Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
17
!"#$%#!"#$&'%()&*+!2009!14,-./012%34!
56"78
1.##9*:$;<=>%%#?@%&ABC'%0D'1.1##9*:&'%EF!G#($(2008,)H&I;<%)*JK2008!!"!#$"#$!%&'()*%+,!-&'(./%()*)"#01)*./2
3%45267$)*82%2008&+'9:52,-.%/0!(#3%)*%&;<=))12>334?4@'56*78''AB89C%:2!D;'16*
9EF+'3%)*%2<'%&'()*%G=H!IJ>K?'LM>N?'16*($'7%OP!Q0#'16%+'RG%S3T%%U%3VW>X*6Y!%U9@6*808'3%9%AZ3[\%!]^!_5`?'16RaB73'S3T%3%@61+b2%cC6'd>e8'16)4MC6*fg8$hO!iD5Uj%kb2'(l%mnob2)%pR!-&'+'qr%s0E3%F%t%'3%0EuvwF%xy)1?$z{9/BG6%H9+|49+/1*}~+'%s����>�I''"E!+��U�JyvU�)%�K=>�*'(�)%
��>��8')*��>t*'15B)'7%fn)8''%&'()*%G=H>��8'15B)3��)/6*�82%L�8'16(%k��)%��'(@��h)%��)12'd4'�!%&'(>IJ)G6H�%H9+��"#/1#01)*./23%45267$)*82%2008+51!52&*
BB!+(�)%��'G/K<��U�JyvU�)%��>��!%&'()*!L&6(%k��#MNOPQ&)%;><=8'3%0Eb2F%(@��h)>��8:2)G6 ¡%¢13R#'16*($'@KR''£ ¡9+'!S%TUV-#MWXYVZ[$PU\]^Q$_`abcTUV-&>¤3%3¥eG6B)!:?'3%%¦§�>¨6)12©�3Lª"#'16*"E!'«¬®)8'%(%&¯)3¥e"#$B)4'£ ¡%[°)MC6*p±'²³#2012+21!22&!:#d'B% ¡9(3%´vµ%%k��
! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !F%M¶)(·
¸¹:)3º*'/"#$')12*78''3%´vµ(9!»¼"#6;e(%&¯))12«¬®3½¾i¿)8'Àe1"#'16*"E!'7#>pRG6$*!'£
18
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
¡9+'%&'(>�I'ÇÈo%É%0Ê%ËÌf&9+/5'º!C)*!:6%kg\h%k¼>º*)G6%U½Ío%Îv#Mij`k$^-l[m&!:?'(%&¯)>*�8'15B)3Ï*E#'16*BB9+'3%)*%;<=)+'(@�)!L&6(%&¯))12^-l[mMNOPQ%<=2%B)9@6)¾CE#'16*
1.2 ABC%LM9+'3%)*%;<=>(@��h)!:?'N2)1?$ÐÑ'7%i¿)/64%
+Ò0*ÓÔ#2011+4!11&!:#d';<=%i¿)8'+'ÕÖ%!S3@6')12*(n×f+(ØIi¿)9@='3´Z%lÙ$%¯3'¥Ú!\Ì"#$f\%Û¿>Ü$8'16B)>i¿)G6B)9@6*B#!+'$)CdOECD9ÝÞ"#'163%ßPISA=AHELO(Assessment of Higher Education Learning Outcoms)%:2/4%3¾CE#6*×à+(o[aYOi¿))412;e4%9'(3%!L&6)*áâ!S1''7#>Ü$8'16B)>i¿)8';%<=)H6¾CH)9@6*MpUP%Miq_`j-VZ[Jã9%ä=åæ3B#!@$6*×ç+(MNOPQi¿)9@='(%U3r%:2/lÙ$èé>ê�8'e$0>i¿)G6;<=)9@6*ÕëçZ>ìí¾î8$A�'ÓÔ#2011&+'×ç%(MNOPQi¿)93%)*%
;>Ý=G;e9@6)ïðG6*B%(MNOPQi¿)!+'"E!!ñòóôõ%%k7«¬jgO'"ñòóô>öC$f÷øé¯>ù\G6jgO'#%U%%kNú'ÎvF%ûü'$%k!�G6%U%ýÙÄÅ)1?$i¿3�(#6)12*9þ+B%2<'$%k!�G6%U%ýÙÄÅ!:6^-l[mMNOPQ%åæ>ÿ2!H9@6*
