342!4)6%� �)2#5,!2� �/�� ����� :D� ?@E� E@� C6>@G6:>AC:D@?>6?E�2D�2?�2=E6C?2E:G6�A6?2=EJ��3FE�E@�=2J�5@H?�2�CF=6�@7�AC676C6?46�:?�E96�2AA=:42E:@?�@7�E96A6?2=E:6D� AC@G:565� 7@C� :? ����� �,'�� � ,96� AFCDF:E� @7� E9:D� AFCA@D6� 4=62C=J� 5@6D� ?@E� 7@C64=@D6� E96A@DD:3:=:EJ�@7�:>AC:D@?>6?E�7@C�G:@=2E:@?D�@7��(��=8� �&6:E96C�5@6D�:E�56762E�E96�=68:D=2E:G6�:?E6?E369:?5�E96�=2H

,9FD� �$-).)342!4)6%��)2#5,!2��/������� 6DE23=:D96D�2�CF=6�@7�AC676C6?46�:?�E96�2AA=:42E:@?�@7E96�A6?2=�AC@G:D:@?D�@7 ������,'�� DF49�E92E�H96C6�E96�4:C4F>DE2?46D�@7�3@E9�E96�@776?D6�2?5�E96@776?56C� 4=62C=J� :?5:42E6� 8@@5� 72:E9� @C� 2� 4=62C� >:DE2<6� @7� 724E� H:E9@FE� E2:?E� @7� ?68=:86?46�� E96:>A@D:E:@?�@7 2�7:?6�2=@?6�D9@F=5�36�4@?D:56C65�2D�E96�>@C6�2AAC@AC:2E6�A6?2=EJ�&665=6DD�E@�D2J��E9656E6C>:?2E:@?�@7�H96E96C�E96�4:C4F>DE2?46D�H2CC2?E�E96�:>A@D:E:@?�@7�2�7:?6�2=@?6�C6DED�D@=6=J�FA@?E96�"F586�+9@F=5�E96�"F586�564:56�E92E�:>AC:D@?>6?E�:D�E96�>@C6�2AAC@AC:2E6�A6?2=EJ� �$-).)342!4)6%�)2#5,!2��/������� @F89E�?@E�36�566>65�2�9:?5C2?46

!E�:D��E96C67@C6��F?56CDE@@5�E92E�

� �$-).)342!4)6%��)2#5,!2������ 5@6D�?@E�C6>@G6�:>AC:D@?>6?E�2D�2?�2=E6C?2E:G6�A6?2=EJ�7@CG:@=2E:@?D�@7 ������,'��

� ,96� "F586D� 4@?46C?65� >2J�� :?� E96� 6I6C4:D6� @7� D@F?5� 5:D4C6E:@?�� 2?5� E2<:?8� :?E@4@?D:56C2E:@?� E96�A64F=:2C� 4:C4F>DE2?46D�@7� 6249� 42D6�� 56E6C>:?6�H96E96C� E96� :>A@D:E:@?�@7� 2� 7:?62=@?6�H@F=5�36DE�D6CG6�E96�:?E6C6DED�@7�;FDE:46�@C�H96E96C�7@C362C:?8�E@�:>A@D6�:>AC:D@?>6?E�H@F=556AC64:2E6�E96�D6C:@FD?6DD�@7�E96�@776?D6��H@C<�G:@=6?46�@?�E96�D@4:2=�@C56C��@C�@E96CH:D6�36�4@?EC2CJE@�E96�:>A6C2E:G6D�@7�;FDE:46�

��+9@F=5�@?=J�2�7:?6�36�:>A@D65�2?5�E96�244FD65�36�F?23=6�E@�A2J�E96�7:?6��E96C6�:D�?@�=682=@3DE24=6�E@�E96�2AA=:42E:@?�@7�E96 �%6)3%$��%.!,��/$% AC@G:D:@?D�@?�DF3D:5:2CJ�:>AC:D@?>6?E

,96�:DDF2?46�@7�E9:D��5>:?:DEC2E:G6��:C4F=2C�H2D�2FE9@C:K65�3J�E96��@FCE��?��2?4�:?��%&@����������+��2E�:ED�D6DD:@?�@7�����63CF2CJ� ���

Page 224: 2012 Bar Reviewer in Criminal Law

���