16
1396 :&’ () *+ 09 / 06 / 95 :&’ /01 *+ 15 / 12 / 95 :34 84 - 69 ! " 1 * % &’( )* +( 2 % -* ./ 3 89: ;8 < &= >) ? @ A B C D 9E FG &H+ 8 I8AJ K .( B E 1361 - 1362 + 1392 - 1393 DMJ B D NH+ .8O8 B 8 B O PO < B Q) 8+ R KHM POM D 8O8 B SG D .()J IO H 8TD K C ’=A : G’+ J 8 +?H . < US B C 3S HP& S A ) <H A US ? KHM (N .8O8 B C D 9E FG I8AJ B F < VA &H+ W+ 8 )Q+ DM X1 D (N J 8 T NH+ . B D (? ? RO1 8 DM 9 E RC8T + S) SO .8 3S Y 0J? Z KO B [\ B ’=A / D B NH+ .8ASG D3S C +D3S H HZ VA ?+ (+ < A C J 8O U+ . H D ]M 8EGO B B \ 8A: .( DM HND KDZ C VA ? >) @ < U+ D 9E FG &H+ 8 DZ ^HQ B :O > _( S HZ (D K H D ]M ‘ KHAZ B GO S KSG+ F\ B KSG D IJ B D C aO 8 8\ B 8T B U+ D D / aAO B J S0J B GO I8AJ KZ < U+ VA C .( Z ) :B8Z KJbD &H+ W+ 8 )Q+ FG U+ C AJ 9E DZ I8 B * ! "# $ %!&’ & ()* + .-. 1 - 1 ! !&’ 23 %& . %4’ 1 5 567 & [email protected] 2 - !&’ 23 %& . .& %4’ 9"’ [email protected] 3 - ;’ !&’ 23 . %4’ 1 5 567 & [email protected]

95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    11

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

�� ������ ��� � �� ��� ������ ����� ������� ���� 1396

:&�'� ()���� *���+09/06/95

:&�'� /��01 *���+15/12/95

:���3484-69

����� �� ����� ��� ��� ���� �� �� �������� ��� ������ ������

�� ! ��"�1* %&�'( ��)�*� +���(�2 %-��*� ���./�3

�8 9:

�� �� ;8�< ��� �&�=�� �� �>)� �?��@ �A� ��B �C� �� � D ��9��E � �FG &H+ 8 � �� I8AJ�K�� ���� .(�� ��B E��� ���� 1361-

1362 �+1392-1393 �DM��JB ��D� NH+ � .8O8� ��B ���� �8�� ��B ��� O� � PO� < ��B �Q)� 8�+�R KH��M ��POM D 8O8� ��B

���SG�� � D�� � .()�J I��O� �H �� 8T�D�K�� �C� '=A� ���: �� G'+ � ��J�8�+�?H� .�< US� ���B �C� �� �� ���3S�� �

�HP&���S � A � �� �)�<�H ���A��� US� �?� KH��M (�N .8O8� ���B �C� �� � D ��9��E � �FG �� �I8AJB ���F � ���< V��A�

&H+ W �+ 8 )��Q+� �DM� X�1 D (��N� ��J�8���� ��T NH+ � . �� ���B D� �� �( �? ���?� � RO�1 �8� ��DM� ���9 ��E� RC�8T

��+ ��� �� � �S)� �SO .8� ���3S���Y ��0J�?� Z ��� K��OB [\�� ��B '=A� �/�� D ��� �B ��� NH+ � .8ASG��� �D�3S�

�C� ��� +D�3S� �H� �H�Z V��A�� ?�+ (�+ � ��< �A� � ���C ��� J 8O�U+ . ��� ��� ��H� D ]M ��� ����� 8E�G��OB �� ��B

\� �� 8A:�� .(�� ���DM �HND K���D��Z� �C� V��A� ���?�� �>)��@ ��< U+ ��� � D ��9��E � �FG &H+ 8 ��D��Z �^HQ��B

:�O > _(�� �S� � �H�Z (��D��K�� �H� D ]M `��� �� KHAZ� ��B GO��S K�SG �+ �F�\ ��B K�SG�� D �I�J ��B D ���� ���C ���

� �aO � 8�� ����8\�B 8TB U+ D ��� ��� ��D� �� /�� �aA��O ��B ��J��� �S�0JB �GO� I8AJ � K���Z�< U+ � V��A� � �C� � ��

.(�� ���Z ����)

:B8 �Z K�Jb�D&H+ W �+ 8 )��Q+�� ���FG U+ � �C� �� AJ ��9��E��D��Z �I8B

* ��� �� �� �� �� ��������� ��� ����� ����� ������ ��� �! ��� ��"# ���$ ���� %!&�'� & � (�)* ���+� ���� .-.�

1 - '���1!� �!&�'� ��23� %&� � . %�4'���1��5 ��56�7� & [email protected]

2 - �!&�'� ��23� %&� ��.�� .&��� %�4'���� 9"'� [email protected]

3 - �;'���� ����� �!&�'� ��23�� . %�4'���1��5 ��56�7� & [email protected]

Page 2: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

70 ----------------------------------- �� ����� ����� ����� ����� ���� ������� !� ��"#1396

�8'�

<'� ���� ��1= � %&� !��1� 77���� >�11?�� 73�1@1 )1988��"$ �����. D.�� (� .��#�� � ����� & � +�1D ��-5

+� =7� �����. �� � 9F9 .!��� G��= �7H� 9� I�3&�%9 73�1@ � !�< �! &� <'� �J �� 7����1= ?������ �9#

�7H�� ���� ��23�� H��$� &K� %��5 �� L&� M!�N O)P .-.� %9# L�;��IPCC� ��� � �! ?������� ���� !�

�!� %&� .���� %�! �?��Q� � � )��1O . &1-.� � � !�'�� R �� ��;� ����� .9 � �� �S�(F9 'T� ���� ���

������� UV ���� )�$ �� � �!����� ?��Q�� .!��� ��� 9��%9 �!&�'� !�� ����� �� ������ .

RT� WH1�� � -(�5� ������ 73� � $�� ��1@ 9� X'V )#���� �� >� ����� !�11?�� 73�1@ .J1Y Z��� .-.�

���5���� )1383 �� %��[.� �� ('�� � � @ ���� ���) �� ��� ��)#�� ��1�� ���� ���&!�� �1'1� ��� &�

�14��1� �� ��)# � (�&!���� � ��'�� 9 � � !�1@ %9.#Z ���� ��)# & ���&! ���)# �&!� ����� ��� �1Y ��

�. �&9( \� J�X �N�� ]�. 9* � !� $!� &� &�R ���� .-.� #���2 ��!�<� & )2013� (1N �X 9�&!

