Upload
others
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Accreditations
3
Image: Shau Lin Hon/Slyworks Photography
Medical
Examiner
Service
Has the statutory duty to determine cause and manner of death
4
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Harris County (HC) remains the third most populous county in the nation, exceeded only by Los Angeles and Cook counties• 4.6+ million estimated HC population in 2018*
• 30,135 HC death certificates filed in 2018**
• 35% (10,577) of HC deaths reported to HCIFS in 2018• 4,554 medicolegal (ML) cases received by HCIFS for examination• 5,653 inquest only cases reported• 370 trauma inquest cases reported• 2,665 scenes attended by Forensic Investigators
4,950 deaths were certified in 2018, including:• 4,554 Harris County ML cases (all brought to HCIFS for examination)• 370 trauma inquests• 26 out-of-county cases
Statistical Summary
* Population estimate for 2018 obtained from the US Census Bureau** Provisional Death Certificate data is from the Texas Department of State Health Services 5
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
86% of ML cases (3,915) received a full autopsy*
• 14% of ML cases (639) received an external examination only
254 decedents unidentified on arrival• 0 decedents remained unidentified at the end of 2018**
257 referrals to Harris County Bereavement Services
228 formal neuropathological consults and 300 unofficial consults***
• 18 child abuse consults
No hospital autopsies retained
Statistical Summary
* Partial autopsies are not performed by the HCIFS.** Excludes skeletal cases and incomplete remains
*** Unofficial consults include gross, photo, and microscopic consults. 6
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Total Caseload (2015 - 2018)
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
4,000
4,500
5,000
Total ML Cases Autopsies Externals
4,644
3,939
705
4,870
4,015
855
4,731
3,923
810
4,554
3,915
639
2015201620172018
7
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Monthly ML Caseload 2018
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450
435380
374348
376384
373376374380
372383December
November
SeptemberAugustJulyJuneMay
October
AprilMarchFebruaryJanuary
Cases Received
per Month
8
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Average Daily Medicolegal Caseload
9
2018
Months with HIGHESTAverage Daily Caseload:
• 2018 January: 14.0 cases• 2017 December: 14.0 cases• 2016 July: 15.2 cases
Months with LOWESTAverage Daily Caseload:
• 2018 April: 11.6 cases• 2017 September: 11.6 cases• 2016 October: 11.8 cases
2017 2016
12.5
cases
13.0
cases13.4
cases
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
41%
34%
11% 10%
4% <1%
Natural: 1,886
Accident: 1,551
Suicide: 512
Homicide: 431
Undetermined: 167
Fetal: 7
N=4,554
Manner of Death – Autopsy and External Examinations
10
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
42%55%
1%<1%<1%
Natural: 270 Accident: 351Suicide: 14 Undetermined: 3Fetal: 1
41%
31%
13%3%
<1%12%
Natural: 1,616 Accident: 1,200Suicide: 498 Undetermined: 164Fetal: 6 Homicide: 431
Manner of Death by Autopsy and External Examinations
N=3,915 N=639
Autopsy Examinations External Examinations
11
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,4001,349
1,140
353 412
114
537411
78 100 58
MaleFemale
N=4,552
Manner of Death by Sex
Sex is unknown in2 fetus cases
12
*Undetermined category composed of cases withUndetermined manner(166) and fetal manner (6)
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
44%
29%
23%
4%
White: 2,002Black: 1,307Hispanic: 1,064Other: 175*
N=4,548
Race/Ethnicity of ML cases
* Other is composed of Native American (3) and Asian (172)
Race/Ethnicity is unknown in 6 cases.