1 Àe"#$%+'!:�$b2$"#/r!�G6lÙ$h�'"sX]lt-VZ[g\h'Wîøg\h'$d��é¯/r%%&øèé'#"'�h¯$u-Qv-i$(h)$b2ø*+/r0E/6,7$--.'$/Ñø/%k�0)12ø3¾¯'9@6*2 $f8'7%~%;<=%t4!S1'':55"�+1Ef<>6?'16*$)Cd'2014!7%01)*./23%4523%)*829%/B!:#d'qr)*%;<=38z/'d!/?'16!4�KEn'!��)8'%VgjQ%;<=%¸Ý3|4!NK#'1/1'";<=>9�$)*'($@�%rB9H604�*';<=%VÌ.3:?$((9@6'#åæ%)¸$i¿$H;3<=f9'Mwgp[OTUV-33%!:?'¥e"#'1/1B)3$d!"#$)12#>? 2015:63&*)5!#%¸!S1'+'2012!%01)*./2(!$/"È>,5$*%3%)*%;ø#$!-&')!L1''Mwgp[OTUV->3%%*+!L1'¥eG6B)3Ï*E#'163'5%J�l9&�ø!3%!Ï*'1/1%9p'.3(81)12#>? 2015:63)*$f8'²³#2012:29&!:#d'!%&'(" ¡Õ)%3%��+'!S%TUV-%�\'FD*t'V^xg+�'GPAJCAP6,9)1?$(×fgj-.)>Gy'(×àgj-.)G/K<()*��>ù\G6$*!')*!�G6-)ø_-z>./8'!!!!7#E%A�>�0%p;�J%U%%kµ1%Ú<!A{S&6)*n2%34%56)!«¬8:2)8'16)12*9þ4B%(×àgj-.)!L&6()*��%ù\)>7¨8$!H9@6*
19
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
!*+,-./01234%34NO5%36789.:;2PQ2.1"36789.:;2PQ%%#%RST<=>808'7%8!'B28$^-l[mMNOPQ3r%:2!ê�"#6%0'7%p
Pl|Q!S1'¾98'L5��3@6*:H#2008&!:#d';!'3%)*%MNOPQ>��G6<-3�(?$3'ã99+3%%MNOPQ)+Ò0!�G6Ñý4/"#'1/1$*!'B%4�!L&6}~_[g�-g%=>4?/1)12*7B9:H#2008&+'B%4�9@NG6MpUP%PqY.o[�iO=>!AG6*B%PqY.o[�iO=>)+'Astin#1993&E!:?'L�"#'4B"#'e$
�_h9'3%)12løn23%U!¶�Gb2�'�%�_h9@6#¨"½C&*
G/K<'!o[aYO#D¼EE&)8'%%0F¼%Gý'qsµH%�I#GPA&'.�[�-J��JK/r3'"MNOaYO#��&)8'%%0F¼'\�UMF¼'3%Ãt%/r!LMG6)£µ!'#n2G/K<3%9%NO5'i^g')P'ñò4�'�I#GPA&'%UU�rF%LM4Q8''MNOaYO>R\G6)12I!E!O�_h9@6*B%�_h>4)!'b2�}-.�[V-)8'%3%%'�!A8'&�ø!+3%!9U!IG6Mwgp[OCIRP#Cooperative Institutional ResearchProgram&)ëSU>IJ)8$Mwgp[OCSS#College Student Survey&>p©G6B)93%)*%b2�'�>hB�G6B)3PqY.o[�iO=>9@6#:T,2013:11&B%2<9=>9+"3%)12løn2##&3'#´vµ%%kMNOPQ!¶�GLM'G/K<#-$%�g>ÿ2*/L'MNOaYO#MNOPQ&!S1''Astin(1993)+áUø,NúøCV)älU
,,EWU%CV>Xõ8''̈ %%:2!&S%%kMNOPQ>Xõ8$#²³2012:9!10&*
20
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
B%2<'3%)*%ï$6®)¾CE#6áUø$äløY¬%MNOPQ!�8'+'PqY.o[�iO%=>>�I''Z=ø!)*%;)¾CE#'e$3%%[\.#1K�69%`¦]&J"^@$=%)*_/r%`a[.:=4')b)%U%cd+&%@=H3LM>4?'16B)3¥E0!"#$*($)5!äløY¬!�8'+'J+=3%%`a[.:=4'%U"e%%kF%o[�hkp[OJ}[�-.p[O%4Sýf33e1B)4gh"#$*/L'B#E%¨i!�'+*'¾C6/Ed'9þ9+'¨"%E-O>'($O#MNOPQ&!S1'+'¨%%áUø/älU)EWU>ÿ2B)!/6*