�N���'� �G�. D.��0,05 °C ��� !� �!� �14��1� � �G�.���� !�2�� .9���� %9 �'�� !�'���3 ��!�<� &

)2013� (1N !N� RT� 9���� ��'�� �"� �� � ����� ��5<'V !�6�� �Z� .-.� %9#��� � ��(� �J ��-.� �

>�11� 73�1@ � !����� %���� a�[�����. .-.�� � !� ���;� � b���� ��# ��� � � -.��� >�11?�� Q�� 61�� ��

@"� ���� ��) �! ?G�2+�� �!&�'�� ����� ! !� c-.� #�Z �.�� � � d.���� �"� � $�� �� �]��. � �

73�1�� �!&�'�� ������ Q��1� >�1� �� 73�1�� �!� L9� ��<7�H ������ �� ��#� .�� � R &e�& !�P �%e ]�)�� �

� � d.���� R.�� >� ��46 � -.�11� >�1� �� 73�1�� �"� !� � � 73�1�� �!&�'�� ����� � ��14��1� ! &�X5

7�H��< ��) �! ?G�2+�� �!&�'�� Q��1� �� �!�Z c

���� �� /D� D ��

c&�- :���A� /D�

����� %��� �� %��[.� �� �S�( � 7�H K�f�7��� �� �.���. ��173� �� �1>� & ��<�"� � �11>� ?��Q� ������

;�. �� �.!�� ��!&�'� YT�� ?G�2+� X5�! & ��<7�H �&! �! ��173� �� g��� h��2� �� !�W�� ��9� .9��

i�� & -.�$ ����2� 91���4 )1978 &1979�� %��[.� -��Q ?��Q� ]9� & ( .��#%��� � � !&J�� � ]�. �� %9#

H�!�� 1361 -1362 )1983-1984H�!� ]�. �� (� 1392-1393 )2014-2015��� .-.� (� H�!� ]�. � � �9��

%��� � � ��1�� � 73�1�� .��#�� �����. ��� g�$ !�'� !&J� � mn. &14��1� � � !�� � $�� �� �� ���d -#��

73� � -#���� &1@ � �14��1� � � 72�� 9)��= .9�9#��� �'1� !� o�+� O��P �� ��173� OP��� �#Z ?���

!� ���� �� �1>� %9# =17+� ���;� ]9� & -.� ��&�[� U��� ��173� OP��� ��!�� ����� 9�6� .9���W� �<���

1 The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) 2 Moradi 3 MansouriDaneshvar 4 Just, Pope

Page 3: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

71 --------------- ----------------------- ��(�) *( +����� �,��� -.( #�/ 0� �# 1/23� 4 -.( 5#�(�/ ....

����� F9 �S�( � �"� !� @173� ?&�[� ��� �-.� ��!&�'� ?G�2+� �� @173� �11>� ?��Q� �����!� ?&�[� �

�! �.�5+� ��;�� p��� !��� 9�� \�q&)1 ���!�<� &2009����� <��� � $�� �� .( r7T� OP��� =� ��S�( �

�! !�'�����!� ��1 ?&�[� � �W� & �"� ��� ��173� �� %��[.� �� �! ��4� �� ��� ����� �� �1>� �� F�* �

��� R#�� @173� � $�� �� �9�� � -.� L�G �Z� .9 � � -(�5� =� �)P !�'� �� X� � ���� mn. & �9��

���4' &e� � -.� �J �4��1� �7V�� ?������ !&�� .��1 ?!�* �� �9$ ��!&J�� ��'� @173� �� OP���

@173� �)P �s��# �9�� %��� ����� �! �H��� ��173� �� =��� �� .9�� �� ?��1�+� ��� ���� t�� � ����

������5�)1391( �� � � ��� %!�#� M&! �� %��[.� �� @ g��$ �� uV�#) ��. �� M&! @ & (� ���� ��

�)P �! ����� @173� (�7��H =17+�) �)P .-.� %��� �9�� ) �;� ��173� �9��1382�)P �� �4�� �<� ( �9�� ��

V��# ��173� ����� M&! �� %��[.� �� �J !� � -.� %9#73�1@ @173� !�"6 � ����� =(��.) t�P�� & ]9��

���$� !���� �(!NV 73�1@ ��5 ��) ��. � � ��v�73� �(1@ N��� ?U�) X'V & L� �( & 73�1@ & L�

=(��.)t�P�����$�( =<#) -.� %9# @15��1 &Error! Reference source not found. .(

�D8N1: �)P ��.� ��173� �9�� ��� �� !�'� �� @15�� � �� !�"6 ��173� �9�� �;� �5( � � �C� I�O K�S�� I�O

��� � �C� ��w.��V ���wS! ��w.��V ��!�w1T� & ]�w+�!�"6 ����"� �LU�� ���)�� �=1��!� ����v ��;���!xJ ��3�# ��;���!xJ&N3 ���;�� �����#��9� ���.�� �9�(����� & ��714"� �%�'����� ���.��� ���

F�\ D I�J � �C� ��.��V ���"[*� ��51. �����. �����$ & �N� ��N��� ������ �@3 �s!�� ���56�7�

]H��� D I�J � �C� �� N�� ���.��V ��"#��

]H��� D �8S�� � �C� ��!9���� ��U1 ���57

��;� :g)��1382

1 Wang

Page 4: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

72 ----------------------------------- �� ����� ����� ����� ����� ���� ������� !� ��"#1396

R9�1 :����� ��173� �(��� - ��;� :g)��1382

%��� �.�.� !� -��&9+� � $�� �� @173� t�T�� �� ����� !� � ��� �� ��S�( � @15�� � ) �w;� �9��1382 (

=<# 9��J�� ��1�� ��� !� .-.� �� ?!�*1 .-.� %9# ��$� �� �9$ !�P � ��173� OP��� �� X� � ����

����� ����� !� ������ �?�9 �'� O)P X5�! & �14��1� �� �! ��173� ���Z��11>� ?��Q� ���N� !�P � � ��

�� %��[.� �?��Q� �.!�� �1�� !� %9# L�;�� ?������ �'1� .�!�9� ��$& 9��� ).�+� �H�!� ?G�2+� ��<7�H

]9� 1)# �� ��1 ! s�.� �� N1� ���9�� & ]�2+� 9#! ��. .-.� %��� ���!�<�! -�� �1�� ��� !� � ���� ����H

� ]�z�?������ ��12� ��U+� &�<6�� )1384( ��<6�� &��12� ��U+� )1387({�� � %��� ��!�<� & =*�

)1388(� J�� ��!�<� & ����)1389(� ��!�<� & ���<H!� )1393( �#��Q� �.!�� � �"�J !� � ��� %! �� @173� �11>�

L9� ]�2+� .-.� %9# V����

]9� ���.� � �6 �717+� �� 1 ��!�<� &)2004(s&��&� & |�N�� �2 )2006(]!�� X� �3 ��!�<� &)2008( �� �

�f�} &4 )2009(���51�G�� �5 ��!�<� &)2011(�� �6 )2012(-5�� �7 ��!�<� &)2013(������ & ]���!�� �8

)2013( ��!�. &9 ��!�<� &)2014( !� ��173� �� �1>� �� ����� �! 91��� @ ����� ��� ����;� ]9� h��2� !� �

�� �W� ����� !� 9�6 � .��1 =�9�� 9�6 �S�( � G&� .-.� %9# o�+�]��!� 10 ��!�<� &)2010( & 971[q �

1 Chen 2 Isik and Devadoss 3 McCarl 4 Yu and Zhao 5 Palanisami 6 Yu 7 Holst 8 Barnwal and Kotani 9 Sarker 10 Gornall

Page 5: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

73 --------------- ----------------------- ��(�) *( +����� �,��� -.( #�/ 0� �# 1/23� 4 -.( 5#�(�/ ....