13
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
31%
19%
41%
9%Harris County Population***
25%
23%
44%
8%Houston Population**
Race/Ethnicity Case Demographics Compared to Population
44%
29%
23%4%
HCIFS Decedent Population*
* HCIFS decedent population, N=4,546, excludes unknown race/ethnicity** City of Houston population, N=2,325,502, estimated by U.S. Census Bureau as of July 1, 2018
*** Harris County population, N=4,698,619 estimated by Texas DSHS Center for Health Statistics
White Black Hispanic Other
14
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
725
862
294
62 59
380
600
60
207
60
396351
122 1474850 72
36 14 3
White: 2,002
Black: 1,307
Hispanic: 1,064
Other: 175
ML Cases by Manner and Race/Ethnicity
N=4,548
Excludes 6individuals of
unknown race/ethnicity
15
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
3%3%
25%
46%
23%<1 Year: 1191-17 Years: 16018-39 Years: 1,15540-64 Years: 2,07565+ Years: 1,045
N=4,554
ML Cases by Age
16
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Homicide Cases
Numberof Cases
* About a 5% decrease compared with 2017; a 21% increase compared with 201117
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
458505
429
354400 412
387
480 478 455431*
Year
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018 18
Homicides by Injury Zip
Low High
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018 19
Homicides by Injury Zip/Commissioner Precinct Boundary
Low High
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018 20
Homicides by Injury Zip/Constable Precinct Boundary
Low High
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
78%
7%9% 3% 3%
Firearm: 336 Sharp Trauma: 30Blunt Trauma: 37 Asphyxia/Strangulation: 13Other: 15*
26 cases were linked to at least one other ML case (e.g. double murder, murder suicide, etc.)
At least 47 homicide cases are associated with domestic violence
11 homicide deaths occurred while at work
Cause of Death in Homicide Cases
N=431
Cases with multiple causes of death include blunt-/sharp-force trauma (3)
* Other causes include the use of drugs, thermal injuries, homicidal violence, and drowning21
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
2016 2017 2018
191 202 183
181 158 153
Multiple Firearm Wounds Single Firearm Wound
372 360 336
Homicide Deaths by Firearms
22
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
48%34%
15%3%
Race/Ethnicity
Black: 207 Hispanic:148White: 62 Asian: 14
82%
18%
Sex
Male: 352 Female: 79
Homicide Deaths by Demographics
N=431
23
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
35%
30%
34%1%
Harris County Excluding the City of Houston
Homicide Deaths by Race/Ethnicity – Harris County & City of Houston
N=98
52%35%
9%4%
City of Houston
N=333*Black Hispanic White Asian
* 333 homicide cases were attributed to injury locations within the City of Houston based on the address of the place of injury and law enforcement jurisdiction.
24
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
11%
59%
25%5%
< 18 years: 47
18-39 years: 257
40-64 years: 107
65+ years: 20
Homicide Deaths by Age
N=431
25
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Homicide Deaths of Infants and Toddlers (Aged 0 - 4)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
22
30 2926 27
24
1816
1411
18
Year
26
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
ML Accidental Cases
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
1,800
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
1,620 1,5671,417 1,4241,5121,567
1,464 1,498
1,747 1,6871,551*
Year
27
* About an 8% decrease compared with 2017; a 9% increase compared with 2010
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
24%
26%
47%
3%Race/Ethnicity
Black: 380 Hispanic: 396White: 725 Asian: 50
74%
26%
Sex
Male: 1,140 Female: 411
Demographics of ML Accidental Deaths
N=1,551
28
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
4%
31%
43% 22%
< 18 years: 65
18-39 years: 485
40-64 years: 658
65+ years: 343
ML Accidental Deaths by Age
N=1,551
29
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
30%
40%
16% 4%1% 2% 7%
Motor Vehicle: 466Drug Toxicity: 616Non-MVA Blunt Trauma: 255Drowning: 62Asphyxia: 23Fire/Thermal: 24Other: 105*
Most Common Causes of ML Accidental Deaths
N=1,551
* Other includes firearm injuries, sharp force injuries, hyperthermia, hypothermia, and therapeutic complications.
