8 October 2009 - BIPM · DSME, Korea – BP, USA [2002] DSME Daewoo Shipbuilding and Marine Engineering (Korea) CIPM MRA Success Story in Korea (1CIPM MRA Success Story in Korea (1-1-1))

8 October 2009

- Success Stories of CIPM MRA in Korea -

Global PartnershipGlobal Partnership

2

3

Activities for the CIPM MRAActivities for the CIPM MRA1

Selected Success StoriesSelected Success Stories

Future PlanFuture Plan4

Better Standards, Better Life ! 2

Joining the CIPM MRA in 1999Joining the CIPM MRA in 1999Joining the CIPM MRA in 1999

KRISS,one of the

signatories to the MRA in Oct 1999


Working out Roadmap toward QMSWorking out Roadmap toward QMSWorking out Roadmap toward QMS

Key Comparisons

and Supplementary Comparisons

Key Comparisons

and Supplementary Comparisons

Establishment of CRM CertificationSystem following

ISO Guide 34 Evaluation of CMC

in each field

Evaluationof

Lab Personnel, Environment, Equipment

ISO 9001 Certification (QMS)

ISO 9001 Certification (QMS)

Peer Review on Technical CapabilitiesPeer Review on Technical Capabilities

Documentationof Measurement, Calibration and Test Procedures

Education on QMS (ISO 9001, ISO/IEC 17025, ISO Guide 34)

Documentationof

Quality Manual, Procedures,

Guides

Expanding QMS covering ALL activities of KRISS for Total QMSExpanding QMS covering ALL activities of KRISS for Total QMS

Establishment of QMS at KRISSEstablishment of QMS at KRISS

1999

2000

2001

2002

2003

Year Quality Management System (QMS)

Keep improving Total QMSKeep improving Total QMS2004


Operating Units for the CIPM MRAOperating Units for the CIPM MRAOperating Units for the CIPM MRA

PresidentPresident

Vice PresidentVice President

Quality ManagerStandards & QM Team

Quality ManagerQuality ManagerStandards & QM TeamStandards & QM Team

Physical Metrology

Labs Labs Labs

TechnicalCommitteeTechnical

Committee

Quality Assurance Committee

Quality Assurance Committee

Committee onUncertainty in Measurement

Committee onUncertainty in Measurement

Quality of Life Industrial Metrology Convergence Technology


CommitteeTechnical

CommitteeTechnical

Committee

Labs


Committee

Better Standards, Better Life !

Carrying out R&D for the CIPM MRACarrying out R&D for the CIPM MRACarrying out R&D for the CIPM MRA

R&D ActivitiesFor

R&D ActivitiesR&D Activities

For For

11-14 projects/ year

(2-3 years/project)

11-14 projects/ year

(2-3 years/project)

EMEMAUV AUV LL MM PRPR QMQM RIRI TT

EstablishingNew NMS

EstablishingNew NMS

ImprovingUncertaintyImproving

UncertaintyExpanding

RangesExpanding

Ranges

TFTF

5


Participating in Key ComparisonsParticipating in Key ComparisonsParticipating in Key Comparisons

( as of July 2009)

GermanyGermanyUKUK

USAUSAFranceFrance

JapanJapanKOREAKOREA

RussiaRussiaItalyItaly

ChinaChinaAustraliaAustralia

509

381 371335 323

276 275228 228 216

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

Serving as Pilot lab for 30 KC’sServing as Pilot lab for 30 KC’s


Expanding, Refining CMC’sExpanding, Refining CMCExpanding, Refining CMC’’ss

(as of September 2009)

Germany UK USA Japan Korea

AUV 76 42 32 8 41EM 326 319 329 32 135L 94 46 49 30 5M 209 81 119 80 47

PR 66 129 126 17 31QM 592 357 975 279 430RI 79 194 540 240 208T 27 19 71 14 9

TF 25 12 9 12 18Total 1 494 1 199 2 250 712 924

* CMC’s to be expanded more than 1 100. * CMC’s to be expanded more than 1 100.