��&��1 )2015( �5��$ &�2 ��!�<� &)2015( �� ��'� ��173� �9( �� �1>� ��14��1� �� �1>� �� %&UH 9� �

�1Q�� ]�2+� 9#! �� N1��!������ & ��� �!�9��.� F��+�� �� & �1'1� & �1�� ���� �9( �� �1>� �Z� .9�!��

$& ]��(� �� %&UH ���;� ]9� !� � �1>� ��� L��� o�+� ��� .9�5 !�Z �Q� ��<7�H �� N1� M!�� �G�� ��T� ��

�� R �� N1� �! ]9� ����J $!� �� t�T�� ���� 7(�� ��� !� �Z� .9 � �� ����;� ]9� !� � �1>� �����Q @�!�4��

�~.����3 )2012( .-.� %9# %��[.�

g��� ����H L��91��� �i�� & -.�$) -.� ��� =<# � i�� & -.�$1978:(

)1( y = f(X; ) + = f(X; ) + h(X; )β µ β α ε

���! ��� !�y ���<7�Hx ��+1S�� �� �1>� !����f(.)�(��<7�H �14��1� g���) �1�� �N$β� ���!�� g��� �

���<7�Hµ��[* �14��1� �� ��5� �� 9���5�h(.)�(��<7�H m���!�& g���) ����2� �N$α m���!�& g��� �� ���!��

&ε-��Q m���!�& & �[* �14��1� �� ����2� ]UV� �N$2σ�� ��'� g��� ��� .-.� &� �J m���!�& & ��<7�H � 9 �

71.& � � 9�5 �N;� �N$?��11>� �� %��� h1S�� ��173� �� �1>� !� .9��#

i�� & -.�$ ����! ��� �1�T� ����)1979( ����<�&! 7(�� . �7�H ��� @1��� ?����� =3�9( �� 4 )FGLS (

����� � 9���� %��[.� �! � ! �J ?U�9�� �V�� �� ]9� ���� =��� � $�� �� �S�( 7(�� !� .-.� %��� ]�)�� �

g��� �� ��<7�H �1>� -5T�f (X, β) ����H � ?����� =3�9( L&� ���� p��� & %9��� M����ˆ=y-f (X, )µ β

%9# ).�+� � �!�P � .9��µ̂ �� !� ��. ��1�T�µ .-.� �[* �14��1� & ��5� �� m���!�& g���� �� L&� L� !�µ̂

�)��;� !�W�� �� M�h(X, α) %9# ��� .-.� %9# M����h(·) ���V ?!�)H �L�. L� !� .�!�� ����� =<#

R1� ��9;� ��<7�H g��� & %9��� %��[.� (��<7�H �14��1� g���) ]&� ����� ��& ����H � =)3 L� �� %9# ��1�

T� .-.� %9# �!&J��%9��� �1� �β .-.� �!�� �)��;� !�P � & !� ��. ����2� 91��� g���� ���� D���# ��� -+�

�� h1+2� ]&� L� m���!�& ���5� �� M&! ��� �� %��[.� �� g3�& !� s����) ��� 5 ���!�<� &2010L� !� .( ��

�"� K���� �� �1>� o�+� �� %&UH �G�� �&� �� X� � �� �173� �� %9# ����J N1� ]9� !� 9�&! �1>� ��$& ��

.-.�

%9# %�� �1�T� �� ���!�� H��;� �*UV !�P � �β &α �� �1>� �Q� �� ��)�!� !� �! ���HUP� Y1��� �

�� -.9� ]�2+� ��<7�H m���!�& & �14��1� �� ��173� ��4�� ?!�)H � .9 �β L� !� ��<7�H �14��1� ��1.� ! ��

� L�.�� %�� �1�T �� �!&J�� �! ��<7�H �14��1� �� ��173� =���H �Q� & ��# .9��

1 Hatfield and Prueger 2 Johansson 3 Feiveson 4 Feasible Generalized Least Squares (FGLS) 5 Cabas

Page 6: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

74 ----------------------------------- �� ����� ����� ����� ����� ���� ������� !� ��"#1396

]- :V '�+ B�aO �O���

M&! �� �! ��!&�'� �� @173� �11>� ?��Q� �����!� �� %9�H %&� &� � ���� ]9� � & 6!�n<� �����!� ���.]9� � �

7+�=1 fN$ ]���� .��� @15�� �]9� 6!�n<� �����!� ���. ��]9� �H L�7H ��.�! !� Y7v� � -.� ��7H ���.

-.�1. =17+� & �N;� & ��1+� -5�� ]9� .�!�� ���!�� -5�� D1+� �� ]���� =17+� �� ���23� %��5 ��

��� ����HH��;� �� ]9� ��� �� t�6!�6 ��� !� .9�5 � � & ���23� %� 9�� ��� ��� ���<� |�# � d.�� �

� 5��& �U� ��23� !�V�.�X -.� ��23�� ��� ��<���5 >� ?��Q�11?�� 73�1@ @ ��� ��23� =� 9#! ��

�� ��#���� .� >� �11?�� 73�1@ RT� �� � � �5� !�P � ��23� �� ��� 1@ �� v1� �5�1@ #�� !�Z �Q��9� %�4�J

-"$�!����� Q��1?�� >�11?�� 73�1@ �!&�'� ��� �� ���� R�<� �� �1� RT� � � �! �� ��� .!��� ��� 1�N�)1 &

���!�<� 2011(� 9�6 � .�� M&! �N� � ���� ���� � ��)�!�1� 'T�� � �W� !� �!� 19�� & �9��;� ��<�� &

����r �W�� !� ��.� !� @173� ?��11>� �� ���!&�'��!&�'� RT�� �!�� ��$&� ����717+� ����� �?��Q >�11?��

73�1@ ���!&�'� ?G�2+� ��<7�H� ��� R#�� �! o�+� �1�� g3�& !� .9� � )��1O ���!&�'� @173� ?��11>� �� !�

��V b��.N1� @ ���-51� .7�5� �4�� � �� @1W�����1%�) ��� & ]9� �����r & � ?G�����%e ]9� !� � � ����

� -.� �19���� ��� R��� & ��&��� ?!�"�� ��$& �� �Z� & -.� �W� t�6!�6� � $�� �� �9���!93��� ��$& ��

& ��&��� ��1- � &1[1- %��� � � !&J�� � & � %9#�%e �! � !�'�� �.�� ]�( !� �� ��$& ��<���p !���Y %���

�3�& �� !&� � & %9���1- .�!�� ��$& ]9� � � 7+�=1 fN$ ]���� �� �!� ���� %&� &� !�%9��J #Z & �4� $ �4� ��

%9��J %� 9�� ������� .��� 9�� ��<�&! ��� !� .���� 9 ��V a�[�� %9��J !� ��9�&! X� � -.� !��.� ��� ��� �� �4�

]9� �� �� �.!�� I�S�� ��� ]�2+� ��<7�H ���. ��46 ]�2+� ��<7�H ��173� �� ���!�� �11>� �� � ��#

�� .��� 9 ��V �11>� ]9� ���� ���. ! ��� !� � %&� &� � �! ��<�&"]9� ]�2+� 9#! ��� �� ���.2 ]9� �� ��

&� J-(91��� g��� -��1 !) X1������" &"]�2+� � 9����� -��1 !"3 ?��Q� �����!� Y��3 !�N�� ]&� M&! .��� @15��

M�! & =�� ) -.� ��!&�'� ?G�2+� ��<7�H �� @173� ?��11>�4 �2010]9� �M&! ��� !� .( 9#! ���. ]�2+�

1)# ��� �� & ��173� D��&! s�.� �� ���. �� =<# %9# ]��� � �4'����J �� -.� !��3 M&! ��� .��1

R1� �� ��'� =���� m<H ��1+� D���# ?��11>� � -)5� ]�2+� X� !��6 � 9�� ��1� -��1 ! .9 �

) �f�� D.�� ]�2+� � 9�����1992�1�� � 9����� & 9# ����� ( r7T� �� ?�HUP� @51. X�� �� �!

2T'� � $�� �� ����1���>$ �� �����!� ]�2+� 91��� ���� �<�N1��1� �� � 5��& X1���&� � ]9� 9���� & 9��

�'1�) -.� ��1)P @7H D��&!5 ���!�<� &2005 & -.� �<�}����N1���� ���.9��J�� ]9� X� M&! ��� g3�& !� .(

��9�� ]�2+� ��<7�H ��$ �% 1)# �� %9# ��1 �� %��[.� ]�2+� ��<7�H ���. ��5�9��) 9��6 �2000 �� =��

1 Bezabih 2 Crop-Based Models (CBM) 3 Agro-Ecological Zone (AEZ) 4 Hertel and Rosch 5 Fischer 6 Mendelson

Page 7: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

75 --------------- ----------------------- ��(�) *( +����� �,��� -.( #�/ 0� �# 1/23� 4 -.( 5#�(�/ ....

