16
F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September 2007 F. Subba, X. Bonnin 1 , D. Coster 2 and R. Zanino Dipartimento di Energetica, Politecnico di Torino, Italy 1 University of Paris, France 2 IPP Garching, Germany

2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 20071

2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL

ITM Task Force meeting

19-21 September 2007

F. Subba, X. Bonnin1, D. Coster2 and R. Zanino

Dipartimento di Energetica, Politecnico di Torino, Italy1 University of Paris, France

2 IPP Garching, Germany

Page 2: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 20072

Outline

• Motivation

• Strategy for SOL modelling up to FW

• Models

• Mesh

• Near-far SOL coupling

• Application to ASDEX Upgrade

• Conclusions

Page 3: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 20073

Motivation (I)

Source:www.eirene.de

Near SOL: well represented

by edge modelling codes

Far SOL: usually not

included

Traditional approach to edge plasma modelling

Page 4: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 20074

Motivation (II)

Plasma conditions in the far SOL affect

analysis and prediction of ITER ICRH antenna performance

© Copyright Protected by UKAEA, Culham

Science Centre and/or EFDA JET

Limiter plasmas, e.g. First Wall/Limiter

(FTU, IGNITOR, …) and/or divertor start-

up (ITER, …) require FW description

Reasons to focus interest on the far SOL

Source: http://ftu.frascati.enea.it

Page 5: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 20075

Strategy for SOL Modelling up to FW

• Well developed codes (e.g., B2) exist for near-SOL modelling– Finite Volume schemes

– Structured quadrilateral meshes

• The ASPOEL code is being developed at PoliTo, with emphasis on the far SOL [F. Subba, et al., J. Nucl. Mater. (2007)]– Control Volume Finite Element (CVFE) schemes

(conservative)

– Triangular (in principle unstructured) meshes �increased geometrical flexibility

Use different codes for different SOL regions

Page 6: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 20076

Models

• ASPOEL

– Two fluids, single ion species + electrons

– Conserve particles, momentum and energy

– No neutrals

• B2 (as used here)

– Reduced to roughly same plasma model as

ASPOEL

– Neutrals (fluid approximation)

Page 7: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 20077

Mesh (I)

• ASPOEL

• Fills the far SOL (no far PV at present)• ~ 6000 elements

• Triangular

R (m)

Z (m)

• B2

• Fills the near SOL

• ~ 3700 cells

• Quadrilateral

Page 8: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 20078

Mesh (II)

B

ASPOEL nodes

B2 nodes

ASPOEL meshes are

accurately aligned to B and

interpolate the FW

geometry

Nodes are not coincident at

the interface surface �

interpolation is needed

Outer wall

Page 9: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 20079

B2-ASPOEL coupling (I)

• B2 and ASPOEL are coupled through an interface magnetic surface

• A consistent solution is produced via an iterative procedure

• Information sharing:– ASPOEL: use B2 computed

fluxes as boundary condition at the interface

– B2: use ASPOEL computed profiles as boundary condition at the interface

From ASPOEL

n, V, T

From B2

Γn, ΓV, ΓE

Page 10: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 200710

Application: ASDEX Upgrade (I)Near-far SOL interface

Very low

density/vacuum

in the farthest

regions

Page 11: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 200711

Application: ASDEX Upgrade (II)

Density profile @ outer mid-plane

Excellent

agreement with

experimental data

Page 12: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 200712

Application: ASDEX Upgrade (III)

Te profile @ outer mid-plane

Qualitative

agreement in

edge and near

SOL.

Issues (also

diagnostic) in far

SOL?!

Page 13: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 200713

Application: ASDEX Upgrade (IV)

B2 stand-alone

No experimental

data available in

far SOL

Ti profile @ outer mid-plane

Page 14: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 200714

Conclusions• B2-ASPOEL is proposed as a tool for

global SOL modelling up to the first wall

• An iterative procedure provides continuity of fluxes and primary variables

• First application to ASDEX Upgrade shows reasonable agreement with measured profiles

• Perspective: (JET), (ICRH, coupling to TOPICA), ASPOEL/Eirene, ITER

Page 15: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 200715

B2-ASPOEL coupling (II)

Convergence of B2-

ASPOEL interface

fluxes

Under investigation

Page 16: 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOLF. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 2007 1 2D Fluid Modeling of the ASDEX Upgrade Far SOL ITM Task Force meeting 19-21 September

F. Subba and R. Zanino, ITM-TF General Meeting 200716

Application: ASDEX Upgrade (V)Electron mean free path λe

Connection length ≥ 10 m � Far SOL barely collisional at midplane

Outer midplaneCollisionless SOL region