QMS of KRISS: APMP pathway [B]QMS of KRISS: QMS of KRISS: APMP pathway [B]APMP pathway [B]

QMSCertified toISO 9001


Technical Capability

Recognized byPeer Reviews

Technical Capability

Recognized byPeer Reviewscertification: Feb 2001

Renewed Dec 20061st round: 2001-2002

2nd round: 2006-2007


• Initial Certification: Feb 2001 (renewed Dec 2006)

• Certified by KFQKorea Foundation for Quality

• QMS of KRISS Complied with; ISO 9001: 2000 (for QMS)

ISO/IEC 17025: 2005 (for Calibration/Test)ISO Guide 34: 2000 (for Reference Materials)

• Scope of Certification;Research and development activitiesDissemination of Standards: calibration, testing, RMAdministration and technical support activities

• Initial Certification: Feb 2001 (renewed Dec 2006)

• Certified by KFQKorea Foundation for Quality

• QMS of KRISS Complied with; ISO 9001: 2000 (for QMS)

ISO/IEC 17025: 2005 (for Calibration/Test)ISO Guide 34: 2000 (for Reference Materials)

• Scope of Certification;Research and development activitiesDissemination of Standards: calibration, testing, RMAdministration and technical support activities





• Technical capabilities recognized by Peer ReviewsPeer Reviews

1st Round: Sept. 2001 ~ Nov. 2002 covering 13 fields, 41 experts from 15 countries

2nd Round: Sept. 2006 ~ Dec. 2007 covering 13 fields, 23 experts from 10 countries

11stst RoundRound: : Sept. 2001 ~ Nov. 2002Sept. 2001 ~ Nov. 2002 covering covering 13 fields, 41 experts from 15 countries 13 fields, 41 experts from 15 countries

22ndnd RoundRound: : Sept. 2006 ~ Dec. 2007Sept. 2006 ~ Dec. 2007 coveringcovering 13 fields, 23 experts from 10 countries13 fields, 23 experts from 10 countries



Responding to Customers and CircumstancesResponding to Customers and CircumstancesResponding to Customers and Circumstances

1980’s 1990’s 2000’sExpanded Horizon ofNEEDs for

Measurement Standards

Open Markets

WidespreadEnd-users

Traceability in local markets (1979)

Global EquivalencyRequired (1999)

ISO 17025Test/Calibration lab

ISO Guide34RM Producers

ISO 15189Lab Medicine QMS

ISO 22000Food Safety

Evolving Needs of National Measurement Standards

IT Nano/Materials Food/Health/MedicineTraditional core industry Environment

Governmental Customers

Science & TechnologyCommerce, Industry, Energy

S&T, Commerce, Industry, Energy, Education, Health, Environment, Agriculture, Forestry, Fishery,

Security, Climate, Food, Drug, …

Effectively responding to customer’s needs for measurement standards under ever‐evolving circumstancesEffectively responding to customer’s needs for measurement standards under ever‐evolving circumstances


TechnicalAdvice,

Information

TechnicalAdvice,

Information

EverEver--growing Satisfactiongrowing Satisfactionof Customersof Customers

Portfolio for Better Serving CustomersPortfolio for Better Serving Customers

12

Calibration,Test,CRM

Calibration,Test,CRM

ReferenceData

ReferenceData

MeasurementClub

MeasurementClub

Education,Training

Education,Training

Efficient and AdvancedSystem of Services


High quality services stimulating innovation of Industry based on internationally recognized traceability‐ Calibration, testing and technical consulting

‐ Development of CRMs for industry

‐ Training and education on precision measurement

Calibration Testing CRMs Training

18 411 2 377 4 423 631

Services provided by KRISS (2008)

Offering Service for Securing TraceabilityOffering Service for Securing Traceability

13

Field Measurements

Private SectorLaboratories

CalibrationLaboratories

Inte

rnat

iona

l tra

ceab

ility

of

mea

sure

men

t sta

ndar

ds

“Traceability for Innovation towards Competitiveness”

Covering some 3 000 customer organizationsCovering some 3 000 customer organizations


KRISS Measurement ClubsExperts from academia, private companies, government, institutes get togetherHolding on-/off-line meetings for networking;Sharing knowledge and experience of measurement technology.

< Measurement Club Workshop >

25 special interest groupsover 4,000 members.

Operating Measurement ClubsOperating Measurement Clubs

14



2

3





• DSME Offshore Plant

16

DSME, Korea – BP, USA[2002]

DSMEDaewoo Shipbuilding and

Marine Engineering (Korea)

CIPM MRA Success Story in Korea (1-1)CIPM MRA Success Story in Korea (1-1)

BPBritish Petroleum

(USA)

An Order of

Constructing

Offshore Plant

REQUIRING calibration of all

equipment to be used in construction Traceable to

NIST



•US$ 1 million, two monthsfor recalibrating 130 items

at NIST

•US$ 1 million, two monthsfor recalibrating 130 items

at NIST

• US$10 millionfor penalty of two month delay

of project

• US$10 millionfor penalty of two month delay

of project

Likelyquite a bigLoss ofTime!Loss ofMoney!