"*UV%WX&YZ%#[01234%\,]T&?%^_`9=>%ø+'PqY.o[�iOhB>4)!'E#løn2)8'%3%&%r%
:2/�j3'O#%U%älø$EWø%kMNOPQ&!LMG6%0>´vµÄÅ'!4%_-z>4)!¥E0!G6B)!@6*7%$*!'2009!:='9%8k23%"7%´vY$µ!´vU!p©8'16(´vµýÙÄÅ)%_-z>4ÆG6*B%ÄÅ%l+'!3%%)*áâ$H;$PU\]^QF%åæ'"%kMNOPQ#3%9e!S&$é¯F%"'åæ&L:{#3%)*F%/ÑøÜm70E/?'16*ÄÅ+no?9'&!C~p%�IY$µ!"oi/ÑÄÅ)8'NK#$*?.q+'!7'%5!:?'0/=x^Se3@6*$"!+'2013!7%?.q>rs8$3'B%!7+t%8%%S%%59?.q3100%)/?$3'uv%5Juw%59+(x�!)r(?'16*B#+')5!´vB:#=>&%/1%59+'&!C8p9´v�0>ym8'8(2%U3L='728$%U3´vµ�IY$>z{G60E9@6)3K#6*B%¸9+'f8%%5%�[ah!+xoMg300?'16*
21
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
/L'ÕÖ%4Æ9+'B#E%%5>'7%ñò4�%;�.>4)!'ÕÖ%!|!4&'ÿ2*G/K<'!^:5%óô+}:%5$/Ñ^:%5$~�%5$M>:�%5'"b25%óô+uw%5$�Ub2uw%5$uv%5$;�%5'^15%5$�ô+�%5'#ht�+EE5%5$��lét%5$��EEt%5$�Ôt%5$n2��t%59@6*
3.1"abX+cdX#[01234&?%^_`%]T(n'áUø$älø%kMNOPQ)8'+'$%!e8$'l>ï�44Æ!0&
$)B�'2009!2014!7%Ñ�_-z94'($¤!µ_-z94"S%�43�@"#$%9'B%Ñ�_-z%ï�4¼¸>älø%kMNOPQ%gsM)8$#$%+!C�)%ï�44ÆA�+�7%�$)½C&*
22
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
B%ï�4¼¸%*�#u!��&>%54�õ!H$%3'¨!9@6*B#!:6)'2009!70E14!7!0&''1n#%!74%5óô!:?'äløMNOPQ!�ý¦3@='fg8'ht�%59�1*($:5�9+'2012!7(9+'^:5%�%MNOPQ3b25%�>ë??'1$3'7#Õ)+^:5%�%MNOPQ3�Ö8$$*'�Z%¦§+��8$*($'��)8'H'4'r%%5óô94älø%kMNOPQ+��ë3=%ë�<->HR'16*
C!B%äløMNOPQ>R\G6��>�?�4Æ!:?'ÝÞ8$A�3$!9@6*B%$!9+'2009!14!7%´vµÄÅ_-z>a-h#Ñ�&8$2C9#/L'!C�)%4ÆA�+�7�$B>½C"#$1&'%5óô%LM>s[Ob-hG6$*!%5óô%�X-�W#i¿Pj�U-+ht�&>�98$2C9'%U!:6)*åæ#1Kd%U!:?'äl"#$%kn2&3'r%:2!´vµ%älø/%kMNOPQ!LM8$0H$*B#!:6)'´vµ%äløMNOPQ!�43e/LM>¶�8'1$%+'º!C)*#(f!C!'3%9%A$*%i�)/6lÙ$èé>e!S&6Îv>�&'�!�?$)&9@='B#!C19%k ¡#(ÎvÕ¢9')b+;$$c£! C6/r%k%ë% ¡>8'5#$)&JPU\]^Q%¤%8"#(PU\]^Q+'[\%óôf&9/5'¤85%;6:2!/?'1$)&'%ký¥%¦§#(Îv9+'%U!%ký¥%¦§/"#'1$)&33e/LM¯>4?'1$*BB9A"#6%+'´vµ%ÄÅ9@6!4�KEn'º!C!L&6%k%i�ø
g\h%O¼3%kMNOPQ!�43e/LM¯>4SB)9@6*B%B)+'%UU
23
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