��!�.1 �2012 �18#Z %� 9�� ������� .( ��� ��<�&! ��� !� .-.� #Z R��� & O���( s�.� �� �4�

�� V���� ��9�&! ��� �1Q�� !�QJ �.!�� � mn. & -.� %���� a�[�� #Z !� ��9�&! X� ��# �� ��� !� .��#

s�.� �� ��<�&!?�9 �'� %�"� ���<7�H �� ��173� �� ���!�� �11>� �1Q�� ����1.� ! D��&! �� %��[.� �� #Z -

�� %91;�. ��!&�'� ?G�2+� ��. �� & �1�� KM�!� ��!& ]9� .��# ?G���� ���� %�)1��� ���� � �!��J ��

�� %��[.� %��. -)5� � ���1.� ! ��#]9� ���� ]���� ��N4��$ X� � �� @ ��� �! 9��J�� ��� �� �� 9���

|�� & =���)2 �2010M&! �%9# L�;�� ?������ ���)� �� .( �� �! ��� ��� �� #Z ��<�&! ���� ���� !�2� �4�

X1�<� �"�J �4� ���� � 9# ]9� ��� �� .� . .-.� �!��J �� �� �! � +� ?�1��� !� ���� .� .-��� O1�

]9� ]&� %����� ?��Q� �1�T� ���� ��173� �� �1>� & %���� �1� ���! G���� �"�J !� � 9�5 ����� ��. ��

�� �.!�� ]�2+� ��<7�H h�. �� @173� ?��11>� �!��6) ��#3 �2015]9� .( �! -�N� ��� ����H ����� ��. ��

���� X� ���� %e�& !��! � 9�5 �!�� ����!� �! %9# %��� ]9� I��;� !� .9��1 ���� 9�6� ����� ��. ��

R1� R1� ���� ����H� =��3 !�N�� ��� 9��&9+� ��� ��1� �|�� & =���) 9�5 � 9�!�� ?��11>� ��1�2010 .� .(

M&! L&� ]9� .9�5 ����� �� ���<� ?��11>� ��� �� �� -)5� �"$�� =��3 !�P � ����� �� ]9� � ��

R1� !� ����� ��. �� =�H �"� ��� ��1� M&! 9�6� �(g)�� ��� ) 9��� ���!�<�! M&! 9���� ����� ��

%��"� & |�V -1[1� ���� ��� �1>� FZ( ���V ���� !� (X1��9 ) �11>� ����� !�P � � 9�5 ��� ��

�� ]9� ��� !� �Z� .9��� =��3 �1v =���H ]��� ��<�� � ]9� *UV !�P � .�!�9� ��$& %9 �'� ����� ��

R1� ���"� r1�S & ��� ���� �! ��1� R1� ���� .� .(g)�� ��� ) 9�!�� � 9�!�� ���� �! ��1� ]9� L�. � �� ��

M&! �� ���� & ��� ?��11>� L��� ��� ]9� ��� !� .9�5 =��� �� %��� � �4�9<� �� ���<� & ����� ��. ��

�� Y1��� H��;���� �� ���� &� .9��# � M&! ��� � i�� & -.�$ ����2� 91��� g��� & ��� @1��� ���!�<�! �� 4

)1978 &1979]9� ��� �� ��� @1��� ���!�<�! -��1 ! .9�5 ( X1��9 �� 5 &�!�<�! -��! �!��� &6 � -.�

��� D.�� N�'�� & ��.�7 )2007( %��� ���� M&! FUV �� .-.� %9# �� !�<� @ =��� �� !� �=)3 ��

m���!�& g��� �� 91[� ?�HUP� {��T.� & ).�+� ��<�� �14��1� g��� ?�HUP� �� %&UH ����2� 91��� g��� -��1 !

�� ��'� ?������ .�!�� ��$& ]�2+� (X5�!) �11>� 9� � & �� � ��<7�H �� �"�� � @173� �1Q�� N1� ��<7�H m���!�

�� ���51�G��) �!�Z 8 ���!�<� &2011 ���!�<� ��6 �2004\��6 & �6 �9 �2005 �s&��&� & |�N�� �2006 & (

�� ]�2+� ��<7�H m���!�& <��� � $�� �� �Z� X5�! �������� & -�13 �!�9����� ���<7�H ?���.�� � �;�� 9����

1 sarker 2 Lobell and Burke 3 Chowdhury 4 Just and Pope 5 Hedonic approach 6 Ricardian Rent Theory 7 Deschenes and Greenstone 8 Palanisami 9 Chen and Chang

Page 8: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

76 ----------------------------------- �� ����� ����� ����� ����� ���� ������� !� ��"#1396

�!N� @1�) ��# !���� �� q� & \�1 �2009 �Z� �(�5��� ?��Q� ��� �&� � @173� ?��11>� ?��1Q�� ���� �!�9�� L�4�

�� L9� X5�! & ��<7�H �� @173� �11>� ?��Q� �����!� ���� �S�( R &e� !� �������� .��# �!&J�� ���N� !�P �

.-.� %9# %��[.� ��<�&! �������� �1�� ��� !� ��� 9�5��� ?�9 �'� O)P %9# L�;�� R &e� �1�&� �S�( �

�� !��# � ����� !� .�&! �!&J�� ��� R &e��$!�V D)��� ?������ ���. � -)5� �.���� @�!�4�� �� %��[.� �

)2012-.� ( !�W�� � � ]9� !� ��173� �� �1>� ���"� t�T��-.� %9# �� !�� � � #Z ?������ .

�� ��'� � �14��1� � 9� � �!�15� & ��� �z��9( ���� =3�9( �M!�� F��+�� ���� F��+�� �=� M!�� ��72� ���

;�. ?!�* � @173� �� �1>� t�T�� �1'1� ?������ !� ��� .9�5 �Q�� ]�2+� ��<7�H �� �4�� ��173� ��

.-.� %��� O�+� @1�2� �� & �!�1V������ ��� !� �� %��[.� ���1"� @�!�4�� ��� ;�. �����Q�� � ��173� ��

]9� !� ��9��#� !�P �� !�<� ���.-.� %9#.

S)����B V '�+

7+� �� 9��1= %��� � & � ���� !�� ����J �~.���� @�!�4�� �� %��[.� �� ����5�� �� )2012( � �1>� �����Q�� �

���.��# 9��� -.�$ ����2� 91��� g��� &- ���� YT�� ���) �! ?G�2+� �� X� � i�� ��173� OP���

�9# �!&J�� �� !�"6%��� u1T'� ���� .9 ?�� �� 2� ��!�6 ��1� ���� ����J ��3 ��71� & m���4 �.!�� ���� &

����J �� =��� ]9� �� �1>� ������ ?�1*�2V ���� !�"6 � !� � 9���� ��'� p��� .-.� %9# %��[.� �'1�

��� �! � �1>� L��� ���� 9(�& '�! �[* ��� ��173� �J �� �Z� .-���Z� ���� �� � ����2� 91��� g��� !� ����

�.���� @�!�4�� ���"� p��� .��� %��[.� i�� & -.�$5 ]&9$ !�2 %9�J .-.�

�D8N2: �Q�� t�T��R1� �� �1>� ���� -.�$ g��� ���� �1�-i��

'=A� �� �C� B @ 1 B��� US� <��S� < *

��� � h�.�� -'� �M!�� �=3�9( [3& �9�&! ���� ���91

F�\ D I�J -'���� h�. ���� F��+�� �91��� [3& �M!�� F��+�� �9�&!

]H��� D I�J -'���� h�. ���� F��+�� �a��� & �1T)��� [3& �9�&! �M!