30
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
53%22%
25%
Driver: 247Passenger or Unknown Position: 101Pedestrian: 118
N=466
MVA fatalities include 30 children aged 2 days to 17 years
4 children were pedestrians, aged 2 years to 13 years of age
20% of driver fatalities (50) were under 25 years of age
25 stranded motorists were hit while stopped
Motor Vehicle Accident (MVA) Death Cases
31
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
81%
19%
Driver Sex Distribution
Male: 201Female: 46
The youngest driver fatality was 15; the oldest 92
77%
23%
Sex Distribution all MVA
Male: 360Female: 106
20%
18%
62%
Proportion of drivers who were teens or senior citizens
16 to 25 years: 5065+ years: 45Other Ages: 152
MVA Sex and Age Distributions
N=247 N=466
N=247
32
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
62 total cases of accidental drowning in 2018
Age range is 19 months to 72 years• Includes 13 children aged 2 to 7 years
• 45 of the drowning cases are males compared to 17 females
Accidental Drowning
33
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
5
10
15
20
25
30 26
1815
3
White Black Hispanic Asian
Race/Ethnicity
0
5
10
15
20
25
30 25
119 8
36
Residential Pool Natural Water*Lake/Pond Community PoolBathtub Other**
Types of Water
N=62 N=62
Accidental Drowning
* Natural Water category includes death locations such as bayou, creek, river, beach and ship channel.** Other category includes death locations such as near a roadway, parking lot or other open area, and ditch. 34
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
ML Suicide Cases
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
455484
442 441 457 441 449486 511 525 512*
Year
* About a 2% decrease compared with 2017; a 16% increase compared with 201135
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Male to female ratio is 4.12 to 1• A record high male to female ratio
Age range is 11 to 91 years
The majority (57%) of suicide cases occur among white individuals
Number of companion Suicide/Homicide cases:• 2015: 15• 2016: 11• 2017: 17• 2018: 14
ML Suicide Case Demographics
36
Image: Shau Lin Hon/Slyworks Photography
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
56%26%
9% 6%3%
Firearm: 290
Hanging: 131
Toxicity: 47
Blunt Force Trauma 29
Other: 15*
Causes of Death in ML Suicides
* Other category contains: Asphyxiation-not due to hanging (3), Sharp Force (7), Thermal (2) and Drowning (3)
N=512
37
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
52%27%
13% 8%
Race/Ethnicity
White: 232 Hispanic:122Black: 60 Asian: 36
80%
20%
Sex
Male: 412 Female: 100
Suicide Deaths by Demographics
N=512
38
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350321
299 279
169134
17
Opiates/Opioids
Cocaine
Ethanol
Benzodiazepines
Amphetamine/Meth
Carisoprodol
N=669
Most Frequent Substances Listed in Cause of Death for ML Cases
This data does not reflect discrete cases
because drugs may be combined within a case.
39
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180173
97
60
23 20 17 16
HeroinFentanyl and AnalogsHydrocodoneOxycodoneMethadoneMorphineCodeine
N=321
Opiates/Opioids Listed in Cause of Death for ML Cases
This data does not reflect discrete cases
because drugs may be combined within a case.
40
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
50
100
150
200
250
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Deaths
Year
Hydrocodone Heroin Fentanyl and Analogs
Hydrocodone, Heroin, and Fentanyl in Cause of Death for ML Cases
41
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
29%
31%
23% 17% 8%
Accident: 65Undetermined: 81Natural: 51Homicide: 46Suicide: 21
N=264
Manner of Death in Children (Aged 0 - 17 Years)
42
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
30%
25%16%
14%9% 6%
Firearm wounds: 36
MVA: 30
Blunt force injury, not MVA: 19
Drowning: 17
Hanging: 11
Asphyxia, not due to hanging: 7
Top Causes of Death in Children (Aged 0 - 17 Years)
N=120
43
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
47%
21%
21%
11%
Accident: 22Natural: 10Homicide:10Undetermined: 5
Injury Deaths Include:• 3 toddlers died in MVA as passengers
• 10 toddlers drowned in accidents
• 10 Homicide cases• 6 males• 4 females
Toddler Deaths (Aged 1 - 4 Years)
N=47
44
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
60%19%
6% 8%7%
Undetermined: 72 Natural: 23Fetal: 7 Accident: 9Homicide: 8
N=119
* “Undetermined (co-sleeping)” are cases with no anatomic findings to indicate a cause of death, toxicological causeof death, or suspicion of foul play but infants were co-sleeping with another individual at the time of their death.These cases would otherwise be classified as Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) but for the possibility ofsmothering. Therefore, the cause of death in this subset of cases was classified as “undetermined (co-sleeping).”