�%gz-Oµ¸%%kg,37%~46�ø/'�>4<'´vµ%%kMNOPQ!(9LM8'1$B)>e¨G6*B#!C19LM¯>4?$%+')b!:6'¢%%k ¡)Îv!L&6%ký¥%¦§9@='ÇÈ0EPqY.o[�iO=>3A8'e$%U"e%%kF%o[�hkp[O%��.>ÚäG6B)39e$*C!'¨&+')5!LM¯>4?$&S%��3älø/%kMNOPQ!¶�GLM
¯#®¿�`?�©W&%!C��>e8$4%9@6#7%ª%��%LM¯%��L:
{¤��%R\¯!S1'+'�7�$B½C3&*B#!:6)'º!C)*%LM¯+2010!7´vU%«0EÖ3=¬*63'7%~'2013!7(9ë3=�&'16*$f7%14'2012!>1''%kMNOPQ>4?)4�5R\G6��)/?'16*ªH'%k ¡+2011!7(9+R\¯3�0?$3'2012!7Õ)+'º!C)*!®¯G6R\¯>e8'16*�;%%U+'Îvf&9/5''¢94)b0E%%k ¡>2&6B)9'MNOPQ>q*6<-3@6)1C6*Õë%B)0EH''älø%kMNOPQ+;!'-ëG6<-!@='7#> C'
e$%+º!C)*9@?$)1C6*$f8'�;9+B#!'¢9%%k ¡!:6%U%%ko[�hkp[OF%°e0&%4Sì�4q(?'e$*
3.2"abX+efX#[01234&?%^_`%]TC!áUø$EWø%kMNOPQ%g®)8'+'Astin#1993:45&%¨i#¨%&!
@63%F%Üm7>&16#(±;9%? !1.5¸%¼¸>²CÜm7gsM)8$&*¨(!+'B%Üm7%*�>%5óôõ!e8$*r%%5óô4'2009!70EÜm73³J0!ë�<-!@?$3'2014!7!+3¤!ë�8'16*%5óô19+'r%!794ht�%5%Üm73ª>0.1/Û¿9Ö??'16*
C!'@)£´%�?�4Æ!:?''EWøMNOPQ)8'%3%F%Üm7%R\�>H'H:2*$4+'2009!14!7%´vµÄÅ%_-z>a-h#Ñ�&8'N?$�
24
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
3 ($B%�$B9+'ìíø�1R\¯>6?$&S%��!S1'+%5óô)%µd+&l>�98''%51%LM¯%¦§>H'16*$f8'B%�$*0EH6¶='%5óô)%µd+&3�ý!/6l+?/5'B#E&S%��+%5!:En%kMNOPQ>R\G6%&ø�j9@6B)3K06*
?�4Æ%A�>e8'16#!7�)%4ÆA�+�7�$C½C&*B%$0EH'4'EWø%kMNOPQ)8'%%kÜm7>4?)4R\8'16%
+'äløMNOPQ)£´'º!C)*9@?$*C19'EWøMNOPQF%LM33e1%+'%k ¡'PU\]^Q%¤8"9@?$*7B9'B%!S%��!S1'R\¯%!C��>�$4%3'¨'9@6*¨'0E
H''2011!7´vU>1''1n#%´vU!L1'º!C)*3%kMNOPQ>�4�5R\8'L='8047%R\¯+2013!Õ)'�(6<-!@6*B#!I8''%k ¡)PU\]^Q%¤8"%LM¯+!7!:6dESe33e1)1C:2*
25
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
26
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
($'�$C9%5óô)%µd+&>�6)'@%äløMNOPQ£´'��!µd+&3�ý!/6wh+?/5'1n#4ñò4�!�©8/1%&ø/��)1C6*$f'º!µ)*!�8'+'2012!7!^:5%óô)b25%óô)%µd+&3�ý!/?'16%9'?/5)4B%!7!�8'+'ht�!ì;'^:$b25%óô!L1''º!C)*3%kMNOPQ>�ý!q*$)1C6*
#*@AB%%#&'%ABC%g,h&'3%U%%kMNOPQ%;<=3��/'d)8'0QD&E#6:2!/?$JK)
8''ç·#2013&+!qsU%Îv¢%kµ13¸?8$)12qs�oW%$d'"3%9!%V´�!:=[\�é3¹º8$)123%�oW%$d>@�'164*1n#!R:'�l-x-�h56>»C'îø!¼38$3%)*+'2008!%!%&'(" ¡!J°"#6:2!'V´�8$9%U>»C')*%;<=>R(E#'16*½¾#2005&!:#d'qs%)*áâ%¿¸!ÍC''3%9!%V´�#*À9!JAO9!%,9'�05%¿¸&4@='qs)3%%�©%@=H4'ÇÈ%(9