Technical Barrier

to Trade

Technical Barrier

to Trade



CIPM MRANIST-KRISSCIPM MRANIST-KRISS

ILAC MRAILAC MRA

Accreditation by KOLAS

Accreditation by KOLAS


Calibrationby KRISS

Calibrationby KRISS

BP (USA) accepting

“Traceable to KRISS,Traceable to NIST”

DSME(Korea)

Traceable to KRISS

KOLAS Accreditation of DSME

KRISS CalibrationCertificate for DSME


• Offshore plant order by BP,USA. • Calibration traceable to NIST required.

• DSME, accredited by KOLAS, a member of ILAC MRA.• DSME keeps traceability of its standards traceable to

KRISS.• KRISS and NIST are all signatory to the CIPM MRA. • NIST confirmed that “traceability to KRISS is

equivalent to traceability to NIST” via the CIPM MRA.

• BP accepted accreditation by KOLAS and calibration certificates issued by KRISS.

• recalibration at NIST; US$ 1 million

• penalty of 2 month delay; US$ 10 million

CIPM MRA,ILAC MRA

19

Claim

Solution

Benefit • US$ 11 million saved• US$ 30,000 Invested for calibration

ROI360 times

ROI360 times

< DSME offshore plant >



Coming overtechnical barrier

to trade

Economic benefitsto

global enterprise


• SHI constructing an offshore platform ordered by SEIC, Russia.

• All the measuring instruments installed in the platform required to be traceable to NMS of Russia.

• KRISS and VNIIMS participate in the CIPM MRA.• KRISS and VNIIMS concluded a protocol

recognizing the equivalence of NMS of both countries.

• SEIC approved all the measuring instruments ofSHI traceable to KRISS as traceable to VNIIMS.

• Additional 3 months of delivery & Calibration;

• Possible penalty due to delay of delivery: US$ 16 millionHad it not been for the CIPM MRA…

20

SHI - SEIC, Russia [2003]

Claim

Solution

Benefit • US$ 16 million saved• US$ 150,000 Invested for calibration

ROI107 times

< The dimensions of the platform is approximately95 m x 130 m x 120 m >

• SHI : Samsung Heavy Industry• SEIC : Sakhalin Energy Investment Company

CIPM MRA Success Story in Korea (2)CIPM MRA Success Story in Korea (2)


• Mexican manufacturer of automobile parts demanded the proof of reliability of POSCO steel.

• Indian buyer of POSCO steel required the certification from BIS(Bureau of India Standard).

• POSCO’s testing laboratory had been accredited by KOLAS.

• KOLAS is a member of APLAC and signatory to the ILAC MRA.

• POSCO has a traceability to KRISS participating in the CIPM MRA.

• POSCO’s steel accepted without being retested in India and Mexico.

• Cost in transportation/retesting at Mexican and Indian lab’s

• Cost due to delay in delivery

21

POSCO – India, Mexico [2004]

Claim

Solution

Benefit • US$ 5 million saved• US$ 70 000 Invested for calibration

ROI70 times

< POSCO steel plant >

Had it not been for the CIPM MRA,ILAC MRA, …


• POSCO: Pohang Steel and Iron Company


• According to US Repair Station Act,• US FAA required KA to secure calibration

certificates traceable to NIST.

• KRISS and NIST participate in the CIPM MRA;

• FAA accepted all the KA measuring instruments traceable to KRISS as traceable to NIST.

• Suspending services for 3 months while calibrated at NIST

or

• Additional cost to substitute instruments; and to establish a newsystem with traceability to NIST.

Had it not been for the CIPM MRA…

22

Korean Air - US FAA

Claim

Solution

Benefit• US$ 9.4 million saved

• US$ 40,000 Invested for calibration

ROI235 times

< Korean Air >



QMS of KRISS HonoredQMS of KRISS Honored

Global System Grand Prix Award 2009Global System Grand Prix Award 2009• QMS of KRISS recognized in Korea.• Organized by the New Quality Forum;• Sponsored by The Korea Economic Daily.