119 infant/fetal death cases (aged less than 1 year)
72 cases of undetermined manner• 39 were classified as undetermined
(co-sleeping)*
The cause of death in 13 of the 23infant deaths with a natural manner was SIDS.
Infant/Fetal Deaths
The birth count for Harris County is estimated to be 71,944 for 2018
(Data provided by Texas Department of State Health Services)
45
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
50
100
150
200
Non-Natural Natural Total
78 78
156
72 70
142
66 69
135201620172018
While at Work Deaths
46
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
30 28 26
14
3
SuicideHomicideAccidentNaturalUndetermined
N=101
* These include deaths in which the circumstances of the death place the decedent in either direct orindirect contact with law enforcement such as incarceration, apprehension, and pursuit. This category ofdeath is not limited to police shootings, arrest-related deaths, apprehension deaths, or in-custody deaths.
Death During Police Intervention*
47
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
1,306
1,040
322 311248
181 124
Hypertensive Cardiovascular Disease
Atherosclerotic Cardiovascular Disease
Diabetes Mellitus
Obesity
Chronic Ethanolism
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
Other forms of cardiac death
Most Frequent Causes of Natural Death
1,886 Natural Deaths in 2018
This data does not reflect discrete cases because diseases may be combined within a case.
48
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
BMI was calculated for 4,121 decedents aged 13 years or older, at least 60” tall who weighed at least 100 pounds:• 1,281 (31%) were obese with a BMI of 30 or greater
• 1,185 (29%) were overweight with a BMI between 25 and 29
• The greatest BMI was 83 (598 lbs./71” tall)
• 27 decedents weighed more than 400 lbs.
• 1,655 (40%) decedents were of normal weight or underweight
Obesity
49
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
For 323 decedents, diabetes mellitus was listed as the primary cause (67) or the contributing cause (256) of death • 72% were either overweight or
obese Body Mass Index (BMI) = 25+
Diabetes
50
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
HCIFS maintains agreements with:• LifeGift
• Lions Eye Bank of Texas at Baylor College of Medicine
• Biograft Transplant Services
337 decedents donated organs and/or tissue in 2018.
Organ & Tissue Donation Summary
4951
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Staffed by three doctoral-level forensic anthropologists, two of whom are certified as Diplomates by the American Board of Forensic Anthropology
2018 case work:• 264 total cases received with written reports
provided• 168 autopsy consultations without written
reports • 24 death scenes with skeletal recovery• 37 cases of remains determined to be non-human
Forensic Anthropology
52
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Staffed by a board-certified, doctoral-level Forensic Entomologist• Reports are peer-reviewed by external
doctoral-level entomologists from three major academic institutions
2018 Casework:• 54 Cases • 27 Scene Collections• 13 Autopsy Collections• 3 Scene and Autopsy Collections
Forensic Entomology
53
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
29
12
58 7
30
7
13
96
35
68 7 6
32
4
12
3 2
Number of Cases
2015201620172018
Forensic Entomology by Manner of Death
54
Quality
Management
Division
Ensures that services provided by the Institute are reliable andof high quality
A separate division of HCIFS
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Maintains a documented quality management system that meets all accreditation and county requirements
Facilitates quality improvements within each division of HCIFS
Monitors the continued use of best practices and ensures the reliability of records released for discovery
Responsibilities
56
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
559 standard operating procedures reviewed
187 proficiency tests administered
401 court orders processed
14 internal audits conducted
110 internal training sessions provided
2018 Accomplishments
57
Image: Shau Lin Hon/Slyworks Photography
Crime
Laboratory
Service
Provides analytical testing services to the HCIFS Medical Examiner Service, the justice system, and law enforcement agencies in Harris and surrounding counties
Image: Shau Lin Hon/Slyworks Photography
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Cases received: 22,537
Cases completed: 22,743
Total Number of submitting agencies: 74
70% of laboratory personnel have a professional certification • American Board of Criminalistics: 53 analysts• American Board of Forensic Toxicology: 16 analysts• Association of Firearm and Tool Mark Examiners: 4