]H��� D �8S�� -'���� h�. �M!�� F��+�� ���� =3�9(9�&! ���� [3& �

* m��� ���!�4� =�9)� I�� �� ��<'V uV�# & 9�&! N;� � �1>� � -.9�5 m���

1�&� �1�T� �� m� ����J �X5�! & ��<7�H g���� � -��& ����H m���!�& ���5� �� �� 6 )1980 & |�� & (

��)5�&7 )1983(�&!� �45)� ��V � p�!9�& � &� 8 )2002u* � 282 -283( �&�� �45)� ��V & � &�

1 Kim and Pang 2 Outliers 3 Interquartile Range (IQR) 4 Lawrence-Hamilton

5 p1<� �� �.���� @�!�4�� ���$� ����"tryem" L�� 9# %��[.� ���.� !�N��. 6 White 7 Cook and Weisberg 8 Wooldridge

Page 9: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

77 --------------- ----------------------- ��(�) *( +����� �,��� -.( #�/ 0� �# 1/23� 4 -.( 5#�(�/ ....

���5�1 )2004( ��'�9���� =��� �'1� !� � %9# �!&J�� �!�9��.� !�1�� �� ��V �� !� �Z� .9�5 �)���� �

Y���S ���"� �!&J��� @<+5� � �!&J�� ��2 N�!��3 )1967���� & (4 )1986( .9# %��[.�

�D8N3i�� & -.�$ g��� Y���S �!&J�� : X'V & L� & ��. OP��� !� L9� ?G�2+� ���� � US� e���f ��DM�

Y���S �!�9��.� F��+�� %!��Jz ]��(�

��� V

��A�

�14��1� g���

-'� h�. 0.599459 0.024933 24.04 0.0000

M!�� 0.038222 0.009792 3.9 0.0000

��� =3�9( 0.195437 0.038738 5.05 0.0000

! 9�& 0.005617 0.000476 11.81 0.0000

91��� [3& 0.150519 0.02696 5.58 0.0000

6� )9��& &�18=(2926,35=]��(� �0,0000 -'� h�. 0.078988 0.000061 1302.47 0.0000

M!�� 0.007904 0.000016 486.75 0.0000

��� =3�9( 0.034692 0.000072 484.59 0.0000

! 9�& 0.000741 0.000001 516.66 0.0000

91��� [3& 0.042249 0.000054 788.23 0.0000

6� )9��& &�18=(5323193=]��(� �0,0000

F�

\ D I�J V

��A�

�14��1� g���

-'� h�. 0.867597 0.076521 11.34 0.0000

��� F��+�� -0.73291 0.140516 -5.22 0.0000

91��� [3& 0.26933 0.047647 5.65 0.0000

M!�� F��+�� -0.08824 0.045892 -1.92 0.0550

9�&! 0.011677 0.002068 5.65 0.0000

6� )9��& &�10=(4038,37=]��(� �0,0000

m���!�& g���

-'� h�. 0.159172 0.002256 70.57 0.0000

��� F��+�� 0.13227 0.004697 28.16 0.0000

91��� [3& 0.050692 0.001433 35.39 0.0000

M!�� F��+�� 0.01804 0.001391 12.97 0.0000

9�&! 0.002226 6.64E-05 33.53 0.0000

6� )9��& &�10=(131569,88=]��(� �0,0000

[3& �� �1>� ���. OP��� !� L9� ��<7�H g��� !� �. M!�� I��;� �-'���� h�. �91��� � �14��1� ���1�

h�. !� �4� 9�&! & ��� =3�9(99 !�P � Y���S ��� �%9# L�;�� ���!�4� =�9)� � $�� �� .9�5 !������ %

R'� @1�5� �� ��'� �! ��173� �� �1>� �� �J �� ���( M!�� �1>� %9# �!&J�� Y��S ]�z� ����H � .9� �

��1��. M!�� I��;� R��N�� 9*!� X� � -.��� OP��� ��� !� �� �! L9� 91��� h�. 9����0,05 R��N�� 9*!�

1 Pesaran 2 Robust 3 Parks 4 Kmenta

Page 10: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

78 ----------------------------------- �� ����� ����� ����� ����� ���� ������� !� ��"#1396

R &e� p��� O���� ;1� ��� .9 � ) ��!�<� & �6 �� 2004) s&��&� & |�N�� �(2006X� & ( ��!�<� & ]!��

)2008 -)z� & !������ ?!x & ��5�� L9� ?G�2+� ��<7�H �� M!�� �Q� � 9��� ;1� �"�J) -.� ( .(9�5

��� & tJ � $�� ����.� �� X� .9�51� !�W�� �� !&� %9�J -.� � p��� ���173� �&� ��� !� �� !��3

R��N�� �H�� N1� ��� =3�9( �14��1� �1>� R��N�� 9*!�0,23 �� ��. OP��� !� L9� ]�2+� �9*!� .���

�� OP��� !� L9� 91��� X5�! g��� %9# �!&J�� Y���S ��1� � .�!�� -��<( ��173� �� �1>� ���� %9��JN� X5�!

91��� m���!�& �� � �1>� ��� ���Z��11>� �Q� ��� �-.� -)z� ��<7�H g��� �� ��173� �� �1>� �Q� 9�6� ��4��

.-.� -)z� ��. OP��� !� L9�

�D8N4 L� OP��� !� L9� ?G�2+� ���� i�� & -.�$ g��� Y���S �!&J�� :t�P�� & ]9�� & t�P�� &

]H��� D I�J V

��A�

� US� e���f ��DM�

Y���S �!�9��.� F��+�� %!��Jz ]��(�

�14��1� g���

1

-'���� h�. 0.940737 0.075422 12.47 0.0000

��� F��+�� -0.14801 0.094465 -1.57 0.1170

a��� & �1T)� 0.252037 0.148751 1.69 0.0900

M!�� [3& 0.198353 0.07862 2.52 0.0120

9�&! 0.026241 0.003851 6.81 0.0000

6� )9��& &�7=(3841,63=]��(� �0,0000

m���!�& g���

1

-'���� h�. 0.226278 0.003485 64.93 0.0000

��� F��+�� 0.0289 0.006452 4.48 0.0000

a��� & �1T)� 0.039178 0.008882 4.41 0.0000

M!�� [3& -0.0332 0.00592 -5.61 0.0000

9�&! 0.003197 0.000285 11.22 0.0000

6� )9��& &�7=(28184,05=]��(� �0,0000

]H��� D �

8S��

�14��1� g���

1

-'� h�. 1.049426 0.036852 28.48 0.0000

M!�� F��+�� 0.146092 0.195741 0.75 0.4550

��� =3�9( 0.153133 0.104981 1.46 0.1450

��� [3& -0.50084 0.733894 -0.68 0.4950

9�&! 0.005527 0.004147 1.33 0.1830

6� )9��& &�7=(7405,79=]��(� �0,0000

m���!�& g���

1

-'� h�. 0.284203 0.006339 44.84 0.0000

M!�� F��+�� 0.022349 0.036726 0.61 0.5430

( ��� =3�9 0.080431 0.021861 3.68 0.0000

��� [3& -0.17978 0.154357 -1.16 0.2440

9�&! -0.00251 0.000841 -2.99 0.0030

6� )9��& &�7=(11993,17=]��(� �0,0000

Page 11: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

79 --------------- ----------------------- ��(�) *( +����� �,��� -.( #�/ 0� �# 1/23� 4 -.( 5#�(�/ ....

�� ��'� i�� & -.�$ g��� �14��1� �N$ Y���S �!&J�� 72� ���� �!�9��.� F��+�� R��N�� �� � 9 � M!�� & �

�� R �� X'V & L� OP��� !� ��J L9� 91��� h�. ���1��. ��� �� s�13 =��3 p��� ��� .9��� X� �� & ]!��

) ��!�<� 2008��V & \��� & (�1 )2010( L��� ��<7�H �� �[�� �Q� ���Z��11>� R��N�� 9���� ��'� � -.�

��1��. -)z� �1Q�� ����� 9�&! Y��S .-.� #�� �"�J �.!�� �!�� ?G�2+� �� ��'� �! �9*!� X� � � .9 �

M!�� & �72� �� ��� �!�9��.� F��+�� R��N�� �!�W�� O���� %&UH � %9��JN� X5�! �7��H ��1��. �� L9� 91��� !