• QMS of KRISS recognized in Korea.• Organized by the New Quality Forum;• Sponsored by The Korea Economic Daily.


KRISS, Recognized Center of Excellence in KoreaKRISS, KRISS, Recognized Center of Excellence in KoreaRecognized Center of Excellence in Korea

Annual Performance Evaluation by GovernmentProves KRISS excellence in performance!

KRISS is the ONLY ONE!

Ranked TOP of government-supported Research Institute

For the consecutive 10 years since 1999

Annual Performance Evaluation by GovernmentProves KRISS excellence in performance!

KRISS is the ONLY ONE!

Ranked TOP of government-supported Research Institute

For the consecutive 10 years since 1999

KRISSKRISS


Global Partnership Global Partnership

2

3





Membership to 9 Consultative Committees of CIPM

Membership to CIPM

Chairperson, Secretariat of APMPChair of Technical Committees of APMP (TCPR, TCEM, TCFF, TCTF, TCL,TCRI, TCQM, WGMM)

President of IMEKO

Chair of Technical Committees (TC3, TC5, TC8, TC16)

CIPMCIPM

APMPAPMP

IMEKOIMEKO

26

Global Partnership with Metrology CommunitiesGlobal Partnership with Metrology CommunitiesGlobal Partnership with Metrology Communities

allows KRISS to play a leading role in

solving the global issues of metrology

such as the CIPM MRA.

allows KRISS to play a leading role in

solving the global issues of metrology

such as the CIPM MRA.

Working in close partnership

with global metrology communities

and partner NMIs

Working in close partnership

with global metrology communities

and partner NMIs


AsiaEurope

Africa

OceaniaAmerica

Collaborations with some 40 partners over the world

Global Partnership with NMIs & Institutes abroadGlobal Partnership with NMIs & Institutes abroadGlobal Partnership with NMIs & Institutes abroad


Sharing Experiences with Developing EconomiesSharing Experiences with Sharing Experiences with Developing EconomiesDeveloping Economies

Emphasis on Emphasis on Human

ResourcesDevelopment

Training/Education 51

Technical Advice 26

Calibration 84

Peer Review 14 experts for 7 NMIs

• Partners from different regions‐ Asia: VMI, MASM, KIM‐LIPI, SIRIM, NIMT…‐Mid‐east, Africa: NIS, JNMI, QSAE, COSQC, QCL…‐ South America: SIC

• Partners of International Organizations‐ UNIDO project: Mongolia, Central Asian Region(Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, …)

‐ APEC [IST WG] Project on Materials

QMSEstablish-

ment

ContributionContributionReady toReady to

Participate inParticipate inCIPM MRACIPM MRA

SpreadingSpreadingCIPMCIPMMRAMRA


Statistics of KRISS TodayStatisticsStatistics of KRISS Todayof KRISS Today

Total Area:

500 147 m²4 R&D Divisions4 R&D Divisions

OperatingOperating20 Centers20 Centers

399Permanent staff

230Research Scientist

Ph.D.: 215 (93 %)

399Permanent staff

230Research Scientist

Ph.D.: 215 (93 %)Ph.D.: 215 (93 %)

Budget US$ 90 million

(FY 2009)

Budget US$ 90 million

(FY 2009)

311SCI Papers

(2008)

311SCI Papers

(2008)(2008)

247Patents(2008)

247Patents(2008)(2008)


KRISS Contribution to the National EconomyKRISS Contribution to the National EconomyKRISS Contribution to the National Economy

Direct Value created : US$ 860 mil (for 10 years of 1994-2003), BCR of 1.5(Data : Revenue from calibration/testing and CRM services for 10 years: 1994-2003)

Economic ImpactEconomic Impact : US$ 812 mil, BCR of 12.76 (FY 2003 budget of $ 63.7 mil)

Data prepared/analyzed : Bearing Point, Inc. (Jul. 2004)

-

200

400

600

800

1,000

1,200

1977 1979 1981 1983 1985 1987 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003

총편익 비용 (Unit: million US$)

Balance

120

100

80

60

40

20

• BCR: benefit to cost ratio

Total benefit cost



2

3





NAP: National Agenda ProjectsNAP: National Agenda Projects

Solutions to National/Global

Issues

Solutions to National/Global

Issues

SustainableGreen Growthof Nation/Globe

SustainableGreen Growthof Nation/Globe

32

“National-Global Agenda”“National-Global Agenda”