Statistical Summary
59
Crime Laboratory Service:
Analyzes suspected drug evidence seized by law enforcement agencies
Drug Chemistry
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
In accordance with Texas state statutes, identifies confiscated, illegal, and dangerous drugs, including: Plant material Powders, tablets, liquids Drug paraphernalia
The laboratory also develops and implementsmethods to identify new “designer” drugs including: Stimulants known as “Bath Salts” Synthetic cannabinoids such as “Spice” or “K2” NBOMe hallucinogens
Drug Chemistry Laboratory
61
Image: Shau Lin Hon/Slyworks Photography
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
1,500
3,000
4,500
6,000
7,500
9,000
10,500
12,000
13,500
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
7,0547,618
7,7868,800
9,56310,227
8,2347853*7,096
7,6297,567 7,430
8,749
12,596
8,1727298
ReceivedCompleted
Drug Cases Received and Completed
Number of Cases
* Compared to 2017, a 5% decrease in cases received because of changes in law enforcement practices
62
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Positive Test Results
N=14,150
* “Other” relates to a variety of controlled substances not specifically listed as an individual result in the pie chart 63
27%
21%15%
12%11% 7% 6%
1%
Non-Controlled Substances: 3,854Marihuana/THC: 2,923Methamphetamine: 2,067Prescription Drugs: 1,703Cocaine: 1,529Designer Drugs: 977Opioids: 914Other Contolled Substances: 183
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
59%34%
2% 5%Synthetic Marihuana: 578Bath Salts: 331NBOMe: 24Other: 44
Breakdown of Designer Drug Test Results
This data does not reflect discrete cases because drugs may be combined
within a case.
N=977
64
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
155
267 297 279 266331355
776
947
798
407
578
67109 105
36 9 24
Bath Salts (SyntheticCathinones)
K2/Spice (SyntheticCannabinoids)
NBOMe Hallucinogens
Designer Drug Trends
Numberof Test
ResultsThese data do not
reflect discrete cases because drugs may be combined within
a case.
65Year
Crime Laboratory Service:
Analyzes biological fluids and tissues such as blood, semen, muscle, and bone
Forensic Genetics
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Forensic Genetics Laboratory
Conducts DNA testing primarily for: Law enforcement agencies
HCIFS medical examiners and forensic anthropologists assist in positively identifying decedents.
Cases submitted for DNA testing include crimes against persons such as sexual assault, homicide, and robbery, as well as property crimes such as burglary and theft.
Crimes against persons are given first priority for testing.
67
Image: Shau Lin Hon/Slyworks Photography
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
The laboratory paused the collection and analysis of touch DNA property crimes in July 2015 to focus on crimes against persons, which typically require more testing and more complex interpretations.
Increasing DNA testing of crimes against persons decreases the number of cases the lab can complete.
0
1,500
3,000
4,500
6,000
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
4,013
4,8854,324
3,148 2,9652,584*
3,4734,139
2,753
3,8823,019
2,761 Received
Completed/Closed
Cases Received and Completed/Closed
* Compared to 2017, a 13% decrease in cases received (see above) 68
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
18%
27%
37% 12% 6%
Property: 467 Assault/Robbery: 707Sexual Assault: 943 Homicide/Death Investigation: 316Other: 151
Case Submissions by Type
N=2,584
69
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
811952 989
1,071
1,3131,540
1,133
600 664590
507 543 536 558 612 687527
319
336283
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
1,800
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
CODIS hits Offender hits
CODIS Hits
70Drop in CODIS hits reflects a drop in property crimes tested
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Specialized DNA analysts who attend select death scenes to collect DNA and trace evidence from bodies that have been:
Dumped Bound Thought to have been in close
contact with the perpetrator
The team has had a number of successes obtaining DNA different from that of the victim.
DNA information assists investigators in solving crimes.
Trace Evidence DNA Collection Team
71
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
54%24%
16% 6%
Gun shot wound(s): 50Blunt or Sharp: 22Accidental: 15Other*: 5
92 collections in 2018
81% (74) of the Trace DNA Collection Cases
are Homicides
Trace DNA Collection: Homicide Cases by Cause of Death
N=92
72* Other causes include strangulation/asphyxia, homicidal violence, and suicide.