%9# V��# ��J .9��

��� ?����+�� R��N�� .-.� !�W�� O���� N1� t�P�� & L� OP��� !� ��J L9� i�� & -.�$ g��� �!&J�� ��

��� ]��(� � ����� �� ���90 � ���( !� .-.� #�Z ��J L9� 91��� h�. �14��1� �� �9H�5��� �Q� %

� 9�!�� 9H�5��� �Q� � �� ���)$ U��� �! ����� ?����+�� R��N�� R��N�� <��� ��$& �� ��T. �4�� � .9���

�&9( �9*!� X� ��N1� � ����� ?����+��0,15 R �� t�P�� & L� OP��� !� �! ��J L9� ��<7�H 9*!�

�� � M!�� R��N�� �Q� ��� 9� �]��(� ��3 !�15�0,2 ��N�� �! ]�2+� ��� ��<7�H 9*!��� R �1�� ��� !� .9 �

�������1�2 )2013�� ;1� ( ��!&�'� ?G�2+� X5�! & ��<7�H �� ���� & tJ ���Z��11>� R��N�� �Q� � ��1

) ��!�<� & s���� .9�5 �fN$ !�15� �N��� ��1.J !�2010 �� ��<7�H g���� <��� ��$& �� � 9�9��� N1� (

�� R��N�� ��G�� �� ��� �� 9���M!�� �� �J �Q� � �� ���)$ 1�&� �� i�� & -.�$ g��� 9�&! �1>� �%&UH � .��#

�� ��'� OP��� ��� !� ��J L9� ��N1� � ��. � ���"� & �<�}����<� ?��Q� � 9 �0,03 ��� 91��� 9*!�

) ��!�<� & s���� ����� !� .-.� %��� R��N�� �! ]�2+�2010�H � 9�&! �1>� N1� ( =��H ����"� ���

]���� ��Q� � -.� %9# M!�N ���5�� L9� ��<7�H �� !�Z �1Q�� ��173��1v1 !� �! ��<7�H !� �G�. R��N�� %

-.�$ g��� ����2� �N$ �.!�� .�!�� �� -�� ��'� ]�2+� ��� i�� N;� OP��� ��� !� � 9 �[3& � � M!��

;�. ���. �-.� %9� �� X5�! �7��H �� R��N�� �� & 9�5 %9��JN� X5�! ��1��. a��� & �1T)� & ��� F��+��

�� R��N�� N1� ��J L9� ��<7�H m���!�& �"�J .9���

;�. ?��11>� �Q� & ]9�� OP��� !� ��J L9� 91��� �14��1� �� ��173� �� t�P�� ��$& ��� �� .-51� !������

�� �72� ���� =3�9(X5�! ��J L9� 91��� =3�9( R��N�� 9*!� X� .-.� %9# M!�N -)z� OP��� ��� !�

��72� �14��1� ����0,08 g��� !� 9�&! �1>� � �J ��$& �� �1��� .-.� %��� R��N�� �! 91��� m���!�& 9*!�

��� ��'� �!������ �Q� �14��1� 9 �� !�15� 91��� �� �J �Q� 9�6� ) -.� %9� �� 91��� X5�! �� �J �Q� ��� r1�S

.(-.�

1 Huang and Khanna 2 Mirzabaev

Page 12: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

80 ----------------------------------- �� ����� ����� ����� ����� ���� ������� !� ��"#1396

�SO�Y g� D

� -.� b��� ]��. ��� �!&J�� �� �7� -#����� g�� ����2� 91���i�� & -.�$ ���� !�"6 ���� !�'� ��173� �

c-516 ��173� �� �1>� ?��11>� u��V �Q� � ��� %!�#� 9��� d.�� !� ��<7�H �&!�L9� ��� ?&�[� 9�6�

��"� �� %��[.� .-.� !������% ��<7�H m���!�& R��N�� N1� -'���� h�. R��N�� ���� ��173��1v �� ]�)�� � �!

-.� #�� ��� �� !� ��. � R &e� �� -.� �7)3 �� ������!N1� ���!�<� & s����)2013.( & �6 ?������ !�

) ��!�<� 2004) s&��&� & |�N�� �(2006X� �( ) ��!�<� & ]!��2008�� �( & s��) ��!�<�2010�������1� �(

)2013) ������ & ]��� & (2013 %9# �.!�� ��!&�'� ?G�2+� X5�! & ��<7�H �� ��173� �� �1>� �Q� N1� (

R &e� ��� �� X� � 9�6 � .-.� %9# L�;�� ?&�[� U��� ��173� D���# !� � ��� I��;� !� ��� �9�� ��� ��

R &e� �� 91��� N1� � � 9��� uV�# Y7v� �Q� !� ]�z� ����H � .-.� %��� !������ 91��� h�. �� ��173� ��

����� ) ��!�<� & �6 �2004-���� ���5�� L9� 91��� �� �72� ���� �14��1� & ��1��. M!�� I��;� �( ��

h�. !� �<����95) s&��&� & |�N�� .9�5 !������ %2006O��P �� p��� ��� 91��� �� ( %��� �.!�� �� 62 ]�.

�"� �� �9H�5��� �1Q�� &� � ��� & M!�� � 9�91.! ;1� ��9� �<���� %9+� ?G��� �� �9�J -���� ��173� ��

L9� ]�2+� ��<7�H�!����� 9�6� . �Q� ����� !Z !� 91��� X5�! R��N�� ��$& �� � ��� ��'� �"�J ��

�! �� M!�� & ��� ���Z��11>������ p��� .9�51� !������ ]�2+� X5 ) ��!�<� & s���� �2010 t��$ !� (

%9�H �Q� ��173� �� �1>� � -.� %��� ��'� N1� ?!x & ���5�� L9� ]�2+� ���� ������ ���!��J ���v �� ��

����� !� 9�&! �1>� .9�!�� ?G�2+� ��� 91��� X5�! R��N�� & ��<7�H �14��1� �S�( � !� �)���� !�"6 � !�

������ ��� ��'� p��� ��� .-.� #�� L9� 91��� �� -)z� ��1Q�� & !������ X� �� ��!�<� & ]!��)2008( �

��V & \��� )2010(X� & ���5�& � ]!��1 )2011( �������1� & )2013 !�P � .-.� (��7� �1>� �! 9�&!����H �

-��'1� �}����<�2 ���"� ?��Q� �� &3 �� �15[� 9����� ��'� p��� �1S�� ��� M��Z� ?!�* !� . ���� � 9� �

����� 7�$ ��) 91��� �}����<� !� ��� ?��11>� ��.!�� -+� ?G�2+�@3! �� -1���� & 9�9$ & �;�&�� ��

��)"� �! ?G�2+� ��<7�H �(����9��� 9'T� �� & .9�� ���)$ �! @173� ?��11>� 9H�5��� ?��Q� ��&9( �� 9����

� SO B� J

������ ��� !��1Q�� @"� ;�. ���� .9��� �.!�� !�'� L9� X5�! & 91��� �� ��173� �� ��� �I��;� !� �

uV�# � 9���� ��'� M!�� & ��� �� � �1�� & !�P � �?&�[� ��173� D���# � $�� �� !�'� L9� -'� ��� ��

;�. ��� �1Q�� -+� ��&�[� �� !��3 ��173� �� X5�! & ��<7�H �� ���Z��11>� R��N�� ?��Q� ���� N16�� .9��1

�� �! ��173� OP��� �V�� !� L9� �6 G��(� ����-1���� ��� �� �"$�� =��3 RT� ?�91��� � ��� 1$�� �1 �

1 Witsanu, and McCarl 2 Technological progress 3 Institutional effect

Page 13: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

81 --------------- ----------------------- ��(�) *( +����� �,��� -.( #�/ 0� �# 1/23� 4 -.( 5#�(�/ ....