27
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
4�KEn'(9�)9@6º!C!L&6%k%i�øg\h%O¼3�ßø/%kMNOPQ!�43e/LM¯>4?'1$*B#+'º!C9%%kg,37%~46�ø/'�>4?'L='´vµ%%kMNOPQ!(9LM8'1$B)>e¨G6*B%B)+'3%)*%;<=!L1'º!C)*3à�/0Q>e8'16B)>ýfG6*804'7%'�!+ñòóô!:6'�%¦+�)�rHE#/)12%&.>4S))4!')5!EWø%kMNOPQ#3%U"e%3%U�F%Üm7&!L1'+'º!C)*%LM¯3;!'Â3G6<-3HE#$*9%%º!C)*%'�!�G6ÝÞ#áØ$âÕ 2011&0E+'9%Õ8)%ìí0
EH'4')5!(¨ãä%å&H;J:Ì>Ä;6¯)'(qT-O$B:%:æ+�H;)3'9%~%º!C)*!:?'@6(7'k¼"#$)¾C6B)39e6*"E!B28$%kèç%k¼)%kU!L&6èüé)%�©>ÝÞ8$A�'(i9øUj^V-)J(EEÝê$./é¯)3e!�1'16B)3º!C)*!IG6èüé>q*'16B)3K0?$*B%¸9+'º!C)*!L1'+'(n+i9ø/%kèéJEE./é¯>q*6B)!ïë>L5��3@6)¾CE#6*RG%º!C)*%$d)8'@3?'16%+(ì�)b%Gý'g,¯%í¦9@='
º!C)*%ø'áâ'Û¿!S1')b19Ñýê�JÄ33¨E#'1/1B))#îÐ 2006&9@6)"#'}~'º!C)*%¼3!ï?'(ðõ%F`H1%Ä3>�%ø!N2B)3(G(Gñò!/6)#Tó 2006&)12gh4@6*B#!I8''9%9+2013!7:=(+,�oVYi))12?ô9ï)8'Uj^V-)*#p_`MUj^V-'=õUj^V-/r&!�¸>Q1$º!C)*>�%ø!4B8'16*B#+s-_`�-z>0Ê!'%8%5>öC$)b3«¬®JV^xg/r>���8'�%ø!®¿�"#$º!C)*>p©G6)124%9@6*B%)*>u08$´vU3@62016!7!+($'º!C)*%'�%�â!S1'EF8$1)¾C'16*
,ijkl-½¾÷ø,2005,(9
28
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
ÏÐÉû.2001,(1"+2%+2+wh�}gj`-Q))*!L&6<Ñr)!)*%!E"8+151!172.áØf,$âÕ-.,2011, (º!C)*!:6qs)3%%��+ÁÂ%Ã3%)/%8%ÐÑ)!ÁÂ%Ã3%
)*=>01�"11+5!32.Tó"#$,2006,(º!C)*%ýf)ýÌ)Þ?ÿ$Tó"#$ü!º!C)*+~�$hB$p%)&w%ú
-"'(+1!12.ç·2,2013,(3%U%%k��%R\��!�G6p=ø=>)!3%uv)�=>"4+93!105.:H�3,2008,(%U%}[�-.p[O)3%)*%MNOPQ)!qr)*=>"11+45!64.:T4,2013,(o[gj`j]-VZ�h$U�-u)MNOPQåæ!�G6=>+PqY.$o[�iO=>
!iD5)%�(%!4B)!3%)*"10+1!12.Ô856$ÕÖ78$×Ø+9,1999,!4W%9e/13%U+21&1%ã93:/1"Á;uw!Eb.îÐ<=Ô,2006,(ã9!L&6º!C)*%ú-+%8kÄÅ0E)Þ?ÿ$Tó"#$ü!º!C)*+~
�$hB$p%)&w%ú-"'(+69!79.²³É�2007,(%U%�¸>>(C$º!C)*%4B+V´�>�?C$)*��%`a�!-&' )!!"
3%Uj%k)*=>w[z-=>1�"5+15!29.²³ÈÔ,2006,(f!C$º!C)*>%U%�¸9¾C6)�9æ$Â#$8ü!3%¯+%%3%��%$*
!"X�h��ã&+57!68.,,,,2012,!%&'()*%;<=F-&'+%UÄÅ)º!µ)*0EHC'e$4%"Á+'
29
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
30
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
31
ÁÂ%Ã3%!L&6)*%Ra)'d,2009!14!7´vµÄÅ%4Æ,