Crime Laboratory Service:
Provides analytical services in medicolegal death investigations, driving while impaired (human performance alcohol and drug testing),
and drug-facilitated sexual assault investigations
Forensic Toxicology
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Analyzes biological evidence submitted by the HCIFS Medical Examiner Service and law enforcement agencies in Harris County for: Death investigations Driving while impaired (DWI) and driving
under the influence (DUI) cases Drug-facilitated sexual assaults Other criminal investigations
HCIFS is the only forensic toxicology laboratory in Texas dually accredited by the ANSI National Accreditation Board and the American Board of Forensic Toxicology.
Forensic Toxicology Laboratory
74Image: Shau Lin Hon/Slyworks Photography
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
1,500
3,000
4,500
6,000
7,500
9,000
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
6,6587,391 8,048 7,848 8,343*
6,5467,104
8,1047,806
8,967*
Year
Received
Completed
Cases Received and Completed
* Compared to 2017, a 6% increase in cases received and a 13% increase in cases completed
Numberof Cases
75
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
80%
12%6% 2%
Alcohol Positive Only*: 2,666Drug Positive Only: 398Alcohol and Drug Positive: 202Negative: 78
N=3,344
DWI Case Results
* Alcohol Positive Only is a case with any ethanol concentration and cannot contain drugs.
76
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
50
100
150
200
250
00.
010.
020.
030.
040.
050.
060.
070.
080.
09 0.1
0.11
0.12
0.13
0.14
0.15
0.16
0.17
0.18
0.19 0.2
0.21
0.22
0.23
0.24
0.25
0.26
0.27
0.28
0.29 0.3
0.31
0.32
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.37
0.38
0.39 0.4
Blood Alcohol Concentration (g/100 mL)
DWI Blood Alcohol Concentrations
7%31%
62%
Less than 0.08 g/100 mL0.08 - 0.15 g/100 mLGreater than 0.15 g/mL
77
Numberof Cases
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
True prevalence may be underrepresented as one case could have multiple drugs from a single drug class, e.g. opiates or benzodiazepines.
Other identified drug classes include: anti-seizure medicines, over-the-counter cough and cold medicines, and anti-depressants.
0%10%20%30%40%50%60% 53%
45%
23% 23% 20%13% 13%
Drug Prevalence in Drug-Tested DWI Cases
N=600Number of
Drug-Tested Cases
78
Crime Laboratory Service:
Physical Evidence
Evaluates fired cartridge casings and bullets recovered from crime scenes and firearms involved in violent, gun-related incidents
Analysis in the three forensic sub-disciplines of Gunshot Residue Analysis, Fire Debris Analysis, and Automotive Paint Analysis
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Conducts examinations of evidence related to investigations of gun-related offenses
Cases received are comprised of weapons, bullets, and cartridge casings
Serves as a regional facility for the National Integrated Ballistics Information Network database
Firearms Identification Laboratory
80
Image: Shau Lin Hon/Slyworks Photography
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
2,4172,501 2,771 2,923
3,334 3,324
2,104
2,490 2,5292,705
2,936 3,038*
Cases Received
Firearms Received
Year
Firearms Identification Casework
Numberof Cases
* Compared to 2017, a 4% increase in firearms received 81
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
82%
8%
7%3%
Pistols: 2,536
Revolvers: 242
Rifles: 205
Shotguns: 108
Firearms Cases Completed
N=3,108*
82
* There are 17 cases with other types of firearms such as air guns, BB guns, and Derringers.
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Provides analytical support to the HCIFS Medical Examiner Service and law enforcement in three areas: Fire Debris Analysis
• Examines evidence from fires to assist investigators in determining the presence of ignitable liquid residues
Gunshot Residue (GSR) Analysis• Assists in determining whether a person
or object has an association with the discharge of a firearm
Automotive Paint Analysis• Supports law enforcement investigation
into injurious failure to stop and render aid (hit-and-run) incidents
Trace Evidence
83
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
329 329
376 361 347 341
7353
85104
77 77
GSRFire Debris
Year
Trace Evidence Casework
Cases Received
Compared to 2017, a 2% decrease in cases received for GSR cases (15 paint analysis cases received during 2018, which was a new case type introduced by Trace Evidence section starting late 2017). 84
20 published articles in peer-reviewed journals
Published Scientific Work
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Authors Title Publication
1 Antinick T.C. and Foran D.R. Intra- and Inter-Element Variability in Mitochondrial
and Nuclear DNA from Fresh and Environmentally Exposed Skeletal Remains.