%9�� ��9�6 � ���� & tJ D���# !� �� ?!�* ]J �"� �'1� .��1 � ��� & tJ ���� !� ����� @ ������ �

��5��� �� & X'V -)5� ��5�� & L� �� ?��11>� & ��1��. �9( �� ��� �� ��9V! & �!�� !��3 ��. ��

��]�. ]�P !� M!�� @W�� o�+� �� .-.� %��� @ ��� �����# �1�6 �� �! ���!&�'� �)5� �!� ��. #Z ��

?��11>���1��. � %��� &��&! t�7���� D���# �� ���!&�'� �'1� ����� & tJ�� �Z� .9�� � ��� -#���� �1�6 ����

�6 !� � ����!&�'�1 D���# �s�.��� �� -1���� ��1+� �9��� �� �11>� �� "$��� !� �! ��'1� ��;� 9�����

@173� � .9�#�� #�� N1� ��J�4�� ?!�)H@W���� & �1>� D1+� �� ����(� ��&!��&! � ����� �!� ��. O��P �� ���

-1���� .-#�� 9 ��V 4� %9�� ����� �! @173� �11>� 9H�5��� =�+� ?��Q� �� "$��� 91�� ���!&�'� �� ��� ��

;1� !� ����� ?U� <��� � �W� ���$& � Y�$ !�'��� 9����� !���.�%!�( ��1%�5 � �� ����� �(���� & X'V

�1� X'V����!� �! � $�� �� & -.� !������ U��� !�'� ��173� OP��� L��� �� @173� �11>� �Q� ���1 X5�!

��1)P ?��P�T� ��9# !� ��. ���!&�'� >� ��@173� �11 9����1�����. & -���( �!�Z �� �Z� .-.� �'1� ��

����. �9H�5��� ?��Q� R �� & %����� -)z� ?��Q� R��N�� � � �4� �'1� �!�Z 1$�� �1�� ��� !� ��!�� ���23�

7�$ �� ����. ��� � �!�Z �� � �����+� 9���9 -��9 & �<'V � L&��� L�3!� �.�� � & ��!&�'� ?��1

-1���� ��������1�) ��� %!�#� �;�&�� �� 2013.( %��9�� & -�UH � $�� �� �%&UH � �!&J�� 9�&! �1>� Y���S �

%9# ��!�<� & �6 ?������ p��� O)P) �<���� %9+� ?G��� ��6 ��� !�'� �� 5���� !� �)2004( & |�N�� �

s&��&�)2006(X� � ��!�<� & ]!��)2008( �&�!�� &2 )2010(s���� ����� p��� O)P) ������ �( )2010(( �

����� p��� O)P) �N��� ��1.J �������1� �)2013(��� O)P) �16 & ( ��!�<� & -5�� �� )2013( (

����. .-.� ����� �1�� ��� !� �'1� �!�Z

�9�+ D ��8'+

�� 71.& ��9������ �! +� ��� & ��3�� �S�17H ��� ����3JV�# R;�. !� !�'��� �!�2�� �S!9�u ��

��� =17+� & ��173� �� ����!93 R &e� �� .���

W �A� ������JL��"�� !��1� ����". ��� �� �����1�� 91(& ��e� ��!&�S!� ) !�1T� �����1389 X5�! =17+� & L9� ��<7�H �� @173� �11>� �Q� .(

(��!&�'� R���) |�V & tJ R��� �(��"[*� -#��&! ���� :��!�� �����) �J �� �#��%!��# �3� u* 135–150.

1 �� ]&N�� #�� L� � �� ���� Y). !�'��� 9������ ��� ����.J !� � ��#� <'�1= �� & %9'�� ���*��� +�.�� ��� ?!93� ���� � x�[�G �� � G���� & �$

.!1�9 >� b��. �11� 9#�� #�9� tJ !�T� ��� !)�9��� ���!�<� &1392( . 2 Cordova

Page 14: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

82 ----------------------------------- �� ����� ����� ����� ����� ���� ������� !� ��"#1396

�9���! ��1�� ���!�1� �91;� �"�9�+� �1�� )1392���P !�'�� & =1<'� �.!�� .(� t��$ & t�v � ��&!& |�V & �� �� ����� t�v

?�!x �e��� G RT� ]9� �� %��[.� �� HYSPLIT .R &e� ��.��# @173� �� %!��#13� u* 1–16.

��<H!�� �P��� ����� 7��Uv�� 61!Z� ��15(�1� )1393 .(����# ��.��V ��!�� �����) @�� L9� ��23� �� @173� �11>� �Q� .(

L�� �#���!&�'� �.� %!��#2� u* 301–310.

{�� %��� � =*���"6�� �<#�� ��S���9)H ����# M&�1. )1388 ��173� ?��11>� ��<�&! �� @�� L9� ]�2+� ��<7�H ���Z��11>� =17+� .(

����� .(��S! ��.��V ��.� :����� �!�� ����) �(���5�� L�7H s!9�) ��� R���J & �N�! %!��# 3� u* 227–256

�<6�� ��S�17H ��12� ��U+� ��9" )1387Q�� .(1� >�11� 73�1@ N�� �� %��� ��R -W7vCO2 � !� L9� ��<7�H ������ �!� &����

� !�< �!� !� ��.�� R &e� 7;� ������ �H�!� �� %!��#1� u* 139–153.

��12� ��U+� ���9" �<6�� �S�17H )1384uV�# �� @173� �11>� �Q� .( � �� .����� !� @�� L9� -'� OP��� X1���17�&�

R &e� ����� �H�!� �� � %!��#3� u* 291–303.

;� � ) �5(9�+�1382(. 5��1?�� 73�1�� ������ �7H ����� 7� N���� 73�1@�.��#� u* �]&� %!��# �L�. 97$41 .

������5� =�[����� 91.)1391����� ��� & tJ .(� � �]&� R����&�# :��"[*s�� ��. Barnwal, P., & Kotani, K. (2013). Climatic impacts across agricultural crop yield distributions: An application of quantile regression on rice crops in Andhra Pradesh, India. Ecological Economics, 87, 95–109. doi:10.1016/j.ecolecon.2012.11.024 Bezabih, M., Chambwera, M., & Stage, J. (2011). Climate change and total factor productivity in the Tanzanian economy. Climate Policy, 11(6), 1289-1302. Cabas, J., Weersink, A., & Olale, E. (2010a). Crop yield response to economic, site and climatic variables. Climatic Change, 101(3-4), 599–616. doi:10.1007/s10584-009-9754-4 Cabas, J., Weersink, A., & Olale, E. (2010b). Crop yield response to economic, site and climatic variables. Climatic Change, 101(3-4), 599–616. Chen, C. C., McCarl, B. a., & Schimmelpfennig, D. E. (2004). Yield variability as influenced by climate: A statistical investigation. Climatic Change, 66(1/2), 239–261. doi:10.1023/B:CLIM.0000043159.33816.e5. Chen, C. C., & Chang, C. C. (2005). The impact of weather on crop yield distribution in Taiwan: some new evidence from panel data models and implications for crop insurance. Agricultural economics, 33(s3), 503-511. Chowdhury, I. U. A., & Khan, M. A. E. (2015). The impact of climate change on rice yield in Bangladesh: a time series analysis. Russian Journal of Agricultural and Socio-Economic Sciences, 40(4). Cook, R. D., & Weisberg, S. (1983). Diagnostics for heteroscedasticity in regression. Biometrika, 70(1), 1–10. Cordova, X. (2010). Essays on the effect of climate change on agriculture and forestry. Texas A&M University. Deschenes, O., Greenstone, M., & No, R. (2007). The Economic Impacts of Climate Change: Evidence from Agricultural Profits and Random Fluctuations of Weather. The American Economic Review, 97(1), 354–385. doi:10.2139/ssrn.876929 Efroymson, M. A. (1960). Multiple regression analysis. Mathematical methods for digital computers (Vol. 1). Wiley: New York. Feiveson, A. (2012). TRYEM: Stata module to run all possible subset regressions. Statistical Software Components. Fischer, G., Shah, M., Tubiello, F. N., & Van Velhuizen, H. (2005). Socio-economic and climate change impacts on agriculture: an integrated assessment, 1990–2080. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 360(1463), 2067-2083. Gornall, J., Betts, R., Burke, E., Clark, R., Camp, J., Willett, K., & Wiltshire, A. (2010). Implications of climate change for agricultural productivity in the early twenty-first century. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences, 365(1554), 2973–2989. Hatfield, J. L., & Prueger, J. H. (2015). Temperature extremes: Effect on plant growth and development. Weather and Climate Extremes, 10, Part A, 4–10. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.wace.2015.08.001 Hertel, T. W., & Rosch, S. D. (2010). Climate change, agriculture, and poverty. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 32(3), 355-385. Holst, R., Yu, X., & Grün, C. (2013). Climate Change, Risk and Grain Yields in China. Journal of Integrative Agriculture, 12(7), 1279–1291. doi:10.1016/S2095-3119(13)60435-9 Huang, H., & Khanna, M. (2010). An econometric analysis of US crop yield and cropland acreage: implications for the impact of climate change. Selected Paper Prepared for Presentation at the Agricultural & Applied Economics Association, 25–27. Isik, M., & Devadoss, S. (2006). An analysis of the impact of climate change on crop yields and yield variability. Applied Economics, 38(7), 835–844. doi:10.1080/00036840500193682