EnergyEnergyPublic health Climate

changeClimatechange

Nationalsecurity

Public safetyPublic safety

National Research InstitutesSolution Provider

National Research InstitutesSolution Provider

AcademyAcademy IndustryIndustry Foreign institutesForeign institutes

NAP’sNAP’s

Environment

Avianinfluenza Green

ocean

Greenhouse gas

InfluenzaA virus type

H1N1

Renewableenergy

Next-generationInternet network


Measurement technology to estimate national inventory of GG

Measurement technology to estimate national inventory of GG

KRISSLeading Institute

KRISSLeading Institute

※ GG : Greenhouse Gases

Performance enhancement of GG reduction system &

Development of evaluation technology

Performance enhancement of GG reduction system &

Development of evaluation technology

Development of GG tracing &monitoring technology

Development of GG tracing &monitoring technology

Standardization of GG emission amount

Standardization of GG emission amount

Development of Measurement Technology for Solving Climate Change

Enhancing reliability of national total emission inventory of GG,prerequisite to establish the national policy for meeting climatic change

Enhancing reliability of national total emission inventory of GG,prerequisite to establish the national policy for meeting climatic change

NAP: Low Carbon, Green Growth NAP: Low Carbon, Green Growth

33


Absolute calibrationUncertainty ≤ 2 %(PTB, NREL, AIST, etc)

Comparison calibrationUncertainty ≤ 5 %(KIER, KTL, etc)

Comparison calibration(Industries)

Secondary Reference Solar Cell

Primary ReferenceSolar Cell

• Establishment of the radiometric standards relevant to photovoltaic scale (completed)

• Absolute calibration of primary reference solar cell (on going)

• Dissemination of reference solar cells (2010)

Establishing SI Traceability of Solar Cell Conversion Efficiency

SI traceable

(WMO traceable)

※ WMO: World Meteorological Organization

World photovoltaic scalemaintained by

international comparison

Industry Products

Role of KRISS for IndustryRole of KRISS for Industry

Candela (cd)Candela (cd)

Spectralirradiance

Spectralresponsivity

Solarsimulator

Referencesolar cell

NAP: Solar CellNAP: Solar Cell

34


Development of Measurement Technology for Reliability of Wind Turbine

Reliability of WT Blade

• Material• Static & Fatigue Strength• Damage

• Smart sensing• In-service Performance monitoring• Safety Management

• Low-noise WT• Prediction of Noise/Vibration• Wind velocity

Real size blade testing

Reliability ofWind Turbine Blade

Reliability ofWind Turbine Blade

EnvironmentPerformanceEnvironmentPerformance

SystemPerformance

SystemPerformance

Reliability &Performance

of Wind Turbine

• Measurement technique for reliability & performance of wind turbine• Performance evaluation for type certification of WT with less than 1.5 MW

NAP: Wind EnergyNAP: Wind Energy

35


Safety (KRISS)Safety Safety (KRISS)(KRISS)

Development of Technology for Safety in Hydrogen Life Cycle

Storage &transport

Usage

Production

HH22LifeLife--cyclecycle

Remote Sensing of Leakage

Ex- & In-situ Measurementof Hydrogen Damages

PP --ty

pe (+

)ty

pe (+

)NN -

- typ

e (

type

( --))

Line

rLi

ner

H+

H+

ReversebiasPP --

type

(+)

type

(+)

NN -- t

ype

(ty

pe ( --

))Li

ner

Line

r

H+

H+

Reversebias

Active Hydrogen Confinement

Measurements onH2 purity, concentration &

absolute amount

NAP: Hydrogen EnergyNAP: Hydrogen Energy

36


Global LeadingNational Metrology Institute

Global LeadingGlobal LeadingNational Metrology InstituteNational Metrology Institute

VISION(2020)

StrategicGoals (2011)

CoreValues

CustomerValues

Regional Leader in Metrology

Measurement Solution Provider to National Agenda

Pathfinder of TechnologyConvergence

Customer-OrientedService Provider

People &Excellence

Integrity

KRISS Vision 2020KRISS Vision 2020KRISS Vision 2020


Documents

8 October 2009 - BIPM · DSME, Korea – BP, USA [2002] DSME Daewoo Shipbuilding and Marine Engineering (Korea) CIPM MRA Success Story in Korea (1CIPM MRA Success Story in Korea (1-1-1))