J Forensic Sci doi: 10.1111/1556-4029.
13843. Epub 2018 June 25.
2 Bakota E.L., Samms WC, Gray T.R., Oleske D.A., Hines M.O.
Case Reports of Fatalities Involving Tianeptine in the United States.
J Anal Toxicol. 2018 Sep 1;42(7):503-509.
doi: 10.1093/jat/bky023.
3 Drake, S.A., Wolf, D.A., Yang, Y., Harper, S., Ross, J., Reynolds, T., and Giardino, E.
A descriptive and geospatial analysis of environmental factors attributing to sudden unexpected infant death.
American Journal of Forensic Medicine and
Pathology (2018) in press. PMID: 30570520
4 Drake, S.A., Pickens, S., Wolf, D.A., and Thimsen, K. Improving medicolegal death investigative gaps of fatal elder abuse.
Journal of Elder Abuse & Neglect (2018)
30:1-10. PMID: 30375941
5
Drake, S.A., Holcomb, J.B., Yang, Y., Thetford, C., Myers, L., Brock, M., Wolf, D.A., Cron, S., Persse, D., McCarthy, J., Kao, L., Todd, S.R., Naik-Mathuria, B.J., Cox, C., Kitagowa, R., Sandberg, G., and Wade, C.E.
Establishing a regional trauma preventable/potentially preventable death rate.
Annals of Surgery (2018) July, 31, 2018.
PMID 30067544
6 Wolf, D.A. Letter to the Editor, in Response to: Laposata M. A new kind of autopsy for 21st-century medicine.
Archives of Pathology (2018) 142(2):158.
PMID 29373851
7 Andronowski JM, Crowder C.M. Bone Area Histomorphometry. Journal of Forensic Sciences. (2018).
DOI: 10.1111/1556-4029.13815
8 Fleischman J.M. Sites of Violence, Sites of Memory: Linking Tuol
Sleng (S-21) and Choeung Ek through Archival and Skeletal Evidence.
Mémoires en jeu (Memories at Stake)
6:76-80.
Publications by HCIFS Doctors and Scientists
86
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Authors Title Publication
9 Fleischman J.M., Prak S, Voeun V, Ros S. Khmer Rouge Regime Massacres: Skeletal Evidence of Violent Trauma in Cambodia.
In: Anderson C, Martin D, editors. Massacres:
Bioarchaeology and Forensic Anthropology
Approaches. Gainesville:
University of Florida Press, 116-135.
10Ambrose CG, Soto Martinez M.E., Bi X, Deaver J, Kuzawa C, Schwartz L, Dawson B, Bachim A, Polak U, Lee B, Crowder C.
Mechanical Properties of Infant Bone. Bone. (2018) 131:151-160.
11 Andranowski JM, Crowder C, Soto Martinez M.E. Recent Advancements in the Analysis of Bone Microstructure: New Dimensions
in Forensic Anthropology. Forensic Sciences Research. (2018) 3(4): 278-293.
12 Love JC, Soto Martinez M.E. Theoretical foundation of child abuse.In: C. Clifford Boyd Jr. and Donna C. Boyd, editors.
Forensic Anthropology: Theoretical Framework and
Scientific Basis. John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
13 Sanford, Michelle. R., Torres, Mirna, and Ross, Jennifer
Unexpected Human Fatality Associated with Bed Bug (Hemiptera: Cimicidae) Heat Treatment. J Forensic Sci. (2018). doi:10.1111/1556-4029.13883
14Blessing M.M., Blackburn P.R., Balcom J.R., Krishnan C., Harrod V.L., Zimmermann M.T., Barr Fritcher E.G., Zysk C.D., Jackson R.A., Nair A.A., Jenkins R.B., Halling K.C., Kipp B.R., Ida C.M.
Novel BRAF alteration in desmoplastic infantile ganglioglioma with response to targeted therapy.
Acta Neuropathol Commun.