Page 15: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

83 --------------- ----------------------- ��(�) *( +����� �,��� -.( #�/ 0� �# 1/23� 4 -.( 5#�(�/ ....

Johansson, R., Luebehusen, E., Morris, B., Shannon, H., & Meyer, S. (2015). Monitoring the impacts of weather and climate extremes on global agricultural production. Weather and Climate Extremes, 10, Part A, 65–71. doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.wace.2015.11.003 Just, R. E., & Pope, R. D. (1978). Stochastic Specification of Production Functions and Economic implications. Journal of Econometrics, 7(488), 67–86. doi:10.1016/0304-4076(78)90006-4 Just, R. E., & Pope, R. D. (1979). Production function estimation and related risk considerations. doi:10.2307/1239732 Kang, Y., Khan, S., & Ma, X. (2009). Climate change impacts on crop yield, crop water productivity and food security–A review. Progress in Natural Science, 19(12), 1665–1674. Kim, M. K., & Pang, A. (2009). Climate change impact on rice yield and production risk. Journal of Rural Development, 32(2), 17-29. Kmenta, J. (1986). Elements of econometrics. New York: Macmillan New York. Lobell, D. B., & Burke, M. B. (2010). On the use of statistical models to predict crop yield responses to climate change. Agricultural and Forest Meteorology, 150(11), 1443–1452. doi:10.1016/j.agrformet.2010.07.008. MansouriDaneshvar, M.R., Bagherzadeh, A., Khosravi, M. (2013). Assessment of drought hazard impact on wheat cultivation using standardized precipitation index in Iran. Arab. J. Geosci. 6, 4463–4473. doi:10.1007/s12517-012-0695-2. McCarl, B. A., Villavicencio, X., & Wu, X. (2008). Climate Change and Future Analysis: Is Stationarity Dying? American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 90(5), 1241–1247. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8276.2008.01211.x Moradi, A. M., Akhtarkavan, M., Ghiasvand, J., & Akhtarkavan, H. (2008). Assessment of Direct Adverse Impacts of Climate Change on Iran. earth, 11, 16. Mirzabaev, A. (2013). Climate volatility and change in Central Asia: Economic impacts and adaptation. Universitäts-und Landesbibliothek Bonn. Palanisami, K., Ranganathan, C. R., Kakumanu, K. R., & Nagothu, U. S. (2011). A Hybrid Model to Quantify the Impact of Climate Change on Agriculture in Godavari Basin, India. Energy and Environment Research, 1(1), 32. Parks, R. W. (1967). Efficient estimation of a system of regression equations when disturbances are both serially and contemporaneously correlated. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 62(318), 500-509. Pesaran, M. H. (2004). General diagnostic tests for cross section dependence in panels (No. No. 0435). CESifo working paper series. Sarker, M. A. R., Alam, K., & Gow, J. (2014). Assessing the effects of climate change on rice yields: An econometric investigation using Bangladeshi panel data. Economic Analysis and Policy, 44(4), 405–416. doi:10.1016/j.eap.2014.11.004 Wang, J., Mendelsohn, R., Dinar, A., Huang, J., Rozelle, S., & Zhang, L. (2009). The impact of climate change on China’s agriculture. Agricultural Economics, 40(3), 323–337. Witsanu Attavanich, & McCarl, B. A. (2011). The Effect of Climate Change, CO2 Fertilization, and Crop Production Technology on Crop Yields and Its Economic Implications on Market Outcomes and Welfare Distribution. In Agricultural & Applied Economics Association’s 2011 AAEA & NAREA Joint Annual Meeting, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, July 24-26. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Retrieved from http://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:ags:aaea11:103324 White, H. (1980). A heteroskedasticity-consistent covariance matrix estimator and a direct test for heteroskedasticity. Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society, 817-838. Wooldridge, J. M. (2002). Econometric analysis of cross section and panel data. MIT press. Yu, X. (2012). Productivity, efficiency and structural problems in Chinese dairy farms. China Agricultural Economic Review, 4(2), 168–175. Yu, X., & Zhao, G. (2009). Chinese agricultural development in 30 years: A literature review. Frontiers of Economics in China, 4(4), 633–648.

Page 16: 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69 -84 :3 ...profdoc.um.ac.ir/articles/a/1062660.pdf · 95 /06/09 :&’ ()˚ˇ˝ *˚ˇ+ 95 /12/15 :&’ /˚01 *˚ˇ+ 69

------------ ---------------------- - - ------------------- Journal of Natural Environmental Hazards, Vol.06, Issue 11, Spring 2017

The Impacts of Climate Change on Wheat Production: A Stochastic Production Function Approach

Javad Shahraki*1, Mahmood Sabouhi2, Morteza Yaqubi3

1- Department of Agricultural Economics, University of Sistan and Baluchestan Zahedan, Iran

Email: [email protected]

2- Department of Agricultural Economics, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Azadi Square, Mashhad, Iran

3- Department of Agricultural Economics, University of Sistan and Baluchestan Zahedan, Iran

Received: 2016.08.30 Accepted: 2017.03.05

Abstract The purpose of this study was to evaluate the impacts of climate variables on yield and risk of Iran’s wheat production. In this context, crop year data were collected from 1982-83 to 2014-15. Considering crop season, monthly data were aggregated into seasonal data. Iran was divided into four climatic zones. To optimal selection of predictor variables, Feiveson algorithm was applied. To test the effect of climate variables on wheat production, a Just-Pope stochastic production function was used for each zone. To estimate the panel with fixed effect model, considering the volume of data, Feasible Generalized Least Squares (FGLS) approach was applied. Overall, the results showed that the effects of temperature and precipitation indices are regional; these zones are differently affected by climate indices. Yearly climatic variability has created adverse conditions; However, in some zones, these impacts are negligible; Iran is in the exposure of relatively dry climate with hot summers and cold winters, and extreme temperatures annual events and irregular rainfall changes over the past years have made these farmers more resilient and adaptable.

Keywords: Stochastic Production Function, risk, climate change, wheat, agriculture