2018 Nov 5;6(1):118; PMID: 30396366
15 Lin P.T., Blessing M.M. The characteristics of all-terrain vehicle (ATV)-related deaths: A forensic autopsy data-based study.
Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2018 Oct 11
[Epub ahead of print]; PMID: 30311068
16Carter J.M., Wu Y., Blessing M.M., Folpe A.L., Thorland E.C., Spinner R.J., Jentoft M.E., Wang C., Baheti S., Niu Z., Mauermann M.L., Klein C.J.
Recurrent Genomic Alterations in Soft Tissue Perineuriomas.
Am J Surg Pathol. 2018 Dec;42(12):
1708-1714. PMID: 30303818
Publications by HCIFS Doctors and Scientists
87
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Authors Title Publication
17Zalewski N.L., Rabinstein A.A., Krecke K.N., Brown R.D. Jr, Wijdicks E.F.M., Weinshenker B.G., Kaufmann T.J., Morris J.M., Aksamit A.J., Bartleson J.D., LanzinoG., Blessing M.M., Flanagan E.P.
Characteristics of Spontaneous Spinal Cord Infarction and Proposed Diagnostic Criteria.
JAMA Neurol. 2018 Sep 24. doi:
10.1001/jamaneurol.2018.2734.
[Epub ahead of print] PMID: 30264146
18 Jones A.L., Britton J.W., Blessing M.M., Parisi J.E., Cascino G.D.
Chronic traumatic encephalopathy in an epilepsy surgery cohort: Clinical and pathologic findings.
Neurology. 2018 Feb 6;90(6):e474-e478.
Epub 2018 Jan 10. PMID: 29321231
19 Blessing M.M., Raghunathan A., Erickson L.A. Progressive Multifocal Leukoencephalopathy. Mayo Clin Proc. 2018 Jan;93(1):
123-125. PMID: 29304918
20 Blessing M.M., Lin P.T. Identification of Bodies by Unique Serial Numbers on Implanted Medical Devices.
J Forensic Sci. 2018 May;63(3):740-744.
Epub 2017 Jul 18. PMID: 28718881
Publications by HCIFS Doctors and Scientists
88
Internship and
Fellowship Programs
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
HCIFS prepares students for future careers in forensic science in many different scientific disciplines as well as in technical, professional, and administrative capacities.
16 summer interns and 6 fall interns from the following disciplines were on site in 2018:
Internship Program
90
• Histology• Forensic Anthropology• Forensic Investigations &
Emergency Management• Victim’s Assistance• Systems Support
• Drug Chemistry• Firearms Identification• Forensic Genetics• Forensic Imaging• Forensic Toxicology• Trace Evidence
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Medical Examiner Fellowship Programs
Forensic Pathology Fellowship:A one-year fellowship that is a required training program for all new pathologists seeking Forensic Pathology Board certification
Fellows focus on the data acquisition and documentation processes from medical and non-medical sources with particular emphasis placed on the correlation of scene observations (forensic investigation) with autopsy and forensic toxicological findings
91
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Medical Examiner Fellowship Programs
Forensic Anthropology:A grant-funded, 12-month training program designed to expose an emerging physical anthropologist to the role of the forensic anthropologist in a medical examiner’s office that serves a large urban population.
During the program, the fellow will participate in casework, attend and process death scenes, process unidentified decedents, and conduct a research project.
92
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Crime Laboratory Fellowship Programs
Forensic Toxicology:A two-year fellowship providing training for doctorate-level scientists seeking specialization in forensic toxicology
Upon completion of the program, fellows will be familiar with toxicology laboratory methods and interpretation. Methods include immunoassay screening, sample preparation, liquid and gas chromatography with mass spectrometry, and interpretation of toxicological findings in postmortem, DWI, and drug-facilitated sexual assault cases.
93
Annual Report 2018Annual Report 2018
Crime Laboratory Fellowship Programs
Forensic Genetics:A two-year program designed to train life science doctorates in casework and validation methods
Upon completion of the program, fellows will have been trained in all casework methods in exactly the same manner as a staff analyst would be. These methods include forensic serology, state-of-the-art DNA analysis methods, DNA interpretation, statistical analysis, and expert witness testimony.
94